The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About98-04334 N .. . ~, ~ "'J ~ ......1.. .., ,,'J ~J ~" j .~ .... ~, ""\ ... . 9... ~ ~ I to- '"' ~ ~ ~ )~~?;" ',\}y,il\l;ll, :',:, ~~~{~;!;:J,'\. ".')1,~;~\ \i~ ::'!J\ '~ ,"j~ ~.,-- , I ~;~ .. "'1 . I ".J. t" ....~ . ....J. . '," -;j . ',',,' ~i .~r\1 . ~......'..:j. ...~ . ('4') >. (lr ............ ~'> "':i ,::~ ~. ~ '~'''('''. \ HURD P. ANSTADT, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA 98-4334 CIVIL TERM v. CAPITOL TREE AND NURSERY, INC., and JERRY SHAEFFER, Defendants IN RE: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE A pretrial conference was held Monday, July 2, 2001, before the Honorable Edward E. Guido, Judge. Present for the Plaintiff was his son/ Hurd P. Anstadt, pursuant to power-of-attorney, and present for the Defendant was Raymond A. Swan, Esquire. This is a property damage claim that is less than $25,000.00, and, therefore, would require submission to arbitration. However, insofar as this case has dragged on for more than three years with procedural wrangling, we were reluctant to send it to arbitration. The parties have agreed that the matter should be sent to arbitration and that the arbitration will be binding. Therefore, by agreement of the parties, this matter is submitted to binding arbitration. The Court administrator is directed to request that a panel of arbitrators be appointed forthwith. By the Court, Edward E. Guido, J. Hurd P. Anstadt For the Plaintiff Raymond A. Swan, Esquire For the Defendants ~ourt Administrator srs The trial list will be called on and AU1V~ It{, 1001 Trials comrence on 1~ol 2Col Pretrials will be held on -AvqcJSt 22 2001 (Briefs are due 5 days before pretriAls.) (The party listing this case for trial shall provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to all counsel, pursuant to local Rule 214.1.) (Check one) PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRY~~ '..' Ii "I1~ 0 r; (Must be typewritten and subnitted in ,duplicate) -nfjj S (I!fYI ..ol- Z::I1 :Z[' I U1J: ,1'- "-'.1 r-G ,,::: "1;) ;<. C'" ::I; :z. .....:() ') ;-c.:: .:. z _ for JURY trial at the next tenTI of civil c~.o' TO '!'HE POOTJ-IOIDrARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNI'Y Please list the following case: ( (X') for trial witb:>ut a jury. ----------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) (check one) (Xi Civil Action - Law ~U(~ Y. AN~-!-a4+; ~rft~ il\-t.t./-~r :::5 6.~ R. .4rJ.sfaJ} (plaintiff) Appeal from Arbitration (other) vs. cCapital ""frill!. d..J N~rslll'lf ,:M'-. a>'1d :Jer,,! 1tr",,<<e,.. (Defendant) vs. No. Lt3'3lL Civil 19 CfEl r <..1 .. -, : ;~'.I'] r- --":;-"i ".'1' ~ .... t .l "i,; ~'~j ~t~ (~)rn ;"r:! "1") '< Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe: f.ltJrJ p, AN~d} Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: Ro.~Mc>.J A. ~waA-l-4lrJ Mh-t,U ~~ RlIlpk F.1D",d.. This case is ready for trial. /lLJ f. ,,~ Signed: Print NaIre: Date: 5/3//1 Attorney for: :Jay R. AN$hJI () 0 Ci C On ;;: c... :~..J -00) c: ii'i~G !;pm - -- :J:I I ""..m zs:. .C' :"9 (J) ..~~ :;~C: -<.~ ~Ci ""0 ..I:2j.; ~c.-J :r.: (:Jo"... -~-,.( ) >8 ~ ~ril Z ::<> '. ~ CJ'\ ~ V. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : 98-4334 CIVIL HURD P. ANSTADT Plaintiff CAPITOL TREE AND NURSERY, INC. , and JERRY SHAEFFER, Defendants IN RE: PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, July 12, 2001, in consideration of Judge Edward E. Guido's Pre-Trial Conference Order of July 2, 2001, directing that this case be submitted to binding arbitration, William Addams, Esquire, John Oszustowicz, and Carol Cingranelli, Esquire, are appointed arbitrators in the above-captioned action. - Q ~..eJ-- By the Court, Hurd P. Anstadt 2315 Page Street Camp HiII,PA 17011 P.J. Raymond A. Swan, Esquire 401 Penn Street, Ste. 100 Reading, PA 19601 William Addams, Esquire, Chairman 19 Brookwood Avenue, Ste. 106 Carlisle, PA 17013-9142 Hon. Edward E. Guido fRUE COpy FROM RECORD In Testimony whereof, I hare unto set my hand and the ~I of saidm;1rt Carlisle, Pa.' Thl~ P- ~ day ~ . ;l&r/. C ~h- 0 . "~"f . ProthonotiJrt Court Administrator HURD 1'. ANSTADT, Plaillti'T : IN TI IE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY,PENNSYLVANIA Y. : NO. 98-4334 CIVIL TERM .'j' CAPITOL TREE AND NURSERY, INC., and JERRY SHAEFFER, Defendants NOTICE Of RESCHEDULED HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBITRATORS You arc hereby notified that the Board of Arbitrators appointed by the Court in the above captioned ease will sit for the purpose of their appointment at the office of the Chairman, William A. Addams, atl9 Brookwood Avenue, Suite 106, Carlisle, Pennsylvanill, on Thursday, December 13,2001 at 10:00 a.m. If any attorney has an objection or conflict with this date, that attorney shall assume responsibility to reschedule this hearing at a time suitable to all attorneys. William A. Addams, Esquire John Oszustowicz, Esquire Carol Cingranelli, Esquire By:-;#~~L William A. Addams, Chainnan Board of Arbitrators DATE: October 18, 2001 TO: Raymond A. Swan, Esquire Law Offices of Ralph F. Touch 401 Penn Street, Suite 100 Reading, P A 1960 I fJ .r~ Hurd 1'. Anstadt 2315 Page Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 G~~ JfJ- -9tf? - ~1:' Qaf/11.i). 1. ".~J -~ ~W r /) {? ;t7 - Jr2lr f7;;ti v/" a/I 11 l ,/Jo. (j~'J LJ . )0. Y' . '1' 3 ~ 7Y~J 7;/ /rr.::-it. ....1 7~- 0/6"; /L /~/~ /C'/ 1// /2/1 Nj tr; /f ....' Atehason and his wife, Mari Atchason, and the thcn owncrs, .lay and Ruby Anstadt. A written proposal was sent by Jerry Shaffer of Capital to Mr. Atchason the following day. On April 28, 1997, Mr. Atehason phoned Capital and rcqucsted that the tree removal be perlormcd. Capital removed the trccs that same day and invoiced Mr. Atchason on May 8, 1997. Allcr receiving no paymcnt, Capital contacted Mr. Atchason on June 15, 1997 and was told that the sale of the property had not yet been completed but that everything would work out. A second invoice was sent on September 26, 1997. In the meantime, .lay Anstadt demanded payment from Mr. Atehason for the removal of the trees by letter dated, September 12, 1997. B. Procedural History This matter was instituted by Plaintiff at the District Magistrate level where an award was entered in favor of Plaintiff and subsequently appealed by Defendant. After the filing of several Complaints and several set of Preliminary Objections, Defendant, Capital, answercd Plaintiffs latest Amended Complaint on June 8, 200 I. At that time, Defendant, Capital also joined as Additional Defendants, .lack and Mari Atchason. II. DAMAGES CLAIMED Plaintiff has alleged total damages in the amount of $16,1 00.00 for the removal of the three hemlock trees and damage to the lawn. It should be noted that the Agreement of Sale between .lay and Ruby Anstadt and the Atchasons dated March 27, 1997 was for a total amount of$225,000.00. The property eventually was sold by .lay and Ruby Anstadt to Philip .I. Murren and Richard E. Connell for $232,750.00 on December 4, 1997, despite the fact that the trees had been removed, To date, Plnintifl: Hurd Anstadt, has tililed to provide counsel for Defendant, Capital, with a copy of this Power of Attorney despite sevcral rcquests for same. It is Defendant's position, therefore, thai the issue of standing has not yet been settled. Further, as the amount in controversy is less than $25,000,00, this matter should be schedulcd for arbitration, not a bench trial. Respectfully submitted, LA W OFFICES OF RALPH F. TOUCH By: M-- a ~ 6t Ray and A. wan, Esquire Attorney for Defendant 401 Penn Street, Suite 100 Reading, P A 1960 I 610-320-4613 Attorney. I.D. # 42169 '..' CERTIFICATION OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I have served a copy of the foregoing document(s) upon all parties, their attorneys or representatives, and all other relevant organizations, in the manner(s) set forth below: By first-class mail. postage prepaid: Hurd P. Anstadt 2315 Page Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dated: June 22, 2001 1(c a,L~ RaY~an, Esquire Attorney for Defendants, Capitol Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer 198300083/ Swan 3, Admittcd. 4, Dcnicd. To thc cxtcnt thc allcgations of thc corrcsponding paragruph constitutc factual avcrmcnts, thc samc arc dcnicd. 5. Dcnicd. To thc cxtent thc allcgations ofthc corrcsponding paragraph constitutc factual avel1ncnts, the samc arc dccmcd to bc denied duc (0 the fact that after a rcasonable investigation, Answering Defendant is without sufficicnt infol1nation or knowledgc to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of such allegation, Proofofsamc is hercby dcmandcd at thc time of trial. 6. Denicd. To the extent thc allcgations ofthc corresponding paragraph constitute factual avemlCnts, the same are deemed to be denied due to the fact that after a rcasonable investigation, Answering Defendant is without sufficient information or knowledge to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of such allegation, Proof of same is hcreby demanded at thc time of trial. 7, Denied. To the extent the allegations ofthc corresponding paragraph constitute factual averments, the same are deemed to be denied due to the fact that after a reasonable investigation, Answering Defendant is without sufficient infol1nation or knowledge to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of such allegation. Proof of same is hereby demanded at the time of trial. 