Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-05722 I' " 'j; " " " " " !j " " " " " " ;" Ii " !' " H " , !;, ,i " " " "I' " " " I'. P ,,' . , , " ,;.. :1 'H ~ .' " ,," " '" I ' 4~ ')':)' "" " .,,< 't., ,. i. " " p 1I ' Ii " " ii '"" ", 11' " I' 1,1 " \ " \ "I' . " I J ~ \ 'If \ , , " " F' " " " II' ,:' J I ~ i' ,,", Ii " Ii Ii 'i {, ,;I} I" " I " " .; , " " I " IF, " H Ii, " " " ;, ", i' ,;' t,I " ,;' " '1! " "I, ii , " i! .II " i, " " Ii ';< i' " " , " Ii J, j, ,:i " ~ <1< " ,\ !I I' , ~, I ' /I " ;/' " , "qit " " I' .. i' " " " " " " J " , " " ;. ~ 'I " " I; " , ,J!' . , 'I , , I " , il I: I " " " " " " i ;; , " , i ," " " " I, u..l. " , " (.').. " " .- " " " " " H " " 'I , " .;" ". " ,-,. " OOMNPtlWI~lml'll Ol~ 11I'JNNflVINIil'H{\ JlI~NtIi1YfNl\NH\ PI~!l{llI'!'MfiiN'11 Ol~ 'VIlMH1I'OH'N\'!'lOtl, IIUHIUI\l/ 011' muvlm kJ:OI~NflnlCl, .l\ppu,l..lIlP , v, I TN '1'1Il!l POl/WI' PI" OPMWlN !ll,'~l\fi m~ I 'OUNllfiiIlDl\tlP COUtl~Y, JlRNtlflYLVl\NTA , I I I , I I , NO, ((~ < I.?)) (!(,I."L~ " T''','' ,- i.-I' ,JPIIN N, flllf,lWA! App~Unnl; DTOMNfln fll/flrrntlflIoN IWl'WII, IWl'lll\l. INWM-1IlllilllllitllillL ol~Ql!ill!l\'l'()H' a J!.llmLllilIl " I' ' IINP ,NOW oomOfj the lIpraUAnl;, ~Iohn M. fJAlAPA, PY <II'" t:hl:P~gh h~.fj At:t;ol:ney, PAtd,q~ ~', J,Allor, Jt:, I E!'l9uJ.ra, I.1nd j:a!'lpaot;j:ully Avarfj tha j:ollowing, 1, l\rpel.1.An1: rau.telae At 239 WAl.t:an fll:rpet, 'Lamoyne, Pu~berlAnd Oounty, PenllaylvAni/.\ 17043, 2. '!'he lIppeUtml; receJ.vect A' Not:J.ce QA1;ud lle!ll:eIllPe.l1 7, Ul90 I l;hI.11; l.1u A 1:"'u~lt of hJ.e Al.1.ager.l VJ.alAt:J.Onof Vehicle Codu llect:J.on ,- , '; 1647, OhemicAl 'l'al31: nafUI3Al, hb rtr-lving pdvHege W!\13 Ila.tng 13ul3pended for n pe:d.o(\' of one yel'\r I effective l3uapenl3ipll clAtp , Oqj:ober. 12, 1990, At 12101' 1'\.1111 A,t:r.UIil t\nd corruct aopy oj: the Notice .i:13 Attl'\ched AI3 IlllhJ.b1t "11". 3, '1'he lIppsllant: a\lpmJ.t:a thAt the roHce offioer. lAcked A , , reAflonabla \)al3.lll to rec.tllellt ApPel.1.l.111t to l3ubl1lU to 1.1 ohemicAl tel3t, 4. T~e .l\ppellant Ilubm!t:a thAt he did not intalligantly And volunl:l.1rily ;tefllae to, oubm.i.t to A chelllicAl teat, fl. 'l'h8 Appellallt: aubmJ.t:1l th~t he wa/3 uonfuried by tho .i.natr.uCltiOI1 that the pou'ce of/flcer llrov.lded h1m ill regll.r.dl3 t,o the Mit:AndA and, 0 'Collnel,+ WArning, " .' ,I " I!)(HIIl!r A .' " H " " " " " " ". , , H ., ., " " " " ., 01; " " .' ., /' f' " " ,. ,I '.' " " " "I I' ! ,. .' " i' " " b , it " i'" " J- I, " ", .' " il' I' 1/, ,d' .' " ,. 'j, Ii " I;, " H " Ii ", " " " " j; ,. Ii'! , . .' " " " " "i ., ..I' " " " " ill' " " .,1; " , " ji .....r"1"" qnMf111N\WA~ TII Ill' ill!NNaY~VANIA nKPARTMKNT 01' TRAHapnRTATIllH 1I111'1In11 n f nr H Ill' I. ~ 11111111 ~ I1U Illlr r ~ lllHlra 1 PA 1" l;13 alwflit11lKfl n" I 19?1\ ......~.. I; . ...... ...-t" " " ... ~ -n . " ~QHN M S^~^PA ~;l9 W^~TON ~T ~~MOY~~'P^ L?P~3 9a~~3hLL43?a?3? PPL pan1099A j,apllililh:L L[.!/31/L9W? " , pOur Motor~llt, 'All 11 rOllllH of Volll' v~n~otion of alllll:~on UHt7 of tllfl VIlII~IlJo 001101 J.1I1IiMtOA~ TliaT, flfi:FUI>Ah nil 0711909911, VOllr Ilrivinu nrivqlluo if; ,IH1~nu auapl1NPlin fnr ,11 I1llr~nll' of 1 Yfi:Afl(a) , ' " ,'In 1ll'llllr' tn coml1:LV w~ tll thb 11l1nllt~pn vnll' I1rll" rllqll~rn~ \:0 return I1nv ullrrunt dri~nr',ll 110nnllUI ':Lenrnllr'll I1nrmi\: nnd/or \:eml1prl1rv 1!I'ivor '..ll l1conllll (1ll1mllrl1 ,lll1rll) ~n VIHlr !1011lllllllli\1n' 'nn lnter tlll1n tlln' nffnctiVll 11n1:0, lhtllll, If lInll' llflnnnt (lnlnl1~v wHh the, rllqqirllmpntll atl1tell nhuVll1 ltOll <Ire 'Ilq\lirbrl to aUhmit 11 PI.l1\1.0 FUI'm PI' 11 aworn I1ffillllVit IItl1\:~nu thnt vnU nrn nWf'lre pf thu lll1nction \HHlinllt !lollr l!rivinu I1rivi'" ~UUIl' Fl1illlre to ooml1:Llt WHh\:his not!IlO 1111\111 rOlllll\: in thia Qllrllllll rnfurrinu \:lIill mottnr to thu Ponnllv:LVl1n~e S\:l1tn roupo, fill' 11rnll\llllltion llnllol' BIiCTtON 1571(11) UtI pf the,Vo- hi,c~1l 00(10. ' ' Altholluh tho Inw mnnlln1:o11 till!