Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-03887 'I',,: , II " .1 i,\ " ,. ,f" I',. II' " " I' .,. t't \\ " ,If ~ " " ~ " ,. I' I! I~I " " " s .. ,f I ~ ~ " . " I'"~ " 'i " " I ~ I' " I' ~ " " " .. ., " II " ~ " ,. r' " \\t, !' " 'II t '" . ~\~4' 11 il ,. ~ \, " \ " " ,. ,. ~ \ "," " \ " ~ " ,. I t ... " ~ ".' I' " " ,-,. , .. Ii ." " I ,. L- " i' I " , .. , i 1\ " f I I I' " " c 'I I'. ,d ,,< " , '1". " " j.~- "J~l " I' i,if " ,I " 01' " I' " ,. " " ',1\ " ,. " " i' " " ". I,j I; ,. iI " , " " " '-,. " " " /; ( " ;1 " ~." W " ,. ,." " 'i " Ii " " " " ..... ,,, "., " i< . ." .2 " ., j; Ii '-' ,I " .. " 'i, " ~ uti. " !I' " 0.. " ~ " " " ,. " ,. ,. " ,. " ;. !i ,. " , ", " ,. Ji 1.,1 " ,. " " " ,. " " /, ,. i' ",. \\'\ (" ,,' <, ,,\ \ ','\. II .',' ! l.~\lkr; 1,'.' I; ',;'iT\'.\"\\ '-,;, i1 . ' !{, ;; Ii 'I' If Ii i' ,.. " ,n ;/>" "l-\\' ,. _"t'l \'\1 .. I' t' f< " ~ \o' '-:' ( !'\'.C1 \ ,I.' /' H \\.(' ,," h!l .. Ii ., I' '.j, ,. ,I< ,. I' i', " /, ". ;; ,. " ." ,. q i' ,. .. ,. " 'I 'i,< .. MARK I3IRQ~N~MITH, PlAintiff IN THI: COURT OF OOMMON Pl..l:Afl OUMI3I:RIoANPOOUNTY, p~NNaYWAN'A OIVII.. AOTION,IoAW Nil, lla.':~'6~) OIVlI.. I I , I I I I I I I I JURY TRIAl.. PI:MANPI:P v, PAVID 1.., PI;VANll; c1/I>/A DAVIP 10, PI;VANII; OON6TRUOTION, ppfpm1Ant r 'yoU '''AVI; l3J:;/;N SUI;P IN OOURT, If you wlah 10 aefena agalnllt th_ olalma B!:ltforth In the fOllowing p~geB, you muat tC:lII13C:lollon wltl,ln twenty (20) aC:lYs aftar .thla CqmplC:llnt ana Notloe ara aerveq, py entering a written /:'lppearance peraonlillly or py C:lttornay f.lnd filing In writing will' tha Oourt your aefenllell or obJeotlona to the alalma !let forth ag~lnat you, You f.lre warneq tt,at If you fall to aa BO the caae may prooeeq without you ancl B Juagmenl InBY pf) entl3roq agalnBt you Py the Oourt WlthOLll further nottce for t:1ny money alBlmea In the Complaint or for any other qlC:llm or rellof requeBtea by th~ Plaintiff, You mf.lY loae money or property or other rll1hla ImportC:lnl to you, . . ' ' . . , YOUSHOUW TAI<E THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONC/:, IF YOt; DO NOT HAVE A LAWY~R OR OANNoT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR .. TIiLEPI~ONE THE OFFICI; SET FORTH aELoW TO FINO OUT WHERE YOU OAN GET LEGAL HEI.P, ,.CumberIBna, County' Bar AaaoQIf.lllon 2Llperty Ave OC:lrllsle, PA 1701~. (717) 249-3166 " ;11" Tal DAVID I.,. DeVANIS d/b/a DAVID L. DeVANls'OONSTRUOTIONI " " " .. ., .. . You A~E HaREllY NOTlf~IEO To FI~E A WRITTEN RESPONElf; TO THE ENo~OSEO. . ,. OOMf3LAINTWmlIN TWENTY (20) DAYs FROM SeRVloe HEREI' OR A JUDGMENT MAY BE . I:NT_~~~b~AGN~BT)OU' .". '" ~ , /. " \.,. PETeR , USSD " ,. I .. Ino\.Jrract PY Ihe PI~lnllff, 11, At ~Illlmall relav~nl haretD, E\aVare ~nct BUPlltfln\l~llef:\I<lng reaultecl within tha IllrgEmsmlth reslclenD!3 f:lS l'I rasult of lilt:! DOnl:ltruotlon of the room f:lctctl\lpn f:\nct ral~lect Worl( 10 the roof, 1 g, 9n or f:lpout Ootoper 5, 1997, J:llrgensmlth optfllnacl l'In fllltlnlf:lte tp rep~lr Ihl'l cl~mf:lgfl f:\ncl 10 oorreol \I1e defeota 10 thEl room flqctlllon f:\nd Ip Ihe reslctenoe, The eatlm~tad 00131 Is In \Iw ~mo~ml of I:Igl11 rllDUsand Ttlree Hunctred Nlnely.flve ($6,395,00) POIlf:lrll, A Irue ~nd oorrept oopy of s~ld ' propollf:lIIB f:l\l~ohed ancl Inoorporf:lleq herein Py reference ~B I:xhlplt 13, . ~ ,0 00 0 13. Plf:llnllff ~verll eaoh ~ncl every allegf:ltlon set forth In ParaQfaphs " 1.though 12 of Ihe Complaint Elnd Inoorpprf:\lea e~oll Elnd everyone herein Py . referenDe ~a preVloUllly set forlh hl'lreln, 14, Pf:\rf:\gr~ph One (1), titled Wtlole 5, Gener~1 Provlslona" , of t:xhlblt . " ,I. A al!1leB 10 relevant p~rt; "All worl< 6h~" be oompleted In ~ WorkmJ:ln.llkEl m~I'ner find In oompll~noe with fill building ooqeB and other ~ppllo(:lble I~ws," 15. . Paragraph Thirteen (13), lIt1ed Artlola 5, General PrQvlEllonB, of l:Xhlblt A Bt~te8'ln relevant p~rt; "Cohtr~olor warr~nts ElII work for n period of . 24 months following oompletlon," ,. W" Defenclaht m~terlally breaolled tl18 parties oOhtr~ot by pl;'lrformlng his duties In a non,Worl(m~nlll(e mannsr, speolfloallY: a' F~lIed to replaoe sxlBtlng roof vents with new vents In orcter to avoid water lealls; b, Failed to replaoe plywood, Bagging raftel'l~ Ilnd old Bhlngles I' .. , 1 fl, Plalnllff I'lvera el'lph ancl every I:IlIeOl'ltlon ponll:llrwq In Pf'lmon:lpllS 1 -1 f3 f'lnQ Inoorppralf.l!> eaoh f'lncl every pne Py ref~renoe herein 1:11' prevlpw!>ly !>el forth herein, ~o, Pefenql'lnt wammlecl IMt the oonatnjotlon of tlw room I'ldejlllpn I:Incl rell'lleQ warll woulcl Pe "pompleten In 1:1 worllml:ln-lIlle ml:lnner I:InQ In opmplll:lnpe with 1:111 pullcllnQ POQC3S I'lncl other epplloeple II'lW!>," (PC1rl'lgrl'lph 1, Arllole /5, Generl'll Provlslpns of Aoreement), . ,. 21, pefenQl'lnt WElrrElnled I'lll worll relEltlno to Iheoon!>tr~lo\lon of Ihlil room I'lQQlllon for 1.1 perlllQ pf ~4 month!! followlno pomplallon, (parElQraph 13, . Artlole 5, QenarElI provlalonsof Agraamenl), 22,. pafanQant oomplaleQ worll on the room ElQcllllon Qurlng Iha Il'lst , weeK of Augull11997, 23, Purlng ElnQ I'lfter oompletlon of the room C1QQltlon, alrgenBlnlth notloeQ severe C1nQ sUPBIC1ntlEllleC1I<lngln his reBldenqe from the roof, " 24, The severe and lIuPBtl:lnlll'llleEllllng of PIEllnllff's roof waB a preEloh of Defendanl's wC1rrr~nly thaI ElII work WElB to pe oompleled In El workmEln,lIka,. .. " manner ElnQ In compllanoewlth I'lll pulldlno oodeB and Elppll.el'lple laws, I' " (, ~5, AB a direct proxlmale resull,of the DefenQanls materiel I breach of . wElrmnty, Plalnllff'B reslQence Was left In a state of QISrepC1lr, causing dl'lmage " , ' both physloally and aeslhetloally to the home thsrepYQeprlvlng Plellntlff full use Ell1d enjoyment of hlB properly. 26; As a QlreQtElnQ proximate raBult ofDefelldemt'1l materiEl I ,preaoh, .. PIEllntlff will pe requlreQ to Inour flnanOlal expense and lossss to mpalr the 'i damage ElnQ to correct the defects to tha rssldertc!3 that was wElrremted by the I " ;: Jl II, " " 'i.' ,. " "I,' ,. " ,. " ., 'd,' .' ,," ", I" .' ',,' /! ,I "I' I'll ,. ,.. ,. 'I '-' ,.., ,. ,. " EXHIBIT A " .' " " ,. ,. '.\ "" " ." ",':1 " " II" II ,: to., I; " " \ j I' 1 ~ "1,1,,, :' -'_nl ,,,' ''''/'' , _,,-;i,~, ,',',',';/-;':-)1'-; ': '/nl!ul ..;./.1)", !ly.:\,l,-;"':_" -!A"'~\),lj :.'_"/:"\.i ""'-:'''''[1 '/" 'i,/'~f\lj ,'I, 11'~I~l. :!i;~~f '/I"!nj,l !i';.';j~'{~ ':',,'~j;(ltl '-":i_.'ii\::(liJl ;',!'!I# , ,,::,!"l{"!,)'~i- ,_} --.;:~_i:'f},\~~'(~'~~:h,~ ,X :)/~,; \Al;i! :'~.?t~:, " " t. ,. I'I'fI\I~I" CON'I'JWJ'I'On M1JUUIUM IUN'I' 'l'lllij ^,llIlll(~IIIN'I' \lllI'ly III' ..r..1ll'lh ,I.y ~I :"1~"1]r. ' IVlll'~f'IIII~'IW~11 '.i\1'''J' ,I \,' 1'::>~ If'~nl'(' ,II',YIIIIII"I ~1I11~'IIII'1 CI'"II1WIIII .1111/\1\ (k '1311I(;11'1/::'(11,111 '''fYI'''!!.! ,.11' IIIYflwl\YI' . . Y . Wllm'>\IIII, 1Ii.1 III, PIIII.I,,'I'ilIIIIl\I' III' flWIIII [\1111" 11I1I11<1"ylllIlI\ 111111111" '11I1II1II 1IIIIII\Vil . ~1*ly" ~YI'I'HIlI" WIII~ , "1" 01'11111111\11 11\p1I [1\ll1hll 1111 ,'f '11Iy IIIIIIYIIIIII IIIl,I l"'IIi'''1I 1111 II[ III, W'!I~ ,III1WIIIIII 11111 I1ll1wllI,I ,IIIVIII . MI'III"'II 1I11\p 81"'1111111.111111I YIIIIII'IIII, 111111 1\, III III1I1Y'1II1 1"1'1\111\ II 1"1111111111 WIII~ III I'" 1"'1[1"111111 I'll l'I"I"'IIYIIII,f~ ~.4f~'fl'I'.'1',. ,q~1ffl ~~Plil"" t"rt . .,Mlllly~, '11111111/111111I1'1111"\1 . " '1110 WI'I~ 1111.. l"'I["l1l1c4lll'IIIIIIII11cI'"II1,q 1111111 I'" 111111111111111",1 "II III 1'"IIIIY,r.....l'l I () ,lVllllllI1 .. 11<,"1" IIII'.IIII1I1I1I1Y "'".'1'111"'1111 \'.1 1"[11111 ')I"l'k~\ 1 P ,IVTI. 'I\1Il1I h lilliII' """!11.' 111' [1I1\I!wllI, 1111111111111" "'\'IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIl'"11'IIIY"II1(WI'I~I'II""'I1III1II1"I''''I"1111"11111,1111111111' ISI",.lfrl flln'l.~f~ ()~ MIIII,~, Thy ""l1lr"IIII.'rllll ~. OWIIIII \11011 ~111111 CIII'I.'IIYIIII [III 1.11' 1111110111111I1111.1"11111'" 1""[Ijlllw'IIIIIII~IIII' CUi1\II\llIIIl' \1111I ,,/ ~15Ihl~(:dlll~f\~IHld -:':I",,,,"lIlh,",h.\{ U""II/'{"Tl,Jf' PIIII\ll'I~I~, 7..):',/, '''1, 1IIIIj~"11\l 1'11I1111'"1 .II~ I "I"~IIIIIII 1'\"11111111 III ."11I"1IIY'1 IIIII\II~Y I'flillll. MIIII. i, I'llliffo'l "~tlllflll' i'PIIII'Jl!I ,,[ 1111 CI1"1I1I'11111~1I .1<11111'" ul1hlllllll~ 11111111111I hlllllwlllW \ 1"" .9'....." 11' 'i.~f\I"\. -,'1,31"'- A~'''''/1~"J" 'r~r~l\'~fl! Gl/fWP" r'P-ll'~'~ .. '3,\lI..I, - . . '(I~I .r(r'I'br:./II'~I.nIQIVI)lr!Wn 'tI,OOO,- ' lJl)(J(1 dl"1lf'.lu'/'ll.ln IP~A,-, "rlll!., rner~ ,J1lY .fillll . .. ' 1\1111\11,,"111111111 IllIYlallllll [11111I111' .hllVII '1111.1011111111111,1111111111111>> l'lIlll\1ll1ll1l1.~ 11111111 lilY" 1\11011\1111" IIf ~'vllllI1II1II1V"lvIII' '111./1111111"111I111011."1 IIIIIVIII 11111111 IIlIm, WII."IYY.'~"II~IIIIII'Y "1"11111 wIIIIIIII 111'.1'1 [lIr IIIII1Y, IliI"~ IIY OWII'! 111I'1 ClllllfMIIII,lIlllll[ 111"" II 11I11 IIIIIII~, [III '1"11 1111'111111111111 ,lovllllll1l1, III' IIlhllll"lIl1l 1111'1>>11 willi" ..ltl,,' III II" '"li11011II'IIIIII II[ Iltll '"11111\'1, ,.I[ l'"ylII,11I " 111'1 111,,10 WII,IIII"y, CUIIIII"luIIIIIIY ''''1'11I111 \\'11/1; III' 11111 1"1t ""ll1l\1~1t 1111I'111 11111'1111111111 II"y III1VII 1..,11 1111111" 1\ [1111111. III I1I1I~' I'"yllllllll [UI II 1"111'1 IllY"'" .,[ ...!I 11<11' (11'11I11" 111111 ,1'1, II[ 1.1" /IOYl1l.III.II1111 h, tI""IC111\ 111111,,11111'1.11,11 u[ 1111. 111111111111I. III "hi 111111,111' [I'III'wIII" '""IIII'IIIV1illlllill/'I'IYI I ^ ,. III CI'II' , , uWulIllil ~, 111111111" IlIullll 11111111'111111" WIIIUllU!ulli!llIi II"~' 1\11,11111101 Ij'pll"I,I.I'Wl,. " . ~:'1l1.lfo",rmlifl1iiil1.llllllhll 1\ 1'11111 1111'1 lVIII' tlllIWllIU ,III'wllli \11"111'1'" II'. llllIIOlIllulI', I\II~ IIIIIUIfIl'\lulI ,,1\' "I"I'IIIYIII '1'0011101111<111\ [Ill 1I1l1ll' 1IIII'IIlllllllllhl\,IIII~I,,11'1 VII II[ III. WIII~ III 1'0 ~nllo 111111 '1'"11/'\111" .,[ Iho 11\1111111111, III I" ""~ 1111,11111I "1"11'11111I11 III 111I 11.,,1 III Ilul,III1<1, 11I111111. "U""~ '"Il.IIIUIIII"1I rill II.. WII'~, "" J, 'Ill 11111 ",1'111 "'llIh~,1 lIy 1,,,.11 WI"~ 0111I111.. 1""(Illlll"l hy III'lIvIIIIIII" tI,'ly 1I"'u,,1 1111" ""I1I1IIIC1II't I.IV 1111"'1[11111I1.111 \V111~, 1, Pllllllllllll1l 11I111 II II' ,1111I,,,\1'"1 YIIU"iY 1*"111111'1111\ IIII""IIIIIU WIII~ 1"""11,111I'1'101100'1 C'l!\lI11'lur 111.11 , [IIIly I'"Y "1"'"1"'111111."'111111"'1111 1I11111\IIII"YI ,,",,111 l"I""ulI'l, [Ill 1111I 1""1"1 "'11'1'1."11111 ".[ Ihl, OUIIIIIIIII, 5. CIlIIIIIIOIIlI 1111111 [111111.11 OWII'I 111'1'"'1'11111' 1111""" III WIII"I\ lor 11," flli 0 I w,"~ 1~1[1lI1ll"1 UI 11I'1011111 1'11I.1""1111111011111'111'"11"1'",11.11' 1"11111I111.111,"1"'1110, 6, 1\11 ,lIl11li. 11"1,,, 'IInlll.. III wlllllli '11l1.IIIIIIIIII"'lh hy OWII" ,",1 CIlIII""'III', 11",11110111" 1111I11'1"'111'" 111,011,11."'"10" 1'111\ 11[111.,1111111111I, .. . 7, CIlIIIIMIIII WllllllilUII i. 1II10'IIIIIIoly 11111110'1 [IlIIIlJllIY III 1I1111"I""Y'.' 1111111111"" IIIYII"'lIi 11", IIllnllllY 0' 1\ "...111'( Ih. "I' IIr CIIIIIIII"IlI 1'111. ',III""Y'" "' '"1"'"111""1"1" ' L9ln1ll!'IIlI .h'~I\I II. IIWII "I"" III I1h 'JI.1lJ'" 111111 ""CO""Y rll' III' WI1I~ 11l1"1~]0ID~Wr1rlV.e r~ v. CIIIII'''''III'l\il I III ''1lllllvo.1 d,I'I'"Il~ 1111'" 110 P"II 'fl"liilif'.'iifflfiil'"I1<1IffiiIl, . ?'i('ll'J..- 10. III \I" oVIII'1 OWIIH .111111 [1111 In I'oy '"11 I""IIMIIII ", 1II1I1,III1111IlII'"yIIIIIllllhlll '''''11I111", CIIIII"'I'" IIIl\y "Ill. I'" Wll'~ wllhllllll"oll,1I IKllllllllr I'"YIII.1I1111 1"'11'"111111 III 11I11'11'1'"1', II. 1\1I11111'11111I 1I"'"I1II.r .hlll I'" 1,,"lv,,1 lIy 1'"I1I111i "1'1111I111111 III """111,1111' will< 1111.. II[ II" 1111"11'"'1 . 1\,1<11/11I111111\","'111111111, 12, CIIIIIIIICI"I .I<III1I1I1IIKlllllhl, [IIII1I1Y II,IIIY 11111I III OI'CIIII"III""" "'YII",IIi. IIlIIIIIIIIII'III"llIi i111~'I, ",,"111 111 UulIlIlIII 11110,"11"1111I11 11[111111"11111, " !iDCIIIIIIII'"'1 worlllll" "II WII/~ IlIr "1"',llMl III' Jl.If ,. 1111111111. rlllllllvIIIU'"I1II'I,ill1l1' JUJ~'J~I,~il, " O~'ll'fl.lhlfll~ 11,,(.,. till/In, 1',iI /..11I. "1....", 'IIIIII.U ~1,'.II. ,~J lilA, 'Il~'II"1 ~t"""",,. Nff,lMt '1.1>1I1 I"ld'~I'lll/aIIl"'III'11 (\'IIIi1I! il~".f' II .,IIHJ.JH1Ihf ''''m', flllllll I.Il t""'''''f'Ol, IhlJiI\t l,.j! ,,\.1 '(otrn"iIJd"ICf,Jl" rfI"h '"'lrf~I'4'~IIU""bf lll.rlatltt. "f'lfllillllT'r11f.t...hh ''If'HIII,. II~h I~M'~.liIt Clfl'H '11111 "ot 11l11~111,"'''II'f I~ r~If"Ji' (IU\H,J I"" AI'llIl I " PROPOliAK.. Nil Q 8 ~!II1l\! 111?U), (t3(Jlfi(/I~(Jtf(.dfi 13~I'PII~ "I!(P t$t&1tlIUIJdk /d PI~V ,~lJtJdJu?tJte 131,111;11 fI1 Ph~ '11(P r9.!J~3 PU~\l /(Jrpr17 ahllll~NIl ,(I) ./~ ~ illurtWJ ' ~tI;(. (!(/{.aUII~~M !'ll'.,""' Hf>, ladtrJ?tMt. /J PIi;y autute. ' . SI'"~IItf4 PIII;\l nt PIUIlU!t>'S-97 ^'~nhli;\lll~ 'Cfllll~ d((lt<f{.. w, """"":;;;;;:;;.''(/ ;;,";;;'Z'~;~"":V e;:;"":'~:~c?'U~ ,t1iW41A '. <MJatu ifa.tv. 7if/4 ,JIr ;n:Jfi1 ~qoJ.JP ,'tf14: <'e ~ I'-.~ ,..~,~d ,Ja8!ftf ArtMM Ycfll!~~e.-L-?(){(~I ((f.?J fz (tl;/t~c!d!uwl ,.J. Y b AK;UI-0 'Ie It f'r'f'lV (i."c:!. r14;fe.p, -7itaMartfll{J.tM am. !(J d(./~()ee/t.l c!((.llItlFd... ?J1cd . ~ rttl ' eud I dIMfAA!f(/J~r: ,at((lcli (1. vP ~(2.ll#(tI pr;.6Itc14gf r;r6d~f t~"tot tiI '-tui, ~ 7~t(1.fJ,e~II(Mit. ~ It ItJ~, tW ., " ,. ,,'., fd!f1I.U~j lta(J/U (!4<lfl1)tte7/,,(.V(.M 1M tal 'r,A~t1 (!(l~Uf-,7j(~C<<O(),~, . !if/;ml'1. ;a/JIi.c~'cI Pj UN;J, ,I/f!'t~te. ,a'tff,I; j~el~ v~U.J(,.)t '" ~mh:; 'gClttit . Ze M 9i ,fea/lttf/ g~lttU I J#i-! orj(({<;i' '~~'J'<. ,,(JIJ tRj)/Jet ?~1t(!t('/fe Till dl((((,(f.'77Jla'" /'67J?J W, . '" , ~Ilo. brJlMPIilII.. iJell<r J(<rtM,~ ~lUIqflll:"t dllf y" 4.