Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05669 ,:1, .." I I I ~'I ~! , I ~ ' ti " . ~ I \JI ~ " " H " " , '1 " 'Ii , " , , ,,' , " " ~ ,. "" " I", I' " ~ I~ rl ~ () ~ ~, 5' ~ Ii, .. ;';' ': ';' I' " " 'I " H l! "" P, 'I' Ii' , 11\ " j " " " " 1\ " "If' " , , ,I, , \ \, ) i j/ ", " " " III '"" " " "; 'I' I',"~ H " .... " ,. " , l " " " , II " " 'I' j"Jf ''1;,i,r..' ;, \!X " "i'" "'" II ,II " " ;I 'I', I, " " I', " ,', " " ;1" ,. ,. jl ~ j { " ... \~ ,..... . .':l" .. I \:) I I ~ I ~I ~I, \ ()'d I " 0'; r~ ~ ,. I '(i " Ii!) ""1 ;, "(0 I' ,. " I' " " 'j' I' 'I 1;\ j'\ I' " " Ii '1 iI Jj ;i " d ,- ". " 'i"'" (1.,1 I "", II \ " 1\ , , "',; 1"11' i,:' ,. " \' , I " " ,:1' c:: 1'-' (u .' .. (I') _J ~ "-., II" ) ,(lq 1,,, "if':;," "lid l":!O. I;" ,., l'; 'I' :"j ,:. ~ " ~:.I '\,,) , l'i!l ('I " " ii' " " " " I,: '" I, .!' j" J;II ,. " II I !\ "",; " " ;/' ,.' ." " " " " I' .. " q " " " '0. " I' ,. II ~ " " 'i' I' Ii " ,,' 'j, ,'I' li' ')i I' i, " " I" '" ", " " ~ ' " , i.' 1'", !\ "" I' .' j; " , .,.i' " "I," " " [:,-~--"-.,,-"1;n . "_~-~~~=~oIuITJE!Pi\J.Jf.QV~!9JWJ(J~-' '---."'. -:~~~7"":'-"'~'~L.J I\NIl NOW,lhlH 12111 dll)' or ,1\1110, 211112, I IWl'ohy 0\11'111)' 111111 I HOIlIIl 11'I11l IIIHlonlTllcl Il\lP)' or Ilwlill'll[Jolll[J 110011111011110 Ilwlhlllllvll1ll OOlll1HOllll' 1'11\101'11, h)' plllollll\ II oON' 01' HIIIllO III 1110 IJl1llo(1 HIIIIIlH, 111'111 IlhlfJS 1111111, pOHIII[jO pl'oPllld,lIlldl'llHHIHllIH Ihllnll'HI (((I\l'lIl'd 1\, ,11I\llllll', .II'.. I\HlIllll'1l WhlllllllHl WllllillIlHII,',I' I HOIl OliO 1,lhol'l)' Phlco Pl1l1l1dolpl1ll1, PI'\ II) 1II:I.U~()5 " 1)1I1l11l11\, IJllnl'lh11'lT, I\Hqlllro MIII.tHnlll 'lOIl!'I'n"f!', WlllhllllH ~ Olin Tlll1l\lIHlllIghHll'ool Clll'IIH1o, PA 1701:1 " . , .1l)'1 '/'''(ll\1^:;''91(}~^2.&}'^J1I~H''4141' . ,,\-// ~.---? ,\ L;i~- ( t/ r-....- bnll~I"H llt~l'coHi('[;Hlliliru--:~-:- . " , " I"~ ,," " .. ), '" ,I . " i .I " " , " I:i'I'L\TI1i\lHl'l.'LU E.1!M1'1~'i-'.~-IMMl\{lWS PllIll1\11TllIIs prn\'lll\llln li\l\illl\lli linl1l1lBIlH hh111~1' 1l\ltllllltll\1I1I Ill'plllll1lll'1's dll11H1I\~S (S\I~ 1\>\1111111 ''1\''), 1'111111111'1' hilS nl\lwd 111 1\'\111111'111\' Pllrlnll1 IISplllllH 111' Ilw Ih1l1HI'Il~i; II'hl\lll, 11\1ll'Il SI1\lIlII1~III1Y, h1l'I\1dlllllllllllll;:! nl\\11 1:1011 plllll1llifs 111I11H\goH IIHI, wilh liW ~x(Jopllol1ol'lIw ~ll\llplllOIII 1'1l111111 olHlrglll11' $1 0,1)111),115 1\1\1111 hlbl1l'lllllll'Bll 01' $1 5,717,n" I )Illhllllllll.lllwsu IIlllllH " ' 1111\1 b)i I'lllhlllll1l.1lho Hllllllll1l\l1\11I1I111\1I11 I'lloolwd rl'l1l1llJpl\, plllll1lil'l'clnlllls lillIlHll!.llS 111 llw 111110111l1 1l1'$21)fl,!)55,OO, 1'1, ~l1N]~AI.i.IUl'.I!US.c.ll!LK..L'i:S1!J!:Ii.UlU..IAJlILnX..L\NllJ1AMAU g:s P1I1iI1I1ITll\111llll\lls thnl dlll'clllhll1\, f\lhwIW R, l\llllll\lY, II'IIS 1\01lllgo11t lI11d bl'UllllllllllhlH llOl1ll'lIlll II'llh plllll1l1l'1'1l1 porl'nl'll1hlg lIis Wlll'K 01\ Iho llll~' oi"liwlirll, 1'IIIInlllToPlllll11dHlhlll Ml', , KllolJOY KIWI\' 111' ShllHlli 1I11\,IlI\l1l1l1'n 01' 1110 PI'IlSIlI\CC 111' IIwl'\lh\wl' lining II'IIhll111wII\'Illw Ilwl1 plpo,' Tlwlwolw 1110h dl'llllHll.I1l plpu III iSSlIll 1'1111 rl'lllllliw bl1l1l1lll ol'II'IIs11\lr 1\111 1I1l, 2 10 II cll\HHil1lll' onlho 1I1'Olll\li, 1'1'101'.10 pOl'Ihrmh11l Il\l\llnll WllrK lit lilll top ol'lIl1l plpo, M!', l\IlOI\IlY .. I'llqllllHloli thnt' Iho I'\lbhol' IInllr Ihr liw I\'nHllOl' Il\h nil, 211\) rolloli hnel, Ihlll' tll 11\'0 loot, This II'llI'K "," ' ,,' " , WIIS donll hy nn IllllplllYllllllr IIc\l1PI llrllH, Whl/o 1I11l111wl' WIIS l'ollll1\'Oli l1'll\11 1110 IIlh, ll110 eO\lld Ii Hllll Iho I'\lbhorlinlng 1111 1110 hl1\1l1\l1 111\11' lll' \llC \lI'cl\'1l hwh plp\l lhlll wnH 10 Iw rUll1nwli, 1\1\ , ll\11ploYOIl or llolllpt UrllH, 1\l'lll'llicd II liro Wlllell Ihl' Mr, Koone)' wlllll\ Mr~ KIlOll0Y \11l1dll II \1nl'lIl1l out l~t 1I11l10p 111' tho plpll, 1\1\01' the crllno exporllll1eod nlCchnnlcnl pl'llhlemH, tho Ilompt lIrnH,' elnp111YIlc Whll II'IIH II'lIh MI', I<ocno~' lell ll1l]HHlslln 111Il1'llpn/1' lll' Iho On1l10, Wllhl1\lt plnlnlll'l'H Kl1owludgll, MI', KIlOI'lIlY Pl'lloo~dol\ In Il1I1KO \\\'n 1\101'0 holoH In .tho tllp 111' IIIIl pipe Ihr\hc 'lining Hlll1l1, l\licl' oOlllplll\lng lwo ClltH /\11' \Il1lllnlng Hl/l1g, MI', Kool\o)' Illn tho hl1mcdlnto III'cn wIthl1l11 IIdvIHlilllllll)'llI1C thll\ 1\\l hlld .Illlldo thoso l\I'll ell\s, llnd/: 1)091111.l \'1 -:1- , ,. ,. 11 IH plllluliI'I'H pllHilllll1ll1l11 MI', l\o~I\Il)' lilllpllllllil1h\1I' 1'1l1\HIlI1l\hl~ H\lII\\IIII'IIH \II'PIII'~ 1'~11\111'\l11 hy hlH 1'1'I11\IHHIIlIl11\ IWl'llll'lllll1lJ hlH \1\1IlIIl!! 1l1Wl'nllllll~, Hp\lolli\lllll)', MI', 1\llul1~)' l'ul'l\lI'llWd IIIH \l1I1I11I!! IlIWI'IIIIIlIIH \IHIII~~ 1111 1I\l1l\~'IOIWllll'\lh nil II plp~ 11\\11 \\'US Ih1l1d \l'lIh,h1uh1)' . 01lIl1h\IHlih1\1 1'\1111101' IInll1lJ \1'1 1 1I1l1l1 1\ 1'1l11nll'\ld 111'\lIl'III\l11 IIH 1111111\1111011 h)' Hlllllinl1 ,l-J"I 1l1'111\1 . " " Nllltlllllll FII'Il Pl'lllo\llllllll\HHIWlllllplI, HllIl1dlll'd 5 I (11) Fll'u Pr\ll'Il11l11111 III \ 'HI! 1l1't'1I11111l! IIml , W\lldllllJ JlrnoOHS\lH I 1)1)'II(dlllnl1, II1l\\hllllplI, Mr, 1\1l011llY p\lrlbl'lllOd hlH 1l1I1I1111l IIp\l1'1I1I1l1I IlI1I1 plpll \11l1l11l1111111111 I1I11hl)' olllllh\ISllhl~ I'lIhl1ol' Ihl\ll' IIl1d 1,,1i IIw 11l1l1\lllll1wllhll\llloll\'ll1lJ 1I1i1'\l . II'IMh III p1110\llhl' 1I111l1lH\ 11111'1)' 1I1111\1tllH 1I1\\l1' Iw plll'lhl'l1\ullllw \l'IlI'K IIH 1'01111lrPII h)' Hllolillll J-J,4 prllw NIIIIIlIIIII Fh'\l 1'1'1l1\l\l1l 11 11 I\HHllclllllnll, Htlll\llll1'd 51(11) 11)1)4 I\llllllllllllld HcpI11l11 J-1,2(d) nr NlIlillll1l1 Fh'll Pl'lllo~IIIlIlI\HHllllllltllll1 1'11111111111'\1 24 I, 19% l\dlllllll, IV, fWMMAHV OF 1,lmAL IHHI'ICH HlmAH1)INCl AUMIHHlIIlI,ITY OF m::rl1MilNY ANllJJ1XUllll11i . II 'iH 11I\11\l11'1\11l1\ thlll dol'oI1lIIl111 11111)' 1l\llll1lpl tll.\llll'nd\ICO ol'lllplIOllllrll I'l'hll'liru 11\ p111tl1111'1'H Ihcllil)', PIIIII1\lITII'IIIIlI1,lcol III \hlH tIlHIIIllIlIl)' l\H 11'1'011l\'1I111 lllld Pl'Il.l\111,lpllIl. lliwllUlL\'.. i!lllUl~uiuJlli...cu., 1 (iD 1\, HSIl (11m), ili '1111\1\11111011, IlItH Illullol' IH II slIbl'llg11111l11 01\li0 IIlld, IlH H\lclh III1Y 1l\'ldlll1c\I Ill' IIlHltl1lOlI)' " . 1'01'o1'r111!! III 1110 l\\cl Ihl\1 plllllllll'('WIIH OIlI1lIJUllHl\11l1\ h)' 111\111' Il1sl11'l\1I00 ClIl'r1lll' IH hlllth1\lsHlhl\l, :1l11l11Illi-Cllll!lk, 4D(J ^, 2d, 1(71) (1979), 1'111111111TI'cq\lllHtH Ihlll tho lI\llIl\lllltollY 1l1'111\'IlIUCH Ihl' !!lllldH Ill1d Hcr\'IIlIlH I'ClldU1'\ld III 1\ll'lhOI'llIlCP or 1'0plllrlI1lJ Ihc pllll1l ho 11111111\1011, V, IImNT",,\, (W WI'I'NESSICH TO BICjd\.LLlm A'l'_TIUAL j, '1lllgCllc s, Koollo)' llmcll WI IIIH1u)' 1J11\'//: I.1UlJ(JO) \'1 -4- Pnll~ln~ II, Mlll'lllllln, I\Hll' ~O~ North Fl'olll HII'\l\l1 P,O,IIOl\ IN\! Illlrl'IHhlll'g, M 17101l.()UUI) I I'll " I' ,. " ,'j, " "I, " " ., " " ., , , " " ,.' " ,.0 "I, ,.' ,)' " " , 1,1, , j; " " , , 'I "" " " " ,I' I " " " ;/1, " '" " 'L " Ii "!.' " " " " " ", .' " " " ". I.. ,. 'i, ,"'I 'j, " " " " " " ~, 01\ J\lly lfi, 1 99\l, p11111\111'1' H\lrV\lllllwllul'uIHIIII1I, 1\\IU\lIW H, Kuulwy, willi HCII\I\lHI fpr t\\ll11lnHloll~, 1)of\l11lhl1H! I\lilWl\c H, KC\ln\lY, r\lHpl1l11l\lIIIO plnlnl1l'1"H I~Pl\\IPSI 1'01' I\llmlHslPII<< on I\\lB\lHI 20, I \l99, 4,' To 111110, IIuI'0111h\lll, 1l\Il!PIIO H, K\lpnllY, ImH 1'111101110 pl'PvhlPliIl<<wllrs III pllllnlll'f'w I. InlcrrPBlIlor\ll<< (Rill I) I\ml (HIlI~) f\I111 Im<< fn IIIl II In r\lnpl1l\lllo p11111\111'1"" gPII\I\lnl 1'111' PnHhlPlllln Ill' POllnnWl\ts, fi, 11\ ronpolHlIlIB III plllllllll'1"s l{oq\I\lSI fill' Admlnnll1n&, II\lfpl\dlll1l, Il\lgonll H, KOllll\lY, fllll\ld III pl'llvldplIllHwol'n '0 IlltPI'I'PlllIl\1l'lon IIlll1oh\llllp Ilw Hoq\l\lsl fur Al!I11IHHlpIlHI (Spo ' plllh\1lff'8 l~oq\lP81 1'01' I\lhnlHHlonn 1IIIIIPhPII horoll1 11<< n~hfhlt ^ 111\11 dol'undnl1l'8 r~8pl1n80 IItllloholl 1I0rPlo 1\8 Il~hlhlt II,) 6, 1'\11'8\11\1\1 10 \110 Ponl1ny1VIII1II1I{\lloH of Civil Prno\llhll'll, dol' 0111111111'8 1I1\8Wor8\p Iho IIhovo dlsoovery 111'0 111llg ovol'll\lo 111111 pllllnlil'l' 1\'111 ho sovorllly proj\lllleod III 11'1,11111' dofolllh\lH IH not COl11pollOlllrl rpspllild 10 Illlllnlll'l"s dIH\lOI'OI'Y rOlj\loHln, , , 7,: 'l'ho IlIfol'lnlltllln 80llgll1 hy IhO.llhovo <II SIlOVCI'l" IH ro10vllnt I\nd rOIlHl)nl\bly 011101111\10<1' , ' , . ' t91ol\<\ to rolol'I\1111\n<\ IIdmlsHlhlll ovll/onco, I\nd IIIH I1ccossl\ry 1\1 pll\lnlll'f for th\l pl'opnrntlon 0f.118 Cl1S0, 1'110 roq\loslod 1111'01'11111(11111 1'1\118 wltlllnlho 800pO of Illfonnl\llol\ dlncovol'l\blllllndor Iho J!00n8ylvllnlll g\llllS of Civil Pl'ocodllrc, Itlld llcfon<\l\nl'R fl\lllIrc to I'OHpOlld 11\ II thnoly .. mllnnor 1'10111108 Iho dlRoovory I'\Ilcn, WIIr!IWFO\{B, pllllnliff,llcll1Pllll'Olhlll'S, lne" I'cHpcell\ll1y I'cqlloHIH IIHlllhlH , llonol'llhlo Cllurt onlol' nnOl'<Iel' compelling dol'ondll11l, 1111gol10 H, Kconoy, to provldcf\lll nnd " cllll1plollll'~8pllllS0H III plnlnllfl'18 f1"sl 8l'I of Inlcl'I'Olll\torlo8\ plnhlllff's second Rol of 111101'l'llgl\lllI'losl plnlnllf'l"s Req\losl 1'01' PI'Olhl\llllln of Doenll1onlH.fIIld 1'1I/1)' I'ospond to II"" I I 7,1 IIIl1'l ,,' I' S~I)lbl\'A " ., 'j' ", " l! " " H Jj ,"' ll' '" " " " ','I' 'i' " " " " .. I' " " q' " I' iI'. " ,..', " I' " 'Jj " I' " j' It 'j 'i "I" " 1\' " ",j; ,. " " jj' " " L' H ff " " " I I' I' /I ". \i ,n " " ,'I, " " ;11 " "1," " , I~ , " It, "I; " " il ., "II , ,. " " " " Ii " .. I ' IUlll.IT1l1Ulln,'r NO.:,Lll Ifyntulel1Y Iho lI\lOV\lI~oll\lesl I'm t\\hnlsHlnn, In whol\lor In pllr\, Ihon all\1\l: (1\) 1~l\ph IIml eVillY fl\pl whlph YO\\ pOl1len~s a\lpporla yom IlImllll; II (b) TllIlldenllly (ll' ollPh porapl1 wllP'hllS porsonl\l knowlo<lllO conpol'l1hm 111\l filcl Ill' fllPla which YO\l conlol\ll s\lppor\s yom IlImll\l; , " (c) Tlwlllontlly \1f\ll\cll doclll110111 whloh YOII ,00n1011l1 SllpportWyo\lr QOlllll\. , ,I . funuul fOl' Production No. 13. PII\.ln\II1' dCl11l\nds prmhlcllon III Iho'lllw omoos of Whllo IInl\ Wlhllll11sl"LP, 1800 Ono l"lburlY I'lnco, I'hllndolphlll, Punnsylvllnlll19\ 0~.7~951 1\ 11'\\0 . nnd corroct copy ofol\cll r100Ill110nl Idunllllod'ln YPllr IInsworlo s\lb.lntcrrolllllory)(c) , " " ,1 hl1l11udllltoly IIboyo, funucsl for AdnllSllJ1I No. \4, AI 1\0 111110 prior 19 Iho firo did Mr, I';'oolloy nak roprosolltnllv\ls of Ihl) pllllnl\O' wllolho[ Ihe pipe e011\nlncd n IInol', ,. !n1~1'I'lll:ntOl'yJillJ4.. \1' you dony thollbovo Requosl rort\dllllsHlon, In ~vhole or'ln plll'l, Ihim sllllo:. I' (II) Elich l\lld ovory filet which YOll eOlltl"1r1s Hupports your donllll; '" " I~.., 201110\'1 Ii " I' " " lltquuL(ucl!.t:udlU1.Il11llll1h.l1i. PllIlIlI 1 11' \lplllllI\ll~ prlllhlPllnn 1I111wlllW IlmpP~ Ill' Whhp. ,. 111111 WllIIlIl11~ I~I.P, 1800 Onp 1,1\1pr\y PIIIO~, PhlliHlp1phlll. PpnnHrlvllnl1l 19103-7305, II \111\1111\11 cPl'rppl pllpr of \lllllh Ilocnn1On\ h!pnlll1od In yom IInawol' 10 ~\'\hlnl\l'TO!!IIIQ1)' \(Il) Imn10IIIIIIPly , IIhIWP, RiuJU\l&I..fut!.AdmlWll1\..&l.J1. WII@ Mr, KO~lwy PIli Iholwn COlli or hnloH, I\~ II~plpl\Jd In 11xhlbl\ "IV', Ih\lIWP ~pcllons ofn1\l\1I1 crolllln!! 1119 11010 folllnl\llho plpu, J..u.I1\lTIllll~ 1'10, 17, If you dpny 1110 IIhoVIll\oquo~1 for ^dmls~llln.ln whnlp or InpllrI, \lwn sllllo: .. (II) !llIch 1I1l1! ovorr fucl which YOII Qon\olllls HUppOrl~ yo\l1' IlImlllli (h) Tho Idol\lhy'ofolloll por~on who hll~ porsonlll knowlm!Booonoornln!! Iho fllclor , ., rllcl~ whlcll you conlond supports your llunlllh , . (0) . Tho Idontlty of olloh documenl whloh YO\l contond SUPpOl'lS YOllr d01\11I1. I' lkqucst 1'0.1' 11roductlou 1'10.11, PlnlnllO'domnnds production lit 1110 Inw ol11CQs ofWhltll , nnd Wllllnms LLPI 1800 Ouo Llhorly PllICC,llhlludo1phlu, Ponn1ylvlIl1h\ 19103-7395, ulmo nnd , " cOl'rcct copy ofcl\ch doclunol1lldclHll1od iI\ your nnswct'losub-ln,lo\Tognloryl(c)lmmcdlnloly nbow. I'~lllnllsn II 15 , , .l1lh1J.'CIlIJ1\.t.ll1~ Nil. 19, lI'rllll (1,IIlY Ihc !\llOV(llt(lqllcst fill' Mll1lssl\llh III wholo or III Pllrl, Ihpll S\O\u: (n) . Unch lIllII pvpry loct whlPh r\lll ClllltPIHls slIppnrls Y\1111' IlonlAI; (b) ThllldcllIlty \lroAch pursoll who hns pUl'sollll1 kllllwlpdau oPlloul'llllla lhu l1\ot or fllpls which YOII COIlI(lI1,1 s\tppnrls YOlll; d(llllnl; (c) Tho Idonlity of eAch 110(lIlIl1Cllt whleh YOll oOlltolld sllpports YOllr donlnl, . . ~lcQllcst for Jll'udlJctloll ~O, 1.2, I'IA/ntlO'denH\n,ls pro,lllctlcnAttho lAW ofllces qfWhhe A"d Wllllnll1sl"I"P, 18000110 Liberty /IllIoo, /Ihllndelphln~ POllllsylvAnln 19103.7395, A tl1le Ami correct O(m~ o(oAcll 'IO~\lIl1(ln! hlonllOed In your AIlHwer to sub-lllterroglltory l(e) hmnodllltely nbove, HeQuest fOltAdlllhsloll No. 20, As II1'0suh of Mr, Keeney cllll1I1B the plpo 011 Fcbl1lllry , ~l 1998, tho Ore occlIlTed, Intcl'I'Olllltol'Y Nil. 20. If you 'lollY !he IIbow Request Ihr Alhlllssloll, In wholo or In pllrt, thell stllle: (II) Elich lIlld ovory tilO! wltlch you oOl1tel1ds~up(lorts yoIII' del1lnli 1~"":111l1l{)\'1 17 i' , ", " " '. " IlCJIII~.frUI' ,II'UdIlClluIlNul.n, Plnhlllll'llclllllmlH prolhlPllnn n\\Iwlnw p!l1cus of Wllllc 111\11 WIIII'"IIII ,10/'1', I KilO Ollu 1.lhurlY I'llIcc, Phllllllclplllll, I'clll\sylVIIIIIII 1910:\-7395, II InlU 111111 col'IllOlllllPY of 0111111 l!\lclIlllCnl.hllll1ll11c(llll yom nllSWcl' tn sll\Hl11crroBlllory l(c) hlllllllllllltuly IIhoVll, UClJucltfUl:.t\llllllu(UIIJ'1D.lJ, Prior III clllllnB tllo 11'10 holcR M IIcplclc\lln flllhlhl\ "II", Mr, Kllllncy knuw thu plpu cllllllllnllllll Illlnlllll1hlll rllhhur I"wr, JIIIIlI'1'flUIIIIl1'>,_NJ/,13. ffyolI (I~n>, IlIllllhovp Itll'llleHI for ",lmlsslon, III wllolll or 111 pnl'l, ' IlIlIn sWill: (II) Hlloh IInd uwry lilel whloll YOII oOlllomls supports YlllIl'llonlllli (h) Thu Identity of Illleh porson who hilS 110rsonll' knowledge concornlng Iho fuct or fllols wllloh Ylln contend HllppOrls YOllr donllll; (0) Thllldllnllty of Illlch documuot II'lIlch you conlend supports your dunllll. " 'i1 ." ,; " 1111":21111'0"1 20 ," l ; ~,~ , ,I. ... '1 i I ~, ., I' W"'TI~ Mill W",',II\~Hi 1,1,1' Il:r: r.PWAI~P A,)Mlllng, Jlt, l\HQIJIHl! 1~\lnlln\lI\llon No, ~~66H 1 HOD Ono \.l\lOI'\Y Plnco . Phlll\\lplphlll,J1I\ 19103-739~ . (~I,5) R(1M322 m~M"T nHOI)" INC, Plnlnlln' CQUltT OF COMMON PI.I\AS CUMnmq.ANP COPNTY . ,. JUIlY 'I'I\IA" PUMANPllP v~, " IWOtiNJU ~, KJUICNEY ,I/h/ll lil, I), ~lil.~NEY Wf11.HlNG Sl'~HVICIU " /\lld IJM,INCOHl10HI\l'EIl NQ, 96.~669 , , pofol\dlllll ClmTIFICATI~OJl sIm.VlclQ I \\0 1I0robr cortlfY Ihlll sorvlcp of II Inlolll\d oorrocl copy oClhp wllllll\ Ilpq\losl fm Adlnlsslons wns 1\1l1do 01\ Iho 161h ,Inr.of "Illr, 1999101110 cb\ll1solllstod bplow by Ullllp[1 SllIlps MIII\, poslngp proplIl[1. .. DlIl\lpl K. DOIII'dorO; Esq\llrp. . MAItTSON DEAIU)OHfi'F W'LLIAMS .'Ii. 0'11'0 1'011 ElIsl High Strool ., CllrHslp, PI\ 17013 [JollgllIs U, Mllrccllo, E~qlllro . THOMAS, 'maMAS & HAfi'len 30~ North FrOl\t Sll'oot, 1', 0, Box 999 / ( A ~L.,'/ .., c........-:. G_ ~L " ..