Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-04058 ", "III, \11\l~\lllll'P\l \1111'11I11I11'Il\l1~ lII'III11I1 HlllllIllIIII Ih\1 VlIllIg\lol'C1(lV\lI'~hllm III tho 'I'lIwl1~l1lp or ~lIlltl11111lpl(l1l1 CIlIIIII~ or Clllll11P1'11I11I11I1I11 COIl1l11111l\Vpnll!101' P\lllo~ylvllllln, hpI1I1IIplllUllI \IOHPI'1I10111l~ I'P II ll\VS , III wlli . TfuiQT NO, I: fll!C1INNINCI nlllll(I~lllhol1oP hy 11I1H1~,lIl1Wnr l'(ll'll1prl,v or IlwlwlrH or WIIII1I11l ,I, YpllI!l~lllllIllIlhprH, 11011111 plllhly-olghl (HR) \lpgI'PPHWP~1 111110lpPII (f Il) p\lrol1llH Ion whllo link 11'1)\1 nlllw iilllll'llll\ll'lghl'lll'-wn~llhpIHJ\l NllI'lh 111,1111 (U) llogrpos WOHI nfty (,~II) 1'1101 101\ pllHllllwlICO 11Y 11I11111111W 01' I'llI'lllPrl~ Ill' I1llwlIl'Il,llll1\lS NOl'lh olghl~,olghl (RR) Illlllrops nnHII1II111t\Hll1( Ill) l,lOrchPH lI,l, II po~11I11I J1l1hllo sll'upli Ihol1\lll,h,~ II pllhllo sll'llot, , SIl\lIh plghly-plllhl (HH)llu!ll'lIP~ IJIIHI fln~ (!iO) 1'\lpl 10 III\l pillllU Ill' IWWNNINCl, THACT ~I1,ll 1II'!ClINNINCllllllhu puhllc slrpollllll Clll'l1~.I' Ill' 1I1011l0W Ill' 1'lll'l1l01'Iy Ill' Mrs,.lllll'hnl'll Ilollur; IIwlICO h,l' 11110 01' ~1I111 1llllllll1lh l,llllllly'oll.lhl (/lH) lIollrpPH Wosl nli1OIolll1 (19) 110l'l'IWH II"~ 111\1 mhhllo 01' Hnlil'llnd.lllrIlIlIlII1011110 Ilhll1ll thc mllllllo PI' Slllll ~trppl, 1'0111' 11111 IWll-nnh~ (4 2/fi) Plll'ol1lls tll tl1o, 11I11I1IIplll' 111111110y nllll1ll1g WpsI I'mlll slIlIl poll1l 111111 III Clllllclllplnllllll Ill' llOllIg OIH1l1pd 1~llslwHI'd I'mlll snlll IIWI,m\lI1II1111011 polnl; tl1PIIllC IIhll1ll tho IInc III' 1IIIIIoW III' 1'0I'11101'Iy 01' POloI' 1\, Mow\ll's, Nlll'lh flvo 111111 0110-hllll' (fi 1/2) lIugrops nll~t 1'1I11!' (,n p\ll'cho~ III II posl nil 1I1ll IInll nl' I10W 01' I'llrl11orly !llllol' 1\; MllWol'S' Inl III1I! 10 ho Iho \lPIlI\l1' lll' 1111 olglll (H) 1'1I01 IIl1p)'1 Ihol1oo IIlllllg lillll llr Hulli MlIWol's' lot 111 PIII'I IlIlll 101 110\\' lII' flll'lllOl'ly III' C1ool'lW Clol'Or, Nol'lh olgllly-olghl (HK) lIogl'oos EIIslllvclvo 1I11t1lwlj;nflhs (122/;') pOI'choH 10 fl'll111 lll1 Mllll1llll'ooli Ihol1oPlllong ~1I111 stroot, Nol'lh 1'Irt~-l'llllr (fi4) 1'''01 tnlho pllloo 01' UHOINN/NO,. . I,nss II slllllll plo\lo of 1111111 HollI III 1l1'1I\l0 Hl1lloook, THACT NO, :1: U1KIINNINO III IIllnst PI' Ill1lOHtol1o 111 thoool1tol' or 1111 nlloy cnlloli 1~lIl1rnllli Stl'oolnl 1111',1 or 1111111,11011' 01' fOI'l11ol'ly Ill' IlIIl'h1l1'1I Hollol'I tl1\ll1oo 1I10llg C\lIlIOI' or sllld 1'11111'01111 Sll'oot Nonh five (5) 1I0groos Wosl, olilhty'ollo (HI) fool tll 11 IImostol1o 111 conlol' of Bl'ollll Slrcot (1'1l111l111!l Hils I 111111 WO~I)i Ih\ll1c\l by 1110 cOlllol'of ~IIIII 111'01111 Sll'ool, SOllth olghty-slx (/In) dllgl'oOS EllS I 0110 hlll1l1l'oll 1'01'1~ (1<111) root tOll polllllll tho COl1l01' of ol'ook; 111111\1)0 1I10llg \l01l101' of slllll ol'ook Illllllolllhol\slcl'l~ 1111'0011011. I1lghlY (110) fool to lino of sl\11I BII1'1lIl1'1I HolloI' 1I\lltll thollce by th\l SlImo, North elghly-slx (H(l) 1I0gl'\lcS WOHI 0110 11I111111'ull fifty (Ifill) 1'00110 Ihl1 f1l'sll11ollthllwd polllllll111 pllll!O III' IlEalNN/NG, ".. J<;XHlIII'I' "A" " '. " [{! ~-'...., i'q .._~ ~-- -v (.:. " 'I ? ~~ I' " '-9 () (, '"0 ' cr. ~'- (\... r:b .9 ~j fA s.~ " 0 d 1'1)" :'1 Q ". ~ .-" " 10 1"" C'" II " 1";0' II, , C)" 8 ,3 , ~p ,\, ., , lc) -:r: 3 <:y.: ." r'(), \I ':t C':i' l' CJ I' , ,'.,,, t-J .>.n ~fl .1., tt3 i I, '3 'C!l 11\ "f.'. ,) I ,.'1 i h" I' , , I, P,\ , " ,. " " " I' I' " 1\' " " I, " , " ".., " " " 11 '" fi " I' " .. " " " 'I H 'I, " " \j , " :" " " .1' 1.', " " ,\ " ,II d" ,.'- ,;I " I' " " " .." 11 " J',' J' ,.,' " ,," ." " " " J I I"~. 11, , " ~ t/) " ", ..~ Ql "~ ~ '1-1 ~, 't I ~ .. ~ '0 [.1 I' m ~ ~,~ 0' ~ . ~J ~ I . ,-1 . ~ Ql fYl ~~I ~I W .a Ql r-l J'; :~g I ~~ jj ~ . 'tJ 'H'I-I j 1 'H'I-I (:l .:g t/) ,-I ~ ~J g g 0 ~, Ul Il 'rl ~ ' ,cl~ '11 tIl ~J ~J ,jJ 'I" ~ t:h I In 00 "~I tilt/) II 1-10'rl I '11 , ..1 I'l: :t11I1 .fYl 0 -'1 ;, t . I . (1) ....11,' " Qlll 1'1 !1; .-1 I'") .. ,,~l H N 00 'r l~ :~ r-l ~ m,~ ~ 0\ I (1-1 '[j e ~ 111.- :~ ~ 'H ~I QI rJ8 ~ 1-1 r-l ~ '" ~ " ,-11.., U t.trwl( ~ " 'I; " fllo 111i106.\r(.02 lllouffor Olll11pl!lln\ olVIl 101:l/{JU G, on I?r ul1O\1\ Ontobor 1, 10"(0, (hlrlno tl10 porlod pf 1110 PI~lln\lffs onO<100111<ln\ prlol' \0 \111311' '11f11Tlflon, Pofand~lnl!l l1arell1 purol1Usocl tl1rua \I'!1O\S of Inncl from r~lol1mil VElmor nn(l Pulrloln J, Vmnar, for EI oonsldem\lon of $10,OPO,00, Snld lruols woroloon\o(l Ell olose proximity 10 1110 PofondElI1\B' rOllldenoe. A oopyof \110 Peeel frol11 Il1e Vmners Into Il1e pe(endElnls Is 1-1IlElol1ocll1erelp ElsRxl11blt "A", One trao\ of \l1e Varner l(ll1el was Improvecl wltl1 a smnil 110use, Elpproxlmt1lel~1 34! py 14', oonslsllno of 1-1 IIvlno 1'00111, bedroom, 1IIIol1on, ul1d b<l\11 on E1 slnole levol. Tllfl.Varner property was purohaseel. by Il1e Pefenelnn\s with tha Inlenllon of Irnnsferrlno to Plalnllffslhe Iraol wltl1ll1e house on It, 7, Commenolng In '1970 and oonllnulng tl1eroQfter, PIf1lnllffs, solely Elt tl1elr own , '. expense, renovElled Ihe 110use Elnd n1Ell1o oortf1ln S\~b!ltElnllf11 f1delltlons, most notably, f11(lrge fronl . , porol1, bow window f1nd side porol1, Elncl EI 14' by 40"Elddltlon to tile bf1ol< of tile house, 8. In 01' f1bout 1003 or 1904, Plaintiffs I1lred a oon\rElolor \0 f1dd an mldl\lonf11 porcl1 nnd anoll1er ~lddl\lon 10 Ihe 110uso, tills adtllllon f1pproxlrnt1lely 38' by 20', 9, In or aboLI11 000, PIEllntlffs, solely al Illelr own oxpense, f1dded f1 oonorelo pallo, f1 swimming pool, and <\Il18' ailed to tl10 property. , I, 10, In 01' nbou11988, Plaintiffs, solely f1t tl1elr own oxpense, f1dded f1lmge gmage and t1 worksllop f1nd built f1 seoonel story on tile gmnge wltllnlmgereoret1l1on room, At f1pproxlmately 111 Is lime, the parties also ~lddod a slled t~ tile property, 1 'I, In or about 1903, Plalnllffs, solely at \l1~lr own expense, ndded <I sooond story to Ihe Ilouse proper, At tile end of the 15-yem period over whlol1 renovallons were oompleted, the one-, story, ono-bedroomlloLlse beOt1l11e f1n elgl1t bedrooml1oLlse wltll three bQll1rool11s, 12, " Prior to oomlwJnolng 011 of the stf1led ronovQtlons and oddltlons to lhe property desorlbed abovo', the parties oblalned the permission of the Defendants und assLlrnnoe by 2 . ' \ ' iiI, "", Vi;~l \.1 1Il1l11\illlfi.07'O~ a\n\l!fpr llClll1pl!lll1\ Illvll 10/3/1l11 pefondl1nla Illnl Pofpn~lt1l1tB walllel Irl1n8for 1110 praporlY \a 111olll. All flelrll\lqnB illlcl renovullons " . clj3sPl'IIJod were undortf11~on In rellanoo on \Iw ,iromlBfJU of pofen~lnnls 10 Imnsfer IIw property 10 PIl:1lnllffs, 13, 1111095, pefendmllll fl[]l'oeel \0 ol1lnln 11113 s~II)(lIvI810n pltlll <wi Townllhlp t1pprovuls , nepossury to II10Jmnsfer of the prppor'\y 10 Plfllnllffs, PI~lln\llfs p<lld for Ihe servloes of $tephen p, , . , . I Wolfe,"who prepmml q s~ll1dlvlalon plEIIl for [?efondf1l1tB, pefenclunla 011 used the plflnto be . submllled to Il1e Plflnnlng oommlsslon and Some! of Sllpervlsors of SOlllhumplpn Township, Oumberland OpLlnty, Pennsylxanl~, und, after approval, the Plan was reoordeclln Ihe Offloe of Ihe' Reo~rcler of peeds of Oumberlt1l1d COlillly, Pennaylvonla In Plfln 130DI,\ 70, Page 127. A oopy of Ihe 'Plfln Is 0\\f1011l3clherelo flS 13xhlblt "8", I_DI No,.1 on r:xhlblt "13" Is Ill(:) 10lwhlol1 pefendMls Inlendecl to Imnafer 10 PIElln\lffs while pefendunls InlendecllD relflln ~ol No. 2, 14, Subseq\-lenl ,to Il1e reoDrdElllon of 1110 subdivision plfln, and before Ihe Peed Into, Plflln\lffs Wfls signed by Defendants, Plalnllffs sepamtecl from onennDlhLJr, 1 G, pefenclnnts hnve refused to Imnsfer I.ot No, 1 Dn 13xhlblt "13" 10 Plnlnllffll, 1 G. During all releVl:1nl limes, Defendants were In a oDnflden\lnl relEltlonshlp with PIEllnllffs who me Pefendant~. son nnd daLlghter-ln.lnw arld Plaintiffs repossd great\rual and oonflclenpoln Defendanls and relied upon Ihelr pronllse to oonvey Ihe subJeot propertYI AI .111 releVf1l11 times, Pll1lntlffs' bellevecl Defendants promises to ODnVey and IrLlsled thot Defendants would never abuse Ihelr Donfldenlll.ll relallonshlp, 17. Defendanls abused thaiI' oonfldenllE11 relationship when they prDmlsed to Irunsfer the property and penl1ll1ed extenslvo Improvements Ihereon, Imowlng Ihal Plolntlffs relied upon Ihelr protl1lee In order to Justify oonslderable Investmentlnlhe eubJeot property, 3 " " \ -'., ~. ~~ . 'ij ~ \,' ~~ ~ II ~ e ' I~ ':I- ~ ~ a ...... '~ "I~ I . ".A.\ I ,.1' ~ Pi ~ ~ ' 'U1 d'~ W: ' , "Z L . , I I ,,) , r I I'" " ".,.. .... ... ."..-. ...,..,.'".......~. - .-..,-~_.......... ~......._--~..~.." "".,,_., ..-, '" ."..,.~,,,.._...,. ,.,.-.-.-......-......-...-.-- /11<< If pI OPllIllv pI . 0'1 flllf, I~p ~qv 01 f~o 'fI"lmlpllo~ pQloor, l'mPMlly AllllPllrqll }", d9 , b,'orf 1110, ""'OW II fo 1111 (or ,qlMAolorHy Ilrol'oll) 10 bo 11'0 I'mo" who" MlII. . flfbmlbo~ 10 tho lI'if!lill "'trlmlllll, 1\l1~ Mlmo\./ollpoflllllll 110 c~'Plflod t~, ,"m' lor I~o l'IWI'o'''' I~(tl'vI" o,,"'(!II!fII, IN W/7WNSS W/lfJ/UWf', I.llorolmlo III IIIV "<<111/ 111111 oPtoi<<1 '0"', ,....!..!',...!..~....".."."...,....,..,,,.,,...t,.....'.""I'",.'.'t..I'....'!"..~ 1"....."..'.1'.'.'.1.'.11"."',.......,........"",,,,"'''''''''''''''''''11'''''' ,.' . 7'11100/ OPlom '/' I 110 hmr,v mUlv Ihllllllo 111"o(ae rqB/lIello' Rllll \lOlII/I/"e 1'0'1 oP11" <<!lilrm ,'0/11" wlI!lill 11<<111011 prllllloo la II, II, H ~ I, IlhippanIlP\I~91 1'1\, l7257 ' ~je-\, ..:i.u..44 I J9 76 '/' ~/ . /" -z;. fJJ'{/ {! /;;.~,#.:. ~r.l;~~;_~lf.f.,""",.~.,~,r.t,''',.",,,,,rtl., "t~(Jrll(lV fot~ ""l!'.".'I~;H';lfl.~~.~J(...",......"""mm""'" t... . "I~ ..1 ~Ui " OOM^fONIY. iI?JlI 0fo1l'tDNN.9!!LVtlN , Cotmtv 0 ....\....";....,-:!~:l~. - -t- , . I/bJOOl1V1W on II!I~ "."g.Lr1.. (laV 0/ ._. -,~\:;.. .. ...t.lf'd-- ii, v, JP~, ('I tl,o 1I0oorelpl"n 00100 0' ,a/el OOIlIlIV,III DOOll nook V Vol. "",,,~k,,,,, I'(tgo ,,,,,,~,,~~t lUuon tllIllor 1IIlIIIall/I <<nllllloP1'~O . 