Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-03651 " " " If " I I ~\ .. I ~\ H 1,1" " "J" " I'" 'I' ;," d , " " " " " ;i " '1',- " $! ", " to '\l ~ " " q. " " '" " " " .'-' \ 1 / t! ;" 'j: " ,.. " " " '" i' ., jl " !'.. t' " ,j 1'- /, I; I' " " 1 jl t. Iii ji 'I, Ji " " " ''-, 11 " 1; " ,,' " I' ( ~ ij, " :,1 " " I' 'it' ,." " Ii! " 'I. " ,; ':"'-0. " Ii " . .~ .. '-J 1;- ,'" !' U " "i " i I i .....j '<<1' I ~' N) " " ,," " " " , ~ i; , " if " " , " '" H ,i I' I \ ' ~i C)..! ,\ ~i " j ":' "~-'i1ll~\';~i~~j~i~~j~i'lVv~,~;,i\W,\lE~J\l;\'r,;;;:. \j~~ 'i?;i:;:;": .'~.~"Y~'i}i~Wi)~I~(\~'}l\WJ!;:A: :';':;;'V~'j;'\l:..\t,:iK;Y:!~ (~I,; !~\(~,i7 .~.'" : ,,~~. \l\lil"\\Yi'-'lJ~fi'I-\"'lhlf(~ti,l-; ,j,\_]I,ll:,j~.\,;,!,i/l\'-'fj:",\;,,-' ~'W-'-~~""m' '-', '.';;1;lni~,Yn~I,Jj1-~I~,J~,- /Jrh\',; ii!. 'H'f,';i, \!,,_!,,',-H__,:,': .f;lll '" - I ' r"'fL'-';"~""\'i'_""I''';)'I;;''-\'hi{'',-",,!,,)I\'\"l.,.-,\.q~;'.' ~ .';~/i';T\r-'(.," J".""'!.\/i'\j\f; .'1",','." :\"j.'.-i"'-V,'., _ , ' ","')"HH,-",'LLpc',' .. f .N ""i"'I"',(, ,'.," ':""""1~:" \ ,.. " "!"'F~, ,1,.,,\ 'I'Vr":",,',T...,',..C ,yh.-",.". .,,-,',..' ,'., .. '-~" ..' ~;:i;[';!;:.Iir:;~i;J~::,i;'!(,\:;,i(~~;\\!; ;'tii\~: :,:: ~:,;j;~rnftMQ g hP'y," ::tY:i;i:.:\:;' :,i:i!I:IC\:II,~;I,;jti !':\tL1i;'!"~ J !rll;~''t '\fli?lf'li;itH,\.i~C;\'),tir'l(:;" i \,,' :'! :,~;j~d..."lII'!lIn!t.l"'~r ':'~'\" ",I' '",,''''' '." ':",;".','(: : V" i ,,"i~:::i ;;r(\;,\1;11,.'('IJ"1 "tkr .'W~~,:,,'l:X\t'~';,';~l,.'I~i'f(I\{'i'~:~il\~,W;':::J" J~nffl'~~~~I,~N'n'Y,~V~~,\~.;, J",R' ,\\;:' '\ ')~(\;:il,)j\';~11 H5\ \~",:;~'!l\',r::1 ,~\~'IA~~"i~,t~{;,~}~;r:1.' " l" .. "e.' . .. , I'" ''',.' 'IT lIU4\9ml' ". '...'..,...; "., "<,,,,, ". ,. ~~i~\;I;~::,;!,;:\;,: " ;..','" ,", :,'" .J ' ",'I[' I '".', '),1, ":':\::";,'!!,:t,;\((~~,':l:~'~:)~:\;!;i,{':i;:":,,, , "1 ' ,. " , , ' ~~r'-'--~-"" ,. IN 'l'IIlU cOllii'if OP..'60MMOlfl>r;EJllfr-5'li-'..;;.............; III Ai,li\:1.f"~ , CUMBI~IUJI\NP COUN'I'Y I I.'I~NNl3n.vJ\NIl\ (1[' i' 'J( (' ("J, ( '-/'- VO, I, NO, . '. .:) ,'~ ( ,::,11. Il' .f/LI' /, (WPl!GI~ p, I3M~'.l'1I / pe /: el1t1,m t mvl.l, l\C'l'lON Ijl\W t'IW'l'I~Ctl'ION )i'lWM l\13\lI3I~ TlilMP,QRARLQlilll1lR <'I (A ANP NOW I I:his 0(1 deW the Pel:i\:ipn of. Plaintiff, Oreler.l 1 t 'rhe ,Dej~endAnt ahAll 1,ef.rCl.\.n /:1'011\ Ab~lJ3il1g, hClrClosfng, 01' q(.C'l'LQ.__ (/ the COllrl: enter.s /1990 upon rev1.ew oc the t:ollowi,ng 'l'el11porary thl'eCltening Clnd stCllking the Plaintit:f.. -_______ , ,~~.___.,...._..:n.__...:.~'.._-. 2, --Pldll~:Lf.f i.13 gi,VeIU:J:xalus~iYe.-J56a-ci.eeoion of U17 'l'dndle \~oEl~r.~~,a:ta-j.-cci'~~:;;;~~.:.bOli.1i eY/"PA,'--""",,___ ;(-";( 3....,__ Pefenel,mt, Defenelant I 0 elaughter I Welll1y Delaware / ...., - Defendant I a"'~QclQl\ghter, Shel-ry Delaw,u:er"Deri3i1da;i't~'; 9l-Al1dOon / ' --------..-. ........-~.-..... rnliDelaware I anc1 De:t:enda;j'E,,':fi!::;eth!3.~, daughtel: I Nanoy t'etrooky I ,are enj oi,neel and prOhi.1;l.tteCr'''f'~om Hvin~"~ t';"-ellt::eril1E/, At tempti,ng to ~~..~. . -.............-- ~.. .,~ enter or V;l,~i'i:il1g the residenoe 100Ated at lU7 'rrint:i.le Road, "'-.'.-' C'!J:Hi31e, PA. ,-" 101 4 I Defendant :la direoted to immediately relillqui,ah the CoJ.lowing weaponl3 to the Shedff.. of this County I gunfl, 5, 'rhls Order shaU be ellforoeel by any law enforoement !, agenoy in f.l Counl:y wlwr.e A violation of thi,13 Order ooours, " 6. Pireol: that: the Def.endant inOUl' aU o013t:/3 aaaot1:lated with , \:il \' \I (,i ", I;' ,\Il\,I' ilii \\\ III I' ('q ,,"..Jj, \ III 'I/rl/ 1.1/.1',' " ~' /i> A/II . H C ~.-I-1,11'''( ,fA"" (\<i.L1'''1' ",i{', '{ (jftw~" ii ' " " ,; " .' iil' I' " " " " " " I"~ " ,: " " " 'i, " " " ;.,1' ,,' !i " " ;," '" "" .. " '" ,!! ,i " ;, " "Ii t' " ; , " " )i, .' " " Ii '1'1 vp, 11'1 'J'Hl~ CO\lW!' O)i' COMMON PL,fUlIS Oli' CUMllIUl\l,I\NIJ CO\JN'I'Y, 1'IUNNanVl\lHlI NO,. '7 J" .n \' / ('iI'" ,( -f'~l-" UIUVtlHI.,';( \1, )'~lI1Wf~, , Pln:\.n\:Hr OIUO!WIi) D, I3Ml'l'll/ 1)13 f. emll1n\: O1VIL AC'l'WN jd\W PRO'I'JjIC'J'IPN l"IWM lIUllS1U j!. I"f c.li ) ,'\1 Jlli'!Tl~IQN..Jill!U~nQ'l'lJlC!llQN_J!'RQM.J\uu.Sjjl '1'0 'l'lm HONORl\IU,1U iTllDGJU OD' 'SlII)) COllR'l'l 1, The Pll1int.