HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-02995
"
I,
t~
.....;.
th
~
.~.
11
>-
Q,
.....
\{
It
C,.J
~
, ,I'
"
"j'
"
"
'\
,j
,,, ,
.'
/
/1
I'
(
" "
\~
-
" . .. "
!::l
...
'-J
.~
. ....:...r
.,~\
~
c:;;>4"
'~
~
.
'()
~
"
"
"
"
I'
"
"
''',
"
1\
~,. t
'I'
"
,j.,
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
I'
tf
"
I'
,
I.
1\,
"
'"
"
"
..
,,'
"
';';/'
"
i.
"
I'
"
H
"I
"
"
"
,,,
;i'
I'
I
i,
"
'.
'Ii
",
"
"
, I ~
"
.'
"
ii'
"
"
d'
I,
I'
,.
"
'I.
f!
"
'j.
>!
"
'j,
"
,.
1"
.'
H
"
"
.'
;!
"
"
,'I'
",;
..
;,
"
,
"
I;'
,
" ,
, "
I'At)l,A mllNli po~~AI\W, .
Plnlnlltr
till' IWrH!llt'lIml nn Ilphlllf nf h\lr mlnnr
phllll, TAY\.O!\ MM1I,IN,
y,
: IN Till! (!OPIl'I' OF coMMON PI.HAS ~W
,
,
: r~tJMnrll\I,ANP CO\JNTY, PHNNtiYIN ANI^
LAWlmNCIl nVAN MAOI,IN,
Pp\umlllnl
,
; NO, 9ft...._E1..JU_____ CIVil, 'IT!I\M
: !'IW't'I1CTION FIWM AIHJtill
. :rEMI)O~ARY PROTECTIO~ORD~R:
AND !'lOW, IhlH .z,':b IhlY nl' MIIY, 11)911, IIpnn I1rPHOnliillnn IIlld cPI1Hldorll\lolI or Iho
wllhln Ppllllon, IIml npnn I1mllnu 1111I1 Ih~ pllllnlln; llllllhl Irono PIlCllrlu, IInd Iho PllfllllH' mlnpr
Ilhllll, '!'lIylpr MIIBlln, nmvl'oHlllhll! III U05,Yyonlnn Prlvp, ApI, CIl, cllmp 111I1, CIIl\1bprllll1l1
CUlinlYi \lonnHylvllnlll, 111'0 ,In InilllodllllO IIml proHonl dllnllor ..(11' nbuso 11'01\1 Iho Ilplumlllnl, "
\.IIw,ronop Ilvlln Mnulln, Ihlllll\lowlnu T!ll\1pol'lll'Y ()rllor Is 01\1111'011,
Tho 1I01bndn1\I, I.nwronoo llynn Mllglln, (SSN: 202.40.~ P9)(POIl: 03/22/(5), now
.:osld,lng 111151\4 Fnlrmonl SlrcoItPI\lsbUl'Uh, Al\oghonyCnnnlY, J!onnHylvllnl!l' Is horeby e'Ii~lned
. Ihlln physlolllly nllusln!! Ihp plnlnllO; Pnnln Irene l)oCnrlo, or 11111 pnrlleR1 mhlnr ohlld, Tnylor
Mllulln, or H,'ol,n pllloln!! Ihem In lunr of lib use,
, Tho Ilotbndllnllspnlorod 10 Rlny nWIlY 11'0111 the plllll1110's 1'0sld0l100 100111011 III II Os
. Yvol'llon'iJrlvll, ApI, CU,CIII11P lillI, Cnlllborlllllll Cnnnly, J!ennHylvlI1\llI, II rORldIl1101l..whloh Is
10llsod by Iho pllllnlltl; 1\1111 Is ordored 10 sIllY IIWIlY ll'om IlllY rcsldel1co Iho plnll1lll1' I\1I1Y In Iho
f\llnre oSlllbllSh Illr hersolf.
" '
, Thll delbndnnl Is ordered 10 rlllhlln lrulll hllvlng any lllreot 01' Indlreol cOlllllol With Iho
1,llllnt1tl' Inohllllll!!, hilt not 1I'11110d 10, lolophono, writ ton 01' Ihll'd pllt'ly oOllll1lUnlOllllons, All
cOlnl1lunlolltlolls reuardlnl! OIlSllllly ol'lho pllrthls' 11I1nol' ohllll 111'0 to he 1Illldolhl'Oul:lh IIlhll'd \lllrlY
lnutlllllly lIgl'eod upon bylhe pllrtlos 01' throngh the pllrllcR' IItlorneys hllndUng Ihe. cuslody nll1l\er,
I'
"
Thp IllllpllIlllnt I~ pltlphw,1 tl'lll11 hnrn~~ln!l nlllt Rllllkln/! tlw pllllnllll' nnll ffpl11 hnrn~~ln~ hilI'
'rplntlvp~, nr thp plIl'llp~1 IIllnnr Ilhlhl,
Tlw IlplilnllnnllR IlI~nhiellll'nl11 !lnhl9 Inlhp pllllnlllV~ plll\le 'nl' IllllplPyn1PI1I, lhe RPhnnlll1'
thp, mlnpr ohll,' nr tho IIIIY Pl1ro InollllY nl'lho mhlpr phil,\,
^ \'llIhllllll1 IIr Iht~ Pnlpl' mil)' ~II"jf.Pllhp ,Iprl''''hllll II" I) III'ml "'"I PI' 2~, J'II,C,H,
"611,l11l) lI'IlrlvlIlll ""lmlll"I 1'1"11111111111 II 1111 PI' 2,l I'IIt(~,~, "1iI1~,111II) II1'hll1'8P IIr hllllrlll'l
1'1'1111111111 PIIIIII'ml11 ",nlpl' 2,l I'II,(],H, "6114, 11\III,",Inhl\l II)' ""111'18111111111"1 "I' .111 81_ II101,Ih8
, ,
IImlll f1I1I'IIU100,OO;$I,OOO,OO\ 1111I1 Iv) (1lvlI \llln11l1l1111 "",I\llt 2~ I'II,C,H, ~lil 14,1,
ThlR orllpr Rhnllrplllnll1ln pll'opl IIntll IIlmllllpll nl' 10rllllnlllcII hy Iho CO\ll'I 111111 Olin ho
oXlomlcllhoyllllllitR prllllnlll oxplnlllnn Ihlllllflho(lnur\ llnll~ II1f\t Ihp IIlllpmlnnl hllR onnnnlltoll IIn
not 01' IIhllRu 01' hilS Iln!lll!lcII In n pnttul'I1 01' prnclloc Ihnllnllllllltcs rl~k nf hnnn In thu pllllntH!'
1I11(I/nl' mlnnl' ohllll,
,-
Thll 1I0fonllllnlls nrllorclllo rcllnqlllah III fhp shprllVR IIpplIl'llllPnl nny wpnpons which ho
owns 01' possossos, Inollldlng, hilI nol limit 011 10, n ,44 hnl1<llllln, hns IIsoll 01' Ihronlonod 10 IIsO In
I '
8n h1llldonl of nllllso nWllnst, Iho plnlllllfl~ . Tho 1I01bllllnl1l Ik prohlbitoll ll'lllll ncqllhillg nr
. pllSSOSSl1l9 nny olher WellpOIlS !ill' tho dlll'nlinn of Iho 01'1101' find Is roquh'od 10 rollnqulsh 10 Iho
shorlffnllY llrllllnn 1I0llnso Iho dufbl1dlll1( mny PURSOSS, Tho dofbndlln('s wonpolls 1111(1 Ilronnn
, "
1I00nso ml1y ho rOlurned III Iho oxplrntloll of tho I'ro\litlllnn Ol'dor lilloI' tho do/\1ndlll1l hilS
submltlod 11 wrltton requosl to tho Coul'l fill' Iho re\Ul'l1of tho WOllpons nnd tho ellur! hilS Ilotlllod
tho pll1\nll/l'ol'lhe rcquost lind lllvon Iho plnlnlill'lIn nppnrtunlty 10 rospond, A copy orlhlsOrdor
"
shllll ho !mnsllllUod 10 tho Ilhlol'ol' hClld ol'lho 1,lOlIco dopIIl'In1onl of'lhQ (lQllllsylvnnln SllIlo "01100
(Cllrllslo llllnnokR), nnd IIny olhel' IIppl'oprlnlo pollco dOPllrllll~llls mill tho shorlll' ofAllollhony
Counly,
"
I'i\\JI.1\ II\1lNn 1l1l(!i\I\ItO,
.. I'llIll1Iln'
, I\ll' lwrsoll' IInll un hphllll' lit' hor mhwl'
ohlld, 'l'I\YI101~ Ml\m,IN,
v,
: IN '1'1 III cPPlrr OF COMMON 1'I,r!I\R OF
,
,
: C\JMIllll\I,ANP COlJN'I'Y, pnNNRYIN I\NII\
: NO, 9"._____._._.'_.._~,- C1YII,'I'1l1~M
1,1\ WI~IlNCn nv AN MAQI.IN,
PIlI'llmlllnl
,
,
: I'I~OTnCTlON FI\PM AII\JSn
NOTICJn
YIlII hllw hop II imp\111I omlfl, If YOII wish 10 1I0f\lmlll!!lIll1sl thpllllllms 8pl forlh In Ihp
l'ollpwll1U P"UIlS, YOlll11l1sllllkp 11011\111 pr\1mplly IIflllr Ihls \!ol\llol1, 01'\101' 1111\1 N\1l1llo nrll SIlI"Il\\,
hy IIppollrll1!l persllnlllly or hy IIUomoy 1I111w hOllrll1!! sohC\\lIIOII hy Ih\l CoUl'l IIm\ prPHIll11hllllO Iho .
C\l\Ir! Yllllr Ilofol1H08 \11' ollJOlllllll1S III Iho.ollllms Hol I'lIrlh 1I!lIlII1B\ yOIl, YOllllro wllrnllll Ihlllll'yolI
. full lo,do 811 Iho CI1\11"I mllY procood wltholll yml, 1I1ll\ II Jml!lI1l11I1I'lHlI)' hilpnlorll\III!lIl\nSI yml II)'
Iho CPllfl wllhollll\lrlhor 11111100 lor IIny monoy olllll11od In IhoIlo\I\I\1n m.lor noy olhor plnlm or
rpllof roqllPslod \1)' Iho pllllnlll1', Y \lit mil)' loso monOy or propllI'I)' or \1lhor rl!lhlH hnpl1l'lllnl 10
)'1111, Ally Pro~lllltlflll .Orlllll' ""'>>Illcd hy n em",1 III1lY hllllllllsldllrllll III ,,"y SllhSllllllllll1
domcsllc rc'"llml~ PI'OCllll(III1~SIIIIChllllll~ ellstody IIctlmls, '
IllnlGS AND COSTS
If Ihp 111180 !lOOS III IWllrlng 11011 Iho Jud!lu grlllllH II Proleollon Ontllr, II sllrll11l\rBc of $25 ,00
will bo 11880S80d 1I!llllnsl you. YOlll1lll)' lllso ho l'll\1l1lrOlllo PIlY IIp'lo $250,0010 rphnbufso 0110 PI' .,.
l.og,,' Sorvlcos, 1110,'0 l\mllhl!l80Uf008 for LO!l1l1 Sorvlcos, 100,'8 ropl'osonlllllon oflhoplllhllllf,
VOII hllVll thlll'lghlIII hlll'llpresllnled by cllllllsel. VOlIshollll\t"ke this I'l\ller IliYllllr
hlwye,' 1I111llce. If YOIl dllllOt hllve Il IlIwyef lilt CIUlIlllllI~Ol'd IIl1e, go to or Iclellho"lllhe
olT!ce scl forth below to nnd o"t whlll'e YllU cIlllllelllll.llll helll.
! . .
CUMUmU,ANIJ COUNTY lli\R ASSOCIATION
2 l.IBUll'I'V A VENl!.E
CAllLISLE, I'BNNSYI.v ANIA 1.70 1 ~
TBLl1JI1IONE NIJMllEll: (717) 249.3166 or TOLl, FREE: 1;800.990-9108
.. f1AX:(717) 249-2663 ..
i\M.iIUCANS WI'I'll 1)ISAIIIU'ltlJ'iS ACT 0111\190
Tho COliI'I ofCon1ll1llll Pions llfCulllhorlllnll COllnly 18 roqlllted by Inw IllcolnnlY wllh tho
AlIIorlcl\ns wllh IJI8Rbl\lll08 Acl of 1990, For Infbrlnn\llln Ilbollt lIccosslblo litclllllos . itn"
rOll8onRblc nccllll\111l\dntlllIl8 nVllllnblo to dlsoblcd Illlllvldll018 hllVllll! buslncss belbtc IlIp c~Utl".
plCRSC cllnlllol 0111' omoo, AlIlIrrlln!lotnollls 1111181 be llIl1dOlllloosl 72 hllllrs prior. 10 Rny hllllrlll!l
or buslnos8 bcfbrc Iho clIln'l.
, . .
MllI,t\ Il\nNn P~\(~t\I\W,
l'IIIIIIIln' .
thl' lIel'HIlIl'II1111 PfI Iwllllll' nflwl' minor
Illllllt, '1't\YWI\ MM1I.IN,
.y,
: IN Till! CPPln' OF COMMON 1.'I.Ht\H ()F
,
,
: CIJMmll\I,t\NP CPIJNTY,I'IINNHYl,yt\NIt\
1,t\WlWNCll IWt\N Mt\OI,IN,
Plllilllllllll\
, ,
: NCl, OH._A_1.'l-r' ______ CJIVn, 'IT\I\M
,
,
:\'I\OTIWTION FIWM t\ntJl:iH
PETITION FOR PROTECTIO~ ORDER
,.. _., d. .... .. ,__.. " .. .. ,_ .. ,. _' ., _ _, '_' .. _ __.. .
I~E,<nel" lJNmm Tille 1'1~{)'J'ICCTI{)N 11'lm," t\IUlSIC t\C'I'
:Z;) l'll,e,/'l, "6101 lit Nil'll
"
{\. A1nJs~
I, Thll pllllntiff. .11llullllrllnll PeCllrlo, IH IIn IIdillt Indlvlcllllll rllahllnu lit 1105 YVllnlon
PrlVll, t\p,l, CH, Cmnp Hill, Cumhlll'hmd COllnIY, flennaylVllnl1l 170 II,
2, The <Illfilndllnl, 1,lIwrence IIVIIII Mllulln (SIlN: 207.40.3139)(POU: Q~mlCi!i), IH
I\n I\dllll hllllvhlulIl reHldlng I\t 1564 FlllrnlPl1l Slroel. fllHabllrgh, AIIQghQny COllnlY, 11ennHylVllflIII
152~ \,
3, Thll dorellllllnt 1ft tho tbrnwr hUHblllld offho pllllnlll1'lIl1ll the I1lthol' nftho pllrlloH' 8.
yellr old aon, 'I'lIylor MIIUIlIl,
4, SllIoe IIppl'P1<h""101~ 1996, tho dolbnchnl hila IIltmnptod to' OIlUBO 111111 hllo
IntenUol1l1lly, knowlnBly, nr rookloaaly 011118011 bodily IrUmy tn Ihe pllllnUn; hllB cOl11ll1ll1cd HeXUIII
IIHallult or Invllllllllllry tlovlnte aox\l1\1 IntllroOlll'ao, Illla IhlHoly hnprlaonoll tho plllll1llO' Ill\l'HlllIl1l In
IR 1'1\, C,S, ~ 2903, hl\a phYHlolllly IIbuslltl tho PlIl'lloa' minor ohlld, hila plllocd the pllllntlll'l\nd tho
ohlld III rOllaollllblo fullr 01' hnll1lnont aerlquB hOlllly InJmy, IInd hila knowll1gly cnBlIBcll Inn oouraQ
of oonduot 01' I'opolllollly oO\11l\1l\tod lIotH towllrd ,tho pllllntlll' lind/or Iho lnlnor child Inoludlng
following tho plllll1tll1' nnd/ol'. tho child, wlthoutlll'llpor lIulhorlzlIllon, undol' OlrOlHl1stllllcOs whloh
hllVo plncod tho pllllnlll1'nnd(ol' tho child I\frollsllllllblo fillll' ofhodlly hUllrY' II'hI8 hilS Illoludcd, Inll
IHllllllltnltcd to, tho Ibllowll1g spool/,lo hlstllno09 ofllhuHe:
"
",
/,
"
"
II) Un Ill' ,,1111111 MIIY ;!;!, IIJlJII, 1 h\l 11\l1~1Hlllnl IlIlhll! I1IIR\lhllll ,Illlt UV\lr hlR
Rhlllllllpr IIfl11 IhrPlIllln\llllhllpllllnllt1' H'Iyln!!! "I HhUlllllhl1 yllll wllh 1I1IR,:' Tlw
, ,
pllllnllll'Icllr1311 Ihr hilI' Hlllbl)',
\I) 011 ur 11\11,1111 Mil)' II, 19911, Ihll dulbflllnlll !!rllhlllllllllll pllrilpH' lI"yol\r alII
, Hlln \ly Iho IIrm, drll!l!!oll him lI\lrllHH Ihe streel, shllvell him Inl\l Ihe \1111', 1I1111 HIIIlI,'
"NllIllW Is anlnu 111113111110 whollllml whor\ll Qlm IlIko Illy ohllll," lmd dmvo IIWlly,
\l) On pr.llhmll MlIY 7,1991\,lhe pllllnllll'rollll'llllll hOl11o 10 nllllllllllhlfQIllhml
wlllllnu Ihr hor ll1l1R1111l hor IIpllrlnWnl.' Wlion Ihe ph\lnlll1' Wllnl' IIpRllllrs 10 hor
IIpllr\nlllnl, 1I11l 1IIllcmllll11 Ihllowoll hilI' Inlo hilI' npllrlmonl \lospll\1 hor lellln!! hll11
nllllp OPI110 hI, pllHhll1llhe door upon, nOli wnlkollln,
d) ,.' On Ill' nholll April 23, I 99ll, Iho Illlfeflltllll\ 0111110 lolho plnlnllll's rORldonll\1,
l\r!!lIlld with hor, IInd Ihl'olll\1I101I hilI' pllllnlll1' ~nyh1!!, "I'll h(l rill uf yOIl ROpn," IInd
thrcntencd her 11'Iond, Joslo, slIylnB, "Ami YOII'ro d11l\0, too," Tho \Iofomlnnt
!lrnhho\I'l'lIylor hy the linn, dnHlBol1 him down 3 f1I!!hlH of Rllllrs \l:lllnnllllzhl!l tho
,., I'
ohllll, IInd Rhovodhlmlnto the Olll'.
(,'
0) On or nholll April 20, 19911, tho dolcndllnl slllppo(1 'I'lIylor reponl\ldly IIbOll1
his bllllooks ellllRlnB him 10 0111.on the flllpr, IInd liS Iho ohlld Iny'. on Ihe floor Iho
,
dofondnnl klokc(1 him RovoI'IIllllllCS IIhollt hlslo!!s,
I) ,On 01' nholll April I B, 199B, tho pllllntUf hoslod II bll'lhdny pllrly nnd slo\lp"
OVOI' fbr hor SOil, Invltod npproxhlll1loly 20 ohlldl'Oll, nlld IlIvllo(1 Iho Itol\mdnl1t III
. tho hlrthdny pllrly, Tho \!ofondlll1t followod Iho pllllmlll'll1lo hOl' bodroom, looked
tho dool' dosplto hol' plollsfol' him 10 lOIlVO, told hol', "You will hnvo S01\ with 1110:
you'romy wilc: you'lIl1lwn)'s ho I11Y wile," (Tho plll'\los hnvo booll dlvorcod ~ll1oo
199:\,) Tho dofclldlll1ll'lppcd tho plllllltllrs olothh\!l oll~ Ihl'ow hor 01110 tho bcd,
Bmhl1lllllwr hllll, 1l111llwrlnl1llml nvor IlIlIlO\I~P ho Wlla gnlnB In hh hilI' whh h, 11m!
allxlllllly n~allllhllll hot:: t,'
B)' In or 11110111 Oolobllr 100'1, whllo I!rlvlng Ihp I'm.. Ihllllplilmlon\ Brnl1hlllllhp
pllllnllll' hylhll Imlr, yllnklld hilI' hellll bllck IIml fnrlh. allVlll'll1 Ilmoa ollllalnBlh\l
pllllllllll'ln loao PhilliPS nf hiliI', 1111\1 honulldllllr hOllllllgllh1allh\lIIIlShhplIl'll, As I\.
ros\111 pflhla h1\llllol1llho plllllllllf s\lBllllnlld bmislllB IIml snrllnpss pnllDI' fmllIlPIIII, .
11011 hlllllhwll\la,
h) In ql'lIbolll AIIBlIsl 1997, Ihe Ilolbndllnl pIIshodlho plolnlHfRs ijheslllPl1 on ..
tho IlIndlnB of II sllllrOll80 ol\llslnu her lu stllmble dpwn sllllrs,
,
I) Onur IIbolll ,filly 4, 1997, Iho dofonllllnl ollllelllllo ph\ln@' II whpro, shll,
, 111111 uther h\lmlllolh1B nllmoB Inlho presonoll of Ilwlr ohlld IIm\ repelltodly Blmllk h~I' .
, Iry Iho nDok wllh II Bilek, IIslnB II slllhhlnB mollon, The plnh\IIIl' sllslnhlCll red morkB
'IIndsoreness IIbOll1 her nUllk liS II rCSllllllflh\slneldenl,
j) In 01' IIbpUl June 1997, Ihe dolbmlonl Brnbboll Ihe plolnlll1' by hor orm,
Blllmmed hilI' IIBlllnslthe Willi, ond PIIShlld IIglllnat her ohesl to keep hilI' t\'ol11
, , ,- .'
lellVlng,
. k) Slnoll IIpproKlt11l1lely 1996, Ihe .delbl1llnnl hilS IIbllselllhe pllllnlll1' In wllYs
"
Inoludlng, bill nol Ih11lled, 10, plllllng hilI' h\lmlllllllnu Hilmes lnlhe presenoe of Ihelr
ehllll IInd In Pllblle, shovln!lllnd.Brnbblnu hul', pulling her hiliI', rusll'lIlnlnB her, IInd
s01l\lolly IIBslllllllng hur, In oddllloll, thu llplbndnnl hils I'CpelllcllIY gono'to Ihu
plnllllHrs l'eBldence 11l1lnvl~cd nnd to her plnce of employmonl (nn elementnry
BclullI\)i He hns letej>honed her r\lsldenlle severnl limes 1\ dlly, tclephoned Ihe
sehool whel'e she lellches sevornl limes lelllng Ihe sehool shiff Ihnt Ihere wns IIn
emOl'gency J\!st to Bol hol' 10 sllenk 10 hlll1, nmt telephoncll hol' Ithmds to delel'lnlne
her Wheretlbinlls, The dlllbndnllt hllB repentedly shoved, Brnhbe<I, klckcd, slnpped,
IlrnIJBP~I. IIIHI nllllllllhrPIII& In Ihp pllrlllla' 1l1111nr phllll. '1'11)'101', flnph 11& IPlllnB him
Ilml hp wllnhl RPmlhlmlo "kl~I'R JIIII" IImIIPIIY\l hlll1lhprp, PlI\lfllnlJ \lIP phlllllll hll
Il'Inll1l1ill~PII. 'I'hp pllllnlll\' 111011 II I'rnlQPlhln Frnl1l I\h\lap I\ollnll IIBlIlnal \lIP
~lpl'pI1\llInl 111 Pllllrhln CpnnlY (Nil, ~1l2HH>~) IImUn AllllBhpn)' CplInl)'ln or
"llIIUI IIlO\,
s, Tho pllllllllfl'llPllovo& 1I11l1lhorolilr\lllyorfl Ihlll sho IIm\,lhp pllrllpfl' l1Iinpr \lhll~ll\ro
,
III Ill1nlPI\llIl1l IIml prp&\llll (11InBPr PI' lI\mHp 11'0111 Ihp dofbmlllnl IIml \lml Iho)' 111'11 In IIPoII of
l\rotopllon 11'0l\l HIIPh IIhuHO,
Ii, 'l'ho flllllllllfl' dn&lro& Ihlll Iho Ilofundllnl ho prphlbltodl1'ol11 hnvlnB, IIny ~\lrool or
Imlh'\lpl PPI1II1PI wllh Iho pllllnllflt hlplndlnll, 11111 nol 1I111110~' Ill,:, tolophl1l1p IInd wrlllon
Pnl1ll1lll11IPII\lPI18 III hpfJPsldol1po, pineo ofpll1plo)'IllOI1I PI' IInyolhpr IOCllllpll, All 001l11111l11lcII\lons
"
1'IIIlllnlllla O\lslPlly ofth\l plll'llos'l1Ill1ol' ohlld IIrp 10 bo I1IlIdo IhnlUBh II Ihlnl pllrl)' lllUllllllly IIllreed "
\lfllln b)' tho pllrllos Ill' Ihrpullh Ihn flllrllos' lI\1ornOy8 hlllldllll!1 Ihp o1l810rl~ I11l1l1er,
7. Tho flllllnlllfdp8lr\l8 thlll th\l dof\ll1dlll1l bp elUlllllod 11'0111 hllrl\sslnll lIl1dallllklngth\l
pllllnllfl'. IInd lhll11 hnmsslllll hor rolll\lves.or Iho,mlllor ohlld,
"
1\, Tho pllllllllfl'dpslros Ilml tho Ijolull1111111 bo rcstrnlllod 0'0111 Bolll!! to hili' pllloe 01'
ol1lpl(1)'lI1olll. Iho 80hool of tho 11111101' ohlld or Iho dllY 0111'0 11101llty ol'tho minor ohlld,
,9, Tho Illlllnllfl' 110811'08 Ihll\ IIny wOllflons the defundllnl OWI1S or pOSS08ses InollldlllB,
, , ' .
hut nol Illllllcd 10. n ,44 hnndlllln, be oonf1Rollted by the Sherlfl'8 Depnrll110nl nnd thlltihe
dQfundllll1 be prohibited ')'Olll lIoqulrlnll or pos8esslnB nlly WellpOnS 'fur the dlll'lltlon 01'. the
Protection Order;
,II, ICXCUJ~IVE ..OSSlCSSIQIj
10, Tho resldol1oe loonted nt 11OS,Yvenloll Drive. ^Jlt.. CIl. Cnll1Jl HIli, ClIl\1hetlllnd
Coullly. Jlennsylvnnlll. ')'Olll which the pllllnlll1' IR IIsklnB the Gourtto order tho defbndllllll~ stll~ "
"
1':\
I,
I
.~
.."
,
'....
n
',~,
I~
~l
, :!.~
,0,
,~3
1~
,~
'" II' I
i ,
i I,
,
/, ,I " .')
( ,
I', , '" ! I
"
Ci; "
I' I ,J
I " "
I,,' I . I ,
. I ,
r ,
"
II , ')
t"l ....,1 (.I
"
"
"
"
if'
""
"
"
i,
"
"
,
,.
''1
,
II)
.~'
,
\'1
~
;i
':,"
,,'
~
I,l
J
~
y
.}
1'1)
"
"
.'. '
'I j
"
"
"
,j;
.f;
Ii
:.\<
/,',
1;1
"
"
;.;,
.,
"
"
,
"
"
"
"
"
,,'
\1
"
"
",
i ~
"
j<
"
"
'I'
"
"
{J
"
"
H
1'.
i H
H
"
ft"
"
"
'I,
, ;-
"
,,,
"
"
-Ii
, H
I,
, , ,
'.' ",' ',I' . '~'" '
" , . ',., 'i .. ," ,,' \
~ '
, tn. hL!!. I' .,
. r~:, " "
lilt: . ,
. IW ' w'
. 1.'ti. ': , ',~ \; " , ~ Ii " "..'"
. ~ .. y ! B I' .. .' '. , ..
, I: .... ..! . i If .; ..... .,.' "'. .
h ; i . " ~iiB ~~, .
, m s IN~ '~H. ififiig mU~~;H~~~iHhha~~y~
" '
, , '
I
, ,
<. j ';
, ,
, ','
, ,
! 1 t
"
'~
'- ..., ~:
f~ Iff
r.:, "s'
... ...'t
r (3''''
pl!,l ~'11 (. ~ ,~:\.~
te, ,,:J.t ,;,:,',';J.i
'. '
tJ ,I; U'I "t(:j~
Q~ I}; I "I "',
'J' l:JiE
r:~'i
F "', l'tl
) <.,
lb. m "5
[J
"
"
Ii
'"
";,ti
"
"
";
"
'.
"
,'"
.,'"
"L
'I'
",
I'
Ii
','!
.;,
;'.'H'
,I
"j,
"
"
I'
I,'i
I' II
I'
I
"
"
Ii
!;
H I.
,.1'
'j.
"
"
H
"
.'
:]
I,
,0
"
"
"
" .
"
,"
"
," ,.
I
.. I
, ~ '\
PRQ'I'~Q1'Hnh I JW')M ^'Ulpn
il ' "
rrj'MAY 2 t; 19~8
\,
,SHERIFF'~S', INFORMATION
GAllI! l'/Arqll! '[)GC~ I ?AubI I~ v~, MAA,O,!' t.~~,
11IA!mHf' , '~' , "
Np, fl ~ ~ f16 OfVtlj 'rEml
, fI~Arjn~'PM!l1 ,~'D4-<r I ...~, '~F .,199;(M '3,00
,TUQ!l!l ,()~(l!'J;;a ,!n CP\'r~rpPIl1 Np,L
J.e"l\1 Illlrv!Il!l1l Iltl\ff pqn~lIot (;!4a~!l400) I ~ ' JA-N ./~'N (,.
GilA+f
,,'
t,fll;
D~FENPANT'S SERVICE ADDRESS(ES)
M~t/lIlQ pf Illlrvip!ll ' .K ~!lrllllnlll emir O~harl .
flaMEr ,/56rf ~em(j,uT' -sua=et, \~n~! /JIu~Mn BWe 'BIbfjS~<<c
,-I;, , "
1={;r~'8u.~~ I M/E~I!#\Y 0.0. " '~'T rbmes~ . Pt'l' _
Phllnal (~,2"lt (5'~,)-('Ph(ma&@-)~/~ ~~llhiftllQW~5 AI1~
Q~har!
"
Phone I
,.
DESCRIPTION OF DEFENDANT
Qemlarl.JIM\..u; , RAoar ~.' Heightl .$f 7" Waightl ISO 16:s
HAirll4-C<~I2IJ(fI~b4~alll G~ PilltinguiBhing fOAturlllll,
srJ!Hep ~~, ~ (1()"f1eK1tMif:fJ(:e-), ~ on (6fT", '6(Q~
, ," "',, '*,~ .'6fffd;~
" ". .,
TERMS OF TEMPORARY PROTECTION ORDER
A- .llI<<elllllle~~ ,. SPEOIAL INllmUOTIONIl' 7<l1fs. #~6N.~ ~J
tit} Tel11PPr~ry CUstody. /';rJ5'i;.lh'f' t!J't-h.tl..>.. ~tSS
~~-;;onfis~ ' ,"1
......0..-
. PAlJI,i\ 1I\UNg PpPMI9,
I 1'1111111111'
fhr hOI~~lfIlM nil b~h'llfnfhpr mh1\lr
phllll, TI\YWRMi\W.IN, '
v'
: INT/lfl (;OlJlnOF PQMMON "1.!Wi OF
,
: {;\JMnm~I.ANP rO\JNTY, PIlNNSYI.vANIA
I'
I.AWI\rlNr!1 UYi\N MMII.IN,
, , .. I)p1011\1II1I1
. ; NO, 9H-__et.?_rc\t___._ cI\llI. Tnl~M
. !' .
: PllQ'lTiCT1PN FllOM AIHJl'ili
I'
, TmJVIPORARY PROTEC1'IOI~ORJ)ER
ANP N;,lhlH _~~~IIY IlfMIIY, 1\l9R, '!pnll prCHollllltl:1I IIml olll1al\lol'llllplI of Iho
wllhlll I'Pllllllll, lllHI IIpOI1 I1mlll1Y thol Ow plllll1\lfl~ P!IIIIII 11'0110 PoCllrlll, 111111 Ow pllnloR' mlllllr
ohllll, 'i'oylllr MII\llln, I111W rosllllny III 1105, Yvonlnn Prlw, Apt, cij, ('limp lilli, <:lIm\:orlllI1l1.
CPlIIllY, PCllnsyivlIl1hl, 111'0 in IlIlInollllllo IInd ,irosonl \Iollgor Of'lIbllao 1)'0111 Ilw dolblHhllll,
l.nwrol1o~ Hvnn Mnglll1, Iho Ihllowlllg TOlllporllry 01'1101' Is ol1lorod,
The Il0rondlll1l, I.nwrol1oo IiVIII1 MII!llln, (SSN: ~0~-"0-3139)(t)OIl: 0,1122/65.1, 1111\'.'
rpuldhl!llll 15M Fnlrmllnl ~Irool, PllIsbllryh, Alloghony COlll1ty, POllllaYlvllllhl, IR h~ruby OIUOhlOd
I'
l1'om phyalolllly IIbllalng tlw pllllntlfl; Pllulll Irono PoCmln, Ill' thu pllnleR' millOI' ohllll, TlIylor
Mllglln, or I)'om pllloln!! thomln 1'0111' nfllbuso,
. Tho dofondont Is ol'llorod to allly IIWIIY I)'om th,o plllll1tlfl'a roaldonoo loolltoll III II o~
Yvprdon DI'lvo, Apt,CR, Cllmp Hili, Cllmborlllnd COllnly, PonnaylVll111ll, II rosldel1oo w'lloh Is
' "
hmaoll by tho plllh)t1fl: I\l1d la ordorod to atllY IIWIIY Irom ~IIY roald(lfloo the pll\lnlll1' IllIlY In th!l
filturo ostllbllah Ihr hersolf.
.'
The dolhndlllll Is ordored to ron-l\ln fhllll hllVIIl!! IIny 1111'001 or Indlroct oontllot 'vhh tho
pllllntlfl' Ineludlny, bul not Ihulled 10, Il,llcphono, \;"rlllon 01" Ihlrd pnrty 1l0mmunlol\t1ona, All
COllll1\unlollllolla royordlnl! oURlmly of the pllrtles' minor ohlld lire 10 bo Illllde Ihrou!!h 1\ Ihlrd 1>III'Iy
. I11Ullllllly lI!!reed upon by tho Plll'llosol' through tho pllr!los' IIttornoys hllndllllg tho ouatody tnlltter,
1(, 'V,
, ,
Th~ Ilelblllll111lla ~llinllWllll'nm hlll'llaall1!! I1I1tI all11kll1lllhe p11l1l1l111' IImll1'om hlln.'flall1ll hel
1I'IIlIIvl'&, nl the pllrlll'a' m\,,11I' ~hllll,
'I'll\lllel\lmhmlla otllplI1Ulllh1m HPhm \l11hll pllllnllll1fl plllol' PI' l,lmpII1YIl1PIlI, Ihe sohpolol'
Iho mlnm chilli or IlIe IIIIY Olll'e IllOlIhy PI' Iho mlllOJ' \lhlld,
, ..,
^ vlolllll,," of Ihls Unll1r mlly sllhjl1~1 Ihl11111flll1llllllll01 I) 1II'1'l1s1 ""11111' 2~ J'n,c,R,
"lill~l II) 11 "I'IVlllfl ~l'lmhml IlUIIlI,lllllll 111111111' 2;l I'n,C,R, "ft1 1.1, I I III) II uhnl'lll1l1f IllIlh'c~1
Hlmllllll Illlnlemlll IInlll1l' 23 ,I'ntCta, "iiI I,l, p,mhlhllhll1 hy IIIIIlI'lsllllml1l1l "llllI sh mOlllhs
nllll" "ne nf$IOO,1l0.$I,OOOtOOlllnll Iv) \llvn ~o'lhlml'l 1111I1111' 2,lIlIl,C,Il, "fil 14,1,
. .
This Oldorshllll 1'01111,111 In 011'001 ul1ll1molllf1oll or 10111111101011 by Iho Coml IInd 01111 he
OXlel1l10d heyomlllfl nlllllnlll explllllllll1 dllle Iflho Cl1mllinda 111111 Ihe Ilol'el1l111111 hllfl oommllllJlllI11
1101 or IIbuao \11' hila 0l1gllg011111 II pllllol'll or pl'llolloo Ihlll 111I1I01l10fl Ilflk Ill' hnnn III Iho plllll1lll1'
IIl1d/OI mlllol ohlld:
Thl" dotclldllnlls llldolO(1 III rolll1qulsh 10 Iho shorill's IleplIl'lmonllll1Y w'cllpona whloh he
.. . uwna or possoaaos, Inollldlng, h\ll nol IImlled 10, n "'4 hnndll\lIl, hila uflod or Ihrl)l\lol1od 10llso III
IIn hlOlllenl or "buflo IIglllnsl Iho 1l111111t11l~ Tho dol'ondllnl la prohlblloll 1l'01l1I10I11lIrIl11! or
poasoaalnglmy olhor IVOllpOllfl I\lr.tho IllIrnllon or Iho Order IIl1d Is roqulrod, 10 relll1qlllsh \utho
shorlll'lIny Ilrollrll1 lIool1~e Iho dolbndllll\ mllY pllsaoHs, Tho Ilol\Ji1dllnl's WOIlPO';S mId Ilr~lIrm
.1I001lso IllIlY bo roturnod III Iho explrllllol1 tlr Iho I'rotocllol1 Ordor 11001' tho dolbl1dlll11 hilS
s\l~mhlod II wrhlonroqnosl to Iho Courl fur Iho roturn or Ihe IVOllplll1a nlld tho Courl hilS I1otlnoll
.'
Iho 1'1111111111' ol'lhe reqnosl IInd glvon tho (l11l1l1lllT IIn oppOrlunlty 10 rlls(lond,' A oopY orlhls Ordor
shllllho ll'llllallllllod 10 lho ohlol'or hond ol'tho polloo dopnrtmol1l ol'lho I'cll11sylvnllln Stlllo 1'01100
(Cllrllale Ontrnoks), IInd III1Y olhor IIPproprlllle, pollco depnrllllollts IInd Ihe shorllT of Alloghol1Y .
Counly, .,
'\'\1
I
;'
1,:\
Ii'
'II
"
, ....,
t\ ....C^'~.N(. rillt\U, .m 1I1CI,1) ON Tmri Mt\"'TI'~n ON
,'llNK-,..,eC; 199", (\'1'. 3:(.)(1 ~,"'" IN C(W'~'I"UlOM NO, L. cUt'
Tille (;lIMUlCIU~t\ND ~O'JNTV C(,)lJ'~T"O'J(i'C. Ct\I~"'SUC.
. ' .
"'CNNSVlN ANtA,
Thp I1lnlnlllf mny Pl'llPllllll wllholl' I1rll-l1l1ynwnl 01' Ibp8 I1Pflllln1\ n 1\11'11101' Iml\lJ nllllr Iho
hPllrln1\,
,.''I'hp CplIlhprlnllll CPIII1IY Shprlll'8 PllplIl'ln1!lnl 8111111 IIllllmll\ 10 mnkp SIlI'Yloll III, Ihl'
,
plllll1111V8 rC~111l81 ,111111 Wlthmll I1r\l-l1nymPI\\ of lbps, bill Klll'Ylpp nlllY hll nplll1l11pllshpllllIHlol' nny
IIllpllonblp mill nl' ClvlIl1l'nu\l(hlr\l,
Thl8 Ol'llpl' shllll bll dnllkollld In Ihll 0111\l1l nl'lho Prolhonolllry IInd till'\vlIl'Il\ld 10 Iho Shorlff
n,l' K\lrvl\lo, Tho l'rolhl1nolnry Khllll nO\1I011l111 oopy 01'Ihl8 Ordol' In IIw llolbllltnnl by mllll,
'!'hll Wosl Shoro l~o1\lonnl Polloll j)oPllrllllont';'hnll bll pr(lvlllod wl\h II IlOrlll1odl1opy ol'lhls
Onlol' hY'lho plllll1ll11'8 IIllnrnuy, This Ordor 8hnll ho onthru\ld by nl1Y IlIw onfor'polllonl nuonoy
whpro II vlollltlnn OPOllrs IIY nrros\ tor Indll'\lctl1l'lllllnnl oontOlllpl wlthmll wnrrnlH IIpon prollllblo
I1l1l1KlllllllllhlK 01'1101' hns boon vlollll\ld, whotllur or nollho vlolnllon Is oOlllll1l\1cd In\1I1l prosonoo .
