Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05121 " " ,\'l I" " HL ,( }, ~' ~j ~ 1\1 ,~ ~ " "' l' " I; ,It, " ,. '. " "' ,e I. " j",\, ,; "i " " rl ~ " ,. "' " 'I" I' I' " 'jl I., "' .. '1 ~ " Ii I' ,I' " , ...... '\I ~ ~ . " " " .. " " ,,' " d j', Ii' !,j " " " It' " I' ,I ,'! " " ',i ",i', 'i il ", of', !\ " (; " " Ii " ,. ,. " I" ,I j,' ii, H ,," I, " Ii' .( \~ it " , 11,'1 " " ... ii' ...... '... I .~'" ~l ;, ;; ;1' " ;; ..... oll \;) o.l. 0-. '! " ",' 'i'.-,' 'i "' i! II, " ;1 ..: Q ~ ii c!nl\lIJtqtll/I;Hf.\ ,tllIO 1I/;1'l/ulI ,. l"h,Q'!'f1 ' Ii, '1'1111 1'(101':11 IIlId 1)lll1\IITIIII'''"' illl 1II)I,'I.I,/JIIII!I:nl.' nl',III:,!!1 t:(lol~ p)nclo ,011 /lI,lpl',01l\1Ill): :\11, 1!I'1'I, 1.11, Ill' nbol11', 'II:I!/ /\,1\1, DI\ /31:1\1:0 HO\l\:o 03 n01:1:11\l61\IId I\nl\ I' l'lx II, I ,) III 1!liltlllIll' I 1\111\ C!PIIIll:y, 1"111\1lfJy,i vnl\Jn, Ii, ' At: 1',111.1 n/'I'II'illlllll\ 1'111I11 I\l\d pll\oil, PJlllnl:ff:1' M'll.'y )'11]:1" wnp I, (1)(1I.'I\I',II\U II Illil!l 1'11111',1;\1111111\\111'1\ 11\ 1:1111 1.'1\1111'. I:rnf'l'ln Inl10 no]:\:\1bol\l1('1 IlII 11l:1\\',u t<olllu III, 'I, AI, 1:11" ill'ot'UII/lld \:111\11 nlld plnOD, Ill.lf'ul\clnnt 1</l\:hy /"i11;111\0r Wila O)>I'I1.'II\',II\U /II !)!lll !lodU". 1:1'1101\ OWl\ul\ by 1'11\11 /"H1.'111\qJ:, Defondnnt !(f.\\:hy \'.<11.'.111\\11' Willi 1111 \.1l\~i:\IIIy opol'I\I'II\[I 110r vnhJoln 111 1:\1i\t: (1ho Wila t:rnvollng III: 1\11 I1X \J(1I III I VO 1'/11:1,) 01 IIJWllC\ In 1:l1p ilOrtilbo1.\llCl pnnl'd,ng li\ne bold,nQ 1'1iIJnl;,.\.f'f: Mnl.'Y 1(1\1'101\ fll:l\l:n HOI\I:n,II:1 nOI\1: 'fiJxJI: 19, " II, ^\: l'.l\ll nJ:n1.'llunJd I:J1I\1J 1\11<'1 plnno, Dof:endnnl: l~Elndill.l Ulnor WElS oporlll:.l.nu il l\)!);! 1!1\l.~v);'{)I(Jt, !lofumlunt RElndnll Il.tnor wnl3 11l11c\Wfu11y npnrllt:tnu htH voh.l.ulo :l.n 1:\11\1: hu WLlII 'l:rnvOUnH f.\t un exaeps1vo l:i\l:o. of n).>o I.H I :l.n tho 1'I11l:\:hJ;OIIIHI rl.nh\: \:l:nfU,o lnllo bohJnd 1'1a;\.nt:,Hf Mary Knr1 find I.1I~J;ullllnll\: KilLity 1"I\:':l.l1\nr on fl\:~It:I] Routo 03 near mX,j,t 19, !), ,1\1: I:hll 1\ l:ol:oHnl.rl t 1.11\0 nnd plnoo, tnl I: J:1o ln the nOl:thbound 1:.1,u 11 I:, I: 1:1\ I' 1:.1.0 lnllll. on IJtnto Rmlto 03 wail stopped near Ilx1t 19 find 100al:ol1 (:,hat .' PIn .l.nL ,I.I~ r: Mnry 1(/1\:1 Wiln w,j,th.l.lI st:oppod trnJ:t:.l.o, " lll, ^\: tho nl:oro/lll.l.d t::l.11\13 find plLw8, Dol:13ndai1t l<uthy 1-,n1:1\11or nppl.'l,l<lnIH)d\:hll Ill:oppod \:rflJ:t:J.oloant:ndoll Bt:atB Route [13 noar l~x.l.t 19, An n 1."111\111', pI: I:hu Ilnllilf'n 111 a 11)10]: 111 whloh j)ufol1dnnt Kathy I"ilril1\o]: l~pn1.'ilt:(ld IIDI.' vllldolo, uho :1.