Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-02938 ~, ~\\ " ~ it "~j J " " " " " " I' ;. ,. " j, 'i 1.1 I' ~ II: .~ .. "- il i:, ~',' ., n' i' " "I' I,"~ ;,",', " ., I, " ~., " " ". c.l ~, ~. ~ I' " " Ii " iI" " I'" 'i," ,. Ii "" L'; .." ,:' " " " -.. "~' ~ '.. ~ \'.J " " " ,. ,1-' , ,I' .1 I, " " , " , " ii' " " t ,i ;it if' #'~~' " - ,- ',' ~ ' ',' ' , , " " Ji !i !I, I'", " " OJ " 'J ,. " lJ " " " ,;' f \. " pl ...... . . ,~ -. ~ 0- IV) ~ Ii ~ Q- " 0, j' H " Of' Ii <t, " " ,." , 'i d' " " '" I'" " .' ,I ;1 I'!',' " I ,i Ii, (,',1 .. ""FlY ',: n '& !D' " " :1') ". " ( """" Ch( " (~':, I " ~ :.., I " J r:; ) ~ , 'J; , ~NCl, I r;.1 I,'., ~ " l(f ~ ;1, " ,,' il"/ J I :.IIJ~ "Q5 ~ @ , ,r" l:!l ,I (~ " " " " " ("''', ' .'I.Irii ii,/ 1'.1,1.': I, " " rli ./.," " ".l' I, " .' , " ,,' Ii " ie' I;, ;i " " ;; r. 'i " OIWlrl'^" 'I'OWlmH, INP, OfWH'I' fW POMMON I'I,IW.l (J\JMIIICm,I\NI) C(WN'I'Y, 1'1\ I'lnlnlln' , NO, (l~ ..' ,.)(f. 3 [1 Ci~~1 v, :1 i\Mlnmcl\N COMMllNfOt\'I'JON/:l 'CONI"I'IUJQ'flON, INC, ' Ollfllllllnnl CIVil, I\c"'lON . 1,1\ W ,lIJRY 'I'JUi\'!, OICMI\NPlm NO'I'IOH TO DEFEND , Yon hnvo \lellll slIellln com!. If YOII wish IUllllfelld !\~IIII1SIIl\llpllllms sel fmlh Inlhe followhlll, pllj!eS, YOII nlllslllIko IIPllolI, wllhln IWelllY GW) dnysllflel' lhls Ilompllllnlimtl llnllllC 111'0 sllrvell, ,\ly clllorlng II wrltlen IIppOllrllnllll porsollnlly Ill' \lY'lIl1orlley IIml filing In writing with Ihellllllrl )'0111' dctonscs 01' Il\ljllcllon~ to Ihp clnlll1s scl fnrlh ngnlnsl " von, YOllnrll wnrlletl \llllllf YOII fnlllo tip SP Iho ellsc nlllY procClll1 wllho\1l YOII nmlll , jllllgmclll mny \lc 1l1\1lll'lld ngnlnsl >,011 \lY tho CP\I1'I wllholll f\l1'IIICI' notice flll' nil>, munoy , plnhl1ellln Iho complnl\1l or for nllY olhcr chllln or l'ellol' roqllosled h)' Ihe pllllllllfl'. YPII 1\111)' 10811 mlllley PI' pmpllrty UI' olhe\' l'lghlllllllporlllm 10 YPII, ' . ' YOU SHOUW TAKE 'rills PAPER TO YOlJR LAWYER Nt' ONCE, IF YOU PO NOT HA vn 1\ LA WYBR OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, 00 TO OR TELEPHONE 1'HE OFFICJ.'l SET FOR'I'II unLOW TO FIND ,oUT WHERE YOU CAN OET I.,EOA1., HEI"P, ,,, Cllmborlnnd COllnty Unr A8solllnllol1 2 LlherlyAvonuo Onrll811l, M 17013 717-249-31 GG ~~~-- Chrlstophllr M, 01000111, Esqnlro .. I,D, No, 19331 , Murk D, OrntlslHIW, Esqulro I,D, No,G1975 213 Mllrkol Slreet 1',0, Box 12411 HlIrrlshlll'g PA 171011,12411 .....hF.