HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-02562
J I f,
.~ >~ I
',J 1 ~ \
I' R 1
"5 \'
"~ ",
" ,
I.... i'l VI
, "
,-. :?"
~,.. ,-'I'~
~ 'ill"
5:~ /~~d
~'" (:.:?::
), rJ~~ ~
,~~ IP
~b)R "', ~
QJ .%wl2 rt-..:,
0'"' ~ (/).11:; N '~1 >.:
"':.~{on. ~ ',J ~
S~~gg'! "
aJ~~"~~' ~
,.Cj~~ wi': l'
"t:~Q.;;H~ ;,
ro::>~" u"' "
f"'\.u.I-~~n..
_ fficZw '~'
EJ~Z ~ ~
i'> "'
'0 'iij
. ~
F. _
~ ~
:; ro CD
u. CI _
,~~~\
~I
Vi
ill
!::
"' , (j
!i . ~~
~ ~a
~ ~ is q
:t: P. ~ ~ "
~gm€~~
() ;0; 0 <'l :~
'I
"
-
~
..
~ L
Sj'" H
i5' ~jj
i ~ ~
oU~j
~;'6~
~ .,5 G~
iJlU ~g
en 2:l i _ 4>
w~~o.&
"'u "
u- ~ !
~~ ~ 1O.~
l- w ...5,4>"
ZUl ala.bl3
::>0 3I1lC l/l- u.
~~!~ ~~ ~
~gb:~~ ~
~8J~ ~~ ~
?~~.!~~ ~
~~ ~q k Ei
~i?2~~o ;i
~ u..... 0 ~8 ffi
o~.. rr. ~ Z
~ ~ ~ ~ ti Li.i it
W~II ~!.! l'i
"'50 :l$> (j)
... a: ~ ex: w
~A~ ~~m ~
...~-':' i 'Zi "rr :t
g.~~=>w
"C "i.. 0 ~
~ ti ~ n Vi
... ~ TI <l .,
e' M h - m
~ ~ ;I~OH "IVtUNfH' ;!LV~)lltlllll
,.... lNlIl:l :llV~JI'Hrl()
M Hill! V,.40 (J ,." .lvtW)IUO
I
';H
V> V>
. ~ g.~ l;i
.jj~~!i'1i
. ~-~" t
~h~'i "~
~l;gt;
.~~~h \
. h~~~ <;
: .~S lo,fI a
. ~~.~~ ~
. ~ ~ ~ t
. tllo.,lII ~'to;
· . · ~ oJ! '
:~~li~& ~
· ~ ~l! t~ ;j
t"~'a ~ ~
.:) s ~ -;
".n~ ~
~€llil 0
. ~ ll: a "Ii u.
~~it: ,iO[5
", 1l ~ 1I III
~ 0 ::a::a ~ ).,<(
<( ).,~ a 0 e.c 1I!
21 t; ~)i; :-...- ll: 0:
u;
~d
. I
V> V) M' VI V. V>
! '
!
~ ~',l
on
):
~-'
, 2
'"
~~
Cl \1,
05
mo
"' w
~1oO
l1.l1-
0*
l5tn
;:ui
~ ~~
(t.:J
wO
u:.(
n. u.
ffi~
r ",
I-(/)
o~
1;;
.q
i2 OJ
",1 ~l'
:::' Ii '
tl,~!11
r~l~1 ~
II) VI III II) II) VI
2
~
"
:5
0-
(11 I .
f ~
E
.
u
'"
F. .
.
f- >r
o.;q,
"Q
'" J-
~i,1
: ~~t
'S'll
:~ ~~ I
. ;~<;t:1
i.}'\111 II
"-.l:1
I.~
t"..~ M-j
')' 'r
~ ........,:--.
~ "', I I'
o ~ n'l
Eo'" i'''I1
~ u: ,....-;~
li
r)\!
r": i
"<J'
V>
VI f/) V) II)
~.-
,.';1 m
. ..
..
tr ~
t ~
f-
V,
,~I
;1
\ ,~~l
111\
,
V>
j IN
!e
~ i"V.
€ I
]j I
<I) ~ iJj" V't .A
@
~
f-
V>
0:
~
"
,.
V> on
I
. I
~ '
I:: I
ffi I
5
"'
~
ro
.
"
'I
E
"
E ~.
~ " ~.
, 1ii
if 0 ~
.(
~ ~ (/),
c E "
. ~ ~
a: . 15
n
Vi
III
~I
Q:
If) jJ) I/) Vl Vllll Vl
H!
OJ .. J:
. ! .
.! . !
OJ OJ "
Iii
>, OJ ..
g ~ ~
~ !IJ .~
Iii > ~
U C "ill
J.1l Q 0
~ 19 E
:l ill $
u. :> ~
H~
M
.. I i f
~.. ;0
ILl 'il ~ ~
~ j ~ "
9~ 8 :i
"" ,
o~ ~ 0
W>, tJl-
Cl ~ I:: 4\ N
2' E :: po ~
<t: 4.l ~ c: W
il.:u > ~ (/')
~u c; .- oj)
Ii,'~ ~ '~ ~
U. 4J ~, b ;.
05 ii1 ~ ~
U.jl1. :> ... L"l
In
"
a:i 1
U,
t:1
Q. I
'"
~ ~
0
r t
~ &
"
c
'" ~
21-
12 Kl
0 :1
f- ...
"l 12 "
'" "
, -. :;;
~ it .
