Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05544 }. .~ ,,.\) ~ ~ , I' I" 'I' ;; ,j ,. .I' ,; , "t "- ; I II ~~ I :-/ 'I ~ ".' .. " cq. " \J " ~ " ~ ,~ ;1 I, :.. " .t !' ::v ' " 'l( q; " t:;:Q Ii If); 1\ .' II 1- u ,j' , ,- Ii l' j!' ',," " I' ;j, " I' " " ., I' H' iI, " " ii 11 'i-, '1, I' " ji " ,Ii ,,' ,," 'f I' " .. 1<' .. .I' I' H Ii i\ .. q Ii! " ,. " " " l' " " " ,- " 'i' " " ",', " , I;i' " " I; 'i I' .. ,.," , ,. ",: ,.. ;; ,."'i,i Ii " .i H' q ;; H ,il ,. i.', " . ~ I ,I ('I ~'I I d, " " " , ,. " " ,,- " ,..,. 'i; " " 7' ... '.~ -U I, ~I ~ ~ ~ ,()... j, 01' n ,',' I' ,i " H Ii I( i Ii Ii i' 'i ;, " ;'," I',' " ,i '", .. " I I ,I , I I' ,I: ,'IANIWI' 1l^J<I<I;J,iY1 : p(" t::, I: Jonn 1:'/ 111l'llIl'Ol! IN 'l'IIH: COlm'I'o\" coMMoN p[,mAS C!llMI:JIi:!U'ANI.l COtJN'I'Y, PJolNNSYINANlfl 1 I' I I I I I I NO, .) I' " j, l/I{ , ' v, I' C!TVll, flC!T10N , lil\\'I , , L', ,,/ I,' V ,"I 1.:i'Bl~i{'J'Y MtJ'I'l./AL, INSlJRANnI,i,J CliWlIP, Ropponcl011t: / 11lf.1llror m.U';rmL~QjLIll!It!L!J'Q..JIlIQ1'L.Qll.l1g!1LWliL'ffi!LR!l!f!~ONU!!INT H!iOUL!LNO'I' I-ll!!mJ;.T:.'!'.Q..JllmJJl!lrn:n!Il1lli.Q.!!LM9_'ffiR.:J;J.H!'_AR!U!!'lli\'1'1.QN Ill'll) NO\,!, oOIl\Op I:ho l'et::I.I:.l.onel', d'"llot: Bill'kloV.. by ilnl! 1:I11:ough her nnorneYfJ, ,Ang:l.no .& Havner, P,C: "idld t:BllpOClI:f'1I11y l:nqlloBt this ilol1oJ:ilblo COllrt to :If.l/JIIB n HIllo to Show C<n\IW wily l~efJl-)Qlldenl:, !.i:lbert:y Mlltl.\nl 1lWl11:anoe CJro1lp, sh0\11cl not:' 'fIllbln:!.\: il 01 ".i.I11'\:0 Undedns\lrc,r.l Motr;n':I.st Arb.i. tri1nOIl, avers t:he f:o11 ow.i.ng I III supporl: thm:eof', Petl.t:Lollel;, " 1, Pet:ltioner Jnret 13ark1ey :10, iln ildult :Lndiv.i.dual residing in 'Cm'U.sle, cumborland County, PenlwylvanJ'1, 21 !.d.bei:\:Y Mutual Jmlll1:'1nce Group ("1,Jb(u,ty") J8 iHI, .i.n81.\1:'1nOO CO\npnny l:l.cellfJod 1:0 do bUIJ.Lness In tfw COlmnonwo'11th of' ,Pel1lwy.lvilnJi\ w.Lth off:l.oes 'lOCli1l:ecl at~ 1/3 'Senu:y Park Wost, iJIt.i.te 261, Dluo 8ell, PonnBylvnllia 19422, .1, 011 May 19, 19%, M1:/1, Bm:kloy Was :I.n:jurod in i't. 1I\01:0r veh.i.olo '1oo.Ldont'.i.11 CEI1;Hsle, Cumborlill1t1 County,' Ponl1sylV'1I1:1.i'1, On that qE\\:o, Mrs, Bflrkley wow n '!ilI110c] Insurod on 11 ld.berty flutoll\obile i.I1f.IUr'1IW[! polIoy prov.i:dInH undorJI1FJUrod llIotod_st bOl1of'.i.tB, 1] 919" /1,lld !' " .' " '" " 6, 'J'hol.'onftm:, l.,:\,bert:y C!Onfll'ntud . \:0 tho " th:\ nl-pnrt:y i I ~- { I' '/\) I I , t.:: I! I, r~, r;, ' 'F" ( . I ,) ", I 1 'I, 'rho /3ul):)m:i: ilU\:Olilol):lln nccd,dunl: Wi\!l CJiUI(Jocl 1')\' 1:\10 IlfJ\,(L:lgDnco.of Morv1n I"~ I(uhn,' 1\t tho t::I,iIlD of 1:lw i1oddont,MI.', !