Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-03757 'I I I 1 I )! ,1 ~. \ ~ I" Ii " I', ., , " , (I " " \1 11 'I' " ,. ,,; " " " I. " d' ~ , I ~I "~ .. t ..... ~ ,. I' \I' " ", " ,Ii' r" I' i':jl:~; < \)'1 I,; " " '~ I< I' 1"\ il, " \ \' ",' , it I, H " ",,1' I.' I' l' .t-' i\ it I' ,. " , f"if 1 'J' " ./ I' H I' " " iI I' .. I, " " f' " " Ij " 'Ii 'j /, , " II " " " /Ii, " ,. ;' " ;! , , !! '.\ " " .i.' " , 'I' .1' Ii " II I' il /,':, (I ~ 7"'- .. ..::;) .. ~ ~ ~I " "I "C) ~ ~ . ~ ! " Ji I" '" II; I' ,. ..f' "~I ,. , " ,,' J! il. i, ;" " ., " 'I. ,'l" !i " i " 'H ,. '" " I' Iill'ccllol1, I), Alllw IIl1l11e Ihllo, Ilmo, IIlld IOCllllol1llvol'l'cllllhol'o, IIw 'l'l'll11hlo I'ohllllo HOHIIOd ovel' 1110 cOllI 01' orlhc I'OIlI\WIIY 11110 Iho Plllh ol'Iho llollry I'ohlclo III which 111110 Iho Ion 1'1'0111 of' !hl! 'l'l'll11hlo vohlclc collldod wllh tho lun I)'oll! ortlw'lllllll'Y \'llhlclu, Ill, All II 1'0111111 ol'Iho cnlllllloll, MillOI' Ilnlll'Y Illcllrrcd Iho Ihllowllll\ 11l.illl'lcH Illld dlll11l1l1oll: IAIUO\'llllol1lllllld IIllhllo'l1l0111 lIulIlTlll1I of'hlll IIclllp 01' hOI\II; 1ll'0liOll 111111111 100 of'hllllon tholl . Ilriillllll~ 1\1111 IIwolllllll 011 hill hOlly; 131'1111111111111111 IIl1hllcllllUl1l10l1dllllllslll1d/ol' 11111111111111111011 of'lho Plll0111l1' o f' hill Ion 1\1100; Poop IlI0orllllol1l10f'lho hllOkllldo ol'hlllloll hlll111 1I11111111y l'o'lllll'll1l1l1lx' IIl1toholllo clnllo 11l1d IIl1hIlO'l\IOI1t1y 1'0'lull'lllg lI\11'llOI'Y 10 oOl11plololy 1'011101'0 II . dlll11l1god t0l1d0I111l1d/ol' olhol' 1I110rnlll plll'I ol'lho loll hlll1d IIl1d l'o-HlIlohll111 II, h, 0, d, 101111011 0, i I 'I IIl1hIlO'lU0I11 10 III11'gOI'Y; 1', 1'01'11111110111101111 or 11110111111 pOl'lnlll1onl II111ng\ll'ol110111 01' Iho 111111111 Illlgol' ol'lho Ion hlllHllllIlll'Ollll1l 01'11101'011101'111 ol'Iho hlldy plll'l dOHorlholllllll1l'o, whloh PIIl't hml 01l11110010d 110111' nl' to tho 111111111 nl1gol' Ill' IIl1ld hlll1d 11l1d \Villi 1l0001l1l1ll'Y 1'111' 11111101'1111\1 f\l1lctlol111l1d III1C, SlIoh Inllll 01' 11110 11l1d dlllligul'oll1ol1t 11101ude: " (I) Iho POI'Il111l1ll11lll1l\hlllty IlI'Mll1ol' HolIl'Y 10 1\101'0 Ihe Illlgol' Il1depol1dolltly ol'olhol' Iil1g01'1I1111 tho hl\l1d; (II) tho pOI'I11I111011111111hllity 01' MillOI' HolIl,'y 10 flox tho nl1gol' lit -J- Cflll~.',I~II.IRlllL:JMIl':lnIU1QLJ1tYny.;.lmllEln.ll,J]~JMI11"1iL::._~H~II.,1 U 11NL~U 15, Tho 1\\'CI'I11\ll1la llf'PIII'II!\l'Ilpha 1 Ihl'ollgh 141\1'~ hlllnrpol'lIl~11 horoln \1y I'lll'cr~I1C~, 1(1, Tllll ~olllalol1 of'llw WhlplcH 111111 1l\llIrl\la 111111 1I111111111~a 111\1111'1'01\ \1>' MilloI' 110111>' \1'01'0 Ilw 1\11'~Ollllll\lllr proxll1l1\lO 1'0all1la of' Ilw groaa 11\l1l1l1l~1100, IWllIIIJ0I100, IImllol' 110gllgol10\l pOl' ao of' 11111101' \)cl'cl1dlll1ll~o\1orll\, Trll11hl~, 1\1 Ihlll ho: II, 1\I111'1uilod Iho Trlmhlo Vohlolo to (11'0011 10 dl'll'o II'lIh lil1ll\l'lol\gc Ihlll hu II'IIR 11111101' or \l'o\lld hu 11l1dl,ll' Iho Inl1l1ol1ou of' lI\(1ol)(lllll1d/ol' l\ol1ll'ollod 811hallll100a lOll \\olll'oo 1'011d\ll'll1g hi 111 I 110llpllh 11,1 of' I\rlvlnlli h, ' Ill1tl'llalod 01'0011 to dl'll'o IhoTl'll11hl~ Vllhlclo wllh liIlowlodllo of'hla pllal pOOl' I1l1d/ol' I1cllII1WI11 dl'lvll1g roool'd \11' hlatol'Y; 0, El1ll'lIatod \)0110110 1.01\\111 Tl'lmhlo 10 0111'0 Ihl' I1l1d/ol' 111'11'0 t1lo:\'l'imhlu Vohll'lo 11'11011 ho kilOII' 01' a\1illlld hnvo