Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05250 " ',' " ,. I' ';l ;.,; II WI " .. i,1 ~ I,' 1'1 " . ...c; ~ " .. Ii' ",. ~ .. 1\ " il; if ,,, " i' " .. ~ .. .. .. " "" " it " .. . A.. " '1; '.. .. " ~ ,. .. ",; " 0-... " "'j WJ " .. 1- " " ~ " " .. J " . H " " " ~ H \ '-', i "" \ .. '.. . ,1 q. ~ " , " " " ~ ... " I " " - i c: ~ II I: " Vl I ~ I " u .... I!: ,( ,', '( " " " I " i I, it , ..' i; !\ , " w , " .. " j.! ,I! " "j, ,ii, ',1 \, (.j 'j, IH " , II' " d' I'!, " I " ( i !, , ~ , " ~ i " I .. " " " " ;i ,., , I " .. " " :" l.j" . " 'd' ~ '" . .. '-J H ," ~I p,;, ;, 1,""" " .. ~I " \{)/ ~l ~ .~ /l, Plfllnllff oonll\oloel Millo ~ll1\ll.flrrY 1~f1llaol1Pr sovuml limps In 1110 follpwlllfJ Wlll'lIIS Anel WAS f1nlllly lolclln JI1I10 111111 11'11) Il\lyurll 110 lon(lol' WfHllnd Ihp oqllllll11llnl \Juonllno IIl11Y 11ml P\ll'ol1Alllld olhor oqlllpl11ol1l fromnn nvlnllon b\lsln088 In I,nollos\ol', Now Yorj(, . 0, Plnlnllffoonlnolucl oonnlp Wolal1lp lry 10 reney! 1110 fl[jOllOY cJQnlrAol wl1lol1 expired MAY 30, 100B,' Illll defomlRnl l'of\lsDd alnlhl0 ah13 I,WI 8olclll11l13qlllpnlenllp 80l11e0l10 In Now Yorll, Tl10 opnlml1l proVlcloclll1f11 pll1lnllll'a nganoy stfllllS sllrvlvos 1110 oontmol 11Y 1[1p,cJnys, , , , " 1 0, ~ay TllnlollOl', s<1losl11nn for plrllnllff. vlsllodl. \'l. M tylflOl1lno In Jllly of 1 (lon nnd s(1olll'ecllll13 sarlnll1lJl1111arll off of two of Il1l) fO\l1' plooas of eqlllpl1113nl, TllO s13l'lnll]lll1111el's 111f11011l3clll16l11lmbel's of 1I1e eqlllpl11enl IIs1aclnllove, All fO\II' 1110del nl1l1111\3l'S Il1f.llohod IIw ' eql11pl11onlllslad nlJOVo, . 11, pefandnnl Connlo Walsl1 sold 1110 oqlllpnlanl 10 I. & M ty1nolllno rtnCI cllclnol pny 1110 ~PO(o snlal1 001111111sslDI110 Ihe plnlnllll ns raqlllrl1Cl by 1I1e lerl11s of 8nlcl 0011111101, 1;1, Aa n oonseqllfJnoP of COl1nlo Wplsll'S Ilranol1 of ponll'nol, plnlnllff 11118 S\lffarod 1I1a,Ioss or $10,OOO,OP,' . , WHt:Rt:rORt:, PI<,lnllff reqw'lslsll1ls Honorflhlo 00111'1 10 onlor nn Orclernwmdlng 10Plfllnllff 1110 SIII11 01.$10,000,00, logolhol' wllh flllornoy'a foos nndsllol1 011101' rqllef nalhls Honol'nhl13 COllrt c10l1I11S '1ppropl'lfllo, OOUNT il .lntontlllnllllnterforol1oe Wllh 13~IIlII1IlS11 Rlllfltlonshlp . . 13, PI'1ln\1ff reallogos p'1rnornpl1s 1 Ihrollgh11 of firs I 0011111 flS It IIlose fllloonllons were sot forll1ln filII In 111 Is 0011111, . , . , , , 14, pohwlants oolllldodlo mrnnge the sfllo of 1110 flbove eqlllpl11Snl dlroollY frol11 ,00nl1le Wolsl1 to L & M Maohlno, Inlonllonfllly flvoldlng pflylng plalnllff's cOl11mlsslon, . 15, Pofllnd'1nls arrnngod the 8fllo of flbovo eqlllpn1Unt frof11 Connlo Wolsh 10 I, & M Maol1lne 1I11'0110h fllhlrd pmlY 111 Naw Yorl~lo ellrnlnfllo oVlqanoo of their rolflllonslllp, ' 16, pefandant Oonnle Welsh wlllflllly '1ndl11flllolollsly Intorfored wl\h Ihe oml oonlraolllfll rolollonshlp bel\'(oon pl'1lnllff and L & M Maol1lne, " ., 17, Pefonctants Mlol1ool andl.arryR'1llsohor wlllflllly and I11flllclOllBly Inlerfol'l;1d wl\h Iho wrl\lon otlnlrflotllElI relO\lonsl1lp betwaun plfllnllff flnd Connie Welsh, 18. As '1 lJOnsaqllonoo of clefond'1nts' Inlol1\1onnllnlorferonoo with bllslness 10l'1llonsl1ll)' plnlnllff Is ontltledlo rooovor pllnl\lve dfll11'1gos from dofondanls In 1110 '1mDltnt of,' . two \1In~s he oonl1111s810n amollnt, ($20,000,00) frol11 eaoh defendant, ($40,000,00), . 1 g, Plflln\lff flips Ihls oOl11plolnl In 0 IImely f'1ahlonl 2 I' i" " " C' " ", " ,. ;" , " w " '" ";; " " " q, , I, " '" , 'j, " " " " ;' ,. ,. !'" ,. " ,I I" I' , (0 It;-. rJ ,.,(\ f' ~ j.. " Ii " j' R ~' It:. h ~ ..... ~ pt:J ~... F 'il--, '<, II' " .. , " ,. ,. " " .. oj " 'I " 1\, " iil i: ,. '(I .. .. , ., , II " I "'((;') , ".\ \'1 ' ,) '"""'- '~\ ~ ~ \ . I ", II' \ , . ~ 'Ii"" " " " ,. 