The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About98-03758 ,! , " '<, " I"~ t. "'i " " " " 'I " ~ ~ ~ 'i ,'" ;; " j, " ': ~ -. ~ < v1 ( " "'..'; " ' p " " , j. ; -I' '!" '" t; p" " ift p " I' ,;; " 'I I' j' .,' . , \ I ~ \ \ !l " (f' .,' I' +I " I' I" ." 'i' I' " p , Ii " .!' P, , I I I ,I I' " " " I' " I' 'I I' l! " . I , I'; I' 01' , , I' "I, " I' I' Ii ",; p jV y ;, {/ " ;, " Jtr' il " ,Ii p " " , ;j' '" I' H i' Ii, p ,j " ,1\ ,. " 'i " ( ~ " i' p I' " ;; " d Ii p " ;! " ~!. I;' " ,I ,; .... . ' . QI ,. ... ~ " p ')1 ,'j 'j I, p ill, Ii liP .' I. i I ~ :;, I, Ii ,," bel ~ K) !i p ;j " ',Ii " I,;; j! ;1; " ,; ';1; , " il' q (' /, , p " " ,,;; " Ii " " ' WA\'NI!I',!lIlAI>I! ^llnrnc~'.ll.aw ~3WcUl'lJmflclSllccl l'Mlllle, l'c:hHl~hltnrll 17111) MAI{II\ II. S\JNI<I':L, 1'111111\11'1' IN Tim C( llll{'j' UF ('()MtvION I'LHM; UF : CIJMlllil{LANI> ('OUNTY, I'I:.NNSYLVANIA : CIVil, MTI(lN -I,AW y, NO, l)l\<175H CIVIL 'I'I\HM CONNIH I" fllJNI<HI., 1)\lj'olllllll1l . " :1 NOTlcn OF J-ll\ARINq you AHIlIWIWIlY NOTIFIHP thllllho UIHlol'slgIW\IIII'\1lll'lItOI'H IIppoll1\o<\ \1>' Iho ColiI'I lil tho IIhovo,onpllol1o<l nmllol' will 111001 Ihl' tho plll'pOHO oj' Iholl' nppoll1tlll0I1I1111 MOI1c1n~, MlIl'oh IS, 1999,lItlO:OO A,M"llllho soooll<1 Floor Ilonl'll1!ll{ool11 oj'tho 01<\ CUlllhol'lnl1c1 coulll~ COUl'thouso, emllslo, l'uIlI1H>'I\'lll1ln, 11\ whloh Ill11u nl1c1 plnoo ~\iul11l1~ npponl' nl1c1 \1u hom<1 to!lclhol' with >'0111' wlt\1OHsos nll<l ~o\ll' oouI1Hol,lr~o\1 so <losll'o. shmllcllhlH 1I1110,\1o 1110011\'01110111 tOil pnl'ly, tho plll'lymn)' o\1lnll1n now tll11o, resol'\'O n 1'001111\11<1 ohtnln olunl'lll1ee f)'OI11 1111 pnl'llos nn<lnrhllrnlors, f)nle; ,IUlIlIlIIY 19t 1999 ~'t- a~ WnYll1rfo\ Shndot Esqull'o Chnll'lllnll AI1c1rcn C, .Jncohso\1, Esqulrc .Jnllc AdnmH, Esquire COPIIlS Tal f)ouglnH K, Mllrsleo, I\squll'o A\lornov-lll-f,(lw . 3631 Norlh Frolll Stl'ool I I 1I1'r1Hh\ll'!l, PeullHylVlIllIll 17110 WlIlllu\1 c, Kollns, Esquire A\lOl'l1eY-lll-l.llw 111)4 Fernwood Avo\1Uo, Suite 104 Clllllp lilli, l'ellllHylvlIl1l11 ' 17011 llullelll1 1J0llrcl ornOl' or tho Prnthol1ollll'>' CUlllhorllll1d CoUll Iv Courlhouse , Cllrllslo, PCllllsyl\'lIl1ll1 '7013 "I' ,'11\ .1" l(I"'l I \ ':. Ii; ., /, 'l,f.1 L}t 1'1..\ (\t,t I' .- 'I' Ii I, I'" I,' .I. I U. (..-, " Ii II',) , ,I":,. ('1) 1:1\ ('..:.., '. f"\ ~_........ ".,.,,~ . ~'. ,'. ~~ "'i, .<1' I" ;', " ..~" 1,"';, " ('J I _-', .~ '.","\n", "., ,. "l I . "I,,:,~- .. h.nooo..., '.'. (.I'; "~'I 'I" J ' I " t~ 10. " " I (..I ~" ,I ", " I , , ':"\'( , I '<0 ~) ,I \ .I , " , ILl I 1'.1 " 1 , , , ( '-t' ;I)il ,', , II I if " i" I' \; >-- .,J) ~ ~ '" "', " ~ " " " 'iI i; I, Ii "I ,.' " 'I' " iI. !. " " Hi t" 'il " " " j, " ('i " 'I'" d' I " " ,. ;, it " p .;: d I',.j ',. \. p, '1', 00 A HIIII\lnw\1lllhI111\ IIw II\lpllIl'lI\1\ Oll\1Porl\l!\\1 loglllnlllcy nlll(\\l holllro \1\0 cn\1I\lIYO\,HY III'11KO I>> l\(\ml>>>>l\llo pI11Y I flho pOI'>>1l1\ whn il\lI(\\l Ihp HllllpllIPl\1 1'/11>> rpllllp(lln Iho \lppllI\'II\1\, .' 14, Ci") F ^ Hllllol\lP\1\ nflill'o{llIlIlIl\lHI II pll\'\Y \hlll hllK ol\nPllrnlwll1I 11001111'1\11\ whl1o>>>> ,.