'Mel oO)~olJbB e~o abol'D lOri/tell, . ..,,(,,U~ ,~.!..S,,,l,~~,,;,/~..,;;,~,~.., tloDor<lor. taoKV 20 ",ILE bO.l .. , ( l . J l'II!,I-( I' './ [[,'!l,J .1 ',1."1111111111,,\1 ',1111111" iii' J I; 1-1 \t-! III "I I'IIIII,!! I! HI '-, Ill: 'j'l II' ,\1, ':rlil.'U, 'I.; 1111 H \ I:l" i\ \:'1' :\1 ~:'ITi\H I'll: hAIII, 1< "/ ill, " h'\ IP] i;il I 'I III, 1111111::11.1,111 ' I 'Hill!! I"i'lill q,I'\.1 j'l \1 .1,\\1, 111'_' \1\ llii (, V;/,,'l-j \q i\;. 1:'1" ill ','jll\lI""I:J: 1,'1:1 " II " .li-' li,'lit"ldlll J \,:n.;i'llliltll: " ,(I l,:!,l/\ ;1 'I,) :'1':\1/,1, ',1/'.1':1" ,\If I ',I III: I',II!:I I, 1''\'' f " ";, " ',j Jj\ t,. \,:i'\\11 i ;.' 1"',1' Iliij' I " , , ! , " II " 'h'_ill!, I " (It I I, , , " " ''-, , 1ft: ,11111 ',' I I" I, , " i 'lql " , u,; \'11: --I II' i 'I I 1 I" };(lill I, 1If; ';1 .' 1 I 11,\ II,.';! '" " ~. \ II " 'I i I .{ , , j j -,; 'I I.', ( ,,- J: I' t I I I"~ 1 ':1'1'1,111:1' l\ II' ie/,-,l.',l I ,\i I ( I i.,t t ~ Hi I" "i! " \','1 If/l , ,I j'.IUJ II 111'{ Iii'!;'! \' \,j ;,;\1(" t' L 1,1'; i I' ~ ,( 'i? Iff' ql'JI''- 91~er" <I'j r,t n /, II, Ci' '1),1t(.C~i~':i' (,~Of'j.i I ",." 1/1 ,u\'lf-"li , 1'1":' \ I 1/:" \il'," " ;It p '! I'" i Iii 'ii i 1-,;,1'<1\; ~' 11i,'j !! ,'!! 1;\; Ill' " q,j 1.1' ", I'\'.',\.! till- I,' '.II,' ;ti,l,Ir-;;,.ill' ,~'-I i'l ,'1 I lli I: \ Ii' i ~ I I 1,1 " , ~ ')' iI1'i:'II,1 /1i1,' I:'; II:' rl'iul.!iI'h ill' 1,11'll q;\, i},l "/11 J \.1/1 [,; i I;' ill t; J\.L ~ \ ~I,\', ;q! ;;, ,i 'II:.. \I~).., , .v:J' /. "., """",,, C;;'<"r"''' , ~,...,;,'" ;r "",~:,"ro...ot.~~v."~"1,4 .t'J~"I"'~" ,,:.' /,. ,. ...- ,.". ..-" 1" - I'll ii', t'. \ 1'(\"; 1 il I 1- l llil~d ld! i'i i I 1,', I', "..', I' ;<""-;J i' ,~{ , ../' ,'-i~;'-:-4 r> I_G).O<:~'~,:/,~;:l ~. ."<" r", '~'.(C-l;{'f/:.e",~.:;;')-e. ,/ .." ! " '.. " ,. I, ,/' " "I' 'f" Ill',I,l! j, llih I ::"1 iil ,',j , . r, 1:' , ; , :\ I 1",1 ,,\ I' I Illl'lilll\',I! ;\1 II il" 1-1111' .,.1 I " I I I I ( II'Jlll'.' II' , \Iillll: nil! ,; , I; I' ',[I 101': I I ,I: t\ " I ill I'. II, " " ~ ': ' r i 1111' - I " 1\ I !-:!,ljj: T 1111'1 1(: 1'1 !I.,h 11("1 II Ii I 't '!' \1,1, I"~ L; \ tl" i'j ,/ i I' I , 1,/!'il'I,I(IJII!' ,,\11'11 IJ'_'lil\ I:' ('_'lIiJI,t. HIli: ,rill OIl'!. , '1 i-JI'J.IJ 1'-\ \1111111\1 1\ ;i\,!, ,t-:I"':" l.l"i/, \11 L hl.t VIIi! 'I iii' ",lll'i!Jl.lJ)";, ',/ill, >it I \'i':,1 1'1"1\1 , :ltiIWII,1i :.'I'o!\ II I, I', Ll,i d\d Iii lld;\p I ,I \ ,I I ,'{'I I !iHJI \l!~, 'II 11,\ "I'" II .1 i'.' I' I'l'('> I \'I'U,i ,I 'Iii l\l;tli\,~' ',;'1.'1\1 '1.':1 ,II If 1111'.(IIIj'it., '(\ 1'/, '" " ',! ,1'llill'WI:\,fdlll " '(1",1 L 'J, If' r \ iill:\V.l \I 1111,)/ ,:" Ii 111-1111\'1 i:q il\;-' 11",111: \'nL.l I-q; I, ,,'1:1 ill!!: I: I, " I,! Ill' 'llld '1\.1 \, ,',;L,)\l 1_'1'1;/ ;, j \ ! II ~ 1 ' 11-:': ;_llill II 1111' " ';I((]I' I '1IV~' tL 1"1 (I IIi') IIi:, I' 1';"'111 tHI 1,_, 1,,1,." , \1111 ',11\ I Llp'l ,,/,,1 '" '.. ;',;!'ii 't ,I 1 I' (!,_,;:d ),'It I' \'",1 i lHi ,I: 1</] (_1.'1 II I I 11I,.I': I! ii, ,:\1','; 1:1/.1 " " I " (ni" J , Itl : (WJ 1 , i;Ho ." ;~: '.,~?' ~.i'~~I' tt ~, ""..)-~~...~~......: ..rf(.;~ .... ,,#,~f, ' ,..' itlll';; 1. 1 jll", ,11"1 I I , tl'- H:IFI-' '''!i/''l i'l;IJ:1 d-:Il'lli/',I . PH,'." 1,1.111,/1 :1, 1'1:,' ',' '{J)'~' '(~,~:;~:i~::'\;:I' \)1 ,-, 1"'.11 I I /~.. /'-"Z":':' ....-- -~. I I' "f , ..... " ;'.'; ". "u;il.cf-' .'f:.J2/ ,1/' '11,1.1 :)"/111 Ii l'lii'l :111.1 " 1/1"1.1 Ll 1.\, II.' ""',lii" rill J'/lt: 'If " ~)I~'I ~"L. ~I i,I',',' ", C)bL'1 \! " 1\. II; Ih(.e(,.~ ! I I L III 1(1-; II (i 'j " I' ,', I,~ (Irt~ ' " '7, Ponlotl, 1311'101 pl'llnl'ls 1101111\11<10\1, Ilr \\'lIr 01' 1\ll'lhVI' III1S\\'OI', 111O,h1!11SO WlIS pIll'ohllsod hY lho Pol'ollllllnls wllh 111\ 01'iISIII\!lIi'OI1\ pl!l'oh 111\11 hllw whHlow, ^n{l'ollll\'lIlIol\s or 1It111!llol1s . I j. . Ihlll W\lI'O I11l1do III Ih~ pl'opol'lr 11'01'0 lI\ilhol'l~oll h)'lhll Plll\JIllllll1ls, Thll Pol'omlllnlH pl'lll'hlod Illhlll' IlmlllnlllloIiIIIlSslsIIllW\lI\l1' Iho 1'1l1l1!1'\llIol1s 111\\1 mhllllnllH 10 Iho pl'op\lrl~, H, Ponlc\I, flll'l\J1 pl'lHlflHdol\HIIHlell, Ilr Wllr nl' 1ill'Ihol' III\S\VOI', \III)' l'enl!l'llllol1s Ill' IltltllllonH IIl11l Wel'O 1111\(10 10 Iho pl'oppl'lY Wel'O Il\lIhlll'lj(utl hr Iho l)olulllhlllls, Tho Dolumhlllls . pl'lwldlllllllbl!l' 1111\1 t1l\lIl\oIIlIIlSslsllll11111 Ihl' thlll'ollnl'llllol\H Ill\dlldtlillnl\H In Iho PI'I1I1\ll'lr, 9, POlllotl, Sll'lol P1'l1l\1' Is IlellHlI1Ilotl, Uy WlIr 01' 1\ll'\hol' nl1HWOl', Ihu j)OIUI1IIIlI1IH IIVOI' Ihlll \lw PIIIII1IIf11i plIl'ol1\1HOtlll IIsod IIhO\'o"grollml plllil wllh Iholl' IIppl'nl'lIl, .^I1~ 1'01\0\,111101111 nl' , ' , 1\lltllllol1l1lhlll 11'01'0 111 IItI 0 II! IIw pl'opol'I)' \\'~l'lllllill\l1l'lj(o<l hrlllO Polulltllllllll, Tho IJolulltllll1ls p1'O\'ldodl\lhI11'lIlld 111lllll011l1llsslsllHWo,lhl' tho l'OI\l1l'lllloI1H II11dll1hlllinlls lollw pl'opol'lr, In, !Jollloll, 811'Iot prop I' Is (101111l\lllod, !ly Wllr \11' 1\ll'Ihol' IIIlHwel', Iho PolUl1dl1111H 11\'01' Ihllt , Iho Pll\lnlll'i1i el'eotedll sl11l1l1l1\ltlitlolllo tlio exlslllll.l shod wllhlhcll' IIPlmWIII, AIl~ 1'01\11VII\lol1H 01' IIddlllollS Ihllt 11'01'0 I11l1do Ip lho pl'llpol'lr WOI'O lI\llhl1l'l~otlll)' Iho Pelul1dllllls, Tho ()olumllllllH pI'l11'Idedlllhol'II1ld lillllllOh\lllilSlillll110e Ihl' Iho 1'0llOVIlllpl1s llIldllddlllol1i1 tolho pl'Oplll'tr, II, DOlllol\' Stl'iot pl'onl' IH de1l111lldcd. Br wWllf 1\11'11101' IIIlHWOI', Iho IJolulldlll1lH 1l\'OI' Ihlll Ihor 1I11lhnl'l~odlll1Y 1'0llnl'IIIIol1H 01' IIdditlol\H lhl\t 11'01,'0 I11l\do to Iho 1lI'0po'rtr, The 1J0lul\(hlllts pl'ol'ldod h\hl1l'lIl\d' 111111l\cllllllsslslll11oU fbl' Ih\lI'Qllol'lItloI\H IIl1d mldillol\H tqlhupl'opol'tr, Tho Dolul\dlll1till\lrlhtll' 11\'01' Ihllt tho hOllRO hilS Ihlll' hodl'ool11H 111111 1111'00 hllthl'oOIllS, 12, DOlllod, I. SlI'icllll'l1ofls dOl1lllllded, By \VIIY or t\lrlhl1l' 1I1111\\'UI', dlll'llI!! Iho nPPl'oxhl1l1l~lr 01!!h10l111 (18) r01l1' IMlod thlll Ihul'lnll1l1ftil l'eHlded 10!lothol' 11121 Bl'olld Strool, ShIPP\ll\Hhil1'g, POI1I\HylvlIl\llI, Ihor dId llo1 pny III\Y 1'0111 101110 Dol\mdl\llls, AllY 1'0l\oVllllo11S 01' nddltlol\H thlll woro I11l1do to tl\o pl'Opl1l'tr wuro IIl1thol'l~ed hy the DuIiJlldIlI\IH, 'l'ho 60ruI1dlll11H provldod IlIhol' "2. I\lHIIi\1nlWIIlIIlHHIHII\IW~ Ihl' Iho 1'~1111\'IIlIIlI1H 1I1\IIIIlIIII\llll\H In 1110 pl'(lpor\~, Tlw \)ol'ol1\IIII1IH 1\11'11101' nwl' 1I\I\II1WIl'IIoIH Ill' hll\llll'ol'o p\l1'~hnHOIllI'lIh \lw 11111'111 III 1'O\II1111hol11 1\11' \IH~ IIH 1I1I11\ll1'1~"'11 h)' Ilw pol~l\lhII\IH, IIIH oxpl'OHHltl\ol1lolllhlll IIIIY 1'0\1ll\'lillllI\H Ill' (Itlditlll\1H \\,01'''' II1Hlol'lnkol1 hi 1'011111100 hI pl'lll11lHOHllfllw PPI'Ol\dlll1lH 10 lI'IIIIHI'o1' Iho pl'llpol'lY (lllho 1'IIIII1IIfl\i, , , .1 ~, Mmlllollll\ PIII'IIII1II II0lllod 1\1 PIlI'I, III~ 1I\lIl\lIlotllhll\ n HIII\lII\'IHlnll pllll\ WIIH llhllihwll ..1111\11110\1 IIH I'll 1'1110 I'\loHOI'lI1OtIIII pllIll\llflii'lJxhlhlll3, II IHtlol1lod Il1l1llho Pol'oI\\IIlli!H 0\'01' hHql1t1od Inlrnl1HI'o1' I~(l\ !'Ill I I III Iho I'lnll1llnii, Hlrl~1 pn1lll' IH tlol\lIl11\lolI, 14, \)IlI110tl, Sll'lo\ lll'lllll' IH dOllllll1dotl, 13~ II'IIY 1l1'1111'\lwl' III1HI\'OI', Iho 1'IIIInll fl\i HOPIII'IIlO\1 \\'hOI1I,lll'l'luA, Slll\II'I'oI' Ion \lw 11\1I1'1I1I11'0Hldo1\0(l1l11 or IIhll\ll .I111~ I H, I \J9(l, it IH IIOlllotl 111I1IIho \)ol'ol\dIlI1IH 0\'01' 11\1011dol\ (1lII'lIl1HI'o1' 1,01 NIl, 1 hllho I'lnll1\1l'1ii, 1 S, \)olllotlllH Hllllotl, \3~ II'IIY Ill' 1\11'\hol' III1Hlvor, I.ho pol'oI1III1II1H 110\'01' hllomloll III 11'1I11HI'o1' , ' Llll Nil, 1 III Iho Plnll\lll'Iii 1111\1 hll\'O I'clllliwd \110 \1\10 10 1111 Iho proporlY Ihoy I'luhlt\llIy ll\\'n, 16, I'nl'lllll'lIph 1(1 pl'll\'ldoH II 10UIII clll1ohlHlon, \ll which IInllnH\\'OI' IH Iwl 1'0\llIll'cd, Tlllho oxlOl1ll11\ III1H\\,OI' IH I'oqllll'otl IIIH donloll IIntl H\I'lol pl'OO I' IH tl01111111t1od, Th~ PoliJlldnl1tH 11\,1)1' thllt " ' Iho Il'lIolli \II' Inl1d WOI'O plll'Ol1llHOd wllh tho 1I110l1t 10 rotl1ln Ihol11 1'01' IIHO liS IIl1lhol'l~\ld by Ihil . Dol'olldlll1tH, Tho, Dol'ol1dllntH 1l0\'OI' 11111do IIIlY pl'omlsoH 10 IrnnHful' Iho IlIlld t\l, Iho 1'11I111111'1\i, IIIH oXlm'HHly donlod thnllll1Y 1'01101'1I\lo11H or I1\ldlllol1H \\'01'0 \lI'idol'lnkol1ll1 1'0llnll00 10 pl'omlHoH or Iho Dol'ondnnlH In \1'III1HI'o1' tho pl'opony to Iho Jllllin\ll'lii, I'I, I'nl'llUl'nph 17 jll'o\'ldllH n lounl cOl1ohlHlolt, \ll whloh nil nns\\'ol'IN ntlt I'oq\lll'od, Tn tlw oxlont nn nI1H\\'OI' IH I'oqllll'od IIIH dOlll11d ni\(l Htdol proof IH dOl1\nlldu\1. Tho Dol\.whllllH I\VOI' Ihlll il . tho tmolH 01' Innd WOI'O p\1l'ohllllOd with Iho Intollt to roliilll tlwl1\ 1'01' \IH~ nH IIl1thol'l~ed by Iho Dol'ol1dnlltHI IIIH llXpI'CHHI~ dOlllod IItnl nl1Y 1'01l01'1I110l1H 01' nddltlOI1H \VOI'O IIl1dol'll1kill1ln 1'~""1l011 10 proll1lHIIH ill' the bOI'ondnntH 10 tl'lIl1HI'o1' lho p,'OllUI'ly to lho I'lnll1\1I'1'H, Tho Dol'ol1dlllllH IIll'Ihol' " ..:1.. " " " " I \ I ., I I j., " I i I I " ~lm:nD~!.IT\~Jl[:t!liH v I c l~ I, TI111uth~ ,\" Bl\lllul', I\HIIIIII'U, dl1lwl'oh~ UUI'III~ Ihll\ 111\ thu 11111 dllY llrMII~ , IUU\), I OII\IH\JII 1Ill'\lU 1111\1 OI1I'I'UU\ Ul1p~ Ill' tho Pl'llo(Jlpu III ^\tlluh VOl'll1ul\\llll1t\1llU HUl'yud I'p\111 tho Ihlt\lwlllll I1Hllvld\lll1 \1~ IlI'HI UIIIHH !HIIII \1y dop\1llllll\ll HI\l1W Inlhu \;)11110(1 ShlluH, pUH\lIgu !ll'upnld, 111111l1'r1Hhlll'll, POl\nH~lvlll1ll1, ' (,,'111'111,1, Lll\dHII~, IlHIIIlll'o FIO\l'ol', Fluwol' ,~I.ll1dHII~ II 111111\ IlIgh 8\1'00\ CIII'lIHlo, M 17013 " r-. [)' 13Y:'__'n,r~,~ :(L--IL~ Tlinu\h~ '1', Ilnlllul', I1Hqnh'\J . . IWn\NSON &. OBI ^WO ^TI'ORNIlY \,\), NO, 7H44H " 4407 North FI'I1111 Sll'uOI \1,0,'13U1\ 5320 Ihll'l'IHhmll, \1 ^ 17110 (717) 232.H525 ^\tnl'lloy 1'01' \)ol\mdlll\tH d ' " Ii " ,." ',j 't" " Y!~Jm" ct\'I'lll.~ I V\ll'ltY l\lII\ IIw HlnlpllWlllH \l11\\\p III IhlH !\llH\\'PI' llrp \nlP \lm\ PPl'lw\. I 11I1(IOI'H\\I\1I1 \hll\ I\IIHP H\!