The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About98-03634 ~ '~ J ~) t.1'\ '!I: I ~I ~. I I Ii ~' ~ \1, 'I, '<If " I' ,I /1 1" ~ .' " " " ii \ '.q" " ~ ~ ~ ,,' ~ v ~ if' 'I.' " , , , " " ii" .' \ \ \ j; I." " it! I' " " " I' ;, I'" " ,,. f I ;. ';i ti,. ,I " ~" /' ./' 'f' !; " " if , ",<'- ,i'T ;I, ,I' /, , " ~... - 'j. " '\ i' " ;; ,," " ii 'L ! , I I I I (.1 \,; ~ ). I' " " " ij I' " " H jl!, " I' I' , ,,, I' {Ii :--. ~ , ~ )1' " " ',i " ! ' " I' ~ <"j ,"'l " ! . ,~ " d' " d' J', " " ul,1 ~! I I ! " fLQII'TOTJ\ 1..11 pl:oapn\:p Oil P111:11 nol:j fJO/H'.lo q\lo IHl!:un h/~ a.trlo rjom/lnr1/H:jp en Il.t 'l'r.ql\ln/.\1 no ,1\1111:(oJ/1, f.l.l \la\:orl rlOaaA rjufonr1orao rlo ,1 (HI A.to(Jl~oj,onell II .t11 clel\1l111cll1 o lIP \I orl1 \:/Hl all 11113 aJglI,lenl:ul1 p/.lg.lntlll, IH1t:oq I:!ano IIn pl/~?oo Chl voJnl:o (20) CUlII3 /1 Pl\rt:Jr clo 111 /:00h/1 (101 I.Imp.l.l1?ol1mJonl:o Y not;,lfJo/.l'oJon (to 1/.1 (jOI\1An(ll1, tJal:ecl puoc10 oompwr.ool.lr par Y oaorJto poraOll111mento 0 I1trl1Voll qo 1111 o~o(Jl1cjo, OHponJendo aUIl daf~naAa u objooJonea 11 .tall a1o(Jl1aJonaa on au contra, 80 111 ndVlorto Que qo no OUmp1Jr con 10 antoa eHPueato ae oontJnuarA oon loa prooedJmJentoa y ao podrJo qJotAr aontonoJI1 on au oontra par 01 trJbunal aJn avJao 0 notJfJoaoJon, par ollalqllJor roclamaaJpn on qJnoro aoljoJtAdA on 111 doml1nnl1 0 oualquJor otro romedJo aOlJoitl1da porIA parte dpml1nQI1 0 aUAlquJor otro romodio aolioJtAdo por 111 PArto ~emAnqante, Se Ie I1dvierte quo uatod puode perqer dinoro u otroa dorenlloa importl1ntea, Usted debo llAvar oata deml1nda a un obo(Jado JnmedJl1tl1mente, Si uetod no tieno obl1gado 0 no puode pagar por alia aorVioioa, vaYI1 on peraona 0 1111010 por tolofono .11 la aiguionte aficJna parl1 pbtoner informacJon acbro oomo ConaoquJr aaJatoncia logal, CUMamIU,TlND COtJN'llV LTlWVmn nmF'mnnlU, smnVICm Court Tldminiatr~tor CumberlAnd CO\lntY,Courthouse CArlJale, PTI 17013 (717) 240-6200 !j , f! P iI, ~ I , 'I I, i,r i , IlPACP fO\loelll\:loO 11I:llHy hoo)( Upl3, Aoc1 lwma, A \:r\lfl nnlj correot: copy of' Wlllch pAr\: hereof, IInel '"f~rl\ec\ nil Ii1xhlN\: "!l", \:emporAry hOO)( \lp \:0 oKtll\:lng III A\:\:nchod hora\:fJ, mncla A 7, Tha PlA1ntlff13 hAVO f,\llfillOcl All the provi131on13 o~ tho Agroeman\: on thoir PA~\: to ~e porformoq, p, ~he plAintlffl3 hAve pAiel tho pefendAnt $aO,ODD,OO And $0,100,00 Accor~lng to \:ho contrAct~, P, The oontrAO\: cnllll for \:ho performAnCe of cer\:nin work And \:ho f\lrnl13h1ng of Cer\:AiO mllteriAls ~y POfenelAnt na \:horo1n Il tl~ tocl' 10, The pofendnnt hAll'fnilod \:0 properlY complete the provi1310n13 of tho Agreemen~ on ita pAr\: \:0 be parformed, 11, PefendAnt hAS wholly nogleoted to do And perform cer\:Ain \:h1ngl3 which Wf3re flKPI:el'lsly or ~y nfloeSlwry impl.l'cf.\t.ton reqU.tr.eq to bo done nnel performed by the agreement, Aa followal (AI 1nstAII the conorete alAb At Or bflloW at induatry Acaeptoel depth, (b) inlltAII footera iufflaient to support the homol (c) fAilnd to Allow the cement to curo ~ofore placing the home on the alAb, And (dl fpiled to wrnde the excAvated mAteriAl properly nround th8 home, 12, Pefendi'mt hAS pC'lrfo:r.med in a poor, improper,' and unworkmnnlike munnei certain other thingawhich were expreasly or by neceaal.\ry impl.1cation required by the agreement to be done And porformed in A proper And workmunliko mAnner, aa fpllowal (A) the home wua not located next to the exiating deckl (b) the five aoursea of eight .inoh block surrounding ,the home hAVO cruolted I (c) the oement alab upon which the houae aita ie oraoking And ah.ifting/And (dl th~, houae floor ia not level, , 13, The Pefen~Ant trle~ to repAir the orAak~ on or A~O"t Novem~er ~Q, 1096, ~ut the orAok~ returne~ within ten ~AY~' 14, '1'110 paf,pndnnl; hA~ AI; l;he plllint.lff,~ a/lpen~e rl~qvl(led more fill Ar.qlln~ \;ha hnme An\~ grA~od \;he fUl Arnl!n(l l;he home, l5, The pofen~An\; hAa f,Al1e~ An~ refllae~, And ~tlll refllaea, \;0 oure the remAining AforeaAid ~reAohea, ~eapite P1Alntlff'~ ~emAn~ thAt the orAoka And the OAl!ae of \;ha orAoking ~e repAired, 16, ~he reAaonA~le ooat of remedying the Afore~Aid ~reAonea la In ellCeaa of $15,000,00, 17, pefendAnthAa ~reAohed hi~ Oon\;rAot with plAintiff, And PlAintiff hAO ~een dAmAged~y DefendAnt'a ~reAch in An amollnt of At lellal:$15,000,00, COUN'l' I I 10, PArAgraph~ 1-17 are incorporated aa if fully atAted herein, 19, ~he l'ennaylvAniA Unfair TrAde PrAoticea IInd Conallmer Protection LAW, 73 P,ft,C,S, Seotion 201, et, aeq" d~finea A~ An unfair or deoeptive Aot or prAotioel , (vii) Repreaenting that gooda or oerviceo are of A partiCUlAr . atandArd, qUAlity or grAde, or that gooda Are of A pArticular atyle or model, if they Are of another"" (xiv) FAiling to comply ,with the terma of Any written guarAntee or warrAnty' g.l.ven to the. buyer At, prior 1;0 or after a oontrAcl; for the purchuae of. gooda or servioes ia mAde"" 20, DefendAnt hAS violAted the Pennaylvania Unfair Trade practicea And co~stim~r Protection lAW, 73 P,ft,C,S, section20l(4) (vii) by Defenctant'a aotiona and inactions dotailed in paragrapha 1-17, above, APPIIIDNA'. THIlMa ANP PPNPITiPNa 'II lulIlrllluf \lI\elurnloo<1 <lnlluUroll<l: ' . , Tho or<<or <ill 1110 rovorllo IIlelll hU!llOllu uIIII/pol 10 IlIulollowlnu Illlll1U 1Il1CllIolle!lllollu, 1111 01 wh!GII IHIVllllupll mlllilnlly "uruod \lpOn: , .1 ,[I\-Ihll-. u,v.\InLlI.,\ll..lru.,Il'II11\lQ1I..rJl.lJl.r[\I~UIL. 11I.lhu-aruur.I.D,.'.IIlI:lI.lllIDII.lrUIIUUllI11l1l.,IIIII.IUlf~lll1.ur.Jlllrllln,.~D.f ll~f-IIWhlt \ll11lWlf-lhlL\tullv.ur~Il!-I,IIl..Irull\lft-l\la~lIuhllll1ll.D l-V.ghlaJIl.\IruUra~...ulll!-'Il-lIUllarlillnllll..\'iI\lI.lhu,lunn'-lIl\tl\toll~11lllf\ll.lI.!-AAV: Ill. 1I111.ll\IlIlIj\.h ul/.Jl. n-Ihll.. Ullll.ll.f_lhllLllruUf~I.I~Il.I\ll\lf_llllUlllIl.\LII.fUIIIIII.Il\DIIIIIIl.llllll-\l-1l1l1r.ull.I".U'\lIl1IrllV-IIUIIlIlfl.IIlIIW1I.-I.\luh-alhuf Jl1fm-l1l-llIlUlllIllUlll.IIILlllllv...\lll-fll{\\llrllll.IW-lIlW..Tlllu.I\1.. 111\1,.1\'111 Pl\Iunl..ullull.rJlI/lllln.ln,lhlLllulluf ...llllllL\llll..lIUlllulWl,ulllhlllll flflllll..l. hU. f.llWf-lU.1Ul1dJn.l\lII.ll. Jllh..,QUI.\I11\\LI.llIVI1IUl\IJUllllrulll.h lI\LbllUn,.UJUlll\ll~ ,..lllld.uUllllllllUl.bV-llblln kJlfJIIlQl\QJl.lllll\lllll: J1~lhlilllllflll.l\.llll\l.-llllliuILIIlPU[JihIlDU[_UV.UIl.lhau ull. nlllunLllullv.\lI'J.1l1nv...blllll nllll..nl_n.~AmlUlolu, , 'P.,Tho pqrohnsor nurous 10 < ollvor 110 orlolll"llllIl 01 11010 or Iho 11111110 qny Ilsur Olll, lIIohllnholl1o, Irullpr or vohllllu \rllllu<< In lIlI pM11I1 p~ymunl ~lol1o Wllh \1111 elolIvolY of Ilia o~leI propnrly ,10 cloolnr'o prol11lsus, IIml <loulI wnr1OII1 Ihnl slloll on!, moplluholl1n,l1Ollnr or volllolu 10 Ila his Pfopolly, Iruu IInel oln~r 01 nil 1101111 1111<1 unUIIlI1\lfIlIlUOII OXllnPlllQ olllorwlllll nnloel 011 Iho 111011 ollllls lnlllr\llnunl, I Pllrol1noar Walfonlo \111I1 01111111 I~Xou 01 uVllry klllellovluclllonlnul Ihu lIuu<< vullllllu or mol1llohomo Irnllo(1111 I1nvu Iluon hIlly p~lll, i' Sholllcllln.r 00. v.ormnolll 1I0unllY luvv or ulohn II lox 11011 or <lumol1cl 011 or oooll1ul olloh IIso<1 VOlllolo, Sull~r lI1~y, III his opllol1 PIlY Iho i'.' o lI{T1a , unl Purohlloor 1I010uo 10 roll11h\l[lIu Iho omo\lflllhuruol 1II11110dlllloly \IPOIl <IOl11l1l1e1, or, sullur mllY, III his opllnn ~1I11 Olloh ['" ",,' ~mo~lII\ lu 1110 1I~lns oonlrllol oovorlno Iho mollllohol\1o orclorocl 1I0roln 1'111111110 SIlIl1U ulloOI liS IhnllOh orlolnnllv Inolllllo(1 Ihoroln, , " , 3, II Ihu II110d proporly Ir~elocl In In ruololaro(1 or 1I110llllocllll ony ploou olhor IIIDII Ihu ololu In whloll Ihlo orelor Is wrlllun, P\llllhnllot , 'uor.aoQ 10 lmmoclllllaly ouollrO roo.lslrollon lor sllllh vohlolo IIn<1 10 poy ony IIn<1 ull oxponsoQ IIn<j roolsl1Ollon loos Inolrlonlnllhorolo, 'Sho\1l11 !Jullor 111111\11110, or Ilo p~lllo, ony OXpOnQO In oonnoolloll wllh sllnll roOlslrllllon, PllrohllSllf will PIlY Sollor 1110 mnollnl Ihuruol on '! d, IIOml\flC1 or Bollor muy nelel, ~1111o op\lon, IlIu Ollmo 1(1111~ oonellllon~1 onllls oonlrlllll ollvorlnu 1110 mollllol1Cllfln orcloru<1 hllroln wllh Ihu I,'" ' onmo ullool liS 111011011 orlolllllllY Inohleloelllloroln, ' ",':\) ....' , :. 4, IIlho \Isud Irllllur or 1\10llllull0ll1u Is nol dullvorocj 10 1110 <Iolllor <ll Iho limo 01 orlolllolupprnlonl, IIn<IIII~lor, on 110 (Iollvory 1\ ; '\'." 'nppumo 10 Iho rlo~lor \lloru hllVo hOol1l11olurllllnhol1ooo mll<lo 111 \110 hllnlBlllnOG or QocooQorlos Ihoruol, or In l1u 00l1orll1 oomllllun, Ihu I'. ;', ,lln~lor,li'loll,l.hun I1uvo 111u rlohl 10 1I10ko II ruopprnlolll, This lolor opprlllnol Volllu will IlIun qolormll1o Iho 111101'101100 In IlU 1110(10 lor slloh t/'1!I~I\'f~9Irollur,'m~'l'!'0"PIJJU' or olhur vohlulu' f,,' , ;! ;,Q,'llw,m~l)l'fno'l!rUr h~s \lID rlol11 10 lI1uko <lIlV oh<lnous In IIw 11101lul, or IlIu (Iuslonll or OilY lIooussorlou unci pllrlo 01 IInv OIlPSO. :~, \ ~\tunl nuwlrnilqr.'9r,'muhllohul\1o 1I11111Y IImu, wllholll orollllno on olllloollon on IlIu Pllrl 01 ullllur Iho dualor or Ihu 1l1111111fllulurar, \11 ; ,',I ,1\Q1qk\l:oq(fospq!1~llno ohul1oQs In Iho Irllllor or mollllohol11o elusorlhod IIncl oovoroel hV IIIIQ or<lor ollhor l'oloro, or Quhsoquul1l 10, <Iollvory ': .1", lq\ ouoh uqlllpll1~111 10 Iho purohllQor. " , l,hY~':\hl\, ., ~! 80~I~JNi~r:!!,,~ot IIU lIuhlu for QolllYo ollusn<1 by 1110 II1UI1Ulllo\lHOf, 1I00lclonlo, slrlkos, IIros or <lilY olhor OIlUS~ lloyon~ 1110 0011' I .',,' ,71WARRANTlf:!al Tlif:! PI1Al.13R attAl.~. QIVI1 TO Tltl1llUygR pOPII~a OF ANY AND Al.l. Wl1ll1f!N WARllANTlll1l ooV- : i" ,f!RlNCt.nt13UN1T P13SoAII3I1P IN TIllS AQRf!I1MgNT ANP Al.l. SgPARATf!l.Y WARRANT13P'APPl.IANoga AND OOMPO, :t!;t.W~:]'NgNTa,"wwott WARRANTII1S ARIi ttgnrmy AaalQNIiP TO Tltlll3UygR, gXOI1PT TO nH~ I1XTI1NT PAol.UIllTlm UNDI>A !1;"l\IU'>~, ,aTATlll.AW, mil Pf:Al.I1R MAKga NO WAARANTl!:a, I1XPAI1Sa oAIMPI.n;p, ANPL W1TI10. UT 1.IMITATloN, PISOl.AIMS TIiI1 ,(~":;)'~;~~~H~,~, ~~R,R~~TII1S OF Ml1l1ottANTAl3ll.lTY ANP FITNllBa FOA A PARTloUIJ\A l'UAPoa13. ',' ',' : !I' 1h1'l'\"'" ," , 'IbIl-ll1ll'.lll1UlJlwuthlluJl!1tDUllllLhoJIJlLlIllOmllluU.\hll..,ulldulll.JII\d1nuluULJlIllllh10 lor 1111LlU1ll1a.uJ1lt.lIllll11l4 i ;,r".!,' :":,, '" tbIlULJlUl.ln\lJlJlptoulll.JlQlIDUl~nd.thoUllUlW.tulV..llnJlllUlWItludurnUlll..l111IlJIIl\llllllJan..', \ (~.. " il:"') " ',0, (Q) II Iho qollvory 01 IlIu 1l10pllo 111111 IB Inolucloc1 IIllhu pllrohuso prloo, or II Ihu clBlllor quollIB p uhurOD lor 'eI,ullvury 100Iho ous. , . i, .,,: 10mo~B dusllnp\lon, holll IlIu Potooll1onllo Irllnsporl SQld unll, os 1'1011 os Iho prlou qllolll\lOI1 I\1l1do, la husodupon'6hulomor's uasut. !hil' , "MoO Ihul Irnvalls IIlono oouapl<lhlo oll'wuplhor surluoml rouds, fully opun 1111(1 uoooss!hlo, from poll1l of orl01l11o polnl 01 dollVury, dur. ' "', ",:" "Hno Iha porlocl roqlllrod.for Irunsporlallol1, l'urol1allor aosllll1os all roapol1slhllily for IlIu propor proporallon 01 Ills proporlY 10 holll ruoolvo 1/,: ;"..,and 100nlo,llIo"oald,m~pllu linll,lil uvonl 01 Iinpoellmolll, nol provlollsly dlsolosod 10 111,0 dOlllurbroqlllras 01 oxlrulllhor \Wl IIqlllpmanl, "I' 1" ',lhooUslul\1or horo,wl,lh .lIoroos 10 poy for QII ouuh addillonlll ousla IInd 10 110111 uullO. r fruo Irom 110 IliIy for domooos roslllllno Irom 1110 1100 ! :'),V~\.\~of:oXlrlllabororllho\\{so 91 oX1r1l oqulpmol1l, (p) Du.alor doos 1101 Ollarllnloa propur plnuurnonl unluso II oonorolo plor, funnll10 uulow Ihu fl' .'),:.";;Irosl ilno,'hlio'IIra\hoen prop~roll, Ouolol\1ar lIorOUS 10 PIlY lor 1I11111hor ond II1l1lorlol uoslo 10 ro.aollho mohlloholl1o wllon oausaq hy Ii 'I', lliIlIto ru,sulllng or olnklllU orlslno frol11 fnllurll 10 provldo 1111 upprovod fOllndnllon, llowor Inuql ho alllhhod oul of oro1md, wlllor IInu ,; ,,':" l\1uol hn'l~ppo(l.oncj, oloolrlo IIno oonl1oolu<< 10 II1olor polo wllh I'ropor roooplllolo wllhln 20 luul of \110 oloolrlo hox Inslelo oll1omu, ,I"'I',"Unlooo oll1arwlao provldoel on 1110 1110001 tills Purolloso Or<lor, 1110 ul1l1 (Iosorlhod huruln 18 sold I,o,p, qoalur's 101, .' ",:!)'/'\I,i~~:~,~,.p'"pu.qleW~.DO,1 pormlllud 1,0 moko plllmblng or oloolrlonl oonnoot!ollQ, or oonnuQ\lngof oOllaln nallltol ooe or prop~l1o oppllol1oos Ii j)';'i;~~1,0!!li,laltt.oJd~9P!,ordlnOlloos toqulro a Iloonaoel plul11bor or u100ltlullln 10 do 00, Spuollll hUII<<lno ordlnanu080r IIIWo roqultlno plllmb, , I,"'" '. 'Ing;'oloulrluol or oonslruot!oll ul1nnuoo IIro nollha rosponelhllily 011110 duolor or mOlluloo\lIror, DUlllur Is nol rosponslblu lor uhlalnlng I:';:'~::,:; hOllllh:dro~nl1allo,l1:porl11l1s" nut lut luonl, ouunly or stlllo pOIl11l1s Il1volvlno ruslrlot!vo ~ol1lno, Ooal 01 uhonuop lIoodud for uUl11pllllnuo I,,:> ,"'l11l1al ha pumo Ily II1O.pllrohosor, ' ' , 'I "I"" lo,lIls,Undoru\oo~ 11101 Pllrollnour lenol uovorod hy InslllOnoo 1111111 oooupla<< by Inollrllnoo OOl11pnny, ond Puroll~ser lIoruoslo If." ,hold l:\ollar, harmluso, Iro{l1 any and 1111 ulalms duo lu 108s or damQUo prlol 10 ooouplanuo 01 II1SlllallUo Uovurooo Py Inauralluu QUl\1pllny. I, :1,1 ':0 I" 11, Nu\loo ul wldlh IImllallollsl TI10 plllUhllsot ooknowlodg08 hol/lO Inlorll1ud of Iho 10110111 al'd wldlll IImllollol1o, as ul 1110 dlllo of ! : !~~,:llllu Inslrumont, 1101'1., In foroo In Iho sllvotal 81alos, or Iho Ptovlooos 01 Oono<lo, liS IlIoy II10Y opply 10 Iho moyoh1ol1l 01 1I10hllohomoa : :fl' I uyor 1110 puhllo hlgl1woys, and tho loollhnl 8uoh 1110vol11onl I11l1sl, In 011 onsos, ho inndu l",elur spoola1 pOll11l1llhll\ Sol11U olatos, urlhe li::l."'"" Prnvll100s 01 OOflAqll"moy 1101 uronl 011011 pOllnlls wh% Iho 011.0 oxooodB tho alollllory l11axhl1l1tn, IInd 1I0ao horohy roloa80 IlIu Bllld !c,.}. dOlllor hurool, 1110 l11anulao\llrot and Iholr osslgno Itolll <lny nnd 011 dOl11nnda, sulls or oountor 011111118, hnsod 011 Iho 011.0 ullllo wllhln '1'\ "'I,lI1ohllal1ol11o, 1111 oxooods IlIo,lhnllaUono whloh oro now, or l11ily tolor bo, "nposod by <lny alolu or provlnoo, " , II 'J::,: 12, Tllla AQnEIl.MUNT OONTAINll THIl UNTlnE AGAUgMUNT 01' Tl1E PAnTlE a AND BUflll.AagpEa ALL flAlORANO " . ' OONTEMPOAANUOUS WAmEN AND anAl. AGnEEMENTS, UNDll.nBTANOINGB AND NIlOOTIATIONB, ALl. or WttlQll ARE 'it' ,I:", ,.iMgnOUp INTO THla AOAIlEMUNT. TIIU agl.LIl.AllAB MADE No AUpngaENTA'noNS OR WARAANTIEa NOT 13XPAllaaLY I, i'i '.JIl.:r-OAm INTHla AOAIlIlMIlNT. I,.or'i'!' -':;'''''", . ,~.." "JJ" _. . I i ~t-;:'" ,.-.1;" ~ ....- "F"'-' "', >:."tj'f~~i!,i~;-~ij~ :;: !~{li-l~~;~;;;~V:~t\~;, '~:;~:~'~'{,:.. j),;: L.I - ;,~ ';:, ;1, i",.:;j':;:;;~:,XA'I;\~:tii~~lJi;7i4;j~f;~;: ;,~L'~~;;il::;;mJ:;;;:..~:,,~:..f,t:;JE ~:; i,:~ ;;i ',,:: I" , t ' il; , . . cOUNTRY SIPJ: 'VI"'~A~~ tiOMJ:S, INC, it ,.,........."......,...,.. of,~~p~lr~~~~~~~ f~~1 Iii. (717) ?,6H.7T1 ~.iJt~~tJ(C1i~JJLM0~lkkt~Wt~m;;'Jb\\;~:.(XrU;).1l~(:;:t;:;Fa~'t\.JWJ;U)lrcttit~om:l~~i{),.;lfJ'"\~ra1/~x:t;;u\\:;;OiMf.1XJ!i!,i;!::i~;;:\l\.~t.;;;y,xj,\ ,a:.: h;;;ji:;; :,';,;', .. . ";',,' ! .:',.',' :d,'.:,;',\';iS;;,,',a;,\ i,-:,;,,;'j;;';'-;"J;. ;1 TO I c;, r>-. '( '\ L~n)(J",-~V\J::YjJ~ -e -e. -- PAT~ Jill ~/jJp--:~' ~ u-.:\- ~ 'Q.. V' )...C~tn 'e .___ NAMJ: S u...,'f\, "t. J\) 'll.\~V" \. \ ~_) ~ (J".. _ . APPn!,B8 S l~p-, ~ I'IION~ N fmj) '7 '7 (L - 3 \ 'lS Q) '9{\::}~D.s 0.\ tt:>'f" Mo..w:\.~~ CA.l'."t Bf:I~IAl N _Eo\J-'n~~-\"\ Cll'\)_~&~.~\:.\~.~\~co\l.. ~~-S-j__ MOI)f:I.N ~C::d I 'b'H.l.,\:ch ~~ Y"),O-.. =r. ~'N'\ \~'C..Q,.'f~ L~~~_ BUT PATf: . \::.'lI..~b_~~Th'Q. . . JOIl N \Jl'~_1(; ~ '.) c, D C::li Cl C:l . '~Dc..c;,- #/950,00 Fle.dr, f.. ~.::!. c,-,.,,~ \;~~~?-.... . NG'7S", DO ;L Cl...: 'I!.. u."l ~c_Jk-\~u..?- -\0 1.S.'I.\)\i,,~ Li",~,) ... -,r)..fSo I DC D- 'ou...Y'\ (J",\'"Wy\ Ve..V\-\s tL:r'~ \.:-. ~-(,~.\' .DOf'lf" - ",.DDS', DO L~"'I\t\~~yS- . .. .. . ,I,;/"?CC,DO. '~c.Cl-..I/II.=-\,\\::''''''''~. ., ,. f.tZaOIClb J-C>'I"''rI1\I--.<,) 'ff\ ""-\~.... \r,\ ~"~_{t..\.,,t>YO ~L.s:J C,}, ..... It; 661 CJ 10 ~ l::j , . ~. r....,.,~\~~r(l..y~IJ:b\<, l).,~ 0\1 Eli.1rJ:l.n~ 1'\':'''''::'- ff rf>'tC I C~" - , ,-.-.-,. <;''f'(~Y1~""'"1"o~n...\#9 I51D I GD~ . ~~~~\~\,",d.. \\\\ ~'~ffi;\'\ )\r~ C\A.~l"()"\'lY" \k~~~I' '-~Zl;,)l (.e...Vb.,\.\..9.n 6..",'d... S~~~\\'"\la ~YL(I,.\l~~3." .ll.c.W.'l.~~ ,II " -----..----..' II nil -~~ REQUESTED DY " , 'IlN"II~ll.. .' ::.-- WHITl!/Ofllco 1'110 OANAnY/ManlllaclUro,', CopV flINf(JOIl'lom~r 1'110 OOPV ':,' ". CIAIW M\.lI\l\li IIIHI IWMNN Mul\llI!, I'IIIIIIIII'IH, IN 'I'IW ('()Ulff' of CClMMoN PI"IlAR ('UMlHilU.ANP COUNTY, I'ENNSYIN I\NI/\ 1'. I NO. .1(lJJ C'i1'i1 IOIJH COUNTHY SIPI\ YII"INW IIPMlls,INC" D\.lIUl1dlll11. CI~lrl'lIl'(CA'",,: OJ! MAl LINe; C!lIlY OF 1%\I~C1I'I~J!{)I~ I~~'I'IW OJ! lillUnl\ll~NT To 'I'hu 1'1'0Ihl1l1l1ll1l')': Tho \1I1i1ul'slmwd 1I1101'11u)' Ihl' Iho 1'11111111 nil. Thlll\lh)' T. IlI1IJhll', uU1'I1 Ilus PUI'SUllllt 1111'11. H.C.I'. Nil, 2.17 Ihnll1l1 Apl'lI 0, :WOO, II copy I1l'lhu nllnuhcd Pl'lIculpu Ihl' lll1ll'Y or .IudIJnlUI11 wns III II II cd by Ill'sl olllss 1l111i1 poslllgo pl'upnld 10 IIw IhllowhllJ 1I1l01'I1UY 111' I'ouol'dl .lol1l1lhlll1ll. I(udel. Esqull'o MuNuos, Wllllllcu & NUI'Ick 100 Plnu Sll'oUI . , l',o.IlI1X 1160 1IIII'I'IshIl1'IJ.I'^ 1710H-1106 " Rospeetl\illy Submitted, IWIlINSON & OER^LDO I'.) IJY:'-~~)-L_ _ '1'1 11101 h)' T. Ell lul'. n.. lull'o ^ II 11 l'I\u)' I. D. 11, 7H4 IH 4407 Nl1l'lh FrotH Sll'col 1'.0, 13l1x 5J20 1IIII'rlshuI'g, POl1llSyll'nl1ln 1711 0-5J20 (717) m-H525 ^tlol'l1oy Ihl' Plnll1Uns ." ., \' " H ..1'. I' " Ii "1, " t ~ ~ ~ r) ( '\ ( I ~ 1~ , C'l 1\ It:. 'r" " 0 "lJ(I' " \I::, !lJ1ii ) ,'1', .... D ., ;1" I p- I{) I " ~ ~',; . e, , ~" ( il. l D r :'11 " W 1.::(' " " ~ ,--" , , 'U"" '-l ; .( r<!f 1,1 ." ~ " !, !tf , .I' " " ,.. ~ ". L-Il .< .' r,:-. " ..J,~ " " " " I" '01 " " " " II " " " " . , , iI, ',.' V\. !.lIiLPl!J./,x 1 11 111 Tl:i , I. p\ll'pl\iIHe AIJlWlllel11 2, FI.lllllllllllol1 C'oI1HII'IICllpl1 ^lJl'cPl1wl11 3, Nell' Ilnllw WIIITlIl1lylSll1'vlce Pnlley 4, C\IHlnl1lUl' l1ellwl'Y 1IIIlII'IlPllol1 FpI'I1I ~lj Mnhilul1llIHU Ih\IIHlllllplI dl'lllVll1g I1D343, (l, Il1vnlpu n'PIll ('nlllsllllll1 Col1HII'llollpl1 dilled II/~I{/l)() 7, II1"plcu Ihl' cnl1cl'ele I{, rvlel1\lll'lIllll111ll 1I'1l1l1 PllIl1l1lllllgel' 10 Scnl I'nhllllllll 1IIIIcd H/20/lJ7 I), FIIX I'l'olll PIIII1l\ 1IIIIgel' 10 Seol\ 1'0l1111111ll dlllell'J/P,/lJ7 10, Lell\\1' 11'011\ sooll pohlllllll1lO MIII1lol1 7,IIlll1101'I1HII1' dilled 10/2 \ 1\>7 II. ^greol1lUl11 10 Hllpply IId<ll\lol1l1ll1ll dlllod IO/21)11J7 12, 1,01101' lI'olll Scoll Pohll111111 10 Mllhlol1 Zlllll11ell11l1n dlllcll12/1 flJ7 ,. 13, In"plco 1'1'011\ ('oldHllll\h COI1Sll'lICliol1 dlllmll/12flJH Ihl' 1111 " 14, Lollel' li'oll1 Mllhlol1 t:IIllI1\Cl'll1l1n (0 Scolll'ol1II1111ll dlllcd 1/14/lJH 15, Lo\\el' Ii'olll Mllhlol1 7,1111 I1lUl'l11 1111 10 Scoll 1'01\11\11111 dlllud 3/30/lJH Hi, " C01\1plllll1\ IIled hy McK\1UH \\'1111 13111'CIIII ol'COI1Hlllllel' pl'olec\lol1 17, DII\ch HOIIHlng. Il1c, specll1cllllol1 sectlol1 4,2,2 , IH, I3l'ehlll . Leho Ihlll1lll1llol1 dl'lI\\'ll1g "t. " IlJ, Selup IIl1d Il1slllllllllol1 pl'ocClIUl'eH, " ;, " '. " <I IN Till' COUg'1' 01' CON~10N 1'1,8A8 CUMBERLANPCOUN'I'Y, ('ENN~Y',VANIA GAIW NCJI\ElE cHV:\ ROXANN tllcKEE, , I'la.intif:fs I' v, NO, 3633 CIVIL 1.99B COUNTRY SIDE VILLAGE HONES, INc, , CIVIL ACTION . LAW Defendant IlllnNDANT'S MO'l'IOILFOR POST-TRIA!, RIilLllilE !