<l\hn WiW \tnded,l1l11ll:orl, Ii, A t:!li nlnpiq'i:y ula:lll\ Wn/l i nLi-.:lill:url il<]nlllfJI: Mr, Kuhn \:hi1l: , W.1fJ ovonl:ui\lly f1ott:lml for Mr, !<uhn' /l :I lab.jl1l:Y polIcy l:lln1t:o, ,/lO\:t:lolilont nlld wnlvod .I trJ l3ubroSfatlon r:l\'lhto, '7, In n letl:'"]' dilted Mi.1I:ph 17, 19911, iltl:nullOc:l ,11(-)1\l\:O 1\13 Iil~\lipit: 1\., ['ol:.l..l::lonOl"13 (Jolin/JIll i\Clv1flod Mr, MJol1ilel 'l'ilLo1an t:hilt Pet:1tJonol.' ',wil13 ilppo':iIlI:JnU 1I1:\:orn',~y 'I':lmothy Hho:j.lonbm:'!Jf1l: nil tho PetItIoner' fJ Al.'bII:'nll:ol:, B, 'I'D ,?L1,1:e" L,ibm:l:y Mntunl h,w not reta1ned oOllnaf1~, or' appo1nted an arb:ltrator, WIIHI~nIFOlm, PoU. I; Jonm: ,Janol; Bill:ldoy rDflpf)ct fully rocj\_I~ll3tfJ t:his IlonOl:able Court 1:0' 1fwuo q Hule upon Rer~pondenl: to Show C'111130 Why, PetItIoner' I] undm:ll1sllrod lI1otor1/l1: 01'11m should not bo. Bl\bIl\11:ted 1;0 t\J:bItrilt:ion, I;hal: HO(jpondont: bo oompeU,(Jc1 1:0 seleol: fin AI:bII:'I:utor i1l1d I;hnt l/ospondont: pay Pot11:10IHH" (1 cOllnsel f:eeD and couts JIlOlIJ:l;ecl 1:0 draft nnd 1'110 th1fl Pot 1. U,O,ll, MIGlNO I< ROVNmR, p, C, ~\~""i.;-,,"qUi.r" J, D, 1I3!S<)56 ~503 N, Front: 8troot Ilill:r1nburq, PA 1'1110 ('71'1) :-l3Bn6'1'll Counflo1 for l:'ot:l1;10no1.'.. Datol Beptoliiliel.' 24, 1990 ($) !i ,- I . " p " Ii", I! 1'(! " " ,." 'i " !'I, Ii ,. If" " "'F ~ !! "- 'I ,; ,i" , , " 1',,1\ " " " 'j. ,';,': " .. " i ; ~ I', ',. "j. " i' " " .I' I . I' " 'I;' " " i,1 ;, " " ", " "" I! " " " " ", .. If-' lj " i' , ' " ", !' <; ,I; " " " " " Ii !I .. " I '.' m~III'IIM,Mlll,li,I.O TIIIIIIY N.IIYhW'l, PAVllll.. prr(. MIr.IIMII,11. KOSIK I'''MIII,^ 11, SIII/MM' 111\.11^1I\l ^, H^\lI.\lGK Angino, . .'Rovner ,,^V\lIII,WISJolIISKI tlllol,\II!,(lI"~nN MII!II^III, t, N^VIINliY. . lilSlll'IIM,POIlI^ \l1J,\JolIIS,II^lIlliGK l^h.lllS \lIGINT\ \.