\.f.f'ia peverly J, Pearce/ An ad~lt individUAl, who re~d.dep "t Hi? 'I'dndle ROild I CnrHale / Cuml)er.1t:ll1d County I PA, 1 '7013, now teniporm,ily 1:eaid1,ng at: 0/0 110dl1e Stdal~lei.; / 1):l,Uab~rg I Pl\, I' 2, The l)ef.endan\: ip George D, Smith, an adult: :l,ndiyh'lua1, pt'eaen\:1y repid:l,llg at 1117 '1'l:1,n(\le Road / Ct\r1:l.131e / C1l1l1ber1:and Co, , PA 17013, 3, 'I'he pl1rti.ea are not mar.detl I)ll~ are bbyfr:!,end and girlfriend haY~ng lived together ainoe Augllat of. 1997, 4, The r8a.\.(leno~' from whioh the Plt\:l,nt:l.f.f ':la aaJdng the Court to exolllde the Deeendant is owned 01, t"entec1 by l)efendant, Ii, Pdor to D'dc1uy, Juna 25, 1990/ only Plain\::Lff and Defendant: ,Uyeel at the residence which :l,fJ the aubj edt: of t:lu'a Pet::l,t:l,on, I,', 6. The f.t\ota of the moat reoent inaic1entfJ of abuaeare as f.ollowa I A, I,Mt WednefJdAY, "line 24/ 1990 I l)efenc1l.lnt wa13 ti' ~~dlll"j.ng <lnd l)eo<\me "ngry wt\:h Pl<\inl::In: "ne1 thrento\loel 11l'1l' "nd l:o:Lcl her' to get 01\1:, l11<l:lnt::lCf, olll.\.ec\ NP1:.~,h Midelle\:on 'l'own!3h:\.p poUee wilD Oi:\me \:p the \:el3:1.tlenoe i:\nc:\ o<l.\.med the lJefenel<ln\: down <1111:1 I', , f.13mOver.:! h:\,I1\ Cl,Om l:he, l:eflidenoe, InCo):m<lt:lollt\l1y, Decen~~nnl: l3ubl3e. qU13nt:ly returned the ne~t:d<lY to the rep:ldenoe, !3, Pel:end<lnt: ht\fl phyaio<1Uy "bl1f~8d P1A:\,11\::\.I!C :In t:he pal3t, ~he f.ollowing nr.e flome eX<lmplea oc pal3t abllaive ooneluOt, " i, Some t:lme on or <lboqt the micldle oC )\pdl of. t:h:l.s ye<lr, 1990, DefendAnt 'lost h:lp lioenpe beo<lUfle 01' II OUI oonv:lotion, Defend<lnt had been dr.:Inking anc:\ Attempted to ptrangle Pll1:1ntifC at the reaidelloe, lJef.endant threAtened h13r <lnel tolc:\ he\: thnt if he wo\ildn I t go to pd,13on, he W0\1ld Id 11 her <md blow of f hel: heac.\; He oal,lec:\ hel.' a fat, L:-._ hog, :\.:1. 011 or. about De,oe\11ber 11,' 199'7, Defendi;\nt bedelll)e intox:\,oatecl lInd got hh' hand glln Ollt und ooolted it <lnd told ,plalnt:l.ff ha waa going to sattle a f.loore, He threatened tha Plaintiff at wh:loh time Plaintif.f onlled the pOlice, )\13 the polioe ardved, DeCendnnt dropped the gun nnd nm into a fiald, After the poUoe left, the Daf.endant Ot\m8 baol, alld onoe again threatened Pla:\,nt:\,ff <lnd told her th<lt no one O<lUS the poHoe on him. Defendant oalmed dO\'l,l,l t\nd went to sleep after pl<1int:\,ff told h:\,1I1 aha waa going to oall the pOlioa a9ail1, i:\.i. La13\: November or December, 1997, Defendant beoame intoxio<lted and punched Pl<1intiff., She f.ell againat a kitchen , APpHllnoe Anel tnj I\rr~(j 1181' hl3<1e\, ~hreA~ened PlAintiff, iv, 'l'ln'oIlH\1ollt: t:l1e relA~.\.on~\1J.p Pef:amlnn\: 111W A11\I~ec:1 \)lldnH ~lrt.1l padocl Pr~f.ElnC\An\: aoohol <\l1d oont:l.\1I.\ollf.lly Ab\l~eel nnej l:ll1:ail~eneli Pl1\:l.n\::\.j:(:, 7 I '1'\1e P1I1in\::l.J:f :1.f.1 in immElcHa\:e Qtll1ger of: I'llr~h~r al)\~f.Ie and a CO\ll:t OrQI31, :l.p neoe~pm:y 1:0 proteot: hel'l 0, Pltl.\.n~.\.f.f. hilP no permnnent place ~o ~~ay a~ thip time, !J, 13eotlUpe Del'enelanl:, Pl3f13ncti1nl:' a ctilught13r., Wencty J)13luWt\r13, Def.enc\un~ 'p gl,aodctaIl9\1l:el', Sherry Pelllwnre, Pef.encttlnt' fl grandf.lon, IUl. Pell1Wtlre, <lnct Def.enC\fjnl:' [1 o\:her elaugh\:el.', !'fnnoy petroalcy, are pl:eaently Hving wHh or. huve been at1ly:l.ng from time to time at: I' ., Def.endanl:'S reaidenoe, Plaintiff O<lnnot rel:lIrn to the residenoe to live <\nct ~o yeoover Hema of peraonal property whioh ehe hila !:Irciugh~ to the rep:ldenoe over the Pilat yet'lr I 10, Thoae Hems of personal property are t'le fo11ow131 living 'room, eeotional pofa, pink reoliner, m<lntel olook, Chri13t:mlls oAotua, aloe vera pl<1nt," blAolc aide !:Iy alcte 1'13 C l' igEll;'U tor./ freel1el:' w/ioe & wafer malcer (approx, $1000), f.lve guna, Viotorian 1aoe HVing r.oom elrapee, Whir.lpool b1aclc smooth top rnnge (approx, $3000~, lcniolt Icnnolce, hunter green If.\oe bedroom drapes, burgundy bedroom bl:l.nds, Viotorian Chdstmaf.l deoorat::l,ona, Chr.:l.pt!mas lights, , Eleotrolux Sweeper, blaolc Sharp miorowave, ourousel, swing, floor bUffer, 4 solid oalc bar stools, oAlt nmgadne raolc, white lace ehower ol.lrtain and mutoh:l,ng curtains, 116" pl,oject:l,on 'l'V (approx, , I' $~OO()), ~511 ;'.e'nj.