8. Denied. To the extent the allegations of the corresponding paragraph constitute factual avemlCnts, the same are deemed to be denied due to the fact that after a reasonable investigation, Answering Defendant is without sufficient infol1nation or knowledge to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of such allegation, Proof of same is hereby demanded at the time of trial. 9. Denied. To the extent the allegations of the cOlTesponding paragraphconstitute factual averments, the same are deemed to be denied due to the fact that after a reasonable investigation, Answering Defendant is without sufficient information or knowledge to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of such allegation, Proof of same is hereby demanded at the time of trial. 10. Denied. To the extent the allcgations of the corresponding paragraph constitute factual avemlCnts, the same arc deemed to be denied due to the fact that after a reasonable investigation, Answering Defendant is without sufficient information or knowledge to fOlm a belief as to the truth or l1i1sity of such allcgation. Proofofsamc is hcrcby dcmandcd at Ihc timc of tria!. II. Dcnicd. To thc cxlcnt Ihc allcgations ofthc corrcsponding paragraph constitlllc factual avcrmcnls, thc samc arc dccmcd to bc dcnicd duc 10 thc facllhat allcr a rcasonablc invcsligation, Answcring Dcfendant is without sufficicnt information or knowlcdgc to form a bclicf as to thc (ruth or I1llsity of such allcgation. Proof of samc is hcrcby dcmandcd at thc timc of tria!. 12. Dcnicd. To thc cxtcnt the allcgations oCthc corrcsponding paragraph constitute factual avermcnts, thc samc are dccmcd to bc dcnicd duc to thc fact Ihat allcr a rcasonablc investigation, Answering Dcfcndant is without sufficicnt information or knowlcdgc to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of such allegation. Proof of samc is hcrcby dcmandcd at thc timc oftria!. 13. Denied. To the extent thc allegations of the corresponding paragraph constitute factual avennents, the same are deemed to be denied due to the fact that aller a reasonable investigation, Answering Defendant is without sufficient infonnation or knowledge to fonn a belief as to the tmth or falsity of such allegation. Proof of same is hereby demanded at the time of tria!. 14. Denied. Answering Defendants are unable to speculate as to Plaintiffs motivation on filing the instant suit. 15. Denied. Answering Defendants are unable to speculate as to Plaintiffs motivation on filing the instant sui t. 16. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that the actual property owner is Jay R. Angstadt. Answering Defendants have no knowledge, after reasonable investigation, of Jay R. Angstadt's residence. 17. Denied. To the extent the allegations of the corresponding paragraph constitute factual. avennents, the same are deemed to be denied due to the fact that after a reasonable investigation, . Answering Defendant is without sufficient infonnation or knowledge to fonn a belief as tothe truth or falsity of such allegation. Proof of same is hereby demanded at the time of tria!. 18. Denied. To the extent the allegations of the con'esponding CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Raymond A. Swan, Esquire hereby certify that J have served a copy of the foregoing Answer with New Matter upon all other parties or their attorneys by first class, Uniled Stales Mail, postage prepaid on March , 200 I. Hurd P. Anstadl 2315 Page Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 (,' ., J !./! I .. <{,~Vh\IA}'l.. L{. _1t'7t.J Raymon(V A. Swan, Esquire Attorney for Defendants 98-4334 CIVIL TERM Notice to Defend. Pa. R.C.P. 1018.I(a) makes it mandatory that every complaint contain a notice to defend in the foml prescribed by Rule 1018.I(b). What possible need the defendants have for a notice to defend escapes us. Their attorney commenced this action by filing an appeal from a district justice award in favor of plain tiff. He isslled a rule upon plaintiff to file a complaint. To insist that the complaint be stricken for failure to attach a notice to defend places a great deal of reliance on form to the detriment of substance. In any event, the rules do require that a notice to defend be attached to the complaint. Otherwise, no answer need be filed. (Pa. R.C.P. 1026(a)). Therefore, we suggest that plaintiff comply with Rule 1018.1 by attaching a notice to defend to his next amended complaint. Specificity. Plaintiff has made great strides in conforming his complaint to the dictates ofPa. R.C.P. 1019. In fact, the current complaint comes very close to surviving the preliminary objection based upon lack of specificity. Separate paragraphs selling forth the name of the property owner, the existence of thc power of attorney and the approximate dates upon which the alleged tree cutting took place will be sufficient to cure any remaining objeetions.3 Verification. Pa. R.C.P. 1024 requires that every llleading containing an averment of fact must be verified. The complaint obviously contains averments of fact and is not verified. A J The "standing to sue" objection will also be resolved by those additions. 3 (') CJ 0 C -IJ ~ C- ;J -On) c: '-;~:~p! Q'[l' z 2...0 I -~..m ~C .;-{,o ".' ..,... ~l~l -<.': ~o " :L:-n ~o :x r)___ ',"0 ~8 r.:: om ~ ~ (7'\ ~ ;'", . .. . '" NO. 98-4334 CIVIL TERM GENERAL POWER OF ATTORNEY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS, that I, JAY R. ANSTADT, of Burlington, County of Chittenden, and State of Vennont, have made, constituted and appointed and do hereby make. constitute and appoint my son, HURD P. ANSTADT, of Camp Hill. County of Cumberland and State of Pennsylvania, my true and lawful attorney for me and in my name and on my behalf to receive and receipt for any and all sums of money or payments due or to become due to me, to deposit in my name in any bank or banks any and all monies collected or received, to pay any and all bills, accounts, daims and demands now or hereafter payable to me, to draw checks or drafts upon any and all hank accounts or deposits belonging to me, to act for me in any business in which I am now or have been engaged or interested, and generally to do and perform all mailers and things, transact all business, make, execute and acknowledge all contracts, orders, deeds, leases, writings, assurances and instruments, which may be requisite or proper to effectuate any matter or thing affecting my business or person or property, including any lawsuits or c1ainls made by or against me and any court appeardnces in cOllilection with such claims, which the same force and effect to all intents and purposes as though I were personally present and acting for myself, hereby ratifying and confinning whatsoever my said attomey shall do by authority hereof. This Power of Attomey shall not be affected by the disability of the principal. DATED at Burlington, Vermont, on this 28th day of January, 1998. IN THE PRESENCE OF: ~'~A. t\~:",__ witn s \ STATE OF VERMONT CHITTENDEN COUNTY, SS. III ~ /J / / let: Il ~ /4 Jay R. Anstadt At Burlington, in said County and State, on this 28th day of January, 1998, Jay R. Anstadt personally appeared and he acknowledged this instrument by him sealed and subscribed to be his free act and deed. Before me~~~, ~ -A ~ \~:~:..t~-_. otary Publlc l '. My commission expires: 2/10/99 lra/r582/l EXHIBIT "A" " G~ C) ( ) c; " . C) r::"j , ,-) _.~ ", " ~./. '. c; ~.~. , _.C' " , .-'" " '. f-' ':::'.--j ," ',' .::1 ..... Q " -.+J en ~.J ", I'Yf;!j 10 ClImhnl'l,1nd Count.y Pro! hnnnl..,ry'B or fico C I v I I CMH' (11l1ll i ry Page I ')1)11, O~ ].l~ ^N:i'I'^,l'(' IIlJlHl I' (v:;) C^I' ['I'^I, '1'111':1': " NIJlISEIlY Un f (! n~"C(~ No..: CfHir~ 'I'yllt'.....: ^PPI':^I, .11Idqmf'll .......: .lud,1" ^:w 1 'I nod : I) I npOH(HI Donc.: CiHII! C 0111 II1P " I H Il.' .00 F i I (~cl. . . . . . . . : 'I'l nH~. . . . . . . . . : Exocul. 1 on nil to lllll"Y 'l'rti11.... () i HllO!iod Dil to. 111'Iu'I' Crt 1.: II 1 '1h"I' CrL 2,: 7/28/1998 11:06 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 *.~kk********k.****,**'***'*l***************************************A.k******k** (lenoral Imlnx M.Lornoy In [0 ^NS'I'^,Yt' IIllHD I' /.]I~ I'AGI-: S'rlH-:E'I' C^MI'JlTI.I,I'^ 17011 C^P l'I'A!, 'l'Rl,;F: & NIJllS/WY 7flll N I SSE/, I.ANE NI,:W CUMlII':IUJ^ND I'A 17070 PI,^ I N'1'J VI' DEFEND^NT NOI,I, FHANKL/N W III i**k*****'**********************************************kkk********************* * Date EnLrleH * *kk*****************'******************************************************k**** _ _ .. _ _ ,. _ .. .. .. - .. - FT RST EN'l'HY - - - .' - .. - - - .. - - - .. 7/28/1 !J9R APPEAl.. FHOM 1115'1'1l1C'I' ;IUS'I'ICE ,IlJDGMEN'1' ,. C^P I'I'M, '['IlEE r, NURSERY ONL.Y ^PPI';AI, I NG 7//.8/l9!JR ll/ll5/199B 1I/27/1!J9B 9/08/l99R l/./llI/1998 l/./lll/19!JB :I/2~ / I !J'J'J !J/O]/199!J 12/09/1999 ~/l2/2000 4/2~/2000 ~/04/2000 6/05/2000 9/21/2000 IO/ll/2000 ----------------------------.--.---..--..----..----- ..--------------------- PH^ECIPE '1'0 EN'rEH RULE 'm FTI.I'; COMPI,^IN'I' ^ND ru n. I,: '1'0 FILE ------------------------.--.-------------.---------------------------- CEH'I' I. VI CNI'E 01" SEIlVICE --------.-.----------.--------------------------------------------------- (MPOlrI'AN'I' NO'l'ICE FlI.ED --.-------..------.---------------------- -------------------------------- CTVIL COMPI.,^TN'I.' -------------------------------------------.