HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-02805
..
" 1:
CARL SHBRlPF.JR",
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT,OF COMMON PLBASQF '
,CUMBBRLAND COuNTV;PBNNSVLV ANIA
v
'1 ,,1
: " CIVIL ACTION . LAW
,
,
. LILI.iAN SHBRIFF,
,Defendant
, PrlQrJildge: EdSIIf ~~ Ba)'le)'
CONCJLJATION CONFERENCE SUMMARY REPORT
, ,
, ,INACCORDANCE WITH THBCUMBBRLANP COUNTY CIVIL RU\..EOF PROCEDURB
, 1915;~.R(b),tho undersigned Custody C<,molllator submUsthe following reportl
NO, 98.2805 CIVIL
d: IN,CUSTODV
I, TIle pertinent Intb\11\atlon pertaining to tho ohlldren who lU'O the subject of this lIt1sation Is
a., follows: . . " .. ' "", "
H,
Chelsea L.. Sheriff, bom ()otober 6. 1990 and Carl L, Sherlff;lII. bom November 19, 1991,
2..
, ,--
A Conolllatlon Conferonoe wall held 'on Mllfoh 29; 2000 via a telephone.,oonferen<lll call'
, getw~n the CQnolllator, I"ee B, Osterling. Esquire who Isoounsel fQr the Fathet;'lUld the
,,' Mot,l\l/!', LllIIan Sherl~whowas unreprll8ented,' , '," ,
" ' I
Tho faotsof thlsoll8e l\I'e that the pqrtles agreed to the,llnll')',of oustod)' order III April of
1999 wherob)'theMQther had prlmllf)' oustod)'. Mother reslded!n Texas, TheAprll1999
Otderpl'<lvlded ~arFatherhave the ohlldren d\lrlngthe summer and lit otliertlmeson
hoUdll)'s; oto, At,the end of the summer In 1999, the Mother agreed to allow the Father to .
k~oustod)':of the two minor ohlldren ,hero In Penns)'lvanla, Falber hl\$ mllinWned
, oustod)'of the mlnorohlldren Slll<lll that time wllbtho ohUdren going tosohoplhero In
penns)'lvlUlla, Father now petitions, the oourt to hllve the existing order modified, torofleot
" tIiollot\lal' faolUat olrQwnstlUlQOS ofhl~, hllvlns primary ,oustod)', Father Is, wilUng,to provide " '
M9'hlll' with periods of oustod)' during the summer months and lit olber tlmes,oonslstOllt " '
with the prior order. " .. ' "
4, 'Mother,~bJeoted to the enll')' of lUly \}'pe (If order" M~thersU88ested,,8ho ncleded]o got a
, Il\wyerand ",lUlted to fignt this sllUatlon, , However.tlie ourrent sta'eof a~rsis, that the
children are liVing with the Fathor heroin PonnsylvllhllllUld'fOr that rOl\Sol1,the,pOtlQIlIator::
I'OpOmmends an ordOr thl\t wouldretleot Father I\S primlU')' ~ustodllUl whllostylnsMot\l,or"
periods Qf temporlU')' oU$tod)' similar to what was I\fforded to Father uMer thoprlorcolU't
order, However, tlte niilttor should stilI be soheduled for II h~ns'o give tho Mot,l\cir IIli
opportunity to prosenther position to the:Court'illnooslte I~ not I\lFooment,With this tYP,o of
rooo\lUtlendl\tlon, , ,.' ' " ' ,', "
,..".
H, " '
"
iI'
"
. j .
:J:N, TH. OOt1RT 0' OO~ONP~"AI 0' OUN"RLAm'J OOmn'.y I
" , O:J:V:J:L AClT:l:ON M LAW
PINNSYLVAH:r:A
,
ClAlL ,SRIRn" ~." I
Phbt:U~/R..pond.nl: I
I
V. I
I
tiiLJ,I;liA,N IHBRU', I
" J;)etendanl:lPeU UOne~ I
No. peMaeos, 01v11 T'~m
XN,Ot1ITODY
'1I~~TrO,N'98, SPJll~t&L RI~r,r., 1~=~~~r O~II~
Pt7RQUAH~, TO PA. R . 'C? .P,. ,'" "
NOW 'COMIB,XoULXAH SHIRXrr,Deferldant/petitioner, py and
thl;'bU9hher attorneYi Ma~Yann Murp~y, Esquire, of ,Legal servicel!l,
,':Jinc.) and averl!l as, fclJ,ows,
1" pet~t:ioner.:LsLXLLZAH slfJllRX"whO reddes at 1l~0 Indian'
'rl:'a.:Ll Drive, #SB;Harker Hdghts, Taxas I
!,
2,
Relilpondent is dARL SIUI~X",JR. Who rasides at 2120
I,'
.'