~ " Ip 1111 nn VllolI\ln\1t nl' IWon1ll0 n\l\ol'wlKo IIIIlIVlIllllhlu, IH l\(\mIH>>lhlp, y'" ('tJ II Yploo hhllllll1oll\lI1\1I>> Villi" o\1ly Il'Iho ppl'>>nnI1lonlllylng Iho Volpo IH I\lInllllll' 15, wHh Iho II110gcI\ >>pollllol"H vnloo, . vlfi, ct> II omolnl Pllhllplllllll1H' I1UWHpllpO\,>>, pLll'lolllolllH, l\I\11 11'1\(10 InHol'lp\llll\N 1'0'11111'0 oxll'll\H\p ovil\ol1oll nl' 1\\lthol1\lplly 10 provo II\lmlH>>lhllllY, .. ,,/17, T (IV A dllpll\lll\o IK 1I{11I1IH>>lhlo In lho HlImO oxlonl II>> Iho oI'IUI\1I1\ 111\10>>>> IIw " IIl1thon\lplty ol'lho ol'lglnllllH 11\ 'Illo>>\lnl\ol' Iho cl\,01l1l1slnlloP>> I11l1ko 1\ \1111'1111' In IId1l11\ tho dllpllplIlo In 11011 nl'lho ol'lglnll!. . .. . . Ill, T cii) ,hlml'H I11ny lnko hlll\dwrlllon 11010>> III Iho (1I>>01'0\l1l1\ oflho tl'llIl jlldgo. How did ynll {lo'l 14.\ H ourl'OOl1 qnod jnhl YOIl nro d\ll1nitoly all lop ofolll'l'ont I'A lA\wH of Bvillonl,ll,1, Nol 100 hll(lt hill yon holloI' PIlY 1111onllon ImIIlY! " 9~ 13 COI'I'o{\11 i (l.R 001'1'0011 How dill YOIl got to ho 1I'l\1ol11hol' of tho hilI' IIHlloolll\lon'l (JII>>1 klddll\g!) 13111 YOII dortllltuly holloI' PllY nllol1t1olll , .' ,I " 'H I' " " II, I,"; , '. W\IlIIil Il, flUNKwr, :fN 'l'lllJJ PO\lIW Q~;' cOMMON 111'Jlll\f3 OJ)' c\lMalJJR~I\NP COUN~Y, VIilNNflY~VI\NII\ v, OONNIll 1'" f3UNKIU, NO, 9~~375~ CIVIL ~lJJRM ,I IN RI!l I PI,AINTII'tl' r:l MOTIOtLl~OR .1UPGMIlIN'J) ON TUIlI fLIlIAPINGr:l fllllFORIll U01'FIl1R, P. .:t'-L-f- OLmR / ~YlIlP / .1..1. OROIllR OF OOUWJ) I~~ I\NP NOW / thi!i_ Motion fat' Judgl\ll3nt on the dAY of DEOmMurnR, ~990/ Pll3Adin9!i i!i DENIse. vl.A.tntJ,ff I Ii EdWAt'd m. Guido, J~ pQu~lA!i H. MAt'!iioo, lJJ!iqu.tre For the Plaintiff W~lliam rit Kalla!i, Eaquire For the~efendant lf31d -, C<tJI.I'.l'jJ~ fltl.(~d),j,l 1;J./,d'1~' . , '(' "".')', I I' I' '," '" ....,' I, :,1 d , ,. \ I ! NO, 91h:l711tl Olvn, 'l'IlHM $~O,O(l(), Pnl;nll II II 1l0p\:, H, ~997 ON PlllHMlP I;hu \l1\IIlll:nl.\H1rl ,,' pr.c1ln.\.rla \;0 PAY \;0 I:ha or.tll3r. pf ~'nrl,lI \I, p\ll1lwl nl: I\lIn:1.III)\lrCJ Pl3mHlY~Vlln~.A 1:l3n l:hol\l~Aml IIml , on/lon Ilollnrll VlHho\ll: tlrll:nlanl:.1.on, <lml wi\:ho\lt .\.ntar.13Il\;' rt: .\.'1 IIllclllrll\;oml l,hl1l: Any IlIU1A1.tl p/.\l.Anp13 .1.1l 1:0 \l13 c:\13tlnp\;ec:\ fl:CJlj' /IllY Ilh/lf.'lI .\.11. Mrfl, ~\llll~el' 11 l!1lll:nt13 thAt l mAY \:lu 1I11\:..I:lml \;0, 4) Punp.\.tll noverAl wr.1.j;.ton dOmAnc:\ll, pafenc:\Ant hAll r.uf\lPuc\ I:p PAY tHl rot.\l1l.rllrl uncll)r 1:1113 ter.lllll of tha "p13I1H'Iml Note", (lltlr.IICJrnph Ii of \:he ComplA.l.llt Am:\ l\n !'IW13 17 ) , fl) while Ilho numHp thAI: (1h13 el\ep\1tod th13 "pemf.\ml Nol:e", the llol:ond'lnl~ d13nloll thnt .\.t WAfl A PlilmAnc\ Nate tlW:\ that !'Ihe OW13fl Plll1.l1t1.ff $~n,poo, ~f.\thor., llhe AllaCJUfl t\lat "the pllr.pOflll of the notewnfl thAt thll ~10,ODO WAfl to be ded\1ptec\ fr.om nny mOn13Y connia ~unkol or her. ohildr.en wer.e to inher..I.t fr.qm MAr.ie N, ~unkol," (l\nllwor Pla.l.ntiff Il), OJ.BCUSSlON Pa, Ruloof civ1.l Propedur.e 1034(A) pr.ovidell Afl folloWfll l\fter. tho l:alovAnt pleAdingfl Are ploaec:\, but wl.th.l.n auph Uma All not to unr.eaaonably delay the tl;.l.