\SlIII1IN l11E 1111,1I1' LAWYHRS --~IN'-' AMIUUCA 1Iil'1I^11I1(!. ^IiClINfl NIIII,I,110VNlill MIl~..ah 1'7, 1990 " Mt,Miahae~ T~~oil\n Liberty Mutul\l Group "10aentry Pnrk Weat, ~lIite ~OO Blue Uell, PA 19422 Inaure~1 JC1net 13arkley I~i.le 1'10,1 1\1,030-040902-03 Pate of 1\ocic10l1t 1 5,~19"96 PeAr Mr, TA~oinnl HEll " Reoeipt of: YOl\r Marclh 13, 1990, f<\x tral1Smiapl,Qn. ill nclmow1edge~ C\nd please be mlviaeq thlll' we have f1PpO.i,l1t:ecl J\ttorney 'l'imothY I3ho1l811berger as arbitrator j;or Mt'a._ llark1ey, P1eaae hAve ooun\l81 appoint an arbitratoral1d hAV~ the Avpi\:ratol: conl:Act 1\ttot'ney Shallenberger so tha~ an E\l:tempt OEm be I11Ade to ~eleqt <\ chair, yout"S I PLLlm~g I' oc 'l'imothy Shollenbet'ger I Esquire I~ .1 "'( , " 'I" '\' " 1~3674/M'l'O " " 4000 NonTlI ~ll0NT 8Tn~'aT, IIAlintanUI1D, M 11110'1700 (717) ~3a.0701 . ~N< (717) &30,0010,. " , " " I. , I" , iI'! 'I, I'. , , , , , " !- " " I ,., ,. " .," " I, ", " ( , ", ..I' e \ 1:1 <', , ,';' " ',.......... '0: .') I Ii", 'J r\J .1': ( ,f:'I) l.l r' , , :1'1 , ~: :1 1,-,........ , :,)-, r~~1 '(II ".:1 t;'qj . ,. (~\. :(1 ,. ,1<.".1. r;i '.('J , .:.trl1 ,'J ., C'" " :1 ,z",,' .) '''-' ~~-'1 " ..~ ", ," ~.~ (~ , .-, ,... ,.....: ,I '\ j'd > ., ,. '\ I' ~ ~ ~, ',1.1 ",l.),1 c " , .. '....... ~', (\ " v~l ~" ~; '-\:;",~, ....... .... <.0-- ' " , ') ("';,,' " '-,',- IC' \ "'\ ' (. "~ , " I" , ~ .J~, " >- " ~'~ I/.~', Ji ~~ f ' r II; ,. " " ,. " " ,. " " , Ii' .. " kf " ~"'" -. ",,' .. " - , ,'ANWI' BARI~l"j:Y, Pal: 11: :LOl)el'/I1Hl\iJ:'ocl JN '1'10;: COIJW[' 01;' COMMON Pl,HJfI,';l CUMBiDRIIANP COlJN'l'Y, I'liINfIl,9YliV1\NIA v, CIVIIJ, AC'l'ION - I,AW NO, 90-li61~ CIVJIi ),1 BIilR'l'Y MlJ'l'UA1J IN8\'H1\Ncm (JI~OU l' , Re~lpol1d(JI11: I I IlfJ\Il'or 'AND NOW, ~ t:h.i~]' -f--- cjilY o:Ufj~-!_____, 199H, '1 1~\.11e ls I' hereby entered ilUi\:I\1E11: HefJpondent to Bhow ()aUfJe why t:he COl\l:t 'should nol: C\ppo:Lnt Dilll Al t::Li\nd, $t:evl'l li'eJnour, 0:1.-' ,9!:eve OJ:'oech81' '1fJ a clmJr of thJs '-\.1:b.itJ:ill:'.i.on pilne1 or, illtm:n'1t::1vely, the CO\.1rt, in .its disaret::lon, appoint i\ Chil:lr,' 1<1.110 ret:ql'l1<lble wlthJn ~ dclYfJ oJ: F.lm:v:Loe, BY 'l'lm COIJI~'l' I f),J": II " ';, .,.' " , " ;1 1-, " ~ , 'r' 'l\ '~l {~ " '", 11~. .. i iI'" t., 1;,: ,-tl , , 1>\1 , \; \ ~, I II , " " , " " ,.;'.rl d' I' I i " i' .. ,,' II j' " j', " ," t'; 'I', " H "," , f ,oil I' II' "l' " " "I' " " .. I'" d' " d' " " 'I, ;; ,.'; Ut' ,: t' " 'I t' ,. " I' " H ,,';. "i,' !; I, 'I' " io. " " !i " " I' " .. ;!' 