\:\1 oon!,!ole 'j'V, anow lJlowel;, IdCl!3 \:oyrJ, \Jec1room fJl,\i\;I3, \Jl'H'\t\\:y & IJI3<ul\: lJ:ll~e, umb~;ellC\ a~roller., IJlflok o1\nl,~ter 1313\:, !3Hvel: WClre, oldel; dlfJI1erJ, glflfJsefJ, !'lilvel; fJ\:one lJlaol~ pO\:!3 I;. pfln!3, whlte Nf'l' CIl1fJwedng I\1flohlne/phone, bluok Cobr<'l omcrUe!3!3 pMne, exerol!3e b:l,I~f,l, ;l flJr conCl;\.tionerfl, IJ8r1 piHowa anCl lJac1 olothe!3, towe~,!3, flower bet' Cleoort\t:l,oI1P, ;\ birc:\ hOl\!3e!3, ahlmef.1, t\nCl ;l frog!,! aittlna on f.anoe, 11, Plalntif.f. believes that ser.vioe aal1l1ot be aaCelY ef.f.eoteel by an adult inqlyictual other than a It\~ enCorQement oCfloer, 1;l, PIO):l,nt:l.f.f reqllel'lta f.tll:t:hel; thut: th:l.13 Court grC\nt her flttorneyll3 fee!3 anct oO!3t!3 pur!3uant to the proteotion From AbU!3e Aot, WI lIil lUl FOlu.1 I J?lai~1tH f requestf.l that tbh Honorable COl\l:'t 1\warct the f:ollowing rel:l.ef. I A, Or.Ell1t' a 'femporClry Orelet. purauant to the Proteotion 1'1'0", Abu!3e Act, a, order::l,ng Defendant to rJtop abu!3iI1g, hura!3!3:l.ng, thr.eaten- ing anc:\ atalking the Plaintif.f al1d atop plBolng Pla.\.ntiff in fear of abu!3e :I,n t\ny place where she l\1uy be found, 'C I 'Wieting' defendB11t flrom the rea:l.dElnoelooateq /'It 1117 'l'l.indle Road, C~lrliale, I?A. , D, Pr.ohibiting Defendant ,from hav:l,ng &ny oontaot wlth the Plaintiff, :Lnolllding but not limited to, l:ef.ltra:l,ning the Defendant from entl!lrinH the plaae of: emploYI11\'lI1t of: PH1int:l,f!:. 1i1, Orc1edng Pef,enc1nnt tp rel:l.nqnJ.rlh <Ill qunr{he ml1~l:pwn (:0 l:he Sherlff. oj: CumlJerlfll1c! COIl\1\:Y, l~ I PelCml.\:l:ing 1:1113 l?laint:l.l: f. to reaovelC nll :\.\:1311\13 ol! pelcfJOnnJ. proper.ty n~ fJel: eor.th, in Pflrugr.aph 6 nbove, G, Soheelule n hearing :l.n th:l.~ matter, U, j{eql1:1.dng Del:enc111nt: to pay OOfJt:~ iWfJoc:\,fltec1 wl.\;11 t1l:l.13 mf.\l:ter, I, Grl1nt:\,ng f\PY ot',her lceliel: the COllrt c1eemfJ appr.opr.:l<\te, " I" ..' C:,..... r." Rel( 13:\.01d. Y I rnl3qll:\,re 1,21, SOllth , reet Har.r.J.fJbllr I 1?n 17101 (717) 23j1-013'1'7 F1\X ('771) 234-'71332 1\tto~y f.or Plaintiff i' I 'I t, 1'1 " ,', \;\ , I., II 1,\ , ~ ~ , ~ ~ , ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~i ill ~i ~. ~!" Iii~ ~I~, - , ~ ~ ~ -~ ~ ~ -, ~~ \II L ~ ~ ~ J :100 ~ ~: m II n "' -U~ t' ~ ~~ '. v~ I ''''Ill jl;::l rc, I ~'" 1Q;:::l ~ ~ !jl , ~" I\: \lo, ~~ ~ I\: Ii' . ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~t.~~~~ ~ro ~~~~~ , ,'~: , 1.1, .~ :~: , "1 , m ~ ~ '~~ ,I ~ " ,- ~ ~ I . ~ I~ ~. ~~~'" 'I I ~I.; I ,~ .1111 '- I Ill' II ~ II ~ 6 1- m ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I j ~ l; I ' ,w _ ~ tl ~~ ~, ~ ~ ~ - ~ Ifi ~ U, I ' ~..~ ~ ' Il'~-' - ~'- - ~H ~ ~i ~ ~r-'llr'I~U~~~ v~ ~ I: ,~" "." k" '" , '" hR;~L J I Ii:." I ~ ~ I~~ U~~~ci~Q W.~~~a~~~~~~~n~~~~~~~~ I i I!J', I , , , . "..: t .~.",'._'" ",". ..)_'_',:.1 . ,.l' , ' r Vaqll1A ), IN 'I' II I'l COIJH'I' <W COMMoN 1'1,1'11\13 I PI" (JlIMI3l!1H1,I\NP COUN'l'Y, PI'lNNf\, ) F" ) ) ) ) NO, 9(l-36!i1 m:vn, 'I'J'1HM UHIV1111l,Y II, 1'1'II\IW1~, P11\J.n\:11:1' QloI0 IH1\!l n, 13M 1'1'11 , pafonelunt crvu. I\C'l'JON 1,1\\~ l'HO'I'I~C'I'JON I"HOM flllUflVI nl!ll~l\t'lllM~l'..~.!L.!.Ll'llimW Wl'I'II_pOIlN'l'1~\l(lJ!!\lM ,'1'0 11I,I\N'HI~I~ r JlliVl!lIH1Y ,I. 1l1~I\H<m It.!!.!IO'l'H10'f':t:.Q!LWIIOM 1\1l\l/:l1~ OOMI1l,1\1N'l' flNP NOW 00m08 tho Pafunel"nt, ooorgo PI flmlth, by ~nr1 through ~l~ ftt~r~u~l ur~~t 1\, potr?ak~, nnel r.oRpootfl111y nnsWora Plaln- tiff a lotlt ,on flOm I\bu60 ~B 10110Wal . 1, f\clmHtoc1, 2, f\dmHtuc1, 3, l)on1.oe1 I Pl,a1.ntll'f mnyocl into Dol'enc1nnt' a l:oa.i.clenoo na n rontor, 1'1ulntiff hOB reaieloc1 1.n \)ol'onc1011t'a homo slnoe nppl:oxlm.ll:oly ootobor, 1997, " 4, f\r1m i.