HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-06111
..,
It
o
~
'-t.
."
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
:-..
,
, ':::>
, .....
~
!
"'
........
........
~
~
~
. ".
1'.<
L:\I(I(Y.I. RI'\",
1'1;,,111111
1\ IIII'('OII(IOI'('()\I\IO\PII..,\S(JIo
('I\IIlI'RI ,\\;Il COI X/ y, PI:\:\SYI \',,\\;1:\
:\() %,11/11 ('1\'11
(i!:\I: S. I.l '(':\S,
IJell'ndall1
A:'iSWER WITU :'IE'Y ~L\TTJ.::R
TO: LARRY J. RUN", Plailllif'!: alld his allorne)', .IOS!:PII D, BUCKLI;Y
YOU :\R!: Ii!:RI;IlY :\OTIFJU) TO FILE ..\ II'R/TTEN R!:SI'O;\iSI, TO Till,
Ei\'Cl.OSED NEW \1:\TTI;R \l'ITIIli\' TI\'I;\I'Y (20) 1l1\ YS FRO\I SERVICE IIERI'OF OR :\
.IUDG\lENT MA Y ilE Et\:TERED 1\(i:\INST YOI;,
:\1\D !\:OW, ihis 24th day 01 N",.elllher. I()<)~. COmes Defclldant, GClle S, Lucas. hy and
through his attomcys, MARTSO:\ DE:\RDORFF WILL/AlviS & OTTO, and avers the 1l)lIowing:
I. Admittcd,
1 Admillcd.
3. Denied as statcd. In or around .Iunc of I ~l)(" Delendant specifically rcqucstcd
Plaintiff to rcplacc thc cnginc in his 1~~5 Volkswagcn GTI with a ncw cnginc, as opposcd to a
rcnHlIlul"cturcd. uscd, or rchuilt cnginc.
4. Denicd as statcd. PlaintilTgavc Dclendani and DcJendant's son, Michacl A Lambcrt,
a vcrbal cstimatc in thc amount of 53.200.00 "to fix c,'crything undcr thc hood," including
rcplaccmcnt of the old cnginc with a nc\\' cnginc, as opposcd to a rcmanul<lclurcd, uscd, or rcbuilt
cngll1c.
5. Dcnicd as statcd. Dclendant ncvcr authorizcd Plaintiff to inspcct thc vchiclc, nor
pcrfonn any work rclatcd to a Pcnnsylvania Stalc inspcction. By way of furthcr answcr, it is dcnicd
Plaintiffor his busincss, Bill's Wclding locatcd at 254 E. North Strcct, was eertificd, liecnsed, or
otherwise authorizcd by thc Statc of Pcnnsylvania to pcrlorm Statc inspections, and strict proof
thereof is demanded at trial.
6, Denicd as slatcd. PlaintilTdid not pcr/orm thc work as requested by Dcfcndant. On
thc contrary, Plaintiffpcrfonncd work thai was not authorized or requcstcd by Dcfcndant.
7, Admittcd in pari, dcnicd in part. Plainti ff providcd a bill which Dcfendant signcd,
S. I kll!l.:d ;1'.. \t.lll.'d I h:(l'lhbllllll;\tk' p,l~ IIIi.'l1h lil:.11111:~ \,~,Slll tOl '. Itld~ldJI1:' )~,~IIHlJ( t
Oil Sl'pll'lllhlT I J. Il)l}fl, PIII',lJ,llllltl PLlIlIllll~.... tlll~'IJ\.t1l,:"lllll.lk IIlI 1\:pLlrllJ~~ lilL' i.'1l~'llll' \\ llll ;111...'\\
I'lIgilH.... as oppoSL.'d 10 Olll'IlI;IIlIILll'llllnl. u....l,d.lll Il.:hullt l'I1)'lIll', alld ~tllj('lJlI 1111 or ;dhllll \1l\l'lIl1ll'r
12, IliliS, lilr rcpairs III Ihl' "'"11"1, ;11111 prC'.SIIlC plall'. 111111 "1'lIal SII Ilrh, spcl'd,IIl1l'll'l, alld
illstallatiollllr illlll'l' \\'Ol'h... ur thl' IU....Sl.I1~!LT dool'. \\ hll'h IL'J1;ms I kklldalll ."I1l'l'i lirally Il'qul'...ll'd alld
authorilcd.
Ii. :\dlllillcd ill part. d,'lIicd in part. It is adllllll,'d the: r,'pair hill illdll"alrs 1I\lal repairs
,1I111llllltcd to Sh,17S.5J. ofllhldllkll:ndant h,1S paid 5.1,SIIII.IIIJ. leavlllg a halallcc of52,.\7S.5J. Ii
is dcnied ihai amollllt is ollcd.
WIIEREFORE.lkli:nd'"l\ rcspccllirlly dClllalldsjlldglllcllt againslPlaintilTinthc amoullt
rcqllcslcd in I'lailltilrs ('omplailll, logcthcr wilh costs and rcasonahle allomcy's Ii:cs. and allY othcr
rcmcdy this Court Illay dccm appropriatc.
i'lEW1\LUTEH
AEElH:\I.\TIITJ)EI'.Ei\SL-_.EHAUJ)
10. Paragraphs I through 9 arc illcorporatcd hercin by rcferencc as irset lorih in thcir
entirety.
II. PlaintilTagreed and exprcssly averrcd he wOllld replace the old engine in Defendant's
1985 Volkswagen GTI. with a new engine, as opposed to a remanuliletured. used, or rebuilt engine.
12. Defendant relied upon Plaintilrs assertion that he would replace tbe old engine wiih
a new engine, as opposed to a remanuliletured, used, or rebuilt engine, and as a direct and proximate
result, allowed PlaintilTto perlorm work on bis car in licu of purchasing a used car.
I J. PlaintilT replaced the old enginc wilh cngine number 027-1 00-003-GX, which he
purchased Irom CVM Autopark 2. A true and accurate copy or the invoice from CVM Autopark 2
is attached as Exhibit A.
14. Engine number 027-1 OO-OIJ3-GX is a remanuli,etured. used, and/or rebuili engine.
15, I'lajlllll'f~II<'\\III,'ly. Ilkllll,".dl,. \\rllfull,. aud "I \\llh IL'l'~k" dhlL'Pld lill IhL'
truth. l'olll..'l.'ak'd li'{l1Jl1 h: I l.'lld ,II II 111;11111.... ....II:,ilh,: pl.ll'L'd 1111 kfLolld.tlll '" \ l'I Ill.: k' \\;lS;1 h.:III;IIlIlLIL'llIIl'd.
lISl..'d. II lid 01' fl.'IHIlIt L'nglllL'
1<>. I'lajulil'f,u"IIII' 1"""1L".IIIII', \\'ddlllg,I"L'alL'l1 al25.J I.. :\"llh SIILL'!. (',ult,k,
I'LlIlIsyl\'allia 171J 13, was 11,,1 IILLIl"d, LLTlllicd, !H'I lllhLr\\ hC ''''II'''lilL'd hy Ihc Slall' llf
I'clIllsyl\'allia io pcrl;l!'IlI I'c""syll.,""a Slalc ill'pcLliolls "I 25.1 I;. :\onh SIICL'!. illlhL Illll11Uglt llf
('"rlisle.
1 7. I'I"illli ff ~uowillgly, illklliillll"lly, will flllly ,""h'r wilh I~ckkss dislcg"rd 1;>1' Iltc
tmlh, concc"led IrOlll Ik1l:ld""llh,,1 hc w"s ll11i Iawflllly p~nllill~d 10 p~rll>f1ll 1'~llllsyl\'alli" SI"ic
lnsp~clions onih~ pr~lllis~s ofBill's \\'ddillg lo~atcd ,,125.1 (':. :\onh SII~~I,l'"r1isl~,I'~nnsyl\',,"ia
17013.
18. Plainlil'fp~rl;lIIll~d " SI"I~ IIlSp~Clioll Oil Dct'~ld""1 's I ')85 Volksw"g~1l GTI willtout
lawful authorizatioll, "lid wilhoui Ddi:lld"ut's npr~ss p~rlllission, ami Lhalg~d Ddi:lldalltlor a "Ilew
mOior," wh~n in fact. ii was a r~lllanul"cIUI~d, us~d, alld;oll~huiltlllotOr. A tru~ alld ac~urat~ copy
ofth~ repair bill is allach~d h~r~io as Exhihit13, alld incorporal~d h~r~ill by rdi:r~llcc.
19. As a dir~cl ami proximal~ r~sult of Plailltirt's lraudulelli conduci, Dcfcndant Itas
sufli:rcd in cxccss ofS3,2IJO.OO.