'iI' I' .. " .. " .. .. '1 q. , 'l, 'Ii J' "t, .. Ii " ,; " " H I i I " , " ,j. " " ", ,)i " .. ;J " " , " :f" u .. ,'i ,- Ij- ,i "1\' Ij;' /: I' " " q Ii " I'., I." ~ " '(I " " ill " Ii, 1\ \:lrI1:d--p'-1I:\'.Y 01<111\\ Wi,lfI 1.nll.l'il\:nd i\~FIIl\lIt: Mr, 1(111111 l:hi,l\: WiW nvnptqlllly f1ot:\:lo(1 1'01' Mr, Kllhn' f11LI\)IU,ty i"Dl:Luy 1.1.ml\:p I " Ci, 'l'!1"ll:Ocl f:l:fl1:, l..iI)(JJ:ty OOllilunt:.od to Lho tll.1l'(j--Pilrty !JIJI:t:lol\1ept nwl Wid.vnrl Hr! fJ\lln'o\Jilt:IDn l'lgh\:n, ,/, In il 10tt01: rliltfld Mi\l:nh 1'1, 1ClfHl, <It:t:i\clwd h01:(11:0 CHI 1ll1lh.ipH f'" POI;ltlon8l:' FJ Clollnflol il(jv,ll]ml Mr, M:lClhao:l. 'J'C\I:oliln, 'I olnJ-1i1J:'eprl'H18ntf\I-,ive (:01' Id.borty Mqtl\cj]" t:hnl: Potit:Loner \'{AI3 ilppoint:inu !\tl:ornoy 'l'imothy ,Cjholl~l1beJ:'UDi: au tho 1'IJtl,t:ione.ri S ' Arl)ft: ri11:0J: , 0, 'l'horoaEteJ:, ld,}Xll:ty r~qtn<11 J:otninecl the f.lervices oj' I\tto1:l1fJY Mc1rkl~, I.,ovott, 9, :[1)''1 lotter da\:ecl OctoboJ: 707,1990, attaa110cl hereto CIS 1ll1lh.ipH B, ,PnUi:,:LolleJ:' S oOl\npel nuggofJted to I\ttorney r.,ovett \:11AI: e.i.th81: Dan I\ltland, S\:ovo l~eino1-\l:, or S\:eve Oreeoher be appo,i-,nted ml the ChC\l_v of' \:118 I\I:bitri:\t],ol1 Panel. 10, 'l'hen 11g'1il1,:l.n n le\:tor,\:o flttorney Lovett: dated (ljovember 9, 1990, <\tt'1CJl1ed l1e1:eto QS IUllhipit: 0, Petll:ionel:'f.l oounf.lol,agC\in '. slIggested Dan I\ltland, Steve li'o:lnouJ:, OJ: steve oreoohe~ as a Chair, H, PetitIoneJ:' f3 eJO\lllf3al 110nt iI third letteJ: to Attorney IJoV(~tt datecl (ljoVOlI\be1: 16, 19C18, c\ttAohed hereto af! Exhibit: P, again l'equeFJtil1g '1 reaponse to the s\lggel3t'3d F.lppo;lntlllent of, e:lt.hor Dan 1\1tl'lIld, SteVB IPe:lnour, or S\:eve Greedher'l ^ttc)rney" 'I.~OVt'ltt' s (ljoVelllber 19, 1990, respollse I.s '1ttc1ched as mlll~ibit: m,' 12, '1'0 dnte, oOllnne( for i:lberty Mutual lWI3 not I.dentl.f'letl 'In cUterllnt:lve Chn:lr or Agreed to Ollfl DE the three ilttorl1eys Hated, lj 2 , I WiI"Ii<"1!i'OIO;l,. Pill: it:JonOl: ,'Ji\ll0t: 1j'II'J~l(JY l'Ol1l)(wt: !'lIlly J:'O(jqlllli:p \:I'!JLI I-JOI1D!:i.1bln Caliri: I:p 1111,1110 i\ I~\llu IIpoll HUl'lpoQ(lt:1I1\: 1:0 i:J\'IOW (Ji\l\fJP Why )Ji\!