Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-04838 WII.I.IAM C. COH'I'OPOlll.OH lJAY11) I.I'OHTI!I\ .\!SI.I!M.1'1I11.PH AI.I.liN c. WIlI.clI qIAl\I.!!S I'. MAcKIN' COIiTOI'(HJI,()H, FnH'I'I~H &, l~lIq4nH A'1'I'OlINIWH ANP CO\JNHI!I.l.P\lH 1\'1' lAW k~I MI\IIKI\T HTIlI!I!T 1'.0. nox m 1..llMOYNI!, I'I!NNHYI"VI\NI,\ 17IH~.llm T\!I.IWiIONI! 7(.1,2121 Al\ll.\ COPIl 711 .. 't)~76H"JI Murch II, Il)l)l) ," I, PIIIII.W. Clrogo, l~sqlllro POST & sellE!.I., p,C. 811110 1000 240 01'l1l1llvlow A VOIIIIO Clln111 lilli, PA 170 II .,' ,. Hl~ I . llilL'Jlluuil!c..tll.Ji 11lI.CllLWU.\!K DOliI' Mr, Grogo: P\II's\II\\11 10 \11ydlsc\l8810\1s Ihls wock wllh ~o\ll' lIsslsln\1l. cncloscd plollso (Inil Iho Notlco ofl\rbllrnllo\1 1\1 thc nhovo.cnpllo\1od I1lllllcr, Thc IIrblt\'lI116111\'11I IlIkc plncc III thc ofl\cos of C0810po\llos, Foslc\' & Flolds, locnlod III H31 MlIrkol SI\,ool, I.CI110)'llO, on TlIosdll)', Ap\'1113, 11)l)C), cOllll1lc\1cll1gll\ C):OO 11,\11, " . Shollld )'011 hnw 11\1)' q\lcsllons o\, COIICCrnS, plCll8C do not hcsltlllc to conlllc\ mc, Slnoo\'cl)', . 'C()S;2~PO\JI.OS'~FOS'j 8: FIELDS . ___~ u.,.;.1 ~ . :ltftt.{ Ami I" Clclhl\\wh .. PII\'nlcgnl ro\' Dll\'ld .I~'oslcl~sq\ll\'o . ' ., , ... " D.IF/lIlg Encloll\I\'C ,/ f {II If: ' . \( .. .. , .. ,. t, " " ,. II l~ ~~I i " ~;,Ul . . " ~ ta' ~ " " ~ ,'I " " ,- \, .' .. .. " 'o, . 'II " ",' " '. 'H! :", ....::;~~~I:<t~'__ , "._.... '.It,-'- _e,._" -'" , I' . '. ,':. _ " ~:- ,': -' _: ','"l . J . . ('~r.~.~ ~\0'.:) , "~.l~~'" . "", "t, ,) , .., :Y:-.N::.",:i(.;;';,_:;'!_1 tluJui.M(...fc.J / A~.), .';i . ~', . .\~:.._~.__~:' "lll" ~ ,."(1", f ~. ) ;/ V "~LL!I.L;L.j4~(L~.:L.~.- 'l; ',' ~.:.~."..".. ,,,...:\~ 1\, :, ' , " ~1'O"" ,:~;--'~'''''.'''' .3I'"C!)''' ( (}'\ n.~"'" on. r.'1~~'~'~'~h' ? f ,)1.:./(-((..(0(: J~4l,:: .t... ", 1'~ /S..;I//".Clfi '. ,.,'~ ... ,," 'j> ;.;,:,.......... .'....:I.<.:~~." CU'x-~. l.....fl.LU.tn.I~I...._(Iy.J).-.i ,SI...__._..~:~....(...- ", '~' ~..."..,..,.., ""lHl,'J . - -----....-.-. rl\I1@,3105',' _~.....,,, d" 0f.Cl,jl.t~. le-c,f,(J,(IILt:L4,~ r d /. 0$/ ~.I'I'I, l.U 14~. Q,j , ....".~;. 2~1?<? ... At(t:i../4Q / It.d,;J' I?C.U.n:I)L(:L l{f~_~......Z:l.~.~...Z~-,-~~.~ '.... . ~~)..~. " -m,<',/"d[i 17"~" .. C1'IB<P"-~~ .... ';r~..~~n::' 0u.(I~:~ c';L(JA-IA'.('1 [I, l:i.,1' , ',._9#.':1- ~/~~;$ _:L....._, (7f:~ J. .' , ':~:. ~/V ~tt~";y ,'V-o!6~' (t/!!!~) Lfi!~~~[!i.J Ii :' '"!ilg'~' " ( " .. ',,~ ,...,J.. ~ C' n~_Jl ....'1;... >.~" 7 :> / ... / '7 70 . /;~)'.." ,'I' '.~~"'~,'ip::' ... '\', ~ ~~.."..;'! , '~' ( {/ M..I.y~""--Y r v _f' ." \,?-I . .... '. '..' '. .,..~...~ .. ,"'" , ..Ji.,fY)w' '0t,&~h~~\l~"';' fpb ~ )Juu-~)L.q~~~....,..? .,..,. cr:-- I. /'r/' ,.. .~I',:~' :~_.....,.'..~:r;r. ';.,';!;'4!oo ,,' . ...; . _:, i,i' ,_, ,.' '," . L:...~. ",'."-"P' "It, I' ' _....",.H....__ , .-,..-- ~.. , '" I] .. ..... ... . }., . f'i t' . .