WHEREFORE, Dcli:lldanl rcspc~tlldly r~qucsls this ('ourt cntcr judgmcnt against Plaillliff
for thc amount S3,200,()(), togctbcr with illtcrcsi thcrcon and coslS, rcasonablc allomcys fccs, and
any oihcr rcmcdy this Court may dccm appropriatc.
C~TERCLAJ.M
COUNT I
i\IISREPRESENTATION
20. Paragraphs I ihrough 19 arc incorporatcd hcrcin by rclcrcncc as if sct forih intlteir
entirety.
21. Plaintiffkncw or should havc knownthc cnginc hc rcceivcd irom CVM Auiopark 2
and placcd in DcfcndanI's car was a rcmanufacturcd, uscd, and/or rcbuilt cngine, as opposed to a
new engme.
"
I k'.plll' 1'1.11111111';-. hllll\\ kd:'l' III l'lllhtllil.:lI\ l' I'dlll\\ kd~',L' Ihal tile l'llgilll' he IL'(1..'I\ cd
fllllll ('\'\1 ,\lllnp.l1k 2. ;llltl pLI!.."l'd 1111 >l'!".:l1d,III!'.... l',lI \\;1', ,lll'lIl;l1IuLll'lllInl. U"L'd. alld tlr ",:hllll1
l'lI~lI1\.'. .1'" IIl'l'n......d III il 111'\\ t'II~'I'h', \\ Illrll h L'\ Ilkllt fit 1111 till' P;lIllllll11hL'1 027 -1 (111-1)(13-( i\. wlllch
app~al' 1111 Iii,' 111\("'" alia~h,'d a, hllilll1 ,\. 1'1.11111111 ,1"lcd 1111111,' "'1''''1 hilI. ,,",,~II~d as F.\hihil
B. Il1al thl..' ,..'Il~lIH: \\ as ~l "Ilt.:\\' llIul0L"
2.1. Ih:ll,'lllbnt h.-lied upon PI;1I1111ffs 1l11"1\.'pn..'sL'III;llitlIlS.
2.1. :\, a dil~~i alld pr<1.\illlalL' 1L"1I1t oll'l:lllll1f1"s III1SI~pl~S~lllali"lls.llcklldalll agr~~d
10 allow PlailltilltD Ill..'rli.lI"l11 work 011 ))dL.'lld;IIII's \'dlil'k illliclI ofpun:IJasing a used car.
25. :\s a direct and pW\llllah.: result Ill" Plailllilrs misn:pn.:scntations. Ddcl1llant has
"uncr~d dalllag~s ill L'.\~~ss "fS,I,2IJ11,1J1J,
\\'IIEREFORF, Ilclclldalll r,"p~cll'ully r~quL'sl' judglll~nt ag"insl I'lainiilT ill ~x~~ss of
S3,200.00, 10gdh~1 wilh inl~r~stlh~rcoll and ~'lSis, r~"sollabk "lIorn~y's Ic~s, alld any oth~r r~lll~dy
this Court may d~~1ll appropriat~.
COUNT II
WRONGFUl. COi'i\'ERSION OF C!L\TTEI.
2C>, Paragraphs I through 25 ar~ incorporal~d h~rL'in by r~f~r~n~e as ifs~t forlh iniheir
eniircly,
n. Plaintiff pi~ked up D~f~ndant's \'elliele und~r spe~ilie instructions io replace the
origillal cngill~ with a new ~ngine, as opposed 10 a remanul;lctured, uscd, or rcbuilt cnginc.
2S. Der~lldantnc\'er aulhoriz~d Plaintiff to disposc of any paris, including Ihe enginc,
notwithstallllillg thcir condiiioll as allegcd by I'lailllin~ and inl;lct, Defendallt spccifically rcqucstcd
all parts be rcturned to him wh~n h~ r~turn~d to pay thc bill.
29. To dal~, I'laintiffhas I~fus~d to relinquisb any ofthc parts, illcluding thc original
cllgine, which Defcndallt was lold by l'iainiilTcould not bc used as a "corc cngillc" to rcturn io CYM
in cxchange for a r~nH\I1ul;lcturcd, uscd, or rcbuilt ~ngillc,
30. As thc original cngine allcgedly could not b~ lIsed as a "corc cnginc," Plaintiff
charged Dcfcndant S300.00 for purchasing a satisnlciory "corc cllginc," and S60,OO for picking up
thc cllgillc on a "rollback." Scc Exhibit "13",
3 I. A satisfaclory "cor~ ~ngin~" was \'al,,~d by CYM Autopark 2 at S I ,5S0.00. Scc
Exhibit "A",
.12. AS;I dlr~.'l'I alld IlIt1\11I1.lh: 1 \.....u II tll PI;III1IIII~s LlilIlI'L' 10 lISL' Ikll:lld;lIlt':-, original
L'llgll1l.... as;1 "rOlL' L'llgiIlL.... I kll:lld.IIIII1,I', "tIlkl\.:d dallld~'l,'" of) I,i).tll 1111
33. I'arh ot' II1\.: \\ Itlllgrllll~ dl"lh",\.'d or P;lIh, flO!\\ ItilsLIlldlll!' tl1\.:Jl ;lIlq:l,'d nllldilioll,
eitllerwuld Ila\l' bel'llused III bl'u "r'l'plal.l'llll'lll. "r "tllemise 11O1l1 a ",ILa":L' \,due, witll wllieb
[kli:lldaul wuld Ila\e applicd 10tlll'JlIII ",otIlLT\\ lSC illcurrL'd 'lllcIlCIil.
}4. As a dirccl alld prO\imatl' 'L'stdt "r Plailltirrs I;,ilurc toUSC "r returll various pans,
iurludillg tllc origilla[ ellgillc, lJri'clldallt h." surli:rcd ill C\CCSS "rs 1.'),111.1111 ill dOl magI's,
W[ IEREFORE. lJrli:llda'lI rcspcclrully requcsts judgmclli agaillsi Plailltil'!' ill cxeess or
S [.lJ40,OO. togetller witll illteresllbereoll aud L'llsi, rcasollable allorlley's Ii:es, alld allY otllcr remedy
lhis ('ourlmay deem approprialr.
COU~T III
VIOLATION OF TilE Ui'\FAIR TRADE PRACTICES AND CO:"SUi\IER
PROTECTJO:" L\ W, 73 P,S, 201-1, el seq,
35, Paragraphs I througll }4 are illL'll'llOrated Ilerrill by rrli:rellee as if set forth ill their
entireiy.
36, Plaintiff used unl:lir deceptive acts or practices as delined in the Unfair Trade
Practices and Consumer Protection Law (hereinalier "UTPCPL"). Section 20[-
2(4)(ii),(iii)(v),(vi),(\'ii),(x\'), and/or (xxi). by perlonning a Pennsylvania State Inspection on
Defendant's car without lawful or personal authorization to perlorm such inspections at Bill's
Welding, 254 E. North Streei, Carlisle, Pennsy[\'ania.
37. Plaintiff used unfair deceptive acts or praeiiees as delined in the Unfair Trade
Practices and Consumer Protection Law (hereinalier "UTPCPL"). Section 201-
2(4)(ii),(iii)(v),(vi),(vii).(xv), and/or (xxi), by performing \'arious repairs io Defi:ndani's vehicle on
grounds of necessary to pass a Pennsyl\'ania Siate Inspeeiion.
38. Plaintiff used uniair deceptive acts or practices as defined tn the Unfair Trade
Practices and Consumer Proteeiion Law (hereinalier "UTPCPL"), Section 201-
2(4)(ii),(iii)(\'),(vi),(\'ii),(xv), and/or (xxi), by knowingJy. intentionally and fraudu[ently
misrepresenting he would and did replace the old engine with a new engine, as opposed to a
remanufactured, used. and/or rebuilt engine.
,1<1. Ikl<:ndalll \\ould uot have authori/ed 1'1.,inlilf to perli'r111 any \lor" on his I')S~
Volkswagen (iTI had he known I'lainlilLnllllli II's \\'c1dinl: \I ere III ,ICL'll; lied. I ;censL'd or olherwise
~. . .
aUlhori/ed hy the I'enusylvania Ikpallnlenl ofTranspollalronlo "erli'ml SI;lIe Inspections.
.jO. Ikli:ndanl \\ould Ill)t have authori/ed I'lainlilf to perli>nll any work ou his I')S~
Volkswagen (jTI had he kUo\\nlhe only availahle engine \las a r.:malllll;letured. used, or replaccd
engiue Irom ('Vi\! Auiopark 2.
.j I. Plainiiff, iudividually and Ihmugh his husiness, Ilill's \\'elding, is in violalion of Ihe
UTPCPL, Section 201-3 by using unl;Jir and deceplive acls or practices as sel I()rlh abun: and
thruughout.
