Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05545 .. " .. " " 'I; " " ,; I' ,,); I" " .:rMON IlMlIl14MiP, . l1~a~Il\:~f,f IN Tl!lll OOUIl~ 01)' OOMMoN l'H!Il~1l OUNPIllRHhND OPUN~Y, 1'1llNN~ I I I I. OIYIH M'l'ION " r,hW : NO, 1t', ,5 !j''1( , , ~URY TR~hH DIllMhNPlllD v, (I' ';J ,.-,1.--(..1..--(..'-._' .:rIilR\IlMY aUHH/ Of! f i3ll~blll t li.JL'l'.. I 0 III YOU fll\V!U I3liJmN aUliJD IN COUW1', If you Wif:lh to defend <\9<\ilWI~ the ,ol<\ilOa aat f:ol'th :In the follow~,ng p<\gef:l, you mUat tal~e Iwtion within twenty (ao) daya aftor thi~ complaint find Notioe are . f:le:ryed, I)y entering a wdtten appe<\rance pel'l3on<\lly Ol'PY att;ol'ney and f,Uing in wdting with the C()urt your dej:enaefJ or . obj eotionf:l to the olailOl3 aat fOl:th I\ga:lnf:lt YOll, You I\I:e warned that if you fail to do 130 the OafJe may proceed without you fInd a .. judgment may be entered agcd.nat you by the Court withol\t further not:t,ae for any moneY claimed in the Complaint or for any other ol<\im or re1:1ef requeated by the Pl<\intifif, You may 10f:le l110ney 01: propel'ty 01: other dghtf:l important to you I YOU /31101lLD 'l'Al<1Jl 'l'Hl/3 l'AI'IlR TO VOU1~ LAWYIJlR Nl' ONCIJl, IF YOU, DO NO'I' HAVliJ A LAWVIJlH OR CANI'IO'I' AFFORD omi:, aD 'I'D OR 'I'li1IJIUPllOl'lm 'l'HEl OI~rIom SWl' fo'OR'I'H I3Ii1LJOI'/ 'I'O rIND OUT WHllRIU ~OU ClIl'l amT LOOAI" HUJI"P, Cumberland ~ounty l3ar Af:lf:lociation 2L:lbart y Avenue Ca:rHale, 1'1\ 17013 ('/17) 249-3166 " ,', d " " " , " I. ' \ " " " QQJ1NU l'UlLCUtWliQ1ll ~lL.Y-I-.-,I11ilREMLID!1l1l " g, p~v&gr~ph~ t ~hrouqh 0 of: the plaintiff's ComplAint are incol:porC1~eq hel'e~,n PY i:pferenoe IInc1 m!-1c1e ~ pal:l: thereot AI3 H ~e~ corth :In cull, , ,I "10, 'I'he \laoic1ent WIIS oAl-18ec1 1301ely'PY the negligence OInc1 CA1"elel3snesl3 of: the pe,Cenc1mlt I J1UHIDMY BUJ<w, , clnel Was ~n n9 WaY o"luSI3c1 or oontdpll\:.,ec1 tq Py the Plll:lntice, J1\SON j<AMIlI.,liND, " 11, The DeCenc1nnt, JWRmMY DUI.,r.,'S, negligence ~nc1 oare~.esm1el3"1, oonsistec1 of the fQllow:lng I A, ,13, "e, "," D, 'In, " PI " Pllilingt6 exercise the h:l9h degree of oare l"eqllil;ed Py a ,"otQdl3t ,ented,ng Em interf.lectionl, Driving hi~ vohiclo nt a I3peed nnc1 in a manner in el(clilSS Of the speec:l Bmit,. Inattentivenessl Driving too f:ast for oonc1iti~nsl Failing to suo~ within the assured olenr dll3tnhoe nheAdl " Violntions of the l'ennsylvnniEl Motor Vehicle Code for driving at a safe speed, whioh is negligenae per se, " G, OperElting his vehicle so liS to ~reBte B danger6uS a1tuation for passongel~s in his motor vehiole} and H, ~ailing to mnintElin contrbl of the vehicle\ 3 'j' Ii ,; ~.Il, . lIB "he I3ple 1:(1 I3l\ll;, oj: \:IH'J Defel1tiant / \JjugmMY l3ur.,I,q3, negHgenae, th(1 pl<d\1til:(:,\JAI3Pl'! gflM;3IJfI\'!P, a\lEl:~1l:ec1 \:\)13 following seyere anc1 pe~nQn~n\:'~njur:leal ,A, 13, C, ,>1" D, lU I F', I3Qol~ P'Iinl l,eg pOlin'{ Ret~opull3e frAgment in\:o.the I3pina1 cAnC\l w~th ~pproKtmAtely 80%oc01\\l3ionl Tlnted.or ll\mba~ c1ecomp~el3/l:lon Anc1 f.~\l3j.on I pil3oeotol11Y at LIl-~ anc1 J,J-i\ { Elnc1 PartiEll yerl!ebral C01"pectomy at W3 / remoying mOl3t of tile bone, 13, MedicA~ billl3 have been inourred al3 A reaUlt Of the Pldntl.f.f 113 injudea whJ.ch inclw;le, to date, the following I r $ IlPo., 00. . Yellow I3reechel3 IiIMS .carHale Hoap:lt"l .. CarH131e CotnmunJ.ty Al11bulance Kevin'J, Kelly, M,D, Herl3hey MedIc"l Center ': 1,761..00. 3fl6,o.O 'l'O'l'1\L 120.,0.0 $60.296.64 ....Ri. 861. 64 1'1, . As the 1301e Imd prmd..l11C1te 17!!aUlt of the Def.endant, JIilRE)MY I3UlJI,lS'1 negi:l.gence" the 1?1i1:!.ntHf/ JASal'! RAM8LAND, hElI3. " suffered.a 10~1Il bf eal:n:l.tlgs Elnd an impairment of eal-ni\lg oapacity, 1\ , YE"IFJQA~gM-nAaER_U~N-ijRH9NnL Htl.QWL.Nl1aILl\NLINFDRMl\'l'.