HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05228b ,.
?., ?
TIMOTHY 011H,J i;;I< IN 'I HR ('!OCIRT O1` COMMON I11dl;A%I
Plaint,l.fl'. cuMHIi;RL,nNncl?t)rl'fv, PMNNaYhV,ANIA
1
v, CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO
i tt:RHMY BULL
pefondant; i JURY TRIAL, DRMANDIN)
YOU ME BEEN AND IN COURT, J E you Wimp to defend agai.not:
the glai.ma not forth in the Following Pogo", you munt take action
within twenty (20) duty€1 nf:l or thin C1o1111.laint: and Notice are yervn&
by entering a written nppeargnue pnrnonal.ay oa: by attorney and
filing In writing with the Court: your defnnnos or objectionda to the
c!:La'1.mm not forth agai.nnt,you, You are warned that if you fai.l to
do no 1=he Cana May proceed without you 6nad a ;judgment owl, be
ontored agnins&..you by the Court: without further notice for any
money claimed in the complaint: or f:or any other claim or relief
reduamted by the plainti.f:f:, you may lame motley or property or _
other ri:ghtm important to you,
YOU SIMUL.D TAKM THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, :IV YOU DO
NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONIM, CIO '`1'O OR '1H1111;PIIONE THE
OP'PI:CH BHT FOR'T'H BELOW TO FIND OUT WHMRR YOU CAN GMT LEGAL, HELP,
Cumberland County Bar Apeor.i.ation
2 1.,.i:bert:y Avenue
Car.l.ible, PA 17013
(717) 299-3160
NOT101A
llilll dolllf111ClfldO ti llflt.ocl all :I,FI c:a1"Cci f3.1 111jCocl elll.l el l'o _r1o C(311do1'F9o I
da clotao clalpmidIAH V x.pl1ont*,o l o11 .1,c11:1 1) E(IT1.1clII f3;l.cllliolivim11f3Catl f, 1.oIIo
V.to11Lo (30) cla.afl C1a p1t1Yo a1 pi1rt:.il' (lo aE1 J,o.(Ala cle :la dollimic"IE1 y .Lil l
11c)LA,f1oac:101l, UrlLed dol--)o I voF.1nnCilr lum c:1por:LaI I cia 0noI-1 l:a o o11
porflona a pal.' ill)agado y Earolliv,11: on :1.il c:01:'Le all forlllfl cifiCirl.l:a fiLlo
daflollotlfl ,.o film object:.{Cllofl o Lilo d0inoll(ho all collt:ra (lll fill parflopl,
,mail il0.f3E1do cilia 131 11W..'ed no w) dcli.'.i.a11do, :L a"1 coma Laillal'cl Illacll.clblfj y
puaela a111:ri1r ttnfl ol'doll UonLl:fl Llf:lLad f3.i.11 p1°eV:1.0 i1V:l.fjo a 11at1:1.frim.-l.i.oll y
pot: amald1,11or cluaJa o al.a.V:Lo clue) ofl pocl.Lclo c.-m 1a pnLi,c!.i.ort cle dolllflllcla,
1.1 vi t.aci ptlado pordul' cl111aro o f.41 111 1) 1:•c:fp:I,ecladefj o oLlx-) ' dallclclllo9
Lmport:ant:an pal:a llfll:ad.
1.,1.&WIP, IIS'1'A DMMANDA A UN AI301DAGO :I.NMI DT.ATAMIINTA, S1 NO '1'IENII
AI3ODA00 O MI. NO T1:PINII Ml., I)TNHRO SUP':I:CII3NTH DR PAOAIt 'PAL, SliIMI..Q10, VAYA
(
114N PRMSIONA 0 T:,GAMH POR ')'TILT P'ONO A L,A 0101C.1 NA CUYA UIIRIICCI.ON Sl
I NCUI NTRA ENCIZ.1"M AHAtiJO PARA AW.3ZIOUAR DONDE, SE, Ptn DH, CONSHOU.T.R
ASIS'i'IINC:I:A I.NCIA1:,,
Culnbor.l.and CoullLy 13ar Afaljaci.lat.-Ann
2 I.d.bal:Ly AVanue
C<ar.11.o..a, PA 1'70:1.3
(7:1.7) 2119.31.66
t
i
1,.:
'N M(?'I'HY OL,:I NORR I IN THIi! couk'I' Op CJUMMON P1,14A.1
I'l0.1111:1 ff 1 C1.IMUHY1,ANI) C(111N111Y, PHNNSYINAM-A
1
V I C!l V I I, A("I''f oN - hA{V
JGIRISMY 131.11,1., 1 NO,
1
hoftlnialll' 1 ;JURY 'IRIAh DNMANDMD
aQM>?I,R1:N?!
.L, 1':I r1a.nL l.l'li 9':I.tl1(A lly 01111gi lr :11,1 cul adult: Who
currently r1. m idnu , ut: 419.. D'a.l (•grounl Avo„ curl inlla c!1,tinbel: lcnld
counhy, Pan nylvania,
url:endant doremy Hula, in an adua:t: inrlav:lchlal and oft-Isoli
of tale FIL'aLe of Ma1juacjl 1.11aot:t H 2111d hilt) a Ila:L: f"a ndd Voon of 333 Il"nh
COMM Avonlo, ;9pringflold, MA Ollgg
3, The No& and oaoUrronoon houolUai.'Ler related !rook p:laae
at approximately 4110 pall, an ,911nony, January 16, 1997, on State
Route 11 (Co linlo Pike) near An intoralnaf.lon with Roadway Drive
in M.i:d'cl.lemix 'I'ownellt.jp, C1.mborland Country, Penneylvanla,
91 At the !..idle and place of the accident, Defendaut.,Jeremy
Bull. Wan operating Stephanie Hrenemanl a 1990 Honda Civid au,omobi.l.e
owed/or enCUHted'to Stephanie 13ronnemiln,
S. AL the time and place: of the doi.dont, Plaintiff 't'imothy
Ol.i.ngor Waa a right; !:ear neat pannonger of the oir, operated by,
Def:ondant: Bull,
6, AL the time and place of: tho accident; nfendant- Jeremy
Pull wan travelling away from cnvlfrlao in the left lane of Route
'. 3!; lit 1
Is who aroo of who rauci,?dunl., Rollt.o 1.1. Ls it four I-ono
highway w:l (:h a largo ec,"wU r turn I qnu ;nld pnvod Hhouldea.trs r
13, Ronwo :t.'.1. .Ln who area r,C who, itcoldonw .I it it Mat IVol.y flat:
and straight root ion of highway with no ohntrunt ions to Vision fc'n'
motorists t:ravel.a.i.nd on who highway,
9. The 1IlLorsoakaoll of: Rollwo :I.:I. alld Roadway Drive A, 1-4
controlled by traffic lights which arcs strung above the highway and,
control the movomo k c,f traffic on both Route 1.1. and Roadway Drive,
10, The traffic control. :Lights are visl.blo for over one mile
for motor vehicles travelling in the d.i.reat tpn of. Defendant derotlly
11, At who time and place of: the accident: the pgsted speed
l.i.llit on Routo 11 Was forty-Vi.ve miles per your,
12, immediately before the accident the Waffle signal for
traffic on Route 11 in the direction that, Defendant aeremy Bull was
driving changed to yellow,
13, When t:he traffic signal. on Route 1.1. tanrned yol..l:oW,
Defendant- Uorremy Bull suddenly applied the bra ken of: the oar and
skidded out of control.,
14, upon applying the brakes,, the car driven by Weromy null.
skidded a distance of approximately 110 heel: through, the eonter
turn lane of Route 11,
1.5 r The oar driven by Defendant ' ,loremy Bull then spun in a„
clockwise direction and skidded approximately 132 foot: through the
southbound lane of! Route 11 into the entrance of nHP Trl.lalt.i.ng
2
1'e!'Iq.i.nFla .L c'c[.il l'. c9({ on tho We,, F.tida of
1=hc- ,il1 L',irJJQG t:{cn With ROMU
16, '1'ho Loft roar qugrLor panol of 'the dutollnhi.l.e, drivoll by
pef:eillclan" Ucn'e?Illy Bull th0P violently CnIAMI With the traffic
signal polo,
17, Poll.np,Wi.ntl t.h n Urnt Mica ool,l.i.r{.toil, the nutnmoh.i.ie I
became Airborne and spun twice in a. 360 degroo oa"ntor clockwise
direction,
IN , While spinning cotnat:or.'-clockwiae, Cho 1990 Honda C!:Lv.N
dr:i.ven by, pefondant Joremy Bull impacted with the ground and
cont.i.ntaed to skid apothor„160 foot acroun the front: lawn of ABP'
Trucking Terminal,
1.9, Vi.nall.y, the car automobile driven by Defendant: Oeremy
Bull., in which Plaintiff Timothy Olinger woo a passenger violent.l.y
collided on its right pannonger side into the a.1.do of a pick-up
truck parked in the n1111 Trucking Term.inal parking lot where it cattle
to rest,
20, The impact from ao,lliding with the traffic polo and the
p rked pick-up truck caused novtare dnmago to the entire automobile
in which and Plaintiff . Timothy Olinger wan riding an a' pasean90r,
21,- Tha multiple impact and violent Aidding and spinning of_
the car connect Plaintiff Timothy o.linger to be seriously injured,
fagUi.ri.ng him to be Immediately transported to Hara:i,nburd Hospital. ?
for treat:mont, I _
.1
1
2?, 'I'lls fcrl'ogo:lllrl acci.ifaIiti iitlcl .`.1111. o1: l-lle :Lhlllr.ara11 alld
d<-lnrlgofl HoL Cort:ll horolliaCLor mu I:a noel by ICietl.11t:1.1`f. 11''IIIIotilly
Uliliper alm Lille cLl.rcnal: alici prnXilijiltin rumi:ll.. of I:ho no(i11(Jollt:l
caar.'ia.laLita, illlci racer 1081.1 111rmi er 1.11 whicill, I)r,f:onchlilt: Totonly 1311:1.:1
oporatod a mULor voll.i.ra) ao fol.lowHI
(el) dl:'.lvi.ng it cull: at all OX0001ji.vo rat:a off flpend ellld i.il
a rook1oll a di.flroga>-cl , fior Llln 'rtaffnLy of; pimp6ngaa:H
allcl Ol:llar 1110tor:lkiLe oil I:ila. 111gllwayl
(b) c11.i.v:1.1-ig al:. a flpaacl wlli.ch would not. parlid.t. Ili-III 1:0
HaCaay, aoiit rel. Lila ca.v 4111d wlla.ch ha know, Or Hllotllci
hravo knowlli cn:oatocl a Htibf3Laptilal. .rfnk of hal:lll for
1l:L fl paHHellgarel'or oLhor motorlotti on L(lo 111gilwayl
(c) fa:l..l'ure t:a e.xaI'c.;ifie 1110 111g11 dogroa C) 1' a a r 0
"
roc.ini-red by <a IltotoriHLH eliL'a1 i.llg an tntorociat .o111
(CO Ca.i.lura to loop aloe:t: and Itlaini:rll.n a propel: watall
for the proHanoo of ol'.f:.i.C"I"O. (a:alit: 3.o cotlLro:lH oil
L'llo highwayl
(0) faIJJLIl:a to gala reaHOnabl.o evarilve act::Loll to avoid
Lim acci.cieritl
to havo the velli.e:l,a 1.111dor Huch aont:ro.l. as to
ho nlaa.e tic) HLop ty.i.l:ha.it I:ho aHHt.u:ad cl.oajr di,ri miaal
(d)... I`a.i.lur0 to obey t:raffla H1.dnal.131
..
(li) f•a.i.hwo tic) l.i:aval. al: a Hafa IIpoedi
(i.) ILli.11.1 a to troop proper aril aclocluate (!OtlI-.Vo:l. 0v61: the
va11:lalo 1
(I cir.i.vi.ng the voh.i.al.e upon the hi.gllway ill a mannol'
endailgarang h01:H011H and property and i.li' a rao)c.leHH
(nL11111or w.i.Lh c;rlrol,ews dhArogard to the ri.ghtn and
ficib-:y nf: ot:hors find Ill vi.ol.al:1011 of the Motor,
VoIllalo Coda oC I:ha 'C'onullonwoa:LLh or, PonhHyl.van.i'a,
3, Am it vonul.L of Lim aCoraHaid acci.dotll:, Pl.ailtl:i.l:i: A-1110thy
01.1ilger HuHtia l.ned pa.Lnl:u:1. filnl:.i.en w11.i.ch i.nc.lude, but ar.a' not
c,
1:11111telci to, ghrumfone to IoVJI lownu Ir,Crc,iq.it.aen, puflchurw wound '
:in him Wht: Wtooku, NoVoa'va rlbdomi.n;l.l. Ira-N Pnvuro hunk, pails, o
pnbi.c'a roman frnOL"ro, Cwo "I'Vta.o 1,111-vopornltchymal l.tlc"ntot:i.ono
resulting .1.11 a t- lPl.etllooto0ly, cow cl 0do fnyorm, and life threatening
ro111pl.i.caL•.i:nnn,
24, 1y vonson' of the clCoresai.d 1nJur.len sllntnJned by
Plaintiff 11mothy gl..inder, he wao forced tc: incur li'ab.il.J.hy for
med.i.cal. t:reatmeRt, medications, and ralmllmr mincollaheous eXPetases
in an effort: to romtorn hiWaalf to hoaith, and claim i.s made
therefor,
2g, Manse of the nattira of him injuriam, Plaintiff Timothy
Olinger has been adv.iaiod rand, therefore1 avorr.•i that he may be
forced to i.ncua: similar exponraera .i.n the future, and claim is made
therefor,
26, An a ronull-, of tho.. afovemontloned .i.njuries, Pl.a.i.nt.i.ff
Timothy, Olinger han undergone and in the future may undergo
physical and mental suffering, Inconvenience In carrying out his
da.i.l.y naLiNdtina, and loran of l.i.fe,s pleasures and enjoyment, and,
claim in made therefor,
?'l, Plaintiff Timothy Olinger cont-i.huen Co be pla nwid by
persi.st:nnt• pain and li.mi l.AJA ancl, therefore, avers that him
injuries may be of a permanent nature, r,atte.i.ng residual problamta
for the demander of him l Hot'Lm='., and claim A made therefor,
l? I
u ".
20, An na,i.•upulC of who Korma,flcl an'jurLqu, Plaintiff: Timothy
Ol'i'11(fer 11tH-1 Dolan, and 1.11 wh(.1 fllP.uro W:L'll. 1)r)1 m.lhjdcL' t:0 ga.l3i'lt.
h11m.ili.aC.inn and olilhnvramnmont:, and claim i? WHO thurof:or,
29, An a `romult: of tluj Injuries, Plaintiff
Timothy Olinger ban laumwaliw Work loss, loan of opportunity and a
permanent: diminl.lCloli of hat: oarning poWor-and capacity, and claim
in soda thorupor,,
30, Au a result: of who af:nrorlold injuries, Plaint iff Tlmot:hy
Olinger ban nuotgi.ned i.lncomponmajod _Work lnuu, and claim is made
therefor,
31, "' An a result: of who af:ot'clanid andident., Plaintiff Timothy
O.l.i.ngor has nur.itnined boarm which µ!.1.7.:I. result in a permanent
disfigurement, and claim In made therefor,
WN17RMFOI M, Plalnt il!l! demands judgment against Defendant in an
°amount in excess of TWonLy- FIvA Thounanrl ($2R, 000) -Dollars,
11
exclusive of interest and costs, and In excess ofi any
jurisdictional amount requiring compulsory arbitration,,
ANCJV 171
z.