&}., Any t~f\r.ty 'may move for. jUdgment in pleAd.l.nga, . We ml'lY grant (Juch a mot.l.on only whet'e the pleadingfl demonal:t'ata that no guntiine iaaue of faot ox.l.ata and the moving par.t~ i~ " " entitled to Judgment a~ a matter. of law. Swartz Vt Swartz, 689 .A.2d 302 (Pa, Super 1997), ~he motion ahoulc:\ not be gr.antad unluae "the moving party/a caae ia olear and fr~e from doubt,auch that a tdal would provo fr.uitleaa,.,. ", AmerioAn Motor.iata l.U.Jlllrance Company v., Fnrmers. BanlL.!llid 'rrul3t Ca. of llanov\at:, 435 Pn, s,~par.. 114, 58, 644 l\,7d 1232, (1994). 2 , We must accept aa true " . , NP, 9U~~75a aIVT~ ~~"M All well plea~art fAota of the party AgAtnat whom the motton 11\ mAc\e, Anl'l conelrler. AgA1nflt har only \;ha fActll whtoh Al:a f1raplfj,oaUy t\r~mj,\;\;el'l, 'flwf\r.t~ v. aWClrtl", f111prI1, !"or. the r.aAPonf1 haralnAfter apt for.th, wa fael thAt lt WOlllrt ~e tnapproprlate to ' grarit juc\gment on the plaArt.tnge tn the .tnatAnt PAfle, It ie Olf'lAr. from the plaaqj.nQfI\;ha\; \;118 Pefenclant rece.tvec\ " '10,000 from Plntnttff. It te Aleoclear thAt Pafenc\.nt exep"tecl \;he II pemand Note" Anrt de1.i.varad H. \;0 l?1a1n\;if. f . 110wever, pefenc\l\nt hAa rtlil'led ..a gen"1n13 .j,aaue of fact; .tn her anawer. ahe a11ege13 that the partieanever intended for. th~ monay to ~e repaid durinQ Plaintife'e lifetime, Rather, the purpoee of the not~WAa to anaur.e that the $10,000 waa deducted fr.om any portion of the Plalntiff'a eetnte to which pefendant or her chl11'1ren would be entitled. If belteved by the fact finder, thla allegation would entitle Pefen~ant to prevail at trial. plaintiff arguee that the not~'ia clear and unambiguoua on ita ~~ce. Therefore, any extrina1c evidence aa to the intention of the partiee would be bar.red by tha parole evidence rule. llar lev Pav.tdaon....Y.. ~Iorr.i.a" 19 F. 3c\ 142 (3d ahc t 1994) anc\ tlJro:lch " v. Shut~, 440 Pat aupar 07~ 655 A.2d 132 (1995), Whlle that ie a , I correot etAtement of the law, we canllot conclude from the pleading a that the DefendAnt would be precluded from teet~fyinQ aa to the intention of the partiee. Aa our Commonwealth Court hAa atatedl '1'he intention of the partiea ia the paramollnt conaideration 1n contract interpretation, '1'11113 intention may l:Je " 3 NP, UP~~75P alVI~ TRHM 11I1PP1:j;I-1.1,IWf! 1:r.01l\ j;\lP rloallll\PIII: .1.\:!lOH whan \:hu t:llr1l\!l /.ltp C+llllr. Anl~ IInll"'~J.l.q. IIPIHh llu.tuhlliQn Vt Jilln!lgilllLi!pul (.J.pr.UJ_ 5l~ BA, 192, 519 1\.211 3U5 (19Ufll. 1\ pOIlI:r.Aa\: 1!l I-1mh.l.qIlP\l!l H 1.1; .l.!l r.PA!lpnA~l~ !lIlIlPeRt:1~+e of fl1ffpr.ent: oon!lt:rllot.l.an!l Anfl ,cApA~+e af~e1nq nnfler.ptao~ 1n mare thAn one !lpn!le, Q.QJll1\1Q.1lW.!lf.\lI:h Btnta JUglumY. /Inri .nclili1!L1ll1.l;.hod.ty-y..J- IU. J'. ~~chl; CJ.9..L 50 iJlI,OmwHh, 246, 430 /\,21:1 32P (10P1.). Whl'lf,'e An Amh1qn1t~ PK1!lt!l, pl-1rola aviflanpe .l.!l f.\dml!l!l.l.h+e to aK):l+Aln pr plAdf~ qr. rl3!lPl..v\'l th\'l Am~~.qIl1t~, ~.r.r.e!lpl3ot.l.V\'l of whpt:hpr. thl'l Am~lg111t~ 1!l creAtl3Q h~ the +lIngllAge of thl3 ~.n!lj:rnment or hy aKtt'1ndl'l or. caHllter.Al. c..l.r.Cmnllj:AnOe!l. In r..a.1 Elatt\te of. lIe1l:, 400 PII, 90, 94r 161l\.;ld 32,34.(1960). .j\.2f.1. 32., 24 (.19601' . '.l!llIlIl,U A PPn1;~IHlt. b Ill'lt. llllhnt.;l.y IImh~tf"PII!l, All Rmh Ul-IUy mllY he ~eveAhll hy eKt~illlli(l evidellpe, ,If thllt. elltdnllip evillellpe ill npt 11I\r.