\: toe1 , r, . !), flc11nHtod, 6, f\, \)unioc1 I P1AinU,r: I' oonal1mecl aloohol to ollooaa - elrank or finiahoel of.f two (2) bottlos 01' toquilla on Juno 24, 1990, Dofonc1ant only oonallmoel wator and iood too all dUY, '1'110 North M:ldrlloton 'l'ownahip l'oU,oo noyor romovod the Dof:en- dCll~t, Dol'one1unt cUel oontaot his broth or' by tolophone and askod him 1:0 00\\10 nnd gol: him so I:hat ho oOl1ld gol: Away fl:om the Plaintiff's lies, Tho Dofondont r.ol:ur.nod not on the next day aa pluinl:iff inoorrootly statos bul: rotllrnoel on ~ridt\y, Juno 26, 1990 at 12100 noon, Whilo at hia brol:hor's resictonoe, Doyor.ly J. Ponroe OAllod at his brothor's rosidonoo for Ooorgo D. Smil:h at 7100 a,\\1, tho noxt 1I191:ning, Jl1no 25, 1990, Ilia br.other told hor thaI: ho wne nol: woklng h.l.m up, Sho onllorl ug,d.n I1t Approx.l.mately BIOO l1.m, unel told his brothor'a wifo I:hAt ahe betl:or. wako him up bool1uao ho hnd 1:0 go BOO hia pr.obation ofl'ioor t\t 10100 a.m. nnd he horl to go thore by himsolf.. George D. Smith onlleel hiA probal:.l.on offioor t\nd aho waa not in tho offioe yot t\nel ahe oolled him baok lator 'tlHlt clay nnd at\icl aho hucl no nppoint- mont oohodnlod with him, Hoyorly J. I'ooroo oolloel aoVerul 11\0ro timoa thot cloy hl1rnst3iug (Jool:go I). Smith, hia brothet, Dl1d his brothor'a Wifo. I I, " I' " " "/' " " " " " " I " ' " I, 'i' .; " " 1,\ " :j, I' i; ii " ", 'it" Ii " " " " " ,I " " " Ii " " " " j,i I , .,t, " " H, " " i; , " " ~pL(r..';'Y' " I!') .( { ,.) I 1/((. " ~l '~ H " " " i," 'pbc)", b: I (' .;:..~ ii I,', . J, 01,1 t U 1'" " ,; " " 'I' " .' '1' " .' " ;; 11,.1./ POll.1.o<l, \)0 J'lllH11I11 \: clnClfl 110\: <lIlli/Hi \:1111 P:l.":\I1I:JH. \)pfoI111iln': rlJd 10Ho I1JI1 HCllJIHlIl il1 ^prl.:I. oj' 1990, bllt: ho h'ls " not: 11Clon llt:\,nld.n91 PIJI'OIlClnl1t: rlll\ 110\: nllllnp \:110 l'],aJl1tJI'I: 110r t:hrfJ,,\:ol1 1101' ll\\t~ wnH I1ll\\fWll: illl\\lwrl by 1101: I1nd I1llr \\n(:o\lnc10(1 \:11 lOll , (1.1) \)0111011, \)(1/'0\1c111 11 \: 1l1d 110\: rldnk nor nl)\\l1o I:lw plfd,nl:1H nOl: cUrl 110 \:hrol\l:l)n hor, Pofol1c1f1n\: rlootl liot own t\ hnl1rl91111, IJ'l1o plnll1t:it:J"n,ill1oC./I1\:lnl1H /lnl wJ.l:l1nllt: bfHlJ[l, (iJl) \)onJDll, poJ'unrll\nl: \~I\fl r1n.1.I1IJ O\ll:rd,rlo work, 1111 01\1\\13 111 J'or. wator nnrl rlipoovororl pll1.\.ntiJ'f 011 tho floor, 1'1llil1ifl' w.nfl r1t:l1nk nnd ~Hd,c1 \',l1l1t f3110 111Jppocl I1l1rl foll In\:o. tho 'lppHanoo (WII \:or ooolL1l:), (Jv), pon1..orl, 7, pllnJecl', 1'1flil1\::I.fl; 111\11 lI\iI[Io up S\:OdOll, 11: Js boliovocl thllt l:h1.,tl ia e1no to hor IIlool101\.o \1I'H\\IO I1nd/o)': l\\oeUolltion IIbl1fjo AS \~01.1 liS hOI: 1I\0l1tn1 problol\\ll, II0r nlHll1\plo on <Juno 26, 1~90, 1'1111ntil'f Htntod tl1nt I1ha WI\S going to kill tlOrne0l10 lit \)ofonel~ nl1t's r~fltdonall, Pho rtnyorl until ilnnu 27, 1990 nnrl drnnk , t\tloust: n hillf o[,gnl:l.on 01' toqllillA, pll1s otl1or milloel drinks IInd took modJaation, Tho loonl polioo on tl1nt dnto forood plaintiff to loavo, ^f.ter plaintiff laft, it Wl1a d.\.lloovorael thnt 000r.9u P, Hmith'll wnllot I1nd othor itel\\a wer~ misa~lg, 0, Unknown ilnd 6triot proal' ia demondoel, D, Plaintiff pould hovo rOll\uinod elloopt for her t\buae elirooted townrda thORO in Dofendant's r.onidonoel aha nlllO was 6orvod with oviotion puper6, Tho 100al polioo reqllostael that \:ha l'lainl:iff vacato tho PI:OI1d.sus, J?loinl:if:fwl1~ lo1:or oitod for her. oonduot by tho polioo, The polioe advised PlnJn~ tiff not to 0011\0 book for har thin9s ul1ti1 Rho ht\d n oonatAble with her to protaot the Defandant and thoso ranieling with tho Dufunelllnt, Plaintiff olraadY rell\ovad somo itoms of tho \lofan~ dunt, ^ftor tho polioo t\nd aha 10ft, she roturnod five minutos 101:0l: suyi.ng thot sha fo I:<J 01: 1:0 ~Iot hor meeHaine, , BhoWAa BPkud to romuin outllido nl1d 0001'90 D. Smith und his dUlIghtora ohacked the ent.\.re house for hor bl1q of I\\odiaino, The modioine wus not thoro nnd \~nfl bol:Lovotl to hovo nlroncly boon tt\lwn by Baverly J, 1'0(0:00, flho askod if fJho oould 0011\0 in nnc1 aha wna told no boonU60 tho polioo had told hprto lenve nnd not to oomo book unti.l Mondoy wJ.l:11 0 oonotob1e for her i tema, GoorcJo p, flmith told l,od.ne "Bnrnoy" flt:d,oklor thot he 001l1c1 \ oomu in und loo!t for thom but Beverly ,J, Pearoe prevonted hill\ I from goJ.ng in, II Ii II I 10, Unknown oxootly whu\: itoms ure still in tho res.1.denoe or woro rOll\ovod by tho Plnil1tiff:I It is admittod that the J?lni\1t.lff doos hovo fJOmO pl:oporty thAt sho hlfl: nt Defandant' El -2~ ,I " l:nuJ,rlpnIJOI It lu f\ll:\:hlll: i\vol,rOll I:hll\: Plll.