~"iX;JGJi) }~\GiJ~ .'/,,~I ~$~ ."1/;"/(' "'t.,J/.27/ f/R=r/~; , "'r;:";?)':;"'~:, " . I. ... ........"..,... ."; 0","" . " . ..-.;,. III -"'-"".. I!"" ,..w._......._..,._ " . :k-1~~ . . . .,\ il'o, 1'.. - _.._.....0"_"'" ... ''''~ . ,_." . (]u /.1 .~ J ~ Lr.ll J, ]TM"~---' .I.__,....,~.,.....v-CH__....... , . . ',j.- ,II" '1" ~' ..' \~~;~V .. .,. .~~.. . ()R , \'. __. ....c,.."""""-'-"'" .. 'j'" ___._..il_~__;..... " . ~( " J \'$1 i, ,.,,'. ...".._,..ur"p .]IIt...._.... , , ~ \ t:' ... .., ....,.....'.'. . LX;')... ..... Y..IQ~. .. ",rH " ;1 111 ',II ... ,. n 'l'IIOMf\f.l II, IIOHN13l\l<mg fllle! I,I f.ll\ ~1, 1I0HN!3A1<lUH Plr!.in\::!J:J:f.l, IN '['IIBJ QOUI~'I' o Iii , cOMMoN Pl,lUf\13 oUMnIUI~l,f\NP COUN'I'Y, PlilNNf.lYTNI\Nl:1\ NO, 9U-40:\0 v, CIvn, IIC'I'ION L,f\W , Ijl~IU ID, SPl\gM I3L,AC1< DeEendant AMmNIlmlL~;WUi',QlU\J.>.EQIl':!'l'Mllli'l'~AlUU..T.RA'1'.QRa p '1'0 'l'IIG HONORl\Bl41;: ,'1'lm ~UDOl;:S OJ!' ('lAID COUWl', Cm:ll1\'in Cd,sUn:! liJJ.rJI1Il1E\n, oounfJel Co!: the PIE\l.ntJf:Cf.l "l.n the above aat:!on, respebtf:ully represents thE\tl 1, The above..oaptl.oned aotl.on l.S at l.SBue, ;;I, 'rhe ala:!1l1 of: the Plc\l.ntl.f:f:,~ l.n the ftct::!on qoa/3 not exaeeq $25,000,00, .' 'rhe EolloWl.ng ftttorney l.i3 :I.nt:ereuteq l.n the case au aOlll1f.lel, Ii ' .Joseph Ii', Murphy! 1'08'1' & BCIlIU!"!..,' WHElRr;:V'ORID, YOllr Pet:J. U,onel: prftya your. Honorftble Court to Elppo:l.nt three ell Ell:bl.trutora to whon\' the cuse shall be ,,' 13U);JIIll. t ted, I . 11 () ,'1 \01 'II " ,:1 J '.' 1 ,,!J I Il~ I; ~) . '(', " 1'1 1:',1 ~ I ~.. ., , : ,) i.1111 it' ..I >) " J. 'd :.q. ". " fl, Allmillllcllll pl\l'llIl1c1 1\lllllu\1111 PilI'\. Ills 1I\lmlllllclllllll ol1ll\lupn\lwl' 211, 11)!)7, III .. l\\1prn~II\1I\IIlIY flI(lO p.l11.. Ilw I )UI\JI1\IIIIII, I,co H, Splll'lllllllldi II'IIS 11'1I\'IlIIIIU \lllsll1\I\II1\111I his \'phlplp 011 HOIIIIl !)II" wllon 11l\l IIUclllpl11 \1\ICI11'l'011, 1\ Is clllllllld thllt POI\JIII.IIII1I"I111\ll\1plclllo pllSS IIlIl PIIIIIIIII'Il;, II'IWII sllllllll\1l)' 11'11110111 II'llnllnu, 1)01\J11\1I1I11 lilllllll 10 clllll\' IIwli'PI1t'hl' Pl!llnlil'PH I'\lhlC11l holhl'll \I\\lll11plll111lo 1'0111\'111\11110 Ill\slhn\l11111111wnl' !)Ihl. A nlll' \,lll\sol1l1lll\l hll'\lllllulIllIlll, AnHII'IlI,' Dlllol1\II\I1IIH wllhn\11 sll('!lcllll1lllllhn\1l1llol1 01' holloI' I\S to Iho Il'Ilth nl' Iho 1'\l11111111111!lIIVOI'I11\ll1ls , OOl1ll1hwll Il1lhls IHII'lIgl'lIphi thol'lll\JI'Il,11l1l Sll1110 11I'0 d\ll1lml, sl\'II)1 p\'ool'lwlllu dOlllllllllcll !IIII'IIII, II' , , i I'lllol'lIl1l" , I , , 7, Adlllillocllll 11111'111I111 d01\1Gcl11I Plll'\,lIls 1\l1111111ud Ihl\l Plllhllil'flH 1'0111cl\lllnll tlw rlglll Hlllo pI' P\lIUnlllll1l'H 1'011\010 unllldod, which cl\lIsod Dol\JIl\ll\llt'8 vohlolo 10 spin sld\lwlI)'s Inli'onl \11' , Jlll\llIlIn:~ IInll Ihul1lo Iho rlghl sldu ol'Jlllllnlll'l', clll11lnuto I'usl holwoonlho glll\nll'llllllnll Ih~ rlghl sldo 1ll'PIIIII111f'1's I'ohlclo, I\IClng Iho oppllslio dlrcolllln 01'11'111'01. Thu rUl11l1ll1h1!ll\l'\ll'll1QIIIs ollnll\llIcd InlhlH Ill\l'Illll'llph 111'0 donlod, CUUNTl.p.J'1I DMAS .11.