~gtLmLJ.1..Eli:UJn_..nY-QQ\llilil'l1l I, \H\llOl'/ Ill\M/:11,I\I'/P, VarlfY tlH)t: J Am 1:110. Plfllnt.1.J~f In tl10 f.prpgplng 1-\0t:1-on i\nel t:111\\: \:110 1\\:\:<1011011 OOMPLl\lN'l\ .lfcl hqE\lile1 HPon , . 1:lw .j.nf.orlllAt:Joq wldol1 I1qo lJoon eJ<l11l1oror\ IJY my opmwo,j. .In pt'oPIH'1\1~j.on oj~ 1:11 1.1-1 1I\Wfcl\l.j t:, 'I'ho 1/ll1tJ11l\CJe of. the oOMP1'f\Hl'l' Jf.1 l:lll\t of. OOlll1l3eland J.13 1101: mJ,l1o, I hilVo r.OAct the OOlvll'IJfl+N'I', 11m! t:o t:l1l!f JIl(tal1t: tllt1t, .i.t: .If.1 bAl30cl \lpCm il1for.mfll:!on WhJoh I hflye g!yen tp my Oollnl'le1., It 1-1'l tr.\10 I\nCl Q01~I~eot t:o tile peEl\! of my . knoW1ec1ge, JnformAtJon, 4nc1 balJef, To tho RXj:ont thut the aontentE\ of tho OOMPLfllNT lIr.e thut of OOUnf.1e1, l hove r.olJec1upol1 00UI113e1 In l~AI~.ll1g l:hJ-I3. VadHol\tj,on, I l\nr.1e!:'I3t:<Inc1 that ,.thtent-ioI1111f<llfla stAtelnent~ h01'eJn 1-11'13 , /, mAc1~ I3l1pjeqt to tha penol-tios of: 10 1'A\O,/:1, g4904 rolattn~ to , Ul1l'lwor.ri fA11'lifJoationp mAde to'outhorJt:-ios, ,,- ' i \ - '~". " . ,~" :"~;;"~"'I-l"'" ~/"~~ JASON Hl\MSJ..flNP .. Ii " '.. " II ;1 ,I', H" " I' " " I' , " " I' " "" ,,' " ,', " '"., ., " d " " \1 " @) -.., jt ," , " " " "II ,- I, , " "" I' .I' " " .. 1,1 ,. " ,.: " " " II I' ,. " " :1 d, " " ,f- .. " '\ " ," J' :1 " " ;,1' " Ii " I I' " ,. , , , " " I , iI, II' I) I ,:'~ j I' I I,,, 'I'''},.,,' '1, " d .1' .. " " I' ,," Ip ,,' " \ " . .,~; , , h r " "-,i ) I; ';' ", ~, , 1'_ i I \;j' 1; I ,\_ ~~;, , "l~1 ;. , 1('11,) l\-: Ii. t': -""". ,lllll\I)~:~1 '- ~t 'f' Ii'; -~I;'.y ",i' "h ,. "J, ',', " "I'," "f' .. " , " Ii," ,. 'it, '" .' !I " " Sc,hrnlc;ft and Ronca ~ ^"Q",.V, ~n,t ~Q"""I"" ~11~w ,J~N 2,~ 1~~ lUV "", II"" " " It",I,bllll' "~I\'tl,~"'~ ,11"' 111/1'104'"0 .-Jf,} ,: 'I,n 1,___,_" " t., " 'jll' " -'i.>'-,u' \ I I ;-t'-' I; 'j~U1'. 'lil " , I " " l: \ f' 'r.' I, ,''1 ~i~l'" , I~i "'.~\ " .'4( Xr;~\'lilJ 1"0"1'\ 'fi,_,"">>j, ", ,f",. Inl'" '\' ",,", ',.' 1_'::,_,I'_~'-t;;:IP. JJ ",m, \ j~.' (~,I" ,) ",;, ;~ri'l ;~',':, ! 'H,\.. " , 'I" '-'/\" !'j\ " I (,1.1.:, 't._,_" 'l(t",:, ,\)f 't_,; ~iL ~t, \1\ -'r" "11!. fl,' l<; '{ ,I' i "'-"l" I , 'i !J.l, , I,> " , I' I. .'i, """',;; ',I' 't,' " . " ", !' , .' " " 'il .' 'i {\ " " '. " '. .' .--~, ';i i' 'lJ" J " 1:::W~\"'I'_l J.~' ...,1' ~ . .,~ ., ,I ,{ "A,_f "il'.'ll'! -,I'''' " " " I' ij~i: '),1 ""1 \', ,j>. 1 " " I' 1:",:r)_nl'I'I('r., I..., \, I.'.. ('" i ',' , " I" ':Yf.<\lW /. ~ I') I !~ , ! I"l J, :~1 II (I " " ! Jl'" ' .,Ii ;; 'Ii, '.1; " " " " I T. " :, ,. ,. " i\ " .j! I' " " d' !' I, " ,- ,. " " i " ;,1. ;! .1' ,,/i ';, .11 " .. \. " " 'II .. " 'I' " ,. ,iLl " I' ~... ~' L ~ " tJ-. ~ ~. II.,~. "6' '.," " .. Ii (Ii ,. ,,' " j. 'l " ., " ,. )-, " ,. ;' 'j, ii ;" .' .,' " ,h' 'j! " II ,. 'j; "" n 1.1'1 Cl r I,U '" 'T11~; I ., , "Pi ., .' II,..!I .. .. l'i , ,.) '11J t.' j ! \ ! :L, I' 'JI.-' I"~ ',. :.11 ,I.!; , ! : ;'1 I ,;Hl 1"" fl) . ! " ~ 'I ,I .- j- _1,. ,(,,) " 'II ."" I' @ II .. . ." I' I' .' " \,;' " I -\ "'t, 0'_ ',' ~\.I{\' (.1.' i, lh' .~,' ,',' '... ,t't~ ," i '."~}h" I 1, '_~ I't_;, 'I""'ill~' ," ~I"\\ 'iih...ItJ ~ " ,- ..I, " Ii, \'" ,'i ,. , H , ! , " Schmltft anti RoI1(:i\' ~ ""Pln_,I ~nrt Cp~II..IQ"M ,I~w IP~ ..~,~ "".1 '1t~IlI,'b"'" '.nn'IIY~"I, IIIP' 11f 115H'1KI " " " ,fflJ "a19~) .." I' " '!'" q II '-I' ), t\ " .\'~~ _;111, " " ',' ,'ii J.i \':111'.;\" '1'1 , . .~~~f 'I' '; (~~~" \ t ,j~"l" ,'I' 'I , ',.,t _'_\ ,,' \ 'li$':..\ i' ," , ~. Iii' '\: J), ,,\:'. ,~' i",I, ""l'~ '" ;{j'\ ,! ' 'fl"h- I ,I .I'!','~ \ t ~'I. IF:' .I" ,. ~-l\, Itilj' _\-', , 'd '''1 ., \l~.',' " , ~~,. .. ~ ,I ' .,'lIl: .1,'; '{-j);I' 1'1,' , '" ' \ " I J v"~ '_~;I\t;l__ ' " J~., ',II,'. ':1-" '~"(t{'i \' ,I " l'\'r ," , .ot , '(/1.',/: ,j: 'f ;l, ,. '1\ , ,0'1' , I 1.. p , , \y' " l' I' ;/I:~ ,. ,. " ',j." iI , Ii' I', ,( , ' U I 1\ I I" , ' ,. I. " ~~ ' . ('1'1" . ,\J 11>111, , ' ~l\-ll\l /"~I~ tJ;, ~r ,., , "'( ", ".l~~\!r}fll " Ii ,,. ,,~, ';1 'l!'