liIlo\l'l1lhl1l aho wOllld alllwolllIol1ily pOl'lnll 01'001110 <Irlvo Iho I'uhlolo ;' d, HI1II'1IRIClI 1)0110110 1,0111111 Tl'hnhlu 10 0111'0 Ihl' 111111101' dl'll'O Iho Trll11l1lo Vohlolo whol1 ho kilOII' 01' aho(jld hllvo kl1owl1lhlll aho WOllld 81111soqllol1tly 110 OOIlSlll11illg hOl'ol'lIl!O OOl1ll1llllllg 1I100hollllld/ol' oOl1ll'ollml slI\1sllIllooa Ihol'ohy hnplllrlllg hol' .!lIdl!llwlIllIlld 1'0llSOlllllg 1\111111108 slIf'!1olOlltly 1'01' hol' to 811hsoqllolltly p01'l1111 Ol'cClllo dl'll'o Iho 1'0hh)lc; ! i WI.IEREFQIW, 1'IIIIIItll'f', Hooll ^, IlollI'Y, 11>, IImllhmllgh hi!! PllIllltll'l'plll'olllS IIlld glllll'llllll1S, dOl11l1lld JlldglHclIllIglIlllRI \)ol'olldlllll R, 'I'l'Il11hlo IIlld sock dlllnl\gos 111 OXOOSs ortho JIII'Isdlotllllllllll11101lllt 1'0qllll'illlll\l'hltl'lIlIolll'orol'l'l\1 hy 1001111'1110, -7. ,. I" ~I ..'J 'J- "" Jf ~ \0 1''\\ l~ 1'1 " h ", r. \/, :;. " ,. 'L' " ,. tH' " !i " , , " " " " ,. .' I'," " I' . I ." .. " ,. " I " ;; '1< " , , d d ., , , I' I , ,'I ("1 , i I ;C:: 1.11(" " I 1; ,I " r' \ ,- Ii ' 1',1 ':i i. [I ,~ ,I', , 0 -/)' ,'i 'I II i 1 Ii " " , I ',il) - " " 1 l.l., I! rn I ..-' \)1 '-.J ". Ii " " Ii ij " I' il I'., 'I Ii "" " " " ,; " 'I I' it ,;'t ,. I), " " " " I' j. \, ~) ;~ ") \'l ",,-\ . sl ~ (j'~ " I, , il! I, f I!' v!'l I' I \ l-JII' i!!\'.'1 iil ;111 i II I I, tIll ,i I Ii' : ,\ I, I (1!ltll 'l' ,i,ll I,lllil\j \.1"'1.011 III Ii 1'1 I flldll .1' I h I', III \'. I '1:lil II , II Ii I .'JUI Ii 1::1.: II 1':1:. 1\1 I, .. . " " 1:1: I /111 1IIoldl I , i: I Ililill' 1;1 /dHi I dlUl" f 1'\'Hil ;.' j "i,jIH 1,I\i, L iii:' \i 11\\1 lii'I'I.l11. 1\1111 ,.----- -" ., Iii Ii"ti;\ I':: lillI/Ii i,djl_J;;U l'I!I,U:TI;q-lIll'l\ lr ,11,1 \'lllld\)1 l,-,',J:\ \1 .',11 1II'II!'"" .'''' ,I. \'11\ 'I' 1,.1; I' h \'11111111'1' .111'11''1'111'1", il\.'II)::I..!'" " ." I' " I' " di,';'1 \11 III. LH.'I"d'i' ,111,'11 1:'1 '(' !.tll!' Iii' I IHI 111\1 ;1\11,\;( II ;11,:' -, i tllllll " II'iI': I oIil ! 1.'1' \{,!i I" 'It II Ililj"IC 'llil',' , ' '1111111':1:1,/\/11' .I Lrlli' ;lHll 11\.i:'l-il_l.'rl 1,'1,'1;'/ 11'1 UIt" 1:1.'\1111;'/, l'I"IlII._I'(.l\'dHJil. li}' liilll.'!'il\iT 1.;1 j!j!JI,:I:~T11;Hr;H !'J'j;',dn'I-:U 1;11.1 III: 111111,1 I If'l'" 1\ un '" ;'?iJIt~~ (!;;!t!~ l~, ',\,11111;1''1:: I: I iii' f ,Iii './ i rr ." l.\i', '111'i1IM:I, '1, '.'I i 1"(;~'tll . , ' ,./;.:f.!I{,\I1~..' .'.,' 'I'I f L 10,1 i 1-, li,1 _ - 1. i ArnA^- !VIA , "\,:,'),,, N I h", 1 i II ," ;lnd "II till' ,'JdUII;" ,\ IllS:, d.i I ..'f' j (1\1 11) l' ,'f' I. " ,. ~.' Ill'" I 1:'1 . i i (j 1 'i L~:;: f'lil Lvi, I (I(J ~,: I 'I I! -if' i-' 1\ j ,I \ 1,1,','11.' I. t- ,III', I, ill'II' 11;\; (11(1) n, I'll' ". t,(/I r.. [fili) :' 'I~(\ " ,,1/"11, .[lld :j-I 1.1' ;,,1 l),y liP.' II );_11 , '-I''" ,td"1 I I~' I,I Is' f([. II, 1.1, '--.\"1(.(_ ~). IJJ'l~ee~v -r I fr'[ " Ii' '111/,/ ,j l LQ,a/"l il. ( ,. ,', 1'1';' 11'j I, I i I)~ II t I fill j P ht:, , !:1Jt!,"!1 \T 1.1)\~'r ';11:1 . .. " ,. " . " "~,I 1',"'11 " " .. " Ill! 'j' I. I' " " ExhlbllA ''''''11',,;., ,,,' iI'" "P .(<, (~}I) ,. " I. ..' 'j, " ,. " " Hi! ,. ,.' ",' i! I. H " , H H 1\ ,q \-,' l!' .. ,. " " " ,il I' I; " ,. ,. I " 'I' " U " , if' ,. I' " I' " , jli ,;' " " " ,I' I: " ., {, I. ,. " " '1. 'I; , " I' " 'F " " " J, {' " .' " " " ,I; ,<,," ';, \1' " , /.' " . Q7/~~/~8 \VllP IN7 fh~ 714 21 P STI\T1l fh~11 C~HI I(lJQQ~ , I I " dJfJ#rI38~1 ~~?