\ Ali:lf1nd, .9i:UVD ["cd,I1O\U:', 0):' fjt:(}VI~ 'clppoJ ntorl <lfl C!lli\:l.l", 01:" III \:Dl'IIi1\:_t vely I d1!3crot: :1011 I i1Ppo.i.nt: II C!llid,l', CJ l'(wCJhnr IIholllrl nbt: IXl t:11i\t: \:110 COln"I:,.. :1.11 :1. \~ fl " ,HOtlpept: !'\llly fillbmHt:ocl, ANGINO & ROVNruH, P,C, ~' . (l~- ..-(;v. . i5a \il:cn~L\1 t:'~ ,-,!fpcji1Ti:O---' J,D; 1/35956 1][;03 N, 1;'J:on\:'Si:reet.' [!<In:lLlbqrg, PA 1.71.10 ('1:1.'1) ;:J30~G7Q1. CounLlel for 1'et::ltiol1e~ " I< I' DOlts I (~~Irnr " " " " " ",t " " " .. , " I'. " " ill , ~ i " ,,; " " ," 3 " " '" it 'i" I' "". " " " " " II " ,,' " " 1 " " '''i, " " " '" J!" H f!1 " ., 1\ , ' " (If) , , " " , ' ",I .," , ' " I;. 1- " Ii ,I; "., " d' !' ',' " .. " , " " " Ii t~ h II Ii . iJ, .. " I' H ,. ;'" IIi .. . , '/; " " " " " " , , ' , " ., 1'. !, " , ,I' , , , .. \, I' 'I' " .. , , " ., " !! " I: I' , , " , ' ',; " " j; " " . , ' " , .. " , ' " I' " I. 'I, ;. " " ", " Ii , - 1 I " I ,I ~ li: ~ ' ~I I." [' ,., ! , I I , ~ i I I I I ,- " ~ j, '" - " " ii' ,- " I-, " ;1' " ;( 11' ," .!' " ). ,f' " " " " .. " ",; ,. 1'., 1 :,' i " " ", ,- ii' !I /, '-,j ,I" }' " 'I d " " " 'j,'- Ii .1' ;'" " '(f) " " Hi' " " It I" I' '; " ,I " f' " .. .. " " /. " q' /' q " ,'; " ';0 " !i 11 ,-II .. i' " ,,-,'" " " " I ~ " ;If 111\ " " , ", , " \ " 01 , , , , " " " "" " " " " " " " " " It 11.' , I; I: 1,,\ .. " i " ~ -I' i I t' r , i , I L " " " (~ ) " " H , "'i , 'f, 'J '\." ij" " ,;- , " ,,' , " ,,); ~'~. ~~.: ~ k .{); .. " If,!, if! f h~:li' " ~ " ,', ~: 'i, ii' "l,Yll( ,Ill fI' " "', 'l~\': ~I "~"Jr\ "'. ' ! 'J' " -- '\ " " ;',"1' ,- " r .q I' ,. " ",i , :411\',',- " \1, i" , "I .. " ! " il " " ~ " " .. 'Ii , ,. .. , " , !( .. , " " I' I; Ii " " " il , " (I I' .. /i , " I'; " ,- " "I " I " " " I,. II. " " " 'I. ", , " ,;t. ",', " I 'j. ,I ,i /,-, , " " 1I " Ii I I " i: , \. " " " L." i; ,,- " ", n I I " , " I,; I: i, I ., (') 'I, " " I; Ii. ...." I; Ii " ," I " 'A, , '/ " I,i, .. Ij " ., " " j'l' ~~( " 1\ " ( ,. I' , I I. n , , .. , " Ii , " I " " " ~, I, " " " " .-" " OlllllPHll'lIPi a, 111'11>1:111111.1, m:Pllm: T, 1lIl\Jllllt\l:n IINOIlf.IV'I', ~\Jollllr.\.l-I IIl1ililY Ill, C, oll"M^N IVI".\II'~ O. Mcr.:llfI1Y A\.r.XANI>f.n 1I1:Nllf-nooN,'111 "our.nl M, I'rlANI\IIOlJ~'r.", In, T1loMlln IV, Ill:nnf.tl ',"01l1lf.1. IV, 11111110 MAIlI' BlIINI.':Y Mil" (f.I.I,OVt:TT ' BI~BIIN 101, 111I1?f.