---- "- l:D A'. I A}~Cltm, JI~ . . \ ,/ /' .../r '- L--/ .. I"~" 2011!ovl " , 4, pU11llld, ,11111 dll11luIII\lI\II1P 1I\1111pl Ilmplp)'IJllll IWI'Il pl'\lHu11t nl Il1u \Imu Mr, K.llulWY " '. u\lIl\lu Iwn hpllJH Illllw plp\l Iluphilod IlIl\xhlhll "II" II I ll\lll I' II1l11Wdll\llllv Ihurllnl1ul', II III nll'lIwl' lIV\lrl'od Ihlll 1 1 IlI11 pi Ul11plllYUUII IIl1d klllllVludu~ ,PI' lip \llIIH Illllw plpu IIllplclllllllll(~\llhll"II"ltll1l1\ldlllllll)' 1I1l1l1' MI', I\UIlIW>' IlHldll I\lu ulIl nlld prillI' Illlhu 11 I'll, ~, I\1I1111111l11111 pnl'llnlll dUllllld III pnl'\. IIIH ndmlllud IlInl Mr, 1\IlUllUY phYHlulIlI)' 11111I10 Ilw 'allll In Ilw plpoH llllplolulll11 I!~hlhll "11", II /~ dlll1lollllllll thUl'lllI'uru Ilnllpl11pl . Ill11plnyouH 111\'nlvcd III 111IlI'llmll\'lllorlhu PhIl). IIIH lilrllwl' lII'ulwIlIIHl\ lIumpl Ill11plllYUUH IV\lI'IlIIlVIII'U or Ilw Illlttlduplclud Illl\xhlhll "Il" hnlh prior to Ilwll' hlllllu .. I11ndllll11illhul'llnllul', 6, Adl11lttollln plll't 111111 dlll1lulllll plll't, It /11 IIdl1llllod Ihlll prior 10 mllklllU 1\11)' C\II ollllw pIPIl;MI', l\uIllWY WIlH told h)' 1I0l11pl ll\l1plllYUOli thlll tho~ II'll\lhll'ull1nVo 1I111ltwrll Ill1d/lll' 1l11l1111111hl0 \I1l1turllllH fro III thu plpo nlllllhu \'1011111)' of tho plpo, 11 IH 1\II'Ihor IIVUITOlllhll1 prior 10 I1lllklnu 1I1)~ C\lt In Ilw plllO, MI', KOOIlIlY Willi '.IndoI' Ihu hnproHHlnn Ihnlllol1lpl IllllploYlloH hnd In Ihol ruplOvud nllllllUI'H IIlld/ol' 1l11l1111lllhlu I11l1lol'llIllhlln Iho pi po IIlld Iho \'Iolnlty of thu plplllllld 111111 thoy hlld, III Ihol, dOl1o HO, I\IlY IIlld 1111 otllol' lIV\lrll1lllllll of 1{lllJ\lUIII Ihr ^dl1lllllllol1llll111hol' 6 IIrll dlllllod IIlld 'proof IIl'dollllll1dod III tll1lo of 11'1111. ,. 7, lllllllud, It III dUll Iud Ihlll pl'lol' 10 Iho 111'0, Ihc Iilllll' wllhllllhu plpll Willi \'IHlhlll frol11 Illlhul' Iho lop lll' 1110 hollol11 of IIw plpo, , , , , ',H, Adlnllled'lll plll'l IIlld dOllied III pill'\. It III IId\l1ll1ud 1111\1 MI': KUIllwy rullcd lIJ1olllho rOpl'~IIClIllIlIollH oflho 1I0l11pt olllplll)'COS Ihlll 11wy wOllld 1'Illl1OVC 1I11111l0l'HIII1d 2 , I' ' I} 10" /II " " " " 1l1l111111l1hl\lIlH\lIl1'1i11H 1)'11I1111w 1'1\l11111~.I1r IlIu pipullnd 111I\11IIu)' 1IIIlI, Illli\ol, 111l1l1l HIl, , IIIH 1\11'111\11' IIWITul1 tlllll 1I1l~ IlIwl' 11'1\1111111\0 pi po II'I\H 11111 vlHI1110 III MI', K\I~IlU)' IIIll1ll1l',WIIH 1111)11'1\\111\11111\11' 111m 10 hmK \111\11\1 \lIl\lom PI' IIw plp\l, AllY IIml 11110111\11' , IIvlll'lllpnlH PI' Hpq\lPHII\11' t\lhnlHHlnn H IIrpdul\lulll\lHI PI'Pl1r IH Ilunllll1dllll III I1l1w PI' 11'1111, " 0, 1I1~ IIl111lilluI1IIIIII III nplln1\l pl'lpl' 1\1llwlll'\l 11111 Ml'i I<U\lll9Y pbslll'VO Illly 1hwI' In IIw plpu, I,IIH 1\lrllwr 1l(lmilIP(l'lhlll Mr, I\o\llwy I'ollod \1)1\1lllhll rlllll'OH'OlllllllollH pl'tlw' Ilompt Ill11plnYllc<< 111111 Ihoy wntlld rlllllPVO nlllhl0l'H 1I1111111111111111\1\u 11111\\ll'in\H 1'1'0111 tlw vllllnlty or 1110 plp\lllllll thllllho)' hlld, III Iilcl, d01l1l HO, It 1<< 1\II'IIIul' IIVllITlld 111111 nllY IIIl'ul' wlthlll Ilw plpll II'IIS 11111 vlslhllllo MI', KOIlIW)', I\IlY IIlld 1111 nllwr 1I1'0l'l11OnlH or Hlllj\lllHI 1\11' I\d1111<<Hlon I) nro dllnlod III1lI pl'opr IH d1l111nn(10l1 III limo or trllll, ' 10, Pllnlod, IlIH \Iolll\l(IHHlt Mr. KOllllOY d\dnPt olillll1ino Ihil plpoi II IH 1I\1111ll1od Ihllt Mr. Koono~ rolllld \lpnn tl10 roprllHlln\lltll1l1H 01'11I1l111l111)11 oll1ploycoH tlllllllwy \Vo\llll 1'1l1110VU nllllnol'H 111111 I1nl11l1l1lblll nlllMlnls 11'llmllw vlollllty ol'tlw pi po IIlld 1111\( IIwy IHIlI, 111 Iilnl, d011ll HO, Ills 1\lrllwr IIwITod 1111\1 nlly 1111111' \Vlthllllhu pill\! \VilH not ,. vlHlhllllll Mr, KCllnoy, AllY 111111 1I11'(lllwl' IIvorllwntH ot'RcqucHllbr AdmlHHlon \011I'0 . dUlllulllllld PI'OO((H dQI11llndlld 1IIIInw orlrllll, , II, 1\lll11lttlld Il\plll'l IIl1d dOl1lOlI III 11lIrtl ItIH 1I(1I\\llIod tlHlt prim 101110111'0, MI', KIlQlwy wnH IIwnro tlllll1'\\hhlll' II110rH 1l111Y bll Ilnmmllh10lllld I11I1Y cl'ClIlo n riuk of Ilrlll I' It Onnlll In cOlltllcl II'ItIl n H)1l1rk, 1\ IH donlod Ihnl Mr, Kccnoy kl\IlW ornllylllwr holll!! II1Hldo tho pi po prior to Ihc I1rc, It IH 1\\I't1wl' IIV\lITod thlll Mr, KClllloY,cllnlll'lnod willi Hompt ol11ployuuH thul thoy wOllld rOIl)ll~1l1I1I Huch 1I1l01'H Ihlll1 tho vl~llllty orlho Illplll II,IH 1\II'Ihlll' IIWrrcd Ihn'! Mr, Koclwy rcllcd upDnlhc rcprcHollllltlollH Dr 11m Hulllpl .1 ~lnpl\lYUPH 1111\1 Ilwy WI1\lld I'UI11Il\'(J 1IlIllIwr~ 11I1l11l1l1l11111\\l11l1111I\1lrIIlIH rl'llmllw 1'I011llty 1ll'IIw plplllll1ll 111111 IIwy I \Ill I , In I'lIul, 111l11\lIlO, 111H 1\\1'11\01' 1I\,\IITPIIII1I1II1I1Y Ih\Ol' 1I'111I11I1111l plpo WIIH lIoll'lHIIlhll1l Mr, l~uI!I\PY, 1\1I)'lImlllll 1111101' 1I1'1l1'l11911111 \II" " , I{P\IIl\llll Ihl' MIIl1IHHII111II III'P \10111011 111111 pl'lllll'lH II\lpH\llllollllllillWlll'll'llIl. 12, POlllpd, It IH llllnlod 111111 prl\ll' III \110 IlI'Il Mr. I<\lol\oy WIIH IIWlII''' 1I111111w plpu,lllrll\lul1 wl1hih Iw p\11 two 1I11luII 1J1llltllllwIIII 1I1WI', 11111 1\\I'llwr 1II'0lWd Ihlll MI', Kooll\lY J ,., olllll1l'111Ull wllh 111lll1plUIl1plllyuuII 11111\ 1110)' Wllll1(1 rllllllll'll 1111 s\lcl1 Ihwl'lI frlllll Iho I'lcllllt)' of Ilw plp\l, It III I\\rilwl' 1IV\llTolllllllt MI', I\Illll1\1Y I'\lllcd \IPIlIl Ihll roprollollllllllllla Ill' Ilwll\lll1pl Ul11plllYUOH Ihllt lI10y WUllld 1'011 \Il V\l 1111' Ihl\lrH 11m! 1lIlIl1Il1I1h\\lllll1tllrIIlIH rl'llll1 1110 vlllllllty Ill' Ihll plpllllllll 11111\ ilwy hml, IlIlilOl, IllllIO HII,,, . 1t,IH 1\ll'lhol' 11\'01'1'011 Ilmllll1Y 111101' wllhlll 1110 plPUWIIH l1oll'lHlhlu III tvll', KUlllwy, I\lIy IIl1d 1111 nlhlll' 11\'O\'11WlltH nl' RO\\\lOH\ lill' I\dllllHHlnll 12 111'0 1I1l1l1u\111I111 prnnf IH .. \IU1111111\10l\ 11\ 11111U nl' 11'1111, 13, I)onllll\, ilia donlu\1 1I111\ prillI' In IIw 111'0 MI', Koon6y 1I11v1Hul\ Chll"'oallnlllllllllr Ihlll II . WIIH IICCoplllhlllln lOll\,? tlwllllol' III tho plpo, 14, J)llnllll\ UH Hllllcll, PrI\l1' In Ihu 111'0, MI', Kcollcy cnnllnl1ol\ with 119111pl \1ll1pll1ycllH thl\1 III0y WIl\lIl\ rOI11Il\'C 1I111111\1\'H IIl1d tllll11\1lllhlulI rrlll11lho 1'I011111y ol'lho plpol II 18 f\ll'tlWI' IIwrl'od 111111 Mr. Kocnoy \,oHm' IIpOIl 1110 roprllallnllltlllnH Ill' Ihe !-loll1pt o\1lplnyooH Ihlll IlI0ywnllll\ rOl1lnV\l 1I1111110l'H IIlId tlllll1ll1llhlo 1Jl11101'11IIH I'l'nl11lho vlcllJlty nl' Ihc plpoill1ll tlllII IhllY hlll\, Inl'nc\, dlllJo an, ilia l\ll'lIwl' IIVOITOlf'lhnl III1Y Ihllll' II'jlhlllthc plpo Wlla IlP\l'lalhle Ip MI', KCOIl\lY, Aily IIlld 1111 pIl\ol' IlVUl'l11011tH PI' RcqllUHI 1\11' ^dllllHHloll t 111I1'1ll\olllclllllld proor la \lollll1l1dlld IIltlllW or 11'1111, I, ,I jj .' 1~, I\dllllllo\111\ pll1l1ll\d d0l1111l1 III pllll, II Is 11\11111110<1 111I111I1\1l1' MI', 1{,1l~IW)' llP\ IWIl 1I1l1~s Il\.I1w \l~III~1' pllrlllll\ lll' llw pl111llW WIIH 1'1l1l1l1l'11\1l, Iw 1~l\llw IIHIlWIIII\IIlI\I'OIl wl\hll\ \\'n 11I1I1II1\lH III Ihe d11W111l1\ Ill' \ '11I11'11IS, Illlllhlll\ll', It Ii; 1\ll'Ilwl' 1\\'\11'1'\1111111\\ MI', 1\0~IW>', ~IlIlI1I'IlWd whh 1IIll1lpl \l1H1HIl)'001lIhl\llhuy wllnld 1'\l1111l\'\l I\1I111\ol's rrnl1l IIw vl\lIl\I\>'1l1' IIw plp~, II IH 1\1\'1lwl' IIWl'I'\I<llhll1 MI', l\uUIl\l)' rullud nplll\ 111\1 r~pr~HUIl\I\IIIlIlH Ill'thu 11\ll\lpl omplo)'Il\lH IllIIllIwy WOllld 1'\lI1IOW 1I111hl0l'H unll nl\1111111\11I\1I111\I\lI'IIIIH 1'1'011111\\1 \'lull1ll)' Ill' tlw plpu 111\(1 Ihl\1 tlw)' lind, 111 ,1\1\11. lllllW HIl, " It IH I\1\'1lwl' lI\'urroll1l1l\1 I\11>"lhwr whhllllllu plpu II'IIH nlll \'IHlhllllll Mr, 1\\llllW)', 1\11>' I\nd 1I111l\lwr IIVOI'l1Wl1lllol' l{uqllCHI I'lli' I\dl11lHSIlll11 ~ 111'0 llllllludnlld prnor IH dOnllll1\lo<lIII Ih110 nr Irilll. 1(\, nUl\lcd, It IH dUl1lod thilt nPPl'llxll\HlI\lly 1011 111 I IlnlllH 111\01' Mr, I<ocllo>, Il\lt tlw 1\\'11 h01eH In\lI\l plpo Hl11nl;o II'I\H nhHol'wd olll11hHI rl'llmlh~ pll\l\l, All)' 1II1<1I1II'II\'01'I11\lIlIH nl' \{CqIlOHt Ihl' Adl11lHHlnll 1\\I\1\hol' 1611I'9 d\ll111l111111llprnnf IH 11\l111l1l1\lod nt tll~ 1I1l1\l \11' 11'1111. ,H 17, 1\\1I1\ll\od 111 pllrllll1\l dOl1lod III PIlI'I, IlIH IIlhnllto\llhll\ \\'hol1 Mr, l\uol1o)' Ullt thu'III'O , " ;, .j 00111u1' hnlUH 111,lhu plpu, IIw 11101111 0111 tnlll'Olll1l IhoholoH rollll1ln tho PlllU, II IH'I\lrthol' IIWl'I'od 111111 Mr, KClll1o~ \l1l11111'11\od wl1h Ilul11pl Ol11pln)'llllH thllt 1110>' \\,Illlld 1'0\110\'0 11\1 Huch IhlO1'1l l\'ll\l1 tlw \'101111\)' ol'Ihu plpo,. 'I III 1\ll'Ihor 1I\'OI'I'od Ilml MI'i Kll\lIW>, . rullull lIpo1\lho rupruHolltuli\ll1H 111'1110 1I0111pt Illl1pln)'UOH Ihlllllwy \\'OIIId rlll1l\1VU 1111 IhlUI'IIUl\1I1l111l111111h11l1l1utu1'11I1H lhlllllho \'lolnl1>, ol'tho plpo IIIl.l.lllIlIt thoy 11Iill, hI Ihcl; dnl\o Hn, 1\ IH 1\11'11101' I'vcrrcd Ihlll ul1Y lillOI' \IIl1l1ll1lho plPll \\'IIH nnl Vllllhlll In MI', " , Koolloy, All>' lI11d ul\ nlhol' uVornWl1ts 1l1'Rlll)UIlHllhr I\dl111HHlnl1 17 III'Il <lul1lod III1lI . Pl'onr III dlll11l11\llod lit 1\1110 or tl'llIl. ' "11 " " ,5 " " ',I " I, I H. Adl\1l11~d 111 P111'11111\1 d~l1l~d 111 PIII'I, "IN IIdl\1l11~11111l11 Mr, 1\~~lllJY I~n I1w 1\1'1111111 l1i~ " Ilhwlllll1ol'ChllrluN 1llllll111Wr IIn~r hu IlHldllllw ~II\II, II iN IIvurr~d Ihllll,n~r nlllKlnu Ih~ u1l111 1I\1\IIIWIIIIIIlIJ Ilw pllNltlllllll1lJ ol'lhu crlll1U, Mr, Kcul1u)' pl'Il~eUllcd Illlhe 1I~lIlu hllllllC wllh Ilw KI111WI~dIW 11\1\1 Illl'ucliol1 ol'ChllrlulI 1l11llhllwl', II IN I\lrlhcr IIWlTuII Ihlll Child gOl1k 1111I1 hcol1l1Nllilln~d 101111111111 hll\1l1l1d Willi IIwllrc Ihlll tho cIIIII hill! b~un 1\11111e, II IN 1\ll'lhur IIvol'rclllhlll Mr. l{oIlK. bllllell IIpllI1I1IWllc)' nl' Ilel\1ptll1l1lltllled '. liner 11111'0 Ihu rellr be/bru. Willi I'eqlllrud 10 l11l1ll1ll1ll1 II Wlllol1.lIjior Iho c,II 01' which ho IVlIII lIWlIru. " III f\lI'lhur IIvurrod Ihlll Mr. Keu110r ~ol1llrl11ud with Ilul11pl umplnrculI 1111\1 Ihuy wOllld rUI\111VU olllll1ch 111101'11 rrllll1 Ihu I'lcll1l1)' Ill' tho plpu, It IN f\lrllwr IIvurrud Ihlll Mr. Kuul1uy rellullllpOI1 Ihu ruprullol1ll1l111l111 Ill'lhe 11\ll\1pl Umplll)'OOlllhlll " Ihur wlll\ltI rUIl111W 1111 II I1U I'll 1I11t! llllmmllhlu 111111ul'IIIIII /i'1l1\1 Ihlll'lcllllty Ill' Ihe plPll Ilnd Ihllt thuy Imd, in/hcl, dllno 1I11, "III I\lrlhur IIvurrud thullIl1y Ill1ur wlthll1l1w plpu ,'1' I WlIH I1nll'llIlhlu tll Mr, !\uCllU)', Al1r 11l1d 1111 olllOr IIWrmul11N 01' gcqllclIllhr ^dl\1l.lIl1loll I H IIru dUll Iud 1I1lt! ploot' III dumll1iilud Illllmu 01'11'1111. ,. I (), Admlttud 111 pllrllll1d dUlllud In pilI'\. 11111 IIdmlltud Ihlltnnur I1Hlkll1lJ thu cllt.IlWIIIIII1IJ , Ihu pOllllhl\1ll1lJ or thu crnl1u I1l1d Ihc Ihlll1l'u ot' Ihc IJI'IlI1U. Mr. Kcuncy prouuudud to Iho IIcnlu 1\(1\IIIU wllh thu kllowlclllJu IInd dlrcellol111t' Chlll'lUH llol1ll111el', , 20, DUl1lud. "III dUlllu~1 Ihl\t Ill1ru occlIl'rud 1111 Fulli'lIl1ry 4. II,llJ7 1llllll'uIIIIII ot' MI" KeelluyCllttlnlJ thu plpu, 21, Denlcd, 1\ III don led IIint thero III Iln ovldonue thllt thu 111'0 WUII cUlIllcd hy ul1rthlnlJ Ill' un)'nnu nther thun MI'. Kuclloy'lI clllllnll nf' tho plpu, It III {\Irthor uwrrud thllt tho f1l'o \\IUH CUIIIICII hI' tho nogllgonco or )Iumpt hy Its ulllplll~OOH Inthu lhlhlru In propllro Iho plpo und tho mOlinI' thoulIts und ohsorvu tho pi po IItlur tho 0111 with rugurd tn tho " " " Ii [K1n1lliw~nWI':.lilillI(JCl'; ANi) NnW, \hlllu_m\8~_r:r.:\II!I)' or ^II\l\lllt, , !l)I)Il, I, cY\llhlll P, 1\)'nlll\l\JI'\lII\Q' 111 IIw I\lw I1rl11ol''\'hlll1H1lI, 'I'I\I1I11IIH II!,: 11111'01'. I ,I,P liur\Jhr eUI'I\IY II1\\lllIel1ll\ tnl\J 111111 \JIllT\JC\ Ullp~' \11' Ilw lilrUlJllll11J II\1C\l11lOl1lloll1c lilll\1wllll\ \JO\lI1H\J\ or Iwol'lI, II)' p1l1\l1i11\ II \JI1P)' OI'HII\lW 1111110 IJnllud ~III\UH. 111'111 CItIHII 1111111. JlllH\IIUO Jlrupllld, n\ldl'~IIHUllnlllilllll\vH: HdwllnlA, .l1l\J1J\J1" ,II'" I\Hlllllrl\ Whllu 1I\1l1 W11I11I11111. \.I,P 1 HOO nnu 1,I\lllrlY Plllc\l Phllll\ll'lphln, I.l^ ..10 I OJ.!J:l05 DIIIlI\lII~, PUllnlorl'f, I\H11"lru . Mllr\~IlI1. \)unrdol'l'f, WI\ 11111111 I'/:. Otto' '\'UI1I\III1\ 11IIJh ~ll'uu\ Cllrlhll\l. PA pop, " , , r- ~'r1.~ '.----- --'-'-\! ~"~- ----- . ~~J1YlIIII)~ I'd. .. .. r .' , I' i, ." ,;" II ,I; , 'i ji H " , , ~, P~nt~rl, 111& 4pnl~11 IIH\I nollpmpl ~mpIOY~OH wor~ pl'~i~nl M 1I111 Hm9 Mr, t;~~nllY ~\lllh9IW\1 hplp~ In IhQ plpo Ilopl\llollln f.xhlhh IIU" Qlllllnr Inmw\iIRI~lr lhprPllft\lr, It t, ,; li I t i~ f\lrlhor <<vorrerl thll' Hempl omploY~~ft hl\rl knowl~rl~\l pftlw elltsln Iheplp~ . llepllllorlln r.1Ihlhll"A" Imnwl1t!ltelr I\nor Mr, KocMy m"lIo tho CIIII\I1I1 prior to the 01'0. ~, AdmhlOrlln p!lrlllnd d~nlorlln p!lrt, It 1& !ldmll1~.rl thl\l Mr, K~ol\\lY pllyslol\lIr ml\ll\! , . . , Ihll O\llsIII Iho plPllS qaplcwrlln 1111hll* 1I1l". 11 18 ltonlod Ilml tharll werp 1\0 Hllmpt ~mplo>,oes lnvolvorllll the romov!ll pf Ihp pip\!, IIlst\lrllwr RVCrrod Ihllt Hpmpl emplpyocs were IlWllrp of IIw cUls ,deplcled In Exhlbllllll" \loth priQr to tlll'lr helnB . I1wlle 11l1d Ihortrl\flOr, 6, Admitted In pllrlllnl\ donlod In 1'111'1, II Is I\dmltlod ~llIl priP! to mll~\tlU I\I1Y Q\11Cllllho . plpp, Mr, Kellney W!ls lold hr Hempt emplpyoos mill Oley wonlr.\ rllmpVt,1 1\1I1lnOf$ , ' " ,. I' I\ndlor nllmml\ble mlllorillls from tllll pille IlnQ Iho Vlclolty pfth~ pipe. 11 I~ I\Irthclr ~v~lTcd th~t prior to ml\klnllllllY ollt 10 the pipe, Mr, K~llllllY WII$ 1l0Qur dill Impression Ihal lI11inpl emplClYooS 1"leI III fnol rcmowd IIl1llh~rs Ilndlor f1iunml\hle .. mlllerllll from tho plpollncl the vicinity ~f the pipe Rod th~1 thoy hnQ\ In fllct. done ~o, Any nl1d.nll other ~vonnc.nls of Rcqllcal for Admission number 6nre denied cmdpfoof Is delllllnded lit time of \rIll!', !' j ,it 7, Denied, It Is donted thlll prior tl) tho fire, the finer. within tho pipe WIIS visible fro," either tho top or the bottom of Ihe pipe, 8, Adh1111ed In pllflllnd denied in pllrt, It Is admitted U,~t Mr, Koelley f<lllcd'uponthe roprcscntlltlOI\S of tho HelOlll clOploreOB thlltthoy Would fomove Illl liners and . ., 2 'i , ,I' I; , . ,. "I' " FI~DI'\ 11l10,1'\t'iS 'll\(JI'\FIS " '11'(~H!\UP 1'1''''1'1\1'1 flflmmlllll\l mnl9fillls flam \III' vl~\I1\lY nflh~ plpu I\II~ lh~\ Iher Iw., \11 fMh ,Ion!' "n, II I~ !,mh!'f AVCm~ IhM IIIlY lhwr wlIhll1 Ihepipc WI\S 001 V161~19 In Mr. K.\lcn\lY 1I1l~/nr WIIS ImpmcllclIl fpr him 10 Il1n~ 1111 tho \lnllnm nftho p\JlI'. !\l1y 1\1101111 othl'l'. I\Vcllllllols of !tcl\\lllsl(Qf !\rlmls~hm III\rpIl9nlelll\l1~ propf Is ~llm\lnrton AI 11m!,) nf' , . ,.' trllll. 0, II is lIomlnel\ Ihlll I\t no limp prior 10 thel1nl nil! Mr, Koeller ol'SlIfW lIl\r liner In thQ plr~: tlls fm1hpr "c1mll\QlI thll\ Mr,'l\.\lI'Ollr rl'lIlIlI Ilpon tho l'oprcs\lnlllllpns nf1he Hompt emploYllllS IhM they WOllin rllmoVlln\l Hrcrs 1\0(\ f1l1mmll\:llo ml1tennls frnm Iho , vlolnl\)' pflhe plpllllnll Ihl\l.lh~Y 111\11,111 fllot, <<nno 6Q, l\ Is fllrt\lI'r IIvlIlTocl thlllllllY IInorwl\l1ln the pipe WIIS nol vlsl~le 11'1 Mr, I\.el\ney, Any IInd 1111 ,olhor IIVlIrmen\Il nf Reqll!,)sl,t'or A~mlsslnn 911rc IllIniel! ami proofh nom\lnlle~ III tIme nflrlll\, . \0, Pentod, lll~ Ill.lni\lcl thllt Mr, Keeney oln n.oll.lllnmlne \lwplpe. Itla l\~mlncll th~t Mr, 'KeeneY rIl\le~"pOn Iheroprll~llnll\llpnB llfthcllemplomp\oyoeB .