Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05158 " I' I 1 I i , 'I I I I "\1\ I ",I ~I ~I , I I' ,. I' 1', " " ,. ,; ,;01' " tJ ,. ,,' Ii'; I' ,I' " I,. 'I' {11 1\' " i,";' " I J ~I ~: ~ ' ~ .. ~ ,. j, H " " ,," " I.' " j,,' , " " -i~ Ii ~')b~~~\~_ ffi~q -'\1,\," -;/t , \ .\ I ! i '\, ,. " I' ,. ij i" I' it ,. I, " ., ,.",. (I 'I ".. ,. '. I' " "j, " I' ,', I:, " ,. .1 ',\' ,. " " " " " "H ,;' Ii, ,i- , ~ rj'" j! .' r; "'; 'I' " " ,. 'J' Ii ,,'; r \~ .. ., ,;' iI: ", " "j, ,';--.. .. .t:I ~ ~ ~ C1 l\~ ,.', " " 0' ,Ii " , d" .i, !i ., " " , '.; " "~ ~ Ii' Arl"d~ ',J, r\'\!.~ I"l (,.u :, I"~ , k; ,'" 1" \ '_", J(",I. (.\1-\'(1 [' ~,Q ') ", \'0 ",' ; "") ,,"/ (\ \ 1\ yv':' \~Y\ P I,J \'i'l"J \ (J 1'\ ':\ (t' 1'('7 1"0'1 \ fro, (-",V,Q ~I i'~ Ii. A ('0 \) '~~C:.\....Q \\'.uIQ (...._y~~ B::-~l~~"~ (k1 \. \ I \""'(~"'~' I'U (1 ~'~I 1...,~ , .. I t'\'~ T I I ( \l.J II, Y'.~' , \ ,'.r 1(.(.. /L.1I,) / t ,.'. (\~ 1.,--.' .' I.",;\.:"'tt(." r\ h '7 .' Itlr.j O)'d ~{"ll. (Ie I I:".) \..,) l ,~. (I \^-t:>\'" c\! (' \" ,I \........11 ,I "I /J Ll' !.; ( f,.t L/" j '1 II \ ~ , /'. ,) .1... ~ ,j ) '(\0 , ~~;, (I_J(~.)() ~n...l).__._r-' c_~_~~ r; \-;;"cf'~' e ""J~ ; '" '"t....f~. of-...... '1'\ ,J ") ~, (/'(jI\,~ ~ ,::r..,,; '\~ L,.) \~Q ''\ ' \' ( 6~ J(~\ n c(.,) "Il,. I I ',_ ~ ,:1 eJ ..:~ ", t-'.. ..~ 'h, ..: "I I ( ._1 C' ,...(1 'it..) ~(!, ,.:J'II,.Vy.........- '.;. VVv (V, 1'\\" 7 '2':'(J i ,~'"~I ,. IlL t\.... ...,r ,\ (.,:r:. (' ~~\'o '7 :N'r,>r_-, (~-I' tJ ""'1', (I I ()..- l,!' 2 1'1 .. ','1 (J () ':S"~\y\, ' )::;'( .. lrx: LI' ~ ., . ii, , '(, ~I (,/ ". '2"3"\, os- 2 .{ ,1 .. L( $~('i.U I I/V"L '( <....::~.I, .., '\1' '0'--o''-~ \~~ ;0 <..) I '!'; '.. ...1-1-0..' """'\A 'l'" ~,' . "t"" ., i --. ~.; 'I j. !', ;, '\ ;'! I " , 'iA.! ". "tl"' ',I~ '1,". , ... .~. ,j, , " , I, , , , , 7, ponl~ct, Aftor roR~nnnblo lnVoR~lgntlon, An~wo~lng Pel!encll1nt . ~,f.l W.l.~:hD\\t: Imow.~a~lr:Jo Dr ~.nf!Qrml1tlon fI\1f.f.~,Dlant to' rel'lponcl to ~:ho nn,ogqtiolW oontAino~l in ptll,nqt'Aph ",oven (7) lllll~ f.ltript prool! t", ~e~Anctocl At tr.l.n1, a, Paniccl. It i", ndmittod onl~ thnt on or nboUt November la, 1997 I1t ApproM~nntplY 7146 n,m., thnt A pOlliaion oppurracl IletweQn the vohiple opernt:acl I)~ Pln:l.nUfJ:. nnd IJpf.enclnnt At or About ~R944 (Wert.ville RCRct) nt or neAr tha int~rf.lePtion with Route Pl North, 'l'ha t'emnin.l.ng twennonta in pnrngt'nph eight: (0) Ar~ clanied Rncl ntiaa\1a p\1ra\1nnt to Pennay1vnnin RUla of. oivil propecl\1re 10a9(e). ," 9.' Paniecl.. 