\: vnllr drivin{J' I1rivilu{Juill llndnr ll11s11onaion evun if Voll 1111 not slIrl'uIHlul' vOllr Ifoenlle to' or-ed;!',\: will nut llDUil1 \lnt11 fill OIIl'I'unl: (Iriver's litlunae I1rpdUot(IlI, tho Pl.l~~O Fprm, pr n lotter ncknQwleduil1u lIQllr s~noUoll h rllooivud ill thh 11\11'0\1111; . WUIiN Till! OIiPflfnl1liNT RlicIiIV~S YOUR I.ICIiNst; Ol~ AOKNOW~IiPGIi" MUNT, WIi 1'111.1. BIiNP yoU A RIiOIiII'T. II' you llo NOillliCIiIVI!TIUS 'RllclitPT WITllIN 15 llAYS OONTAtT Tin: PIlI'AIITMIlNT'IMMlillIATIiI.V, OTlll!llWIBI! ,YOU WI~~ NOT 011 GIVIiN cllIion TOWARP BI!IWING TlUs, ' silNOT! ON. Thesffebt:l.vs date C)f Buaplll1dol1 h lO/U/1998i ,UlIOl a.m. ~********************t**************~~**********H**HH******H***HHjH* IWARNINGI If volI \1rooollviotud for driVil1J whiln vOllr licellseia I sUalJendull, tho \1ull\1Hioll will helllot leas thElll 90 (!Ellts impriaun,~' me 11 t ElllIl fI 1 I n 0 0 . fill 0 ElI1 d Elll 11 d d i ti 0 11 nil It e II r a II S II ens i 0 11. " . * * * * H * 1\* H H * * H * * H * * * H H H H * * IIH * ** * * ** H,* H liH * H I( * * * llH I( I( *1I11* * I( I( *1( H* H H*'"**,, , q, I , :1 " ' I" , " .j" , '" "... II..' Porw.rd 101 Qtplrtm'nl of TI.nlpottollon . , lIul"u of DIIV" L~.nllnu , 11,0, lIo~ IlISll ' ":" H.rt,.burt,IIA 171bS " " ' W,W'ftn I'O"MIAAY ..IlUIlLIOATlb II ,~, ~ , ;;" " . PII~1f TJllR~Ru . PAU 1111111 II~' r (:) , , '" a, ,2., Q '..-. , : t ,Il, PI'''' '" 1~l'll'd UIAl r9~ ,,, now Un\IAI "'''I 191 !lIlvInp unllol IhAlnllu,ne, 01 '~AlloI91' .onll911.</ '~bll'~' pUllUlnl to I'e#\ln mt 9' " tI1',Yth~l, Q9~, ' , I~' I iH11 '~mpnp ""I rA~ lubmll 19. ''',ml..II'" ol..bl~ , ("'''Ul, blood AI uII"" PII~I ~"pq"I 111, m.mIeII "I',) .,llllf,m' r dulY] p, , ppll~ 9m"" II Inl91m r.~ Ih,,1I r911 "'~I. 10 lubmlllo III' ~hAm~II." r.\l1 Ipar.llnp PfIY~p. W!l b' lUI",ndfd fo, I , ' ' 'PtllO<f 91 01\, rn" , , " '"',, ~, lit Th'''''l'IIIUIIOn""g[," r9U hAY' 'I r. eilmlnpl dOI,ndAA\, oommonlr ~now" Mill. MII.ndo fllDhll, In.hldlnu Ih. Ilghll<l IPf,k WIIIIII~" ,ncl ' QIIIDh IQ rtm.'O II 'nl, 'pr.IY only 0 oll",II'RI Plolloul pnl pnll db ""I Rpply 10 Iho .homlp.llnll n9 plpooduIO Iln~PI".nnlr I~I"I Imph~ ' oOI'n ~aw WhlQ/1 I. pili, halo OIlmln.1 pl.mdln~, I ' ~I AU '.VI no liOhl 10 IPI,M IA a I.wvor, 01 .nrono .1'0, \Iillo,.lnklnO\ho ehom onl 10" 10quoll.d hy Iho polleo 0111,,, no, do ypu h.ve. "ghllo ' "m"lIlIlonlwllr~Ukld by Iho pollp. oll\eol 10 IlIbmlllQ I "oll.'nl~ Ip\1 Unlo" you Igloo 10 IU\'mlllo Iholo" IIquo'Io~ hr I'" ",,\Ie. ofl~" ' Y,OI" "pn~u. Wi I d..m,~ I. b, "'1111 .nd VOIII opollllnog'lliloop Will ho IUlPondolll., qno VO'I' 01 Yp~fI"ulal /olu mlll'o ol'IR",IO,'/ol"nD undo' II" Impllon Q nlen, ~.w !lI.r oolnlioduCQ~ Ihlo .\1\ In~ In I crlmlll,1 P'OIPoUllon 'or IIIly,.,o - .._wntl!.,'lnd~'!" n luon '0 .100110 pf ~ ~onllollod IUbllonl>O, I ..... . ... .. ,- .. " , ., . _'. . _ '. ", .~.~'1-":' ~~ _ r--w_, ~~~eL~VI ~:~tmMI'~:I~~;" Wolnlng ~,OI911~1~, I,~Z .',lhPII OpOII"ng pllyll'9' .n~ve j~. mO,'OIIII '"9P""II,U , '," ',BlgnRlul.oIOflIPOII . ~~.........., P.IOI,I'" .:J~y d'Jfl " I h.VI "',.n .dviIPd 'M~~.'~r.':1 Mol.IIIII xff,.;!;,1,../ .' .....:.. PRill IY ~"1' /P!,r!-- , , Molldll II/U\od I. ,Ig," allol b,lno .dlllod, 'r.::u~, f'1? .A. ).,. ,f)? ,/ ", " 'II ,:n,.I"" ~pp ..;._ " ".lon.lol. 01 Olll'orl~.;/..e:-_,-___ 0010' ~ ~ ~-r:=, ~rrloAYlf "~he ,b,OY' mOlo III\W.." Pl.,,~ un~ol 'l'UIIOld/IIIII 0 und<!IJh' Inlhlonco 0' "','0/'01101 aoonIl911',~ lullll.ndo In Vlola,".n ql Slo/"'n 8731 qll/1, ' ,hkll. OOdel.nd hll. Ivll'"JlAn.H UfAun~1 0 b.II". 'IRI Ihq .boll mOlp, I IlOb~ bOln UI II0u, opt/a ling 01 In '.Iull phrl oal ~nIlPI.' , ,moltm'n 01 a molol V'hlQ/, willi. Unull 1'\1 In IUln.. 01 a co '01 PI. ""lioll,~ lu IIIIIQQ IIr bnlll, , ,. '- . . J ,. ot . ", .' _, . Th'I lh..\>Qv, n,m.d fII~\Ollll W'I Inyolvodln.n ,o;</Idtlllln whl~h Ih. opmlPf or PAIlOngol olanr V'hlel. InyolVtd 01. p.dRIItI'n "'lIllfld ' 'alm.nlll a Fo~IlI"1 ,.0111Y 0' \VAl ~III,~, . , , f' "b~Vt m9 I 'l'~RI r,~Il"I'~ 10 lubmlllo ohom'r"llo'"ng RI .IIlholl,od br a.O\lolI'IU7 ollho VOhlolo O~do " , ,. · 'bAil mo 0 11 WI! Inro'mo~ by , polio. 0111"1 0 III..tIPIIIIOQII~11 WOlnlnUI eon 'InA~ In PAl'9loPh 8 'n~ ~ .bolo, ", I' "OVllII.m,dmolollll'llmdlolubmlllolll'''''OIIIIIng" , ':~ Th'/IIu", I., IOlllhl.,o,,,, I, IIpl a ',IU', ",1'.', ~~I"'I t. 1111 'h,,"I.I""'I Vou {lI~11 .11" ulV' Ih. "'n'o",' In OPP'."~' ' .,. 'ml..1 1111 .11" "vlllllno Ih', 101m, III' n. Ildu, IVn oPIIIIIIIO' pom "PIal mOlo, VI"lol, wit . h'Y/no .ny . "" · "h.'