\11p1.:6p81.'ly ohnnund trnffJ.o 1/111813 und wlthollt. , ,'; wn1:n.ll1<;J )1\1111)11 ll1to I'.IHl d.il:ool: pnl:h 1.11: DoJ:nndlll1t I<nlldnll Hll1ol:' FJ Vllhl(J.IIl Cll1l111.l.IlH I:itn t)Ollj,Hlo11, 'i ? fJol1\lllni n/l;nr1', \\oCJ V(:l,\(IlU 11, lis <\ l:et3l\l\: of: t1\o llnS<\J;o \\\nnnPI' 1n whfoh Dof:\'lIH~'1I\\: jh\nrl<lll lHnqr opol:<\tec1 h1a vell1clo, he f:",Ded to l,oop <\ 'proplw 1001,01\\: nnel WEH> \\Hq))lo to stop \lifJ Vehicle \1i.t:hln i\n EI!'l!31l1:oel cle<\t' rUt3\:qnol) ilnd fJ\:t'qdl, \:ha ))Elol, of: Dof:~ndf\n\: J<ill:hy [,a ri\\Ie r, P vehiole, p\\ahfng II: In\:o Plnil1\:l f f' s veh1ole, l;l, 'l'he impudtl3 were of: 13110h a fOl:oe tl,,,\: It mnlSocl Plalntlff:' 13 vehiole to be 11l1/3hec1 forwnr~l lnl:o \:he ,vehlole opclrqted by. I~ol)er\: Dangelo, which W"f.l "lso stopped in \:raff:lc, in f:ront: of: het', 13, lis a result of: tho oollls10n qncl the resUlting eventfJ thereaftel:, Pld,nt:i f f MElry Kqrl' hEls sllf:f:erec1 j,n:Jud,Qs <lnd Qa\l1<1ges, " p'AMACillllS 14', PE\ragraphs 1 tlu:ouUh 13 m:e lncorporE\ted herein by ref:erence i\l1d made a part hereof., I' 15, lis 'n direct and proxi\\ln\:e result of the <lforesE\id qccielent, Plctinti.ff Mary Karl Bus\:alned injud,es Whioh Inolude, but are not: limltec1 to, the following, a, necl" shoulder and low bqok \\IlIsal", f1tl.'ainl and " b, pln point teildernass on the \:17npo?oh\s muscle nnd at T.5, ,16, ^s a l:osUlt of her 1njude\], plElintiff M~'ry Kad Ions suffered phYBlml1 pq1n, mental C\nguish qnd s\\fl:e171ng, humD1at,i.on, 1nconven1ende, embC\l'l:assment nnd 10138 of U,fe' s pleE\S\n:e8, i.'1 .. " 1.'7, "!Is" n result of her lnjuriet:l,/ Plainl;lff Mary Karl hE\s Bufferecl physirJnl impa1rl11011l:s wh1ah OOl1st:l.tuted,liE1r u8llal and customary dallyaativltlet:l, 10. !I',l n result of hel: Injuries', Pla1nt1ff MEU:y J{arl hns suf:feredn loss of enrnIngs. 