Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-04672 " ,. ~ ~l J j ~j I..., i J " -I' " \1 ". ,. h I' " " " t ,.."" ~,.. " " " " ~ " " ii ~ B ~ 0'1. ," ., " l;;; " " " " ., /, ,,, ';'; ," ..oI" " , " 'Iii ili I, ~ \~ ...... "IW O. '... '-.J ~ " " ':1'-" 1 I . 0. c:::r- , ....t:> ~ ,. " " 1\ H , " !.~ , i\ '" " " 'I' Ii' .' ..I'; " d' " " il' " I' IN TilE CCl\JHT PI" COMf'1'10N PI,lil\S of CI JtvllWH I,'/\NP CO\JN'I'Y, I'IlNNSY1,yI\NII\ sTHYI\N H. STITZ 121 Cirolo Privo Ih1\H1Vllr, 1'1\ 17~~ I CIVIL I\C'TION. LA W PII\II\III1' v' Tln"INc' 1 ~o i\rlllH\\'IlIlIl HOI\I! PilIH\\lll. PI\ IlIMO 1\1111 I{OllllHT I IlJ'I'CI IINSON 7~O MI\Y PllHI Of11oo 1~01\\1 Stl'llsb\lrU..PI\ 17~7() NO, 'I J. 'I i, '(;)'p ('t,',,'( r~,., WHY TIMI, DEMt\NPllP PolOlllllIlllH , I'n,\lli(WIC FOn wlm' OF SIIMMONS TO TllllP1WT1IONOTAIW/C'I,llln, OF St\ID COllin: ellrt LOllu . , IHHllo HIIlllnHllH1 ill troHp"Hs ill tho IIhovo eIlSO, ,_J'L__ Writ oI'S\IIllIll()l\H ror Dorondl\llts shl\lIlw iSS\IOI\1\1l1! lhrwml!edio Sl1erin~ I)l\lo:.__"f1/;!'/.'2'L_____ (="_ L==._LW..~/ .Ienlll~ r ,1<IIIW, IlHquiro 1\lIorl\ I, Ihr 1'II\IIltifl' Supromo courll.D. "()~l)~[) .11 Suulh QIIOOI\ Stroot Yurk, PA 1740:1 (717) H4H"~H~lI , , , t', SUMMONS IN CIVIL ACTION TO: TI~L, 11\0, l\lld Hobort Hutohlnson yOU ARE NOTIPIED TIIAT TllIl A!lOVE-NAMED PLAINTIFF IIt\S COMMENCED AN ACTION AGAINST YOU, ) t.) ------S},~;~~-,;,I~~~-t,i~l1f:ii~(Hi;;;, Dllt\\:,_LlLL,/,WLL__.L{,../iLZl' I (l /' ')'1 ,,' , lY -----~'fV"-lL'o~_c..(~-- _~lj:~:______ , Doputy " SHERIFF'f;3 OFFICE 7'/'1\../) flr1PQ~a~'I~I:::;t~~~~1~:I~~~rii~I'~J:~I';::;::~I~^I;'1'1'1 \, I 'l'I"""YI;~~~rf#~lg~W~I~~gI!WIv~---~ . "-.., .., , ,. , .... ,. U ,. d'_ ..~._....._-N...T_9EIA_tl.A.N.Y.".._flEl:!L"_'_a " I'tAlljiWliiii' '-'.. ---.. , ,., " -, . , (lourll NIIMIlI'II /3'.!'IWIUN IU, I3'l'I'l'(\ 1990...04672, ,. [IWfV;Ri^NTjHT-'-'~""-". ...- --.-..., ,",. ;f' fyji(i)TWiin"'lj'I"O()-Mi'l.Aii'if-- --.-,......----_-,_ ~R~r INO, ~ ROONHT "U~a"rNI3QN ~UMMON~ 81i--V~.---... "'-niiij;1Ciifi@iVlffiJii,'ITiit;W7iilY,-oliiiJiiITi^'fi(lfi'illr. :10'1I: 11I'IVi I> ...... - . . ....-- - , .--......-.________.._", ~ {...lA~Uim~~~;hJ~~~;~I~{{~J~I~~,il.i1,I:(jil~'IT"ii,;l iil,',ai"iiiliiiii Iii' I:,i~iil ..h. ..-, .. - '-.. .-..-- , .. .. - h_... """_'_.___ ~ ~___1E.Q... MJl\!_foa.'LCl.~' ~~ J: qr,1_ R D -!.LI:!'!~!~~.S .!3.l!IW! .['.r\..J.1~.~.~ __... ,,_ ".._....____ "__.___ ~ 7 INoICIAl/! lJNlJlilJAI alillVIOIL 1I0/lPlJTlll I) 01111.11 t;j ---.---..~....._-..--.---.. -"'-- ..-..----.--. . ..-....... '-- .,-.. ..-,.... -----......--.. .......-- .------------ (II Now, -.-....-..--...-- 19 ---... ,I, 81f~nlFl' OF I-ANOA8rt:n OOUN'fY, I'A" Iln horallY II0PIIII/!p \110 8horlll 01 0 --- ----.....-.....--........-.....---- OO'II1IY 10 exoollle 11110 Wrll olul nmlw rOlllln thorpn! onoorc1lno 121 to IIIW, Thin Il0pu\nllol1 1I0lng IlWlo nllho rOlllloll1 nnd rlok ollho plnlnllll. ..'...____...........__... ......._h......._...._........__..._......_~ 0' QPonl^I, I N ~TiiffPfipN1iDii-~TII on 1f<<'0 li~fAfiplffl'A T WnT^ijillijf1ff'~xj1wlfmQifpi\viil~ i" ....Jill Ill! LQlH!)gl~!ULL~."~~ ...,___:,... ....,.:....._.~_. Non pN~Y I\IlP~IQAo~o ON WIlIT OP oXanUTloN, N,o, WAIVoll OP WATOIIMAN.. A"y ".P"IV ah."" 10VV'llg "po" u, IIIIIIohl"g 'OllY P"'P.'IY "nc'.' 'Wllhlo W"I II1"V 'oov. ,"",. Wllho"l" Wlllp'""~", '1\ oli'lm'vol Wh"m.vol"'olI",I'''I"","..I",,, oil'" ""IIIV'lIlIllo,"""\II'.vv '" 011,,111".1\1. wllh""IIIII"'IIIY "" lllp IIlHl 01811011 clOllUIV or Iho shollll to Anv 11101111111 hotllln lor mw lou, 1I08Iru(1110(1 or Iflflluynl 01 fillV IItwh IH(ltIlIlIV htllolO 811u1UI'9 8"10 WOlllul O. QIQNATUAP olATTOANH III "1Iii>'OiifnINATiijf~-'-"-----:"'----]'O T/li.'fiiiTIifjfiWWil'll - -ITI,IlATt.:------~- OIJ~~Q~~~~r~o ~~'tieAVIOO, iffiJ>y TP"NA, Mo1No AOP-fi~BB~riii(OW'.:.IT!iJ' ~ilii"iiiiiil "~~~I;I;'~iWn,lIlrool',I.~' mnfii"dl 8- ~ 2-9~__~;-_,_ :~(il~l~r,b'lm 1\ l<r,ll'lrn ,ffl,9Q I\'J' H. IUUIOT l<fI'l'l!liUNI\I'l rnSQ , 31 8. QUmrnN ST. I YOR!<, PfI 17403' " 8P,\OgjjtLOW -p"offU!!!tQf.J!!:1gi]IEP ON.bY~:::::'P.Q:NOfW.nIIrJ!l;!.Q.w..Il:l1!l!J ---- I:J.' IIoknowl.,IUII'.OOlI'1 ollho WI!I I NAMo 01 AII,"orllll!I, ~OBO Oorll'~ 0' G,mk , 14, Onlo floo.lvod or oomflllllnlltR lndlonll.ld nLJuyu, , ;---. ' , "---,lUDY.-NOHR,t,s...2.9S-.3609_"h_.__..__._.-,a~..J..ll..g 10.1 hOlohv Oa[ITIFY Mid fUiTU'IN 'lllIII f1 hnyo IHHbUI1!lUv 81UVpd~ hl\YO lounl o~l(lnlloo 01 fl~rvlco n8 t'ihOWfll/l "'!Ornntkll",[ I havo Oll:oouloll nil ahown In -nUIllIUkli-, In WIll 01 oOIl1f1ln III ( ooorlhollllll Ihu Indlvtdulll, IJ0I11lJUIlV, o,orJlo/11101l, ole,/ (111111.1 {HldroQu atHlWI1 II JOy" or 0111110 Indlyldll"l, OO'"IHHlV, Oaf- pOlntlon, file" nllho IldclW8h IIlSIUlnd bulllW hy I1(UH,'11111 n lUlIt! nllll A n~8T1m 001_ y Ihol{lu . ,_ i/:i1ii1.,.~V oO'I!lViii,ill.h"" II Norf:OUiijj h.Ollll'O 101" IInohlo 10 100.10 Ih~iii;jjY"I"ni;";.~m;;~~-v,-;;;,;;o.;;jj;;;~~i-;;:;m,,"o'l ."hoyo lB.. ,om.lko hol.WI ., I B, NIII1111 A'''I 11110 nlln'"VI"',o" ''''.Y.'I-i~liOiDiiow,i-"ij{JVOI iTiiIIAllnnO'iii'ii;1iOi0iiiionll---"---'-j I U, 1..1110 a",~",-'''-- , ' ""b)J',I n (l.1J ../:1.vr.cfUM::t!tIL.::.... (.!1:mj~L____n_..________,..___......_.._.. ..._...-~ll1onl4lk.'''''"' 1110, 301 "l/.Ad(J;(I1'r 1f!WllOIU flQIV(IfI(o "1111'!.'. nnly II \lIIfU:Oyll hr'\IlII(Jwr~III){)VOllaIIOOI 01 f1F(),^lll11ItnoIIINo.,Clly, Uoro, Twp. 2 I. PRIO,Ol80rvlCO 22, ,limo S'AIOIIO'I~If100<llll,I'7I() tV/1fr1.,\r , ( rt,q", , " It'1111(~_VT 1.,\ e '4 I!I;I'O , f"lq ,qt ' ~..rO, ~3. AmMPT~ 'Rl~"I\t~ ~\J~t9 J ,~~~.. !)~'~~lno'~j MlfD'J~~ll' 11I"fla'O I Mli"J"P.I"" P'I~ II.. ".~4, AllVAn.o On8'8 ~ 4~ 26, SOIV!OO G"'I'J26' NnlllIVCO'I'J' 27, MII~" oIP", !lI~H, 120,lo'"IOn., 29, C08TOII' Q lFllHP, ~.9,!1, 237 ~L9~_._.___ ....~91_....5_0.".n_('71 'nT,.......~---,.-.r;;-;.-/ . ~ . .1...3 7~ff_ c,;;l... (J ~ : 'l'.oAfiMAnKB',...[rl~2.0 -'{II)' I; .\.I,~:l\.L<-7,lIJ,'RU " cl<:tF/~4~7 B~~ .J ?; i;J,.'1~9' , 31. A1TIIIMI,11 ",11' .u~" I/hll" 111 hlll.'~ 1110 '''I~ _L'Z ~~---=- - '-~i ^NJW~UI;;'I: 3~ Bill"""" 0' ~ ~ nOlI 101111 ~. '34'~'.~III. -----:-- ~'i-,y",~- J~ 1I1,:'~~:!.r.iiii' .\ _::; . , . . . '/--!- ,1 ,I. pr' I, ""~JJ1- ~ ..,..c. 31 ,- Toi"'''n''iii' "1>>...' -/.---.... ----- -- :tIij~~ LAfiIIlatll 00 MV OOMMIBOION txp.!l!!ill..__, _' , _ ' 30.1 AOKNOWlWOli n~Clil"T or l"~ 8"~r,IPF'Q naTIIAN blaNATUnn I ' Of AIJ1lfOnIZIW IBall I'!.<:l AlJlII0I1ITV Ai) T!!!:!!c.____-L.__.___~.. w'tT i" ~n j 11~ ~,O\1n 01 L0l1111101\ jJI~t1S 01 L\linl)~I'It1I1l\ LO\lnl}, IJlll1nS~'IYill1li\ 'I' ' B~flvpn \':, HU~" VS, 'l'IlI'1 J:1\O, , 13\:, Al" BrJl:VP, llolJ01:\: 1I11~r;i1jnaon l\ No" UO-~67~.ci.v,i.l _I?_ Now, U(.1 '7/UU 19__, I SI1ERlff Of ~V~I\1EHl-ANP COlJNTY.l',-\ (10 110rQh~'IIQP\ltlzo tho Shorlffof Ijl11\PAa ~P':_Collnf)' to O~ao\lto this Wrll, this c\aplltntlol\ !lolng 1110(10 I\f ilIa ra9\1asf 01\(1 risk oJ Iho PlolnflIT, ~~~~~~ - shorlffofCUlHhorlond COllnl)', Pn, " .i' Afflc1I1YI\ 0 r Sel'vlce " NQW, \9 ,,01 0'01001, ~I, se,r\'o(l fha within IIpOIl M h~' hondhlg fO rt IrllO ood ono5!Qdcor~' oflho original, olld lIIddo kOllwnlo , fho cllnlent5 thoreof, " SQ 1l1lmer5, "" ,... " Ii. " Sherlfr of COllllf~', po, COSTS " S\lotllllllU stlbscrlbod bofore mo Ihls dllvof , 19~ SEIWlC( ,IIILE.-\Gi: MTI~,.\ I'IT s " " ~--- I' " ,';~-;'P . " " ",;1 I"" ,,' ,I' Ii s /I " " " " ,. " !' ,. " " " " t; ';, " "'-", " " ", I' " ;1. d' " " " I( " , , ," ,; , , ,n 1.:'_0.,_ , , " \ J " , , 1,,- .. I : , I , " 1 ,-j; "'j .. 'Il , ; r'l , ;:.I IL " .. " . ". ,. ,. I' ,'iI " " "j. " ,. "" 1/'" " " .. I' " .. " 1-" "'1 , '1 " " , ,. !: " " ,. " ;. H .. 'I " " '\ " " I' , ,. ".; I', " " " "I' ." II, ,. " " ',t" ,! ',.\, j, C') \ f~' "') I': CU ~fl I' I;') ',' 'ili,'.! , ') :,::q PJUI !.., "'r' ,i .1 I "'"JJ " l,i\J" i " ('.' I , , , :C) t! I tOO I':/) " (' "-,, '-_"-'_1' , .' , , , . ; ,-'ii'fl , C.) .- 1.,.',j , . ~_J;~.: ! . :."J ,~ '''0 fn ", .' ,I' '(i r.\ I'II~I IIIHlllilllr~ln~~ nl' lifu'~ ~l\ipYl1\ullt; p, 11II~11l1l1! IIllllru ill~illuIlII\1 pn~ls; i(, 1'lIs1 lIIHI IIillIru Inss nl' lll\l'IIlnll~ 1lI111 ~nrnillll unpn~IIY; 1lI1\1 II, 1~IIl\SPl1nhlll 1II1\lllUUU~SIlI'Y ll\~diclll !lXpCIlS~s III uXU~~s nl' Ihc sll\IIIIIII'Y I1ruullI~lnl1, I If, /Ih\/nlifl'lI\'ul'S Ihlll hi~ IInll\lIllU~ !JXCCUlllhc IIppIICI\\llc li111ils ol'nrhl!rlllipn, III1I! Ihcrulhrc, 11.1111)1 Irlllll~ hurohy Ilu111111111uII, W'"1IWIIOHI1, 1'llIil1lll1' r~spuullIllIy rllqll~sls ,hilI Ihls IlPllnl'l\lllu COIII'I Ol\lur .illlllllllulll 1I!1111nst l>uful1\llIl\I 111111111111\1\1111 il1 \lXCCS~ nl' $25,01l0,00, phl~ un~t~ IIIHllllloru~1 liS pOI'll1111!J\1 hy I,ll\\', , ' I, COIIN'I' II STICVICN IC, STITZ v, IlCllllCH'I' 1IlJ'I'CIIINIlPN 1~, l'III'II!!l'lIph~ I throll!lh 14 II~ suI fpnh IIIHIVll nru illCOrp\.lrnlol! horoill hy rolurollco Ihurolo, 16, lJufolHlnllt rupoII\U\lIy slrllck thu 1'0111' ol'l'llIinllO'~ wl1lclo inlulHllng In 11\111111111110, 10lTClrlzu IIlld it\illl'u hll11, nl\d with lI\1ur diRl'olllll'l1 fpl' PIIIII1UIf,R Rllfoly, I'lghls IlI1d hOllllh, "WillllWF01W, 1'11111\1111' rospuult\llIy I'llq\lo~ls this Ilnl\omhlo COlin to on\or.illdgl11U111 ngll/I1M! lJul'olHlllIlI Hnhofl H\ltul1lnHon in 1111 IIl11nllll! III O~OOHH nf $25,000,00, plll~ IlltOI'OHt nllll cOSI~ 11M pormlHod l1y lillY, 17, I H, COIlNT III 1'l'1'IC\'ICN IC, STITZ v, !tOlllCln IIlJTClIlNSON Pnmgl'llphs Ithl'o\lgh 16 ns RU! 1'01'111 nhnvo 111'0 Illcol'pol'lltnd 1101'0111 hy rofol'Qllco thel'oto" hUuudod to hnrl11 PllIlnWT. ' WllERllFORfl, Plnllltln'dolllllllds pUllitivo dlll\lllllUS IhlllllJufundl\lll '~ohorllJijlohh\snlllll nil nll1o\ll\t 'i" AlIllctlulls lI1ldorlllkol) hy IJulul)dllll\ \VUI'U Ollll'llguo\ls, \Vlllltnll, \\'illnlllllld I11l\lIolnllS Illldwote iI; ,1 .. ~, \'urt:hor\npro, Hlllo l019(f) 01: t.ho ponnllylvnnln \~1I1op of civH prpo(Jfhn~p rDfl\l,lrpll 1:111\\: IlnVllr\l\Pn\:n 'pF t,jmD, plnOD Anll H:oml3 of ",PDolfll rlnmnrjpfl \>11n11 \)0 Ilpn\)l(:,i.OilllY fl\'.nt:olll1, Ii, \11nlnt.IFCI'l' (.lpmpl/dnt (Warp thl\\: plAln\:H;I' wnl'l lnj\n~act in n motor vohlpla ilooJQOnt wIth f\ trllo~ pwnOQ by Qofandnnt TR~ An~, Qr.jvan by TAL'p omployoa, Robart lllltoh1npon, Q\la to tha nOrjlirjont nnCl/or lnt:ant.tollill not:p of c\ofol1(li\nt llllt:oI11I1pon, lit \1lnlnt!.rfs, 1n tl1a,\.v COlnpllllnt, fAH to !'lat fort:11 tha mA t:ar in 1 f AO\:(~ LlPfll1 wh ,j,ol1 tho 1 r ai\\ll.'W Of Ao\:lol1 io \1nl'\3(I. FII!:'tl1or I plaintiffo fnllto !'lpaolClcally othto nV13rmont:o Of tlma/ plnpa anQ ltom~ of I'pooli\l di\mi\goo. 7. Tn. COllnt IV of tho r,on1P.].ldn\:/ plidnt:!rFI' AVOr thnt clofonQllnt: '1'm" Wll8 nag HeJant j n 1 tl' hldneJ of ctoConctnnt 1I\1tohinflon t ill, In COllnt: IV of the compli\1nt, pli\lnt.IFfl'l pllrpovt to aver that elofonc\nnt 'l'lU" i8 Hnble to plnlr\t;.l.I:f: in nctuAl i\ncl pllnitiv13 clnmi\gal'1 I'1lnoa it lI~naW or al1ol1lel hava knownll thllt At the time 'l'RL " ," hira(1 llutohincwn thAt he WII8 llnf'lt for the :10)). i'li.lint!ffs further a 110ge thnt 13 ince '1'H!, Wi1fl lI11tl:h inoon' s employer and he wal'1 acting w,i.thln .tho Elcope of hlp employment at the \:.Imoof tho IIcoic1tmt:, 'l'R} lp' )~130poIWll)10 'fal~ itu cldvOl~'U IIl1ocf1.l.gant ancl/eJr in1:ent~,pnal COllduct. II 9. COlll)1: V of pln.lnt:JI'l'n' campl/dllt: l.l1oorpornt:oB'Al.l of the I'nct.lHI~ i\V01~m0l1tEl muclo' in tho campl/dnl: nnd 110sert:13 thai: 'l'nL'fl cOl1dual: I.n hirl.ng l\utchinuol1 ,lnd porm.ltt,lng hIm to ddvo 1\:8 t:ruok wnEl lIout:l'l1goouo,uwnnl:on, vlillfll) uncl mul1ed.ol\l3l1. 