-110 H.NUAKI~IU~. " LBE.l!J.,SlIAIU\lUl.ACI';', , , 8, Tho Incorpnl'lIlcdlll'ol'lllcnls 01' IJlIl'lIgrllphs Ithro\lgh 7 ol'lho Clll11pllllnl 11\,0 \Ionlcd 1'01' tllc 1'01\SllnS hl\lIcl\lcllllhllVO, 9, Anol' rOIlHlll1\\hlulnvosllglllion. i\nslI'ol'lng Dolundllllllllcks liilhl'l11l1lilln o\' l\I\oll'lcllgo slIrticlonl 10 fhl'l1\ lI'hollorlls Illlho"ll'Iilh ol'lho I\I'Ol'l1\ol,HS cllnll\lnod In Ihoso PIII'IIUI'l\phs I\lId SII1110 111'0 thol'ofhl'c donlod, 8\1'lel prolij'holng dOlllllnded 1Illl'llIl,ll'l'olol'lInl. I I, ' .i; \\ 10, Af1ul'I'OIlSnllllhlo Invcstlgntlnn, Answcrlng Dufundllnllllcks Inlhl'l\1l1llon 01' kllowlcdge , slll'f1clonl 10 Ihl'nl II hcllol'lIH 10 thlJ 1I'IIIh of'lhc IIl'cl'l1\onts contlllnud In Iheso plIl'llgl'lIphil'lInd SIIIllO " III'C Ihol'cfbl'c dcnlcd, slrlet Pl'ool'hclng dUl11l1ndcd III IrllIl, 1I'I'0101'IInl. -2- II. i\1I~I' \'\JlIsollllbl\J II1\'\JSIllIlllloll, 1\I1SII'\JI'Il1g I kl~I1I1II1H hlplis 1111\11'1\11111011 01' 1'"ll\\'lcllgo sllrncl\Jl1t III i\ll'll1l1lwll,'1' liS 1Illlw Il'lIth 01'111" Ill'UlIIWl1ls l'olllllinUIll1I IIwsll plll'lIl\l'lIphs 111111 SIIIIW " IIrll \bll!,llf\lI'll IllllIllllI, slrkl pl'ool' Iwlllll II\J II 111 1I11\J1I III 11'1111, I I' r\J hJ I'll 11 I. 12, AlIllr r\JlIsllIHibllllll\'\JslIlllllillll,I\lIsIIWlllll P\JI~III1I1I1III1\Jlis 1111\11'1111111011 01'li11111l'1cllllll slIrnollll1\ Illlill'll1l1ll\JII~1' liS 10 IIw Irlllh 1I1'1bo 1I\'\J1'1110111s COllllllncllllllhpso PlIl'lIgl'llphs lIlI\1 HIII1W 111'0 IIwl'o(\1ro lIol1l\JlI. s\rllll prop I' Iwll1!!lIplIlIlIlIl\JIIIII 11'1111. 1 I' 1'0101'11111. 1;1, I,OlJlI1 \JOllChlSlol1s I\'llloh 1'0111l1r\J 110 1111 HII'\J 1', Whol'O 1111 lIl1s\\,o\, Is dool11~'IIO hll roqlllrllll, IIl1cl' 1'0llsol111hlo 1I11'0SIII111110ll, 1\IIHII'Ol'll1lJP\JI\Jl1dIlI1IS 1\1\'1, 1111\11'111111101101' kl1o\\'lollg(l slIf'f1clOI1I 10 1\11'111 II 1101l0l'nH Iplho Inl\h llrllWII\'UI'lIlOlIls clIlIWll10d In Ihos\J PlIl'ng\'nphs 111111 HlIl110 111'0 Ihoro(\1ro donloll, slrlot propl'hc;llIg dOllllll1dod III \1'1111, I I' rolpl'nl1t, :1'1I Ihu cx\0111 lhllllll1 Al1slI'Pl" Is rOll\llrod, Iho II 1'01'111011 Is oOl1ll1ll1od 111 Ihls plI\'ngrllph 111'0 dOllllld, ' 14(II.dl, Al\ol'l'ollslIl1l1hlo 1III'0stlgllll1ll1, Al1s\V\Jl'il1g i)pl'ol\dllllllllcl,s 111I'Ol'll1l1ll11I1PI' I ~l1o\Vloc\go slIl'I1olol1llo Ibrmll bcllol'lIs 10 Iho 1I'IIIh lll' Iho.,l.IVUl'll1ol1ts Cllll111111CIl Il1lhoso PlIl'llgl'lIphil IIl1d SlIlllO nrc Ihol'ol\1ro dpl1lcc\, sll'lcl p\'ool'boll1l\ dOl11l1l1l1od III Irlul, 11'1'0101'11111. Tolho oxlcl11 Iblll , U'lAI1HI\~OI' Is I'cqlllrod, Iho UVUl'll10l11s COlllllll1od 111 ,!,hlli 11llrllgrllph UI'(l dOl1lod, WIIIJIWFOIW, Ansll'ol'll1!! Dol'ol1dlll1l Loo 1\, Spnl'll1 13111uk rosl1coll\llIy roqllosls 111IIt 1'11I111\II'I's Clllllplull1l 110 dlsmlssod 111 Its 011111'(1)', COUN't.lbl./SA.M,JIORNllAKlmY, LEIC,E"SI'ARMlILACl\. 