:i 5 t'
w
~ 0 ~ ~
" - w ~
0 w ."J
> u
~ t= " Ci
'" Q 0;
u. ,< . ,
III ., ~ " 0
2 0 ,
~ ,- u U- ti:
oc ::>
,- ~
u:f
0.,
,itw!Q ~~U W
I, !~.'~! l~~~
- , . !H
~ I~J 'Jut ~~) '!i~~ ! H
'" < ,., l>.1 . , ' ,
U 11. ; fj'iJ -0 C> r,j!1
~ () ! t1,~ Y1li! rn~ l' 1\ 1j
III '.' 61 () p." ~ f-' ~l ~ ,',~,?,?' -,.
Vi :,~-! ::.( i;l ~ ., \.'
.( E! _~~ c f. '':'
m i-! li3~ ~C~~ f~~
~: i .~X ~ ~. g ri~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ W
r ! i~ ~ ,. ..~!! E ~ ,~ ~ ~ g
~? ! tl.~_\! I.: \' ...1 0' ,) h 1. ~
, 'ii c: d: \ i'l 'o""~ IJ Q ., '-,.
: i I {) ..~ r: ~.c 'J ,ill ..
., ).'~U, j .," .M'" nk ~ ',.
g: 1\ii1 ~-:~ 1jiJ~~~~
, i:U-~ ..-.: L SJ ~" . l, "
() 1,..<<1 "q ~!.!~~[\g, I'
u '1'1: t ~ li~;-:- f, ';i ~ Ii ~ ~~ -:- I "t.
~! : ~ g ,M il tV) S ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~,
01 'lE;ij~h' f'lld~
~ r~~~i~ ~hW
f? I~~U"., fi ~~ I.,I~,.J I
[/" 1!...~~:I.( ~B~~t~ I
~ n~~H H!m;1
'UL i1f4~~d: ~g;6ftt" ,I
>-.. I 0 ~- 0 U, Q. ~ n ~ ""
rr lilJ"Eu(:: a;~M_~~r\ I.y,
R I!.h~~ fj~!~~~ ifl
,~~ ~~!2~r?~ ~$~l~i, 15
u1 ~ I ~ n f- w r~ 0 ~ :. ~ v' ,I ~
t5 ti~~fiod{ ~1l6~f~ ~I~ I
."_Bn~' ..i-Il.I-
~ ItJH~~B~ m~ 'JI}'
_ .. '~EOC1la;O~~{}!
ill ~ 1..Q ....~-u-fi li's' l!
u I~!i v)lil~~i~~~~
;) ~C~~l:4DI'J~~ ~~\'... ~
~ o;c~ a:Cltio~I"~! .~ c,"
~j ~ ~ ~ ld.. ~ ~ 1; f;j 8 : t. ~ ~ Ii 5iiSl ~,
"I I \ I
';- <'I
~;>I :]'1
! I, ';,
8 g.j (~ >,!
It >f ,.I\t \1
N "j' 'IN ~
~ .'
i '1~ /;
~ ",j ,'.18 il
,:1:1 ~1
'I ~ ,1 ~..~:
....~. ~ J.? ~:::'
~ E .,! 1: .;..'..1
8' ~. ;Ii}, '''-''~'i
, \.,',
I E'
~
t'
.I
~
"
'"
:Li
. ~ " u
q:; !l
. .
o <5
- ~ .~ ~
.;' ~
~ "
Iii,.. tiJ
"
,
"
~
~
~ ~
1i ~
ft ~ ~
L]
~~5
U~
~ ~ ti
~~li
no:
"
.....
~
U} VI fJ) VI VI VI'\.;
'!4 '"
::;
0 0
r :r:
~ <i
a:
"' w
z z
~ ~
" u.
oc 0:
W W
~ iE
0
" il
<
i? :a
0
m ~ 0:
"
~ V>
ui Z
IiJ " ill ~
is m
" u- "'
.( " . ~j" 10 0:
, c <, " "' "
" E. 0 " " " z 0
oc ,. n 5
'" . 0 g is "'
:i u ~ '" 9 oc z
" " u " ,!j ~ ;;:
UI ~ ~ 0 , ~ w
, " i.\ li Ii' c'
~ ~ c " , ,
" Cl '"
0 ~ 0: ~ ci () Ie. a:
I I I: I
V> V>
V> W V>
\ \j '.j :~ t')
fJ) fJ) fJ) 0 en ~~~ U}
, l
.~.')..I :;..
:"~ \ \
;.; \J'
'\'., ,"
.'<( '-
.., \ ('
\),~~. "
:'li~
:)'1 t-:) . ;.,
~. '. '1. "', ,";
~ .'J \V~ ::
:6 '.\....' d n ,.1 '-
il'" ~,,\: ,
:c "--0 ~ ".)
<..> P .......::~ '
iT. III ,n. 1../..
:~~~~.~ '~
: IJl <1> ~ a;
. J t: </I ~
iijOir~~l?
U tlI .'!> l'l: -
"' z '. ,~ ':i
.~ .{ ::, ., "
g ~3 t-; 0 0
C UJ .'-. 0 E
Jl 0 l/. ~
~
.,
.. ,
':" I ~-.~
". .
"'. <:..:
"
,l.,; ;,.....
,,,
.),"
~\t
~
~
'.
III
,!
oc
'"
Z
~
f-
Z
o
U
)~ ,. ;i
, -
" a:
::>
'm
1r.
w
,-
::>
o
tu
:..~
>II
iJ
~
~
\j -
~ lJ
,- 2
Ji J:
"
.( .
