Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-03993 ii I. ,. " I' ;. " !\ " ;, ,. '1\"," ~ ~ ",,' ), ., i.) ~.', ~. " ", " " ,;, 'j, " I! .", I; " I' 't., " 'J iJ I'I~ '" 11 'W t ~ '. t'l ,~ I ~ , ~ ,~ ~ ~ ,~ ~ '. "" " ';. " " ;; 11 ,~~:t i~ "i. ,~,- \"/; Ii I' " "., "../ :k i,;'~:f .>,J' I,);f ',~. ': !J Ii} -,.'?~ "'(~{. I' " ,\~; .~ :;'t!, 'lh, ::';,(.l ~ ( :M 7'" i'i .!)~il ',.'iJk1'- " " ,.h "It :'}l> }, '/'. " ,. ',I." " " 'j, '" '" " ;1 " fi I' ," ,. ,i' " .) , . iJ ,,;J' ('Ii ;\l~;:/ \\lll'l I'~" Iri', ' ;." it ,fJ~1 ";'~:'-i;'~s: I/.) .' '~fl '::J.'II: ':,I~!Z Ir~n~ i4,~ ;(.11 'W'~y , '-J l' i/(!\~, .!J~ . :".~ W It "'--;, 'Jl' '{ft ,"lh "it! J)1 ,l,i jJ r ,Ii " " ,. ;, ", ;, ,. " ii ,,' '" " il ." " " i! i;; " ;" '" I" " , , u .. " {' .. " ,. " , " " , ~'i Ii)] fIg }~~~ (". /;,,( " ,- " \, " ~" " i' " \i " . " 'Ie . .0 ... '-.J' i if, ~. ~ f'C)' ~ ()- " i; " " " Ii' "~I' " " ,/ ,. " ;it " ,~' MYOIIAK mWl<I,I~ & WmI,jODH, P. C, nYI Riohard 13, DatamAn, ~r, Idan\:tfloation No, 1 61131 2~0 ,9ol1th I3ronc:j stroot mleVEll\\:h l~loor Philadelphi", P1\ 19102 (2:1.6) 73l;-33;1.6 JOHN P; MI\RSlll\I.r., <ll)d '1'IIBI\NI\ MI\RSll/\LI., l)er huabal\d 63 Circle View Driye .lyaburg, P/\ :1.7024 v, HI\LPll JOHN Rli1HM, 4R, ;103 rOl-ae Road poiling ,springs, P/\ 17007 and MILL.R & SONS, rNC, n09 Boi,ling spl"ingl3 ,Road Mechanicl3burg, PA 17065 alld PAm. P, MOURA'mDms :\.110 S, DuPont Highway Apartment 427 New Ca~tle, om 19720 HOTIOI "VII. "'" ..... ..... to ~" "'" ..,~ II ""04 ...,.., 1M ,tit,., If! h~'~ I. ,~, '''''n'''1It ~,", ,.. ""'~ ,.., ..I..... ..I~,. t"rol, flOt ok" ,!lf1 ,~~ ,...pl'"" ,.. ..u.. "", .,"", ~, "'I."", , """" "',.",." ,."...., .. ~, ."......, ,.. .,.... 'o' .111... ",'~ ,~. 10." ,.., ..,,_ oo ,~,tk'" '" I~ ,It,... "I ,..,~ ,'.".., ,.. h.." WI"'" ,Ilt,,, ,,,_ Ir<I I" '/1-., 'N ......., ,...tt4 ""~M1,._.04' ...,...., ..., lor "1"" ....... ,.. h "', '"'' wI'h..., I."..., ...", ,.. ,., ..."', ,..,.... .. t~. ....~...I .. 'oo .., ,M"', ,101.. .. Itllr' ~""... ~r ,,.. ,...."". V.. .., h... WI'''', .. "n,.,,, .. "h" ",hh ..,.,.1.., ,. ,.., "V041 "I04ILU fA., ",,~ '4" ~ yO VlKl~ \.Ann, A' "Hr', II vnll Ol) 110' "A". A UwVU O~ fANND'. 4""_11 0111, Iltl YO"~ nU,rtlOll' nn o"'n .n "'~flI "lO. '0 fllllI 04" .UUI VOU UNCi" "'iAl un" , , I i il. CUM\3rnHL^ND COUN'I'YU1\H 1\880cl fI'I'ION 2 LlBrn1l1'Y flVlnNUIn CflRLI8Lm r^ 17013 (717) :1.49 3166 l\ttornoy for Vlaintiffa COllWI' 01" COMMON PI.E1l\S ClIMllIDIU.I\NP COUN'l'Y 1 I , 1 1 1 1 I 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1'10,1 (lr ,,-'Jen.B (l;'v.~fL; " AVIIO "LA ~.. .. ......... . ..104 .. It ...,.. '" ...,,,/ ~'k" "''''''''' ... f1111 ....04" """"'" ... I... "'".'" "'~."I, "",. 'M', "",. 1101", .. rlt,,, tI r"l. ,a, It It.... .. It "'...'.. t It on"nlOllllo ".., ItII, ,....,.. ..., r."","",... fhllU, ,a "U'\IM'.\"""" .tw.~", ..lIn... .. """ .. '"'''' ",'"' ., "".." "... '".''''''' '"' ........,.. ,..."... .. ,....... "" ,......., "'" .. ."'~ '" · .'~'''', It 11<1' ......" ""~." ""... """""1' It .. ...... .. "'"''' '-II .. ..."..,... " ."ItI"...1o ~... ''''', III ,.." ....... ..,04. , It... ..1......4"" , "..",,'t. _ ..I.. ,...pl. ,.. 'n", It, ~oo_,.. till ......~l '''...~ ,.... """ ","',. · ... ,fIttl..... . "'"r ... '~'r ....,"'11"''' .." .",4 "Llf II. UtA "tlUIlII~ ~ ".., AIMM.AIWI 'II ~ ,"A'~lU~" ""II "lit' 4"",~1.1 " " '-'I ,.." rc- III III ~O . !fIfIHI'II It! 'A', ~ tAl, ~"1e10'''4V411l"UO''AOlUMI 11__ "~""'-'I " U OfIl1IlA NU Ill.,et''''' II 'lIlIUN'IA ur",~ AU'O '~.A 'A\lUIIiVU WIIIN ~I Pi'I III ('O~I1IU Amlllll'A ltI1AL, I.; , ' 1'\: it ill I 1\, L( I'i. I " l\ I , \,' , .. 'I , I'"~ 1,,'1',' ."\.~ se OoU'l"l 1.dmd~..4';6..... A-t.u i COmpa r ..."ntl-ccun~y 1,.;t}'tlT't:-llQUIHl "3td ~J!;l,ol}l'- cn"hntl. 'f'1i l-?,l;G.J 1\, P\~I:()ndnn\: 1'1\\11, 1', MO\,llll\'l'liJI)Wl :l.p <11\ QC1\ll\: :l.nr.\j,yldllfll ynp~,q:l..1\g AI: H 0 13, PIl l.'pn I'. 1I:1.,ul1wny, I\P(\l.'\:1I\\3n\: 1\2'1 f Naw Ci\I3\:la, pelnWI\re ).9'1;10. B, AI: /\11' Un\1313 II\f\\:ol::I.nl 11ore\:0 l)efencl<1n\:' Rl\l~rll JOliN BlUHM/ \lll, wnl3 IInli :l.p IIn flgent, ~lll\ploY13e, WOJ:)tmf.ln IInd rlOrYf.l\lI: of D13f13ndlln~ MI1~mH & SON13, TNC, apUNT I ,.rOlll'l' I? I l<m~S!f(\~r~ V, RhIll'H JOIULRl!llll1,-1IR.t. I' 6, Pla:lnl:iff JOHN P, MI\RI3HJ\L,I" h131:13PY inpOl:pO):lIteil PY raferenoe pE\rllgrflPhf3 one (1) ~hrough J:i ye (B) inoluf3i ye "1f3 tho\l\]h f3'f.l,me Were, set forth at l13ngt:h harein, 'I, on 01" flbont May ;11, 199'1, fit: approy.i111f1\:13ly 1109 'Ptln. Plfl:l.nl:if; f; JOlIN P, MJ\RSIIALI~ Wf\f3 f\pf\l3f3enge1" of a 199'1 Nil3f3<1n when I' ,:l.t was l:ef\l:ended by fI oar oper<lt:!3d by I)13fendf\nt RALPH, JOHN RIilHM, JR I €\nd owned by Defend€\nt MlL,r~mR & ,90NI3, INc" o I At the IIforE'.f3f11d \::I.l1Ie<ll1C1 plewa/ Pefendfl\lt RAL~)H JOliN RIUIIM / JR, waf3 negligent:.ly oper<lt1ng a 1110\:01' vehiole OWnet~ by Defendf\nt f MIl,LmR & SONS, INC, Which l3uddenly and Wi~ho\\~ warnlng Wi\a of\\.\sed to violently I3tdke the vehiole oooupy1ng ,." p~flintiff JOHN P" MARSHALL in the 1"efl1' whlch reaulted in l3evere " IInd aerioua peraonal injuriea to Plaintiff, 9, 'l'h8 1991 Chevrolet, Sohool Bua~' bearing a Pehnaylvanil;\' Reg:l.atrlltion Numbe1"SB1?649, owned by Defendant MILLIUH t. SONS) " 'INC, waa oarelea131y f\nc1 negli,gently operCltec1 by Defendant RALPll JOliN IUDHM, JR, when lit v:l.olently atruok t.he' vehicle Oob\\pying Pl.aintiff JOHN p, MARSHAr~L in the rear' whioh oauaed the aeVere .i.njudel'l 1:0 1'1fl:l.nl'..i.fI: liP !JOI', , I:Pl'\:l\ l\IoJ:(~' f'lllY below, 10, ArJ n nlfJ\lll: ot: thu nl)OVo-mlln\:~.On()r~ mol:or yehinle ,. , QOc,J.c1eq\:, Pl,dnl:.i.j:f: Illlfll:n.i.nnrj YI\I,'I,OI\IJ per!Joni11 :I.nj ~Idllll nnc1 inOU1Terl YlldoQI3 lI1ecUCJnl oxpenr~eu In /lnrl 11(101\1: enqsi1vodng to . . Dlm'l h.i.mIH'lH' of: fJi'd,c1 .1. nj I\d,el3, more I:~\ny c1el3or,j.I)f!c1!1ore.i.nftfter, U, DeJ:encllln\: Mn,r"lill~ & 1301'113, INO, Imew 01' rJho\lld hftYs lmown. \:hnt DeJenc1l1nl: Rl\I,PH JOHN RIilHM, ,JH, Wnl3 IIn opel'III:01: who repeft~eqly dr.i.vefJ in II Pllreleuu, negligent nnd reakle8u mllnn~r, 1;3, 'rhe IIfol'eplllq ooaUn"enae f\l1q the .i.nj\ldef,l to Pldntif: f: JOHN P I MMI3HJ\LI~ were aft\ll3ed polely by the negLigenae I ollrelefJl3neaa and reokle13anea8 of: Pefendnnt lnl n) r~l'dh\re to opperye tr<lff.ia oontl:ol deYJ,oea/ bl 'allure to properly operate and oontrol thelr yehlcle/ 0) FII.i.l\lre to yleld rlghtof way to brnff.i.ol " ql Failure to keep a proper lbokout, e) Failure to I:rllvel <It a a<lfe I3peeq unqer the.. o,i.'roumatllnae8/ f) Failure to give propel.' <lnq l3uffiolent \<1al:n1ng of Elpprol'\oh I g} Fa.i.lurl:! to opel:llte a veh.i.ole w,i.th que regElrd for the rlgl1t8, al'\fety I'\hq well "being for othel's/ h) Failure to operlltl3 l3aid veh.i.oll3 in suoha manner 80 as to be fI),la to I3top within the assured olellr dlatanoe nhead/ i) Fal1ure to maintain a aaJ:edistftnoe from Pla,i.ntHf /' j) Fl'\ilure to wnrn and proteat Pll'\intiff from df.\ngerous oondHionl3 whioh have onuseq serious personal injuries/ I I , I I I , I , ,,) , i I I I 'I I j" kl Vtol~ting the v~rio"~ rulep of the rOlld, ordim\noep of: the COl1\l1\onwoi1l.l:l) 01: PennpylYi1nIa ~nd!or wIth regard to the Opel:fltion of i'\ 0011111\0n oarrier 1110\:or yehiole qpon pul)l io h1gbWllY I 13, ~olely flP ~ rapqlt of the negltuenoe of the uforepuiq Pefendi1nt I (:he yel]iole ooclllp1ed l)y Plninl:,Hf JOHN l'! MAl~all1\I.LJ " Wi1S ouuperl to be y10lently ptruok in the rear by B motor vehiole repulting 1n peripu~ IInd p~inful perponlll inj4riep, inoiurl1ng, Pl\t not Hl1\ited to dI"l?,i.nepPI he€H:1uahflPI,i1I)rll~ion aboi~l: the heAd i1reUI oerYl,CJlIl spruIn tmc1 ptrll1n, necl~ pl'd.nand n4monepp!, tingling In IIrmp ~nd neck, 14 I lip II fl\rthei' ]:epUll: of thla IIqoident, pl~int1,ff JOHN I' P, MARSHlILJI. tncurl:ed ~ ~~3Vere shocJ~ to hi/3 nervea and nerVOUP pYl3tem, great PhYl31.oal p011n IInc1 mentul angUlah i1ncl WE\P pl~eyent:ed from att~ndlng to hip UpUal dutie/3, actiyttiep ahd ayoaE\tlonp, E\llaf whIch mllY oontinue to /'In indeHnJ..l:e time 1n the,'nea]~ future, 15, 1113 fI direat and proximllte reault of the negligenc~ ap aforementioned, Pla1nttff JOHN P, MARSHlILL haa or may puffer/'l aeyere 101313 of earnlnUl3, and impa1rment of 111,/3 "earning oapaqity or powe]:, which f!uoh loaa of inoome anq/m~ impa1.r.ment of eal'ning oapacity 01: power I.nay, continue for an indefinite period into the future" .,16 ;' 1113 a ~ireot und reasonable result of the aforementioned accident I Pla1.nt.Uf JOHN P, MARSHAl,l, muy have or may hereinafter continue to inour. financial aMpenses or lo~sea which do or mllY exceed II1110unta whioh ,he lOay otherwise be entitled td recover, " ,. i PI I lIf.l 11 q,j.reclt: IInQ prol\ll\\f\t;e rnfllllt: 01: th13 i11:01;'l'll\\llnt:l.Onec1 ina;\.clent i1nc\ t:hl'l l,njllJ.'~.l'lfJ f\l1cl clf.\lnqaen f.lllpt:<1;\.nec\ I)Y L'lllint:ifl: , ~QHN L', MlIRI311l\I"I" hElp \)een" 1111<'1101' I\\W{ be oompened \::p el\pf:lncl monief.l ~or mecliaa~ q;\.qe, mecliaine q~cl/or other f.liml.lllr meclicIIl 'find/or meelialllly relllteel l.nptrllI\\Bntqli\:l.f:lH Anel/or mOcli11l.tiBf.), 10, pefenelf.\nt l.S solely Itf\ble for Vlf\intiff'f.l tnjuriBf.l ell'lf.lcribl'lel herl'ltn, inElf.ll\\uah qp P1IIl.nttff'f.l injurief.l are the clirect ancl proxtmate ref.lult of hip nl'lgligl'll1oe, cf\relriaf.lnef.lf.l ancl recklef.lf.lnef.!f.l f\f.! f.let: ~orth IIbove, Wllli1RlilFOHIU, Plqintiff JOliN P, tv1I\Hl3lllllll" elemandl3 dl:\l11l1gef.l of pefBnelant RlIlIPH JOHN HlilHM, JK, for II f.lUI11 ineXaef.!13 of Twenty- li'i ye 'rhouaanel ($25,000,00 l fJonE\rl3, plua aOl3ta, elelay damOlgea and interel3t, OOtm'l' II JOlll>! 