3 <, 'I' " " MI'IHY Iii, 1< 1'1 \H, llllct ,'mM\ilfl \Ii, \<I'I\H1, Pln:l.n\::I. I: 1'13 IN '1'lIln CQUg'l' oP' COMMoN Pl,lilM] C1JMBlTI!lI,i\ND COUN'l'Y, Pli1NNl3vIN^NJI\ NP I t/lf . ,,;,'1,;)/ /l ";/ ~((.< ~.(( CIvn, I'IC'I'):ON - !"I\W v, !l^ND^T.,l" llINrnl~ find 1<^'I'IIY 1"I\!UM1~R, I)e f enclc\ll \: f] ,mllV 'l'lUl'Il, l)l~MI'INDliI\) ~~a' RroaumsT FOR PROPUOTION~-DOOUMm~ m:RlnoTlllll'l'O PlnD'mNPlili't '1'0 I 1<I'I'l'UY l,I'IIUMlil!l " 115 l1en\:;!.Ell !lond ~ewif]berrYI 1>1'1 17339 I'IN\) NOW, \:hifJ Jjd;;_ dny of I3r~p\:ember, 1990, pUff]\.lnnt to Pa,R,C,!" ~"009, 'If] amended, oOllle \:he Pled.ndffs, by \:heh 00\:\1113131, 'l'uol~er I\rensbel'g & I3Wc\l:t;!., nnel repreFJen\: \:he nbove-nc1med pm:l:iea t.o "\11ulce avaUElble to Plaintiffs oopiea of' the follow:l.ng doculIlenta w:l.thin thirty t301 dnya of Bervioeof (his requeatl 1~ 1\11 I3tntemon\:I3, aigned 8tEltelll~ntB, transcripts of r'eGordedatatemE1ntfJ or intel'vieWB of any person 'or w:l.tneas relat:l.I19 to, referri~g to, or desoribing of the events desor:l.bed' :l.n Pln:LntHfs' Complaint and in, the Intwn'ogatorieB, . 2, 1\11 ex:pert'opinioI1I3' re1'ortB, summad,es or other writingB in the'~ustody or oontrol of Defendant, or its attorneYB or in13UrerB whioh relate to the subjecit matter of this Htigat.i,on. 3', 1\11 dooumentf3 :l.denU l' ied in Del:endnnt' s Answers to " Interrogatbries propounded to dnte and Inter~ogntoriEls propounded in the futuJ:t'l in this c1ct:1.011, nnd n];J. dOO\lmentB reVl,Elwec1 by Del:endnnl: or Elnyono "aodng on behnlf of' the Def'endunt in the , . pr13prH'nl:':i,o\'l '01: l\llflWOl:n 1',0 l:hu l'oJ:ouo:l.llU 1 1l1:fllTDun\:m:1.rw,\ 'I, /\:1.:1. rjr)(J\1\\iC1n\:n PI."folPI\l"Oll by 1:,ol'f.1l1rlnllt, 0:1.' 11Y ill\Y 1.I\PIl1.'\'ll:, 1:op1:ellol!\:f\t1.vo, <lorH\\: or ,(\\\ypno IIn\::\.no 011 bohnlE 0[; fJi11rl poj:onrlil\\\:, IJXOPp\: 1.tf.l n\:\:0l:110YU, d\\l:1.nu l'.hD :l.nVlJpl: lUfll: lOll' of: tho :l.nolcjol\\: :1.1\ , ql\ea\:i.on or <lilY of I:\w oyol1tn or n118\11\I:1,01\1> rjenod)Jad 1.1\ P1a:l.l\l:lff:pl (joIllP1ftl.nt or /\nnwo'rn to Int01.'roSjal:odBf3 I l3\\oh rlponl1\01~\:s 13\10111 J.nrJludo fillY dOO1l1\113n\:p mwlo 01' pl~()pnrorl liP \:h1'O\H:lh the prBPenl". t:\.,I\\f.l, w:l.th \:\10 o~;rJ1\,iI3:1.