\IPI1WIl\H hpl'pllllll'P 1l111(\PH\I\l.lpp\ III IIw pPIlI\\lIIlH PI' I H PII, C.f:\. Rplllll1l1 ill)(l4, I'c\II\II1!lll1 \II1HWl1l'11l\\\HII1Il\llll1l1 1111111\1\IlI'I\IIlH, " " , .. ,', ~ I, 1/({2-,-}, ~;:, /! ~ ,d~1~_~tA.4~~d. ;.!.~-- 1I'IIIlK n. R\l1\II'1'ol' ' . f)~ 1'::1 J:r~ -'''-e.1-----'" PUI'IH N, fllo\lflul' , .11,- 'I" , ili I' ,f,; '1 ,. ,Ii " " \I" ,," , " I" ',,' " " " , ,Ii " " /" ( 0: 1 'I ' ,),\, ~ ~, ,~\ }j' "~I "J ',,~" 'I,:.:; .' \ ..1,'1 (,\ . 1;:'\ (( . . ~' 1 , ~~', ~ I' :- ~ 1~~J4 tl[)ftkaJ:), 1,0RRII3 A, ~rrOUFFJ;R <<n~ I IN TH~ OOURT OF QOMMON P~I3AS OF ., ~I3Ff1t;RY 1-, SToUFFt:R, I OIJMI3~R~ANP OOUNTY, pl;NNaYI-.VANIA (J . f'll1lntlff~J... ..' I , ,,,,rp IlMUlJA ^"AA;mr~ ,-' I l1Iv "'1"''''\ ~QivV. '\/t/}.)~ . : ~~ll.o~~~~N~~i~~FRM FRANI~ 13, J:lTOUFPI:R I1net ~;./J/AffJ'l/I,~~} . PORia N, STOUFFt:R, 'Vr I . I Pofonctl1nta 'srh t;Q~~k)) Ir __' ^ AI ,aRlS~ '( . VII? E.QR.J!J.IlliM1lliI..QNJ~ Pll'llnllff, I-.ORRIt; A, STOUFFaR, throuOh her oounsal, PI.OWI2R, Fl.OWgR & ~INP8AY, , .. PIC" oppose tI~e Mollonfo~JUd9lnent on ~1.l,ePlaI1Cllnga I~the al'l plio n ed", aflSe, '___--> +\J f) 'n\ \.. \ \/\l;, \ \ . '11\( )/1/1;(\> " I. FAOTS ANQ_PROOEDUIUlL HISTORYI The PIE1lntlffllin II1ls aase are huspand and wife who ware rmmled~n MI'lY 27, 1078, I , ,. (Oomplalnt, Par, 4) They are estranged anq Wife 11f,\S flied a Complaint for tha qlvaraa to No, 06, I ' ,4783 Civil Term In Cumperll'lnd Oounty, PennsYlvania, (OalhpIQlnt, Par, 4) Prior to the parties' marrlEme on or apoulOatober 1, 1076, PefendfJnts purahaseclthree . . , tracts of land from Rlcl1Euq and Patrlala Varlll'lr fcr $10,000,00, (Complaint, Par, 6) One of the traots wl1slmproved with a small' house of approximatelY 34 feet X 14' feet andoonslsllng of three . rooms and a path on a single level. (Complalnt,Par, 6) Oommenclng In 1976, sol~IY at their own "eXI)ense, PlfJlnllffs renovuteq the house In oertaln parllQ\Jlara, The renovallona oontlnued In 1083 .. 01'19841 In 1986, In 1088, and In 1993, (Oomplalnt, Par, 7-11) The house Was transformeq from ." I ^ ~ ~~ ~IN' OVW)J'v\/t+~~t::.~~~__S" JIt"IIL.... , ~ !,V V"" ~}<I y~V\" ,....., , ~4-tvl4Vt;t: ' 10 ld. tiJt/\i~, (.11'\'l VlC~'tt,.~A,vlR J'h?>tl44', (II!l115105.117.(l~ QI!lII,flnr Ilrl(ll In uppPlIllIlIlI (:1111 dlllll) ^11\l11II11I, IIlIlIl " ,. a p'na-~torY, pna-Ilpdroom 11(l\I~O tn u IW\,Hltpry I1mlHP with flrfdltlona, oontalnlng elol1t (8) l)o~lropmflnn'l throa (3) 11Il111roolllu, (Oomplnlnt,Pnr, 11) At nllrlllovnnt thnpu, Plulntlrhl OIJtulrlll(1 t11(1 pornllaslon nf tl10 PafendElnla 10 make the ranpvElllona, nnd lmlll rnl1l)vntlnl1t1 wow Il1mlu In roltElnoa on tl1I'l reppatad promlaea pf Pflfandl'lntll 10 trElnafm Il1n prnpurty 10 PlullllUrll, (Complnlnt, Pm, 12) , In 10Dfl, pllllln for tl10 trnllllllll' ofownnrtllllp of 11113 property prooreslled to \lle point Wl1e.ra PlalntlffB nbtul!lnd \1m lllllV.lol111 of Btupl1nn P, Wplfe Wllo prepmfld ei sub-dlvlalon plEIn IsolEltlng 11113 Imol Oil whllll1 \1m IWlno WUII IOllllto(1 from \110 reml'llnlng propertYI pefendl'lnls tl181;,aelvell ~Ullh1ltlpd thll pllln tn thll Pllll1l111l(J OomrnlBBlon l'lnd 101l1e l3omd9f S~jpervlsora of Soull1ampton , . Townal1lp, OUlllbllrlnnd OO\lll\Y, Ponnaylvnnla, and tile plEIn was ultimately l'lpproved Elnd rooordad In tho Offlon of thn Rnoordm ~f Oeeda for oumberland oounty, 'PennaylvanlEl, (OompI111nt, Pur, 1:\) Thn uub(lIvllllon ,plnn, attl'l()lled to tile Oomplalnt I.Hl ~xl1lblt "B", daaorlbea Lot No, 1, Lot No, 1,nl1owa tl10 l10LlSfl und outbuildings added by tile Plalntlffs, Tile plf1n Was " ' 'reoordod on SoptomllOr Hi, 1005, (Oomplalnt, r:xh, (3) Subsequent to the reoordatlon of tile SUbdivision plun, and boforo tho deed Into Plaintiffs W<lS signed by Defenqantsl. Plaintiffs . Beparntod from ono ulluthor; (Oomplulnt,I~llr, 14) Tl10 I)uronduntll uro tho pnronta of Pluliitlff Jeffery L, Stoufler, , .. (Ool'nplalnt, Par, 5) , ' SLlUBoqUOllt to Iho PlnlntlHn' lIupnl'ntlon from oa()11 other, tho DefencJants refusaq to tranflfe,r t~ Plnlntlrfn I,ot No. 1l1111:xhlblt "1311, (Oomplalnt, Par, 1 G) At nlll'olovnnt tlil1Ull, lip UI1t11I1Hlh' rolunal to tranafflr Lot No, 1, the Defonqal1ts Were. In a ' oOI1I1(lol1l1nl,:illnilDl1l1hlp with Plnlntlffa who Were tholr son ancl daughter-In-law l'lnq upon whoso .' , . , ' promlnu In ()ol1vny Ihu nubjoot property 1110 Plalnllffs relied as they Investeq heavily.. In the " 2 flip 1/1l165.07,Og a\ouffllr Ilrl~f In oppo61\lon (3rll drnl\) Auol1615,1000 Imprpveme,nl pf Iha properlY, (qomplfllnl\ Pm, 1 (3) ~ol No, 1 I~ ,\ow wprtll flpprpxlmf1lely $1 po\pOO,OO, (Oomplf1lnl, Pflr, 18) Plaintiff Lprrla f3lo~lff13rflleq E1 Wrll of Summons on July ~O, 100a, Tharaf'lfler, f1 Oomplf1lnl wafl fIIeq on Maroh :31,1090, pefenclF1nlfl fIlad ~m Anflwar 1011113 ()omplalnl on or E1poul May 7, 1900, TIll3 AnflWer OOnlE1lned Naw Mfl\\pr, ,PUIII wafl nolanqorfleq with a Nollo(:l to Plpa(l. On or f\Poul Juna 11, 1 990, pf,~fendflnlfl fllecl a Mollon for ,Juclpmflnl 61'1 Ih13 PI13acllnofl and IIfltaq the oafla for aroumenl, Aroumenllfl ssl for Augual11 \ 1 QDD, This 13rlef Is In oppoaltlon 10 Ihe Mollon, I ,.. /11,' . 'issue '-"- ,e , The only lafluecl r;1laeclln 11113 Motion for Juc1pm<:int On the Pleflqln9fl III whether Plalhllffs' . ( , pauae Is pmreq Py the fltfltute ofllmltflllons purauant to P!:l, O,S.A:5526 or 5625(3).. " -'r__,.\._ " !, Plaintiff Lorrie Slouffer !:lllserls It Is nol so omrecl. III, ARGUMENT " I I Ih order to enlerjuqgmenl on ,the plGl'lcUngs, a Courl must aooept as Irue 1:111 well'Plel1dadl allegations In 11113 ComplEllnll1nd reJeot asunlrue ,the allegElllons Of.lhe. moving party which are denied oy the Plalnllffs, EJill1lID1vanla GAB I'lnd Water company v. l(assflQ, 322 A.2d 776 (1974) In Ihat CElse, tile Cotlllnonwealtl\ Courl oiled with l:1PPI~ovl:11 Goodrloh.Arl:11n prooedural Rule III Servloe for Ihe following stl:1ndard: "LIMall sLll1l1l1aty judgments entered WltlloLlt a trial, jUdgmellt on tile pleadings may iJe entare(./ .only In olear oases and wllere tllere' are 110 Issues of faot, Tile CO!/lt Is toobnstrue tile pleadings alone, drawing all the Inferences and assulIllng all tile oonoesslons whloh would apply In' a rUling on a demUI1W, The movinG patty for tile ju(./gment un tile pleadings admits for (lIe pUlpose of /1/s 3 fill1I/1l11lIlo\)7'O? lI\lI11lfnr hll"f HI lIpplllllllllll. ([llll 111l1ft) A\IOlllIlll, 1000 IIIP/lolI /110 /1111/1 O( II/Iof/II/lOlltl p( IIIlllHlvolllmy fI(1r1 /lIe I/n/fll/ll p( fillY o( 11111 PWIl "I/0UIII/OIIIl WlllolI IIIIVO IwoII (Iolllarllw 1lllllle1VarllmYi NOl'llUW IlVOrmflll/1l Py I/I~ 1II0vlllr/ Il/ll/Y 1111111101/(/1110 IHI/PlIlIIl/oolly 1I/IIlIlUfll Wllloll nae/ino/ pe elen/ael, /Je. 110(01)/11(1118 /f/WI" , . . Slnh!ll'" or 1I11111nllonu urn OOn!ltfllfHI flnoorr11no 10 tholr \ruo Inh~nl ~nq n1flflnlno, anq Me Qcmornlly IlIlllrnlly Ilonlllnloll with reapon\ tolhelr oll)eol rwl purpqso, llilJlaghor v, ellver 6rnQls QaLlI.Jloll1llill~1 01 BllpnrlQI, 1 (1016) The (Ioa\rlne of ollloppel mflY loll lIie rUnnlno of Ihe " . , ,. ' " " Ihnllntlonll porlncl, upon n al1owlno Ih~t thoPef(wl~nl Incfuooq tf.l Pllllntlff \0 fElII to t1m13ly O(ll11nHlnllll 111[lIlI pmoomllnoa, or otholWlaf.l lull 1110 Plalnllffs Into !01 false almBe of Bf:lourlty, muultlno 111 II r1Cllllterlollfl O'1f.1110~ of posltlllnby Ihe PIEllnllfi. ~l1uey Distilling Oorporallon v, P-umll1~lv.L\llln.BnllrnillUJllllll1lli1Y., 166 Bupar,Ot, 460, 7'1 A,~d 802(1960) Furlher, the IhnltrtllOI1B perlo,~ may pa tollad Py nn!o1olmowledomant of ~n opllo~tlon ole~rly I. . Il1dloUIIllO n fll'Oaont Intol1tlol1 to m(~ot Ihe oollol1l1on" , 268 Pa,11, 101 (A) .' ,. " 020 (1017) . Pnfendl1l1ta, relY 011 two alillulory Blalemenls of the Ihl1ltatlanB period to aupport Ihelr l11otltll1l Tho flrBt la 42 PI1,O,8;A,~66?6 whlllh Bola a f1ve~year limitation period ani , ' , '.'",(3)' 1111 notion to ol1foroe Elny eqully of reqempllon or any Impllllq or reBultlng IruBI aa 10 . rU111 proporly j II 42 PUjO,B,~96625 BoIs a four-year IImllatlon period 011 a oontraot aollon, Seollan 6626, , ...''T,.~......--.. 110wnvor, ~PPlloB 10 oonatruollve Iru'sl whlohls Iho thoory l(Jlder whloh 1~IEllnllffs broughllhe oc;lse, "I' , '_" ,-" n'_T_..._..,..,.....,"'._,,._'._'....~.. v~,_ OOllt1lrllotlvo IrutllI!! u remedy deslonod by Ihe Oourts 10 prevenl unjust enrlotlmant, " I " I " "" ~ I 1/1l1mlr now 1I1/1ltot, l)nflll1llunla tnlao 1110 alnluloof 1I1111101l01111na n/1 offlnno\lVo dofo/1BO, Tho AnBWat WItI1 Nnw Mllllot wna /101 o/1doraod wlll\ n Notloo 10 Plol1d, No Inply III roqlllrtJd III 1110 IlbB0I10f) ollho Notloo 10 Pload, Pn,I~,O,P, 1301, l'lIIll1l1r, 101l1l1 001101llBlol18 111l80rlod III n plomlhlll uro Ilovor doomod ndl11l1lod, llill~, DollltlllJit, 3011 BlIpnr at. 430,077 A.2d 023 (lOIlO) . " i 4 1II0115165,1l7-02 elopffllr Ilr!llf In opp\>61110n (~rl'l eiml\) 'AU(J\I6\ 0, 1111111 Paf!3nch:mts f:\rgWe tllflt tllO last Imprpyenwnl Qone to the hO~lse In whlol1 the Plfllnllffs lIyed 10.0.\\ plfloe In 10fJ(3, pefendl'lnts aPPl'lrently llellflva till'll tlw Iflst ronovatlon pl'!glns thl'! rwhnlnf,J of ,. " , Ihe lImlll'ltlona [l\3rlocL Five yef1rs from tll1:11 lima woul~l Ile 10fJs, T11l:1 Oompll:1lnl V(I'IS flied on , .._......,~_.". " "-, _ ' .'r~"'''''''''''''-''.''''. ,~~r~,~-,.~~-~~ TllePefendl'lnl1l Pelll'!ye that Baotlon 66~61ll'lrS the Olfli;~." ,'. ""',. . , 'To pegln, 11113 Instant OI:1Se orlglnl:1ted with 1:1 Wrllof summons fIIedili1 J~lly, 10fJ1v. Tile I', -~'_.....~...........,,~.."...n.~~.~....__l" T'''______'''"'''_:'_ ............-...;"l,..l, ._.