." OQnll.lIf11 '~btl'"o' In Ih." "VII.m, you mOIl allo OOMpl.l. I'" ,IVI" Id. 0 I ""0 . '. ,:", ' "~I\YIl1lll 08 0 a "Qlllo.'~lgn"1UI11 , " ,....,1. . OIII.orN.mo;'MI/IIOoo ~". .;..a....L. i I'd ,. , l'rM~ I , padgoN\lmboll~~___JUllldlcIIPnl~l, ' ,r"on"~ ' >~" ,.,,~ .,,, " " )::1:'/ M"llno A\kI,... ....Jill ' .",....~". ..IY~.,,,,, .'.: ,; , I.~ ;1,;!!!I~1:i1 """.,,~, ,1';11, ....,j ~.... ,"~ ',: < . " ' -- f .. - , . . ,. . " ~ "~:.t : " , ' , '",k II, 0111 Anr ~.,tln. nl h""l\ClloollI.d brnlllU rnll'~"~. I~ bo lUbmill,'" on ~::'l:,il ' "p.'al' 1 HI al1d alllohl~ h'"\O, T .1 'hll" u d ~.",cIt the nlnl'l ~r', "II ~ addltlOn.1 IV Ino".. no..11I1}' 'Op,O\'l "'.m'lI I 0 Wh ~ VbU h'llIlI;l 'd, ':\ ',;: " i MlIllflONAliUPrunll or tlllll~"M MAV ik nOUn11l by COMPtlllNO lOAM tlN"A :;:}i,' .. , II \, ~\,... ,A~" " FO~ COMMON~~ P\:l, l~ohoJ:t T., RelJplel' " I," ,d , ~I \'\ , Pilll!UL'I'() WT'I'N1il&!flHf! " J2llilliQ!c nl'lQrlOtl&l . ~(i .QUOO12. JiIillmillQ'C 3 10 21; f: ", "," i.... ,.,. T"'...... "',- ... .. "'i' - ..... .. ... .. ..... '. ...... ... -.. , ", "t, , , EQR COMMONWffillltTli Inx. NO, 1. - D1-26 form ,II " , 'L " i< , " " II~DffiX '1'0 I~XHIlU'I'S MlillKlill (prellll\r),edl {lDMI'l"l'ffiD 9 ", I' 'I" I I,', I' " " 2 . 1. 1 '1'1 1m CQllH'1' I 2 Mil, 1<l\llllfJI< , 3 '1'1 IIi) COIJll'I' I ..Ii il .. VEll'fJ\lP Snl.flpn, .in :1.\: , MI:, Goorl /I 1: \:OI:nOOl1 , . Good <\f\:ol'lloOI1I Your 110110):', ,'I'I1!f.1 il] \:IHJ'rJi\PO of (JOIlI1110nwep.1.1:1l !ilphelmnn 'f G MH, IflSIHnIJMlI\Il1 Ye~, 'loll I: Ilonol:, '1'llH) Cpllj('1' I OI~fI'l, Aro yeiu t'efldy \:0 [)):o(Joed 'f Mil, I<AI3lJS1<1 Yep,' YOllr 1I0no1:, Pdor \:0 thaI: 6 '7 B "'flY); tntn)duo(l to yoll Lll.€I:l.ne 131<IIJO, IJlle' f.l on <lsptol:€Inl: 9 oonnl3el wl\:h l'ennPO'l', 10 M8, . Br.IAI3SI Plenper! \:0 meet yoq, t1'lU~ COUIl'I'1 Good nf:l:o,I:I)Oon, Nfoo to mel"t l.l 12 YOll, 1,3 14 15 16 off:,tatol 1101:1013 doted nnel 1n€l:Lloc1 SeptombOl~ 'ith, 19901 .I:ho 1'7 l)opar'L:ment of. 'l'rnnoporl:ntion notU: iec1 the mOI:or.ipt John M, 10 8al€lpn, operC\t~r's'11CJel)ae nunilior 1-0.O-4~2-a-6-1\ th€ll: fib €I' 19 ral3111l:.ofi, hil3 viol€lt:lon of Seo\:ion 151l"7 of: the vehiole code 20 rdlnting to ohe\11i~€I1 teat ~efup~l on 7/1990, his driving 21 pr1Vilego w~o baing lJuspendod I:or a pertod bl: 1 yon!:, ~~a ". il . ,!'2 tho \:!Omlllonwealth aaltf~ OHioer ReI31310r" 23 Nhe rqnpon, " ?oil 1"1')., .1l013IJlH'1' 1" ImS8!.!ilR 25 having been duly sworn, tostif:ied C\o l:olloWBI " 3 1 .7. 3 1\ 5 6 " 7 a 9 10 1.1 :1.2 J.3 1'1\ III 16 17 . .' " 10 19 20 21 22 23 21\ 25 ('I t~ I IHt:h 1\1'( },lg111:(J ClClnEl,n\l8[~ bB:l.ng on, \:h'1 '" vehIcle stHl oonl:.j.plled nnd \:\len pullod :l.nt:o i.\ ddvoWAY i.\t " ",,39 Wal\:on ~\~l.'(Jel:, 1\1: I:ha\: tll11e \:h() OpOl:f1tor or' l:\ie ,vehlole I, . " flhllt h:\./3 veh1olo off: I bql: he .1eE\> h1p.. hO<lt,\Hghtp on n\ld rel\1!\:\.ned 1n t\10 dl:1ver'13 petll:, Q :I'hen whal: happened? 11 I believe <II: \:hnl: Ume anol:her ol:Uoer oamo 1n \Jehl,nd me, 1113 had heC\n\ me tryIng to - - I oon\:aol~ed hIm And inforn~d him 1:0 try to stop thi~ vehioie, I APprqsohed tho open\tor of the vehiole, anCt I <'\/31<ecl. him for hla c1rlvel:' /3 U.oense And vehJ.alo reg].I3I:1'al:10\1, <lnd I .informed 'hJ.m Why :r wal3 I3toppJ.ng h1m, '1'h<;1 operal:o): of l:h<1\~ vehJ.ole " hc\l1ded me hJ.(3 'ddvor' s llcense, llowovel:, he ooul'dnol: l60ato ~is registr!\tion oard, oven though he had 1t: in his hand, \~hHe f3peakJ.ng with I~he openltor, I del:eoted an uloohol,io beVel,'age on hls breath, lj1s oyes ,wore gli'l/3SY, . and he had )1<\0 a /31un:ed apeeoh, I asked the operi'ltor to . tun) b~f hiahead:\.ighta to hi.p vehiole, At thaI: tin1e he Was attempting" to turn them of:!:, but 1nstead he turned on h1s windshield wipeJ:13 and he apl:ayed the wasllsrf:luid twioe, which WQuld 13pray mo in the f:ace, , 11 I:t 0):' that he then exited I:he yehlole: J obsorve'cl h1s 1110yements to be somewhnt 1l10W, lIe did dieplay n stnggBl:od walk, ane;], I:hete wero ueverul tests requested of G 10 I', ). (. 3 11 5 6 ,7 8 9 ),0 , 1). 1;? 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 ,', ;?O 21 22 . 23 24 250 flentenoe, the seoond pont:fl110e, t:1)1rq aOl1\:enco, f 01\1:\: h " flel1\:enOfl, 1:0 inolllde ft, b, ftl1q 0, C the lElst: aenl:onoe, I f:ll:f.