11, ~~lllfA):,):, '{ v. MILr.mn &~QN@, INC. 19 I Plllintiff JOHN P, tv1I\R/3I'11\l.11" hereby inaot'poratel3 by reference parOlgrllpha one (1) bhrough e;\.ghteen (10) inalual.ye as though I3l1l11e were,eet forth at length herein, 20, lit the afore~aiel til11~ and place, Defendant RALPH JOHN RIUHM, ,JR", slldelenly and without' Wl1rnl.ng struck the vehicle occupyl.ng Pla:Lntiff JOHN P, MARSHAlIL, in the rel:\J: at"eating ~, dl'\ngerou~ and hazardous aJ.,tuat,ion which rel3ulted in l3eyere ,'.1 'I' ,- injuries t~ Plllintiffa, 23., lit all time 13 l11aterial hereto, Defendant, Mlt,l,EJR & " SONS, INC" was the owner of a 1991 CheVl"olet, School Bua, beating a .Perirsyl~lInia Registratl.on Numbe~,/3fi17649, 22 I Defendant MIl,Lli1R & SONS I ' INC, WC\f3 negligent I cC\releal3 i.' An~ raakl~aa for knowingly antrnatina And/or gIying Pafendi1nt RALPH fJOHN. RliJllM, ~R, t:hah' perm.if.lfjJon And aonfJen\: \:p opa~'El\:e, their 1991 Cheyrolet, School U\\[1, bellfing A PennaylYElnia l~egifJtrA\:ion N\\l11ber ,9817649 on or II bo\\ \: MAY ;11, 1997 at at' Aro\1nQl,,09 p ,111, ;l3, Defenqllnt: MU,LliJl~ [. 801'18, INC, Imaw or fJl1o\lld hi1ye I~nown \:hAt Pefendlln\: RALPH JOliN RI~IIM, ,JR, wqfJ An ope.rAt:Ol~ Wllg repeC1\:eqly qdyea in II 0<\1.'e1ei3(3 anq l~e.oltle(3i3 I1)Annel', ;l4, Pef:endAnl: MII.""!TIR & 801'18, INC, ' a yehicle 1'1<\13 negligentlY, 0<\re1eai31y And reck1ei3a1y entrU(3ted to Defendant, RALPH JOliN R!TIIIM, JH, when he i3\1dqen1y anq WHhO\.1t wA~'n.i,ng st:~'qcl~ Plq.i.ntiff there))y creat;ing II d<mgeroqs IInd haZllrdoUI3 t:~'afJ:ia' aitl.\lIt;1oni WHIiJRlilFORlJJ, PlAIntiff JOHN p, MI\R8!II\LL del11l1nd cli'111)fmel3l'of pefendant MILLDm &,1301'113, INC, for q 13\\m in excel3s of 'rwenty-Fiye '. 'rholll3qnd ($26,000,00) DOllll~'f3, plLl13 aosta, ~t;1lay dAmqgel3 And inte~'ef.lt , OOUN'J.' III JOH1>l' P, MMSllALL v. PJlUr.. P. MOURA'l'IIJDlW,' 26, Plaint i ff JOlIN p, MARSHI\L'" hereby incorporates by reference.parAgraphs'bne (1) through twenty-four (a4) inclusive , as though same Were set forth at: length herein, 26, On or 'abollt May 21, .1997, at approX;,i.I1)Ately 1109 p,m, Plaintiff JOlIN p, MI\RsHALL Waf3 a' p.assenger ot; a 1997 Nisaan operElted byOefendllllt PAUL P, MOUR1\'I'J])DlilB when it crossed oyer into another l,ane and WII~ rearended by a car opel'ated by , " , " " ,-" gD, ~ple1y qs II resUlt of tho ne~IIgonco of the qforepaid Pel:endAp\:, I'lq1n\:,j,ff [JOlIN p, MlIHSIIJ\I.J. WIII3 Ci1upact \:0 pe Yio1ent:1y 13\:I:U(J)~ ln t:he relo\1' by II mo\:OI: yeh:(,olo reS\11 t lng in l3erJ.O\\S Anq pflInfu,l penlonll1 :(.nj lidos, InclucHng, ))ut pot; !.tm:!. t:eq n(30)t I.1ncl I \\ppe1' Pllok PA:I.n" 30, fill II fllrthel: rOIlI,\lt: 01: this IICJc:!.ctont, Plaint,tff JOHN P, MlIHSllAI.I. lnOlll'rect f.l POYOI.'e shool~ to h.ts naryel3 c\llct nerYOl\13 I3Yl3tom, groElt PhysioEll pa1n IInq mentlll IIngl\l13h anct WC\1:l preyonteq fl.'om Eltt:enl:'\.i.na to his Ul3uC\1 ctllt1el3/ f.lot1yitie13 and ElYOcAt1ons, "111 of whioh II1E1Y oontinue \:0 an .i.ndeflnite time ln t:he, nec\l.' 'fl\\Jl\re, 31, lis i1 d:I.1'ect: <\lld p1'p~:!.mqtel:ellu1t of the neg!.tgenoe as C\I:ol:ement1oneq, P11dnt:(.ff JOHN P, MlIHSllllI.,L hEl13 or mElY 13l\ffer a severe 101313 of OElI:ning13/ Elnd ill1pairment of his ellrn.i.ng OElPAoity 01.' poWel.', whioh ~l\oh 101313, of .i.noome c\l1d/or ,i.mPEI.i,rment of ~arnil1g oElpaoity or power may oontinua for an indefinite per.i.od into the fut:ure, 3:1, lis EI dJrect I' Ell1d reElsonabla result of the " Elforemellt1oned IIcoident, Plalntifl: J'OHN P I MARSHALL, may hAVe or may herelnaft:er continue to inour f.j,llanolal e~\)enses or 1013ses which qo or II1AY e~oeed EllI10unts wl~loh he may othel.'wiss pa " entit1eq to recoYer, 33, As EI direct ahd proximate result of the aforementioned ", incident Elnq thelnj uries anq damages I3Ustllined by Pldlltiff \JOHN ~', MARSWII.L haa been lind/or II1I1Y be oompelled to expend monies for medioAl aide, medicine and/or othel: simi1al.' medical and/or medioally r~lE1ted instrumenta1itie13 and/or moda1iti~131 31\ I lJl3f:(~nqnn\: .1.(; palely 1:l.nble for Plnin\:Hf:' [l j.Jd\lr.1.es q\3[l9dbeQ Iwrein, innsll\\,ICh 1I[l PIIIInl:Hf:'p injqde[l 1I1~e. \:!w~ direa\: <lnd prol\J.mll~e ref3u1\:o{: hJ.s negl1.gonae I 9Al'ol13tlflnepfl 'I\ncl recklsflf3neSfl 1If1 fle\: for\:h n~oye, W1IEJHIilfo'OHUJ I' PlAint:Hf: ,JOliN [>, MI\I~1311l\l.,r, delllanqfl di1mngsa of: pefsndnn\: PI\UL 1', MOURl\'mpJUI3 I:or II 131111\ in el\aSflS 01: 'j'wen\:y-I"J.ys. 'l'housand ($2li,OOO,OO) pollarf3, 'pll\f.l aoat:f1, c1elai (l<\1\1ngefl i1nct inl;erest aOUN'l.'I:J::J: 'l.'UID~A Ml\RIUIALL v, AllI',L-IlliE.l!lNill'ili!M 35, Pll11ntHf, 'l'IImANl\ Ml\Hl3l1AI,r, hereby .i.na01~pornte/3 p)' referenae the. nllegCltions qont:cdned in PllrllgrnphJ;l one (J.) t:hroughthirty-four (3d) inoluaiye CIS though the aallle were flet forth at: length hereIn, 36, I\\: all t:J.meJ;l mllterl.lll hereto,' "P1II.i.ntiff: '1'lllil1\NA MAHI3H1\T,r., WClJ;I ClnQ cont:inpeJ;l to be the wHe of P1ClintHe, JOHN p, M1\RSHl\LII J;lJ.nae IInd befors the tlcaldent deflo17ibeC;\herein and WEI/3 entitled to the care, J;loalety, '~orv;\.aeJ;l, aOIllPClnionf3hJp anct aonJ;lortium of her husbllnd, 37, As II direct nnd reaJ;lonClble reJ;lult of the tnj~rles suffered by hot husbCllld, as aforeJ;ll11d, Pla.tntiff, THIilANA MARSHALL haJ;lllnd Will in the f~ture aontlnue to sUffer the loss of the care, J;loalet:y, uJ;lual servlaeJ;l, 'I companionJ;lhip Elnct " consortium of 11.131' husband and hnJ;l been further requlrE\d to provide epocinl J;lervices and cnre to her, 30, AJ;I a dit'eot <lnd pro~lmate reElult of: tl1e aforementioned ,I I incident and the l.njudeEl IInd dnm<lgea ElustalneCl by JOI'IN 1', ,I ,. " Ml\R~Ilf\l,l", , 'l'lllil1\Nl\ M1\li,91l1\1,I" hf.\fl I)l~pn IInO/01: may l)e domPelleq \:0 e~ppnq moniep !:IW modlanl n:\rle, merllolno Qnrl/or O\:h~ll: sin,il~l- medtaal nnd/or medioAlly relntec:\ tnflC~"men~f.\lltiefl lind/or moc1t11.it:h'fl, 39," M f.\ dlreat IIno pl:o~imll\:e rermlt: of the tlforemen\:loned lncd.rlen\: IInd the lnj udel3 .nnd dlll11agClI3 f.lul3t:l\tned by 110111'1 P, Ml\HSIIl\l"r" 'l'IlFIl\NI\ M1\I~SHI\l,I, httf.l 13\\ffereq <\nq/Ol: c6nt:lm\el3 to l3uffel: hom \:he' PlQlnl:J.ff htll3\n\l1q'l3 lOSfJ of eQrnln913 Qnd/ol- " earnIng CtlPA~iUY And/or may ln the future l3uffer from his 10flfl of earningl3 f.\nd/or earningcaract~y, 40, 1\1). Def.endf.\ntfl are jolntly and fleyer<\lly liable for Plalnt:lff'l3 injuriefl describsd heretn, inf.\l3mUah al3plaintiff's inj udel3 <\Fe the direct IInd pro~.j.m<\te rel3U~, t: of their negligence, c<\relefll3ness And reckleflSnel313 f.\fl flet ~orth above, WUInHIWOnm, Pl<\intJ.ff THIn1\NI\ M1\HSHl\r,L c;jemtlnd c1amages of f.\11 Pefendi:\ntl3 fOl- a l3um in eXC813S of '!'wenty- Five 'l'houl3<md pollf.\rfl, plus cOflts, delay dam<\ges tlnd interel3t, , MYCI,t1\l< GHlOJ<LUI &' WlilLl<lUn, P, 0, -~~' -. ._-f ~ ~" -. , --7 ~_:.:---::~.-~~.. ~/ ' ,".--- ItTCll7i 0 D"..,laA'rD1~~.Ji0 mSQU~Rm . Attorney fOl' Pla}'~ff8 " " , (,/ I' lj , ,~ , I' , ""d ,r;\ l'_:"\\~:l,;,l",,;,:-:\\/" . \ ,.V",'-".;,,,:,,,; ," . I:, ,\ ,: };,~II t'\'\'j ~ \ \, III .\: I' ,,' \\ fh'j-f.\~\ \ \' I', /. ; ~M'\l.fl:.J,;I,:~n\':1!!""i':-'" i."., '" \ . .. ''')I ~ 1'1 '))""" ',I , \'1 '. .. , 'V', "\'\' '~II' '(1'1' i\~ i~: ,,,, , " I ,I.' /. l\iii\'",,:1:":':""\, ",'~~"O. ','," ",\~. :~ ~,. '.... ~":' " \\lr'~i:Hi\\II,I;;;:,;>.: '1 '. ~l 1,.','1,11' 1\1 JI, ': -, tll'/!\i. I' J:" I. ::+"II\:'?':'i,;:,;,\~,1'\\i"\~I~J'1 "I~I, /f., . .n}~'~,,;:~ VI/.'\(' ;, ': ~ q, "[ \ \ '. '(. ',. '>, ~~,,~ {. \'.\I;",\\~,t\-;,Il\\\\"" II..' ',',~ " r'h~", \,{ ';\~!n:'l.:~,~~, '~';'"tl~" r1)ti~'!1'" Jill' '!I'J'I'\"~\' p ~l' 't. '(1';) I ", I')'" \""1 J-. I] " '/11'.\(1'11/ fi\ ' :.1, I,", t~l:i,..'\\', i,\\\\'>, lj ";111, ',II''' /: ",'1;;.1 111', l\" '{!','" ''\ )'\"" "'':'' ./1 I I '\i ", . \ ,"" ,. ~ I' I" 'I I I \\"',..\'\"'I"\\'J'i\.,'...lt!y",,(, &i;:':r"'~"':\">'/'I" llli~'; ( I ;~f I L,t,. . \ '-' II \ '- - I -'_ '-(l') '. \ ~ 'j~,\',t;:':":I\<:W\', 4' ':P " " 1/:'"'""",,, , 'i. o.:il \1 ;, , '1 '1'1" ..' 1\1" H',t -',I~-l' '" I \ '\1 JI:.' ,~ ~" fI,V.",(.oI' ''1,\\\;1 '_, '_n ~ ~, t ;:!:;W,;";' "::':!I',:':" "';,,1: '. -'1' '\1" "'if J'''''''': ','., ~~;~J" l ':11';::(,:'(:.:'1 ,.'\,,> 'jl;. "'1", I" ,i' ,..' "" "\ p ";:!;'I.", "''.>;'''''''';''',,, " I \(II.,;_.I\"! ',(\'\il\.;,I'::__'", -' :",!" I ',II' '~;i)llJ :.0 -j (u,::;.lt\k; ;~i,,1), ,II I" "~I': ~ , ',\\;; '] _\' '_ "".;' :' . _, \ " ' j" LL'; "Ii, I! (!""'''',I'' '_1", ";', 'd. 111'(,11':'. '\","'1"";", i "', I"~ f,\l-,';\:'~~' il - ;t;)l\1;'t!l::.\' .;olli'. . t ii;%, I ~;~,:,:~,\:/,:' ,t,L\.,",; ,r,1:I''1I,"1 ,j,> q'., i-;' 'i;' :Jli'/; i, ", \~;,,";.l'_:'d ,~.\.-';' i " 'T"'" ''''''",,,, ""I ." , b:,i::,;; '. ~V'i',,<:'i;':;':';..:. , i . .' '""",'.'1 ," ,I',' ,,.. I:' ,I"~ ~l "/ I . _ _ < ,I j\ :,', "q,_, ~ii:r:~~J";\~::;::i,:;X ;: ~:, '!I\\"~() ci:;~}(;_!( ''''1'_ '.' \,.\ ';"'/'1:' "1'--' 1;-1, U,,;,: 'I' rl,\'_'_';_J. i ,I;~ _, '" .;\ii(;:;:;:~,.::,..,>':,i:,,: "'"!I'!I___ :,-1,"1.1' '-' \,. /" ',~I J.J, Ii"j' .; \:'\;;!,'i':?,~':::':.;' f:{l";i'i ,I! 'II,::" " ' "!i i ~ - I' i ' .o,,':.',l, " /i :'0;,')1 ',pro,J\ !'.;:; 'J' .,.".' 'q , '-'-I , . il!!. ii,' "'.., '.. :',,; l ~ j :,,',"J l': II ;-:: "!;I_"I;"" L\~:'r1,' ! I,' \'1.' li\" tH, . li,,',1, ':.' ,. "'j.,l"" '1.,'. " " '''.il.'}I::jJ, , :'1' " " /1' , I' ", ,".\1/ ,. ", :1" '- '!: ',.,)! " .'j , . ';' , .(, !JI I" ',i'. oj, '/,,1 " " , ,J' 'I' d' ", " .,:r " " I ", I" ,I' "1, "'/,( II' ~ ( ", ',. , " j r~ ~' '~A .~ ~~\~," ~, " , " -'" I:' " " ;,',: .,. ~ "'" ,",' , , ',.,." . ,. .' . ',1 "'_, ' , ..~ " 'I." " ", ,\,\ " ,. " I. " . "---- '" II .