\.n\:J,J:f I:nok propIW\:y of. \:hll pnl:ondnn\:, \1, Pl1nJ.ocl, ~lorvJ,CJn uonlrl bo by nlwbodY, 1\\: Ilnyl:lmn, wJ.'\:hon\: IlnylJol\Y bl1.1,n\l J.n dl\ll~I()I:, 12, pon.l.od. ~m~Hlq~'oHl~1 p(~l'onrll\l~t roql\r.~~ll:U 1:1In\: thJ.1i 1I0not:l\blu lJom:l: dony llAJ.nl:J.ff B 10qlloPl: IInd/ol dlsm.\.ap tho 1'01:J.tJ.0\1 f.\.lod ,bY tho 1'111J.ntiff, lJOIlN'I'lqI\Ol 'll:ll'l..JmlLllilo'I'NIJ'I'1 (}l'l...EJ.l,o~n!J.fi.!1 .\.3, ]'lIrll~Jl:llp\)a OI\U t\)rollcj\) twolvCl 111'0 .\.noorPOl:lIl:ocl hot:o,l,n hy roforonou IlS lf fUllY sot forth, 14. Iluvorly 0, l'uArop had boon on mudlonl:lon duo 1:0 hur amol:),on<ll l\Iloonl:rollllbll.i.ty 11ncl fOl: 0\:\)01' pl:01110ma, Ifi, pl1d,nfj I:ho p<lpt InDn\:IHl ahG' hilS l:hrul1l:onoel 0001".10 I). f.lmJ.l:\) i\nc'l ol:horp on ,numorol1a ooonI3J.ona, nnrl in I:ho pllPt two WooJ~P I:hl:ol\l:onocl to blll:n clpwn 0001'90 p, sl11U:h '13 ~Jl1r<lfjo wJ.l:h hJ.13 R\1I:J.guo oar ln iI:, 16. Bovorly JI 1'01'1'00 hal3 phYI3J.oally <lbl1l3eel Goorgo P. f.lmil:h IInd I:hol3o wil:h \)J.m, More pArl:'\'oularly 011 0uno 20, lP90, nl: t\)o roaJ.donco of Ooorgo p, smlth I3ho booRme violol1t nnel wus Ilrrosl:oel by tho 100al Volloe, 17, Ilovorly JI Poar.oo WAI3 givon UI1 ovial:J.on nol:ioo on JtlnO 26, 19911 to vaoul:o Goorqo p, 8mJ.l:h's prom!.aClCi prior 1:0, har '~ur.vin9 I:ho I',F.A, 6n Ooorgo p, 8mJ.th, i\lthoufjh aho oOllld roaido with Lor.tno Sl:rioklor. Ill, on 011no 26, 19911 Dovorly admitl:od to boinfj dr~nk IInd to drJ.nkinq I:wo botl:los of l:oquil1n while tAkJ.n9 mOdiot\\;ion. 19, On JlIno 24, Jun6 25 and Juno 26, 19911 Dovorly J, I'oaroo oul10d Ooorgo p, Smil:h's dnllghl:er 1:0 try 1:9 oontool: him,' It, ,20, On Juno 29, 1990, llovCJd,y ,J. liouroo /lgA1n CAmO 'to I:ho r.oaielonCJo ul: R\JProXimal:olY 12120 p,m. for. moro olol:hes, whioh OV01:yl:\).Lng fll0 IlCilwd for wus q.Lvon to' her, I ~l. Devorly J, 1'0Ar.OO I:olophonofl ooorge P. 8mith t\1: hill \ work, pnrl:iolllorly an Lluno 30, 1990, whon ho ia not t\llowocl I perdbnul oull~, whioh flho i8 IIWllrCJ of, ,I -3~ " ~~, 1l0vorly;l, 1'0llrl10 011 dnly 1 f 1 !.lOll lit IIpp1:ox.\.mn\:olY 13100 'p,m', u<111~J(' (loOl:CjP \1, pm:!.\:11 <1\1<1 nll\\u(\ H ul10 (JO\lJ,\\ (Jam\) np \:0 \:l:Y \:0 rl111d\HHl \:11111~JlI nlono un 1:I1UY oonJ,<l C011\o \:0 nil t\{j1:uoll\unl: 1111<1 wot11.cln' I: I1I1Vo \:0 C.JO \:0 0011.1: \:, 11110 nrr ,I,vorl n \: <1<m1"~Jo \1, !1.11\lth'H r(1[1!.ch'JlIOIl,II\: IIPP1:oX1mll\:0:\,y !i,4fi p,m, i111{l r011\/l1110(\ ontu1<10 tnlk1nC.J nl1<1 Wi1\1\:Il<1 llvoryth111C.J 1101' wny 11114 uho loft nt 6150 r,m, p\:nt'\'nU tl1nt "I'll HOO YOI1 1n Conrt on WodnDncti1Y," 0001'90 p, p11\ltl1 wnn HDrvod w1th tl10 I'ro\:uot.\.on U'r0111 /\1)\1110 COl\lpln1111: 1<1\:01: tl1ill: oVDn1ncj nt npprox:\.11\ntolY 0,15 P,I1" 23, pnvovly J, 1'0/11'00 ta nn nlool101 Anel pr.~~Ol::\.pt:l.o\1 nl~\H\or ,Who. 1~ vl.~l?I1\:, I1nv:l.l:C.J,~ !Jne'! tom\J01: /ll1cl noaoAfl \:0 Hro" htmfl wh10h nLO At111 !Joll19 tDLa.\.I1Dd hy lot, WIINHlWOmU, (}OO1:rjO P. !1mHI1, l:ac\nofltA \:hn\: th1A 1l0110rnb1.o conrt nwnr<1 tho fo1.1.owlI19 rolloI'I " 1, Urnnt u pOrmAnD"t ordor l:ofltrnl.n1n9 POVOl:1.y d, 1'0nrou fr.o11\ ontur.1ng Upol1 nny 1nn<1p or. hn11d.\.ngs of. ooorge 11, I3mHh II\: 111'7 IJldncUu HOIle'!, CnrU61,0, C\\1I\IJOl:1.l\n<1 COllnty, I'Dl1nsylvnn1a, lI\1d C.Jrll\1t1n~ Dxolusl.vB poflPoAP10n of tho prol\lls01 to Dofol1dllnt ooorC.Jo n, I3m1\:hl 2, OnlO1, Bovod.y J, ,pOllron to 6\:OP <lbnll.ng, haraAP1ng, 1111<1/or thrnn\:oninC.J OoorC.Jo n, Smith or. plaoing h1m in fOllr of n!Jnoo 1n any plAOO whoro l1u \\IllY !Jo founel, 3, "'Ptoh1!JJ.ti.n~1 l.lovDJ:ly JI 1'01\l:oe from hAV1ng nny oontnot wHh Ooorgo IJ, SmUll, ,i.l1olL\eUn~1 on.1.UnC.J h1.111 A1W\~hoL'o, 4 , IJJ.root IloVO.1: ly J, 1'0<11:00 to pny 00(11:90 n. am1. th' I ].oaa of oarnil1ga, I [J , D1root I.levorly J, 1'0nroo to P<1Y GDOJ:C.JO n. I3mith'i IIttornoy'l foos nnd oostll DJ.root Dovorly JI PORJ:OO to J:ofJ:o1n 1'r.0111 Itnlk1.ng Oool:go n, Smithl IInd 6 . '7. D1.L"oo\.:lluvurly ~r, POI\1'.'oo 1:0 1:oU,11C(td,6h all f.l.l,oUl:ml tht\t sho hos 1100011 to OJ: pOlflols10n of. I" \ II I , '- ~'- '~l . '~~~~;l1~Y f.0l; '~lJ' ldal1t Qeorrjo D. Bml.th 200 m. Wt\tor Stroot ],obk 1IIIvon, 1'/\ 17745 (717) 740,.lOln /\ HOJ:ney r.. D, NO I 17370 -4- .' /;' " I;' (';1 V, I .. ,. I( r , ,l( " ! , ,t > ' , I ' I'.'