\ND NOW CO~IES, Defendc\l1t CO\1I1try S.ide VUlage HomEJs, Inc" by and through .its attorneys, McNees, Wallace & Nurick, and makes the follow.ing Motion for Post-Trial Relief pursuant to Pa,R,Ci:V,\" 227,1 requEJstIng the COllrt to direct the entry of jUdgment in favor of Defendant on Plaintiffs' claim " not IV it hstanding tho j Llry' s verdict', 01' in the al terh" t.i. ve, g)~ant a new tria+, In support of this Motion, Defendant avers as follolVB I 1, Plaintiffs commenced this action by Hling a Complaint against Defendant on June 29, 199B, In the Complaint, P1aintHfs sought to recover from Defendant in an "mollnt: of at least $15, BOO for the costs to repair dertain"lleged defi~iencies in the founcbt.ion of the home that l:h81' Pll1'Ch;oiSNi ft'om Defenda!:~, ~, On l\lIgust' 1, 1996, Pl"intiUs entered into a contt'act with Defendant to pll1'chase a manllfactllred hOl1\e for $61,059, (Defendant's 1'rial Exh.ibit 1), ~ 'os " , 3, On S(;}pt:e11\bol.' 19, 1996, l)l~.lnttif:f:f.1 on\:orod ,into C\ contnlct \'I1th' Dofoncll\nt. to conr"tJ:Llct: i\ 1'()\lnd,'\I:iol\ unrl"'l: tl10 CI.'l\Wl r1Pl\C13 of the home, <111<.1 to move 1\nc\ tompor1\dly hook IIp tlie plaintiffs' e;dsting'llO\I\9, fOl: the tCltal i:\mo\lpt of: $9,100, of tl1.io cll1\OUnt, $6PO rfllfltod to moy1ng anr.1 tflmporary hook \.IP of the' . e~.isti.ng homB, (Def13pClcll1t's 'l'r.ial Exhibit 2), ^ac0rding1y, tl1e total cost of the now 110ll\B and founcli\tion W<\S $59,559, 4, Plaintiffs claimed that after the toundation was constructq~, cracks l\ppenred in the concreto slab in the crawl space uncleI.' the homo, anel in the (Jement block. Walls \.tsed 1113 sk.i~ting on the outside of the crawl space, Plaintiffs sought the coat to repair these alleged construction.def.icienc.ies, 5, 'l'his \I\atter was arbHrat.ec\ at a hearing helcl on Nal'ch 1,199B, The at"bHrators awarded Plaintiffs'$1,500 on their Compl a i I'll , 6, Pla.intiffs appealed from the arbitrators' aWard, and a ') jury trial was conductecl on Februa~y 1. " 3, 2000, 7, On Febl:lwry 3 I 2000, the jury returned a'verdict in favot' of Plaintiffs and ag"inst Defenclant in tl18 amo\.lI1t of " $15,900 on PlaintHfs' complaint. 0, The Court agreed with Defendant's 'position on the pt'oper mect8ure of damages as set fOl.th by the Court in f.refJm~n v, M.1ph: Point', t~, 393 Pa, 8upel:. '127, 574 A,2d 6B'1 (1990), .. In that case, th~ Court stated, The measure of damages to~ breach of contract in construct.ion of 0\ house aontl1ining defects iaset fOl"t:h in llil!;.lbois v, 1JGb-Co. BUilders. tnlh 312 Pa,Super , 144, 152/ 450 A,2d 55,559 (1903) wherein We statsdl 2 '['he 11\0<1111\1:0 0(: dllllli'~'lJlIll1 cillIUII wllu I.'U i1 hOl1\llownol' IlIlll'! t'Ol' du!'<,,:I'.lvu ''<'11111'.1'111'1:1\.'11 JII 1.1t... dll:hJl'uncll bUl:wl1(~n 1:.110 11\.II'kul:' v.dlll.! Ill' Iilu 11<>111'" ,"' ClJllIll:I:\lc:Lwl <Ind tho 1I11\1:kut Villw'l 1:11111: I:llu hOllllU Wllllld hilvn IHld if 00l1l1l'.l:'uctm\ iI/J [H'OI1\J.IIUd, wHit ,'lIn 1'j1'<ll.iJ:.lCl/ltIolI tlll.lt if .J.t, io l.'oiHlonClbly pr'i\cl:lrJC'il I:n Cllru t:llo dufm'l'.1l In OOl1stl'uCl:ion by l'\jpilir,inHI It' 1:lIn cOIll: of roped!.'/J (loUIl not: oxceed tho c\if't:o!.'onco .In I1\l\l:kul: vlilllO, 1:.11011 tho muasure of di\mC1glHl is t:llo COllt: of rop..dl'lI, 57'1 A, 2(\ at 686, In commenting on the plaintiff 's blll:c:\nn of proof, the COLl!.'l: in l"reellillIl statedl '1'he rule set forth in llml9.la.lllLll, Licd..1.rdLJ::ullllt:rucUQn Co" Inc'd Jlll!:2ll\, requires thl1t the cOJOt of ropa.irs be clearly gisproportionate, to the probablo losf.1 in vallie before dClmages /Ire limitec[ to the'loss in value, :r!lEll"eforo, ther~ must be SOllll~ evidenmLpl.'oduced by JJlfLJ.1lill.n!:..;\ff of ,:~ reductionJn value, altholl9h it need not bel shOWn Idl:h eXactituds, There mLlst be a balancIng between' the probable diminlltiol1 .in value, which is often quite nebulous, and the cost of repairs wh.ich may be determinod with greater aCCJuri\cy, ' 57'1 A,2d at 6B7 (emphasis adqed), " 9, 1~e Court gave the jury the .instructions requested by Defendant:, which we!.'e based on the above quoted language in U!i:5lliliill , 10. At the trial of th.is matter, Plaintiffs fCliled to offer any evidence as to the reduction in value of their home caused by the alleged deficiencies in the concrete slab and cement. block wall , 11, PlaintHfs attempted to offer testimony as to the " I alleged cLim:lnution in market Vallie of the home, but the 'to~ll't properly sus~ained Defendant's objection to this tesl:imony since none of Plaintiff1s witnesses were qualified to offer an o~inion as to the redllction in market value. I;" 3 "I' 1;J, Plidl\l:U'1' i1\:\:emp\:ocl to get ill.'OIlI1d l',ho COlll.'t's ruling on IXJ!:Ulld,'lnl: 'lI ob:)lH:I: iOIl by ,wldn\J Cldl'Y ~llll(l'lu 11huthul: hu bul iuvec\ IInyono would \1111\1: \:0 buy I: 110 homu ill Hll ClIITl'lI\l: cond i tion, 'l'ho COllI:\: pOJ:I\\.lt:ljIHI C1r11'Y ~lcI(lJO to i111lJW'H' thin qlll)Ut.iOI1, l1nd Cli1l:y ~lcl(e(J \:ollt!f.,(1lC1 thilt no ono WOllld Willlt. \:0 ),\lIY tho home ill itlJ clll,'!:Ol1t condit,(ol1, 1\l1d t1I\Y IJI!yll:: 1"Olllc\ want l:ho concreto u1<:IIJ and cement block WillI nlpairod bof'ol:o pUl'uhindnv tho homel, , 13, 'I'ho only othertostimony of.r:omd on this sub:joct was the tes\: imony of ~luhlon Zimmerman, tho Do fondanc' s OWIlOI', who tesl:.if.J.ecl th<\t he had sold homolJ with thu sumo types of: cn\cks in the concrete slab uncI cement block walls as in thePla.intiff:s' home, and there was no reduction in Villl\e associatecl with these type of cracks, 1~, The Court should not huve perm.itted Pla.intif:f Gal.'Y McKee to test.ify as to whether anyone wouldwallt to buy Plaintiffs' home .in its current cond.ition since he was not qual.ified to offer this opinion, Gary McKee was not qual.ifiec\ as an individual w.ith specialized knowlodge in the sule of real estate such that he was capable of offering any opinion as (;0 what ,;j reasonable buyer would 01.' would not do, first home that Gary ~cKBe had ever purchased, 15, ITven if. it \1as proper for thl) Court to have admitted This \~as the ,,, this testimony into evidence, .it was insufficient BO. a.matter of law to ,pl'ove the alleged J:eductir::>n in mal'ket val.ue of the home,' .~ i l'l /, The general rul", of law dIscussed by the Court in Freeman cannot be so easily avoided by the Pla.intiff simply testHying that in'. " his opinion l:he Villlle of tho property h"s IJO\~n dimInIshed by 1;110 cool: to l'epail: tho pL'operty bUCElllue i\ bllYul.' \~mllcl L'uclQJJ:u thi\l; the prOpeL"I:\,' po repcdred' before pllrChafJing tho propllrty, If l:his were the law, then there woqld never bo a need to offer evidenoe as to the reduction in I1lclr!<et vC\lue of the property, 'l'he I'ennf.lyl vclnia Courts have made abLlndantly cll~ar that there InLlst be some evidence all to redllctJon in Vllltle wh.ich is .in addItion to ev.idence as to the cost to repair, and simply d.isguising the oost to repa.ir as the reduction in markel: value is insllff:.tcient to meet the Plaintiffs' bllrden of proof as to the IIlleged reduction .in vallie, 16, Plaintiffs failed to meet their burden of'pt"oof to offer evidence as to the reduct.ion in valLIe caused by the alleged construction deficiencies such that the jury could balance the probable diminut.ion in value with the cosl: of r~pa.irs, The only nun~er offered to the jLlry WaS the cost of repairs of $15,900, The jury \~as not g.iven any number for the diminution in value to LIse in balancing the cost of repairs against the diminution in vahle, 17, 'l'he cost of the home WllS $59,559, and the cost of 'the land Was $34,000, for II total property cost of $93,559, Plaintiff Gary ~lcKee testified that after tho' home was instal1.'ild, the propel.'ty was C\ppraised at $10-1,000, Plaintiff offered 110 evidence as to any subsoquent: apprili,sal thl1t the pt'operty ~Ias worth <my leos than $10'1,000 after the cracks were discovel'ed, It would have been an easy matteL' for Plaintiffs to have offered 5 .1 into eyic:lence Clflllbl3flCJUent appl:ais<l~ of. the pl:operty Clfter \:he cl.'<lcka Wfll"U dipcovol.'ed, bill: thoy t:i\ilud to clo 130, , IB, Defencj<lnl: if] nnt:.it:locl to judgment notwit:hstanding the verdict, I'laintit:fs f<lilecl to meet thetr ~urden ot: proof on C\1\111o'19"S, f.\nct <IS IJllch, the Defendant iu ent.iUed to judglnent as a 1\\C\l:ter of lL\W, and/or the evidence W<lS sqch that IN two re<ll3onable persons could have found that I'laintiff.s offered sufficient evidence from wh.ichthe jury could balance the costs of repair w.ith the alleged redqction in value of the property, As set forth previously, three reasonnble attorneys serving,C\s arbitrators hearing the lame evidence conclUded that the Pla.intiffs' df.\mages amoqnted to only $1,500, 19, In the. alternative, Defendant is entitlecl to C\ new trial for the following reasons I a, The jury's verdict is <\gainst the we.ight of the evidence since there Was no ev.iden~e of the , , reduction in vC\lue of the property with which the jury could balC\nce the costs Of repC\irl b, The jury's verd.ict shocks the sense, of. justice 'since there was no evidence from which it could h.v~ found that the cracks .in the concrete slab .1, and cement block walls resul ted in a reduction in value of the hOl\se by $15,900, ,. c', The trial court cOllllltil:ted leg;:\1 el'l.'Or in allowing I, the Plaintiff. GarY'McKee to testify that no buyer would want to buy the house in i tf.l cUrl-ent G " " IN TIII\ ['Ol IHT OF ('OM~'ION PI,I\I\S ('11M IWH 1,i\Ni) ('( HINTY, I'I~NNHY I,V 1\ NII\ (1i\1W Mol\I\H IIl1d IW>ii\NN tl'lcl\l~n, 1'IIIIntll'l's \" NO, JhD ('IVII. IlJl)H COIINTI{Y sll1H VI \.1 ,I$Hi II()MI~H, IN('" ['IVII. M'TloN -I.i\'" \1ul'cndnn\ lllil!JllinAl'f.cti.lilll:imNSlCl1Ll'.Lt\l1'L11El~',l:i.lU (lTHlNltLLllilllSl': PlnliilllT I'ollucsls tho Co 11\'1 III oxollldcd nny I11cntlonol' ovldonoe 01' Clll'l'UHpOndence Inl'olvlng Plnlnlll'l'H ngl'elJlllonllll pny Ihl' 1111 slIppllod hy II)() nol'cndnnl. The lIuh.loolol'lho pnl'llos'ngl'ounlOnllll1lhe snlu ol'lho 1111111111 i\llllnlllY 1'0hll11111l'S rille ns OSOI'IlW ngol1\IH I\llIy dlscusscd In D\JI'cl1dllnl'~ tl'lllllllnll1 L1llllno, I\S sollbl'lh 111 Dol'cndllnl's Mlllllln, i\ltonlUY 1'0hll111111'S conduolln 1I\lIll1g 10 CIII'I'Y oul his dutlus liS Ihe OHCI'IlIl' IIgcl111'1llHe sUl'lolIH quesllons liS 10 his ownlinhllllY Il1lhls III II II l'l', Dol'cl1dnl1t's Cll\I11Sel hns dlscusHcd \\'lth 1'IIIInlll'l"s cOlll1Hol hlH CllneCI'll OI'Ul' i\ltonwy 1'0hll1111n's clll1dllclln hl'ollehlng his d1l110s 1111 tho OSCI'IlW lIgent, Ul1dllnhlodly 1'$lIlizil1g lhc SCl'hlllH ISHIIOS sllI'I'nUl1dlllg i\IlOI'I1CY 1'0hhllnl1's Cll11lhlOI,I'IIIII1lllTll0W 1I110111p1H (0 oxclude nil el'ldellco liS 10 the plll'lleH' IIgl'celllellllnl'oll'lllg (ho IIddilllll1l1ll1li lI11d i\lIonwy l'ohhllnll'H !'Ule IIH CHCI'OW ngcl11011 Ihe hnHls t1l1lllhe PlIl'llcs' IIgl'cel11Cnllhllt I'lnllltifT " "oil .\. 1 I:::~ 't~4 II'PII II I PIIY Ihl' IIdlllllllllllllilllll h,\ s\lppliud hy l>orulldnlllullllHIIII!\US solll\.lllluliI dlsllllSHiOl1s, 1111111111)', IrPllIIlllllTls Illll'I-"I!I, Ihcll IIWIlIlI)' ISSllU lill' Irlnlls II'hullwI'Ih1luIldnl11 , plJl'lbl'll111d IllHlpl' lhu pnrll\.lH' IIl1o!l\.ld SOlllul1l\lIlIIl!lI'\iOI1I\.1IlI, I'I'uHII1l1llhly, lho ('11111'1 Sh\llllll dlHllllHH Iho Plnll1lll'l'H Pl1lil'o 01111111 hllHUd 011 SlIllsliwIIIlIlIl11l11l0\11l1'l111' II 'filldH 111111 PoIUIldl.1l11 Hllppllud Iho lill. Sil1l'u IIIH 1I11I1IsPlilod Ihnl PIJIUIHhliil Sllppllud Ih\J lill, lho ('0111'1 Shllllld dismiss PllIllllll'l'H 011111'0 01111111, Tlw Illlb' IHHliu Ihl' Il'lnl wlllillllllJ PolUlldnlll's Olllllllul'-cllllmlhl' Plnlnlll'l's hl'cnch nl'lhlH 11011' IhlllHI Sulllol11ulilllLllWl1lOlll 10 pny Pl.lcl1dnl1llhl' Iho Ii II. , II dllcs 1\I1111pp\.lnl' Ihlll Plnil1ll1Tlhollghl ollllho I'\lHlIll 1ll'II'IIIIllilH nskll1g Ihu C'lllii'llll dll, 11'11 hlld, Po I'e I1dnl1 I Is oUI'IIIIIl1l1l11 1III'llllld 1101i'Cllliesllho COlii'llo I1l1d Ihllllhu plll'llos ngreUl11elllll1l'oll'llllJ Ihu slIppl>' Ill'lho lill Clll1sllllilud II sUlllclllllllllI!ll'uUIl1LlIlI,lI'hlch 1I'0lild Illl'uclr,se Plnl 1111 IT 1i'0111 pllrlillil1lJ lis prosunl clnlllln!lnhlsl Pulundlll1l il'tho ('o\lrllblll1d lhnl DplUl1dnl11 pUl'lhl'\l1cd lis \Jlld nl'tho bnl'lJlIll1.. i\lIhuligh DullJl1dlll1tl\'ulild 11010bJucl il'lho COIII'I hold Ihlll 11\0 ol1ly Isslio, Ihl' Irlnlll'lls \\'hclhel' Pu/ulidlll1l pCl'lhl'll1cd lis ohllgnllollH lil1<101' Ihu pnl'llos' nlJl'Oull1Ullllhl' Ihe 1111, Du/cl1dnlllunI1I10111'l1Ihl1lll)' 1'qjll'usul1ll111ho C0111'1Ihnllho ngreul11el1t 10 slIpply lhu 1111 WI1S CI'OI' Il1lel1dud 10 bu II selllunlllnlnlJrc\1mOIlI. l{nlhul', Ii wns simply nil nlJrcunlllnllhnl Dululldnl1ll1'ollld HliPply sn1\1c Ilddlllul1nl fill 10 PIIIII1III'1; nlld PlnllltllT would pny (hI' Ihls lill, nl1d nolhll1g "llol'\!, i\ccnl'dll1l!ly, Ihe Conl'l shollld nllow nil \!l'ldcllue ns In (he pnrlles' ngruolllel1llhllll'lnlnlilT\\,ollld pny Ihr II1\! Ii II In Iw HIIJlpll\!d hy Delul1dnlll, Plnll1li1TnlHol'cqlicSls lhe COIlrt.lu pl'elllllde D%l1dlll1lli'om cnlllllg Soolll'ohh11nl1ns n will1uss, The nl1ly 1\lIsls Ihl'lhls rcqocsl is Ihu IIl1ul'Iloy cllol1l privilege, As sullbrlh III Dclul1dnl1l's Muliol1ll1 Limll1c, Altnl'llllY 1'0hll11111l \\'IlS Ihu osernll' ll!lul1llbl' hulh pllrtlcH,llIul Ihcl'U \\'ns llullllnl'l1uy cllunl prl\'llugo wllh l'uspucllO his rol,b IIH CSCI'O\\' IlgUll1. Fnrther, i\tlOl'lley , ~ ,IIII\IIIID' 1 (J, 2(JO(l, ::i~>! li,xhlhll"l:," 1\llh'Hlgh 1\llllI'IIC)' Pllhl1l1l1llUXprOHHUd 1111 \! II 11\'\) 1'1 1 III A\lllI'l1O)' 1{l\dd III11lllllho III 1 IlI'l1\lY.C I k'lIl prl\'llc!lu 111 Ihull' 1'0 11 \'lJI'SII I 1\111 i IIPPIII'CI1II)' I1l1cl' 110 1l\lli.cd Illl\lilH'IlC~' i{lIdd, 110 IIl1d 1111 ~:qHlI'Il.' l!tlllllll1llliolllllll1 \l'llh .Il1l1gu <il1ldlllll' IIIIi \Irnuo \l'hl'l'uln ho uXPl'uHsu\1 OIlIl\lUl'l1l1hlllllluHIII~'ll1g 11111'1111. I\S 1II'llHIIII, ,ll1dgu (1lIldll ISHl\cd 1111 Uqlol' I'cljl\ll'illiJ Dulolldlll1lIII IihJ Ihls NllllllllI IIlI,ll11ll1u 1!llllllllllllll1l1l111I'j'ul' llr pl'l111r 1111\1 Hllpplll'lhllllllllhol'llY 01\ 111101'111')' uliolll pl'lvllugo. II, 121S!.l.1J'il:illlli., I\S sullhl'lh IIhll\'U, Ihlll'u III'U 1\1'0 gUllul'llllll'UIIS IIpOI1 II'hluh DI11'0lldlll1l IIIIulldH III ljlleH\11l1\ ^\Iorlloy \lllhhllllll, Thu 1ll'lilllruIIIIIVllIl'us \110 slIhJc\'llll' lIw \l~\'m~\:lIlll'lJOI11Ullllllld ^\I11n1U~' l,ll~h11l1l11l 'H nllhll'O III .rUIOIIHO Iho eHel'll\l'ed '1\1I1dH III Polulldlllll. I\S Ihe CHlll'll1l' IIg'ml, AIIllrl1Cy pllh111111l\ 1~llloco\l11ll1blu lill' his lIullolls, lI11d Dlllul\dl1l\llH elltillmllll ljllostillll hi 111 liS III hlH clll\dllCI, IIIH pOHHlhle Ihllll\\Iorl1u~' Pohhnllll'H ClllWUI'I1 is Ihllllll oxpllllnlng Iho rCl\soll hu Ihllod III P!l~' i)"ful1dIl111 Ihe oHCl'l1\1'od I\IlHls deHplllJ ItH clolII' ellllllel11U1I1III IheHo Illtll1lus, he \1'111 ho rCljllll'cd III dll'lIlgo slllllc C01111ll11111c1I111l1l \l'ilh Ihc PIIIIIlII nil, 'I'olhl) oxlolll A\lnl'l1U~' \ll1hll11l1l1'S l'el\lHl\lln l'elellSU Ihe csc1'll\\'od I\lI1ds Is hl\Hod 1111 Hll1110 I11HII'IICIII111 hy Iho \l11I111111'1's, 1I11~' Hllch Cl1l11llllllllcnlll1l1 IH 110111l'11'1Iegcd, All OHCI'll\l' I\g\lnlls gOl1el'lllly cllllsldol'cd Ihe ngel1l11l'hl1lh plIl'llcnlo Ihe OScrl1\\' IIgl'CelllOllt, IIlld o\\'os I1ducllIl'Y dill Ion 10 bl1th Plll'tios, Sl.'J.l .ulUfiJ.1l1..Y, CnZOIl llUl.lu:..c!lJJUQt, 'ISO 1'11, SlIpOI', 415, 1l7(1 A,2d 242, 247 (I l)%),Il/ll1imLumhal, 54!1 Pn. (MI, 685 A,2d 54(1, Ills 1\1I'IhlH I'CIIHI111lhl\lgol1Cl'lIlly Illlnllol'l1ey 1\11'11110 ol'tilll plll'tlus CIII1Il111 bo Ihe 3 UHul'Il\\' ll!lel1l, IllJCII,IlBU 10 lip SII, \\'lIl1ld Cl'lJlllo 111'11111111'1 PI' IUlul'usl, 110\\,ul'ul', thu 111\\' illlp\\'B 1111 111101'11\')' iiiI' olio I1l'lhu plll'lluB 10 Iw 11I1 OSuI'O\\' IIgo1111Ul'01'11I11l 1,ll'lllIUIHlilllPOS: '1'11\1:;, "Iho IlIlol'Uuy 01' Iho gnllllol' 01' Ihu S.\Ih.iPl'1111111IUI' 01' Il\u UHllrO\\' IIgl'UlJI)IUI1IU1IIY 111'1 liB PSUI'O\\' IlUUIII BOIPIJg liB I1IH d1l1luH do uol iUl'olwlI IJIIllllkllll'il1lul'CHI \\'llh, Ill' II 1'1011111011 01', Ilw dUI)' 10 hisulluUll1s Pl'll1l'1plll, IIlldun.l\H\llJlu,1I1>L~1l1ll1l111llLULlIl\!.Qu\:mw JU,IlUl-tlllld>LllQllQlllhmLlIjl\llLilll.LQ.Iil!IlI~u_\'UlIlllllI," Thu 111101111011 01'11)U plll'llCH 11\ Iho 111l)U pl'duposlllH 110111 1'011 I Il!lliS 10Il'hOlhul'llILlIllll1'll~l~'jli,Jl\:1IIlU,lIliJIlLillllL\'Jdlllll PI'III his CiIPIIOII)' 1I1ll11101'l1OY lill' I1I1U ol'll\u PlIl'llcs, JJlllliUll,liUjllll1 (17(11\,2<1111247 (ellllllolls 01l1111cd)(01llph1lSIB Il<ldodl. Il1lhu IUHIlIlIlll1llllul', IIIH IIPplll'UIII 1\1I01'l1e)' Pllhhlllll1 huliuwd hu \\'IIH 1l\\lIl1lJ 1l1l1l11 Iudll'l<lUIlIIIIHI11l11IlH Ihu 1lll01'Iluy Ihr Iho 1'IIlll111i'1il IIllho IlllW 110 ncuoplcd Ihc 1I10llUY 10 ho plllood 111 hlH USUI'OIl' 11110011111, Olhul'wlsu, 1\II01'IIuy l'ohhl1l1l1 1I'01ll<lllllve hUUl1l'lollllllIg Iho IIIII' 11Y IIgl'uolnlJ 10 HUI'I'O lIutlW UHCI'OIl' IllJUlIlwllh 110 Il1lUl1llouol'cllrl'ylng 0111 his Iiducllll'Y dlllluH 10 Ihu Dulbndill1\, II)' IICCuplll1lJ 11)U pllHlllollol'llSlIl'OIl' IIgulIl, I\llol'l1cy \'lIh11l1l1l111'1IH ncl\lIowlodgll1g 1I1ll1lhe 1'010llHU 01' lhu 1\1I1<1s \\'ould 1101 hu "11111l10 dupul1dcl1lnpol1lhc CIIUIlI 'Il 1'01111011," JllllliUIl,liUllJ11. (l7ClI\,2d 111247, 11'I\lIol'l1uy \"lhllllllll sllbsuqllCI1t1y cOl1dlllol1~d Ihu relellllu of'll1u 1110IIuy IIpOlllho 1'11l11I111'lil' II1HlrllcllolIs, Ihcll he I'lollltod Iho IIIII' IIl\d 0111\ he 110Id pUl'liOlllllly IIllhlc 1\11' CDlll'Ol'ulol1ol'lhu IIHlI1U)', fkQ j~1l.hhl.Qullll1..MruiliJ1QllI1~c.&Jl.rlUlmiillhJ~ " U\lJlIlQl, H32 F,SIIPP lJ22, lJ32 (IW,I'Il, I \)lJ3)("I\11 UHOI'DII' ngul\l, Ihol\lJh he hllH 11111'1\11 , posses III Oil, JlLulliUy_uLcmlYlil'liluIUJ.'.hQJmiUJ.J!wtl11hullll)c.llUI I1IIY\1L.lJUCl'oW.9.111UlIllli, H IlIca 10 gill 1IIIe 10 Iho 1\llldH dOUH 1101 pllSS 1I111111l1ey 11I'0 dcllwl'ed,") It Is 1I111100plllud Ihlll ^"ol'l1cy 1'1lhh11l1l1l1'llIloslllY Ihlll hu pl'opel'ly ClIlTlcdollllllH dllllos IIH eHcrow IIgelllllllll did 1101 cOl1l'cl'lll1u InOIlOY, The ol1ly 11'11)' ^\lOl'l1c>' 1'0hh111111 CIII1 SUpplll'l slIch ICHlh110I1Y Is Il'hu II'IIH IIclll1g 11\ hlH Illdll'ldlllll cllpllcllY while slJl'I'll1g IIH eHCI'OW IIgel\I,lI'lId II . l10lllH Ih~ II\lorl\oy Ihr PIIIIIIIIITs, 11"\\l01'1\\>)' pohl1111111luSlllips Ihlll hu \\'IIS 1!CII11g liS Ihu 1I1101'l1ll,l' lilr Plllllllln:~ \\'hllo CIIIT,I'illg \1111 his dllllus liS u"croll' IIgOIlI, 11\\111 Iw vlollllcd Ihc 11111'11111\ sholl!!1 hc IlUldpllrsolllllly IIl1hlu Ihl'\lOIlWl'slol1 01' Ilw 1I1111l0)', I I' '\1101'110,1' jlohlllllllll\\lllllls 01l1llU.I'Ulll1l'd IlIllpUII ('olll'llhllllw I'iollllclllhl) IiiII' IIlld l!llllvorlcd Ilw 1I111IlU>', Iho11 IJcluIHllIlI1 11'111 1101 IIHI; hll11 1111>' 'Illusllo11s llh\llllll'hlllllw 1'IIIIIIIIns 1l1lghl hll\'c slllll 10 hllllllhollllhu usno\\'cd llllll\s, Ollwl'\I'lse, 1111,1' IlIlIcpl'IHlo11II1CI or nllllll'c IIIIWI, IIl1d IIIlY COIllIl11l1llcllllollllcl\l'oCIl ^111I1'))ey I'phhll1111lllHlllwl'IIIilltins, is 1101 l"l'ivllogcll, Thu sec.olll\ 1'1.'01101: 11Il11e,1 pnlc,d 1I.I,leHIIIlI1I.I1~.II1VIl,I\,es^!lpl:I,Wr 1'01.1I,I1.Hln' srol~ I !l" " "..... '" l1egollllllllg !hr 1111 oXlclldod \l'nl'l'lIlll)' lolix Ihc CI'IICKS III Ihc Ihlll\dlll I 011111\11 hlocl; 11'1111. IIH \\'ellllS ...~ '" ..', ; - '. ,. "-.,; - "I. -, . , .. , .. .' _ hlH 1'010 III dOlllil\g 11'1111 lJelUI\I\II111 Oil repllirlllg Iho e1'llCKs, 111 his 10\101' 01' Pccolllbcl' I, 11)1)7, _4....~......,_'.." ~,,; . ^\l01'll0)' pohl1l1l1l\ cxpl'oHsl>' SIIlIOH: "Fl11l1l1y, Ills 1110 Mcl<ee's 1I111lel'Sllll1l1ll\g 1111111110 II'lIlTlIl1ly fhl' Iho IInucled ;'11'1I011l1'0s II'II!he oxlelldod 'hl'lI pUl'lod 01'01\0 YCI\I' Ihl'll1lhe 111110 ol'ruplIll' IIl\d Ihll I jllrlll!.k~:QIII!I1QIILCillIl1ll',lCB111l!..ll'ilLlllllk\Uh\Ll.lQMHj~'...QUI1'QQ.Uillltl," SQy J\,x 11 I h I I "13" (olllphllSiH nddod), ^\lol'l1\1y l'ohl111111l1l'IIS IIlso cOlllIIClud by lJufulldll11ll\hIlUll11l\ld11g replIll'S 10 Il1e fhlll\dnllll11 111111 bloel; 11'1\11. Tl1el'c Iii 1111 IHsllo Il1volvillg 1IIlIl\llll'llo,l'"cllclll COll1ll11llliclllllll1ll\ ' . , Il1ese clrcllll1sll111CUH, sll1ce A II 0 I'll 0,1' 1'0hll11nl\'H Clll111\1IIIllcntllll1s II'cro II'lth Duful\dlll1t. This. , , gel\erlll sllb.lcel\\'I\H dlsclIsHcd hy Ihe COlli'! III JululIDillLl'.w!llllllliliill, 34h I'lI,SlIpor, 427,41)') ^,2d 1074 (11)85), Illlhnl CnSe,ll11l1l1ol'llC>'loSllf1cd nhlllll sclllel1101\11I0go!illllol1H bclll'eell his I'lll'lner elielllH nlld Ihe plnll\lil'ts, The I'Cl1llsylVIIIlIII Supol'lor Clllll'luphuld Iho 11'lnl eOUI'I's d~clslolllll lilloII' Ihe 1I1111l'lley Illlosllly IlhoUI his Ihl'll1el' I'llprcsel1lnllllll, Spcclliclllly, Ihu Clllll'l stilled: ^llhc sllhsoquelll hOlll'll1g, 1111101'110,1'] WIIS clIllcd liS II lI'il110HS hy IIppel1ooslo ClllI f1 rill 111111 ' explllll1lhe SllIlel1ielllH IIllldc II111pel\ cOllr( IIl1d Ihc IlI'glllhltllllls pl'llcucdll1g the Sllllle, Thul'e \\'IIS 1111lhlllg III hiH IcSlll110llY which WIIS prlvllcgcd, 0111,1' COil f1dcl1l 1111 5 II" " I ~ it "p II I l r I , r , '-. -j I'i I;;" i'- :' " " III I ~!I '<I ." t' ,. 