.j2. As a direct and proximate result of I'laiutilrs use of unl;Jir and deceptive irade
praciices in violaiiun of the UTPCPl., Dcli:ndanl allowed I'laintilTto perl(ll'Ill wurk on his car in lieu
uf purchasing a used car.
43. As a direct and proximaie result uf Plainlilrs Iraudulent and deceptive conduct and
practices, Deii:ndani has sufli:red iu excess 01'53,200.00 in damages.
WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully demands judgmenl against Plaintiff for treble
damages in the amount of59,GOO.OO, plus reasonable allorneys Ices pursuant io Section 201-9.2 of
the UTPCPl., together with interest thereon and costs, and any other remcdy this Courimay deem
appropriate.
MARTSON DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO
8YBen~~r'~:lu~
Ten East High Street
Carlisle, P A 17013-3093
(717) 243-3341
Allomeys lor Delcndani
Date: November 25, 1998
r<-OIM
Auloparll 2
,
Chrysler/Plymouth. Jeep/Eagle. VOlkswagen
111')11,\10<1.\111;1((;1'1"1..1',\1<11\11.1',\ liOII. IIIII'.~",":~.~
- ---
HI)!JW)
tllAW,1Y FHIIMY
3MUIlIJA~
,: ,l.p _ '): ~),,,
B: ~~, 1'l : ',~1
IHANK YOU YO,Y HUCH Fe,1( mUll IJU31NE33,
"" "1", "',~
'" III'" , ",', II '.".,., ~,., ..,., '.'" ,.,.,.,
i"""" '''''11'''''.''''''''1''''',' ".'"'lI'''
, ""'" , ,~,'/ \""" "" . '" ," "" "",01, ,"'" .
"".' ..""<,..,,,11.'1""" ',,,."','..1,',,,,,,..,,,,
''''''''''''''''''''''''''''.''
,,," " .' , , . , , ,'~. L'. ." .j
"""""""''''''0''''0''''01'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''1\'.'''''''III.
", '. I',. ,'", ,./", ,..,',. ", ,"W '''!It! H~~II"'U""f'"
" '. 'I'" ,., ".', " . ., '" ." , ',,' " , '''''~ "" ',' I I ..", I" ''1 I 'I
"..,' ,.. o. , ..., 'J" II' .'01 ...... I" " "'1"""'''. '~"'" !lV' "".vn
~'l')'J .)
7
(;(i~.1l
'~Iflt~ Hf-tKU<
o7/<l3/% J 866,
VWW
11l"'243"\13~B
FlU 215168/0
? RUNKS GARAGE
t 254 EAST NORTH 3TREET
CARLISLE, PA 17013
T
o
5
..
I
P
I
o
. SH'P' ..q,. .' "'.' 'p'A~:r,~~~o.~~ / Oe~~RIP~ION ",: .:-. BIN, : LIST" NET: I, A'MOtmT.
-1
,~ 077 -1""''l-'~5-t;X
'" YW01.7-10\.1-rJ0.,-(,X
PIlICE
tll,dNl RO
CORl
':Of~[ RE TUHN
3P-UHO
1229,0(~
1106.10
1580,00
1580,00
1106. 10
1580.00
-1580.00
3,,';t
7-
pJ.
fJ J J-I
III I l.Ll\.H..: ,I! ' ; P :: Ii : i, t,. , , " '.1;', f l',l i\: 'C;)UI"/\I'Jli:.D
UY rlW; l:IU..
NO nUIJfiN~; (liO) I!: Glllle/,I I'i>llr:.
NO I1U;Ur'jIJ,; 1\1' I U I :;0 i)A '(::;
, NO nUUHW: em :;I'U:,/\L i)f.lI>F11I ['PAin,;.
SUB,TOTAL 1106.10
3:13:26 .. DUPLiCATE o.
TAX '.0.00
FREIGHT .0.00
PAY THIS AMOUNT 1106.10
1 OF 1
EPH
......
I. \J.)f\~~ 00 f~ ~, c..~C\l~II~~~(r'I.I~
" \jO,) ff\DV::L', \l.~'1 \'2..cw f",le:; A ~cl' t~~~~~\~~.cft....
~ c:.J.y . .,. , " . ..1lV\'
A'\ lCDO il'l, ~E:.~I~ oil\- -\'&It l ~t he &.4~ ESTIMATE
z..~~^~ ""f>l..\AI5o)nA\.d<lbe..Mf'l~,.. _ ( F ,RHJ I~S l
ttr ~,' . ":) ,( "'(IIJ (.l · -, .,I.D' .J. t"'~
....
l~ "(.;r1.
I -..,.......
-1 L~'"'' ""'....
1...r.c:rO"
....-
.~::~-
u.a.. "AIN1'
.....gUNT A"OUNr
TOTAl.
AMOUHI'
..,t.U"
-1...'Oft....
....,.......
....... ..
...... -....
\JW
..,.,.,."
Q"',
D.ecRI~Tl0H Of' AIE.......A. AND REPLACEMENTS
PARTS
ttUM.IN AMOUNT
d.. 9"1i3 oc>
\ ~ 'll
g'",'5
\'- 00
;1,,+ 2.')
J..#q'5
\R 1Q.. \~ /0
_~I~____~~SO
EA.~ Q, n.1"'l_ \").., ~
/I "\ 4-2D 00
..,
,...J.
..,.", .-..J'
~w ,__ -;0I~',,\.L)~.:.~~~!~'t'.':1.c2..1 ,}
~"'u) \I) '-.ar. !\c;,S\J. ...- I"
u.)- - . ~ - a~V.J....
\.,_oJ'\,~1I r,:tn -(i"'o'f'o..",,,,,,O&' ..I~
\\'I\\\t.X1\- ~~-\; '- .-
(l\,~-\,.\..."'ii+
~~, U\P
e.~
-
-4.- ()\OO~
\.OI'"'I~'\.d ~\-~
.. .\ ft. rr.P..L "Cl\ ( Nq' ~f~,- ,~~^-'~
{)Ir b.. U~ \ ~Ill. r "on .
a.. ft.. ~~b (J.-\i~,tKltL'
e>\~ f\lk
4- I nb-., (' oA. "..&?!;;,...."' 1- ~T
1t<CJt \. A.- ~pg070
~ ~, cl9.f.u.i-
p.,\~ t\~
n..<:t., :\1
-r;C':."5__
1:ft:?S
. "''''
tv Ie
[:,1\. l.ClSi 1C ~ rv:.
1 J.. s<::\
F-A. ,A,"
Q k",
~f\. 'S ':0
~ I 2.lJ
CD
4J;:;oo
l?.A-t s<n
\~lil
~~
cq~
\ b '50
21 Zo
TOTALS
INSURED 'AYS , INS. CO. PAY~ -II. O. N__
INS. CHECK 'A"AllIlO 'AI
~::I" .. "'JMD", ....... .. .., 5III...dl.. 1M 4oe' ..I coorer .ddlll...1 ,.,It IF I.bot ~
_ ....:.1JM ,".IfM . Nt 1M ..,k ... ..... ......... All.....,. h. 11.....4. '"' -- "..ha'n..ll I!CIC ·
.-.w: .. IMrte .1I1dl .,. .......,.. .... ." ... ..,kfe-' .. Un' ....d'". we ....,.. .11. ~ IIflC
... ... ..._IWI ........ .. ...... ....... .. "I, ... ....... ~k.. .,. ..t ".,1.1.-4, ....
.. ........ .. ....,.~ _t,. All ....,'-' III .-it u4 kMf I" ...... .-4 ..-.-
nolA.' ellG'l
bOQ9
EST. MAD. It TOT" l 0 F
ISTINATI
'_lUtI"n.prAlL ,...--""..-...----.......--
SIGN~. DAu:>(
Exhibit "A"
~t
\
I;
, ,
",'
~
\ "
,.
~,
I".
I'd :
-
..... -I.......... ....
.... ... .... \J vJ I~ .... &t:t. I LtC..... ...,.... ..""..... J...'........ H.fA......
I.
...."...... ..IV"'" .......G1'.. 1:-'
......
PAnTS I,A.ON P~UMT T01'Al.
...... O.ec:AI"ION Of' RII~"fn. AND REPLACEMENT_ HU"_'" ANOUNT AMOUNT A"Oll"'I' .MOUNT
( Ll~ ~1ili.. A."5<:JJ., 0.., ~l.. ~L ')t!J D.a t::.i...