. I . ,. II , till I,. , ' I . : ,It\. ,; I!; r" t (1\ i:.l II" " If. , , , ' " " " " 'f 'f I' " " ", " " " 1; " " " " " .' " " " 'j, " ., " :1 " , , " ,( t' ;,! " 1 ' ", " ' jI " " " 'f/' Ii , . i1, " ,," 'j' ,t' I:: , I'I! <' , 1::1, (.,/, 'i /.', , i, " ;,,1 , " " "'1 " " " " " , " " " ,I "/. " I' .. I, " ", I, " (I', " ~ '. , I' " " .. " " , " ;i'! I I 1'1') t' I,.' I I,) r,t If' lI,l, 1)01\lo(\, pnJ'ollllnl1\: d!leUl 11<1\: n!JI\lln \:1\0 Pln1111:1,ff, pol'o\1dnl1t: 1\111 ,Ioflo hl,[\ llClOI1[\n 1\1 I\pr.\.l orlgulI, lJ\\\: hn IHIIl 110\: \lonl1 11rl\1ld,I1'J, IlCJrnlldnlll: 11,\.1\ IIP\; 111l\\lHl (:ho I'lnln\:.I.fl: IInr '\:I\I:on\:ol1 hili: 11111: wnll Idll\lwl f' n\}\\llllll IIY ho1' nl\(1 hOi: 11I1fpllIVh)(:\ I:nlofl I Ull \)011,\011, pornl1clnl\\: 111(1 110(: Ilr.\.l1k 1\1)): nll\1lH1 \:ho Plnll1(:,I,fr I\O!: 11.\.11 ho \:I\1:on\:ol\ hOI:, 1)0 (:ol\llnl\\: (100A 1\0\', oW\1 11 hnlHl\I\\l1, '1'1\0 1'1nl,I\I::\.H'u nl.\,O\ln\:,I,o\111 I1rn wH,holl\: Ilnu,\,to11 (:\.U,) pnl\lo(\, \101'0\1111111[', wnA (10111\1 0111:111110 \~orltt II() Ol1l1\l'l 1\1 fm: wnl:Dl: nl\ll e1l.rlDovo1'llll I'lnll\I:1 f'f: 0\1 \:hn J:Joo1', 1'ln.\.l\l f.f. wnl1 (It:\\l\lt ?1I111 Ald.ll I:hnl; uho nq.ppnll nlHl fnl]. :1.1\1:0 I:ho npp].J.nl\oo (wn\:CJr oClnlor), (lV), \lol\lml, 'I I pOI\.\,ol\, Pln.\.nl:l.Ef: hnA 11\11110 1\1' 13 (:or.\.ofl, :r\: :1.13 bo].l.oVI,irl \:hl1(: I:hln 1fl (lno \:0 hor nlonhol1o I\An\IB flnel/or 1110eHoflUon nhl\no nn.wo1.l IIn 1\01: 11\0111:111 }'l1:oblnllll3, 1"nr oXllmplo 011 .-Il\l\e 7.6, 199111 pln.\.I1Ur:r f.ll:l1\;ocl (:hfll: ahB Wnn \lo.I.I1IJ \;0 Idll nOIllPOl1e fit pofoncl~ nil I: , A ron1,(\ol\('O, Rho AI:nyod 1\11 \:,U, .-11\110 2'1, ].gUll I1l\cl elrnnl\ Ill: lOflsl: 11 hAlf of \1111101\ of \:oqn,U,lfl, pllln o\;hC:ll: l1\.i.>tocl (ld,nkn IIl\cI 1:(lDlt 1lI0rHoIII:1011, 'l'ho 10(1111 poll(Hl on \;hn\; (ll1\;e forood Plnll\\;.\.fl' (:0 1011VO, I\f(:or plllll1(:'\'ff: lof\;, 1t WflS d.\.noOvorBc:\ 1:11111: OeonlCl I), 13111.1,1:11' n WAlll1t 1111(1 01:1181: U:l1l1113 W01:0 1111 na 1ng, II, Unknown A\1~ s(:r.\.ot pronE .\.n ~omnndo~, 9, 1'1Il.l.nl;1J:J: op~~lc1 hnvol:ol11l1.\.norl oxuop(: fa!, hal: t\bnaa e1:l.1:aol:oel \:oWII1:(ln thono .1.1\ pufen(lnnt' n 1:oa1110noe, f.Ihe nlao ~na,n~rvu~ w.\.(:~ uvlot10~ P~I]or.o~ TI\e lac~l po~1~~ i:oqnal3~e~ \;hl1\; tho 11u1nl..i.f:f VAOUI.O l.la p1.ol111fleal llA1nl.l,\,f Wlll'l 11'\;131, o1.tod far hel: oon(ll1o\; by t:hu pOU.IJO, 'l'ho poU.oo AclvllWd P1Aln~ (:.\.ff no\; (:0 ODilia b110k for hor (:hll\fja I\n\:.\.l aho hllcl n oOl\sl:nble w1.th h01: t.a protoo!: (:ho Pel'en(ll1n!: nnd I:hone l:en.l.clln~1 wll:h I:he paf.on(1Ant, Pln.\.I\\;,\,f!: 1I11:01111y r0l11DVOll f,lO'ffitl l\:oll\i:l of. l:ho pof.on~ (111\)1.:; 1\ftOl: tho poJ.\.uo onl1 nho loft, nho 1:n\;l\1:n0l1 Hvo 1I\1nll\:on In(:or nny11\g thn(: aha forgo(: (:0 qat bor 11\011101\)0, aha Wlla IIn\to(l \;0 l.'e1l\t\.l.n oll\;n.l.de IIl\d Cl001:CjO D, I'lmL\:h I1l\d h.l.l1 c\l1l1fjh\;al:1.l ohoollo(l I'.hl) 01\1:.\,1.'0 h0\11111 rOl: hnl: bn"l of ll\oc\.l.cJ.l.no, 'I'ho ll\oc1.\.o.l.no WI1I1 nol.: thl11:o nl1l1 wnn boU.ovm1 1:0 hovu nlroody bon\) I:nlw\) by "overly J, POllraD, 8ho IInkod .l.r nho c0\11d oOIllO .l.n ol1d nho WOIl \;old l10 bOIll\utln (:ho PO,U,dO hrll1 l:cJld hor 1:0, 101l\,e I1n(l 'not to ,ool11e bllol\ IInl:.l.l MOl1(I,W wU:h 11 u01\nl.:nblo for hOI: 11:'011113, Ooor\10 D. Rm1.th \;olll !.,ol'1.no I!l\nrl\oy" fl\;r1.oltlo!: \;ho(: he oould 001110 1n nl1t110nlt f.nr thol11 blltBovot:ly 1I, Ponl:00 \wovonl:od h1.11\ rrol1\ \loln~1 .l.n, 10, Ilnlwown oxnoUy \~hl1l:. 1.\:011\0 IInJ AU.ll 111 \;ho r0131del\do or wo,ro rOll\ovoc1 by \;ho I' 101.n U f f, II:.l.n odl1\.i.I: 1:0(1 t:ht\ t: the l'ln1.nUff doon hllVo BOI1\O pwpot\;y \:hll\: 11ha loft 11\: Dofondt\nt:' 13 ~;!- l.'IlHj"l1nnllo, It: 111 fl11.'!:l\eJ1: Ilvorroll 1:11111: PI,II:\.nl:.\ff 1',ooK prPI~or\:y Ilf \:ho !lo l:nnc'\l1nl: , 1,1, Pnn:I,CJll1 IJdrv:\.oo 0011.1111>11 I>y IInyl>oc'\YI III: 11!