-tt~ ~ ' AIlIl1~tu"llIl In Ulln"lIIl1;ulIlf tu 110 nn upoolrlorl, OI1r1 1;lm 1I1111VO wllI'k 1;11 110 pOl'ftl/'l11U11 111 1I11onrclnllou wl~h thtl rlruWlllqll,UI1r1 Upllolfll1l1~II1I1U nlllJllllla,lId fop 1I1mvu WIl/'k lIIl1l oOlllplol;IlIJ 111 II nllhu\;ul1l,IIII wll/'kmul1l1ku 111UI1IIOI' IllI' tl1u' ollnl ut" WII;h PUYIl1I1I1I;ul,u hU'IIIlIIu flU flJlluwu; xla f() . #' 61... ',' . " IJtillUl'lllill, " ,.1. ,j, Any ullllrothm UI' IluviullUlI Il'llIl1l1hu'w'lIl1llU(:lfi(JUlIullll 1I1\"Ull'lll{1 IllLtl1 ~..L. /J.~. , COSLa, w!11 hUlllUI;ullJd (Jllly 11111111 wr'jtltl n ordllra, 1111(1 willlJ(I(!umo CHI l1oupuol..fllUy (11111/11/1,',0(' ""'"J;o# ~ II Oltl'llllhoruu OVOI' 1I1ll1 Ulill\,O t llI(Jnllrnnlu All UUrUUf!lU/ILll t,lIntlh(Jufll f}. a' I IIIlorl UHI~09.IIC(:lllotll11 01' 1lllluVIl hllYllfll1 OUl' l:llrlll'ol n"'fllll'LII uOIrv rlA/AlA rJ JI ~I 'A'II/'JA.LAlj fj.o, tUf'lIudo OrllJ Mhul' 1l111:Ullllnr'v IIltHU-WU:O IIjl/llllllllll/O Ww~ 'Wurl. POI' f,ft-(Ltu ..,........ 'W# fJ;.('f'" montu Orllllj1ClnllnlllJ/l mul Jj,hUIlI,lflllIIlLy 11lI1'JtOru~I' Ill! nhtlVtl WW ~ tlJ hu , ~n\oll UU~ hV "j N11I;ll Thin P':Uljllllj!lllluy hll Wltlllli-llWlIlly 110 I.', not utltltln~lltl within C/U dnyn. . ., " A!JOi:PTANlJE []F I'BOP()SAI. . ".'." 'Tllo llhuVlllwlllun, Ujllllllflllul.hlllllllilll IllllllllI,ILlIIU IIl'IIUUt.llltcllJl,III'y ulld 111'0 hlJ/'uhy IIllIlIJpt.lld, YUllnl'lI ollthlll'lwtl t/j do tllll WQI'~ abllP~(lllilldi . Pnymunt 1'1111 hi, 11111110 1I1l1l11t1l1lOlt IIlmVIl. ..' , ., . .... ~.:: .,1,(",' " "'1..;, ..i., , ~ I, I',i ; "''if' .,"_':.' 'f' PRQPD$A~ No. Noma '71141/ (t3(/1j'f5k~t!( ?t1 ~1;I'ao~. 'III; ,6/~NttlJttf.e f}.I, Ol\iy 13-1~(),j.f4(.f(tt( 811(1\,11 ltt Pilon a 7 ~ ~93-.2;3 1l1l~1I /I.~" 5~ ~7 S'lIlO~ Nil. (~) ~ /L. ~1('!1~4<J 1t trf1l4t1I1~~il1 SI;I'IlIl~ / 13 ~dl( aU.1e., . J) . lJlI;y {b.-Iltde. ..l3~ll~O r'fl PIIl;o of PI!lllll IcJ "S-1/111'IJI;I~0'lIa.:::b/i(e4 At,.1<;V Wo liol'oily PI'OPOIIIII;o' flll'nlllll ~hllll1fIl"lI'llIllIlIIlll pIII'[OI'm \;ho lohnl' 11l1011Olllll'y (111' 1;110 Oomplll~llln pf . fauil it(.I/rlf(l(JrJ(/'V cuI(! lld(~ &il.ur. (i((R m ?<-h:tt.(..d~~I~ ,..7]!tt/J . V/(4.tA.tI fiu~'~~i: (t~(d ttt'nl.- a1~t(m 1(I'l~~~AuJ "UIl-h(I/(~tf1~~ JI4WJI /file d;JIl1: (/in!' r!!Jf)f-J.??t Mt~,'('(JilV' - t;1rJ;M eJ!, -? !;(;SP !~?al r A(JftJrll(/ . J; 3 96" t!E. lio ,. i r''', .. , All mntol'llIl In {Jllnl'onl;Ullll lio hll UlI IIlillolf/ucI,UIlc/ tho' nh~vu wu/'k .I;ti 1111 jllll'flll'l11llcl III Ul1011/'c1ullllll with t.hu dl'llwlnon UI1U " . nPllOIf(lllj~I'IO 0 "Y~lllltl,oil. !(~ nl'p~o . wo~k 1II1lJ. QU.llljl[lll,ucl ..I:~1l I ~l/hul,lIIll,lul WllI'kl11un/lko I11UIlIlUI' fill' tho' UI~I). Of ,. 'a 't(f~(.ullwtY~ I-/lUl.a/1H lU/ct'rtJ we ' - !Jollol'u !ill R.j 15 4.JI I, with pUI fOlltn to ~l11oilu 00 followo: fl~ ~ A"v "llorotllX ~~IIlI~C:~~;~l~~;t'~'~;'I~~~~ -01/816 title tll){'~tJ(fhf1(!dtl1t ::"~tt7flr1 ~ {/(?/Rtlaf-. f;oQ~II, W"I hll tJ.lUr.ULltIlwlly t'llhl! wntLl111 tlIdfJIlIj l/nd Will Ill/elltllll un Ilnupool.ftllly ulIlunll,l,ml ~ ~~ C!.i:trollhnr{lllfM/f'OmlllhnvothuunLtrlllltll AlltlllllJOl111JllllltJtmlll111UIlI ~ Ii ,j' Up'IIllltrlloll, II(,tlhlllnLuw'd,,'u~o hllvlIIulllllrfJWILI'ullMIlUI'lufl(,trv f 1...1..., A 'JI1 /t'flLt..J.L .,,4..nJJ 'Ire, tUr/lmJo tIlJd tlthor I1I1CIHlMIV llllllUIUlllllltJllfIUhuilI \VlJ/~ Ww~. JI1I' (J-{{tIfU ..- l. 'tiff/.) v~l r..;..( (rJf I I, nlOll'n OUlllllOlllllILltlfl wul ruhlin Lwhlllt\' IIIRurmU,(J IHI UIlOvll Will I. t (I hI! (ulo"",,! IIy ,. " NoW .Thllllll'OIHYlllIIlIIlY 11II wll;lllh'IIWIl hy'lllIlf Ilot 001lnpl;1I11 , wll,1111l (jJ() dIlYII... AlJOEPIIINDI, DF PIlClPU811L " . Tlm'lIhllvll IJI'llJIJIl, IIpulllfilllltllll1111llHl OlllHlltlUll1I 01'11 !lul;llIh,ULIJIY IJlld IH'IIIHJI'uhy (ItJllup(;wl. YUII Ul'III1I1I,hllf'l7.0d (;0 do Lhll Wlll'k 011111'001/1011, I'nYIIllIllt Will 110 Illlldu no OIlI,1I1l1l1' uhuvu. " " I I i I " '" i' ,. I. ;t ;! !. ji ", 'L" ;: ! , 'd ~. ,~ ~' h ~,. !, "~ ~, , l\>, ~, ,~\ B ~ \j I' ~ '~"~ '~ \ \ ':~.. "'\\ ''\\ , \ ~ tS " . ~. ~ ~ 1 ~ '--- ,. " I, " 'j " ;I, u :.,. " ~' I',' l j " " ~ /~.) ( , , 0 I "J 1 .)"J 'i. I . 1 , ) 1 , , I ! '/ , , , (I, , ., 'I , , 1 '") t.;-.. :.' /i'l , , lei , , , :q ..' 'i , ", " il ;1 j,. , ' " j< . I , I flJ:;T~R ~, RU~~O, J:;SQUIRI; PA S~lpr\3lT1\3 (Jourl IP: 72967 61 W\3l1\ ~o~,tIlar 6\ra\3\ . Oflrllllla,PA 1701('l MARK ~IRGt=N~MITH, I IN THI; OOURT OF OOMMoN PI..I;M PlAintiff I OUMI3J:;RI..ANP OOUNTY, Pt=NN~YI.VANIA I v, I olVl1.. AOTION.I..AW I PAVID 1.., DeVANIJ: I No, tlQ.311117 olVl1,. cllpllI DAVID 1.., Pt:VANIJ: 1 oONSTRUOTION, I pefentlllnt I V, I JURY TRIAl.. P~MANP~P I J,O, 1,.t=130 ~ SONs, INc, .1 MllIUo",~1 Defontlllnt . 1 I " V, 1 I . RONAI..D ~, ARMOI.. T ! I' Allllltlolllll Pefenlll1nt 1 " , ,;" E.lillllQN FOR LgA-V.U~O PI.Attill.EE'S OOME'hAltfi ,". , " ANP NOW, oOMes, Plaintiff, Mark I3lrgensl11l1h,py and throu{.)h hili underlllgnad ,\ attornleB, and petitions thla COlII'tunder PA. R.C,P, 1033 for leava to,ma fin aniended Complaint E;\nd In support themaf repreB€lntB the following: .. 1, Plaintiff fIIad hili Oomplalnt against Defendant on July.13, 199B with the Cumperland Oounty Court of Common PlaElB, ,. !o, 2, Plaintiff alleged 111 hla Complaint that Defendl:\nt pullt a 1'00111 addition and reoollBtruotod an exlBllng roof to lilatoh the roof to the room addition, ,. 3.. Plfllntlff f\lrlhar flllaoaq \11111 Pafenql1n\ pral1ol1eq Il1e flgreall1ent I1nq ~lI1qerlYlno wI1rn1l11ylo \l1e Pll1lntlff by provlclltl0 I1ncl In8111111no I1 defeotlva ropf re8~llIlno Inlal1kl1oe I1nq WilIer Cll11l1110a 10 1:l1111ntllf'B reBlclanoa, 4, pefencll1l1\ fllacl 1118 An8wer Ilncl New Ml1\1ar 10 Il1e Opl1lpll1lnl on Seplal11bar 17, 1990, 6, Pllllnllff fIIeq hl8 An8wer Ip Pefanclflnl'8 New Mflller on Ooloper 6, 100a, 6. . Pill In tiff aael~\llaI1Va of Oourt 10 Inoluqe fl oO~lnl flllaoln9 fl vlolflllon of 111(:1 Unflllr Tracla PraolloeB Aot, I1D 8el forlh In r:xhlblt A. 7,.. pefenclfll1lB will nol be ~lncMy prejuclloecl or BlIrprlBacl by UllB I1l1lenclmenl, eapeolfllly !Ilnoe Ihe fflolul1l bflBla for Ihe new 00~1t11 IB wl10lly bl1Becl on faol8 fllreE\qy plelld by Ihe Plaintiff In hlB orlolnl1l Oomplalnt. I 0, Ml1lllfeBI InJlIBtloa will re8~11t If Ihe al1lenclmenl I~ not I1l10wecl, 0, OOllllBel for Defendanl, David L, DeVl1nle cl/b/l1l David L, DeVflnle OonBlr~lotlon, l1aB pean notlfleq of 8alcl petition 10 flmend Ihe orlolnElI complEllnl flnq oppoBea flny flll1enqmel1t to the OomplEllnt, 10, oOLlnBel for flddltlonalDefellqant, J,O, Lebo & SOnB, Ino" has been ,I nollfleclQf Plalntlff'B Intention to amend the original Oomplalnl ancl l1aB no obJeotlonB to Bald amendment, , , 11, OounBElI for Elddlllonal Defendant, Ronalq E, Armolt, l1all bElen notlflecl of Plalnllff'Blntenllon to amend the original Oomplalnt and l1aB no obJeotlo/1 to ,Balcl amendment!l, 1/ ,," ..'.',i~' ., l'. ,). ~~~' l-\ ....l. .' .. ,. WHJ:RJ:fPRt:l, Plillnllfr, Mmk I3lrganaml\l1, rag~laallhaIII1IEll-lpnpra!)la C(Jllrt . ,. anlarlha attacl1aq Orqar flllpwlng Plillnlll' to amaml hill COl1lplillnl wlll1ln IWf3nty (;20) dIWB, ,. Palel j'1-, J \ \ \il'lr R1311paolfully BU~ll1llle~l, .. . C=;Y~~~C~a~ Paler J, f~UBaO . .. Pa, Supreme Coul'l '# 7;28\)7 " ,_. 'f~ _. ,., ~"~~ ' .....")"......,",........ K,..... \ . .~ ~ ,)", ~\0.~\ WI..:. ~.{,\.-<, Mlol1ael g, D~ldEl, ,EBq, Pel, Suprema Oournnm49 Pelt!'): .J;;?./, ( I 0 '( "il '1 I' , .. .1 .,. ,. " .. " : q " " " ,\ " " " " " " I';: " . ,. " " " ." .. "I " " li; ,.... ".. ." Ii; L,; ~., r'~ r.'..'J~~'I~ ') 1.1.1"'1" f,t)':". C.) ',~ "(" I ..1 ~'{' n:(; ,".. n(., Ie. ,'),;:.j r!.ji: - ~,:: rij .,_llf.iJ fLlI! L.1 1'1[1.1 I. I !Ii J. I.. (':"1 ....: " II. !t..." ~J U {j', 0 ",. '" .;' , ii' " " // ,. ,r , ,. " ;' ,I,' " ,', i' ,. ., :'1 " ,. if " '" ,. ;. " I', "il ,. I. 1'1/ " If 'I, " ,1- " II, 'l\ II! ",I ill j; " '/1. " " " ,. I " .. '" ", " M^HK Hllte II\NHMI'I'II, 1'IIIIIlIIff YN, IN '1'111\ ('(II'HTlW coMMON 1'1.IWi Ill" (~IJtl'lIIlml ,^ND CO\ INTY I pnNNHYI.Y ^NI^ "'VI I. ACTIoN.. I.^ W IJ^ VIP 14, DllV ^NllIll/h/ll P^ VIP 14' DIN Mill ~ONHTH\J~TION I Illlloll11nnl NO, UH":1IH17CfVII. " I, I "" YH, IWNAI.P H, AHMO!.T, I Fmthlll' Addlllolllll P\Jlonllnnll .IlJlW THlt\!. DHM^NPIlP q ~n (OJ t.; ',Il 'II r'} ,,.j '11 ; rq '11 I ,it , , 'J "'r ' , I r'.l ',!J 1.1.' , 10 il J "~I') I , '-1"1 Iii 1':1 : : I. ' "1 " , ':11 , "'R ~~ -j , ' , .. " o. f h- ~q ':', If) .<.; ,I,C, 1IIIIlO & liONI'l, INC" ^lldltiollnl Pol\lIldnll\ YH, " '" J>ICFICNJ>AN'I' J>A VII) L, UIi)V ANIIi1 d/h/ll J>A V III L. lUCY ANII~ cONsTn(JC'I'I~tiANSWllill1J) I'IC'I'ITION lion "ICA VIC , '1'0 AMICNU I'LAIN'I'IIII"'S COMI'IAlliT ,;> AND NOW, OOnWH IIw D\Jlol1lh1l11 PlIylll I., D\JVnlll\J d/h/II f)nvld I" DuVIIlllo COIl~II'IIUlloll("D\JVnlllo"), hy nlld Ihl'ough ,hlH 11l1dcl'~ll!l1\Jd IIttol'I1\J>'~. 1I1\llnll~WOI'H PIIII1\t1ff'Mnl'k Bh'goIlHl11llh'H Potlllolllhl'l\Jllw 1011101111 AlllOlldod COl11plllllllllH 'hllolV~1 ", I. Ad1\),lllcd, " 2, Tho COIHplnil1l Hp\JIIIIs 1\11' ItH\JII: ", 3, Tho coiilplnllll Np\Jnks Ihl' ItH\J11: By IVny Ilf' flll'lhul'I\IlHlVOr, Dolb1\dn1\1 donloHnli)' bl'\Jlloh of' IIgl'O\JIl1\Jllt 01; IVIII'1'1I111>'. 4, r>ulllod, D\Jlol\llnllt'H AIlHIV\JI' wllh N\Jw Mntt\JI' wn~ l1Iod 01\ 813/llomhol' I R, I ?9R. ' ,j 5; Admitted, /J'''''/II,,''"I/:N6/,)(I,1 " '. (I, ^IIIllIII\JII \11\1)' Ihlll 1'111111111'1' ~11 H\J\Jk~ 1\1I\\'u pr< 'PIII'III1 111111 11 ('0\1111 1111h\' Imlllll' , ll'llllll PI'lI\lII\l\JH IIH 1111111111\111111 hlH 1'1l1111pl1, Pllnl\Jd Ihlll 1I111\11\\lIHII1WIIIIH pl'ol'OI' PI' IIppl'opl'llIlll HI Ihlli limo, 7, ,CollohlHlpl1H PI' lilli', IlPIII1HII'\JI' 1'\J\I\1II'\JII, II' 1II1I1I1H\V\l1' IH \,\J\llIh'OII, Ihu 1II'Ill'l1wI11B III'U H1W\lII1\1I1\1y llul1l\1l1, IltwlIY PI' 1\I1'I1wI' IIIlHW\lI" Il\JVlIl1lu hll~ .IPhlCI11I1l AlllllllplH\lllo1'lllHhllll, ,I,C, !.\Jhollil. HpI1H, hw" whollllH .Ipll1\JIIII Fill'llWI' ^lllllllol1l1lll\Jlol1lll1l1l, 1~011111\\ II, Al'Il1plI, 111111 Ilw plUllllll1gH I\I'\J \lhl~\JII PII lho Adllltlolllll P\JIOlllllll1\ .Ipll1l1\JI', MIlI'\IPYll1', 111111111 IIIHOIIYllI')' .hllH IW\J1l pxollllllgoll b\JIWIl\J11 I'lnllllll'l' 111111 P\lVlIlllu 111111 ,Addllll111111 Ppl01ll1llll1 ,I,C, 1,llbo Ill.:. HIlI1H, IIw, 11l\~ pl'lI\Julpod IhlH UIIHO Ihl' 11'11111\11' IIwll'illlH COl1111lllllCIIlg Oil Fohl'lllll'Y I, 11)1)9, 111111111111011, , , IIw PllIll1tll'l'dooH 1wl hnY\J nllY I1\JW I\lolH 11H11l \\'hnllw pOHH\JH~\J1I1I1 tlw tll1wh\J I1I\Jllllw '111111111 , -" ' " 1I\l1l011, IIllll cOlIlII hll\'\J I'I\IHCllllwlI\l\Jgllll11l1~ III hl~ 111111111 CUlllplnll11. Tlw 1'111111\11'1' 11IIH oxul'\lIHolI 1\111'\lIlH0l1l1hlulIllhl)' 111111 hl\JK 01' dlllg\JllCo 1111hlH l'\Jglll'd, \\'hloh wOllld 111111111)' PI'o,llIllIo\J pololllllIlIl lit thlH !1I11l hllll\', AH 1101ud In PlllhllllrH 1I\'\J1'IlWlll~,lho Ihctllnl hllHIH Ihl' IIWIl\lw CUll111lH wholly hllH\Jd 1111 n\ol~ 1I11'\Jlllly pl\JII hy 1IIIIIIlIIIT III 1M ol'lgllllIl CUl11p1nll1l. Fmllwl'l11ol'O, 11111111111'1' lIiloH ll0rhll\'\J 1\ 1'111111 ulnll11lhl' 1I1l)' 1'101111,1011 ol'lIlll\\ll' 11'1Il1\J pl'ncll\J\JH, H, COllOhlHhlllH ul' IIIW,1l1111I1HW\J1' 1'\J\I\lh'\Jd, I I' 1II1I1I1HW\J1' IH 1'\Jllllh'\Jd, IIWIIWI'Il1\lIllH " 1I1'\J Hpooll1clllly dCl1lod, ol1.lIl\l oOllll'nl'Y, Plnll1l1l'1' hml tho uPpUl'l\ll1l1y 10 nlloll\J IIWCOIlI1I, \\'holl ho fll'Hll1IulI hlH CUlllplllll1t 1II111 dO\JH Ilul hlll'u nllY Il\JW Illlhl'l11ntlolllllllll whnllw pOH~oHH\Jdnt Iho Ih110 ho 11101l1h\J COlllpllllnl, Plllll111t'1'H Intll honl' Illlllg 01' thlH PllllIlOll ,will (111)' Iloln)' IIl1d i, pl'\J,ludloo D\JVIII1I\J nlld 1'0qull'\J 1\ll'lhcl' pl\JlllllllgH, nrmll1nllw dlllollHOH, nnd dIHOOWI')' .lbl' II CIIHO which hnH 1'\J\Jlll1l1y lm\J11 IIHI\Jd Ihl' tl'i1l1 hy 1110 t\dlllllol1nl Dolollll""I, Moroni'll!., 1'1"\11111'1' dno~ lint hl\l'o " C""HO ;11' "0 II nil till' IIIlY vlol,,!Il1l1oflll1l\lll' ll'mlo PI'lIo!locH, 9, Adl1lill\Jd, " .2. 1J/If.'IIf1Il't1fll:J.I.t1fJ,V.J ,,! r ~, " " " " 'j. " " " " , ' . ~ " I' " " '; " Ii " ;1 '1 'I' , , (.~ , " , " , I I ~ , , I , , ;, III I , , I " ,. , I ,1 '1 , :'..1 " " Ii " , ,l.) , , " ~ :\l , " I I , , 1 , r" ,I , , " , , " , . , \ , , 1 " : ) .~~ " ~ I n ~.~ " " , , If .' " ,. ;, d " " , " , , ,.0 " it " " ;i'! ",- HI , , " " " ,I; " " 5, , Plll1lp\IIIH HIIII\JII, Tlw PllrllpH InlllnlllUlwllwlll WIIS iiII' IIw HI"\1 PI' $1 R.722,(l() In IIlllJPnlnlW\J Whh lho ol'lglnlll CpIIIl'lIllllll' i\gl'ulll1l~111, IlmVIlI'\lI', Ih\Jlv Wlll'\J 1Il1\lIl1ol1H 1111\1 lllllllllpl1s Ihlllllfl\lClp\lllw lJpnll'll\ll pl'lll\J 1110111\lIngllwllllll\J111hIl111111110hpll hlll'\Jlo, (i, ^(ll11hlll\1 Ip Iho 0~1\J111 Ihlll Iho nWl'l1WIlIH 1'\Jllll' 10 Ihll orlglnnl ~~olllrnlllpl' ^ul'I)\JnWI11 UI1IIlI'\Jd Illlo IWlw\J1l1I Ilw PIII'II\JH, 7, ^lll11hlo\l, .., ,Il. Pun lilli, Tho HIIIII shlllul\J work WIIH plll'lhl'llwd 11)' .I.C, 1.\Jho I~ HOIlH. IIlU, 9, ^(IInhlo(1111 pllrl. (lolll\Jllln plIl'1. t\dl11hl\J1I thlll P11I11111fl' pII11I D\Jlol1dlllll 0\J1'11I11l . Slims In oonHI(lornllonllll' IholJlll1Hll'lIcllol1 of Ih\J 1'00111I1\1dlllonl\llllr\Jlllt\J(1 WOl'k 10 hi,s r\JHI\lonc\J, p\lfbl1dnl1llH pOl'fhl'lnll1g nnll1V\lHllgllllol1lo II\Jlllrl1111wlho \Jxnul H111O\1Il1Ihnt WIIH PIIIII, 10" ^dmllloll tlllll Iho. ol'lgll1nl\Jol1ll'lIol pl'lll\J IIWI'UIIS\Jd, AH Ihl' Ilw HlIhplIl'lIgrllphH, D\JI\111lInI111'\JHI1JlndH liS fhllo\YHI (II) ,i\dl11ll1\Jd Ihlll Dolul1dlllll IIdd\Jd woo(l, flool'll1g IIl1d IIpgl'lldoll ,cnrp\Jlhlg 10 tlw I'pOI11 111111111011 IIH dhwlud, FUl'lh\Jl'l11(ll'\J, tho cnrpotll1g WII~ II1Hlllllull by M&Z CHl'j1ots, fllo, (b) D\Jnlod IIH Hllllolli Tlw Dolol1dlllll hlHtnllud 1\11 oxtullslon to Hill UXIHlll1gphhnlwy of lIwl'oHld\Jl1c\J liS dil'uctod hlll'III1I1Hltol'illlH IIHUlI \y\JI'U d\JI\Jl'l11hw(1 by 1'111111111'1' whn hll'\JII hlH OWII OOl1tl'llOlol' Fll'oSPIIC\JH-I.lll1dH\JIlPO II, ' (0) ,DofondllllllHCOPY of Iho COl11pllllllt IH I11IHHlog col'lllll1 IlIl1gllllgo 1\'<1111 Ihls HlIllplIl'llgrnph, To thu UXI\Jll1 01' tho IlIlIgllUg\J Pl'oVlllolI, Ihu D\JfuIHIIIllt did 1111\11'111 PllIllltl!'1' Ihut oOl'llIln 1I0l11H \V\JI'O lind\Jl'blldg(llod nlld Ih'lIl mlded COSIH WOllld bo 11101l1'1'od. I, " the l1hllglllloll 10111l1k\J COI'IIIIII uhllllgOH 111111 l'opIIIOOlll\JIIIH IlIcllldlllg In Ilw YOl1lHwhlch Pllllntlf!' .2. 