Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05485 ~ ~ ,_." ...... . - .') .. ~ '0 ~ ~ ~I ~.J ~ 'I' H " ;l' ;( ,. ;, .1 <;, d " ( -, (' I, .~". -,:'.. '- RP, ~fi~1< H, ~UY"~l\L, "1IImi~f! Xdfinl<i~ip~l<ipl\ "PI ~aQt4 J:n~K1Ui ji;. f1t~.vM~, V,P, ~Q "1\1'41<' 1l~l<h;\1 ~i~~ ' ~~~~~L p~nn~Y,tYPl\i~ t91lQ~ (~;l.1l1 1l4Q~RIlIHI . .. ~I<I<R~'WY ~Rf ~ll\:l.l\M~~1l 'flIt~ tl:! Ml' ~t'.l.'1U'\.WtP" )u\''.l.''l'"" , Mlm/=lI3JoJElf.V PV p~M~aR~ ~~~X"~ ~f1 R~QT.mI:!TIUl I ~________~.l.l._.___ , I' I I , I I , " , I . I OPIDl'.l.' PI' ogKHO" P~l$f.I .. Ol.lJom"RMml OPUIf,l.'Y iTBlUty ~;l:~l~"RW I-ln4 ' ~~ ~Il!lm"W "II WQl\y.01J;Qh ~QP~~,P~ t7~~a o IVtfl 1\O'J1IPN .Y, "0 I q~'. 1,.'1 ,I' \' (.'~~,,:(' '~r.;.,,-, PPRUel3 cn~O~"W, 1:"0. .~""Q npJ;~~d~l~ pJ;'ivp Camp n~.tl, P~ t7Q;I.;I."7~30 Hll1'lQR '1'0 PIUU!lill YP\\ 1'~YB \Jlllln P1\Il!\ tn co, \\~~, :t~, Y01\ whh ~o !\B,f"l)<\ ~lIpinll~ Che ohimp !le~ ~Q~~ I ~ ~I\ll fqUow nil !lBlleQ!. YOII m\lQ~ C~k" no~ion wt~l1in ~wencY I~o) <\~YQ . dUIII: c I:l.P 00111 hin~ ~nil 110~ oe al:e aGt'Va<\ . hy onCllr n ~ wrHcon a12po~ranOIl p. rpon, a 1'1 01: C." a\\C'ol:ney. anti filinll" ill WI: hill, II wi~h cR,'o oO\lI:~ '10\.\ ",llfanaop or 0!>1110\:ionB ~o \: Ie oll\:l.mn QOC fqr\:h lIillinG\: 'lOll, 1/01\ al:e w,,~nll<\ \:h,,\:';lf '10\1 fall t:o !lo 110 t: III oallll mll'l 1:00 1111 !I W \:holl\: Oil Il d ~ :l\Idll111ent: m y bll IInt:II~ed ~9, lI:1.np\:'.'101\ 11", t:hlloolll:C wibhollC fl\~ 'hor notioll 201: "n'l money o~llim, lid in \:1,111 oOl1lplaint: QI: for any o~hpl: 0, 111:1.m 0,1: rll;1.ief 1'e'1l1ll1lt:e, d by t:hll 1'1~:l.n\:iff, YOII m~y ;LollII monllY 01: p!:ope~\lY pr ot:hll~ righCII il~!lor\lllnt: ~P Y01\, . yOU pUOULIl '1'MIl ',\'IlIIl 1Il1PIlR '.\'0 YOIlR MlfYllR ~'.\' ONOIl, XII YOU nO NOT JIl\"u ~ '."lfYBR OR ~IfflOT AlIIi'ORO Oml, GO '1'0 OR '1'Rl,IlPIIONR '1'1," Oll'Ii':tOIl IlIlT li'ORTlI 111lJ,0'lf '1'0 li'JlI!l \"111'1' "'IBRIl YOU l>>IN OIl'1' ',\laM, 111lr.t.', ulJ)ll1llRLlUIO ooulf1'Y II~" MIlOO:tM'ION ~WYRR RIlli'IIRRlIJ, ~ND INli'ORMAT:tON IlIlRVtOB a r,II1IlR'l'Y ~VJIffiIR OJ\R.,IP"U, P~ . 1~013 Wllr,IlPl\omll 717-aU-ll37:\. ,.1, roallP. "8 hem d811180<\I\<\P 1\ uececl IIn h oorCo. ai l;IIClld qllhra d"eendlllJllII d" IIBC~'; de BB\:all deJnan!lllP e!lPlloaCp8 an llla PP9inlla aillnhn\l811, 118C8, d Chn8 18,inco (ao) . dilla d8 ph.o al pal:\li~ d8 ill f.llo11a d8 1.8 t\em8ndl\ y ill nut:ifio/lo on. Uaoe fal\:a,' I\pencar unl\ cUl1lpa~lInoil\ opo~i\la 0 8n pe,rpon/\ 0 Con Un, 8110lladc Y IInCrll,9al: ~ ~a COI:CII en forl1l~ 8pcriCa,BuP dllfllnPaB 0 PUB o~jlloionllll II 11111 d8mandap en oonCra cle IIU pnBona. alia aviudp ,qulI pi IIPCed nO pe '\IIf.hndlll 1" corc".. comal:a mll<\.i<\ap Y puede ooncinuar la d"mand~ IIn canCra ,allya Gin pl:"vio avipo 0 noCiUoaoion. Adllmall, 1e cprCII p\llld8 dlloidir II favP~ dill <\emllMallC8 'I rIIquian qUII UG\:lId oumpla cun COc\M laG provh;l.onllG <\e 8P\la'demanda, . UpCed pued8 pordel: dinllro 0 Plla p~opiodlld8P u ofl\lrOp'.d"reohoa ~mporCanC80, pal:ll 118Clld, ,. " ....*"IC ICIlTA nlllltlllll~ A UI( 1I1l0GAOO INMKUI~'1'AliRl\TIl, III 110 TI~ 1\1l0GADO Q III NO TIBHlI aJ, bImlRO IlUJ'IOIlIllTH PR PIIGAR '1'AI. IlUIWIOIO., VAYA BN IIIlRBONA 0 r.J>A1Ill 1>OR TB"IIli'ONO ~"A OtIOINA ~A VIRBUCIUN IlK.BN~ KIlCRIT~Anllao lIAnA ~VBRlauAn nOlllla Illl lIUKOR OOIlIlBUIIIR 1I":tn'1'~OIII ..ICGAJ,. aSRVICIo OK RRli'BR""OI~ LBGAU OUMnHR~ OOUNTY bAR AOPOOIIITXON ,. a J,lbBR~ ~VBNUIC OARJ,IIl"B, P~ 1~013 '1'K..nroIlOI 7;l'1-U9.31fifi 'Ii Jl,ptl..r.\: H, IlUv..~n" ~"m.hl1 ~~tn\:1~iqR~ipn "PI ~~p~~ K~~~ ~ Il+~~~", v,O, ~Q ~~~\: ~"\:~~r. Vi~Q ~'mh1l1J', VlJnn"y~vllnit.\ ~!lOQra (;U~) ~.Q"QIlQIl' ~\:\:p~nIJY fpf. V~~in\:iff" 'ffl+1l ;1:11 .l\.W AA~+'fM".\.':m" ~'l".V~\l, MIl~llfU.RWl' . PJI' PMlI\.~Ilf.l n~+w~ ~Il R~Qlmll'l.'~P , ~RRJ ~+~n~~~ IJnq ~'lOOfJIA ~+MmR'.\.' .0 1J.1pn:y oir.Q;L11 ' ~nillll,. \?.l\. ;\''10~& , , , , , I , , I , , (11'- ,/)",'{" II I'" "0, I 'L"U'(.( Qo~1J.1 OD' (:10,,",,0" V~llM o~"U~ln~m> QOlfflTY QIVU 1\.0':1.':(0" v, .r;:Cf--- lJ'ORftllll oU~O~ll1J.1, +"0, 3.00 na~\:~~a;LG U~ivG Q~P ni;Ll, VA 1'101~,,7ra3Q. aOM1.lJ.AIN'j1 :1. " Pla;l.ritillfl3,,, Jerl:'Y Qilbtll:'t ancl ~ynnea G:I,1pert, Are /.\U"1\: ;lnclivicl\\!lo;L oillillleml an~ ;Legal reBiclllllPP of phe Oq1l\monwellltlh of Vlllln13ylVIl:o.ia, t'e/3idil1g at 40 'l'ol'1Y airo;Le, IIll101a, Plllln/3ylvanb ;1.'10:;15, " :;I, . Defendant, Forpe/3 OhevrOlet, i/3 a b\\/3ine/313 aorporation qua;Lilliecl to do b,\\/31ne/3/3 and regUlarJ.y oonr.luo\l13 bUl3l,ne/3/3 in the dom1l\onwealth of Penl1~YlvaniA, ancl il3 a aOl:'porlltion.of the aomlllonwea;Lt::h of Penn/3ylvania, with itl3:lega:l re/3idenae Ancl pdna;lpa;L plaae of p\\/3ineea looated at 3400 llarclIldale prive, OIlIllP H;\.ll, V~nn/3ylilrallia 17 all" 7:a 3 0, and oan be l3ervec\ at '/3al,C\ addroe/3, 3. At:: all ti1l\B/3 re~,f!Vant hereto I Defendant aated and or" ,~ailed \ll;l aot by and t::hraugh ;lUll' authorbed agentl3, /3ervanlll3, IUlc\ amplayeall, all of who1l\ where aOlling withill the /loope of Ilhe;\.r author;\.t::y and emploY1l\ent. l!AQKGROUNIl 4, On pr a~p\.l~ May ~~, ~99al rlain~i'fR wan~ ~p Pa~an~an~l~ 4aalarRh~p an4 nr~oif~RAlly nagotiAt~4 th~ pr~oe p~ a new l~~a ohevrolet polO pio~\.Ip, 5, !?l\\intiffP ~i~ewiRa, f,l,agotiata~ t:ha Ilarly lllaf.1a terminaUon ~n4 ~\.Irn in ot! ~tutir 1996 Honqa Moorq, Vahinle ~4ant:Uioa\:ipn N"~lIr :\.liGOP65~6f.1A16679a , ~ tr\.la AmI" corrac\:, copy p~ ~he Immra!loe VerUicRtion/Pllyof.f In:formllt:~on I'Ihlle\: ill at:~apnaq here~QI maQIil ~ par~oereof IInq mar~aq lll~hipi\: 'WI, 6, In aqqition thereto, Plaint:iff~ Ilpac;\.fical1y na~ot:~ateq w~tn Pefenqant: that: ~674t76 of the General Motorl'l Oal'lh aaok inoent;lVI:l bIOI uPI3Q ~o Ji!ay oft! .lWIer:l.olHl !lonqa li':\'nanpl:l' ./I. t:rl.\E1 anq " ppr~ect cPpy of t:oa e~eO"teq I'It:atemant: ;l~ a~tachaq hereto, made a part hereof anq marked ~xh~bit "a", 7, On or abo\.lt: May :\.3, 199a, Vlaint:iffp tUrneq over l?oRfJe~fJiop. o~ the Ilub~eot 1995 ltom1a Mcord to Detlenqant to ~e rallUrned ,to Art1erican Honqa Finance in oonneot~';ln with the ,ea:t;'ly ;Leal'le termination all apeqifica11y negOI:;I.ateq for in t:he eale t:t;'anaaction, 8, 11.1"'0 on o:t;' 'abou~ t:hatf'lame date, Defendanll oont:aoted 'l'la;lnt:if~1l Inll\.l:t;'ance Agent ap.d ip.atruoted him to remove the :\.995 Ho~da ./1.0 c o:t;'d from Plaintiffa' 1Iutomopile pOlioy and add the new 1998 Ohevrolet: SolO pioltup, ~Ullll purchand from pefep.dant:. W Jilxhihit "1\.". I, 9. On or aboUt May 14, 199a, Defendant pdd the balanca qUe Amer:l.,t;lan Uonda Finance for Ilhe early haae termination. 11 true and'dorrect: copy of the check an~ check ahUb are att:a~hed hB1'eto/ . made' a part hereof and marltad lillthibit nOli. " ill " ~p, Po or ~~A"~ MAY ~6f 199~f P~A~n~~ffRWft~Q RQ~tQP~Q~~Y ~h~ ~PWa' ~llQn P01~PQ PapAr~~Qnt An~ ~nforme~ pf ~hp ~haf~ o~ ~hQ 1996 Uon4A hpoor~ ~rom ~ha lot of Pefan~pn~'~ pa"lar~hip An~ Warp inR~rllota~ ~o ~apor~ ~ha thpf~ ~p thQ~r lnRlIr.np. oarr~pr, ~ ~rH~ pn~porrpOt OOPY of the ~owpr Allan Polioa PQPArtm~n~ ~npi~an~ Raport And ~UPPlampntp~/OontinuAt~an Aro at~po4ad nllr.I'l\:Pr mA~Q A PArt 11EIrepf and mprl~ad Dl~hipH "P" t 11, p:\.dn\:iUfl im11\e4h~ely l:herIH~ftpr POn\:AO~p~ pafendant \:o.in~uira afl \:0 ~hp fl~atuR of the 1996 ~on~a hooor~ ~e~ng ra~\.IrnQ~ ~o ,""edOlln lfon41l !!'in/lApe lInqer ~he eA~ly ~erl\1~nA ~ion of, \:he laaRIl an4 were al; ~ha~ tima inforl11lld Py DIlIl,en4ant ~ha~ ~he v~hiole had in~ead bllen fltollln frgm Defendpnt'R lb~ prior ~o Peflln4an~ ro~Wt'ni\'m the vehiplo to tho, Itea/Jing Oompany. ClOlffl'l' I ~RNNaYLVANIA UNlI'AIR '1'~J;Ol!lS AND,OOtmmmlLIWO'1'RC'l':tON ItAl'f l~t PlaintUffil hereby inoorporaue a:\.lllaot/J anq allElgation/J I. " pet fprt:h in ~hi!'l Oomplaint:py referelloe a/J i.~. fully filet for\:h at length !lerein. Plaintifffil are IIPer!'lonp" ap qafinad ~y 73 p,S. 6~Ol. " 13. ~(~) t I." 14. :l(~) t 16. Defen4ant ifl a "Parfilon"ap qefined by 73 p,a. 6201- The Pennpyl'Vol\ia Unfair Trade Vraotioep and Con/JUllIel' . " Proteotion Aot, 73 P.S, Q201-:l(4), defines "unfair Dr deoeptive aotll or praot:ioell" 1:0 il101ude, but nou limited to, the followil1g1 " II (vU) t RllprePIlI1\l~119 t:h~\l gOOqp PI-" Jl(Jrv~pllp " A~~ o~ Ii\. v~r\l:\.OI-l;l.f.\.1-" p\lli\.l1qf.\.l-"cl, 1l\.\f.\.;l.Hy Or grf.\.r.lll, or \lllli\.t: 11r.1I;~qp I\rll p~ f.\.PAl:'\l~P\1l1l.l-" pt:ylll Ol:' ~oqlll,~~ \lhllY Are of Al1ot:hel:', (#V) t ~rll,:\.HmJ \l0 comply w~t:h t:hll t:1ll:'ll1P elf Any WI-":I.\:ot:el1 a11al:'Imt:ee of. Wf.\.l-"l-"lmt:y gj.Vlll1 t:o t:ha p\.\yel:' qt:, prior \lo, orf.\.~t:er Ii\. OOl1t:rAOt: lol:' \lhe pI-Il:'chape of SQpqp or Ile!:'vioep ill mf.\.qll/ ' (:ii:V) t Jl;now:l.ng;l.Yll1~prIlPl1ellllnt::l.ng t:h~t: pllrV~oell, l:'llplAoemen\lP pr l:'llpa:l.rp f.\.re needpd if t:iley f.\.l:'1l not: I1lleded, , (~vi) t MA~ing repairp, improvement:p or r~plf.\.Cell1el1t:P on t:f.\.nl1ible, I-"Ilf.\.l or perponal J:ll:'opllrt:y Of a nat:"rll"Or q\.IRl:l.t:y,:\.nfet'ipr t:o or pelow t:he pt:Anqf.