15,' Tholl1\lol'lJ()\,ulod ul'Ol'l1lOl1ls lll' 1'II1'IIgI'I\phs I Ihl'lIl1uh 14 ol'lho COlllpllllnl 11I'0 dOl1lcd (\1i' Iho 1'0llSlll1S IndlclI(cd ubol'o, l.j 'I /I .;1. " ~ ,', , ", " 1\ ' .,' \\Il'l'l~" ..,,' \ "I'r; I', ,. I, 1 I ~ l." I \. 'I~' :'Ii ('_ t !'\' , 'pI "f " fi;,_,!{L,IIV,', t !, :"., " ' ,'\ ,:rll ,-, "-" .( J, -_""1 '." I ,I' ':'1" fltti~~' ", ,',.,\pn R Tam" PO:IT~~~~~~h~A~,Q. :: ;;,;,I""_!,,':,,.',n~,~,~I~ ::~ yP,'(a:"M', ~Y:;;~aM:I', .. ~UIT"1Q~t a1~~R^NPVmW^V~, 'W"p.wo,l\eR~,'I1Y, Cl'I', I, y~H^,T,' "\I/M~~ g\' e~ep~ M lIPll~FNT QA~P 111hhlf'A m11 ," 'THe IT iltVa A ^ Pc OaR. !ijI:"PY. "JR ~fY~ V. '__ ' , l71-7mh1910 f~~J'I~~.l~'~~&TI ",a GINAh 1,"':';'", , A ,1", , FA1(I(7171731t190Q", '---,-~ ,l,'!'" ,J ",' 'IN(,';",n,:","/I\j\:'"!;;iiE:,';''{'''!V~~('';'';~;:,';:''':~77'7:'Tr']l";.,~?:'"""i:,!,'::rn;i"'il:;""';':::",,,",'t,:,if\1::\','fUd;Ci,l!, 'l'f~'i.'-; _'I~!' t, Wiii;!t1l'ri:'v; _"I .,1 Ji,*,\i~j;/Jri'~'i\\,:,\'t";,.,,,,,,:,,,LI"i' ," .".. """," ,..' , ,""" ,), , "i .' , ,-"+,,,,U'..,i,'->"..';, h''''''i'''''Tl'\'{'ito.JIJii''~'~i\\k'litl(fI~'.1 ';" ,t~''''''''''' :'''"'' ,', , , ' . '" "" ""~, i ','~r,' " .' :'~ " .~. ,., I t :: ,'" t .. /, . . i..,'" -'I .11', "1"', '~'i/f'~. -, .'~ .' \ ," .;' ;".., !t!,'i- " . ;.\.~ I I', y\\, ' ~\m; j t {I ,-(' .. ~. A ':J't' _ j;1 \ \ '1fl~: ;'> , '. ,\ 'r' . ',.' JJI , ._'I-t\',....',~"'rl',;''''' ~~ ' , I' ... .' , , __';' ,d. ,,,. \ ',Jl'\ ,V j:~' hJ",_!~~I. If AI I...:) , ;, .... 'if-'\ - d ''I", ,I,.,.. -,,', tl, - , l.t! 11'\ ,_ ~ "rlf to' ,.~..., '~"il;,i '".. t ~'! I l' , ,_ , j -,.., I ,',1 \~,.:l". '. '" ,.?;:\~.ti~-:, I,..,." 1 , '"' \ 1,"'-' ""1 , ,_ '.\'1 ',' I to" i,! ' ~:' .. ,.'" '. ,1,\ I' , ..": ~\ ".. 'j --:;. '~ '.', iI&-.I' li\jjf'f,~,i'\.I. '. .r1~IIJ(I,.\ ,f' ,'r' .' ..,. It', J;' .. " '" ,r '-j, " I' ;-,) " " 'I' ., ' " I" , ' " :;1- Ij,( '. " I' \. \" "I! I "~ I. Ij. I " 'I" )j" 'I '1 .F ) ;, '(' ." \' :". , \ ,:,\ .' 'l'" .' ~_' ,.-'- i_', ,~\ i' ,!..-~;t(\.f-i 'I - _"'I;, ~", ' 'r , 4, lit till. tll\101'1 l:olovcmt t~o \~ha wlth,l,q ptl\l:ocl 0(1\11'>13 of f\otlon, Anel PArt.lo\\lArly on PooomlJel: ;W, 100'1, pofanclAnt y.,pe \U, f.lPAr\l' IUAo)) I WAI> tho owner <1ll'1 c.ldver of 1\ 1005 91c1l>mo\J!ll'l PUtiAPP, Regla\:rAtlan Ha,~rf.l031, 5, At fill th1el'1 r.aleV/lnt ta \:ho wl\:hln fltAtaq OAupe of Aotion, Pl"lq\:1r: f 'l'ho111111> II, 1I0rnbAI<ar ,Wl1a thQ llr,lvol: flnel OWnOl: " oJ: thp 1003 l<enWol:th '.\'rno\:OI: le/1sl)(l \:0 'l'dpla crown 1'l0rvloep, (it on \)0001\11)01: ~o, 1007, <1\: npprox.ll\1l1talY 6100 p,m, I \:ho Pln,lntl.f fll, '.