10 t I'ln IntI f'f'fl' I1Val"l11onl:11 1\l'0 objocl:Ionablo l3il1oe tl1ny f~il 1:0 Eltl1l:o vd,t:h upoo,j 1'1 city hDW '!'HI, l1hl111lcl hoVe known, l\POI1 hiring ,. ~ 2 - \:lIn\: IIlI\"ol1lnu~)11 \~iln II\lnflt I'or tllo job 110 \~nIJ 111lcorl \:0 pOI:forl11, " (PomrlnJI1t: nt pnrnqrnph ~O,) n,' l'lldnl:ll'f'fJI nvprmo'i1t:iJ IlnJ nlBo olJjoot:lonnplo Illnon \:l1oy f'nU \:~ Q\:/lto W.t\:11 Arool t~loj \:y ho\~ 'I'HI. ol1o\llct I1AVo Known pr.j.,QI: to \:110 ,{ ntllqont In rj\lOu\:,jon "11\1\:011 Inl10n 'Ii oont i,llllotj prol'lOnOn on tl1n job roppe! n r.lnnC]PI;' of 11<11:11\ \:0' tl11rci pot"pOnU," (Oompl,nJnt: n\: pl\1cl\t:wnpl1 n,) l;l, +n Ooullt +V I 1.n pnl'tJOlllnr \:)]0 \tlllm'~F01WJ plnul'lo, !Inri In Oount VI p1nintlf'fp nllogo thnt po fondant ~~Ll1holllq bO<1npool'!od pllnJ\:lyo Qnll1nl]pl'!, lIowoV01:, plIl1nj:1ff hils 1'/,110(1 t:o ppoaif,Jol\Hy fltnto, 1n ~lotldl, tho n1,lorJod fnotn l1pon wl11ah tl11.fol a1nJI1\ Ja bnl1a~li ,. ~lol:01y r.1tn\:Jnq th,\t 'I'HJ" 1111 II\ltol1 J.f1(1or.' a DmplOyol" la V ianrJo\lsly llnblo for his natJona 1n not ono\lgh, rho ct90trtno 01' ropponqollt folLlpodor qool'! not: ho1c1 nn 0l\\p10yor rosFonsJ.I)lo for J.t13 omployee'!> , Jnton\:10I1n1 nota \~hJQh '11'8 boyond tl)6 aOllras nnc1 SOOp13 of I1Jl'I omploymontl Llnlosp tl1srs io oomo fnotual ballis for sLloh 1\ olnim, PlnJn't:Jfl'a' a1nlm IlllflllppOl:tod by spe:::.lf!a fuot(l .ts .tmproperly Pl.Ol'ltloc\ , 13, PlilJnt:Irfs 11llVo f,dlod t\1 Olll:.'Jtllnl:iilto t:ha bl'l!l.tI'1f.ol' t:he 011'1 J1I\13 I'O!." , pllnH:lvo cl'lmllCJOB, PlilInt.::'fo hi1Yo mOl'ely sat f.o):th bo.l.lo1: ,pInto 1\1logntJonfJ wlthollt :lny .l.nfOI:mnt.ton, 14. 'I'ho n1.1t1C]lIt.l.olls mndoln cOllnt' :1/ ot' pln.l.ntlffl'1' COlllp1.nint IIn) II1Dll1:'f',jO.t.ont 1:0 nplJl" If.lL' dOfnnd,,;'.: 'J'HI" oj' tho basia' of subst:ant.tVe f.aotUlIl , ,pln.l.nt.il'l'e' cl1n.t.m for l1lHJ1.iqont hId Ii,: anti ol1tl;\lstll1ont: so ae to" al1ab18 TRL to IIdogl1nt:oly pl:OpnrD II c1ofe~Bo to thess o1.aims, - :l - I,AW PFFIPt:~ OF OAMPflli~~, P'I<t:IiFIi, NO~AN /lI PA~Y flY; Itln.lm!\ J, 'Vnylor, Jr" 1'lpCllliro AlIllrn~y I,P,Nll, ~4'/6i! Thp Pllrlla O\II1!pr, ~\illn o;w Wnhllll Il\fPPI III '/111 S\fPPI flhlllltl~lfllll", flA 101!Hl 1i!16Ioi!O'4111111 flltOPf11l ATTOI1Nf:Y 1'0111 Pnfpmlnnl 'J'HI., 1110, nllel I\P\)OI~\:. IlLlI:ohillson vp, I' COUH'J' 01,1 OONNON,' PL1W~ , OUMUC1Hl,ANP COUN'~'Y , 'NO. )D90,..046n I, illJBY 'J'IUl}1L-llliMAlilllill " /:l'J'1WC1N I~ ,fl'N'J'P, nnr1 J '~l\I'l a'J'I'J'iI, 'J'BJ.<, :mo,nl1\l HO'31~IW ItU'l'oIlHl/:lON Ml'lM.QllliliIllULQE...1JMLJ.fLJll!1~ll'LQ1L1UlFlnillllN'I' Tnt.. INO.t...Ul l'.IU1.YIMIllll.R.'LQM.N~IQNfL..!ffi_ELl\J;mF..F.fl..-'-.QQmlU~ ' Mov.i ng clofondnnt, IJY allc1 thl:Ol\gh 1 ta lItt:ornoys, cnmpboll, Ol\<oofn, !'l,)Jnn ~ l)nly, fi1'os t:hn attnohecl PrOUmin1H'Y Objeat:iOlll'l t:o pla.intl.ffs' complaint: In\sing Hs objeotions on aeVerlll groUl1c113 mOl~e apeolfionlly c1ollnontec1 hereaftor, For tho ran sons stnted heroin, 1110v.l,ng clafane1i\l1t: raspootfLllly raqua!'!l:a thls 1I0nOrllbl13 Court t:o I'lust:a.l,n its Proliminllry Objaot:.l,ons, I . MO~'ION._.'l'Qjl'.!'lU..lill_F..QIl...l!lI.Q]{ 01' OO.NF.!lliM.I.'!'X-T.9.JJ\lL.Qll RillIFl OF' OOUR'l2 Ponnsylvi1nil\ HUles of clv.tl PI:ooac1l1ro, Bllle 1.020(11) (2), alloW!,! 1\ pQl:ty to f.l1o prol'imJ.nl'\l:y Objoot.l.oll8 1.n t:h81lI1tlll~e of a mot.l.oll t:o I'ltriko 11 plsading boonuss of laok of aonform1.ty t:o 1111'1 or rule of oourl:, " l'enI1Sj;lvi1n1.11 HUlas of CJ.v.i.J 1'1"000(1\11:0, I\UI,o lO1.9(a) requJ.res that mnter.i.l1l [i1ata upon IvhJch /1 CnllBO of not.loll 113 based to be 8tntaQ, in il 001101ao nnd Sllmmt\l'Y fal"m, FllI:t:hClrmOl~(l, HUla 101.9 (f) of the l'onl1Pylvnnln Hlllon or CJ.vll Pl~0(Jocllll:0 rogl1Jrofl tlli1t "I1Vet'mants, " a/' t!.ll1P, pll\ClP tll1c\ H:pmp 01' upcw!.nl clnll1f1lJou UI1il1l 11D ppoaHloqlly fltntDcl," Ac\c1!.j:'\'onn11y, i1 c\ul'ondnnl: lu [.lnt:II:lm~ j:p 11c1 [IIIPp1.jpcl wlj:11 ~HlI'f'lpjon\:. inf.ormt\j:.loll nnnl1l1nu .j j: 1:0 IqloW wl1nt \~.Ill ll[.l nj: JPflllO At j:l1o j:ril11 01' j:11I:1 onup, lid!] fnllc1i:jnl: Ifl j:o bel 11pprJUUC\ PI? , \:110 1"~\llPfl , wl1Joh w.j.ll 11P l,jj:J(jI\I:o[I, 1300 fl..mitIL'L,_-:J~_nOllll.\:1 __I'AI ~\lppr, !jlJO lI';lcl 130lJ (100l) I Mm:rlY-Y_1_.J~gjJ.!hl~1 ,'1P/iO ?cl on (10BG), J:n tl1P OAI10 II\:. IJln', plnJnl:itrl3 I1/1VO f.nUpcl 1:0 oPlnply 'wJth INl13 103.!l(1\) nn[l (f) or \:l1p 1'01111f.1ylvl1nJII HII10p 01' o.j.YH 1'1,00Pcl\1+p, spoaHJonllY, pll\!.ntiff.B I:nJ1 I:p 130j: f.orj:ll \:,110 Illntprin). fl\ott:l uppn \~I1!.oh 1:l1oy l)fHHl j:l1oir PI111l30 o/' l,a~Jon I1Cjnlnf'J~ mQVlllCJ (.\pf.onclllnt:, \'Ill't:1101'H1oro, pll1Jnl:if'r.u hllvo 1:11118cl ~o I'lppalflol111y [31:1\t:0 l1yormonl;l> of t:Jmo, plAOP find itomu of. upoalnl cl/lH1I1CjOf.1, 1'1i:11nl:lf/,[3, In COllnl:l,1 J:V i:1ncl V, i:111aCjo tl10y nro ontit:).oe\t:o IIn m~Ewc\ oj: pllnJ\:.lvo c1nll\I1CjOf.l, 1I0WPYcu', pIn illt] I: fEl hAYo 1:ld.locl to Elat for.I:11 flllffioionl: fEWI:f3 ~o efl~lIbl..jf.1h t:hl\t: tha n11(1)0c1 pOndllOt: hy moyinCj clofanclllnt: TH~ H1Bril:s BIIOh II olnIH11 , Plaintiffs nuurirt:, withollt aett:lnCj forth q fnatUAl bA~i~, t:hAt 'I c1afene1l1nt 'l'Hf..I 13, aonc1l\a\: wnB Ilol\\;rngaollo, WAnl:an, willfUl IIl1d 1l11'\J..loiolls," (Coll1l1,lninl: COI.II1\: V) Pllllnt1ff~ Bimply qllage thl\t 131noo lI11tqhlnr~on'f.1 IIH:ol1\:.loni\l aonduot: WI,\(l l'I11oCjBc11y Iloutr/:\geOlll3, wnl1tol1, w.llll:1I1 nnct mi:111oJol\B" i:1nc1 110 1'100 TilL'S 13mployo13than TilL 18 Vloodol\f3I'y J'(lppono,iblo' I:O}' Illntl1tont:,ionnl 1101:101\13, l"lIrthar, ,ploJI1\:.l1'1' illlorJ13o' i\fjid 11 Idtl'loul: il bilnlU In I: II a\: thnt ~I'Hr., sllould Ilovo )mown thut IllltahinfJol1 wiln "llnfJt:" for tho job unl! hil3 c1\:iving "poom) 0 dnl1'Jol" oj' IHU'111 1:0 tilt l.'el ))01.'130n8, ", ... 'J ... ,. ,. . , '" In' f,!lI\itlL..Y-l..-._I1l:ill'lll, _.__...___ I'n, /11I PO l' , ___.m.._' 11;1:1 fI,2cl 74~ (1.0110), tlw I3llpodor pOllle\; l1Plcl \:hnt: 1\ plldn\:lj:f'p compllllnt mLlflt f1llpatnn\:itlto \:hll\: \:110 pondllo\: I)y tho Qofonclnnt:p WilP "Q\l~:n,goO\Hl" \:0 f1llpporl: R olillm for pllnitlvo dilmngoQ, In f,!l\Iith, 1:110 (Jollrt (~~lnl)l:HjO\lt;nlCJ(lOli/3 oonc1\\o\o, ;.I," foHQWl31 (In p/3opntinl fno\: nooc1od t9 f1llppovt: a oJ.nim for puni\:lvo dnmagofl iflthnt 1:110 c1afanc1clllt' 101 oonc1llo\: m\1/3t 111.\'1(1 boon O\1\:jeAgUOUp, o\1j;rngeollfl 09nc1\-10\: ifl nn 'ROU dona wit:11 \:he bOd motiv13 or wi\:11 t"po!llp/3f1 imU ff'13rOnoa to t,ha In\:arop~ of o\:hol:!'l,' I'ooh t VS-L Hnhnnrl, 1'/), SupaI'. , ;l611 A,;lcl 157 (1970) oiting pamm13nt p to sooo of t:ha HOflt:nl:omont:' of 'I'ortcl, 'Rook1oflp indifforonoo to the lntereatof ot:herfl' or 1\13 it ia (lOmo timel'l' reforV13c\ \;0 "wAn.ton miflOondUct,' moana thnt 'tho aCtor hAP ,i.n~ontIonr.111y elano I\n Act of lllWl3l1flOnab1o OhI11'lIctor, in e\.l.aregard of A riak known \;6 him or ao obvioufI t:hnt ho mua\: bo tAkon to have been aWnro of it:, nnd 00 groat: aa t:o mnke i\:hl.ghly pl'obal)lo thot 11llrm will follow,' E.YnlL-.....YIL..__I11~' T.r.illlllPOl:tntlou.....Q2-t., 1'", Supet'. :l1.2 1I,2c\ 440 (1961;), JJj at 74(i/ aoe a1f10 .BlliL'l"._MQ.D~imn, ti06 I'a, 3U3, <lOti 1I,2q 74:1 (l!l!l4) , In flm.i:tll, the oourt oono1ucjocl \:hn\: a ComplaInt whioh mej;alY pltH\da oon01uf.1Ion 113 not aUf'f'.i.olont to pupport n claim .fat' punitive " I " " c1l1ml1goe whqt:o p1nInt.i.ff hnp not: pIm\ nny fnota .indlol1tJng ~\hat thr.1 dofondnnt:' f.l oontluot: W1W olltrn,'.:1oo\lIJ, Int:hoclnl1o,nt: In\l', thoro 1\l00 no allb<]ot.i.oncol In thls Complaint \~hioh WOllld 11\11)))01:1: 0 oln 1m t:hnt: tho l111egocl actions of. 'l'HL Were .. porformoLl wIth n bOll mo\:Jvo or 'WIt:h l'oul~lt1l'lf.1 ind1rfarenoe tb \;ha JnI:Ol'Ofll: 01' ot:hOl'B, In I'nllt:, pLdnl:tf'f'a hl1VO fi'\.i,.lod to at:atle allY , " - :,\ - " " \'.\0~13 o1'c~of13nr1nn\: ln thn\: l'oCjIH'cl, '1'l1n\::\ p, tl)Cl 1)Q,I.l,13rpJnl:P nUp\1f\\;lon!'J inOollnt~1 IV .\I1c1 V <10 not: ~lpopHl(J,ll)'( Appril3p 'l'IU.. qf till'! i1)lorjacj P"oncll1pt: wl11011 WDulcl I3UPPPI:t: II plll.lm 1'01: r~miqv(l r1 AnH\\J 0 fJ , (If] f:PI' plqint.t.fJ'1'l1 nog1.\CJ13nt: 111dn\1 IInc:l 13nt:nw\:m13nto)nimfJ f,ounc1 .In OOl1n\: JV I pl.lrA\1r<lphl3 :!O nl1el ~ 1 / tl113 l3<1m13 AI-glJm13nt: npPl1l'!ll. Plnin~.I fJ'fJ IHIVO lnol:oly fHwortoel boi]el:p.lnto Allegl1Qonll w.l.\:11 no Ilpooiflp fAOI:S l3upportinCJ tl1000 olnims, ainoa p)Qint1ffa I1nva 1'Ql)oc:l t:o oomp)y with thp P13nnsylvnnin l~ll)QIJ oj' C.tvi..l PI:0013Clul'o, in pl1rtloul/ll: 1019(11) Qllel (f) / plalntJ.frq' Compln.t.nt:, count~1 :r.V i~nc1 V "':0 IJllbjoot to a mQtiol) to s\:r.il,a, NlIlilHEI'OHlI, mov.\,nrJ e\oJ'en<11Int: ',I'HI" Ino, r013peotfu.\.ly.rot:.lus13t:s that t:h.il'l COIII:t I3l1ottdn Ha I'roHm.t.nnrY OI)jBOt:.t.Ona IInc1, el)te,: Ill) orelol: IJtr.ildnCj Cbunto JV I1nel V of plll.int.tffs/Compli\int,' u.' nL~lrnJ\II'!'