Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-03968 ,. " j" ," 'j, " I' "!l t~ j ,'4 I 1j J.I Ii " ,'!' " " " " " I' !." ,i " '." " " , " ''il. ~ " I' " ~ 1 ~ ~ I : ',j, " "h~ ';"\ I,. ft I, \ , " , ~ " !i " '" ;1 " 1\ ,. i! ,; II' " Ii " I' Iii " ., " " 19, Vlaintiff'~ gift of tho engagement ring to Pefendant Wa~ ~\lbieQI: to an .i.ll1pU.pr1 oonrl.1.t.i.on reqn.1.dng .j.j:~ l:e\:m:n J.f thl'! marr.i.age d.i.d not take plaoe, ?O, Pef(~mlllnt ,t~ reCJ\lh'e~1 PV law 1:0 l:et~ll:n to the enqAQ!3ment r.i.ng to Vla.i.nt.i.ff, , " I'/Il111HIil\!,Omn, 1-''1l'\i.ntiff, 'l'i.mothy p, PrallbA, re~paqt;f\lUy raCJ\le~t~that l:hi.~ Honorable OO\lrt ctil:eo\: \:ha\', Pefenctan\:" Mary Iil, n\ll\\phde~, i.mmactiAtely ~.etUl:n ,the engagemen\: ring to PlAi.ntiff And enter a juctgment for poe_eeeion of the, ring for Plai.ntiff and agA,tl'let Pefenr.lant, ~nolmli.ng OO~lte of. the aoti.on to be .1.mpo~ect agai.net Pefendant; CmINlIU!.....Ml..'.I1.:tO.N_l N._lJ.QNVmRIUQN_(J:N_Tnm_I\Illt'.mRN l\lt'.:t.VJ!l.). [, ~1~ Paragraph~ 1 through and .j.noludinq ~O are inoorporated , herein Py referenoa AI3 if eet for.th at length, . 22, Plaintiff ie uncertain ae'to the location of the engagement ring and whether or not the engagement dng hae beqn "dispoead of by pefendant,' 2:3, pla.1.ntiff lielieveB and therefore Elvere thElt he ,1.e entitled to the reasonable value of the engagememt ting and special damagee, incli.lding amounts paid for tax of $457,94 and , ineuranoe on the ring in tl)8 AmOlmt o'f $10:3100, all to the exolusive bel1efit of Defendant \~ho hae maintained the ring in her exoluei.ve pOBaeslilion since June of 1997, 24, To the extent l)efendant has disposed of or dall1aged the :3 ill ~ ('; <.. \ IIi " Ii " I';' " " 'i' " " i' " " ,; " " " ;; " !' 'j, I' " , I' " , , " " " " d' I' " I' n " ;,' Ii " I' '" 1 ~ " " H " ;; ;j ,. ,. iI i' ,i(, 74g l~ ~. ", '........ ..... ~ \ ,,' (,j.' :.'') , 1 "II , .. i'illl "') "/ I'> '. H \--j ji'll ,I!,! ~U ~, ..,~ " 'i o ~ F .c: \"\ .~ '''$ .. .(::," V> ,10 8 'i:! t f\ I, II '" j'l ii! Iii , I' lill 'I"~ " i I ~'Ii i 11'1'" ,J' I " :tl,li~! Iii, I,,'. 'dId,)' ". " }_! !.lL;)!','! 1\ !!-j-:~' . d, 11,\1 111, Illit!,;-, Ii' [)"'ii':!1 tl' "Ii \ JiI!. -' \ l~ Jl J I Ii I II , \{,\ Illl d' !II I'll , ,,1";\ 1 Iii L '.', , 'j'l I, Ii' I,ll I ~ \ , , I' IF'l \\1 ;1' )-.1' \! I \, I ~ -3 t'l ,1:11'11.1 II 1 liT ;l.lfl i-!,1,\;'JL! ,J I iI, 1 'I 1 , " I I "Iro I. I tf II/Jill 'II I J I' "I I ('1,-, )'111'1 i! ('j,.,'; .. I.,j\ I'. II! ; Iljlj I (illi,! ,\1. ., Il) (I II ~ ii/'J ./i,,';! ir'_,' /,1:1Iidl\l/l ,". ';, , ii-,! 1,'\.1 '_~t'I< 'ii) ]\11 j 11,'1.\'1 i.' I , - ~ I " , , " " ,. 'Hip l'f"_1 illl il'i t. li.-,;' L il Ili lil'l "I !J," II '.1.', J, " I' II II( 'I; j,_ ;1'! '.'i],iil I :.\,'\11 , ,- 1I,.I,-j ; ;, li'l .,'[ II,!III ,. '_I_I\~I :.'~~,)', -,.;":-,~~'/ !r~I'7~~;.--' . ./,....:,..,::~/~ ',> _ ~~.,,".-rl-f\"(:, ~ Y","::. ...~~ h',! f 'l'h, 'Ill.\" i: I f II" ',IlL' j r I ,1/i'll" 1 .! I,,', I " ;,1111 I \II',: )( ,Iii , , {; , -'ij Ii' I, II <P.. , I;; ! atj<~ 1\ '/'1 I " " g..r',Cw- Q, '711/-te~ Nffi' ': I' il ,!f,,; " " H " I' ,I< ;, Ii I' " I , 1 '1 , ; I , U , I i , H'- " , , \ 1 I I'. 1 , I " , 1 I ." I.i. ,I )l, L \;, ! "j ; I/,I J 'i'l! n "~it' t "i.;-I \ I i.(; I i!'- 1'\ III 'j"\I, '1'./ 1,';(; " ';, I!, " ,. "Ii. ." i'i I ., HU'l'llll'l [, COMPI,!\,1 N'l' J U IllWI,IW\ U t~..., 'lI\,,'I!)(iil C\VH, ],01>1111<>1\, 1'/1, IIU\JUt.!t Ii, JIJ!1l1 (1li\'\'IIHH '1'0 CIlMlll,;rU,lIH\) CO, Hmmll"I;') 'I'UIU'I'IIY l'I, \1\\11I'.1111 \),';1 , lXJ(.'I:t-:'.\' 1'lIOg L2fdllJ MAllY I':, IIIlMl'lllU' I\~: 1l'\'lI',m 011 l'BNl'lS'llNMfll\ } COIlN'I''l 0\;' Ll\nIlNON ) ~lfl, Cllnrlul'l g, IHlllf111lfJr \)Uputy flhor.lfJ:, bo:l'n~l c11l+y sworn I\OCJOI.'CUl1\l \:0 Im~, dopmJU~j l\\1l\ ~lilYfl thnl:, \'to I>orvod l:ho \~.\.\'.h.\,n 1l0'.I':lcm I< COMPT,l\ItIII' IN Hl\Pl,IW:m upo\1 ~lllHY \;1, I\IlMPllHH18, \'.ho w.l.