HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05432
"
'jl
"
,,'f
~', '
,",
~
i
"\.
--.."
~:
~i
".,-"
i!
,,'
Ii
"
I.
'"
,,'
"
"
II"~
"
"
" 'i
.,
[' "
, '"
.,'
,.
"
"
,$."
"
f"
,.
"
'L
"
"
')
.~.""\
\11,
\l
~"'lkh
,\J "lii.,
lQ 'ltJ,
..., '\
~' '\
"
"
"
"
"
"
!'
" I
"
,,:i
,.
H"
I'
q f'
It!'
,,' "
"
"
\
l
,,'
"
"
,
"
"
'i> 1
'I, ."
H ';,
I' ,., " "
!'
,.
"
,,'.1'
.1
, )
,,j
!
,/
)'
."
I'
H'
"
,.1'
"
ii
0'/"-'
_\,<'
"
"
..(_n
H
"
if
'if'
,.
H;
II'
",t.
I;
! ~
"
"
r
...
\~
''I
if
,.
I'
"
" \,
"
q'
"
'>",
.'
,.
"
-
, .
I;'
cj
Ii
I.
,;
q,
H
"
"
},
"ii"
"J;
"
i'h;
~
~
:::i~
'0
'I'
.1
"
"
\
t,'<.,;i
(:'J'
,I
~I
0::::
,.
W~~~~AM 0, PUN~, ~upervispr
Ohdrmll\n, W~!:.H~.1\l1 ~t OOO~,'
Wownahip MlI\naq~~, Ana ,
I1J\M1ilI3 li1, tlMI., Zon~ng Of1;i~lar"
~i;t.v~t' /:lprin\J 'J.'ownahipl .,
,
,
I
,
,
'1 t.1
i1PlIN li1, RNP~tH~m, anr.\
HOl\NN~ I<NPWM!l/3 r
hUQP~nt1 1I\~t1 wtf$,
+2 Whaal:~ant1 prive
Maph~nipQbUr\J, ~~ 170~8
J:1ro l'lft
J:1l1l\:l,nl:i1;t:1l
v,
6478 Oarlisla Pi~e
I<mO"^N~O/:laURa, l?/\ 17088
Pafonaantl'l
I IN Tllli1 OOUR'~1 OU' OOMMON
'!?HE~S QF oUM~mR~NP CPUNTY,
1 !?lilN~/:lYINAN~~
,
I
,
I
I
I
,
,0IVIt., J\Ctl':tON~ M1\NPlINUS
,
eN r'l-j' ") r~ \ I "'I' .'
No , _:.1.0..:_,) :) c)(, l.l Ll,'~), e ( (1)
COMPLAINT
1, !?lainU,ffs, John E, l<nowlos ana .roann~~n6\~los, ar~
individuals r~siqing at 12 ffiloatland prive, SilVer /:lpring
Wownship (Meohaniaaburg mailing addrese), Oumb~rland Oounty,
l?ennsy;t.vania,
2. Pef~ndallta are William 0, Dunn, supoL'viaor Ohairman,
Wi~lil!lm a, qoo~, Township ME\Ilagep, and. .rallies .m, HaU, ~on;l.n\J
Oft'ioQr, havill\J their offioes at th~ 8i;l, ver spring TOI~nship
Munioipal BUilding, 6478 Oarlisl~ Pi~e,
Meohanicsburg, l?ennaylvania.
PElfendElnt Dunn is Ohairman of Supervisol's anC\ is empowered
to enaat ordinanoes and direot employees of t;.he Township, .
, ,,' OefenC\ants ooolt and lIall fll:'e aharged w:\..th enforcement of the
ordinanC1es and ~egulaUons of a:l.lVer springtolmship,
3, l?laintiffs I .residenoe at 12 Wheatlanc\ DriVe is
adjacent to the property at 20 Whentland PdVe owned b~
Rob~:ru W. Buohe~ and Marybeth BUah~r, (the' lIl3uahel.'slI) as
I3holm on F.he po~tion of. the lIubdivision plan of l:he Bali Uai
Section :3 development, f\t:taohed hereto ae exhibit: ItAIt t
"
2
\:
"
4, ~"pp"~hout ,t"~ pp~~n~, pumme~ ~nq ~A+l of +997 ~nq
thl:Qugl1 +1)913 tp q~\:a, \:hf>l 'r:I\.Iqhepf.! h~ve ~HpwQq \1P~'H' ~nq
\~oOq!J pn\:hQ~p pt'opapty \:0 I1Po\~ t~o a~PQlldVEl hO~\Jht!J in
v~p+At:ion 'pf aePt:~,pn ~,of opclin~nPQ No, +7 of !'lHvol: app~n9
'rQwnf.lMp,~ PPllY Qf wM.qh h ~t:tflohac\ haPlito ~f.l a~hipi\:
, "r:I",
Pt '1'he r:I\.IqhePIl hAve :L1'lft: \ln~61l1if.ltl'lvQcI ~ne! un~inf.lPQo\:aq
" jun~ Veh~Qla!J pn thfl~.~ ppoPflPj:~ :\.n viohtion gf /:leotion
:30~, Il of the I/<on;\.n\l Ol1eUn~nPQP of.. !'lUVflP Ilpdng 'l'ownllh;\'p, a
,CloPy of .whiph ;\.11 fl.tt~phflq !lll \i1xhip;\.t '10",
11,' ,'1'he pVePI1t'pwn I1r!l!J!J, waecla, ancl othfll1 vage\;!lt;\.on pf
\:he l3uohop' II ppoperty pPaaent a f;\.l1e h~lIavc\ co the
p;La;\.nt;\.Ua' aqjapant ppopol1ty anq othar PPop61t'tiall ;\.n the
neigh\:lophooc\, It also attrM\lf.l rlOltll !lncl ot\ler.vElrmin, whioh
have oome onto plaintiff1f.l propElrj:y Ilnq ptefl.j:ecl a nU;\.Ilf),noe~
7 , '1'he j\.ml~ veh;\.plell em the l3uaher propet'ty ape
unllight:1Y, cI;\.minillh propePty VAlue/J ~n tha neigh\:loP\lOPcl, ane!
p):'obaply lJopve aa a breE\(;Ung and ne!lting p:L~oe for vOl;min,
"
8t ~+aintiffa h~vQ rOPQatec\ly a!l~ed defendantll to
enfoJlPe't;hoaboverpitac\ or.d;\.nanoea to pampva the viola\:iona
desodbed a\:love fpom tho Buoher pt'opElr;ty, . Among the
vequQlJtlJ made py PbinUff'lJ werel .