-1 , , I, , Oompll'llnl IIllslf III slh'll1t 1:113 to on Wl11QI1 elate In 10P3 the ,renovl:1t1ons wprl'! oompletl:1d, I:1llsumlng mouendQ..lhl'll the ql'lte of the Il:1st renoYl'ltlon Is 1:1 releYl'lnt dl:1te at,I'III,~Pefenelahts, Iherefore, ,. .. oannot show 011 tile pasls of tile pleadings that five yel'lrs pl:1sseel from ttle (jatl'! of the last of the .rel1oV<1tlbnll to tha ql'lta of tha toiling of 11113 stl:1tuta py the Writ of Summons, Seoondly,llla flva,yel'lr stl:1tute of'llmltAtlon III lolleel IlY Plaintiffs 'ooouPl:1l1oy of tl1a' premlsl3s, (>J.lIardloe v, MoOaln, 376 Pa, 62.8, 101 A,?,el 366 ('1064); RE1ymafLIL...Morrl~, 361 Pi'l, 683, 66 A,2d 397 (194fJ)1 Wosohe v, 1< ranlng , 363. PI:1, 481, 46 A,~d ~20 (1046): Barrett v. fuuI1blli:, 81 PI:1, 247, (1876) In thesel:1ncl numerous Cl'Ises Wllloh followed, the oourtsl1l'1Ve made .olear thl:1t If 1:1 party,ls olalmlng real estotu undel' 1'1 oonstruotlve trust, the stfltute of IImltl'ltlons . does not begin. to run until he or she Is out of oooupanoy of tile premises, Although Ihe Oomplalnt ,If> silent on whether one of Ihem oO,ntlnues to reside In the 110me and the exaot elate. on wl1loh Plaintiffs' separation from eaoh otl1ertool\ plaol'J, Plaintiffs have averred thot they Pflld for the serVloes of tile aurveyor wl10 prepared the a~ll)(lIvlslon plan In 1996, and that subsaquent to the reoordatlon of the subdivision plan, the Plaintiffs E18paratecl from eaoh otller, (Oomplalnt, Par. ~4) The subdivision plan was reoordad on September 16,1996, Therefore, based on tile . " 2. AllhcluoI, 1110 c()rnplaln(rool\oe,tl1ot \110 IOBt ronovollon ooourred In 1003; 1\ oleo mol\ee Ihal Pefendan\e \l1emeelvoBIook BtepB to offeol the promlBed \ronelol' by obtolnlno BubdlvlBlonopproval of.ll1o Bubdlvlslon of Lol 1 . Md 1110 rooordallol1 of \110 BubdlvlB.lon pial', (oomplolnl, Pnr.13) ThOBe 0016 look pl.aoo In 100li.(Oornplalnl,l:xh.l3) 6 " "", 11111 (11l101HI7.0? u\ol1lfnr Ilrluf 111 oppllulllpl1 (;lrd rlmll) AU[Jlwlll, 1\10\1 aVermenl1'l ool1tf:1lneQ In tlw Oompl~ll1li tlw fIV(3.yem IImllallonll perlo~ oo\,*lnolluwe Ilagwn \0 Junany soOnflr \hl'1l1 ~flplemller ,15, 1 P06, II slllllms nol rWI1, Fln~IIYI tile OefenQtmla are wrong whenll1ey relY on \l1€l qala of \he lalll renpvallon aa \1113 elale Il1e five year Elll:1lule of IImllallonEl ppglns 10 r~lI1, A rlohl of aotlon In oonlltrl-lotlvo Irul'll peglnll . \0 rlll1 \lpOn tllE1 prel:1oh of 1:1 promlae loo\lnvey or when onppnrty Imowa or sl10Ulq reasonflPlv l\I1oW'of\l18 Gmnlors wrongful rell:lnllol1, ~lIv8r,v, SlIvm:, 4:21 PtI. 533,219 A,2q 659 (1966) In Il1e OEls8 fll pf:1r, at leasl unl1l1 095, the Defenq€lI1ts wera 1'10llng on IIlfllr Inlen\lon 10 oonVey 1-011. They w~re IEllllng Ejfflrml'1t1ve 1'10tlons ,re~ulslt8 10 IIle (.lonveyanoe, to wll, \118 s~ltJqlvlEllon of Iha' !' .,.... . .,;; j,. " BupJeol proparly, II Wf:1S nol until t3pmlltlmeafter Seplemper 15, 1996 Ih~1 pefenqants renep,eq on Illelr promlss, I2ven If tl1(3 refusal to oonvey 1001< plaoe the day after DefenqEml'EI reoorqeq their !I'ubdlvlslon plan, Ihelr refusal oommenoes 1118 running of Ihe stElMe of IImlt~lIpns, ThaI I " ooourreq lessll1al1 five years Elgo, " I' Defenqants 1:11130 a!lsert Ihal tti~y h<.1Ve a defense to PIEllnllns' elation In oontraot or qUl:1sl " . II oonlrElot". Any Aotlon on oonlrElct or qUElsl Qontmol oarrles El four-yem limitations period, The ,. d " Plaintiffs e\Ver, as.set out In the paragraphs 1:1 pave , thElt the running of the statute of limitations , ' oommenoes with the last renovallon to tl18property, Please note that there Is no l:1uthorlly provlqeq for Ihls position, It la l:1 bElld assertion, Defendants then AVer tllat anY oontraol <1011011 Is I, " " barred by El four year IImll<\lIon period whloh would run, then, sometime In 1997. Plaintiff, asserts, El,s she qld Itl the par<lgraphs above, that any breaoh O(oolltrao\ did not tal18 plaoe unlllafler' September 16, 1995, This four year limitations period would terminate, at the earllost, on " 'I j September 15, 1999, By Il1at tlmo, not only was a Writ of SUmmons filed, but tho Oomplalnt Itself' Was flied, 6 to filII Illl 1 0lh(J7 .o~ ulollffnr hrlM 111 oppqulllol1 (;Irel tlrllfl) AllfJllul (i, 1000 , r'unl1prl In Q oontmol nollon, Pofan(l.mtB mp oBtnppecl fromnBaartlno n r~lnnlno of 111\3 . . atnlule pf IImllflllonB dllrln(J tho porlod wllan tlwy Indl.lop(j Plnlntlffa to fnll to' oommonoe laglll prooaadlngs 01' otllelWlso 11.11113(1 the. Plnlntlffa Into f.I' flOllsp Bense, pf aepurlly rpaulUng In II . dplelerloua ohnnge of poalllpn by 11113 Pll1lnllffs, Sll1ncfmq PA Pmollce ,~13:571 Kinsey QJfttJIilnQ OorpOrtllllm~rllil,Sf!l[[Qw;l Ooml~, 166 SUper,OI, 406,71 A,gq BOg (195P) l3y prPQlleqlng .lpWflrq .lh6lr stl'lleq Intention of oonveylng 1-.01 1 10 Pll1lnllffa, 11111\ la by submlltlng €I BubqlvlBlonplEln 101l1e Towno!1lp for approVElllOlnq reoorc:llno tlml pllOln, Pefenc:lflnls evleJenoaq I'l oontlm-1eeJ Intent 10 Irflnafer the property, There would hflVll beliln no reflBon, for the ' Plfllnutfs 10 !1flve filed Em ElPtlon before Septamber 15, 1995, fla Ihe Pefendanla Wera In Ihe prooaas of performing on Ihelr promise, Tharefore, 1118., Pefendflnls I'lrllllSlopped from flsaenlng Ihe four yeElr Slflll.lle of IImllflllon peforeS\lplember 15, 1999,' . Slmlll'lrly, In I'l oonlmol Elotlon, Ihe stntl1te of IImllatlons may oommonoe to run from IIl.e IElsl flokl1owledgmenl of I'ln IneJebteeJness, Standard Pa, Praotloe, ~13:18g The ElollnoWledgment pf IndebteeJness must be an expression Il1at oleorly .lndlOEltes 11 preaont Intention to pt1Y Ihl=! IncfebteeJness, conBlatenl VlI1I1 n promise to pay on demond, Payment need not be Immediate, but the Intention to ptlY mLlst be preaent, &h.Manilltalds' fIDf'J.lli, 258 POI 11, 101 (A) 920 (1917) The submission for approvElI of Ihe subdivision plrin and Ila a~lbaequent reoordlng 10 evldenoe of ' befendants' Inlenllon 10 mal~e the promised transfer, Any slatute of IImltElllons oannot begin 10 ,run before Seplember 15, 1995, IV. cONcLUSION 'rhe Instant oaDe presents the not unoommon situation where a husbElnd and EI,wlfa live on ~roperty owned by In-laws. 1111he usual ORse, when the spouses separate. t1We Is 11'0 reoourse 1 0I1l116106.a7.0~ ~IQlIrf(Jr hrlo( IrlPflflPalllnn (;3nl dl'l1f1) A\1rJ\IS! 6,1000 fpr Iho pFlrly Whoae paronls qO nol own the property on Wllloh the fT1f1 rllf1 I home Wflll allual!3Q, In Ih\3 Inalflnl oflap,howflvOr, Il1ere Is a allbslflnllfll qlfferano\3, In 1I1e Instanl Ofl!la, Iha Plflln\lffa, ,. -. . 1 relylno uppn pOfenqflnls' promlae 16 QOllvey 1110 properly, prooaon13q pvpr a13varfll yeflrs Ip InVeal supstf.1nllfl/ mnounla 10 UPorF1Qe a sml'\1I on13ratory house Inlo I:1lwo-slor}', elol1l beqmom hOUSSI , Plfllnllffa Imd 110 raflao~ 10 bfllh:lVe \111'11 pafenQl'mls wpulcl nol ponvey tha prop13rty l:1a promlsaq, . Thlsla tr~te eapoplfllly onoe Il1e (Jefencfl'mla aupmllteq 1'1 aUbdlvlslon pll:1l1to tile Ipwnahlp InWl1loh . tho properly Is looF1led anQ au!Jaequently repordoej Ihe plF1n, Suoh slaps I:1re nepessary Iq floocmpllsl1 tho transfer oonlemplaled, It waa only after,Plalnllff ~orrle Stouffer separalerJ from her husband, tho son of \he PafendanlfJ In Ihla Oflae, thaI Ihe Defenclanla reneoe~ on tl1elr " promlae,~nd In ff.1ol,now slale Ihf.1tthey naVel' mf'lne any auol1 representf.1t1on, Dafandf.1nlll flre IImllad by Ihe Elssertlona mElde'ln the Oomplfllnl, .. ap lono as ~orrle Slouffsr was rllsldlnolll Ihe mflrllElI homo, Ihe IImllatlons perlon, did not commence 10 run, ,Althoughlhedflta of sepamllon of tho PIEllntlffs Is 1101 Elsserted In the OomplEllnt, Plfllntlffs clo aver ' i that thfll sepamllon tool< plaoe su!Jsequent to Septflmber 15, 1995, The WI'll of summona was ./ , fIIocl on JUlY ~O, 1 g90, Nallhel' a five year nor a four yeElr IImltatloll has pAssed a/noe that time, FLOWER, FLOWI3R & LINDSAY, P,C, Attol'nllya for PIlllntiff .. By: O~le~ 4/f'f'l o 1:\lllIllIll'llIlIll COllnl,y 1'1'111,111111111,,\ ry 'II (~IVII (~i1{111 11I'i1l1ry , Ill!lIl'll'lO!ill I1'I'O\IFI"I'~ll l,ollll1l': ^ 1':'1' AI, (VII) Ii'I'OIIi"i"I'lIl IIOl'orr1lliJp 1'111" I . , ," ,{lfll} ,'I'Y\IO, , I , " WilliI' Ill", H\lMMll.Nll/l':l,JUI 'I'Y 'I'll (jllllll\ ;, I ' " ,\" ,on 1, II 0 1\1111 111111111 ' 1111PlH\11I l)i.lllil,I' ,- " "" , ":' -. C,IIIII (!lIl1l1l1l1nl,I' " I1YH!i' 0 Illlluo I I"HIP I"HANII I': I':'!' ^1'0'''''~-'''''''' ,I'; II III 1 , '" , ',' , I'll? n I !l P.1l I IIIP" """ I ,J , 1':XOilIlLIIIII 1)1\\;01 ()~{tuJlw~ .Jllry 'I'rliil.. " " 111111'111',10'1 'l)ii'll' O/oo/nooo' 1 q III I' (,I', 1, I I q 10,1' (~r. ;1, I ..................1......1.............................~.....A..~............... (lllllol'lIl Inllllx 'Al,l,lIl"noy Illill ~II'OIIl")"lll 1IO~~ II,: 1\ "0 J "",,: 1 '1:1,1" ':HY I, "0 ,',' H ~'l < I': \ 1 ) 'I' l' "'I' JOd1'lJ lillllll';/\ 1'/21;'/ ~'l'lllJll'I"lm POll I H 1'1 0' l W 1 H'I' 1" '''I' IId,hlAWnl1H j '1;1\ ,1'/;>.11'1, 1'1,1\ I ~'I'I 1"1" I'l, I '1'1 "I" PI,:01': I'AN'I' 1,1 ~1)H^Y CAj((lI' ,/ ,I )1' Y C ((l I ,j ':N( ,110 '1'1 A l'l'liv 'I' PI':Jo'I'INI1ANII' I':NUI d':H '1'1 MIl'1'1I Y '1' ,I \11\1.)11111111, 11I<lIIX H'I'OI,II"j"Nll 1"11111'11<, I': H"OU ""I'J I IJ llllH 1'1 AIIIIII'"I, PIIIII: lJill,lI '1/9.1)1 I !l!lll 'I I~ II !lUll 1'111 PI'iNI11'iNtI I, H .1'1',1'11 ',NH ......................................,.........*....*.........*.**.*..*.{,*..** * !llll:o I'lllLrjol1 ' .', .'.. '. .. *"" * *'. ,I . ~, . ,... A' '. "1 '.. '.. . .... '. '. '. '.. . .. . . . H A . . .' . . . '.' 'h' . '. . . . '. A. I . '.' '.' .' . Ii'. *, ....... . *, .' . ~ n,., ... P'IIW'I' 1':N'I'IlY I'lt^,,)(! 11'1': 1"()1l WIl 1'1' (Ii" tilll,tMONH IN 1'IUI. 'I'Y, PIlAI:l(~ '11'1': 1"IJll 1.1 H l\j':NI1I':NII ^NIl 1.1 H i'1':NllI':NH l'IN'I'I':IlIW ,~ .. ., ., ,. ...) . ... ~"\':lUFI"'H IU:'l'llIjN 1"11,\':1 ' 11t~~r~~\I,I~' : I". ~'~~;\ ~ ~'lj:~(, ~ j~'T)!~(JQ\m~ MllIH~I~~',1'1!0~,',I,., 1','II~)~I':ll, ~) ~ ~ t. ~ U ~ ~ ~~ _ ,. _ __ 'II?~111H)n HII\'iHII"I"'M 1ll':'I'IlllN Fll,I':1l 1,,1 :1'1,1'1111" I tpl'lllll"I"I,m IlOlllH 1'1 HJo:llVh ) I 'l/2:l/ lJ I W WI' (li" HIIMM (J(H'I'H I $12,llll 1"I,llWI'11l M(JIHlI'IN'I'II^I, i"I,OWI'11l I':HQ \Ill '1/2'1/!11I -. """~. ~ --", ,. ,. ., . ..- ,- . -..". ..... .. .." ,- . ".. "., coM P I,^ 1 N'I' ,- I':UIlI'I'Y NI"I'Y I" NIlH^ Y 1'1l1\1~CIi'I': 1"OIl l'IN'I'IlY m' ^1'i'1':I\IlANCI': I,I()I{ IlIH"I'H IIY 'I'IMO'I'IIY 'I' I~NUI,I'iH I'll:!