\'.ll1n nllH\ocl 1l'\l!'I~Nnllwr, by hunc1~.ng n t l'\1O Ill\d II \:' lClS\:od Clopy \:horopJ', to hor I pUl.'sonilny I on lIuc;Jlls t !i, 191)0, ut ?IOO O'OlcJIJI; P,M" lit 9110 l!1ust: Mllplo s\:root, PnllllYI.'/'\ (nOl'0l\9h), I,obllnnn County" pqnnuylVim.1.ll, <lnd by l""kJn\'J lil1Clwn \:,0 hor tho (Jonto\ll:fj 0:1: tho 11<111)0, " ,!3\~Dl;n to Ill1d fll\llfJor:lblld llllfpl.'o 1)\0 so lIw>wmHs, ._ (l/(i1,tCL ,;' )" ) If'"", D1WIl'l'Y mmRn~I" "~.. .!I~~ ,?~.,/""pl {j't v' , "'1..k'1'WI'.J/..e r ~ . /1<'.."-,_ f.HII~l\ll;lli' \ - ,(/?S .' tl1'ls 6th <:1ay of' ^uquui: I \.._-, 4 .-?<Ti~ .. 'r.';t;;,ii;;';j: '~f~:';\\. .;'I~_.u N NP.11.. ~ll\IH~I:ri, N,t., y II/hUe l.~bQfWI. t~:)MH(l';(\:ll.I' ;Ilt M, ClIlIlllln"ll hpll'~l '\'1'11 " \'(J(I" ~-. - ...~~- ,-.--'. ll,n" l!l~lIj Nr;>Cill'Y Pub1.\':1 8I\RHI~F'S COSTS IN lIDOVR lIdVunood uat,t:s p,11d on '7 n.9/9B Choo\-; No, Costs .1. noun: ad I Hofund I Chock No. 536B PROCIWlDINGS 2lG'IB i'lmount lImO\tn t Amount 'Iti,oO 4;l,30 'j?, '10 1111, Sho1' Hf:' s Costs Ahu11 bo duo and p,wablo whon aol.'V toos 1\1:0 parrol'l11od, lInd H. ahllll bo Iflw1:ul f'D1: h1111 to dOl11llnd Hnt! 1'oooivo 1'1'0111 tho party lIlHt:1t.llt.ing l:ho PJ:11000d.l.ngfl, OJ: IIny pUI'I:y Hablo for' tho Or.lSt.H I:hol'oof, Ill] unpn1d shod.ff:' s foos on tho smno bofol'll 1m shall bo ab:l.1.gatod by ll\\~ to 1i\llkoJ:CltUl'll thoroof, , __J1C1l1.~, lIot of JUlio 20, 1911"1 P.I" 1072 I I li l " "I I:" II" ' I:' i I " I , I, i ~,j"i~ L. .., 'l',jIIlOl:lw il, p,\:i\~\)I\ VS, , Mi~ry I;:, Ih"I/1111:.11]1I NII,.~:I%ll C,jvll ___19___ Now, . '/ /(.Il/\lll loll\>IIllOI\ .1 v_II Sl\F.lqH PI' C\!~1I1Iml.M"I) COlW\,Y,l',.\ 110 hmhr Iluplltl7.U lhu Shul'lfl'llf Clllllllr III mUlllu Ihls \\'l'lt,lhlslluP1lll1ll011 hulng mollu 111 thu I'c~llcsl lIull risk oflhcl'lnll1tlff, '"" ~ -" ? ,'/" ,.; /-"if!' -;".6'" !>;i;f(;1-"""""~C: / ..d,,'l' 'a. ,it '1. f........... J-': . , Shurlffof ClIl11hQl'lond COIIIIIY,I'II, . ' , " 'I' I' Ml1dn\'lt of SetTlec ., 1'9(/f)/)(, f- .<1- .;~, ,u.;:{. e 'vi Cf,'ili/ll.., ,/I f I'" IIpOIl_ ,/I/-t,. ,,' /.:~ , Ihn.",), '-/":" C.l , -"'7 I I I I .,""v / ~ j 01 (',j t' ":::11 :; /1/(1 ,(>.L.l!...51, ,/ (< (,./ to" ("(Co , 1;1- I . , " . h~' hnn1llng to ,{ t' I" " I.','t" .,.(. " ~./('I {/ I1I1OSI0dcop~'oflhool'lglnlll~ ;t;..!;'c'" v" C~'/(.!- /1' '" ~~ A." ,- Iho oOlllollts IhOl'Cof, Noll', within 19 ';,l' ,01 ',., , ^ ~'. /)/(,'(.111' , ,.2 " rt' _ o'clock ill '~1, un'oLl (ho " ,OJ If It L11e. (J) ;" I n 11'110 ood nnd II1ndu kllo\\n.10 /'1 Sn nnsworl, <);' ,.. I" I ': (, \ , ;7~~~P!k,.. '. - . , -..... - ,~"Jt Shorlrfof ~(..j '" ;1 .'" COllnl~, Pa, ' 0 , -"",:> COSTS /.:/, "I' ,~, '/- ~',j" c'l tt ,':; 1(,. 7J'.~ "'1.1"'; C;. I " \' 'i,il,' I,} ~I\'oru null sUhlcrlh.dbofrm ,(,t... '/1 Sf! Is (,. ~I;~ or~t.:.....f-19.il: , :1.'1.., '-CJ/ .A , . -\;;1f./I.........,.-(~,...... . N()l'\m~\1 Bt Al ] MNGY I. ~ IAIlNf H, NI'.M r PuNic l ~~i"lnl'l I !!111rUIl (;U'l~' ,ll\. _ L'" ::~III'IIIUIIll t 'PIrIU I\~'U( H ?(t(I{ SEI\\'ICE ~~~.nj s '1111" \C-I' I.' J'e' Il ..~,. I',_..!::~ A!'F!D.\ \'IT ~~:... ;-~,;?, )(1 --'-.., j ,0 /Jl I;' 'h. I; 7' C>,e#f~(. ~~r.l.? N "," , ,,.dc.,,/e... "t. TIMOTHY p, PI\M,lll\, PI.lllnlll'l' . IN Till! ('()\IHT (IF ('IIMMllN (IF ('\l~'lIl1\HI.^NP( 'I II INTY, . PI\NNHYI,V^NII\ v, IJK.,\IJrlH <'I VII, M(\In' II, IlllMPIIIW\H, P~lonlllllll ('IVII,I\(''I'lllN., I./\W N"I'lllN IN IWI'I,I\YIN JllWll~.!lMJ:'tL61'lt\Wlil~,..!'t!j.WJ:YI^,rt'l~l\I.6l~~ll~M.6'!:I.Y.I\j)IiFJi!'HiL\tl ^l'!l~_~.:s_~.Ul'!JJHi~~16JMli ., .' . ^NP NOW, 0\11110S llw Pol'oI\\llInt. Mllr)' I!, II\IIllphrlo~. h)' nlllllhrn\lllh hOl' . ~ll\lllsol, .lnhn.1. ('\1S11\n 11\11111I111. 1\~\llIlro.1\I1I111Ios Ihl~ !\IlSWOI" Null' MIIII~I'IMIiI'l1\III1\'U polpllsos IIl1d C'\l\11\lol'ullllms, ^NH\YEK I, 1'II1'11t11'11ph lis 1111111111011. 2, Tho dorolHllIllt's onl'lwl mhh'os~ I~ ()HO nllst Mllplo Hlrool, I'lIlm)'l'lI. 1~\lhIllWIlCn\lnt)'. 1'0nns)'lvlIllllI, 3, 1'11I'IIUl'lIph 3 Is IId1111110d, . PIII'II11l'llph 4 Is IIdl11l1toll " !' '. 