\\:es o~ €I 1 oohol or ft pontrollocl f]ll!)s\:anoe, ,. MR, Kl\13l1i3K I Okny, MC\y. r npproaoh \:1113 wit:ne~fl, your ~onor? " 'J'Hlil CDtJg'l', /3l\ re , MH, l<llUU/3f\ I r' d II10ye for the adm.j.fl~don of Commpnwelllth'fl filxhibit NlIlI1bel: 1, MR. lijl3fllj)I~M{\t'l', No ol)jept:Lon, '1'IIIil COUR'!' I I\: is ac1m.i.t ted, (Whorel\pon, OommonweC\lth'fl l'l~hibit No, 1 , ,--, Wafl ftd\11it~~d int:o evidonoe,) ,,' BY 'MR, 10\13US1< I Q 0 l\f!ter you read the l1\otodst the D1,";?1 Wor'd for wor'd, what hnppened? ' TIIm COl.1R'J', 'l'he Dl~- 2 6 '? " MR,l<ll13U8K, '!'he J)1~"26, thnl:'s the l>imnDO'I' 'I'HIil COUR'I', yeah. YOl\ sal.d DL"21, MR, KII13U/3K, oh, I'm sorry, 'I'he p!./-26, 'J'UIil WI'I'NlilSS I Af:l:er I asked him if he would " flubmit to a ohemical teAt: of his blooq, he stated nd~ I'm not tnldllg YOI~r test" We then 'dep<\l:l:ed the soene, I " "tranSpOl"t:eq the def.endant to the West Shore Booking Cental', , lit the Weat Shore Booldng Center he was sef'\l'ohocl '!9cd:11, lIll hfs prol)orty th<\\: he had 011 his persoll 9 r'....'-' , ',', \ 1 wqri 'plnood ip A lJfI9 I ,He i3i' \: qown l,n the ohn1.1: I "pe:l :r, ~ ngAin, re<1d.hhl\ \:hl~ pr.,,'26 'fOl:n\ W01:('! 1:0): worc1, \:\d.13 Idme on 3 CJAmarA, '!'l1ey vh'!eol:Ape \:hAt: port .j.onor I:he l;e<1c1.i.ng, 1\ UV MR, K^UU~KI Ii Q line'! how d:Lcl the motodst rei3pong? 6 fI 11131 C\gninl ot:A\:ed no, 1113 wno mlll~bUng 7 flomet:hing elpe nbout:'nn at:torn~y, but r am not i3urewhnt: he o i3dd, 9 Q 1\nd then what c1id YOI\ do? 1\ I\t that 'H.me I :J\\sl: rolf,aaed' him \:0 tho Weal: shqre uor.*.i.ng <1gon\:fl where, he 'W<1s prooeafwd for tl,e cldv:i.ng " \\nc1er the influenoe, aqcl then I had no I:m'the1.' oO!1taol: w:\.th tho del:end<lnt, , ,. 10 ),:). 12 13 14 Q Is thE) ll\otod,i3I:, present \:oc1ay :i.n the 15 oo\\rtroom? sir, a:l.\:ting w:l.t:h , 16' . 11 Yes" He's hil3 ooqnflalor 17 wit:h tl1e white. shll:t on, O'1\l:B you aWEll:el:hat a vJ.dBol:ape was m!:\'de at , the' boo),J.ng oent€ll:?' " 10 1'9 20 '11 Yes, i3ir, 21 22 23 24 UY MR, rnsltml,M1\NI , :MR, 1(IIBUSK I No further questJ.ons, 'l'Hm COUR'l'l M~', mshel.l11!:\n, . CROSS IUXIIMINA'l'lON 25 o Did you have all opportunity to" revJ.eW I:hat 10 .. j' , t"'.l r"~t " , 1. op~p~ or n B~~nn~ 2 1\ q 1\ I~eliq~a iUI~ l:Lptqd nn n 00\\116, ,\~O\!lq YOllr 1'opo1'l: l:oj:leol: 1:\10\1;1' Oh, 1'111 [Jon:y, ~\:~fJ lj.ntoq <W n seelnn :Ln':mv i' . 3 4 Ii 1'\'lporl:, Q 1\ sediH\, ,Ifl thAI: n 1993 Sat:lIJ:n SY, Iledt\n? 1\ YOp, fJ,b:, Q lire yO\! nWAre thAt'p n V-4 engine :Ln ~hnl: 6 '7 0 ," 9 vehlo;te? 10 l.l. 12 13 .14 lli " , 16 17 10 :1.9 20 21 22 23 24 21i 11 I don 1 I: ){I\OW whnt 1:01.' engine W<1P i.n :L I: 1 a:Lr, Q So thin vehi,ole, in orqer 1:0 be going 1 I bel:Leye aa YOll teptif:iod 501 ~o mile an ho~r, wo~ld have haq to gel: f.\ll t.hat flpeeq up oOl1d.nf,l oyer L:lie bddge I:here C\nd oOll1ing down, There's only.eppentially oneblook inoluding " ., !i I:lle bd.dg(3 between Marl{el: and l3op},er I ipn' t that correo\:? 1\ ThAt's true, Q And you ndmH',tl!at'"s n I:Airly ateep.hi1'l, al: leaflt oom:L,ng upl:he cthel: al.de towards t.h~poU.CJe' department, for instAnoe? 11 II:'e nob real steep, bllt itip a gradUAl hill " there ',' yep, Q. How fur into the inl,'8rsaal:ion wal3 the gl:een Saturn When you firl3t 8aw it? A I'm not sure I lInd~rstand your question; Q How far - - well, where waf.l \:he green BC\turn , +2 " 'j I' " I: ", " ~. when yoq O'!:fJt s<\w :Lt:, U:, I Inf1y 1\10* \:)1111:, I3P\3oHiof1l~y? ;l W<Il') , .n ih the lnl:el'peotj.O\l of 'l'h11:(:1 ,'\ncl BOfJler'? " 3 .' " 1\ inl:erpeot~,on , 5 6 ? f\ rt wnp right,pripv \:Q enterinothe Q A , lIbout ten I:eet? ril:teen 1:eet? " Q lIrOlmcl,50 feel:, I\ro\mc1 \:ha\: <wen, !;'J.J:l:y I:lj',et, 'Ian' t: :Lt l:rUe thC\t between' o Bopler I3tveet ~hen ~ou were sitting at the f.ltopl.lght thC\t 9 the ne~t:' p\:l:eet along then ip IIUl11l1\el? 10 " 11 Yefl, wl,r, Hummel lIven\\e, " Q 'l'hen ther'e's <\ trnf:Ho light there,nt Hl\mmel? 11 Yes, I' Q 'I'hen lIel:man Street? 11 Yel1, fl.b:, Q OJ~<\y, lInd then there's abridge,., and then H" " U ),2 1;1 11\ 15 16 comefl '\:lown into Lowther'? 1? 10 19 11 Lowther ~treet, yes, air, 1\nd then i'\ Kentuoky !~ried Chi,oken and' then Q <\nother tii'\fl:io light? 