-lp~ , \ \ I, , IN TI'~ CCUll'r OF COMMONPI.r.Ml, CUM'\u!I1P,.NP CQUN1'Y, PENN~Y)'..V A.1'{IA CliARL1!/i f,:,HOJ.TP.V, lJ\, IlIlII HARRlnFJLIRQ . '~lJaANM,HOJ.Tl\y,lnlllvlq\\\II1)'u,ml JUL 221998 Ils~I,",~n\J/8\lanU~n. on \lchl1lf of aCO'rT 1\..' UOLTRY, "Minor, R~CIUIVep m l3IPSlll'VilI" Rollll NllWVlllll, Ph 17241 rlfllntlffl V, I I , I No, q\,. :3 ?S1 ~~... Civil. L\lW cmuaTom:an,IVI,OREUN, a Mlnpr 4~ Water atTccl Wlllnlll 'Flo\tom, M 17266 pONui.....a J-EANN TRlMBl.U, a MinOT .anll. RO~nRT n, TRlMEIt..B, Inlllvldllally IIIIQ , liS pllfcmVallardhlll ofpono\lll J,.lllUln Trimble 64 MO\lnlflln View TlllnOIl NIlWVlllo, FA 17241 Dofendanls NOTICn TO DUFnND YOl) HAVE nUEN SUED IN COURT,IF YOU WIS~ TO PEFEND AOAJNaT nUl Cl.AlMa SUT FORTH IN THE FOLLOWING PAGES YOU MUST TAI\.E ACTIONWITHlN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER T1{IS 'COMPLAINT AND NOTICE ARESBRVEP BY ENTERING A WRIT1'EN I\PPEARANcn pnRSONALf.,V OR DY AN A'ITORNBY AND FILING IN WRITING WITH THE COURT YOUR DUFBNS~S OR oamCTIONS '1'0 THE CLAlMS Sf-'f FORTH AGAlNST YOU, YOU ARE W ARNED THAT IF YOU FAIL TO DO SO 1'HB CASE MAY PROCBED WITHOUT YOUANO A ,Jt1))QMl!NT MAY BB El'ITJiIU!D AGAINST YOU BY TlfB COURT WITHOUT FURTHER No'rrCH FOR ANY MONEY CLAIMED IN THE COMPJ-A.IN'1' OR FOR ANY CLi\lM OR IlELInF REQUESTBD BY THE PLAINTIFF, YOU MAY LOSE MONEY OR PROPERTY OR OTHER RIGH1'S IMI'OR'r ANT TO YOU,' . YOU SHOULD TAKE nITS I' Al'Jm TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCB, IF YOU DO NOT HA VB A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE TUB ' OFIlIes SET FORnI BELOW TO FIND OUT WI-mIlE YOll CAN OET LEGA.L HELP, Cumbcrhll1dCounty Bnr Assoolatlon "", 2 Uberty AVllllue . l Carlisle PA 17013 T~UE OOpy FRCM RECORD (717) 249.3166 Il\1reirtlnl~n~' l~hUrilof I I hflru un1t' tIS! II1Y hiltld IIntl tllB 5001,01 snld ~~;. ~~ C<lrllcll1, f'a, Thl~, f t day ~"__I" ~<J'~,t 191P . . ~ ,~~~ {(, 2!t~!.~ ~J~.. , ,lltottiOnolAty 0".".......,..'" 07/~~/~& \~P !~197'fhl 77~ ~11~ ~1'hT" !'h"lI cl.,\l1l @l09~ A\lpmll~ Cpr NllInllffftl Mlphucl J, W\l~on ~ll\,IP Nllt! ,26aO ^\\om!l~ at J.l\W al~ Pllrlly l\V~m'll ' GUl\111 Hili, PA 1701.8~67 (7\'/)774.70111 (717)7'/4.7019 (fl\ll) . \~.t\RP,'8B~JFI") JU~ ~ 't 'a~~ ~~C~'v I-~ - " ' I'N l'H~ COURT OF cOMMON l'l.UI\S, CUMUmU-ANP coWrY, P13NNSVlN ^NlA , scon ^" nOl.T",V,lI Minor, by hl~ OUlU'lIhms I CH^lU,ES r." IlOl.TIW,~, 111\11 I SUSAN M. HOl..'rR.V, lndlvlduully ftnd . I us O"lI\'d\tm~ pf allolt ^, HoUr)' I 7 \ \ JlloJorvlllo ~\()ul\ I NIIWVme, PA 17241 I PIllIntUn I I v, , ! \ i , CHRlSTONi.BR M, GltEEN, II Minor . 42 WilIer sn-cot Wlllnlll DllttolU,l'A 17266 DONEl..l.B LuANN TRIMBLU, l\ MlnQr -lIJld. RODERT B, TRlMDLB,lndlvldua1\y and a~ p!lfellllguardlan of OQnelle Leann Trimble 64 Mountain View Tem\co Newvl\lo,PA 17241 . I I I l'lO, 'l~..3 751 C~\.l. T',t......" Civil. LIIW Defendunl& COMPLAINT ..1, JllalntlffCharles L. Holtl'Yllr" (C, HQllry) Is un adult Individual and parent aT ,; .' guarcllunofSnol1 A, Hollty,ll mlnor, and rOllldesal the abova-aaptloned adMan whloh Is sltuale III CUlIIbllrlnml County, ~anll&ylvanla, 2, JlllIll\tlff Susan M, HoUry (5, Holtry) 1& an IIdult Individual and parcnl or llUlUdlun .