\'ho111na 11, 1I01:l1b<l1)0\: flncl hls el f.1\,\rJht PI: r..l!'lA M I , lIornbAl,er, Anel pofenelf1nt, I,oe ,In, ppn~'m IHAcl<, were tri'1veUng l;lnl'ltbounel il1 l'Iopnrnto vohJ.oles on Route 044,' When P13t:enelAnt " attempteel to p1'1S!'I the PIAint:ift:s, when eUdelonly without wAnilnrJ, YOUl' Pefel1cjnnt fnlleel to olanr the front ot: 1'lll1n\:1ffp I 'vehiol13 perore I1ttelnptlng to retlu:n to the eflst)JOLlnel ll\ne of ROllt:e 944', 'I, Pefenelant hit the left front piele of PluintJ.ft:l>t vehlo1e, wlth thedght !'IJ.de of hl13 vel'llo1o, whJ,o!i onuaed !)efencll'\ntt13 I' vehiole to spin sideWAYS in frOnt uf PlnintiCfa find thbn,to tho right siela of pll11n\:1ff, oOl\1Ing to fI l:oot between the gUl\rel ,1'l\il Rnel riqi1t 1l1cle of Plnlntiffto vohiole, fAcing tho oppollit~ diroction of trAval, " , 2 Q9.L!1i'LllQ.w ll'.l1QnWLll.......IlQ..lmJalUH' v. t'@.lt..1L.-l1nunUll,!Ulli 0, p:\.lI!nt.1.ff !nOol'pOr.Ilj:alJ ))y rof.oranpo tho nyor.llll'lnt:!3 :\,n pilr.'lIm:IIPh!3 ,~no (:1.) t\wollcJh !3oyan '(7) n)Joyl'l f1!3 H {;\lHy Ol'ltf.orth hl'll:o.1.n, " 9, 1113 a' 1:e!3\11t of. thl'l f100;\.c1ant, oolllaion, Pln1nt1r.r., 'l'homll!3 II, 1I01mPA1~l'lr I hila !Hlf ferml c111mng0!3 1n An APproxilllllte IImolmt of. $10,394,oa, ,for the 10138 or. U!3a of hi!3 trnetor dUo to tho damago .. to the traotor., ell\l!3ec11lY the noo~ic1pnt, fot' f1 podOd of timo ft'0111 peqembi.~r aO" 1.997, throUgh \~abl:\\nry a, 1990, wh1eh .t!3 1\ ped,pc1 of. !3iX, (6) week!3 PI\!3ac1 upon 1\'5,5 dny work-weak, ealoulnted on An nverllgo weeklywnge of $l,73a,47, la, ,1113 lI,t'esUlt 'of .the .tnoident !3ot forth Abovo, plAintiff I 'rhomAI'l II, lIql:nbllker, hl\!\l sustAinec1bor.1il.y injury, whioh .tnol.l\c1el3 loW pnok pllin,nnd An aouto lumbo!3aora1 sprain. 11, 1Iri IIl:el'lult of theofol:el11entionodilljudolJ, plri".tnt.iff is " unA)~le toengi\ge in aoti v 1 tie!3 IInd plll:s\llts formerly enjoyed by h11ll, I\nd he is unabl~to oonoentrat~'as effeotiveiy os be hAd'in the PA13j:i lie hus I3Uffet'ed und will oontinue to suffer 1\ losf! ,o'f life1s ~njoyment. 12. liE! a result of. tho af:ot'oment.tonac1 injudes, Pll1intHf. haa IInd ia undorgo.tng great phY!310nl nnd mantul pa.tn and aUf:fedng and will' ool1tinllo to undergo gt-eat phYa.toal und mentEll 3, ,,' Q.Q1!N'LJo/O . a L.i.R1L.lli.-ll9r.nh~ULY.l-llllft-f1....J1lll\.r.nLlllMlk 11). \'+/\ In\:H f lnoorpor/\\:oe))y ref,ol:pn013 the' Avor.m13n\:~ in P/\I:lIrjl:APho ono P) throUfJh fo\~r\:aon (14) A\JOVO AI3 fl~ f\.llly !Jot , . - ' I:ol:\:h horoll1. 