:; ~.
15 <i
~ ~
u,
oc I'!
u '"
l- Ei
u ,.
~! :i
a !i
'"
0.
~
,
...0
&
.-I
"
o
,('4
0\
.....
t'"\
.
o
~
d
2
~
<(
o
w
t)
o
>
2
~~
~~f:
tIl '0
<O~
1><'
~~~
t3~
~~
b""
.,
~~~
~~~
d
2
IT
a:lU
:)5!
~O
o
2
IT
LLI
a:D
:J[(
00
~~~_.-
~ - ....
-- .:::. '>
...~ -;;;.-
, ,"-= '"
\. '~,~-~
"~~\ ~~, -
'. -:;'
- '\
ct- ~\ ~
,:~~
"Sll 1181HX3
\ /'\1 0 8
~;; 8 0
!..-i ci .
td () 0
0 8
~-r n Lf\
If\ H
- - --.-
--
"
'"
rcl n,
- -_..-. -
-
"
J~ <:; III
,I ~~ "
6 cr
(;) 0,
0 III
,I
~t. ':!, -.---
'" Ii) ---. ~ -
0 ....- --
H
"
~, "
~,' ...:t
~it;;
:< <l)
<l) ~
'f. ;l ~
'@ 0 0
I"
c" Cl, +'
[L
'E ,\1~
in
- z ,ci
0 M,
~I 0 [;' if! '"
III , 0
CL 6' 'r!
[L U ~I +'
1: (f) <1l u
UJ w ,r! <1>
lI' 0 ~U)
'" -Q <::
0 'rl
- "-'
o "
0
<1>N
t'"\ I ~+'
0 .2 oS
r4
'- H
<l) rl ::l
::l n,
~ rcl If) , "
" I
,. cr. 0
, o:t: ~t.,
UI
<:: " .... -,
hO
0 H CJ
.,
. Ul il llJ
-'I " [L
0 Ul 9:
'0 ~ '~ :r:
a If)
'" ~
H
0 .-I r:r:
r:1 0
~LJ
I f5
. 0
c~ cc
Q 0
- ~....-' .....-
.
~
+'
~
<l)
o
+'
<l)
~
;:j
o 0
r .
Q. +'
X ~
(f)
"
'0
<1l
o
PC:
~"':
H
o
t--<
'0
H
o
IX)
0\
H
t,;>
'H
4-,
o
o
.
"'~
'OJ
+'
~
H
o
'H
o
in'
,-
'H
o
o
'OJ
,r!
H
"
m
'"
o
r..
o
1-
a
..J
o
([)
4--
.-l
<(
z
a
a:
o
~!
(:i
IT.
o
~
I
~_-: ,i
:,~
~ '>",
, ~_:hl;n
,:at:
, .:0,"
'()7\""
",;c,
~;~
'p..,
',~
, ;,q;
()~
;:ill,.;?~t-
'-(~-I:Q
F,< "
:(~;;
,(t~,i~
1_' \\;!uj,
!1.!0':
;.,i"1
-,~') ,
o
,
,
"
I II
, '!!
I
.
~. .
[0.1'
'~
",
_,I"
,.'-
,"-"'j,
~
.n
';,
"
'l;
'"
,~,I I
,'~~lll;
~ .t 11111
I II,!,.
~., ,
. ' .
'",
,~
Cl- (~) t;<
~~1 c.::
!,!,(') (~.J '".,
J
(l.,.. ,;il'U'
U!.. i-;:: ()
I !
(I
1); ,
fijU; h.
[[Pi "';. I , i'i
/-' ~i. / !!f!J
'!" e'J .,-'1.1-..
0 en '~
(1\ c.)
~ ~ 8
~ ~ ! ~ ~
r... (ri ~ '~1 ~I I::::, ~
'1...... ~"o\
11~~~' i:::q
-:s . e;'>~ ~ "-
"" :-l"I 0 .f! '" -.; ~
~ e (jl\~ ~.~
~~ Jf' '~~
~ ~~
I,
george lQ), :Porler
(.l1.Lj-,
DONA!JD COFFEY and IN THE COUR'r OF' COMMON PI,EAS OF
DIANE COFFEY, I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiffs I.
vs, I
NO, 98-2562
MARY E, EVANS,
Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PRABCIPB
Please enter our appearance as co-counsel for Donald Coffey and
Dl.ane Coffey, plaintiffs in the above captioned action,
Date, (6)/-?<b
_J~1Jzr-
Ronald D, Butler, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiffs
I,D, #09826
300 North Second Street
P,O, BoX 430
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0430
(717) 236-1485
, ')
/ .", //.'
(" )( "t:t:5'"- <:'..
'.
'\~,...
300 North second Street
p,O, BoX 430
HarriSburg, PA 17108-0430
(717) 236-1485
DONALD COFFEY and
I>JANE COFFEY,
PlaintiO:~
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, I'ENNSYLV ANIA
v,
CIVIL ACTION - LA W
MARY E, EVANS,
Detendant
NO, 98-2562 CIVIL TERM
AND NOW, this
ORDER OF COURT
\ (( (tday of November, 1998, upon consideration of Plaintiffs'
Motion for Sanctions under Pa, R,C.P, 40 19(a)( I )(i) and 40 19(a)(I )(vii) for Failure to
Respond to Discovery, a Rule is hereby issued upon Defendant to show cause why the relief
requested should not be granted,
RULE RETURNABLE within 20 days of service.