'f"1 r'.l, .. "", (-..1 "1 I " I d,t , c, I ,"~ - \,,1 I' ) li,1 i II 0, Plnlnllf( nonlnolorll-I\.M r:l1olnllll, Ino, llPVllrAIII1110n 1I111w (01low1110 WPlllm nncl W~B f1n<1l1y lolclln ,jl/I1('lll1nIII1Il11l/yerI1O Illl\IWr WlInllJllllw IlCHllpl11U111 110PrI!IBIlII Imcl pllrolHlBorl ollwr eqlllpnlOnt frol11 nil flVlnllonl1llnlnosB 111 I~ocl1DBtor, New YOI'll, 0, 1"1,,11111[( cpnlnotllcl OOl1nle WClIsl1 to try to rlJn('lW IIIP nOllnPy cJOn\nwl whiol1 . explreq MflY 30, 1000, 11111 clefpl1clfllll rehlsacllltnlln(J nl1fl ,'WI Bold IIw I1Cllllpn1l'lnt to Bomeone In N('lw YOI'll, Th('l oonlrflot provlcl('ld tll~t plAintiff's flOOllOY stillllll sl.IIVIV('lS 110 oonlmot hy 11\0 dfWll, 10, ~AY Thntol1or, snleBIllf1n for plninllff. vlslterll. & M r:l1olnqs; Ino, In July of 10081111d seotlled Il1ellerlnl 1lllll'IIlllrS off of two of 1110 fOilr pleono of eq\llpnlOnl, Tl10 serlnl ' numllllrs I1lntol1acl the n\lInllers of Il1e oql/IIll11onl IIstml flllove, All fOilr Illodol nlllnhars I1Wlol1('lcl tho equlpnwn\ listed fl\love, .. '. , . 11, pefell\lnnl Connie Walal1 sold the eqlllplllel11 10 \.. 8. M r:noll1eB, Ino, nl1cl clld nol pny IIle ;!O% a~Ies oOl11l11lsslol1l\1 tl1e plnll1\1ff n~ rO'll/lred hy Il1e tarms of Bnld oontrnot. " 12, As fl OOnSI3'1\le110e of 00111110 WelBh'R IlrallOh of oOl1tlflol, plflll1l1ff 11f1S sllffered tile loaa of $1(>,000,00, WI~pRgFORp, PlAintiff reqlll1sls tills l-\OIWlflble 00111'1 to enler nn Order ~wm(lll1o to Plflln\lff,tlle BUm of $10,000,00, looelher wlll1l.lltornoyls feeB f1l1cl sllol1 otl1el' rellaf fill tl1lll '.lonomIJle court . doolns flPPl'oprl~\o, GOUNT ~ ' ln~ontlonnlln~orforonoo wllll ~wllnooo Rohlllonohlp .... 13, Plfllnllff I'ealleoes p~tf1gtf1phs 1 II1rolloh11 of flrsl oount flS If thosEj alleOfltlons were Sll\ forll1ll1 flIIllnllllll oOllnt!' ,,' '. .' 14, pefenclElIlts oollllcled to atl'f1l1ge 1110 SAle of IIle flbove oqlllpl11enl cllreotly IrOnl Oonnle Welsl1 10 ~ & M gnolne,s, Ino", Intenllllnally \wolclh10 paylno plalnllff's oOl11l11lsslol1, 15, De(ondants mrangecl the sflle of above equipment from Oonnle WelBhlo ~ & MEnolnes, Ino, tl1rollol1l.1 tl1lrd party In New Yorll .\0 elhnlrl(lle ,:Vldel1oe o( \l1ell' roll1t1onsl1lp, 16, Pefendf1nt Oonnle Welnll wlllfllllY andm~lIolQusly Int\1rferod wlll1lho 01'111 conlra6\\Jfll rolElllonshlp belweon plaln\lff ~ncll. & M Enolnes,'Ino, . .. 17/ Pfl(l1nclflnt ~&M r:nglnes, Ino, Willfully flncll11flllplously I~\erfered with Ille wrltton oonll'110\\Ifll relationship between plaintiff f1l1d Oonnlo Welsh, .. . 18, As f1 oonseqllonoe of c1efendanls'lnlanllol1nllnterferel1oe WIII1 business relallonshlp, plalnllff Is entllled 10 I'epovor punlllve c1f1lllfloes froln defencl~nls Inll1e I1moun\.of Iwo times 1110 oOl11mlsBlon I1I1101lnt, ($go,OOO,OO) fl'OI11 efloh defendant, ($40,000,00), II 1 g, Plflll1l1rf fIIos tills oomplnlnlln f1 IImely ff1sl1lon, 2 WH~R!;FORf., '~lnll1l1(( 1'(l~IIOa\1l Il1la I'lonprnh!iJ CPIlI'\ Inonl\ll' nil Orclol' flwmdln(J 10 Pll1lnllrt 1110 ~11111 of $1\0,000,00, loop\l1Ol' wlll1 nllol'noy'u [OUB nnd IHlol1 011101' rellp( 118 111/8 l-Ionol'f,\1110 OOllrl cloel11a npprnpl'llIlp, .. " " " RoapoolfllllY 11lllll11l1lacl, ~., /4.' , '-../ ~/J ..,.A---,__ tLt'..- ~..~"'.\' --.----....-_~..J '.i.lndanYPmel3iiirci,'(:Bq-;-- 378, 1-1 11 nc1\'O I' 811'001 . 0111'11810, I'A 17013 (717) 243,6732 " " " . ., j " " of' j! " ii, " " " " , " " ., " ." " '1'\; " I; " '. , 3 '1; ,. " " , IiI " ,. " ",Ii i,' " I' li('\I<!':,~'!'/II'~[1 [,':::6 1'1,1 /.IA/l"I' EJ:[i $11(11' E',II'[ I: AX 11(1, . /':'II{:;r.1f:,jl 1 h ... ~ f, 1 d IImWllill1111N'.l' rO{\ f:lM4/il PI" Nl\.9I!INIU 1.11111' lll~~'IJ.'mlWl.' 'I'PI M'f.\ll/lfJ.l'!li\ Hhop !JJ~l\\iPIl1Q1\t 1:l(\l,~"I, 11111, !J M(l1\\:/iI0r/1 gOt\,j 'C.'~\~'~J.1.11HI PI\ 1'70i:l 'l'l1ilJ A[JFHHIIIHnl;, 11\(\1:11) \:11;1.(.1 .3.Q,jqy PI' ,;\'/11.\1." ,LI)!) 'I b~' l\nd.. . Pf1t.Wfll'1l1 Mqn(ll~~o~r.