~.'w.. tlJ\....... /- 'Sq ~ ~., ......, ~
~l~~ (, .....:DI--.\ ~ cP M C. h<. 0::>
C\\ \. (~.D~"'\ -, M
.96. '\:2. c.. q7,. :)2,.
c.. ~ .....L..I..' U,~~DI/Il:l~~w'I*d\ ~ ~ \oJ c.... A., =::c:
M+, on Ii.. '1 VI ~ iP
.-d.., 1'_ '.bf\D ~l~C'- . ..- __'::. .L' - t=./o.. ~A ....... \"'2.. ~ 'A~I ~
t. - .\ ,\t tU\Mv~l ~a Q).J, fZ.. tv." ~2. ~ -~ '0>
~ \I \fo~;IILA\ "l f-- - -
. ~ \ f.:\( l ~
''';, r ~
\ .. - -
'A _\;l:-t:t A~uSftt.. ~f(O. E-#., l1: 1111: \1- d./)
;:)... H-cf 'SCI..iLM..J f-.4 "5 iF , ,.. ~
d- H: - U ~(t.q.uJ t:J -'S. c>-=> I.^ l-..
BoH: 1..1 ,.... ,/I 1,_,
t<.oH: I.f\ ,e;: If) ~
. >- .1 L .c... uti I 10 I qO
, ,
~o. A:'ilSU. :l.:-t '~'S , 4=1 R5
~ .
C'\:i'i , fpol'tJ (-A. :,( ex> q~ CO
d... ~ ~+eu\: baA~~ f~, 3,q ID 1~2... w 110 2-D
INSURED PAYS , INS. CO. MY' a. o. N._ TOTALS ~
INS. CHECK PAYAILI T(:I ,All .2A ...
~~. t. .. :t,r...... "'IM.. _r ""PMII.. IN ... ..I Cewf ,cfdlllNl' ,ltft ... r.M4 - cJ"t"'1':T~
Mey ... ~'''' ~... ~ ""'.4. AfI., ...,. ... .1.,..... .., "'.. 1tN...~ WalCK"
~.... .. ... . ... ... ... .. ..We" .. II,,, ""dIM. .. """" '~ .UYlel
-~; ... ........ .. ~At'::.... t:1t Nle ..... .l'i.k.. .nII ., ...'..I....~. -
Ie .... ......... ...... .....1 .. "rt. . lea- .re c.rr.I N41.. eel noLlo.1 C...'S
. lolADI It TOTAL OF ~g
. ISTlIIATI 53
w.....n n. r.... ..1IIIi.&h~ rrt*a .. 1M -...........
~.2. wlid-E14bA- q,I.O
~~~ ~~, "I.lS'5 -~.OIl uV-
A(e. '5",~k ~\ ~ ~.C\ 'S
. ~ ~1l: I~Qov \S'.OO
ot ~.<,i\.~ e:A. 1~.8(:, - 3"Z.'lV
,
..
..
.
.
Ie
:-;x~ --
bn'i.~3 ~ldtS
1000. DO \::b.'l-13-1C. _IT...
":> t "1 g ,'"jl 11
- 5()o.a.->~,q.'3'~6v.rI~VI$ ESTIMATE
+6 Iff. $'S- f1J/ll~9-15'% OF REPAI~S
""
-Maete
OAT" X )!tj1t?/
....... He
...
"H.CTII
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
III.... ~ l\.ICAS I ,.,,-0.... ~:I~-qb
."....~ lQ~ n.. I I ue.... ,.u...... "llo""'.. 1".'."-' .e...."....
\JW .,IIMiI'
...."....., ...,,,,,.,.11I .,....ctOIl 1-....
.....
..D.SCRIPTION or REPAIRS AND REPLACEMENTS PARTS &'A.O" PAIN" 'YOT"1..
art. NUM.I" AMOUNr ""OUNT AWOU"" AMOUNT
tlr..o -r\..0wIS ~ Milo r 1::..1'1 .r-
C''''^.",D ^' \ \-" r,ltrL- 1
AI L CO i\ \' '2.0 I<.D r ~\ \ ~ q EJ
~l" ('-fl.. -2...
- -
-, O\l fll-1
~ n 4S \2- 4S
, nJ' ~G-. ,,^\OI~ - ,^^J,,, A' l AM{tII~ \') 1/, \2 ().J
\ J\ QA'P - ....Y) e. '1
, - -
-- .-
M' I L.l1rlP ... n(')(') q 1(,., - I- - - 1-- -
\l -
- .~.
"..
"
-
"
- -
,.
.'
0"
-
/
INSURED PAYS , INS. CO. PAY' It. O. No_ TOTALS -<-4 2.5
INS. CHECK 'AVAILI TO lAX '6- 0\
I~ ...... t. .. ..II...'. ........ .., ....pee".. ..4 dOll' ... eoww ,ddlll.".t ,.,1. ., I.bot -
..~. MIl, ,.....1'... .1.. t~ _, .... boN_ ,..,t.d. All.' w".... .t....d. .., _'II, 110,....' WlUCxrl h~
"i.:ht:' .... ..... ... · ........ ... ... H' ..,...,.. ,..,......,...... ....- ':J JIIYIC.
~I =.,:" ....... ~ ,..-fiJi:.... ~~ .... ..... "Irlll .,. ... ...,..'....'b4.
... .. ....,...~ ..". f .....111 .. lIoltl .... II", .,. ~ .M" ... 110...... cft.,. -
EST. "'ADE rY TOTAL OF 3-biz]
ESTINATE
'_II.II1IR AI&. ,. II..... ... ................ lit'" -............
D
SIGNED~~
,
OAT" q /w) 9"
1
. .
I
i
( ;
I'
VE~IFJ(',\TJ()~
! '
'.
I, (il'nl' S. l.ucaS,Ilt'fehy Wlily lilt' ""<'going /1I1\\\l'l wilh New Maltef and ('ounlefdailll aft'
based upon infoflllalion which has hlTn galhl'll'd hy Illyself and Ctllulsel iu 11ll' Pfl'p,u'ation of this
lawsui!. The language of the document is that of counsd aud not nt)' own. I have fl'ad the dOCUllll'llt
and to the extent that it is based upon inforlllation which I haw giwn to illY counsd, it is true and
correct to the hl'st of nty knowil'dgl', inforlllation and hdil'f. To the extent that the content of the
doculllent is that of counsd, I haw relied upollcounsl'l in Illaking this verification.
This stalement and wrilkation are muk subject to the penalties of I X Pa. C.S. Section 4l)()4
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities, which pfovidl's that if I make knowingly false
averments, I may be subject to criminal penalties,
1
I ~~"
Ii
I
I,.
~!:s~~
...;
,
.~
h
1
'f
,
~
I
,
I
\
i
:
,'.!!
~ !
i'
, ,
"
CElUIFlC\TI:: OF SEH\ICE
I. Tri,i" 1 l. I 'l'kc'llrll'"1. "II ""II111I1Il'd "~~c'lll I,ll \ I.lIh. III. 1 l,'.II .1",11. Willl"'I".~ (lilli, Ii,r,hy
((nily 11i"1,, wpy IIrlli, lilr'l~IIillg :\IISII,r \\'ill1 :\C'II \1.11il'1 '"'' s(1\l'lllliIS ,i.lil' hy dq1<lsilillg
S"111, ill 111, l'osl Oni" "I ('"disk, 1':\. Iirsl c1"ss llI"il,l",sl"g, prq1;lid, "ddr,ssl'll "s 1"lIows:
.I11"pli D. Illldky. I:sqllirc'
12.17 IIIIlIy I'ik,
C"rlisk, I'A 17111.1
\IARTSO:\, 1lE:\RDORFF, WII.I.1A\IS 8: OTTO
C2V"~Lt!{{l.K) 0 tjd; ,()~~ j
'rei,i" D. E,k'llIo"d -ro f'
.. I Easllligl1 Slr((1
Carlis,," 1'1\ 17111]
(717) 24].]]41
Datcd: Novcmbcr 25, 1998
..:
""7:
o .
eIl~
..:'"': 0:: l~
"'~
...J>- '"
"" ell _ ....
~..- ~
z ...... <
dZ< ~ -
"'...J ell ~ j
~ c.. 1- Z < '"
::;c:z:: ;:J u ~ ~ '"
0:: :3 '" ~ 0
o. 0 '9 z "- ""
v5i=~ ...; il~~ 0 '"
>- ~ <Ii ~ '"
"" v' ~ f- < "'
00<0 c: w w Z
0:: '" " 0 'F, W ""
f-V...JZ 0:: Z .... ~Q~ z " :< N
~ ~ I- ~
O::Cl~ :J '" 0 '" ~ F:
:::>Z> U ."