\hal tlloy WPlllq I' " Temove 1\IIIIIIors llfll\ llllmmnhlo malorlftl$ from the vlcln\ly of Ihe plPellnll thl\\ Ihey l\IId, In flleltdoM ao, 11 Is t\lllhorl\vollUlllhlllnny liner wllhln Ihe pipe wlla not . 'I .' vl~lble to Mr. Keeney, Any IInll nl\ ather i\Verrnellts o(ReqlleM for.l\dmlaslon 10 nro llenllld Md proof Is doml\n~ed 1\111010 PI' 11'111.1. 1\ , Admlttod In part lllld donled\n plln, 11 Is IIdml\\oct Ihlltplior 10 tho fire, Mr, Keener'. WlUlllwnrO dllll rubber IIncra,mllY ~e flllmmab\o Mil IllIlY 01011101\ rlR\( of Ore If II oame In oontnol wld\ II apllrk, 1\ Is dellled Ihlll Mr. KOeller knew of My liner bolllg Inside tho. pipe prior 10 dIe Nre, 1\ Is t\ll1her averred thaI Mr, Keeney conflnnoll wltll Hempl employeos tllM Iher would remove all such liners from lho vicinity of Ihe plp\l, 1\ III ,. " "1 f\trther averred Ihllt Mr, Kr.;l\\or Telled l\pontlle lepreSOlllatlona oflho Hempl .J , " " " I " ,. I:ROI1! T1101'\R5 111DI'\R5 IlJI ':;Il~lbl;lp'l (I~!.l ~mpll1yep~ 1\11\1 Ihuy WPIII1\ r\lIHoY\lnllllnmnll\1 nl\lllmll~l\l lnlllelillls lfllm tlw . vlcinllY lit' Ihe plpo nOli Ihqlllwr hnQ, III filel, IIOIW SQ, It Is flll1her "I'elw~i Ihllllll1Y III1\lr wllhln \h!l pipe WAS Ill'll vlslhlo 111 Mr. l\o\lI1\l)', Ally l\n~ 1I1111llwr lW!lnnpnls (lf .. .1~O'l\les' fl1r Achnissllln 11 Mil chmiellnnl1 rrMf Is clOnlnmlpcl,llIllnlo pf Irllll, l~, Donlyd, 11 Is cl\llliol1 Ihlll pripr to .Iho I1fe Mr, I\PPIWY WAS lI~lIro Ihlll Ihl' ripI' Info\llJh whlllh ho 1l\1I1Wll holes cC1I\Inlnun A IInor, " I~ fllnlwr nl'urretlllml Mr, Ko~nlly Ill1nflnn\l11 with li\llllpl \lJllpll1rQ\l~ IhuI Iho)' woulll r01l\Pvl,l1l1l sllch Iil1crs Irom tlw vllllnily of Ihll pIpe, Ills f"nllor "verretl thlll Mr, Keener rpllol1 \lpon I.hll rllplllSOlllllllpns of Ihl' Hempl omploro09 Ihlll HIlly w(l\\lrl rpmow IIl1linmlllll1 . IllUl\mllhln millennIa fTOm Ihe vlclnlly ofthQ plp\lllllrl IhM they hlld, In fIlPI. done so, II tsl\Inhllr AVllrred IhuI III\Y liner wllhln Ilw plpo WDS 110t vlslhlo 10 Mr, KellnllY, Any llnet ~1I olher IlVonlWnls ofReq\lASI for Admission 12 lire denlfld 111111 Pl11l1f 19 tlenlllndod AI Ume oftlilll, " 13: Denied, IIIR4C1nle<l thlll prlnrto Iho'fire Mr,Kcol1oy n{lviscd ChnrlQs Ilolllngor Ihllt It \lIIIS 1I0corlllblo lolol\v~ tho IIher In Iho pipe, . , . 14, Ponlod OS ,SIll lcd, !'rlor 10 tho firc. Mr,1<.oelll,l~ cOl1finncd with HomPlemployoes Ihlll Ihey wOllld rQI110W IIU IInors and f11\",mllbles from the vicinity oflho pipe, It is I\lrlher nvcrrcd Ihlll Mr, Koolloy roUCld ~'pon the reprosonl~llons 01'11\0 Hempt " .ompl\lyees Ih"llhcy wqlllel lel\l(JVO nil liners IInd t1aOll1\nble mRtcrlnls fromllle vicinitY of the pIpe IInd Ihnl thoy lind, III fnetl, done so. It Is 1\ll1l1or IIverrell U\l\t nl\)' Ih~er wlU\ln t1.~o pil,e Wns not Visible 10 Mr, Keoncy,'AIIY and all OIlier nvermenls of , Itoqllc$1 for ^dllllaslon 14 life dOllied nlld rroo( Is dOn\alll1cd 1\1 time of Inlll. " 4 ;J, " --,.-f' " I1W\,. I'lj ~~ \,j~ I.?\:> r tlW1'1I I nUI'II;::' IIWI'!',':> 1\.,1, ;'1.4~-4.,1~tJ'll.iU.J 11"I.:.lI-'~W l.i 1~,J' 'H.J~, '" 1 fi,MIIlIII~\\ In Pllri I\mlll~I1IPl\ In PIIII, It I~ l\~miIlQ,lihl\ll\ftpr Mr,l{.uPlwy P\ll IWo . , ,. , , ' hl)l!l~ In jh~ 9\1nlPf p\lrllol\ "I' Ihe pl~~ hp WI'S rompvln~, he 1~f1lho Immc~hll\l IIroll wilhln Ipn mlnlllpa !lllhll \1lr\l9tllln nl'Clmrlc9 n"llInMPr, Ills ftmhcr nWITll\\ Ihlll Mr, I'{.lllllWY p(lnfirm~~ wllh Hompl oll1ployQQs Illl1llhey \\'011111 rcnwvo nil IIncrsfrpm Ih~ . vlolnlly of HIll plp~~ II \9 I\lrthllr llV\llTQ~ Ihlll Mr, K.QollPr rollp" IIpnn Illll roprPA\lnllltlons of Ih~ H\lmpl Cmplllro\lslhllllhey W?"111 remove IIIIIInPrs !lnll " flflmml\\ilc ml\lcrllll~ from lhp vlplnity llflhll plpu Rnll ,Imllhllr hllll,ln fAPI,lIpno sq, II Is t\n1hor IIvcITOlllhnlllnY IInar wllhln Iho pipe Wl\s nl1ll'lslhlo III Mr, Keonoy, Any " IInll 1\11 olhQr IIVQmlcnl$ pf lteq\Iosl for M.nlslIllln 15 1110 ~onlp~ 11M proofip . . , c\pmllndQd l\IlImo of lrllll, , , , 1~, Pllnhld, II Is c\llnlcc\ lhlllllpproxlmllloly Ion mlnlltos 1If1~r Mr, Koeney 0111 tho '1'10 holos In Iho pipe smok\l WIIS 0\lsc"'o,1 el1mlnB nom the pllll\l. AllY IInd III1I1V\lrm\l"'~ j' ' of RQq\lOSI I'M Admission numppr 16 lire denied llnc\ prol1f 18 dcmlllldec\ lit 'Iw time of' trilll, " ,. . l7,MlTI.lnedln pllf1 nnd c\cllled In part, 1118 n(lmllled Ihllt,when Mr. I\.eenoy c\ltlhll two II " center ~(\Ipp In the pipe; the moml CII\IO crento Iho hole8 fell Into lhe plpQ. Ills i\lnhor " il avenel\ Ihlll Mr, I\.oolley conflmlcdwlth Hempt Qmploy~os Ihlll Iho)' woII1,' romove ~1\ 81111h Ilnetst\'om thQ vlcllll1y oflhc plPII, \lIs ful1hor l\vef\'Qd lhIlIMr,.KQon~y ,. relied IIpor thq roproHulIUltloll'S of 11\0 Hempl employoeslhlll they would remove al,l . , IInor9l\l\d tlnmmilble mntetlnhi fl'l1ln the vlclllhy of tho pipe IInd thMlhoy had, In fnet, .' do no so, It Is f\iithor "verted Ihllt nil)' IIncr wlOlln UI~ pipe wils not vlslhlo to Mr. ' Keeney, AUY nod nil other nvcflIlenls of Reqllest for Admlssloll t 7 !lIQ donlen nnd proof Is demtlnded nt I\mo of trlnl. ,__i 5 ,: ,. d' , ., " d, .',. I' Hljl:l"r.\:l \J\J \';J'b~ 1"1'lJ1'IIIIILJI'IH\:> 1I11J1'lIn, "i 1..~lllP:~ ltJI ~Ir:::.l :nJp't I J.~") , , " t' I~, Allmlll\l4ln p~r1 ~llll rlonlQllln p1ll1, It I~ Mlmh1\l11 Ihlll Mr, KeelWr Ipn tlw IIrllllIII Ilw 4Ir~\ltlpn I'll' Challoi Ilplllnppr !lflllr hp llll\ll~ Ihplllllfl, It I~ nvlltTIlrl Il\I\ll\l)or Il\II~hlll . Iho 1l11!S IInlll\wl\lrlil~ lho ppsillplllnll PI' lh~ r.mnc, Mr, KCIl1l9)' prnccpl!pcllo Ihll ~QIIIIl hl'lllflll wllh tho ~llnwllll\plll\nli rllroc'llol1l1f Chnrlps Ilnlllnpllr, II Is flll'lher >>VIlrrPQ tlml ChQrlltnn~ hllrllwlln I\ssl~'lCrllo II&OISI 111111 IIn4 Wl\flI\Wl\re thlllllw ell1s hllll hllPn mlldll, It Is fllrlhnr nvm04 thnt Mr, Rnnk, \lllsed \lpnn 0 polloy of Hempt Instltlltlll\ nOer 1\ tlrp Ihl' rOllr Ilofl1ro, WIIS rllcllllrerllP mnh\lllln II wll19h IIller Ihli em I'll' Wlltl'h hp wllflllwlIrCl, It Is f\lI1hcr Ilwrrprl !hlll Mr.l<llcllloy Ilonlimwd with Hempt omploYllos . Ihni they wP\lld remove 1111 sllch IInClra frllmthc vlcinhy of Ihl1 pip", Ills litnhcr ,. IIvon-Pll 1111I1 Mr. Kelllley rcUpll \.Ipllll Iho rcprosPnllI\lons oflho Hempl emplllYcoS IhAl " , , Ihe)' would ren\oVQ All liners nnll tlllmmlll,*, mlllerlllls fro", Iho vlclnhy ofthQ rlpCl ~nll U\llllhey hllrl, In filet. Ilone so. II Is furt!wr Ave Ired IhlllllllY IInor wilhln 11\" pipCl Wi\!l 111'1 vlslhle 10 Mr. !,-eene)', Any /lncl !lit olher lIvomlon\s of Requesl for Arlmlsslon 1ft !lCP donled IInd proof Is domllnlled 11\ IInwof Irllll, , 19, Mmllleclln pllrlul\d denied In plt", Ills nc\mlllocllhnt lifter mllklnlllhe CUI. IIwnllinll Ihe poslllonlng of the CTlInll undthe f/llluTO oflhocfIlno. MI', Keene)'procllcded tt;! the aClllo house whh Ihe Iroowledll~ IIf1ll direction of Ch~rlos flolllnger, 20. Delliod. Ills delltod'lhlllll fire occurred on February 2,1997 ns liroslllt ofMr; . Keonor CUIIIIl(llho pipe. 21. DOllied. It Is denied Ihnt lhcru Is 110 evidence Ihllt Ihe tho WM cnused hy unythlnll or anyone other dlllll Mr, Kccney's cutting of the pipe. 111$ further, Avetted that Ihe ilio ., WIlS CIIllsod ~)' ,the negligence of Hempl by its employocsln Ihe fnlluro tD prePllfO the II " p1lllll\nd the ntlll\ of Ihe ClllS IInd obscrvc the pipe I\fter the cllt with roglltd Illlhe " ,. 6 n\"\i-',~JI u " . , , " ;; " I;' " " ,. .... 1(' ""1 ii' 17; ., " If; j'.' 1~}J 1""1_1" 1.1 , , (~\~ h~ I, , ! i, ."r ; l- ~- ;~! ( ,I', I), Ij') Cl.. , i ~,>:, , i idi;h (, , 1',' , ,~l!) 0.., I .. , . ~, .. I , ;;j ( 'J (;:' U , . . ~ " " I' " ., " II" Ii II " I.. H '.!, , ,. " " I" jf ii, ,. -I! !l Ii H , " i' ,. ','j.,.-, .' ',. Ii ii', I< ., .' ,. :1 Ii jf ",' I; " " ,. ;j, " " " 1-, " " ,\ ,. " " " t-, .! '" " , . II! I' , ' ; I') , 1 -, H " , . ,,' " II 1, " , il Ii ,i'; " " " " .l' -,'I' " '1 I; " " ,'I " " " ,,' ". 'I' /' H "Ii .," c. " " " , H " " i! ~ " " Ii " " ". 1'. " " " " " H " "i '" ." ;".,. 'OJ, " , , !-, c Ii ,,' , . ii-" " " " i' " " II " " 'I, 'I " " " , " "I! "" " "I' :ill:l-. .11.'1"': hl.''\'III;1I HHoIII,AIi " eA':F 1111 I 1'1',11\ 111!,loI,'1 I' 1:1'11'11'1111)1'/1,'111,'1'11 .111" i'lillll::'!'I,"AIII II: en 111'1" 'Iii' I'; 11111 ':(11,/\ II' " " .' \II': 1'\1 "!:. .!I!illti .1'111: , ! 'I ~ - , 1 1\1';1':[11::'( r:III}J:!II;:, l:i 1':,'1'. !\ I" " ,1\I<HI!I.:;J!L,(i\l!;~.:I';Ii'.I' ::1'1'1'1\,1( II 1'1 I II I PIII)I !:'I H',II 1 f r _1,l,I' .,.",j" , Itpl)ll r't;'llIli,,/lvdliid, Villi hvtoC(-.lltly j I' d I. ' \lll" i I' !'!IJ:!}LJ; ^J!L' 1,:mll'l,,\r liT' , , Jil';!':I!I';'(I:;llI'dii!I!L:: 1\( 1\ (II 1';,!:YI'Tli 1';1' ,1'11:1,111 ) IIi, i,\{111 II 11(\\'(11,0:1 i flU C:Ui'lIII':I,I.IIIII' (:1."1111)', Lu -',:iH, lJiI)'I';, LlII' ~/ ,.I : I U(dl '/nd :,:I':l'\' 11:1': I.h" dt'fupdllnl., ul I,,) ;,~-rJ lllllll~::. (1)1 Llpl ,_,(,Ijl. ,1,1 rkl," dJ rl~' 1.1__1.1)1'"'-' .' ,..' tq~lI\ iii, H'!.'!I 1:1(1\1'11':::, 1l/\I',.){118I' C:,II BL:,l,:':].,\';,,!'^,. ):,''''1.' " " ."/' ,I,}iI'llll:WNI,II I:OIIII'\.}.', 1.1 l.l'llFI l)PIIII~'Jytll'I(l"lrll 1')\1 /, ",11,,11,111\ I" 1::\lI!F:/Wlil::VIII':Y , " . "I II", ,,11/,IJI.',:!~!i1q, CII1'!I.'I,td!/I, dod ul"fr,'uI.LltJ ":"Pi~ Hll',\ nt. Lhr' ::ii.lllll_ol lillll:' ',I:iI'FJf:'I:jlH,f \t.!.:.l, ':II,\"'I'II.:I[III'Lu I Ill" un~\t','_'llLld UII_\I'f;"IJ. i' r;!'II'j'r-1J -r ' ~,) l::l'IC; I: ITl Pnr:I~r.[LJ Ilq nul' v:i. t:~I_.1 . l,fLi.d,"vJ I ! ; III ~.' I, tll \il. " :1<, r~~W"~<: ti~t!.~ F~-, Thrl/iirui I,:lllll',/, '~;hl;;-lTff' (), mV) :1. .1111 I ItWI c., (f,e,) '!I'1.!~i', '1' 'IJ 1'1111'1'1,: .1', 1'11'1.1.1/11'1': 1. (/1 /<~(, / l'i'JQn 1 " II);, ..,. , !r:_;WI,'l\'1I drH.l 1.:,\1 b:.'H) I IIHhl 1...-, hl:lj'i'll'l;' IIII' \.1,1'", J~.fl~ ..1";\' ;" G)tL,-h~ " e,l' " .1'),. ~ A. II, '. '('~-\'/'t."'~I" C':\,ll'l}L<..til."" I !l-Q,~'r., I '";-1 -'III _ 'iI,'ll"II,ili)l1 'r , I, .. !i "I' I;" I'" " f' , 1 ''l'J' Il,-, , ',~ QOMMQNWI~fll,TJlQE.EI;NN6.),I~V ANIA QQlJNIY,QE.CUMlJl:B1.ANQ " , , I' III\MI''I' I II(()S " IN( '" 1'111111111'1' IN Till! COlJlt'l' OF cOWvloN I'I,IW, ()II : ('Il tvfl 1 Iill I.""Jp ('Cl\JNTY, I'I\NNSYI.VANI,\ v, NO, !lH.5(rfl') IHJClI\NI\ S, KlqiNI!~:d/\l/1I Ii,S, KliliNEY WI\/.I1INCI SI!IW\C'H 1I1ll! U\'I\ 11'H'OI~l'oM'I'lm. pol\JI\dlllllS : JIJIW Till" I. PI\MI\N\l1!1l 6.U6P-OENA.IOJ?RQOJ..lQf:-RQQJlMf;NIMBXLiINGB EQIU1l60,QVf;RY..EUR6UANU.QBUl.~.QQO.2~ TO:' CU~IOlllnn of Rooalcls, I<,R, MoDonoldlnallronr.o Ago!]oy, 1'08 4500, Harrl8burg, PA 17111 (Nill"O of "11'000 01 flnllly) \'mh'n Iwonly I?OI dllYo 111101 oll",lcII 01 \hl. OIlhpoo"., Yllil.'Ollld~"o'llI1 U.. COIllllO produeo Iho lollawlou doo\II""olo or IhlnUB: A copy qr any ololm fII1l8, p11010grap118, s1010mon18, wrlllng8,11010Q, or any oll1or documents fl11l1rilnlng 10 loa60a Il1clllrocl by Hempt ar06; Ino,ut \l1e ToloO(IPlonl of lIompll3r08, <1' (lny lime, Inclucll,io,but nolIImllod10 1110 flra Ipaaos f'olmll1ry ~, ,1908 ondll1o flro 108a of Jmlllury 30, 1997 '1 l'I'IOMAS, TI'10MAS & HAf'gR, ~~P, 306 N, Frool8lrool, poa 900, Harrlaburg, pA 17108 IAddrooo) You iliaI' dollvol or 1lI01l100lhlo caploo 01 UIII docul11o.la 0' II,odllco U11,,0' rnquoallld Ily Ihla oullllOOllO, lll\Jlllho, Will, Ihll cOIIIIIClllll of cOlllplloneo, 10 11'0 pOlly ",,,kino Ihlo rll'lllool ollho odd,o." 1I010d obow, 1'011 h'Vll 11m IIOhl 10 oOllk, In "'voneo, Iho ,olloon"I,lo r.ool of Plol,ollnu IIw COlllllo or prodllclno Iho lIil'l\l' .0uUhl, . . "you 101110 Plo<lUClllllo dOOlllll01\10 01 Il1ino. 10nul,o" hYlhl. oulll'oon.. 'N~hln twonly I~O) <lI\Yo nllllr 110 "lVlco, Ih~,pOlly ,Or/'"0 11110 oullpounn . lI1"y ollok 0 cOlul a,dol c0ll1pollll111 you 10 c0Il111ly Wilh II THIS SUBPOEN~ WASISSUI:D AT THI: REQUg8T OF mE FOI.i.OWING PERSON: " ., NA~!U_0J2UlJlruiJLM<1!.CJWQ~(;lil1ulr.u Aoonfiss.aOlill...ErQot..alt!.1.lll,EQlill911 l:tl.llrjalllJ[g~~l.1.QD, T fi ~ fiP 110 N r: ; .LZ.11.L7.3.Z.:Z.1!L1 SUPHr:~m coutu II) No: __-.:iaalll__..._. ATTonNl:v I'OI1:.:.:.D.QfQill1uoLKwlOllY___ DATE:.\!l,Wl~a....____, f'lolhonolory/Clolk, Civil Olvl.loll ill Dopuly Soal of tl10 Courl. " ", .j" " 6. ponlll'q, Anawllrlnp Polone1l1l1\ \s wllll01l\ l\I1owleqge or Inlorll1p1l11l111S 10 the \Hllh 01 \llllllvennenlspl Pl'1rllQl'llpll 6 IIm-l, lis sllPh II Is clllnleell'1l1cl p[ool \lwreol Is c1lllnllnqlld 11\ Ihe .. , Ih111l 01 \rllll, ,. 6, A~Il1I\\lld In pllr! Ilnq qllnlocl In PIlIt, Ills Ilclmlltllct tl11l1 on or prior Ip 1:Il\Jn/llrv g, 1P\lB, PIFllntlfl req\lllstl'lcl ~uglmll a, !<lloIWY 10 removll FI a\3o\lon 01 plplnQ. Any ~mq FIll pll1l3r ~vermllnlEl .01 PPfF\Qfl'lpl1 B mil qllnlllcl IlS Ihe Answering pefemlf1nlls wl\lwul. knowllldgll or Informll\lon 1111 10 the Irl.llh of \l1e IIvermenla of Pl'lrf.lgff1ph 6 I'Ind, liS s\lph It Is qllnll:ld Ilncl proof Ihereof Is d{:lmllnq{:ld pI \116 time of t 1'11'1 I , 7, Admllleq In pl1rll1l1d clenlecl hi pllrl, It Is pdml\led \11111 ~\lQene 8, !<eeney I1I1Q prevlp\lslyworl\{:Iq III Pll1ln\lll's plllnl, It Is I'Iqmlllsq Ihl11 ~Ugene 8" Keensy I1l'1d preVlo\lsly worlled on Pllllnlllf'EI plpllEl, It I~ el{:lnleq 111111 ~1I0Sn{:l 8, I<seney 111'111 previously WOl'keq on or " ' !\I1IlW QI pipes oontlllnlng rupper IInlnll, AllY !\nd ElII oll1er Iwefl1113111s of Pf\rIlOlllp\1 7 Ilre denied IlD9 proof Il1ereof Is tfem!\nded Ilt 111{:1 tln16 of,lrl!\l, 8, Denied, Ills !\dmltled \11111 Mr,l<seney used 11 toroh 10 sever 11 pipe, U III de,nled , tl1l1ll1a W!\S !\wmllll1e pipe \lpol1 whloh he W!\S worklngllllcl II I'upper liner, 0, 'Denied, It la Ildmllledll1llt Mr. !