'I< en ;;r' ,. I, " " " ,I " I;"~ ;.1 I ~ i.'! " 'I; ",II I' " ;-1,> '1; , ,I il " " )1 i', " "" " " Ot ii' , ", 'il' Ii Ii I', t'ii "i " ,. "I' Ii " "," ;L !i" " ,. l' " ,. " " , n " ;I; " ,/ tL, " " " ,-. I ExhIbit 8 , "", 'j.... ..1 L " I' ;1' t;' " " ", rlWlj11;1 ~"'~ 'Q/1 ~,;;;r.y [P( ~lfMgJ Irl'/Rlh::f~~ 7244 OOLPSMITH OONSTR\.JOTION 1666 Coldlll1l\h Ro~d ~HIPP~N~PURQ, P,o\ 17m (717) ~63,3QII llJ , QP.UNTflY ~ [QJ, 1I0~,\~~ -,.mUI~,mN ,UAY, ~^ST. , ......C1lN.mER~p,uav~,Ll n01 ,.....""'.",,... "1-' ''''f''" ".". ".......t. ~'" J~r.v~n. )? d ~9P ,". '" ...., .OQ NJJ.I; ,\19,~OO "'" ~(l"'rQ. Nn\'(y ,fl1,q I ,~,~,.. ,.".11""'" 11/1\15 ,1"t d. ,'" , ~ , Q '- .........:....-.., -,- ~" WI>>."-.,..." .._.l!!I.uy,v.t'!LH,9."y',~r..~IQ!,..f.l..U_,W~L.\~P'!~II" ~P.J\lIJ 11 ~~ J_ .'. '.., .,..,. I , "",..,. ,,,' ""--,'' .......'..-'........"..-:- .,..'-_.....,,,.'t_.__,.....'..'I"'.,._'.,....,, 1'1'" ,-. _............._... ,,' ,. 't, ..... ..."'."...........,_......._ .. I' '~pl''''_' ..,-,..,..'....'1'.'....,... .f.JJL~!1~_tP.P.l.9 !J,.......,....".. ..,,,,, ",,,,,,,,,,0_, .,." '" " .." ..,'I."..... fhq9.ll,;~l~? "t D40;~O ". '1""-' I I , .... .'.....,.......-..-.. .-'''..1.._...,...._...,..... '..., "..,-..-.-.", , ",..".., , .... ,...... -,-'.. ,.,. "... .~...... r~" , ~"'I ,. ,,'..;,..... ) ,,-.--..., ....-...,...,'"."...~, ....,.. "", ..".... ....... ,.. "-'-"'" ,'.'... .'....R.'_ _,... ".., '4" , , ,. I , I I , , I I , , , "'1'"' I " , '~"""" .."., .....-. ._,t.. ......-.....'1.............."., ,It .., ,,-..._._~,...'t" .. ......,...,_."....,....., '.,.,......., . '.'.' ....... R" ,....--.,.... _'01_.~..,..". ,..,. ,."..,.".. ,..,..,... . ,..,.., , .' . .' ..... _..,., .._.. ,.......,., '... ....,.-......"..'H."...... "'-''''''''''h......._,., .,... " , ......_'.....".._." .,.."..,-. I'...." .',.'.' ".." ",. .,."..,..,..., '. '_.....,.'...'-., ~.. ,..,-"" -....'......."...., , .. "....~. ,'. 1 " '"--'-''' .. '. ..,., ,.-. "."."" ,...,....._,..,..'.-.~..... "-""" . . " .',,,...... , .' ,.;:.........., , .."_.......-",, " ' ". '... -.....-.-...., ."..".......-.-..-..',..01...' ...' _........,.. "- "'",,,,,,, "p'"" ." , " , , " .............-.., '.... ,...,t,...,_.....__ ...,...._'.........,'...,......_.,. ...' '''. '. ~. ..;, .'.,.,.'''."....,.... .. , .' .. ~-"'''H'''''''''' ..'.... ........,....._,............, '".... .. ,. ." 1;.,,,...,,,,,,. "... ..' I ", I I I ',.It.....".,..."..., "1" ' ,'" .-._. ..... "'''-" " ..........,........ '....,....,,_ ,001--. .. "'''_ ,', ........ ..._-"" ,"........., ....'.....'."......: ''',''" """'",,'..... . ,.-,.....-.... ..., -.-..........-..... . n., '-,...-...........,...,............., t,..,..... ,....,_,'. "...,... ......., , ,..t"."... ",'.. "'-""" ...... '._".. -,....... ".".. ,.... ,-, , ..,., ,. ,I ... ...f...... . t,,_ ..... .......... .......-.... .. '.., . ..__..._..'h,..,'..'...._~ ".1 ,,-.' . ... ......, ....,-" ....-.,.-.... 'to '.......'......, ""''''''''- -"q ...--.. ". 1,',.."""'''-'''''''''''' '.....'.....,....-..........."., ...".._,_.. ..... .." H'... .,... ,., ...._,'.'", " .' .."....""..t '.""", '-''''.,' II" ., , ,...........-,,, '1'-",_,,, ....",-'. , '''.... ,,,.., OrlGlnll1 l'h~nk 'YOIJ .. i ,,, 'd~!l', I """ ' I". 0.., 0;"" (l,}) ,,' " Ii " ." " " , . " Ii " 1\, , , " " " ", " .[, " " " i; " " . , " if ,." l!! " t'" "I j' .. j"" " i' Ii " 'j, t,., ;," , . " .' I' " I! IIi " " " I' ii;'t " " ;,1' 11 Ii u ;., ;, " j;" I' If . " I, ,. , " " " " q " " I!! I,' ,.) ;, ii' 'I' ~~b '~ , " , "f ;~ . 1 "It ",'," . 'I' ,"I,', .., " . " " " " p , " ii' u " j' " " " " " " \,' " " " " , 'p " ,. I; I' I'; " " 1',; " " " " ,. d' I, ,. !i " f' " '1./' " If , , , H '" Ii jl ,. d ~ I' -I; " " .!! ,. it " it " ,; l' ,. ./' " " ,. jJ n " ,. j! , 'II ,: In' " " '_.'Ii " ',i \" " " , . - - ~ /I " I:, I . ~ ' j t:xhlblt e "..'f., I . ., if ~ ".- . j' ~ :i ',\, , , ;.1 I I I ! I .cHln!1 ~!Ll\IliQ EJ:i IJ IW I (,Il ", i" I' I, ,1\\1111111111111. Hlldlli IISljIlII'O, IWl'oh>' P~I'III)t 111111 Oil ,IIlIIIIIII'}' ,21,2000, 1I1I'1I\l1l11l1 POl'Iw\ '. Clip>' ol'llw Ihl'9uoll1g Illl\lllIlWI1IWIIH H\ll'l'\'d hy lil'sl-plllHH 1l1l1ll,IlIlHIIIIW pl'9pl1l1l, 111\1110 filllowilllJl TI111nllW'\', Hl\glul', IIsljllll'o 1~l1b11lHIIIl & Clel'lll\lo 4407 NOI'II1 1"1'0111 SII'OCI p, 0, 1l11~; ~~2() 1IIII'I'iHhlll'lJ, I'A 17110.5320 " ',< " .. " , , , L' ~ ,', ,. \,,/ " '..__/ , " "1:, II " ". " " " . " " , " ii' Ii.; j! " " " H IL " ;t I, , " .! '1,',' " " " i,I' (l^i~ Y MpI(1\1i 111111 HOXi\NN tylPl\lW, 1'111111111'1:<', IN 'Ill Ii (,'()\JWI' OF COMMON PI,I~i\H C'UMlllil~I,i\NP ('(JIJNTY,I'I\NNHI,v/\NI/\ , , v, NO, 3(,~J C'11'1I11)I)H COUNTY ~IPii \'II.I';\<IIJ IluMI\s, IN(,'" . P~I\JI,\IIII1I, I'LiIlNTIFn.;' tyI()"'ION IN LityllNH ..__.__J ~_..____~.._____l_._._.___._~___ PIIIII1III'1's, (1111'>' Illld Hn,~1I111' tyI~Kc~, h)' Ih\ill' \IIHlcl'slgllctl cn\lI1s~l, 11101'0 IhlH Cll\1l'llll plwl\ldo 1111)' 111 CI\ 110 11 Ill' o\'ldullcu WhlllsllC\'01' llf'Clll'l'USpOl1tlullco 111 S~lpplll'lllI'Holllpl11C111 dlHu\lsHlpllS Ill\d pl'ccllldo Iho \)ol'Cl\dlllllli'ol11 clIlIlllg HClll\ 1'0hll11l1l\, US'IlIll'u liS II will1ess 1111\'1111. 111 SlIppol'l ol'lhlH !Hili 1011, 1'II111\III'f\l III'UI' liS lilllnwsl I, ThiN Iii II hl'ullch or \!Ol1ll'1lcllIl'lllll1lhl' dlll11l1gcs SllSIIIII\ud h)' Iho Plulllll n:<. Ihl' Dolulldlllll's II II cgud .1\111111'010 pur fh 1'1 11 lis cllllll'lIullllll ohl1gl1ll11l1s IIlld IIllcgcd Ihlhll'e 10 pl'Opol'ly II1Hllllllhu Ihlll1dlllilil\ sllIh 1II1I1Iillllul's Ihl' Ihu 1'11111\111'1:<" Illl 11 \0, " 2, Thu Delul1dllllls hllvu Clllll1lol'-olllh11ed 1\,1' $7H4,OO 11\ dll.11Hlges Ihl' IIddlllol1l1llll1 Ihlll \VIIS dullvol'ed lolho 1'111111111'1:<" propel'l)', 3, 1'1'101' 11l11111\g.tho pl'USCl1ll1Cllol\, 1'111111111'1:<', Ihl'ollgh pl'lol' cOUI1Hol, Scol\ 1'0hll\lIl;l, IJsqHll'c, IIl\OIllPlcd III Hellle Ihe.1r dlllllngl' CIIIII11 h)' I\cgllllllllllg dll'eclI)' wllh the Delolldnl1l's I'CpI'CSCIlIIIII\'CH, Li II UARY WJI(lijl,: AND ImXANN MClq':I~, ;rl II N '1'11Io: (!Dllii'l' ()}o' I!OMMON \,I,I':AH 01" I 1!IIMIlI':I<I,ANI;J (!OIlN'I'Y I 111':NI~HYI,vANIA I 1 I (!IVJI, A<!'I'IPN I,MI I I' 1 I SllI..:!(;:!:! eTVrL, 'l'I'lIiM I'L<11nt.ll'l' v, COlJN'I'I'Y f3T1J1i: VIId,AUlil IIOMlilfJ, I "Ie, , \)ol'onclnnt: IJLR\i:1 1'100llll\iLJ !Ol'lEl1lRl'lNC m 1\1: a protrJ;,d (Jonl'OrOllCllJ ho.l d Woc.\nouc\i1Y, IJ'\l1\\C1ry l:l, 8000, bofon" tho Ilono1:a1)10 jlldWin'd In, GuIdo, ,T" preF.IE1nt 1'01: tho Pl"lnt.i.I'l' w,w 'l':lmot\w 'I', ..1-lnglo1.', EloqLl:lro, nnd prE1fJent 1'01.'. the do f'ondnnt: waF.1 .JonEll:hEIl1 II, IHldcl, nlfJCjl.\lro, '1'\1IfJ :lp 11 rJOlwtrLlot:lon \:ypo CJi'lfJe thL\l:w:lll talw approx.imaU11y ono and one hc\.11: d'1Yo 1:0 tr'y,' :lnclud:lng jLn:y ooloo\::lon, Del'olldant may have a schedul:lng pr6b1om on the I'.i.rot cleW or two oj: td.alfJ, depencUng on whether 01: not he's attnohedfrom the prevIous week :In Di.llij]h:ln CO~1ty, otherwIse, thero an) no sohecluU ng pl'oblomfJ, 1\11 mot:Lol1fJ In lJm:lne w:lth fJupport:lng .' authod.ty mL\ot be f.J.1ocl by tho close oj' bmd.nefJS on Wednesday January 26th, 2000, Any raspolwe thereto, wIth suppot,tIng C\uthol':lty, l11ufit be U10d by the oloso oj' bl\El'..i.neSfJ on PrJday, JanuC\ry 2B, 2000, '1'he De I'onclnnl: hnfJ ElUbpOElnaecl tho I'onnar "I' attol.'ney of the P1a:LntHErJ', If: he :Lntencls to call h.iJ\lafJ a wltneElfJ nt tr:\"l, he mUiJt Ulo C\ motIon :In 11.nl1ne contC\:ln1.ng h ! " i! ,'i .. ',. ',I " .' " ,. "..t, 'Ii .. " " " h ,. H l'i i' " (' ,I', " " " " " i! 'I'; Q fill 0 [" t.,l '11 ::Pl'lj r,~. ;'il ,I._ "'I 1J..11/} t'/J li/C ~;r" 0'" 'td, "l'" 6~tl~; (4'Y 'I" p f.~I) r:1t 'rhr1' /:('J' ..tr \}r'J ('f' to.. 'i",\l'fl ,. .f.-. J,. t..., ".. 1\ 1::J ;/' ", ti'" i:j ~J I .,~ ,C:-J -', "";' ;, Ii " 11, "i., .. " ",,'1 ,,: ;'). ,1 ,. ',. ,. j; ", " ., ,I. .. I' i/ " :!, :It in tho IljqIHtlJ:fll' lHH'di.lll t.n'pl'od\lt:'u lItlll\u t.!v.idPIl(!ll oJ: L,hu !'I!lhl,,\.'i\ll\ .Ill Vd]l\ll l'i\\IIII"\' hy tho n.\luql"l \.!UI\f1I.I'I!\)tiulI dl,ll'.lC'.ipl\u,iUl.1 110 tll",\: YOII Orll\ bn.\i\I\L!ll' L\Hl prohi.\blu dllldnli\',.lolI :In Vid\IO with 1'.110 Clout 01' l'(JIHI.tl.'U, i2U~l lQ:J~!.tllll'llLy'.,.-IYl(lll.l.!Ll~i~l\;",_l.UQ.", 39:1 l'l\ I ~llipJ'l' \ '\;'.'/, 1;'/11 (1" ~'.cl GBII, (ill'! (\ 990) , ( \ R08poo~l'ully Bubmlt:tBcll MClNlms, \~^,,],ACI~ [, NlllU CI\ . . /,' ') / ( ,~ 13Y:~~~T<;C:;1'ii~:~.~i/ii;lii"JSc~~.Ic:-~--- · ^tto1.'ntlY I,I),No, \j6IJOO 100 Pino Stl.'Ollt ' ,,/' PI 0, Box 11.66 IlaJ:l:iI3buJ:'g, l'A'I'110B-1166 (717) 237.'1140!; (71:,'1) ;'.3 'I,. [i3 00 em: H , ' " "" Datmll Jal1l1C\l:Y 31, 2000 , " ,. ., ,. " ,. " ", ,. " .,!' " " "\ , 2 \ l/1ili ") 'II {'~~.1"'11I)i (.I[ ... U Ai) I'" J .. i',\dlv'~J ~j({;,'. ).~ ' / ,,' ) 1/..1,,1/('1"\ i ) ) (' ) , Ix,., CJP\lI1cy, !'n\1\1!ly1Vl\\1.t.11 ---, "/"/',/' I ' )(, .,).'.J 1." r'/~'1 . Ir\ Th!! CP4L'I: of OP\lIITlP\1 ~hu of CllII111!!~111l111 ..c/"V ~Ip ,.LLL." v /' / I ,", I /(I(J;W//(i ."'//)1"', II./u '/~ I)"f~ . (7 IVI,"'~?)I,?'I'/ ~ I)I\TII \~l\ clo sol!!mnly SWBar (Or affirm> uh!l CP\1!ll:iU4aion Of th!! Unicl\d StacnQ wealah And UhAt VII will diaQha~Bl\ tl1!! thllt WIl wJ,:j.l SIWP11rt, OIHlV 1I\1t! <Infent! lII\e\ th!l C,Jr\Q Cit4U~P\1 or this OOmmO\1- dllCiuQ of 1ltlr orfj,qfl, wiC)I,f;l.,dBlity,' -" . . .- ,) ...":-,,,.,- -~". {-,; ";.'-' \: t,- t' \. .' (, CI)41ir;nl\\1 , ("I:"'~':".,' " ;' (, (' /.,' r<~.~~<,. ('-:(:,.:~) a.Q ,>(~)-.-:~',c!(t .--'" ~1'iAIW (ot' Wll, thll u\1t!l\rd!l\1Bt! arpitrator,s, haVin!! bBl\\1 d41y appoinced ancl awot'\1 I\f~i.-met!), maltl\ the fol.1.oWil18 1I\.,E\rcll (Note I If clA1nallas fOr <Iall\Y Ilra l\wnrqlld, thl\Y shllll ba Sl\pllt'ntaly stated.) ,'p .~;,." /;;/'/J/('t.) 'i""j).:;,":,A"' ,',0 '~~:'/[~""LI -1l1V() Ie' 1ft;" 1'78'Y.';)f~ "e /1., "'. /..!tl, /7// ..6 / . , , Yd, l-~ .,j ') . ./ r~ .- (%~ ~I'I'~' r;""'~)'1 (,- / ... .J,.) , ... (';~'I,IJ):)I.J'.rI",fI--'~ /..,,~.. ~"/ (,,'-'., .J..:,.I(.,/(..~ ~1-~ , ,~, (';.(11.),,')"1'.....'..1 ,,,'L'I,. 0'1 ',J'r:~;~ ~O;'C/,,)J (J.I~-::; "1,;1/ .' .. tJ ~"\-;t J'( ','.;,', (','I/. (","-{ (I (is';:.r;: /7'..'> ,ap'pl.iiiiiblB. ) Date of nenrinlll:YI~;...~;;.... Datl\ of Award I 1":'11/ /"r" · Arbitretot', dissllnts, (Inset't nama if /./.,...:k . ,..) ___,_. ,/ ('",.<(">, ,'-" -:./~'l' ,,,,.---- --'~':,:':". /~,/,-_.. ;,:J ('1(/1/ " ,,-' -1"/ Chni1;11\un - {' ..." " J, "" -~, .r'"."; ,", I -..... · ~. "'Z"Y'T-:17; , (~~llQ/(:,,-l!l! ,:t.,~, ':'1 .,~ 1/ NOTICE OF IruTR'l OF AIWUJ NIl1o/I the /1, '. day of 11/ /,..1.:. awnrd waa antevad upon thadoqkat parties or their attotnaya. , 19'/'1' j I1t i:l2:f; .,C,lI" tha <\bove and no tiaa thareoe givan by mail to the Arb.itrators' compensation paid upon appeall $ ';.'II:>,U'-' ') If) J~ _ .1; "07 ,.,j''': Pt!otl'1'onotary (,, 'J ' ,(, {lll.li'/f," to ba ('J 11.1-, .)' {.- ) By I .i....- )/, '/ r ,. , . Deputy I) ,)[1 '- t. .\ (" ~ t' ('l( Ih\l\ St" ,( (',1. "'I' " H ''1 4;;01'/;;- ;;! . (,'J/tl, fl. (,' (.i, ))1(.(-1.4 fl.~ ,. 1fJ' (I,., , I'~ t_'-' t , ( .') \. \ 0 _ II t,'''''' ,<). .' 1 r ' '71.(.0:(.((1:, dl"'fl.,..i.,.1. " 1" \.., i! j,. .' tic d2~. ,.. d ,./ II' d' " ,-" ;' ",t Ii !i " ., " " " " " I, .. " ". .. (,r) \n (" t" 1.1:) ',11 . ~) ~l"iii "-f. " -... "'I Up! -", ~ i~lnl ~'l' ,J, ;,U ,. ~ ,. C -. 'Ill) C9 ,~' 11\ 'of .. (;::{,:i \S '.~.-:: , 'J "r> ,J,n ~:r:: i';,?t~ !?:~~;\ i~l 'I-rn <'" !;;:] :) I'.,) l' " ,"., !..J :~ '" , " " ;'" 1\, Ii " " I' " 1 !' Ii 'p .. I' " :u, 1'11t:lIgrl1ph :n 11> IIQ11\1. \:\:or~ I 3;1, ' ['1I1:lIgt:l\ph 32 ,It] t:\\'ln1orl, [1 \:d a \: prop! \:harl3o! i!il Q011\lIncloQ, 33, PArllgrl~ph 33 ,It] rl13n,\.ocl, [1\:1710\: p,:oof. tharaof. 113 qamllml13rl, :14, Pl1rll(JI:l\ph 31\ 1.1l clan1on, [1\:1:101: proo! tharaof. 11'1 clamAnQaq, 3li, P/WAgt:Aph 3li 11> rlan ,I. ecl , f;1\:r.,j.a\: PI:oof. \:harpof 113 clal\1AnQaq, 36, PArtl']rl\ph 36 113 AQI\11 I: l;aQ 1n pl\r\: I\ncl rloniaq .In PAl:":' It 1.!3 /Ic1mHl:ad \:ho ornolHI 1n \:1)13 mor.\:ar jo.lntl> werl'l l:apA 11:aq , I\: Ja clanl,ed tho' oraol~!3 :r.etUI:nact IHI a l:e13l\ l.\: of \:ha II 11 a']ocl l:aU,\lre to 1na\:nU ']11\:1:13171'1 I~nc:l clownflpPlr\:!3 , fl\:t:10\: pl:oof \:I1l'lI:aof 11'1 daml\nctacl, 37, Pa:r.A']rApl) 37 113 dan1act, It i13 ctan.led tha pafandant offared to repl11r the o:r.aaka, ~o the oonl:rAr.y tl)e pefenclant or.lginA11y offereq to flupply the P11\1ntiffa withtl)e mpter..lala to repl1.1r the ar.llpl~13 , 30, PArAgrAph 30 il3 Actm1tl:ect in pllrl: And qen1ad'ln pArt, plAintiffa Ag~ead to PAY f.or Aqct.it1pnal fill, ~he Pefandl1nt!3 agraad ., toinal:a11 and grade the f11l, It is admitted thllt '701\,00 WI1!3 p1aoad in'tha a!30row AOoollnt of Robinson & Gar.Aldo, 3!l, PAragrllph 3!l '1.13 /.\dmHted In part and qeniat;\, in part., '1'he Defendant qiq not. deliver. the. top po.i1 quality f.lll that. had been agreed upori, ~he f.l1l I:hat was d~livered aontained a l/.\rge proportion of rook13, ~he l'la.intiffs hAve ref.uaed to re1eAae I:he aum of. '701\,00 beaAuae t.he DafendAnl: did not deliver ~he qUAlit.y of f.l1l t.hAt. hAd bean agreed upon by the partiea, 40, ParagrAph 1\0 is Adm.itted, 41, PArAgraph 41 ia denied,St.riat proof thereof ia demanded. ',' WIINmWol\l~, Pl A 1n\:1 f fn ClAl~Y Mp'~IHl /1111) 1\0l\l1lH1 Mnl~oa l,'llfll~opl: f:\\l.ly raqllonl: I;111n 1I01101;/l\11p 00111;\: \:0 on\:OI; j\\II(]lllan\: In .\\:n fAvor And A(]111ml\: Ppl'pnll/\I\\:fj COIll11:1;y fHclll Vl11IH\ll l1omao, Inn, Ranpoctflllly f1\\\1mlttad, ROIHNaON N (J!~RI\!,I)Q n~ )r;~" 11'li\10\:hy '1', l~n( 'ler I IE C]\\ ro RODINaON N G.ll\l~O AttornaY I,P, ,7044D 4407 North Pr.ont atraot PIO, 001\ 5320 IInrr.J.a\1urlJl PA 1'1110 (71'/) 232,-0!l25 Attornay for Pl/lJntifffj I. , .. I' " ,i', ;, t. " { 1/, , : I '1/ ;".' ; ; , '~ i .' I !/IC ,;ipJ' ,;, "', , '. , '", ,.,..1' ,I !, '"..\', ://~.,,;,i,'.'" . ' ',1\ :~.' " , "\.' .. "" ., " " ',' , "\!: ~i'i ': '1>"lfl,"i :'!"/"" 1'".(,' i J ,/fl " .. '"" " "'" ., '. I' '1(,' ,Ii,,;,;.>' , ,t" ", L' ,.;,1' " j'tl' . " w: " \, .' , , , II ~ ' " , , ~ 't(. "i;, ,,' ':'11 III ,ill: ",' ., ,Ill', 'J',"\: ,tl",','; "01 ",'t /", ", I' " "I: {I" 'i/' .,'.:: , ,; ; ~ r \ \ : ,," ,,,',, .1" "./ " I'lf \. I! I, ~ , 'ill '" / /' '1' i!I,'" ),,' ,t'\" t1 ,d" 'I (:l;', ':', ,;1,' ','t!'" .,:..', ',':::", ,:t.J '.il. I;":" " '."1 ~ J i" ,', <;:/';': "'.'1' , 'I 'f 'I' ..,.; 'I': :fJ. .,.: ij~FI' ." , ll' :. ~'.\ :{" ,,'(l~;<,: ~', 'I, ',~,;! , I" J 1/' \ '1 'j 'j;J. ' ,'It ,\'J<\\, t;' I"~ , , ",i 'p:" "I::;;' ':' ,,; ." ", 1:;",' ,. ;'.,:,,: " , .if , "/1." 1; ',' \ ',.' .. I , :(:.J 'I ~ ' ',' . ',:;,:.. , ",. ~)(>:'I ""1.,;1,, ";'-,';'.':" ,!,~, >,,-~',,',:'i) ." "I , I 1', " , " \"".' , " , ;"',',t,; "', ',:/:':,X 'j' J:',~ , ." i.H ./I;J ). :< ..":. " "~~;~: ,1,'\ 'i ., '/:;,'1, :1' il\ ';,,' " .." ,. ,'", I ,i' I' ,,' 'j,'" ,,':. "'I', i , I.' ," , 'II" ",',',' II ':11-' . ',I,' ./. " " . ~ , ,i " I';, ,.' l! "..., ,II"".,;I! " i 'I, ',' j I: ,;, '~', ,'; " I;" '''11'' , ;'1\':". " . \ ~ I I '1,;1,: to' ; I~ -\"1 '1";' ',1/1. " , " " ,,' ,,- ',1!, ,; d.: '1\:' ",Ii ,;;,).' , t,: 'I. , , " " ; .'(,', ," , .', ",',!" j:! ~, ".' . ,~ " 6, Pn 01~ Allonl: ^ng\Hl\: Iii, 10!l6, Plll1n\:,trf.s pn\:Ql~llel 1nl:p A writton DontrAnt w1th POfondAntr rtopnr1hnrt np A rropo~Af for DrAwl I'lpAco f:ollnrtll\:.t.lln n\:JLII:Y hoole nps/ nl\e.l l:emp01~nry Iwok lip \:0 Il~Jfll:.\:nq homll, A trllo nnd Dbrrect copy of wl1ich ip AttAched horoto/ mnqe A 111.\1:\: heroor / 11nd mArlwel /HI (~~hi\lJ\: 'q~lI, 7, The Plnintiffl'l hAve fnlf11led'AII tile ~roviaionp of tho Agreemenl: on I:helr pllpl: tQ IHlperf01:murl, 0, The PlA1ntiffa hllve pAlq tho POfondAnt '51/050,00 Anq' '!l,lOO\On Aacording to tho contrActs, 0, The contrAct GAllp for the performAnae of certain work Anel tho furniahlng of aert:Aln InAt:erJ.Alp Py DefenctAnt ap t:heroln 13\:Ateq, 10, The DefenctAnt hAP fAJleq ta prQperly aomplete .the provislQnp Qf the Agreelnont Qn Itl3 pArt to be perf.ormed, 1l, PofenelAnt hAa wholly neglected to do And porfQrm aertAin thingS whiah were expressly or Py neaessAry impl.iaAt.ion reqll.ired to be done And perfQrmect by tile Agreement/ AI3 fQlloW131 (11) instAll tho , ' aonareto PlAP At or below At .lnduala;y aaaoptecl c1epthl (b)' .lnstAll" fQoters sufflaiont tQ sUPPQrt tho hQmel (a) fAiled to A1lQW the dement tQ auro beforo plnoing the hQme Qn the SIAbl And (d) failed tQ grnde the exaavated materiAl properly Arouncl the home, 12. Defendant hns performed .In n poor/ improper, And "nworkmanlike mAnner certAln other things whIch were expressly or by " neaessary .lmpliaAtion requ.lred by the Agreement to be done and performed in A proper And workmAnlike mAnner/ AS folloWSI (A) the , " hama wn~ not looAta~ naxt to tl1a aX~st.in9 ~ookl (~) tho fivoOallr"O~ Of night inoh ~look a\lrra\ln~inq tha home hAve orAoke~1 (0) the camont .. slA~ \lpon whioh the hO\l"o "it~ is arAPk~n9 An~ shtftin91 And (~) the hO\lse floor is not leVal, l~, ~he DefendAnt trie~ to repAir the crAoks an or a~o\lt Novem~er 25, 1997, bllt I:he orllOllS re\:urneq wi I:hin I:en ~AY~, ,. 14, ~he Defendant has At the Plaintiffs expnnap proviqe~ more fill ArQ\ln~ the home An~ grad~~ the fill Aro"n~ the llama, 15, ~~e DefendAnt hue fa(le~ an~ ref"se~, un~ etill ref"se~, to Ollre the remaining Aforeaai~ ~raAohea, ~espite PIAlntiff'~ ~emund thul: the o:J.'AoJIS un~ the OAllae of I:he aruolling pe repulre~, '1~, The reAsOnA~le oost of reme~Ylng the aforeaAld breaohea ie in axooas of ~16,000,00, 17, Pefendant hAS ~reuohed his oontraot with Plaintiff, and Plaintiff hus ~een damaged by bafen~unt's ~reach .in an amollnt of at least ~16,000,OO, WHffiRm'ORm, Plu~ntiffs Gury and Roxann McKee dema~~ jUdgment againet Defendant, Country Side Village Homes, Ino" for aotual damages in an amount of at leus\; $15,000,00, pI US OQats, of suit, Respeotfull 13 c (, TImothY T, mn er, ROBINSON ,. oml 1\l.Po 1\ttorney I,P, 704 0 1\ 1\ 07 N. l~ront treet p,o, 130K 11320 Harrisburg6 P1\ 17110 (717) 232~ 11211 1\ttorney for the Plaintiffs ~,,:,"o;-.t...~...,....-.., p..~,,,_...,., . COUNTRY SIDE VlhJ..AQf.HOMf.e, INO, pUROHAa~AOA~~M~NT . , .-.t,.. -- ~-_._-. ......, I " tf I q) ...Q;1 ie;',', 'l" "'::"L~L.,.,.-.___ SI!~I1~(l,l!,P:S A~\r.S" ~'A lo'HIC lit: SP\P 'll. f1'1IE:':-'(...1'-..gl-' ~ f\t,~f'L.J):)sJ~jUL,., 'u_~__ ,. 'APpnl\I\!I_eL\__nl\r,l..~ JU J../V..Hl, ,___, ' _.._Nt:: v.\i1!d:.!b-rlf.1j,J--\~7~t-' . .. ..' . t~l\ ,!l,.,,.... S.lfjlQ IIO~U I: -,~7g...k-!-"J_lll ....,\'10111\ IM,.f~,-.~+ ~ ~\P n~T,lIl' AlllJllliUUi _Jil..l...ffi l.A. T /...1:. Ii.!. )...1~1'.4t;_, , ta V\~/.tr ft : . . SliMS! ro !II~ !~IIMfl MID COIIIllTl<llII lTATEOOII DOTlI liliES OF 11118 ^,lIl~~UiNT SHl~IIAI1nfiU 10 Sill ,1/11) Tlli I'III1CI\lSill AOlliS' 10 [\JIICI S~ TIm rOlioWINlI Oii'lIlIOiIlI'1I0I'iIlIV. M-'!NUI'APTUnpn MOPPl,NAMli Mopa~7~ - P.Il00Ms AI'I' o~, aToOll/lIJMnnn--- '. ..p, ,I 01 0 '3 ..I. nuRlAl, NilMlllill . f'llPf'DSI!O "(\)c:t'l:lll' to.' lJUSlllJ 1'S1C'1&-5 llil,IVUIlVPA1U oI'TloNAI. UQIII'MliNT, lAUOf1,\NO Aoonssollms OH'r'f!H .9 r.AfJ(.IA!lp F,IAT/ . l:1JN~ ',' pAau I1ITlOU . ,!T'Il~1 ..... 'T , .a l'AOTOf1V ol'TloNa OI'T1oNAl,IlQUlf'MIINT SUP'TOTA~ ----" f..!Ul_ ,.., 'fLJ.,.