\ f,lhQI.1 IUI'1Il.1P\Mltl~,~Jl\loSI lPi;1, r)f. 0 Mrm\dIfH'''' RI)~I\, (J1'I\":\t~llil, ,~lliInnl'l !lVMi), 1hIH\' 1 111.1 f'\:", I' J:HCIH'r','I:1 t':1 I.\f~ IMllnnfl",'lfl") ilfHI . . r. .1,~;~I.,\."e,_._, :\,,I,~~-n,'~'y+'III(L. .."......,,"'\lil:I'l.i.' A~\:ei?""~oloi~i~,.i.rTi~ ~~ T-,.,....~ ' ..~~~~..&~~Jr.,1;.l-41< :1-__,..... I,")" 1, ,~ ",.,.,_ ...._~ " ,. ill in:E:~rt.. H. i:J t'lll~, 11'!l \?W\10l1 (fl) .. o~ floe' l\)~,n flI11rl\qt:.1H;w:l.l/lfH~ \1P I~X/!!Oqt:r" IIn. A{:11:t\ ,f~)L' thl,1 lll~ln pi; lIIiRr!I),LIlO UllOll \~(~II;1.~~I1\: Iq~,lIH,'dpl'If,1 MI C()J,~, WfJ I " . I. )" n MMli1 , u:n:It.UVta~~J 1",Ml'IJ<l11I .G, .e."it(.l.l'\ ~ ) M1\ !<li! I.k6.:u1.J<.;/1&.l.JL..:-n".JI 6 ~"~ . MOP~\'.II_C.lk.1\i'''L..__."", MOl.l/ilH J. ,. . .,:j ,~..,...., , MC.lp~ll, I .../)1/2".1.,.._:.&1",:5.'.'1.,,_ (!.Clc..K I 13~ I_I ir:.(i...:.J'~-,.::..".." flN I.r-&... ~_., ." m~ I _."._.,...'''...........'' ~ Plllll.;l~'~1 'j,Qn, , , L)~)f;lpl..J.pI.".(')n 1 l1r~llql'.1.pl;ilm I , .cr.(.~v:\\{~. i\t.:J~C, (:".- e r.u..\:iS:..-\AlJ,/.Lf:.(,,_. ll') c'.111.UJtoJrtc..f:hl:ttdlb...J.hpt1f, tlb 1'1 "'ICe, t'-I( / ". . . " . ' Xill'I!.\.\ ~ecr ~I~. ':1/dl1 I!l<\lo c\;t:'fj 111,1 J:t'lla\;(II:1 "O.~lqwj()r.l.i'l1'l l\(~ \;he . oI..\IIJ,pmfll)t, oxo~VI. r:1.~l'L_.. .._./-.Y(\~:\.,l/,<<.'. _,.:."......" _. I' . The pl.\:t:'l:,iEltil ha1.'0 t:Cl, il'l\:Mdi.na \:0 /;Ie :1.1.\\1/.\:\1)1 ~m~\lI"1 t10 h!u'a~'\' "f;t\'l~'flfl A~ CoUQ,WIlI' , :~ ,~lIJA1NILll.NIL.QQ~p.;!;UONa 1\, ~/1 l~ol1fJJ.c1or"t.t()r) pf."Mtlllsf,io.l.d l.l.al;,tng I;.hl';"liibt.>ve dOll" 1'lr.1bocl ml\oh~.OI'I fJ!1pp ijtIlI.i.pnll'll1r. to;r fJ\lla allcl ill C~\l.'I;.,hf:1l" Imnl'l;l.cl111;'L\l::loll oft MUflFJI!.l.ald'll /101;"Y;l.r:J, fJ IIml ClCCQ1~i:,/l :in f.illti Il~ /;I, pUL'tlhL\llC,ll;' for \:1)0 . mquipl\\l!ll11: I " -J(~U.1. . 'Ub~ll. rJl',!\I1~ MlIlll:lf. ,j,elq the, ,. I~X01U1~y t.:LgJl~,' fQx' ~ p~r,1:or.\,. Qf .,,\1~H)y,\:' .S, up 1;0 Clnr.l :lnolndfng .......4/ ._.:-t) () , ~,nqL'7.1 \'0 lIeH pf;t.(le(X~IJ.Plll.nt" D, '~hlll fJt1llbt1f/ pdoP.l for oqLli)?mr.\lIt, ,ll.h~Il\::lr..t~d /;I,1'l 1I;t llbcJV~ IIh~l.l I~e ~,~. ,~,t-)'6,r: " ' .' ~e .ellit1rJ prjce for aqu~pment :lctenbie:lH~ .s 02 above ahA 11 be $ I.;J. ~!,(JC' ,IJ,~ , " The 'ffiiffl"i'i'o"' J.,~l;ifla F,'':>l" I.lqLdpme11t :lL1Llllt,i.fiRQ ,,; 11:1 above ahn.ll 1.10 L!i;,ili.~,,~,~_._..__., . . Q, In the Avont thmt MllnBfie~d p~DdllQo~ a purchaser ~m to ~'el\cW/ will:ltll'l I\I1L1 I'Ible \;0 p~lrqhar.It'l thlil mju.i.pmel\t:. lie-thE! !H,''.l.Qea '.\nL\ h~rmf.l I:Hl\l )lort,11 abov/", ol~ i:f the eqll:!.pm<;ll1t ,113 uold o:r.' L~Xqhi'.\l1r19.;1 by _k(JA"I<p.JC _ o. "'Y 0'"'' ..,.tVh.for' 01,. ~f''''''to.c \; IiI'! I\Ylt~E.1 IlJlmnt:, a~l\ny, PJ.'lC1El,Ol" l',arml'l 1I0"f;\[1tl'\bla I:r.1 _.., V1\("D... , 011 if _"0. ''\Ly.\.IAlCt1.<(~ ..__ "lAllA !ll\id f.ll)u:lrimtml:, w.1.l\hit1 crayi'~ 't:e;l;'~ha t'l?{pr.r;!t iClI\ 011 ~11:l13 fI~J.l.'eol1\ent tl1, ~ Pl\l"ty whh whom I atlf5He~c\ anel/ot' tm tlul:l\l"1izsr.l' J:flPT:t'l8, ent,i'llj~Vfl ,.(.CI~:tM<ll1flf:l,t!l~l ha,I3 M(1ol:J.nt:od (.Ill '1\ prO!lpL\ol:,:l.Vfl p\l~"t111I'lUat., y.(lAvd .' ag1.'M (Ell tQ l,ny MllnrH'.t131d <I dI11l\l1\:lS,Y!0l1Df. ~% oF, l',Re"r~~J:afl p:a.'~ce, whioh f.1Qllllllitlsicm rJhllU be r,\~\1:\ l'ltltl J.,~Cly-~blf:1 at, Bal;.l:,lalm,nt, . . mXIlJ.IU'I' IW' J' , q \ ", "~I' II('V"2I\-j'l IYHlf,: ::7 f'M MAII-" Iitll SIIOI' E(II'T FAX If (I, ,;:msrd fl, ;: . .'? , ,PQ~IUl/l/l;I:Pti 1~'n/lf1ftfJfli\'iI1 I',ll: allie1 11\1\~)hinl) (~I1~)P ~lq\i I.pmri1!ll: 1,11111:\1 hrl rlpl tvt'n7f.lrt he') p'l1mhant\l,' Ilrmnl'Ml'Ilpt., o~ OM/h, Q\'l~'~if~or:\ {.1hmf.1k qr vl1Hr.'\ I'l\;L'9hnse Ort.\r;n7 fflrom 1'1 tmnn f,i riel lr'lllnEl o~l11Pf.\nY, oil \lho "01:omr:\ MP~1 ~Al$$ prtQ~1 :3 , ~1M~lllo:r:nI'G..qll'".