01' tho polloo nl11ool', In Iho OVlll1llhnl nn nrrost Is 11111do, lindoI' Ihls socllol1, Iho II0t\Jt1dl\nl sholl bo
IlIkon wltholll lIill1\lOOSsOry dolny Illll'ol'o Iho I1mlrl Iho\' IRsllod thll ordor. Whon 11101. enllrt Is
unllvllllnblo, tho dol\Jndnnl sholl bo IlIkonbofbro Iho IIpproprllllo dlstrlol 1'ISlloo, m Po,C,s,
'"
~6113), .
Judgo
JOlin CIIl'oy ,
U:GAI, SICltVICICS. INc. I ~t" 'l(lJ'~ '~t..r
Allot!loy 'hI' Jlllllntiff i) ..
TRue OOPY FROM RecoRD
In Toollmol1Y whoroo', I horo limo Got my hand '
Md tho oenl of Bald Court at Carllslo, Pal ..
rhl~" (I~. day ot ..~ '. .,I!6J
I. '. CJ''f' 0 i< d. ~'f
. .' Prothonotary ..
"
I.
I
=
(Jil':lC,r.t~' IY '\:~t.; r ,'J'
'.'I;" '
~n 'L,u
Z ~\\ \1\\ '~a
"
',__},I
n'dl,',
I.i.
\,,"'1\11 \ i\
,! /'
"
!'"
;;'
1"
,,:\
"
Ii-
"
;,'
".,
I'
"
"
1\
"
"
'I,
"
,.
,
(>.
"
,1.11
"
,,'
''''''1
"
,
;i
"
ji
"
"
"
I,
'I.,
ji
"
"
I"
"
"
',l
.,"
I.
I',
,_ H
I,
[-:
"
I'
"
"
"
/'
"
"
;,1'
\\
"
";.,
,/
,,,,.
j."
"
I'
'. !
,',
'\'6~f~v.
Il~.rf'
. '" ~ If!
'I' . I <Ii
,"' ',"
I '~\~,
\i!t;;~ih,
It "'L,
''f''
.....
"
"
~t' '
.,
"
"
"
"
d' ,
"II
'.
,,\
" I,
""~'tIt;
"
.
.,'
,
'I
"
"
(f
~.. ", ,"\ ..
t '"~ I
:~"h% '
',< ~ ,". ~'~I-j,~<!~"
,
,~""
I,,,, "A " ; !
~ ,v,': 'I
. 'I."'.. I" 1
, '~'il'~I,~
\ PH~", ,
.1 0\." I' ,~ I';
'-',"- -\' .
>,;...',1'1''1,.4 ;
JI.t "'\ f
l~' \$.;, j f
" .(,,\ ...
',~ I, "",';
,l ~ '. .~. .).'
~.' 'ftt.!"', ,'~ ~
t) ',' .~' _ "
. \, (ii\/.' I,' "V
1~ '.,rl .,
, (..' 'r\
, \,
..
"
i
I'
'"
i.
I,
" "
.":A
,,~i,
"
of.
.i ' ':'t ~ ,
.'
, 'K"'~, 'I~.
(~, t'l'\
, I;~
I
~
"
,ii'
"
v.
"t'
I'
"
,
.,
'J
'..1
\
,iI..... ,0'
,"l" ,
,\\
"
...
\
.
1
~\,.,
,1
"I
1"
. ~
, ,
~/f~ ~f'I'
,
J
t
:!r.
: (\
.
i
>;&1
j
~,.
,.
I
,I.).
"
I.
r;
,;.
,
,
i
,
\ ~l
, '
) ,;\
I" :.~
,
..
MIll'A mUNfl PoCAR\.O,
111111nllO'
l'pr her~oll'lIll1l on IJolllllltol'\1or mlllor
\1hllll, 'I'A YWR MAOI,IN,
v, '
: IN THIl CO~R'r OF COMMON \11.1!1\S OF
,
.
. ; C~MJlnRJ.,ANP cOUNTY, ImNNllYLVA1'llA
.
; NO. 'JO. r.1I9f.s __ CIVil. 'rfll\M
L/AWR.llNCfl UVAN MAOLIN,
pol'ol1lll111\
.
,
: I1I\OTHCTION I'I\OM AIlUaU
TE\YIPOnARY PRO~ECTIO~DE", .
. ANP NOW,lhla "~IIIIY 01' MIIY, 1!)'Jo, Ilpoll prollonlllllon IInll ~101l1l1\lornllon of Iho
wll\1ln POllllon, IInd IIpon Onllln!llhlll Iho pllllntllT, 1'1111111 Irollo l)oCllrlo, IInd Ihll pllrlloll' minor
\lhlld, Tllylor MIIBlIn, now rosldl,," lit 1105 Yvofllon Prlve, ApI, co, CIIl1Ip Hili, Cumberlllnll
COllnty, ~onnsylvllnlll, IIro In Im1l\0dlllle Imd prouent dllllBor of 11\1\11111 \fom Iho dothndllnt,
Lnwrono\l UVlln MIIBlIn, tho lbllowlllB Tempornry ardor III ontored,
Thl1 detbndllnt, Lllwrcnoe Ilvlln MII!llln, (S~N:202.40.JI3'J)(POn; 03/22/65), now
rClllllhlB 11\1564 Flllnnont Slreet, PllIsbllrBh, AlleBheny COllnly, I'CmlS)'lvnnlll. la hereby enjoined
ftom physlolllly IIbllalnB Ihe pll1ll1t1n~ PllullI Irene DeCllrlo, \1f Ihll pllrtllls\ minor ehlld, Tllylor
MnBlln, or trom plllolnB Ihemln tbllr of IIbllse,
The dotbndanl Is ordllred 10 stllY IIway O'om tho pllllnllll's resldenee loellled 11\ 1105
,,' p ,
. Yverdoll Drive, ApI, CO, Clllnp Hili, ClIl11borlllnd CounlY, Pel1l1sylvlIlIllI, IIresldenoo whloh Is
,
leased by .Ihe pllllll\ln~ IIl1d Is ordered .to sIlly IIWIlY \fOI11 IIIIY resldenoe the plaintiff may III the
t\llllrc.eslllb\lsh lbr herself, ..
The defcndllnt Is ordered to reftllhl /fom IH\VIIlB IIIIY dlreol orlndlreot 00l1111ot wl,h tho
pllllnlln' Il1ollldlllB, bill 1101 Ihlllled 10, telephol1o, WOllen or third party \l01l111l1l1l10Iltl0I18, . All
00111l11111110lltlollS reBllrdlnB oUSlody of the Pllliles' mll10r ohlld lire to be Inllde throUBh II third llllfty
I11l1tlllllly IIBreed IIpon by Ihe pllrllell 01" throuBh Ihe lJllrtlea' IItlohleys hllndlll1g the 11lI1IIody I11l1ttllr.
I;
il
"
Tho IIOrlll1lhmlln ol~~lnllll Ifom Imma&lna IIml &IIIIklnlllhllpllllnllff IIml Ifmll hllflla&hlll hilI'
" '
rllll\llvoa, nr Ihll Pllrtloa' mlnnr phllll,
Thp Illlflll1lllln\la oruohlolllfom 1l01l1a 10 Iho pllllnlll)1a phloll of 0Il1pI0)'1I1011l, Ihp nallpolnt' .
Iho minor Ilhlhl or Iho Ih\)' ollrll)'lIallll)' oflho mlnol' Ilhlll\,
A vhIlllthlll, Ill' Ihl& Qrll~r mRr all"J~~1 Ihllllllfllllllllrllllll I) IIrl'e&1 I'Illlllr ~~ JlII,C,~,
Q6U~III) II JlrlV1I11l IlrlmlnRl 11",lIpllllnl 11I111"1' ~~ J'R,e,a, Q611~,t, III) " ehllrUllllf Imllrlllll
Ilrlml""l IlpnUlmplllmt"r 13 1'lIt~,S. fi6l HI lmnlal,""I" hr Impl'blll1ll1ll11t IIJlIIl Nil mpnthN
111111 1\ flnellf $1110,1I0.:!ll,OOO,OOI"nll Iv) ~lvl! "lmt"ml',llIIlIler 13 PII,e,S, 96114,1.
ThiN Ordor &hl111 roml1ln 111 offllPI IInlll mmllnod 'or lormhl111011 ,lIy Iho Courllll1d 01111 110
IIKIIIllllod hoyomllla orlllllllll cKplmtlon dlllo lflho Coml nmla Ihlll 11111 Ilofondlln\ hlln opmmlllod 1111
IIcl of I\bllao or hllSOlllllll!\ld In II PlI\lorn or pl'lllIlloo IIml hllllolllos rl&k of hlln11 10 Iho pllllnlllf
lind/or minor Qhlld,
" I'
,Thll Ilcfol1dllnlls orllerlld 10 rollnqul8h 10 Iho &horI0'8 dllpl\rtmonllln)' wOl1pona which ho
pwn8 PI' P08808QII", Illollllllnll, bllll1olllmllod la, II ,44 hlll1dllUI1. hll8 \I80d PI' Ihrolllonlld 10 u8\1.ln
110 1001110111 of IIbu80 1Illllln&llho pllllnlllf. Tho liofondnnl 10 pmhlblllill 11'0m I\oqllhillll or
,
poa8os81ns llIlY 01 her Wllllpnns fur Iho dlll'lIllol1 of Iho ardor lInd 18 roqulrod 10 rolhlq\dllh Ip Iho
8horlff IIny. t1rclIrm IIcc1l180 Iho defol1dlll1ll11l1Y POS8088, Tho dofondlll1l'p wOllporls IIml'Orollml '
,
j .,
lIoon8~ II1l1y be rolurned lit Iho oKplrnllull ilf Iho Proleolloll ardor lItltlr Iha dofondlll1l hus
lIllbmhlod II wrlllon rl'qu08110 Iho COl\rllbr Iho relurn of Ihll WOllpon8 lIoll,tho Court hils nOIIOo~
Ihll plulllllffnflho requesl,,"d I:llvollJhe plllllllllfllll ppportullllY 10 rospond,A oopy oflhls ardor
, "
shnll bo Irnn81111110d to thu ohioI' or hend 01' tho polloo doplIrll1\Ollt of Ih~ POllnsylvllolll Slnl~ Pollllo
(Cllrllslo Dllrrnoks). nnd nllY 01 her nppropllnto pollco dopnrtmol1ts nnd tho shorltf of Alloghony
County,
, '
, I.'
A U~IUNG SHALL PIC HELD ON 'flUS MA TTlUlt ON
,JlJNlC ~, 199", AT , $:<<l p...,m" IN COUltTROOM NO, J-, OF
Tim CUMIIli1IU.ANO COUNTY COURTHOUSE, C!\ltLlSLli:,
Pli:NNSYLV ANIA,
'fho I1I"hllllf 11\,,>, procoel\ wilhout pro"p"YI1\\l"t of I~Il" pOlllllnll1l Ibrlhllr orrler "nilI' the
hOllrlng,
'fhll CUl1\borlnml ellll"Iy ShllrllV" Oepllfl"lIllll ahllll II1\0mpl Ill. mllko lIorvlce III Ihe
pllllllllO'a roquoat lI"d wllhout prll-pllYl1\onll1f fooa, but "orvloo mllY 110 l\collmpllahod umlllr IIny
IIPlll1Cllblo mlo ofclvll Proceduro,
Thl" ordllr ahllll he IlllOkolcl1 ill Iho offico ol'lho Ilrothonlltlll)'"ml IbrwnfllQII to thll ShllnlY .
Ibr aorvlco, TheProthonotllry IIhlllll10l aend II copy ofthlll ardor Illthll dolbnd"nt II}' 1\11111,
The Weat Shore Reglo,,"1 Pollco Oopnrtment ahnll ~o provided with l\ oortllledcopy ofthla
Orrlor hy'the 11111111\10's nt\orney, This ardor allall hO ol1lbrclld by any' Il\w onftwcol1\ent II1l0noy .
whero II vlolntlon occllrs by aITosl tbr Indlrllct crhnlnnl contempt wllhoul WIIIT"nt Ilplln probllblo
enuao IImlthla ardor hilS beon vloll\tod, whether or nol tho vlollltlon la QIll1lmhted 111 tho proaonco
, "
,I .
oflho police officor, In thoevonllhnt 1II1 IIrroslla mndo, under this sCCllon, Iho dotbndn"t ahn\l bo
tllken without unncccssllry delll>' belbro thc COUl'l Ihnt IRsucd Ihe ordcr, Whcn II1lIt court la'
" "
Untwnllnblo, tho dotbndant sllllll bo takon bQlbre the IIPJlrOpt1l1to dlstt1ct jUlI\loo, (23 Jlll,C,S.,
fi6113),
Dy tho Court,
I-.:i
~
, Judgo' ·
"
JOlin Carey
L~GAL SJilRVICICS, INC,
Atlanta)' lbr Plalnllff
~RlJr:capy FROM ReOORD
In J ~~I/rnony \Vllaroor I I hora unto gol nlY hand
~~f9 l~:~ or snld COliI'I III Oarllsle, Pat
a "T;day ~~~'9~:
." <... .. ..' .'J it:
. ,Prolhonota~. "
.",.
MIJI,A 1l\~INIlJ)\ICAm;O,
I'lnlmllf
fill' horaoll' n'n~ 011 \10111111' ofh~r mll1\1r
IJhIlII, 1'A YI;OI\ MAQf..IN,
V,
: IN TIIII C01JI\'I' OF COMMON PLUA& OF
, '
,
: c1JMUUI\LANP COl1NTY, IlgNN~YLVANI^
,
,
: NO, 98.
. CIVIf.. Tl1RM
I,AWIUINCIlUVAN MA01,IN,
Pol\ll1llAn~
,
I
: I'I\OTUCTION J1ROM ADl1SU
,P~TITIO~ FOR I~BOT,ECTION ORDE~ .
RtcWUF UNDli1n '1'1I1i1 PI\O'rIi:CTION Ji'I\OM AnURE AC'f
13 l'Il,C,S. g(lIOI o~ SOil' .
A. AnJ1S~
I, J'ho pllllnllff, I'nlllll Irone DeCArlo, Is IIn 11I11111 Indlvldlllll rosldhm 111110~ Yvordon
..I)rIVe, Api, C8, Cnmp Hili, Cumberlnml Coullly,l'enllsylvllnln 1701 \,
2, Tho delbndlllll, LnwrOnellllvlln Mnslln (SSN: 202.40-3 1 39)(DOU: 03/22/65), Is
IIn ndlllllndlvldulIl residing n\ 1564 Flllnnonl Slroet, I'lltaburah, AHesh\lfW Coun~YI Pennsylvlmln
\5221,
3, The dolbndlll1\ Is the Ibrmer husbllnd ot'the pllllnllffllnd Ihe fulher ot'the pnrllos' 8-
yenr old son, Tnylor Mnslln,
.1'
4, Since IIpproxlmlltoly \996, Ihe delbndnnl hila nltelllllled 10 onllall IInd hilS
In~entlonlllly. knowingly. or rcoldessly enURed bodHy hllllry to the pll\lntlff, hns c9.mmllted soxulIl .
. IIssnult or. hwoluntnry devlAlo soxuallntercours\l, hilS fulaely hnprlsoncd th\l plnlntlff pUrRllal11 I~
18 [III, C,S, ft 2903, hnsl1hyslcAlly nbllaed the pnrtles' minor child, hnsl1lAced the plnlntlff nnd the
I' '
child In rensonnblo fonr of Imminent sorlous bodily Injury. nnd hns knowlnBly ongnBod In II ~oursll
. '
of conduct or repontcdly conimlttod IIcts townrd tho pllllntlff nnd/or tho minor ohlld Including .'
fullowlns the pllllntlff nnd/or tho ohlld, without proper nuthorlzatlon. lindoI' clroumstnnces which
hAve plncod the plAintiff nnd/llr the child In rensonnble fenr llfbodlly Injury, . This lins Included, but
la notlhnlled to, tho Ibllowlnllspcelfic Instuncos 01' "buse:
i
..,
"
:1'
"
!
-, ;
i';'"
I',
"
n) On Qr R~O\l\ MIIY ~~, 19!JR, lhl:' !11l1i'mlllnl hplll 1\ IIMPhnll hnt oVllr hIs
ahp\llllll~ IIml Ihrlllllllnp!1 Ihll 1lllllntllT allYhlll, "I sholllll hll YIl\! wllh Ihls." Thll
plnllllllT fllRrlll1 for h~r slIfllly, .
"II "I'
h) Pn or 1I!l1l11l MIIY, a, 199a, Ihllllllfllmhlll\ Ilfllbhl:'lllhllpllrlllla' a.yllRr pl!1
SPI\ I'y Ihllllrm, IlfflBlllll1 him IIcross Iho slroo" ShPVlll1 him 11110 Iho Cllr, IIml alllll,
"No Illlllla BPlnlllo IIlIl mil wholllllld whllrll . Illln IlIkll my ohllll," 1I\l11 dmvp IIWIIY,
c) .. 011 nr 111111111 MIIY 7, 1998, IhopllllnlllT rlllllnllld hpmlllll find Ihe dlllllllllllnt
wnlllnB. fur hilI' 1lI1\alllo hilI' IIpllrlmlll1l, Whlln Ihe pllIllIlIlf Wllnt Ilpallllrs I~hor
IIpllfllllonl, Ihll dllfllndllnl followlld hor Inlo hor IIpllrlmlllll dll8pltll hilI' tllllhm him
,. ., , "
1101 In cOllloln, pllsh\lI\lhe door npllll. IInd wlllkllllln,
II) 011 or IIbOll1 April ~J, 19\>8, Iho delbndllnlllllllllllo tho pllIll1lllT'a fllsll\onllll, . "
IIrllllod with hOf, IIlld lhrolllonPl1 hor plnlnlilf 8l1yllla. "f'lI bo rid of yo II 800n:11 1I1lI1.
I,
Ihrol\lell()d her ftielld, "J0810, 8l1ylnB, "Alld YOII're dOIlO, too." The dofblldllllt
Bfflbbed 1'lIylol' by Iho 1If111, dmBBe!1 him down' J I1IBhlS of 8\1111'8 ImllmalizlnB Iho
ohll!l, IInd shoved him Inlo tho 0111',
e) ,011 or IlllOlll Ap,,1 20, 199R, Iho d()flll\llilnl alnpppd Tnylol',repllllledly IIbOlIl
. hl8 bllllooks onll8hlB him 10 0111 on !holloor, IInd liS thollhlldlllY onthelloor HIll
dcfundlln! kicked him sevllrl\IIIm08 IIbol\l hlsleBs,
t) . On or IIbolll April IS, 1998, Ihe pllllnllff hosled II blrthdllY plll'IY nnd sl,oop,
oVllr till' hilI' SOil, Invltod IIppl'ol<hnlllely 20 ohlldl'en, nnd Invited the defblldnhl to
Iho blrthdllY pllrly, The defendllnl Ibllowod Iho pllllnlll1' l!llo har bedroom, lookod
\110 door d()spllu her ploRs fur hlllllo 101lVO, lold her, "Vou will hllve So)( wllh mal :
YOll'I'o Illy wlfel you'll RlwllYS bo Illy wllb," (Tho pRrtlos hRyo beon dlvoroed slnol! .
1993,) Tho delbndnnt rlpped Iho IllRlntllT's clothlulJ off. Ihrow her onto Ihe'bed, '
" .I'
"
"
, '
,Ii
IJrnllll~ll hol' 11011, 10111 hol' In homl PVlll' h\1ol\lI&1I hllWII& 8olnlllollll hill' wllh II, 111111
BlIlll\\llIY 1\&&1\11111111 hill',
g) III or I\bm" Olllohlll' 1997, whllllllrlvlnB Ihollllr, Ihll IIl1fomlllnllll'lIll\1~lllho
pllllnllfT \Iy 11111 hl\lr, YIIII~o\1 hol' h01l11 bl\llk IInll fpl1h &lIvllrl\l Ih11I1B 1)1111&11111 111\1
pllllnllfT Ip IIl&1l ohllnp8 Ilf hiliI', IInll \lnnBIlII hill' hlllll\ IIBlIll1sllhll I\lIsh\lPllrI\, AB II
I'IIPI,l\ Ilf Ihlll 1I101ll\ll111hll plllll1llfT B\l81111nlll\ bml81nlllll111 BIlI'lll1llSS on hill' lbl'llhlllll\,
I1l1d hOlldllQhllB,
"
h) In Ill' I\bo\lt I\IIBIIs11997, IIIIl Iloflll1ll~)lI pllphcl\ 11I1l pll\ll1llfTlIB Bhll BIPml'oll
IhlllllndlnB.of 1\ 811\11'01\80 01l1l81na hill' III slllll1\1lo IlpWII B11111'8,
I) On Ill' I\bolll July 4, 1997,Ihllllelbmll\I\I Olllllld Iho plllll1ll1l'1\ whore, shil,
"
1\111\ nlhol' 1IIII1IIIIIIIInB 1111111011 In Iho Pl'llSllnOO oflholr child Imd rQPllllll.ldly slmok hill' "
, '
In Ihll neok wllhll slick, IIRlna 1\ Blllbblnll mollon, 'fhll pll1hllllf.8l1sllllnlld rlld m\lr~8
\lnd aOl'0110SS IIbolll hol' neck liS \l roaull of Ihl& 1110111onl.
,j) In or IIbollt}lIno 1997, Iho 1\0fonl\IInl !lrl\b\lol\ Iho pl\lhllllf by hol' 111'111, '
~h\ml11lld hor \lBlllnal Iho wlIlI, 111111 plIBhci! \lBolnsl her ollost 10 ~Ollp horlfo,"
, "
lellvhl!l,
k) Slneo IIpproKhlll1lllly 1996, Iho Ilo.lol1l\onl hll" \lbllsel\ thll phllnllff Inwl1Ys
'., .,
InollldlnB, bllll10t IImllol\ 10, ollllll1B hor hlll11111111111B nll\llllS In tho prosonoo of Iholr
Qhlld IIlId III pllbllol shovll1!lllnd Bmbhlll!! hor. pllllhl!l hor hiliI'. roslrnlnlng hor, nntl
sllKUlllly \lssl\ult\ng her, In IIddllioll, Iho dol\llldl\lIt hilS ropenledly gone 10 tho
pllllntllrB rosldollcu ulllnvlted IIl1d ,10 hor pIneo of employment (nn Qlel11ontal)'
schoo\), Ho hllB lolephonod her realdence sovernl thuos II dny, tolophoned the
suhool whero ahe tellohes sovernl thlles telling the school slnlf thM Ihere wns IIn
Oll1or!lolley Just to got horto apollk to hIm. ~nd telephollod hor tliends to dolol11\llIo
her wherenbOllla, The del'cndllllt hila repolltedly shoved, !lrl1bbed, klckod. slllPPOl\,
"
, If
"
drnllll\ld, !lOll !mlllo Ihl'llllla 10 Iho plIrllllQ' milloI' ohllll, 'f!lr1or, QIIllh !la 1\11111111 him
111111 h\1 wonlll aoml him 10 "kl\P Q JIIII" nmllll!lvl1 him Ihllro, IlIIllQ11I1I1I111 phllll \0 111l..
" 'I
Irlllll\\lIllzell, Thll plnlllllll'OIIlII II Jlrollllllloll From AbU"o I\II\lon 1I11!1h1S1 Ihe
lllllpmlnnl In Pnllphln CO\II\IY (No, ~a2Hl.o~) lIml III AlIllllhllllr C\llInly In Ill'
, I' "
IIbnu\ 1 QI) \,
5, Thll pllllmlll' hollllvoR "nd Ihol'lIfllrllllV\lrS Ihlll 8hllllmllhll Pllr1108' minor chilli 111'\1
,
III Iml\\odllllo IInd pr\l80nl dnllllllr (If IIhllsO lToll\ Iho dol\llldlllll lInd 111lI1 Ihoy !Ire III neod of
" prolecllon Ilom 8ullh IIb\lQIl,.
6, The! pllllnllll' dll81r08 Ilml Iho Ilolbmlllnl ho pl'llhlblllld Ilom hllvlllllllny ,111'001 or
Indlroot oonlllOI wllh Ihll, llllllnllll' Inolmllll!!, bUI. nlll Ihlllloll to, lolophono IInd wrlllllll
QOll\Il\IIIIIolllloll8111 her rosldllll~O, pllloo ofelllploymllnlornny olhllr loolltlon, ~U \Iomm\lI\lcnllo~fl
I ,rollllrdlnll o\l8101ly oflho, p"rtlos' millOI' ohllllllrll to ho 11I11110 Ihm\tsh II third Pllfty mulllnlly nllreod'
\lpon by Iho pnrlllls or Ihrollllh Iho plI\1111"' nllofl\lIys hllndllll!! Iho o\l810(\Y Il1l1l1er,
"
." Tho plnlnllll'doslnls Ihllllho Ilofondllnl bo ol\lolnod !rom hllfllsslllllllnd 81111klllS Iho
'.. plllllllllf, IInd trom hllrAssllI1l her rolnllv08, or thlll\\llIor ohlld,
0, 'Tho pllllnllll' d081roslhnllhll d\llbndnnl bo r081rnlllod ffom !!olIlY to hor pllloo of
omploymonl;the sohool oflho minor ohlld or IhedllY OAro filollhy ~flhe millOI' ohlld,
9, Tho plnlntlff doslros thnt IIny WCIIJlo\lRtho dolbl\(llInt OW\lS or possosses h10ludln!!,
f ' <,
butl10t Ihllltod to, n ,44 hlllldgun, bo QonOsolllod by the Shonll'a Dopllrtmont IIl1d thnt Iho
" " ,
dolbndnnt bo prohlbltod !rom lIequlrlnll or J108Ros81nB nllY WOnpOIlA lbr Iho dumUoII \If tho
, ,
Proleptlon ardor,
10, Tho rosldo\loo loonted .I\t 11 OS Vvordon PrlVll, Ap\. CB, Cllmp 11111,. CUlI\borln!ld
COUllly, Ponnsylvnnlll, ffol\l whloli tho \lllIlntll1' 18 \lakhl!! tho COIlt! to ordor IhD dlllbndilllt 10 atay.
'..
"
'''1''
, ,
"
5, OnierlllB Ihe llllfenlhmll\l 'RIllY IIWIIY li'Plll Ihll plllll\lll1'lI rORllhlflllU
\\l\lllled III IIOS YVllnlpl1 Drive, /\pI, C", cllmp 11\11, Cumhllrlllllll {)IlIlI1lY,
PeilllRY\VIlI1II1, whlph Ihll PllfllPR hllVII nUVllr Rhl\fllll, 1111I1 III1Y f\lshlllll\lll Ihe
, ,
plllhlllff'mllY Il1lho I\lIl1re I,1Rlnhllah IIII' horKPIt'.
6, Onlenl1a IhllllllflllHllIOllo rellol\IlIRh III Ihp Khurln'K II\lpllrhllul\IIII1Y
WellppnR whlph hu ownR or PIlRR\lKROR Il1l1hlllll1!!, hilI 111111111I11011 Ill, II .44
hllmllll\n, nod prohlll\lInB Ihp lIel\l11lhllll ll'IlIllI\lIlllIlrh11lllr IIIIRSIl"Rlo~ IIIIY
WIlnpon8 1'01' Ihe dllfllllllO Ill' Iho 'l'U1l1pllrary 1'1'1111111111111 Ordllr.
P, Schodlllo II heRring In IIcCllrd"ntlf! wllh ,U,,' Ilrllvl~lolI' 01' 1111'
Ill"'oloc\lon f)'UIII I\IIIIRC 1\111," ,,,,d, "l'I.,r RIIIII1 I11111rln8, elltllr "" nnlllr III \Ill
1"lllTecl flll'R Jlerloll of onll yell 1'1
"
I, OnlprlofJ .tlm lIe!bmlanl \!l retrain 1\'0111 ahllRlnQ Iho plalnllff'lIolI/pr
Ihe minor ohllll or lfom plnoln!! Ihenlln !bPI' IlfllhIlR\l,
2, Ordenng Ihe delcnllnnllo rofraln thllnlmvlnB any dlreol or Indlreul.
0111\11101 wllh Iho plnlnlllT Inoll\lIlnll. bill nlllllmlted Ill, 1\llophooo, ,...rlllen or
Ihlrll \lOfly oommlll1101l1l0118 a\ hor rllRIIlonoo, 'plaoo ofll1l1111nymonl or IIny
olhor loollllon, 111 oommunlOllllllnR rOllarlllnll OIlRllldy of Iho I1l\nloR' minor
01\1111 01'0 10 bo II1l1do Ihrough n Ihll'lI plll'IY 1I1\11111llly 1I1lrooll UpOIl by Iho
, , '
parll08 or Ihrough Ihe par\l\lR' nllnrlloyK lllllllllllll:llho llURlody malloI', "
3, Ordorln!llho 1I0lbndlllll III roll'lIhl lhlln hal'llnlllll and RllIlkllllllho
plallltU\' and trolll hnrllRKlnll hol' rchlllvllR nnll Iho II1hlor ohlld" '
4, (lrtlhlhltlllll Ihu 1I1llulIltllnllh1h1 llollI!! III Iho 1llllllllll1'R plaqo of
employmenl, IhoROhlll" 1I1'lho mhll11' ohllll, 111' Iho day 0111'0 flIolllly of Iho
I\llnllr chlld,
,I
'I'.;'
"II
"
: ,.:
,t
.
,
~, Pnlprln~ Iho dofondl\ollo flln~ IIWIIY Itllll1 Iho plnhlllffn r~sldlln\lP
locRllla .fII110S Yvorcloo Prlve, Api, CPt Cnmp '-1111, ClIl1lh~rhmd COllOIY,
. flonns~lv~nln, whl\lh IhOPllrlIllS 11I\V!l OOVllr 8hllr~ll, nO\llIn~ rllslll!lnc!l Ih~
plnlmlff mny In 1110 l\lIl1ro I)slnbUsh fpr h~rflolf,
6, Ordprln~ Iho llofpmlllnllo rpUnqlllsll to IIlp flh\lrlfl1flllllpnrtmonlnny
WI,lnppn8 whlllh ho o~nfl or pOfl80~80S Inol\ldhl!l, Imt 001 IImlloll IP, II ,44..
111I11\18\1n. 111\11 ,prohlhllln8 tllP Ilelbodll1l\ ltom IIcq\llrln!l or pos8\1ssln8 IIny
. wOllponn lpr Iho. dllmlloo of Iho I'role\lllon Ord~r,
7. Ordllrln!llho llofoodllnl.lo plly $ZSO,OO 10.C\lmborllll\ll COllllly, 000
of tOf,l1l1 S~fVl\lP8, In\l, 'fl fundln8 AOllrctls, 118 rplmbllrnomonl for Iho coft! of
,
11I1f,lnllng Ihls IlIlBO, 1I11\IIIssOnsl08 Iho $Zs,OO surllhllrgo 1I0d \lq~'rt \l0818 10 .
Ihl' dotbl1lhlllllflho ollso 800810 hOllrlnB,
Tho pllllillllfll'rthor IIS~S 1I11111hls PoUllon boOlpd nod,sorved wllhout pllymont ofl\l08l1nd
OOSt8 h~ Ihe. pllllnlltf, pending II lllrlhor of\lor lit tho I1l1llrlnB, IInd thlllll oprtll1pd\lop)' of' Ihls
. Pelltlon nnd Ordorbe doUvered 10 tho WOBI Shoro Roglonllt flollllo Popllrtmont whloh hils.
. jurlsdlo!lolllQ onlPrco this Ordor,
Tho plllhlUIf prn~s fur such olhor reUef liS mil)' bo jllsl nnd propor,
llespooll\\lIy SUbllllllod,
~L('
.'
JOlin ClIro
l'hlllpC, BrlslIlltl
Attorneys Ibr Pllllntllf
LEGAL SEUVICES. INC,
8 Irvlno RoW
Cllrllsle, PA 17013
(717) 243.9400
~
"
I I
., Pnla: \'5"'c2 '1-2i.--
Tha npI1V\l-nIlIlWd plnllllllf, I'nllln If\lllt) J)IICIIIIIl, V\lllthlK lhulUIII n!lIl\lIl\IIn1" 1II111,lu 111 !hll
nbpV\l pallllon lira Inlll IInll \lOITIIII\, 'I'hll plnlnllll' IIl11hlllllllllllK 11"'1 I)IIKII nlnllllllllnlH h\lr\lln nfll
mll~\l ""bJ\l\lIIO Ih\ll'\lnlllll\l" Ill' I" 1'11,(;,&, ti41Jl)o\ 1I11111lnu In Ill\nWnf!l I)IIII1I111nllllll 10 11I11" rlllll", "
".)~ ') , ~.
'i/-fJ' " ',';,' /~ (.';, ..-
~~~{l(l ,(j.J..~L(, ,dr.....1 "r; 1((..,,;u
I'nlllllllonlll>lICIII11" ,'t~i111' -
., "
.'
"
"
"
,
"
j' "
;\
,. ..
.'
" ..
, ,
"
"
it
"
"
"
11
" '
,.,
II I>
"
.,
"
"
,.
.' ,
, "
" ,f
" ..
'I. ,
.'
"
;;
",
"
"
I"
,:l~'
liil
(/0"
;,I,~
,
"
"
"
i,"
"
'I
"'1
I'
"
,
I' I<
"
"
","
"
,
"
"
!I
,11
"
"
;.I,
I'
I'
)1
III.FI'i OF\'ICH
OF 11 Ii" I' "'(Ii i.I 'OTI,IW
~A ,1\11111.1 f,;\ HI fill
CUMiiHHiJj ),1 tfJUI'I1Y
, I'I:NI'~(iYI 'I!\\II,~,
I'
I'
II
"
"
,
" " ,
,;
d'
d,
"
I'
I'
Ii
"
Ii
"
,
,"
"
"
Ii,
I" '.'-
ii'
"
"
of
T.
II
II"
,}\
",
Ii
"
W\lJlJI\ rJWNEJ DeCARLO, ,.
I?lA,i,n\:iC~'
rp~ her~elf An~ on behAlf
or herl11!nor chil~, TAylpr
MAulin
:m 'rum COUWl' 011 COMMON PlJjUAB 01"
ClJM131UIUJI\NP CO\1N'~'Y, I?(UNNf3yrNl\NII\
, v,
00-2DO~ CIYI~ TmRM
lJ1\WIWNOIil mV1\N MAOr.,IN,.
Det:enqAn\:
,,'
I'IW'l'IilC'l'ION 1~lwM lIB\1I3IU '
. TN RIQ, 11'EJMIJOI~TlRYI'RO'1'lUO'~ll0N olwml" '1'0 RIUMI\IN IN lW!"liJC'I'
QRl2lilH 011 OQ.l!ltl:
TlNP NOW, this 6tH dAY of allne, lODO, upon
Qonl3iclerAt!on ot: Pl,qj,n\:Ht:'13 l?e\:il:ion t:or I:>ro\:eo\:ion Orcle:r, Olnd
following a hearing a\: whioh bo\:h oounl3el feel they hAve not hA~
.' l3uffioient: t:\me t:o prel3ent: \:he,tr Oal3es, t:he l"edol-d I3h<lll r.em.dll
" .
open, ancl t:he Gourt W~ll reoonvene .on Friday, JUly 31, 1098, at
1,30 P till" for the 0,01)01 \113 ion of the hear:\.ng i lit that time, t:he
~lAintiff will be I\ffordeq one hour withili. whioh to oonoltlde her'
oa~e, I\nd the Dellend<mt will be aCfOl"ded two hO\n:'13 within wh.ioh
~o prf.3l3ent hil3 OAl3e,
Pending the additional period of.hear1ng and
"
"
,
further Order.of Court, the Temporary l?roteotion Order I3hall
remAin in full foroe and,effeo~,
It il3 not:ed that at the time of "adj Olll"nment on
thil3 date the l?lalntiff Waa bei~g aubjeoted to oroal3"examination
d~\ring the P1Aintiff'a oaae-in-ohi'ef by De.t!f'mdant'a oounael, It
. ia noted further that: Plaintiff'l3 mxhib!t 1 (pajamaa) had been
iqent!f:\ed and admitted,
,',
Joan Cal"ey,
Counl3el for
,lllrs
maquire E I
Pldnl:ifj .
By the COlll:,t ,,,'
. /') ;/
t./ / / /' ':. , ~
/C/ /' / /
""' ,.".. .'. -
Wea1,sy Ot~J;',( Jr I , .'~ , .
"7/1,,, I; "- fg~~~:~: :~~p~:; :~~i~~'h
{~ If. fJ r
Jtls
," J
,CORRECTION,'
, .. ' "" "
" ,,:"
"
'" "
J" '
.-' .,.
I . "
\
1
I '-,
) ., I
,. I ' .'
I
~ "
. I
\
,J '
.,
"
I
-,}
j'
"
i\'
,
.... Previous Image
Refilmed to Co,rrect.
Possible. Error"
"
,,'
"
I,
"
"
'"
.,"
"I'
Ij
"
,
"
"
t ' i ~
ii
Ii "
/,.,
(,
r'
"
V)
",."
f~'-l
"
"
"
,;"
'J
,- <::)
~
QJ
~
"
"
1\'
", "
,
'L
',"':.i
"
"
II.
"
""
"
;i'
;,
-d
"
,';
\__t..
'*
tji.'lil
,:
if/',
;~t ~
i'I'
\i:
'j
::'iJ
LV
","J:tl:
,(/1
//ll
II',
" i:~
:~
';';11
"~I
"';~
:'!
.):1',:;:-1
: ,,~,
-'::/1
II'"
','
"
,I
"
i
I'
"
I'",,,11!,
......,;,yr
. ,I.
."J
I;':
if
! '
"
'i
--,({
",',!\
,;",'"
,;'1(1
}'I
"!",,,:I)l~
.,,_.t
i' ~ 1;'
,_;>,JI
;:,;__~';:~{1
",I~
'~:~
'11'il
;;-:;f:_j,;,~
!\~)
",'"
,"i,
:"},!l,
: ,,\i~
"~flJ
:,:J
nlt,
"~Ii~\l
11'
, ;/fi
"I
It*,
,i ~J
<,'I.
('
\ ~...
~.
,
"
"
"
~.
'''-t:o
~
~i!.
<:"""\'
"
J',I
"
;p';
I'
H
" "
;'
!,oj
,
in
it
"
,,' I' "',
.'
rilU~~ J?ePilRlPt
, , ~~Ain~~ff/r~titipn~~'
Vll,
I XN wlm COUR'~' Ph' COMMON' rLMS Ol"
I C\J~1ElrellLflNP COUN'l'Y I rIJ:NNSYf.NANI/\
,
, NO, ~7~5BOO, OIVIL ~reRM
,
I OIVlf., fla~'IOl'l ... ~iI\'/
I c\JS'~'OPY
LAWR~O~ MilGLINI
Pefan>'1l1n\:/l~a!lponqan~
p.,.
,"
ORPIm ow mJR'l'
, 111m ~I,~hill ~ qllY of(\~~_. , 199B, \.lpon
OOlW!qa!iation of \:h~ a1i~cua\:oqy ~iit!\':ln Rapp~t, it is o!:c1a!:'eq
anc1 Cli!:,ao\;aq all fbUowl'l' '
1. /I, lieA!:'ing il3 !lohequlaq in CO>l!:'\; Room No, --':1,- _f of the
C\.lmbal:'~lInq CO\.lnt:y Court llousa, on the 11th day of. saPt:a~W8, at: 9,30
a.m" a~ whioh time t:el'l\;imony will Pe t:aken in thil3 CII!le, l~ol:' pu!:'pp!lall of
t:hill lIell!:,il1\), t:he Fathel:' !lha11 pa c1eemac1 to l:>a tha moving pat-ty anCl Ilhal~
pt-ooaaCl initillllywith tastil\1ony, CaLlnsal fol:' ~he P<\1:'\:iell Ilhlll~ fill'! with
t:he CO\.lI:'\: IInd oppalling counsel II Memoranc1\.l111 ,9att;l.ng j;orth allch PIII:'\:Y'13
pol3it!on on CLlI3t1Pc1y, a ;List: of \~itl1fJl3l3a,9 who wUl Pe c!\l1e~1 to \Jel3~ify !\t;
tha lIallL"ing, and II I3UlTll1!lJ:Y of the antioip<\tac1 testimony of aaoh wit:nel3l3.