\- P7/~~/~8 Illll1 ~~'P8 1'0\'177-1 ma ST~l'll I'''IIM c'-^lll talPQ~ , 1 HI', f;?,V(1Fi8IJRCft Jill ~ ~ 1998 \lr~QPIt A, Hpltly, ~ mlnpf, 1lfIc\ fl'NlllplI IIIUIP ~hPvo-PIIPllpn\l(I lIc\drcllR whlnh III NillI~lp in r~,,"~':'1 II I:iP , I Ollm\J\lrl~nc\ CIlIIIlIY, 11onn'Y\VlIfIlll, 3, ' PllIlnllff SPPI! A. Ullllry (Mlnof Hpll1)') III IIll1lnof Inc\lvldlllll Rod fafic\pllII Iha lIhpVIl-Ollpllllllllc\ 1Ic\t1rcall whlllh III Rlmnlllln Cllmullflllflc\ CQllnlY, J'llnnsylVllnlll, tt, Dllfpnc\ant Chrislopher M. Green (OfCeTl) III 11 mhlPf anc\ rcaldllR al Ihp a\lllvP' Clllpll~lIlcc\ 1It1d\'~R whlllh III lIhllllto In Gllmbllrllllld COIIIII)', llClnn~ylvllnlll, Up 011 Informlllhlll lInc\ pllllef, 111IIIIIIH'(1l al\"~" Ihlll Do(endllnl Groon 111111 \:101m ~llIecc\ hy oPlUt Ilrc\er c\alC<.\ DOllombcr II, 1 ?P7 of Jlldlll' HlIfOld at Shpoly" InlCl ~ plllC\lmaOl t\lcllll)' ofllnkllQwnldonllly IIlld IQIl"dpn Qffllctlvo JlIllllary 13, I ?90, ~, Dafnllllant Don\llloLllllfm Trlm\lll1 <M,lnllr Trlm\llo) \s II minor IIml rOllideR IItth\l IlPOVQ.clIPllllnc4 lIc\drC:Sll which III 1Il1ual"In Cum\lorlllfld Cpun\y, llllllnllylvllnlll, , 6, DefcndMI Robcfl E, l'rlmblo (Trimble) h 111\1141111 Inc\lvlcltlalllnd ppnmt or gUllfdlllnofDoll~Uo Loann 'I'rimblolllldl\t Iho tlme porlod ."t forth h~f~tn holQW was the \tile IIl1d fe~IBl9rctl owner of a 1 !l!l2 Chevrolel CavIIUer, PClnnaylvanl1l relllatTllllonplMo num\ll,lr MWB228, Pennsylvania 11110 voh\cloldontlflcatlon numb or 4461>5533601 (horelnllilel' "Trimble " Vehlole"), 7,. Oil or IIboul September 26, 1997, at or about 11 :00 p.m" Oroon waa operaling the Trimble Vehicle In a weslbound dlreotlon on SR.0641, ppproxlmatcly IWCl"tol\ths of Onc mile .. fl'om lu Inler8lllition With TR.427 Croek Road, in WeS\l'ennsboro Township, CUlnborland COllnty, Pennsylvania, 8. AI the slime dille, lime, and loentlollllVe!TcQ abovo, Minor HoltI)' Wllll oporntlllll n 1997 Chevrolet Cavalier, I'cl\nsylvlll1la rOllistratlon plate numb or WR2090N, l1cnnsylvo.nlatltlc ,. -I. . " vehlole {dentlfica\lol\ humberS0118!l660101 (horclna[\cr "lioltry Vehiole") In an eaatbountl -2- 07/~~/PQ ~p ~~IOQ rh! 77~ 211~ $ThTI> F4Rll C!.h\ll ~o~o . .HARI:':lIl:lI:':l.'.',...., . " ';,)I~.'.. .j. , direction, 9, JU~ 2 ~ 1Sua ~~fVi:C1 AI UIIl ""mO ~lIle, limo, 111\11 l!loMjon IIVCfTQclohPVll, IlICl1'rimlll1' vehl\lllllin:I..~1 , OVer \III' cllnlQr oflh~ roal\w!l)' 11110 Ihll pll\h of1"" Holt'" vchlcle 111 whioh tlmolh!lluft front pf Ihll Trlmbl(l vohlclo ollllldll(\ willi 11111101\ tronl afUlo H!lllry V\lhlalo, 10, Ao II rlllIlt Qflhc cQlllolon, Minor Hllllry InPllffllC\ thp fplIllwlnn Il\IlIrlllO ancl dllfl1R8C'1 11, b, 0, d, london e, " J..Rilorllllono lIfIlt ,ubAllqllonl lolUlinll at' hlo saalp' Of hlla!ll IlrokOl\ Imllll lac of hlo 10/\ ibMl J:lrulolnu fUllllwollIlI~ !In hill bodYI ~rulQlng !lnd Aublr.qucnl lendlnltiR lIocVor Inflllm1l1a~qn of Ihl! p!ltl!lIar af hi, loll ~fXll Deep hICOfl\llons oflho bllakalcle of hip IClft han[lll1ltlally requiring al)( slilahes 10 01000 amI subleq\lonlly requirinB ollrllcry \0 aomplclelyrcmovo a clamallod Iendon IIn[Vur other inlcmal part of tho 111ft hMd and re.stllehlns subsequent 10 Pllt1leryl f, POmlMau\ 1088 of use. and permanllnt dlllflguremen\ ofUlo small tlnaer ofthe left band lIS a rCltl1l of the rompvI11 afUte bpdy pllf1 described ;tbovll, " which pm had conneoted nell1' or to tho tnlall finllor of said hand and WaS , . . , nocessary for llll n0m1111 function and URIl, Such Iou OfURC and d!Rflgurement ,I Includel (I) tho pcnnanent Inability of Minor I-Iollry to movo the finger. IndcpcndcnllY of olher flngerR on Iho hand I (11) Ihe rcrmnnont inability of Minor Holtry to flox the finSor at ,', .3. 