--". " II " " ,. , " ,1', " ,Il "'j I. ' I'"~, "'... :'--1 ,. " " " ", " " I' .; ". .. , 'I '., d ',I " ". ,j" I, ,.' ., " '\:' " P' " "If", " ,',I, i ~ I , Ii " < , ~ " " I;' "I' " ,/ ,. 'i_II ',ij}'! '"~ p' .. ! ',: .'. "1' ,,, to!;, ',; ," ., " ,,'il , / ." ", !I" " , ~- , ,,'j; I; " : ~ I P ',::- t' ,i,i.- -~ ,\ "" " ',' " ":' " ,. ,l.! , I, ,', t '\;";,. -\" 'i, ,',1 'I i', " '! '\., i',i ," -\'1' " :,I! '. ,,' " I.,', ", . q' "','./;::, , " /, I' ,.,,' " "'I ,,',' " I, " " " I , ;.\', " I' " '1'" ';, "1', '"j! ,," " ''-1'/ ", "., '.;i , " '. ",I " 1(' 'TI' "l! 1\" 11,' " I'j 'I ~ ,: -'j,- '-1/, "I,Jj_. '"i, ,I! " . ~ , , I'.' 'II' "ll , ',,' \' " .' " " " " '" ., I' I' " " ., " ~ (: " " I' , ". " " I/' .1' " " " It i' I' I'" \', .1' " " " ,. , " ." I. ., I' If,' " ....' ',. ,,', II,; .~ I, I" I~ . I 'jl' ",1. " !ii. i~l, ',' ,,"':.,\::i:<:'(:.;, ',. i. '" ' \ I' 1, I, ~ :. - ,j j (f j'; , (,.: i if i ' i(;l~i~)' !IH(d't~';i; :~"., , "~ '1' 1I.'j 'i..J ~. ,-,I " ", '" "'I " ;', fl' I' I '.,. ()p~mt x ~m p , ' M&r.l2lltl.J.L,'?-l--Utll12ll-J.olllW\~hll4-ilr... 6. '1'1113 <II1I'Iwet"e o~lI11:&ineq in PIIVf\qVlIph13 :t. 1:l1t"O\\911 5 her.eor Are inOOl:'porAtl'1c1 het"l'1~,11 qpy VeCet"el1oe 1\13 if. 1Il'11: f.or.t:11 in thdt" entit"I'l'l:Y I 7. Penied Ae IItatl'ld. .0. Penied. TI1l3 C\l1egationll oontAinec1 J.n tl1ie pl'lt"AgrApil etAte EI legAl Opnoll\eion t.o whi.oh no rel3ponae ill neoe[ll'1at"y. 1ly WAY oC f.\\t"thet' I'IneWet", witl1 rl3epeot to Any I'IllegAt..ton thl\t Plaintiff e\.ll'ltll.!ned peraona1 inj\.lt"y A/3 1'1 t"el3\.11t. of the motot" yehio1e l'Iooic1ant whioh oOOqL"red c;:m MI'lY 21, 1007, I'Iftar rel'leona~11e inyeetiqllt!on, pefenclf.lnt.a a):'a w1thol1t knoWloc1ge or information I'I\.If~io.tent. to form , ,II pe1ief al'l to thf3t1t'\.Ith of I'll10h I'IVer.mentl'l AM, therefot"e, they ars deniect. 9. J;1en1ecl, The I\I11'1wer oontdnecl 1n pf.lrf.lt;lrllph 0 hereof il'l inoorporatl3d herl3in pv referenoe /HI if I'let forth in itl'l l3ntirety. , 10. Penied. IJ!he Elnnwer. oont/doned in rlllraC;f!;'lIph 0 hereof I ' ;\,13 il1oorporlltec1 herein by r.eferenoe I'II'l if 138t forth in i t.!3 entirety. 11. penied. The allegationa oontainecl in' thia ),JAvagrllph I' '" atat'e a 1egl;\1 oono1Uaion, to \~hioh 110 ~eap(,nse ia neoeSl'lf.lt'V. 12 (a) .., (It) . peniec1. '1'he Allegatiolla contained in thia ),JarAgraph atate a 1at;lal Oollo11laion to whioh no reaponse b neoesaary, - 2 """ 'I' " ~pon R~V~o~ of ooun~~l, no ~n~wpv on the p~rt"pf p~fen~Ant~ ~a Vl'\qu~l:'~cl, \'I111i1Rli1fORlil, pefencll'lntl'l, Rl'llph \Tohn R13hm, <lv, nncl MH113;t' &c !:lon!11 :rnp" clemnnt1 j\\qml1~nt ~n the~rfI1Vor. nnc.1 ngl'linl'lt rl<\~ntHfl'l, OO\lnt ~E1~ol' :ru ~'lle.anlLNal'l'IluLl..L.v..,..,...AH Daf13mll.'\1lt.a 36, The I'Inl'1wev", oontainec.1 in Pl'Il'fIl1l'l1phl'1 1 thr.o~gh 31\ h13r13of Ar13 inoprporl'lt13Q h13rein bf refer13noe I'II'l 4f ~13t forth ~n th!3ir !o1nt!rety, 36, Den~eq, After reA",onl'\bl13 inya",tigl1tion Pefenqnnt'" Are wi'\;hput lmowleqge or infprml'lt1on l3uffi01ent to form 1'1 pellef 1'1'" to the tl'.'uth of the avermenta oontldn13d in th1/l parl'lgraph Anc.1, therefore, they are qenieq, , 37, Deni13Q, '1'he anewer oontained in pllrllgraph' B h13!=,eof 113 ~noorporllted herein by ref13l'13nCe ae if fl13t for,th in ite 13ntirety, /1' "I' 3 B, Den113d, '1'he aneW13l' oontllinec.1 in ,Parngrflph B her130f 'ie incorporlltec.1 herein by refer13nce /11'1 if' r.l13t forth" in ita' 13ntirety, II' r 39, PEllli13q, '1'h8 anewer oonta1ned in pllrag'l.'flph B hereof , ia inoorporllted, here1n by ref13renoe aa if eat, fO!='th 1n ita entirety, I I ! 1. i ... 6 !"'" I, I: ,. " ,. ,. '" ," 'd' , .' 'i' " , , , , " , " " Ii, , , ,I ii' , " f, ,. " '"j. 1\ " " , ,. , I' I.' " .,,' " jlf " ,. " ,. I' " " ;; /. -I, !', " ,. i' " ,if dlj ." I, 'I; ';- " !, " .j' 1'1 ;, 'I' " i, ; n " fl " ;- q " ;. " ;' '1, " fl' " ,.1' I' ", " " " " Ii " ,," 'i " 'j ~i Ii 'I , p ("j ll"~ '''' '" ('I i';', .\1; ',/ ;")(\ t,; , \, "''' ,., ,. ',1'/ Ill" "Ii " ,. ,. I/~) (;l.1 b:, {'.,~ r'j':j I\'-~ .... : I' ~ , ,iL. " , ;'/ q ,., ,-Ii ~O ..0/-'1 ""J .: '" :)r~1 "; :r./ '1.,1 dill, "l.ti 'l;,' " " ji 'Jf~?; .,' , , ,5j6, 0, I ,~t ' '" ,.:ff.i~8 :,~ j . ... t...... I . r', ,""'" i" ".,' fHtTH:' ' , ". ',: ~"~,' ""'.., , ~VI~ ","~...........,.. tf',..,...M~...... ... lit", "O\I~'" -~~..."""'. ~'ri' ~m" " .... I~ .., '/~l~ 11\ ,1Ht ,.....,.l!lll "'__. ""' ~ I+t, ...... ....""HIlI ... W" .)11; , .1~41 ~, " , ...~ '''''''. "t, "" II'" .. '~IM "'" ~.... ........,; lillI, ..'" ...w , ..... .., mt'~.. ''''''"j II; 'ill:!;" . "",'INW'ijI,."'1lft ~........ ..~, ""~. II ..~... t.1I ~....., ~,4It,.,.,.''''..... """""', .., '. .. .l!l!o\1l'~ ... .... ,...,~... .. ,., :::::':."'::'~ :'I~~~~~ I,;f.~! ~t~ ....\......,," "",. ""~~""''''' m ..."",~"". "'I'U"I'~ ""'I~" _'.~ "T~~:~"",...... !.i'l!" rll'fl ,.. ""lit II!! W ~ "'f, ....l...~.r:= .-.. ., .,~~*, iii IIllU ii~ *..,. .. -ii' ~..._ .. ' ~'Tt":.W:: ;:,:=",,..:~~'fJ'~~-= ' ::",.... ~:~=..~::~.:t.1:~.ijj,~t,Il'i,. . .., "'1lIr1_I,DIllil",~, :::~ I'CliilolfIW""~' ""~...= ,lI'I..... ...ll!'III.....l!l.... .::: ,.:; "':.t'.."r~~m~~t.,....,J,. ~1~WYr. ~~'~:':. ~:"'.~"~"" "~,"'IH~ , ., '.......'m I'll. i ..~w ~.... Wll Oil".~'~,' ~M tPk4' '''.g. . 'lIII' .1iiI1I1."" ,,, ....... ,In m ftU,"","t,ftlr .PW';'''' lit " ~ . lilt, 11M' ."IM'" It .. '"" --.... --.-- ..~:~~ ~L~::_:~_~:.~~~.. ~~:_-~..:_::._~~-~L~'A~r}J' '~~A..,.-Xr~r~J~ '..... ....... .. . - --, -. -, . - - . '. ~,.u ...",IIt,. ""AL ,. ~lJ~~:mi~~~" ~:.) edu~tA~~!l'lht:utor OAr." "'~.h }. .tJ/i. e"b.d~.~.c...ty 00'" 110'" (7 7~,' t~4.h, ,~~.' nro~,; '~'~~nf:r;~A,.':'Ul03'"",:, ._--, ....-.-.....,..... ,"1., . M1<*A~ma~-'\i~ ~ l@f.lJ{~, '~.9, . . !ln, R. .11*"~ ,~, ,~Ml,:Clm."!. .:r~, I. .. f~"Il~~,.~;p.~l,:...pn'"!?, I fi:l.J,U .~~g ~g~tlh "fP.4f:l/3~~.~l!~ . .' . 1J~llVftn~h\fJ.qg:r". " ..' '. ~'lU.~fl.l..lmj,~, Ml~;l"IlR , ..(U~), ?~fl,~nlil~ ' '., '., . -, . I ~ " '0' ..,p_,' ',lL_, "j'",,,. " .....j ,- ,:,r" ' , ~!)im..".' ..Pi'~~~J~ Im~H'Ji~^ I M'l\nl'l~" O~J:' ,hU~~Anq I .' ij~, ~h'pita V:l.13W. Pf~V~ . , .' ! ~~~~I.1U:j:'~I,rPt .P!l:l4 I , ' , ..... , I.' ' " I "" I k, I' ! ! , I',,; I' " , 'I. " I.. . , ' ;- \:'.',. :;', ~-' ~'> ,', : " ., , ~" f' '\v; . , :.' I " "',,' , ":m\t.p"t1l'puif UIpJMI '.~. .' 'l.lijf,FP~~.~P.fL" . " . ~g~l~ng~fl~:l.pQ'1J , ,VA' ,1.7P.07 , , ,,'\, " Iilnd, ',.....- . - I M~M~JaR" III ~f.)~~, :UfO;, . " "':' ,~~~~~~f~~~~~~~Ufl9,~1~~:rl. '. ., ". p~tit"i~~'k?~~~ij~~,,: '. :t;~llfll,;U~rl;lnt;IJ:I.{J!lway . A);(l4rhmllot .;'VI"',' (, ..,' .. NoW:~ q$.tt~, 'p1l U?~ II , '-,',". I. " .' .1 ,I . ,. ," I.. ..' " , '., '\1,_:,', , 1'1 1;- " , "', 'i 1 I"'. "I ",j' .'--' " , ;'\.~~p~n~y ~p:r;:' ~~ij:l.n\1:1.t.f!i! , ", , ;..1, j, C\)UR'l'. 1;1' OOMHQW' ~z.iAA~ lJUIom~~tm cm.J~ " " , . i,/ .1 " I', NO",. 9~'-Cl7.9~' .. " ,'. .1 ~.If'~"/'" .. . . . , , '-';" ',' . -, ','; ,', "c"" " ' , , . .,' 'il 'Ii ..i I ,i I I I I I I I " ' 4. ,. redqina . - . I Dill o!\WfI !='13 &, RlilHM, I1R., De~Elm:IAnt: . Pl3femlflllt: P~IJ(~ p, MPIJRM'~Plila ill An f\ql-lll: inl'1iv:!.!:lI-lAl' , AI: H 11 I'l, P\lPpn\: lI:!.ghWflY, IIpflr\:mllnt: 4.117, Nllw aAI'I~~l(t, :j.97:.JP, . J\\: AU t::!.me~ mfl\:edAl hllre\:p Pefenq~n\: IU\.f.!Vlf q-ollN WI\'" flml :1.1'1 All Agent:, omplpyel3, WOrkmlll"l AncI llerYllnl: (.If MI~f.!mR " aONI'l, INc, (JPtnfW ;r .:rPIffl' p. NU~Jmllr. v. ~PII JOlIN RRItM. Illh Ii, PlE\in\:ife ilQHN p, M1\RIlIH\1'H ;reference PAragrE\plm pnEl (l) t:hroltgh herepy inaorporAt:IHI Py UVe (6) it\Cllltl'l:!.Va all t:hol-lal1 1300me ware I'lel: fort:h tit: l.erl9l:h here:!.o, 7, On Or APO"\; MtI)' illj 1997, i't:APproxiOlately l109p,m, Plaintiff .:rOIlN P, M1\RSIH\f.lLt WE\l'la p~l'll'langer of a :1.997 Nhl'lal1 when F' ,I , it: wal'l rearenqed Py E\ CAr operat:ed by Defendant: ~ltl?H 110HN RIi1HM, JR, ,anq, owoeq Py OefenqAllt: MILLlilR & SONS, INc" ,a, " At., the aforel'laiq t:ime anr.1 plE\Cle, Defendallt: MLtPJI .:rO~IN' Rm<<M, JR, wal'l negligent:ly operAt:l.n9 A mct;or vehiale owneq py Dl'lfendant:, MILtLtlilR I. ElONa, INC, whiah I'll-lddenlY ~nq wit:he"t wArn:l.ng wal3 CE\"l'led to violently /3\:rike the vehiole ocaupying , , Plaintiff JOHN P. MARSI{ALLt in the rear whic)l relilu1t:ed .!n I'lElVere' , , and serious paraonal,in:lllriel'l to plaintiff, 9, The 3.991 ahevrolal:, School Bua, bear:l.ng a l?ehnsylyanh Registration Numbar SB17649, ownad by Defendanll MILtL~R& SONs. INd. was oarelElsaly and llElQHgently operated by Defendant 1U\.Ll?H ' ,. , .:rOHN RIDHM, .:rn. when it violentl)' stl'uck tl.~e vehiole oooupyi,ng Pi.aintiff.:rOHN ,Po MARSHJ\I,r, in the rear whioh caUsed l:he aeVa);'a "_,I,.,, " '~h_. ... .._.....",...._,~'.. .....-. - .-:-... '-'--. ..,t ~,~...,_.___.. _~....."_ ,I' "'1 "), " " ~nj\H:'~fl~ !:P J,1:rdn1:Ht A~ I\lfl\: tar!:h mora fuHy Pl'I:!.QW, lP, M A ra!l\!+t: pt t:hl'l APOve-.ll1en\:~onl3~ mat:or vflh~oh RlJoiQl'In~, NlI~.nt:Ht 11\.1~t:llin!!q Vflr~o\!P per~pnAl ~njm::\.efJ An~ inpurrl'l~ Vi!lr!P\.lfJ meMpA:!. e~plm~ee in !wl APoill: !;\mlalworing \:0 ,. ; , Pllra h:\.m~eH ot /:llt:\.~ inj\.lr!l'I~/ mOr!! h,Uy QaI1PJ.",tPI3Q hereinltl!t:6;r:. 11, PeeenQAnt: MI~~rnR ~ SONS, INO, knew oj." ~houlQ hAVl'I Impwn t:hllt: pefemJlln~ 1U\11PII (TOliN RIilIlM, .:JR. Wl\~ An QParAl:or whp ,f' . , rflrei!ll:fl~Uy Qr:\.va~ ~n A Pllre:).eafl, negl!uflnt: AmI l,"eo1\:lea~ mllnner. 1:<1, The Ilt,oreaaid o OOIl:t:'l:'enoe anq t:he injuril.1a \:0 ~'lAinl:!ff aOIlN fl. M1\RI3IH\~l.i were oll\.lfle~ llolBly Py t:oe negUgenqa, ollrele~~ne~a anQ reo~leaenal1l1 Of DeeenQllnt: inl al bl FA,!l\.lre to oP~erve traf.fic callt::.rol devioaer Fllil\.lre to proparly,opera\:e anq Oontrol . their vehicle I . i ., -j 0) FAi:\.