Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05127 ,\, " " " ,I' " II " \, " "1 " \, r', 'I, '. ,I Ii " " ,1,1 " , " '\, '.; Ii \; " Ii ,,'I " '"5,', - ~ I" Ii " d' '!I " .j " I' " H ~' :::. , \ , \" " \" " ", oj ~ '~ ~', "L ,." "', I' ;j .: ," \ , , I" \ , " " ,,' " ., I. " " " 'i ';' ~ i '. ," II " ,," " .j; " " " II, ;," " !; " " " , ,;' I', " .I, " " ," " " ~ \~ ;f " i': 'i. " " 'I . ;!.;, 11 ....... , .~ <::J ,. H \, I ~I i ,,~'I C) 'I " .1, 'j " " ," ~ ~ , " ~: 1'" GlIIl~P Il'; \ffit,OtI, 1m" P~":l.n~:I.~~ v, I I I I I , I, :tN ':\.'11111 OOUR'l' Oil' Oo~ON p~~~ PPM~IIl~P OOPl'lW~ P~I'lI'l~l~V~N~~ No, ~13 -SltJ..7 a~v~~ WIllm1 OIV:t~ ~aTIPN - Ll\W ~N OU~'l'OP~ ~OR~1I1 ~. WIll~OIl, P",f"'n~"\'I~ ORQIll~ O!l' OOUR'l' ~P NOW, lIpon oons.i.c!ol:il\:,i,on 01' tho clttc)Ohecl oomp.lld,nt, ,it: ,1,[1 hen,l)y d:l.rootecl \:Ililt t:l)o P'\l:t.l.OIJ ilnel tho,i,r respeo\:.i.ve aoul1E101 <lpp~~:r I)Ofa~:e -~sli\i:...l I. 'I ,F;CI"\C3'<' , IUlr.u.tJJ:.()., the conc;d1.i,atar, at ~W~,.l_J?)\'h ~\'I (rV'(\f) \~~J2h on tho d~\ clay oj' C:c\('bc:.c_; 1990, ~t ~-)\OO .B.M" for tl rre~ " Ve<lr1ng Custody conJ'orenao, At sllah aonforenaot an ~J'fort w.i.ll bo " l11acle to re/301ve tho i.."IBlIes .i.n ell:BputGI or ;i.f thIs CCinnot be aooompll~hod, to deflno and narrow lho 188U08 to be hoqrc\ by the 09I\r\:, t1nd .to ontor into a tomporilry ardor, ,1il.i.thl3l: pin:l:y milybrJng H, (,the ohLlcll:en who Ciro tho sub:)oot o,ff thll3 cU8tody ilct,i,on to tho aOl1ferenoo, but the ohildron I 8 a \: tonc\C1l10(~ Is not milncla t01:Y, W[ll:1.ure to appear ilt tho oonfo~OnbO InCiypuovlc\o grounds for ontry of il t0l11por<lry or pei:manont oJ:Clor, I"or tl.1e Court: I " , -=n::u~\\C.,JJ)Q.;-"f,~~-a-i\j,rp.1 . ' , ' t. . l"l\'):) YOU SIlOUl,D 'I'AI~m 'PillS PAI'IDH 'J'O YOUH l,1\\~YIilH All' ONcm, lIP YOU DO NO'l' IUWID l\ l,1\WYIilH OH cANNa'l' AI!'ICOHD oNm" GO 'POOH 'J'IDI,mPHONIil 'I'IIm OIPI;>J.Cm Sm'J' JPOH1'1I nmI.,OW '1'0 ~'IND OU'I' WllmHm YOU CAN GEl'I' I,mGnI, 11mI.,)?, ' . , cUMllEil,L1\ND COUN'J'Y BAH l\SSOCI1\ll'ION 2 LIDm~l'Y 1\VIDNUm CAHLISLIil, PA 17013 (717) 24o~3166 , I' " lilllMllP Il', ffi!l~O", JR" j.l;t,,;l.nUff v; ~~ W"~ OO~W OJ!' oq~oN j.lll~~~ o~mRltl\NP OOUNWY, j.llll~~Y~V~~~ NO, ~p ,... /;'(<27 ,PIvi~ WlIlllM OIVIM AO'l'IOI'I ~ ltl\W OU~WOP1 ~O'l'~ON ~ORXIll ~, mnIJPH, P~f~nq"n1: OU~'1'OP1 POMPPAII'IW 1l'0 t~"~ HONOMnL1I1 .:Jup(;~a OF a~IO aom\t~ I l, 'I'he Plcd.ptlH ,la Gbralcl 1", Weloh, Jr, l'e8J.ding at 116 Ilummel Avenne, 1,e!110yne,CumbBrland cOl\11ty, Penn8ylvanla 1'70~,3, 2, 'I'he pefBndant 18 !,od,e A, Woloh who resides Elt 116 Hummel AVenuo, l,emoynB, cumb(')l'landCol1l)ty, Ponnaylvanla l7043, 3, I'lalntlff80Bks jolnt logal oUatody and primary physlcal ,cu8tocly of tho fOlJ,owing' chJ.lclrBn 1 NAMI!l PRESmt-l'l' RmSIOENCm Jea,13ica Welch 116 IIUIl1'~,el Avenue MichEle)., Wel.oh 116 Hummol. Avel\UB Ii'. " 'Paylor Wolah, 116 HUll11l101 Ayenllo DQB 'OJ./17/89 10/1~?92 02/06/97 All olf the children woro not born Ollt ,of Wflcllock, 'I'he' ahUdron aro prBsently in the' physioal custody of Geruld " ' & r,orl.o Welch wha rosi(18 at 116 Ilummel Avonue, Le\noyne, Pennsylvanla, " " 'I ,,.. " " " " ".. C:l '.. i" " n~ ~- ,. .' " j' ~ '1 ri2 n:~;:, \,I.ltj;! I.) ~! ~'n 11;1' 11\: l',"j ,'. :' ~ LllI," .:1' " \;.(,~ L.l,~ I .,,11,1 ,'" :llffj (\',:, C' \ \U4 I j:3:. I' ('(: .:,) {'I (J\ (~l "" , -n ,,f' " " 'L'l ,. , . I,"~ ,i d' H'< " ,. " '" " ,',! " ii' " I, " "; , " " .. " " " , " " , ,. ,. . /:'' /.' " ,. " " " " , " ,'I " " ;, I!. ., " " , " "'!. " ,. " ,. " " ,j ie, " ," \, " ii" ), " o'(.;;;.i~J .r.;W l._ . ~. r Y .,:f~\VO,ylt' L: ," " " j" I,' ,. ",..1 , 1"'1' ". I , , 'I' "f' 1'1 :,I, I" ,i" 'I) 'Ill j I II t ,) (;I..Ji'..;, Iii' '\'l,il (IrHY I\!i'~i/(I.V/I.!I.,\ ' I' " :1 ,-) 1ffV ./ .,.,L dt:/ \ ,(J}t;.\y /n((d{~'l ....~, ~t(i' . '/:J!'TM'f ' ( <') --/ ... ," d "I .;; ':.L .f! ,/((I(((!;'.; tr:r"f#'~ y..:v;<(~llc/ "(1./ rl~~ , .' d.,y? f''1.('(!, , I' ,,' ,', '1 " Ii Ii I' " H " " "1' ,II " ,." oj' ,\\ " I' " '1; I,~ I 'I' " d" I' " I;' " " " " " "( l \1; " ";, " " f'.'/ ell i" i_,ll , . I'd) t'~J \1 ~~ ~ ' c, ,.," ,/ I' " ::,', ,'-, ." n;~ " '1:11' ,! " I \l,,! ", .' . fJ) I,ll' , I:! ,~ "n'!\,11 :1:' Pi, led "(, I'.,'; 1..!j ;"" ~~:', I" p') ,f) f; :,j) u" (.1 " , ' . , " ," " " , ,. ! ,. " 'I "I, " , , II ,/ ,. " ,I' I, " ,,' " "" " /.' 'i " " 'II " ,I' " " " ,,'0 " II' " " , '" !;, , , I' , " I' " " " ,. ,;,1 " '.), ,', " " " " " , I: " Ii " , , , , (, '/ Ii " '.. " " , ':' " ;1 \, " " MAY ,I 7Infl~) (If=/lAI,P f' W/:/.clI .1R "IJH ~'JfE.' 00!111~' 01,1 (JoNNO/{ l'I,~i'll.'.1 01;' I (J/lNIINHLIlNP (JOrJN~'Y, llFl/1N{1).'I,VIlNJI\ I IOl'VJI. 1I0~'ION - Mh' I INO, ?8"51~l OJvn 'l!J'/& I o [J,'j 1'{JfJl' IVJ'N,l'W\ ~'.TON N'lJ/l (:./.J'f V /.ORl/: ANN Wr:/.c/I /lO[ollrJ.'I/1I: " Ollnml 01" OOHIiE !lND NOh', tlll/J , IJ[JOfl OOTllddorlll;lo/1 of 1:/10 f1/;/;,!lohad 00/llp11,1/1(;, ,it: :1,11 1I00:tJ!Jy rl.i.l:ool:od t:/lllt: t:llo JlII1:I:.ioll llnr! 1:1l01r. r.o{.ljJool:iVt:J 00111I1101 IIJl!JI'II11.' hoforp , tllo oono.lJ.if1tor, nt 0/1 tho . cJll'y of . _., 19 , f1t _'__ N., for. f1 llr.oIl0111"i/la ollst'ody 00/1[01:0/1PO, 1\1; {.IlIolI 00/1 [or.O/lOO, " 11/1 oft'pl.'/; wLll /Ja nwJo to 1'P1J01VO 1;110 ,tn/won j,/l d.i/.1[JlIto/ OJ;' if thl. Of1n/lol; bo f1ooon~l.i{.lhod, to dofi/lo f1/1d /lf1rroW tllo ,tDRUD{.I /;0 bo hO/.lr.q 'by tho oOIU:t:, /.I/ld 1:0 o/1l:or 1.n t;o II l:alllJlPrllry on/tn', Hi (:11 a I." p/.lrl:y /IIf1,Y iJdng tllo 0ld1d whQ 1./1 1:110 IIII/Jjoot: of 11!/.I:11 o/.lut;ody f1otioll 1:0 1:110 0011[01'.0/100, hili: tl10 o/d.1dloh./..ldJ,'On'll Ilt:l;a/ldimDo 1./1 /lot /fIf1ndllI: or.y, ,Fld1l1ro 1:0 IIJJ!JOII!, lIt; 1:110 oonfor.o/1oo /fIIW prov.icio fJ1'OIl/lrJn for O/1tl'Y of " I;O/llPOl'lllT or !J01.'/IIll/lolll:or.do1.', li'OH ~'JlB COllH1' I By 1.':"'--_'r:-:-r;_'-,,-r-7'--- CUatoQY 001l011111t01.' YOU SlfOU[;fJ U'AKB ~'lIl',9 I'AI'EH ~'O" YOUll L"If~l'm~ A2' O/lc.'B, H' rou DO 1101' JlIIVB A Mr~l'lm Oil CIIIIN07', Al"JlOJW ONH, GO m Oil 2'NLI~lJlI()NI~ 2'1(1'7 OJo'f'ICli' 13I~'l' Jo'OH2'lI D1nOr~ m FIII/J 0[17' r~I/E;Illi' l'OU CAN GB1' ],]WAl', 1JI~'L]J. " ClQlllxlI:.lunc1 County Ilm.' l\oaooJlll:J.on 2 Id,\X1l'W "vonuo cm:J.J.nlo, \la, 17013 (7J'/) ,7.49"3166 \...lIOO.99()-9100 , j , ( , \i \ \ j " " " " ii' ., " _ ~ ii ~~ ~ .. '~'?, \1 Ifj ..tt'~.!!. ~ r- .~,... ':: Ii ~'~ ~ I~ r~" h ' '~ l ",;~I{ R ~~ f~ ,*i\7 1 ~~1 j~l ,A ,~ ~ru J r- " '" " " " <.1\ ".~I "~I '; :. ~ J I". 1 .'; ',' (~., , ' .. " ",J"r 1,\ ',.,1-,) : , ; l~ ' ,l! 1'1. ~ ; ... . ~ ;'.j ro.. .;{r) ('.1 J " (,i :,-' \:" , '111i,1 ;';". I,!;!p. I , "., l , ') ,;.;, () ,I ,. "It ,. " " " ,,' " , " ,", ,. " " ,. " " " " ",' " /1 ,I' I', ", I,", '" .,. If' , " .. i! " "j 1"- ~\ ,\ " '~}' . o l,h)r.if r '){ +.: (1; (r, (iX\, v 'i I- .61 (if, I Lit ( (f..h I IN TIIB CDIJHT OF COMMON PIJW3 OF I CIJMnngl,ANpCOIJNTY, PBNNRYIN^NIA , , I ('lVII, ACTION I,A WIN CIJRToPY : NO, 9P"'SI;J.7 C(u~L ~~IY] .mITl1~UNJ~I!J\lOlllII.\Ci\TJUNJ.lE..A..c.Ul:iT.uJl~ Tho PollllnI1PI'___~~_.._~,___.__,__,______I'08puotf\llI>, 1'\lI1l'08\J11181 1,"l'l1l1t0I1 ,/.J~2iGll~lbtl~~V.J!lq,'~lIgoIV!JJj}ji('2,:, Pl1lol'o(I"I1,OI'(lol' 0011001'l1hl!J Ihe \J118,IO(I)' pI' Millol' ohillll ohllllroIL_, [),e"f\.:::~Lt:?L.-'.0(,L..2lJ,d.t!.,l':),--_..., ^ 11'\101\11\1 oorrool oop)' o('th\J 01'1101' 18 I1llllilhllll to lhl~ polltlol1, 2, il'hhJ ardor ahollld bo 1110(1I(1od 1\8 (,oll\J\WI ,'. , 'I) , .J f 'l' I ,J i? ' I J /fl"AU,I\-) C"c-I,'{\4[O~' ,-:h-ct<le.yf4)t'"e'~<\i{U ,-iLL:\. (.t!~(/\I.f' 1) .,d/-C. I. - , ,-;..t Ol~Cy\j/i.', t-feh ,LY. iV,,'~f:..I,~..e,?l /\.lP.() ('11,{\ (.tj~j! I, ' ' ' , .,/, }.~n(.\ojt.-{)-e(:C..(Q.ft-I"t.l ll)l"(./I'V.Jj (!i)ncL(AIOllJ./~C.ldl\ (/lll._ 7,/)1AI/YtLtiYA- J, Ae.1"-f.h(1 'a (~)/J fJ-IILfh(1)\:: ell (~j ci {.,()(}/{!'?fi tu." (td>pf!,u! (v(/Y.;( . _ e ,'1')Il,Q'/h..el\.,.(/tlt-'th (~ttl'YI'~1~ ~ f,vnd /Hi.''I,tl(.;J (?f)1,t..l.'!)(.'~'7(,ll IYe,{.tl"r)1~/t;(, .," 'b,l!:c;J),!fcLP {),Ju/,\(~, ,/e~~ -int. '-(/)/I~lj"(,MA~ ,,-.<\ ,.I!~/)'t~ .,,/..1t\~ ,..fN-lj0~,U?1~'tf. .,G',e~\(~1~et,L.:' ..//(leLJ A^ftl/~I'JIv.t?Ll)ed "L( hJ?C/ ,2Jf,,-~. I...f eet!'!l' lllli),f (t~t //{~ d 1,~ 1'\cle,A + ht 6.,~ t, tlywLc tJ{h~/.) ; {l 1'1 ci ,.{.() , /1~t~~~1 f-t.1t (~1})rJ-.7. Y" .. . !l.l'~/,~~~t\~, '~~tfl.-;~? ,ef\f.'(!I,-. "I/fl, U)YL!cr. t/ tudfYJ \Ilv /.,C<i?,Ll Jlh.(!/-u 1<"((1101)CUl0-tK(~/1 Ch,tk(~/)(:'1\ l.1.)l.d )lnf..\II,\,:.~I'>,ilY(li<,) CLi~d" fe,~,tVLeh1. CUI.C{ (till /\,de.i.~/~/I il..( ,:.f,C:/'l'l.&7j)U 'YJ;Lidd& l)(I-h~t..',ye ' WI.1ERIWORB, Potltlol1ol' l'oqlloHtn (hilI Iho Comt modll'y tho \Jxl8tlng onstody ordor, hOOll1180 II will ho 11\ tho b0811nlorost oflilo ohlld(l'ol1), ' ,'., ' 'n~"lr/~1, "1~_LOlL..:.l., ' 'otlltlo'flcl' " '.I "" " c~ 9J' t 10 (l.. ,; ?' "' i"~' ~, ()Sj ..", a:' f'" R 111(:) , J ('", t""-(. (" 1,:/ '1", II' ,~d I"!" C\., ,Lri.. ~,:~ "It,.. 8 I',lt" i.. ~.,I ~ iA', ,;1' ",' (fj . ""'jI ~ I, I. :',. :q:i. '1' F' ( 1,1,1" I :J.: ,,-,H. ~ " ..~t ~3 ~ ('I , C.:., i) " '0' , ,,' " " ., !Ii " " ,; " oi >,. 'I'd " '" '" 1', " " " "I'. 11 " \, ,. iI' " <I" I. ,i " " ", "1 " \\ " \, "", ., ,. ). ,.' " ,,'.', . '. I , " ~ I, ~ " .' I, I'tl ,...r, '. '''~iA.,h,~j'-" , "\' . ,<',,\ '", 'i, ~, 'H,' ",;1 I . (.'~ \ . \l;; " ,) iI^,~~\.' ,,1.: \?,/:~I,; I' I ' "I""l, , 'k ,f t~'i ~ i' fI' , " ,. , " " " " 1," " ,. " ::rU:2 02001 \' ,. , I,"MIIIl I'< APt.lIII, I',C, ATTOIlNUYB AT lAW ~331 MAIIKI!T aTl\lJIIT CAMI' 1111,1" ,loA 17011;'IO~~ 1"/1'11 703,131\3 " i: "'- t .,<.... ..' --. ".'," .'.j.., ",0 jl'I>" 'A~',' " ',\ II \,~,\, ,I , ":h,;' > I' (~~ , titf \,~', ( -}f 1,-,11' , ,,'\ i I"~;) Ii!' 'L0......t4...;-"'l11. ';:. ,I, {fJ""',\ " d. ~'.. r.", "'I " '" ,,. ,"(:" ' " I.' '('1\1 .' (' "~ ~ . d ~~, , ,l _~'; , ,I., , I) -l' ',t I ~ ,ti"\~;, I "/'{l("; , , , f IIY)li,' ~ (t~ ,'; , , h'l ~'li.l. 'I' "y. :~r ;~ 't~tl .. ',~~, If! .. '~;'f/l ~ ,~\\, " " .' '" " " " " "~" , ,!, ~; 'f,J" . " -' ~I ,(.iIl~".", If'" , il" ..{- .,~' .. ':.l :~~hd' I. ,; .~ " ',.1 "J'~ ill '.4.ll . " \1': ,j'". f, ~ " l i \ I I " , ,\ , ' " I qnIl.AI.]) P. WHI!cll, lit" , ' Plllln\\tT ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) va, I,ORIll ANN wmJC\I, . D~Tul\dl\n\ IN 'Hill COURT of COMMON PI"12M o\, CUMUnftl.ANI) COUNTY", PHNNSY1J V ANI/\ NO. 98,5127 CIVil. T1\IUvl CIVil. ACTION. IJA W IN CUSTOPY UWllm' AND NOW,lhIs _il. ,;1;1, _ IIII(of _:J...l:~L'I'-' ,19911, \Iron ro~ol(1loflho Cpnoll\lI\or's Il,opol'\, II nppollrlng \hll\ Iho pllr\los hllYO "~rool\ 10 Iho lonils IInd pl'Dvlslona ol'thls 01'1101' whloh WIIS (\10'11110(\ In Iholl' pl'osunoo Ilnd IIPPl'lwod b~ Ihol11 1\1\1\ Iholl' oOIl1\sol',ll\s horoby " ol'(lol'od 111\11 IlIl'oololll\s followsl " I;" Tho \0111pornry Ol'dor dllWI Soptombol' 21, 1998, liS II I'olll\ps to o\lstody 11101\0 Is VACATED. 2, Tho pl\l'tlos ahll1l 9111\1'0 10gl\1 O\\8tO(\y of tholl' mlnol' chlldl'on, Josslon Jo Woloh, c\,o,b, ,1ol1\II\I'Y 17, 19891 Mlchllol J. Woloh, d,o,b, Oolobel' 14, \9921111\c\ 1'lIylol' A, Woloh, cl,o,b, Fobnllll'Y G, 1997, .' 3, Mothol' 9hllll hiwciprll1'llll'Y phY910n\ OllSloclyoftho ml1\ol' children subject 10 periods of plutlol ous\ody ond vlsllotlon wllh Foihol' ns follows: A, 01\ ollol'notl1\g weeke1\ds fl'Om Frldoy 1114100 p.I11, \l1\tll , " .. 8\\1\doy'01 GIOO p,m. " n, Every WcdnesdllY from 4100 (1,111, \lnlll 8:00 (1,11\, " i/ :/'.(~~H!~lti::-; ',' ';",," IIAIl \ ~Y:'i':/i;J(:\;' "" ',.. ":,..;..,, " " " __ _ , ''''---o;-~----'''''''.''''''----~'-'---'''.--_._'''''''---' ___",__",___",_.1 '~"_._.__.__u__"___,_,_,,,____,_____':"'__'____~_____'_-1' , ' c, Tho ~0\l01\(1 Tllesdll~ of ollch nwnlh frol11 (\1(l0 P;111, \\1111\ ~IOO p,m, Whol1 FIIIlwto\llllll1s S\lII~\l\ollvll1lJ I\ITI\11{!el1l1ll1\S, ho 1111\)' u;>i\\lI1\1 Ihls \111\11 Iho followh\l! mumlnl! III whloh limo he 11hllll ,Iollver Iho " ohl,hll'ol1 10 so\\Oo\ or \~ Iho npPl'opl'llI\o dn)'unl'o provl(lol', , 4, Tho pll1'\loo ohnlln\\ofl1l1\O Ihe 1111\101' holl(ln;/H, Ihone holl(llIy~ \lell1!,> (lonno,1 oS Thlll1Ksglvll1{!, EIISlol', MU1\lorln\ Pn~, Fo\\\'\h of ,Jllly, IIncll:!\hoI'Pll~, 'l'hoso pori ods of plll'tllll clIstody nnd vls\lollon shnll .\le 1'1'01\14;00 P,I\1, Ihc IlWnllll! \lcfOI'OI\\P holl(lny \\111\\ (i!ClO P,\I1, ol1ll1c holldoy, This n\\ul'l\lIl1nB ooho(llI\o shllll ~ol11mol\ce with Folhol' hllvlnB IljO ohlldl'oll for 'I'hnI1Ksglvll1!l In 199B nlld shllll lIl\el'l1{\\o Ihol'clIflol', 5, Tho Chrlsl11111S holldllY 8111111 110 bl'oKenll1lo'lwo SC!ll1l1ll1\S, Segl11enl ^ shnll bo from 12;00 P,I11, 011 Chrlsll11n!l Evo \111\1112100 P,I11, Chrlstnlfts Dn~1 ~el!monln shnll ho from 12100 P,\11, Chrlslmns D(I)' \l1111l610P P,I11, all Deeomhor '26Ih, MOlhor shnll hllVo SOl!11\onl ^ 111 1998 IInd nil eVlln ~Ol1l'sl11CI'Onfter fmd Sogmenl B In 1999 nnd n\l odd yem's Ihoronftor, Fnlher sh\\1I hnvu Segll10nl A In 1999 IIl1d nil od(\ yel\lS Iho1'onfter nnd SO!ll11en\ l1ltl 1998 nm\ IIIl oVOI1 )'Ollts !l Iherollftot, '6, Molher shllll hnvo Ihe ehltdrol\ 011 MOlher's Dny from 9;00 n,l11, \\1111\ 6100 P,1I1"III1d Fnlhel' shllll hnVQlho children 011 Fnlhet's Dn)' 1'1'01119100 n,l11, \11'I111 6100 P,\11, , ' " I" it " '1. ,\ , 1\ .' (I I ,,' ~C'! '111\i'\r,!'" I " ' ." ; Ifi. 'I I '. 4"1 .'i' .,.' I " " " " " " .' ,. " jl'",!''' ". , .. " p " " " .. I', ). t. :t' t U'r 11,1 ' i ", III t, (Utili} ~I\" " " fmAQr,n III API,foIl, I',P, , ATTPflNfiya, AT I,AW ., ~:J:Jl MAIIKUT lITnf;fiT PAMP 1111,\, I'^TI011:'ln'l~ I7rlllna'l:lIla I, ,,' " tY(l: ",.,1. I \"',.' J',' , ,~,I',-1ri,'I.','!,':t, 1" ", '~'~"/,'~:i!~ ,,' '\ " I 'lu ; 'I' J;,~r "I ,\1 '~..~,\,'" : I ~ "i' ,I, 't' 'l,,,("\I"i' .~ In .t,.,,', '.', ' '"\/,,,'~l'; \\""J' ',' ','1:, ".\ .' ;, rn' , ,!Ii; ,r'j , " '11.. Y111 ,',' f , ' . if,-' I, .... "\J~..,, d .,ll.." j,~. "~" \ I '! "I"," \:', " 1/"t1, .,' $1 \~; I ") i' I , (, I ":..' II' t ,I,,, la,,", '.. , ~~'lI"f?',I.. (, 1,,-' '. ';,". \'1' ""~n , ,',.Q.'r ,J, '.\ ", \ " " !I l'\ ' 'I,t. " " it " , I\, fi " ,(, " .' " "i' <1".. .. p- ,;' " Ill' 'j ., .~ ',' "', '.' fl " ,"\ '~,t,' , .Ob.~d' "I~V1'1 'I Ii., .;. \ .::' 'I;' , '-,I! ! " , .j'! , , " , \ I ~ OlmA!,P 11, Wm"clI, m" . Plnhl\lrr VR, LOI~lll ANN W!H.C!I, IJQfol\~lllnl ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) IN Tim COUI\T OF COMMON PI"L\AR OF CUMnnr~T.ANP COUNTY, PHNNRYfN ANIA ' NO, D8.S 127 CIVil" TEl~M CIVIl. ACTlON . LAW IN Cl1STOIW f.l.l1WUH AND NOW, Ihls ..-.....-.if. #, dllY or ~ :?-=1,a.\tf4.l.ibP=L-, 1998, IlpOll l'uo~IPI of Iho ' Conolllnl01';9 Roport, It nppollrlng Ihllt IhoplIrtlos hnvo Illll'ood to Iho h'l'ms lI11el provisions oflhlR OrelaI' which wns (Ikintod 11\ thaiI' pl'osOl1co nlld nppl'owd by thom nnel thaiI' oOll\1spl, ills horaby ol'dorod IIl\d dlraolpc\ liS follow,~1 I, Thalampul'lll'r Ordol' dnlad Saploll1bal' 21, 1998, liS il rollltos to f,llill1o~ ollmo Is V ACATllD, , , /l (, 2, Tha portlasshnll shllrolognl ollstolly of Iho\l' 1\11 nor ohlldl'on, ,losl>lon .10 " Woloh, el,o,b, .lollllory 17, 10891 Mlohno!.I, Woloh, d,o,b, Ootobol' 14,,19921 IInd , Toylol' A, Woloh, d,(l,b, \1obl'llllry 6, 1997, 3, Molhol' shnll hovo prlll1111'y ph>'slcllt ollstody oflho minor ohlldron slIbJoct 10 porlods of POI'IInl cnstody IIIHI vlsllollon with Fntl1Ol' ns follows I A, On oltal'l1lltlng waokonds from FrldllY lit 4100 P,I11, IIntll, SllndllY III 6100 P,11\, ' , " I n, Evcry Wodnosduy 1'1'0111 4100 P,lll, IllltO 8100 )Mll, '""""i"'Il.'Vlll'tl.','r' "'"''1''' ''''"".-"iI'MnnN "':"', i" :;,::"":";',:"",~;/''';,';j ;,i ',,;I: ' '.r': ,",IIA,' III' , ,:", ; ,~,:; .. i,';:",:':'::-;/,.',;,' ~ ,. 1\ ., "Ii j', :i " " " " h, I !. ..d I , J! I i': I 1 " , ,I " " It ,'.1 "_1 Ii " " ,', 11"'(1' I... '-_"; ,J tan)il, . i'I;; " J! " " " " , ! I iI' 1':1 '/'11 n I !), 1 "( ,",) ",1'11' 1\(;'/I,\;'/,j\I1/\ <I' " " " ,1 " " ,.. ., ,. "" " " II '" ,. " :, ',' F., " " 'i' ,i' " " 'I. ", " Dafenclant 11)1 Tl'1!~ t)Ol,JRT 01' pOMMoN PI.I~AS OF OlJMI]I~I~I.^NP GOlJNTY1 Pj:NNBYI.VANIA NO, on.fi1 ~'( olVII. ACTIoN" I.AW QUSTOPY Gt:RA~P F, W~~QH, ~R" Plplntlff ' va, ~ORI~ Nt Wt:~OH, mJliT.OllYJJ.Q.NQJI.IA.TJOIi.llI.lMMAliY_RI;P.OIi! INAOOORPANO~ WITH OlJMt:lt:R~ANP OOUNTY RUI.~ OF oIVII. PROOJ;1PURJ;1 , 1016,3.a, the un~lersl[JI111d O~lllto{ly oonolllator !HIIJmlts tile followll1gr13port: 1, The pllrtlnant Inforn1atlon oonoernlng thll Ohll~1 who III ,"e subJeolof thlllllllgl'ltlon,ls n~ follows: , ", NAMe Jesslon JoWeloh QATa..Q.E...13.1IiTt:\ ' QUBBIiliTJ..YJN..QUBTOPV OE Molllflr Jamwy 17, 19B9 ~, A oUlltody Oonpllll'lllon Oonferenoe wps held on Deoember 10, 200l"wlthlll13 following Indlvldllals In Elttllndanoe: Ihe PetltlonerlFflther, Gerald F, Weloh, Jr" who Elppearlld pro se: tile " Molller, l.orle N, Wllloh, Elnd her oounsel, Pllbra, Denleol1 Oantor, I:sqlllrll, ' , ;, r- .. , , 3, Thll pElrtles were seen for-their first oustody OOl1olllallon oonfer\'lnQe elnoe Ootober 22, 190a, Fl'lth13r pelltloned for modlfloatlon of the present Oustody Order pndls seeking primary " " pllYslOElI oustody of the Ohlld basecl on tile following oonoerns: , A, l.Ivlng oondltlons: Father expresses oonoerns tlH~1 the Ohlld Elt limes 11ElS not, hEld oleElI1 ololl1lng, that Ihere Is Eln ElOPlll1llllEltlon of dog WElste In the YElrd Elnd that thEl grElss Is high In Ih8 YElrd Elt Moll1er's I1ome, , " 13, HElreh plwslo~1 dlsP'llllnel FEll her expresses fpur 9ono~rns In this ~re~, "In the first, Falhllr Ellleges hElllwo yeElrs Elgo Molher puslWd Ihe Ohlld downlhe .. . steps. 1-113 fltEltes tlml he bElses .Ihls oOl1oern 011 a report from his D~ughtfl[, .. FEllher sl~tes .lh~t 110polloe report was fIIetl and that, although Ohlldren Elnd " Youth was o!1l1ed, 110 oElse W!1S opened, Thill WElS alleged 10 hElve happened approximately IWo years ago, In the'seoond Inoldent, ElpproxlmEltely Iwo . weeks ~rlor to Ihe Ouslody 001101l1!1t1011 Oonferenoe, Father alleged IhElt Mothel's boYfriend threw a ohEllr al the Child, He aokl1owlEldQes Ih!1t the Child WElS 1101 Injured ~nd thallhere were no bruises Elfl a result of this Inoldent. FEltI\er ~Iso reporls IhEllone of his younger ohlldren reports Ihlll Mother's boyfriend hits him with a bell, The Ihlrd Isslle of oonoern for rElther In Ihln area WElS b!1ssU on the ohlld's report thElI she was not allowed to leElVe the house lIntll shewrole alElller saylr1[J thaI anlnol~enl where she Was dlsolplll1ed with a belt In Oolober 2001 Was, In faol, dlsolplll1e as opposed to Elbuse as she hadllpparenllY reported whel1 she spoke with Ihe police. " No, aa-(i1~7 - Olvll Tefl11 I'nther 1'I1~\l e><pre~~\l~ 0011061'11 tlHl! MOOHlf 1(JI~S\3~ the OhllrlllY her nlothlno, Il1k(J~ II Ilnok, I1nd Ihan prpml~e~ her mnt\3rlnllt\3l11s whloh ~he then (Ipas nol prpvlrje, Tile Ohllrl hqs 111\1[1 repmleello I'nthar Ihnl BIle hn~ IIPfln onlle~1 11 Vlllgar nl1l11\3 Wllhlnlhl3" I\l~l f\3W waak~ IJY Mothllr'~ IIv\3-lnIJoYfrlenel.. 