I.? 0:: < u iJ Z
0:;:- W.J ~ ~ ;,j _ 7- D
U U ~ :r:t:
",;;2 ~~~ ~ w
~ ~ :j Z
ell Z 9
:r:'" Z 'r, ~
I- " " ~ :!l it
f-ell < " . ~ ~ w
~~ .:s :i z ~ ~
/. ~ ~U w
U f-<
COMMo...W....LtH O. 'INHIYLVANIA
-."-- co"un'.o. cOMMoN 'lIAS
NOTICE OF APPEAL
ClJMflF:RT ANn
JUDICIAL OlinlCT
FROM 10' .J(.. . Ci Y"
DISTR ICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMON mAl NQ l' j - (. / II .(1(,: t./&,=--
NOTICE OF APPEAL
NotICe is given thot the oppellonl hra flltoJ In ttlf~ ubov(. (outt of Common Pl~m on opp~ar from th,. ludgment rendered by Ih~ Di,'rjet Ju,'ice 00 the
dote and in the COUt mentionc!od bt!low
Gene S. Lucas
'Alal~r~u.AN"'--' . -_.,--
eliy.
IM~i~ ('o!<f-~Kf""6ii r.IA;;i.:f6fb."T
. ~__._ . __Q9:,2-01
STATE
Zi'C~
~.
I.
,
I
f,
,
NA:Mfor'A)MUANT' .
6 Oak Lane _ .. M<?~l:!allic:s_b~E___!?A
t>>.T1Q11J..OGo1,t"fNT ----- -~Ii.4fti-CA!lOf{It."fl'l IC.~I"rxl.lflIl
9/28/98 _____ ___~!:Y J. Runk V!o Gene S. Lucas
~~ ~;i: OC00366-98 m __ _~___~__:J'NA1~~~.~:='~~~Q..
Thi. block w;!1 b. li!J!lCd ONLY when th;. nolation ;. ,equ;,.d under Po. R.cP.JP. No. tfappel/ant was CLAIMANT (see Pa. HCP.JP. No.
loo8B.
This Notice of Appeal. when received by the District Justice. will operate 0' 0 1001 (6) in action before District Justice, he MUST
SUPERSEDEAS 10 the judgment fa< po.....;on ;n th;. ca.e FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days alter
Ii/ing his NOTICE 01 APPEAL.
17055
~ I
,
"
Signature of Piotflonotary or Deputy
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
(This section ollorm to be used ONLY when appellant was DEFENDANT (see Pa. R.CP.JP No. 1001(7) in action belore District Justice.
IF NOT USED, detach Irom copy 01 notlCG 01 appeal to be SGlVed upon appellee).
PRAECIPE, To Prothonotary
Enter rul. upon Larry J. Runk
NatntJof aJ:fK!lletYs)
. oppellee(s). to file a complaint in thi, appeal
"
I'
.'
"
I
(Cammon Plea, No. q I - ~ III ) w;th;n twenty (20) doy' aft.. ,
. appell..(,).
f rule or suffer entry of judgment of non pros..
-----:
( -
;."
RULE, To
Larry J. Runk
Name of .~llCc{s)
$Ign.3lure of appellant Of hIS attomey Of agent
WAI!~Lr'
(1) You ore notified that 0 rule is hereby entered upon you to file 0 complaint in thi, appeal within t'WCnty (20) days after the date of
service of this rule upon you by personal service or by certified or regi,tered mail.
(2) W yoo do not file 0 campla;nt w;lh;n th;, t;me. a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS Will BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU.
(3) The dote of ~rvice of thj, rule if service was by moil is the dote of mailing.
C}.f'L.
()
In''/IL ~'
Si[Tl8tIl9 01" or Deputy
Date: ()~ ,;2(.. 19q SO ,
''!,:
AOPC31.,?l\.(
COURT FILE TO BE FILED WITH PROTHONOTARY
1"," ,
,,\,11 :
() ~.o ("?
,- ~
-. :::J
"Tj C' n "
n, --< .;, ;=
~; ,"" en
': -,0
~D v' :~C)
~~~ '. -, -;::;:,
:::; c- ~(')
" (I r:' b01
~-:.~. -<
_.- ~
:.<i \0 ::<
r~
-("-
" ""
'" .."
.... "-
~
"'\ j
r "l
:::-\ -c
'\ - ."
\... ~\ '~
"'\ ~ ~
It
jyt
.f
.
"
I
~. '
J I
, .
\ .
..
,
,-
-\
,.
;;!
,
"
t
I;
I ;
f I
I
( ,
,
"
I
I
I
i
i
.
1,
.
,
,
,it:>
/.
,
, !
,~ \
I
I
i
r.
I'
t \
1 i,.o-.
r.~
1;
:-"'..?"i"'
COMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTYOF:_ CUMBERLAND ______~~__
I.A"'I I J.\l ~..,
09-2-01
(lJ fu...'e ~t()"
PAULA P. CORREAL
~",'" EAST WING . COURTHOUSE
1 COURTHOUSE SQUARE
CARLISLE, PA
,,,.,,".., {717 I 240.6564 17013 - 0000
ATTORNEY DEF PRIVATE
BEN WARNER, ATTORNEY
10 E HIGH ST
CARLISLE, PA 17013
NOTICE OF JUDGMENTITRANSCRIPT
CIVIL CASE
f'I.^INllff
'RUNK, LARRY J
254 E.NORTH ST.
CARLISLE, PA 17013
L
1.,")1 ...,o;JM;('''' :"
-,
.J
VS.
IJUBWMJT
'LUCAS, GENE S
6 OAK LANE
MECHANI CSBURG,
L
Dockol No.: CV- 0000366 -98
Date Filed: 7/28/98
~,M"L ,1",IA'iOflj ',',
-1
PA 17055
.J
..
THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT:
Judgment: JOR...FLAINTTFF
[iJ Judgment was entered for: (Name) R1'1m(. T.l\RRV .T
[iJ Judgment was entered against: (Name) T.TT~l\g, c:lF.NF. fl
~ ~ ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BY FILING A NOTICE
~ OF APPEAL WITH THE PROTHONOTARY/CLERK OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, CIVIL DIVISION, YOU
MUST INCLUDE A COPY OF THIS NOTICE OF JUDGMENTITRANSCRIPT.FORM WITH YOUR NOTICE OF APPEAL,
,.' /~,. j'
,,/ ./ f {. .
/" ..':.. tf f." .' ..i I' ..:..-
.:.,L: ..~ ' \
I certify that this is a true and correct co~ of the record of the proceedings containing the jUdgment.
. , . .' Date,... ./~ . i .. /.- ,... ,... ........ , .. .f../ . District Justice
" "'':'1 ~~. , "'. ',' '\
My commission expires first Monday of January. 2000 SEi.)L
in the amount of $
~ 07'1 RO on:
D Defendants are jointly and severally liable.
D Damages will be assessed on:
D This case dismissed without prejudice,
D Amount of Judgment Subject to
AtlachmenVAct 5 of 1996 $
D Levy is stayed for _ days or D generally stayed.
D Objection to levy has been filed and hearing will be held:
1'-'
-~ Time:
~ ","
:JJ~ !i /')B
Date
,
\
,
AOPC 31 S-96
(Date of Judgment)
Q/?R/QR
(Date & Time)
Amount of Judgment
Judgment Costs
Interest on Judgment
Attorney Fees
Totat
$ 3.014.80
$ 65.00
$ .00
$ .00
$ 3.079.80
Post Judgment Credits
Post Judgment Costs
$
$
------..-----
------------
Certified Judgment Total $
. District Justice
IALlH Of ,....IY,VANIA
;..6 ... COUll Of COMMON ;L'..I
'ii VB I,
NOKIA'D"'.'C'
NOTICE 0' APPEAL
fROM J" -.:J(,. .9f"
DISTIlICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMON ..... No. If F. (,,1/ I {<'" L-Lr=-
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Nolie. is given 'hot the oppttIlool hen f.I.d '" the ubo"p COUl't of Common Plea. on orp&ol from th& judgm&nl r&ndefed by the OI.trict JuShC. on the
datw ard in tho (cue mont.".,d below.
HAMI 01 ","U.ANl
\ ;"'[1,' '. . .Il< '.
ADOlf>> Of UPlUANl
"6iY
IM~MTNO'OlHA""rJt'ij "._-~'_.-.'--
----- ~Sfl.rr_--..-~".------.--~..--T~
() l)dJ{ [""111.'
:t-'
9/ ~~d/r'Jt)
NO
ell U-iT.....,,,-- - ---- -- --------------
IT 19 --'--:_--"-- ---- -lOC...Mrn....lUz,'OIii>i"oo"'y"'..dr.i-
CV 19. \J;ji;il
This block wiD be signed ONLY when thjs notafion is required under Pa. R.CP.JP. No.
10088.
This Notice of Appeal. when received by the District Justice. will operote as 0
SUPERSEDEAS to the judgment fOf pone,sKln in thi, COle.
1""
IL' )
~I[~."~I
Sl!JfIature 01 Prothonotary Of Deputy
If appellant was CLAIMANT (see Pa_ R.C'p,J.P. No.