\.rq of \lhf.\.\l ~gread t:o in wd t::Lng, (:ii:vU) (:ii:lli:\.) t lllngaging in !lny ot:her frAudulent or deoept::l.ve cOl\dllct: whioh oref.\.\lal3 a lil~el;l.hooq of pCll1flll3iol1 or of mip"l1qarpt:andinl1. ,16 t p;1.f.\il1t:iffp \:leHeve, Al1d \ll1llrllfol-"e IWE!r, that pefell.t'\ant:' f3 oondllot: fdl!l within t:hoafbrernen\lioll.ed defill.;I.Uon Of "upfAir or t'\eoept:ive act:p or praot:ioBIl, II lJ'urther,more, Pefell.dant:'f3 actionp oonpt:itut:e otherwifJe l-"eo~llllfJf3, W;lIl.t:OP, or wi:Ll:ful oonduot: Whiah j.fJ J;lrohibited hy t:he l3t:atlut:e. 17, ~eation 201.9.2(a) of t:he I3tat:ut:e providell for privat:e oaufJBfJ Clf aation fcr any perfJop IIwho pUl-"challep or leafJol3 goodp 01-'" pe;t;viCJep p:dml\rily for perponAl, falllUy hOllpehold pUrpo/il8P. II The 'atlatut:e l\uthorilllep t:ha CotlrU, in it:p dhcretion, 1:0 award up to Ilhrae (3) timep the actual damageI'! pUlltainad for v,iolauionfJ. 10 I ~eallion 201-3,1 of ,l:heM\: providep t:ha\: Ilhe aut:omo\:ive :Lndul3try Ilrade praalliae rulep and regu;tatiol1p adop\:ed \:ly the A\:t:orney General for t:he enforaernenll of thill Aotare deolared unlaWfUl, /. !' , :t.1l, ~'1A~,I1~:t.f~Q l)1lI1hVIlI II\1q ~h"'VllIfp~e IWIlIL", t:h!\\: PliIf,unqAll\\.f Ii1 ~Ollq"p\: to \:\la IlA~,1lI Al1el Plil~vtlJtnq of, t:hu vehtp+e V~qlll\:'" Ildc.'l l:'"llll!l Anq r"'S\\+A~tOnrl, Wfm"Jll!!'oRlll, pldnt:tff,/3 rl3l'l[.leot:f,uHY qernllnc\ 1"qgrnent: ASlltnflt: . . Dl'lhm\Ant: ~or OomPflllllll\:ory c\l\mIlSliI~, t:VllPle c\l\mase!l, 1It:\:Ot'ney , ' I!afl!lf OO!l\:/3 of Il":\.\' , Imp IIny f"r\:her ra],;l.el! II!I \:ha.Op"v\: ml\Y Qllll!1l j"llt: And proper~ OPlJWJ! ;l:I OOMMON J,I\,W BAILMENT ~O~ P1II;l.n\:ilf!l hereby iooot'porllt:e all fAO\:/3 IInd 1I11egl\\::\'001l " !let: fovt:h :\.n t:hi/3 oomplaint: P~' reftlt'eooe all if. f\.llly !'la\: fort:.ll II\: ;Leog\:h \lo2;ein, ~1, plllint::\.ff!l veh;l.ole Willi \:urneq over \:0 Defendant: c\ea;Lerllh~,p' fot' ret:uro \:0 ~erioAn' llonela 1I'i""lloe \.Inde2; \:he ellrly lease \:errninllt::\.on 1111 a re!lu;Lt: of Pldnl:iffll' p~\rohl\lle of II new 11190 Ohevrole\: 1'l.],0 l';l.okup on MillY 13,11190, pefundl\nt, WI\Il :\.0' sole pOllllellsion of t:ile vehiole during t:his period lI11d \:he vehiole wasn\:olen from Defandllnt:'1l lot: on or about: May ~6, 199B, ~~, ~edoan 1I0nda lJ'inanoe pont:inuea ho bill PlaintUfll for t:he .aub1eot vehi~;l.e although l?lllinl1iffll\:urnedthe vehiole over \10 Dehnelant f02; reburn to t:he Lellaing company at: hhe t:.ime of t:he II ,i llde tl'anaaotion for the ne\~ 199B Chevrolet: 13.10 piok\.lp, ~3, .Defendant, flliled t:o live up to it:ll end of \:he bll:l.lmen\: and ae a reaul\:, plllin\:iffa have ptiffe~ed great damage. anel injuriell, " I' ,I 1N\i\N1~HI:\\ Vf.Rll'llllTl!IH ~lI~lPM~R (7"" ~,'" IA ,C , ~.I",~i I b~ r '1- ~ (' \ ItaJRN'lIJl ~ilf,tlf _~ C~ +-Uvl... - ' AOE/il PI\ONE . (7 17 ) -1-G I ~ ,; ((.! 0 I . .., . tHSIlR~:r: co, Si'fo...'(-E'_ t <;\..(' 1"1 f{J~WH G 9 s - I 0 '2..0 ~ l);:u~ -18 c... , TI'I~D To:...Dc:l1'\. ~J).... J O-c.V\ . , D~m 05LI3/1f?' ~. ,-- r-- TlI'I\ 0 'iS4 5" ~lM'JWlE PliRIOD Fr,llH 7./2-G/i'~ TPJ(zG,hL Dli1lIlCT1BL\\S __C\1J.1Sl~ .2-T(),~DIf11A/.1IVIl. ,,' ~ SliLE5I"/\H 91DNAllJlW tfV{.J..f~j ~ j{. r~ " DM.NlCE ONED TO M\1I1lma r~lllln . AI:~T , PAYOFf MoutH nOllp TIll ' , .' 11AYOFF I tfORHM I 011 A'Me.r:~.",-", ~\"""J.o.. y.:~I\"'-v\.d.-e... V\',1+c.I"P"',\', f1 c:c.I;:....",~I.; "':1 " ~, ,'.- 1L2.65' \:~-e~P<'('-\- ~c<.fku.'o..Y Sc~,k Ib';l.t) I I' ," r -. \ ,"'v 7&0'(;3 Uc,c~ 70S ~ ~ 5~S ' '.\:"t\h 1'\'\'" , , ,,161. 6lc,s~ "7IG-9?~3.. rv J Y4 Ec"r Iy 1..f.\a..St!. 'T'f'~\t\.A.:I..:O f', PliR O~y lr.l':(Et' lh :s .....a a \\.; 1:'11. OAlli 5/12./ 9'1' TI~f, '7,(+ 5 1111\ , \ \{ 1(\ ' 1,\-\ Gr c.. ~ 552<;; 'Ii .....,,, " " , -..-~-- -- ...--.~.~.- - ------....------- -- .--.-.-...... -_._..~.-......._-----_._'_.._--,,,_.---._._._-.....-.-. _.~ ~ II {(1," ... e' s'~ (::jfS~ , '.'f.~,......(~ .,"... , ~, ': Q U 13 V R 0 I. ~ T, IN p, ' ......., 1, 3'100 HnrlzqnlP Dr, . CAMP 1111,~, I'A, 17Qll .PhpI1P 701,0600 No, 044272 n1'II,PIQl 't4PUI 00,la73 313 P"y;:.:!.1Ui..JIII I' IIi I:' P:I) Ir,I,III':H'I'UI1U1i: r"pl.l,i\I::n I. TOnt<< onn~11 or , Ai'lIm I:l1iltl HI)I'II>fl FHII~l'iel, ." , PIIl,I~ 'I,'! ,',/"!'l.li!).', 'r , PHq,nOI~I-F'I'I.f.f~ pn '1,'Hi'H ,. " , , , ' " I --- a~@IHl"~nllil@(Ql.'1TOt~\(IDtJ.1El ..AI! PNO MtiK ,,~ftW aUMAftn\-ltlll, ~~ ..' '.,:" . 'I.' .. .' " --~!--:mliltlIlIZlloli1ONn\J rr ~ . NAM~ .)II(::ro:H)(,\I'1 1'lflHP(,1 (':1'1'1(1111;[,' ll;\',';)fl OATE 1J'.'i.' :1, 'ji,'r,l/\ - , om ItlV, NO, AMOUNT DUar., OATH I~V, NO, AMOUNT OQ'90, " 1''f'll)!:'F ..t')lir.'(\I.:) :; ';1., t:i:~I:1 r r':' . " ;1\.,t,;T (;1 t,I:\ I I'!llt'. ;"" 'ld " . " 'I. . I , , " " , , , " CHr:CI<.NQ. NET I .. RaMITTANCE ADVlca FORBeS OHaVRot.fiT INo, . 'I ..'I 1'.; /';, ~ AMOUNT '!i .',ll:' '\ " ,j' ~;,:, Ol'!TAOH AND RIHAIN OA I ~ 0 MP II~ I PA 17 11 '-" '.'. ' ' " . -- --- -.,.--- -.--,-- ___,__ _ _ __ __ _0-;-:"_'_""__ .~.. .~_ ......_._ __ _ .__.._ _ _,_ __ _w..-_ ~._ I,' I r ..PI-AINTIFP'8, I' e~~IT .. ,,~ " . .., ~~tl-31'l- ~ 91'18 \'la' 44 , FHPH 1 7t7 7Bfl :m~)9 ",P3/li1 1,(}WH~ AUd~N PfJf.,(fJ1i1 P1ifM~'1'MRNr J . fNf-'IPPNr HliNJR7' ~l~ ) f. ," / j~\ Inll'~a"l {j11!l.. ()5. '7? i ) 'b. . UIR..L 'IUV._ ~~. r.\lcAlhlO' .,31/00 WIJ"rz.M~~ /1,,-, (f1o::.p-'hJ/~\~-,.__. '. "01'1'1'''_ tfMc~., qa\lClllj~1 I'lfl.., ,. PU(u: "''i'I,.I!I.9/L PIH\1Tlm!lI__--1..1S\.I .PAYI--1Hu,.,. C""C1mrlr/(l"~-r.;til"'~' "rim !J~~i_-:!'Iti"?:L~all (:IIII1'Y\1111 .-(ftI,rt.':.P~'.y II((O'T~fA (,I I\lurrfll YaK_ Nu..lf. In rrulll'll~'1I YUK..I'III"':: Vlvlll11'~ 1~llIhlKI Ya~_ NI1-,. Inu\RCl!H lllfl\llNl (5"'!III~'~li<I"l-' ,,' ff1c.I!ld!ii\'Ii;t'fl!lrRlfH -- Chac~ HpfCl 1'01' 1\11~I!'onul NIII'I'!IlIVu (nn, ~U(lpICPnl P"~P) ... .~ (YJ...r "i.,"t:1/~"hq, ,~. "b,t ~ (.!J,,""" \..' r"r.'~a:4-tl".~ (J,'~~ I t\ .~ "l-fk'".1' (('Wl4l~n')Q"c.,~) ....:bi~",\ ,~.........h.ur.: 1"""",Lc'lVI"" 1l~~ll'U;'~ Ii~h., :t~ .(.\~".. IUI!:...J ~.,,~ nTh..~!! ,~..,' ~'~IO'It lu~loII:I ~r",,~.k_; ~!~!<A!!l,~"Cj~~L'- :!'Gfl,"'" I "'\~I--/IL.'1 1J..~::l ,,-4!,:;;..i.. rub "JJ... t:",(l if. JJn1. J~W1~J "'1~~-----..:i_~.!L. If4.1~~. ..~...t- fI'1 'l~r.i1'? \~t.,~.rt~!. , -nu ~1"~4!. L.\itt~, (t1Q'I+~JJ1~"..:t:li1 \ r :--.-:=----:-:- -r.:: ~, / . ...... , ' ~Wt'4X\ ~,t"4,.t& '","",1' $'.t(,.?f?, ~."p~'ln u~~~~.~'" -IJw ,1m 1_~IIAI'.J Iff"1'oI,'j...iu-J!. ~ "II~ -.., "'.......'."~I~:l " , ...~"fl"tI't't'~~1 Nllmll i\~~rlluli IUu""l'i,y,ll,IC,;!i,,, W$It\ PhOnCl II . .1l;!~-r.:IWpL.Jo,.J..,.... '~. ~'~..;"'/~M,.J;; ~;'~~~~~t~F'''~1 .l:::..1Jn.1..Jil. 'i'l1j./:35c:J__ <"0"... q"1'01AJ,,-,,,\.:r ~'iCO Jj"IL",-,\,Ii",- 1\, . ---.~_ w..1.~ba" , . fI7':'ro"~ {!, II/>/Il.rc''c, 3 'I' 't "~ 2, ~lC..~.uJr,i?.J::!.I.:::l1.I...3a. CI'tI./.s,a~.1 I ~6'. C.1ll.l!.I>l&r'...~, Iff) -;;;1"\ C=". " ;z:"..J,,'''' J'l, 1~(.li1.,; I...J I.!!LI_ '7'3:;1.. ?-,ao of LI''''.-J~(J /.I. ~:Z:L&J.!&r "'. .. " ";': !:l-.I.!!...I_ ',' II .s .<1m1lt:lc:.~II.~l'"1'" ~ rN~11Jl. 1!"sa.-1!!ol L\!:1!:!W"" "'''" , "('1:.4 I','" . ,,;;.J"'ir"G IJ"L!!;I_I_I.tl~Q' 20B.(.>~';;..J. ('NVOI,V~~'.NTI M"'I'PNII ~"IlIIJ",nJ, W'Wllflttll "'''f'Wl'"~,tly, Ooothtt'1 , Officllr f.qvoIV~QI Un" " Type IlIlQgll /I ~~. J' -Z.... 2:..... i!.1.. PIRp --LJ.~ 1\5" ArrivlI/ No).. .......!.i1L"'-., Clullr 'z.""r, 1'I'lL Rpl -{- PfficPI'll llaQQe II 23 ~ - -- -. "-;--0" tlllpcrvlsor& /I I, - /J -,- '- -....--. Unlfonl\ IlIve.UB~Uol\ Ituvortl OCCUr! lllllo AI: --.1_"'-,.- , I3cIWCUOI--1_j -" MllIJuROp<:ranlll: '_.1- '__' II or Orrllnllurs~ (II or U . Ul\~nl\\IIn) alns Mutiv~tionl Iilhnlc l~aIlHlolls__ Ro1otlll__ ~1l~lIRI Crlmc ScCneS~lIlcltll~1 YOR_ Ni:l_ PI'IIIIR TRk~lI: Yos_ No_ "mJgu (I PhlllllS Tukcni YUR_ No_ Ilndguli Tlmu DIlV Sol\'1lblJlty 1111I:11II1; I, Was Ihern i1 WIUle.'iR? ..,.,.."'.",,',, I , . . , , , , , j , . . . , , . . . . , , ' , , , . , t I I I , I . . I I j I I I '" " , . . V or 2, SURptlCI Nllm~ or Ouod Dc.,crlplll'ln ' , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . , ,', , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , Y nr Jt K.nowhtdsc or SUlIfll1Cl LucQlion . , , . . . . , , . , . , . , , I . I , I , I I t I , I , . , , i , , . . , . . , , . , , , , , , , , I , , I , , , , , , , V or '1, DeffCliplloll Which Idenllllel Vehicle Usml hv SIlS~ucl , , ,', , , , , , , " """'""""""""""",,. Y nr. 5, J.IIl\I;~2 ()ppol1ul\lty lor Suspuot tn Cll111mll Crlmu ,,' , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . , , , , . , . " \' ur 6, 1..ltl1l1e~ Nllmher of Persons u l'oRRlhle SlIspeclS , ,', , , , . , , , , , , , , , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . , , , Y or 7, DeliaI' that Clime can he fl.esnlved with RUo1RllnubllllnvuRlIuatlve Efron """'""""""""."