clinton', Av~pue, Chambafaburg ,Frarik~in County, Pennsylvania;
, ,
,3, Pet:itionerana ReSpondent arethaparants of two (2) minor
qhi'ldren, nj;\melYI OH.LSI~L. sHIIRZ", bor~ 9otobet' 6, 19'!J0} Jlnq
" "" 1
C~L L. B,..an" ;UX, ,born lIIoVember +!J,a!Jl,
,4.,'T~e partielilli!l3parate~ in., January of l!J!JBand l?et:itio,!:1Elr
to retUl;'ll, h~meto, 'l'exas whareher f~mi~y rerH:de,s,'A Custody
,Pompldnt was filed to det;ermilieaClustod:lalar,rangemen~ forth..
..
"
,
m~nQr ,~hildren, g.tven Pet: i tiQne!:" s plan to relooate,
6, 13y OrdElro~ COUl;'t dat\ld April, 15, i9'9~ ,petitione.r . was
elwat'ded ,phY/ilioal oustodY of the minor ohildren dut'ing the sohool
year, 'with Jteapondent having oustOdyduring the summer and
Ohristmas vaoation, (t\:l,e Apr~l 15.1 ,1999 order il9 attaohed hfiU'.to,
inoorporatl\ld ~y referenol\l hElreit\,' and marked u' lllxhibit I'AII),
"
6. R\!UlpOndljl,t\t had the minor ohildren f,or the las,t: two (~)
.. we$klll of aumm~t' vaoation in 199$,
,
7, The 'minor ohildt'en oame to Pennsylvania . to /ilpend . the
$ummer. of 1'~99 with Rlllapondenti, ,Toward. th~ epd of ,thesummet' I
..
Rl\I/ilPol'l~ent ',told petitioner that the ohildren' wished to rema,in with
"
him. The ohiidrl\ln also expressed a, de$ire to stay witn Respondent,
petitioner and Respondent agreed that the ohildren oouldremain in
p\lnnsylvania.'forthe 1999-2000.sohool year witll the Underetli\ndin9
" .. ...." " ,
that ,tne parties a,nd ohildren would re-evaluate the ou 13\: 0, dial
. .' .' -. . . . ' . .
al;'rangE!l\Ient during the BUmmer of 2000" pdor to theo.ommenoement ,of
".i
the2000-2QO:l., sohool year,
"
,
B ,~n February of 2000, Respondent filed a Petition to Modify
Oust:?dY" requesting that ,.the tElmp~rli\ry oustodial arrangemel\t agreed
I.1pol1bythe, partie~ for, t,he 1999.2000 sohool year beqomePliIrmanel'lt,
";, '
w~,t:ARes",ol1~en~ havingpdfuary qustodyduring th$ soh90~ Y,8o!\ra.l1d
. ,,_ - ..,'.c ..- .
",'" f._,
l?eti't;i(:'lner A~\Ving oustOdY dudnl:l the summer and.Ohr.ililtn\as vao.~Jol'I,
9. A CustodY Cilon,C:iliation ,was held befot'El H'~berf X ,Gilroy,
"
that Olli:l.al:'en ana Youth and Oh:Udli,nehad bllUm dOl1tlldt~d to
i~y.stigat. allef1aUonlioc al;lU$e agdnst th!! ohila!;,!ln bYt,hei\;'
Cather, she said, that Chelsea hadl;leen having pa\licat:tatl~., alla
l;ha,tOal:'~ al:'eW a piot:ul:'e ofhimselfshqoting his fatllel:', deact, Both
, dhi~c1ren to14 Ms, PO\lbl:'lwa that tlley wel:'E1 tet'rifie~ to return' to
tlleir.fathel:', Me I DouJ?raVa sdct that there., WIl", enough in . the
"
Clhil.dren' s disoussions to tlonOnn her/' and thatslle wou~d prefer
, ~hlt.t, an investi~Hltion be completed before the ohi.ldreJ:l. retul:'n to, .
~ell!~.(mdent ,'l'\lthough she understood that there walll a Court Order
c1ireot;tlig/iletit::ioner, to rill turn the ohilc1li"en to Relllpondent' by August,
~3rd,IWhenalilltec1 by oounllle1 for Petitioner why the ohilc1t'Eln l:'IlIPbtted
'coptentment with their father in June and fear of him in AU~Ullltl
"', ,,'- i;:"
i,
, ,
M!i! I DOU!;l:rava explained that the ohildren / s' exp1,anations IlIatidied
,-, -. ii' ,
hlilrtl:\atthey were bei.ng 'trut.hful/ the ohildren apparently be~.ieved
,. -;,
tllat ifchey IlIaid anything negative about theiX' father irtJune, he
, ,
it .... - "
, would ,not 1et,them go with theirmothar.