MI c 11e1. Ll, 1 oei.k, Maguire
l,'D, No, 36513 „
4503 N, Pront Street:
Harrisburg, PA 17110
(71:7) 2:30 6791
counsel for Plaintiff
„
6
i
Y 1?1131.[?: IVCh1'.T ?N
T1,`1'TMOTFIy 01-iTN131?jt, dd horoby Pwoar apcj d1.Ji1.1'ill Chic. C.he f:;}aLp
1381: lfor.l:ll 1.I1 Lilo f1?1'ogoa.il9 (100111110111: arch 1:1?no and (jorroaL Co Ole I
))opt of Illy k1lotY.10dgo, 111for.Illal:l•011 aI'Id be.1-tclf, l: mlclevrjl:mlci that,.'
1:11:GH 1,10ri.f3 ,r.,p1:1011 1.0 Illada nub; fool: a:0 C11ca pnpiJ.1:;?,uFi of 111 PcC,.9 ?
9904, rol.at*.Ing t:o Itnoworll falFlafi:a(Il:i.oll to, eull:hov.IIA.np,
T.TIA0'I'11 1 T.NC11 R
Da t ad
? ??, ; ' ,: ((171R?4A1Af _ °i .
? 1`lc ?tl 'l,i cih1
I f ?. t 1? ' . „ !t "' ' ;
? L
??
,1.: 1 If
i i 7 !4 ( 1l? 11 1 t( 1 It., (,
.ry.M1.4? d! e , 1 '1 'O 1 1 ix ? , 1J\
1II1!
n[ . 15S,
kt
'I''(MO'1'l1Y OLINOIdIt I N '1'111? COURT OF ' COMMON I: td1AS
I?:L<1 L11L:1.1'I` CUMI]16RLIANI) cOuNFvY,_Pli;NN£IY1 ANIA
i
V' CCVII, ACTION - bAW
i. NO, Ili-5M
t111RIilM?' l3llI?L _ I,,
Dol:crndanL 1 ilUltY 'I'ita'A1.1 DI?MANDIiIp
OTI:Ci
YOU t1AV11 BERN HUMID IN COUR'T',- IF yoll Wi.i3h to dofelicl 'Iyaillnt
.
tile 01g.i.41f) not f;ortal 1.11 the followj1llc7 pagoo, yotl tlluflt: Lace aapaon
W11:11111 t:Welll:y (20) dayo Aft-or L11113 Colllpl.a:lnl: and Not-aan are) flot'ved,
by 011t eri.ng q Wrft.ten appea rglicio pol.°I.ioljal.l.y Or by al:Loruoy, alld
fi.l.illg i.n W.ri.tIng WiL'11 tales Court. yoilr dofenaes or objoot lops to Lhea
al.0.1flo FjeL for:Lll agai.llyt you, You are warned Lll.1v If yogi fai.a. to.
CIO yo tile caae Ilvly Proceed W1.Lhovit yot.l and a f udgm0lit may bo
entered agal.nHt: yOtt by 1:110 Coul'L W.i.t:hOUe f•tlrLllor 110L•.i.n0 for ally
Molloy 01.11.Illed 1.11 Cho Co111Pl.ai.nt: or for any Other al.ai.tll-or rol.1.6f
requested by tale Pla1.nL:i.f•f, You llmy_1013o Molloy or. proPorCy or
of:ller rigllta iloportanl: to yotl,
YOU SHOULD TAKU THIS PAPER 1110 YOUR LAWYER A'I' ONCI , .11-, YOU DO
Nom IIAVII A LAWYER OR CANNOT APPORD ONE, 00 1110 OR TrLa1PItON1? THE
OPPICS SHIT POR'PII BELOW 'i'O G'IND OU'T' WIIIDRE YOU CAN GHT TAMAL, IMLiP,
13ar Asooci.gti.on
Cuillbol'l.and Cot.lnty
,
2 L,ibert:y Avenue
CarIA.Fj10, PA 1.707.3
1i (77.'7) 249-3166
i
TIT. k
. . . I _ 1 r. 1 Irr 4 r-r ivI„
NOTTCTA
lava 11c 11 tlf1 III IIIl C1 f1 C1 o it tln l: ad Ca II .I Et ClOI'lail, 3a IICl C(,I (;lll.l. 0 1'Fa 0101`C1 clr. rfan
de aFA L'c3I1 aallkllldafl expueaLEIFI nn Tzlrl pElgillan F11 gt0.111:oIII Illit.od tJ.01ia
V:I.alll:n (30) cll.ttF] eta pial0 E11 pt.lr(A.I, c(n 1.a fcaollo do to dollifinda y 1.q
I1 ot;1 1.`1.o Aa:1.oII Unl:ncl dolxt pL"eFlolit.ar min anI1c1a.F1 00a]':Ll:'I C) all
., pornolla 0 pol:' abogado y drolt.i.val- on as Clort:0 fall,, forlllcl afiorita fma
clof(a11f1ElH o F11IF.I ob?aOC,:l:onao a 'Tap dollh'Ulcla0 all c"olltlr,l de ou-perflOI161,
'goa E1Vi.faacio qua fai. tl@Lod no ye clnf:iollcle, la corLo Lolmo,ct ipocliclElQ y
pl.lndp,0llLr.E11' LIIJEJ 'doI I aonl.ra I1f]L0el 01.11 pl-OVID clVi.HO 0 110tif:i.aa01.011 y
holi C71.Iill.C(t.i(.41, clt.lo;ja o 91A.vi.o qua o0 1Dndic10 on la pel.:1.01.011 de domanclel,
Ufllaid ptlodo pordor diners o nii0 pl:opa.edad0n 0 CILroFJ d6r00110f1 .
i•I1lpojrulncefa PEIra Wit:ocl,
L, iRVN @EITA DI MANDA A UN ARODAGIO :INMLIDTA'1'AMl N7'A, 93: NO TT.LINI!
A130DAC40 O ST NO TT.RN1 1:114 D1:NRR0 ,SILIPTCT111N'1'il D111 WAR TAL+ 911RVTCT.O, VAYA
'N P1 R80NA O L+L,AMM POR 'I'I LEFONO A LA OI TCTN4 CUYA DTRIi1CCTON DP
ItINCUf+1NTRA TPISCRTTA A13AJO PARA AVRRIGUAR DONDiH 91E PUBDII CONSHOUTR
A,9T5'VWNC.T.A LEGAL,
Ctllllbal-Land Cotmt*y Bar AfaOooiat:ion
2 TA,borl:y Avenue
Call:ll.01e, PA 1:70:1.3
('71.7) 249-31.66
TIMOTUY 010NOWR 1 IN THR COURT OP' COMMON PL HAS
PAInt.i ff 1 CIIMBHRhAND COUNTY, PhNN,9YAVANIA
V. i CIVIL ACTION - LAW
? Np, 9f1-!i22t;
OORNMY I3[.I1.IJ i
Dof:c?ndanC. I JURY TRI:Ai. DRMANDIHD
1, Plaintiff, Timothy Olinger In an adult: individual who
currently resides at 490 Fairground Ave, Carlisle cuillba.r.l.nuld
Country, Pennsylvania,
2, Defendant Jeremy Bull, in an adult i.nd.i.vi.dual and citizen
of the State of Massachusetts and has a mailing address of 333 IHaht
Columbus Avenue, Spri.ngfiald, MA 01109,1-
3, The facts and occurrences hereinafter related took place
at approxi.mate.ly 9110 p, m, on Sunday, January, 26, 1997, on State
,
Route 11 (Carlial.e Pike) near its intersection with Roadway Drive
in Middlesex Township, Cumberland County, .Pennsylvania,
4, At the time and place of the accident, Defendant Jeremy
Bull. Was operating Stephanie 1lroneman's 1.990 Hondai Civic automobile
owned/or entrusted to Stephanie 'Brenaman ,
5,. At the time and place of the accident, Plaintiff `timothy
Olinger wart n right: rear Gnat passenger of the car operated by
Defendant Bull,
G, At the time and place of the accident, Defendant Jeremy
Bull. Was travelling away from Carlisle in the left lane of Route
144400/MMM
! 111 1:110 ill: oit (,If t*Ito aac:1. d o l l l:, 12olI t: cI 1.:1. :Lp it f;otu' Lillif,
11:1.gtwit y.. wi l:h a '10vl In eecltor tlu 1 a<uie) it lid pit VOd a11 ol11dc1,Ft ,
f1, Itiml:o I.A. .1.11 1:11a ill-ai:t of t:li:1 tloa:Lc1c3111: i,rl it ro.1.10.1voLy flat:
i
and al rci:Lc3}il: nect:lon of: higliWay w1t:11 no obal:rllctiona t:c V:l.pi 11 for
IICol:or;LFtl:k7 I:ravOa.la.ng on t:ho highway,
11'110 lllt;orociot:i.ol1 of R0111.0 .1:1. alld Roitclwdy ]7.vlvo, J, ti
controa.a.ctd by l.r,itf:f..lu :I:Ighta whi.all am atrung above Hia highway and
control the 4lovemonl, of t'raff'..Jo on bol:ll Routo 11. and Roadway Drive,
1.0, The traffic control lights are vitillhl0 for over' pile 411.1.0
fQV 1noLor VOhi.al.ea t-.raW11.1i.ng i.Il t:ho di.r.ection of: Def0ndanl: ,:f01:'0111y
13u1.'L ,
1.1., At. the timle and place of the aael.dent the poal:0c.'t apegcl
l.ianit on RolttO 1.1 WFac1 fort:y-• f i.V0 Illi.1.08 par hour,
't.2, 1.1nlnOdiit0l.y bef:orO the accident the traffic nignal, fior,
ti.affic oil Route 1.1. in the direct:i.on that Defendant Jerellly 131.111. Was
dt:i.vi.ng allanclod to yellow,
13, When t1lo ttraf:fic signal oil Rout0 1.1 ttirned yellow,
Defendant Jai.elny k3t11.1. Faudclenly ,ippl.ied the brakes of the cat: and
alcidcled out-of control.,
1.4 , Upon applying tile brakea, the car driven by Jerelily,13ull
ski.dd0d,,, a distance of approximate.1y 11o feet t•ht:ough the center
turn lane or. Rouge 1.1.
1.13, The car driven by Defendant Jeremy Bull than spun in a
e.l,oekwi.ao divect•i.on and skidded pproxitnat0ly 1.32 feet' through Lilo
aotithbound „hUiO of Route 1.1. into' tho etitrance of AD Trucking
i 2
o ,
I'Itl'lllllYl.I. :Ir?c'ial:etrl rill tale Weill: 1111de of 1_hn Illtol:faec:I::Loll W:Lbh Kollto
16 'Place :,. rail. a'ctetr rh1111'I:rat' pallua ali lale lJtltoliloha.l.ey r'lI::LVr31'1 by
pcif;encla111: Joroilly I.ltla.:l. t:holt V:I.O:Lon1:1y cu:,l.a;.adetd W:LI,h Llle Ia'El l'.f1.ct
Ili.gllal polo,
1,'7, 1'o:l.a.oWa.ng lala:la f::lrlit.. V:101.0111: coa.a.a.y.i.op1 tho autotllobi.l.ca
boriallle airborlle and 13ptgl tW1.C:o :1.11 it 3ti0 degreo collllt:or c:Loc:ICWirlo
d.i.a'aol:i.011
1.0, WIIi.1.0 PJAIIna.llg countoa:-c:l.ockw.l.lao, t:he 1990 Honda civic
dxi.veit by pUf:endapt ,7eaelily Ilua.a. :LnlpacLorl WIHI the g.rotuld alld"
conl:i.nued to rik:Lcl :atlother 160 foot. acx•orlra Ole lir.ollt lawn of: 4131'
'1'r.ttclCind Ter.tlli.llit7.,
1.9, Pina:l.ly, Lhe caa: outoltlohil.o dr:l.Ven by polienrlatlL r7ea:elily
Bull.; i.al Whi.cli Plailltil;f 'Pi.itlothy ol.i.ngor Warr a parareengoa: vi.o.lently
col.li.cled oil il:ee right paQk+ellger aide into the side of a pick-up
truck parked in the AIAI 'Pruflking '1'ermi.na.l. parking lot where i.l: came
Lo a'er.4 t:,
0, 'P1lo illlpaot froth col].:I.di.rlg wi.th the Lr.afliic pole and Che
parked pick-up t:a:uelc eaUtlecl aevere da111age to Hle entire outomobi.l.e
in Which and P.l.ainti.f.f 'i'i.mOLIly Olinger wala ricli.rlg a13 a paooenger,
?.l, The null.H.ple impact and violent 13ki:c1di.ng and 13pi.nni.ng of
the car eauned P1.ailll iff 'PilltotIly 01.i.algea: to be taeri.ounl.y injured,
requiring him to be immeclintoly trallt3ported to Ilara:i,f3btlaac? lloapital
for treatment
J?, 'I'llo f:oi•etlo:ing aoc:Lclnllt= tlllcl +1.1:1 of In i.11;It1r.1.e? cll'td
daltlagon aet: fol:•l:)I Ito 1,01.11afL(Ir ftllilt11Illed by l'.'1 c11.11t:11: lllothy
:Li• Ilc,a r ?l
Q ' rU I'. he da, rec. tt: glld p.rox Illlil to Coit11.1 f. q1: t:Ito 11 agl..l tla 11 l:,
ca rel.etta, and reokloon Inlnnor 111 Wll:l.ah polioLldi1111: Cleanly I1u1.1
opal w:od a motor vall:Lol.o eta, fo:I.:Lolyo I
W) dr:Lvirlg a cilr at clil exoeoH:lva I'ot'a of apeocl ttlld itl
rl rook1arm d1ml-aclard for tha atlfol:y of pwillollgera
and ot:llol Illol:n'1':Let:e oil the IlIghwayl
(b) d1,A0110 at a apaed Whi.all Wot1:Lc'I not: perllli.t 11:1.111 to
safely control the oar and Whi.all ha know, or alloilIcA
have kilowil, preatec:l a atlbrltallt:tat. ra:ak of harlll for
11:44 paaaeilgeria 01:? othar Illotoriyt:ri, on tale h:Lgllwayf
(c) 11,11.111re to (I xoroi.Ha the high cleg1.a0 of care
regtti.red by a Inotor.lot-H entering an inte.r.aect:ioni
(d) fai,.lt1re to keep a1.er.t: and mal.Itta:111 a proper. Watch
1:
.or tile proyetlao of offii.ci..11 trafifi.c colit.volij on
the Ili.ghwayl
(o) fa11tu'e to talce r.oaaonablo oVM3A.V0 aat.i.olt to aVoi.d
the accidentl
(f:) fCIA. hire Co have the Va111.a.1a ultder at.lah aontrol all to
be ablo to atop wItlli.ll t-]lp aaatlred c71-oar diet.•alloa l
(g) fail"re to obey traf:f:i.a 13;1.gllalaf
(h) faI'litre to gravel at a aafe apoedl
(1.) fai..ltu,e to keop propel:' and aclegwlte control over t: lie
Vehicl.eI
U dri.vialg the Vohi.al.o upon the highway All a Inanller
andatlgeri.ng pel-aoha and proporGy and III a r.ecltleaa
manner wi.t•h eareloaa di.o egard to t•he rl.ght•p rl)id
safety of otharo and i.n violition of the Motor
Volliale Code of the Colnlnonweal.t•h of Pennaylvani.El,
4
U I A M .I'.