-,.<..."',,,.......~.,,,,."".__,., T-H~ . '1/6 /~ cl',50 9/I"e {i~J~ .. " , . " ital ' ~a~ '" 'r_.. 10.., ere ~WII, II II ~RPNN~Mf'iN PIRP~P , M"OHf\NIQ!i~I,JR~, PA \7Pij!l , PliONP717oQ1I7,\l"l\P , '" .: !'AX 71H\l7'\I1Cl1 I\ClO~ ~WI\~~M~NT Q~ PP~N INVgTr.ro~ 1\1'1 or. ~~~a~"~a II , , tWQ]' "OB Jtl.tlatJUU' " .' ~mw. wv DATm ~NV 1\tU: 0'1' JOB. ~, 10H/ll.\ 'Ie7 1\4..U,,1)7 $ ~00 1I~1'l11 1 ;3f1:i! ' f,UtA Uf.l7 m"4m 7\l1l ~4"1\H:I'l $ )" ~00 (~fll) 13P4 l3~te ~:a41 II m"um 131~ 05"14"9'/ ~, 1\00 ;1.1104 f'lH1f1 flU~/).,en(.'l11 fil:, 1~(fl..710~ !3Z9 0!1"\Hl"~7 I'J 400 (~~ll '4il~ s~t~ 1I1!?,~/~1t;\13Il Qljd~ 10N0/l7 '30~ 10"17"P7 $ ~,0Cj)~ Ullll PP\.IljIll!\PI1VU e , ~/M0m ~0~ 10"1!~"l'l7 Q ~150\il 11l'/~ I3tte~lall MIt~mIH't ~/N!IlI1G, ~U 10..~1)"~7 Dl0,n00 '1\'1~ f3~lle ua~ MI!I~ml'lr\: ' 0/a2"2G 91" 10..n"1J7 $1\1,000 l.'475 RAmPey, ';l'N ,1/04 I'l~p 11"0'/,..9'1 B ,1,4ell 11175 Ramlil~Y, TN J{ll"U07 ~33 " ~01"~1"\l~ $lfl,1\1\1\ 148i? /\t~\lnll,Q1\ ,1/11"nm au ~01~\'l1' Pll F,I'3,ql00 14a~ I\t, anll, 0/\ 1/'''lW7 93li ~\11 ,. 01 ,,\le 0 1l,j1.I\Ql 111a? M\1I~nEl, Q1\ " TOT1\~ ~7e,7Bl '~otuallY blllu~ last w~ek ~n November lP9'1, \I I' ,. ," " 'I, ,. .. f_;: "") II', ... 1 l'!~ , " , , , .... 'i I' i;' ll)j, I' I"'t ,:." ({It., (tJ I. ! " e f': .\1: .1'.'1 I, " :/;' "i-I.' ~;j 1;.1 I'.i. V\ C' ,) " \t) " ;" " " " Ii .' " " " ,,' " " " '\". " ) ~~ ~~ ~ ~~ \ ~~' .~ ~\0 .~ " " " " ' '\ " ~.~ 1\ '~ '~I ~. ~~ ,~' " , !ill " 'i ,. 1\ il j' " .(, "ii' .. ,. " I'. i' " ;1, " ., ," ii' ,t. .. " ,. Ii 'I. II .' ,. i\ ,P " "L ~, MJOI, nllw Plpnr Cpll1l11lllllQnlllllls IIIhnllH \Ill' nllplllI\lllllH \llllllnhw!111l pnrnllml1h,~ pflhl' ,'G~mnlllllll, 4, Acel, nllw Clllnr Cnl11mmllpn\l(lns, IIIlmllH \1\1.11,.11 lillllll wnrkllllll'llll1\1onHhll1wllh Cnplllll 'l'PWI'l'R hplllnlllnlllll Pf IIhmn April nf 1997 IIml PPlllhl\,llllllhn;\I~h Jmllllll')' Ilf't99R, Hnwpvur, I . , , Ppfpllllnlll IIpnlplllhp romnlnlnllllll\llln\lollH oonllllllPl1 tn plII'nlll'llph 4 of Iho Complnhll, ~, Ii , " Acel, now ClplIr CPI1111llllllollllonR, !lonloR Ihe nllplln\lonH pOlllnlnell