_mRt:lM'.lYlL.JLMOTION.j'Qll MOIU) Sl'E10IFlo PLEADINGS, A pnrty may fil~, Prolimin4ry Objoot:iona for a more apeoif.io plo/1eling plll.',3ljant to HUlo 1020 (/.\) (3), 'I'hilt 1111 n Qefenc1ant is porm.tt\:eclt:o 1'11.0 PI:ol!minnry objootlons for " m0l713 spsoifio pleqeling 80 t:hat a clof:ondant' a right al1cl abl UtI' to IInswer I\hc\ c1of:endwill l1~t bo uneluly impn.t.rod by n plAintiff:'s vaguehess .in' st:nt.i.nCJ tho ljl:olll1Cls 01' mdl:, L9_Qil.LJ.1..Q.;LJllj;~~1 Ul)iQjLo~ tJnitecj 11l:(]W-Ql:Y-4~.Q.LftL-'l_1__Jtjlttinn, ________.... l'iI, ___I 207 ^,2c\ 776 (1965), AB BOt: ,fOI.-tl1 iI))OVO, ilO \~o1.1 ill] J.nth~1 Pl'ol.in\il1ary, objeot:ions 01' movinCj dol'ondi\~t, pla.i.nt.lf:I'B hilyo'rnilod to stnte ilny .peoifio n1J.o9ntiol1s to tho illlogor.lm,isoonclllot oj' doCol1qilnt: 'I'RL, That ia, '.'1 (: - 4 - I' " p~Q!nl:~l'fs I1I1VO \1\orol y u\:nt:OlI l]ol1urnl illlol]i\\:lol1u ill](\~,nl3t tho ll1pving c1ofol1rlnnt'I'IU" , I\ll notorl nbovo, 11l1l'lllH1n\" t:o H\\IO )019 (1\)l\lwl (f), plnin\"lffll' m\\pl: 1'10\: [oL"t:h l11nt(q'lnl I'not:13 In A oonolso utlc1 rlll1\l\l1nl'Y 11111111101" fll1rl, apoo.l.fioAlly ~lol: I'ol:t:h Iwormonl:a 01' tJmo, plnoo 1111c1 ltol\\iJ of pP001Al c1Al\\A(/os, FI\rthol:\1\Ol:O, it: OhoLllc1 \)0 notocl \:hnt ~ha AlJ.agAt:ionl'1 !'lot fqr\:h in COl111to IV Llnrl V f.Il:O vnl]~lo, boUarpll1to unci oll\:oh-f\lJ. typop 01' nllo(lll\:iol1s whioh Aro ImpOn11l\lAtIJlo in l'annaYV1An.i.11, l~o(Jol,c1J.nlJly, co\\nto IV and V PhoLlld bo s\:rIokon, I n tile 111\:ornn\:Jvo/ plnln\:11'1'8 sho\\ld bo roq\\iroc1 to U\1\ol1d tho Complaint Co\\nts IV Anc1 V to ppocil'ionllY plond thollo 01\\\1301'1 of aotion, \~lmlUi11'OHI~/ movinu dol'onrlnnt: 'l'lU" Ino. rOl3poo~I'\llly roQuoatp thip COllrt 1:0 u\:rJ);o counts IV ,nncl V or in th13 nlternntive to re~lIfra plaln\:il'f to fila a mora opooil'lo pIandlnu within t:on (10) " Lillya' 01' t:ho com't' a Order, " III. Illllli!lill!lli..,!!,OIL.El\.I.k\!R.U!LIl'l'lI'l'El lUJI\!!/HLQF_Mtl'ION FOR l'UNITIVfl ~l\MMllll!h PIII'fJlll\l1t to the Pc~nnsy 1 vllnin Hulop 01' clv i I l'L'ooedure, Rule I02U(I1)(4), 1,1 r.lol'ondnnt may I'ile Preliminnl:y objeotlona on t:he b'1Sis of logn.! Insul'flcionoy of a pIonc1J.ng (dolllllrt'or), In oonsldodnrJ PL'ol.lm1nnry objoot.i.ons 1.n the nl1tllre of 1\ demllrror, tho followlnlJ stnnctnrct is nppl1.odl It Is nx.lomntic in tho If\W 01' plend.lng thnt i'rol.im~nnl:Y ob:loot.lOllf.l,.ln \:ho nf\tllro 01' n d0ll11llTOl.' nelmi t liB \:nlO nIl \~oll nnd olonrly ploneloel mntodnl, fnatunl liVormenta and nll .ll1fOI'onooB Ud,l:ly rledlloJ)Jle t:horol'rom" . C0l10111810nl1 of lllw IInd lInjll\lt:ifiad inferonoes aro not ndndttod by tho plond1.ng, stQrting f'I,OI11 this point: of l'ofol1l.'OIJO tho OQuao of nction \~hich, .If pl'ovml, woUld ont:1.tle t:ho - ~) ... " pnr\:Y \:0 \:I1P leol,iPI' POlIgh\:, H p\lf.lh ill \:ho pm'!!, \:llP r1011\1I1Tllr '\lny noj: 110 P\1I1\:1I il1o'1, On \:hO pt\lOrl1nl1\l, wllorO \:ho oomplllln\: I'nUp ~:p 130\: n 1'01'\:11 11, PI1\II.10 01' no\:iol1, n pro111\llnnry PI)joll\:ion '\ n \:110 11"tllro qf 1\ l\p11\lIrl'or ill rroporlY 111111\:l1inod, QftliQy-Y.~aQ..l.mn:, 346 I'n, pUpPle, f!?!), MI\l fI,;ltj 606, {lpponl 110n101\ (ilG PA, 6381 633 I\,fld no p. \lOli) , {Ilpo pOD, JQ\lllfi.QJ1--Y.._CJ.i-t.v. 01' fllilmjgln.l1Jn, 31Hi I'fI, pLlppr, 3'/6,613 (I,;!'1 lillUilllL..dnn.l.!}-u 615 I'n , 601, 5;l'l' 1\, fll1 6 n (1906) . , M 110ted 111)oye, tl1p I'P11l1l3ylYl1nia (3l1pe1'1or Oln\rl: 1n \:h13 OI\I'1P of fiudt:hv..t..-...Brown, mlprll" 4;l3 A,2d II\: '/45, hple1 t:hn~ n plnintHf'1l comPlnln\: ,,1I1PI: PII~otl\n\:in\:o \:hn\: tho aondllct: ~y \:ho~ofendAhtP WAP 1I0lltl:ngoollpll to pllpport: 11 olni11\ for plln.ltiyodn11\l1ljOI3, In amlll1, 1113 o\.\t:linOlll1l)ovo, the COllI'\: dpflnOl.I oLltrl\rjpoLlI3(JOl1t:ll1ot, 1'\\rtllprmOr13( \:ho IJ'Ol\I't:, .In fll1\1-tl1, no\:O(I \:hl1t 1\ ,complnint: wh.loh 11\proly plol\lla olmolllal.ol1El ill no\: olll'l:.tol.on\: t:o IlLlppor\: i1 oll\!m fOl, p\lni.l:ive damqejol3where tlw plll.lii\:.i.fr 11au not plod fillY fllota JnrHollting I:hat the c1ofondqn\:Ia COndLlO\: Wflll ou~rngaoLla. ." " undor th13 ppnnl3ylvilnil] HIlloll of civil. Prooolll1ro, 1~lIlo 1.01f.l(1I) I 1'1 C011\pln1nt l1\1lflt not: only l)lve the dot:enr.1nnt notloo of \~hat the plnJnt:1ff I l'l r!lnIm 10 and \:ho 'j1'o\\I)(10 upon whioh it: roatl3, put: it mus\: <11110 f'orl1\\llnte t:ho hW\1013 by ull~mllddng thooo filots elll3ent!lll' t:o BLlpport tho o1.l1i1\\. Lil111.tlL.'l.I1_I_1,roW.n, sllpl:a" 4fl3 ^,;!d l\t '/45. ^fl o\:l1\:od nbovo, 'thoosl30nt:illl !'llot nl?oclod t:o BUPPOtc\: 11 olaim for pLlnitIvo dnmngoo In t:hn\: \:he dofondant's oondllot: wnfl ou\:rllgeoull. .. In the unno n\: bnr, pli1lntll'l's' compln.ln\: dooa not: S13t fOl't:h . ' . I I'; \:ho oxlntenl1o ~f OIlt:l"ilrJoq\H1 conciuot on tho part, of moving <:lef:enc\nnt. 'I'hol'o nl'o 110 illlo<Jilti.ons Ii1 suld Complnlnt whioh woUld Bupport: nny nllo<Jntlon t:l1nt: tho nllccJod ao\:.lol1f.3 of do/:olldllnt: 'l'IU, - () - '. ., WIlFIl clol1o wHIl <I I)(H~ 1\\0i:Jyp PI' wli:l1rllakl apn i nd.t t:I'onll1oll \:0 i:l1rr ~ n\:PFor.t: PI' Oi:1l1l1:P t N01'QoYIJr, \:IH) 1)0.1101'11,\11 \:[1 n ,llIHJI\\:Jonp 1n oOllni: lV I~ilrl V(~O lWi: spopj 1'1.01111'1' I1ppr,Ir1O rlol'onrlnni: of i:l1o lI11oeJorl PPl1rl1lPj: \jIlJo!1 woqJ.el fJHppor\: 11 lJ1'1Jl\\ I'n): pllnl,\:.ivo cl'1l\\/lgop, {lclclJ~JOllI\UY, n l\\pro <\oPllw\i:.lol1 i:I1I\\: tl1P c1Qt:onclAll\: 1:\atllq .ill 1\ WIIll\;qll ntH1 h:3Pklor'H! niunnor 1:\IJpont: 1301\\13 (HlppOl,'i: (01: nlIP!1 nHogAi:J.pn in lnsllffJo.l.onl: IHl n 11l11ti:or of' lnw, ' /lop 12I1IlJ!ILlIfJllIn(!.../IIH'loaa,_~-I.n1h .'l....J11.mtmQ11 publi r!1li110~JLu;J....., I'n I ill\ po I.' I 429 A,ac1 726 (100l), AaolJl:c\.infJ1Y, cOHni:!') IV nl\r1 V I:OCjHQst.l Ill) plll1,ll:.j,yo c1l\llmglln !'\l1oll1rJ ,1)0, r.lif'llld"f'IC~rJ, WIII~llI'WOHI~, mClv.llll) rJol:onc11:\nt 'I'll!.., Ino, F138poatt:\ll1y rpqual3t(l thnt i:ho CPlll:t 8\.\ptldn 1 tEl I'ro+1.m1 nl1ry Objoo\:.ionfo\ I.'\ncl t:o q1,!'\l1IJ.aCl wHh proj\lc1.i.co Counts IV I'\l1el V l:oq\lOflt,j 11!J punlt i V8 cl1:\11\l.'\gol'l,' IV. OqtWr.u8Im~ l31:\soel on tho f'01:09I?illfJ, 11\oy.lnl) c1ofonell\nt '~'RL, lna, rOClpaatt:\l!J.y requaf'ltCl t:hf\~ tl1iCl COll1-'\: CI\lstcdn J.t(l Preli11\.lnary Objoctiol18 nnel to ontol: fin Onlor .in wl1Jol1 COllntl3 .IV flllel V of pJ./lint:iff'a Compla.lnt aro atrJakon with PI.'BjUdio13. In the gltornatlvo, .It Js raCj\lostod that COllnts JV ilnd V ba c1iam.lClClod and plnlntJffB ara por11\.lttod to t:llo an l.'\11\ondod ComplnJnt I3poaifiaully plolldiW.f tl10 l:oquil:od f'aatsw.lt:ldn tan (10) dnys, :' .. C_~MPJlI~I.I.~. O;Cr:Fl:~.._HOr"\N7 DALY Il~l ...~\ jl~~,,~ ~ "..... '. .... Wii~r:l~ ,J;-(tA }' '~l", ,JIl" U:SQ IlUn Attol:noy 1'01' let: ndnlts, .> TRL, Inc, and Robort I ut:ahinaon - ~/"" fiN\) NO\~, \:\)In f\\l\:\111I1Y 0\: opt:o\)or, 1\l911, I, \~i HI<1111 il. '\'nylrl1:, "'" I,"""i" , " '."'0' 01 ,.1," '",," ol'f ioo,' 0' O".pl,.i', 0' ~",,'O, \10'"'' , ".1" "1,,.0'''0'' 1'0' ".h' d" ,. 0,,0" n "" 'I'"", lno, .n" \10Po'" \\n,Oh'no"n, 110"01" "or""" 1.\>", 1, ",', "n', "o<vo'l 'ho within .,,,,i.ln"" .pj""tio,o to ,U0",I"" ...,I.inl, IW ..1'''0 ".'.' ""iI, ,00""0 "'.1"''"' In 'hl1 o""I.hi" , I'., ""o,.".d 10 1\1' pnr\:\,OQ 01: <1t~:ornOY~1 01' roOI)):l\ iW, l'oll,oWfll Qi'lR'H F.1Ql\ TfL.Qr_J1i'lIW-l!ln " ilonnlt:01: 1\. IC\.\,no, l~f\qldl"O Knt\1ormon, MlIrt~ & aoiloy 31 fJo\\\:\1 Ql\oo\1 f:l\"ropt' 'iod" 1'1\ 'l'I~O:1 C.~MP~"'~ ~,~"g ~1~.'~1 (NtN & PflVI ~'i\__~J!Jf- .~ I ,. ,'-'. WI ~ll\M J. T 'iT " JR., ~ l\ttornoy fa\' PI .o\1cln\1t I , 'l'RL ,Ine I 0 nd Rol)ort lIl\to\1 \1110\1 [, " \ !i I' II " ,. f ,,1 \ ~ ' I L.~ '~ -' , ',"I 1-';" ',;;~ '/! I",' ,._;\ ,. ,!{ ",i_; 1;(: .,1 .,' '<I (i. , " " " \ " I, " ,-; .. ,. !LK...,IL.:LJL*,~~_ ,. " ." " ,,'" Hi' .' ,. j" Ii " ,. ;,1' Ii ", ., '1 ~ " " " " 'f' " 1"\ u H " .,' " 'I " ,. ' 1 " " " ,. l.' ~.l lJH'I'lm 11,\ lilllO IlIC~I~\NIMIlO I';N I...' II (cUWI'IC, ~I \lslud dusun !luI\IIHluIS\1 !Iu Ills Q\lujllS UNplluslns uII Ills Pllllilln~ SiUlliulllVlI,lluhll 111111111 IWui1l1l dUl1lJ0 ,ju hiulllJ (20) (1I11S n pnrll[ (Iu In l'uuhllul1 rlllu rooihlo III Illlllllllllln y Ollll'islI, I1slo!1 'Iohu PIUIIUI1\II[ OIlIllPn[uo,',;~ usolitn UI1 PUI'IIUI1I1 U[ pOl' IlhnlJlIllo l' pl'USUl111lf 011111 C:or!u pOl' OSUl'ito 111111 IlurUnlllls U SIIS ohjoulullus nlllil !lol1lnndos UI1 SII oUI1II'Il, ~u 10 l\\'isll 11110 III Il(lllo (lol1ollllu, olollso PllL'tjO procullnr sill 11111011 >' In emlu p\lurlp !Iuolllil UI1 SII o0l11rn 11111 11111S 1I\'lso II l1olil1OilOlol1 pilI' ollllll]\llo[ dll1ol'('\ roollll11l1l1o 011 III 1I0111nl1!11\ (l pus OIIl\lfllllul (>II'II'1\lujl\ 0 uOl11pol1i1l\oIOIl IPollI,n\lIdoll Jlul 011)uI1lI1I1I1I\I110, L'STEP pUm)B PURI)IJR PINllRO, 0 PIWI'Il1PAPl11l U O'I'ROS PIJIWCj-IOS fMPOIt'I'ANTllIlI'AM USTED, I_,",WIC ICS'I'A I>lCMANIl,\ A UN ,\nOGAOO INMICIlII\.'fAMICNTIil, III I1STlUn NO 'I'IlCNIC 0 NO , CONCOIC tIN AIlOGAIlO;VI\YAO I,L/\MIO ,\ 1..-\ OFFICNA ICN I,A 1lI1WCCION ICIlClHTAMIAJO, /. l'AnA ,1\ VICHIGUAllllONUlC l'lImlll!; OIl'I'ICNI::R ASISTENCIA LICGAI" / COlin AdlUlnlslfll10r 41h FloOI, Clil1l11cnnndColllllY COllflho\ISU Cnrllslu, pcnnsyll'nl1ln 17013 Tolorollo ~0. (717) 2<!I).(i200 i I, " , I ", " 1\ " "I' 'r (I,. " " 'I" " f') \f1 !ll \; :.11 ,::1 --I " ""1 : l '!,'I] " t".I'-" .1 11'[', " 1:'. , r~.l '/9 ,,' ..,. ~, l\. ,', 'I L r .' I, '11 "~I. ~~ I"" .' ) :.l ~ '(,'1,1 ) ", :', , I /,i ^ "1\ ,j", , H - " ~:;I '.:' l" r~1 ~ '1 ...... " -', ,to '\' ,.I "I' QER'1';n~.tQl\TILQl~_ J!!my;];Q.\q IINP I'lDW,I:I1:1u lllth c\ny of ,Jqlll\i\ry, l!l!l!l, I, Will:l,ilm ,J, 'J'nylor, ,T1:" tTInqn:\.I.'n,n lI\umbol' of' 1'.