~ i.!- \ " ",. " \, ., " I' ,,' " .. /i ;1', ,. j! Iii! J' ,!" I ''I " " " II I " ,1 I". " 'I " ,. I' " " " ;1 ,. " .. "I " " " " , -. ji ". '11 ,. " !i' " .. Ii " Ii iI' I,' .i' I' I' i' ,I' " ,. " i' ;i ~I-( ~r ,~ t-' ~' '0 l' ~:, ~t :g +-. -..j) ~f ~ ~J ,-:) f{ ,,-' " I' I'" '\> " ii WIII,mmE'OHIn, \:11_1 P.lilJ.I1(:jJ:f'/ JilllOIl HQIlUJ1IIIlC.1, nwpootf\llly l~C'lCJ\losl',1J \:h~,ll COllr\: to C)n\:OI: Iln OrelOl: gr.ant:.IIlIJ Ills Mol:ion f.or ~'OIlVC'l l:q AlllPl1rl COIl\plll,l.Il~, d' 1I0llpoOt fU,Uy submit: toel, 1301lMlPlj' ANi) !~ONCA, p,c, 13'1_ ,/{:cl (~=~_,__~__~ erllrcl C I l~rl1mer 1\ttol:l1oy a t..l'I1\1 1\ttornoy I I P. No., 44715 20D state ,~treet ' :lll1rJ:,!.sbllrg, [>/\ 17101 (717) 232-6300 1\ttorney for Plqintiff ," Dl\'l'J;]J) I ~ n a I D D " .". I' ". I'i " /', ,. ,.. It .. " !i ., " " q I! Ii " ' ii' 1\ ,. 'il " " " ,', I, Ih~ \l~1\I1"YIVIII1II1I.I~1I1111' Cplllrnlllplll'lllhr 110111111" PI' nfW 111' 118 110011s~e9 \1111101' 01r01l111811111P09 SlIph 119 ~lo"erlllllllll1lh~ Cp1111l1111111, 4,' 47 I'nJ\R.A, ij4,40;l( I) prl1vhlos IIHlI, "II shllll \10 llIllilWl1l1 (I) Ihr II11Y 110011900111' Ih~ HPIII'II, 01'1111)' Ill11pll1)'oo, "orVllnI nr 1I~lln1 nl'slIoh 119011soo In 901l,1111'1118h 111' Blw nl1Y Ilqwll' 111' 11101l0d 01' \1l'llwolI \1~Y\lI'i\Boa, or 10 pOl'l11lt IIIlY IIq\ll1r nr 11111110~1 nl' hroWollllOvol'!\Boa In 110 ao111, , ' '. ., , 1\II'I11ahOll or UIVOI1, In IIIlY 1101'91111 vlslhly 11111\)(loIIICII, ~r In nlly 11181\110 perSOll, nl' 111111111', or 10 hohll\lnlJln111knnls, Ill' IWI'8P11S 011k11PWI,l11110111POfll10 111\1,119,11, ~, ti4-403(1) In 10 hll rClld III C111U1I11011011 wllhti'1.407 whloh provlllc9, "No 1I00llsoo ahllll ho II 11\1 III 111 Ihlnl pllraollsIl1111CCOIII1I 0l'dll111l1Bosll1lll0lcllllpl111lhol11 ol1'lho IIcoIIso~1 prll1111a08 hy O\lsll1l11ol'" oflhllll00111100 II111oa81ho 0llalll1,I1or who 1111110181110 dnl1l0Bos Wll8 8111d, 1\11'1\191101101' BlvOI1 IIqllol', 01' 1l111110dol' browed hOVOl'l1BoS hy 1110 8111clllcoIIsOO or his I1Bonl, 80rVII1111lr ompl\1Yoo WhOl1lho ~1I1~lonsloll\Ol' Wll8 vlalhly 11110xI011Icll," , . - I 6, Tho Acldltlolll1llJof\ll1llnnl Wl19 II 1I00n800 01'1110 1~IIlIlI1I'Col1lrl1l11l1l1rcl hotbro, on IIl1d ' lilloI' JIIIHlI\ry ~(j, 1097. I. 7, 011 JIII1I1I1I')' 26, 1997,lhof)olblldl111IJoI'01llY UIIII ollllll!ledln 111111Y oflll'lnkhlB wl1loh Illtlmntoly rosullodll1 him drlvlnl! whllo Inloxlolllod IIl1d 1I1101l0dly ollllslllB In)lll)' 10 1110 I'llIlntlO' , . JoSOII Hllmalllnd, 9, On JOl\lll\ry 26, 1997,1\1llllprnxlmllloly 12:30 P,M.lho f)olbnllllnlllrrlvoll ollh\1 it j '" ;, A11d1tl0111\1 Dolbndlll1t's Ohlh, " 10, Whllo lit tho Addltlonl11 \)olbndl1nl~s 011111; 1110 IJofbl1dllnl drlmk II vl1rlol)' nfllOllol' or , , " , " , !' I' " 1111111ed or browoIl hcvol'l\!los dllrlllB 11Inoh IIl1dsllhscl]llOl\lly whllo plnylnll 0llrd8III Iho .clllh, . I' Ii i II, 'I'hp hpVPI'iI~ON whloh tho Pof\ll1lhll11 pnllNlllllPl1 \VOI'O Nol!f nllll/or fl1rnlsho!1 nml ' sOIY!l!I,lnhlln hy 111'1I1Olp1118, nln1llts nr oll1plnyoos nf't\lhlltlolllIIIMOlIlllIll', nlld/nr \Voro pIII'ohnNocf hY Olhol' ollstnlllOrN O'nl11 Pl'lllolplIlsi ngollls nml oll1plnyoON of' 1\IIIIIIInllnl Del\lIl!IlInt who IhPII pennlUo\! nll~ nllnwoll tlIP f)otblHhlllllo cnllSlllno Iho IIOVlll'llgosl1l tho 01"\1, I~, Tho IIIlt/olls prtholJof\lIl!lnnl worll sIImplollt ICl pIli II pOl'sOll who h,lIcl ronsnnnh/o Irnlnlnllllll!ll'l(porl~llop lis n hnrtol1llor, HolYor or I1pol'lllol' pn nntleo fllIIl hll IVnN Intol(/(:ntod, " " I' I I , ; I~, Tho nhvlnllNnncl phyNll1nl'slgns whloh Iho Pof\llllllllll !lIsplllyod whllo In l\!flllllPllIll Pof\ll1!llIlIt's Phlh IImllll tho IIlllo he WM sprVPCI OllnslNlo,1 I1l'blll nro IIPlllrn!to,llp tho fhlll1wll1!.l: . . (II) I)of\lmlnnl WlIs nol/llg III 1111 nl.lJjrosNlvo !lIlIllolnl II111nlll'r, (h) I)of\llllllllll WIIS Sllll'rlll!! his wonls, (0) IJl'tbllclnlll WlIs Ilolslornlls. (d) I)I'f\lndnnl wns nrU\lI1lontntlw, (0) nof\llldlllll WIIS II11SiollclyIn his \Vlllk. (/) porOndllnl f1nnlly Pllssol/ !llll nltho IlIbll', " . 