Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05093 ,! " " I. !I i, " 1,1 " 'I ,0< " " " " '" ~: ,'1::\" ...:::. \l ~ ,. " " ,I' " q'. I' " " / " ~ " ,. ;0 " " ", " J J ~ '1 , 1:,_ ";1.,. ''11,1.,,'"'.; 119}X'-'io;' '"'.\'-'~", 1,'_;. '--(f1 , " " 'oj; .. " " 1"1 "i' " ,.\1 , 01' p '\ \ " " " !, .. " " " ..,I; t'" " I. I' I' 1"11 " 'I I: 'I' " " " " ,it " " " ",' I' " "" ,n 'I Ii' i! , " ..H" " , "'.; "" ,. ..' " ;1' ~ ~ " 'j, .1 t,~ ' I' " " " " ..... , .. '.. .~ ~ ~-i i.- ." " , " " "H ~J ", ;j' ,. if ," ", i; i' , i, \'I) \~ ~ " i. j, \!' " .. '. ~1 t)-, \ , ' ~\ \ ~ : " " ,. ., ..' '" " ',!.' " " " " " 'I. " , " ,. ., .., I I I ,:; II; f,)'. ,'" .. \'\ ,t' ll:r' I,:) , I "1" , 1\;. , '. '. ~ ; , I i/; , , vi! Iii r ' , : , ,I' ('" , ' " (L , c' ( .. I ,I ,-'I ., I' 'I: " '. I, ,Ii " , " Ii I , " " " " , " " ! ~ {'i. \) '" .. ;; " Ii " 1.' '" {I " (II) IhIP'\l (3) NllOW\llllW\lI'S (\1) IKiW\lI'Si\W (c) 101l1'111ow\l1' (II) IWo (2) Chllll1s\lWs, PilI! wllh II CIISO ,. (0) Gl'ISWlllllllOok (I) IlUnWl'llllS ,11m 13P1I1ll1U1'k\lY coll\lclpl'sll(llll\lS (/l) IlIwnmnwOI' (h) ono 11\11\\ll'od nny ($150,00) IloIIIIl'S cilsh 15, 011 or IIbou! .July 21, 1997, plllll1lll1' IImldolul1dllnt 1I/ll'uod Ihlllllw vlllllo Ill'llw " mls~llI/l nhlOly.ulghl (9H) plocos of l!ssorlod cnst 11'011 cookWlIl'O, whell cOl1)bhwll with Iho VIIIIIOSI)f Iho Olh'cl' llolm pl'ovlllolI 10 Iho dcf\JIldnnt, illeluding tho ono hundl'od filly ($IS0,OO) dollnl's clIsh, CIlIIW 10 nllllnlqrolovon l11o\ISnl1(l rorty.tlvo ($1 1,045 ,00) dolllll'H, 16, Tho plnllllll1' nlld Iho lIol'olldlllll cnlUl'od 111\6 1111 1\Bl'cellWnt wlwl'cby tho dofel1dllnl would pny eleWI1 IhmlsnlHI 1'ol'ly.tlvo ($11,045,00) dolllll'~ 10 Ihe plninllf1' nl tllo . rnW or thirly ($30,00) dollnl's pOI' wook U11l1l.slIeh tlmo liS Iho lotnl VIlIlIU ol'tho mlsslllB hOllls , . wnS pnldilll\lll, 17, 011 ,July 111,19911lhe tlolondnl1lndvisod Ilw plninllff Ihlll ho Wt?Uld no!ongol' mllko PllYlllOlIls, Tho (olnl blllnnce dlle lilld owing 10 plnhlllff I\S or .Iuly 1111 1998 WIIS lIino lhomllnd roUl' hundl'ed Ibl'ly.two dollnl's IInd tlf'ty:Ovo cunls ($9442,55), Ill, The delulldll111 bl'onched his ngl'cemel11 10 plly Iho plnhlliff 1'01'. tho hems, pl'ovldod to tho dol\mdnlll by pllllntll1'; " 19, III Ihp i\IIPl'llilll\'(!, IIw IIulbllllll1l1 hils Ill'ulI~'holl his IIlllwnwnl 10 PilY Illll , plllil1llfl' 1110 Slim of ploYPI1 IhpIlsiltHI f\lny'l1w ($1 t 1(l11.~,OO) IlollnrH whlph 1'0pl'oHonIPd lIWlhlr " l11i1rkPI vllllloOr lIw Ilol11s Ihnl Ilvl\lndnnt l'VrOlyuIllhlll1 plnhHIIl~ bul rpl' which lIw Ilvf~lHlnlll " , nVYll1' pnllllho plnll1lll1', 20, ,,1Jn1l1l1' plIlwl' Ilwol'Y{lr rocovol'Y Ibl' 11I'Oiwh or C:ol1ll'lwt Ih~ IlilhllH!odlle IItHl pwlnl! 