20 21 '/\ Q " Yea, , Okay, Isn'l: H l:rue that you did not: time br 22 otherwise oloak the vehiCle, the green Saturn, throughout ~3 that 1:ollrbloa~ period? 21\ 1\ We have linea painteq on the roadway "25 bel:Ween d,ght there at thfl, poHce sal:ety league, ,13 1- ;1 3 1\ 6 6 ? 0 9 10 1:\.. 1;1 13 14 16 16 YI " 10 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 ,\.."" le"i 11 1~A~ iA correa~, " Q soion/~ it trna thAt if you weteto drAW n 8i:~'Ed,ghl: Hno I:rom 1:110 orou\: oE thnl: In':I,(190 00\111ng f:rom down In\:p j,owther to ~he fCll: p:!.(je DE 1:IHlt lnl:(~rfJeat;j,on l1t: 'l'hird, anc\ ],owl:hel:', l:hC\l: i\: WOlllr} r\\1l l:h1'OIl\1h \:hl\l: leJ:l:-I1ill\d \:\\):11 lC\nel ipn'\: thl1t \:r\\e'j' 11 I don'\: believa \:hl1t would be tr\\o, Q YO\l inc1l.cAteq hhElt;. YOl\ I'lC\W \:ha vehlole \:rC\yel.' in l:hat lef:t-h<1l1(j \:lp:n Inne, Jfm/ I: it: trUe \:hnl: only '<I pf\rt of the vehiole W<lfl in \:hC\l: left-hi,\nc1 t\\l:n :Lnne? A Ho, air, ~e wap entirely within the lef:t t,ul:n lane, " Q " It'p truo\:hat he did not hnve on unyturn oignal indioatorpl 'io thnt correo\:? ,', 1\ ']'h<lt' p \:1'\10, Q Ia l.t tr\le th<lt the trnfflo oonditi~l1l3 \:hnt morning wore pretty light? " A lis I reo<lll, I do not believe We aean any other vehioloo on tha rOAdway, Q lIPP1:oxfmlltoly how f('lr behind the S<ltlll:n was your Plltr.ol, car when it a\:tempted to turn ,left onto Walton? .1\ [lour \:0 I:iva car lengtho, Q l\nc11an't it true thut WL~lton 1s,n -- how \, about thia? Let me give YOll a description und see if you oortsidor it a falr c1eaoription or not, sir, 1/11 withdraw 11; l f?, 3 4 'Ii 6 7 0 9 1.Q. U,' 1.;3 1.3 1.4 lli 16" 17 3.0 J.9 20 ;31 '2:? 23 24 25 " r,q) /,'''1 '\;hs f'lrnl; Pll1:\: of: l:hs q\lOpUP\), If' T wers ~o~eporlbo W~lton Street AP ospen~iC\llY ~ repi~sn~iAl Dt~aot With no 06~tor llne Pf: C\ny port or trAfifio Inn~ indioC\torp pnin~Bd 0\1 i\:, thnt parklnQ If] pSJ;mlttiecl on po\:h m:Lclef;1 of; l:he fJ\;ree\:, 1)\\\; I: hll I: H'yoll hn~ OAr purked bn.ths right-hand ol~s C\nd the loft-hnnd sIde, two ncld~tionnl dnrp qouldn't paOP enoh other in )letwson," b\ll: one would IHWQ 1:,0 I3top j,n Dl:der 1:0 T,eIJ \:he ol:her 01\1: pl:000e(~, through, ip I:hal: a fnb: clef.lodpU.on.of \:hC\l: f.ltl:se't? 1\ 'PhElt' a fnir, It dopendp on I:hq, vehiole, /3mnller vehiolea oould 1'<113/3 I:hollgh, Q Twol3mnll vehioles mIght be nble to flqUee~o 'I through, is thnt a fC\irstnl:ement? 11 'l'hal;' Wquld be 1:air, Q l\ntl there' p nl\ npartment oomple~ 1'1nht l;l1e):e at the interf.leot::i.on of: Wnl.l:oll and 'rhird, ion't I:hel.'e? " 11 ,Well, il:'13' a hDlHJo, b\ll: lJ,),e apartmElI1I:/3, yefil' Q" O),ny, 'l'here <Il:e severnl parked on1'S leading \IP ,to I: hll t; interpeou.on, C1t lel1l3t lending \liJ 1:0 the yellow plI:i.nt I Isp't. that t:r\le? 11 At theltill\o 01: thnt inoident? Q Sura, " 1\ 'l'here Wnl3. sporadic pm:ldng on t.he street, I',!II not sUl:e Whsr"e I:hey Wero pnr)ted, 16 " 'i " " 1 ? 3 4 Ii Ii' 6 'I 0 9 10 1.1 1.;>' 13' 14 11i 11,,16 17 10 19 , ;>'0 21 22 23 24 21i /"\ 9 (\1'0 YOll fnm:Ll:Li\r W1t:l'l \:110 t:ll:l.'oq\: \;I1Oll\Jh rlllY Ilnd "~gh\: IlS n gonornl vl\la? 11 Ye s , Q CUrB pnrk ulnng thnt ~traotl is thut ~ fnir fltAt:emen\: '? 11 Yef3, Q So H YOll're clom1,11\J J.n \:Q 1l\ulee n 1.el:.\:-hAnd \:ll1:n in\:? \'11\1\:011, und vohiolefJ 111'0 domIl1g oul; t:.I11il o\:hor ctll:oot:ion nt the' 1J<11l\e \:il1\o, you woulcl be FJCIl:er 1:0 a\:ny \;0 , " the side so all not: \:0 hl.l: Iln ol1Goming vehiclle I 113 l:hQ\: fQlI:'? l\ I '\11 not Ollre whQ\; you' ro trying \:0 get ut , \:here, Q OkllY, 'AlloW me to rephrQt:le \:he queat:l.on, If: thip ia 'un inte~seo~ion where-- and lot'S.IlSlJlIme the atllndard no pnrkIng IlrBC\ oondng buok from the Garner, 11 Okay, Q 80 now you huve \:hree to fOllr car wid\:hB worth of road there Qt \:ho interseotion, but then you have a road thnt lit lens\: tracUtionally or of:\:el1 hC\s Clara parl'lfd on ej,thel; saldo/: :\.t, l\; :Ls n resident:L:ul stree\:, 1~C\ir so ,1:C\r? 11 UI1\-hum, QO)wy, If: you'ro making C\ lef:\:-hand tlll;n, , , You'ro oply going 1;0 have a short dlS\:Hlloe, essenU,Ellly \:he length' 01: the yelloW U,Ill~ ba\:W~len \:he JntoJ:seotlon and where 1'7 '( . 