."" Y or H, /leller Ihl1l'R Major Crlln~ cnn bu ItDsolvell wlllt Pllhllclty """ , , , , , , , , , , , , , " , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Y or IJ, PfllsCncO of Slgnlflolll\l Physlclll Evldencn to IP SURpucl """,."""""""""",.."""""", Y u/' 10, ~'\l~nYll/lth Chlltllclcri611uS, Mllr~', NllrnberR, 1I11t1 uAn bllTlilClld "I""""'""""""""""" ,. Y or II, rllNllIv" n... ,'I ' r.. . ,,. .. ".1",. ~cel1ll S~~rch fol' I'rills. , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . , ' , , , , . , , , , , , , , , , , ' , , , , . ,. Y nr I 1)0/00 NOT IIIlsh to pros~culll Q , . I' JIJN.,.3Vl~\90i3 ~F.l14l'i PlfH 1 717 71~~ 313'il'3 P,P! ': (..QWBR M'("RN PQ~l(}R fJarMfl'Ml1NT .. ~I1IW.RMPNmUc(JNr1NVATf()N lo\~hl~l1f 111_'_' """'- Priulnl1l NRrm11 r\r\ll~l f{~I'!lr1 ~lL- ,SIl\lpII1I1\I11l1 p 111\\11I111111 ,r(, Nqlll1 R!l9"111111 I(rrl1p~rty Infl'l I \lsarW {lR\1Iill CI111\pl1111111 __ I\lhllllpoRI r~r801l(.\) nil 1\\l~l1rVU 1'1111 ~llrQI1, 1\1I11~hlla " Vlallm FIlII Nil"'.',.;.... ~Lf- ,,', Aaansa,d.Fnll Nfn,JI! P!.bl . 'f:!~ Vli:HlC"~ lNFOllMATlONI J'I~.~ J./1J"",f! .L1J;w.:u'~ ~~ _ ~.,I."".(' \I' (il/r,~,: v_r'" ~/;fc..(~~ ,':i:$2(jl~,q 14> 5 ~11P.l ..., SU/iPIlCT onSCRJP1'JI;lNI ~r~I~14~f?~~_c:1.. ICJCI"'.~' _~ 6.J',~~ "H'n~JiQL~"~'"Y\ ....'-~I.ml:,,.j~' ,,1'"7d' ~ ' ~ a _"'i'JI,..._rl:t.b.x.?o~.~ ~. ,~""t': Qi 1J)....'.1.. \.a~e''''D Ca _ AllJ '-:IJ~Q.'1" . Qn~~r\~a . '~;~,i' O't g~~;'C)~c=:~',; ~f.~~cjf;:;: ~t~;;~;:+ ~n~.'l:-U~,~. I'V....fi.,.~T' .~I)( i?Q ~~,.I,.,nJd (%W;; ~;;:.. ~~.- ' ~ " - - rt, ,.- '.----- .--, .-r- , . ..- Ai ,I , ,......,--, DI\TB: I ',' D~'L.;,.ql:' ,I'AOE:-1-..ilf--1., om~utlll 1..\ SUIl,#i' ~ Ca\ftSlAtulI Q" (QIOpen, ,\.,\dlnlll Clen!, 1I,t;'lhl'Otl Mun.C"lllli\~I, ".EI~6pilonMI CI.M(1I1~C, l'.rcndlll..^U611, It.CIUl'td/^f1lllt, U,UIll\llltlltc~ " ~~~3~-\ee~ ~R'4r, , I'I'\I~A , 11'1'i' 1'i31'l 31'le~1 F',I'lI'J"H' I' ~"MH,It~1 " . ~MlIl"'~~'~II"n Nllmp 1 I I ~ P~, \. :!.!j~I~- -~~14+- 7(.i.(,(::l-L,.~ ~I- . ,... "". ,."..'" -'":'_"":":"_" 3, " __ ~, S, fi,___.._. 7, ~, " ' , Sl~l~nl-'L (Il,oPOI1I .\II\.lInln al~ijr, ".q~q",11 NIlI1,Grllllll1Rl, ~'llI~~p\luMI CI'I/,n~" I"P~I,'Unl ^fIClI, 1I'C1~.,,,III\l1.I~ \!,Ul1rOIII1~cdl a~~llpllllnl\l r:IMrnnl1a Cll~--. (Sac Curio ~Oll~' !-lICIII!lln l/ll&/OIIIlI I CD [.lul\lI. I), Wcnl1\afl! ) .. l\lmpl..l:L,. " (1.],11.10.1, ~,rnllr, r,pqlr, IJ,Un~1 (1l,1l.ln. $.$now,I..ahllllly, C'C1~lf, U,Ullk, Q.Q~lIrI . Vluw/lnrol... (V,VI,w, 1.ln[o r~'\v~l', IHIIVRIIII, NR'Nol1 rnp<lI1!~I.,II~r'I\QPo~I>I.)' Whlel. In, rnl c:?)N (INfO Pt'/t..Y. NUl I'llI' $(lIlnn, f~CI1Val111I, qllmllllar\ 01' lllWcq) .r1 ' C~ VT Hnnllllnl*1 Y @ pCeD Vlpll\n/WIl I'llI'm I & N DlIm Rallll Flinn!' Y l.IY JiM Slllnall pocnmnnit Y C! SOli, SII, my I{II~' '(@pafnrTOrlpfn$nPllllnllIYaDSllllamnlll/Cllnfn!&lnnlY,'LW ManU ,y@ (lllrtlwr M~&I$I Y /!D S\1rnmllnil "YaiD WlIlTiIIltl Rec Fulluw Upl . Q?N Ran~~tll1lmonllnl_" ClIntldanUill, YaD . .~rp,rl~n~"'I.P411~lIyft, ~'.llIY~nllft OllftMpr, Q,forpnll'l, f,IIlY~nll,l:hll~ A\Ju... c.C:;ummllnllY P.I,donl, r.I't\'",1l rv ~ ,., INVOlNIll;l'PliRSONSI (V,Vlallrn, W,WII\lftll, S,5'II'PO", '\'1\'''110'\, p.ownar, ol',OrPlnlor, 1l.lIppona4 Ur) (VICTIM 'TYpal '.In,lIyldu~l, 1""u~loo!~, HIII~n~IIIIIIIIIII\lIlon, O.qoY~mm~nl, 11.11.1111111111 Oralnll.lllc% $,SIJClI~IYt1'Ill>lI., O,Olh~rl . [nvulvel1\~nllTYpal_JiJ_ PJ/Clllln:~ II,PIIl.llrIlIK, a.PI '" C:llIInlV aI, 3>CollnlY ai, 4./'lnl /'l~h COOCIJI.dl-1_ NMMI (~ilIl, Ph'l, M ,1~la, Slln (liS/A POll _ ., .1I.:'l'",..I1 ('l1Rrtk.. __ &J '.1!fJ..m. ,,--,,-,_ A<ltlr~s~IISI.~; 51, Nlma, ApliN, CIIY, Sima, Zlpl . . __ . ' ,.. . " \0 11,ClIJI,"\"..lt-. A.....) 1V\,.I,.\.l.l\>-"', .'.~ ~ ..,.. , ;.., rl-l#i~d~...../J.!ii;: liISJ'ANICI U@U CllnANI C{Ell1 ltESlDnNTI ~ u (at'LawerAU~nTownshlp r;mplayofl (Nlm~li\iI~i~n) fIb""",.,,,,, Ch""J""""'~' !t'\c.'IO 1-\t\(l.-n.I~(~L::_ 1'.14 c.;.....p 'HI ~ I "lot> 1/ " . I'H#:_'juJ,,-'&1:J.' Ii hllHhl0Si vl~1I1111 Y ([) T~plll----. ,I , '" I, Wllrk HOllr11 f.x:.-'r.,. \ \-ow ST/QLNI_' ,')",1... SSNI ~ef1llad (llllly6'...J ~ Invalvnmonl/Typal...cc:L DJ/C~urtl,..JL II ,PI, ;",rII1K,2.pI & CIIIIIIIY ai, ),ClIlIlIlY CI, 4.NoI N~"Ia~1 ClIdeSl&l-1_. NII11l01 (~~II, PI~I,Ml<hll., sun PJ~'A Don h:"tf.~~.".ln.jJ,,:,- -r/fI1~ --NfL1........ t\ddrOHYIISI,#.SI, Nln\~, ApI.', CIIY, SI'N, 7.11'1 ,; I\...-" . II :3\Il:lC \lr"It.:r7~Lc...),:.,fl... ~Ii.LU ~ 1':)011_ ' rll#:_,..:t!ul,.~ HlSrANIC: 'li.:!Pu CU~AN: CC,li..U ., Ri:lS1DIlNTdDN U (Of 1.1lIYor Allen lbWI1Rhlp' Ilm"loY~f! IN.m~f'l~t'~11 .J ')1- "Plilll_'--11L- Ii husll1cYi vlo\lm 1.v 1'1" TY\l~: Wurk Hnurl: ,,;J.4-_ ST/OI_N:. ~'(~_ SSN: i", Clluperated Puu6' ~ Involvumo~l/Typo,-.1~-'_ D1/CuI1l11-Z... (I ,O/ll.."nn, 2.0/ & Collllly Cl, ]'coulIly el, 'I-Nul /'1..<111<1) Co<loYI.P..:iJ_'~ NnmouLIIII, 1'\IIlI, MI~~f., sun 'RlS/A DaB , )/"'!el!.(? I MI,"\..;'~U D I t5. J::!.JC!.L/.8 ~'~/__ A<l<lrolSl (SIN. 51. Nom., ,lp'.!I, CiIY, SI.I., Zip I ' . , " 'W'~ (~{.J.'Il~ ~1~'~a.,.....cu~I~'" I ~ PH#!_,..1i~.-1ill.} H1SPANlC;'HZis) lJ CUBAt'/: C~ lJ Rl!SlbBNT; RQ2l u IlmplaY"/IIN.mo/Adth"'J ~ ,,,.... ~ (.'1.. u, ....p" T" "...3 0:, I'l,t#:~, ~(,i,~ I" hllRlnUHS vlulhn'l Y €.J 1y1)~: Wurk Huursl "/JOD - I ).01./ 5'1'101.1'1:_' a.dE............ SSNI tieR '~) p . OllmpJet I\lIe",l1\ - -0:- ~""\ ~ ,.., . " JUti-3~-!99a ~B'f1f:l PHFFI ! '71'7 7i31'l 3B'3~1 1',1p112 PRPrllRTY Il'IrORMATION (m8nHi!pl~'j, R-R~~p'/~ro~, f-l'p"nll, o'Pllm~"~II, :'iK-,S~r" K;ppin~l /I, ~, p p"',fnrl1pn.(M\lI\Il, ,MP~~I, Sprlll! H"m!J1:r, ~pll1(, ~Izc" c:1~,) l. .' Q6J1pAlJo,A oJ tkLf'~~. .5/---1_.1 .tJ./~,:.J CCl/f'~ ~, _ \/......:. II I )ICe, b. 5i -;;''''.!.tj.lJa5r~E) l. _ V>>ll1o h?-,~,r . .~' .,- 4, S, el, " 7, . a, 9, ....~, -, - ~ 10, __ \1. _ I~, 13, 14, --,-,.., IS, ~11l111 Vftlpol J / Z. n 00' w TOIQI Pnmlllle~1 COP",Y Inc:tlllSnl #1 \NYO\..VIlP PIiJl,~ON~; \V-Vl~ilm, W,WjInf.l', ~;SI1\1"~I, ,\-r\~~u~~~, 0,0\\11'1, 0\,,01'"1_10'1, !t'lIoporte<l !IV) . (VICTIM TYr~ll'ln~lvl~!I~I, 1).~"lln"', Nln,nol~lln.lllllllolI, q,Oov'mm_nl, R'II'"nln", ori'nl~llllll, R'SO*lYil'4blll1, P'oll\01l \ -..., JnvolwmanlllYlllll.J:d..J ~ PUr.:olllf!-k..... (I-PI n"lhl.,~, Pf41 CUlml~ 01, 1,Cq~mY c:~ 4.1'/11\ N!lOdall CQ(j~1 "''' 1...--1..- ;NlUllal (~&l1, fir!!, MI~illo, Slll1. ' MilA' poa tJ.!t...""~T . f'.... ,~I" J tit" CIllo , _I::!.J.!!l-I~ .!!3.J (.J(ul./sl!, AlIllr,o!il (S~II. s~ i'I"m', N'~II, CilY, SI.\O, ~IIII ' I1D 7ii(lit( G;:J;'rt,o. '<..J",/.~ wz.", PHftl_' 'HI,. 'lL1'2.t> IiISPANICI H &,) t1' C\.IllAN: Ca9JU RaSIDllNTI l1mr1ayer: (i'I~mulf\ddhlh~l U..J y <l'~lu;J PH#I___'~~ .. fa bllilnoaa Victim? Y @.> Typa, Work HO\l~I.. /.!.^/f,., , ST/OLNI.w ',;ltl4'Hl "'.;.'-1 - (Of LQwcr.Allun 'fownihlp I' S,SNI U.J to, , COQP~mlo\l fUIlYLP r . lnvalvom~WlYpa,-bLI,,-- PJ/COIInI-iL, (I.Pllldlnn~ll-O/& COUIllY CI, l,COlln\vCl,4,Nol Necdc41 Codoal~/_/_ Nama, (~J,u, PIIII, Mld~I., SilO /I R/S/,\ Doa . fJ::t\.~fl.'7' ~ '-"'IlJNI~M {~ ." _w"ILI..:ti. !-!..!LIZ" ,1d>}. A'J\lroullsl,N, SI, Nom., ,",PI,N, CjIY, sw..lip) ,~, 40 'ro/t.'1 I-rA('~' J ~~_,~ /'HJ1.'S PHHI.,.- "l:}b-'1/'lP HISPANICr H@U CUllANI C &bu . IUlslbllNTI RQDU (Of Lowar Allen Tawn,hlp employer: (i'I~m.I"d~lmJ CI~C>w..... PH#I_, ().J{( _ '''bualness vlcllm'1 y Qv Typol I Work HOllr~1 I/..-Ic:.. S'l'/O/..NI ea./ l'f<t~q Oln.::, SSNI (/-1~ti: Cl1ofl\lr11lod 1~1I1~ ~ lnvolvomonlnypal-.\L.I-E DIICllurtl~ II.OJ "'''1111, 2.01 &: elllllllY eli, J.tll~nIY 1:1, 4,1'101 N..d.d) Codall~/~I_ Name: 1I..III;~I,"I, Mlddl., l;U~) I ...-. ,~y~. Dy~ f)fPtJl<lt'....t<1,.J l:f!,,"'.c.(~ h ""^'~.. ('"rt.... --..I::l. _ --IJ.. ~ , AI\ltroIIIISI.#, ill, Nlln.,' /\1'1.#, elllY, SIAlU, ZII;) " ' ' '''. GJU I t!1I,""",~ ./)t!~tJJ c.. ~ ~.t1L1!j-r'rJ,.j 11./1.::1:"1- l1J Don"; '. pH#I~'.le!!' "li$ , BlSPA1'IICI H N U CUhAN: C N (J I\ESIOBNT; R N U (Of LOWel 1\lI~n TuwnJhl~, ;':"'l'lu~dn \1','11\0"1""""', --t.dl... ' ,.,. , , __ nUll' .._, ~..' .....~~,..,._. fr 1.Ijo.'!~It~'\ tll.'.t\t~!') V 'I 'T',II,." Wmk !iIIUtS: JJ}'" _STlOLN; I , - ~/I,~ SSNI ~ltt~ Cllopllr~t~dFully;(j) ~ , . , J\..\"i~3a-~~913 1~8'4\'l PIlFA 1717 713ll 38<;iS< rJ,lll~j:! :' flBOPPRTY INF(}fl.Mt\TIPN ('l'YPEI ~'~Ipjcn, IHle~nVtll'\lIt, f'PPlln~, P'P"m"~~q, ~K,.~.rc "'U~P"H:' # TYpe P~$CIirllon (MIIKu, Mu~ul, ~Qrt"1 1'1111111>1:1', Cpl\1I', ~I~, Plu,) Wille I. ' , ~. ~, - 4, 5. --, ti, - '7, --- , H, ~ ~, , , I), --- la, II, - 12, .-- ~3, --. 14, IS, ~'" Tlltpl Vulllol. TOlal Oumllllusl _ , , CPllnlY u\cldDnl#, \NVOr.vaD f'11R~ON~i IV,Vlo,lm, W,Wllnm, s,S~'P'OI, ~'^..I"a!l, O.Qwnar, QI'.o~IOrl R.~a(HllltCllm (VI!:1lM TYPIlII,IOlllvlllll41, '''lIu.ln~', f,f1nlll1ulallnlluuUun, r~,ouvdm,"an','M-flcIlMlou, Onrlll1l''''IIQn, S.$OIlI~Yl\'llbll., o-ollt<r) " Invplvo/nunIlTYpuL.J...LI_ OJlCollnJ~ (I.P/IlDlnnll, 2.01 &: CU~IIIV C4 J.\::RunlY CI, 4'1'10' N..~a~l COllosI,Q'S 1_1_ , Namc! f~all,J,lrll' Mlddlc, $~1l1 WS/A" ROil' 'M/ n4, c..I,H..k:./ltJ" I !!!:!... .1:!J .J!1.J..L --I!."" If..- /\lldflliSl (Sf,#, $1, No~., API'#' c:1\v, $W", Zip) , , , .s...,~ Lla'r . Co ' ~IQ_ I'HIII_,.:tll:.~. CUIlANI C N (jJ) Rfl.,.~IDa I R NaJ) (Of t..o\llDf A!lull Thwnshtp {, 13, ,"player! (N.me/MIII.'.,) "JM'-' '1--=-hu~-t.. l,/(J ~ I IBM (..l'"'l(.'~.wl1 /2,,, IltJc... 