BY THE COURT,
tel
.' --'7
/ ,/ .(~. j >
J. '(I, sley Oler, Jr., J:
Ronald D. Butler, Esq.
Jana C. Butler, Esq.
500 North Third Street
P.O, Box 1004
Harrisburg, P A 17108-1004
Attorneys for Plaintiff..~
George W. Porter, Esq.
909 East Chocolate Avenue
Hershey, PA 17033
Attorney for Defendant
c......ltc~~ !"'~ "t I'll 'II ~ '6 '"
:rc ,~:i .
ll\i
i.1
9'li ~ I ! C, l,\~,,-; Cd
,:,)
, ..
DONAt,O COFFEY /Iud
DIANE COF,'EY,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COuNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
r/laintiffs
vs,
NO, 96-2562
MARY E, EVANS I
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Defendant
PLAINTIFFS' FIRST SET OF
INTERROGATORIES ADDRESSED TO DEFENDANT
TO. Mary E, Evans
c/o George W, Porter, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
909 East Chocolate Avenue
Hershey, pennsylvania 17033
Plaintiffs, Donald and Diane Coffey, by and through their attorneys,
Ronald D, Butler, P,C" ~ilimit this Plaintiffs' First Set of Interrogatories
Addressed to Defendant to be answered in writing and under oath within thirty
(30) days of service of same in accordance with Pa,R,C,P, No, 4005 and 4006,
These interrogatories are deemed to be continuing to the extent provided in
Pa,R,C,P, No, 4007,4,
If any Interrogatory is objected to, in whole or in part, or if the
information responsive to an Interrogatory is withheld on the ground of
privilege or otherwise, set forth fully each objection, describe generally the
information which is withheld, and set forth the facts upon which you rely as
the basis for each objection,
EXHIBIT RAil
p~:ntH'I'WNfI
Unless negatecl by the aOlitext of the I\11:erragatory, the following
definitions are aonsid.,red to be <<pplioablo to all Inten:ogatod.w oontainad
herein:
A, "Docu~lSnt," shall mean the original and any nonidentical copy
of any written, printed, typed, photographsd or other graphic or recorded
matter of any kind or nature prepared or received by or in possession, custody
Or control of the answering party, t,heir agents, servants, employees or other
representatives,
B. "Identify," when used in reference to an individ\lal, shall mean
to state his or her full name and present or last known residence, When Llsed
in reference to an entity, "identify" shall mean to state the name of the
entity and the address of its principal office. With respect to documents,
"identify" means to give the name or title of the document; the date of the
document; the date it was received by you if it came from another source; to
d'escribe the document sufficiently well to enable the interrogator to know
what the document is and to be able to retrieve it from a file or wherever it
may be located; and to give the name, address and position or title of the
person or persons who has or have custody of the document (or of copies of the
document if the original no longer e>:ists) ,
C, "Person" and/or "Individual" shall mean any individual,
partnership, firm, corporation, trust, governmental agency, or other entity;
and also, where relevant, the individual representing such "Person."
COM/IlCIHW~'H O' ""Nlnl'ANIA
--"ciiilafOl t.OMMON PllAI- ---
,J, ) (r~
NOYlCE 0' APPEAL
4J-,)j (1\(11
fROM
lUtNCIAL DIIT~IC'
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
-~-_.-._-~_._.,_.........-.._------,_._--" ---" ----.--------.
CCMlMON mAl N.. 98-2562 Civil Tf:lrm
----_._~-._..".. .. ------.------_._--
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notic. I. g1_ that the appellant hat filed in tho above Ca..' of Common Plea. an "",,,,al from the judgmenl rendered by lhe Oi.trict Ju.lk. on lhe
date and In the ca.. mentIaned below,
1WlrN ........... ___no_....,_..,.... ..",'u ,,------------ '" ,.._u___ -------~..-1~l5J1't\Ml1ln1--'--'--"-'
.; !J:lIllilUNlC c_E I!fl/lj~~----_------m-'----?JfY--,---"--U,----Q'1 ;!A' -- (') I ---- 'HOOf
5'1 J)LJS(~~De, "!l~I--nT.'-- _ __ _ -_GR~N.....n/I(I.J;.___._,____'__F...~_n=_--,--L1.~~
Dl\Tlor~ ~A lJII'(Vai~lrIJ .." (I.-'efI.JfllJnJ
- ,,-~, q L.1~.!!Fffj~b,A".kQr~JL-m~~ FjI~, N5~, mIlJ}.Y
QAW. NO NA IJIII~ UI" ""'1' l ANI OR 11$ AI otI~y ~ AOfNT
cv 19-2/ .. 9 f..._________ '7'11.. OA CO ~(-<L
~bIo.:k -;"ill ~~ ONLY when thij ,';;,ati';;;Ts-;&qui-;-;dund.,-;-Pa." fl,(,P,J.P, No, -Ii appellant was "CLAIMANT (see''P8, RCP,JP, -,,,o~
l00Bl '
ThIt Notic. a' Appeal, when rec.ived by tho Di.lric' Ju.tiee, will operate a. a 1001(6) In aclion before District Justice, he MUST
SUPERSEDEAS 10 the judgment for poueulan in thi. ca... FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after
-----s7iii'i.tllle..af ProlIJO(IDI.ry or CJiiiji;iY------- filing his NOTICE of APPEAL
----.------'"RAECIPE TOE""'-Ti'RliuIETO-jiiiiC-OMPLAINT AND RuIDo FILC'-'--
(This section of foon to be used ONLY w/I~n appollaflt WaS DEFENDANT (soo Pa, HG.PJ.P, No, 1001(7) in action be/OfO DIs/f/ct JliSt/cO,
IF NOT USED, detach from C(l)Y of notico 0/ appeal to be served lIpon appelloo),
PRAECIPE. To Prothanafary
Enter rule upon ,__&f" t: EIL,.1 J~"!._U.j) i' N /I Lb_____ ,appellee(.), to file a complaint in !hi. ~
Nwoo of awolloo( s}
(Cammon Plea. No. 98- 2 56:2 _~ i viI Term ) within twenty (20) day. afler .ervice of rule or .uffer entry of judgment of non pm..