16. ^13 fI l:OElUlt of \:ho ino1elont pot fOl:tl1 E1IJflVO, Plllint'\'ff, 1.,\,8<1 M, 1I0rnl)OI\01'1 ~\18t,doI113d boc\l.ly InJI\l:Y, whioh :lno l\\c\Ofl oorv:loE1+ PA1n find at1ff,nna8, 1.7, ^a II rC\ault of tho flJ'ot'emon\:lot)oc). :lnJt\l:Y, Plf\intHf, 1.101\ M, HornbAKer, lfl unAGlo to ongAge 1n Aot1v1tiea And pursuits 'fOl'I"or).y ~nJayod by hor, nne\ ahe ia unable to oonoontrllte flS ef.feotively I\S 'sho hAc). In 'tho PAl3t,'Sho hAa sul:feroe\ And w111 oon\~inue to BUffer n loso of life1fl enjoymont. ,. l.ll, Ml <1. reflult of the: nf.orementlpned 1njudel'l, Pln.l.n\:1ff. LIsa M, 1I0rnbnker hne nnd 10 undorg01ng physioal and mentAl pill" IInd l3uf.fedng and wIll oontinue to unelergo phys1ol11 IInd montal p~in ~nd BUfforingln tho futuro from tho effoots of tho Injuries sustAIneel on Dooombtu:' 20, 1.!l!l7, 1.D.The inoIdent upon whIoh tho wfth1n stated'causs of /,'\ot101\ Wao dt\e, WaS tho rea\llt of. the sole 1\0eJl1gonoe of D~f.end/,'\nt, Leo I, Bpar~ Blaok. , 20, Dofendant, Loe I. BpArm Blaok was l\e~11gont in that! a. "Ho opernted his vehiole 1n fl l:'eo)llos8 manl)el' Undel' the oIroum~tanooel Ii 'i; I " : I I '/ " i, 'I. '\ '-,. " V'DlR4:T1'+ONl'IQH 'J;VOlH~1 \.:h\'l l,r'fltElIl1l'lW:fl 111~1l~€1 1.-11 I;h.ts CCJlIlpJ:O'l,int: 03,lm tn~o 'An(~ , C:'P~T~lut, .1 \1nr.l,~rgt,{lnd th~t: fcll;:!l f.lt'OitGIIll:nt!;l n'~J.'eiil ,W", I11cH;kt 09llh:loot: t;o t1w p'"nlllt;j,fl~' of;:JfJ" P'~I C.,S,II, !l 'I~O(\ l'c:Qf\\:ing \:r,l \Ins\Vl)l'!1 [:''11il.ificllr.ilm to ill\I;/loritien, ," - " ',', " .. '~J.I..J.t~f~~ 7'hC>OlElL;\ II, IIqt"nbElkol:' , ,Iii I' Illms Vl~l."a 14,!;18 1!H<jO ";'i, !' ,; l' " " " if H , j. ,. ;, " .. "d " .. ';'1. " " " \, . ,'I' ,I' 'i, " .j' " It oj: .I' 'j" " " Ii " " ",. " ", " " " " " " ,. j' " I" 'I! " .' " "'I '- " '.- ,. tr' ~'l f;:; 'f ,. litH I:~ ~,:l . , "', " " I,. "'j ('(' ~ (1:> fi' I, r(,' ')>\ " J; 11ll: , ,.. ",J;l ,'. ((j " hI\! N It;l " " I'''' II,d) It:'!' <...1 tin. I, f;:' '".; " " [" ll~ :~j :) l.' t;J " " ,'!' Ii I' U !' " Ii .. " I'. I' " ji i; " , , " " " " q. ii' 'I; " I, " fI11alV!f1 II, 110111)11\1101: 1I1lc1 r'~,!3fl ~1 I IInrnl.,knr f P1 111 111:11'('/1 PA'tl!!'f\'MI.!!I'IIIW I'Wf'!l.lYI!VI\!,{]!\ !B!!'!I'Y rl\" 1~IMJ\l'~I!flt-Il! I I I I ,/'1 In No, ..\l/Hn:I!lG,I~Jl..fl'lml\____~...'.n I , I V, r.oo IU I . Spl1l111 !nlIOII, ' . , l1ofollllllllt: ,.. !lUUl'Qiill/LJ!U!(IOOl,gUlOc;u:r;rmLQlUlll!tl!i f:Q!LllL~(jR'L.P..!Al@ANLTQ.JILJ[,(UQillll,R2. T\> I J.i!l rr iAI:> 1~-c1 JlQ.!lpl!;!!J:L.J!or!:~ \:h ~ ]:11 r'2~~!Y~t~~~011....~~e~::.\:III~~2~.'._~~~~2~I,?~~..1_~~~~~:~~~.:~~~. .~_~~~~n \:~~ (N~l)iJ of rOf'flan 0(' l:nI:1I:y) , Iliwrlfll:\IIn/, PI\ 17101 , IYlth1n I:wonty (P.O) nayo nft:ol' QOI'Vlco of t:hlQ IlUllflOOnn, YOll OPO ordol'od by thl) court: to PI'odlfcO I:hll fa 110wlno doct.ll)t}nla. 0(' thln90 I -/IllY -l1nCl-I.1~L.rnl'Jm:rltLpor.\:nillin(J..tp_n1Q!JlIjIL!h....._... --Po\.1l~er,._UQIlL..lP./1.1Lf;:1 L.I?.fi.r'!1..J..('1\-3r!.::.nl~.~___ .'_....'__._.__.________.._. _____. ._--_._-------_.-._-.,.....-..--~_._--_.-._..- _. A~' P.ML& aDholll-I\\;j:J;ln\;irulLi\tlUi!iI_.11\0_C!.E!!L1Y.!:~li_ 1\~~!.1!I(),,l!.I!lIP_~L!:~L~~~~~~:.