\,) _,_... ... __'_'n ... ,..._ _'_....h ._,._, _,.. ~_"....... ~_.... ,. __ ...., _,_. n_....._ ..__ _,.... _._._. ,_ ,., .~.-...~... ..,.. '4"_',,_ _ ~... _.., _...~_ ANHWlilH 'I'n COI~PI,1\ 11'1'1' IIY 11i':I'''I'H j;I;^,' i,ii~ il~i::'II'(l .. j.,II';I'A(:ij - VI'llii' j"1 C^'I'ION 1'1 I'IM:!I': . A'I"I'^CII '1'111': '.'I"lNC, ;i',os~j) ,. - ,- - - - -- v,lIUJi'1 !^'I'ION "n ANHVHl '1'0 (IOMI'II^IN'11 Ilf\l1'I':1l li/ln/UJ IHj.lII'R .....,.......,,_,_~_,_ ,....,...__ uu',' ___ ,.__ ....." ..._.._......__..,_..,..,_~.__..__~__.____... 1IIIIII::I~1 I'H, 1"()ll I d 1",1'1 ~~I(:IIH I': 1"OIl ^IHIIIMI':N'I' 'i'IMP'I'IIV'~'H I::~~~l~~~~ _ ~',I."~,'~ ,Y~!~'~' 'NP'l'lUI': I1V DI':I"I':N!lI\NII'H (li" MO'I'ION FIlIl ,lIl1llIMI':N'i' oN 'I'm: l'f.l':AIJINCIIl , .. 11^1i'1'" I':N'I'H Y " ,., - . ...........il..............i..............................................*...*. · " .' '1~1,r:I'IlH 1III'0t'lIJilL 1011,,', . * 1"GlJB Ii !lllbl LA .. nllq ,\/1.1 I'Y'jll:l1/ II'" 1':IIr1 111\1 . * *.**.*......,..*.........,..............*".....4....*".t... .......*.*.....'*. 7If,O/I!lUll 7/?o/l!lnli 7/2~/1U!)1l 1/:111.1 UU!) 4/2(iIlUU!l 5/1011 !l!lU !i1l2119!)!l fill!l/l UUU 6 I I !l/l uun Wit I'I' Clio' tlllMMONH (HHIII':n' WH 1'1' 01" HlIMMnNH 'i'IIX ()~ WIlI'1' IjWI'il'11 ',MI':N' I . (1M I, "I" I, I.; \ Il '1' " :l!i , 00 ,!iO 'i,OO !i,OO U.OO ,00 ,00 ,00 ,00 ,00 :1!i,110 ,!',O !i,1l0 !i,110 !), qo !i'I,'iO 'i>\ ,'iO ,00 ...........................................................**....**...f.*..'.*** '. I';n<l Ill' Il1lHIl 1l1l1l1'1i1i1l,IIlll . " " Impr\lw\1 wllh II tll11l1l1 hIlIIHO' (!iV~\ Cllmpllllllt, I(xhlilll I '1 (}j, P\II:IIlU Ihoollllro porlllll PllIll1llnl! ' ro~llloll 1111 POI~lllIIIIIIH' prllporl)' Iho)' IlId 11111 PIlY I1I1Y 1'0111111\11 r~II1HIIIWII 11l1lho prlll10rlY IIllho . IlhWIllll1l1l1llll1Horollll1l 01' \lw POI'ol1lll1I1IH, (Hoollxhlilll 2, ^IlHII'OI' il\od MIIY 10, 11)1)1), ~112 , ' 0101'0111111\01' "1\IlHWIJI'")), PllIll1llnl! 1\1'01' Ihlll Ihoy I1111Wl\ III 'I'1I'0111Y-OIl\lllrllllll Hlrool (I ,Ill 1/ " NlImhol' 0110)111111 bO~1I11 rOllllYlI\lPI1 PI' \lw 11I1\IH\l111 1'\111111100 111111 prl1ll1lH\l \lY l)ul'Ol1lll1l1lH III lI'III1H\'or Iho Pl'ppu\'\y 10 PIIIII1II nl!, (1'100 COlllplllll11, I\xhlbll 1 ~I~I (I,' 12, 17). Tho I 111 pmVOlll\lIlIH . 0111111\011 by Plllhllll'l\i h\Olllllo Iholltldillllll 1l1'1I11I1'll\l pproh II11lJ7fl,IIIllldllltllll1 10111\1 hllllHO ilHol1' . 111 11)fl3 Ill' II)H'I,II OlllwroloplIl!lllll1t1 pOIlIII1II)H(l,lI'hll'!!U2 Hlol'Y 1l\1I'Il!W 111111 wllrk Hlwp In IlJHH, IIlltlll HOOOIllIH\!lry 11I1 tI il III 11 111 tho IIOIIHO IIHol1' 111 11)1)~,(floO Cllll1plllll1l, Bxhlhill '1~17.11), Tho Pol'onllll1\tH II0ny I11l1lihllllll1Y proll1lHO tll OOIIl'OY tho proporly to PllIllI\ll'I\i 11I1IIIIYOI' Ihnt IIny 1111l1rOWl1Jol1lH Il1l1t1o to thu homo 1I'01'0\1I11101'1lI1IUI1 wllh Ihoh: purll1lHHloll, IIHHIHlllnoO lIml 1111111\01111 H\lpporl, (HOU I\IlHWOI', Hxhlhll 2 ~I~I fl.\ H), '1'1\0 PllIll1l1l'1\i I11l11lu Ilw r0I10YII\!llI1H OVOI' II nl\o01\. yOllrpurlol1 ullllll1!! 111 11)1)3, (Sou COlllplllll1l, IJxhlhill '111), WI\l1\1\1ll11\yII1IUI1t101\1l1' trll1\HI'uI'l'i1\g thu proporty 10 tho PIIII1\t1I'1\i, 01101' lIholll Mil)' 5, 19lJ5, Iho Dol'oI\IIII1\\'H Hllhl11l\totll\ HlIhtllvlHlo1\ plllll HOPlll'lItll1lll.01 No,lllntl Lot No, 2, (Soe ^1\H\I'O\" Exhlhlt 2 ~113, COl11pllIl1\I, Hxhlbll t "13), Tho IlrOH0l11 1101101\ \~IIH 1111\111\01\01\ 01' IIbout MlIl'oh 24, Il)l)lJ by Lorrlu S, SIOllrt'ol' linol' Rho hlll\ HOPII\'II\od li'o11\ Jol'l'o\,yl., Sloul'l'oI' IInd liIod II C0111pllll111 fhl' dlvol'ou, (Soe ~l1\npllll1\\1 I~xhlhll I '1~14, 14), . Jon'oI'Y L, SIIlUI'f'ol' IH .1011\01\ IIH 111\ Inl\lHlllll\Hllhlo plll'ly 10lhlH Hull h~ L\ll'1'lo S, Stouffol'l (Sou C01l1plllll11, Exhlhl\ I '1 5), Tho Dul'ol\l\lIntH l1\od 1111 ^nH\Vol' 01101' IIboul MII~ 7, 11)1)1) 11111\ \'IIIHcd the dol'oI1Ho of stlltulo or 1I1111\II(10l\H IIH II now I11l1l\ol', (Soo Exhlhlt 2, ^I\H\VO\, 'I~I 21.25), 2 '1 1'1, hIlIlUI'IIlIIII'''''lllIM Whlllh I\I'P 1'1111'\'1111 l\~' ~lIl1l"lp~ nl'l,h"lIl1lhlll~ TIll' PUI1I1~~lvnllll\ ~llpl'UI1W COliI'I hllH I'PPUlllulli)' Ill11pIHlHI?,Plllh'plll1pnI'\II111 plll'pllHPH Ihlll III'P Hlll'v\l1l \1)' HIliIlIIIlH 01' Ilillll\lIll1l1~III1,lulilll'III1UU Cn, nl' Nonl1.l\lll~l!.l!LYtC'ul'!l!llmD, 44fi I'll, , ilU, 2H4 A,2\\ 72H (11)71), \lw C\llll'l HIIIIIlII Ihll\ "ll1Iw P\ll'pPHU nl' 1I11~ HIII\1111l PI' 11I11III1IIPIIH IH In UXIW(II\1l lill!llltlllllllllll IllllH ,lIhcnlll'II!lU 'I chi)' 111\11 Ihu PI'UHUI1II1t1nl1nl' HIIIIIl 1lllllmH whluh 1\1II~ !lI'PIIII~ pl'oJlllllup t1w 'lol\lI1HC nl' H\lph p\lIl1nH, (~ltll1g Ulllkovlo Y~1!llllliillilll1~lli, DI) " PII, ~711 ~75'5761 101\,211'11 (11)40), HIIII,\,IIPH nl' 1I1l1illll,IIlllH I1nl nl1l)' HPI'VU Ip ulvu pl'oll1pl 111llluu IPI,lllt\lI1(llIl1tH Ihlll u\nlll1H nl'o 11ll111!!1l1l\l1011!llllilHI Ihum, hilI Ihoy pl'uVlllll Hllllp pllIll11H \11111 Ih\lH pl'nIl1Plol111l\III)' 111111 HIl\hllily, !ili:1I~nl!IIl\l v, PI'UI'llI' F\ll'I1nUOH, 41 U PII, S\lpol', III, 114, 613 1\,211 51)5, 51)7 (II)I)~) 01t111!! BHllllu nl' (jIlHhll~ MudlClI1 c;':!!lll!!J~nf' BUlt1'll1' Cn\lI1I~.Lln~, 4H7 PII, 2M, 272, ,1(1) 1\,2(\. 343, 34fi (I fJ71)), Thu dul'~I11HU nl' Iho Hlllllllu Ill' IImltlltlnl1H IH I1IlI 100h111PIII, bill HllhHllIl1lll1ll1l1d 111Ul'llnl'ln\lH IIH IIw H\lch HIIII\lloH III'U vltlll Hi Ihu wull'lIl'o ,if Hnolol)' nt\llnl'o 1'lll'Ill'Ild 111 Iho IIIII'I SChl11\ICk~11' v, NII\1ul!!, 426 I'll, 203, 231 A,21112,1 (1l)(i7),1I1HIlI'II110C po, nl'Nlll'lh Al1lul'icn, 446 Pn,l\1 51. 2U4 A,21\ III 721).730, 111 C\I!l!l!illlh!lll1 V, II\H, ClllnI'N,t\" 515'PI\I 480, 530 A,2d 407 (I1)8'!), Iho Cllml Hllllod IIllI\ HII\\\I\OH nl'lIl11ltlltlnl1H ul11hml)' l111pol'II\I1I pollc)' J\ldg\1l01\IH Ihnl 1Il01\1IIu II hollul'thl11 lIol'ollllllnlH Hhnlll,l ho proloo\c(ingIlIIlH( tho pl'o,llllllc\l of hllvln!! lol\ul'onll ngllhlH(Hllllo ullllmH, llH wollllH Ihu notion \hlll, III HOllwpollll, olnlms sho\ll,1 ho IlllII to I'UH\ HO Ihlll Hou\ll'lI)' lll1dHlllhlllty Ollll hc l'OHIOl'cd 'in h\ill1l1llllfl\\II'H, . Soo lllso'II1HI\l'llI1C~i C~I11)1I1I1Y 01' ~nr\hAmol'ion v, Clll'l1uhul1, 440 I'll, 48, 51, 284 A,211 72H, 7';!.1) (1971). Suhll1\1okol' .. v, Nll\llllo, 426 PII, 203,205.206,231 A,2d 12\, 123 (1967), \1 3 " \V1l1I~lll\llllllhn\lhp Iln'l\llh pI'Ii\lW ul\'II1IlI'IHlllo IIw On\I~lInl' HOllnl1 Hlnl'\H Iho 1'1111111111101' 11\11 Hlnl\ltp pl'llmllnllllnH, SilO ,lJhhoI'LYLI~>JllmllltJ2U CI!J, J4H PII, 129, :14 1\,211 '193 (11)11:1), ThlH 1'\llp pl'PI11010H thl\ pollll~ 1'11111l111110 lill' 1111111111111111111 HIIII\I\I'H Ill' 11111llnllol1H h~ I'llllllll'll1U pOllplp II'hp 11\\\'1' HIII'fol'olllllpunl.wl'llnUIIl OIlI1W'i\11'1I'1I1'11 nnll IIHHol'\ Ihoh' olnlm, 1l.1. II IH 1101 d\lHIUl1od 10 III\PW plnlt1\lfli; III 11'1111 \111111 Ills tn Iholl' 1I11\'nn1111l1l01' HPl110 olhol' \1111\111' 1'\lIlHOl1l\l houll1l\lunl, pl'pI'00dh1UH, .l!L". , Il1lho pl'PH\ll1t OIlHP, Plnll1l1 t'lil Il\'Od I'onl ll'po PI1 \.01 N\ll11llul' OI1U 1\11' P\'OI' oluhtool1 ~OI\I'Hpl'llll' In I,nrl'lo Slo\II'fpl"H HOPII\'IIIl(ll1 fl'om .101'1'1'0)' 8I011ITOI'I Pmll1U thlH porllldPllIll1llfli; IIV1ll'IIlIIt Iho>, porl\11'1110d 1\II\IIIIol1H 111111 rOl1o\'lIllol1H tll Iho propol'\~ 111 1'01 1 1\Il\l0 lllllho pl'lll1\IHO 111111 polblHllIl1tH wO\llll Irlll1Hlbl' 1110 pI'OpOI'\~ 10 tho PIIIII1IIf1s, (Soo llxhlhit 2, Compllllnl '1'1 (i; I~, 1'1),' 111 Plllll1tlfl'tl' C\llllplnll1l Iho~ ololll'l~ oHIII\lIlHh Ihl11 ulllll'tho 1'0110\'ullo11H \nlho pl'llpUl't>, WUI'O ,. ,. oOII1pIUlul\ 111 19\13, (Sol'l\xhlhlll, Complulnl "11), IIIH IIIHo \lIHIIHp\llull Ihut tho.I\'ol11lhu thl1u tlw rlllll1l1fts 111\1\'011 Ol1to IA11 No, 1111 1976 \ll1ll1lho \11110 Iho COl11plllll1t II'UH IllulI, Iho Pul'ol1dnl1t'H hllvo nuvol' tl'lll1Hlbl'l'ud Iho pl'opurl)' 10 Ihu 1'IIIII1IIt'1i;, Thul'ulbl'u, ns 11110 nH thu und of Ihu rUI10\'ntI0118 In 1993, tho PllIll1tlfli; hlld II right to Il1l1ll1lu nl) no\lOI1I\1I' UPI1Hll'llullvu, 1.01'1'10 StO\lt'ful' 1I1ltlnloll II luglllnullpl1ll1 Mllruh of IlJlJlJ 0111~ IInUI' Ii II I1g 1\11' dl\'ol'uu Ihll11 ,Iom'u~ ~\O\ln'ol', Thu HII\I\\lu of' Ihnll1\1IollH pr0I\10\UH l'uHoI\l1l01l of IHHIIUH lit, Ihu Ill11u Ihuy U\,U o\,ulllud 01' l\IHuovorul\ 1\l1d 1\I'Ui!UHl!jl1Cll IL' pruvollt plllll1t1f'ti; Ih>111 wllllll1g \11111111 IH lolhuh'lIdl'lI11IUgu 01' . HO\11U olhu\, \1111\\11' l'unHol1lo hugll1luglll p\,oouOlIIllgs, Lorrlu 8to\lt'lbl' wullud 10 IIlu 1111 nOl\111l \ll1tl\ H\luh II 1II\1u liS 10 I>rovldu lu\'u\'ugu III hul' dlvol'uu pl'llcuudll1gH, Thu nli1l0\lIH uxn~t1)' whlll thu , .. Hlllt\llu ofllmltntlolllllH dUHlgllud 10 pI'UVOI1!. Thu 1'IIIIIlIIft:~ 01111'1101 Ilu nllllwud 10 pruHo\\1 n Htl\lu ulllhn Ihlll p\'o.l\l~lIcuH thu duful\Hu of Huuh OIIlII1\H h>, thu Dul'ol\dnlltHI Lorrlu 810\11'1'01' ohoHu 110110 . l1\u H\l1t In 19lJ3, whOll hur right 10 lllltllllo luglll hugllll 10 1'\111, nlld IIlHlulld wnltud 1111\11 It WIIH to ,. 5 l\Ilr IIIIVIII\\II11o, !\I\Y 01111111 lll'hy 11\0 1'1111111 I fI'H llI'CllI1HIl'llllllvoII'\IHI..1H I1IlW hlll'1'ctI h)' Ilw liW)'PIII' Hlllllllolll'lImll\lilpl1HI V, Imp1tvlI '~nllll'lI\l1 C1l1lmH "I'P nnl'l'Pl1 h~' 'hp FlIlll' "PilI' Hllllnlp of I,lmlllllhlllH PIIII110l'l\l Hlloli III IIllpllHO IIl1hllllY Oil 1110 POI~lldIlI1IH' 11111101' Iwn 1'011llctllhoorloHI hrolluh , \11' 1111 Il11pll\l1l OUII11'lI01 1111<1 Ilw IpIlIHI-ool1\I'IIOl\lIll Ihoury of IInhlHI 011l'lohI11011I, (Hoo llxl1lhll I, ('llmpllllll\ ~119), AollollH 1\1l1l1d\111 IIpOI1UI1 IInpllod CUIII,I.'1I1l1 111'0 ~.lIb.loOllllll\\llhll!' )'1l1I1' HIIII\IlO Ill' IImlln\lllllH, 42 PII,C,8,1\, ~ 5525(~), QlIiIHI-Clll1ll:\lol!\lnhIHI onrl\lll1nol1l IIOIIIlIHi, \11'0 IIli\lwlHO .. .. ~H.". . ..... '~"."~'''''Uh''" ... . ,. HllbJoPI IUlIlh'\II' YIlII!' IImlllllloll porlu<I, IIH 11\0)' c0I181\'1\110 II OllIlII'IIC\ l111pllolllllllIW, SoofulMru.! SloolJUrl1l1 WUlli!!l 1110, v, 1I1010hol' \~ HOIl!