-'1Y1CLuI C~,~1o,~._or~
j])(JtJAIb" appellee(.),
RULEI To~COfFaJ._b..JAAJ€
IWI", '" _10ol.)
(1) You ant nolifled that a rule i. henIby entered upon you ta file a complaint in ,hi. appeal within twenty (20) cloy. after the date "I
....vic. of !hi. rule upon you by p.nanal ,ervke or by certified or regl.tered mall
(2) H you do not file a complaint within thi. time, a JUDGMENT Of NON PROS WILL BF. ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
(3) The date af ..rvic. of thi. rule if lervlce wa. by mail i. t.... date of moili
Date:-4A Y
,6- q F/
,19_,
~
AOPC 311011,4
COURT FIL.E TO BE FILED WITH PROTHONOTARY
NOTICE OF JUDGMENT/TRANSCRIPT
, .., CIVIL CASE
I_LAIN llff" 'IM,ll Ul'cl I\Dl)ill'_j:,
r COFFEY, DIANE/DONALD -i
112 HOUSTON AVE
HARRISBURG, PA 17103
L ~
COMMONWEAL TI-I OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND
I_'_>O;~(;:\I;-;:-~~=~::::':'::====~==--=~=:;"---==------=:;:::""--='"
09-1-01
u!rj,IU',Q tL",
CllARLES A. CLEMENT, .TR.
^cI'J<m 1106 CARLISLE ROAD
CAMP HILI., Ph
VS,
UEfTNDAnl I,/,',It ,1"1 .'<'_J~IIH 'j:
'EVANS, MARY
57 AUSTIN DR
GRANTVILLE, PA 17028
l_
r.:-"' .~---_...--._-
DocketNo CV-0000091-98
Date Filed: 2/19/98
I ,,'"""'" (717) 761-4940 17011
L.........___.'__T____._.____.__".,".,_.~__...
MARY EVANS
57 AUSTIN DR
GRANTVILLE, PA 17028
"
-~._-_..__._-_._-~-_..._..._~----'~
THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT:
Juclgmellt:
DRFAULT JUDGMENT ,_,ELj~_,_,___,__~_,
l1L Judgment was ellteledlor:
(Name) ~nl1l1F.'4-1lTA1ITF./nO"Il\,T.n
W Judgment was entered against: (Name) ~N!l. MARY
-,
...I
a~&
g}~
_._..~-- ---------------'. --_.~
ill 1118 amount of $
(Date 01 Judgment)
4/0~ IQR .___
. .
::I,4~4 ';0, on.
(Date & Time) ___...__,_.,_____,____
o
o
o
o
[]
o
Delenclants are JOIl1i1y and sevelally liable.
Damages wili be assessed on:
Amount 01 Judgment
Judgment Costs
Interest on Judgment
Attorney Fees
Total
TillS case dismissed Witllout prejudice,
Amount of Judgment Subject to
AtlachmentlAct 5 011996 $____~,
Levy is stayed lor ___ days or 0 generally stayed,
Post Judgment Credils
Post Judgment Costs
$__~,J 400....2.0
$__.~4 .50
Q .00
0+'--'--
$__,__,-OJ1
$2....i.64.50
L.
$-,----
Certified Judgment Total $~..~~~~
---------~--
...--_.__..--_...~.
ObJeclion to levy has been Iiled and hearing will be Ileld:
-~~---".__._~_......,-_.
Dahl.
Place:
~_._--~---~._-
Time:
ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BY FILING A NOTICE
OF APPEAL WITH THE PROTHONOTARY/CLERK OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, CIVIL DIVISION, YOU
MUST INCLUDE A COPY OF Tf-l.IS NOTICE OF, JUDG_~ENT/T\(~SCAIPT ~OR,M,WITH ~Ol!R~0T~CEPF, APPEAL,
----',~.'.',:."'.::_u___ Date_ U~_\.v. '~_lLJ. , v/.,_.;1;,',-"ii' , ,District Justice
..., .
I certify that this IS a tlue an~wrrect copy 01 the,rec~"d\OI t~e procee(lin~~n~~nin? t~~ j~~gment. '
_,':~~::.'!_"__,_ Date ~~~i1~':::..~,_'--'c..-~__,:-:~----,~.:...:~, ,.' '"',-:;,, '-:. ' Distnct Justice
~~. ....
, "-
,
,
I
.,
'. ./
'I., SSAL
"'t",
My commission expiros Ilrst Monday 01 January,
2002
t7: cn >~ ,
l;'f( I"
.' "
(.,; " ..