4, ~, l'ul'II!!l'Ilph ~ Is IIdl11l.\lod, In l)ul'l, thul dof'ondunt IIOO\1l11pllnlod plulntlt'l'tn tho hlllldln!! hnllslng thu.lowolr)' ~Inl'o, I'lIl'ugl'lIph} Is 110111011, In PIII'I, thlll tho \Iol'onlllln( \VIIS pl'osont whon pluln(II'I'p\ll'ohu~cd (ho ring; 6, Pnl'll!!l'lIph (\ Is IIllmll(cll, 7, I'1I1'1I!!I'Ul'h 7.lslllhnltlcll, ,t!, ))ol'ol1llllnt, IInol' I'ollsonllhlo Itll'cstlgllllnn, Is wlthnll( knn\Vlollllo nl' 1111\1l'll1l1l1nn S\lfI1clolll (\11\11'11111 hollof'lIs tn t111l'tl'lIth nl'tho 1I\'OI'II1onl, " I), 1'11l'1I!!l'lIph I) Is IIdl11l1tClI, 10, 1)01'olldl\l1l, unol' I'ollsnnllhlo In\'Oslllllltlon, Is 11'111111\11 kl1\lWlollgo 01' 1111\1l'1nulltln sllfl1010ntlo 1\1I'In II hollof'lIs tl1lho 11'\llh lll'tho 1\\'OI'I)1onl, 'I " II, 1'1\1'1\!!1'lIph II IH IIdl11l((cll. 1.1 ., I '. '.1 n p ~-:. " J .. Jiii'n!\.lI~liL~ ~rl, 1111\11111I'1'1 II II PI' hn'lIklllullw wpdllill!l PIll\lll\~)IlWI1I, 1II11'IHPll Ilul~l\lllll\llhlll hp 11111 11111 Wl1llllwl' 111 rpl\11'I1 IIw UI1l!IIU\ll\wnl 1'1111\. ' n 11111111111'1', IIl1ur hl'Ullkilll! Ihu wulllllllB \ln1\lIlWll\unt, 111111 lIulunlllllll IIw rllll! WIIH IwrH III kPPI1' ~H, 11111111\11'1', IIlIul' hl'ullkhlL\ IIw wlHllllnu ull!lll1\unlUIlI, 111111 Ihu dululIlIl\lllll1 kll\lP IIW rlllulhr IwrHull; 111' III Hllllllw 1'I1l1\II1I\Olp PIIY Ihu hlllH dlll~lllllllll h\OllITOII 1Illlllllllll1111111UI11' 1l1l1ITIlIl\U, ' 1I11111111n; 1I11\l1' hl'\lllklnullw wulllllllu ulllJlI!luIlWIlI.llIII'Ulhu ulllllIlJ\lIlWnl 1'11l!lIlH 1IIlll11UOnlll11ollll1 !lln 10 IIw dul'ulldlllll, P\llulldllllt l'uUclI \llioll pllllllllfl'H Hllllull1UIlIH thlllllw UIlUIIUllllWlllWIIH hUI'H 10 kUcp, 01' Hull, IIH Hlw HilII' nt, ' \)ulUIIIllIl\t I'llllcd \lpl1ll plllllllll'l'H word Ihllt Hhu uould kllllP 01' Hull.lhu IllllllIllUI\1Unlrlllll, . I)olulldllut IICI1lll11lld pllllnlln'H \lI1col\lIltlol\lIll1ll1 ol'lIw lll\lllll!UIlWl\ll'llllJ'.. RUhHcq\llllltly, IIl1cl' plllllllllT llllVC thu 1'11111IlH 1111 11l1COI1l1I I hllllll lJllI 10 dulunlllll1l, HIlII IIl1uI' dul'ul1dlll1ll1uuoplud thu I'hllJ. plllhllllT "1IPIII'I)lllly uhllll!lcd hlH II1ll1d IIlld l'uql1uHtod I'cl\1rn Ill' 1111 \l11colllllll<~I1I1I11' 1\, tlw I'lllll, ^I\UI' hl'cllklnlll1lTtlw wcddll111 UI111llllUI1WIlI,lhu plllll\lIn"H 1I'0rdH 111111 lIulH ol'tullllllJ thu dulul\dllllt tn koup thu 1'11111lhl' hUI'Hull; 111' Hull 1110 PIlY duhtH ,.' IllclllTud, Ulll\Htll\1tulllIl1l1l1uOl1dlllolllllll,I\ Illllolul1dllllt, . . ~S, ^llullhl'ollkll1!lthu wudlllnll 0I111Il11lllllUl1l. pllllnlln"H Wlll'llH to t10lundlllll tll "kcup tho I'lllll" mllko II ulolIl' thllllhu 1'111!JWlIH 1111111 ulll1dlllol1111 gill Huh.lcol tll.lmpllcd ullndllllll1l'Ullllll'll1!lltH I'utllrll Ifthu 1111UTill!lU did nol tllko I1hlcu, .' " 21), .1(l, ~1. :\2, ~J, I, .. 34, " ii, 3(), ^ I\cl' hl'ullkil\!llhu wuddhllJ UI111Il11UlllUl1t, 1'11111111 f'I'H WIlI'lIH 10 dolundllllllo "kuop Iho I'll1ll" IIhl'll!llllcll 1111 hnpllud uOllllltlnl1l'uqull'll1g IIH I'ulurn Iflhu mll'ITllIllO did Iwltllku plllUO, . " , . , 1'1 EBALU2 n 1'II1'IIlll'IIphH Ilhl'O\111h 36111'0 IIlCOI'PIlI'\\tud hy rul\Jl'iJl1uo hUl'ol11 I1H Hu'II\ll'th lit 10l1gth, " WIIElRlllfOlUil, ll+Ain\:.tf.f l:l3apl3o\:fllny 1:13\1\\138\:fJ j:ht\t \:hil3 nonorAbll3 OO\\~t I3n\:~r An Or~l3r of COllr\: ~irl3oting Pafl3n~Ant to t n.13 An AmanqE1~ ,~laAcling .i.n JlooorclAl1oa wHh \:h[3 Rlllap of OO\l~'I:, or in ~ha .l\:arnAtivl3, d.i.fJmi8a Pafandpnt'a OPllnterolt\.i.m with prl3jmliol3, 1.J:.,_~ R IilltIM:t N I\RY,.uQD Jill ell' J: Q N_:ttL'J.'1I Iil.NA \i1 YRI!L.Q 1"...110. IP..J:O tLf' Q R l\...Mgl\l!L~pmQJ:I".:tJL.P.U.l\IU Nil PYRIiI1l\NIt'.Jt'Q...Pn ,R,e,p'"ul021l( b), ( J) 5, Vl\l"pgl:Ap!1l3 1. tlwough AIlel ,i.nohlcUng 4 A~e J.noOrl1prAteq here.i.n by referenoe <Ill .if Ilet for~!1 At length, 6, Vprl\gl'APha Pll, 55, 56, p"l, 50, 60, 61, 62, 6.'l, 64,(i"l, 69 ~t1d "10 refer 1;0 Alleged gJ.ftll Inpcle by DefendAnt to Pll\lnt.Lff, ,. , "I, Pl\rpgrAphll 54, 55, 56, 57, 50, 60, 61, fi2, 6~, 64, 67, 69 And 70 faU to Allege with speo.i.f.i.oil:y the nAture 01' daaodpl:.i.on of all~ged ,giftll mAde to P1Ain\:.i.ff, O,pl\rpgrApllll 54,55, 54!' 