, '
(J\) I:l, f~:li: latter to the oodeEl li1nforoement Off~oer on
l<!ovempE\r 1? I lP9? I a oopy" of whioh is attaohed hapeco a/J
Iilxhipi t "P",
(e) a meating with defandant on Januaty 12, 19981
"
(0) a fax !litter to the, Townehip Solioi tor on June 1,
1990, a oop:! of wh;\.ohill I1ttaohed he!;'eto as li1xhibit "1il"I,and
(li1) appearant:ltl at a meeting of the 'rownehip SupervilJorEl
oh June 24, 1990,
9, '1'0 date, no vil!li\:lle effort on the part of. defendantEl
to enforoe their own ovdinanoea have baen obllevvedt The
vagatation r;amains unmowed Bnd the jun~ vehioles remain
unmoved,
n
III
i"
"
~
II I"
~
:1.0, I?tl\:\.n1;:\.ff!3
tr~tt:\.o prq:\.n~na~p
(Wh~lit;l.~nq Pdvl'll ,
"
(I\) Mfilt ,~:\.t:h Ph:l.~11 Wqpm~y, who hliq IlpaElq 11m:l. 1; "':\.~nll
erao1;aQ, .
h~Va/lll1o lillk.acl
lincl rOIl"bt:\.Onll
I:hflY h~val
for enfOPoamflnt 011 the
on . tha:\.r ~\:l<'ae\: .
. . ,
(~IIi'~~,,;l.e\\tet' \:0 R:\.oh~rq I'lne;Loak:ar, lilli'll flU vel, I'lpring
wownll~:\.p flo;L:\.o:\.tor. rEl\l~rq:\.n~ tr~l1f:\.o ppop;Lemll on our
IItrelil\: I (~t.\:aClheq hflre\:o ~II 1i1~~h:l.p:\. \: ~'I
(01 J.,et.\:er. ft'QmO\It' Qa\l\lhttu" II l?h~doa:l. l~hat'ap:\.ll\:,
r.eg~r.q:\.ngtha clangar Qf \:ha Ilpaecl:l.ng on our
Iltt'eet I (a\:.\:li\ohel;\ ha;t'eto all Iil)l:h:\.p:\, t GI "
(!ill APpearecl befot'e fli;Lval<' flpt':l.ng ~uparv:\.lIot"a, at
maeUng allk:acl flot' he:l.p in t'lllgarclll to the IIpeecl:\.ng on 01111
strae\:.; Inf.ormed them that:\.\: a oU1"'clQ"lIao t:lnq only 1000
feet long,
'I,
, (11'1 Me\: Wi\:11 Oh:l.ef l'l\:e:\'glil;Lman, who :\.nformecl \.10 \:.h~\:. thay
were P\.lt \IP il:l.ega;L1y ,In la!'!\: flu\=,erv.l.sot' mee\:inl;J ,
pI! l1une l\4, llllle I heinfl;lrmer;\ tha Pla:l.ntitl111 emq thfl EI;Uver
Spring SUperV.!.sorll, that the speeq limi, t!'! werl;1
"unenfo/ioeable" ,
,.
(01 I.,e\:ter to Govel'nor Rj,clge regal1c1;1.ng the enforoement of
the IIpeed limit a:\.gnl3, (attaohecl hereto as li1)th:\.b:\.\: HI
, j, "j,
(HI letter to,. Governor R:\.r;\ge regarding the nonl"enao\:ment
of \:ha proper ot'd:l.nt:lnoes in,flilver flpring To~nsh:\.p to malte
tm~ffip orclinanoel3 enforoeab;Le, "
(attaphed hereto 1'113 Iilxh:l.pit II
11, As pithens and taxpaYElt'll of t',hlil To\'/nl'lh:l.PI I;ho
p;La:l.nt:\.ffl3 haVe th~ t'igh\: to fair and :\.mpartial enforpement
of the 'l'ownllhip ordin/lnoesagainst v:\.olations, 'l'he
~nElPtivny Of thadel:'endantsdesP:l.ta repeated oomplaintll and
requests from the p:l.aintiffs h :l.n viobtion of\:heir p;Lear
duty \lndar the ordinanpes 'of the 'l'ownship, If the
ordinanc;les have no\:"blilen oort'eotly enapted or ado);lted then
.\:he J;1oarcl of aupet'visors have a f:l.duoiaty lieapc;lI1sibili ty to
thlEt plaint:l.ffll and o1.th:ens of Silver spring 'l'oNOIilhip \:0 sea
that it is done immediately,
.
"
"
" ,
L
"
"
,,'
"II
"
t, .'
"
"
,
"
"
'"
!1xhibit'A
,"
',.
'"
,.
'I
II"
" ,.
/,
"
"
"
"
H 'f
" "
.,
, '
"
'"
II
,
'" I;
~
"
ORDINANCEl NO, J.?
OHDlWI eE OF IL 'R S1.'Ht a TCWi/S 11.' cu~rnmRUlND COUW1'Y 1.'El'i'l6YINAWIIl,
'001 I'l' G 'l'IE an, (Ii' I'IilEP9 OR l'lil U'l'.l'I G 'liE 1 ',\p llI'1M'ftii IJE,...,
pr,J\RII'IG 60011. wmu:r.s NUl CEl 1\NP ' 'mr.. 'l'Olll1ATll' SIIJi'E71'Y. --.:...
~~~s lINP.Cr.HFOlU11 , lINP 1\Ul'IPm;rm 1\ l1\'l'jlJ,Um-rl1 lIND .fl~6CRIlllNO --!
, ,.. -"
l3El 1'1' lil'l/lOl'!lD I\NP OIlWllNlfD llY tho SUpeu.-v;L\lOrll of i:IVl 'l'o,~llIlh,tp
of s~;tyor Spr,tn9/ C\.1f\\b;3rlancl CO\ll1i:y, PllllntJ~lV<ln![\ I:\e follo,~tJ I .