These Namorllnd!\ shll11 Pe fileCl at leas~ ~en (10) days pdot" to the lielll:'ing
, Clllte,
"
,
2. 'l'he P<\l:'tiell I3ha11 coopel:'ate in compleUon of the ongoing cQstody
, evalQat:ion baing performed by Pr. stan~ey SchneiClal:',
3. PenCl;!.ng fQrthel:' Orc1et- of Court O~" ag~"eameht of ~\1epartiest the
Father shall have OQs\;ody of tha, chi;Ld ft-om Jqly 9, 1998, at 3,00 p.m,
thl:'ough .:rUly 30/ 199B, Elt 6,00 p.m., and fl:'om August 11, 1998, at 6,00 p.m.
\.lnti! August: 20, 1990, fit 6100 p.m. The ~lothar shall have cQBt:ody oj; the
Child at fill timell hot, othel:Wiae speoified fol:' Fathet;'" '1'he Fllthet-' s
pel:'iods 01; partial custPc1y upon twenty"four (24) hours not:ice I\S proviCll;ld
undel:' pcIragraph 3 of tha pcIrtiea t Stip\.llation daueCl Narch 20, 1998 flnc1
entet"ec'l ElS an Ordat- of Court on Naroh 23, 1990 ahall Pe sl1eJpendacl pending
fUt-thet-, Ordal;' of COUt-t. "
II. Fol:' the pl:'otect!on of both the Father. and the Nother, the parties.
"ha11 exoh/lllge custody of 'the Child at tha St:ate Police bat "racks in
Daclford, pennsylvania, for all exohangas uhder thill Order with the exoaption
of tha exohange to ooour oh July 9, l~98, at 310b l).m. which shall OCOll1:', at
the State Police bat "racks in cal:'lisle, Pennsylvania. ' "
5. DUdng his ot- her pedods of custody, each p<\t"ty shall insul:'a that:
the Child cohtaots the nO\1cuatodial pat"ent by telephone on MondaYs I
Wednas\'lays and Fridaya lit approximately 6100 P.m. ;tn tl)e ('Veht the Child
is ullable to t-eaoh the nonoustodial pal:'ent at the Bt,>eoified tima" the
noncustodial I?arent Ct" II thir(~ patt:y on the parent's behalf. may retut"h the
Child I a telephone call. '
"I
,
I'
,'\
, ,
PA\JW\ peOl\Rl,D, ,. ..
. N~tntttM)Ii\:i\:tonElf
VII,
J'../lW1l1l;N91!l Ml\oI;IN, . . .'
pe~Qn~~nt/llli/lpondan\:
I IN TWllCOI1R'l1 Oli', ~ON Pljllll\S (.)l"
I ClJMI3lJl1lH/lMP ~I l"lmml3~J'..VI\NII\
I
I . NO, 97,,~P90 OIV~I; 'l'Jl:IlN
,
I PIV:U~ /lC1,l'ION " r./I\i
I CUI3',fOD~
ii
"'JU:~ ~I Rav!n fl. lleSll
ctJ.S'fOm!' cx:wn.IAT1c:ti ~RY REPOO'J)
Iti. ^CXXJ10J\~ mwu ~t.l\WO <nJlfl'Y nur.lJl . OF ory-u. PROOIIDURlJl
;1.\315,3-8, \:Ile \.IIldel:'lli~neCl CuIil\\oCIy Conoi11li1tpl." liI\lbmi\:/I tile followin\l .epar-\:I,
1, The pel:'\:inen\: 1n1:o+111a\:ion Qonoel;'nill9 \:he Child who ilil \:he
/I\.Ibjeo\: !;If. \:111/1 11\:igl\\:ion ~s ~s 1:OUOWIiII .
'"
C\1ild'liI Nama
S. '.l'ay;!.ol;' Mag;l.in
!!!!te of nil:'\:.h
lip!;'!;!. 7, 19\30
In Ous\:ody of
Motile!;'
~, II Cono!Ha\:ion Conferenpe was hel~ on JU;J.y 8, ;1.998, wit:h
t:he 1:o;l.lowing individlla;J.1l in 1iIt:\:endanoel '1'he Mothel:', P!l\lla peC!j):'lo, wit:h
. he):' oounlilel/ MliIl:'oue A, Mollnight:, III, J;JIiICJuil:'el and t:he\,at:he):', I.aWl:'enoe
Maglin, wi\:h hil3 collnee;!., l3at'pal:'a S\.ll11ple-s\.lllivan, Ii1sCJ\.Ii,e,
.' 3, 'Thie oal3e involves oomp;Lioatec1 il3l3ues !lnd a Oll/l\:oCIy'
evaluat:ton i$ o\lI;,rE!ntly being Qonduot:eq, Py Pro stanley Sohneide):'.
lIooor.cUng \:0 \:.he f'ather, Dr. sohneidel:' hal3 I:'EKJUesl;ed t:hat t:he Ji'athel:' spend
an ellt:ended pel:'iod of \:ime with the Chi;I.d Pafore obtaining,observf\tions of
the ll'athe,-Child.. relat:ionl3hip. The pal;"ties agl:'ee to ooopel:'ll\:e in
oomp;!.eting the evaluation'so that 01:'. sohneideL; Clln submit his repol:'t pdol:'
to the llearing llohed111ed in september.
4, lit \:he time of the Confet;'enoe, th,ee petiticms eoI:' contempt'
and two Speoial Ilelief 'PeUtions were pending, Both tl!l!;'ties ag!;'eeQ \;0
W1thdL"l!\w thaiI:' l>euitions fOI:' Spe01A;I. Relief and t:o reserve theil:' l:'ight/3 to
prasent; Any of the issues !;,Elisac'l in theh- !;'eapeotive ContelllPt Petitions, . if
naoe/3ssty, all t:heSepteinber neAring.
5, The parties wel:'e able t:o agl;'ee on tllmpol:'ary oustody
arl:'angaments pending the Ilear;l.ng ana completion of uheoustody evaluation.
nowever, it i/3 nece/leaty to sohedule a Nearing in thil3 tnatt;e~' uo addl:'ess
the J.l'st:hel:"s raCJuest fo!;' transfel:' of pdmary physical oUatody of the child.
1\0 him as Well as the Contelnpll issues I:'abed by both, p!\l:'ties.
6, '1'he Nothel:'ls position on ollstody is as . follows 1 '1'he MotheL'
al.leges that the J)'ahher hall violated t:he eldsting Custody Otdel:'a by
,
rJA\J~A p~CAR~O,
f'luln\lff
IN Tl-H: courn or COMMON PI.~AS
CUMf3~n~ANQ COUNTY, I'~NNSY\- VANIA
v,
I
I . NO, 97.1i1380
I
I CIVI~ ACTION - I.AW
I IN CUSTOPY
"
~AWRRNOr: MAO~IN,
Qflfand U III
Q.Ji.1l11flQ AT r: 0 F S 1i1W.l!lG.
1,.John J, Connolly, Jr" r:squlro,lll JOlllOS, 6mlth, Purl\ln & Connolly, llttornoy
I . ' .
for the f'lillntlff, PE1LIIQ peCnrlo,horohy oortlly tlHlt I Iwve aorvad fiOOPy 0',1110
..
foregolno Order and f'o\I\ICln for Contol11pt of ClIstlldy Ordor on t110 Iqllowlno on tho
date find In tl1(3. 1110nno(' Inc1loutod hulow!
llJLML\I1.J:LBST 0 LA sa.. P AI: - P A LQ
"
13mhara Slll11plo-SulllvOI1, r:squlro
1i48 I3rldgo Stroot ..
Now CL'l!llhorlllncl, PA 17070-1831
bATEI4d~~
'-0' ~..,.,
,.
I'
',.
,.
L
,.
,.
,. , I ,
,
I'
"
"
" Ii'
"
'I,
I'
',I,"
"
"
,
,
,
","
"
,.
"
,.
'i:
,.
:'1,
:',
.,
/1'
nXHIBI
,.
"
";
,.
"
I',
'I, t.
,..
"
I,
T ^
]'1
Ii'
,.1\
. ;.
,.
Ii
,/
,.
I.
,.
,.
"
I' ",
!C1'
'I! "oI' "1",'
,.
,.
"i'I'
I'"~
"
"
,.
J' I'
"
'I
"
,.
w
"
"
'11',
,~ '
"
,/
, ..
MAR ~ 0 19~8 fP
, I,
f'
"I
MULA PJJ;CAj~LO,
Plnlmlff
1 1!'l1'H(': COlJ1\'fOF COMMON PLEA,s
I C1JMDlrRLA!'ID CO UN'l'Y , p~l'lN\'lnVA!'ITA
vs,
,
,
I CIYIL AC'l'ION L.A W
~A WREl'ICE MAGLl!'l, ..
Po(omiqm
,
,
I NO, 97-5890 CIY1L
I Ql1,s'l'OPY
Oreler
~:'Jf1t.l
And NOWlhl&lldAY qf MAroh, \998, \lpon oonslcleru(lonof the Stlp\IIAllon of lha.
PAlites' P"\IIn Doo"rlo "nd I.,uwranoa MAglln, d~Heel Maroh 20, \998, ~njcl Sltpul"t1on Is he'reby .
, ,
rhAele nnOrcler of Court,
"
"
"
IS! 'i{;{..,l....-t~~
~evln A.. Hess, J,
"
','
"
"
TRUU CfW( PROM RECORD
In Testlm'\;r.. ".1 .1, I :~ .." Imt" $':1 my hand
srld the ~oi\1 oi '" '.i ,:jIJri "I CMlIsl~, Pa,
. i\Ll. . el' S-
This "",~.3."". du'l oiJthJ"~~"',,, 1.9.., ""
......~~.~..;J.~Jr.~~r..a".'"r;A.~1<f,!,/".,.,,,..~....
. . cZiti Prothonotary
i
I
. i
I
I
,.
,"' ~1' "...,u". .~ .., " ,.
,.,
, ,
P 1\ UL.t\ 0 !r~I\!lLO i
'PI~lmlff
V~,
I IN 1'1~E COURT OF. ~OMMON PJ.IlAIl
: cUMBgnL,~ND COUN1'Y, PENNSYI..V/\NIA
: c\V1L AC1'ION L.A W
I NO, 97.5890 ClV1L..
: CUS'fODY
I.. A WRE!,/CE MAOLIN,
De (en~nm
S'flPULATIO!,/
AND NOW THIS day of.MAroh, 1998, (hll pnnlos, PaIJln DOOlIl'lo, PIAlmlff IInel
.,
LAwrenoeMllslln, Defendnm, do agree AS follow&l.
,.
t)Penqlng oOlnlllollon of the ouslody evalUlllion of Dr, Stllnley So/melder, as Is
l'eg4lre~ pursllantto the Ordor of Tho Honorable Judgo Kevin Hess daled DeoelTI/le,~ 24, 1997,
"
"
2) . Referoncing Iho ivookend sohedllle (or January, 1998, It Is speolally 1I0tnd that
. tvfother, Paula DeCarlo, shnll have oustody on the. weekend ofJanllary 9, 10, and 11. Father,
Lawrence Maglln, shall have custody on two consecutivo weekends of January 16, 17 andI8,
199a And Jnnuury ~3, 24, unci 25,1998, ThereaflOr, lhe weekends shall elterna'le betWeell the
pat'tles with tvr'othol' huvlng oustody on the weokend of Jt1nuary 30, 31 and FobnJary I, 1998 and
eVery olhol' woekend Iherenftor and Father havo oustody on Fe/lrunry 6,7, and 8,1998 and every.
"
.,
,.
. ,,\l.:.:.t'"~l''' :':L~...'l:t;:i.:'i:::.-~'.::~~l:.;"
il"
, . -. .
. ,_..l:~:.~~,....:~;~.~.;,....~____,~'~':.::.r-,'F~;': ;,~. .~....
"
..~
(,
J~
'., f"
rn 'l'ImqpPW\) OJ? qolftlPti Pl'.<1i1j\A OF ~T4.J;j(lJ.rntf'l c:qQliW'l, IlEtftf(:l'l:r..vMf:J:?l,
~\ffilJlllOI1l I-iMUiI:lf / ) ~A,l<III,~ p:tV:J:~+Oll
)
l?~i\j,n1;;j.f.f, ) V'P90...909B
)
"" , )OHDEll\ OV' aOUWI'
t'MTT...\ IlnOr.:u" I )
)
Pfilfenl~unt I )
~~
NOW, thie. a9th day of Ar~i~/ 1994/ it iq he~a~y ORPEREp/
and PlJlaRm~p i\q followSl
lIllP
. f,DJlmQEP
1 I ~\othet" ~nc\ Father sh<\;1,l f.lhara ll;lgal otlatody of the
jJll,r1;!\l!'l 6011/ Ti\ylor / and Mothsr aha,1,1 have pdnlary phyf'liciC\l Cl1atody
Of thEIlI' SOil I
"
2,
Fllt:her shall. \lave partial C\\s't:odY of. hiI'! son as fol;1,owl'!l
II I Every other weel\'.Elnd fr.om T\1,urlilday lit ~ 1 00 P. m I until
MondllY lit 6100 p',nll aOlnmenaing tna week:end of^pril 29, 199<\. Tn.!,,"
week:end visitation would r,Bml\1n. in 1:ull forae anc\ Elffec1; untj.,l,
I
aeptElmber 1/ 1996 lit which time Te.ylor woul~ COllUl\EUlCe lUndergl'lrten.
Il ,lit t:he time at wh10h aon'oommenaee I<inc\ergarten
(aap1;,embel.' 1, 199B) every other week.Bnd from Friday lit 5100 P.m.,
l\l\til, ,SundAY at 6100 p.m,1
C, pudng the summer months the lEl!!lt 14 dElYs in June of
ElV~l'Y yaal.' commencing at 6100 p,m., on the 111ra1;, qay !lnd ending at
6 100 p, m. on tho l.fist dC\y I 15 days in Ju],y of ~aoh IItld eVel-Y year
" -,
"
aomlnsntHng at 6100 p.m, on the f1rat day and ending lit 6100 p,m. on
,.'
tha ],nrJt day I 1.;ho 1.al'lt .U3 doye in i\uguat (OJ: / if aohool starts in
Auguat, bhon 15 c\nys in August prior to the start of. sohOol) of
,
"
slIoh And cwm:y 'IBm: oommenoing at 6100 p. m. Oil thE) firlilt day And
ending l\t~(\IOO P,n\. on the last dny. Bagin'ning the aurnmel.' that
. -:-,: "" "',;c:~..,::.~"-- ., ... ,,:.,?:. ;";,;~::'_.:.::;~. ".':~7: :":::T':::=:\~,"";:S:;::.::::::-_..: 0.::~':; iL ::..::: ~.:::: ~-~ '''::':~: ,;::..~ ::.:.;:~-::__., .
it'
,.
..~
r
'""
'lJ.1~yloP ~\.11.'!1.1'l f:l.~.ll: (6) yeAr\,! 91(.\, tile chJ.1q flhA:\.l \'!pen~ ~q(.\~ tionfl,~
til1\!iI w~ th MI'!' ~'~t.I1f,jr ove:t' tile alJ,l1ll1\erf\ ~p t\,e p<\rt.iel'l I'!I,a~l fl,grlll'l 0):'
Py motion to tni~ court~
p, Jnyery ot\'\3J;" 'l'hFll11il'lqivinq hp1!(.\AY 1!ro111 \'lflc\nfl\'!c\ay At. .
(:\,!pp p,m, pdo):' to 'l.'hAn)~Elq~vinq LlntH ~unc\AY at alPo p,'m; 1!ollClwing
'1)hf:\nlHlgiving, commem~ing in the :fear 199'\, FAthe!;' \'!Mll hFlye tl1a
" ,',' '
'l'hA!1Kl'lgiVinq hpl!c\IIY in even n1l1ul~areq yef\l;'a; \{pther !'lhllU have Vol''''
IJ.1hanK13qiviM hql!da:f 1113 out;l.ineq here!J" in tlla oqq number :fGAPll,
'1)hifl IJ.1h-An)~ElqivimJ aohaql.\le !'lh~ll Elutl~r!'l<lq.e IIIW wee.k;enq aonedule,
ijoweVer I in the event Hother or Fa thet' were to 1013e hifl" 0):' her
wflElKenc1 with tne f.l9n due to tpis Thankaq;l. ving ho1,;!.c1I1Y I the tlllrE\nt
losing the Wllf.l!l:enq shall llave the OUf.l'toc\~ of the Elan the
il1Ul\edilltely following weekend I Tn.Ls shall in no WElY ana.nge the
weeKenc1 ou~toc1y aohec\ule of the partial'll
"
El, Every . wintE\1-' brenk 1;:r:ol1\ peoElllllJer 26 Elt 1100 p,m,
unt,n JlIl1l.\ary 1 at 11 00 P,I1\, I
11' t As the tlassover holiday gen~l;'a;l.ly fll1,;1.s during' the
\'
mont,hfJ of HElron Elnc\/or /\pdl, Father spall hava Ol\stoc\y eaoh and
av~ryya<lr at a 1,00' p. m, on the day il111UediEltely prior' to t.ne fi):'f.lt
"daY of passover until the tllitd clay o'f paaSOVEll;' lit 6100 P ,,1\, In
the event pE\ssover were to. fall dl\r:\,nq a time in which FE\ther h~s'
h.ta waeltend ol\Ejtody I said passover 'snall be attaClhed \:0 FE\ther I s
WBekenc\ ouat,ody and,be oonseoutive and uni~terruptadl in the ,event
. '
the passover. holidllY falls on Easter I Hother shall have ol\stody on
I . . .
liIaater sunday beginning ,at 6 lOOP, m, pt'.tor to EasterS\lnday,
0. As Hosh Ha.shanah allc1 ~iol1\ Itippur holic1ays fall' within
. . I .
, ,."
2
, .. .._......~.. ""~'.:"""..'.:' ."_::"'_."~'_ ~_'.~."::',. ,::"'__::::~. "-:.~.:-:--:-':':__'" ','" ._......"'::::....---=_...::.:::.:'. ~;.;:.~. :_:::','_' _ ._,...._~.."..~.~ ~_.. .._,';_:'. "',' ,or """ .-. ,
'__" . _ " . '"' ~;." ._....:,~...~::...:....:.~'.T.~':"...., ',:"'1"
,
,',1
I
. ,
I
..,
'I
I
i'
I
.,
(-'
~en (10) qM'~ of. Ill\oh Qtll\'l:t' 1\111=\ oOO\1r in tile Il1QI11:h q~ SIil~tlll1\pet',
l.\ntH'\'i!\ylol.' oOlllmenpes ~il1qer<;JI3.rt."l11 l"e.t,pet' I>IW.l1 Mve 04etPQY for
II ~edotl of eight (a 1. oPI1~eq\.\tive' (~~W~ c\\.\:t'inlil 1:1113 11\80tp o~
~ept~nIPe:r Ilnd dwring the til1\e in wllion tM Rosh Haehl\l1Ah Ilntl. '{om
Kippur holic\aYe fAll, SAid eight oQl1eeo\11:iVa d~ye ehA~l inol\1c\e
li'llthel.'11.1 w?e)~I3I1c\oustodY, \l'!l,the:r. agl113ee 1;0 not,!!!:.' 110tPt3r 1.\1: least
. two week:s ill ac\Vl\noe o~ the exa.ot qaye in wpipl~ he shElll Olive
oustpclY. 'l'he oue\;oc\y l'lhlll1 11egin At. 6100 P, It\ I. on c\f\Y one C\m\
onnolutle lit lilOO Plm, on ..day ei~htl lifter Taylor ~egins
k,inc\ergarten, tile oUetoc\y shnll be rac\uoec\ 130 that'Pl'\ylor misses no
~,ore than two clays of. sohool owing to the I\oeh HE\sll~n<\h !\nc\ '{Ojn
Kipp~r holidays,
H, 'l'ne CI1/l.n<1xah hol~q!\y genar~lly f~lls in PeOEllllber of
..
,\lIlOh <1l1d every year, until 'l'I\Y1.or. oonlmehoee jdndergElt'ten I Ftltner
will oaie~rate tIle Ch~\nakah hQlldElY witl1 hi~ eon eMh ai\c\ I3very
,
year at his option ohoosing to ha:ve nia Elon c\L\r1ng hia c\e!>.tgnated
weexenc\ in peoEllnbep of eaoh anc\ everY yeal.' 'ei tl~er. oomlne!loin'.l
Wl,ldneElday at 6100 p,m, prior to h~.s weekenc\, or, in the alternative,
.,
oontinuing hi!'! regular weexand \.lntH TueElc\ay tit 6 I 00 p. In. Fatl1er
shall notify Mother 1n writing of his.ohoioe of c\aYEl for. lOlaic\
. holic\ay at leE\st thr.ee weaks in" advanoe I l'\fter Tl\ylor p13gine
kinderg::u7tel1, he,iEl not to miEla sohool .peoaUI>e of the Chan"lkah
holic\aV but ah~ll oelebrate Chanakah with his father. on the daY~
deElignated by the sohoo1 on.t.enda:r: for that\ hol.iday I In ac\c\i tiol1 I
Qvsry effor.t shoulc\ pe made for. Chal1E\Jtah oustody to be Elttaohad to.
one of Father's oustody weekanda.
. 3
I' .
."
"
,.
'ft
,,-,
, , ,
,-
('.
"
:j;. In the event tACIt ~!\y1pr qPElfl npt hl;\ve a8110p1 ~m thli!
1"1"tclAY Ql: oil the Hpn~AY l'l\.1rrpurH:lillg f'E\thEll;'I!,\ c\e:dgnl'll:ElQ WEleIH1nOI'l/
I"l\ther !>llAll \:hllll hAVEl plll;'til\l (J\.1stpr:1y, eitl1flr qpIIIl11enoinq 'Nl\.1rSQIW
At: alOO p,m, ~ripr to the holic\i\Y OJ;' \.1nti1 Mondl\Y at: nloo p,m, from
tha clAY pf the ho1iclAY/v~oation clAYI
,~, liiVElry other I'lpring prsAk (if 1lhere il'lorje on the
!'\ohpOl o!\lenc\l\l') erom the clAY pdo!;, to spring preal\'. At 6100 p,m,
" until the lAat Qay of ",pring preAk At; Ii I 00 l~, in, I oomnlenoing in
:!.9~~ I Hothsl;' ..f.IhA~,l /lave o\.1l'lt~ocly c\i.tring thEl I'lpring' Prell~, cI\.1ring the
even yel\l'fl, '. 'l'hia ol1!'rt:oQY aohed\.11e shl'll.l euperf.lec\e !Ill othel'
ot1l'Itody l'Iohedules, llowavsl: I in the sven1: eHI~8l;' pnrty is to 10l'lEl
1\ \o!Ele)l;13nQ v'hit with hhe.tl' son Que to th.ts spring bl'Elal\: hOUc\AY/
" tho ,PA.l:'ty 10sing the weeKend shqll have the sUPseq1.\ent weekend b\.1t
;.. - ,. "
the C\.1rrent weeKend floh.clule shnll rema.tn in full forae ancl effeoti
:I, The partiefl lihall shnre tl"t\naportntion in tl~t\t the
, , . ,
,par1;ief:l aha11 piok \.1p ancl cI;t'op off their flat;' py n\eet.ing 1l1'df the
,
clistanpe from Ii' i ttsburgh / l?ennayl vania Ancl Iiarr.ispurg / !?enmlY 1 Vl\11h
whioh sh!\ll be the BElclforc\ ex! t on the Pennsy.l VAtliA 'l'lIrnpi)te I
that they shall COnl!J1.\lI: Ona !\nother
,. . ,
in l"egarc\ to the sohoo1s itl whiqll the
0\ , ','('he pari:.tas agree
prior to mAJd.i'ig AllY deoisions
Chilc\ shall atfencl,
6, The p!ll;'ties shall oonsul t one another Pll ior to the
allroll.m~l1t .i.n Any aotivities in whioh the chLtc1 padio.tpatefl stloh
as flPorts I the al:ts or !lny extl;'1Icur'd01.\lar 'loti vi ties I
t3, 'l'h", !1l'lloumtocliEll parent shall haVEl telephone !lOOOSS to
the Child, Saicl telephone aoolHls ehall he at le!lflt three times per
0\
..
"" ,
, II
, I,
0,
( .
('
, '
. W~~~ lW\ I1hAil, lJe lit f!H\"an~IJh A 1;.~ml\1 Ancl A. reAsQna11la length o~
timer
".
1, Hgt~er ahAll ma~D ~vary raAsonn~laaffort to ~aep .'Ather
. ,.
timely informeq of apnpal, axtrAc~rrio~lAr Ancl meclioAl aotivities,
Il, )j)Aqh PArent 13111.\11 at a1.1; timl\1s ~aep the otl1t"lr .!nfornteclof
hl", pr ha7' plAoe of ~-lls!clenoa ami tf'!1l3phona n~mpl31-" Ancl IlhAll
promptly nQt!fy tlHl other. of Any.chAnges giving thE! A~clreEla of tne
ne~1 pJ:'!\aEl Of reaiclenoe' fH\c\ new telephone nUf!lber /
9 I J;1'19h party mutUAlly I.\grE1es ~Q inform the other of tne
Whal;'I3APOl.1t!'l of the ahilc\ inoluc\,i.ng th"1 a,c\c\reEla <mc\ telePhone n~mQer
whlla on vaoat1cJIl with }lather 01;' ~AtherreapeotiVelYI
10: E:Ach ~Al;'ty l1\l.1tu<\lly a.q:r.eea th/\t !1; ei thEll;' of tham hal'!
Imowlaclge of AT\Y i !11T\eI3El or I\ccielsnt at' other OirOLU\1stl\l1OeEl
affecting \;he l~ental ,.\1el\.lth or welfare of tjle Chlld, I'laiel PI\:rty AEI
,. . I
the aase lUl\Y be, I3h<\l), prolll\Jtly' notify the other /
,
,,13., E:l\Oh PI\J,-ty ehall be enti tleel to comPlete c1etaileel '"~
Fl.' ,
informat1on from any physician, elentht, ccnr;~1 tant or other
speoj,!\,li&t p<1rtainlng to the Chllel for. any reason whatsoever ancl
IlhL\ll pe furnlaheQ wj,th copies of any l;'epol;'t' given 1:0,. the othe,r
party/
~;a, maon partYl3haU be entitled to' clataUed j,nfot1\1E\tion
from any teaoher, sohool or othet- inst'l:1.\otor giving il1lltrllCtions to
the Chilcl .~\l1el to be furnlsheel wi th oopies of all t'epqrts <lnel/ot'
notioes of evalits given by saiel sohool at' 1:.eaohel;' to the othel,-
p<ll,'Gn1;/
13 I 'rhe judsdiaUon of this oUstoely aotion shall t-am/\in
!l
IO".'."H,j._-
i"~\>I~':'''~'li'' > -' \ '
._..~~~;,?;,~-<~, :;-~ .~,.
., ~ ~ ...."....~~. ".., .:...,:':;;..:.:::.::.:.....:.-....7,..:---.,:.~.l--..~ ) ,. ....
.,\1
to.
r
"
I '
w~ch t;h~ opu:t:'t o~ oommon 1'1eO\I'I of lIlleqheny county r'O\l\1ily pivi,sion
for th~' \:il~B \Jeinq', until f~rther orr.ll'lr of oourt.1
10\ ,}loth",r I1ha.U PfI':{ cp ji'O\t;her '0\13 r\'limburseJl\Elnt pf he:r. OnEl'"'
IH\~f 13hf\1."e of the oost!'l of the psyohploqiol11. aV'I1uator the amount
of $ 1300,00. ;3.aic\ <1l1\oUnt !311a~1 pe pdc\ wi thin twenty PO) r.\<1Ys 01:
the c\E\tfil Of tllif.l orc\!'lr, o\:, I in th13 event sair.\ al\1011nt ia not pe,ic\ <1t
that t,imEl, sa,!r.\ l\l\1ol1nt !'lhall be pAir.\ py Wif.El' to 1il\!'lPa,nr.\
..
!'limul\:l\lle~U!'lly ,w1,th the oCl\101uaion,, of tile aql1itflP;).e c\btrib\.\tlon
propeer.l!nqs,
Ii'
Wi TtlE cotmTl
iv*
I-I" ,
,;r ,
11- ;
"
,.
"
,.
,I
"
I ..
"
ii,
"
'".i ",
" .
I'
.,.
,.
/;
',.
.,
" '
6
'"~
f"'\
f"l~
"
INDIi1X '1'0 WI'I'NEl88~
FOR Turn P~AlijTIFF
j?<\\.Il.a Irene DeCarl.o
llIRnJOll~ mmaa
6 '2~
M1\RI<nJn lillM I'I'TIDD
16 36
,.
"
PLAINTIFF'S ElXHIBIT NO.
~. - p,<\j amaa
I)ElFlilNPllliT.' S P1XIUIU'LNQ...
1 - ^llegh~ny County Chil~ren
& YoUth ~erviaea
. ~6'
"
"
"
"
"
'<1/.
,.
\"
'"
"
"
2
IIf
~I,l
.' ~
"
"
"
:).
2
3
~
5
6
,7
0
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
,16
17
10
19
20
"
23.
22
23
24
25
"'"
~
'l'l!lil CO\.lH'l'l 'l'l1il3 ill the \:ime Ancl p+Aoe for A
heAring on the Petitio" for II Proteqtion.Dr~er filed ~~
Pf\~l<l It"ellS peCOlrlo on beh!llf of herllelf Olnq tIle pAl"ties'
minol" ohilcl, Il'Aylol" MAglin, Y. LIl\~renoe PlYAn Maglin. We
Will let the reoorq incliaate thAt the Plllintiff i/3 prellent
in oal\rt w.i.th her oo~mllel, JOlin CArey, l~IlC.\l\il:e, !lncl the
Pefenclllnt ill prellent in oourt with hill OOUnllel, BAr~arll
Sl\mple-l3ulli YEm,
We will let the reoord fl\rther 'indioAte thAt
the Co~rt is in reqeipt of !I Petition To Amend Petition far
Pl-oteotion Drqer whioh WAs evidently filf-ld on l:odAY's dllte II
fe\'(. minl\tes before the time Ilohenl\ler;l for this hef\ring. Mil.
. 13l\l11ple-Sl\l1ivan/ do you hllye ~ny ob~eotion to hellring thei
, . .
issl\e rAised in thllt petition/ whioh is the iS~l\e of pl\llbody
of the ohild at this time?
M$. SUMPLlil-StJLLIVAN I Yell, YOL\r Hono~",
.TUrn COURT I You feel you'l"e not prepal"ed to
ptooeed with that is/3l\e?
MS. SUMPLrn-SULLIVANI Your HOnor/ ,I believe
lit this point that the oustody issue is 130 oomplex that it
WOI\ld not be IIppropriate .to be l~eArd ~y the Court at this
time/ and that if, in fact/ the Court believes that a
modifioation of the eltlsting ol\stody ordel' fa neoessary,
thf\t we bifL\roate that issL\e and have a' separate hearing on
it,
"
3
"f'
""'"
,....,
1 'I'HIll OO\1H'I', ~n fillY eVl'!nt:./ YOIl / ~-e not: prePf\l:eq
;l. . \:0 ppooeec\ on t:hlll: :\.1313\113' 0\\: thifl he<\dng?
3 MI3, I3tJMl?L,PH:J\1l,r.,IVMII No/ + I In not: / 'lo\1r
II Honor,
6 l'HEl C0!1H';l'1 We / 11 ent:e~'. l:hb O~'qer,
6 (';l'he ~o11ow:\.n\J Orc\erWE\13 enterec\ by the
7 C0\11:t: I )
o IlliND NOW, thi!! 6th qE\Y of JLtne, 1~90/ upon
9. aonflic\erE\t:ion of the l?el:itionTo limend Petition for
10 ProtsCJt:ion Orcle~', anc\t:he Peti.tion To Amencl hAving been
11 t;eceived by I:he Court 01 few mintltel3 prior to the time
1;a l3ahec\l\led for the heOlring / <\nc1 the Pefenc\ant: / thro\1gh hifl
13 90\1nl3el, having ~bjeot:oq to the .ip~\1e of cllptoqy raiflec1 in
,
14 t;h/;\t: pet:it:ion being hearc1 at thil3 time, the Pe\;iti,on To
16 Amend hcieniec\ \'{itho\1t: p~'ejuc1iae to PlE\:\'ntiff'l3dght to
16 file a Pel:ition for proteation Orde~' oontlo1ining the il3l3ue of
'17 austoc1y for hearing ab 01 later time,lI
~O MR, CARID'l1 Your Ronor, jUl3t for the peoord,
19 if I might: say that W~ have been t.lking OIbout modifioOlt:ion
;ao of t:he aUl3tocty orcte~' to inoll\cte some ldnct of monitoring of
.;a1 the l3ituation bOlsed on the allegations of abuse that are" in
;a;a this petition, So, I would maintain t:hal; there has been
23 1301013 notice 1:0 the Peff.ll1dc\l1t's attorney,
24 . . MS, 'SUMPLID-SULr.IVANI 'ro clC\:rifY, Your
. 213 Hono~'
1\
,...'"
f....'
ii,
,I"~ ,
G
"
t'
1
'fi1
3
4
6
6
7
8
9
:1.0
11
1fi1
13
14
16
II' 16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
26
~
...~
.wll\:ph, P13PAIHle r \'IAI'! Afn:dc\ t:hA\: he WAEllJp.tng ~o ,I)\H~\: m\3 01'
1'l0I11e~h:l.ng, r lwl flo\11eonlol who W!'Hl wII~f.lh:l.ng \:he e~OIIAnlJe who
fol10wec\ "I'l c\pwn, ! Will'! Afl'A:l.c\,
q lJow ~Uc\ he AppeAl" when h13 WAI'l holc\:l.ng liP ,t:\)e
I;lAt:?
1\ lie WA!'l Angry At me"
Q Wfla he c\p:\.ng l-\nyt:hl,ng pef.l:l.c\el'l hol.(Ung ~IW
PAt:? .
"i1
1\' He I'!fli~, you fp1'got thia nn PU1'paae~ He
"
l3f1ic1, 1'\11 going to hit you wi~h t:hil'l, you c\ic\ thh on
p~\l"pol3e,. ':(oU forgot it: on pt\rpoae, I ~dec\ ~o e~pldn \:0
him ~hAt I c\icln'tfQrge~ i~ on Purpo!'le, I Wfll'l rushing, flncl
I WMl teAOhing, <\\lc\ I Mc\n' t clo it to mE\J~e him Angl"y,
THm COURT! WhRt WRa it you Alleg~c\ly forgot,
the Pflr !'leAt?
II'HEl WITNElSI3! It: "WflS fI Sony p 11:1 y I3tC\~ion thEl~
he hElc\ bought, Elnc\ I forgot i.t: , He got very angry ab6ut
that, 1 bOUght: him thflt, and I WAnt it baok,
B':( MS, CARmy,
Q Direoting your attenl;:l.on to May 8th fit
sohool, c\ic\ flnything happen then to dause you ~o f\'la]~ far
YOUl" I son?
A Yes, May 8th what. .had hRppened W<\S Larry had
grElbbed my aon and dragged him out of the sohoo1 by hia ar.m
ancl put him in the bflok seat of the oar, I sAidl p1eas~
7
',.
~.
;a
3
i\
. 5
,.
6
7
a
. ..
9
:LO
U'
:L2
P
:L4
:L5
:L6
"
:L7
:La
:L51
20
2:L
22
. 23
24
25
.I
I,'
1"'"
;"'"
.,
clan' t:c:jo \:hi.f3, "Any, ~'~.eAflfl c:jon' I: clo \:hil'!, pan' I: clo \:htf3
\;0 him, 'l'he~"e I p ol:hap chill~~"en hel;e, l'+el.\pe c:jon I I: clo I:hip,
lie, i..n (;urn, pdq, I Will do WhAt - - I will. I:AI~e my flon when
,
And where I pleAfle, any \:ime I pleAI'!e,
Q What: Wl\fJ he qoillg 1:0 YOl\~' chi+q that: WA!3
urfle~ting'YO\.l7
1\' Wel+', as they c~-ol'!flecl the f3tl;eet;, Tflylol; WAI3
j~;lcl~ing <lndf3flying, .mom, mom, I f.lAid, TAylor __, I flAj.d,
Lf\try, pleAse don~t do th;ll3,
Q . WhAt W<lfl he doing?
1\ lie WAI3 grabbing him, flnel then he C~\~"fleel At mE;'"
a few \:;lme[il,
Q Where wal3 he grabhing him?
A He had him by the arm, And he openeel Up the
bao~qoor anel thr~w him in the oar,
BY IrHlil COUR'l'l
Q May I flsl~ a ql.\el3t!on, Was there a OUl3toely
orde~" in affeot?
1\ Yes,
Q Who hael cUl3toely at thAt ti.me?
A I elid, It was 3130,
~ This Woulcl have been e violatio~of the
oLlatody orde~'?
1\ Yes, 'l.'he~'e is a contempt right: now fQr I:;hat
isaue I but' that 'a' not the iaaue right: noW, I Waa to meet
..
a
"
,;
~
r':l
h~m Ab GIPO At Redeord!
IlY MI3, ClIl\!ilY I
q Yall were \:omes\: him At 6100 III: Reclf:ord, AmI',,,
YOII went: t:at:he pchool. \:0 pio)~ him liP?
A 'l'o pio)~. LIp my eon,
Q And \:he fE\t:her' WAP thel-e?
A Con-eot: ,
Q WIUlt: WI'HI t:he f:<lt:hel~' a l'e~panpe t:o' YOII?
A He Wf.\El vel~Y 1i V icj, He WM Angry,' He WAa
o\lr.ping /:I\: me, 'rhe prior 'l'h1l1'eday nigh\: !I\: t:he p/:Ipeb!'tll
13l\l1Ie, I!'aylor, c1icln' t: want: \:0 go in t:he Oal~ wit:h him,. He
en\:!31~eq t:he car' wi.t:hme, C\nd he PC\idr I 'llaee you I\t:
. Reelf,Pl~d, 1\nd I e/:lid, O!~E'\y, ''l'hen.he Went t:o t:he eohool
wi\:hout: me even Imowing t:hl\.t: he W<la \:here;
Q Beeidel3 . being' Afrdcj for YOLlr, 130n, werEl t:hel'e
Any. mAl'lta Ol~ Elllyt:hing on his <lrme? Ii
1\ Well, on h113 I\'i"m whel'e he gl'abbad him, when.
he oElme bMIt it: WElI3 at:illl"ecl, .1..meEln, he I1l\eI him hard, He
waa drElgging him, 'l'he othel- lcide t:hElt were t:here I \~Ele
worrie~ ElboLlt, I Went:. to the prfrioipal, Elnd I ~bld her, 1'.111
very 1'101'1')1 \:hat: thia hElppeneel, I fel t hEld fOl' the 0\:h81'
children, t:oo, Who I3E1W Elll bf: t:hat:,
Q Dh'ecHng YOllr EI\:t:ant:ion to Apdl of 1990, ,
the. 23rd, at YOU1" home, ,did anything hElppell t:hen to Cf\Uee
,.
you to be afraid?
9
" ",
~". .
fI'\\
:1. l\ Yep, 'l'htp Wflr4 II' 'l'hl\l:nqllY nlohtl, f\n(~ he WAP
~ V"1ry" - \:hip W;.Hl AI:\:01: the lJ;.q:\:y h<1q l\flPPl'lnaq on t:he :1.P'\:h
3 fo+ 'l'<lylot', on l:hl'l ~~n~, \:hi.p WAP <I ':\'\nlt'f!QAY nigh\:, he ""
tl. n1Y Oil:lfdenq .1ol'l!.e wall c\1.'oppi.ng,.oCC hel:' IlPIl, DraWl <lIlA
,u .ropi.e WAP ill the hO\llle wi.t:h her eOll, Dl-SW, l~<ll:'r.y h<lq CAme
6 to my hO\HII3, ~ qiqn f t: even l~n9w he Wf.\e aOlning, He oame
7 I\Pilt:f\il"13 I\nq al\i.Q, I WAI1t: my san f yOLl will. oi.v€Jhim to me
o now, pl\nging on t:he Qoor, pl\ngi.nf,l 011 thEl QOot' , t hAQ the
9 QOOl:' l.oalteq, :r. I3dq, .don'l: open \:he ~00l:', 'rile ne~t Q<jy, he
'10 lmew we wero goi.ng on.<I fieiq trip, l\nq I pl\iq, Lan'}'l
11 WhA\:'eW~ong? He sAi.q. I'm t~ki.ng him now, ~ Pf\i.Q, L<jrry,
12 YOLl a<ln'\: take l1i.m now,
13 ao, I openeQt:he Qaor, I l.ookeq the qoor
,.