<eeney uaeel !I 10rol110 oLillwo 110leElln the pipe, II Ie denied Ihlll he WIlS IlWllre Il1e pipe \lpOn wl1lol1l1e WIlS worllll1O hlld 11 ruppar liner, ;. II 10. Admitted In ,pllrt IInd denlecl In pElrt, It Is f.ldmltled 11111111 Ilr~ oocurred al Pll1lntlff's plllnl, Any ,and 1111 oll1er Ilvermanls Ilre dllnled, In Ihe Illlernllllvl3, Anawel'lno pefendllnt la wlll10ut Infonnllllonor pellef Ila 10 Ihe Irull1 of Il1e Plllllnoe of 1I1e Ilvermants IInd ~roof Is demllnded III lime pf Irllll, 11 ,Pl3nlaq, U Is denied tl1l1lll1e lire and resultlno dllmlloe to Pllllntlff's property WIlB a dlreot Ilnd proxlmllte resLilt 01 pefandlll1t I<aeney's work In oulllno Pllllnllll'B pipe wltl1ll1e Uae of ' 1110,'011, 12.Penllld, Anawerlng Defendanl la without knowledge or Informallonlla 10 Il1e Irutl1 of Il1e Ilvermenlll 01 Pllragrllph 12 and, Ila suoh It Is denied Ilnd proof tl1ereof la demanded III the time of trial, 13, Pallled, Answerlno Defendllnlla wltl10ul kMoWledoe or Information aa to Ihe trull1 of the averments of Paraorapl113 Ill1d, as auol1ltla danl.ad al1d praol tl1ereofls demllnded IIllhe .. \lme 0111'1011, 14, Denied, Anawerlt10 pelendlllllla wlll1tlul knowledge or InlormatlQn 111110 Ihe trutl1 01 the averml3nla 01 Pllragrllph 14 lind, as suoh Ilia denied and prMf tl1ereof III demanded Ilt Ihe \line of trial. " , " 1 Ii. Ppnllld, Anl1w~rlnQ Defendllnt 111 wllllOHI knowled(J1I or Inforl111111011116 Ip IIw 11'(llh pf \he IIverl11pnls of P1Irll(JrI!ph 16 1Ind, as suoh It is denledanet prpof thereof Is qll11111ncla~lllt Iho lime oflrl1l1. QQYtill . NllulluenOll' Hllnlflll3roll" 11111, V, 1=1111111111 a, 1~llllnpy fflh/ll 1=, a, Kllllnoy Wllh:lII1U allrvlllo 16. The Answerlno DefendAnt Inoorpor1lle6 PlIrll(J[lIphs 1 throuoll 16 of pefendllnl's Al1l1wer wllh New MlIller 10 Pl1Ilnllff'lI oompllllnt liS If 6pl forth In flllland mllde II pint 11llrepf, 17, Pllnlaq, .11111 denied thllt flny dmn1loa 10 Plalnllff's prOI~ElrIY anel expellees Inourred releV1lnl 111I3re\0 were ollllsacl IJy allY neolloel1l, reokless or ollrele6s l:1ola' or omissions of pefel1dllnl. (a) penled, II Is'denled IImt Ihe pofendllnl fl:1l1ed 10 or was reqHlred 10 properly Inspeot PllIlnllff's plpll1li for known hl:1~l:1rd6 lind/or oomll\lslIlJlel11l11erlllls, I:1ny lInd..all I:1l1llOl:1l1ons ofkl1own ha~ards or oomlluslllJle mf.1IEHllIls are denied Iwl proof Iherllof Is del11anded lIllhe lime pflrlal, (IJ) penleQ, II Is denllldlhat Ihe Defel1danl flllllld 10 tl:1kll neoe66ary preoll(llIons 10 prevenl spllrks, flames or holelllllars from oomlno Inlo oontllcl wllh comlJuatll~le malerlllls, II III epeolfloallY denied 111111 Ihe Defendl:1nl knew or 6hould hllvelmown Ihll\ oomllusllble I11l:1terIElla.. were within PllIlntllf'a plpll1(J ayalpm, I, (0) Denied, Ills denied Ihat the pefendllnt flllled 10 follow proppr, 'l:1ccepte~ oonatruollon lIl1d Welding pracllcea, (d) Denied. Ills denied Ihllt Ihe Dllfendl:1nl fallecllo warn PlalnUffof Ihe c11:111(Jera of usll10 a weldll1g loroh on Plalnllff's piping and/or Ihe Defllndanl waa required to do ao, Any' Elnd all alleglltlons Ihat Defendanl knew or should have known that Ihe piping oontlllned . . oomlJuallble l11alerlala EIre QenleQand proof Ihereof Is demllncled allhe lime of Irllll, (e) Denied, 1\ Is denied thai the Defendllnl failed \0 perform the work In a good and workmanlike manner, (f) Denlod, It la del1led Ihlll the Defendlll1l failed \0 rnalnlalna proper fire watoh after oomplellno PefendEll1t'a work and/or, In the allernatlye, the Defendllnt had a duty to do aO, (g) Denied, 1\ la del1lad that the Defendant failed to perform. the work In , ,.' aooordanoe Wllh I:1ppllol:1llle federal, etate and/or looal oodes al1d regulalluns, Inoludlng, but not Iltnlled 10, Ihe Natlonl:1l Plre Proteotlol1 Assoolallon, (h) Denied, Ills denied that Ihe befel1dal1t failed to apply 10 Ihe work the dogree of skill which WOllld ollstomarllybe brollght to 6l1oh work Ily competent Ell1d skilled welders, , .. " ." ,," , , " ?,i3; P\lI1I\lcl, Any ~nq 11111111e0l1\1pI18 pf 11 \lpn\l'I1pI\lHII 8n\3QlfloflllY Qlf\lecl Ihfll PQfenclRnl WflB QPlety rIlQPPI181~le for, Iwflpr hllcl oOI1\rol pyer Il1e QOns\nlo\lon InPI1I1Q, I1w\llPcla, leohl1lq~le8, Qeqlllll1pea, PI' prp(Jacj~ll'aB PI' for ooprclll1f1\1no 1111 ppr\lpnQ pf Ihe WPrll IIlOIII(lIno, 1)\11 nlll IImltep Ill. \ha prPpllr I1nc1 sflfa \l8e Ilfwelejlno 111f1\arII1IQ f1ro clanlecl f1l1cl proof \I1\3rapf IQ Qaml1l1clllc1 11\ .1116 \lme pf triAl. . . ~4, pal1laq. II 18 (lanlecl 111111 III \lle Ilm\3 Qf pefanclflnt'8 renparlno pf hla Q\3rvloes, .' pefenPflnllll1aw or ahmllcl hflva I\I1Pwn \Ill'll. Pll1lnllff WI1Q ralvlno llppn Ills suparlor knpwlecloe, Qkllll1l1d ll~pllrtlall, ' .' ~6, Pllnlaq, 'fhe I1vermenla pf Pl1rflorl1ph ~(j sll1lp 11. oonolu810n 9f. Iflw' 10 Wl1lph no raQPonlllve plallclln9 IQ I'eqllll'ad, In \l1e Rlternflllvlil, II Is qanlacl 111111 Il1e pefendflnl Impllac1ly wl1rrflnled I1l1cl raprasel1laclll1l1lhe WI1S \lllllled In \1111 flelc1 pf welc1lng I1nd Ihl11hl8 worll WO~IIc1 P~ parfonn!lcllnl1 ooocj f1nc1 workml1nllkll ml1nnar wl\hou\c111feo\8 f1rcllpr In'l\ ml1nner whloh woulq , . . pe fll for orcllnflrY I1nclln\enclec1 pUl'poQe8, ~6, panl!lcl, 1'IW avermenls of Pl1rl1Ofl1ph ~6 Qll1te 11 oonoluslon pf I~wlo wl11011 no resPQnalve plclfldln9 18.reqlllrecj, In\llll alterna\lve,lt IQ c1enlecj \lll1t Il1e Defencll1nl prel:l.ohec1 flny , Implle~ warrl1nllea 10 andlor I1ny oonlrl1ol.wlth Ihe pll1lnllff 10 perform the worll In 11 prOfeQ81onl11 and wprlm'~nllkll mannaI' andlor fEllled 10 aElfely parform Ihe worll, Any I1I1d f1l1l1l1eg"\lonaof 90nlraol, Wl1rmn\lea or Defenc1anl'a failure to a<1fely perform the work ~re llpeolfloEllly clenlad. " ~7, DQl1led" It Is denied IhElt Ell !III Ilmea releVl1nl l1erelo, .Ihe Pll1lnllff flIIfllled Ihelr opIIga\lon8 under Ihe oonlraol, ;!e. Danled, The Anawerlng Defend<1nl InOorporl1les Ihe Elvenllenta of lIs answe'is 10' , I'. Pl1ragraph 17 Elslf sel forth I" full, Ills denied \hl1t the Pefendl1nlbrel1ohec1E1ny. oonlrl'\oll1ndlor ,. " I Implied Wl1rrElnlle8 to II1El Pll1lntlff, Elny I1nd 1111 I1l1egl'\tlonB of Implied oontrl'\ols ,l1nc1lor Impllad wl1l'rl1ntles I1re BpeolfloElIlY c1enled pnd proof thereof la clemElnded at the \Ime of trllll, Wt1ER~FORE, PefendE\nl reguests '. Ihls Honol'l1ble oourt to dismiss' PIEllntlff's " OOlnplalnt, " gaUNT III .. Nogllgol1o!l ' Hampt BrOlll, Ino, v. U~A! Ino, ~9, Tha averments of PElrl1grf1phB 1 Ihrough 28 of Defendant's Answer with New MlItter to Pll1ln\lff's Qomplalnt are Inoorporated hareln sncl msde a part hereof a~lf aet fo~h In full, ~0'32, Dallied, The avermenls of Pf1rl1grl1phs 30-32 are dlreotetlto a pElrty other than tile 'Answering Defendlll1t and 110 responsive plea(ilng Is reqlllred. In the I1lterl1l1\1ve, s!1ld avermentB sre denied and proof thereof Is demanded at the lime of trial, Wt1I:~i:rORE, befendal1t requeste this Honorable to dlBmles Plalnllff's Oompll1lnt, . " " " Qgll'tIf.JQAlli.QffJ~ &BV.IQg AND NOW, 111111 g(Jllt r.lI!1Y ofNov~11111fJr, 10PO, I, Oyn\lllf.l p, l3yr,llla\lralt:lry in \1113 If.lw.flrm pf.T111l1111HI, TllPI11f.l!l 8< 1-If.1ffJl', l1Bral1Y oarllfY 111QII !lanl f.1lnlfl f.lnr.l ollrreol oopy . Ilf 11113 fora09hlQ 'Iooumanl 10 Il1a fllllowlno pO~ln!lal of raoord, PY plQPlno f.l popy pf !If.ll11a Inll1a Unlla,l SIQlaa, flral olQ!la I11nll, pOfllf.lOI3 pl'eptllcl, f.lclclraallar.l f.lll fllllowa: gclwf1rr.l A,Jf.I!.'lOOr, Jr" l:ag~llra Wl1lla f.l!1cl WIlIlf.lI11!l, hl.P . . 1000 Dna hll1erly Plf.loe PI1I1f.lclalpl1lf.l, PA 1010~.730p " UPA Inoorpllrf.llaq 33g0 Dol'fY elraal Ht:lrrl!lpurg, PA 171.11 'I Jr. (")) /) ----.:.0.41\lJ';!'(bL A..~~ 'oynthl~ p, 13yrcl .." " :41770,1 . " .,. , ,. , I: j, '/ " i' , ,. , ,. " ,i" i' . " " " " " "I; " ., " ., I, , , " .\ 1-" , . '" Itil 1 " " " .&_~_~~_~.-~~~irl 'I'llllW\H, Tllmll1H \~ ""I<'Itl! 1.1,1' 111111"111'"' Mll1'1'\'III1, 1(1111111'1' ~II~ Nllrllll,'rlllll Hlrl'l'l l',n'll'I~9w "lilT \1111111, 1'1I'1711111.II'J9IJ l?171 m.mll 17171P7,7111A 11'11\1 ~..~___n~_'_'_'._'_'__""'<"'_"_'__" ... .. ....~m _.______......_ _,_..__._......_.._____..._.......'__ -----.-.... ....'.-.---- u. .._._.________H...n..~_____. '"MI'T IIIIOS, INC, I'IAlnUH " IN lIII rnlllll or COMMON I'IIAS CIlMIIIIIII\NP COIJNTY,IIINNSYIVANI^ CIVil, AClION , lAW v, NIIl IIIHi"~1I ,JJ',:,IJ{' HJ(lt:l'./I: S. KllNIS ,1/"/iI hS, KIINIY WIJPINCl smVIct: ill1Il IJI'^ INC:OIII'DIIATW 1\lIlY TIIIA!. Pl,MANPrP Il\Ifl!llllilnh r-'! -. - - - -- -- , -- .., - .- C':I~1.Q1]lIL\%.;Ji ~~--~ '~ I, IlAII.IlAI~AA, ONol~AlO, iI pi\I'i\lollill illlhnl,ilW 1:lnn of ThonHlH, ThonH\H & l'lnfor I.I.P, . . . ,. . . ('oltlfy 1I1i,1 onlhlHll'h dny of \)ocol11llOr, 1'J!JlI, n copy of Iho foronolnll 1~l!qlll!sl for Prodllctlon of \)01'1111\1'11\11 Plrl!cll!lllolJofondill1\ UIlA II1Cllrplll'ull!l1 1I'0ro 111i1l1ml Flrsl ch.lss I J, S, Mi,\I, Ill;r.lilIIO , propnld tOI " Edwnrd A, Jilllllor, Jr" I:sqlllrt, WI'IIIt: A"IIJ WIIJIMvIS, \.II~ IIlDO Ono I.Ibony plul'o I'hlldnolphlu, PAIl) 1 Il:I UIlA Il1cOl'pllrntml :\ ;12 0 IJt1IW Stroot Hnl'rlshlll'll, I'A 17111 " ,.' Dulol \)('l'ol1,\wrI1 ,1l)!JIl J, " /) (I) , _Mt.d'lLL..L~.._CiL~j~tL& " Ilnrhnrn A, Ol\mnlo " ,,,,,","c .,. ',I '\, CllHTIFICI\'W OE~IJlI,VK'\.i I. ,llIeq\I~lhllll\, Ilouliur, 1II1I1IIlhol'i?ud IIgulIllll' ~MWI'HONPI\I\IWqll,FF'WII,l,'I\MH II:: OTTo. IlPru\1~ c~\'III'~ Ihllll\ uopy or Ihu IhrUllllil1ll Anllll'cr wl\h Nu\\' Mllllul' or Pul'undllll\ UP^ 111\1(1I'llP1'l\\~1I Willi HUI'I'cd thllllh\.tu hy d~pllllillllll ~III1IU 111 \hUPlll1t ornC\! III ('l\rlllllu, PA, 111'1110111116 1111111, plllllllllU pl'uplllll, mldrullllolI 1111 Ihlh'Wlli ,," ' " lidwlIl'd 1\, ,!IIUIJUI'i .II'" 1l1I1IIIIl'u WlllTIl I\l1d WII.LIAMH, 1,1,\1 ' 1 HOO OI1U Llhurty Plllcu Phlhlllolphlll, PA \1)10:1 Pmlllhlll It 11'1111'co110. IlHII\1lru TIIOtlMH, TIIOMAS & Hi\Fnll, ~()5 Nlll'lh 1"1'0111 Slruu\ ,p,o, !3ox \)l)l) 11 II I'l'l IIh \I1'lJ, I'A 1710l) I':" ".' . " " , " '.' " M^RTSON. IJE^IWORFF. WII.I,IAMS &:orl'Q I: u.y_G 1%l'~.' aQci:.~~~-",._, (1)9011110 t\. Dool\CI' . 'Ol( ElIsllllglt Sll'oot , C'III'IIHlu, I'A 1701 ~ . (717) 24~.:I:l41 " ,. .". " . PIII~l\i 1J00umhol' 2H. 11)l)H " , " ." " , l\, " " ,. 'l" " "I, 'II, " fi~ ICI ;..' " \ I ~ I' " ", " h _l.t , 1"01, I.". , .'J i, .'.1;" ",., , ,/ , V:, ;.;1 , " II, }", , .1 ,\. If! 'i) f " 'I"" (1,1 , ,.' ,., ("'I'" (, , :i 1:"11 . I. J I':' I:: ...., !Il. .,1 ft I'" '1 0; " ~.J (.n n " " ". " ,. "" I' 13 ,~.-:- ..~.~. :;,.i':"~ g~~ 2. I Iii; 'ii', ~.'g@~ 138~/? ,~~O , \,l~ ~'~ ,"1 -....,t , . . ---=;::':-...-- --rr ." '~~ ~~ :!l~' (<, 8 ~I?i 1'. fl1 ~~ ~~ ~' ~~. 'A (il " tl .1'1 !;i ffi. r.>l~' :d ~ J ~~Pl ~'fO ~~~. ' ~~~ " ~~"1. [3rn~ iE ~~' , Vl IJ.l tJ ,., R I ~ F\':l ~ ffi " 10' '~~ ~ '" d '< 8 M ~~ ~ I::;ffi ~ ~ ~I~~ ~ ~ Ii. 5 ~~R" i.~ P2lli :.~H t::E ~ t~S ~ " " ~. t," " r ,--.----..-.-- " ,. ,. 1.,1' ,," " " ii" " II ,. " " " II , ,. " " " " '... ., " , ". i,. , ,. Ii I' jli, " '..' . 'I .1 \, " , "~I; ,. 'j. " " -- ,.., , I,.: (;~ 'l~ ' i I, .. \J I. i .".1 I ~ .. ,. C'I' li:', "" (-l~ " , t {; ('n " , " ff 1 ;. I Ll':!:l . , j: ~ - 1-" ;. 1.1. , ., I <...' '.1. ) ., -{ ,. II I: ii ," ,\ ,,;! " \. <II' ,. iJ :f It f, " 11 ,. \I " , " " " ,. I" ;1', 'f' I, " ,. " 'L, " !j,,, " ,. " " " ','1 " "I< " ,. ,,' ., I, I', I' " 'il " I' ,. ,. " , , , , , " " " " \. Ii i' "! 'I j' ., ,. .J,\. I' ,I'; , , ~ , " " " ,'!I' 'I. ,,' ,;, ",\ !t 'f): 1'" ',', ,. " I" " " " .' " " !' , , I I"~ , , d' I " .Ii j' Fjo ,. \" 'j OJ " 'j; ",1 ., ,. I' ,. '.'. ;'. .1' ;. " d! ,. " I', " , , r.,t~l)' 11/11111:'''(1 iillllJI :'{J ("1'1"".--,' '.". ._',;" ',_, ~'- . ('r" 'L - II ,~, ':,.' I. 'l,t/I\ I) "'{iNN'iii.M\I'.'I.'I. . . - - '. j' " ..' H '-'f " j', I' " " u' if ,"f ,. i. " 'I! I' II I, I' ,. ,. Ii " I' !' I. " 'I' " i' " I' /, I' " " I. 'i "'i " " H I' " " '; '1. IIi'. " ii' ,II Ii' ii, II .. " lilliI'lli'll ^, .IlIull~l'. .11"1 1!~'1l1ll'u IlIllll Ol1ul ,lh~I'IY I'hl~\l I'hlhlllulphlll, i'll, II) Ill~, 7)1)S PIIIlI~II\, lWllnllll'l'i', I!H'IlIll'u TUlll!llHllllllh Hlnllll CIIl'IIHlu, i'll, 17111 ~ IlOIlIlIIlH 11. MlIl'uulln, n~ql1ll'~ ~IlS NOl'lh Fn1l1IHII'uul' 1',0, /lox 01)0 I I 1I1'r1Hh\ll'll, i'll, 171111l,IlOI)!) :Hhl " 1/ ',' "+I '1 . "" ,,' ,. ",. , ,,' " " " '" II ': ,,' " " 'f," '" J I' II .,', ,,' " " , ,.,. " " ", ." " " , " "II , j, "1' <':. " I, ,. ,j " " " ,. " " il; " " " ","~ " " , " If I, P111111111'1' , : IN TI.IH ('Ill IHT llF ('llMMllN PI ,lil\H (1F : ('lltylIWHI,I\Nn ('(l\JNTY, j1HNN/:lYI.vi\NI^ I,HMPT IIHOH"IN('" \" : NO, 1)1I.~()(11) mJ<lHNH H',IWHNHY Illh/ll I';,H, I<;IWNHY WHI ,PIN< I HHH VleH 1111\1 111'1\ INClll{Pllg^'I'lm, .. PUrU11\llIlIt~ : ,1I11n' TI{II\I, Pl\Mi\NPlip :"""'i)JilF~N!)I\Nr'tn~Jfl~N~ ~l\ImJilNIW ,"h/l,.J'n,a..l(jij~NJilY WIQmnN(ffiroRVIPJil!ffl"'i}:] . :. ':"'. ,;." MQ":l.Q~'I'()q9M'11QkANflwmH;J'OIN'IIIi1Hl\OCM1'onmR<';. ',:~i ^Nn NOW, Dulol1\llIlIll\uulluy I11\1WH IhlH 1101l0rnhl(J CplII'lln ~nll1pul Plllh1\ln~ In mnl'u I\llIy l'uHpo!1d In Ol\llillUITOl\lIlnl'iuH \11' pulomhll1\, I!IIl\Ul\ul\uUllUY, hllHUII \lpl1l\ thu Ihllnwll1gl . I, 1'1,11111\11'1; Ilul11pl nrnH" IIIU" hllH ~lIud Plll'ulldlllll KU~11U)' Huuklllg dllmllg~~ III'IHIII'1l Ih1ln II lin1llln\ n~\\\IIT\llllllllul11pl 'H MI, 11011>' pllllll, . 2, Ppl\Jl1\hlllll\uunuy hllH pl'npolll1dud II1IUI'I'ogll\lll'lu~ IInd HU\I\lUHllhl' Prn\I\I\lllnn \11' IJllulln1Ul1l~ IIpol1 IIhll1111 Ir, I. " ~,' ,^H plll'l Ill' Ihn~l,l Il1lulTnglltOl'luH, lJul\Jndllnl KU\lI1U)' hllH I'U\l\1u~lu\1 Ihu Hpo\llllu 'liI\ltH, WItIl\lHH~~ 1111\1 dOU\IIllulltH whn will Hnppol'l. thu CI;lltulltlnllH lIul I\lnh In Pllllntll'f'H COllipllllnlllfllllllHl Dulvlldllllll<;ccl1uy (lI1IUlToglltOl'luH 12 Ihl'nllgh 25), " 4, PIIIll\tllTllul11pl hllH "ruspol\dud"loIJul\Jl\dllll\ KUUI\UY'H liilul'l'nglllnrluH. ~I llnwuwl', PllIll\tllT 1I1l111pl hllH I\llIud 01' rpl\IHud tn IIllIy IIl\d u\lI11plutuly l'uHpniid't\l li\lurrolllltol'lus 12 thrllllllh 2S IIl\d Ihu npPIICllhlu HuhpllrlH In Idulltll)' Ihu I\\UIH, wltll\lHHUH, nlld \IOUUIIl\llltH Itl Huppnl'\ 111' Ihu Hpuclllu nllugnOlll1H ngnlllHI ^"OI'lIuy' Kuul\uy, II uop)' nl' PIIIII\OI'f'H ^I1H\\'UI:H In IlIlul'I'ol\lIlnl'lus IHnllllehml hUl'uln IIl1d Il1l1du n plll'l hurunl'nBHxhlhlt "^", ,. (l, P1uluIII'I'H 1\11I\ll'u nl' 1'\\I\IHulln 11111)' nlld unlllplululy rUHpnl\d In Hllld 1111urrnglllol'IuH IH pru.ludlululln Dul\Jlldlll\l'H prUlil\\'ullnl1 nl'thuunHu 1\11' trln!, 7, Pll\ll\tIf'l' hnH 1\01 pl'llvldud 1111)' l'uSpOIlHU In li\luI'I'ngnIOl'luH'I" nlld 15, n COP)' nf II .' i lJululldllllt'H cOll1ph.Jlu, Hl'l nf Inlul'I'olJlIlllI'l\lH Is (1\llIched hCl'ulo nnd .ll1l1de II ,)\1\1'1 hOl'\lol"IIHllxhlhll j, , ' ,"II", " , d' , H, FlI1'lhel', Illllw c:<it\l1\1 nl'UHpllllHU IH provided tll Oil\) IlItel'rogntol')' lII\L1 lI1cOI'pllrntu\1 hll11 thu nthul'H, 1;llIh1l1l'l' hllldl)' IIHHUI'(H, "11\ IIddlllon tn thu uxlunl thlll Inlhl'I11\\llull HllUl\!ll,IH . cOl\lIllned Ihcl'oln, HOU doculllents pl'llduced \1)' 1'llIlnlll'l' 111 RCHponHU In R\!qUUHI 'fhl' 1II'mh;ctlllllllf',. I' " .,. ,.. " SKhlblt A ,. , 't,-' d' 'j' ., ,. " " " I' 'I' !.', " i\ , " " " ,,' " .ii, " I" " If, ':;' ,." t"' ,. ,11 " " " Ii 'I' II I' H J'i' " " ,,' '" " ''',' " J. " " " \, " ',', Ii " " !I, qPIll'Ilj1l\1II"h,~py I II, Phl'l~llltlhp,' "ll\lVII lit nlpnn l\1rH~ l'IlIlnlll1' I'mI'VI1~ Ihl1l'lllhlllllllllPnll Ihl~ IIn~Wj1" II~ 11l~\lIlV""r ,",,1 hIVj1~lllllllllln 1I,!'11 1111 1.111 IIIllI. .. ~, 1\l1pol'\~ orln\llllpnl, . !llonllty 11\l\l\lIn0I1I~ (\lxoopl I'Op\lI'IH Of\lXP\lI'\H H\I\l)\lOI In Pi\, It.C,\" 1'/9, 4(lOt~) whloh I10SCl'lh\llho 111011\11111 PI' Ih\l \llllIHO Ilwl'llllf, . l'hllll\llT i,hJl1clH Illlhls IIIlel'l'l1llllllll'y I\~ lIsl1llllslnflll'llllllllll'I'I'QII1\111111 hy 1l11l1l1l1ll'II11y/llllelll'"Ul/m' IIlInl'IlIly WlIl'lllll'llll\ll1llll'IVnl1lllll Wlthllnl Wlllvtllll slllll llhjl1pllllllN, 811j111I1rllll'lllll~ 111'111 \ll1ll,I hy J'''Ihll'ff III HIlNIII'n~llln nlll\nllslflll' l'l'llllllelloll l1f Unrnlnl111IH of n\lflllll"lIIlt JiJIIgllnl1 S, KIlI111\ly IInll fllltll11\llllllnllll Ul1lln\l81 fill' l'I'Il!llIrllllll, . 4. Tl'lnll'l'op!