Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-03891 " , !tl ~ ~. f' " j. I' "" I' I' II " " ~ ~ ~ l ( J 'I, " 'I 'I, I' ;i " " II ',1' , " I' ,I' ii " " ~ " '~i r;,; J~\j ~ "'"', "-t, , ;'., \, \, . ~ '\ ~ \ ~ \ " I I I I ,I , I: " ,. ,I: " H " ,. .." " I' .. " " .. II., " I' I' " d ,! " " ;i I' ,t" d " j; " " " I' 'j " ,; 'I \ I I I I i (i ~ " " if d " 'j, ;,: 1/', ,. "11 I;;i Hi " ii d H I' ,j " , " Ii - '. Il:) .. c:; 'il I'" j' ,,' ,(I " d 'I" " 'i ,. ,...... 0'- Do N') 1/ ' " " I, " Ii ,. " il. Pl' I Q,. (:ro " .I I' If ~ Ii ! i "1\ ,I "Iii,:, I'! I I 1'lilL ,l,'[1,11i , I I" i,()jll'Hiii-,n 1\1 I lillllT,' I,il ,Ill )11' ,1'1111 ,1"\-.\ ;"lp-i1'!:T,I', 'I' ,." " n'IIi',':U ',1;/,1111\ ,!lIHllIlIVii'/'1 'III III .li.1. J'tl\I_-!li_:J;) I; \ pli' ii.' " I, " , ' .'- ~ I i ,.- I I t' t . " " i 1IIIlH-(1 I (II; t' \ 'l',iLl \11;'1 ;1 H'J ,'1 ,!I'J l'II'fil ,qrdll '!;'ld 1_lIlld Ii)' l'Ul "11',0.4' I;,; llii-' "i lU'I~' ;,i',/ (I i 'Ii" ;1(, I ',i 1\ III 1111 " I" " 1_ II I \ II" IIliidl 1",', 1'/1'1 Iii' \i'III\ LIJ 1'\:1111',(1..'1,\111,.1\ .,,11)]1'11,'(1\'11;,;'0.11'11 .I_(',-j l'l.;r:-'{' 1_'!',I_l~,\U l\" I~,-jl \,\,\1 H j: 'ld,lll.!., .-! 1{]1 iil I' , 1"jlU I I 'i'l t I hi' diUi' I I 1,\1 il' I, , L'r \11,' l,i \1 I 1,1;,1 I. 1'111',1 ,1\ I, 11.'1' (III '-1\,1.1 '{ .'1\,: I, ,'1 "I>" Ill';' \ 1,1. ,,' flr_Ojj 'I'" I \I r.j r 1Ii',I "Ii :;J\I \ \ I I, . ; j ;" \. ~ ~ i I 11l,11 '\'.1,' I 1,11l! \!\1 ~ (\.1' 1,1_',\lII-I}' ;'.11) r 1-,' lid r,q" , 1l1-'i" 1i,II,q!!II'l I I:'.. 1./, t." ; I, ~ l', , 1,-/1:/ ,i'lliI Vll!l '" 1',--' 1'1, i;j':-;I,'j-,- ")!' . . " ) ~I 1,( Ii .'li II If! II f; :J' I I );,; il II,' [)<,-'!"I\ (-, ,IIi< c..}dtl , J. i ,~I".!. . I' \ ',' "I 1 ' I (I~' ,i. I" ('~Jll"'l..,<..., e,',' ')ll-LQ,. ft"'H d'/J1'1 1'1 ,d I, '!lll \ Ii', -, , L'I, .,. II ill! 11 .II I !j,j t 1,1 ,-' ,I . I. " !.-lllII I I' , H i' ., " . Hi' l'lll", I, '1IIli,'/ 1"1 111;,1, ',Il i' jlJ\UJllllLl I1,1 ut t'1i. I; j i;i'\:'\.j,l, Pi 1'111U}'.lI);:\(J,j,.'I' (if "',I" 'i( /'11,\'1'1'11/1 ~ n' u\ I, '/ I Ii; I(\::~.'...;'I/' ,,~/ ~~;;:'l(,/ /?!;;t? ' "Ii, ('IT1r-iii;,,-i:' \-;1\iZ~.~t:':Jli:'l',\.'_rr I' l,hll.l. I, -/1 t ; ;i'Y~)!\ 1< 111..1:1-" ,\ ,. '1".-, " ., /( 'I' " jJ Ii ,; !\ " ", \'-" , "'i',' )fl" 'j" ;'1';\,',1,\ ",. :\';'\\ ,~" , " j; ,-; ~- ',-- -ii' f \ .:. \~ : j I ~: Ii: \ ,;~, . ,",\ ' :L' \ r OJ) _ t_, :-if~ 'I' i"':1 1,';',,1", ",'; q'" , !, .'.J' " ' i -; . ~ ; i: '~~ ~ : ,,_, fi 't.' .~-, /- il"" "ii-\ , -;'! ,,;;-,:-~';t'-~~\ :'-.;. ..,::;i;til\,;\;;\,;, ;," '~;(''''''l'' , " } !, t:~ " I (ii ,\ " -t' 'i 'II' :~~ :1 ;i' .