07/~~/~8 W~p l~,OP PhI 7H H13 ST^'1'Jl f^-RII CI..\HI taloop . HA~R'~,\1!it~PI'G JUL 2 ~ 1998 . . ,,1;(., \::1 ~.t40 U\lartllllllq, ~emanIIJ\ltlllmenl p~aln.1 PcfC\l~anl ClrCClTlllnc\ Jeek clllmIlM". in Il~CllS. ofth!' . Jnrl.allllipnlllllm!lllnl roqlllrln~ IU'pllr~1I1l11 rofoll1l P)' IIl0pl rnlo. CQUNT TWO - (MINOlUlOlfl'RY v. DONfiLt.E LP.ANN.T/UMBrrE) . NRGLrOENCll 13. nle I\Vllrmclll1l ol'pllrllarpphll Ilhmllllh I~ Ilrllll\cPI)lOflllcll hllrllin by fllfercncll, l.t, 'l'l1I~ colllslplI Mfll\! Vehlclaa linr.llnjllriclI pnel dampSclllnollrrCl1 by Minor Ilplll)' WCl'lllhlllHr~llInl\lof pro~lmal~ r!llllll' (If "10 ~u 1101111111)1100, ncplhJenco, pmVllf ncpl\soncc par .0 ofrnll\or Defollc\lll\1 Oonellll LePlln Trlmblo, In Ihal Rhol p. Enll11atCl<l"tO Trlmhlll Vtlhlclc III OrCllln 10 drlvo Wllh !mPWlllllSll IlIal ho WlUl under Of WOlllel PllhRcqlloml)' be \lnder Iho Inflllence pf 1l1110holllnd/or llllnlrollctlSllbllllU'lcOI 10 p dOgl'Oo rendllrlllU him IncPplll1lcl of safe drlvllllll b, 2nlr\l810d Oroell 10 drive Ihe 'nimble Vehicle with knllwleduo of hi a PlUlI poor lIfId/of negligent driving rCll(lr!1 Of hl.lol11 . , e, Flllle4lo la~o ph)'lIleal CPnlrol oflho Trlmblo vehlclaaflor .ho boclime awllrC Iltal Groan hlld como \lnder Iho Influllnco of alcohollllld/or conlrollllq allb&tancll8 to a dogreo rendering him Incapablo of safe drlvlngllllld, or. alternatively, d, Asalaled Oroell and/or pllftlelllnled Wilh Oreelll1nd other plUlllengcflln Iho Trlmblo Vehicle In conaumlng alcohollo 110veragel and/or controlled sublltancos whl\o aald vohlele waa bol1l8 driven by Oreon and/or olher lntllvldulllal WHEREI10ltE, Platnllff, Scott A, 1-101111, by PIId through hlA \llnlnllffpatCllts and llullI'dlans, demnnd jUdgmellt nglllnat Defcndllllt D, Trimblo andacek t1prnallea In f,lXCOSS of tho Jutbdlollonal amount requiring atbltratlon referral by loaal nile, -G- '.i I, Q7/~~/~8 IYIlP WQ~ ["hI 774 ~W. &1'hl'll f~"1I CI-<\Pl .' 11/, l~RI~~' I~ ,IUL Z 2 1UIl~ 1,{~OIiiI\lJi;liJ c.QWl~m.rn~ - ~ll'IO'~ J~Q4'Ol.Y~OB~l\r E, 'l'RTMtltB) - NEQLJGBNCn 15, Thl' 'IVprrnonl,Qf PllfllBfllphR IlhfP\llln 14 _f~ IneorporillC!I hllr~ln hy rof~r"n\lll, 16, Th~ 1lf.l1\1~lon pflhll Vllhlol~~ lI11a Il\lllrlll4 Ami ~l\mall~llnllllrrc<\ hy Minor Holtr,v Wcrll IhCllllflllllllndlof pfPlllmllle r~"lt. of Ihll &mSll neRIIRcnllll, nOIlIlHRlIl\l, lind/of nOllllallncc ,. pllf AO PC minor Pefondanl l\ollQrt Il, Trhn\llll, In Illal hili II. llnll'llsl~ IIIIl 'l'rllnhle Vclllallllo QlWn tll !Ir1v~ wllh lmowlQ(\ac Ihll\ hl' Waft tlllllcf Of WOII111 \lc Imrt\lr Ihlllnflllonell of lllllllhpl _mUof QOnlmllcll p\lhlllanllll4 .. 1IlllllollToO rondorlng him Inllllpahlo Ilf IIrlvln81 h, l!ntnlsllllI Green 10 drivllll\ll Tnm\llc Vchllllll willI knowledlle of hi I PI\'I . , poor anl\lor nCllllSRlI driving fll\1ord or hlltoryl , e, nlllnlPlc<1 Donolhl Lcann Trimble 10 011(0 for llnlVpr dtiVC )1111 Trlmblll Vehlolll whon he !cnow or phlluld have known Ihat alto we\lld 8uhpequonlly pllrmll OrOCln Ie drlVII llle vchlolol d, Entl'llsted DOflolle LOlUln 'rrhnble to OAre fOf nnd/or drivo Iho Tomb III Vohlolo wlum hc knew or shol\ld have 1010WII Illn\ ahe wlluld slIbacqu\lIllly be consumll1S bevcrlll!