20; Petit;l.onfJr hlld an appointment: this mo~'nin9, 'witr childl:'en
, ,
and You~h in Franklin CoUnty, pUl:'liluant to thill, PhOne oall from' Mill,
DO\lbrava,
.~:J" pliit'itioner completely understllnds tllat sll" must oblilY tile
'I, I,
"
,. o\,lrrent Orcler<:\il'eot:lli9 her to. t'etu.l:'n the ohltarsn to RelllPon<;l~mt
tC)day I,,'however, Pl;ltitiC)ner is ex~t'elllely oonoernl;lcf for tlle",safety
..
we;j.l'..bf:ling of the ohildl:"en if ti'\ey f':c'e rel;ut'ned bllfptl!!,the'
"
I ,~
inv,"il\:;~9~t;i~m is G:ompletecl" Ji1et;ib.:Lonel:' is pel:'sondlyaWare of tile
"
~n\J"~ anclr~ge t:hat, Respondent panpr9jeClt, a11:1l049h Iilhlll nlllvet'
t:1l0H91lt llewould" hll.Ve directed \:l1is angl!ll:' and rage towards t:hdr
ohi~dr.,n, \iow thl!\t; the children have shared with petitioner end
j ;.
douns'elors som$ of the incidents whiohQClcurrE!d while t11eywere
, '
wit:h~heir !lather, Ji1e,titioner is evel1more nearful t:hat: Respcmc;tent;
wUl...reteHat:1l agdnst the Clhildl:'en if t:hey are returned to him'
befOre the,oompletion of the invest:igetion.
.22. ,Petitioner and the children, alongw~th one of her ten,
(10) ye"t ,old dauglltl;!r, are currently staying at;:.the Shelter in
Ol!.l:'lilille. petitioner cloes nqt have the funds to i:ltay at a motel,
" ,. '
l\\ndthe Shel\:er graoiously aljJreed to'let her IItay there. However,
petitiol'ler,is' un'abletostaylong,lilr than Fric\ay, AugUst 25'1\ at ~he'
Shelter ana her ten year old, c:l/ilughter must r,.,tUrnto school in
Tl!IxasonMondl:\Y' In actdit;l:ol'l, pet:it~one'i' ,has a twelve (12) y~al;'Cl~d
dau9hteJ:' w11o: is staying with ,friends/family in Texas while
, '
Ji1etit:Loneli!e in penneYlvan:l.a. petitioner must aleo ~!'ltl.1rnto:her~
"
2~, Ji1\iltitibner requeete tnat this Court pel:'mit her t:o,tal~e ,the
,. " I ..... -." ,
subjeot minor children back tQ TexaB ,Yiit:hher and llInrop. ,them in
sClhool"eVen "temPorarily/so thattl~ey do not fall behind in t:hd~
ea4catibh, utlt:l.l a thor(:)ugh ,investigatiQl'l oft:heallElg.ti.on~
againstRespon~ent Clan bEl\,omplet'ea, .. ~ebi tioner fullY.Un<:tlilrlilt"nQ$.
t:hlt ,,!he must make, hElreel f and the subj ect mi,nor ohilaren available
"
, " \(,' S
-~:
/
. P8YCHIATJUt., .'S\'CHOLOGICAL
, and
'nI1IRAPIl1mc SBRVlCII8, PC
, ,
c
,
La~ L. von Raao,'M!) .
'Marc:)i H; Ullnn.r, 'MS . ','"
LIl""r Drlqe, MSW '
1:1tbr. A. Collbrav., MS
Nanoy,W. ,Bl\wekMS
~ l'11"'PClHi~'
;.1~ M.IWt, MA
Lynn c:1.,~, MIld.
.1WA.~,MS. .
CrntNa SI'~r"Ms ,
,Rt~,wu.on,RN,USN
'IMI.... Wrlsht, MB
Junl 30, 2000
':
, ,
'I.
...T...........................
,
" ,
;"IIP,"IlIFUI\9'I ACllornlY
, ,.20:' "noH"t Illr.."
'H.qll.n.liCl.q~9', f^'l.7OllO,.,
(n~)7'0~O.'O ,
" .. - .... l ~
0,; _I
DeAr 1111' ,
.
, "
P'~'you/:\r'q\oI'l!llanc;l 1.'1#'&'&'~J., P1I~/It..oa"pt: t:/l;1! .-.rY,ot "
j.n#q_~~qll,; oblllj.n.c;l IIrqlll 111\ appqj.l\Q\l!nton 6"7"00 Wll.llll yow:oUtnu, , '
,QI/:l 'h,.#tt,/:" anl;lllh O/l4.1drtn,.C/llhU(QOIl 10"6~90), "nc:lc'rl Jt.