1311~\3~1 on Ole~eoonoen1P, FnlhQf I~ seekll10 prll11nry phY~lnnl o\lstorjy of 111\3 Ohll~l. Father proPQ~a~ tha Ohlld \1onw 10 liVe wllh hln1 on n prlmnry Im~IQ, Fnther prellenlly reslfle~ In MO\lnlvllle,I-l1non~tflr Oounty, I1ml works In MeohnnloQIJlIrQ,PennQvlvl1l1la, aholllrj thara IJa a 1110ve to Mo\tIltvlllu, the Ohlld would likelY E1ttencl 0113 !-Iel1lpflplel Sohl1ol Plslrlpl. 4, Motlll3r's position on Quslo~IY: Mother slnles lhnt Qhe ht1~ hf,lanlh\3prlmniyo\l~todIElI pfll'Elnt ~Inoe the p.l1rtlElS' s\3paratlon In 10pa, She stntes thnt Ih\3 Ohllrl.l.s on 1111'1 ho. nor rQlIl1t. ' \.emoyne Mldrlle 80hool, Mother reportstl111t shEllms plElyerl sopoer fl'Jr the InQt four yeElrs liS well. She f\,!ols It would be In the Ohlld's IJest Interest to rel1l111n wlthlwl' slhllngQ In Ml'Jther'lllll'Jl1le In the present o~lstodlal fllTangement and 10 oonlllllle In Mother's prlll111ry phY~lol1l QlIst!Jdy, Molhar l'Ioknowled~ee lhallhem 11Iwf/ p\3eq Qlgnlfloflnt InoldElnlflll1t\3IY with the OhlkllJelng cflQrespeotflll and lll100pperatlve In the wElY Ihat adoleRoents frequently ohooee 10 oonduot thel1ls!llveQ, 111 . respol1se to this Mother hns al'rnnged for the ohlld to pElrllolpate Inl11Batlng .wIth the oounselor Elt the. sl'Jhool al1d hn.s I1rml1ged for prlvute peyoholoOloElllnterventlon with PI', AIII~on SlellElr, The Ohlld hEl~ I'Ittended five appointments wlthlhlQ psyohologlst, Mother relEltas 111'11 the Inoldentln JE1mlElry of 1000 was, In fElot, a Qllp dowl1 Iwo steps Ell her home. Although the Ohlld threE1tena\j to rElport Ih.Is In.oldent to Ohlldrenln YOllth they apparently did nol open EI oElse I1lthllt time, Anolher .Inoldent ooollr[ijd on OotoPfJf a, 2001, when Mothar EloknowlEldlled thElt she dlsolpllned the Ohllel with a bEllt due to deflElnt !\nd dlsobflcllent behuvlor In her Interaotlons with Mother, Fpllowlng this Inoldent the Child WE1S Interviewed py tile looal polloe department and by Ms, Miller Eltp~lmPerlElnd OOlll1ty 8001'11 Servloesfor ohlldren E1ml Youtl), However, onoe aQf.\ln, the OElse WIlS not opened, Mother dElnles FElther's ElIIElg!\lIons of teaslno or Proken promises, However, she does noknoWledgEl that on one oooElslon she did refuse to go Into the Ohlld's room 10 plok up her la~lI1dry E1nd waahlt for her, However, the following week the Ohlld begElnlo plnoe her Qlothlno 111 the .. I~llndry to Pe wElahed as Ihe other !llernberfl of t1.le fan111y do, '5, The p~rtlos Elgreed thElt there. would pe a Olls\ody evaluallon plilrformed by Relgler, 8hlenvold Elnd Aesl,JoIEltes, I:aoh pllrty will pay hnlf of the oost assoolutecf with the evaluEltlon, Elnd beol.\llse ~f FElth~r's request, a heMlng will be SOhedUled(forejUdO,e Hess, ~ 1d-.~r1 DI c .' ;)- 2-.liftr!. /~.../ Df1te tv1el ElSE1 peel GreeyY, I:squlre , Oustody Oonolllator " '.l " ;111 , . (lI\MI,P F, WI!I,ell, ,lit,.. PlhII\I\\'\'; ) IN TIIH 1~(l\IW\' (IF ('()MM( )"1 \I1,1':M; ) OF ('UMllliHld\Nil ('()11NT\', ) I'I!NN~\'I,VI\NII\ ) ) N(), \JH-~ I 27 ('IVI L TI'I(~'I ) ) 'cIVII,!\("TION. I.I\\\' ) I N C'\J~T()il\' ) w, I"OI~I\l ANN Wln,ell, \)0\'01\111\1\\, " 'j, ORI.um.OlLCO UH'!' , " AND NOW Ihis .___.___.. dll~ \ll'.........~..._...........:!iJ(l:!,llpPI\ rovlolV pl'lhu ,- "" 1I\1l1oho\1 Poll\ll1l1lbr COlllol11pl.11 IHI1Qroh~ ()IWlmnp 1111\1 DIK'I(nlm IIH\IHORl'ol\llul\\Ciornhl F, Wolrh;,l\', RI\l1\1ltnI11OlIlIl\olv RlIlTellllrl' ellslody ol'lho I11hlPl' chlldl'oll 10\'cllllol1ul', ,I" ,_...... !,,' . - -,. I(ospoi\(\on\'s ph~8lclIl c\l811111~ rlgh\8 10 the 1\111101' chlld\'un.lo,8RlclI, Michllclllllll TII~lol' Woloh 111'1.1 S\18\1ul\dod PUI1I\ll\g II IWII\'hw 0111hl8 \'011\101\ 10\w hold llll (he ... .......u......_. dll>' or I' III ..._AM/I'M 111 Cl1\1l'1\,lllll\1 No, '''J~_..........__.1I1 Ihu C'lIl11\Jul'illl1d Cllll11l~ Cn\ll'thn\lso, Cllr\lslo, Ponns~lvllnln, Tho RuspondcntI1H1>' hlll'O sllpcl'l'lscd plll'lllIl clIRlod~ orlhc ohllllroll nl 1II110s I1llllllll\ly ngrood 10 h~ tho \1111'1106 ponllll1g Iho hUlII'llIgpn Ihl6 I1WIlOI', In' 'I'll\! CDUH'I': " , ,~~__.",,__~_,._.,,~~-~"'-'.""-'"~1.'._.'----'-_.'''''''_4 , :. .. J. i'" I' physlolIl \3\181111Iy 111,,10<<81\311,1: WUlllh, i\ 11'lIP 1111\1 PI1I'1WI ooPy 1I1'~11111i !'olllllln IH 1111111'110.11 IhUI"I'Io liS Ii~hlllj\ "11'1, . (I, i\ PIlslolly uol1l\Jl'ol1Uo WIIS hol\1 01\!lu1lU1l11lUl' I H, 20011\ol\ll'~ ~11tliHHII (hw\'y, . , , 7, Tlw plll'lloH I\'UI'U Il1mhlp 101'0HIII\'o IhlH 11H11101' 1111\111 ill In ho r~I\JlTod lill' 11\'lIHlod~' -O\'lIhlllllon, 8, I'lll'llnllnllolhu PlIl'llpu' 1l\1I'1'OllIt'o\ll'1 Onlol' ol'Nol'Ull1hul' 'I, Ji)IJH, tllo chlltli'un WUI'U III 11\ll'ollll'l1O!1 hy l{oHpol1llonllhllwl' 10 Pullllol1ul',l1lolhul' III (1:IH,II'M on lJ~uol1lhol' 25, ~OOI. " I), I{UUI;ol\dunII'Ullll'lwd Iho Il1h\lll' ehlldl'ul\, MluhllullIl1d '1'111'101', 1I\'~ol'(\Ing lolhu . , - , Ol'llul' on \loeol1lhel' 25, ZOO I, Il0wuyul', RUHpol1denll'\3f\IHod 10 1'01\11'111110 mlllol' chilli ,loHHIt'11 I' " (thc Hl1h.loet child qf' hlu pl'OHU Mmll I1Pllllol1 1'\Jllllon), I1l1d,luHUlulIlI'lIU 1'011l11l~IIII1I{UHp0I1(lol1l'H Pll1'e 111 dll'oul ylolllllol1of'lho CIIITOIlI (;lIulo,ly Ol'dol', 10, F\II'llIol", plll'UlIlIl1llolho COliI'I ordlll' IIlld II HOplll'IIIo IIgl'uol110l11 hy Ihc pl\)'lloH, " 1{0upnl1dont WIIU to plel, lip Iho 11)111111' ehlldl'ol1l1l 4:00i.I~'1, Dcool1lhol' 2h, 2001, I\lJ hlH ." 1\II01'l11111ng WCdl10HdllY O\,Ol1ll1g 11111'11111 UIIHI!)dy IIl1d l'olll1'11lh0111III H:OO I'tvl. 110 picked lII' ;, 0' , Mlehllel W()(ll\uudllY 111,4:00 prY!. II, ROUllol1del11 I\llIod IOl'ot\I1'11lhe 11111101' ehlld, Mlehllel, Oil Wedll~H(hIY, D06elllhol' 2(1.20011118:00 PM. In dll'eoll'lolllllo11 Mlhe COliI'I Ol'dol', 12,Ih1spol1do11US 1101l'el'I'UHel1lod hy ellllllselnl1d hilS ul1gllgcd 111 sull~hlJlp 10 lIuhiL'l'u Ihe I'OHlllts hu Is soukll1g ill his pro su Modll1unllol1 PUllllon, Del\Jndnnl's u(lullHolndl'luud . Plnlllt1ITshu would I1lu tho Pullllol1 For I\n1Ul'gunuy Rollof'nl1d PUllllon Ihl' COlllull1pt unluss " Plnlnlll'flhlhul' nlxud hur n lulieI' Indlentlng howould I'UIUI'Il Mlchnolnnd "usslon hy 5iOO P,M, on Dcuomhul' 28, 2001 nn" Ihnt he would rosUll1e Ihllowlng Ihu physlunl cuslody H~hcdlllo ns sui " Ihl'lh'III Ilw Nn\'lilll\WI' ;\, IIHlH ('\ISlpdy (lnlul" 1\ ll'll\llIl1d \'\lI'I'l'I'll!I'lp~' \II' slIl\l I'ax 1\1l'\I'ill'llud hy 1'111111111'1'10 I'M\llllllllll'H \lO~IIIil\lIIH 1IIIIIl'huIIIIIll'll\OI\S lixhibll H( "', D, HOSpo1H101I11'01111'11u1111Il\ l,hlhll'ul\ \III IJU\'l!11111111' 2H, 2\11l1 11I\.(1I' Ilblllll S:()() I',M,' III. PllrHllllllllnlhu ClIs\lHly (}I'dul'llI'No\'\:ll\lwl' 4, I')')H, i{USP1111lIul1\'s I\lIXI Hohulllllul\ pul'lllll ol'Plp'lllIl UIIHll1d~' II'IIS, III IlIliU pllluu 1111 Wu\IIIUHlhi~' .II11HIIIl'Y 2, 2002 n'Oll1 <1:00 p,M, In HIOO P,M, " 1 S, ,011 WUdI1UH\hl~' ,lllIllll1l'Y 2, 2()O~ l~uspnl1llcl1l l'lIlhl'l' pluliUd III' Ihu Ihl'uu Ilhildl'ul1ul 4:00 p,tv\, bllllililod 10 1'01111'11 lIlUl11 III H:OO ",tv!, 111 dll'cul viollllinl\ol'pllI'IIl\l'l\ph J II ol'lho Ul'dcl' I, ,. IIIId I~CHp(lll\luI11 liopllhu uhlldl'ul111\'Ul'l1lghllll1d l'cllll'l1od l\I'n nl'lhu childl'cl\ III IIPpnlXlllllllcly 7:15 A,tv\, 011 Thlll'HIll\Y .I1\1\\IIII'y J, 71l02, l~ospllndollllililud In l'u\ll1'\1 ,IUHSlclI, 16, I~CHpllll1lolll's 1I0lloIIH IIH IIbovo 11cHcdbcd Is il1 dil'Cl\l \'llIllIliollol'lhu COlll'l Ol'lll'l' " 11,l1d I11I1KOS II olclIl' Ihlll i{ospollllollllil\hul' IlllH 110 l'cHpocllhl' Ih~ IIIII' IIlld Il1lul1ds In I'c\nll1 ph>'slclIl CIIBlolly of Iho chlldl'OI1II1 dll'ccl \'101111101101' Ihc CUSlody Ol'dcl' nl cllch cus\bdllll oppol'lIll1l1y, .., 17, 1'1I1'1I!ll'lIph J C, 01' \hc Novol1lbol' 4. 11)I)H Clllll'\ Ol'dcl' spoclliclllly pl'ovldcH 111111 '" ItOBpOllllol11 fhlhol' lillBpnl'lIl11 Ollsllld>' or Ihc ohildl'olllho soool1d Tuosday or OIlClll11Ollth li'ol11 .' . ' ii, 4:00 \I,M, 10 R:OOP,M, Wholl 1111111111' IIhllllns Sllltllhll'lIvlllJ.lIII'I'IIIIJ.lOlllOllts, hltlllll~' OSIl'Il11 this IIntll tho ful\uwltlll IllUI'lIhlll III which thllll hll Nhlll\ <101\1101' thll chlhll'llll tu sl'huul III' tll Ihll "11111'1I111'1t\(0 <,III>'CIII'o lll'uvhllll'. (El11phllsls IIddcd), ROSPOlldoll\ Iillhcl' hllH Ul1l1l1lOl'ulIy dooldOlllhls o\'ol'l1lghl pl'OVIBlol1ofplll'lIgl'lIph J C sl\ould IIIBIl ho uppllud 10 his Wcdl10Hduy plll'lllll ouslmly sohodulo or 4100\',M, 10 HiOO I',M, dCHpllo lho I'IICI ,this IlIngullb\c Ihl' oWl'l1ighl " ' , \'lsilllllol1ls ol1ly Hot fbl'lh 111 PIIl'II!!l'lIph J C oI'lho Ordor IIIHII101 PIII'IIl\l'lIph J II, (Soo Exhlhll A,) 18, Durll1g Iho porlml nl'tlmo RospI;ndol1f 1I'1'01lgl\llly l'clllll1od clIslody or M khllol holll'ool1 \)000111hcl' 2() 11mI' Docomhcl' 2ll. 2001. Rospol1dol1t 1001, Ihls I) YOIII' old child 10 1I'01'K. , 'I' I' ','I ',I' Ilr: .. I,:-~,,/j ....._~ li'{61~KI'~fiN[Si)~.~!^N'~~','T!f1T.i\"Til~i . . 1'1\ [I) Nil;Hl(d7R .. .., f 'J () .\ ;I()ANN~WA:~;~)'N ('IJ' .'(11/, ,'\Sijtl'll{i!" PA IP No;: ~h4(l1 " UYI ", ", 2~,11 MIII'I(ut Struut .. CI\1l1P lilli, PI\ 17011 (717) 7(1~-1 ~H~ "i I' ,j' ;.j' Ii Ii ", 1- '1 " " " 'I, I::' " " 1\ " '" , " " " " i,i,' '" " J, ;1 il h .j ; .' '. .' ", ," "I, I' " .. " 'j, .' " , . I/i " " ~,i " I, I' "',u "'..__._....... ...__...____..._......_ ., .. ..... ._._~-,. ..-.....--.--.....---.-- ........_~-_..._--._.--~.-_.-...--_..,..._--_...:, el, Tho ~1:oOIl\I TII\l~\II1~pl'on\lh Ilwnlh frol11 f\10() p.I11, \1\1111 H100' p.I11, Wlwn Fnllwl' llhllllllM ~\!IIi1\l\o IIvlnUllrrlll1LIOl1\ol1ll1. ho 11111~ uXlull\1 'hiM 111\'11 'hc following 1110 I'll I nil 11\ which 111110 ho ~hllll lIulIyol', Ilw ehllllrul1 \olle\\\lol or 10 'he I\P111'\1pl'll\\0 III1:;OllrU I1I'0YI\lul'. , " 4, Tho plll'llollllhllll IIllol'nl1lo tho 11\1\101' holl(!II>'lIllIwn~ holllln>'lIllOlllll ., 11011110(11111 'I'hlln~lIillyllIl.I, !':lIlIlol', Momor\1I1 Pn:;, l1(1\IXlh Ill' ,1111)',111\11 1,lIhol' PII:;, Thollo pUl'lnll1l of PIII'\III\ ollM\()(I:; 111111 Ylnllllllon IIhllll ho 1'1'(11111\100 P,I11, thllcYul1lng hL1lhl'e \hc 110 II I\n)' Imlll (iI()O P,I11. ol1lhe ho\l[lll:;, Thill nllul'I\lI\h\1! ~clw\l\llo 111\1111 u0I1111lCl1oU wl'hFII\hul' hllYlnLI Ihe ohlllll'ol1 for 'l'hlll1~sgIYII1I! Inl99H nllllllhllll IIllul'lllllo Ihl\r~llf\ol', , . , . 5. Tho Chl'lslmllM hollllll)' 11111I11 bo hl'o~on Inlo two 1I0gnwl1tll, SOl.ll11unl ^ . shnll hu {h1m 12100 P,I11, 011 Chr\slnHIII EVOllntll12100 pll11, Chrllltmns DII:;I SCl.lll\OI1\ n shllll bu from 12100 .p.l11, Chrlllll11l1l1lJlIY 1111\11 6100 p,m. on lJoollll1bol' " 26\h, Mo\hol' 8hlll\ hllYo SU(Jlllunl ^ 111 1998 nntl 1111 eYOn YUIIl'lIlhorellf\UI' IInl\ . ,. ,I " . Segl11cl1\ n III 19991l1\fl 1111 ml\1 YOUI'll thol'ellftol', Flllhol' IIhnll hllYu SllgllWl11 ^ III 1999 (\llll 11\1 odd YOI\I'II \1101'0111'\01' 11111\ Sogmol1\ n III 1998 11111\ nil OYOI1 YOIII'II \hUl'ol1l'\ul" ,,;' " ' 6, Molhol' IIhnll11l\vo Iho ohlltll'oll 011 Mothol"lIlJny 1)'0111 9100 n,l\\, 111\111 6100 p.\11" l111d ]1l1lhol' 1111111\ hnYo Iho uhlll1l'oll 0\1 Fllthol"lI DllY frol1l 9.100 11,111, \\1\\11 6:00 P,1\1, " " , , " 'i " ,-' I, " , e,t-hhcY {f.',' 'lVe,f,rAr'l O~, ' v /-.-(N 1-(., ~,u,el~h /11'1 T!m QOlJH'" QV COMMON p!,n!\fl OF i CUMJmm,ANP (loT)N'I'Y,118NNI'1YINANIi\. I I OIVU. ACTION j.AW IN CtlWl'OPY , : NO, 9P"'S/tl7 (f~{..l~L~'tl .l'Ji?1:u101'l.ltOlU\1PJUlrlQA'l'lON 0 lUf.lUS~Q.UX I; .. ..:-' "'.j, , '1'hn rollll\lll llfl-~___"--:' __~_l'onpll!llt\l\lr rOpl'oRonlKI ,1, 'rim! ~;\.l{oXUllbl4C ~,J!NJ~IIAo/<e.01.}lf~9!)' onlOrllll An ontol' aonO\ll'lltlll3 Iho C\lKIlll\~ ol'Mlnor ohllil I Ohtl\h'on..-8~~e.--.(LJ&~':'~U~C. , A 'me !Inri \\nrrocl onlly'ofthQ Imlo\, In otlllohod 10 tiltH 1101l1ln(l, " ~',. ThlK \lrch~I' $111;1\\11\ \10 I1lIHlll1od Iln fo\h1WHI ..' ,'~ ~ ,. c:9.04i~ Ov ~~.a .R,y~M.tf.14M ..1rtJA dJA'u\-1.-, 717) t(l/~ (~dl^', tt.tA. 6f.:tY\J.~/, H'f.Jl-, '~Jf-'~4-'!-rJ ,/U(J4hiA _ ()A~;" ",', j." . " rLMA. 1f:.. ~u..()..,cUfJ~ t~ " ...J- ,. , '~lMJith rV1.~,t r:{ !Ht~l11/J ,UYt.tJ11(JYJ 1f'r;{).I {1-1 " '0, V:0f;rJJ aJtVJ.i' +ru 'J1iHAtA-:~ .lvre~")/(Y l.-ttry 1f~4i{" G'~c-ev ~~ .4 tqv~U)),ed.>ftW, ~Iu. \. eei!.& L/-M.-e.cdVJ{uJ Uf\cUA. +YLUl~ UY\CU;fIO'YV) I Mtd MI Ill-t/l WYl~p(j' ' , " \~.t~.~,~, .-iU01 ,tJ..fi?l,-, I h ~~fatt tU,l. Wv t1-J.U,fV .JII/!1.e 'r<J~1f/JYiaJ fJrt~U!./ I C-~(;hU-.~/1.q{ Jfpu'l1^, .40Jft~ rJ.4td , ' -1 e~t~. lXl\.d ~/)u).4elw a..L c{,e'r11$7j ru 111A.'dd1~jj(!.i'i.pt.9l ' \V1-IrlREVORfi, l'utltl0l101' I'llt\\I0Atn. Ihllt tho Colll'! modllY the oXIAtlllU ollRtorly otc\ol..llQonuae It will ho III tI\e boatlnlol'tlRt oflha chile (ron), .',' . , ,,~~l-, SL/ " "" . " 2x/'rIb,'/- (!;, " ' j' .. 7.R '1C)\jrl ... 1'1'\" ^^""l~lf) rl \i'\ST1'1W " '1hhRlbblTl. r,R llH Tl'IR~lqnli'.t' Ii IIIU'''-\\I''HlII'll,\',\ 1',l!lli1r 1,~\\\I'l'ln,l\illll\ '\lnIIHtI,III\'''I,JI('l'ltl I'II\H \'I~I " Ii 1'~IJ , " ,.'< L'll:H'O "'l(.'i\TIW",~gH" I c I~ 1"IIlIIIllW 1 1 111'1'1 HlllI Clplwh, IiHqllll'~ dp h~l'~h>' ~\!l'liIY Ih\\1 Oil this 11\\11l1 H~I'\'llll (l1l' Ihl'ognll1g P\lllllllllol1l'llIll1ll1'f'hy lilxl11g II CIlPy III hlPIIII hlH pille\! Or~lllpll'>'lIlelllllll i1gh I\HHl1olllloH IIlld III his l'\!sill~1111111 lilx 111111 hy plnclllg II cop>' illlhe I1Wlllnlh\! l'tlophol1~ 111lll1h~'l's " "; " , 111111 mh.h'~HH HUllbl'lh bulll\\': Jinx III Iligh AHHllUlllll1H @ 7 I 7- (ilJ7.0H 70 . JlIIX 10 0"1:1'>' WUlllh @ 717-~H5.5()HO U,$, MIIII, posllIgu pro pnid: [1,,, OUl'lIld F, Woloh, .II', " (170-]2 Ilumpf10hl ROlld Cllhllnhlll,I'A 17512 " 'j, , , " " 'I' A i;;";"~1 M~ig~~.. . ----- ImMlE {& ADLIlR, /" \ 2331 MlIl'kul Stl'cet ClIll1p 11111, I'A 17011 Telephone No, (717) 7(13-13H3 AllY, Id, Nil, ;Jr>4r>1 " Dille: I.... 3,,. 0 Z.,.. " .' " {< ii" '.. ,J\ ~~. h" 11\ " Ii'" .' ,llll'j 11/:' : l",r U ; ('.Ii" ~ ! " , ,l ~:'.r; t' II.. I . I " l") ,I),. , "il , " '" i ""1 ! .. , U. 1'1 I'd t" ,:,,) I,. ,t!' (. " '. " f,/_ " " " Ii ,. " I ~ ~P~\'~9L(?I?1 HOV'\ IO?1 V~ 'Till I ~wvn J.qU\I~q mllvw ,~&~ MVl tV 8AUN\10J.-\V '0\1 '!lijl\1Y ~ \HlIlYUII I I' . " , !f I' " " 'I '1{' {'. '" i! ,.. " " 'I "" i " " " " il t! I;' H II , " " 'I' " " ..' " " I' i' " 'I, " I', i' ",I; ". " ,.' i" ,,' " ", ! " " " f, 'I, " " " "" , " l, " " " I ,]Ilt,II,\ :,'\111;', ~U ,. ., Paf13ndnn\ (~, 2 :>. 200? IN llll: OOI.mTOF OOMMON PI.IW3 OF OWMI?I~RI-ANP oOWNTY, PI=NNsYI.VANIA NO, OO.61~7 OIVII. APTloN -I.AW OUSTOPY Q~RAI-.PF, Wr:;~OH, ~R" . Plfllntlff va, I-.ORI~ ANN W~I..OHI Q.US.T.Qtn'...QQtiQJL.lAIIQNJU..!MMARY_Rt;.~BI IN AOQORPANO~ WITH'QUMt:I~R~ANP OOlJNTY RlJl..~ OFOIVII-. F'ROO~PURt: 1 016,:Hl, the und13ra.l~ned OuatoclY Oonolllfltor SUlJl11lta the Mowing report: . ,. 1, Tha pertln\3nt Information l1onoarnln~ tll\3 Ohlldren Who EIre 111\3 subJeol of this litigation Is F1s followl3: '. ". . ' NAMa CAtffi..O.E...a.lliTH Ootober 11\, 199~ JEIIlllElry 17, '!fl09 , y-I.IRBaN!bY.1N CPBTOtn'.JJE Molher Molher MlolmelJ, W~ll1h JftaslQF1 ~o Wl'lloh ~, A O~lstOqy Oonollll1t1on Oonferenoe, WEIll h~lcl on Febl'llElrY 5, 200~, with tlw following IndlvlduElls In AllenclElnoe: the Fatl18r, GerEllcl F, Weloh, Jr", Qm se; the Mother, l.orle Ann Welol1, Elnd I1Elr oOLlIlsel, PelJrEl Denison OElnlor, Gsql.llre, 3, The pElrtlel\ and Ms, OElntor were seen pllrsllant to a JElnUElI-Y 3, ~002, petition for Oontemp\ flll'ld by Mother Elllegino Ffl\!lar's fElII~lre 10 oomply with the Orqer of November 1\, 190a, ,.. . 1\, The pmtles reElohecl an agreement to strlotly oomply with the Orders of November 1\, 1000, and Janl.lF1ry 15, 2002. Upon those oondltlons, oOLlIlsel for the Patllloner agreed thE1t ,the Oonteml)t Petition presently before the Oourt will be he, Idln abeyanoe, Howevar,lnthe ' .evenlthat there are repealecl violations of either Order wllhln slxly clE1YS of the dale of this . Order, an adelltlonal oollOIlIatlon COllferenoewlI1 be soheduled, Upon proper petition the lllE1tter will then be referred for IJlsposltlon by JUdge I-less, , 5. There will be no ohElnge In the Order of Oourt, However, Ihe OonolllEltlon Report will be fllecl with the ProlllPnotary Elvallable 10 Ihe Oourt, " 6. It was theOonolllEltor's observation at the Ouslody Oonollla\lon Oonterenoa Ihat these parenla rJemonstraled sOl1le ability to have oonversatlons Elnd parenting dlsOLlSslons Ihat Were produo\!ve, Mother speolfloally reported thaI there was E1 t1rne wilen they were able to hlWe parentll1g conversations regLIIElrly, Ideally, these parlles would be well served tOl11eet with a medla\br or a mental health professional to ElBslsllhemln non-destruotlve guided pE1renllng conversations to regElln their ability to set aBide Ihelr dlfferenoes and fOCLIS on the needs of their Ohlldren, . " h , No, Ogl3.G1~7". Civil Terlll PIB\: . " ) , .J.Is-JJt'/[~Q. C~._,\ M\3I1l'lsf:ll:le\31 Greeyy, ~sqlllre O~II'ltody Oonolllf1\or' . ....nIWrl\ ppl1lapl1 clmlor, l"aq\IIIO, ?331 Mnrku\ Slrool, OUI11~ Hili, I'^ 17011.A042 ,.9"(0111 F, Waloh,.I!'" 117U.32I1p!1Ipflulllllpncl, Oollll11lJlo,1 ^ 1"I!i1? " :1 COP\~~' f'\o:\\~d 6 p, ';l ~.Of). ~ p,~~ r11/, ? (~ 7-' Pr1\e' " ,,. ;.1' " " " " '; " , " ;.\, " I' " '" Ii i. i' " l' ii,' " /; f', i' ,. " j; " i.I' " " " " " " " I, "" " " " il ", 'f, '" " " " r I " I' I , , " " '" .. " " i' u!' " ',I " q ,,' I, !'I' " "I. " H ," l. '" i;I'" "i .( 1\ .,11 " I' " !';,'i h lj, ,! ,,' ;n " \:Ji ~<'~'\ ~~ .,~d ,,\ I" '~ \,) ~ '~ ( 1~,~ '~t "1 ~ " " " ,. 'J, ;' , . , , , " e. 0A(j f~We.f,vh ~)f\, y W.-( (1:.- ?V.el <J-.f1 I IN 'I'Im r-PI.1W/' 01' COMMoN Pl.MIl OF , OUMI~I1RT-ANP COT)N'lY,I!~NN~YrN,^N1^ I I OlYH. AOTlON I-A W IN aUf/rOpy " : No,9P.....s-m7 a'-'~L ~~IYJ l'~JmQl'UrQn I\fODlVICWI'ION OE.A-Cl1~P1U:, 'rho !1oI11illl\ of .---.-----..:____ ,rQ~ppolf\lll>' rQllI'QnOnl~1 , 1.1'h111 on NQ,~ltLhC:K::!/' IQ0ftllr,P.teJiJ.l.lle.s.!), OnlllrPlllln Onlol' 0011901'l1";UlhO ~ii~lnfl>, I'll' Mlnnrohllrll ohlhlro;;,-8,.e4.t.jL&--~~~~...... ^ IfllO Il!ln poqllol onpy orlho onto,r IflIIltlluhoflto Ihlsl1otillon" , .. "Th 1 "".'''110111'11'' '""01"<<1 '" fu UII"., ..' ,,',' '...A" , '~"(Jv ..../1~<1 IJy~ ,JvA~. -/7J ~'wdA iM." 1~'- i 11'//. "~~IU-,d ~(l4 Hv.:\ _ CIA I ,", ,. ' J:'~~"~f:Jfi/J~~~~Y-^I' ' '....~HAJith ~.t 'tVna rHtlh1/J, U)1..():lltfriaJ 1Y'e()llr/l.~1Lt 0, V:vJ;~ a)rtVJ.t it! ~tu '-wurt AI/\..,~ ..lt1'f./;,0t\, -1Jry M~1i1, , "6/-4Uc.b-/ ~M ,A/fAll1Jl.;-e'1J,ecJ J.ffW ,~M \.. eet20, l/Ndcclt-1{~. d ' 1+f\cUA. +ht6.t t.d"Y).cU.xiO'iVJ~ CL11d M~ /I"~ U/)tLp~W' '2.t4MM-- ~ ,I/-eb"- I h , aM.