-------------------------- PIlAECIPE nlR EN'l'HY OF APPE^HANCE FOH DEFT BY FHANKLIN W NOLL III ESQ ------.----------------------------------------------.---------------- PH^ECI PE FOH WI'l'IIDIl^WAl. OF ^PPEAHANCE FOH DEF'I' BY DANI EL J PORUBAN I,SQ ------------------------------------------------------------------- PIlELIMIN^RY OBJECTIONS ------------------------------------------------------------------- PHM,CIPE FOR L.IS'l'ING CASE FOR ARGUMENT PLFF -------------------------------------------------------------------- CIVIL COMPL^IN'I.' -------------------------------------------------------------------- OHDER - DATED 4/12/00 .. IN RE DEFEND^NT'S PHELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PI"AINTII'F'S COMPLAIN'1' - PLAINTIFF MUST AMEND HIS COMPLAINT WITHIN 20 DAYS OF OHDER BY GEOHGE E HOFFEH J COPIES MAILED 4/12/00 --------.----------------------------------------------------------- PHEI.,IMINARY OB,mCTIONS - MOTION TO STRIKE OFF PLAIN1'IFF' S COMPLAINT BEC^IJSE OF IJ^CK OF CONFOHMITY OF LAW AND HULES OF COURT MOTION FOR MOHE SPECIFIC COMPI,AIN'l' HAYMOND A SWAN ESQ ATTY FOR DEFT ------------------------------------------------------------------- COMPLAIN'I' .~------------------------------------------------------------------ PHELIMINAHY OBJECTIONS ---------------------------------------------------------------.---- PRAECIPE FOH LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT DEFENDANT'S FILING OF PHgl..lMINAHY OBJEC'I'IONS STATING THA'1' PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT DOgS NOT CONFORM 1'0 HUT.,ES OF LAW AND LACKS SPECIFICTY - BY HUHD P ANSTADT -------------------------------------------------------------------- EXHIBIT "A" 'ro COMPL^INT - GENERAL POWEH OF ATTORNEY _ _ _ _ .. _ _ .. - - .. .. - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ******************************************************************************** * Escrow Information ,* * FeBH , DebIts Bea Bal pvmts/^di End Ba1 . * ********************************~********~******'******************************* ^PPEAL D.J. 'I'^X ON ^I'PEMi fil,:'l"rLEMlm'l' 35.00 .25 ~.OO 35.00 .25 5.00 .00 .00 .00 I'Y:';~i 10 I'i1CJO :! CUlIlbnrland County P,-ot.honotary'H Offien C 1 vii C,lnn I nqu i ,:y I!I 'Jf104 :U4 ANS'I'^,I'I' IIlIIlll " (V:l) CA" I 'I'^" '1'IlEI': & NllJlHEllY Uf~ ru 140IlCl! No..: Cilsn '11ypn.....: ^PPI':^L - I>lJ ,ludCJlIlonL. , . . . . : .00 ,II,HJqO ^~HiJ gflnd: iJ 1 Sposnd 11(!flG.: -...------- C;aso COnllll(!rlLs -- ,IeI' FI':E 5.00 5.00 Fi I nd. " , . . , . : '1'1 (HO. . . . . . . . . : 1':XflGut.lon l1il to .1l.'I'y 'I'ri ill.. ,. I1tSI]()SOd iJato, III q 101- Cr't. I.: IIlghnr- Crt 2.: .00 .00 7/28/1998 I I : 06 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 ------------------.------.. 45.25 4!).25 ~**lk****t************************************'****************k*****'*****~,***, * End of Cosn InforlllatIon * IA****t************************************************************************* n c <." "'Of.;.; [!Ii' : Z_'l,. :;::c." (I) l~ - ~c; .,.-,. ~c:' ~() ..>c:-: :?' -:J ...... a o en P'1 u N '7J ~~.. J) h) () "1j ; , !, _!~;:1 .~'~;.,q )~n~ ::::i '> :iJ =< IlJ8300083 LA IV OFFICES OF RALPH F. TOUCH BY: Raymond A. Swan, Esquire 40 I Penn Street, Suite 100 Reading. PA 1%01 G I 0.320-46 13 Ally. ID II 421 GlJ Allorncy ror Defcndants Jcrry ShaelTer and Capitol Trcc and Nursery, Inc. : CUMBERLAND COUNTY Hurd p, Anstadt : COURT OF COMMON PLEAS vs. : 1998.4334 Civil Capitol Trec and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shacrfer : CIVIL ACTION ORDER AND NOW, to wit, this day 0 r ,2000, it is hercby ORDERED, ADJUDGED, and DECREED that upon eonsidcration ofthc Prcliminary Objections of Defendants, Capitol Tree and Nurscry, Inc, and Jen'y Shaeffcr, all Paragraphs orthe Plaintirrs Civil Complaint are hereby stricken. Leave is grantcd to thc Plaintirf 10 amcnd his Complaint within twenty (20) days of the date orthis Ordcr. BY THE COlJRT: J. ANSWER: NO Thc Defcndants. Capital Trcc and Nursery. Inc. ,1I1d Jerry Shaeffcr, have filed Preliminary Objections to Plaintiffs Complaint duc to thc Plaintitrs fililure to avcrallegations ofDefcndants' negligence with the required specificity mandated by Pa. R.C.P. 1019(a). 42 Pa. C.S.A. In his Complaint, the Plaintiff alleges Defendants' negligcnce eonsistcd. in part. of: Defcndant(s) removed thrce (3) hemlock trccs...fi'om the property... Defcndant(s) were not contracted by properly owner to remove thc three (3) trecs. Clearly, such vague and conclusory allegations arc not allowcd by Rule 10 19(a) and should bc stricken from the Plaintiffs Complaint. When addressing similar allegations of negligence in indicated: Connor v Allel!henv General Hospital. SOl Pa. 306. 461 A,2d 600 (1983), the Supreme Court "If the appellee did not know how it otherwise failed to use due care and caution under the circumstances. it could have filed a Preliminary Objection in the nature ofa request for a more spccific pleading or could have moved to strike that portion of thc appellant's Complaint." Pennsylvania employs a "Fact Pleading Procedure" which requircs that every act or performance esscntial in defining issues must be set forth with particularity in the Complaint. Goodrich.Amram, 2.d I 019(a) (5). Accordingly, the Superior Court in Weiss v Eouibank. 313 Pa. Super. 446, 460 A.2d 271 (1983) notcd: Pcnnsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1019(a) provides that the "material facts on which a cause of action..,..is based shall be stated in a concise and summary form", This has been interpretedto mean that the Complaint must apprise the defendant of the nature and extent of the plaintiffs claim so that thc defcndant has notice of what thc plaintiff intends to prove at trial and may prepare to meet such proof with his own evidcnce, As the court stressed, the purpose of Rule 10 19(a) and the "Fact Plcading Procedure" is to ensure that thc Complaint is sufficiently clcar in order to enable the Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, to prepare his defcnse and to ensure that the Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, is aecuratcly informed of the specific basis upon which .. ..... .... As the eourt stressed. the purpose or Rule 10 19(a) and the "Fact Plcading Procedure" is to cnsurc that thc Complaint is suflieiently clear in order to cnable thc Dcfcndants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffcr, to prcpare his defense and to ensure that the Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, is accurately informed ot'thc specific basis upon which recovery is sought, and of the issucs which the plcadcr intends to provc at trial. See also: Hohcnscc v LUl!cr. Pa. Commw. ,412 A.2d 1111 (1980), Fcinl!cld v Hill. 360 Pa. Super. 539, 521 A.2d 33 (1987). Further, no wherc on Plaintiffs Complaint is it aJleged that Plaintiff had at the time of the subject events, or at any time for that matter, an interest in the subject property. Without such interest, Plaintit'f has no standing to bring this suit. Pleadings such as that employed by the Plaintiff in the present action leave thc Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, in the untenable position of having to guess or speculate about essential factors in the case. This situation is clearly sought to be avoided by Rule 1019(a), and the Connor decision. If the Court allows these allegations to remain in the Complaint, the Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, cannot prepare an adequate defense to them, and arc exposed to the danger of having the Plaintiff offer proof of trial of any conceivable set of facts that fall within the general language of their allegations, Accordingly, these aJlegations should be stricken, WHEREFORE, the Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, , respectfuJly request that this Honorable Court order the Plaintiff to amend his Complaint to allege facts upon which alleged negligence arises or else have the Plaintiffs Complaint stricken.. Respectfully submitted, LAW OFFICES OF RALPH F. TOUCH /) ~ R ond A. Swan, Esquire A ttorney for Defendants VS. ) ) ) J ) CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT, PA CIVIL DIVISION NO, 1998-4334 Civil HURD P. ANSTADT, PLAINTIFF CAPITAL TREE & NURSERY, INC. AND JERRY SHAEFFER ) ) ) DEFENDANTS ) ~ CIVIL COMPLAINT BY THIS DOCUMENT. I AM FILING A CIVIL COMPLAINT AGAINST THE ABOVE NAMED DEFENDANT(S), SPECIFICALLY AS FOLLOWS: 1. Defendant(s) was never called by property owner of 2303 Market Street, Camp Hill, PA 17011. 2. Defendant(s) cut down three (3) hemlock trees from property at 2303 Market St., camp Hill, PA 17011. 3. Defendant(s) removed the three(3) tree stumps of the three(3) hemlock trees. 4. Defendant(s) damaged the lawn during the removal of the three(3) trees and stumps, 5. The three(3) hemlock trees were each fifty(50) feet tall. 6, The three(3) hemlock trees were too large to replace. 7. The largest replacement hemlock trees available are nineteen (19) - twenty-four(24) feet maximum. S, The cost of the largest replacement trees are $2500 each. 9. A 24' tall tree valued at $2500 averages out to $1 04/foot. 10. This makes the value of 50' tall trees at $5200 each. 11. The total damages for the three(3) hemlock trees cut down is $15.600. 