-, 0 1/ - I ~ aA~aa TAX TIlIU , NaTAIlV INUUf\ANQU 00, ii'AiiiiPf1IOU ,.yr - i-l , ' Man, ,. lEt: t' ~ It.. /l T" . , . , r , I. Uti lOllol. CnU14'. "iii . , ,ntH' .... ~UI"'~."v.lfClo'OMlmLI'~O' . , , 'I ", 1 ' '..:S"o (')~'J - , ,,' , , . 801l0r MQ Purohllsor nuroodhlll nol wllhalonQlna IIny.ol/lor . provisions 01 Ihlsoonltllo\':\tlOl upon olloonllnaonolos 1f1:,lhls oonlrool hovlna hoon' mol;, If pUl1lhosor shoultl loll or rofusD'lo purohaso Iho lnonufPlltllrOQ, homa Qoaorlll,oQ,ll0roln wllhln Ihllly , QOYs ol\or nolloo ol'ov,ollop,llIly 01 Iho allmG Iroln Sailor, Ihol Sollor may rololn Iho onllro ollsh downpoymanl ondlor not omount ~.oW~d for IroQo os, ~lqllIQo~oQ domoaos, " )t-:.{;;1,71( . Inl1l01s . L.f=.1l\ IT IS MUTUM.LY UNDERsToOD THAT THIS AGREEMENT IS SUIl. JUOT TO NEoESSARV CORRlJOTIONs, ,~ND ADJUSTMIJNTs CON, CERNING CIIANGaS IN NET PAVorr ON TRADE'IN TO SE MADa AT THE TIMIJ or Ban~IJMuNT, S, S, _/7i{ I S'ti( I {J16 f Nomo s, 0, _1111 I r a'\ I., ~.ll 'S 'Nomo_ i.',' '!Il' . it --,. - ", , ,j. I I . ", ' 111 7" 'J '\jtlll '{J'e.'jll't 0'1,) Ca 't I ;".; CI " t ;"\'\~i\:!'~~~:i'r.!r;\'~~~t: '{.t,~~~" ',' " ~: ""4:)"':".i~ atl.' ~ '" ..:.~ ',:, t .' - 'I .,.,holt''' :~~,l';l;' 'I" , ~. '..t " . j.;o:~ -::t:-.c" ,-1~'\C4it1 ~.,j 'I,:::: :' o~~,~~~~I~~li.~T Uf'O~'MANA[l~nlt\l. "NO ~INANOW.AI'f'I\OVt\l. ~~,~ '~,\ ,,~',~~I,^:~~~~r!~~!~.P~TIONA~U~UII'MUNr' " I () O~ ~., ""Au.'WtlUn~( Tllldll',',\NO ,\)a.ua TO nUMAIN TIIU PnOl'unTY Of' OOUNTRV Slllll, '" I,:,' , ,OU~al\Jlll\l0ll,TO,t40vn Ij()MU~tJOlINTf1V. alPl1 WI~~ SUI'f'l.Y AlIovn ImMal :i' Pl1al1nlr;rION.gf'TI~'!N",~:'): ,,' VBAI\ , ~'h'" J .fl' I \".\: ;II{' j ,.' l~'\.l(':' "1' ", ~f' 'M1<ll ,"",.,." ';'~' ~L"I IlllP/1OOM8"" olm :' \ ~ ':" INtll? ,.\11 .tlf~ ~Ut.j.... . "I~ ,t.~':"\~ t"l, I \:,l,,,,~,.,,. ,r.'lr.,\i/ll" , 'X I,' r~~'~:JJ!I,' \liJ,'::.:.\.\:8f:4lfl~m:,', '" OOLO" It,,;l 'I, t,I"'~t' I~ "I\I'Fkl.'~' I . ~','. AMoUI/JO\\lI/<l TDWlIO"I J "l"" '... . ",I t~" ~..., ...'.'., '."', ;t,~~'f.~I1:II~"'1, t'_", ~l~ 't,."h,..., I,'" .. ''', -'It l.\.-\,;"~,I'\':''''II' .. '! ' l':, ~~~:~~:~:D~,~~,~~:~~t~~~.,~;...:, ~,~~. ,q:OusT~Mun" . !t, . ;i,I:..~.1. i,.1l .'......" I\I';'I\'~~ t~\'j"', \ ,I; "," ,,"', ' . !' '\"..1'" """'}"'/ "01 ' 0 ' I', "'" '.,.... " .,' "./. "HoI~ MIl an 1~~~I1" ~g ~'fY' I " '10,'" f"j. \..:/.... ".' n....,. no ~".""". _ h-!OIJ romolIl,lov,'w'lIR rl-~ ~"" lilY '101ol< ~.IIlf1."'1ofblMl~.000Cft'" " ,I 1!IiW1UOIlLCI~". Ih. 1MJtwuln1Il1i.l1IL111t.1wlILhlLaQLhaUIlIltUJW1.ll1U ~ILtlllLlll111,.aJhoJjllhJlW'ILPllltlll.JhgujJl' 1I1111llJ1U11I"" IIIIVOfi'" of ~oIl/lOl\IlICI. Of 0,,"1, Of tlIlv. 'IIInlopalti 'mll1O~ ,1Il1Kt, \1101 1110 wtIljn ~"'l m.o:I......., 11\1 llflllontl ''''\1I{l1I~ oi1d ~"' ..,101 lI11onl/lll, moUIMC4!, IlnclulIod, IlUe" YoIutlllliy 1><lIU\uod, III fl!1lptlIV I1IInl1UI<lIKt 10 IIN 'rom .n.IICII\1,'I! . I'/IlIllOOVor, '~CIJlI" ... ",lid abova, j'u/tll.", 19r... ..cll\1lrlllllJi>i "'d 1"ov!tIon ollhlo OOf.,.tl9n' 1I001IIrotll/1l1 bock 10 Ml'Ifthl'i'II Opt pOf1lonlll,"of 1t,1\Tj~ 1II1III111Ir'.,o fl<H'lon'''lllll'{lrltllleol, IImUlIn M'lo,,", 1/lll.f1BCt, ,::0,.," '.' .. IlUVllfl OANNOT'OOOUPVIIOMIlUrml. A~I;MOIlIlV8 Mil ,AIlUlABEO TO ClJUNTT!y B!Dq Vl~LAllIlIfOMIlB,INO, \ ':,', I, OR WIJ; IIUAIlIlV AOK OW~EOt1e necalPT or A copy op THIS 0f10e~1 . ' ( ,) ':' ~ ' " "', ~IGNIlD)f "~1 " , . BIG'NaD~"\ ~PPITlPtM" T~I1Mfl ANP qONPlfloNa . IIlq furll14r unrlm41umj "1"1 i!QrUOll; ".. , TI14 oHlar on 1110 raVar~u ~hlll hariwf ia alllllocl 10 Iho/allaWlnQIUrll1a anrl comllllono, ,,11 of Whloh hqva poon 1l1\llllOlly ilQruorj lip om 1 '1Q..lhlLQ.v.Q.nWhll-lnm'Il~lhHUlllonQ.llIajQ..lI\\l-llulIlf.lLO\lLlLllJI'IUlllll'IlQJlnn.-1hll-ll"l1lhllllll'-hll<<lll\-l.lliln~i.4wIlQ 1111\fl-llWlllLlllltlV.Rl'lLllW IIl.\Q1I11l1'+-m\l1llIQ.llllrn\l-lll'-~hl\llQ.Qulllfll~.-Q.nlWfWlml~alioQ-Wllh_lh\l-lol'm'_1I11~l/llhlnL\l41~ mOnl. -lnlllQ..lIlllt/..l1ri_. '.liliJ~. \l-llWhlu.qJor+-ViIlI-i1!Ullll'-1lll(U1Jn\l-ll.lllIAllJn'llIl'rnon.I-Rllnlf.ll~h_Jlllll". 11I~1l. P\llOmllllWlI~~1;!t.lhAI J1ilm-llLRll~lI\Q.nLalLIIl1lv"4lL\llq" IfJlll-llV-IlIw..tIlllL\IL'Q.hLllquhul\Q.II\.JIl!d~IQ.lIIl1hl- II-lluulsllll!!+-ll.nlll-lhILllPl'llJI . 1'~U1l Ill'. Il ll-\.hllf.\l1llf.l~WJ. n-t"IWui.ht-1lf-lLllmll/Ul~. 11ll1l\-Rll1l. 1.1'.IlIlUIIIL~1I1111-IIlIllll.UI\lU.."nl/,luul. DI1.lAQ-It. Y-l4utnkjll'-llllno~ lIy.WhlU'lllllllll\-lllll41lllJ.Q.'-I\l.I111IQ.hIl1llf-lIV,lIl\-1h\lUPI\-IIIlI11nWIlIIV-\ll\'-flllIV-4lL111l1~Il11\'1I,t.AIIUl1IIlIO, ' ~,Tho PUlnl1uoor uQHioa 10 elollvur Iho orlQII'ullllll of ~(110 01 Iho 1111010 any Iloor 001, Illollllohomo, Irollor or vohlolo Iruclucl In.M 1l0~lol paymonl nlol10 wllh Ihll rlollvory of 11111 oolel praporly 10 cluolor'o prumluoa, uncI cloo~ wurrul1llhul a\loh our, mopllohamo, Irullol or volllolo 10 110 1110 PloPO~y, froo ancl aloM 01 allllono ancl OnallmllrllnOO~ o~aOPI na Olh"lw/oo nOloe1 an Iho fooo pI 11110 Il1alllnnonl, Pilrahooor worrol1lo Ihol 011 ilia lo~oo 01 overy Illnellovlocl ooolnollho 1I00el vohlolo or mollllohol11o Irncloe! 111 hoVo Ilonn flllly pold, Elllaulcl nnr oaVornmonl noonoy 101'\' or alolm u In~ lion or clomancl an or nooln~1 alloh uaoel Vohlalo, Sellor moY, 01 IIle opl/an poy 1110 oomo, om Pllralluaor oOrooa 10 rohnllllrao Iho umalln! Iho(oollmmocllololY IIpon rlomoncl, or, Sailor moy, 011110 opl/on allel 0\1011 d, ., ~mo\mlla 111.0 011101 aon.lmol oovorlno Iho mohllol1omo arrloroel horoll1 1'111111110 001110 011001 oa 1110\1011 orlolnally Inollle/ocl \lloroln, ' " .. lI, f 1110 1I00d proporlY Iruclod 111 10 roolalolocl or 1I00naorlll1 ony plooo olhor Ihon Iha 01010 In whloh Ihla orclor 10 wrlllon, Pllrahooor . '" 1I0raOO to Immocllololy aaallro roulalm\lel(1 far O\lah vohlolo onello pay OilY onel 011 oxpol1aoo oncl roolollol/on fooa Inolelonlallhoroto, ., 'SlIaul~ Sollor oUGllmo, or po pili 10, MY OXflol100 In oOl1nool/on willi _\Ioh roololr~l/on"Purohllaur 1'111I poy Sollorlho omollnt Il1arool an "., clomone! or 1I01l0r moy oeld, at hie opl/on, 1110 allmo 10 1110 aonellllonol ooloa aanlroot oavorlnQ Iho n,"pllol1Omo Olcloroe! 110roln 1'11111 ,Iho ,:, \. como 011001 00 1110111111 orlolnolly Inahlclocl thoroln, ' .. ':'}1"~ t, , ::4, II tho.. \Ioocl Irllllor or mOPllohamo la nol elollvorocl 10 Iho cloulor ollho I/mo 01 orlolnol nPl1m.lolIl, onelII lolor, 011110 clOIIVory11t 1:....,..;lIppOoro 10 1110 elonlor IlIoro huvo poon molor/ol ahonooQ mmlo In Iho IlIrn/allll1oo or ooaao~orloo Ihoroal, O( In Ita o0l1orll1 ooMlllan, 110 ,,:' . Snlllor. 011,,11 ,I,/\al1. IJI\V~tll~. rl(1hllo mako II roopprnlalll, Thla lolor opprnlaol Voluo 1'111I11100 clolorrnlno Iho ollowllnoo 10 po moele lor alloll I.~ ~'I~ traller,lfTI9PllallPl,lJo, or nthor Val1lolo, , , . , , I ' In: 'loa.. TIle:rriril'iuf~oMor 11110 Iho "0111 10 mako uny ohonooo In Iho mOclol, ar Iho cloalooo or any noooaaorloo and pllrlo ot MY a\lPae. 'I." \1tlO'111 110.'1'1 lr'IiIW.;~~:toP~lIlOl1omOI 01 any \lmo, 1'11111011\ arool/n\l on ohllolll/an on tllo Pall of ollhor Iho cloolor or 1110 monlllllatllror, to !'" Qlako;'oor.roepqp\l,n'u allonlloa In 11a Irollor or mopllohomo clooorlbor! 011c1 aovorodPy thla arclor ollhor Iloloro, or allhooqllonl la, elollVory \\. . ,.elf\ QllolI eq\i1pmont la' Iho p\lrahoaor" " 'l~n'j ~t~ot ,~, ~~~!?,~,;o~~~!!!?aIPO 1101110 lor doluYo oOIlQocl Py Iho mOll111001llror, oooldonlo, olrlkoo, IIroa or ony olhor aOIl~~ ~OrOf\cI ilia aan. :.'~. ",7 WARFlANl1llBI TI11l PIlA~IlR SHA~~ ClIYIl TO T11F. UUYI.iR OoPIF.B OF ANY ANP AI-I- Wf1ITTIlN WAfI'1ANT.II~B Ooy. . ~~,,'\llnINQI.THlrUN'T'PIlBOf1laIlP IN nnB A\.\nIlIlMENTr ANP AI-I- IIIWAnATIlI-Y WAnAANTIlP'AI'f1I-IANOIlBANP OoMPO. :: .'~NIlNTB "WlnoH WARAANTIIlB AAIl HIlR/lIlY ABBIClNIlP TO THF. aUVlm. F.XOIlPT TO TI1IlIlXTIlNT rnOWJllTllP UNPIlR \i""'BTA1'Il'CAW, THIl PIlAI-IlR MAKI1B NO WARRANTllll!J EX.PRIlBB OI1IMfll-lI~P. ANPl WITI10UT I-IMITA110N, PISOI-AIMIl THIl '>y.;~~~~~~!~~, ~~~.R~,~TIIlB OF MIlROHANTAIlILITYANP t'ITNIlBIl FORA PARTIOUI-AR ,'URPOBIl" ;,'" '.... ',: . ~l'i"'~II\\'<" I:"" 'I1Il\.1U1CRhlllllLtuI1II11UOI1CRlIllltLlul-hl\LllXumlnlld.lhll\1lll.dWlll1tulllUlndJlJlldlob 10 fo r hll.$llltlllUlloUlUda. . ,oj: ,I,\,,~( i:'.. h .. '" ',:;...'. tlutUUUlloooaplablo oqUllllllWllllljJ~lIlJlld.ntllu1l1l1LLllwnJUdgUIll1lt.llndJ1\.I1IlIllllili\' , ' \ (~" .i.:, ", I' '0, (II) If Iho clollvory ollhe moblln llnllla Inollldocl Il1lho purohoao Plloo, or If Iho donlor qlloloa II ohlllOo Icir'd,ol!V,ory:!eQ!le oUn- ,:'; lomo~a doal/nllllon, bolh 1110 lIorOOh1onl to trnn~po~ alllcl unit, flU 1'1011 oa 1/10 prloo 'I\lalotlon mlldo, la Pnaocl IlpOn-CUSIOmol'a IIUB\lr. N.; "lInoo 11101 Irllvol 10 IIlnng aoooplohlo oll,wolllllor allrfllaocl ranclo, lully opon nnd noooa~lblo,lram polnl of arloln to palnl of delivery, dllr- '/r : ,1'lng Iho parlocl roqlllrocl.lorlr~nspartotlan, Pllrallo~or oaallmoa nil roaponallllllty fOI Iho propor Plopolol/an 01 hla praporty 10 hOlh rooolvn :~''''''',ond laolllollhe;oolcl,m~bllo unit, .In ovol1l of ltr4lodlmonl, nal provlo1l81y dlaolooocl 10 Ih~cloolor roqulros .of oxlro IlIbor lII1c1 oqlllpmonl, '~:" '1I1h.O o\lalamllr l\oro,W).1..111. ~1I'000 1.0 PllY for IIl1aucl1 ocldlllonlll oaala ancl to halcl aollor Iroo from 1I0bllllY for domoooo roaulUng from. Iho u~o" li~,Ilt"ol:l!Xlrl\l~b,or.oriIJlqmo\li9f oxtmoqlllpmonl, (PI Poolor doea nol glloronloo PlOp or pllloorr,onlunloUB 0 oqncrolo plor, rllnnlno 110low Iho 1,.1' '.'ilfroalllno, I1tiB'/lral'b.oQri'proporod, Oualomor OglOoa to Pny far 011 labor ond m810rlol aoala 10 ro.aolll1o mob lohomo whon oouaod by 'rl futuro ro.aoltlng or sinking srlall10 from 1011\110 10 pravldo IIn approvacf 101lnclnllon, Sowor m\I~1 bo alllPpod oul of grolmd, wolor,lIno /; ",', mllal 110'toliP,eef.,nn'cl, olqolrlo 11110 oonnoalod to motor polo wllh Plapor rflooplnclo Wllhln 20 foot 01 Iho 01001110 hOl( Inaldo 01 homo, ,/'I ",;-' Unloaa atllarwlao provldocj on tho 'ooe 01 Ihla purohoso ardor, 1110 unit dooollbod hOloln la aoltl ',O,P,dolllof'a 101.. .' , 1,,\,\':\I~W'7~,,9,"PO,l\lo~I",n~1 pormlllod to moko plllrnhlno or uloolrlool oonnoallana, or oannootlng of aortolnf1QIlllof 0"0 or propllno opplfonaaa ~'/.l":"!WI\0'0"11I1'l..oII199Pl.orcllnanaos roqulre II 1I00naocl plumbor or oloalllolon 10 clo ao, spa. ololpulldlno ord.ll1anaoa or Illwa r09111rl~1I plumlJ. ~ "'''I~o,'ftloi\(r 001' oroonatruotlon ohllnooa ora nollho roapanalbllllY 01 Iho clonlor or monu'oalllror, Doolor la nol raaponalblo lor obllllnlng 'J,j:":i;1I00Ilh:df.'.8~nll,nllqn:p.ormIl8"nor tar 10001, oOllnty or allllo porrnlla Involvlno roalrlollvo lanlno, Oaal 01 Ohllnooa noodod tor oompllnnoo i;', !' mllat bo porno bY tho purohn8"t, , . j ',,, ,." 10, It,ls,undolal~o!l1hol Pllrahoaor 10 1101 oavorocl by In811ronoo unW oocoplacl.by Inouronoo Oompony, llhcl flulahllaor ooroosla h . ,hold Sollor,lIarmloaa,fram sny and 011 olnlma duo 10 laua or clotnago prior 10 ocooplonoo arlnauronoo oavorogo l1y InaUlnnoo Oompony, 11 ',0' '", 11, Nalloo'o' wldlh IImllollonal Tho pllrohoaor lIaknowlodoos bolng Info 1m ad ollho 10nOlh ol1d wldlh IImllatlons, OS of Iho dalo of :'III',,:)hls Inalrumonl, now"ln foroo In tha aovarol Bloloo, or Iho Provlnooa 01 Oonodo, aa !hoy mny opply 10 tho Inovomanl at mol1l1ohomeo e,''''. over tho publlo hlol1wllya, and tho tool thllt ouoh 1l10Vomonl mllal, In all ooooa, bo mado undor apoolal pormllllhol 80mo alalos, or tho i"\',,,, ,Provlnaol of Oonlldll"moy not glonl suoh pormllo whoro Iho SilO oxooocls Iho stollllory maximum, and dooshoroby rofollao Iho aold ~t' 'doolor horool1lhO monufoalllror IInd tholr 1I1010na from ony oncl all domnnds, alllls or oOlllllor Ollllms, bllaocl an tho allo of 1110 wllhln /{ "'1' ;nobllohamo, III oxooodo 1110 l!tnllollono whloh ora now, or moy Inlor ba, !tl1f1oaad by any alalo or provlnoo, " ,'I, ' III THIS MRllllMENT OONTAINS THllllNTlRE AGRaEMENT OF THa PMTIEB AND SUl1llRBEPllB AI.L PRIOR ANP ,'" CONTilMPOAANIlOUB WAITTI!N AND onAL AGAllllMENTS, UNDUIlSTANDINGB, AND NEGOTIATIONS, ALL op WHIOH Anll C1,,,Ml!nGED INTO THIB AQnEIlMllNT, THE BELLlln HAB MAllE No AllpnllBI!NTATloNB OR WARRANTIES NOT EXflnaBBLV ~~ ' ' ~aT FORTH IN THIS AQRIlIlMIlNT, . I :~-.rq;.,,,. " tlf ';" ,,~"""I"" ,I, , " r7\ r.7" ',~' ", ~ .', I"' ._, '~l , I \:,II,'~,.~,;t..':"i~;'1W~\'.I\1~~'\41.\~;,J,~;;;.~;;;;~,..;;;;'i":i,\.~~i~~l\I.Y.:lI(ifii;'./.':iifJl~mu:xW4:\IUlimjiJ.:'i;;;;,i:I,::\';;;i:;\jr:l )',.;.,\\;;;'" '... . i ' . QOUNTRY SIP~ VII-J.AGfi HOM~~, INO, iI' .m"".""""",,..,.,., ?,oga ~Inopln WAY !:flal fi OI1f1ml:mrapurg, FA 17201 " (717l26Nl777 1,"Wr.:n,,,,~,,.",r,,,r.l'''';j)'''''''''I!l1o.''"''''~'''''''n'''':''''.'Ilr,.,,'.'''m"'a..............4.""""'_""_,..,tJ.,,\"I!,.\I""/.'""r'j~.".,,'~.,',\':';\""":';'.l!\'l.~"".""',,,q'l"." ''l'\f.I~fflli~~~~~~;~ff-''''~J(lli",,*,",t~~'.<.tf.~~~I~jIMMffl\OOI'lIl1;(\.h~W.I';{'M'fA'.JiV~':;i(,;1",..;,>t",',.,,1~d, ",tllrfhllMI,~'i1,.;,,~ :; TO I C;~. y. '\.~~. . s.K..,. , ~ u..:,\ \ ~ V' )..,o-,'P-e J~'L~"'\.1\.:LJ ~~, ~.so..\'_j=~bY' G'I'CMJJ\ S ~t<.c-{ .~ '. ~'.~ Q..-\-;l:lY'\i1J&\.~~~\~O~(lA,~S,1 -S:h..n ~ '\ ~'f'/'\ I') 0"(' o,.'{I 'l\ ' ~.t ~ E.~\~:hV'\~ \\'~n.~ , J l NO, PATa --E-()~ 9 (p NAMa SO u... '01 ~ APDRass S ~,..,., ~ P1IONU N i!.1Ji) '7 tl (I' - 3) \ ~(~ a~RIA~ N MQPI1I.~ .~~ d I 'QlA,\;c:...~ .. S~l'PATU __ JOll/l ~\~,)" ~-.O'Y'\' ~G D\:), C:lD II g b~ (!., So ::;- . III 9 50, oC;- 'c"''''',\, \'''00 \l., ~~ -- 'R <ll '76', DO ~\~? -~c>G.'i.\r:h,,~ L.il'l"t,~ - : ;lH;;CJ, DC D... ::Ov..Y'I ~~ \> {t,n-\: S (........ ~ \: -1\ r:.c.. '<. s.r .D ~....~ ... ,;) D S', a 0 I ~ - "r"I G"h~'Y'S ==-- l:i1,scc, CO '~ c.tl...vu.:-~' t:> !-1 f.t8'OD ,cC) j::O'f''rf\\''~ ~ ""\ ,~:('h.. \ ~V\~ lCJ..\~~ s ~b .... IT; 002 D , 0 ~ _ \ .-CIw"'~\~m~"Q...\"~IJ'\'oo\<, lA~ oJf l;:)!,.k}.J"9 t.\<::>"",'t.-. "It ~8'o, 01::) " -- II -:-._- c:;.V'u.Y'I~-ro\n..\"" CJ I~(') I GD .1 ~fQ\\\\ ~~'f'M;\s )tr~' CI.L'i~...MtlV ~~1.ti.l;;m:y=1 ,~.c.)c. 8.>,- C,l'J..V~,\ 'on Ct-.",~ S(>~ ~ 'i Y\~ Qj \rLtJ..u:>'r\ J3:'.It c.1"'~.l! ~\ ~ --. - -/t. s 7/Y "f;'4 "11" ~,~-~ REOUESTED llV - , , ,EHhlbll ,,' I' WIiITl!IOlIlce rll. OANArWIMllnu'ac1U,er" CoPV n72'1'lllnln\IIII.I(..\ n~~upl~\111~Plh, I11Hlnlll1llol1 01' l\1ol11rH Hllrnllhllll In Hllppl1rl tlw hOI11\l, nllowll1g Ilw ilOllOl'lll1l 10 I\lI~q\Hllcl)' lllll'll b~lill'll plnpll1~ Ihe homc 011 thc pollCrlllll Hlnh or PI'Op~r1~ Ilrlldll1~ 11I'0111\111110 lWI1W, 011 tho \lol1tl'lll'~, PelUl1dlll11 1\111)' pUl'lill'l1\1l11 Ill' WI1S prllvol1l11111i'om doll1~ IIIl nil 1\ reH\11l 01' Ihll 111lpl'l\lI'\l1100111' Plnll1l1l'lilnH HOII\1l'lh 1111l1'1l 1\111)' 111 NllW Mn\lOI', 12, J)pl1l\ld, pel\llHlnnl il9nleH Ihlll It hllH P\lrl\1l'l11ed 111 II pllOl', h1\pro)1\I1' Ill' \lI1wol'k1l11111llke 1111\\l1l1' oel'lnll1 olhol' Ihl11lJH whli'h W91'0 pxproHHly or h~ l1eOOHHnr)' 11I1pllcnllPll I'~illllrod h~ nl1Y 01' lIio Ilhovo l'elurcl1oed ngreel1lO11IH Inoll1dlng Ih(\n1l1111101' In whlell 1110 homo wnH Illenled, Ihe n1llllnor In whloh tho eMU oll1'lnln wnl1wns hlHlnllod, the n1l1111101' Il1whloh Iho cOllOl'ole .. Hlnll IVliH InHlnlled ill' IIwlevollng oflhe home, On the oOl1ll'1\l'Y, Pcf'ondnl1ll\llIy pel'l\1rmo(l 01' WnH pl'eVOl1led Ji'llm dolngHo nH n rUHII\I ol'lho Inlel'lurel1uo 01' Plnlntll'lilnH Hellill'lh 11101'0 1\llIy In Now Mnllel', /. I~, Delul1dnnlndmlls Ihnl II ropnlrcd lho cl'lwks Oil Ill' nholll Iho dnlo ~tnled' nnd Ihnl nddlllol1nl CrnekH nppenl'ed nl 'Honw Intel' dnlens Iho I'UHlllt 01' Plnll1t1l'1il' lillIlI1'o to Inslnlllho gUItOI'H I', nnd (lowl1sponlH which they nlJl'ocd 10 InHlnll to,pl'llwnll'nln wnlel' f)'ol1l running of'fofl'lnll1tll'lil' 1'001' . .. nl1d Honking Ihe eMU olll'\nln wnllH HUITolll1dlng the hnHonl' I'lnlnlll'l:~' homo, 1 'I, ^dl11$tod In J1~lrllll1d denlcd III pll1't. Dulllllllnlllndl11l\H Ihnl \( hns pl'Ovldcd nddlllollnl I1l1l1nd lop IIOIlIlI'O\II\lll'lnlnlll'lil' home IIl1d gl'lIdcd Rnl110 pUI'sunl11 10 IIn IIgrcemonl w\(h 1'11I111lIl'lil In whloh Pllllntll'l'H 1I!lI'ccd thlll Dof'endnnt would he pnld lineI' Hnld wlll'k WIIS d011e fl'lllll f\lIldH , 1'11I1nl\l'l'H plnecd III escl'OW wllh PllIlnlll'lil' counso\, Delundn11t d0l11eH Ihnll'llIl11tlff:~ hnvo I110UrI'ed IIny Hueh expCI1SO, howo\'Ol', hoonuso 10 dnlo, I'lulntll'lil hnvo Ihllcd n11d 1'01\IHOd ,lol'elenHe sllld f\lIldH In escl'OW 10 Dolundnlll desp\(e Defondnnl's cOlllpletlo11 Ill'snld wOl'k fllll'Hunnllo the ngl'eel1lOnl, 3 (I1ml\"""IO$'I~'1 22, \1l1\'S\llIlIllll \he IIgroell101I\H relol'rcll \0111 thu Cnmpll11111 1I11\II\nHW91', pul~1\\hHl\ sol<l \11 \1II1II1III'1's II Illlnblo wille P\I\ch l1111del 2m I mlln\llilelmod hllHlo I1nll h1s\nlle\lit on \1111111\II'1's' lot 11\ 21 IMler 1,11I10 In Nowvlllc, PonnHylvllnl1l on II Uonoro\u pnd Il1slnllell by Pol~l1dllnl, 23, Altho\lgh Ihe p\II'ohllse Alll'eel11Ul1tls dl1tell A\lll\ISI I, 19%, Ihu homu WnH se\ \lp Iln 1110 clll1el'ele pl\\lll1 pecembol' 01' (1)%. 2.1. 'I'lw home SitH Oil Ilry IlIld C(1)(lrcIIl111lls11nry Ul1its ("CMUs") HlTIIIIllud In Iho Ihrm of IIpproxhnlltoly 2M piers pl1l90<l 11\'lll' II PllIlcro\e slllb whlllh Is thlok911ull lit Ihe 100i\\lons of Ihl! plol's Ihr, str\lc\u1'lI1 p\lrposos, 25, Anol' tho home WnS II1Hllllled Oil thu )llors, Dulondlln\ COIISlnlC\od II ulll'tllln wnll oonsls\lng or n)lpl'oxlmnte1y I1ve COIll'SOH high or ulght Inch thlek eMUs, with mort III' .Iolnls, to onolose Iho undorsldo 01' Ihe hOl11o he\ween tho topor \ho conorelo shIh 1111\1 tho hllse 01' tho homo, 26, ThorenHol', Hurnelont sollli'oll1 Plnlntlrt\l' slto l\l0ludh1g soli exolIVlIlod to oonHtnlct \he sinh wlIHhllCk I1l1cd 1II'(1\ll\d Ihe outside ol'\h\1 eMU cmlnln wl111H 10 suf'l1elon\ height 10 pllloe tho oonuretu slllh hulow thnn'oHllll1u, 27, Al\el' Delondllul completcd pmper hllek I1l1lng of tho hOllle 10 provcnt Ii'ost hOllves, Plllln\lITClIII"y MeKeo dll'llulcd thc Dolondlll1l's employce 10 rogrllde Ihe hllek 1111 to lIehlovo II ccrlllln lleiilhe\lo orfcot deHlrod hy 1'IIIInlllTs, Delon<llll1l's employeo IIdvlHed Ml', McKoe or Ihu rellsol1lhe hllck I1l1lng hlld beon doml, nlld d\1splto sueh IIdvlHe, WIIS dll'cctod 10 mnko the chllllge, Accordingly, . ()OIOlldllllt's employee compllcd with I'lnllllll'l's' request, 2M, DelondnntlllHo IIdvlscd Illnllllll'l\l III cOl\lunetloll with tho sllle IIlld IllHlnlllltloll of tho homu tlllltrllln gullers IInd downHpouts would he required hel'oro ()eloudllnt could WI\l'l'lInt the \ I 5 . . 1',.,,1, I; .,,~ 8, " 9, ~" OIlANGE ORDER. noforo ~ny AqQi~ion~ ~o or qo1otion~ fro~l ~ho work OhPWll on tho Propoal\l:' AttachoQ all ~lIhipi~ ^ Aro modo, Dwllllf Anq nU~lqor llllAll ~i8n A ahAlIgll orQOr cbllqr\l1illi\ Agrellll\on~ to thll propo~oQ ChAlIgo, 5, PIOOUTS AND APPROVALS, OWllor ~hAll PAY tho COSt pf AU reljllLrpq pO!:'1qi~~, LII~pllPtionll AnQ Apprpval~, 6, CONCJEALED CONDmO~S-1. 'l'hh /\groomollt i,9 P/\~oq 011 tho lIormll1 OXCAVlltion CPIHlitLOlI1l And tho A~IlUmpt~on thAt thore Are np qOlloell1eQ CPllqitiplI1;l po10\l tho SUrfACO Of tho groUIIQ, H COllcoalOQ conditionll a\loh Aa IIpt limLtoq tC CPl1col\loq rock or Wl\tor Are ,,0naOUlltoroq in tho OXallVlltioll, ~he rOl;lultillg illcroAao ill COllt of ;;'.tho projoct ahall po pdq Py Ownor \lpOI1 reaaollAble qOC11mOntatioll of expollllO to nUilqer", 7, CGfpLE'l'IOIi DA'l'E. BI.ILl,dllr ahllll cOII\p10tll tho work ill a gooq allq lI.orklIlanlLko IlUllln. or, Sllpject,to dO.1l1fa CllUSeQ by ws/\thor or other mllttnrs beyond Builderls COlltrc, Buildnr' 'shall achodu10 construction ao that the fOIHlqlltion shall ho rOAdy for delivary of the hpme with~1I two (2) lIeok~ of tho"timo whon thl\ manufaoturor oan dlllLver ~ho hpme IInd Oll'ller la 10nqor, if allY, hilS A4thoril1eq paymellt fOr tho hO!Ile, ' ~1PANCY, OWller IlgreOa that Owllor shal], not ooouPythe heme ull1eaa anq until Ownar haa made filiAl pllyment for the homs alld for tho fOlllldation conatruction undor this Agreament, If Owner vio1atea this pl1ragraph, Owner ahall pay Builder a pondty of Olle ll11nd~~d Fifty DoUara($J50,OO) per dl1Y until BUilqer ia paiq in ,full, ~ a, Owner is roaponsihle for purohal\ing liability inl\ut'alll:e and, at Ownet" s option, l1llly purchase ahyothet' insurallce to proCect agaillat c10ims Chllt lIUly arise from the work, b, Owner shall purchase firo alld cnsualty inaurance on the . entire worlc at its full insurnble Vnllle, '11\ is insurnnce shall nnme the Owller nlld the Builder nnd sh!tll' insuro against the perils offiro, extended GQvernge, vandalism, and l1Ullioious miachiaf, Any illl/urod lOBS will ba adjus tad IIi th the Owner and made payablo to the Owller as trus tee for the BUilder, lIS their respective interosts may appear, ! } ,. , , , . I, ['I .' " ., " " " If i' " " " " p." '1' ii " " " II " l" , , " H .' " " " " 'I , ' I' " i' '1 'i, n '\'" ,II , ' " " !ft, I, ,I' Ii " I' 'n " " "'I' " " , ;' 'I', ,1 I ,II il' ,f, " ,J' 'I, " " ,,1'1,'1'" " 'I " I'; " " ",' I' I"~ ,"~ I' '11' " " . "H "' " " , I ' I' I, ,. " I' " " ..".. " .