TIM"I'lly OI,,IVUId1; V. ORR MY 1111111
23, P.u'agraphll :I I:Ilrcrngh 2, of I:11 u Co111p1alttl'. argil :Lot,o1:'pol't1Cec1
herei.ll by 1:rr1ierI o11ca,
24, ALI a rer.nllC o1.' l:110 afornsaid Ilco:l.dnllL, P.Ullllciff '1':I.nlolaly
011.110er' ntlElCa:ltlocj pa.i.nl'117. :Ltljul"Iml) Which .lnal.luie, bill.. are clot:
11.11ti.f.ad Co, a??rasaons Lo bot'll lOWe1: nxt:relni.L.LrIH, a p1111aLtlrn wound
:L 11 Ili. FA night: 17it Ll:ocjkn, Cleve va albdolna.nal. pai 11, nave I.'e back pa 1.11, a
PV0:dc minus fracLllrn, I:Wo F:Ipl.olt.i.e :Lllln°?parenchyma]. lacerat:l.ollo
resulting. i.n a Hp1eliect:only, 1.oW evade Covers, and 11.f:n Lhreat:elli.ng
colnp1A, ca l:10IIL;
25, By reason of` t:hn af:oreflai.d J.njuri.en sustlai.ned by
Pla1.ntif f '1'1.1110thy ol.ingor, he was forced l:o Incur 1i.abi1l.l:y for
medi.cal. treatment, mocll.catlons, and o.lmi.1.al: I11.1.nCeit.alleouf7 expnnsep
i.n an effort La rostore lti.msol.l: t:o heal.l:h, and claim is made
therefor,
26, 13ecatlne Of On naltu'e of hi.s injuries, P1.a1.11Li.f:1: `Pilnot'hy
O.littger Ilan bean advi.sed and, (therefore, avers that he may be
forced to 1.nam: eilllilar expellner; fil the f.uturol and claim i.s made
therefor,
j 27 , An a rentl1t of the f11(or'ementi.olled injuri.en, P.lai.ilt'iff
i
'l i'mothy Olinger: has undergonn and i.n t:he future roay undergo
phyai.cal and ment:a]. nuf'f:eri.ng, filoollve111ence in carrying out his
daily activi.t:aen, and loss of l.ife'tr pleasures and enjoyment', and
el.al.n1 '1.e ,1»ade therofor ,
5
,
1
2t1, I?Lal.nt:a.ff 'fiptc,t.hy W,l,rts,ler c.ronAlnuun ti) ho phiquod I'>y
pormintont pain ttnd, limitation andr thopuVoru, avriCn Cllal' hio
l.njur.ion may he of a pnl"nlnnollt nmf.uru, cauning vol.+:Lriual l?r??Uaaagttl
for the reminder of him .I Lfutimu, and claim in made whornfcar,
'20, Am a result of tho aforonnid Injur.i.on, l'Latutillf Timothy
Olinger Ilan boon, and in the Future will. lie, subject to great
humiliation and olltbarramomant, and caal.m in made I boa°el`or,
30, An a result: of the aforementioned injurlant Plain'
Timothy Olinger has nunt:ained„Work loran, Iona of opportunity and 'a
permanent d$m.i.nuLiO" of him earning Dower and capacity, and claim
is made therefor,
31An a result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff: Timothy
Olinger has nuatai.ned uncompensated work loss, Gild claim in made' u
therefor,
30„ As a result of the aforesaid accident, Plaintiff Timothy
Olinger has sustained sears which will r.enult A a permanent
disfigurement, and claim in made therefor,
WHIARNFOR1, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendant in an
amount.' in exoenn of Twenty-Five Thousand ($2b, Ooo) Dollars,
exclusive of interest and costs, and in 'exooon of any
YJur.iodictional ayomut requiring compu.rnory arbitration,
COUNT 11: - PUN:1TTVS, DAMAGNS
Tl:MO'PIIY OLINURI? V. L711RWMY 13UfaLj
33, Paragraphs I through 22 of the Complaint: are incorporated
herein by reference,
6
iQ; I'i icar k.o OuT cx.cl.lrrOlloo of tho afo.rcn a I d acnldoIII*'I
Itnfolldant: Jnrc»lly 1.111]10 HhaphHuLo BlynomonI an well. all Itnvnin I other
co•wot:Icea:'h incJudIng T:I.Mnthy Oling", Woro at thn (141011DIO Country
Club for a brunch hontod by StlophHoiu Br.enelmnn,
3S, Unbeknownnt to Timothy oa.i.ugor, Dufondanit ,'terellly 11101.
connttmod a lavao amount" of alcoholic wevoumgon at (-•he c'ar:I.101o
County Cluj), primarily in Uho form of bong Island Too Teas,
11
36, Plaintiff 'Timothy olineor had been nent:od at another
liable with other co-woricorM other. than Jeremy Bull and therefore
Was not: aware that , oromy Bull wan conolulli.llg al ' large amount: of
alcoholic boVorndoo,
37, Plaintiff: Tim v1.i.nger has become aware that Defendant
Jeremy Bull hap alleged as New Matter in a previous claim which was
brought: agai.not lit, by Barbara Joan Layne, ghat: he Was intoxicated,
38. T.n his New Matter, Delionda"t JOrOMY Bull has also alleged '
that the Ca>:liple County Club oorved him alcoholic beverages at a
time that-. he was v.l.sib:l.y intoxicnted, See New Matter filed in
C"mber.land County to ci.vi.l action no, 98-A0M
39, Plaintiff Timothy Olinger has learned that a blood test,
i taken on Defendant Jeremy 13u1.1, some time after the motor vehicle
accident showed a blood alcohol level of ,29 percent,
AU, Plaintiff Timothy Olinger does not recal.l observing 'qny
conduct: out of character for Defendant Jeremy Bul..l. While at the
Carlisle Country Club and While p.roparing Co leave until' the
Defendant, accelerated no alleged previously in him complaint,
7
I
j '
i
(11, If: Dtl'cnldilnl: 0011110y Hill I.'P 'I.I:Ieclalti(All I 1;1Wit: Ile Wclo
i.111:ox:LCttltnrl mid Ciel'Ved Cllaollo.lAcA hnvol-iig(Ill by l'.hlj Ccnlltl:ry
c1mb htyond tho po;l.IA oi.' vifll.hlu .I.Ilt:oxioation avo true, Pl.iIIIII'Aft.'
l':Llllol:hy O1 a.11c,'?er Illa11IL-cl.1111i T-lult Do1'cttldant I.It11.1 know of pho11:LC'I have
ICnoW11 hhal: lie Waf+ t+nvotn:ly i.nl:ox:Lcat(ld "lltd tUlaha.u to malinty oporcit:o
a IllCtta'r Vnh:Lca.e,
4:1, Dof.etldatlt:. (lore111y H111.1,.011ot11d Imvo known or kilcm that hip
aotldtlat ill oporat.ing a Illotor velligao W111..1-o i.ut:ox,tClated aonul:.i.t:ul:ed
ot.ltragootlp oollduat and a reakl.orio .I.n(-I1f iiovonao to tile righta altd
0afoty Of: athorn on tale highway, as weld. a0 the oaatlpalltm of the
Illotm. vellic1o Wil:i.ah lie ullono to operate,
43;' Dofelldal'IC Jornilly HUD. E11101110 litiv.e known or knew that
oparat:i.tlg a 11101:01 vohi.c1c) Whi..lo i.ntaxi.oated created a high degree
of l"iFA of :I.njl.lry I:o other peroQnfl an the 11.1.011Way and tile ocampallts
of Ilis veltio1e,
44, Defondant• avoilty 13111.1. ohoul.d have )mown or )plow that Ilia
cotldtlat of reak1a001y operating'' a vehi.al.o. at a high 'rate of 0peod
wltil'a i.ntoxi.oated conyti.tut:en outragoaus conduct and a rec)t1a0a
indifference to the orattpant0 of 111.0 V011101:e,
45, Dofotldant Joromy Ht1.1:1. 01lolt1d have known or knew that )lie
colldtlct in operating a Iltotor veltfal.e while he wa0 intoxicated at a
high rate of 0poed and approaching a t:ratifia ei.gnal. Which waH ill
the proce00 of changing, clieplayed' w.i.11.f:ul, wanton, and reckl.eap'
i.ndifforetlce for the 1:i.gltto aTtd 0afety Of h.i.0 oacupallt0 alld°ot•herh
Oil tile highway,
e
oi, ;old nonr uov by hrilaand= ,1nromy 11111.3 unnftt :I.Gtt4rafl wnnt:nn
1 ,
41111 WHO Ill,'ca.3ronar? alnd At, otll:i'tllacaatln end nnl:al:aurl l'3aa.nt::1:f
T:Imothy Oli.tlyr:111 to an award of p"n3t:3VO dam€ge ,
WHIi;ItGlFUI W, Plaintiff demunc' o judgmont: ngni not pt andant in an
amount: Ln oxcu n of TWont:y-1 ivo Thanwond , (026,000) DollmVp,
Oxa: "@A.vn of intovout nttci aarlCti, and Or nxaartw oC any
jur.i d3ot:innnI amount: requiring aompn:luory a.r.h.i.t0tion, i.naa.tlding
punitive danlrl9ev,
RNCITN - 01 o/NNK
irdllao. il, ICciF?iJt, liir?c3t.ti.i?o
.:,p, No, 361118
4803 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, PA07110
(717) 230 679:1:
dat.ntno3 for Plaintiff
9
„
VOW
MICI 1Ahilc 11, It(.)rl'II( mn,91HRIII do 1)(31'017y FlWo,lr r1lPl ii CV 1.1'11 Glift
I:IIn I'Lint:(J t1n1: f:o1.1'rll I It kiln Co1'ngo:1ny nlllnli(lncl l!nlpl'(1,111.11t: 11 vu triln f1lirl
anvve( t: 1=n t'11o 1?(ap11: n1.' Illy knaWI.nclgoc inl:rormatAolt mi(I ba.l.i.(a1; I
Ullclot^tll:r111r1 1:11111'. L111n Vcal'l.ltloal:anll lti Illarln HIIb;?onC l.o t:ho holla.LL'i.ofl
of I:llo R117.no n1' CI.V:II Procor111rn 1'nlat:1110, L'o 1111r1Worn f: takla.l`.ibtlt.a.o11
hn aUl',11o1°:L l:ictGt,
.r
W:C'I'NIu9,91 ? j? ?!
1C0S TK( 17,9QC17atll
Da todt ?._ ?, ? -_
r.
r 10
1i
AND NOW, I:Ilip ;?l;l'.h ?i=lY c>I; IpIl1 Ell°y :1.995) [, Mf.cijta:Lara M
M.1.:i.o;)aV:Lcil, illl (I111p.10Y(u nl.' A11c1;1.11(1 & hgVllol', PC„ cJo ilnl'c11?Y c1?1'l:i.f'Y
thot :I he1VC1 LI01.'Voci El I: P.LIe r111C1 cx1'tuc':L-u'('1?y 1?li 1:11c) AMIiIVU1,I) COMPLA.IN']' I
Lrl I:IIU IJlla,l:c?ci 411 tlba+a pllla.a., pclClLarlc?, p1'npel:Ld tll; IIOL'l:':Lelhlll'C?,
PallllfaY.I.Valll:LEll ilci(ironaa(1 1111 1.'o:L:LaWf11
poh?l7.d 13., II0YL•, MOCILlIVO
13T AKIN, YOFJ'P, 13111)1 k ,gC!IIA(JMAIgN
:1.7 14" mgi-kcit: '9tronL,
York PA 7.19 0:1:
r 1?7? ? L
I? M:LaIla-
7.:La M. M:L:L?,.Javi.all
r ,
i
i
r
. `t
}r
I
TIMOTHY OL rNUUIt t 1 N 'rill, Comm, Ov C'6MMON PhWAS
?1. Ft1•I1G:If:(: 1 CAIM13111MANDC!OUN'1'YpTENN13 MANIA
V, L:I:Vl:li ACT:I:ON - LAW
NO, 911-b?,211
aHl IZ 14MY 13UI,1,
pnf0ncielnl i MJRY,'1'It1.AL DIBMANDED
ZIL?'•1' 1" 1'111 C' !I_ OP R 1: CHI
1 DONALD 13, IIOY'1', DIyQU.T.RI 41quap: r30irvi.a0 of. 1:110 o11010riaci
JtI11FIi:U'y
COMPLAINT oil 1301101E of. Jerc)Illy, 13ti.1.1. l:liip 1)1:11 clay of, 4}f 01W) a.f
J
DtslIAM 13, IIOyL IiF3gtlj.re
14R22:3/MMId
T7 A
IN't'lil? C'(IUIt'I' t117 COMMON 111,17AS
OF (IJMIII?RI.ANP COUNTY, I?FNNSYI.VANIA
CIVIL ACTION ION - I.AW
TIMOTHY OWNtil?It No. .')H-522H ?,'Ivll'I'orn1
NInIn1111' ,
yo,
,lC?Isl?MY IIUI,1,
Dul'undnnt ,
vH, ,
CAI;1,181.1? COUNTRY C1.,U11 JUhY'1'It1A1- DCsMANT)I?h
Addlllum it Dolbndonl
NO'I'1CI
TO; CAIt14Ih1,P• COUN'I'IIV CI.11p
YOU I IAVI313131?N SUFI) IN COUR'T', IF YOU WISH TO DI?FFND ACIAIN91" I'1113
CLAIMS S17T FORTH IN I
TWl3NTY (20) DAYS AI 118 COMFL,AINT ANT) NOTICE A103 SI3RV13D I3Y
RNTI'RINQ A WKIT 1'RN AFI'I?AKANC131'17RSONAIA,Y Olt 13Y AT 1'ORNFY AND FILING
IN WRITING WI'I'II THR COURT YOUR Dl?FFNW8 Olt O13J1?C'I'IONS'1'0'I'1 113 CLAIMS'
sm, FOR'I'I-1 AGAINST YOU, YOU ART? WARNFI) TI IAT IF YOU FAIL TO DO 80,11-111
CAR, MAY FROCI?I7D WI`T'I IO1JT YOU AND A JUDCIMIKI' MAY 1317 ' RN'1'171MI)
AGAINS'T' YOU 13Y THE COUR'T' WITI JOUT FUIVITIVIt NOTICE FOR ANY MONI3Y
CLAIMED IN 1I113 COMPLAINT OR FOR ANY 0111138 CLAIM Olt 1071,1131 It13QUPST171)
DY'I'lil3 PL.AINTIFI7 YOU MAY 1,0817 MONRY Olt PROPERTY Olt 01'I113It RIGHTS t
IMPORTANT" 1'O YOU, ?.