57,50,60,61,62, 63,64, 67,69 And 70 faU 1:0 l\lJ.ege ,Wil:h Bpeo,iJ.i.oity the ml\l1nel:' of deUvel:yof l\lJ.eged glftll to P1l\intlff from Defendant, " 9, VarAgl'aphll 54, %, 56, 57, 50, 60, 61, 62, .63,64, 67,69 And 70 fl\U 1:0 l\lJ.l3ge w,i.l:h Ilpeo.i.f:l:o.i.l:y as to when of. l\lll3ged gifts , were made or dElliVerl3d from I)efendant 1:0 PlainU.ff" 10, l,Jaragrapha 54,55,56,57,50,60,,61,62, 63, 64,(i7, 6~ and 70, fail ~o l\lJ.e(iJe with Ilpeo.i.Uoll:y who alJ.egedly prov.idad g.iHs to plaintJ.H by fa.i.ling 1:0 J.denl:.iry whether l)efsndAnt or.. hel' parenl:s made gifts 1:0 PlaJ.ntJ.ff, 2 ' , Ii , W"~RmFORm, plAintiff roapeot;ful1f requoata thAt thia' lIP1W~'flble QPur\: cliall1iaa Pef'enclflnt' a oonnl:el:\lJ:fd111a w.tth prej\.1clio13 " . Ancl enter j\.1c1gement agAinat pafenclant Ancl in f'Avor of Plaintiff' on All pO\II1ta t ReapePtf\.11ly aUb111ittecl, " , ~i~{~g~ ~~:~ei~%I~'ftTi'e Attornef far Plalntj4~ 1?7 i3, MArkel: i3t:reet ,,1',0, Do~ 95 Meohanioabur9, PA 17055 717,...697-7050 717-697-7065 (f'AX) ,,' IJat:el l3eptem\Jerll, 199B " '" ""It '" " I' I',' " 'I' " ,I; 'I, " " " " ,. II I" .." " " <<, ,,', ,.1 " " I; )i " 'I' " , ..\', " , I,' i. I', " 1'" " "II " " ,,t' , " 4 " " ,I ,', " ",1, I i~- ~II' ~', I ',I' " , rJif\\'C 1 \1f. \'OIU.!.H1Tltt~LOI\Il!i) t'OIl I\llgUMI'N'r (M\lU~ \)0 \:ypowrH\:Cln i11\U Q\1\:J1\l\:\:eQ ~n n\!p~..tCA\:!J I ' 'rP ~'I1j1: p"O'rlipl'lP'I'l\IW ot' cUM~~\1l,l\l'lP COIJtl'rv I PWllBP +j.a~ the w:\.l:h~.n'Il\Q\:\:Cli fClt:' j:ha nelll: l\F9I,~t c~rt.. ~_~~~~~~~_~~~~~~~~~~~---~-~-~---~~-~------------~~----__~_~--r--"~---------~-~-~------~ ,," OI\11'l'lOl'l Of alWI' . (Cl\l\:~ oAption 111\11> I: bo a tA l:eQ ~.('1 ('U-l.l l '1'imo\:hY P. pt:'a~bA, il' " (j':\.Ainl::\.f.f.l VI.. WHY E, llU\IlP\1dei3, (pef'a~ant I " No, . CivU 3968 _ 19 .2JL.--" 1. ~\:l1I:l'lll\fl\:tlll: to \)0 a~eQ (i.,o" pil1in\::Lf~'" IlpHon for nOW trial. defendant'a d!lll1\ll:'rUr \:6' Cl<1l1P1a:\.nt. e\:o.ll .. . Plaintiff'S preilmlnary objections to Defendant's countercln:\.ms 2. lden\:l.fy collnael who will m:gUB cllQel (II) for. p1n:\.ntiffl, lIndl:eW C. Sheely, \!~aquire I\ddr.eaal P, O. !loX 95 127 S. Market street Moohanicaburg, PlI 17055 (b) for dofondanl:1 John J, cosmo 1I011and, ESCjuir(l, /lddteael p,o, ).loll 11513 Harrisburg, PlI 17100 " 3. I w:LU notHy aU part:\.ea in wd.\:illg wll:hin t\o,o dlWe tlul\: this case 11llB been lJ.s \:ed fdr ar.g\.rnBn t. 4. I\rg\ment court lJ.ltel oo\:ol)er 7, 1990 " ,~c~ "00_ '''Pl,!nt! , . ,----- bated I " " I.' " " " " " " I' j " ','1' , , ", " ,. " " I' " " " " " " I,' ,I, I II" "I; ',. , " " " " " , 1'1 ;, ',(',-\ " , i",\ ,1.1 1 " ". "I'! , " I" I'! ! i(I , I " " i '~\ " " " " " '.. " 'I. ,. " t' 1,1 , , " " " ", ,. , ,; ;';" !; " , j; 'Iii ;,1, " " , '" " " " ,', \' ;t> I, " " ,. ,I " ,. II I " 'I, } /~; i: \,', !'!1 l~ 'Ii I~t' '.1' " \1 " , ., .I' " " .. " " " " " TIMPTIIY p, PHI\7.IlI\, PIIIII\\lI'I' IN Till! ('DUln of cOMMON OF ClJMnHI~I,I\NP C'O\JNTY,' P!!NNflY1N I\NII\ , ' , y, UH.3%H CIVil, I, MMY Il, IIIJMPllIWlfl, P\l IUIll hill I CIVil, M~'I'ION" 1.1\ W ACTIoN-IN l~nPI,IlVIN " J2Jl.ELlliI21\.~TIUMll~UEU.A~J:iWUR,.NLLWM4xWIIL^r~EJRMM'JYJjJ2HIillWiilll I\.MI1..CQU~Tllll.CLI\.JMs..e.UlISL!ANTJDh\JI.,c,l!.J'ill.,10~8.(\,1.)_(.l) , I\NP NOW, \lOI11\lH lIw P\llul\lllll\t, Mllry H, 1l\lll1phrl~H, hy 111\11 Ihl'll\lgh h\ll' \lOIIl1H\lI, ,Iohl\ J," COHl11l1Hpllllllll, IlHltlllr\l, 111\11 I1I\lH Ihlli ^l\wIHI\ld ^"HW\lI', Now MIII\OI'IMl1rll1l1tlw,POfoIlH\llllll1\l COIIl\to1'011l1111H, ANB...WllR " I, PIII'IIH1'lIph , IH lIlhnlltoll, ~, Tlw lIolulllh\lItlH (1(11'1'\10\ nlllll'oHH IH UHO lln~\ Mnplo Slrool, Pnlll1Yl'l1. 1,\lhlll\l1l1 CUIIl\ly, POI\I\HylvlIl\ln, . ), 1~lIl'ngl'nph 3 IH I\(lmlltoll, . 