4t. (1 Pl-\II:,':'-"'lli. tala'! II hlt~lhu ~ vlollm'/ Y<JD Typal__ Work (,lours I V"IC, _. STIOI.NI_'_U..,.dc:,. SSNi_ C/.1 J(~ Cooperate~ rull~ I Involv~munl/l'ypal--' __ I)J/Cllurtl__ II.nl ",jlin~, ~,DI '" CU~n\Y CI, ),C"'IIIIV CI, 4,Nnl 1'I.a.f.til COdONI--'-'...;.. Namcl (~~" Flr'I, MIII~I., s~n WSIA pop . I I ", / , ---../- --:-, Aurllml (S(.#, SI, NOIII', Apl,#, ClIv, SIDI', Zip) I'IINI_:_'__ JlISPI\NICI H N 11 ClJn,\N: C N U Ill1lployufl (Nome/Addrcul_ PHH'_._. Is huslness vlollm" Y N Typul_. Workl-Iounl.__ 8T(Or.N: __I, RUSIDEN1': R N U (Of Lowor Allun 'lbwnahlp SSN . 1_. _. , tnvoIVamul1U"l'yI'o:_~'_ DJ/Cnurtl_ II.DJ II"rlnw, J.IlI &. C"UUIY CI, ).CU~I1IV Cl, 4.Nul Net.~'d) Cudcsl_I_I....... NMlllli 'L~\I, Plr'l, MIIIIU" sun ' . WSIA DOP :'"'- _1_'- _,__ /\ddIOSSI (SI.#, SI, Nom".. AJtI,#, CUv, Slol., 7.lpl rItN:~,_.. IIlIlP^NICi H N U CUllAN: C N U ttillpluy~,t! ,NRm"^O,l'<III_ __ ,'!ll"_'_' ': '111,l>"f"'1 "',::tn'~ 'f 'I '!,.I~',: _ ., - Wnrk Huul1l:.__ :moLN!..._1 l~nSIPaN1'! It N U (Of Lowar AIl~n Thwnshl~. ~ -- S8NI__ Coo!Jetllled PullYI V '~ ..~... ,.,{ 't \A .;, !:-, , '" ~ -Ill' \[. t;::l <1, A ... ~l) , 'I /, ':l '-'1 Vi :r "" ,," ;, I" " , ..... \', :)'. <.:::; I"" ...., \)' .." ...., \-, . jr4 " " " ., " -- ,,' I', '," ell , .' . , 1\~, (: I' .J '" \'In C1 I~;', ' ,'l,,( " ' ,'\ . rl" , .., , (-;<.,~ , I .. \\ " i'll, );n " l' l F'" ~'"I : ~'(-1 .1," \\1' ".1 . I ~;' I' ','1.11 f' I ,if I " < ~ I,i,'. ' , ,; ... Iii l.',.j.\. ,-: II, .,'! l,,' n' :~) " p' u " " " " ;i' '." ,. d' " r.', ,_d Il " " I t, , " " ,1i:RRY QI~!3j:RT ANP I-YNNj:A QI~!3j:RT, P~AINTI,FF~ v; : IN THi: OO\JRT of OOMMON P~i:AS of : QUM!3i:RI-ANP pouNTY, Pi:NN~Y~VANIA , , , " , FOR!3j:S oHj:VRO~gT, INo" : Pi:Fj:NPANT : 90,64Qli OIVI~ Ti:RM IflREl MOTION oFDSEOOAlfi..fQR SUMMARY JUPGMsN! W;.E.Q.RB.ID\.'l.I:.SY.MNQJ:tt:BB,..J.. P...IIDBR OF ~OURT ANP NOYV, this -'J.}-" dElY of ME1Y, ~woo, the motion ofcl13fendant for .. SUlnlnElry )ud~Hnent, IS GRANTt:P, I, / By the Oourt, / , , / /'" ;/, (\ j' I'"~ ' '--" \W' --,,=,,' ~dgar f.\, l3E1yley, J" ILfU'WJ f~)cIL.t ,~'L')'OO ' 'KI~'3 I', PElnlelle l3eauvalsi Esquire For PIEllntlff~ William opatopoLllos, Esquire For Defendant iaaa ) ,I,' ,.11 \. I' , . .1: I' , \ ' ),'1. j'I,1 l \:;"1/1\.\1 " 'l., "Ii, " I, ,. j,. Ii' ... i ' " lJ , . , Ii " " " 'I "d' " I,d ,,' II ,;d " 'I' " (1 " tl ;1 I;' r" " " "'1 " ;1 II H J'. " I', " \1" " 11\ " " " I . " j'~ '.\, \,1 " II" Oa,54!'l~ QIVI~ T~RM (Ii) QnMflY 14, 1008, ql3ff!nq~nt pflld 11113 $674,7611fllflnae d\18 I)y pllllntlffl'l to Amerlofln I-\om:lfl Flnl'lnoe for the ellrly lall!>e tl3rmlnllllan, (m Tile Hondfl Aoaord WIl!> !>Iolen from IIw 101 of clefench:mt'!> del'llarahlp, (7) Thl'lt defenclflnl's ponduolQonstl\llled \tI1ffllr find qeoeptlve flols.Pl' pmptloel1 il!> defined In Iha Unffllr Tmcle Prllolloe!> find oon!>umer Protl'1otlon Ael, 7:3 P,S, Beollan ~OH(4), il!> f~lIows: " .. (vII), Repre!>enllng .Ihflt f)\loel!> orservloes I'lre ~f I'l pl'lrlloull'lr sll'lnd~rcl, q\II'lIl\Y or f)mcll'l, or Ihal goods Elre of a Pl'lrtle\IIElr styla or mogel, If Illey Ilre of I'lnolhar: (xlv),. Fallme 10 oomply Wltlllhe lelm!> of I'lny written 9Uf1l'l'lntee or wl'lrranly given to Ille PUYeI' I'll, prior 10, [fllo) or EIfler I'l oonlrl'lQI for Ihe pLlrolUllle of floods or servloe!> Illl11flde; (xv), I<nowlngly h1lsrepre!>entlng till'll servloes, replEloementspr rep!:1lrs me neacleq If they are nolneeeled: . (xvi), MElklngrepillrs, Improvemenls 91' repll'loements on tlilnglple, reElI or per!>onfll properlY, of I'l nalure or qtlElllly Inferior to 01' pelow the !>I!lndmcl of tlll'lll'lgreecllo In writing: . ... (xvII) (xxi), ~ngl'lglng In any olher fraudLlll'lnl or qeoepllve ooneluot whloh orElates I'lIll<elllloOd of oonfuslon or of mlsLlnelerstandlng,' . (8) That "Pefenelanl, fl'llleel to live Up to Its enelof the PEllllnent Elndall.a reeult, plaintiffs Ilava suffered grel'lt damage Ell1ellnJLlrles," In count I OfU1Ellr oomplEllnt Ellleglng vlolElllons of tile Unfair TrElde Praotloes I'lnd i. ,II' OonSLlmer Protaollon Aot, plalntlffll seek "[o)ompenGatory deunagss, treble dElmages, Eltlorney fses, oost of suit, and any furth~lr relief as tile COllr\ may deem Just and " proper," .111 a oount II titled "Common LE1W Ballmenl," plaintiffs seel< damages "(lJn I'lll , This Is subseotlon(xxl) of seotlon 201.2(4), Plaintiffs have not Il1Pluded the oonduot desorlpad In subseotlon (xvII), .. . .2. 'I I; , " 0~,641H~ OIVI~ TF-RM wllh r\'lapael to 11113 ~lol1~~ 10 "If!ke II ~Ip" 10 IIwlasflor 011 \I1\'llrl3l'lrlY leflsa IfJrmlnflllol1, (~) 110 mOl1ay WfI's \'lXPI1~I1l]l3ct for thlll OO~lrt\'lllY, flnc1 ((.\) 1101111111] W~HISi1I~ ~boull1pW long 11113 t-Iol1~a was oping 10 ~a 011 c1efan(lant'slot, Gilbert fllsp l(:)allll\'l(1 th~t 1113 l'll1d 11Ill wlf\'la~'ffereQ no flmmolflllollS\'lSl'l!l a reault of l1avlng left 1111311' t-IPI1Qflwltl1 c1\'lf\'ll1clanl 011 Mi1Y 1:3,10f)8, pef/3l1dflnl moved for summary jullom\'lnl whlohla r\'lfldy for disposition, 111 Wpshlnpton V,l3llxtllr, 710A,l!d 733 (Pi1, 10(8), the S~lprem\'l Courl of Pennllylval1lf1 , sel forth Ihe atand~rd for deelqlng fI motion for summary j~ldomenl ~lt1qar, Pa, Rull'la of ", Civil Proeequre 1 03p, 1-1036,61 lw)e musl view 11113 reoord In 11113 1I0l1t mosl favorflllle 10 the non-moving Pflr\y, E1nd <\11 (Ioubts asIa Ihe exlslenoe of a genulno l~ll~le of mfllerlal faol musl be,ra!1olvEld agalnlltlhe moving party, Pennllylvllnlll S,~llte UnlVllralW v, Oounty of Control 531! PfI, 141!, 143-146,616 A,l!d 303" , 304 (1901!), hlordllr to wlthlltllnct Il motion for 8\.lmmllry hldOlllllnt, II' ' non.movlno p~rty 'must IIdctupo sufflalent llvldenao on Iln laaue eallllntllll to,hla ollSllllncton whlah he \lllllrs thl! \lurctlln of proof 8~IOh , thllt i1 My ooulct return II vllrctlot In his fllvor, Pllll~'rll to Ilctctuoe thla llvldllnOl! l!stllPllshoa thllt thllrllls no Ollnl1lno la8Uo of mllterllll fllat IInct thi) movlnll pllrtv h, ontlUlld to Juctomllnt liS II mlltter of IlIw,' 13rtel v, Plltrlot-NoWB 00'1644 PfI, 03, 101~10g, 674 A.2d 1030, 1042 (1096), Flnfllly, we musI str\'lsalhal summflry Judgmenl will be granled only In Ihose calles wl1lol1 are free and olear fronidoubt" Mllrkll v, TIIsmlln, 61!7 Pa, 132, 580 A,2d 206 (1991), (l2mphasls added,) Plaintiffs aVer In an, answer to defendant's motion for aummary judgment that Ihelr oount titled "Dommon Law B~lIment" Is based on a Bllbrogatlon olalm of their Insuranoe oarrler, We learn fior" plaintiffs' brief Ihat they aotuallY Beek $11,316,40 on tills oOllnt, whloh Islhe amounl tl1elr Insuranoe oarrler paid on their claim, not an -4. ," 0~.P461i OIVI~ T!:"M IImO~1I11111 f3xpas!! of $(50,OPO 1I11 Improp13rly plelldad In tllalr oompllllnt, In fll)rrlok ~1I'lIWAtlnQ IIn<< Qrlullnp Clompllny V, I3l!nQPr TrIIllklnQ OQrnpllnv,. (loa PII, 161 (1064), thf;l.B\.1pram~ CO~lrt of Pannf.1ylvl'1nlll at~t13q: . Tha IlIw of ~~lIl11anlE\ III w1311 alltal:lllllhBQ, I)oth !11l to tha oenaml n~twB of IJ~lIman'lI ~1lI1~1l to the Q~Ity of OBrB owad In Qlffal'ant typall of p~lhmmt, All e~rly 1111 1876 Ihll! ()ourlllt!:1tecllh!:1t ~Ilto QraMto\.11l IJ~lhnantll: . It)he I~w', , , h~1l Pael1llelllad I\lnoa tha daollllOI1 of OPOflli V' {3emarci, ~ hd,Rtwm, OOp,In tha.yem 1703, 'Whare a mfln tlll\131l gpoqlllnto hi!! oustody to keep for tha Ullf;l qf the p~lIor,'..lt wallllalq PV I~Qlclt, Q,J" In tllat OElIlf.l, 'he III not I':1nllwer~plB If they lire Iltole without ~ny fa\.llt In him, naltll\3r willa oommon n\3Qlect m~llE! him fJhargeaple, put he m~lllt pe O\.1l1ly of IIOme grolll:1negleot,' The prlnolpl\31l whloh goVern Ihe relatlonll betwean pallOI'll and palleell ~re ll\.1poinotly Iltated In Blorypn 13~lIments, Ileal, 2~, 'When tl1\3 pallment ls'for the 1101\3 peneflt of tl,e pl:lllor, the IflW req~llrea only sllghl cflllgenoe on the pflrt of the pflllee, anct of OOl-1r1l1'l mflkes him fll1awempl\3 only for oross negleot, When the pallment Is for the sole peneflt of the bflllee, the IflW requires greal dlllgenoL'l on the. part of the pflllee, E1I1d mflkf.lllhlm responslple for sllolll negleot, When the bailment Is reolprooally beneflolal,to poth partles,th\3l~w requires orell/ialY dlllgenoe on the PElrt of the Pallee, and m~kes him responsllJle for omlnmy negleot,' In TI1ol11pklns v, Saltmarsh, 14 B, '" & R, 276, Dunoan, J" In delivering the opinion of the oourt, said: 'Whare, one undert~lles to perfcl[fn ~ gratLII\ous~ot, from whloh'he. Is to reoelvenobenaflt,flnd tl1I;I benefit III to ~OQrLte solelY to the pallor, the bflllee Is lI\3ble only for gross negllgeno\3. , " It Is that . omlslllon of care Whloh eV\3n the most Inattentive ~l1d ti10ughtlesll men talle of their own cO!1tJerns, , , , The bailee without reward Is not bounct to ordinary dlllgenoe, Is not responsl~la for that CElre whloh every ~ttenllve and diligent person tQkes of Ills own goodo, but only for that oare whloh the most Inattentive take,' ThaBupreme OOLlrt stQted In Ferrlok that different standards of Delre apply to various b~lImallts, because "The common sense of tile matter Is tllf.'1t a person who holda 1~ , ,. another's yoods l'IS Q favor ahould not be held liable for dl'llTlages to tllose gbeds unlasll .6. I, ,I; 'It , 013.646G CIVil. 