\l'nllonMnloI'IIII, . !fyoll, or HOmOonO IIpI IInl1xpOrl H\I\l)1l01 to Pn, It.C,I', NQ, 4003,5, ClllllhlCIIl(1 nlly IIIvoRII/:lllllon~ oflhlllllclllllnl, 11111nlll}': ~ " (II) Hlloh p\ll'pOn, I\mllho omployllr of ol\oh pOl'sol1, who \loml\lololl:nny InvllslIUl\llon(8)IIl1HI .. .. (ll) ^"llol\lS, rpporls or olh\ll' I\oo\lmonls propl\l'ol\ I\mlng or,l\sl\ rp8\11t oflho... , hW\Jsllunllon(s) 1\1111lhll porsolls who hnvo U\lSlody Ihol'oof, A.NSWEUI J'",'"II1T ohjcots III Ihlsllll\lrl'O~lIlm'Y II~ Ilsll~kslllfnl'l1I,lIlInll pl'nleelllll by Ihllllllorlllly/e1lllllt IIIId/or 111101'110)' .wllI'k PI'Oll"\llllrlvllllllo" WlthQllt wlllvlllllsllhl o'ljecth,"~t seo llllel",IIlIIlsIII'Olhl\llld hy l'llIlnllff hl UIlSPQII.sclo Hel\IIIlHI I'm' J'l'ollllCllnll ilf DO\llllllllllla of DlIflllHl"lIt, Euglllle S, I{lllllley 111111 SIIl1pllllllellll\1 UellllllHtflll' l'I'ollllellll'" . IIi " Trlnl wllnll~s, . h\onllfy efieh persoll youlllllllld 10 ofill fi8 n 1I01l"oxllorl wllncss fil . Ihlllr\n' 01'Ihl8 OfiSO, filld for efieh pOr80n IdonllOod, 81nle yom rlllfll\o,,~hlp wllh tho WII\\llllS find, Ihllsub81nnoll oflhe 0\e18 10 whloh Iho wllncssIs llxpcOlol\ 1010slll}'. . ~NSWEnl' Pll\lntlff o~jcel810 Ihls IIllel'I'08,,10I'Y lis II Is IIot "Illlulred tu dlsclm Its Inlendcd Iwoofs prillI' 10 h'llIlllud wl!l 1101 he IImltcd b~ 11011111 S(I III1W, Wlthoul wIIlvlullsRld objcctloll, Pllllnllff's .fllel wllneSsea IIIl1y 'nelndel hul "I'll 1101 limited 101 Ihe plll'sona .Idcnllnlld In Ita IIllNwel' 10 lnlcI'I'ollnlory 2; Pllllullff I'IlSCI'VIlS Ihlll'lllhl lu SIIpplClllllIII IIIld/uI' 1111I111111 Ihla lIuswer InllCclll'dllllce wllh the Uule8 of Clvlllll'occlhu'c IIndlllr IIUY schedullnR ol'llel' Iuued hy Iho COIlI'I. ' .., 1"~11l4l100 vi ,,.]10 l'li' " .' 6, ,illl1\lr\ wlllw~sll~, . hl~l1llly ~lIph PXPIlr\ YI1\1II1IIl11[1 III PIIII lIa II wltnpas IIllhp 11'1111 pfthla Imlllcr, IIml (hI' ull~h ~lIp\lr\ ~\l,,~: . (II) Thu ~\lllJUllllI\lIllllr lI\lnlll whluh Ih~ cll\l~i1ls OllPO\lI~[lll1IC~llfy; IInli' (11) .. Th\l S\lI1S\II11PP nl' Ihp nIP'~1I1111 nplnlons In Wllloh Ihll \lXPPrI Is pxl1Pol\llltl1 Ipalll)' IImlll a11l11111111)' nl'lIw !lI'PIIIlll~ n,l' ~lIoh I1plnlol1, (YI1I1I11I1Y 1111l1l~ Y\1I1r 1I11~WPI' III Ihl~ Inlol'rl1anlnry IhQ rpporl I1l'lhu CllP~rI PI' hllVP \h\l h1l01T11BlIllll), l\lla\wrPII by Yl1l1r \lllPOr!,), , " . .Al'I~Wlm, IIl'11cp llIalllY FIHIJl ~I'~1mM<Ia'I' '1.7 Norlhlll'IlI'1I11l TI'IIII llnll'Ollhl, f'I\ m'l.o . ClIl1'nl'll 1'11111"" I', Ie, nllWanll t1l1Rhlllllrlllll. hIll, 114 '1'1'1l1l11l11 Hm\ll Fnll'lllflN Hilla! f'I\ IllO~O . " MI', 1'1111011 wllllllalll)' wllh l'IlRIII'IIIO fJf'I\ 'a IlIalllllllll\lll nf II IIIlW . awllchflll' I,IlIhllllTa 1""111' "nd IlUII\I1Hln 11I'Mllp\llll"I "I'IIIlPII",'pIIlIIIIl hlllllallr, MI'I lIIalllY wllIlllallf>' wllh I'IlIIIII'1111l allll\ll"I'II wllhllnR . 1'llqllh'lll1lonla II1H'~r lIl'pllrl\hlp Plllllla, nlllh 1l11'IlI'la will III'OVhi Il ' 1'1l1,",'la IIllhll plnallllf IlIsIlIlVIlI'r III' I""'anI\IIIIII IIl1y aph\ldllllnlllll'llpI' lUlled In thla Pllall, "1111111111' I'llalll'Vlla thPI'lllhll" SIIPI,Iol1lollll\l\IlIlII' "I1IPllIllhla I\IISwIlI'ln IIPcUI'IInllrll wllh Ihll Hnllls IIfClvII1'l'oelll""'1l nllll/lIl' nllY Hchlllhtlhllllll:IIIl" hallllll IIY Ihll COlll'l, 7. ,~ol fonh IhuI~\lftllf1Pntlplls of 011 ph sllPh OXpllrt, lIatllla tho SPhPCllslI\tpmlod, YUlIra of ntllllldllllCO, doarooa rllpolvod, IIml oxpurlolloo 1I11111Y pnrtlculllr I1l1ld of spoollllli!nllon or ollporllsll,' " I, " ANSWlm, SIlIl nllnchelll'llsnmllS for MI', H1sl~y 111111 Mr, I'nlloll, , 8, ' Trlnl oxhlblts, . Idol1l1l)' 1111 ollhlblla Ihlll you 11\1\llld 10 USII nl tho trlnl oflhls ntllllor nn[1 sllIlo wholhor Ihc~ will bo uBoclllurll1B Iho IIl1hlllly 01' (In1l1n~0 portlona oflho Irlll\' . ANSWreltl SellllocllIlIll,.ls III'odnced hy I'lnlnlllT.lII IteslllIIIslI III Itllqnesl for 111'oduelhlllllf J>oClllllllnls of Dllflllldlllll, EIIllell1l S, KeellllY, SUI1llllllllclllnl ItlllJUIlSI fOI' I'rlllhllllllllll plllns IIf Iho w"sh pllllll 1"'llvlously IlI'lIdnclld, video, dlllllllllllS bhllllll~ IlrllvlollSI>, 1"'oduClld, . doclUIICllh 1I1l/lched III "\lJlllaUlona IInd dOQUlllcllts "l'lIlhlClld III rcsl'"IISC III subpoenAS Issucd llllhls ellSll, PllllnlllT rcscrvea thc rlllht 10 sUllplemcllllllllllllf Illlllllld Ihl., IlllaWIll'III IlCCOl'dllllCC wllh the Itulcs Ill' Clvlllll'occdlll'o 1I1111/0f Any aehednlllllllll'lllll' lssucd by the Cmu'l, , ' 1~"!I2422(Nlvl -4- " , " pm'I'II"1CA'!'t: (W SI!11~VI9~ '" I her!l\1y eerll\)' Ihlll II Inl\l eplT\I\llcopy pfPlllinllll's Answers \0 1I1I!lITIll5I\IQrl\lH pf l)oI'Pndlll\l, Hllgcl1Q S, Kucl1cy, WIIS mllllc(1 \lY V,S, FIt'HI CllIss 1111111, pOKllIgc prcplllrlln: \)11111\11 K, \)\1111'\101'0; Hsq\lll'o MAI\Tf:'ON lUcM\llOIWII WII<I~'^MS ~ OTTO 'I'\1n HIISI High SII'\l\l1 Cllrllslllll'A 170P " " " . POII!!IIIS 0, Mllreollo, 13sqllll'0 .' '1'1I0MAS, JI'HOMAS ~ HAllER 1<1_1' 305 Norlh Frpnl Slrool p ,0, 1101\ 999 Hllrrlsbllr!!,PA 171 08 I." '.', " ,,' ,._/ . " , , /' , " '\ ' / " / <~~W; A:;:'~;'I~;';:Y . Whlllllll1d 1I1111111S 1.l.ll C. .' 1800 0110 Ibol'ly Pllloo Phllllrlolphlll, J1A \9103 (~\5) 864,6322 / " " \Jl\lol " ",' " \'1 " , , " " " , " Il,~", IlIUIl 1'1 .12. " ,. 'j " " .<;, " Ii. ,. !IlIhlbll B I, " , ',., " i' d' " ,-, !. " ." " " " l"i ,,Ii; I;' 'I;, " " 'l . ,. " " " ,; " .,' ;'11' ." ." L ",. "to' II " "~I " (, ,. ',;; i: " j, " " I, " !; ,. 'I' " ji " " " " ,. /I I., Ii Ii ii, ,. I,; " " jei' " "j' " 'j. ."1' i' \, OJ " " . , " , \ .~ilIt~, I ' " , , . IlI.LI N IllnN!illN IJJ N!iIH ULl.1 nN!i I^) WI1\lI\IlI'I'1 11111 11'1111 "doc\iliilllll" .15 Illil'dliOllllll, II IIlChHlo5 (1;\'111'1111'1' or Ilpl 5pllclflcilllv cilllod for) (III. prllllod, Iypowrl\lon, hillldWII\ll!l1i lIlilphlc or Il!l:ollll,dlllillll'l, hll\Wl'llI' proi!lIcoi! IJI roprodllCl'd ilnd holYl'l'ol' fOrlIH11 or Infonlw!. (il) VVIWlIllvor 1'011 illl! il5Kl.'II 10 "ldonllfy" ii dlll!III1Wnl, 1110 followlnll Inrllrlllilllol1 shollli! 110 Illvon ii' to oilch i!lll'llllllllltllf which 1'011 ill 0 ilWlllo, whlllhl'r or IIIlI 1'0\1 hilVI' pll5,o5Sllln, C\1511111y Ill' cpntmlllwrliori .. (1) Tlw nillllru of Iho dllcllIlwnl (0,11,,11'1101', lIl0nlllrillllllllll COlllpllllll' prlnl.olll, 11\1111110" rll,lllllllrJll, lilpO r\lcordlllg, olc.)J . (2) 1\5 lIillo (Dr If II !JOiIlS no rlillo, Iho dilll! whonli Wil5 propilloi!)i (:I) 'Ih'o nillnO, nrhlros~, omployor ,11111 pllslllol1llf tho Slllnor or signors lor If Ihoro Is .Illl slglwr, Iho por,oll who prUpnrl'rllli (4) 'Tho Ililllle, ildilross, e1llployer ill1'd poslllon of tho porsoll, If ilny, 10 WIHlll1lhll \ioC\lInlllll WilS SOil Ii ' (5) If YIlII hilVllP(lSSl!sslolI, clIstody or COlllrol or tho rlOCIIII1l'IlI, Iho IC)Cilllon illlrl doslgllillloll or tho plnw or fllo III which II Is collliilllnd, nlld Ihn 11<lInO, mhlro5S nlld poslllol1 of 1111'1 porsollhilvlll!l clIstoily of tho rloclImol1lJ (1'1) If YOlldl1 nol hnvo pllssossloll, ClISIOlly or wlltrol of tho dOCllIllOlIl, tho prefiOll1 .. 10cilllol11hQluof illld Iho nnll10 illld ilthI fllSS Ilr 11ll' qrulllll7.iltloll hllVIIl!! pllfifiossloll, cllslotly Of wlltrolthoroofJ nlld (7) ^ brlof .tntolllOlIl of Ilw sllbjuct mllllor Ilf sllch dIlCIIIIIOIII, (C) WIll'lIoV!)1' Yllllmo il,lwel tn "ldolltlfy" illI olal WI111111111lcalloll, the followllHllllforllmlloli shollld Ill) glvol1 ii' ICll!nch Cl[i11 C0l1111111111cilll011 of which YIJII Me nWnlU, wholhl'r or IIllt YIlII or othllls were pr(~sullt or pmtltlpnlml IIWl'ollli (1) 'IIW.I1ll'ilIiS Ilf Clll1l1l11mlcillllJl1ll!,Il, loh!pholll', pl!l;ol1al CIlI)Vl!fsiltlol1, olc,): (2) Whmo it look 'plaClli " "I , (:I) OpllolllO prolllll:11 1I0I'\III1I'llls, ,- InliPII o( lllonllfyillll 110111111I'111, In rO'llIlmll 10 \hoso lIilr'rrnlllllollllS! Y"li 1I1/IY I1lovlllo wplilsl!( slIch 1I0Cl1I1101I1, wilh ,\I)prOPllillO 10((11\1!\COS III Iho (:orro.ponIlIIlU 11I10rrollilll.1l'lll!i, " " l~nlmIlGAll.Wlili I. " " 111H1'llilnco, -If Vll\l i1(0 cllV\ll'od \1Y ,H1Y IYpo o( \YPi! of Ins\ll'iH1co, IlId\ldlllU {H1Y 1', IlXpJSS or I1l1lhl'ollll Il1s\ll'iln~;,o, Ihill II1IUhl Ill! IIppllclliJlo'lo Iho Incldl'111 III Ihls Illillllll', 'slnlo Iho (qllowln!l wllh rospllcllO oilch SlIch policy: 'I. ' " , (iI) (1)) (c) (cD " " .,(0) Iii ~l~ I." " Tho nllll10 of IholnSllriH1ClJ CiIlTlor which IS'IIl~1 \110 policy; , Tho nlll110d Il1slIrol1 lil1dol' f)ilCh policy IIl1d 11m policy 11 1 IInl181' of Ullch policy; " 'I ' Tho'lypo(s) und n((ocllvo dulll(s) of oncl, policy; Tho mnOllnl n( COVOl'lIgo pl'Ovldmt for Injury 10 Ilitch porson, (or onch . occurl'OnCl!, IInll Inlho 1I!llll'll!lll\p for ellch policy! IInd I:nch l!xdllslon,lf IInY, IIllho policy which Is nppllclliJlo III i1I1Y dllhl1 thllre!lnt!ol' IInd il/lY rl!USOns, If IIny, why YOII or Iho cilrrlol' dllllll Iho (IXChlslol1ls IIppllclIl>lo, .. " "" 'I " " I." ,. .1 " " I. .. I' " I", H II , " 'J!" 1.,1, I~;!,i,"dillll \,IIW ri1Ilh'IIIIIII1IIIiIlIII'fI'IJllilllll<I'I'II11\, hilll ,I 1/1111" lol'lIilw 0(1110 PI50l\Cl! " . of \ho 111101, "11I'llIlr,III\" 1111',IW \1,1111 Ihl' 111111111'1111I: " (ill I ',!I'h ,111111'1'1111' 1.111 willi h ''''ppllll\ 1'0111 1I11"lillllolli 1111 ph'lIll1 "IIII(llhl'ldl'1I11111", III 1111 Wlllllllohl'!i who will (I) I'It',I\1l PI!ll 1111'1' .111 dlll'llIlIlllIl!i III hllppollllf'lllllli(llllh11lllllollS; . , ^N~WI'III ;!II, 1~lll1liidlllll 1'1111I C111Ih!lIllolllliilll)pfolldlllilI\01l11llY'hml workl'r! Oil 1110 111101 Oil pl'lpr , " , " 'I" !' (ill " (h) , ((:1, " Ol'l:i1511111S, 111111/01 hlld 11'11101'1"lIlhl'1I11111 (lIl'lllI)SOIJl:nlUllllI~, 5Plldficillly,pl0llSO !il<llo Ihu (ollowlll!]l I'nll.! 11111111\'011' (/Ill wl1lc1ISII/lPOIIS 1'0111' illlolllIlIlllI; " , , 1'loilMl Slillo IIll!ldllllllllo!i of nil wlllln5'Ils wilD will I'IIIIIso !illJdlll'lI iill dlH'. II 11I011 15 III 511ppnllllfihnso 1111I%ll1oIlS; " t\NSWUll n, , . . I'IOil!iO doscillw III l/olilll nlltl;!sllnll pr.r(orllwd 011 Iho 11m Bllpprossloll syslol11, sollll1!] " (1)/ 11ll! 111111111 11111/ 1II111/1)!i5 of 1111I pl'rsoll who jl[ll(OIllIlXI tho l(lst"l!]; 1110 <Ioto 111(1 IUfillllg wo~ t ;., . 11111 flll'll1or!: ill1<1 IIIl! l1l11CII1l1O of 1111' 1051. If 1110 Ilisl m!ll/Its lvert! rodllcol/ 10 wrltllln, plmlsll pr()\'ld~' i\ ,copy of'iilllllpnrl~, ^N~WUIl .. 1\ " .I Ii' , ,.., I.. I I ~ . , , ,', I' "I.' .;il fl " '1 I I ' ~ , ~ l' ~ I~ 'I' " " " 'H " " II" ;! " " " " , ,;11 " " Ii. . , . Ii " " ,. Ii H " , 1'.,. Ie' " , !' " !I i 'I' II II ,. " Ii- " II " "i ., " " , ' ;! " I' " ". ,. ,. , , \~, " I , " Ij, 'I, " " " " ii,"i ;\ 'I 'j; " ,if' II' J, " 'II h " " 'j, II ;,1, " ,. ti ,. . , 'I., "I I . ,. " . ' " " " , " , I , (' 'f " " " " " ;, 'II, ;'" I' Ji" !, . , " I "I' .' " i' "'i i'- " ,I ", I' " I,i, i;1' ", , . " " ji ,,', !i 'I I.d' ,.;'f' Ii "I! " " " I, " Ii/; ,. " " II, 'II d' , , If, il~ II , . I' , . II ";' . I; ,. !I'.'! 'I Ii' "i' " I, !I II' /I " II " '-J'! " " fl., " " III\MI''I' 1l1~nB" INp., 1'111\11111'1' : IN TIII~: C(lll\rr ()F COMMoN I'IJil\~nF 1 ClIMIIIQq,^ND L'O\JNTY, I'I.\NNHYI.Y^Nll\ \" , , : NO. !JH,S(I(I\J , " nlJClIlNI1 H, K1~11NI'iY d/l1/l\ Ii,H, . 1~llnNnY WnWINCI HHIWWH 1111\1 IJM INCOHPOH^TliP, , , 1 Mll\1\1 1111 !H : ,IlJIWTI~I^L 1~1,\~1ANnnn i"',.~lll'I'm~MI~NT^'~ INTI~nHu(INI'rlnllcfTmini~ll^Ntr'~V(fipNlq~Ct~~Ni~X>,l 1",;,,1 II/hili '~I~I j\'QI~NinvWIQ'iIllN(I~f~HVIPJij, UII\lUOTJI1n'i',Q "';AINTWF", ' " );i r- TO: Humpl Ill'llH" Il1u. u/n Ild\\'II\'11 ^. ,II\Plllll'; ,II'" EH\I\lll'u Whllll 111111 WIIl"lI11HI LI,I' I HO{) 011111.lhul't)' I'llICo 1'1\lImlolphllll M 1 \J I O~ I'W^~11 T^I{E NOTICE lhlll )'I1IIIII'U horoh)' rU\lllll'lld, plll'HIHln\ to POllllH)'I\'lInlll RIIIIlH \1f , prnoudlll'u No, 4otll, l!.LlllliJu \0 IIUI'\'O uplln thu \In!lul'slllnud, II'llhlnlhlrt)' (30) \III)'H nllor sCl'vlpu 0(' thlH Nulll',\l, )'\1111' AnHwOI'H In wl'ltlng \1I\(lur olllh to Iho Ihllo\\'lnL\ 1I1l0l'l'Olllll01'IuH, , , THUMM" TIIOMi\H & I1i\FICR,I,I-I' ll~': !Jougllls 13, Mnl'cu1iu, Esql\lrc ~()S Nllrlh Frol1l Htl'll\lt !loHI orncu llnx lJ\J\J IlllrdHhlll'llll'1\ 17101l-0lJl)lJ (717) 2SS, 72~1I Dlltol Scptlllllbu\' 12, 20D I :141430,1 ' .: I' " ", H , ,Ii ", (~) Tlw t\iiI1HIIIIW~ III' \\'11\1 H\II\I \1'\1111111 II'hlll1\ 1I11111hu III'1IUI' III w\ll~hll W\lH SIII(II ((I) Wl1ul1wl' \hlll ~lIIHI\HIIII~lltllll\ Ill' \111)' plll\ Ihul'~()1' IH 1'~~llnl~d, \IUH\ll'lh~11 UI' I'VI~IT\l\1 111111 1111)' dll~\\IlWIlI (Ill I II'U\'IlI' Illlhl'lHlIll 11\1\1 II' HIl, 1111 111~11\llivlllllln PI' S\I~h \11I~\II1WIlIII1 \hUlHllIlIWI' IIHII\Jlli~\III"'Il\'ll, , , (11).. II' )'(IIl,pl\l11H IIHII 11w HIII~u~1 1111\\1\11' 111'11 (hWIIIHUIII Ill' urnl ~nl1ll11\II1I~IIII(11l Is prlVIlUll~d, )'IlIlIWUIII\\l1 H~II\lI'II\ Ilw hl'lul sllIl\.IIlWIlI nl' \lw HII"IV~II11I1I\UI'.1l1' IIW \IIlPIII11\lIlI, nl' \lw s\lIIHIlIIWU ul' \lw 111'1I1 ~oI1H\1III1I~lItl(111 \l1l11~d 1\11' IIho\'ll, YOII H\lIIII, I1nwu\'Ill', nllWl'wlH\l "1\!cllllly" HIl\lh dnc\lI11\lllt 111'111'111 \J1I11111111111\ll1lll1l1l1lldHhllll Hllllu ulluh IlI'lIHIHI'1l1l \\'111~h )'IIH \.11111111111111 ~Il\lh IhWII111\l1l1 Ill' 111'1I1 ~IlIlH11l1l1Icllllu111H pl'l\'llulWd, ". . on Wh~lw\'ul' )'11\\ '1I1'U IIHliudlo "ldUl1llel' II PUI'HUIl, Ih~ 1\I\lnll'lllllll1lhl'l1ll1llnn s111111 bll ulwllI . (\) 'I'lw I1IlI11U,pI'UH~l1t IIddl'~IIH 1111\! PI'UHUI\IU\nph1)'~I' IInd pllHltlnl1 ofllw pVI'Snl" 11I1\11 (2) Wlwlhul'thu pUI'Hnnl1l1H lllvulI IUHIII11I1I\)' h)' \I'll)' of \!upll~11I111l Ill' 1l1Il\1l'\vIHOIII IIny PI'IlVUUIIII111I1I1\\!ol' \l'lwlhul' thllt IWI'HOI\ hllH UIWIlII Htlllul11Ull1 wlwthvl' \ll'lll, II'l'ltlvll, Ul' 11I1wl'\\'lsu, IImll I' ~n, \hu titlu /1111111111111'0 nl' III\Y ~11~h pl'ou~udll111, \lw Ilnto PI' Iho I~Hlhnnn)'1 \\'huOwl' )'llll hll\'u II POP)' 01' Ihu 11'l\llHUI'IpI \IWI'POI', ,tho 1\1\1110 or Iho PUI'Hllll tu \l'hol11' tll\) HIIIIVIHul11 WIIH glvu, whul'Q tho IItlltOI11UI\\ IH pl'~H\.Intly hWlit~\11f \l'r1\1~I\, or nlhul'\I'lHO 1l'lIl\Hul'lhu\I, 111\(1 Ilw PI'UHOI\\ IO~IIIl11n nl' H\I~htnms~r1Ptpt' HlnlulllullIl I' I1nt In ~'II\II' pnHHOHHI\II1, ' . " , (F) . Thu IUI'I11 ")'nu" IIhl1l1 b\.l dUUlllOd (0 11101111 nnd 1'~lbl' to 1110 pnrl~' to \\'hom IhuHc 111IuITnllll(ol'loHhIlI'U buull pnlpolllld~d Ihl' nllll\I'OI' lI11d Hhnll nlHO hu (10\.1111\.1\1 In refbl' to, hilt shnllllo\ ho 11111110(1 tn, YO\II' nllol'l1O)'H, uOIlHIIllnl1lH, H1II'utluH, Il1dol1111ltms, hlHIII'PI'II', hlV\lHlllllltors, lllld (111)' 11lhpl'lI11UlltH Illsolin' llH thu Illnlurlnll'uqlloHIU(! huroll1lH IInl prlvllugud, . '(0) Thu WOl'd "hluldulll" Hlml1 he dculllud to IHCIII111lld I'utbl' to IIw IIwldullt nn'illlVllud to hllW ouu\\\'rud nH Hullbl'lh 111 );lllU' COlllplnlllt. I' ThuHU ltllul'rollntol'lcH Hhnll hu dcul\1c(lln bc COlllll1ulllllll1lUITolllllorluH, 13ol\\'UOIl, tho 1I1111l ol'YllUI' ^IlH\\,UI'H 10 Hnld 111lul'l'OgntmlulIl1l1d thulll\1\\ ol'lrlnl.II')'OlI or nl1)'oI1U lIulIl1U 111 )'0\11' bchnlflollrns lhu Idoll(Il)' 01' whul'cnbou(H 01' nthlll' wlll\UHHUH 110\ dl~u10Hcd' 111 ~'nUI' 1I11H\VOrs. nl' II' )'On 11blllll1 01' " 1\.1111'1I nl' llddltlol\nlll1lhl'lIlnllnl1 roquuHlod heroll1, bill 1101 Huppllod 111 )'0\11' 1II1Hwe1'H, Ihull yO\l Hhnlt pl'01\1plly 1\ll'l1lsh n Hllpp1ul11011lnlnllHWIII' \lndul' pnth ~Ol\lnll1ll111 thu HlllllU, .' ,.. " Dol1nltll1l1H, '1,'I'ho IhlInwll111 dol1nlllnllH nl'e IIppllcnble tn (hOH\.I ~11I1\dnl'd Intul'r()gnlorlu~1 \1" , " I. . t, " " " " , , ,~: r: , , ,~. , ' , , ' ' , ' ' " , '"' , " " l' iI " I ;' , " I " , , , '" " I 1! , ,," I ' H .if ,I' Ij 1 .' J . " '\, " , , " " ,;, , . " " HI . ' ", " , ,. " " , I I " I': , , I' , " ,. " I;' " I' :i " " II " " , , , , , " " 1\ '.j , ' I' !i fl, . ' d " .,1 ;I' 1-\' " I , II;, " H " " ~ i H , . ,.! " , I' jj " , I' " ..,. " " , I! I; i' " " " ., " I'; .. , , " , , , ' I' '! i; , " , I' " " , " " Ii " OJ I, " .l1l':W"1' HIWH, / I He!, / Plr,dnt::Il:!' IN '1'11\': COtJ\('I' of' (!OMMON Pl"I'IA8 O\" C\JMI,liiII<L,^I~P (lOllN'I'Y, P\iilii'lfJY I NAN l^ v, I 1 I 1 I I I , I I , . crvr L, MJ'l'ToN .. L,^W ' NO" !l1l-li6(i!l CTVIII 'l'l;:HM Ii hlUtlli)Nn: fl. I\hll~Nl!;Y d/b/ c\ m, ~-J,' l\blI!JNiJ:V \~\iil,PINCl mmVICI!I and \JI'^ TNcoIH'OI/^'I'i!lD, \)0 I: U 1\<1 illl I' QlUlliR. ()j;' (!