12, The cost to repair the damaged lawn is $500, 13. Defendant(s) was not authorized by property owner to remove the three(3) hemlock trees, 14. This Civil Complaint is being filed to recoup the value of the three(3) hemlock trees and to repair the damage to the lawn caused by the removal of the three(3) hemlock tree stumps, 15. The total damages are $16,100 and this amount of money paid to the plaintiff will settle the Civil Complaint. Please set a Court date and advise. V'NuJf.~- 5/t/OD HURD P. ANSTADT May 1,2000. 4/10100. This Civil Complaint was filed in Cumberland county Courthouse on 12/3/99; copy sent to defendant on 12/3199 certified mail - defendant would not sign for certified mall four (4) times. 4/10/00. Copy of Civil Complaint sent regular mail to defendant and sent certified mail to defendant's, attorney. 4/10/00 _ This is notice often (10) days to respond or DefaultJudgement will be filed with Cumberland County Prothonotary, 5/1/00 _ Civil Complaint revised and sent to: Cumberland county Prothonotary, Capital Tree & Nursery and Law Offices of Ralph F, Touch. (") 0 0 ",; 0 on ::: ,-I l:JCU ;:;to '2: ::!J rnri: -< ~ I\-_ :;':'::I.J .T~lrTl -;( ."0 ~("; '.' sjC) .., ~~ ~J:.=B 2:0 ..-- ~~1o ~~8 9? Oln ..'::'" ,:=> ~ .-; ~ --:. .[:"" .< APR 2 5 2000 As thc court strcsscd, the purpose of Rule 10 19(a) and the" Fact Plcading Procedure" is to ensurc that the Complaint is sufficicntly clear in ordcr to enable thc Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shacffer, to prepare his defensc and to ensurc that the Defendants, Capital Trec and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffcr, is accurately informcd of the specific basis upon which recovcry is sought, and of the issucs which the pleadcr intends to prove at trial. Scc also: Hohensce v LUl!cr. Pa. Commw. ,412 A.2d 1111 (1980), Fcinl!eld v Hill. 360 Pa. Super. 539,521 A.2d 33 (1987). Pleadings such as that employed by the Plaintiff in the present action leave the Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, in the untenable position of having to guess or speculate about essential factors in the case. This situation is clearly sought to be avoided by Rule 10 19(a), and the Connor decision. If the Court allows these allegations to remain in the Complaint, the Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, . cannot prepare an adequate defense to them, and are exposed to the danger of having the Plaintiff offer proof of trial of any conceivable set of facts that fall within the general language of their allegations. Accordingly, these allegations should be stricken, WHEREFORE, the Defendants, Capital Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, , respectfully request that this Honorable Court order the Plaintiff to amend his Complaint to allege facts upon which alleged negligence arises or else have the Plaintiffs Complaint stricken.. Respectfully submitted, DATED: April 20, 2000 LAW OFFICES OF RALPH F. TOUCH Raymond A. Swan, Esquire Atty. J.D. No. 42169 401 Penn Street, Suite 100 Reading, PA 19601 (610)320-4780 Fax (610) 320-4787 'Attorney for Defendants IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Hurd P. Anstadt, VS. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) NO. 1998-4334 Civil CIVIL DIVISION PLAINTIFF, Capitol Tree and Nursery, Inc" and Jerry Shaeffer DEFENDANTS, ORDER AND NOW, to wit, this day of , 2000, it is hereby ORDERED, ADJUDGED, and DECREED that upon consideration of the Preliminary Objections of Defendants, Capitol Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jerry Shaeffer, all Paragraphs of the Plaintiffs Civil Complaint are hereby stricken. Leave is granted to the Plaintiff to amend his Complaint within twenty (20) days of the date of this Order. BY THE COURT: J. LA W OFFICES OF TOUCH, RUZZI & McKEE By: Sally A. Lytle, Esquire Attorncy I.D. No. 62304 401 Penn Street, Suite 100 Rcading, PA 19601 Tcl. 610-320-4678 Fax 610-320-4767 Attorncy for Delcndants IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Hurd P. Anstadt, ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) CIVIL DIVISION PLAINTIFF, NO. 1998.4334 Civil VS. Capitol Tree and Nursery, Inc., and Jerry Shaeffer DEFENDANTS. I 98300083/Poruban 50755654 PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS And now comes the Defendants, Capitol Tree and Nursery, Inc. and Jcrry Shaeffer, by and through their attorney, Sally A Lytle, Esquire, pursuant to Rules 1018 (b), 1018,1, 1019, 1021, 1022, 1023 and 1024 file the following Preliminary Objections: Motion to Strike Off Plaintiffs Complaint Because of Lack of Conformity of Law and Rules of Court/Motion for More Spccific Complaint (') 1..0 0 c: '.0 :;~. , J : ....,'" [:;0] I pOl .,T :'i '0 ~.:_. , ,.. ~) l' I ,"I , C., ','~) I ,. :::.\ , -n : , , ., C ,,' , , ("" , ;'i ::-:1 0,' ......... , (..) ....J '., -~ , " " ..,.. --..- ...l.."I .' ,~" ""f .~_' ;"-"'-~1_''''.' ~'~_''';''':''~'''''''ip'r;;')~''fl''''''~''''t''''''''1''f1a~r;'''l~.t'\':;~~---:~'7.;:-r,{~".;~~i:<'t'~:::,~~." ~~rr.~~,~" ...'. ' ' til'_ '.' .,.,'.mM, -...., ...'nlllldll!lll~"f,"Jt,!,.JJ1"';~~\""',,~.y"1,;;t'~rl'''''J"li~>J.1'f~~\itY'E :1~"J;r~;'i\.;)'i:"m(t.1ltl~t'f.5tP'~f('I'\h..t:.,<",.~..~\M:'~'~1~"i("lIi\ 11,1,.. I, >l1..J' '. '. : ;' II, j ,I., ,\>........~;~ "'l':~"")"KlI!~.\:(.',,:\~.;'~~;q. \.''''"I'\\\/';\;r;;'iJ.;7i:H,~'''.{\~it,>1,t;M''' ", ~~"1\f{~1t~~ \~\;X!.J1 ~';!~~,ilh~:n;;:~i.1~b~;';'f::~t!N\ ~'r;I"~'" ;"<"'" ,:.1 ,J, j :': ."11II'11III".''''':' .,', III . .',~ 'II': "~" ~'".''' :\':\~"'.')lt"1"_'hl"Ml\~,:)')1.11~:l?~\,'~h"\I~;V:';:t:'f.~~~'\t~'r'i'h ~if'rJl} {t,j," ..l.UJ ~~\i;/';:~~J;,<;~::.\'..r:(rif ""'~\i.ll}y.~ltl))\;.'(' I":' ....~. /. . '. :11' , 1111_ 'I'"' ,Ii /'J "\'1'-h\1."".!_'''....'~1Iil'...'W;I~,,~''lf.t'.'\l~'\J)f,.I!f.% t~~ i%:..\tot,'<:iii:,!'-; r..,.."V':.f;'~W"t~,{!...,.,,""~r.f'.....,..,..I.~..'.(...'.:......,iJ, '~J<t '''''''I~'~'I . 1IlI1lIl--'" . . ' ",11II' ,'.',.." ',:<', .JlIIl:I\lII',o.. 'L,',.,\....';',_<dN~"""'...' PiItI"" ;", ,"'.",..~,...:-:.;, "..", "u",l!i-/l,) :,"",,'!i&11K'.....;,,',..",""'....%.''''':,~,1,......'',,'''''''''' " ',,,,JI1I!"'~....>..' ,II!I, ," I" '. :....', .'''., 11II:. .........-..- .' II -!!lI!!-' ....., '....., -,' ..."..,.',...',"""'.. ','I'JlIIII.I' ....".,...."""""'""IlII',...,p,,.. ,."." <^"",. ~.IIiI!,"""'c.""",'.""..I!I:O.'...n....(I""","Yl.,....'......"'''Ii'''"iIIl!.''..,-'"11I. ,,-, -', -'... .'... ,- , . ..>.....iliIIiI..-=..~'~..,......=-''+...''.....'".....''.........\.,..~..'II''''.~''''~'''~''''''"....~II~.,..=......._,,,.,.,,.,,._.....~~fl".....~~ 't.l~ft(;< rrrm,l ""'_..............~,.'h":'l'..-'ti-,.-"..."""""'''''''t...'1...,-;;.;.;,.c,...._.....'.."....,.._.'''''''.'''''''~". .......".....,...-...* .." t ." -.: _, _' .... .'-,,' ~ ,:,1";'1 ) ,,'NI '1"'1"'1' 'l~!I\'I~ L'jii.,~ ~~.'IIil:.:..t;~.Ji,.~!..':\~l~'\'~,h,\./"'\ /'.'_f,I/''''1J.. '-, " 't" /, .I.. ,. iii! -"-II'" I ",""..,'_;1,', ',;f",n .~ ~,",~";!'i'?f'/~' -4' -; 1J...~ ....~I Ilf,W\.,' il:;~'t,~"t"~;.~tJ'l~I'(~t. I~l". ;a,!1I1"'''''''/~'. "",:,"'11III' .....I~llll.rl. J. ' .' , ., _'. " ".." ;"",' :H',',"." -po' '1"i<Y',IJ'.'['W"I'ff,:: "'JI~;:t;~ ):.>f' '...~,..'I~~1:1~.',.n'V~\! '~:l.";,,1'.r,~ r-;.l..:...,...." \'/:'\ ,\.' " . ". , I. . _. "', ~.I., "I. f J, 'j ,;If I J,. t:J': 1 "J~l ~. i'\,~t N J"'I \ l1J, " ~:'['t"tt.. r ,~ ., '-'..' ., , ! , ,..', ),,:~ '''-,)'..~lilil.J''~II:>l'~~'.),'i~~;., D'l~J} "",r(..y,,' ','T\ "~',"..l{.'/jJ";i,\l...,~.,.{lJ\'I';;I,""I'_'.IL""'rllll\'" . .", "; \ iii':, j 1",. :'i:", ,;~J;)I1~.,\l~IJ~lr,ft~ ~J.if,::ij::~,:~\~f~~{~~lj {; Iy~t;vr:; ,VU\4jH~ ,~nl'I';}').\.rl 'ldr '~.~:.~'};;'.'l;t;.,tJ~'~'l:,.l;'./IIl/~': ("'~lIlII'IIlIl':""" Ij'!\ ,~lo",~ ' .'.' ' , ".; .', I', I . ."11I" llII,' ,",'~:.~'" _i,.,o".""'...(""'l"";'r"\"hr",;:y')',;,t..,,,, '\\I,~!I~,1 >"'1',;,\,1 f~,.(\,;q:r'.''''"'\'I.(''::!'''1''-:':\'41''').:'.'''III'',lIlI.'"',"IIll....',.,lII,,.." " , 1\1 . ^ " ~"_'1'~ )'. ,,,,./1' "\ 't~J.'i{,< l'.~le.'\:: (I\T<j ',,' J'jl ~1"-':t,,+' .\\.,~.~":,;J-:h.lr1.J,;~.'~1 tYPItIi.~l "J<.f~,~ t~''i'?: (1"1 i',/;; ',lA' ~:l': Ii. . ~t'.I'~ "\1) ',r ",' ',';'J"'" .,~ "...... '\ ., ,{. .'1 . .' " ,..,", ,,,' .:: !,., ~1\' " \"" ....,~, ~','~ '.'1 ' j' '/1(/1 ~,' ~'.,;''if;.:r:r/'~'I,'','(;~,>,('}'','i~' i'f'~li\..;t'^ v~:(. I" :... :rL~"')'1 "'~ :\<~,., . .1~ II:" I : ' I,~, . " I'.' \~. \, :,\:', I, (If '1llIl' ,-",' , . " . 1 . ".I!II'....,..j".'I'jf.'I., ..'Y',,-,.~, ct" \~"('I,'\r?~,~'t.~a l'A, ,d '~"'\.,)I', . ,'.,,'.'.. ",.11".........,11II.> . I ,'!iii' >>; ,) \" ;J. ....I.','J_~.,., "~~;;,' .../, "'I"L.TI.f;~.I'I':'V 1:f..:..t\j~'41 a\.~'l. "}",::.,tt't"d('1:."!;'J~ ':-,\ (j,~'!~ (1J.1~'t.. ,'l~~...~,:'..',,'"'t,/_l:'" -.'/",','........' ,_1 ] '.. .,'. .' , .1. 0, .11 .......11II'1.' /' /..(' "~\' 'I ~ 'J "}~ I'~" '. \1 . ~l~~bt '1'''''.~'' u'~-"',"')rt l1<'rt ,\ ';"1'1 rr )'1,:0 '/ 'jl \ " ,'.' '.... to". ." II' '." . ., '.' , ~" :.' '1III'.';Il." ~ \, 'd.,II'.'I~t~'I.j~\'~)({'''~'~'''~!''I",..-;.,:~~,.(..,t.f,~;',tJ '.}'.~llt\H/~/,,'li'~'t ("':ji. \J,,'f,,'-V :'i,.IJ{f.;\i,I'i';'.'~ ,~'r" - (o,,':r.,~' i ""."~' "11'> /flIII/!,' lilii, / ", .','.,~ .. '.11I',,1 _", J.'~ ,. " ,....."l.:.c,. ',,' .'\ ;fl.. l'IJ".~~'ij~}'I:U ,\').,f.r....M,{~.tJ~.1~~~1- 'm"l' \.)j',.'....,~.I:til,;' 1','"",,,, ,!(.\ l,v"iIJ"il , -t',. ('/.''1.' Il!llt..,:. " h'." 'iIII'III'I' '~'" ' " , '-'" . .. .), ., .-......'.'.;" l\,rt~..f,v...^~'\.'~"i.:tj,h,1!. ""~,"l:'i4.....l;irl~I,V.......",,",;l"H,\'I'...~,,,,\.~:~,,..r"JI.'" "'. .,......:',_,dJ..._"....~lr,r.'(",~.JIJ'~l ,1'111"'" .-' "\ III ,...'.' ,".-"'" j","f"'d'"",.'''''''!";i''''''I''''I''''''"''''''''~'''''''I,,,, c!., '^>,"""",,'~"'\I"",I,:, ,-",-','''''-''''!II,;",,,,,'','''' ,'...", ;.'" -', .,... ' 'II .' '.'