14 pehind me, and I went outei.c\e, beo<lUSI3 I'm the. one \:ha\:
15 Alwaye tri.ee to deal With .it before Tayior eeep it: or
16 . <jnythtng, So, I w.nt outpi.Qe, AnQ I t:rieQ to tal.k to him,
1'7 I eai.c\,l,l\rry, what i.e going on? He paid, I have \:0 get my
10 . "rentAl. OAl:' baalt And dA, qa, QI\, Youwil.l.give me my son
,.
,
.. and pangingon the thip door i .roeie htlQ'
J.9 noW, QOOl:' , . Open
20 dOme over anQ opened the qoor, He Illammed the door, anQ I
. fell ,.
21 i.nto the wal.l' He proaeedeQ to go over and gra\:l 'l'ayl.or
22 off: the aouah where he wae aitttng with Drew.p~aying with
,
, 23 \:he'Sony pl.ay l3\:a\:ion,
..
24. Q HoW did he gl:'ab him?
20 A He"grAbbed him by the ar.m, and he said, you
1b
I'
..~
f~
1 Will gp w:l.th. m(ol, flnq Janie's ltke, YO,", havo no dah\: to elo
;:l t:hi[l, ~'his il'ln' t YOl1r \:ime, YOI1 o<\n'l: j usl: b<\rge in hel"e
3 And ~p thi~ to this ohild,
11 Q 130,.tt: WEHl not h:ls tim\'l to hAve ous\:oqy,?
13
No, it: wasn't, l~rielElY/\\: 6,00 :I.t W!\S,
So, Elfte; he grabbeel him, wh/\t eliel he elo,?
He ell"Ug hill1 Ot1t of the hOl1l3e, Anel he t:old
6
7
fI
Q
A
a Prew -- he looked /\t me, an~he said, I'll be ~id of you
9 1300n, find he lookeq at Josie and l3aid, you're done, too,
10 Josie said, are yot1 threatening me, Larry? fire you
11 threqtening me,? He SEliel, yoy heard what ~ s/\id/ and he
1;1 ,prooeeded t:o dr/\g 11'aylor qown the stairs,
13
14
113
16
Q How m<\ny I3tairs a1"e t:hel"e,?
A '1'hel"e /\re three flights of stairs,
Q How was Taylox' behaving at thie \lime,?
A l1'aylor was orying, And Josie said / . yot1 need
17 .\:0 oall the polioe, and I did,
.10
~'hen he put him in t:he O<ll"?
Wall, he toolt him dOWl1at:ah"s, After they
,\(:
Q
;1.9
A
20' went: outside, ~'aylor..ran fl-om him, Josie'a lilts, run, run,
21 and.11'a)llor ltapt: running, He ran aft:er 'l'aylol" out:l3ide and
22 grabbed him and ~ioked him up and oarried him and threw him
23 i11\:0 t:he oar and t:hen atal"\:ed I:he o<lr and loolted I:he doors,
24 lIe st:al"tad 1:0 yell at: Josie, t:hreatened Josie / my 13011 will
213
nevel" be around YOLl or your ohild or YOUl" I3l:epsoll, II: was
11 I
"
,.
1"",,,\
r'''''
:\. jq!'ll: i\Wf.ql.
,2
3
1\
Q
1\
Q
Whal: WA~ I:he ohildlp reaovion AI: thip I:lme?
TAyloJ:1 W",!'I Ol"yhlOl1nc1 hil:\:i.ng on \:he w.i.nqow,
yoq I'lqic1 that I:hat w",'" no\: hi~ I:ilne for
. 6 oUlll:0qr'i'
bottom. I, in' turn, got up at that time,
Ii Q Where WAa the ch;l.ld?
,.
A 'l'hey wel'e in the bec1room. Taylo~' Wanted tl=!.
,
21
Q
I'm a little oonfu13ed, You're diVoioed?
22 A Right,
23 Q But your huaballd waa there at the h9uae with
,'24 .. you Ol" at the apartment Ol" whateVer?,
25
.. A
'fea,
12
"
1
'"
3
4
5
6
" 7
fl
P
10
11
,"~
12
13
14'
15
16
17
10
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
~
f!'"'i
Q Why if'! \:IH\\:?
A BeoftUf'l~ I t~ie~ to MlWftyf'l get him tp ~e A
PA~t oC Tftylor'f'l life, I'm &lWAYf'l trying to do thAt, When
he' WAs ftbulling ma, J.t;. w<\f'ln't f'lO muoh, P\.lt: it:' f'l J\.ls\: gett:ing
WOl'f'le ftl1d WO~'f'la,
Q ao, an April 20, 19PO, the pefendftnt W&1l
liVing At your hOUf'le or JUllt Vif'liting?
A No, JUf'lt vil3:Lt.i.ng, I told him he ootlld oome
tip to I3t:ElY fol;' '1'&ylor' f.l birthdEly Pftl'ty beomH3e :l.t WEIll ft
sleep.over, &nd h~ f'lftid .fine,
Q ao, he WClI3 aleep.i.ng at yotl:\.' hOIWe?
A Ye&h, There wet"e people there,
THEI COURT, All daht, MI3, C/:\l"ey?
BY Ma, Cl\l~ElY ,
Q Sa, thil'l wal3 in the morning 011 the 20th, and
. he W<l13 open.i.ng hil3 prel3entl3, 'rClylo;r WClI3 opening hi13
prellen\:s, YOll s&id he ripped q pax, '1'hen whftt happened?
11 Well, LClt"ry got' vel-V angry and began to hi t
him,
"
Q Where d.i.d he h.i.t him?
^ He had h:tm by the arm, on the Plitt, It j'Ul3t
ltept going on,
Q He had h:tm by the arm, Ellld he WElS hit:t:tng him
whel:e?
11
He WC\13 hit:t.i.rtg him on h:l.13 bot:tom, lie kept
Ij
'.,.
13
'"
l
2
3
1\"
5
6
?
0
"
,I' 9
10
11
12
:\.3
14
1.5
16
17
10
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
('''''
,..-"
I'
ht\l\l~.ng. htm amI hit:\:ing htm, 1: !3<1i\1, r'<ll:n, wU~, YOH I'ltlop,
,^ll.~ictp who open up presen\:s, thsy gat axci\:ect, They're
going to rip the b9~, Well, yo~ ctqn't teach him how to
respect t,oysl anct thts is why my family doesn'\: senct Iltm
. m1Y\:h~.ng' tip here!. lie doeI'm' I: Imow how tlO t'el3pect, \lOYS. You
1m ow ,how I l~eep my Iloys till my houss, HI3 wenl: on anct on, anct
he kep\: hil:ting h~n, Taylor fell, anct he began 1:0 kick him
l:1nd I3dct, see, you have 110 l"eSpeot for nothtng, 'l'ha t'l3 what:
yotlr' mOffi'l:eaohea you,
Q Where wal3 he )dcl~ing him?
, II
A On his leg, He WOlS in.OI fetal l?osit:iop on
the floor, and he jtll3t Itept ld.o)~ing . him,
Tum COURT! $offiepocty ell3e saw thiSI dict they?
THm WITNmS$! Not I:hat incident,
,
IrHEl COURT! t-jobody /:law it, MI3, Carey?
BY MS. CARIil'i1
Q l\prU 18thl you paid thel"e wal3 a .bil:thday
pArty, WOII3 that when the biruhclay pal'ty Cloourred?
AVes, .1' hOld a 131eep-over,
Q Did OInything hAppen thOlt day to OOlUl3e you to
feAr foryourl3elf 6r him, for your pan?
. A Yep, 'rhOlt WOII3 the ni.ght that I ~ent: into my
room, And he hOld followed me in, and he pUl3hed.the door,
'l'he ohUdren Wet'e all 131eeping out on the Claar,
Q Vou need to tallt into the miorophone,
1.4
~
"""
1\ I\U t;ha ol]ilc1r\'ln ware plaep~ng oq\; on \:he
floor in t;he liv~ng room,
WhA\; h<H~ hAPpeneq WAil lw h<lq
II' ;
fCIUowec1 me int:o t;ha paqrool11, ~)eoi:'\qpaX wan\; \;0 PilI: on I11Y
II
p~jAI11AP At; l~,OO\ 1\11 of \;he kiqp.ware in t:heir p1eeping
P~f,lll <Inti \;hinmOl I fI\; thAt t:ime, he loo)tecl t:he claar, Ila Ol\me
over l:ol11e, Anc1 he I3dd, 00111\> here,L <lnQ grflPped my olothap,
IInd hljl P<l~Q, yoq l'\re going to be wi\:hme :r;ight: now, x helVe
t:he p.d AI11AIl where he hAQ rippeQ them - - my girlfrienq hl'\q
fi~eq themi they're dght: t:here '~- .tn t:he Ot'otoll At-eA, 'l'h13
)Jut: ton WAI3 )?~\+1eq off, He prooeec1ed .1:0 remove my 010\:hel3,
He grabbec1 A bel t, l'\nc1 he /3C\iq, benc1 OVf,lr, X lmow yoq' 11
Hlte thi(3, )3el1d over p x' m 90i.ng to hi t you wi tht:h~(3 ,
II
You' :r:e my wife" You'll alWAYP be my wife I You Will alWAY/3
. ,
be with 11113, I clic1n't /3oream, X c1ic1n't: 01'111 the polioe,
beOC\u/3e X WC\/3 C\fraid thC\t the ethel: lcic1/3 woqlc\ get: lloal'8c1,
At that time, 'l'Aylor - -after 1'111 thC\t hC\PPlilnecll 'l'C\ylor hC\c1
"lmooked on the door beoC\Ulle he oouldn't eleep, anc1 X 'Wa/3
lAying 'in the bec1,
Q DiQ YOU /3AY he /3exUAlly a/3/3~u1ted YOU?
A Yes, '1'he 9lothe/3 wel'e ~-il?pec1, and the button
WAil l'6moved, He pulled the olothes oH of me,
, (PIAinti ff' s lJlxhibit No, 1 ..was mar.ltec1 fOl"
"
ic1entitioatiop,)"
BY MS, CllRIJlYI
QX'I11 ahowing yoq what has been l11arlted Exhibit
lli
~.
?
3
~
Ii
6
7
0
9
+0
U
+2
;1.3
l4
1. Ii
l6
'" l7
lO
19
20
2l
22
23
24
25
~
~.
No, 1 f(Jt" t:he PIA:Lnt:iff, \'IhAt /:wet:hpl'!e?
I
A ~~ese Afe my PAjAmAs' thAt I hA~ on,
Q \'IhElt/s the aOlllUtion of t:he PAj1\mA"'?
A \'11311, the bUtto~.W1\'" pff/ An~ they Were
..
. dppe~ by my arot:ah At"eA where hepUlleq,
Q Pi~ YOU repA:Lf the orotoh AreA?
A \'1313, My gi:t;lfr~en~ r.\,t~, ! ~i~n' ~, MY
g~.rlfrien~ ~i(l, And she lmowl'! wh1\t h1\Ppene~,
'l'Um COURT 1 She WAS t:here?
. TUIil \'IIll'Nm$$ I$he W1\sn / t t;here, $he WElI3 __
. '1'11m COUR'l1, M.I'!, CAt"ey, we / re rS1\lly .l:\lnn~,rm
out of time, If you want to run through these ot:her
allegatio!1I3, you'll hAve to cto it prettyquiokly,
BY MS, CARmy 1
Q In 1997/ in Ootober, ct:Ld 1\!1ythi~g happen then
to OaUI3B you fear?
A Yes, When! went ~own to his family' fl hous!3'
fot" 1\ dinner / I Was in the oar, and I ~roVe them down, He
grabbed me by my hAil" and beg1\n to pull 011 my harr severely,.
and 'I hi t my heC\d, He pulled out: my hl'd.r l?eClause I Elfllted
h1m a question, f.llld he got Ve~y angry at that, He/s just
Vel:y volatile, !\lld he t"ages ,
Q . You say he pulle~ out yout" ha~r, How 11111 0 h
,
did he pull aut?
A r.ike a handful. He kept holding it, lie
16
I')'
(,
1
2
3
1\
Ii
6
7
0
9
10
11
12
;t3
"I. 14
15
16
17
10
19
20
:U
22
23
24
25
"
ttl'l
"'''1
W9111Qn't I3toP" I I3del, Ple/.\l3e, f.ltop, I won't: Ill'll< YOll thllt
I\gl\in, Plel\se jllSt stop,
Q piel yOIl hl\ve IIny physicAl l3igql'l lI~ter thil'l
incid\3nt?
A Well, I hl\q A l:ll'lliSEl on my heag, IIncl Iny hAir
W<Hl out whel-e he Wf\s holcling my head,
Q In AlIgUI3t: of thl\t: Sl\ll1eyeal', '97, cliel
any\:hing happen then?
1\ We were on a ol"uil'le, aqd he haq pUl3heq me
. ~\,own a few~light:13 of at:ail'a,
Q . How cliel he appeB~IIt: t:hat point?
1\ He WAS <\Hgry beaallae I WAan't: going where he
want:ed me t:a go, I waan' t: I'ltaying where he want:ed me t:o
'f.ltIlY,
Q July4t:h of t:hat: same year, what happened?
A At my home, Iraylor waa t:hEll-e, Larry had
prought: up a b~moh of fireworl~f.l, He became very angry with
me beaaUf.le a friend of mine had called, and he toolt t:he
fireworlta <\l1d pounded them int:o my nealt, And Taylor was
arying, saying, dOl)' t:elo t:hat: t:o my mom, st:op that:, Don't
do that: to my mom, YOLl need to stop that, Don't do that,
Q When you say the fireworks, where t:hose like
sticka of
A They Wel"e t:he stick fireworks, 'I'hey wet'e
like M-OOs or something, I don't: know,
,
'.'
("1
1'7
'1"""'1
n
:!. 9 'l'hey wel"e APpl:o~~.mA\:ely how long?
;;j 1\ 'l'hey we~:e \:he pig onel'l,
3 Q L.il~e flPo~:t f.\ foot:?
4 1\ He pOHghl: them 1n \'Ieli1\: Vi:t:g1n~.E\ , YeAh,
5 \:hey're /Jig,
6
Q
MAypemore.thAn <I foot?
r WOUl~ Ii1AY <lpoHt <I foot <lnd f.\ hfllf, T~ey
7
1\
Il . were pig.
9
"
Q
Then he );l~lshecl them inl:o YOUl- __
My neol~,
\'Ih!\t h<lppened to..you fll'l <I rel'lult of thAt?
\'11311, they b~'o'te, They brolle beOAUl'le he wal'l
I h<\q m<lrltl'l <IntI br\.\hing t
In JUI1e of ' 97, Wh<\t hAppened t:hen, if
", '.'.
10
11
11
. .. Q
1\
h:lt:ting \:hem.
1~
13
14
3,5 anything?
Q
16 11 He waa angl:y <lgain, There Were 130 many
.,'"
17 different inoidentl'l, This Was another one; He c1ictn't Want
;J.1l me to gOl'lomewher.e, so he grabbed me and he threw me qgainl'lt
19
the wall bec;JaUl'le I Waa gofng to go out, It w<\s DiAne
,
Velo\1:o, my good fi~iend who teClohee with me, He thl"ew me
againi'll: the wall and sdcl, youlre not going anywhere.
"
20
21
'22 YOU'l"El I'ltaying l"ight here,
23 Q Now,' there wel-e other p\:oteotion fl."01l1 abuse
24
PrUel"S elll:el"ecl,
25
A
"
In Pittsburghl.. and they .were dl"oppecl, ItJ was
10
"
"
~
.,
~
1 wi~h hiph~n~p, ~Arry p~i~, ! ~on'~ t~Aoh yoU ~hiQ, you're
.:,) no~ an ~nfm~l, 1in~ he l~ick\3~ him, bec~t1pe he WMI pi~ ~j.ng
3 ~own on l:he f.1,?Ol:, I /3aic\, L~rt.y, I)e' p ~. )~iq,. lie' p not "~.
4 he' ~ a \'ll)il~, lie' /3 going \lo U/3e hip h~nc1p,
II
5 Q liny\lhing el/3~ ~h~\l YOLl paw LAn-y c\oing?
6 A Ll'\rry hA/3 t-el?e<\~e~ly hi~ him,
'1 Q Where .c\oep he hi~ him?
o A Yo~t will no~ tall~ ~o my -" YOLlt- dac\ - - he
9 aml'\okec1 ~im ~t a hockey pr~ctioe in hi/3 faoe,
l,O
11
Q
1\
Where c\id he f3ml'\ol~ him?,
In ~he faoe, Hel'\~mH tec\ ~hil3 to 1<01 te .
12 Warnigirip, He 1'11130 I'\c\mittec\ to K~te WArnigirip, T~ylqr'f3
13 \'lq~ml3e10t', 'th~t Tay1ot' Wl'\l1ted to come in my CAt', I'\nc1 Larry
), i
,
14 beOAme verY Llpaet, I aaid,~l'\rry, he'a jual: coming to my
15 oat' 80 I CI:\I1 t~ke him home ~11c\ get him reAdy for bed, lie
16 pdc\, well, I'm going to c\r.tve him, Thia i/3 .my time, I
17 w~nt: to 8ee him, so, he .c\rl\g him from Iny'oar and t;hrew him
10 in t'ha car, l(ate add, YOU need to f3\:op that behaviot",
19 because I Went to cOl\n~eling with him, beqaUp8 he said, I do
20 ne~d 130me help, He told me that,
21 Q He told you he needed help, For. hia ,.tempet'?
2;1 A Fat' hia temper, yea, And he told Kate
23 Wl'\rnigiria thl'\t, He did ac\mit to it, This i~ not ~bout
,
24 ol\atody,
26
Q
He admitted to YOLI e.hat he had c\ot18 that?
20
1
2
~
'\
5
6
?
8
9
~.O
11
12
13
111 ",.
;.
15'
~.6
17
18
19
20
2t
22
;' 23
24
213
"
1"'",
! ,.."~
^ Yep; Thts ip no~ q~O~~ ~~Pto~YI ~ Wfin~ ~o
qcjcjreps \.he i/ol/ol\le/ol of. w!)qt my /olon 1!'l e~per.j.enoing qllr.! I flm,
,
I .Wf\n~ ~.~ to /olt:oi) , It' a been et~ yeAr!1,
II
Q !low ooel'! YO~t' ollilo <lppt;1l\r when i~/a (:ime \:0
go wi\:hhis fflt:her'j>
1\ ~\here qt'e times t:lmt: he I /ol h<lppy <ln~, yo~
. know, he wAntl'! \:p pee the l~id/ol cillO I1hose l~;~n~/ol of things,
PLI(: \:hcm I1here qt'e time13, lil~e when he j\l/olt OAme PMI~, I:h<lc.
he W~/l in feqr, He, /olAicj hi/ol c:tAcj WA/ol going to 'PLl\: him in
Jdos' jd~ 11:. he ooesn't t:ell t:he OOLlrt:s t:hAt: .he W<ln\:s 1:0
st:/'I)' wi t:h him fat' t:Wenty,one dqys, l\n~l cjon / t: YO\.l lte,
beo/'l\.l/ole YOLl'l,1 go t:o l~:\.~p' j~i1, Het:ol~ (:he Clounselor
\:his, Or, Sohne,i~er, He s<licj i.1: he ~oesn' t:, t:/'IIJ~ to him on
\:he phone he Il/'l:\.~, mom/ I clon't: wtlnt: (:0 t<lll~ (;0 him, I'm
pl.ying with my fr:\.enos, I ~on't: w<lnt:t:o t:Alk \:0 him, I
/olA.i.q Why? He go\: very I\ngr}', wi t:h mfl, <lncl he /oltl\t-ted Ifl/olhingl
au\: at me I\nd Cl:ytng and ooming up to me IInq pushing me, I
sdq, 'l'lIylot,., wh/'l\:'/ol wrong? lie 13dcj, my cl<ld sllid 1'11 get II
Whpop:\.ng i.1: I dbl)'t t:alk to him when he olll1s het'e.
Q SOl you observed fe<lr in Tllylor? .
A Yee, very much eo, and 130 does hie teaohet'
ancl. othl;)t-s ,
Q so, YOU're aaking the CaUl'\: to en\:er a
1n'o\:l:1otion Ol:der el\yillS \:hat there OAn be no v.iolel.~oe ..
t;owell:cle Your eon, no abuee or \:hrel\\:e?
21
, ,,""'I
;-,
1
'0", ;.l
" "
~
4
6
6
7
q
9
. 10
11
1;3
13
. 14
16
,.16
17
10
19
20
21
:32
11 r qon' \: WAnt: h~m. to to\1oh my Ilon __
q Or YPur/3elf?
11 01:' mYllelf in tiny Wtly, 1'l!1t1pe 01:' f01"111. He
Otln Ul'le other \:hing/3, ttlking the Sony tlW~y, I tried tq talk
. to him tlPout tha~, IInd.. he said, yoU tire nail going \:0 tell
me howtp di/3oiplille my /30n ,Tholle wel"B hi/3 e~ac\: WOl,"da,
Q Do YO\.l have <lny' othel, aOnCe1"11l3 to be
e~p1"el'll'led to the CO~lrt?
11'Hlil COUj'l.T I ~lhtlt 'I'l. too bl"DElcl tI t~Ue/3tion, We
l"al\lly <lr\'l nmnillg O\.lt of time,
MS, CARmy I .. I helVe other q\~estion/3 ,
no
,
II
'l'HEl COUR'I', M/3, SUlnpl e - ,9ull i VCln?
CRoss-m~lIMI~IITIO~
BY MS, SUMPLm-SULLIVlIN,
Q YOU indioClte, Mil, DeCElrlo, thClt YOU observecl
1;etlr in 'I'tlylor in qe!\l.i.ng Idth Mr, MClglin, is thC\t COri"ea\; ?
1\ Ye/3, it i/3,
Q Il'hat is why you feel this chi:l.d .is in
ilnmediate fe/U' of phYsical Clbuse f1-Om Mr, Maglin?
A 1~1-0111 whtlt my son hels told me. anct What I' ve
seen, yes"
Q 'The/3e EIre /3.in1ilar a.llegElticns th~t We' Ve
.. 23 acldl-essed, allegCltions of YOUrself and of 'l'ayl01" I as', fill".. as
2'1 the seXUal Clbuse allegCltions in Octobe1"?
"
26 1\ That is correct,
22
,.
1
;a
3
" <1
6
6
7
B
9
'.
10
. !'
11
3.2
13
.14
16
16
17
1B
19
20
21
IL
2;]
23
24
26
~
r~
'rlil1l COUR'r, I'Ih<\\l qoe!3 tl1i\tme<\n, <\qq~'e!3lleq
tl1am in Oo\:o\)er? piq yo\.\ h<\ve iiI ha~l'il1\J?
MS, sPMrI.,lil" SULJ" I VAN , Mf,my of thepe ill!'l\.\l!l!3
q~me \.\p <\\l th~theAring in Ootoper,
THIil COUR'r, There' Il no~hing on the reoord
~))PJ.It ~I"lOther he~r~.ng ~t thill point, Jf you Want. \:.0 PH\:
\:.h~tpn th(3 record, you neeq \:0 do it,
BY Ms, sUMI?r.,m"SULI.,IV^N,
Q . Mil, PeOar101 there were Ile~u~l ~bupe
~lleg<\\:ionp r<lilled l:>yyoU~-!3elf. in <\ pe\:ition t:ol3Hl3penq
oUl3toqy rightl3 for Mr, MAglin, ip that:'~orreot?
A Yep,
Q Tlmt W~13 filec\ in Oa\:oberl ill th~t correat:?
A Th~t il3 aorreat,
TI.lm COURT, Oatober of what ye~r?
" nil]] I'II'rNlilss, Nineteen ninety"peven,
BY Ms, SUMI?I.,m " SULI.,IVAN 1
Q Mr, Maglin's aUl3tody rights Were SLll3pended.
tl1l7ough Deaembel.' 23rd of ""
A Pending the invel3ti9.tion, yes,
'I'Hm coUtt'r, Wait, The I3tenographe~- aan' t
talte \:Wo people talking,
Tim WI'rNmss, Oh,' 11m sorry, l>ending the
inveptigation, We oan' t find Audrey HSnne/3l3ey, who did. the ,.
investigation for three )101.11'13 with my son. Yes, tha.\: h
(I"
23
:1.
;l
3
..1\
5
P
?
B
9
.,.
:1.0
H
:\.;l
3.3 .
:t.4
:1.5
16
:1.'1
:1.0
:t.9
20
2:t.
22
23
24
25
';.,
(..",
~
the w~ekend of the :\.Otl1, :t.9tl1 and 20th/ Mr, MAglin ~pent At
YO\.lr home, i~ that oorreot?
^ 'l'ha\:. i~ oorreot,
Q lie sPf3nt there the enth'e Weel~end?
A lie wf\~n/t therl3 \:.he wlwle time, He Wflfl \:l1ere
for the p<lrty, He W<\~ there "- he tool~ Tf\ylor to hool~ey,
Q He ~lept FIt your hOU!3e thrp\.Igh the weel~end?
A yes, in Tflylor'a room,
Q Prior to that timet aPProximfltely tha13th,
14th <lnd15th/ you ofl11ed Mr, Mflglin find f\!31~ed M~', M<lglin \:.0
~eep ~he ohild beo<\u~e the ohild wa!3 ill a"dyou hfld t6
worl~?
A That ).~ qorreo\:,
.. ,
Q You gave Mr, MagUn thif3 ohilg for the dflte~
of April 13th and 14~h to oare for peoause you weren/t
"
<\vflilable to oa:r,e for him while he WflS siok?
I;
A Hi~ brother and the worlee~'swe1'e up here with
him, When he's wfth someone ebe / I I m okay I Thflt / S ol~flY,
Q So" flra .you &11egino' that Mt', MagHn took
your siolt ohild out onto a oonstruotion site?
,. A No, he did not:., He kept him overnight / <\nd
he brmlght:. him t:.o my sohool beoause he oouldn' t leeep him ..
anymore, He walked int:.o my sohool and gave him t:.o ma,
Wa I re not addJ:ess1r\g the abuse,
Q Yes, wa: E\l:e addressing t:.he abuse I Mrs I
20
"
~
~
1
~
3
4
6
6
'7
B
9
"10
. ,
11
. :\.2
. 1~
14
16
16
~. '7
10
19
20
21
22
23
24'
25
"
29
. .
1
il
3
"
6
G
7
0
9
10
U
" 12
13
14
16
16
17,
10
19
20
21
22
23
?4
215
"
~
r"1~
fonow~cl me :\.n ~f\:e:r IhM~ I:ham on, ! cliqn' t WAlk- A:rOlmcl
\: he l~icl/3 1n the!'l8, 1 WI\!'l in my I:>eqroom,
q Anq /Ill of thel3~ ohilclr~n, /It ~ight yeA:r~
plcl, went 1:0 /31~~p .1.mmecliA\:ely when ypu pl\t I:hem ill I: he i1:'
l3+eepi.ng pA9/3?
^ Iran, eleven, 'l'hey were "- wl~en ! \'i!:\lk-aQ ~,<\cil~
oUb, yeAh, ,they we:re/31eaping,
Q How 1l1<\ny l:>oyscl1.cl YOLl h<\ve? How m!:\IW hOY/3
",
were \:here OIl: th<\t fl:leep-over?
A 'rhel'e wel'e !:\lJoLtt twelve, l'Ie got vary'<\ngry
when I to+cl Josi.e WhA\: he hAQ clone, He l3<\id ,I:\on' t tell her
Why \:he/3e Are dpj?ecl / t:hEl next day when I a/3)~ec\ hel~ t:o f fx
\:heae when hel" Anc\ h€lr hUl3lJAnc\ oame ovaI',
Q Le\:la'go. Again, We 13\:Art Oil t:he 10t:h, 'Pha
l~t:h ancl.14th he'a'oatin~ for t:he ohild, On \:ha 18th/
you're alleg.tng thAt he foroilJly rclpeclYoLt?"
A Heclicl,
Q Pictyou file any oriminal charges?
A I was.going t:o oall tha polioe, but I clicln/t,
and that was my fAult: ag"in,
Q Dic\ you have any medioal l"epOI'ts indioat:~.ng
any Idnd of rape? ..
A No,
Q 'l'hen 'you let. him stay thal'e unt:i1 the mornil1g
of the 20t:h, ian/t that: oOrJ~eot ?
.,
30
"
r""""I
,.,~
1 ^ q~a~ i~ porred~,
2 Q !~n't it tr"~,a~~i~ionally thAt YO" ha~
3 "1l9~ifiacl t:he oH~I:ocly Ol,~el" And imllot'teq t:o him thaI: he
4, wcml~ be able to take the ohil~ on the 23~~ when hl~ work
Ii oreWe' were leaving CorPittabHrgh
G 1\ II'ha\:' e not trHe,
7 Q - - 130 th1'\t he oo"lcl h.\Ve '01 l:l!.r\:hday pArty
o with thiR ohil~ in Pi~tebUrgh?
9 /\ 11'hat i~ not tp.le, April 24th he I~new 'l'<\ylor
10 OI11d I wel'e going to Indian )iloho C<\verne, I have a pareofll'll
11 day to. prove it,
1~ Q When ~id you reque~t thOlt~
13 f\ Il'hepereonal day ~ reqLle~ted 1'\ Whi.1fl ago,
14' You have to P~lt in a perl30nAl day to get; it aPPI."oved ))y the
).6 Har1:!ebLlrg City !loard,
16 Q 130, the 23l'd you're indicAting he CAme \:0 'the
17 hOII~e to piclt LIp 'l'aylor to tAIte' him to pittl3purgh?
10 f\ Without: \11e lmowing And not telling me, He
19 left several meaaages l3aying, ):'\11 coming to get my son. I
'20 ,. said,,, Larry, he'l3 going to Indian rnohoCavernl3, I'm,in
21 oharge of eight children for Mrl3, APpleby tomorrow, I will
2~ drive him down and meet '~OLl,
23 Q 80, then you're aaying he forced himself into
24 .the apartment and fOl'cibly removed the child?
26 f\ 'l'hat 113 cor:r,ect:, I came out atld opened the
"
I:
31
..
1
:1
3
4
0.
6
7
8
9
10
:\.J.
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
. 24
25
,,'
~
~
~he ~~me or~er ~hR~ i~ in orde~ righ~ now,
Q +n ather worqfJ, J\.\dge He~~ l,einl3~R~eq the
"
DE:lfenr.1An~'r;l PAr~iRl al.\l3~ocjy dgh~~?
l\ COl'l'ea~ I
QDo yo\.\ hAVe primE\ry a\.\r;ltoqy?
A Cor~'ea~ ,
,
E\reE\, E\nc'l thE\t WE\S to oaal\~' with twenty-four hours not;l.ae to
Ml-a, PeCarlo,
"
TilE WITNESS I
Bl.\t he haan; t clone t:hat I
THE COURT I Ms I Cal'ey, are you in agreement
that thE\t is all trUe?
M8, CARlO'll I don't know t ha t ,
'THE WI'1'NlJJ8131 That is la'Ue I
MS I '8UMPIJID-E'tJLLIVAN I I have a aopy of Judge.
33
:1;
'I'
.'
I;,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
0
9
10
r"""\
"'"
,.
P~fendAnt AP to what h~~ popitton i~ on A~l thl., Wa haye
f.j.fteen mimH:es left fOl: \:\113 \1eA1'ing, I wo\.\ld All30 li)~e to
hAye A ClOpy of .I\.\dga Uea/3' ,order mAge PA!:'t of the l'QPord 130
I haVe 130me ~deA what the eX~ating OU/3tody order ~13,
Mil, Cf\RElY I WOU:\.d YO\1~' Honor l'el3erye A few '
m~nutea to tAlk to the ohild?
1'llEl WITNmllll1 W0\11d you pleA as tA:\.ltto him,
1'um COUR'I', Ilure ,
'l'UEl WITNmss, Il'h<mlt you,
MS, sUMPI4m-I3UI.,I.,IV/lN, At thil'l junatU1'e, Yo~\r
11' .llonor, dO you WAnt my client to \:Alte t.he atAnd?
12 T1IEl COUWl'l Well, I' ye got to he'll' from him,
13 beaa\1ae I'm only heAring one I3fde Of the cC\l3e;
14 . TIUil COURtr, .Yol\ h~d I~laintiff'a mXhibit ]"
15 the paj AmAa, Are you moying theil' Admial3iol1?
16 MS, CARlJlYI Yea, Your lionor,
17 'rUElCOUR'r,' Ia the1'e C\ny objection to the
10 Admi13aion of Plaintiff'a Elxhibit 1?
19 (No responae,)
..20 Il'IIEl cou~'r I Hearirlg none I Plaintiff' a Elxhib.i.t "
21 1.i.s Adm.i.\:ted.
22 (Plaint.i.ff/13 ElXhib.i.t No, .~WAa ~dmitted,)
23 MS, CARElY I You are ordering t;,hat he .testify?
24 TUEl COURT I I don' t haye time f or any mbre
215 Witnesses, I'm sbrry. .1'113/11 heAr h'om the Defend~ntls aide
.I'
35
II II :I-
2
3
4
6
6
7
0
!l
10
11
;1.2
13
14
16
16
17
1B
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
"
I~
,.
~
"
npw,
~^W~~NC~' ~V^N M^Q~+N
hAVing ~ee~ ~U~y pworn/ teetifie~ Ae f011pwPI
,
'l'llm WITNlilS/3, ':(o~\r 1l0nOl-, + lnww yOn qOl1' t
I1wre mnoll t~.me,
"
M/3, /3UMPLlil-/3ur.,LIV1\N I . Mr, MA\Jlin, pleaee,
Let me ~el~ the c.tuel'ltione,
TlIm WI'l'N~S/3, I jUet WAn\: him to lmow tlUlt' my
fAther drove Up for three houre, lie ehoUldbe entitleq to
PIW ~omet:hihg, Tlwee hOUl;e,
Irm~ cou!\,r I 1/11 tell you what we' 11" qo',
We'1.1 l"eeahedule thj.e 'he/.Il:.ing for '~nothe;rtime" We' 11
reaeee, An~ I'll aanl'lult; my eeoretal-Y ae to when we have
time for a further hea;ipg,
'l'Hlil W;rTN~SS 1 What: do, we do with t:he aUl'ltody?
TUm COURT, YO\.l may I'Itep down,
i',
(prief 'paul'le, )
TUlil COURT 1 We / 11 C!~nt!im\e with thie he/.\l:'ing
until. 4115, whiah we ,have another appoinument. The
II ,
. Plt\j.ntiff a/.\n aontinueher aa",e, and then I. Will l'Iahedule an
.'
additionAl Afternoon of hearing for July 31" 19!1O, .atardng
,
At 1130, MI'I.. Carey, do you want: to aontinue examining the
~laintiff, or do you WAnt to .oal1 another witneas?
"
MS, /3UMPLID,suLLIVJ\1'l1 'lour Honor, if time
permits, I Would lilte l',o oontinuemyoroaa,'examination,
36
1
~
.~
Ii
,
THEl COUR'r, Clo <\ha<\q, Mp,' DeC<\rlp I :l.f yoq
~ Will raPl1\11e ~ha p~<\ndt VPU ~re pti1~ undar p<\\:h, .
3 (P<\u1<\ Irene peCAdo rep\.I\11l'ld ~h\3 w~\:nepp
4 ptf\nq, )
5 CROIlIHjJ~^MINl\'l'ION (Con~lq,)
6 ,PV Mil, lluMPtEl-IlU~LIV^NI
,,10
U
:t.~
:).3
:t.4
1Ii
16
17
10'
19
20
21 ,
I,.,
22
23
24
25
7
q
Mp, paClu'lo, We ware wEl~)dng tlWq\\gh ~he t~\11e
o periodp, Elt 1eElpt that are relevant ~o tl1i~pet~t~qn, ap pe
9 . April of 1990 anq May of 1990 t '(ou indioate that the chUd
Wflf.l returned f,rol11 pittPPL\l:gh on the 26th of 1\pdl., h ~ha~
rJOrl"tlot?
A Thflt1e oorrect,
Q At tl1f1t time, yoq did .notfUe <IllY pol.:lce
o\'!flr.geeor make al1Y other
qOl1tempt petition in thie
other than' the filing of the
""
oourt, you did not file flny police
chE\rgee relE\tive tohia'tE\king the child on the A3rd?
AI filed -- I cE\lled my attorney, and he toid
me he' e filing contel1'pt charges,
Q When j,n --
A But I did oa1l the police,
Q
You did Qal1 the polioe? ,
Whioh one are you ta;l.king. about?
BeoEluse the
A
po1ioe were oalled,
Q 'rhe, Weel~ of the 23 rd I
A Not May, You're talking 1\pri:t?
37.
j.
"
:\.
~
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
" 1~
13
14
3.5
16
17
10
19
20
21
22
.23
24
25
I,i
("""
,.~
q lIpril 23rd,
1\ Yel3,'~ cUclll' \: PAP.. \:he polioe, No\: \:hAl:
one,
Q 113 it your tel3\:imony/ Aclclitional~y, thAt you.
cUd not heIVl'l an I\g:):'eement: wi\:h Ml,', MAg.Hn t\lA\: woulcl helVe
Allowecl him to leave with the ohilq on the ~3rd? .
,
Thet'e Wee no Agreement,.' He Imew the!:e WC\e A
following day to IndiAn Iiloho OAveQW thAt I
for, lie lmew thAt, 1\nc'\ my 130n mil3eed hil3'
1\
. Uelcl trip the
hEld tAl~en off
Ueld t!;'ipt
Q
daye o~ echool
Did your child m1a13
thia yeAr?
M~, OARIilY!
..
APpro~imEltely l3ixtee~
11'HIil OOURT I
Objection, TI1E1t/a irr~ieVl\nt.
Me I Sumple-SulliVCln, why would
that mA\:tet'?
I'IS, SUMPLIil-sur,r,IVAl>11 BeaaUf3e I'm at\1emp,ting
to determine Wi\:h what frequenay the Pll\intiff kept this
child out of eahool,
11'lllil WI'I'NmSS I
THill OOUR'I' I
BY MS, SUMPl,E1-Sur,LIVAN I
If he W<\e l3iok, I --
The objeation ie eu.tained,
.,
Q , 'I'hen the next aUetody period t'elEltive to Mr,,,
~1E1g1in WoUld have been the weeltend of May 7th al'ld May o\:.h,
ia J:hat correat:?
~ That il3 correot,
30
.~.
f~
Q find Mr., M<mUll. WfW in t:he lIAl'd13p\.Il.'g ,FaA'
d\.lring t:hAt: weuk, i~ t:hAt oorreot?
A 1~At i13 oorreot,
Q I13n't it t:r~e that: Mr, Mflg~in hAd arrAnged
wi\:h YOl1, to f.\void \:he ob1101lt:19n 0(: you d1.'1vino \:0 Bedfol."q
ear t:he exohf.\ng~, to tAke. the ohild wit:h him for Che'o\.l~t:ody
Weel~end when he was leaving onMI\Y at:h?
1\ 1'/0/ he dict not:, lie hf.\q mact13 an flgreeml\lnt: I
pdor t:o t:hf.\t: fOl" Mot:l)el"' a PAY ,I\nct t:ha\: t:e:rminAt:ect
'l.'hl\rsctAY night, when he C\brl\p\:ly\:ool~ my l'Jon -" ag<\in/
wi.t:hoqt tal ling me - - from l'Jol)ool, "And flmy, who Wfll'J the.
lC\toh~key te<\oher/ didn't know C\nd just C\1'J1'J~ned C\nd let him
go, He t:ool~ him without notify.in9 me, I dic\ I'JflY / oould you
w:dte C\ note for me, pleC\se, to let t:hem - - to \:e:U them
that: I oould hC\ve the ohild, l>!eeqlef.lS to sC\Y, \:hC\t night:,
"
dl1dng the bC\sepElll gElme - - beoC\use he wanted \;0 Bee Taylol"
22
23
24
25
play baaebC\ll/ and he WC\S at the gElme, After the game,
'Paylor WEln\:ed' to 001013 in the oar, beoause he I'Jdc\ he Wa~n' t
.,
hungry, It waa '0100 fit night, .
Q Let me flalt you a ql\E;\stion, Whioh .dl\te al.'e
you apellking of, May 7th?
A I'm talking MC\y 7th,
Q MElY 7th Mr, Maglin'took the' ohild from
'I'
aah601~
A
Wi.thout notifying 11\13, without notifyillg hlle
39
.1
.~
3
4
6
Ii
7
lj
9
10
II
l~
13
14
16.
16
17
",
10
19
20,
2:\. .