'fI:RM l1e h~~ h~l1f!ve'q In aPlnl;! repllleoll fl1ahlon , , , ," In Ihe p~lIe !lull Ju~I!lO, pll1lnllffa din I1plll'l1Qe.ln Ihelr 1-lonQI1 AooorQ when IheY puroh~f:1ed Ihe 1000 Ohevrolel 6-10 plokup from defencl~nt, A pl1lhnenlla "1111113 Qellvery .. of per~onl1l1y for \3OI11a pl1rlloltlar purpoae , , , upon 11 oontl'l1ol, ellpreaa or IInplled 1I1~1 ' , ., , II ahl-lll pe , , ' Qel1ll wllh I1PoorcHno 10 hla dlreollona, , ,," Wrluht v, Btlnllnu \.An~ . Comp1my, Il1p" 1li7Pa, Super, egG (1946), When Jc'my Gllperl,ln hla clepoalllon, . aolmowlacloecl Ihl1l defe~dcmllooll poaaeBalon of Ihe Honda as 11 oourleay, wltholll ~n eKPhangB of mOl1ey,lhal Wl'la an fl(lmlalllon Ihl:1lll waa ElI1Elllmenl for Ihe aole benefll of plEllnllffa, The dlBpuled fElol aa 10 whelher pll:1lnllffa 113ft tl1ell' l-Ioncll:1 wllh defencl~nl for . , defendl:1nllo relul'll 1110 Il1e leallor, or If Ihe laaaor waa 10 pome 10 defenclanl'a dealerBl1lp 10 plokup Ihe Honcla, doea nol ohl'lnge Ihe nEllure of Ihe palllnent, Plalnllffa have proQuceQ no evldenoe thai when Ihe I-Ioncla wns atolen fr'om Ihe lot of defElIlclElnl'B , . dealerlll1lp Ihalll waa aa I;l reallll of groalll1egleol on Ihe pElrl of defend ani, whlohla Ihe duly Ihal mual be Ilreaohed by a bailee before there oElnbe reoovery of damage~ uncleI' a pallment for Il1e 1I0le benefll of Ihe IJallora,~ The fallllre of plalnllffa, Ihe nonmoving party, 10 aclduoe su~h evidence ealalJllal1ea Ihal there are no genlllne releVElnllallllea of mElterlal fact and Ihat defendant Is entlUed to summary Judgmenl 011 plalnUffs' count titled "Common law 13allment," [, ~There Is nol even Any evldenoe Ihat defendal1\ did nol exerclsl.'! ordinary dlllgenoe 111 theoare of the balled properly whloh, If II had not, would oonBtltute ordinary negleot whloh Ie Ihe duty that must be breaohed by a bnllee before there onn be reoovery of dalnl.lgea lindeI' a bailment Ihat Is beneflolal to bolh partleil, -6- 1. aa~646p PIVII- Ti=RM ' Plfllnllff& I1f\ve nol evan 1l~logf.ltl\ad In 1111311' ~rlaf IIlfllll1ara III fllW avl(1e~oe 1111\1 oouldpe a~IPml\led 10 a jmYflupporllno Il1alr olall11ll1alll1l3[e W1\1l II Vlolf\llon ~y dafendflnl qf tha \Jnf1\lr Trade Pmotloea and oona~lIner Proleollon Ael, and Il1ere ill l'1Pflolu\aly none, Aooorcllnoly, clefemlf\nlla enll\lecllo &U1nmary 1~ldomenl on plalnllffa' . olalm unclar thl'll Acl, 9.-BP~ROF OOUB! AND NOW, Ihla --J ~\._.. day of May, 2000, 11113 11101l0n of (jefencll'lnt for sLlmmary Juqoment, IS GRANTJ:P, panlelle l3eauvala, J:aqulre For Plaintiffs j ,., 13y the Oourt, /'/ , ',/ ,." /' ~~ J:dOl'1r ,13, 13fJ.Yley,( )' "" \ ,. " WIIIIE\111 Oostopouloa, gaqulre , For Defenqant . :saa " " .' " !'" ill I", " -7- " 3, A~ II \In\IIWHY In IIw p\ll'\lhIlH\lI'S, F\11'110H p\lI'Il1IIl\l11 IIwll' (lIw (lIll1\l\'ls') 11\11\111\ I\lUHO~1 Whl\llp In \'\l11111111 \11\ IhV Fml1PH 1\11 \1\1111 A 1l1llrl PIIII 11\11\111\ \l~'III\1 \'\lll'lol'\l,IIH v\lhl\llo, III li\\lI,1I ]1\1rI1I'H \ll11pluyoollllophq\1\lr! 0nwl'l\lll\1 11\111l11l 1\1 1I[lvIH\l thlll oul11plll1Y Ihl\l lis vJhlpl\l \VI\H ., 1111 Fnrll\lH' prpmIH\lH, 4,. ~\II1H\lII\I\lIlII~, Al11oi'l\ll\lllluiHln hml C\'llwlhl'll ~l/:, (;ul\1l1lnl)' -~ II \lumplll1Y whloh .. , 1I11111'lI1Hen 1II11\1l1lul1l1\lH - vIHI,\ Forl1oH, \1I~IIlU plOlllr\l11 Ill' Ilw whlol\lIll1\1 p\lrHuIH\lI~ \l~lIll1ll1lnu II, 5, AI Iho111\1\l nl'lIw C\'lIwlhl'd &. Cum pliny vlHlI, Fnl'll\lk IIHkllll whollwl' 1I1\\l\lllod In lllllil\~thhl!! 1\1\'Ilw\', In which C1'II\Vlhrd l'oplloll,IINn,snl11\lllnO will plo~ lip Iho 0111'," . 1i1~M1J)AIu) (W IUCVIEW, (i, . 1\1110 I 03S,2 nf Iho ponnH~lvnllll\ 1~lIloH nl' Civil Prnoodmo prl1vhloH 111 plll'\1 Al\ol' Ihq rolovll\11 plclIlIll\!!H lI1'O OhlHOI1, 11\11 wllhlll sHoh limo liS IlIlI In 11l1I'CUH0l1l1hl)' doln~ \1'1\11, !IllY pul'l~ mllY II1nvo t'llI' H\II11I11I1\'Y ,lml!!ll\oll\ In whnlq Ill' In PUl'llIH U nlllllol' nI'IUW'" , , .. (2) II', unol' cnmplllllul\ 111' dlHonvol'Y 1'010VlInt tn Iho mOllnil, Inohl~lhl!! Iho pl'ntlllclhl\1 nf o1\pol'l rOpnI'IH,lW_lIUYllrlllLllut:l)!....\I'1lU. ~vlll bOlli' Iholll\l'[lcll nfllliill.t:.llUrIIlI hllH 1\\IIcllln pl'llllllCO ovldollco . nf' fholHoHsonlllllln 1l1lLC1l\1lllUll.lIll1luUll\' dol'onHll whloh In lI.1my IrllI\ wn\1111 I'cl\lIll'o Iho IHHnoH,ln \10 HlIl1l11l\lod In lI,hl\'~ (ul11phUHIH IlIldod), '.. ELi\lN'I'1F11S' AIlMlSSIONS I>t HUNG \)\SCOV!lliY.g 7, DUI'hl!! Iho cl1lll'HU nl' Illull\Ill'I' Clu\'IIldCllI\1ol'l' H dUllllHlllnn, lho Iblluwltl!! onl\nl\IIY " ' I . lonk pll,OOI -2- Q, Now,I\l\ I1W IIHk )'011 ,hi", MI', Ollll\ll'l, !lnor )'011 Ion \lwl'o Pl1l1w \III)' 111 11\I\lHllolI, Mil)' 13\h, whh \h\H IWW InlPk 111111 ,;<, I\ln Ihp Iloml!l ^\l\l11l'[1 \1\01'0 1\I11111n\ll' IlwlPIIHo PII)'!lWI1\H " , Wor\l plIl(ll1IT,lHli'Lhll~lLllllITol'od Ill\ll1w_lull~lIfi_\\JlllU111 uf-lllll'L\UlUh~\llllQ.Jb\ll:Q" , " ^, ".wu.rllHll~~_dldlL1, W\l.lIIH\ !Wl Hol1W pholW o!lIlH, Th!lI'H !l11O\l11\", Q, Plllllond!l Mool'll 01'\11' H\lCYO\l 01' mllko II ollllm In !In)' lII\1p11l11 !lnlll' )'o\ll\ln 1\ !II FOI'\1oHChovrolot? ^, Nil, '1:1\0)' nol'Ol' "\1011 \lH 01' !lnYlhltm IIko tlml, 110, " Q, ~illLhll'LILlIUY-ill\UllO 1111 I [JfililllUllUU:llliUl.Lut1l1u~hiu.-hill " 11111..'Llililc1o Ihol'o 1lI1 Ul'-IIhu.uL!Y1nxJ~'1 ^, No, " " , Q, D\1\IH YO\\I'wll'll'l " '." 1', ^, Nlll \hllll know, Wxhlbll "(\" 10 IhlH Mollo!l, dopoHl\lon 01' Ooml[1 Ollhort, III 21-22" Ihlos 12-25 IIl1d 1-5), mmphllillH nddo\l), . II, PllllnlllTlMnld ClIl\1cl'lnlHo rOHpondod 10 Honw l\lIoHtlllnH oonool'l1ll1g'lho C01l1plnlni, IIH thllnWHI Q, l.ol mo 1\ 1 1"0 II I yn\1l' nl\ol1l1oll Illlho Cnlllll\nlll\ whloh IHIH \10011 llIod III IhlH CIIHO", Did )'011 01'01' Hlgll IhlH plll'lhJ\lh\l' , I\oomllolll whloh t'll\ nnw Hhowlng )'0\1, tho Cllll1pllll\1\ " IIHolI'l ^, I dllll'11'01l1c1I1\1ol', I dnll't 1'001111. Q, Do )'nlll'o1l101l1hor 01'01' Hoolllg II holhro II \VIIH I1ll1d" .J. t ;l , :I II Ii 6 7 P D t(l 11 12 13 14 Hi 16 l7 10 , " l!l 2ll ,.1, 21 ;l;l , 23 24 2ti ,-------...........-. ---~-------_.--:'.. 2\ 1\ Q 1\ Q Wl\~ ol\HpII I:p l1ondl\? 1\ Q I'm no~ ~p~nl1Y ~~rp, no, , \~hn r~oYP\1 \:hl1111 \:hoy lIto'l l' nnll'l. r"W\~Ql: 1;1\/11: 110011\\f.10 I'm nol: I:ol:/\,lly H\llm, OkAY, po YOII kno\~ whol:hol: nn Arljllal;monl; (Hll11pnny , ~o oomo loa\( n~ ~ho vohlolO hpforo l~ wn. ~n\(on No, I\H dghl:, [:10 yolI dOll'kl~now whAt offor.l:a wo:r.q' mi\flp (.\~ FOFI10H ChpVl:olq\: (.\ft;PF YOIl 10ft: \:ha vohia,la \:har.o 1:0 hnvo 'Hond/1 pi ok l~ np? l\ No, Q !'low, 101. mo /'HIk Y~\l \;hh, Ml:, GUIJer.t, /lnel; yOIl ler.~ ther.e on ~he d/1Y in qlloa~lon, May 13th, with this now 1'.1:1l0\( All(j,lof.\: thellondi1 !\Goard' there ,/1nd after the l~naa " PI\~ll1FJntl'l wer.e paid of,f, hoW have YOll allffer.od finonaiAUy ae a reanltof leaVing tho vehiole ther~? 1\ We reAlly didn't.,. Wejuat got 1301\10 a./.\lll3' " ,,' '1'hnt'l3 All APout H, , , Q 1\11 r.1ght, , I\n(\ the oAlla OllmO fr.om c11Cfo,~'ent ngenc.t.ql.l? Ii' , 1\ Yes, Q Pldltondll 1\caol:d ever. SUO you or. h\l.\ke A oll\il11 ~n " Any ~monnt after you left 1t "1: Forbes CheVt'ulGt? 1\ No I '1'hey never slle(( us or. /lllyth1ng like that I ' , 1\0. I I!)(HIPIT ~ --~-------.~--.- 22 Q Do yon hAVP Any finAnnlAI losses As A ra"\I1~ of hllV11)l)111l'\:' \:hfl vahiola \:horopn or 1'11)0\1\: MAY 13\:11'1' ^ Q 1\ Q AllY WAY? 1\ Q No, 00013 'yeJIl!' wi fa'l Not: \:hA\; 1..~nO\1, Po YOII know If YOln: oracl.t'\; rl'1\:,I,ng WAil Affoo~ac1 in For ~0hllo, yeAh, au I: Ulll\; o1'ecl.l\; 1'Al:1119 Wh,lah' nll'1Y hAve he en IlffeClieel for Awh.lle"hAs now heel1 oleAr.eel Up? 1\ Yell, ~ Let me ell1'ec~ Your A~~ention to the compilllnt whiah hllB baen fileet in ~hiB aaBe, Let me ahow yon the Complaint Whiah hAB been filed Al)cl reoeived by ForbeB Chevrolel: , " Diel Y9\1 eyer Ilign ~h.lB PArt.lbular document Wh.lah, I'm now Bhow.lng yo~, the Complaint itBelf? A I don't, remember, I don't recall, I Q Do you remembe~ even Beelllg it before i~ WAs f1lect ? 1\ No, Q, All right, U~related to A Can I talk to my attorney t1 second'l Ie that all r.lght? Mil, COB'l'OPOULOI:lI Absolu tely I' -_.~_._.---_....-.~~.._-~_... 211 ~ 1\ No, 2 Q'Thera WAa no~h!l1g SA1~ A~O\l~ porboa roaalVlna nny 3 monlilY for leAVing ~he CAr. thora fOI: hoWnVlll'lnngl,l: wna 4 going ~o be~har.e? 5 ANa, 6 'Q 1\\1 L".\.gh\:, f\ncl YOII am:t,nl.n.1y'dl[II1'\: PIlY \;lwm 7 l\ny\:h1ng \,.() leAve H: thol:e'! B 9 10 ^ Q A . No. or. \:0 ~)adonl\ \;)).I.\.1'! No, rr))ey soI.c\ 1 ~ \~IIH 1\ 1111111:\:ntly, 'I'hny WOlllel 11 tnke'!t liP, 12 13 14 15 16 17 10 Q So ~hlawt\a /.I, COIlr.toIlY IJIHJtur.n Oil \:h01r. pnl~'V! 1\ Yea, Q Po you know whether. Ilonlll\ WIHI no\;.!.f lotI Imel J.f. YOII don't, ~ou don't -- to comb pick tho vohlclo lip? 1\ f heArd, Y~Ah, thllt theY wore, rorbeH,cAlled t))em And told them to pick it liP, When,ctic\ you lenrn thllt? couple days after, How did you lonrl1 thllt? '!'hrough mywUa, If YOII kl)oW t IIn YOII know how yCllll: w.