Sli:CJl!ICl'l.1 'l'hA\: from IUlcl f\f~el1 \:l~ I?IWilC\ge o~ t:llJ.1l orcUl1anpe, ;1.\;
Ilhal;t'lXi Unl1\wfl\j, f!or any per.1l011, f!;l.Ll1\ or O::l1,WrC\\;j,oH, C\~Iu.n9 or. h/\Vj~w
A preBGl'\\; ;l.1]tl:lLlllli: ;In' any l:eAl efl\:<\te w~ thin t:lle 'l'cl,'/nehip, of ailVi3L' fJPl,j n\1,
to parmi\: Wi3i3t'\s IInc1 llimLJ.ali Yi3gei:Al:ion, no\: \:l<'U!Jle 01: pllll1teC! for eq\p
Wleful or oLllarrani:Al PUL1.Xlse, \:0, grC1i/ or raffi/.\Jn 0\) the L)L'i3mtllell CI,\'nec1
py them, Unli3B!l ~uoh ;taM j,fl ~l1ec1 ",1\9L'iollltunllll, nnc1l\ll pQQl ~\3e,11l
IUw1 vegei:Ai:;l.on are heI1Gli);f ~C11I\rec1 \;0 l:e f\ l1u;l.aanoo an,l t1ei:d~lpn\:l\l to
the health, sAf!ei:y, aJ.ellnJ,ineBB l\l1c1 9C\1\forl:. oE tho inlwbJ.tuni:s or. \:he
'l'ol'l\)!lh;Lp, " ,...
'~Effi'ION 2 'l'he aeare\:m;y or. the 1l0al.:C\ QP, SllP3liVi!lOL'tJ.;La hel:oby
!'![\\X'IIElrec1 \:0 notifY,')Jy oor\:if.tec1 ffi/.\U, any IlllCh f"lt'son, f!;LL111 <(t' .
conJOva\;ion y;l.oll\\:ingtlle I?royi!lionB or. thi13 ordl.j)lIn03( IIntl \:0 rC<lldl:o
the LllrrPVAl pf t~lfl 1l1liC\ 'nuiflf.\n03 wlth,in ,\:en (J.O) c1&Y!l frqn t~10 (lilt!'! of
al\oh no\:iC!C<\\:iCl11 .
,
SECTICl'l 3 ~'he Seore\:al)' of! \:he pC<\rC! of Ill~:o!;yiBor!l' !ll\l\ll 1:>3 nlle1
iflhflt'eby ero~lo'GlC\ tOCll\~llle 011 l.l!;in\1\1bol\t: i:he rElll'Py/ll of! an;f DI1011
nldsan03 lifter \:he violA\:t;lr fails <<0 do flO within the L:edocl of Dl1ch
. no\:,tf;l.ca\:ion, ' ,
SEP1'ICN 4 J.n \:he even\; of t:l)e L'\3I1'PVal oll \:he mdsance At; \:lle . .
dip3al:icn oJ; t.he .Ilear. e\:/U.1' I i:he fJeOLlltllLl'. is allth.od\lOc1 to. coHea\: \:hfl
coa\: of s\1oh l'~OVlIl, \:o;Jethe;r. 1~J.th f"l11111\:ies .prOy;l.c1ec1 by.1!M, by liol1
or b;f aallicn in aflslll\1?sit, or in any ot:)\el' nmnner na f1\!1;f l:e pL'ovic1etl Py
lll\~, ,,'
, .
~ECJ1'IOI'I 5 TII1;f pers~), f!,t~1l1 or cotp:>rf\i:ion YJ.ol!#.ng this ordillanOO
shall l:>e s\lb:J8cll: \:P II fins of nOt ~es!l than f.ive ($5,00) Pol1aL'fl or I\Pl:e
than 'l\\\311l:y"five (~;!5, 00) Polltu!S, ant'\ mats of L)roB6ot1l:id), lind, ~~1
c1efAUJ.\: .of payrrf3n\: of Buoh fine nnCl ooats ( to JmrdBOnlTl3l1\: fOL' not; ll'Pre
than \:en ,P,O) days; 1\ aeparAte ot!fenae./Ihall.l:e c1eGII'1Bc1 oomni\:\:etl on
eAch day c1\ldn\1 or on whioh a violatJ.ol) ooaura or COnHnl\ell,
I3lWl'IDN G ~11e Bern:etary ia tluthodllec'\ \:0 ins\:i\:ll\:e proceedings ill
. oO\.lrl:s Of eCJl1!t:y to enforce the prov~ai~1B of th!a Ol:tUnanoo,' if SLid)
IXlCClT/38 neoos ,fl,ary. .
. SoorICN 7 . 1111 ol:l;linanCXlB nntl )?al:til of! ordl.l\1I110013 in oQlf1l.ol:
hel:BwIt:h nre l't3reby rep3nJ.ec1, . ..
\
E1>lI\Cl'ED fiND ORMINIiD this l5th. d!l;f of Mwdl, 1960.
i\'ltl~,s'r,
") " /-h
'7 /-l.t~tLv v\.. , t1'""t.
SS0l:81:l\l.-y ,
/t-<:l."!. ,
I'
\ :
i
i'
I,
'i
I
I:
~
"
~,3,
,. .'
~02.4,
. ,~02,$,
~02,~,
"
~.JJ~I1m~~~, or JllO~ '~\cept ~s prQylqc~1 III Sec!lalls 4~r 1,IIHl (14S af
this OrQhl11llpe, tlle p\I\qoor MP\1IT1111llllpll of Ir1l;5h, ~ftr\Jfllle, refllSe, PI' )11\11: fOl' 1\
pcrjo(\ cxpeep\ng MCCll (15) q~~s js prohHJI\cql .' .