~ed tly the PIUia1Q ev,ldtlnPQ 1.'1110, And Ollpe th,lll Rmh,ltfll,ltyh vevBA;!.ell, pRva;!.e oviqellpo VlltfAr.qilltf the ,lnl:ent. at .I:ho PI\Vtiell iQ I\llmb!iihlo. fuillgar v. Monarch r,1.fa IlUlllL'1ml'le OQ.w. 079 :D',2c:1 75 (3rd 011'. 10(9) (l'lonatrning Pennaylvlln1A oontrAPt lAW). Preaton v. f.l1lliQ9..IL.Y.alley Sahool p.\.aj:dpt, 666 1\.2c:1 1120, 1l2(i~1127, (PA. omw+tht 19!HI) . (emj.Jhaaia Ac:lded). In view. of. the ahove, evan if we wel:e to Agree. that the note , I ia nnnm):l1guoua on H!3 fal'le, thar.e mAY he "elltJ:'1ndo or oollatel;al oiroumHtanl'lell" whioh would revenl an nmhiguity, ther.eby allowing pArole evidence aa to the intent of the part.l.e!3. unc:ler theae oir.l'lum~tanoe!3, we c:lo not feel that it would be appropriate to grant P1a~ntiff/a Motion for Judgment on thepleac:linga. J.r\ ORUElH I eo'" day of PEOEMllER, 1990, Pla1nt1ff/a i', l\NU NOW, th.i.a Motion for Jlldgment on the Plead1nga 1a UElNIEUt Uougla!l K, Mnr~il'lo~ E!lquire For the Pla1ntiff William O. Kallas, Eaquire For the Uefenc:lant 13\1 the Oourt , , , /fJ/ Edward E. Gu1do. J", Edward E. Guido, J. 11 fl' " , ' >,. 1f1 , r~: I,~ .. ~-l : '~I, I ' ~- " ,1,';1' IJ',,-, I ,;q ,}1,,'1 ,. (-) :,( ,.( . , ' 1.1-. 'J;:;J , ,IiI; 'I' Ii ,,:-1';) t, ij 1/'; ,,') ?..;, , . I' E~ I , I I ," I " ILL ~'~ ) .,",\1.1., "") : :,~! I '. C) ,..J C:I <I" 0 I' " .,' i, I' Ii " Ii" 'I, ;' .-, I!- j' ",. '-" " " ,I' i,l II ,i 'J,' " " ,. ..", " " !' " Ii ,; 11- " " II, " ,. . " ,;IF " ;! /. ,. I' d';, ,. ,I" I'" " ;, !J' 'Ii ./: ;!, I, ,. 'I ", ,. 'I; " Mi\I~JI! 1\, HlINI\IlI, , \1111111111'1' VH, CONNllll" H\JNI\IlI.t , "l)Plumllllll AUG S 19aa'l.!N\' . ~, IN '1'11\( ('OUWI' OF cOMMON PWi\~ ~ CUMiIIlHI,i\N\l CO\JN'I'Y, \lIiNNHYI.vi\NIi\ + i( ~ Nil, llH,375H ~ ~ CIV\I,i\CTION-I,i\W ,~ ,I\JIW THIM, PIiMANPIlP " ". " llRllliU ANP NOW;(hIH__~,__"_.IIIl>,llL___._...-_,.._.__._._,._--,, 11)I)R,IlIH h\ll'ohyOHPI~IWP Ihlll \ho PlnllllllrH ~lllllnn 1'01' ,hlllllIll0\11 nil Iho PlolldlnllH IH 1l1'Ilnloll, ,hllllllllOlllIIl Iho IllnOllnl \lr $IO,OOO,O()t 11\111 $1 ,~()O_OO ool\co\loll IboH, 'phIH" Inlol'oH\ 1\1111 OOHIs In Iho 11I1101m\ or $___._.____.__.~.IH lWl'ohYllwlIl'llod In Iho Pllllnlll'l', 11I,1IlHI'J,l.H(, "t, ,I " , oj." " IW 'I\HI~ COURT: ' Ii ',I, ;' .' .' " I., j, I" "il ill I, -, l:xhlbltA ii' " ,. " I; .t." I< I I' ,,! II, i. " Ii '-, I' ;" I' i.n " ",I " !i j. " 'Ii I';' " " " " II " " j" ,. 1';\ ,t' II, I. " I' ,'I' H , " I' Ii. j' ;. " I' ,-I' ,. I' " . " t/ ,. , . " " . , " , , /, " i " " " " " :', I, I' , " " ,-p,- 'f " \ , I I I \ + IN 'l'11I! (~()\JWI' OF COMMON l'1,I!AH + C\JMnl!I~I,ANP CO\JNTY,l'llNNHYINANIA OJ . '/l~/ ') '7~/') (] ( ,( , " No, (/ U .. .,:?' ,) ) I " f. ,.(,.( '\" _J " CIVil, ACTION" LAW " .1I.1llY Till^,. PI\MANPIlP NOJICn MAll\l! II, H\JNI\HI, 1'IIIInlll1' VK, CONNlll I" H\JNI\BI" , PIl!\l\l1l1l1l1 " you IIA VI! nllBN Hlmp 11'1 COUll'I', II'YI1II wlllh III \llllill11111l.JII\nNllhll Illnllll11 Hili I'orlh III tlw I'ollowllm pllllllll, YOllln\llIt II\KP 110\10\1 wllhl\1 IWPI1IY (20) <llIylI 1I!\\l1' Ihlll COlllplll\\1II1IH\ 1'101100111'0 lIorvoll, hy Ill1torll1l.l11 WrlllollllppOlll'l\1100 pllrHonlllly 01' hy IIlIlll'I\oy 111111 11111111I\1wrltlnl.l. wllh Ihll CO\ll't yO\ll' 1I01'IlnlloN 01' I1h]oOII0\111 10 Ilw clllllnll 1101 forth 111.