(]\JRT AND NOW, \:iI.\n ?o!lt:1l c1i\Y DE AI\911P\:, ;WO:I, UpOI\ " co\,wldol:,;]tlol1 01' Pl<\lnt:II'I' 10 ,Mo\::lol1 '1'0 COIIIPE']. ^n[jw~l.'t:I to rl'ltClJ:J:ogEl\:or.\.un / Hocp\OP\: 1:01:' I"l,'ocltw\:.\.on of' DO<J\.\1\\ol)tn'i.md !<oCjqou\: for Mjndf.lp:l()I1~1 \):1 J:oo\:ml 1:0 \)ol'fJl1cjanl:, "1\IUOI1(1 f3, l<oOIlGY, r.\/bl El, W, $, 1\onnpy Wold:lng fJoJ:v:loo./ und Eollow:ln9 ,q c\:l.1300VO'J.'Y oOI\Eol:OnOO Ii held in \:ho ohlJllllxn:fJ 01' tho \lnc\ond.unoct' :JlIc\go :1.1'1 \~h:lcll\ I:ho PlH.1.nl:.\, r J: Wf\rl l.'oprun(~ntoc1 by fl\:ophun )." Bj,1rkoJ:" IilFJC(\\.1.J:G / ElnQ !,Do f:onQElnt KOGney wn.r'l J:oprononl:m'l by DougliW J3, MElroollo, H1SCJuiro / mlCl ul: wh:loh 00\lnol;11 1'01:' DeJ:ollQllnl: lJP^ 11100rpoJ:ElI:ocl QJ.cj no\: Elppl;li\l.' becf\\180 hhl o]j,onl; WElrl not cHl'oatly :Lnvolvr~,l :Ln \:ho :113(1\.10 of: t,he oonf'81:Gnce, t\nd Plu.jnl:.1.f'f'lf] ,lo\lnfJo'l.'hElv:l.n9 ,:l.nd:LoEltecj I:hi\t ho woulcj bo ,JElt:1. FJ Ued W:I th cOl\lplol:o i1Ilf)wor(~ to yIEdnt U: f: 'fl sGqon~l .Sol; of , . Inten:Ogi,\tOJ:l.ElfJ, withoul: n:f:ei:once to dapool.t1.on l:afJt:l.mony, it :I.s onleJ:C~d and dJroctod 't:hl1t wUh:Ln 30 dElY" of: today I 1.1 Qato Del:onclal1t Keeney oarvo upon Plrd,l1l:i. ('I: . 1:1.111 Elnd ooml~lol:El Ell\fiW8l:s to the q\loot:lorw :I.n PlElJntJJ'f" fJ flc'conc1 SBt oJ: Intm.Tog01:or:LOfJ wi.thout J:Gf'm:elloo \:otontil\lony of' mUgono 8, KC;Jeney :I.n' 11 dopos.l.t.l.on, By tho COllrt, " ,/' ."-/ ..~}IT.~~f0ll tl WOfJ,.oy O.l~( Jl, t9' ' i, " l!Ut\I':l~ll ,,~ FllllLlli:I~lS.\l..cAIiIUi1).IUIUAI. (MII~I h~ 1)'11011'1'111111\ '1\111 ~11\lmIIlPIIII\ 1lllpllplllO) , ' . TO}111\ I'IWTIIONPTI\IW PHI:I '~'lIlnlq.^Nil ('(It IN'!'Y I'lplI~~ IIHI.llw 1'11110\\'1111\ UII>>~; ~~~ ..... M ~ ~""""1i..,..:. ....~ .....";..... ........... ..... ..............."'!...... ............................................... .................. ..................... ........... ~ "; ...... ':~ ..........'u........~....... ....,................ .,",...,.. ....".. ('i) Ihl' ,!!lllY Il'IlIllIllho II~X\ 1~1'I1\ 111'~lvll C\~\II'\, ) lilr 11'1111 \\'llhl1\IIII.lIII')', {Clwck (lllp,) (.:AI'TION OF I-:Nili (~IIIII'~ CIIPlll1l1lllllHI ho BlllIOIIIl\ I'III1l (~I\Opk Ol\U) (X) Civil MilolI ' Lilli' ( .) I\ppolllli'OII\ MI\III'IIIII\1I 1I~liipl nro~,,'\I\u, (olh~r) (1'llIllIqrn ''tit 1l11~Ullo ~, 1\001\0)' <1/11/11 1'- S, l\oOIlP)' Wolilhw Sorvlcu 111\11 Thu \rllllll~t 1I'IIIIw 011110<1111\'-______ 1111\1 Tl'hlls Cl1111111OIIoo Oil 'I" IIPA hWl1l'PIll'IllolI " I'ru\l'llIl~ will ho holll Oil _ (111'101'>> IIru 11110 ~ <l1I)'H hul'l1ro 11I'011'11IIH,) (Thu pllrl)' IlslllI!lIlMolIs~ fhr 11'1111 shllll provl<lo l'ol'\hwllh II oOP)' ol'tho I1l'lIuolpu 10 IIllcollI\Bol, p\1I'>>\lII\l1 101oUIIII{\llu :l \.",,! ,) (1101\31\<1111\1) VS. Nn, lJH,5()()I) Clvll_ 11I1IIuIIIU 11\0 1I1101'1I0Y who \1'11111')' ~IIBO ril\' Iho plli'ly who Iilus Ihls 111'110Ch101 lid\\'lInl.1l1l1lllltJilillultIL_ :lOll ,. /. III(IICIII~ 11'1111 cnllllsoll'nr nlhur pllrllos Irklloll'n: JlulullU!iMlI1:oolln. 1\&lIiilru . This OIlSO Is rOlldy 1\11'11'1111, <:;,\ J SIl\lIoil(' "'v "(' . .. '\ 1'1'1111 NIII1lUI~ill\~lifUJUlllllU' -7 I. (r- / ' I,r .ll111\101 DOll l'duct:l'.li5.l1 II I 1'0 " ' f)1I1~1_.lli1.ll2 ~ AlIl1l'lloy IhI'lJlllllll1Ll1mUlllrWUJ.ll-- " 1J1l~'1': In~I~~ \'1 " " " " ," ':, ,,'- II " " ,.'!, " ,I; i-.' i; 11., " q, " " , " " ;,'j " " Ij !' " " " " " ; " I' . I;; i~' : \1.( 1 I~-i t;: ~: ~'I~ r::: , ..~ I" ':."HI' 1,.'1 L) r.;1:\" 11~1 :~ ~ ~~-, ; 1 ,,' -,-' ~IJ, I i,J !~; I lill)l If/I :i(;. ,'. ,') -'11 i' " "H, '\ .,,: ~,~'-: U) I I'" 1.-'1 ~'j--:: I! Ii, q" ,," " " " I, 1":'.' I.", Pi' , " " ;'; '" Ji " " .. . Ii ~ f ' ,I' q ., If " Ii "; " ;j " , 'Ii pi' 'I " " " jI I:' " " " , f;' i/ " i' " " " "j ..'I I' " " j; , " ," " " I;' ..j' " ,', " " ,. II< , " " .. " " " .j' " " ,. \ . j . ,. " "j It. I' " , , " , , . " ,! ,. ',. " . , . " , , ,,; " , , " , . " , . , . , . .. " ' , , , , H " " ,/'1 , , " ;'/; , , . ,. ., " ('j f! jl " " "" " ,.' , " 'I \', . , " .,(. " II. , ,. 01' , " ." I I' " ' . " I: " f!' "" Il" " " '1" i 'i ., " I 'I '" I' " " j ~\" I. 1',llllHll,\I\lll.t:"II(I,tH,II,\I.II\l\',I'IJ.tdl . l"fJI!\I,II'lIulll,IIUt\M . 1"lil!,1 ~1 l,l'IOlllf ~ 111 AM 1111\1 '~l I' fULJ,.AN lu.alM I~L$tK.,1 O1rfl~'n lltTjllr.A/inRlUkU~AfiN Kl'lOW 1\1,1" MIIN IW "!'IIIIS\! PI~IISI~NTS, '1'11(\'1' WC, 11\llnp\ \lrll\lwrs, 1119, 11\111 PMA Orollp,1\1r 1\11'1 1\1 Onl1shlllrll\lnl1 nl'\hiJ PII}'111011\ uf 1\\0 Sl1\\1 or $2,,()OO,(J(J 1\Oroll'l\h, IIw 1'O\l\llp\ IIn\\ ", s\lrI1olollll}' ol'whloh III IwrohY 1I1*"I1WI\llllloll, IIIHI h}' \hls gP11l1l1l1l Iln, rorll\lrUlllvollnml PilI' 1101r8, " " ,I; ! oxuolllors, IIlhnln\s\rll\prS 1\IlIIIIssIIJI1s, rlllclllIp IIm\ Ihrul'pr IIlsllhll\ll\l UPI\ hworpPI'\I\CIII\IHI I\s , '" clI\'rlor, j)PI1Il111l1 MII\IIIII II1SIIl'II11C\l (:1I111pnl1)', hpl'cll1l1l\or 1'01'01'1'011 I(ins "I~\llollsllll '1'01'11'01111111'," 1\'pl\\ " ", ,I 1I\1Y 1111\\ 1111 1I\l1\1I1111111, dlllllll11PS, ncl!lIl\lI (II' IIIIlllIUS ur 1I\lllnth clllll11s, 111111\rlh\III\111', Imlolnl\llY, \losIS, . IUHS or lIurl'lous, uXpoIlSOS, O~li11pOI1Sllllol\' 111111 nlluP1\1I01\IIUI\IIIII 1111\1 hWUI1SP11I1U111111\ Ihlllllll!u, Il1ulillllllll hili 1\11\ 11111111311 III clnllllll Ihr ulll\lrlhll\lulI 01' im\ullllllly io IIIIY olhur IW\'SIlI1I PIII'lY "I' OOrplll'lI\\\1l1l1rI81111101l\ (11'1111)'1111(\1111 cllll\l1l1 1'01' IlIj lII'1911. I\I10ll'I111pl\ 1111KllolI'l1l\1 IlK, II'hloh I11I1Y,hlll'O . r9Kllliv1\ ~'011111 111'0 which IlCO\IIW(\OI\ Fohl'llllr>'2, 199H. 1'01' \\;hloh u\ni\l1l1l1lll\1l!l \wuI1II1S\ltllloll HIlll . l~ pOllllll1ill11 IIw COllrt \1I'Cu111111011 PIOIIK IIrc\l\l1hurllll1ll CIl\IIII)' 11\ No, lJR.5liCi9" " .' hilho 01'0\11 II11Y pI'ORcll\ Ill' 1\1\111'0' I\urolldll!ll III Iho IIlhr08111<1 110\1\111 01' u\ho\, pcrson or Inrll~lI~or ollllll1l1l111lllnlll \~olollsoIITnl'lrunSUI' 1111119 1I11]I'UlIIIIII1\olloll 0\' 1I110pl\rll\0 Ilo\lol1l1rlah\lfOIl\ Ill'lho 111'01'0111111\ I1l'u ,Ib\' c0I1\rlhllll\111 or 1\1llonll1l1y, 11111 filrllWl' IIg\'U\l(\ hy \IS Ihlllllll>' JulllllHcl1\ ol1\ol'od O\, dl\I1\1I~OR IIIIRCRSUII 01' rCuol'ol'lIhlul\llllil1sll\I1~' olhcr IIl1ullo<l lorll'o1l80rK hy Hump\ r~ro\h~r8, IIw, ahllll bo rcdl1cod hy 111111\110\1111 U1l"llllo 11\0 111\\011111 ol'uol1sldornlloll pllld for Ihls golollso, O\, rQI' ,. I\W pro 1'11111 Rhl\l'O of' I.ho RolclI~od TlJI'll\JlI~nl', or 111 1110 OV{\II! IlIuulw dolil.l'llIO fiJI' l\nl11lwlItll'lI I1cgllgollcols hult! 10 bc Ilpphollhlcl 111 \110 1111101111\ of \hc I'ollltlvo f'u'\lI\,lfuIIY, IIl\rlhlllcJd hy II OUllli 't " IlI'jlll)' 10 RololIsod ,\,01'11'0111101', whlollovor 18 grolllCl',lIl1d Ihls Rolull80 IIhllll opol'lll01l8 118111181'11011011 0f'1\1I Clll11118 '1I111l11181 IIl1cll o\I\Cl'pcrs\1l1s or 10rlf'ulIsnrll 10 Iho oxlol1l of' Iho \,clll(\\,o PI'\1'\'1I11I or , ' pCl'oolllllllC 811111'0 uf Iho UOllllllOl1l1l1hlllty of Roldnsod 'l'ol'lfcnllol' 111l1'uln\,0Ionsod, who slml\I101 ho l'uapolIslhto for I1I1Y I\lrllle\' plIymcl1\s.olhcl' 1111\11 solforlh hOl'ol11 nrlslng Il'oll~ Iho nfo\'0811111 Incldul1l " ollhor dlrootlYlo 118 01' 10 \Ill 1\1lllrcollY thro\lgh cOl1lrlh\lllol1 or indollll1ll1clI\lo\l of o\hol' n\1olJod Imirollsor8, whclhor 0\' 1101 pllr\II\R 10 Iho IIfOrOSl\ll1 nCllol1, '\'h18 Rc\on80 III holl111Il\l\do PII1'II\111111 10 I\llll 111 cOl1rnl'lnlty with tho p1'\1\'1810118 oflha Uniform , CU\llrlhl1\1ol1 Amo\lg TOl'll'cl\Sllr9 Act liS cl1l1clollll1 Iho Cllml11l1\lWOII\th or POllI1SY\I'IIIlIIl, This 1\0101190 il1110WIIY cllllslIl\llcs 1I1111<1I11lssl.\ll1 of I\lIhl\lI>' lW 11I1Y pllrty 1'010115011 h'ol'oll1, 1,1, '"~ I " ,.., . /, '" 1,llIti!iIHI.\llll'll.W;!li,\l Ilil('ll:I(I,. "1)1 \ lfi".1 II II III II I. I: ,~\l ' IIp\1111 111 \t/Ulili Jill ,\\I \111'111: ,. " FIIJ J I "I\l'/llCU~IPI ,1';1'1':-11111 NT .JOIiT FI!~MinH.HI~Ll'll\.:1I~ KNOW 1\1,1, MI\N 13)' TIII~Sli I'I~HSHNTS, '1'/11\'1' \l'U, Ilul11pl Urollwrs, 111\l, IIIIIII'MI\ Ul'l1l1p,lill' IIIH.IIII \!\II1HhlurllllllllllrUIIl PII>'I\I\II\\nflllll HlIl11ol' $2,,(JOO,OO huru\I'llh, Ihc l'ocolpllll1l1 lI\lf'I1lllul1\!Y 111' whh:h III Iwr\!h)' \lllkllllll'ludllUd, 111111 h)' Ihis H\llul\lIu dn,lhrl1\1\'solws IIlId Pllr hiliI'll, UXU!l\l\lIIS, 1IIIIIlIIIISII'I\IDrll IIl1d IItlsiul1s, 1'01\JI\IIU 111111 Ihl'uI'CI' dlHcllllrllP UPA IIwl11'1lOI'IIIud 11\111 lis . )'. , lllllllul',l1l1l1UlllI1 Mll\lIl1lll1S\lrlll\Co C.'l1l11pnll)',lwrl'illlll\llr 1'\'I'url'ud 1111111"I~ulclIsodTnrll'olls\lI'," frol11 lII,y 1111i1 1111 dCl11l1l1l1l1, dlll11!lguII,lloljol1H nr ClllllluS nl'lIolll1l1, clnhlls, cl1l1\rihll\loll,llldul11l1l\)', COS\H, ,. Ium; 111' HUI'I'I\JIlH, uxpUIlSUH, C\lIIlPOl\lIllllul1 111111 1111 eOllllOlll1Ul1llnl 111111 illul1l1l111\llIonlllll dlll1l1lgc, Il1ulllding 11\11 11111 I I 111 II\J" 111 cllIll11s fbl' enl1lrlhllllol1l1l' IlIdol1ll1ll)' 111 nil)' r!t1wl' pllrSlIl\, pnrlY or UllrpOl'lllll111 nrlsll1g 11111111'1111)' IIl1d 1I1I1:IIIII11H for I I1jlIr1us, kl1l1wl1l1l1d IlIlkl1llll'n 10 \IH, whlohl1lllY hlll'u rUlIllllud 11'0111 n I1ru which ol:\J\I\'rud nil Fubnllll')' 2, IlJlJH, Ibr whl\Jh clnhll Hull hllH hcun Il1sllill\cll nlld ' III I'UI1\II\lUIII thu C'ourIIlI'Col\\11101\ Plunsnf'ClIIllhul'lul\lI Cnlll1l)' nl No, I)H-,,(j(i9, ,. r " , 111 Ihu 01'\111\ 1111)' I'I'usul11 or [\1\111'0 fk'fu\I\h\nl ill Ihu IIl'ilrusnld I\ullnll or olhor ,porsoll 01' , lorll'ul\sor \Jlnl111sllllnlllsl I\olollllud Tortl'unsol: Il1lhullfhrullllld nollol1 or II supnl'nlo' ncllon IIrlslng nllt , 01' Iho IIli1!,usllld 111'0 1'00000nlrlbllllol) 01' ilidull1llilY, II is I\lrlhol' 1I11I'OCII h)' \IS thlll 1111)' JIIII1l111111l1 , ' ,,', ol1\OI'ud lll'(llIl11l1gus llssossud nl' rocol'ol'lIh Iu IIlWll1st IIIlY olhpr 1I1101l~d ICll'lfulISllrll by Ilulllplllri\tllOrs, 1110, shllll110 rucllluod by 1111 1I\l1 11I\l1 I cqllllllo thu IlIllllllllllll'col1sldol'llllol1 pllid Ihl' Ihls Rulullllol 01' I'llI' "" ' " Illc,p/l) 1'11111 allillf; or the [1.clcIIScdTOI'lfill\5IJl', l'l,illlhu evclll Ihat the docll'inf~ '1'01' e01l1pllrllll\'~ 110gllgonoo III holillo bo IIppllcllhlo,llllhc 1I11\Ill111111flhc I'ollltll'o fimll, 1I'II11Y, IIttl'lhlllcd by n cmlrt or jury III l~ololl~cd TorI I'ollsor, whichul'ol' is grunlur, IInd this RllloUllC shllll opol'nto liS n RIIIISlilC\llln or 1111 clllhnllllllllhlS\ HuulI olhcl' pursol1s ol'tortfulISOI'II 10 tho oXlonl of Iho l'ullI\ll'u pl'O I'lItn or pUrCOlllllllu Hhnl'o ol'tho CO\l1l11on IIl1hllll)' or RolclIHod TllnfulISlll' hUl'ul11 rclulIlIud, who shllll 1101 ho 1'0spol1sIhlu 1'01' IIn>'llll'lhcl',pIlY\l1CI1IS olllOrlhlll\ sol fortH humll1ul'lsll1g fi'o\l1lho IIfbrOllnld hluldolll ollhcl' dlroolly III liS 01' tll liS 1l1dll'cully tllrnllgh" olllllrlulllloll or Indu1l1111f10lltlon or olhol' III1CllCd 11l1'l\'unHors, \l'hcthul"ol' 1101 pnrllcs III thu IIlbl'Cllllld IIcllol1, ,. ThlH Rolcllso IH bolllg \l1l1dn P\l\'lIUlIl1lloUll\ll11 cOl\l'onnll}' wllh thu provllllollll ol'lh\\ Unlronn ('ol1ll'lhllllOIl Allllll1g Tortl'clI~OI'II Acl liS ol1l1olcd III tho COl1uuonwcllllh of POUI1S)'IVIUllu" This Relcllllc III 110 WU)' uOl1flllllltcs IIlludl11lsslon 01' Iluhllll)' b)' illl)' purt)' I'clcused hOI'oll1." I' "; , \" '" /i I Iii: I" iill; I' . )lli, ' Ii ,I ~ I ' . [\\r, I, 1,/'1, IIi" i! ! If 1\'::: .!" '1,' ',,' , ') J " I I " ~ " t~,; ..~ .. o\:jflO " , Ii I~\Q ~ .. I' nF1i~~, , , ,I' f~~ ~J i " i I ~ ,Z ~' " , ~ ~ d' ~ F1 ''l ~ f I i I I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cId t7, I" ~ ~ ~ VlVIIS .:., .: ~ a: ," ~ d ~~~~~i. , t7, 2 '" ~ ~' ~ ~ " ", if 'j i., " !' " " " H , .; i" I ,j "1' !,. ! , ,. I I i I I I I i' i I , , I' I ,/\, I , I I' it ,. " ,; i i" ., " " . '_il\ > " ; "', . " ,II,/t; '" " , J 'i ' \. \. I.' ' 1',t~~U\:;, J~, 'j - I "_ -i~;'(i1'-_/, '-'1- " ~f .."'--r,, 1\ " "h' ,/1 \~1 ~,-'Il~-:'''I.lj; f ,.'., 'J' , ). '\\(I"'~) ,(. I!'.' "'\ I\j~-'--j\\ ,;' j j'J' -."-,,,;," j" ~'," '. ....i -,> \ ~'J t l\" . ',- f t' '". I' !)_' 'i~,'" ~,' 'V., ,,~,": II I; ;,.- - ,~' ~ 't;$, t' ,\-. \ '1.! _'-.1- .' - -;'{', . Ihh) "'i' . ,./'\,\ ~!r" I '1 r. ll..; (, , ' .\t( i f. .) ,"'. .if l'" ,/,ri.'W,1_ . . ".-1 /,(, '\' , 'L.'; , I' " , 1\ -ii, ,'. /. I} '. I '.' " " '. ,< ." '(I i~t ).', I, ,,',1.' \ '\ '. ''''Ill' ~' -\~ -') ,) ~r I . I I' '~ 11; I' _~l'li, iN~\' .; ',I ~t~'l' ,. (,"~i'I);1 "it,;! , 1'1-'; r'~ .' \'. nl(,i; I." '.t { . ~ ' . ': , " '\" I, _;.~A>%;r " 1" ,I '. "it, , ' I !,i ;.I!, " " " " " " " ~I ,,!' ~ , \ . " I " I ,,' . " .. ,'-, , ; " . 1, .. " , d ! , I . , " , pJ' I " I' " C 1(\ i I \ ' I.' )Il. " I . " I I r,1 ~ I . L , 1:1 (.) " ,."1,' It " " I'"~ " " 'j'" , . I!',', " " " ,i' " ,I; I' ,II !{ ,1'1' r! " ;,; " " ;; " I; " , " " " '" , . I':" " ," -'1 .' ,',' 'j, , . " 'I. " I';, " , i' ",; " I' " I; ,. " II' 'f I" " ". " . i "I' '"~ ,. ,. ". f) ,', r" \.. .... , (') I,' ~' f t 1;"\-, /,1, ," ~:'J (Y;, \, , , i;,5 )"j'.~'\ " " t\ jl ",. l .':::;: , ,. \:"':) ~)- f... . ) .~7) '>I: ';; '.. " " " " " 't Ii i" " " I' " " ,,;, I:; " i' Hi " " H "., ;; " "" j't! 1I-'/II"'!I,t:,ld Vii'!\,\,J\:c'l 1"('1') 'I'I{-."', iI','"' "''.1, " t\ ,I" ,I<..J", l' "; l:ili' :;1) r:,1111 !PI I' ,),11<1'1(,1'1'./';' 'Crdl :1,' 'I' ;. 'I , i , " " j, 'I , , , II " , , , " It " , ;. I' " " " 'i '.' ,I " " I. " ii' I' "; i, j" " '.." ;; , ,1-, ,. ",I' " " ',I d' .,. " .t',,, I' I', I' ,. , I. , ". fi: " " fIKhlblt A " " I' ",' "I '. .\1 ,.,j " " ii, ,. " " " " ,', ;1 '0; ,. I". ," " ." ,II ,. " " r/: II, ,. " " ,'"j, j,' Ii; I' 'I; ,," I' " Ji' ,i" " " '" " ;' I'; ,. " " " " I', " " " .. '.' ,. Ii ," " " " ,. " ,. ,. " Ii If, II. (I' " ) I' "I " , ,. ;'- I' " I; " I' I' " ,-" " ;1: " It !j- " " ,. " ,-p .. " " I' , i ' " " " .' " " " " r," ,." Ii " , . " " .1< '1 i' " " " " " " ", ',. " " " 'I H " " " ,,' , . ,i, I'! I"~ I' I; " I', !i /.1 " " " , ji , . " " " , Ii " , . I'" " "I' I' " " " " " , . /1 " , , . ," I!' " " , .. " " ;,1 .' " " II " .j' " " "" " " II " " , " 'I; h~a , . " O~lUlflilAT1UU<:J:i~1iY.l{lli tlNn NOW. IhlH I Hili \In)' or ,hIllO. :!