-ma CULt; 'f-Iv ;;;ne JAhe ra~/O'r1cU flrtfc...e., I C./vtJd0M. ?VfL.o{ )/p-u... i1'\ 4b>-1te...f.<J r.t11.d re)it~. altd 'C.~l(A.4elw CL.L c:(e,rh~71 tu 711.<c>tcl1e J:JC!.h.~t.~, WHUR1WORB, l'llllllol\~l' rlllj"OallllhllllhO Court modify fho oxlatfu/l o\lalocly 01'1101', hllQlI\lao It wHI bu" 111 1110 hO~1 fnlol'e~l!lr tho ohlll (ron); , .' .,' " .' , I\XIl1111.'1' "I" ,. ..... ......i.l \.00........ "_."H'''' " ;'1 .JMIO :\i' Vs, I IN lll~ OOlJ"T OF qOMMoNP~M$ of ICUMl3r::I~I.AND OOUNTY, P~NNBY~VANIA 1 I NO.Oa,fi12'1 I I OIVIl. AOTIQN 'I.AW I OUSTODY (:aI=RA~P Ft WI=I,.ClH, JR" , PIl'lln\lff I.,ORII= N,WpI.,Olil P\3fpnrlnnt HaBS, J"", QBDE;B.QE...oQUR.T. , 'II- ' ' '~.' " ANP NOW, thlll .-L!f. I- "q~y of ( \<I&j~' ---'-, 200~, upon ' oon~ldJ3[1:1t1onl1f thJ3 attElOhJ3q C\llllorly Qonolllllllon summ~Y Rppl1r11 II III herepy orqereq E1nd dll'!3ol\3q I'IS followal , ,", , 1, Pencllno furlher 'prclJ3r of Oomt or Eln E10r"lement of lhe p~rtles thlll COllrt'e OrclJ3r of ' Novl3mper 4, 100a, ~hE111 remain Infllll fa roe ~nd effeot with the following addltlona: ' , /13, .' ,. ,A, , 1_' Tile pl'lrtleal'll1all ~HIPmll theme\3lves E1nd their minor Ohllq 10Eln ' Inclepenqf3nt O~lstOqy eVElluEltlon to pm performed Py "elgler, Slllsnvold "Elnrl AllSOoll'lles, The pE1rtlea sh~1I sign ElII neoessE1ry releE1sea anq f.luthorlzetlons for the eVElllllOltor to opteln medloE11 E1ncl psyoh610gloal InformetlonperlEllnlng 10 Ihe pE1rtlea, Mdltlonally, tI]a parties shell extend thalr fLlIl oooparEltlon In oompletlng this eVElluEltlonln P tlmElly fashion f.lnd In the ,BohedUllng of eppolnlments, Tile oost of 11113 evaluetlc;II1 silell pe ahElredeqllEllly by Ihe pmtles wllh Father pElylng hEllf Elnd Mother pl'lylnf.l hEllf, ' A heE1rlng Is aohedyl~d pefore,JUdge Hess In Oourtroom NlIIriper 4 of the OUlllperland OOllnty OOllrlhollse, 011 tile ...115!::- qElY of ' " ~J " ~002, at .(/,' 80. o'olook .fl....,M" Ell whlph time ' teallhlOny Will pe tal~en, For the purposes of the heElrln9, the Father, GerElld F, Weloh, Jr" snbllbe,q(:lemed to be tile moving party and silall prooeedlnlllally with teall,noIlY, Counsel for the parties or the pa~les pro sa ailall file with the CO~lrt ancloppoalt19 oounsel/party a memoranclum seltlt19 forth eEloh party's pOllltlpn on oustody, a proposed pel renting pll;1n, " EllIst of wltnessea who Elre ex~eoted to teatlfy et the hearing, and e " 'bLlmmery of the Elntlolpqted testimony of eEloh witness, Ttlase " 1116I\1orenclashElII ps flied At least len clays prior to the hearlng,date, , , II' ' I3Y TI-II: COURT, h J ii,J./-";" 0, )/{..J"" r<e'vln A, Hess, J, liXllllII'1' "2" rr'1~ H'~ (t-;"'P~J'/(' p'_: ,,'....11;:.. I, I", -," r11 ,h 1'1' II" '.", """ ,'. ,11, \ J ~ . I"d~ t, "'~" ! ':,',~ In <,"'(.1 1'111""; l"",.~ 'I~"\' I' " . ,,{tf I till' ,', ,I," ,I, i', " ;" , ': '.. ' ,I' i I~' ,'~ ,f l' .' '.' ' "'-,1 if",." ""r'P'" (ll,;t ,.) f,,'. . ",,' " . ,..1"'."""'" -""""'9-' ",', l'~'1 . EJ:... .' " H' ," . ,.' .,. Iilla_~;:""'.~.,:J;lY i/. 't11\r.<1.<1\.I<-t ',Y...!I.!1.k ,,("" {,I "\1'~~f "l.fI.~, " "" " :1 tl " Plol: I. '! i' I , ,I 1 , i I I I I )l II I' PO\lrp POI1IUQI1 OO.I1IQr, t:Mllllro, ROOUPf llml AII\Of, ?3:11 Mll!~QI Slruot, pomp 11111, PA 17011 {]ornlll r, Wolpht Jr" U'/O.3? \'\olllplloll1l!IIIIWl\(I, oPl\llI1uIII,PA HU1? . .' ' j, .' " " . /' " "it " " " , " ,'{ .' " ;, " " " .' il " ;1. I; " " Ii " " " " " " I' " n " 'I' " " '\' " ," ,./; 1; I.' p " ., " ," ,j' '" I:, ." ,." " " j; " " '" " " , i I. I " l:i1I=RAhP f, WghO~t, ~RII ~hllnllff IN 1'1-1[:: oOURT OF COMMON Pl.~A8 of OlJM!3~RI.ANP OO\JN'fY, rl~NNsYhVANIA NO, fl&r6127 OIVII. AOTloN " I.AW OUSToPY ~ORlg Nt WJ:l.oH, Va, pefemlflnt .Q.UllT.QQ.Y qONQ IblA.T.lQNJlUMMABY.-'~imOBt ,. . - , . IN AOOORPANoJ: WITH OUMl3gRl.ANP OOUNTY RUI.f!l OF OIVII. PROOJ;PURf:l 1016,3.0, tha lInclerslone~1 OllsloclY OClnolllEltpr sUPI1llls the following rElporl: ,'I, The perllnf,Jnt Inforl1lfo1t1on oonoernlng the Ohlle! who Is the aub)eot of thlalltlmitlon Is !'Ia .. follows: .. ... . . , . . , 2, A O~latody OOl1olll!'!lIon OonferElnoa WAll held on Paoel1lper 10, 2001, with tile followlno hl~lvld\IElls In Elttene!mlOe: the Petltlol1ar/FElthar, GerElld F, Weloh, Jr" who !1ppeared PIP SBI the Mother, l.orle N. Welah, !1I1dher pO\!l1sel, Dehra Dan leon Ol'lntor" ~squlrel, ' .. ' . , 3, . The pEli't1es were seen for their first Oustocly OonolllEltlol1 OonfEl[{:inoe slnoe Ootoper 22, 190a, F!'!thar.petltloqecf. for 11l0dlfloatlon of the pt'\3sentOllstody Order and Is seeking prlmElry physlo!'!1 ou~tody of the. Ohlld btls.ed 01) tha following oonoerns:. , " A, I.!vlng oondltlons: Father e~presses OOnCEln1S that the Ohlld Elt times IUls 1101, hEld oleAn olothlng, tlH~t there Is Eln aoou/1llllEltlon of dog WElsta In the yare! and Ihat the ortlSS Is high In the YElrd' at Mother's home. i;, " Harah physloElI dlsolPllna: Ff.\ther expresses four oonoernsln this areEl, IIftha first! Falher f.\lIegEls that two yetlrs Elgo Mother pUshed Ihe Ohlld down the stepll, I-le.stEltes th~t he bf.\ses this oonoern on f.\ r\3polt from his Pf.\ughter; Father sll'ltes thElt no polloe report WElS fIIeH Rnd thf.\t, tllthough Ohlldren and Youth was of.\lIed! no oase Wf.\S opened, This Wf.\S Illleged to have hl1ppene,d ElpprOxhllately two yeElrs Elgo, In the seQondlnoldenl, approxlml1tely two wee.ks r.rlor to the OUlItody OO.l1olllallon Oonferenoe, FClther Ellleged Ihf.\1 Mother s bOYfriend thrElw EI ohEllr I1t Ih6 ohlld, He f.\oknowledges thaI the Ohlld was noUnjured Elncl thElt there Were no brillses RS a result of this Inoldenl, Fl1ther also reports thl1t one of his younger Ohlldren reports t1u~1 Mother's boyfrlel1d hits him with a belt, The third Issue of oonoern for Falhsrhl this arel1 was based on the ohlld's report thElt she Was notl1l1owed to lel1Va the houss unlll she wrote a laller sElylng that anlnold6nt where she Wl1s.. . dlsolpllned with a belt In Ootober 2001 was, In faol, dlsolpllne I1S oPposed 10. . abuse os ahe hl1d opparenlly reported Wilen sl)e spoke with the pOlloe,.. ' .NAMg jasslol1Jo Weloh. .. OATS OIUllB.Tl:! JEllnlElry 17,1989 .Q.U.RBIiNrbY...IN OUSTODY oE Mother 13, " " I ' Np. 0~.~12'1 "" olvlI Tprm Fll1l1er IIlap e><preaaea OollO\3rn thllt Mpther lenaes thl'! Ohll~111Y Iwr plplhlno, tEllllla 1\ 11pok, I1ncl t11Eln prpl1llal'!a hl.'1r l1l!lterlplllel1la whlph sl1\3 then ~'oea npt prpVllle, The Ohllg hils IIlao report\3~l to Flllh\3r IIH1I lllwhns lleen oflllecl a v\llm1r IHHnll within 111\3 lallt few wae~a by Molhl:lr's IIvl:l,lnI10Yfrl\3I1!I, I3l\aecl 011 tllElae Clonoerna, Fl'llher la llel:llllng primary phYllloElI ollalolly pf the Ohllll. Fnlher prppoeea Ihe Ohllcl Clpm\3 to live wllh him pn II prlmnry I)flala, I=Eltlwr pree\'lnlly realelellln MounlvlIlll, 1.lInoElatar Oounty, IIncl wpr. kllln M.l:l. ohanloapurg, p\3nnaY.IVllnll'l, Sho~tlcllhElra I1l:l a I1lPVEl to Moun\VIIIIl, thl'! Ohlld wpulclllk\3ly IItteml Iha 1'len1/lflelll Sohool PlalflQl, ' 4, MqthElr'a Ilosltlon on oUllto~IYl'Molher atlltl:lstlmt Ilhe hnll bel:ln the prlmllry oustollll'll , pllranl slnoe 111El pllr Il'ls' eeplll'Eltlonln100a, She stlltElS thllt Iha ahllcf Is onlhe honor rolli'll hempyn~ Mld<ile Sohpol, Molhe[reporlll IhElI she hElll plllya~l eOOOl'lr for the laat fom yell(S ae well, She feela It WOltlel pe In the Ohllcl'll PfJst Interest to remElln wlthh!;1r slhlll1gs In Mother's homa In Ihs preael1t Qus\ocllall1l'rI1ngeml.'1nt IIndto oontlnlla In Mother's prhm\IY physlolll Ollstody, Mother !1oknowll:lclgas IhElt thElre hnva peenslgnlflonnt Inoldents IEltElly with the Ohlle! bl'!lng cllllreapeotflll ' flnd unoooperl'lllVl'lln Ihe wlly.thElt IIdoleaoents freq~lently ohoose to oonduClt themaelVEla. In , response 10 Ihla Mother hlls,arrllngElel for thfl ohllcl to PlllllolpElte In,ml:lellng wllh the oOllnaelor al . thl3 aohool and hna ElITllngecl for prIVal\311syo!10Ioglonl h1tl:lrvenllon with Dr, Allison SlebElr, The . Ohlld.hna 1I.'hencleq flvEl' Elppolntmanls wi h thla f1SYllhologla\, MothElr ralElIl:lfl thElt t.l\e InolMnl In JEll1llllry of 1000 WIIS, Infllot, l:l ellp clown Iwo s epa III her hpl1le, Although Ihe Ohllcl thrlllltenEld 10 report this Inoldent tp Ohlldren In Youth Ihey ElPPllrently elle/no, t open EI CIISEl t:\t thElt tlm\3, Another Incident ooollrred on Ooloper a, 2001, when Mothar noknowledgelllllllt sh\3 dlaQlpllned Ihe ohlld with II bl'lll d\16 to qsflElnt and ellsol1edlent behllvlor In hElr Interacllons with MothE1r. Following this Inolgent the Ohlld Wns.lntervlewed by Ihe IpOElI police clepllrll11.\3nt Elncl by Ms, MllIl'lr lit O\1I11berland QOLt[llY Soolal Serv/oea for Ohlldrenllnd Youth, 1-\oweV61I, OI1Qe again, the oasl'l was not opened" Molher dElnll'ls FElther's I'IlIegatlonsof teflslng or broken promises, However, she doas Eloknow., leclge. Ihat on onlil pooaslon she did mfuse to gp Into the ohlld's room tp !llakllP l1er.,lElLtIldry Elnd w~sh It for l1er, I-Iowl'!ver, the follOWing weel\ tile 0111111 pegElI1 to plEloe l1er 0 bthlno In Ihe . . IElllndry\o pe waahed as, the o\hftr members of,ll1e fElmlly do, 6, .. The pElrllea fig reed Ihal Ihere WOllldb13 a ous\odY,ElVElllIEltlon performed by f~elgl~r, Sl1lenvold Ell1d AssoolEltea. gEloh pElrty will PElY half of the oost Elasooll1\ed WIIIl tile evalLlEltlon, and . beQElllseof Father'a re~Ltesl,a hearing will be SOhedUIOd(Qf JlId9~ I-1MB, ,', ' . . " 0.,.- Id-/zl-O! .. lM."" p",'Gra~, E,qU'r:~. Oustody OOl1olllEllor . " , , I ',' " II : :'",'}, I",';' '. ,I " ,J,l " /t"1 ,< ., , ,..;-' ," -I, , I. ,- I'~ I <, '., I ,'" 1-' ,- 'II .', ,.,,'1 "." '; ;1' I ;\. . :'j, I' " " 'I' ,,' " I, ,I' '. ),.. ", , I,..." j,'. '11. " " , _, I. , :"; '0" It Ii" ,f'\~ ,i . '!Hii ~Il'~!' .. "ll"l'~, i'l.'\.! i I ' (.'. '.' ~ ;~li"\i' ; .f If, ~ " " " '; . 'j,. I.;' " " " " ," (? n~,l,v~' , " Ill'AUlilllI< AI111!1I, 1',1'" AT1'OIlNliY" AT I,AW 23111 MAI\KIIT IITIII!IlT 'CAMI' 1111,\" I'A 17011"11112 1'11'/1 "/1I3,lana " " l-,./ JlJN .1p4, ZOO" " ,.. T': ''l'\;:;(: ;f.'i;}l\~' '; , " , 'i~~1 , .' . ;\~~t I r ',_.' ,itll ;,' '/r'i~,\, ' 1.,\'" \ \,1 . \'t\ ;' 'l " '1;1::('\;';1., ,i il\;i ',' 0\_ l, ' " ',' ~ ~ ' 1_;;'-'.,tn.~.lJ'. ,,~ . /[1>>,',_ \ , ~, I" ., I j, '11' ',~.,;" ,/ I" "V,I,\, ';a-,", ,I.l~l" "','" ' 1,_ . ~f ,,'- 'I"'" I', ,11..11; .' l' I'" Y.-< II , ' T. '~_I f I I " . '1", i'Ju.f;' (\1, 'Jl.'~"'fr/' , ,";;' \t ~;1Afl ..' r~ii, '.., .".. ) " " ," \l "d " ~ .~" ,( }li I -.-.) ;:,w'I':"IA 1.', I,r " ,I,. ' ,,',{ 4.A F ,. , '\~~If\'-, " .,~: , -. ~ ~t \\1) to' ,I " , " " '" " it,\ \',1 ,j\\ v,;, '01 1 i if '1 , ,. " " " " I' " " " " ,," "-I Ii " " ,." " " " " 1'1 -.~ fY~ I,. o.;l~ ,., ". "., I"I'! ,\:, .:.J .:1" I: Il{J C'tl " Jr.: ().t', I, ' ..(. I"" r I.~ ',1 ~i t\ ! ~ . ,t,. , I ('I') ',j! {/)' /')1 1'.- l'II, i"'f';;'ii d I j t~-j "I'l') I " '" i.t1' ..' , "'J ,'" ", f" (') ") 0 'I .' "'! 'p " " " j. I' 'I ;j ;, IPI, " " II' .' Ii "I;' " I' " " ~ ij H. ,II \; ji' " q '!'" /.'.; " I' I; " " " .. " " I' '" " . I' (illl{^I"P F. WIII,VII, ,ll{" , 1,'\nll1\II'I' 1', ' : IN Till! ('01 I If l' (lIQ'OMMoN PI,IIM; I ('\]M\lr\l~I,I\NIl ('()\IN'1'y,I'I\NN~YI,yt\N\^ : Nil, 2(l(l(f.7t~7" 1'l(!'i(--I'iI:CI 1',r[:1Irn , , l,cl\{\ANN W1\1,(,II,I1/li/1I \,(ml ^NN HHI,1\ IHN/\ n~l'u11dll111 I ('lVII, ^(,,\,ION. L^W i IN IlIVIlIW\\ l'HI\I~C1PI~ TO WITIIIlHt\"'t\I'lII';t\H/\NCN TO Till! PIWTIIONO'l'AIW: 1<I11dly wll\1dnlw my nppUIIl'l\1100 llll hohnll' Ill' Ihu Pulol1dnl1l. 1.01'1 "nil WuIH\1, I1lli/n 1,0\'1 A1111 g~ljll~IH\ 111 Iho nhovu ~nplllllHJd nollo11 111111 ol1lo\' Ill\! npplJnl'nllO~ Ill' 1.01'1 .A1111 W\lI\l\1, 11/li/n l.lll'l A11I1I{LIlj\llJlll\ ol1lw\' hu\1l1ll'. \, '.1' DATHD: .JlIno II, 2002 1<111t1ly ~l1tul' Illy IIppuIII'II11uU 11l1my huhnlr ill tho I1bllVO Ollpllol1otl notiol1, DA'rrm:UII8(02- I I {'\ Ll(' I"\~" ,. l~; 71 ~ .j ('l .nf...~...', _);+ 1..ILLf\-.\clJl(l 1\ ' _ _ Lori AI1I1 H\oljll 1111 11611\111111101 AVUl1l1e LumoYl1u, II A 1704:\ (717) 7:1 l-Il) 17 ' " " Ii " ;i '< , " " if " " 1'" /.' " " U ," ':,., (,'~ " " ( " I'L , , , .~r , , , , , )", " ,," >,'-.t iL "1 I,', ~, .', )e) 1.\'1 . , ~:rt.l " V!l I , , ~'...l I_c' "I' 0'-; I 1).1 '~:' ~ i ;,1(,':, " '"I._I-Cl- . ''') .!... " ("l ") 1..1 C. (j " ;! " ,j! , " " H " " " Ii , .. ,I. " H ,-, " , " " . I, .' " " ,. " p" " ,I, " " (',' l_f' ,!' ,1 " " "1'- H !' " " [I " " 'i; ", " "~,; " ,Ii 'to ,',' " ,i' " " '1' .j. " I' " " " " " " i: If! r\: to'} t- " 'd\;~'; (;.~ ',' " 'I' l'l' r;l rrl " (,'~() --- d.<- )1.1 ~I';': I~l ,'I;', ;, ~):~,~i " 'I', ",-,1 ;'/li , ('1" '\"" .... :11,., n~t.ll ;.;.,1 i1i(" I" ;I":~ ,. flit! " I', C',l I'i": Li r;..::' d I, " " " ,," "J " " " " I ," I" 1/'1' ", " ." I' " ,. " ", ji' " I' " p" I, I. I, ' ," " " I, " 1,/, '" ..-' " !I: " " ", " " ,-" {, " 1\ " ',.. ~o r.~ ,.l)~ ". ''-I , I"~! 1t.1I f... :'_;l~ ,~r. \'1,,1 ( ~ll) ',:,.j'-;, f:',:;, f)ri1 11,." .1": ''j' ,'. I "'1"1 Il'!', j-;, r I", r..., ~~J 'ill '-. ....t, 11.:1" r-_I,. "1" " I,' I fl i " t.:.:.) !,L. ~ .,. .,:,1 II. ".1 "1 c.:) C:J () " " " " r,; Ii. '-',1'- 'i ,l' " " '" " " ,. 'i " " " , " " " ,Ji of! I'" " '" , " i, " " t', " I'j,' I' i; ,I " " I( , . Ii I,ll " I, ': , /, " I'. i'- " ", ,I' l," "i1 " I, " 'j " " q II ,I' " " " '-" I' , " \.1' q~I~AI.P p, Wl~I.C'-1, ,Ir~" PI-A!NTIFF V, .1_o'~II~ N, WI~I.OH, ' PI=FJ:NPANT PI.AINTIFFIFAnII3R'S PR!:.TRIAI. MI3Mr:o.RANPUM IN TI'II: oourn OF COMMON PI.I::A$OF OUMI3I=HI-ANP OOUNTY, PI=NNSYI.VANIA PODI~i~T NO, on.01;?7 . OIVII. AOTION . I.AW . CU8TOIJY I, Pll&ltlPIl QIl O\.l&lp~ly, AI Fl\QhHlII3l\IlI\~ro\.lm~, I?ll1lntlff GlJrElld Weloll(llerelnafler "Fl:llller") I:lmll)efen~ant I.orla Weloll ' (Reql,leml) (IwrelnClfler "Mother") me tile pments of IIlree chl,ldren: .JeeslcEl, Clge 13, Mlclll:181. 11ge 9, <1nd Taylor, age 5, . The SlllJJecl of lills cLlelody Is limited solely 10 'JefjsloEl, The parties separEltod Elnd W\3re ellvorcedll1 199B"PBlnce \Ilat time ElIIIll[ee Olllldrell have resldecj wl1l1 Mother, ^ copy of tile Oustoely Dreier, elated Novemper 4, , , 199B, Is altachedllereto ElS I~xlllbll "A", On or abmlt November 14, 2001 father filed a pro se Petition for Modlfloatl'on of CustOdY, reqLlesllng that 118 PEl provided primary plwslcal i:lllstody of Jessica, A oustocly cOllolllatlon bCOLlrred whereby IIle parties agreed 1I1EIl El OLlstody evalyatlon WOLlld be performed by Relgler, Slllenvold and Associates, Tile COLlrt Issued an Orsler reqLllrlng tile pElrties to submit to tile ouslody evaluation, as well as e'xtend their fLIII cooperation In oompletlng tile evaluation, A copy of Il1ls Order Is altached as l:xl1l1JIt "8", Mother sullsequently l'efusBd to 'attend the counseling sessions, ahd therefore Il1e evalLlatlol1 was not oompleted, ,,', III, l:.h.t Qf WltnQIHH1!> AnQ Antll1lpAI!lQ 'fllfltllllQIlY, . .1, gQf.lllcl Weloil, Ffcll1lOr wllllosllly <IS 10 Ilia (IISOl.Isslol1s wllll ,Josslpn nile! l18r ponllmlaq ple<ls 10 oOlnc111ve wl\lll1lnl, 1~f;lIl10r wl.11 tesllfy /.16 to \Ile SIf;lIJllltyof Ills home Elllq 11113 sl.lpporl f;lncl CElre 11e provldos 10 ,jasslcQ, Fl'ltller wllllestlfy ElS 10 1118 living pondltlons of JesslPOl, fcllld \1113 conc1\.lcl of Mollwr, ~, ~, Mrs, Welollls the Cl.lrrElnt wife of Fl'1tller, (referred to iler\3ln l'1S Slep-Motiler) Step-mo\ller will tesllfY f;lS to Iler converS<ltlonll with Jesslol'1, Inollldlng .Jesslol'l'S ~Ieslre to liVe wlllllwr l'Ind Fl'1\1wr, f;lS well as J\3ssloa's stl'1lC:lmente regardlno t118 aPllse sile.llf;ls sl.lffereq from Moll16r anq , Step-l=l'Ilher, " " " 3, J~, Jessloa wllllelltlfy as to iler desire to live wllll fa\l.ler and Step-moll18r, Jessloa Wllllestlfy as 10 iler living condlllons, .Jesslca will also tElstlfy as to illS pllysloElI f;lnd mentElI aPuse slle 11flS suffered Elt the hflndll of Molller Elnd Step-Fall18r, 4, JSlm Welcll, 1<lm Weloills Ule sister of FEltiler, 1<lm will testifY to tile slptsl11ents mflde by JessloEl regarding the Inoldenlln whloh Mother flPused , Iler wllll a belt. 1<lm will fllso testify as to her (IrstIlflnd.lmowledge of tile verbElI abuse directed al Jellslca byStep-FEltl18'r, 1<ll1lwllllesllfy all to the living conditions, Inoll.ldlng 1118 sanltflllon, of Motl18r's home, 6, fuUigy I<eefe, HelQler Shelnvold and Assoolf;ltes, Ms, I<eefe will te~llfy to Moll18rs failure l;lnd refusal to cooperale in tl18 Oourt Ordered OLlslbdy , evalLlatlon, Ms, I<eefe Wllltestlfy e~, 10 the stfllemenls made Py Motl18r, 8118 will Ellso le611fy ElS to Father's cooperilllon In tile evalLlallon, as well as offloe " ,I' " h " q\\ " '0 \, /;XHlaIT A '\, " " " " Ii" " " ," " " " " 'I. " " I' " " ;' \.; " ,,<I '1~!~~~'.,..-,.ry,"'!'W"t'I1 T", .,'....... ~r-l .1"1" l. ' ~L..." '.E, R"'!-,'I'II T~" 7, Flllhul' Ilhll\1 hllVu rum (II) w~u~~ pru\\s\u\111I1 tl1110 wllhllw Ilhll\11'1l1\ ,. ' \\mI11lJ'tlw ~\l1l11l101' 1l101\Ihs, Tho Fllllwl' ~hllll nnl hllVO 1110l'U Ihlln tWO Woo"" pI' OOl\lIoolltl,v\J 111110 w\\\llhu uhlldrol1 \Imlnl! \hlll porlml 01"111110, Fl'lhllr IIhll\ll1olll'y Mp\llUr or 111\1 wuO~1I ho 111101\\\1110 u1\ol'olsu Ihollo porlOll1l hy April 1 III pI' 0110\1 )'ul\I', >>, Tho plok IIp IIlltl \Ir\lp niT llmll1U \lwIIO purlol\1I nl' pl\rlh\\ c\\IIIPlly II11l1 Vlllllllllpl1l'or Flllhor s\1iI1I1ll19.llr III \lw \1111\u\'l1111 gn1lltll11l11lw\,'1I roll\lllll1UU or 11\ IIw t ' ,,' ym\!ll.lun\ ohllll's l\nyolll'u provlllor, 9,ll1lhu'uvo\11 Ihlll Molhor'lI 0\\1'1'011\ I\vllllllll'l'lIl111U\llO'\11 8h\1\111I ohllllllu, VII\l\Ur rllllorVOII Iho right 10 mluo Ihlll 1I11111l1ulI\IO II1111111110\llpt 10 \11ollll'y Iho lurl1\lI IIntl o0l1d\l\\1I111 or Ihlll Ol'llo\" 10, fllloh olhor \lInollllS tho pllrllull\lll1Y lI11rOIl.' BY TIm, COURT, \1 " l L '-J./ ' .,., "-, ,Q..) ,. . .-J. _1-lL-I.H,~..\..-.-L-'1SA KEVIN A, llmm, ,I, ',. l' Thnl11i\8 ]), OO\lld, Hllqulro Oom\d H, l\ubll'.9011, ESljulro m\1l OJ" TRUE COpy FROM R~CORP In Tootlmony \"hl,r(of, I hero unto sot my hond ~nd tho sool of sold Court al carllslo/Po, 1111$ "",Y:,~/!n,:, day of,~\).....,',,,,, 19,..~"f ___JP.1I\~>>IIff""Q."";;!t"~IJIr~M"",,....ml4 . tDP,J.' rrothonol~1Y. , " ;.:.::fU4.. , Ii II , I ,"'1' III' L., ,I!' \, I "; 'J I, '.11' " . I3I;RAI.P F, Wj:~CH, ~R" Plqlntlff IN Tl-II~ OOURT OF (JoMMON PI,~AS OF' , o\.JMI3~R~ANP cOUNTY, P~NNSYI.vAN.IA NO, (la-pm OIVIl. AOTloN . lAW OUSTOPY " va, I.ORIt: Nt W~~OH, Pefeml!mt lie~~,J,,,.. .olIDgaQEJlQ.Lurr .. ANP NOW, \hl~ ...--1..2..~~ dl'lY of ~1>"~(.f-~'1 " 200~, uppn ' Qonslqf:lmtlon of the q\tQpllecl Ouslody Oonollll:1llon aWllilll1rr I~epprl, 1111> 11I3repy orelElrecll:1nd qlreoted q!! fpllow!!: " . 