1)(/1'11I1/('111/1: '-11270 II' " " SXHIBIT A " '1"-\ '1 0, ',' , ',' mJHQUl!'lflfol, ,~'X'~' \, 'I PAV~(.\ J~I p(Jy'nn~o opn~tt'l\pt:~pn ~nli:1 np:\.~..))tJ f.lP"'~ngo Roqn no~l!ng f.lp~~ngpi. J.'^ 17007 n7/llilh.[jllIi0 Mwil Ill, lll1l7 foIArl~ An~ I~h, Jl"l;golH1m~ t:h 4lli Jllonovv~llo RpQ~ !'l13WVillp, WI 171141 771i..1l31l3 pprp13o\:ion 1:P /lOK/lU '~IO Pllil~ on \:h13 13K~i~t~ng ponOt'oto pM tIt tho' 1:(JfU: pf the h0l1113 ^ /l6K46 Q~~~tion ooneot(J~ to the homo. '.Vhe fplloldng il'l Q Hi'll: pf "ml1\13n:\.t:\.ol'l, :\" Il, 3, 4, 6, Ii, 7, 0, g, 10, ;1,1, 11l, 13, 14. In, 16, 17, , 10, IlKIi ptu~~~ng , VQU~to~ pOilingpfgQP10~l Probu!l\: truppep Q"plo~ TWo ooloniAl otee ~oor entrooa '1'Wo lArge w~nQOWI'l ,(to l"Atoh tho oille in kitohen) I"Pllr aky:t:1ghtp. Pry WAll finiahed ,,"d PAinted, VAinteQ woodtril11 rnnoh ptyle oArpeting , 6 inoh ~noulntion througho~t, 110\1001 wrnp t...ll1 eKtedo).' Pnintecl " Ulleotr:\.onl ^, '.I.'Wo outlutl3 pe).' WAll n, f.lwitoh Ceiling fnn with light ' a, l~eaet bre"Ker ))OK to new looAtion p, olenn up olQ wiring f.lpffit, fQO~A, gutter to matoh othel'a, TeAr of AnQ replAoe ahinglea of exail3ting homo, 116 yr f!lio).'glnfJl3 roinforood I3hinglel3 throughout. Rework entree fl'om'neW aQdition to home,' Proper vent unQ cobra vent , " . 'i 'l'otlll ooat of thil3 p,roj eat $ 10 ,71l1l. 00 , ThanK you fOI: oonl3idel'i!lg Pavid r~, DeVlUlie OOl1l3t).'uotion. " InoUrA!loo information il3 AvailAble for faxihQ1 QUqto pr:\oe il3 gUII).'alltoed for 30 day 13 f).'om the aboVe date., sinoet'e;ty I II ,',' David ~. DoVnl1io Page 1 " " 11 ' , " ",' ".' '" " ';0', fi " 1 " I:' }.I' ;/ 11, " rJ' II 'I; " ,. " II ;,,. " "I " EXHIBIT a " " "II I. ", /; '" " i'" " ! " .. " 't. I! " I', ,," ;,,, " ,.!, 'I. ii' " " " H " r> " " ;/', " " i.',. " "'-" " " " " f' I' " , ,I i' , " Ii " " " " " " " ';', " " '. , ;,., It.. " I, ;0 :.; " .,;', <I' 01' I'IIIlnlll'l's Civil CpI11plllllll Is IIIlIII'I1~11 IWl'olp llH IIxhlhll "^" l\llll IIWol'pnrnll'l1 h~I'\J111 hy 1'1l101'~llull \\'IIIH1\I\ lI\hnlHHloll PI' OW OOllllllllH OUlllllhwllll1ol'ull1, ~, 'l'h~ P\JI\JIHhllll IHlH 111'1I110111111 ^IlH\\'\J1' 11'1111 N\JII' Mllltol' III lhlJ Cp11\plllllll IIIllI 1i1l'W1I\'llfillII Illlho 1'1'lllhuIlPlm)' PI'Clll11111l1'11IIlII COllll1y Ih,:IlIlIl!!, t\ 11'1I1l 111111 Cl1l'1WI \II1P)' ol'llw HIlI'1 ^I1HII'O,: \\'1111 N\Jw .M II II\J I' IH IIlln\Jh~\1 IWl'lllu IIH I\xhlhll "11" 11I111 hWlll'plll'nl\Jll hlll'\J11l hy 1'\J1\J1'\lIlIlU, 6, ^11,llIloIlIII Dol~'llhml 1l111\Jl'llllll1lo II Hllhoo'111I'nu\ 1I!!I'IJUIlWl1t 11'1111 \)ulol1dlll1ll\ll' Ow , p~l'lbl'l11111101l111' o\JI'IIIII1, w\ll'k III Plnhllll'l'H l'\JsIIII'11O\J, whluh Is Ih\J s\lh,loIJI 01' Ow COl11phill1l, ^ II'IIUI\llI\'Il\H'I'uol oopy 01' tho p\'llpoHulllullllll1Ol1tH wl1l.oh IV\l\'l) llOO\Jpllld mil IIllllulwd 1101'010 UH llxhlhll "C" 111111 hlO\1I'pOl'nl\JII h\JI'\J111 hy 1'0 I\J I'\J 1I0\J , 7, Phlll1!1fPs C0l11pllll111 1I11\J!lIlH, 111 plll'l. Ihlll Iw HIIHtnll10d SOV\lI'O nllll HllhHlullthll Illllkll1!l to htH I'\JSlll\JIl\J\J l\H n I'\JH\llIol' \\'01'1\ 10!l1\l1'001' I1l1d thnt lhu wPI'k WIIH 1101 p\Jl'lhl'lllod 11111 " . wOl'klllll1\-lIk\J 1111\1\1101' In lhlll IIIH 1I11\J!!lld thlll J)olclldl\ll1 'lhll\Jd to l'I'pllloO oxlHthl!! mol' WI1IR with lWW WI1IH III Onlol' 10 1\1'lIld wnlol' l\JnkH IIn\I 1\11I\Jd \0 l'\Jplnu\J, hwtnll llnd/ol' IIpplYlWW plywood, l'nnlll'H, lolt pnp\JI'lIlld Hhhl!!I\JH 111\110 \JXIHlh1!!1'00l', H, PllIllltlfl'IIIHo nllu!!oH, In plll'l, lhnt ho 1'\JIIllh'IlR 1'0plnoIJnwnt ol'Pl'oplll'ly nl1d pnl,lllh1!! hOOl\\lHO 111' WlI1UI' ,lnUlIl!!ll, 0, ' ^ddltlol1nl Dololldllnl n!!\'\l\ld to nlld did pOl'lh\'l11lh\J WUl'k 10 Iho l'l101' 01' Pluln\ll'PR , " , l'oHld\11l00 fhl'whloh ()olondunllH \)ll1h1101! 10 h\J I'\JHpol1Hlhlll UH Hot Ibl'llI In I'lnlntlfl'H COl11plnhll, pnl'RIll\1l1 tullH HllhlJOlltl'l\\Jt with D\Jlondnnl. 10, ^ddlll';nnl D\Jlol1dnl1t nlso nHHlll11od, 1'0Hpol1Hlhlllty tll I'opnh' 1I\1l1 pl'oyonl 1\1\'lh\JI' lOllklll1l \1l111ul' nOl'l1l1\1 IWllthul' ol;ndlllunH In nocIIl'llnnco wllh tho PI'opoHnl'~vhloh \Vns uuouPlod hy , " , \)olol1dl\nl, 1 , - 2 . """",,,,'1//1/, Nino ',,' " . /i " S, On PI' I'IPPwl,J!me gal 1flQ7, Ihl3 p!1rtles antereq Into l'l wr/llen Aqre!:lmenl fQI' Ihe opnatrwPllpn of El ropm aqcHllon Ip I3lrqen13mllh'a raslq!:lnce I'll 41(ll3lpa!:lrvlllEl Rpl'lq, Newville, f'ennaylvl'lnla 17241, " 4, The PElfanql'lnl Wl'la to rElshapa IIW exlallnq roof tp ml'ltoh IhEl roof tp Ihe room aqqlllpn, A Irwa I'Inq corraol oopy flf al'llq I'IgraElmtlnt 18 ElttElohecl ~ncl Inoorporat13Qhf.lreln Py referenoEl Ela /::xhlplt A, p, PIEllnllff I'IgreElcl to pElY pafenQllnt I:lghtaen Thol.lllElncl SElVEln . Hun~racl Twenty" Twp ($18,722,00) PolIl'lra In qonalclerl'ltlon for tha opnlllruollon of the Elclcllllon to PIl:1lntlff'a reslclanoe, 6, The oontrElct price W(i1a aupJeo\ to authorl2:13cl ohElnge orders aaaet forth In Artlole 3 bf, the Agreement, ' 7, The PafenclElnt pullt El twenty fool (20') by twenty-eight (28') fool room Elclcflllon onto the Slrgensmlth reslcfenoe, 8, The. clefenclant I'Ilso put new sh/ngles on the exlsllng roof of the rsslqanoe, , 8, ,Slrganamlth palcl peVl'lnla Nlneleen Thowsanq five Hunqreq , , ($19,500,00) Oolll'lrs In oonslcfaratlon for the construotlon of the room Elcfql\lon I'Inel relatacf V(ork to his reslcfenoe, 10,' The original oontraot prloe Inoreasacf cfue to the following olroumstl:1noas: a, The Defendant adelacf wooel flooring and Upgracfecf Oarpetlng I,i to the room aqcfltlon, b, The Oefencfant built a extension to the oxlstlng ohlmney of the reslcfenoe: and 0, " At all times relevant her~to, the Oefencfant Informed Plall1t1ff " that Item!l for the prbJl;lot were underbudgeted so that any added ooate would be " /', J , 11, AI \~II ,llmea rplaWH11 h~raIQ, AOVor~ tW~ Il\.lPI\I~I1IIf.lII(;l(.lI~lna nH\ullo(j wllhlnlha PlrQPf1smllh realqanr.a ~~ n rl:lQU/\ pf the QpnatruQllon,of Il1p rOPnl . f.l~lI..llllpl1 ~nrj ralt1taq Warll to the rOPf, 19, On PI' ~~Q\11 Oqtoper 13, 1flQ7, I3lrpen!lmlll1 optAlnE!Q an ollllmfltl3to rapfllr the Qf.1m<<oa Anq to cprroQI the;. clef~otato the rpom I\clr1lllon Ell1\.lto thC:1 relllqanoe, The eatlm~tad oPlltlllln the Pin pUnt of eight Thpullewl Tlm~E\ Huncln~q Nll1e1y"f1v~ ($a,\Hl/,l,OO) PolIl.\r!l,^ trlle rm~ pprralltr.opV pf l:I~IQ Pf'ppoSI;\IIEi t1tlAoheQ Elncllnoorporfltf3d 1111r~ln tJv referanoe I'l$ ~xhlpll a, .,' ~ ~.Q~ ,13, PIt1lnUfft1Vlilrfl eAch I.\l1(j evolY ~lIegA"on eat forth In PArflgrapha 1 though, Q of the Oompllillnt flnQ Inoorpora\ea 'ol.\oh SInd evelY ona her~ln lly roferenoe t1f\ prevlaU!3IY !let fanh harl;lln, , ,14, Paragraph One (1), tlllpd "^IUol~ 6, Gl,'lneral Pravlalons" , of Sl<hlblt A lltt1telllnrelavanl Pflrll "All Wol'k 1111<111 be oampleleq In fl workmfllHlke mflnner anfl In OompllAnoe with llll bUilding codes t1nd other applloa~IG lAWS," 15, Par~l'Jraph Thirteen (13), t1l1ad Artlole 5. General Provisions, of ' ,," Sxhlblt A stllles II' relevlilnt partl .OontrElotor warrants all worl~ for a period of , ~4 months followlna Qomplat/ol1," " 16, Defendant matertally breaohed the parties contraotliy parformlt1Q his dul/el1ln a non-workme\t1l1ke mr.lI1ner, /lpaolflonllY: , ' t\, PEll/ed to replace Gxlsth1D roof venta with neW vet1ts In ordar to avoid Water lealH31 " I r ~'i!~t\ I, ! L~~~G,"~ 0 1998 QcA S l;;,..~....<-f~X ,,'In < . wUh m~w plywpoel, rAfterll, fall p~parl ~nel slllnglaa II? the exhl\lno roof; 0.' Onnalr~oteel fl dafeollVQ hip roof to ~n axil/ling (l~blf:l roof to ellvart wl1ler qff tlla roofl el, Falleel to properly flElall qhlmney wllh propar metl'llllnq rOClf cemanti Fallael to rElpalr an exlating powlng Qab/e enel Clf thEl roof; , f, lhatalleel E\ SElameel g~t1er rather than a aeamless guttElr tg tha room E\elellllon aa originally agreeel 10 by the partlesl g, Installeel elefeotlve T~111 sieling to the room I'lelelltlonll'lnel h, Failed to Install paneling anel pl'llnt trim arounel newly , ' ' Imlt~lIael Frenoh qoorll that le/;lq Into 1I1e room l';\eldltlon, ,. ,< 17, All a ellreot and proxlml'1te result of DefanelE\nt's materll'1l bral'1ch of contrl'1ot, Plalntlfrs reslelanoe! WI1S left In a stata of desp~lr, caUsing damage poth physloally and l'lesthetloEllly tei the home therepy eleprlvlng Plalntlff.fulI use anq enjoYment of his property, 18, As a dlreot and prOXimate result of the DefenQElnt's material , prel'loh, Plaintiff will pe required to Inqllr flnanolal expense ancl lossea to repair the damage and to correot the defeats In the resldenoe, e, .." , " " , WHaRaFOREl, Plaintiff, Mark I3lrgensmlth, respeCJ\fuIly requests JUdgment against Defendant, David ~, DeVanle dlpla David L, DaVanle,Oonstruotlon, In Eln amount whloh does nat exoeedthe Jurlsdlotional Elmo\lnt I attorney's fssa, Intersst, as well as any reasanaple amount deam appropriate by ,the Oourt for , future oosts, 1 ' "j=.~.iWKf':l I L:'~~:'r~:l~l~~ " 0 AwS 1..,.....,...J7.t.lil'~ ~" , I:'~ , , )~.;, d~fl'lnQrml! WH~R~FQR~, PIl'!lnllff, Ml'!I'I~ ~'rgallllmlll1l I'aspao\fl-llly reqwflslEl Jwdgml'lnl ' f'l(1l'!lnal Pllfllnqf.lnll Pf.lvlq ~, peVl'!nla d/l.l/El PElVlq ~! PaVr:mla QpnEllrwolloll, In an Ilmol.lnl whloh qOlla nol axoeaq \l1a jl.lrlsqlollonl:1l Elmol.lnl pll.ls Inlerelll, oasIs of Ill.l II I altornlly'a fell~, l'lnq any reaaonaple Elmol.lnl qeemeq ElpproprlElle Py 11111 Ool.lrt fpr M~lrl'l oosla, " I' " , ~ Pllla:'~,-- ~'-!l.\~~ ~~,~'.. I-.i l~' ' ".....~ Reapeolfl.llly Ill.lpmllled, ,C~-tQ . \~QLQ~~'~' peler J, Rl.lllao ' , ,- Pate:,~" \~~~'~~& , '~~~c?~~JJ~ Mlo ael g, DUEll 13s'l_ ,," " I' ,i' ' if ,. " ,I, " '1',1 " " , ,,, ]i " \, '; " " II, i, " '" II' " ". " " " I ~ / ' " " l' " " " " " I' " " " " Ii, H' " ,,' " I' " EXHIBIT A ,', 0" " .,1' ',,, I. i I, , ' , Ii' "CORRECTION ,~, H, , ' ,,' " ,~" , " 'i, I' " " , j' ,1,1 Ii' "t" I . , tfrl'{! , , II ~'~m\ M~' CONrI1{~'I'()n A(~"~le~UlJNT .' 'fJllij t\OllJm~WN'~' llltul~ 'h~ ,A1 rrr-h.~~y \If Ji"H':l.F: , 1"'1 ~~/,II~ 1~IW~qll , ';i4Y'lll k, 'D If- \ff\..(\, ,;:, , h~r~ll1~flmllll~\1 !ho P\ll1lr~p'Iir AIHII"I (l (k 1.3 o1Il 'l'';I6'r/~l'li I;) I hfllllllAl\or 01\1101 110 PWI\PII , " , r o'..~ ' ( ", WIlII~'ltllhll' Iho (~llI\lIjll1'llr !\lilt Ih~ f~wllor fill Iho f""'I!Iorllll\llllllll",~III~ro" Iii follllwII . ^lil~I~', ~OllHr!llt W"I'/l '" 11110 POnll'AOI~I' ~hllll "Iflllih 1111 or Iho ml\lorl~l. 1I11~ POlll1l1',ll1l1of 1110 WOI~ 'hmvlI \In "'0 Pr!lWhllll IIIIIVllr 1'9tcr1~~ n lito RllIIotnORII!lII' 01111110" I1xhlhll A, II~ IIIHlOXPII hOI\1\o III II 1>l111111111 10 II'Prk \11 1'1\ porfnulIol\ 1111 IlrllrollYllllf~ ~',. ~rtIJ 1I/~lJIil'" ('>'f?' MIM~~, '1'11110 "' OOIl\l1lollon '_ ~ ' ~"" work 11\ ~o l'urfpnl1\l<I \111~Or Ihl~ CnlllrMI 'hlllll>o IlOIlII1WII~o!1 Oil PI' ""lilloC! I.>,..\~ "I () ,IP911111" rhilllllll '"hll~lIl1l1l1,1' 911111plOlllll 1111 lIr \lIlroro Av.,::I\-'o~'\' , Cl , Il,lo:n 111110 Illlf Iho m~lIoo! 'n\O 1'0111111'1118 onlllllh\lo~ IlIhllftllll.1 omn"'~lIaolll~lIlllf WPrl; /1111""011I In H\'~ flrl'/,oa~1 nn" olllllrn~II', ($~IfY) ~~f~ (J~ MIM~ 3, 'fhe CIIIIII'~~I.lflnp t.', ~ OW,Mf 'h~IIIlAY llioC~'~\rOclOr for Iho 1I111\qrlr1 OII\II~,It<lr III \I~ pl'rrormr~I III!'I!lf Ih~,COOlllWllhb 111111 of PIS,h44lI',n h~MlVl~ 6.e14Nr! hl'W.( (rM 'OWr't'lfI-/;li'tJP P911r.r1 ($/ hi7it:J, "',?, .\II~~1111 O~t1l1l9111ll1lll ~~IIollpl" 1111fillnnl III nlllhPII,td nhnllllo ofllor~" " , ^,"lcl~ 1, "rp~.~ "A~IlIM~ reVIll~lllllr Iha CoolrMIl'flon ~hl\lIllO mrhlllllho 11111111101' fnllowln~l_ I '\' . V\'\ V1>I.-JI' 'r\, .....\~,\. "~I~H"I, ~ $\1-)'''0-Q4~~ ~ \';>n.o\\.I!lCl,.' 6l,A~A- I. r\""p,\1,"'Pl ~ '~I~IA /, - " I ' ,.. ... MM~l~~~r~~~~}~H~n '\;I,9()Q,'" \)PPi1 ((1>'1'\fl~41(ln " IPO('.l, My o1\orollollllr ,lavlollolI from Ilia nhnvo ,/,polnnnllolla, hlohl~IIIIlI\lillltlllhllllo'lln noy .IIph "1\orollollllr ,IevlllllolllllvolVlllll p'IIIIIIollnl "'MuriAl PII,Vpr Inhr,r 1'0111, wlIIl'~ nXePlllod 0111,1' IIppn" II'rllloll ontoI' for IftlllA, .18110'1 ,II,\' OWMr Oll~ CPlllrAolor, 0,"1 If Ihoro IUlly phnrllo for ~lIoh llliornllllll or ~ol'lnllolll Ihll nrl~llIonnl. nhnrao will he olldn" 10 lh~ oonlrol'l' prloo 111'1111.00111(001, ' , , ,If /,0,1'11101111. IInl rn~dn Whell d"O, COlllroelor mA,\' I\I~reI\!I wark on Ihn luh 11111/1111011 111\\0 0'11/1 poymellll, " ~\I~ h~v~ hOnh ll\~do; ^ f~nur~ 10 mllke ,'"ymalll fur II 110rl0l111l oxonllllf.-' ' IIA,I'I fmm Iho ,duo dnle llf Iho J1~ymollllhonllo ltoomo,' II rMlorlllll>rnlll'h pf Ih1. ponlrnol, ,,' III A~dlllnn, Iha foll0l1'In8 pOllornl provlflon, ~r.jll,1'1 " 1\ 6" w.l!rk ~h~1I 1lS.~I~J' III o.\VQI~~o mllnn~r ~11't In oOUlplhinco ,vllh QII '_lP C0I1M Rnd nlhpr " ...ijIJlllanliie lows, " I" ,. ~,' 'nl~lInlri'~lOrlmilr furnish II pion ~nd Scolo dtPIVlnU IhnIVlnn Iho jhopo, .I~Q dlmellllllll'l alld oOllslmOllon nll~ oqlllpmont 111DOlnllllllolls fur homo hllprovDII1UIIIM, II dOlurlpll9.11 of tho work lu 110 doo~ nnd dosr.rlplloll \1f Iha IlIPlorlals 14 110 IIsod 1\lld Iho olll1lplllonllll 110 115011 Of Inslnlloll, And Iho 08rood , oonsldnrullolI for Ih~ wurk, 3, ~h Iho oXlOlllloqlllrc4 hy 1ftII' nil work Ihall 1>0 Il\lrfollllod llY InlllvldlllllN "Illy lIo~nlo,1 nn~ O\l1l1011~ hy IIIV 10 1>OI(U/11\ 111111 work, " . 