\1I'} J'IlW OI'f'lclclfl oj' cnmphol:\" 0' l<('l~lhl, Nolf\l1 Ii. , Pnly, c1\,:1:0l:\WYIJ h)).' I:ho c\\'lf'c\llclnn\:,., 'J'IU, , 1no, , lwn3by rJOI.'tU:y,tbnL I, thin c\ny, fH1J:VOc\ the w:ltl1in PI.'I\OC1:\ po to Wlt\1drnw pl.'oU,nd,nip:y Objeot..lo\lfJ, by Iln:l.tBd fJti\I:(31l MaLI, prlf:lt<lge [1l'OPi1:!rl, in P)1ili\rlolph:la, PA, c\c:1c1 ro fJfJ 8 cl to I:I1C3 pnvt' \.l'ln OJ.' iI I: l:onWYIl C) 1; l.'8001'rl i'1fJ l:011oWfJ I JenniJ'er A, 1<1:1no, mnquiJ:B 1<'1 1:.)11'" l:mill1, Mill'l:z & GiI:l1ey 3l /3outl1 Quecll1 Street YOl'k,PA :1.71\03 " " " I, - - WIl,1,I1\M J, 'I' At tOl:ney fOl: 'I'RJ" 1no, ,," Ii " II' ,I, " . i' " " I' " i1, I..,' " " ,. " ..' , , d' ,. " \ I, i I. III ,< I I' i , I L ,I, I ,'I " II, !'1. ,. it I.', " " , ' I. II I,; " ,i'" ,I; ,t' " ), 1 ' 1 l (,J:'," I Ii L " Ii ,," " "I. II! I' ,. , ' :\ i j, I I , , i " ;1,,< " "... ii" Ii d' ., " " ,II I ' H it IJolla/:, liP 1:0 qj(:l 1:I.'II1:h 01' I:h~l nllrJon\'.lDIIP "'il(I~1 :1.11 Urln pnl'I1!J1'ilp\1, 'l'hl'lBl.-l nl.1oHil\:lpnp i.ln) \:Iwrqf'oro rlon1ml ilWl (1\:)::\0\: pnlOf' l:honlOl' .1,.1 rlelllnnc!ad nl:' \',ho t:l.I1\1) 01: \:r:lnl, t;, Dmd.l)rl, 'I'D l:hlJ bOI]\: of: emflworlH!! rlol'lJl\rlnnl:P' ImowlBcl(J~l nnd IJollel:, the t::l'ilO\:Ol:' Ii l.'eglpl:vnl:lon n\\mbo'" WiHI l\lD'/'/2'3, 6, Denlerl, 1\f:I:ol.' l:ennonnbl(~ :l.nv~lPt::I,HiII:lon, i1lWwr~rlnlJ rlel'el1dnntp "re W1t:\101\1:' ]~110wledlJo or :I.nf:orm,l\:lDH flllf: Uplent 1:0 f:01:1\1 <1 ))e1:l.el: nl3 1:0 t:he \:1.'ut:h of: I:he i\llemlt:.i.Ol1f.l I\1nde ln I:h:l,f.l pm:<1lJrnph, "l'hel3e Allegnl:lOl1fJ nt'o thel:of:ore r\rm:l.ecl <lncl fltr:!,a\: proof: I'. \1e ,1:130 I: lfJ demAnded Ell: the Umo of: t:r:I.i'l:i, 7 t Denia'd, '11h8 allegi:'\l:.iol1f.1 aont:f.d.'lled :l.n t"h:l.fl pnragruph nl.'e flpeo1fl.o<\11y clen:l.ed, l\nl3wol.'lng defenc1m1t:fl not:ecl properly nnd with c1ue onre' nt nll timsfl l.'oley<\nl: to \:h:l.13 npt:ion, {lt1flwer:\.ng clefenc1Antfl I'lpeo1U.onlly deny that were O€lreleB~, ,reolde~lfl or negllgent in Any mnnner alleged, By way 0,1' f\\1,'thor lmflwer, theBe allegAtlonfl nre clen:l.ecl beof\l\138 t:hey are ,potlOllll3:1.0\1fJ of ,lAW t:o whl.rJh no l:eflP0l1fl1yeplellc11ng 113 rOCjt\lred, B, Denleq, 'l'he ClllogClt:l.onfl aont:nlnec1 In, t:hl.fl, pc\rngl:llph nre flpea1fionlly delli.ed ,A1lflWI;Il:1ng def'enclantfJ noted p1:operJ.y and wlt:h 'c1Ue onre Eltnll, t1msfl relevant t:o t:hi./J nell:l,on, l\11J3we,rl.ng qefenc1antfl, I3peai.fibnlly clony that: were Oare181l13, t'ealtlel3ll 01: l1eg11gent 1n nny l11nnner nlleged, '1'0 the oot1trf\l:y I 'defenc1nnt Hut:ohlnflol1 IlpaoiHOi\J.1y den1ea t:hat ,he Clt:tempt:ecl to rUn oY13r 'pla1nttff at: nny tDl1e materilll to pllllntlff'S Complll1nt, COUN'L!, !J, 'rhe Elnawedng clefenc1nntfOl repeat, <,ud 111Clorporate by referenoe I t:he Ill1flWel:~1 oOl]l:€dnsd 111 pf1l:agrapha 1. through 0, I'"~ - 2 - In, 110 1\.tnl\, 'I'lw nlln\.lil\:lo\lfl \IUI\\',i\L1\l1rl1n 1'.ldfJ pnrIHJI'i'IPII \11'(\ fJP(IOl.(' lpnl1y <10\\10<1, I\l1flWIH'lno dul'undil\\\,1I il('" 0<1 prnp\Jl'1 Y <In<l wH.1I (I\Il.l (If\l~n <11, n]] 1'.I\IIWI l'l11IlVi\1\L 1:0 1'.11111 i\utlon,' I\nuW(Jrl1\\l "1\0 ('0Il<lnl1l:13 fJpou:1 t::lml11y' (lulIY \',lliI\: W\ll'll (lnl'l~](~PIII 1'0\*:\01:111 01' 1I(IH1,I,\Jl.l\\I, In <IllY mi111110\: itJl(~tJ\lcj, lly wny 01' 1:\11'\:11(11' i\llIlWOJ: I \:hllllO i1110[Jill:101\fJ Aro c!(!lniml boamwl.l \:hoy <11:(~ C1onClllWiollll of lnw \".0 whlClII 110 nl[Jponrd. ye plene1!l1tJ l. fJ l'e<.11\ 1.1'ec\ . 11, Don:Ll3c]. '1'l1e nllegatl,Dnn Clontillllecl In tldtJ pAJ:ilgrnpll nre npop:Lfianlly del1lod, I\noworlng defendanto Aoted prDperly nnd w:Lth elllo afire ill: illl \:lmoo roleYnn\: 1:0 thln notIon, I\nnwed,nu dc.l!:encl.mtn opea:LfloullY eleny th<lt, wel.'e om:elefJfJ, 1.'0ClId.BfJfJ 01' negligent: :In Any mamIeI.' nlleged. ,'I'D the eJOl1trOJ:Y I n\wwel.' defend<ll1l: l'lI~ahl.nl'!ol1 fDllowec1 the I.'uleo of the road al: <Ill t.i.l\1efl lIlf\tednl to pl<li.nt:l.f 1" 0 CDlllplnint, 12, Den.i.ed. 1\1' t \3].' l:e<lOOl1Able .i.l1yeat ,i.gal: :LDI1, illlPW\3l.'.i.l1g defenelAtltn are wlthollt ImoWledge 01.' ll1l'Ol'l\1<lt:Lol1 fJ\lff.i.ahlllt to form i\ bellef ill'! to ~he tr\ll:h of thB nlll~g<l\::I.olls m<lc1e :I,ll th:l.o pm~ilgrClph, 'I'hene illlegnt:l.oI18 <11:13 therefore den:l.ed nnd std,Clt. proof thel~eof 113 demnndec1 <It the t:l.me 01' \:1::L<ll, By WHY of E\lrthel.' <\!lfJwel', these all,eg<lt.i.OI1I3 are den:l.ec1 beCnllfJe I:hey <I);e aOl1alllnlDnfJ bf lAW to \~h:Lah 110 I.'soponfJ:I.ve pleac1lng :La reql\:I.I.'sd. 13 , Denlecl, I\fter l.'eaf3onClble ll1ve/3\:lgadon, al1f3wed.ng, " dafendilnta are without Imowleclue or lnfol.'l\1al::Lon fHlffJ.alent tD fOI.'\1\ CI belief 1'/:1 1:0 the t:rul:h of the illJ.eg<lt:LOl1fJ made in thlfJ p<I!'i\grClph, 'l'he/:le allegatiol1n a1:e therefore den:Led ill1d rJtdal: pt'oof thereof :L/3 I \("( 1'1 I II 1\ !I I" I ~\ I ,( demanded at the dme of, I:.d,nl. l3y wny of flll:t he 1.' nnf,lWel.', these - :.l - , i\lloUn!;:lol\fl iH'(J rlollloel bl~PiHlun I:hoy ilru rJnnc"llInlollLl or lilW l'.o whlul1 I\P l'OPPOl\p.Ivo phlqrUI\\1 I,I l'uCjll:l.rml, l.~ , pfJl\:!.od, I\tTol' l'oiHlnl\iIIJ.lt'J I.nvofll:IOill:lnn, ilnpWrll'llIH rloh1wlnnl:p lire \~:I.I:l1olll: kl\oWlocllJI) PI' .II\I'ol'lIIql::lon 11\11'I'.lII:lul\l: !:,[) f:I~I'1II II pnl:i.ef ,II> \:p I:he l:l'lIl:h of I:hq n1hl91ll::I.PI1u lIIi1rlfl .III 1:11.1[1 pfll'i\Ul'llph, 'l'h13~10 /lJ..le9<Il::I,oI1P Ill'n l:hel~O!;Ol.'n dOl\i ud IlI1el fll: I~:I 01: Pl:o[)l~ I:hol~eof .Ifl elOIllf1l1r:leq f\l: I:h,e 1:.i.1I1e of l:l.'.Inl, By Wqy pf flll'l:hol.' flnpwel.', t:helJO i'\lleg<1~.tonp fll:e don.i.erl b13Di\\\f.le \:hey nl'e CJonql\1fJ:J.onn of l<1W 1:0 Wh:l.C1h no l'efJpOnfl.i.V13 ple<\e1.i.na .I/31.'eCjIl:lrer:l, WflElRIWORliJ, flnl'lWel'.ing elefonr:lElI1!;/Ol dSlllnnd I:hflt l:h.i/J COlllpla.illl: bo clil3l11.i.Sl'lecl ,w.tth pl:ej Ilel.lCJo, ' COl1l'/.'!~r I ~.!i, '.\'he anl3Wel.':l.na clef13l1clnnl:s l'lilpeat, fll1cl .tnaorpor<\l:e IJY referenDe, l:he ilnswanJ CJontll.i,necl .tll Pf.ll:Hgt"nphs J. 1:111:0\.lgh 'l.Il . J.6', 'j)en.i.ecl, 'l'ho nJ..1.egflt:lonl3 C1ont:f1.tnecl .in th.i.13 pl\l:ngrElPh EIre flpea:l.fJaaJ..1.y clen.tecl, Anl3wer1.ng defel1clnnt IllltahJ,l1son ilOt;eel propel~ly" anc1 w:l.th clue 9E1ra "at: Ell.]. tJ.l1\efl 1.'131evant:l:o tl1:l.a aot.i.Q!\, AnfJwer:l.ng " r'lefenclElnt ,HlI!:ah.tneQn flpeo:l.Haal1y L'len.i.fil/3 that he :Lnl:encled to ,i.ntJ.mJ.c1ate, terror.h:e IInd :l.nj lire p~.nJ.nt:,i,ff, Anl3wer.i.ng clefendant Hl1t.ah,i.nspn fl1rthel: denJ,es that he na(:ec1 w.tth litter cl.i.sregard fOJ: , pla:l.llt:iff'fl safety, right/3'~ncl health, WIIUlnlDli'OREl, al1ewed.ng c1efend<\nl:a demnnd thElI: thia Cotnplninl: be d,i.am.i.s/3ed wi th prej ncl.i.ae , COlIN'l' r r r J. 7. 'l'he answer.i.l1g clef:endElnt:a repent: I nnd .i.naorpornt:e by referenae, the answers aonta.tl1~cl :l.n pal.'agrnpha 1 throUgh J.6, " I , - 4 - :to, ndn.I~1(j, 'l'1\n r.)1.:IBuill:lunn nont:iI:III\~~II n '(,11.\11 pil nHJl.'npl\ ill'(~ fJpecJJ.f:lo(.ll)y rjen:\.od. 1IIWWflr.\,nr.r rh~"llnr\i\I\I: 1I\\t:ClI1.\linon fI~J\:l'H1 [lI'OP(ll.'1 y nnc,! wJI:h chw (l(.\I.'a "I: 1111 \'.:\.II1!lP l.'UhlVill\t I:n UII" 1\0 t,,IPII , ,AIIPWOI'.IIIU (jaf:qnc'lnlll: npfwlt:.\,cmlly rlolllop 1:111\1: h:1 Pilol'. :I,OIlP WOrn 0111: rnnOO\\fJ, wnnl'.on, Wllll'I\I, 01.' 1\1111:1.0:10\111 nnel t:1I1:1:1181' clsn.I,tll1 I'. 11i1 I', he :I,nl:nmlfolc1 to h,mn plnlntl.('f:, WUlTIluwortli1, Al1iJwe1'lnu Clo!:8IlC!nnl:p dBl11nncl I:hnl: I:hln C!ol1lplA:l.I\I: )Jp cI:l.pl11lnpocl w:l.th p1:ejUclipo, " QQ!lli'l'-lY 1.9, 'l'he AIHJWelc:I,I1U clef:enclf\nl:p lcep\'lill:, Al1r] '.I,nooqK1Icill:o l)y l.'et:ol:'enoe, the i1I1Pwelcp aOn~Alnecl :\.n pol1:f\grclphp :t I:hrough :1.(1, ,. " 20. penle~l, '1'he IIllegill:lolW oonl:i1Jneel ,In l:h:lfJ pHl:<\urilph '11.'13 f.lpeaif;laClUy clenleel, I\IHlwedng clef:enclilntfJ i1eJI:13c1 pi;opel.'ly i1nd w:l.l:h dl1€! ai\l:e 111: uU tll1len releV.lnt 1:0 thl,3 .1Ot.I.on, l\lwwed.ng deJ:endi\ntl3 flpeoHla<\lly 'deny th<\t welcO (J<\roJ.e~ip, real~leflfJ or , negligont In <\ny l\1i1nner illlogeel. py Wily,of further ilnnwer, thefle ilJ.J.egi\U,Onfl 'Ire den:l.ed beamH3B they .1l:e oonolUl3lonfJ of law' to wh~,CJh no l~\3nponsJ.ve pl.eildi.ng ;ls required, 21, Denled, jl I The nllegat:l.onl3 oontaJ.ned In thifJ Pilri\gvaph are speo.\f:lcally c1en:led. 1\lwwedng defendanl:Q aated plcoperJ.y anc1 Wl tl.l due"oare ilt 1111 tJ.l1Ien relevant to thifJ aotlon, Answl!ll:J.llg qef:elldi\l1ts speoiHaEllly deny thaI: we1'e" cEli"elefJf3, reoklefJs, or negHgent' .1.n .lny manher <llleged, By way of El1l'tller IInSWe1"i thene i1llegations 011'13 denied beamwe\:hey 111.'8 COllblusiollS of law to whioh " 110 respons:l.ve plel1dlng is requi.l:ed. 22, DenJ.ec1. '1'he allegatJ.ons contaJ.lled :l.ii this ~1C\1'Hg,1:f\ph are conclusions of law to whl..ell no repponaive pleac1illg l.,fJ l'equlre<;! t - 5 - 1I0WPVIU', :l.f: flny oj' \:l1flPP illl\~gnt:lonfJ nn1 rlnoll\ncj 1:0 1)8 1'1\01:\1\11 I',hey firs IJPpaH:l.Pfllly elen.j.ntl 'lilt! ol:,rhil: proof 1:lwJ:ool' l.fJ (joll\flprlOtl ill: t:lmE1 of \:l~.j.fll, fl3, fll3l1:1.et~, 'l'ho n1.1o[JR\:.t.0I1Il nplIt:"dnml .1.11 \:h.i.p pnrilffl'ilpl1 m.'(~ I ,tJOna.l.\\f;:!onfJ oI: IflW to wh:l.eJh no l.'fl/IPOllfJ:l.VO plefltl1.lln J.p l.'oqll:l.l'otl, l-!oWIWC:ll:, j,f: ,my of \:l1ope fllle[Jc\\:J.olHl ill'B tlp(~lI\(ltl \-,0 be f:no\:\lf\1. they, fire rJpea~l:J.anlly clen.l.pt! <lnd fll:do\: prool: I:hel:eol: :I,p t!em,mcleq <II: \:.l.m8 01: (a:J.n 1, 2<\, psniec1, 'l'he <llJ.eUflt:1.PI1fJ llon\:<I.j.nec1 J.n I:h.i.p pflJ:nfJl~'lPl1 fire aOlla.l.UflJ.Ol1n of 1.nw 1:0 whJ.ah no l:espOnl3:l.ve pleflej].IlU J.13 l'eqn!.t'eq, Uowevel~, 1f mw of: thei3s nllegnt1.0llfJ fire qeSl\1ecl ~o IJ8 f<lCll:un1. t:l1ey flt"e I3pso.i.f.i.anll.y deni.ed anc1 fll:riat proof: ~l1el~eof ifl c.1ell1l1nqec1 <II: l:ilne of; l:ri<l1., WlIElIUWORlil, answsdng c1efe\ldnnt:/3 demnnd th<lt: tl1J.,13 Complnint be c11pmi/3sPc1 with prejudiae, , COlJN'~ 25, 'l'l\e f\nf3wering del:enr:1f\nt:p repent, nnd 1.I1aol:pol'f\te by l:efel:ellOB, the f\1113Wers conl:nJ'ned 1.n Pi1qlg1"nphfJ 1 tl1]:ouUh 2<\, 26, ben.i.ec.1, 'Jll1e all.egAt:1,ona aontn.i.necl in tl~J.f3 pm:fI\lraph nre 13peo:lfioally clen.i.eel, Answering def:endal1t, 'I'Rr.., flctec.1 properly nncl ' I, wil:h clue anre. at nll tJ.mep releVAnt to \:h:l.s aatJ.on, 1Inswering clefendant, TRr.., speaj.fianlly clenies that 1ts hirJ.ng find retention of cl13fendnnt Hutahinf30n in 11:f3 employ anel ,entl:Uf3ting defenc1ant IhJt:ah:l.llf3on 1:0 opel."<lte .i.l:s vehiale WilS aoncluot whiah was outtageolis,l wanton, "w.i.J.lful <lnd Iil<1Haj.ollfl, WlIluRmFORJ:il, ansWering c1ef:enclants c.1emancl that this COlllpH1.i.nt be c1islll:l.ssed with prejuc1iae, - 6 - C!QUI'l'!'