1001 (6) in action belore District Justice, he MUST
FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after
liling his NOTICE at APPEAL.
Name 01 <1~llac(s)
, appellee{'l. to file a complaint in this oppeO
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
(This section o//oon to be used ONLY when appellanl was DEFENDANT Isee Pa. R.GPJP No_ 1001(7) in aclion be/ore Dis~icl Justice_
IF NOT USED. detach Irom cC\Oy 01 nolice 01 appeal 10 be served upon appellee).
PRAECIPE, To Prothonotary
Enter rule upon
[-'C::.rL'j . i.. \:1 l:~
(Common Plea. No.
q ; - (, I I I
) within twenty {20j days after service of rule or suffer entry of judgment of non pros.
it
&gnarure 01 aweUanI 01 hIS ottomoy or agent j','
RULE, To
f....J..rrv J. :ll,;~':
Name 01 awe/Ice( s}
, oppellee('I.
':'.'1'. I I ,-
(1) You are notified thot a rule is hereby entered upon you to file a complaint in this appeal within twenty (20) days after the date of
service of this rule upon you by personal service or by certified or registered mail
(2) K you do not file 0 complaint within this time. 0 JUDGMENT OF NON PROS Will BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
(3) The dote of service of this rule if service was by moil is the date of mailing.
Dote: (hr.:/e.<_)I" . 19q r,
''":.
<.. " I
I I
(,
)h , /1". A i)"T,- ,
.Si~oI'Pro!Jfoi>cbfY",_ !I
Ii
i
I'
I'
i'
I
I
"
i
,
....
..
--
"
".."....,.....
N:JPC 31;2.80(
COURT FILE
,
I
I'.
.
,
,
,.~
. " ":<.1
rnoor OF SEI1VICf Of NOlie! Oi t,P!'"AL MID nUL[: TO FILE COMPLAINT
1'f/I"'I,IIi'lll'"
. ,',./'
,j ,,;.
. or,' .,"''':'''.'1'1
COMMONWEALTH Of PI: ~lN",n_'a,'Jif.
COUNTYQF ~
AFFIDAVIT: I'''',t,.,
"/. ;\ ':1,\, ,"~ :r,l'
(If.a,} ":1 !,'J(/I
',....,.,
qg-(oIJ \ ., ',. I. .'J"""": """,.,,, ""
t.a.rry'::J' .'P;uh~" "".:,; :':',";''': :[":Ji':,~
"Xil',. '.'''!:''\:,1, ('-(1-,",' ,j, r~ ,l:1 .~'I;',:j"" if,\'I"I': .lll,l, tlqd tH~rpto
;': cd6ttr ~11Iqq8'
~bu~l :.Q~
X <lfi-j lurrtwr th,lt! :,;r,\,; 1: ",.[...~.~(~.r ':i1:1"~
lh,_' fi,'.''': 'Iod' ;nl ;,,' >"~ \..A,;lU.J.,ILI ~
.."
. '! ~.,' r " .
".,r:<"!'l,,, ';'h:) .1: ",,"J
'"10 ~,', ;.r
. ')! /,; 'f"';" i,. )" 0 ." .11'1l" Il"~~~,) If) whom
(:,<1' ',,".' ..XIII" 'rL''''di l"':ll:'tl.~redJ
I"Llli. '.,' h'\" r.", ..,. . ,," '. '
swonr~ (}\r:4tl:~F:" i\"dJ :~'_j[\::r:!";;:;
THIS _Q.l_ . .. L;,\{ ,.i Oeioblf
~rA.\'Ah If
jf(jjJaEt:PiJJ/tr- .. .
f,tliJC,~~::::l-
qg
/3L..t'"..;...TliL.~-_._n_-
I) ,"li;II'17{J({' of affl,lrH
Notanal Seal
Denise L. Nye. Notary Public
Carlisle 8oro. Cumbe~IBnd County
My Commission Expires Feb. 26. 2001
Member. Pennsylvenla Association 01 Nola,les
',Ii (.'Tr,r;!:~', " ...;
(") '" 0
S 0:> 'n
~.. 0 =r!:IJ
-oC:J n
n1r.-\ .... 111.-
z:n f') ."m
2"- 66
en4C; -'
?b .'-' .
<: ,.. ::r::B
ZO - 9,0
<~o e -m
:l"c; S
Z r..J ~
~ -'
k. PI..inlliT agrcl'd Ih," I kklll'.1I11 llluld lIlaJ..c p"YlIlcnh 1111 lhc sollll hili 10'
!
]
i'
scrVlcc; 11I1I'l'ver, alier lIlaJ..lIl): p.ull.II p.l\nll'nh Illlalnl!! SIl.I7S SJ, IkJi:ndant ccascd
I). Dcfcnda11l has a halancl' 11\\ ing lln his hill \\hich hc rcfuscd tll pay.
~.
i
l1lakmg paYl1ll'IIIS.
WHEREFORE, PI..iniiff rcqucsls judgmcnl against Dcfend..nt in Ihc amounl of
$J,O 14.S0 togcthcr ",iih filing fccs and servicc costs tolaling $(15.00, plus inlcrcsl alld
..Homcy Ices.
Respeclfully suhmilled.
~h 0, Bu -Icy, EsqUIre
Atlomey for the PI..inti ff
10 /I 38444
1237 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-2448
-
,.....
I. \JJI\~11.J a.J fIV'Trl~ I j, c.~ OIl ~{"itl.. (:\}t.~ '3::JX> (ll.1~
\Jl.U 'ff'O..;.;2: \ :l,ll\<.>.1 \;:-~'tl\le:) A ~.....tl'Q...;\: (\t~~Ii'4 tvt.ul.l.ll ~ \tJCJSi2-&
~~ CNi.y , I ." 1\ d""v\ , 'l ....~".;:: .... .......
A1 lCOO~i.it.Ll':'Wh,1 t"\({c~ ~1 ~.w~ ESTIMATE
2. ~~ ^~~.} Mt-l.I.AI~ nA.,( .\:." rx. ""~t..e., . ( F REPJ IRS
1rr\\\6 \\~ C),( M. U!J\( (\ I. ..G,-j J. 'liI~~1
l-"~"'" ...n
~ ",. _F. uc;;;......"II.II... F'"Jl"'.'j".'." .... ..",,.,, ....
U2_ (..,.1:1- .'-. .
..,"'..... ."....c'o. ,Hon"
MCt".
I....,....
.....".... ..,
..,.".-~
\jv)
PAnTS
LA.O" PAIHT
AMOUNT ...MOHNT
TOTA\"
"'MouNT
art.
DaBCRIPTION or nEPAlntJ AND nl!PLACI!:MI!NTII
ttUM_I" AMOUN'
" \~b"~,,:,:.-~'-I~\j:.:y..I\"<>'1 \)..,~~I\P- '"
l\..\<W \ \Ie) -."AUJ,,:::I.' (OMr.r,*J I J
, "
\. J).,' \1)f\'('.' n .~ 1'\ 1\<,,>'-1,
\)..)- D\\('('\D "",<lfn+-
\.v Ii'\ .('I'..~ r,~iJ) -(ro,lf'. (\, 1('1\0 f\1I1'r".A<.Jli::'1
I\'lY\ilat\ ~ \:t '- /
('\ukh~i+
~\~. l.l\O
^\
'M-?S
144:iS tv'r
-.I\-. D~
t{l\()t-..,'I'-I ~ \-~
.". ,Lo ('flU 'let-- f~\/1f~f~'A~~~M'b\
.o1(,~U~ \ - ~"L f(\QO
_Cb.. tt, "'\-\t.v...~ (}J1~ ,f:t'dtl_ .
C)\~ fll{fL
4- ats. f' '/\ <..i 120.-... 'l.r\ I Q') 6\ l
I!-~ \, 1\..- ~P.o070
~ CtJ'), iliA\..RJ..
^\~ ti~
{:"f\, l.02J.Q Sk 'Y:
t')... S<' I
f-A. ')...I+~
C\ <;r,
(-1\. 'S:D
I-"lW
TOTALS
INSURED rAYS I INS. co. PAYS
INS. CHECK PAYAIlE TO
l, O. No_
lAX
1"~ ......\:... ..11....'.,.........." ltI.lttdJ.II ,lid d~11lO1 e~' ,ddlll...1 p.," Ir I.bof ~
::~. .0'. ~.he4..... 'ill _,t h. bH. .",tld. All" _,It tin lI.,t,d, I.' _'11 b"'''~~ JIleK ·
II ~ ..."" .Ilkll "II t1lto'l""cI ,lid .,. ..I ...Id..t .. filii M,"CU", .. N"IV" Ih, ElYle
.~~ ;;.~.I"'h .,IIM." ..., .~,. 'u.... .11"1' Ih .~ IIfle.. .r. ...1 ,"""M" ..d
.. _.e. IKC"'." ..I,. All ...,.tl... .. ..rtl 0,", I.... .,. c.,...... ..41 M\.lect
ITOu.ot C....S
<00 Q9
EST. "'ME IV TOT A L 0 F
ISTIIoIATI
&UIBOIllAftDJI re......... ,.......,...... .....al aM............. "1M............