\I 00l1lall11118 alcohol nmVor conlrolletl,ubslnne\'\fi thereby " Impn1nnll her Judgmonl and reasoning abilities sllfflel\llllly for her to Pllbseqllenlly pennll Green 10 drive Ihe vehlehil WHEREFORE, Plnlnllff, Scoll AI HoltrY, by IlIId through his PlainHffparet\ls and gunrdll1llst demnl1d jlld(llllonl ngalnat Dofendanl R. Trimble AlId 8~ek dnmnges In' OXCCIS of Ihe JUtlstllcllonalllll1oUnl requirlnll nrllllrntlon referral by loaal role, -7. 01/~~m I\'f.D l~IO~ Fh~ 7H ~qa . talpu ~RRm~URCil JUl ~ 2 19U8 . . Rec~lvj:.!p ~!MINOR HO~~TIW v, Q~, POWlLL~ LE"~I'I Tl\lM)J~.~" ~NJ;l . ~Oij,~~T B, TlUfyffiLEl - ~UNUW~ DAfyfAG~S $ThTll fhllll r.\..\IM " , 17. Thll IIVt;nncnlfi ofpllrllg~h. Illlrollllh Hi ~ra Incorplll'i\l04l1~rlljn by raf~rcnqc, I~, MlnOf tlQllry pelleV~, IIn~ Iltarofprn IlVQI1I, 111M pllnllivCl dllmllS\'laUc 1I11111n81 Dofondlllllll Oreen, 0, ~'rlmplc, Ilnll/or F,,'flim\llll, fpr Iholr ImllvlQ\llllllr 1l01l1lOIlVClllc\lonl Of Ilmhljplll ponllllmlnp IlIc opcralilln pf ilIa Trlmblel motllr vphllllo liS qcsllrlhcd III \llllllsrllph. 1 IhrPlIgh P IIbllVIl In Ihllllhe operAtion pfOf IIl1pwlU\cC of Qrecn 10 oPllI'lIllllllc vohhllll while COIlBllmtn!! lind/or bolnll \1",lorlIlC InflllcnoCl ofalcoholAnd/llr II conlrlllllldlllPalllncc conatlllllcll " Imenllonlll, Ol\trlllllKl\lI, oxkcmc or f\lllklou condllol of 1\ nAlure Ip allalllln lho l1lIseasment of'lIl1llh Qllm~~Oll 1181llnsl PliO Qf mnre ni uld Dcfcllda!\\R, WHE\WFORn Plaintiffs doml\nq jlldmnnnl analllRI DcfondllnlROrcon, D, Trlmblo, and . I~. Trhnplo Md lIcak ~lllllSSC$Smenl of punitive dlll1lll(lCS In Ol\co811 of ~IB jurllldlPIlonfll lImollnl . rcQlllrln811rhltratlonrlllcmtlb)' 100111 n\l\I aSlllnal Ihomlmllvldllall)' or oollcotlvoly PI II pcnall)' fpr Dna or more of lito 11018 or omlsRlons IIVt;1Tod lweln, " ~OUNT FIVE- (CHARLESJ.. HOLTRY. nt, and SUSh GREEN. DONELLaLEANN TRIMBLE and ROBnar 13. TRlIltffiLE\ . NEGLIGENCE 19, The uvennenlll of'(larugraphlllhrough 161lfc Incol'(lorated herein II)' reference. 20. As II dlreet ancIJof proximate cnURe of thl! nogllgent Bela or omllllllons, slaled herehl, hyofonc or morooftho Dofendanlll, Plplntlffs Chllfles L, Holtry IUld Sllun M, Holtry, both Individually and in their enpnoltlcs as pllfonta of Seo\\ A, Holtry, havo Rllfeered Qr wlll sllffer damage.. ,,I -8- .,,' " IIworpornloll horoln hy 1'0101'(l11\l(l, ~(l, As n \11I'(lPII\IHI/ol' proXllll1ll(l OIlIlS(l of' ilwlwgllgol1ll1(lls 01' ol11lsslol1s, sllIlo<l IIpl'(lll1t hy of' 011\1 01' 11101'0 I1f' \lIP POIOI1<1l1l1ls, 111111n1l I'I'H C'llIIl'los I" IloIIl'Y IIIHI HIISIII1 tv!. III\III'Y, holh,lnIlIYlllnllll~ 1111\llnlholl' (ll1plI(llllos liS PlIl'Ol\ls of'Sooll 1\, 1I01Il'Y, hllVo slIl'Ioro\I, I\my slIlTol' 111111/01' IIhllll slll'IOI' \llIl1\lIgos, whioh <llIl1\lIgos hlOllIlIo 01' \\'lIlll1ehl(lo oosls 111\11 OXpel1S0s Ihl' PIISI" pl'oSPI\I, I1l1d/ol' 1\1111I'0 11\01llPIII Olll'l' llul PI1VUI'O(IOI' 1'(lll11hlll'soll hy IWllllh 1I1S\l1'I\1\00 1\11'.11'011111\01\1 orilwll\llIrloH 10 MillOI' HolIl'Y i1usol'lholl hOl'oll\lIho\'O, I'IlIoh l11Odlolll (Jilnl 1\lls 1I1\111\dod, 11111)' 1I101lldo 01' Hhllllll\ol\lllo. hllllH 11011llnllod 10: IIl\y Pl'oHoI'lhod sllI'gl(lIlII\lHI/ul' 1'0hllhllllllll011 pl'oood\\l'o 10 Iho 1I\I\\I'od hlll1d IIlld nl1g01' of'lIl\ld MillOI' 101'0SI01'0, wholly 01' pnrllllllY~ Iho pro- 1I\I\I1'y IIH(l 01' 1\1I10lj0l1 of'tho 11\1\\1'011 f1ngo!, I1l1d hlll1d; I\l1y pl'osol'lhod SlIl'glollll'oPIIII' 01' r\llllO I'll 1 , \\'holool' Plll'illIl, orlho 111101'101' PI' oxlol'lol' HOIII'l'll1g