\.Ire to yield r,iShl: oe Way t::.P t:r/ifeic/ el) . FAilure 1:0 keep a propet' lookout / e) F.Ailllre 1:0 t:raVel,at a safe ",peed \.InQe!," t:he oircumat:ancel3/. , Failu:t;e to give proper and l3\.1ffioiant: warning of approAoh/ Fail.\.Ire t:o operate a .vehicle with d\.le regard for the rightl3, safety and well peing far othera / Failure to operate aaid vehiole in aUoh a manner aO lIliI to be able to !ll:op within the "aallured cleardiatanoe ahead, Failure to mdntaina safe dist::.ance from' " Plaintiff / Failure to Warn and protect: Plaintiff from dangerous oonditionlil whioh have oaused sarious personal injudes/ . f) g) h) 1) j.) k) Viol,,\:ina t,he VAriO\\1l l."\\~ell ~ of tht! rOl:\q, orcUnl:\noe~ of \:.he CommOnw13Il+t.h of Venlll'lylV<lniA AncVor with refJArc::l \:0 \:he operA\:ion of A cpmmon oArr~eJ;' mo\:or vehiol,e \.\pon p\-ihlio hiahwAY I ~~t ~olely <<a A reaul\:. Of \:h13 negligellP13 of the Afore"'AL~, Pt!fendant, \:.he vehicle. opp\tpiec:\ hy V1Aintiff !101lN p t M~naIU\l.l~ WAQ O~m"'eq \:0 be violen\:l)' ",\:.ruPk :\.n \:he rellr by A ",01:01." veh:\.ole reQuIting in Qerip"Q /.mc:\ painf\.ll pe~~l3pnAl inj\.lrLea, incl\tc:\inlJ, b\.l\: no\: lim:\.l:ec:\ to c:\hdneae', heAc:lachea, abrAdon' app\.\\: \:he heAQ <lrea, cel:'v:\.cal I3prain <l11c:l I3l:rA:l.n, I1BPk pAin anq l1I.\mPllel3QI l:il1g1:\'l1g in arm", Anc:\ neck, 14, . 1\a l:\ f\.\rther reault: pf toi", Acoiden\:, P;taill\:Lff tl'OllN P. M1\Rf.lHALl.l incurrec:\ 01 aevere ahoak t:p hif.l nervel3 ancl nervo"", aYf.l\:em, greAt: phYfiliaal pa.in .md men!:al l:\nguif.lh and W<l13 preventec:\ from l:\\:tendillg to hia U"'I.UlIl dutiea, act:ivit:ief.l anc::l l:\vooat:.Lollll, l!\llof which may continue !:o an illdefinita t.ime in t.he nel'r f\.\\:ure, 15, 1\13 a c:\ireot anc:l pro~iml:\l:e rel3ult of I:he negligenoe a", aforementioned, Plaintiff JOHN P. MAR,9l.lJ\l.!L haa or mOlY auffer a severe 10f.l13 of earningf.l, l:\nd impairment of hia earning capacity or power, which Quch IOfilf.l of inoome andlor impairment of eArning capl\oLty or power mOlY continue far an inc:lefinit:.e period int:o the future. 16, M a direot and reaf.lonable 'reault q of the afaremen~.ionad aooident I PlaLn\:iff JOHN P. M~naH1\LL may have or "lay hereinafter oontinue to incur finl:\ncLal e~enses or loaseQ Which do or mOlY exceed, l:\maunl:a whioh he may otherwiae be ," I I" I I - I ' I " i entitled to reoover, I' I' Ii, t 17. 'M A d~,rapt ling prp~imAl;e rl!I'l~H pC \:hl! IICPl:'l3"lent+pnllQ ~npiql3nt Anq till! inj"+ie~ IInct dAmllgal'l 1'l"l'ltAined hy V~Ainl;ief \lOIlN f'. W\Rl3tffi~lt h~1\ pf!l3n IIncl!m:, mlilY PI\ pomppUeq tp f!~pl!ng monilll'l fp1' m\"!dioll:t. Aict\"!, madioinl3 Allrl!or pthel:' Ilimilllr mll~U.(]I\:t. And!,,!:, maI-HIlII:t.:t.:y rahted ~nl'lt!:'"manI:Alil:iell IIl\tVpr" modIlHl;il3l'l, 1ft, pefl3ndAn\: ,ill I'lP:t.ely liAb:t.e fPr P1Aintiff'I'l injurial'l , I, del'lcdpad hal.ail'l, inlll'lmuph 1111 ~~:t.llintit:f' I'l Jnjurial'l IIr\"! I;hl! d;l.ract I'md ll!:'odmAta l:'fllH.\lt of hip negHaenpe, PI\!:'EllafHmelll'l anq. ra91~lal'lf3ne!'l/l Afl flet fo!:'th above. . WI1~RIil1!'ORm, P1Ain\:!ff. JOHN P, MI\RaH1\f..lt Ql3mAnQI'l ,dAmAga/3 ~f Pafent:'!Anl: MltNl tJoHN. RlilllM, tJR, f.or A /3um in e~O'efl/3 of Twenl;YM Nve Tho\.\flllnd ($25, OIlO,Pll)PaUAr/3, plU/l O(Je I: 13 , Qeby damf:\gefl I'lnct inl:ere/lt" " OOIrn'!' :J:I iTOHW P. ..uSHALI. v. ~ILLRR i-HQNS. IN~ 19. l?ldnt!ff JOHN V. MI\RSlmr..r., ,hex'eby ref.erence paragI'Aph/lone (1) I:hraugh eighl:een though !'lAme ware /3el: forl:.h at length herein. , incorporAte/3 by . (10) inc:t.ul'liva all " ~O, .., AI:. the aforEiadcl time' and plC\ce, Defenclllnt lU\LPll tJOllN llut:'!qen;Ly ant:'! withautl warning at;ruc)c the ve!l;l.1;11e Plaintiff tJOHN P. MARSIU\LL in the ;rElIl:!:" o;reating A , I " " RIU1M, JR, Qooupying dangeraUIl ancl hallllrcloull situation whioh reaulted in 'aeverl\l "I I' . .inj uriea l:oPlaint.iffa. " , :n, At all times material hereto, Defendant, MtLllIllR' & " 'I, SONS, INC. I waa~he owner of /.I 19!>l Chav:!:"olet, Sohoo;!. Bua, , I I< I" t be~ring a PallhaYlvania Rag!atrat:ionNumber SB17649. ,. I ,.. ' I f,'" q. .,' .. ., '. 22; .. Defendant MIllLERIicSON8; INC. was.negHl1ent.,.C1lll'ill13I.IF...._....".-;, " 1,1 " An~ J.'lIP~hIlP fpf,' knpw~nQ:\.Y IInl:l-"\m~~n!J ~nQ/pf,' ll~v!ng p~t~mlAll~ Ml-I.,II l10HN RliJtlM, ~R, ~Illl!r ';ll~rm!IlR.\.Pll .'m~ PPI11l0nl: t.!) oPPfAtll . t:lle~J.' ~1I9:\. Ohevrole\:, ~olloo:\. PllP, tJeAdna A "fJllnllylVliloh Rft9~!lt.f,'ji\\:.!pn NmlllJlIl:' l'lIU7fi49 pn pr i!ltJl;I\.\t: MAY'~:\. I :\.997 At: PJ:' Aro\.\n~ :\.199 p,m, , :a~, peClIn~An\:. MH-Il.lli:R f< ~ONI3I INP, k-new of 1'1110\.\11:\ hf.\v'" known t:hjilt: PlIhnPlmt: MT.ll."1l HOIIN nlilHM, tl'R" .WAI'l ,liIn operAt:qr wilt:! replIllt;ecl:\.y cldvlII'! in !\ Pjilre:\.f11'!S and rllPl\;lel31i1 mllnner, a4 ; PlIcencllilnt MIT.lT..1il1l f< fjONI3, :U~C, '!l veMola WM neg1igent:1y, oArele!l!lly i!lllcl feok1el'!1l1y ent:rUI'lt.ecl t;oPeCellpant., lmT..J111 ITOllN nmUM, IlR, wlllln he Iluddenly ami w:\.tllp\.ll: warll:\.m, I'ft:r\,\ok: 'Vbint:iff I:hereby orejill;lnl:l AclallgarO\,\13 ~ncl hallllilrclpul3 trAftip I Jl:\.t\.\l\l:ion, " I I' Ii1fJilRIilI"ORli:;' Plainl:if f !JOHN V, MARallMll clemand damagel3' pf Det:emian\.: M~T.lL\i1R f.< aONa, INC, for a Il\.lm :\.n e~oella of Twenl:y-Five 'l'hoUBli\nd ($ali,OOO,OO) PoUara, plull ooal:l3, delay clamE\gel3 and I" interell\.:. COUH'J1 IXI JOHN P. MUSlIALL V. V.UL P. MOURA'l'lIDllIll ali. J,>;Laintiff ITOHN P. "U\RaUALll hereby inoorporat:el'f by reforeno~ paragraphe one (t) thr~ugh twent.y-faur (24) ino1uIlive as t:hough Ilame were flel: forth lilt length herein. ~6, On or about May 21, ,1997, at approKimately .1109 p.m. Plaintiff JOliN P. MAnSHALL WaS a pa/ilfienge:r t;Jf a 1997 Nisfiall' operated by Pefenclant PAUL P. MOURA~mO~a when it o:roll/iled ovet into another. lane andwas,rearended by a .Cla:r operlilt:ild).>y. " " " " , I' Pllfl!OR~Ill: 1tI\l-i~1I flQIlN RJilHM, ~R,., .Aml PWnllq py PBfpmll4lll:Mn~llJilR ~ PQtm, mo" . la7, M A ra"\.Il\: qf \:he ~l:IqVe~mant.iolllld mo\:!)1=' Vllh~p~1I r4pp~ql!n\:, I?lAill\:Uf Im"\:A~lltlR VAr!p\I" parlJPna! !njwr!II" And !Ilplll:'rl!q V/lrip\.I" med!olll ellPen/ilelil in And AI:IP1~t. endel'vorinl'l \:P q\.lt'lil himlileH pf Iil/lid inj\.\rie!l, mQre f,~ny (.\I!!lpr!lled hllr:e!nl\~\:lIr, ;all, 'rhfl Aforelildd oc!:mr:relloe Ancl \:he !nj\.lril!!I ,to J!!A!nI:Uf .:rOHN J;l, MAn/ilIll\~I1 werp PI\\.\ II lid IilP:!.ely \;1y, t:h!!i nlilSUgpnoe, .. cArlil1.ef,fllnelil" ,And reo~lelil"m~1il1il at: Petlmd/ln\: inl " al pI Uail\-lre 1:0 oPIilerve \:raU!iooontrol.dev~oe" I Fail\.\re \:0 properly oper~\:e ~n(.\ oont:rol t:heir vehicle/ . " UAil\lre t:o yield right: of WilY to \:raftic/ Failure to ~aep. a properloo~out:1 Failure to t:raval at: a "ate "paael Ilmler t:hll cirClllnllla\l1call1 . , Failure to give proper and Ilutfioient: warning of approach I Failure to operate a vehiQle with d\.lQ ragarel for the rights,. lIafety ~nd well baing for ot.herlil ' ..' Failure to operl\te'Ilaielvehiole in 'Quchll . manner 110 alil to pe able to stop wi-thin the aS$ured olear dbt:ance ahead, . Failure t:o maintain a safe dist:anoe from Plaintiff I . .. ,'. .' Failure to warn and proteot Pl~intiff from dangeroua oonditions whioh have oaused aerioua peraonal injuries I Violating.the va~ioulI rules of the road, ordinanolls'of t:he commonwealth of pennsylvania and/or with regard to t:he operi:\t:l.on of u,oummon oarri8r m~l:or veh~ole upon publio h:l.gh\4~rL.... . . .... . ........ ........ w.,.... .... .... .... ...., 01 1:\1 el fl gl hI " il j I kl 'I; ~9\ ~P~~~y ~~ A rPQ4~~ oC ~hp n~al~gunp~ gt ~h~ ACpr~~~~Q P~cenQl\n~, /.l.\.A~n~HC ifPIfN P t ~R~HI\~ll WA~ \lAl1!lI3Q ~p /.111 vip~l3n~ty ~~~l1Pk: '~Il ~he rOl\r I:lV A mO~or v~hip~~ r~fl\ll~ill[J. in ~lIripn" ~m1 l1Ainf\.\~ paraClnA~ injurie!l, inpluQinfJ, h\.\~ no~ limi~ert liillpk Al'lt\ I-IPllat" PAP!\: pdn t 3(1 t All A tur~het' rerH'~1: oC I:hb APpill~l'l~, 1?1Ain~iff, ifOJfN p t MAIUlII(\Lll. inc:lUrrel'i 1\ !levpre Ilhocl\: 1:0 hill Il~rvl!la I\nQ nafVOUIl , !lVIl I: em , grpAI: phVllipd PA:l.n. Illl'd meljl:l\l IlnEfUhh And .WMI prevanl:QQ , from IlI:I:enltin9 1:0 hia ulll~d t\\ll:iell, aotivil:ie~ All!! I\VoPAl:ionll, AH of which ml\V OPl'll:in"B !;o an im~efinil:ll t:ima ill I:he nElar , " f\.\l:nre, U, I\f.I A t\ireot: anlt pro:dmat:erel'l"lt: cf t:hll negliganoe 1\1'1 Aforemanl:ipne!!, Pldnt:i,fC .:TOliN P, WlRSIfALL IWJ or. m~v l'Iuffer A l1leverf! loss of earning/l, And impairment: of lib el\rqing oapacity or flowe1', whioh Iluah lCllla of inccme anlt/pr impairment: of earning oapaoit:v or power mllY oontinue forl\n indefil1il:e perioQ int:o the fut!.lre, 3:il t As a di1~Mt /lnd reaaonable. reault: of I:he " Aforemenl:ionelt aooident, Plaintiff JOHN P, WlIWUALL ml\Y havEl or , ' , , , may hereinl\fl:er oon~in"e 1:0 incur finanobl expenl'lea or losl'lel'l whioh do cr.. may exoeed amountl'l Whiot,1 he may otherwise be , entitled to reoover, " ,- 'I. , 33, As e direot and prodmal:e reaull: \il,f the aforementione.d , , incident and the injuriel'l and damagel'l l'Iuatail1ed by Plaintiff... JOHN P. MAnSHJ\LL has been and/or may be ccmpellelt to expend' " lnonies for medioal aide, medicine and/or other a~milar med~cal and/or medioally related instruf1len~aHt~el'l. !1!1d/Q);'mo~"UtbQ..".. ..... t' -:.i; ~.. " " I I '~4 " p"'tl!lll~ftl1~.h ~pl~.l:y HAb~1I fpr NA:l.IlI;:l.tt'''~ :l.llj"ri~1I ~Q~pr:l./.lp!t hllr!tilll:l."AJi,m~ch AA Jl.l":l.Il~Ht I ~ J.llj !!fi",. ,.rl!! I:hll l1:l.r!tPI: "n~ prQ,lI::l.m!ll~ltrlt"""n Qf h:l.A llQ!l,ulifllnoe, pl\rll.lllllillllll,." -OIl fl!llJ~:t.""flnll$" M "'!ill:. forl:'l Above. WUIjl'UilFORft, JllA:l.nl:itt ITOlm Al, AARS""fJlJ a"ll\l\n~ff !:l1l1lm911" C)f ' , P$tl!!,"~"nl: PAtUl Al. MOUM'!'lilD~EI tpr A ,,,,,m in,lu<oO/il1f Of 'fwfml::Y"V.ive W'm""l4nlt ((l~a,llll(l, Oil) DP1.1."1:", plll" c<mt: If I Qo.ll4y aAIlm9811 Alld :l.n~erel'ill: , ; i ; ! ; \f " , qO_., ~:(;J: ~~~ " ,'I/'. " ' , ~DJI~~'" ~li" J.1binl:.t,.f:f, TJm,.N~ ~$W\tl:! hl.lrl:lby ;lnPI;u:'PotAI:':91J /.ly I" . '. .'" ., . ,. , ' '" ", ','", ,r"fllr,'onoe. I:h!l" A:Ueglili::/.onf.f QPnt:d"..