14, AllhollBh Ihe Pofbnchll1l WlIs Visibly h)loxlonlod, lho Ul11ployeos or AI/'"lllllill/ IJorolllhlllt's olllh 001111nllol/ 10 nlrnlsh him nloohol. IS, Wlthlll 11111111tos nllor 101lViI'l!! A1/1/1l1oII1I1 l)ofelldllllt's olllh whoro lie hnl/ poell servcl/ tho IIqllor or mllltccl or hrcwod hoverngcs wllilo visibly illIol(lontcl/, Iho I)orolll/nlll WIIs IIlVo1vo11 hI Iho IIroreslllclmolor vohlclo ncolcl!1lllln,whloh I'lnlllllfrwns nllegeclly "~Uroel, 16. The I\cldlllolllll Doronclllnl ns n IIeonsco ol'lhe PonnNylvnnln Liquor Control Ilnnl'eI , hns vlo/nted tho stnllllos sol thl1h IIhovo nnells, Ihol'olllro, sololy IInh/o n,l' IhePlnhllllf,s lI110geel huurlos, 17, The lIollons or Acldltlonlll Dolondnnt Ihrough ,l,ls prlncll'"ls, IIgellls nll'l employeos liS desol'ibodheroln Were II vlolllllon ortho slntlltos nncl woro Rololy the Cllllso orthe nllegcellnJurleslo \\ Pllllnt/fT. " 'I , .. , .. , .'" ~ 0 \l' tOt ~ '~e h/.1n ~emqn~n~o A ust~d en 1Q oorte, ~i usted quiere c113fenclev!'lU ~e a/.ltlla r.lumnnclaa l3l1P\lastAs I3n J.Cl!'l pl\g~.nA!'I /.l,t<Ju,i,ontG!'I( U!'Itocl tteno viento (201 c1iCl/.l ~e piA~o al. parttvcle ill teqhA dQl.~ dl311lllnclA y .1<1 notH,1.IJAO.ton, Us\:pr~ cJube preaentlll: \In/.1 ,apAr.ienql/.1 ! e/ilOl-.tt:1l 0 on perlloll/.1 0 por /.11)09Ilclo ':I Ai"oh1V<\.l' on l.A oor\:o en forlnA e/ilOrltll !'IU. ~efen8As 0 aue o~jeo.tonos A 1ns,demAnclll~ en oontrA de !'IU P 13J: !'I 011 11 , /31311 <1v.l./.llldo qlle e.t uF.l\~ecl no 80 del:,i,oneje, ,l.A l;1PI:te 1:01l1Arll ' mecl.t~<1s ~ PUedo ~ntrar una orden cpntrA uuted ain prevlo AV.tso 0 rtotitlqllolon V pDr aua1qu.ter quejn 0 a.1iVio que es pect.tdo en III pet.toion de demAn~n, Ustactpu~d~ perder clinaro 0 /.lUs propiedade8 ~ otl:01l r.lel:echo!l ,i.mpor.tftnl:es pl\rll 11sl:ect.' r.,J,mVUl mwrTl PIUMTlNP1\ TI UN l\I3op1\00 JNM~llnTl'!'I\MfjJN'J'Iil, /3J NO TllilNIil TlPo~1\Po 0 /31 NO TllilNm m~ pINmRO SUrloIUlNTIil PIil fAGTlR T^~ ~UlIWIOIO(VTlY^ mNPIOl\SONTI 0 J,~1\Mm 1.'01' 'l'mr.~lli'oNO II r,TI OIi'IOIN1\ OUY/\ PIRmOOION /310 lilNGUlilNTRTI m~CRITTI TlDTlJO I?1\RII TlVmRIGUTlR pONDm 13m rumDIO OONfJIUGUIl\ TlSIS'l'IONCJTI L,IUGTll" " OumberJ.l\lld.OountyUAr Assooiation , .' . I .. , ' ;? ~,i.bel:t':l Tlvenue " C~r.1is.1e, PTI 17013 (717) ;?'~!l-3166 ., ,. " I' " " '" " " '.-/' " " " " .. ,. "" " ,. OOUW.l' I ~hlQIJIQIl1!:lf!!l1 fTASOM.. RAM13LANP V, ,I'ER\llMY aur.~ lO, ('IHCI<;JrupIHl 1. through 9 oj: t:ho P:I,A1n\:,I.ff1a COll\p.lA,i,n\~ ~Ir.l'l 1nqprrorlte~ harein by rafaronoo qn~ mqdo ApArt: thoroof A~ 1f aot: 1=or.\:h .in j:ulJ, 11; ~~e iooident: WAS oA\lled solely by the negligenoe And QA1"olpl"sneSIl of \:he Pufanelunt, -1It1l\1OMY 13tll,I;, <md Wllll ,I,n no WilY "oAuseel " , or. Dontribut~d to by t:he PlAintiff, J^~ON' RAMSLANP, l~. Tho Pefend"n!:, JIORIOMY DU~LIB, neg11gonoe And otlr.elessneafi oonsisted of the folloWing, 1\, 13 ., 0, " , p" In, Ir, 8, /I, , " I fAiling to exoroise the high degree of OIl~C required by a ll\ot:or1at entering An inter.seotion/ Driving h1s ~ehiole at a spee~llnd in a mAnner. in ' . cxopsa q"f the apeecl limi\:/ Inl1ttent:.l.veneaa/ 'Priving toq fAst for oonditiona/ Violations of tho renhsylVA~ia Motor Vehiole Gode fo~ "dJ:.1,v.1.ng ut u Bllfo B1Joed, wh.toh is negligenoe .por so, Ol:)fjral:ing his vehillle so IlS to oreate a clAngorouS' sitUAtion. for passenaers 1n his motor vehiole/ ahd IrilJ1in\1 '1:0' maint<d.n oontl'Ol of the vehlo1e. '.' I, ii",,, ! ,.' " omm'l' :c ~mGr<:CGIIlNOIl1 iTMloN IU\Mar~~O v. iTmRDlMY nUI.l1 10, P.1t".lgrrWIW.1 \:hi'ol1\JII 9 of tllo l'l.d,nl:JJ'f:ls COlllpl,Cj1nt .1l:0 .tnoorpol:n\:oci !