In pnmlll'llph S pfthp cOllllllnllll,Illl\lrlhpr rospollSO 10 Rnl4 pllrnllrnph, Dofenllnnl RhowR 1l1ll1 Cnpllllt Tpwers plli'lbrnwcl work In Ihll SIllIeR pfQoorllln nnd 'l'onn~Raoo,lla ovlclonoo!1 br Uxhlbll"A" 10 Ihe Con;,lllll"l, " 6, ACCI, now CionI' COnllllllnlpn\lpna, ndnlllall1ll1 frOIl1 111110 10 limo II hila h~'d workhl11 Ii' rolnllonahlpa wllh Ihlrd pnrlloa 10 porform work In \1\9 COll1l1lClllwenllh of !,ennRrlvnnllll Howovllr. , , ' Dofondnnl donloR Iho romlllnhlll nllosn\lClnR oonlllh1011In pnl'llllrnph6 oflhe Comph\\nl, ' 7, In roRponRe 10 pllmsmp!1 7 oCthe Complnllll. Acel, 'now Clellr COllllmmlonllona, ndmlla Ihlll , ' IImlllnlllhlcll aOlllo ooil1lllunlonllons with Cnplllll Towors by lolophonll, fml or mnll, prlmnrlly :, dlrootod (0 or reoelved fl'om (ho SllItlll! ofOoorslllllncl Tonnossoe whOI'll tho worK wna portP~lod, ' , .. , Howovor\'Pofondlll1( donlosllll rOI1lIl/nlns 1I11011n\lons oonl\1hlo,I In pnrnarnph 7 aftho Cotupln!l1t, " " " ' " 3 ;." 7117/1-11-97 7~6 /4,..11} "a12 la,,11 a:~~ '7,,6 ~P2 " 0-17 ~OD ,10-23 , ' , ?11/10-24 I' 916 'f'Il0-31 P26"'11-7 93\/1-1-98 ?31, 0-1 93[\ 1-1 O/lI'1'l'f1r. ').'OWE~~ 1n~tullAtionp of mMP Wqs ~lllod At $6PO,00 ~ut phoul~ hAVO 'b~en fol' $30P,OP par proj, Mg~, $200 Wqp ~~~Uote~ f.rom invoioe, I'al' /JOY ( eroctmono poloshoulcl hAve I)eon only $10,300 PUt: WAR lnvo!oed At $11(300,00, $1(000,00 Wqs c1eduotbd from invoioe, $600,00 ,1nypipo never ~eoeived, wor.k Ord,r WAS fal' $16,60P not $19,000 a~ bllLecl, $400 WAn deeluoteel from invoioe par Pl'oj Mgr '$3000,00 paid 1-26-98 ohook '60202, oleAt'eel hank 2,..2-98, $2500,\10 Downtime, Php\.ltoel py, Proj, Mgr, , Original,invctoe of $19,600 inoor~eot( was to be revised And re-submitteclper ~oot~ of CApital Towers per Proj, Mgr" Revisecl ~nvoioe never rooeivecl( rut .in system At $18,600,00 per Prpj, M~r, " $16,000,00 _ insystem for payment' (' ", .~ $4,461,O() in sy~tem fol' payment $19,000,00 - in system f~rpaymont, PAid $7000 6-5-98, Took oredit of $795,00 for work not: performed by Capital 'l'owers, put: oompleted by And paid to o,ooLlins, ' $3000 - Pispul:ed by Pr.bjeot ~19r,.., DPwntimebilleel for 8llnday - $5,20~- Disputed - original never returned to aoo\:9, " ,. 