\.f.elet\l;ne~\ I. 19 Q 1\ Q 1\ Q thHt'/ 1\ Q 1 ~ll1ljlllJ uhn Ilot 1\ 11/11..1, 1'\1) 110\; sure,' \)0 YOIl Ilnl1wWho cl:nwf~l.lr.d I\nll Company ls'/ 20 2t 22 23 24 25 ___~~~.., c_ri ..,'~ H"~._'CO __00_' 'po. ._._.~_c,.. mn_+-" ..~-.....~. " " , ____._.,.,.-._..._...,....._....~.....".r.."'_h..___"~__..,,. Ii 1 No, fI 9 fI p.l.rln' \: pny Clllflh 1:0 IlIlYIHllly'" 2 3 No, 4 Mil, C:OS'I'OI'O\JI,OH I I hllvn 110 1'111.'ld\ol' 1111011 1.\ 01111, 5 MS, SICll,lflNoI IInll'l. hllVn IIIlY'IIlI\lIl\~lp"lI 6 (3 .t\: h 1'.11: ! 7 Mil ,COS'l'Ol'OU1,Olll 'I'hllllk \,1111, \'/11' I'll dOllo I o ('rho rlopCJIIII~ lOll nOlln I IIcI(J11 II I: 11,.1 '.\ II ,Ill, ) 9 ).0 11 12 13 14 " " 15 ,. 16 IIi ,. 17 II 10 ,. "l' 19 20 21 2;1 23 J, 24 25 , " . _~~__.~~..............."'__.r_....r.....~-.+--+..+_..,~_______~__________~___.~ ,IICHHY ml,mCln' 11I,,1 INNNM em,mCWI', 411 Tllny (;h'plp ICnll"" I'A 17l'~~, IN TIlN CfHJHT OF (~()I\1M()N "I,I~i\I'i CIJMIIICHl,/\NIl COIJNTY, "ICNNliYI,v I\N!i\ I1lllln1lft'H Nil, !lH.fHHM:I\'1I Tpl'll1 \" jlonHlCIi cllfCVlml<WI" INe, MUll lInl'lzlIlIlp l>1'1\'P CIlIIlI1 lilli, M 17(1l1-72~(" , I)pt'pl\llnnl CIVil, I\CTION - 1.1\ W . " Cllil'I'll1ICA'I'1C 011 HKUYlCE This Is In ccrtlfy Ihlll I, Ami I" CllJlhnugh, II pIIl'lllognllol' IlIw ol'lloos ofCnslnpnlllos, Fostcl' 8<- FIlJllls, hnYIJ this dny sorvud n InllJ IIlld COITIJ~1 cnp)' nl' IhlJ fhl'lJgnlllg, "polomllll1l's Mollol1 I'UI' HlIl11l1llll'Y ,hldgl11lJI1I," 1111 IhlJ hlJlnW.l1nl1ll.1d Il1dlvl(11I1I1111 thlJ 1111111111.11' 111(lIcnllJd I'I'Plll LlJll1nYIlIJ, POI1I1Hylynl1ln: VnltclllitntJlJLll1llll. Fll'st.CltlSH.IIOHIIIUlLl!.ti!lullil IllJlllhc\' I'HIJII1, Esqulro KIMMIIl, & sltVm~Mt\N, P,C, 30 Hnsl nulllJ\, plko . Amhler, PlJl1nsylvlIl1ln 19002 Dnlcdl It' J.l ,.:?,., ;~Cl()() , . , ~.., iil ,II. , ' \" " oont:dnsd h13l:s~n, t:lIjdl1 nl~'Jgi1tionn fl.r13 npsc!fionlly dspi.oc\ "pel fJtdd\: pl:OP~ t.l1srool: i.p damnndeq ql: t.ha \:J.ms of: l:d.C\l, 341 peni.sd, The nll.egntJ.opo of: thJ.p pC\rngraph o6n~t~tute C\ oonolnoi.qn of fnot and/or law to whJ.oh no reoponsive plsac\ipg io reqllJ.r~,q, I!owsver nnel to t.hs s~tenl: thers <Ire ClIW c\l,ls,9C\\:ioI1l3 ClOnt.nJ.nec\ hers:\.n, ol\dh C\l.l.egntionn <11'13 J3Psci.f:J.onlly deni.eLi nnc1 strJ.ot proof t.hsreof i.o c\ell1al1c\ec\ nt. the tJ.me oftrinl, WHElRElrORlil, plE1intlff reopeotfullY c\emnnc\1'l j\.\elgment ngninat Defenc\ant i.n <In nmount equnl to the contraot pdoe of tl1e 1311\;lj eat vahi.ole, Pllll3 'i'.lll collntsrnl ohnrgel3 cmc\ Clt:t01'nsy feel3, j'lo" ~~~m~ & ~XHVm~, p,a, BYI c;'J\x~1(\i\9 ' ElRI~ M; SICILIANO, lilsqllJ.rs Attorney for Plainti.ff 30 Elast. Bntler Pike l\mblsr, Pennsylvani.n 19002 (215) 540-0000 . , " . .I' " Ii ,; ". ". " 1\ ,. , . " ,. , \\ 5, . l)qnlql\, POI~111\nn\ Is wl\lw\I\ slll'I1clol1\ Inl\lnnll\lpl1 \0 1\l\'1l1 n \l~\Iol'ns 10 tho \\'lI\h nl' IIwlI\lpgn\(on clll1lnlllOd 1\\ pnl'lml'llph ? Ill'llllllnllnil' C01l1plnln\ 1I11l1., IIq\l\lnllngl~, dllnlqll IIw Snnw, l'l\l'lel proo!' Is 111'\111\11\11l\ln\ limo nl'\rlnl, 13~wn~ Ill' , 1\\r\\wl' nl1sWlll', whllq nn~ 111l11o\ln\lons wllh AnWl'lenn i'1ondll\ilnn11lllJwlll'c \wIWIJIJI1 Illnll1t1fl'lllll1ll Al1wl'lllnn llol11ln, II lil llIl\l'lIo \Im\ PhllnlllTsl1l.1go\lntlHlnl1 onl'l~ 10llsp \~nnhlnll\ln wllh HlllHh\, 1l1sl01lll, IIIP pnynwntlll'l.1\11nll1lng on \ho lenso \\'01'0 pn\d, II\\1nl'\, wl\h 1\1I1111l\11111Io nvnl\nblu b~ tho 1'0blltu on IIw I\\lW clwvl'olcl PI\l'OIHISqd lit Pof~ndl\n\'s dqnlol'llhlp (1100 El'ihl\ll\ "IV' to Plnlnllff\i' CO\11pl"ln!), 6, Adl11lttqd In pnrt 1I11l10llnlcd In pnl'l, 1\ Is dCl1lod \hnt \hol'o \Vns I\ny nogotln\lon Involvollln IIpplyll1B n portion ~\'thlJ rcbl\\1J \0 \holll11o\lI1ls l'emnlnh1B nnpnld " on \he Allwl'hinlll-lol1dn Fllllll1Ce LOIlSIJ, Tho re\11nllldol' n\,Plnlllllrt\,'\IVIJI'l1lOl1\ III pnl't\gl'lIph 6 Illlllhnl\\od, liS wcl\ liS tho 1'0pl'oscI11nllol1 sot 1'01'Ih n\ nxhlbll"13" \0 /I Plnln\\ITs' Col11plllllll. . , 7, DCl11cd, 1\ Is splJeln~nl\Y dOl1lod Ihnl Dolcl1Unll\ dCl1lcl'shlp hnd lI11y Il1volvo\1l011\ In Iho I'c\\Il'i\ of Iho 1995 11ol1dn Aeool'd 10 Anwrlcnll Hol1dn Flnlmcc, . Rn\I\UI', Dolcndnlll pOl'l11ll1ed Plllll1\lff\i \0 IOllvo Iho vuhlcle 011 lIs' pl'emllle\~ SD \Iw\ AllIol'lenll HDlldll could rlJll'lovo ltR vchlolo, Dclblldnl1\'R scrvnl1l \cl~phollcd Al11ol'lcnll HOlltln to nuvlso \hnt eompnny Ihnt Its vehicle wns olllhc pl'cllllscs. Dol'olltlnl1\ dltlllD\ jt recolvo llORSOSRloll 01' Iho suh.locl vohlelc III 0\'(101' to rcturn II to Amcl'lclll1 Hotidll, " ' ,. r i , ~!l l YJllillilCA'tJ{'.~. Iill~lncl\llnn 10 lI11thnrlticsl " .' e) 'J ' , .~ 1.//, ' /, ~. / I?', ".., I' i " I .-' /.1/ t',:.l4(.l ,,;I,~ ThOl1lllS Prlost II DIIledt Oclnbel' 15, 199!l " " , , .. " , " .\1 " ~~M1'fIl1lt ~ ~UVJi1Rl1M p~n;p~~~ ~, ~~ft"V~;q, ~p~;'rp ~RPn~~~ipA~~pn Np, a~4~~ ~p ~, ~"~~~r ~~~~ ~mp~pp, V~ 1900~ (~;l.PI P4P....aaaa P'ifIIll\l\y,~;t:H~!ll"'W Am~ ' lt~~!ll~ ca:tIt~!llRW ,. ~~~prnpY~Qr ~~A~n~i~~~ tN WP!ll COURT o~ qo~oN p~!ll~a O~ OUHa!lll\~~NP QO~\I!1 , . I 1 , I 1 O~V~lt ~oWtON""~W v, Np, "IHI"'a40~""oh;l,~, Tarm 'OR~!lla OH!llVROlt!llW, tNO, PLAINTtFFP' ANSWUR.TO P!llF!llNPANTIS MaTtON FOR a'~ARY JUOGM!llNT , ' ,-' Plall1t1ffs, by Anel through the11: counsel, 1~1m,ne.l and S1lyer.mAO, P,C" hereby r.cisponds to the Motlol1 for. SUmmAry J"d~ment and stAtes as tollowsI 01. TIcImHt:eel,1n pa1:t, den1ed :i.n PA1:t, ,It 1s den.t.ed thAt .1i'odJes ,"p(HmHtec\" the: GU.borts I lea!3ed Ilonda . veh1cle' t~o' be parKed on.1\:s lot unUl it could 'be l:Btdeved );,y Honda, Hat,IWJ:, lJefel1d<1nt I S s<11eSm<1l1, M101H\el H<1r.r.l.s, tolel tho GHber.t/3 th<1t on the day they \1er.e to lease .<1 vehicle from Defend<1nt, they' shoul~I.' ,leave the Honda at. IPor.bes' and someone from 1i'0J:!JOS would ddve it , J. , , dO\1n to Bobby HQh<11 Honda, wh1ch 18 located nearby, on the sC1l1\e" d<1Y, " IIper.mit. tho GJ.lbert.s I Honda leased, \'eh1cle totemain on the " li'orbes10t, b~t r.ather. told them to leave 1t thcireand li'orbea " would drive it to Dobby Rah<11 Honda. q " ~, \)11niod, Pli11n\:1Hn arB w1thont.IJllfflc.j.ent i.nf:orm'lt10n ,. to f:onn iI l)o.U.(~ (:, r :J , ponied, Plr11ntU'f!lare w.1\:110n\: suf:f:lci.ent .l:nforll\At,ton to f:orm a bolief, 6, Ponied, '\'hill ill i\ logill oonolusion requir.t.ng no Feponlls, 7 , I\c\lni t tad, o , Adm.1.\: tad ," 9 . I\dmi t \:,ad , 10, . Denied, Whether the Ilt:C\\:ell\onl:f.l amO\\nt to 'In adml!'1f.llon 1!'1 <l legal ooncluslon requIring no ~eIlPons~, 11, De'n.l,ed, 'I'his Is a 1e<Jal oonolusion req\\i1:1l1g' no. reponse, ; (' 12, Den1ed, Ploll1t1f:f:.13 are suing on beh~lf: of: the1r. 111suranoo oompal1Y, StaboWnrll1 Mutna1 l\utomobl1e InSUrance company (IIState Farxn'U, 1n .'1' /Jubrqgat.i.on 01a1m, (3\:ato IfiHm was c\ni1\agec:\ ;, " 1n the all1o\\nt of: $11,315,40. (ffiKhlb1t 111\" \:0 this I\nswer to pef:endal1~IS Motlonl Proof.of Subl:ogatlon) , .' (ffiKh1bl t "1311 to .thls I\nsWer to Pefendant' B MotiQnl l'robf: of" State Fi\rm's dlsbUI:semonl:s as i\ rosult of the \:heft of tho said I, vehiCle) , (INhibit "c to thls I\llswer to pofendant's Motlol1i 1\ trMo and oorreot ~opy of: Plalntlf:fls Complaint ill tho instant oaile). ,\ ., . " ',' ,. ,/ \i i l~t:!I. 1,1,1 ::\:; U ~ ~. 'I, " " ,i " ,,)' j, Ii! " '\\ ,,' " " " " 'L " ,. .'1 " " ,. Ii '1' i' ,. H " "'I 'I' ". " '-t, oj t \ " .-, H " ;I' ,. ": ..' " 'I ,. "j'O " ,. ;{f., "i,,. " " " d' .I; " " " "I, " " "" H , , " I ~. ~ u ~ ~~ ~I I' !i " I"~ " ,. l; " ,}' ;; ., q, Ii " .' " Ii I~ ., " .1., , ' ',,'I, ", ", " ," .j; " ,,' " 'll ,Iw. 'w. (Pi "j:j rJ'l~ " ~~ ;il, Ii 'I, " " " ('.:l' '~ " " ,.' " d ,j " 'I H >H' lJ ,. " , " , ! " ., , , ;I' , " " H, 1;11 " " 'f, 1I " " " ,,' ,.' " " If " .. !'/l1 )! ,. -.['. I, ',' oj ., J; " " j\l " " "~"~ i. " ;I I! " .,'. '.1 Rp~~~p ". ~t+V~~ijnL ~RqH:l.r~ 'Xaonpi~t~"~ipR "PI ~q9t~ ~XHK~~ ~ ~,X~~~N, P.P, ~Q ~""~ ~"~~pr V+~p ~!lb:l."QJ:L VQImQ)(+Vlll'ltP,. ~,9PQ!l Illta) , 111!:hIIlHlll . ~~~P~l'l~:y ~PF p:l.l\;t.l'I~iftf1 . U~I~ I~ ~" ~~~WIQ" ftll\.'+"!'~ll. A~~~f.l~HWW!' OF P~MAQ~~ ~X"~ rf.l n~Qn~f.lW~p, ' ----~_.. V. . , , , I I I I , , I I apPnW ov ap~ON P~~Af.l aq~~n~~ QO~ ~~y Qt~~~nw Al'lH J1nilfflll. ' QXMmR'J.' 4Q Wpn~r q~,po:l.Q ~l'IP+AI VA +7Q!l~ QWIfj ~OWXOtf NP. erf. ,~-~I J~~' {!,~~~~? r~..~ .,!!; r~ q ,1 '" ,\1 . ,ll i'; ~'/._I -"1 II" ~ .';,'." ('..1 . '(ll ,:.\ ;;' f.u "I ~I: I , \.i C ,) I~"J .~.. : 11." i" :,:!:'; h: \ 'i::J " "I to.. . ,f ( ) YOII llIlY" boal) UUat\ il) 00\1...\\ I IC yOIl willh t:o t\afaol1 IIUllinll~ \:110 olduili 1I11,~] l'..1//1 fo...~ I ~ I:lIa fOllowinu PIII/aul YOII 11\\IU~ I: II I\. a 1I0Uiol) wit:llin ~Wanl:y (~Ul'J t\1IY.f\ ,'..