(()08~~..u~n). r l1!.t:, J.nQJ.V1:a1lldJ.Y'WJ.tll llll, oll:LJ.drt~ p;~or to th.j.,&,
;"por~'dc:l.p.ru\l:' Ill! It:.YWll.t:II'th.j.'&,IIl011Il,,&, 'tor t:1I. .~er 'J.n TIlllI.
. PI/: ,,1111, qlu:r.ntlllll.tg,:!y' 'flr.nq'm.nt., OIi..1;I..> aneleU'.:. Jr. "'"r. '.,y to. ,
..t:ablL.1I r.ppo&'~ wJ.th ana pre'entlc:l'.. pl....nt, ooo~lr.t:1v., .na
I IPOI\ClI)IOU" throuqllout: my J.nt:er.otll.on. w1th thllDl. "
". - "'-'...,. -.' .... -.. -'
OIlIJ.lle,lnl;icllrJ. wer',.bll to ....rb.1J.z., _n ,\lI\c:lll.'It.n\l1nq to 111. 011 thl
oUl:r.n~ ~,~Oijy aq/:"l1Ilnt: (.li...tll.t:tlltY't.Y'WJ.t:h:_tll.r .ncl,.t.p
,/lIO~l\.r ,Ion P~QW::!.nq.llhl .0/lpQ>l, ytar'.'ncl Wi,tll t:hl.l.I1Il1OIl/l.r;n Tl( c:lUt.l.l\q, I
th'.I.\lIIlqI.I1I.nc:lbOtl1.tIP~t!;ld th.u th.y,w'l\ll ~!:.l.mat'l ~.toely,t:~ ,tllQA.l.1\
,\f.i.1lhllhl.l.r 'l1:h,r. ,PCI.~ti.liV. tl~'Uqn*h.l.p. w,r. e1l1,I:::!..bld blUW"p t,h.m
incL~h"~,,. 1I11:h,1I1 AAeI"IlIllP"lQOt/lll.'. ThlY IPP"'" ,toh''I'1 '.c:ljU!ltl~''''.J.1'to
thtj.; ll'w, .qhQ01.~d ;QOllllllun!\lV I' .vJ.c:llno~a ~y ;I~O". ot IIroillnc:ll! '~h'Y'
n!!o'VI~4' 'l\c:I'c,;,!.vhb, tih,y II\~QY. Ch.leea '~PI.'....c:I, .' pn,t+oul~t
c:l1;'4.tlt:q"n_VI'oonIl1nuleI Q~\'l..~.t:"noy 4.nhllI1Aj..lle by. '1:'Y.l.~q .t ,1.l:hll1'.
' 110"'....1\# ,..vq4.QJ.~q "11I0'1.1."q llI1ound.,'"
,-.: .. .... -. ,. ..' ,"'" . '.' - I ,." ~,
''l'h.n~',~ou.(#oi'' tll#lIrr1nOllh... dIUqht:~ul and .rt:.liO\llllll, qh.i.lclzolln to'ml.
r ~~;"'Ic:lUO \lJ,:\t1r ,t,thl; ind,to t:hlll\ thM: : ,allnbl .vl4.J.IbJ.;'lIq". .
1l~'/:lplllt:4.0 i\lPpOI1t ,4.nith' "\.It",t. U 4,'.I.;lc:I. " D+'10toll .l..,e1It.l.n.l.,t:1I1:.tln
,IlIlO~.I.~hl~1:i'.n4~tll.on, ~o; ohUclzo,n,lnc:l'OIov.n bot:/! o/lJ.'.l.cIp'n(':
~,.",pon!l..l.~'A.",tl,l!jQy 4.ntlll'o\l4.on '1'1:1.1;11. .Illl~,. Ill\aYllolLl.c:lbllllt#.l.ut;Qm
..~"r4.n~i' I\IU1:/:ll pJ,.q.,to <lUeu.. tlhlj.ttIlQ\lOhti., Inc\t"H-nr;I,.U't
o.npr?V.i.<llt1i;llhlt'\Mj)~u~on OI1,p. ,0,11 leleI!t:4.onlJ.~l!d'll.n~. j;p ,'!lY
'w.y'pJ.I.... ~o nq'l; hll~,t:lUI to lloM'ot: 1111. " ,
"
.
.r i$~~j~h.'\~~."j~
' DtbtlDPUbt.VI, HS ",
P'ycllOthl;IIP4..t: .
,
, ~,
'",",
;, ,
Iii
..
~XH~&X~. "II b(i
323!Sl'forth 1'hlrdSb'eet · 'Jiarrisburg, PA 17110
181. 717.2,U.3839 Pa)( 717.234-6247
.~ .1
, ,
\ . ' ,
. PIlCl.ld. 2So176~6~
, ,
....