\cH'oln IJY ro1:orqnoo unci lI1ucio A PAl't 1:1101:001: <IS If. sot fOl:\:1I .tn full, 11, '1'ho aooldent wus o<\uaoci sololy by I:h13 nog.1,.l,gonoe ancl'.. qarol13ssnosB of the Pof13ncian\:, JI;:\,InMY 13UI,I" and \1iw lnno wp.y o<luB13ci or oori\:rlbutod to by the l'l<lintlff, J^~ON R^MS~^NP, 12. Thl Pofonci<\nl:, JffiRffiMY BULLIS, n13g11gonoo <lnd ci\relessnoSB " cQnsisteci of the followlngl 1\, 13 I " " C, D, rul b" t " l~al1ing to exerdsothe hlgh c!13g1:eo 6f' qilre re'1u1rael by <I 1I101:0risl: onterlng <In lntorseotloD' prlving his V13hicle ilt a sr130d and lri <I md~ner In eXcess of the speeci 11mil:'I I na tl:en tJ venes s, briVlng too fast for oonciltionsl ~1a;l.1ing 1:0 8\:01) wHhin the .ilSSlll:eel cleilr clls\:anoo' aheaci, Vl01iltions of the l'ennsyJ,vilnla Mol:ol' VehloJ.e .ooele for cidving nt a safo speed, W\\loh .is l1eg1igeno~ per so, G, Opernting Ills Vehiole so IS to oreato il dangerous situat:ion fOl'passengers in Ilia motor vehiole, aod' H, Falling to maintu;l.n oontrol of the vehlale. H Hi, Au I:IHJ IlDl() <lilt! proK.iIl\il\:ll l'ml\lli: 0(: \:110 1l0!'r;lIdill1\:, ,JmI\lDf4Y ,mld,lf], nO<]l.l.(jIJI\ClU, I:hu P11IJI1\:JfI:, ,JA/JON IIAMiJl,ANP, 111lt' \lnCIOl:goIlIJ <]l:ell\: 111\11\ 1\1)(\ BIIHol:,lno .1.1\ tho Piwl: ilnel \1,\1,1, oOlll:.lnllu \:0 \lncl(jt<]o \Jl:O<1t pH.l.n Iln(1 IJ\lJ'fur.j,no ,1 nl'.o t:llo .l'\1!:lIre, ].'/, All 1:1]0 80.1.0 <lnt! pl.'Cll\Jlllilte routll!: of: tho Dofendl1nt, iJlnHJnMY IlUl,r., ',9, IW<]lJ(jol\oo, 1:lw Plil,llltJH, iJl\IlON II/1M/nAND, ,h<18 11Il.l'J:etecl 11 pO !:I II IJ 1101\ I: (1.1m.1.nl1l:.I.on qf: 1\.1 tI itl'J,U.J\:y to olljoy 1.1,.1'0 /llId .l..j,f:Cl I fI II plUI1SlltUI] , 10, As thu Holo I1l1a prOKJm<lto l'Ollult oE tho Pof:Clndill1t, JJnRJnMY IW!.,!., I S,nl.l<]l:I.<]onoo', thD Pln.1.n\:JJ'.ff, JASON HAI~SI<ANIJ, hl1f1 I)eon obl.1.\leel to expend vilr.1.ou~ BUlliS of money ill1e.! .1.110\lt Vilr.1.0\lB expenses fot the inJ\ll:.l.es thill:' ho suff:oroel ilnel milY oon 1:.1. II lie to .1.ncJIII: I:he Sl1me .1.11 .l:he f\lI:\11:e, Wllhml!ll~OI~m, the PlilJ111:.i J:J: I ,JASON IIAMSltlINP, dOlllill1e1s j \lel<Jlnenl:of \:ho Peful1e1<1n~, Jml~mf4Y 'nUl.I" .i.n an am~ul1t .in exoeS8 of l:he I1moullt l:eqU,11:ed 1.n oompulsory <1rIJ.l.t:r<1t:.1.on, ," " Q.QUWl' II " , . JAaO~ lU\MSLAl'lO V, illllMt.!:l aULIt t>UI'lI'l'IV1IlOAMMlJ1S ,. 19, Pnragiaphu 1 through 10 of the prDJ~t.1.ffBI co~pl~int ore Jl1col'!JorEltecl het:e.J.n by reference ol1e1 II1Ade i\ pf.ll:t thereof as ,1.f sliIt ii, forth .1.n full, '" II " " " VIlRIFIOOlill/ I' .. I, Mlohllol 'I', \\ \11'1 IIH, JI'" horohy Iloknllwlq\I!l\l 111II1 ClIl'llalo CI1\1nll')' Chlh 1"'1111 I " " ,~(Idhlunnl Pol~mhmllnlhlallolllln nn(llhllllllllll\\t1hlll'l~o(1 Ill1llnklllhl" VOI'If1olllllln On It'" llohlllr. \hlll I hllvo I'ollllllw l\lI'Ollllhl!l AnH\VOI' wllh N\lW MlIlIol' Ihlll Iho 111018 8InIO(\ Ihol'olnlll'll \1'110 IInel PUIloN lolhollosl or my knowlod!lo, Inlhl'll1l1l1onll1\(1 holluC I umlol'alllnel 1I1111 nny 111160 "\111011101\1 a hOl'olnl\l'u mndo 8nlljoollo p01\nllloll or I H Pn, ,. " C,:;, ~oollon i\\lO'I, rOllllln!llo 1I1\8Wprn 111181110111101\10 lIulhorltlos, _Z! NI\1\101 Mlohl\ol 'I'. 111'1118, JI', '1'11101 Cluh M1II11I!lor ' " 1)1110: "V8l5)n ',I ," ,. " " ',' ,. ,. \, ,. " " I1MIQN nMI~1.lANP , I :n'f '1'11 III OO\1R'~ QJ.i1 COMMOI'! ~!'.lIllMl 'l'll\illt:!ffC , OUM!1Ill~LMW OOUN1'Y, VIllNli~YfNAI'!;!:~ ' , v. , o:J:VXl'-i 1\.O'I';!:ON' LfI,W I,., - , I1IllRIllMY JlUHHI , 1'l'P, PO-55145 Dafamllmt: , I I1\1RV TRIM PJlIMMWIllP p~OIVIll '1'0 ~UnS'l'ITU'1'm vmRIFIOA~Qtl '1'0 THill P~OWHONO'l'MY I, rlease s~bstitute the at~aohed Verifioation of the.Vlaintiff, Jason Ramsland, for the Ver.t.ficat,i.on of the undersiYl]ecl counsel for' Vlaint,i.ff, Jason .'