4, Pn1'llHl'nph 4 III IIdll1ll\cd, :I, Pnl'lIgl'nph :lIH mhnltlcd, 11\ pnl'l, thnt IIclul\lImll ncoOlnplIl\lcd plnll\tllT to tho hulldll\/;! . hOUHll\g tho .Iowoll'Y HtOI'O, Pllrngrllph :I III 1I01\1ml, III PlIl't, thllt tho dolUl\dnllt WIIIl pl'OIlOl\t whol\ plllll1tlf'fp\lI'ohllllod Iho 1'11\1.1, l'III'\lgl'lIph 6 III lIlhnltlcd, 6, 7, H, , u, 10, " " P\\rllgl'lIph 7 IH ndmlllod, '(:lolundlllll, nl1ol' l'Onllollllhlo htvollllgntlon, IH wllhoul knowlodgo 01' 1l1tht:ll1ntloll " HlIl'llolont to Ihl'll' II holiofllll 10 tho trllth of'lho IlVOl'lncnt, Pl\l'lIgrllph l) IH tldllllltcll, . ()olol\lIl1l\t, 111101' 1'0llHOllllhlo Il\vcHtlglltlol\, IH wllholltknowl\1dgo ot' tnthl'mlltlon Hul'llI.,lol\t to thl'llll1 holloI' tiH to the tl'uth of tho IIVOI'IUOI\t. II, PIII'II!.J1'lIph II III mhnttlcd, . " 'I' I.WJ=.UEE :\7, flnnllJl'llphH Ilhrollgh :1(1 lII'pII1CIlI'POI'l\lc(1 hY'l'ul\il'lllwc hunlll1l1H HIJII\lrlhnl IClllJlh, 3<<, 'Pplul\lhllll u~lwllllp\I I1Wlluy Ilnd hWIII'I'u(1 IleblH 111 pmvlllll1n pIlllnllfl'PUlHllliollll1 lJIIlH 1I1111111clpllllpI1 Ilrl11l1l'l'lngp, ,:\1), fllnlnllrl'lI'nH nllvlHPd h>, 1I1li dpl\JIHhllllll\l1l IIw nl\ll1~y Hpul1lloll'lIl'dH lhe lI'u(hlllllJ , pl'PPlIl'lIlinllH 1I'11~ II 11'1,l11(lIl1lJ !l11l III Ill\' plllll1lll'l', , " '10, Thu plllll1lifrwlIH IIWIII'pllll!1 lhu u~pelHIIIIIl'eH WUI'U IlUHliiwod wUh nl1nllll\lhcd \llllHlIllon Pl'ucPdul11, n CllIHllllnn whl\lh wnH IW\'CI' mcl, " 41, Tlw plllhlllfr I'ccclved uPIHllllnl\ll1 !JIIlH 1l'lll11lhu dclullllnnl, 42, ,011 111'11110111 .lllI1u Iii, 1997, dulun(IIII1(PI1I" $31000,00 III PIIIHhllrgh 'H Cll'lInd "nlllll Ihu Pl'hlI'Y, 4:1, PUrUl1dlllll'H U'lPUI\,IIII1I'U {lIlI1Hlillllulln ulll,1dlllOl\ll1 !JIll 10 plnll1lifrpl'ovhlod 111 UIlI1I\llllplnllnl1 1ll'l11l1l'l'lngu, 44, 011 Ill' nholll,luly I, 19(J7, (lelundlll1l pllld $595,00 1(1 Ilull1;.o: MUl110rlnl Chnpul, 45, "IJulbndnl\l'H C~pel\dlt\lI'U wnH pl'ovldud Ip plnll1l1ffnH n opndltlol1nlglH 111 cllnlumpllllllll1 ofllllHTlngu, 461 011 Ill' nholll,lul>, 711997, dulul1dlllll pllld $750,00 10 All. Pro Vlduo, 47, Doful1dll111'H uxpulllIIIIII'O cOI1HIIIII1ud II 01111(1111011111 glH 10 pllllnlll'l'Il1 Pllnlolnplnliol\ or 111l1rrlngu, 4R, 011 or IIholll AUgllHl' 15, 1997, dolul1dlll1l pllld $'11 li,:lR 10 I<lmhul'ly'H Ihl' IillhhluH, IhltllUH, 10nHIII1g gohlulH nl1d II onko (OppUI', 49, -,?olul1ll11l1l'H oxpondltul'o uOI1Hlltlllod'lI u0l1dlllonll1 gin 10 plnll1llffpl'Ovldud In OOl1lul11plnllol1 orl1ll\lTlngu; , 50, 011 (ii' nhollt A IlgUHt 20, 11)97, dolundlllll pllld $H5,02 (0 13011 Fnlllkllll 'H nil' I'lhhonH, . hrlduH nlll!llll\lnuH, hl'nHH ulIndlu lop; nl1d glluHI hnok, . , 51. ))olbnlllllll'H oxpolldllul'o oOIlHtI\Ulcd II oondltlnl1l1l gin 10 plllllltlfl'pl'nvldod In Cnlllul1lplnllnn of'I11I1ITlngo. . 52, 011 01' IIholll.lnly ;l0,1997, dofundlllllllllld $1 oO,on dopnHIt 10 woddll1g phnlngl'lIphul'. 53, lJulundllllt'H OXpolllllltil'u cllriHtlltltod II C0l1dltlnill11 gin 10 1lIIlIntll'l'pl'Ovldcd In onnlcl1lplntlnnll f 1l1111TIIIgo, " 71, PO\\JI1\IIII1I'H o~P\lIHII\I1I'\l cOI1Hlh\I\\lIII\ \1011\11111111111 gin 10 pll1l11I1ITpl'ovl(11'11111 \Jol1l0l11pllllhll10r Il\IIITIIIUO" 72, 011 \11' IIh\1111 Novpm\l\J1' 25, 1lJ\J7, Iluf\JII\IIIIlI plIlll $1l(l,(lO Ihl' \1\lIMl'pl\JuooIIIlIII\JH, , \JllnlH, w\Jlhlllllll1lhllll\, v\1llv\JH, lI11dulllHH ulohuH, n IMolllllIlll'H o~pol1dlllil'O 11\111Hlh\llud II u\11ll1l11011111 ulll 10pll\ll1lllTp1'\lvhlCIIII1 uOlllcmphllloll \11' 111111TII\Uo, 74, 011 01' l\h\1\1\ Doooml1ol' I, 11)\17, 11\llullIhllll pIIIII $67,14 Ihl' compllel IIIHo orwPlldll1u 11\\IHI\l, Ihlll1k YI1\1 ullllio I1l1d Illvl\llllolllllll\\pluH, . 75, Dol\JIll'IIIlI'Ho~pOI1l1l1111'0 \lOI1Hlh\l\OIIIl 0\111\1111011111 uln 1\1 plllhllllTpn1\'lllollll1 c\111lompllllh1,11 nl' I11I11Th\u\l, 7(1, 011 01' IIholl\l)coomlwl';10, 11)1)7, durolldlllll pllld 1\ $10,00 dOPOH\1 \111 p11l11l1lff'H \\I~odo, \ ,i I HS, Dol\lIldl\nl oxpondod IIppl'l1xll11l\lol>, $3,140,4Cl on ulIndlllllnlll gll\H I\H II gin clInlmol h>, IInd hOlwoon dorondl\nlllnd pllllnll!'