()1l pf: tho 11\1)111:(\1 :l.1\\prBfJfl:l.ollfJ, OOl\ohISl:Ollf; or op:l.n:1,01\13 rBPperJt:l.l1U, tho vnll\8 or modt oj' i1 rJ1Ed.m 01.' rlaf:pnae or reppaotillg~trf\tBgy OJ" tnot:l.op, G, /\11 rlooumel\tp YOll 1.l\tol1r:\, to of:f:er :l.n ev:l.danoe at tr:l..11 of: \:h:\.,s OAse i G, /\11 matJ/3 , c1rf1wiIl9s, s)tet;chBfl, photogrl:\ph9, , \11ot:l.on pio\:111:ea, ' v:1"c1eotur;e/3 anc1 ./3:1,m:l.lnr documen I: a w:\..th resper.,t \:0 Any , matl:er at :1./3/31\0 in \:h1,/3 aase, " 7, /\11 f\co:l.c1ent , '~reports prep.\ l:C~d w:L.th respeot to the aoo:l.dent at :l.ssue 1.n this case, 0, All Slllm1\a,r:L.ss or notes of: <lny oonyersation with Elny w:l.tne/3S or person witb respeo\: to any matter that :1.& at issue in this aalle except' f:or any mated,c11s proteoted fromdisoovery 913 attorney ,wor)e produo\:s, 9, /\11 medical reoords, medical reports and med:l.cal b:l.ll/3 regard:l.ng Pla:l.ntif:f: Mary Karl In the cUl3tody or oont1:ol 0/: the pef:el1dElnt, :L.nclud:l.ng, but not Um:l. ted \:0, those. medical reoords, rep01.'\:fl cl1,1d bEla f:or \:l:ea\:ment of \;,he Injud(~s Plaintiff: 1.'eoeived " as a reflult bf: the aod:l.deot aet f:orth :l.n plaintiffs' Conw1aiht, 100 Any reports of any inveSl:igat:l.on ocll:d,ed out wIth jl ,,' .." " " " " ',;', " ("" , , '\' "I Ii'J,"1 1.1" ., /I:'!I (1)1. '\1 If I' L '\1,' / I' ()' I' ," I; .'/' ,~~:tj (;;, c') I [; (.J',.,. p~ u1' ,I' '" I.. l' ) " j , . , " , : i . 1 i' :, . 11 1 j 1.1, ,I (,) ,. i.'.' " '" " \\ ,. " " " , {i " ",' 'i, '\ .," " ,'" '~I ,I ,. II ~ , ~ i I! ~~j~ ~~ ~'~ ~ ,0, J s Ill, po; d ~ ~.s, J'" 111 " '1'" " " " " 'I' ifl " " " ,,' , ,', prOpf\1:nl::!.o\1 ()~ (\\wworll l:n \:ho .1:01:13u01I1U Tn\:OlTPUi\l:nr11Jf!, ~, 1\11 rl mJ\l 1\111 11 HI propnrfHl by Dnl'ull\,li\\lI:, pI: by ic\lIY :l.lllHll:Or{ roprermn\:iI\::\.yq, nuonl: or iWY0l111 '101::\11\1 PII bnhilll' oj' lIil:l,(,l ()of:(1nc1nnl~, ~~or:Jp\: :I.t:p q\:l:ornl)YfJ, c1\ll::\,nu \:I]u Invopl:lunl::l.ol1 pf: \:\10 :l.po,\,rlenl: .I,ll 'lllll~I3I::\.on or 'lIlY n~ \:he OV8n\:n "or' ij],:l.esJill::l.ol1fl del3CJl:iboq 111 Plill.nl::\.1:f:P' (Jompli\:l.n\: or (\11IlW11nl to IntIJlTogf\\:od,of3, I3l\oh c1oClllll1onl:fj 'philll :I,nol\.\d6 f.my c1ocJ\lInOn\:13"l1\ildo or pn~pqrocl lIP l:hvo\1[Jh l:ho prol30n\: \:.:1.11\0, W:l. th t \18 m:Oll\Pion of \:h8 montf.ll llnpr8PI3:!,Onl3, Clonahlfjlol\P OJ: '.. oplniol1fJ 1:0I3poo\:1,n9 \::ho, vnlL\l') OJ: mod,\: of: i\ olillll\ 01: [10f:011130 or ~8l3pooting strnt89Y or tiloticp, Ii, 1\11 [lo(J\\l1\~ntP YOll .