HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-02558
.~.
1\:
I'
t
\
,
4~~'t{.:
. ..i'-
. ,I '{
'. "\ "'.f
;i,
. ,
II
Ii
(f,
Itf
-,..,.!,-,
I.
!!i'
!tJ,
r~" "~;,f;'
'Yi
,
;h"'-
i""-- -,",
.:r'-~. ,!,\t
:; _.' I'l,
~_;i l ~;~~ " ~'
I', \: -,""*
''',
J:,
"r-.
1
,
~
I
I
I
/
1
~
~
~.
I,
I!
c
'\ .1.1'1.,
~.. .~., .&
", ,1
~~r,.. .';,,':v,
C)" wl
',i-.J '
.,' -ll ~:'~.J
.,~1J "
.".;;, J
'.I\t\, .
..,' ~,
" I.
I
,
~,"
. - ~
~~'\'
{i'J '..~
"'f'
y-
~\
..
'd .'r~!,U".'; ""n.,. : ~'!!I!
fn
"".".In, G)
',' .
.
,
LUIGI ARENA and
ANN ARENA,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
"
I'
t
r:
,1'1
v,
NO. 98-2558 CIVIL TERM
,.
i"
)i '
'11
,t!
I
plaintiffs
DARRELL KLAWITTER,
Defendant
[\l'lSWER
AND NOW, comes the Def.endant, Darrell Klawitter, by hia
",
1-2. Admitted,
attorneys, Addams & Rundle, and makes the following answer to the
Plaintiffs' complaint:
3. The oral agreement is admitted except that labor for
the air conditioning was to be extra.
4. The answer to ParagI'aph 3 is incorporated herein by
.i
",
.
I
,
I
reference.
5. Admitted.
I \
\
,
I
\
6. Admit ted,
7. Denied. In or October 1997 the Defendant was required
to go to work on another job and ceased working on the
By mutual agreement, the parties agreed to terminate theil' oral
,
\
\,
\
t
i,l,
I
I
plaintiffa' basement. All the work done was in good condition.
agreement with the Defendant retaining the amoLlnt paid to that
point which was about $2,400, The plaintiffs then entered into a
new agreement with the Defendant's former employee, Ed Moore, to
complete the project, Any subsequent deficiencies in the work
were solely the responsibil i ty of Ed Moore.
8. Denied. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herein by reference.
9. Denied. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herein by reference.
COUNT I
10. The i.lI1swers to Paragraphs 1- 9 are incorporated herein
by reference.
11. Denied. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herein by reference.
12. The conclusion of law is denied.
13., After reasonable investigation, the Defendcll1t is
without knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the averments regarding the plaintiffs' damages. The same are
therefore denied.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requests Count I be dismissed.
COUNT II
14. The answers to Paragraphs 1-13 are incorporated herein
by reference.
15, Denied, The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herein by reference.
16. The answer to Paragraph 13 is incorporated herein by
reference.
17. The conclusion of law is denied.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requests COLlnt II be dismissed.
90UNT II I
10. The answers to Paragraphs 1-17 are inoorporated herein
by reference.
19. Admitted.
20. Denied. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herein by reference.
21. The answer to Paragraph 13 is incorporated herein by
reference.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requests Count III be dismissed.
QOUNT IV
22.." The answers to Paragraphs 1-21 are incorporated herein
by reference.
23. Denied as stated. The answer to Paragraph 7 is
incorporated herein by reference.
24. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated herein by
reference.
25. The answer to Paragraph 7 is inoorporated herein by
reference.
26. The answer to Paragraph 13 is incorporated herein by
reference.
27, The conclusion of law is denied.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requests Count IV be dismissed.
NEW MATTllli
By way of further answer and defense, the Defe~dant asserts
the following in new matt8r:
". CJ G,:~:
fie
j::S. -
.. ~:i
LUC,? "J \
( 'J ~_n 0;-, "
ij~ ~(- ._'",.
I~ f L.t.