..-YJ. ;~'1, '1'llP i\llnW~lI:,I.ml d~l(:on\li\n\'.n l'npB(I\:, flllr1 \,n(lOFpol'nl:e by 1-'\o1J:on~nqo I \:)10 i\!lflWl.\ i:'fI r.lDn\~flIIlBrl In )JflJ:i\w.'npl'1I1 1 \-.111:<]11(111 ;Hi, 20" pan:l.or], i\f\:uJ.' I.'o(lponllblo :Lnvol3\'..i.ullt:l.on, nnower:l.ng elafane1nn\:rJ nre WI\:hOllt knowledge 01.' .I,nf~Pl'II1(ll:,~o\1 ollt:t:1CJ:t.ent \:0 form fI )l(3lJ,el; IHl 1:0 \:)11'1 \:1:\II:h at: t.hl3, nLloHA\:ionn mmla:ln t:.ldrJ pf.lrn91.'flph, 'l'hona nl.l.egt\\:;\,onn fire \:.herej:ol.'l3 rlenJ.orl onel Iltdol: proof therooj: :1./1 clemnnqee\ fll: \:he I: :l.me oj: \:d.nl, By WAY of t;nrthC3r OI1PWel.', !:l1e/le nU.egi'\tionn f\l:e qen.j.ed beamwe I: hey' ip:e rJOllCllLw:l.ono ot' l.AW \:0 wh:l.CJh no l:el'1ponfJive pleAd:t.ng :1.0 l'eqq:l.red, 2.9, Den:l.etl, 'l'he AUeg<l\::l.ol1fJ..Clont.a:l.lle~l :l.n thin P<\l:flgl:aph Are aonollll'1:1.o11n of lAW \:0 whi.clh nO'l.'ellponfJiva plending il'1 reqll:l.l.'E)(l, However, if: <lny at: thef.le nl.legf.\dOnfl are cleen\ed 1:0 be faat\lfll. \:hey <Ire I'1pea:lUqal.ly denieq and ste:l,ot. pl"OOt: tht11.'eof' :l.r~ demandecl fit I,' dills of t.dEll., WHlimml'olllil I <nwwedng det:end<111\:fJ demand t.hAt I:hif.l C01l1)Jla:l.nt be c1:1.S1l1isf.lecl w:l.t.h prejud:lo~, NN\'LMl\'l"l'mR 'l'he answering clefendnn\:s ~lll3eJ.'l: the f:ollowJ.119 lIlew MEltter I 30, J\ny reoovery :l.n this aCJt:l.on 1f1 limitec1 01.' bf.\l.'l'ec1 ~Indel' the provial.ona of the I?ennsylvanin Compn'J.'t\\::l.ve NegU,genae 1\0\:, , 31, J\t that:\.me and pInoe alloged, the pl.dnt:\.ff hEld 11, duty to exel:al.se rea/30l1able oal.'e for hiu own SElf:et.y a,11d was negligent ~'11 the following I al operat 1,ng ,h:l.a vehiole :l.n such a neg;t:l.gent Elncl l:'eol~lesl'1 manner, ElIl to oJ:eat.e 11 nlidden emergendY in front' of def~ndant'D vehiale] - '7 - !-; I'I " I)) IWHl:\.g"n\:.\.ym1e\/or :I.n\:on\::l.onidlV opa.ri'1\::l.nH h1.[llI\otol.' VPhj..el1,B :l.n j:ront pf: (1el:spclnntp I v(lh:\ll\ (,] Ln PI\(Jh II II\l1nncw 1111 \:0 C1i'1\.\I'll'l r1el:encle\11\:fJ I veh:\,eJl,o to IrI.I'. pl.d.nl: i. f: f:' PI 0) \:n:l.l\\l:e 1:0 \IIn:l.I1I:f\'\.l\ prOpCH' (lOI1\:,l'ol .1.n \:1\0 opc~rn\::\.ol\ 01: h:\.fJ veh.1."1B, 32, 'l'he \\eal:\.genCl(~ of: \:l\!'l pl<dn\:,HI' Wi\1:l i'1 Il\\I)fJ\:i\n\:.J.il1f:q(J\:m: :l.n lJdng.1.ng ilbollt I:he iI(Jo:I,dent .\l1d :I.n:ll\l:y l\1.1.og13(1 nnc'\ thi,s negl :l.gel\oe opel:i\\:ep, 1:0 l)il1: 01: .1..1.11\.1.1: the c1E\lI\ilgorJ f.\fJpel."\:()c1, 33, 'l'he p1Idlltif.f: hAcl 110\:i.oe f1ncl ImoW1fjclge ol:\:he oonc1H:\.oI1P ,ilUegl3c] 1:0 h<\yB O<1\\pocl, tho neJOi.donl:" nncl ',cUd Icnow:\ng.1.y, nn(1 Willfully, 131100\\n\:e): \:I\epe S'D\lc'\:I.t::I.onp f.mc1c1:l.d f1fJlllll1\El <lIW 17:\.fJl, of. :I.njl\l:y\:h<1t OOLlId E\1::l.oe, 'Phe ola:l.lI\ of: p1i'\fnt:\.f:f: :1.11 In\J:j:l3cl by I:he <1POLl\l1pl:j. on of: ripk, 34, 'l'he oli1i\l\13 'of: the p1e1:\.ntHf: nre 'IJ.Il.'l.'ed by \:he <1pp1.:i.o<1b'.1.e Stn\:ute of: ~:III\:I\:iI\::IonfJ, 3 Ii, Reoovery:ln \:h:ls nol:ion 113" U.mHec1 i'\nd oonl:l"61.1I3d by the Pel)npyJ,Viln:ln Motor Veh:\.ole U':In<111o:l,nl nOf.lponf.d.biU~-,y J'<1W, wh:l.oh :1,13 :I,nOOl:pm:n\:,ec1 by l!'ef:erenoe, 3G. P'lf.d,ntHf::I1l ~)O\md by the HII\:I.tecl tOl:\: opt:l.on pe\:, f:ol:th in his nuto\\lobHe inp\\ri'\nae poUay whioh Wilf,! in ef:teat 'At the time 'of \:hi/3 i,nciclent:. 37, The plilintif:f f:n:l.1ecl to tilltel:eil130nnb1e meaI'lU1:'e/3 to cure' the i.njl\ry or prevent further in:lm'y or 1011f,! f:rol\\ tnldng plaae, and t., did fail to mitigate the clall\~gep aal3ertec1, 30, PlnintHf: h<lFJ J:tliled to at:atB a o1.a:\.1I\ upon which raUef can be grantecj, - 0 - , I " '-'" Y.E.lLl.FJQlI.'!'lilN "]f' (' " /.. '.-,.., +, _____~-__.;<_-1..(~j:~ft.'fl--j1L.l..--Y-~~:..\::.::!'.--..-----., h~ I:S by fl t: n t (') I 1, r <\In m\\111cil'i~l3d to t:ilJ~e \-,\1ill vor:\, e.i.ofll:j,O\\ on b(3hill e of 'I'IH" Ino./ 2", r ved,fy \:hi1l: t:\113 fJl:iltsl\1en\lfJ 1\1i1(,le :l.n tho ['01'ogo:lI1U l\nllwor to Pl,id.n\::U:f:' f3 (Jol\1p1i11\1\: elre \:1'\\6 ilnd OOl.TOelt: \:0 I:he I)efl\: of I\1Y In1DWledge, Inf:Ol:ll1ilt:.i.oll ill\L'\ \181:1,ef: I il!ld ' 3, J: unel81.'fJtf\nd tlmt the fJlliltell1enl:fJ i,n fJll:l.,d l\11f1wei: to P1q:l..I1\::I.f:f:' fl C0l\1p1cllnt ,ilI:e I\1qde f.lll))jeeJl: to \:\113 p(millt:l.BfJ of 111 P1\,CJ,I3, f)4904 1.'61qt1.l19 to \'lllfJWOl:n f:cl1,fJi.f:l.oilt.j.on'\:o il\\tllod,t::I.efJ, " ') Q" .--- ,_. -) . " . ) '___"h__~l:;;c ~"::~~:!;(~t:!Lf..._,:,yr~s. ..l'r't'u/c_. (:..- on behnlf: of: '1'IU, , In,eJ, J)l\'l'I~n I , I, .. ,:.~//c.I9L_____.__ { I (., -- NnlOllnl Sonl .Jnnnno Ahnon., Nnlntv I'lIh\lo M I'llIalonlWll"I.UZlIJI1o Qnllll' Y y Commle.lnll !:'phoe Rnpt, 20, 2002 , amb.', I'onnaylynnla ^aaoolnllo" 01 Notatloa Wi.lliall1 .J, TnylOl: I jJr, /131:1t..." V, '1'I.'onI100111::I.11e\1I:'11 Ref:t:1gerat;ed r,inefJ, Ill0, /PlIG40-90GG "I' .,. .. ,. ,. Ii " ,. ,., " , " j, ,., ,() " . (" tli \j) \'.., I' I' I n -'"\ , \1\ 1.'\.' , .\ . , ~(') '>1 1 ,,, , .,j "':1 'j";'; " .., ....-1 r," ! , , ...., '<'1 I' I C) " ,. "j' , ._~ . ;'1-'" " II II ." 1., ,. ,. ., " " " " , '-, ~ .1) ) I,. " ,. ,. H'I'ICVICN ,':. H'I'I'I'I', IIIHI .Il':,\N H'ITI';!" I'1"1,,lIn~ IN '1''''': nll1H'I' Ill" Cm'IMllN I'I,ICI\H , Ill" CIlI\'IIINIH d\NU CllllN'I'Y \'H" NO, I t)')H.fHlt72 'I'H"I INC, "'''I ' lmm'iHT 1I\1'I'CIIINHON, IM~'HI""IH CI VII, ACTION, I A W ."lIn' 'I'HII\I. UI':IVI'\Nmm 1'14i\1NTlFFS' HIWI, Y TU NlcW l\'Ii\TTlcH ANP Nl )W,lhls__~j_'/',_lhl)' Ill', uJl\(L~LL.!~'../__, 11)1)1) ~0111O PIIIII1I1f1H, ~lml1li..HIIW 1l1li1.l~illl HIltz, hy 1I11111hl'lHIgh Ih~11' 111101'110)', .I~l1l1llbl' 1\, 1<'lilw, IislJull'~,IIIl\II1I~ Ih~ /i11l0WII1U Rupl)' 10 N~II'MIIIIIlI'l )0, 1l~I1I~d, Th~ 1I11~gllllollS 0I'Plil'II/;\1'lIph.10 III'~ dUllkd liS COI1ChlSlollS 01'11I\\', ) I, n~lllcd, It Isd~lllcd Ihlll PllIll1llfl'WIIs IlCgllg~1I1111 (111)' I'~Sp~~t. PIIIIIlIII'l'Hp~ell1~I\II>' II1Clll'pOI'llIIl~ I, the III1~glltiolls 1\1' his COlllplnilll. 'A, D~IlI~d. Ills 11\Jl1ied Ihlll Plllilllll'l' Ilp~l'IItod his whiolu 111111l0glig\Jl1ll1l1lll'~oklcHH 11111111101' CI'OI\tlllg n suddoll CI11OI'/;\OIlC)'1 . , II, DOlllcd, II Is dUlllcd Ihlll .1'1111111"'1' IIcgligclltl)' 1111\1/01' 1Ill0nllol11111y \lpol'lll~d his nwllll' ' ;< whlel~ in sueh 1I1ll1ll1llCl' 10 CII\ISO Dofulldllnllo hll Plllinl"'f1 n Denied, Thc IIl1cgllllons or PlIl'lIgl'lIpI1'.12 111'0 dOl\lod liS cOllclUslolls llflll\\'. J.l. DCIlI~d, The IIlioglltlolls ol'plIl'IIgl'IIl\h)) lire denlod liS oOllehlsipllS Mill\\'. Plnlllllf'fapcc1Il11lllly dOilies Ihlll he llssull10d IIIlY risk nil' Iho lIeeldiJlll 01' h\llII'lus sus(lIhwd, .14. Donled, Tlw II110gnllolls or plll'llgl'nph J'llIl'u don Iud ns (lOlllllllsiollH of hiw. , l'~ ' , I' 'iI, J I: " )H, \)Plllud. Tho II110gllll0llH or plll'lIgl'nph :IH 11I'0 dOlllod IIH OllllCluHlollH or lillY, )IJ. \)olllol!. Tho nllognllol1s or PlIl'lIgl'llph )0 nl'O dOlllod ns oOlloluslollH of' III\\'. 40, DUlllod, Tho nll!lgnUollH or plll'llgl'nph 40 1\1'0 IIPlllod IIH oOlluluHIOIlH or IIIW, 41. ))Ol1lod, Tho IIllcgnllollH of' plll'nlll'nph 41nl'0 lion Iud liS collcluHlolls Ill' lillY, W1IHRHFUIU\, PlnllllllTs dOll1l1nd Judgomollllll Iholl' iiII'llI' nl1d nglllnHI Polomlllllt, . 1{~Hpccl I\llIy Hnhml\tcd, KATllI\lHvlAN, MARTZ &. OAlI.IW , / . ~ .'~ ~ . .. ( J J . n ': _..'. .---1, / I / ..' .. ) '-'-" ------,------ ,IOl1l1l1ul"l1.. Kline, ,Esqull'o Atlol'llo l!ill' I'lnll1tlf'tli .11 HoUlh QIIOOI1 Htl'oot ,. York, pUIlIlH)'ll'llIlln 1740~ (717) H4H.mH \,I), ((651)511 " t, >p +_ :".~~':-_'H_ J~~~~.~TJ.0Ji. .~~.!.E~L,.._~:.:~_l~u. "Alli' , 1 __ P.E G~lill~_J\[\~!'.~-,~'!: !'Jl~_, ____._.__. _,....__,. HEpIG"I., !lII.I.II10, A1W X-RA\'(5) HEIlIOAI. ANll IIOSl'l1'AI. II II. I, >:.r-A\' 0111,\' HEllICAI. /lNll 1I051'1'I'AI. 11)1.1, >:.RAY ONI,\' IoIEDICAI. AND 1105 I' I'f AI. !lII.L >:-RA\' 0111,\' IoIEDIG/lI., n:p.I.INlJ, ANIl X-R/l\',(Sl 1.IEllICAI" III 1.1.1110 , "Nil X-I\A\'(S) HEllICAl., IlII.LINn; ANll X-P.A\'(S) IoIEllICAl" !lII.I,IIlG, ANll X-Ril\'(S) IoI;;oICAI., IlII.I.ING, ANll >;-Ril\'(S) ~IEDIC^L, IlILI,ING, AND X-l\A\'(S) l'IEDICIIL, lInl,ING, AIW X-MY(S) IoIf:llIC/lI. /lNIl 11051'1 TAl, IlIl.I, X-RA\' ONI,\' IoIEllICAI" lIII,LIIW, Aim >:-R/l\'(S) , 1.0CA'l'loN IlAIoII'; .. .._...,_._...~.__._.' _ .___~..... '..+ ....._4._..___ ~_.___.~... _~_ n. ._..__._.._.__ ...._._+~; __ __".'._.__~~____u.__ SIIOI\t-: Ht:lJIC/lI, m:wrr;l\ 51101\,; "'E~101\IIII, 1I0SI'ITAI, 5110RI\ l,n:I'IOI\IAI, 11051'1 TAL 1I0HAI\Il COUNTY !lEIU:R/l1. 1I0SI'I'r/l1. 1I0HAI\\l GOll/fl'Y OI\IWl\AL 1I0S1'1'1'AI. fiT, MiNES 1I0SI'1 TAL fiT, A!lNES 1I0SI'I'!'A', \l!\, IHI.1,Ij\:III, AlJOLl' .)>11, 1':.A, 1\1J1I1';nO IoIICII/I::I. ll1\OHN, H,\l, 1>1\, HICIIAEL II, FINK r, ASSOC, DI\, .1AHES 1\, I\INKER \ll\, .10t:L IHN,:R KOll\lNER CIl11\01'1\j\GT'IG cENn:l\ 1Ii1110Ylq\ oElmRAL 11051'1'1'111. IIAIlOY,;I\ GENEI\iII, 1I0SI'IT"', 1NHIIII CliO. /01, \l, , .. /I il ' " " , " .\' " ,0 " j,,, , ",'- ..' \If:02-103755 :I.0:l.30-00:L, CQMM 0 ~W.HAIJ:lJ..QE..elLl\l.~:Y.J\l~l6. cQ1!tr[YJ2.I~Q!J.tY1l!.liIU,-i\Nl~ Htrvl'l', VA I'lhl Nil, ,_I,P_~~.:i)116"~._..__n_ '1'1\1., llill. ~ ll\J'I'C\llNSON ,. " SUlIPOENA'I'O"p'IWPUCE DOCUMENTS QJLlJj.lMG5 FOlllJlRCOVHlW fi.UlliUA.N.T_TO .li.!J.11\ ilq09,22 '1'01 ...9.l,Ill'tQn.lN!'.Q~J~JWl!!~P'S lIgl\ I fll!Ol\g HgHO!iIAI, \lOSl'l'l'Al, IN,'n\U lIr l'vI.nn \It I!r1!llyl \\'111.lI11IW0l1I)' 12(1) Ilo)'s I,rllll '"II'ICI'llf 11119 sll\1llClllno, ""1\ 01" Hr'I\llu,1 l'S II", CllllrlllllltllllllCU 11w fll\lowlnl\ ,llIo\lll1ol1ls "I .. I si,' " Nl'l'MI Jill ' Ihll1I\" _ -..~-~~---'-~-_.~-------,-..-- --.,.~ 111lnAllEl,PI1IA I'A 19103 ,11 ~lS l1I\OUI' JNU..!_~!'