1, Pending furtl1er Orqer of Court or I'In qgrfl\3mant of the p~1[tleIl1l1Ia Oourt'~Order of NpV\3mper 4, 10136, I>l1nllr\3ml:1ln In fllIl foroe I'Ind affeot wltl1lhe following l:1ddlllons: , . A, Tile pEll11el) sl1all sllPmll themselves t.1nd their minor Plllld to Eln . Independent ouatocly evqlut:lllon to be performeq by Relgler, Shll:lnvolcl t:lnd Asspoll:1tes, Tile parties shElII slon ElII neoessmy releases flncl qutl1orl~t:ltlons for the evqlUt:llor 10 optElln mecllpl:11 t:lncl psyphologlot:ll Informt:ltlon pertt:llnlno to the pElrtles, Adclltlonfllly, t11El pqrtles shqll extl.'lnd thEllr full ooopemtlon In oompletlng Ihll> eVEllut:ltlon In q timely fflShlon t:lnd In tha sohedullnS'of flppolntments, The ooal of theeVfllunllon shElII pe I' shmed equ~ll1y Py the pt:lrtles with Fqlher paying half and Mother paying half,' " fl, Ahearlng Is soheduled p\3fore Judge Hess In Oourtroom Number 4 of the CUmperl~1Ild Oounty Oourthouse, on thf:l II G< dt:lyof ' _QIiA~J " -", 2002, aU ,'3() 0'01001< ../,h,M" at whloh time , tesnmony will pe tal<en, For the purposes of the heqrlng, the Father, Gerflld F, Weloh, Jr,,: shull be deemed to pe the moving party and shqll ' prooeecllnlllally with lenllmony, oounsel,for Ihe pqrtlas or Ihe parties pro Sa shqll file with Ihe OOlJ[t qnd oppolllng oounsellpElrty a memomndLIIll settlno forth eaoh pqrty's position on oustody, q proposed pflrentlngplan, q list of witnesses who are expeoted to tesllfyat Ihe hearing, Elnd a summary of the E1ntlolpated testimony of eaoh witness, These memorqnda shElII be flied at le<lst ten dElYs prior to the l1enrlng date, 13Y THI2 OOURT, 'J4-tr!tV'M'-' 0, /../t..JAJ I<evln A, Hess, J, I,' '(,'. , I ' 1'1 , ,', ,'.~ I" i lllll'~~~' ,~~...,,' '. ,'n.~ .J(j:^... .---.. Utti-c.li\.,:v~(~~~:~:: ",I '" ", " " " " .' " , , . " :,1"f:' \" , ,:;' l, ",\ ~ '\ ::) {(;J. 1\1' '".t,".- r "~I ~,~,I;~ ('I" \ .:' .' ,'I:\l<;~', ' . , ~~,llf' i " " '. . '1\ , .,\ " , ,i ,. " .' ,0 ,. ,{ '_,' 'I )I'I-,'IL " ,/ ",, " " "" !.t I' ,0' ." I' , " " ,0 (, IIlWlIlll 6< API,illl, I',q, ATToilNllYB AT i,AW ~3a 1 MA!\KI:T BTIlHi!T CAMP IIII,~, I'A 1'10\ 1'4M~ \,/171'/03,13113 AllG .(lli2nO? ~" Ii " , "I" ,,; " . "J"-b ' r ft ,\ ,,", I ,~ ,,;!h " i~ ,ft ',liFtl':., " ~! -lnv :. ,~ ~ I' ",j -:',.I::;.r,.'.t"l,j .i i'r,f:"f<, ,,~' V,l,';_. '\ r :,{:Ilt'" ,; ,. I, 11~~' ,';,1,-\ ,'d t\:1;, q . ~/ ~ }" I,'H,~: ,~ I 'IV'j't ,J' ,_If.,'! .' I )',' ".,,(;,\/ .' f J' ~t' "lf~\W~11 -( j 'l{' ,\.' \ i " ",;' ;1' " , , " " '.1. , 1/\ 'Ii " , " . " \ii! " 'J:; " 1-t\ " " '1 , ':"".'L, ,:~\~f .;, " " " ~. , " ,,'~ 01,. ,"~ '{'~, -- """1' ~}, , '/~' f,~ t :~i}ll,r'. 'i \1!~ -' '~V: I}. . "'1 .' \ " " 'I, " " " " " " ,I" " Ii " 'I' , , iI' " " " , , , " .'1 " " \, " ()f' filTi() III (, " i iI'l Ii'.' 'lli.I'i'( " \ ')1 r;l, 1-, ' I; ,CUMUI. ii, :,) i,<'Ui~IY l'I::NI,jl,\'{I,W'I"I/\ ()i,~ ^IIG;" [I " " ,. JI " qr " Ie I'"~. 'j. I" ,~ U \ \- 'i:~ 'I, ~. eX (,1 ~1 {" i~ ., ." h II ;r' \1 qrt-"'\i"~. " I1Pllr Ilnllnrll\1l\1 JIIIlgp II\l~~i 111 rpply 1111hp PlJlllllll1lq Wllhdrnw II~ CUllI1Hpl nlr Plnllllllfl1llJII wllh Ihp IIIllIII 0.11 Jllly 12, 2002111\\1 yo\ll' Ilul1nr'~ ~lIhHO'IIIOIIIIHHIlIIlICP of' 1~lIlp Ill. Show PIIlIHY, ll,urlo AIIII 1~1'(1~1\l1111 (Wpl\lhl rCHppoll\llly HIIIIIllII thlllhllnwlng, " "" Illlnvllln HIII'I""'llIf ihlll'Nlltnnl1l'H I'IIII"11HI nIl' porl111HHlun Iu wllhdrnw lIH (1u\l1\Hol 1'01' e11l111110; IIIHllIHk YIlll'ro Honur IIn,1 !hp Cumlln Qt'''''1 ~nlll pollll\ll1, . I 110 H\l wilh HOIllP rolllulllllCll, 1I0woVllr I Hilly II11110rslllmllhulhlHlrlllluIIR or Ihl' uppn8ln~ \l01l1l~0111l hlHomlrt~ III Pllll1lllllllllltHll wllh Iho pllllnlll1'.l hllw booll tJylna 10 oon1l11l1l111l1l10 wllh him fill' yOllrN wll.hnlll rOHlIIIH, Thll pllllnllfl'll1 Ihls n1l11lor hils 1180111l\1l "phlldrlln orlhls IInl11ll1ll11 nllllThlBIl 118 II pllwnslnOll ho Wlllkllct 0111 011 Ihlllll 11l1\1 nw, IIuhllN ropolllollly IIml \1ll1ll1l1lly IBI10red Orders oflhll Cmll'IIHHlIell In Cllmbllrlllml Cl1lll1ly, I'll, Ilne1 OhU(lH08 10 do IIH ho pllll\sos 11I111 whon hp plollsOSIO liolt,TlwlIo ol'llol's Inollldllll Child SIIPPllr\ IIlld I'll1lpollol1 lrolll Ahll~1l holh vlollltlld 11l1111\lm\l~ tlmoH wllhOll1 proiloollllon or rolrlbltlloll f1'om Ihll 00\1I'l. Tho support vlnllllloll8 o0l11hlllllllH uflhls wrlllll~, 1 hllVIl SpOlll thullsllmtH Ilf' c1nlIIlI'H In 10BIII foos, whon 1 llJtlllnllll Ilolinspllo c1llfllnd IIBllln~1 IlllHllhsllll1111110d IlhnrBos of'ohl.l.llllbUHO'lltlOIllPIH III Ilhlhl9\IHlmly IIl1d POlllllHtlo '.tollllhlllH ProollcIIlnB8 wl10l1PVIll' hlllilUIH II 'H IImlllllll101ut 1ll1ll'0 olllollnnlllllhllHO IIpOlllllO, 1 hllYO 1101111 wllh lhlH hlHlory Ofll1110tlolllll, PhYHlo1l1 111111 Il11ll1tlllllbllHIl fnl' YIlIlI'H 1I111t IlIIOIlBh IH IlnOllBh, I hllVo dcoldolllol'lllllrollllhoRo WIlHlol1 f1IHllIlllllII'OHOl!rIlOR 10llmoru IIRol\l1 Jllll'jWHO,lIl11tlhllllR 10 Hl1pporllll1d b0l1011lmy ohll\ll'on IInll my lilm II y, 111m OIlI'1'Ontly II Pro So 1.ltIBIIl1t In IhlH mllllol' bllfqrll tho cl1l11'lllml wltlshow liS bOHt IIH I CIIII do RO, nlld by" ., ,II propOlldlll'lll10C IlfovllllllloothllllhlllllllllOI' bollll'o Iho OOllrlH Is II bllBIIH mllllot', void of , III1Y 1'110\111I1 Ilvldoncll or HllppOl1hlB orllurllllllld !hllt Ihll plllll1lllTwll1 1111111 IIkollhood f1l11 \ollppOIlI' nlld proHllclltllllsll 1'1'0 SIl I'''III1IIlTwllhPIII bOllol11 OfOOlll1Hol. I will ho Ihol'lllbr Ihll AIIBUHI 08, 2002 proccodlnB 1IIIIIlHS (1onlillllllrlIlBIIIII; 1 hl\Vo III bo III\UI' 1111 I IIllllho plll'Onl with phYH11l1\1 clIstndy"lIl1d Iho ol1ly pllronllhoHo ohlldron hllV\l knowl1ln tho .. ponloxl I1l'w.hnl ,OoflKtltlltoR II plll'Ont, 1t0Hplloll\llIy Submltled Iii , lMi,~ ~nn el Q-lLQJLrJ.- Lorio Anl1 Roqllonll II ,: ) ( .....1- _fc ,'I, ,~L~._, (J 11~(A< t ,/ ((,i I 1/ il 'If //'('1.p NO/MlnlSool . 1(lIlhrYI1I" a Inon Nalnry J>Ubllo MunOll'nrmohoro '11\11,,/'\1101/0"01111 Vounl" y 0111111111001011 "Hpfion NUY, 171 ~OO:1 oll1,Or, 1'0nnnylViIT'MosCXllnllon or NolArlon -\--!-,.t.!' '~.!. ,... ~'-V'f'. I .l i..~ , .. . ...., "q..'Y'. I "I " ,(> {, (I 1.(' , , " .11 " " " . '; ", ,J " " " " il< .. /, '.,., " +, " " I.lf ill I,' J , f,., ,I, I, I, ",'Ii,'/' " " "u " " " " " I" " I' Ii ..' , " 1. 2 3 1\ G 6 '1 8 9 " 10 11 12 13 .11\ " 1G 16 1'1 18 19 20 21 :t2 23 24 215 .lW\1l1l'UIlPOIl, 1:IHl f'o:!,lo\,!lno cUarJ\lpplon wi\:1l ,'Jopuj,,\1<\ \~(Jl(Jl\ pOn\1 rt'ocl ,111 ol1'\lIlbfJ 1:'1.11 ) ,3Y 'l'lIIil QPU[l'l' 1 Q 80 YOII'rd the porpon l've boon haurtng about all (1<w long? ^ YBtl, Q Good \:0 f'j,:nCllly Ineet: YOll, A Nlce to Ineet: YOII too, Q YOII i'lro \101'1 old now'~ " ;, 1\ 'l'hJ.rteon, Q 'r\1l1:toel1 , And you I 1'0 aUl'l:ently In MJ.ddl'e ~a\1001, I gClt\1er, rlght? 1\ Yea, Q And golryg lnto what wlll .be the 8t:h grude? A Yefl. (I; Q find I underst:and'You'vo ~ono fal~ly well J.n 130hool, have you? A Yes, Q What sort bE grsdel3 have you been getting? , 1\ l'Iell, for our final gradell I got all 1\ III un,d one B for like jUatthe fJ.nalll where they just add up all '., your grades, tn one subject, bllt: when I went il1\;0 -- in61:h , grade I g6t like jupt a couple C's in like harder subjecta because I just: wasn't 1I1led to everything yet and it Wall jllllt like a cOllple Ilt:epshigher, instead of one, but then, " " , 1 2 3 4 B 6 'I 0 D '10 11 12 J.3 14 " 15 16 1'1 10 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 yall Imow, I thinl~ T J:j,n.i.~h0d o\\l: w.i.\:hol\\; LIllY C'a elF.! my "j Oned gri\rle, ^ In fifth grade we had jl\F.!t No, introduction, and I took Spanish beoause that's I think itls/ next to I~ng,:iish/ the moat popular language, 80 when people walk by speaking a d~fiferent language, I could kind of understand what they were saying maybe if I got good at Spanish, Q Sure, Well, that's probably a good I Sure, 3 1. (l 3 'I [j 6 '7 8 9 1.0 U 1.2 13 I' lJ\ 1.13 1.6 1.'1 1.8 1.9 20 21 22 23 24 213 " Pl:i'\o\:.jonl 1]0001\(\ ,1,<\I10\IIIUO to \mvo, PH1:tic!ulr:p:ly pinco 11 lot: of ppoplo .1,11 1'1I11\luylvilldi\ iJp(Ji\I~ ~jpi.\ll.jIJ\1, ImUeVl1 i.t 01: no\:, 1\ YOi1h, Q Tlnd:r lIOn thA\: YDI111.'U in fI nll\1\\)IJl.' of ~ifforont Actlvit.joPI pp61.'tB flotiv.jtioA? 1\ ~oaaOl:, Q Soccor 1 YOIl, I\n(1 ,,1130 in l:ho f)lll1tW 1\ 0\1 1 YOf.l, Q 1\n(1 wllllt inatr\\mont do YOll plAY? 1'1 Woll, tllio YOAr 1'111 stm:dng J:lllto t ljl'll3t 'YOl\l', Hl~e the [Jocon~ nmrldng pedo~ 1. think. it WI'IO, I , ~tartec1 plflying t\1e bl'loo clArinet, an~ in 4th ~ra~o an~ 13th grl'\c1oI played the french horn, Q "130 this 1,s a marahingpan~ ope 171'\ \: ion 1 I aSl3uml3'i 1\ No, It's just liko a ooncel't band, Q ah, a concert' band'? 1\ Yea, . Q sci' YOll'I:0 not going out to football gG1l1\\3e alld \:hat kind of f.ItuEf: yot? " I: 1\ No, \d Q Mnybo flame day? 1\ Yeah, Q 1. had throe dallghtel:n, 1\11 of thOll1plElyec\ in the bt\nd, ul1d as f1 matter t1f faot my Wife' F.i lidehse , ... 4 r I' 1. ;.l " 3 1\ 5 6 '7 0 9 ),0 U 1.2 13' 11\ 1.5 1.6 ~.7 " 10 19 " 20 21 22 23 21\ 25 pl.!1\:p on her oC\r p<lyrl Bflml Mom, So Wll qre a \1cllld fc\lllny; " ^ ThC\tip VDry Qrrropriato, Q . Well, \:\)ore 1 /3 Iddp cllld tI lot: of t:h:Lnm1 going on In YPI.\r l1ol\l1(3, f.\nd oopaalbna11y ,JllC\n'~1 boyp oomo ove1:, 130 .:I.l: 'p interepUng to me thC\t YOII 111[II'!age to l~aep y0\11: grC\des so high when tharels ao mlloh going on in your life, Do yOll hewe qqfJPUOns C\)Joq\: YOllr h9meWorlt do yoU ever helVe C\IW qqepU,pnp apout YQur homeworl,'or til1\ep where YOll,. need help on yom: 110mework.? AUpUCll1y I do 1110pt of my 119meWOl:I~ in sohool pol only hElve Hlte 'one 01: two bool~p to bdng home, put I do ptydy for my hirdor tostp, C\nd J uPllally don't ask tI\Wpocjy, Ox.cept l~tely - - 111~e the lC\l3t mal:)dng periOd I had my granclmother help me ptllcly for my verteprae test, and 'l't\mI11Y helped me ptudy with one of my other tests, I ctln' t remember, C\nd usually I don't i:\sk. my mom, I lll3ually C\sk my dad beoC\ul3e over the , Wee)~endpl you )qloW, I remlly don't cIa too much stuff Sl\llday nIght land usually, you )mow, nobody really paYI3 attention Sunday night to me C\nyhow, So I I'/ollld ask my dad to help me on a projeot that I hC\d to do for 130hool, I think it " was in 6th grade beca\H:le he'l3 l:eally good C\t math, Well, that's ,what my aunt telll3 me aJ1d my graI1dmother;' Q And your grandmother lives around the borner from you or nearby? 5 " l' ~ 3P il 5 6 " '7 " 0 'i 9 10 11 1!J 13 1.4 15 16 17 10 19 20 21 22" 23 24 213 ^ No, no, MY c\ndlIJ 1I\0\:ho):, 9 0\1" pI.1<1 I 'I 11\0\: I \Ol."? !\ '1'oP. o '1'0\1 riD hLlVll 1\ tp'nnd1l\0\:hol:wlll) Uvop in yo\\r immed1El\:s 'l)ro<\'1 I' A Yep. ,. t. o And do I unc\erptElnd thnt thElt1p the person that pome\:l.\11ef.! you go to her hOl\s8 1\1 \:\1e f.!1\1l11l101~dll1s? A I've only been there onos or twioe oyer the f.!llll1ll1el~ , o Oh, O)C€\y,1 A Bllt. that' P wherB allr clad piolw up €\nd dropp us off Elt., Q And wh€\t about. TElylor ancl Miahael? What. dO they clo wIlen YOII' re OVBr 'at yollr granclmotherp? Are they" wit.h you or A Well, 11'Clylor goes t.o clElY oal:e, Q He'/l tIle youngest, t.h~ 5 YOcu' old? A Yep, YBS. My \TIom said t.o me onoe/ if 'all of thi/l ht'ldn1t happenscl, if I woulcln1t havs s,~icl . I WEll)t to go wit.h my dacl and /ltuff / t.hat I could, have' wat.checl Taylol; this allll1mer and I would have go\:.t.en pElid ,for, it., and I mean she doaf.! thL'lt a lot.. She says if" this c'lidn It, )lappen, YOII " , khow, you would have gotten this, l'meL'ln witH grades sha said I coulcl have G " ',I. 2 ~ ~ ,. 5 6 'I 0 9 10 n 12 1.3 1<1 15 16. 17 10 " 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 gpl:\:an $liO,OO /\n (I iC 1 1);,\clnl\: pttll:\:(J(:1 fill of: 1:lltfJ t 1.'0\\1)1 0 , (Inri f1~) iJ\WWI.lY, lw'p fit c\nyoql"O, <\11c1lil~6 i\:'13 d,gl1t ACl1:01H'1 1'1.'011I my f1o\1oo:\, whiqh ,11m It \:00 I'ell: flWfly, And M:\.ohnol wlnt\lly rll.a6pn ill: 0\\1: 1,01l1Hl, nnd whal1 110 w/llwp lIP in tho morn:\.ng 1113 gooP OVEn: to my grnndmo\:hel: 1 f1 hO\lEle, lIa \\flIlAlly qOCll3n 1.1: r,,:ny 1,1011\e, Half] \II3IHllly Clt I:he \101H1Cl ml\ylJa ClII. \101.\1:, \:Wo ho\\ru l:oPI3, Q all, ovan In, tho 13\\mmar\:illlo whan ha' p not: III: l3ahoo17 1\ 'Yep" Q' Oh, I l3ae, (I I mel\n the only timea \1a'o ovel: \:hel:e ip , when my oOllpinl3 ab~ down, E111q we 111311E111y get ,together. , , aoniedmCla E1nd play gi,\mel3 Clnq they, gel: on I:he oOIllPlltel: CI lot, I' Q So Clpparently YOIIl" mother hElo q],aalll'll3ed thia ouotody IIIIII:tel" wi,th you then'l w],th thj,o OOlll"t pl"ooE!oding? I mean what's going on now 1\ Yeah, Not too m\loh, She' 13 mOl"e 'Ie 11. j, ng lit me COl: it, Q I aee, Meaning, for example, lilte 'lOll aay " " .thElt auah and auah would hElPpen i.f you hadn't stEll'ted E111 of thia, ia thllt aOl"t of like it ia? A Yeah, ". Q HaS she talked to you about what ybur 7 :'1 H 1 OOn\:AO\: WOllld 1)0 w:ll:h !lor :\.t: YOIl wonl: \:0 Hvs wlllh YOllr 2 r'lI:11PI:'1 3 ,A Bho told l1\rJ <II: lni\l,t l:WIoo'l:h<lI::Lf I Wl'Jnl~ 1:0 11 live with my dt1d/ fllw rlIdn't 'wunt \:0 son mo eyer <I\]<I In , 6 q A HoW do YOII rool a~9ut thnt? Well / t\10 riqlt Ume 13ho fud.d It it I1wlo me " 6 7 cry beoA~ae ahe dIdn't foully oC\~o/ ~nd aha dIdn't like mo/ 8 thAt/a hoWl felt, And thon,.tho pooond tImo I juat -- r 9 l;1Ir:ln' t I:OAat to II: bem'lllaell\Y dud r.1nd 'l'i\mmy i3i\id not to'lot 10 Glnything ,aha /.luya pother YOII / l.il~o t'ry not to let het' puph 11 my PI\ttOl1P anel, ,at1lff 1l.1~o Ehat, booause they jll!it PClirj EhClt 12 ahe Was tl:ying to 111<lI~o. me Wtlnt ,to Ejtay wlth her, And they 13 ",aiel' it waa my deoiaion whether r wanted to or, not /, but 1.4 thClt 'a whClt, YOII )mow / they thollght she WAI3 trying \:.0 do, " 15 Q Well, loan tell from aome of the anSwerl3 to 16 my qllestioll/3 alreAdy that you have pretty muoh forll\ed an 17 opinion abollt who you would 1l.ke to 1l.ye wi th most of the 18 time? 19 TI Yeah. 20 Q TIm I dght? "You know, it.',s so. fllnny, I ", 21 have many of these custody QClFles, /3omedmes one side Wi 11 22 tell me they Want to.1l.ye with me/ and tUe other side S,ays. 23 they Wi\nt to Bve with mo, and r get the ohild or the young, 24" person In lny of Hoe, and half the thle they stlY I juat wiah '25 theywoulq atop fighting, but other times in these ltinda of o \' 1 2 3 II , 6 6 ? 8 9 10 .ll 12 13 I' 14 15 16 17 ' " 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 26 a,Wetl aOII\\3porly hna 111r.IClo liP l:ho,h: mind, " r l~now .i.\:lp A YOl:Y brond q\lep\:Jol\/ bnl: 1 think i~'B tGo dnly way I aun APk yon th~p,Al\d yon sudm intelUgenl: enongh to i'lIWWGI: :1\:, Ci'ln yon doaortpowhat i\:. j,13 thCll: hi'l~l bronoht YOII 1:0 where yoq m:e I:oday / 1 me<\n wHh yonr mom, ClnQ (1008 H hi'lve unyth.i.ng to do wi th "TnAn? Whnt'p peen ooing on thClt1p ai'll\plng thip? TI Wen, pome of j.t 1.p l:hCll: '-- you 'mow, I WOllld be <11)10 to go home J:l.'01l1 l'lahool Clnrl be f;lverything in i'\ house where everypody llkes mo, and it ~eels like l'lomoqmel'l ],f' 1" cjon' t do something. doht my mom yell(3 f.\t me peCallpe 11m not Perfect beoaU/3e I Oi\n't do ltright. Tlnd JUAn reCllly rloesnl~ llke,me At all, und he l'laClre/3 me a, lot of the time when r' m Al'O\md hlm. I I mean.l.i.I~e when I'm ait:t:Lng there, <\nd I oCln hear him 'j . ' talldno, he jl\l3t always seems filo angty, nnd IIslIallylike lately he was marl at me, and my m0111 told him thilt I wasn't , WOl:th gettino a divorae over, and that it wasn't worth like pr~aking up thelr marrlage, , Q Tlnd.is it:"true that he has f\ct\.la11y.gottsn IIp Clnd left the room when you oame :In Clnd vloeversa? TI Yes, Idke most: of the t ime l:h~t: happens, scimet.i.mes he doesn't, .' If he 1.8 1 ike doing somethlng in the kitohen and I Walk In to get a, drink, you know, sometimes ho'l1 l.i.ke just ai\:. there and finish what he' a 9 " , 1 fl 3 ~ 6 6 ,7 fl r'i 9 10 11 Ifl 13 14 16 16 17 18 19 ' 20 21 '22 , 23 24 25 IIPpol: I bllt 1 !cnow If; -" If: T pH (lown <Inri \:ell thel11 why 1'11I nol: l.j,ying w:l.\:h tllUl11 illWlllorB .. ".,1 I\\(Um 'l'f.lylol.' won't: \.\1 HlonJ\:mlc\ , llc]' 11' JIll'll: lj!~lJnoti('Jo 1: '1\\ gono! )JI\\: ,,- l. l1\e<\n h<lH tho, til\lCl h(~ l!,I~I.I'l \:pj)ol:hOl: 11\(' IIllYW'W, 118'11 probf\)Jly jl\llt: move on t:o Miol1i\ol or (1011\8\1orly (llpe to, bo\:IlBl.', IJllt Mioh<\l'll j,p pl:oIJ<lbly goin9 \:,0 be I~im\ of \.Ipoet l)eO<lI\,le/ yoq l~now, r )mqw how"" 'tlinoe tllio hAP }mEln going on he' 0 peen feeUng HI~e' left ollt: f\nrf fJtllff. I <\nd h8'13 been :I,j.)~e l1e'l1 oAY one thIng to my mom And t:l1en Olle thing to my 'Clar~ jllS\:' to get like aome <lttention, Tlndhe hf\p like ADD, So thi\t Idnd of -" I' t:hj,nl~ that might h<lve' ldnd of rIm In w.i.th l.t / bl\t I know at fira~ they'll be IIpl3et/ bllt I haye i\ feeHng onoe they Und ollt why f\nd eyel'ythlng" they'll IInderotand, " Q Tlnd wl1at m:e YOl\l: thoughts about flndlng yourself in a different aoho~l"this ~ear? TI Well / you know, as long afJ I am' happy ,<\1: home, I don't oare, 'rllt;1Y're I mean/ loan make friends, ,. ,I not like ,,- I'm not really hQt:eful to other peoPle, So r thinl~ I aan get fdenclEl ref\lly easy, but -" and my old fdends, they' 1:e not going to, Bite dj,toh me or anyth.i..ng beoauf.le we"'tallcatl <\bout ), t, me and my friends, :rf I" moved toa dH ferent ,sohool find to a dH ferent.area I thut they'll still Bke invito my d(jW~1 to their parties, beoclllse We haVe pell'des for Bke no reason like at least once or t:wiae a 'i, " 12 1 i' ., ;1 :\ ~ 6 6 7' 8 " 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 1'7 '10 1~ 20 21 22 23 24 26 " 1.'Oi.l~:ly l)ml, Clwl 'l1\opl: o/f I:!lu l:il1\p u!lo of111p 11\0 C\l'1 :Ir1:\.ol: imd f\ dOl:lt ilnq n b:\,I:ol1 Ilnd f1\:qf:{: - - jnul: ptn:l;J: lil\~\ I:hi;\\:., jt Q :[ Iwl <I 1 :\.(11: - - :1 quI:, n hnnc\f:ql 91: worda Wd\:I:l'In dOW\1 \jhi;\t l:hl'l popplo ant thOl'ewnnl:oc.l 1I\CJ I:l? i.1fJ)~ YOI-I , bbcII\:., and r dan'\: l'Ivun undorp\:and thin 0\10, ptm:\: pJ,altino, OUl: pnJ.nl:.' rOl: rool11'~ 130yp fJIlonlcl TI 'Yeah, I:hl'l f .il:p\: 1:.111\1':) my 1I\om One time \:olcl mo thf\t H I moved clown \:.0 my clnel'l'I, 1:11/:\1: phB noyer Wf\n\:oct,l:o pee I11B i\9/:\:\.n/ phe /:\lso thnt /Jame tJ.me Cll'lltod 11111'1\:j,n, WhOWAf.l J.n the cqJ: with l\f.l, Whi\\: aolor hB Wf\n\:ecl hil3 new rOol11 to bB, Q 'TInct JlIl3tin j,f! who? ^ One of JllAn'fJ boys, " Q Oh I I /Jee, ok/:\y, And thB other ahil'dl-en i\1'the hOl11o then alflo, do they bother YOII, h/:\J:~I3f! YOIl? ('j. TI Yeah, Q Ancl 'whAt about t:!liF.l, better hope that Jeny wins or they1ll ma)te sllmmer i\ living hell., I guef!S \:hat w/:\s some \:.lme ago/ dght? ,[I Yeah, It Wf\S when Bohool WaS Btll1 in " before they met In Tlumlst, I guess l.l.th it was/ when they 'Were first suppoaed, to get' thia ,worked out - - a aontlnllanae or whatever ~a8 filed, Q Um"hum, TI He aald when we were gettln~ ready to go to 14 " 1" sohool \:h<1t 1 l]pl:l:fJ\: 110pP "nrl pnlY \:1\1\\:., ho"~, 1:11n\: I1\Y r\ II r.1 2 go\:tJ rJllP\:ody of' I1\P 1]!wi\\\fW 110 '11 op.tno \:0 II\nl~(~ I\IY UI\I1\11Wll: II :j' Hying hsll ( I\nrl t11i1t 110 W0I11r\ IJ(I on II\IJ 1,i.lw C\ :j\\nl~yC\):rl dog ., 4 on 'Jllnl~ or pOll\p\:hino 1:1),0 \:h<'1\:, 6 Q Ilow r\o YO\\ gel'. A,lona with 'l'<'1l\1my'~ (, '^ gllil1ly nIae, !