~'( I" ,"-
C)I, I 1 (<:1
1'1'"
t=;' '=" ~/J .'_::_i(\1
CO'
(,' ....r ~;} (J...
.i;:
1.1. cn ::J
0 0' U
, 'Ii
IJlii
\
,\i
I'
t
\
ftl.-1 ttf;,
i ~ l
'I
,
)i.
f'
It;'
"
"
L
[1 [,U 1
'il i,l:l
"I
,;
"'Uji l
h-
Il_-Hi\
\li.l !.
"
)
,
;;
\','1
i;',[
"'i,
il'
ii'
,Il'
ii'
if;
-" n
;1'_\
Ci',\\ t'
t j,,;' '>! j i [i.\ :"
fi'itF'
!:;>j-i:.\:\f:
~!l
'Ii \.l
Or,'
,'n':-lii_!
l.t
\:'l1,
in ,I
I' i-,l i W) L"
1 h'::'1. C'!
I.i
',' t ! i ,-.~, it
! l\ '1.
.l1'
Iii
~i
','
- ,
.i,'
'~1 r J
H l
Iii l'c"
;1-1,1
~ , .-c ,
')
'\
,
I
t h!
it.!
~p Iii. j
,_:, \ !! [i
; ,~ , . i -' f \ i (
\'::,11
1"_1 L !!
'J \.i ;~i :1 l-, l' I, I
I.: L\ (
j-;' y_!
I.;;t ~~ /~~~'
f1G;,,~~(~{
,11'_'('.1
. t',-i
l_'tl
/j!:i
-,'d;' L II
Iii;] ;, !'_i- j
'Q~
, j
rio'
3/41'
i 9f,
Q' '
) 7- .
."_ ~l;JkG."TJlfj,(J.""',
I ," _ II
u-
I~~I
Ii;
~~..WIAUH 0' ""IIYLVAltA
coun 0' COMMOIl ~L1AI
NOTICE Of APPEAL
.MOM
9th JUDICIAL DIURICT
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMOIl ~L1AI Il"
911- j', " I' (:'O,(Pu'r(~.
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notke is given that tho upflnUont hus fj""d In the above Court of Common Plum nil (Ipptwl from tho JudOIHo1l1 rtllldlHfld by tho Di,t,lct Jus'klt on fhe
dot. and In tho C"1e mentioned below,
'~1":~;el~~:~~tter I MA~~;: ;i~~:'<AMf cw [l;
Ali6iiJfNAHfITmr"--..... (11'1 ~fAfE
1765 Roseda1e Avenue, Lot H Middletown PA
'r>\'~,i;;:t---u--__I~:~:~~'f:~;;'ff~lll Anma " Darrell KIllWI t I':;"ii"
~ll1';-.~---u 'GNATl":~)Y~lIoilNl'V)~?' . .-----.---,-----
CV HlL__BIi':',9ft,.__..____.__. /;.-;:~.....-: ,V.,.v....
IT 19~_.___.._.."...".."___~. WilHam A. Addams
Thi. block ';'-lifj,;;.~gnod ONLy"-;i;,,;; Ij;i.;;;;I(Jli~-;;';""q~I;;,;j~,;d;;;P(J. R.c.PJ,P, No"" - II appeiiantw~~ CLAIMANT (seePa.-R.GP.J.'PJ,i;;"
1008B.
Thl. Notke of Appeal, when received by lhe Di.tri"t Justice, will ope,ute as 0 1001 (6) ill aotlon belore Dislrlol .Iust/oe, he MUST
SUPERSEDEAS to lho judgmenl fOf po.....lon In this ca.e FILE A COMPL AINT wit/Jill /wenly (20) days after
__.._, ,.".______==.s!'lI."ill;o_~p,~]Fi(iiroiiiiYtij6iiixilv _Imino IIis NOTICE 01 APPEAL.
."",l'CNir'-'"
17057
~---~_._-----.--~ PR""ECj"PE'-,O INTI.it RU1-E-YO FILE COMPLAI'NT-"AND-RUi:'E'-'foFILE'--'-~~-'~~
(This sec/Ion 01 lorm to be usod ONLY when IIl'pol/an/ was DEFENDANT (soo pfl, R,CP,JP No, 1001(7) /n aclioll bolore D/s/I/OI JIlSt/oe,
If: NOT USED, dotach "0m ctpy olllolico 01 IIppeal to ba sorvoelupon appol/ao),
PRAECIPE. To Prothonotary
Luigi and. AmL1\nma ._," ,""_____.