()IU, I h~nlb)' \l~r1II)' Ihnl I Slll\\ 1111'110 nml uIII'\'\l9t 1l0PY or tlw l\1r\ll.wII\U \hW\II1IPI1\ \11 Ilw lilllowlnl.l oO\II1H\l1 or ruuIIl'Il, by plnvll\l.lll uoPy III' HIIl1W 111' thu \lI1I\U\\ ~llIluII, I1l"s\ uhlllH 1\11111, plllllnl!\l11l'\lplllll. n\l\INHII\l11 ns IhllllWHI " " l.lllwlI\'\\ ^, ,hwllcr, ,II'.. Iillqlllr~ Whllul",,1 WlIllnlllH1l,I,I' I HUll O\lU 1,IborlY Plnuo . 'Phllll\l~lphln, PI\ I \l11l~.IJ~l)~ Pllillol K, P\lnl'll\lrn; nllq\llru M^,fl'HON1 J)lliAHllOHlrtl\ WII,I.IAMH ~\:t 0'1"1'0 'l'O\lHIIlI\ 11111h HII'IJut Cnrllll\u, PA 171113 ,. I' . "'i~tH'~.'!l(:~~H ~B.~l"~"' !",,;, Dill I!lnH 1\, Mnruullo, IIsl\\Ill'o . " '\, " j' ,. " ,. " . Ii ..j, I, II i' ,,' ,. " " " ,. I' Ii " . ,," ,. 5, penlerj, AI1Bwprlno ppfpmll1nlls wl\l10ul 1IIl0wlpdoo PI' hMrl11fllloq flEl to 11113 Inllh of \l1\'l !lVClrmpnlEl pf Pf.lr!lorf.l(lh ' Ii flnrl, fm S!JClll\ Is elpnl!ld flncl proof thprpof Is clemnnclecl A\ 11113 lima of Irlfll, ..' .. . 6, Ail 111 I\ledIn pml nl1d denloefln pml, 1\ I~ ndl11ll1ed tl1o\ on or prior \1'/ I=al)ruflry 2, 1998, Ph'lln\lff rel1W~6Io(1 I~~loellO 8, I<eeney to rel110ve n Elecllon of piping, Any' Elnd "Ii O\lW . Elvernwnts of Pf.lrl1grflpl1 6 me clenlpd AS 1I1e AnSWering Pefendflnl Is Wl\houl !<l1owledge or . Inforl11f1\lon flS 10 1I1e 11'11\11 ofll1e Averl11anls of PnrElOl'Aphll and, 'flS sl1011 1\ lEI 'denied "net proof Ihereof lEI demancled At 11113 Ilml1 of IrlAI, 7, Aclml\led In pM nnd danl!ld In pm\. It IEl adnll\led Ihfll i=~lgeile 8, I<peney Iwl prevlollsly worked fll PIAln\lff~plnl1\. 1.1 Is Qdml\ted Ihnl p~lgene 8, I<eeney I1Ael prevlo\1slY ,. ", I,' " ' Worked on Plfllnllff's plpea, 1\ Is denied II1AI r:Ugene 8, I<eenay I1f.1d previously workecl on or kneW of plpas oonlAlnlng rul>per lining, Any f.lncl All olher f:\vermenla of Pflrf\gmpl1 7 Are clenled ,; I'" flnel proof thereof IEl denlAl1llecl fll 11113 lima of IrlQI. 8, penled, . It 16 f:\dl11l\lEld tl1f1t Mr, !<eeney ~,spd a torol1 to sever 11 pipe, 1\ Is ,Ienled 1111'\1 he WElS flWnre .ll1e pipe upon whlol1l1e WflS worlllng 11Eld fI rul)l>er liner, 9, penled, Ills Eldll11\\ed II1f1t Mr, I<eeney useel a torol1 10 out two 110les In Il1e pipe, 1\ Is denied \l1f1ll1e Wf.lS ElWElre 11113 plp13 upon whlohl1e WElS working hEld a rlll>l>f.lr liner, 10, Adml\ted In pllrtl:\nd denl\!ld In part, Ills Eldl11l\\ed II1Eltfl fire OOCUl'req fll Plaintiff's pl!1nl, Any find all olher flvermenls are denied, In Ihe al\flrnnllve, Answering Pefendnnl Is wllho~11 Inforn1f1\1on or\Jellef flS 10 the Irulh of 11113 bElIElnce of Ihe flvermenls find proof .Is dem~nded '11 time of trlfll, 11, P\'lnled, 1\ 10 denied Ih'll Ihe fire and reaultlng damage 10 Plalilllff's, property WElS a dlreot and proxlmale result of Defendant Keenoy's Work In ouHlng PIElln.tlff's pipe Wltlllhe use of fllorch, 12; Denied, AnSWering D13fendanl Is wltholll knoWledge 01' Informa\lon as to Ihe truth of Ihe aVElrmen\s of Paragreph 12 ."n~, as SUCll II Is denied and proof thereof Is demanded I1l,\he time of IrlAI, . " " 13, Denied, A!1swerlng Pefend~nt Ie wlthoul knowledge or Inlorn1a\lon as 10 Ihe trulh of \he avermenls of Paragraph 13 and, as suo!llt Is denledl1nd proof thllrqof Is demanded al \118 " \lme of \rIa\. 14, Donled, Answering Defendant Is wllhoul knowledge or Inlorma\lon fIS to the Irllth 01 Ihe avennenla of Paragraph 14 and, as such Ills danled and proof thereof Is demanded at tlie t1ine of Irlal, " 1 p, panla~l, An~warlnQ pafanct~n\ Is WI\llO\I\ know!aqga or Inlorl11l\llon f1S \0 \1113 \r~llll 01 \lla [Wal'l1wn\s of Pf1rf19fI1PI116 IIn~I,f1S slloll It Is r.lanlaq I1n(1 proof! Il1arao! I~ (lal1111nclecf 111 \118 lima of \1'11\1, OOUNLI . NeQIIQIlI1PP Homllt !=Ires,! Illo, v, t:lIUPIlP I'l, l~ppnpy cUP/II ~,I'l, t~llallPY Wol\\lnu servliip 16, Tile Answering pafend1\n\ Inoorporalas Pmf1gmpl1s 1 \l1l'ougl1 15' of pafeml!ln\'s Ii" Answarwl\11 Naw Mll\lar \0 Plaintiffs Complf1lnl as If sa\ fpr\llln full1\nel mllcfa.ll PM Imeof, 17, Panlad; It Is qanlaq 111111 flny dCHl1a9a \0 Plalnllff's properly f1nda~penBa8 Incwrl'ad l'alevm11 \11131'13\0 wem ca~lseel bYf1ny negllgant, reoklass or o1\relesallc\s 01' ol11lslllpns of pefendc1I11, (11) panleel, Ills danleq lhf.'lt 11113 pefenqanl fllllecllo or Wf.'lS rl:lq~llred'o properly hlspect P!f.'Ilnllff's piping for kn.OwnI1Cl~lIr~18 Clnq/pr oCl11pus\lple n1Cllerlllla, f.'Iny Clnd ClII Clllegl\lIons of known l1a7.arcls or oomlllla\lpla 111I1\arlals are denleel f1nel proof \l1I1I'aof Is cfel11al1decf alll1l3 lime of trial, . , (b) Danlecf, 'Ills denlad \lwlll1e paflilncfan\ fallad 10 lake neges8C1rypreoauII~na \0 prevant spark!!, flal11es o.rl1ot em pel'S from oomlng In\o contacl WIlI1 comblls\lllle materials, It ", I' , ' Is speolfloallY ,cfenlecj \hlllll1e pefcmcfl1n\ knew or ~l1ollld' 11131'13 I\nowri Il1a\ cOl11puellple materials were wlll1ln Plalnllff's piping system, '(0) Donled, 1\ Is c1anleel 111\.'1,1 tha Dafandanl falleel 10 foltow proper, acoepted oonslruc\lol1 E\nd walellng prac\lces, (d) panled, '1\ Is denied Ihal IhePefendan\ fl'llled 10 warn Plaln\lff of the dEmgers , I ',' , ',. of using a welding torch on PIE\lntlffs piping and/or the Pefendl'lnt w~s required, 10 do 130, Any and all allega\lons Ihal pefelldC1I1\ knew or should have known 111131 \ll~ piping oontalned oombusllble mE\lerlf1ls are cte'nledand proof thereof Is demanded Clt 11113 \lme of trial. ' " (e) Denied, It Isdenledil1elt Ihe DefendClnl fall~el to'perform the work In II good and Workmanlike mannaI', (I) Denied, It Ie denied \l1al the Pefanc1cmt failed 10 malntaln'a properflra watoh , ' '. after oomplellng Defendant's work and/Qt, In tho alternallve., Ihe Defendanl hnd E1 duty 10 do so, ". (g) Donled, 11 Isdet11ed Ihat \he Dofendant failed 10 perform the work In " ' , ji aooorclanoe with applloallle feeleri'll, s\llte and/or 100131 codes and regula\lons, Inoluellng, bulnot IlInlted tb, Ihe National Fire Protection Assoola\lon, (h)benl!3di It Is clehled tl1allhe Defenelant fa\ledto apply \0 the work the degree 0/ skill whloh would cuslomarlly be Ilroughllo such work by compelent and skilled welders, " (i) .. plll1iacl, 1\ Is ~lenle(1 \Ile\ \110 IJefemhlll\ fQlled'Io IlclequfllalY enq prop\lrly pm\flol l:llllln\l(f's propellY lJn(ler \11U clrc\1l1lB\t1I1Cetl, (J) P13nleq, 1\ 18 denllllj 111;11 \he Dofrmdflnl (fllle(I \0 tflka refo1spnf\\ll(3 end epproprlll\e moasuroalo (lx\\n~ulsh Iho Ore, Any p.nd {311 <llIool1llons Ihel the Dofenctan\ oroa\f:lq n qenoero\1S ooml1\lol1ls qenled end proof \\1Uraof Is dal11fmdeq e\ \\le 11I11e Qf Irlf:ll" , (k) Dllnl(3d, Ilia del1lerl \11111 IhaDofandenl 1~II13d \0 If:lkarllf:lsOnfl\ll\3 f.1nq IIpproprlelo maesuras Ill. Ilmely nollfy flrll I1nd/or 1'01100 qfflolflla, Any .lnd. fIll el\agfl\\onS Ihf:lt Df1fendf1nl oroalecj qQnO\~rll~IS oond1\\ons(\l'a danled and proof Ilwreof Is clamflnd(3d fll 1116 \\me of Irlfll, (!) 'Denied, II Is denied Ihal Ihe pefendf1nt ff1l1ed 10' 1101 raasonl~t)ly and appr9prll11ely unqer Il1a olrolll11slQnoes,' 1 a, Denied, II Is denied Il1fll \\la pe(end~nt !Jrafloheq lis (My of Ol'\l'l'l I'\nd/or I'\clad rlaollorl!l\\Y fWI failed 10 p(3rform worK In a workl11l'\nlll\e l11anner and/or InOPl11pl\anoe wl\l1 good pl'l'\olloe f.1lld alflndflrds In \\lS Industry flnrj/Or ordinarily employeq \ly fl reasOnl'\ll1f:l, p[llden\ licensed weldorl . , 10, penlocl, 1\ Is qenleq Il1al as e dlraol flnd proxlmele r€lsullof \he negllO(3nl ~ols end omissions of pefenclenl I'\nq Ills failure 10 perfonn his worl< In' fl v'lPrkmanlll<e mennaI', Plalnllff auall'\lneq deml'\ged 10 I'\nd des\nlo\\\'H\ of Ila real and perlloi"1al properlyanq b~lelness Inolllqlng bUsiness In\erl'\.lp\\on,exlra expense I'\nQ oUiflr Inoldentelend oonsequenllel demeoes, WH~RgrORg, p(3fendanl I'equesls Ihls Honomllls Qourt .10 dismiss plaintiff's Complaint, COUNT \I . 13rollllhof COl1trallt el1d Implloll Wllrrlll1ty of Wprkml1l1shlp Hompt 13ros"lno, v, Ih19ono s, l~eonoY dl~11I 1:, B, 1<1l11I1IlY W\lI!l\no Borvlce . ;10, The AMwerlno Defendant Inoorporates I~aragrapha 1 Ihl'ough 10 of Pefelldal1t'o Answer with, New MillieI' to Plalntlffsqo111plalnt aa If Rei forth In full end made a pml 11ereof. 21, Adml\\ed In pmt and denied In part, II Is admllted tl1at Pefenda,,1 agreeQ 10 perforn1 'werl< on a seollon of piping at Plalnllffs manufaoturlng plant, Any al1d all oll1er averments of Paraot"ph 21 are denied "nd proof the,reof Is demanded al Ihe IlIne of Irlel, 22, Penleq, The avel'll1enls of paraoraph 22 slale a oonOILISloll of law to Whloh 110 respo,11Slve pleadlllg Is I'equlred. In the nltel'l1allve, It Is denlsd Ihal any spoulfio terms 0/ any oOlilracl required pefendant 10 ramOVe the piping In a good and workmanlike manner, any and all allega\lons as \0 n conlraol are deiiled and proof thereof Is demanded ~t lime of trial. ' " \ \ I I , I : .i I I I , I' , I' " 2(3, penlll~\' Any flml flll fllle0l1110116 of A oon\raol \l1fll 6peolflofllly slf1laQ \l1n\ POh1l11lfll11 woa solelY rasponsll)lll for ,uncI/or l1ad oOl1lrpl. over 111a 00116\l'\lo\lon' mann6, .nwll1ods, " ' laQI1nlcl~lesl sequenpes, or proOed~lres or for oqorillnflllno flll pO[\lon6 of Il1e wprk Inoludlno, \)ut nol IIml\od 10 \110 prop\"lr unct silfa use of welding mflterlnls me clelllod flnlt proof \l1ereof Is qemflllqed ill Il1e lime of Irllll, ~4, penled, 1\ Is Clll\1ll3cl \llfll A\ Il1a tlma of pafenchml's rendarlng of 1116 6ervloes, Pafenciunl knew or sl10uld hilve knowl1 Il1ill Plalllllff was relylnO Llpon Ills superior knowlllqge, . ' 'I, aklll nnq e~per116e, g5, Panled, Tlleilyermenla of Pf1rilprllPI1 2p sln\e q oonolu610n of lilW 10 wl1lcl1 11\1 re~pOl16lve pleilellno Is required, In \l1ll !ll\ernilll,ve, 1\ Is ljenled Il1ill \l1ll Pefendanl Impliedly . wMrilnteel Elnd reprasenteq Il1fll 11e WilS skilled In Ihe field of welellno ilnci \llfll 111swork woulell)e parformllq In il good ilnq WqrkmE1nlll<e mE1nl1er wlll1Pul elefeo\s ilnd/or In 11 mE1nnar wl1lol1 woulq be (II for ordinary ilnelln\!wtael purposes, ~6; penleq, Tile f1verrnrmlll of PE1m9l'ilph 26 slate E1 00110lLIslon ,r,>flllW 10 whlph no rsspon~lve plellellno Is required, In \l1e alterna\lve, It Is dehl~d \ll/:1t tile pefendanl\Jreaolwq ilny Implleel warrilnlles 10 anelloI' ~ny oonlraol wl1l1 the [Jlillnllff to perform the work In a professlonill and workmflnllke mElnner anelloI' ff1l1eel 10 silfely perform \118 work, Any anq all f1l1f.1Oiltlona of oontrilO\, warrf1nllea or pafenciilnt's fE1I1Llre 10 silfely perform Ihe work ilre spaolnoally danled, , ' 27, Pell1lad, II Is cienleel 111 at at ell. times relevant herelo, tile Plillnllff .fUIfilleel Il1elr oPllgf1llons ~lI1eler IIle oontrilo,t, , 28, penled, The Answering pefendell1\ Inoorporales tM' ilyerments of lIs anSWartl 10 Paragrapl11.7 as If sat for\l1ln f\IIl. It Is elel11ed Il1at Ihe Defendanl \:lraaolwd !lIlY oonlraol and/or Ill1plleel warranties 10 Il1e 'Plalnllff, ell1Y and all allegations of Implied oonlraots and/or Implied Wamlnllea are speolfioally denlag and proof Il1el'aof 15 damendeq al the Ilma,o( Irlill, ,Wl-IgREFOR~, Defendant requests Ihls Honorable Oourl to dismiss Plalntltrs' Oomplalnl, " OOUNUIl Negltgol1oe HomPI 131'00" 1110, V, UPA,1t1c, . II 29, Tile avern1Dnls of PElraorf1phs 11hroLigh 28 of Oefendanl's Answer wltl1 NeW Malter " 'I, 10 Plalntlfrs Oomplalnt are Inoorporated herelnlll1u made 1.\ partl1ereof ae If sel forll1ln full, "',, . i 30.32; Oenlaci, The Ilvermants of PomOl'ophs 30-,32 are cilreoted 10 a party other Ihan Il1e .. Answerll1g Defencial1\ and no responsive pleaellng Is raqulreci, Ih 1I1e illlerhatlVB,llE1ld , ' averments are elenled al1el proof thereof Is dell1andedal the tln1s of ttlal, WI..m,RUFOI~E, Defendant requ'estlJ this Honoraple to dlslnlss Plalnllfrs 00111ple1l11, "j. " " " " " " " " " I'. .' " 'j.' ,. " ,. " " ;1' "., , i\ " " " "J., " rll " "'I; " "I. " ,.!j, " " H \, ",. '. " 1"\' III i " ~ " II" " \.' Ii I'" I)., " ,. " I'" ,,' " ,. I" " u j;' 11' .. ,,, I; .' I, " " ,[' " "qi " ,. " '. Ii :~(, , i i l ,'~ ,[,\ : I~. , I" , " " , . if , Ii " " l\ I; "'I' " I." " 'i' 1;-/ " 'j, '1, ." " ., " r ., " " " " I( 1-") r " Ht 'I '"~ ,i II I, ,\ I Ii" ,. " " l 11I.\iH"",\'llr"(I'~\\I\\ 1\\1('11:'111, ,jll' "IUII,1 Ull\Il1111 )IM! , ~!I\llll (II \ri ('ll'~ Jl 11.\\' WI'IU: . EI!I, L..M~J]'GUJ\II'I. J~'[\!~.\I1UlfLTII BTEI'~A!:iUg.lnaJkMm I\NOW AI-I: MIIN U,Y TilES\! PHI:SnNTS, '\'1\1\'1' \\'u, Ilcl11p\ Hrollwl'fi, IIlU, 111111 \1MA C1rllll\lII\lr IIllil hi 1l\ll1l1ldurn\\plll1l'1lw PIIX!ll1ll1\ ol'lllc HI\\11 (II' $25,OOO,O(l 11Uruwllh, \ho rcuclpllll1\1 ' ~\I rf1olul\llY of whluh III hurch)' l\o~Il(l\\'ludllU(\, 1111I1 h)' Ihls R\JlullfiC 1111, 11)I,'UlII'lIulvclllll1\ll1\1r 11\llr~1 cX()1l1l101'~, IIdl11ll1lr.\l'nlnI'S 11111\ IIlmlUl1l1, ro\cn~c nl1d Ihrc\'lll' dluohll\'ll\l UP,\ hWlllllOl'II\cilnnrllts cllrrlor, i:lol1ulllll M\II\II1III1S\lrIlIlPU COI11\1I1I\}'. IWl'l1llllll\ol' 1'01'u1'I'0111\1 1111 "ltclollllP(\ 'l'or\r\lIlIlOI',11 rroll\' ,my ,wI 1111 dCl11l1llds, (\1111111[\011, IIclloll~ 01' UIIIISOS I11'IICllol1, ul!lil11S, uOlllrIl1\lllol1,ll\llcrI1l1Ity, costs, , luss or lIcr\'lccs, OXp\ll1r.us, cOl11pl1l1l1l1\lolI !l1ll1 1111 Cl1llllul\\lOIIIIIII 111111 IIll)IlI111CI\\IUIlIIIII dll\11I1110, 1'l1ollldll111 h\llllolllll1l1oll 10 Olllll11s Ibl' \1l11l\l'lh\llloll,Il\' Illdul11llll)'ILl IIIIY 0(111)1', perllolh\lIlI'\Y or corpllnl\lollllrl~lllgn\l1 ol'II11Y IIl1d 1111 clllll11s n~r IIIJ\lrlull,lillOWII IInIII\I1KI1\!Wn 10 \lB., whlcll 11111)' \11,1\'0 I'cs\llIud 1'1'011111 rtru wlllch llCCillTlll1 on Fcl1l'lllll'}' 2, 1 \11)8, for whloll cllllll1s\l11 hila \lOcn 1I111111111ed 1111I1 Is \lQllllhllllll \hc CO\lrtol'Conmwl1 1'10lls ol'C\llI1bcl'llIl1d CIllIl1I)'1I1 No, 1)8-566\), I~ . 111 Ihc cl'on\ !IllY pl'csunl Ill' 1\1\llre dufclj\llIl1\ In Ihc ill'orcs!lld IIcllllll or Ll\l1cr pOI'SOI1 or \or\l'ollllor 11111111ls IIUIIIIISI Rulol\scll '\'orlfcllsor In Ihcl\l'ol'usllld IIclloll or II lIcpllrlllc IIcllonllrlsll1l! 0\11 i' \11' Ih'6 nf\ll'118111d liru .I'llI' cOIHrlhutlol1 or 11;llul1\nll)'. 11111 fllrlhcr I\llrccd b>' \ls\hl\l miy Jlldll11\OIlI. , " elllercd or dllllllllloS I\lIl1cssud 01' ruco\'el'lIhlu i\~I\IIIBI 1111)' olhol' 1I110go\1 to\'lfcl\lIors hy H61\1pl 13l'olhol's, ,. " 1110, shllll ho I'oducud b>'1I1I 111\1(1\1\11 o'l\lul 10'lhc 1\Ill00lllt ofool1sldul'lIllol\ pl\ld 1'01' Ihls Rclollso. or for . , \lIoplo 1'illlllllllllC of lllc RelollAI:d Tmll'l:usol', 01 111\110 ovcl\l Ihut the doc\rinc 1'01' ,;ol\1pnl~lItl\'~. l1ullllllol1cC Is IIcld 10 bo 'ilpplluublo, 1111110 UIllOIIl1I o[thc rolllllvo \'n\llt, I I' lillY, uUrlb\llud h)'uoo\1l'1 ", 01' Jill')' \0 RololIBcdTorlfollsol', whluhc\,ol' Is 1ll'cnlcl',ilIHIlhls RolclIllC IIhull oporl\\c liS II slIlllIfllCllclI or 1111 olnl11\s 1I11l\llIst such 011101' pOI'SOIlS 01' lorlfol\80l's \0 Iho OXWl11 of tho I'uhllll'e pro I'lItn' or porccl1\~go Bhill'O or tllo ooml\1ol1llllhlllt~ of' Rulollscd TOl'lfcusor hcrolll I'clol\su;I, who s11I111110\ \19,' I'OllpOIlSlbluJlll' I\n>' 1\lrlllc\' pll)'n\lll\ts 011101' Ihnn sol I'or\h heroin IIrlllh\ll fi'ol\1 IlIc 1I1'oI:eBllld Ineldonl elthcl' dlrcell}' 10 \IS O\' 10 \IS IlIdlrcctly IlIrO\llllI contrlbullon ol"lndOllll\llicl\lIol1 of 91111lr nllegcd . 