(1 " " " I , 'i,"" .' ,.!. " !;j "I IH! ,."t~ ~:V ~}: " ii~ ~ ~~o , '.' ., /", ,f ." ,. " lei { ! ( /, \'.,' '_C_"J;,i.<'/'f';I!' , I. \ I' Y!/;';'. ! , , '" ,p~ '!' II !" ", "-'''' (\~) I. ,', I I I I I .' ., , , " 1', P " " " " (1 ;'" " .' ", :1 'j, " 'i" Ii u t. " " It I, ", "i " ,j\ ;,)1 .' .' !j " , " " i! " " I' " ;! tJ, Ii " " ;, ;' 'ji " ,. Ii II' H, ., Ii" " I.. ,. It,' Ji., " " " ,. " .1 ,. . " ,. J'; El(hlblt 0 j; '/1",,- ..J. \ i" . ... - '1..". ," I. 'r! ." J. _, ~I \I72Y9ilillnll\l!'16,1 'I YIlliWICA'I" () IS , \'ol'lIy tllII! thu Hlnlon10111H I11nll~ Inlhu Ihl'ulJoll1l.1 AI1~wol' 10 AnWIHllld Cpl11plnll1l wllh Now fv1nuol' nml Conl1llll'lllnllll lII'll II'IIU Ilnd OPl'I'ccl. 111ll1lcI'Hlnnd Ihnl fillHIl Hlnlol11CnlH Ihol'oll1 nl'O 111l1\11l HlIhlullt 10 tl10 ponnllluR of" fl Pl\IC,H,A,# 41)04, I'ulnllng 10 lInHWOI'll fhlHlflontlon to l\lIlhorltloH, Dn\ul - rJll '2' \ .e' 46~ ;l?",'n,'7J:1.!,(/h.( (l'--...._J nhlol1 /',111111101'111111,10 " (../ . r~r (1 rr' \,F .' ( I ,I I' " ,. 'I' , 'e, , 1,\ H " ,. " fl l' ,. " " " , F j., Ii " " ,. " i' " I; ,.!. p " ,', . , " .' ", " .' " " .' " " " " .' " I'o! " i ('1 III , n i' (" .\1 '1'1 " , .- I'J 'I , !:n il)l" , ,)\rJ .. " ~I,! l : ; " .1 .~ '. , , r,') "',\, 'I',) " 1 i.". : ''\'J jJ' ,. t::: ( ,I" II, .. " ""-' L"II ~]~ () ~l'; I'l-,' ". ~ 1 " (II;':) I.,) ,(; I ( ,Jt C" " ~::l " I, ',I :::> '1;- -,"I ~.q J' ..~, '~l i'J,,~ ,1' ,;! " ;j' 1 , " " "p I: " " " ,. " "", II' {, " I , ,i ~ ' " ,," i'" " It,,; " Ii' " 6, Pn P:t,' AI}PIII: f\1\U\HII: ill, 1996, Pll~lnl;Hf!l ol1\:o:t.'pd l.nl:o A , w~ltton OontrAot wl.th DefendAnt, de!lorl~od AS A prppoaA! for orAwl ApAoe fOllndAtlon Iltil1ty hook IIpa, Anrt ten~orAry hook ,liP to oKIAting home, A trllo Anq corraol: oopy of whIch III AttAohnd heroto, mAqO A 11Arl: I\pl:eof:, Anri mt1rkpri Aa IUllhJl}11: "nil, 7, Thp PIAintiffa hAve f"lfill0d ~11 thp proviPtonA of tho AgrPemont on thoir pArt to be porformoq, fJ, 'l'he plAl.n\:.~fflo1 hAve pAlct tho PefonrIAn\: $lll,OnD,OO And $D,lOO,OO Aooorcttngto the oontrAota, {l,'l'I\e ,contrAol: oAlla for \:he performAnoe 01: oe1'\:Aln Worl~ And , the fllrn1ahlng of oertAln materlAls by Dafol1dAnt AS thoroln. atAtect, 10, The DefondAl1t hAa failoct to properly oomplete tl\o provlaionlo1 , of the Agreoment on ~ta pArt to be performe~, 11, DefenctAnt hAa Wholly negleoted to do And performoertain thtnglo1 whioh were ellpreaaly or by neOeSf3Ary lmpl.loAtion relll1irect to be done Anct performect by the Agreement, aa followSI (A) lnf3tAll the oonorete alab At or heloWAt.lndUf3try Aocepted depthl (h) inf3tall footers aUfflolent"to s"pport the home) (c) fAl1ed to Allow tho oement to cure before plAcing the home on the f31abl And (d) fAiled to " gr~de the ellcavated mAterlnl properly nroul1d the home, 12, Defendant has performed in n poor, improper, and unworkmnnllke manner certain other things which were eMpressly or by , neceasAry lmplioation required by the agreement to be done and performed ln A proper And workmanlike manner, AS follows 1 (a) the, Ii homp WA~ not lpOAte~ next to the exiatino ~eokl (h) thq five OOIl~~O~ of, elgl11: .Inoh 1J,~llOk ~\m:puncUng l:ho home hAva on.\pJ~ect I (0) 1:110 oaman1: ~,1.AP npon wh.j.oh l:ha hOIl11a ~Ha if! o~/.\okino lIne! 11hJf,\:inOI I1ncl (cl) tha hOllee f,loo~ i~ not 1eV91. 1~, mho PafanclAnt t~iacl to rapAi~ tha orAok~ on or Ahout " Novan~er an, 1997, hut tha o~Aoka returned within ton clAYa, 111.. ~t'he pefonclfwt IH\~ AI: tha P1A.lnl:.lff~ expomw pr.'ov.Ldecl moro f, 111 Aronncl l:ha home f~nq grAqoq the f, 111 L\round I:ha homa, 15, !~o Pef,andAnt hAll fAiled Ancl rafU~acl, Anq otill refnaep, to oure the remAining AforoaAi~ broAohup, daapite Vla.Lntif,f'a clamAn~ thnt tho ornoka Ancl tha OAuao of tho orAoking ha repAirecl, 16, mhe renoonAPle OORt of rema~Y!ng the Aforepnicl prenohaa i~ in exoa~~ of $15,000,00, 17, pefenq~nt hAP breaohed hia oontrAot with Plaintiff, Ancl " PlAintiff hAa pean clAmAgacl hy pafendant'a braAoh in An Amount of at lenat $ln,OOO,oo, WllmHl~FORm, Plf,linl:.i.ffa GAry and Roxnnn MoKea demAnd jUdgment againat dllmAgea Defendant, Country .' in An Amount of At Side Village Homea, Ino" for aotuAl leAat $15,000,00, pIlla ooata of auit Reapeotfully Subm.Ltted. . ~, .~ Ilr,'" \ ,......,. . ' ~f - . '.I' mothy '.1', mn lar, ~ II ROllINSON & Gm ALOO Attorney 1,0,# 70t40 4407 N, Front street 1',0, Dox n320 Harriaburg, PA 17110 (717) 232-0525 Attorney for th'e l'lllint;lffa " ~r-"'''j.""_,,, .......,".'..'f", ' cOUNTRY SIPE Br~.C1 10 G:ll.b\'(.-.:t:...R r-' ~ (\f.:lli_lll.S.j,.Ij.~._..____ VlhhA" ~ HOM ~~ INO. '<Pi,,,,,, _~ -\-B-~J:'''''Lklii''1'-:____-,~ PURPHAa~AQR~~M~NT , "---1. ' , . ,,_~ ---.NJ!:..Y-l U ll::LIi. l-,f.~\.QQU-t I ,., ".J! L:q~ J. 'IJlI/\ t~l~ 'fl.~lr~r~1r;'Q ",' r<' -. -, - d'_______ ""',,.' ---',-",._~;s=-!! "'''"'''''' 1-9-'l-1 S~J~~ 'i I"'1r. ,p; .:s A f'l-' lr'.s' &> t'.l L ,.." C' He SUHll' APfJ1l1iB11i a \ ill \-1. T LE.,~ .!.:1~'\"1E_, ' ..., Iii V-l V , j. to #" e~ I . :' iUSJEcr 10 IIIP rEIIMiMIPCOIiDlrlOlii ilArEO 014 00111 SlOES OF lll1iAll/1EEMINI SEUEnAUOIU IU SE\lli/ll IIIE I'Ullciii'iiii.iruIEESIOfIJnc,JsE lliiifOno\VlliOOESCllIPEO I'nOI'Enl) MIINUFAOTUnun FJoPllr. NAMa ' MOPIl~' .- n,nOOMa AFF P~, sTOOI( NIJMlllln. .' ",, ,'p,!,.\ 'Ie r.:!. L_ .sl a :7 _ ..t ~~~~~M:E; ,,"0' , !:lUsUI) O't~-,~e SUSYFR?'bllw OPTlo I. 'QIIPI.4EN lAnOll P AcooaSOlllES - " en .9 lit. . ~ '" FACTOIlV 1'1f1f10Ns ol'T1PNAI, UQUlflMIlNT IlMIl ,.,lIoH 1# j} .;:r Il ~ , , SUIl'TQTA~ SA~ES TAX TITU1' NaTAnv - INsUllANOI1 CQ, Mos, CAB/I fin ICE" . . . . f . "" ~ u" "'r.. .ft.",,, , " .1. t.' lit u- , , ~""~~'AlA/jO'''!'OA~II~A~~,I,,",p '.': .,': ',',:S- 0 . , . . '," , I Sall~r amI PurohllQar IIgros\t/1I\1 'nol .wlthQta~dlngony,olh"r pro via Ions ot thla qontrllor:thllt upon al/'llonllnoa/1llhlQ ''''IIhls oonlrllol h~vlng Ilaan 'mat;." 'Pul'llh~.sar shOUld 11111 Ilr relu'sa'to purchasa Iha ma@'aoI4rod, hllme daso,'~ad,haral/1 Wflhln Ihllty claya lIf10r nolloo 01 '1IV.lll1a~,IIIIY ol,lha srima Irom Sollilr, Ihlll So liar mllY. rataln Ihs antlra ollsh dllwnpllymanllllld/or nal am~unllll owod tor trlldlt .I\~ 1I~lIldlll~d dsmllgaa,;' , . . "-;.-1.71(,: Inltial~,',A, R-/k "n/li~"s IT IS MlITU.A~LY UNDIlRSTOOD 'I'HAT THIs'A'lReIlMIlNT IS suo. JIlOTTO NIlOIlSSARY CORReCTIONs, AND ADJUSTMIlNTa CON. ollRNIN'l oHAN'lllS IN NIlT PAYOIII" ON TAAOIl,IN '1'0 Pll MADij AT THll TIMtl OIl8IlTILllMIlNT. a,S,'I:!'.tf S"'dt.l iH" NllInD .. s,U I~I/' r", I ""A'S 'Nama, LJ;.0.111.,k;-' II.... II "~. "ot · ..- h_ .... -...... Iovol ""'" f>Iooo~ ...'" ...r ..._ ~""'hftlf or~'I"I"-;," ,tUtch....ll.Cid ==~,~~I/. .,. 0/ otlllOl)l 00. 0/. 1,0/ hol'll ItllOl" .""",,~ Plto<!, Ihot all ~.Ij" dtooqlleQ~, 11lt~"., ''''llflltrC 1l/1<I1lCOt.. io,1G4I lff'O" and, Ino~, H' Includtd, ,. b Vlllllnltill)l P\I,qItHd, Tilt etIY bt~ Ittel. tel It 'roo lrom .. ,.nw=, . ~.." 1lI""I.d tl 101 tbOl't, UltllO.,_ ..t1~ I and l'lovblon ., a,lt com... on /, lronl IItClC It "l'tItColt;IH a""oIl1.ll1'/~ UIlItI11'll,*," pottlon 1I...llty.fIt,......1tf11tk1 i1 'Iu.' _1I1<l ""oct, ' '1,1/1'," "". " nUYllA OANNof' OOOUPY' HOMI!' UNTIL ALL'MONI'lVs Mil " ,lll1lJlAs60 TO CbUtlmy sl'?~ VILLA'll! HOMl'ls, INo, Ii'.'," I, OR we, HIlRllllY AOK OW~1l0'l1l RIlDIiIPTo/, A bOPVoII THIS. .. Ol1oeRI . ( ,)" . (" ,', . ,'" " . ,;' 8/GNlle)f ,,(;;, ',' .. (1 . " . ,~~119f~~ftA 8/QNeo~.J:, . &1.l110fi~811/l 'I. .' I, I I ~ \ t "','. , " " - I 1'\""'\"J'\'(l~f,.I"'I,. ~ 4'-.\ ~_ _\1.'~'~""g ~ 'u.'H';,.:t',,'" "" 'l '". i,: 'CONTIW CPNflNllI1NT Uf'ON MANAGUIlIAI. AND PINANolAl. APf'noyAl. ~. ,~':':' "nAlAN>>til~lIllhp'TOOPTIONIItI1QUII'MaNT. '. ~ '_ ,: ",\",1"."11.,,,:. '''~~IIUj.\fll,,,~.''I,1 " ..' " " dO # , t' "AU;'w"Ea~'/,''rlnBII;'ANOAl<Ul8 To AUMAIN 'rHa fIf1lll'unTY CJfI COUNTRV slOll, If' I' ',CU~H/lJftlliDS,TO,"OYE IlPMlf,iJouNTnv. 8 lOll wu. SUPPl.V AllOVllITllMO, ':IJIlS9nlr.r/<IN.9PT/1.'1OI1"I~:~.\i.'): ,.' .VIlN1 , ' .l.i"", ''1''!I~ f"( , ".f';';;h~I,...:.! "rl MAI<II' "',' ., ML'" ' . I ~I"'~ ~I\t:""il.lf !v'ttl .. ~""'i~'" ,', .' 'J"l' ,t,,"', ' " I; I .'.'... ',1" I., . :, . ;~11,' II. , TIlL"""', "I~~,NO ' l",JiiV;'';.,I.it" '.dJ\.'~lJ.t,.~" ~.~~:'I'I." 1 ";' ,tl':'1 i"'., ~" 1.1 ',Ir... l'i,~' 'j, . ~~~q~.NQ.~Wli'>,I,\:,.M,*i.~\I""."f '.': ....'Il'\i.. t \ "', ""'I 'l,u1",,4'.;.&\\,.'.,.\ I' "'1 , , TRAOa,IN,OUDT TO ua flAlll nv" 0 DIlAUlIl !:l OUSTOMSn IlllPAool41 ' " '"', SIll! OOLOf1 ..".. . "..,....." 11111 h"lIll1r \IIHjplllolllj ,11111 'lQrlloc~; nlO orrlor on Ihn 10VIH~0 ~IIIII hOIOllllq ~lIllionl 10 1I111101l0\'lll1Q IlIrnl~ ,wI oonrllllnllq, '11Inl \'IllIch IhlVO II00n IIllllll~lIy ilQrllorj !lponl I 'llWl\ll-llV.~/lt..llllt.lfa/llllQl1all-<<I/~lfalll\l..j/\_'hlU1, ulal-ILI\,i1,I_ _111',11 1I111-lrIll1IJlg~la/l...\Il~Llf.\l1IAlOt.ll, QI,lll~/ala;.1l, 41Jha 1I111A.llWha...l1~1l~afY-Q1--I1A.IIIlIIII!.-jl1lUtl1aflalUA.1lI-v.lIhlllllU1II1AIIltL.al1l.1JI4QQIl<<l11l1l1a-\V11'1_lhlWll~ULllII\llIap~/l/lln. \l' I'A~ lIIanlJ, IIl1llUl,' IA\lil,' l\..~tllL/, ,llI<lLaLlhlullllllr,,-IV ,lILllllhll, l..lUIllIUIIA-A-falall-lIII'Alljllll/llll, fln,lfJlllh-I~Llr,IIV-JlIlIIIIIIll\ll\l-\lLJlIlll\-llllla( IflfllW\La, 1II,:IIlIlIlQIIWtLl11IlI'-IUU,II 1IIlIIallpv-,I, lIw....nllA.llLllllll\lllLllllfllllllt..Jhll ~<<I1lI1IIn_,I\-ltlll..tls11hi4-\lnl/~IIW.JlOrIlQd 1111, a:anllQ IIf QJLlhlllJl/fl(JLllalq ~rwLlIl..\lJl.hl-llc.lLllmIlU1l11ll1ill\t..llllnIU\lll-hIlLPlllln.Ql(IlQ.\lIll{j","nl/Jlg,g.a~IIU/-4Y..lLl1"niI.nW/unnQ!I..llfl1U$llll nll+-lhIlIllU/I.IIIWUIIlIUIlJllLIIl-PllflllllllOl,nIIlWhQ.Llllh_lI11IUIlLIIQIIVJlIV-fIlIlI'-P1lf11nl.lIUlLII.lJ\tl;fldIl1Il, .. a, Thll p\HohllllOr oorooq 10 rlol/vor Iho orlulnnl 11111 01 qlllll or 1111 111111 10 MY 1I00r om, fIloI1l/llhofllo, Irollor or V~IIIOIII Irlll/ncl In 1111 f1l1rllnl PIIYll1onllllono \'Iilh Ihll Ilol/vory 01 11111 qolrl PHlpllrly 10 <1l1l1ll1r'q prollllllO~, IInlt rlollll \'I",rlllll Ihol olloh ~or, mop l~hol11a, Iroi/or or vo/llolo 10 Po hl~ prOno11y, Iroll IIn<1 oloor 01 1111 lIanll onrlll11011l111lrol1000 OXooPI 00 olhofWlllo noloct on 1110 Inoo 01 Ihlo In~Irllmonl, Purohoq,lIr 1V0rr0I1I11 Ihol oil hlo loXoo 01 ovary, klnrllov/II<1l1olllnollho IIOllcl, volllnlo or l11ollllohol11o Irorloel In hOVII Iloon,'l/llY plllrl, fihoulrl ol1yaoVornl11l1nl ooonoy loVV or olnlm 0 lox lion or elofllnncl on or 01111, Inlll OllOh UDol/ VOhlolo, Sollor 1I10y, 01 hlQ apI/Oil PllY Iho 10mol oncl PUro/lolor ooraoq 10 rllll11PurQo Ihll omol/nllhoroollmmolllololy upon ,Iomonrf, or, Sollor 1I10y, 01 11 0 opllon o,IeI olloh ,', " Iimollf11 10 Iho Qoloo oonlrool oovorlna Iho 1I101l1l0110mo orr/orocl horoln \'Il1h Iflo qamO olloo! 00 1I101l0h orlolnolly InoluQoQ Ihoroln, . I" ~,lIlhll II10rl proporly Irllrlorlln II rOOllllorll,<1 or lIaanoo,ct In IIny PIIIO, 0 ollw IIl11n Iho alolo In whloh Ihlo orrlor 10\'lrllllln, Pl/ro'lI~qOr.. . ", oa(oao Ip Immllrllalllly 000\110 rOlllolrollon lor 1\loh vol1loll1 onr/lo Poy ony onQ 011 uxponqOO oncj roololrollon 1000 Inp cjul1lollhorl/lp, ""'ShPlllf1SlIl/or OOq\II11I1, or PO rl~ Ip, ony OXPol1qn In oonn/1(lllon \'Il1h ouoh roollllrollon, PlIrO/llll1or Will poy Sol/or Ihll omOllnt Il1oroo, on '," clol11oncl or SlIlIor fIloy'o<1dl 0 hlq opllon, Iho 1I0fllll 10 11111 ooncllllonol 001011 oonlrAol oOVllrlnUII111 mobl/ohofllo or<1orOQ /l\Iroln IV/lh ifill ':0\':' oomo ollaol 00 Iholloh prlolnlll/y Inolll<1o<1ll1oroln, !.. ., ':.l{,i~" , ;:.4,' If IhCJ 1110,1/ Irollor or fIlOIll/o, hpmo 10 nol clallvororj tp Iho cloolor ollhp Ilrno M orlolnol oppmlool, oncl ", lolor, ~n 110 elOI/VOIY,1I ;'\-.,:oPPOllrO 10 Iho cfoolor Ihoro Imvo hoon motorllll ohonaol m",Io In Iho 'urnlllhlnllu or QOollu,orloq Ihorool, pr In 110 oonorolC/pncllllon. 110 ,\', " SPlllot, Il1oll.l,I\on hqVp ,I~~, rlllhl 10 mako 0 roopprollol, TIIII lolor Ilflpruloal Vohro 1VIIIII10n clolol111lno lito ollowunoo 10 ho mocfe 'or ellol1 I.', ff,~i/ trollorim9b.IlQ(lP.I,I1u, or pIller vehlolll, . ' . , ' ,; to,'TI) ~'mqllll'ool.urer hnll Iho rlohllo mako ony ohanoea In Iho 1I10dol, ar tho do%no or ony uooollOorlol unrl purtl 01 any II/hao. :! ~ I~nt: ~rilV )f,IIIlr..f9.r,:mPhI/OhOmOI ot any limo, \'IlIholll Proullnll on olll/aol/on on 1110 ROil 01 0lll10r tha <1oAlllr or Iho monll'oolurer. 10 !'-' rnkP"OQrrolpqp~lna ,o.h""oou In t III trollor or !nopllohomll cjlllorlbo<1 anI/ oovoro<1 lIy Ihlo orclor ollhor \Ioforo, or ollbooqllonl 10, <<ollvory 1'\' " Qlloh eqlllpmont 10 Iho pllrohAoor, , ..t;(.J'"I'!, 'j" , 6, POlllor:oh~II not Po IIAhlq for cloleyo OOllllOcl lIy Iho II1AnllluoHlror, oooldonlB, Olrlkllo, llroo or Ilny olhor OBUIIO hoyonrl hlq oon. ~\,WtrQ, ' I ,.i, ,',,:,?, (fj-;!!.',' .,:,; , , .'}.. ",7 WARIJANTIIlSI THIl PflAl.llR SHAl.l. ClIVIl TO Tt111IlUVIlR COPIllS OF ANV ANP AI.I. W/lITTllN WARRANTlllS oaV. ~""~IlR'NClI"THIl'UNfT'DllaC",llflP IN THIS MRaaMIlNT AND AI.I.SIlPARATfll.V WMAANTllP'APPLfANoaa ANlrOOMf'O, " I 'NIlNTS,"WHlOH WARRANTIIlS Mil HIlRIlIlV ASSIQNIlP TO THe IlUVIlR, axcllPT TO THa 'llxraNT PROtlllllTllD UNPI3R :~," Ii, TAT,Il CA, W, THIl PflAl.IlR MAKIl8 NO WARRANT,' a~ flXPRIlSS OR IMPI.IIlD, ANo L W/Tf1bllT I.IMITATI,a INd'llSOl.AIMS Tt113 '~IIMPl.'~P~ARRANTIIlS OF MaRoHANTAIlIl./TV AND I'ITNIlSB fOR A PARTIOUl.AR I'URPOSll. ,.. ,'. ", " : . "",),~!;\, "',:1';""" '\',<. " '. ' , '" ,," " I 1"'~lh'"\",,,' "', r/lo PllroblWlltul1hor roproaQIlILlUUlllLftlllll11llUlli.UIIUUJldLlUllllld.1flunlllLtulloblo lor IJILJUu:!lllUlar l1aod,. ' ,<, :I:'W ;;', ^ '. .',' 'I.' l1u1llLJLaI ~ooepl.blo oqulfl\l!..anltJllllhlLdlrilll1ll.lUJ.bI, own ludot~~, " . ) iI;-r' { i' \II ", '0, (8) If Iho <1ollvory of Ihe mohlle IInlt 10 lnolllclocf In lho pllrohlloo prloo, or II Iho doolor qlloloa' 1\ ohorao lohlol!v.ory Jo.lfro 011., ",';, 10mo~1 doollnal/on, hOlhl/HI ooreomonl to 1(I~nBport 001\1 un II, 00 woll AO Iho prloo qllollll/on modo,la baoocl IIpOh"il\lllomer'l OUllr., t ': "onoo IhAllrovoll1I olpna oooolltoblo AII,woulhor ollr/aooel roado, hilly oplln ond OOooll!jble, Irom ppl", 01 orlllln to point 01 clellvory, rlllr. ,i,(.~ Ing tho pllrlorl roq, IIlrod,lor IrAnuporlAl/on, Pllroho, oor aOOllmOI oil rOllponllplllly lor Iho propor proporal/on 0' hlo proporly la, both reo.lvo l'\''''''Anrllooulo,ll)e;oold.l11pbllo ~nll"ln ovonl of I~odlmonl, nol provlpuoly dlllolooocl 10 Ih.I.,doolor, reqlllro. ,of oxtro lubor Bi1<1 oqlllpmenl, I.. "iI he ollltomor 1J0re.W~III\ Qor08B 10 PAY 'or oil olloh oddltlonol ooot. onrl to holl/sollor 'roo IromllobllllY for domoooo roulllllng Irom Iho lilt! l~ttrol;BlIIrl\job,cir,ofilh.i . ~BiP' olllro eqlllpment, (p) Poalar doos not glluruntoo proflor plaoo,"onl IInlllua a oql1orolo plor, (IInnlng bololV Ih. , ,!/.11t froll IIne, 'hril'/IIIII'P,o n'proporocf, Ollolomor oarool ta,puy lor All lobar ul1d malorlol ooola to r"oot tho mobllehomo whon IlllUOorl hy , ., MlIre re'oolllng or olnklna orlulng from fulluro loprovldo an opprovocf (olln<1ollon, SO\'lor rl'lll~1 bo stUbbocf OUI 0' oround, \Vulor IInll '; ',"~ muol bo',loPP.llr1"un'cI, III~olllo llno oonnooted to molor 11010 wllh propor rooopluolo wllhln 20 1001 01 Iho 0/00"10 pnx Inoldo 01 hotne, '/",;"'Unlol8 olholWfue provlcllrl /In tho IAoo 0' Ihlo PlIrohaoo ordor, Iho IInll dOllor/borl horolnlB oolcl I,o,p, cloalor'slol, " , , '~\:\I~\~:+~,\~"P,O.~lq~!M'l1 pllrmillocl 10 moko plllrnblna or oloolrlool oonl1oollo/1u, or oonnoollna 0' oortAln Mlllral gall or propono appllAnn08 .. ,.,\tI1.., ""'.'1 1",1. "",on". ."'. · ..",.. """"" " """"" " ., "" s,..,,, "'.'" """,.""" "W' .""po ""'" '~''lolna,'8100frlOurllr'00nol'lIcllon ohonaoa Aro !1Ollho'rosflonolbll/lY of Iho doalor or mAnu/oolllror, Ooulor 10 nOI rOlpOnllbl1l for obllllnlng ';~":ii'ho,ollh:d!.'o~nll,l\,'qn:p,ormllu" nor lor /0001, COllnly or olulo porrnllq Involvlno rOlltlollvo zoning, OOlt 9f ohonaoa noodllrllor cornpllanco i.",' /11411 bo horno liy Iho,pllrchuoflr,. ". . '."..; ,~. la, 1l,lo,lIndorq!!lo~,lhAt Pllrohnaor II nol oovororl by Inlllronoll IInlll Mooptod by InollrAnoll bompony, ahrl puraholor ogro.. to" ' ,holrl Soller,horr:nlol~,Irqm eny anI/ oil ololl11ll rluo 10 Iou or rlarnogo prior 10 Aoooplonoo ollnslIranoo COverage hy Insuranao Oompony, 1'-" '.., 11, NOlloe of wlcllh IImllol/onl/ Tho pllrohnaor oolmowlodaol bolno Inlormod 01 tho lonolh anrl wldlh IImltot/oni, 00 01 tho dati 01 '. ;.\\:,thll Inslrllfllont, nOW)n .IClce In Iho laVelal 1I1010BI or Iho Provlnooll 01 Oonlldo, 01 Ihay may apply 10 Iho moVOfnOnt of mobllohotnu . 1 . . "" rh. ,"hi, '.Ohw.,., "" 'h. ''"'rh.' '"," ....."'or "",, " ., ,...., b. mod. ..." .,..,., '''''''' rho ..'" ..,.. "rh, "","" ,Provlnoeo of Oanadu"moy nol ~rant IlIoh pormlll \'Ihllro 1110 ,'zlI OXoood, Iho Ilollllory mt.lClmllm, onrl dooi haroby reloalll thll ..lrI rluler herool/ tho mOl1l1loolllrer and lholr ol8lgl1ll Irorn any onc/ all domonc/o, slIlIa or OOlll11or ololml, buood on tho ilzo at Iho Wllhln '. "'I"mobllal1ofllo, I It Oxoooda Iho 1I1111101l0no \'Ihloh ora 110W, or may laler bo, hTlJlollod by any ulolo or pro\lll1oo, , " . ' !. · 12, THIS AOAlUIMIlNT t10NTAINS THllllNTlRfl AOnllflMIlNT OF TIlIl PARTlllll ANa BlJPllnBllbaB Al.l. /IRIan AND caNTIlMPOnANllaus wnrrrllN AND O"^L AIlnllllMIlNTB, IlNDnnIlTANOINQ~ AND NIlQaTI^TIONB, ALl. ap WHICH Anll ,,>\MIlAQIlD INTo THill MRllllMIlNT, TWl SllLLan IMs MADa NO nlll'RlllIllNTATrONIl an WAARANTlIlS NOT lllCPAIUlllLV ' ' liST /'ORTH IN THIll AaRllllMllNT. , , , ~,~;~;. III .. .....,.'." ," 'Iln/['Qr-M~ T!ill~a ANIl nONlltnPNli I...... (~k" ....., " " '" "1 '_, .... , :~ I ,.":"i,.,;.,l!,.\..'i'Nw\m~~WJ.l;W:!.''1M;';~'';';;J,:i;':~'''~i~,\i;\'~'i\\l~-_l~:i',(;;,ll.h;'\'i.;;'ji;iir\;,;::;.~\,:;::.. i .' . CQUNTHV ~'DQ VIJ..J,AGQ HOM~S, INC, '; ..,....,...""'""..,,,,, ;:!Q;:ltl hlncQln Wa.y f3alll Ol1amperllPuro, flA 17291 (717) ;:!6N!?'77 " .~~~\ll.l'\U;/.lif.tf~~~1\1~U~I:iUIJ~l\T\I\\ll'l&)}~a_.I1~II;~tl~;'Uil':ll~\~r\\r~ii~>iI'.l~m';;.. TOlb('.l..V',,'l-il, "("l)<.c....1\V\, rf\ ~k'e~ ' ~V' )...n..>~'{l : ~'t..~\.l\.\..\'\t r ~t..... . =+'~'P.C:lsa.\ 5:c c:.,:c.o..w\ 'S ~~i. ~ ,....& ~ "-,,~ ..~, '~.v\;,'.li.:,~ '\\\~I"':~~ S ;J _ C\, 1"\ ~ 'T 'f.!.'m ~:c o.."''l\-'~.k~ L\\L:~ \::) , ,..j=.I\l.\~:b "'\) \\<:,""'''' , _ . J L ' NO, PArr. ..R()c~. 9 (p ". NAMt: S' C>....V', ~ I\PPAt:sS oS ~~'\'.. flItONI1" ~ '7 (p - 3\.B~ . St:AIA~1I MOPI1~ II~ CJ d /....:Q \A.,\: eJ", SI1TPATI1 J6ru - C:lC_ SD,oC -, riJ._'7D', CI 0 Z.J..fSo'Da_ ) ~cS', D Cl \ !iJ ...... - , ....,C(), C:>C 11' 0 a (;; c,C')~ \<t'>n-.'t.... ' .. iPio, C~ , . -:- tj b.",u.",~ -rotll,.\ 9-' 'ire I Gc _ ::A "'>1~"8- ~.. ~".,; \, A r, G ""'~ ."'<: R\.p.~) . ~\c, S:,<",,~~\.