22
23
24
25
I , i ~ '.
.' f""i\ M
tha @phopl, H~ ~i~n'~ tell me, At th~t time, J
thought I WA~ meeting him At the ~Ape~All ~ie~~,
I'~ meet him At the ~A~e~All fial~ At 5130,
o ^n~ the ohild WAP ~~ the bApe~All fiel~ pt
6130 w,ith YO\I,' ~.s thAt oorr.eot?
1\ l\n~ I<A:L'~'Y WA/!! AI: my h0\11e on MAY thEl 7th '<\fte:L'
just
I \:old
him
"
pohoP1,
OWAP there Any ippya A~oUt hip. remoVAl of the
ohi1~ . from the l'Ioh,ool on MAY 7~h?
A Yep, there WAS AI1 :t,PPUtil , .1 AI3)~ed Amy, where
i too)~
is my son? I\nct phe p<\irJ, oh, PAulA, HArry him, pidn't:
YOL\ )mow? I s<\:I.d, no, no one - - f3he didn't )nlOW, beOAUl'le
ahe di~n' t hAve Any of the J;lAPElrWprl}, I ~idn' t I~now,
~obo~y Imew, 130, I WAS lil~El livid, I cl:l,~n' t: lmow where he
W<'Is, so ;r went: to my home, HA:L'ry WAS sitt:ing there with my
son'in the oar, l\t t:hAt point: I s<\id, wdt hera, 1'm goin!:1
to go up <\np get iI'Elylo:L' ohanged, It was a~lout CJ\1E1rtel' till
"
five, beoause I had EI maeting <\ftel: sohool, It was the last
'rhursdEli( of the mon\:h, I llE\l:\ gone ttrJ t.c' talt~ - -_
Q MElY 7\:h is the last.ThursdElV of the mon\:~?
1\ Wall, ,it WElS \:he seoond to the lElst Thursday
of the month, 1\nyways, We had golle upstairs to ge\: him
ohanged - - I did, He had fo);loll'ed ma up, I s~i.d, r.ar~:'Y,
,.
wail: OL\tside bY the oal:' I and I'll have him l.'e<\dy in one
minute, /30; I I:an upstdrs, and he Pl'ooeeded \:0 follow me
,.".
" if
4()
1
;l
3
,.11
Ii
6
7
0
9
" 10
11
1;l
,. 13
:t.4
11i
1~
17
10
19
" , 20
;l1
;l2
23
24
26
~
~
UP, At: \:)1<1\: po;l.nh he lw~ t:he Ilareen ;l.n hil'l lU.\l1q / ~nq he
I Ilhut ,the qopr, &nq he pUllheq it: open ~nd p&id, jUllt ~et me
~ring the pqreen ;l.n, I Il~;l.q, no, I don't w&nt w~n~ yoU ;l.n
'the houpe, ,stop, No, I qOn'l: wOlnt yoU ;l.n \:he hpl.\/3e, ~et
tl1e gat ~'OIylor 'l-a~qy / Elnq he Ofln go with yoU to the gOlll1e,.
Thl'lt'll fina, HI'! prooeeqeq\:o PUllh, A\: th&t t;l.me __
Q Mp, DeCOIrlo / lot me 'ClIlJ~ YO\.\, whOltaotl,\E\++Y
ohE\nged from April 20\:h, when Mr, MClgJ.JnW&f3 I'llaeping
yol~ntClri~y ;l.n YOU1' homa, to Mf.\Y 7\:h, when, in f&o\:, you
. qiqn' t w&nt him t:o Oalna into the dam;:?
II Qeoa\.tlle al1ol\gh ip enough. 'I flm tireq of the
&~ll/ila, I tim t.tred of what'll h&ppening, Thl.\rllQ&Y nigh~ he
got very angry pao&l\/ile TE\y].or would not get in' the OEll" with
him. He r&ged Elt: me Elnd started oEllling me a /illl\t/ &.whore,
.scl\m, He s~id, I w:l.ll meet you in Beqford at: 61bo p.m,
Q "You did not fUe t:hil'l protC:)otion fl"om EI~Use,
order until the ;lOth, is thE\t oorreot?
II lie did not hit: me, AIlCI I ElIlSUnleq that).f it:
wasn't a hit.~nd it/s justa pUsh "~ Clnd t:hey had to explain
it ,to me, Domea.\:io Violenoe ./ilays, if he pllshed you and the
door hit: you, yea, it'/il Violence, I /ilaid, well--
"
Q nut: you didn'tp~roeive it a/il violenoe at
t:hat: l?oint?
A At: t:hat l?oint, I!ll admit: it:, Idi~ not,
Q Now, let'/il fool\s on --
41
"
:I-
~
3
1.\
6
"
6
7
B
9
10"
"
+1
12
13
14
16
16
~
~
^ ijim en~e~ing my home~ I ~i~nl~ pnrootvo thrit
MI -" II
Q ~he ~~~e of the B~h, Tht" in tho ~ntA..
~hAt there W~f3 ~n epil30qe O\~ "aohool, .j.p I:ho\: (Jl)I:)!Uo\:','
.~. ThA~ i~ aorreqt, ~t'JI30,
Q The 'epll3ode WF\13 ral.F\I:od 1:0 1:110 f:llrJl: I:hl\\:" yon
wO\ntec1 ~p re\:a!n, ~he ahUc1 in 1111+1:1[1\)l\ru 1:01: MDI:hru"" lJuy'~
1\ Il'hat i,f3 no~ trqe, . I hA~ 1:0 IIIlJnt: him nt: fi 100,
'~ea~UI3'e Th\.\rf3dAY nlgh~ he I3tAtec1" I wU]. noil ym\ 1n IlUl\f:r.ll:'d
~t 6100, .I l3ald, Une, I,.hlldto gel: /lnd lVI', I Wf\1l 1\1:
1101m Harria' High for an in-f3erviae, 1\11r.l I hnrl t:o 00 unt: find
IVP at Holy Spirit,' I left t1.1ere eAdy 1.10 r 00\1111 (Jel:
there, A~ 3136, I walked in the door, flnel howno /ll:nud,ing
'l:heJ;'e paaing, AmY, at thia time, hEld "rAylol: in I:ho bAal~,
Tlly16r Wae running ~round her, She got nervous,
Q Let me agAin foaUf3, !Jid YOI\ tell Mr i . MngHn
,.
"3,7, that hEl dould pial~ the ahild up on the O\:h III: fJohool?
10
19
1\
No, I did not,' No, I dj,d not: t lie nevel: even
tolq me to write a note t He nevei' l3!1id t:o wdl:a n IlCll',e t If!
1/..
20 he would tell me and let me Imow I:hinga
21 Q lan't 'it I:]:ue, Ma, DeCI1I:lo, l:hnt:'Ytlll cUd, .l.n
22 fa6t, right a note forbidding him frolll tllklnu
" 23
24
26
1\
That ia nol: trlle,
--the ahild f:roll\ I:hn Iwhool.'1 .
"
Q
, ,.
1\
That i13 not trlle,
Ii
"
4:1
~
.
Ii
1 9 l\nq thf.\1: yp\.\ q~q. I:hAI: k:npw~ng \:IlAI: he WO\Il'
2 go~ng \;0 Ilhow \.\p \:Ilere 1:1' pio'~ \:he ohilq \.\p?
i A I e<\iq Th\.\rll~AY when \:hf.\1: hf.\ppened, when.
4 ",omeone OElme Elncl ""when he OOlme 1:0 I:he I'lChoo~ OInq pifJJ~eq \.\p
5 Iny @on witho\.\\: not:ifying me, I wrol:e 01. note sl:<\l:ing my \:wo
6 emergenoy n\.\mber@ \:hA\: I fJo\.\1q bl3 reaoheq, beo<\\.1lle r WOllln't
7 in l'IOImi1\:on 13011001, I W~1l qoing f.\" meeting on ADD <\nq liD/liP
8 \.1p AI: John "f.\rr11l."igh for f.\ h<\lf f.\ qAY, r hf.\q to Bet f.\n'
9 IVJ? qOnS f.\t Holy f3pirit HOIlP.i.td, I Ilf.l!q, I will be I:here
10 nol<\l:sr \:hf.\n 3130, r Wf.\1l <\ 1itt:le lAte, I Il<\iq, plef.\se qO
11' not relef.\@ehim tp f.\I1YOl1e \.\nlslls there'S wril:ten form, Anq
12 YO\.\ f3hoUld hf.\Ys f.\'oopy,of the note, beoa\.1f3e,hegrAbbeq the
13 ,note, It: q~c1nl t I3f.\Yc1f.\d, g:r'oll)c1ma or i:\l1ybody, II: f3aic1, .
1.4 plei:\se do not l-elef.\S8 him to no one or f.\I1YOne Ol' f3of\1el~hing
15 Hl~e thf.\I:,
16
Q
After I:he epif3oc1e on the 8th ""
17 A 'l'hursday,
10 Q r'm talking About the 8th, whioh Wf.\sFridf.\y,
19 Mr, . MagHn toolt \:he child from l:he achool, is l:hf.\l: corrsct.?
20 A . Illsgf.\lly, thf.\l: is correot, f.\nd l:he police
"21 W~re cf.\lled,
22
Q
A
'rhepolioe were cf.\lled?
Thf.\l: il3 correcl:,
And y?U werethel's?
Thf.\l: is correct,
"
23
24
25
A
Q
113
"
;.'.
I',
-
. ...
"
1
2
3
q
1\
q
I\n~ ~he lAtah-kay r~qrlu w"rBtl~r~?
'l'hA~ i", cm'l:ap\:,
M~ Mr, Mool.1.n \:001\ \:hu phlld n\ll: nnll pllt: hl,lI1
~ In hll'l cAr?
.6 A .. G!:I~bl)a~ I:h13 rJhUd, I'tlU, 1111' Ill'll,],
6. !I Q Ann, in f:/ciot:, (Un lIpl: :l,ui\Vu \:ho ,wen Im\::l.l. hI!
7 q~.f3ollseed the!3e i!31311611 Wi\:11 \:ho pol l C)() 'I
B. A lie OAlI1l~\:O YCllI1: pll1tlO, I1nel t:hn\:'fl WhOl:O you,
9 in turn, told 'l'Aylol: \:hf.\t: hu II/HI lit) llr.d.l1l: in' qoyl.no uny\:hin9
10 to YetI --
11 Q I'm goin~ I:Cl o)ljoa\: \:0 what: I !lId.d,
12 A' You !3Riel 13omo\:h,\.\lO l:eolly, rle~dmentl\l to IW
.t3 !3on, You have no oiPoioe in l:hirJ 1IIl\I:t:er, you sdd ~o my 130n,
'11\ !\nd he doel3 have a cihol.oe, .lla doel] have tl' dl.l,oioe,
16 THm COUR'l' , Wa'll enter thi~ order 1
lli ('rho f:ell:\.owing Ol:der WAf] ",ntered by the
17 Court')
lB "ANP NOW, this 6th day of: of June, 199B, upon
19 oonsideration of t:he 1'1ninl:l.f:I:' fl Pe\:ition for proteotion
20 Ordel', and following A headng at: whioh IlOth oounsel feel
21 they have nOI: had l3uffio:l.erlt Ulne to pl:esent \:heiroal3eSt
22 t\1erecord shall l:emain open, And I:he Court will reool1Vene
23 011 Priday, July 31, 199B, at 1130 piM" for the oonolus:l.on
21\ of the hearing, At that time, the Plaintiff will be
25 affol:eled (:l11l!l hour wl.thl.n whl.oh ,to oonolude her onse, and the
1\1\
f'I"\ . .
t~
CElRTI~IO"'l'lillI'
'1.
"
I hel'e/Jy oerl::\.fy I:hAI: I:he pl'opeect:\.ng/3 al~e
C1011I:f\:\.\1ect fql1y iind Mo\.q~f\.~ely..:\.n I:he. nol:e/3 I:f\l~en py ills on
'.
I:he above Of\q/3e anct I:hal: I:h:\./3 i/3 a oorreal: I:rall/3or:\.pl: of
'/3<\\11e,
,.
.kn)~
SU/3<\n R:\.oe 'Sl:oner
oefiqi<\l Stenogr<\pher
'"
--~-P-~-------------.~----------~--
The foregoing reoord of I:he prooeectinga on I:he
. - , .
he<\ring of I:he wil:hin mal:ter ia hereby <\ppl"oved and direotect
1:0 be filect,
"
~~J1~~,'
Date -,
, ../." W.".Y
.,' ./
,I' p.
i" """'7 I:? ./
( ''&I-b
_'Ii ' i '~
1-, Jr" ,
,.
46
I't"
"
'I'
"
t"~
~"'""
, PAl1L/1 Il~Jj)NJil nQCI\f~LO,
l'ldnl:Hf
fpr her~el~ ~~d on beh~lf
Q~ her mip9r child, Tqylor
MqgHn,
TN 'l'IllD aOtlHIl' Ol~ COMMoN ~ll~Iil/113 OF
. allMI3IDIH~I\NP COllNll'Y I P/ilNNsnN!ltH/1
y,
NQ, !l0-2VpS CRIMINAl.. 'l'/ilRM
. L/1WRJilNCID IDV!\.N Mi\GLIN, .
Pefeng~nt:
l'ROTJilCTION FI~OM Al3l1Sm
VOl,uMIil IX
TRI\N13PRXPT op PROC~mDINGa
Prooeeqing/3 held before the I1PnorE\ple 11 I wm13I,JilY
OLIilI~, JR I' J" C~l1\berlE\l1d 'COunty cOul"thou~e, CE\l"1iI3~.e /
Penn13ylYcll1iq, 011 Fridqy, Jqly 31/ :\.990,' in CO\,\rtroom
Number one,
" ,
'i'
"
I'
APPIilI\MNCIiI/3 , '
,q
"
MARCUS A, MoRNWHT, III/ Iilaquire
For.the Pl~intiff
BI\RI3I\M SUMl?I1Ii1- SULI,IVAN I maqUd,re
ror the DefendE\nt
VII\VII1A:;I,I/,nd
MM'I: () .'./ d !'!;If~n:)
G c: Ii; lid I.'.' UII" Ub
ORIGINAL
,
'I
11"\'1\"'11"'1.,'.' "'l' .'0
(\ ~ ...1 1( j...U ."1. ...
''')IJ'{' ')'J"II
;1.. .~, rC: I:.
"
"
,.
'*'
,.
"
EQlL,'rlIEl rrJA:fNTIFF
~~~l~ :frene DeCArlo
\Jo!'jey Tr~mp
^~y El, PAtohelor
INDEX ~'O wn'T'lfQlJ!?ElS
D1RElC1' QRQ~ Il~DIlmr~ ImCROIW.
.3 :1.9
;U <l9 36 37
39 43 47
FOR THrn DmFrnNpAN~
LAwrenoe mt MAglio
49
86
INDIiJX '1'0 rnXHIIH~'~
FOR 'rHIil . P.LAIN~'IFi:
1 ~ PAj C\mAa'
2 - Order of CO~rt dAted 7/16/98
MARKElD ~OMITTrnQ
~o
:u
FOR THEl OElFIiJNDANT
1 ~ Letter dAted 11/17/97
2 - Qrd~r of COl\l,'t dateq 6/8/9p
3 ~ Letter dAted 10/16/93
ll8
12 98
66 98
67 98
60 98
..
4 - Order of; Court dated 3/23/98
6 - FOUr photographs
"
" '
,.
"
i. "
,;,
2
+'
~
3
" 4
5
6
7
0
0
10
1:).
12
3.3
14
16
16
17
10
.19
20
23.
22
23
24
~6
il
~
Il'UVl Cpuwr, '1'h:\.13 :\.f~ \:he \::\.me ~nq I1lf\oe for a
aont:iI\l~A\:ion of. \:he hef,ldng on \:he pe\:i\::\'o\1 f.or a pl'o\:ep\::\'PTl
0l7qer fi:\.aqpy PAtllA ~rene DeCtldo on l)ehf\1f of her13e;j.f rl\1q
the Pf\r~ie13' m:\.nor ohi;j.q, Tf\ylor Magl:\.n, We w:\.ll ;j.et the
reqot'q inclioate thf\~ the Plf\in\::\.ff :\.13 I1re13en\: j.n pOL\r\: with
her I1\'lW QO\.I\11'lel, Mf\ratl13 Mal<nighl:, li113'ltl:\.re f anq the pefenqE\Il(:.
:\.13 Pre13an\: in cour\: with his aptln13el, Bf\~para
,
atlmp;j.e-/3t1;t1j.yan, I pelieye at \:he oona~.\\f3iQri qf the pdor
.. .. .. .
qay qf hef\d\1g the Plain\:iff. .Wtl8 be:\.ng f3upjeoteq \:0
n;roI'l8"e~am;~nation qu:dng h\31' aa8e'~:\.n"nhief Py Dafenqf\nt's
notlnael, an, M13. o,Carlo, I ~ill aak yotl to rsPtlme the
'al:f\\1d,
P~UL~ IRm~~ DeC~RLO
IH\Ving been duly 8wol-n, \:e13t::\.j!:\.ed aa . followa I
nllD COUR'l', l~or I:he record, would you 13tate
"
yotlr name again, plef\se,
nl\il WII1'~(jJsa I PE\ula Irene DeCarlo,
"
CROSa-mXAMI~ATlO~ (Cont'd,)
BY Ma, SUMPLli1-aULLIVAN,
. Q Good afternoon, Ma. OeCa:r,-lo, I only' have a
:few more que13don$ for you at I:h113 jLlnatl,lre, Again, peaal\se
we had su6h a 10\1g hial:L1a, sadier in thetasl:imony yoU had
indidated that YOLl had fUed for the proteation.from abuse
shortly afl:er the oadurrenoe of evenl:a o.p.,. April, where the
alleged rape and Idaldl1g of. the ohild had onoLll;red, I think
3
"
"
1
;!
3
~
6
6
'1
a
9
'10
:\.l
12
" ;p
14
,.
16
16
17
10
19
20
21
:a2
23
24
26
,.
~
~
yo~\ tfll3tit:iecl \:hflt: ".hAt. WAll t:l1'l Wl~el~enc:l 01: t:ho ;aOt:h of.
^r~il, i/3 thAt corr~at:?
A No, i~'_not: oOrreot:, April ;!3rd,
. Q OCln I AI3~ wh<\t YOll'l'e l'e.l\t;\hm from, MI3,
pec~rlo? rait A PA~eri~Ar or
^ APdl ;lOtht:hrough ." thllt WI\/3 A S\HlclOly,
ftprp. ;:!Ot'.h, No,' r' l.n not l-e<\cli\1g 1\ r.mlenclm:, I li<Wet <\
. ,
o<llencl<\r, peCA\lfile whllt h<lcl h<\PPllnecl l<\st: time 1.a you I~inc:l of.
"
oonfUfiled me, tn~ing me b<\ok ancl forth through clifferent
,
dAtel3. So, :If we oould jUst refer t:o the {~AY I3pecifioAUy,
I woulcl be better At that, if you'cl clo thAt, ple<\f3e,
'rHIil COUI<'1'I Wh<\t ye<\r Are we tall~ing Abollt?
MS, SUMVI,Iil'SUiJiJrVA" 1 Ninateen 11inety..allVen,
YOllr Honor,
nllil COU\<TI BLlt I neecl the Witneafil to l3<\y
th<\t, I W<\a rencling the trAnsoript from the +Aat hearing,
.mcl Chere are jUat hunclrecls of dates in there but no ye<\rl3
given,
['JIEl WII1'NIilSS 1 Are we talking -- I'm sorry,
Your HOnOl", ~pH1' 20th, 19913, ill that what you'l:e talldng
nbout?
III' Ii'
MS. SUMPiJm,sUiJiJrVAN, Yea,
'rllm WITN!J1SS I You adcl ' 97, .
BY MS, SUMPiJEl-SUiJt,rVANt
Q 1\g<\in, I'm trying to follol~ the allegations
4
(""'~
f'I'\
in YQIU' oompl~inl:, WhAt nAte QO yO\,t Allege \:hAt: t:he ~e1\\lAl
,,.
enOPllnl:el' 01' t:he tApe by Ml:, Ml\gHn of yon oaolll:'l-eq l'
1\ It: Will! not Al~@ge~l; II: hIlPpenec1, II:
hllppenec1 on lIpr.!! +8th At: !lPPl"Ol\i111At:El~y :n 100 P,\11, AI: niahl:,
IIf\!er.\!he ch!lc11'eI1, Were in t:h!3 living 1'0 a 111 Elleeping, l.Ayinq
:I.
'~
3
-1
6
6. qown wi th \:heir. !>leepi.ng Pfl9l'!,
7
Q
1\
130, I:hflt WII!> 1\pr.U +8th of +!l!lO?
ye!>,
o
i .
!l
"
NbW, flgflin, we eElI:~pli!>hec1 thAt at thAt time
Q
!I
J.Opedod Mr, MllgHn, atllyer.l the ;LOth, J.!lth And 20th lifter thll~.
.11 . IIllegedly hAPpened, iathllt correat?
J.~
13
J.4
1\
Q
He !>tllyed until tIle ~o\:h,' whl.ah WIIEl IISunclllY, .
oJ~IIY I 1\fter thllt til11e fr.llme ""
,
A' The l!l\:h, I'm Barry,
16 Q
16 A .
17 Q
10 a Monc1I1Y?
1!l
A
..cor.r.eali"
20
21
22
Q
On I:he 20l:h ia when you ElHege that he kiaJted
I
I:hei ahild while I:he ahild WIIS in a fetal position?
.. "
ThAt ia tr.uel afl:e~ Taylor. hAd r.ipped the box
A
23 from his presents, "because Lar.r.y al:ated "I:hat 'l'ayl.or. ha/3 no
24
l'eapeal: for.. I:oys, and J. I: ' El beoAuse I don' I: I:each him how to
2S r.eapeal: things that he OWIlEl,
6
1.
2
3
11
5
6
L."
1.0
1..:1,
1.2
13
14
~
~
7,
g ^n~ ~hn~ hnppenqd on ~he 20~h?
^ Yel'l,
Q 'l'hAI: WAa ^pr~l, Now, \:ha ne~l: weel~, wh~ah
WO\.lld hAye peen MAY -" le~ me f.It:l"iltel:hRI: , pic\ YO\.l fns I'Iny
kind of AO~~On At: ~he oonol\.lf.lion of ~hA~ weekend?
^ No, O'uI; Qf feAl- for my 130n <md mYl3elf, no,
l\nel l:hA~' a yery normAl, peOnUl3e I j UI31: l"eAel A poole
, . .
per~Aining 1:0 I:hA\:,
Q IN\: yet: ~he feAr for youp 130n elid no\: I'l\:op
you from hAying Mr, MAglin bAby-ai\: fo~ I:he ohilel ~he
fallowing week, whi~h WAI3 Mny 4th, 5th and 6th, il3 t:hA~
.oorreot? '
o
9
^ Beof.lUl'le he 'I'lAiel he woul~n' t do i.,t' f:\gA!n,
Q
Ii1~OUli1e me?
15 " A He cUeln' t bllbY-li1it, TAylol" WAIi1 I'liolt, lie
16 wen I: with Taylol" for thAt night whel"e there Wl'll:e otllflr
17 people, lIis brother, WAI'l there, QIU"Y, anel thel:e were other
,.
16 .worlterli1 there, TAylor hAel stayeel with hif3 ff:\ther, Pfloause I
19 wasgiYi.ng Metl"Opolitan Aoh.ievemenl: Tests, Anel Larry sa;l.el,
20 :r will talte IraylOl", beoAuse it was <l I:wentY-four-hour not:ioe
21l:hing, He oalled prior to it, <lnel I hael to follow the ~ourt
22 oreler, I'm not alloweel to go againat the 00U1-t oreler, nor
23 will I ever, I hael to give 'raylol: to 11im, '. I s<liel, fine',
. 24 T!\ylor ia si9k, He ooulel atay with you while.I go teAoh the
25 next elay, And he said, fine, However, what had happen~d
['
G
'I'
-'\
r"'\
1 w~~ a~ around 1130 ~ha nax~ daY, ~arry had ~rough~ him ~n~o
;l my /'ldlwpl. flnc:! qemllnc:!(~d' ~lw\: Mipp Porpey (phonet:lo) la~
3 Taylor in\:o my room,
'1 0 Wha~ q~te 1'11113 tha~, ml\/lIm?
5 A Tha~ wa/'l l:he weel~ "- yo~ \lave ~he dal:I3, I
6 don/l: h~ve ~he aK~o~ da~e oe ~hat,
7 o po/ now i~'a yoUr l:aat:lmony thAt when Mr,
a Maglin had ~ha oh:lld during the 4~h/ 5~h and 6th of May/ it
9 wal3 acioording to the oourt order whioh allowed Mr, Maglin to
10 /'lee ~he ohild whan he gave yoU twenty-four houra no~ioe'i' II3
1:t. \:ha~ t:rua?
12 A Qa did not have him on tha''1~h, 5th and
13 6th, It Waa the night of the il~h, find he prought him to
14 aohool on the 5th, whioh waa a Tueaday,
15 Q HoW did Mr, M~glin know the oh:lld Wal3 l3iok?
16 1\ Beoaul3e I had tolcl him, .I)eotluae . he had to go
17 to tile emergenoy. room beOaLH3e hl'! had a fevet-, r had
1,0 notified I.,arry/ ;Like I'm auppo!3ed to py law, and told him,
19 Il'hia il3 not about oUatody, Can We. gat baolt to l:he i~.auea,
20 YoUr Honor'? II
. "
21 THE! COUR'r, Now, jusl: II minute. When yol.l/re
22 peing q\~eationed by M/3, Sumple.F.lull:lvan, your reaponl3ibility
,13 lI:La l:o anawer l:he queatioha, Ilol: debal:e w:l.l:h her and not tell
24. her what queationa to ask,
" 25
THE! WITNESS I okay, It waa on . - whe\l I had
~ .., "
",,'
7
15
16'
17
10
19
20
21
22
23
2.4
25
.......,.
~
1
\:A~en IrAyl.ol" 13nnctAY \:0 \:h$ emargenoy room, I 1111':\ no~~.fied .
LIAny \:IWI: ha WAI3 l3iol~,
B~ M,9, ,9UMr~~-,9UL~IV^N,
o ThAI: WAI3 whqt dAY?
fI 'rlmt WAI3 \:he, 31;d, LIAl"ry WElI3 up worl~ing on
\:h~ 4\:h, I hAd \:old him thElI: I took \:he dAY oCf on \:he 4\:h,
LArry oAl+ed and I'ldct, Wfjll., OAn I l3ee 'l'.\y~Ol"? He gAve me
the \:wen\:y-aoyr-hotir no\:ioe, ~ine, I' SAid, l3ure, find I
WAS pre\:l:y lenien\: wi\:h \:hAI:, ^nd he's like, we~l, then,
I' l~ l~eep 'Il'tiylor, I l3aiq, i:htit' 13 gl"eAt, IrhA\: will. help me
ant, '~eoaUl>e I' m 9~,ving Mt!J\:l'opol:l.\:tin ^clhievement Testl> \:hA\:
Weel~, ,90, he hAd l~ept 11'Aylor fol:' the evening of the 4th,
II
MId \:hen, At AI,"onnd 1,30 Ihe bro\.lght, him to my 130hoo~~..
withoL\\: my ImoWledge, beoA.Ul>e he agreed to meet me a\: .my
hOl11e C\t 3115, l1'hAt'l3 what hAd happflned on the 5th,
Q ,90, at that point, At least during the week
oJ: May, you were agreeAble to having M;r, MagJ,in A\: your home
and meeting him at YOUr home for these'transferl3 of oustody,
il3 \:hAt correot?
fI That is correat.
Q And at least unt:il the 7th, you were 11/wing
Mr, Maglin help with the ohild in doing baseball and
"I'
a~sisting In the tr.nspor\:ation of \:he child baak and forth
.to the basebAll ~al11el is that oorreot?
fI That is not true, He pioked him up illegallY
,
;1
3
4
5
6
7
o
9
1Q
11
12
13
14
o
,"""\
r,",
:\. on the 6 t:h from (3chopl, f.lnel f\111Y -.' ~ Wenl: to I:he flohool, an~
;a I (3f.liq, '1\nn', wlwre' fJ 'l'AVlo? ilhe PAl-el, oh/ I elieln't Imow,
3 He wl'Jnt wit:h hi(3 elAel, f\nel r'm Hl~e, wh<\t: qO YO\1 meAn he
4 went: withhi(3 elAel? Hi(3 elf.! elieln't tell me he WA(3 picking
5 '. hi.m \.Ip Aftel' (3ohoo1., 'l'her.e, WAfJ no not:e, '.!'heve WA(3 no\:hirm'
6 to +et: me lmow thflt I.Ar+Y 11f'\el [licl~eel him \.Ip, I' VEl I)een
? ~+ying to get f\long find worl~ with t:hifJ mAil And t;rying to
0' eleC\+ with fill of thef.le if.lf.l~lef.l ,. He just thinl~f3 \:hAt: he OAIl
9 jLlf3t come Am] \:C\l~e my child whenever it' (3 cOllvenient for
10 him, I WAil Lmf.lWAre t:hflt he WAI3 tAI~ing my f.lOn to the game,
11 He waf3 going to oome to the home to get my child, 1113 p;l.ol~eq
12 h:l.m up at the I'lCJhoo+ without my lmowledge.
;L3 Q MI3, peCal"lo, it il3 hil3 chilcl, too, il3 \:hf.lt
14 ..oorrect?
15
A
Thf.lt ia correct,
J.6 q And YOLl hflve I'1hflreel leg<\l custody of thia
.17 ohild, ia that cOrrect?
18 1\ Yea, and I hflve primary phyaiofl1 . ouatody of
19 the chilcl,
20 MR. Mcj<NIGH'l', Objection, Your Hohor, 'rilis
2.1 is debC\ting, Irhia is not queat!oni119,
22 't'nEl COURT I . Ms, Sumple-Sullivan ia jU$t
23 C\sking questions,
24 BY MS., SUMPLEl.SULI.IVANI
25 Q Again, by your adn\isaion, and the
~
I ~
:1.
~
3
(\
6
6
7
0
9
. 10
11
"I, J:~ '
13
.
14.
16
16
1'7
10
19 '
20
21
22
23
24
25
/""'1
r""i
,
,
(:want:y-ftO\\l"-hp\.lr r.'\.l~e thl\t: WtHl ~,wt:it:\.l\:eq in t:he Orq(:ll: ~l-Om
..
a\\qge Hepp, Mr, Mllglin hRq the right: t:o p~ok \.lP the chilq At
, .
PPhool H t:he~:e Wl'\f3 oontl\o\: to you t:hAt he WAI'! in \:ha
HAl:ri!'lPllrg' arell?
^ If .11e woulq \:elLmf:l, 01" if Ilnypocly elf3E1 ip
to pipk up my ohilcl, I woulcl tell ~he pchool or let: the
pohool Imo\'{, or I wo\.\ld j\\f3t: hllV€l oomt1\on QO\lrtepy to le\:. Amy
lmow, No):ioclY lmowa who'p piol~inghim up, I l1\ean, you olln'\:'
jUet aap\1me that: f3omeone if3 jLl/3t going to get him, Irhen I
go to get; him lit /301'1001 I\ncl no one'e there, lie nevel:', tolcl
II
me he wap p;\.oldng him UP lit eohool, He /3dd he WIlP go:l.n9 to
mee\:. me f.or ths\lnifol-m - - he wapn' t going to come into my
home "- - WI'\:l.t:out/3icle eo I oo\\ld ~et the \miform for Iraylor,
get 'raylor reacly, and he would p~ol~ him up lit the front:
door, 'rhat wae Larry' a e~planlltion .to me ~n the 6th that he
WI\f3 to qo,
Q ,90, he hlld t:he ohild on the 7th, and he went.
to the ahild'.s baseball gllme,'il3 thllt oorreot?
A' He wae wa~t:ing out:aide my apartment, He tool~
the ohild, 'l'hllt' a when he oame into the l19me, I aeltl3d him
not to oome into the home, 'rhe blind had fel.J.en from the
window, He eaid, oh, here's your blind, Hete's your blinn,
l,et me oome up, I said, no, Larl:Y,
Tim COURT, Wait, wait, wait, I'm sorl:y, It
was a aimple question, and I don't l"amElt1\ber it anymore,
10
.,,"
1
~
3
II
6
~
7
0
9
" " 10
r"""I
"
~
di~oonUinu~~ usina him, beo~uaa l found ouU Uhrough YOUr vi.
yoU, Uh~U thi~.W~~ noU filed unUil Uhe ~6Uh, We h~d
di.oussed this l~at timet Your Honor,
II'Hm cquWl'1 l / m apl,ry,. 'l'his a,wwe~, ;l~ too
oonfusing, Wh.U is that? ThaU's .11 th~t Wa~ aaked, just
Wh~t ia n.?
11'1I1il Wl'l'Nmss I l\ oontempu of ousUody order,
II'UIil COUR'l', 11, oontlampt of oUatody ordel:,
Il'hat means l;hat: ~ jUdge found somebody in oontempt?
THm WITNmss, Taylor Wa~ taken illegally, l\
11 . pet;;I.tion for oont:empt of oustody,
1;1 'rum COURT' ok<lY,
13 BYMS, sUMP~m-SU~~IVANI
. ,
111 Q Now, this petition for oontempt of oustody
15 Waf.! filec1by your oounsel, John Connelly, :la th~t oqneot?
16 A lit the time, yes, th<\t :ts oOl'reot,
17 Q You h<\d <In opportunity to review thi~
10 pet~,tion with'Attorney Connelly before you filE\d it, is that
19 oorreot?
20 1\ l'Io, I did not, beoause I had told him the
21 speoifio dates <lnd signed it, He said, sign this paper, I
22 will take it ovar immediately,
23
24
25
Q
1\
rJet me show you the --
'rhat's what r signed, Il'hat' ~ the paper I
signed,
,.
13
r"""'I
,'I
,...\
"
1
q
Yo~'rQ pointing to tllQ veri~io~t~on, I~.th"t
, .
;a oorl;eot?
:l
II
11
Q
~~At i~'cprreot,..
11'ho vel'.ificA\:ion ~~ l~f\teq MAY ;l6tll, 1998, it.!
5 thAt correot?
6
1\
~~At'~ not "- I qidn't write thAt, I w"~
. .' . I ,
. ,
ther-a on the
he woqlQ get
Q
ConneJ.ly AnQ
13
1\
'I'hat :1:13 not aooqrate, It w"~ May 1<jth Wilen r
14 Went: into hie off ioe, I qon't how we oan get Connelly to
15 tAl)~ to UI3, Out ,May 12th i~ when I want, anQ that WAI3 a
16 'ruel3dAY, beof\l\ae ht'l, ooulCln' t sea ma on the Monday,
17
Q
,90, thia petit.ion WEla filed on MAY 26th by
18 your attorney, f\nd then you f.peQ thil3 Pl'oteotion from ab4se
19 mf\ttel' on MOlY 27th, il3 that dOl'r.eat.?
~o 1\ ~hat ia oorreot, I t~lked With Legal
21 ,9al'vioea pdor to thf\t, but I filaQ for - _ thflt fil1C\l1y Went
"~I
22 th];ough thepet:ition on tha 27th.
23 Q 1\t f\ny time that you. filed thil3 petition for
24 oontempt, did you eval' rAiae Any of thel3e f.lllegAUi6nl3 of new
'25 f\buae of the dhild a$,l1de the If\st hel;ldng before LT\.Idge HeSI3~
,
'.
14
"
].
;l
3
II
5
,,' 6
7
~
9
10
:ll
],2
],3
],4
15
],6
17
].0
],9
'20
21
22
;l3
24
25
~
;MI\
^ Yee, I diC\,
Q .. ^re \:hey apn\:A.1.neQ ~.n any plea<Urm pe~pre \:he
OoUr.\:?
1\+ didn I \: even l3ee \:h:\.l3, I [:'lid not: l3ee \:hil3,
Il'hil3 il3 why Mt", Oc;mnlil+1y WAI3 dil3oo\Wimled,
Q '1'0 your lmowledge, to thil3 date, al3 we l3it
here p/?for.e thll3 Oourt:, in t:he OLll3tody aat:ion, anC! s:\.nce
Judge Hel'ls ul1founded t:he ElUeg~done t:hat: yo\.\ had maQB p#or
t:o Optopej." of 1997, have you ever Hled any Elat:ion in t:he..
oUI'lt:bdy,oo\.\rt: seekingElny ~ind of rellef for t:his oont:inued
ab\.\~e ~hat: yOU I'lay ooourred thro\.\g\1 May of 1990?
A We I3till. hElve not ~iled ".'
MR, Mol<~IGllTI,. May it pleal3e
TUm WI'l't-lmaa, I'm sQrry,
,
MR ,Mol<~IGIIT I May it: please th~ Oo\.\rt, there
have been two petitions for I3peo:l.al relief filed whioh haVe
now been dismiesecl beOl~Ul3e we' va reaohed an Elgl,"e(3'ment on
OU/ltOdY' I thilll~ this' whole diaousl3ion on oustody il3 not
relevant to the proteative order,
"
i'
ll'Hm COURT, MI3. Sllmpla-Sull:l.Van?
,. MS, SUMPll\il..SUllllIVANI Frbm our pOI3~tion, if,
in faqt, this ciontinuad behavior of abuse Wal3, in faot,
oontinuing as alleged irt this petition, it would l3eem
logioal, that they wciuld havs been ~ail3ed in all de the
l3ubsequent oUI3\:ody filing/l that have been ooourr:\'ng, and
15
1
i3
3
11
5
t.' 6
7
8
9
, , 10
1:1.
~.2.
13
14
15
16
17
'. . 18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
t"~
~
. t;hl'l~ hi'll! no~ OOP4n-eq, 1'hEl 1n00t:ter O\.ll'r13nl:ly tl'l t:he~imtng
of ~h;i/3 aont:<:l\11pt pet.i~ion !\nQ t:he 1?Ii'f\ ~o 13\\Pl'ltl'ln~il\~13 ~he
mpt:.ive/3 ~hl\\: we pelieve unqerlh ~he fiHng of t:hil3 !?l!'f\,
MR, M~lmIOH'I'1 YOUl' liqnor I ~he i/3/3\\e of
OUf'l\:pqy haf'l been heftvily lit:igateq ~heae ll'le~ ~ew month!3,
..
tt: re/3\.11teq in eln orqer of pourt l3.igneq Py J\.Ic\ge Ilel3/3 i'lt:tf!r
i'I oonoilitition on thl:ee oon~eI11Pt: pet:i~iolll3l emd JI\qge He~/3
hC\d ~wo petit:ion/3 for I'lpecil\l relief, Om: pet'it:ion for
I'lpeciEll relief., whioh I filed on PElhC\!f of t:he Plain\:if,f,
<\f'llteq t:hl\t:, pecC\\.Ille of t:he i'lPUf'lt3 /1nd )J~Ci'll\l3e of. hil'l I\qt:ionl3,
no fur\:her vi!3it:ation hE\ppen, 'l'hE\t'/3 aU peen l'e/301veq by
'. ,
t:he orde.t,'of' oO\.ll,'t ~hE\t: we rlE\n ,.to .E\dmi\: q/1.teq J\.I1Y16t:h, in
whioh 1'1 l3et /3ohequle WClI'l l3et: whel'eby the Defenqemt h/1c1
oe'rtE\in pedoqf'l of oUf'lt:ody the rest 'of the f'l\.lO'\11el', and thel3e
twenty, four-haul' viaitationl3 !3toppecl, anq 1'111 e:ltohl'lngel'l were
goinff to be. hE\ppening now E\l: the St:E\te Police BE\ rrl'\Clt 13 , 13<;J,
,.
thE\\:'13 bqen deE\lt 'with, and we'll put t:hE\t: E\13 E\ matter of
. l'ecol'q, BI.\t it' 13 not relevant to the il3l3tlB of this il3!3ue,
whioh deE\lt with. B\Tentl3 thE\t hE\Ppaned pdol' to this,
MS, SUMpLm,aULLIVAN I YoUr 1I0nor, MI'l. DeCal'lo
hEld gc;>ne before the CO\.lrt in CUl11bel'lancl Count:y anq 130\.lghl: !IIi'
ex pC\rta petition in October alleging all kincll3 of I3BXUE\l
E\buse and ~)hysical abul'le of this child.. 'I'hal: WE\S \\nfoundecl
by JUclge Hel'ls in December of 1997, E\nd hil'l cUI3t:ody dghtl'l
wet-a l'einst:ated I In regE\l:'cll3 to the pet.iti61113, thel'e have
16
.,.