Nivllo of n,..HJlloo(i>)
(Commar, Pleas No. _9ft.::. .< :[<;L.,~"e_.,.,'JL<~'_1 within twonty (20) day. alter .ervice f
/?~.
Ente, rule upon
".... , app.lleel'), to file a complaint In Ihi. appeal
C<;
SignalUfO of sppellant Of his altofney Of If{I8fIt
RULE, To Luigi and Ann Arena
Nil/Till 01 alJ(Xllloo(sJ
.",.,,..,.,,,,___ , appelleel'),
(1) You are notllied that a rule i. hereby .ntered upon you to Iile a complaint In this appeal within twenty 120) day. oller tho date of
,",vke 01 thl. rule upon you by persOf1(jI .ervice or by certifi.d Of r.gister.d moll,
12) If you do nol file a complaint within this lime, a JUDGMENT Of NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOu.
(3) Tho dote 01 .ervice of thl. rul. If .ervice was by mall I. the date 01 moiling.
Date: May 5
, 19..98..
/ 2 )
(/ ""'/,.. f.,
7y"J..,~
lJ.i{'-'-'-C/
SIgnal... 01 ".,1Iioo'ioiar~IY
NJPC 317-1H
COURT FILE TO BE FILED WITH PROTHONOTARY
~3/0S '98 00:48 fAX 717 737 6779
1).1 Place)'
~001
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF: ~BlU.AND
-= ~- ":,';::':.::::::':-:::.'
T..",,,,, (717) 761.-8230
17055
NOTICE OF JUOOMENTrrRANSCRIPT
. . CIVIL CASE
PLANfIf.r.: ""'''''''AIlUH!..
fiRRNA, LUIGI 6: ANN ..,
3433 LINCOLN DRIVJII
CAIIP BILL, PI. 17013
L, ~
vs.
DEF~NO"NL """ I'd 'UUMf,.~
fJ(raAWIT'l'D, DARULL ..,
1765 ROSIDALB AV!.
LOT 8
~DDLBTOWNt PI. 17057 _I
['Docket No,: CV-00000li4-981.
Date Flied: 2/17/98
.-.------.-..-
~a\J,Dllt,Ng,;
09-3-04
OJ NlII1l1: HQn.
TROMAS A. PLACBY
......" 5002 r.BNXD STOBT
MlCB.Ur.IC8DURG, PA
TROJIAS A. PLACHY
5002 'LDDJl. 8TRllB'l'
KBCBANXCSBtJRG, PA 17055
~:
THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT:
Judgment: FnR pT.ATM'I'TIi'Ii' .
[i] Judgment was entered lor: (Name) _ AVJ!V1, T.rTTG\,1 .. una
[i] Judgment was entered against: (Name) lCT.a.WT'PI'RIl., na.VVIl!T.T.
In the amount of $
1;,011.00 on:
(Date of Judgment)
(Date & Time)
4/0G!.ll-
o Defendanls are jointly and severally !iablll.
D Damages will be assessed on:
o This case dismissed without preJudice,
Amount of Judgment
Judgment Costs
Interest on Judgment
Attorney Fees
Total
$ ~.90~
$__113.0g
$ . OJ!