SIGNEt>(.
M~
Exhibit "A"
4,-1(.1'
~.f.,wl~J-tilo~ r1.(.U
~~~J- p.....~. nl.~"") -,rl-b\ LJ(.f_
Alc s....it-d'\- f,,'l,,\ ,,'C: U.S
\'-A.\TI\1t ,,,,,,,,,,"",,M> Ih".l"
~ (la.,<;,,~ <:A. \).Sb - 'n,(>.J
bll'i53 ~dld\-S
I 0 uO ,(\0 ~\ !i' ,~-~(. .
"lIT He Of' .HI~
'Slig f')~ ^
_ ('" UO. o.-'-,lj,<H3'11, v.~tIVI5" ESTIMATE
J
"7 ,S"5 fJ:J/d~q-I~'7G OF REPAIRS
f
I
I
I: .
f
'.
i.'
(
I'
f
,,"'.. -I "';0.... .."
...". .. ..,. I~ I~'. &'f1:. I Lr':I"" 11II"."" ..'''"...... I..'....... ....""....
\)vJ
....v......, IA'lye,.. I"....env.. I :::~.
"0"1
.....
O..cAI..T10H or nl:,..AlnS AHD nll!:PLACI!:MENTI!I PI,nrB LA.O" ""'N" TOTAl..
Qn, HUM_." AMOUNT ""OUttT ...MOUNT _..au,,"
llJlt:ba... ~~ A.<.><u, 0.., ')~ ~'2.. ~ l)'~ Sf.,
t,' \J::of. 'IA...... /~ '5<1. ~ fd )V ~
~ l'$1tl 'O,;:IDL. (\ ......" ,,\ ~ ~ C IJ...~ 0:>
("""L",\ -, lVI -,
(' I"\i \ ~ '\:2- c.. q?-. 51.-
f...c.. , \vi 4-JJ
~~ U,o.\\ D~~ ~w'l*ch A::b qs c... sc::;
f\'+, ~\-\-' '1 ~ ~, 1:9
.~ r .oM I? tK'S Ic-"~ 14-W\...":, -\-ir do. FA, ,/'VI t:7r. \"L ~ ~2J. (d;>
., ...L. \~ '""'1...."1,, l1?iA ffiJ. g, tv,., J2.. 0> -~ 0:>
I- - -
, , ~~ . \4'-~:",^ \ 'I :::,( ) , ~
," ,~ ' I
d , ~ \J-. dfl
\;\:-e A~u.<;-\-tL ~HO. E:^, "In'
I--
~ \{- cr '5CliVJJ HI 'S i.P -\..0 JJ?
d- H.-U "5 ct.V-v 6~' S c>-=> '^ '"V-..
B.o \-t I" - .11 -,
~Ii to lS 10 12
\'\\ ,..d:, . I L .\:...ull \ 10 \ :10
, . 4-"1 )<5
(' lu-\t1.. r Mo A~Sl.A . ;;l.~ ~S ),,0 :ov
.
~ ('\.1:'\ , fpo~ ~I\. '31 CO q~ cD
d-- ~ :s-\-d baA6~ f-~ ' ~q to ')2.- ~ \10 2-D
TOTALS -- ~
INSURED rAYS , INS. CO. PAYS R.O,No_
INS, CHECK rAYAlll TO TAX M-'l J3
'~-.. ~"..n""'1 ....~..... "'&Mclloll ."eI doe. 110' CGW, .ddllloll,l pllh 0' I,bot
.. 1M, NCt,h:;1:'tw '~ _, hi tt-. ...,I,d. All., __.rt ... .1,,.,.., '"' _'", brll'''~ WUClCU
., ~.. ~.... .. "I oiiiii "",."d ..... .,. .., ....14.111 .. 'Int 1'lP4ld~. .. N.O".' Ih~ IIIVIC.
tJt~t::.7* .... ..11.... ." ....,. 'Ice." ~r '111, .11. ,ben ,,,Ieu I,.", .."..INd,,'. -
C' .......,. ....,tl.u ....,. AU .._11II1 _ .. pull ...tI 1,_ I,. &II"..' .... .. I_d StcltAet C....S
EST. MADE IY /1 TOTAL OF ~gS3
I.UI'IOIlIAftD n. _ 1. In //// 15T1",,,n
,~aal' aM~"'" '-... _..........
"I
"
f
r'
~
h
Ii
, ,
! I
i
r
I
\
!
OA!")( ~!tJ/~/
y,;
..tan He.
or
-H."'"
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
. ,.:0.... .
...... ~ LucAs '1: I ~-llb
."'.....,..... IQ~ n.. I''''.... ...... FU;' _. I..'." .e. .,.."" ..e.
\JW I., t\~6'il
,...."f1...l' ".,U"'" '"'~'C'OIll I :~:".
MOM'
,....
D.SCRIPTION 0" nl!PAIR9 AND nEPl.AC!:MENTB I'AnTS LA.O" rAIH' TOTAL.
QN, HUJ.4.... AMOUN' AMOUNT AMOllNT AMOUNT
I C)l1.O \r..M ClI.Al MIlD ( r.. ul) <l-
I C''''^" "'0 "i l .- f'1 (ftl- I
;t- T r-il\ '2.01<1) r;,\ - f-
.,-ql'\ c=-A. ') l:12 I-- 9- E!
--. -
\ OIl flh 4
w n ~ \2-
-
In). ~G-. t(\,~A - 'lNluLI\' l AMmUf p 1/> I~
'\ J\.~ - ky) e
~
I - --
- -.-. ..-
-- - - - - - -- -
Ifv\ \ l..f-A ~ -- nnoq /(...,
If - -
- - - - -
-
.
1- - -
~ -
/
INSURED MYS I INS, CO, PAYS R. O. No_ TOTALS -<"4 2-
INS. CHECK MYAILE TO 'AX .2. 0,
~, :beorti t:." .tlIIII.I" .....d ., 0" IlUPlClIOI ud dM' flO' C'_' .ddlll.II.' p"lt or I,bo,
~ M., ,...hld I tM 'N ..,. ".. b... dlfl.d. All., -"0" ".. II..'.". u, ."', b,.ha~ Walen. "
iN ~'" pori. ...hldl '" ..11Ch'."d .1Id .1lI .01 hid..., .. Ihd IltpOdlOl. _ ,.."...... I~ IllY Ie.
'10:1:': I"" "Ii'..... br ,.,..r. ..c.... ~' Ihl. I.. .bow I:lIlc.. '" ..I ,."..,..d,,'
t;. .... "I.t. 1C'....,1Ce ell". All ...1.1 .... .. p.ri. ,Id I.bor '" .."...1 ud ... I.d -
ITOlAClt Cke's
EST. "'ADE BY TOTAL OF 3-b~
ESTlI<IATI
AunolllAl'lOK .11I.1.. .. ...... UtI ......,.uw rttdrt.. eM CIf..... ....
o
s
a.....>
5
SIGNEDjiIi;~
,
DATI:
cr I'~J f}fo
VEnlF/CATION
I, LARRY .I. RlINK, Ihe Plairllil"i' in this aCiioll, vcrily (hal I have read Ihe
I<m:going Complainl and io Ihe best oj' my knowledge. inlimllaiion alld belief (he
slatements madc therein arc true and correct.
I undersland Ihat Ihe stalements made herein arc subjccl 10 the provisions and
penalties or 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904 relaling to unsworn ralsifications to authorities.
Date:
}/-b--1 ~
~/ /_~T7
-~--~,_._----
Larry J. Runk
n:IlTlFI(',\TE OF SEIH'ICE
II IS herd,)' rl'lIi1il'lllh"l " IIl1l' "1I11 wrrl'rl ropy 01" Ihe i,'regoillg Complailll was
servell vi" lirsl ria." III"", po,I"gr IHl'p""i. "tlllrl'"e" "s ",I lows:
BellJamln T. Warner, Esquire
Marlsoll. I)earllorl'!:Williallls & 0110
10 Easl "igh Streel
Carlisle. PA 17013
(Allorne)' I"or Defendant)
Dale: 11- ~ - '11'
\l, t~.
Joseph D. Buckle. Esquire
I.AI{I{Y.I I{I \;K.