"
" ,,'
" H
'; .
6, Prior 10 Ihelr dOPllrture, llnd by ltsroomonl of oounsol. 11)0 ohUdron,hud mill with a
,. . ',,' " ".. ',. .
Dobra A, DO\lbrnva, MSfa Psyoholhoraplsl with Now Passa~os,Psyoho'0810allln~
Thor~poiltlll Sorvloos, ,
7. Thopurposoof Iho oounsol'ins so.slon was 10 allay oonoorns thai dofuhdanl/molher
" would prompl Iho ohlldron 10 make, nOSlltlvo allogallons aboullho pllllntlffl fulhClr
d~,r1ns her periods of oUslody, aa. Ihls had been a ptlorpallem of conduol,
'. - ,
FurtMmlore, Ihe parties, by IInd. Ihroush oounsel hadagreod Ihlll thooollnsolln8
ae8alo~ W~UI<l be dlreoted towllrda ostllbllshl~S thai Iho ohlldron wore thl'lvins
. physloally and emotionally I" the oualody of tho II' futher,
8, ThO parties further aareed that addlllolllil sesslo~8 mlahl be neoessal')' 10 asstsl thl/
. 'oourt In determining the,lIpproprlale oualodlal Ilrrllngemenlal time \lflrlal.
9, A repor! waaprepared whloh Indloaleslhal the ohlldren wer~ "plollsan!;','
"oooperatlvO," IInd sl1onlaneous thro~ghoulthe Inlervlew with the psych\lllleraplsl,
The report" further Indloalea that Ihe children had adjusted well to Ihelr sohool"
oommulllty IInd surroulldlng8, an,d dea/red to, remain wllh,lhelr fulher as primary
ouslodlan, A lrue and oorreot oopy of Ms, DoubrilVa'a rep\lli la alll1ohedherelo as
Exhibit "B,"
'_;"'" . ", ..' . . . .', ',' ", ;' i_c, !', '
'10. On or aboul J\lly 20, 2000, plaintiff rooelwd a oa\l f\'Qm the dofelldanllh whloh
defendant Indloated th~1 Ihe chl,ldren desired IPspeak to plaintiff while defendant ,
rem~llled on the. phone, Upon be!ng prompled by defend ani tne llhlldren tearfully
e~pressed II desire to remain with their molhedn T\lxas,
It, Plaintiff lPather belle,ves lIIld thilrefore ~yers thllt defcllldllnt hRS P.rompled the subJeot, ,
.- .' .: ' . " . '. . "
slatements f\'Qm the ohlldren llnd oreated anatmospllore of Intimidation towards the
,-" j ". ,', ',',,",.'
ohlldrel1lii order to gain, a more advantllgeous position hI the pending QustQdy
litigation, , '
. '" I" . I. I
. 12. ~)all\tlff I Father belIeves and therefore avers that ,~Inoe JulY 20, 2000,\ defendant has
\ ",; .- ,
sou8ht to tsoll\~e tho ohlldren ",om any lelephone contllot belweonthe. ohl1dto~ll"d
plalnllff In order 10' galll, " morel1dvantl\scousposltlonln the .~endll1g oustody
litigation"
I
"
,I',
"
" ,
" "
"
)3, Pltll,nllff bellevllH and thorefore avers Ihl1l .hortlyaftol' tho roturn ,of the ohlldren .to .
Texa~l! dofendl1ntlmothor unllaterplly and'slll1'eplltlously took the ohlldren to II
dlfforent counselor and llnaased II1e1r services, ..
, 14, Plaintiff belloves .and theretbre avers that, dofendantl mothlir Intends 10 present. the
. " I,
testlmony ~fthls oxperl at trllll, .
I L' .' :'. .' . ~ ". , . . .' ,
1$: Plalntlff bell\lvee Ilnd therofore avers thallho courl will beneflt from having a more
thorouah ovltluatlon porformed by, the payllhotheraplst Inlthllly, asroed upon by the
'partlos. .. Accordhigly, plaintiff hils flied II motion to oonduct a oustody evaluation "
.' shn~ltaneously with lhls potltion,' , " .
, 16, Plalntlff,bellevesand thorotbre avers that the sudden ohango In the ohlldren ~nd' the.