(', .;~~ ~,T
~N: -. .,
....() ;"~; "
lb'I '-'l;
Ule.
f In
1:: I , . mp
r.-I" >'~ I"~ !Lfi
I~ J f~ ) Ct.
f': :t:
b ~ :::,i
(.1
~ \..
~~J~
~
,.J
~
~
'-
\
~~
"^' 'f-S-
,., \...\.. Y')
~ ~ '--S
J~'~
~,iwt.,"-.",-y,V_
C_' or COMMON PlIAI -
.'
HOTlCI O' A"IAL if!) II ...( " ;~II
I'llOM
lUDIClAL IIITlIe' '
DISTRICT JUSTlCI JUOQMINT
COMMON PlIAI ....
98-2'\62 C evil 'I'utn
NOTICE 0' APPIAL
Notice II ~ thai the appelb,1 has fllld In '''' above Court of Common ~ an "l'P'CIl from tho JIIdgn\enI .....d bv the DI.'rlet Juttlce oft ....
... CI!d In tho _ """Holoed I>eIo.l '
fWIlI Of APPIU.AHr -
V .,111,-!;{. E V;JNS
, ..:5'7 US rnJ be. ~
"'"~ ,~(1II_,"1
, "lIllII11b - t, - q ~ A!..! f' E 'I I
CV 19. 9/-9 f?
J09-~/':(~in'
GAIRClI'N r VI( L t ITp A
,- , lo.tWiiIintr
()/llNE)})OAJiHi) Yl [:YIIMS,rr/'MJY
'EArPtLlANftJttlSATlOllJl4l!YOIAOINT ,-
JI{l
,-- "7ri',(~lA'<'1 C . c',Ut"-"(.Q,
IT 19 ------'-- ,~
Thk j,/ockwll be t/grJod~,thI. nolatl,," I. required under Pa, RC.I'.JP, No. 1f~llint was 'CLAIMANT (see Pa--:REP.J.P. No.
1001& (I _\\.\ I'" ,) r.:, \ .\ 1'\ 1.\ \ t,' I,
ThkNolice of Appool, whorl ........." bv the 1ll,Irlet Ju.tlce, ",III apetate Of a l00'1(6}I118CtlonbefQre~I/~~tJustlce,treMUST
SlM'!RSI!DEAS Ia tho judgment "" po.....1oo In thl. ca.a FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after
~ \
',llIng his NOTICE of APPEAL.
SIgndIUf8 01 I'rolhcnatary 01 l5iiiiUfy---.;-----
II'(;QUI
/ 1"( () ,)8j
'v ", ,~p~AECI"EI T~ 1~:rElt ."LE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE ' '
, (T1!IIlItOrlon 01 fotm to be uslldONLY wlHlrr appel/ant was DEFE~DANT I~ Pa, R,C'p,J,P, NO, 1001(7) In ac/loo,befote ~,&Ict Justice,
IF NOT UfiJED. detach /rom copy of notice of appeal to be, servlld'lJ{XJ(l ~/Iee}, " .
'IAICI'E. To .....lhonolarY "
~ nJre lIPO"-_{ZP F t~ E Y I D I t:I 1,)/[,/6 tJ tJ II u)
N.",. 01 oppcI/8eI.)
98~2562 Cl.vll '!'tlrm '
) within twenty (20) day. ofteto ..,ylee af rule 01' .uffer ""lfy of judgment af non """"
''7/1
Yn ClA.<J. C. LA-,"'t:!.4L-~
-r S/gneIu'e 01 -'"'" Of hill .It>mey or __ ,
, appellee(.), to file a complClln' ,In INs appeal
(Common P\eas No.
RULI. To
(!OFFl,Y, hlf.ll..Je.
Nsine~.)
/])ON II Lb ,appeNu(.),
(I) V""cn notlfIed that 0 rule I. hnby en""'" upon you to file a complaint In If.. appeol wltNn tMnly (20) day. aftw the dalII af
..w.. of this rule upar\ VOU h'f p....onol .eryle. 01' bv certified 01' "'lll$tored moll
Datt:
:""~"'''''' "''''\'-'\\
' ,'II
:::~ ~ :~:: :::w;:::,: ~~;: =:S ~ll BE ENTEREDJ~GAIN$TVOlI." ::l~I'I~,\.
A ''''i'A" 'f
!r/AV .:r, 19.2X ! M elf, ' ,~,;
~, ,"
'.j
"
,. ~
'It. '-,',
: t:,i,;f ,
"
COURT FILE
:j<r
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
'.J
fThls /lIool 0180rv/O(l MUS 1 I-IE: EIl.EII WI nUN n N (10) DA Y8 AI- rill IIlIlIg 1110 nO/I()(l 0' "f',,08' VI",,,k OPI'IIoaM9 boxes)
t4" copy ollho NOli"o 01 API'",d, CW""OI1 Plo"s No, ,9~~~4.. ~, LlI,on tlI(' Di~Jtrl"t Justlco d'lSignotod Iherf)inon
(dato 01 !loi'VIe") ,/fJ/J,"-,~7I.l'i'l~ ____", [J bl' porsonal "OIVlcn Il( by (oerliliod) (r091>16Iu<l) mall, son<lor's
reeeipl allaehu<l horolo, lJnd uponllilJ iJppoll<1o, (f""iltl) ~ ~,,,CQIf'-~it-]),l6!blF-/.1:2aNJJ.l,J:)____,_,__, on
-"./J1,ttI,,~'l--~ , 19_~~i' fJ by po,"ol1l1l "orvlel) i.i1 by (certified) (mgl~ler",11 ,"oIl, sendor's receipt allached herelcl,
[iiI and ""Ihm thai I SO:V""lhO fllIlo 10 fllo a Co,"!,lolnl "cconJPilnYlo!U'?-a~ovo NOIi(~e of ;PP"'~llIPon Iho appollm,(.) 10 whom
Iho 11uIu w,,~ udel,o,'so,! on ----/1/..4,1.... 'l--~m..._..~~, 19.t"__, U by p(Hso"al ,lor Vice fIG by (c.ertllledl (reglsloredl
mllll, !wnclor'n reeolpl f1ttachud IlfJtlJtp
SWanN (M'f-lnMED) AND SUBSCfllflbD BEFOfl[' ME
THIS ___.1..!t!. (;,I,Y OF ~MIt '1-__ _ ,19_ Q 8'
._____JIA '~~m..,
SI(}niltl/ft l~1 ~Jf.lIOff; wi 11 r1f1111,\wl W~ll mte/',
I
I
.. I
i
COMMONWfAlllt Of Pf.NNSVlVANIA
-
COUNTY Of..,..-.1JA.().fJlI~_ ,_.. '''_' ; ,.