\1\\\1111 yOII, Yollllrll wllmoll Ilm\ Il'yo\l 1\11110110 lIolho 011110 I11I1Y pr11001111 w\lhOll1 YIl\lIl\1I111 ]\1111.11110111 I11I1Y hI! O\1tol'ol\lIglllnll\ YOII by tho Coml w\lho\lt I\lr\hol' \10\100 1'01' IIllY 1110noy ollllnl\lllln thll Complllllll 01' 1'01' IIny olhol' 01111111 01' \'111101'1'0\11101110\\ \Jy Iho 1'1111111111', 'vO\lIl\\IY 1011'0 mOllOY 01' pl'opol'lY 01' olhol' rlghlll hnporlll111 111 YOII, YOU snoUt,p TAIW TIllS pAPER '1'0 YOlJll LAWYER AT ONCIl, IF you 1)0 1'10'1' HA VI! A LA WYllll OR CANNOT AFFOllD 01'111, 00 TO Oil 'I'll1,IWIIONE TIlE OFF1Cl'.I SBT FOI~'1l1 BBI,OW '1'0 FINI) OUT WHBllH YOU CAN GHT LIlOAL I-mLI', CUMBElll,AND COUNTY LAWYIlR lllWIlIlllAI4 HBllYICIl COllrt A<lmlllhlll'l\tol' ClI1l1hol'llIll\\ COIl Illy COl\l'thmlllo . CllrllHlo, PA 17013 (717) 240-6200 01' I , .n (;) ,I r,u <I , , , " !"I " , , : ;11 1 I "I') .. I , 'I. 'I, 111 " .,1(.) .. ~, ',II 1 . . < ~ /., f;- 1:..1'" " I' " "'I r" ','1 '. ,- ." " / I ' ,I y.lmlElCATIUN It Moria RII1\~olt h01'\lhy Vllrll10>> Ihlll >>110 I>> 1110 PIIIII1III1' Illll'oll1l1lHllIlI 11\1011 vol'll1ol1 Ihlll IIlll 11\1\11'\11111101\ 0011\1111\0(1111 \Illl wlthl1\ CPIlIpIIII111 III lnlll 1111<1 OPI'I'OO\ 10 Iho h01l1 or hili IlI1owlo<ll\o, 11l1\1n1\I\\lol1l1l1d holloI', Thill Yorll1ollllollll1 IlIlIdo 1I\lh.loo\ lolho pOl1l1lllol1 or I H PII, COIlII, Sllll, ~(Il)()" 1'011l\l1m 10 IlIlIlWOI'll 11111111101l1loll10 1I\111\\1l'hloll, I, " , ~JJ\~*-~~L\, Mllrlo Slmkol (".'''11, /ffS ,i. Plllod: ,,' ,Ii " , '" ., t, i. ' " ,.); ,I' ,," I"~; Ii I, II, /' 'I, ..1, I; " I' I' 'j)' " ;;.,' 'I' ./, , " IIOHH'1 m 3:2'1 r.M .pm m~OI/AI, rRo~r 1)~I'r qq ~ :~~~ illS I '~~ ,- FAX NO, 'l17231.~~.;t(l~~ _".A..."''''~ ,'. C"oqrt f,L ~ I)~I . ~1:.~ R.~~:~~::'.~"r~AN~::::::2Z'a:,li~:~7;~""'''''~Jf~';;';;~':; ''';~~~ ..,,;,;;~; Ih'~~ lYrllh,,, on~, JQI,,"y ~ "Y'l1lllyl p~ml~~~I1f ord,r:,' ~~J" .11, UllllK..i:___,...." .... .' ~limflhQlfl "P.~y'y!l!.nIIlr~llrt\ltl!' "lfl' 1\~1'lt~tlt?:;.)f\~'1 ,rr;';";'I' ,,, 'III '"1111', I' 1111 1'1.'111 PQ~~^"U "I~I II,r,10,lIol\, IIml \lHhl,l\l~ l11~"rU~t J~ J. """lr.voa,1 \hll~ alW ""'III.t~ \1il~llnl1" 1. ~11 h' lIollll11t.d frl,llll lI\lr .11HI In lint UlI"lIll'. Ratatll thllt J 1'lIY \\ \ .nl=i thd ~D, "lid ,.",hfr 't' ~"d,"~",~ ,,w ...h 'I 'h'~~' ~~r \YI/i""I"I'" '~""H m' ID.lhqIW1""'~"1 .''''~ .r .., O'Y~ ., ""'N 'f r-,I'Of\I..,,~.. 1I1"'.p I"I,""dr'''lftJ~' ,,"'-.i,,1I ~...., 11111111 ",i"" " ''''''' "'m' "~lmlA. ij"llliwm~"I'" 1I1I1..1IIi ~ 'f,!'I".r'''~'' "lfl~.."", .It~' ", 'NU, ,.~..-lI" ,.,.... .~~,~ .mu., '" '''~ ~'i,~I II] . >>0 'j~o(' "'/II"~HI~flt -"..."'I1<>.."rt'ilI~~r>P"I.""r ,. iYP'l"lnl""''''nj~II'''''''''''~\''oI1rrp"~jf4n~..' .n n"'a rlO< "'u'l'm~l Ill' ,.r"""""Inl " 1114''''"\11 n41l11,i'.n~1I1 mi '''If .11 .I~ '1ff.,""I ,no ""'" ,U "111'"'" ,"IIP""I"."... """ ""'.PIl4" '"" /II, ,..... - \II IIIIq 9' '"1f 'IF '" I"t pII'IIl , S jn Willi'" 1I'1I,,,ul, lh. IIl11tmll1",1 I.... dilly "'~"I'~~I ., N al' lilt d.V ,hi! y'.y nI'!l ~ .hm ml\!'I~ '. 'PIt ,su.~ ."~ P"lvmll III PI"'"!! 0/ 00' A "' III ' [ ,~ ,J A ,~. -"".Jf'1.' (':;If' J~ ,_ /U",^,) , <.. \"w . ''''I t"'ll/!i.l1'f~I'I'(d"I'T' 1!"f1l~1'11"'" '''''~, '~'\~~t~~'d',r;~~,I;;1, l~t~"1"", It"" III IIIlH~\VHr'IYwWp"I""" 11111' I "ll' I (a~^~) l'Ol""'IIII""""""""'IIII'!!'