0, r.W, Milnkovip t:hen of.farllel to hr.1V1l cl'p/lr'!3 (101'pO\:II\:(I rllprpfjOl1tll\:!VP pppel\~" tn 1I11~'d!3I)\lrg / i.f OnpHnl \'/O~lhl IJllY hip \:nwul, 1111(1 :\.oclg.\ng olllJenaes t Ml:, lln:\qHhm~ r.af\lflflCl t ' P t In Ugh\: pf l~lfl il1\lJlltlSEl Ovel" tho 10ClIII:ion, of, the pr.ppol>eel deposition, IIl1e1/o1' pvar who !3honlc1 pf\y fol' whoae trllvn1. flnc'l " loclg:\.ng / Clenr r.e!'!peotfnUy rec,InOtltfl 1:I1f\t 1:11e OO\~'t ,i!'!flua fI prPteot,iv~ .areler. !letl:ing looation of 1:118 c1epor4Hol1 to Pe lItl/lntfl, (':J€lor.gia, "I!ld t:l1f1t el\ph 1l~c1e pay j.~1l O\~n ,8lqJenlll'l!'! (.inalndimtl:avel IInc1 1.oc1g:\.ng) ,in oonneotionWi1:l1 the el0pOfl!tion, lI,Hor.nll\d.vely, C:).ellr. r.e13peatfnl'ly reqlleflt13 thnt/ if 1:I1e depo!,!ition i13 to Pe 'hl'!ld' in lIi1rl'!,13put"g I, Penn... 13y1Vllnitl, 1:I1C\t Capi1:al Pe ,reqllired to pc\y Olear' p trC\vel and lodginu em:>enflefl, 10, 1\ny rell\1lt 01:11er 1:I1un 1:Iltlt I:equesteq in' paragraph 9, supr!l, would be unrel\sonably )lUr.c1enaQ1\e 01: Ve>lC\tio\1s fol' Clf1F,U:' , l'ar,tipUlarly, 1\, CleC\l', its dellignee, and, 1111 ofitfl recordfl /11:8, looatl.1d in1\tlanta, Geo~"gia. Heq\.liring it to undergo the time fln~ expense, of. ccwpil:l.ng its records and tranBporting tl1E!l11 to l.>ennBy1.van.ia with I\.corporat:e wit11eBI3 WOUld be unduly btl\:c1flllBQ\l8 and Ulll'el\Bonable ill light of the IlIlPUllt aotuallyleft ill c11l3pute In thb case, whioh ,is an al1P\.Int wh~oh (lOBS not even O)(ceed the' Hmit for cal1(l\.\1.pory arbi-:- trntl.oll in Cumberland County, Il. 'rile cause of aotion nctunlly arose outaic1e of ,. ,', PenllBylvunia, 1\ll. of the COIlElt.rllcUon woL'lt at'lasue W/lS perfo~ in .. :1 .... I' " NOV 2 If W9~) V, IN 'TIlEl cO11m' 01" cq,1lPN rl.f.J\S Of" CUMllluiU.JINP (:OllN'W, I.>ENNflYTNlIN+JI aMI, l\C'l'lPN ... IIlW NQ, 9a"O~93a ' ~rolW '1'\U/U.t PEWlNDI"..o PIW~fl'l\T. ~RS, INC" , I.>ltlintiJ'f I\MliJ\l.lCl\N ~ICl\'rWN~ (XlNI'l'rnI~WN, JNe I , pefpnc1ant OIIDER ' '.I' , 1\1\'0 ,N~, ,thif.l . ~lay c;lf herepy OllDlilRED j~lE1t Defenc1nnt' f.l Motion GMm'jl:l) , , 19pe, ;1.t :\.f.! fm: I.>rqtllotlve orc1er' i!'! , , 1'1 'l11e c'lepo!'!ition of PefendM\l1 a corporAte c'lel3i9l1ee f.l111\11 take ,plf.