.....,IlIIlII.,l!1II._l.. l.',,,~. ',no \.'H,},j.!t"Lt"I.,~.~,..g'~'1 '1"'V..~t::;_..,J';.Vi~'I';;'~;'~J>~\'>~\~'~~I'\i':I~I~rrL.'I"",I '7~'~.,IIi\lI,".1.<,~!\,'i."'...._i.)I.ll if', .",..,,1_, ...."... 'II'.' .1" 11I1 .' ... .. ',:", . ,'" /";,';_' 'i't ;\~ ,:.(~.,:,;'~,~I\I.\\:...~.r'~:.\~i,r.,y~-i~~.t!~Vl1.1i:'.\\'{~11~1~'h".r"fI.~.;.'~\: \.!....'i,;;,,\i::v, " t.rtkzi;; _;.,~,~....~\I:",~ ',;}'t~!.. < '.;_l'r' ,'i)' ~ :l;r" ~'), ~ t ....,1. I '1llI,1o "~' ;,' ~l. J'IIII,> ' -" ...... " ,'.....,' '....,'-, ,.....,;,...,'-~ ...',.,""',,,,"",(.,,-,,, ,...., :,"", "..,.,ii!,....""'''-',_".!~,.'I:_.!t<l',' ,",\", ,.....,'.."'''.lvI7,...','',...,',:'I>''''I.-,..,....,_t,,,,......, "','.,,11II',',...',0"",' ,',.'......, ).....>'...." ,-'"'11I..' ......" , .. ',c' .'" . " . ..... _,' , ~I_o",......." ........-' ",...... ....1.1;"......" "'UJ ,....",..." """.,_,.-"._l,;.(! ,~" ,.",fu, A ,....,..._,_, ,...Ij....'. ...',~,_.._,', _0'-1. ,. ,'....'" ,.,_" ,_,-" '....., " , iiiii,., ....' Bill' .' ," "'.'_",IIIIl" '-,'">>; ';_',;......l'iI'IIll',ItII',... ""'IIIII'..'IIIIJl'I..,'-',.'III!t.....'""IIIl,' 1lf.II'!lIIIi':,.......,,,....,,.....,,..,IIII".....n.,..,,"...,'iilIli"'IlIIIl'iIIli"'......,..,.."...IIIII..,', "III!'IIII"'" .' ;,..'11II"""'_1" .' .....".', -.- 'III' .', ',J: '. . "I,'.,.....,.'" .\,-./,,,,,.;, '!IlIi' \,." 'rj;l',' :..~';.....",_'l\,."!II!,,~}1,~ 1_"~1''''''''''''' ,'/i'~~....'I/,l\.~~.,..."'IIII'JI!'..",'......,",II!!')' J'lIli{.''-. '. '~.~~\'., .," '\"'~_J"" ,..11I1> ',"11I1'( ,f 11II....' . r ' . " . .', " ~; ,'~ 1 'J,', ,;\';, :1\\';,'/,I\,'~~..jll~~;"','...>',~1._~::'I~( "'IIIIllIlllI'l'::'-'(:'l,'{ ,'\._'l.\'.q.I,;!'~..".'lr:".;;' "i:,:'~)Ill1(,'/iIIII\~_, ,.' :;r,:.'( ~,...."'i~t;;\LIIIII!::~. ,~ ,Y ""I';, ,"_', ,','" I ." ........, , ,11II11" '.'..,.,",., ",..."'"'''''',.''.'''.,.,',...,'..,.._'..........1'..'.,'''''''''''I!III"'..,,, ,.',,, "..'.,1'.1"/ ,.:.._",.11I.".. '.,'11II, .'--, '..' , ." . ......" ...."1'." ~" If.' "'\:'''''''''I'''~ .,1 ,<,_,'1"')1 ~-'~"l....'''''r' "~l) 11~~")I":'p"" , ~"" ,"r' ',' . 'p-;>.-, .,1 '4' 1_".__ .: .,.~'. '111' '11IIIII"-' 1'l!'.flIIIrl.'\..;".~'.".~'""'II'.......,.IMl.'IIliI';~,JII\1l',;.;;.\n"'~~.'.:>ll\I:""l'.'~l.'~,,,.',~.~ l" ~.,.,.~.l,:! ,"~/""'''''''''',:'.l\,\,- '11\" "'-'...',' '. , ' ,_I .,1, ",' ;~'._:'"", ,1i!{1 I', ."~'/,:, '''l":,j, _;,~I. .,'..< '.r ,"~: .~,'I...~7~~~~tt'! J _f',I", ,"i';' '~~I',~.\;>~""\' " ~ Ir'J'.t ,,;. ',~, .r"I; .,_'1,';', ;' -:. 'I;', : '" ,. ,11I: 1 '. " , , ........r", ~". 1..,;").,....",r'I.~.I'rllII.,.,r:'l,.lll/'f.J'l.'jlt'lV.~",.vl.,,,'1'.r,".....'"'....."II"'_~ \..,."" 'lilli' '..., ' I .' ': .,..,01 '.' ,\'.'::',.\'-:.'::'::1 ~"""l,"-~~;'l, '....,'!,\/,':'~? ~r.2.;;i:'~L:.h,i.'..;:vJ...."';I~~~~,~'~:~U::.~'ti}'<\;/~.i,;J~:,'~>~~'~.. -r.,l:':J)lll!,'_.:,.......':',.'.(f~',,\.~IIIII{ ~,,', 'n,I,," ," "" :-. 1"""" (. . '~.', . .. 1.1, "If '''''I'r1".:1I''''''r 1!II!!I.."..!lIlt;~',.....I!.I,~.;:lV\'".t",.,1,_". ,!,~UI,~!II'...."..."."."~ ",LIllI!, I,' -'IIIIiIlIIIII!III', ,_,. _.. '.~ ' '. < c. "'-"'11I1", ,:.';)~:t,:;:I'.~ ~~':,:..:-:Itl,'.~r,~'\'''' ~l_, r,..z~'.",.l:;';t'~ .;~,'ll>'''.1'''it':P~~~.1 i.~.rl'/,,' ,.7':;: .:'!,/....~j;'IIIi.....,d""i.I//;:{\'/..frlll.'4..:},r;,~..'1.IIII,'. .:_, . "." '._', .' '. ._,! III"" , .;' Ill,",. ,!'-.'I"....'\:..;:".;. .r,'1.,.'11 '. )',~.":.~~.;~~,;r._,'"~,\'.';I.trll,:"V.i',\):l\\\,,\~.",t:"F~~"':.'<'1',,/~:~ .f,..:.'.:,,:\,.,.', ,,,,,,,~,,~,:_,I,f,"'.Il:,',.o: oI\~'''I'"....,.,_,'._'" :,_, .:. _. ~ '.. '" ., ,l _. ," "."",IIIlIl. .11II' 'iI!!.."_~ :cI.I,\.".!.~, .,....~'t,' 'h, )"'>~':" 1''' )j1~1"~ .(.<> \'\ >:r,.;'''.....,,!......J..r''J''''\'.,;I'.!';'ll".'t:.'~,.. ~r,~....,'..a;". ~"~"'~J"';"" .J~~........~J'lt <,IIIlI,'I'..'I_'dll~'''', '.'" .", 'J,' t...." '.....', ~......, I..""" .' II.... ....,-'.11III,_.,_" .','. '1'\"'!""M/J~" ,. ~ "I.("}'1."'~.I""...;\'I~.,.~'ij.'"("'.I;~'."<>~III"~! ........., .,.....' -''"..' j' " '.' -,-' , ,.m ". '. ^. '., III.';'" !......:,:;... ~,/J\II,,, \"'t'{j: '.:':~f ~\\<T"""I".,(J~ ,~.:t";it~, '!,l.(~:....:;~~/.J:.\J.";:{P,.~1.r.:l',.:;f.'f;S.,TI';rl':.,,'~..;.:.:,,)?,IllIIfi./'(llI!Iill,t~Ii!I('.{"'.......,~:":~.......t/l/r:.:\.,]>.:, ,,~'''..I', ,j'.:-:IIl!I"."'.' ' '. .'." ... '11II",., ,.,..h, .. 'I""'" ',,., , .,'r.,.,,,,- ";1" '," "{..,,I.. \.,,"""W.'......,''''''',.......,q..'!iiIllI''011l1rl..lrJ;;''-_'',IIIl''..'', ',.." ". ..,,,.,,, 111I'" . " " , . I . ~ .' rill 11II , ," '1IIi'1lI 'vt'~':>'I" 1"e,','IIo''::: ,~',"",' 1..H'.:'l.:.!:~l~...._f~,!I',"..' ~(('....t"'J'l,r;.\.. "",It''; /!',';" flllllllll".....'OD" \"'~..:..;'III'h'I.'.l.", '\ " ""l~' ~'" . N ~ :" ,,, " \",' '.oj .', .f'I~",'~ ,~),'j' "t'."~lt. ,'':.'1 '11'-1 ""; ~,t'"I/I'J..,~t_"i,~"~_\I"""I!~"_'I.'''''''~'' ~'U;l'~ ,- ;\(.'~. "....J""'I'''.'. 11" ,'" .I'. ,':~. "..' , ' ' I.' ,,~ " " l' . . '... _< \,...."_ _:'~~"f.f,:" ,,,:'.'~.1I..-f:""t'" l,,~',,).. ~:'~',ft,;'i'lil. ~fl'_,'~')':'1.l"""~;~~_/...,',\iIIlIC"'..:'~J.IiIl.;:IIIIII'.I'''. ""'~';'lc!\'~.I"." \ ,i,". " _"...1,11II', ' .. ..:.. r' ',': ,_,,' ''.I!llII.'', ,.\-1,\ .'~'_Ir-.\ Ii.,: ':~.'" ", """,;,;''-'';;'1'1,' ~i''''':'"lj,.;.t~,~II.., ;'\'~:-'~'",~f'_:'~t' !l't, ,,~.,(w~~_:...i:.':J../,::. ~. ~;''';'1' "";t'" ''l ':\o~.: " "11IIII" '." ., 'I' -.' .' .. '."," II '\ ._'.1 ;\..~iIlIIl;_;.....r.~...I,l.I'..~I.,i::..' ;,"1 'f' '1r 1\1'7:;.}t.l'.H"..,\~'.~J',\.1.{,".\~..,.t/,~ ~..~rl,'i~RIlJJ:.' b;.IM{lr,.r..o' t'r>' "No"', ,,,.t'';I'\JIl!I-f~'' l':IIiIl,~'.!I': ;-,.., ". "~ :.:,'.. , ,lIIIIIIII" .'.'.. II" ,,,....,,,, . .,"',,'.1,0' , ..'"." ",,' '..'I".." "/" ",001"\ .,"", " r,<, "',, 1 ",-"\,,,..' ," '. ,,,,,. " "f_", ..'" '.' ,'. ',' , ' . . . ,\ ". . ,'J".l~;I.,.J".~\, '......"11' '1,~":~.."\',.~,';"L..e.f'1 }..~.lPt"'l'~':~I..':t.':lI,~III~'I(I',~~,.~' ".'lr'~''''l\.,'1,..\l\.;,'.,I,''....\,'/_,.I. '10"1."'" ..", _'; . , '_. ,Ill" .~...~ ,,.,,\....,; ,,':1'H"'~~'~'''''l-<-''~ ~~L:r'1::.~~Af.i,'''ri-~,,~~':.:Si..,;.i~~t..\.'!.:-l.~''''''''.J''~t .J~.~I,.~~.......~~l.o!-_'....'to-;j.S".-;;-,......... '\""~''''''''' ,'T~' _'" ....l......, _--~;;;;~..-:""OIOi>~IilIl.,~~....~-0~"_.\","f'~"';,.~~!.'..I.M(-il".,.I:\....,~r:..;0J1'.tC:t....''''V~~~.rp..7.7'~;"...,~!.,,~..J,.1'..'''/;::-.....,-.~_, ~iiii-...." '1'_7~ ""':"'-"';"";'!.';"""':~ , -I ...1lI " 11II" ""'r ,1",-;1; ".4 -1lli11"_r-~!'f"'" '., \~ "l}i ,....({,.~ \11' '\", 1." ~ .1".,," ')1' .I~~'l!.:.l I.-i, ',~..., i~. ~. r'.-<il""'.' ',,'''''1' ,,;'11..," .......".../,....,111I(', ~..., I""~ .'. '/11II' 'I' .!' "". ",.." ,; "';I!II,I.~..."I"I~'..:. "If"."\" '('~~"~',~,\."\h'" 'l.l~~..,,\..lJ',.!I..I:'i!<\."','.: 1,: ,11-j"....."'(".:.;l':" .l,.~',':'.r,i,.........' ,'~\'...ll 1"'1\1"1""" 11II. ',. , "11I11III'..' ", <I' ('I" )",'; ~I" ",'kll' ""I \""", 'l" ," ".~ ."""t~"JI. "'-I' ~",,~1,'r, I' ....., \, .\.....'.'1.," )'., ",' ',' II " ",.... "1'-' 11111I-' , . > . 'HI' '- ',.~ ,," "~~ ~,"',..,. "'.' ,,,,, '~,....;'.'ll"',.,"'<".,_,.~ ," ,.-,,' ,-.. 11III','...' -"- '1 ~ , ,.w n_", "'_'IlI'iJll."'" 0'\ "1.",.,,,, n.. "\/"/1:r..,(1.1t"., I iI',r,".\(. (1' "',.,'..,~, 4"""/""""''>"'.'''''''''1' "...' . I',.' . .. ,'. I ' ,,' 'l,' ",,' '1" ,~{....~'/_'.' l~....d:' '.'\......:;I;(((.({,""):'< ,0i,\:":l':":J ~"".tl:,:,,~,t~ 10<:, \~If~jtii/_~;(:t~/.I'\{./;..'I.r,;r:."..-\;"..'fr';.. ;.ilf.. ";;~,,:::y,}.::\~,\,, /"'f" I'" \, ,', l . I' "".' .~ . ......'.. '.II!IIII..IiIIIlI,.' 11I_, "..IlIlIl...,..' 1IIlllII'''''''' '..........\,'1 """','111;1""... '.""1", ~ ,I",'];\';':J. ~'o;..~,~~;"j'!"'"" 1'~'I~":JI'r'\'f'I>"'/"_" 'liIi'i.r.lllt~tl.'1"I";I.,.1.~~11.J,tl'!l";~ ~l "~'1,%", 'c>".~-{r '^.'r{,. ''''''''I~\ ",". ,'.,,) III .... , ...'_. ...... M',_j '~''IIIIl..,_'.."~_, ':IBI"\ 1'.",. ~<~-...,;,\I;_\,:"\"(':r-;'''~!.'l,';:7Ir'~!~~/' ~:(\.j"1"i,"'I,-.;,,~(,. "li";I":~~\,>c.r'~li.1 ':"IW"I'J~""h'L'~.I,.;,i ~.:t'-~~'f~' "r.'l.t,/!"t~~;/,\." ;"'::::"'1" '""..' ~ ,',!1M.' ;11' , ' I "':. ..11IIII:_." "_'Ill" .......i _;""11\II'-,;,0'.111III\'''''''' ,.'...t~l..,:n~':.?c,;.:.;,' !.~..;,_,)\'IlIll\IIIlIiIli,;'liI!i,':..1".i ,1IIII,i\.I'",H:.!.,,:<'I!Ii!;,~i".IIlI\....,'>/,i"~;"';::',ifJ"""'",g':"I'!lII':\irllllt:'.,;.;.,c"I'':'\'''', ;:';'1: '.....,":,'. 'II,:....,..',....," .....' ".' .l '-. '.', ,lIIIII, ",:'.,,'d-':' '....',_.... .':.II\.;\\f,....,:... .:/~',' ~'./.';,';',/.J, ';,;.. <.,;~"",-:)_.~J,{:./.:r.{.~".:/ ;:,:?i'N'):l):.~,:I'I!IIIl':~~,U.,'~ t:';,'(',.,....'~J'?~'....~ ~'.X:\.:,t'~~y:t ~'4 ,,'ri. ,,' ~'....~,,1:',,' :...1, .!:~.,' ,iIII~: R, ',: . .,', ,,', ...'" lI!Ili" '"ll' l""'ll'j:.III'f 'J;"..,.<J~.....,.','I'Ill"jj.l""'~,"~., 1,~.~,l'j,".f,",';,..,'..!(::.,'\O\\J.'i1'i~\:,1: f""";),:.')).II..;tN,fllll<-,.'~j(.ll,,<l;~\L.,.,".,'{.,_~!IIil:....,"..~1_1.>~ ~"\;>/lilIlI"~''''~'.''' .','..\ /11III" 11,,11III", > '1" .( '\~'I." I" '.' II. " 'j) "~I '"~,,,'i.,\',If:~'.'.'l'I' ,<"~J'i,,,,.,:~'-,~'V1J "J~_j'.',~'" ".' ....'....,'....._".\..)~,./.....~.,..\"...."'_". , II , '. . ,:;' .> ;.. ,,>........;:'-:> "':,'~ >:\ ...i.; ~ .\.>}, '!l~l\~~}}:;;' ,\~:l',~(V">?-.,\j-r~~'''.l;~-j~.~'~)ill<,::,,'!'/ ." ;'I~\{ ~:l''':-(''::':-''''>L'~ :,~t '~r' :~I :I:'.'::~~'F~ :i:<,-"'<\f~'.' '~"r'IlIIlII~:, :.'0....: :...~ ',: ".''',;"...., ~.l!IlI'" Ii,', II.' J "'..' . II," . '"",,, -." ." ',- , . """"','''''''''','''''' ,.., ,A',C',_"Illl/o, ',,,,,",,.. ' """"""'1)"" '"~ ,..,",..,..,.., ,,,,,,,.'.0 "..\"'"'' "III,v....,.. '....,,' IIIIII!I" ..... 'III _': ,_,' .: , ._..:.