I
YOLJ SI10UI..1)'I'AK13'l'IIiS FAFlilt'I'O YOUlt I-,AVVYI?Il A'I' ONCIII, IF YOU DO
NOT I IAVI3 A LAWY lilt Olt CANNO'T' AItFOI(D ON F, GO TO 010131,1?PI-IONI; Tl III
OFFIC13 SI?T 1701t'I'l l 13Hj,OW'I'O FIND OI. T WII17R13 YOU CAN C117I' 1.13GA1.. Ip31.:P;
Cuntborlnnd County Unc ANHoointion
2 Llbooy Avonuo
CnrliHlo, FA 17013
'I'olohliono (717) 219-3166
AV.ISO
1159'1',1) IIA 9100 PI'%MANDAVO EN 14A CORTIOt SI 089'111) P11817A
PFITNP17R9111)11 I..A8 QUIDASHNIIUI7S'1'AS FN I,AS I'ACIINAS ShU111N'19;5,1)171117 .
TOMAR ACCION PI7NTRO 117 VGIN''11(20) WAS A PARTIR P11 I,A PI I IA FIN QUl7
10101110 I.A PAMANPA Y 111, AV180. USTFP 11,1)11 11107811NTAR COMPAR17CIINCIA
I7SCRITA I7N 11111tSONA OR POIt AROCIA1O Y 11107S11NTA FN I.AW CORTF POit
I1SCIkITO SUS g111'1?NBAS O SUS 01311TION IS A I,AS PPMANPAS FN SU CONTRA,
SP 1-I1 AVISA QUII 81 NO 8I1 PI117117NPA,111., CASO PUIIPII PROCM)FIt SIN UST1371
Y LA CORTF PUFP11 OIiCIPIR IIN SU CONTRA SIN MAS AVISO O NO'I'IPICACIION POI(
CUAWUA11t PINIIRO IWIXAMAPO IIN 1,A PHMANIA O POR CUAhQUIIJR 0TItO
QUI71A o COMPIINSACION I(FIC1,AMAPOS IM lily PIIMANPANTI.I. UST111) 11U11P11
PI1RP171t PINFRO, O PROPIPI)APIIS O OTROS 1FRECHOS IMPOR'I'ANT118 PARA
US'I'11P,
L,LI,VI; ENTA 11',MAN1A A UN AIIOQAIO (NNIEMIATAMEN99',,
SI IISTrI) NO 991'1NI'1O No CONOCI', UN AIlOGA1O, VAYA O LLAMI; A LA,
OFICINA EN LA 1IRItCION l,SCRITA ARAJO PARA AVI'.RIGUAR DONIM,
Plll&UP, OII'I'ENVIt ASISTENCIA LEGAL,
Cumhorinnd Caugty Ilnr Asenointlon
2 Uborty Avomic
0p91HIo, PA 17613
Tolophollo (717) 2,1()•31 Gti `.
f{€
to
I,N'I'lil? COURT 011 COMMON 1'1,11AS
OIT COMIll',ItI,ANP COUNTY, III;"HYINANIA'
CIYII, ACTION • I.AW
TIMOTHY CLINOVII, No. 08,52211 Cl011,ol•111
1'1111111111' .
VH,
a1?Izr.MY 11U1-L. '
?aol'cndnnl ,
VH,
CAR1,I51.4-1 COUNTRY Mt-111 .IURY'I'RIA1, hf?MANIVI)
Additlnnid hulun(Innt
DEWENDAN'12 IQUE ,AIN'I'
4GAINSTADDITION?L DEFENDANT
Dofond11nt, dorulily 111111, Ily 11110 Ihrrntgh III" nllornpyH 0111,ccor(I Ilorcin, Ilhlkoy, Yost, Rupp
R: Sch11tnn11nn,1.1-p, 1101,0bY 11108 I1IH Complnlllt monist the Addlth,11111 hclbtl(111111, C11rIIHlo Crnmlly
Clu),11nd HlnteH its 111110m:
I. Dofund11nt, dummy 11u11, 11n n(1i11t ill(Ilvf(Itllll roHiding lit 27 Cluvulond Stroot,
Apnrtmew 1, Springflold, MS 0110111 IN nonlod nH tllo solo boibli(Imti 1111110 orlgin(11 11ctloll 11100
horolrl, n 11110 gll(I corrcel copy o1'which IH (nwelled t1H 1101bit "A,° 11i1(I hluorporo(ed horcin by
roful'otloal 1
2, Addlflnnnl hofbndmil, CorliHlo Coumly Chub, Is 111-iv11to Club onlorlng to Its Illembers
,
and thou pCH18, 1oc111e(I 111 1241 I Im'riHbtlrg I'Iko, CnrllHlo,1'A,
1, Thu Conunolttvo1111h of 1101111Hylvnnlll Ims ellacted two suctions (Illdor 1110
I'o1111Hylvnnln Llguor Codc whioll provide rot' 1110 Imposition 01,01v111111h1111y 1tllnlltet n I1c0n40e a1'
I
i
lit Ilolmsylvillllll I'llwo1' Volill'Ili II11or blbr IIPIto it 8 oro110 of Its IIPp11HPP iIIOar P1ratI11181itI1Pa8 HtIPit
its do4Prliml III ilia Gomplninl
;, 171lo.C.SIA ? 1.193(1) pn,viclON Ili III, "II 811111) ho it III1INVAI1(I) for olly,IIPPIIHPP pl,
.. Ihu 11olvd, or m1y pillployou, Hprvallt or 1180111 111' HIM) IIPunsve 1o Sol I,11n-n14f1 or 81vv+. any liquor or
11i111tad or browoll bpvoragOH, m' 10 11Pr1111t 11ny liquor or nllilt od ar InOWOd•hevul111sp4 to ba Hu'ld, !
1111'1118hotl or BlvPll, to ally porHoll vI4Ih1y Illtoxlonico, or In illly III41111c pol'Holl, or II1h1o1', PI' to I
1111111mol (1r11nk11rdH, or pol'HollN ol'kilown liltunlporillp hHbltH."
S, §+-49Y1) Ill to ho rowl In coldnnotinn wlih H1497 whIall provlclb4,-11 No IIPan HaO
8111M 110110/)10 in 11111'11ar4onH oil licooillll okfill lBOH Illlillolell• ppoll thont oil'thP 110011800 111-01111808
l
by cmipluor40,1110 110011800 ullIOH4 ilia ouHloplol' Who In111o1H Iho (1(111111808 Wn8 Hold, all-1118110 or
131volt liquor, of 11111Iled of brow0d hovorilgoH by ilia Hold Ilcumgo nl' hIH 1180111, Horvnnl or u111p16yop
When tile H1d110uNW1110r W11H vlHibly 11110*3010(1,"
61 The Adclltlomil Pol'and1111t woH it licplisoo (11'010 Lkillor Conlrol 13oord 1101,61'0, oil' flild
r. 111jor Jolimily 26, 1997.
7. On Jonmlry 26, 1997, ilia Pal'andinit ,tor0111y Mill ongligod In it (Illy ordrlnklllg Which .
tt111n1111oly rosolled In 111111(11-1 1118 1x11110 Inloxioalod 11111 nllogodly cotising Illy to the 1'Ia111tiIT
'1'1111P1hy Ollligor,
9, 011 Jnnuilry 26, 1997, at approximately 12,3011 M, the Dol'OndHnl arrivod at ilia
Additional DolbnclmiCH club,
101 While al ilia Addillonni Dol'ondont'H ulub, the 001,011(a11t drank it varlely orllquor co,
mAlted or browod bovorages during 1o11e1t and Hub4equolitly wllllo plitying cards a1 the 0lubl
,1
,
11, 'file huvunlBoo wllleh the 1?e1011(hil comilmod were oold 1110/ol NI 1114110 mid
t101'vud Ill IIIIII by pi' nopllls, {Iltallttl 411' 0nlployues of Addhiomil herellihmWind of \Y01'P plll'ohnsu(I
by other?Pnatnnlol's Il'cml prlnoiplik, itlown and emplnyees orAddlfinnnl Rofenwnt Who 111011
purmlitecl mlcl ollowud the holundant to commitle Ihu heVoragvs In the Chill,
P. 991e nu(iollw orihD Porblidillit WPrP sumolunt to pill (1 1101-soli \vho hill I'Pgsnimblo
h'n111111FS and 0X1141'101100 its w bn1'1011(lel', s01'vPl' or 111101'lli(1l' nil Ilntlco thwl hu Wils 1111oxicillell,
T Thu nhAPIIH null physlenl sinus which the Pul'endmit diKphiyed while III Addlllonol
P00e11(hilit'N ehlh mid III the Illoc he was sa1'ved anllslsled nPhnt ire will hnlhed to the Ihllo v ilm:
(n) Pol'etl(lanl was acting In nn nggresslvD will mull nmnII01"
(b) 001,011(lont Woo slnl'1'lllg Ills words
(4) IaPrundanl Wns bolHicrnns,
(d) Pal'undfult was nfgimlonlnllva,
(P) laol'endntlt lvas uns1oady In Ids \vnik.
(0 hal'olidsnl finally phased out nl the Whip.
IA, „ Allhollgll IIID 1)ar011(111111 Wtls visibly Inloxicllled, the omploym of Additionol
lhl'hlralt 11111 idaohol.
I]afuhdnnt's club cnnllnuod to
S, Within inlimies agar lowing Addhlonsl DoI011dnllt'H 011th \vhoi-c 110 had heell sa1'ved
the liquor or milted or brewed beveragos while visibly Intoxiantcd, the DON11dmlt wits ltivolve(I in
the 11(111-cost Illotor vehicle aoaldaltl iii which PIninlltTwws wllogedly Inlnred.
16, The Addhlonnl DaMildnill ns a IlamHou ol'Ihe pomisylvmlln Alklor Control Boill-1
htla s lohoad IIID switltes set (brf i shove and is, Ilicralb a, solely hwble fbv the Plaltitl(1's aAegael
lilhn'1DH,
U „
17r The aellows orAddhWnM Pelandom lhmugb its pHnalpwls, agonls nfld eltlployeas as
d0sc1'Ibod 110/.0111 wore 11 vlnl011oll of IIID sinlutct and wore solely the ammo ofthe alleged Injuries to
IA, if It IN judiclolly t1ot011111mu1111RI ilia P000110n111 wile In eny WAY rOHponHihlO,lbr
Plnlntlll'H ihunt113oH, 111011 It Is ev01'I'0d lhnl IN Addh1)mIl Put1111dt111t IN roaponHlblu dll0 to th0
eforo"Od nogllgoneb, end as such Addlllonel Pofundnnl IN 8oluly Ilnblu to PIIdnII1T'h)r tiny mid ell s)
1 1flaH 81111pred by 1110 PIn111011, or Is Ih1blo oval . to Pufomlhm for Indunu1111untlon, end 1111y end till `
1111111111Y oil tho peel of tho P01311dwit 1101118 uxprOHHly (101110d,
W1'1111t11110103, POtbndillt, )oromy Mill, r9spocAlly rogtims this 11o11111,111110 cot.lrt Illot Illly + 1
,t
q
f tldg111P111 III thIH Peso 110 011terod Ili his Awor, will ogliI11H1 AMIllo11e1 POfolltl11111, codIHIu cotiilllY
CIO); Willi Costs of still; or it doternllnmlon Owl Addltloenl Pofondmil lie Hol01y 111116 to MAIN, or
111 1110 Milt a v0rdlct IN rocnv0r00 by 1'IelnlifT'egnhlHt P01'o11de11t, that Pel'ondonl mey 11ev0
Jndltntullt oval' mid egel11Ht Aclclltloltel Potbndottt by Way of Iml0nml110et1oll mid/or 0onu'I1111tio11 N.
1110 emocmt recovered by I'InlntlfT'egnlnH! Pe1b11cln11t, togother Willi costs, 1
I(Ospoctfhlly Huhmlttud,
13LAK11Y, YOST,13Uf1' K SOIAIJMANN, LIAl
i111T1 L131110y3squllci
S. Ct, 1,p, HIe061
Attorney for Pofonclow
17 MINI Merkol Street
York, PA 17401
I'0leplul11o (717) 845-3674
s
p?G I I @@ IPRI I I? lU @t,{RE1,1'UST, @VYY k SGN?UM?kh T(l "I' Bl?, ?93y
l MMOY vAgivY OAP IAN7' IFIInIaFan{I FnIRA01 {p {hAA +? pfn1Y ImPW A Ci
AUMNT AI?t'?TPOATS p?f'T~?P
Infh ,N,An of pallAf 1 undaratand thFt any i lea FtFtamantq aAnlAlnNll hAleln FrF ?11pJa°t to ?hF
( nolt1A1 of 10 Par CA, 4944, TAIF{ing ICI 11111WOM WOOkl1An to AuShodfloF'
OP < yull
1, 11
I
a. ...r r.: >.r t.. •r 1 e. Tr? FF
TTMOT11Y 014INGER I" IN TIM COUP-111 OP C.OMON PLnAs
P].ai.ntif.f I CUMBURLAN1) COUNTY, P1?1q1qr3YLV41qIA
I
V, I CIVIL ACTION LAW
,7u;PcMY BULL No, r71z•S?Z7
, I
Defendant I JURY TRIAL, DEMANDED {
YRU, HAVE BEEN SUED IN COUPT, If you WiP11 to defend agaillst:
the alaitpp,. pet forth in 'L-1le following pap es, y9t; must take Action
Within tWenty (20) days After t1lis ContplaiilL and Notice are served,
by entering A written appearance personally or by attorney And
filing ill Writing Wi.ttl thy' Court your defenses or objections to the
claims pat, for.ttl against you, You are warned that if you fail to
do so the case clay proceed 'Witllout: you and a Judgment Inay be
entered against you . by the Court wi.tllomt further, notice for any
Inoney clailped in the Complaint or for. any other claim or relief
requesLed' by t1le Plaintiff, You Inny lose money or property or
otller rigllts i,Iltportant to you,
YOU SHOULD TAIM4 THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCWt IF YOU DO
NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT APPORD ONEf GO TO OR TELEPHONE T11p
OPPICE OUT FORTH 13ELOW TO FIND OUT W1151 M YOU CAN GET LEGAL 11414P,
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue.
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 299-3166
11
a
NomicxA
Le haul delll.?ndado a listed an la cort:a, Si• upl;ecl quiere dofenclaa:pe
cle estap dsmandas oxpuesl as all ltls paginas piquientas, uoted time
viente (30) diap de plazo al partir de l.a foalla do' la dsmanda y la
notificacion, Upted claba pr(ilpentar upa apal"iencia epcr .l:a o all
persona o por aUogado y arollivar an la corte on forma epcri.ta sus
defeneap o oils o)DJecti.onap a, lap demande{s an contra de pu persona,
Sea ayipado que pi: opted no pe clefiende, la eorte tomara medidep y
pvlede antrar tlna orden contra upCed sin previo avipo o notificaci.on y
por eualquier queja o tlivio clue as pedido an 1a peticiol de demanda,
Upted puede parder di.nero o pus propiedades o otrop dereeltos
iplportttntes par.a usted,
L,L,PVIu A9TA DEMANDA A UN' AnoDAGO INMRDIATAMENTA, SI NO TIME
AAODADO 0 91 NO TIGNR Eli DINERQ SUPICIGNTC DE PAdnR TAI, 9CRVICIO, VAYA
EN PMR90NA 0 L,LAME POR TGLnFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION 94
ENCUGNTRA R9CRITA ADAJO PARA AVERIOUAR DONDE SE PUEDR CONSMUIR
ASI9TpNCIA LEGAL,
Cumberland County Bar,Aenoaiation
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-3166
i
i
TIMOTHY OT4TNCWR 1 IN 'IHN COURT OF COMMON PLWAS
P3.ai.tltiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
t
V,. CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I NO, 90-1228
,?nRWMY 13UT.111 ,
Defendant 1 JURY TRIM., DEMANDED
} DUP COTP14A,=
it Plaintiff Timothy Olinger, is an adult indivi.dtlal. who
ourrently resides at 440 Pairground Ave„ carliele Cumberland
Oounty, Pennsylvania,
21 Defendant Jeremy Mill, in an adult individual and citizen
of the Mate of MassachuHetts and has a mailing Fodrass of 393 East
C.01111 mo Avenue, 9pr:i;ngfiold,, MA 01109,
31 - The facts and occurrepoes ?lereinafter related took place
at approximately 4110 p,m, on Sunday, January 26, 1997, on State '
,Toute 11 (Carlisle Pi)ee) near its intersection with Roadway Drive
in Middlesex Township, Cumberland Cotlnt:y, Pennsylvania,
4, At the time and place ot; the accident, Defendant Jeremy
Dull was operating Stephanie Breneman a 1990 Ronda civic.autotRobile
oWned/or entrusted to Stephanie Areneman,
G At the time and plain of the accident, Plaintiff Timothy
Olinger was, a right rear seat passenger of the car operated by
Defendant U11,
6, At the time and place of the accident, Defendant: Jeremy
81111. was travelling away from Carlisle in the left lane of Route
11,
144400/MMM
^a n
I
i
1
i
I '
r ?.