-d.lr.e pho I p - -I~ho lIelpl3 I\IP C\ ,. 7 lot, i\nct f1he'p klnd of' llko C\ siats1:, liko ft blg pis\:.e1:/ !l <Inti she'13 jl\l3\: reQlly niau, C\nd fJhe,no\:a li\~o A mom phoqld, 9 !low I thinl~ C\ \110m should, bll\:. YOl\ 'mow, I'm not l3C\yi,ng -- 1.0 Q 'ren me C\ li\:tle bil: i\bOllt tl1<1t/ how i'\ ,1110111 1.1 fJho\\ld I 111eC\n I think I Imow .whC\t YOl1mean / put I WOl\ld 12 lil~e to hear YOIl' SAY H, 1.3 11 I .. I l:hinlt lil~e A mOm ShOUld lJe 'fJomepody who'l3 " 14 nioe C\nd aupportiVe C\ll of the t~l1e,and TC\Wl\Y'p like that, " Iii YOII lmow, HI tell hsr something, fJhe doesn't l3i\Y/ oh, 16 that' P /.ltllpid or J3tl\t:f lilte my mom doeJ3 beOallJ3e lil~e I Wl'\S 17, loold,ng in A mi'lgnldne and found" thi/3 really aool thing that " 10 YOII would ,wem:/ like you dllt YOllr jeans and ta\to the po~tom 19 part ,that flarea out kind oft If YOU've seen the j~anfJ that 20 kind of flare, and you would take'lhem About YOllr knees and 21 ,wear them with shorts and stuff, and I SaW that/ and I " 22 mooked that, and lIlY m01l\' told me that wC\s stupj,dl, that I 23 ahouldn't we at- H/ and the one tim~, we wel:e',getting re"tiy 24 to go to the mall ahe wouldn I t let me wear 1,t to the mall.. 25 becallae she didn't want to be seen with me looking lilte "" 16 " "If " 'I. ,. . 1 Il 3 ~ 6 6 'I 8 9 10 11 III " 1} III 16 16 17 10 1~ 20 21 :l2 23 I 24 26 " " f1J1\lPl,ot)1ingplilw \:)1f\\: \:0 Il\Ed~e \\flli\l\gl1, <111(1 \:llCJy':!l, II\I\k.o . flln of p:l.ctlll~efJ f\nd fJI:llf:f: UI~o \:1\<.11: :Iqpt to malw lIB 11\\1011 <.1nq hi\vfo1, 1:\111 1~,I~e \lhal"., o And wl1<\\:'p t)1e potqp thpre in tel:II\D oe who p1eep13 whore I\l1qso earth? Do YO\l h?\Vo yoqr own 1:0011\ nl: }'Ollr d?\d' p home? " .1 11 No" Me l1\1c\ my bro\:.hel~a sh<lre a room, b\\t we qonl\: f\11 aleep In ths1:Q, ~ lI\el\n fJome\:J mop 'l'aylol: anq me and Miah~e1 will sleep in \:l1eJr r60m boaauae they )1Ave lik.~pa\:ellite and we'll watch 'I movle I\nd wo'll fi\ll 1\131eep/ and uSllally lik.e ollr beqs i.1ren't Vel:Y oomfortable,. I mean theY'ro ok.ay/ bll~ they're not the befJt thinga \:0 hi.1ve, So we, \l13\\i.111y pleep out on the pull-ot\t peq and w<'\tch 'l'V; Anct we QOn't hayo l.i.l~o a 'rv in our room so we jllst l3it out there 'Incl w~tch TV nnd fAll f\aleepl Q lInd hAS tl1ere been any diacussionl3 if yqllgD \:0 live wJ.th your dad during the I3chool yenr whol-e youlll: , aleep'? 11 Yeah, Q ,lInd whClt yol\r room is goihg to be? A WhAt We're goi.ng to do -- well;e"not golng to 1:eally do anything nbout where Mll;lhael and TClylor aleep sinoe they're llke on the floor --I mean aOll\oUmes We just O<'\I11P out on the floor to watch 'l'V or the snt.ellitsl' but usually theY'll aleep on the couch or In the pull-out, and 1'1 , \ It " 1 Q I II\rliln J hilVD to, l\ YrHlh, Q llOOi\\WP I1chool rog.ip\:rntJon :l.1I - - ohl my gooqneolJ/ monl lOw <I Woul~ f\ncl " h11l( tOPll uo',' l\ I :lllElt 1.'13,111 Y cton't W1111 t \:0 go 1)f\[)I~ hOl11El " ;J :3 "I 5 6 wlth hal:, 7 Q Wall / YOl\ know, todny 111\1 not ollro thf\t thf\l: o oan bo i1vo.i.deq, I ann I t wrap thingll lIP t:hi1t f<lfJt,' bllt 9 , Whf\t you '.t:o snyinIJ hero is going to u\',l'\y here / YP\I Ilnow 10 whf\t I mean? If you l\\1Clerl3tf\nd Whf\t 1'1\\ f1<1ylng', 130 11 there I P no need for the whole world 1:0 know, YOl\'rl3 not 12 with YOllr dad for tho all~nor now? 13 11 ':Jllst this weelwnd, Hl~ Q Ollay, lInd you were wit:h your dr~d bElfol.'l'l' 16 \:.his hei~r:l.n\J though, dght.~ 16 11 Yeah, Just when he ploked l\0 up WeClnl;l!3c\ay I' 17 I stayed, 18 Q, lInd whon 'you say want lw go home, YOU're 19 tal~ing About this afternoon? lire YOII talking about in 20 the longer term? 21 11 I j list don I t want to go buak to my mom's 22 houso, It IS going to be like really bad, 23 Q Well, not if we don't uay anything, i 24 think - - I thlnk everybody in tho world knowa whElt your 25 position ls, Thiu Juan aan bo a pl:etty tough gllY, Dan't 21 ~ , 1 ;l 3 <1 6 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 ' 15 " 16 1'1 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 he'? A (No yorba1 l:OppOnpe,) Q OI~lIY, Wall, Whi.ltoyor'I do, I'll c\o <113 Cj\l:!qllly iW I CElI1, OI,f.lY? 11 wH:h my mO\1\, OI~f\Y, ,J\\fJt pleAi3e don' t mf\l~e me go paol~ il; Q Wo11, f\P I Si\Y, todllY I'm npt S\ll:O thore'p tmy WilY t:hf\t Dan PO avoided, Pill: -. because I llilve to give the pl\r\:iel3 the oPPOl:tllnHy to i3u\)mi\: pome thJ.ngp to In13, Ancl you ImQw, thepe doa:!,sionf3, theY'l:e i\lmos\: nover, made l':Ightfrom the benoh in the clay 0/; the heAdng, A WOllld It be pOl3pible thon -~ Q I WOllld be very al:itidi~ed for not thlnk:ing abollt whAt I've jIlPt,~eard, 11 Wqulcl it be possible H I oould l3\:ay with my ." c1i1~ \ll1tH YOl1 mf\lte YQIU' permanent c1ea.ision, because I 1m j upt reAlly saared to go home" and I Imow ap aoop as I step in the door she's going to yell and paream 'at "me I and I t-eapv don't want to go\;hrough thilt, I mean I've alreildy been through it for B long tlme, " I just -. Q Oltay. I think I aAn arrang!3 tllilt, YOll \1 " were brought to t:he cou):thouse today with yom: father? 11 Yes, Q Okay, Okay, ^ 80 I'll be able to go home wHh him untH 22 " .. '; ,,. millIDl"I Cf\'I'I oN :r he!:el)y 06r\:ify thAt t\18 lwoOt~adJngfJ 'Ire " oontAtnec\ full~ f\n~ aCOllri\tel~ in the nptep (:f\ken by ma pn " the A~ove aallse/ and t\1at \:.\1ifJ is a correct \:.J:an80rJ.pt 6~ , " I3Ame, ': /Yhid, .if ,.tiZ()/ Michele 1\, blUne , offioial COllrt Reporter " \.. (I , " .. " I,. 11 " h .. 'j " ~ ~ M ~<M - ,7 - M - - - ~ - - - - -,~ ~ - - - - - - - - - " " Ii I 'l'he fore(JoJng record ,of the prooeedtng/il 011 , I; the hea+il~9 of the wJ.thin matter is hsreby approVeq Elnq direot~ct to be filed. , f!, Pate . 1<€lVill, 1\. Hesa I .T, Nilith JlIdlaialDistd.cit " 24 ;/' f' " " IIml whloh Hlw Willi lillb,I\lPlod \0 nl tlw hnn(\H or 1101' nWlhol' \.01'10 A, g\l\IH\lnn I\ml SlopHlllwl' ,11\1\11 F, gO\1I101H\ ,II't. , , I will !lliHol'Uhnl whnl WIIIl nllnwo,\ to I I'lIl1Hp I 1'0 !lnd Hl1lhl(lln Yom HOnl1l'H' C!olll'll'on\11 PIl 'l'hHi'lldn~ AHI:IIIHI H. 2002 wnH n dll'ool I'\lHIlII 01' \11)' ,lolllHlon lp ,Ioronel M)'Hclf'nml M)' I-IIIHbn",\, ,IllIIn F, gOlll1\ll1!1 .11', ng!lll1HI tl1Ulio vOl')' li01'1Pl11i !lllo/!nllnl1H !Iii II Pm-So LIIIg!ll1l, 1 will nd1111t th!ll 1 Willi 1111110 1l\lI'VOHH nl1el I1Yel'wh~11110d loflin)' tho 10nHt nl \vhnt wOllle! tnko pllloo nnd/nl' bo IJXPI:Olod nf 11113 In , , Ihlli Pl'l1oooe!lng, I wnH howovol" pI'OPIII'O(\ to (oil thelnl!h IIml tell thlli 00111'1 whlll " I ,. " II'HI)' hnppol1od 011 OQ!ob91' H, 2nD Innd Iho, HllblioqHont downhill aplrnl of I'olntlonll \lolwoOIl Iho IlHb,loot ohlld .JoIlHlon. hol' StopHlqlOl' !lne!!, Conll'll!'>'!O 1'0mlll'kH mndo b>, Cnllnllol fhl' Iho Plnllltlfl~ "th!lllt WIIIl nllnbolll mo, !lnd 111111 ovol'>,lhlng oontol'od !l1'ol1l1d mo", YOIll' HOllOI', II hnll npVOl' bpon 1,lboll! 111\), ;, 'L 1 hnvo bool1l1othlng mol'o Ihlln n pOI'foot mothol' for 1111 my ohlldl'011, .JoRHlon. , Mlohno! IInd TlIyl,)!', I Hpenl ~ovol'lIllho\lHOnd dollll1'H (Iol'ondlng IhlH f)rlvolo~lll , moUot' nH It wnH potltlollod 10 tho oourt. Thill Inoludod tl10 hll'll1g IInd Hl1blloquonl 'dlaohll1'glng of'oollnHol nobro Cl\lli~1' to tho tuno lil' $5,000,00 dollnl'H, mOHt of whloh W!lll Hlient OOI'l'OHpOlldlllg with tho I'Jllintl fI' 0111'1>, on In Iho prooeedlng !lH h~ . WOH lit thlllllmo II PI'O.So LltlgUllt. Ihovo 10Bt ootllltloHHll,lIl11borH ofhOl\l'H'fj'ol1l work to IIPPolI1' lit C~ll11borlond Clllll1ty Offioo of'[)omoHtlc RolllllollH dofolldhll:l ' thoHo chlldrollln u'I1I1Uompt 10 go! thoh' fhthol' 10 do whllt ho IH by IIIW requlrod to .' do, 1 hnvo ~lo011 to ConoHlnlol' HellrlngH Hovorol tlmoH with nnt! without oounHol, 1 hnvo~pont IhouHnnc\R 01' dollnl'R on COllllHOI 1'01' Iho dlvOl'co, nnd HubHoquonl -2- ,I' , I' " " MlIl'l'lnl:lp SpllhmlOnl ^I:lI'PPI1WIlI1l1 whlph 11\.1 IlPVl'1' IIblllp(llIml III IhlH (In)'hIlR Ihllp(1 Ip lIvp \\P Ip, II hllH nov~,' (woll nbolll Il1P, 11llllH 1111(.\ nlWIlYH will hpll\ll1l1t tlw ohlldl'Pll, I I11nc\p Iho ,. .. " ,cl\loIHhll1 Ip lilop Ihl'pwlllB I11plWy II~VII)' plllhlH IInll HIlI1'l IIlilng tho I1WIWy 10 pnwlc\p l'PI' Iho \lhllch'pl1, Tho 111lhpI' hllH Iwl boon pllylng hili oU\II'1 cmlpl'ollliUppul't III tlw 1l1nnnel' IIncl 1I1l1aunt Hppclf10d by Iho pnlol', Tlw lillhol' IH In .1I1Tel11'H tu tlW IlIno PI' ,. ,. . , $l,(iOO,OO clpllnrH umll1l1H prthodontlc OllI1011HOH . nccl'lIlng nt llw.dontnl Pl'noo IIH lInplllcI nndordol'ocl pllld b)' tlw comtH. 1 WIIH Ilpt In IIny pOHlllplllinllllclllll)' \0 I:IQ tlll'ollgh with Iho 00\\\'1 ordel'od hPIl10 litlldy, ovon Iholll:lh 1 onllod, liohodulodnn ," " , IIppolntmcmt thelll'oluolllntl)' cnncellocl nnol' giving muoh IhplI!:!ht nnd oonlilclol,'lItlO.1l to It, 1 hlld I'onohed mnllll1lul11 on n l1\lmhol' of or cd It Ol\l'dH In un effort , to clofomlugnlnRtthlH l1'l'elipol1Hlblc IIncl dcndbent dnd, who 11'1 In nl'l'elll'H, 1 hnve n mOI'tl:lngo ta I\ny, lltllitlcH, food, olothlnl:l nH ncpdoll, nollo mention Iho ncodcd requll'ements fal'golllg to 1:10 bllok to sohool, dully wnnlH unci dOlih'es of tho ohl1c\I'OI1, pOol nwmbcl'shlps, soOC(3I' ol1l'oll111onl, hnliobnl1, 010, 010,1 huvo Inclloutod Ihut It hus nothing to do wlthnlO, It'H nlluhout tho ohl1dron und tholr Iinunolul, ' hon\th, wollilt'o, snfot)' und hupplnolis nl1d In spite I'll' nil thut'li boon anld 01' Indlouted by tho Ihthol'uncl his fumll)', l'YO dono II n\l1tn~tlc ,lob oflt with little 01' no hOI,ll' n'omthe Hlthol' 01' UIIY ol'thoao POOI)lo, .. Counsel fal' tho Plullltlffhns lIot eyen U oluo lIS to whut hilS been gollll:l,on in thili fumlly Oyel' tho )'OIll'S lInd fbI' thllt muttonYhy we ure eyonln this oourtroom todll)', I um ee\'lllllllhllt he hilS onl)' hOlll'd whut MI't Welch nnd hlsfllllll1:r hllvo wtintod ,him .to henr lInd wnlltod him to kll0W nbol1t, -J- " , ';, Cmmt!O\ rnlt!m\ IIw 1t!t!~10 \wli1ro Ihlt! \l\1\I1'I,\hll\ "\lwll\.lfimlllln\ \111t! 11\1\ H\lbml\ll1lll111Y WI\I1\lt!t!,\lHlt! nl' fi1\' 111111 .111111101' 1I11~ Pr\l-Trllll MU1l1ornl\lhnn" whlph Wilt! np\PII..fnr Ilw 1'oPlml h~ ~OqiCO~1I1H\llll1ml\lIICI01l1' Ihlll \1\lllld 1101 ~110W 1\1 whlll IlXlPI11 1 " pllll1lWII \P Ilpl'oml IIw nclloll PI' who Ilnlolld\ld \0 cllll (l111l1~ .Iwhnl 1', Whlll 110~IHHOI Wilt! nWllr() nl'wnH IhlH, 110 hllll OY\lI'~ l11\on\lnn \n dolplid Iho nollpl1 1'\11' hlH pllon\ In nl1~ mnmwr \\1n\ ho CllOHPlo do tlO,lIhHOIlI IIw nl\1ronwnt Ipllcll cl'l\orlll. \0 I1wl\lllo tho nd1l11t!t!lon or,hcnrHI\~ IPHlln1PI1~, II)h,lco\od 10 lit which WIIH OWl' 1'\11\ld nnd nllpwod 10 bond1l1IHt!lhlp, From Ihol poln\ 0111\ wnH plcnr \0 mo nnd Iho oppoHlng cP\lI1Hol Ihnl ~P\I woqld porml\ Ihe plnll1lll'l' IIl1d Ihp WI\I111Ht!QH IIH ho choHQ 10 onlcl' 111\0 Iho rcoI)!'el I~H\lmoI1Y Iho\ wnH ono-Hldcd. \hll\ 1)'0111 tho Hub,lIlClchlld. ,1CHHlclI nm\ un~l1own Il'0Xl1'IICled , "'om hOI' vol\lntn1'lly, oOOl'poe\ 01' bought \111 pl'omlHoH, Cotll1t!I~1 prollel1lod nt Ihlt! point no evldenco l1\to tho rooonllndlcntlyo or \11' nt no point did nl1~ 01' the, , wltnORROIl mnke \lRO ' of' tho WOl'd nb~IHo, Why no\'/I\ WOH n torm thn\ wnll Ihl'owl1 " nrmmd quite oneil .1'1'0111 Oc\obol' 8. 200 I nl1d ono \hllt WIIH cited 111 tho po\l\lol1l1nd pl'o-\I'lnl momol'nndt\l)), Could 1\ hnyo l'IlHultod 1\'0l\) tho l'cqIlOH\ ,\hn\ wnH 1)1Xocl \0 counHcl,lhnt lipped 111~ hnnd \0 Ihol11llnd Indloll\od Ihnll would I'cqllOH\ \01100 tho pl'ool' IInd nl' (loclImon\nllon 10 Huppol'l Iho lI\1ogn\lonllnnd Iho>, kncw Ihol'o WOI'O 110.'10, IH Ihllt why oOllnHol obJcctod to 1\10 Intl'oduclng tho nIxed I'cqul,lHI 11H 1\ doflllldnnl oxhlblt, which wnll H\lH\nlncd by you'l <, I' .4- .. Yml1'lII1I1PI't I Wlll1l~1 nHk III IhiH llnw IIH 1\ P1'P-R\.l \'l\iglll1\, Whnlwlllw" , I'\.lHpl1nHlhlll\~ Il1l1dvIH\.lI11U Ill' \IW1'\lI\.lHI1I' PI'P\.lll~I\lI'\.lllml \llllIW\.ld I~) IHIY\.l \.lol'llIln ,dp\.l\lnWI1IH H\ll'v\.l~IIP 111\.1 oP\I1'Ill1lml\.l1' \n p1'PI\lOII11~ 1'lalMl Tlw 1'lghllO bo Iwnnl h\.ll'p1'o tlw oPUI'I,IIW1'lghll\1 ~I\.lluml 111~HIlII~ IIWl'lghllll'l11>' 11\IHhl1nd to ~lclil1ld hln)fip\l'nglllnHllhc ohlll'LWH 111111 WfJ1'll IIl\llgfJd IInd hl'll~\ght Iwliwlh\.l OP\lI'I,\l1\I I'lahl of d~1\.l pI'PC\.lHH, In Ihu IIhHIlIW\.lpf YO\l1'lInHW\.lI' II11hlH point, I olin nnl>, IIHH\l111U' , IhlH IH II 11111\101' \l1111,:;hpuld hllvo bOlln 1I~ldl'oHHOd hy 011lll1HoI p1'ovln\lHI~ I'ollllnod IInd H\lbHO~lullnll~ l\IHch!lI'gc~1 h~ 1110 nH,ll1ol'foollvo on ,1\l1)ll Rl 2()()2, IIWVIlI' 1'ooolvod IIn~ a\lldllnoo 01' Info\'l11nllnnlp IlwolTocl, li'ol11 ho\' 01' Ihll11 11pPOHlng oO\lnHollmllolll1t1g, IIn~ H~lllh \,Qqull'onl\ll1lH Ill' Pl'o\pool. , I ".' 'thl.i OXpoollI\lol1 thlllll Pro-So LllIgllnllH tonppOll1' In oomllll1d bo oxpoolod to bo IIH'IJl'oplll'ed IInd kl1owlodgollblll nf tholllWH IInd plllCOII\lI'OH ol'lho 00111'1 In tho Hllnw 111l1nnOI' Ihlll would bo oXpoolO<\ b>, I'ocqgnlzo<\ cO\lnHol ol'lho 13m' AHHO(llllllon IHnt bOllI, nbH~\rd, I WIIH PI'OPIII'\Jd \0 pl'oHonl 111~ dolenH\.l ol'lho nllognllonH' bcfbl'O IhlH ,. " oourt. t f\l\'thol' oxpeclcd 10 1'eOelVOHomO 111111\1<\0 In m~ p1'oHonlutlol11 bllt Il1Q\'O ' , ' Ill1pol'tlll1tl~ 1 WIIH 00\'111111 I would be nl10wcd III H\lbmll n dol'onHo bllHodol1'\ho nllogl1\1onH l'lIlHOd In tho polltlol1 bcfol'o tho comt nnd Iho pl'o.tl'inl n1O\1101'11I1d\1111 OH" , " Hubmltted b~ oounRollbt' tho plnlntl f1', " ;. ' Thorol'ol'e, I H\\bmlt to the COlll't LInd YoUI' HOI1~ll'nblo ,IUflgo HOHH 1'01' COIlHldol'utloll (h~ Ibllowll1g1 whloh 1 bollevo to bo \1'\10, AH nYl'o-So Lltlgulll who l'elulllOd !llld II !lUbHoqll~lltly dlHchnl'god nH 1I10lTectlyo counsol 011 ,lul1o 8, 2002 unt! whut I bqllovo to bo 1111 ovol'ZOnlo\1H deHh'o topl'evnl1ln thlH \11n((OI' nt the ox pOll He or un \\ .5, hwxplll'llln\llld PnH31l1l1\/M1I11 by \.lXI)IJl'llln\l\J~1 \J1l\ll1iilJll'lllnll1\l11 by plllll1lln~ I wns Illlnlcd IHlu\l pl'll\J\JSS Ilrlhls \JIlIII'I, I 11m 1\l1'lhpl' \JPI11pollpI\ln boll\.lvU Ihls \\1 lw lI'IlIl,111 tlmt Ilwlllsl nrli\lllll Olll'l'psppn1lonoo Ihnll WlIs In 1'000lpl nrWIIH nPlltlllnn to WIlhd1'llw nH CIl~ll1splli)1' Iho Plnlnllfl', nl1d n I~ulo to.l3hllw CII\IHO which WOI'O Hll!llOd by }lnllnnd IIl1swol'lld . by nw i\llhp nf'f1l'l11nllvo (pgl'llnt HIIIIII'\'lq~lOHI 111 MlII'k I1n1OI'Y, nHqull'o, I hl1vo 1\0VOl' 1'00plvo(lnl1 of'f1rilnl1'PHp(1I1S0 liS 10 Iho dlsPQslllnl1 I1rlhlll \1011111111. nmlntlHl\l1llllllhll1 plnlnllrfwlIH nlHo PI'O,Sp, " I'vo dono qullo n bll or 1'OSOIll'oh on this I11l1l1el' ns II p01'lnlns to tho 1'010vlInl nppllolltlon of'the Inw nnd how bost In npply tlHlt IIHpoot of It.to tlwdoolHlon bofol'e YoU\' Honol', Il'nl1 with the snmplooltod by op\1osln~ Ooul1HP,lln MoMlIlen v, MoMlllon nnd rovlowod Ihllt (looIHlan, llnltlnlly fplt It hml no l'olovnnoy to this ., . I11l\ttol' duo to tho IRHue of 1\ Hole ohlld In thllt I11n\lol' nnd siblings In this ono, Upon rondlng.tho onHo,1 Htlll I1n(\ nil oot'l'olntlon f(w tho Hlbllnl:ls In this I11n\lOI', I WIIs .l)erplexod to I1nd thnt Ifthu ISHUOS !'nlHod In McMIlI~n y, MoMillon WOI'O IIlIqwcd to bo nppllcd tnthls OI\SO. IIHh WIlS Pl'oHclltcd 10 Ihe courlln tho petlllonerH l'equosl nnd subsequollt pro,tl'lnll11el11ornndu111 tho honel1ls or l\ppllCnllon would WilY more . . In nwol' \1t' I11Y cnse thun Ilmt Pl'osenled by Ihe plnlnll fr, Although I WUH nOlpcl'1111l1ed 10 cnlerlntn the Issuo ol'nhllHe tn,my dllfbnHO befhro Ihe COUl'I, I WUH pl'opurod 10 mlso IhlllHHlIe und Ihllullcgullolls Ihul worc Il1lidll pet'\lllnll1g 10 It, 111111 YOlll' Honol', u vlllllm of Domesllc Vlolenco pOl'pctl'l\tcd by the plnlnltff, r H\lffered pl'cvlollHly by vlrtuc of his nollons ulld I continue UH of tills -6- " IWl'hp\\I' nrI1Pp~llIm\'lp prllvld~ Iwl' wlll1, \1111\ wl1lcI111\l1111~ Illllcd I11IHl.ll'I\hl~LIP prpvl~I\lln \Iw pllHllhll1' PI' liw ~OI\l'H nrlWI' 1110, II nuhol' IIml d!\\l~hl\.lI' l'ohltlllnHl1lp, I w()lIl~lI1Hk Ihlllllwl'\l\\lVllnl nppllcnllnn or \Iw Ihllllwll1~ \w IIppllod IIH It pCl'lnlnH 10 tlw nhnv\l pnl'ngl:\lPI1, nH Hlnlod II1t1lOJnw 1\1 n !In, C,S, ~ 53()~ ^ wnnllll' CIIHIPd~, \1nl'lhll CIIHlp~l~ nnd VIHllnllon nml ~llIll.ld Hp\lolfionll>, Ihol'l.lln nl (II) G~II{ll'l\l HIII~, '" ","I~III~ IIn Ht'lllll' fot' (lll~tody, JlIIl;tllllll"!itlHIY~l' VINltntlllll to 1l1tlull' IUIl'llllt, thllllOIll't Nlmllcnl\NIII~l', Illllollg nthlll' flllltOl% whlllh Jl"I'llllt IN IIHlI'{lIll~llly tn Illlllnlll'lI~e, pel'lI1l1 I\lId IIl1n\v t'I'ellllll"t,lIlUlllollthllllll~ Ilonhlllt lI11d IlhYNlcIIIIlC~CNN hctwoolI th\! IIOII.OIINtOlIlIlI JlIIl'ellt 111111 thll child, '" IIddltllln, the OOIll't Nlmll conNhllll' ellch 11III'cllt Illld IIdlllt hll\lNllhllhl mlllllh~I"N , " IweNent "lid !lIlHt vlolllnt Ill' Ilh\lHlve ol)!ldllot" which lllllY lllchlllc,Jmt IH IIot ' limited to,llhllHlvo conllllct IlH ll\ltllllld IIIU\OI' t1lllllct ofOlltl)hlll' 7, 1976 (l~, I~, 1090, No, 218) ImownllN the PI'otectlph FI'om Ab\llie Act, (UeIICllle(\'by the Ilct of Dcecmhcl' 19, 199()) (P, li' 124(), No. 2()(i) Illld \lOW 1l00ltllllllld III Chllptel' 61 of this cIU\(ltel'. '{ , In I\sldng YOl\1' HOllOI' 10 IIpply II1\HnHpool of' Iho Inw nH I'olovllnt 111 YOlll' dOlermlnllllon, I would l\nly,olto Iho losll111On>, pl'OHollted by Iho pllllnlll'f' 111 rogllrds 10 lillltllblo living oondltlons IInd nl'l'nngom~nts whoro l1e (osil lied "!, work d\lt'lng ,." " tho elll>', tho Stopmolhel' works nlnlghlllnd Ihol'e WO\lldbe somoonc IIlhol11o wllh Jesslell, nlnll limes", Hnvlng s\lflbrcd nt tho 1\llnelH of' this cownnlly Indlvldunlll\o 1I'1Il1nin ot'domosllc vlolonce nnd the fncllhlll.JosslolI Is II sl)lttlng IllllIgetlrhol' mother In IIlInHpccls illld ninnnorlsllls, I fOIIl' tho Inovitllblo I'cll'lblllloll shc could fnco li'om hel' 'filthe\' who losllned Ulldol' onlh Ihnt he d\'lnks Inlho pl'esence oflho " .N., " " " ohll~lrpl1l1mllllllwl\buvo HPollnl'lp liS lo~llli\l(1 to I1y hll1l.lw Ol1l1llllw tho onl>, " pnt'onl III hOlno wilh ,lo~sl\JlIl\ll' II mll1lnllllll PI' H hPllI'H III n limo I1l1l1n>, /:lIVOI1I1I/:lhll I hllVo I1IWIlWl' gOl1l1lno I~lII' h\lI1O Iilotlhnt tho stop~PI10r(h.llilllll Woloh IH II) >'ont's \)filgo IImll'osllllilg Inlhnlsnmo Iwmo whOI'\l tho>, Intol1l1lp 1'Il1~\JlhIH dnll/:lhIPI', PlolIso glvo I1P IOSH oPI1HldOl'nllplllo this soollol1ol'lIlP 1l1IV nl1<llI's Il1h\.l1'P111 IIppllonHpl1lP Ihlli OIlSo, n~ Ihlll MhoI' ll'lpl'OSHOd lIosh'o to 111'0 wllh 1101' IlII/WI', ",' Tho ()lIwl'1'010vnI11 lowH 10 whlcih II0finlllon nl1d IIppll~lIllpl1 sholllll bo g I'll 11 1 011 111 , this mllltOI' lwlhl'o Hw 00\11'1, IIIi pl'osol1toll h>, the pol 11101101' 111111 oO\II1Hol 111'0 2~ PII, CiS,*6~0 I, Tho IIppllontlol1.ofthlwlnw pl'OvldoH Ihl' the l'opol'lll1gpf slIsP"otod 0\' 1I0tlllllllots,ofnhllSo liS Indlolll\Jd In tho I\Uhol's' pollllun IIncl his ooul1sol's ' i)lOmOl'llnllum holol'o th~ oourt, Tho\'o nro provisions wlthlnthlli IlIw tOllllow tho Il1vostl/:lIHloll,lId.ludlontlol1, I'PCol11mol1dnllonllne! pl'ovontlon of' IIhuso 01' I11nltol'H , ,doomodl\s 110n-nbulilvo, Thlli IIIW I\lrthol' IIddrosso:nho offbotR on pnl'ontnll'lghts liS' ,. ,. . , gonPI'nll>, I'oooanlzod line! oxlsling tp ~ISOI'OnHol1l\blo supol'vlsiol1l1nd oonll'ol whon mlslng th~h' ol1l1dl'OI1, Thoro 1\1'0 11100hllnlsl11s Intol'l1nlto this lnw nnd oxpl'ossl>, ' stlltod iI) ~. 