P.um~ ' A.lllfflSh ~hmirsters s!mll pe !oellteq WlW11n 0' S/(le or renr ~III;,I,
spreeneQ '~'om IId)olnlng rOftds Ilml propertIes, fllld complelely el1Qlpse,1 wllhln II
slglH,lIght mllSPPrr or fellceq enclos\lre \lq\.llppeQ wllh IIs\llf-lftlChtl1/J qpor or glllel
,. Don~ - The PhiCemel1l of frnmert \l!wlos\1re pompaSls liS (1IlflCOPSSOIY
resjqenllfll \1se Is permtll~d, sllP)eclto 1111 IIccesspl)' 1'5(1 SOllll\cks, Only 11'1\510
m!\lerlills from lh\l resIQen~~1 sile nlml! pe (IOposhert wllhln lhe COl11post, Ilnd 111
no case slmll mel\11 or me!\\ p~,prpdllcls,' \Je oomppsl\I(I, AU OOI11P(lsls shull \1(1
prpper!~ mml1lalned SO IlS not to Pecome n n\llslmec 10 l1cllr\ly proportlosl 1IIIlI,
. . .,
:&rkJn~ !lOd. StorlJlle .91' Unllceflsed or Uninsl~C\e<lMo.1o.r....Ynl1(mQfi . Molor
vehicles wllhout OI1ITen~' v1l\ld license rImes or OIlrI'llnl, vn\ld lnspaolion sUckers
sholl nol be pflrkeq o. r. filorlld In. \lny 1:.01111 othllr thAn In II oomplelol)' onQlosed
b\lUa~lg, '111e rllq\llrement~ of this seollonshAlI nOI \Jo AppllCl\hle 10 fllrlll
lmplemel1ls flllQ otlw fAnn ve.hlcles nOI l]omllllly used lIS 1\ n1OUI1S"(lf CllnVe)'III1CO
on pnlJllc hlghwil~s, NOlhlng Conlll(necl herein shAll bo dO(l1l1r.d 10 Hlllhorlzo thA
pnrldng or storil!lll of An~ molor Yllhlcle In ilny zono, 1\l1loss slwh motnr vehlclo Is
An IICC~ssory Use to th(\ presont \lse of the lot, NOllvlthstAndlng Ihe f01'06011% Ihls
seotlon, In Ilnd of Itself, shflUnol be (llIerpreted 10 prevenl Iheunilnclosed S\(lrll"O
of mOlor vehicles Wllho\il OIlrrel1l, YlIlld Uoellse plAtes IInd currenl, \'11 II tl Ins po 011 Oil
sUckers If stich s\Ornge Is performoclln OOIl)llllotlon'wllh Iholo!!111 oral'lllloll of II
maIoI' veblcleslllos estAbUshmon~ A motor vehlolll servlco or repulr oSlAbllshment,
or 11 JnnkYflrd, .. . .. .
SECTION 303
I.
SETBA.CK MOPIFICA,TIONS '
303.,1, FroritSetback of BIlI\dlnJls on Bullt:up Street~ . Where nl 10nsl.l\vo (2) IIdJucol1t
puUdlngs . within one hundred (100) feet of n propert~. l\1'e sel buek ulesser
(Ustnnce Ihlln requJred, the IIverage of Iho lesser dlslOl1ces beco1l1es tho raGulrod
mlohnul11 fronl selbnok for lheproperl)', HOWever, In 110 CASe shllll the, setbllck
line be loss Ihnn twenty (20) feet from An~ Abutting streot r1Uht.of-wIIY lhlel II\HI,
. 30312,Accessor:y QUppurtenanl Stnlcture~ . 1110 setbAck regullltlons do nOlupply 101
1,
Bus sha1tersl telcphono !>oothsl And cornices" MVOS, ohhllIl0}'S, slops, CAll0-
nles, Alld shnilllT eXlenslollS bUI .dQ Apply to porches IIlld plltlos whelher
covered or noli
Open fire eSellpcsl .
Minor publlo nUllt}' structures, nrtlcles of Otllrullellllltloll or decol'l\tlOll,
mntlboxeslalld,
Fences, hedges Alld retnfnhlg WAils,
2,
3.
4.
w' .----...~
m . ""I~II 3 QIMt11 rtmillnns
..._1--_- .
. (p/J,t\>,I) SlIvI/ Slllin. 'I'O'~lhl,. 71'"1"1 o/dlnln~
, I
"
'I'
"
".,
;.""
"
I
..
".
'I
;,"
, ,
..
I' I'
I'
Ii
,.
'-'II
I'
"
" .,
j,
1
!'"
,I
I'
"
"
11
,
"
,-,' .,
,t
';
"
"
,,'.
"
I;,
"
"
"
, ~
';
"
;;"
II
ie'
..l!
"
I
,',I
n,
'i'
Ii
,.
II
i:
"
I
..
"
."
,;
Ii
i'
,
.,
" ~
,
"
."
".,
,.
t'"
"
,
,/j.
h
\I
.'
'if
"
"
.'
I'
"
,.
.\"
Ii
'i,
"
'i'
"
"I.
,.
"
',',
.'
"
"i'
"
,
"
Ii , I
..
..
1,'-
"
'i.
"
,1
"
TWO OTH~RNJ;I~Ht:lOR~ ON THI~ STRF.t;T HAVF. TO~P M13 THAT nu;y ..
POMPJ.-AINF.PA~OUT 'Hila ~OT I3f.!FORJ; I J;VF.NMOVF.P IN, WHJ:N I WAS
!:1UYING THis HOMf:1 OUR RJ:AI.. TOR OHJ:CKF.P ANP FOUNP THAT THJ:
hOT atiPUl..p ~F. MOWI;P AOOORPIN~ TOTHF. PRPINANOJ:s OF THF. .