~amslI1l1d, whioh \1as attaohed to the Amended 'Complaint Hlacl on 01; I1boUt May 17, 1999, Respeotfully sUbmitted, ScIiMII)'Il, RONCA & l<l~AMlm, l?, 0, " B //!-J /1.-----, , y-r---(~ Ja,erard 0, I<ramer ./Attorney at Law Attorney I,D, No, 44715 209 State Street Ilarrisburg, I?A 17101 (717) 232-6300 Attorney for I?laintiff " , DlI'l'!JJP 1.j)?7 / f'f ',I' "j' " " " '1 ,,' 1\ Ii " 'H i',\, ,i I' "." I' " " I' I, , .j ~ , ",0 I' I' ":i j-' " Ii I, ';' " I,Jt"" " " " " t! ji ,; " " " " {: ,.;; Ij ,1'; " ii, ,,' ,j, , .' ,; ,; Ii ,/ "If I, '1. ,. I' "', " " .. " ,', " ,I i,l I' I, I. I;' " '.. I r:) l,+) " H \ ,) , I , " ! I II , t' , I \ 1',1 1 I l"-' I .. ! f.l,') II " .. , ,', " , , I , , ;': :.'\' <'I ,i; ! ii, " Ol ., '" " '/I ,. Ii I' ,I " ;; (. ii " .. ,.'; ;ill I' i I " :t !Ii , \' I' I. Ii ,." m\1l0N R~MIlIlI\N"P, , ,.1' In,Ain\:iff , ' I V', ! , 111llllIDMV BUIlJ:l, , DSfsnQAll\: , I V, I , CI\Il~III3f.l1ll COtrn'TRY Cwn, , Md;ll:;la"Al P~fsmlA"1: I :m 'l'!i1D CO~1RT OF COMMON l?I,1lJ1\13 C!1M~/l)nHI\ND COITm'Y, l?llllfNl'I\'J:lVI\N;l:l\ O~V~Hl\a'l'ION'" IlI\W NO, 98.6645 CIVIJ:l I1URY 'l'lU:M, PIll~NPIIlP . l'I.AIN'.{'IFF' S ANSWlli.. TO APDITIONAI. DIDFIIllIDANL. .. ~LISLlil COUNTRY CLUB' S'NlDW ~IA~I!IR I AND ~oW, comes the PlC\intiff,Jason Ramsland, b~ and through h.i.a attorneys, SCIIMIP'l', RoHci\ & I~RlIM/!1R, p,c" anelrespeotfUlly resp'onds to the Ne\1 Mattel: of the I\dclHional Pefenclant:, CC\r.l!sle 'Country Club as follows! 19,' Pa~'C\grQph 19 stQte/3 no allegQtiop to which Q l'el3pOnf3e .;L/3 reqllired, By WQY of furthel" fl1Iswer, paragraph/3 of the Plaintiff I s Complaint. are inoorpor€lt.€ld by l~eferenoe, ,,' 20 I Paragl:c1ph 20 states fI conclusion of laW t.o which no , re/3pon~iVe pleading is necos/3ary, 2l, Pal"agraph 21 states JI conclusion of law t.o which no l"espOllaive pleading is neCOs/3C\ry, " , , 22. Pl\1"agl'upI1 22 st.Cite!3 a conolu/3ioll of "lUW t.o whioh no re/3PonsiV~ pleading is lleoessl\ry, " ;, I' ;a3, ' pO\rO\gl:f\ph 23 ",t<l~013 f\ aOlloltwion of. l/ilW \:0 whioh no , l"Ol3pomd.ve pl.eO\cj~,ng ~, fl l1eO(l13fJ<l1:Y, ;ail, ~)<\l"O\gr<lph 21 13\:<I\:ep <\ oonolQ13.j.on of. l<\W \:0 whioh no :rol'lpon13~,vo pleO\(Ung i13 neaeI3P~\l:Y , " 25 ['O\l"Agl'Aph 25 fJt<ltefJ <\ Oonoll.\l3ion of. lE\W \;0 whioh no . , !:Ol3pon13~,ve pl.e<\rUng il3 neoof.l13O\ry, ;;16, ['Al"C\g,l"O\ph 26 f.ltC\\:el'l C\ oono~,ul'lion of. lAW \:0 whioh no rOl'lponpivo pleaQing .j.p neoo13f.la1"y, 27, !?E\I;A9r.Aph 27 I3tA\:ep C\ oono1:\.\I'lion of. lAW to wh~,oh no l"Ol3pOn!l~,vO pleC\t~ing i!l neOOI3I3E\ry, \'I111!l~lnU'0I~m"the 'Plain\;iff,requost:s \:h<lt jUdgement pe ente,r.ed /\\JA.i,n!lt the pef.onelant: on bolH\.tf of \:he Pl<\intiff I Reapec\:f.ully l3ubmitteel, " ~oHMIPT, RONCA & ~RAMI!lR,' [',a, {/---r-' . ;I ",. onl rei a, 1~r<\1l1er At \:orney At I,AW Attorney I,D, No; 44715 209 StAte ,streot Harrisburg, ['A 17101 (717) 232~6300 Attor.ney for Plaintiff I " " " <I, ,. " I' 11'1'1'1111 COI1WI' PF COMMON 1'1.1~t\H OF C\JMIlI\lq,t\NI) CO\JNTY, I'nNN~YI.V t\N'A ' qVII, t\CTION -I,AW JAllPN I~AMRr.^NP, 1'111 1 Illil'l' ; No, l)H.~!H~ClvlI '1'111'111 Vfl, JBR.IlMY UI1111" " Ppl\llllllllll ANSWJm TO AMI~Nlmll COMIILAIN'I' 111111 NNW MA'I'TII)I\ .. - . I, Th~ ftllpgnl/ollfl fll'lhlfl pnl'nul'lIph nl'u Ilonlull, i\ll\ll'runHollllhlp IllvusllBnlloll, ,- ,. Putbmlnnt la Wllho\lIllllllwlollBP 1ll'lllfbrlllllll\11l slIff1clunllll fllnnl\ hpllol' uslo Ih\lll'l\lh ol'lhoflo , nVurmunls, .. , 5. 