4, ClllllrllOlnr IIlAt ollis dl~arollon 1'11110110 I\I~OOII.clor'lo pM~nn \York hNulllldof,llIlIl'ldC<l Cllllh';10lur .hall ^llIy pay anlrllll\loollll'lllllor fllld 111 allll1llnn~U 10101l1n rOillonllhl~ far 1ho JlfoJ1llr oUl\\plolloll of IhlJ CUlltraol, ~I Culllroclor il'nn furnlah Ownw ,A11j1r\lJltln10 rOloILl~~ or \VolvoraM 11011 for all WOI~ Il/llf~l1nDd Ilr mPlerl.ll , 11101'/clod 011 Ie 11100 tho nO_lllollodlc l'oYllluflllhnllllO dllO, ' 4, All ohnnllo otdor. shAll \lo In wrlth\1l flllu .IUIl"" holh hy OIVMr 011<1 COlilrt"IIOr, oncl sholl 1111 IlIuol'\\Ornlcd lnl ftlllllJccomo 0 ~M1 of 1110 oonlruol, 1, Conlroolof IVMIOlllo H I, 0(1(:(1111I101)' hlllllod for h\J!l1}' 10 II~ Oll'(lloYl'.llS ond alhnl. IlIcUlllull loss lit h~IIJY nv o r01!l1l of 1110 llal~ or COl1lraolor or 113 Ollljllo) DO>> UI MlllOllnlraolcIII, ' . lar $111\11 at lIs,owlI ox 10 ant> 0 "nlla 1I0CQ.lIlIIIY tor Iha work 10 III' IlCrfol'fIIJJJj,--J(1'~ tv'c!: q~ , CoulrAClor parelll U 11IIHll Oft lor 1 all 1001'0 litO jifOl11tKH1i1 bloom olOl1n oonOlllon, ~y 10, 1111110 ovom OWuar .hAII filII 10 pay MY 11011011/0 ot h\.llJllltnolll (laymon\ duu hurounder, Conlronlor",.)' COMO r work wllhonl ~reoeh JlIludllli IlaymOIl\ ot 1010111\1011 of 011,1' dh(llllu, .' II, All dl~pUlc. horeUllder lhnll be toao'~od hy hlodlnll tuhllr^,hllllu ncoor<IMlco \Vllh 111101 uf Iho AmclluolI ' AthlltMlal\ Auoolnllol\, , 12,ColIllAClor Ihollnol ~o 1I0hlo fot OI\Y dlllllY dllO'11I OII\1UI1\IIIII\OIlI beYlIl\d Ila I'onlrnlllloludlnn Illtko., OMUIIIl,l' or lIol\ornlulIPvAlhlhlllly or lllllletlols, ' <U)COllltllclllf WMTlIllI. 0\1 IValk fot 11 porlod III it" mOlllh. follllwlllll Wll\pllllloll, " " J~~J~!~~~~j t . c> F..it .....1/'"'.1..11,1011 ~.u "",I,ll ""'I'''~ Ii, nlll~ 11/ I,I"~" ..6 .u.lil Whll'1II1hln.lllr. IIhd~lI)' In )ltlur rnrll\lllltll UIIII~klltlll. C"lllhll.IIIW~L't U)UII ~llbl lhG '1)"111. ntu." tor ;twt ~'pol' il,~ ~\fj n.t '~l~' rOIl'" itlll\t,.'tMl4-t huh flo t"'rll'\t~'_UIl" III WNfMlrt tip".. ot Ill'lpllc4, wllh t"f~"lh' "." ',nllb 1/1, .tllll ,nllll "" In Inl'Ii~" liil 01 r""",'" 'IAlVll.<lllNII APIIR '.,,' PRQPO~A'" No, N~mll /nMJ: ' l'!~rllll~ t(/~ 6/41 , PI~v YJtM4~udIe. Phanl! 77/P "9$;'3 W. horn ':;;;;;;"1;';;; ";;;;; "~~~~~r~1;J ~ 4Va!u .If~, 7laA. LJ.1 ~hfl~ tfl0~{)JvI{) ..fef!la~ L.-~d 1';~1f. L.t<<d .4r:fj)tr vi~ V(e/ll(ue.vw~~f( Il(!(.J. ~ 'L;d}JttJfdi fu<d Jl ,'f b Al.lft#4) i..f-tt ~f(?(/ (Ule! .(JI~..v, -7jt4.IJ!4t<tutLM~?e. Y~L.-?U(4f.€N d(i.IX~I-'?<htd ~ ~ r~ I '. . ., " fMd .Jft.4U ui~0~r ,atta~A-(r Voct/l4tul ~?(devt~' ~r6c/~f WA-'U~. L-ltkf(, -- -r;(.(l.'t~~tlfxdt. ::: It J'OC), a.n . , ,.., ., 'f:Y .' IIMIv tM(f/YIJltf.-y Uvtt/" metal ~4/)t;j &~-71tMJ=p!oo,~ I35t PI1 '1 /JafJfuw) i U/)tdl liltflu (dJ/f71.; j(U,W yuA4tail' , . ~m-tu:J"gatIit · 7iiU ~. .J&ntd fjt(.tlt. I 4#-t ~tttt ,r7i'tal.!tW UI /!wI;.t.t. dtlttftlw. H II ~a.ialAi ,.,~ It 5ot> eJJ , . , , ' Jjfla.tt.. .bMMlJtmL &l.lt1f #/.~tIt d,V tt..'d1l cv ffUit.t due YziuXJ;~ dr~, ' "All mabarlQI Is aual'ontoQcJ ~aba as BpaallloQ, oncJ tho ahovo War'k to Po psr'armod In ollollrdanoo Wlbh tha dr/lwlnaa and apaalflaatlona aubmlt:tsrJ for abavlll work and aomp!at:acJ In 0 suhotantlnl wnrkmonllko mannoI' for bha allm of With pal'msnts to bs macJs so fOllawsl..J.a #' &t Dollars lIB . 1. fJ ' ., 'My IItorotllll1 or ~l\'Iatlon trom auova apooilloa~lona Invol~na o~tro ': 1;;:;' /) - " o.o.t" Will b. a".lItall only IIpOll wH~tan ol'd .rt, and Will hocolna on Raopsotflllly submitted ~ a>tr. oh.rg.lMlr.nd .uovo tll. ..~IIn.to, All 'ONlOll\.nto oontlnaont ' , /3; (b I uPotl .trilo" 6Cold.nto or d.l'l" b'jdndour 'on~rol, Owner to uol'i'V P It/A 1 A '1'}I' A+, ,,".h M HNl, tomodo and o\h.r noco.. ry In"lranc. lIPotl.IIlII'U wor~, Wor~' sr fe(,U ,. \J' ~crt",( mill'. Oampanllllon and Pllullo Lllu,lItV Inaurenco 011011"". work to ha ' , ,1'.'f1llUt hV " " Nota- TI1Ia Ilrol3J1BJl.ll11oy bo withdrawn by ua If not aaoepted " , , ' within "'U dsl's, , Po~a It)- 5.97 BIWa~ Na, (I) Ir~ J!!t.P.arlcrmoll Ah. , " ., . . , ?MtftuJ fmt~llwf4,ufIe~p.-; ."'~. It 3 1iUPt &dt. /J Oll;y (}UtUJf.e, l'!r.~t~ ill , Pata of Pleno/?) 'S.97 AI'ohltpnb Yf.1/Ud ~~ .J AOOIiPTANoe or PROPOSAl. ' nla abovll prlooQ, apob/floatlohs ond oancJltlons oro satlafsatarl' oM ora hsrol1y oaoDptud, You ars suthorltod to do tllo work 00 spaolnsd, , POYl11011t 1'111I Ud mods aa outllnsd sbova. , " " ~ 'I nllli-2f1-!lfI 12,3'1 1'1'1 !IF' 1I1.11l~ 11111 nfil1f1p, fl1 Ill) 7.", 7.111'11 .,~ I ~~ F~":fl"''''.1I:'\';;'''\:''::~:Ir.'';;>.,='C---,." '-=='" , rl;lpP~n ,...."""......."=-=-0.."" ""', ......,.w_.. '1"1 ............,._...'" , J,C), 1111 .. ION', IN!), ' ~r I ~I Ilf IIlI In. tid4 III ~'l" 1',11.1 .__~ 08., O~~\~~~:~~W'I l'illii"lliiTi.i'~.i)' ~ /' "'" ,,, '. ",'I 'ilii~"""...~~ ""I'IW~;~"'~'-"-~-','- 1 - ,~P.'..rf, ...",(I..~UA::U.(".~, 1" -, ,...11 ,..' ,--,Q. _.. I ';L;'~2-.....\, Z'l .,~~.a_&<'et~'r<".,Q~.,~~~:, ..':"I~:P.._ ." , ,.... _'OO, _...._____.._. __.._.,_ ' '1\'1~"'I' ,,~ 4t&' ,r '??"';;i, '~' <1'2" ',-, ~' """~,,"'" , 'J~1.!. :L/... ~rr;.".i" /.7.1 ~,_..,.t.:'~r~ _~,~.~~~:~......~.._ N1QlPI,i:;"-' "'li~wOF rIA" '7'ri~~"a ',..........'--"_..,~..,..,...,""'"..,, -- .". , "....-...."""'_.....""", ~.,_,-rr __~:.._ ,''''''''_=.".., Wv Itl'f~11Y ~'11!l1l,1 ,'(Welrl("lhJI" Illllt lJIIU1"UI~'lvl: I' ./J ./ ~ /J. LP , 4- ~t ,~I'~ r?ft.'~ ....~ ~ t'1td -~ 7'? r ~I(P.~ 4-(4~ ~ ~~ ~#"7 ~~~~ ~I'~h-? ~",d~~ ~~ ~~"~~~-A",,~,:, , ,'Jt"d ;A., A<- ~~.&~ ~ dJ,...+-:':'>bl /~?~ .'., LL4 " 4/ it.., ~ C,'rlli'I" 2-~;;7 , "." ,;;:? f!?7 9-' " , .....,{, ~\1.l..-.,.H~l"'=ll':'-tr.-'r.o;r '\:.~:..&~...I, '" lU:':.oo"r=jJ',:a~'" If=r1' ......1.,1..., .~...~r" ','14,'.'1_"'" ",..:_ ,.. ltIr p ~pa,sr ;;;.,orObY 0 furnlnll m~\hrlal alld Intlor '''' OompIDI"n uODordnnoo Willi ahove ,poDllloMlfo1\'" fttnli1l8wlI oh ",,"" , ... ,,,. ~" -~~-' 'r"'" "'..,~,L, ,_. .11011011('.. /~..~_I, ,'6yrnltf1llu 1,1 hWI'1 1\" 11.11.\l~ : ' , _ r- -..,-.".-....... ." ,..', ,,~.... ,...,..., '-' ,."oot. ,,,- ,.. '_...._, 1,_' .... ..., '__, "___ , ._,~ ., .-, .'. .'. """""." ..' ,"~ .-......."'. -....-. '.-.,..---'.-_1...' AI ""U"II~t .,. (JIlItIIlI1l"IQ 10 bv ",vt)Oolh~. f.J1 WOf1l to b. t'OlnpltltU tn . WOfltl'tllf\lIk, fTWV"/ 4\C/;O'Q'II~ IQ ..1,,,vht!11 ~I,"~"O.. ^'IV "'lfl.llon Of cItlvi'I~l'\ tram lbO~v _ptellQlllQllt Irt\'dYtlt Otlll W,I_ w~l bu "1I:'\',\llIt ant\' ~tn wrlnffl Gl~.t, IIld WI' bt\-'Oml an ..11. chIIt' Q~II ~".. .tKI~l Ihll ""iMIA, AI, V,'nlllllll tqrlltng~l~ l.,xttt '''1)''1. IQQtdunl. ., ""I' ~'I'W1Q '" '"'..'" 0"",, kJ..I 1'0, 1"'0<10 II1d .VlI' n'''utl'! ~'"11i1C1l" , "" I'CI'h<<' tiN! '"'t c"r'rrwI hr WQt~h4l"'1 Oofl"lP"""II~n InlltJl.lI~", , ' ..:...1 "'I', .,"TlCl:U...~=~'.._.;=.~u.. . t\ftL't1tnllrl! pf prllJll1dnl .. I'.. '~U\'ll Pl~~., 'OI.,IIIIIIkIl" ""d 'UhcktloM .,a ,"fl"I'JIIIY 1f1~ a'. "ul~bV ,celli lad, ~'\l 01' luf"""'ld Sign I 10 dO ".. v..I'~ .. ."..m. , r'm,.", 100" blll1.d. ., ",,1~11'" liJo\'Q, llaltOfAOj)'ol.,ICI' ........-" ..___ slgoalUlO. ,_._. -~..._, .1;...,..__&.1, I_:'~Jo_ ... 1-' ._. It ""1__.---, "..,.,-"'..- --. . -'-' ..'.1,.,/, .LC::;'~ I~l .'t="' .U:=;,\:l, , 'l; ;, .. " Ij~j4 .",1 \ "1.1\1-:2\1-"'11 I'll"",' 1'1'1 111'1 111.FI~ 11111 I1RRnr-InT!lA ~o1 I '1111" 1'1 nl? I, ,/""=""'''",,,,,,,,,,-:;,'''r. .",~_i~="""='-lI"-'-"== !ll1 r a fn, (l It I 0--" .".,,, .Y'V~L,,==, ,.. ,~~ "u,,,,,w""'~~~\... ' '. ., i~i'~;,r~~~r' iH,~~f' II QU111Ill!JlM~.I' " lmmi,'4hl ~, ' ':"'" ""''''''J7~; .:. '! ..../\q'1;;2 , ~~~.,~" J"PAl!. Z' "1-' ';:-......"........ ". -"" .,&i.t~~,,{1f.! ",,,,--.4,.,, ,... .-.'1,{~(.rt7--,..,.. "~ ~' c::""p~ lOllI/AI" (I.., , .....'2. , .? 'S' '. , -I..J ' "'II~" ~'" ~ ~ '.' ~ " "1""'=." , fI /7." ... "'." ,n"".. ."'"'' .. ,....:.~~'"'fN:l n, '5"J.... JOnnc.'II')..I {.. ~~.p2 ~ b......J ^ri{)1tf',r, ":. .. t~_.~~~ 'i~If~fH.vln/?':;:; ...77 't'/... .~~ ,.. ~~~~'i,';'i~'i;'~" ,. '-'''''''''--. - .-.-.. _ d& ., ... .."="", '" ,,"", "" " '=I..'~'"......,..,...."..~.........J.,.~-~,...-,._-_J"..".,._....-;n..__... W"hl"II'V'''''''"''~I'''''''I''.n",IYII~III''''lfll'' ' ., -......... ......,.'.. /~~~~~ ~, t. ~I--r'~ t"''' t~"~ ~,:;J ~.4f" 4?' r'/?'~~ ' I I' '"; , I' (\,\ ~ ~D ~) \{J> C't' ? I II I"~. '" "'lil" p;o;;;;'''h';:;;-; "..;,.;';;",;".; ~;;"",,'~,~"i:;;;; ..;~".;' ;",; ;.;..;';;~;i;.;";;;:.i ;;;;;;;,; -- ' ::f~':2-:~"!~~ ~~c:.-:..r dlJl,n'U\.-,Lc22~,...." PlfI'll. 10 bo moo u lolloWI' . "_"._H'_'M"" . ."..,,_..'..~,' "..,. " ,...,,,..., .' ,-,'.', "~'-"'''''''''' ..-..-..,."'" ,.--- ,.--......1'--......_..__"'''' ,..- ..~.,',. .~._.., .. :-'c";.~;r-..'.. .. -.,,',.... ' .'.." - .''O, ,.,...._ ~ 1n.,."..II. V~lIlnt.td 10 b. .. 'Pt~lllllIl AN ~cllk 10 I1t cum~I"M III . 1'ffl00ltlli1'lkt 'IWl'ltlll'A"nltllt\Q 10 "ill4llfG p,al4IoQI. /lJIY ""b'"II01\ Of dhla~on '101" ,..boye ,ptCJ'IU!'o"t In,,"'MrlU ,.UN CUllt ~" b, .......vt'd nnly ~O" WI/UIlI (It'dll'. .ull Wj~ ~~r". 1111 '.1'. ',I~il ~ nynl M" nM~fi Inll "Umll., NI \'I 'Il"'O,"', ~()fllinglJnl Upofl lUlU', .tel,f"II. " ~".," "'1,,"1 "II '~"II'1 0''',., 10~!1 ~tt, lo,"u, I.' 01"" nl~ nlry '''''1011>'' Till. rlop~~Ullnh~ b~ OIH W\IIhl~ .," tulty.~UtvIW,IJt' W~l~ttl"'" O\lfTlpon~nllo" In'!,ll*~~~, w"hdrawn y 11,11 tlO notll~led WIthIn ...,., , ,......~. ".. t"- ,_ d"V' , Amv;/iiitiuf PrUplIBlil I". 'b'~"IIII"':::"III"III111:''''-"= ~ /~~..,,~;. ~'"I "."'hl'"''....''' ,QI""ldury _"U ". Iio'.~r .C~OPII~, You "'W lulli.,II.U 610n"UI'1l"P''''- or ~ In ~" Ih. Willi Al IV.I:I".U, I'nynlOIII W,U hu IIIMII 01 .l/iII"I~ Ahove, , ,~ Pulll ul MCfl'III.rw,: -.,..;....__,1* "",___...., ~ .,....--'-...~.. OlgtlahJ,e ...~ ,---......_ \;'~j. JtI-<tJtl'l'ta.' ,.11,.';1"Au:ti:::=:'~"J.\I':',U= ~"'''-=n\W:- ..-. ~1_~" ," 'i' M^HKIIIlWliNHMITII, 1'111111\11'1' IN Tllli cOIJlrr of COMMON PI,li^H OF (~lJMIII\HI,^NP CO! IN'I'Y, llliNNHYI 'v ^NI^ CIVil, i\CTION .I,^W NO, 0~'~1l1l7 UIVIl, \IN, , 1M VIP I" I)I!V ^NII! (1/11/11 P^ VIP 1" DIN AN III CONHTI~\JCTION, ,llJlW 'I'HIAI, PliM^NP\iJ) D\Jlolllh\l1\ JlIWI~NnAN'I"S ANSWI~n WI'I'II NIDY. MA'I''I'Im,'I'O COMIILAIN't \, AI\I11I\1ud, ), Al\mllluellliloopllhllt Dufol1dllnlllOl'IlHllly ol1lynHlkuH 11111\ roc\JlwH phol1\l uIIIIR III " ' 1 ~63 llolllng Sp\'h1gw HOlld, llllll1l111 Spl'll111H, \lOI1I1RylvlIllll1 17007, 3. Aelmlll\Jd. 4, D\JIlI\J1\ IIH Hllltol\, Tho 1)0r\Jnl\nl1t onlo\,\J1\ Inlll n Conlrnolo\, ,t\grool\\\Jnt wllh \1ll1lnllfr 011 ,1\\110 2", 1007 whloh uonlll\11H Iho\~I'InH Hol Ib\'Ih In IIw l\o\Jllnwnl 1I\1l1oh\Jd 10 Ih\J , Compli,11l1 liS Exhlhll "A", Ilowuvol', IIw Agroonwnl 1I\111oholl IIH Exhl\1lt "A" 0011111111H 1I110\'1I\lonH Inollldlng umlol'lhlOH IInd mlll'lllnnl oll11111\IJIlIH whloh W\JI'O nol p\'osonl on 1\10 o\'lglnlll " Conll'llolo\' Agl'00!110nl, 'Mo\,ooVol', Iho AgrconlOl1lnnnoxon tlw qllolo, II lruo l\I1el Col'I'oot copy of whloh IR lI\1nchod ho\'ulo nH Exhlhll "A", nnrlnlHo IH Huh.l\Jcl 10 nn nddondl1l1l, III\'no 'nul\ oOl'l'oUI.. \lOPY of whloh In nlln\Jhod hol'\J\o nH Hxhlhll "\l", h(lIh 01' whloh 111'0 11l001'llol'nlOd hOI'olll by " \'ol'ol'onoo, Thc orlglnl1l Conlrnclol' Ag\'o\Jmunt ns wull I1H Iho quoto nlld 111\I\0nl\\1Ill sponk fbr thOI1lH\JlvOH, 1 , /loclIlIlellllll/4/1711 " " 5: P~IlIIl(1 '\S HIII1~ll. Tlw plll'il\J~ 11l1111l11l1!1'~onW!ll \Y!lH 1\11' Ih\J H\l11\ of $1 H,722,()() 1\1 l\~\lol'\llI1w\l wllh Ilw 1l1'1~11I1I1 Con11'l\C11I1' AI!I'Cel1wnl. II0WllWI', lIWl'e \WI'\J IIlldillollH 1111\1 llel~tlol1H lhl\llIn~ol\Jd Iho \l01111'1I91 pl'lu\J 11101111111111 lIw ndd\Jllli\l11\ nllll\Jh\Jll hlll'\Jlo, (I, ^lil11ltl\Jll 10 lIw ~XI\J111 11111\ tho llYUI'l1Wl1lH 1'\Jlol' 10 Ihe ol'lg\nlll C0I111'l\1l1.n\'. AI!I'00llWI11 Ilnllll'ellll1lo hQIW\Jol1 \ll\J PlIl'lleH, 7, ^lhnIHllll. H, DOIII\Jd, Th\J slIl\1 tJhll1l!lo work WIIS p\JI'I'o1'111011 hr .I,e. I,ohll & 1l011H, 1110, 9. ^dlllltlud \11 plll'l, 1l\JI1I11d 111 P"l'l, ^lhnlll\Jlllhnl PllIlnlll'f pIIlll DolOl1lhlllt llol'llIll1 s\lIlltlll1 oonHlllol'lIlIol1 1'01' lho oOI1Hll'llcllol1of Ih\J 1'0PI1\ lIddlllol1l1l1\ll'ollllod work 10 hlH I'\JSlll\Jl1oo, f)\Jt0l1dllI11IH pOI'I\J1'I1111lg1111 Il1vcHIlml\ll111 \0 dOlunnhw Iho OXIIOllll11olml Ihlll "'"H plI\ll, . 10, ^.lhnltlPll Ilmt Ih\J orlgllllll 001111'1I01 pl'loo hWI'\JlIslld. As lill' \lw S\lhplIl'nl!l'lIphH, ' pololI<llll1l I'IlHpol1ds IIH IbllowHI " (II) Alhnlll\Jd Ihlll f)01\1Ildlllll IIddod Wll!)ll 1l00l'hUl lIn<l \lpl!l'lIdod Olll'polll1g 10 Ih\J 1'110111 IIddllloll liS dhwlod. FIII'lIWl'l11ll\'lJ, \ho' olll'potlnl! wnH.II1Hlllllod hr M&Z Cnl'pOIH, Ino, . Donlod nH Hlntod. Tlw Dolondnnl hlHlllllod nil Plllol1sl11n 10 Iho 1ll\lsllnl! ohhnnoy 01' Iho l'oHI<lonoo ns <lll'oolu(1 hn\1111 n\nlOl'lnls \lHod ' \yOl'O dolol'mlnod hy \lIIIh1lIlT who hll'ud hlH own oOlllrno\oll Fll'oHpno\JH-i,nndHonpo 11.' , , ()ol'onllnnl'H ollPy 01' Iho COl1\plnlnt Is mlHHlnll uOl'tnln 11I1l1llll\IlO I\'om IhlH H\lbpnl'lllll'nph, '\:0 lIw ox\on\ of' t1w Inl1g\lnllo pl'llYldoll, Iho ()%ndllnl did Inthl'm PIlIlnlllT Ihlll oOl'lnl11 lIol11s WOI'O llndol'b\ldllotodlll\<I Ihn\nl,lded UOHIH \Yo\lld bo 111011I'1'0<1, (b) (0) ,,' , II, CllnllhlSlol1ol'lnw. no nI1SIV\JI' 1'0<1\1ll'od. If nil nl1SIVOl' IH l'u<1\1I1'od, tho lIY\ll'lnOl1ts n1'0 speolnonll>, donlod, MOI'OOYOI', Plnllltll'l'hnd pl'0-oxlHl1nlllonklng pl'obloll1S1 PlnlnllffnsHllmod ,.. IlIu ohllgl1llon \0 II1nko o\Jl'lnln ohnngcH nl1d l'uplnooll1\JnlH lllOhldlhg to Ih\J Y\lntH \Yhloh 111nhl\lll' 1)"<'1/11"11I ~,' 14/170 .2- " '1i\Il\Jfl 1\1 porli11'11\ 11111\ WI1I1111 11111)' hllV\l 1l011\rlhlllll\1 In IIIlY 1I\111U\J" IlllIKlllUi llw 1I\111IWlt onllHlnloll\111111111 worK 1\11110 1'00t'wl1l\lh IH rololToll \\1 hy PIIII11111T \11IIY hll\'O h\J1'11 p\Jrl'nl'l1w\1 h)' , , . , ' ,I.C, l,oho {i!. H\1I1H. 11I\J,; 1111 WOI'K whllll1 WIIH p\Jrl\ll'11wi\ by l1ulolHllIlIl WIIH o\1l11pl\JI\J\1 III II W\1rKI11I1I1,IIK\J 11111111101'\ 11\111 PIIIII1\IIT hr\lllol1\Jd \\w IIUIWIl1CI1\ holwuoll llw pll\'\luH 10 llw Ilx\Ol1l 'IIm\ lwl\\lIol\ 10 ulw \)l.1flll1l.