____..__ ( Add/'o IlfJ ) " . You n\!\y dollvol' 01' n\!\l 1 10011110 cOPloo of tho QoC~nontB 01' fll'oduc(l th1nos I'oqllostod hy thio suhpoena, tooother with the cOl'l:lflcl\to or cCll1111nnoo, to tho pBl'ty mallino thio I'oquoot lIl', tho,lIddr'oQ8 11!lt;od Abovo, Vall hl\Vo tho l'loht 1:0 (1001\ In AdvAnOe tho "oaoanahl" 'COllt of PI'lIpOI'lno tho copion 01' IWOdl/ofno tho thlnoo DOl/ohl:, . 'f yO\! fal I to PI'oduco tho dOCll1-,:lnto Of' thinos l'oq\.l11'od hy thin r.JubpvcfI(! w1th1n \;\~onty , (!lO) dayo nftDl' ito oCI'vloo, tho fl/l,..ty 801'Vlno thlD Dl:,11pOOnu n\1Y !look n COUI'\; Of'dlll' CCfll1ol1 tno Yotl to CClll1ly wlth it:, ' 111' S SU\lflOONA IYAS I S~O AT 11ill Hlr@ST OF lHll 1'0(.1.0,'/1 NO rlr[1SON I NAi'J!l PlIul W. Orono, EsqllJ.l:0 -- ~'--'----~----'__'~""_4_~ NX>flllss t ..R~Q..Gr/)lldvJ.9l.'[.:.nVol111o_____......._.. ..QnmllIIi1.l'.--"I\...!10.:~.~.__._.........._.. 11;1..l!PltoNU' .j1.17.U.JJ:J!'l7~~....____....._.___. G~'nlffi rom II.> lI....:H!.lQL......,.._..._............ A lTOflNEV FOIl I DtJfondul1l:-LiOe..I'l'.J'?L^,l1.l!Ll!lQ.oI1 " IIY 11<<: OOJIlrt ()A ru 1.....,.,..,......_......,.. ......., ".._... ."_ ,....,..., !lon 1 of tho Goul'l: ...__._._,I;;~l:'hOf:;O.Lii;.;y701of'-k-;-OlvlrjjTv 1 11 Ion --- ..__.h.....__....._. .._.._h..._;....._..___._____._____......____.. Doputy " (liff. 1101) ~' , 1'\'/ i!'( " ( ~lmTI1!J{.;ATlUllUilkll\~UlI~ I, Amwlll M, FI)'I1I1, 1111 ~111plll)'G\lI\lr thG IlIw linn Ill' (lllsl I~ SGI1UII, (l,C" lI~ro\l)' ~lll\\l Ihlll IIlrll~ 111111 COIT~\l1 coPy Ill' 1110 l\lr~l\nillll Nnll\lo 01' II1I\l1l1 to S\l1'1'\l1l SlIhpO~I1I\ II'II~ scrvcII IIpOlllll1 \lOIlI1H\l1 ol'rG\l1l1'l1 h)'l1r~1 \lhl~~ lJ1111C11 SIIIICS Mllil. P()H\II11~ pllld, 1I1hli'~~H~d liS 1\lllllW~1 olllllG 1111\0 " , 6cllhl'lI1 holllll': BY Fll~ST C.LASI:i.MAlL I, CII1'1110\1 Crl~lIl1l I1lchl11l1l1 ,PANNHl3AI\llH &. .I0NHS, (l,C, 4000.v1110 Slrool Mllldlo\nwl1, P^ 17057 " \lOST &. flcllIJl.]., 1',C, ",;, ..C ' \c.\...'\'\\~'" AN~l, FLYNN (s-" PIIlc,ll ~ \C\ \~'1 " I' " !.',[ \1\ I' ' " d , '." ~2'T , ~! I:. ( ~: 'IJ,'."LI .. " ( \-.,." ,-t, li"( i ' II": ' ' (Iii , ( LJI ('.J {',I,! , , 'i'} '. ' r {." ';-' r! I,i' lilii~ II, ~ !-')'L -' (:~ j u, (.) " " " ;-" " ,," it ., , ' " " "~I " , , Jr, p H " I , " {, !; ;I' " 'I' H ,I .' 1'1' " .. " d; " , " " " " .. \' , , : ii l'! " !I , 'i, " .. " 'I' " ! ~ !' If,' Ii ," " .. .. {};' " " e:, , llil 14: l": c-'(~ ..' ( '/ I 'r 'J.: ) I;, " ",. (,,\;-, LI.. , ,. , i I" ~'\'I . il:" I 1'[.'J f / , n !:": l' , "Ii'd ''i /I, .,-,; .,1(.1. U l,t, .... 'j ,', (,;-, (,J j<l H " " .. 1; " " , " " " H " ,,I' ,'I /' I,i " ,: " \" I' !I 'I; ,." /, " " " " /, i,1 " " i , , , " , " , , , , , " H " " " , ' Ii I' Ii " " " ":.-. (;;, II; 1,-; he I ~-":l .. , il'! \: " " , Ii' ",,, :,1 I (j" ,I' (", 1.'1 1.'