~i " ~;' F HA Y lJml'Alll\l~N'l':r f3, PI,AH!'I'J1"I' , IN 'l'llIli COUW\' ()Ii' 'COMMON PI,I!JAIJ ()Ii' CUMllID1U,ANlJ COllN'l'Y, PlliNNf1Yl,vANTA v, NO, 98-3891 CIVIL ~m~M COMMONWWAI/"ll QV' pmNNfJYl.,vlllUA, lJIilPAH'I'MlliN'I' (W HlwmNtJlli, PIUNNSYI-NANT1\ 1.O'l"l'IiIHY, DIDI~mNlJAN'1' , CIVIL AC'l'lON- l..llW PHmijIMIl'!{I.l3,Y Ol?~ lilC'I'IOl'Jfl AND NOW, comes the Def:t3ndunt., COl1\1l1onwef\lth of: Pennl'lylVC\l1ia, Department of: Hevsnue, 1'ennsylVf\nicl J.ottet'y,bY'f\ncl throllgh itll f\ttot'nsy, Jll.llia 1\, Sheridf\n, Deputy Chief: Counl'l81, f\nd filsl'l"the within Preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's Complai~t flS follows I I . l.,1\CK 01' SUBJIDC'I' MA~"l'IilH ,JU1USIJIC'l'l'ON I, 1 , ~'hs Honorable Court of' Common Plel'18 of Cumberland .1, County cloes not have jud.8r.lict:J.on over thls 1\cu.on 01' the SUbject mf\tter' ther80f, but 1'1\t1181.' , jlldsdlcl:.ioll, 11: 1\ny, 18 reposed ln the Board of: Claims of: this Commonwoalth 1\S esti'\blished by '.i ':ii -,;'/ ," ~':' ;;;'4" IJ\ 'I',l TV1 " , l statute 1\t 72 1'.8, !),j(j51-tl. 2. The BOt1rcl of: Claims has exlJ.l.uslve j\ldsdidtion to heal' I, ancl determine all claims arising from contracts entered int6with the Commonwealth whol:e l:he amount in cGnl:roverey equall3 or ,I' eXlleeds ~noo,oo, 7;;:,1',,'3. !itl651-tl. ,.. ,I '. , IU\Y D1Cld\UlUCN'i'lS, , PIJI\IN'I'H'F', IN 'JIlin; COU!\'J' OF' c'J(,lMMON Pl,F:l\fJ OF' CUI~BmlU,I\NIJCOUN'J',Y I l'H:NNSYlNI\N 11\ v, NO, DO-3891 CIVIl. 'j'blHM COMMONWUlAl}I'll ow I'ItlNNfiYINANIA, PICPAH'J'MrilN'I' OIi' HlilvmNUIiJ, I'lUl'INSYjNI\N1A, I,O'I"I'IiJHY, DICIi'IilNDAN'I' , CIVIl, }\C'l'TON - J,AW IJItWll:NDAN'1" S PHF:1JIMINl\RY OBJF:C'\'lONS 'I'D ---l;L7II!'!'1'IIi::'IN S..Jl.MI!l.,J1i'llifP--co,tl)l!AH/'I' - {\NI) NOW, comes the DBfendant, COlI\monwealt:h of P,ennsytvan.i.a, ,Departmont: of Ravonuo, Pennl3ylvan,ll'1 l,ot(:ery, by and through .i.t:s att:orney, Jull.i.a A, Sher.i.dan, DeputyCh.i.ef Counsel, and f.i.les the wHh1n Pre.l1nd.nar.y Object:.ions to Pla.i.nt:l.ff's Al\lendocl COlnp1n.int as fallaWi'll I, LACK OF' SUBJF:CT Ml\TTF:R JURISDICTION ..~-------.__.----~---~--------_.----.._- 1. '1'he lIo11Orablr~ Court of' Common Pleaa of Cwoberlf.ll1cl Countydoos not have j\.)r..i.sd1ct.ion over th.i.s act:.i.on or t:he,~ub~ect , matter ther.eof, but rather., jur..isd.i.ct.i.on, .i.f any, Is reposed 1n t:hq Board of C1611118 of th1s COl11lnonWBa.lt:h as estC\b.l1shecl by statute at 72 P,8, S~651-~. " 2, 'l'he Board 01: C1a.i.ms has exclus.iva jur..i.sdicUon to hea'r and determlne,a11 ~la.i.lI\s ar.i.sing from contracts enteted 1ntoW.ith the CDmmonWealth where the amount .i.n controversy equals or excoecls$300,OO, 72 p.S, J~~51-4, iii' !'