$,_ .00
$ 6,013.00
O Amount of Judgment SubJect to
AttachrnentlAcl5 of 1996 $
o Levy Is slayed for days or D generally slayed,
Posl Judgment Credits
Post Judgmenl Costs
$
$
~:S:ll..:I;;;_=~~S
Certified Judgment Totll $
o Objection to levy has been filed and hearing will be held:
Date: Place:
Time:
ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO, APP.I;A~.wITHltUQ, o..~ YS AFTER THE ENTRY OF JUOQMENT BY riLING A NOTICE
Of APPEAL WITH THE ~~OTHO, NOT AR)'ICLERK Of THE):OURT OF COMMON PLEA~. ~!~9:11BlY'JION. YOU
MUST INCLUDE A COpy OF THis No"dE OF JUOGMENTfTRANSCRIPT FORM WITH ~ ~'F,,:'PPEAL.
, /., '.' ~.... ~-".. . .. ',-
LLQ 00 ; i : $~'"," > "'\..
:.1::'_'- aD Date : 1 ,"" "'i-'-"''',,",_ fq"";Dlpt~ClJ(Jst,\\e
. "... '<.' " ',' --..
1 ' 'I '. ... f" , ... ,..-." '..~ - 0:;
,I I . ;::..... ...... ,- " II ~.
I certify that this Is a true and, cQrrBct~opy oflhe;record of ;the proceeding!>'~n~lnlng t~~!lljm~nt."" ~'
Li..,q- 'i8 Date 'v' __~. ,;.", \;; :': .~. p'ip,lrl~~,fs1/8
j,' """ ;:0. . - ",: ~ ..
i '..~ ",_,f. , . \.> ,."
" " I' '\ .....
Mv commission expires first Monday of January,' ad,04 "",,,,,~~L."""
>- 0\ ~""
0" ~'J l;.
..,,~
f~ .. -)
01
f'h" :u:: '~ ~,~
fJ;\, 01(.1;' " :':J
,tit-
C),.,- ;';j
C' trJ
C1!~" I ~"J
IJ'I"
-~.l ! ~ ;>,. !_d[7J
tl.. "j .,',: ~; ILl.
f' ';d.: t' _~~
1'5 CO ~)
en 0
,,'
~ 0\ "',,~
h; -~ I.,
rJ, '>
" !'..'S
f! 0, :;
'/.
[ : ~, :ff ~ , :iJ'
'j "':-C "
" U) .'-
fi' '//.'1
_'1'; I , , '}.",
0-"1' '..,., /i:;",
~.. " ."
r ~ IlL.
b O':l ::'j
0', C)
Ii.,
COliN'\' \II
Nellll\lellce
18. I'nmgruphs 1 through 17 hereof arc incorporated herein by reference us if fully set
forth,
19, Defendunt owed a duty to Plaintiffs to perform the work in a good and
workmanlike manner lInd not to cause damuge,
20. Defendant breached the duty owed to Plaintiffs by failing to perform the work in a
good and workmanlike manner and causing damage.
21. As a result of Defendant's breach of the duty. Plaintiffs hnve sustained the
following damages:
(a) Out-ol~poeket expenses and payments of approximately $4,240.00;
(b) Estimated cost to repair nnd/or complete the work in the amount of
$3.854.83. True and eorrel~t copies of the estimates are attac,hed
hereto as Exhibit" A" and incorporated herein by reference; and
(c) Market value loss of the residence,
WHEREFORE. the Plaintiffs Luigi and Ann Arena demand judgment in their favor and
against the Defendant in an amount within the limits of compulsory arbitration for Cumberland
County, plus costs, interest and/or damages for delay as allowed by law.
COUNT IV
Misrepresentation and/or Fraud
22: ,Paragraphs 1 through 21 hereof ure incorporated herein by reference as if fully set
fotth.