'j'he .Qller:Jnt!onfl of pArAglinph nine (9) nra qen~.ecl AI'I ponpluaiona of. lAW to whioh tho PennaylvAnin RUlea oj!, oiv,il p~'ooecl~WG reCjl1i!,G no reflPonaive pleAcli\lg nnct at:r.iot p~oof "ia clemAnclecl nt ~riAl. 10~ peniecl. ~o the oontrAry, Anawering Defendnnt wna nt no time negligent, oarG1Gas and/or reo~leaa in thG operation of hia motor vehiole, A~ditionally, all Allegationa in PAragraph tan (10) aub~aragraph (b~e) Are denieclAa oonoluaiona of lAW to whi6h the Pennl3ylvAni& R\1les of civH, Prooect\\t'e rGc;{tlire no reaponaive pleac.'llng. Moreover, the Allegations oontqinec.'l in pAragraph ten (10) aubpQragraph (Q~e) arB denied ancl at issue pursuant t~ '" Penn.Ylvania RUle of civil Prooedure 1029(S). 11. Denied. It i8 speoifioally denied that anawering Defendant \~al'l' nt' allY time negligent, Olwelel'll'l. ancl/ot' reoklel'la in the oper&tion of hia motor Vehiole on the date ill question. 'hese Allegations are oonclusiona of law to whioh the (1.< I' , I' , '" J.ll3nn~Y~VAn~'\1 mnOfl OJ? o~YH ~'r0013Cl\lI~!3 V13Clll~P13 no l.'l3l-'lponp~VI3 rlaAd~ng, ^ddtt~gnAllY, w~th VOflrpot'~o rlR~nttfe'fl pvoPl3pty {'I dAmflt;l!il, I'lt'~~(.lt pl~ooJ? ~I'l C1Pll\111)clecl At td,tu, WlIl!lR!WOl\lu, P13f.13nclAnt I ~aott 1\, l'eto'~I'l, l-'13l'lpeatl,'~IP,y rl3q\.la/3I:/3 " ,thAt th~/3 OO\wt ~mlnj: jmlmnant in h~!3 JEWOl.' Am:! AgAini'll: tlw ' P~Aint~ff on tho Oomplqint, togethev with aOfltfl And expan/3efl, ~n' i I ~~, PeJ?OnclAnt,~pott: A, Petorfll inaorporRtan herein ~y l."efel.'enae the AVf:ll."l1\entfl oontAil1ecl in pAl.'AgrAphfl one (1) thpo\.lgh elj;lYl'ln (1+) of the fOI~egoing 1\nflwev Al'l if f\.llly flet forth hl3rein, 13. 'l'he Pl.A~.nt.tff' f.l QOlllplEd.nt fAilfl to fltate ~' a;Laim \lpon Whiahl."el1ef OEln pe lJrElntecl. , I 11\, P1AintHf' fl alfdml-'l Are bElvl.'ocl in whole or in part /)y " the cloatl."inefl of,pontrib\.ltorY/aomPElFAtive n~gligenoe Elncl aSflumption of risk. 16, Plaintiff hAfl not fl\.lstElinecl Elny inj\.lriefl 90gni2.ble under Pennl-'lylYElnia lElw al3 A oonl3equenae of anflweving Petanclant'l3 alleged action, 16. "P1Aintiff'fl alElimfl ArebA~~ecl in whole or in part )Jeaa\.lflePlaintHf' a nllag~cl inj udea, if Any I Were not aa\.l!1eclby the Elationaof DefenclAnt, Saott 11. Petere, .. , " . 17, Plaintiff'a alaims are bArred beoause the Plaititiff hal3, I3Ul3tnined no injury in fnot. 10, Plailltiff's olnims Ln.'e bart'ed by the applioaple statute ,I' of 11mi tatiolll3. 19, ~laintiff has not nlleged fqots sUffiaient to sU~pbrt his allegations of negligenae. '" i. " " I' "\" I, \, " I' I' I';,; ,I' I; ." " q ,L " ,. I; i! j' ;'j ,. " /'1" ,'" ,: . I; " " . , " 1'1 " " I .. .. "" " ,. " " 'I', fl_ I C\ C 11'1 " ,. "I 1 'j"' , il'l' ~ I I .' "~I ," "fl .." '1'; p , Ii" '-,I ..,1 \ ~1 I ) \ (:,') " :- " (d) '1'1 " I ;,,\'1 " ,,'.\ "IL, I' I, II ;" \ II" , , . \" I, \'~ '-'t r" ( l.