\.ntoncl to' oJ:f:er :l.n ov:l.clElnco n\! td,'ll of. th.\.s oaSEl, to, 1\11 m'lpS, dl;awin9f.1, sl,etc1hElI3, plio\:ogl;apl1f3" 11\0t:l.on p:l.ol:urElI3, y:l,de~\:.qpEl'13 ElI1 d 13i111i1nr dOOlll1\Elnta wJ.t:\) l:Elapeot to EllW " mat\:e~: at issl\El in th:\.s Oa136, " ", 1\ll aooident roportl3 pn3jJill'Eld w1.th respeo\: 1:0 tho " " aco:\.dElnl: at :\.aSlIe in I:h:\.13 oallEl, , 0, 'AU" Sl\111I1\Ell:iea or notos of: any oonveraat:l.on w;\.t.h any wl.t:nel3l3 01: ponJOn with r13i3peot 1:0 any mattor I:hal: is at l.l3s\\e j,n 'this oal3e exoept fior ilny mat:ednls' proteoted from 'dlaoOyel:y aa attorney"W01:)c pl:oduota, 9, 1\11 medioal reoords, medioal reportl3 ilnd medioal bD.lf) regarding PlninU.f:f Mary Karl in the c\\fJt:ody 01: oontrol of. the DoJ:endant:, inolurUng I but not Hmi I:ed \:0, thoae ,lnedicEll reoords,' repo1:ta and bills f:or troatment of the injur:\.es Plaintif:f: reoe:l.ved aa n r.eault oj: the abaJ,denl: f3l1t J:01:l:h in plal.nt:l,f:fia' Complaint:, ,'l; 10, 1\ny rtJport:fJ of: any invosl:l.gat:l,on' oarr:l.ed out W:l,l:h ,., ,. \i " " f'H .':1' , J" (; I'/~; ..', -f! 1',.'-" ~,~; \ ~..'J " I,,' il': , j--'" 1'1 . !r '" , " j \"11(, ' LI! , ) C'] I I .,.1\ l: .!,','j II " i' ',L t' (I :i " , ,.I (',I .) , " " Ii " " 'j, ," " ".,' -- ,- ~..; .' 'il 'I ,. I ~ ' " " ,. 01' I .1' H ", " " ~ .1 Ii Jj I; .IJEQ~5 ~ II( ~ ~,~ r J' l' I, " ,. ,I I, Ii " " .1' ,,' ,. G' ..tl' . I!; ....~ 1";1 (~r, ,'i ",." I~ ' -.:.' "" . 'j c.(~ (,' ":1' Ii]! ; N 1i:1I' Ii', f : '-,." '" 4i"' U U\ . I' .. ,,:: ,!','.fd: I, :":,,: '1.:-'1 ('I .J"'I' "II'I"J 1:1(.. Ii,: -,.. ()- ,;" I ~ " ", ., ,. ., III' ,. " I:, .". ., ,I' I' ",I' " I' 'I ,,'; ,I' f) I', " " " " 1 " ., '.' EAC.11i ~, AllmiltPd, 6, l)pfpl\IInl1ll~III'll1wr I~ wlthptll kl1l1wlpllllPpr 1l1fprmntlpn ~lIfflplpnlll1 fnrm 11 "pUpf nfllp IIwlrlllh pf thp mnllpr~ spl fprlh In Pnmllmph (il prupf thprpllf Is IlpI11111111PII, 7, J)pnlPII II~, ~tnlllll, ^' Ihp IIfllrpslIllllIl1l1lllllll plnpp, P\lfpmllln\ Klllhr l.nl'lmpr WIIS ppprntlnll n 1990 ,PI111/.1p ~hllllpw ll\1\pmpbllp OWIIIlll b)' Pnlll nllll I\lIlh)' Lllrlmpl', "Is, IIllnllllllhl1l shp Wlls IInlnwflllly op\lmlll111 hilI' vPhlplplllpnlClllhnl ~hll wns