-. lIfbllt' \: li/1 OOI11~lllin\: IInt\ nO\: Cll I\t'a IlQl,'Vlltl1 by an~adnll II Wd\:l:lln IIPpall"'lI/\<la ?J PIlt'Qol)1l ly 0'" Y 1I~~Ot'nay lI1)tI fil:lnu in w... ~inl/ whh ~l1a Call1.'1: YOII t\afanllaa o~ 0111ac\:iol'1I ~o 1111 oldl1\a Qa\: fot'~11 alJllinll~ YOII, YOII lIt'a WIIl.'nat\ ~hllu if yolI ,h,U \!o tip ao t.ha cllua mllY pt'ocalltl wi\:hollll YOII !Inti II j"t\gmanl: mllY bll ant:QI,'oc\ "udnll\! you b:{ bhl' OO\\I,'U wHhout f.""'llha... nollica fat' "llY monay clllimlltl in Illla comphint: 0'" ~o... lin\' o\:ha... cl.Aim 0'" ",aUof t'Oqullll\:otl 1\, ~ha plAiIlt:if1!, You llllly 10110 monoy or pt'opa~l:y o~ oUlIat' t';i.ghUu iml?o~l:llnl: t:o you, . . YOU nllOtffitl '1'l\ltIl '1'IlIn VAl'RI\ Iro YOUR I.MIYRl\ 1\'1.' Oti'CR, III YOU DO !f0'1' m\~ 1\ I.l\wYnn 01\ Cl\'lIliO'1' Ml1ono Omll, GO ,'1'0 01\ '1'RI.Rl'1l01Ot 'l'I11\ 01,'I1;1:0R 'Illl'l' 1'01\'1'11 lIRr.Otf 'rO I1Iti'O om: !ffIRnle YOll OM' GIlT I,UG4Il 111\1'.1', oulmllllLlUlll POUlf1'Y Ill\ll MIlOCIM!J:oti' I.l\WYUI\ Iml'lIR\tlUt l\II'D III'110\\MA'1'tOIl' /lIlI\VICR :\ r.IIlRl\'1'1r l\VltII'U1l CAlU,IIlI.I\, 1'1\ 17013 '1'Rr.UPllol!1e, 717-249-0371 FOan~f.l ~OJ1~T, INO, ~4PO HArb~Q~~e nr~v~ Q~"~ ~;t.~~1 V~ 170:l.i~7~30 NO'1'ICU TOOU~ A'lIflll ! ;c " r.o' han t\amant\lIt1o II ual:atl an 111 oo...l:a, /li Uuulld quht'o t\aCantlarllo t\a oal:llfl t\1l lluUall damantlaa aXPullllulIU an lllu Pllainllll,Qigni,anUoQ, "Q~ot\ l:illnayo,inI:O (aD) tliIIQ cIa plaoo III pat'l::tt' t\a ill facha tlo 111 l1al1\andl\ 'I ill l\qHfiol\c an, \ll\dQ' fal.1:1\ aQllnl:l\t' una COl1\pl\t'llncia aoc...iUI\ 0 all PQ!;'llolllI 0 000. un I'bogll, do Y 'on 1:... a, gllr a h 00...l:1l lln forl1l!l Doodl:a Qua .'t\afenpoll 0 QUO opjaciol)oa II 11la t\lll1\lIntlllll an contt'1I da IlU pal.'Qonal '/loll IlViallt\o qlla IIi "OUlltI no Qa defiandll, la'<lo...ua l:0l1\1\t'1l mBdida~ Y, pUQua cont:inlta... 111 't\pl1\lll\da on con I: t'1\, OU, YII Oill pt'avio I\Vh,o 0 "noUifioao:lon, 1It\llmnlll 1a c'1l.'l:a puat\1l t\acit\it' a favot' dill dOmlll1dl\l\t:a 'I ' l.'aqu, hra qua uot:ad, oump1a COli todllQ 11\0 pt'oviQionollda auUII dllml\,l1tll\' UIlUlld " puatla pordal.' tlil\Ilt'O b QUII ),iropht\adaQ u oUtt'OIl t\araoholl i\1lpo...l:anullll pan UIl\!at\,. r.r.lr/ll RIl'l.'A oRMl\ltOl\ 1\ Uti' l\nol1lUlo INIlUIlIl\TAM1tIfrR, III ti'O, 'I.'IRI!1C Anol1lUlo 0 III 11'0' '1'IKNU Rr. o:uml\o IlUI1ICIRN'l'U Oil Pl\GI\1\ 'I.'l\r. IlIlI\VIOIO, Vl\Yl\ llN l'lrRIlONl\ 0 LLMUC 1'blt 'I.'llr.lllrolto A LA OI1IOINl\ ~A OIRllOOION ale lUIOU1lIl"1'RA UIlCI\I'I.'A l\llAJO l'AlUI, AVllI\IGUA1l. DONDK 1111 PURllil CON/lRGUIR MIll'rIDIctA I.I\Gl\t.. . /lBRVIClo Oil RUI1IlRml'CIA r.RQAI. OUMUUllLl\I!1l COUlf1'Y liAR AIl/lOCIA'I.'IbN :\ r.IIIR1I'1'1r A Ie CARr.Illr.u VA 1 013 'I.' ij I ........ \, " I DAOKQROIDiP t. on pr ~bo"t M~f ~~, ~9P', p~Rin~if'~ wan~ ~o , pa'en~qn~l~ ~eR~ar~hip an~ ~papi~icq~~y naAq~iA~ad the pripa o~ a n~w ~p9a'qhavro~a~ ~.~O ~ip~"p, 6. P~Rin~iff~ ti~awi~e napo~iq~a~ ~ha efir~f ~eq~a , ~at'1Tlina,\;ion am\ ~l-\l;'n in' c~ \:hair 1996 l1on~a j\Clco:r.'d, Vehip~a " ~qen\:ifi~a\:ipn N~er 1I1QOP66~6~fI~667PO, A. \:r"e And corrao\: Popy of \:ha ~n~l-\renpe VeriCica\:ion/~ayoft InfPl;'ma\:ion ahea~ i~ a\:\:aoha~ haPa~o, made a PAr\: hereof and mar~~d m~hibi\: "A". 6, In addi~:l.on ~here\:o, 'lain~iC~a apecificql~Y negobiated with pefendan\l that; $674.76 of the Qanera:\. Mot,;or~ Oilah J:la,cl~ . .' , - . - , incenhive pei' "~ed ~o ray ~U Merica>> 110nda FinanoE!. .l\, ~rua and, correc\; c;1opy of the eXElcUtlel\ ahatemen\l ia attaohed !larElho, made a Parh hereof Iin~ l1\ar~ed m:x:hih:l.t; "Dlli " ' 7, On or apO"t May 1~, ~990, '~a,intiffe tl-\rned ovar poeeeaeion o~ the euhj~c\: 1996 "bnda Aocord to Defendant to be !:'e\:urned ho AllIElr,iaan Honda Finance :1.1'1, oonnection witlh I;he,., 6 !U' ly leaee 'hermination ae epeoiUoa11,y negot:iahed fpr inbhe eale hra,neAotion'. , B. hieo on or abouh t:hat eame dahe, Defendant contaabed Pla:l.nhillfa InIlUl:'/lnOe Agent: and :l.nshruohed hil" to l;'emOVe t:he :t1l96 1!onda A.tlool:'d from ,1dnl;:l.ffll' AUhomobile polioy ,~\Ild e.dcl hhe new . , 1990 OheVl:'olat /3-10 p:l.ol~up, JUI'lt: purohaf.led frompefelldanh. fu!ft mxhib:l.h It A" , 9. on or about May 14, 1990, Defencla,nh paid the bale.nae dUe An\e:l.';\'aan llondA V':l.nanoa fo:l.' hhe Dildy leaee hel;l1\:l.na\:!o!l. " A bl;Ue and aOl;reoh cOlJy of I1he"oheck and dheo!\: tltlub arEl e.hhatlhed I herehol l1\ada a pe.!:'t: hereof ancl mavkel\ IDith:l.bih IIdll, '" '..1, ~O, oR A~ A~04~ M~r ~a, 1.9U, ~lA~n~~~fp war~ oOn~Ao~p~ ~y ~"P ~ewa:t.' Mlal1 PA:!.;o"! ppPAr~lJ\~n~ And :\.n~CJr.maq qf \.:\~a ,tllf.l~t CJl! ,. ~llp ;1.99a !lonq~ .l\ooort\ from. t:ha lot: of Defanql\n~ip Pal\lPl1flhip /l\tq Wllra iRatr\.\o~eq \:0 re);lpr~ ~h!l~haf~ to ~ha:\.r :I.,mnn'/lnoa oarr~l'Ir, ~ \':r4P AR~ oorr!lo~ oopy of ~ha ~ower ~llen Polioa'papArtman~ tnoiqant R!lPor~ anq ~4fplemen~Al/aontih4A~ion I\ro At:~Aohet\ h!lra~o, mAt\a A par~ horaof Anq mAr~ad m~hib:\.~ ~p~, ;1.J., plAin\1iffp immet\;l.ately \:hera/lf\:er oon\:/lot:eq pefenq/lnt: , ~o :I.ntJ"i;t'l.1 lI,a \:0 t:.he flt:At:\.\a of the 1D9a !lonqa .!\poo:t.'q beimr ra~\.nmaq \:0 ~erioen !londl\' l~inl\noe \.mc\er ~lie al\rly \.ier.mination of . hila laefle an" wera el: \.:ha\.: t:ilJ\e inforrllec\ b~' Defanc\en\.:"'*I\t: the vehiole hac\ inqeec\ been .at:olen f~em DefendAnt'fl lot: pr;l.gr \.:0 Df.jfal,lql1nt re\;Ul,"I'ling \.:he vehiole be the !'-leAfiling Company! aoTnl'l' :I: RENNSYINAlttA UNFAIR TRADE PRAOTIQlW AND OONSmmR PROTEQTJ;.ONLl\.W l~, Plaintiff!l hereby inaerpora\.:f.l all faotaand allegatione " file'~, ferbh in hhie Oomplaint by referenoe ae if llulJ,V ee\.:, forth at length herein, plaint:ifeaare ~Pereone" afil definec\ b~ 73 P,P, 6~01- 13, ~ (2) , 14, ;l (~) , 15, i" Defendant: ie a ~Perfilon" ae defined by 73 p,S, 6~01- 'rhe I.'enne:ylvania Unfair 'l'rad.e Vraotioefl alld Oentlumer I.'roteotion Aot:, 73 I.',S, 6201-2(1), aefinee ~unfair or deoeptive aot:s or prrtobioes" to inolude, but: not limited bOI \.ihe following I .' ,., ," " l~, ,N~;l1~:l.~~P bl'lJ.ieY\3 f.\l'\A \lhl'll'e~ol'l'l,'AYt3r, ~hlil~ Pt3!jl'l~AI\\'l.~I!3 qomllHlt;l.n ~he PI\:\.O Ill'\!:\ pary;l.p.ing of \:110 Yt3jl;l.plo Y:l.pb~t3 !3l'\.i1.\ l'u:\.ee Anq ~o~u:\.I\\l:l.onp, W1i~RmVOR~, v:\.A.in~iffp rt3!3rap\lful:\.y pt3mAncl J"q~en~ AgAinp\l pe!jt3nQAnt. !jor opmpanpAt.Ory Qlilml\ge!3, ~reple dlilmAgt3e, IiItl:orlier ft3\3p, Poatpoll pu:l.~, Imd IiIl'\Y furl:her pel,te!j ap l:heC!:Jut'1: mfl.Y Qel3m, J \.\1'1 I: tmcl . p!,"9pt3r , aouWl.' ;tI COMMO~ LAH.PAILMENT " ~O, P:\.liIintif!jp hereby inoorpot'Al:e all feotp Ancl allaget.ion~ et31: forth :l.n ~hip Compla.in\: b~ refel'enoe ap if. fUlly eel: forth fl.t lam111h hat'ElhH ~l, Plaintif!je vehiole was turned oyer 110 Defal'\clen~ 4eAlel'ehip for rEltut'n to ~er:l.oen Honda F:l.nenoe unde!," the ee!,"ly leese he;qninabion es a l'e",ult of Plaintiffl'l' purohase oil a nl;lW 1~9a CheVt'o:\.et ~.10 piokup on May }3, 1~90, Defendant, wa!3 in pole roel3oadon oil ~j\e yehiole dut':\,ng t:hifJ period and the veh;l.ole wae stolen Ilrom Oefendanhtl'l lot: on oX' About MaY 26, 19aB, 'l'l, 1'\,mer.ioa.n .1l0nd'aFinanoe oontinuee to b~ll Vlnlnniffl'l for the subJeon vehiole although Plaintiffe turned the vehiole OVer no pefendant fol' return to the !teasing comrany at the I:ime of the ",ale tranl3aptibn for the new 199BqhevroletS-l0 Piokup, 'l3, pefendant, failed ho live Up to itA end of the baUmenl: and al;1 a re~ulh, plainniffa havo suffored grean dEUl\ag'e anCl injuriel3. .',: JIJN-3\'l- ~ 91'li'! ~fll tl4 , FHF!-l 1 717 7P~ 3a99 F,p3'1~, " 1..(JWlfR t\f-,/.,RN POf./ge IJRPAR'fMRN'! (N(.!(fJ(jN'f' HSNUfr Inchlpnt If/I!f. ~S': '712 . 1 WIl\.i"IJV~ M\j r,\lpnllllnl.----J1/OP J.ll>f.'I'~,,"-Dn.. (f1n'1p..JLJL~ . . ~~1'^~"_ . tf !:jPIlr,Pflul /'/'IJ"" . PijlcL-'''-'i,.!j;'l.q~, PI~\l'l1mPI 1:!q4 D~YI 7HlJ..,., . . CillI qil~~~.11L.~~ Prim UC~:_-:!~-P;.l"'~.cJ C!\1I1'ypcl . (,.,;,p' p ~ ..-\ ~("~'I/ t./rf,1 Ttf. Alu!i11! Yp~_ NIL~ In f'ru6ru~11I YUII.. NIl...$ Vhllllll'~ Rlllhllil YeN_l'/n....., hlUlqlln~ ~ll\lllQI (S"" 1I11"'>1\<l. l~lld"h~rnoF~; _ C:huc~ liclu rllr All\H!llllll\l NMHllvp (011 ~lI\lpIConl pllpcl ''f';q,.r -r:'Ula.t.Jb4 '1 Ai':!'>I" cl~~ r"~!,,,,,,.r~ MI.t (,1,11.-: \ '" (,. "l-J1l;!n.r (Tr\, "<1'aliun~a _tJMO",\.~\J' t~\C-~~"'t!""Y\la~\~~':,. h.',~~:r .t\..",,. I\I~~' n"., Jl'''''''rlo. rl.\:>lU~\.lt~-t:o..c,,~'a.. .t!'......t1(Ll.~~'1 ~".'!'" _~"I?' I.Nt,,~';l ~.L<!,';:t.~ ....J,Jr'l A." I~ .,.1I1~!m. \. "'1:c..u.7"'f'~'I~"'\\l,....~":f. ...."P.,,"'(I \\"..,,~!.>: '0"'I~W"b f""':'t II\~ _~""''''~0-1 5"'\;"16 ',""," !l'I.~ ?fl, '''~";.J:~.n l~.rJ.~ '0'/'_ f'/~(. 'tMc~ Ii'!. ,~ ~ ,..."'.'....'~I~.... . ..,--, I'lIffiqWlII"""" '. .;' Nom!; . . AllllruuH 1"'<<1," hI, ",,,, ~I"" RI~I t\ r~onc '" 11/'<!/~/(... -r.;;"",nt-J",,,-I la ,.JCJnt-.IA,.] '- 4..... ,.J)1:C\,I..(\i~ ..!-::..1..t!'_/.JdJ..., 1f,/1/-I3S.:J .ct:'J,"'~'" (.l.h"",,,-,,,\,& ,~~!'J:) U"/L\:t"~IIIA.. /.).(/., C!.,~r.>...&!L,Ao" .,.......$1- 9/D1-6b"~ -L!2;'.j-n.~.1! to, )/~11.'~'';, I!tJ'To I"'","'~ 1',lJ.;Jt2~ fV/t~~~;'''uJ..., (?, (..j I,"'" 1-3.-:1 <=I~Ji.5Ia? -1- ,. :-r( . l - - p:J/ --:Ir -tl:.~I~. 6"', 4~LI'.;ol'(I.'" /",'J'[, ~r'. c.!;(/. I -=~,d..., n. l~tli1-.; 5!...1.!!l.1_ :7;?"1-IZC Lf'o'i.Jt!.1I, 4. 6l"'l.J3.+t&r ",' ., ." ,. "__ :::!