~:"", '11\ t"'{'.'i;t ";:.':{.':~;:\{, f, . ;S,\,'~J-~I'/ 1 '~-,,~ ~:J-i,(1l;;:/:\)1l <~~~IIIIl,~,', . ~";:;'~ '1~:/i'" ;'!h:.h~'~''''!'I'')~1''. ',"'~''''I:,\?"':.,'~"r.~ \:1'4'\ '~.'\'\,!I"~.{":J).. 11II;......'>:' illAl,.{..tllil,~.," '11III1",,_, , .., '..". j 11I".''-' III" 11II..' _I.. '.IIiI' \", i~." q. 'J~l....'....'t~"'"' "",,-,',t'-" ,'j\.,i\l~"'l ,.W .' ~!lIllI,!",.~""th'11\~"'1 Jt.~~,> .. ....' I.; /' >~.\ I"~' .....t'..."'"......". '''1r ...',11II'''"'',1.,1. \ .., \ . 1:1_'11"" II, ':'., ):"'lr/',~/:,:~. ,....~.""}" t:;~.\~...i,'. ':;'L,!,,'~~,;I:r;I~.~,.:'"'~!-~\ ';<;,'~~IIlI~~y~;;'{r:~~':';:../~1-",~I;::I..,{\.~:~~:;1:7~_:':.1I'.~',l:;:":...;"~'~:~~1, ./,t;I'....,rc../"{.....~:;r;..,.';,;~:'J"l :',~,_vJ_..., .'., ''. ' ,"'~' 11III'.:' III. ". ' ".'IIJI'" ~ f' .,'." ';/"'-_'".IJl"-"_P~,.~I~' " 1'''1,\.~1\" ,,' ,"J'.~ :;;'~\' '',.'j\",'~l ,J" ,.'r\'''<~'''II'"'~)IlE,'l\\!I. ""'r-lll~'I".,.h "!.-"'I-_tl~''l ~lllI"IIllIfIltlII'!,-'~I'",{,- "1_'_"'" ~_, ,'....' "III, , r I '.. "~. " III.. '1Iil.~' ,11II" , 11IIII. \<1~1111l1:.::;,.::.:t.:.:I{;j~:\~}_t7...;~'~rt:T[.;1;i.,,; '~i'l~i':._:#t".;J".; ,,'1 \r,~~_h':...~:~~.J~ji'\/~":~,t,~;/i{"i.J.i...,~;rc!llllll::;7,''!~.~:::l~$T,~7Y'!lIII,>:'"\;l'lllIi,!AI'~{~;1:'~.t_t~t.:':} (j2 i:.-~'III: '1lIIi/~i.:',_... '. ~""'~:,l", 'III". .'H;' . I ',11I' 'l' .'lIIi.' )'" 11......,...~.'",o~j.,fIIIlIlj, ,.!t!llll,"..l'/h."'IBI"_::'ifI!I";111!'t .",,::.ll.,....("'i\I\..-'I,_..I\."):}.~.1,),t;.r.j,.....,\~'....'r~~!lIIll..,.t'I,.."...."'>')J:\~"~"\';II"d~'I\Ili!I'''':_f''~'lllIIli''IIII'I. _" '\'"".', I" "'IiIlI' ' III '. . - II" " 'I' ,~"\\.,, 1lI.'IIll!....'.'II"."~l"\.f r,' '~I' _,,,,':).".i' !~'ll'\t-';I""!'~l""l~I\!~' ;';""'~""_"~ "j'I'Il"""'~"..' ;J;,',t'tI'J"j' ,,;.~, ~ 1,~' 1'1""< I "I. '"."."; , . '. .'~ ,.-, . 11III'11I'1\1'''. "I"IIlI'" ,...." "..".".\"., '''lfil' ""..\-',.""." ..',..)r,',,, ";""""","""_''',''''''' .-'" "'...,""",.". "("I "..IIllI""'IIII..........'.."II' . ".""11I'.' .. ".., 11III' _' lIE. I": ~":-; 'I .'o.'.'lR~\;\.>;.~f.,/;.1 J"\:';':,\~ht !}:~.;t'rii';<;";'(,~~-/l;"1~.I:J:i{>~:1~~Yf~" ;..~,f~1;LI~.:;',~_~:._;':;:,\il!&\~j;_~:,~,li,\i"1;1.'~"Iff."~,;~;I :i{\:~.':,~:~~t:!~,.,-~;'.\,IIl:;~.....':l~'\.'-;!"~ ~ ,,'.,'^: 1'''''1":.,''' '. . . III, 1I\lI' -' ,) '. 11..111;' .'IDII<<' .\r~IlI". '<.;""":""),;;,(,;"''''''~(~j'.r;-f">t;t-'''\\'.J-r ~_':!"" ~~1"'l}"""'~':'""<; .i~""J't'i'",t};_;I~,-"[tRi,~.j,~_,,_~.~l7!f r.~,c -~~'t;;),_~'-l" I' "1~~~;1....."1ilI4"" :_I",'~.1~I,"_b>\""""~ t." '...'" ,. ".' ,', ,.,11II" - " ,~.::l ,'.~ ::'( ';.11II, .~:IIil;)\,.~1:~<II1;,(,;t'.tJ;;;:l"d';':/_:"':~ ~}I:'':: l'.L~,!.~\,~i{f;!~:./:S~:r;SI~{~;~'.1 'j,-.I.;~;;:/~.rr.J~,?iI!Ir:_'~~~;Vj"~?~/'":-..l~::ilIlI',_;~...??l.rll!!'f,~:~ ,'h:'.....I....b .-~' ;;.IIiIlII,~" ';1\\";':" '....~'l::": '.': ",_.'.'.11:.. ,','" 1 , ,m,...,IllII."II".. ,....,_..~-',...."'.""..,.,'P""",.."",',)'_,"."""',^'.n,""""'."""""" .'.""..~i"_\"""'''...',.__.,.."',~.,>""..,,,~'' ',..."..,,,.,"......,. M'" .'1' '. .' _'......~ ~. "'"'''iII},f':1I'4_'_'~I''''' '~l~<;:(:I.<"I'l"l.t"h~IL.,~.....',V_'ii.-rI.H~.'l....',J,J{...r".."":,,,,'~'r~ v."'~""'>\~'7>\,'rr:;~~'~^ ::'<',H'''''\_(''~'''f'i'~v,.'~~;./)'/l;{; "'II~i'\( ,1.:....":-,',, ~t '..~,,, , . 1111' ........ ' ,t." -, .\,~. ',.'~!IlI:;...,':.. .~: ~-;"'f~.W,t \'{.~ri -.;-;: ;l,Sl':Nl~~ "/"'/_l'~ r""h.~.1'I ,lmr:::\1.,;I:, n,,', h l~'.i~b''.,;J:'::>r;'il:7... ,,j'Hll'j,,~,~~'~"~"l.~,'I, \:l i.~,,;V " '.(."./..,\ 111:'-;'1 ~. _f;l. t' _III' , " . ." .-.. '~: ~IiII,n,~ I:, ~:;;':~_'" '.\l:~",,~~;.!i',':~.\J ;,';:~.J .:{';,_\~~:;}\~.~,,-;~'i.f..~:~ri'r1Jliil';.l~lilll.V:1..:~.',';~\1:~,(.~,(t;<'::\~h;,::i,'I:,'"\''iI):/, '~:'1~'f>~""i)::"'l<,l.0-:\,;';'),!'~" '\:';/~:'I;,\"t'h "..., ',;-' . t:" .' ....~; .. II, .', 11II.'" .: < 1Iiil~'"' iii': '11II, 1i'.::1 1fI1", l~IIIl1l~~)Ili!.~ilIII:~IIIlI~;: ,II' ,~',: ~4\::~Z,:I~i%f ;'.~~ \,~~~}:j ~\'5~~.t.:~~ :!IIIr'/lI'!"iYI~~;,~ ~~I~;;,imlllltilli!Jl~,;:.:1Il4l:'~ ;;fr~'~~;~~niJ;,}I~:~~;~~~t:~~}:!~:h:; t~'1).t~j>~I!ill:l~~~J~:~!:'~k{/':~f~., " v.~: ,I~~{:\IMI\: ~:';,~ :'~'I""': :~'~II~\>~I~' :<'III.~ .>-, '-.' .." II' '. .. "'1' '.: -:. "'I,.lI..fi"' ,."".t~_!"''.i I".:~ 't ~l\'.;" ,,,_~:'i~ ~~V~"''',:li''!, "'~''''''l.'~'' ~'i""lot'.."'.;t.,l)..I"I.\(,\"\'\'i~,,(...."..,.r'..~'~. ")h't"l"IIl')\I"" ,,,...,.... .. "r (, \.1 .' . I III'" '...... II" "'1\' \ .~' '1I'\.~'""_{.''''''i '''II,,~~,.;:);:..;J,,:'''':}.\."lll,'"/i'~~,j.'!, \";.:\ ,~,jl'.'"~\',/II'\ 'f~:'f". '1<..l;r;."'}'j1..)<'~~ ~;!~,j'~'~'r.~ ':,:;-' . t/::'t~I",,~p'~\II~ d'~:;i:i,.~'1(/"1 "I"~ .q,l <. '.>'-" ': "-, '.,11I1\' \,' . II". ,_",~ c' I' , .-:: 1 ,1",", '!'"i.~ll, ~!;~.,.(;,',.,r"."'li.,1 "~ :\~;;f'I'<"II~"""'\ ~~"1"1-:.~.1,'~ ./~i};'J' ij!"!"I!.'J.,.'.:If.j\:~."."~,, '~_l,/'l~.<'1I.\t_t("""'I~ ',I"J,I'~ ',"\ '" -'"~ ~"'\ ''"', ,1I.'1Iil!,1!lIi' ',' , ..,' 'I" :'IIJ""'" 'II'""'" "".',', """,.>, ,.".",,'.1'" ''''" ",,,,,, "" ,"""""'IIl!,_""""",,,,,,,,,""',",,I.&'" ,........',.(,....."." '.' ""'.''''''''' ,~..., 'II" 1''''''' lIlIi.....' , , '.'., "....,._.'"'.....r'.~'" J~\,,'1\ir,. ,r \"tt~,"r~t.f'.'.!,\' ."~1..."...;.'i(',."'lu.I~I.r".IVJ(/~1.......',..\~ '~l\.'''''.''f'IIII' .<," .....,-"".!,.,,. '''.. 1IiII' . ~ ',, , ,~ ';"j-,-~:',I. _' .,;' ..l~",(,':If.&'~;I'I"r"<';;'_~,'~....,',~,..: II~":'\"'.!:":-.'" ':~i"r,~'I._'.5.{:',\I:"""-t_,~',,,,,,;,'.;..:\ It,.!r;:1.:~:"y,,,,;!',l,'''''\'')'' "f-I";I'.' ...:-~"I" ,c.;t"~\ ";~,;,'\' ""'.. '11II, lilli' '1lIIII( , :J:_ f, 'II' ' ~ ':" ..:"." ;~,,~,t(.._;~,i'~IIlIII. 'llIII.'\:>iIlII\ ~"I.r';~i?'\lt_l~ "'~"-!0.".:,:;{~\:';:"m""!' ,:.,:v,l"~ ~.,~IIIIiC_'I. .'i.;:"'1~::' }..~t~:'~r:,;r.Jil"12'~~"'Jth,~ 1?')""'iIB;>'\i',\'11'J111!!:"~lli1lllll!!"'~I!IIIII{~i'~.IIi!l,\~"""~"/ },I"...., _l' :-1iI-;iIIII~r~ .! .1;'_. ';'; ,..;'.c, '. . " , ;," ",ill, "-1"11,' ",fIB' :" '">"'.'II.I',,.,'"IIII.I,,1I1l1l,',,",,', '",.. '-">""""'11"1'1" ~'.!IlI!:".'" ):,"ilIl"",'4I1&!,.,'IilII",.'V,,~,,;! "'i."i"''':''''/''';''''I_''''-'''''~''1ill!Bi\'''!IIIIIIII'' '.mi..',,'!'I.....,., l","IlIll!......"_.IIII, ." '11"i ...~.' ", '" , lIII' I "~", ' ,. :> \l "-'. ~ '.' ," ~)',,,'.l< ,', 'f" f..... j ""','.' 'I ,\',;".." '" \'1' :J",,'^"~ ,~,~"" -, ,,-,' '\....'_..1...'......' ',"",....... ,. ''"' I' ' -" , '".' '.' . '. '.' ,,' ,\'" . j"''''!'~ "'}'"I',I" I' j,';' ),: J.'.", '( l'IR'i'\ 't\";r,1 '."-, O.~ "'J~ ',,;<, ".'1 f~{\'IJ' 'j;:(';"~~"I"('~'lVrl' ~,t, ",~_l'..!:"_," _,',,1.... _"'III!",.\>..ji......1 ," I , 1 '. . . ~ ""< ,- I .' 'II" 'ill.. ./, ,...i,.,_.~/l".,\;I;.'...\' "\I'"l,.,,:\~,'il'~i't\'.fir,','t:^.~".1 '~."'.,I"'.\'I,i.'t(,'\~,lilII',,.:''''~d,:,.,'U:.. ';., .:\~, '1;...t.'1/~l'(j(<(~''"tl,_,:~"'~,', \(,',1)'; ;..,;.:,',,':,., '1.:;~_'" ';,_:"'1\-,...'........"IIIII.....'III!I'" .,"~ . .., .... I. .' -; . _. "l"'~ ,'~",> ,...-,. ",,".,,~:.,'( '1.\ '"t ,j._..: ,'....'"",~,. f' ".t. ._, _. "II ,;t"I'\-.''''j'; <;:~'i1,,,'}:~" 1"~",J _..'''',....,<... ,...",_. 'I""); ~rp".~ I .:. ,,' ""'" ""","",' ~',.....' ,'. .; _..,; ...." ~ 1 ,_', _. '. 'ft."' '1", "''''''''_''tfh...,Il,;, ._,'>..'""'.....~'')f.,!I'>!tl.I_..,. ._~"ll)1 ~{ . '.',1;r""1" .'jl":~'.'I~~~"~....!'i"":'''''''ll!IIl''""",'''\!!l'''V~~'.IIliI\l'\'''',J, l'~Wl!I~"":"-!!IIIl' '!!!!--,-!!!l!l!!!!. , . 'R.IIII'.""'....' .....'. '...."1,','.... '.' ....-."-,"...',.-, ,._',..."...11I'I'...,",..,".. "."",,-, " ~". ",,," ",_",I_h ,riili, jIjj,' =~'IlJII''''' ........._' . ... ' ""'1111II'" ., -'...., , '...~,'r...,'....I..".....'..."III'/l'C\.".....', _,......,.....,.~_..,_".....""".~"':~..~..'~."'..,\."~_,.,.'Il ,\''''',~~i.,'\V-.,."....IIT.,,\1-~'.~ilII..''"~' .,_,"'('~1.','.,...,,~, I....." ...."....'..' ' .'If' .' .' '..' ,.111: " .1IiIII'~(", .;~;:/~lIlIIl",:t..... :'.'~',;, ...:~.._3::~:I....;f';;I"""'\<'}_.:1 l".'_~, l:':.iJ.l..l;!.t:,~;1::"j/.:ji}r';\J'J\>;,?:;\\,I.J/'"~':J: 1j,8r';:...\J~L~lt ~l,:;(t,}f~Y'",;:::::.: (':;::'i'('~;'r,j' .., )IIJ'.'::i~ 'II')'" '~IIIl'< ,.'._: ",: ~ ~ .: " ~; .' 1 'I'-"III!'....,'- ,." h~_"..'II.....'''IIiIl\l'~ti)"..,I1;.{ \ -"'-'lJ'~"""/' .'(..".>~,I'f,'j.'I'..'-"'j,\\'.\\'r"j<.!,I.'f ""'14')"'l't"'I,,l..})'.:t',~~ i.'l" "<' ,.,( .,'".....;", ~\ I" "' ""'1< l' I' .' ..III' 11II'... ".""'t"~ :,..' .", ';J~"'" ,'g'I" i"i ! ,',"',,': /" l'l_r.t'. ,1""bP"'~""."""'t.\'1;' ~I " ':!J''''''';~IJ'-r lH.;\'t:., ,:-,'t;,,'.r I",..) "'.',..t' .". I ,...~: '.'. I.' ',..1', '-, "1'" . ., _, '... Ml'\' -III .,,',.' I.,l " ,,1 !!II"'. ,~f\<\!,~.:, ~IlII!IN._t 'mlt"r! ~'~'.l,." .\f''''~1'... ..:~l'-;"'l ,tr.',~.e~,1.~? '( ?'l" " ,~j ,"."~".' .it, (k' ..,^"M .-' I,'....,. iIII" , '," ,l&II..IIIlIl;..... . , - , .-l' ,- '.'. " ',lilli" ,(.,'..' 1!. ::~'".'I,I:" J~ ""\'f::~"::"I'~~';lI!lll'_/ 'f j';'/"~/\:~!'~~.;1:'~"1,~;I',(\I;" t.l"'\:'!/?{.~; I/t ,,~:;'f .:::l;,~~~;;;:'':;{'j~i: ~,~:.f,/~", ,/ ;/JJ,i:~" .'~. {, ,'::", r...., ';;:;iIIlII',' Il)":l:.....,;, ,1i'I-r/', . \ ,f,'.'III,:" , .'." ' ~""\." '!;p'iltt~> ,.; ~~)-.(\;!.,c<:"r~(1'i?"r"l':..:-.";,,,\,j".,;, ~.';; ,'J~""':'r;:I".:"j, <~i?\.\" ~":{JI~" ;.tj\ .,,,~',F. ".~'.~L^/I,,~\J'" ,.~. h,\' ';'";. _:.,,_1,. "1"!'Jl1':I'IIIII;' :'. .' "I"" .;~, >)<'1""1'"''''\ ifl\\:\^"I'."~^" II ~i!l>t,tr1lt..,"l".l.",~..lt, "l~;<;},\"",-fl..~ ~,\", ";"~r.~,l &,-,,1,,:.') ~.'" ','" ."1'....'.,.,)...".-'"""11..'" . I ". . ',' . ,;..' , '~l,' I ~'''.' 'r- " f./. , l',"'-,,~"~'" .,~. \"..Ij.,,"t~ 'r'~'~"'f ., .'- . ~\,,"..". ": ' ,,~ "i:(~"':'~' " fJ.~."'i~'':'''''.''''';f_"'''I'":- "'~.;:..,_!"~_.. . '.. ""Bi~"" "/)"".,,,"1; 11.,.,~..j!. '.~.h"I.