TOWNS~IIP, I HAV!: FOUR (4) OHII..PRJ:N, THF. YOUN~~sT OF WHIOH If:l
M~N'fAI..I..Y OHA~I..J:iNGF.P, I pO NOT N~F.J:> OVF.R~ROWN Wl:iF.Ps AND '
~RABl:l (WHIOH IN SOMF. QAs!:s Is OVF.R FoUR Ft;~T TAI..I.) f:\ORP!:RING
, MY PRO~13R'fY,
" '
"
WHF.NI APPROAQHI3P MRS, I3UQHf:lR A130UT H13R 1.;01' AFT!:Rwr;
MOV!:lP IN 61il: R~apONPF.p THAT IT WA~ AGRIOUI..TURF. ANP THAT
'I NOf:\OPY OOUI..P TF.l..I.H~R TO MOWHf;lR I..OT IF THF.Y PIP NOT WISH TO,
WI: HAVt:I SINOI: P.OUNPTHAT IT INPF.F.P IS RURAl" RI:SIPI:NTIAt.. ANP IS
I3Y ORPINANOI: SHOUI..P !:11.i MOWI:P, THAT IS WI:RI: THI: PR013t..I:M
!:1~GINS, .. "
I APPF.ARI:P I3F.POR~ THa ZONINGf:\OARP IN MAROH OF 199!l
RF.GARPING A BPI:OIAI.. F.XOI:PTIPN FOR MY 13U8INI:SS AND A PIOTlJR13
OF THISOVI:RGROWN 1..0T AI..ONG WITH THI3 JUNt<I:P OAR IN THa
13UOHI3R'.S MOt<YARP WAS I3NTI:R/;P INTO aVIPI:Nol:, MRS, aUOHI:R
SAIO AT THF. MaaTING THAT MY J:lNcl..osao STOMGI: OF MY I3USINI:SS
f3QUIPMI3NTWAS AN lWf,lSORF. AND RUINING THa NI3IGH130RliOOO, MY
AT'rORN13Y THaN RaaUT'r130 IN RI3GAROS TO TH13 JUNK O~R IN HJ:lR
13AoKYARP, .. "
I liAva PUT up WITHTHI3 speaOING ON THIS STR,ealUNTII.. wa PINAI..I..Y
GOT spa130 I..IMIT SIGNS INSTAI..I..130 ay oHleF TOOMIW, I MOVI:O INTO
A TOWNSHIP 10..1313 PROT130TeO I3Y THE l..AWSAND OONVENANTS Or
THAT TOWNSHIP, IF THI3 TOWNSHIP IS GOING TO OHOOSI: NOT TO
ENPoRoe TH131R l..AWs OR TO aNFOROI3 THeM ONI..Y AGAINST WHO
THEY OHOOSI:THeN THI:Y SHOUI..O 1313 PRePAREO TO Oepl:NO THeiR
" AOTIONS IN COURT,
THIS 1..01 Is A NUISANoe, IT IS OVeRGROWN AND NEI:DS TO sa TAKI3N
. OARe OF R13GUI..ARI.. Y. THE VAOANT l:.OT AOROSS THE STReeT FROM
. Me IS MOWf3D ReGULARI..V BY THe OWNERs ANP THEY HAVIUO RENT
EQUIPMeNT TO 00 IT, ANOTHI3R LOT sOU1'H OF Me ON BeARlJ ROAP
IS VAOANT AND IS Moweb RI3GUI..ARI.. y, .
"
"
"
" !'
"
;' "
"
"
"
"
',I'
..
"
.,
'lH
"
)1
Ii
"
I.
H
B~hibit F
"
"
ill
!'(,
" "
"
ill
.,
"
h
dj!
"
j."
,
" "~i.
"
,'."
'I ',~
"
/,;
I ~ i I i
, ~ ,
;l
L
"
",.
"." I'
"
"
"
,.
,
"
.t
"
"
"
"
;r
"d
,J'
,"
"
I,
"
I'
"
P I.
'i"
;1'
.,
"
"
"
I'
,I'
I.
"
I
!,."
'"
"
,.,j, '"
"
,.
I'
I'
,,"
"
Exhibit. ~,
"
"
"
"
"
'.1'
,," " "
,I! H
" 1',
un " ;1'
I',
"
"
'I,
"
"
"
I' 'I'
"
"
..
,
{'I
"
.'
within tho ~iaoration of PQfQn~Antp,
7,Plninttffpl OOmplAint qOPa not aeek to enfOrCD mare
minJ.pteriAl ~utJ.ea of ppfen~Anta,.
a, PlRintiffpl OOmplAlnt aAila to pet forth legAlly
, ., '
enforceAble ~utiea Pf Pefen~Ant 13uffiolent to WArrAnt enforoement
by All Alrldon in mam:lAmll13,
9, plAintiffp' aOmplAint aeekl3 to require PefPn~Anta to
ennot or A~opt leglplatiol1,
10, Pl.li.nt1ff:a' aomp,l~lnt fnU13 to ae1: f:or1:h a olo/'\r'-
Ppeoifio, well~qefineq An~ oomPlete legAl right to tha rellef
requepte~l ,
1.1, Pltl!ntiff.a' aompltdnt fa1113 to .aet f.ol~th A PAUae of
/,\ot16n upon whioh the relJ.ef. a6ught oan be grAnte~,
wnmnmpoRIU, pefen~Anta reapeotfUlly requeat yoUr'HonorAble
Court to ~J.amisa pIAintiffe' Complaint pureuant to PA~R,c,P,
1020(a) (4) nn~ to enter jU~gment in favor Of Pefendanta an~
againat PIAJ.ntif.fa,
LAW OttjC'JIW
BN~LI,^K~R,
I'lIl~NNUM^N
G BI'^,W
FJ\IIJUlm'I'O CONF'oRM '1'0 HUr,l~ Ol~ OOUR'I' [Pa,R.c,p. 1020Lftl (2) 1
12 I pllilnt.it:fs' complldnt aeeke t1~nmageatl but fails to liver
the bnais thereof,
),3, Pa,R,C,p, 1019(f) requlrea J.tema of: speo,j,al ~ami:\gea to
be speoifioallY atate~,
W"m~rnFOHrn/ Def.endonte roepaotfully requeet your Honorable
'i'
Court to dismJ.as PlAintiffs/ ComplaJ.nt purauant to PA,RiC,P,
1020(11) (2) And to enter jUdgment J.n favor of Defen~anta an~
against PlaJ.ntJ.ffs,
"3-
I, '
I
" ,.
,
'."
~, Pl<\.tntH'f' Il cto 'hiav~ th~ r.tght l:p Il\.\~, . 'l1h~y h<\vl'l
~~Elrphect evet'y mllEln!l ~VEl.ul'lplfi to ~hem fro", thEl 'l1~wn!lh.tp,
'~'hlll ItI1Pjeqt prpPIll-'ty .tIJ oWnlJq py thll1i1;X:-!:lllpervillor of I:lHVel1.
/:lpt',.tngll 'l1Qwnah~p liInq ct.uiglilnoe in' hlilvj.nq I:h.t!l ~ttej:"
rfillilplvect hl\1l npw pe~n OnE! yelilr qr. try:lnl1 pn \:he P<\t't pf thlil
l?J.E1intH'f' fl,
,.