\III1\ \\11 pppor\llI1l\y In II1Hp\JO\ lI\l1t l1\lrl\l\'I11I111Y 1I1\\II\I\1nlllll000HHllry work, 12, ^nPI' r\JIIHPl1l1hlu II1Y\JHllgllllnll, 111.11'011\\11111 IH wl\hnlll kllowl\Jllgll 01' Illlill'll1l1lloll Hllfl1ploll\ \n t\lI'l11 1\ hnll\Jf IIH to Ih\J \n\lh of\IWIIV\ll'l1wI1IH, lly WilY 01' I\II'llwr I\l1HWPI', P\Jfl.1\11hll1\ on\11plol1.111 hlH WOI'K 111 II WOI'Kll11111.lIko Il1I1Il1WI' In 1I0001'1\mwo wl\h \110 IIl!1'\J\J111\l111H h\JlWOOIl \lw " PIlI'IIUH, ," COUNT I . IIIUCACH 011 CON'I'HAC'I' 1,11ll'I\gmphH I \hrollgh 12 of pololll\lIlll'H ^"H\VOI' 111'0 1III.10l'porlllol\ ,Iwl'oln hy D, I'ufol'ol\oo IIH I I' 1\llIy H\J\ fOl'lh, 14, COllo\\lHlol1 of luw, no nnH\VOI' 1'0q\\ll'l.1l\, If IIn OI1HWPI' IH 1'0q\llrol\, Ihl.1 l1I'lglnll\ ngl'ool11l.1nl 1,11.11WllOn Iho pIIl'IIoH IlI.1l'oto Hp\JIIKH for I\Holl', 15, . Conohllllol1 of IIIW, no IInHWOI' l'uqllll'u11, If nn III1R\VOI' IH 1'0q\llrod, lho ol'lglnll\ IIgro\lI1ll.11\1 holwoonlhl.1pllrll\JH h\Jrolo HpOllkll Ihl' \tHolr. lei, (lI).(h) ConolllHlo1\H of III\V, 110 1InH\VOI' I'oqllll'oll\ If 1111 IIIIHwor IH 1'0qllll'uI\, Iho nvorl11\J1\tH III'\J Hpoolflonlly donlcl\, By WilY of flll'thol' IInHW01" polol1dlll1l flllflllod Iho IUI'IlIHl1flho , , o\'lgl1\lIllIgl'\Jo\llOl1t hl.1lwoon Ih\J \1I\1'\loH horoto nnd oOI11\1IUlod hlH work \tIll wOl'kl11l1n-lIku \I111nl101' " .- ,t 'IIH roqlllrod hy Iho ngl'CO\l1ol11. \)olonl\lIl1l f\\l'\lwl' III1HwurH IIH folloWHI . :l . /)m"IIIWIII": 1412711 U\Jl\"j'I1P!'lt l fI,~ Pnviq r" I.)!'lynn.tp PQ@\:l'~IC, \:ipl1 ~~03 Pp!l.n9 ~p~ingp nPAd 1l0iUmr Ilpl'in9p t PI\ :!. 7PP7 U7 !!6Il"'~1l0P " I, I\Pl'!:I. !l:\., ~.!l!)'l MI\P~ And "im IlI.U,'9onpmi 1:11 4Hl /3:!.Qpal'villp ~pM , ' t/pwiUl'l, /.11\ :!.'1~4~ 77~"'Q3~fl porpaptipn tQ ~OHaO '~'p Pl\!:!.q on the eXI'lip1:!n9 cpnOl'PUO pM lit tho l'e<11' of thp home II a6K46 IIqqit!on pQnect.q to the homo, 'l'hl'l foUowi,n9 ip A Upt of Ammanitial'l, :I., aK6 Pt\.iq~i\1g , a, VAU:!.toq P1311i\19P [9AP:!.adJ ;1, Pl;'opuil t trUI'lpel'l rc~AI)lod J 4, Two cOloniAl l'ltep:!. qoorentreep 1l,',l'Wo If:\1'90 WindowI'! [to mAtch, the flha in IdtchonJ 0, l~oUr l'l1~Ylightp, '1 t Pl'Y Wf:\~.~ fini,l'!hed And fJA,intl'lq, 11" PAintoq I~ood t1'1m VAno 1 I'ltyle !) , OA1.'poting :\.0, o inch inpulntion throughout, U, /10111313 IWf.\P " 1~, t"'111 o~terior Pqintoq 13, 1113.0C1:l'!clI:l. II, TWp oUtletp pOl;' WAll , /3, Switch Oeiling ~An with light 0, Ropot breAJ~er PQK to new :!.ocntion ,. p, O:!.ean up old Wiring 14, SOffit, fAoia, gutter t~ m~tch othorp, :1.6; 'l'oar of anc1 replace I311il1g1ep of aKl3il3t;l.ng home, 16, a6 yr fipOl~c;11apl3 reinfol'OOc1 phinglop t.hroughout, 17, Rework ontrep from new addition to home, 10, Pl'opel' vent t\nc1 OOP1'n vent " , , " Tot~l COl3t of this projeot. $.10,7~~,OO Thank you fa);' aonaicledng bavid lit DeVanio OonptrUctlion, Influ~ance information is availablo fol;' fAKing, QUote pdce is gUArantoed fOl' 30 clays from the nbove c.\ate. Sincerely I , " PAvic.\ L, beVanie 1 ' " ji " Pnqe'l ," " " i, I , ", j' " " " " " . " ,] " " " q " " " "t' ',. I' I, " 1', 'II 'J " (, If; "''-' " ," i' ," , ,)' " :\ I; " 'I, ;1 " 'I' I', " " eXHIBIT B j! . " , ': . , , rnlITmJ.cATllliEJil'JH VI C ~I~ I, Clmk P\lVllI'\l, liHlllIll'\l, Ill' tlwlllw linn nf M\lI~'IWI', WI\lk\JI'Hhlll11, 1\llI1I1HH ,"I:. lil'h, I',C" IWl'oh)' P\Jl'IlI~ Ihllll H\JI'Y\J\\ II II'IIVIII1I\ Vnl'l'\Jul \lOpy 01' IMVl1dllI\IH' ^"HIWI' wllh Nuw MII\I\JI' wllh , ' ' ' 1'\Jlvl'\Jllollllllho lilI'V!lI1II1IlI\utlnl\ hy IiI'H\ VhlHH 1111\11, pOH1II!l1l pl'upIIII\, 11M 17111 dl\)' Ill' ~llpl\ll11hlll', 19911 pn tlw lilllnwhl!ll Mfll'l\ Uh'!lUIIH!1\llh pin \lolliI' J, 1~\lHHI1, IIHljnll'\J 61 WOHII;lllltlWI' SlnJUt CIII'IIHI\l,P^ 171113 (717) ~4U.1177 MH'I'ZOHR, WICKIIHHlI^M, K.NMJflS & mm, \I,C, --:::":-?=.~ cllII~v::.iiHq\iII'U ..,I ", II, "" " , " " " " " " " " " .J " " '" " , " I, ' " " " '>I 1)0"",,,,,(11: 1412.70 l.~ " ". . f'i'I!i-2r1-~n ''''' is 'I PI'I 111;' 111,1;" I III> Aflfl\1P' f'iTl;fl 2'1 \ 2t17l'l I', n;l ,l"""'=..' , ..1'-1" ,."'- "'--,'-'''==1;;;- . ~ , .....ll!"fo~,P..~~~ ~ I, ,...,... .".," ....11P9.~ Nn:_'=J""'~', "~.,,.'m""C~',~ Jr~f k,f~~r~"" 'H,~~f' 'II QU4,11 tl'mvf~il' r , '1~\1/l'(',~hll.,. "'11,1'11 "I\'"~llItI"U rif"'"'''' ". "'.'~ .c:: " ~' ,..., , :rHiiiii" ~~;;::"~" "p~i~.Z"'~' ':.--..'.'.....".' 1"'1 /..;~ ~ ';;;2..r~ ,Iil';&rl , , ,-J,7,1"$rL ~__, , " '"lri~.f(,I.l ~ ~~~ s:: '. .....l~,~ '.~Iriliii:liiii" (.: ~~.. ., .... ~ '~" "." ',ll.~...".~~.,,",5"~~....\ ',:/;?~ ....'?'-"1, ~l~~!f!;.f(~~"(;~J~.. ..._~." ~:~,',~.r .,-~",..~-'"'"".:""'."d~'~:~I~ ,:,'_._....J7"~c1~'r_J~:,m." ,i~:',::::,~.~_ , Wnll111ltllV "llll!lll1~11 1t\-'lllllllllllflljVllhlutlll,I"I/' "" ' ~ ~f)~rl-~9'~~ ~ Iii {#~~~~~~'11( ;/~~n~~~ tf&~ t:lrp~ ("'6 ,~@ ~(::J ~" ~? :r/()~~~., ' J " " I' , ,-1 , ~\ej ~D~) " ~rI- c'l' ? I " I " " II'" ''''..'',.,';1., "".,"'\~a.'"!;'ta'I" "~'.'''-'', ,'I t;:::1,l=1", 't."..,::::.:.,.\", t.. li,1.l.:1: I:,: ,..0-1-",'" "t1t't'r I;", ",..,1\' "~"""'''''''",.IOo'l'./-l''n' -4~::r'r.,I';.',... ~IJtn~nDt,..,hn~bY Illlltlnlo/\ 01010/101 Md lobar, Dam/lint, ,In noo~';o' WillI nbovo Ipol)l(loullori~, for \/\1 :UI1l nIl '''~~~I-':.~~~:r:: .;;",!:r':~ ~ ullllnll". ...,Lc?"::k..{J.," ,., " '-'111\'0110 b. mla. ..follOW.: ", ' '._..._"....~.",. ,..'--......".--"" ,,'._,......, .' ,_.,,'. .,..,..-.....,." "...~....."" , ~_. '" ~~~:1~~~i~,R~\~::ii~~i~~i::i~:l~i~3~;~~;~~.~~~:,r:~';i.~i:;r.:~I~~'~~: "'~:,~;o.-I";~l.' .... ..'" .. ,..,-'~-~' '. jl1~f,lh'lnu '."H 0011' "'~ b, .r~v1,d Nlry upo" WI~lIn pm".. Ilrld WIll b'OOIllI 1\11 ,d,. R ." " _'.' "..., I" .. ,. ... .'.. '.'M_ ',I~1I jt hVlll AM "Mvel lh. "UIn.to, Allnt'''.''1.nlt c0l'111ngvtll UIKIIl M,lk.., ttclrltfltt Tll lap ~\1l1"1I~ b ~ ~;;;~~~~:~~::::,:::::.::::.~'~ """~~~,~...._~-_.... ~1"'IIO/Ofe",,", "" '^I"I'k~'1 "'" "" h".~1 belepllu, Yo" or. '"lh'"I~U 8IUl1l1l1reVZ_ In UII Inl \YI"1 .! 1..llllleu. r'ymWII w,1I bll 1116118 ~I '"111'\'~ ahoye" ' .~.. OII\.'ltltC.II\"IVIi_...__.._,,,,,"~...,.____ .,..___ 8'Ql1lhlll.,.__. " ' "'1,,": .'ll_lt~..., .,:,..~'IIf'u.~:.r...l.\l_,~=n.tii"'._'::::::.--..\.t.=="j., ~1_"'.t' , . , ClJRl'H'lC'1\TlLOfSlJl\ VI C'lJ I, ,IIIO\IIIPIlIl\l ^, P\J\*\JI\ 1II1II1I(11PI'I~\Jli 1I(l1l111 of MIII'1Holl 1)\JlIl'llol'ff WIIIIIIIllS & Olio, !111I'(ihy pOI'III)' lImlll \l\lPY of Ow 1\ll'o!Joll1!J Pl'llpolp\J II'IIS HIlI'V\JlllhlH lhl\ll hy dOpORIIII111 RlIlllO In Ow POHI 01'l1\l0 lit ClIl'lIslu, P^, OI'HlulllSR 1111111, IWRIlIll\J PI'IlPlllli, mllil'\JHH\J\IIIH Iblloll'RI polol' ,I, glIRRo, IlHlIIIIl'o (il WOHlIA1\llIwl'1:1liwl CIII'IIHI\J, PA 17013 Ii ;, " L, ., CIIII'I) PIlV\Jl'u, I\slIlIll'o MI1TZonH, WICI<WUlIlAM, I\N^lJSS & BIW 3211 NOl'lh Fl'ol1l 811'001 P,O, 13m; ~300 I I IIl'd Hh\l I'll, PA'I"/ll0.0300 , , ,j, " ,. " MMTSON PBAIWOHFF WlI.LI^MS & OTTO /;', By (''!<<'.-I.cduJ,J (] Q(fi'ev o'lll,~fln\J A, I)ookol' 'Oil l1ilSIIIlgh Stl'\J\l1 ClIl'lIfil\J,I'Al7013 ' (717) 243':1341 'I, 1)1\10\11 Ootohol' 2, I UUB " " ". i' 11 " .. , ,,' I, MARK ~IR(3r:N~MITH, PI~lntlff ' IN THJ: QOURT of QOMMON p\..r:Ml OLlM~r:R\..ANP QOUNTY, Pj:!NN~Y\..VANIA CIVI\.. AOTION.\..AW Nil, 91l.~Q"7 CIVI\.. VI I , I I I I , I I I JURY TRIA\.. P~MANPr:P DAVID \.., Pj:!VANlf. ~Ipl~ DAVID \.., Dr:VANIJ: QON~TRUQ'fION, PofomlAnt fbAlI'lTIFF'B ANSWER rO PEE\;NPANT PEVA~gw.I'v'lATTr:R 19, P!3nleQ, Nil anllwer Is requlrecL To 11113 exlent al1l:1I1SWer 16 rf.lqulr13Q, 11113 l:1vermenls Inparagraplw 1lhroll~h1 B of QefenQanl's al1\lwer Clre speolfloallY QenleQ, 'I ' " ' WI1",1 apoul Il1l'llr E\Ql11lsslons7 20, DenleQ, Canol us Ion of law, no answer requlrl'ld, To tile extent an answer Is require, PIE\lnllff hall lIet forth sufflolenl Md adequale I1venllsnts for a I3reaoll of Contraol oallse of aotlon wl1loh relief oan pe granleQ, 21" DenleQ, Upon flrs\nollolng leal~age 10 Il1e roof, Plalntlffoalled Defendant to Info'rl11 111m of the leakage problem, On severElI 0001:1s10118, Plaintiff InformaQ Ihe , " PefellQant and DefenQ",nt's supoonlraotor, J, 0, Lebo & 80l:\s, Ino" that tile Qefeotlve , roof neeQed to be repalreQ, " ,,, , I,', , -,,',\ " 22. panll3p RI1 atl\tl3Q, Tlw flrat pflrt pf Pl3fencll\nt's RVsflnl3n\ III E\ opnol\.llllpn of Il\w whlph no flnawer la raq\Ilrl3cl, TIls al30pncl Pflrl pf Pl3fencll\n\'s IWl3flTlsn\ \hll\ Plllln\lff lIoree~llo tE1I~13 rl'lllpO'llllplllty fpr oer\"ln wprll Incluplng rsph'1oemen\ of ven\a,la speolflolllly Ql3nlecl, pefencllln\ pon\motecl Wllll Pllllntlff \0 reahllps PlAintiff's e~la\lno roof \p 11111\011 \1113 roof \0 the room aclclltlon, 'Tl1I3Pafencllln\ cpn\r!lotscl wltl1 Ihs PI!lln\lff 10 P\l\ new shlnglellPn the I3xlllllng roof, The WPrl\ rala\scl to the rpof Inol\lclacl thft replE1penwnt of existing roof venta with new venta to Elvolcl posslple W!ltl3r leaks, 23, psnlecl, The PIElln\lff con\r!lo\ecl only with the Pl3fsnclant \0 perform work on tile Ollhnn13Y !lncl ohlmney extenalon. The Plalnllff rjld provlcle clefencl!ln\ with !I phone mlll1per to FlrepIEloes.l..Elnclso!lpe II. The pl3fendant aomplalnecl th!l\ 1113 dlcl not have, " , " the necessary mElterl!'\la to perform worll on the ohlmney !lncl ohlmnay extepalan. The Plaln\lff, hEld no aon\raot with Flreplaoea.I..~1I1dso!lpe II ElS \0 what materlElla were \0 pe , , , prOVided to the PefendEln\ to sa\lsfElotarlly oomplete thlsparllon of the roof, The plal~tIff had no Idsa ElS to what materl!'\ls were obtained by the Defl3ndElnt to oamplete \I11fl portion of the roof warll, In !lddltlan, Plaintiff had no Idea all to the qUElllty of the , , materl!lla provided to the Defend!lnt, " 2A, Penled, The averment Is an opinion Elnd/ar oonaluslon tit IElw far whlah no answer Is reqLllred, Under the aontraot, Defendl:\l1t,WElS permitted to ellgEloe , , subaontrf.lotars to parfarm work Lll1der thl3 aOl1traot. The DefendElnt remained " " responsible for said work ElB It rela,tedto the proper aomplellan of the oontraot, Therefore, any alalms, damaOeB, expenses, Ellld/ar losea caused by J. 0, lebo & SanB, " 1119, flncl/pr PY pIller ImHvl~Ll{:1I!l, flrmll, l'lmJ!pr pprpOrEltlpna a~IPopntrflPll3ct py the Pefl3ncll'lnl to 00l11pl13113 11113 oonlrflolls the responEllplllty pf 1118 pefemlflnl, " ~6, penleel. The Elyerll1ent la fin pplnlpn finellaI' ppnolualon of IflW for whloh np , flnswer lEi requlrl3ct, Tp Ihl3 exlenl fin flnEiwer Is requlrecl, Plfllntlff apeolfloElIIY ctenles Ihfll fllI,oonclltlona of the f\greelilenta pelween P\'!fenclllnt Elnq PIEllntlff hl'lye peen fulfllll3Q, (See pUrflampl116 of Plfllntlff's OOl11plfllnt), 26, Penleq, The flyermel)\ la fin opinion flncl/qr oonoluslon pf Iflw for whlol1no fll1llWer Is reqLllreq, T~ the e/<tent fin IInllwer Is rl3qulreq, Plfllntlff Ilpeolflol'lllY clenles thflt tile Defenclfll1t 11I'IS supstfH1ilflllyool11pletecl Elncl/ol' flIIly perforl11edLlncter Ihe oontrflot " petween tll\'! pflrtles, (See parl'lgrl'lplls 14 tllrLl 16 of Pll'Ilntlff's Oompll'llnt), n "Penleel, Thl3 l'Iyerment Is fin opinion find/or ?0I10ILlSlon of Iflw for whloh no " "I , , " fll1swerls reqlllred, To the extent fin a'nGwer Is required, Plaintiff spealfloally clenlea tllat tile Defendant performed Ills dLltlfls Linder tile oontrflot In a slllllM oarefLlI, dlllgent,anel worllmen-Illle l11f1nnel', The Defendflnt has preflohect his oonlrflolllfll dLltlflS ElS sel forlh' I !' In PElragrElplls 14 thrLl 16 of PIEllnllff's OomplEllnt. PIEllntlff aclmlls thfllhe pElldthe ,I' ' Defendflnt pllrsLlflnt to the oontrElolul'Il terms, " 20, Derilect, The flverm.ent Is l'In opinion find/or oonoluslon of IElw for whloh no answer Is reqLllred, To the extent ,fin Elnswer is reqLllred, ~Ifllhllff specilflcf.1I1Y denies thElt ,. " ho failed to pLlrsue, oomply, ~blde, or notifY Defendant of any warranties In the oontract 'j'l Il(llwl3l3nll1l3 pmtlell, Upon flratnotlllln9 the lallkllOl3, thl3 Pllllnllff Informaet thl3 pafcinctl'll1t of prop lama wi 111 11113 ropf flnet res~lltlng etllmfl9l3 from the lellllflge, ~O\ Panlact, The flVermenta Ilre oonol~,alona pf IflW IInet/or oplnlona fpr whloh no I1nswar III req~llraet, Thepefanetflllt Pfl31'10118et 11113 llontrl'lot With tha Pli\lnllff, The Pll:1lnllff neVflr provldeet tha Pefendflnt with ~lIreollona I:1net/or speqlfloflUons oonoernln9 ponstnlollon,lothfl rpom IlctcHtlon Emd/or reli\teet work to tha roof,AIl €I oontr~ot~If.\1 pf.\rty I1ml oontrflotor for the f.\~1Pve worll, the Pefenetllnt pel'\rs respqnslplllly for dflfflotll ol1~16!3d Py hla own €lotions or by those of €Iny supoontrElotor hlreq by the Pef13ndant to perrornl worll under the oontraot, I', 30, P13nleel, The averment 16 a oonoluslon of Il.'Iw l'\nd/or opinion whlol1no l'\nswar III r!3qulred, The Pefenelant Ie responalble for any elamflge path physloally flnd I1llstllellol'lllY to the Pil'llntlff'1l reslelenoe oauseel Py the Pef13netant'e work on the' Pll:1lntlff's roof, In addltlon, the Defenetant la rflsponelble for any clefeotlve worlr performed by I:1ny suboontraotor whloh the Dflfendant hlre,d to perform WOOl Under the ' oontrl'\ot. " 31, Penled, rhe averment Is an opinion anelloI' oonoluslon or law for whloh no ElI111wer Ie reqlllred, Upon dlsooverln9 .the leElkE1ge \0 the roof, the PIEllnUff pronlplly E1nd IlpproprlElt13ly notified 11113 D13felidElnt of defeots to the roof resulting from Defendant'a WOlk, " Plfllnllff parfprmeq hla opnlmol\.Jfllopll@IlPIl IlY pflYlna Ihe Pefl=lI1clflnl p~tnHmnt tp the oOlllrflot, Pefenclflnl fl:llleel 10 1I1f1lfl apeolflotllly oerll:llll work 1!1f11 Pefenf.lflnl Wall not " tlllpwecl to oomplele ~tppnnptlflotltlon of the leullt'lge .to Plt:llntlff'a realclenoe, Ref!311cltlnt lIenl p\.llhla s~IPopntrflotor, ~, 0, ~elJp & 60na, Ino" to 111f1I~e flllY rept'llrs 10 the Pltllnllff'a rpof, AIM time cHcl Pefenelflnt oome tp Plalllllff's realclanoe to rept'lll' flllq to oprreol fillY elafeols from PafencleHlt's worl\. , , . 