1 I, ;J '( 'j 3 ,A Ii 6 7 P 9 :]..0 :j.l 1;J ,:}.3 14 15, 16 17 ,.18 19 20, 2l 22 23 24 25 " , /e""1 , , /,'''\ 1lJfllll:'fIl10fl/ C\ncl rog:\.IJI:r.ilUon pAperfl when YOII t:l.qll: <1prl~oC\cht3q I:he vo\1l.p:ja? I apkeq I:or hia Itoonae anq I, <;.1 rant I: i.t: 1:1:110 \:h<\t Iln offioer mflY reqlle!it: All 1:1\ree 01:' I:hofle dooqmolJl:s of a driVer fjt: EI l:rC\f:f:1ofll:op? 11 'l'ha\:,'ifl trlle, Q I13n/,I: l.\:l:l'lle I:hal: I: he.. clefendAnt: incUoqt:ed to YOll t:hilt he was not: l:am:LHC\r. wlt:h thnl: p"rUoUlf\l: <ll1t:.omobi}.e Elt the,I::l.me of t:he trAffio 13t:OP <\8 II: wC\fln/ \: hip oqr?, A' r don't reoC\ll if he Ba1q'thC\t, Q Bl\t YOllwould hRve Been the regist:rAt1on fllip there at: t:he t:r.aft:l.q atop And aeen I:hil,t: ltwas 1n R woman/ r3 nAme, ooq:ecJt? A Ye/3, Q Oklw, :l.s :l,t fl falrly narrow , 'Phe c:1dVeWAY that: he held Plllled 1nto, , driveWAY? A 'Not I:or one vehicle, One vehible W:l.dth, yefl, Q IInd whClre Lha green Saturn enged lip being );lC'Il:)tecl, ,that:' a thaI: I:rl\l)'~ A Q the build:l.,ng? 'A No, r' don' t, I Clouldn' t te1.+ you thC\t \ " ,,' 19 " il ~. :? 3 4 li 6 '7 U 9 10 11, 1? 1~ JA 16 16 J,'7 10 19 20 21 22 23 24 2li jl ", '--I "I . Ii 'I Q Do Y(J\\ ~'ooi\ll woL!" i\lloW 11113 \:0 rlJphFiJno l:ho qllea\:~(.ln, pl~lnfw , lan' I: 11: \:1:110 1:\1n\: whon l:hG r1pfonr~nnl: , WO~llcl h~vo ,hncl \:0 opon liP l:ho vohJele, tho opD):al:01: nJ: 1:110 gn~I:J11 fj"\:lIrn open lip \:ho '~oor of \:ho vohlolo ln 01:1'\131: \:0 gel: ~\1\:, \:hey WO\lldn't: bo' nble to opel) I:he (l<;)Qr I:he whOle WAy ))130<1\1[10 thsre' f.l CI ohlmney 01: n bl:lClI, wnll nSIlI: whore \:ho .. ,,' qoor .1. s , l\ I don't reonll tlml:, honefJl:, Q YOll lnrUdi\\:eJ:l thAI: <It HID tlmo C\ftsl: yon plnoed the J:lef:elld"nt undor fll:rOflI; , und. a I:\:er YC)\I plQoerl him lnto hi'lndoll1: flfl, \:hC\~ YOll l:eC\dl:o him the DI.-1l6 thi'l\:' fl bsen Innr),ed C\s Commonwealth I sNnmbor 1? 11 Yes, sh:, Q Did YO\l prossnt: a oopy 01: thnt for him to rsC\d Or did you just read it \:0 him? 11 1: 'j list reAd it \:0 him, Q' . 1\ndIsn' \: H trUe \:ha\: at that point he Appsared somewhu\: agJ.t:a\:ed by 11he arres\: or tlpse\: )JY the ui<l:eat? , 1\ lIe was flomswhal: EI):gul1\entatlvo, yea, Q YOll indioa\:ed that you were ,present at the' booldng oenter when \:his SAme f.orm 1: IJeU,ove thut YO\l f.luid you relIt' \:0 him a IJ800nd tj,llIe'l A Yea, sir., Q' M: thllt t:.j,llIO did you present a oopy of: H (:0 20 " 1 ~ 3 4 Ii 6 'I 0 9 l.ll 11 1.2 13 l,ij lli 16 17 ,10 19 20 21 22 23 24 2il ~ \ \J Villi 00111<1 C!onr:Jl'liI \:ljil1: 'noJI:I)1)r of: t:hopc,) , i' yohiolou wore R~ru6k? II 'l'hi'1I:.if! I:).'\le, I\c1J\:hm: ono Wncl' fltl:\lCll'l (1\'ls 1:0 ':hs fncJ\: ~: WOllt: ~)Hok ,Inl:or I:c,> oho[JI~, Q Ipn't.il: l:r\lo \:hf\t 1:110 cje/:ollclnn\: n\:n\:e[j :Ln your pl:C:lf:lClnOO Ill: \:lm )Joc*Jnu contC:ll: \:hl\l: he wnntud nn ' , <ttl:Ol:lllW quol:e, \In'1\lo\:e, tQ dio[J\larl I:he leonl l:all\.Uj.rJf\t:,joI\fJ qnC]\lat.e, 01: the wC\rnJn[JfJ \:hq\: ho hucl bl3fln g.ivon? 1\ I qan'l: !:lwnll I]im lJf\y.i.nu thut:, MR, Ii;SIIu:r.,MlIN, No fLlrt:hflr .qltopt:.i.ol1f3 on O,l:Of.lS, 'l'lIlJJ COlJWI', (\0[111'001: , HIiiIHRITIC'1' IJJXIIMJNA'I'TON. IW MR, l<J\ilUSl< I Q Of:Hoer RflSslr31:, YOll a\:utod \:hC\t the Illptorlf3t 'f\ppef\rod to bAt\gJl:Ell:ed C\nd <lrgtllilElntC\tive, W<lS j.t YOLlI:' <lfJSl'lPf31l1ent thf1l: he oatlld generully follow yom: d,j rl'lql:lonf3? 11 Yes, Q P.i.c\. he seelll to unclerf3tand wh<lt 'you Were flllying'to h:l1l1? A Yea, " , MR, KABUSI<,' No fllrthor quest ions, MR, ITImmr..MIIN I Nothing fLll:l:her, BV 'I'um COUR'!'I . Qu Of:Hcer, YOll 111<lY have st<lted Hnq 'hlC\ybe I Ill.i.ssed it, I)j,d YOll notioe the odor of <lloohol 01] h:Ls ~5 , l pel:UOn',' 2 I '\ 1"-'; 11 :( bo~JI1Vo you, I did fJl:nl:o I:hnl:,,' '1'lwl'O wnp 1\ 3', 'nn odor 01' nl(1ohol on hJIl brqll\:h, Q IInd 11\: fillY \:1mo wlll1C'J YOII wero f:ol.l.owJnv hllll on \:),0 mnJn nL:root, (lid YOII pOD h(lW I:nnt YO\l worCl uoJno 1:0' uH,ln on hJ1I1 Ol~ whq\: Idnrl of; npoorlp Wo!.'o YOII doJnu',' ' Ii G 'I 11 1\\: \:ho I:op 01: \:ho IIJ11 r1uh\: lJf.l WI)' orofJ\:c)e:1 ,n 'l'hJnl ,91:rool: rlght: bof:ore wo hH: I,ow\:hOl:, l:hllt:/fJ when :t !l CflllUIW lip \:0 h:l:m, nlle!.:r In,li:Jh\:ml i1 01001(, MYfJPoed WfI[J lib, 1.0 6'1 m11efJ per hOllr, 11 1.2 point:l:n \:ime? u l4 Hi 1.6 hJil\, 1'1 lO l!l 20 21 g, I\nct YOI\ Were no longer UHlnlng on hlm n\: tl\nl: 11 'l'helt'13 \:rlle, Q 11 You woro staying even wt\:h hJm? T Weill npprOldmlltely three our 1onnt:lw pohlnd Q 11 ;., And whul:' F.J t:ho /3poed UmH in l:hnt flreil? 