\IlQt!;J;Ii'MWIll~ . Mflllf.lj:.1ftlrl flh$.):I, ln~qvi~\o 1;)~\Pur.i Qf)(.)!1 (.If(nl~d,fJnQ\1 ill ~hlol IIltlpl~e!;i.1\9' of. "l/~:ll~ ar;j\\ipI1\Ullt H,.1 bl:l/1\: fltl:m:t;fj \;0 f1l110\I,l;'S a. p\lt'qhMI'U: f,Ol~"t\hfl aq\\ipmen~, Ml1nI.1f.i.I.-1.1.ll, hl')WftYfl;t', O{;{;t.'ll:'/J I'IP EIUIU'IlIIl\;al'l I;h~~ ~\: w,tH P!~ a.b:\.f! lip IHH'J\1l:11 l'I P\\;L'Qhtll.Hf1I~ tor l;!lft ~J~n\ivm~ll~l;, 1~~'1Mn.f:11,tl l'flflfll:'Vl'I/l lthlfl ;I;'.laht: h,) mflr.l~ft\: l;ha ,I'tGl\\~r.1Vtll' 1\1 ~bovit \;hl~ al,\1;1.J;~ng In'ir,lep r.lOnl;el1,nf-1l~ hl':~:o,l.n ~,P pover.' e~'a inl;lurl:url by M/.Inll.f;ifI~l~ p\loh till l?;Lol~"~lflf ctal.iv\it')'1 ill~tlllll~t:jrJnl minc'~' l"I~Pld,Vll /.Illc~ /.IllY \l'llrl~ar\l!'l' aXtlel\lqeq py Mnrlflfl\ij.I~ \:0 ~ha );1l1l'U \1'.\ 11\i r' , . '1'ho$4) (1\1IIl:~lell /.Il,'e pd(~ by ~ha v~\r~lh/.\pf\,r 1'1i,l.'erJI:,~)' i;p M/.\llfolf.\.I'I.j.C\, 4 '~M^\,('~.g",..:.. ,_..,,,,_W(1t'l'..lIlt,II'I~fltJ\iUl!.l:l,' I~f rl.l'dd IIIllOhl.na I1hnp 1~I:Jl\i,~lmen,t:fm.\il:lil~l: 11l1~hl;\,y hf.\Vfl 1~l')Pc1 titl'il i:,q fJ"dct e'.\Qi~,)lIIanl~ f.lncl hhut.: puoll \;1\::\.0 ;l.a j;rea f.\flc) \'::\.eL)~' ~)f. all lil'll1ra 1,l11<1 t\l\(1UIIIln'/.\nl~I.'lIil, il101\.1tUnp but: not 1,:I.mHarl 11CJ mQ;ro~:gl'.\gllfJ, UC~l .f;.i liP911, IInl:\ jlHlgemel1\HI, J;n ~,l\l'l aVflllt tho\'. I.Inyl:Llll\til liltl(,llllllhJ.'/.\nCJI~1'l exit;ll:, -,.-Lr~' .K.Q,i,:.. l!\11l;'ee(il l~hl'.\l~ fidel ri4)r,,~ or tllw\,\\\)I),I.'!\nr,1811 131w,1l, b~ l,)!\~q, by _\^~'l\r.:L ;111: 01;' In'lor 1:0 fll'/tl:lllml)l1i:" .......", 12Jil.I;'.Qfi:nc. . !lU t\apl;lpH m\.>l1eYlndrl 1;(I\VIH'r.lr~ \:.htl pUJ.'I~h~ae,l.' pdo€l of: . aai.<i mach;l.ne pIlot' l'l<;(\\ilJIIII;H1t. fJhl!\ll l:>e hale) in ~HIOt'OW by Ml.\nlllf iaId Wl\\!l IHl~t:hm~nt, ' '. .. . . Ii . J:NPIi1MNlP;CNl':rON ., . . ..1(llAli().,... _ ' u\.l rl~e (rJ) to inqemn.Hy a.ncl h<;l~.r;l M/.\Illolf ~c~r;l hn~'m.Jif;1nU J:l;'om l\lW 1.1aIilTIl;y Q~' ~1){ptlnlJa ,l!I~';!.lid.n~T fl:O\1l l\1lX' Iilil3l:qpl,.tl- flan!:!\\1ion (~l! IM\l~,I.'i~,.l, j;A(Jt" c:>~' of nn aXl.pl;;!.lIlt Utili 01' ~1I'Wlllllb1;'P.\llClfl 011 Iill\id 1l1iwhill~ /j!lop ollll,i.t~men~" '7 ',' ,LAW 0l1' a'l:A~,l1fl1 TO GO\tJillUl . 'l.'hiIJ A~lrt'lEllnnl1l: ,~l\l~ll .i.n till "l'111PHCl,liS I~l(,~ .lnl;l'tl.'pl'Ol:.4\d 0J:" ('1\';11ll\l!:l'\\od a\)(:\ goVe~'I\I!lt1 1.11' thlll l/lw/l (If hhe ,:lpIIIlIIOIlWfii\ll:.h ~1f: Pel\'lll- 'I~ylv~n:t.a, w:ll:.hollt. ,I.'et:r,\n~lwa tic:> iura (;lOtlf.Ll.l'.I\:$ ~lj: ll'lW/l c\eoira~'C'"tl. 8 , MQI}U.lQNli.:t.gN ",. 'l'he'I;IH'I11fJ c:>t ~,h:\tl Af1l'eelllri111t mOlY IJe llIudJ.Ciad Ol\ly .111 wr;l.ltin~, Bigna~ by the party toba l'.Ihurgod with tl~ Mcd.1f.iaation. IN WI'I'N1llSS WltlllRIilOP, t.lla pt;\l:\:ieo\1l31:Il\:O huv"I 13Xl3Qu\;l'ltl t,hltl A\,lJ:'MmEll1t, us of. \:ha tlnt,a and YIH\t't:il"Bt:, j}1o\l: tnt;l l\b~w'7'l. .1 Mh1'191r!IJlLL)",WIOP ElQ.I,!;U:~llli,. INC I -Av... ' , 'hL~Cill'S bya..~,L1~JL...1 Pr'tftTa.._b~J x.. . " - .~" tTFIe . , "adchau J:.(r,..!.':l Al\ui:li_~;..wlLA~ladJl,l, . . . . ,4J.J.b;a.tL/l.d<t-/l.~o.,..._ Llhc)llI? . .......!./I.2..:..').(..L.::../).5.'Y6".._...._,__ " I" " I' 11'\'II1U '1',,1. \~oOI\PI', I\H\I' -11J1/:!2rm IOH 1'010 PI', ' Npl'lh WnluH, 11/\ I U45d-"~(11 1\ 1I0I'lW)' 1\11' !JplplHlnl1l "\~1vI Hnllll1PH, 111\1, II " ,/,pl (~15) 412,- nrl7 Fnx (21 ,'i) 1112- 73(iH _.. -,---. ..._-_......----...,~~"_._._-_......._-_...-.-..._----..-.~-.....,----...~,.....-._.._._--.__..--..,.-._.-----..."';--.__._~-.--.---.;-- Mi\NHFlliW HI 101' liCJllII'MI':NT Hi\f,liH.INt', IN 'I'I IIi Clllllrr OF cOMMoN 1'!,fii\H OF' CI IM/lI\ltl,i\NIJ COUNTY, PHNNHYI,V ANIi\ CIVil, i\l'TION" Id\W 11111111111'1' \" CONNW R, Wnr,HII.,nnll IllJlJ ) IWNI<III, i\\JTO PMTH, IN<\ UH.5250 CIVIl. TIIIHvl ill1d I,&M IINOINIiH, INt!, ) , ,IMpllllnnlH -'---_..""!1._.'