~ in Plll:'al1:t'aphlJ' pne ' 1:1.) .' , , , , , ' '" b~rqllgh't:lH.rl:y.,toln." (HI lnoluQ:l.VQ lllf f;ho\~gh t:~~l!ll'me~.~'" 1I11t: ' tO.l;'l:h Ai: longt:h hel:'~,ihi ' , " " 36. At: All t:imeQ material, heret:o, pi.int:iff, '~~A . . f' , foIA.nStmt!t~ WA,lilMct ciont:inuEIIIJ tio be t:he WHopf P.lIl:l.ni::l.ff,J~p, ~S"At.L /Jinco an~ before t:he' apoident: desoribed herein and' was I d ent:it:led ,t:o the oAre, l!lQoiet:y, IlQrv~Cle/:J, Oompanionl9hiP~nd oonllortium of ~er h"~band, 3'1, A~1l direot:, and. reAllonaple' ,fl!llult: Q:ft:heirajUt-iell ,'Ill\fflllred by her ,huE/band,. IUI afol'eliaid, Plaintiff, 'l'>>W~ MARSUALL hl4s and will in ~he future oontinue t:o '$Uff~r the 1088 /':, of t:he oare, society, USUal Qerviceo, oomp~nio".hip.nd consortiUm of her husband and has baen further required to i!. provida Ilpecial servicell and oare to her: ";.ao,r~:.: ;~l.' 'I-~'",;;.;o "-"_, .,.~_ ~ ''-<..;;''._<- " 30, As a dit-ect: and proximat:e result: of t:he afore~entioned - ..... . --- .' - ".., ..---.,...... - ---,' --. '. -.n.'.....:.t:..............._..;:._."._~...._...__......n...__, .~_ '!ncidEiiiE"-'anll~1: li(t"':tnfurles~"iliiiCdiimllgeS-li"iill tiiiIned --by JO'JNp;-._;:~- " .UHlN I'. Mi\UHHAI,I, 1111I1 THMNi\ Mi\UflHi\l,I, IN Tm~ VOVln' OF tlOMMON l'I,I~i\H ()J1' PUMm~HI,ANll vO\JN'I'Y, . ' ..ICNNHYI,v i\NIA 1'111 I nllt'l'H VH, Nn,l)",;Wl)~ PIVH, ni\U'1l .fOHN IUClIM, ,m, MIU,lm ~ HONH, INV;, IIIlII l'i\UI, II, MOlJIWI'ICUlCH Uill'IllllhllllH VIVH, ACTION .- LAW " ICN'l'IW 011 i\I'I'ICAnANCIC I'l'o\hllllOlIlI'Y. plellHo ENTER th\lUppellrnn\lO or 1110 undersigned (IS cOll11sel 1'01' the. pefendlll\\ MII-I,m~ & SONS, INC, In tho lI\lllvn OIl\lllon\l(1 nHIllel" ROHpcotfull)' SU111111ucd. .' ~~~~ TIlllolhy J."6;\glll1' J];i(~ .11111 M. Wiley & ASHoellltcH I South 13111\III\01'e Slroot DIIIHhlll'g.I'A 17019 (717) 4~2.9<i66 1.1), 11779'14 \)IIIe\1I '1-, I ~ l' ,I " " " ,( '" ,I ~ ~"' ' I.. ":', " ," ~ ~ I~ f~~~~\I"Ji ' 'J\ISl WI ,'! ~ ! ~f.11 ~*~!J,~{~i\'tl~lh\;ri'!\"'~'."{ ," j("n"I''''l\I\" " "" I , Wi';)lt\. '\,,~I),Ji ~t','; of'1 'I ,'1 I~ ' " it '( "f f1 J ' I! "Ii>, 'I; d " {/..j\~)~:j/'l {', "1111'1/ r ,,-'I .:ti'{l"''':'/'' ,'" , 11 11':11 ,I ~I ,I, f , j 1{(,'~ ',' 1',', ',,\' '(I I" " . \"1'( ,!', "', I " Iq)~\r.i!UJii;)':1:1;"rn::'" T'I~J"'" ,~";~,,, ~1'/!ll'"''""''''''''~' 'I I, ... <\~Yl~;.,t'\""""L'.\,~ "J~"'l/l' v,' !~ ':'>~ljll;'l"i t .f'}'lih 1'1' .'1 I~~J ~,lj ~t' ffl.'1l\ .}!l,t t,' 'II a ~., ~,");, 'f~'!) r_~ ;"I'M';';'"'t:!'/.;-" 'p .I I'f' 'W ,t ,~f" "kit'''''l' "" 'I' '!r~', ,,~ \!:rJ.\~~\~~ ,t,:ij ,~. ~: t-(! "," Cl :::;1 ~~'" '\"'I/~"l '("~I ! ,I '" . , "'I')' j' !~ ~0'11'!',f {.\ 1"ll,,~ I I'll' """ ,I" '/1", .,.w. "'"I,l', 'J'I) Ii 'II 'j ,/,.' 'Ii.' ~' .' J{~,' J ( 'I "'1.,1 .1~I,,(!,"".i '"j ll)," "~'" lilf)l I"\I\';'~~ V"'M: 'I\} .. m ).. ~'J7,'f'1"\'I"1'\III""'ll" 1"",'1:' I "t' 1~"~!II\ljl~'\'J:i1I, ,-",,\ ~Il \ (h./, 'l,) ~)l!~]~i,II\;fl~JI;i'i':~I~.i!JI' I: ...;,' , . (.:, 1l!);l-li"I' I,}/! ','1 '11''./ :,,1 ,t I' ',. (./I IVt~.l{ JJ:,. ; \ ), , ,/" .I '. , 't II", ~IVf't~ " 'I ~lu ' ", I , (~"'~ 1 ,..,. \'1'" "" "i' 'I, , "i 'ii/! ?:~~Ih ""'; ~, /,' , ;,' ~1'I,lMlif\lli'I'1i")',f' '", \; 'I ~"W":" "",\',,'11'1'" ,.,' ", ,I' I' ' f<; n~f ,'n \ , ' ".' , ,I}, 'I;\,,:r, ,.. '}'" "'''' , il!\" "I '1, .. ";" I' ,J{ 'j " ~MI'iL1,;}! , if .1,\1 1'}'~"';1 "r; I ,~' ,'i~~ll:l{ \ f1l'4o" tl",/I 'I,,' :H~; ll:U I~ J 'll~' It r,' "II' ~1.tf~;~fl(\1 ,Hi'. I,ll '{ '",~, I,. ii/"! "", "~"~ liII{I'j.),\J1: :: "\''t/':~';:;I''J< jil(~lil~ '/ :i', ,I)f"" I, " 1f/!,\,/' ~~l, 1""{j' . )1/1: ,:', I ~i'\I': J,~~" I ',/\Ill ,\' 'II ," I\;~I~(N i, I!:,!", r',"'I~ "," "l~\1 t' /1;'\)", 11,1, i ';:;~h':~i. \' 'I.;'",b',,', '11 (i J.l f " ) ~'/1I 1'1 1/' IJ *~; :t ,"'," ,,//1 ", ' ~lil()\{I,I)C :'......'/,:'lli.':;.;,y,.1 I{ll (1\1" I' , fi. '\'Il 'I" l~ '", o "Ii' I ,", t.1 ,,) "I" 1'" . J(" 'fO !' 'tf ',I" 1, :'fJ'~';1 1 II..',:.,: ::11'; '", :i,'" ili:ifhJ~' ~: r\~,\!/fl(:I"') :(/1 ) l~ oq, I ;/ II' I" If ' 'I' " t')lI'l-t, "f'(fi! ,'j} 11 ':t"I' ~, ",fl. if { , Yi'I.I/.JiJ/,'r ,;I.l'f n,.'i.';,l"_I'" ! "1\''''1 -'1~"-r If' - '~;'r r' ('1;;\ ;"..,: i\ '~~llIi,;i')I~/c, ~ ',if ,.',Ii"I~ilflt':~ " 'Ir,I'~.;: t;,.U.\.'~ ',:',' fiJ!''-..~a5/ i\ .l,a;:;,l;\t'!! W","-:-'! IlN(l4YI'\" 'I I! -,\'r'jf~j.',_,,'!'I',"':'_i:' !!i(;l'1;;!l '1""""'1,,,,,,.,""" 1'1'-' "~'!' ,. . ,.~, \" " 'II' h.' .''.:" I"':'" ) ",i , !'l'J!t"Y'j./"I" "'i,lr,'I''',I", /,11 1!i!hl'~ll .' 'tl,j '\J- {, I ~~ii~i;Zj~ill '!?,i~~;::/~(lI! '/I:" 'J (it'~~'~"t \',1 ("jJq"il!' "" I , 1".,,;1 ~'IJ'~;w- I~', 'I ) " , I'} 11'"j 'l" tJ~,'!' I'; ,< " ,I '1'1'." ;11 1'1, n",,:, r,t"" , /i)i'" ','I, #," 'I""", l 1" , ~}.IJJU7/j l,)~, '(' "lld I).' /1' (;,:/1t~~/~h/ ,~.,~' ::/11 ,'," " ";'; 'f ~Vi"JIJI " "/I, "If I I I' (.HI ,. ~f'!: /\ f'JI I, " ' , '1"'111')' ,JII ' ""I '"'' 'I {l/J!'f,~\j'il~',.r;! ~I: "1>,'1' n tJ " [' '.!' /., I "} ~<' 1 (,{',\N i '('i",'/r" II,', ' u ,'\'.(' [, I' ',' ,~ '" . {"i''''I''1 ',1; I'" I' " 'D.-",!,,,.,\ ,f" II' il)'oi/II''',)I/.' I,' , 1"'{'II 11,- ", I, /il ~'/ll 1" i'~1 I" (lit If ' UL,'I':l "'.1,', I' (.J.111/.h:iIIJ/',....,: ,I' /1 ~", fl'). fJIl"'II' I " , III' 1:;H11',,:/,'.. '_I J-l~(.,.:,j\~r(/i~!~."ihr ~ i U} '~':" ':,~l, ..,1i;;\hi::C-; ;'f::'i\,'_1 ~'X;_'!;-'_:/ .ij. 1\f!?;Ji'I.'i'l/i'"",,:,;(/,_, OJ': fi)ii;!~;;;i!';r:,,;:,~;,:~!~~:;.' .':' ;" ;, fi-(,-"'~:-f}'(Jj',:~(w:,:,:, / ,1,;~, :;','-:'"'' ~\'m'Ju", -:;, .}} , 'I" ";1 ,/ 'j /: ~;;\~.r~;'J'~ "111 {i f/J'",/,' I ',-,'; . 1;,lf,/',' [/1'" d' '; ',', ", :~:?'i:~:',,;;:"~ ,,'i, {., ~ {! - " ,,- -, I ': . 't. (, . l'~k_~<;:','~( ';; I.'il,~i'-' --'; -i. ,~!, ~'I'JltfJ!,). ~"(r '_,I~. -/ ,"j _ " , fit ,,~!~d,('''' d~,-", J 'I' ;'~:},f{t"'Li,~,,'.'!~lp,_: " \'1_:,' , I" ~',.t(:'W',~~~~i:<'I': 1.,~iV ;p.\'-_~' " '/-'- "I,iIJ'f,1 ,"_'L II"/X" 'j ~. " ., _,I' p'..,' r/--'ll_/',I{_'-' f; t, f /,;' ii,'. !,' I ~ _ ' :" }::l,r:!:~~;!>.';4X:'~'<,> 1';:, !, li{\';"ih,,_:-I'I,. P, 'i,'., \.,~._l;/:,-'/)i':" -" .,' :'~'-%"I "1' -'.'~, /: : (i ~,I'I' " 'l'H' .'tll,-'" , IJ~"'I''''''''''';' '" Vl\_~ _10"\;:.\.';-, ;;'t;'I_IJ:',; ,',; i i,l." !,~'{d,\I'I'.'J""'" 1.' : '~.;',1:.J i":,,';t' ; ,,' r " '.'1'\ ''I, './, "., /." ", ",Ii ", , "oj,;:,,) ,lij!:::'~'lli?1 i\;li ';~! ," " '.I'~:' Ii":/.I, ',II;':'\;\\\!r,!,.-,\~f1~b' " " I', ", " " '~'H' l' q t, .11 , ,,,/. 'Ii; 'll.. ',1\'_" ,','ll-l ' . , ",- ,J _ 1/, ( ~ ' ((;'1'_ , ':/'1 ~ 1\1,',; '" ", , '.;;' :;'\liF':~'::,'-'~ '~/:';"~'l\:,~-:., "," ",J,'-. i_/'::l'n_'~_\\' . -' (,' '1,\"'-1,\1,', ,,' ". '(!i.'i'.'ii,,':;i(;: ':'; :,,::' : ,~i'i':::,;A;,~i: ":',.""':,,i ':;-(.\ '1.)/)\ ," " ':;;:{;:itr; i ~".... I( d 1;-, ," '.'1 "(-',-)'/j '," .,,, j'/', -'>-., FIf.t.j~ 1'(,-"-'I"IJ_Jn;/T1 "j.;\1 ;~~ ~'~:'-~::r {l'p '; /.,.,,'1" ~,:; !; ~.~':' i~},;:{~ i,' '; t, ' , I \, 'II' (.~ 1,1 )' '_I f j.l1 - :i"~,:- :-: ,;; '},~\JJj I, 'd'-",-,'_Jlh, ,,;.", ;,.,.:!I"'J. 'J! /~ -~.::,!, .:,(',*r ' '(, '.III ~". ';1-_ i.J, " .,11'-"/['1 <--'f ... "'it ",,1,',',\. "f '1 h~. ," r 1",' 'I"" ' l I , 'l I I~'! "I' Ii /.. 'f 1Jr '.' i' ::" I 1/.;:1 :: ;,"" I I; """':.' :"t,~,,'I{i~j ~;;;. "'1 '", '.;'!'" " , '; I:, \:'~NV. '," . ! "1' '\~l'! i :~) l' ~f';t " ,. , ,j '/11 ; I ; i idijq , . ,. 1 ' , :i :~h ~. ., 'I' : : I" ,( :li:'/I~f' , 'J:!/k"'',;' I'" " f' }, /' {',,;i 'j~h.lj'~,fj , J 'I" """ , ~ i , 'I','if ;r~;!~,~, 'I' ",lIt X, ,,';'1',/ I4;Yh'j ,'1'\'1. ,'If,,'" ,'I'" ",1I~II'," ~ i' ~;,"ll""r Iii',. , I');", '1"IJ'~i 1jUiJ't.if: I' " 1 ,q, ,. :U I./~ilf'i!\~I ,'," I, ,., , I t' I J; "'.111.1 ' ' .!: ' 1;,1 , n., . {'I ",lIj'~l~fJ ,-'I , 'I',"o,",!f\j{ I~"~r~ '0 '! .,', \,~f)lJll ~ '" I iV!1' "", . J . "I Ji"~ IH,': '~tJ, ,);0 /11, II' rl'ti!'l.al(;f,Ij,~'lt!~V ',1;,1 'I, If'\'~:!1 :lJ <I'~'~I "11'\ ',r,I,1 'i:,:'IJ~iA'I~h, ' '," '1\ ~ "Ii,h:ll ~'" ".. "t'" r 1(,'I(,.ll ~~,' t \ I. " '!, lj' j ~ f ,:1. ,,; . .-\l, l ' (Ii. j , I "s '''Ij'~t,\, W . \':, .j,',) J,'d;ti:'~;ifr~'it~ """,1, "'''''''';,'I\(I'lj'l I' I, .'1' \1 ' , :JI'/ /""',; ., i I, , :" : 'j I~ '11" ;.': : I I,;'", l' ((, L,?n lh';~lI " ", ",;;,',',:j';:'f,i;:;~;,;,~Jl ; ;, ...: <i'::;::'I~':I'\';I")i~.' .'- P,. ','__ '!j\ "'_OJ'>' ' I'i},!" ,__' l' I!}~'_' ~-"};\-{:.'Hl._ ,-t,., "._,.-'II_'/","f.I"/'_i,,;.. ," ",t' \:'i;(,,:I.~<~~:::~, ,t ,;.., .' '-'!. ':"I-i-H~: {'!fI;}'-t::if d i.';', ' . J. '__' I, ~,' ;i'j,/Ji'/{IIJf'r"'11 I', ":1:. ",:''',;-:::;:';;{{%)R{?1 ","-/' i q'it"",,,/f"'I'~11 """",'! t" J. ~ :/ ':'!., ~ I J.' /1// i'Jfl}.;! " ~ ~ ''-.';' "I' ~ '111',/.11 ' ,,,,., "I r~ I, fIlii" I.,: I 'I "i}'!fl,!~\ i ,.~ '" ',).\' I'.,:H'I \ ,I l~i Ii "'h I '("ft' {; 'J'~' :,~ ',:", j ~1 : 1t,' l~ ','} \'11:, " '. , ''''''''~'I'i- '(1.11' ',"{-"'\' \1 ("I, l"'lt.." ,/ ,,' " ", oj d\a: ;l (~;/l, ' ,. ii"., "(t,l,~'~ :/,11.,' '\1' ,1\',;:' '.1'1, J ,:/ ~~';')):,1~11{11~:' d It!, , f, 'j ,)),'1 ,fJ,'/i{1\) I '; "'1).\.;:.11 'II , ""I"'" ' I r IT'},\" /ltl;,lH:)1'U'>>' II'! ,,1:' ,l/'j} , '1~~1 Jil'llf11. . 1/' r "/, IN. 'If 'l,lll} "r ,H:,''<.!'n,'j}'I ,<, ,:,,(""\ J( , ~/i ' ;""/,i/,r,:1 .:'V;-,'{,.~>:tl, , ,'!. , II r ~ '// " ii I"~ ,,I. " ",,' , I,' I. 1," " ), ,-,:','" II' " "', " ,< " '" " "II' " , " I' I' ," " " I, "I' 'I " " " " " '\ " " " " .,,' 'I " " I' I, ,. '; ',' " '\-10 " ,," -..