6302 (b) Purpose, thllt 1I(ldl'PSS (ho pl'otootlon of'ohlldl'oll I)'om 1\11'(hol' abuso nnd providing of I'ohnbilltnllvo servlcos 1'01' ohlldnm IInd pnl'onts Involved, liO " liS tOOllSUl'O tho child's well"bolng nl1d to pl'osorvo, stllblllzo nnd pl'Oto9tthe Intogrll>, of' Hllllll>, life whol'ovol' IIPpI'Opl'illto, with nddltionllllnngungo suppllod, " Tho I'esenroh I'vo conducted Indlclltos thnt one of tho Issuos pnl'lJl11ountto ' oOl1sldol'lltlonlnohlld oustod>, OIlSOS is tho oxprossed dosil'o of tho ohlld to live wllh ono PIJI'olll ()I' thc o(hol" In this pnl'(Icu!LIl' (Jnso nnd In cOl1sldol'lItlon ol'tho . Ill'orol11ontloned 23 Pn, C,S, ~ 630 I., I woul\1 nsk thllt YOlll' "/onol' cOI'tnln/>, give .(). " ii' " J onI1HI~lo\'nlllll1 III Iho oxprllHHoII IIOHII'IJ, wHh 1\11 OmpllllHIH 011 pro O\.llulwr H, 20(11.1\1111 , , pO~il Opln\1ol' I), 21101 \vlwllllllllI ,10HH101\, to onlllWl' Iiltlwr nml hflVo him "lnKb >,1ll1 10 >,PHl' Ol'tholloll\IHI vIHII" nIHil ~\XPI'IlHHOd tu him 111 1I1l11I1WI'HIIIllll1 Ihnt I hII'I wl1h .. him Illw 11001Ip~llllIIHHIIIl1\l 1111'111>, o\lllgl\llol1H, >,0\11' 1l!lIlghtcll' IH 0\11 or o\1l1tl'ol" IhlH WIIH 111\01' I pllgoll him' IIlld hol'otll1'1101111 phllllPolIll tl1lllO nt Wl1I'K, Flllhol'pl'POClJdlJlI Ip plok l,lhllll lip tlHlI IJVOl1ll1g 1I11e! wllh Hl1l1lO IllIpl'lOI' m()tiv~), thnt hi HtllI Ulllmowl1 Ip I1WlhiH Ihl>"loIlK\l1P Huh.lIJl,llohllll,loHHlolI, 10 WOHI Shlw Rogllll1111 Polleo,l\lIcgelll\hUHo h>, 1ll0lUid 001111101 WIIH I1llldp 10 Chlldr\ll1l1l1d Youth I' . SOI'vloeH, whllworo l1011l1ce! 1111(1 \lcICnmoll1volvod III tho mllllcl',Tlw l'Olllllll1e!ol' wnH , .' plnyo(1 pullll >,PIII' oomlrnlll11, wl1h 110 1110nllol1 or nil>' PI' Iho polloo f'indll1gH or dlkpOHllloll ol'Chllllrolll1lld Yl1l1lh H(~rvleoH lI11d Intoryollllol1 PI' 110 n1\.ll1llol1 nl nlly pollllln II1\) prooocdll1gH tho ,,{ord IIhIlHO, Tho tOI'I11110W utlll7.0d IH c1IHclplhw, " " " Whel1 giving welghl 01' cOI1Hldorllllollto Iho ohlld'H oxproHHccl dllHh'o 10 IIvo with hOI' 1)\lhol', YOUI' Honor, try 10 <10101'1111110 why Iho ohlld noYOI' OXpl'CHHOd 111lHcloHII'0 ,I pl'O OcloDol' Il, 200 I, Why ol1ly II nor bolng<llHolpllncd b>, 1110,on Oolol101' Il, 2001 .. for donlll1l bohnvl01'lmd wh>, ol1ly nnol' I'cHti;lollng hol' fi'0111lhocompulol' nnd mnklng hor HpOlld 111110 In hOI' bodl'oOI11, TI10HO WOI'O 1\\1 dlHclpllnl\l'Y mOllSUl'Oli Inklm by 1\113 10 cOI'1'oollho of'fondlng bchllVlol', Why'only nl)W hUH Hho oxproHHcd Ihls lilrong dOHlro 10 IIvo with hOI' Ihll\OI', Tho Hnl110 1i\lhcl' who hllH hlld illite 01' no " Involvoll1onlln hOI' 1I1'0,hnw, whon 01' II' CVOI' Hho WIIS disciplined, I hllvo 1\ IlIwl\ll l'oHponHlblllty 10 dlHclpllno IIndcol'I'cct tho ohlld'H of'fondlng behIlVlol', 1"01' tho oOUl'1 .' 10 glvo PIIl'lIll1oulltoonHldorntlon 10 hOI' oXPl'oHliod dOHh'oH wlthoul PIII'IIt110Unl' conHldorllllol1 of I\\y 1'lghlH IIH II plll'onllo IIdmlnlHlol' dlHclpllno within Iho bounds -10. ,J' .;' , i' ,'.,J .}.\}' ,,~ '!, '!if, lI1HI ap(lpc pflholnw, Yo\l1' 111111\11" Y\l\! WOII\d Iw I'pmlaH In ~/O\II' ~1\'llciH \n 1)P1 IIpply 11lIllllw 1111 I'olovlln\ In \hltlI11I\Hol', In o\palng, Y(lm' I'Ipnpl' I \\l\lk. wl\h pl'ldo nml grolllln\OI'OHllho 1'0111n1*H Ihll\ YOII '" I " modo 1\\ tho oonolllHlon (l1'\ho honl'lng, Spoolllo!llly,IIH Ilw~' pOI'\lIlnot\ \0 ,loHalPII IIntl yom ,1\:ltiol'lp\lon ol'hol', YP\I H\II\O\I Ihlll Hlw la II wry HI11I1I'I, knowlodgollbll,J Iwl , loving ohlld, who YO\! bolloyod IIlao 10 be \l'ollblo\1, I oould not IIBI'OO wHh yo\llIny , moro, I \00 Iwllovo \ho\ aho hllH boon.\I'O\lblllt\ IIn\\ IIwl'olil1'o 10PK Iho lnltlllllvo III ., 0111'011 hol' In ohlld payohologlolll HOl'vlooH, I bollevo tho II'Pllhllng oonwa 1i'0111 \hil ., , ' !llthel' nnd I not ofToo\lvoly'oo111111\mhmllng with Pilch 0\1101' on IHa\leapol'llllnlng to thll ohllc\l'lm, 1 1\ll'lhol' bollovo \hllllho Iilthol' nml HIOpl11otlWI' hnvo boon ongllglng Iho ohlldron 1\1l11l1ltol'a thllt nI'O boallon to IId\l\la, Tho~o Ihlnga cO\lpled wllh' .. to .' ' pl'ol11laoa 01' gl nH IInd vlalol\a of tho WOl'ld IhnlnwlIlIH 1\1'0 mllltcl'~ \hlll Ilwllilvo hoye only HOl'vcd 10 Il'oublo hOI' youl\g IInd doyol\lplng 1l)ll\d. 1 know aho 1'0110\1te.l\ Ih(3 dlaclpllno of Oolobl'I' !I, 200 ll1mll O\\n III1HUI'O you (hut Iho dUYH thll,I hllYo opmo for\hHlnoo Ihllt dllY were loHH Ihlln plollHmllblo 1'01' hel" bUI nol nIl 01' IhoI11WOI'O Ihlll I, way. Wo WOl'e nblo 10 ahlll'c molhol' IInd dnughlol' 1I0tlvltloH, 1)0 you know n ohlld " thllt. enjoXH dlaolplll\o? I did notllppl'oolnto tho lIeH IInd docol\ Ihlll Hhe 1\1I,owcd hCl'aolfto ongngn In with guldnnco IInd lnlluonco l'l'ol11lholillhor nnd Hlop-molhol' nnd 1101\ hOl' know It In no unool'lnln lormH, YeH YOlll'lIomll', aho Illn Hl11ll\'t girl nnd entlroly too ~mlll't to bc tnl~lol\d IlH I botlove aho hUH boon, I would Illlk Ihut tho Ol'dOI' of tho coul'll'elllllln IlH pl'OVlollHly IIlHuod NOVOlllbel' 4" 199R Ilnd Ihllt Ihlnga rcmuln,IlHI~ und whore \a und conllnue to 10llYO Ihlll fiunlly,und Ihe albtlnga to " l'el11llln JUHt 0\11111 fiunlly. ,II. Iuslhnpny PI' 1111 pllnius 111111 wIII1USSUS, I1l1d 1\ \H hulluvud \11111\\1 ('\1\1I'I's IIII'll IlhH\)ivIII!,l1\S, .i\llllilul\ Is II wry 11\III\II'U 1IlIIllnlulllllul1l. Y\111111\ 1111'1, PIIPllhlu \11' 1Il1l1\1!\IlIlI'UIISIllHlhlollu\lls\OI1 lIS \oll'l1ul'u ~l1u Wlsl1uli 10111'\1. HUC\1I1\I, ,IUlllliclI's 1'\l11l11l1l111hlp wllh l1ul' slopllllhol' Is sI11111111' 10 Iho Ph\lII,'1I111 " 'I. lYlI}Mllhm, \1 Is ululIl' Ihlll)uhlll\111Shlp Is, III \IUIII, 11011"uxlsI01\1. 111 u\1l1\plll'llIlll1, ,IUSS\\III'S l'ulllllol1l1hlp 1I'111! IlOl' IIlopI1\\llhul',T\IIIlIllY, ill sll\hlo, 101'1111.\1111111111'0111.\- 'I'hu 1I1\l1.1I1Ir\11l11l0 sl1\\111I1'. , " Il1lhlll )ulIslolIls oOl1sll1l1\I)' 101\ 1I111llO.,holh d\l1'll1lJ Iho sllllll1lOl' I\l1d Ilw s\\11\I01 yulII', 1I11111hlli sll\l\IlIol1 hilS 01\\1\11'011 sI!IO\l shc II'lIsl1ll1o, ,llIsl 1111 III MclYlill9n, pl'ovldll1B ollslody 10 Fnihol' Wlllllllnllow .IoslIlol\ In hll\'U Il\u sllpol'l'llIlol1. 1.\111dl1l\(1l\ 1IIIIIsIIppOn 01'11 pIII'uI11111 1111 Ihnuli, Tho gUl1ol'lIll'ulo 111 ulllIlOIly dlllplilus Is 111111 chlldnJII shollld 11011l\lIlOPlIl'lIlud 1I1,Ihu I\hS\111\10 01' colllpulIll1ll I'UIIIIOI1S. 1~1ll\ILV.,.Jl\lI!I\. 3'12 1111, SllllUl', ~~. 55, '102 1\2d 59. hO (I1)HS), 110\\'0I'U1:: "Ihls polley Is hili 0110 11101(11' III hu oOl1siduI'L'd, 1111\ulhol' II'I\h l1\hul'lI, III dulonl1ll1ll1l! Il!o I1HIIII1UI' ill " wliloh II ohlld's helll hH ul'ulll II 11'\11 ho lIul'ved," tvLlLV,.IUL lIh 1111 SlIpOI' 2f)H, 304', 4H5 /\.2d H13,'11l6 (19H'I), *10 111110, SW\J\l9.Sw~WnllQ.'15S PII. SUpOI',5H7, hH9 ^,2d 2M (1\)1>7). "1'\'llIls ii" I' ' " . 1'1110 Imllll yluld 10 11\0 pnrllll\olll1l pl'lI19lplo Ihlll.\lIo ilolllll1\ul'Ollls 01' ul\oh 1IIIIIvlduIII ohlld 111\1S1 ho' , Iho detunnll1hlll l\\Clol' 111 cUlllody doels!I1IlIl," I hlllll.l',Hl\lll!. :l.l() P\I. S,lIpOI'. !jCJ I. 4C)9, '\HS' ^,2d IIHI). l\'J:l (1')H4). I. Tho H\lpurlnr COll1'll'ullml \11\ Iho IIho,\'o'~\II\od Pl'lllOlploH IlllYllllmncy, ft\lpl'l\.. M\\hlm\l~' III p\ll'lIo\ll\ll'ly lippl!o\lblo \III Iho C\1111'\ W\lS Ihood wllh ,Iho IUII1\U IwolHslleH pl'lIIlO1\1 herein, 1110 Ht\ltud pl'ol'oi'uncu or Iho L'hlld, IIlld Ihu IIpllllll1l! or Hlhlllll!S, 111 tillhmw~~ Ihu 10ll'el' cnul't h\ld \I\\'I1I'1\od ,\ cllslody nr ol\ll SOI\ In lho Iillhol', hllsod 11\\lll\ly \lpnll Ih\l\ ehlld'H HIII\ud pl'ol'ol'ollCU In llvu with tho' .. lhlher. Tho (\ll11'llIphcld Iho dcclHlol1, I'L100llll111l1glhi,llho "host hllOl'ulIls ol'lho ohlldl'on III thu hlHllIl\t OIlHO 1\\1IHl pl'o\lullol'Ol' IIIlY IIhlltl'\lot policy"." hi.. 5 12 ^2d, \II ()'J7,(cltll\g M\)^I\\\IIIHlI', " " ,. , . MCI\HllllpH, ]llll!ll\. H\lper. <\OCl, '11~, 'I'H11\,~d I) I H, 02:1 (I \J~~), ' " Applying well:uHlllbliHhed prueu1llll\\, .Il1,HHiclI'S prpl'urulwc lollw wllh \"llllIcl' 1I1\ISI bu glWH sII1181I\11\\1I1 wulgl1\ 11\ Ilulcr1l11"hl[1 whlllls Iii her \luHlll\lol'oHIs, IIml1\1lr IIpplyll\l\ Iho s\l\l,11\1 l'ulIsol\ll\l:\ Hul l\ll'\h 11\ Ml1h\llIQ)/, II'hllu Ihu CI1\1I'\ ulll\lIolllll\Ol'u lhu Iilol Ihl\1 Ilw Sllllllll:\s 1I'1I111ll 8Uplll'lllu\11I1I1\11ll\811Iw pIIl'ol\lH, 111\1' "lIbHll'llel Plllloy" 01\111\01 01'\l1'l'Idu Willi I is illllw IMI h1\orosls nf,!cHHlol\. , " MIII\I!\\Qy sll1l1\ls Ihr Ihupl'Pposlllol\ Ihll\ the bOHtll\lul'eslH nl'lho child Is Pll1'l11l10111\11I1\d' \11\lsI bo cl~l\shlorod ovur IIWllulW1'I11 prul'urel\oe ol'keepll\B sllllhlBH 10l!0Iher, II' .Iossl~1I hilS 11111(10 II 1\1I\\llre, rOIlHol\lIblu IIl\d ruspol\slblo dcelHiPII 10 live Wllh 111111\\11', IIl\d Hllch Is I1l1hnlod H\II11\1lcl\l wolghl \ll hl\lioll\u II is III .IoHslclI's bCHI IlIlcresl \0 do Sll, sllch dueisipt\I\I\IHI o\ll\wll\h Ilw I\Pllllelllll~1\ ol'lho "I\\lnlly \1\111" doolrll\e, See IIlso, ClInhHlWIlPYcEIH!lul1', <\'12 I'll. HlIPl11'.2Cl], 6~() A.2d ~7~ (1<)(J~){n\lnlly lIl\lI doclrll\e 1\111 olll\ll'llllllli:\ where ehlld'H prcl'urel\ce olherwlHe' eSlllbl\HheH beH\ Il\lul'eH\), I' ,. \1\ Ihe pl'esel\t ellse.lhe "lil\nlly lIl1ll" dllclrll\e Is I\nthhl!! mnre Ihlll\ 111\ IIl1s\rllCI pl1l1cy. TIWl'ollllH heel\ I\n \oHlhl\ol\Y Ihlll WOllld Il\(lIcII\u lhlll \hc HUplll'lIl1ol\ 01' Ihu slblll\l\H wOllld hllvu II l\ul\lIl1vulmpllcl nl\ 111\1' nl' Ihelll, IIl\d .111 pllrllclIllIr 1\ nU!?lIllvu Implle\ 01\ .IusHICII. Thu Cllllllllllllw tusl1111n1\Y 1\'<11111111 plIl'\ies IndlclIluH Ihlll Ihe ehildren Hpend nil IIllle tnl\elher dmll\g the sllIH1I1ur 01' IIl\el' Hchnnl. !tlllhul', .IesslclI Is III hOlllu, MlchllollH III his grlll\dplll'Cl\ts, IIl1d TlIylor Is 11\ dllyclIl'e. " Furllw!', hllKod lIpOI\ II sllll1dnrd clIs\ody IIgl'colllUl\IlIS Is 111 plllcc eUI'l'ul1l1)/, lhc chlld!,cl1 would hu logclhcl' UVCI'V wcckcl1d, 1I11ells\ onu nlghlll Iwck, IIl1d WOllld hllVC SUhS\lInllllllllllc logclhul' . '. . . . " durlnl\ tho sunilllC!'. Tho!'u IK Rltl\ply IW I'oqlll!'olllent 10 lippiI'll goneI'll I policy wllhout thorc l>ell11\ , " II kUIl1c\cl1t Ihcllilll hllhlH 101l1dlcnlc lho policy hllH lllorllll1 Ihu pl'cRunl sllulI\lon, r' \ '.' 1'.'-< ," ,., ". ,,,. .. ""," l\1\q" 'r"'c~'\" c9;'S' . '\'.}:)" (')' ,~.:~ '(1'.1 ;)()"')(~ '. (':X)I' ~\ .. ,I~.I. ,,\. "",) .U'I.", U . ( . ., (. _ I Y ,. .',"";' "." .., ..:....~.<J-LU~S ',2i~ld.:.(t.LYrt-()r~)')'..)I' 1,6'" +~o '., , .. .",. ,..,' :; I:.~/.) ,~.', YOl)....,be../.:./-er-,;.f"rOpf}, :l"II("~"1" ",Ii<)()," . , \ ( I L .r.~ -. 1("';:: O' ~~. II;,,) r-"I/ (I 1"1,,;:-,1(1 \ ];~ ~''::\ " '. '.. ",.,.:J -.n,(,( .. iJJ .~), I). ,.';~~ . '. /.;;":,;:~- ,c~\.i::;~\:' , I:.J/'\/l c'.' "\/' ...J."A ('):)C" 1.1--.4 ll~ L)'r"" 11.1-, ;r" "") , .. ..' i~~~,~{~j)~6ir~f:tITJ~~I/~~:~Y .... '" " . ,)(){)C(CI)2'. (.)flC(:FI/~t...J.L 'L).'".~.I ...~.Jl, J,. . ' L\JI n bt(,tH.1'r.:".e.. ...1.". rn Cl(,)ll )c~k"rn j..:)(:;. (",) ''\ IF'') L'I C I (" I \ ' \ ,"\ " ,,1.: ("". II ') (" I \ (' . " ". '1" /'l.._}l_ """/ "'::;:;"...11 (1<;:.; '..' _II,...?-, .\ . , 'jVi) rL1 clef}" . . , :'"...." ". .. L. .1..../... reO-' '"'J''' 00'" "',i''' < .," ... i"~:C' ) .:. f/'.. . 1,'" ''':'t '''''I '''1 '-I':' "'r" \';'~l'" , '-" ',. .~.. 1:' :~I.,._':: :q..r.I'..IY....1V (cnj;~X..1CfL .~.." \"IC\.~ .: J\(.,."'~\0 :'li -",;d-::..._OL:d~s I q,(:', '_"a' _ H '. ,., ... "" ,., ". ., i I ".... TO. . < ..,. .1''-.'0.......... . ..._. ,-,- '" .-, '......"...... ". ....:--.l=I.e.{CO II (':(j...nit;j.C\ . t'1U5ty -(..i,;::;';:/'. -.'",'.. (~ncl" tdUi5+:Yul:)I"I'C\~"". . '.' ," '" , ..-...... -......... .....-..".-.....,,---.-- ,,- '--q --"._, ... ,... . '..... ......... _ _,_ ,_.Ii ,,_, . d, ... '-_ ". ': ,.., ,;.~C\I~ I y'.~~~~'1 ~_ L~)~.tt'), ),!.~;~ g'I':;i'~SI:) 9 ,.!.~'I:.~.C~:.;~ / ") , ' .' ",,_....'.,-- ,.".I!Lc.lfYl\()XGlc(\~g~.J~\?_e\:'~}(c"'.D:,~}]L ';;'>)",:~(:;l/~bX;J~t./I! .' . .. ,.. .,','~L- L.. .tc.. . , ,...d\,. ,,].1.... ." .1--..,;" .".. .I, I:".~:\....,'" _: ..,. ,"':, , a' ,~~~n~)~~~~7~i?fi I:'(~f": 1-.::-1 e u~\:t::~ ,J I, /1 r /.l:3+C, Ii . r , l..l-Jolt; crOGOJ .f;':i ~",\ '/,,:,' , ~/.J' St'le -}-e115 {J')e che Ck)e5r-')/+ ..' '\ CUQ(l+ rne +0. see r.Y')C ClQq\n c-j, 'LAINTIPP'$ kF I qo "'J -0 I ( V C (;U I-j- /') tn r aael , I 1.,::"'BXHIBIT' ,-\-'ce l v-~ loVecA (~)')r) . I I'" (()/ 1) D (~ ., ..~)I Ii 'J) ;,1\, 't \I,1I1 (IIY lill," iF)1 I I.AJlle '\ I J.. 1:\',IJ1r,i'"I" (',\\(IIJI,\,r" ,), ('),,~'IJI(\(",",I,l fl 1\,'\ C\j', ,'" I \ I",' " U,l II II \, '1,,1i', '\"/ " {'I U (f ,t ll/:, 'I 0 j l/ '" n(.y'l( "\' L.. ( ~" ' , \ I ' LlI... ' I I ,,\'X'\(I' ( )/' / ,/,/;" II} (I ,il'ln' 1)/)'/'1" '(";'). I' I' \.,( .~ . "(( 'n, ,{"..( I , i. ",~, ',~"',,"\' ..~ ,,{, \/ ,I I' I! '{! I <'! ' (' ....". " ",' II , .. , " ( (I Ii' , " Ie .~ ().\ .If (1,(, If" ! \, .t.J ",.' \, ,. ' ,~\' ,'l;~;itl!'l,,"nr'~ 1(\ ')f( )""/'. t; ,,\ ( t' '; "I()I') /, V I vI" 1"1 "":1~ ,il'...,.. ,"", ", ,/ ~.". J ..,' \ ',,",', ". ',. ,I.) "t, rc.....,. I.., \ I.. .' ,./' ""(') /.t'V I) "'\ ( II ./)j .,/.., . I....., .J. ., .(. . ,,\, .' ",I L I I ( l..'...J, ,," " ' i, ' i / ., ]~,' ((::\:1." (.1., l)c?crJ() ," S:')I' )d~:)'ltvi(19 , !" ..lcI IIVC r)<,) Uk:.., L( 11'\ n}(}!\c~ ' \ C'Y 'I V I \ 'r" ~1? ! (. " f ' ., I f" I " ( " ' . '. ,'" '," r ' ~. ,., m., .)(i. '~_', i" 0(,1,.,.1 .({, I ." c.....,.7' ('f;~. :)(:J, " i \. " ,.,(~1/t\1rl"IYfl':,I'l!;:<<'r\~;1;)'l'I,\'''. "'\'I');J1~'( 7y;::""r~)(} ii:ki) ,(\&21\1l~.dlf '\l'.t ,f;l..:lt., (,.,jL(.:c~' ..---1 I .s, .... ~ " II \ . " '-\.)JQJ\ tCt U ,s Yh? t}(O(Y)(L<i! i.(h~?' , " nqr r)((~ U) cl' (fd)<~('\.j.L. (J.l.(J{,(Y:~'( r)e.r-') "It) "Vt) II r ) I rf /., "}e,) L,::)I'L';..;f'~)( Ii:.:> t)()(I ~l: ' U:5/C r \ i.J v y I(:~ l'~.:te ( tt elIT::/-, '1 <? II h \, 'f), I :J \\lL ( \;. \ (,J u\: i-( ;':.:d () (- ) .. i' .._.~>tv~ lk"j k:':JJr.'i" rnc LX (,:tA'Uc:,r(' I ' p~' .p~n~/T 'Ill ~:"~)JtOC)'(:;A . ~)(\\ ':~'.:-~\ f~ \C~UL\, ( i, \~'I""-/C. (,) , LL . ,! L / (: )l , / J; ie f~~~t)(':) " (~)~e~.r ) \ ~,>\ I, (v:_'[: V.) (I/) (,/./" n' 'Ai ", \(,,'\CL,,\: \<:Je., ,t.,) I "J" I ' ' I ",i I I~,( il: . ~t' , I ; i'I'/ I' 'i\' '. \ M. \ " ii' d\ "'.'-' ';.1,. jll(' J , l'lll. \ .1 II" , IO,IIIIW;W()2 MI',IlI1WI'Y My 111'111\1.1 I>> J,lll'lu l{uIIIIUIIII; 11\11\ i\PW I'Upl'csul\lll\U I11YHu\\' 11\ \\W \Vu\\lh I', \V\.lluh CIIHIlllly I>>H\IU, FII'HI, hulbl'u ~IlIlW Ill' YIl\ll' U\1IHlU\'I1H III'U IIIlSwul'ull I WIlII\lllIku Iu hl'il1lJ II I~'w 1l\ll.lUI' " Ulll1uUI'llH \11 ylllll' 1I\IUIIIIUlllhIlIIIlIUI\ III hu IllhlrUHHUIII11111WIIIIHuly, Thuy IIl'u liS 1\>III1WH: PUIIIIIIIIlHI11'lI1\uu 1\11\\ MI', Wuluh I\I\H 1111 his uhllllru1\ UIlVUI' $2()()O,0l) Ihr hrlluus, T\1u SII1I1IIIlI'lI Pl'o\ludlll'\lls Ihlllllw >>lull\l1l 111.11\1111 Ihnll Is .H\.lllt 1\'lll1\ Ihu Ol'lhudPIIIIHt lu llw II1Hllrlll\llp CUI1\PIII1Y IIwyll\ 1\ll'lllHHllu P\lpUI'S I\II' lhu Or\lll,1dol\\Ist 11111\ IIrplo hu HUl1111l ' ll\OI\I\1ly, Thu \lll1ploypu (Mr; Wulu\1l Ihpll I'UUUIVuH Ihu l'ulI1\IHII'SUll1u1\1 111\11 Ibrwl\nlH lhu uhul1ks Ulllo thu OI'lI\lldol1\IHI, ,lUHHlul1 I\I\H huul\ gllll1UlU Ihu OI'\I1\ldlll1tlst IIllluU Mil,>' 2()() I, Tlw Pllpul'wllrk l\'ul1\ MI', Wuluh 'H II1Hlin\l\uu WIIH H\lbl1\l\\Pllllt thll\ \Imu by PI', DuIVUY'S Ot'lluu AHHIHlllnllllll\l\lu, Hhu hilS Illlhnnud 11\1.1 1l1l1l1l1l\UI'IllIH'IlUUl1l1luns Ihlll nil plIYl1\ul\lH hllVu huull I'UUUIVUII fl'lllll MI', Wulllh'H IIlHIII'IllluU UI' MI', Wuluh, MI', Wulu\1 IHIH buul\ I1wlu IIWllrU nfhlH rUHpullHlhlll\y hy Tn\ld MIlIII, f)lll1\uHllu ltull1llol\Hll\lld 10 thlH dl\\U hllH I\\lIud In ulll1\ply with III1Y l'u1llluHtH ulll1uomll1g lhu dOI\IIIIIIlSI\I'I\IlUU, tvll', Wuluh IIl\ugoll\y I'ullulvud IhuHU l'ullnh\ll'IIuI1\0111 Iill'lnH hlluk111 ,hllW of200 I, I hl\Vu tho pllllll1\l\l'KUII ul1vulupu IhnlwlIH Hunl l)'ul1\ I'll AHHll\.lhltuH Iii hlH nddl'uSH, thUHU limns WUI'U I'uulllvud viII JUIIHIOII I1I\Z-:l4.nz, Wh~ MI', Wuloh hu\d 01110 thu Ibl'l1lH Ibr Ihll\ UII1\! pUl'lmllll\ll\knllWI\ 10 11\1.1, 'I'hll dUIIIll1 l\J\'\n~ WOI'U l\ll'l1ud llver tll 1301\1111.1 III DI', PL,lwuy'H nrnou, llol1nlu hllH Inlhnnud l1\U,s\w s\lhl1\l\lcd Ih\.ll1\ Ihr rpll1\h\ll'~ull1ul1t hlluk In Apl'l\l1nd, IHIH "ut 1'l1Oolvud IInythln!! 1\'1111\ Ml', Wuluh, 1 ullllud 1'I11\HHuolllloH IInd thuy Il1lilnnull \111.1 lhlll NIl', W.