\LJJlI!..I ~l)H PII, ::;llpor, HCI, 1)2, 5HO 1\,2\1 H5~, H5Ci (1990),lIppolll <lla1111H8011118 hllVII111110011 Impl'uvl<loll\ly gl'\llllol\, 521) PII, 62, (j(J I 1\,211 Hor) (11)92) (II 11\1I181-0llI1II'1I0l, 01' 001111'l101 Impllo<lll1 IIIW, Impu80H II <lillY, llol 1\8 II 1'081111 ul' 1I11)' IlllI'0\l111011I, , hIlI In 8pll0 01' Iho IlhHllllOO 01' \111 1Il!l'ool11lJIlI \\'1101'0 UIlO Plll'lyrooolvoH Illl.lIIH( ulll'lllhmllllllll \lw ll1\p01180 01' \ll1olhol'~1 42 PlI,C,S,I\, ~ 5525(4) (Hpoollylllg Il Ihlll'YOll1' HIIIIIIIIl or IImlllltiollH fbi' 1111 Ilollon IIpOI1 \I 001111'1101 1 111pll 011 111 IIIW), The Hllporlol' Co\ll'( of PCllllHylvlll1hl hila rllool!l1l~c<llhlll 1110 HI\ll\llo of 1I1111111110l1H hogll1H 10 rUI1 011 n CIIIII11 1'1'0111 Ihc (1111\l Iho clIIIHC or IIc\lOI1 IIOOI'\IOH, Pllokol' Sodoltl:!Jl1. Tl'l\vol J\l!1l110Y-Jnc, v~'oHhYIOI'IIIU U'llvol'~UY or 1'IlllllHxlvnl11n MuI\lllnl COlltol'. "3D I'll, RU\lo\',. 025, 631, (1~5 A,21\ MlJ. 652 (1993), 111 gOIlOl'l\l, 1111 IIll\lol1 b1l80l\ 011 j .' , ,,' 0011tl'll01 IICCI'lIOH 11.\ Iho IImc or hl'olloh, JJ], Whol'o tho cOlltl'lIct IH n QO\1I1I1\\ll1g OliO. Iho 8(111\1(0 of Ihnllllllo\1H 1'11116 1\'0111 Iho 111110 11'1101\ tho hl'olloh OCOUI'H 01' whol1 Ihu cOl1t\'lIol IH 111 801110 11'11)' "lonnll1l1tol\, Thnl'~ v, 80hoo\1hl'llI1I 2D2 I'n, SUpcI', 375, 37H, \95 A,21\ H70, H72 (\963), Tho jhlll' YOIII' 8tnt\\10 of 111111111110116 gO\'C\'Il1 11!l both (ho hl'olloh or I1l1lmpllol\ oOl1tl'lIollllld ., tho Q\\1I61-col1(\'IIollIlI\ thool'Y of \\Il,h161 ol11'ICh1l10l\t hcgl\1 (0 I'Ul1l\l (ho \11110 of tho hl'ollch ol'lI'hol1 (1 d ',./ " 1110 P\1I1\I'\lol WIIH III HOI1WWIIY 10rmhHIloll, 1111110 proH~1l1 ollHll, 11I1' Iho 011111'0 liurl\ll\ prior 101:01'\'10 , SI\1IIITol"H Hlll1l\1'llIlol1li'om ,Iot'froy Hll1l1l'1iJr, \110 111\111l111'l'H IlwIIIlI1I.01 Nl1l11hol' OIl\J1 PIIIII1\1I'1'H \I\'pr Ihlll Ilwy 11U1' 1\1 I'I1wll 1110 1IIIt\lllol1H \111\1 rll\lo\'I\IIIl\lH 1\1 II1\! pl'I111lll'Iy III rolllllWP \Ill Iho lI\logol\ Pl'01l11HIllhlll Pofol1\\\lI1IH 11'01111\ Il'Il1lHlul' Ilw propll1'\y Illlho PIIIII1III'1'H, IIIH 1I1l11lHp\lllld 1I\IIIIhu rOl1o\'lllll1nH lolh~ propol'ly IW!lI\1lIIH olll'ly IIH 11)7(1 111111 woro oompll1lollln Ili\)~, IIIH \lIHO '1Il1l1lHp\llolllhllll1wl\'01l1l1w limo Ilw PIIlII1III'1'H nWVIlllonlo 1,111 NOIIII1 197(1 \\1l\l\lIw limo Iho . COIl'p11l1111 WIIH I1I\ld, Iho rMolllllll11'H hllV\lIW\'PI' IrllllHlurrol! 1110 proporlY 10 \lw PIIIIIlIII'I\l, Tlwrolllro, IIH 11I1\lIlH Iho 01111 of Iho rOl\l1vllllol\H In IIJ\)~, Iho Phlll\lll'I'H hll\11\ 1:lghl 1011111111101111 ' 11011011 fhl' \11'01l0h of Impllo\1 0111111'1101, 1.111T10 HlolIl'lul' Inllll\l~d IIlolllllllo\lol1lll MI\I'oll of 1 \)\)IJ OI1IYIII\or 1111l1l! Ihl' 1111'01'00 11'01)1 ,Iol'i'roy S\\l\IITol', Tho HIII(IHo ofllmllllllollH IH lIoHIgil1111 10 pl'lll'Ollllln 11011011 Hlloh IIH Iho pl'oHoII\ OIlHO whol'o 1,01Tlo Sloul'lul' wllllolllo 11101\1111\111011 111\111 Hlloh II \lll1ollH II WOII11I work 10 hili' mlvlIl1ll1go 111 hOI' dlvol'oo pmooollllll\HI LOI'rlo Slollt'lul' 0lH1HO lwl 10 t1Io Hull III 199~, whol\ hor rlgh\ (11 1111\11110 loglllllo\lon hoglll1 (\1 1'\111, l\l1d hlHlol\1I W\lI\OI\ 1111(1111 Wl\H 11\111111 IH (0 hol' IIl1v/lIllilgo, Any olllll11ol'lIlllll1pllod 001111'110( IH 1l0W hl\\'l'oll hy Iho Ih\ll' YOIII' HIlIl\llo of IImllll\lollH, VI, CIUlchlHlun Tho Dol\lnlll\nIH hllvo rOHpoollilllY 1\1ovod Ihl~C(lIIl'1 101llHmlHH Ihol\hovo,oIlP\lol\ollllollot1 bOOllllHO Iho 1'111111\1 ft'H mo lil\ly hllrrod IIlld oHloppod Ihhl11\SHOI't1llg Iho 01l\h11H Hot fhl'lll Inlhol1' , Complntnt slnco Iho Hl\Il1ol\l'O IlOW liIod hoyond (ho oxplrl\llollof'tholl1nllntlollH pOI'It1\I, , Judgl110n\'l1ll tho p\el\dlngHll1l1Y ho Ol1lOl'od 1Il0l\HOH wI1\lI'0 (hol'o 1\1'0110 IHBllosof Iilcll\nd Whol'c tho OI\IIHC III HoololIl' Ihl\llI tt'llIl would he 1\ Ihll\loBH, IIIH ll11dIHPU(od Ihllt Ihol'ol1ovlltlollH III Iho , pl'opol'l~ III qllOHtloll cnntll1\lod lI'Ol11l1H cl\t'ly UH I \l7o 1I\lllllho ond or 1\)93 IIlld Ihllllhl'n\lghll\11 7 , .' fIIa./IU1GQ.OMR, ~Iolillllr f-PlT1pl'f' 'IvlI ,. I, I I (' 10/3/08 , , I. ,. . I.,.QRRlt: A, ~TOUFFt:R 11111;1 I J~FF~RY ~, 8TOUFft=R, I . . Pll1lntlfr~ I I va, I I FRANK t:, STouFF~R 1\11(1 I DORia N, STOUFF~R, I " Pafandl1nta . I IN THt: OOURT OF OOMMON PI-.t:MI OF aUMa~R\..ANP OOUNTY, pt:NNaYI.v~NIA OIVll.. AOTloN - hAW NO. OQt405Q OIVII..1'J:RM IN ~QUI'TY ~ ,NOW comae l-.ORRIr:' A, BTOUFFr:R, PIf1lnt\.ff hareln, ~y' fln~ through har counsel, Fl-.oWF.R, MORGgNTI~Ah;Fl-.oWGR & l-.INPSAY, P,O" f1n~ states as follows: 1 I PIf1lntlff Lorrie A, Stouffer Is an f1qultln~lvldual who rosldes f1t138 Ruella Prlve, I.ot 50, Shlppanl:llJurg, qymberland Oounty, PennsylvanlEl, ". 2, Plaintiff Jeffery 1.., Stouffer 11:1 an adult Individual who resides at 21 arom:l Street, ShlppenslJurg, bl.!mberland Oounty, Pennsylvania, 3, Frank F., Stouffer and Poria N, StQuffer, his wife, are adult IndlvldLlf1I~ who reside at 20 aroad Street, Shlppensburg, Oumberland Oounty, PennsylvanlEl, 4, The Plaintiffs Mamed herein are hlls~and and wife, having b~en Jolne~ In marrla(]8 on May 2,7, 1970, Plaintiffs are estranged, and Plaintiff Jeffery 1.., Stouffer flied a Oomplalntfor " Dlvoroe In the Oourt of Common Pleas of Oumberland County, l:lennllylvanla to No, 00.4783 CIVil. ,. . " Term, 6, Pll1lnllff Jeffery 1.., Stouffer Is the son of the Defendants and Is Joined as an Indispensable pmty, 1 IIIPllll1flll,07,P~, "Io\llr~r PP1npllt 'Ivll , . . 10/3/00 (' , , 6, 011 or alimlt OlltoPl'lr 1, 1976, clurlno the pl'lrlocl of 11113 Plfllnliffs enOflgpml'lntprlprtp , their marrlfloa, Pefanclanls Iwraln purohl'leecl Ihrea trl'lota of land from Rlqlllml Varner 'tmcl" Pl'llrloll'l J, Vmner, for !'I oonelclel'f.ltlon of $10,000,00, S!'Ilcllmots were Ipofltpcl !'II olo13e proximity' tq the P~fpncl~nts' raslct\1noe, A. aopy of the peed from the VE:1rnere Into the DefemlE:1nta ,Is , !'I1If1oh13ct herato E:1e !:xhltJll "^", onp tmot of the V!'Irner l!'Incl W~ll Improvad wlt,~ 11 t>n1f:1l1 houaa, E:1pprQxlmE:1tely 34' lJy 14', oonslstlng of fl IIvlno room, p\1Qroom, 1<lIohen, E:1nd Ilf,\th on E:1 1I1nQle laval, 'The VE:1mer properly WE\S puroIH\secl~y tlw PpfanclE:1nts with tile Intention of tmnllfarrlnf) to ' PI~lntlffll tha Imol with tha hOllse on It, 7, Qommenolnoln 1976 and oontlnulno therPf.lfler, PIE:1lntlffs, eOlely at tl1!'llr own axpense,renov~tecl the houae f.lml mf,lcle aartElln flupatElntlE:11 acldltlonl'1,most not~tJly, a laroe front porah, pow. wlnclpw ancl elde porah, Elnd E:114' py 40'ac.:h:lltlon to the paok of the houae, 8, In or l:lpout1003 or 1904, Plaintiffs hired a oontraotor to add an aclclltlonal poroh Elnd , , E:1nother addition to the house, this addition ~pproxlmEltely 38' Py 29', , , 0, In or Elbout1986, Plaintiffs, solelY Eltthelr own expanse, Eldded EI oonOrete patio, a sWimming pool, ancl Eln 10' ahed to the property,. .10: In or apout1900, Pltllntlffs,solelYElt tllelr own expenso, Eldded a large OElrage ancl EI .. workshop and built a seooncl story 011 tha garage with a large raoreatlon robin, At approxlmEltely this time, the parties .alao add.\'ld a shed to the property, 11, In or about 1993, Plalnllffs, solely at their own expenae, aclded a seoond story to the house proper, At the end of the 16.yaar .perlod over wllloh renOVEltlonll were oompleted, the one', story, one-bedroom house beoama an eight bedroom hOLlse with three bathrooms, 12, Prior to commencing alt of the atated renovations and addlllons to the property ,. doscrlbed above, the partlea obtall1Gd the permission of the Defendants and assuranoe ~y . . 2 m~.II5160:~7'O~ QIQ~r,r~r ~amp'~' ,Ivll. 111/3/0U ,," " (: , /I, pefenqflnt~ th~t Pef!'lnclanl!l woulcl Imnsf~r tlla prQperly 10 l118m, All ~clfHtlons I1nr~ ranoVatlon~ cle~orlpecl were llnclertl1ken I,n rallflnOEl on Ihe prpml.~ea of PefemhmtEl to tmn~fer th~ properly,to Plalnllfra, ,,13, In 19913, Pefancllilnts l'Ioreecl to olJlaln the~~i~cllvlslon plan E\I1CI Town~hlp'!'IpproVala nElQeaaflry to ttlEl trallafer of tha property to PI~lntlffa, Plalntlffa paid for tha eervloeE\ pf Steplwn p, " I.. i WQlfa, who prepflrecl fI llulJcllvl!llon plfln for Defanclallla, Defendl:1nta Paullacl Ihe pll'ln,to PEl au~mltteq to the Planning Oommlaslon ancl Board of aupervlsore of SOlltlll'lmpton Townllhlp,. . Ouml:lerlflncl Oounty, PannsylvClnlEl, ilnd, ~fter flpproval, the Plan wall reoorcled In the Offloe of Ihe Reporcler of Daecls of Oum~erlancl OPllnty, Pennsylvania In Pl~n 13001< 70, Pilge 1:27, A oPpy of the Plan Is Elttaohecj hereto ae F-xhl~11 "a", I..ot No, 1 on F-xhlolt "a" Is the Iqt whloh DefendElnts " Intencle~ to transfer to Plalnllffs while Defendants Intendecl to ret~lnl..ot No;~, 1~ Su~sequent to the reoordallon of the eUl:ldlvllllon plEIn, ancl before the Deeq Into . PIEllnllffs was slgnecl ~y pefenclflnts, Plaintiffs separated from one 1:1Il0ther. 113, Defenclants hava rElfusecl to transfar l..otN?, 1 on Exhibit "13:', to Plaintiffs, 16, During all, relevant times, Pefendants were In a oonfldentlElI relationship with , , Plalnllffs 'who are PElfendants son and daughter. In-law and Plaintiffs reppsecl great trust and .. , oonfidenoe In Defondante ancl rellecl upon their promise 10 oonvey the subJeot property, At all , relevant limes, Plalnllffs oelleved Defenqant~ promise!! to oonvey and trusted ttiat lJefenclants would never abUse their oonfldenllal relationship, 17, Defandants abused their oonfldentlal relationship when they promised to transfer the property and pormllled flxtenalve Improvements thereon, Imowlng that Plaintiffs relied upon their promise In order to Jusllfy oonslderable Inveatmentln the sUbJoot prdperty, I ,3 , , tl I i ,.1'11, ~' ,,' ,., , "'f. '." .".. ~..... .."." , '....J " , ,..\,' .\. I' I ...._....t..~_.._ _'_ .. ...._It. ..,-., -I.., ,.,,,,.. ..... .,., 1..". 