Wllerlilfore I 1?11il,tnt.tffIJ rel3plllotf\.\Uy t'eq\.\el3 tyollr HPOPrlilp:\,Q
OOlll,"t to Eln~Elr iii peremptory ;l1lc\IJment in flilvpr pf;' thQ
I.'ll<\.tnl:if;'f/i!' p\.\r!'lIlFlnt t9 1?E1 ,,~, 0, P 10~H~,
4, , P;\,~intif,fll' rell.tct~.j.n a\.\mPlllr)./in~ OO\mty I l?Elnn/:1ylvliln,t<\
I'Inct are Oi\:i!l:ElOB of the oOllnty, ~'leintif1.'Iil" hlilve the"right
I:p lleEllt .1:'elief in ,.oommon OOllrt of P;t.eC\IJ, J;lefenctentIJ hl'lvQ
'\'n!l~1f;'f,toient).y c\emonat:.rl'lteq the Oo~wt' I'l bolt of ;lllrhctipj:ipn
in tlhia mli\ttler I 'I.'hh q~n on).y pe li\aol'lrtlilineq by A ful.l..
viewhlIJ of the feot/.! in theOli\lle,.
a, 1.'l1l!linUffll' hava af.ll\:ed' the c\efanc\entB to perform, the
miniateriCll ctUtj.(;\!'l that they a;t;'e employed to do, The
Ilnfo;t;'oemE!nt of' the ordinenoelJ of the 'l'pwnl'lhip i/:1 one Of
\:hoBec\utilllll, There h no ment;l.pn of d.hor~t;\.qnf.\ry j\lc\gment
in thQ. enforoing of the Ol;'c\inanaaB thet the !i'laintiff;'f.1 whioh
to haVE! anforoec\, ,'l'hh orc\inlilnoa hlilli baen "liIdminil'ltar.ec\ py
the PefElndanta on tha othQI," Clc\jeoent aide to the aubjeot
propet'ty, Thill a.uVer apring aHi$l:en (Lot loaated on l'lo\.\th
aide of Buohar , B ,pt'operty) hlild enfot'!:1emEln t ProoedurGI3
enlilPted a~liIin~t them by the tONnah:l.p fortne identiolill
reaaonll that the l?bintJi~j;'Il' arEl a~~inq,
IS, Pldntiffl3' 'al3 o~t:i2:an~ and' tallPlilYers living in
S~lVel;' Spring Towlll3hip have the legal right to e:ll:peqt the
ordin!\noes of the 'l'oNnahip to ba enforaed whet) it 'interferes
with the rightl3 of anothElr oi't:hl!ln to anjoy their home in
pEllilOe and without oonoern for fira 0;1:' rodent infestation,
7. Pllilinl:iff,s' liIa~ for rel~ef from .the oourt,
Wllet'efore, P],li\intiffa rellpeotf.uUy request your Honorable
Court to ent€lr f.\ pat'el11ptory judgment in f.avor of tha
Plaintiffs' pl.\rsuant to Pa. R. C I P 3,0:20.
loll"" ol'f'IC'lttU
BNUI,llA~"il,
. OI1MINI'MAN
II SrAII"
.,
the mf\tt13l'fJ fJCl\lght to P13 pnf~l~oerl lm~ppenqpnt pf the lntpvef:lt..
h(3)c1 pY\:hp pullHo 1'\1: 1/H'9PI 1'11'\1nHffl'l' In\:el~Pl'lt: .t.f.I rlpr!.V13q
/lP)P).y <1l3 mpmppra pf. thp rJal1l31~Ql p\\I)).l.~l,
;!, 1'1<11,ntl.f.ffJ l<HJ~ o.Ip<1oHy t:o /lll(l,
""PAPPORI, PefandQn\:/l l'el'lpaotfUllY r~q\1'l3t ypur HPnovQPl13
OOUl't to qi/lmll313 1'11'\1ntifffJ' .~menc1e~ I'l(lfidlng - aampll'\lnt
P\Wf:l~Ian\: to PII,R,a,p, l(l~a(l'\) (Ii! <1nd to entav j\\dgment 1.n f.AVPI'
of pafendQntfJ And agQinl3\: I'll'\intiff/l,
OO\1\~'l"1'I Ll\al~ OF ,JlllUapIO'\'T.ON avaH aUl3i1"ma'l' Ml\'l"l'\!lR
r 1'1'1. fl. C &....-lQA!L(.n) (1.\1
3. Pla.t.llt1ffl'll lIm13nded Plalldl.ng' - oornpllllnt fl'\HfJ to !let
forth an intev13fJt held Py Pll'\lntifffJ whioh 'islndep~nqent elf thll
intel-"el'lt helc\ Py thp geneval pupLto af3 raquil'ec1 Py '11'\1'1 to
,
mlllnta.t.n An Aotion in mAndArnUfJ ~o enforoe 1'\ pupliaquty,
4, Plalntiff~1 1\mariqed PlaAc11ng - oomplAint fAils to set
fOl:'th J;lupj eOt mAtter oVer whioh the aout't hUfJ jl\l~ isdJ.otion,
"HERIFOR\!l"Pefenc1An~~ respeotfUlly req~el3t your Honorable
Court to c1ifJmisfJ Plaintiffi'l' l\m~nded Pl~ading - pomplAint
flUrJ;lUant to Pa, R, c, p, 1.028 (a) (1.) und to enter juclgment in favor,
of pefenc1ante and against PlaintiffJ;l,
!.IG1\T" INaUl~FIOIENC'{ OF .1\MIDNOIP PL\!l1\IHNG - cOMpr"l\,r.N'l'. (OEMURRER)
". U:IWl.&t.E . 1. 0 2 0 LllLWJ '
l3, l'laJntiffll' l\menc1ec1' Pleading - Coml~ll\int fI'\U,f'l to set
fo~th A oause of I'\otion Whioh entitlea pluintiffB to enforoe 1'\
,.
puplio duty by failing \:0 Bet forth I\1l interest held by them
whioh is .tnc1ellendent of \:he intorest held by the generl'\l pUblio,
-2-
I.I\W OI'f'lcIW
8Nl!I.IIM(IHI.