¢,
i
tarn lane of lZ' Ute 11,
15, 'T'ile car driven by Defendant Jeremy Still then span in a
clockwise direction and skidded approximately 132 feet through the
AOLIL'IlbOtlild lane of Route 11 into the entrance of ASP Trucking
11., AL the time and place of the accident: the posted speed
limit on Route 11 was forty-five miles per hour,
12, Immediately before the accident the traffic signal for
traffic on Route 11 in the direction that Defendant Jeremy Bull was
driving changed to yellow,
13, When the traffic signal on Route 11 turned yeljoWt,
Defendant Jeremy Bull suddenly applied the brakes of the pax and
skidded out of control,
14, Upon applying the brakpo, the car driven by Jeremy null
skidded a distance of approximately 110 feet- through the center
9, In 1:110 area of t:11e.. acclident:? Route 1:1. in, a four lane
hitlhwe(y Wi.l:lt a large center turn Irmo tend povecl olloulderp,
a t jWut0 11. ill the area of the acai.clelll: is a relatively flat
slid ptraight: section of Iliellway with no obptructiona to vision for
motor,i.ptp travelling oil the highway,
J, The intersection of Route 11 and padWay. Drive, is
controlled by traffic lights which are strung above the IligilWay and
control the moVelllent of traffic on both Route 11 and Roadway Drive,
1Q, The traffic control 1.i,gllts arp visible for over one Illilq
for motor vehiclea travelling in, the direction of Defendant Jeremy.
Bull,
3
p'
Terminal located oil the
Wept: pido of tha i.nl:aa^aeat:.all Wi.l:ll Rolll:o
16, The left rear quarter panel of t:110 a aul:alltobi.lo, driven by
pof.endallt jet only (lull then violently 0oll.idecl w.it:11 tile , traffic
signal pole,
17, PolloWing this first vtolgnl: collision, tile fintomobi-le
became Airborne and ppull twice in a 360 degree counter aloo)cWi.pq
direction,
18, While spinning cot.tlll:er-clookwipe, tile 1990 lfondg civic
driven by Defendant Jeremy Bull impacted wi.t11 the gre.und And
aontilnlled to skid anotIler 3.60 feet across the front laWn of Apr
Trucking Tarmi.llal,
15, rinally, the car. Automobile driven by Defendant Jeremy
pull, in whiatl Plaintiff Timothy Olinger was a passenger violently, collided on its right passenger' side into the aide of a pick-up 1
truck panted in the Apr Trucking 'terminal parking lot where it came ?
to rest,
20, The 'impact from colliding with the traffic pole and tile
I.
parked pick-up .tr,'uck caused severe damage to the ent• re''AUtomobile
in which and PlainL•iff,Timothy Olinger was riding as a passenger,
21, The multiple impact And violent skidding and spinning or
the car caused Plaintiff Timothy Olinger to be seriously injured,
requiring him to be immediately transported to Harrisburg Hospital I)
for treatment, I,
P2. 't'he foregoing Accident, and all of the injllries And,
da111Ages 'fiat. forth haa-oinAf:tar. sustainad by Plaintiff. 111.giothy
oliilgor. are tha direct. And' proxi.fhato renttl:t of the ilegligent?
Careless atld reckless manner in Wlli.cll lWandant Jeremy null
Operated A motor. Va(li.ale As follown t
(a) dri.yi.ng A car at An excessive rat:e of speed and in „
A reckless disregard for the safety of'papsengers
and other mot:orintp on Ells highwayl
(b) driving At: A speed which would not permit: slim t:o
aaf:ely control the car and which lie knew, or sllotlld
have )Cn4WnI created a atlbstantial risk of harm for
his passengers or other motoria63 oil the highwayl
(c) failure to exercise the Iligh degree 'of care
required by A motorisl:s angering an itltorseotio.nl
(d) failure to .)seep, Alert and maintain a proper watch ..
for t•lle presence of official traffic controls on
the highways .
(e) failure to taste reasonable evasive action to avoid
tile acoiclentl
(f) failure to have the vehicle under. each control as to
be able to stop within the assured clear didtanoel
(g) failure to obey traffic signals)
(h) failure 1:6 t-r.aval at A safe npeedl
(i)
• proper and adeC(L1Ate control over the , .
failure to keep
vehicles
(J) driving the vehicle upon the highway in a manner
endangering persons and property and in a reckless
manner with careless disregard to the rights and
sAfety of others and in violation of the Motor.
Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,
4
i
cr?rizM :[
TIMO'1'llY Qr.Jj GFR V, UR171v1Y BUr-d.i
23, ParagraPllyd 1. tIlrougl'i 22 of l he, ComPlainL• are incorporated
herein by reference,
2A, As a result of the aforesaid accident, Plaintiff Timothy
Olinger stlst wined painful in)Uries Which include, hut: are not
limited to, abrasions to both lower extremities, a Puncture Wound
in 11is"rigllt buLtocka, severe abdominal pain, severe baclc pain, a
pubic ramus fracture, two splenic int•raparenchymal lacerations
resulting in a oplenect:omy, loW grade fevers, and life tllreAteni•ng
complications,
25, By reason of the aforesaid in dries sustained by
Plaintiff _Timotlly Olinger, 11e Was forced to incur liability for
medical treatment, medications, and similar miscellaneous expenses
in an effort to restore himself to health, and claim is made
1
therefor,
26, Because of the nature of his injuries, Plaintiff Timothy
Olinger has been advised and, therefore, avers that he 'may be
forced to,ineur similar expenses in the future, and claim is made
therefor,
27, As a result of the af.oram9nti,oned injuries, Plaintiff
Timothy' Olinger has undergone and in the future may undergo .
physical and mental. suffering, inconvenience in carrying out his
daily activities, and loss of life's pleasures and enjoyment, and
claim is made therefor,.
J„
i
aQ naintiff '1'.+.tlotily Olinger, eolll:inmaH to be Plagued by
perpiPl-,ent pain' and Lill itat:i.on and, t:llerefore , avers that, Ilia
injtW ep may be of n perlllfltlent nature, oaupijIg residual problemo
for the romi.nder of Ili.s .lifet;illle, and claim ip made t)lerefor,
29, ,As a rePlllt of the aforesaid illjilr.iep, P1.ilint:iff. Timot:Ily
oliager )lap been, €lnd 1.11 the f W'-';r0 will bo, pt.lb;Jeol: to. gregt
Ilumi,liat:ion and embari:asplllent:, and clailll is mfAda therefor,
30, As a rosult of tile aforeMonti,oned injuries, Plaintiff
Timothy Olinger has sustained wor.)t loan, lops of opportunity and a
pe>:tilanent, climinut.i:on of Ilia earning power and capacity, and claim
is made therefor,
311 As a result of the aforesaid i11:1uriepj Plaintiff. Timot.Ily
Olinger has sustained, Llnaoptpenpated work loss, and claim is made
Lllerefor. or,
32, Ap a result of the aforesaid accident, Plaintiff `i'imot)ly
Olinger has sustained scars which will, rasult in a permanent
disfigurement:,' and claim is made therefor
WLIwPErORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendant in an.
amount in excess of Twenty-Y'ive 'T'housand ($20,000) Dollars,
exclusive of interest and costs, and in excess of any
jurisdictional amount: requiring compulsory arbitration,
COUNT II PUNITIVE DAMAGED
TIMOTHY OLINGER V, JLREMY BULL
33, Paragraphs :L thl-ough 22 of the Complaint are incorporated
heroin by reference,
f
II
34, Pr.i.ol.^ I:a I:hra naotlrre111nQ 'a f• the Aforepaid aaci:(Ion t,
Defandatlt: aerellly 1111.1.7., 9b0hllallie BJ'e11eIIlAn, As Wall. Elf) I3everAl,other
00-War)GQra tnoludi.119 Timotlly Olinga),, were at Iate Oal.-l.i.131e County
Club for a brunall llopted by Step;lAnio Hl enemas,
35 Unbeknownst L•o Timothy Olinger( Defendant Jeremy Bull.„
aonaullled a largo Amount; of Alcoholic beverages at tile Carlisle
COtlnty, C.lu):), p9ill1aril.y in the forM Of Long Island Ice Teas,
36 , PlAintif.f Timothy Olinger had been peaked at another
table with other co-worlSera other than Jeremy Bull And therefore
Was not Aware that Jeremy Bull. Was consuming A large amount: of
a.lcollol.i:a beverages,
37, Plaintiff Ti.I11 Olinger has become aware , that Defendant
Jeremy null has til.leged as Now Matter in A previous alaipl Which was
brought Against hint by Barbara Jean Payne, that:, lie Was intoxicated,
30 In his New Matter, Defendant Jeremy Bull has also alleged,
that the Carlisle County Club served him alcoholic beverages at a
time that lie was visibly intoxicated, see New Matter filed in
Cumb6r.land County to civil: action no, 98-4094,
39, Plaintiff Timothy Olinger has learned that a blood test:
taken on Defendant Jeremy Bull some time after the Ipotor vehicle
accident showed a blood alcohol level of ,29 percent,
40, Plaintiff. Timothy Olinger does not recall observing any
condtlat• out of character for Defendant Jer.eMy Bull while At the
Carlisle County Club And while preparing to leave until the
Defendant accelerated as alleged previously in his Complaint•
7
I I ?'
41, 1f pefeadant Jeremy MIll1S al].egOions that he Was
into?4ical:eci and served alcoholic boveragep by the Carliple country
010 heyoncl tile point of vioi.blci .t{ll:oxi.ca{:i.on are true, Plaintiff
Ti•matlly Olinger Inai.ntains olat Iefendant 13tlli. knew or should have
known that lie Was severely intoxicated Lind unable to safety operate
a motor velliale,
4211 Defendant Jeremy 13u11 ellOuld have' known or knew that his,
conduct in operating a motor vehicle While intoxicated Constituted
outrageous conduct and a recliless indifferenon to the r.igllts and
safety of others on the liigllway, aa' well. as the occupants of the
motor velli.cle Which he chose to oporato,
43, Defendant Jeremy Gull should have 'known or knew I Ilat
operating a motor vehicle While intoxicated created ai ll:lgle degree
of risk of injury to other persons on tile highway and the occupants
of lii'a vellicle,
44, Defendant Jeremy null should have known or 'knew that his
Conduct of recklessly operating a vehicle at a high rate of speed
11
While intoxicated constitutes outrageous conduct and a reckless
indifference to the occupants of his vehicle,
45, Defendant Jeremy Bull should have known or knew that his
conduct in, operating a motor. vehicle While lie was intoxicated at a
high rate of speed and approaching a traffic signal Which Was in
the process of allanging, displayed willful, wanton, and reckless
indifference for the rights and safety of his occupants and others
on the highway,
8
46 Sclicl nollduat: I)y tJefeilclant Jeremy 131111. gonptitut.,ea Walston
and w1.11-NI negligonae al'tcl iv ont:rclgeollp and elltitles Plaintiff
`1i111Qlaly (linger to an award of punitive clatnafreer
JgIl17RUMRn, Plaintiff dentande.?udgtpellt agai,nl3t nefonclant: ;ln all
a111oUnt in exaeep of Twnnl:y-T?ive 'I'llotlpand ($251000) po3.1arp,
exalttpive of interept ., ctllcl cloptp, and In excenp of any.
juriaclictiollala111o11nt roglliring oo111ptt.l,pory irbit atioll, ina3mcling
p11niL'ivo. de1111agea
;AN a1N tlTlu1R c,
Ilse W, KoailG'' 17pcfuiro
,D, No, 36513
4503 N, Prom Street
liarrieblrg, PA 111110
(717) 230 6,791
oouneel for Plaintiff
,r
9.
J1Il131'F.;'C '.l'_LrSI ,
It MICHAN14 RI KOSIKI ESQUIJjbl', clo Ilelraby awonr, encl affirm {4111
{.J1p fa ats rant fort;{l lp 1*110 fioraao:1.119 Amended Colilplaipt; etro I: r.tia alld
aorreot; to tile rapt of, illy knowleclgo' i.nforlllFlt:ioll ti11r.1 belief, I
ttilderpt and that ulli.p Verif:.icEl Loll i.t7 illtlc{a m1bJeot: to tile poll?ll.t iop
of Ole Jttlloa of Civil Procedure rEdAting to tulpworll falpif;i,antioll
to mit horit:iep,
WT'i'NpuSS 1
CHAlUi Icos?tC, raQpz{tp°
Dat:edl
a
I
;i o
AND N0111t:hi.a ?SHI day of ,'tantlary? 1.999 i,, Michelle M,
mUo, 10Vich, all alllploy0a of Angina & 1ZoVila r, P,C„ clo I1ar.aby 0017t.tEy
that I have, p0ry0d a Lmla anlcl correct copy of the AMIBNDDID COMPLAINT
in the uni.t:aci 9t:ateo Illai 3., popt:agn pr.0pai.cl at Har.ri.pbttrf7,
ponnpylVgnia, odc1r0ps0d clp f.ol lowu l
Donald 13, Hoyt, Ppdtlir0
DLAK14Y, YOST, BUPP & 9CHAUMANN
17 la, Market ntr00t
York, PA 3.7401
1?1 ,01h Ile M, M11oj1 Vicli
r.
i
IN T1111 COUKT Oh COMMON PIXAS 01+ C11MMIRI-ANI) COIJN'I'Y, Ill?NNSYINANIA
CIVIL, ACTION - I-AW
TIMOTHY OHNOM(I ; No. 98.51211 G'Ivll 'I'urm
l?lllipliff, '
Yfl,
JI 101mY Hull',
hulbndn114
?lil?'111?ICA7'1i_Q1?Lil?V1?L
I Ilvroby aartlly thnl I hnvo t11is ditto solvocl Il onIly 0f iho fnrognlna C6mpinlnl ApNhlst
Adclltlnllu) Dolbllclnnt nn 1110 1101scl?t And 111 I110 mnnnor 111(110111001101mv;
Sorvloo by IlrHt olnss 1111111 n?l
HOW 11, Knslk, 1?agtlll•a
ANOINO K ROVNt?It, KC,
4503 Noilh Front Strool
1111rrisburg, PA 17110
111,AKRY, YOST, BUPI' ? SCI IAUMANN, W,P
Dole:
M. Dell, I'nra?ognl
K.