37, Penlaq, pefelldtlnt'lI flvarn18ntls t'ln opinion for whloh no anawar la req~tlrad" DefandflnllJreaoheclhla wfllnmly fp/"worl~ performed unclerlhe oonlmol as sel forth In ,; " pt'lrl:l 9!'a ph 15 of Plalntlff'a Oompll:1lnl, Pefendflnl ftlllll 10 speolflol:1l1y stl:lte Ihe Wflrrl:1ntles Preuo!1eq py the Pltllntlff, Fmther, Pefenql:1nt fl:lllsto speolflol:1l1y attlta Pltllntlff'a tlotlona ' , and/or omlaalona tt1al oflUlleq tl 13raflqll of Wflrrl:1nly, " WHgREFORE, Plfllntlff, Mflrk 13lrganamlth, reapeolfully requesta JUdgment I1galllst tl1epefencll:1nt, Pl:lvlcl L, PeVflnle d/lJ/fl Pl:1vlcl ~, Pevanle Construotlon, In an \; ~l11oLlnt wl1lol1 does not exoeed the Jurladlotlonal amount, pl~ls Interest, oosts of sull, Elltorney'a feea, and I:1ny l'el:1sonl:llJle I:lmoLlnt deemed appropriate by 11113 Court for future poats, Respeotfully SulJlT1/1tedl DRle: _llif s I q t ~ DRta: I 0 / S / q . (;" ---- " " il' " "" " " " " " " ;" ,,,j' !I'I" ii' 'I' , , d' " 'i. " " , , 'I ,I' " ,,, " " ''i_ " " Ii' "i' " 'I' " ,j' , I' ,. II " " .' " " " " " Ij I', 'I " Hi! " ,;, " " " n (,', ~,\)\'\ \. , ,( U.l. .' 1.1 I \ ,'" ,'-:,"1 " ,I .1"" ! ......J r) .., " " " p " ", ,n C'") \/J 1\ ," I' 1') P" 1(1J \ "~I ! " \ ~ Ui h , "I ~ \' <I ..\~ 'I'> \.0 'l.~ r\ , " ' :.t! ~.l' ',i,l IP t(~ ,. ,; " " " Ii 'i " " 'I' I, , d II' hll I ' 'I II \ lid I !.I,\;III ,'Iii I, iIf, I" 11111 1'1' 11\..,,1 11\/1'/ I' I IlI'\l'l"II\H'fd""'~1 1 II' 'I rllil::Y 1 \' '"111\ : CIIII! TY 11" (:111'1111:1/ ,{lIII. i\IH\WWH)I'l',II, 111\111: , V\"I !'i';Y.IIJULI,{lVLI'\." \',J (\1, !'I1iJ!^,\':L..I\M\li.ll:li' :,:11',,'1 II '" ,1'''1:111.\' ,;I"'II.!'I "I Ctll'lllI':I\I,AllO ClIlIn1i', 1'L'(I/1rll'lv/\I\ltI, \lhll hU'I,ll\1 '11~1'\Y lJ\lnlll rll"-I'up'rll.l'l\! I" lilli, ""Y", 1.1.., >I.l.lllln 1'I1'1'1:.,!I,\';l\J.iI."\lq'i1'I.!lr'\ITJ'IlH' Will' ';1'1'11'11 \, lit', UPUII OI\1'II1\.'I',lni!l!\I,I1 l':. u l. Ul,' I.,nk';'L dF'luhdilflt, dl. !.lUJ !Jj \ ',,";11\ 'll ,,\ I~J 'r ,(i\til.!l,\I'):, , !!I':\'ly.!.\,I,!';, .I'A)'I;:IU. IIIlIII\':, 111\ III" W.lfll'",Ii.II{lI\, , ~ " ! I ; I'! di\Y " ,.I:U1:!\I!<!<I,!\!IJ'.," - ..I C;".'ll\ly, P"I'I,,"ylv'nl.id, by 11",,011""1 ,.. !iLllI^.\.J' L:"..!\li.l'lf;q..T....",..", ,\ 1.1'\11.' ,,,,,I ,dl,'''I!.'''' ''''PY ',II 1.11',' 1!"'\'.\I,:;I';../\III....,I:I,101'1.I\I,II'L1"I,I\\... ",I '\;'''1''11",,\ w.! '11 !::.II!ITI!!~H.,t\I.\J'I,:.. J11,:!':,!",.,... '.......... ':'l'nd nl. Ih"" nUIIII'.' 1-.1.1111;' d\!'I'.'cl','iIIU IL!J~'dt l:i,'ol iun 1',1,,(111." ,~__",. '.,__._..___<,. ..,,"u...._.... ,.. , " 1~(Jll LI.'.lrl I.n,L'tIL1l pur, I " I' Hh[lr:\ {:["'I' Cuutu I " nrll)\t,i:'l.i 1111 ~::cq'i} i liP AJJ.I ,IlIV 1,1. f':;urclltl rOle' :';(1<'11'10\>1/11 I,' I 1'~rl'~I'I' ~r'rtnu \,"Tl'l'\~III\W \ ,111I:I,f':h'F:7:I,,: , 'ItAln."IIII, 1 01';111 ,(ll(,'\-, , \">>1.1,11'0\,/:: /7, /"j , 1.1/111:,:11':",1(' ;d.,:1{:~./ ~~'.:-:(l~V/., // I) '/ '. _,// ~;' .'" .,.'-' / .' ~..~..... ,; , ' ""'''L~;'#J''_~F ~ ....,..'. _.~'~"_<'M"_'" 'r..r~1r\':'r,\'d'T': ,11'1 n.' .n.....'...,....,,, In. 1/11/1 ['. 1) ~~ ;\M/1 C. f"(~Il/1 ~:;~.l(6. --tr;': 1,';,\Il'1I'(I ;,llld :'J\lhl-;f,~r iht,d 1,\) buJ 1.11-1,' '1\II_J ..' 'I t. h t ~; ,1~.!lAl di,l:J rt;! 11..t't)f!,~......4~~,.. " 1 'I...II.S?, ^, I', ().'l~ t?, J11kU'-'-'l ""11,.1'....:7.-;; '}1'jl,L If"'lfl"i,lll"'-/ "i I' I'PIIH\11\1I11Iu hl\'OHllllllllol1, lIy 11'11)' Ill' 1\ll'lh~I' l'\JplY, ^dlIlIIIlIWI, llul~l1dllnl ,I.C, !.\Jllll I'll: ~OIlH, Ino, 11'011111 1'Ill1l111l11111hlu liS IIII~uod In Ilplundlllll'H i\\hlllloIlIlIP\Jlul1dlll1\ ('11 111 pi 111111" 16, pUl1llld, 'l'h\J IIVPI'I1WnlH IlI'U 11~llllld IIlWIiI\' IIH IIlIly cllll\l'lllllu\ Plllol1lllllll'H ^,lllhlnl1111 Ppl~II11llnl ('Ol11plllll1l,,IIy \\'IIy or I\lrllwr r~pl>', Dpl~ndlll1t hllH HPrY\lIIIlI~PIlnIlHI fhr Hnll'Y IJppn Propmy Phwlplllll 1'11I1nlll'l'll1 ordol' 10 hlHPPClllwlII'\JIIH 01' tllll 1I11~1l~11 prllhlpl11H III Iho rCHIIllllWP IIml 1111111 Ihllt hlHfl\Jullol1 IH uOl11plp\\Jll, lh\J (]lllulldnl1t IH wlthollt kl111WI\lIIIl\l,Ill' lnlbnnntlon Hllrnolllnl \olhl'ln n 1l\Jllol' nH III IllIl tnllhlll' Ilw nVUrl11lllltH, t 7, (!lll1uIIlSloll of IlIIY, 1111 r\Jply r\JII\III'\JII, If II roply IH rOll\llru(l, Ilw nVPl'I1lOnla nru Hpooll1ulllly 1l0111pll. on lhp pOI1I1'IIry, Iho ^(Il\lIlol1nl Dololldnl1l ('1l111plnlnt HlllloH II \J11I1111 IIplll1 whlph rollul' onl1 bo Ilnll1lo\llIllllhlHt (\(Il\lllol1nl l)\JloI1lII1111.l,e, 1.\Jbo f'!(. liOI\H, 1110, 1 H, ^dl11ltiod III pllrl, (1\Jl1lod 111 pllrl. ^lll11l!tod tbllt Dol'\Jl1dlll1\ hl18 mlsod N\Jw Milito., In 1110 cOl1lplnh1l I110d hy Plnlnllfl' Mnrk Bh'IlPIlHI11I1I1 wl1l\JI1,111 pml. 1110111(108 pnrnllrnphH ,21.n .. J)ofolldnnt 1I1811nl\l11ltH 'Ihnlllw N\JW MIIlIor Is pI'Op\JI' IIlld IIppropl'illto 118 1\ nppll08 10 Plnll1tlft1s " olnll11a, 'i'llIlnY\l1'l11011IH Hl'P donlod nH UUnol1l810llH of Inw Ihr whloh 110 r\Jply Is roqlllrod 118 lhoy " '1111lY IlPply to Dol'p,l1dlll1t. By WilY of f\1l'thol' ruply, tho ))olol1dIlI1II110prplll'lIl\JH by rOfOr0I10\lIlH If l\llly's,ot forth hlH A(\(lItlollnl Dolol1dllnt COI1\pllllnl "l1d dOlllos Ill1y Now MlIltol' 10 tho 01\lol1t It IH dlrootod 10 DofOlldnl1l'H 0lnhn8 IIgnll1at tho Addltlulllll D\J1'\Jl1dlll1t, WlmIWFol~11,Dorplldlll1t ))Ilvld I" DoVlII11u d/b/ll DIIVll\ L. DOVIII1111 C'onHlrnollol1 , dUI11111ldH Ihllt ^dllltlol1lll Dolol1dnnt .Le. Lobo & HUI18,11l0,'HNow Mnltol' ho dlH\11lH8od nl1d thllt Ii ,2 - /)"<"""'''/ N,' /4.l.IP8,' I. MARI<'f3+RQIi1Nf3MJ'l'lI / 1 :r.N '1'1I1i1 OOt)~,\, 011' CPMt40N Pi.li1l\f3 011' rJ11'\:\.ntHf. , CUM~li1Rl..,l\NP OOUNTY/ PIi1NNllnNlINI~ , v, I I NO, 9IJ-3138'1 , OIV:r.r. 'l'li1RM PJ>,VIP HI PJl1Vl\IHIil cI!p/a I Pl\VIP l.., PIi1Vl\NIlil I OONf3fJ.'HUOfJ.1ION, I Oefenc\ant 1 , V, 1 " " I .:J,O, r..li1f30 & SONf3, INO, / I /IcIc\:\.t:\.onal Pef.enc\an t I I V, 1 1 RONAlIO m, ARMor.'\' , Further lIdc\i1:ional Pefenc\emt , tT\JIW TRIM. PIi1MANPIilP FURTIlIi1R APPI'\'IONAL OIi1Ii'Ii1NPANT'f3 l\Nf3~R TO l\PPITIONAL PIi1FIi1NOANT'f3 OOMPLAINT 1\NIJ NOW, pOllles t:ho Further l\ddlponal J)of:enclanl;/ Hona,le\ I~, l\rmolt:, by and through his attorney, Richard C, Gaffney, illsquiro, ,who maKos t:h:l B l\NSWIDn. '1'0 l\1~DI'l'lONl\I., DIWillNDl\N'I" S COMI'I.,)\IN'I', with ,', ., pl1rngraphs numbered 80 llB to correspond wi.t:\l 1;\10 Il\lInbered parl1graplH3 .i.n l\dd1t:10nal Defencli1nl:' 13 COI~pla.int' I 'I " 1 , l\dmit:tocl on 1nfonnat:ion and beU.ef, 2, J\ehnHt:o(I' On 1nformat::l.on and boUef, 3, 1\chl1it tod on informat::lon ilnd belief. ~, J\dmit:t:ecl. 5, W.i.thout admitUng to t:ho conl:onts of t:ho l\nswor" w.i.th New Matt:er, It: :l.B nclm:lt:tocl that: l'lainl:.\.l'l' !::I.locl 11 c1v1l OOlnpll11nt: llgi1inst: Dof:('Jndnnl: nllogedly n,!:.i.Bing out of worK potformed by Defondant on PlninUff' B residenco locill:(~cl al: ~1.6 Blol3orv,l.1lo Hoad, Nowv.Ule/ CUllIbeJ:.l.Bnd Count:y, 1'1\ 1'72~1. " 'I' f>, W:lt:llPul: iHlm:lt:(:,l\1<.J I:o,\:ho Conl:onl:H 01' I:ho C:oIiIPlnJII\:, It::ln ndmIttod Jhat tho llol'llllrlfqll: driil'I:1H1 .'11\ AI\li\10I' wi t:h Now Mnl:l:or 1:0 I:hll (Jomplrd nl: nnd I'01:Will:dod :I t: 1:0 t:ho C\lIl\l>or.l illld <Jollnt:y P1:ot:hono\:nry for l'i11ng, '7, Ilonjod, Al't:I]r rlliIlIOnf1hlolnvosl::lU<lI::lon rind inquiry I!'ur(;hlll; ,,' l\dcUt:l.nnal J)ol'ol\dll\lt liHJkll Jnl'onl\ill:Inn' 1i\\I'('Il1:1onl: '\:0 f:orm n bolIol: illl (:0 I:ho I:rllt:hol' wlwt:h\l'i' l\dd.l.t:,i.ol\i\l 1)0 foncliln I: lJnl:01:ed int:o f~, BubcontulOtor f1g1:00\1111nl: wIth Dot'ondilllt I:or I:ho P01:f:ol:Jl\anmJ of: cOl:ta.inwork nt: Plidhl:.I.fr'/l rll/d.donco, l\coord1ngly, t:hIs" al.l.ogatiol1 ls dllnIod, 0, "l\dm.l.t:t:od In parI: and denIod In pt\rt, ";'u,t\:her Add.l.l::lonrl1 Defendant adndtl3 I:hal: hll ontel:ed 11]1:0 E\ BUhconl:rfrol:or ilurpolilenl: w1th Addi\:lonal Dof:ondant J,C, Lebo and Sons, Inc, Further Add.l.t:.Iollill De'fenclilnl: den.Ies that: I:ho oont:ract: Inclllded all of thc) "[wid work" allrJgod ,in ildd:ll:iontll Dofondanl:'s Complaint, ,,11'0 tho aontrary, I:he colll:ract betwoon Icurthor l\dd.it:.1.onal Defendtlnt <\nd Adcl.1.t:.1.onal DEl~endant J,C, Lobo and Sons, Inc" 'l3fJC)c.1.J!.Laally '.provided thl1 t: U'urthsr l\cld.lt.loHlll Defondan t wiHJ,'only refJJ:lonsiblo 1:0 oloan and 1nst1111 o.ight vent/J' and relOovc) and .Install o.i.ghl:oen squares or 8h1n~los, ' 9, Admitted.i.n Pllrt and den.i.ed .1.n Pllrt, a, It::l.8 admHtocl that; Pla.1.nI:1f:Us, Compla1nt 1l11egel3, 1n l?arl:, t:hat he l3usl:a.lnecl sovoro and /lllbstant:.1.al ll'led;.i.l]g 1:0, his res1dence as 11 rO/llllt of work to the roof I1nd thl1t the work WI1S not, performod'.ill 11 workll1anl.iko lI1anilel: 1n that it :1.13 allogqcl that: , , Dofonqi.1llt [i~.lled to replaco OX.iB\:lng roof: VCln1:13 w.i.th now vonts 1n order '1:0 avo.i.cl water loaks nne! f'a.Ll.ed to replaoe, 1n81:1111 tII1cl or apply new plywood rafter~, folt papor, and sh.ingles to tho eX1sUng 1:001', ' b, l\ft:er reatlOnablB .i.nvos t::lga t10n Ilnd .i.nq\.l.lry, U'llrthe); Add.It10nal Qefendant, Is w.Ithout .informatIon sllf1'.Ia1ent 1:0 form 11 bel.ief: fIs t:o the truth of', the 1111Bg11t.i.on that the Pl(1inUff 8ustidnod 10al:1ng to his ros.idenoo,nncl l1ocorclillgly the samo .Is', c1on.Iocl and fll:J;.i.ct proof t1wroof J.11 del\\anrj(Jd at tr..i.ul H ];elevunt:, a. By way of further rosponso, .It iB spocIf.i.oUlly den.I~d I:hat Icurthor Additional Dofendant did not porfotll\ the work .In a worklOanl1ke manner, T6 I:he contrary, U'llrl:her l\dd1t.i.onal "Defcmdant porformod all of the work .i.n a workmanl.i.komanner, d, By way of further rosponso, .II: is spoo1f1cally den.Ied that U'llrl:hor Add1tionnl Dofendnnl:'s Work Was not workmanlike .In "i. " ,I' ,J 1:llII!: Dof'ondiml: l'ilLI nc:! (:0 ):'nplillJo OX! f1t.lnq rool' Vfm\:ri \~11:h now ven I:u 1n ordl,q:' I:t) ilvo,ld wal:o r lnill::! ilnd f:illlod (:0 rOPllHio, 111(1(:1\11 imcl or ilpp.l.y now p.lywooc.l nd'l:nJ:li, '1'0 I:lll~ (Jont:rl\rv, Wln:l:hur flr.1d.l. Uorwl Do f'nl)diln I: was until)):' nn 011.1. Iq,1\',lt,lIl, eJOn I: J:iHJ 1:1\i.l 1 or ol:hllrwlllD, t:o J:'op,l/HJtl DX.1./'Jl:lnq reoed' vont:!.l wEh nc~W vonl:u ,)I:' t:o rupluco, In131:1\11 ilnd' or apply now plywood l:irf'(:orH, JPnrt:hot l\dq1l:.Ional PofGndant: wau h.ll:od on.l y t:o l:mI\OVG nnd .IllBl:n1..1 e.i.ght:eon I3qllilnl of' sli.lnejlclI3 anel clenn ,lIlcl .I1113t:1111 Dx.i.lit:.(ng roof venl:fJ, l"Ul:l:hol: )\clellUolHll Plll'endilnl: porl'ormmi Utili work .Ir\ a worf:milnl.ll:o marmor, 1]'0 thu oxt:Gnt:, If ilny, t:hat: I:ho Plfl.lnl:.i,ff IJUflt:i1lned lonf:.Ing t:o h.ls l:OIi.ldGnoo, illld 1:0 t:ho oxl:ont, if. any thAt: sil.ld luak.lng WilS thG tuslllt of' fn.llUro to rOPIneo roof venl:f1 'W1th now vont:s or t:o J:'oplnceor .Inptnll now plywopd ral'tGrs, 11'\1rl:hor i\dd.lt:Jonal dofondi1nt donl.es tospons.lbll.1.t:y I' 01: t:he saille nnd i\lle\1GB, tlw I: the 1'1idnt:.1.f 1', tl18 Dul'andant and the "dcU Uoni\l defendant: are sololy or jolntlyl.lablG for t:ho same, e, By ~ay of further reBponsG,lt .Iu 8pecif.lcally den.loU that tho" fi'urt:her 1\dd.i.Uonill Defonclant:' fJ work WiW not: wOI:I;mnnJ,:I.ke in tllilt Defendant f".Iled ~o apply felt: paper lind/or sh.lnglos t:o t:he eKlsUng roof, ']'0 l:he cont:rary, F'urt:her l\dd.lJ:iollal Dofendna(: appl.lod felt: papor and new 25yoar sh.lngles to e.lght:een square 01' eKist:.Ing roof In a profoBs.lDnal and wotkmanl.i.ke manner, To tho oK\:ent, ,if ilny, that: t:ho Pla.lnU ff sl1sl:a.lnod leak:l.ng to il.ls re81c\encG, [i'urthor l\dd.lUoni\l Defendnn\; d~lniel3 t:hn(: sald IOi'\k.i.pg' wa/3 the result 0/: faLl.ure t:o apply fGlt papor and/or sh.lngles t:o t:he eX1sting roof, 10, lIdmHted.ln par!: and clenlod In pflrt, It: 18 achn.ltt:Bd t:hat: " Pla.lnt.lff alleges that herequ.lros roplacement of property and pil.lnUng because of wal:Gr, damage, Wurthc1J: l\dd.lUonal DefGndant:, artGr reaBonable.lnveat:.Igat.lon and .Inqu.lry fa wit:hout: informatl.on /3uff.lc.lGnt t:o form a'bol.lol' as t:o t:he truth of these allegat.lons and accord.lngly tho same ate den.lod and st:r.lct: proof thornof 1a domanded ilt: trial .If relevant, 11. , l\dm1t ted In part: and denlod, 1n part, It: 18 achni t t:od tha t J, C, l,obo entered .Int:o , a subconl:ract:1n\1 agJ:eGment\1:1. th ~'urthGr lIddH.tona.1. Defendant, it: 1s doniod tha t tho agroenmnt: 1ncl uded all of thG"said workq alloged in l\dd.lt:.Ional DGfondant'g Coml)laint. '1'0 the contrary I t:ho subcontract:lng agtGement provides that Ifurt:hCill" l\ddlUonal DGfondallt: Was only r\)spons1ble t:o clGan and 1nst:i'\ll ciight vonts and remove and Install o.lghteen /3quarGB of /3hlnglos,' 12. Den:l.ed, J\dclHJona.] Dof:\mdnnl:' s il.ll~lgat1olls consl:.l.t:ute conclUs.lon~ of l~W and ho redponso .Is requ.lted. To, the BXt:ent \:I1<It: n J:C,HJlJOI\B1VO plonr\ll\rJ III J:'oqui /:(-)(1, I:i'lu F'llr\:hllrl\r1r1I\:toI\111 Dr~fel.ld.iln.t;, IIIJCw.ll',tnnllY dOllluli t:hi1t: II' I'lillnl:lf'fln IIl1uf/i11:1op!l re(I<\l:dIng t: 10 I1f'o!:ounld \'lor); rlr() provon 1:0 ho t:r\lo, t:holl F'\ll:l:her l\dd.it:.Iollf.d, Pefcmc:lnn I; lJJ:onchod h.lll HubrJOn I: ri,lnt: l\qrnulllclll t: W.l \:h !\cldU:Ionnl j)flfondilllt:, 'I'n I:ho nont:rirry, In 1:llCl ovcmt: l:hl1l: I?lnIn\:J.