~~ ",'" I, ,~ , " "'~, ~.--~ /. " ~ " _____ 7~"_,,, -- '-. -' '" 1 ,'.. ,/.' " " /I" " " I' " '" " , " " '1' " Ill" " " "f , I' " I' " " " " 'Jf' ~ , ' ,,,' " ,'I, , " " ,-:'_f' ii, ", "-" if" " " 'Ii I,' 'I' __, ,'-'/I " " ,', " I,'" .;." -"" " 'Ii' ,I "-\':1" I, " -' " _'I., " " "i!, I " ,,', " "II , ;,' , " ",' }, "I,. '"'' " " 'I.:" , I,' '" ,.' :'" ,; I: I' ,~, " , ./', '0 " ,I " 1\; , ' ,'/,1. "'1 ',; ! f", 1; " " " " 1,' " "i. , , " ,. I',' " " " " . ~, ''j, .., " " " " ~t ' " " " ,; ".' ,," " I, ", .(1 :,. ,I ,..',,'1(, " 1 " "1' ',', , , I:;. " "!L'. , ';'" ,,' 1'" '1, " " '" i, (.' ,,'. ;j. iT" I:' ", I' .. " " '!;',' I " " I, ','II ',,-,,',, ,/" "" ", f' " " ",/ I"~ " " ,: <I, ',d. .I" ii " f,'_I. ,-.'. " " ", " Ii ,:, ,. , " '" " " ,,' ,~:,'J . I, " /.(, '-/ ,; ,/, J' " ',II " I' /'" .. '~ i,lrj, ilf ,/ II d ,.',1'" 'I) III :.1'. I, f:;IIl"[l:\ I~V'!'i 1I1::T\lllIJ . (J\1'I' CW CDUN'I'Y CA8R HOI 19UB-03993 p ggtHN~w5~"61.hl~\~IlI'.~lIw;nvMn I, I " " tlA!lEl!1lhld.l~!!!i.-e..-E't~c1\J:c_,..--~..--_....-_. .1'" V8, 't', IWlIl1 llAhE11 JOHN JR_mT AL .Jl. 'r1H) U1ftJi1_JLl1M-..,---- ,__..'-,.., "8 h e 1"1. J:f , II h f.l Ill'l:L n \J d \11 y to JaIl, sayu, ~hf:\t hii' T1Il:\de., f:\ di.U.(Ient 81~al'lJh and i.nqlli,ry nalnl"d dl"fendElnt, . tD wit I -I1UllliliTI':pn:8,,1:A!JL..j~-.,,-_.- ~,lIlll-n nlloord:\.no ,(pr 1:1111 w:\.thin ------- . '" , 'lilt \l1~13 UnE1\lJl'! tr.. IDDate _------LL:LUI.-.--- :Ln his IHq..UWioll,' IIr~ there:fLll"e deputi.~ed thl'! f.lhedff of ()lille..lLUL-,...-~,----- Co\.lnly, pennl3ylvanil1, tCI serve tl1e withtn _.l~E.I.t!IJ.t-.lill:J~lJlli_...lill.Q_C:DJ1rJ"JlilIT.......-_---" --- , ~.-._-----_.._-_.-........~_..._-----...;.---_._.............--- ....---------~- On ..Jl!iptemhilL.J.5thL-~j).'2Q~_..._-_., tllia c.ffioe WllS tn reoeipt Df till? at taohed fE.tUfn :f.1'olll .~'____...D.l\.Ue1l1H.___..,_.___":':' County / 1'1~IHiiJy J vania. "I " I I I 8hl?ri.ff' a Coatu 1 Dool\l?ling Out of COllnty S\lrohargl~ pep, DUllphin CD p 'i' 113,00 9,00 (;,00 ~1(3, 2E'1 & \~I,~Ll\fm Iii i!;lJ7."0r5" MY C 1\ A . 09/1: , ,I' Sworn and I3UllElOrj. he.>J;~),t. ~:b8:flJl"~ me.> . I .;"" ,~"., ,,-1.1 ,'. lj.1!l .:1" r~ay of n1f..!1.J!!:(;.J~------- .\ <;] ...!LL_:.. ^ I P, " ,I." " ~.. C.:, 1....1u.....C1),--):I:IJ.C&.~-'=Mti_..~~.__.__. ,~ ro ~ lDnDt.i'H'y7 " ij " \, " " ,', n 1",; "I' r','; \/1 I" MYOIu\K GIilIJIH.,111 4 1'1111l-ll<lilR, V , q , py f R10hl\fQ p, 11I1I:t:!man, !1:r, J4E!ol:1UPA\:ipo ,Np" ~nn ~~p ~9"\:h~fQAP ~\:ree\: lil~"'V",!lt:h 1~~PQt' .. .Vhi. 1.,AQe:!..})h~a,. VA :\.9:\.P~ l~:\.lll 7;3!>~~3~Hi ,-., , I1PHN P J .MI\RI'IHA\"Jl-l Anq. 'l'IiIil1\NA MARI3IIAl'.tll, hep hlHlbAI1Q 113 01fP:!.e View Pr1Ve IUyl'lP\u:'S, VA :\.7/l~4 v, ' " RJ\.T.lVII 110HN RIUIM, fTR , ~l)3V'pl;'ge RPE\Q npiling Spring~,.VA 17P07 E\nd M:n.fl'.tElR ~ SPNS, :INO,. . 11/19 Boilingl3pl;'in~~.Road ,Mechania"'bur~, VA 17011S . and Vl\trIl V. MOtiAA'~IilOIilI'l UP 13, DUt'Ollt, Highway Aplu;otl11ent 4:;l7 N\1wOa",t::!.13, Olll 19720 'j' " , " ',I- 1\1:\:pmey fpl;' Naint.~,ff~ COUR'l' Of' OOMMON V~lill\a OUM~ElRLI\WP OOPN'l'V , I I , I { I , , I I , I I , NO, I 9r"'~d?~ 0. " ',,~ .11. ~ C') LO ORO r; co 0 .. . Tnlll: oorv rnOM Rr:!O . ' [BNi ~ '1 I" TOlilhnlll1Y wl1oro{lf, 11i/lln untl1llot rnyhnnd ." ~#I . r~ /H!Jt aT~dl tho 6.~'u (l~.~yllld~'iourt 'UIl;~rll,Slfo..P~~ "u' :'d.A' f,?il; ;:;; (:~j(~ 't" J - ~'.; <;) ',1 ..;.;h,.l .... , '.. 0''2'';> "v l. I IJ?' j;; \,.) t:lr {!J;:ij '. " ,Protl1o otnry , ", , ~ (\" (~i,frf NOT/C* . AVllo a: '~ , .V,. lit;' ""'. ,wI ... ,"", 1/,.... ..... ,. "","'........ ..... lit", "MI"'''' , ..,,, .. It ..". iii "',~'........" "" ",-,,,,,,,, "~th .~ ,... '''''n,.,... ......, ."" ""'''' ,.., "'1M "'.n...... .. nt.. ,., MI"'-. Il.....,~ ...' '" ""'~'" ...th," ''''~I. "" .." tI'ff ~ 1"","lIlt .... ..".....' ....... ~"ll 11II1.'"'' ro,." 1101 .... .. ""In" ....,.. ... " ...,...., h, ..t.".. . .nll" ...,.."..... .._" .. II, ""....." ....I... , .. ""'tIIIlOIkIo I"', filii ....",.. ..... "",,",,, to' ,110;I, .. .","" ..,~ ,... ,..." ,.., .If'...... .. ....,." .," m,," . .~ "",.., 01" .. ....,,;,, , 10""" . ,..... ''',,"' ,~ .. ". ... ..' .... ....... "" ....... ""~. ." II! "..... .. ... '....".... . .., .....1 I,. ... I ,..... ""...,., .... ,...It .."... ......~"~ ...."" . ...._ ... ........, '"' Ii ....11'..... "","."",..,,,......,,Jot........'........M..........'... . ..,.....,.. III" ........ ........, "".., ,""'....... .....""., ." "" ""M '.....M .... 0, "', ...... ...th.., ...n.... ..nt".... " "''''' ...u ...""..tI.... ~'" IN., let...., '''''re III .., ""'It, ...,I'M.... ".. ,...,....,.. lei .. ,..t, "".. ..\14. . II.... ... ......,..t,', ........'..... ., ......, ,..... II .....' ,",,"It' 0, ,lIt ;II"'''", V....., ..... ""''', ,... ...... '-' ....._, . "I."'""",. ,..... "h.. ......, II "",.,., !II Ilhtt "" """""' '0 ',,", ...... ..,... .."',. .. lot ,...." . "'..~ .11...... .~nll ~rnltL" ,.., '"'~ 'AH II "' VCMlII LAWV.. .......,....,,, .... "'I' II' ''''''t, II ""' pn IIn' "II \It II L."YU 011 C'1I111f11" ""''''t "'A ,..,..111111 " .11I 1I1Ii1.AlII' .11 """.n nlll. '111 m nil ","","011' ,"I .,.n.n '''"4'~ ..,~ II 1l,!!tril-11l1 -""1411' II lit HlI Hllllll II lOW '0 flNn n\rt "NUl VCMl ell" en ..':J1aO Ii.":. ~tO"rnwA"D'~"':' "~W.., "WI ' 1"111'11I". " ;i CWln"''' NW~. 1I11'C\'!IllI II, 111I '''''''''A. .., ,lUt ItA ""10 '..A I\liU",U,,1I 1lUl<f1ll .. "" 1M t'Ol nl... "'"UlIf'" Un4'" ' . ~u~~~~=~=~j!~~~~oe!.~\{\'l'~\t!.'tl court Admihhtrator C^Rr.IBt~'tlllMulfJ()l~ .: .... Cumber1~M Couhty court Ilouse (717) 2t1itU~o.tll I',1..l.HoQ , 3rd rlDor CiU:U.a1'.. 'PA ',"l1lD3, , , 4, P13flf3nclfmt: PAUl, I), MOUIU\TI1lJ1DIj ill 0111 AI:lHl\: imHv.1cl\1C\+ l:'a~iqil1g flt: l4P /3, Puflop\: ll!qhWAY, lIpArt:IOl'Jnt: ~;l?, N~w Cfll3\;l,a, PelllWfI'!:"e 19?;lO, 6, ,I\t. A+1 t:.1me~ ma\:er:l.al here\:o Peflenq'\!1t: IW.fI?H 110111'1 RIJlHM, IIf~, WI\I3 Ancl il'l I\n Agen!:, elnp:\'oyee, Worl~men fll1cl perVlInt: o~ PejjenclAnt: MI~~IJlR ~ QPN/3, INC, , .. aomf.l' X Il'OIm J.1 I JoI~"'lmlll'.f V.I RALPli .:TOlJN RlllllM, .:TR . Ii, p:\.A~nt:Hfl 110111'1 fl, Ml\R/3I1I1i.i~1 herepy ;\,noprpOl:'At:el'l Py rejjal:'enae P!l;j:'A9;j:'OIphl3 one (1) t.h;j:'ough fli ve (6) inolUl3:!.ve 0113 t.hough 1'l00ma wara l3et. flort.h.OI1: 1engt:h herein. 7, on or APout MOlY 21, 1997, at: APpro~imat:elylfOP p,m,. Pldntiff 1I0liN p. MJ\RSIIl\LLJ W!\13 a pal3l3enget' of A 199.7 Nil3l3l\l1 when,. ,it: W/lI3 reAl'endl3d py a Ol\r operat:ed Py DefendAnt MI-tPH.:TOliN RIilHM, JR, <lnd owneq by Defendant: MII,I,IilR & /301'1/3, I!\jC" O. fit: the aforel3aid time and plAoe, DeJ;endant MI,PlI JOliN.. RlilliMI JR, WElI3 negligently operAting 1\ motor vehiole owned Py pefendant., MILLIilR & SON/3, !NC, whioh l3udqenly and without' " warning W!\13 caUl3ed to violently I3tril~e the vehicle oooupying " Ii Pldntiff JOlIN P, MJ\RSH1\LI, il\the reflr whioht'el3Ulted in /levere and l3erious perl30nul injuriel3 to ~ll\intiff, 9. The 1991.Qhevrolet, Sohool DUf,l,bearing A Pennaylvania , , ~l RelJ!l3tratitm Number /3B17649, owned by Defendant MILLIiJR & SONSI " n~c, wasoarelessly and negl.'igently operAt:ed by Defendant: lU\LPH . JOlIN RIilHM, JR. when itv:l.olently struok the vehicle oqoulJyil19 Plaintiff JOliN PI M1\RSH1\LI, in the rear whioh caused the /Jevel:'B '" . ," , , inj4ria~ ~p rlA~n~iff ~~ ~6~ fp~~h mora flllly belPW, lP, f\f.l A ref:14H Pf ~l1e APPye-l11en~ipneq 11101,:01' vehiole f\ooiqen\: I PlA~n\:Hj: f:1\1P~f\in(lC~ VAdp\1fl peraom~l inj4fief3 ~nq " " inp\lp:'eq verioUIi' metHod' e~penaea in ~nq ~bo\1l: anqe~vo+inl'l ~.P. Q4re, h~m!3elfof af\~,(~ injurief3, more f411y qlif30ripeq hereinAf\:er, 11, Pefenq~n\: MI~LmR ~ ~ONa/ INC, knew or ahp41Q hAye Imown \: hFl I: Pllj:c;lndAnl: MIII'II .,:JollN RElIIM ( ,:Jft, WAf:1 An ope~'A~or who repe~l:eqlY~rivef:1 in A oAreleaf:1, negligen~anq reoklef3f3 m~nner, 1;:1 t The AforepAid aoourre\1pe And thc;l inh\.r!o!3 to " P1Ainl: Hf ,:JOliN p, Ml\RIUH\I~r, we1'e oauf:1ed !3olely by the negligenoe I' , PAreleaenepp And reaklef:1ane!3!3 of Pefendf\nt inl A) ,Failure to ob!3erye trat:fia aontrol devioe!3l )J) FAilure to properly operate and oontrol their vehiole I ' , . , , 0) ill f) Failure tp yielddght of way \:,0 trAffia I Fl:d.lure to J~eep a proper lookout 1 Fai~ure to trAvel at A !3afe !3peed under the oir04m!3tanOe!31 ' Failure to give proper and suffioient warning off\pproaoh, g) Fail4re to operate a'vehiole w;\.\:,h d\.\e . . reg~l:d for the rights, f,lAfety and well being for otheri'll h) Failut~ to operate f,laid vehiale in.!34oh a manner so as to be able to stop ..within t;he aSsured ole~r dif,ltanae ~head, , -, I' q) e) " " " i) Fai14re to maint~in a safe dietariae from. P1AintUf 1 j) Failure. to warn and proteat .Plaintiff from dangerous aonditions which have aaused serious peraonal, injUries I' , , ~) ViolAting ~he Vf\r.j.ol.HI r\.l:j;ef3 of I:he rOll~, Or~inAnOef3 of the commonweAlth pC f'13!Hlf3yl.vrmiA anA/or wH:h regArd to the operAtion oC fl oommon OArr.j.el: ,"Peor veh.j.ol13 Ilpon p\.lpHo highwAY, ~~, ~olely Af3 1'1 ref3ul.t, of, the negligenoe o~ the .Coref3f\iel pefBn~f\nt I t:he vehiole oooup.j.e~ PY .f':j;A~,nt.j.fC !101lN l?, MM~IiAT-!T-! WFltl cA\.lf3e~ to pe yiolent:ly f3trl\ok. in t:he rflAr Py A motor vehicle ref3\.lHincr in f.lerioU!3 <m~ pAinf\.ll. perf3pnAl inj\.lrie13rinPhlq.imJ, P\.ll:. not limi\:eq t:o dhi'lin13I3f.l1 haAclAOhef31 ElPrA!3ion Al)out: the heAd f\rl3f\ I oe:rviaEll 13prain f1ncl t:ltrf\in I neal~ pdn Anel n\.lmpnel3f3/ " , t:\.ngHng in ArlHt:l' And n~ol~, 111, M Afurl:.ner ref3ql\: of t:hh Eloaident: I l?ldnt:Hf !1ollN l?, M1\RI3IIA~,llinaurred a f3Bvere t:lhopk; to hi!3 nerve!3 and nerVo\~!3 !3Y!3tem, great: phy!3ica;J. p<lin And ment:al Anllui!3h Anel WA!3 preV€lnted from Attending t:ohi!3 uaUf\l dutie!3, aativitie!3 and AvoOAtiorif.lt All of which may continue t:o an indefinite t:ime in the ~eAr fut:Ure, , Hi 18, l\.a a direct: And proximate J;"ef3ult: of. t:he neg:),;l.genoe /l!!l af~rement:ioneel, Pldntiff JOHN P, MARI3HA~r. hA!3 or mAY I3Uffer A f' " !3eyere 101313 of eArninga, OInd il~pairment: of hi!3 eArning cApaaity or power, whioh fluah, io~a of inaome and/or impAirment of earning o<lpaait:y 01;' power mAY oontinue J:or <In in~eUnite period into the . fl.