\ce :l.n llarr:l.f.lPIlrCJ, VennsYlvania, as c1esi):'eq py Vlaintiff, P\lt only " on the follOWing condition I , l'ldntiff i!'! tore,imb\U'f.l6 Pefenc1ant f9V" all t.l:'avel and lodging expensef.l inO\.1rraq for thla c1epof.!it:\.on, witl1in . t,en (10) duya aftor prel3en\:m3nt of a\.1cll p:l.lia to VIAintiff Py' \ pefendant, " 'J. ' " , " '/1' " I' .. " !i :1 " "'1' H' " \j " , " 'I, \1 .,1' " , " 'j, ""I i! '. i, " " " ' j, " .f'" " ('" " P, Ii " II,: c:: 1'11'''1) ,"" "-! I'i (;H f'n,! ~ll) " ,I':i'/:( I;. 1'1.1:: i, ;,! "1""1\" , l' I 'it l\ll lli :lli ,lilll\:I\1' {\\i: p,\ ,,' d,' "I' " " " " " Hi " Ii '1. ..1' . , ,. C!l\l':j:'j'AT, '!~nllS, we I , PlAJntiff , , I IN 'mill CO\!m1 ol~ \.Cl>1<\PN I'I4iJ1\S OF' ., ClJitlllJDRr..ol\l'ID (XJ\!I'm', Pmt1N$Y:TNlIN!1\ , t , I t I V, CIVJL ACTION ~ I..oI\W ~~~I~N ~lM\!NI~~~ON$ CONfJ'l'110C'.l'ION, INC I , pefenqtmt . I'P I 9n~0203n .. .:TlllW 'lml\T, PliWINPED 1\F'Ii'IPI\\1I'.l' ,sTI\~'IU OJ)' GIJX)~or1\ COllN'l'Y OF' F'l.lLlr~~ ,sill ,. Ml\rciA M, JiJr,n!'lt:, ID!'I~lirt'l, )Jeing c1l1ly !'I\'IClrn Aooorqingto lAW, . qepo!'!B!'I anq saY!'!I . 1, l /lm 1\ mamba. in gooq /iltancling of the bc\r qf the oourts of the ,stllte of GeorgiA, hAVing been quly ac1mitteq to practice on UUL~ ' 10.!rt. 2, I am /l partner with the l/lW firm of Pmi th, O<lmbrall. & 'I1Uaael.t, LLl', andprllot:l.ce at; this f11111' a I\t1ant<1, Goorgi<1, office which .ia loc<1ted at Suite 3100, Prcc~n<1cle II, 1230 "paaohtl.~€leStreet, N.El" I\l:1f.l\1\:a, GeorgiA 30309"3592, My telephone numbet, is (404) " 1115~3500 , . 3. I have previoUflly t'epreael1ted Pefendant in other ffi/ltteta LInd am p,t'saently CO~CoUnf3el with ThQMs 1\. Beckley, Eaquire, alld John G, MilakoVio, Eaqulre, J.n t:hia nlllt:ter, .. " "" !' " It ,. '\. Iii ',I' I! 1'.1 i1 i 1"; :J "I/'I I' (;I!,\; " " ,.! "'.'[ I,'II"{ "I\il':HF:YI.,\//\\ W\ "" l' " P" , ,. , i! , , " " " " " L " " II " "I' I', " , it " " " .1 ,." " p. ,. ;'1' I' ,. I' j: I', ',', ./' i( ,. ,. ','1 " Ii! " ," ." " '", " , " it " " " " H " 'I' " !,l;, I'" ,. , ". ';' " " I," i'. ;. " ";, ," ,. '" ". ,. " (" " L. " , " , " .',1 I, ,. " , , , " " /I, I' " I' "'. " ,. " I. :.,. ;, i.', ., " ,. " ;1. I' " " " " i' " ,." " " ;'ji i, "i' " 'I. "i " " ," ,. " " ';"" " " '\ 0;" ;', ,I ;' , , ., q', I'" " Ii ,,, " " " "