:\.
2
3
'\
Ii
6
7
a
9
~O
11
12
13
11\
.15
16
17
1!l
19
20
21
22
23
21\
,25
"
,'....'1
"'"
\a'He,
q Me YOH IIWfll'e ~hll~ Chi1Qren M1Q YOH~h
/3ery:l.oel3 :In 1\Uegh13IlY Coun~y fOHIlQ \:hp/3e !.\Ueg!jQon/3 of:
l3eKHlIl IIbHl3e al/3o to be HnfoHnded?
1\ 'Irhf\~ i~ ~l'He, Al1tll\Uegheny f:OHl1Q t:hil3 QIW
alf.!o unf:oUI1Qf,1Q,
q 113 it: fllf.!o t:r4e that: the OUI3t:OQY ey!.\14n~ion
t:h!.\~ went: on M p!.\r~ of ~hf\t: :lnit:b~, O\HI~oqy 0<11313, whjol. Wllf.!
en~ereQ and if.! P<ll."t of: t:he Cl\mberlllnq CO\ln\:y orqer, t:he 1991\
,
oi-qer, t:h!,\t: t:hel'e W<l13 no aeXl\al or phYl3iqa~. abuae foUnq of
your ah:l.lq by \:hl') Allegheny Court?
A It W<l13 IIU l\nf:oundaq, t:hat il3 \:rue,
M/3, I3UMI?LE-I3ULLIV1\l'It . !'Io furt:her ql\el3 t:l ana ,
,.
MR, MoJ{!'I.rQll~'1 I jUl3t hllye <I few,
'REDIRmCT mXAMIN1\TIO!'l
IlY MR, Mol<!'IIGIIT I
Q Ian'tit: true that: from the t:ime th!.\t thel3e
eyentl3 happeneq in Apl'il and May you wet'e very oOlloel-neQ
about: YOUl' welf.are anq the Welfare .of you;!: 1301'\, Taylol'?
A Correot,
,
Q Isn't: it 1.11130 true't:hat you went to your
pl'iol' oounsel and sought l'el:lef by way of oontempt:
prooeedings/and you all30 t:hen started thil3. proteot:ion froln
abuse with Legal Ser~ioe~?
A That is t:rue,
19
,.
>. ,.
'Ii
" I'
1
;l
3.
<1
5
li.
7
0
9
10
:t1
12
).3
14
15
16
17
1B
19
'20
'1
:u
22
23
24
26
.......,
I,"""
,.
o
1\
'0
+t: hllPp13neel Aho\.1t \:h~ l3<\me tima?
1'hl'lt il3 tl"Ue,
1\13 /I ;re/3\.1lt: of aoma of the v/ldo\.1/3 pati\:ion/3
<ll1el t:he OOntempt petit:ipn/3, ther,a W/lf.l /In ot'clel" of OO\.1rt
ent:areq auly t~a 16\:h, i/3 th/lt oorreot?
A Yel'f,
(Pl&intiff'e ~xhihit No, ;I Wf.\f.l mf.\~i~ecl for
~.elent;ifio/ltion, )
BY MR, . Mal<NJClII'I',
Q I I'fhow you /In axhilJi t I' ve htlel ml"lr)~ecl
..PlC\j,ntiff' /3 Iilxhih.tt 2 for purpof,lel'l Of iclentifioation,. WOUlel
"
you :Lc\en t: Hy th/lt: fOl' \.11'f7
A 1t'l3 tin orcler of oourt:,
Q +t:' e cltlt:eq cruly - -
A July 16th, 199B,
Q Signed hyJl\dge Hel'f/3'~
A Yetlh, I<evin Hess, Yaa, JUelge Ha/3I'f,
MR, Mal(NIClHlr I Your IlonOl", we tI/3l~ t:htlu thtlu
he Cldmitted tll'f Pltlintiff's 2, indiaFlting tI l-eaolut!on, 1'1,1;
letlet fOl" tha 8Ummer I of oeJ~ttlin pel."iod/3 of visii:/;\tion,
THm COUR'I', M/3, Sumple-StlUivtlll, do YOU htlve
tiny objeotion to the tldmission of Pltlintiff's Iil~hibit 27
,
MS, SUMPLIil-SULl,1V1\N I No, '101.11' Honol-.
'rHm COURT, Pll"lintiff's Iil~hibit 2 is
admit: tad.
!J
20
"
,,' .
,.
,;"'1
M
1
Q
Who e~phl\nged word13?
a ^ PaU~a Anq I~rry, ~ b~pkeq ou~; beQAU13a even
3." I:hoqflh I didn' \: :).il~e t:ha\: \:he ohi:\.q~'en were ~here, ~ dign'l:
11 . fee~i\: war> my p1aoe, II: Wa~ t:he,i.r argument:, ~t: Wa13 - - yP\~
6 )mow, up u.nt:!1 t:hip poi.nt:, Ilmaw not:hing,
6 Q At: !:my t:imec1ur.tng I:hal: e~ohange be\:ween Mr,
7 . M.mlin <lI1cl MI'l, DeCado, did you hear Anyone t:hre<l~en anyone?
o 1\ Ve!3 ,
9 Q What: did you h~ar?
10 A He \:o~.d her t:hat he W<l!3 go.ing to get dd of
11 hel', lie !3aid that !3he wal3 an l~' ing pl3yoho i.n f,ront of t:he
~a ohi.ldren, He prooeeded ~o !3ay in front of the ohi1dren t:hat
13 my !3tepl3on'l3 father, ,ny hU!3hand, hEld cUl'ltody of hil3 130n
111 pecAur>e my stepl3on' 13' mother WA13 an [0" ing psycho jUat lilte
16 MI'l, PeCarlo,
16
He said all of that in your presence. and .in
Q
, j, '
17
the prel3ence oll Il'ay10r?
10
Vel3, he did.
A
19 Q Did he address you <It all dUringthil3 time?
20. Did he ",ay anything to you?
:a:t
22
23
,. 211
A Vel3, he did,
Q What did he say to yoU?
A lie add, you are done, too, YoU'l'e done,
Q What did you take that to meElll?
A A threat, And ! aalted him, are you
215
26
"
II"
,.
0(;
1
2'
3
<1
5
6
"
6
.9
10
.11
12
13
"
1'1
15
16
17
i'f 16
;\.9
20
!
21
22
;." 23
24
25
,""""
fI'"
I:lwe~~en~ng Ilie', J"~rrY?
Q . 130, WhAt hAPpeneq then?
11 Then he tfr~l)peq 'J'Wl'~or by t:he Al"m, We~,~,
~hi~' i~n'~ of OOUr~e, he hAd ~o ge~ thA~ 13egA th~~ he
bought' Anq tAI~e wil:h .him,
Q 11 l3egA gAme?
11 Ye~, It WAS a plAY~~at~Qn, I~ Was -- he
hf\q \:Joug!W it:, .clOd he WAnteq to, \:alte it: w1t:h him, He
grAPpeq Tf\ylol- \:Jy the I\rm, You ooulq tell 'J'aylor cUd not
Wf\ntto \;10, '~'f\ylor wal'! I3flying, I qon't WAnt to go With yo\.! ,
I clan It Wf\n\: to go wHh you,. He Wf\S SAY iOg I you 're going
'with me, Elnq he grf\pbeq him by the arm f\ncl toolt him o\.!t oJ;
the f\pf\rtment physioally,
Q f',jow,when you lf1ave the.apartmenl:, how QQ YO\.(
get to the /ill:ree\~ level? II'! there an eleVf\tor or I3ta~rl3 Qr
whf\l: hl\ppeOP?
11
Q
There'a three flights of stairs,
Oicl . you opserve him taking Taylor dQ.wo the.
stairll'~
11 Mo, I dicl not,
Q oicl yoU observe him at all following him
leAving the apartment?
11 Yell, I hacl went -" after he left the
apartmel1t I I hacl Went out to the baloony again I
Q What clid you see when you got thei"a?
27 .
1
;;I
3
11
5
6 )!
7
0
9
10
11
12
13
14
" 15
16
17
"10
19
20
21
2;;1
.23
24
25
f"l,
~
,.
1\ 'l'l\ylo:r. l'\\I1n:l.ng ~l"Om h1m IHly:l.ng, I qon' t: w~nt:
\:0 go wit:h you, 'Anq he ~~iq \:0 'l'~ylor, get: t:h~ HpH ~~ok
11131:6, VOU'l"a gol.ng WJ.t:h ma, 'l'OIylm: oame ~ li~t:le fu;r\:her,
lie gl:/lpbeq'I'~yJ.or ~nq PIlt: him 1n t:he OAl',
o Did he phya:l.oAlly piok TAylor Up?
1\ I wouldn' t: ~<1Y t:\)0It: he piol~eq him UP, ~t: Wf\e
mo:r.e of 01 I'lhoVe, get: 1n t:he o~r,
0.. WhAt: happeneq /lft:e:r. T/lYl9r wae in t:he O<1r
I'
\:hen?
1\ Well, Mr, M<1g1in et:/lrt:eq t:he oC\r, pulleqout:
;'
into t:he ~t:re.et:, I\nd c1eoideq he woulq at:op <1gain <1nd at:C\rt:
yf;llling Elt: me C\gl\in,
0 Pid he \Jet: out: of t:he O~l" t:o yeU C\t: Y9u?
,
A Ye~1 he c.\j.d,
.0 .When he got: out: of t:he ol\r, whC\\: did he do?
1\ Het:ol d \11e t:h~t: he oouldn"\: believe I w~s
doing 't:hia I t:h~t: when my st:epson w~s ~:r.ound him, he \:1:eC\ted
,
my a\:epl3op juat: lil~e h\"l would t:re~t: hia own aon, !\rId at
t:hat: point: 1 stl\t:ec.\ I if you tl'eat my st:epeol1 the wC\Y YOLl
.. treC\t: i YOLll" 'son ,I gon' t:want my stepaon I\rol\nd you,
o He '/3. doing C\ll of thia from the ~treet I'"
yelling up t.o a baloony t:hree floors Llp?
A Yea,
Q So, he'e very viaiplY upaet?
A Yea.
20
1
;1
3
1\
6
6
7
8
9
10
'11
1;1
,il. 13
14
..
Ii" 16
1~
17
. . 10
19
20
21
22
23
24
26
f......
,"'"
Q CoHlq YOH l3ee 'l'AylQl7 At: t:hil3 point? WhAt: Willi
~Aylor 1 ~ I~e?
,.
1\ flat:.\.\<llly / I WA/3 look:l.ng r.'Arry dght: ;j..n t:lle
eye, I reAllY .- TAylor WAI3 in the oar, He oo\.\ldo/t get:
out,
Q J\t: Any po:l.ot: While he W<\13 on the l3t:reet:, waa
. T<\ylol" Upl3et: or orying when he Wafl tryj.n~ \:0 get: aw/w from
h.J.s fflt:her?
11;. Qefore he got in the Oal" / yel3, He W<ls
yfdbly UPl3et:, ory:l.ng, He r.lic\' not: want t:o. go,
Q 1Ift:er 1)13 e:/Cohf.\ngecl thol3e 1&l3t wordl3 w.J.t:h YoLl,"
WhAt h<\ppened?
11 He got in 0<\1' <\ncll3pecl off, It:olcl paula /
YOU neecl to 0<\11 the police, You need to 0<\11 your
<lttorney, Youneecl to do 130\11ething, Thil3:1.l3 wrong, He
I3hoUld not be <\110wecl to clo this in front of the chilclren,
Q
!>IoW/ this was on the 231"d of April/is that
I oorreot?
A Yes,
Q
Wh<\t "til11e of the clAY Waa :I.\:?
, I'P
11 I would say arouncl 4,30/ 6,00,.
MR, Mo!(ltlIClH'I' I Those a17e all the quest:l.ons I
"
have,
CROSS-ElX1IMI!>IATIO!>l
BYMS, SUMPLEl-SULL.tV1I!>I,
29
/I
,,<"
:1.
2'
3
1\
13
6
7
"
6
9
:LO
, ~ 11
12
13
'14
113
16
17
~ " 16
,
19
20
21
. ;'....'\
\I
~
. g ~o~~YI ~n YPUr ~ir~ot te~timonYI yoy
"
inr.lJ.ollte~ thllt YO\.\ I1l1ye lmown M~, DeCfp.').o for <lPPl."o:x:illlflte).y
ten month~1 i~ t\lllt oo~r~ot?
A
Q
the hot tlW.t
t<l~ldng <\!)Out
Yef3,
lW:\ yo\.! lIiao in your te~dmony referretl t:o
yo\.!.went to, quote, theil' home, Were you
Mr, Mf\gHn f\nc\ M~, DeCf\r~o'~ \1o\1le, or wh<l\: di~
,
YOl\ meAn when you ~<lic\ their home?
I don't unc\er~t<lnc\ wh~t ybu melin, I ~<lid
1\
thei:):' home?
g
A
Q
A
home?
Q
A
Q
Ye~,
When?
When you w~re f\nswering yol\r que~tiona,
When I !ldcl I WM t:al~ing my f.lon to \:heir
Right,
I was !lpeal~ing 'of PAul<\ And !'.larry' a home,
I ,. '
So, you aee them aa A ooUple, at le<lst as of
May of this time, l:hat they were together andthf\t that was,.'
,.
~uPte, unquote, their home?
'A Well, I aee that no matter when .1 went ,~- I
22. mean, it WIIS, ~- usually it WA,e the Weel~enda I but When I' went
23 "there, 'Larry WAS there,
"
"
24.
213 Clol.-reot?
Q
O\(IIY, 'l'his was as of April of 1996 I is thllt
I'
30
L
',;
+
;l
3
II
5,
6
7
11
!l
10
11
1~
13
14 ,
'15
16
17
10
19
20
21
22
" 23
24
26
I"""
~
!\ Vel'l,
Q Now, YO\I~' l'lon or p\:ep13on, pl:ew, he Wf.\1'I A
,friand of TAylor, il'l thAt aorreatl
l\ YeAh, 'J'hey Were in, Ilahool together,
Q 1\pproXimAt:ely fa):' the mOn\:\w p~-eaeqing the
!\p~'H epilloQe I r.lid yO\\ hAye Any pro~)lem with MI: I MAglin
t:AI~~.ng PL'ew And 'l'Elylo~' Elnei ~oing the k:incll3 01: thingl'l he cii,q'
with the ohild~en7
A No, I did not,
Q And he did A lot of things with the ahilciren,
l'luah Aa Chual~ m' Cheelle, alim\iinfJ gyml'll Elll of thoae thinga
whioh EI df.\d doea, il'l thf.\t right7
,
1\ Y~B, he aid,
Q And you hEla no p~-oblem with h1m doing thol'lE!
thingi'll'
^ No, I ciid not,
"
Q At Elny time, did TAylor yoiae Any objeot1on
to you' about hia father'i'
^ NOI he cUd not.
Q And had he ..eyer refeL-ended any feaL' of Ida
father?
^ NOI he did not. ,.
Q NOWI when you got to theil' home on that date,
did YOU have any idea of what Waa tl:ahapiring fOL' the
.,
weeltend, whioh would have been the weekend of l"l'idElY the
31
...... .
I. 1
~
\,
1 ;a~t:11 t:1WO\\ght:1W il6t:h of flpr~l?
2 ^ No I I did nO\l,
3 Q Wf.ll'eyolI <lware that: Mr, Maalin hac1 a. ph't,hday
4 party plAnned for t:he child ~1 Pit:t:~Pllrgh w~t:h hi~ family?"
S f\ I \)eOllme I'\Wiilre of i\:. when I haanl P<ll1la
Ii \.,13Uina r.,arry t:hl'\\: ~hB wl'\~pdnging him, 'rhey were go:l.ng to
7 meet t:o bring him to the meeting epot, Thl'\t'~ when ~ knew
o I'\bol1t: it, I dic1n/t know I'\bout it prior, no,
9 Q fit the l:iln~ thllt you 1'\1'dvec1, WA~ thel'e I'\I1Y
10 lllggl'\ge, baggAge, any iteme l'eac1y for Ml', Ml'\glin to pial~ up
11 the ohilc1?
12
1\ No, t:hel:e Wl'\fm/ t,
Q 1\nd you Wf.ll:an' t: pdvy to any of l:he
acmvereAtibne thl.\t ooourred begin .M~I Maglin and M~, DeCl'\rlo
abollt the plane fOl' the weekend, . were you?
1\ No,
Q I would aasume thl'\t Dl,ew 111\1:1 I'\t:t:endeq t:hh
13
14
15
1G
17
10 b:l.rthdl'\Y aleep-over t:hat oool\rl:ed on.t:he' 18th of 1\pdl in
19
20
21
22
their home, in t:he DeCarlo home, is t:hl'\t: oorreot? '
l\ Yes, he did,
'Q .. Did you aot:ually piolt t:he chilq up on I: he
10\:h -- or the next: mOl:nil19?
23 1\ Yes/ we did,
24 Q 1\t: t:he, t:ime that you Wel'e thel'8, can you.
25 deacdbe for the Court what the olimAte was when you pioken
32
1-
2
3
"
II
5
6
7
0
9
10 ,
11
12
13
;L4
16
16
17
18
19
20
21
"
. ;l2
;l3
211
2B'
.~
"
,
~
~'O\n' fJPrIHP on \:h\3 morn:\.r19 of. t:he 19\;h7'
f\ 11'he next: mo~:ning when we piol~eq him HP?
Q It Wa~ A ~leer-over, oorr\3p\:?
A Y\3A!I,
g Whqt: time qiq
A 11m rial: ~H+~,
,!3omet:\.me a1'01.1r\ctthare,
Q WhAt: WA~ going on in ~.he hou!'lehqld when YoH
piakeq YOlh: ohUq LIP thAI: morning of. \:he 19\:\1?
A I really ~ - other th<\I1 whAt tJ;'ArI!'lpireq Af.t:e!-"
I !-,eAlly aAn'l: remember l:t.I~e WhAt: tlie -- c10 you meAn WA~
there ten~ion in the Air?
Q Right, Was 1:\1ere ArgLlment? WAS there fear?
Wa. it you were pioking your kid UP after B ,pleep-oyer,
evel'ybody had A gl~eat time and Was up haH I:l~e n,i.gIW?
A Well, yef\h, The ohHdren were everybocty
haCl agref\l:.\:imEl, yef\h,
Q So, in dealing Wil:h Ms. DeCarlo anCl Mr,
'.. ." '
Maglin over a ten-month period, ctic1 you notioe any marked'
,ohange in their inl:el:f\ot:ion on the morning of the 19th?
A Yes,
you pi~!t you!-'
Nine I ten in
ohilf.l HP?
t;he mO!-'!'lir19,
,
"Q Whal: did you notioe?
A' PAula was !,Ipeet, Her and I hact Wenl: 1:0 the
bedroom to I:allt, Do you WElnt me to tell you What: she I'lail:l
or What: happened?
. 33
,
"i.
1
~
3
1
11i
16
17
10
r'i
~
Q
11
l)lefll3e, '
Ilhe 1)/1(1 <l131~er:\ mrcl to, well, while we Wel."rcl
l3itl:!no thel."e, ahe hm! "f3I~er:\ me to l3ew,pome pfljfl,nAI3 ~or her,
'l'hllY hC\q \Jott:endppeq, I tolr:\ her I woulr:\, ,fll1l:1 I looker:\ <It
them. I C\131ter:\ hel." whf\t Wlla going on, Anq than wa went into
dppeq them
0
polioe? Di,q
11
0
11
Q
"
11
!'la, I clid not.
i
o Wal3 it hel.' intention to weal." theae pajamal3
After ahe wae rAped i'n them? Had ehe al3ked you to fix them?
11 '1'0 my undel.'etanding, they were dpped, off,
"
I
"
1fl 'rhey Were talten off. She wanted them f!xeq eo ahe oould '
:aD
21
22
23
24
21i
I,
I
,
,"
II
I',i
I,,'!(
'n-
34
,.J
1
:a
3
4
B
(,
"
7
0
9
10
11,
;1.:a
13
:1.4
11i
" "
16
J.7
10
19
20
21
22
23
24
21i
, I.
""\
(~
Q ~'hell from the ttma l:hflt: yotl (lAW her C\f\:e:r.
'yo\.l ," when dicl yot\ fi~ her PAjamMl?
11 ~WP dAYl3later, I l:h~nk, I qon't knoW; I
meflll, :tl: waf'l may\:le " weelt, I'm no\: l:eftl f'lUl."e, I tool~ them
home and fi~ed them IInq thel1 t:ool~ them \:laolt, Maype i,t waf'l
.'
\:he nexl: weekend, I'm not pure,
o You jUl3t gave ~hBm to her, "nq that Wal3 il:?
A Yeflh,
QM:r., MlIglin hfl~ been viaiting w~th the child
through the begil1ning of MOlY anqon the WBel~endl3, pid prew
l3eB Mr, Maa'Un In Ml'lY?
A Oh, my \1oodoel3l3 , I don' t pelieve po, I'm
not l3}1re, I qon't Wl"ite Clown ,datep every til118'1 you )mow,
1'111 nol: aure, MaY, I Clon't think ao, no, "
Q BUt in defiling with the PeCarlo ,houaehold
aftel' the April epieode, l:hers wal3 no r.eal change l:il;J. the
, - ' . - .
end of l:he montll, ie that about dght?
A Real change in what?
o In cPIll:aot wil:h Mr, MagU.n al: the l."el3iqelloe I
hil3 coming and going to the \:lal3Bball gamel3, thol3e ldnda of
thingl3,
A For me and my poll?
,Q Yel3,
A Yeah, there' waB 'change" It WaB no more, 'rhe
one time I can't remember the exact date, But the one
"
313
" 1
:a
3
II
Ii
6
7
0
9
10
1;1.
12
;1.3
fi
r',":,\
'~
tim!l '~IIWlor hf\8 A Plll3epAll 9l\me anq I WAI3 gplno \:0 l:€\lt13' praw
clown, once I, founcl OUl: HArry WAa t:hel:a, I l:oolt my 130n PAolt ,
home,' We hAve Ilot been to PAul<\'13 rel3.idenoe Ilinpe, pec€\U!'lr;!
I'm not gpil1g l:0 l3upmil: my child to thAl:,
o Mr, M<lgUn WA!'l ~ngry wi.th you \:hAt YOH were
,
tAking l3iqel3 q\1drm \:he oOUl'l3e of thifl <\l"mlment I :l.an't thAi:
. c+ue?
11 No, ~ wal3 no~,
o Dicl Mr, ME\glin tell you l:hE\t he wal3 go~ng \:0
oHt prew off, th~t he WAl3n't goingl:o do any\:\)j,ng ell3e fol."
prew peOaHl3e yo\.l were tf\)ting aiclea in the argqment '?
1\ No, he dicl not,
Mil, IlUMP~Ii1-SUlllIIV1\l'11 ~ have no furt:her"
"
15 ;il
:),4 qHel3tiona,
MI~, Mcl<NIGH'I'1 I jUl3t have one fo;J.loW-up,
16 RElDlRIilCT "ElXI\MIN1\'rIO!'l
17 BY MR, MoKNIGH'l'l
1Q
Q
You eaid thAt you oElme by to pick up your ",on
19 aftar that pleep"over I ancl you were ta)ten to the bedroo", and'
20 shown the ripped nightgown, D:i,d Mr, Maglill conf1"Ont you at.
21 fill at that ppillt whell he discovered thaI: you )mew somel:h:1.ng
22 about this nightgOWn?
2;3
24
A
No. 'Ue oonfronted Pal,lla,
D:1.d you see him that morning Elt all, Mt",
.'
Q
25 Maglin, wh~n you were there?
36
9
10
11
1:a
13
1tl
11i
.16
3,7
10
19
ii 20
21
22
~"1
,""'
1
1\ yel3,
Q Pi~ he indicAte't~ yPU fI~ al~ thAt he W~!'l
"
OOnc€ll."ned f\POU\: yon lmowing about WhAt hAd IIC\ppen€lQ?
A well, he hAq jtll3t fl."0111 hj,f3 "ir, 1113 hflc'l
f3f1id to her, yO" tOld her whAt hf\~pened?
o I!'l it yourtef3timony l:odAy'th<\l: YOU're now
ooncerneq flPOut being in M+', MflgHn'1'1 prel3ence PAlled on hil3
,oonduc~ on the 23r~?
"
:a
3
1\
Ii
6
7
o
11 Yel3, I am,
MR, McKNIOU'I'1 'l'hAt:'1'1 <\11 ..the '!uel3\:,.ii?nl3 I
hC\ve,
RmCROaa.rnXAMIN1ITION
BY MS, SUMPI,!il-aUI,I,IVAN, "
o JUllt for the l'r;!cord, what. wai3 ripped on the
pfljeml!ll'1 that you aewed?
1\ The lower part thAt's buttoned down, The
lower part and kind 6f like I!Icrqaf3 the ebdomen/~rotch area,
o Were these aleepet' pajamaa?
A ,Yeah, They were li~e penta and <\ shirt al~
oonnected,And !lame of l:he button!l were torn off of it, One
button waa l:o,rn completely ~. thia was ~ot foreplay, Thh
Wal3 one button waB dpped wit:h the meterial iUi3elf OU,t: of
23, the pajamea j,taelf I
'."
"
24 0 When you l3ay thia was not forepl~y, \lid you
"
25 . believe that that"may have been what waa ocourring?
37
'1
,..,
II
1\ !!'oreplflY'i'
o Yea,
1\ . No,
,14,9, I3PM!?~m-,9ULLIVT\l'l" I hC\ye nothing f\.ll"ther /
Your Honor,
Ml~, Mcl<NIGllTI '1'ho!'le <Ire all of the quef.ltJ.on/3
I hElVe,
j3Y TIIEl COURT I
01\re ,yoq a l3eAm/3trel3f.l? :]:13 thel:e 130me l."e",l3on
thAt a pel."l3o\1 woulcl l\l3lt yoU to, aew f.lo11\e\:hing?
1\ 1/11\ pretty h<lnqy," t'lo, I'm not a /3eAml3trel3l3,
0 H<\cl you been C\/31~ed befpre to l3ew dlol:hing for
the P1ClJ.ntiff?
"
11 t'lo,
,
0 How did thil3 opnvel"/3ation oocur that you Wer~
aaked to l3eW thl/3 garment?
A It W<\l3n't " It. waa .. W~ are frienda, and we
,tClllt, I grew Up in CI I3mall town In northern l?enn/3yl v<\nia,
,I know how to'. do CI lot of thlnga, In one of our
converaC\tlona way prior to this, I \:old her I cC\n l3ew, Clnq, I
buy food in bullt <\nd paokage it down, you lmow, ,tt: wC\a juat;
womCln tallt, So I ah8 knew I oould aew,
o So, how did this pClrl:icular oonversation
adae thal: Yotl were aBked to aew the pajama/3?,
A When We got there I" she had j Uet aakedlne if I '
30
"
"',
~
13
14
11i
MS, SUMrLli)- SUI,T-lIVAl'I, No ftlrther qU6,ati,onl3 "
Ml~, Mol<l'IIGlIT I That's all I have,
Tllli1 COURT, JOl3ey ie apelled how, J-o-a - -
'l'Hli1 WI'rl'!li1ElIl, J-o-a-e~y,
'1'1lli1 COURT, Thanltyou, You l11<\Y atep down,
16
17
10 MR, Mcl<NIGI1TI Your Honor, OUl." last w~tnesa
19 Will be Amy Batchelor, She'll juat have very brief
20 testi.mony,
, :;>,1 , AMY mI,I Z1IBEl'l'H BA'l'ClllilLOR
22 haYing been duly I3worn, testified aa follows,
2:1 PIRElC'r lilXAM:tNATION
24 BY MR, Mcl<NIOH'l',
21i
state, your full name for the record, pleaae,
,Q
39
" f!
l,',]
.'
~
,.....,'\
,.....,
~, 11 limy Jj]l,1....f1~le~h ll.f\l:ahe:j.ot',
;.1 0 Whal."e do YOH l~va?
3 A" In I,emoyne,
!.\Q Whflt cjo YOH qo fo.):' f\ J.i vina?
Ii A rll11~ lA~ph-key l:eacher ~or Norri~
6 mqUcC\~ion~l ~et'vicel3,
'7 THill COUf{'r I 'IIq!'lt for the r~cord, m;Li...~peth ia
,fJ wit:h a II~II?
9 TIlIil WI'rNffilllll yell,
10 TmU COURT I!\ncl how do yOU I3pell 13f\\:chelor?
11 THill WITNIllS~1 B-f\-t-c-h-e-l-o-r,
12 BY MR, Mcl<NIGH'1',
13 Q HoW 10llg have YOll WOl'ltec\ fOl: that
14 organi"'Atioll?
~5 A ,FOUl: yeat'l3,
16 Q Are yoU familiAr with the Plaintiff in thla
,17 "Qal3e I PAul<l Irene beC<\rlo'?
40
1
fl
3
4
Q
6
7
0
9
;1.0
" 11
12
13
14
;l.1i
16
17
10
19
20
21
Ii
22
, 23
24
21i
"
r",,\
.~
Ii
w:\.l:h Mr, MC\gl~n ancl 'l'AY~O+' i,n YOUl." r~:el3enaa?
11 Ye~, there Wal3,
Q po you reoi'll.l t:.he
1\, t9.ome\::\.me:\.1'\ MAY,
qAte?
I'm not aure .of t:.ha exaol:
~Ata,
Q
1'1
, Q
A
May .o~ 1fl90?
Yes, May ~f +990,
Jilflrly MflY?
Yel3,
Q Rel<\ta for the Court wh<\t:. happaneq thflt Clay,
A I Pl.'oceede~ to worl~ thflt d<lY, I /JO\W Mr,
Maglin pUll:\.ng up, ao I Wenl: ina:\.de, t..atch ltey hAd been
oalleqclown to t:he caf8teria, AmI '1'aylor ltapt l3aying, I'm
not aUppoaeq l:o go w:\.th my dad, I'm not: I3UPPol3ed to go with
my!cl<\d, 1 ,thoughl: it wal3 a littlefil3hy, 130 I wenl: ovel." to
the,of.fioe to cheolt to aee H t:hel'e waa <lny note or Anything
About Pa~la picking Taylor up .or Mr, Magli~picking up
'l'aylor, There waa a n.ote aay.ing that P<lula W<\13 going to be
pio!d\lg up Taylol.", 'and ahe atreaaed she Wal3 picldng him up,
86, I proceeded to the cafeteria where Mr, MAglirl W<\I3, <\nCl I,
showed him t~e n.ote,
Q mXouse me, What time of the dAY is this? Is
it morning! aeternoon?
1'1 This ia 3130, 3131i in the afternoon, I
proceeded into the cafeteria to ahow Mr, Maglinthe note,
"
"
4:t
;1'
.<"1
~
,n, ,.1\11d I fI~ltecl him' H ha poul\1 p;l.ef\~e W!\i\: for M~, PaCAl"lo to
~ IIp:ive,. A\lC! \:hey pould worl~ out:, you Imow, \:he 1l0heC!Ull11,
3 th~~ anC! thll~,
1 Q What: lmppenec\?
Ii 11 He Pl"o'oeec\ad' to wtd,t,' 'I'AY~:Ol" WIlf3 wC\;l.lthlO
6 "l\I'P~mcl the room very nerVOlll3, Very I3CM"eq, ~t '13eamr;lq lilta
? when Ml:, Mag;l.l\l WfI!'l on one l3iC!e of the room 'l'Aylor wa!'l on
!l the other l3iqe of \:he room, He wal3 lt~nq of !'ltlclting to me,
9 whioh w!\. very oqd, beOaUllft Taylor uaUfllly never c\oe~ \:hat
10 wi~hme, I went l:o get l\ I3nack, l\nd 'l'Aylor oAme in ~nd W<\!'l
11 l3\:icking py me agAin, I tolcl ~im jUl3t'tOgo eit down <\hcl
"
12 ,eAt a I3nl\C)t, Mr, Maglin !'ll\iq,' come on"T<\ylor, We don'~
13 l1eecl to wait fOl: mom, I,et'l3 go, Taylor w<\ll~ed l.IP t:o me,
~.4 So, I thoqght to l\vold a confront<\tion in front of the"
11i chHcl:ren, I took hi"\ clown .to q ldnqeraArten l:OOm and
16
prooeeqec\ to wait fqr t~I3, DeCarlo to I3how uP,
Q Dld ahe ahow UP?
A Yee, ahe clid,
Q ,\'/hl\t happaned when ahe ahowed Up?
, '.
A Mr, Maglin and Me, PeCEll:lo were down Elt ~he
17
10
19
20
.,
21 ot:her end of the hl\1lway ax.changing worda, I don't ltnow
22 \~ha\: they aaid, We walked, down the, hdlWflY, lIlld they W8nt
23 outaide,
24
25
Q
A
Wh<\t happened then?'
I Went illto the offioe ,to loolt throl\gh the
"
42
"
,. <1
1
;l
3
1\
Ii
6 "
II
7
, "
11
9
1(l
11
~.ll
;L3
14
15
],6
17
18
19
20
2i
22
23
24
25
"
"
,,,o'''~
r""\
Q
,I:p p!ol~ Up t:lm
A
Ml', MAolin WAP there At the appropr!<\\:e time
child, le th<lt correct?
Correct,
Q when YOU C'\!l3c\.\l3eeq wlth him thAl: he eho\.l:].d
WAi\:, WAI3 he oonfl~ontfltj,pn<\l with you, or qiq he j~ll3t:. f.l\lree
\:.0 wflit:?
A No, He waned,
Q M; the time thAt YOU e~!q \:hflt MI3, DecC\rlo
finAlly C\rl"i.ved ,- how long, C\fter the time pe:dod t:hAt the
ohil~ I3hoyld h<\ve been qil3~iaeeq qid Me, DeCarlo Arrive?
11 I WOU:].c\ I3AY flbout :j:'H~een minul:ea/ fifteen,
l:Wellty mirml:ea,
Q At that; j\.l\1ctul."e, l:hen, Mr, MflgHnanr:\ t:he
child were <\l,ready in t:h!s Un'aol11fortAble l3ituAtionfor
approximately fifteen to l:Wenty minutee, ia thAt right?
I' ,
A Yea,
Q NoW, at Any time th<\t Mr, Maglin balked to
Ma, DeCfll."lo th<\t you obaerVed, was there fillY pUl3hing,
ehoving or, Any Jdnd of physical abuse?
A, No, I d,i'd not pee anything,
Q Did you hf.lar any inappropriate aCream!l\g,
,
yelHng or Cf.\l"l."ying on?
A No, I didn't,
Q so, the partiea, again, talk~cl at the end pf
the :\1'111 about thia cUatody sil:ual:ion?
"
41i
II,
"
1
:a
J
11
,6
6
,,7
fJ
9
10
U
12
13
14
16
16
17
10
19
20
21
22
,J' 23
,.
24
21i
,,"
,.....~
f~
1\' Correa\:,
Q 1\\: the PPl\ol.\UJ!O\\ of l:h/lt, Ml', MAglin I;ool~
the ohUcl and pqt: the ohi,lq in \:ha Clll", .ip thAt oOl."rept?
1\ Well, they hAq'wenl: ou\:siqe, I q!c\n't aee
them, 'rhey j u~t l:ool~ oU, .They went: o\H:sicle,' 'l'he
l3eOrel:\lry Wal'l orderecl to oa11 \:he polioe,
Q Po yoq lmow who Il1<\qe \:h<\t ol"del" fa): the,
l3ecret~r~,to oAll l:h~ police?
1\ :j: think it WEl13 Py l:he principC\l, thAt if
there WAI3 a oonfron~Eltion in the I3chObl agEl.in that the
polioe were to be' c<\lled,
Q In regarde l:o the police, they C\rrivecj at the'
,
acene"ia l:hElt ootrect?
A Ye13, but they hC\cl - - Mr, M<\glin /lnd T<\ylor
hC\d alre<\cly lef\:,
Q At C\IW time, did you see ,Mrs, DeCflrlo tl"y to
pull bn the child?
A No, I didn't see l:hElt,
Q "Now, <\t theol:her Umee that Mr, M<\glin had"
ardved <\ncl takel/ the chilq fr.om' the ech~ol" ,were there any
other problema that you ,wit.neeaed In, regal"dl3 l:6 Taylor
leaving with him?
A No,
MS, SUMP!,m-SOI,LJIVAN I I h<\ve no fUl:'t:her
questionl3,
, 46
;t,
2
3
4
B
6
7
0
9
10
11
12
13
14
lli
16
:\.7
10
19
20
21
22
23
"
24
26
"
"
'.''''''
t' ,
r"";
,
lUllDIHIJlC'I' IJlXTlMINI\'I'ION
"
,
13Y MR I Mdl{Ntd\l'~' I
Q ~1113\:11 cOllpla ~olloW"I1P, Wel'a YOIl aWfll."e of
whY A 110te hAd peon ~el1t in? WAI3 ~h~r~ llama pro~lem
rrsv~ou~ ~o thAl: 'ctPy thflt ,-
1\ ~he dAY be~ore, Mr, MAOlin oAme \:0, piok up
'I'aylor /' Anq I W\3nl:, in\:o \:he oC floe to mAltS I3Ul"a, you Imow t
~ l3aid, l~ Mr, Maglin AllqWed to piCk up ~aylor? And they
',told ms ye~, I diqn't hAVf.l <\ny ol."dr;n"1l 'that I - - to l~eep him
<\WO\Y from him, 130 I let l:he chilcl go,
" "
Q Did you then lAl:er noti1:y t:he mother \.\hAt he
h<\cl been piclted I1p?
1\ I3h8 haq come, Ancl ahe a~lteq where TC\ylor waa,
1\nq ! aaicl, well, you lmow, Ml', MAglin hAd picltecl Up TAylor,
Q WAa ahe aurprieeq? Dld ~he --
A Y~I3, She waa very ~Ul"pril3ed, very I3l.\rpriaed, '
Q 130, l:hen the next d<\y ahe Ilent In a note
~aylno, pleaee, I'm picking up Taylor?
A COrl"act,
Q NoW, when you ob~rirved 'l'aylor being"removed
to the car through th8 window, did '1'aylor,aeem tb be going
willinglY I or WAa' he b8ing gr<\bbed? , What: wae happening?
MS, SOMJ?Lm-SULLIV1\NI I'm going l:o'objeot. to
the form of the queAt~on, being dragged,
'1'11m COUR'I'I 'l'he Db:l ection ia ovel.'ruled,
"
'47
"
1
,2
3
1
Ii
6'
7
0
9
10
11
, ,
12
13
111
16
16
, .1'
17
10
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
it
"
r"""I
t~
13l( MH, Mol~NIOll'r,
g You OAn Anl3Wer it,
11 I wo\~ld flAY he Wal3n'l: go~ng wilnngly, \:Ie
CO\.l+nn'l: even l~eep UP wit;h Ml:, ME10Hn, He WM"l pU1Unghim
AC:roa/3 \:!le Il\:~"ee\; b'y hi/3 fll.'m,
MH, Mol<im:U!'I.' I 'l'hE\l:'/3 A+,;I. ~he Cl\\eal:ionl3 l
have,
'~'/IJll COUR'~'I M/O, ,9U\11ple-,9ul1iVAI1?'
Mil" IlUMPr,JlI-,9ur.r,lV1\f'.!1 I have no further
,
que~tiona, .
MH, Mol~t>lIOH'~' I At l:hia pplnl:, Your' Honor, our
hour is up, Anq weill rei'll:,
THm COUHT I J; thinlt,poth of yonr r;lxhlpi t!'l
ware admltl:ed, May the two wil:nel3/Oel3 be 8xCUl3eq?
MR, Mol<t>lIGl-l'l'l They maY be,
Mil, ,9UMPr,liH3UIIIIIVAf'.! I Yea, 1(otlr Honor ';
'rllDl COURT, 130t MI3, Patohelor and Ma, Trump,
You" oan I3tay oJ." leaVe 1\13 you chool3e, 'rhanlt ~'ou very mlloh
for coming in todflY, We'll take <\ brief receae in thia
caae I dq, a benoh wal"r<\nt I have to de.Ell wit;h, ~nd thel'\ Weill
al:art l:he ol:her aide,
(/\ reoeee Waa l:aken,)
1'Hrn COtJR'l'l We will lel: the reoord illclical:e
l:hal: the ooUrl: reconveneq in l:he caee of DeCarlo v, M<\glin,
Me, Sumple-sullivan?
40
"
"
~
~
~ p~tng~ YOU l:o c6l1tr<\1 Pannl3YlvC\niA on pOl11e oocAPlonp, ts
:a th_t correct?