of'lho 1I1.1\11'od hlll1d I1l1d f1l1gor ol'slIld Mll1or;" I1l1y Pl'osol'lhod BIII'glolll IInph1l11nllol1 orllny nnllll'nl 01' lII'llf1olnl dOl'loo 101'0sl01'0, wllolly llI' . , plIl'tinlly, tho pl'o-I1\lmy IIS0 01' 1\11\011011 01' tho 11\llIl'od lingoI' IInd hnl1d; IIl1d/ol' IIny pl'osol'lhod BlIl'gloll' nl\d/ol' 1'0hllhllllll\lvo pl'ooodlll'os 10 1'0<1110001' olll11lnlllo plIll\ SIIITOl'od hy Hllhl MhliJI' ns II 1'0sI\II or tho h\lmloH 10 Iholnj\1l'od hnl\d nnll f1llgol' of'snld MillOl', WHER1WOIUl, Iho 1'IIIInll rfs domnnd .Il1dgl11Onlllgnll\sl Polbl\dlll\ls 01'0011, D, Tl'lmhl(l, nl\d R, 'I'I'lmhlo, joll111>' nl\d~ovol'l\lIy, nl\d s09k dlilnngos 11\ OXCOHS or Iho .Il1l'isdlollol\lIl "lnUIII\I 1'0qllll'il\gnl'hl1l'nllonl'01'01'l'III hy 100nll'1I10, Rospoolf\llIy Huhlnltlodt /~~(j~--- Mlchnol J, Wilson, Atlol'l1cy lor "llllulllTs . -2- , ' Pi ," i ~ H " " " " " " I' " " " " " I' 'I' " ~\ " H , " , I' " II' '11 Ii " I' i' " " ii II, " " I ' it " " " j;' 1\ ]';, ,~ I' ;! /if " , ' if "I II' " I, Ii I, 'I, " I', , " ,." fj, /I If' " I' " :,11 i' " I' " ,. ,. " " i! I'; ""1' " , " j' "" " " " "." " " " 'i, 'll " " " " j' ,I' " I" I'; , ' "; " , , ' " I ~ " Ii fi , , , ii 'i." I" ;; " "I; " .j' i, I ~ d " I' j; ~ " " , " " " ;d " " " , " Ii ;" " " ;'" "I' J' " " " " " , " " ..; " ji 1 3, P~ni~d, Th~ ~n~w~r ppnt~in~d in rArAgr~~h~ h~rapC if3 i.I\Povpprt\teQ har~.1.n \ly retaranp~ Af3 if f3at forth in itf3 antirety, 4, peniaq, '~1ha t.lnl3war pontf,lineq in pArAgraph 1 hf3raoC . if3 inoorporAteq harain by reCerenoe AI3 if l3at forth in ita enti.rety. in pArAgraph 1 hereof il3 inoorporfitaq her,ein by rafer.anoe aa if aat fOl'th in ita entiraty t ' 6 t Mmitteq, 6. Mmittaq, 7 t Mmitt"lq, o t peniadt 'l'lls anawer opntAinsq ",j - :I - ll~IU:.l~A'.!.'..J;Q1'l. :t:, PrmflUfl f.fl",nn ~ldmhlfl, QapPfl'" I1nrl a",y I ~\l\Jjapt 1:0 tha pflnAltilill'lOC :\.ll ~l\,Q,I3'~I' I3pot!,pn 4904, re:\.",Ung tOllnawqrn fA:\.I'IH~PI1Uon to Al\thor;\.t:;\.el'lr thl1t: the fl1otl'l aat fOICth in the fo).'egoinrJ dool\ment I1re tIClle I\nQ oPl:'r.eot to the pel'lt pf my . " J'Z/I'L1Y ( pa 'e pe:\.ie(\' ~! I J"" i I)' "L II ~,' 1;:'.1 vV\., /,...( I' Jonell~~ eAnn V,vim\Jl.e 'I, Knowledge, informl\tlon I1nd " I' 'j, " " i' )1 " I " " " ,.". 'II , ;! ., " " " " " " ;;'1 , , J' "d " " " ,. i' " ,. ,. " ,,' 4094-1 " I, '.- "I II, ~-" I ,-I " lid , (") i,', ., ( 'I" lj. iF' : , (t.. ;,1', i) I' \ ,I 'i , 1,:/ hJ I I II' <. " '.!.,o, " III I, I i_IIU I' I (', , ,;lfL /, , I) -, ( , t:'l () " I' -t- l'i ~ j .,~ ~H ~ !lJl!i Bld~l ~: r ." ~ 8 Ii t- .. It I' ,\ ;J " ", "r' " " '" "...."; j; " " I', .. 1 !I " Hpl'vP\1 Ilp01\1 1~lphll\'\ll\' WI'i Mol'l1PY 11\ Lnw 47\),~ \)l\l\p Rlrpp\ llllrl'lHlll\m P^ 171(1) RlpplWl1l., 11111\1\01 ,II'. ^"pnwy 11\ I.nll' ,tol Pllw HII'Ppl IIIIrrlHIl\ll'uM 17101 . 1~J1a~/L--. Mlphllpl ,1, WIIHol\ I ^"pnwy 1\11' Ptlll\l\ll'lll jl /' j," " I' 1"1 " " I'" " ,;j I , I I,; ;.j' " " ;.. " I'" " , I' ;; j,I' " I' " " Ii 1-, ;.j, " ;.,. I' " " Ii " H " : JllIgP 2 (If? t! I' 1 ~ I " " '" i ! I ,I i .' " ,I' /,.j " " " . " !i " ')j " .' .' "Ii! " Ii ," ", ,,' .' .:,j d' ... ,." " " "iI q -", _;1 I. r,/, ," " .' i1; I:: lll( l f "l' i {. ~ _ ~ (,-J 1\ ! II',! ll'i ~;' :11 !I.- .1. 1 I' I,) Ii /'/ iI 'i. " " il.., '" '. /. il,l. Ii .'H " ~- i J ('II (.\ i,l; J." 1:)'- i,llt.! !