.5-
OO.II",u/ll N: /31944
23. Delcndunt (Ind/or his cmploYl'c. serVunl. wOl'kmlln lind/or his IIgent. lIeting within
the scope or his employment IInd/llI' authorily. reprl'sl'nted to Pluintirrs thut the repuirs and/or
improvemenls would he perlill'lned to the Prl'mises in u good II workmllnlike munner und would
be performed in a timely munner,
24, PllIinlifts relied onlhe represenlUlions or Defenduntllnd/or his employee. servunt.
workmunllnd/OI' IIgent hy paying to suid individullls $4.240,00 plus the cost or muterillls,
25, The Defendanl und/or his employee. servunt. workmun and/or agent. knowingly
und/or within intent to defhlud. took Plaintiffs' udvallee payments. fhiled to eompll,te the repairs
and/or improvements and disappeared without notke to Pluintiffk
26. A!i a direct und proximute result of the misrepre:;entation and/or fl'llud of
Defendlltll und/or his employee. servant. workman und/or ugent. Plaintiffs sustained the
following dllmuges:
(a) Out-of-pocket expenses and payments of approximately $4.240,00;
(b) Estimated cost 10 repair and/or complete the work in the amount of
$3.854,83. True and correct copies of the estimates are attached
hereto as Exhibit "A" and ineorpornted herein by reference; and
(c) Market value loss of the residence.
27. Plaintiffs arc also entitled to punitive damnges because Defendant's actions and/or
the actions of his employee. workman. servant and/or IIgent were intentional with the intent to
defraud Plaintiffs,
.6-
D~wmo~/N: 134944
.vlmll~ICA'/'I()N
I. Ann Anma, hereby certify that the !illlowing is COITe(:!:
The facts sct fl1l1h in thc tilrcgoing Complaint arc based upon informatjon which I hnvc
furnished to counsel. as well us upon informution which hus been gathercd by counsel and/ot, others
neting on my behalf in this mutter, The langunge of thc Complaint is that of counsel and not my
own, I hllve rend the Compluint, und to the extent that it is bused upon inllll'lllution which 1 have
given to counsel, it is true and COl'I'cct to the best of m)' knowledge. infclOlIlnion.und belief. To the
extent that the content of the Complaint is thut of counsel. I have relied upon such counsel in
making this Verification, I hereby ucknowledge that the fucts set forth in the afofesuid Compluint
arc made sul~ieet to the penalties of 18 I'a, C.S.A. ~4904 felating to unsworn falsification to
authorities.
Dated: 5-20-98
aMIrG (1~~
Ann Arena
{)oc",IIetllN: l.f./9.I./
, COMMONWI"""'" 'IHNnLVANIA
cOlIn 011 COMMCiil'(iir---------
NOTICE O' APPEAL
fROM
9th JUDICI"L Dla'IIC'
DISTIIICT JUITICE JUDGMENT
--...................;.._;n,_n.._~~_~, v_n..'.......,----'-----_._n.~.~_.__.____~__....~_.~_.~_~_,.,...,,-.-..--..-________,.".". .<0._ _~______._._."..."'..._.. ..~.__.__.__..~.~~~" ~.-'___+____._~.~"'''--'"'--
.~_T~"____.___.__~_~_~__~_~
COMMON'L1"SN.. 911~ .;2.,:,....,;"S'
NOTlCI OF APPIAL
NoIkt la 81- that It,. appellant ho, filed In lho (lbov. Cou,t of Common Plea. OIl """""I from lhe Judgmenl rendtfed by the DI.lrkt ./utlk. on the
... GIld In It,. -.....,Ilonod boIow
"IlAMIao..",...,. ~ .---'-~---~._..-~~--.------r.... "I' NO CI !lA!llNrrr---~------'
~Kl~tter ' .----.-.-.,-.----~.------~lI'--.---,..--- _,Q9.::~-_..-_---.:....~,.~
1765 Rolledale Avenue lot II md(Uetown rA 17051
"'-!I'~ .---J:kC'II~I_"'.- ,.-.-----..-------,.----------~
.~~ -~. :::" ~~_'<S--J!lOI'f.rlilr6rAmn~-OllI;:~~~~~~~~-~"'''---,--,.......-.
'n. bIoCh WIt~ ~~Y when thl. nok.1lon I, req.Jired u.;d; Po. R.c,P,iP.~' If ~~CLAiMIINT(Seo'Pi. R.C.P.J.P. No,
100'" ' ......- . , .