(,,",,v. I"'j,j ~ q",'c~Sjl'1' ,..,'!IIlIl..,...,,-',...., '0.,-,,,, I' .'.\~:1{,rlill;.;!"_Z~~"~:~{_r/~+I~\r.~;~~~l~tSitf" :;:;':;:i~ft.~~ )!:r 'IS'?i~ ,. .~~~'!r7~i~~m; ~,r~;liIlI\Ittlllll::/-;'. '::"..._;:\-", '..' .' "i/IilII", - " /"'\.......''''.~I'''.~,\'..'"fi.!~r',7t ~~': ' ",I~~')'I, """"f"'illI!')i ...,...,IIIll,IiII."IIIII,!I!I". -: III}' \," \\: ~'. ~ ~\~::r,,:;,:...:~_':;'}y:,::""'ih\:.;./:~r.:J . . , ~.\'.,I{\'T,1f:,~ ,h ;'<""~!{;~'iC~:'~~3j~..c.)'t",r,\':'l"l"';. ,,': ,",' ~".' " ". 1_",""..-, 1; ,'""'....,.~.,',....j\.......I./.!4K! >.J'.......",,-. l/~~\({~~';i; .\r' ,,,,'I,'.lllt_..,..!IIII " 11I,. 1 ,.;\., ....' iIIII' '\ ", < ,. '"....... . (,' ~,," ;-" r' ~fl :r- ../'~ 1" " " " ,...." ...." . " ; "';':" '....1.' },....'''''''<''.I.....}r'.....;~' LII,,,";'lh:/,r,,ot,.,I\;S-'.\',;""71\.,n.(' " . 'I", ~"'I .III}' \, 1IIIl, ),-'~ -R" ' ._,....,.,'1\.........', ...,....\ .""". ",hl'r')\')'!'~f'\<' l, 1",1., . _..., I,,', ,'" .......,""'.,"""'.'"<.IJIl!'lIll.''''''..,e<,,.,',.,..,C,,''..'''i''''' ,.... """'"'''111I''''' .....,..-"., '.' . ...'.._'<.;....~'~Ill"'IllI..:>" '"{...".'~A.:I\,I...I.. .:,I.Ir,,,' .",';.\',", t..,.'.r',.,_"....".,:j,~,.iIIlIII". , (I'" III'....'..~ .-<"" ,-I. ,'11III"" ,..: 1;;.li';;' ,'11 ','I, ~l,~,~\ (1;~"~'1'" .'.'tly", "' ,:.",,~ ,',) M..-"....'lIl'" ."I'lII" . .,'.... 'H"!<~'_I'/( "t", "r."'1 "'iI"...'I."IlIl~...."..'('..' . Il'l \. ,'_,' . '_,.,.,:l"~r"I,.\~,. '",,1,,~~' o,r,',h, t1i~"tt~.,T ~'\;( :~"{"' ..1.....:,.,1,.'1"'1"': ,1,'.;'i.{ .: I.: '; ".N,.' _:"'WII':' ":,;t_:' /,....:\,'l'IiIil_<.....I:~f,/~~~'.\If.l'./ < ,i!"....il :,'~.t'II:1j,;lFlfI~IIM:;.i_';;.>.~'_:.,,'IIIl:;-,f~IJIIII,',:III\1II~j.;~r\,1~,,,,p:'\:". ",.., "" .'11'_"_"'" .~\.'.....,I,......III'\"'t,~~\.l'\."\,.-.1 ':~\I.t,'~ . ~ ,;'<),:,'.'_1\ ,~...-",.w"_",.,.,, '. .~, ~I'..," "I " " ,BI'" 'I" " '.;. '....~~.,l "/,,, ,'i,j /, "'11IIII",11 /i't,~}~r.^r;' r. " '" 1\):t~ll, !., ,\' i'/' ,.,(Ii ,I' ,;.' ';:-,' :1lII1.' '1llIII1., 1lIIIIll' " -.< 1IILo;'o, .....':, III" 1 '\";;,;, :,;:.{ J~U'j'\{nli;!~l't.~ /,~~!:i >._I~'g:_I\';;~:.;.!.......:" '~l :",r~~-""""','~ '_: '\. ...., ....,. , I} 'w,\,' '''IIll'-II''\'.'''~'''i,.''1..:J~I'NI ._"I,!.' 1:'\"?1 _~'Ilil,..."....", -, :'....."11" . ,,-"-11II' .....,'''''",,'...,,,.....,,,,,,,,",,,,,,... .,' .. -'.' ''''"'''''-...,.".,''''-.:;''',...,'-'_..,......,'' ' .' '-,' .-" .1iIIl',"'"',_".......,I)!....~I~ r';\...'''''f';r~~'(li.~~'' :,>..~,~J\1:;: fi', ')' ;~,\".,'C"I'-I..'~,;.".;,;:-.;"" ,Ili!'::''':'i.-;\t_",~-,'''''!\ _;L ,,\ < l' II'..::: ,-~; l'i"'_"',,':::' ~ :,r~~;(/:F.:l..0~;'.f~~1,:~I:, '"?~~~~Jll~ {f~} ;1~~~ ~~lY,~I'.~I;;\}:~;;;>:,:II}~:~,v"".lr~, : 'II~: :"",'"I'~ ',,' . ,.,.-.-,1;' 11I!i,:\""\ I ,".......,IIllIIIl,.."I1'.'..."-'...'I1I'illI.,:J:l:M~' yf; J \ i''''';':.; If: 1~'i:'f,,:.,'1"'1~'\"" ,~I"{""('"II!,~, ,:.,\,\tI,','.'" " .., . " ~_''"''!....,t_'c.I~,..',N\-it.".,l'. .._ ;(:>:1' ' ',\'i\"tIJI'.;"/~;'..ll,I..IF'."~',".. ,,' :.........~' '"'.,t:~,'."'.'~"'\i. ~\-~."}' ,1"'>\\',",..;~.T,,,);.,..''''.",.:,,t,,I, ", Ii..... (.~',~\"t '!II"~I;:I f,,';';..i~l:: "H~'",I' 1~..,...,~.... ') I,." , , _I 11';'-' ~>~"...,','."I_~'t.l'R.t;.l~i'j;: 1,:1 ~,:,.'1'i.~f'I";"}~ IlG.J.l'~l,~~,"'IR::..I~";~.(J., '." II'.. ": I' . . III." I ' 'III',.:-:,....,}~':,l: .",r.~~-::'.!,,:~:'~2~'lt(-~r~\' :;~, '.~~~..f;i.l','i. :'.i,'{~""\.I:t:...._;.~iIJIl~;,_" ,..._~:~:i ,f.". l!lI'.': . ''';. 1 Ill..,', ':,' _",".";Il,~\.: "(.\".1',,' 1l~ \", !;~.r{J;~>~'I'.''''I:'i ':",,',",'<<,-,"' '. " ",.", ~IfIlI'"'' ", , .,. \"1' ,.". ,I~ ."',.'I{....".."',.,'1i,,.' "1_" I' II- ~ I'.'" ';J.,~'.,'i'~.,,',I:I'.'~" .,.>'".~.'~,",' ~.<, \,,, ~ 'j ~ ::i~\'l, ").'(1", ,"::"\ P ...~,..' 1IIll' \"1 .' 'I'" " .~, ?:,"i' "", ,0.:, . l"'11'i .,r,",.f...-.","...,.","'",( ',.'" 1..' _,",'ll.' ,"", r, , Ii .'."'_"'....~."{,h".r:'1.1,.I,('A,,' '.'<;'l,I',..'1 I' ,; ''''\.' .,'.,." '("." I III" ,."_'. ~,'I!Il..\ ,...:y;: fl~'( ;.C..(\~I-. .~~ "11.'., kl:;l\~ ''j ';:;'J 'j'!';'i' '"~,:: ;i':.. "', I,' " ,,, "ll'. ': III ill,. .' 'II i..' .'''(.,' l"i'I.V:.,~h'r\' "Pl<,f;t1d"". :~ ,'l~ ~"i'I'~l,,,,.~,{,~.,,'r 1 ,11II, ", 1 '.! " _.';/" \. ~;;':~r:~:!IIM~~"Vlllllt'.,,; }~!$~"t~I~~~I~fl(i!"";>'k 'f:\...l:.:.'i:....i~' ~]III':!. }.;~,.. '/\1' , ,,( >'. .\J.._'.l::IlII!\~lI!lIlIi',r k\~~:!I.R~~',.~,...:.'{ ;~')~~;I'~'(.:~,~J....;~~r:~)i~~p, i"...~I:'I'. 11I"\\ z .(-';~l,,,,,,~.,:l,; ; ~ "1'11':' ~ ':. " I ,-!>1I'1.'.._lj';\'>','(:'~llIIl}~""'" 'f! ~~ -'.-.: '~I, ') '((",t~"'r ~\. ,'\ I' '. " . 1Il'l"fIEil.;: ~";." "'\'.','mt\'~ ',~ ,\.,b,.'.l ~,' ,~, 1M \':'\(it:l;'~':~:j~:; )\,~~..~ U,,;UIi~')\ \,~"'.'( ,,;,',' .', .' III ,'....1,.', ,\\,:"'1~ .!.r:"".\'~!.!'1f I, '.,l;{j'" "',j'.1'\"f";""'~ ',:.'.tc.' ~",~I:I\ ."'";' Ir", '/1 '~\''''l^ ./oj ~\i'i \.!,,~l'-r}'irl' '~""'''\' .1.. !,W.... '_"1'., ,.,.....lIIIr~,';"..II'~'J,;I,.:';<'r..J~l:, ~i"I J'N fF'>);. ;'~1\ \'.;":1,<'-"" . (, .' -""I!B-" I . ~ ~:.~"';''''''.'I''~\\ifY'-'' I('/i;;:':~~\ ,l~'l':>":t'"\',"_,''': :,': ~. 1Illl".... ,"...,. Ile'''\''.;!l,,1 ,~,,'::'-"r~' 1"'''\-::0;11'' ........,.\ ,. .....' , .. ': 'r"\'\""'-\!""_"",~ ..~\ ~"'1'''''~''''' ~..~"./,"lt.'::;"'.I"""'_"'~'III' '. " II!I'I", ;'I,,;,"'IlIl!,1'~'_'<"'; '.' ,,)(,:~!..;;i",', ".',,' ";,\!f'hlllll"" ",'.....:,_." ''''....,' ,,', ~ A,~,' t " ,- . "'';'' ~ ~::t; ~...f r,':. 1, l {,'~' ,~ ' ~... (,:'\" " , ii. .' '.' "B""';lllll'OO111;;"I'':<lf :~~~~i\\~ti{i~;~;:)~~;M!"', ~ ::f$'~'~'~.\l?~:III~lillll~\,lIIli,_>>'fI:_r:O~""~'.~i~',IIll!" '<,"~.\'''\''''.'' '...'. '. ',\ " I '1--: I.~.,) ',.1"'), ~.\'. ~'I '.,.'\:1.:1'/ ~l' ~~l\,..,'.~~ji:1IN;~l'.1 1<:",\I',.lt{' ;r\:' ,"< '_"', (;11 \~I,;I.' 1";'~\\:"1 .....1, .'iJ ,\' 11II > 11II.'."'."0"""" 1"'(;,,,,,1, '(~~I'ZIf.'</\) ;"'~"~<"'''\ ~I,\ij,\ "~t"'I"_'.'1 __"'II''''..''~\\~' 1:,'" '\:\11',,\, I. i"l~I'.:~.i:'1~:~'~ 11'\"'h):I!!;l(',".>''''r:'~i.r " . _._ . :', ":ll1I.!"""'.~~1 ':'j,r;., "':,'1" 1\~;"!,,'I','~"',, '1';',~I.iI': ,.1.'.;....'.', \-:""'11II ' .'....l' ~.(1',." '\"1' [-. \'\'.. '"'~~"t""\",^'I'~~'l'II'" ....., 1IIIi,"_.... . l"~.."'!'(',~.t" .1 ",\t:I"~.:} ~ \.i',;I'~o:\i'~ I ~'1"IL't"~"i'.'-"~' ,_.. ,'1' ',- ..lllIlI' _" "'~"l"'\' {'1iri~" ':'~~i'I'~i'(k~.\P'~'fo)"-'l.{? ..~'fIYiti':t:. "~'~.,\'I.I~;'.t':'-;t.'j~:r:~ ',"'~,~\4t!.1~~~,~ '~\(~;'J-~1'';'1,./(.:, j'~;t 1;\,,','.'))'11,,1 '~,}/;1> i' '.' i...."..,. I, . :.-J~_ljo;::iJ~~~_~111~~_ ~ ~ ~~_~~~~ ~.~~~~V~ti1J~k~~~fl.j.~f~.'~:.-~"~...'.~;' I , I I I 1 I , I I I I i I ./ HURD P. ANSTADT, VS. ) ) ) ) ) CIVIL DIVISION NO. 1998-4334 Civil PLAINTIFF CAPITOL TREE AND NURSERY, INC. ) AND JERRY SHAEFFER ) ) DEFENDANTS. ) CIVIL COMPLAINT BY THIS DOCUMENT, I AM FILING A CIVIL COMPLAINT AGAINST THE ABOVE NAMED DEFENDANT(S). HE/HIS COMPANY CAUSED THE REMOVAL OF THREE (3) HEMLOCK TREES (EACH IN EXCESS OF 50' TALL) FROM THE PROPERTY AT 2303 MARKET ST., CAMP Hill, PA 17011. HE/HIS COMPANY WAS NOT CONTRACTED OR AUTHORIZED TO REMOVE ANY TREES FROM THE PROPERTY. I AM SUING TO RECOUP THE VALUE OF THE LOST TREES AND THE COST TO REMOVE THE STUMPS AND REPAIR THE LAWN. THE TOTAL DAMAGES I AM SUING FOR IS $8000. PLEASE SET A COURT DATE AND ADVISE. THANK YOU. ~I?~ HURD P. ANSTADT SEPTEMBER 8, 1998. ~f ~ r/I1/18 ~ '. :::.-) C) n '/) -} ; . ;'1 -,:J -:i :":'1 1:-:') ~.J jC) . 'j :f] ~.? C) <- .71 (0 ~:'.:: ( ~) :,0 -.-,;,: ,: ...- .... I'VS~j I 0 pi)qn ClJmborI ,1ncl CotlnLy I'roLhonoLilry'fl nrric(! Ci v i I Cil!-W I nqtl i ry !')!JII O~:u~ IINS'I'M)'I' II I JIm I' (vs) CIIPI'I'III, 'l'IlEE f< NI1HSEIIV Hnfol~OIlC'n No..: CaBo 'I'Y\H~.... .: ^PPI':^l, --. n.1 ./tldqrnctl .. . . . . . : .00 ,lllrltJe ^nB j{Jnod: III SIll.HHHI lleRe.: ~--------- CARD CommonLR .--'.------ I,tj lurl........: 'I' t.m{~. . . . . . . . . : Exoctll.lon DilLe ,J U I'Y 'r I~ i f1 ) . . . . Il! RPO~(!(! Oil LC: Iflqlwt Crt. 1.. Ifiqher' CrL 2.: 7 12H/1 ~)90 lL: Or, 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 A'~J*k*Ak**~*********J*****************J'kk**k*'*k**'****'*****k***k********."*** C:onnrill Indox IILLor.nny Info JlN:i'I'MI'I' JlIJllIJ I' 2:1 I!i Pllm: S'I'H1':E'I' CIIMP lilLI" I'll 1701 I eM'1 'I'M, 'l'IlEE " NI1HSERV 'IliA NISSEl.. l..IINE NI':W C1IMI\EIH,IINI1 I'll 17070 PI.IIIN'I'IFJo' IlI::Jo'~:NDMJ'I' NOLL FRIINKLIN WIll ~~'~***jk'k*****************************************************************k*** · \lill.,~ EnLri.cR * 'A~"**k*******************************************************'*'**'*********** "J/ 20 /199 B lAP PEAL' ["I{OM i;rs'rRIC'J' - ;)US'I'ICrl~~6G~~~~V, CIIPI;I;II[, TRE:E - & - NURSERY - - - ONLY IIPPEM.TNG 'I I 2 R I 19 9 B/;~~~~~~~ ~~~ ~ ~~~~~ ~ ~~~~~~?~ ~~~~~ ~?0~~~~~'E:: 0~~~~~~~ ~i'~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~ ~~ ~~ B/05/ 1 !19~s/~CER'I'IFlCII'I'E OF SEHVTCE -------------~-------._--------------------------------------------- fl/27/l99'/~~~~~!0~':_ ~~':~~~..~~~~~_.._..___....__ __ __ __,.."" ,_,..,___n"_n ___n__ ....'.' 'ot I ~ ~ ::~~::: Or ~~;~~I~~~i.~~ ~~~TRY - OF -APPEARANCE - f.'OR - DEP'I' - BY -FRANKi',IN . WOO NOLL-I I I nO ,.. V I~SQ 12/01/199 a/ PRAECIPE' FOR - WI~'HDRAWA[,-OF" APPEARANCE - FOR - DEF'I' -BY-DANIEL-J-PORUBAN- ~ jESQ 3 I 24 I 19 9 c;/ )REl,IMINARY - OBJEC'r IONS - --- - -- - - -- - n -- _U - - - -- -- _nn__ ___nn_ - -.,,- 9/03/1999~jRAECIp.E-FOR-LisTiN~-cASE-FOR-AR~UMENT-----PLFF-------------------- 12 I 09 I 19 9 ~~ ~~~~~~~0~r.,~~~~ ',~~ ~ ~ ~.