~ " " L; '1: (' '-'-1'\1 '!'{,'1) ': I ~ . r I '\ t,' - , j ,{ ,; ':; l' I ~,~ ,I. '1".',lj 1; ,i \1', ". I' ,. , "'II !! " ", " " " " " " ii 'I' .I ... " .. " .. , , I' ,',\ ,. I, " I, " " " \, " ,. II.!' 1,'1' " ',,, 'I'" I':i ",\ 'I j'/ ~' ,',i !.\ ," I' " '.. .. " " , II, I,.;li '.,il] 3." :)p,\ '~il J~ 1',1' ,. c: " I' " " ", " " " " ;, .. .1 .' "Ii " , , .'1 <, ,-j. .11 (9;' p. ~ (~ ~. ('\ "\) ~ B "() c-., e rl;: ;V, .....1 '"'0 . t"" 't, ,. I' ';j Ii' " " I' " " I: ;' , \ J , " ,', I , " , I Ii ) , 1 , j l I h I i L.} , i' !-,'i , .., , i ., , , .f;' " ,', I , , i:J 1 . , I I -, , I ;), ,; , , , ,. I, f. II ,I ,. .' .' .1 ,;' I: " I' 'I' I' ., ., (~:) \('1 (') .1' ( ;(,;,0 .-'1 f,':t .\1,- . 'lTi' 1;\\ '1,',11 t'l '" ';') ..~ , 1'1 ,.... !111) '" "_'I jl' f.I,1 \' .. .),1.) ,-'; " f~;; "",! "(1 , ,1,,\\ I~~ CI ' . 'p~ .~'~ f.,I" :'(' (1:11' ',';-\1 PC.- " '.:), '-j' [0 1\" q Irq .<., . ..~ ...', ,I " " "" " ,j, ,Ji' "~) , I I I I , I;, " \'1 " " 'j' ,,' " 1\ " i; " ,,' ,.'.j 1< " " " , '{' !Ii " " ";. " " " " "I' " " ,I, 'I' ,. l' ! I' " \\ ,. ',-,j' H i( " 1( "" d;':_ "j' ",. " if,'" " 'Ii i; " I> ,', if! " I( (:1 ," \ I :,' "1:. I ""1 , , , " jX!l 'd I , ! I " , I . I , r; , I I ) , , . , i C:-J ,I' '-'i-.J :':'1 , i .,1 , I '.., I I I .. ! :J , ',I << ," " ,- ,~ .11 /'/ " ;, " , .' , ('" NOT lJU\ I.a hnn fjen'lIlnclMlo II \Ifllou On III porIa, 61 llftlofl quloro UllfenuerllO elP alllPIl elpmllnelllllllxIll11llllnn an IIlIl Pl1lllnllllllloulonlllQ, Ullllleltlonp vlpnlp 1~01 ellllll cle plll1.0 111 pllrllr flp III fOllhp fla Ip dpmllnctll V III nOllflOflolon, Ulllofl flllPIl prllllllnlnr ltnll I1llllrlanolll.llllmlll1 0 Iln parllonll p pOI' I1PClllllflp V IHPhlvl1r Iln III o\lflo on forml1 allorllll flUlI dafanllllll 0 IlUIl oplaotlpnlllllllf.111 flllml1ndnlllln oonlm UIlIlU perllPnll, 6PI.\ nfllllnflp qlllllll Ulllml no Ila eloflllmlp, I~ 11111 prllvlo Ilvilw 0 nOllflol1olol1 V pOI' oUlllqular quln 0 IlUllfla pardoI' flll111rO,O IlUll proplafllldoll 0 otrOIl doraoholl!rnporll.\nllllI pllfllulllad, LLf.!Vg J:STAPJ:MANPA A UN ArlOQAPO IMMgPIATt:MJ:NTJ:, 61 NO TIJ:NJ: AflOOOOO 0 61 NO TmNf.! J:1. DINl:RO 6UFlclJ:NTl: PJ: PAQAR TAL 61:RVICIO, VAYA f.!N PF.RsONA 0 LI.AMF. '~OR TgLF.FONo A I.A OFlclNA CUYA PIRgaCION 6J: f.!NCUI:NTRA f.!SCRITA AaAJO PARA AVf.!RIQUAR PONOg SJ: pUJ:pg CONSJ:QUIR ASlsTI:NclA LJ:QAL, CUMl3J:RLANP COUNTY OAR AS60CIA TloN :z Llporly Avol1ue Carllalo, PA 17013 Tolopl1ono (7171 ~49.3166 CUMl3J:RLANP COUNTY l.gOAL Sf.!RVICJ:S, INC, 8 Irvlne'Row Cllrlllllll, PA 17013 Telopl1one (717) 766,.8476 Zf.!IGLt:R 81 ZIMMIlRMAN, p,o, 'I "', ,..,..- , ~, ,,.,,;' ,J'''/ /, / /.:"../../..~"".. .." -,-,...:..:. -,. ~~-' BYI ( .