Irnvelllnlllll nil ~lIpe~slvp mill pf spelllll denhlll IIHII shpwl1s ImvplUnllln \lIe, norlhhollllll PflSSlll1l IIII1PI denllld 1111I1 she wns ITlIVplllnll11phhlll Pll\lrillft' Mill')' Knrl, i\dmlllpd Ihnl ppfpndllllt KlIlh)' q " Lllrhnpl' WIIS ll'llvelllns .PI1 SIIIIP Rotlte B~ nPllr PlIlt 19, U)' WilY of fllrlhill' IInswpr. Opfpndllnt , IJllr\mpr IIvprs thill, 1111111 limps rplpY!1lI1 hprp,lo, shll wns lnwftlll)' oplll'llllns, hilI' vphlole 1I1.!\ Il\wflll mlp of spollllln Ihp norlhbollnd rlghl'hnlld 11l\1Il behind nllrcpn 1I\11omobllp opllrllllld b)' onll RobeI'I O'AnBPlo lind, III nnolher polnl In IlInp, behind I\blllok plok'up Inlok ,operillcd b)' 1111 IndlvldulIl whosp Idpllllt)' Dofcl1dlll1ll~1I1',ll11er does nol klloW, B, ' ,A(lmltted Ihlll, III the IIforesllld time nl1d plllOP, Oefel1(11I111 Hiner WIIS opel'llllnS 1\ 1992 Chevrolel, Oefpl1dlll1l IJnrllllpl' Is wltho\l! kl10wledSp or Informntlon sufflolent to form II bollef liS 10 Ihe Inuh of tho rpmnlnlllSllverlnol1ls 111 PnrnSrI\ph 8, " 1" \ . , 9, Admitted, nl 10, Admitted Ihlll, III lho nforosnld lime Ilnd ph\oe, Oefondllnl Lllrlrner " IIPpronohed Ihe stopped Irllfflo loonted on Sll\lo I~ollle 8~ nenr clIlt 19, .Denlod Ihnl , ,,, . Dofondnnl Lnrhner WlIS opernllns hor vehlole In l\llllnSnfe mllnner nlthe IlInel denied Ihllt ',2, .'.\ iq " \JIJPnl1&P nl nil 111110& flllpvnnllWrllln, f)pf\lllllnn\ , I<Oflnwr Plllr IlflllrlllPlI hill' vllhlolp III lIw rlBht- hlllHI trnffl\llnnol (h) Il\lnllls Ihol &Iw fnllllll IP kpllfl 11 rlln&nnll\Jlp Ipnkll111 fur othpr vohlolo& Inwfl1l1r nil Ihp hlSI1\vnrl " (I) Ilonlofllhlll &IWIlPI'rlltIHlh\lr vphlolo In II n1l11ll1pr In vlolntlon pfllw Mplpr Vphlolo COllo of thp Cnllllllunwpnllh of Ppnnflrlvnnlnl B~ Pn" C,~,^ fi~310 rphlllns 10 fllnowlnlllPPolo&olrl , (j) Ilpnlp& lhlll &Iw fnnllll Ip&top wllhln nn n&&llrOII Clcnf 1!I&llInoo from Plnlllllff MAr)' 1~lIr'l (k) dcnlp& 1111I1 aho fnllod In Ilrlvll nlll apPl'ld find III II mnnll~f 111111 WO\lld nlluw hi'll' 10 alofl wllhlnlhp n&&\lroll olcllr 11l&lnnc\l,llholllll (\) (I!llllp& lhlll ahp fnllolllo OpPl'lltp hcr vphlolp ,III n snfc appedplll'allllnllo Ihe MOlor Vohlclo Collo of Ihp COl11mon,wqnllh of PennBrtvlll1lnl 75 Pn, C,S,A, ft~3611 (Ill) 11IH110& Ihlll sho oflorntod her vohlolll In eltollss of Iho po&tod spooll