\y\:ill\nr w,i\:hmll:\lIwl)oc'\y 1>o.j,I1'1 in 11nnljo\" 12'1 p0I11D1j, ~nl'llml;:(}I!I;ll. PI~fonllnl1\:, I'OI)I\I~fJI:fI I:hlll: 11011Y 1111,1,11\.11.1. Il 1,01\110HI. ,111<1 01, IUHl1ll.HO IIY I:l\o.l'll1.1I1I:\l'f, 1:1\.\.0 1101101'(11) 10 Up\1\.' t: \:1\0 po 1:\ t;.j1l11 f. .1..1. 0 c'\ mm!f!~~!!'Q.ll..llnLJ;:!-,~!LrJ\Q~!~tm~l'l lli'LJ!1t9.M..J\.!l!llil'l 13, PnJ:I1I,1r/II'hH ClI1I) I:l\roll\lh I:wolvo I\ro 1110Dt:poro\:ocl l\flre.1..n I>y l.'efol:ol1oe) 1111'.1.1' flllly pol: 1'01:\:1\, .If, 1I0vorly ,'1, l'onroe 11011 1>0011 011 11\0<1:\.001:1011 1\118 \;0 her 011\01:101111,1, 1I111.10111:rnllnld,l.Hy nll[l fo'l: 01:1101' 1'J.'ol) 1011\11 I 1 fi, IlII dl1q \:1\0 PliO\: 1I\0n l:hH fll\o I\lIs 1:1\I:01J \:01101.1 (1001:'1U p, 1311\.i.I:1\ lI11n o\:lw1:s, 011 111111\1]):0118 or,'onl~10I1s, nl1el ,il1 I:ho pilAt: I:wo WOOI\H 1:I\I:on \;ol1oel 1:0 1>1\1:n dOWI1 !'1D01:\IO I), IJlld. \;1\' /l ljt\I:II'1o w.l.t:h hi/J IInl:111110 0111: ill .\.I:, 16, 1l0varly.'1, l'ullroa hUB phya1CJIIl.\.y OblHlIlCl (]aol;ljo p, f1111,1.I:h 111111 t:hof1e w.i.l:h h111\, ~Io]:e pnrUol11Ady 011 dlll1e 20, 1990, " 01: t:l1o l:cnd,llalloa of GDorga PI Am.l.Lh aho \Jaonll\a v101l3n\: 1,11111 ' WllO IIrJ:e/l\:ael by I:ho loonl po1..ioo, 17," 130varly ,J, 1'0111:00 WlIfI \11Van nn evlol:.i.on nol:loo 011 ,h1110 26, 19911 \:0 vnoll 1:0 [Jool:ga \1, AIIl,U:h' B prolld.f10B pd,()); \:0, hale 8orv,I.119 tho P,fo',I\, on Q[30nla P. I3m.\.l:h, nll:hou\,/h Bha oou111 roe.\.de wH:h l,odno f11:d,0Itl8I', ' , ll1i 011 Juno 26, 19911 13ava);ly Admil:tad to 1>01ng drunk nnll \:0 Ill:.tnld,I1\1 I:wo lwl:\:la/J of l:oqI\U,lll wh.l.1,a told.n~, modiclnt:.l.on, 19, On ,Juno 24, .1Ullo 2~i on[l ,JUliO 26, 1990 IJevnr1y ,I, Pduroa onllad Goorga ,po Bm.\.l:h's dllllgh\:aJ: 1:0 I:ty 1:0 oonl:o~1: hl1l1, ' 211. on Jl\lIa 29, 199n, Bovol:1y il, l'l~nr()a 11\10111 0/111\0 1.:0 tho l:o/Jldono\3 III: II\Jp.l:OX.l1l1nt01Y 12120 1'.111.' /'01: 1I10J70 010\:hosl wh.toh ovoryl:ld.lIlj 1310 IIBkod [01: WIIA \J.i.vall 1:0 hor. 21, II cw 01: ly ,J, 1'8I1J:OO I:olophonos GOCll:qo I). AIII11.:h 111.:' hl13 WOJ:k, PIIl:t:.tdllll\l:ly on ,JUliO 30, 19!)1I, whon ho 1JJ nol: t\l].o\~Gd P01:BOII01 0111111, whioh aho 1[1 I1worll 01'. ' -3- , (.(., 111WCIl:ly \'1, 1'(11\1'00 on d\11y 1, ,19!ln /1\: nPl'l'o/ll\\1i1I:oly 51(10 1',\111 ofll\.oll Oon1:<jo p, fJIII.l.I:11 /11\11 1111\,0(1 if AI10 00111.<'\ PPl1ln \11' I:n \',):y 1:0 11.1.1111I1nn 1:11111<.111 1I1nllCl IW 1:l1flY lJO\\lt! nOll\n \:0 1\11 1I\lrc.lfllllol1\: 1\1111 W0\11(111' I: I1I1Vo 1:0 <.10 \',0 0011171:1 Rl10 nrdvn(l n\: {10(1):(jO Il, 81\\.l.I:I1'n 1:0111,(\011110 Ill: I1Ppl'nXl\\ll\l:01y 51451',\\1, 11i1'1 I'Olll111\1ml on\:fl\,lIn l:nll\ll1(.1 1\1111 will1l:all oV<lJ:yl:l1ln<,J hel: wny nnrl fll1n 1.01'\; 1\1: (i1!iO 1',11\, al:n\',.ln<.l 1'.\)111: "r'1.l AOO YOII 111 CP\1l:t on Wot!noR<lI1Y, II OOOI'IJO PI fJlIIl \:h Wllfi I1nrvocl W.\. 1:11 1:l1o\ll'o\:rl(J \:1.on 1~l'o\\l I\b\1uo Clll1lp,\I1\.nl: lnl:ol' 1'.11111: ovnl1lml nt, I\PPl'oXll1\lIl:01y Illl!i p,\\I, (.3, Ilovor.\.y \'1, 1.'(1I1.1,'oo..i.fl 1111 n1.ool1ol I\nll prenorl.pl:.\.on III~\H\CH' wl10 11~ .vlr~lol1l:, I1I1V.\.I~<.I ..11 lHHl I: 011\ 11 f.l1: nnrl11000nll \:0 fl,l:e~ ,H\\IA wl1.\.nl1 1\10 a 1..1. 1. 1. \lp.\.n<.l 1,ol.lI.\.nocl I)y 10)" Wl1lmlWOI\fQ I ClOOl:\jO I)', H\\I.\.l:h 1 ).'{Hl\IOIl 1:13 1:\)/1 I: I:\).\.H 1I01101'lIblo Courl: nWI\1,<l 1:\)0 fol10w.\.n\1 l:lll.\,of'1 1 I Clrllnl: n pe1:lIlAllell\: o 1'<1 Ol: 1:0Htl:t\ln1\llJ IloV01:lyJ, \'01\1:013 1'1'011\ onl:od.I\\1 UPOIl I1IlY ll\l\ll11 01.' bu ,Uel 1 11\/11 or Cleo1:<Je " Il, 13111:1.\:h lIl: 111'1 '1'1'.\.1)1110 11011<1, cud.\.alo, cllmlJodnl)el OO\\l\ty, P0l111ay ,1.voI11a, il\111 grt\I)I::I,I1(,I ell01\\ll.\.ve PO!3fil€lllllj.on of. I:ho 11l:em.\.aoll \:0 nofoI111,0"\: (1eor\le p, 8m 1.1: h I 2, 01:r1e1: lloVOJ:1y ill peorrH~ to 'sl:op IIbllll.\.I1~I, I1Url\llfl.\.n<JI 1I11l1/IJl: l:In:Olll:1.111111<j (1001:<10 PI Rm.\.l:h nt' p1nrd.I1<,J h.\.m :1.11 fOOl: of: Ob\\Fle .\.11 111lY pll100 whore ho '1IAY be fOlll1ell 3, 1',1:011:1.11.\.\:1.11\1 Bovot;'].y J, I'UllI:OA fl.'OIll havlnlJ nl1Y OOI)l:i:\ol: w1tll <1oCJr<JD n, 1:1111,\.I:h, :l.1101\\I1:1.11IJ onlU,m/ hlm I1llywhel:e/ /, ~ , 1li.I.'OC\: Bovo!: 1y ,1, I'O(ll:CJo \:0 PIlY GooJ:\le n, Sill 1 \:h' a lOI16 of 01l1:n111\)IlI B,Il.