........_________._~_~._._~-___._.___ -1_---------,;-,-- " , olWliR AND NOW, thlH IIn)' 01' Ii , 1(1)", IIIH hPI'pb)': It OIWERIiIl nlld IJIiCIUiliD tl1nt dplul1dllllt, I,&M Iil1llhlPH, Inp,'H Pl'plIl1lllllll')' Dh,lpotloIlH'lI'U lJI'1I1\1od II1Hltl1o 1\I11OIIdod Cpmplllll1t ol'tl1o 11111111111'1; MlInHllold H!1op Ilqulpl1lllnl . HnlPH, IIWi hUllnd IH I1ol'uh)' dIHI111~HUd, wlthonl pl'u.llldlpu, '. flY '1'1 IIi COURTI -----.---------.. '--7-....... " ,I, il. y '! , "I ,.j' \, I' j',; " " , WlllifUWOIW, Ilpl\JI1(II1I1IWlllsh I'VIIII\lsls Ihls COli 1'1 10 sllslnll1lhls f'1'(llhl1ll1l1l'>' Ohlvplllll1 '10 V\lI1\1vIII1IIIUII'III1Slill' Ihls IIvllun III Allv~IHlI1)' COli 111>, pll I's 1111 111 10 PII,H,C, p, IOOfi(ll), "'i\n,Vlm '1'0 S'I'i\'I'1C (Ji\I1HI~ Ofl' ACTION i\Cli\INS'I' CONNIIC H, WI~"SII . ,. . ,," - . /- I', )1111111111'1' fllll'pol'ts 10llSHVI't II (lllllsvlll' 11(lllollllgllll1sl j)(llolllllll1l ('0111111' Wvlsh, 111 IWI' 1I\(lIvld\l1l1 PlIPIlPII>" lfl, IIoWOV\1I', I1pon I'(lvlvw or 1I1(l Aglwl1l1ll1l, lIpol1 whioh PllIhHll'1' I'vllvs, Ills CIVIII: 111111 f)ptondlllll Wolsh Is spvolnolllly 1'(llol'l'cd lOllS "Collnlo 1\\1111\01 (1,(I\\lI1Kol Alllo " I PlIl'ls", (Olllpllllsls mldo(l) Thl1s, Ills OIPllI' Ihll! j)pf\Jf1(hllll W(llsh Is Iho COII!II\l1 pOl'sonfnt' f)olonlllllll KIIIIKol. , I?, Fmth\lrl\1ol'P, l'!lvlowlllg Iho o~oPllllon soolloll of Iho AIlI'OllIlWI1I, h Is eIVIII' Ihllt f)ol'vnclul\1 Wvlsh oxvOIHvll lho A!ll'oenWIII 011 hohull' of' f)olol1dlll1l KnnKvl.1 1I COl'pol'llllon, nlld 1101 In lIny Indivl(llInl cupnohy, t 8, Pllllntlff fhlls 10 Sllllo u OUlIso of' uollol1 ullulllHt. f)\,londmll WolHh 1'01' hnlu\lh of Iho Agl'ool\1ol\l ll\1culIso sho is 1101 U pUl'ly 10 tho A!lI'COlllOI1I. 19, hi Iho lIhsonoo of' spoollll Oll'\llllllstllllcos donlOlIsll'lltlnglllll1 pOl'sonllll'ospOllslhllhy WUSI1SH\lInocl 011 hvhllll' of Iho o01'/lOl'lllloll, II cOl'flol'lIlo of/1001'OI' closl!lllhlod lI!lOIl! Is nol pOl'sonlllly 1'0sflOllslhlo to tho olhol' flul'ty, WHBREF01W, Dol'olldnllt Wolsh I'cquosts Ihnt this COUI'lIlI'UI1I hol' Pl'olhninul'Y OhJeotloll il " p , 1I11t! d,lsllllss tho Allloncled COl11pllllnlnguinsll\cl' with projudloo, . . Ii 'I " " " " ii,! Ii" 'I, " " " "Ii " " f! I' d " " H " ii' 'I ii' ,; i' " I' " " , 1 " " , " " I' "I " " , , " " " " " '\.(.1 \::0 :-n !:') " . l\ " ,(~; PI/If ,~' II' ,', " i i, f' , " ,;:", II I Ij:,lJ ,11'.1 li\',', \ , J(J :;;:1' ",d, ,/., r'j I" I ;:,J ::J , C'j I: 'n ::1;, ,i~j " Ii ,:';1, .,., (11 j-, " " I' " ,/ " 'I, " I' " ',. " , H j, ,. , ,: I ~ Pi. i'o' " " " ,. , " " ii, " "~I ", '-'I ," ,I' 12, ArImllted . , 13, Pell1lnel. Cl1l18n of Hollon 11r0811 In Cllmllorlnnel County 118 n rn8\11l of 11 !lenoQ of 110tlPlwlnvolvlnu 1l1n pnrtlufl," " 1'I,P\llllml: Tho lJl\\18e of I\ollon mose 111 ClIl11llOrll1nrt COlmlY, Trnl1sl101l0n8 allet oP\l\lrrenoes oul of Wllloh lhe llOtlOI1 QlOsn rlld luko pinon In CIlIl1berlElnd County, WHf.Rt:FORt:, plnlnllff r08ppctflllly r0<1\108Is this Courl to clol1Y Ihls Preliminary OllJaotlon 10 vel1\lo; , Hi,Admll\eti, Hl, penlml. Slrlol prllof of palemlr1l1t Wolah'!l rnpresllnll1l1ve onpnollY for 1~lInkel All to PEuls Is req\llrerl. , 17, penlerl. I~roof of corporate resolution 01' Ily-Iawa empowering pefentiont Welsh to aot on oorporatlon'a, b(jhAlf re<1l1lrerl. ' 1 0, ~1enlecl. Defendant Welsh Is pOlly 10 agreement wlthollt fllrlher proof AS listed ahoV\l' If nol, her aotlons In Ilreaoh are speolal OlrO\lll1atanoes I1Hlklng hor personnlly responsltlle, , 19, Mmltted, WHt:Rt:FORt:, PIEllntlrf respootflllly rfl<1l1osls Ihla COliI'I c1eny IhlB preliminary Objsotlon to dlBmlsB the Amendnd Complall1l. ' . 