~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~~ ~~~ ~~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~ ~~~~~~=~ ~~~~~~~~=~~ 4/l2/2000J OHDEH .. D1I1,'lm 4/12/00 - IN RE DEFENDAN'l"S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO V PL.IIIN'I'] fl" S COMPLIIIN1' .. PLAIN1'IFF MUST IIMEND HIS COMPLAINT WITHIN /20 DIIYS OF ORDER BY GEORGE E HOFFER ,T COPIES MAILED 4/12/00 ' 4/24 120001 PREiiMI NARY" OB:iECTIONS" = - MO'I'ION - TO - STRIKE - OFP-PLAINTIPP-;-S-COMPLAINT RECII\JSE OF LIICK OF CONFORMITY OF LAW AND RULES OF COURT MOTION FOR 'j I 04 I 2 oooli~0h~~~~~~~~~~~~~.. ~:~::~::::::::'::::::::::::::~::::~:::::::::, ~~)"..,.\,,: (1/O'i/200(~PRELIM:rNARY OBJEC'I'IONS ' ,,<:i;: ') I 2 I !211orJ PR^Ecip'r.;-FOR-l~,T.S~,iN~-C^SE-FOR-AR~UMENT-DEFENDAN~' -;-S-PILIN~-OP----'-"-,":;P! AHELTM INIIHY OB,TECTIONS STII'l?ING 'rHJI'r PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT DOES NOT:/", CONFOHM '.1'0 RUL,BS OF LIIW AND LACKS SPECIFIC'l'Y - BY HURD P ANSTADT,,:'>:,;;: - - - - -.. - .."- - -"'- - - - - --- -- - --- - -- --.' -- --- ---- - - - :...._--- - --- - - --------.-- _.:.-._':....;~..:.':.,:;':.;.;,',\: IO/l1!2000 EXHIBJ'r "II" 'ra COMPLIIINT - GENEHAL POWER OF A'l'TORNEY . ',,',,;;:, - - " .. .. - - - - - - - - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - - . - ,. '-, - - -....j.i;;tji kA. "k -A it- "Io.""'k"k * * *- * * * * * * * * * * 'r.: * * * * * * * * * *'k * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ** * * * * ** * * * * * * * * * * * **'ir**'*:* ***;*,~::[;2/ " Escrow In [ormation ,>,';\"~~( . Fco,; " Df!b,iLs Beq Hal Pvmts/Adi End Bal.,,' ,',',*'....({".. It"k iI." ,.,"* * * * 'k* ** * * *** ** * * *** * * * * *** * ~ * ********* ***** **** ** ***** * *****************",,*'*":.::!i1(i ~:~::?~M~~~"^L 3: :!I 3::11 !!\,;~jlll , , 'j'c)'.i~t:'1~t~~t~t,~:~~~;'~' I'YS~IO Pilqc ., .. Climber"' illld COlllILy I'r"oLtlOoolil ry' H Of I' 1('0 Civil CiIHl' InrJlliry I'J~'1l 01.1:l1 ANS'/'^,)'I' J/IJIlfl I' (v,,) CAP/'I'^,. '/'IIi':i': /. NIJIlSEIIY I(Plf!""f1(:f! No..: ('tI:I(, II'Y\ln. . . . .: ^I'PI':^', .Jlld'llllf'fl ......: .IlId'lp ^!iH i qnnd: f) i :iPO:il!d I>I~:;C:.: CaBo COlllll1nn I.~i ,)e:1' 1")':1,; ~; . 00 ~i . 00 FI lod. . ... .. .. '1'.1010......... . EXQCIILlolI flate .Jury '/'riil.l.. . . f) i H!)OHCd Dol te. J/lf) lOt" Crt I.: lIiqhlll' CrL 2.: .00 .. ...." ..--- .._- <._- .00 7/28//998 I I : 06 0/00/0000 O/oo/nooo Il,J .00 45.25 15.2~ 'A'kiA*'*i*k****k**********A**A***************A*******"*"'*'*'***'******'*'**' . End of CilRO Information * 'Aii***'****'****,,**,****,****,**,****,**,****,******""*'***'**********"*'*' COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA -. -, COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY JUDICIAL OISTfllCT NOTICE OF APPEAL FllOM DISTRICT .JUSTICE JUDGMENT _,___,_COM~o.~I'~:.".ii~":..-!.2~~_-:..J{~3Y civil 'rerm NOTICE OF APPEAL NOljc~ is given that Ilw .1ppellill1l hil'; filed ill Iht! illJove Court of COllllllon Pleils illl appeal fl'Olll lIlt: jUd(JlIIl!flt rmHltHed by the District Justice Oil Ihe cia Ie imd in the case 111l!I1tiwwd Iwlow. ~D,.-"';-;.-;.'ic~l,"l'\rl'l' ._--------_.,---~.__._._-~_._-- "PDHI:.. 0,. """Il:LL"''''T ClfV I ~~"b~';'t N~.o';~~i~:~; 09-1-02 STA,II: ;1'1" COP. Capital Tree & Nursery 788 Nissel Lane Ne\~ Cumber land 17070 0"''1'11: 0,. JUDG""IIi"'T I'" TH~C""~';:;:--- 7/17/98 Anstadt v, Capital Tree & Nursery CV-0000148-98 TA 19 LT 19 This hlock will he signed ONLY when this notation is R.C.P.J.P, No. 1008B. 11>' ." r CLAl"" NO. PA 19601 SiYflilWffJ of Prot/lunOliJrv or DtJputv If iJppellant WClS Claimant (S(H.' Pa. R.C.P.J.P. No. 1001(6) in action be(of(J District Justice, he MUST FILE A COMPLAINT witllill twellty (20) (lays after filillg llis NOTICE of APPEAL. This Notice of Appeal, wilen received by the District Justice, will operate as D SUPERSEDEAS to the judUlT1ellt for possession ill this case. PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE ITllis section of form to he /lserf ONL Y wilell appellallt was DEFENDANT lso'e Pa, R.C.P.J.P. No, 1001(7) ill action hefore District Justice. IF NOT USED, detach from copy of notice of c?fJpe"J to bo s(!rved upon appollco}, PRAECIPE: To Prothono!U(y Enter rule upon Hurd P. Anstadt , nppellce{s), to file n complnint in this npponl (Common Ple.s No, Name of appel/cl1JsJ 1998-U~~JCivil T L.:J~ erm ) within twenty (20) dnys after serl1"ic{ . appellee(s) entry of judgment of non pros. .......... RULE: To Hurd P. Anstadt Name of apPIJIlt.'fJ(s) igflal/ue of iJPAellaf1t.or his attorney or agent oruoan, Mqu~re (1) You nre notified thut n rule is hereby entered upon you to file n complaint in this appeal within twenty (201 dnys after the date of service of this rule upon you by personal service or by certified or registered mail. (2) If you do not file a complaint within this time, a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WILL 8E ENTERED AGAINST YOU, (3) The date of servicc of this rulo if service was by mail is tho date of mailing, Date: -'ill.:t.Y- 28. .19 98 + K.. COURT FILE TO BE FILED WITH PROTHONOTARY 28. PUl'llgraph 28 sets f'orth u conclusion of' luw to which no rcsponsc is rcquircd. In thc evcnt that a responsc is deemed rcquired, said allegution is denied. Dcfcndunts arc directly responsiblc for the injuries. losses and dumagcs sustuincd by Mr. Anstudt's property insofar us it was Dcfcndants which rcmovcd the trccs in qucstion without proper uuthorization. 29. Paragraph 29 sets forth a conclusion of law to which no rcsponsc is required. To the extent that a response is deemed required, said allcgution is denied. By wuy of further answer, Mr. Anstadt took stcps in un effort to rccoup his losses. 30. Parngraph 30 sets forth a conclusion of luw to which no response is required. In the event that a response is deemed required, said allegation is denied. Defendants are directly responsible for the injuries, losses and dumuges sustained by Mr. Anstadt's property insofar as it was Defendants which removed the trees in question without proper authorization. 31. Puragraph 31 sets forth a conclusion of law to which no response is required. WHEREFORE, Mr. Anstadt respectfully rcquests that judgment be entered in his favor and against Defendants. ' ?N, ~ By: B lock, Esq. Attorn o. 5889 305 North Front Street, Ih Floor P,O. Box 1003 Harrisburg, P A 17108-1003 (717) 237..5526 Date: September 18,2001 Attorneys for Plaintiff 2 HURD P. ANST ADT, Attorney-in-Fact for Jay R. Ansladt, Plaintiff v. CAPITOL TREE AND NURSERY, INC., and JERRY SHAEFFER, Defendants. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : DOCKET NO. 98-4334 CIVIL TERM : CIVIL ACTION . LAW PRAECIPE FOI~ ENTRY OF APPEARANCE TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please enter the appearance of Barbara A. Zemlock, Esquire, and Duane, Morris & Heckseher, LLP, as counsel on behalf of Plaintiff Hurd P. Anstadt, Attorney-in-Fact for Jay R. Anstadt, in the above-captioned matter. All papers may be served upon the undersigned at 305 North Front Street, 51h Floor, P.O. Box 1003, Harrisburg, PA 17108-1003. Date: September 18,2001 DUANE, MORRIS & HECKSCHER, LLP By: Attorneys for Plaintiff ".,,":' ~^,:,:',~:;,.:::;;:::~~~-,~ SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 1998-04334 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND ANSTADT HURD P VB CAPITAL TREE & NURSERY RICHARD SMITH , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within WRIT TO ADD'L DEFEN. was served upon ATCHASON JACK D the ADD'L DEFENDANT, at 1950:00 HOURS, on the 25th day of September, 2001 at 303 HARMONY LANE CAMP HILL, PA 17011 by handing to JACK ATCHASON a true and attested copy of WRIT TO ADD'L DEFEN. together with and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge So Answers: 18.00 8.45 ,00 10.00 .00 36.45 r~~~ R. Thomas Kline 09/26/2001 RALPH TOUCH Sworn and Subscribed to before By: . (c...... me this ~ j' ~ day of 1,,,:1<"'... II.. . JiJa ( A. D. 1/- ( 10, -- !;J7M, I;, -' UfPi I I Prothonotary , ClISE NO: 1990-04334 P SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR '. COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND ANSTADT HURD P VS CAPITAL TREE & NURSERY RICHARD SMITH , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within WRIT TO ADD'L DEFEN. ATCHASON MARl A was served upon the ADD'L DEFENDANT, at 1950:00 HOURS, on the 25th day of September, 2001 at 303 HARMONY LANE CAMP HILL, PA 17011 JACK ATCHASON by handing to HUSBAND a true and attested copy of WRIT TO ADD'L DEFEN. together with and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge 6.00 .00 .00 10.00 .00 16.00 Sworn and Subscribed to before me this ,Hit lr.i,r;",J-. _ dOc! !--) LJ'I'" () J'J.u~&:.... Lj.,~ I I Prothonotary' =r-r day of A.D. So Answers: ..../') // ';:;::''''' J!:;!'C:::-_,~_.,_ ...,p/~ '7 "r.~c-" "'.__o:r_~-4':..E~ R. Thomas Kline . 09/26/2001 RALPH TOUCH By, ~rif;- - ~ - ~ - - --~- - . ~i () /I J ,_/ (0-'l"",,~\ 1.I..-vl 'Y~('A'( .... ( c<.. J ,J!... ()-.s J t-L~ ;; <.o.-I,,~ J W;Lc.(~, /J, j!t[,fc"",J -"~. 'I I /'- "~I ' (..(..'I.".r- .~ Sot'. ,-/. Il-t,:LCL,V J/c((p- !..iL(u 1~- /~ Gu....:L, 1.2/;/ VI -=", :;;;. ~ ~ ~ ~ "".t:)-.::::::: S5:' ~ r-:? Sl...~ ~ ~;:, -....... 0- ;-;s- -+-r:'- ~ <) ~ :.::F' ~ --rl 'r- :A::::,'::'+:"':} d' I 0 "" .c: " :::, ::.- ~ _"::l --0 ~ .-) 7\- ;;;;- ;:-;...:-- ~ ,:)~ :7) D:i> >-. :::) V:> '-- v~ ;;:: ]S'- '-' "Sl- ::J -I- s1 ~ ::s- ~ .., c:J <> ~ >~ c:,....... ,...:\ ~ >c ~, ~ 7< r t': I' i I 1~ L 1 ~, ;' " , ! n:, c::.. ~ ~ ~ .::> (') ~~~~ ~'-' ':':':") ~':'1 r, o (\~ ij.::. ~11L. ~.::'.. ~:"~- r:: t:~ ( ~~:" ,;:~ '-', :.-:. f;:; ct- =~ o .::l:::::, c.~ -',:) f") ~::'l :~~ ,,) r',j