ThkNoIlce 01 A",*", when received by lho DI.lrlct Ju.lic.. will operate o. 0 1001(6)/nootlonbeforeD/slr/OIJustlCfJ, he MUST
lU'lRaIDIA$1O It,. JucIgmom far po....1lon In ,hi. ta... FILE A COMPLAINT Within lwenty (20) days after
filing his NOTICE of APPEAL.
S/gnaluro ii11fiijff""'O/8/Y 0i1Jiiiji;rv------'---
-....---.-..---......._~-~,---......~
"'--"-.- . ..----... ------...
P~AICIPI TO INTlR RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULI TO FIll
(fflIhfICtlon 01 fDml to be L'lled ONLY wf!on /lPP6lliint was DEFENDANT (see Pa. R.C.P.J.P, No. 100 1 (7) In 001101/ before D/slt/cf Just/olJ.
If' NOT USED, deIooh from copy of nollce ollfPP6ll/ 10 be served upon /lPP611oo).
'IA,CIPII To Prolhonolqry
Entw Me upon r 'If at ... AIIIl~ 0/ ~~-._-__~_._ . """"""I'), to file a complaint In thh flppeol
(Cclmn\on I'tta,s No -5J&,.-E 5!i8 I wllhin t.....,ty (20) day. (lIter ..,vlc. 01 rule or .uller ent,y of Judgment of ndlt jlRII,
lULl, To Wid and Ann Arena ('''''_.~,..!~.~'~~.!!..~:'!r'7
Ntmeo/-"""f" ._~._.-,app..l'l. ! ,,:: ",,,,,:;,",;,::,:',,,,, ,,! I
(1) Yoy~ nolllltd that a rule Is honoby enl.,J upon you 10 ftle 0 complaint In ,hi. appeal wl~ t~l' (20) day.'''", .......:ot. ,.)
II/We. of tN. .. upon you by pt!IIOnal ..,vlc. or by certlliod or "lll,teNd mall.' ,
,
(2) H you' do not flIo 0 camplalnl within 'his time. 0 JUDOMI!NT Of NON PROS WilL BE ENTfiRED AGAINST YOU.
(31 The doIlt \If ....vlc. of thlt rule H 1Il'We. ..... by mall I. tho dole 01 mailing.
Dcltt:w.,...~__. 19#, () '/"
a "lhuJl.",--
..J,.l;" ~ nI AoIIlOolClllry ~
/illI'O."...
jJ Tl4 d'l.:\ bid
~ Certified Mall Reoelpt
"No InSllrl\nCO Covoraqo Providl.ld
,~ Do not llHO lor InllHl\i\tional MHlI
~~IIP.a':\I:\ (~t::.~~..__.
Sonllo
Clark A. DeVere, Esquil'f'
I' '/:IIIr!'I:1 ~,/II
---_.-_.-~_.,-----
SHOtll &. No
P.O. Box 5300
~. ~:~:~:\~I~,~:~:",~:~:~~~~~~'!;;~~~I~I
;',j{lrN~~r, UtilI! 11l!'/llhHI 'F
\li."\'~;)'111I VI ^. 1..>II1I'(!Y' \), J,
'1\;"';' _~ II"
r)(KI~'. I ~!III\(11' ~lt nUll
i'I', ",.;,,,',, 'W' ",I,
\:::,:::",':'1< ,,' "'1\, I' ^ $ 111:::
"L:.l5n
PO, 91'11\' II. ZIP Colin
Harrisbur~L~:'. ...17110..0300
$ .32
r',)~'a[Jll
Corlitlod 1'1)11
1.35
Sp~O~~y~-;;._---'.-
'<1"""1111";";'1',101"
.__._~____n_ _._,___
i!t;,;I",I,;,! il"Io-""l I""
Ros1rir,WI Dfll,~urJ' HlO
f1elum flocnipl 9hflWlfl\l
~ toWhorn&llill.111oh~urll(1 _..."'_~ .__~l__"J~Q._-~_.
f'" FllltumflOCllipl SI\OWil1\) 1(,WI\m1\,
~ Oato, /I. Addr.}"" "I Dllll'/f/ry
,
1 raTAL P051unll $ 2.77
0; &falls
i PQ9lmnrkOf(Jillll
C'l
& 5/5/98
Cf)
a.