IN T111; COURT OP COMMON 111,17AS O1. CIJMPPItI-ANP COONTY,,PI:NNSYINANIA
CIVII, ACTION - I,AW
TIMOTIIY OIANQPR, Nn, 98'.5nti Clvll 'rorlll
Plnlntlff,
Ir
VA, ;
dl?hGMY I1 AIL,
Oofondllllt ,
NOTICE TO PI EAL)
TO; Mr,'finlothyOlirlaor
C/o Mlol?noI F, Knslk, Isqulro
ANOINO X, ItOVNPlt, P,C,
4503 North Front Street
FinrrisburB,.PA 17110
You ore horcl)y notlilocl to ploild to tho onolaxocl Now Mntlor witlfln twolity (20) clilys (1'onT
sorvioo horcof or n clollmll,luclgnlont filmy bo ollterml ngnlltst you,
Respoctflllly suUnllllod,
11LAK13Y, YOS`P, HUFF & SCIiAUMANN, 1.4L11
honnlcl B. 1.16yl, ? ulro
Callnsol for DO 1)(1411t
1TERst Mnrkol Stl-cot
York, Ponnsylvnnin 17401
Supromo Cl, l.D, IIIBOO 1
(717) 845-3674
IN TIIli C-01JRT Op COMMON MAW OF CUM1113RIaANP COONTY, pl?NNWWANIA
Civil, ACTION.- I,AW
TIMPTIIY 014KEK, ; No. 90-5228 Clvll'farnr
Plaintiff, ;
Vol
mmMY oul'I.,,
Pofandnnt
AI`1?4YL'•li.'1'O_AMI?NL)?t?S?M ? " udSliLw Mnrri?lt r
1, I'ho 1111081410118 of ihls paragraph at-() donlod, Allor runannahie invostinntion,
Dolbndant Is wlihnut knowlodgo or Inlbrmotloll suftlolattl to 1111,111 a hollof ns to tho (111th of thoso
aVPI'lllelltH,
2. Tho allegatlotls oJ'Ihis pa1'0g1'tiph al•e odmittod.
3, Thu n1logotions of this p0maraph are doniud pursuanl to Pn,1t;CA 1029(0),
4. Tho allegations of this paragraph Oro donlod puntront In Po, R,C,P, 1029(0),
s.. ,Tho allogntinns Aldo paragraph are donlod pu sum(o Pa, R,C,P, 1029(0),
C, The nllogations of Ihls paragrnph are Honied pursuant to Pa; I1,C,P, 1029(0),
7, The ollogntions of thin paragraph are donlod pursuant to 1'a. R,C,P, 1029(0),
8, The allegatlons oftitls paragraph mro donlod pursuant to Pa. R,C,h, 1029(0),
9, Tho allegations 01 `11118 paragraph are donlod pul'puant tp Ph. R.C.P. 1029(0),
10, Tho 8110gotlons of this porogroph are donlod tnn'su0111 to Pa. It.,C,I?, 1029(0),
11, Tho all0galiolls of this paragraph nro d01110d Inlrsuanl to 110, R,C,11, 1029(0),
12, The nllogmions of this paragraph nrodonled pursuant to Pa, lk,C,P, 1029(0),
13, Tho ollogallons of Ihls paragraph are donlod pursuant to Ila,, ILC,P, 1029(0),
14, The allegatlolls of this paragraph arc donlod pursuanl to Pa. R,C,P, 1029(0),
2
15, The alIppotlonsWt1?is pnrngrnph are OPOW pursuant to Nu, IMP, 1029(0),
16, The nllogntigs of tills porowallh pro denlPd pl?rstlant to I'll, It,C,1', 1029(9
IT The Pllegatinns of tills pnrngrnph we denied purnutnri to pn, imp, lo2S.
1 % The nllumnllann of No ilmmumph no denied purtampt Io I'll, IKY, 1020(o).
19, The nlIogolloos of tills plrnumph pro dpgkd pllrtnlnnt to Pa. IM A 10200),
20, 'file nllPHntiollo of tills pnrngrnph pro domed purslnult to 110. It.C,h, 1029(u),
21, The ollol3ntimis of tills porogroph fire donlod pursuant to 1'n, K.C.P. 1020(o).
22. The allegallons of tills pnrngrnph ore Healed pursuant to t'p. It.,C,l', 1029(o),
CLAIM I
TIMOTHY OIANAI?h.v, JVRIWY HVIA, ,
23, 11prngraphs I through 22 of Pofonclont's pnswors re Inoorporntod' horoln by
reference
21 The nlipplone of this poivamph are donlod pursupnt to 0% IMIN 1029(01
25, The ollogatloas of thie'Iiarnumph pro denied purnunnt to I'n R,C,1', 1029(o)
2a The nllogntlonp of this pnrngrnph no domed pursumlt to IS R,C,p, I029(o),
27. The allogalloas of title porngrnph are donlod purnunnt to 11a It,C,I', 1029(0),
28, 'file nllognrlons of NO pnrngrnph no donlod purnunnt in Pm MAN 102001
2% The allegallone of tills pnrngrnph Prodonled purAunat to I'll, It,(,14 1029(0),
30, Tho nuaguouns of this pnrngrnph nro donlod purnunnt to I'll, R,C 1', 1029(o),
31, The nllognllrnls of tills ppragraph are donlod pursltnnt to I'll' It,C,I', 1029(0),
32, 'Pilo allegailaos of this pnragraptt no honied pursuant to I'n, R,C,I?, 1029(0),
WITEREFORR, the Dofoadant roquests Judgnlont ht his filvor sod dismissal of 1110,
Complaint,
3
,
cQUN`I' it NUNI'1'IVI3 PAMAQW9
'I'iMATIIy OLIN?if?It v, dI?t?l?MY I?UL1,
i3. POMMI)hs I through 22 of Iaofondant'& OnsworO Oro Inoorpo rOiod heroin lay
rofor4noo,
14, Tiro Ollogallona of this parogrnph Oro Odnlitt4d,
.1 The x11080 loll" 01 70116 parosl'Oph are doniod pul'stltllli to pit, R.C,N, 1029(4),
36, Tho alloptiolls of t1lio palligrtiph Oro tlotllod ptirlalallt to Pa, It,C;p, 1029(o),
37, The allogotlotts of this parogrnph Oro doniod pursuant to Nib It.C,h, 1029(c),
18, 9'114 oll4gatlona of 1111s paragraph athltlttod,
I
39, Tho allogatlmts of tills paragraph Oro doniod pursuant in 1029(c),
40, The allegations 01"1111.4 porogrnph tiro doniod pursuant to Ila it,c,p, 1029(0),
41, The ollogoliom1 of (111.4 porogroph pro domed pursuant t0 PO, R.C,p, 1029(0),
42, 'file ollogotion5 of this parogrnph are tlonled pursuant 10 Pa. R,CA 1029(0),
43, The nllogations 01"(1)1.4 parogroph Oro doniod ptlrsuatlt to Pa. R,C,p, 1029(o),
44, Tho allegations of 1111" paragraph Oro doniod pursuant to Ila, R,C,P, 1029(0),
..
III
45 Tile allegations of 0115 parogrnph Oro domed pllriauant to PO, (C,p, 1029(0).
46, Tile allogations of this parogrnph Oro doniod pta'suont to 110, R,C,I', 1029(0), .
WII13 RI?pQRl3s Tile DOfeadallt requestsjudgrnollt Ill 1115 mvol' and (11511115501 of tho,'
Complaint,
NEW„'xLt
47, on Januory 26, 1997, the Plolntiff Ilvcd In an opsrtltlolll bullditlg with the
Defondanl and five (5) other individuals,
I
I
z1
AIt, It hal11u11'y 26, 1997 at aphroNjiltlltoly nooll, Ills pllllil{Ii) Wpnt In (110 col'IINIP
Cnilnhy pleb will) the plahltlIT'lad "even (7) a(hpr Individuals,
49, While III file CarllNlp Counlry Cluh, the 111011tH fuilsl the Pelbndmtl and others ale
nn(t (hank, pnnNlnninS nloohnlla hpyorages,
501 While at the C111.1100 Country Clllh, tile 1'1ah111lTan(I the Dot'onclant hp Mlle
Intnxipalo(I,
51, While At the Carlisle dounlry Clllh, the plointilTond the Dof'pndant, while viNlhly
Illtoxlonted, were NarVp(I 4100110110 h0vp1'agoa by 111011genls, N0ry11111N of olllplpyaoa of 1110 Carlisle
Country Club,
52, Wlpn It cattle tllno to loave the Clll'llslo Conlllly CI1Ih,1110 plailltilrknOW (lint 1110
DO(Odotnt was Intoxicated)
When it cattle tiale to leave 1110 Cal'1I810 Collnlry Club, 1110 plalntilTdl(I not protest
that the Dolbttdant WAR driving Ibe v0111e10 and volunla?'ily antcred the v0111010;
Sac The Plaintitrwas contrihutorily 110811genl in that 110,
Al Kllew Dol'ondatlt was drinking and httoxicoted and novortholcas proceeded
to ride ill the car with Dofondant;
h, Should hove known laofondant was 'drinklnd and Intoxicated and i.
nevertheless proceeded to ride In the oar with Dofondont;
01 Know Defpadant was drinking and Intoxicated and was tulaNo to drive the
oar; alld
d. Should have known hofemlont was drinking and Intokleated and was 1
tillable to drive the Col',
,.1
55, The Plointiff,as timed the risk of tlto occidonl by:
rf
5 I?
#
fi
I
II. Know 111111 opl11'pollltod Po1u111h1111 woN (111Ik11111111111 1111MI01100 111111
novortholm provoodpd to rMo In Ihp 0nr wllh Polunllnnl; and
h, Know old npproolnlod Pol'ondnnt wnN drlnklnll nnll Inmxloolod Innl
nUv0rth01OHH 111 .0000000 to 1.100 1111110 0111• with Pullondanl, ovpn 1111111tH
PofoII(WIIl W118 1111010 In drive,
W1.113IMFORP, th0 Poronclgpl 11118 o gill and pomplolo dofollHe to thlo Ration and roquoo1N
Its (11H1111HH10,
izeHpeetR111y Hubmiuaa,
KA W, YOST,13UIT SCIIAUMANN,1.1.11
omllil 13 Iloylr ?squlro • ^_.__.
C01111801 for 13011011dollt
17 mast Morkol Strout
Yolk, honnsylvonlo 17401
Supromo C1, 1,1),1118001
(717) 845.3674
I ,.
I I
. I
?. .. .... __. .- 17. 1 ._?.,. ..r 1
1 f 132
I'1:U•-lis..?_I?1 Pp;3:1 PPS p
rrY 1 tv ir1A1w IV GuM4?h'?l'rYP$t, BUPPI k. SvNrlUb?hNR ??? tl,? @6a., 7q?y . P PIS
YE111.?11.AT1U? ;
I "FRI 0y VERIFY 1l10111hA InformAllnn opt ?ar111 In ilia foropnlnp CQNO)I AN'
A06INPT APOITIPN,? P#p"RNAAN I' Is Inio onl cor<o111 to IN *4 of mV knowlodpp,
InflnrMillon W hollpf I undorotAnd that Any f4lop Atolompnlo oonlAiltod horoln ArA v0jpm lu IN
pongltlpA of 10 IRA, C.el 4904, rololino to tmowom NIOPAllon to Autl?orilio .
,? Al V NI1 '
1 ?.
i
1
IN TIM COIJK'1' Oh COMMON 111d?A9 OF COM1111RIaAND COUNTY, (u1NNSYINANIA
f'IVII. ACTION -- I.AW ,
TIMD'1'I1Y OWN413It, Nn; 9H-.922H civil 'f'orm
P1111n11f1',
v1), ,
XIt(?MY 110a1,
? ,. Dpfond11nl
U,1011:1CA_TU LlI 0111..
1 horoby ccrllfY thnl I hove 11118 (111!1) WWII n copy n1'1110 forogolm Answor mici Now
Mollor On 1110 person 11110111 tho 11111m1er 111(1Ieolod boinm,
Sorvlce by first oloos moll on
Mlehoul K Koolk, Ls(pilre
ANOINO & ROVNRR, P,c,
4503 NOith Front Strool
1-ford4llrg, PA, 17110
111.AK11Y, YOS'I',11UPP SCI-IAUMANN, LLP
DAN: ?--_ rlyt_
?_-` Nat•nin M, poll, Pnrnlcgitl-..
Alma
TIMOTHY 0I0IN01113 I l:N 'I'IIIi1 COURT OIL COMMON PUMAS
Plainti ff t CUMnWR1.,ANo COUNTY, PIi1NNSYLiVANIA
i
v i CTVII, ACTION LAW
NO, 9n-522H
Defendant 1 ,JURY 'A'RIA[ I)MMANDGIp
AND NOW, coMom Plaintiff! Timothy Olinger, by and through hill
attDVn0yp, Angino & Rovner, P, U, °hnroby rampondu to Defendant's
No, Matter UP follows l
47, Admitted,
48, Admitted,
49, Denied an stated. „Pl.ai.nt.i.l'f Timothy Olinger does not
di.spl.tta HVltr he was at I:he Carlisle Country C.l.ttb with Defendant
Jere111y null during which time they had lunch, p.lai.llt.if f Timothy
Olinger was not aware of what Defendant: Jeremy Bull gto or drap4,
Therefore, P].ai.nl:'i.'r.li Is unable to admit to what extent Defendant
consumed alcoholic beverages, it is denied that PlaintIff Ti,m
Oli,nger's consumpttion of alcoholic beverages, If any, in relevant
or admissible since he wan a passenger in the czar, It ip deftied
,that Plaintiff Timothy Olinger was under the influence of alcoholic,
beverages or intoxicated.
50, Denied, !H: in specifically denied that Plaintiff Timothy
Olinger became intoxicated while at the Carlisle County Club, To
the Contrary, It is averred that Pla.i.ntaff Timothy Olinger was not
intoxicated or under the influnnau of any alcoholic beverages
during the time that he wan at the Cnr.li.sle Country Club or
14G3ORIMMM
affI. ol'wa1'dta, A, blood LcIfIt: ?ondtlCPed cjt IIatr1.11 Ibil rcl Iloupl.trl:l.