1I~~'ii,~ra~I'lr~IJ~'p ''''', ~!4 III"'. QCbt~ AlMl~ 'rUN i4;t- pI PI'r I<pt'{l ~II' I~p'''"'\(l IIIIIG AHII4r'4 Jattb, lI~vP' ~ An~ "QvQn~~~pix(1~7fil 1111/1' V'M nN'l'II'I#lN , fxon^"P Jil, VIII1NJil!1, lliJlIIh ~IAni M ~hll TpwnRhip P' p\\\:hllmp\:pn I (:lQ, \1n,\:Y, Q" ~ 0, 11111boj:, I\,n~ !lnll OPl11momiflllHh Q~ ' IHH1PY~\'l\ntll, 11/'11'II,toX/\ '" VIIIINml, 1l~Il\lh liol11l1n, Q~' , ' , ! I I I I I I I ~I~B: B~~I B ,ID l~jj'4 :: ' m,~ " "rlI,,'pr I 1'IWill ~t a'rollt'l'J:111 11M pOllxa N, lI'l'OIlIi'I1'Im, 'hip wi'lI, P~ " I\t p, ht IIhipl'"lllnpUl;g in \:hll TQwnnhip p~ IIQ\\\:hllmp\:on, pO\1nt!y 01:, P\1l11bpt'lI1M Anl1 Ollml11Cl, nWI\II~\:h P' rllnnQ~lVl\J1il\, pllt'\: en pfI \:ha IIfHlonl1 pllt'\: liB" ' I I I , , I I qrll""'" I II'I'rN/i/tlSN'l'ff, Ihll' III ~f"l4fmffp" pI '1'lln ',I'holl'''lnl1 (nO, 000, 001 ~""M~~~"" ..,'" "'.,,, tot nl" "'" ~ 'I'!' "'.., "".. "" "'... ""... "'..."'.. '"' "" "" to! '" "" -... 1"'''' '" '" \'" '" '" "" !"t".., "",..... """'" ",~""",..."" "'''''' POU4r'l IlIhllfl(1 p"'d,IA, r,~,jllllvhmpf I' hm~v Mkllpwl,dp'd, Ih. .M4 IImlllor d~ ll~, hm~V,'lIrl1,," "lid ClOIIV'V'P lA, '"II/ pmlll~'~1 ^~'" ~hollo ~h~lle oe~tAin ~~I\!l\:" ot ~And pillll"\: in the Vil~Alla oC Olavet'IIP\I~\I l,n tho 'l'own~h~p pf 1I011\:hllmp\:on QO""\:y oC O\lmbll~~IW\ 11011 OommoJ1l~olll~h of l'el1l1~ylVAnlA, ~1011J111ed AM '~IlQo~lllell IIQ ~ollQWIII tp"Wl~, ~l!Pill~.JilILL~ I1~GXtlNXNG At, A POPII, thenae Ily hnd" noW or; tormet'lv of tha-lfiilrQ' of WUliAm ", YBln\lBt IInd athe).'p, POIIIII' eilJhlly"ei\lh\l (08) l1eg~BllB Wall\: nine\:uen 119) pet'oheQ 110 'A white OAk \:t'eB II\: the t'Aill.'Olld ti\lht"pf"WIIYI thenae North nine (9) degl:'ellll WepII flCty 150) fee\: ~o A pOlitI t\lOnOo by lllnl1 now ot' forme~ly Of Edward JOnaB No~th ei\lh~l'"o1\1h\: (DO l111gt'1I1l1l J:1AQ~ ninot:een (19) pot'ohep ~o II po~\: A\: II PIII~lia, IItt'ootl \:henoa by II 'PIlblia Pllnet: 1I0\lth eighty"e!gh\: (00) dOllreOIl ~lIllt fiCt~ (1l0) foet! to tlho plAoe of Il~GXNNXNQ IJ.IIlIIO'1' NO, 2 ~ I1IlGINNING on \:he p\lblio p\:t'ee\: I\\: A ool.'nllr; pf 1\ lP\: now Ot' ~ot'rnerlY, of MI:'Il, ~\I\t'IlA\",1I lIaller I \:henae by Une pf naid loll 1I0\lth eigl\\ly"oigllt (80) dogl.'oa" Well\: nlnatQen (l~) PQt'oheB. 110" Ilhe, , midt\lo of Rdh'oAd tltt'eotl ,\:!lonQa IIlong \Iho middle of PII~d PIIl'81l11 .. Collt' And \:wo~.f1fthp (4 2/1l) pat'ahllP to \:hll middlll of an eUey r;lInn~ng ""'P\: jl,'I'~~\ U!d \,,~I,I1\l rllll' j,ll '1011'1f1l11n1l\\:1,,')n '1f \'t"j,J1I,l o\'l~l\ed IlI\Q\:Wl\rd f\'..:n fHlj,,1 lM11 ml~n\\j,ollfll1 Nlj,nt;, . \lholloll I\l.Qng t;hll l,j,1\1I of lat. nr;\\~ ol.' ~(l'!\\I,~~'l.l' Ij~ ~'llllill ,\, NO\~"\IPI ,llo11hl1 ~I,vn 1\1111 OM"h/lU,' n, 1/21 I'lfl\l~e.. l1M,11 nuu,' \41 1~II~ahM Iii' ,', 1""11 h (,\1 hho 1.1.0'. or. 110\~ all nM\1\lld\' 1i'lIflnr. ,P., 1I0W~\'~t '.r;o\\ '\.'111 110 !"e hhfl t1f1"\il'I~ Of Itn Ilighll (Ql f(ll)t: nl"hVt thonll. 01011\1 line a~ BRill Mowet'pl lo\: in P/lt't nnd lo\: now 01:' forma~l~ of ' l"l()ll~n Q1nVtill: Wirth oightY"dghll' (00) deg~eBP QI\QIl twelve I\nd twO" fJ,nhllt1 11~ ~('n) llM,'qhM ~I' Crqnh Oil H~f,1\ ft~~"At, 1I\\oInOIl 1\~,Clt.'l9 Pl\J.\\ SI;,lII\I,I\1 t/~~~ I fHI.y"f',IWI (04) t~f1tJlll" hh~ ~.l\I(CJ\l !In nIlOlllt/Xlla, ' LIlDS R Plnall Phooof hllt\ Bolfl t:.o Dl.'uoll IIMIlOck, n\.1nlCl th,\ !lhhlll 1:1.'111111\1 nP. 1,," 1 '~h Lflll "I\I:'~h'~ II. M"""U /In<1 Ol'll:'llllhl! p, nlllHlltU, h:\'. 1/,\,"0 I by h~,\I11~ \l~o.l t\Iltloall Ilh~ nl.a\l dM' :l~ Jnnun\:'l'l 1.H,' ~ncll,'urllllldllll ,1,III\hl/ nP.f,tJII n,)ll hh,. r."ooroll.\'1l of ,'unQ tl'\ al,l" .s h, .112. .s, ~ ' , School 01 I, Cumb, CQ" Pi, ,,,, ~..I 1',Il~ .1"'1h, III I \JJL. ' Oil' IctQ";.'r.17~,,,,:/q~11 " ,\., v a,..~, c., hi, 1l,1, All, ,2:::; &O~N rlOlAUt ~ ~~~W,~,)!I;~i~'lWJ~SfNN,&IWt,NI^ m ~ H~l1l~tI' ;;'l~;; f$.~ II 0 0, 0 ~ ~ . 409 .. Ill, III . S .... ...... .,.... -.., ", , '-""f'" L !, It "~'I '~fU ,,: '" .....'''''....,............,..........--.......- I. _...........--.~......_. . -_.."~..'''.~.....,......., ""-"-"';'---0_- ..~ ,. .' " " I, t , , , . ! I... ~tpl. 9f 09""1V pI OlllhUt Ih. dqV pf f~, 'wlmlv'lfd pQ\9,r, p,r'PMUv p/lp,pr'd ~u, , ~'fm ""I d9 11II9Wtll9 Ill' (9" ,n!/ffp9wrtlv Ilrl'Vfll) Ip ~, Ih, IlmPIl lvhol, IIf\1l'" ,u~m(~ld'o 'h, wItMlllff"n~II"", 01\4 M~1IPW/'dvf"lhpl h, m'""dl~. 'Pili' f,r #h, ,IUrp',N Ihm/n ~~~. . ,. IN IYI'l'NI'J~S 1f/~1iIImp"" I hmll"'9 "'11\11 h""d "lid ,01,/4/ ,,"I, , ""'-",.._-'"..,-""....,"'~,......._,...,,"~,."'""......!"...~ I "I , ,,\ ""'t"."I....tll..I"...II'tt"t~tft"'.._"....'''_'I"'.'...'fl;,"..,...., . fll/. 91 (l8f"f. . I d. hfrf~1I ,'r/IIII Ih"'lh, pm(" mll/,"a, olld pomp/,It po,' '81" oddrm ,.flh"uHhI""o""dVfPIII"jt 1\, II, ,U, Ilhippllnlllm;g, PII, ~7all7 '.I~J~ ,,3\!1~ I ~p 76 ~. /~ ...t~" .. .~I' ,,I' ,,' l! ~~~, ,,,.""':,,, """I""",,,,,,,,,, / A"pn1_V lor ""'H",",~P.,~A!;,~"'-",,"_..,....,.._..u.t " ." I ' .,J' , '-.," I' ". ,. 'I " , . , .' ,"p ,t"'; 1-" ~ . if m l~ ~, " ". '~ I~ "$ ~" ~ "- ~. .~ _I i " ..fa ,Ii! ~td ~f ' , 'I " OOJljtONl H ()11 pmNNS)~W"f!JI" . L" ' , , QQUlltll 0 ....,_,,~~..~~ P:)../ . ,. Rmaonb~D olllhl' "",,g$dov o,~~tf~ II, b, a~ IlIlhe Heoord,r'. 061., 01 UiiOoUtlWI /11 Dud J1.ah V V(I'. I"U"t:f?k.IlIl' P(t08 'fI..~ne,e:. " (, ' ,. mu.tI 'lnder IIIV houd Rlld Ih~~"R/d ,o61q', Jb' d .4bovftvrl/l'II. , u...l. 7" I '. I, + .... ...,r,', "" ''''''".."'''''''''"~, ,""'''''''''"'' RfCord'r, eoo~V 2(l"ALt 5tH ' (/ ... I , ,"' - , ".. , .1., If ...~.--.. .,1 ' " fU ~I~n~ [ U1 .' rtr - ~rN .. iF>> 11~ ~,f':'a' ~ ~ha ' fl'il' f\l ~PN . -~ 't -,.. r . III ftll 11.' It' ... I I:l ' r, \ \ ... ,- ..\ \~,~ ... "",",'" l".fl"\~!l_ [:~ r rl: ' J ~ ' Il~ ' ., . ., . '7 I'll . I ~ .. " rll'l 'f;' It! , . ; , ,I : ' ,I 'j I" :, \,:,~W:l:I"'I' .',. :/ ~.lrLU. ,..... ~ ' I!XH , ' , j. of ' \. " ( , , " \..ORRII; AI IHOUFFt:R IIml JI;FFt:RY f." flTOUFFI=R, .' .. f'llIlntlffa IN THt: POUR1' OF QOMMON PI..I=Af:l OF QUMFl~RI-ANP OOUNTY, Pt:NNflYI-VANIA . VI!, ' OIVII.. APTiaN,., I-AW NO, IlQt40ap OIVII.. Tt:RM FRANI( t:, STOUFFf:1R IIn~ pORia N, STOUFFj;lR, .. .. 'PllfQn~l\nt!l I IN t:quITY ,gERTIFIOATa OF saRVIOE ANP now, thla' dt:lyof _ , HlOO, Oarol J, I..lndet:lY, Ssgulre, of the It:lw firm of FI..OWF.R, Fl-oWSR & I..INPsAY, p,c" AllorneYIl, herepy . oertlfy tht:lt I !leryed the within OOMPI-AINT t,hls cl~y lJy cleposlUng SElina In the United t:ltt:ltea Malll , . First Olt:lsa, poatElge Prept:lld, InOarllele, Penneylvt:lnla, a,ldr/:leead to: "~If, Mr, Frank r:, Stouffar go 13roacl street , shlppenaburg, PA 172p7 Mr!ll Paris N, sto\tffer gO I3road Street ' ShlppenalJurOI PA 17257 , FI..OWaR, Fl..oWaR & I..INOSAY Attornoy for l..arrlo A, Stauffor By: .. ,Oarol,1, lindsay, Ssqulre . 10 #44093 11 Saat High Street Oarllsle, PA 17013 (717) 243-5513 ., , I, , .,' ( ( I " 1 J,Ulmnc 1\, ~TOll'I'llnn 'Hul ,'InIWJi1HY '10 IiTOllf1f1ICH 1'llItllllffli1 I IN 'I'mc COIJWI' OIl COMMoN l'I.JD..\.s 1 CP,,"IIWIU.I\NU COJJN"'Y1 JlJjJNN~Y'~V ..\1'111\ I 1 I CIVil, ..\C'I"ON I NO, 9"0-4(1~" CIVil. TICHM. I 1 I I 'IN I~Qlll"'Y ,,~, Ji'Hi\NI' lil, 1l"'OllJi'lrlm..IIIUl Uo/US 1'1, f.j"'Oll'lf"'CH UOflllulllnt, , tlliIDY1CH'I'qJ1QMflL..\INT ,." ," . . p :~:g" . AND NOW COMIlS, tho Dlltbl1\lnl1la, FHANI<. u, STOUFFER anll PORI:3~~)\ .. ~ llrOUFI'Ull, by ""I "'",'''h Iho'r IIl1ornor Tfilloll'r To 1l1l~,I"o, ",,,,,I.",. on" llomN~~ti ~ OaRAf..po, 111\11 me thin Anawor 111111 In Hllpporl thoroof atntlllho followlngl ~i' " rg I. AlhllluCII, ' '. t:~ ~;; , . 00 "1'1 2, Acfmlltllll, ;r~ Fi ""'!i; 3, Alhnlllcll, ~ 4, A<lmllto,ll, l3y wn)' of f\u"U1\lr IIlIswor, Lorrlo A, 8tollffol'Iol\ tIIll Illnrltlll roslllonoo 011 01' IIPOlII Jllly I a, 1996, 5, .ool1lo(llIa sllltcd, OOfollllnllts n<ll11Hlhllt Joffory L, Sto\lffol' la tholr soil, The rel11l1lndor ofPnrngmph 5 provides n IOBIII'ool1olllSloll, to whloh 1111 nnswol' Is nol roqulrod, To the extent nn ,. IIllSWCI' 'Is roqulred, It Is donled IInd strlot Jll'Oof Is dOllllll1dll.(I. ' .. 6, Donlod "salllted, It la I1Ill11lttcd thnt \ho Defclldlll1ts purohllscd threll tfllo!S of Innd 1IIIlloso proximity to the D~fuildnl1l's rosldonoo ns f\lrlh(ll' deaorlbod 111 PlnlntllTh' E1Chlbll A, Tho Oefcndnllta' nver .lhnt the 1I'l\ots of IlIlld were Jlnrohnscd with the Il1ten\lo rotnlntholll foruse lis nllthorlzcd by .tha Defelidnllts, It Is expressly donled the tmots Wero Jlurohnscd with the Illtont of. tl'nnsfen'h\s the trnot wHh the house On It to tho PlnllltllTh, , I!Mhlbll 2 r~ "I :;1;:1) 'cdp' ~...i.r.. tJ . . "Ai" .15 :~J ~~{~j" tM g \ \ " , ,., .1', '.. 1\,,' ""1 I, " , I '. ,., ( ,,' . , ( , 7, P!lI1IIl\l,~lrl\11 prpnf I~ 1I01111111111l1l, Ily WIlY of '\11'1111'1' 11I1SWOl'lIho hpII~p wn~ plII'ohosell \ly lhll /,)1'1))11I111l1ls wilh 1111 \l1\lsIlI1U l\'ol1l\lproh !\Il!l IlllW wlmlllw, Any ronovAlIlll1~ llr 1\l111l1l~l1s 11111\ \V\lI'O IlwlolP Ih\l pl'opprlY wore 1\\I\I\<lrl~1I1111Y Ihll pOlbllll11l1ls, Tho Pefcl1llAI1I~ pl'Pvlll\l11 , .. " IlIbor 01111' filll\lwllll Assl"tlll1p\l fnr IIw rOI\llVllllpl1s !lllIllIlldtlllll1slpllw properlY, a, Ppnl!lll, ~lr191 proof Is d!l1l1l\l1lIed, 13y WAY of f\lrllwr l\l1sWl'r, 1111)' rOI1OVllllon~ or mllllllollslhnt \VOI'P mnllp 10 lhe prolwrly were l\\llhorl~pd hy Ihe PpfplHlllnls, Tho PPfclldlll1ls , provtdollh\hor 11l\111l1\011\J11I1 n~slslllllPo I'm 11\0 ronovAlIons AIIII Addll\Ollslll Iho proporly, D, Ppnlell, ~trlpt proof Is dIlHll\llll\ld, l3y WAY of I\lrther "'\Swpr, the Defolldllnls nvor thAt tho \lIAll1tllTh pllr\llU\llell A liS 011 nbove.urolll1ll pool wllh IIllllr ApprovlIl, Any rollovnllons or 1\(lllIllolI~ thnl wor\l mlldo to Ihp prOIl\lrlY worOllllthol'ilwlll1y tho DefplHIAnts" Thp ppfpI1IIAI11a , .' '\ provillod Inllor nl1lll1l11ll\OllIl AssIstAlloe, fur thl' rellovnllu1\s Alld AII(Hllol1slo Iho proporly, \ 0, Ponied, . Strlol proof 1811\1l\1nndoll, l3y wny of I\II'lhol' nnswer, tho Dpfcllllllnls nvoI' Ihnl . tho Plnll1l1ffs erooled II smnll nddlllon 10 Ihe P1!lslln~ ~h(lll with their Approvnl. Any ron~vAlIol1s or AdlUlIons Ihlll \Voro mAdo 10 tho properly Worelllllhol'lzlld by IhuPofol1dllntB, Tho Pefendllnls , , pI'pvldcd lnho\, 1I11d OnllnolAI AssIsIAnoo fo\, Ih\l renovAtions IInlllld\IHlollS to Ihll properlY,. II, Doilllld, . Slrlot pl'opf 10 demAndoll, By \vAY of f\l1'lhor Answer, thll Defelldlll1ls !IVel'lhllt Ihoy 1I\llhorlz\ld Ally renOVAtions or IIddltlonslhnl woroll\lIde 10 Ihe properly, T!lo,Dofendlll\ts provided Illbol'lIl1d Onllnolll!lIsslslllnoe for tho renovlltlonsnl1d IIddltlolls 10 IheproperlY, The Defondllnts f\lrlhor IIVel' thllllhll ho\\se hllD four bellrooms nnd Ihreo bllthl'Oo\l1s, 12, Denied" Strlot proof Is de/lllll1ded, By \VIlY of I\lrlhorllnswcr, d\\r\nlllho IIpprl11!hnlltllly lllllhlllCll (18) yellr period thAllho PllIlnllffsreslded logother III i I Brond Street, ShlppOIlSburB, Ponnsylvllnlll, tho>, did nolllllY 1I1\y rent 10 Ihe Dofpl\dllnlsl AllY ronovlltlons or lIddlllons thAI. Wore nlnda to the property \VerellUlhorlzed by tho befendnnls, Tho Defendlll\ls provided IlIbor' .. 