~ "",8- S"\1~~ ~~~:" .Ea.:.r.:x:i~! ~ - - - - , EHII/blt ~,~- RIlQUl!STao BV :- '- WHITl!Jol/lce Fila 11011 ~" OANARV/ManuflciO,.", Copy QI\IW Mp~~ll!l nncl nOMNN Mp~IUI~, IN 'J'IIIU aOIllW' Pli' COMMON OP PT~mMl allMPIUHLI\NP OOUN~V PIUNNaVLVI\Nll\ " Plldn1:.t f f~~, y, NO. 9U-3Ci33 aOIlN~RV aIPm VILLI\QIU 1I0Ml!lI3, ma, POfllndtm1: , CIVIL I\C~ION - LI\W nNl3WJCH '1'0 NIQW MNJlIJllm /\NP OOUN'J'IiJHOld\lM I\NP NOW, Q~~y MpKee And HOHnnl1 McKoo, ~y And th~o"9h ~.tmothy ~, !!lngler, !!l13'lIl.lr.e nncl HOUlN130N &. Glml\T,po, nn!3WOI'I3 PofpndAn1:!3 now mt\\:1:o~ nnd pO\lntCl~Plnim n!3 follPW131 I\Nl3wmH ~Q NmW MI\~~mH .lU, ~he Aye~ments 130t fc~th ill PA~ngrAph!3 1 through 17 of the Plaintiffa' Amended complaint A~O hereby inco~porAted by reference AS though fully l3et forth herein. 19, PA~agraph 19 i13 a legAl conclusion for which no Anawer is requirecl. ~O. ParagrAPh 20 is A legAl conclusion for which no An!3wer is reqt\lred. 21, pa~AgrAph 21 ia A legAl conclusion fol' which no Anl3wer il3 reqt\ired, 22. Ptll'l.\grAph 22 is ndmitted, I 23. PA~rgrAPh 23 ia denied. I3triat proof; thereof 113 demAnded. 24. Paragraph 24 ia admitte~ In part And denied in PIIl:t , It .ls admitted the home 13 .l.t 13 on thirty five piers plAced oyer a concrete ~ll~h, II:.\.I:I qen~,efl \:ho t1lAIJ .1.11 \:h.l.okoneq /II: t:lw 1001\1:lonl'l of l:lw ple~l:I, I:Itriot proof theroof III qomanqeq, ~a, P4rl\grAph 2a il:l Aqmlttaq, 26, Pl\rl1g~Aph 26 1f.1 c1en10(1, fil:l~.I,oj: propf l:horeoj~ .~I'l r.\.em'\nc\!;Jq, ~7, PA1:/lgraph 27 .1.1:1 clen1eq, fi\:r.Jot prooj~ j:horoof .I.a dellll\ncloq, 20, PArAgrAPh 20 .1.1:1 qen.l.oq, fitrlot proof thereof 11:1 demAnqeq, ~p, PI~l:AgrA~)11 29 .l.s qen.l.ocl, S1:r.Jat proof 1:heroof.l.o qenlAncloq, ~O, Pl\rt\grAph ~O ~,I:I Aclm.l.j:\:ocl .I.n pArj: /lncl ctonloq In PArj:, II: .tl'l Admlt1:od the oraoks In tha mortAr jo.l.ntH were rOPAlreq, It 11:1 qenled the O~Aokl:l returnoq Aa A rOl:lult of the 1\1legecj fAl1uro to 1nl:l1:1111 g"ttera And cjo~napRuta, Strlot proof thereof 11:1 demAnded, 31, Pl\rAgrAph 31 ls denieq, It 11'1 denied the DefendAnt offered to repa1r'the orAaHa, To the oontrary the Defendant orlginAl1y offereq to f.1\1pply th~ PlAint.l.ffs wlth the materiala to repAir the )1 , 'I ) f ~\ I, arAoJtl'l, 3,2 I PAragraph 32 ia a(lm1 tt:ed In PAt't And denloq in part I PIAintlffa Agreed to PAY for addlt10nAl fll1, The Defendanta agreed to lnata11 anq grade t:he fJ.J.l; It la Admitteq thAt $704,00 Waf;!" P1Aoeql11 the eaorow aooount of Roblnaon & Goraldo," '33, Paragraph 33 11'1 admltted in part and denled 1n part, The DefendAnt did not deliver the top aol1qunlity f111 thAt had been agreed upon, The fl11 that WAS del1vered oOl1talned B large proporj:.I.on of. rooks, '1'118 PlalntJ.ff13 have refUsed to release the aum Ill", of $704,00 beaa\lae the Defendant dId not deliver the qUallty of flll 'IJt~ thnt had been ngreed upon by the partiea, If ~ ( )':. 1\ ' I' , \ I{' 34, !lIH'Agrl\ph 34 .1 a I\rlmll:\:ael, 35, PArAgrAph 35 111 r~oniat\ , S\:rlo\; pl:pol: \:hOI:oof ,Iii rlOlllAnejarj, ,16, PAI:A91:Aph 36 ,Is rlan10/j, fJl:r,t.p\: proof \:I1Ol:eo f. Is t\amA nr.\pll , 37. PArAGrAph 37 la cjunjarl, IH;d,ol: proal: \;11131:013 e la rlolHAnelat\ , 31l, PI\l:AgrAph 30 1.a rlan! act, I\NfJWlm '1'0 NI~W MI\"l"I'I~R ANI) OOIJN'J'IUHC1,l\lM 39" PArAgrAphs 10 through 30 Aro haro~y lnOorporAtot\ ~y raferonoe Aa though fully set forth herall1, 40, PArAgrAPh 40 is A legAl oonclus10n for which no Anawer ls r.aqu.l1:od, ',\'0 t:he Ol\tent nn Answer lar.oqu.t.recl, .t\: .j.s clenlecl', 41, PArAgraph 41 ia a lagal conclusion for whiol1 no anaWar is. raquirocl. To tha Ol\tont An Answer is rOCjulrad, 1t is daniod, \'Itllml!JrORE), 1'laint.lffs Onry Mol(oe and HOIlAnn MOI<e,e rOl1peotfQlly request this HonorA~la Court to enter jUdgment ill their fAyor And AgAil1St Defendant Oountry Side Village Homes, Ino, nes~eotfully submittedi ROllINSON & OI!JR/\l,DO n ~~-;< Il'lmot IY r;-En ler, m Cju re ROllINSON & arnl/\wDo /\ttorney I.D, # 704 0 4407 North Front Street 1',0, DOli 5320 Harrisburg, P/\ 17110 (717) 232~0525 /\ttorneY for PlAintiffS " " , ;, \" , I" / 'I, I N u Iii ,!Q !i I :E & 0 ,I, d 0 :S ~ ~ 'f '" .P. ~ /# ., IS d' d " 'II I.~ I, ., (J "l!j' ~, . II! I'lh " o 1 1\ I l' ,- I' kiN ~ ' 'I !\' M ,'1 ~I I Ii l' (, , ,tn,.' ~; g 'd~ '~i ,~~. - ,~, Q >, ~;; n~,. i! i; E,: hlf! , ~ ~ f! '~Ai " t! Ii "~I'; ~l .1 ,I ~ , 1\. o. "'1 (.) : ,g IJII IN IU /!i ; r .' Bo IM/fri' II() B r~IDm i ;: L)'''II\1 III ~, i;; 1'1'!~~ ,/, Id .~. oU !!! h ~ '''' ;?: iii' U) (Al,-j o (' ~.: (.,!::: If),~ : Ki hi ~ .:i- I n. (= III 'r.:; uhB o b :; n. rr. 2'/il ,~ 'f:: f.1'ni , 'I ~: ',/.-/ a c-. a ,,, ,~ t<( J fl. ,J ; l.j 01 , OJ QJ '0 t~ l.j f'1 0", Ai rlll1J ,_ l.j ''0 QI N .!:I ,c ;<8 15 l.j ,... c: 01 ,q ,-. " ,..1 H w rot, fT1(~ L_ ..J B >> Ii 1- ,", ,'1".\<.. il,..".> , .\1. 1/ ,'.) 1r', " ,d '!, ,1" " , ,If.~ ", ' ,;' J I l'ltl,1 . tf'~;'";, '~,j 'il! ~m: ',r '!' I' , ','I '1'*0 I \fj':,. ).':" ~jl~,. ~ \" I~ l' " I ';"" 1\. l, , ~'j~I.,4 ~'-. '''', _ Y, ~.. f ~I \t, "J t , '~i\ ,~,. ~, ; ~ 1 ' "'.j , <1,1\.. , < :11, .." ,1'1 " ; j~ . .-~ i ( l': 1,_" tl~ I( , .)~"'" J ' ~, , "I' ''''w' 'I I ,.~; , , ,~ .:." I '; >," " .'/ " v .. .~~'" ((f$.: '".It' ,"'" " \ "\' ,; ~f " .., ./ \,l"" " '0 ',,,1 ':\ 'I' "'~i~~"i, '" ~il" I,! l ,,; ~ ' j I ' ' !" i,' i}' ~ '~r '.' - " .... v ,G!'1 .1" ,I. I ',I, I. ~'.. I .' (""', ' ,;1 ! .I: 'J 'I '\ .1'" IN '1'111\ muwl' of COMMON PLIW, OF ctJfv1l\liHI,ANP COUNTY, PHNNHYf.vi\NIA CIVIL i\C'!'ION, LAW OAIW Mol<Hli IInd f{(}XANN MoKHl\, Plnh1\If'lil \" I No, !]fl.;Hi33 CIVil, COUNTIW HlI)\\ VILINIl\ IfOMl\H, INC, pol'ondlll1t NP'I'ICI'l1'.{) I'LI~^I! '1'01 sootl W, Po\1hlll1n, HIII\nll'o RohhlHlll1 &- qOl'nldo "407 North Front Stroul 1',0, Box 5320 HllrrlHhmg, "A 17110 YO\l III'C horohy no\ll1o\\ to 1110 II wrlttcn rOHpol1H\l 10 \hc Cl1010HOd ,Now MolloI' 11l1d Coul1torolllhn wlthll1 twol1ty (20) dll)'H or tho dlltc or HUI'\'loollOrCOr or n.!udgl1lOl1l111lly ho cl1tol'o\1 IIgllll1HI you, ' GlIlBHL, KRA YIllLL & HESH DIIlodl ,fuly 31, 199fl I' I' 4 I I\nH\ Ol'lll1go Stroot LlII10l1Htol', I'A t 7602 (717) 29 I. t 700 Hup, Cl Atty, I.D, 1144233 .' r' ,', I, .)'i.1 "',' \lll')YK"II!\\I\KI~M pllrl of' \ho CIIHlollWI' Pullwr)' IIlH\I'II~\hlll FOI'Ill (IIxhlbll"A" Iwrolo) whlllh WllS pl\l't of' Iho llBl'lllll11llllls \1olwulll1 IIw pllrllOH, 7, POIlI~d, PllllnllfTs hnvu f\11I~d to PIlY $l.OOO,O() of' lIw 11\1\ll1dnll\ln CIlllNlnl\lllon AIlI'Ollllllln\, hnvu lillllld 10 I'ulllll O\ll'lllln 1\II\\ls Ihll11 IlH~1'\lW nN slnlod mol'O 1\111)' 111 Now Mnltol' 1\1\\1 hllVo Ihllll<l to II1Hlnllll\lllul'H nnd <lowI1HllO\lts Ils nlll'O\l<l, fl, Admlltotlln plll'l I1ml dOlllcllln pm\. Pulundnn\ ndllllts 1I1l11 Plnll1lllTs hnvu pllld tho slll11H stnlcd In plll'nlll'llph II of lho COlllpllllll1 hIlt dOll Ius 1I1l1t Ihosu pllyl1llllltH SIIIIHI)' thuh' oblllllltlolls to Polulldlllll llI\\lul' lho 1I1l1'0UlllUllls, 011 thc ~olltrll\')', PlnllllllTs owo 1111 ll<lllllhll\l11 $1,000,00 Illldol' Ihu FO\llldlltloll Constl'nullon Alll'con\Cnt, $7fl4,(l(J Illlllul' 1111 OHOI'O\V nlll'oCIllClll IIlld Plllhlllfl:~ mllHt \I1HlllllllllltCI'S IIl1d dOWIlHpmlls onlhoh' homc to pl'ovulll 1\Il'Ihul' ol'lIoklllg III lllu ~OIlOl'oto mllsonl')' 111111 ("ClMlJl) O\ll'IIIIIl WlIlIH, 9. ^dllllttud 1\1111 olloh of'lho suvul'IIlllgl'oomollts ol1tcl'cd Illto holwoclllho plll'tloH cIIlIs Ihl' pOl'fOl'lllllllOO hy holh PIIl't1UH thol'ulo, ^<ldltlolllllly, IIH Hot Ihrlh 1\\01'0 I\llly IIlldcl' Ncw MllttOl', PllllntllTN 1I1ll'00d to hllvu gllllul's IInd 1I0wnHpOllts Il1slllllod 011 lholl' hOl\\o hilI fllllod 1I1l1l l'ol\lHod to do HI1 thorohy clIlIHlng tho urllckltllllo tho morllll' JolnlH Inlhu CMU 0111'111111 wlIlIH H1I1TOllm1l1l1l tho hllHO of Plnlllllfl\l' homc, 10, DOli lcd, Dl,1f'ondllnl dOlllos 11\11111 hilS fllllod 10 propol'ly oO\llpfoto tho pl'OvlslonH of IIny of tho ngl'oolllonts 1'0lul'l'ed to IIhovo, Oil thueonlrllry, IJolundllnt hilS f\llIy purfbl'l1101lol' hilS heon pl'Ohlhllod lI'olll doing HOllS lho rOHll1t of Pllllntlfl:~' Inlcrlul'ol1oo IIH Nof forth IllOI'O I\iIly In Now MlIttcI" " 2 .. 1'71'Nili,III\IIIIII(,1 , I I, P~IlI\lI\. Pof'Olldlllll dlllllus 11\1\1 II hils whol!>' Ilogloclod 10 do or plll'lhl'ln 1l01'11IIn Ihlnlls whlllh WUI'O Illipl'ossl)' 01' \1)' I1CCOHHIII')' h1lpII1l1llloll 1'011\111'1111 to bo dono IIll1l pOI'lhl'l1w11 plll'Hlllll1t 10 lIW IIboyo 1'01'ol'cllucII IIIlI'CCIl1Ullls hwllldlnll Il1stlllllltlon 11f' thc oOIWl'ulo slllb lit 01' boll1w l\llll1d\lstl')' noccplcd doplh, Insllllllltll1l1l1f' Ihotcl's slll'liolcl1llo Hl1ppOrl lho homo, nllowlnll I\w UOnCI'Ilto to mlclJlllllol)' OI\I'U bulill'll plllolllll tho homo olllhoool1cl'olo slllh or pl'opul'ly Ill'l\dhig 111'01\11<1 tho hl11\1o, on tho 1l01111'1I1')', Dol'oI\l11l111 fillly pOl'lhnnod or \VIIS PI'OVOl1lod 1\'0\11 dolnll HO liS i\ I'cslllt I1ftllll Intol'l'ol'onoc of' PllIll1tll'f's liS sot lhl'lh 1\101'0 I\llIy III Ncw Mllttol', 12, DOllllld, Dol'ondlllll donluH lhlll It hllH Illll'lhl'l11c<l In II pI10l', Il11pl'opol' 111' . IIIIWol'l(l11l1nllko I11l1ttUI' oOl'lnl1l olhcI' thll111S whloh WOI'O olipn1ssl)' 111' b)' I1cCOHSIIl')' hnpllontlon I'oqllll'cd by nllY of' thc nhl1Yo I'ol'ol'ollood 1I11I'U0I11CntH 1110hlllll11l tho 11\1\111101' In whloh tho h01110 WIIH 10Clllod, tho 111I1I1I1UI' 111 whloh thu CtvlU cmlnln \Vnll wns hlHlnllc<I, Ihc 11111I11101' 111 whloh 1110 001101'0to slllh WIIH Il1slllllod 01' lho lovcllllll 01' tho h01110, 011 thu 0011t1'll1')', ()olol1dlll1t filII)' pUI'f'onno<l111' WIIH pl'ovol1lcd 1\'0111 doing HI1I1H II 1'0H\llt of thc Il1tol'I'ol'OIlCO or PllIll1tll'lilllN Hol rOl'th 11101'0 1\111)' In Now Mnttol', 13,. Dol'olldlll1t IIdmltH thllt II I'opnll'o<l tlw Ol'lIOKs 1111 01' IIhOlI\ tho dlllo Hllltod IIl1dlhllt . IIddlllollll\ Ol'llCKS nppclIl'cd lit SO\11U Intol' dnto ns tho 1'0sIIIt of Plnllltlflil' flllllll'o to hlHlnfl tho Illlttel's IIl1d dl1wl1SPOllls which tho)' IIlll'cod to hlHlnll to pl'cvol1t 1'11111 wntol' Ih1111 I'\1l1nll1ll 01'1' of PllllntlrrH' 1'001' nl1d HOllk1111l tho CMU ol\l'lnll1 \VnllH SIII'l'OIlI1<1ll1g tho bllRO of P\lIlntlrfH' h01\1o, 14, ^dmlttod In (Jnl'l IIn<l dOl1lod 111 pnl't, Dol'on<lnl11 I\llmlts thnt II hnH pmvldcd , . lI<1dlllol1l1\ l1f1nl1d lop soli 111'0\111<1 I'llllntll'lil' h0ll10 nl1d Ill'll<lc<l NlIll1U 11III'NIIlII1t to nil nlll'CCII\Cnt with PIlIllltlrt:~ In \Vhloh Plnll1tlflillllll'ood thnt Dul'ol1dlll1t would ho pnld nl\ol' Nnld \Vol'k 'VIIR <10110 :1 1172Y9i\I\I",II{I{I'16'1 1'1'\1111 f\IIHIH Plnll1l1f1':i Phlll91lln CHCrnW wllh Plnlnllnii' Cll\lllHCl, 1101\)11'llInl IlcnlllH Ihnt Pllllnllf'fH IHIVlllnullIWlllll1Y HII\\h CxpCnHo, I1I1Wovol', \1ucnllHC 10 IInl1l1 PlnlnlllTH hnVll f'nlluII nnd I'cl\IHcIllo I'ClllnHO Hnllll\IIHIH In CHCl'oW 10 pulomlnnl ,lcHpllc I1clbndllnl'H C(l1llpllllllln of' Hnl" Wlll'k p\lI'H\llInt to lho 1\g\'IlUnlOnt, 15, pcnllld, Pufondnnl Ilcl1lPH thlll II 11IIH filllo" nn" I'OfllHCII 10 I'llpllll' ornllkH In IIw CMlJIl\ll'lllln wIIIIH HIII'l'l1ll1ldlng Ihu hllsc of' P11l1111il'lH' hlll110 In IIml Pofo",lllnl hllH \In Hovornl , ocolIHlonH IlXPI'OHHCllltH wlIlhlglloHH In do HO IIH Hoon IIH Plnlnlll'lH (l0111p11l10 hlHlllllllllon 01' t1w g\ltlel'H IInd doWnHpO\ltH 60 crneklng In the eMU cIII'tllln willi WOllld nol ho I'epelllolllll'tlll' t1w 1'0pllh'H Wlll'e dono, 16, pen led, Pof'U111111nl d0l1106 t1l11t lhc I'OIlHOlHlhlu cOHt of' l'ol11Odylng tho OrnOkH In Iho , . cMu omlll'n WIIIII11I1H01l1'Y Joll1\H If! In OXOOHH 01' $ t S,flOO,OO, 011 tho oontl'lI1'Y, Hllld el'lIokH 01111 " hc IInd wllul,' hllve hccn rcpIIll'ol1 hy f)ofondnnt (hud Iho gUtlOI'H IIl1d dOWIIHpoulH beon II1Hlllllod) fhl' IIPPI'OXII1111loly $500,00, 17, " Penlod llH II leglll oonelllHlon 10 which no l'oHpol1Hlve plomllng IH required, To lho extolll lhllt IIn IIl1H\VCI' IH required, Delbndllllt donleH thlll Pllllntlff'H hllvo hoell dlll11l1glld In nn II1110llnt of III lellHI $IS,flOO,OO IIl1d dClIlI\lHlHHtt'iot proof thereof III It'illl. WHElWFORH, Delol1dlllll Country Hide VIIIIIgo HOIllOH, IlIe, 1'0Hpeotl\llIy l'oqueHt6 Your HOl1ol'lIlilo Coml to'ontel' Judgl110llt III IIH fllvor IInll IIgllltlHI Pllllntln" Onry MoKoo nnd Roxnnn I',' MoKeo with OOHtH,t, ii, 4 "1l'1~~\I\III\Ii!(I'I(d ' J~, A~ IIw I'c~1111 pf' WHlol' ~oHklnlllho pUl'lllWlul' ()M\1 PIII'IIIIIl w"lI~ I1mlllw 1l01l11roto pml b~lwllth dllu 10 Iho UhHOIlOO of llllllllr~ 1I1H\ dPWI1HPO\IIH, 11111\01' IlI'llIlKH l!\lvulopo(1 In IIw 1l\ll1lll'clu plld Hnd HOI11ll of' Iho Illol'lll\' .IplnlH 11\ Iho CMIJ 0111'111111 wHIIH, J(i, Pol'olHlllnt rllpHI I'Il1l Ihu ol'IIckud mol'\lIl' .Ioil1tH III tlw eMlJ 1l\lrlHln wHIIH 011 nno OIlUHHiulI \llll Hlmlllll' Ill'lIu~lnl! 1'0PollUlTOd nH II I'IlHUIt nf' I'lull1l1l'1\1' filU\II'c ul1d 1'01\IHII110 InHlnll UPPl'oPl'illlu 1!11l1cl'~ lIull IlownHpuIIIH. J7. Pol'ondunlllllvlHolll'lIIlulil'l\l thlll tlWHU ornCkH Cllllld bll onHU)' 1'0pulrll(lund WOllld hu I'llpnll'od 11)' DuliJmlllnl n!IlH OXPUIIHC Hncl' PIHlntll'l\i hlHlHllcd thOl!Il1l0l'H Hnl! dOwnHpoIIlH lIH orlglnllll)' 1ll!l'col! to h)' Ihc pllrllllH, JH, Dmll1l! Ootohcl' 01' NOVOmbcl', 1997. I'lnlntlf'f'H cOlltmotcl1 with I)ol'olldllnl to pl'ovldo nlld hlHllilllldditlollllll111 nl1d 1'11I11ltlf'f\l 1II!I'00d to PH;.' lor Rnlno b)' Il0poHltlng tho HlnH of $7R4,OO,ll1to HI1 OHOI'OW HOOOIIIlI with 111011' Hllol'l1o)' Sooll W, 1'0hhnnl1 of' RoblnHon &. Oomldo to bo 1'010llHod to Dol'olldHIlI \IPOIl cOl11plotlnl1 oj' Iho work, J9, Althollgh DOJ'OIll!lIllt dOlll'ol'od IIlld I!rlldod thonllllH nBrood, III dllt\l, PIIIIIlIIf'J'H 11I\Vo fllllod IIlId rol\IHcd to 1'010llHO 10 DoJ'olldlll1l tho UHOl'Owod R\lm of' $7H4,OO P\H'slulnt 10 tho pnrtloB' IIgroolllolll, 40, B)' lollol' to l'iuil1t1J'f\l' oOllnHol dlltod ,lullllllr)' 14, 1998, Dofolldllnl oOIlf1rlHcd tlllll " thu nil IIlId top Roll work hllll booll complotod, 1'0qllOHlcd !hc rclclIHo of Iho CRol'Owcd l\mds nnd romludud PIIIlutif'fH oj' thu Ilcud to hlS!1I1I gllttCI'H IInd dOIVI1HpOlltR, A t,,"o IIl1d OOI'l'col cop)' of!ho . .11111\1111')' 14. 1998 lellul' fi'om Mllhloll ZlmlllonUll11 IH IIl1nohod hul'o!o I1S Exhibit "C"I 7 If " {'r, II " i I I I ii' " ,"I< " " " Il " " 'I, " I" '!>, 1"\ j; I' " , ,Ii "> " H ill Ii " " '! '0 " " /' ;, d I' H ,I' " " q " ,;' H .ii' " Ih; " " ,II " if , , , , ;, " " ,c " " " 'f, " I. " " " " " " " J' (j I' /, " , i! Exhibit 0, " /, <'" " .,,:, 1, , ...".. " " " " , t, '(.' " " ") " " ii' " ',I. " ,- " ;: " , f' II" ,. '; " ,. I,' " " "" Exhibit 0 '- i,' ,- Ii", !' " ,', Ii " " " " " 1\ " Ii ,. " "~I; ,,' I' " ;; , " " " ," Ij " " " " -, I r- Ik .' '\;\, "'1141. I j'" , " .' I171Wi\IIII'\II1I1'I('~ ' CICHTlElPA'I'N ()\I SIlliYlCIC , "I IlliHflflY crmTIFY Ihlll I hllvu thiH ) 1'\ llllY Ill' .Illly, 19911, HOrVlll1 t1111 fnl'ollolnl! llou\ll1\ol1t \lpnn Illu pOI'Honlll1llln lhu 11111111lUI' Il1dllllllu(1 \wlow, .. ~o,'vlllo hy 1ll'HI OhlHH 111111\, IIlldruHH\lIIIlH l'nII<IWHI , ~UI1It W, I'nhhl1l1ll, HHlllllro , I~nhl\lHllll &. Clul'lIll1n 4407 NOl'lh Fronl Hll'ool 1',0, 11l1x ~:l20 IInl'l'luhllrl!, PA 17110 omnlil" KR^ YUILL, &. IlHSS " llyl,.....~.".-~A.~~ N;iliu.:-I~H~IY - ( ^ttOl'lWYH 1'01' Dof'oI\lllll1t 41 EIIHI OI'lIlll!O Stl'oot LlIIlulIHtol" P^ 17602 (717) 29H 700 HllP, CI. Ally. I.D, 1/44233 , fl, ,I "I'" I, 1\ ;,,1' , " I J '\! " ", . , 1";\ r-;-:-. ,....., ,I ,~ I .', '" ,.~' , . ""."""i,.-"..,'.....,....',..',,,,,(,, ,!'""""",, ~~~"r~~"M.~.!....~~.~~~..~4 COl)NTflY!iIPJ: Vll..l..AQJ: tIOMJ:!S, INC, 1!O23 1.lnooln WAY I~AEi\ Ol1nrnpol'lll)\H'OI PA 17go1 ("117) g07-g77'1 Ii .. N~ . TO I Go M '\A~\l, C>li."-.M'fYjJ<, """---- PATi' --'({it J),bfe___ __ ,,____ ~ l_B u.-\j_~LLQ,.~_.___m__..~ N^M!' -~"'Dl.~______...._______. .:-.N '<!...~v, \'\~-}.J~ t>,., ____ ^ppm,Sll ~ f\..Y"'~__.___. .. _ ._ PIIONr: U i~1l~[:!7!LSf_:',,3j..B~__. :p~~a.!io:.\ S~DY:~D-,W~ s._~~G't'-'-'C--~ S!'RI^l.U __~,---,___.______..__~_____ -&~-Y"\~o...\ ~ ~~i.1J.1;\~\~\\\'~I-~'=\901s'.yY~s..)__ MOOr:!. # ~(:):3 .Lj~ \,~}ch,_____. ~ ~m \') <:10 o...;f-~\__b.~&\'<( ~.\).__.:.\'~ 81,1' P^TI, _____..______.___ _r::.'Y-,\.s'\li"\~ \\l':l"")'~ . . ____,___ JOPII ___ Gonc.'('t!.:"'~ S\~\.J.)'~'~..), .2t\S;-\-an- .,~S'\'~-.l.r.roDI::),6C:l - G 0 ~.g /( a l D c.. \s.-==-_ . ...!!.J ',,, 5 D -'..SJ C . -lec\Ji..s.-IDoV~ rJ.."'~oSl.\~?- - -------,,____3..qLl~, Cl 0 0..: ~'(' ~"'~ ~~u;)..:\,:ld;:\~l!L\<",. u.~..~ 8'L\ijl"~ L.i",~~_~ .L1.5c"&9_ 0'" ~cu..", f!-.\"'''''''' Ve.,:o:..\5 ('~J~~.\' j,Jl)or - . ~DG"", (J 0 Lef- l\_tlc..l.c'l"S -_ . ,!i;/.sao,CO , ~x. Ctl...VlJ.:\::\ ~-r--. -. ,1-1' 8'0 a I C) C:\ C> ,~Tn c.:\ ~dc,\ ~nQ~,J:,..t>:b~'C" P Of' fIt~~ ..... . ... ~ 6'01 a Ii) ~ <.::l cJ..."0~'1~_~"'~~~IJ:\<>d\~~~ o' ';;1!..l.s:h "Cj 1-\<:>",,,::.- II 08'0 I a C)-----". 1\#---- , G;.'('{~",~""1'Cl"<\.\"" c:il:ilo I GC) ~f\ \"1"\ )\~~ Err=..\):~'f \(Y,\ls-=t\r~ ClA.s,l..(YI'lY 'fkpl)"~SL\~'.[hP-- =~\"Q~~~~\.9. n 6-.", ~ S ~ ~ \1.b.~_ Q\ ,-' L~\~'I\ l?)l, c.1~;-~ "'------. ". i:=--- ~J c. ~~~=---_. ~...4~~ ~'f~KL - -- RGaUUamD BY - WHITl:IOlllno 1'110 OANAI1YIMonllloc1U/ot'a Oopy f'INI<lOllalofTlOf "110 Copy '''i.,:?,''' , , ....., -,", ---,' . 'f~' I, " ,~ ." , .ef)<<ft(~de , ..' " lOl1f UO~ ~1J.u.lI'l1'{/~;ny+ull ~9~gx OCl4n\:~ aill. Ilqlllllll Pl~J.ll!;l\J.n. II "t:a1!.l! of q\11\~U,t,,1I plIl:IHlnnd OIIlHlb1Q ql: ooqllP\;inl] lllPll!; llr:q~~I\Ill11. hl!;IIr ~P~Ii'JIO~. J.~ QII!;, A ~"rvJ.all.tIlQhniai~ wi1~ l]o ~Aak to ~II IIplllQ !;o OOlll\llAUlI II " Wl\~'" lr:llllgh C.lIIII'* Ullt;~, ^!; thAI: t;illl\1 IIQ will PQr:~oti11 Any ll!"rvJ.Pl\'l:"~~li'1I1t 11M lll.u;141\ l.b1;. o.l! An~ llhq!11:l\IIQll l\O~ llny itall111 ,1:hll\; hll~J.1I no!; aOlllp~lIt;., , !'fa lc:11ow \:l1I1, t; 111I1;8l:', 'I, o~ 'IllPVll 41 '1P~ will, tinll thJ.lJl1l<l t:llll\: 1ll11'1 nQ"eI lIeljU, Q1:ll1l1n\: 01;', t'lIpdli'. !Ill l\Q~ 1:-11111; :fc:n~ .1.J.V. in 1:-I1a 11011111 t'lr: II\: ;l,IIIUIU tWo W.lIlIll lInel IlIAlcll II l.ht a: \:110, "" it8l1l., 1iI1I_ :lI1U:III UP Illlllcll ttl. lilt; pOlllp,hlllh Wl1J.b '1a\l.ll h01l111 1:1 WAI;'r:Qn1:_eI I:c11,' onll ~"ll/ ~\llalc8 tIollD\lt::le t'lIoain Im1v onll t:im.... Illlah 1:IIingQ II' Dl:IICklll\ glll"., ,"C1:'l\\lO, 11." 00\lll1:lU;' top., IIClIi'IlIlPl\.l\ Unollllllll/ Plll1l1J. 1]01191111, tll:"Plll.1' II, 1I11l,'1I, 11\;0, Alill no long. I,' WlU;'rantlltl Itt;lU;' Ollt' 'lI;f.rllt. 1I11".1,C8 od1. !III \:l!1' to .oha!l4111 "pn....IIl.r:II.n~ UJ;V!QII w;l,llJ\in \:we to t:In:._ W-IIlI. 1I.l!!;Ql,' it< ill r:llPOIlIlIll\ 1;0 4B in W1I'il:ing:, . . ~Sl1hno.. llli. W~llnt.ct anc\ 1IlJ;V;l.Clc\ /:1'1 \:II. ClolllpanJ... \11IAt lIlan4hal:llt'lIc\ t:l1111l. .. WAIO"l,'Il,nt,'1 P.PlU;'1 tm.t; '/Qlt IIIlP..1.Vlllt tliOIll 1:11. lIlan4.l!l\oll\l.llllli o.l! '1'lllr: h01ll1l ellIllol;'ibll . · pr,oce~\ll:e. ~PJ: 91ll;tilll1 t:l1.t; I~J.Q.. ~"t:l1a .vanl: \:tU\1l Y'l" hllVll, II (lr:ohblll w.l.\:4 ~Q\II1l;~n9., %,',,(J:iljJ.li"~IlQJ:, ella.. YOII Ilhou~c\ rltslI I:a \:110110, paper,ll. ~~NlS8 OP S~vrcBI !'f. wi~J. m.u;..v!lt"f et~ollt to /.lerv.iCQ YOIIII hol1le l'IIOlllpq~y, Wll,an WI hAVa \:0 Ol;cI,lll;' 11,art. ~I;'ODl,~ 1III1n~l\o,t:,IIt'Jli', J.t 'IIel1er,I\;J.'1 extamh. Ollli' I:IIllpOnSlI l:ilIllI IIncl we hllve no con~QJ. OVlIJ: tlll 1;I.\:\IlIl:ion. lis soon l\/.l PIIl;'llll 111111 I;'QOQ,l.vllcI, wa wUJ, 'oheclIlJ.. ,/0\11;' "ollle. : DE'LIV1m~IlSI; All c\1IJ..l.V~ Ic:ilJaltuJ,es 1It'1 \:ont:l\l:.l.vo. Ul1oon\l:;oJ,J,lIhJ.Q sitUI\\:.!.OnB sUoh liS WSlItI1l1t, equ, ip=.nt,~lIlakt\own, 81:0. 1II11Y cllIJ.AY II eleJ..l.vet"f, lI,new ell\lle will pe ut:. Anc\ Y'lU ,101111 bl in~ot'lllelt. . ~, 1'J.IlIS8 ~Iport an'l IIl.1.sain\T 01;' clillIIAl]QcI J.llenlB to UlI wi.tl\J.n 3 clAYS o~ cI.J..l....IiWO~ '101lt' n01ll1l 110 t:.nAIl 'il Clan J.n:#o.t":ll1:l\a lIlanu:#tl.otllr:llli i~~c\bt:.J.y. '4'h." II , .I. t:IIlIUI .incl.uc\lI 111M llJ\inqs II. Illmtt.lill, llot'.8II~, lito, ' OSVlt wiJ.~ only honor tmoSll .l.UIlILS t.hal: an on '101ll;' 111.1.88 lI<]l;'aQllIont. I'lI'J SlJR! WlI.\!I' ALL COIlm'1'IIEllWS AmJ AGltBll:liEUWS.\IU!: A l'AA'l' or \CoUll l'tmCll.AS2 AG~~Elf'.\'. 1'12 WILl. nOT.. /tenon ollAr. CO,~S. . . mn~ ~t,yOIlt' l1oDl8 b 1:0 be llkillilec1 .ill \lill bit comp1ellact as ''lOn all CSVlI CIa'" "O::!