LIIIIpodl.aL'oly aELcti' tale tlcu.h.11-111v ollowcci t:hal: Ile Ilia<1 Ile illcailpnl'c11?:Lrs
b.l.ood alcohol. oorltalll:, BY Way Of f111'l.hol: c111rlwor, I'.Li1-l.ttl:.i.f:f '1'.i.fllolaly
01.1.11ger plai.hta:ins t:11at 11o War-1 not awilrcl that Lila Dnfellclant:, 00vallly
i3u1.1., was inl:oxiaal;od or dri.nki.ng hnavlAy Wh•ll.o, at tho Car.Liral,a
County ,C1t1b, l3 macl ttpoh 1.1'1formati.nn vocleived 11011owing the
aac.1dellt•I Pl.ai.ntiff 'l'.i.lllotily OLhigor doers Ilc3t. cleliy HicAt Jerallly 171.11.]:
was tinder t11o i.ilfatlance si.nc'a 11:1.1:1 blood a10101101. 10Va1. f'o].l.owi.llcf tale
accident was ,29 percent,
53., It is cletllac.T that. Plailitif:f: Timothy 01.1.11gol: WI11.18 yi.si.b.ly
1.11toxi.cated was sorved a1oobol.1c, beverages by agents, servapts and
aIllp.10yoos of. the Call..iole CotulLy CAUL), IL Lij spalci.f:i.caal.y cleilied'
that Plaijitiff Ti.lllothy 01.1.'119o.r via Fl intoxicatecl„or , oven Linder the
influence of aleohol.ia beverages and boeame intoxi.gatecl as set:
forth in the response to paragraph 50 above, By way of flll:ther
arlewer, it is spedif:ica.l,ay denied l:hat the Defendant Jerettly 13u1.1
Was v.1s.ibl.y iI1tox.i.cfltod Whi.1.0 at the Car.I.i.iile Couilty C1.ub,, To thci
coliti^ary, it is averred that Plaintiff 't'imothy 01i.nger's Iijl ited
observations of JoremlS 13111.1, during the afternoon of January 26i
1997 did not 1.0ad 1.1111 to bol.i.eve that 'Jerallly 131111, was illt:oxicated
as the Defendant was not. acting any differently than his normal
u
behavior to the oxLenl: that. PDAi.nH.fffi had become aware of
Defendant's conduct,
52, , Deniod, It'. is speci.f:ical.ly danied that,Pl.ai.ntiff Timothy
0.1111ger knew that Defendant Joremy 13u.11. was intoxicated, at Elie lime
2,
thal'. t:llwy .hifl•. I:lii, cr11'I h11u cluunl:y Q111b, To r.lto ()c)ill:t'al:y1. 1.1: 111
av(ll'1'ac1 that. ill: no I'.lliln prior h) I.llc, aui,lt'1e1111:. Oki 11tH. rl 117f 'I'anloHly
0-1111lal. kllow I:hal: 17c1felldanl. Willi IIICoxi(lotaad o'i' undoy the .1.11f1•tlnnaca
cal' a:Lac?ltaa., D1 rtlig Illonl: of 1:11(': afltoCIloollc 1:11il.int:a.ff 'P1.111ot:11y
O:l.inger jull; al: 11 f.+epal.`t1t:n t:clh:l.o phly.i.ntl o,.li?l?lrt and di.cj not: cb'il111
alcohol. hnvnvlllan and 1:11e. pnnp:lca al: hin table who wero dri.tlk.i.ng
wol'o not dn.ilIg fro t•o oxoni m, Puica, I:o gnl:1:.ing illl:o tale pare
plal.nt.-iff '1'.i.mol:lly 01.111gjnv Willi 1101: clout-ilin 'afi I'D W110 W.11.1 evoll
driving Cllr vell.i.c 1o and Willa aware Of a d.i.ool.l6s:l.an t:alci.ng plaon
het'.Wooll fll:epllani.e 131"6noltleul iulcj ,lol'nllly BlO1.c llowevarl ?lli lie t.illto Ile
Was entering t11e volliole on 1'.Ite right roar: panficingor c1,i.do, lie wao
not, part of ghat- diraeusfll.on loci WaFa not: aware of Def.iatlcdcint•' fa
conclit-ion,
53, It iii adlttitL6d that PlaillLiff Timothy
pvol:est to Defendant ,leyemy 1311:1.1 cb:i.v:ing and vohmt-ari.ly entered
t:116 vehicl.e eince lie WaFr not aware tliilt the Defelldallt„ Was
u.
.1. 11 toxi.r.ated, plnint:.iff Timothy 01.1oger. io awa.yo.,of a discussion
occurring between Defendant. Jeremy nul..l. Auld"5tepltettlie3re11emclll 11110
Clint; Defendant der6111y 131111 i.ndi.cat:od that he woul.cl drivel' the
vahicle, At no time dial Plaintiff Tim 01inger know that tile
Def:endelilt: hacl been drinking heavi.l.y or was intoxicated at the time
that he entered the motor vohi.clo for a ride hollle,
1 , Denied, This averment: in a conclusion of law to which no
responsivo pl.6adiiig is rngvii.r6d, I.A. is speci.fi.eal.l.y denied that,
p111int-i.ff Timothy 01i.nger wan comparatively or contributorily
i
11oI?:Li.gcJnt: 111JC?11 l:hl oillU?o oI' tI[Jl:ic>il ?ICili:od I11 I'.LiI:LI1La.l.`f'!P Collll?. at qt
1
Pai:llnt 1IV Ttmotlly OtInger Curthot' tlvavq that the defon'me of:
compilrrli'.i.vo to: contributory nonliVion LEI not avfl i. Lablo two `t
Wandanl: who is grossly and wantonly Il"glir_anuo an pAi.nl:i.ff Plan
1.L l.cltJtJCI LaiIfJOCI upon the illforilotion which he hart received concerning
hefnlldilllt: aeromy HOW oonducl: on the day of the accident
Plaintiff vaspondn Lo Lho To.lloWi.ng averMants off thin paragraph ni,-i
follows 1
a, Et'. 113 nol: denied ghat Plaintiff If Timothy Olinger
was aware that Defendant; wnm „cir.i.nki.ng and hpnvi.ly
intoxicated While aL Lho c'arllsa.0 Count:lvy Club,
Plaintiff Timothy 01,.i.ngen; warn not mwaio of the nature and
extent- of the alcoholic beverages which Deiendant was
drinking or Lhdt: Lhe DofendauL Waal intoxicated aL ally
time prior. to hhei moL•or vehicle aocidlh, Thou, it is
denied that Plaintiff Tim Niger know or should have
known Lhat he should not r.i.dS in Lho car being operated'
by the Defendant:,
b :It in not denied' that.Plni.nt:i.f:f Timothy Olinger
was aware that Defendant wan drinking anal intoxicated
While at the Carlisle country Club, Plaintiff Timothy
Olinger was not: aware of tile ocitt-H.a and extent Of the
alcoholic beverages which Defend
ant was drinking or'Lhat
the Defendant was intoxicated at any time prior to the
motor vehicle ncoi.dont, 't'hus., it is denied that
Plaintiff Tim 0109or know or nhou ld havo known what, 110
should not ride in Yho car being oporatnd by the
Defendant
o, I:I: :i.n not daniod that Plaintiff Timothy Olinger
won aware That Defondaut Wan drinking and heavily
.nt'oxi.oated' and won unabl.s to driye..tho oar, Pla,i.llt.i.f:f:
Timothy Ol.a.ngor Wan not award o f the naturo and extent of
the al.cohnli.a beveragev which Defendant Wan drinking or
.. that, who Defendant:" Wall unable to drive the car prior to
who tttotor vnhlolo acoldont, 7Thuol :it Is doni.ocl that
Plaintiff: ff: TimoEhy Ol.i.ngor knew or should have known that
Ito should not ridct III a oar being oporatec.1 by tile
Defendant
d, it in not dogiod that Plaintiff Timothy Olinger
wan award that pofendant wan drinking and heavily
intoxicated and wan unable to drive the cat:, Plaintiff
Timptily Olinger Was,not aware of the nature and extent„of
the alcoholic beverages Which Defendant- was drinking or
that the Defendant wan unable to drive the car prior to
the motor vehicle accident, Thus, it in denied that
Plaintiff Timothy Olinger know or should have kngwn that
he should not ride in a ca r being opoirat:od by the
Defendant,
65,' Denied, This averment is a conclusion of law to Which nb
rosponnive bleadino is required, To the extent that a response Is
daulllod Ilocallfukry, it-, Iii ulx.c:ifJo,I.I1y denaed t:hal: p:l-"[11l:a.f1: T.J1ncflaly
Ol.itlgnt' anFI111ilncl L'hn 1':Lf:Ik ol'. I:IUa acul:Ldollt: r)gdlk'a':Lllg, 'I'o l:hct
aonl:ra.t'Y, :LC. 1.1.1 nvervod L'hal: aP, aa.a. t:.Illlutl Ill'ahit- AA: '111.nlol:lly 0:I.111glal'
Waa not: aware oil t:ho naLltra flllcl nxtunt: of alooho:L:1a bovera?len Wll.j.oh
1:Ilea Do falldalll: ?lernmy nlla.. clrank or. l:ImL I.-Am Defetldclnt Waft
i.ntoxi•catod prior 'L'o Lhe accadenl: ociclu' ving, 11'11urofaveI iL in
npeoifi.ca1.1y clulliod I:Ilat ho coltric,10 .11Y otleoiultParo(I tale r.i.f)k of
II c1r.;Lvi.ng With a (:11'11111 dri.var, p:Ltla.nl:i.l'I: rollpondit Lo (:Ile f:oll.owi.ng
elvormentn of; thif pat'tun'aph III] 1:01.1owa 1
a. T.C J. I] clp(.)CH fJ.cy (10111 ad l:hnt: hl.a.i.11H.ff:
Ti.mol:hy k1low or (appreciated I:ha? DefonclanL- Wan drinking
and llnavil.y or wan :1.1lt:oxaoal:oci, 1110 the cotll:rar.yj it in
averred that av. Ito C.i.lnn dial pl,a.illI.A. .. 'T'imothy Olinger
becolllo aware that Defendant: had drunk al.cohol.i.c beveragea
to the poi.t1t that lie, had become phySICE11.1y 1111.1b.1.0 to
drive a ear, At' no time dicl Delionclant:'a action appear to
be out oil character or indicate to the p.lainti ff: that the
Defendant waa ill LOX iecttnd, and thoref•ol:e, it 113 denied
that he knowi.tlgl.y proceadod t:o drive 1.11 the car With
Defendant Whou he knnW the Defendant- Wan impai.rod or
under the i.ilf.luenee of; 1.11cohol.,
b, .T.t i.n npecifica:1.1y denied that Timothy Olinger
knew and appreci.aLed that Del:anclailt had bean drinking
heavily or wan intoxicated, TO the 0011trfary, it is
averred that aL no time, dial Defenclant0n nations appear
1
to bo out of oharnoter cn• ill a maunor which was
i.nconnint:nnt with Plaintiff Timothy Olinger' s aNporionco
no to is ondnn% pvnvi.oun behavior, it .i.s npuoifi.cal.ly
dallied that Plaintiff 'l'jnWAQ Olinger know that pefendant
Jeremy Bull. Wan, .IntoxlQatod and appreciated the risk off
riding in the car with the Defendant, Plaintiff Timothy
Olinger was not Aware that Wondmot wan intoxicated or
unable to drive the oar or would not have gotten into the
car,
WHL;RMFORE, Plaintiff Timothy Olinger, respectfully requests
this Honorable Court: to dismiss Defendant's Answer and New Matter
and,nnter judgment; in her favor against: the Dofenjant,
ANCl1NQ &/R0-121 QC'
M.'iclaael Ail/, Kosiic; ilsquire
1, D, No, 36513
4503 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1799
(717) 238-6791
Counsel. for Plaintiff
Datedl
i'
I?
11
T
11 TIMOTHY OL,:LNOMI2, htl'Vf3 Load tale, fol.-Ovoi.llg ItPpl•y j
l:o Now Mal'.I nr, Fuld CIO havaby Ftwow" oC affE:l rill (altll: the faal:F1 1301:
fiolelal in l:hu foregoing ara tnto 1111(j aor.l aal: to tale bon of. Illy
lalowlodno, flif.orlllati.oll and Ual i.of' t -nlldart,talid lalat: 1:111[1
Vorif,.Lcatit%q i.Fl Illacie F111)Jeat i:o I:ho pona:LLi.on of! :La Pa,C,S,A,
Bea l: ion 4904, rel.hl:i.ng 1:0 1.111t7Wo1:11 falf3.i.f:i.cell-i.o11 to MUt IJOV:.LLiap,,
W.r.mNUaB,
1. m IriIY OL, Nclal2
rP113'1'!11?'n'pJ; or' LqEa?YfL"
AND NOW, I:h:lp ?Lich day of po171'tlary, 1.995) :[ Mi.ullo7l.a M,
M.i.:lo;loV.l.cih, till calllh.l.oyol= Of Angina & RoVilnr, 1',C.,, do ho.tohy dart 1.(y
l'1tt11: :I: I1t1Vn 11o1'Vn<:1 it l:rtlu rind col tacit: copy of Hla Pl.ATI T1P'f'r 8
I21i11?IrY 'l'C) DR]"RNI)ANT'9 NNW MA'11'6111 .i.tl Itho Ilita.l:oc? 9l'.?I:crl It11.1.7., poyCac?o
ptopa.ici ill: Ilcil'r':Lp1?tU'LIr Pul'ulely.l.Vani.tl, ttrldhorrtaclr( tlt3 f:o:laoWrdi
Donald 13, Iioyl:, (o;Eigtl.i,l-n
131.11\IWY, YOST, 13UPP & SCl[AIJMANN
17 R, Mal..1 o0L Stxoot.
Yolt, PA 1'740:1
Cot.ItlCioJ, £vl' Llnf:ondanl_•
Mi.cllcl7...o M, 1..l.oJoVi.uh
11r
a?
,
' tllly I I? 11118,1:X, I?Hllll?lu _. ... '.
I'll, No. '111672
(101,I)OV4 I, KA'IFMAN,k tiIIIIINIAN PX,
.12(1 Mill k01 H1fpd1
I1,0,1lox 1268 .
IIH1(IHllunl,11A 171118.1268
(717) 231-11(,1
AllomoyH 1ilr AI14111a od PuranQmll
-
TIMOTHY OHN010t;. -
--__..-IN TIIli UOUIs.'I' 01? COMMON PlaI;AS OIL
PItllntill' CUM)WRI.ANI)COUNTY, IlVNNSYI VANIA
Y,
JI?RI'?MY IitJl,l.,, No. 98.5228 C"•IV11.,
I)olbnclHlll
Y. JURY'I'RIAI, I)17MANDI?I)
CARL, SH! COUNTRY CLUIi
Addillonol Do(bndnu l
!li!
'I'nt hulblldmil told 1118 enunHol
,
Donald 11, I-loyl, 13H(1ull'0
13lekuy, Yost, Hupp & Sohnummul, l.1.,1'
17 East Market Street
York, PA 17,101
You fire 1101'01)' nollAed to plead to (110 Ivilhin New Milder ol'Addltlonal 17e1bn(IIIII18 w101111
twellty (29) dllyx ol'recoll)l bol'eol,
Ituxpeutlidly xubnlltlucl,"
('9014DIII0,I2G, ICA1-ZMAN & SHIPMAN, P,C,
13y;
(111' 11, Brooks, 118quiro
Atlorney 1,1), No, 49672
320 Mittkut Street
P.O. lion 1268
I fare. xburg, PA 1710& 1268
Unled; (7234.4161
Att
n
Addi
l
h
1
o
orneys
o
)r
t
u
11
lbndaot..