20, Admitted, 21, Adnillled, 22. Admitted In part, denied In part, Statement 'I la admitted, Stalement21s denied, The pLlrporlllcl sale of eqLllpmenl to the bllBlnElsB In Rooheeter, New York, WaB L1sed to .' thwart plaintiff of lis commlBBlon for Introdllollol1 of Defendants Welsh aM 1~lInlcello Defendant L & M Maohlne, Ino, I3II1B of l.adlng and f1nanolal reoorcl8 proving alleged movement of eqlllpment to the buslneBB In New Yorlc nnd Bnle thereto required n,B IB name, prll10lpals and address of New York business, ' '.' 23, Denied for rensons above, plnlnllff does stnte a oaUse of aollol1, WHEREFORE, plaintiff respeolfully roquests Il1ls COllrt to deny Ihls Prellmlnnry Objeotlon to clls1l11as Amended Complaint fol' breaoh of oontrnot. ' 24, Admitted, 25, Admitted In parI, dOllied 111 par\. Altorl1eys fees can also be grnnled by order . , of cOllrl should the clroumstOllces be deemed npproprlnte, "II i ~ I. I ( \"'.':0 !i \i I I> I ( ',\,',',', ,-,'t', '( ",;~ 'V, , I.,. \'iJl ')'11 ..~." :: I\j~ ' ,) , " I: 2 ': IW:' ", .. p~\al oQtp~Elr ~(3, 1 ee~ I: " " " " " " I ~ " " l\ " " I, .. " /.i. II, f" " '" " \, ,." ,', I, 'I " " 'f, " " " " .. ;: \\ '.L " 'I "" ir' I' " ,! " ,', " ,. p ,. " " I' " " " " ;, " ., " iI\ Ii " " ,," " I' " " II 'I' \, " H "" ,', ,j' " " In I' ',' " , ' " (' , ':' \ " I I I I ,\, , Ji " I I Ii , \ J ~ ! , i' /,: I ! , , I !,-;) I;' , ';, \,1 .. 1 I , ::;'1 C.l . 'I I , '-j I ,r,-' , ) " " '. rl) ,J" .,,-., ,I r~.i 'it .,~ .. -'i! " 'l'li '" ".. " ,. " " !i ,. q fBASQIPg POR ~~IIllii. OAe!; PORARGUMm TO TI.I~ PROTHONoTARY OF O\JMI3~RI.ANP OOUNTY: . MM*M.*_.ftM......*M.**_.*_.__M.M_M___________~~!.".----M_________________~__-__-"--___-_----~--~-------__________~~-~~--~-~~--~-__ . MANSFII:~P ~QUIPM~NT SA~~S, INo" PIEllnllff OONNI~R, W~~SH 8. pup I<UNI<~~ AUTO PARTS, INO" 8. I. & M I:NGINr:S, INO" . pafendonta , , ' :,OIVIL AOTION . ~AW f') it") , " , \ CI.. " , ;. ~1 J '(I, I i 1'1 1,,,1') I! I, , ,1 ;Jij , i I , , ..., ,1,1., 1,:,: , il 7~ "1 'il.!' :' ; ,., I '" ,,(-) , , .~M :: \11 I ...h ..I ,. lj ~l :,1, ~. "') :1) ,1~'" ...;. v, ' " ,I 1. No, 90.5;150 StElte ml'ltter 10 ba arg~led (I.e, pll'llntlff's motion for new trlElI, qefenr.Jont's demurrer to oornplolnt, eta,): .....Q..efandonts' Prellmlnarv Oblections to P,lolntlff'sAmandar;j 06rntllillnl ;1, . Identify oOllnsel who will argue oose: .(a) for plolntlff: , odqress: , L1ndsElY Pore l30lrd 37 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 . (b) For defendfjnl: address: steven J,Flslll11an 17 West South Street Corllsle, PA 17013 IWIII notify all parties In writing wllhln two days that this Dose has been listed for Elrgumenl, .. . 3, " 4, Argument COlll't Delle: JanuF.lry 6, 1999 , paled: Deoembf;!tjQ....1.Q90 " 'I' , al3"p~QQ OIVI~ In 11'1113 Novl3mpl3r 1 0~71 Thf.l o(mlrf.lol Ql'IVe pll'llntlff IhE! exolwalV!3 rig 111 10 aell four pll3(:lpa of !3qulpmflnl own!3d by I<unllf.ll AUla PArt!il/n flxolll'lnOe for 1'1 oomml!il!illon" Tllfllarm/l of Ihe .oonlmol inada pll'\/ntlff an I'\Oflnt for K~tnl(81 AUla Part!il and Ihe agenoy atl'ltua Wl:\a 10 !ilurvlve tha oontl'l:\ol by 180 ql'\Ys, At the time tile pontrf.\Gt ' ,. -, ' waa anterad Into, plfllntlff believed Welsh to be tha aola ownar of 1<l.1nl~al Aula Pf.lr1a and ejld not ral'\llze'thl'\l the PLllllneaa WI'\/l InoorporElted, Pll:\lntlff ,worllel:! Ip sell the equi'pmanll:lnd found 1'1 proapeotlvf.l bUYf3r In l..BlM Maohlna, In MI:\Y of ,1 flaB, plaintiff's reprl3aantt:\\Ivas tl'l:\velacl to I<unllel Aut,o Purts with repre!ilenll'ltlvas of L.,BlM Mflohlna to ahow tham the aqulpment, The L.&M Maohlna representatlve!il understoocj tMt pll:llntlff was ~otln9'a/l An flgflnt for I<unllel Ayto ,Parts In trying to .' I. . negotiate the sal!? of the equlpmenl, The brollarage oontraot explrecj at the enl:! of May 1998, 'Plaintiff oontinuad to oontaot I.,BlM Ml:lohlna about the SElie but WElS toll;i It w!'\s no longer lnterasted beoEluse the neoeSSE\IY aqulpmeht hl'\d been purohasl3d " '" ;,,, ,-" .