.,."", 11"'I""'tllllll"'I'II"111t.'III"1111111(Slt~) _ """"'1""'1"" , ... ~1:llA~ ^mu' :H. ,~'\'i-'ChiJ (1"/1 ,.If' ;: '(I. r~p 't:.~(:) -<, I -,,;( I .10 ",,,lbl" Y",,4... Ilia , , ,. .. id " j," " ill., ';,\-i: " " I' ", , ii " ; ., " " IlOY-~~:9rl m 3:20 rM vm m~OIlA~ 1'RUS.U' 2Q30 '. ... ), "fl. " "I d I, " i., '<> " i'. " Ii I ,', " " Ii ,. " r;', \,' .' I'" , j" " I' ' ,," , ,. .., . I J \ !lij!!~ ~ 11\ '}t \11 I'~ ~\ ~ ~ d \ ' .., , \ : 1l,; I. 1\11 \qtl '1 i : \ \ ., H 14 i!h \ it., . . \ \ \ '\\\1" '''\1 t 1 .... ,\l\pi\ 1 \\\\\ t\i /'1 1\ 'l~!\\\\ 11\H1 i\~ , '," I \ I t I \ '\11\1\' l11h 11\ 1 , 'I " \ I" ;;'\'. I, I , I " , ;, I ' , ," . t ," ";; 'or' 1'\ " , " " ;I' " jf " " ~ " d~ ", El<hlbl\ a l\l\lll\.,,'lll ~')III(>\\) 11l\1 mo."lll> ~\ \:f,1 , I, 'L " !i " " " " I I' if " !I, I' 'I( H , " ,J i".1 " " ;'1" ,," I',. l" I"i' 'I' ,I' ., 'I' 'j "l< ij I, .' " j',' d' " j, I' I'll " I" " " " , " " I, /; " , " " " I' I, 11-,.- " f;, .' iI I; " " I! i ~ 'I "I iI H., I, " "f" " 'I. " " CIiRTIFIL'ATU oIUW1~ V1C!.i ^NP NOW, 111111 :lOlh tllIY or ,lilly, I'JIJH, lhu\'uhy uul'lllY lhlll IIHlVu l1u\,l'ull" uPpy or Ihu wllhln IIOu\\l)1uIII onllwlhllllwlllll by ilupoHllll11111 II'\IU IIl1d uorruul UO!'y nl'\hu HIIIIW IlIlIw u,~, MIIII 1Ill-llllTlHhlll'1J, PUI1l1Hyll'lIlIllI, 11nH\I\!JIl pruplIlll, mldl'uHHuil In: WIIIIIII11 C, l<oIIlIH, nHI]\lll'u . I<OI"I,^~ &- l<nNNIlPY 1104 j1ul'11l1'\1.I)(1 ^ I'UlIlIUt RlIllu 104 CIII11P lilli, P^ 17011 " C^I"PWEI,I, & Iq\^I~NS I. , . ~2I/J/J' I ~ /7 /) I! .. . 13)'1 . ~.a't..fJl1l.{(J L0~f:i.:l-e-.~&'t fJ 11l312HIV3.HCl ,. " " H II I.'; 'II " I'" " ..' .' " ,'.f " I. " " , J',' i" I'i ' I' " , I' ", ,;, ' . , " 5 " MARlllJI.IWNI\IlI, Plllln\llT Vft, CONNJI1. I" S\JNI\:llI., ))ofol1dmll ~ IN Till! co1JWI' OF COMMON PI,HAR ~ C\JMIWHI.AN1) COUNTY, PUNNflyr.vANIA ~ ~No, !JH-~"l5H ~ ~ CIVil, ^CTION. hAW ~ ,JURY TltlAI. PIlM^NI>IlP MO'l'!ON-EOlU!lUGMEN'l~ON-'1'llE__'l~JCAll11S01l_ IlUUMI'l'1'Ell.llY..'.l'IIEJ'LAJN'1'lml,.MAlUJUl,_IiUNlillJ~ ''1'01 COllnlo I'll 8\1\1110lt 1)01011(1111111 IItHI WIIIIIII11 C, Kollllft, Bsqnll'o Kol,I.I\8 &. KI!NNI!PY 1104 FOl"mvOlld ^ vonno, 8nllo I Oil CIII11)1 I !III, Pi\ 1"1011 " , , " ( , \ " r !JI' " , , , '\'1, ,1\ I ~ ,I I , 1'1" r, i , 1'\ CIl I 'I ~ \, I .1 , , I J: , , 1 " \ :,1,1 , ;, , .. , .- - ,. t I I ,I 1/1 '. " " MlIl"loII. SI\I1kol, , ATT^c)'lIm, )1101lHO !ind II Mo\lon Ihl' ,Jllllg\llOnt onlho Plolldlnl\s flnhml\\od b)' Plllllll1l'f, i' ).11 ROSfloOll\llIy Hnhl11l\\ml, CALDWELL & KEARNS r"-----, . ~ 13)'1 "",0 i/. .-...-- (-l5G\i~i(.(~'~:I;Sqlllro ^\\ornoy II) No, 69H04 3631 North Front Slroot IllIrrlHhurll, PonnH)'lv\\nlll 17110.1533 A(tornoy 1'01' Pllllnllff , . , DIIlod1 '~l /) '1/1 J) IOJI?Rm.HI, " 'I, I, 2 I. ,I I' I VII, ~ 11'1'1'1111 CO\JH'!' OF COMMoN PI_HAS .' CIJMHIlIH,ANP COUNTY. PHNNflYINAN1A ~ ~ No, I)H-37~H .' MAlllllll, S\JNI<\!l- PI"ln\I('(' CONNIIlI-, fHJNI~m-, . . pofonllllll\ . ~ CIVil, ACTION - I_A W ~ .JURY THIAI- PIlMANPHP Moj'.lQNJilll~,.wUGMEN'fj)l'L'ruEJ'LJCI\UlNQS- SUUMn~rEDJlY_l'1lEJ'l..AIN:l'Um,-MAIUJC.JJI-SUNl\.li1L ANI) NOWt oolllOS tho Plnln\lff. Mllrlo H, R\lnkol. hy (11\11 Ihrough her n\\ornOY8, CI\tllwoll {it- ){onrns. 