IlnI<NNI<MMJ
II B~^,II'
,
.~, Pl~intlffp' Ampn~p~ Plpn~ina - pomplAint ~paka to
pnfpl:oP cM:lall I'Iplply wl\:h.1.n \;ha rHi:lprptipn of DPf:'l'wlnntp,
d'
'7', 1').11 inl:jf. ffl' .AmolHlorl P1PAr:\ing - opmpl~lnt cloo~ not api'll<
to anforoa ma!."o mlntfltorlnl d4tiol'l of IJpfandnnta,
U, Pln,i.nt1fffl'flmanrla~ NaAIUna - oomplAint fA.1l~" j:p !3at
fOl."th legnl:l.Y'l3nfprO\1<lll,la d\.lt!a!3 pf. ppfon~l'Int 1'111 f? f. io1.pnt: to
Wl1rrl'lnt enfol."opmant ~y An Aotion in mnnr:\nm4!3,
9, Pln,1.n\:,lffl'l' Monclp~ Plandtna " oompl~int: fan", tp ~at '
forth 11 lagnlly oognl~n~la I'Ind !3Ufflolant bl'li:lia for. the antry of
tha nppremptory jU~gmantn l."equal'ltod therpln,
10, Pll'lintiffl'l' Amenda~ Plpn~lng -OpmplAint fA{lp to set
forth q OleAr, i:lpeolflo, WPll-~aflne~ nnd oomplete :l.agnl right ~o
the l."pliaf raqUOl3ted,
11 i' Pla.i:nt1ffl'l' Amende~ PlaAr:\.Lng - Oompln.i.nt ff\Us to Set
forth f\ OaU!3a of. aotion upon wh.1.oh \:ha raUaf pought onn be
grl'\ntac1,
I IHJrnRIilFoRln, \)afenc1nntl'l rel'lpsotf411y raql1'e!3t your 1I0nol:'nilla .
OOl1rt to c11amlsa Plaintlffs' Amenc1ac1 Plending, " complalnt
"
pllr!3llnnt to Pf\,R,O,P,102U(a) (4)l'Inc1 to enter jUc1gment in fnvor
of Defenr:\ants and agaih!3t Plaintiffs,
E]lII"1lIU11 '1'0 OONI'OHM '1'0 HULm OF COUI~r i'1I. R. a. P. ~,020 (a) (aL),
12, Plnintiffs' Amende~ Plapding - Oomplllint faill'l to
oontnin a notioe to dafand in aooorc1anae Wi~h the requirementl'l of
Pa.R,c,p. 101U,1,
1~, Pln.i.nt:.l.ffa' lImencler:\ Pleading - compla.l.llt faHa to se\:
forth material fllote as rBCJUi~ad p~rBuant to PI1,H,C.P\, 1019(a).
-3-
1'"
, ,
"
~4, rlnintirf~' Amended PleAding ~opmrlnlnt fAil~ to
oontAin n verifioAtion AI3 required ~ursuAnt to PA,R,o,P~ 1024.
15, PlAintiffs' Amended PleAding ~ Oomp).Alnt fAila to ~ot
forth Any legAllY opgnl~Ahle olAlm for rolief AS roquired
purauqotj:o PA,R,O,P, 1021,
, ., I
".
W"RAR,aAR, DefendAnta respectfullY request YOur MOnOrAble
COUl~t to 'lll3misl3 P1Ain\:.if~fo' lImsnctljld pleActlng - c~mplA,tnt
pUrsUAnt ~o po,R,a,p, 1020(0) (3) and to enter judgment in fAYor
of DefendAnts anct Against P).A.intlff!'l,
' ,
INSUl~I~IOIHN'l' 8PEOIl~IOI'1'Y LE.n....R.JhP. 1.021l (I.ll..(~.Ll
16, Plaintiffs' Amended Pleqcting ~ oomplaint seeks "a
pel'emptol'Y jUclgment" put fA11a to aYer the baa,j.s thereOf,
"
,;
17, Pq,R,C,P, l019(a) re'.lu.irea <\U l11<\ted.al faota to po !'let
for\~h in A oomplaint. ..
W"HAmFORR, Pefend<\nta respeotfully reguest your Honorable
Court to ctiamiss P1A.intiffo'. Amenctsd PlsAd.ing aOmplAint
pursuant to Pa,rt,o,p, 1020(A) (3) And to enier judgment in fayor
of Defendants Anct <\gA.inst Pla.intiffa,
l.flW (I1'Ii/Olln
BNlit.UAKlm.
IlnuNN"MAN
II f.l~All"
N~^N & SPARE, p,a,
I3Y_{~ R O'la~'(:~I~er
. 41\ Nest Ma.i.n Street'
Meoh<\niosPllrg, Pl\ 17055':"O3l0.'
(717) 697;"0520
Attorneys for Oefendanta
-1\-
"
UIIElll I"Po 'r: IiI':TIII/N
1n-;lilJi.^1l
O^S~ NOI IY98'~H~32 P
Ci:JI'j "1C1N WI':AI.:'/,I I rIP' PIUNNIWI,VI\Nl ^ 1
en tTY DP tMU~RL^Nn ".
IIHL1\'1Jd':rL;lPp tLJ~,!';L^ 1:...
VI3,
"-LflU"
l!lttlN...\t ni, 1./\ 1'1..'2.1;;,'1'. ,{\Ie
..H.lJ111lllUL.IHJ1'I.E:.l,!,..........,.,:... ...........,__....."..,..............,' U/iu,':lJf hr PI/put)' fHn;>'rl fr pt'
CIlJI'1I1r~RI,^Nn COlilll,y, Pr.'lllllily,l,vpn:lfl, I/ho Ill.' 1110 dlrl)' HI/nlll .l\(1l:1nrr.l:I.II(J
1.0 .1<11/, EIlIY'3, 1,1\11 IdLllIl1 NJ:!.'!:!.GI:;AN.tl..!,:mlPJALl!:i:........__..........:...__............ I/OP 13(H'YI~rJ
111'11n ..CClqILI'/JliliJ..II.U...iL.......__.._.......,..........._... ..............__. '.........'.._......._'...."...._........ 1.11.,.