.' . oonduol of de fondant In surreptitiously seoklng the Intervention ofoounsoUn~ sorvlces
, . 0 '. . , ~ I , .' . '-" , ;
lII1d denying tho children aocoss to tholr father neoessltlltes a more thoroUgh
ovaluatlon and t~e relum of tho ohlldren to phlfntlff during the, pendency of said
ovaluatlon,
'" ,'- ,,- , ,
17, PIII!ntlff believes and therefore avers thllt Iho current trllll date of Ausust\~,'2000, '
wlll not allow suffiolent time for .unlQre thorough evaluation IInd thllt It wlll. be. "
nlloessary to continue tile heartn8 unlllthe oompletlon of s~ld eVlllUlltlonl
18, Plaintiff believes and theretbre avers that defehdant' wui not be harmed by a
,.".f' .... ".... _.... ; _ '_, ....,
.'. coiltlnu~l1oe In tllltt the ohlldren lire scheduled to return to tiithor on AuStiS\.231il, liS por
,. -. "" - , '" "
Ihe most reoont Order of Court, ' , ,
19, wliitfl the hearing hIlS been c9ntlnued once at tile request of de fondant' II oounsol, ~hls
Is'plalnllfrs first r~queat fur II oontlnuance,relatlveto Illls custody prooeedlng, '
20, Plalll'tlff'~, attorney has sousht the oo~sent f\'Qm !>pposlng oounsel, MlIl)'ann'Muq,hy".
'BH,qulre 'but reoelvednelth~r a oonbent n~r II refusal' to oontlnue Ihe Il'\~tter,: .. " '
FUrthermore, plaintiff's Oounsel hue provided defendant's oounsel with a oopy otthle
. motion prior 10 It's presentlltlon to Ihe oourt. ' . , ",', .' ."
2 \, For the' a,foromentloned reasons oounsel fur plaintiff rllquosls thlll thle H(illor,~bl" ' ,
"'. '.. , . '. . .' . ',. . .":',' ..,:_.".; .,':.--.'1.;,,:,.::-':--:'-'..,.--.-
CQurtgram a oontlnuance andresohedule theo~stody Heaiin~ sohoduloa fur AUa"8l
16, 2000 at I :30p,rn, to an IIltematlve day and time, ' " h;,.
,. -,. i'. " - ." _ "
,', ',' ,
,,"
--',1}"';;;
,,'-
- - --:"..,,"
" 'j
I;
" ", ~,,- t
'" V
""
",,
"
; ~
CAA~' St-UlIUf/f/,"JR, I'
" ''', Plaintiff
IN THE COURT 9~COMMON
PLHASOF CtJMBBRl,AND
COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
" Vs,
1,Jt,;I.IAN SHBRIFF,
' Detbildant
"
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NO, Q8-c'J8ofS' CIYIL ~'
~Swu: "
day of Ha'l , ,1998,Upon
ANPNOW, this , d.)?
oon'lder4ltl~n Qfthe attaohed oomplijlnt"itlslloreby dfr~ol!ld*at tho partlesftnd their rosp~Qtlve ' '
OQllnsolll#peatbetbro ~\"f)', Gilr O1EsqUlre, the oonolliator,at ~e L.l ,\1'\ P\ ' C~(tt)Ct.
, " '~ C\lVlb!r\(J"'i~ CO, C~O/lnsYlvanla,'on ,the&\'S"dftYOf "
" . 1", "
, ,~\j~r\'~ I 1998, at ~ \ ~O O'olook,., ,Ill, fur ftPre.Heanng Custody Conference, '
At '\loh oon.terenoe. an ~tlbrt will be mllde tl? resolve the Issues In dlsp(!te; or Ifthls'Qanliotbe
;, p
~O,obl'npll.hed, todellne IInd narrow the Issues, to be heard by the oourt, lInd to onter,lnto II ,
'tomporaryQrdor, Elth~\ ~~rty may bring the child who lst,he subject ofthlscustl?dy lI~ilonto the
' , ,
conterenco, 'but the ohlld's attendanoe IS,notmandatory, FlIllure to IIppear at Ihe confer~noemllY
,
provide ~round8 fi?r entry of a tempo\ary or permnn\lnt order,
f'- "
.'
FOR THE COURT"
BY--~\~Y'~L~T6vt. ,'", , ,.
Custody,cc>nolllator 'J~.) ,'~tr'"",
'yOOSHOULDTAKJfTHIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYBRAT ONCE, IFYOt) DONQr
aAV;EAMW\'ER OR CANNOT Af'FORD ONE, 001'0 OR TELBPfJONE THE OFFlCB
SB1"FORTRBELOW, TO FIND OOTWHERB YOU CAN qET ~EOAL$Llt ,."