-IL/---, I' I( /)ml!dt..l\.1 II.";:',,, h''''~,<)I-\l (~I (,,0 L!.", .., ~.'1:0;. (','" .1~..Ip->'tAJ-f/,IL!!:I_I_I.floo. J08.M$" INVUI,Vf!M~,NTI ,1.j,m~rw~'11 .h'~Ulllf\l, \'/'Wiln<1l! J\IAf'Qrttrtt'hy, Q'Othet'1 Offiour Invalvndl Unl, '" 'n'ru llOltUll II --2:..-. L ' , -..2:... l ',11. PIRI' II,"; --L.J.j.!L, . "mynl . II~o.?. ~4A-.. C/pnf 'z.P~ IYn Rpt ..,L. Qflim:i ~aq8c 2.3 -....... ,-.., -.., SllptlfVli0I1.11 " Ii t -- Unlfllml llwl'Illluullun I~UplH1i Ocour! . Pnlu All --.1_1_ llelWtlunl:...J_) .,.. MmluROp<lnlndl: 1_",1' 1 . 1 1I11is MQllv~t1iill: lJlhlllu Rallglllll~ I~aallll. crlmc Saena Sllufchadl yuu~ No_ PI'IIlIH Takall: YUH_ Nt'_ PhlllUH '{'uken: YUH_ NI1_ Tlma Duy SolVahillty lllIClln, I, Wn$ thore n WIUle.I\.11 ..,'...", t ' j , , I , , , , . , , , , , , . I I . , . , . . , il " ,- t j., ,', . i , . , . I , , , , . ' , ' , , ' ; , . . , V 2, SURpcct Noma or Oll\m Pe.~crlrlhJn , , . " , , . " , , ' , . , . , . , . , , '. '. . , , , . , , . , , , . , , , . . , " , , , , , . . , . , , , " y 3, f<.nowlutJu~ of SUSp~l,:l ltocntlun, i , . . , ; , , ,. . . . , , , , I . , t ,-, , , , , . . . . , . , , , , . , . , , , . . , , , , I I , I ! I , . , , ' , '( 'I. DORclinllon Which Idal1l1Ulls Vehicle U,\o,1 by ~UHrcat , , , . , , , , , , , ' . , , ' , , . . , , ' , , . , , , , . , , , , , . , , , , , , ., Y 5. Lll1Il~~.! OpportUnity fur SUSpdct en CI)f1H1iil Crhnu '" , t , I I , t , , , ' r' ' . . . , , , , , , , , , , . , , f I , I , , , l I , , I , . \' 6, l-lmlled Number Qr .persolls ,\.I 1'0RRlhle SUR peets . . , . , , , , , , . , , , , , , , , , , , , . , , , , , , , , , , , , ,i , , ... , , , " ' , y 7, nullef Ihilt Cl1mn 0.111 bu RCRlllved with RallRIII1~blu InvcRllgallvll Erfon """"""'" I . , , , , , , , , . , , , . , y M, nullef lhllt a Majnr Crllnu CI\II bo I~usolvcd with. PllllllellY " . , , , . " . , " , , , , , , , , , , " , , . , . , , . , , , , " , , , y 9, I't\lsoncu IJf SlllnlflconlPhysluul EVidence to ID SIIRpacl .", , , , , , , , , , , . , " " . . , , ., , ' " ",'. , '. . , , , , . y 10, PI\lpcny II/llh Chllt1!uloriRtlas, Mllr~, Nlltnba~. Ihul COil be Trlload " , , , , . , , , . , , , , . , , , , , , " , . , , . , , , , , , Y II, l'oxitivr, t1 ~ ,," (.. tot " r1..1-... tlct:nc: Sl!llrch fnl' I'rills . ; f , I I I . . . I .' , ; , , . , , . . . , ; I ; , i . i . I . , . . , . , , .. y 1/ Of Orfu,,~e,~_ (I/or U . 11llknnWn) So^ulIl 1311118c #- IlndllU /I I noma NOT WiN" lu I1roHcculc II" P\.AINTIFP'B a>CHlalT b J UN-:.II~-' ~ \l\J~1 Il81fl', .1'1'\1'8 '?1'i' 'i'13f1 313aH rJ,~I;':" PJl!\"Q!1:~1 ~'~il","~"h4~~IIf11\ I ,_.:.:\.~~) " ' ~ ~,- ], .L_ ", ;.I --;- ..~ fl. _ ____---. ,a _.- .,7, - ---- aI' ---' ~1~1\1~IA Ir.H~pon, ,"'\"ml" C\~lIl', IH::Iuqf.~ NIII1,Crl'lll0nl, f.'!l,\u.pllllnnl CI"I~ll.ft, P'PCI11UOR "'~I, JI'C1F1,,<lII\ll!ll1t lJ'Unf.\II1~cdl a~eU\lll\lnlll ClUnrnn"" C~-:--' (~UU !:,udu nook I . l,lloollon lln8/0\1l)1 I c..':J !,18IHl~d . Wll"llwrl~1 j ....-. l'nmpl 0 IQ-Olloll, rtl'!'% f'll*- IJ.lJn~I' ((\,1\'''1, ~~nnw, 1"C\lllllly, C.C\.ar, U.Urlk, O-Qlhllfl V\\lw/lnflll ;;::;, . . lV-YI,w, Hnfn f~'lvc~, IHHiIR'''l. ~lHlon f1l1"111~\lI., lIu~'l\cp",\.\bl~) Yuhlglu In. fol (j)..1'I (lNJl. 0 PN\.. Y. ' I'Inl 1'111' IlOlllo, rllOQYU\ll!\, QI1I\1116."I\ or tPIYe") ...,. ell. VI Hllndboo~1 y @ pcc;p Vi~I\m1WII Formi & 1'1 Pom Relnl Ii'onn! '( (},V Hltt Slunnl\ poc:umu~p 13110, SI.""VllY 1\"~1 Y CD P.ufUrrucl PrpSllOllllonl Y Cj) Slntumnm/Confu8slolll Y.C!P !\rTusll. Y@ pqrthur (\{rustSl Y @ Summonsl 'taD WlI!T8nll' Ruu Full11l'1 UPI @N RUWlshmmcm 101_' Conftllunttnt\ '(aD .1orp,rJ"""~1 P'I~'IIV', ~..luv""lIft Otfcn,'ur, Q,fOI,n1Iol, f.lllv'nll. Chll~ ,\\llI..Q,Col11munllY lIol.doOl, r,r ',__ - " ,\, - ___ - ~. ~ I INvoINliP'PI1RSONSI (V.VIUIlIO, W.WlIlIOH, ~,SIIPIIO!1, ,h\oaUI.~, Q.OWII.r, or.op'\'lor,Il.II'~!1'4 nYI. (VICTIM TY"~II,lolllyl~U~I, n.n\I~lrl'!~, l'-flll'II,I.l'llIlIlllIlIo",P-OI1V'I11I11'"I, (\'~ftIl81nlll ol\1lnlL\\lnn, S'SO<lI'IYI1'I'~i1., Il,olh.r) . tf1Y\Jlv'm~nl/lYp"I-LtJ- OJ/Coum-1..... (I,DI 1I00frina, ~,PI ~ C:0j11\\Y CI, ),COIIIIIY CI, 4,t'lnll'l""""'ll Oolll'SLt!.!t/__ N~mlll (1.,"1. rllll, MI,ldl., SilO." Rill/A pop . ~p\'"''''"..I1 ~ .J:LLCJ..JJ.a. _1-':." !\qQr.s~1 (SI,~, St. t'hrna, r\pl,~. Clly, Shllu, Zlpl ' _ \0 ''':'''l.om.I",'''t> A- 1 ('f\"I,,\.tJ,,"V',."-\ ~'" PI-\,III ~.~,...t.I.;iu. (-nSJ'AI'IIC: II@U CUllAN: ctWu RESIDlli'l1'1 \l!llI U (Of \..I1IYer AlI.11 Tow I gl'l1ployur; (N",",It\lidf1lll) h.r.t(!-.ll"" (1..,"4~.,C;;"" b'ill!.Llj.MirzML:. r.(~ Qn....p U ,\.l ~'''''H..!l' \'H(,I:_-lM'~' I~ bll~IIlU~~ vlctim1 Y {[)TyPUI i\, . , . ' .. Work Hou[sl.r.'E'r''',' \ \--0'-' ST/oL.N:___' ,').../,- --'- SSNI_ COO mi." pully' I'@OII .. NOI.lj, -r1f(1r '"r~-W>!w~/...1 7;U~t!!J --1..- lJPn P '?O'.l Gllmpl~~:~ .-- ,,. -- ~-- .-- ,.-~-- lovolvllmllnt/TYPUI..ct:f"_ DIICoql~i._!L II ,PI ,;,"rin~, 1.PI ~ CmlnlY CI, ),CmHIlY c~ 4,Nnl N..4'~1 Clldesl oS '.......... NHmlll iI-lISt, fl!'l, Mhl~I., Sl\n .' . IV~/A ,OQa. ~rf."..-'!J>' c.:.~~I~lnJ't:r- . .... .---f'Jp_ -NfC" I\QQI~SSl(SI,~, !li, t'I!m~. Apl,H, City, SI'III, 7.lpl , \ I~"'--. . J~~\A(~:1'1,,~ll:!. Krl... ~~" 'f.l-tl. 'r-!_ noli rH#:_.3!el.'.c1:.Ql.J 1-1l51'1\NJC: lv.R:;u CUllAN: C ,R.J!SlPl!NTaJN U (at' LIlIYur Allan 1\Jwn HmplilYtir! INom_~J\Itcl!"lI .J 'Y!" . . ~.-- rt~l/i_--!.i.ti.- Is business vl~lImlY N TypUI , Work HilHI"i: I]. 5T/OLN:' .4' "ssN:~ \ Il1volv~I1111IlIf1'ypUI 't..l.J_ pJ/Ca\lrtl_..2... (I.DJ II'onn~, 1.()/ ~ C"Il\lly CI, ),Cul'nIY el, ~-NUII'/..-ed..1l Clldu~1 o'i/_____, Namel ILall, Plnl, Middl.. MI RlS/A pop .. IIp~t!.I'::. I "",':..I,.,r~~. ..!::!..Jc:1Jd:!:: --(- Addtau; ISI"". Sl. Norno, ,I~t.il. CilY, SI,Ilu, Zip I . . ~--9.D')- ~/,t,r.ll! ~i'.l J ('fU,-"'-IJ.\dm.d!LI-Iili..._I~ PHiI:_,~- ~iLn HISI'ANIC: HzR) U Ct:llAN: C$U MstDllNT: R<]l U (~f~oWetA lenTil" g",I)loy~tl (l'/.mol.ld,lr.'" ~..:..,~;. ('L"~. .J'",.,. ~ ~1YOt, 11"!l:T';]~\11 Lt., .Ix<- ,Os! , J 111.11/:__, ""~i ,,..,;........:....;. 1" llH~IIlUS5 vIctim? Y b lYIIU: I.. WlJlk Huutsi .:J/joo .. 1 ':>-Ill;. 5T/OLNI_' i.l,J/C,. IlSNI Coop~fnleq l1ull~ ~ " ~\JN-~\:l-l\-J\-JI~ 1'18'!1~1 PHFi1 ~ 'j'1'i' 'j'131'l 313fl9 p, ~\'l(!., 'I " rROP/lRTY Il'lrPRMrinQN n;"t:P/l1 ~-IlIPI~'h R'RQ~PV~f~tl, r-r"p~"tl, P'P~"~R~!\, ~t\.,,!l"f~ ~c~plnll) /I TYpe" . P~!.Flipl\\1n (M!l~~, M. Ptl~I.,~~r1~1 N~.m\>cr, t:!p\!'r, ~\.l.a, ~\.C,l I. ~ (/6 ;/fIAlAB-~"./!4.,...Ah~-J ~, 1......\ ' 'N ~~/u t'f!". ~, . \/'-'rL# 11Iq.c.,b.,..s6';).(p..1.I4/I.:If.i7;<~e;J '. , ), 4, 5, q, 7, ~, 9, 10, II. __ \~, -- 13, 14, __ _' \5,' __ TOlal V~lual J I z. '0 00 ,<M _ p--- - 'r---"1-'" \., - I, Total Dama\la~1 Co~nlY Inclrlant #1 rNVO\..VI1P P/lR~ON$; IY'Vlullm, W'W\IOI'-II, $,SUlpM, 1,.,\~Ju1.<J, q'Own'r, OI"O~~!"r,IHI.p<m.q ~Yl IVICl'11-1 'rY1'~II"n"IYI<JII~I, IhOlllln.", N\n~ncl~llnllllu!lnn, a.onyorom,n!. I\,R.IlQlnll1 O!i~nlf-\lIQII' $.socjoIYI]'ll\1l1n, Q,QII\.n InYQlyum~nlffyplll"J::d..J_ PIICo\lfll-k.... (I'PIII~nlll, ~,PI.t CIlUII!Y al,~,CllunIY c~ Hinl ticc:kq) C9<l~I""; 1;':"1, N~lIlal\t..'\lI, rh~t, Mhj<Jla, Sut) RlS/A , DO~ _' (}."'_.....~.,., a."r->I,... J f}', J CT:e. , -H./.Cl..../.llLa" 1 0"'1. Mdre~ql (S~II, S~ M~mc, 'V'I.I/, Cliy; SI.II, ~Ipl i1CJ -r.; . C, _" ""'-l z,<;; . Plittl_..lli. ""'2.0 HISPA ICI H~U' CUllt\l'I: C@ll ,R/lsIOElNTI , . Urnployur: l/'lulnwA~d",'~l~Li..i.bu.LU;J . PHf,lI_.~L-_ la b~atnou YIOllm? y,@.> Typcl_'. WOf~ t-\QUf1I\ U"'r...,. ST/OLNI.&..! .;104'18 "''''1 SSN:!! u.; ~, IOf LQwer Allen Townl ' Involvcmontffypel-.hL,I:__' PJ/Co'\nl.....k...., (I.Pllfulrlnv, 1.PI &: Onlll1\'1CI, ),CoIIl1IY CI, 4./'101 titc4t'll. Cfldoql~/_I. Nnme: (I.~I~ Plnl, Mld~I., SuI) . /1 . . !USIA .. POll c;:>:...f!-.4~T ') L"'~JN1~ (::!... _I.J..I..f..J.%i. , GIL/ l!luJ AQQf~'IIISI,N, SI, Nnme, ;\N,., cllv, SIIII, lip),. " . 40 '7S~'1 (T'<t.Jl,L~t.:..LeL,:-.~'C:-'" I,.ol-S PH#I_ ~ '917'<:' HISPANIC; H@,l,I CUllAN: C ~u REsIDaNTI R@U (Of LoWer 1\l\ulI Towns Bmpll)yor:(N~mcl,\d,h...,_ ,u >oJ PH#:_. U-tJ( ,,, blulnoss ylctlm'/ Y Typol . Work 1'loUt~: V'-'II.!.. ST/OLNIl:a:./-1.?l'::'i'1 ot.,~SSNI '(/...IIC, , CQ~peral~Q r~uliy6 -- ~ Coopctuled Ful~ (nYolyotnenl(1'ypol.......\L.IL DIICOIlrtl.....z...., II ,OIIl."I"!, ~,.DI &: CnoIlIVCI, ).CnllnIY CI, 4.1'1011'/0.<1<<1). Codes: 01/ 1.---1. Nama: ll..llI, Fhll, Middl., SUI)) ___ . ~y~ . ~~IlA f.}(I'U{llc.r'J,.J J.f~"'l:iff 1"'1 ""A/Lt.. ('M'..,I-.. ~ __ ,'~p. Atldrellllsl.#, SI, Nlmo"\I'L#, Clly, SIll<, ZlpI . . -.!.uli.~tlt!Ib.LI" 1\"" .":>'I,:bJ 11.t- .L2u::flg-r"J.J 11,11 .::r"L" loDonL/ . pHtt:~,~,t.!OC; IllSI'A~ICI Ii N U CUhAN: C 1'1 U RUSIDnN'r; /l. N lJ (O!, LOWd! ,\lIen TUWhi ~lllplll)t!r:\N,ll\IlIJl\~U'Q~"1 . . ;",,'!v1o .." " hUII4 ... _.,' .......J/~~...,_ tr "'lll'i"...t~ Ill.\I!...,1 I.('~ .,..,.....,. __..._ IVllrk Hllllt\: w}'\- ST/OLN:__I ..o',,~ SSNI w)f1,. C\lOntlrntud f\llly;(y , , (,.- . , . " " {:' , " 'I , , , r , , , " , , \ ] I, ~-, \ '1 " ;,1 " 1 II. 1 1 ~ r.,,1 :) l) (;~.I .() ., -; " h ,. " I' ,", f'" ,,' " !\" ;I; ;J , . " II.. " "i ... 1: I: ,. .' i! 1\ " I'. ,f ~I 'I J . . 'h " " _I' rH " j. .' ,. Ii ; t. , " .' ;,"1. " ", ,"j ~