10 lIw plnll1lll1'Il'om 1110 dlll\ll1dnnlls nino lIwlIsnnd 1'0111' hlllHlrotllbrly,twn dollnl's nlHll1ny.I1Yo CUlllH ($9"42,~5), , WH llRHFOIW, plnhHill' pnlY11 1\11' Jlltlllmenlllllnh1N1 tlcrondl\nlln t1w illnOllnl or I1lno .lIIPlIsnnd Ihlll' 11\IIHll'od l'orly-\Wo dollnrs III HI nny-OVe cenls ($9442,55) pillS costs, COUNT II - QUANTUM MERUIT ,," In t1\li ovul11 h Is dOlormlnodlhllt no omll\!lreUn101lI oxlslelllnlllol 01' Inw 11olwocn pllllnllrr nnd tlofcndnnl ns nlleued In COllnt I. Iho plnlntil1' nllouos nij IhllowSl " .. 21, PlIl'nUl'nphs !lhl'OlIuh 20 nl'O Incorpol'l\lod horoln liS If sellbl'th nt lonlllh, 22, Al vnr!olls limes Iwlwoen ,'une I, '1996 nnd .Iuty II, 1997, Ihe plnlnlHI', lit Ihe oml 1'0gUoSI or dlllbndnnt nnd wllh lhe dorendnnt's knowlcl!ue nnd nC(juiesenr,o, unvo to " dolondll/1lo/1o huntll'od olghlY'lhl'ee (11l3) nssOrled ploces or cns( lmn cookwnro lInd olher 'socond hlll1d goods willi tho \1ndorSlnndlng (hnl dclbndnnt would olllwr pny Ihr thcsollomN IIln IntoI' dnlo 01' rClul'nthol1l to plnll1tll1: 23, Of nil items given Ihll11 pllllntin'to delbndnnt, Ihe tlofendnnlhns pnid pllllntlf " OXCllpl fiJl'tlwlbllowlllg: ,,' (n) (h) , i nlncty.olghl (911) pleces,or nssnrted clIstlroll cookwllwj three (3) snowhlolVCl'Sj (p) pllW\lI'SIlW; (II) Il!i\l'\llllWOI'; (~) two (2) 1)11i\lnHI\ws, \lllI! wllh II I!l\H(I; (I) OI'IHWi\lt\ \l(HlK: (II) 1l\II1WI'OUS ,1I1l11l~lIm ImKoy co\lIIPllll'S \mllluHI (h) IlIwnnwwor; lIn\! (I) onu hUlHII'\ld nfly ($1 ~o,O(l) 1I01l1ll's clIHh 24, 1Jespll~ ll1\nwl'OUS 1'0qUOS\S \IY pllllntln', llolundllnt hilS rol\lsl'd, lInd cnnlh\\lOH to rO(\\HO 10 rot\\l'I1l1wsolloms 10 pllllnllq'or lppny lbr HlInw, 2~, Tlw 1"1111' MlIrKel Yllh\o 01' the ItO\llH Ilot r(lll\l'lIod, nol' 1'11111 1'01' by do fond lint Is nhw Ihllusllml rom hUlHh'lld Ihl'\Y'IWt; do\li\l's IIlld lll\y.l1vo cel1ls ($9442,55), WHHlWFOIW,pll\lntllf pl'ilYS thlsC;oUI'I w\ll OIlier JUdglllont 111\lIlnst Ihe dtlromllllll In thd 11111(1\1111 of nino Ihousllnd 1'0\11' hUlldred rOIW.IWo dollilrs ilnd l1lly.l1vo CUIlIH ($9442,55) , , phIS COSIH IInd InleroHt rrom dlll\1 \lrjuIIUllwnt. COUNT 11 . CONVERSION 26, PlIl'ilgl'lIphs I through 25 nre IncDI'pol'i\ledhoreln liS Il'sul fol'lh illlonl!lh, 27. lJelundllnt knew Ihill he WIIS to I'lIy Illr Items I'l'llvlded hhnby plilllllltf,orto l'elU\'I1 these !toms to plnlntlll', , ' 211, The runsonllhle vnlllo or Ihc Itoms III ken hy delundilnt lInd nol\1\ol' pnld Ibr nor relurnod to pllllntlll'.is nine thouslIl1d Ibm hundl'ed llll'ly.lwo dol\nl's nlld lit\y.llve COIlIH ($9442,55), " 29, J)tllundllllt hilH convel'lcd lhese IWmH tn his own Use, " " '>-, ~" .;;.." .....Q ct.' ~/} r() , '-..I ~ .J ~ '" 1.(1 ~ () l' '<-;1 () t'- Ii ': ';,' f B 1'/ , L, 'll Tk I' " d' l'i Vi (/i ",' ~, Ii:' 1 ~ C.) ,", "I , ~ II I, , Ci " " .' ( ~ j' Ii,. Ii " " , " " i" .. " " " /' ;; ..II, 10 " " 'II il ,_" ;1- Ii' " ,/ I; '!' " " " " " "I. I', 'Ii