11111\ SIIh1l111u tho following MQ\lllllfm' ,Illllglno\ll llnlho Plqndll\gu, nnd Inllnpport Ihprenf o\nlos Iho followlngl L Tho Plnlnlll'l', Mnrlo 11, HUl\kolt hns brllllghl Ihls Ills\nnllnwllul\ ngnllls\ Iho I)of'ondnntt Connlo 1_, S\ll\kolt for \he hl'olloh of n wrl\\on ounll'llol (l)ol11l1nd Nolo) by fnllllig 10 pllylho llulsllllldlng dohl ns IIgrooll. Sou COlllplllinl n\\lIehodl\Orolo liS l1xhlhl\ "A", 2, Tho COl11pllllnl I'/IIS flIod on ,Jllly fl, 1998 In Iho COIII'! of C01l11l1l1n PIOll8 of Cnl11borlllnd COllnly, '3, An AIIIIWOI' 11'118 Illed Oil 01' IIhOll1 Jllly lOt 1998 by Iho Dofendlln\' Soa Anllwol' n\\lI\1holl hOI'0\(l1I8 Exhlbl\ "13", 4, Tho plolldlnglllll'~ololloll IInll 11 trln\lllrblll'lIlion IIl1to hns n?1 l)Conllol, 5, A Motlonl'nl' Jllllglllonl un Iho 1'lolIlI!tlgs ,pllrllllllnt 10 PII, RIII(ls of Civil Pl'ooodlll'o, I ',I I 1034. Is IIppl'oprllllo III Ihllllll110 liS Iho l)ol11l1nll NlllO RpOllks fOI'l\Rolf IInd. Inllgh\ of tho 1'111'010 nvl1l9nco Rulo, \bol'o oxlslllnolsRIIOllorllllllorlll1 fllolllnlll'll1lntllTls onlltloll to.lllllgmon\ nil nI11l1tlol' I.. of h\w, , Cl. Tho I)ol'onllnnl's Answol' fhlls to stnlo n vnllll lll' 11101'ltorlolls 1I01'onso 10 tho Ptnln\lff'II' ': :1 " " " " " 'I " I' , " I' " " I' " " " " " I' I' , ,,'\ 1 " " it ;I' " " " I' f" I' " " ,; , .-',i EXHIBIT A I' " I' ,I II "" I' .' " " I' " " " H! ,. " " " " ,'.1' I' " " I' I' '; "H'I, ',' 'I /" ,,,,.1.. ,;'.., ",. "',', '. "I' ,,"""", ",:.,,,!.. "",iI."\, .h~"\"1U1j.hl..jll"'I""""""""'" """'4'\l~'Y'''.'''' 'I." " , "I " ,':'.' \~\I 11'1, "'(1',\ . ;' ""'j .".."" ,. ,."""" \' ~t..,,,,,,,,, ""."H' ,..".......,", ", ."."" ".'.'~',;";:r~\:: :,', '~,1i;~~, '; '.""";,., ',' ,... ..... '-, ." , ,': ".' , " ":'I\ih!':\1':~'\' ',\"\ ' ',,'-,,', . , "'" , ,l':'f' ",I , i ! ~ " .' " '/ MAllllll'" ~IJN1\11L 1'1111111111' >I< IN TIm COUll'l' OF COMMON I'WAR >I< CIJMIW\q,ANP CouNTY, \lUNN/:lYINANIA ~ )J r/ '1 (7" I'P >1<1'111, 711' ~ ,"J( >I< >I< CIVil, ACTION. I,A W >I< WIlY '\'Ill AI, PUMANpnp VH, a~~~ CQNNm L, HtlNl\lll" Pofol$\lml NQ'llClli you HA VIl UEBN ,/:lunp IN qOlJll:1' , lfyo\l wlHh 10 (\01'01\(\ 1I!.lIIInNI Illll 011l1l1lH Hol f(1r\h' In IlIolbl\(1wlll!l pII!lOa,YI1\IIll\l"1 1III,ll 1111\1(11\ wllhlnlwullly (ZO) (\lIY" IIlllll' Ihl" C01l1plllln\ 111\(\ NI1\lollIIl'll <<ervll(I, by lll1\orlll!l1l wl'l\\lll\ IIpplllll'llllOO plll'lIl1lllll\y or by lI\\ornoy lwl f1Ihm 11\ wl'lIln!l with Ihll CO\lrt YO\ll' dofbnllOR or (1b)oOlloll<< 10 tho Olllhl1" <<lll forlh 1I!11111l"t YO\l, YOlllll'll wnrnll(\ tlmlll'yo\l f1\1I 1(1 do"o Iho 0llHll1l111Y PI'OOUll(\ wllho\ll yml IIIHI n)\I(lglllol11 mllY blllll\llll'lld n!lllll\"1 Y(111 by Ihll COliI'I wllho\ll f\Irlhor nol\oll for IIny 1ll(1Il11Y 011lh1l111lln Iho complllll\t or for IIIlY othlll' o\lIlm or I'lll\llfl'llqllllR\ll(1 by Iho PIIIIlltln', YO\lIlIIlY \(1HllIll0IlUY or pl'opurtY\l1' olhol' I'I!lhl" .. Imporlllll! 10 YOII, ' YOU SHOU\,$ TA1<U THIS PAPUll TO YOUIt I,AWYllR AT ONCIl, IF YOU pO NOT "JAvn A LAWYH\l OIl CANNOT AFFORP 01'111,00 TO OR THLlWHONI1 TilE OFFICI1 RET FORTI'I Hlll,OW TO F1NP OUT WH\mn YOU CAN onT LEGAL UBI,P, CUMI1IlRLAND COUNTY LAWYEll ltBFBltRA1, RBlW1CE Courl AdI11II1IRII'II\ol' ClIl11horllll1d COl\I1IY COl\rlhnlIHO CIII'IiHlo, PA '17013 (717) Z40.6Z00 () If) C) .1' "11 . I j'[ ..