\lIctull .it, W. "1:1.11 g'\Uu:'llnt.. proplll:' J.nst:allllllJ.on but: oannot <]\lu'1\nu811 agAin.t i:Ilprop11I, oan 01;' IIQa.1ns1: WIlIt:l\lll:' ltlllllll1/8 !lllo 1:0 hil/h wind. 'l1:' t:r:'lnu. , D!':t.!V1mY AlID S!:'I'..J. 'l'l18 dllJ..l.Vll.t'Y 1I11t1 nu up at: 'lour. 1181/ lI'lllI8 i.8 i.nc1I1do!l in tho pl;'J.ell ot: Y'l\ll: hOIDIl, D8J..1.V.ry clOllS not ClOVer \U1l1l1u1\l CJ.r:OUIJUIt:l1nCQS. The silll IlIUll!; ce rlllcty ~O~ ua to pill: t:.ne lIolll1 in plAcl\ with 'lilt' tlol!vu'/ t:1Jolc, Thllr:1l U'I Ixtn ,QI1IlI;'Il'IlB .l!01:' IIavine; to r:enf: II bUllltour, ~act:oll, Il~' OliB.l1Q 011 1.: wa "'avlI to I:'I1IlCiVIl \::'UII Cll:' clabdB t~olll t:.h. dill. " OffIce ./ncaln Way E141 ersbUro, M mOl '~"',l)'rr1 , ' " Park O",c, '; '94 RUIUCl OrN. '-'I' iI" ,"'ii~:::i, !, ,'I" ", 1/" "'I ,l,', ' " , " '~ ,! , " , " ,\ II " " " " , <I; " , ,I I" '~ \{' .. " " "H " , '" :1" ;1' " ',I ',' ,n ',1), iI, " , 1(,' " ." ',,I '" i', ,,'.',(0' ,j,' , '" ~,t; I; ',::l: , "" '".ii ,j'!, " " \., ';"" ,"\jl ;1".- r. '.'!" " ,1 . , '~, ,. L I' ~ /' ,', '" " :"(,,, /,'I',J, 'I 'I" :,\:;\.; :, J,;\;/:i ",l,f',!.' ii" " ,II ,,'l 1',:1\ .' ,,' " I' II ",,' Ii " ," " "1 , '/.; j" , ""', " "I I~: I ' ,':' , <' ",/, '" I' , 'I,;: ",'t " "I', :J';" ',::" ," "" .' ',',I] i I. , ~' ".':',t, ':,,'I~' ,.. ','~ i it '";,,,' q,< ",I " "', ," ". '" : ~ I '!; '1,'/1;:'\\:" ",I" ,It,' "I, "1, <, ":'(';'1 , "\' ." , ," t{' -'1",-, ~', f' l, , " "',, ,!.., ''" .1', , :fI, ., j,':,,', ',I., 'J;I'.' " .';,.lI', "'I ; "t'I',' I", "1'.' ,';/, ,"',' ". ;,; 'i, ". '" "I' """ ",\ "",'1 ,', ,'f' I', " ",I, , '~" " " I ", 1\"" '" 1" , ," " "'I', "" " :11, II" ',-' " -,!,/;" ,(,',,";' '''I \1 "I', " " <.,:~?,;j:\';:/, . :1, ,;I',/.' " ' ',' "I ~' ',', " ,; l' ' ,\':'../;, "j '!;,', 'I" -, ~ " ,,' ",' ~ L ',:\\i'" 1-':1,,; ," ':', )"1-,,'" , ',oj '. , , '" ," II, ,;, 'H " " " i ~' " ;, 'I I, (/ , " l~\ C" I , I , I ,,'( . ' , , , , , , " . : ! I , .fl w ~1 ~ I ()! ;;1 , 'I 61 I , I..j U rl~ ,ij f), 1 (J, r~l i' " !'t " " " " " , ' " " II " 1;11 I, " ,Ii " , " " l! , i i' " '" I' ,. "'! " !! i'j ii; I' I, " Ii I' 'I, If " It , I " " "I' )<,!' ,,, It II " " " I' " I,' C3AIW Mol<~~ AND IWXANN Mol<!:;I=,. PI.AINTIFFI3 V, OOlJNTRY 81P~ VI~I.AG~ HOMF.s, INo" : INTHF. OOlJlU OF GOMMON PI.I:AS OF : GlJMI31:lil.ANP OOUNTY, PI=NNSYI.VANIA " PF.FF.NPANT , , : 06.3633 OIVH. TI::RM !N..B!;LMQ,TIQN..Q.E.QI;EJiNPANT FOR ~.M:"mIAI.. RELlsE QflNtmiAtill..9..RDER OF OOIJIU allyloy, J" MlIrllh :.19, 20001"" In tile l!'llter p!'lrt of 1006, pl!'llntlffs, Gmy !'lnd ROXElI1n Mo/<ee, purol1!'lsed E1 four bedroom doublewlde putol1 modelmEllHlfElotllred 110me from defendtlnt, OOlllltry Side . 'it 06.3633 OIVI~ Tf::RM few 1110nlhs flfter Ihey 11l0veq Into Ihelr 110me severe omolllng st~rteq to ~ppe~r In Iho fpllmlflllon sl~p flnq sllpporl plll~rs, ol'l1olllno ~Iao flppamecl In Ihe 1)10011 w~1I flllho~19h Ih~t ooncllllon Is oosmetlo, Gregory I.epo, EI olvll englnaer, lesllfled for plEllntlffs Ihfll Ihere Is dlffel'entl~1 movemenllhrollghout Ihe fOllllclflllon slElI) Ih~t I1fls omlsecl It to fElli, He w~s of Ihe opinion Ihflt the deml IOEld of the home WflS plfloed on lop of the foundfltlOn slE1P pefore the oemenl oUl'ed, flnd thflllhe t;loll underne~th the sl~p Wfls nol oompfloled oorreotly whloh oonlrlplllecllo Il1e fflllllre of the slflp, I-Ie oonoludecl IhElI 1I1e SIE1P no longer flots properlY flEl one str~lotllrfll ~1I11t, l.epo WflS of the opinion 1I1flt the ' dlfferenllfll moval1lent will oontlnue flnd 1I1fltlt poses fllhrefltlo the atruotul'fll Integrity of the 110me, AqequfltelY oorreollng tile pl'oblel1l will reqlllre removing Ihe hOl1le from the foundfltlon E1nd oonstrUOtlng fl new foundfltlon properly dealgneclto ellmlnflte the dlffel'enllfll setllament, Plfllntlffs Inlroduoed evlclenoe thfltlhe oost neoessE1ry to fldeqUfltely remedy the defeots wns $15,900, whlol1lnoludf.ls moving tile home off lhe slE1b, the breflllup of the slflb flnd the wEIll, preparing fl new founclE1l1on bE1se, pouring fl new oonarete slnp flncl support plllnrs, flncl putting the 110me on thE1t SIE1P with E1 new foundE1l1on wall. A 110uslng Inspeotor EIlso lesllfled for plE1lnllffs thE1t, tile oraolllng In the ~!E1b E1l1d tile support pillars poses a threat to tile strlloturE1llntegrlty of the home: , Plalnllff, Gmy Mol<ee, over obJeollon by defendal'),t, tesllfled that he W~a of the opinion . thElI no one WOllld buy his home as long as the fOllndflllon posed a threat to Ita .2. op,:m33 OIVI~ H:RM I' ~ alnjolur~llnleorI\Y,,' On Felmmry g, gooo, fI j(lry enlerecl fI varcllet In fflvor of pl~lnllfrl'l flncl flWflrclacl \1113111 $'15,000, Tl1ay flwmclecl clefenclf1nl $7P4 011 lis oounlel'olflll11 for some mauncl fill Ihfll plfllnllffs hflcl clallvel'ecllo 1111311' properlY sulJsequenllo Il1e oomple\lon of 1118 1101116, Pefencl~nl fllacl <I 111 0\1 on for posHrlfll rellaf, 1\ olflllns 1I1fll pl~lnllffs f~lIa(lto offer any evlclenoe ~s 10 the r8cluotlon of v~I(le of Ihelr 110l11e oauaecl IJY lhe ~lIegecl cleflolencles In Il1e ponorate sl~1.> ancl oemanll.>looll wall, 1\ ~versi Plalnllff ~ltel11pteclto oel mound the Court's ruling on Pl;lfendanl's obJeollon by aslllno Gary Mol<ae wllell1er he bellevecj ~nyone WO(llcl want 10 Inty Il1ehoma In I\s ourrenl oondltlon, The Court permlltecl GalY Mol<ee 10 Elnswer Ihls q(les\lon, flncl Gf.\ry Mol<ee tes\lfled Ihat no one wouldwf.\nl to buy Ihe home InltB ourl'ent oClndltlon, and any buyer WO(lld want tile oonorete sll'1l.> and oement blook wall rapalred before purolll'lslno the home, Pefendelllt averstl1atlhe oourl erred In allowlno IhlB lestlmony, alld even If 1\ was properly Eldmlllecl, there waB Insufflolent evldenoe as a malleI' of law Ela to the I'eduo\lon In any value to the home oaused by \he oonslruotlon deflolenoles such Ihat the Jury ooulcl bEllanoe the possible diminution Vfllue wltl1lhe oost of repairs, Plaintiffs Beall a judgment n,o,v, or In th!,'l alternative, a new trial based on the following e\Vermentsi " ,I, a, Tile jury's verdlotls t:lgalnslthe weight of the evldenoe slnoe I Defendanl presented the testimony of a olvll engineer, Pemlel l-Ionlg,''I-Ie was of Ihe OPinion th~llhe ora oils at plalnllffs' home are normal shrlllllageoraoks and that, there Is no differential movement In the foundation, However on oross-examlnatlon, he E1oknowledged that he oO(lldnot assure plE1lntiffs that thare was no struolural defloienoy In the foundation unless he oOll1pleled a measurement survey, soli analysis and engineerinG analysis that would oost apprOXimately $3,500, none ofwhloh have been done, -3- . 98-3633 OIVI~ T~RM , , I' \1 1'1 I loss III VflllIO 10 11113 InJl/recl pfllty /l1CI/ clflll1flges will /Je lI1easlII'Ocl/W /lIe cl/fferelloe bC3lweell/IICl 1lIf/II(e/ pl10e /lm//lle propal/Y WOllin Imva flacf Willi 011/ /lla dafa(1/s allc/ Ilia IImrl(a/ Plloa of /lIe propal/Y wl/ll /lla defao/s, Althouoh mIlO~llft\lno the nile 111 EI \1l1phtlY different mElnnel', tile Cp~lrt Elolmowle(loecl and fpllowedlhe BElI11I'l prlnolple In Gar/bols V' ~e/J"Oo, (3l1l1clels, IIlO" 312 P<I,SlIpel', 144,468 A,2d 656 (1983), Where Ihe oost of remedylno 1I1e defeols 111 .. oonstl'~lollon Is nol olearlY dlsproportlollElte 10 \1113 proP<lple loss In value to 11113 Injurecl pmty, Il1e l)reaQlllnO oonlr<lolor pannpl req~llre Ih<lltl18 Inj~ll'ed p<lrlY's d<ll11<10es pE/l11easmed PY Ihe dlfferenoe petween Ihe l11arkel prloe of tile property wlll10utthe defepl!! Elncl Ihe prloe of tile property Wllllthe clefeots, (~l11phElsls Eldcled,) .. . The Elppellees did not estElplIsll Wll<1lthe VEllue of their 110\jse wq~llcl have peen hEld Ihe !l~lrfaoe WElter pl'oplel11 not existed, and lIs diminished VEllue peoElU!le of Ihe water pl'oplem, The JlIrY enlered EI verdlol PElsed on Ihe oosl of oorreollno the slluEltlon as IhElI WE1S the only Issue supmlllecl 10 ii, Tile vercllolln the amounl of $45,786,00 represenled Elll11osl48% of Ihe oosl of the hollse Elnd II Is pleftl' In these olroun1BIElnoes thatlhe jury sho~lld hE1ve 11Ad some Ide<l <IS to tile c1lmhulllon of V<llue In ol'elel' to <lvolcl EI wlnelfulllo Ihe appellElnls, The rule sel forth In (Jollglass v' ~Ioolardl OOlls/mo/loll 00" 1110" slIpra, requires 1I1<1tlhe oost pf repairs be ole<1rly c1lsproportlonElle 10 the prob<1ble loss In VEllue before damElges EIre Ihnlled to 11113 loss In VEllue, Therefore, there must pe some evldenoe procluoed . by tile pl<1lnllff of tile reduction In value, Ellll10ugh It need nol be shown wllh eXElolltude, There must be EI bE1lanolng between tile pl'ob<lble ellmlnullon In value, whloh Is often quite nepulous, and tile oost of repE1lrs whloh may be determined with greater aOOur<lOY, However, Ihere musl be some reasona,ple basis for determlnlno reduction In Vf1lue, before EI JUdgment I11E1Y be made that the oost of repEllrs Is a proper measure of d<1l11E1gss, where the required repairs to EI new house represent f.\ high peroentage of the oost of the hOllse, (Footnotes omitted,) In .the oase sub JUdloe, the jury was ohargedthat: (t]lle measure of damElges for a bl'e<lch of contract In oonstl'uotlon of a house oOl1talnlng defeots Is the dlfferenoe between the marl(et value of the house as oonstruoted and whattha marl(et value of that house would have been If oOl1stl'lloted as promised with the quallfloatlon that If It Is reasonably praolloalto OLll'e the def~ots In oonstruotlon by repair and If the oost of repairs Is not olearly disproportionate to the probable loss In value, then the meaSLll'e of dal11ages Is the cost of repairs, , , , -5- 06-3633 OIVII_ TI=RM . 111I1!! tha plQlnllff!!' Illlrden 10 prnduoe Ilome evlelenoe of Ihe redllollon In VEllue oQUGed IlY the ~lllegecf oonslrllo\lon defloll3noles ao IhElt YOU OEln PQIQnoe 11113 pOlllllllle dlmlnullon In Vl'lllle wllh the oost of repl:1lr!!, And In tllElI regQrdmy raoolleo\lon, It's for you to delermlne, .Is IImt plEllnllff laid yoU Ihl1ll/18 oondltlon of this fOlllldElllonf.1l1f~ will'll It Is, IhElt h!3 cioesn'l IlellElve 1111'11 QIWllody WOlllel eVen PIty Ihe hOllse f.1llhls PfJrtloulElr point, Hells Eln owner,..lie OEln offer you \llftt opinion, It lEI for YOlt 10 cielerllllne whelller tllElII!> Ihe OI'lE\e, I'Indmy reoolleollon Is Ihflt elefendElnt find I'll . leQlil one ol\he wltnesseE\ for defendl'lnl ~.11Y tile defandl'lnt , n18l'1n Mr. ,zlmmenmlll peOf.1llse ha Is OOllnlry skle, Ino, -hfls tnld youlhElt they don't feel tllere's Elny cllmlmltlon In the VElllle of the house, In Elny event, thElt Is for YOlllo determine, The testimony presentecl Ell trll'llllY ciefendElnt 1I11'1t there WElEl no cllmlmillon In the Vl'lIue of Ihe hOUE\e WI'IS PI'IEled on Its posltlCln tlll'1t the omolls In the fO\lnclEll/on I'Ind supporlplllms were oosmel/o I'Incl not strlloturl'll defeots IImt pll'loeci Ihe hOUSe In jeopElrdy of oollf.1pslng on Ihe foundEll/on slElp, When the jllry aWElrded pll'llntlffs the enllre $15,000 tllElt their evldenoe IndloElted WI'IS neoeSSElry to remedY Ihe deflolenoles In their home they opvlously f100epted plf1lnllffs' evlcienoe thf1t the deflolenolea went to the struotllrElllntagrlty oftha foundalloil rElther thEIIl being merely 00sl118110 I'IS posited by defendant, PIEllntlffs' evldenoe Wf1S thf11 the dlfferen\ll'll movement In the foundEll/on Of.1n oause the foundEll/on sll'lp to fl'lll whloh would meEln thElt the house whloh Is eleVElted on oonorate blooks oould tilt Elnd Ultimately oould fall onto the slap, PIf.1lnllffs, of oourse, would be obllgl'lted to dlsolose, this problem 10 Elny prospflo\lve purohasers. on these unique faots WI;) believe thaI no testimony as 10 Ihe vEllue of the home WllS neoesl\alY beoause ElG a Inatlerof oomrnon ImoWledge the jury would know thl'lt the home Is 1101 sElleable In Ita Pllrrent defeotlve oondlllon, In any event, we are sal/sfled thElt It WElS -G- PB-~633 cIVil, TFRM proper to Elllow pll'lln\lff to pffer fin opinion tllf1t no onl3 would P\IY IIle 110nW IlI1tlllho IltnloturElI claflolenoy In the foumlfltlon Is oarreotecl. Pel1nllylvanlEl RIlle of Fvlclanoe 70'1 proVlelell1 If tha wltneElB Is not testlfylno l'Ill ElI1 expert; *,10 wltnlll'ls' tostlmony In thll . form of opinions or Inforonllos Is Ilmlto~ to thoso oplnluns or Inforflnlllls whloh IIrll rlltlonlllly b~SfHI pn tho pllrl1optlon of tho wltnosfI fln~ holpful to E1 oleflr ~lIlclerlllE1ndlng of Ihe wltnellll' talltlmony or tho dotormlnl\tlon of II flllltln 11'101111, (Fl11phElIlIIl Eldded,) It III only whare the ooal of oOl11ple\lng the performElnoe or of remeelylno Ihe c1afeots III 1Il0llrly dl!iproportlonl'lle to the proPl'Iple losll In V<1llle to t11(:J InJI~red pmty thElt ell'lmf.1geEl will P13 meElSllreq py l'I diminution In VEllua, Pll'IiI'lt1ffs' home Elnd founell'ltlon o01l1 $50,569, We oonolude thElt PIEllntlffll' testimony WEl\1llllfflolant l'Inel no Elxpl3rl lelllilnony WElIl required for the Jury to oonolucla 1I1ElI E1 $60,569 mElnLlfl'lolllred home with a Iltntoturl'll defeolln Q foundEltlon would not reElllon<1ply be sEllel'lble, ancl tlllls the proper mel'lSure of elamagas wall the $'16,900 oosllo repEllr the defeot, The opinion of plaintiff w<1lll'll<lnlo the opinion of valLIe thElt an owner of property OEln testifY to In El oondemnEltlon prooeedlng alllloll~hln Buoh El O<1se there Is stElt~ltory ElLlthorlty at 26 r.B. Seollon 1.704, For the fore(Jolng reasons, the following order Is enterecl' ORPE 1tQE..Q0!J.BI AND NOW, thlll /2,(-tl.,: day of Maroh, IWOO, the m~tlon of clefendElnt for pOllt- trial relief, IS DENIED, -7~ ". :1:1, !'Jilinl:I !'!' ill:tlll1\ptUrI to rJut ill'()upd tilo COl\ I.' I'. ' 1.1 \'l\'1II1U Oil, l)lll'ulldnnt '0 Db:! Cl(n', \ Oil by ilOldliU CliI ry Mnl\ol.l wilul'.lull' Ill) Ill/l :lovod ni,yollo WOlllr\ I~i\nl: to bl\Y tbIJ lIoll\(J J II Jt:o ourrolll: (Jollc\lt:lol1, 'l'bo CO\ll'I: pOJ:1\l.l\:!:or! C1ilJ:'y Mn\(oo 1:0 illlllWl.l1' tldo Cjuout:ion, illld Ckll.Y Ml11(IJl.l tunl:l 1',1 Dc\ 1'.hl.1l: 110 OliO would WiUI!: to buy t.llU hOll\ll In i!:rJ CIlI\TlJnt oon,lI I:.:lon, ilnd nllY bnyor would Wi1l1t tho COIIOJ:U!:O ulilb nnd OOll\oll!: blooll WClll ropiI:Ln1d bll/:oro plll:chiHII.I\U tbll \!Oll\fJ, 13. 'I'll" only ot:lwl.' !:.oul:llI\ony of'l'Ol:Or.! 01\ \:hl.l'l IJllbjoot WilE! !:lre I:BI:Jl:iIl\OIlY 01' Milhlon 7.:11\\1\\01'1\\<\11, tho ))0 f o IIclil 1\ I; 'IJ ownBr, who toul::I./::locl t',hilt lHl lwei lJold hOll\olJ Idl:h \:il11 f.1i1I\\O typrlfl 01' c1:C1cl<FJ :In t.hB OOnCl:B!:e fJlnb illld oell\enl: block wnllu iHl 1.11 tho 1'1cd.llti fl'IJ I hOll\fJ, ilnd l:h01:o waEl nOI:O(lucl::l.ol\ in villul~ 1IfJIJOC;liltocl wl.til tll0F.10 typo of C11:i\0)W, 111. '1'hfJ COlll.'t ohould nol: have pm:lIIHtocl pIEd.nt:I/'f Oc1ry MoKoo to tOfltl.fy ilEl to whether E1I'lyone WOl\ld want 1:0 buy PlilInt.iffu' homo :l.n :ltu OI\I:1:0nl: concUUon ulnoe he WilfJ not qUill.i.Liod to 0/:1:01' th.1./J' op:LnJ,on, DillY Mol(oe wafl not qL\illlf.i.od as an I.nd.i.viduill with npociall.Rod knowl~r\go in the E!alo of real OfJtate fILloh'thE\t ho was capilble 01' ol'/'ed.ngapy opl.nion mJ to , ' whilt iI reatJOlli1ble buyor would or would nol: do, '1'h.1.EI WilfJ the , I'irot h01l\0 that Dary McKoo hilel OVOI.' pl\rchilBad. 1.5. . gvon I (: .it: Will] propm: 1:01' the COLI):t 1:0 havo adlld.tted th:lLl trmt:lll1ony Into evIdonco,H. ,\~cl/J .i.nlJlIf'I':Lol.ent ElfJ 11 ilia t tOl: of 101W to provo tho allogod roclurJtI.on .i.11 llIil1:l,ot Villllo of tho hOllle. '1'ho ganel;ill rullo1 01: li1w dI/lcLllJOod by thc) COLlrt :In PrefJIn@ oilnnot be flO emdly ilvoided by tho PJaIn\:.iI'l'oill1ply tosU.fying thClt In II hlfl op:l.nlon \'.hu yqll\Ll of l".lIo propol:t..y Iwu huon dlnrllrlnhml by t;I"IO DOHI: 1:0 I.'CIPII:IT \'.110 propol..ty bOUilUllO iI buy!) I.' would l.'oql.!i.I:"\'j thi1l: 1:.110 IH'opr.n:ty bu ropi.dn,el bel'ol'o pllJ:CJllilf.1ln9 t:JIU In'oporl'.y. Il'l".IlIu " wurn thl! lilW, l".IlOl\ tllui:C' i'!oUld noyOI.' bn il uund to Ol'(:llr oVIt!lJl)CO i1U 1:0 I:ho J:od\ICJl:.IOl\ In lI\iu'lIo\: Villllo 01' 1:11Cl proporl"y, 'l'hu PUl1nfJylVilldi.\ COllrtn lFWlJ ll\i.lClo i.lbl.llldi111 l:1 y ol(Ji11: thilt l:hlJJ:c~ II\llut be /1011\0 uVldollou i.IU ton.llluctlol\ In villtlo whloll .i.e.1 In w1dltIon 1:0 oyldol1CH'J il~l 1:0 1:1\1') C10tJt 1:0 ropillr, qne] ullI\ply dJflSll.!i.s:lnU \:ho cout to l:ep.:d.l: q~1 tlw l'l1l1uctloll In lI\i1rl';ot valllB lu Infl\lfl'ld.ont tq meal: tlw Pl<lll1tHfo' bun10n of: pi'ool' ilf] to tho i'111ogml l'ClChwtlon In Y<lhw. " .1 G , PI il lnl: 1 l' t:fJ f ilU. eel 1:0 ml.lD t t hel r bllrckJll 0 I' proof \:,0 oUO!: evlclcJnco l1S 1:0 thoredl.lut:l.on In Vqlt\O C<lIIf.18cl by the qllegocl. oonptn\ct .ion do I' .iciollcJ:i.08 "ll.lOh. tllell: tho j \I1:'y Doulc1 bi;llqlle8 the 'I ' probl1blo cI:lnlll1llt:.i.on. in Yl11.tlo wHh tho DOflt ot: ropi'll.rp. 'l'ho only 1ll\1l1bel' of:t:c)J:ed 1:0 tho :JlIl:Y Wi'lfJ tho cool: of. repid.nl of :~lli, :JOO, 'l'he jury Wl1fJ nol: 91.von <lily m.lI11ber j;or the di.ml.nutl.on in VE\luo to, uso I.n ball1nd.n9 the cost oj' repcd.rfJ agl1J:iwt the d.i.ml.nuUon In valuo, J.7. 1'110 cost: of tho hOl1\o W<lfJ $59,'559, and tho cont: oj' .the li'lnd Wl1S $3~,000, for a toti'll proporty oout of $93,559. Pl<l.int.iEf bary MoKoo teDtif:l.od thi'lt l1ftor the hQll\o Was Instulled, the proporty W118 appri'lIsed at $10~,OOO, Pl<lInI:IEf oJ'for~d no evldonoe il8 ,~b l1ny BubfJoquenl: l1ppr<llsul I:hilt the property wafJ Wor\:hi'lny leflEI than :~J.O(I, 000 iltt:OI.' tho cl:<lOlw wore dl.fJcovoroc!" It would hE\vO been <Ill Oi'lsy 1l1i'lttor fOI.' Plnl.nt:lt:J:a t.o"h<lve ot:t:erod " :J " (lDlldJl:.I Oil, 1d.1\l~(J (j;lly'McKuo WilD 1\01: <1l\il1.1 (' j ud to off'lH' l:hiu Op.ln.illl\/ ill\d, el. ;I'bo tl'.lil,1 naill'\: (JOIIIIII.lU:ud .IUUil.l UITO): inl'il.il.ln<] 1:0 grimt: Ilu fUlldilll\: 'p ilia\: Ion for i\ Clolllpu1noJ.'Y I\on- mdl: 111$1/01' lIIol:.ion I'or i\ d.i rontud vord.i al:, ;W, All 01' thu ~J1:O\.l1ldfl UpOI\ widell ))OfCJI\r]i.\Ilt: :iu IJouldng judgl118nt: notw.it:I1fJl:inlllin~] the vun\.iol:, or .ill l:ltu illtorni'lI'.Jvu, il now tdnl, \~Ol:0 ndf.wd Lit: tho till\B 01' tdil1 in tho f01:'l1\ 01' obj oat :lonu to l:cwt ill\ol\Y, nl\d/Ol: Dotondi1l\l: 'u lIIot iOI\ 1'01: il COlI\p\.\lDOl:Y non- sui tilt tlw oonelL\ldon of: Plidnt it:f'rJ' Ci'lfJO <lnd 1I\0tion f:ol' [\ d:Lroctm\ vOl:dIot [11: tho cloDo of' ,111 tho ev:Lrlence. 11lmRlwolW, tor <Ill tho f:ol'ego.i.n~J rG<I/30Ilf.l, DClfondill1t relJpeott1l11y regl\CliJtEl t hi'l I: tho COllrt 8nter jlldgll\ont notwHbstillldIng tho verdict :In HfJ filvOJ: i'lnd aga.inst Pl[dntHf on the Plaintitfs' olaill\s, or In tho altornatIve, Liward a now tri<ll. ReElpec~fll11y ~llbll\ittod, MaNW8S, WALLACE & NURICK . ).ly:=1~ -,~..,~.:/-L_.).l ~($,.{ . ,/ .ronathan II, Rudd . ( ttorney I.D,No. 56000 / 100 Pine Stl:eot .. /' ,-_./' P, 0, Box 1.16 G llarrifJbllJ:9, PA 1710fJ.l166 ('717) 23'1-5405 (71'1) 237-5300 fax AttorneYfJfor Defondant Dated, FobrllLiry 10, 2000 .; '.1 'I '<'1 'il 1,', r I ,I" i'l I, I, '., 11111 OOUNTIW sIP!'; VII.I.AGF HOM~S, INo" OOUNTRHOI,AIM. PI:r\IN"tWF V. I IN THE CO\mT OF oOMMoN PI-FAS : OF OUMI3r:HI-ANP OOUNTY, ," : PI~NNsYI.VANIA , . , , GARY MOI~r:E ANP ROXANN MOI~r;F, OOUNTFRo~AIM . PI~Fr:NPANTs . . : PO-36~3 olVII. TFRM ,. ... . VgRPIOT AND NOW, to wll: 1:~\\IVfl'~ l~_~ 2000, we, tha Jurors fll1lpl'lnelledlnthe ElPove entlllad OElaS, find SUI l\.. \~'I\I,\\ji if' \~'I"'l"'\\ '11ht(\ FOREMAN: ,f') ,0,). ,A c.(\) 1-' " " ", \', " I' , " ,I Ii \ , .~ :1 ! i Ii 1\,( I I \ i I ,r< 1 1'-/ I .,'[. \'~:,,~ , ['.:.' ':,,\~ 1, ".\ . ~'., " ,. _h__", ,~-~ I f" I ! '; " " 10/' '." " ~AIW Mol<i:!E nm! ROXANN Mcl<I~E, 1~luln\lffs .. IN llil~ COURT OF cOMMON PI.I=A8 DF CUMI3I~I,I.ANP cQUNTY, PENNsYI-VANIA V couNTIW $IPI~ VII.~AGI: . 