~ ,~.. i ;) (~ ) I:' ,< ,-I " " '" q Ii 1" <i ';,1' " " ,,,Ii if; .' ji '. Ii " " ;i ,. ,; " II' " ;1/ '!i .' ;,' "", " " (I " il f' ;i I'! " Ii ;, I, ;i /' \, 'i, '-I; 'I, ' 'il ill , " " " if ! ( '~ .' i, " " j' ,J,' i'" " " .. " , IN '1'1 III CO\J\f1' of COMMoN PI,IWl, C\JMI\HI~I.ANP cOUNTY, PllNNHYIN ANII\ CIII\I~I-\!S 14, II()I,'\'I~Y, ,H~, 111111 SUSAN M, IIOI_TIW,lilll\vldlllllly 111111 Ila pllrol1\a/UlIIII'lIIIlI1H 011 hullllll'ol' . Hco'IT 1\, IIOI-TIn',!1 MilloI', 7 \ I Illoaurvl\\u gqllll Nc\Vvlll\l, PA 1721\ \ PIIIII1111'111 v, " " , CIII~ISTOPI\llI~ M, OIW\lN,1I MillOI' 42 WIII\lr Hlr\lol Wlllnn\ 110\\11111, PA 1720(1 " Nil, 98,37117 PON11I-I-H 14\!I\NN TRIMlll.,\l,1I MII1<1r. -llml- lWllwn 1\, TIUMIUJ!, Imllvlll\llllly 111111 IIH pllrontllll111r11llln 111' \)111\0110 1,0111111 Trll11hlu (i4 MOl1nlllln Vlo\V '1'01'1'1101' Nu\Vvlllo, PI\ .17241 I '1 I I I I Civil - 1411IV " \)ol'ol1l1l1nlH I CICH'I'llfICATIC 011 SICRVICIC . I hUl'ohy 001'11 I'y \111\\ I1n Iho 22,\\1 III1Y or Fohnllll'Y, \ 1)91), II Imo IIml 001'1'001 ol'llllnlll or pl\l1loHlllllo oop~ of: I, PIII\nlll'l'a' suoonll S\\Pp1011101\1 10 In\OITo!!lIlorloH IInll RoqnoHI 1'01' Pl'oll\\o(\on of \)OOI1I11\lI1IH \VIIH/IVOI'O HOl'vell npl1n tho pOI'Hon(H) IInll Il1lho llIunnol'll1l1lolltoll holow" I I\ll'Ihol' cOI'(\ lY . lhlllll oopy ol'\hlR COl'tll1cnto IVIIH HOI'VOt! 111 Iho a'1I1ll0 111111l1)OI' 011 HIIIII POI'HOI1(H) 011 \I]Il22"'! III1Y or Fohrn\\I')', 11)99, Sorvloo WIIH 1I000l11pllHholl hy I1I'Ht ohlHH 1\\ull, pllHIIIl!O pl'o-Plllll, , Sorvot! I1p0l11 Rlohll\'llll. Wlx A\tll\'llOY lit LillY.. 4705 \)\\1(0 Strout IllInlHhl1l'!! P A 171 Ol) Stophen L, 131111\\0, ,11', A((0I'110Y III LlIw 101 1'11108\\'001 HlIrl'lahul'll PA PIO! 1~,-A1Ji.-- Mlohll\lI,1. WIIHol) Al\ol'l1oy 1'01' 1'IlIIn\llTH 1'1I1l0 1 or 1 I i I I. " ir (.II 'o- r; II,' i"- \~.. " fj,. ", c.;, , 1\,\" hl1':' ~: ( : ,I 1.'., "1 !, 1.,1.. '('fl /' i f'Y 1.'.1 , .\ .", 1I.!'l '1" l" P'i i J. l' Ij:'I, 1p. i' r... f.,:: 1.1- ~\., , (.> "/i I;) " , ,,' ,. " " I' " , 'I, ,. ,. " Jj I' " " .. j' " '-il H h' ,- .j i' t; " oi " !; 1,1 " ,1\ " il' 1-" " d, " " {I fi " I' "j' ." ,I I '\ ,I' i' ;, I ~ 'ji ,,- " " " " " ',' \ CI':nTlF'C^,\'I~ tW I'iICHVJ()IC I horoh~ oorllr~ Ihll\ oil Iho <!Hlh IIIIY or ,1\1110' I \J\l9, II 11'\10 111111 001'1'00\ pho\l1l\\1I110 011p~/\l111110H or \1\1'l1rlloolpo \0 PIHIJOlllIllllO, O\O,IVIIHIIVC1'\] HorVOIIII\lOIlIIW porH111l(H) l\llIllllllip 1111\111101' Imllplllol\ hpl\1IV" I nll'\1wr \\Pr\\l~ Ihlll II unpy ol'lhlH f-~pr\ l1ullloWllH HOI'VPIIIIl \110 HIII1W 111111lllPI' oil Hllhl porHoll(H) 011 \1w 2Kih \III~ qr ,1\1110, 19\JI), S\ll'vloo WIIH II\lOllmplIHI1011 \l~ I1rHI ph\HH 1111111, pPH\II~P prO-pIIIII, Sorvoll \lpolll ~lo\H\r(ll\' Wlx AHl1I'llotlll LIIIV 470S D\lkll ~Irllo\ IllIrrlNh\llll11 ^ 1710\J Slllp\WII I., llllllko, Jr, Al\ol'l1ot 11\ I,IIIV ,101111110 Stroot IllIrrlHhllrg M 17101 ;i~L- Mlohnol J, Wllaol1 ^\\llI'l10~ 1'01' PIIIlll\lrfH " " " " , !i 11.' .' jj. /! .' d' ;! " 'i " '-f I' " 'It. " , !' I' (lngo 1 of I " , /; 1"1 " (\'J .'1 (.'i,l, .',! r, / ! "I I 1,11 .- II., li'\ ('./ I' ',II J.;';, " .i_II.I;' I: COd );',1 ". '("1 .,'/;'; li,-, '"tiel;, ," 'j U " I' I' I, /, I I, 'j. Ii I I' " "I H,' 1"1' " ,:, l'l " , " ",. H1I /. I' '," II ,/ " ,. " " fi il' , I' Ii ,I " '" , ,'u " I' .' H I' " " " i' " oj, ,. ., ;,.. ., " I; " I' " ,. ,. u Y do iLl ,. ii' " I' I, 1, /, " I / " " " " I I' " , " I' , " ;/ " " " I' "