[i f:' S iI.i,lurJnl:Iollli roqilrrllnq t:ho i1 forClfw:l.d wor): i1rO pUlvnn \:0 bo I:rl\e, l\dd:ll::lollnl /lof'onc:lflnt:, nnd not: Ji'urt:llOl: l\ddi.t:,Jonnl DGJ:endnnt:", WIll blJ /lololy Il.n\110, By \~ny of furl:hor rOf!pOrlliC1, It III ll(1on:lJ::l,(Jil,1..1,y don.lod l:l111t: l"urt:lwJ:' I\c:IdIt::I.ol\rll j)o/'lmclnnl: 1)J:oilcheel h.i.s llu)x)ontrarJt:.ing i\rjroeIl\Ont: I'/l.l:h l\ckl,J t::loI1111 Pofondnnl: pOJ'.'1:onnorl fill 01' his contrnotllf1.1 ohllUill:Ions t:o l\c1d.lI: Iprhl.l Dofondilnl:, 13, Ponied. I\dd.lt:.Ional Do[ondnnl:'s allegn(:tons const.lt:uto concl\ll3.lons ot: lnw Hnd 110 rfJf.lronso ,tll foqu.lrml, '1'0 tho llxt:ent: t:hat n responstvo rloildl.l1(J 113 rGqu,I,l:Jld, Ji'urt:I10r.' l\ddi.t:.tol\nl Defendnnt spoc.lfl.cally dGnlea t:hat: lf thero .Is lIny Itnhll.lty on thG pi\rt; 01: l\ddH.loliil1 De f'ondal1 t I'or t:hEl 11 J:Ol:ll!iidd c:lflr1\i\gIHl, oxponsol3 and/or 101313013 clil.lll\8(J by PlidntJff, W11.i:ch 1I.n})J..l.i.t:y is denioct, that: Ii'urther l\clcl:I,\:.ionnl Defendant: ~B pJ:\,mar,j],y ,1.j,ilb.1.o or sdlely 11ilble a.lnce .It porl'ormod t:ho wor): wh.i.ch Pla.lnt:.Iff c.!.a.i.1I\1i Wl'\s performed ,in a non-wc.)J:l:man,1.j,kB mannel:, 'Po the Cont:J:ill:y, .i.J:, there is any l.ll'\b.l.llty on t:he part of l\ddl.t:lonal Defendant for theaforesa.ld damagos, Gxpensol3 and/or .I.osses c.1.al.mBd by Pla.i,nt:.1.ff:,.lIde{JU.onal DllJendant: is primar.il.y, .l:l.able and solely "l.Iable, By way of ]:url:hel: rosponso, i"urther I\ddH.lanal Dll1:endant perforll\ed all of h.ls contractual obl:l.gat10ns :In a profoss.lonal and workll\anl.il:e lI\annOJ:, ' j4, Den:Led:' Add,j,tAonal" Defondant:' s allegal:.ions cons\:Hutc;l cOl~9lusions of ,law and no tosponse :1.13. roqu.lrGd, ']'0 the eX(:ent that IIdd.lt.lonal Dofendant:'s allel)at.lol1s const.ltut:e aaaort.lons of ract: and a tespOnfJ.lv8 pload.lnl) .Is roquired. i"urthoJ: I\ddlt.i.onal Det:endant: spec.lf.lcal.l.y denIes t:hat .If' Add.lt:.Ionnl Defendant .Is found ,Uable to ,the Plaln(:jf'fi which Hab.t.U(:y IIdd.it:io11al Defendant: has expressly deniod, the lI'urther I\dd.i,t:J.onal Def:endan\: must bo found Jointly and sevorally Uab.1.o' wt.t:h him orl.1.able ovel: hIm by'vuW of indGmn.U:,i.cid:.Ion and/or contdbuUon, ']'0 the cont:rary, I\dd.lt.lonal Defondant: .ls pr.lmar.lly and solely l.lable to t:he Pla.i.n\:iff, Dy way of fur,thor n1fl!mnSe, I~urther addH:lonal dGfendant specifIcally donlos that ho has any obllga\:.1.ons, cont:ractuil.1. or 0\:het:w1se, \:0 ,inrlemn.l I'y lIddiUonal DefGndant: 1:1:om said lJ.abLU ty. ' '.... ' WllmHml"OHm I~utt:hor I\del.l t:iani1l Dofondant: demands that: I\dditIonal Defendant' fJ Complaint bo dlsnd,sf3ed and that: jUdgmont: be entorGd,ln h.ls favor t:ol)ot:hol: w.i.l:h hiA coatis tInd att:orney , " 'I' " ','I' , " " I'" " ,I , I' , 1" 'I; " ", \1' " " 'l' 'I' , !" . I, " '1 'I " . 0\',0 , '\ , . ~ .' I 'I It . t , f "I' ~ 6 ' Ii ~.~ ~ b . ~'.~ '~: ~' :,.'Q fJl ~ ~. ~ .~.~ ,i> .:d.,~ JJ.l !:;j '"\,~ ~i ~ ~ ~A ::1 ~ ~ :.r:,..j U. ~, . A .., ~ A I', '- C:l '.. ~, (('/ r:i~ '" ~Ill (~ ~; . olJ'lf 21[\ ' (.) 11-) ',,'" (;1 :lr ~. '1' il:: df:": r')rJ ,- ~.l U 1 ,.~ :;f;i.{j h:Il:, ,,' U. fl1 i.., 'fl!2 t,.l lijli~ l"r: q c" ,..,;" f\~ 8 !:l.~'; ~..~ ~J~ ~g:~~ ~~'~:d ~!~~ .. ~l' ~d II I, d, ' " , , !~ , ..I.r",.. " I' ','\ " 'ii , 'I ~ ~ ' A ~~ :?: <i!, c5~ ,g~ ei]U ~ , ; " 'I. .. A , " " " " " <II " '1 ': L d, , , "1' ....... ....- i, I' (" '1'1111 1~\llull\hll1l IIl1s Ilnrl\ucI nil I\IIS\IW willi NIIW MII\!ul' 10 1\10 ('ol11plllllll I1lIcI Ihl'Wllnlull Illp Ihu Pl'olhplIPllIl'Y 0l'Cllll11WI'I1I11l1 COIlIlIY (ill' I1l1l1lJ'{\ II'IIU 1111\1001'1'0\110\111>' \11'1110 SlIlcI ^IISWlll' willi Nuw Mllllol' Is 111111011011 1\01'0\0 liS I\xlllhll "1l"lImlllluoq1\ll'lilocl hOl'ol11 by 1'01'01'01100, 7, ^III.IIlIo1\1I1 l)ul~I1c111111 ol1lol'od 11\11'1 II Sl1bOOIlII'lIOlllgl'eOI11\l1l1 wilh l)ulbmllll1ll\11' \hQ pOI'I\1n11l111uo ol'uurlllll1work III PllIll1lltrs l'os1I101101l, wllillh Is Ihu sIll1Joulnl'lho ('ol11plllllll. ^ 11'110 1111\1 o\lITUoI UllP>'Ol'l\w pl'oposlIl 1I00\111101l1S whloh WOl'u 1I000Plell 111'11 1I111101W'11 hOl'ulolls Ilxhl\lll tIC;"~ 1111\1 I1worpi1l'lilucll\OI'011l by rolbl'u110ll, H, ^clllillolllll !lol'ullcllll1l,I.C, 1.01108:. SOilS, 1110, ol1lorodll1lOI1 811bool111'1\ul wllh l~o1\lIld 11, A 1'111\l II In pOI'I\11'111 SlIlIllI'ol'l;, ^ 11'110 IIlIcI onl'l'ool olW'ol'slIl\1 slIl1oollll'llOlls 1I\lllolwd 1\01'1'10 118 , , 111ihlhll "I)" 111111 Il\unl'pOl'llloll hOl'ol1\ by r'~lbl'ol\uo, 9, PII\II1\1 f!'s C0l11pll111111111ugos, 11\ pllrl, 11111\ ho 811s11111IoII SOVllro I1I1d811b8111111111110llklng 10 his 1'0~,ld\11100 liS 1\ 1'0sIIIl ol'wol'k lolho 1'001'1IIItllhlll Iho WOl'k 1I'1\8nnl pOl'lhl'llwclll1l1 wOl'klllllnlll;o 11111111101' In Ihlll ills nllogoll lI11I1 I)olbl1t1l1l1llilllotl 10 I'opllloo olilsll1\1.I 1'001' \,onls wllh now \'Ql1lsl1\ mclol' 10llvohl Wlllol' lonk8 1111\111111\ld 10 ropllloo, l1\sllllllll1t1/ol' IIpply 11011' plywood I'IIHol'8, roil pllpOI' 111111 shll1lJlos 101110 oxlslIl1g 1'001', 10, PIIIII1IIIT nlll(lllllolJos; 111 pilI'\, IIH\I ho l'oqllll'08 I'lIpllloolnolll ~11' Jll'opol'lynnd pllllltlng bOO1\\1811 01' 11'11101' dlll11l1go, II, Acldltlonnl Dolul1dlll1l ,I.e, I.olm sllhool1t1'll010d lis WOl'k to Fmlhol' ";ldlllol1l1l I)01u111111111 AI'Il)\l11 who pOl'lol'lnod slrlclWlll'k Oil PIIIII1III'f's I'oill'. 12, II' PllIll1llf'1's nllol.lllllolls 1'0gnnlll1g tho nlbroslllli work nl'o pl'ol'on to ho trllo, Iholl F\II'lhol' ^dclitlollnl Pbfundl\l1l hroll\ll1011 lis sul1ool1lr'lIol ngroonlOnl wlih Alilllilonllll)o(ondllnl, I~, If'lhoro Is Ilny IInhlllty onlho pml ol'Aclcllilonll1 Polundllnllhl' Iho IIlbloSllld 111l111!lgos, OXp0l1S0S lind/or lossos olllhnod by 1'11111]11 rr~ whloh IInhllllY Is oliI1rcssIY';lonlod, F\lrlhol' Alldlilol1l1l Dofumhllllls prlfnl\rlly IIl1hlonnd/or sololy IIl1hlo slnco Ii porlhrl11od Iho work whloh PllIlnllfl'olnhnR WIIS porlbl'l11od In n non-workl11l1l1llko 111Il11nor, 14," ' II'^ddlllolll\l Dolbndlllllls (buiid IIl1hlo 10 th~ PlnlntlJl'or to nl1Y olhor pllrlY In this , .. ., OIlSO, whloh IIl\hllllY 18 oxprossly donlod, F\II'lhor Addllhmlll Dol'ondllll1 111\lsl ho (bnnll jointly 1Il11i . sOl'ol'lIl1y IInhlo wlih 111m 01' Ilnhlo 0\'01' 10 him hy wny ol'lndol11nll1ollllon nnd/ol' oOllll'lhlllloii, , ,.' ~ " " " "j. ~ , f , ,~ , " " ,/ /, /, /, ,/ d i' " " -/.!~ ," , ,.j ~I, " " ," ,;, liKhlblt A "'.. , ',.','l [1l,1 ,:..., :'"]" ' ,'....",mon" .",...,..." ,,' ,. '~~--"-:-) ,-, ",';'~-: ....., __. r , ' Prro!R,.I, Rl,lfj~Q, ~~c:lU. tRP. AA a~Pfllma oP~~~ 7213!lr Pff~rra~~~r~f~ I ,',' ~~~~V&~\~~~1~7 8Mr8iilp~~'11rbfrel ,.. , T17"~4ltl1~rr ' , ," f ~.. y , " ., -"~f, . Allpmay8 (pr Alaln<<rr " .. r __ ,r , MARK ~IR~P.NSM'TH, . . fllI'l"tlfl' '" ~ , I I I , I I I I IN 'rHa COURT OF CqMMoN PI.B.Aa Ol.JMl!l!;Al.:AND COONTY, PI!lNNS'fl..VANIA cllVIr.. ACT\ON-I.AW , '" , I, V, PAVIa I.. DEWANII=i MJ/. DAVIa 1.,I:IIWANI!:l CONS'mllOll0N" , ,I P.f.nq"nt . , . " No, SQ. ' , CIVIl. , . I I JURYTRlAI., aElMANoap , , ""~ . i I NOw OOM~8 the Plaint/if, py fm~ throllgH hIs ~lltomey, Peler .I, Russo, I . . . ' ,; I I aSqtll/'G IInc1lll~tes Ih~ t'r.i/lOWfng In'll\.lppim of hi", 09mF1'a'n~ , '~~U ,. I, I . I, '" '1. Plarnl~.,~ark 13lrgenSmllh (""/'Grnaner 'alrg"nlll11lt/,'~\) fa ~ ~l.Ilt ' . ", , , citizen Ofl/1a OommOl1WGl!lllh of Penns~lvanr"'l'esldll;lQ __t 416 Blo.erVllllt 'RoQ(/, . 'i" . , ' '.' \ , N~"'e, P"n~lv8n'. 1712"1, " 2. "O"'nd8l1~ O"vld I... DeVanle (hereInafter '~oV,lm/e'pll 8n adult .. I , l"qIvlQlllllc/I~G" otfhe commonwo~llh Of P!!~n8YIv'M1111 resIdIng ~t,1283 ~alll(lg Springe ROlld, Bl:lllln; SPrfnlP,l, PennSYlvanIa, 1700!" r.Ilnd'cIOIno buS/nlShunper', " tne name of Dllvld L.DeV8ll1e OO/.'lstnlctlon Wfl11 rtll Principal pr_ Of bUllln ' " . " , " IOQ<<led lit 1263 BOiling Spfll1lls Road, Boiling Sprfngs, POl1l1l1Ylvanla 17 ' . . .. , '" ~- L._.. ,i ~. , O~/~a/~8 . 'fl' 1 /lONIlOM.. 19ii,1 f^~ H7 T~Q RHQ , i\lJQllUll\ rWRTIllli\ST . I ._,..,.,.,., , .'.-.......,-.\t-. -r""ITf"T-_ . .,'.'.~'l!"Hl!""'____ , ,. ,. I '~l1>ff...,."'w:l~ - '. 'i :'[' 1.... \ , , , , ' FAOTtJi\L t'V~RMENTS ~, Onar fll'lP\.!t ~~1111 :Z13, 1~El7,lhl'l part'''.. enlefltq Inlq ~ wr1I1Qn AllrllPmllnl rpr Ihe CQnlltrw::tlpn of, II f!JOm flqqlllpn Ii) l'llrolthllmllh!1f rEl.IQ(:lm~e l!lt 4'~ ~IPllPrvlllll RI.'ll!\c1, Newvflla, F'l'nn"Ylvllnla 17:i!41 , ! ' 4, ThfJ Oef\3nQanl WI! to rallh~PQ thl!l, 9Xrlllfnll mof to matPll Ihlt mof Ip .thll nmm, lIq~llIpn, ,A ~'\.1I) l1ncl IlOn'e'lltllOpy of s~l~ PQI'qorn$nlll! taltllPl1eR\ am1 InQQrpQfllltlr.f hllrnln py reftjlremc;a ElI:s'!!xhlpltA, ~, PI~lntlff i!llrall~ tl.'l pay' Oefenl:tMt ~IQhleen 'fh<:lllllancl SeVlln Hunclrec.l ~nty. TWp (11I1 6,722,00) Po"ar~, I~ CClnlllr:ll'lfllYon fo'r the (:On~lf\J!:llpn ctf' the Ilclclltlon 10 Plalntlf!'s relll!:tanoo. ' a, The oontract prf~ WElSllldiJ\!!c;t to'aU\hprfIlSQ ol)~nQaarclel'll gllllet forth In Ar1IPlp ~,qf tl1e ^graempn~ " " " 7, Tll~ PefahQatlt pulll 'II 'tw~ri\~ foot (,20') PV \Wenty.:elght(2D') fQQt ., , " fOom Elctdlllcm,onto U1~ 13lrganllmllh rellfdence, ' ,. I 0;. 'T11e clef\!lndant alllo' p~tnew.lIhll:1gle" an the ~1d.tlnlJfQof oflhe raslqanc;a, .,9, I3lrQen!lrtlllh paid \)e\!anIEl Nineteen Tl1ousand,ffY$ Hwndred I' t" ($19jQOO,OO) PQlh':\r'8,lrieqnllldem!lon for 11113 cclli~ot'\'m of the room adcllllc;rn ~d l1II~eQ Worlfto his reslclenoa, ' , . I '. ~ , '10, '1'1111 original CQnlraDt prtce 'Inoreaeed due to I/'ill' followf.nri , " clroumatanQGll1 ," " , , 8. TIts Defendant 'Ilddacl WOod floortng'end upg~decl carpeting , , , . to' tho ro~m t:lddlllan. , b. ' The Defendant built II extfll1!1lon to ll1eexlatlng Chimney of I' , the reafdGnciel.llnct 0, At lilt tlmea relavant heratol the Dl!lfllndllnt Informed Plaintiff "', , UUltftemll rOrU1it project wurra undemudgeted eQ tl1tit any adt.led coats would be, " .", ~Q1Q , , t" t." I , , , ~,: " .' ' " " ,\1 " ,,,i' . , J M;ol\lll~ tiP"Tll!l~ST , ~ pnti!lIli\I, ~lIh ' , . t'. ,', ". I l~'"~. , ", "', "~It-'''I~~''Hr,tr:;'".{- _., . , ,- .,.;,:.c..IUI~ ~ , q-.,,~. <.' " ," " , 11, At fllI,lIm!J1I m\ltVI'nlllnrlittQ, Il~Vl!lm "nN ~\lIlQIMI!Il' l~llklnl1 r!;lll\llloc1 W!lhln fh~ I'llri,lI'mllmlth rQ!JI"~nI1Q ~fl ~ !'QQIJIl Qr \!1\lI1Qnllfl1!1)lhm pf 1I1~ r(:lam "c1I1It/Ill1 AnR rol~tl'ld Wl'lrklo fhli rpof, 12, On or "~ql,t Ootp~lilr~, 11'l97, ~frgenllmlth pbll1!nilcllln e~lml!\te to r(lpA/r Ihlt l"'lm"!l'" ilnq 10 OCJrt'l!ol thQ c1~faotll to Ihe rQqm all!1l11on Ilncl 10 ttll'! ' , rClpl~I!II1~, The aatlm~teq PPlill1ll In Ih~ RIl104nt Qf alglll 'fh911IlJln~ 'rhna,El l'f\lnQr$~ r-IIl1eW.flV" ($a,~lil6,QQ) 0011141'$, ^ trult l1n~IJOfT$~ \lOpy (If tlli4/cI " , , , pmpoaClI 1$ illtm~hiJq IlnQ InlXlrpQmllilq hl/rllln py reflilrenQli1ll~ ~Ibll a, , , .t, ',. $l..9!!tl.l' O~t:l, ... ,,, IlRElAOH o)f OQNrRAO'T: I 13," P'~'ntlfr aVers liaQh I.wl e,VorY:QllaQl1l1pn 8r,l1 fQrth In PIl~gmpIlll " 1 thouQh 0 Qf thl'! 'Oomplalnt Iln~ InQorpol'2\\ea e~M llnq eVllry one her"'n by , "'fe~nQe Rrl pr~Vh,'l~aIY ~t forth h~reln, .,. I ' 14,' ., P",mgrap!i One (1), tll/clct "Atlloltl Q, ~.,nlll'lll ~rov"lrpnll. I l'lf f1l<hfbll ' , ,.." ^ ejQtfJll In f'JI&v_nt p'al'tl 'AU'WOrk'~hllll be I10mprtilted ", Il WPrkmQn-IIke m~n"llr ,. ,. Bnq In c:omp"lln~ wllt! all PUllqlnQ (:Q~e.s ~nll other ~ppl/\lfl1ble f~W8.' ' , "", II, '16,' Pamoraph ThIrteen ('13); 'UUed Artlel. 6, Q8n~ml Prtlvlefons, of ~Iblt A' etntqe III rel~v.nt pal1l 'Oo/1tfllCltor wamtnla all werk for Q PQrfot:f of , 114 manilla fol/owlng QOmpl.tloll,' ,'18, PefendMt mllterflllly brellche~ !he pfirtles COritrnct by pllrformlno hie dLlU~ In Q non.worl<mllnl/ke m~~nert, speom~IIY: 'Q, Failed to replAQe \!Ildellt1g roar VIlnta \'Iflh new 'lentlllri order to Qvoldwatar IIlakel , , " I AUG 1 0 1998 , ,1 - PUMD(~Q \DIH f~~ 7\7 7~n ~\111 1 , ~cnll!l\ ~ NnIlTll~hST 1 pnNI1ClhJ.. '-n r... .1\r~'" .,~'1"""''''"'''''''~'''''''''''',",'..m'';'t ."..,.'......""'''r., " wnl'.l nllw p'yw~pq, fl'lllllf'll, f~l\ pl'lRllr, Qf1q !lhln~IIiQ Ip Ihll !Jl(flillnQ !'QQfj 0. .. Opnlltr\.lr4I'cl'~ rWamlvEI hip racf la' Iln llxl"lInQ \JIIIPIIl !'Qot Ip I, qlvp,rl wAll!r 9ff n1lil mati Q, ,"RII~Q'tQ pmpllrl~ f"~Qh Pnlmna~ Wllh,propll~ mlillRll1ncl foof " ,""'9~ Qemflnlj " ~,' FfI/lllc:llo replllr Rn aX/liItlnQ ppwlng Il~ple E1ncl of Ihll mo~ . t. , Insta/lllcl Elllllllme(j (ll-l\tllr I'llll1er Ih,an ,II Q~~mIB81t QultQr to lI1El f'QClm !iI\'Jclltlun 1'111 orIClll1aIlY'~!J1'lIl1q \Q'py IhB'par1I~QI " , 'a,' 'Inllll'lll~cl clllfs!:\lve T"1t1.~IRln(;J to Ihlll'llQm,Elclcllllonr'Elnd , h, " Fallllcl 10 In811'111 ptll'\allng I'Incl paint trim Ill'Quncl newly lnlltallaq Frffnoh tlciprll thl'lt 1!lllcllhI9IhMQpm'acldltlon, " ' 17, All ~ tllr"ct \'lOci proxlmple' resl.llt 9f Pllfllnclant's malerlElI pfsl'I\;h Ql' QOnlr~(;t, PlahitltrB rIJ8fc:ll'lm::a,'WElDleft'ln ~ IIt~to 9fclElDp'slf, Qt\uBlnll d':lmaGll . . . . 1 both F.lhYlIloally. pM QBlltl1etfcally 10 the homa IhllraPY qeMvlng f'laltlllfl' full \lite , aM Ill1joyml!lnt ~ hi. pl'Pperty, , I', "t I 1 a. Aa ,Ii cjlr!!lct anclprolllmate reltwlt 9l' the q13~nQ!lntta mall!lrlElI ". . ! .." prel'lch. PlalnlllTwlll tle 'f~ulfad to Incur flnllncllll exp.lIn~a r.lnd 10$Qea to !'Gpafr , . the dam~ft.f!lnd to qorract tI1ll cll!lf"otl!l"n the fllsldonce, ''Wt1I1IiElPq~ f'1t:llntlfl', Marn alrgQn~mllhl reepeqtfully ('G<lue~ II-ldom9l1t . 'I . t I . agQln~ Clfen~an~ O.wlcl t. OeVa'n'IHlIb/~ Davld.1... DeVanls qonelructlon, In I , . " ' " an 1NTl0000t WhIClh, does not eiceecl the jurfadlctfonalamount" altomeY'a fee'l .,' 'rm~ast, .a \WI! a8 Elny r$allonabl" Qm~unt deem Elpproprfate by IhlS Court for ' future coela, j" "" , , l- r. ~'''''''''''''~'IIiI~_''''';I,.~.,~,,' .. , __io. .~__ '---'-=aL -. "__-rR.'- \IlO~~ . " ,. \ . I , ,..-~-t'" " , , . ' , , . , AUa 1 0 1998 , lB'~~J1~. m m ,~HQ " ., . h .., ~ , . ~ , ", .. :~ 1;11:: fl,. . , , ~.. M~'~~" , , ,,~...,\,......,.. """ ..... "".. ,......""'~,.,~., , , I' I . " '\ tiPfIIP ~11 ~;~"'r~llqp NQ, ~r M~ 1l~I"p!r4P" whq ,~II~lIQ<l IIr nPIIPIl~'~" 11'1. ~pnlf~C11 r.:lo 'f I ~~ r-l:-. r-'g:;<~~, '" . Ill~n~"~. ".c:l&-', " '~\lr ~~r1j "9";'1 , , ' t/lan~ III ~~ ~nc.9~ , , "'l/.e ,f7t! ?~ 1A~(14(f. ..- ~ . wtrn". ~"lA~.iL~' ~l' .~' I . ~ n ':1."f "'':"'i'' " A, ., IIr~ \lit, . ~c.;r.,. ,,4: ana'PtJ '" I 1i~~~&.I-, ^:!