'l'hat's 26 mUllfJ P()J) hOllr, 'rUin COllR'l', 'I'hai:'nnll, Do you have unythlng iI in l:1:no with I;hilt, Mr, hlshelmnn? MR, mBllmll~I\N I YOflh/ bdl'1I:ly, " 23 BY MR, 1,1Sllml,MI\N I 22 RlilCI10~18 mllllMINII'rlON ,,' 24 Q 213 111.'0 YOll sflyJnu YOll Went 6'1 mHes fill hour' DVe;\." tho \:op of: thn\: bd,duo? H "'j 26 I '\ " ." l\ YOf.l, pJr, (Ucin'l: n.irborno'? " Q YO\I gel: " l\ No, (oJ.i l:', Q !low far .is 1:l1e rl.1.pl:nnoo I)etween r.,oWI:her C\nd Wel.ll:on '? 11 lIpprOl\1.ll1iltely I:hrl3e ,b~o[iksl .in thai: are"" Q I~rom l,OWI:I1l'll:, I:he OIW wH,h '\:he t<entllol,y fo'rlec1 Ch1.oken ~t the traff1.o light? ?\ ,Yes, Q l\nd then up to WC\lton? 11 lIpprox1.mately three blooks, ~wo tqthree .- blooks, in thilt C\reR, Q lire I:here anY,.ol:her strel;ltl3, in between \:here? 11 No, slt', It's a lilrge i\J:8E\ between ;' Lowther Q Yeah, Can YOll g1.ve an idea maybe in J:ootbal~ fields, oar lengths, somethingothel' thi\n blooks beoause my " oity blOokll1ay be dtf:ferent from i\ OOllntry bloak? A ^ goad si~e football field, Q And I beLieve you responded 1:0 one of the " 2),,, jUdge's qUl!lst.tons that' essentially I beHeve 'Yoll testified 22 thai: there was e1n odor of aloohol, Isn' t it true that 23 someone oan sl\1ell of aloohol 1:01.' reasons ol:her than , 24 aonSU\11l11g i)loohol? Whether .,its splll.ed on them, for 2fj .1nsl:anoel 01: ClnYl:h.1ng 11ke that? 27 " I' " ("'\ /""\ 1 II, Nfl, Pl.\" '1'11111 Willi (1) 'Ii III "1")/11:11, 1\: Wflfll1't " " 2 011 11111 bndy, 3 () ,11111'1: il: 1.1'1111 I:liol: ,IlVIlI1 IE f1011100ne I1flr! ~ non III I 1II111 I II I IIolill I 111111 I, Iilll'l! IYIIII 1111 lldql.' nf' 1I100hol 011 1:l1oir 'Ii b1:01lt:.h, Ii, dllllllll' 'I: IIPIIII.r"IIII,'I.I~' 11\11'1111 I:hny' 1'0 Inr.l<lp<lble pH (j flllf:ll dl'lv.lllll'I' 1111111: I:hnl. 1:1'lIll'I' '1 r,m, 1(IIIIUtlii I ,ol!'j CHII: lnll, \'0111: Ilonor, '1'111'1 ('~lI'WI'1 1I,llIl:/lllIod" u 9 IIY Mil, l'I/lIII'lI,M^'" 1 10 , I/IIW '11111111 WIII'Il YOII 1'1:01\1 I:ho cli3fend/.'lnt 'when Q H YOII lIol:llIlId wltlll', YOII'V\l 1,1l1l1:l.j'lod 1:0 be <111 'odor of <lloohol 12 Oil hlll bl'll/Il',h',' l3 1,01 1Ii 16 1'1 " " 1,0 19 20 ;11 22 ~~3 ~~ ~ " ;u, 1\ 1 WIlli !'Iuhl: nl', It.lll oftr door, lIow I:illl., IH'O YOII? Q II Q /I lIow 1:1111 1111I I'l' Yonlr, ^ 1"lvn l'oPt: n,lllo, Q IIl1d Ituw f'/Ii: ,111'1: I:hogroul1r] would you SEW l:olIuhly .... Ill' how 1:111' lip to YOll Wcl\lld the Oflt' door be on' II I3nl:llrll? "Po YOII l,'llllllJlllbnl.' I:ltll\:'( WlIlIII'.',' Jllcl It 001110 up to about Your ,. II \~hl"l.'n l:ltll' wlndDW 111 or - - U 1111';0, \~ll/lrn I:lw door hllnc110 ia, " II 111.\Ihl: Ill; lilY wnln\:, pl;l.ght:ly below H, \.. 11111'1. 11: 1:1:1111 that IJOIIIBon c;> oould have all OdOI: 2U " " " I' ("'\1'1 flk'1 1 bf <\100110}, for 1:1113' OOnl3l1l1\ptlon pf 130mel:jl.i.ng ol:he~: tl1An fl recreA\:ional <I}ool,ol, Whether it be )Joel: or 11'1\10):7 In 3 o\:her wordl3, l.i.ke 4 1\ ,In f\jYCjl\H or' SOl"e , \:hll3 oaflei no, other I:ypeof l3\\ba\:AnOa7 I know t:he di.f.f:e:renoe' 5', pe\:We~n l'lyql\i1. and C\loo/)ol, 6 7 Q 11 1131'1' t f\jyq\1D oompdfJec1 oj: <\loohoH Yefl, 8 MR. )i1,9I11TIlW'If\j, ok<\y, ,Nothing j:l\l:thel", Yom' 9 10 Honor" . 'rIun COUR'r I "MR, I<l\BU,9I<, II'um qOUH'I' , Offloer, Anytl),tng e1.[3e7 MR. I<IIBUSI< , lIny l'ecl1rrlOt 7 No", sir, YOl\r Honor, YOl\ mAY step down. '1:\1<Inl, YOll, 11 12 13 " ,. 14 ~~e depArtment oalll3 Offioe~ 15 0' D011l1ell I " 16 THm COURT, Offer of proof. , 17' " MR, I<1I13USI< 1 JUst ba~ioAlly to oonfirm 18 Offioer Ressler's t~~timony, 19 ;W :ml3helnlC\n7 'rum ,COURT I, Unneoesflnry, l\nythJ'lg, Mr, 21 MR~ mSHmLMIINI If I ll1ay jU13t consult with hJm ~2 to find out whethor he Would1.ihe to testify. 23 '111m COUR'I'I' SUi'e, 24 , MR, KIIIJU8I<i I hnve H videotape, Which onQe n5agaJn ib just , it'13 the second reflleall The firBt rel:usal 29 , " :l ;l 3 ~ 5 6 '7 0 9 10 1;L 12 13 14 16 16 1"1 ;1.0 , 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 , , ,MR, '1~l3mJ\,MlINI In I:n.