, '\
3'
A
It c1o<:1lln'l: exflCltly 1)l,"~l1g me he~:e, MY!lon
we cOIlt~Act our own jqbl3, we finc1 ot\r own
,
of thaI: nAture, ~ut I try to wo:t"l~ UP here
cloae C\13 I c,m to my 130n,
9
10
o
The record ae preaenl:ec1 in the,'latnttff'~
"
,11 0<\1313 hall conf1.i,cting tae\.\ep apo\.\t whAt ia your relationl'lhip
12 Anc1 wllAtcontinur;lf'l t:o pe you~ relatlolll3hip' with MI'l. DeOa~io,
13 I'd ltke to jUl3t priefly cla~ify, ~elllly Chronologically,
14 'you~ relationl3h,ip wit:h her and 'the l3ignHicO\nt eventl3 th<\t
11i 09cu~~ec1" Yo~ m~t her in apProximately 1900, ill th<\t
16' qorrect?
),7
A
Correcl:,
10
Q
And you' 111f1rried
wel1, ahe bec<lme pregnant
;1.9 at th<\t polpt, 113 l:hat correct?
, , ,
20
A
After abol.\t a year and a half of Qal:ing he:!;",
"
21' ,we were married, When we Wel."e married in November of 1909,
, '
22 ahe was <\PPl"oximat~ly fOUl: -" three to fO\.\r montl1a pl~egn<\nt,
23 I b8liel,ra, Ol" maybe four or five montha pregnant,
24
Q
1Ind your son, Taylo,r, was born O\l1\pr;l.1 7\:11,
26 1990, ls l:hat correct?
50
"
1
~
3
1
6
6
7
0
9
" 10
11
12
13
I'll
11i
16
17
10
19
20,
21
22
23
211
25
'~
~\
'1'lIlil C!O\lR'~', MAybe it:1p 111f1roJn~1~y ~:e+evAnt,
.r'm InPIlt:ly !nl:el'epteq ,in WIlAI; hC\f.l been allegeq by the
Vl"in\:!ff, t:o hAVe hAPpeneq AI1c'\ WhAt: the P8fenqAnt'13 reflponfle
l:Q it ii'll
MI3, ~UMI'I,lil-~ur,LIVI\N I 1\nq I will get to thAt:,
Ypm: Honor, I j~If.lI: bfllieva Waneeq l30me bC\l3il3 here,
!3YM13 I ~UMPf,Pl-I3ULL.rV^N,
Q Now, a!Jllin, when you flAY Arg\.\ll1elltl3,' your
re1Ilt!onl3hip, w!th MI3 I DeCarlo hall Alw<\YI3 peen EI vel."PA:). type
of pitu<\l:.!:on?
11 Not on my behf\1f, Yo~\, lm~w, I WC\13 dWElYI3
defending myaelf 1!1~e I'm I3itting here tOclAY, I nevel."
wC\nted to argUe w,tth thia wom<\n avel"y ,",imlte I ~he oQuld
never gal:, Along with anybody, eithel." me or my fElmily
membera,
Q Whetl YO\.\ fleparElted in 1990, I3he qid file a
I.
protection fl"om ,ElbUfle EI\1A!nat you, b thAt cOrJ."ect?
II yep/ahe diq,
Q Wl\a An order eyer entered lit that time
period?
A she diq it right when I - - !n Sep\;8mber of "
1990, when I left OUr 6011dominiull1 in Vll:taburgh at Fa~rmont
street:.l\ncl moyed bi\i:lk with illY PAl"ehl:a, ahe filed a PFA <\lid
add that I oouldn't aee my child,
Q After the time that the ex parte orcler
62
,.
1
) ;l
~
1\
Ii
6
7
0
9
10
11
12
13
;1.1\
11i
16
17
10
19
20
21
22
23
24
21i
1""'\,
I
~
expi'liec'l, yon flppl."oaohec'l t:Pl: A h\3arino, i,p \:hfll: COl."r.ept?
,,, f\ YeAh, We, went to A hel\r~ng, yea,
Q '^nq,~ha PPJ\ wafl ,-
1\ It: WI\I3 nevel." ment~oneq, never even pro\.\ghl:
uP, 'l'he only thlng thflt Wal3 brqught UP WE\fl Clhilq I3Uppo+,t,
Q Now, you, ,lIgO\in, reoonoHec'l with 'her in flpoul:
~unfl'9C 1991, ll3l:hllt oorreot?
^ Correct,
Q Y9\.\ were \:ogether fOl" <\ppro:!\imfltely flJ,?t more
montha, il3 ,thAt correct?
A ,Gorrect,
"
!.';
Q Now, yO" I3plit up in necemper of ~99~, At:
that time per!oc'l, 1I110ther PFA Wllafiled, ifl th<\t, C01;'reot?
A Yeah, A few claya before Chdfltm<\fl ,when her
Anc'l our re1llt:\.oMhip waa broken up agdn, flha )tnew l:,hC\t it'
wap my Utoe \;0 be w~,\:h Taylor and I waa, going \:0 ta)te him to'
my p<\renl:p' hOUl3e, Il: WAf.! my timo l:o be wlth him, Anq ahe,
r<\n aw<\y with my chilcl, She IddMpped him, her and my
child, I\nc'l aha ran .w<\y, She ran to a woman' a I3helter, It:
'I "
w<\a right <\l."ound Deoembel" -.. the eC\t'ly par~ of December
21at, 22nd at: 1991,
Q So, you mil3aed basioC\lly having YO\.\r ohi~d
for that whole extenc'led ho.t!dE\Y period at tha\:"tim8?
A !'lot only th<\t time, liiyery ~ime it's" my ume
to be Wil:h illY !'Ion durir\g either my oUl3tody or my holic1C\Y
1i3
,:
I"."
" 1
~
3
4
Ii
6
7
0
Q
10
11
1<1
13
14
11i
16
1'7
10
1$l
20
r"'"'!
~
A,
Yeqh, tnAt'a correct,
Q After. you h~q Qivorceq, Wer~ your cuatocly
rightl3 'int:errupteq by allegAl:iona of ae~ual abuse by you
~gainat thil3 ohild?,
A. Yel3, "
MR, Mclt!'lIG1-l'l', Again, YoUr Honor, I' d' obj ~ct ,
,
I don't lmow,how this il3 relev<\nt to the ,haue of I?FA before
thla coUr.t right now,
THill COURT, Whal: Mf3, ,l3umple-Sullivan ia,
,21" . trying to ,eetablieh ia th~t there' e a pattern of false
" 22 ohargea brought, Withouta~ying that I agree oX;, cl:l,aagree, I
23 think it'e at le<\/3t relevant,
24 13'/ Mal SUMPt.ljJ-SULLIVAl'l1
213
Q
After your divoroe in 1993, there wae
,
Ii4
"
.."
I'
"
II I,
, ~
2
3
4
Ii
6
,7
0
,9
~O
" 11
1~
13
14
1 Ii.
j,G
17
10
19
~O
2:1,
:12
23
24
21i
"
~
,....,
Q W~r~ l:hOfl~ allElgation~ con\:~nued py MI3.
p~Cf\plo th:r.ough th~'cul3tOqy l~~ig<\tion wh~oh odourred tn
"
199~ into 1994?
A Ye/il,
Q At the t~me th<\t: you hEHl!'\ full. cUl3tocly
he~ring pefore \:he. ;\ uc\ae ~.n AUegheny count:y, were the
<\llegf\tion~ of,phyaicl\l And ~exu.l apul3El t:hfll: ~he rAil3ed
\.\llfOuncleq' al: l:ha\: time per.ioo?
A Can YO\.\ rereac th<\t, r1eO'\/3'e,
0 At l:he time of. your cuat?dY h~flring in
Allegheny Co'~nt:y, clid t:he judge unfotlno her allega\:ionl3 of
138~UAlf\nd phY/3ioal abUl3e?
l\Of.dourlle,' yef3,
9 picl you" in f.aot
THrn' COURT I I'm not l3ure whflt thE\t meanfl, Do
you meE\n the judge maoa a I3peoific f.illdj.ng th<\t: the apUl3s'
c1id not ,oaour?
"
MS, SUMpr.,jil-!3Ur.,r.,IVAt-ll I believe ,Your HOller,
that th/:lt WE\a t:he pOf3ition of the court down thel."e, that
therewal3 no b<\ai~ to l3ubat<\ntiate the allegationl3 of ElbUl3e,
MR, McItNIOI-ITI' YOt!+' Honorl I thinlt it:' a more
. APproprial:e that if. there I a aome 'court order whioh l3<\ya that,
apedifidal.ly th<\t it be entel;'ed otherwiae, Aald.n(:J a laY i' ,
witneaa aboUt: that ie inappropriate I
BY MS, sUMPr.,m-sUr.,LIV1I.NI
'"
liB
II,
).
;3
3
4
6
", 6
7
0
9
10
11
;1.2 ,
PsOal.<l,o?
14
16
16
17 '
10
19
20
21
;12
:l3' :
"
24
, "
"
{\
o
t'"
,~
,
That:' f.l oorrscl:, "
An~ yO" ragulArly VACA~ione~ wlth Mf.l.
",
..,;
"
139
1
2
3
1\
Ii
6
'I
0
9
10
11
J,:a
,,13
14
15
16
II 17
" ' 10
, 19
20
21
22
2;l
24
21i
i""")
,.,.,
,i~ you c~n, n~~pa~,
II I'm l3on:y,
o Up unl::!.l '",he
~ir.l3t a+l~gal:ion o~ ap4fle in
4th, approximal:~ly, pe '97?
lI, Corr.ac\,:,
\:i,\11l.'4, thAl:, l~t'!'l !'lAY -" th~
t:.hla t:empor.<\ry 9,l:q~r Wi'll'! July
"
o Cml you teU thEl Cou~t hpw you hf\Ppened t:.o pe
wlth her on JUly 4th o~ :\.9971
II YeAh, ShE! WAI'! vil3iti,llg me in 1?~,ttI3Pu!:,gh,
. . _ 1
I3he I'!tayeq fit my conclomi\1i\~m, hel: And u yoq ltnow, I'!he
at.Ayed with me find 'l'ay;l.or during TC\ylot" /3 l3ummer vi/3itlltion
lal3t I3Ummel;',
Mil, IlUMJ?r,El-I3Ur,L:rVAN I I'm going to, mflrlt theBe
U/3 fin exhil:>it, which are p;\.cturel3 l:hat were talten July 4t:.h,
1997, of the p<\rtiel3,
(Defenqant' f3 Iilxhibil; \110, .Ii waa marlteC\ for.
iqE!ntificO\t!on, )
BY MS, SUMpr,El-SUr,r,IVAl'l1
Q I'm going to I3how you four photographe \~hich
you have praaented aa evidance concerning whal; l:he par.t:l.e!3
were doing on July 4th, 1,~97, Can YoU deao:dbe fat' the
Courl: Wh!\t you, aa a family, were doing on that day?
'I,
A Yea, '1'0 mal~e the ~ay 13peo;!.al, Iaomehow" W!\a
lucky to gal; us reaervationa at a very excluaiVe' ref3l;aUrant
in t>il:taburgh, r,eMona ~- it' a d.ght on top of the 1nbuntdn
(;0
~
~
:l. whl3l:a you lool~ A~ l:he UreWorltfl -- on Jul.Y 4th, :j:t' a Hlte
~ pl30plegeperRlly cC\l.l ther~ monl:hll in A~Vanpe l:o get thm
3 rel3l3rVAtiona, I j\.ll3t oAll.ed fio~ the heck of it, I ~ig\.lre~
.. . ~I
4 I woull:\n'\: l3ven \:l€l APlt;\ t9 gl3t it, ~?\.ll::): cli,q, 'J:'hey 9E\Ve ul3
6 j;ronl: rpw l3eAtl3 on Ju~,y 11th, 1997, .1;Q+ me, my e:lt-Wi~e C\nd my
6 ohUq,
7
Il
:1
Q flra \:11l313l\l pict\~raa of you <\nd YOl.lr chilq find
your ax.,Wi,fB ~qdng thO\t dipn\'lr time perioc'\?
fI Yel3, thElY are)
Q There' 13 ~llegatiol1l3 thl\t Are rdl3ed in the
..10
11 pet:Lt~,on th<\l: you hAd pUl3heQ her on thatcl<\te ,00 you h<\ve
1;1 <\ny recollection or Any ider;l of whflt uhOlt waa APout:?
13 A No, I CIa no\:,
14 q It aaya, OIqdi,~ion<\lly, t)l<\t you oalled her <\
11i whore, alut OInd other humiliating namel3 ih the prel3enoe of
;1.7
the ohild and repeC\t;edly atl."ucl~ her in the neck with a
I3tic)t, ualng a I3taJlbing motion, ancl eUl3t<\ined red ,m<\rltl3 &nd
II "
aoreneaa C\ro\lnd het peolt 0113 C\ reaul t of the lncident, '
16
16
" 19
A
Yeah, Thel3e are 0111 fOlll3e,
20
Q
To your lmoWledge, arB thOl3e Accurflte
~1 pictures of hBr cluring the 11th of July celebtation?
22 A Yee, it ia,
~3 Q Do they lndicate any kind of mf:'l."lta or any
24 kinds of problema to hel." nec)t?
21i
A
No, She 100ltB pretty good,
"
61
r
~
~
1
Ii
6
7
n
9
, 10
1:).
~2
13
14
],5
16
17
10
19
;aD
, 21
22
23
24
21i
(""'l
~
',0 J\f.\:.ftr \:!1\3 fhllY i1\:h epJ,l'locje, then in 1\uguat of
,
r997 I3he"inqtc<\\:el3 thA\: fO" pUl'lhecj the P1A~nl:iff ~13 !'lhe
I'ltooq on \:he l~nqlng of A !'ltflirc~~e, oAu!'llng her \:.0 I3t:.U"~le'
qOWI1, Do yq~\ hC\yl'l Any recolleol:~pn of \:.h~t?
1\ ThAt'13 tot~~lY unl:r"e, Yo"r Honor,
Q /It O\ny \:~ml;l in the p~:ooeeqing13 thf\thAppeneq
pefore \1",cjge He!'l!'l, h~cl there ~)een ~ny flllega\:!ona of the!'le
ltinql3 of pehflVlOl"!'l ~gdnl3t: fOU?
"A !'lo,
Q r,el:'s go to the 'neXl: cl<\l:e,
t:.h\il. pe~j,tion, Octoper. Of 19~7, It:. add,
whioh Wal'l lil3tecj in
,
while qriving l:he "
oflr, th8 Defend,~nt gl..'APpec1 \:he l?ll\intiff I a h~ir, yanltec1 hi'll;:
I" ,
he~c1 pack anc1 forth l3everal timel3, oaul'Ilng her to "loae
olumpi;! of.' hdr, And p<\nged hel.~ he~cl agdnat\:.he cl~l3hboO\rd,
I'
As a rea"lt of l:hel3e inoldenta, Pldntiff "I3Ul3tO\j,ned,:
i, brul3hlng, bruiaillg and aorenea/3 of hr;ll." ~orehead and
he~cj<\chell, Do you l."scall anything About thi!'i Ootqber 199'7
ep:laocle?
A Th<\t' a qtu:ing I:he Jewish hol!c1<\ya, Your
Honor I whel"a she Waa invlted l:o 001013 clown - - my p~r.ents
invitec1 her .to come to dinner, and a'he actually drays ,me !n
her oar,
, ,
It was Taylor I myeel f ancj her in hel~ Oar,
I Was
dl"lving her oa1", She waS sltting in l:he paasenger' a aj,de,
She really dicln't - - she neVer, liked my family fl:Om the
,
beginning,so, while we Wel'8 driVing dOWn, she sta):'l:ecl with
"
62
'.,.
"
,ii'
,"
.,
\\
1"""\'
I'
~
"
1
2
3
my mother f ,. Ilw(.iml <Ill of thel3s' l:errlple thll1gll C\Poul: IllY
mo~hel.", 'Anq I'lhe flOOUI'lScI me of, br;~,ng gAY I I3he IHdd J W<\1'l <\
fA9oot,- exClUlle my lflnguaga -- thl\l: I Wflfl gay, l:ha~ + WAI3 q
IlomoaeXuAl, thAt: I Hlte C\nC\l I'le~ ancl All of t1161'l\3 typefl o,j;
thingi'l, '
<\
Ii
Ii ' Q HAq I'lhe qcoul3ed you of hAving l'le?l:\Hll
7 l"elE\tionl'l with YOln" mothel."?
B A Oh, yell, numerQUs OCCl<\I'l.iona, 'l'hat WE\1'l
9" 'brought: UP in ft"On\: of JUqge (i'olino in 1!J94 at t116 CUl3toqy
,
10, I:dC\+, Pl", Wetllel, who Wal3 t:!le"cour\:-f.\ppointed
" :t.:l "pl'lychi<\tdl3t, notea thC\t in hil'l __
12 MR, MclmWHTI Opject:ion, YO\W Honor,
),3 'l'HEl COURT I ,9ulll:Ainsd,
14 1W M,9, ,9UMPr,m-,9UilI,IVJ\N I
15 Q Well, let me E\ek, in regardl3 to thim I'lpecific
16 epiaoc1e, waa thel."s phyaioa+ conl:,act: by her against you in
17 the ,vehiqle'?
10
11' YeE\h, She tJuaheq me while I WE\a c:\rJ.virm the
19 o~r, I"ooulcln't even oonoel1trE\te on driviq91 For about E\
20 h<\lf hour atraight, ahe juat continuou131y kep~ cE\lling me E\
21 lwmoaexUE\l, oE\lling m8 a Jaw, tenible namoa about m~,
:a2 l:el.igion E\nd all theae, typea of thinga, It W<\a dud,ng my
23 JsWil'lh hOliday. +t's ~ur biggeal: holid<\y of the Year!, I
24 oouldl1' t: eVen ddve clOWlI in peace, My ohilq Wal3 in the bacle
21i seE\t with a h<\mster from hia achool, Be was ale8pil'l9,
63,
, ,;
"
I;
"
,,"
1
f1
3
It
'..',' Ii
6
7
0
9
10
11
1~
13
i4
113
16
17
10.
"
19
20
21
22
"
:a;l
24
21i
.I"
f""\'Il
~
l"okl~y, Ilo h~ ~i~n'l: h~Veto heAr ~hl~ &bul3e, thtl3 V.r~<\l
~pUfle Py hif3 1110~hi3r,
o Piq you p~\f3h hel." he"c\ AWC\Y ~nq l:Angle her.
hC\ir?,
11 \'efl, I q.j.q,
Q .PJd YOH ~\: any t,tme y<ml~ oqt; c:LumpFJ of her
hA.i.r?
A No, I ~icl not,
o When you €\rr.j.ved in l?it\:.I3PHt"gh, c:1!q I3he f3tflY
for the hoUclay?
"
,11 No, She turned righl: flround <md clrove paolt
to l'~,tl:l3bql'gh, My PElrenta cC\me outilicje C\ncl Ill:iU <\l3k(lq her
to oome in, peoaUl3e they,cl!dn't ltnow whClt hAPpened, They
. . I ' ,
cliCin't ltnow \:.h<\t her &nq I t\rgueQ op the WAY down, 'l'hey
, ' ,
still inv.i.ted her in,
Q After thAt epiaode on the way to Pittl3Purgh,
diq you indioElt8 that you del3ired to ,tel.'minate. the
relationahip?
A Yell, That1a when ahe hit me with th8 ee)(Ui\l
aUegal:iona again with my 13011 a coupl.e of d<\ya latel' and
"
atopped me from aeelng him for seV8nty-aeven daya, Your
HonOl: ,
"
Q Now, you aaw hel." .for the Jewiah holidl:\YB,
WOH:t,d l:hat be lilte the beginnillg of September - - I mefln "
OctoP8r?
64
1
2
3
4
6
6
7
6
9
10
U
12
13
],4 '
11i
" I' 16
17
" 16
19
20
21
22
23
211
26
"
1""'\
........,"
" ,..,."
, f\
Q
t~,I11El peri,qq
A
Y!3I3,
I\ncl you h<lc\\:he oh:\.lq wi\:h YO~1 clHrina \:hAt
thAI: you were in pittl3Purgh, ll3 thflt corr!3ot?
Ye!'1,
'9
f\
Sh!3 OA111e pf\olt l:0 t:he Hfll"riflPUrg, Are<\?
Yell, flhe clid,
q , Then you hAcl Anothel: two weel~13 of viaitC\tion
.w~\:h the ch:\.lcl, is l:hAt 'oorrect?
11 Li,l~e l:wo other wee)tend viaitat~.onl3, yel3,
o During thflt time pe:dod fl,"om when "thll3
Alleged evant had ooourred, you I3<1W the child regularly~ <\Rd
therEl WAp no problem, i,s thq t oorreot?
1\ Yes, becaul3e 'it: wue pArt of our othel." Jewhh
holiclaYI and :l.t WClS my wee)tenq, <\nq her antl I -- when aile
drove qown on that flrat Jewish holidClY and caused all o~
thel3e problema with me, WE) terminAted ~hfl relat:.ionahi)?
<\gdn, So, the nex:l: twb weelta that heoame doWn, ahe,clicl
not come with him," He came by himl3elf, Dudng that time il3
when' ",he wae
bec<\use l:hClt
c,onllpiring, her fClhe allegClti,onfl sgsinal: me, .
..
wal3 my laat:. time I aaV{ my child unti,l I hil."ed
you in Decembel." of 199'1, ,
Q 'rhare was no 1?FA that was ever filed' duri.ng
thal: time peri.od?
1\ No, there WaS 'not. She,alreCldy dld t:;hat
" ,j.
numerous l:imea before ClI1d il: dlcln' t wodt, ao noW aha's on l:o'
61i
:\.
:a
3
1\
"" Ii
6
7
0
9
10
11
J.2
13
1,4
16
;1.6
17
10
19
20
21
22
23
24
21i.
(')
.,
~
fI 116W one, ,
o Ilo, ,then !n Ootoper. pf 199" WAI3 when l:he ex
"
pArte order. Wf.lP ~nter.eq Py ~\.Idge Hafll3 in thil3 <!ol:i,ol\
termina\:ino YO\.lr ~"ighl:fl ~1Aflecl pn the f.lexUA~ fll1agAti,Qn
ohflrgell, ~,13 thC\t oor.raot?
A Correot,right flfter tha Jewil3h holiclAY
Vlfl!l:, our l<\l3t one,
'1'I1!il couR'r, In whAt:. €lotion'! It woulcln't be,
:\'n thil3 ap\;ion thaI: ~1111 hearing,
M~, @uMPr,m-~u~r,IV~1 ~o, It Wae in the
ouel:oqy .otion~ Your Honor,
'n1m COURT I Do we have the term and number
for that aPt:l,on?
,,,' I'
M,S. ,9uMl?x,m-,sUJ,WV1\N I Yea, Your Honor, 'l'he
axhip!t thAt I juatintroduoecl oontaina Judge Heal3' orcler,
;i ' ,
BY M~, ,9UMI?4m-pU~LIV1IN'
'Q can you l."eacl that, Mr, MagHn'i'
1\, Num!Jer 97-1i090,
'Q NoW I prior to the entry of her petition for
the' ex parte relief paeed on the Bexual a11egationa il3S\.Ie,
"
all oUl3tocly aotionl3 h<\d been handled clown in 1\lJ,egheny
,(,
"
Q childreli ancl Ybuth Servioea WM o<\l1eQ in and'
did an inveatig<\tion of the repent allegatiolla', ia \;hC\t
"
66
"
1\
Ii
6
7
0
9
:to
11'
l:a , I
13
,14
;1.6
16
ii"
17
"
10
19
;aO
2,:l.
22
23
24
:.as
1"""'1
~
'I'
I"
you I Ellld we went to 131313 Judge 1.leaa,
,Q NoW, we had filed an emergenoy pel:it~oll
"
pimplY to reinatf,\te, baaed on the eX parte order, the pr~oF
order, i13 that oorreot?
67
1
~
3
4
Ii
6
7
0
9
10
11
;12
13
111
. lli
" 16
17
,1.0
19
20
21
"
22
23
24
25
r~ ~
^ yea, wa Q~d,
\J Mel Mf.l, p(lCAr:j.o f Heel "11 Al1flwer req~~dI10C\
he<\l"i,ng pl1i,or to ~h<\t: ~'a~nl3t:Ataml3nt ?
I I"
A Yea, I3he ellc\ , jUl3t \:0 ItElep me C\WIlY fl'om my
ohild al3 long Afl I'lhe pOfll3i,bly ooulc\. 'rhat' fl her whol,6
.'
mOI:~v<\tion, Yo~r Honol."I It'l'I her who],e 1110tiv"t:~on p8hincl
l:h.J.a,
MR I Mol<NIGII'l', Your 1I0110r, I unqe:)'"fltl\ncl t;,he
point theY'l."etrying to m!\lte, I j~let clon't W<\r1t to
1;'alH.j.g"te the olll3tod'l' l}e<\rin9,
MI3, 1311MPI.E).SUr.,r,IVJ\1iII We' relool~ing Ell: the
tim~,ng of when theae filingfl/'ll:e ooming in, '(OUl: Honol.",
MR. Mo1<NIG11'1'1 'l'heyi re :Ln\!roduoing
infol."mation <\pout the oUl3tody hearing befol:e J~dge 1161313, flncl
" ,. .'
,
I clon't w<\nt to relitig<\te thAt, The' orclera apealt fOl:
theml3elvel3, We lmow whflt hil3 dghtl3 fll:e involving o~atocly,'
I.el:'1l wO'l."l~ on theae allegEltiona,
THE) COURTIMa, Sumple-Sullivan?
BY MS, SUMPr,m.sUr.,r,IVAN,
, Q Aoaln, there .wEla a heAring before Juqge Hel3a,
ia thAt oorreot?
A. Yes, there WEla,
Q And t:h<\l: Wfla on Deoember.23rd, 19971
A Yea,
" "
Q "At tlwl: time period, J.el3uea of. the ae)(ual
60
~
~
"
1
Po
Ya~, !I~r flllq I wel:e to OhApel."Oll~ ~'aylor' tJ
2 Iilleep-oV8rph"thclflY PC\l."\:y,
3 Q Pid yo~\ 13l:C\Y w.tth her AI: her" home cjqrtng t:hat
Ij' ttme pedocl?
5
Po
'(el3, ~ dicl,
W<\a l:hC\t &t her reqqel'll:?
G
7
Q
1\
Yel3,
o Q Alleg&tiolll3 hAve been mflcle th&t you hacl,
9 whlle the ohilclren Were 131eeping tn the other rool11 I <II:
10 Cjpp~"oxim&tely ten or eleven, enl:el:ecl hel." pedroom C\ncl rlPP~d
11 her pC\j &maa &nd rC\peq her?
12 1\ Th&t la <\bl3olutely unl:rue, Your Honor,
"
13 Q Could you qea'adbEl for the COUl."t whAl: that
14 W~eltencl Wfll3 about &nd wh&u o'ooqrred cluring th&t uime, pedod?
lli A Yeah, We hAcl a pirthd<\y party for my ohilc\
16 fit hel." apc(rtment in Camp Hill, We path ohElpel"Onecl the
17 party, We had a great time, We even took Taylor to
10 Benlh&I1A' e clurlng th&l: wee)tend, We playeq with all of hil3
19 fdehcla,' We hacl b<\l1ool1 thinga outl3:!,qe, all ldncl of gametJ
20 for the l~icla, all )dnd of toya t .It waa <\ good WEle)tencl,' \'Ie
Ii".
21 hEld a great weekencl,
aa Q At Elny time during the loth, did YoU enter
23 hel""room and have aexual intel"ooUl"ae with her?
.,
24
A
No,
25
Q
oicl you rip her pajamaa?
,71
l,u
/.
, ~ '
'111'
,. ,..
"
,"'""
~
1 rere~tedly plAPPed~1\yl r, the chil~, in the ~uttock~,
2 oc\Ufling h!m to fflll 9n lhe floor, And 1\13 he lflid l:here in 1\
~ fel:Al,poaitipn you kickld him peyerAltimel3 qpoU~ hil3 legfl,
4 ^ ~~<\t ip <\PPolul:elY ~nl:rUe, In fqct, I hqva
6, tOJq my f'jon on nI-lmel.'0\113 QCCal3iOnll. qpout whC\l: ha doefl with
6 hi13 tOYfl AI3 fAl" /113 r.ipping \Joxea, We hAve al:rqqition where
7 we tl:Y l:Q ta!te Cl\l'e of oUl.' toya eO we lmV'e l:hem for, A long
"0 time,' We \:lox them, He hF.\elmown month!!, <\ncl monthl3 ih
9 <\dVAI1Ce not to r.ip l:he baXi;lI3. He prOVOllel3 me in fl."Ont of
10 hil3 mother I pecAupe he lmowl'l aha lik:el3 it I IJlilC!\~\f!le ahe
. 11 t\oel3n't ollre that much about: hi13 tOYI3 Afl I do, ancl I3he
12 thinks it's 130 ~nimportant ,for me to get ~C\d flpout thAt,
,. j' , . .,
,,13 /3omel:.imee my apn p:royoltea me in fron~ of hil3 mom, He dpped
14 the pox in front of' me, and I SmaCllf.1q him on the butl:,
lli
Tha~'s all I did,
IlnOw,
"
I told hlm about it, not doing that, you
],6
17
10
19
Q Oic\ you repeatedly elap h,tm?
A No,
on hia "
Q Dicl you hit him <\rlywhe:re but but toolts?
"
A Nowhere' but hla butt, YoUr Honor,
Q Did ldoll him? ' '
you
A No,
20
21
22
23
Q
/~'he week of April 20th I the next allegation
;;14
Wae 'April 2:lrd, Did you have contacl: -. regulal: oQnl:aol:
,26 with the child dudng that week?
73
I';
'.
.,
,',.
"
1:a
13
14
15
16
" 17
II
10
,I
],9
20
21
2:l
23
:a4
:as
f""\
f~
, ], ^ Yel3 I I WMl WOl"I~~l1g I1P in HaPl::\'E\p\.lt"g thflt
:a wel3kl Th~ :aO~h WAI3 l:ha MOnq~y,A~ter the plrth~ny pC\rty, <\nq:
3 r hflq WOl.")t UP In Hflr~iI3P\.lrg, I pel!eye,
"
'1 Q Piq YOll hAve all flgreem\'lnt w:Lth'her ponoern:\..ng
Ii when l:,he ohilq wo\.\l~ !\oaO\1IPAIW :YOI1 to P.j.ttI3P\1l"gh for bhe
6 weekl:lnc\?
7
o
A Yeah, The next weeltenq, we Wel."e going to
hft~e ,/\ birthc\ay Party for him :\.n Pittl3Purgh with my famlly,
l!)(e we alW/\ye ~o eVl3l."y year, He' EI l."E.J<\lly exc:\.l;eq <\pout
,
that;, put he'a !\fraic.l <\round hill 1I10t:hal:' to Aclmit that he
wflntl3 to ooma to Pi\:tl3b\.\rgh, ~he knew thllt: the fol;l.owing
weeltend litter h.j.a l;lirl:hday PArty in HArriabul.'g thC\t we W6tllcl
.'
have l\ birthdAYPElrtyfor him in Pitteburgh, Pat
Q Dicl you hlA)te <\rrAngemenl:a wHh Ma, PeCE\rlo to
pi ok ~p l:h~ child on the :a3rd?
A Yea,
",
9
],0
11
"
Q Whal: ware the E\n"angementl3, aa you underetoocl.
them?
A Nhiah day'ia the 23rcl, 'l'hu:t'adf.\Y Ol' lrr~clay?
Q .. 'l'hul;a~ay ,
A 'l'hat Waa the day thflt aha ~ - I had a retltal
I.,
oar that weel(enq, Your Honal", And I tAlkecl to her early in
,.
l:he Weel~, I eaid, wouldL :you mind if I took '1'<\yloron
'l'huraclOlY ~I;1,l3tead of, J!'l"iday, becauaer wl\nt to helVe a
birl:hclay party for him in Pittabul"gh, I I m going to be
...t
74
!"
:a
3
4
5
6
7
0,
9
10
11
12
13
14
" lli
n ' 16
17
10
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
"
r"'I
. ,..'~
l'All"aC\qy qp here WOl')~ing, Anq I hAve l:0 ret\.lrn the, t'enl:A~
'01'11."1 IJeoF.\\.Hle my oO\r, Wc\lil in l:he flho/.l, And Iqiqn' t WAn\: \:0
',. hAve \:() QriVfl A~,lt:he WilY pAOlt to r>:\'tl:I3P\.I:r.9h ,on '~lhl\rf3qAY
night I\nq oome fill \:he WAY PflO)t, I1P on FI'idAY l:o p,tok: \\p my
aon\ ~ f3f\id, ainoe I'm alreaqy up here, woqld YOU m:\.nq if ~
\:ook him on 'l'!\l1rf3Qay, whioh I very rflreJ,y / 'rarely AI3)~ to
,
t:AI~e him A, deW' In A\:1Vanoe I 1\1130, on Frid/ly I i,t: W/lfl <\ UelQ
tdp c\AY, where he hAI3 a~re&qy wen~ \:0 Il1cliAn Eloho 8avernfl,
130 it: W!\l3n / t lil~e he Waa m.if3aing !\(laqemioa at All \ " /3he
f\greequpon it, Of OOUrl3e, ~l\:il the tim~ OAme, ahe renege~
.it, her \.I 13 \.I a 1 , /3he woulqn'l: lel: me 'hAve him,
"
Q' There, Wal3 telltimony hel"e toqC\y by MI3 I Dl'lCl\r~o
Clnq by 1413, . Joeey thaI: you oame to the hOlne anq thf\t you Were "
phyaioAl in for~ing your way into l:he houae" Can you
deaor:j.be what you beUeve hap(Jen8d during that time per:toli?
A Yea, /3ee,. odginally., the real30n why J013ey,
l3f\id th<\t I waa ao upaeb ie beocnlee '1 Went \:0 the 130hool t:o'
piolt"him up. 'l'hat wae the/;\rrangement, I'cl plolt him up on
'rhUrl3dflY, He 'Wasn 't ther'e, So, then I oame to hel'
<\partment, and I Si.'\W the whole plan in wci i"lt a , Joaey' waa
there with her ohild with the SonY plily at<\l:,ion, '1'hey
wanted to make it ao that Taylor WOUldn't w<\nt to lfl<\ve,
so, I get to the plaoe, and 1'\1\ Very upset, "
I'll aqmit it, /3he' a aitting 011 the (Joroh with JOl3ey, Md
"
the f il~at thing ahe aaya is, What are you doing here?" And I
75
1
2
3
<1
5
6
7
0
!)
10
11
~,2
13
" 14
lli
16
'17
10
1!l
" 20
'21
22
23
24
21i
I,
"
,,""",'
fI'""I,
~~YP, I told you ~ArJY in week, You knciw J WAP gal:~~ng him'
\:p[.\AY, Ilht'l flAya, oh, np, ,.I'm go~,ng \:0 pdng hirl1 [.\oWI1 on
!1':dc\I\Y ,I, WAIlt him to go \:0 1l1dl<\n Ji)oho \'1!,\vernf.l, I PAYfl/
PAII1A I yOIl Itnow thC\t 1'111 hC\ving IW rentAl OfU: pC\olt anq my
J;c\l11ilY'a hflVil10 A p~rby for h~m, I h<\ve l:0 hAve him 011
"
'l'huVl'ldi'\y,
So,'wepot\1 got upeet
, \.\p into l:he <\p<\rtment, bAnged on the
JOl'ley loqltacl the door, They HnAlly
:1
Sony, plAY I3\;At~on, It w<\l3n't ~ilte I WAa going l:o tAlte it
"ancl not return it, When he' a in Pittl3Pllroh, that' I'l,our
<\gr~,ement, l:hat: I tAlte it, Ancl then I bring it baol~ "You
lmow, we bought it for him for, hil3 birthqay, I grl\bbecl my
ohild, and I took him,' And I knew that I3he'would try to
I3toP me fl.'om tAlting my ohild', beoAUl3e ahe cloea not like it
when my famUy haa allY l:ype "of Aotiv,itiel3 for him, She avon
wanta to diarupt him having enjoym811\; out of thia, beaauae
I3he oan 't ~'tand it, beoauae ahe hAtep 'my parents And I11Y
J;amily 130 muoh. She di.dn't wanl: hi,m to oome to Pil:taburgh,
,
so ehe triec'\ to atop' j,l;. she tded to have JOlley Al1cl Dr.ew
thel"e I knowing if he ht:\cl a fdend thel'e 'ancl th~y Ware
,,'I
playing Sony and all thal: that hewouldn't want to leave,
Q NoW, Mr, Mag1in, at any time dicl you hi.t or
malts allY phyaioal threatelling move towal"d Ma, DeC<\rlo',?
.'
No. Josey eaicl that I pucihed her, I neVer
ancj 130reamil1g, I oC\me
cloor, peo!'\l.\pe her fll1cl
let me in, I toolt l:he
A
i"
'76
I'"
1
;a
3
4
Ii
" 6
7
,. U
9
10
1.1
1.2,
" 13
14
J,P
16
17
10
],9
20
21
2;J
23
24
:la
f"i
,...
PUl1h!u~ ha~", '(l1l\l." Honor, naver.,
I l:ool~ my 'phHc\, 1'hAI: WAil J.t:,
I PIIllhaq ~ha clP01: oPen, Mq
fmq l:he reAl'lon I WAI3 eo
Upl'lel: At JOfley ill peoA\1l'le IIOflflY amI I gel: Alorm, flnq her I'lon
And I gel: fllong Val~Y wall, I l:l"eflt: he~' I'lon ,lJI~e I qo my
own" I t:AI~e him PlAOefl, II: '13 gooq \~ci ,hAVe A CJhilq ,t:hflt
13<\me Age, I'lO I pring him flnq 'l'l\ylor t:oget:hal" when we go to
plAY PAl3epa:Ll OJ." putt-put:t goH or whflt:evel:, I t:f\l~!'l hJ.m ollt
t:o cUoner w:\.l:h me floCl Mil, PeCl\do <\nq 'l'l\ylot', MoneY'13 neVElI'
an ,tlll3Uei, 'rhey even fll3lteq me, qO you neeq aome money? I'd
/lilY, no, c1on' l: WOl"l:y "paUl: it;, I qon't mind, I'm 91Aq thflt
he'l3 here wil:h UI3, J\nCl ahe tool~ mY'Elx-wife"a /3:\.de OV8r. t;hf\t
i!'l/;1Ue, flnCl thAt gOl: mEl UPl3et, r~'hAt:,'1'l why I adq, Jopey, yo\\
E\nq Pr6W /'Ire Clone, too, NO,'mOl:,e me being Ml.", fIIioe Qu~', you
Imo\'{, ThAt'13 Why I WA/3 Upaet,
o And at any l:ime dicl YOU me/;\n to phYl3ioE\lly,
l:hr,ell\l:en <\Ilybody?
A I never thl"e<\tened anybody. AU I add Wfla
t:,hat you 9tlY13 are done, too, I'm not - - Taylor. ancl I al"en It
going to be bl"inging Drew flround anymore with ua, 'rhatll'3
<\ll I eaid, It Waan't a threat,
Q You cUd talte the CJhild, then, on the ~:.\rq?
A Yel3,'
Q How clid the ohilc1 reaol:?
1\ He WaG juat happy <\1'3 ooulc\ be, All aoon aej he
,. "
left the Camp Hill, arel\ and Wall on ,that tUl"np:\.lte, Your
"
77
I'
I'
f""\
f""I
3. 1I0n01:, he WAe h~ppy <\13 oO\llcl I)e, He'l3 eo fr:\.ght:enecl of hh
2 mo\:hel", YOII wIJllldn'l: aven believe i\:" You don' \: eVen lmow
3 how Vdghtflneq he il3 of. hh mother, ' '
4 Q You hac\ him fOl" l:henext fO\l1:' dl\yat l)id you
. Ii l3ee Any mArkl'l on him f.rol11 the til11e that you pllehecl him :\.nto
G the oE\l.'?
7 ^ ^~ fI mfltl:arof faot, I hAVe piot\lrea of ,hil3
o weekanq p!rthclAY pArty At my hOllfle right there, if you' q
9 Bite to ahow thr;lm to the COUl"t, He hflcl a gl"eC\t time. He
,,10 hAd <\11 of hil3 pl."el'lenta. He hAd hia family in l)lttaburgh.