-1 , 1.1' ,., I, .' i j'L I' ()-' , /;(1./ " ~,' \ ','f';Jq! " f.'1'l " ~':i' l ) I); c.> " " .. i". " 0/ " " " " " 'i " j, , i< " ",! .. "" I' II " " .. Ii " i! I; .. ;/ i' ,I' " "'I; '<, " 'i' ,;"' ii " ;, " II!; Ii 'I; ;1 "II , .. H " " h, " " .. ri .. j, ,'1'1I0NflfI1l0\\NlI^l<\\\\, \ll:'\\x ..,..~,:,~.,.,,,..'!r'':'''~ ",..~~-,-.,."!".....~...~ ..~~ ..-~ ~~..,..t'..~..- III Ih.~ lJ~\," pI qpmmQ"' rl~nl C~~~flaI1A (:Q\ffiIYI r~l1lWflnl1hL "1',!"~..!'""l"1"'. ~~~"1""~""""'~.'r" ,~........t\'''-''~"''-''''''''l'.... Nil, Ull-illl:J1l Glvll, 19~",....!'" ..~~..~.....~."...~.......~.............. VI. 1,I\1\,Il\'l\\\HII1,M1\< ""~.. ".. .. ,,"~1"'. ",,"""~.1"""""'1"~-"-"!"'~':'""!"":'T"!"''''''''"~ ~..~~~.........._.............~~t.........~....~..._.,.."".""" !'...... .. !I..~....... ..,.".,"..,...~....\'I!",,~,,_.,,~,,~~.~""".f- ~..,!",....",..,~..... ......... ,'" '''!" '" ..!'~............,".."'....~"...,.. .~~~..X;UJ~-~~~-~~..~,~\.~~l';. f 1~~1. .U~.~~ ll.~~~ll~~~~~_~\~l~~~~I~.l!!- ~U.111~1~~ r #1~l."-'1~~ !!;ll.J~:.u...l\~~J~J'...,,~-, , ,.. ..." "......"".....'IT,~'.....,"'......,......tt..""!'''''...,.........,..........,...,I'!...... ."..........,....""..."'_1"'1"..., III......, 0'.... ...."'..........,,!..t..,.,..., ..,~!'!..7'! 'I " !;!..",.~ .,,,,,..tl~"f""'~-""'''''''''''''"''''''' ~.,'" ...."'!' ..,._"'.._"'......."""'~,.,"'.,...".."""""..",."'"..'!"""".,"",."'.."'""''!'"''',.''Tf''' .....O:O,~.."',."'_... t~"''''r'' ""...~_ ".,"""'''!~_.,......,.._~''''''. "'......."".,...,...~""''''''''....,'''Tf.,...,........"......"..."'''''''''..''''..'''..''''''..'I'''"..........'''.."''''..........'''..'''..'''' ,~~"'~~,,~"~"",."'~"....._.._,."''''__..~~..~..._.....'''..'''..~''"....~.........'''.........."'..""......"'."'..,.~_"'.."'......"'..,.,...~.."'~....."'~Tf..__..., " ' ',"'-""--~"',.'!"-."'''''.....,...,..--.,'''''''''...., .,."".,.......".........."'........ .....""...."'...."'" ........"'....... ,..."'''........ ..""..",.. .......... .."............. " t"'~"...."""""""""",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,.,,,,,,., ....."''''''''............'''..''''................"....'''...." ,...,"'.."'...,.,."".....''''...... ...,......"..........,..,.~-"".. ':\'0 oure 1.1II111 ~....~~"..-"'-~.........."'~......~"'~........."'...."".~~~~..~ Pro\hono\ary Apl'l.l 15, 1999 ~~~~~_..~..~~"~~~r..~--..~-~---~"..~~-~~"'~ ,I I\,!n" II -----_."'..~~~~-~..-~--..~--.-_..". (\ttomll'{ 1M Plaln\lIf, ", ,.,.,.,,' " " " ,,', ,">;';''','.il1Z;, ~'\~,.,:~;;\', " ' ,,",' :,1'.'\ "":':';~<:':~':\' \\, .:' ~_~ -/ I, t' ;. ~'I'i !', ,"., ,',,'," ,.-i',,' " '-.,..1 '.",' ., " 'Ii' ,','/.... " 'j ~ Ii, 1'.\ I,f) f,';j .,0 Cl "-'1'" 1"1' 'j, /.1,1/1_; 'il '.1 " ,I') :-1.1 i-f I :~o I , h;, :: lij ,,, C.), '. , ",I. , :::-! ,I'r-' " ,'. ,} .1,,[ ., I ,.01, .\ .' " (_.:>('11 ) (7" "( ~:~ " 0) :,~..'