!', n Pol\Jlldlllll'H o~I1\lllllll\lr\l CIlI1H11I\l\od,1\ 01l1\l1l11011111 gin to plllll1lllTpl'\1vlllullll1 c\1lllompllllllll1 or 111111Tll\go, " 7H, 011111' lIhll\ll ,11111111\1'>' H, 1 ~I)H, dolul1dllnl pllld $:2,400,00 10 PIllHh\lwh 'H Grlllld "1I1l1l1 tho Prior>" ' ,. 79, Polundl\111'H OXllOllIlIlIll'o ulInH1It\ll\ld 11 01l1l(1I11011111 gin In pllllntllTprllyldodln 01l1110mplllllllnlll'mllrrlllgo, ' HO, 011 (11' IIhll\lI,II\I1\\I\I'>' 26, 1l)l)H, dolundl\l1lplIl(1 $100,00 for ongl\gol1lOnl phlllllgl'l\pllH, I HI. Pol\JndIl111'H 'oxpcndl\mo ollnHIlt\llod 1I ollndlllpnl\l gin 10 pllllnlllTpl'lIyldod In 01ll\lol11pl1l1l1l1l of' 1lllll'l'llIgo, H2, Polul1dll111, MlIl'>' II\\lnphl'l\lH, hOHtO\vcd o\1l1dltlpl1l1l glflH IIpol1lhoI111l11111!'rw\1l'lh IIPI11'oxII1111101>, $1)(lD,46, . H~, \)OIUlldlll\l, Mill'>' Ihlll1l1hrtoH, through dlllgonl ortbl'lmltlglllud hol' IlunlllgoH h>,. " IIpprnxll11l1tol>, $S,H60,OO, ' H4, l?olulldlll)l oXl1undcd IIppl'oxhl1ulol>, $;1,140,:i6 on oondltlonlll gll\il In U\l1110lllplullon 0!'1I1UI'l'llIgo, ' " I\, H6, '1'110 glf\H glvunlo pllllnll ff WOI'O Huh.loot 10 tho hnpllod uondltloll thllllho>, ,you'd ho I'llllll'nod hy tho plllllltl!'l'whonovol' Iho ongllgonlOl1l WUH dlHHolvcd,I 'i " , 'I . . ,/' 130, P\lI\llllhllll'H V~pVI\\IiIlII'O Illll1HlllllI~d II \lIlIlIlillpllIIlllll\ III plllillll1'1' pl'llvlllollIII VllI1I01\1plllllllIl11rI11I11Tilll\\l, .. 131, 011111' 11\111\.1,1 PIIOIlIllIHlI' 30, I Ill)'/ , 1i\11~111lhll\l pllld II ~ I 0,00 dppllHllll1l plllll1111'1'H III~OIIIl, . 13~, PIII\llllhl1l1'H ~XpoI1l1l11l1'l) IlllllHlllllllld II Illl11l1l111l1l1llul II III phlllllll'l' pl'l1Vhl\ld III 111l1l10I1lplllliIlIlIlI'I11I1ITIII/W, . 133, lIl1lll' 111111111 ,IIIIlIlIII~' H, .11)IlH, d111\J11I11I1l1 pllhl $2,(I011,OIlI1l I1II1Hh\ll'Uh',H 01'11I111111111111 Iho 11l'hll'Y, . 1 ;111, 1l01~I\IiIII\l 'II o~pulldlllll'O ollllHlIlIlIod II Ollllllllllllllll Ulll III plllll1ll 1'1' Pi'\\Y1111l1111l PIlIlI011l\l11l111l1l1l1'1I11I1TIIII\ll, ' 135, 1111 IIi; 1I\11l1l1 ,11I11l1I1l'Y >1(1, IIJ!lH, IM\llldlllll plllll $\ 00,00 Ihl' OIll\IIl\IlIlWIlI phllllllll'lIphH, 13(11 .. Ilol\llllhllll'lI IIxpol1l11l1ll'U 0111111111\1101111 ollllllll11111111' gl1\ III plllll1tl 1'1' pl'llvll\ud' III \llll1ll1ll1pllllhllllll'IIIIIITIIII\ll, ' 1:1'/, nlll\111I11I1lt, MIII'Y I 1IIIIlllhlloH, hOHlllwul1 ulllll\lllolllIlllll\H \IPllll thu plllll1tll'l'wul'lh IIPPI'IlXII11I1IIIIY $IJ,()(IlI,Mi III Pl'llplIl'llllol1lhl' Ihull' wulIlIllll\, 13H, \)UI\111I11I1lI, Ihllllluh I1lllltllllioi\, hllH lulllloul\ 1)111' IhI11H1gUH to IIPPl'llxll11l1luly. $3,1110,llh, 131)1 Ilol'onlllllll, MillY 1IIII11phl'IoII, IIlIvlHml plllll1tll'l' Ihllt Ihu UXpOI1\\II\l1'IlH uOI1HlIl\lI\l1\ l\IHH 1\'lll11lho 1I\\luudIl111 Illlhu p11l11l1l1T111 00Iltolllplnt!01l01'111I\1Tillgu, " \1\0, Tho IIol'ol1dll111lH pnlolllH mlvltwd plnll1t!I'I'lhll\ thu uxpql1dl\\II'OH cOI1HIIIlltod gll\H I\'om tho dol\ll1dllllttll (110 plllll1lll'1' 1\1 Olll\l\lll1pllltllll1 ol'll1l1l'l'llIl\O, 141, 1'111111111'1' WIlH 11\11110 IIWIII'O 01111 l'ow llUCIlHhlllH Ihllt lho U,\pUIII\itUI'OH horn by dol'ondlll1( uOI1HtI\\IlUd UII\H 11'11111 1101'ol1dllllt tll plllllltll'fll1 ullntull1plllllol1 ol'mlllrlngu, \112, IJvI'ol1dlll1l'~ 4XplllUllllll'OH tllWIIl'IlH hol' IInd plllll1t1t'1\i \yodllll1l\ UXPUI1HUH cOI1HtltUIUll1l Ulll Cll1111'1I01 hy IIIHI hotwuol1 dol'ol1dlll1t lIl1dplllll1t1rl', 1,13, 1'IlIIIItlI'I'kllow 111' HhllUhl hllvo kllllwnlhllllho glllH WUI'O bUH(o\Vud 01l1l111mpllcd Cll1Ulltlll11 111111 Iho plll't10H wllnld wud, I.I'\. 11111111111'1'ul1l1l1lol'lIl1y d\lcldcd 11111 III 111l1l'l'Y lIol'ul1\llIl1l, 1,15, IllIIIIIllITlll1l1l1lol'l1l1y OhllHO III hrullk lllTtho ul111llgul11unt bulwuul1 hlll\HUlflll1d dlll'oIUIIII1I, MillY IlIullphl'iiJH, l'Iei, Tlw IluIUI1\IIII1IIS gills IY\lru pl'\lvldull 10 Ihu plllll1\ll'l' iiII' Ihu plll'pllS\l, whioh cl1l1lllol1l)' 1l\lIl\lhl\l\'ulllll1ll 11111I~od h)' Ilw 110\l\llWI1!!