1-loMES, INc" No, (l8.3033. olvll CIVil. ACTION -1.AW Pofond~lnl '. I , , . , PRAEOIf'1= FOR BATIBFAQIloN OF JUOGMI:I'ff..8NO VERPlct' (-j , j-.1 , :' C) , '11 .', f'"! ,.., !iii'l '-.u" 1'-.' Ii,!! I" I ' L , "'I ~ i I -, , \:rl ~ I' I r,', : ,nl .. , f -'~! (.,~l TO: Plotl1onolory Tl10 jlldgnlOnl onlored In ft1vor of PIElln\lffs Elnd ugt1lns\ Defendant 110S been sallsnecl, Tile vercllolentemclln favor of pefonclont nl1rl agtllnst Plolnllrfs l1as olso boen Bollsnoc!. Pleas\! mmll Il1ls ootlon oS cllBoonllnLled ond endod, Dolo: \ \ I ~ \ 6 l\ McNEES WA~LAOI~ 8. NURIOI< LLO JilY:'7'-' "l~..~,-;.t/bJfA,'Jvl~ / -, Jonotllan H, RUdd, ~~B~. I 100 Pine Slreet '." P,O, Sox 1166 HorrlsbLlro, PA 17108.1166 (717) 237-5405 Attorneys for DefendEll1t Sy__.~~~~~ Geralel ROblnson~ Robinson 8. Gemldo ' 4407 North Fronl Street Hmrlsburo, PA 17110 (717) 232.8525 Attorneys fOl' PlolnllffB " Datei 'I" " !, " n, il " " ,. " " 'j. ,. , , " ,I' " it ,. ,. ,. ,. 1: i' C\ h,~ f'J ,. I'....) 1" lh' 1.-, /I '!i ,1.1 '-1 ." " "\11 i" " {II :)1 , IJ! .:-' '-'I , , " ~II: (""'/:['/ '\....' .. , r\) ,. I' "i, ,-,_, \.f,1 ("(l.) f i I I,-j " : "1.'1 ",,,1/ 'I. " ~ j, \..,. , J.--, .' '1. ,I}II .' .', ("'~ ~'l " " ,,, ';1 ("', ~.. 7 "'.. C...l ~'-" '. " ~ " " .. .. " " 'I' .' ,. ., \ ., " '-I Ii " I ,. ('IJ2:P' .' \" l\~!.j)' .' I.,"" V' I' , i'I' . i . fj . ...:..1-7... i .' , - ,. n .' ;~ %cc \~~., 1J~,-~&\- f'/ ~O." 1.QP.L'-:"\ , ' cl:J.:~.l)~\~:c5Q...'! 1,;. , ~ "'Y--' :~~' I ' I ~t." 1~~ :~CL~, .y.L.Q~_._-- !:"~:' of;, ~ 7.." ~l\:-' .\-Q...'I'a. r6 '\ -\:t;a~\d 'fi, ':'''' ' ____ ' ' no' \ , . lt~, ,. ' ; ,,. . " , , .....J.l' _ ---... -. If 'I' ,.t' t... " , 7.~.1I _'_ [, ,t I~~~t.'" '. ., "t ',' ~!l.II_____.____ .,~_._---~.. I j'" " I _..1:....,..-..-....- .'....___ I I" I; I ".~ ~I-'~,I ' . Jmi~t~.d II'.;L,~~~ ~~/--.-,.--:-, / cnllm~LJL_~ tf.l.t.ge ...J4.$J OWlI, -.---,--'- " l.1I \;?S~~~~)r C-) ~\~~n~__~.__, ;!. II Ul:.-~~Q.. _ ;;i.)D=)d\:)~__- -~)-;#~~,_.\~Yft',..,g~~. ... 0-',. M. \~~~u').'P.J~'-\~.~...- ,. " iii, II \ () ~). l i ') \ \'11.rf"\ \ LX>.. Qj::d-":': . /I'~~~~J '-~~~d ~'I,/)~~Qf:4-1. 17," ~\-lD - Q~,~e..;. -- -. -L Q,LUP , .. J . C': \. .t:1--' i tlo,II,1W-- . ~ ~Q.cJ~cQ'e.C._---- 'I :~;~\ " ...._,=. -. .... . -~ .D:-', CD~~e..c:i \;1,11 \.9~'~ "I,\.k\ ~_.'\)r r- ,"'--'--, 1J.!""4~~~i'J'~- .;... ~r "'1A1*'~1:_.\-":'C'l\ )tr"x. \=.\4~ .1.t:..-4J-... " ~, .. \;J.,) .\.J '( u' ,lfll,# ~\C).. ,. ~'--t'.J i 16,# lD5' ~c:..~ , -0' .. .,1 , ~6.11 . . 7.'/ ',fl ._~_.___. ill, ,I ,. ., i" ,I. .... '. '" i:\'~ ' i f ,OJ i,'; " "J. . '.; .,,".....,['\,'_1 I i' 'l~\,<'1J..'1 j (" . " ~ i: I:"') - '.I.',I.~.\.., ,I ,. J , . .} J I ;"VIL-",,:., ,1'1 ~- I - ,'., , . v , ",t. . ., ., .. ~ " " " , ,. " f', " 1'111:1). OFiijr:\': .or T/H: Pilon i(,I'.iIl"'W 20U[lIIM( ~ I ,'-' f'1'1 :1 I (~Ii ell',l,Ji. f Ii. ",Ii:' l,\)UNI '( I J~JII\IS'(l.\WM " ." " Jii " "j " 'I.,. " ,. ,. " ,I ,f "'i ,. " " ,. , 'I ,. " f' il! ,'; " '" \" (" , '1\1 (- ,,1', , ,. ,. f, " " 'f' n , " ,. ',. , , , " " ,f ,. " I' I' " ,. " .. " " ,.,. " I. I, ,'Ill IJIII:.illf'.ll.'rl .111 il I: I 11\1,11 Y IlIdlllll"I', C;oUII1:ry IHdll \\Vl.Il'lI illl f'ollowII I I, 'l'h.I.IJ 1\11.11:1:01' WI,III I:rind hn!:<)J:(1. I', :)ury Oil l'U,lnlllll'y 31, III f1111.'lll>l'I: or Lhln '11\01'1011, llOOO t:,\1l'OlIUh li'ohrllnry ;~, ;'.O()() , 011 li'ohrlli,ll'Y ?-, ';!()OO, \:hlJ :Jui:y ronrl81:mli\ vOl'cl.lut .in l'i\Vpr of' Pl,'dn\:.i,f'j'[1 <me! i\~jfd,I1/,1\: CO\lll\:ry fJle!lJ lp I:ho ,11\1011111'. of' $:1 ii, 900, '1'110 :Jury i~l!l() rOlldorml II Y8rd.iQt in f'IW01: of' COIII'lt.J:y S.ido Olld '<19idnpt Plidntl I't'fl ()11 COl.\ntl:y Side' fJ UOlln\:o1.'01i:dll\ III 1:110 f1l\1ollnt of' :nfl4, A oopy of. tho dooltot ontd.ofJ FOf.loCJtlng 1:lle prOOOdllJ:i.I.l h.ifJtory of' \:ldfJ qclflq IIJ ilttiloh~da8 8xhlbft A, ?, On AprJl .1.1, 2000,' :jl\d~JI1\ent WilD ont8l'oe! .hl f'avor of Pl'l:dntHffJ ilnd c\gl:dlWt Count1'Y SidE) ill the 1111\0\.lI1t or; :~lli,11.6, 'wh~oh Wl1fJ the net L\I\IOllnt; of' thlJ vonl:\.ct :l.n j'iwol' of' i'lnint.iffl'l ancl n9cdllfJt Cb\.lntry S.ielo, (m~;hd.b.it A) , 3, On MilY 16, ;1000, COlllltry S.iele lJi'lt.if.If'hlel tho :)uclgl\lent }JY pq~dn" Pll1.int,l.f:fu I1nd thol.\.' lI\or\:91.1908 ~;.l.6, .1."1'1,05, ,(J<JxhJb.it 13), At thi.s fJal\le t:.i.II\O, Country Bide' n I1tt.oJ.'ney .1:equentec1 P111i.nt:lfl:1'I1 attorney to "LUe 11 jJJ:il8cJpe w.l.th tho Prothonotm:y i.nc1.1.C)I\ti.ntt tl1l1t the :J,Ic1gmllnt hilD uow boon f1ilt.lB['Jeel," (l~xh.i.bJt: C), ~, On Juno 2"1, 2000, Plai.nt.iffn' attorney sont c6untry S.iele' B I1tl:OJ:noy q chock :In tho amount of l~fl03, ~ 0, whioh WClI'I. to Pi'lY the vBrcl:lct .ill f'aVor of COllntry Si.do I1nel agaJnut Plaintiffs, Ir ;>, " 10, COIII\l:I:Y H.ldu Wil!! 1I0t: nHpl.lrt,rt I:() I:01\dol' I'Ldllt:11'f'1I i\ f'oP 1:0 1':11cl \:ltu lH'iluuJprl hJl: 11'.11'.\11/"11'1:1 oil of' .J I!dUI11UlIl' ni IIll0 tiLl II COllrt: dool! !lot l'uqIl11-u II lIoPill:ill:u f'oo t:o I'i 'I u il Pl'illl!!.! pn I'DI' /Jill: Ipf:iwt.lOI1 of: .Jlld~J1I101l1:, 11, I'lilJlltJft'/J 1\nnliIIlOIlI\!lly I'id1ud W1\',ltol!t: W?ocl U<lIIlJH to' f.U\,) tho [1rilHoJpu fOJ: IJilt::llIl'i\ClI:lolI of' :!\\CI\Jli\unl: 1'0],' Ii\Ot'I" 1:1\<\!l 90 d<lYu Elft:Ol' C'ol\lIt:ry f3:1.clu l'ol]llont:ml :1.11 wrJl::I.PU t:hLlt: 1:110 pJ:'iWCI.l.pe bo j:Ll(J(j oll,.Mi\y 16, 2000, '<Inri .-July G, ;WOO, (HxhIbil:p C' ElIFt m) , , 12, 'l'hoJ:o won) OVOI' [;2 Illonl:lw bO!:lvoGn WhOl1 COIInt:ry 81cle J:[:lCjllUI!I:eQ In Wl:'Jl:'.lnrJ thElt: the Pl'ijl"c.i.pe bo f.Uecl, Elnd t:he elCtllal f:.ll.Ing of: the pl'i.\ec.i.pe, t f'; ,13, Pllrl!lIClnt: to '12 Pil,C,S,!\,.!lB10t)(bL Country IH'dej,s enl:.ltled to,l:lCjUidC)tod 'dillnilgeF.1 Jnthe i\mOLlnt: of ~~2,500, ,,, Alt:hollg!l the stEltlltB providep for liqllidEltecl clwl1i\ges of 1%" of the j Lldgmllllt i.'H110unt for overy month beyond 90 di\YfJ thelt the jUdgment .Is not IlIm:ked i\0 flC\t:J,flfJed, th.l.s would C\llIount to ovel: $7,'100 ($lG,l1G x ,01 Elt '19 " $7,40G), AacorcHngly, Coupbl'Y Side is lim.Ited to tho stotut:ory ci\pof $2,500, 14, Country 8.l.de hEls lIlado 0 good f'Ell. th al: tempt to re/301ve this iosue with Plaint:lff'o' oounsel, but P1C\int.l.ff:s' cOllnsel hes refused to pity C\ny on;ount aFJ oi thm: aOlllpenoC\l:ory or U.qu.lc1C\ted" do~ages, As such, Country S.Ide hos no choice but to re~Ueat ,'.! 5 . ('\'J!~'I'r I' 11'1\'1'1;: ON r~oN ('ONI '\lII!mr~l'I': I, 1!"!H\l".\Io'HI II, R\ldd, 1IlII'olly (llll:t:II'y Ihiil', Jlllid.\1.Il1 il (lOPY of: I:h.lw II\nt:.lol\ \:0 P.liilnt'.\ f'l.II' '.L'U\\llI,ul 1'1'101' I:n I'LIII\\! 1',IIlI IlIot::lol\ <Inri l'OCjl\lJlII',nd thill', 110 OOl\lHl1' il\ I',ho lI\otl 011, P,l i\ il1l',.l1' I:u.' (!()\111110:\ I (ju'l~nld I<nb.l nllOll, ltiurj\l:ll'l.l, l'ol:lIuml 'i:o (lUI\(!(ll.' :111 1:l1u l'uCj\1UII\:mj l:01:1nl', I, " ,. yfi . L.' '. r"l I. , , __.._- ..; ",'._'h.'~:'''(-;>~ )J.;';i'''/\, ,. ('" 0~-~\tl\~\n'-i'i':-'I~l\ctZi---'- ----, , \, .' . ".....,* , ,. Di\I:oc]I ;} \ \ ,\ \.~ r" " I. ., ,. " " " " '., 'I I' J", ,. iI" " d ,j.. "1, ,. I' " , ,. 1'1" ',I " , " ,/1 1.\ II,' ';' ,~ , jrl" f~' j " , " )';Ii : :~if-, .,J.' 1.'(;; !~fl " I , I'YS511 Cu!"b(~d<lq(\ QOllnty. Prolr' honol:nry' rJ 01' Uar1 , , UV11 Cl\fJCl fir nl: I . I. llWU.03633 MCI\ElVJ GT\RY IU'l' /I.~ (vp) COUN'I'RY f:lTPlU Vll,j.,I\Olil IIOMlU8 INr~ ROfl'l~'e~'10l:1 1'10" I 1":I1llc\, , , , , ' , , I aa~o '1' pa, , , , " COMI'I,!}ll'I'1' ~':lII\Cl, , j " ! " , I 'J~ gl1\a It '1" , ' , Hi116., 00. mXll(J\lI:.~n 11<11:Ij 01\ go . QfJ gnoc\, HWSS jCmYIN 1\ 11lry Tr"al"" PQPOI:h9C\ P(~FJO I I 81\'1'18 rUUD )'jlJl]opm Pat~1, ....-------- l!l\f.lO COI1\I1\f:lnt:f.l ....-........... .1..CJ1l:l1.:' Crt: 1.." ,9181: Crt: 2, I t.t........................t....tttt.....ttt..t.......tt.tt..tttt..t.ttt..t....t Goner<ll Index 'T\t:t:orney Info ~CI<ij~IU G~I~Y Pl,'T\IN'l'H'I" . POIll,MT\N 800'1"1' W 21 U'l'I., , ~ 1.,T\I'l1!i IilNtH~lill( 'l'IMO'l'lIY '1' NElW rr...I~U 1'T\ 1'/?-41 Mal<~El ~OXT\NN ~ffiWV~f;t~rn'\,kT\I'l~U7 2 41 CO\1~'l'~Y. ~IDm XIlJI.,J\OUl gOMUl/3 mo ~BIIIJ~'rRIJI'~O ?7m~~ IWA l' I~I\ I 1'1'1' I 1" Ie POH!"MI\N 8CO'I"I' W IUNCl ~lnr~ 'I'IMO'rllY '1' Page 1 DlUli'IUNPT\N'l' NI/381,Y N. IU.DIUC 1" IWPD JOI'll\T\I\N II 6/;l9/199R 0/00/56~o 11/20/?-004 ttt...ttt..t........ttttt.tt.tt.tttt.ttttttttttt.t'..tttt.t.ttttttttttttt.t.ttt. Juc1gment Index T\I1\Olmt: PElte Pepo MClmm G~IY 70a'OO a5 ~R~ ~~~ VILl.d\OIil II0Mlna INC 1, ~go: gg MCIS m 01\ Y . 704,00 a56 ~ ~ost~l_ VILLAOn l~C 15,~g3:gg caul'r~Y SI.nn VILIJA.O!.~ 1'18~rn~ I C 1[,,116,00 coy TRy ~Inl VILLI\Gdo~ru8 I C ~al( : m ~~XXNN 31.1.16~1999 3 16(,]!)!)9 3'( 16'/1999 2%02%2000 2~02. ~2000 2(,02(,2000 4'/,1l./,2000 1J,~~9/'2004 11,/(, 9'/,,/2004 11 ,9 2004 ~IRH~ 8.g {\. fiRf1'~. :fg~~ A I~B O~ ARDltRXTOI~s V, dhc'T V ' ~Plch , lPl:CT ~ . GM~NT ON V~HPICT SAng 'AC'l'IO~ S1\'l', S 'ACTIO S1\'rfsli'AC'r.ro ,. ' .. *t'.t*...tt..*..ttttt..ttt.tttt.ttttt*.ttttt.tt.tt..tt.t*.tt.t**....t'*ttttt.ttt * Date li1ntr.iea . ., * *t'..*.*t.*.t.ttittt..t.t.t*ttt..tt.t.tt.tttttttWt*tttttttt.ttt..tttt.ttt.ttt..t 6/29/1990 7/02/1990 0/03/1990 9/16/1990 9/16/1990 9/16/1990 9/16/1990 9/22/1990 10/02/1990 10/05/1990 10/0li/1990 10/21/1990 3/16/1999 . - - . . - . . - - . - - leI I~8'r mw!'RY -. . - - - - _ . _ _ _ _ _ COMPLAXN'I' . CIVIL AC'I'ION ~~MM~___~_MM_____"_________________________________~___"~___I'______ 81lmlUlele I 8 RmTUHN li'IlJIUD ., IJitigElllt, , C~UNl\RY ~!f)lU vnLAQ1~ Il0MUlS INC . SIHVlUD ,7 02 90 OT & COMPL . . Coata"", f.l 7, 2 P By, I\OlUNSON & GliJlV\WO 07/02/1990 ---_________________k________~______________________________.'-_____ AN8WEll\ '1'0 COMPIJAIN'l' WI'I'1! NJilW MA'l''l'IilR AND COUN'I'IDRCLAIM ---------------------'---------------------------------------------- AN/3WElR '1'0 NElW MA'I"rml~ AND COUN'l'Jj)RCI.,AIM -------------------------------------"--------------------.---.---. S'I'IPUIJATION AND AMIUNI) PLIil^DINO . , ------------------------------------------------------------------- plV\ElClp.m '1'0 AMINI) COMPLAIN'l' BY TIMO'l'IIY T IUNGLmR' " ~______R________________~_______________~_________________________~ ^MmNPElD COMPLAINT ------~--------~'------------------------------------------~-------- I\N8Wml\ '1'0 J\MIilNDJilP COMPLAIN'1' WI'I'Il Nmw MA'I''l'IR ANp. COtJNTElRCLAIM -----~---------------------------~-~------------------------------- ANSWElR '1'0 Nmw MA'r'rJnl\ AND COUN'rmRCLAIM ---~-----~------------------------------________w_~--,__________~___ PUl'l'ITION li'OR l\PPOIN'I'MmN'1' Ole ARBITMTOl\S BY 'l'IMO'l'HY T ElNGLElRElSQ ------------------------"_.~--------------------------------------- OHP~g Ole COUR'!' 10/06t,90 API'OINTMIUN'r OP ARBITM'rORS BY GmORGEl E HOIi' e/ij~ 1> JUDGffl AI\!3I I'RJ\'1'O~~ ME At~13ElR'l' 130QJ~H'1' ElSQ - 8ElPHJ\NIIll ! . ~~~ 6Ell<M~~~IU~ D RICIAHD CO ElLIJ mSQ, ! '.. ---------_.~-,-----"------------------------~-----.,--~--~----------- PRAlnCIPm rOR InN'!'RY Oli' APPIU^R!lNCEl POR PLleli'S BY 'I'IMO'1'IIY T ElNGLElR IJl/3Q " ii.1~ii.iiD - OP - ii.iii3i~'Rii.'i'Ol~S - : . frO "'i'11m - PLii.iN~'i PPS - ON - ~'HrniR.- - COMPLAINT. THm. .,~. ! SUM 0,(0' $1500,00 AND '1'0 '1'llIn pmli'IUNDAN'1' ON I'l'S COUNTElHCLAIM TIWl 8UM' Clll11per1<1l1r.Il COllnCY PI;c;~h,?nOCt\l:Y I fl Offiao . IC YH OMJe [lj.nC I HHIB-0:l633 MCI~EE GAHY E'l' /I'" (yp) COUN'l'RY awn: VII,I.I\Gl'! llOMElS INC R13fl~r(:\lloa ND",. . ." ','~1.1ecl,,,,,, "I tJt\ao 'IRI)O"'" I COMPI"AINI I IlII'J. 'I" 'l'" . J\1 gl11e'\:,~, '.';1 1.lillG.,(JO IUlIe. olltlon IJ.t\t:13 II\\C go . fl~]. glleq 1 Illuas !<mYIN A ~qr~ '1'J:.{<l1, . , , 11:1.~popeq I epo).,1 ' SI\'1'IS IIEll) )'tS lOfleS\ l)ilte, -""~---'''---"\.1t\fJe COllll\1en:fJ --......-- ------ .1' 9 \01: CJ.:: ].,1 . .9)131' ort: 2., o?" ~ 'Ill~ ,00 IEEA O. II PI\H'I'Y '1'0 13JJJ.I\R 1'1'S ONN 0081.8 . 1'1 'l'lClil !I1AIWn .. " 3 26799 13Il,lJlm COUN'l'Y IIOI~ ATWl'I'IlI\'I'ogS .. .. .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ... ... .. .. .. .. .. .. ... .. .. .. .. .. .. ... ... " .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .... .. .. .. .. 1'10'1'1 Clil air APPIEM, IrlWM AWlll~P 011 I\HIH'I'IWI'ORfj 13Y 'l'IMO'I'IIY 'I' IENGill~R WI3Q ..'........................................................ ':"..........~,.............,........ -................................ t1-...... Pill\IN'l'lIrl"s I MO'I'ION '1'0 r,!ow'mr, ANPWI~RS ,\,0 IN'I'lllRIWGA'I'OIUlilS ~g')P~,.~,ffi~I?~~'~IU~~~. O~..~~ I ~ 91~1~);;~~I~J~Bifln,~~.;~1 J~I~~[~,~NQ.. i;I~D~~'i:~I.~&?N&.~~~~N.;' ~\~~11~,; 13m' OF tN'l.'m ROGI\'1'OIU WS 11'h HN 20 1)1\ YS " l3Y !<liJVIN A HIUl3a J - NO'l'lCIE MAII"lilD 10/'1 99 --_____M~_~__________~__~___~___.._____________________.-----_w_~___ PMJilCIpI~ POR 1,1S'1'ING CASlil FOR 'l'RIlII" l3Y 'I'IMOTIW 'I' IilNGt,liJl~ ).i1sQ ---------------------------------------------------------------~--- pI~I\ElC. I pm '1'0 AMUlNI) lilN'l'RY Oil I\PplEARANCIU Oil OOUNSElL IIOR PIEft'ENDi\N'I' 13Y JONi\TH1\N H Iwpn EI3Q M CO-COUNslill" ----------~-,._-------------,.------_.,--------------------------.---- Plm'l'IUAI~ cqNPIURIENCIE - PA'1'lilI) 1/12/00- I3Y U1PW1\IW IE GUIDO J ----------------------------------------,.-------------------------- l)lilFr~NPI\N'I" 13 HlilSpONSW '1'0 1'1.,1\1 N'l' !F' II I 13 MO'l'ION HI l,lMINlil ~ - - _ _ _ _ _ M _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ " _ _ _ DP)Ii'lilNDAN'I'1 S MO'l'lON IN ilIMINEl .118 '1'0 'rIm 'rms'I'IMONY OF SCO'I'T POIll.,M/\.N -ft-~----~---------"----M_____________..____________r---_____________ V~I'RDIC'I' .. JU~ORij Smr,DlC'I'In!) Jl\~UAI~Y 31 2000 - fiW '1'1m JURO~S li1lJl\nElI~I"IUP I. '1' 1m 1\. BOXlil nN'.I'I'II~.IE.) CI\S{u F'IND ft'O '1'~llilCOUN 'I' I Rgl"AIM .p 1\1 '1I1IIF 00 1'1'1' Y ~IJ)I~ VII"I.II\GtU HOMEls INC 1~ '1'1El MOlltlT 0, 704,00 \1' '1'1' El ,TUROR~) lil I'll Ell" "ElD. IN 'I' m 1\130VI~ ElN'I'II1IElD C SEl FIND II R 'l'Hm I'LA! 'rIFFS GlARY 1\1'1) IWXANN MC <Elm IN '1'IJEl AMOUN'I' 0, $l.l3, 900, 00 ------.____ft__"_____________________________~-_____~--_____________ nmlrElND~'l" S MO'I'J;oN. IIOI~ 1'08'1.' '!'RIM" HIilI.,ImF . " _ft______________"_________________________"_____~--________________ O~DE~ OF COUR'l' - DI\'l'l1JI) 02-16-00 - DblF'l' 1.llilEl BRIWr II;! CIJAMBElR~ NOT. ~Rfffit~ ~g~N1,K~m~A:r.rrA~R?W e;R~5 ~fi;~~ElAF'I'~U~~' ~VI\~11,l6~BI~~E13lJ~~~f;mY COPIIns MllIilElD 82 -16 - 00 . --.--------------------------------.---"---------------------------- ~/29/2000 OPl~roN I\ND oHlm~ OF 'COURT - j)A'I'lilD 3/29/00 - IN Rlil MOTION OF DElF NDlIN'I'. IrOR l>Q '1'-'I'RIl\l, ImL1;)II. - DElNImI) - BY ElDCl1\R l3 BAYI,IUY. J _ COI' ms MAIillilD 3/ 9/00 .. --~--------"------"___ft____________________________________________ I'RAElClPE FOR lilN'l'RY Ol~ ,JUDGMWt>l'l' ON TIIEl vmR!nO'I' AND JUPGMlilNT. ElNTUlRElD ____,ft_________~___'~___________________"~--_____________~___________ NO'l'lCEl. MI\IilElD TO DElI~WNDI\N'I' . --------------------------------~------_.._-------------------------- OElR'I'IFICATEl 01" MAILING COpy Oil PIU\ElClPm FOR lilN'I'RY OF JUDGMlilNT -_____ft___________________________________________~________________ PIU\ElC1PE FOR Sl\'I'1 SFAC'I'lON OF JUDG~IUN'1' ~D VElRDIC'I' BY JONATHI\ N II . IWbD m8Q. FOR DEl 11'1' I\ND GllllU\LD IWI3I sON InSQ FOR PilllFs - - - - - " - - : .. - - - - l"lIS'I' ijNTRY - - - .. _ _ _ _ _ _' _ _ _ _ ~/1.ll/IP99 9/2+/1999 10/0~/1999 12/t3/199P 1/0612000 ]./13/2000 1/2~/2000 1/24/'1000 2/02/2000 2/1112000 2/16/2000 .4/1'1/2000 4/11/2000 4/11/2000 11/29/2004 . P<<96 2 G/29/1990 :3 46 0/00/0600 n/;l9/;100~ ******************************************************************************** * . Elj3orow InforlUat:~on * * 'eea & Debita l3e. 13<11 P, ta I\d End l3t\1 * **f*****************************W********~W**~** ******************************* CiP1'~IN'I' 'I' 0 C Pil'1' 3 'TT~ ~Mlil~'1' lIpg,1' Olr. MI3ITRA I\PPEl1\L ARI3I'I'M'I' JDM'I'/DElI1I\UW' 35,00 35,00 ,00 ,50 ,60 ,00 Ii,OO 5,00 ,og 6,00 6,00 ,0 16,00 16,00 ,00 290,00 290,00 ,00 ~,OO 9,00 ,00 - M _ _ M M _ M _ _ _ _ _ _ M _ _ _ _ _ M _ _ _ ~ _ _ ~ _ _ _ _ _ ~ _ _ 359,60 369,50 ,00 *******************************.************************~**'******************** * . Elnd of Case In~orlUation * " . ('t) . I, t I 'I; 't~l: ;' I ," l' I ." 1.1 1,:I,I',t( 1{'11 p;,'l;(\ 1 1'1, . .. '1':"'!'/-'-< ,. '-1'" ,. ,'. ,- . l. -I \"f f ~- /1'1 'Ii_l' If, 1[111 'I II J /il Illv ,- i \, \ \,"-11 \.' ,,'I .... " " II (: {/"d)it B "~...----".~_.~-.... " " " " .l .l' " " 'I, ot " ,I' " " , , " : ,. " " " " ,. I' " ",. II ,',I' , I'" I. " .," '.,1 , " " 'I ,. ;'1 " ,I, " " " " " ., ','jl', ..1 " .. ' '.1 " .\ -,j;', , '(' ". ,',I ," f' 11..\.1;11',"." . \ ; 1, '/ \~.\~ 'i" ~~ t \j;};'- "/.: ,'1 i',IJ! I." '';' I exhibit B '" >,",1'"'''''' . ",,' II.' (fl ~ , , " " 11 " '" " ,. ,,11 "I' H " Ex l~,lilll E, ", ,.,---,..b, " Ii " " ., " lit " 'I " ' "I' " J' " .' /, " i! .,. i ;.' ,I. ".. " .If " " i! ". " 'I ., , /! !; .. " " '" lj' " ;, 'I' ..1 exhibit E " 1':,"1 "lJ L .'} t It ~ , , '''','^U'".,', " I"" "1[' (;\ , i,' ,. i' ,. .. .. Ij " 'i " ~l(h'bltF '" . ..' f'. , " " ,. " " " Ii' ,'. " i, 'I" " " f'" , ,', L." ",1 " " " 'j ': " p~ ( I ." ~ 'i .\ . ,'I ,. , ."1) 'II, 1_ _'/1,\ 1,:\ " I -': (II l!i., ,.IJj ;, .I' ,. " .". , ' "I' " Fl' ','1',', (, )1' 'i"I' ;"l 'I .,.0' " ., .-,'1 " ,. , , I..... " " " ,j~ tll ,..... .' ,I' 'I. " 11" " ~, :.r'y'....-/ \(1- 'i. I'" " " " H " ,~ ~ ( " j,. I' ',', " " ,I II, " I \ , I \ I' !. " ,. " .' " ,,":; I' " ,hl\lullwlllllnd V\.l1'11I1~IH, 1'llIlnlll'lii l'uHpuolrllli>' Hnhmll Ihlll H\1(:h dn~\I1I1UnlH 1I'0l'U lilud h\1\ I\'UIV nnl !llllurud h)' Ilw unllrl pl'lllhnnollll'Y'H ul'liuu, HII\:h UITnl' d\llllol ~nllW In \hu pl;,lnlllfH 1I\1~lllllln IInllllivu (51 )'Ul\l'H IlIlul' huuIIIIHU oppllHlll1J c\l\II1Hull\tllud 10 nlllll)' Ilw pllllnlll'l'dmlnlJ \11111 Ilmu purind, 7, Punlud, I\PPI'OXh\lIllul)' I1l'c (5) )'Ulll'H IIIJII, II prlloulpu In HIIIIHly Ihu.llldlJmunl WIIH Hll!nud IInd Hunt lolhu prnlllOnnllll')"H nrncu 1111110 cOIlr\hIlIIHU, 1\\ Ihlll \l1\1U, ,Ihol'l) II'IIH l\ol'CIIHIII\ In hulluw Ihllt Ihnl p1'I\uclpu WIIH 1\111 .I1Icd IInd un\ul'cd prnpurl)', .I)\1I'11\1J NnvumllUI' 200'1, pllIll\lIl'1'H II'UI'U 1\II1111uII Ihlll1l1O prlluclpu did I)IlI 11\ I\lcl 1J1l1\II'Ollllh IInd I\H HOOIlIIIl 1'IIIInl 1 1'1\1, ll\lulll1\u 1I11'II1'U or thlH, 1'11I11l1I1'lH' cO\1I1Hcl pl'upllrud II HUCOlld prllcelpu IIl1d HUIllllw HllhHeqllcllt dm1\1I1Wnl 10 Ihu prolhonol!II'Y tn hu I1I\ld 1\1"\ unlcrud, ()nu m\lnlh IlItur III pueul1\h'JI' 20tH, plIIllltll'l'reuolvud Il\llluu thlll Ihu .I11dl!1I1Clll HIIII hlllll\ol huen HlltlHl1ud 111\(111 lullcl' or 1III\II11'Y 11'1\11 HUI\I hy Iho pIlll1\III'I'H omlnHul10 Ihu COlll'\ IIdmlnlHll'l\tol' IIH 10 when IIl1mo-HtllI1\PUII prlluulpo will hu ul\lorud 11\ ontul' III HIIIIHI)' lhu .Il1dlJl1lul1l, Plllllltll'lW cmlllHUllinllll)' reuull'cd II dlllud pl'lIuelpo\ ho\\,cwr Hllld pl'l\uulpu WIIH dlltcd \lccull1hur 2004, Thc dll\o or \lcuu1l1hul' 20lH l'ul1uelH 111Il , II ' HCCOI"I \Imu Ihu prolhol\ollll)' 111\11 to ho cOl1lllclllnd Ilollhu Nllvumhor 20lH dlllu ol'lvhun 110llcu j.,. Willi I'uculwd thllt thu orllJlnlll pl'lIoolpc WIIH nUI'Ul' 1lllllHllud, IIIH IIw Plllln\II'I\I' pOHl\lon thlll thu 1'01l1l01l tho .Il1dgmolll Willi llol HIIllHl1ud I1vu (5) )'CIII'H prllll' IH duu 10 thu IIU\H or Iho pro\hOIlOIIlI'Y IIlld llol IIny wlIIl\I.llIelH on thc purl or 1'IIIInlll'l', Thill IH IIppnl'cllt lhl'oulJhtho continued IIctlol\ll or thu 1'IIIIIIIIrl'H IInd 1'IIIInlll'l:~' UOllllllol thnlupon noli co 11111 pl'ollHll\ollll'Y'H 1\llhll'c to onlel' Iho pl'lloelpe,l'lnll1tln:~ nllldc ~,vuI'Y crlhr\ tOl'oelil)' IhlH 01'1'01', H, At\ml\, II, Adll1l\, 10, Admit, 2 ;1" 'i, /' 'I' ;, " j;' "" ", "., '" , : " " ., .j, j< " " ,. j. " " " '.j, j. h !< " I' H " " " r.f.7 llv ., ~" ~\ Ii ,,' I< 'j;; i' i' j, j ,. " 'i. " Ii " jl " ,p "'1 q t,., (;',;1 i:" t~, I-J ','I; ~;~j Ih'r.l ',',ii ;~V, ~n[9 I I',) ~ I ~ C:1' .',),1., ...;,.1 ,,'I'll " ..- ~ /-ii,) iiiili ';','11 /, "'f',' r,,) ~7 .. ~l:" ~: ') (..11 If] ...... If.~ I~" I, " i , I II! I i I I i' ;. I I i ! ~ H if " " \-; j'