11o;!'"'' 11"",HIII 1iliq;l,'iliI
~ !nWI""!'/I, 1)"11,,,,1"'.1
..1.10..--
II"\"H' 11,u'''jll !!1",...,,,ldl,,WI,,,,,1
III li,ll" 1. ';'dd";'" n! 11.!I",,("
f\ __
'-1 Iill^' 1';1',1*1'1
~ AI"""
,~
$Z.77
!,d<;!n'<H~ ,,( 11111"
5/5/9f3
'"
n,
..~.u,""_r_' "~-"-~'~'"
".
8. Denied. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herein by reference.
9. Denied. 'the answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herein by reference.
COUNT I
10. The answers to Paragraphs 1-9 are incorporated herein
by reference.
11. Denied. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herein by reference.
12. The conclusion of law is denied.
13. A.fter reasonable investigation, the Defendant is
without knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the averments regarding the plaintiffs' damages. The same are
therefore denied.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requests Count I be dismissed.
COUNT II
14 . The answers to Paragraphs 1-13 are incorporated herein
by reference.
15. Denied. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herein by reference.
16. The answer to Paragraph 13 is incorporated herein by
reference.
17. The conclusion of law is denied.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requests Count II be dismissed.
COUNT IIi
18. The answers to Paragraphs 1-17 are incorporated herein
by reference.
19. Admitted.
20. Denied. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated
herei.n by reference.
21. The answer to Paragraph 13 is incorporated herein by
reference.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requests Count III be dismissed.
COUNT I~
22. The answers to Paragraphs 1-21 are incorporated herein
by reference.
23. Denied as stated. The answer to Paragraph 7 is
incorporated herein by reference.
24. 'l'he answer to Paragraph 7 is i.ncorporated herein by
reference.
25. The answer to Paragraph 7 is incorporated herein by
reference.
26. The answer to Paragraph 13 is incorporated herein by
reference.
27. The conclusion of law is denied.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requests Count IV be dismissed.
NEW MA'rTER
By way of further answer and defense, the Defendant asserts
the following in new matter:
3\, Conclusion of luw. no r(~ply mquircd, If u rcply is rcquircd. Ihc uvcrll1cnls arc
spccllicu\ly denicd. By wuy of f\ll'thcr rcply. thcrc wus no tcrmination of the original ug\'C(1mcnl
. und the work which was pcrfll\'lllcd was very POOl', not pcrformcd in a good and workmanlikc
manncr. incOlllplclc and causcd addition..1 damagc 10 Plaintiffs' prcmiscs,
WHEREFORE. PlainlifTs dcmand Ihal Dcfcndant's Ncw Mattcr bc dismisscd and that
judgmcnt bc cntercd in thcir favor and against Dcfendant as claimcd in thc Complaint tiled in
this action.
METZGER. WICKERSHAM. KNAUSS & ERB. P.C.
By: ~.....a. ~,~""'~-_.
Clark DeVere. Esquirc
Attorney \.0. No, 68768
3211 North Front Slreet
P.O. Box 5300
Harrisburg.PA 17110-0300
(717)238-8187
Attorney for Plaintiffs
Dated: June ~3, 1998
/1
- 2.
{Joel/me/lt H: 130/944
(:(<,;lrl'lnCATI~ 0.. SI,:IWICE
I, Clark [JeVere. Esquire. of the law linll of Metzger. Wickersham, Knuuss & Erb. ().C..
hereby certify tlUlt 1 served a true and corrcct copy of the Plaintiffs' Reply to New Mutter of
Defendunt with reference to the Illrcgoing m:tion by lirst class mail. postage prepaid, this ,,J.3.!e.day
of June. 19980n the tllllowiag:
Darrell Klawitter. Defendant
c/o Willium A, Addams. Esquire
Addams & Rundlc
1',0. Box 208
28 South Pitt Street
Carlisle. I' A 17013
METZGER. WICKERSHAM.KNAUSS&ERB.I'.C.