. ,
OFFICE,OF TtiE COURT ADMINISTATOR
"CUMnERLANnCOUNTY COURTtlOUSE, '4TH FLOOR,
',,' C~rSLB, PA,17013
(717) 240.(j~OO
"
"
i=
,
,
"II. q
, ,"
"
Ii, 'TilOrd lIIV' two (2lmlnor oltljdrOil banI of tho IlUlrrlllllo, Chol.OlI Shoriff', (7 YOlIrs), and Carl
~1\orltl',III, (6 yonr.), "
7,potiUclIlor hn.tlIodll Complnlnlln CU~I6dy hlvo~lnsllto Jurl.dlollon of tho Coi\1monw\llIIUlof
''-, j
"
Ponnsylvnnlllllnd tho vOllU9, of Cumborhllld County IllllOOOtdllUOII wllh tho requlrolllonls of Ule' ,
t)nllqnn Child CUSlodY Jurlsdlollon AQIlInd PiI, R;C,P" 19IM(II)(I)(!Illllld (1l)(f1),
! ,8, Onlho 2311I day uf July, IY9K lI11lntorhll ordorwlls on,ored by Hub9rIX, 011 roy, I3squlro, 11'0
06nol\llllor alv1ns,tomporllry ouslOllY of tho ohlldron to IlIUler,
9, 81noo tll(i,.opnrllllOllofthc pnrtleson onbolll Jnnllnry 4, 1998, resl!ondonthll. movod 10 al
104181 (3)soPllt~lo,rOllld\lnOlla and POlltlonllr bollevOS,'lUid IhoreforelllorsUlllt sho inlon~~ to
, , . . - . . . .
relOOQto 1I fourth limo,
"
10, BlnoO ,UIO sopa'rllllon of tho Partlos on or IIbout 'JnilulIry 4, 1998, l'OIlpondonl hils ohtwo '
oocaslon9 rentovedtho children trolll sohool,
,11. 81noo !lIO sopnrllllollof tho pllrtlos 011 or llboul Jl\,IlUlIry 4;1998, rospc,lIdonthas ongllSo<I 11111'
"" ,. ,
.. ,,/I ,
'oburso ofconduotdosJsned to frus,lrllto potltloner's 'rlihl8 10 oustedy of his ohlldroll' by d0l1Yl118
d' .. .' -,- J
,,' I"
hlnl physical, wrltton and telophonlo IICOllas on nUlltorous ooOll8lol1s, Pl1tltlonortU\1horbollevOll
"
thnt respondent has 1lI1111010usly lIIld vexlItlously I\ttempted 10 allenllto tho uffwllona of tho
j' " - ,f" - _ ~ ;_
ohlldren as to pelllloner. ' "
" .' _, _ ' __ - '. _ _ _' - .': __ _" .'._ _ _1
\2,':On or IIbout OlIrly MlIy 1998, rospondonl removed tho ohlldren from tho Commonwolilth of
" ,- ,- - -, j ~
, ,Peansylvllnla, wllhoul petltlonor's ~nowlo<lso or odnsonl, to tlU<O up r~slde,nco In the ,BllllO of
" TOll~,::,Furthorrnol'\l, the'only IIQ!lc6' pOllllol1orrooOlved wils 1I10,ltor citlllsllllildd~s8,and a
: p.- '. ",. .- "--.- ,-
phone mllllbor lit whloh potitlollor wllllllnllblo 10 cOntaot respondent, II truo lIIld correot copy of
wl)lch Is lIttnohod horoto, mllrkod iI>> ~lililbll "A"lilld Incorporated'by I'cferonco t1terelo,'
,13. ,Since Iho lII)poratloll oft\to'pllrtIOllolon or'abOllIJlIUun..r4, 1998, rospolldolll has colulbltod wllh
, Indlvldllllls who poso a subsiMtllll throat to tho phy.loal, omotlonallll\d mentlll wol1 bol118 of
" ,; ." - , -
',tho ohlldrol1lU1d III 1I110000t 0110 Ihslllllco were allbjool to IIn InvOIltl811tlon bY Child Protoetlve
"
"
j ~ j 0
'L,
"
"
I,
'-'oj,
, j'
'j,
"
H,
"
"
" , \, ~' ~ ~
"', g~ n1~
~fl]'
I ;M
en II;; Jr .~
~~o '''1,;)'' 'J;
:_'t,: "( )
~S '",
rH t~
41'
~ ~" ,~
.I,:)
;!
1"
l>
\'
.
"
'-:' j'
I' "
.'
,~ , , r"'.
"
, isr . .
"
j, ,- ,if
,; ,
. "
, ;{
t3 f(' . I"
~' "
'j,
"
, ,- ~
I
~.
...
"
,~ I'
.,
,
If ,
......
I'
'0_,
",
1"-'
. - 1 ~
,E'xt1s'i rC.
.
',.1
, ,', \(,1 S
~.
PSYCHIATRIC, PSYCHOLOGICAL
and .