8, 9" , 2, Tho nlh)Bntlllllfl ol'lhls purngrnph nro nllmlllo(I, Tho nllognllollfl of'lhls pnrnlll'nph 111'0 IIonloll IlllI'fl\lnllllo Pn, ItC,P, 1029(0), ;J, 4, I Tho Illlpgl\llol1fl of'lhls pnrnurnph nrll lIulllu(1 P\II'slIftnlll1l'l\, ItC,p, 1029(0), Tho ~1I0Bfttlolla ol'lhls pnrnul'llpll uro IIonlull plll'S\lnnt 10 Pn, ItC.P, 1029(\1), , 6, Tho ftlloBnllllllfl ol'lhlfl purnUl'nph 1\1'0 lIunloll plll'S\lnnllo PII, ({,C,P, 1029(0). Tho IIl1cglltlolls of this Pftrnurnph nro 1I01l10d IlllrS\llll\lll1 Pn, ItC,P, 1029(0), Thu ftllOBnllonfl oflhls pnrnurnph nro dOlllod pnrSlinl\lll1 Pn, R:t1,p, 1029(0), Tho nllogntlolls ol'l"\ls pnrngl'lIph nl'o dOlllod pllrSllnnt tu PlI, H"C,Jl, 1029(0), 7, CO(JN"'.' N I<)OLIO JCNCI~ ",JASON HAI\1SLANI> v, ,lIm":MY IJllIlli " 10, Tho 1I110gntlontt of'lllls pnrnBl'lIpll nl'll dOllluc/ pIlI'SIII"lt tn PlI, Itc,l'. 1029(1,1), II. Tho nlloBnt\oll~ Millis PI\l'n!Jl'nph nro dOllll1d plll'Rllllllt tolIn, R,C,II, 1029(0), 'f j' 2 I; 12, Tlw II111lUlIlh1l\H pl'lhlH PlIl'lml'lIph IIl'u 11\11\10\1 P\II'H\II11l1ln I'll, I~.C,I', I029(u}, " 13. Th\l nlluBllllnllH nl'lhlH PIII'II!ll'lIph MU \1\ll1lod p\II'HllI\l\\ III I'll, I{,C,I', I079(\l), 14, Thu nllll~IIII\lI1H nf'lhlH plll'lmrllph nl'\l Ihll1l\lllp\ll'Hlllll1ll11 I'll, IU~,II: I079(1l), . ,. , 15, 'r11\lIlII\llJlIllnIW !lj'''lIHPIlI'II!ll'lIph lirud\lI1I\l11 plll'H\lIl1l1ln I'll, '~.c.I', I020(1l). ICl, ,Tho II110Bllllnl1H Ill'lhlH plIrngrllph IIrl,llllll1lod p\ll'HII II III 1111111, It~,I', 1029(0). 17, Th\lllll\llJl\,I,IIlI1S l)fthlH pllrnllrnph 111'0 d0l1lo\1 PIII'HIIllllllnl'lI, g,c, 1', 1029(0), IH, Tho 1I1101l1l1lnl1H nflhlH plI,rn!lrllph 111'0 1I1l111\ld plll'HIIIIIlt tnI'll, r~,c.l'. I029(\l), WlmRIWolW, IMol1l1l1ll1 J\ll'omy IMI 11\lllllll1\ls .hlll!lI11\lllt III hlH "lYIlI' 1111\1 IllHll1lsSlI1 nl' tho CI1IllIlIIlIIlI. ,. '.. PI)(IN'I' II ,'^SONn^MSL~NU v. ,1I'l1U;M" 11111.1, . r.JJNI'I'IVNDAMMlI';11 19, TllllllllolJlIIIOI1H nt'\hlspllrn!ll'lIphl thrllll!lh IR 111'0 Illonl'pnrntoll hOl'ol11 by , 1'01'01'01100 liS II' sot Ibl'lh 1111\111 .20, Tho 1I110!lllt11l11H of'thl~plIl'lI!ll'lIph 111'0 1I01110d P\II'S\llIl1t \\lPII, 1~,C,I',1029(\l), 21, '1.'ho IqlolJlIllnllH ofthlH Plll'lIlJl'lIph 1\1'0 Ilol1lod Plll'SIl 1\ 11 I tn PII, ItC;P, 1029(0). 22, Tho lIlIO!llltlnl1H orthls plll'lllJl'lIph lIro 1I0111ud plll'Slll\l1l tOPl\, ItC,P, 1029(u), WUmmFoI~lJ, Iho Pofonlllll1l .!UI'OI11Y 13\111 I'oqllosts J\IlI!ll11onl hlhls !l\VOI' nlld IIIHmlssnl of tho CIlll1pllllllt. l'lliW.ML\T11lli' ,I' " 23. 011 JlIl\lIlIl'y 26, 1997, lho 11111111111'1' lIyullll1 illl IIpnrll11ol\t bl\lIllltllJ wilh Ihll PlIl'ol\lInl\t 111\11 flvo (5) othol'll1dlvlll\lllls. 24. 01\ JlIl1l1l1ry 26,1997 IIlnppl'nxhlllltoly 1\001\, tho PlnllltlO'wQl1t to tho Cllrllslo COllntry qlul\ with tho PllIll1tllrlll1d sovon (7) !llhoi' Il1dlyldllllls, J " II, KI1\l\VlIl1\lllppIWh\lu\l PuluI\\II11l1 \VIIH drlllklll!lI\l\\IIIHp~lulIlll\II\I\\1 n\lwnh\lIIlHH pl'\JC\lullllll Ip rl\lu In 1I1llollr wllh P\llulldllnl, own Ihml!lh puf\l11111l1l1 \VIIH \l1ll1hlulp dl'lw, WI1HIQWOltll, Ihu pulullIllIl\\ J\ll'unlY 11\111 hils I,' 1\1111,\1111 cpmplulll dulul\HU 10 IhlH IIcll1111 11I1III'011\1091s lIs dlsmlsslIl, "" l\uspuull\llly H\lhmll!ud, 11I"^'\llY, YOST, II\JPP I~ SCIIA\JMANN, 1"'<P 4'~,/ ./",;?' ) /,' , ~~""_L,~/"'" , )'" )' U :.__ _-=-._~_,_":'___.__~_.._L,_,..';"~_"__,_,_,,_ , ollllld 1\, HoYl, Hsqlill'u CO\ll1>>ol for putul\dllll! 17 IlIIsI Mllrkul Hlruul York, POl1l\t1yIVIII\III 17<101 S\lpromu CI, I.f), 1/ I !lOCi 1 (717) 1I'15.3Ci74 I' -j Ii' I'" '1 I, " "" ." 1\ '. II" I' I'," I' I, I .. , ' ' " , " H. '"~ I:" '", p! .. 1-" " " ",_ Ii " 1 ' I' ,. 5 ,I' . \ I- \( ':.~ ',,' ~ , , " ' IN 'I'IIH CIlllllT of COMMoN Pl,lWi of ~!