\.rneon '['11m caug'j'l lInd 1:l1e Inw io oleqr I:hal: \:hey hiw" the d,oh\: 1:0 prOCJe(lf.l \:hell\ <\t tho booking oenter l)efoi:e , nn i\ttorney, 130 don't tell me he W<l13 entil:led to C\II , nt:torney when he got e\rTefJl:eq, MR, 1i113111ilT.,M!IN I I'm not flElylng thnt he Wi'l.f.l antitled t:o olle, I'm saylngwhat hls lInderl3tElndlng wn13, '1'mil caUR'!' I AIICI we're not \:Ell),ing apoul: hlfJ , I: We're tEl~klng abol\t t:he law ,here, and when llnder~':anding , Mr,' LEluer fJigns a pleadlng, whloh he dJd here, H fJpeolfiof'\lly fJaY13 that L:he signature of the attorney oonstitutes a oertifioation to det:e~nlne they've rend the motion,' find to the best of:' his l~nowlec1ge, informatl,on, and belief ther~ is 900dgr~und to support: the motion, MR, , mSHElLMAN I Yel3, fJl,r, '['1m CaUR'!', You tell me th,e good ground thflt Ii thero is to I'lupport this appeal, MH, mSHEll.,MANI loan give you base laW that says that: his refllsal mllst be !wowing,' intell:lgent, and vol,llntadly, 'rItEl caUR'!', okay, Now, wl1at flbout his rel:usal after the DL-26 Was read ho Il1im twioe? What about , ,." " 33 "II" j, ' ). ~, :\ '-I' 4 5 6 ,'7 0 !l l.0 H J.<1 l.3 J.4 15 16 1'7 10 'l.!l <10 <11 <12 23 24 25 , ,. \:llfi\: rol:l\l]l\l In, nol: know:Lna I1ml In\:B1Hgent'i' Ml~, );)f3jllflJ.,MflNI W!101:her he, \IQc1e17fll:ood whA\: WElP 1,)u.1n9 mnrl to hlm AI: \:110 \:!.\1\o, '1'111il CO\JWl', OI~I1Y,' Now, 11: flOO\1\J3 to Ino I elPn:oat lniJ .1r.' I'm WI:on9, 'n!.r, thore lfl'al1f30 lflw, \:ha\: ! .. .; ,,' ppeaHlofllly r~ClYIl l:hn\; tho l:ocll\Or3t pf: 11\1 fI\:tl~rnoy J.fl nOt fI\: J.fJllIte J.1\ \:he pr., " <16 , :La tl\el:o nol:? " MR, lU\nUS\<I' 'l'hat lfl fJ01:l:eot, Yom: 1l0nOl:, and I would alte you \:he PennaylvClnJ.fI Supremo Court Oallo of OommonweEllt:h V, saott at 604 fltlantJ.c <1nd 539, AnC\I'll' just; l:eCld to you point ntlmber '1 In that c;af3e, . ' , Acaorc1lngly, onoe a mQtor:Lst hap been , properly arlVif3ec! of hif3 0' ConnoU Wctrnfngf3, 11 refU!3al to , aubmit too ohe\1\i9al test under the te~na 6f the lmpliec! , , ' Conf3ent ~aw will not ~e eXOUf3ed as ~lknowin9 ~n the ba!3.1f'l of , the motorist subjeotive belief regarc!ing the intoipl~y between ,the Implied Conaent" I,aw Elnd hi,s Mil'anda dghts, 'l'llS GOUR'l', What' f3 the dal:e of that? MR, K1\l3USKI 'l'hEll:'S a l.!l!l6 dose, '1'111]]' CaUR'1'I ,altay, NoW, Mr" l'\luer ia an offioer of this, court] ia he not? MR, mSHm~M1\NI Yea, air, '1'1m caUlt'l', I woule! presume that he )ttloWS the " laW, does he not? MR, mSlmr..Ml\NI Yes, sJ,r, '. 34 " " 1 ;a 3, 4 5 6 'I' 0 : '9 10 1.1 l;a " 1.3 14 10 16 1'7 III 19 20 21 22 23 24 21; " , I"~ ~'\ 'l'IIliJ COIlW!', Olt'1Y, III Hgh\: of: tlll\\: 'OfllJe YOl\ 't(lll me Wh'1I.: th:\.(J n1pt:t.,on 1.(1 11iwncj Ilpon, Mil, milH\nt,MflN ,'1'0 be IIOn13f1t, I WtlP not nwqro of: \:11e $001:\:. aqf.lB flpeo:l.HoElUy, I1l\el n eJ\:i:l.l COmB!] elown to ,w!1et:her t:he poHo13 pfficer had pvo))n))l13 CI1IlI3B \:0 br1nu l1tm 4\1~or the avve!3t, 'l'llm COtJR'I', It' [' not: pl'oP4ble eJttlll3e, 1\:' FJ reEl/lonn))le grounds I MR, lilSlllill..fvlflNI It's rflapolHlbl!,l bn!311:\, 91WtlfJe mil, Yos,air, yep, sir, I dldm1!313tl1te, '1'IUn caUR'I', l\nyth:l,ng ,elae, Mr" lUshelmnn?. MR, mSlImr~M1\lI11 No ,slr I 'l'lIm COUR'l', 1\Np NOW/ todf~Y',1J qal:e,. Elfi:er heOl:ing, tho uppel11 of: John M, Salapn from the atlfJpensiol1 of his operntor' f.] pdv.j.leges i13 c1eniscl, 'l'he aation of t:he Department if.] af:f1rmed~ Mr, SalElpa, YOU1' liaen/le, arG !3uap0nded for a yea,:, If you 1: Elttorney ha/ln't toJ,q YOlt, l'mgoing"to tell you right now, 1t' a EI mElnCla\:ory 90 day j EI:l.l a~ntence anf a mandatory $1,000,00 f:ine if: you get behlnd the wheel! So don't ~o 1t.Pecauf3e we have no discretion ln that regard, ,. . f-, , You've gohto go to jall, Co you undoratand that? 'l'lI1il nml<mND1\N'I', YGS, ,p1r, '1'11m Call1~'l', 1\11 r1ght I Court's adj ourned I " (Whereupon, tho pl'oceedinna concluded tIt 3,05 p,m,) 35 ! I I i I I , 1 I . I I I "j. i ' . I . ; , I ',I " '( . . ' , , , " , ' , ' t''" ", '. I:J " " ,I., " " " , , , " I " " " " " , ' '. " " " " " ;,' , , I, " , 'I, " " 'I,. " " ", I' , " ,; II , , ,,' " 'pt. " " i.' " I, " ,,( p, " " " " rn ,;' ", , " d',. if ,I' I,,, " I' " " "j. " " " 'I" , , , . " .' " " " ., ., " " 1 I ' " " " , 1 " I' .' I' .'