11 'l'h\'lY hAQ <\ 'gre<\t birtMay parl:y for him, He had a greE\t
12 time,
13 Q " Now, <\fter the Altero<\tion on the 23rcl, did
14' YOIl hElve an OppOl."l:unil:y to pe wlth the ohild the following
,
lli weel~, whioh WOllld h,we been the weelc of M<\Y 4th, lith and
1G Gtll?
17 A YeAh, My ohilcl waa a iolt. ' Hel." <\l1cl I were
10 llt,ill gattingdong at that time. She hacl to go to aohciol,
19 And hel." jop I own <\ oompany, eo I ot1n F,1ometimea tt1lte off,
20 So, inatead of hermil'laing work, I s<\id, if he'a eiok, I'll
21 wal:oh him. No pl:'oblam, 'l'here w<\a no twenty-four,-hour
22 notio~ th.ing Hlte ah8' a l:alldng about. We ware all gel:l:ing
23 along fine,
24
21i
Q
Al: that time period, clid you watoh the ohi;l.d?
~ea. I aotually took. him l:o l:he hotel where
A
70
,',.
1
;l ,
'~
I!
E
6
?
0
9
;to
11
:1.:,]
':1.:3
14
;tli
;t~,
17
10
,,19
,20
2:t.
22
23
24
"
25
~
r"I
"
:r WOlf'! ~t~Y~ng 01\:. f.lhe I3AY,a in hel." l:tlatll11ony tllf:\l: ah13
qoean ',tfe~l." 'l'f:\yl.ol" when he'l3 neflt' ma Anq IOY pl"other ~lJ1q
"
~Ve;t."ypoqy, I haq t:he hotel room All py mYllelf, IHlq 'l'aylor
fllept; ~n the hotel., with me py hll11l3elf, '
Q '.l'hen the ne~~weeltenq, whioh WPulqhaV(:l peen
MAY OUh/ thal: Wfla your tlme to l:f:\ke him to Vittl3Purgh, ill
'that aOl;'reOl:?
11 'l'hal: Wa/3 my time l:0 tf\lte him to l?i,ttl3b~lmh,
He h<\q pf\f3abl\1l thflt weelt i I went to hip 9Al11e13, I WEla
invol. yeq, The coaohel3 even €\l3lted me to help oOfloh, peOflUl3e
one of, the oOAohea weren't t;hara , So, I helpeq QOAohing
t;here, getting \:he bl\tl:ing ol:qer C\ll Umlcl up <\nd
everyt:hj,ng, " ,:rt t\.ll"na out the r"rid<\y I l;mme to hll3 /3ohool to
piolt him up -" Ancl ehe Itnew I WAa worldng t;here All weelt __
ahe h<\f3 t:hia not:e l:o her lE\tolbltey t;eO\oher that the olJUq if.l
not <\llowecl to leave with me,
Q Now, unclel." Any oUl3l:ocly order, whel:her with
twenty,foUl"-hot\r notioe Ol~ unqar t:he regulO\l" al.ternflting
weekend baaia, thia ~aa your weekellcl, il3 thal: oorreot?
1 it
A 'Yea, itWE\S', YOUr HOllar,
Q You Wel"e in Harriaburg, and aha knew l:hal: I l,a
,t:hal: oorreot?
A Correot, 'rhat' a why I donlt underl3tf\nd why
13he wl~ote th<\t lel:ter kno\~illg thaI: I, waathere, Why would
ahe Warlt l:o dr,ive all of the Way l:o Beqfol."d When, I'm up
79
,'i'
""
"
"
,,.,..,
~
"
1
:a
3
there inllAp'i!3pur,g ancl ooulcl pialt hiln up? +l:'!3 lil~1l -"
Q' HAve yol.\ pioltsd up the ohild at: I:he flohoo:).
. . .. ,
pther timefl?
4 11 Ye!3 ,
,5 Q ., l'loW, '131113 :Lnclil=ll'lte!3 thl'lt - - let ma f\!lllrllfw \~ha
6 allegatioll thflt on MIW 7th, whioh woulc:l hAva bpoll \:hll
7 'l'hUl.'fldC\y night, that: I3he hfld rel:l.\rnl3q home \:0 '/!,l,nr.l yon
8 wai\!ing forh~r oU\:l3lqe the I\partment:, Whell t:ha Pl.n.!nl:,l, I: I!
9 went \lpl3ta:Ll."~ to hel" <\pArtmen\;, t:he Defollcl<\nt' f.O.1.l,DW[ll\ \1m:
10 into thf.'l<\partment,deapite her telHng hlm Ilot:, 1:0 [Jome :\.11,
11' ptlahecl t:he door open <\nd WC\ll~ecl in, 'l'h<\\: woul,ti luwfl hoon
12 the Thurflday,before the !3ohool epiaocle,
13 A ThAt Wal3 not true, ThAt Wl\fl the dAy ~f hifl
" ;1.11 bal3ep<\:).l gl\me, Anq I Wafl :Lnvitecl into her p1l\ae \',0 hal\,) him
15 get drel3aed for hia bal3eball gAme, Your Honor,
16 Q Dic\ you take him tm the pallebAll!gAme?
17 11 Yeah, I tool~ him by mYl3el f 0 ahe WAflll't eVen"
10 I1hel.'e, She dicln't oome until later on,
19 Q l'low, on the I,lth, again, you ardved 'at l:hfl
20 achool, Could, you dal30ribe what hE\ppflned, wholl yoll fll~d,Ved
~l at the achool?
22 A Yeah, I we,nt to the uchool /It: ,3130, aVail
23 though agclin, I feel very, vary Ul1Cloml:or,\:abll1galn9 to
24 the 80hool, beoauae dur:l,ng t:heal3 ot:hol: f.nlfl~ nl.l.llg'Il\::I.ol1a ,in
,
25 front of: Judge HeBs, aha brought: un \:\la/lIJ "" \:he tltillcipt\l,
no
'"
"
'If''''''I
,'"'"
t:lte t13f\oher I the lfltoh l~ey, Everybgcly WAI3 invP~,v(;lq in t!le!3e
ff\l!3a al~egattona a9ain13t me, ao they -- I fe~l: that they,
yoq lmow - - I ,f131l: thAI: they treC\teq me upfC\~dy, anq I fe~, t
very U\1oomforl:aple golng to the eoh90l., Elvery time. I Went
there, \;herfil Wall 130me \:ype of poqh"ontatJ.on, )\u I v.:~nteq
tQ AO woif3 plpl~up my ohP.cl, pe invol veq with the /3ohopl ~nq
l3ee hqw he'fl cloing in 130hool,
Q 1\nd you O\rriveq on May 8\:h \:0 l:ake him to
Pittaburgh, i/3 that oprreot?
A Yeah, I arrived on MflY Ol:h, 1\13 aoon '113 I
,
get there, limy, who jUl3t te~tified, t:e;J.l13 me l:hel."e' a 'I
l.etter, You oan't t<\lte him\I 'l3aid, what; clo'yo\.\ mef\l'l?
WhC\t'l3 goin~ on noW? What'l3 her ne~t move? what clid floe,
ptjJ.l now this tlme? The, letl:er wal3 that uncler no
oiroumatl\noea that ahe releAl3e my dhilc\, so, ahe sC\ye, wait
till Mil, DeC<\rlo oomel3 and try to work thia out, I waitecl,
al1d I waited, and I waiteq, ancl I waited, She finally oame,
Q About how lono did you hAve to wai t?
"
A I waited at leaa1: twenty mlnutel3, limy l3<\id
fifteen I twenty minutes, It: was "maybe twenty minutee or
more, When ahe got there, I aai.d, what are yol\ tryillg to
do? She l3aicl, I'm taking hil11 to the'~irehousa, I aaicl, you
can't take him to the pirehouae, It'a a new reataurant, I
said, thiB ia my weeltencll:o be with my ohild, He wanta to
pe wi th me l:hip weeltend, He w<\nta to go to the l~ireho\.\se"
01
:\.
:;)
3
14
Ii
6
7
0
9
,10
U
1:;)
13
""
114
15
16
,', 1.7
10
19
" ;i"
20
21
22
23
24
2ti
~
~
I f'lfliq, I I m fllreAqy \:Aldng him t:o ~)l\:\:/Iblll.'l1h, '1'11.11;1 ,j.1l III\'
weeltenq, YO\.l lmew th<l\:, I'm lip heH'U, Phll wn\l:llln' \~ .lul: IIlIl
tF\lt\'l h~,m, 130, I jUl3t ~HIJq, no WilY, /\1111 T \;()lll~ IllY Idclflllll
left:" I weill: l:o P"rPArA I a of I: ,1.013, 110PfHlfJIlI 1\l111W I:hll\: I~hfl
Wl\fl going \;0 OAll \:he roBoo, Mr.\ T 11,I,dn' t: 1\l:IIU lilY nhtl.ll",
He hafl r.\.1nning wil:h me, 'l'l1~ 1.1\1:oh-l~oy t:anelllu!: 1;(11)1: :1.1: i.Glj
l:hAt he cUqn'l: w<\nH to go, 'l'hnl:'u Iml:l'\lll, only l\l:n\llld hi.a
mOl:her qoel3 he not \'I<\nl: to be \'IH:h 1Illl, Whci!1 1\(1' /l not IIl:o\\nr,l
hi/.'l "mothel.", he loyel3 \:0 be wi.t:h IIlG, 1111 l.PYI~'1 1:0 ba wJl:h ,11\13,
Q' Wh~n you lel:t:' the IwhoCJ1, YOIIOAI1\U cUl,'epl:ly
to my offioe :l.nl3teAd of go,tng t:o, Pi,t:I:llblll:oh, i.f~ t:h<lt:
oorreot?
A Thal:' a oOl'l:eot, bOOI~\llJe I~heli I left - - when I
r&n to my o&r, you ,!mow, ~)ne of I:he lAl:olHIClY lucU8aa<!:LQ'
l:hllt they were going to be oAllintl t:ha polioe I /]0, I w<\l3n't
going to be driVing on thEj turnp,i.lta wJ.\:h lilY /.Ion <ilL ,IPaet
And \'lorry &boUt the"polioe, I wGnt to Ilni:bff] ol!fioe, I
Imew I dicln' t qo IInything wrong, :r wnl\tet:l (:0 t:nl.lt t:o the
polioe, We o&lled the poli.oe from YOU): offioe, Ii
Q And We a.l,ao olllled At I:ol:ney Connelly"
d
correot I to \:ry to aOl"t through whllt .I:ha iaall8 of this "
weeltend
A Corl'80t, Sea, , eVIH'Y time I \;l:Y be with
to my
son, Your Honor, thoro' f] Ill.wnya 0011\8 tYPl;l of aonfl"ontation,
I don It \'I<\nt Anything 1:0 do wi.l:h t:hiawOIllf.\Il, :r jUllt WAnt 1;0 "
11:1
.'
"
1
:a
3
'I,
il
6
6
,7
8
9
10
11
1;.1
13
14
lli
16
17
10
19
20
21
22
23
2il
21i
"
I~
~
h<\ve time with my ohHcl, 'l'h<\t I fl fill {WAnt, Why o<\n I I: I3he
, "
j\.ll1t follow the oourt: orderl3? ;r j\.ll3t don't \.lnde~"l3tl\nqi\:,
TIiIi1 COURT I ThAt'11 really nOl: rel'lponl1ive" <\T\c\
we're 13l:f\rting ,to l."eAl;1.y nm OUt of time,
BY MS, SUMPr,rn-su~r,~V^~1
Q The l<\l31: AllegEltion thflt il3 int'\i.oioltec\ on here
ifl MAY :a;lm:l, 1998, whioh Would have peen I:he ne~1: weeltend
yoU were to hav~ the ohi;1.d in Pittl3burgh, II: india.tea that
you helq A b€\flebAl;1. b<\t oval.' your I3hoUlqer anq th~"e~P8necl to
hit her, p<\ying I I3hoUlcl hlt y~u wit:h thil3, Cfln you
c\el3oripe
A Th<\t'l3 totl\1ly, tol:<\lly UT\tl:ue I' YOUl." BOnOl",
1113 a l11at:ter of, faot, I3he I3tC\l:el3 .in her,t:el3timc)\1y, in \:)113,
tranaodpl:I3, t:hElt ahe!iElqaomebody follow her to Bedford
thElt clay, Where ia t:hil3 mAnteatifying that I <\lmOf.lt hi\:
hel" w.ith thh PAl: l' 'rhElt '1'1 tot<l11y untrue I YOUr Honor I My
ohilcl Wae dght there, all3o, exohElng.tng l:he bal3eb<\ll pal:,
the Sony play f.ltation and t:he baaebElll glove. My ohilq,win
tel3tify th<\t, I never, ev~r rEl.taed that bElt to her,
Q So, you neverthrel!\ten8q hel", You juat
what cllej you do with t:he bl!\aeball bat?
A Another one of hel' - - just to get me \.IPl3et;/
she d:l.cln't bring the sony play station, I aelted for it tWo
oooaaiona prior I and ahe didn't bdng it "
numeroul3 on purpoa~
, j ual: to gat me Upaet, She 1 i}tea to get my morale going, '
03
'~
,...,
fllle H't!3~ to get me UPf'!et, n rf:ltll~y gatfl lwr fired UP,
Q Wh~t WAI3 your I1nqeratanqing <\13 to \:1113 dA\:e
thC\t your 'CJ\.lfl\Jocly for th~ l3t\mmar WO\I3 to oommenoe?
11 9n ~uly 6t~, hia,lElI3\::. d<\y of 130hOOl. ~UI3\:
Hlte the prio~" two I3Wnmer!'l, Your HOllar, I W<\13 to 9,et hi,l11 for
\;Went:y-one dO\YIl .i.n ~une, l:Went:y" one Qayfol :\.n ~uly, <incl
twenty' one dAYI3 in AqgUl3t, 'l'he next thino :): lmow, me flOq my
br.Qthel," oome to a PAl3epal:l. gAme, <\nq I3he haa t:hl."ee po1;lCJ8
offioerl'! there with I?fo'1I13, 'l'h<\t' a what: we',re here for ,right
now. My prol:her'clrove three hourI'! to see thl/3 poy play
baaepflll. My oh:\.lcl W~13 130 frightened and upset, ~n frO\lt
of All of t;he b<\sepAll ooaohe!3, in front ot: all"of the
pa/3epAl:l. playeri'll he aees 1,l.I3 f<\thel." bei.ng "" I don'\; Itnow
iff it:'13 oa1l8d ;!..noar08r<\teq or wh<\tever, but three polioe
ohioera oonfronUng me at hi!3 bflaeb<\ll game, My poor ohild
Wlla, flO upaet find eo I3tl."eal3ed out. r aoulqn'l: believe it t I
17 WAa Up therf) to wfltoh hi.13 game, find me <\nq my bl."otheir' W8re
10, going to l:ake him baok: ,to l'it:ti3burgh for hia twenty-on8
19 d~ya, then Po om , She knew I wl\a ooming for l:he twenty-one
;aD cl<\YI3, ancl ahe gel:13 the PFA, juet like all the ot.hera I
21 Q. The PI!'1\ l:hetl prohibitecl you from I3tartl.ng
d 22 YOUl." time periocl of oUal:ody?
23 1\ rnxaotly right;
24
25
:t.
:a
3
II
.'
5
6
7
a
9
:1.0
11
12
"
13
1~ .
11i
16
Q 'l'he heal."lng dAte that we hacl fo:.;' thia .1AI3l:
,
time before the Court was June lith, is that oorreot?
"
"
"
a4
Ii,.
10
"
,"'"
,..,..
].
1\ ~~A\:'1l po~rpo~,
Q 1\t ~IlY t:ima, Mr, MAOlil1, hAf1 ~he ohUq
i,Tlc\:\.Ofl\:ecl tp yoq or cle YOII peroai,v\'l the ohilcl \:0 pe f.aC\rf,\.Il
of yo\.l?
:1
~
4
Ii
6
1\
He j Ul3t 13pent
He' I'l helpp~' flf.!
Q
No wl.ly I 13hC\pe or !;orm, My oh:\.lq ~ova13 me,
\:wal1\:y-op,e dl\Yf.! with ma, YO\.lr llono~", ,in ,July, '
PAn pe,
7
o
Haye yoU eV!lr phYflioAlly tht'eAteneq M!3,
,!)
peCado?
1\
Never, she'l3 <\otllC\l1y ~)hYl3io<\lly \:lwe~ten~o
11 ' me ,
12
;!.3
,14
lli
,16
].'7 tha time, 'l'hia WOm~\l hela never eVel." been to ~ hOl3pit:al,
, ., ,
10 She I 13 \lever hac\ elny mal."ldnge an he:\." , r,oolt at these
"
lP pioturel3, I've never l<\ld 1.\ hand on thiawomAl1, Your Honor,
20" I mBeln, I might helve pUl3hed her, I might have gr~bbecl' het'
21' hl.\ir a few timea, I've nevsl.' physioelllY abuaecl this woman,
,22 nevel.', she has no proof of it, She hElS no hoppil:al
23 l."eCJorcla, no polioe reool."da, no anYl:hing, 'She doel3 thie 130
24 t,h!\t I oan'l: eee myohild, 1\11 ahe' a tryin\1 to do is lteep'
213 ms aWay from my ohild!
Q The OOUrae
of aopdqo\: thAt ehe'l3 cleeoribed in
1.\ hOl'ltile <\nq threa\:ening "
\:hil3 ple!\ding al3 oreAting
enVironment, "
,
A , ,Thia il3 'all p!\rt of her . . I don't Imow what
ahe'l3 4P t:o, She w<\nta to meel: at the l.Jolioe parl."!\o)tl3 all
Oli
1
2
3
4
5
G
7
0
9
10
" 11
12
13
"
~
~
'" ..
Q' 110 A 111 , 13~,noa ),DPO, YOII hA~ A OOntj.nul!ld
"~"alAI:i.on!3h1p,,w,i.I:h hel.", 11il' t 111\ \: oornlOl;?
".," ,
11' Yal3!,on Anq off, A !3a'X\.lAl r'31A\:i,onl'lllip on and
off.,
Q ,Il1noe 199Q, \:helle 13Ama fllleOAt:,ionl3 !3h~ lteapl3
mC\killg over Anq over, il3thAtoorreot?
11 Over Anc\ Ove~", OVel: And OVe~", It'!3 Pfo'lIl3,
'~t r I'l fle:x\.\a~ "AllegApionll, Now ip'!3 beating my ohL\.q, peflting
hel." , Whap'l3 ne:xt? I'c\ Lilte \:0 lmow what'a ne:xt, I'd
, r~fllly like to know,
o HaVe you 8ver hfld !3ex wit:h her ,in aaituA\!.ion
where eheh<\dnpt oOn!3ented?
A Never,
14
M/3, /3UMPr,m-/3ur,llIVANI I,hAve no fur\!.her
lli ..~ueation!3"
lG
17
10
" 19
20
::n
"
22
23
24
21i
,;
Tim COURT ,I Mr, Mol<night?
CRo/3/3-mXAMINATION
BY MR, Mol<NIGUT I
Q I have flfew QU813tione for you, l3ir, you
have A te\11pel', don't YO\I?
i .,
'A, .,It's more fruatration, I beLieve, t1lan'
tempel',
Q Well, when yoU'te fruatrated
,1\. If you weren', t IIb1.e to a'ee YOUl: ohiJ.cl _"
Q sir, anaWer the queation,
" I
'\'
,.'1,
OG
:\.
'I' 2
3
,1
Ii
G
7
0
9
" 10
;1.1
12
13'
14
lli
lG
17
J.II
lfl
20
21
22
23
24
213
"
~ ~
'~'Hlil r.0I1R'~'1 \'IA!\:, wflH, WAi,t,
'j'Hlil WI'l'NlJ1alll ,I'm /.lorry, YOHr 110\1pr,
THlilCQl1jFI'1 l\ai.lin, ypur l:eJ:l).JolwipUity i,J:I to
reI3P~\1q ~o \the que!'!~!!JI1I'l).Ju\: \:0 you Py Ooun"lel,
'1'Hlil WITNlilaa I I'm !'lorry, YOUr Honor,
BY MR, Mol<NIGIi'J11
o You' hAve A temper, ~nq whel1 you h<\ve, A
l:empel.", YOH l."flil3e YOHl" voioe', And you l3omel:imefl uJ:le '
profal1ity, don't ypu?
1'1:, Yel3, I do,
Q Now, /.lpeoifioAllY, YPu've Aqmitl:ed i~ your
, , '
tel3timpny that j,1100tol:>er of '97 there W<\a an !noident..
l:>e\:ween you <\nq M13, PeC<\rlo in whi,oh you engAgeq in puahing
,. i'
her, <\t le<\l:It in, pUlling hel" hAit, You qid do th<\t? You
flqmit thflt?
,
A It WM very millor,
Q \'11311, pu\: you did clo it?
A Yes/ I,did, She did it to 11\13, too, the (3ame
d<\y,
Q 'l'hroughoUl: your rel<\tion/.lhip / you've had
argumenb/.l, with her, /lndyoU've of\:en gol:ten loud with her,
and words haVe been apoken, iB that oorreot?
A' We've had <\rgumenl:I3, but: ehe/s the one thAt
,,,
alwAya WoUld argue in front of my ohild, '
Q Your poaitionla all of the atgumente are her
, ,
\,'
"
"
07
"
~~ '
:a
3
4
6
G
7
0
!l
10
:t.+
12
:1.3
;1.4
lli'
1G
17
",
~,Q
19
20
21
22
23
211
[.lli
~
--
Cau~t, il3 l:hAl: rtght?
1\ No, no,
mAin l:hing tll when we
l'm not: l3ayt,ng I' '" all Angel, 'Phe
h<\d <\rg\lmenl:13 I wo~~q try not to, Al."gUe .
I .. .
in frol1t of my ohild, 1Ind thAt's whAt oAu~ad mOflt of the
argwnenti, pao~~fle ehe would argue tri fron~ of my ohlld,
Ancl I:tolq her not to qO il:, not to do it; and not to c\o it,
,she wo\\ld naver give ma th<lt ana w:\.flh thAt I grAnted, pleC\l3e
clonot Arg\\e in front of. my ohilcl, She woulcl Il!?t clo thC\t.
Q There' 13 130me l:hingl3 thal: really upset 'YOU,
Ql1e of them you men\:ioned was if your ,l3onte<\rfl bo~ee, That
reAlly UPl3etl3 you, ia thAt oorreot?
,
11 'l'hAt cloeen' t reAlly upset 11\13,
(;I, Wall,yo\l l.'al/3e your voio13, <\ncl ~'ou get angry
at hil11, clon't yoU?
A I r<l1ae my voioe, bl.\t I don't hit him" l
clon 't, you l~noW u he ul3u<\lly knowa t:hat I - - lny voioe, i/3
pretty louc'\, eo that:' a good enough for him. I don'l: hElve to
I'
ua\\ally hH him, 'the only time I hil: him ia whEHl he rf,!<\l1y,
really doee e6mething wrong that, you know, I have ~6 emaok
him olf the lJutt, Moat of the Ume, my voice la good,,8nol.}gh.,
o On your direct tel3timony, you sdd 011 l\pril
,.
20th he de;l.;\.lJeratelY, in your preaenoe, ripped aome bOl(.e/3 of
hia tOYI3, and you raiaed your'voioe, and then you e\;lankecl
him on the bu~t be(,laUae you kliel'l it: WEI!'! deliber<\te?
A '1'h<\t' a dOl."reot, And Me, DeCarlo apan)ted him
00
"
1
2
~
4
Ii
6
'7
0
9
10
11
12
13
14
'11 15
16
17
10 "
19
20
21
22
~3
24
26
"
. -..- ""
./;,'
f~ ~
w~t.h f\ f.lpl\t:ul<\ pn nl11nel."oUa OOCAl'liol1l3, III I3he oaing \:0 lJe
to l:h<lt:?
the C,\u6fltion,
'l'IllJl COUR~'1 W<lit:., I'm f.lOn:y, '~lhC\tWf\l3n't:
r~HlJl w+'rNlillllll + ' m aOl:ry, Your Ilono1.",'
'l'HIil COUR'.!' I 'l'hl.\t PAl."t of the Anl'lwel." iI3
I3triclten,
BY MR, Mcl<!'lIGH'l' I
Q Now, on \'.he ;l3rd, you had gone l:~ th!3 I3chool,
" CIne! mAc!e
ClPpl:\renl:1y, not found YO\W I'lon there, and thal: yoU
<\ngl."Y, So, then you went ."
"
A I woulc1n't Ul3e the worcl very <\ngry, I wou:\.c1
uae the word <\ngl."y,
Q When you arrived at: the apartmen,t, YO\'\ aaW "
Ma, DeCarlo find her,friendeitting on the balcony, and you
i~med:l.<\~~lY'beg<\n to yell at them?
A 1>10, I clicl not,
Q And you uaed profanity?
(.
,A Thal:' a not true, 'rh<\t i!3not true,
Q IilVen before you got in the house, you were
09
10
11
12
13
14
-'
,.."
~
1
A Of 004rllei il:'a fAleq, Itl~ her frien~,
Ilhe'l3 goln9 \:0 I3Qok 4P fOl' her fd13nq, 130me o~ l:he\:I1~H913
t:hAt: 131113 WO\fl aAY~,lig Wal."a t:rqe, yefth, fJ'here'll no qqe~t:j,on
ftpoHt: it,
2
3
4
Ii
Q 1~lh\3re' il no quel3\:ion t:hAt: when you C\n'iVeq, PH
the 130ene there you were <\Ilgry?
A I <\rr!vec1 on t:ha, 130ene, I gal: out oC t:he
OAr, anq J a<\~c\, what'a golng on hel."e, PAul<\? ,What'a going
, pn here? '1Inq I3he ,!'la~e I I'm golng to c1dve' him clown tomorrow
'a~l 'the woW tp Pil:tl3burgll, We'll come w:l.th ~au ;130, at;.
,
thAt Hille, pur rel<\tionl3h:l.p wal3 l3l:ill 13\:rong, beoaUl3e aha
WE\13 going to qr:!.ve'l'flylor <\11 t:he way to plttl3burgh wit:h UI3,
Q !IIow,' if ahe hAd qI'i ven him <\11 the way to
P:!.t\:aburgh, ahe would h<\ve been in t:ime to hAve your party
Ii
7
o
f)
15 on l3E\turQay, ian't thE\t oorreot?
16, A She woulcl have been on time? I clidn't hear
17 you,
10 Q 'l'a~J.or wou;l.d have been there fOl" YOUl" party
19 on l3at:urday haq aile dr:l.ven hllil clown?
.' 20 A That I a true, but my oUetody time WAa on
21 FridaY I 'Elnd I WElnl:ed to tak~ him F~'ic1ay,
22 Q 'rhe whole ieeue was you knew that they hac1 E\
2;1 field tr:l.p on SElturqay, and you clid not h on l~l"iday, and
"24 you di,d not Wanl: hia fielc1 trip to' intel"fere wlth your plans
,21i to take the oar baok?
J;j,
"
'I,
90
"
"
....
".
",
"
:1 ^ '1'1111\:' 13 nol; I:n\a <II: fill, Whfll: l."efl:).ly hllPpeneq
2 i,fl We cjiflo\.lI3!'1eq it ~lIrUel" in \:h13 waelt, ~he rUqn'~ minq,
3 Ilhr;l I'lfliq, ha'l3 peen to :rndiAn JiJoho Cayernl3 onqe peCore, lie
11' doel3n' l: l."eftlly hAve \:0 go, 1\ncl I told hel." ...'.. I l3C\id, do me
I:i a fC\vp+, PA"I:).a, 1\11 of the money th€\l: :r give 'YOU, <\11 of
6 the b;il+I3l:hat:. I PI\Y fol." yo"" w~ill you leI: m~ have h~m all II
7 TI1Url'lc,'\&y inl3l;e€\q of a Fdc\II~, 131113 1'l00iq, yeAh, no proPlem,
" ,
0 Q YOII lmewthllt 'l'&ylor WAI3 e~peol:illg t:o go on
"
9 the field tri,p?
,,10 A '~'aYlor ah"~lIdy ltnew earli.el' in the weelt I:lmt
11 he WEll'ln't go~ng to go, beoauae we cjll3oUl3aed ... hal: flncl I
"
12 rl!.eou/3aed i:t an Monclay and 'I'Uel3dAY that he Wfll.m't going tQ
14
11i'
" :),6
" 17
10
19
20
21
22
23
24
21i
:t~, 'go,
Q But you lmew that 'l'aylor w<\nted to go on the
fielcl trip, clidn't ,you?
1110, he c:lidn't: He wanted " to
,1\ want l:o go, l:o go
"
Pitl:aburgh with me, 'rhe only rsaaon, Hlte I Baid, ahe h<\cl
JOl3ey and Prsw l:here waa 130 that he wouldn'U want ,to oome
with me,
Are you telling thip oourt that, aha arrangel3
thf\t aomehow that interfere a with your
'Q'
fl."iencla jUl'lt " 130
oustody j:ighta?
A
peroent,
Q
One hundred percent, CoUnl3elOl', 01113 hundred
So, you h~d !moWn thl/3 Joaey for a number of
"
91
1
~
3
11
Ii
6
7
0
9
10
11
1;;\
:L3
14
lli
J.6
17
", lQ
19
:aD
21
22
23
24
21i
,.
,..
lIIollt:lw Anq hA!:\ A ni,oa l:l'llA\:~onl3hi,p wHh her?
1\, Not A l1umbar'of monl:h~, 8he'~ known P<\t\lC\
fo~' ton I\\ontlw. aho'll no~ Imown I\\e for <\ nllmbe:r: of mon\:hl3,
Q I ~hpW you/.\ note, ,WoHld YOIl ~,clent:!f.Y that
for UI3? "
A YeAh, It 100k13 like il:'fl TAylorl~
hl\ndwt'iting,
Q HAve you eyer ~een ll: pefore?
A Jljevel" t
Q You've never ~een it pefore?
A Nevar,
Q 'l'<iylor neyer indioC\ted'l:o you that he WAnteq
to go to \:.hif,1 field tdp p~"iot' to your ~howing IlP on, the
23rd?
A No, beoaul3e' he l~new he wC\nteq to go to
Pittaburgh inl3tead for hie big bil."thr:\ay J?<\rty.
Q J:ql show you - -
A " Yotir l!onol.", he'a alreaqy been to Indian IDaho
Caverna, He didn'l: even Hlte it, He'a afraid of it,
'I,'
Q I'm showing you a oopy of l:he note
inc\ioating --
"
MS t SlJMPr,m-SUJ.,LIVAl>l1 I I m going to objeot to
\:.he relevance, We'll al:ilJulate thal: thel"e WE\a a tl,"ip to
Indian moho .0averne t;h<\t Was aoheduled for the 2,4th of.
April t
"
92
"
~,
fiM'l'
1. Q!'lo l:h/.\t \:h),/3 wOmAn il'ln It: WOl~t:hy of ,l:rHl3t, Allq
;a yClH we+~ ooi,no to elq whC\t you felt: YOq, hAq '(:0 do <\~ thf\t '
3 po~nl;?
1
l\
It'l3 not WhAt I fe~t Ihfld to clo, It'~ whfl~
Ii we agreed \.lpon a~+;l.ier in tl113 w~ek, He+and I f\greac\ tl1f1t I
6 Wpu:\.q ~f\I~e ~'Aylpl' on 'rhm"l3cl\!\y, He mil3l'led I'l,ixteen c\AYI'l of
7 130hool ~hia yeAr, Counselol:, One \110ra clflY waSil' t: golng to
o h~l:t, el'lpeo~<\lly H it WAa A fleld tdp,
9
o !'la, you the\) phYl3i,of\lly gl"C\pped him Py the
I.' .
arm c\llq gl"l\pbecl hll3 P:\.C\Y I'll:Atic;m?
1(l
J.l
Ii No, no, no, 'l'hf\t'l3 !lot true,
0 ' HoW c\icl YOU get him - -
"
A TAY:\.OI" / when he/fl in t:ha oare ofhi!3 mother,
he' ~ petrified of 'hel:, I grabped h.i.m Pyhifl hancl, ~nd we
12
13
111
lli w<\lltecl down l:he I3tepl3 to my o<\r, And he wa!3 happy Aa oould
, 16 bE;! <\13 aeon Ela We got out of the area ,
17
Q
113n't It true l:hElt <\a YOlI were grabbing him
10 Py thE;'l hanc;\ he's sElying, I don'l: WElllt to go?
19
A ., Never ever did he aay that, l1evel", Your
20 ItohOl:, 1-18, never sflid that ollce, He neVlU" aa!clit once I
21
22
23
Josey totally lied up here on the atand, '1'hat wal3 a He,
..
'l'J.1Iil COURT, Plaal3e, Mr, 'Maglin,"oalm clown,
'I'HIil WI'I'NESS I 1/10 aorry, YOUl' Hqllor,
'l'H1il COURT, We'll talte <\ five-minute reoess,
24
21i May! Bee oounael iriohambets,
94
, '1
7,
o
,...
'"
1 (~reoe~~ WAP ~Ak~n,l
~ [J1\Wlll~NOlil Jil, Ml\Qr~IN ~"el3\\m(ip \:ha 13\:lIncl,
3 IW MR, Mol<NIOll'h
4' .
B
6
0 On l;he :a3rcl, whel)' you W8re in the ~p~l."tmen\;
ge\:~ing YO\\l" pon, q~,q you hAve ooollpion ~o tell MI3, peCf.\l.",:\.o
\:!1C\t yo\.l wo\\lcl pe riq of hel." 13001l?
1\
'Q
!'la, thAl:'fl not l:rue AI: 11:\.1,
WhAt'~ ~ot I:~ue At a:\.l?
yo\\'ra trylng to al:op it, You're trying to atop it, I "111
taking my ohild, It'a my oUetoqy, IInd I'm taldng him, we
Elgl'eeq upon it: aEli:Uer in l:he weelt, That'll ;\,l:,
"
10 " Q When you turned to JOl3ay <\nd aaic1, and you'~e
.' 19' dana, Coo, what dicl you meAn by that?
20 A When I said"thal: to J<;J138YI We Wel.'e I was
21 alraady In the oar wi\:h my eon, and we Were leaving, JOl'ley,
22 Wae on tha baloony aaying all. of theae' profanity I:hingl3 :t
"
"23 didn/t:: pay <\ttention to, All:r l3aid Wal3, Joaey,l .it/a a
24 shame, I got out of my oar ,I al:opped, ;I;aaid, youltnoW
2li'whAt, the way,I treated D~eW allcl you guye/ it'a II shame th<\t
913
"
"
)i
~,
2
3
4
6
6,
7
Il
" 9
10
11
1:a
13
111
11i
'16
17
1()
19
20
21
22
23
24
I,
25
~
,.
yO\-l WO~llq take her l3i.de, l)onf t YOH even lqww l:hfl\: you '. rs
\Jeing \.!fl\3d IJY \:hi,13 wom<\n? 'l'he only 1'e<\fll=1I1 whY YO\.l're h\3!~e
if:! l:o 13 \: op m8 f~"om l:fI)~ing mY ohild, '~'hen f3he wall\: pn A\1q
On, Md:]: I3dd, YOH 'lmow wh<\t, YOU'l."e done " tOO, yoq <1m!
prew, I'm not going \:.0 pe M1', Nioa Quy AnymOre, 'l'hC\t'!3 fill
+ fldq,
Q Yo\l We~"a in \:\le mic1dle of \:hel3t~"eet when YO\~
qiq thflt?
A No, I WAI3 on \:hr;l other l3iqe of t:he I3t1'eet,
ahe hAI3 one lfl.ne on eaoh a icle, 'Anq there' 13 an i131flncl, I
t\lrnec\ the o<\r f\rotmq, he<lc\:\.ng tow<\rdf:! l?itt:l3burgh,
Q Now I you ',c1a <\c'\mit \:ha,~ when you ,0Ame to t:he
l3ohoo1 on May Oth anq yo\.! hacl thflt dil3oufleion wlth MI3,
pecqrlo whan she arr:\.ved after abol-lt twenty minutes that you
then deoidec1 that's enough o~ tllia di!3oUl3flion, you took your
ohilc1, and you l~ft?
A l'lo, tlu\t' e not what hAppened, Whflt happelleq
wal3 I waa waitlng for MI3, DeCarlo for twenty mi,nUl:ep I Ancl
TaYlor, W<\!il very, very etreaaec1 out, very UPI3E!t I beoatHle he
)tneW th<\t ha WE\13 auppoaed to oome with me, f\ncl he waa afraid
to qefY his mother, totaUy afrdc'\ to defy hie motller,' Il:' a
f\ I3hame it hf\d to get lilte thisl Your Honol.", I It\loW thElt my ,
child'Bin a bad aft~ation,
Q 'p Si,t', jUet anawer my queation, W1Wn you
deoided to leave, whal: did you aay to 'l'aylo:r I we're leavillg?
96
"
;I.
~
3
il
Ii
~
7
B
9
10
11
12
13
14
16
,16
17
'j' :t,(j
1Sl
20
21
22
I
23
" 24
,26
'!"
',",
f' ~,
,...,
A I ~Il~,cl, I'm \:C\)~~,ng h~,11\ ~,o p,j.~t:ap\.\+'gh, :q:'",
'.;: . .
I11Y tim~ with him, ,
Q WhAt: 'did YOIl I3f\Y \:P'rflylor?
1\ what qicl :I: flAy ~oTAylor? '
Q , Yep,
1\ I I3Aicl, lel:'a go to Pittl3Purgh, 130n, Ancl he
a<\YI3 I o<\n'tgowith
I'm not <\llowed to go
I3Aicl, 1/111 nOl: "Hawed to go, My mommy
you. I'm not Allowecl to go with you,
with YPI.1,
Q so, wh<\l: q;l.q yqy qo?
wait8d ,
1\ I for Ma, PeO/u'lo to ahow up,
"
Q Wh<\t c\id you do <\f\:er ahe I3l10weq up?
A' She l3aid, 'l'Aylor / yoU oome wil:h me,' I add,
na,' he/a nol: ooming with you, He/a ooming w,ith me, I toolt,
him, And I got in my oaX', fmd I left,
Q Now, YO\l toolt him, and then got in your oar,
You aaid you ran to th~ oar,
A We j~ggecl to the oar, beOAU138 f;lhe waa oa:LHng
the polioe ,They ware oalling the polioe,
I
TI1El' COURT, Ple<\ae ,oalm down, Ml", Maglill,
'rllEl WITNElSS, ElxoUae me, :r ' m 130rry,
13Y MR, MoKNIGHT,
Q You're able to run faster tha~ Taylor?
A We weren/t running, We were just jogging, I
knew that I Waan't going to get into a oonfrontation at l:hat
il7
,,11
j'"
"
"
"
"
~
*"
1 ~dhool With f\l~ pf her te~oherl3 ~ncl ~ll o~ her Crt~nd~
:a t\1el."s I I lmew that ~omel:htng WA~ going to hC\ppen where I
'3 WAfi'm' \: going to pe APle tD t:C\lte my Ilon \:0 l)i~t~pl-lr.gh fo1' my
1\ oH~\:Or.ly, I W~l3nf t going l:Cl let t:hAt: h~J?pen ag~in, ~o ~hl'lt' fl
Ii when I \:op)t htm into the 0<\1', Al1q we wenl: l:OM1:13, llul1i.vl'ln' fl
6 off:\,oe,
'I I.,
?
MH, Mol<NIQUT, Thol3e Ar.a 0111 the (we~ti,o'll'l I
o hAV\3,
9
Mil, SUM~'r.,m" SUr,r,IV1IN , Nothing furth~:r.', yot\r
" i<
lP Honor,
H 'rHm COURT, you mOlY Iltep qown, 'l'h,mlt yo\.!,
12 Anything fur.ther, 'MI3, SI-lmple-SI-lllivan?
13 MS, SUMl?r.m-IlUJ.r,IVAN" Your Honor, we h<\ve 110
~4 further wit:ne~eea, but I WOUld, in fact, Aak for l:he
lli fl,dl1'1il3llion of our exh:l,bi\:fl, please,
16 'rum COUR'1' I 'Mr, MOI<nlght?
].7
MR, MDKNIGHT, No objeo~iDn to thoae
10 exhibitl3, Your Honor,
19
THm COUR~I All right, Defencl<lnl:'13 mxhibitp
,..,," .'
20 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 are admitted,
21 (Defandallt'a mxhibit Noa, 1 l:hrough,1i were
22 admil:ted, )
23
24. teatimony?
25
'rHPJ COUR'r I Mr, MoJ<night, any rebuttal
MR, Mol<NIGHT, I don't think ao I Your Honor,
90