- (, 'from an ,aviation business In New York. Plaintiff attempted to.ranew the brokerage oontraot with Welsh but she told pll'\lntlff that she had sold' the equipment to' someone InNew YOI'll, In July of 1008, one of plaintiff's salespeople vlfllted L.&M, \ . , . Maohlneand taoll sarlal numbers from,two pleossof equipment found on slle, The ' , " serial numbers matohed the serial mJmbers of the equipment to be sold under the . I. " brokeragE! oontraot, Plaintiff asserts tllat Welsh and Kunkel Auto Parts Bold the' d' 2 II ' .. , " a~'~12RP QIVI~ , I~unl~fll AUlo ParIs In a\.lmp~rll'lnQ OO\.lnlY, venqe Is proper In O\.lmherlflnq ommly fol' Qefflndl'lnl Wfllsll, Pefendl'lnla' preliminAry opjeollon la oVal'rul!'lQ, ~JllmlnftLWftlrilLlilltMduflfu! Pef!'lnQAnls olAlm 1111'11 pll'llnliff Il~a fflll!'lQ 10 alElI", A oll'llm E\gfllnsl Wel~ll InQlvIQ\.ll'llly, PreliminAry oP)eollona, In Ille form of A cten1~lrl'er, mAY Pel aualfllneQ , only If, E\ftl3r E\QmllUno I'IS Ir\.le All W!'lll pl!'lAQeQ, rellmml fAals ~\nQ any Inferanofls ' fAirly dad\.loadlllarefrom, ilia 01 em 1111'11111131'13 Is no tlleory of lE\w 1I1E\1 oould provide relief for tllaolalmant, WIl~nla.M!idllmL.Qillilli\rQ/J.hlL~, 1549 Pa, 613, 61~, 702 A,::!d 8~iO, 853('1907), Tile omnt of a Qamurrer Is proper If Ilia olflE\r anQ free from QouPt tll(:'\1 tile moving party Ilas falleQ to s.late E\ olalm upon " ' whloll relief oan .be granled, W. AQQlllonally, It Is an axiom of oontraollaW.lllat "one oannot be liable for bre~oh of oontraol unless one Ie a party to that oonlraot," J;Jaolron I:nergy Oor~, 408 Pa, Super, 563,567, 697 A,::!d 175, 177 , " ., (1991), PIf\lntlff olalms tllat at the time th~ oonlraot was formed, II pelleved tllat . , Welstlwas the sola owner~f I<unl~el Auro PE\rls and II did nol Imow Ihallhe business wa~ Inoorporaled. ,Looldng at Ille faoe of the oonlr.aol, Ihere Is nolhlng thl:\l mal(es It 01131'11' that Welsh was 1:\0lh1g only as an agenl fdr I<unl~el Auto Parts, " , Welsh may have been aotlng In an Individual oapaolty, Plaintiff has pled faols , sufflolent to wlthsland a demurrer. Defendant's preliminary obJeotlon Is overruled. 5 " I.i , 'i 'I., W~IHh \lllIll'illllliOIIIl\llll'plll'lIIO Ih~11' f'\'HllIlll~ilH Olllllllhl\lllllll'Ill'IllIl'lIph J II hll I'll , 11'\11'1 h\11'1 11 1l1'\1 , Wol:lh i\llIll'iIlIlI"illllhl1l1lhllll(~hlhll A IH Iho AgI'OIlI1WIIIIIIIHHIIO, ' ~, Tho 1IIIolllllh1l.1H Olllllllhlll11 1Ill'lI1'II111'IIpll ~ 111'0110111011 III pl\l'l \lllIll\lhllll\~d III Pllrl, , ' , Rpo\1ll1o\llly, IIIH 11~lllolllhlll WolHh O~oolllodlho l\gI'OOIllOIlI UH 1111 1IIIIII'IIhlll1 Ill' 1I1I1I1'1Ihllllly , Ii gl'llll\oll MnllHliold nllY I'lghlH III H\.1lllho olll1lplllOIlI, olllhIJ olll1ll'III'Y, i'i 11 111101 \I lid, M1111Hlio11l olllo1'UIllllllllho AWOoIllOI1I, 'I'll \lw o~lollllhnl M111lHlio11l nllolllplH \11011111'110101'1;(0 Iho AIlIWI1Wllt, WOIHh 111111 KIlIlI,PI Hllllo IhllllllH 1111'1'111\111 1I1101111l\lIH whlll\! HIl\lllkH 1\11' IIHoll', (I, Anlll' 1'01lH111111hlo IIlVOHIlglllloll, 1\11111101111111 WOIHh 111'0 \\'IIhll\l1 HIIl'f1ololll .. 1111111'1111111011 tlll\11'11111 hollol'nH 10 Iho 11'111111111111'01'1I(11)' ol'lho III1\.1WIlI11IlH OOlllllll1od III PIlI'II!!l'Ilph 0, '1'llIIH, HII'lol Pl'lllll' Is 1101111111111'11 11111'1111, Ills IIdl11hloll'lhllII'OPI'OHOIlIIIIII'OH 11'0111 liMvl 011I110 I~. KIIIlllollo hlHpoollho o'llllpllWIlI, 7, Allol' 1'0llHOllllhlo I11VO~\h!l\lloll. KIIIlII\.11 nl111 WOIHh 1\1'0 wllholll"HIIl'f10101l1 . Illlhl'll1l1l1oll,lo 1111'11111 bollol'lIH Iii 1"0 1I'IIIh 01' vOl'llolly ol'lhu 1I11011Il\lo1lH oOlllllhwd III I'lIl'ngl'lIph 6, 'I'lllIH,'HIi'llll Pl'IlIlI'IH 110111\11111011 1I1'll'lnl. By WilY 01' 1\1I'lIwl' III1HII'OI'.IIIH 1101110\1 Ihlll MIII1HI1I)III 1I0ll)IIIIH 1I111111t Ihl' Wl)lHh IIH M1I1lHfio11l \vIIH 1I1I'lIgollt 1'01' Kllllkl)l ollly 1I1I1'11I!l tho tl)l'Ill ,01' hlH 001111'1101, " 8. .. ^"0t' I'1)1IHo1111b11) I11VOHII!lIlIlIlI1. 