2 .. '" t.Ulml!C 1\, l'i'l'lHlIQqm !HHI ,llWFICBY I" H'I'UIlFFICB 1'11I11111f!'" \'H, I%\NI~ I~, l'i'l'UIJFFlcl~ II1HI . nUlWi N, l'i'l'lHWFlcB nlll'lll1lllllll, I IN '1'11I': ~:O\JHT UF l."ml~mN I'I,NM~ I c\i~II"q~'.,\NI) CO\JN'I'Y,I'ICNNHYI.vI\NII\ I r 1 I I I I I CIVII,I\CI'IUN NO, UH.411~H (;IVII, 'I'ICBM IN ICQ\lI'l'Y .N.!..tlJfJH1J1 UlWUS.lTION. I'lunHIl Iuku l\\llluu Ihuldurulldullls, Frul1k E, HhllllTu\' \\Ild !Jll\'IH N, Hlp\ln~r 11'111 luku Ihu dUpl18Hlllll \IPllIlIJl'IlI u~n111lnutlllll ol'.plnlnll I'r \.ol'l'lll ^, Slll\II'I'c\" oil .Inl"ln\'>, 11,2000, nt 1)1 00 n.l11, lit lIw ot'l1CllS or II\lfulldullIs' nllol'lw>, 10Ulllcd nl 61 W, I.oulhu\' SII'\lut, ClI\'lIslll, . I'cllnH)'lvnl1ln, Thu duposltlon Hhull cOlltlmlu 1I'0111dny todny \l1\tll complctcd' ulld 11'111 hu Inkull hull1l'\l11 notn\'y Pllhllu Il\, Sollw othu\, ornuu\, 1\\Ilho\'l~ud h)' IIl\v 10 ndmll1lslu\'nulhs, YO\l nru ,. Invltull 10 n\\lllld I1l1d pn\'tlclpntlllllllw u~\IInhll\lllll1, Thu plnll1tll'g LpITlu 1\, Sto\IITIl\' Is \,oljucSlud 10 PI'OI\!IUU utthu Hulwd\llod IlupllHlIlul1l111 \louul1wlHs wlthll1lhu HUop\loI'Pn, g,c,p, Nil, 400],1, whloh nr\! I'olntod lllrootlyil\, 111I\lro\llly to. nny ol'lIw olnll1\H l1\' dul'onHCS 111lhlH nOllol1, whloh nro In tlw POHHosHlon, uUHtody o\' oOl1\rol ul; 01' nvnilnhlu to, lIw plnll1l1l'1' 01' hur ngontH, rupros\ll1tnllvustlnd lI\\oI'lWyH,' Tho IUl'm "11(~u\lI1Wl1tH" IIlUI\l.duH, hili Is llullll11l1od Ill, l\\lIIlH, nWlllol'llll(ln, ollrruspo11du110U, r\lpnrls, vldl1llll11d n\l(lIll tnpus, I1hllH, nrtlulllH 01' uthu\, puhlluutlollH, quostlolll1nh'uH, UomplItuI' prll1tllllls und t1lu hllhnnntlllll, H\II'VUYH, 01' drnwlllgs, o\, II1\Y ollwr wrltll1gs ol'll'llllHUrlpllol1S ol'nllY kll1d whntHllUvUI' 111 huth dl'lln \lild I1nnllhrlll, .. Dnled: l)ouulllhul' 1 J, 11)1)1) gOHPUUIl\llIy H\lhmlltod' ..lmUlNSON .~ (HmJ\',I)O "\ly:.~c~_)LE_~' ~__ Timothy '1', Ell \101', Es( \111'0 Atlol'l\oy)'D, 0,7R4'll 44ll? Nol'th Frol)t Struut 1',0, no~ 5.J20 II lII'l'lshlll'g, I'Ul)l)s)'IVIII1II1 1711 () (717) 2J2.H525 Atl01'l\0y 1\11' Duf'ol1dll1\1H Ii I.oggm A, ST()\JFFI~I~ 1111" ,lllFFI~I~Y I" STOUFFlJI~ PIIIII1III'1\;, :IN TIIi~ couln ()F~:()fvlMON PI,I~AS : (:'uMUnnI\NP r~ouNTY, PllNNSYI,YI\N'A ' VH, : CWIi, M'TloN I NP, 9H.40SH cWII. TH!\tvl . FMNI'; I~, SToUFI'Il!\ \\IlII POI~IS N, sToUFFlll~ , , : IN liQulTY P!lfIJl1fllll1ls, " nl~Ii'I~NIMNTS' MOTION '1'0 C()I\:l.ru.L..MIHWI~I!.[I'O'IN'I'I~HHOOI\T9J!1ICS ANI) COI\'/IlICI, ImSI'O~sltH TP HI~QlJtCST FPH I'IHlIllJGI10N UF nOCIJMICNTS , 1)0fOlldllllls, FI~I\NI\. Il, SToUFFllR 11I1<1IX)RIS N, 8TouFFm~, ("I)IJlulI<llll1\s "), h)' IIwll' 1I1111\Jr~lgll!ld 1I1\111'11O)'S, 11101'0 Ihls COliI'I plll'SIIlII1II\l I~\llo 40 II) orlhu pUl1l1sylvlIl1l11 R\llus or . ,. . . , Clvlll'l'OUUlhll'o Ihl' \111 01'(101' oOI,l1llolill1g I'llIllIlln~ [,Dlmm 1\, ST()UFI;Ill~ ("Plllll1llff"),lll . , , Ill1swol'[)olol1dllllls' II1IOITOlllllol'loH,lIl1<1 111 S\1111101'1 ol'slll\ll1lOlIol1 sllllo liS followsl I, 01101' lI\IOII! 1'>0plol1\hol' Ill, IlJ!)lJ OOllllHOllhl' 1)0lol1<1l1111s HOl'l'o<l OllllllHIlllhl' PIIIII1I1IT ' " with tho 1ll'lgll1l\llIl1<1 two ooplos of OOIOI1<1I1I1IH' Fll'sl Sol or 1I1101'1'0glltol'Ios lIlHI RO<j\ICSI FOI' Dl1UlIII10111Sllddl'osso<l t\ll'llIll1tIlT, (1\ t1'110 IIl1d 001'1'001 O\lpyof'tho 01l\'OI' 10\101' IHlltlllolw<l hOl'olo liS Exhibit "A",) 2,011 Ooll1hol' 2ll. IlJlJlJ, D!llul1dlll1!H' cOlll1sol. sOl1t I'hdl1llff's cOlll1sol (\101~01' l10tlfylllg hol' IIllI\, \llI<lol' tho POlll1s>,lvlIl1ll1 RuloH orclvll 1'1'1l0c<llI1'U, l'lnll1l1n's l'us\l(mSOS \0 olltstlll1<111111 <lIHcoI'OI'Y II'CI'O 01'01'(1110, (1\ tl'IIC IllI<I Cl1l'l'oot copy orll1ls lotioI' Is lI\lnched horotons Exhibit "U",") " j " " I.OI{j{lIl/\, SJUUFP'lm 1\1111 .IIJ11FIJIW I" 8TOUFFIi!\ Pllllnllnii, : IN '1'111\ C'o\iHT OF C'nlvltvloN PI.I\/\s : C'l1Mlllil{j.I\NIH'O\.JNTY, P!lNNHYI.vt\NII\ VH, , , ! cIVil, t\CTloN i NO, !lH"lll5H CIVil, TI1RIvI FH/\NI'; II, SToIJFFIII{ 11Ilt! P()/{Is N, STOLJFFI11{ Pol\mlllll1ls, : : IN IlQUITY, .' CI~H'I'1 !q(WI'I~ m~!5J~H\'ICI~ I, Thl1\1lhy '1', 1'il1ulol', 11H(lllll'c, hOl'ohy conlly 1I1II1 pnlhc ~ I slor Poool11l1ol', I !l!l!), I sOI'\'oll 11'110111111 001'1'001 oopl\JsnrlllC Ibl'ouoll1u I'lnlllllnii' 1vI11llllnlbl' Cll'lIol' IllCOl11pol, hy \1\JPllSlllllu . HlIl1lO IlIlho Unlled Slnl\Js Ill'sl OhlHH 1111111, poslllUO pl'oPIII\I, InlllllTlsh\ll'u, POIH1S)'I\'lInln, el1l'ol .I, 1.llIdHI1Y, Ils\lllll'o Flowol', Flowol' ~ I.lnllsny II I1nHIIlIgh ~11'001 ClII'IIHlo, 1'/\ 171113 , , \{ospooll\llIy Sllhl11l11od, .. .. HOIlINSON & Glm,u,uo 13YI_~~) [J.-~ Tll1lOlhyT, ~~~lol" 1J~~~\fO- I\t\bl'llC)' l. f), Nil, 7H44H 44117 Norlh 1"1'0111 Sll'ool 1',0, Ilox 532ll 1I1I1'1'Ishlll'U, 1'01l11H)'lvlIlllil 17110 (717) m.H525 Attol'l1oy 1(11' J)olul1l1l1ll1s ., " I, RG ,. 1IIIIIIN~IIN I', 1011(,11111) ,/ Sop\omhol' 10, 1000 corDI J, \.lnd8I1Y, l1~qlllr\1 fl.,OWI1It, Fl.OWHI~ II? I.INPS/\ y 111111~ll-llllh 81root cIII'1I810) PA 171113 .' ' ROI Stollffol'V, Stollffol' 9Yll.A!!.lJUII Nil, 98.41168 Ponl' Ms, \.II1lI~nYI My 01l0n!8 h((vo 1I111hol'l7-o\l 111Q 10 011101' IlIto goo\1 fnlth solllollwnt nogo\lnlloll8 . with yownnd lVII', MoK1\lglll, \'101180 hnvo YO\II' 01'1100 oOlltnot A.my Itlnglo)' to oOOl'dl1\llto o phono oonfol'onoo fOI).1\o~t wuok; . " 1\1 tho OVOllt tlHlt thoplII'tlos 11I'0 \lnohlll to ngl'oo Oil n J\lstI'0801\ltlon ofthls 111nllol', ( will oontl1\\l~ to mlvllnoo Ihls mnttol' to\VQ1'ds trlnl, To Ihot o1\d, OIlO\OSO<\ plOll80 nnd tho PofOl1llont's Fll'st ~ot of In\Ol'l'ollntorlos IInd RO\I\lost 1761' Pl'od\\otloll or Poo\\\nonts, Planso hnvo (.01'1'10 S\onffol' I'ospond within thI1W(30) dnys In lIocol'dllnOO wilh tho POIl1l8}'\vlIllln I\ulos of Civil Pl'oood\\!'o, In uddltloll, I would IIko to \lop080 Lorrlo Stouffol' III Inlo Oo\obol' 1999, llllltl\llplIlO lhllt Ihl8 d\lposllloll will tllk\) n 1\111 <lny, I !hllnk you 101' youI' oOl1sldol'u\lol1 III this muttul' IInd look Ibl'wlIl'd to tolklng !p YO\lno;{t weok, . S IlIcol'ol}' YO\II'S, ,. ROllINsoN _I/,: G1m,\LDO .. ,--....r~(' "; (" , B}'I_ \""l>"\,'~..h-. Tlll1othyT, EI1~lol" fJs'l\~I'O 00: F, StOll lTer TTB:dlj . p,o, 00. 63iO IinflllhlllO, flA '71,0,6320 IlaUlablltU ~~07 No'" IfftfflebUlU 17171 2:12, 000) 67101 ., : I , IlMh1b11 CumtlOll~nd County W ~o"lI,o. SlIool !llalnl flA 1'/013 11 a~6'94& I WMhinUlon, U,O, . . 1016 flnnn.yIVnnl. Avo" a,p, Wftll,lnUlon, 0.0, 20003 12021 64~'2&,QO ^ ( ( ',,\WOI'I'Ir.li.I' , ~"~~nw,u" "'M)Wlm Ii( 'i~Nn~!\V ~ I'I\Ol"SIlON^',W~I'il~^llllN III!IIST I II III , STI\IIWI' r:IIIII,lijl,I!,I'IINNSHVMIIi\ 17~IJ',\~I(, 'j^MIIS II, l'I,nW1Q\ .^MIII I,I,nWI!I\,JI\, oMn',J, ,INPS"" OololJur 2g, 1009 TIIllPlhy T, !:nglar, r:squln~ ROI;IINSON ~ Q~R^J..PO f,Q, apx p3~0 Hflrrl~purg, fA 17110.fj320 R~I Stpl.lffer v, StP~'ffer, I'IIIHH'IJ I'^~' 111)W'.19 I'I'I.I!"tQ'ol,~o", pel'll' Mr, I:nIJlef'! , 'flm In reoalpt of ypur leiteI' of Ooto~er 20, 1909, ' My ollent ancll have met onoe /:llrea~y to prepElra 1'1 reapon~e to the Req\.lest for Prodllo!lon of Pooumenls and Answers to Interr09F1torles, Ma, stouffer hE1S tEl lIen (hem home to oontlnue wor/I on tham 1'1l> cllreotecl ElfieI' ou,. meotlng, I requeet !:In extension of !1m. a until Peoemper.10, 1999 to prOVide the rElapOnae, .1 clo not pelleve auahEl request Ie llnreasonl1ple, Please let me know If you dlsE1gree, " " , Very truly YOllrs, oJlllJp 001 lorrla Slallf(or (w/al)ol) . fi Mh 11111 ,', ," " " " " 'Il ;' i' " ", , " '-1; " ,. ., " " \1" " " 11\ " , "" " " ," ''-1 I', " " ii 'f' " '.. ,. ,. j.," "'j', , ,,' Ii " ,; ;. , '-'.1 " " " H I,OHI\II! 1\, RTo\lFF!!H IIIHI ~IIWFI!I\ Y I;, HTOl1FFIII\ : IN Till! COl JHT fW cnMMoN PI.!!I\S : CIJMllI!HI ,,\NI )('DIJNTY, "liNNSYI ,VANIA "llIlnllnll, I'~, : ('IVII. i\lTlnN ; NO, IJH-,IO~~ FI\I\NI\ I!. K'I'PllFFI(H IIIHI IlPH IS N, S'I'ol JFFllI\ I : IN !!QI!I'I'Y j)IJI~ndIlIlIH, ,\III'I.lCWI'f(lN FOlt 1\ (,ONTINIJ,\NC~ j)IJI~IHIIIIlIH, FHANI': I!, sToUFFliH IIlld j)OlWl N, H'I'OIJFFI!ll, (I'I>IJI~l1\llInIH "l, hy " thIJlr \IIH1111'Hlulllld IIllnl'lwYH,r(IHllClllllllly I11nl'\.llhlH COllrt plll'~IlIlIlII(lll\lkl 21(1 nl'lhu , PUIlIlH,Yll'lIllln 1\\lIIlH nrell'lI I'I'llIJIllhlrlJ In cnllllll\lp IhIJllhnl'lJ,ullpllnlllJd IlIIHIJ,IIIHIIIl H\lppnl'l rIJ(lrUHOIlI~ nH IhllOIl'HI I. Aholloh trlllllH HolllJd\llod Ihr ,1\1110 H, 2()()1l11l thu IIhow-ullpllnllud I11l1ltol', 2, ThIJ pllrtluH hlll'o rUllohud n IIJIlIIIIII'O HUllloll1l11l1llgl'OIJIlllJIlI nllll nru proHolllly ruso/vlllu tho row rOl11nllllllu nlllslnlldlllU IHs\luH hllhlH 111111101', :\, ClIl'MII,Y 2'1, 21l1l0, h,Y II!lI'C0I11Ulll'orCll\1I1HUI, i\tlnl'llu'y Hnulul' Illlhl'lllU\llhu IlnllOl'lIhiu .1, WUHlo,Y Olul' Ihlll Ihu pllrlloH hlld l'ollolllJd I' IUlltlllll'o Hulllul1101l1 n!ll'uul1lUllllllld WOI'U l'ul/\losIIIlU II cOlllIll\lllllCU \ll'lhu lIPClll11IIlU hUlloh trllll. 4, Tho pllrlluH wlHh \n (lI'UHUI'VO Iholr right In II 1I'IIIIIIllho u\'IJ111 n 1111111 HIJIIIIJI11IJIlIII!lI'COI11CIlI Is Ilnt I'cllohcd, 51 ThlH 111111101' hllH Ilnllwoll pl'cvlnllsly uOlltlllllUd, , Ii, I'lnllllll'lIl' un\lllSIJI dnus 1101 nhJcol h~lhullpplil;lIt1nll Ihl'lI cnlllhlllllllcc,