.9J,)lAI\I(I\'L' _ fl'l'l\El\'I' Hlll'l')\ ROll II\,hllml YIIIIII'0)' ,lolIl'0!.1I1 11101l10g11110 ClI\l\u. III Iho ,IIIC1I1110111911r I'rIlIIIlC\I ihll11\6 1\I~1I06'011 h)' Ihl6 6I1h\'1I0110, 101\01lWI wllh Iho c\lrllf cMo IIf CIlIIII'\lOJ1C\I, 1\llho 1'0,11)' IIInkll1l1lhl. rO~lIo.1 nllho o,lIlto66\1slo,1 Ohlll'O, Y,," hol'o I 10 rll\hllll sook, III o'lI'nllco, IIW 10,'SI1l1nhlo CIlSlllf l'fol'nrll1l1lho clIl'los lit I'!'mlllcllllllho Ihll1S6 61111Sh!. If )'011 1011'l1ll'rlllll1co Iho IInolllllol)l611r Ihllllls 1"~lIlroll h)' Ihl. 6111'1'110110, wllhll1lwol1l)' (20) ,10)'9 oflor 116 9011'100, 1110 I'nrl)' 9011'1I1l1lh16 9111'I'Ilol1n mn)' 600k 0 cllllrlllt,11l1 cllml'o\lll1l\ )'1111111 cllml'l)' with II, . Iii THIS SUlI\'Ol1NA WAs lBRUHI) ATTHlllWQUllSTOFTHll rOLI,OWING PHHSONI NM1EI \~ILLl.AH 'I'AYLOI\, i\SQUIHI\ " , AI)IJIWBBI.......!!lI\ OUI\'J'lH OI\NTI\I\. SUITI\ 620 80\1'1'\1 , . . P1\lLAllliLI'\I'IA I'A 191 (Hi THI,llI'IIONEI (215) 2M,-0900 ___ SUI',I\I!MH COUI\'I'IJ) #1 A'I'\,OI\NHY FOI\( '\'11I\ _lllilll\NllANT I'ATEI (),~,;Q\95 lIY THE CoUnTI lJ'I'III)' Bonlnf Iho Cuml (Elf, '1/91) H QOMMLlN\:\T\i\IJ'IU H~PI\N N.H.YI,vA NJ ^ . COldNTYJJE.(;VM (IUHIAND ", WJ11'~'Y,' I'H Fllu Nu, _!.jI.~!"OI16n 'I'IU"INO, I, 1111'1'1:111 Nlll"1l HPH l'OliN ^ 'f'() 1'B.OlllJC.;HJ.!DQVMliN'I'S OH Tl!.!..Nrt5 EUlll.llfiq lVlnlY,I'\J.IUiIJANTJ.:O HULl! 4000,22 '1'01 ,_.G\!l!'1'!lIH^N \iF Iq':PPI\PII .fOIl I .. 1!1I!lln;,Nt~!Q!UAk..llQ!iPl'l'^l, IN~/lII' IIf 1'1'1011/1 ",linlll)'1 ~I~I:!IW: 1.\~"~III'H(~IIIIIII)" MII'I '"II'it'I' IIf Ihl. '111111""'~: 1'"III\\W.IA~:\rb\l!~lil~,~' I'lIl1rl~~rll"III'O Ilw flll\l1wll1l1 \IIII'\IIl1ol\l~ I1r --'-~.'.-r.'_~'r_' ..,._.~. ,11 ~ICI; 11lWlll' I NI:, _.._..~._-~_...,.. --- ." - - -~..n>'..__'''''_,"_n________ Ifill I f1hIU: 1:'1' H'I'HI';WI' "'HII~IJI~.J.lOO _. 1'11l1,^1lI\l,I'I\1.^ P^ 19103 1,\.I,It"", YI1\II1I~\' IlullI'/l1 III 1111'11 11'1111'11. 1'111!h', IIf 11"'11111'111111'111' IIll'rllIlIll'U 11I1I1."~ r"llll"~loII il\' 1I11~ "lhll\lUIlII,.II1IWlllur wllh Ihu 1'0111 (lc"lu IIf 1'III11I'II'll1l'lI, 111111" 1""'\' 11I111111'111111. I\'IIIIIIHI .'111111 '1I1,lrl1"~ 11"0\1111'"1'''' YI111 h,'I'o 110 rlullllll Bouk, 111 nrl I' II 1l1'11,Ul\l I 11 ,1H II 11 II h ", \'I1.llIf 1""1',"11111 Ill" I'llI'll', 1III'"l1hlclI1I1II1Ulllll1l1' '"IIUIlI. . i, , .If \'1111 (,'11 III 1'111\llIl'l1lhl1 11111'1111111111' '" 11111111' r"IIIIIII'II h)' 1111. 'lIhl'lIl1l1".wIlIlII1IWI1I1I)' (20) 1111\" ~f1or IIs80rl'lco, IIw l'~rI)' sotl'll1Ulllls .lIhl'lIl'III1I11~)' .l1l1k ,11'1I1111 1I1\I"r 1'111111'1'1111111 )'1111111 (111111'1)' willi II, THIS SUlIl'ollNA \-VAS IBHUIl)) NI' TIIII lWcjUIlHT OF Tim FOLLOWING PEnsoNI N Mllil ...J'lJJMMLTl1YbIIH,I.. !1f!ljII,IJlli,.... "'''u_._..,,,. AIJlJI\IiHSI_.__~l1!!u:!mTII;CI.:N'!'I:I( ,B,ul:I'i';_ f1}O .!~I\J'I'1I , ~.J'!IJ),!I!lI\L,el!!A I'^J\II!l~i THI.lil'IIONI!I "' {;U ~ J. ?I'(":llli,1I0. ..~___, BUl'lWMIi COUIIT 111111 .., A'ITOIINIiY I'nlll .,.'1'111:: P.I':F1-:il!'t\lfl' """'_' IJA"'1l1 , (11 ~~J.,,~.l,I(L -------'1J;'I'"IY III'ill IIflllt, CIIIIII (Ill(, '//97) .Ij 11l';II'I'lif I 01\'1'1'; l'IIIWI';qIJ I" 1.'1'1'; 'I'll II\';IIV 1m; 11\I 1\ 1I11111'11\';HI\ I'IIIIIIIIMI'I' '1'0 11111,1'; lilllHI, ~~ nTl'T~ III: GOII\\'I' 011 (\OI-lI'loH 1'1,1~1\1l 'I'IQI!1, .0000 Gllill'; Il(li \008-0(,~12 1U '1'11I': 1'\11'1"1'\':11 ('.!"-I ..Vii . Till" 1110, All\! 1111'1'1:11 I Illillll. " All 1I 1'1"11111"1'111" \11 lIol'vll'lI III 1\ IIllhp('11I111 1',,1' 11\11:\111111111.11 1111,1 \,hll1l\lI plII,lllllIl1l: \11 11111" I,(I(I\I.;!~ I-\lll\ 1111 hllhllll III . ,.\m,!;.IN,\.'!'~Y!.,(1IL. !~Qm!H\.!L.------- t!tdlllldlllll: 1:II1'\,IfloII I.hlll. ' (I) A 1111\ I,ill \If 11110111. 1.0 IlIlI'VII 1.1111 1I11hl""'1I1l wl\',h'll ,:oI'Y 01' I.hll nllhpllol1l1 1I11,nl:lll1d 1.II111'Ill.n 141111 11I11 111ld \11' 'Ill JJ VIl 1'11'1 III 1111,:11 pol'i',Y Ill. loonl: IWllnl.Y 'II\YII prillI' \.Il 1,1I11"t!nl.ll \III \41111'11 tllll III\hpl"'110 .111 1I11111\h\, I.ll Illl lIorV(tlt " (n A rllpy III 1.110 11I11.il:1l III I II 1,Ill1 I, , Jnl:llld.llll\ 1.1111 pl'lIpllllOIl IIl1bpOllnl\, .lu III.tnrl\'lIl 1.11 11111 CIII'I,lfil:lIl.il, p, ('II Iln IIh,lot:111I1I III 1,1\" IIllhpllOnn hnll h"on 1'0l'lllvtHI, onll "I (II') '1'1\11 IIl1hpllllllil wllll'hwlll hll IIol'vod ill Ulnnl,ll:nl I.ll tho !lIlhpllOnn which in nll.nt:llIlIl III \,1111 nodl:o IIfllll,nnl. 1.0 1I111'VII I.hll 1IIlhp()onn. 11"'1'1\ I...!()/JJL~.~, )n.LJ.'1.A.1U~11,OIL~1~-'lUIIIE Atl.ornny fill' DRVRIIUAU'I' Imll-1382fll, :1,0:1.:1 0 - L 0 'I CDI"HvlONHI1~^ 1_,',1'11 UV' PHlI'IN I:; YL,VAl'I TA 001JN'J'~' C)J.i' CUlvll.~H1FtI:,^Nn ill 1'1I~: HA 1'1'F.1I OF, COURT' (JI' COHIWN 1'I.1~^S ' B 'I' 11' ~ ne: TEll,"" 0000 -VB- '1'1\1., lllc. IIIHl 1I\1'fCIIIIISON CASE 'HO, l008-01t<i7~ " NO'J'] a B aI" I N'J'I'lN-T-:r.Q_,fi!1H VIUL,lli[!ll'O I~ tlll_'!'rLl'!illP\JC;.!:U)Qm!MI~N'l'1:i ( Hol.O, 9011 Iln'clnalld 1 Jut of loc,1I.ioI19 'fO I JEIJIlIFEI\ 1:1.1 Nf:, ESQ1l11\f; HCS 00 hehnlf of HJI.JJ~~1._'!J.I.L!~Q.."-.ll'g!!l.!l!).._._______ Iot.ends to SllrVll n 9uhp\1011I\ Idelll;icnl 1.0 t.ho 0110 I.hnt. io lIt.tnchlnl 1',0 I.hi G nol.!co, ,You hll"" t\iOl1\:y (20) dnya from I.hll dnte 1iotod helow in which 1.0 fllll of roeord and 90ryo Upol1 tho "ul1flerajgnod nil ohjoct.ion to tho 9uhpoonn. If no objoctiol\ is mndo tho oubpool\n may ho soryed purlluant. to tho. npp1Jcllhlo Pllnnsylvnl\in l\ulos of Givil Procodure /.000.21,. Completll cop.l09 of nny reproduced rocol'llll lIIoY he ol'llerocl ot. YI1\11' e~pon'se hy complotJ,ng t.ho ott{!chod counsel cnrd nl\d roturning snrno tD fiGS 01' hy contacting our 10cnl MGS office, DATE I 10/13/00 MCS on hohalf,of CC, HII.I.IAf! 1'/\"),01\ f1sqUIRf; -,.PH&~D0066Al~21 Any ljuestions regarding this mottOI', cOllt.act. " 'I'll}: HCS G1\OUP, INC, 1601 I1AIU:E1' S'rl\EE1' 1/800 ' 1'1l1l.ADELP!lIA PA 10103 (215) 21,6-0000 '. ( .,11 DE02-103755 :1.0~30~CO:1. ~ i~~ " ': ' .., ~::"."I'(),S;A'I'! ()U..!~,1,~ '1',:,:':' -: .., I'M;!':, 1 ,; ------1lE09J\!.lDilig~!';~1'!~!J, ...........__...____...,.., '..._ ..., __m...'._.......".._...._..~..!~9CA 'I' I !.llj rJi^111,:._._...._-'~ ..,....:......___.....___ !. , I1EDI0AI., !ill.I.I1~O, ANIl >:. HI,)' (S) BlioHl': I'1r:JlICAI, OI~N,!,EI\ 11Elncl\L, Al1D 1I0Sl'lTI\I. 1111,1. ' sIlOIU; 1,1r:110RIAI. 1I0f>I'l1'''I. X-MY 011I,\' SIIOHl, l'mHoRIAi. 1I0SI'I'1'M, MEDICAL AlID 1I0SpITAI, 1I1!.L IIP\YAl\D C10lJW1'Y QENl':l\AI, 11051'1'1'1\ }:-p.AY 0111,\' , IIO\'/ARD OO\lNTY Gf;/H:RAL 1I0lll'l,!,", I,IEPI01\1, AND 1I0S\'.1'I'/\I. 1111,1. 5'1', AGlms 1I0S!'1 'I'AI, >;-PJ\Y OIH.\, ST" I\GNr;S 1I0SpI'1'I\I, Mr:pI0AI., IIll_1,lNO, AIID X.R.~)'(S)I' IlR, HILI.IAMII, AIlOP' 'I1EDIOAL, IIILI.INO, AIID~-RA\'(ll) ,DR. E,I\, RUIIERO I1EDIOA1" 1I11.1,INO, AND XcRAi'(S) 'HI0IlAEI. IIl\OHII, H.I), 1,IEIlI0(l1" IIIl.IjlI1G, ANIl X.~R"\'(S.l DR, 111CIJflEL II. FIliI( (, ASSOO, IoIEDI0AI., IIll,I.INO, "1I1l X-I\.W(S) " .. Ill\, JAIoIF;S 1\, jUNl:F:R I1EDIC"I., 111I.1,II1G, AND X-I\" i' (S) PI\, JOI\I. HII1EH I1EOIGAL, IIll.I.IlH), (l1I1l X- M i' (S) !:OIWIIEI\ OI!II\oPI\AOTIO OEN'1'ER 11r:DIQAL ANP 1I0SPI'1'(lL III 1.1. "IIANO\'I;I\ OF:IIF;l\AI, 1I0SPI1'AL X- RAY ONL i' ' IIANO\'r:1\ OF;IIEI\AL 1I0spl'1'Al, I,IEOIOAI., IIll,!.IIW, ANIl X-f\Ai'(S) INHII(I 0110, I'I,D, . /; ;, I' " " .. " " I' j! " 'i " II ',; ,I' j, H I; ,," " " " ,. " " ,. , 'j ;\ DE02-10~7S5 J.0130-001 ~ClMt\1 0 N.\:\]1.!\.!,TUgEj~J1NNHYJ.L'~ANJ^ CQILf'f.I~Y.QJ!i;;.ill.1J1illI.LANn ~'rlTX VH 1 , , I I I I. " 1%1 Nil, ..._1.\}jJ,ft.::Qtl1!l.2 __'__,_., 'I'HI" llW, ~ IIU'I'CIIINHON SUIlIlQJlliAJQfBOf)\JCE POCUMENTI! QH THINGS FOH IJISCOY1Urr.PUHSJJ.M/T 'fa Iwen 4n(l9~~ '1'01 - CUS'!'!2!JTtlli...P.l'.lUl.COHllS-1!!).RL_.__"._li'tl-..lIHNlili.:Jll.lli.lTl'lll'-._____. . IN,IHW II( 1'1'1'1111 lit I!nlllYl WIIIIII1I\\'nl1l)' (211111,')'6 MInI 6nll'lrn (If 11110 6(11)1'111'1111, )'1111 :irn 1Illlnrnlll>)' 11111 rlllllll" I'lmlllre 1110 ((111i1wll1l1lll1r\II11111116 nr II SFl' "'''I''l'''i''I) I I 111161 . -~_~_,__,__--,-,-" '-..!.LUu ULU'-'-----._ , ----_._---------_._--~-- ---------.__.-......._~-..,---- .11 .JJCS G1\OIJI' TNC, ----- 1601 NAHKEL!!.'I'Iill!IT.._----.!~IIl'1'I\ Ball (I\llIlt...' PI.!!.b@EL'plIIh Ph 19103 ",011111.,)' doll VOl (II 111>llllenl\1lo C"1'106 of l\1e IlIlrlll11111116 01 I'I"d\ICO IlIil1nll 1011\Inolo,I \1)' Ihl6 611"1'001111, lonolllol willi Iho corllflcl1lo of rOI11I'II.'I1(O, lollw I'MI)' 11\.lkll1n Ihl8 10'1110811111110 11 1111 t066 11811111111101'0, "0111111\'0110 tlnhl HI80nk,In 11ll1't1!lrO, 1110 10,16\11111\110 r081 (If I'tol'l1I'll1l1lho cIII'I08 01 I'iodllclnn 1110 1IIII1go 0""11111, If )'011 f,ll110 I'lodllrll Iho IIOCll11101110 or Ihln!l6fo~lIlrod h)' Ihlo 0\1\'1'0011>1, II'llhII1IWOI1I)' (2011111)'611f101 116 6oll'lco, Iho 1'1111)' oOll'll1n Ihl6 811111'11011>1 mil)' 80ilk ,1 COIIII onlel rOllll'ollll1n )'011,1" 1011\1'1)' wllh II, . , THIS SUnpOflNA 'VAS ISSUED A""I'IIE I{):QUHST OFTHTi FOI.LOWING PEI\SONI NAMIlI .:.Jli1!tlJlli 'I'AYLOR, ESQlIIHE ,APDllIISSI '1'111\ OtlH'I'Tp O"N'l'I\l!..t-J!]JI'm 620 BOIJTII 1'1IIl,AIlEJ,1'1IT.h l'A --1.9106 TEI.lll'nONI!I' (215) _~.-"6-0l)00 SUl'llIiMIlCOUlr1' If) III ATI'OllNB\' 1'01\1 -_l1!!L,!!m:rrNllhN'1' :,', DATIlI 9.,\3Q\~~\ " IlYTllECOUlrl'l ,~ , (J.l'llly Sel1lnf IlIe COllrt " UOHlvIC:>!-J \"lI.,lA I. 'J' J I () I'i' I' !tIN N !:l Yi..v AN :rA .. Cln 11 1'1 '1:.'1' 0 Ii' UI1fvll',.IJ1Hl..A N P Iii 'rlir.: 1,11\1"11;1\ 01' I COIJi\T 011 GOHlIOIi 1'I'I';I\S S'I'IT?, ne: 1'EI\I'\ ,0000 -I's- Gt\sr.; !W! I!l1l8-01,672 Tl\L, lIIe, I@J HIJ'rcillIlSOH , .NO'I'.\ SUL9..r~_IWr!':N'L'!'!l.Ji!i!~V(i: _JL1?U Illif?tltll\..J.'9.J~.lwnt!n I~ _ Dna ll..MI~N'!'B. I HO~UI ~uu oncloHod li~t of 10catJonH ) TO, JENrlll'r:l\ CLIHE, ESQUIRE Hes on huh/llf of HIU.I1,!L'L6X!,-Q.~__.!~l!n\I:,~...:_.____._ int.undll to llurvo U Illhp\lunu il)ontic/l1 to thll ono tllRt iH utt/lched to thJll no\i<:o, \'011 havo twonty (20) days fl'OIll \.ho dnto jillted ho10\< i..\ which to filo of rucord nnd Hnl'VO III'0n tho IIndO\,llignud /In oh.J"l'tion to tho IlIhl'ofmn, If no oh.Jettioii, ill mndo tlw Hllhl'llUnn lIIay bOHorvod I'lIrllllnt to thu /lPl'llclhlu Ponnsy1vnnln Rll10R of Civil Procodllro (,001l,2I, , eomp1uto copieR of /lny rUl'rod\l(:od rocordll IIIIY ho ordorud at'yolll.' o):l'onse hy r;omplotingthe ,1I:tnchod cOllnsel cnrd nnd retllrnlng llalUU to HCS or by contacting 0111' locl1 Hes uffJ.o" I DATB! 10/13/99 " .1' HCS on hohnlf of ", _YII,I,-~^"I 'rA VJ.OR J;SQQ.!Il~; Attornuy for DEI'f:NDAN'r CC, "I~~IAI~ TAYLor, tSQUIl\11 1'1161, oP0661\1', 21 Any,qllRstinns regarding thJ8 lUattpr, ~untect ;, rm; I1CS GROUP 1 !No,. 1601 11ARKr.:T STI\EET 'paoo PHILADELPHIA'PA 19103. (215) 2.6-0900 !JJ;02-103755 ,:1. 0:1. 