(Illy 11.11rim*H, I N 111110
t). No. 019(72
WHAPF-1110, IGA'I'XAtAN ?? ti1111rMAN,1' ?•',
120 MII&I 811ml
V.O.IN)x 126H
11imINWir11, PA 171uH•1269
(717) 21?1.1I61
MIor11oyN Ihr Mldllloluil I>uli ndH111
TIMOTI IY 01ANCHIK, ; IN 9'I Ili COIJIkT QIl COMMON 111a11AS OF
Phlhltill' ; ('lJMilliitl.ANI)CAIJN'1'Y,PIINNSYI.VANIA
V,
JI KIW)' IIU1.1111
Po1'ull(111111
V,
CARI.IS1,13 COUNTRY CIAJH
Additional Pufenclant
;
No, 98-5228 CIVII,
JURY'I'RIAI. PI3MAND131)
Addldonal Dol'ondont CarllHlo Colmtly Club, by and Ihroullh Its coumol, Ciuy 11. Brooks and
(Ioldborg, Kalmium k Shipman, P.C., Illo tho Ibllowing Answor with Now Mottor averring as lhllows;
113-101 1218, Pursuant to I'll, R,CT. 1029(0), nH amon(Icd ollbetivo Soptombor It 1994,
oxcopi ns her0imlllor sot IbrIIL all ovornlontH not doollml admitted under tho provisions or sold ntle
are Ilaroby donlod gonorally, 'I'hOHe avot mantes (1r lllcl which muHt ho domed 811001110ally pursuant to
Ila, R.C,I', 1029(e) aro Illt'lllor lomworcd bolow,
2 la011100 lls Nintud, 11 IH ildm1110d 1111111110 Cor11HIP CPmliry clol) IN 11 privnt0 PIPI), It IN
lnllllltted flint the 01111"10 Colnltry c-1Ph IN IPPIlmt 1111242 1 hn-riNhnrS 1)IkP, pIrIiHIP, PA, It IN llanic(I
111111 1110 CIIrIIHIP G'PIIP(I:Y %hlb °vAton to 1I4 II10111hP1'N IPM their BIIoNtH,"
1 I Po111411111H H(nlcd, It IN 1011111100 111111 Ow CI?rlislP ComIll'y (11111), IhrollBh Its 0111ploycoH,
801'vus11leohollebevurl?BuN, As 1111110 PIh0I'id10g111Im18111pI1rmispin,11001,renHnltnhiPIPVPNIIBOIloll,
IN 11n8worlllg Addhinital Polbn(Innl Is withaPt knowledllu or Infnrnlnlimn 01111100111 to form 11 Imhof
ON lP 111011'11111 01'1111811voriilen1111)11 prool'th6runf IN domUll(icd (1t 0-1111,
LY1.W MA'1'1,1p?t
1(? Addlllamil Uult)ndant IncorporoteN IIN mwworN ihm)(I In pHrngrllplis 1 1 B,
M 1'111111111A c1111111N 111-0, or 111nybu, h111're11 by IhO Slnt111o (it' 1,1111il Ill lolls.
21. pi111n0111)1 Ohdals 111-0, or na?ybc,'barred by wilivor,
22, 1'Iai11111% claims Iwo, or maybo, barred by comem
p1alotIM olalms m'o, or Illnybe, borro(1 Uy tho Slaloto Of Frmlds,
24, 1111111th 1 C1111n1N are, or oloybo, ba1'rod by 01013Nrole flv161100 Rtllo,
25, I'IalntillH clamps aru, or nlHyho, limited by tlwlr 110411-0 to 1114190lo dnmogoS,
I,.
26. 1'Inlatills clalols in'o, o1' nluyho, barred by l11o po1111Hylvanla Compnr1106'Negligollao
Slatl)to,
27, '1'110 damages 01111111ed are coused, ICat all, by tlw conduct ol'thh'd persons 0yor whom
11141 1111H1V01'111g D0111)(111111H 1111(1 110 001111'0l, 'I'1101'011)r0 (Ile 011111118 as to 1110 I1118wol'Ing Dofond01118 111'0
barrud, l
z
WIII11iV FOR I Ilit) nIINwo`insAdditiollilllaalul1011111rvg1lvHlHtltlll?llF11yI11aI111?aP111afa4111t01P1r
thvnr nncl lt?nlnnl tha Pafaadnnt, ,
? ItaHpaoUldly Kuhnllllad, I.
(10149IIF411(?, KNIZMAN & SIIIPMIANt PA
Cluy 11. Ilrnnkx, Ilagnlri+T
Altormoy 1•P, No. 49672
320 market Struul
h,O, noK 1268 "
„
Ilorriybin, PA 17108-1200
(717) 234.4161
All(ii-nuyK I'or Addithmul PufNnllant
Pate,
18427, l -
It tally ll, BroolcN, Ilm(pliro, horolly aoknowl0go tint 1 1411) Iho 11110r11Py Or tho
Adclilional Iaofondnnt, CarHAIO Country Club, thnl I hlwo rod the forogoins Answor and Now Mollor 1
Ilnd (h11t d1U I11UIN N(illod IIIVI'UIn life 11'11(? 11n{I Uol'I'UUt to tho host of my knowlodso, Information, and I
WHO, 'I'ho Adclitlonnl Polbnclnnl'N Voritlention IN unawdlohlo of prosont, but will bo AI«l with tho
Ccntrt wl?en It boe0.11100 ovnllablol
I ull(IUrHlaml 11111{ ally WHO Ntntol11ontN horUhl 111'0 11114do Nlll)lect to pollaltION of 18 Pi1\
CA §4904, rohltilg ?o miNworn 1111Nh1calloll to u111lhorillos,
13yi 'q
(Illy Pl. 13rookN
320 Market Streot +
S?rowborry Squnro
P,Q, Box 1268
IiarriNburg, PA 17108-1268
[71712:14-4161
Attorney I.D. No. 49672
Dn(o; , II \ to I ` I`'? AttornoyN fdr Additional Do(bucillot,
Carlisle Country Chub
LlIRTIhWATE 01? SERVICE
1 11fR1111Y GCwrll?Y thot I soryed it Into and Correcl Copy of flip ffirugoing
cloauitment upon fill uolmHOl,of rmord by (loposllltB Iflu saiito it) Ilw llttitacl Status Moll, firot CIm,
11mill a propoid, ntthtri.IHburs, Pannhylvmda, on 1110 (lily ofJ 1199,
acldl'owd qs RoIlows,
Mlolmul 11, Kosik, 138quh'o
Anglno & Rovnur, P.C.
4501 N. Front Rtruot
florriRkirg, PA 17110
homlld 11, tloyl, t:equire
M AKIiY, WWI', IWPP k SCI IAUMANN, 13,11
17 I-1aHl Morkot Struol
York, PA 17,401
GOI,DRERG,, KA'17.MAN 8i 8HIPMAN, 1W,
yy ?.
Cloy 11, DrookH, llHqull'o
ID, No. 49672
120 Morkol Street
P,O, Box 12611
IlarriNtims, PA 17108.1268
ce4.i61 (717) 214-4161
1lu)' I I. Ihauke, I?egllhu
Ll?. Nu. 4ur?72
(IMPlIVIM, KATZMAN 0 NII111n1AN,1'-('
120 Mvll:al nllval
K0. lioN 1261{
Ilmtleburn, PA 171(IH-126H
(.717) 2.1,1,1161
All(li m Y" Air A(dlllmlul POR11,0u111
TIMOTI IY OWN011A, ._-IN TI M Ctaltll'I' Galt COMMON 11 AIO Ott
I'Ininlill' CUMIllilkl ANDCOUNTY,IlVW9YI,VANIA
Y.
dllltf?MY I{UL,L,, No. 98.52211 CIVII.
pol'undnnt
y; JURY'I'RIAI, INIMAND11)
CAR1,181,11 COUNTRY CI,UIi
Addillonlll hul'undnnl
!! LtQl?s?'1 L'li
'1'O TI IF PROTHONOTARY:
1'1.11ASI7 HubHliluto the Ilmlelled Verillentlon with tile Attornuy'H Vorillantloll nttlielled to the
Aimm and Now Muller of tho Additional Dolbttdunt In the obove-relbretloo notion,
Rofilmillllly Hill) ntitIed,
(1OLUIII:ItC, KATZMAN & SHIPMAN, P,C,
Illy:
--
(tuyV17l3rookH, 118(luh0
320 Mitrkot Street
SUmvl,orry S illttru
11,0, I)ox 1268
IIm-0Hburg, PA 17108.1268
1717123,1-4161
Allprnoy I,D. No;" 72,
I)Htua ' I `? 'I AllornuyH Iln• Addltionlll Dalbndnnt
' I'ri5o.1 -
RRI "1'1(111
1, Mlohmol 'I'. KNm1s, Jr., horohy aeknowledg0 that Carlialu Country GIN) is 1111 Additional
Pol'uiidnnt In This oollon mid tilut 111111 0Nlhorleod to lNaku this verioelition on Its bohalf, that 1 haVO
road the lbrogolm A11Hwor and Now Matlor to hotbadant's Conlplailtl,1111111 the filets slated thoreln
are 11'110 INl(l oorreol to 1110 )PHI ol'my knowl0go, h1111romflon mad bollol'.
Nndurat1111d that any 111180 HNIIu1110111H 1101-0111111.0 mildu SNbJo01 to 11011/111108 of 18141, C'S.
4904, relalillg to 1111Hworn 111181110111 loll to a11thol'itioN,
Mime: Mlollla'l T..?Kurli , Jr,
TWO: CINb Manager
01110;, gliqlg9
r
S !i!MER A'1 E 01' RUBMICJ;
I lil?Ill?I1Y G'I?It'I'lI Y ih4t 18ulv0d 4 truo la?II anrr40t oppy of tho fnroonhlj3
Oppunlont upon rill poil11HVl ol'ro0nrd by dopooltin>3 tho 841110 hl tho u111100 StntoH Moll, tirHt 01488,
poelA?P pl'upldd, q(I IIII'1'18b111'!{, llplllIHylvlllll4, nil tllo __ dny nt'_i l,("I I,(' Lf_L? 1999;
w1flic ed 4H 11,IIdtvs;
Miohou113, Kn81k, I?Hgldru
Angino & Kovour, l',C,
4503 N, Front Strout
Ilan-18hurg, PA 17114
04441(1 11, linyl, 1?Hqull'u
111.AK17Y, YOS'I', IIUf'p &,SCIIAIIMANN, I.,I,p
17 I?+141 Mt4•kot Strout
York, I'A 17101
( OL,1)111,11tc , KA'f7,MAN 8c S1IIPMAN, P,C,
Ily
(lily 1), 111,0048, 138gu11•0
ICU, No, 19672
120 M41'kot Stroot
N,O, 110X' 1268
ll4rri8bwg, PA 17108.1268
iedtl.l (717) 231-1161
IN`dg11.1COUKTOhOWINI ]N1114. h
OF CUM1I1?R1,01) COUNT)', I'f NNSYINANIA
C'IYII• AC" riON - I.ANV
TIMOTHY OI,INCII K No. QH-522H (!Ivll'I'urnl
I'Inlmill'
vs ,
dl?It1?MY 13111.,1. „
laolulldlllll ..
VW
CA10,151,1, COUN'T'RY CI.Ui) . JURY TKIAI, PIWANPIII)
Addllinnoi Puluncitmt
RIBPIN OF 1)EFENDAN'I',(hREA1V IIII11A
' ..' 'I'O N1?7\V NIA'I"I'I?ilt OI' Appl'I'IONAI I]h'1?1?'NI)AN'I'
- CAltl,ltilrl9 COUNTRY C'LUII
DeNndnnt Jorumy Milk by his nllornoys, lilnkuy, Yo.91, liul7p & Sahnummliit, MOM
W8 A1lswor to Addltlonnl P01'undnlll's Nuw Moller, ovorrln8 as Ihllows;
20; Tho nllogNlons 01'1111-4 11111-ngroph nro dulliud pul'suanl In I'll, R,Cd', 1029(0),
21, Thu nllogntlony ol'Ihls I'll r,lgrnph nru dullud ptu'stnlnt it, I'll. R.C.P. 1029(o),
22, The ollugollons ol'lltls pnrograph pro clulllucl puPStlOtll to I'll, R.C.P. 1029(o),
23, The ollogntlons oi'this Parngrnph nru dunlud pilrlimull to I'll. ILC,P, 1029(u),
24. I'hu,tdlugnllnnn ol'Ihis Pnrngrnph nru dunlud pul'sunnl to I'n. R.C',l', 1029(0),
25, Thu nllugodony ol'Illls Pnrngrnpll ore dunlud pursulull la I'll. R,C.I' 01029(0),
26, The ollogu1lons ol'Ihls Pilrngrnph are, dunlud pursunnl to I'll, R',C,P, 1029(u),
„
{
i;
27, Mor runHnnnhlu inyustlunliPn Polbildi nt is wilhnyl knnwiudnP ar
hdn Mollnll @nl)1PIPni In 11,1'111 P bulPl nH In Illu II'lllh ilrlhlm uYurnimil Old h IH, Il1PrPlhru,
cIPIII?d,
WI1PUPPRI3, PPlundnnl rmilJOHIH dos C Aurl to umol-jlldamunt in Ills lilvnr Old
POOlnal IN Addhinnnl PPlunilnnl
' ItuepoulJlllly H11Un11tlud,
III,A!WY, YO ST,13UI'P SCII JA1;1MANN, Flap
11yi .-
Prnlnld li, lin>?I,13Ngnh.?
S, Q. I. P.1118061
Altornuy Ilur PolbndaO
1713nH1,Mnrkol Slrou1
York, pA 17,101
'reluphnno (717) 015.3674
11.1131iY WRIFY thAt 1110 ItlkillAtloll Not f??rih In 1110 fbrognlns AMM111, Is into And
oarroot to tho boat of my kn0wloduo, Information cold hollOG I mndoratond 01101 Ally folio
atotpill 0ills OnlltAl[loll 1101'0111 AI'0 milljocI to tIl0 1 anoltl0a of I A I'll, C,S,r,190q, I'O1A11118 to immyori1
fnIAItlOAtinn to nntllnrltloa,
r i
• _ JOIOI lY ?tlll' I
Dotoc ?
I rrr l rr
r
l
t
y
m.?
CE TIFI(1ATH.,,O SUMVICI,
I hoi'ahyvarllly that 1 inl 1111h (Illy oallsluB n copy of' 1110 Io Now
WIWI, of Addillomil Polondlllll to bu suryml tell IN I1111oNV111B por8one III 1110 Illllllllol'
Indlpilodl
fly 1711'81 Cliss Mill oil
(lily 1-1, Rrook4,11fiqulro
GOLP111M, KATIMAN SHIPMAN, P.C.
320 Mnrkol Suwvt
11, 0, [lox 1268
MIITlsbor$, pA 17108.12611
(Allornoy for Ad(lllonil hvl'unclanl)
MAIM 13, Koslk, l?sgUlrO
ANQINO R ROVNRK, P.C.
4503 Nomb Front drool
1-IIn,-IHUurB,1'A 17110
(Altornoy ft„ plnlnllil)
111_.AK11Y, YOST,11UF'P &1 SCI 1AUMANN, 11,W)
fly, ?
?N 114,11 M 311; T?nrnloBil
antvdt
Curtis R. Long
Prothonotary
Office of the Protbonotarp
Cumberlanb Countp
Renee K. Simpson
Deputy Prothonotary
John E. Slike
Solicitor
98 - .S229 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF TERMINATION OF COURT CASES
AND NOW THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2007 AFTER MAILING NOTICE OF
INTENTION TO PROCEED AND RECEIVING NO RESPONSE - THE ABOVE
CASE IS HEREBY TERMINATED WITH PREJUDICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH PA
R C P 230.2.
BY THE COURT,
CURTIS R. LONG
PROTHONOTARY
One Courthouse Square • Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 • (717) 240-6195 • Fax (717) 240-6573