IImll for Ihp hlllhwllrlnnd (n) dellllls IllIll sho olherwlsc opoflllell her vehlclc In II Pllreloss, reokless IInll noglhlol\l mllnnor, WHBHEFORE, Dofondlllll Lnrlmor Pfll)'lllhlllJlldlJlnonlllo ontoroll IIthor fllvor IIlld nlllllnsllho Pllllllt1ffs In IhlB CIISC, . " ,Ii ,COUNT III -I<OSS OF CONSOI~TIUM JAMeS KARL v, I~ANDALL H1NEI~ nnd KATHY LARIMER 27, Dofendllnl Lnrltnor Incorpornles heroin b~ referonco her. IIl1sWers 10 -6- I; " II ..': " " (p) I1pllrnlln~ Iwr Vllhl\ll\l In n mnllnpr In vlnhlllon 111' Ilw Mnlor VIlhllllp O\1llu PI' Ihp Cpl1ll11pnwllnllh of l'cnnflylvnnlnl 7ft PII. Ci,S.A "~~ 10 rplnOnB III fllllnwln~ Ion IIlIlKlllYI " fnlllnB 10 (Irlvll nl n flllllUII find In n mnnnllr 111111 WOlll11 nllow hor 10 KIllp wllhln Iho nfl~\lrcd \llollr dlfllnn\lll nhclIll, ~2, If PlnhlllffK cKln\lllKh Ihnl Ilwy ~lIffllr\l(lln.lllrloK nnd III\lllI1BOfl nfl nll(lBOd In Ilwlr' Qompll1lnl (whlllh nll(lgnllonK Ocflll1dnnl J-.nrlnlor 1101110&), Ilwn Rnllllnjllrlos nnd dllml1~IlS (II) WO\,(l\lll\IRlld Kololy \Iy Iho nOBIlBllnoll, r\lokloSflncRsllndl or OllfCIIlKSI10KR of porSonK olhor Ihnn Oofomll1nl 1~111'll11l1r, Inlll\llllnB IInl nol Ilmllllll 10 Iho nllBIlBtlnllll, rOllklosfln(l88 I\nd/or ollr(lIIlK8n(lR8 of Dllfllndl1nl Hnndnll Hlnllr, IInll RI1I11 pllrsonsl\rp IIlono Iln\llololho Pllllnllffs for nny Injurlllfl ur dl1nHIBll8 Ihcy mny hllVO 8I1ffo\'llI\' ~~,' If 118 II 1'118\1\1 of Ihll mntlors IIIlOBIlII 11\ PlnlntlffR' Comrllllnt, Oofondnnt }..(lrlmor 18 hold llnlllo to Plnl1\lIff8 for nil or pnl'l of slIoh Inj\l\'lo8 or Ill\mn[1es liS Ihey \TIny " hnvc 8\1811\11\od,l)ofonlll11\1 Hiner , 118 Ihe rnrly prlmllrlly I\n\llo for 8\10\1 Injlll'I08 l\1\d " dllmnSlls, Is 11111110 ovor to Dofondl\1\t Ll\rllnor, lIy WI\Y ofllontrllllltlon l\1\d/or ",lndo\TInlflontlon. for 1\11 8\1oh dnmJ1BoR II mllY \10 reqlllrod to PIIY 10 Pli\lntlffs. ~4, 11\ tho I\lIornllllvo, If liS 1\ r08111t of tho II1nIlO\'8 l\\loBod In Plnlntlff8' Compll\llIt, Oefcndnnl LI\rlmod8 hold 1\1\1110 to Plnltltlff8 for nil ,or pnrt of Rllol\ Injllrl08 or dl\ml\Ile8 1\8 thoy \1lny hl\vo 81\811\11\Od' Oofo\lIln1\t HI1\llr 18 jol1\tly l\1\dl or Rovorlllly 1\1\\110 10 Iho Pll\lntlffs for 81\oh 11\.1111'108 n1\d dnmnB08 l\1\d IInlllo ovor 10 Defendnnt Lnl'lmor by WilY of oonlrlbutlon for nil 8\1oh dnmll(lOS Oofondllnlmny he requlrod to PllY 10 Plnlnllffs. .8, " ('1 ' ' r I ,; ~ -} , I' " I , , Ii II " I c, r l' " I I , \ I. 