~luh'H Ins,IIt'l\l100 pllYH $?'OOO,OO IqWllrdH hI'lIUIIH, IIl1d lIu\.lol'lll,\!j to 1l0rrullpOndol1uu I hllVu "'",, Welch hllH rcuul,vulllln Inllllllrulnllllll'HUl1\clllol' $1511,011111111 nnuu Iho HillIS IIro "CUUIVllll he will hU,I'ulmhlll'HulllluullI'IIlIlt\ly, NumlluHH 10 HIIY, JUHslolllH IIOW In WI' HOUllll\1 YOIII' nl' ',' nl'\hodonUulI IIwlllo pllymolltH fl'iim MI', Woluh 01' hlH IIIH\lrUr hl\Vu hoonlhrwlIl'llcd 10 Iho Orlhorlpl1UIIl. YIlII Ulll1l'uuulvu II uoPY l1t'1h\.llll'lglnlll fOl'm \i'ol1\ Mr, Woluh'H omployo\', plullllo ulIlllhu luluphol1u IIl1mhul' IIl1d IIHk tn ~pulIk with Nl\l1lu Sill1l1WI1H 111 tho hCllol1t~ doplll'lInunl, IIhu hllH 1I!!l'cod 10 uOllpul'I\lo with ""y 1I110l'l1uy lIl1d ShU,IIIHo HtlllQ(1 Ihlll shu .wllllll1t uoVUI' lip Ihl' lIny omplnYuu, II hllH 1.1011\1.1 III I1\Y lI\lulI\lOI1 viII Iho uhlldl'on Ihlll Mr, Woloh drlnkllllluohullu huvurllguH In Ihu prcHo"uo of' tho uhlldrulI d\lrhw hlH wO\.lkly vlllltH, Thu Hlt\lllllnl1lH Iho" Ullll1pllllllllud mlll'O Hnwhul1 ho plllCOII thum 11110 hlH vohl\.llu Ibl' Ihul'ullll'lI lrlp homu, His vuhlu\o III this .. UIIHU IH \lHlll\lIy lhc HI AIIsOulnlu'H Cl1\llpllny vuhlulc, PlunHu loll him thllt II\\Jl1l1nno111 ' huglnH with thu 111'~1 drink IIl1d 10 I'ulblln fl'lll1\ drlllklng whllu dlvlllg (1I1d UHI\uollllly whl\o uxul'olHhlll hlH I'lghtH In vlllltlltlnll with hlH lihl\dl'un 01' risk lhu uhlll\c\lof InH 11!!lho rlghlH lIucol'dod him, ' II , " .. " " f. , Tlwl'o 111'0 1\II111Y 11l1l1'0 ISS\IIIII, 111111 '1I11l1\ll'olls Y\lIII'SI \, Cl1l\olll'11hw Ihlllll'l\hllltl\l1\ .., tv\1', Wol\lh h,I\S 1111111011 \11I1I1l \l1~1I1' \\1 1110 his poslllnn \lll PIIl'unllnu ,.. II'0uull'Illlllll ull1l1l1 fl'llll1 hlll1 SIlI'IlI'llI w\loks iiiJn ill whluh hU nlillhwdhlH l'\lspnl1HlhllllY Ill'holnu II pIlI'O"\, l\u\lI1I'1I1I1U III hlin,IiIH I'IlHpl1nlllhlllllllii IIl'ul'ln 11I'n\'hlu 1l1~llIullllnlll"\I\IIuul 111\11 plIyhm Ilhlhlllnllpnl'I", (1'1\1111111 nll(UI Iliol\ll'llI 111uIII\lIII hl~I"'lInllU) I Olin 11I\11 will dn snll'll\l\lUIlIIIII'Y 111111101' nuudud pl'\ll'lt!u >,0\111 ullpy nl'lh,u 1l11111111\1I IlwlIUPI'Ouuudlnull III'U 11t1!ll1lud, Thul'u 1\I'IlllHIIlY I11IlI'U 1'0l\HoIIH why I dU\llllurl III ulII\bullh\lll\lIlPPllll1ll1wntll Ihl' t1w ol'l\l\IlIIIIlI\H, SIIII(ly I'l'olll \)1', Shlu\'ohlllornuu 1I11llulI Ihlll t1Wl'u ill'Oll1l\lIy 1'111\110111'0 ponplu \IOII! 111U1'u" 1I11\11hl\l'lI why II'SIlIl Illrnullll tll !lot IIppllll1ll11\lI1!II, PIC! 1 111101111 Ihl' MI', Woluh 10 !lIlIIH'OII!lh wl\h hlul)lIrt llrthullvl\lllIlllol1, nn 1 11111 111l1, My IInl)' 1I11uIlI WI\H fIll' MI', W\llllh III !lul uUlIllHullnllllfl I'ICHIOI), I hllvu "PilI lip With", "UI1IUl'll\lllolI" 1\1111 "lllIOl'lIlut!" MI', Wolol"lIllllllull 1\11' 11101'0 Ilmllll yul\I'S, I hllVOpll1 lip wltlUho \l11101InnlllllhIlHOIlI1(1 OOllHlll111 Illl'll1unll\'lIl11 hllll 1'1,11 lhulIU,llhlldl'ul1 1\l11!l01l011!l1i, ,luIlHlun, 1\1111 1IIIIIollIIl'Pl'IHII1uly HO III IhlH wholOI'\l\ISOI1 Ihlll OIlUU \H olll'l'l'l1lly bulbl'o t1w Omll'ls, shu hllll huul1 Nil', Wulllh 'H IIlHll'\11110111 nl'lIllo Ibl' YOIII'II, ovon prior !ntho dlvoruu, , ~Iw hllll boonlnvolvud In thllll11l1ttol' 11'0111 III1Y nl1u, Pluuso l'ul'oI' \plho dulo \hlllnltll1l ulHH'guH woru llIud- ,IUIIIIIIlII Willi with hll11 onlhllt dny, Whon llluy pr\ol' 10 tho (lI\'ol'ou, 1'111 Hllylng "III1Y tlmo wu 11'01,11<1 hllVU un lll'!lll111 011 t ,lorry WIllII(1 IISO JOlllllolI" .Ihl' UIlIlIll/1\0, 1-lolI'ollld tulI hur "1110\1I'~ 10llvlng IIl1d IIho wnlllt!ool11u to wlwru UVOI' 1 \VIIS bllWllllg WI' QYUS 0111", Tho wuuk prior to MI', Wuloh'lIlollvll1g 0111' hOl11o Ihl' gl'001101' pl1Htlll'oH 01' wllllt III 10llslIIppuIIl'od 10 bo !.l1'UUI1Ul' pIlIlIIlI'US, MI', Woloh on AHgUHt 14, 199R gl'l\hbod .IuHlllulI ' by Ihu blluk of tho l1uok, und IIhovod IWI' dowl1to thu Ilonl' to look III pnponrn kornulH II'lth hol' nUllulll1 WO\lldho 01'01' 1I(lInl\ toslluh ounrhlct, I'd III\Y pl'llhllbly nol, How IIhOll1 tho i1U\ or JIIly 2()OI, ,lorry told JUlIlIlOIl hu WUIl plokln!.l hul' lip III HiOO III Ihu 1I1l1rnlng 1I11<1 Hho 1111\ thul'o Ibl' 1\11 hOlll' IIl1ll II ,hlllf1I'1I11ln!l for hol' Iiltl\Ol' tn oomo, HO'l1ovul' IIhowod IInd IIhu Wllllonu 1'0l'Y IIl1d IInd'I\l1huPPY uhlld, I hopud hiring 111\ IIllornoy 11'0111<1 flnully II10p him Ii'om pUl'potlllltlll!l hOUIIlIl\nd/OI' \lnlhllndod G01l\pllllnlll to chlldl'ol1l1l1d YOlllh 01' tho WOIII Shol'u Ruglonnl P\lllllO IJopUl'lmol\l ol'lIl1o[\od ohlld Ub\lHU 1I!lI1II1HI n1O, MI', Wuloh OOllll))onlud lit thu Clllltndy Ilul\rln!l with Mil, Ol'uovy, thl\l hu II'IIS uonco\'llod ubll\lt .1011111011 IInd ho woul<l go to 1\01' uppnlnlllHll1lH wllh 01', Slobol'to 110Ip hill ohlld, Nil', , Wuloh hilt! 3 01' 4 OhUlluUII (llold hlmll'holl hOI' nu;<t IIppoll1\n1011t WIIH lit lhu hUllrlng IInd thonllonl2 111' 3 11\01'0 dll(ulIl'lu ol11ullllhu Inllt OliO bolllg April I, 2002, MI', Wuloh ollllud tho Dr'll, ot'lloo I\hOlll 1111 h01l1' bothro hol' IIppolnl11\OllllhllU und ounoollod his IIppOllrlllluo, Dr, Slohol' oollod mu to I\dl'llIU of\hu ouncollntlnn ulld told mo "ho hud somulhlng goh111 Oil III \Vol'k", MI', Wolohlohl Mil, OI'OUI'Y, "Thu ohlldron I\oodoll(o piny sports" und thll! ho "lI'ollld do ul'ol'ylhlllg pllslllblotlllluulhnl Mlchnol got to his Il1door llllUUUI' gll1l\OS", WolI hu only hud,lo luko him III (Wll glllllOH unrllhu( novol' I\UPPUIlUlI, " " Tl1ol'\l Wl\~ II \l1l11111\l1 II1I1I~ ~\ll1uIIIII\llill' 11\11 111'~IIlIlU IInll IlllTlll'llll III hulp, 11!III!lI'l'll\I, 111111 IlwIII'\1 lIo\1111l1J 1111l1'1l 1'nln111111\, l1u \JIIIlllwlI 111\ll'u WIIH II hlnllllllY plln~ III Ihu \lhlll'ol1.1I1~\11 l~w hlllPkH,lhlll1 ,,;l1pl'o IlIv\llill' 111~ n\llllwl', 1111111 1111\ Ihll1\ MhJhll\lllln 8\1l1lh\y 1l11111\ \Vlwlllw MIII'I1H 11\l11101\'IlI11I)I\II'~ vllilultlpl1lhllllw 1111~HCII I1IH 111l11111, Poor Mlol\lI\ll.lw IIlVUH [:lpouul' IIH dllll~ ,1\l~HllllI IIIHIl, ' Tlw lIoxl !lIll1\u wn~oll tvllIl'oh\l, 2()02 - tvll', Wlllul1 WIIH Illlullllll1u II Pllrty, I w\lnl 10 1110 ,. H\lhpIll Ip Hull hl~ .\IIHliJlIl1111IllHI \11 HUll II' Mlchllpl WIIH \1101'u 1111\1 tvllllhllllll10lllly Unlln lW In II lln111111l1\\1 no \I1I1I1Kfi In I1lfilll\1141', IIIH 1\\111111 cllll1plllll1lH III 111011\I~\IlL\y IHH\I\l \l\l\\I,IlI'll\1 1I1'0\11ld hlull 1ll'llHH 11\\11 dllU IlI'lIP III tlw hlllll,yl\l'd (011 plllllHU,III II1\l'l1\hl\lIll pl'wlnlul"l) l'lll ' nlHo oOl11plnh1\lL\ 1I\!\l111 IlIrlY 1II\II1111'y 111\11 HIl111OIhll11111IHll, 1'10 1111~ Hl\Ilwn 1110 Ihlll Iw IH 111l\ II I'IlHpnl1Hlhlu pOI'~(Jn Ill' lillhur, Illl pluk~ IIml OhIlIlHU~ whull ho Wllnlfi In HUU hlft kldH ql' 1I11\lml Ihuw \lXII'l\ o\lrr\o\lllll' 1I0\lvl\lu~, PIUI\~U oXlllllln In 11\0 nI' IIIlvlfiU Ill' t\1\l portloll \'If \llw IhllllllluWH II pl1rolll to 01\11 ulT ~Iok I'l'nl\\ \ho I' 1'0~pul1slhllltluH Ill' pl\l'olillllU, I ROOm tn 11I1V\l mIHHU\1 \hl\l pOl'\llln ol'lho onHlody pl'nouodlnllH," .,., MI",Wolol1l1l1s II IlI'IIVU oonuul'l\ wltl1mu s\lh\l\lnllng OvoIIIH rlmllllll1lH pOl'luI\~ 01' vlsl\lIt\nll, 111m 1\l\pPY \(l \011 yO\l \11111 111110 l'ulhlw \l1l\llJd hlH HU(IHUIl with 2 It13I'H IInd I'm oostntlo \II t\w prnuruHH ho hilS IwonllHlklnu, ElIuh yollr ho gIJI~ bolt~r (,"d hUI!UI', Mluhllol IH now \l, YOI1I'H old I1nd hns boon pll1ylnll hllR\lhlllllbr 4 YOlll'S, t\w IIIHt lWo wllh Ihu Sl1mO cOlloh. ,100 \)okllnHkl Olin ho rUllohl:r1 111717.761.H640 I1nd ho wO\1111 ho r1ulluhtud In toll Yo\llIhu\l1 Iho nllmbur or t\mos Mlohllul's rllld hllH ovcr brought him 10 hllHolllI1l Pl'\lut\oo Ill' II gllnllllbl',lhl\\ I\\lIltol', Mllyholllslolld ol'\lllll1\lnlllllo Ibl' MI,\Jhllclnol unlng with hlH rliirl, mllyho Mr, Woluh o\lllhl lo,illst Ihlllk \lhOII\ tho mUHHllllO ho iH oOllvoylllg to his ohlldl'OIl, Lul'H st\lI'l In April - April 511\ - Mlchllul hurl pnwt\uo - r11;dllldn't Iliku 1;111\, " April 91 \ - Mluhllul rlldn 'I W.l\l\l 10 UO '" ho Slllrl \III hl~ II1Id OIlI'UH IIhlllllls ,losHI~", April I)lh WIIH ll\lppOHO to ho \III ovol'l1lght visit \lnd thoy \VOl'o h\lok III 7145, . ,'.. ' April I Olh - Mloh1101 WIIS nli'lllrl \0 go (ho rll\ln'l SIlY why). Aprll17lh. MlchllolllHkod his dndll'ho un\llrl \\lko hllll'\() his pl'lIo\luu 011 flr\dny Iho 191h_ his d\ld s\\II1 nn, . . April \ 9\' . M luhllol dldll'l gll nllt 10 lhu vlIn whon ,lorry W(IH Ihol'o iil <\ :00 - ,I ol1'y un\ lod MluhllOll111 his uoll phono lIskod \llll1why Mlohllol sllld lhlll hOOllllSO ho Uurry) wO\lldn't \l1ko hllll to his pl'lIo\luo, My lIIolhor IlId hOlll' Mluhllulllsk Irho oOllld plok him np lIl\ol' p\'lIOllou 111111 hu IIIllH\ hllVu snld ni" ' MllY 4111 - Mlchll~\lIl\ill'IIlUI \0 Ull 10 hlH unll1uI11l Sl\tlll'dny hOC(\IIHU TlImmy didn't utit unollgh sluop, I,' " " ,," " Mn~ BIIi, lIPPlIl'Ul1l1Y (lhls Is l\uu\Jrdll1lllP Mluhl\oll Mlchl\ul WUl11 llli\sl\lu IOl\sk hlH \111\111' Iw ull\11t1 IHku hlllllP hIs \ll\Su\11\1\ UI\11I0,!PITY sl\ill nil 111111 MI\lllIIul IWIII hlluk 1I1sltlulhu I\lHlso, ,lul'l'Y loll, 111\111 'I gpllllo Iho IWIIS\! (lhls Is 01'11111111111 's) 10 suo 11'1\111 Mlohllol Wils .. lllllllll --Iw .Il1sllul\l (ISII'llhlll ulll1shlpl'uill\\1\1IHlllI1I1Wl1t'/'l'I) 1\ 1\11 h~ thu wn~, MII~ HIli WI\S Ihu I1l'sl Ilnw MI\lhnol hil Ilw hl\l\ "-111\01' 4 YUill's IlI'WI\IIII1U -l1l1l1l1y ho hll tho hlllllllllllll Thu cpl\oh 01l1l1U 1'\1111111111 \1111"" I 0\1\11\11\ '1lOlllI'hll WIIS 1I11ll'P \lxullull Mlphllul, Ihu C\lllPh lll' II1I , Mluhllulmlsso\l MIIY 14111's 111l1l1U, MI1Y ISII"~ pnwlloo WIISII spouill\ p\'llp\lpp III Ilw lOll Hll1k PI1 13oslul' AvullllP, Tho CPII\lh 'WIIS IlIklnll Ilw 10111\1 III Iho hllllll\lI Ollllos, ivlluhlWI \VIIS llxuilo\I, ho IlHkod his 1111\1 III IlIko hll11l1l\1l .lorry IIUl'uol1. Mlol1l\pl gol In \III! VI\I1, Wlwl1 Mluhl1111 1l1l1\1\l homu, IIIHI,od hll11 l\Ilw his pl'lIollou WI1S IIml hplh ,Joss III\\IMluhllOI Slllrll)II'111IIll his wuoklYYlIl'\I Wlll'k III \Ill, Mlllhllollll\ll\'l go\ 101lO, (Hu 110\11\1 his uhll\l, hu slIld ho IVIIS lloll1!! lolllku hll11l1ml Iholl'(\I\lI\'ll\l\low thl'llllghll Mil)' 17111 -, Mloh1101 1'01\lso\l III gOIl!jIIIIl"" he hud II w'llndlll't\11 11I110llwI\ull\l\IIy lIPI 101lo tOlhu Blku 1~ll(loo llIld MAY Filii' 10 SPO his uIIlSSI\1\lIoS, Mny n,"I... Mluhllul l'ul\lsod IOlll;lIglllll'-llc hlllhu 1lII\lllgllll\"" (Wlllch OIIlPI:PS) Ml1y 27111 .. MUll\lll'l\l1 Pny.. Oops"" llllPSS J CITY dllll\'l WIlI1I to \nkp \ho kills Ihr hulldny MIlY 31 st .. tvlluhnull'ol\lsud III !!Ollglllll, J\lI1~ HIli -. Nnl his wuul<oIHI, hilt 1'1 thnu tvIlohllul ullllghl Ihu bl\II111 HPonnd hllsu !PlIU! thu Oppul10l\t lllltllllll WOWI Suu whllllllwllIl,LOOK III whlll hc's mlHHlngllllllll1 ' ~,\lIlull ,II nl\d 12'11 - .Il1nu 11:- .Iurry ulIl\oll olT slok nl' 1\01\III\ly 10:3211111 TIIll\ITIY ul;1I011 n\O III WORKI And lold ll\U hu wns 11\ Iho hosplln\ (I kilOII' ho wns Illsuhll\'!lPI\ SiOO lI\1\t , I\I1Iht), .1\11\0 12'11.. hudldl1'! Hhllw Ill' 01111, '" ' .I\1l1u 14111 -I,.nst gnmu. .IurlY IIUl\lI\\ly plpkod kldH lip nil .1111\0 15111 11111 :00 - 1\l;'WIVOllld hu hllVo l\ol1lllllly dOllu Ihll\'1 ~liuhllul hilS sho\vl\ l'uspunHlbllllY towllnls his IUIIll\ll\nluH IIlld his Ipllll1, Whnlls .Iurry l'ull1ylng In Mlulll\lll whUi\ huduusn't tllkp hlm'l Whn! Vllluus Is hu HhllWIIl!J Mlohllol'l I " hllvu told Nllohllul ho hllH III lull his dlld IlIllI WO hllVo rllsulIssu!l this Issl\o ml\n~!Ill\os, I, 'i I " , I', (b~ 00 I , i . L ........ ~.:tl.,JgD '..15 pH. Oil. . mY;~, ....'qhdwbel"i,,-. ,_,....1" 'I' """"" J:,-t:r"'u,n(t;(~,~raun'0'~?dv.vIPe.., It' C1JUCC-tj, '.. ""....; I'~'::::: !6.~.~~~~::!I:::~:::~~~::(tl.V:,:=::...., .. 'L_._.,_.__.... ~,ro~""~a:thc~{jtrt':.t.o-/:upi~.,,,bl.-. J~;I"""""-""'" .,..,.: ,---- - - ~u 2:~_.J2Lj],d]'J,~{"ut=Q.&l,_,_t.-':'_"_'h_"""""__~'" .,;,__.....".._..,",.._.._...,j : =-- ~~ ";- ~r;&L-{~Qjj li-t$~r:l2[49:::= :1 . . -- -_.~, .' _.JW-C ~{!'t:Lrd!l.~~" ,- "" J~, ,e-""j'---"'--,_J , _..--'-' w_ . . -t-loaJ--tqi~_~._~.-/L~_~_~___"--1 " - '~J )~"" --. 11 ---'" , i-""'~ , ...,., ----(.) ---, ..o( ~V1~~-~~.I:l~ . L)~" " " - ... --uLJ11-;jCL.. W '-/tA.!-.-,,- "-.0:-, , " ~_..,,"_..~.,_; .J.::. he....:.du.d" ;. ~.._~ "o..p--" ' "_"'__, i, ',~ ,..--. " -_. - re==--- --,,- ~me "-"-l.r~~ F-~~~=~:; . !L.. ~r/lr~ '". , --S/~~, -.t. --'m-- C_, bQ- __~f;t'~o:~'==-~~ ~_J20-. _._~"'=~JY----_ ~ ! -..-...- -.--"----- ' '"--0"""-- I ., .~ ) .-..-----..- I ~..---_.--~-.~._-..-~----............,-.---------'-------~.--.........--.--1--- , . ..~._.._._....._-....--:-:- -------..-..-...-~, ~.~...;..:....._.._..._._~--_.........~-~..---.~-.~...~.~-.-.......------..-.~--_..._.~._.".,....~-- . ,- """":'1"........, --"'-'-"'---,,,,-- - --.......--.------.-- ._,.j.-- I ....:.:..- \' , "~I' " "...._'!"'.~.tf:~.' " " " ,. r"" _ " " '" "," L,'.":." '" ,'.Mdfcf\,'6k5.), O',b()c~,6:~i()ojer.ojrl ~ , " " "..".".., " ,'..',' .', ,JLii~::) '''::~l(~ ...{(t.i.yr-rbrr)"'..':): I.B' -1-0 " " ' ,,:-r:.\~'?) (," , VOL)" ,I:.:) e+'I't~;r\; , hope, -!-hq,-l ' ~IO U C. , Lb. -I,..., .t~r' I'U I ('\e"') , l'')V'" 1.\0 '-"1/ I J' :.:t',::'(' P \ k;';, (..", .", . \. :-.\., .1.' l.., .....~ .. 1 .. }. ,;\t: ' ~ ,7"" - r{....... ~.J\.. 1-'/'\1'/ C' "'II' ...J--'] (')ft"~ 11...;c;.. lr 1.)1f"" Ill. ';..':, "") , . '" " ..,,,. ~)I-, "/"1' f}:)III)(~'/:If.I"",r\;' "~C('t-;;(';""l"J'lf:~r"~' ':/l:(~~" .I;~ . .... .. .1i1r~:~YDl'frd-,fl0 hZS~!~~~;(~~)~'Y'~')I .. ,;){)(jC(CI)2(.)pCI',PI,CAY."..I L"I.'1,CtJ ...\,&J'-' ,~ , ' ~: . , , ". LUI n, beU:.JCTJ",,:,e ...7..". r"I'lCt()) IIr;;flc'''/'('} L~(~:' , \") ") .1[')\ ') C I ,"'t. ,.. "\ I' \ ", .;Z {"'" II C\ (' 'I"\h " /.. ",..r".,} .t, )",,::;;,..':'11 I Ie.',; , . " '_\' '.,.l.' " ,. VClrrJ,(~C~}. , ,. .,.,:..,:.,., "". ::.."\:::',jJ.e"]:.ooh::'yil:y.:..b.Qc.bpoc~.;:-i::. .~:,:;.:li7d.-lj::.\ rc:.JI:,g F'1" ~_'...m"'" ,jL:J::,.()U~+Slcl.e.uu" "d "'.. 'd"....' "." '" ., , ,"," ". "'" " , " ...~....: ..., ., ,,,:::]J.e.,~ cell 16::1. .. {} )(:j.. ,CL 'C1U5tYLV.s"z).. ,'.',,'... .., . ",.. (~nd" ldU6+ Y.):>I"/'CTY". . ,,',., . " .".."..,",.."..,"..."[ai.....ry,,+bi;s'. .Lljt:er~)I'x? ~d'r~,cV)() LA'''CCfr'') .. .. .... ' .,... i.n..-jYY\l face: '[1']0 br:(,~O.rtl (,.1)0"::, 1",n~i""1 y , ' ..' I.~u.. j~o. .c\e'C1C1-\'-\'l.t' , Ckx}'::: .'1 r)"1 (,"''C:'2/\' J"+ ,. '" , ..' .., .. <;:t'5' ,d,{5{~u~'~:::::LlI '/C.J. k,le ,(i\)~~ ':'11' / II I.(j "I'D ' t~ l-\~..nrl f 'iu 1+ I") Pl", , " " ,'. (fdci-l-hCIOG?j,r').' '~. ',\ "/';i" " ' , ' .'. ",.... , ".\~( , " St)e ~/-e115U')c~" che Cbesr,/~I-, "'1 ' ~_~C\Cl:-\~ ,~'Y1~, : +0" ~ee ,gJ~ ,.0AQ\n " .."'~,(."....lI.qCIO }rVC,-\'JVI f/) UJr4acl,T -r.ce ,eo (oVt?C'/\ (~~)\-) , i \ '.! \ III ,I I I' , "'11' " \ if I , , " ,,'1,. \'.', ., J,\,l"l,i~'(~.J .', "I 1) II .. . ,,' I)' " !~. i :1 - . 'r J I f1or~lcI ~" Woldt II': ,,', ; , ", ' ' , ,:',' . ~:V:\l'~1 P:iii'-'W- ~~~~roi1tml'1"~1i:n.~'Pn7'i~r71'P,;~_~.lm:,~~r~~rr' ':n~~\'\n~'0,"~:~~!,"':';~:",:,;':~'- '_0\'1'-:lr!.,~p\!,Y.'l:\r~;:J~.?~.~~\1Irl;fj~_1~lj~m,Tt1{onJ!J\~ . ..J....'Jl':JJU J.;i,t~.~\'J..~h.~:'i,_,,<..~J\.,i;'/.t:JI,.~,,~,,:.'I.i~'J..".._'~I"I""",_'I,,"":'-I,._-i:\,~., '". ,_ ,.-, "c'"" - ,-.-.,' q._ll.'./...:.tJ.Ji ,;. ;'71,~_"j:.'J'.'..,..~\. ~,..I.1I.,I~J1Ti!j.;j:,H , G 70 3? II~mpflllh,II'IIIU\l1ntl (:olilllll)liI, "^ 17517. P!lolIll 717~?1l5"5()li() Ill' 7\ 7 VB 3'j1l5 JIll\lI i~.I, ;!()03 D'I<lrJlIdfN HilS;;, On !\1I91/SI :~ 2002, tr,mp',lrlllY cLlstorly nf 11\'1 ,;I.1I1glll111' J'~~Sl<:lI .II) W.!II;h, WlI" ;IWi\I'r1orl 10111(1,1',1 'lOlli' C1l1l1t I'l)om, ~;Iii':n that ,jilY, ';Olll'! IlnVeSUn'; 1111'/1) I1cc'IIT;)d with rO~Ji\r,h to 1\11 tlll'e.!! .,1' 1\1'1 cllllclri!lI, I am writlllO to '1IHI, III hopn5 lhill 'IOU ,;;," do ~'I.\li\l!thll"] I.) ,top th 'lI II , I hnvn not ",,!!II my i,nll'; 1vI1\:IIillll ]f!ITY Woldl, (1I1d '\',Iylnr !\II(!II W,'ic:h ~11I<:aAplll ;'0 21)11': I'IIN to tll.,t dnl.), th,', 11I)'1s',wnllidillit'l I,) I1F! Will ';\i"II"'iI'ill~ nt ,"",,,L ['i,dl \11111l 0(.111'1 sch.jrll,I,?d vlsII.Uloll'>, I :\Illvnd .,t 1:11\\ '\PlloIIHlirl ol,'lc.." ,"I thl! ':\1)\1011'11.1':<1 111l11l, 0,,1'110 il.! told by thdr 'JI,llldpill'i!IHj ,llldrl'lYc1rr, O:l)t,)1 Vior!;er;,' unt, r.1I<i IJO'l$ \\>,,[I,! lIot t1Hil'(1 "1111 WOllld Ilot ill! th,)I'I1. 111111 IIl)nble! to contin:I Iny "on~ b'/ \81';1"1PI1I1. L'lr1e R.!qnl!l1a hlll1g!; '1(1 ;1" !;oon ,I'; "hn hoarr, 111'1 voiCe, ~;IW'90l).',i out of hur wny to 11l.,k,) "111'0 lh.) 1,;(1'1" nfl' not ilvnllillJl\) to 111\1, for Vlsltntioll, 01 illlY (OIl\IlHlIllcnllol1, for tl1<,t matllll', Thllh'1ll1lJ dOll5 110t Il'WO ,,11 an5Wllrll\() dllylC\l, rllsnlctlllO ,111(: frollllt!iIVII\lJ ,lI1lUII,\!Jl),fol thol1l, 1III\lllmlllld frolll <:10111<:1 tl) t111J1r ruWloll\;'l 'II pilI' tho .. ml\llnill cw;tmly ol'rfOI' II111ffoc:t frul11 NOVHI11b.". ,[ 1')<)11, Thh; clI~tody order I~ 110t IIl'l only ,Co\lrt '((I'd.) I' thflt Lorio RIHlllt1l1ol I,s vlolnllllO, ~;hl! ha5 Ilot ,nltlHllptllCl to '11511 1)1' lllolklll11wl1 comile! with 0\11' d'lwlhlOrlo55IQ, \111(01\\10\15172002, Coupll!(lwlth tho fnetth.:!l )I15511:a ,.\ll/lot Illll her IHothel'1 ':1I1d LOll,;',,; I'nlll;,d to 'Jlve Illll lid perlol1al 1.1,,1011(1111<:11, h,\\ C,HI\od h'H,' ,[lIHnl iHnut!ol1nf dlstrol", ' I hlllllblY admit, tllilt lillllllIl<lblo to ,lfford 10 ''<ltall1 lhl) ~,.;,vlr.Q5 of C\I1 <<ltol'l1'l'l ilt this 1111lll, Th'HllrOl'o, I fl!ltthi\l thllli)s WiHIl hopelol,\, ,\l1d IWllllld b'J [.uilJ'Jctlld tll this crlllllty, with 110 , raClnlr~a, HO\NoVHr, I WlI!; glval1 tl'lI! oldvh:e In tlY '\Nrltln9 'lOll .] IIlIIei', If I had known It could be dOIli!, \)0 a,;sl,lrlldtl1at I wnllld h1l"') wl'lnol1 this lotIOI' mllr;h,~ol)llor, ,. YOUll\ollor, YOlll\'lVO biHlI1 the soaled JllrI(ji! flollltho bu'011111111i), 5t'''IIIlIJ with tl1l1 dlvlll'ca, thro\loh cur.tody hunrlngfi. YtlU hrlve !;ol11a oxporlenco with tho partlor. Involved. Pla~fil! dOIl'( think I 1\111 uylno to wnsto '1lJl1rtlml! wltll thl,\, I knoW '10\1 nre i\ IlllS'! I11nn nndl olpproclnla your cOl1sldorlno nl'l clrctll1l!ili\I1CI15. 1111155111'1 son!; terribly, alld I know th,lt tiNY have to be wlvulsoly <lffucted by I1'ot b'lllli) 'I pMt ,)f thulr Ilv\)!; cll1ymorrl, I fea'r peplh'"11"t <,lIol1atlol) of tlH!h;';lfFrlct.llln~, I alSl1 fiiilr lIlat: they might 111! IIndnr t1w raise h"presslon that my nol ~~llln!J tl1om, or contnctll1g thQIl1I~ by 111'1 r.liolc:o, Notl1lmJ c:orlit! b\) fl'lnllllr from tho t 1'\ It 11. I WaS si\ddal1ad Whol1 I could 0,,1'1 soil illY chlldrol1 Oil Wl!'!1(t1l1d5, to Ilt!I]ln with, whllo I WilS 11'11\1\1111 tho homq with thom, I was their ptlllli'UY cilroi)lvc!I, Now I ,1111 ptlShlld completelY out of Iholr IIvos, 1111 expnrlonca ~ollld ,hn wnr"'!, Ih:IV(! CI1GIOSlld Gopln" of lhn Cl'fitocly onlerfi, , , , ~ll1coroly, I), u,.J. I ' ' ,,? . . " (/.-?b -(. .v (l v )'1M"~ II ;t~n JeffY Wlllch Jr, " 1:11<:,. ,~ , . \ t , (\Tlw P\lI\J11\hH\\'~ pOHlIlon'n1\ \lIlHHl\\Y IH IIH 1(IIlIlWHl R\l\ln\\IICh\ll\ Or(\\lr, 7, 1'l\l\lIIIl)\, H\\PIl\'II\\l \l0ll\1H\l1 \n \'\lp\'\lHCI\\ chllll(\,cn)1 Ncll\w\' pnr\y \,C(l\I\lHlcl\, ft; NC\lI\ I'm IlI\lcpcl\lI\\1\\ pHY\lI1Plol!l\lnl cvn\lln\lon n\' cn\1I1H\lllnm 1'l\l11\l \,CI\\1CH\C\llIn(\ \1\\1 CUI\\lIIlI\\PI' l\nO~ nnl \lcll\lVc nllY IH I\\lCOHH1II'Y' " 'I '1 , \ I '\ ( Plllot O\l\n\1o\, ~8, 1998 ~\'~t~() , Is ,till, \ '{i;l,L -- ~ oIHICll", n11l11!~ " " C\IHIo\ly Cn1\ollln\p\, " I' I' I, " " I'" 'i Ii; ,\\ ',1 I, '" .,' i';, ", , , " , " , " 1,1 q, '\ I; ,i,', ~': I " ' " , " 'I, '1' , PUll I' J\III~\lllu~~ I))"~ 1.,)1"/,(11 I' 11'1 I' "1\ I . I,' " I ( " r" Wllh 1111 !hlll I'USjlUllllll111 synrlhlBynll1l I'IlSpnllSlll1l MI'. \Vokll's lolllll' (II!I :lij.lllllP 0.1, (\lnpy III111Uhu\1l , " " T\I'n \Vooks IInlll' )/nill!I'I\l1lvll IlIlHlIHl)' nl'.lllssIu111n MI'. \Wkll Iw slnplw!11I1l Iwuk\'IIIY I'lsilllllnl\ 11'111.