30 - 00:1. II, ; " CDlvll'1ClN\"I"A 1,'1'11 u It' 1'11;1'1 N p ~rl,V1\ N X1\ C1CI\.!N'!''( DTi' Cllil'11'.pn'U.,ANP' III Tllr: I'Wm:n 01' I " ,:01l1\'1' 01,> eoHl-1011 PI,I':AB ST!T(. l\C '" 'I'1':H11, (lOO(l ..\'B.. "" GASK HD, lPP8-(l~672 1'1\1,,\ IIIG, 1,IHl 111l'l'CIIIHfiOIl . , NO'I' ;tQ.!i.._Q~....L!.'l!!~ELti'!'_,'l~9_.. fl !1!!Y_tL!LfiUlIJ1 0 J1tl!L~!~9.._.l~!!g..!!.!!P 1'1_[1,9(1 P 11 a N'l'(i ", I .!JOI.U, li"O ,'nolnllnd lillt. o'f locnt.innll ) 'ro, JEHIUF1':l\ I;UIU:, ESQUIRE HCS pn huhnlf pf .\!,!.!~l,!NLT.I1.'ilig.B.....J.:fl..(l!!,l.!ill,____...._._tnl:ijndll \,0 Iloryo II s\lhponnll idontical 1;0 I.hu onl' thnt in lIt.t.lI\lhod \,othlo not!co, \'0\1 \1l1ViJ twonty (20) - 1\1I)'1l fF<l/n tho dnto lJlltod h(Jlo\~ .in I>'I\.1('h 1'.(1 fJlo of l'fll;ol'fl nnd Illlryo Ilpon \,\1n \lndol's!gnod nil oh.lo\ltioll to tl)'o Il\lhponnn, If 110 oh.lnctioll III mndll \'.ho \l,llhpoonn !nay he Illlryolt lJ\lrllllant to thu apl'l!\llIhlu pIJIlI1Il)'lvunlu t\\ll\'1l of Ciyi'l Pro\le<ll1ro /,00P,2/1,Cnllll'li,'t.o cnpill!! of nny rOl'ro<l\lco<l rOCOI'<l1l lIIay hIJ l1l'florndat YOllr oxpon!!\I hy cnlliplnt.1ng tho llttachnd cO\ln'"11 card un,t l,(,t\lrning Ilumo to HCS or, 1>)' COntRctIng 0I1,"'loc01 1,Ies offlce, IWIt:, 10/13/90 HeR on hehilf of ~].I,UAI'1 TAYI,Ol\ ESQUIII!; Attornoy fot' DEn;NDAN1' eel \I'ILLIAl1 'rA\'Lol\ r:SQUIP.r: , '1'1i6liOfJ 0 (, 6A\I,21 '" ,. An)' quostion!! ,I'oganling \.hill InAtt.ef, con\.oct " 1'111' JlcS GROUI' , !Ne. 1601 MARKET STREET paoo , plIll,ADr;I,l'lIIA I'A' 191 03 (215) 2/,6-0900 " , '.,., lJE02-10n55 :1. 0:1. 3 (j ~ b 0 i, , -- l\EgQ!H~.J\!';ill!!':!m;!J__.,:. '--C"'-- ..,,-..~..::._._.. '-' .. ...'- .~.... ,,_,_J'.().<.JAT.!9.lU!M1.1::,... T' _..., ,... m_____ __ ____uh___. 11ElllCI\I" 1l11,1,] I/O, Aljl> x- I\A\' (li I lillol\I': 1'lt:I>ICAI, CElm:l\ 11EDICAI, Aim 1I0lil'l'I'AI, II Jl,1, liIlOR)': 1'11-:1'101\1 AI, 1I05!' I 'fA I , i:.RA\' Ol/I.\' lillolm J.H:l101\lAI. 1I0lil']'!'AI, }.IEIllCAI, !11m 1101; 1'1 '!'AI, 1111,1. 1I0HIIHll COIlIj,!,\, G1WEl\AI. 1I0lil'l'J'AI, i:-P.A\' ONLY 110\1111\1> COIlllT\' Ot:I/EI\AI. 1I0HI'ITAI, HElllCAI, !11m 1I0lil']TAI, 1\11.1, li']', AGIlE5 1I0liI'1'I'AI, i:,P,A\'OI/I.\' li'l', AGIlEli Wlfil']'rAI. lol?:lJlCAI., 1Ill.I.llW, ANIl i:-III\\'(5) 1>1\, WJl.I,lf\'-II1, AIJOI,!' IolEDICIII., !l1l.1.]1l0, AliIl i:-lIf,\'(li) 111\, t:,A, Itlllll':WJ IolEPjCAl., III 1.1. lNo, IIIW X-I\I,\'(li) 1'lleIlM:1. IlI\OWN, '-loll, IolEDlCAl., !lll.LIHO, AI/Il i:-I\A\'(5) DR, IHcIIAI';1. II, l'll/t: [, ASI;OC, IolEQ1CAI., !lILLII/O, AIlIl X-RA\'(li) Pl\, JAME5 l\, RlllliEI\ IolEP1CAI., ,1l1LL11l0, A'W i:-HA\'(li) DR, .JOEI,lilIH:R 1':EP1CAL, IlILLl110, AIW i:-I\A\,(5) KOlmlml\ CIIII\OI'I\AC'j'lC q:WJ'r;i\ HEPICAI. AIm 1I0lil'l Till. B1I.I, IIMloVt;1\ Gt:/mRIII. 1I0SI'l'!'^" );-RA\' olll,\, lIA1loVf:l\ ot:I1EHAI. 1I0SI'1T/,1. l'IEDICAI., 811.1.]110, IIIiIl i:-RA\'(li) 1ll\WA CliO;' }.I,ll, " :l~;f 1.0CAT]OIl I. 1 li'I' ,;':'; . .~...-..~ ..-. . ..... ..-....- .....,.-~. 1':-"-',.,.--, I'AOl\, " ", " , .,j' .. " Ilt:02-103755J_ 0 j, 3D ....0 o:t. , I l~,! 1_ h: , , I 1 , !'i :1 ,I ,1,1 " ,; .. f;Sl 1\11\1 Q.N,Wlittl.Jlli1LI~liNNS.Yl.Y.t\ NI ^ QO \J NTY_Q F ~\J.MmU~Li\NJ2 HT1T~ VS 1'1111 1'1110 .._199l1-0i((,'/ ~_~_ '1'1\1.. HW. ~ lill'I'ClIlNSON SUIlPonNA.IQJj\QlJUC\l\JOCUMENTSOH THINGS rmU1.L'i~oY.lili.LEllilinJANT TO !tU],E 400l)~ Tal _CtlS'I'Q!l.!.!l!L!1U\l\COIU1J!..J::!.HU___..____Nl CIIAI\J, lI\Wl'Ltit.Jh.11 , \N,'"wnfl'cr,n"nrli"I\l)'1 Wlthlll 111'(1111)' (2(1) ,I~y. ~fI,lt .utl'll'o Ilf 1111. ",hl'nOllnl Y"II MO ".\,l\ltuII hI' Iho fllmllll ptlllhlfO 1110 filII IIII'I 11[1 IIIIfIlln0l119 ot Ihll1[191 ,.___._____~ slm 1.!"CII m ..________ . NeB G1\OUI' 1NC, 1601 NAIlKI\'I' B'l'HEl\'I' B1l1'l'1\ lIOO ,11 _________,_____________ (1111111""1 I'I\Il.AJll\J.l'lIIA I'A 19103 ""n IMY ,Iollvor III \1\nlllo[llhlo fllplu. IIf II'" 11\'01111\01\1' lit ptllllllOU Ihlllll' toljllOSluli hy Ihl. 'lIhll\l0l1'1' 10[lOllwt with Iho fotllfk,11o of fO\1\pIlM1I'O, 10 IIw pnrl)' \1\.\llh1[1 Ihls 10ljllosl .111110 ,1I1I1\u" 11911111 ~hl1l'o, ""11 hnl'o 110 tl[lhl lu,ouk, III .1111,,,,,,0,1110 ron'"l1nhlu 011'1 of 1'101''''111[1 Iho \'oplu, or I'mlll"llIlIlho 1IIIIIIIs SllIl[lhl, If )'1111 fall 10 prolllloo Iho IllIfIl\1\OI1I. Ill' Ihll1l1s Il1ljlllrod hy this '\lhl'"ol1a, wllhllllll'ol1l)' (211) Ih\)'. Mlor II' 'orl'lfo, 1110 pMt)' '0fI'111!: Ihli ,"hI'OOln m.1)' ,ook ,1 mllrl I1nlor olll1\polllllllYIIIIIII oO\1\l'ly II'llh It, . THIS SUIlPOENA W AS ISSUED AT THE HEQUEST OF TIm FOLLOWING PHl~SONI NAMEI \H1.L1AN 'I'AY1.01\, ~~'!.!l)!.!.l\Ii ___ .A \J\JIlESSI '1'111\ CII1\'1'1 S Cli~'l'Jm, Slll'l'li 620 HOll'l'lI ......1.IJ.IJ.AIlI\1.l'lIlA ____rl<___JJJ,06 THI.EPllONEI (215) ;l/,6-090.Q______ SUI'IlEME COUlIT I\J #1 ___ ATrollNEY !'Olll __~I'II!L.!l\iF~NlMNT..___..:..__, lIYTllE COUIlTI ',~' JI\'I:'I~r- DATIlI q-\-3.o\~l:.L----- !J.I".I)' Hunl of t1w CUlIl't " (llf(j 1/97) ';" .;f, 1,- I~; ';1 H 'ri'. ~l ~.V , !~;k , 17& 'l~ ,~'~ ,I \~:" -' ,. CO_MM 0 ~jYHAlJ1L 0 1~,[1JlliNRl'1Y...i\NlA CO U .NIX.Ql!.. CU MUliIUdtNJ.1, SlrI'r~ I'S !'/l1l Nn,._U)9!H11i672 -"--_. '1'1\1., INt:, ~ IIUTClITNsoN SUIlr..QlINA TO rlillJ?uCE DOCUMENTS DB THINGS FOH QISCOVERY..PUHRUAm:":[QJWLIJ 4009.2~ '1'01 ~ (]US'I'OIlI~N O!:'J!liCOI\!!H FO!!.L__. IJH, mCIItili.!<..Jh lIINK & _ASHO(], (NAI1Wllrl',t.1l11 Ilr l'nlll)'1 ' Wllhll1l\1'el1l)' (2U) II A)" ,lf1"t 8"t1'1rO ,,( Ihl. 8,,1'1'''''1111, )'11\1 MO I1t<lOtolll'l' Iho ClIlltlll1l'tl111"co Iho (olll1wll1!1 <111(111110111' 01 . . '. " ". Him A'l"l'AGI ED " . - - " - - - - . Ihll1l1.1 ___..____'____________,__ -----y------. _.__._-----_.,-_._-~ ~ Nes GI\OUI' TNo, ,1601 NAI\KE'l' S'I'IU':1\'1' SUI'l'1i BOO ,I --. '___~__.________._____.._.....~_____.__~_'":"-~__ IAlhl"..) I'!\TLAIJI':J.PII1A Ph 19103 " YI1\1 '11")' 110111'1'1 I1t mAll. 101111'111 "UI'III' 1I(lho 11111'\111111111' 111 plllllllclIllIlI1I1' tOI1\1\I8101lI')' Ihl. 8\1I'I'101111.1."611IhOt IVIIIl Iho' corllnr.le 0('CI1111pllt1l1\!o, lolhll pMI)' m.llllIlllhl. rlJ~II081 J1IIIW"llllloR'"RloII "hl1l'o, YIIII hl1\'o 1\11 rlghlIII.ook.111 . ' 11lll'l1l1ro, 11\11 11"'81'I1,lhlu CI18II1( I'tol'l1tll1lllho cnl'llIR nt I'rI'llmll16 Iho Ihllll1' ,~I1I1Bhl, I( )'011 (,,1110 1'1",hICO Iho lli'C\II1WI1I. I1t Ih1l16' tl'lllllroll h)' Ihl. RIII'pnOI1I1,wllhln IWOI1I)' (2U) <111)" o(lot II. .0rl'lco,llw I'M I)' 'Oll'll1l1lhl. ,"Ul'nol1l1ll1l1)' Rouk 11 collrlolllor CIIIIII'IIII1I111 )'(11110 clll1\l'l)' \l'lIh II. TI.IlS SUllPOHNA \V As ISSUED NI' TIlE IWQUliS'I' OF TUll FOt.WWING 1'llIlS0NI NAMEI \nLLIAH 'l'AYLllI\, I\SQUlHl\ ADDIll!SSI '1'111\ CtJlt'l'lH OEN'I'EH, RUl'l'l\ 620 SOU'!'II P1IILAIlI\J,PHIh _____!'A 19106 TI!I.EI'IfON~,\1 --..i~~1-2!!.<!..-o90() SUl'rUiMH COUI\T 111 HI __,__ ______ A'ITOI\NI!\' l'Oltl __ 'l'1\t:"J!l~I'!i..liI!.~1f~_____ II'\' TIlE COUIl'n bATEI .---9..Lulss Ittulhullut " n.,lIlIy Senlllf thll Cnutt .1' C01"1l"'10N \'lE.AL '1'11 Qi" pn;N N H Y!..,VAN :I:A 00l,IN1T'~( 0 I)' ClUI"'1BH1RLA ND III TilE HATTER 01'1 COUI\'l' OF OOH/oION I'I,EAS STITZ , He 'l'EH/oI, 0000 -I's. O^~~ liD 1 1998.011<i72 TRL, IlIc, AliIl IfU'rc!I I NBON NO'l'I0J01 01' IN'I'BN'I"I'O S~IIlVI') II SIJIlJ10);INlI 'I'D P I HlIJ II 0 HI I)QOUM)~IJ'I'Q "~4--""'_____._4_____~.__.._........__.._~~._____.._.---....-._. _.______~ ( Not!" "ou oneloGod lint I1f locutionr. I TO I JF.IHlI FEI\ 1:1,llm, ESQUIRf: , . Nes 00 hoh&lI' of lQliLg!:L:J:A\'I!.<?U~g!!!I\E____... il1l,undl' to GOl've 0 Bllhpll\ll1~ .ldopdca1 1.0 tho one t.hat in nt.t.nc)\,"\ 1;0 thin not.ie!!, \'011 hnve 1;\~Olll;y, (20) 11(1)'5 frulII tho dnt.o 1iGt.od 1>ulo\~ in \,'h.lch to UJu of 1'0,'01'11 ond nol'Vo, npol1 tho nl1dorr.igOod 011 OhJllC\.ion to (',ho )'\11>1'00110, If 110 obJect.ion 1r. 1I10dll tho IlnbpOOI1R 11\0)' bo GIll'Vod p\II'Sllllnt to tho /Ippllcablo )>onn")'lvon.lo 1\01u9 of OivJ1 PI'Ocoelnl'1l ,,009,24, CDlllplot.o cop.lO" of ill1)' lopl'odnelld I'econln 1110)' bll onlel'o!l ot )'otll' expenso b)' ,coll1plot.ing I;hu at.t.nc!wd conn"ol cill'd ond I'otnl'ning 501110 t.o Nes ,01' b)' cont.aeting 0111' lr.'cal HCS offico, DATEI 10/13/99 ~OS 011 behalf nf ..\iII4.!AH TAYLO!\..2SQUIR~,~.....:- Att.orl1oy for DEF~NDANT ce, WILLIAN TAYLOR ESQUIRE' I'lfl; I, OfI066A11,21 AllY queniDll9 1'l,gal'll.lllg tbis mntt.o['," contact. " Tim Nes GROUP, INO, 1 ~01 HAl\RET ~TREEr .,'800 PIfILAbELMllA PA 19103 (215) 2/,6-0900 ,I 1)"02-103755 :!,O:L30,,..dbJ. 'I.; " QOMMQ NWJ~IiLTlHl E.l~H1'IINfiY.LY_t\.NlA f:'.f].lJ.J'II!J:LIW,CWM.I\ IHi.LANI1 WIII'r~ vs I I , I I I I I I'lIu Nn, .-199!!.::i)116,?1~__,_,__ '1'1\1" 1 H(:, ~ 1111'1'01\1 NRON SllilEQ.H1'l.A.TIUBOlJUCB ()OCUMllliTS on 'l1llNQH EQJU2JHCOYlmx.r.ldJ~SUANT TO IWLlill!!Q,~ Tal ..J:..t!.l!:tQ!l..T AN .!.!.I' llEao1\Il~~.1'91\L___,..KQtlllli!\lUlliJlillJ~I!-'illTl.!lJlliN'l'\qi_.-:.__.__,____ (N"nD"( 1'010"1\111 I!nlll)'I , \\'lthln IWOI11)' (2U) 11,1)" AfIOI.'"IVICll IIf Ihln RII\'ll(Illl1~, )"111 '110111'\"10,1 \')' Iho rllnfl111 I'Hlllllcolho (1I\1l1wlnll,h'CIII1Wnl8 IIf' Ihlllll61 ______.__.__,_. . . RilE NI TAm !Ill ., , ,11 Hes 01\01l1'_INC:'_,_.:..~~~.t!A1\KE:!:_~!I\E1\'1' , R!lJ'l'j~ 1~<!.Q...._-.!:.!UJ,AIll\1.PlllA_. 1'A 1910~1 IAIIIII""I ' \'1111 '11~)' ,lollI'lIf III m~lIlollll1lc clll'I1I6 "f Ihu ,IIIcllnlPIl16 IIf PIII,IlIfOI. hlnll6 "'III.IC810d h)' IhI6811\'\'OO'''1' 11100111111 wllh IIw COlllflcMollf cIIIl\I'IIMWo, lolhoporty lII~klnolhl6 fOllll081 ollho 011l111186\1Hl01I ~\l(I\'O, \'''" hovol 111 Ilnhlln 8ook,In Mlvonco, Iho t'lo18nllohl0 co'lnf I'topMIIln1hll clIl'loR III 1'f(1I111r1nnlholhhln8 Hllllnhl, .,' , If )'nll f~\lloljtlllhlrolho,loclllllcnl. Of Ihlnn8 tOIlIlIIl1\II>)' Ihl8' RIIl'l'oonll, within Iwonl)' 120) dllYR lIf10f 116 HOfvlco, Ihol'orlY .ofvlng Ihl. 6\11>I'00no ")")' 800k II I'nllfl olllof COl1ll'o\lllln )'011111 Clll1ll'ly with It, ". ',rIllS HU\lI'OllNA WAS ISHUllD AT '1'111; HEQUIlST OF '('I iii FOU.OWING I'l!I~HONI NM11!1 II'l1,1.1AM 'I'A\'I.OI\, IlSQIII1\\i APD1WSSI 'I'IIE C,~I\'I'1R CmfI'lm I ~!l.l'I'E 620 HD!.!'I'II 1'1ITLAIlF.!,l'll1A I'A IJlllH\ THl.El'llONHI (215) 2Id)~()90D SU\'IHlMI! COUI\T II) III A'ITOI\NHY 1101\1 ~.-'.I1!.E DEF!iNI.!..AN'.!:.______ DATE, -.