\.roo\: )laVOl:.1.y.1, peoroe \:0 PAY OeorrJe D, 81111t'II'[3 nttorl1oy'fl feoll And aoatuI , G, D.\.root 1l0vot:1,y ,:I I POl\rlle to rofl:oll1 froll\ 1l1:011d.1)\l 0801:\10 n, sm:l. tlll olle1 , 7', 1):\.1:Ulll: Bovor1y iJ I l'on1:01l l:o rol.1.nq\\:l.ah n11 1':\.l:eol:1I\1l thot Aho ,hnll noooall to 01.' pOllHAaa10n of:, , 173'/0 .,~,. I: ' ,13\UVIi1H l,v (I, PIi1T11WI,l, p1.o1.1nt::I,I: I' HI 'j'lIm COUH'l' (W COMMoN PI,lUl\E10l" C\JMUI,lHI,TlND COllNtl'Y, PElNNf.lYINTlNlI\ CIvn, AC'l'~ON " 1,1\1'1 9(1-3661 CIVI~ TElHM v GltiO\Wl,1 \), 13M I'I'lIi pe f;endAP\: 1'IW'l'P1C'I'TON PHOM ,i\BlIf.l1U TN IUU I I\GRlUlilM1UN'I' QlillillLQE....illl..!lRT AND NOW, tld,f] O\:h elAY 01: ,July, 199B, in uooorelal100 01' the agreement of tho pElrtieB, us Annollnoed in open oOllrt and 1n the1r presenoe, the oroof3-oompla1nts 1n proteotion fl,OIl\ abUfJe E\l:e r~eell\ed withcl1:awn, It if3 c:\:l.reoted thAt oer\:A:l,n proparty desoribed in tho lif3t f3ubmitteel il1 open oourt and \11i\l:kad af3 lUlIhi,bi.t No, 1 f3hall beooma the property of the plnintHf, It is hlrthel' el:l,reated that on a Suturdny or €I Monday, w1l:hil1 two weoks of today, as t;ha partief3 shall ugrea, the deCendnnt will open hie home to the plail1tifl' for the pUrpOf3B 01' removal 01' the itomf3,.li~tael in lU~hibit No, 1 nnd under cd.J:O~lmstunoes i.n whioh neither party ehall have, ,or ahnll " 0',1l10umO aloohol, Any 1,0\11u:l.nin9 proparty :l.SSllef3 EIre praeerved ,und \11ay be purf3ued without prajud:lae in the ,nppropriuta 1'0rU\11 I " By the Court, '/~r' /) IqL Kevip' j\,"'-I1eel3, w, , r", Itex Biokley, msqu:l,re Por the Pla:l.ntiff /' I I ' 'I ,t' (b' (.,,,.J' lw) /I....,",.,(.,t. I I ~ ( , ,. , .\,,'0', Brent A. Petrosky, Rsqtiire For the Defendant lug " ' ." P~V~R~Y ~, VpnRCR, l'~,AintHf. IN 'l'm~ COUR'l' Ol~ CPMMON I?r~lUMJ Ol~ CllMlmlU,l\NP COUN'l'Y, \?I~NNI3n.VnNIn 1'10, UU~36S1 U1Vl~ THRN CIVIl, l\C'l'ION l,nW j?RO'l'~C'l'ION 1!'1WM l\l3Ulll~ V~, QlJ1oR(H~ p, /:lM!'rH, pef.enclAl1t QE'l'ITION 1, Ypur petitioner ia Plairitif.f heroin, nevorly ~, l'earae, 3, On June 30, 1990, PlAintiff. filed a Petition for proteo- tion f.l:Om 1\bu~e I 3 I 'l'hh Court:!3ignec'l a t;e1l1POrAl'y Order on the !3f\me c'lay I 11 I In ~el'ving lInc'l e:)\:oaut:l,ng !3Ed.c'l Ol'c'lel", l:he CumberlAnc'l " County I3heriff'a Offiae a~ao confipaA\;eel guna At the Defendant'a home apeciHoall.y inoll1c'l:l.ng a ,33 w:l,th a acope, 3 Dahy DB gUlla, A .' I I1:LO ~hotgun, 'al1other dUe (mAI~e unlmown) and poaa:l.bly o\:her gl111a I 5 I All the gun a l:l.ated Elbove Actually belonged not to the Defenc'lant but \:0 \:he P:J.A:lntiff, I 6, On July 0, 1990, pluint::l.ff t\nd Defendant appeal"ec'l with counael anc'l ente):ec'l :l.nto an Orcler of Court, t\ copy of whioh i!3 attached hel:eto whel"ein Proteat:l.on from Ab~l!3e petition Wt\O 1'\ , withc'll"awn anc'l tht;l Defenc'lant. relinquiahed to the PlaintJ.ff. oertAin , items of. pe'r13onal prOpel"ty j,nclud:l.ng "gun!3.I' . 'I ! According to the ohed f f 1!3 Of: f: ice, they will need an Order directing them to turri over the guns they oonci!3ct\ted in .VIilUf'.lDli'l'l.QH T, naverly JJ, PellrOf), VfJl::I.I!y l:l\nt: \,:1\0 Ptnt:omel1t:p II1"Qe 111 t:h:l.p l'13t::l.\;:I.ol1 ,u:a \:nm <111(1 Oo'l:l:eo\: to 1:l1e be~lt of my :l.ill!orl11t1t::l.on, Imowleqge ant1 bel:le/!, :r f!ilft:htw IIncjm:l'lti\llcl \:I1i.\\: ./!qll'le fJtntel11fll1\:f.l l11E1cle hare:l.n m:e p\lbjao\: to tihf3 pen<1lt.i.eJ] of 10 1'~1, c,'S I !jI\90,1 re11'lt::l.ng t:o UI1Pworn fnlp.i.f:l.oilt:.i.al1 to <1ut:l1arit:l.ap, DC; l:e l.;t~'f/P i1.f' " ~"'~~~r/ ~u.(I't~? Bl~vrnlu.. " PEllIRClJJ ,. ,. " II,', h " " " , " " I' " ',. i' ji " ".J H (I, " " ,. " 01, ii' .. ii' !i " 'H If " " " h ,. " 'c. , ,;1 " " ," 'Ii ",. (J' .J: 1'1 , ' 11,1 fl' l.l'i I',' ")( I" (' "r I 1,1, j"l\; 11'1' I' " l,.1 ,,\ I.i;' ,'.: . " " ';-' ;I...:r I) .I ,',1.'.1 'j:', ,','I;':i #',';(; i '(1 :;,:11.. ~:J " ,I- !H 0. " '.:1 (.) ~; .,1 .,.J ~. I (I,) U\ " I"~ ;1' j! " I' " ,. " " '; i ,,~',. Ii" " ", 1;.1 " , ,. I' ., " p \I " ".It; II. iJ I' j' " I, 1" ,. Ii " I' /,