'I I' , , fL,! , ,'I, 'I' t', I ( " ~ J" ,/ \; " . , i 'I Ii , . , , j ~ ' " ;, " , , Ii " " " , ' Ii il ",,'f' " " fl'f " j," " '1' ,-, '~; I, " J' H,., " '1 " " I' i' Ii " " , ~ ' ", " , ' ';i,1 , ' " ,,' ,J il ~ I' "ti 1\ , " I' " " I. " "" !I,.. " " ~r ''''I - ~;, j I . . (~ c I III \ ) ;;ij , , , 11\1 : I " I'h' . . (II ", , \ ,', l~) ~ I I C~J il I ~ ,t', , I ,ql! R I ~i_l I;.!i(, II :.'1 ') I-, In ,IJ I< ' l' ii' .. ,'/ " " .. , !i " "', '/, Ii! " 'i. I. ,.:.\ !i ,. " " " /, ,. , " d' 'I, "", 'I ", " " I', "" ", " " ,,' Ii Ii 'j" 1\' " " Ii " , . ,I " I" " II 0;, i . ' i , .i " 'i. ., " (, 'f " H w " 'Ii " 'I, " I' 'i. 'I Ii " Ii. " " " /'iU>/J'(!,'ili:ri i',',,'.' '/" "'"'''1/'\11''' ; . '\'-,' -.f n9 H;)\',/I /1111/ I PO ('(i\I' .'," 'I' , 'I ' , , U\ll)' J "\",4\.ll.,,, 'Ii "'1' I" 1}~NN~)\n.\(\i ,flA " " H " " i" I, H., 'I' " " " " " I; ,I" "I" , " I' '" I' " , , " '! Ii I , I' " " (I , '\ " " i' 'I. " " -" ,I, n " Ii .I' " " " " ',. " " " " I' MAY I':, MHI.nllll MMI':S II, I\MI.. Plllllltln~ INTI III CotJln OF COMMoN PI,I\Ml OF CIJMIWHI.ANP CO\JNTY, P/,\NNHYI.VANIA v, , CIVil, ACTIoN ~ 1-1\ W ' Ht\NPA!,I. '"NI1H nllll 1\t\TI IYI .MIMHI{, l)\lfbIHlnlll~ NO, 011.5121 CIVII,'I'IIHM I' OIUlEj{ OF COllin , ANPNOW, IhlH 1.( i~dn)' Ill' Ail/,\\IHI, ll)fJl), \IPl1ll OIlIlHllllll'nlllll; nl' !,ho Mllllllli lhl' HlIloA\JHol\110 nlOllllll \Johnll' Ill' j)olclldnlll HnlHlnll 1111101'1 Ihll l11otloll IH gl'lllllOll, IIw glllp IHH\lod nil Mn)' II, 1 l)l)!)" IH 1Il111lllllhHOllllo. IhlH nctlnn IH dlsoollllnuod wllllll\lI ,. " pr~ll\lIlllo ns 10 Dofbmlnnl Rnndllll IlInor; III HI tho Pl'othonoll11'y IH dlruololl to pO\11 tho snnw Oil tho duokol, " , BY TilE COURT, ji j~tila ~ (J1!n_ "~OHIO)I ()~ /, , (') ,', \'., , q Lou C, SWIII'tz, BSlI. 111 Norlh Front SIt'uol p.n, Box 8119' "llnrrlshlll'g, PA 17101l-01lMIJ At!ll\'l10Y fhl' Plnlnlll'lll Bl'igld f), Allilnl, Esq, 315 Nl1l't11 Fl'nlll Stroot )1,0, Box 74 I )'lnITIHhul'g, PA 171011-0741 Allol'lwy Ibt'Dcfbndnl\t Kllthy Lnl'ltncl' " "'1 "j I (-J,'" "i; 1,'" 0'1 , i ~ ~ 1 r " , 1'1 \ I '" :1> ) " I " .. il\ ,II ., " :',,: ;, ,'.:, 1,,1 " _ eb'd.~t<I.J (l"M~cC!,f.. :1/L'I/'ir'n ...&,', . "i "