---9-I~.95 nOl'ul); Sonlnf Iho Cnntl (Err. '1/97) I' ,,\ ',' i~ ) ",1 nOl"lI"lON\'/I.':^ \,,',1'11 U I." P Iq'lN !:lYI,VAI'l :t:A U 0 111'1 'I' Y. (l F Cl 11I"n~ Il1 1{.1 ,A NP 11/,Tlll, HI\T'I'f:1\ OF, COUI\T 011 COI,l~IO!~ I'I,EAB 81'11'(. I I\G 'I'1(I\H, 0000 CASE IW, 1008-0'16'/2 -VR- '\'fa., 111C, ^IW IIlITCI! 111soIJ N.o'I2.P I~~. 01,:... T W!'.I'l !tl.'J'g_.lJmW!L!UH!l!P()I'm!l._TQ.u\:!iP!~!QtLJ2QQJLM m NT!! I !lot,,, !i~(! nnclO!iHd li,!t of lncill.!onll ).. TO, Jl:;llInn:R t:1.IIJE, ,;squIIn: I1CS un behalf of 1;'11.1,IAH TA\'LOR ESQUIRE intundll to ~urvo il lllllll)l1oon i<lul1\:ica1 t.o thll '.:;,iili:iilit'''Ii;-'1it:iiir:l;;;;r'i:o\ll{;;u.nol.!"u, \'nq hllvn I"'UO\:Y '( 20) <lays frum t.hu datu 1i"tnd hn1u\; in which tn q10 of rucnr<l nn<l "ervu lll"ln t.ho qn<lersigne<l 1111 objuction to th,) r,qbponna, 1 f IIn nbjection I." lIIa<lu t.ho Bllbp\lOnll 11111)' be slIrV'HI pllr"llant tn thl, applicable PennsylvanIa Hlllon of Civil Proco<lllrll /,009,2/" Cpl1lp1utll GopiuB of any reprnclllcell n,corull lIIay bo onlurud at YOllr uxponsu by COIlll'lut.il1g tho ,1\.t./lchod Cnlll1B1I1 Gal'll and ['('tllrning same t.o l'lcS nr, by contacting nqr lhcnl Hes nffico, DATEI 10/13/99 ." HaS nn hehalf of \11.1,1.1 "1'L1" \'I,OR E.~gIJ1RE "ttorl1oy for DEFENPANT co, \lll,L1/111 TA\'1.01\ ESQUIRE PIl6/,09b66A1/,21 AI1)' lj\1ostiol1u rogarding'thiu lantt.nr, Gontnct TilE ).lCS GROUP, lIle, 1601 I1ARK,;T S'fI\Er.1' faO() PIl1LADE~Pll1A ~^ 19103 (215) 2/.6-0900 'il', ~ " . I;' I II I; :i I, " I)E02-103755 :1.0:1.30-00:1. , " 1\ I 11,:-;', , , -_~l',~fQ!~0.~_.nfQy'~,~n:~...........,. .........'..'''...__.__, ,., .'. -....--."...-.-....~.'u....\l(!.~:^T !.()ll~.Ib'!H!:;_.:.__..,....._._...._______.__..___ ",. . ,-. . -.J " ,,:~,~ ~'-__.I~)~;,IITl (l!L.(! illl'.,__..::.:.:;, PArIl':, 11::DICAI., BILLING, AND >;-nAYIS) fiEPICAl, AIm 1I0Sl'1TAI. BILL >:-Po.W ONI.\' 11E!lICAI, AHP lIosh TAl, [\lI.I, >:-P,A\' Oil!.\' HWIcAI. AN!J 1I0SI'I'fAI. Illl,I, >:.?'AY ONI,\' HEDICAI., 11I1,LlNG, AIW l;-f.A\'IS) flF.DICAI" 11I1.1,INO, ANlJ X-P.!I\,(S) , , 11EDlOAI" BII,I,7NO, AND X-RA\'(S) HEDICAI., BILLING, AND X-RAY(S) HEDICAI., BILLING, AND X-RAYIS) I1EDICAI" BII,I,I/W, AND X-RAYIS) MEDICAL, BiLLING, AND X-RAY(S) HEDICAL AND 1I0SI'I'I'AI. BILl, >:-?AY oN!.\' I'I"PICAI., BnLING, AND >:-P.,\\,(S) " , HIIOIU~ /'1f;PICAI, m:wn:r\ SIIOIU: /01',11'101\1 AI, 11051'1 'I'AI, SIIOI\!: flt:/,IOi\W, 1I0SI'I1'AI: II0HAI\P GO\JIl'I'Y llENEI\Al,' IMl'l1'AI, ,,1I0HAj\P r:o\JNT\' Gt:JH:I\,\L 1I0SI'1 'I'AI, G'l", 'Ao/mB 1I0'SI'I'I'AI. B'l', AoNBS 1I0SplTAL lJl\, linl, 1 AN II, Anol.!' Pi\, I:, A, 1\111ll'I\G MICIIAEI. IlRoWH, M,!J, 1)1\, NjClIIA1'I, Il, PNK f, ASSOO" ))1(, .1i\I'll';S 1\, I\IIHa:R Ill\, JOEL \Hllt:l\ KONlJNER CllIli\oI'RACTIC CENTER IIANOYEI\ OI,;NI':RAI, 1I0SI'I1'AI, lII\JlOYf:R aBNEI\AI, 11051'1 'fi\l, INHllA CliO, M,D, " .". t. II~ r" ,,' I'. " " ILl, Ii i_I< " " " '" I',;' " " ,. " II " p I " , 'I, " " " , I Dt:02-1o;'/55 :1_ 0:1_:3 <;;1 - Oo;i 1 :,i" ,,', IN TH!: GOUin OF COMMoN PI.I~Afj OF CUM!~ERI-ANP COUNTY, PENNSYWANIA STEVEN i:, STITZ and Ji:AN STITZ, , plninllffs No. 1998,04672 VB, JURY TFMI. PEMANPr:D TRI., INC, and RO!3ERT HUTCHINSON, pefendants CIVil. DIVISION 'I.AW , TO: llil~Q1iliA.T.Q..P.BQQ.l.lGl~..QQ.Q.l,Uyll~~IS 0 flllilNt:lli E.QB PI SCOVEB~.!1U8t'l1IQ..B1!l..G.-!l91l1L.22 CUSTODI8tI...QE...Rf:;QQBD5 FOR: 1,IUIillTYHOM[;;J1.JNQ. , (Name of Porson or f:nll\y) Within twenlY (20) d~ys after service of this Bullpoena, you <lre orejllreq Ily the coun to procluce IIle folloWing documenls or Ihlngs: llliY.JllliLlliUl1fQfmallon aDd/or dO!lliJJlftlllilllill.1Jn YOllr fllft..rnsmrda relatL'm. to the ab.o.YJttfttftfenced DefendnntJ3.oilllrlJ:lUlcl1lUliQO, al 31 5. QUQillL~I~YJ2f.k..EA 17403 (AcJcJrsss) You I1l<lY deliver ormalllegillle caples of the rlocuments or produca tl1lngs reqLlested by this sUPpoena, togelher wlttllhe oerllflcate of compllanoe, 10 the party milking thie request at Ihe adqress)lsleq allove, You have tile right la seek, In advance, Ihe reasonallle cost of preparing the caples or proquclng the things SOUght, /, ,If you fall to prodLice the documents or things required by this subpoena, within twenty (;20) claye O1fier its service, the peny serving Ihls sLjbpoena may seek a COLl/1 order compelling you 10 comply with It. 'THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THr: REQUr:ST OF THt:: f10I.LOWING PERSON: N01me: Address: .!!llinlfer A. 1<lIn8, ESllillm llful~iJh Queen Slreet XillJs, PA 1740~ ' illll 846.3838 lliillQ.Q EllllnllffJi Telephone: Supreme Cour11D II: Attorney For: BY THE courn: " ',I " I' DATE: Prothonotary/Clerk, Civil Plvlslon "." Seal of the Court Deputy ., ,. i " \ , , '" ..1' , ' i I i IN TI'II~ COlJrfr or: CCJMMON PI.EAS 01' CUM!3ERI.ANP COUNTY, PENNGY\.VANIA.. { , ~( , STI~WN I~. STITz anel ,IFAN STITZ, PlnlnUffa NIl, 11l1l8.01IG7~ vs, .' JUIW THIAI. PI:MANPEP i , (\ (" II i I~i I,,' ) 1'.1' \' , 1.\'" ! . '{ \" TR~, INC. find F~oI31::RT l'IUTCI-IINsoN, Oefanclllnts CIVil. PIViSION . l.AW iilJ.lli"...Qfilil:UQ.E.B..QmJ.QIl.I2QQU M f;N.TlLQB-Il:lIt'lQ.1:l . FOH DlfiQQ.IL1ill1'..fl.!BllIM~1.I9-RUbli..1D.o.l1.?.2 . TO: ,__Q.\mIQL1.11\N..OCBG-QQJill.S..EQI3.:...QJ.QQJJ.GRVI; . (Name of Purson or r:nllty) Wltllln twenty (;20) daya O1ftal' service of Illls sLillpoenn, YOLl are orclered ~lY 11113 court to prOcl~IC(!l tlW fqllowl ng cjp~U me n t s 01'\111 ng s: llI1YJlulifl1UniQIlllillllln.nndl.Qr..f1Q.GJJlllftnlB UQllJlLY.QI.U:lllJUftQIllilll..t:lllil1l'Lfl 19-1hll.a!m.v.fti.SlllillIDa[l.ct..QIZLl}lli!llI1l,.BQIl1l1U:iuIQl1]lWQU, 3'1 S, QlIeen 8\(ll.ftL'U1f1\.1'.8.j].illl;L~___ (Ac1Qress) YOLlmny deliver or mElllleglllle ooples of tile docLlments or procluoe 1I1ings requested Ily this sLlllpoena" . togetller with tile oer11f10l.1te of compllanoe, to tile PElrty l1laklilg this request at tile aqdres!l listed O1lloVe. . YOII I101ve 1I111 rlgl1t to seek, In arlvanoe, tile reasonallie cost of prep<lrlng tile ooph!ls or produoing tile things sOLlgllt. . <ll If YOLl fall to produce Ille doclllnents or t11lngs reqLllred by this sLlbpoena, wltl1in twenty (;20) clElYs after i\s service, the 11FlIW serving \l1ls sLlllpoenEl may seek EI oourt order compelling YOLl to compiy Wltlllt, THIS SUI3POGNA WAS ISSUED AT TH12 REQUEST OF THE FOI.I..OWING Pi::RSON: Name: Address: ," .Jennlfer A 1<lIr:lft.~nu1m ;U.~.Q.!Jlh..Qj,Ill.ftI1JiII:ft.qI t9I.K..PA 17403 17m 848.3836 !i6.QQQ Eloll11ltfJi Telepllone: Supreme qOLlrt IP II: ,AlIorney For: I3Y THE COUIU: DATE:, Prothonotary/Clerk, Civil Division Seal of the COLlrt ,. DepLlty " . IN THI; COURT OF COMMON P~!=AS OF CUMI3ERI.ANP COUNTY, P!=NNSYi.VANIA . ST~V!=N 1:, STIT~ ilnq JEAN sTITZ, PI<llntlffs No, 1998-04672 'Vs, Jl,JIW TRIAl.. PEMAND!:D TRI., INc, ancl !, RO!3ERT I,\JTCIlINsoN, pefenclilnts OIVl~ PIVISION . \.AW ,SUBPOENA TO PROPUOE DOCUM~I~9E\ . FOR DISQ,QVERY PUI~SUANT TO RUI.E 4009.22 TO: OUgTODIAN OF RECQBQ.~Rl OONSTRUCTORS, INC, , (Nsme of Person or !::ntity) . Wllhln twenty (;20) clOlYs after service of Ihls sLlppoena, YOLl are ordered 11Y Ilie cOLlll 10 procluoo. the following do04menls or tlllngsl any ancLlliUu{Qrmation and/or dOOLIIl1lll11ftllo.l1.Jl1"'y.QlJrJlIIH\'lllQIJJfi rJllullvJl 19J1le above:mmrenoed Defendant. Robert Hutcl1l(lftQQ. " at 31 S, Queen StW!"y"Qlli~PA 17403 (Aclclreas) YNI may deliver or mallleglllle caples of Ille dooLllTlents or prodLloe \hlilgs .requested by tllla SLlbpounll, togetlier wllll tlll.'l certlfioate of oOlllpllanoe, 10 tile parw mOl king tills request at tile edQms6 listed <l1)OVll.. Youlwwe the right to sl;lek, In aqvanoe, \hereasonel1ln cost of preparing tile caples or procllmlng the tlllnga. sOLlgllt, If Y04 fall to prodLlce Ille qocLlrnents or Illlngs reqlllred by thlssj.lllpoeI1!l, wltllln Iwenly (20) day a after 118 servloe, tile party serving tills sLlPpoenOl 1ll,00Y seek a COLll1 order compelling YOLI to comply with It, (, THIS SUI3POENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQU!:ST OF THt: FOLLOWING PERsON: NamlJJ: Address: Jm1nlfer A, "line. Esqulm. 31 So Lith Queen Slmlll Ymiw:'A 174Q;1 !illl.Mll.~ 66960 ElIlInllffll Telepllone: Supreme COLlnlD II: A\\orney For: /3Y THE COURT: DATE: Prothonotary/Olerk, Olvll Plvlslorl Seal of the QOLll1 ..__.___....l.__~_'I'r'............. DepLlty I " IN llll: COIJIH OF COMMON fll.I=AS OF CiJMI3I=HLANP COUNTY, PI~NNS'(I.VANIA STIW'~N I:, 8TIT7- onrl ,JI~I\N SlIT(., Plaintiffs No, IOOIHhlll7~ VS. ,JUIW mlAI. P':MNJPI~D TRI., INQ, iHlrl RO!3r~I~T HUTCHINSON, Defel1dtll1ls ", CIVIL PIVISION . LAW YOLl Intly dellyer or l11alllegllJle oopll3s of t11fl qOOUllwnlsor procluce Illll1gs rsquestecl Ily this sUllp'oeI1Ol, together with tile certificate of OOlnplt01noe, 10 tile pany fTlaklngUlls reqLlesl at the Oldcjres/1 t1iitec1 allove, Yap Iltlve the right to seell, In ac1vOlnofl, the reQsonallle oost of prepllring tile ooples or prodLlalng theUllngs soughl, . 'If YOLI fall to proclLlce the doouments or Ihlngs reqqlrec1 by lhis sLlPpOe'ntl, withll1twenty (20) cjays' 'after its servlos, the pany serving this sUppoenOl mOlY seek" oOLlr1 orcler oQ/1'Ipelllng you to comply wltlllt. ,. THIS SUI3POi:NA WAS ISSUED AT THr: R!:QUEST OF THE FOLL.OWING Pi:RSON: ' I- . . , " " NOllne: Address: Telepl1one; SLlprSma C01ll11D I~: Allorney For: . Jm1illfer A. I~IIne. Esqwm 31 SOllth QUeen ~1r!lliJ . Y.9.ds, PA 17403 17171 846.3836 fllif1QQ elall1t1ffs " BY THE COURT: DATE: . Prolhonotal'Y/Clerk, Civil Division Seal of the Court I.,. Deputy 'Nqv 101 ?OOO 10 ?VI\I,I NO GIG r ;/~, ,1 1 I I I . I IN THf; Cfl\!HT Ul1 cr.ll\lMON 1'\',1\"\:-1 IW (!\!!\I'lJi:H.l,,~NH CIWNT", 1'11:NNHnvJ\II'\. 'StlWJ:N ~;H'f'(Tiililri .IHA"N ST!1'~ .... U" ) NO, I !.l!JH.(Wl7(. ) ) ) ) ) ) VS, '~:~~~:~::~:.:r::") ti f,1 t1, 'J J IN, i\i, i ! I,.. \ I' I F'.t, , I 'f I!'! \ 'I \ TRI., INr), 1\1111 IVJ13ER'f fl1nCU!N~()N n~!D1m TO Slj;nH~d~U:I(~(}~'I1~\!!';~\.NP ::NIl TO TJm PItQTHONOTAHYI. " 'jQllcll>' llmrk the nPIlVlhQnptioncd mllt\~T sei\lvl1, qlsQIlI1\hl\led lu,d i~I,dqrl Il11Pn pn>'I11PI1\. 'I,'. of' YO\lr 90S\S 1l111>', 'Iii 10\.TIl1J:RM!~N. MARl' & GM1,"~Y n\"IJ';r)~i.,;~~~- ...~,~. ~ I $, QueQn Stroot York, PA 171103 (717) 848-38)8 . '\\\I/me>' tbr Pluintiff I 1'\~Pllllllq t;:"url r.r,l, //61\150 \'~ "I ,I' rj~. I" ; ) I , , i I ! ,. D^l'hl~ I '/../5' IE. D._ " , " III " I ,I .,