< ;Jl ,.. I 'II") '. , , '[ .--,\ "\) ,) I ' \. ~ /;" ,1'11 .. ~...\ ,r ." "I l"'1 :q ,'f, " .'", " " " " \.)' \'i ,( " I':, 1" ~~RmJC^,I'10N . It.MlIl'lo SlInk\lI, IWI'\lhy v\lI'II1\l1l Ihlll Hlwlll Ih\l PIIII1\IIn'h\lI'\lI1\ 111\(1111\ H\loh vorll1ol1 Ihlll \1]0 1111'01'1\111\101\ oon\lIl1\o\lln Iho wllhlll Cnlllpllllll\ III Ir\lo 1I1le! 001'1'00\ \0 tho bOHI of hlH linowloilllo, IlIfol'lllll\lo1\ 111111 IlOiloI', Thill Vorll1ollllolll11 1ll1le!0 11\111.100110 Iho pOIlIlI\loII or III PII, COIlII, SIll\. ~4904 . 1'011l!11l!! 10 1IIlIlWlll'lll1\llIll1oll\loll In IIl1lhnrlllnll, " ~'l)f\ . f.\ ,~. lI.,' .1_~~J.>=.h-V~~-~-- MlIl'lo HIIllI,ol . . [p '-.'( 7', Iff 3 1)1I10e!: 110 , " .i ',:" ';; , I' I, , I' " i' 1\ ' , " I', ,. H , ~ , p \ , ' ., " /. , , " . 'IONrl~~\1 TVa 3:'~O PM ',ipPPT pmOIlA~ TNU~,t~O, '11ID.12030 , I to." l p ,\ ' " u. '6."';' ,,'1';' _ ,~l l' ,I, I' " " i' .(, 1.,1'" (~"', "~,' ,j \(' , ':"'\j" I, " " " " ' ",j " "j. " j, ., " ;, ,o' 1'1 " , ,. " lei r,',.,. 'I,' " ' ,. I' " I, j. j, i", I, 1~11i 11 P\iTl'll<;::J ~ \ '1 't ~ J ' I , ",. l\lj .1\ Ilil1\i.lH '1 J " 'i, ~\ \ I .. · i ~Vfi1' ' ~ \ ..... \ ",t~t"'9h ~ , ' . , 11 I'll II' 11 Ii l . " '1\ ' 1'1 · l't1.\ \1 itl'l r '" Q, \ 8\ ' 1 i .n\\l\Hn\llhIP~ \, ,I, f i 11/'1, I i' I, 'I Iii ! " I;' I' ;;' " ii' " 1';-, ,. " " I' Ii f; I, ," " if " " I,. exhibit B 'II ~ll"ll\lIli ~.jlll,ll~ IHII ~H.l(ll(l ~ \:f,J 'I " I; " " II '1 " '-,; !i.. f. " ii' .J' !I! !- , ,,_iI " II " " " ;I' "u Ii I' " d' ..' ",; " I' "jj ;d-,. d" il I' Ii " i' " I' I' " ,;',\ " H,j " '"~ l'P i' iJ I' ,II " ii' I' " ,I' I' ,i" I' 'j', I' " " I' " ,,!!!! " " , III ;' ExhlbllA ''''I' ..1', (f) !c." " ,. d' " " "r\ " " ., II "J .I\\'" .' : \ I ~ I"" ", -"1"1, I' \' 'i."'" ;:':""'., .,.",:..;:,",.'":,":,,I'::!':' , \ \ ,,'~ t I' '1 \ I , , "...' \ '\,\\1 1" 11,j I .,,' I ,. "'1\' " . ",J" J' ">l ,\.' \1'1 \ , " ,\.. " I' ,I' '.' " " I \1,,\ 1/.', ,I " <'I I I " " ;',1 , " ", 1\'. , " , , " " ,;, j, " ';') , .'\' , l' ,II \ \ 'I ' I, I,' " /\'1\ ,1'.11, " , "" 'j'{ 1.\\'1 , I ~. I, \ r" "1' o ~ t ' , ',." ,~ I' 'H -"p, ," , ,"WO!,'C\fl CA\..p\NE\..\- I). ~EA~NS . \\. . "no","Ol\" con""n",Ol\ ,....--."J ~ ..., A1101\t1~~5 1.1 I./.'II Y , ~' lt~3\ !l0111\\ I 'lOll' \\Hlrt"1 i\An\lIa\lU~'cl, 1'~t1t1a~I.VAt1\A 17"0,'533 ,. "I' 11/, '/,,'1,1 'I \ . dT, ~l" 111\",,\,,1\ II . ,)'" .,' ", '',orl., ;\ . II' ii" ' 1\ ,,','1:.1' J,',1\"'. 'I, '( (, \ II , ' . ,\ , '.'" ',\' : '. 'I \ \ "" ~'! ;,:I:/., ,:ii ~:. ,:"::': ': I : ,.' ,P,' ,,' ," ,," 11\" 'JI ''',ii'' '.'/" ::i"(')::,,::,::;I' I': "I '\\i[ ;/)' ,\".-' ; i 1. " \" r." . ) ~l," .,',1:' 1.\:....,..,(,\.:1,:, '.ljl "', 'I' "L,. ,,'ii'\'[' i' \1'" , ',I . "I, 1.1, " "I , i',' "d, I' ,I'.', 1 ,f:' I!" jo" ,I> I J 't".'7 'I "" ,i i , "I" ,Il 1',' " ': \' . 1\ 1 ~ :\, ' " " \' ,'1', i ,I ,', '''' j,'1 ",' i" . \, ,\'~';, ,.;.~ ~, "d ' I ,!'I'I', ":./'" j' " "', , ' 'Ill, !. '. I,',,~ 'l I. d, I I 1.1' 1'!f,\1 'I,i' ,;, r' , , ",'1'1,/',,:';' \1': , t: ,I, ; ,,',,'} ,:i .' ".'.T"I~:': ',' :: :':;':".::' \ to '\ .... 4,: '. \ II \ . . . . l " '," . \~ \ ,\,'::i.,' d''''\:'~ ,h, ~ ," , ~ ;.] '1'''';. \ ..~, ,II' ," ' 'II"