\ture, '16, '1113 A' direct AndP reasonable rel3ult of th\3 aforementioneq Aoaident t PlAintiff JOHN p, MAnI3HlI~L may have or may hereinafter aonl:inue to, inour J: inanoiAl expe\ll3es, or losses Which' do or may" exceed amounts whioh he may otherwise be 'entitled to reoover. " " if , . 17, 'fHJ A cl~l:flO\: flnq proXimfl\:a I"OJl\IH p~ \:hp Ilfqrol1,ent:~(:m13cl inai~llnt: flnel l:he lnjl-lriafJ An!:! clAmAgellll\Hl\:R~naqby ~~Ain\:Ht !10HN f, . M1\IlI311I\TJLl hAil baan Anel/or ml'lY pe aompeJ,lael t:q expanq mOni131l tor macliol\l Alcla, 111flclioin13 anel/ol" ot:hal" .Ilimilar maMaAl 'find/or madioAllY rela~adinfJt:rl-lman\:ali\:i13fJflncl/or mocll'llit:iall, lQ, petanclant: il'! I'!olaly !:j.l.\pla for Pll.\ln\.:.if.f' Il injur~.efJ qal'laripecl haraiOI in~l'lmuoh AI'! pldntif.f.'p injllriaa al"a \:he. cUreo\: an~ Proximat:e rflfJUl\: of hill neaHaenol'l, pl.\relef.lanaall ancl r130kleaanel'lfJ AI'! fJat: fOrt:h APoVq, WIlIllRJ.ilro'ORIi1, I'l<\int::l,ff ~OIlN p, MJ\RI3I11\IJLl clemf\nclp clAmllgefJ of Pefend.mt: MLlPII ~OHN RliIHM, an, for a flum in ex:oelll'! ot: 'l'went:y" ~~ive Thoul'lanel (~:a5, aD!), 00) DollC\rfJ, plul'! OOl'!l:fJ, clelay clFlmflgea, find int:llrel3l:, OOUN'!' IJ: JOJrn P, ~~nalfJ\.t.r. v. MILLBR & SONS. 11'10. 19, Pll.\int:if f JOHN p., MI\RI3HlIr...l!, h13repyinoorporfll:ea bl' ret:erende pflraarapha one (1) t:hrough eighteen (18) inolupive all " ' t:hough l3ame Ware set forth at: length herein, ;aO"At the afior.esdQ time and plaoe, Defendflnt M~IPH JOHN Hli1HM, . JH, fJucldenly I'\nd Wi,thout warning I3truclt tha veh:l.ole " occupying ~~la.intiff JOUN 1,>, MI\UI3IIALL in the rear crl3ating a. cll;JngeroUfJ fino hflzarQous aituation which ral3ult;ad :l.n a~Vara injuries to Pl_intit:fa, , 21, At. "U times mCltadal heret:o, DafanQflnt:, Mlt.jLElH & SONS 1 INC., Wae. the oWnt;lr of a: 1991 Chevrolet: I sohool nus,' " ~earina II PennsylvAnia Regist:r.ation Number SI317649, 2;a I Defenoant MIL1,lDR .& SONS, INC,' Wa/3 negligent:, oareleaa " ;/ , . Pf3fen~~n\: IlI\l~PII HOlm H1illIM, IJR" ~ml pwnl3Q PV Pefflnr.lf\n\: M~f.tf.tJjJIl 1iI ~Ptm, mo" 117, M A" rall\1~,I:pf \:hoAl:lov~~mon\:ioner.l mo\:p!;, vehip~ll f1opilifln\:, "?:\.Ain\:Hf ~I1P\:Ained vIH'ipuf.l pl3r!'1onal in~~lrie~ flnr.l inpurred variPI1~ meM,OAl expen~e!3 in flnc\ IlPout: Bndf3Avorina \:0 Pl1re himl'lalt oC f.lA:l.d injuri1313, more f"lly c\ef3ol'!P13c\ hereinaC\:er, ;.111, 'l'ha Ilforef3dcl ooourral1oa And \:lw injur!all \:0 v~~in'\:iff. irOHN ~, MlIRI'lIlJ\T.I~ ware OAUf3en f.lOlelyl:ly \:he naaligamle I Parllle"'f.lnel'll'l Ann reclrlal'll'lnelll'l"Of Paf.annan\: in, railHre \:0 oPl'lorve ~rAffio 0011\:1'01 devio~"" rAilura \:0 properlY OparAr,a Andppntrol \:heir vahi.olel . . . Ji'llil\.lra \:0 yil3lcl right: of WAY \:0 trAffio, rllilUl'e IlO Iteep a proJ,JB,rloo!tou\;, FailurE! to tr.wel at a I'lafel I'lpeed under t.he cirp\.Imel:4noeel. .' .' Fflilure \:0 give proper Ann f3l1ffioient Warning of approaoh, rllilure to bperAte A vehiole wi\:!) nue i regArd for the righte, I'lafety and well peing for othere, ' h) _Allure \:0 OPerat.e I'laid vehicle inl'luoh a manner ac AI'l to be able to sllop within \:he af3l'lureQ clear dia\:Ahce ahean, i) Failure to maintain a 'I'lafe dietanoo from plaintiff, j) Failure. to Warn and prot.eot plaintiff from dangerous oonditionl'l whioh have oaUI'led serious perl'lonal injuriea, ,It) Violating the var;\.oue l;'uletl of the, road, ol;'dinancel'l of the Commonwealth of P,ennl'lylvania and/or with' regard' tq the operation of a oommon oarrier motor vehicle upon public highway, a) " ~1) Q) d) i' " e) f) g)' j{ " " " I ~'", f!ll, 13\"J+Pl.Y iHl f\ ~\3I'l\-\H. \"Jf ~ha IWaUgamm pf ~hfl f\~prpl'l~~4 PI3~el1clAn\:, 1?+f\;\:n\:H~ t10lm I? I MI\.\H1Ii~~r~ WIHl PflHl'lpcl t:ppa vio+anl:l.y ,.. t filt:r.\.lcJ~ ~n ~',ha faflf py f.' mot:l:W vf3hipl.a J:"aa\.lH~n\1 ill flf3r:l,p\\1'l Allcl pa~nf\\l. farf30nal. '~nj\.lr~\3I'l, ~IlPl.\\ding, P\.l~ not limit:flrt nap~ Allcl \.Ippar pao'~ pain I ~!l, ~I'l a f\.lr\:l18r rEHil~,l.I: Pt: thh aoPi(.lent:, I?l.alntit:f t10HN J;l, M1\RI3I1ALJ.t inC;l\.Irreq' ~ I'lavere ahoP~ ~o hil'l Ilaryl'll'l Anq nf3rYP\.I,,,, ~YI'lt:l'lm, great: phYl'lipAlpain ami mental. ang\\il3h f.'ml wall prevanEaq frQm a\:t:ending t:Q hiP \.If-Hlal qnt:lef3, AO\:ivit:l.efil and I\vPoA~iQnl'll i:\U of whiph mAY qpnt::I.n\.le t:P An incleUnite time in the n"'a~ 'I ,1:\.I,\:ure, 31, ~13 A direot ancl pro~imAt'" ~eflUl.t o~ the negligenqe aa i:\~Qrement:;ionecll \?laint:iff ~TOIIN P, MAR/:JHJ\lIL haa or I11RY l3ufl:"'l:" fl ' l3evere 1013'" ,pf,l3arningl3, ancl impairment: of hil3 earning PApaoit:y pr power" which auoh 101313 at: inoome anc:1/o'r i!lIpa:l.rmenl: of ei:\rning qapaoity or power may oontinua for an indefinite pe1;'iod intp t:he fut:ure, 32, ,l\s a, clireat and reafilonabl.e reflul\: of. the aforementianecl aooiclent, Plaintiff t10llN p, tIIARSHAJ,L may have or may hereinafter qontinue to inour finanoial e~penaefl or loeeea ,whioh do at may I'l~oeed amountl3 whioh he, may o\:herWi/:le be entitled to reoover, ' 33, J\~ a clireot and prodmfll:e reault:. of the aforementioned inoident and t:he ',injurief'l and damages auatdned by pldntiff ' Jom~ .,p, tIIARSIIAJ,L hM been and/or may be oO!11pelled to e~pl'lnd monies for medioal. aide, medioine and/or other similar medioal and/or medioally related inatrumentalitiel3 and/or modalitief'l, " " I,', , .. " H " P!'l'j:~nq"'n\:: ill ~pl13ly H~p~13 fpr Na!n\:ieff!l inj\.lri13!l rl\'l!lprip~q h!'lt"(:l:\.n, im\!lm\.lph All "'lf1:\.n~Hff!l inj\.lr:l.e!l A;re \::he ~:l.rep\:: aml J;!rodmAt.~ re!l"l\:: Pf hill J1~llUgenqe, CF\rete!l~nl!lll!l 14M reok:l!'l!l!ln~!l!l all Illlll: fpr\::h f.\POv~, IfflIilRJilf'OIHll, V1a:l.n\::iff aOtlN "', Ml\IlBJW-tH ql'lmanct!l QAmagfil!l of peft'lnclan\:: J?AIJl.l ~, MOUIU\'~JilPlill3 eOl-"' a rmm in e:jc:Cfill'Hl pf IfWen\::YMfiv\'l '.l'hml!lAncl (~I1Ii,OOO,oo) Ppllar!l, plnll qPl'lt:Il, clfillay. QAmAgel'l ijn~ in\::er131'1t: " " OOlTWI' ;J;n 'rn~ "M\IJ~!:.J1 v. ~Lr.. DIII'BND~S " ~Ii t Pldntife, 'l.'HIDANI\ MM/:lHA1'-!T" IlllrePr incor~ara\::e!il by rf.lfE!rence \::Oe al1!!Qa\::ianl'l' containecl :I.ll varagrflphl'l one.' (1) through.' thirt;YMfp\.Ir (34) inCl\.ll'live AI'l \::hough the I'l/.\m!! were !ilet forl:h at' lengl:ll nerdn, 36, 1\t all \::im!!a mater.i.f.ll here\::p, Plainl::\.ff THIilAWA MAIl/:lH1I.HL wa$ and contillUe$ to be \::he wife of plAilltiff, JQI-IN 1.", . MAIl/:lIIALIl $inol'l ancl before the /lccident. clfil$cribed herein and wa!il \'lntit:lecl to tile care, l':Iociety,. l'lerviCBS, camp/lnionl'loip /lnd " I' oanl'lortium 'of her hUl3band, 37. As a clirecl: and relHlopable' re$ult of theinjuriea I'luffered by ner h\.lsbllnd, .' Aa afol:el3dd, PlAinl:i~f,. THlilANA MAIlBI~Il hal3 and will in the ful:ure cqnl:inue 1:0 suffe~ the 101313 of the care, sooiety, ul'lud services, oompaniol1l'lh:\.p and oonl3ortium of her hU/3band ~nd haa been fUr.l:her required 1:0 provide special servioes and care to her, 3D. ,As fl direot and proximate re$ult of t;hs afo>:ementioned , , ilididentand the injtirisl3aiuidahlagaasuatahiecl by JOHN ' 1>; , , '!I"" MYCHAK G8CKLm & W~LKru~, P,C. 13y, H:lalwrd 13, 13nl:GlI\an, ,Jl:, Ic\lll1dUol1t:lon No, I G1131 230 f:lo\lth BrOEul StrGet l;n. eVG n I: h 1;'1 DOl.' Ph:1.1ndqlpl1in, "A :\ Ul02 (21[i,) '13[i-332G Al:tornay for ,PI<1inl:iff~ ' -------~.._----~~---*--_._--_._----... ,JOHN p, M/WI:3IlAI.,I., flll{1 'l'HlilAl'lA MlWi3!lAl,I" her h\lpbnncl COllg'l' 01" cOMMON PJ.,8AS CUMlmlu,AND COUN'l'Y I I I , I , I I , I !\IO, I 98"3993 " v, ~AI.,P11 ,TOliN lUJlIM / JH, <\11 cl Mll.,l,lillt & SONS / INC, <1nc\ PAUl, P, MOl1HA'l'mDIilI'J , f" .QJ.llllitlnQM'1!l....QlUIJilllYJ;.QJ.ll I, In CIIAIW 13. I3A'l'ElMAl'l, JR 1/ mSQUlItru, of MYCHAK GElCI(l,lij & WEll~Kmll, ,p,C., i\tto~'nGY for P1E"d.nUff:s, c\uly oertify that on FGbr~ary 2, 1999 I served a Complaint in Civil Ao~ion upon the person and in the mnnner indicated below, whioh servioe satisfies t~e requirements of the R~les of civil Prooec\ure, a true and oon:eat oopy of the SEllne in the United states lI1E\il, Ii Cert1f:ied Man ~eturn Receipt Reqll(~8ted E\llc\ i"i1:st Class Mail/ postage prepaid at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and addressed tOI Paul P, Mouratedes .15-31 Amstell Drive New CEwUe, Dm 19'720 1)l\'l'mD, -3J,.~/)9 _ MYCHAK OffiCKLU & wmLKBR, P.C, "--.. I' --_._~::':":'c"7~>:'-=:::::::::''".::'''':::::-:.::;;''''':;-;''-~-1 By, . ':2:..-'. ,/", . .... .._ L_ .. Le-' . ----R"ICllMD' O';d h)\ii1fuMJ\N~ -JR., ,EJSQU~B Attorney for Plaintiffl3 /7 " "" " " , f',!! '0 " ,/ " " " (I !,'; ,t, " i; I, i' " ,;" ti j; I"! Ii " " /' "..I i' '" " " " ,; " " " ,I' " 'j' H 'I . II,' Ii " " " ;1' 1", 'i '0 ;; I' 'I I'; "\ !) ,': I' 'I' " ,', r li,1 ti Ii " (") ~J n r" ",\ ,. ,n .'~ :.\ '11\';\ ,.'1'> ',l.~ i'.\r1 01\.\,\ ':'<.) f, \\i\ .- \\o~ (~) ,I;'. \;1'~ (1 c~~ i: l I ;II:,~ ~'r.l ,I. ~ ~i'~.i') :'\I~ ::.W, .