U8:fu1ndonl., IlL ,--.~..LI?l.L~1.\'1 1I0UIlf:1, nn 1.111'.' ;'~;?m!. <In)' of [.!\!I!.t!].m!?Jn....._.:._........,......~_m'
"
l,ll'!/l 11 \, ....S;!,I.LYl~lL.f:WJJ1...:rn\tlWil.L...!J.UrLJ.1JJilL..I;!'!'!Ll.(;^ IUdJ~I"E~,.I".J.!t!L.........._........_....m.._
lilcr; ILltt:U..08.1H1.1lQ,...J'.L.1:Z!{1.1i!L..,........_ ............................... ..~........ ..................._.... Ul!nnlmLlI.HJ:!__.._.._,
001111 t Y I rOll !W)' 1 VIlli ,i fi I h y 11/1 II d :I no 1.0 W,,li!Ll.ll!:L:[:....G~\D1\...;.._..'7.............._._..._...._.....__...__
(1 .tnl"; finO at bnlt.C>d ClfJ I'l' 1;',1: t liD ,JJJ!T.IQK..!\NlJ..J1J:mCL^J.HT.........."......_........_::___,_H.._......,
IHld nt. 1.1\l~ IHlllln' 1::1.11I" ill "FJIJttn\l ILlr), lIt.l'.I;>nt',:l.nn t.D 1.111:' nDntr>nt:13 t!rPI'r,>of,
"
~hel'i:f:f'n Contnl
Jf1(Jlwl,tnu ,,"
"~lGI"yiol\'
~f(",dav:lt: '
, 31.1 l"l~h'lr{J[? '
[,:g~ Hn,,':>JI/~<, ~.~ . "
, (Wi "..C:I--....._....-l"l.I..._.'..~I...-,...:'.".r---..._..._....._..,-".....;,.,
6, (11(11 II. I I0l1Hlf3 "",Ill" ... '''1.1,'..1 .
H2.;(/)~...'111'^G'I. /'I^'~I(I.;TI'Nni TNG, ~
(/I:I/:,:J/I.')'I/\ 0-
' hy Ar /Y-(i.
, (.,t./J A
' ...-....- -,.... '-rffiFiil:)"",li'i?r.iTr"---"'''
"
81/1:11'/1 an,l m\lhl'ml'th'n~t;r, Iw:fn"'l' IIIP
tlltl3 .....;:nlil~l: d;;l)' oJ --'....~f.Ji.J!:'~~':l.,':m_...._..
, I u_._fr..._ At [:It
<... '1 {7 'I ' .-.,
_.._....-~:";1'~/~.... ,lL1.'}lrl.((...... '~(1-'" m.... ~... "_'
,. ," rjt.) ,hono1~nl.:.r~.
.:1 ;
,',
"
,.
W11j)rj)fQ~Iil, \?)./lj,ntHfA ~j)!lpePtf\.'ll.).~ ~lilq\,1{illlt ~oU;' !ipnpJ:'apllil
O~:nll-'I: toiQI3\'\j) II heedml qat!) pj)fot'1il him in pr.q.lilr to Q~VIil
Naj.ot;\.t'f'lI ,tlllil OpPQr.t\\ni t~ t~p lIelillt j,ml11BQia tp rflmpqy,
"
1~ WllBatlanqprivlil
MCi!ohllOiOl3burg, VA. 17066
(7,;1.7) 79,\H'i4ra4
"
" II
'!
"
"
"
"
,',
"I' ,;
'ji
"
"
'i,' ;.,.
I' "
"
;'"
" ,,"
I,
I' ,
I'
"
'./
;,"
"
"
"
"
~. ~. ~.,
I,"
.' ~:, 0
~,8 0 , ~
',:.' , :.1.'/1
Ii;',. ;~ ).'
" ~.I, '<'i)
/-'.j
l't
[ " ", c It.l
.J/(, ,\!
~~ . , ;,
)('1
J ' C, ld.
~1
i\ \'\ ,.,)
(/, t)
"
,.
"
"
'II' "
"
'i.
"
j,
"
I!'
i '
"
, .
"
"
,.
I;
ilj
"
"
"
i',
"
"
\1"
.I~
,.
'I.
;,
"Ii
"
i,
H
"
,,-;
',I
h
,~
~
I'
, .
q
t,.
"
, '
"
"
'I ;'
"
"11
,.
I,
,.
II
'.,
~.
, "
"
"
it
!!
',.
"
ii"~
"'
,.
"
!1,'
;.
'!'
, .
It
I'"
I,
';"
ii
',I
, '
, '
I"
"
"
"
",.
i,
,.
"
j,
"
,.
\\
".
,.
.1'.' ,
( , \",1
.. "
,; ~ "
" )
"
. '. " ..1 "
, If "
('. , I~ ,) "
(
,
, , . (I.
,.
,. ::1 ,
( .. ,':,
,.
I,
I,
"
iI
"
"
"
,.
l'
"
"
,
"
"
"
!! I'
l'
1\
(,
"
"
I
,
"
fl.
"
"
,.
Ii
',;
,:
H
"
d'
'..
"
,
"
"
d.
,.
Ii,
\:
'L
'"
I.
I',.
"
.
.'
"
I.
;'
"
"
I ~
"
iI
'! Ii
:'
Ii
;;
I.
"
"
!'
,.
!!
"
"
"~I
\"
;I!.
,.
"
"
Ii
\;
"
H
''"
"
"
'I
"
;I.
,.
"
I'.'
"
"",-.. lr) ,. ;;
t.;_~ C: it H
"l ,of;, .
/... It ,:,:1 II
L.U~ " h... <.-I,,:~. I'
,'/., ..... '( ;.
Ii " ~) :,- ,.
';':;;' ',JLi~
C-'I ;")i~:i if
,7 ; I' I
h'lii ." '-'i((i n
' . f'.J " .'
(,L,I" ,r,"j 't';;"jJ I' ,
i (1 "~) " q
/, ~.: . " Ill. it !i
'"'- ~J." '" ,I. ,. ,. ,
(:') ;~l
C' .,) H
(.~') (~
ii,
1'"'
"
"
#
'.,
"
II
.1 ~
("';"
i
U!
.,',.'
, '
" '
"i
"II
, , "
I; .. '''1
.':\,
(:
') .'~
,);"'I,I!
)"
:;ll
;\~l ;::,
;',\,1,1
1 : ~~'
('iffl
!,lCI'i
'~J
(J
'.'W
"
;::;l
l'1f
.I
It
,.
"
,
..
"
"
"I'
"
II
"
'I;
I,
"
;:
H
'j
I
"
"
,
"
"1'
1\
l'
"
,
"
'",
;,
!';j
"
I"
"
ji
\I.
"
,.
"
"j.
I'
,_I,
11 'j
Ii"
,.
,I
"
"
"
"
u
"
'I'
"if
"
i'
,
:,'p
"
,.
1\,.
II'
"
I,
"~I'
"
",-,.
..
"