THBRAPBtJTJC SlIRVICBS, PC
,
LlIw~nc. L, ,Von Rlso,'MD
Marcy H, BI'tMer,'MB
LUlher Bne., MBW
"DebrA A,Poubrava, MB
Niiney WdllNtl,'MS
.' Mary llU1. POll, MaW
1,..le. M. Harl,:MA
,.Lynn ct, Loomll, MUd,
111I A, M....haU, MS '
Cynthla al.uHlIr, MS" ,
Rebll1ca Wllaon, RN, DSN .
ram.r. wnshl, MB ,.
J'l.In, 30, 2000
':
..........."Y................:.... ," I
r....R..~.I1lJ.nq, /lCllo:nlY
'20 S HUklt SIl:..ll
,', HIQh."iotAUl:'IJ, PA' 1708&,
(717)790"0490
"
I:IIU lilt.
'" ~
'11: YQUI:',Clfl1.\tlC ana ~.hnal, pl..... '4coefJti ~hia l\llllIUry 0: ,
Lntdl:l1llUon t obULnl~ ::om "1 IfJpoLntmlnc on a..7"00 ,whll you I: cJ:J.,nc,
,CallJ.8hldU 1/:., Indllh ohlldtln,Ohelll.. (00,10"6"90) Ind 011;'1 Jt:.
(bOB U"U..91). % ml~ LndLv1:G\uIUy:whh elle chUd:ln pdot: eo chtL:
" ll',po/i'cICl dlp.rcuneo .c.y w.1,th che.1.': mothu tot uh. '\,UM\tt Ln, 'I'ixII
pet'" uhl CUl:'nne :lunodl' .tl:"liqemenc .chlJ.eu'endCu~ .:IT:, WIllllIUy 1:0
ull.b1hh r,ppoll': w.1.bh Ind pt:uln~ea II plll..lnc" ooopu.~Lve,end .'
I ',ponc'nlou, thtouqhouc my Ln.1;lI:eoUori. wL ch ch~m. " . ,.
" ,;,
eli.iuland C.t1 '~eJ:'1 11>1'1 co verb.1hlan ,unaeli,canellnq co me ot thl
.' ourl:lnc 'QU'.1l0dy ';rltmenc, (L." Chat thlY ,1:.\1' wLth ~"llhn' ana .hp"
"l\lothlr Ln ~A au:inq thl .01'100\1 Ylllt'end lolL th ehe1J:',~othlr .1,n 'I'll dUtLnq
chi .Ul1Ill\Il:I 'and boch liepotuea,ehec eh\ly, want: pl:LrnerYQUa't:od,y to remeLn
.' ,w+ch thlL: tachlJ:', ,Pfll1tLvI:el.~t:1onlhLp,wll:ed"ol::,l)la bltw"n th'n'
.nat~,LII hcll'lI and '1lep"mothll:, They appur to, hen ad~ul1lla' Will tp
~hl1rnew .ohoo1.lnd QOlMlunity U IV,Lalnoea by ,npolluO,# tll~en~. thlY .
hllv, , m.!:!e ena ,Ot:. VLthl, thlY enj 01'. Che18..ellprund a puti.oular ,
<l,~'Ll:'I to have \ oonc~nula oondltenay in her l1te by .uyinlJ"lt hehIr' e
'1'101.1" arlQ eVoicUnq "l!\ovil\\1' lI:ound."" '
. "
"
. - - ,. I, !',;':
. Thank you !or uturLnq ,th..I' del1ql:lttu1 ana utLClu1ac.' ohUelnn to. ml,
r 'Kpn"'d to thlh tuhu and to th.m thet 1 oan b, evdlab1,' tor
,llhuaplutLq ,11.11'1'01:1: in ehe tuturl itelldud, Divorcl La, dltin1tlly an
.moUoh.1 ,trandtLon, to;, ohUar.n ana qivln ,both ohilCt.n" ;,
lI..pon..1,vtnt.. co my Lntcu:aolli'on w.l.th them, th.y oou1d bln,tit trom
"h'IVLn\1' II ,0.utn1 pliol to ,eli.ou.. IIhl1l:"thOl.lqhc., and t"t.!.n;.. ,,:1t,1',
oan prpvLell tUtthu', Lnfol:l1\,t:ion 011 b. o,t aaelLUonala...l.tcanoa in any
way pl.... do"noe h..~t:attlto contaot m.., ' ," , .
SLnol:'~' "
" Vl-v:\o- ~h.V"~:(\"'>S
,. , Dlbta DoUbrava, HS ' ,
P~YOh~ch.:aphc
mXHIB:t'1' "B"
, "'.,
,3235 North Third SlTeet . 'HamsDl.I1's,PA17110
TeI,717..234-3839 "FftlC717.234-6247
"
, ! '.'
Ped, ld. 28-1767862 "
" ,-
.-"
, ,
, ,
"