~ . r:) r,'? '.i;"~i~ (1j r.: ,'.II \11 m "" " " ',',; Ii " :" " II, " " ,', " I, " COUNT IIW1lliNJ!J_MAltlitIAlJ v. l'AUt, ~n~].l1llfi 25, No r~15pnn5U rpqulrod, 2fi, ponlBlI. Aflur rUi15olll1hlulnvu5\llli1t1on, i\l15worlng l)ofoncli1nl 15wllhp\II l<nQwloclBP prll1fnl'l.l1illlon 5\lfflclonl In forl11 i1 bllllof i15 In Ilw 11'11111 ofllw nllog'lllons suI fprlh III pi\!'.llll'ilph 2liJlf 1'II11nllff5' C0l11pli11nl, iIIHI \l1Urofpl'P, .1115worlnll I)ofonclilnl donlos Si11110 ill1d dOl11i\l1ds slrlcI pronfll1oroof ill 11'1111. 27, IJonlorl. Arlur r0i150!lnhlnll1vOSIIBi1llpn, nl15worlng pofonclnnl Iswllhrnll 1<l1pwlodgo or Inforl11l1tlon 5\lfflcloI1( In forl11 i\ bollof i15 10 tho Inllh pf Iho i1llogi1llons 501 fprlh i '. In pi1l'i1gmph n of PI.llntlffs',Col11plnlnl, nnd \l1Oroforo, I1n5worlnll Pufondnnl clonl05 5111110 I1nd c1ol11i1nds slrlc\ proof Ihoroof ill Irlnl. 20(i1) Ihrqllgh (I,), Ponlod. Tho ,1Vorl11onls of pi1mmilph 20(n) Ihl'ollllh (k) 51,110 conc!llslnn5 of Inw 10 which no r1l5pnnslvo plondlngs ilro noc05s~ry, ilnd 111Oroforo, nro" " . donled, 13y WilY of fLlnhor I'osponso, It 15 spoclflci1I1Y dOllied Ihnt nnsworlng pofondi1l1\ (nlled to obsorvo Irilfflr. control dllVlcosl filllod 10 proporly npornle ilnd conlrol his vohlcle) fcillod I? ylold Iho rlghl-of-w,iw 10 tl'llfflq fnllod to kl10p n propor 10okOllll fi11Ir/,d \0 \ri1Vol i11 iI snfo . spood L1ndor Iho drtLll11s1nnC05j fi1llrld Ie Blvo prOPQr ilnd sllfflclont wilrnlng of ilpproilclll 'fillled 10 oporille sillel vohlcle wllh dlloregill'd for tho rights, snfelY nncl woll bolngef o\hol'sl , I', fnllod 10 opol'lllo snld vohlclo In sLlch n l11ill1l1OI' n5 to bo "blo 10 slop ,n Iho ilssllrocl c;lllor dlslill1co ilho{\clJ fnllod 10 111i1lnlnll1 n snfo dlslnnco fl"Ol11 plnlntlffl filllocl 10 worn ond pl'olocl I'lnlnllrr fro 111 dongol'oLls conrllllon5 which hnvo nllogedly cilllsorl 501'10115 InjLlrlesl ilnrl vlolnled ony Vill'lollS 1'11105 of lhiJ rand nnd ordliH1I1cos of Iho C0ll11nonwoollh 6f " 1'0nl1sylvonli1, i1nd Ihol'dol'o, 5poclflc proof lhol'oof Is dllll1i1ndml ill 11'101. iI " 2 1.Il, POlllod, Tllo ,lVIll'll10lllH PI' pill'i\lll'ilpl1 ~\l.Hlillo r:l,lI1CllIBlpIlH of lilW 10 whlcl11l0l'oHpOllHlvo pllliHIII11lH 1II'OlHICIIHHiII"Y, illHI iI 111 1'111'0 I'P, mo dOl1ll1d, :10. !Jlllllml, AfI\lI'I'II,'HOI1i1bloII1VIIHllllil\loll, i\llHWlIl'll11l !Joflll1d,lIl1IHwIIIHlll\ 1<I1owludl\u PI' Illfonllillloll H\lfflrlllllllo 1'01'111 iI bpllof ilH 10 11111\1'11111 of tl10 illlol\illloll,H Hili fonl1 , IIlPi\l"ilnri\PI1 :10 of 1'lillllllffH' CIII11plill111, illlrlllllll'lIfol'o, ill1HWOl'll11\ !Jofoll\lillll dllllluH Hillll\l , ill1r1 dlll11lll1dH 511'Icl I1l'llpf Il1ol'uof ill 11'1,,1, 31, !JlIlllml, T1101lW1'I1101l\H of l1i\1'i1!\mpb 31 Hlil\1I ~:ollcl\IHlpllH O(IilW 10 .. which 110 I'OHp0l15lvol1lu"dll11l5 i11'1I l1ocUH5ilI'Y;' illld Ihul'fJfol'o, ill'O r1onlml, , J~, j)ulllorl. Aflol' I'Oil5011illllo IllvoHllUililol1, i\llHWlll'll1!l!Joflll1r1ill1\15WI\ho\1\ 1\l1owlo.dl\ll 01' Il1fol'111illlol1 HLlfflclullt 10 fOI'Illi\ 1101l0f "H 10 111~ 1 nil 11 of Ihoi1l1o[\illlollH 501 fortl1 Illl1il1'ill\mpl1 3~ of Plrill1l1ffH' cUlllplilllll, illld thol'ufol'll, i\115WIlI'II1[\ !Juful1c1i1Il\ d0l11oH 5i\1110 i\11~1 dlll11llllds Htl'lcl proof lhul'ooi' III Il'lill. , :1:1, pUl1lud, Altul' l'oi\HOllil\llo IllvllHtll\iltlol1, ill1HWorll1g !Joful1dillll Iswlll1o\11 kllowlod!\u 01' Il1fonlln\loll sLlfflelol11 10 1'01'111 il bollo( ilH 10 Iho 11'11111 o( Iho illlol\il\lol1H sot 1'01'111 III Pill'i1!\l'ilph 3:1 o( l'I~II1I1(f5' COl11plilllll, illld 11191'01'01'0, illlSwol'll1l\ lJofol1dill11 donlos Hill110 , ',' ill1d c10111nl1d5 511'IcI proal' Ihol'(lll( nlll'li\l. 34', !Jol1lod. Tho ilVOl'I1101115 of pi1l'ill\l'ill1h 34 sli\lo C0l1ClllSlol15 o( Inw 10 which no I'ospollslvo plondlngs'i\I'o nOCOS5i11'Y, i\nd Ihol'o(ol'O, nro donlod, WHEllHOllE, IJU(Ondilnt I'mill'. M()UI'i1tudos dOl1lilnd5 /lIdlll11on( bo ontol'ocl III his f"vol' ilnd ill\illnst I'l,llntlff Johl1 1', M,ll'shilll, pillS C,05\5 ilnel O\IHlI' 5L1ch I'ellof lhilllhl~, Court de0ll15 lllst illld "11111'0111'1"10, :l " I' ;if '" , " I.. " " " ,,' ", " I; , " ,j" (i . IJ (., \.0' 'I' ~_'lt ' I " " I I '''J , Ii, i;'\,: .,,-, , ,) ,., ') , ,\ " , I .1 " I 1(,,1 "n 'I~ I " \: : ~ ( I , N ",I .' f. '.J " ',J ,,'(j' ") ::~ , ~p . ' "; ii " " , "I' If ;" " 'Ie 11' " Ii ,{I " .' II' Ii" " /'," " I' " " "r' " " f,' " " I " ,-,; -i, ji j: I' "; " " ,{' ,', " II' " " " ,; "I' "I " " ;' " " j, !' Ii " ii " " 'I' " I,; ',i '; ~ i " " ,; " \I '1: " " " " " " ;; !' ," " , " ;; ," " " " I' " IJ .I' ,,' " " ;Ii " " " 1\ I' ,; " " ,n tn' ("." \',; IJ.l l\ ,,' :1i~ "T' .....,h.l rllli\ J_'"' ,: \'1\ , ."'jl"" ,.... "\1) " '.'i - t./!' \fJ; " r:'- '\\'1 Ij;. I,-)i \111 , : r.!"\ ,t', j "".ltJ ').. ,.' ,,,'\1\ L Ii '.~ -.\ ~'::~ 1 'I ;'-'" ~}j F.'., CJI "''t 'I " , " " 'ji ii ,"i " " " ;i "', . ' Ii I' " I' 'r, (':' \ """( 11/,\]'1 " , ('" " 'If " .\ I) I "I" I,ll \;j I. 9'.1 r-:il': ' 1 '" I'I'\'I"'[V CU1/ci)'I,l.l'\J.1 ,.J.} 1,' I'H'~I J~,'ILI/NlI/\ f' " " " '" " " " , " ", Ii "f ,,", , I' " " " " ,. '" , " 'i " i'" " , , ~" ~ '''/ ~....... '..;; ~ I i I ' Ik I ~ ! I! " ,. f I~ ~, P . " ~ ' in\:e):l:9CH\\:odOfJ. fJ:\.mili\dy! POl\llfJyl.ymdn !l\llp. of ciyq ProrH3Q\lnJ 1\00ll (b) (;1) proy1c1c'JfI the\l: "\:Iw pi\r\:y 1l\10n whom IA l't!lCjllOt:l\: for lwoc1\\o\:J.on of; dOO\lmC3l\tp] ,h~ ueryed f.lh<\U f.Ierve A wd\:ten reapomle wJ.\:\]in I:hirty (~O) rjnyf.l qf;\:er \:\]13 f.Iery10e of: \:he reqL\t1at / 'e~clept I:h<l\: il cjrJf:e\1Qn\1t I\\uy servo <I reillJOnl'le wH:!lin forty-f1ye (45) dilYP after Borv1oe of the or10inn1 procef.lp upon, h1m. " P\\P3\,\Ur\\: to t\lerJO \:'1l113f.1, \:\le clefendilnt:' S \:C:lf.lpOnf.lC:lf.l 1;0 plAintiffs' 1nterroga~or1ep, C:l~pert interrogatorJ.ep anc\ reques\: for pl'oduc\:J.on,of ~ooumentp were due on or befqre May 9/1999, No respOnperJ have been rode1ved to t\]ifJ d1f.lcoVel-Y reqL\ef.ltf3. Pennpylvc\\11E1 gulB of C1vH ProceC\ure 11019 provj,dep A 13 i folloW/3 I (<I) (1.) 'l'\1e Court, \nAY, on modon / \nElI,e <\n appropriate order J.f (~) A, party fElHf3 to /3el:ve ilnawers, f3L\fficient ill1f.lwer13, .or olJjectiona to wdtten interrogatoriea under !{ule II 005/ [or] (yB) A pal:.ty, 1n reaponf.le to a reque/3t for produotion or j.nl3peo\:.1.on made un8er Rule 11009, faile to re/3polid the inl'lpeot:J.on will be ~ermittBd aa requested or fElil/3 to permit inl3pectlol1 as l-equested, . . , I.., , PuraUan~ to thls ~ule, plaintJ.ffs request thAt thia Court ent~r an order oompellingthe defendant to provide anaWers to their interro\Jatod.~B and expert: i.nt:erro~atodea wi.thin . thirty (30) . daya or auHer 'auch sunct.1.onl3 CIa thJ.s Court \nay deem , , " appl:opri.ate., 'rhe 'defendants' l-esponsea \:0 t,hef.le discovery requests are overdue and 110 di.acoyery .1.n the form of responses , ' \:0 plaint:J.Hs' lnl:en~ogatodes haye be~n recei.yed by pldnt:J.ffe' oOUl1sel. Wit:ho~t the defendant'a dJ.soovery .~eapol1ael3/ oounsel 1'01: plai.nt:l.f:fa Are' unable to move f:orward and/ol- evaluate \:his , I t ('I) 1:.\1(') flU!JpoPIlfW whioh W,i.ll be uOI:ved ~ro icl(Jl1t::I.(J~l \:0 1:\1I~ fl\lPpoellf.1fl wh.irJII ,11:0 i.1ttr\Uhorj to \:\10 Not.i,Jp 01: Jllt(;lnt to serve t\1epUbpoonnn, .. DAtfll ,Jqlll'l l.;'" I 2000 I> MlIIWOI.:L f3 H:PIB1IS'!'HlTN ) , ", I)/, ,V J By 1~{:tL'i.;:t(11~__,_ " ~ .~~Pl!en fl': 13f\nko, .11:.". XtLoLney I,p, No, 11/21 " r, 0, 130x 932 UAl:dpbql:g, I'll 17l08-0932 3810 Tr.indloRo~d OAllIP II.Ul, PI\ 17011 (717) 9'15-0)1,11 ( 'Il 'I ) 975 " 0 1 ;3 '1 'l~lIX " Coqnpel for De1:~ndantfll RAlph John I,shln, JI:, C1l1cl M.qlej: & Sona, . :r.na, ;, 1. " , " I' /1 " " ,II :" d ' I, " ';, ii' " " II " ,. I',' 'I " , I' " 2 ';1 " " , ( " r;'~IU'l.El.QA'l'm Ol~ SI!JHVlm:l I'11erepy aa+'t:ify l:h~t I hewe porve(~ (\ t:1.'\.\0 <lncl correat: aopy II ,I pf the foregoing clocument: on <Ill aounsel of reaorcl by,pl~aing t:ho El~me in I:h~ \lnitecl Sti\tes MAil 1\t: Ci\mp Hill, PennsylYi\nb, firpt:- al(:\l'l!3 pOElt:i\ge nrepi:\icl, on the -t.''-~ cl~y at Mi1Y, flOO~, i\clclro!3s~cl M3 follows I RiClhA1."d B, l31\tol1\1\n, ITl:" [;Jsquire Myahi1k, Geakle & Welker, PIC, ;;l30 South BroAd Street, 11th L~loor Phil1\Qelphi1\, PA 19102' " (CounElel for Plaintif~sl John c, SWArt., Jr" Rsquire Law OffiaeEl of Wesley H, Payne Hilll'lide Corporate Center 5001 Louise Drive, :a~ rloor Meahaniasburg, PA 17056 (Coun~el for Defendant, Paul P, Mouri1teqes) '.,1. t, ~ ,-,.., '":' '/,~d Barbara J, Sl1\ith,iearetClry ,,1- j' Ii , ,I' " " ,.. " , " I' J'I II 1\ Ii I, " " ~'.U..r.I..::lm~ cw SI~Il.V],CI~ I ,hereby cert:~,fy l:h.\l: ''1 hi\Vo Bl'lryeq iI l:t"qe "!lq correa\: copy of.\:!le f.ot"agping qocumanl: on <111 CO~1I1!H3l of i;ecord by p~i\cing l:he !I.Mla in I:he uniyeq Sl:i\tea MqU <It: CiI\1IP Hill, l'ennsylVani<1, t:it.s\> cl<\s13 pos\:age prep<licl, on ,l:he 1(.) cl<1Y of Mi\Y, ;1000, <1c\ql"eS13ec\ " <Ie folloWI3! .' "", Riah<lzq B, Bal:emi1n, Jr" msquire Myah<1~, Oeckle & Welker, I',C, ~30 soqth Broad Btreet~ 11th Floor Phi1<lc\elphiil, I'^ 19102 (Counsel for PlAintiffs) John 0, swartz, Jr" pl3quire Li\W Offioel3 of Wesley R, Payne Hilll3ic\e OorporAte Center 6Q01LoUi13e Drive, ;a "'1 PloOl" Meahaniosburg, P^ 17066 (Courwelf.or Def.endil1lt,P<\ul P, MOl\r<1tec\es') /I I' ! iL~t'-t____ JLd !lArbar<\ J, Smith, Seoretary '" " 'j " , .. 'j, I' n fI' " ;, " ), " "j, of' I ,I " iI ,I I' j' \, " .' " " "I'1f .' ,f" " '/1 " " I:', '", . " 'I, " H " ", /I 'I " "' I, I' " If" " ,I' " " If" I" f'-' i" .' .'" " /, " " " d' '" " " 1/" H /. .' " ,/, " P 1',:',) " I, ,; j," j.'J C~) , I "\,L". C'''1 I:: \ , \'.H:I ;:! . , " t.':~ . ...,. I J , #...,ll' \ C' , I 1'1 {jl. , r'; iL \ U ":1 I . ~:. -. .,h \ l;ft,J " , ~l~~ 1" !, I I , ,.-, " ." ~; , , ;':\' (.;l ,'\.~ 1'~ " :..'+"1 ....;" , ~-.~ .,:.. 'j! " .' , "' " !' ,! H ;,;, " , " \, "