\JMllliI~ 1.I\Nn C( l\ JNTY, PI(NNHYI. V I\NII\ CI VII, I\CTION - 1.1\ W ,'I\~nN 1~I\MHI.t\NP PIIIII1III1' VN. JnIlHMY IHlI,1. yu, I, Nq. I)H"S~d~ "Civil pul'ulllllll1l j<' CAltl"IRI,.n COI)NTI~ Y CIJJII I\dllllllll1l1l pultiildlll\l .I\JIWTI~II\I, nHMI\NPHP .' ImlllS OF IlIWI':NllANT ,INlml\IY IIULL TO NI':W 1\1A'I"mnOE.MllllTIONI\I, llIWII~NIlt\N:r C,\IU ,IHLI'~ C:OlIN'I'HY(!LIIII PV,liJlHhll1l.1Vl'ulHY 111111, hy his 1I\10I'lWYS, 11I1I1'\ly,'YIlSI,llllpp II!.!. SChlllllHlIl1l1, nllls hla ^ilSWol' In Alhlltlol1l1l pcl'ulldlll1l's Nuw 1'1:111\101', 1I1'U1'I'lllg liS Ihlluws: Tho IIlIulJllllt;ils of IhlsPIIl'IllJl'llph III'U dUl1lud p\ll'slIlIl1llU PII, I~,C,P, I DZlJ(o), ZD, " " 21. 22, 2~, 24, II 2~~ , 26, 27, " Thu IIlIulJlI\I\1I1S ol'lhls 1~lIl'IIl\I'lIph 111'0 donlu(1 PIII'S\llIl1llo PII, ItC,P, ID2lJ(0), Tho IIlIolJlI\llllIs Ill'lhls PIII'1I1:\1'I\ph 111'0 dOlllod plll's\lIl1ll tn Pl\,ltC,P, ID2lJ(0), Tho 1III0lJlIlIllllsul' Ihls PIII'IIg1'l\ph III'U \lu.lllolI plll'Sllllllllu PII, ItC,P" ID2lJ(0), ThulIIIUlJllllullS ut'lhls PlIl'Ilgl'llp\! IIl'u dUl1lodpill'slIlIl1llul'n, 1~,C,J1, 10.2lJ(o), " Tho nllOlJIIIllllls Ill' lhls PIIl'lIgl'lIph 1110 d\llllud P\II'S\llIllllul'll, ,ltC,P, IOZlJ(o),' Thonllollll\lolls ot'lhls Pnl'lIgl'lIllh 1I1'\l dUlllod PIII'Hllllill 10 PII,I~,C,", I02lJ(0), A 1\01' 1'0llsIlllllblo hlVusllglllloll Dol'ulldllnl Is wltho\ll kl1owlodgool' 1111'01'1111111011 sUl11ol01l1101hl'Ill II h\llIol'lIs lulhull'lIlh ol'lhls nVonllull1 IIl1d ItIH, Ihol'Olol'o, ,. d01l16d, ,. , " ".. .,." Ii " '\:\16 pof:ondl\IW I 0 J.n\:o>\1.o1\\:lon ))nct1\1fW of: tl1l'l p(3j:Onr~nn\: I p ,c.H~\I\;\,rJl"1.omJ l,n' ,thla lHl,gi'\t:l.on, 1'.'1, n l,p r\eniocl thnt \:l1e (]In,ln\: 1. f!: wnl3 i.ntol\J.o/.ll:oc1, 'l'\lP. L>l/l:l.ntHf clict IWl: W1.\:\'II'HW /lny flO\:1.onfl on \:hU p"t't. of. \:ho pef:enctnnt At' tho Onrli13le OO\1ntry ql\~) th"t WO\1ld ev1denCe 1ntol\J.ontion, , "'Il, pen:1.ed, J\\: the dine he left the ,OflrH!3le aO\.\\1tryO+uP, the L>ln1nt1f:f:.~lct not kn00 thnt tl10 Pefenctant Wfll3 1ntoXionteq, "'9, 1\: j,,13 udmHted that when they lef:\: \:l1e Cfldl131e OO\H\try OJ.llb, (:l1e ('lEli,ntHf volun\:.ndly got :1.nto \:he veh1.ale, l\\:. (:\1e t,tme, \:.ha Pll.\lnt:if:f entered \:ho veh1ale l1e was not ael;tal,j1 whb Wfll3 ddvi,ng nor cUc:\ he have uny lmowledge thflt the Pefendnnt Wfll3 j"l1to/CiaEl\:.ed flnQ :l.na/lPElPle of !3<1f:e driv1ng, , 30, It is deni,ed \:.hat, \:.he (]lflintHf WflS' aontr.iblltory negligent, (EI) H il3 ppea:l.fianlly r\enied thnt \:h~ L>ldntiff lqlew thai: 'the, Pnf:endnflt wal3 lntoxipatecl when ho entered the par, (P) It 113 specifianlly denied thnt the'Vlnintiff knew that the 'peJ:emlnElI: wal3.illtox1.at\ted when he en\:ereCl the aar or that the pla1ntiff; shoulr\ have lmown thqt the Pef:enclEl\lt WElI3, intol{loated, (a) See (b) above, (d) See (b) above, 31, It: io I3pedfiaally den,jed' that the'. plaintiff al3l3umed the risk, (a) It is specifically ddnied tl1at the Plaintiff k~ew .thEl\: the })ef:andant was intoxJ.,cated when he entel'ed tile OElr, ,. , I i'., O~RW~FIOAW~ o~ ~~RV~O~ AIW NO\~" I:hllJ l!t/IL dilY ,.oJ' ----..-!),~,..ol~l---,-I 19P9, {, G~lI:~J:C1 'it l<r<111\()r" l~tlq\d,rn,hol'(]bY ourtJJ:y l:hlll: :r 1:ld,[J chy serverl bhe AIHlwor \:0 New Mil\:tor OJ' f)ef:ol1dilnl: ,Jol:lllIIY /lul.l I)Y clOPOll.l\:.inu tho 81111\0 .in ullB U,,9, IllIlE, f.Itsl; 01i1IJB 11\11.11, pbsi:i1\JO propliJd ill: IIlltr1sb\ll:g, 'Ponnsylvqniil, IIdclrolJsOd n86011.owoI /)on<11cl'/3, /loyt:, J!Js'1\11r8 1ll.f\\\I~V, vaS'l', /3lJPP & fJCIII\lJM^NI~,.. I,r,p 17 ~ilsl: Mnrkot Stroot Yorl" PA 17'101 Atl:.orney for /)of:endnnl:. \. \ \ \ \, " Respeotfu11Y subm.Ii:ted, sClIN:WI', RONCA ~ I,RANlill~, P, a, " , ,~L^ i 1/ ..//-". y-LL_---r-- el'<ll:cI 0, l<rl'lI11er t tOl:ney 1\,1: 1,11\~ Attorney I,D, No, 44115 ~09 St<1te Stroet lI<1rJ:.i,sburg, l'II,. 17101 (717) 232-630(} IIttornoy for l'1<1intiff' \ \ " \ \ \ I"~ ,'t, 'j, " 'I I' II "i " ': " "" , ..