} , " - , ,...., t., ,t. ", , , ~ Af), ,'I' 4(" t(af ..,. . , e~IIAl1\OI'UlaIO LI<:4"'p Nil, , " "fo'i1VL (to\$' ~' PI FJ:r.l"O(ll, Ia,(.. <!..ta:-, P~-'lei~rV ( ',: f)-'fV~ /):, Dp(T;'47 ~: ~ ~Y~a '~ \, . ' ('aJC::J "'.., t~" ...... " (I II ,_ II,. 'OJ '''I ~ l1oN~a~/. \4o~o ' ..I, .'. l _ . , , r :1;, .1 Mi~ 19 pnf\1ImMI\ w11I911 P\~:y ~aV\l ~llnlflll\ll!=C\IQr-t1r IIIlCjJ, I~!I.; ~n~IIP~ 'k" " , , " " ,,1;'''~' tit:) ,','" ~l\itnwllllll ~ml WI1* III UllllllQfwfllph J" !1lfono4 III \lr rl.lnllffmllY I~Y!l Il!lOnpllfl'llnn\l<l flY' , W, r.,P\J11 ~ Ilnllt, lnll.j II!I wprl< wt~l\lh 1m J1orfpnllo~ \1y Pcfcmlanl WIUIIll1ml'llltoclIn ~ wnrkmlUl.ll~o 1110nl\ctj lU1d 11lalllflff 11~4Qholl Iha O!l!1l11mIlOl bqlWIlIlf:1lho P111111l~ 10 Ihe OlllCllt , I1mI ho tlIl!Plllp Illvll pcr"lullUlI fII\ ppporwnllY 1'1 '\1~IlPI 11II4 p~rf9rm allr 1I114It.1ol\ulIIIlPP~Sal",Y WIle, 1;2,. AlIllf toll8onllhlll InYc~l1gl\li\ln, Ppfllmh\fll l~ whho", lcno\Yll~8c or /llfbffil~lhm fIlifflphllll 10 (Plll\ 1\ hllllaffllllo Ule tOIl" of III II IWCllI\cnt." 13)' 1Vll)' pf/\lrIhor IItI&Wllf. Oef\:I1QilI\l \lOmplplcrt his WOfk In 1\ wwk-\1ul\l,llkll ml\l\!wr In ~coll\llanQIl wltll '''\'IlIgwClfficnl~ botweell Ihe j1/1111cs, COUNT I . DRFlArlH OF CONTnAC~ 13, P!I\'1lllruphs t Ulm\lsh 12 of Ol!lfclldanl'a AllSwQr arc In\lol1lPraloll Awcl" by " ., p ~tbfll\lllllU1 if AIUy ~lll fu~, 14, GOllol~lon pl law, 11\1 II~WIlI' fIIq\lll1l4. If 11l1lllSW0l" I. l1IiI\l1fed, the,. original iI8flIOllIent belWCQn thQ part!ClI hemlQ sPllllks (Of !lSIl!1; . IS, 'CQnolllslon Qf 11Wf. no IUUW~ fIIl1\llrcd, If.illIlIllll~ Is ~lted,'tho orlalnl!l ~OllIcnl h~W\:en the Par<<1lS blll'Oto $pllllks' fur Itself. t6, (a)-Qt) CoullhwlQIIS \If JIIW, no Sl\IlWllr l'eqUfred, If an 81~r ISl'lll{ulted,lhll IIvcnnenls Ill'll apealfill8lly denied. By way of!\lrtbot lltmVm', Defendant Mlllllld tho terms of the I " , t original all\'CemOllt betWllen the parties heralQ IInd compllllcd Ills \YlIrk In a WOrkman-l/1(o lltIIMllI' B8 ~n1reJ by Iltell~ent. DeJ\lItdant i\trthor lItlllWe11ll111 foll~WlI1 -3- ~"'III", - '---" ~,' . .~.'-~--- ,. " ~ ' 'nu,a(~a l~la~ r~X TH T3n ~HII .\POlllll ~ NOIITII~~sT 't pONIlI1~k . , . t" ' , ': ,.,'~~Il ~1~11 '2', Thoj1I-!J1!lll'hll4fl1n~!JtQmlllaMoh~~~~lllIIIQ\I "'~\ltllut mllOflIQ, ';l ,,, J,\ 1 ~,.II,,' , " " 1"'1,;-" ,"~,''' ,faQllIi 10 I'rol~1l1 PlIAI"~ JlIlY pIIOao'J'"nltlnll, ' ' ''If''J' I,," I " ... .. . 0.'.,17', t' " , ' .'" ~~, Pll'h"Ifl1~ plplm, IllIlY 1>0 1>PfTCf! PY Iho dpctrfno 9f qonBCI\I, pooon' pUl~ , I4l1lf11ollpn, pcqlllosppnnll pnd nlfl'comen~ 10 Innl\1!lIl,PIII MI PI! Hmll~l\ ta, Iha fllOt thaI Ptphllltf . llsT=tl (0 lokll rO.J1nnBlhm~ for cllrl4lll Willie InpllIellns TllplAoomcnt Ilf vllnts, ;13, ThQlltnlnliff oanlrMlo\,! wllh \llhl'l l'IlI\l"" 11/ 1'llIvh'~ IJIII(I:rM. Ibr \110 1lI11mlloy lll\l~ thmtnrlllook r~nJ111JUthIllIY for /lilY problems IIBsoolMcd wtllllllo mntllria!s IIl1pplle<lwlth IllIs phlmqey IllClenslon. 24, Phullllfra oUllPod ohilms IInd dIImos~, ll1lp~nSCll III\IVpr IOSSCll may havo blll'lI ,. . , flnllsBt! by olher Indlvl<lua1s, flll11s /lnd/or corp om lions for whom Pllfondaqlls not rcsJ1al1slblo Inollldll\/J J,O, f.,ebo ~ l'lonS,lno, .' 2$, 1'110 DefemJanl hll4 Mfill~d MY IIllIl I'll oandlllol\ll of Iho llBr~~mQI1IS betWllon Ibe l111rtl~ bemo, 26. Dore"dIIll~ hllll II\1bS'tlllltlally, caml1lefcly IUIdlor fullY pqrfoJmlld Ilntter the BiIC\lmenlll blltweel1lh~ partie" 27, Detondant 4as pcr(anncd 11I\)' eMy be DJVCd 10 Pla!ritlJf'llnd~ tho lIgtllom~1 between the Partlcs ald11fully, oarct\JIly, dlllBontly 'lIld 1st II wurkmen-Ilkll manner end PlaI~ , ;1 bpi made payment thlltllfor. ' , 28. Plalntlt1's claImS may bo banod In whole, lJI' In pllrt, beCllWlIl at Ws fill1ure ItI pur.rue, comply. Mdlor abldll by IIllY WlUTantlos betWCCII tlte parties hCl1'llllllnoludlnlJ the stvln$ ot'requll'lld nDtioB,1 " " .G. " , ~"'mlD ... ..... ..t.I.LJ.-"-t.._......... " . II t ..., ....._.... -~- '.Ll--_II..__., , . . " ~u~pm 181D3 FM H7 m ~UQ " ~CUllP' ~ tlfJl\l1ljl~Sl' 'I pOtlllll~J. GlI031 I , , 't .! I , .. , I. t',,::, WtmlUlJ'OJl.l3, Dofonda", ,P1lVi4 f..- O"y"III" WII PAV'" J., PqVllmll OIl~\flIO~Il,!1 I , I )~~, \~ 1I11111'h111\1IW' Gomplalm 11ll I'lsmluo~ I1mll1lll~ J\ldIlffiOIl~ \10 cn~lln lafs fIlvcrr "nil. i". IJ ,ql"l .1., to ,. . ,.,J ': 1:\"I,!,','\,;;'i', "~\lIa llllllnmrphl~ co.", oflhllllll1l1\1I1, I , , . t-f111'Z;OPlt, WlO~eRBnAM, KNA.USI'l'~ Imll, 1l,C, UYI "r-z... ~:'" Clork PaVerll, Buqlllro ~ Allomoy (,0; Nil, <<Q7~Q nil Nprth Vm~1 S\1'CCl ll,O,11Ill~ 5~OO HlIffia\l\ug, l1A 17110-0300 (717), 23Q-III Q7 AlloOlOY for Oefendant Ollledl SoPlamb,,[ 17, 199ft . - I, .I- " " " " " ' I. I' " J' " .' " " .. 8 ~ . "-'f'! Wlro . " ... '" Qpmm UI~~ I'^~ 111 1~1I PUll I ^CO~P'^ HORTPnhHT 't PPHIlOh', !iIIm , , " , ~ f. 'I t'l ,',', 'I ._1,.. /' , , .,', " ,', " (,f q , , " " /, q ", " , " " " " . " ",I " I, " /1, , , ,.. ,I "" ", " " , , r " " " ,. " I" d' ',I , " EXHIBIT A . _'I_.j I, ' '" t ,.. ,,,,. ,...... -:~-:'...==.=:.I" --' ......."...... -..., .... ,. -.. , ~ . P9/3Q(90 ~QIQ" rh~ 717 7~" ~l~q . ' ;;, " .\ " .' o-f(UlI'IC! I< hCO~Plh NqRl~h9T :! pONJl(j~I. ..; '. , , ME11:0ijR. WlCl{.EIotS~KNAUIlS & lI1Ul.l',C, r ~- - ~ C!llf!l:PPVIlfl'. ~sq\OOl ",. to , .' " " .' I: " .' /, " /, " " " ,., I, ,; ,f '. " ., " i., \. ,'jI:-. " , P9(~~/9Q ~~1~7 f~ 7~7 7~n 911q ", ". .- '""!"T , ,.,...., " , \ , . , , .~ " .. I, \' , " . : "''' ;."",...,. '.",,1'1'1 -- '" ,...., 'I ~~~; "".1., .'\' , I i'Iil \~" ' , " . '.' ,. '. ' ,,..,, ~."' 1-",&. '.- ~"L::' . .--~ ....I~4iPf",......' ,., u"U-., t, ~mi "' ,..Jf!7:t - "" ".",~.._", ";'5'J~;i'" ""I VI"':" H~.An.. _"id~ ('P;"'.J -~~~;?S~~E""" ~~.....- ~;:t; I j.4.1!;-'. ~ ~ 1!%$t';:;f r';~@ #-",~~ ~ . ., , II\~ .lVI'IJ o~ ~?"\ ''\ ~\V " " _''''''.ln~r''.H'u.:u=::n'- " -..t ~.,,u.-=-"I\.L.'.-.,n ".&.I-I'.&t ~ "," ,,-= ,.~.\tt--' " III \ha\llllf h.t1I11V 10 furnl.h mlllrl,1 .nd l,bO,' aomp"" In ~~~ ~llh ,bOV' .p~1 , " ~" . ~.__ ___l~_;.' ..,...___1"'"".'.'_' ,t'._- \ =r..~~~'15:l#S' 'C"J.;rI\T~I~.&'='~"~ lIIftIIoj~~= 0........ ""..., _101 1/1 ""- -~ ^~uphmn of ~11..a'lI1 llMoIlMlf'lOI,.,,,,,,,.II<aIlDn>' joI4 'll',,",~ ..~ "'INt., ... .. "","~y '"te!l1t4. \W ... ~..~ II ll'Ill1t \IIIIIh '"I,"ilI.~, IIJIIltlt lIIII III iIIMt II """", .-, ~ O..\lf~"""1 ...........~ .-~,~- --- I i: , - ,I -II ,t " , !",' " '";, " " I H " " I-I' i, " Ii " " " 1,,; " ,,"~ i ~ '" I' " " I, " " 'I oj! 1 " " " " , " " " il. " If' " I' " " I" " ;1; " It "I II " lid " " " II " " " " I , " ,,". " " Exhibit 0 , ".-"1..,, 'I\l~'t ..""..,,"~ mIA' i/; 'Y~1~~;': " 7 'Mtll~'W~IH~ 'QlfQ:~~rr~X\\.a' " ','t. .. WlO,.,," i\,.-, J1-'I\'UI),i;;~~.~. 1.1~.1 tl'l.V/ (J () f1 ~ Vllml.-, ,'m"~I'!'!I"." f" r"" ~OOJ';tlIG1 ,fi;1t'ft ~'MvmI!r~'!l tiM,' ";pJ~~ " fJlI~"",(I~ W'lllU"" '~f,J\JFIJ&b1. ..~"." , ,... '.' "P t" .', .. , ~~T~ , ,if Q Jl ,~Q' 0 ,. ~ ~ P.Il., .f fI'" , 1/"'" 9' 'Z-- ., ,'" ~S~~:=~ I:"~"~ ~ ~,,~, tJ.I.~~~ ~ r. 'I 'I ~!:.e ,. , ~I nQn~~~ ~~ ^tmQ~tl'~~ ~~~~~y 'f~qVp~- ~9j~~~'~~ t~~ fQ~low~ni wo~~, ,q~'~"pp1r ~.~~~~~~~~ ~~~~p~ ~o~~w, f~~.~.~~ ~~ ~h. "~~~. ~. p~~ CQW~h ~o1QWI ' P.'\J".~,,1:o~cm o~ WQt1c \19 ~ 1?"J1I:QI'III\II\'H~ . ~:_::.~~f~~~~~ "'\l''''U~,' ~Q ~. ."Pfil:U.~' '::1\..' ' ' , . """11, \I1'h". lIlW, w~U W \,,*Ultl114 .:,n;, lI, ta\:lll lP\Qnn~ 01 ' ' '~' ~hJ.ll1\ J:~f.t:.. .. to" down \11I31111I--\1, . ~ \1M '..~"n' o,*,,1.t:J.on. , , ~"~tlJl x, !tQl'u,;(,d It 1\:J:~o).t, b....,., tlQ11I1Il \;1.' ,n "\11l"~IlI"t\ 't.a P,,,,!:Q;J:JlI t:lI, "uti,all II"~ Pll\l\4l1I' 1.;11. l\\a~..1!''''~'' " t,n".,,,.tal'l I'bo"., ,,;1.1111 \;11\\ p~'U:.onll WhCl.. i91:i. b\1a:.', ,"Ppflar:, b.low, \nl~.\llf\t: ~o ~h. ~.1l'~' IIIP" to~th 1n t~~. ~~al' ~n~ ~lna~ng OO"t1!'.Cl~' :l;, . , ,. IiI(JClglpt;th~, II).!PV. IlliloPPllldt ,,~d ag.ij' ~o "b~a. ~t the ta~mQ 'DQh tor~h (n ~b~. llval .n~ btn41nw 110 "Clt:, . " I,,' " , ~ . ~ .:1:' I oate, ~t'l. "..:-0"".,........ Plltcn ,,", " Exhibit "pll 1+ ---- , , , 9& 101 HOH 8lr~oHo'6" ..-, GO'd , f.... ; \,h',,' - ~ :1\\,1,_1/ " '''''.'.1'' , /1 "'..-' ., ',. V ';"(hl'l "', 1"\"" , I,ll I.', I \"'f: I( . . 1 I~ 1 (.... .., " ''if \, !:j: . \j'''''i'F t' '. ; \' t', i~ \/~'lll' :' t.1.';i1'~~:'):;~; )~~:\/i. '.' I,' I.'j \ ,.,I:,\,.I,j"",:,)"., .! ' , 't1. \!,.i ~ "t?;~'i',('U-!io '''''' ,I ,I .....'.' r'" :tj, };'j 'i.l..,..' ~b. l,; 1 '/, i';I;\\\1 \ ",\ ._'.1'b"i__' SUIlOON'l'RIIC'l'OR-l\GRElIDMEN'l1, " I 1. ~u~co.ntrActor~ will..pr,~'n.t A curr,nt c,.rtificAt, of liAbility in~urAnce to ~.O. Hepo ~ sona, Inc. (~O~~~). ';1 . . ~, Ilyaigning thia agreement, the aUbcontrActor ia neeuring thAt he Ie A legitimAte bUaineael with bu~ineea licence, phone, etc, J. gOH~~ ie not reaponei~l~ f6r c1aime or injuriae incurraQ ~y the au~contractor or Any pareon~,mploye~ ~y the aUbOontrActor. workman1e oompenaAtion, if ,requireQ by lAW fo~any employeee of the aUbcontractor, ia ~he aola reaponeibillty of th~ au~contractprl 4. subcontractor will aubmit,per job, A prcpoaal pontaininga ~etaU!3~" atntelM\nt an~ ~oop, of work to be completeC\, number pf conaaoutive working ~aYa to completion of work, AnC! PAyment aQha~ulel . 5. su~c6ntrActor will Agree to return to the job to correct any' problema' epecifie~ by JO~~S (leAke, reaaonable oomplainte,etc.l u~ to a perio~ of one year aft~r completion of contract work. 6. supcontractora are working for JOL&S, not the customer. Pieouaaione with the cu~tomer to be referre~ to JOL&S ae well aa any aQQitional requeete an~ referrale for work. 7. subcontraotor will BuboontraoteQ job, be ,ooyereQ oyer. I not diBplay any of hie oompany,aignB on a /lnY aigne on truoka, equipment, eto., mUet ,," Wedeaire that our working relati6nBhipe will be oonQuoted in a fdenc\ly ahc\ profeBl!lional manner anc\ that they will be mut:ally , profitable. SlgnatUl:\'lB _ffl(j'):di/ '.~ , ' . . Pate 2~~d-CJ~ --,., .' MARI~ "IR~'W~M'TH, . , fllllln" ' I I. V, I p~X,p' t.~~VANI~' I I '~ P . PA 0 I., PI!VANI~ I' OON$TR oriON. I PQf.md~n' I v, I ~,O, U~~O iii SONES. INO, I I Md Ihlnlll' Pllf~nt1AnI , I v, I RON~t.~ a, ARMOI. T \ t A ~ lIon,,' OQfQn~ant I IN!TH~ OOURT OF OOMMON Pl-liAll ' OUM~I!I"l-ANP (lOIJNTY, PP,NN8Yl-VANlA PIVI!. ACTION,I-AW NQ, ~Q.:UU'7 OIVII.. .' JURV TRIAh Pf:\MANP~P AG.B5M~NT TO l=)tTEND TIMElTO PI.eAD. , It 1ft nora~o Ihl\\ f1ll1lntlff, Ml'lrk 13lroanftmlth, Ie orf.lntecll'ln axlanalnn of lima ,\hrQugh Mal'Qh ~1, 11199, In WI1 Pl1lo file: , , 1, An AmQn<lll~ oampl.lnk xxx .,' (500 Altllohl1d OroM. of Courl) I. . 2..l\n anewal., . 3. An unswer or prellmlnL\ry 0\))ecllon6, . The 1~/.IIiIIUI rmw exeoulalhlll Aoreemllnlln Idenlloal oounlerparts, Gaoh of whloh ahnll onnotllule I1n orl\llnL\ll1nq all of whloh shall oonatllule Ihl1 oama Aoreement. 1" , Rallpeolfully oubmllletl, Olllll: " 0/110: Oalu: PQtor J. RUBSD, OQunsel for Plalnffif ...~" ~ara, Ooune~ Jor Pefandiiiitbovllnlo . " 'ffiiiiiiill( Doardorff, Counaol fOAl' Ollfandimi'LeTiO'"'~ ...-,.~._.-:;- ~~/I Ii' " ,. -~ ~ %. <-- . --to . t l!. JO;YIP , ,~ n, r" ounsol for II on lInl' rmo t / OalOlltf I";;'?-jj . "I I MARK I:JIRQFrNaMITH, I IN ~H~ OOURT Of CP~ONJ~I3A$ ., PlAint ff I OU I3I3RkANP COIJN ,PI; aYJ"VANIA I I v.~ I clVlJ., AOTION,I.AW I P~VIP I.. PI3VANI~ ' I NQ, IIQ,aIlQ7 cIVIl.. ~ hip PA~P I" PI3VANII; I OONSTR OTION, I ,.1' PQflJndnnt' , I V," I ~URY TRIAl.. PI:IMAN0130 I J,(J, 1..~130 a. SONS, INc, I MdItlQ",~1 PQfQndAnt t I V, I I RONAI..P a, ARMOI. T I i'" , MdltlQnAI PQflJndAnt I " ~.TOI;XTIW~ It l!l agreed that Plaintiff, Marl< I31rgenllmltll1 la grl:1nted an extanalon of time through MArch 31,1""", In whloh to file: " ' , 1, An Amonded complAint. xxx (See Altaohed Ord~r of Oourt) 2, An anaWar, 3,An.anawar or preliminary opjeotlona, ,. . Tha Partlea may axsoute thla Agreement In Identlpal counterparts, eE\oh afwhloh aha II oonatltute an original and all of whloh shl'lll cqnslltute the Sl:1ma Agraement, . I, Raspectfully supmltled, Dl'lte: 'PEii8r"J.RU!lSO, Ommsel for Plaintiff Datel' , Olarl< DeVerel counsel for Defendent DaVE\nle Ii, Data; ~.. aba " Date: Joseph V, Sebel1i1,'"'Jr'l OOlmsa(for Defendant ArmaU , , M^I~I\ 11IIWliNHMl'Ill, Plnln!l''!' IN TIll! COllin of cOMMoN PI ,IW:l of (-~llMlIlq~1 .^NP COUNTY, PIINNHYI ,v ^NI^ \" P^ VIP I" P1W^NIII II/bin P^VIP I" P1W^NIn CONH"'I~uc'I'loN, Dul~llIlllnl v, CIVil, M~TloN . "^ W ,I, C, I,nna {\l. HONS, lNC" ^dtlhlonnl PIII~llIllInl v, , RONM,D II, ^RMOLT, FlII'llwl'^dllltl\l11111 lJulol1dn\1t NO, 9H.3HH7 CIVil, TERM. lliJ!El PLAINTIFF'S. PETITION FOR t.EA Vii lll.L1MEND PLAINTIFF'S COMl~ IlEFORE HOFFER, PuLl OLER.J\I1d..illillli4..J.J., QRIJER OF COLlIU: ^ND NOW,lhlR I f ~lll)' Ilf.lIll1\IIII'Y, I 999;nfluI' CIII'III\II uO\1Rldul'lItlollOf PIIIlntllrR " PuUtIO\1 for LOllvu To ^mclHl Plllllllil'f"R Complllllll, lI\1d orthu hl'iofli Huhmlllud lI11d 01'1I1 III'gIlIl101111l )l1'URIIlliud 011 thu mllltOI', Plllllllifl"1I pulltllllllH J!,1'1I1110d lI11dl'llIlllll!'!' IH II1'fhl'dud20 dll)'R 11'<1111 (ho dlltu ol'lhlH OI'lIOI' wllhln whloh (ol1loll11ll11lClulcd com)lllllllt, without )ll'l,l,hllllcc to thc I'lghl OfOPPORIIlJ!, )llll'tl01l 10 III 0 tlmcl)' )ll'ollmllllll')'llh.lcutlollH (0 (hollmu\1dcd pIOlldlllJ!" BY TIlE COURT, " , ;{ d/k2 O,e/ "j, WCRlo)' 0101, ' 1'" ,I, , i" I , , II;':',~ ," I ,," I' " ",; " "I' I, if I " " ,., il il [! " , ". j, " II If' " I' ,'j, I' " H " i( Ii " " '\ " " I' 'h.. , " d', 1,\ Ii ;I' " ,. , " i; iJ " " .1 /I " " " i, fii " , ,I' .. t , .' 0 \ n (~l ;\., Ul 'II '1 "'I '..j !i:tj " '\11 1 1\", -,1-1 "'JI;) " 'II I' " " 'Tl , ") ~l) , ,I, !!-'l " , \I- F" ':.]'" " t/; " " ,) '" ;,.q ul ~...., " " . , /I I' " I', " " " 'I I' " i-" " j' , i " " " 'I.; " ,,' it" " !Ii "H " " t, " " .1', I, " " '. ,," ,r " Ii ;' " " " I' " ,'< ,,, '" " " 1\ " " 'i,,, " !' " " ,I , (," 'I)