\l 1ll'l1\lIl'l'illllU, 147, PII\l III plllliHln's solo Ilu!!lsllll1 10 hl'\lllk olT Ilw ull~II11!!I11l)I1\, Ih\l \1HI1TIIIllU 11111 \111\ Inku pll1~\l, 14H, Tlw u:>>pUl1di\lIr\lS il1l\\IUSIlol1 cOl1sll\\llcIIl!ll\s 0'0111 Ilol\lll\llInl. Mill')' 1 h\111phrius, 10 plnll1lll'fll1c0I1I\ll11pllllil1n \ll'l1\lIrrlllllu, whluh hOOllllSU Ihu Impllell \l011l1l\l1111 Wlls n\ll I1wl, III'\l \olw rU\\ll'I1oll, 141), Pulundlllll's u>ipul1ll1l1lrus WUr\lI1wl\lliS II gll\ 00\111'1I!!1 h)'1I1111 hulwuonllolumlllnllll1\l pllllntll'r. I ~Ol . Tho Ilol\lndnl11 Is 11\11 III Ihllll Ihlll \lw II1l1l'rhmo did \1111 \lIku plllou 1\1\11 Is ul1ll1lu\1 10 I'oslltlltlon IIII' l!lns pl'llvldud Iho pllllnlll'l'wllh Iho hl1pllod \l011l11l1011 0l'n1l1lThlgo, . Whol'ulhl'o. \)ulul1dll\1I, Mill')' 1IIII1\phl'Ios, I'llspoolt\'llIy 1'01\110sIs Ihllllhis 110\101'1Ihlu COlii'I H\1ds Ihlll o\VllUl'~hlp oflho ullglll!onWl11 rings I'osls wllh dulundllnllls II \VIIS pl'ovldod us 1\11 lI\1oondlllol111Il!11I hy plull1l1fl', 1\ll'lhol', Ihlll Ihls Il0nol'lIhlo COllrt Ol1lul' .Il1l1gol11ol1lll1 I\IVOI' 01' dofundlll1t. MIll')' \-I\ll11phl'ios, 111 Ihu 11\110\1111 ol'lhl'oo Ihollsund 0110 1\\1I1I11'0d Ihl'l)' dolllll's 1Il1\llhlW' six uUl1ls ($~,140.4(i) IInd 1Il!lIll1s1 plllll1\1n~ Tll110thy \), \)I'lIZhll,lII111 thl' oosls und 1111)' olhol' 1'01101' . Ilool11od .Illslllnd ollullllblo, , \)11101 Oolohol' _L, 199H RospO\lll\tll)' snhl\ll1lod: " "..., ~ ,) Ur-t?~ ro 11.1, Co Sill l.lol~I~it;'I)IIIt.o . lol'lloy Ihl" )otl)l\dlllll ,0, Bn:>> 11513 HlIl'l'lshUI'l!, PA 171 OH.151J (717) 774.2331 ;\(" . : I I' \ I :i~\1 , ~ "';' " '" TIMPTIIY p, PI~A?,nA, P 1111111 I'/' iN '1'1111 COll!!T 01" CoMMON ell" c\'JMIHlHI,ANP CoIINTY, PI~NN~YI- VANIA v, I)H-39(lH cIVII_ " MAIW H, If\1MPIII~IHH Ppl~11111\111 CIVII- ACTION -1,1\ w.. AC'I'ION IN IWPI-IJVIN Cllll,'l]ElCA:rJl.QI!..SURY1CH I, Johl1 ,I, CpNI1H1llollllml, j~sll\ll!,p,lwrllhY cortll'y lhllt I sll!'wd 1\ Imo IHlllllolTOol copy ol'tlw Nollco, Plll'ol1lll1nl's Al1l1lndlld Answor, Now Mllllpr/Mlirll1l1l1vo Ppl~I1Sos IIl1d CI1l111lo!,ollllllls III 1'01'01'\31100 to II1llnhnY\lIlIl\lol1 b~ Ilrsl ChINN, pnstllUlll'rO-l'lIld, 11l\{Jl1lho Ihllowll1UI I 'I 'I t\l1drow C, Hhlloly, I1sq\llro 127 S, Mllrko\ Strool p,o, !lox 95 MCllhllnlosh\ll'U, P A 17055 , I-j , , 11 ;, I \ ;; ,. , 'I .t,' " I; I' i(', .~ -\ ill '11 I' ;I': 'I, " " , ii, " , ,. " " i! Ii i' .. " " P;!i " ", " " , ' " .j' .. " "' " .. " " " " " J'I' " j' "', " " 'I UI " ITI .", ;"'1 'I I .--{ " 'I" ~ : i: I,Ti I') ;~ " n "II J : "} 1;1/, '''''1 . " i._~ 1.1'1 11_,. (;:.,-, :\,1[':J .1'1'11 ~ "I !:li .." I !' j, C.-) ,~',' '}'.I") r-;, (,'1 ""I ,,' ; ,:o,j' ! t,i._! '. ~:{: :, c__"', l r<l,., , ;Ji. .~; ,':: ~::'I .-.t, 1: '! i' ! Ii " , I " ! I " I I ,". " l. " " I- I I " I , " " I " \ ,I , . , \ IJ " ;'1 " " " " "I; Ii ,- Ii "It ., j' " 'I! l' " " P \1 ,. ,i' '\ ;J ,1.1 1; I', ),t., ',. '(I '" " _I " .' 'It j j1r. ~;J' I~ :'I'-~~_~::;jl , , -; ',} ~i;, \\ t .\~., ',' " , 1.\, ,I .,''( 1 '~i:" .\~\ - ,; ,,!, 11t:!'Jt, _; I . . 1 \~ ';1,;( " ~. . i ',' A~: "i'f ':l,'t. i' I ~(>,. )/' ~:"..,\~, 1 .,/) .\,.,;_1 , _ ,- ,~\' ",.1';4 "'("f 1: \ .' FIJ - olc, ,~ , , d'"', , ' ~~'\l'.;; ,j" '; .J,i'~ '-,j'" ":Y,l. " i' ,I. "II..; ,'~ ,v'l .' }' 'lj I . '_;/'~f~'it' 1''1, <,'I,., "I" :""1' " ,!tt. \ .\ ;'i \I il '~;i': \, "..., I;' .....' " " !tN~'''1 ' \11. A,' '\: '( " ",!-' i~"t/' " 1,( ., ,'I' ",.~ , \ 'I ,.' ',' ", " v, Hl 'rim OOIl1\'I' Ol~ COMMON l'lJI~I\13 cw CIlNllIDIU,l\NP OOUN'l'Y I P1DNNI3YlNl\N1l\ 9[1 - 39li[l 'l'H1O'1'IIY P t Plll\~ Ill'll P111in\:Hf, Ml\RY m, HUMPIIRlma, pefenclnn\: cwn, l\O'l'lON - Ll\\~ l\C~ION IN R~\1LmVIN P.LI\tNT U" \1'.~~L.P.RIUII M J:Nl\IlY..O n III!IO.TIO N fLTLD I!I f'.1!I N DANTIJL AMI!l NO I!I 0 ANIiWI!I RI_,N IllW.MA T\L'1!l R_.l\NILl.1.QUNTIllRClLl\ IMIi.. P_URliUl\ NT_.TO_.Pl\..._R.