...~....,.:'. LJ.-'/
Clark DeVere. Esquire
DoolIIIIOIII N: 134944
',,"'
..
t
j,
"1'""'-
"
;'t)
N
,'a
.
',~'~\ti
", ~,ti"'~
, ~':.
" "I
,
\"
'~',
;,,,\
,'f'If,":
Ik+
,)j,j,~
/
<~'
, .,,"
,!. ,-
!l
\
1
I
\
/
";
~':.~ 1<")
"
,~ -l'r, \"f; ~
/J "j
t, ~
i" .4i
.. \. l,~,
,~
~i~ ~'~
"\.
;i""
, , i
'~i;~)':!
it \'.
-, I"
~
'::'li
"
'!,
'I ..';
,I
.
~h
tf~,;~
"i
, ~I '
~,;.
,r
,
.'
'f
r-
I
... '
J..UIGI ARENA and
ANN ARENA,
iN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
plaintiffS
v.
DARRELL KLAWITTER,
Defendant
NO. 98-2558 CIVIL TERM
v.
ED MOORE,
Additional Defendant
NOTICE TO TAKE DEFAULT JUDGMENT
TO : Ed Moore
R.D, 1, BoX 117 AAZ
Loysville, PA 17047
DATE OF NOTICE: september 10, 1998
IMPOR'l'ANT NOTICE
\
\
\
\
1
I
\
I
\
\
\
\
\
i
YOU ARE IN DEFAULT BECAUSE YOU HAVE FAILED TO TAKE ACTIO~
REQUIRED OF YOU IN THIS CASE. UNLESS you ACT WITHIN TEN (10)
DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE, A JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED
AGAINST YOU WITHOUT A HEARING AND YOU MAY LOSE YOUR PROPERTY OR
OTHER IMPORTI'\N'l' RIGHTS. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS NOTICE TO A LAWYER
AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO
OR TELEPHONE THE FOLLOWING OFFICE TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET
i.EGAL HELP.
cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 1'7013
(717) 249-3166
ADDAMS & RUNDLE
By:
william -A:li.ddami'!
Attorneys for Defendant,
28 South pitt Street
P,O. Box 208
Carl, isle, PA 17013
(717) 249-8300
cc: Clark DeVere, Esquire
(~lill,(,WICi\TI\ OF SlIRVICfl:
I, Clark DeVere, Esquire, of the law Iirm of Mel,zger, Wickcr:,hum, Knuuss & Erb, P,C..
hereby certify that I served a true und correct \,opy of Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators
with reference to the Ii:lregoing action by lirst class mail, postage prepaid, this y.~ day of
October, 1998 on the following:
Darrell Klawitter, Defendant
c/o William A. Addams, Esquire
Addams & Rundle
1',0. Box 208
28 South Pi tt Street
Carlisle, I' A 17013-0208
Ed Moore
R.D. I, Box 117 AAZ
Loysville, I' A 17047
METZGER, WICKERSHAM. KNAUSS & ERB, P.C,
~~
Clark DeVere, Esquire
/Jncllm~m N: uno/
Q(Jr~ y -1<.) C{),
\~~ ~(A,>
C ~ ~ \P ~
f\0.CN r,:"C-cA,ll \ S "" \ '*.l".,
Elf/'-.J
,
I
!
I
I
, ~ ~i
?' quOO'fk ! \
~~,,~
~, ~ Cf' tv <;; ,-
\~o f)&l ~S~ --
tV D-fv.- S ~
I S'() ~ 7~)"" 0 I C; 8
/71 ~ '38
Cui ?Yo
A.JoJl'c..'i:.. m :;>,l hel
~ ::8 0
'Tl
.~~ G1 -1
ih;;g
!J~
~~" N ~~
t::L'> -0
2~c) L.
:x ,')
~(~) \r"c
\,;' N 0111
~ .. :;;~
tJ'1
-' ~
"
,J/U!9 'I t:iu;., c..
!