\. IIf.VIN M, F1U:NPII BTf.f'IIf.N fl. I,AWN JOBIIIJII 1>, cOIlf-N MAPf.I.YN 1', Nl~ IIIMI1,BMITt-1 BTllof.Y ~, MOIHJIIN [lO, !lYo, OPNNIIUl\IlTON , I'ATI1ICIII~, I)UN~r.VY Jf.fl'Ilf.Y Cl, OOBa JOliN II, MIITf.YAI\ tiARTMf\N l-lNPf.:Rli11+ ~, ~Rl-lt:lAKI'iR l-I-f' ATTPnNI:YQ AT I.AW (If II 1:1\1\1 (~\IPllNUl lHIHTI I.I\NGAIHFR, l'I:NNaYINANli'I l'lIlPIl'1l7Q!l t"/('/1 nlHI.'nJl1., "FAX I'll?' UUU::"lflCl li.MnUI I1IIVll{(\llllthlnW,(lUlll W"I'"111" \'1\'1\'/,1111111'1\,/"""" l111ooll"lImlll 1111I1kIQiJllllhllIW,Olll1l' (JOlltlPf.l. JOliN t. 1111111 MIIN, J[l, Illf.oponl: \.. i1!l\lIlAt<f.1l .J()OI:1' I II, 1II11?I'/N , Tlw IlnllOmhlp QPOl'gP n, Ilnnol C\ll11hpl'lnnd Cll\lIIty C\ll\l'\I1111l~ I CUl1rlhpll~O Sgllnrp ClIl'lI~I\l, PA 170 1)-;l3R7 pOPPI11\lIll' Ill, \!)~,~.,.. ,......,n~, ~ ~~ '~~ ' I ''',...,...,W"~ "":,,,,/"'-"{<:y 1/ ///' C( e .~ (Ml/c,~/, (,: ,/ /' ' 1'1.,)' ,,~PI ~~nlunllnsnrnl1oo(ll'Onp' /", , P'V:iJl Q'(l)~ . ,"- : ~! (). r\.. '(iV- .' \'7 ' "" , CLI DQ!l1' Illldgo Ilnffol'l ,. ,.", . '\ V' ' ' " ~,;' Q,,,mp,,' 9, '''', [ '"",',," Il" "1O'''~ '\~1I" "',,1101lhY )lUll In tho !lboV(l~, "J I. 1'01'01'0noo(\ Ollao, " "",.".." . ./ ' . , ' 'ct,> _\.,,~, ,...~.., , nm writing 10 Inlol'l11 you thllt ,I, Stophol1 Folnoul', n~q\lI;:~':"~~'li~~;;oloi;i~d'~;;ho ,. , nClltrlllnrblll'lI!ol' In this 111111101' OVOI' II wook !lgo, .' ... , , , j.' ,. COI1~oqllontlYI on hohlllf of '.Ibol't)' MlltllllllnsUl'l\1ioo Grollp,1 win not lio . rospondlng to Ihe Rlllo na thP11lflltol' l~ Inoot, B)' COllY of this letlor to Attorno)' Lutz, 111m 1'0ql1ostlng thnt ho oonl11'1n tho solootl(ih to )'011 nlao, 'l'hlll1k )'011 foli YOlll' oOl1sldcl'lItlol1 of Ihls lnultOt', Yory 11'111)' )'olll's, ' ~I?M r Murk H, LoV()!! MELlkl\l'IOII<17i~,()1 .. 001 Ms, Llslt ))colnqllo (w/ot1olosltl'o) Chllln No, AL830.048()02.03 Dnvld L, LIII"'" ENqulro (w/onolosllro) " " ,I, I' , \\ " , ' 'i' ,,' I ~ t, 1 " tl " j ," Iii \ ,) , - " ,. " ,j " C ".Il ':Ii' " " i ' " " "~I' tel i, If " 'i' " I ' q I. " "; ,. ., i1 " " , - II i' H, " " 'I " '1 ,. , " Hi II' I, ',j ".', '" ." ,. ,I ,. 'fi .. , ., " ,. " '" .<! 'i II ,1/ " " i; " ,f' " ,. " " j! I' " t : " ,,' " I,; i, , - ;,' I' ;,ili' 1'1' tl " .. " 1',' " ;; ~ . " ill J ~,