\ IlIu hn)'s, This WlIs Illlllld 1I1'0\111\llho IIIIII\U limo MI', Woleh 10sI hlH .Ioh Inn, Ilu's h!I\1 sU\'IJl'nl .Inh IlIH\I1IWS Ihls pllal YOIII', SIII11I11\>1' ylailllliol1; HII1\l1l 11.11)1) hilS hoolll1lll)'h\, nlW \l'l'Oli 11I1\l1l YOIII', IlIls YOIII' 11111W \l'IIS 1'0!llIllsllld. '., RII1\l\l20flO - Nnlllll1l'llw t11'\lSllIII'O!llfnlldIlYs. Tho hnYH \l'Ol'uulllshud,llIuy Hnllllho,wholollllllllhls WIIS l!nll1l\ 1111 (Dolo\!ol' thnl/\lI11llstllllnl llvol'Ylllhm \l'IIS Jllssl\lll, ,1\lNSlvn, .Io>>sl,II;llIoy 1'011111011' loulillUs WOI'O pili nalllo, " I, 1'1'101' In Duln\!UI' I), 2flfl I nllil nileI' t\1Il\\11i1 7, 2002 , hlH vlslll1lloll WIIS IIlwIIYs 1111" '11os IIlwIIY>> hllllll 911111111 nlf Thll uhlllll'\ll1, 111I111l'\l\l ol'lh\ll11. sp\llllll1l\uh Ill11u WIIIIIIll! 011 hll11l111\1 Whol1 110 HIli,,!! 111 Sh!IIY, Ihol' wmll\1 uIIIl him, ThOll ho wl1l1l" 101llhol11 ho WIISI1'1 comll1l\, 1I11lY IVOI'O !lIsl1ppull1lilll. , hlll'o I1IlW'1' Inllllhl Ihu chlldnilllu ho "lsl'llNllIlClIllll11lhoh' nUhol', Thu hny~ \Vnl1lln soollloll' nllhol' hilI' \lllll11l1llllllk\l'hlm POIllO, I elll1l1ol SIIY lho SIII110 OUPl'tosy hl1S hool1 OXIOl\lIlld 10ll'nnls 1\1Il 01' illY hllshnlld, Ynll sl1ld dlll'lIIg Ihu honl'h\lI Ihlll MI', Wolch IHIlll1lllhllllllll1l1W. Thnlls 1101 whlll Ih!!y hnl'll hooll tollln!! Josslcn. TumlHY 0\'011 HllIt\!d III nllU or hol' OI1\IIIlH 10 I1W Ihnl YIlII 1'0luI'I'od In m.o ns "II 11\11 \lllso, II shollld nlsll ho Ilnlod Ih111 April Is Iho sll1llof hnsohnll fJOII Sl1 1\ , Mlllhllol hns plilY\ld hns\!hllll Ihl' fi\'O Y!lnI'S, ho hns plcndollll'lIh his I'nlhlll' lolnkll him III his !!nI1\OS I1lld pl'llolloos Illl1n nvnll, " SOl11ollmos ho IV(1111d sny YON !lllly tull'lck hlln nlld IIwll l1ollnk\l him, ,MlchllOIIlSOlllollcl Hllllpscl, SIl, this YOI1I' Mlohllol slnl'lclllllkll1ll IHnllol's 11110 his OWIl hllnds; hodcolllod Ihnl ho WOllld 1I0ln hla Ill'nCl!uoWlIl1d 1l!IIHOS with 01' Ivl1hollt hlalhlhol's'pol'lnlssloll, Mlchnel IYollldhlll\l11l my lHothul"H lOUSO, MI', \Yolch no\'Ol' 01,111\0 In Iho duoI' 10 pl\lk him lip, wholl h\l did show ho would WIIU OUIsldo in tho I'nll, ho hnd n coli phollu IIlld ho didll'l ovell 01111. MI'. \Volch hns 1101 scell his SOil pin>' ' hnsllhnlllll nyO yelllH. I dill liNk tho dnycIII'!l If MI', \Voleh hlld enlled 01' showll up Ilwl'll tl\(lY sny " , "Ihuy hnvoll'l aC\l1l him slllcolho olld IlrApl'lI, so thnt mUnllfJ ho dldll'l show lip thol'o. My l11olhcr'H huuso Is ollly nl'OllHd tho col'l1OI' Il'om mille, His nJtlwl' know ho WIIS plnyll\!! hnsohnll, I 1'01\1011\[101' tl'lIchllol,lollln!! mc thnllw dllll\lll his dlllllhll1. 'Bnsohnll onds III .111110, doos lJ\'OI'Y yoill" so whol'\l hns ho hCOII slllco thon? SIl Il'hllt hns ehlllll!cd slnoo MI', \Yelch's 2,1 .hllll' 101101''1 ' ,hlly (i'200~ wnstho Ilrsllll\\O I hnd phollo CIlIlIIICI wilh Mr, \Voleh slnoo ()olnhol' I), 20(H whonl hndlo cnll him In 1'01H11l!1 hi 11\ or his rllspollslhllllles, July S, 200.1 - Mr, Weldl slIWMlehnelnllho LClnoYlle l'ulll, July 6, 2nO~ - Mr. Wolch cllllolI me III hOl\\o lo,soo Ifhu eOllld pick up Iho hoys Oil Thlll'sdny, I\\Y tll'Sll'OllpOIlSO 10 hhl\ WIIIl "Whol'o hllvo you houn", ho sllld "1\1\IIII.I\lsl tbl'gollt ".nlld hUllg up, July 17. 2nO~ ,- VOUI' loltel' 1lIIII'Od Illlho 1\\1111 Th;1I OVUl\lilg J lilld II eOlll'Ol'Rlllil11l with .IosslcII viII Illlul'l1ol JllsIIIIlI tl'llJssngo, Inlll'cod "hilt hlJr dlld IIOllld pick Iho hOYfJ UpOIl FI'IIIII)I, Thill FlldllY, July 19'" MlehllolWllltod Ibr S hOlll's Ihr his dlld nllly ;\ Ii ,. In mll~p n phlll\u clIlIlPll.ln!l him h\l Cllllhlll'l shill\', Mlullllol \,1I11011n)O III WOlk clyllll! unll slllll his . dU,11 II'lIsn't oomllll:l' ' ,llilY ~J, :JOll:\ '. Mr. \\'plch ollllull 10 SUI' II' hu cOlll1! plllk lip Ih\lboYIl 011 Thlll'sdllY, I sllhl no, '1'111'101 wuslnllkln!! IhlW!lld 10 sllnWIIlIIII:l 011 FrhlllY hI' IIlIhll pill' hllll'lhu dllYl'lIlll1 slllllllP YIlII dpn'.lllllIl Whlllllnus Ihlll IIIII'I'IPIIIlI\'IIIi Plckhwlhl'ln lip on 'I'hllrsdllY hl'II111111 dlllll'I l\\ll,lI OhllllOP In !!Iw ' Yllllwhlll Iwuk IWUlllcll Iholll, I suhl Sll hO~~PIIOhlllc{llho phillip clIlI wllh "lIllck mu" ,- I h\lll!lllP, .Il1ly 2fi, :J(l0.1..11\, ullllolllI)ll 11111\\1110 In sCl'lflw clllllII pick lip Iho h\l\'1l ullrllul 11I!llwll. '., .' Jill)' 27. :J00.1 .. Mr, \Vulcl, ollllcd illY I\llhol' nllll HIII\I ho wlllhrhl!l,II101ll hllck Mnlld!lY, Sn h\lro Wlllln, Illnro !lIlIllI'S, Ilrsl ho dll\lHII'( Slllllhulll,thl' IIlDlllhllllllW hl"lI koup Ihomllll,whIlIlIlI'OI, I hllw IIlwnYH h01l1l tho nilI' rl'spnllslhlo Ihl'llw clllhllul\'s OdllC!lllolllllllll11olllclIll\ocllll, Ml',Wolch hllll nllly IlVOI' hl'l'lI tOllllO of.lllHlliol1's dnelol' IIppollllllwlltH (hur Ilrsl 0110) 111111 hlllWIIIWhuII Mlchllol hllllll\hos 1'111111 his Illll'H. III' \VOllllo work 11'11011 Mlcllnol hl\\l his IPIIHlIs 0111. Ilol\lll'ol' slnyol! hOlll\lwl(hi 1\1 olilldroll whl)lIlh\ll' 1\'0l'U oll'1l11hool sick, ho snhllhnl I WlIs Ih\l 0110 wllh 1111 Iho 1'1101111011 \lnw, hI' hl1d 1'1101111011 IllIWlno h\l.lIlHI ehoso In IIHI' II III go hlllllll\g, HI'WI1H 1I1lllho 111'1mnl~' ellrll,pOI'Sl1l1lw \lIIlIIllA 10 bu, Tlil1llnlhrllllllll1l\lI'llIlwlllllhorod Ihl' the li\lXI"oIlHtnclllll . 11l1l1'11111; Mlchllol \lII'IlH 1I1l\llllllglonlllBl'l\l'xt YOIII', ' ('\11101111111\11\ .dlllllttlulo hl'lp nn}' pl'oblul11H Mr, W\lleh hilS with 1110 lIunlhm with Ihl' chlllll'un, '10 un II' SCl'kA l'uwn!!O 1I1ll11'Ol'I'I1Ul'only, Ms, Cil'ul'I'Y (lIw conollll1tl1l'l hll\1 snnw \\'ondl'l'lIll SIlB!!Ollll\1I1A; sho sold 11'0 oOllllllry Cr)l11llllllllcllllnlll'ln 1.11\11111. '1'11111 wl1l'kod thl' sllch II Hhon puril1d wlwlll tblllld 0111 Tnml11Y WlIs (he onl'l'\lSpolldlnu lolhl' I'nHIlIll,1 hnlll'cqllusl\ld Ihllt MI'. Wolell. hnw hor ~top 11111 HlwlllHlsls so Il'uHIIlI'. Tnml\1Y \Vulch IH Iho ohll(II'I'II's slup l\\oll1Pr, she III nOlhh,g " to 1\101 \(11\111 stop"motllol' nlso nlld) CIII\I1111 Illlllgll\l' doh1!l hlllfthu thlilllH shl' dOIlSIMH, ClIwl'Y SIl!!llOSlcd Ihnl MI', Wuleli Illl to cOllnsolll1g with his dllllghll'l" llllTllnllud n1\ IIpplllnlnWI11 Ihnl WI1S oonl'ol1lul1l Ihl' hll\\, 01111' Ihl' hlmlo olllleol nlllw InAII\11mllo, Illolh.i\>u he hill! 1111 Inlol1llons of hl'lplnll Josslon, 'I'hoy Hpont II Inlol'tll\\o 1ll'lhlnll. l11y hllshnnd Ilolleell !lint lImll1ll tho conelllnllon with Ms, Cirool'Y Ih111 '1'lIlllmy hlld .IosHlcn on hol' Inp, stroking hol' hiliI' nnd t1wy wl'rotnlklllg 11hollt , n horso, pld sh\l 1'1'1.11' Ilel Ihlll hol'su? Ilo\\' nhOllllhe Irlp to Spllln IhlH sllll1111or? Thu IIlghl thoy 1lll'lWd Iho Ootolwl' 1:11111110111011111110 II thl'ou-,:fn!!,'oll'olls tho ollly 0(1IllI11Un\ shu hlld spOiltI'll oll'lol\\u \Vns 'dldl1'l hilI' hor 1111111 ololhos, nOlhlngwns sllld nbo\ll (he s/llll1klng yot MI'. WI'((:,h hlld tnkllll hol' d\lwlI 10 tlIP We'lt Shnl'\lltolllol\nl Polleo, Illed n eomplnlnt hl\l ('hlldrl'l1l1lld YOllthollllod.ln nlld Ibr II'hnt.", Mnll clotbos, 1>0 ~'OI1 bulIl)\'P Ihlll ('hlldl'on 111111 YOlllh WOI'I' cllllulllllhecnllse 111111 not blly .Jl'sfllon MIIII ClotlloAI 1'1'101' 10 MI'. Wl)lehllllng Ibl' (1Il'orco lI'uhl\ll gOlle Inllll1l'l'll1gu COIIIISI'III1!l. 01', LI'Hliol', III C'nl11p ',1111, WIIS 0111' cOIIlIsolol' sbe IIlnlud III Dill) of 0111' YlsllH thnt sho \\'lIl1lod to seu Mr. Weloh by hhl1sulf 101llsCIIss SOlllO decpl'oolclI problolllS, ho 1'01llScd, Thnllll Itllull'told l11u Ihlll II'M''. Woloh 1I11111't UIII'O oll\1l1!lh IIblllll hllllsolftn !Jct bolp Ihlll ho dldll'l CIII'U pUl'llld.MlIyho Ihnl would be el1llHldol'ed thu "Insl slrnw", Slllco 1II,(llllld Ihu Illne wholl ~'ll', & MI'IJ: Wolch IVI'II' golllg Illgolhul' IIlld sllhsCl(lIollllYlnlllTlcd thuy hnvu beull trylIlg to flllrl WIlYS 10 ludllco hili child SlIppl1l'l: "1'1\'0 yunl's Ilgo (huy Sllllturl with Mlchl1CI, ho sonl IllO U Il'lIol' lI1lrl nskud Inll In (:onNldnl' lultln!J hllllllnrl TlInllllY rnlso MlchllCI, huro to Ilnd oul 11'11111 Mlohllo!'thnt bU wns prolnllled n Il'lIclnr Ifho Inll\'u(lln with Ihom, ThUll whl\n thllt didn't WOlk nut (hey >>llIrled nil .Iosslell, nl tbo hoglnnll1gnf sllith grndo shu hlld Inld InO nholll thnt nlld IlIskod hul' If Hho wnnlell mc (0 Wl'ite her dnd IIlellul' IIhu sllld nn IhlltWllllld ollly Illnl;e Ihllll;\s worso dnwn thol'e. Sn I didn't. .JeSHICII sllll'lod olthl)dolltlcs In nrolllld Aprll/Mny 2001, Tho COlli Willi qlllte oxpulIslvu, nPPl'llXllnllt\11y $4 100 heCIIlIlle Hho needed II spoellll devlcu, MI'. Wuleh blld the h1slII'IInee lit the IIIllU; Inl>>o hlld Iho ohlldl'im covered lll1del' InY IIlSIII'II11CI', Inlllnly hccnusu Illy Iillnll'lll\cu Cll p"ya WOl'o 1\I\loh hOlloI', Th\llnl\ll'lnllllon poncornln!! .Io~Hlcl1'H 111'IICOH WII'a 1\lI'WlIIllol! In hol' 111111, Iho., (hmlnl nmC\l hill! colllnClOII hla Inalll'nnco twlnll IholllTnngelllollla WClo nlUlle, I11Y InHlll'nnco pnh( nppl'\llihnlltlllY $1 SOO nl1\l hla InHlIl'lInCU pllIII $:!()(l() which nWllnl I \\,o\lll! only hl1l'0 11110111 of pnckuI u"ipOn~\l nf $1100, t.,.1r. Welch nuwl' fill'wlIl'l!o<llhu hlHtil'nllcu Inl\llll1l1llnn In I11U \II' Ihe rlenllHI omco, . thoy Wol'll tlw onoa Ihlll 1\1111 III a\lhlllll Iho 1\)1'I11H. I conlnclellllonwHllo I'olllllnna aUY\lnlllllllea, 1111' pllp\llwol'k wn~ lIolI\'Ol'ulI viII ,lu~~lcn III Feh :!O():! IInllWkon ovur In Iho Ilenll~1 omcu, Ihu orlgllllll onl'olnpu hl\llll dlltu Hlmnp of Jl\no 201l1, MI', \Volch hlld huld on 10 Iho~u dOC\lnlU11I~tbl' IIpprOli Ii l11olltha. Sn wh~ wnH II an hn!l\1l1l1nllll gcl C\I/lllldy ol'.l\lHulclI, Ihul'o Wlla II honrlnll Hch\lllnlcd fhl ^"gll~1 {JIll. Ifhe 1I111n'l "win' hla CIIH\l ho WIIH Inhnlll'lIlol' wllh 1l11l11oHllc H\lllltlonH, NocllloaalnHIIY - ho Ilhlll'l Hhnw 1\lllw i\\lIlIIHIIJlh IWllllng,. ' , flo wlinl hll~ hllppenod with ,JU:IHICII, IIw hul\ll1ll\ll child Ihlll WIIH hrollllhlt\l ynu AlIgIIHI H, :!IlO:! hllH hl1d hol' ellra gl\llgod, noHe plul'cod, Hho d\lu~ 1M 1111111 clolhuH, !llc, Shu 111110 gOIH \\1 HpOlld wuukul1\lH hy horRelf whllll Jerry IInd 1'I11111llY go In MlIl'ylllnll, Sho hllH In gel hol' WilY thoy IllIHlo n Inlol' promlReH 10 hel nnd Igllllrnnlelllhnl Hhu.wlIll1111ku Ihull1 Hllck' IInOI' IIl1.1orry nndTlIll1l11Y IlI'U l'eaponHlhlu fhl' Il0HII'oylnglllU l'ullltlonHhlp Hho hl1d wllh her nl\llh~I', Sh~ (1111 lollmo Ihol Rho 1'00011'011 Ihu JlloRlrlollllll1 AchlownWll1 AWllrd thr Mlddlu Hchonl, ~o Rho hl1H houn. koopl11!.!/lol' t!l'nllosllp bl1llhllt la Ihll WilY Hho WI1H I'IIIHOII. PORpl\o whlll .J~RHlclIllIlllllI, Rhu kllowa Ihlll hol' l11olh~I"lol'oS hol' nllll HUl1pOrtH hel' 1IIIIy, Wllh IIl1lhu IIl\ulllloll Hhu W(lH rU~'\llyll1g l\'oll1lh~ \Volch iimllly IInd IIl1lho prollllsoa why wouldl1'l Hho WIII111011l0\'O 111 wllh hol' nllhol''1 Shol'lll'oly hl\\l Ihlll uliPlIl'lol1co bolbl'o 11111\ 110W WIIR Iiul' ,l,lmo 10 Hhll1o, So why IlId 1.lIlRt lonw .J~HHICI1 gn, 1 COllld 1101 cnmpulo, Tllmmy allltod III Ihu ol1d of yom docl61011 "WB WON", IIl1lp doua sho kl1llW thlll'o IIrul10 1I'II1110lH 11111 Child Cuslody. Why do , chnnso nollo tight thl .I0HR\CII nllYll1ol'o, I1l'sl nl1d thlomosl II Wlla JosHlcn 1111\1 Rllld 10 mo "ltllll\ighl YOII would 1l0Vlll' Rtlll' lightll1g tbl' Il\llmom" thnl \VIIH 1'1'101' to Ihe cUHtody henl'lng,1 kllew golllg In thol'uahe loveR hpI I hilI' mothol' 1\1111 nllhol' nlld 11111 01'01' WII1110d Ihl' hol' WI1H th~ chnllco 10 IIl'u n nOl'l11l1llllb, Hhllla Iho ol1e WhO,WIIR nlwllYR URod hyhol' I\lIhol' dmll1!! 0\11' IllOllth hl1l1loH whllo WO WOI'O HIIlI . mUlTled, hu would IlIWllYH IcWhol', 1110111111y WIlS 10llvll1g 01' ROmO CI'IlZY 110l1HIll1RO Illld ahu would comll to mo crying, '1'111\1 la 110 WilY Ihl' hel' lollvo, Thla WilY Rho would ol1ly hll\'u 0110 sol of rl1los nlld Hho would 1101 hu \IRed IIl1ymol'o, S\ll'c hol' 1'1I11wI' Hlllllolla hol' ol'Ol'Ylhlng h\lt I'm \101 \VolTlod, I kllow ill Ihu 10l1g run .JORHICII will nl1d out Ihu truth. I k\lOW Ihllt tholo iR n .Iud1l0 Illuch hlghol' Ihllt la Wlllchil1g I11Y ovol'Y mow, ho kl10wllit nlllll1d ho kl1nWH thllll hnve dOl1o 1111 thllll could do, MI', Wolcll hllR no 0110 10 hillmo hut hlmHol1' 1'01' hlR IlctlOI1R, 110 knowR oXlletly whllt ho IR 1I01l1g, 110 stolcd 10 11\0 hothl'o Ihollho chlldl'el1 dOllot Ilckl1owlodge hlH clilHlcl1cu. 110 \VIIH Rtolldlng In\ho Ibyol' I1l1d tho kldR I'nl1ln Hllylng hi mOll1, Ilnd lollllly Ignol'od h"li, 1J0I nccd 10 tllku thu blll1110 Ibl' 111111 \00'1 In c1oRing, IlIpologl1.o for thla llOing HO 10l1gthy hilt whllt it I'oolly IlOlIR down 10 IR: ^I whllt point nnd limo 111 Mr. Wolch's IIdlllllll'e doos ho I1HSI1I11O rCHjlol1slhlllty Ihl' his 1I0tions'l Thlll1k you , Heapcctlhlly Ruhmltted l-O'l{t fQ <.)t(('IUl... Lorie ItOl]UOI\II l\ "1' ;J. -/,;p, II h IIUlnll1el ^ \'unllo Lemoyllo, PA 1704.1 \' ',I',', ',""'1.. (...."",,\,./.., " i'.1..-,'" 'I' I ,I 'I I L '! "I 1-.\" " ,: . "-.. ':'- '. '. ' ". \ "~'/' i .....' ,: ',', '. '.., , I' fH/ ii.;' ",' ': ~\( ;~)" '\':'-'1'\"- .! 1':'\I,:;~~'II\.\'i"tl"~f 1"'1 I' . ,," ! ",~.!" ,1,':hlj,J!:,~ \1'" ":'l'."\~:I"-'I!:",,:~,!.\\/\~I~'~}}'(I\' "\,, "-,,_I'';~;f~~~I,\,~,,''''', ','.. 'j,' ','f'i'" ""'iI,I,1,~',,:,_,;,;, aornld r, Wfllc:)UL_-.:...~ , , 'fil'1l1 ","q'r;mnl'\I"{,\'/,I"'~'!'!1!1"~"\"llfi\nnUll1\l'1ll/!llni.1\l ,I aWlYMWLlJ!1'mlW.K!rnl'(!!.jl!ll\'32~:t\lYm'!}1Y!I!L~~]tljljl!(l\~~1\li:1.1;"..'lTI,&~ ILC:;),1111~'I",t,lil:ll;Wil,ljllliinj'A\.\>!Ii\lIl~kl'm/llli.~ ' 'firO 3,! IIQI1Wfllll(llllIl'l\nill! Coltloll>lil, I'A \75 I ?, 1'1\(1/11: 717-;W5~50(j(), 01' 71 i' ;'.7Il 35/15 JIII\U ~", ~OO:1 PI1M.jllr/(Jll 1111115, Oil A1IIJ1l~l'il 2002, tOl1\prJl'iI/'1 <:II!,lml\' nr my d'1\.lght.t.lr Je~~I<:a.Jn Woit:h, w~~ ilWilrdllc:l 10 1110, In YOUr (elll/t 1'0l1m, Sll1co thilt dny, ~j\lI1111 trilvosllos I\i\VO oc;e:lIITOI'! with I'og'irdsw illI thl'ou of nlY e:hllcll'iln, I ~!1I Wl'ltll1(J 10 YOl\, 111 hopus lhilt Yilll'i:iln clo 50nlothl110 to slop thl11ll, I havo nnt ~(l(ln illY r"JIlS Mlch,lul.IUI'fY Wuh:11, and Tnylnr Alllln Wtll<:/\ r,IIIC11l !\prll ~o 2iio3, Prior to (hilt dOlO, tllo hoys nynllnhlllty to /TIll wns ';pol'ildlc,'H Ilost, [;,1<:11 tlI\1I) nf illY se:hllllllh1d vlsltilt1nils, I <ll'IlYnd ilt lhn ilppolOlnd I1liICO, ill thn _Wpllll1t.1\./ \IOIll, only to bo told IiI' tholl' 1)1'ill1lh',\l'llllts MId daycill'o ,:nnt(II',\V"l'kurs, thllllho b,)ynvul'o not thur.l \.\lId WOlllil ,!lot 11U thel'u, , I ili11 IHWhl1l to conta<:t. my ~nlls by tolllplNnn, Lnrlll Illlllllun,l hill10S lip ,15 SIJnn ,15 shn hllill'~ my y9/('\1,. Sho gOOS ollt of hel' WilY tn l11illlll slIl'iI'lllll bnys ilrl) not ,willlnblo tc> 1111), for vlsltiltloll, 01' <IllY COll\l1l1l11lCi\flol1, for t1w In \1l.tu 1', Thl1 hOlllll dOllS 110t "i\VO <Ill <ll1sWlll'lno ejoylr.o, r06ll'lc;tll1o 1111! fl'ollllllavlng al11Ass,Hlo fl)1' tholl\, 11.\11\ 1I1l1ltod fl'(ll11 (lll/l1g tll tholl' l'osldol1r.u i\S pOl' tho I1riglnnll:lIstody orrlul' III offoet thll1l Nt)vurnilul''' I 91)3, This t:llstr.it1y qrdol' Is r1l11 till< only cOlll'lol'<ler thnt !,orlol~eqll'lI1ll Is vlolillll10, Sill) hlls,Iwt l\ttlllllptocl to.vlslt or 111clke milch C()I1tnQ with 011I' dilll(1hlol' j05slr.i\, slnr.u !\IIOllsl 7 2002, CIlIlplod with lh'l filq tllilt josslr.n C,\I1llOt son lllli' llt'ClllI~l's l111d Lorlo'nofllSl\I to Ulvo.ll)sS lull' pursot\ill bulo\\iJII1{Js, hilS C,Mlsud hur gi'U~t ufnotlnlhlldlGtross, 11\lllllbly <\cltnlt,'tlliHI i\lll \lllI\IJI'l to ,lffol'f,lto i'otilll1 tho s'lIvlcllS of i\n nllom:1Y at this tllllll, Thul'ofore, I f')/t ll\i\t thll1gs Wlli'e hr)poIIlSS, 011111,1 \Vl)uld bu sllbJucWI to this crllelty, wltl1l1o I'ec,o II 1'5 0 , HQ\Vovul', I was a/vlin the ndvlcll tel t,y wl'ltlng YOII il letlor, If Ilwc1 knowll It cOlllcl be clol1o, be n!mlrec' tlHlt I wOllltllHlve written this Il1ltor Inllch SO!?lllll', YOIII' hOllOI', YOll IliWI! bonl1 ,\hu sa,wIII Jut/ou frolll thu boollllllnl.l, stllltllu] with' tho cllvorr.o, tllI'l111gl'cllstnrly honrlnos, YIJIi hnvo SIJlnU uxpllrluncu \Vlththo p;lItlus IllYnlvue/. Plaaso don'l t!llnk I <\111 trying to WilstP. YOlli' tll11l1 with thl,s, I know YOll lire ,1 IHISY l11ill1 ilne;11 npPl'oelclto YOIII' r;ol1sldorll1U illY cltr.llIl1sti\l1COS, I III 155 OlY SOll5 lorrlbly, nnd I kl10w thnt thuy I,,\Vo to b,f llClyo/,soly ,\ffoc,tod by nOl bultl(J II part llf thull' IIvus i\I1YIIUlt'U, I foar'pul'Ill,IIHlIIhlllulIl\tl,)I\ ai' thillI' arf'ul:tlnns, I nlso fanr lhllt lllllY might be 'lillIeI' t/\I1 rulsa Irnl1rllsslnn that my 1/01. soul'19 'them, \11' contilctlng thorn Is by my cl1l)lce, ~Illthlllg cOllld 'b'1 further from the truth, I Wil$ snddullud wholl I ~(lllld ollly 5UIl0lY chlldrOIl!)1I WOI\l<lll1d5, to 1)I!1J11l with, whllll I Wl\5 Iivlno 111 thu hotllU wllh tholll, I was theil' prltllllty c;1/'llrjlvp,r, Now I ,1m PUr-lllHI completely O',It llf thulr lives, nl.] OXf111rlollC1U <:nuld bu WflrSll, I hnvu ollclOhed <:nplllS or Iho <:llstody nl'durs, $11lc;ol'oly, ?)0l) \'I..(,~i(,jl~(ov )'LlM ll.\ ,\.~~j Jony Wolch Jr, I; " .. ' ;'" Ulle,; 2 " . I ~ )' I :' ,.1/ I I \ ) , I '\ \ "I 'r' .f.'tt~-~." /'\110,', It.,. " 1',- ,. ;" If ..I, '~Y'_: ") o. I" C\ ~I' ~ I'I! 'I' , I ,'('I'I~'..- " ........... l , f' \: q, \:1 "I 'II ,. '/.) ~/ I " 'I iI 1'1' ~.f 11J~ ~I~ ~ , ~~~ i~ ~ ~-r tv:r. ~ , 4!~ ~~ I -~ ( - "-, I ,~ ,; '.,. " .' ~ ~ ~ ('(l () ~ t- tI1 1/1' 0 ~ I <! -f I~ C\: IJI c:r.. ..J :l r 0 2 c.J 1/7 :::) .~ ? -) W Q} ~ -;; (). 0: ~ o c:) " " " "11 '-:: ,~ r. '-= ,.- ~ ......,. -5 l~ '--:: ':: ~ ~ I::;: ~ 1=3 ~ '~ 2 I'-=: !~ ....:: 1":1 ,'I, ,1"1 I'I~I ,j' 1'<:1 'd "1 I", '" ;Il~ 'i, '" I, i L , t "; 'r ~Ib' l}i . ! i,( ,11 ]J I~~: L, i' I ii .. ! '" !t' .;1 \ I :(,, \ ~,.. 'I' " I I \ '1/' I,' , j. "\~., "i , .' ';1, ,',/._j(1 , ,,' "\',~'f1~',' ~,~' , ,,' ""I('\'\"'! ,.. "f'.I-f,< .' ((.1,_,\. ". '1/,ll'fI' ~~ " j .\l"~\' 'I ; '\'1. ,,_l~ ,,\1'1' "'ill'lh,' ~\/)., ' ","1 ' , ~ , ' I ~ , I~ I ': ,( '~{)\ /\~j ! 'I I" n 'If \ ,J~: ' _\' _' ,I'i'!~ ',-i,,I:. 'n' i :.- 'P'tl:",;:1 , , , ~,I'J',," "\1' . iF/ill 'f ,',,'1 .\,~_~ 1 l j: -i) I 'lIlt"\"., I . P'I1\i' -. , ,'~ "',i' ,II I ,I\;~\,*rn\"'\l ,'" 1'. ','1' ,'fI , '" "'. \, - ~ti-t' !"L., . ,C ,( ,,";r," 1(., J , ,1,1.'."'_: I , ,"':),'\,'~ f~l., ., 1":', ','" .;' III-}t~\' 'r, , " I', f ..; ,; . ; ? f ~ I , "~.~,,, ~)~Jl;, ()" " . ,if.... \~'. t 'to ! I <; ..' \'. '\ I' '..,~I\ . I;' ' ,)::\f f', 1,,". , .f:,';'; " ',\'.rk'("\d 'J, 'f, ",: t ,~,^"p; "I!"I" j " " " JI!' " . ~' 'I '\:- ,. ~: '.I "I ,;,1 , . 'Y'l , , ' l\ 1-, .;. .