<~":,,,,/.,/ /JO}IN ~I Z I L -R, f.!SQUIRI: /' I, D, No, 79476 (., 366 (i-i, 2111t Streot, Suite 304 p, 0, Box 1080 Camp HIli, PA 17011 (717) 731.1484 OATEI Soptembof 3, 1990 I, II' : .' H ,. ' '- ,;" '~r..J ~ II' ;" " i I ...,(;\ .. 4J 111\ -..... - , .. -kI' '~~ I', 11 0,.., - ":J <. ,', lj) . .0 KJ. '" "I I 'I.(j , \\:: \, I " I \l:\' ,..f'~ ':jt I :f ~_ . 1 It! t..l " '::1- - - ....C ,I,t !~ I.d 'U t\.) ')!. " I' ii !,. Ii ,,'; ., ,. " ,. " " , " I, " ., ,',I ,. 'i, " I' .' \' 'I I" /, " ',j it' d (p,li , j. ., ,'I. ,. j, ! Ji. " H .;li ;'1. " ,. ," i., Ii " L " ,; j; q, i' " " ,. " " " ,. " ,. H, ;1, 'i,.' "II , " " Ii I, I' i , ,. ,I !' .'Ii .. " ii ," ,I I, I! '1 " . , I' ,~' ,r" .. .. " , 'I I' 'I' '1 " i' II , .. " .. " , i " I' I .. " , " , , " 'I' I',,' " ,. 1; " '\1' " . Ii ,. ." ,. .. I' " " i' ii " " " ", I, " I' , ( , .FR!;Y Be T'h~Y ^TrOI~Nr:Ya'AT.I.^W Ii 1I0lJllll\AljOYPI IIII1WI OAlIlIIlIIi, l'njljIlYlv^'rM 11111:1 1l01l1:IHM,I'IW'( ol'lip\JNsl'l. 1lT!lI'IWN p. TII.r:Y l1011PI1T n. FIIr:Y April ~o, ~o(JO 11:1,11I'IIClNI' (71'7) U'UHiII311 I'(lClIlIMII.I:(7I7124:i'1l1'1I " 1-lol1ornl)le Geol'[Je I:, Hoffllr O\IIl1I)erl,mrl OOlll1ly OOllrtl101I~e One OOllrthollae Sqlll1fC:l Onrllslr~, Psnllsylv<1I1I<l1?013 Re; O'Donnell v, pelers No, 90-51 (.)8 Olvll Term pem ,Jllclge Hoffer: . I WI1S <1ppalnlecl OllEllrrnf1n of <1 I)ome! of arl)ltrfltloll In tile Elbove o<1ptlone~1 lllf1tter, 13y letter (I<lteel April 14,2000, <1 Dapy of wllloll Is enalaseelll W<1a Informecl by oOlll1sel for tile clefel1e1!1llt tll!1t t1lt'l plQlntlff ancl e1efl3nfl<1nt had reaolled a settlement. I 1Il1derst<1l1e1 \lmt oOlll1sel will be filing a pmeolpe to dlsllllss tl1!Hlotlon as settled, , I haveretllrned tile file to the Offloe of the Prothonotary Elnd I ElI11 writing to YOll to reqlleatlhat Rlohard 0, GAffl1ey, Gsqlllre, NOI'El 8, Glbaol1; Gsqlllre And l11yself be e1lsohargecl fl'ol11 0111' obligation f1a f1l'bltrf1tol's In the Elhove referenoelj 111 <1 I\e 1', .. Slnoerely YOlII'S, , i~::;r~-:)\ j 7~~ RGF/ol1l11 EnoloSlll'a " " " j' ,. ',I " " " "h , , " " , " " " Ii " 1'" ,. " " I, !I ,," " ,','1- ,. ii' ,. '" " " " ;,' l'. p,' !I ,I' ';! ~ 'L' " ,. r. } '"\1{'; 1"1 ',"i' . ~.'O! !:, ':'1 !".. " .. ~\ j;'l :' {<I 1:,:1 " " , 1,1,' '1 ,.... d! f I,~ " " " '" I! " " ,'I' .-:' i-' \ (j ., l,' -,I, :' " , I, ,. Ii '! Sf/=> 2 5 ?nnl " '" ,i " " " I' '" " 'i 'I t.,. " " !! j, " " , " j' " " r' r:::, , ';, \/. 11 ;; iiJlJj ,:) I (") '",1,"1 I ,. "1 , , " :1;1,: h"l I'/:i 'l I' ~.;, . ~.. :),<, I;::L;' ;)} '.-11 oJ:; _. 1//' /,,),.' ../. r...\ :':/'1"1 /;(;! 1....,' .. '~'I 1'" ::J Ul :1:/ ." 1 \:1 "'1.; . " '0; If II il' I, " ,', 'F j', i' " r ,. , I I I I I' i "