AFFIDAVIT: I heroby SWUllI 01 "ffirfTI thAI I t,tlf'V(l(1
,
!
~ -
, , ~-'__"'''.'..~__''...~.___..-l.._
'mJeOfb!lit)ll11
MytOlnfnl$,j({iil.
f,'~~~~!= NIIo" Is
~ 'li".'HIl)tIVtr 1Wll,. D.u~n OO\lIllY
My Oomml.,lon SKpl,.. "prll 7, 1001
~bII.l'allnlllNlnII AlIOClIItiIllI
~_'1~.._C ~"ro 0/ alll~7,T-
Z 034 326 460
POI'.
C.I1iIledF..
() U') ~
c ro ..
~,.. ::-e -t
'uf:r''i "" ..r:
ftl( :' H>: ;;1:r1
:'-~~ :T r-
:/.", t;:, I uEll
~:) <:;_1 ,,I
:)
~~ L; 'IU
W1'.J L~H
~l:~ ("'1 :.'1::' ")0
(') ):-'-~f'n
~t. t ,:" ',.J
hl~ ,..(
'.:J c~ ~,
-<- U1 ~,
$
}2
/,3<;-
Spedol DeIlv.1'f F..
/ 10
6. Admitted.
7 . No relponle is neoenary.
Re8peotfully submitted,
kflJ
. Porter, R8quire
52
Chooolate Avenue
Herlhey PA 17033
(717) 533-7130
....2.
">-I ~l' ,
fr (;
.11 ..'""
I ~~:~
,
,
I ~ . \
"
, (\J 1,
(. ..-.:
" , I
l leI.
I..' .~.
" to ..1
( , 0' ()
Ll.c(
0....
~~
UJ..J (/)
..J>- ... ... UJ ~ , ~
o.Vl 4- " u , ~
Z .... ro ..., 1: a ~
ZZ +' '0 ". , .
~ -
OUJ c: c 0:: '-1l ro;! '. ~
!!"" 'C .... Ql UJ -
~ ~
c: '" ... Vl .11I ~ ,
0 - ~ '" ~ Ql ~ .. r~'~ ~ ~
u>- 0. (/) -0 Ll. ~ ;:;
"
I- ..J >- . > Vl 0 ~G~('j ~ ,
Ll.Z UJ >- Z ;:;t<.
0::> , Ll. UJ c( UJ ~ ~ ' ,'\
0 Ll. Ll. ". ~ BM
I-UNZ~ 0Ll. UJ ~ J ~
0:: "'" 0 or- uo U 0., 1 l',
=>CLOt---tll) w . .... IJ) ~
02:Nl-'o. 0 oJ Ll. .~
uc(,UE ..J UJ ....
-1COCC::S ~~ >- I-
L1J 0:: 0\ V) ~ 0::
:I:UJ ..J(/) 0..... I~
I-CO ~-l oct: CC u
:E .:>
z: :::>>Ot---t ~
t-tUZ;UI-t
.
. '
DONALD COFFEY and
DIANE COFFEY,
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYI_VANIA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LA W
MARY E. EVANS,
Defendant
NO. 98-2562 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURI
AND NOW, this I ')f I day of December, 1998, upon consideration of Plaintiffs'
Motion for Sanctions under Pa, R,C.P, 4019(11)(1 )(1) IInd 40 19(a)( I )(vil) for Failure to
Respond to Discovery, and of Defendant's Answer to Plaintiffs' Motion for Sanctions,
Defendant is directcd to answer Plaintifl[i' interrogatories and produce the documents
requested by Plaintiff.~ within 30 days of the date of this order, or suffer the imposition of
sanctions.
BY THE COURT,
.I.,
!
Ronald D. Butler, Esq.
.Iana C. Butler, Esq,
500 North Third Street
P,O. Box 1004
Harrisburg, P A 17108-1004
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
(')
c"' 10
. (,'lJ
'nt/;' \'.")
(J./{i. ;"1"
l:?f_-~ C?
E:'I': ,
'~.~Li, '""-J
>,C) r::~_
;:;;E? ;'
~~'
'-
-
(")
'I
, ~I
'Ii ~CI
',,(71
U,?
'("
'1.J
1':'1
:)(')
ijf"l1
'/
't.
:J)
""
,OJ}' "I q~,
".8,1-'.