1\1111111)1111111 Wolsh 111'0 without Huf'f1olollt ,lnlbl'll1l1tllllllo 1111'11111 bolioI' IIH 10 tho 1I'II1h 01' 1'01'11011)' 01' Iho II110Ullll0IIH OOlltllll1011 III I'lIrll!ll'lIph'6, 'I'huH, Hll'loI pl'ool'lH 110111111111011 nl 11'1111. 9, 'I'h\l IIlIoUlltlollH oonllllllod In 1'III'IIgl'IIph \) 111'0 1111111111011 III plIl'l nll11 dOl1lod III pllI'I, IIIH IIdll1ll1odlhlll Plnlnlll'l' OOlllllotod WI:IHh nOllng oll'bohnll'ol' Kllnkol Illl'onO\V Iho Agl'ool\1onl. " 1\ IH 110111011 Ihlll WolHh WUH noting U~ nnlndlvlllllnl. ')I IH ndmllttJd Ihnt Wolsh (\11 bobulI'ol' I\.unl<ol hnll Hold Iho 1)(\Illpl11onl,Io UpH(ulo ^ vlntlon SOl'vlcOH, FIlI'IhOl'l\1ol'o. tll Iho oxlontjhnt " "," " .3. , ~HIl7Hl-IV"I""KlIlIk,1 ,', Mllnllliohll'vl'ol'H IplI Wl'lllvl1lloolll1lOlll, WulHII IIlIdl'i,!IlI,ulllllll~ 111111 II 11I1I\\'l'lllolllllwllll1olll Hl1d IlIul'ul\w IlpVIII\1l Ihl' IIHoll', 10, I\l\ul' 1'01lHo1III\110 IIlI'VHII!Jllllpl1, 1\\1111,0111I\11 WollIlI 111'0 Wllllolll Illlrnolul1l 1111111'1111111011 10 Ihl'l11 II \1ollol'lIH lP!\lu 11'\1111 01'1'01'1I011)' ol'lho 1I11~!!II\10111l ollllll1ll1ullll1 I'H1'I\m'lIpl1 6, Tl1llH, 1111'101 proM IH lIu III II 11\ lull III 11'1111, Wullll1ll11\II\III1IIUlll1uol'Il\ll'lIl~ 111011' I'UllpOI1IlU!, ul1l1ll1l1lOlllll PIII'II!ll'lIph I), II, 'I'lIu IIlIu!Jllllol1ll OOlllHll1od III PIII'IIm'/lpll 11111'0 \lol1l1lll, 1IIIllluIlloil Ihlll WollllI \\'1111 Holing 1I111111111dlvllllllll. WolHh nl\ holllll I' 01' 1\111\1\01 111111 Hohllho 01111lpll10111 10 LJpllllll\l Al'llIlIol\ ROl'l'loOll, II, III \10111011 111111 Wollll.101' 1\\lllkol Ilold Iho uq\llplllolIl 10 I.,II/.M, FlIl'lhol'1II0l'u, hl \110 0~10111,111111 MlIllllliuld l'ul'ol'lI 10 II 11'1'111011 dOUlll11ul1l, Wulllh 111111 1<Illll\OIIIIIIIu 111111 11 Illn 1I'1'1\lul1 \Ioullll1Unllllld IlIul'olhl'o IlpUnkll Oi' IIllllll', 11111 dUlllu\llhlll Wulllh 01' 1<\II1I,ul o\\'u nil)' 0011111111111101\ 10MIIIlIlIi\lld, I~, '1'110 II110gn1101l1l1'01\1n11101l11\ l'lIl'n!lI'llPI11211I'U UOlllJIIlllloll1l of'llIw III whloh 110 1'0llpOllHo III 1'\1\1111 I'ud , To Il1u uxlunl 111111 1\1I't1101' I'UllpllllllU 11l1l0ul1wlll1oUOHIlIII')', nl\\ll' l'unllol1l1hlc hwoHtI!l/llloll, 1\\ll1kulllllll WOlllhlll'u wllho\ll ll\lrnulul1111llhl'l\lllll01l 10 fbrlll II hcllcl'nH lolhc , , II'Ulh of'llIo UIlC!!1I110111l of' PIII'II11l'llpll 12, 811'191 pl'oof'11l !\cl11l1llllcd III 11'1111, WllElU!FOHI!, l\ul1kclnllll Wclllh IIclllnlld jllll!!IllCI\IIIl Ihuh' 1111'01' IIllllnllnll1lll Plnll\lIl'f': COUNT 1\ OOICN'I'ION I\.L.I N'I'ICltEllliJCN(~1UYJ1'U lIliSI N ICSS I{ ICI ,A'I'IONliJJ.J.e 13, PlIl'n!!l'lIph 13 .If1nll IIlCOI'P\ll'lItlollclnlllio to which 110 I'Cllpll1l1lC11l 1'01]\111'011, 14, Tho 1I110!Jllllol1ll 01111111111011111 l'1I1'11!!l'lIph 14111'0 oOllclulllol11l ol'llllv'lo 11'111011110 1'01l1ln111l0 III 1'0qull'od, To 1110 oXtOl1ll1l'Ollplll1HO III I'oqull'od, IIIH l\olll~l\ WolHh 01' 1<\lI\kol o()II\1d~d II'lIh Ill\YllI10 tllllVllld lI11yll\!! II Olll1l111IHHIIlI1, 01\ tho Ollllt!'III')'. KUI1IlCI ol\tol'od lllill nil III'I\lHI 'JHII7K, - \Vol.It/Kllllk,1 .4. ", ,I,' " I' " ., I il,:, 1',( :1 !(\\ II ' ,\ I " " " " ", " " ,I; I' , , " ,I \ 'I "'1 ", " ,",. .. " " ,I' !< ,. ;! " Ii .d ~, i " ", /';" "', 1\ " " " ,.., ;If i; " " " "I " " " " " " H I , .. , , " , " , , " " ('J r- "1' I' Jtu I,; I ~ l~1 I. (to' {I .. , I~ ~ '~ ( " .F: ," , 1.',_.,_ n ;;:i-h'i " .':' (', "-" ::'1 " '01. i, " I, " 'I " " , " ;; " !' I' " " ']. i' it, i' " i' " I' "'" "II " " ;' .'1 11" " " ;,!I r{1 ;, ,,' 1.1:,) q:1 '__J '" ('\) ,', ',r 'I' .' ,., !"/ i\, 'I'l' ,. ,I,: ! !/lJ i;'il ; \' ,~! :,q ~~; i, C:.. ,'" ;,,-, ;.-,,', I,,,, 'i " " '\ ,',' I; 'I .i, " " , I \1 '.'"