1011f'cIIIIll\'II, whcthcl' O\' nol plll'llos 10 Ihc IIlbrcsnld IIcllon, " This RulclIRC Is helnl! I\1l1de plll'lIuunl to IInd III cllnlbl1l1lty wllhlhc provllllo\ls oflllc l)\llform 01 " CO\llrlh\lllo\l Aln0I111 TOl'tf'uuIIll\'S Ael IlS cnuclcd In thc COl\1\11ollll'l1llllh of 1'0\l\ls}'I\/ul\ln, Tills Rc101\1IC11I no \\'11>' constltutcs 1\\llIdmlsHlolI of' \II\hllll)' hy II,,~J pllrt)' I'clcl\scd herel\l, i.. " " " , '. , , . J. f)1! ,,70.'>- ,. ,.},J". J ,; 011 Ihls!1 "'ill,>, or ,~(.IP1j,(I'(f; 2t1o.~.,Jlu(prO\l1\l pcrsolll\lly IIPpcl\red .7.1.::::.:......f:/:!I.!.:9~- . prHol11plllrcillwI'81 hw, \1I1PWI\ \0 nw \ll\ho pmo\1 W\,lPSIl \11\\lW Is s\I\lslJrl\lCII III Ihc W\\h\l1l~e\o\\s~ , ,. I' H\ld I\u~now\\ll\ll\lll \hll\ he oXoCII\\ll\ Ihe Ill\l11cl'pr l\1u p\\rpnSCS \horuln clll1\!\I\1u\l; , \1'1 W1TNn::;S WIIlJ\\lJOF, I \HlVe hcrelll\\o scl 111>' hlll\\111I111 nfllcll\\ selll, i'd : ss, COUNTY OF ) 1'1 , 0\1 \hls dllY or ' ~()() I, before I11C perSo\111lly I\pPul\rad -~r--"'--:'----' ofl'l\'\A OI'Ollp, 1;11011'1\ to I11U \0 thc porson whoso lH\ll1C Is s\lhscl'lllc\\ (6 .\ho within Rolcl\5e' mill IIckllowlodllod \hl\\ he cxcclltmltho SIII11C ror thc PlllllDScslhol'oln OO\1\llll1c\\, , II IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I hlll'o hcrcunto 1101111)' hlln~ IIl1d off1cll\\ 501\1, , -- Notllr)' Pllhllc ,. , " " 'I ;. " ., " \' 'nl 1'11111,\ 1 "lll.I~'llm;l1(l^\ 1I0\"~~'HII ,'\1,11"1 I\'~H\ 11 ,It n MI \t\lIf~ \11'"\1'/(11 \I~ Hll ""I HII~t IH JfllijkANLLClJj\:U~ljl~TILLO.lf'l:e,JIl1rtEl~AB.(UU!KLlv\fiE KNOW AI,I" MEN 13'1' TIl\lSE rlzl~f)IINTS, TIIAT \l'C, 1:lpl11pl IJro\lwl's, \lw,'1I11\1 \lMA Grollp, 1'0\'11I111111 r.\ll\sldorll\lon 01'\119 pll~111on\ ofllw Slim (If $2"OOO;on Iwrpwllh, \11Ll1'\lccll'\ IIml I, ' " ' ' ~\Irnclonoy of whhlh III hll\,llhy 1I01;l1\l\l'le::dgo\l, 111111 h>' \hl~ IZclellSO (10, I'o\' ll\\\,se::ll'cS In)(1 0\1\' hqlrs, ,0!'\ecn\orS, IIIhl1ll1ll1ll'l\lprll l\Il\IIISsllllIll, \'~I\lI\SC 1\1111 lorpl'ol' ,l!schlll'llOUPA IncP1l10\'lllcI\ IIml its cllrrlcr, f)Pl1oglll MII\lInl h,S\II'IIIWC Clll11P\lllY, lwr\lll1l1l\ol' rllforrod \0 liS 11.\ZOIIl1l80(\ '1'01'\1'0115(1\'," ~'(l1l1 Ill1y IIl1d 1111 d\l1\1111111s, l\11I111111CS, IIc\I~I1S or OllllScS of l\cllol1. clllllng, 0011\1'11111\1011, Iml\ll1ll1l\y, cpsls, .loss or scrvloos, oXpol1SCS, cOl11pcnsllllon IIl1d 111\ conSc\)\Ien\llIl lI\1d 1\1001180\)1101111\11 Ih\\11I\l!c, Il1oIl11111111 h\ll 110\ 1\1111 \01110 clllll11l1 101' ulmlrlhll\llIl\ or Imlull1l1lly 10 IIn)' olllll\' pllrSOI1,I'"\'\)' 01' corp~i'lIllol1l1rlsll1ll 0\11 oflll1>'lIl1d 1111 c\l1ll1111 for IIIJ\\\'los, Imowl1lllld \I\1\(I1o\l'n 10 118, which 11111Y hl1l'c roslllted 1'1'011111 Orc ",hl\lh ooc\llTO\I 011 Foh\'\IIII)'7., \ 998, rll\' whloh Clllll11l1l1l\ hilS hooI1111s\I\\IIOd IIl1d Is pOl1dl\1l1 111 \hc COlin Or Co 1111110\1 Pleil8 of CIII11\1ol'1lll1\1 COllnlY III No, 9S"S!i69, " 1\1 Ihc CI'CI1\ l\n~ I'rosonl 01' f\1\\lI'C dofol1ll11l1\ 111 \lio IIfOI'Osl1ld 11011011 01' o\ho\, pel'son ~r \or\limso\'oh~.ll11s IIgl1\nS\ RololIscd Torlfollsor In tho IIforcsllld 1101101111\' II sPplll'A\C IIc\IOl1l1rlslng 0\11 of Iho IIforOSlllil I1re fbl' clln\rlbllllol1 01' Il1donll1llY, 1\ Is f\ll'lhcl'.II11l'ecd by I\S \hlll ~11}' Jlldl!ll1Cl11 ", " " on\orcd 01' dll11111ges 118scssml PI' rcoo\'~l'I\blo nglll\lsl 1111}'ot1101' nllollcd 101'11'ol\so1'8 by Hel11p\ Brolhcrs, hw, shlllt.hc I'oduco(l by 1\11111110\111\ cq\lullO Ihc 1I11101\111ofool1sl(lc1'll1l011 pllldfol' Ihls Rclollse, or for \lw pl'ol'/I\\\'sI18rl,1 of Ill!)RI,lol\9or.\Torlfol\~OI', or 1111hc 01'(\111 (hill n;(.i'dool,rlnQ for 1\01\1plll'\\\II'Q ncg\!gcnco!s hold \0 bc IIpphcllblo, In tho (11\10\11\1 (11' Ihe\,ullllll'O flllll\,lf IIny, u\lrlb\l\ud b)11\ 00\111 01' J\I1Y \0 Rclollscd 'I'or\fO/lSllr, whlohcvol' Is grell\OI', IIncl \hls Rolol\so shll\l OpOI'U\o 118 II sllllsfllo\lon of lilt clulms 1I11IlII\s\ SlIoh o\hol' 11cl'sons 01' (OrdeIlBol'S \0 tho OX\0111 of tho 1'0111\11'0 pro rill II or porocnlllgo Shllr~Or\he oOll1l11onllllhlllly of Rclouscd TClr\follsor huroll1 roll.l/l8(,d, whoshlllln\1\ bo ,. ' ;," 1'0~pon8lblc fO\'II\lY fur\hcl' pllYll1e\llS o\hor \hlll1 sol forlh hCl'clnurlslng 1'1'01\1 Ihl.luforosuld Inoldon\ ohhcl' dlrocll}' \0 \IS or 10 \IS Indlrcctly \hl'ollgh con\ri\\u\lo\l or 11ldo\ll\1llioll(lon ofo\hor 1111egod , . ' .. 10rll'ol1sol's, WholWcl' tll' \1olj'llrllos 10 Iho IIforcsnld IlO\lon, This Rolcnse Is belllg I'll lido pm'snnnt 10 I\\ld In oO\lfonnlty with \hcllrol'lslons oflhe Un,lfol'l11 ," ,.Col1trlhllllon Am~\lgTol'lfon!lors Ac,! liS ol1l1cled.l\l tho Comll1011wcnllh of Pcn\lsylvllnln, This Relel\so In 110 WilY consUh\lcs nl1l1dIl1181110nof\lllbt1I\)' b)'III1}' pnrly I'ololl~od horell1, " " r , .. , ~ I.' (,,1 .1 l'; , ,1 ,') I, " <I' 'i I' ., 1:1 'j 1'\' 'J I I .1 ,I., .I I:"'! ~ " I' ~J I' ,,' 1''' \i ,d 'I" I' ':' , " '\1 ",', , , I' , , , , I , 'I " , " '-fo " , " ,I' ! " , " I, " " " !' , ji' " " ,. " " " ,. " " ;' , , " "i! l' I' " " " !i "/'. I' 'I. J'" I' I' " ;/. I' ,. ,. I' " " I' I' " ,I, " " " ,. " ,. " 'j. u I' " " i"t' ) ~ '1 !'" " il;. ,i '; ,. .' '" " 'I , J,I r__, " , " i , , " " ~\. i",', L~ \( .' \ ,( . :1 ,'. , , l' , " ('), C. , ; '\ \', \ " ".!: ,. ','! .-_,1 , " ~'" U \ , n \,11 ,... /, 'I"" '1'( \,1' \,:0..1 ('I " , .. I ,\(" , \ {~~ .. , "',, , r:. I i' ., I ,.1 .J " ,H' " , " " " ('; ii P,; , ~ " " " ;i ,,"il Ii, " " I' '" ,/ " I: " , I' J,,, il " ,I, jJ " " ii' ': II' "; Ii " " 'Ii,,' j"t " " " " ".;, " ." " H " ,. ;-,1 ",,; ,. ", ',' ;J " " " , /, " ,.\1' 'i' , , I~ . , , I" " /; " :1 ml+~~ hNP W+HH+I~~HHV Ily ,. InpWf\IllJ A, IJ(\IilCJlnH, ,JI~, I iJ1S91lI RI,l lclonU.I: IOil\:,jOI1 'Nq, IiIiGGU lUOO OWl IdjJ01:\:y PlilOfJ ' Ph:l.li\cjolp\lltl!' PA :1!llO:!..'1:!9Il (rIb) UGtI -fi3;J2 IIl1lm'~ ~RP~ II :l:NP, ;JOB [Jl'ool~ Rond [Jillnp' Unl, PA :1.'1011 Pl<lJn\::l.1: f: VI'l, ~UQ~Nm ~t ~IIlIllN~Y q/p/~ ~ I ~, 1(IIl~N~Y W~4P:l:NQ ~IIlIWIalll 1010 Crlnes Gnp RORd Ci\I:l.l/31e, PI\ I '10 13 anq . UVA INdORVORhTmo 3320 Perry'St:reo\: 111\1:l:l/3IJl1rg, PA . ,1nU ))e f: e nd/1!1 t ~.QMVLAINT " " I I I I I I , I I I , I I , I I I COUR'j' OF' COMMON PJ.,ITIAS " CUMBITIRTJANIJ COllN'l'Y ~llRY TRIAL ))IilMAN))1il1J ", NO, 1/ ,i'. ','(" (, '1 (I " I' ,./.~; {f..... . v~t.(,'I, I', PlnintHf:, Hempt Bras" Ino" by i\l1e1 through ita oOlll1ael, hereby demands judgment: against defend1\11ts and cOlnpla.i.nfil Igalnst def:endants a/3 folloWsl 1, Plcl.lnt.i.f: f:, 'lle1npt: 131'08" Ino, I .i.s. Pennsyl va n.i. E\ oorporation nnd, at aU times relevant he1:eto, engaged" in the business of: m.i.ning and l1ia'nllf:aotllr.tng oonol:el:e sElnd and other sand , , 'Ii stone produots and maintained a pr.i.noipal plEloe of: bU/3iness . . , loo~t:ed nt 205 Cl'oek ,Iload, Camp Hill, . Pennsylvan.i.n 3.'7011, 2, Defenc:Tnnt:, mU!;fene S, I{eeney I isa pennsyl v.nia !:esident Whq, at all Umes relevant hereto, condU0,ted bU/3iness under the nnme of: m, S, I{eeney l1eld.lng Service and mld.ntained a pr.tna.lpal :!1I1'H:(~IH ,Will, pli'\on at: \)\\~in(la~ looill:ec1 <It. 1910 Crilnes Gilp !to<lq, Ci'\rU.~le, PannaylvAniA 17013, 3, m~lgellO 8, Keaney, AI: all times re1eVCI1lt: hereto, WilS ()ngAgqd in t:l1e l)twlnef.l!3 of" welc1fng illlc1 mel:ql f:C\briontlon, 1, Det:enc1al1l:, IJPA Ipoorporq\:ec1 (lwrelnqf:t:er "lH'i\"), 113 '1 Penl1f.lylVAl1ii\ oorporqt:ion Wl1ioh'muil1tC\ina C\ ptll101pC\1 pii\oe of: 1)\1i11n~)sa 10oC\l:eq Ilt 3320 perry 8I:ree\-, I HC\rrlsbll1:g, Pennf.lylviln:l.ll .17111 C\11c1 WAs regularly el1gC\gec1 ln the deslgn, ilsse~)ly, ropiI:l.r, millntenilnOe ~nc1/or construotion of eleotfloill Wlring ilnc1/or eleotrloql f.l~steml3 qnd their oompon~nts inoluc1il1g, bUt not "lj,mHed to, the instullC\Uol1 C\nd/or use of: c1if3oonneot swil:ohes, 5, At C\ll t:\.mes releVi\l1t l1e1'eto, plC\intiff. owned c\l1d operC\tec1 a sC\nd stone miln\\f.C\oturil1g ilnd prooessing plant 10oi'\ted ilt 4700 Cqrlisle ROi\d, Oilrc1l1efS~ Pel1nsylvC\nia (l1ereil1qfter , , referred to "IS "the plC\nt"), , I' '6, On or prior to FebrUqry 2, 1990., plC\intiff orally , " 'contrC\oted with defendC\nt, lTIugene 13, Keeney, to remove' a fleot:\.op of. pip1ng e\llployed :\.n plai,ntHf' 13 munufC\otllr,i.ng prooess dtldng iI " sohedule~ work outage i\pd"is pC\rt of. plaintiff.'f.l ongoing maintenanoe progrC\m ~ith the plant, (Soe invoioe refleoting work perf.ormed C\ttaohed hereto as Exhibit "A"), 7, mugene 13, Keeney prevlously wprked at plaintiff's plant Cln8, as suoh, had lmowledge oonoern1ng"plaintiff's pipe SYJ3tellll3 anc1, 1n partioulai, the faot that some of pla1nt~fels p1pei " , - " " ooptained rubber 11ning, " " .I' 20Hccn4.\'IIl!} -2 .. 'll, Oil li'llbrlli'll.'V ~, 19911, qeJ:enQE\ll\: I IE~lgene 8, I<sepey, 1l6e(~ i1 WI':! eHIlH 1:01.'011 to /.loyal.' one snQ oJ: l:he pipe ~eCJdon l)~ WC\S l.'ol:,i\I,I1O<I 1:0 rr' 1I\0v 0 , 1)lldnu l:hil3 au I:. , Mr, l<eenl3Y ob/3e1'yeQ, I:Ile .' Ei\ol: l:hill: tho pjpe he3 W<\fJ rOll\oy:l.l1U conl:C\iperj..nlblJEll: lining, 9, ,~ft:er oon~letinu the abovB out, Mr, Keeney proceeqerj to \Ise n weldsl:' 11 \:Ol'ch \:0. aut ilno\:her seotion oJ: l:he pipe i 10,' On 1;'<)bl:lli1l:y ?, Bun, ElEl:or Mr, l<e,enoy OOI\IPleteQ Ol\\:Ullg t:hopi,l10 i\ seoond l:inH3, II f.i.n~ 131.'11pl:e'Jcl i.n t:hI3pi.pe when I:he nIbbeI:' l.i.ninu c1i1\luhl: Ul:e ,11'h1J ,J:.iro tllon Qxl:ondeQ <lI1cl I3pl:eElQ to' "pln:l..nUf:t:lfl II\l1:1.n oontrol. i\reEl .'Inti 01:h8l' ,P01:'I:';\.OI1fJ 0/: tlH3m:l.ning towerqElIl/3:1.119 eKtens:l.ye QI111\Elue to pla:l.ntiEE'/3 property, both real anQ perl3onal, ill1Q OEll\flinU QEllI\l1Ue I1nd hardship to plaintifJ:'s, busines131 il1ol.uQinu, but 110t lill\ited to, b\l/3iness :l.l1terr~ptlon, 1013s oJ: :l..nooll\e ElnQ gooQ will., extrA expense AnQ oAl\l3eq plainUff to :l..nour 8~b8tl1nt:l..al :l..noidentill ElI1Q oonsequent:l..al. QC\II\Elges, II, Tho nbove fire i1I1Q reault:l..ng Qall\age to pla:l..ntlfif's p1:operty, was the direot i.jnd proximate l7eSl\lt of Qli'fendant Keeney'a work :l..n outting plaint:l..ff's p:l..pe with the use of a " torah, 13, Prior to the above fire, on or abou~ Deoen~er 11, 1997, I . , , UPl\ was retained by plriJ.lltiff to rl'lplLloe EI GOO amp disoonneot l3~itoh forplaintiff'~ trElnl3fomner ~nQ to install a new switch in ,1\ ,plnintiff's WElter pump house, (,gee Elxhib.i.t "B"), 13, DUrJ.ng the OoUl:SS of perform:l..ng :l..ts WO)7It, UPA d.l.sooljnecl:eQ J:tlses fOl: plEl.l.nt:l..ff' El water pump whioh it used as pElt't. of Its ,IllElnUfaoturJ,ng pl:ocesl3, '1'he aforemenl:.i.oned pump WElS r!(lHe~IJ1!"W" -3- ,. " , 7.7., 1':\i\:I\1I~.HI' ilvqrp thi\l: clol'onrlllnl: WI!l,~ }"o<l\l1).'(1(1, \lII1.'p\liln\: tn \:he lJontrnol:, 1:0 \'nmoyo l:hn nJpll .\.n II Hood IInd WOl:I\l11i\l1l.i 1\11 i1mnner, ;33 I P\lr[;\lfll1t \:0 thD C1onl:rfwt, clD('o\lcjm\t WClfJ nolely r(~prOnfllble for ilnc\ hfld cJOn\:rol OYDr fill oonpl:r\loUon mOllllfl, \I\e(:l)oelu / t:eClhn1qllefl / IJequl~n(lBf.i, cmd pl:ooeclt\l:es E1nel 1;01' aoorqlllF.ll: ln9 fill POI:t 10nfJ of l:h8' work inCll!lqlng, I)\lt not: Uml ~ed to, th~ proper and safe use 01' waldll1g equtpmerit, 7.4, At the tlme of de('endE1nt'p renderlng of hls perylC1Bp, elefel1dnl1t knew or f1hould hflye known that pln:lntlff was relylnd \-\pOI1 hls Sl1ped.Ol~' knoWledge, ,sld.ll / C\ncl ellper\: ipe" 25, Defenelant ~nplledly warral1tecl al1el represBnteel ~hC\t he WC\~ skllled ln the fle:t.el of'weleling nncl bhilt his work W0l11el be perfQrmeel il1 il gooel and workmanllke faphlon without qefeatp al1d 'I in a mann~r whlah WO\lld be HI: for ordinary and int.ended purposep, 26, Defenc1ant breached his implied wnrran\:.l,e!3 to and contraat with plaintiff to perfono the work in a profeflsional ancl. workmanHka manner by failing to sa~ely pe~"forio the work I 27, At <Ill Umes releV<lnt h"lreto,'plnintiff fUlfilled their 'oblig<ltlons Ullder "I:he contr<lcl" ,; 20, By reason of the aboye-cleflCJl:ibed adts and omh[31011/3 of: elefendant, mugene s, Keeney, dAb/a ill,S, Keeney ~elding Service, a~ set farth in par<lgraph 17, whlqh is inaorporated hereln by I, I . " reference, defendant breached its contract with and implied warranties to plaintiff, ;1014ccn4.Wl1ft '- 7- " f l\uM Will TII 1I1l11 \'ll l-l- 1 ^MP ., I \ ~'~P-I~~~~M/4. , . " ~..~~~~_ t.,,' '!--. , ,", "Hill VIA, -..- ' . j" "HIPTP, .' ~"'; -,'. " \ t" "'I'I?,I!!""""" I,'" 'I ,1,1,,; ..'i"'!f~''"1'':"''f'''l,' .","-" .'. rM'r N\Jh\DII\ ,~..' ' " 'j,; ..' , ,,'; .' ,/...., II ,,'. ,,,-,. ---- r,;,":'~1.-t.'..t.~.:~..'-"~~; o,::..:.t!. , ' ".. '". '. --- ""~....."",,...,,-k~" 0' ...",.". - -~ ~ "t" it..,... fit'.... \ ....'too .~ """""''', "'01" "i'''.'' ........_............._ '....1.... ....-... ......."I'.v.li. "-'.," jj...,...,y,. -.-..- l-l-I' I' " .' \ " ..,..,.....- . . ""'''+/4''-' , 1l:ll.11 1- 1'" ~i \UI~2t'ijT, ,U'1y(~g'\JH'~'H~it~rQhp" HIMPT '",OSII NC. -----.--'..,-"'.' ?,Ut; CA~~K ROAD I p,p, ~px;m~ I H 24134 CAtv\P HI~k, P^, 17.011 I, \.!.-- TfH.llPHQNP 171111~7lil411 ( --- -~, -~.. - - \)1IT1l, I A J( - rt':2. f!RPJ~PTNO,,,,,,,,,,~" ....' \.PQAllPN. ~,l, 1/ ~I~I ' ~QUIP'NP~~~~~ AOO'" ORIn:' NP~ry~~ " , t. '11' I" f1tIlCIlJ~TJ<)H , tTOPll' 'r'r:im .4oMClUNI " 'I:, I,!:. ~, ~~~ -~I:--- " ...,.,-.. ,f" '.;:It';tl'''r.~.D I' , , , --. ., I,! '" ..., i";,i, I '''t' If' ." , 'I. " I'. ,'.. ':'''1 , ' \,,,,-., .....',1'.. """ , "'f"" H.' .. - . 'il ,. -, ~,., .." \ 'I' '" ,~ , It'. , " -. '" , \ , -' " , .. "II " . . " .1., ," . '1 '. " -,.,.. " 111 . 'I : \ t.. ,I ..,,,.. t ~ \; , I. 1"~Wl .... , 1 ~ .. tl t-.j' II.. ~H""', " .. ~., , ,~': I '. . · "."".w~~~~nn:/l~'r,'llW~ '" ," " ,. ~ - ~l'-?I'_I ,\ ---"-'"' ~,- SlUT I .. .G::>. ,. ------- ". :ttTtr.'"'t'......,.."',..I.l~#.ll.~~,. -~._~. " fllfl'" WIIIT\I ",m 1'11)..\,''''''" I'\or " mill ~,~'/' ~u \~ltlVWI""~I~UM\h ,~~u~~uU~ I','" FEe 2 ~1':88 NQ4ao~~ " " , " t1-.mnt pn~w" Inp, ,/ F" ,..1... "r 7 J;QUlPM~N'l' R';PAlR RtaPQR'T' I~I" ft~r1.q , .-::l;t...,,};J;IL...: ., . Pf!Or~IPI CNlllmonl r.... .. '~:''''i'''r''' ....r: ~..-r: :"~- i~".y'(>,;<J M.'.rRo.~ln\l, ' ,- . ~~,pn .. ~l'II'c1 ,.. . P.t.R.p.lr~,. I ,:'n.<"\ MII\lI\tl11<l. \- ~r-l- ppl'9VfQ , t " t , " ~,~~ ." I. ".1" .1. , ,[ , ,. ,. " ' ~.....~k~ , " J'!.-'" A~ " " "-f' 1-'~ .--<<--- , n.. . ~fIlPT' f " '~'>I ,1 .....,C',V14' .~"" r'Y"~/) ~' ' ,. __ . ..~T'~i",...P~ L'....,...<l--.....,'~.. fr ( .." I.' Cl\.lflNTm' TOTA\. opaT -'-ll" qC;,I, I, p^Rr P13QORIPT,oH ~ . , ,. .-. -. -....- __..t'~,:,. -.... ,..,-- r ,\-' I ," I I I I i 'j ~ -~ ,Ii ,j \ , . - 'I" i - I 'I - yeLLOW ,liHOP Iltlfl~ , ./'INK' OLOs~ I'IllPA!fl JOlI HI to 1l.1A P,.,_11hQ ",.., AU p"" ~ U"w Md rl,,,,d "bov', "del oonunuloon s~..lt At. N~'''IV, ~ " .' . Ir' " -. - ',. ----..