George W. Porter, Esq.
909 E~st Chocolate A venue
Hershey, PA 17033
Attorney for Defendant
C\>rr<"'" r1>~Q.....,l
:rc
~
, c:,
i' ..
c;
"
,,' ".'1 ,
, ,
,
I'
1.--; '1
, "
. I,
(I)
l.il
4
'F
!:l , ~
~ , .
"a ~ r~
N en ~ ~
L,,\ ...., , " ;:
~ ] ~ ~i
~ "1~:
~:-tl ~
III e l5 r, EO)
.... c ~ ,t-;
r"~ ij ~
is t':; 'J'1!
(j) ~~
'-
.
gedrge 7;) 7'orlel'
~J
.IAN 1 3 1999 ./
J-/
~
c
"
c ~
~ .)
I. ~
~ -i~
~ ,
~.!::o
!;~
'"
"
If,
if' \..l
Iii ;:
/ ~!I~ l
tj_.. ~'c' ~;;
\ "~Il.Ii\C.J ~}
'"
<Il
CII'
r li) \J -,;
r.ortliXj
... 'i' t" \-
~
~ ';::J
'3 ~
0" ...
<1\,<
~.~ ~
....::l6
g ~ r-
OC) 1'"'"1
,,,"..3 <r:
;....' u ~
t:>.... "
v, >,
%'0 OJ .l:J
h ~ ~
8 0., ~
'.:,J ~ ;r:
I 0
~ " E;
I ~
~ ~ ~ ~
, :i
~ t( 0 g ,..
I ::5" ~ d~
~ ~ t ;z
, "'
~~~d~
~ ~ g /. ~
i::l 0 "'
o ..
" "
;:J Oi
~ ~
,..'
"C'_;\
-I,
L ~r~~t;..
. j, ~
., '.'
t t;) '-'I
~
J ,t;
ii.'.__ _'
" ~1~1,
, 'I".,
, f -, \ ~
<-~; \.
, ;;
I'
,_t
If
.~
/.'
"
,t4'-.!-\..f~,; it--~:,,-,~,
.
';"1( ;,4"
,< " ' , '"
1'" J
,I ~~-'_Jt",
~\I' ';.l
; ,,;' _' i,
':. _~- -f'ft "\1 JJ
" ", -
,. ,. _ f
t\ \J~; J;
, '.,
':},1' --!~-
"
rt':'" v'
-.~, .1,. t_. 1
,Jt," ~- .\ ,;', '1~
,:;.-\~>>_! ;
{~-- ,: "-:'~HiY
',ft. -:'
i'
..t, .
I
;;
<
)"j4~,,,. '
~,i
, y.~
~,
...
,
<,
'-'\'
',,' I
";"
, I
I
'.. ,
!
"
! . ,,'
i& , },
!
, . ~ ,I
= ,',
111 "
I
i,.r,
,,-
'i ~
'=',
'.
"
BUTLBR I;AW FIRM
*' . ..
NtTO."U' AT 1.4"
'!' .\;;;i
, .,..,3,'.::Jt'S
",'.:'fr:~;rf,
t.~; ".,;;.
'.',,'
',j,
:'1' ,
;';1;,., ,.;
',".'~.,'
t>:.-. /".
,.-..,
'-~,'::: -- -
-,,' ~~. '
i
::.~"~
Il ~
'i,
I!', ~
.
...
III
11
-II
Ii.
I:'
a
:'!:
,.
..,
.9
e
...
.~
l
-",
,I';;
,1.'--
'/ -"
,,-
/'
dis~nvcry requests,
5, On Deeemher 17, I l)l)l';, this ('ourt issued an Order upon /)oIcndunltounswer
Pluintinll' interrogatories and producc thc docul1i~nts reqlil'slod hy Plaintifls withinlhirty (30)
duys or suncr the imposition or sunctions, Iklcndunt did not comply with thc ('ourt's Order,
(" On or ahout January 21, Il)l)l),Pluintins Ii led a Ivlotion tllr Sanctions Against
Delenduntlllr ndlllre to comply with thc ('ourt's Order or Decem her 17, 1998,
7, On Fehruary I, IlI91), this Court issucel an Order making the Rule issucd on
Novcmher 19, 1998, ahsolute anel ordering Delcndantto respond to Plainti fill' interrogatorics and
,
request/or prclduction ordocuments within twcnly (20) days or surfer appropriate Sanctions,
8, Dc!endant has lililed to comply with the ('ourt 's Order or Fehruary I, 1999,
9, Plaintirrs' have ('xpended in excess 01'$500,00 in attorney's fees to prosocuto
those proceedings to compel discovery,
\VHEREFORE, ((lr all ortlia /l'rcgoing reasons, Plaintirrs, Donald and Diune Coney,
respectrully request this Honomhle COUl'l to grunt the following relicI';
I) Enter iI default judgment against Defendant, Mary E, EVans, pursuant to Pa,R,C,p,
4019(a)( I)(i) and (vii) and 4011)(c)(3) intlie amonnt or $J,O()l';,45 plus 9%. interest Hum
Decembcr 17, 19'16" ($S9834) less paymcnts orSIOO,(JO Ill!' a total amollnt or $3,S(,(),79; and
2) Ordor Defendant to pay reasonahle attorney's Ices in the amollnt or1iSOO.OO,
rcprescnting the cost to Plaintil'lS orprosecuting this action to ('ompel discovcry; and sllch othor