& ,p NQ,_,.l,Q a.a.clI). Plt\,i-ntiff I 'l'imotlW p, Prt\~bfl, by t\nQ through 00\1I1ael of l\nQrew a. aheely, IDl3quire, hereby Hlea t,hel3e l.'1:eHminnq' Objeotions to the /lll1anQecl Answer, NeW MCl1:ter/1\ff!rmat.tve oefen13813 tlnQ COllnt8l-pldlllS f11eQ by Defendant I Mnry In I llumphries, Clncl Plaintiff respeotflllly stt\tes CIa followsl '1, PlClintHf commenoed tile flbove-ot\ptiol1eQ mt\tter em or about ,TIlly 15, 1?90. 2, On or ClbOllt Augu~t 25, 1990, DeJ;enclt\nt filed an Answer, NeW MCltter with AffirmClttve Oefen138s nnd CI Counterolaim t\gainst Plaintiff . 3. On or Clbout September 14, 1990, plaintiff f:.i.led Preliminary Obje(1tions to Defendflnt' s 1\nswer, New Matter with Affirmt\tive ()efense" and COllllteroH\im. 4, on or about Ootober 11 1990, Dsfendant fileQ an 1III1ended 1\nl3\~el-, New Matter wH.h Affirmative Defenses t\nQ Cout'lterolaims against Plaintiff. ,,, I III I, PRllllll MINAR Y.QP JIIHJ\I.' UmulN..\I.'IlILNl\\I.'URIY..QF',l\.l'!IUMURlllllR PIHUII1I\N\t1.J~gp Rd\,Q,.P,...UI :ilR.( bl. (40) 5, P/,\r/,\urt\plw It:hrplluh t\nq ino~\l~U.n'i1 4 /Wl'l inoqrpOl"t\~13q Iwrein p~ ref131'l'lnOe t\U .i.f aej: .fOl.th <lj: ~l'lngj:h, 6, pt\rAgrAphe 37 thro\luh 09 of Pl'lfenqAnt'a P~e<lqing entitled "~etMoff" fAile to eet torth t\ o<l\la~ of APtion \lpon whiqh re~ief pl\n pe 91"Ant13ct Ae tho 1\11891\j:ionl3, fAil to I3tAj:ethAt cteUvel:y of f\n~ i t13m WAa mAq13 j:o plAintiff, 7, PA1'agrAPhl3 37 thro\lgh 09 of D13fenctant'aPleading entitleq "~et-off" faill3 to l3et forth /'l CAllae of I\otion \.Ipon which 1'eli13f oan be g1't\ntect 1'113 the allegt\tiona fail to I3tate thl\t I\ny benefif wt\a cQnfer1'eq upon PlAintiff, 0, Pl\1'agrl:1pha 90 thro\lgh 150 of Pefenq<lnVa neaqing entHll'lcl ," I, "131:eA~h of GUt contl:l'lct". faila to aet forth t\ oaUl3e \1f acUon . upon whioh relil'lf can be grAnted, 9, Pl\rAgrl\phs 90 thro\lgh 150 Of Defendant'a Pleadiriq'ontitlod /ll3reaoh of G.i.f\: Contrl\ot/l fl\ils to set forth a OI\UsE1 of 1\0Uon upon whioh relief can be granted aa j;he alle9aHons fAil to stl\te thAt delivery of any Hem wal3 made to Plllintiff, '10, PI\ra9rapha 90 thro\l?,h 150 of Defendant's Ple~ding ent.i.tled "I3reach of Gift Contrapt/l faila to aet fdi:th a oauae 011 <lotion' upon wh.i.ol1 relief OAn be grl\nted f01"hreaoh Of an <I],leged g.i.ft contrl.\ct due to the laol~ of an~ alleged. benefH oonfel"red upon Pll\intiff I the laclt 'of any alleged ml\tual oonsideration anct the laolt of any allege~ ml\tual oonaont, ;, " ,,1 " " H it , ,. ., if I' " /. " ;' 'I '\ " ,I /,1 '., " it , , j, " ". H '" Ii' " " ,', I " " f~)' '" /:n c? 'i'! 'il I' 'j , . (:') ,;, 'f .', (" t.') ,. rUI;~i '-i i,'I& 'i \; " ti '!J(' h.) 'IJ H (h,I.~ tJ\' " " i"'t:, " ';)fL, "'I " ;! ,-:",",'- , "tl :1. ~ p ~1:' 1"'1 :.r~ LJr.') ;, I':'!C'I r.- ""11 I' ~l)' (''... " .. '1,1 " , ..;. ~, '~J ... ~~ " " ",c;: (;.'I " H I I' " H t I' ;1 'I' " ., ;,1 " " ,. " ;, ,; i, :,' I' ;," " " " " 'i " " H " " ", " " " i,' " " ,. " I J! , ,. " " " f' ilt ii' " " " ;. ji j< ", ii, H " H I"';j" " 'I, II j! " 'I' I' " 'I' 'II Ii " " ..-, " j' !' ,.' " j, '/ I, " ii' i! ;0 I, !! i' '; ~ ; " " r~ 1 , " " " " " !! " I ", ,I" " 1\ " p .. i' I' i; " t,:, f","l ~<\ .\ IJ i'l " -'I' I~l 'J "", Mt)j'I', r,-'') r "'I l.J~I'i.] '-1 :,1....., :~ [Ij lrJ~ f .: l'-l ' c;i'L,;,'j, 1''' Il~ " ..l~ { ; ! :...~I pi '" (') ;(:1 J,;Cl h., ~ ~..',.. . ..r.~ ) " \"\ l.'~ ii' '~j"l .I"~ r'" ,j' '. "'.i " .~ '~J ..., , 1 -', (:::J '..... "", ", , .. ,. H, I I , I' I"~ .. ') J, " ii' I " "t, 'I, Ii " {.j' ;-" d, ;, Ii, II " I' " I, I ,h II 'f I' I' 1"1 I' " " " 'H f, ;Ii: " I' ,); d' Ie Fl, Ii ii I' , f' I , '-I, ,Ii 1'" ,i q If " .. " " I' " 'of< I' "" I, "" if I' I' " " I' '" I' " n ~ ;-~ i ! ~ iI' i; i I'. ! , i (/'1 t,',> , I" ;:1 'I " " :td . ~, " ,''','' ,: ~.), I f',),; j ,~ I" " (..) " I' ,~ ,,'1 " I, I, I' , " " 1/:'1 I...t:) "'1 rr I;>: Cl '\I ([I ,,:11 , ':'l',) "'1 ( ~l(J "I"J , . ~l;l 1r'l) ,(-:/11 ii;l 1\1 j...... ", ;I' fl 1<,