I'I.II11IIr1
" IIII' ('()i:RI 01. (,()\1\10\; I'I.I'!\S OF
('I.\IIlI'I{I.A~1J (,OI'\;'Y, 1'1':,\:--iSYI.VA\;IA
\.
\;()')S.lilll ('IVII.
(il"I.. S. II '('..\S,
Ikklldallt
REI'L Y TO NEW "lATTER AND ANSWERTO COlll"TER('LAJi\lS
A~n ~o\V this ~I!i, day "f.lanuary, I'!'!'! cum~s I'laintill by and through his
allorn~y Jos~pb n. Iluckky, I's"uir~ and a\~rs tb~ following:
REI'LYJO.NEJ'LMAIIER
,\J' ElRMA.TlYEJ).EEENSE..:.ERAW2
11. Spc~ilically dcni~d. Dcfcndant told Plaintiff tbat hc wantcd his cnginc b~
rcplac~d with an ~ngin~ from thc Volkswagcn tilctory which had a Volkswagcn warranty
and not a "junk yard" cnginc. Plaintiff was instructcd to procurc a lilctory cnginc which
carricd a Volkswagcn warranty Ii-om thc Volkswagcn dcalcr.
12. Spccilically dcnicd. Dcfcndant dircct~d Plaintiff to procurc for him a factory
cnginc from Volkswagcn, through a local dcalcr, and not to us~ a "junk yard" cnginc.
13. Admillcd.
14. Dcnicd as statcd. Plaintiff purchascd thc only factory cnginc produccd and
sold by and available from Volkswagcn whicb carricd a wan-aniy for thc makc, modcl
and year of vehicle owncd by Dcfcndant as dircctcd by Dcfcndant. Thc cnginc was
shippcd in a crate fromihc faciory and carricd a standard Volkswagcn wan-anty, Plaintiff
has no knowlcdgc as to what Volkswagcn does at its factory or what it did to thc cnginc
he rcccivcd; howcver, upon inspcction, the cnginc appcarcd to havc all ncw paris and
appcarcd to bc a new moior.
15, Spceifically dcnicd. Plaintiff believed he had rcccived exactly what
Defcndant bad requcstcd he purehasc for him, that bcing a ncw lilctory cngine,
Iln IllisrqlrL'SL'lllalil)ll.
\\'1 II'RI'f'(l/{I'., !'lalllllllrl'qllcsls Ihis I 10111 lIahie' (."11I1.1"'"1" Ikklld.I/II', ..1.11111
:\:--;S\\'EH TO (,OLXIEHn,\I.\1
('OlXI JI - \\'IW:--;liITL ('O:--;\'ERSJO:--; OJ U 1.\ II /;1.
2(\ PL.tilltllf;1I1S\\'LTS 1I1l':-'i.: pllldgraphs tiS hl' l1t1s ahtJ\l'
cnginc with a nell' engine as opposcd to a rcmanUI;Il"IUrcd, uscd or rchuili l'uginc.
Dcfcndant's \'chicle. hut denicd thal Ikli:ndant inslruCkd hlln to rl'pl,,,.c the onglnal
n. Admillcd in pari, dcnicd in pari. It is ;Illmlllcd Illill !'lail/tllllllCkcd np
and ordcr a lilctory cnginc which would hc warrantcd hy Volkswagcn.
Dd<:ndant's spccilic insiructionio PlaintilTwas that Plail/tillwas 10 wnlacl Volkswagcn
to disposc ofthc samc.
28. Dcnicd. PlaintilTproni:rcd thc damagcd paris 10 Ddi:ndanlwho told PlainlilT
Deli:ndantthat duc to the block of Dcfcndant's cnginc haling a holc in ils sidc whcre a
Delcndant who told PJainliffto dispose oflhe same. It is admilled thai Plainliffinl,mncd
29. Dcnied. Plainlil'/' proffcrcd the damaged parts and thc "hlolln" Cllginc 10
Volkswagen prior to obtaining the I;lelory enginc.
rod had been thrown thai it could not be used as a "corc" exchangc rcquircd by
30. Admitted.
31. Admitted.
"blown."
32. Denied. Defendant's engine could not he uscd as a "corc" cxchange as it was
falsity or suhstance of this avermenl and demands speeilie proofihereoJ:
33. Alier a reasonahle investigation, Plaintiff is unahle to ascertain the truth,
Plaintiff dispose of the same.
34. Denied. Plaintiff proffered the used paris to Defcndant who requesled
lor wrongful conversion of chattel.
WHEREFORE, PJaintiffrequesiS this Honorable Court dismiss Defcndant's claim
CEIU/J,'ICHE OF :sun In:
II is Ii":!"l'h.\' c\.'rlll;l'll 1l1al ;1 Inll' ;1I1t! COIH.'rl l'tIP.\ Ill" till' liJlq~t)III~I. Hepl.\' III \'l'\\
;lddrl......"L'd .1..... Jpllll\\....
\lath..'1 ;ll1d .'\II:"\\l'l III ('tlll!lll'lcl;lIl11\ \\<1.... \l'/'\l'd \ 1;\ li"'l cb;-.... 111;\11. P{l.....ltI!~1' Pll'p.lld.
Iknl'"l1il T. lI'arnel. hqllllc'
\lansoll, Ikaldnlrr. 1I',II,all" eX (Jlln
III 1'::lSllIigh SIIWI
('allisk,I'A 1701.1
(Allnrney Il,,' Dcli:ndalll)
Date: /
I. "',
i
\
I
,( '. I / I
j'/t I I /
J ! '11 I.',
~' _ L ~/.
Joseph 1>. /lllcklcy, I'sqllire
. .
. . ....
. . \,' . I
-- . . '
.. -
- .
.~
~:-
",'-~
;' :;."
-,,'
:c:
:,1
ro,:
,":
.'. ",,'
'~ ". ,. .: '
.... ,'->
,J' "
i ~~ i ,.,".'
,"i'
i.
, '
.,
.\;
.'.\
...."
. . '.:,~'~\.:;:?Yt~lff:
""
, . .1';111'
'~i!iC"
"-,.,,...,' '",.: .
.' ,.,.~'.:.~ .:\~9, ;i
", '" "~'\' l
, ',. _ ~f~~'.1;
._ , c",;.,-;~~ ,,'
i,~~;t~r
"<., -.,:.,",i.'
:~'~'. . '.- ~ >'.,',
,....,
1 '1(;2 '16"/ 91.5
,i' '.'.,1: "'._.
,~e,ce.ipt for Certified M~"
[ , '. I, .' . ", t J'.l'. ~.. :
I,; ,I." ,
I Jr'_""'I' ('.1"",1
~
\
I i
/I..
j I
,
\
"
l,
'.
."
'd
~"':1'.1.,,'11,'
" ii'
~";( ~,~;,\:,,;:-""t'l.;..!
~~' , I 'I' I,"
.1_
I
/1 "
"
.t" I
I
S I
,
I
I
-,T.I'I'!
,"'d"o,jf,.,.
:,'l''''.ld: r",,~,.,,; f ,."
'n 1l'''':flr.1'~J~.,..r'';;'11!
~,
,,'
-'-1
.----.--..
..
Z u52 467 914
us Postal Service
Receipt for Certified Mail
No Insurance Coverage Provided
Do not use for International Mail See revorse
So')':'1 {/II/d;; ('{ I, I/Ii
SlreC!~llLJmbcr ({i';1 H:,'J1 ('< ';J-II!~'.I'/
I tt I I) ,<-_d_L. . ( l(ft I'
Post Oltlce, Slate, to ZIJ':Codc
((u Ii /(. 'Ji /7,: '12'
i 1
! I
I
I
I
,
\
'..~.
Poslago
s
Cer1lficdFce
Spcaal Delivery Fee
AcSllldcdDchvcryFec
on
C>
C>
.'
. ~.
I 1111 S ll~ 1 ,,111 I ,.1 '.1 . . 'N JI ~ 1: I'll ^ 1 ,II"
/',r.rr,ln\:toWr:rl>l:l'"
""1'~" .., ,~.... ,~ ,'. ',' ,....
~r ~l 1
LARRY J RUNK,
Plaintill'
IN TilE COURT OF CO~lMON PLEAS OF
CtlMBERLAND COtlNTY, PI'NNSYLVANIA
v
NO 'IX.hlll CIVIL
GENE S 1.1.IC AS,
Defendant
PRAECIPE
TO THE PROTHONOT,'.RY
Please mark this docket settled and discontinucd as to the Plaintiffs Complaint and lhe
Defendant's Counterclaim, with all costs paid, and with prejudice.
MARTSON DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO
BY:~
By:
Benjami . Warner. Esquire
Ten East High Street
Carlisle. P A 17013
(717) 243-3341
Joseph D. ckley,
1237 Holly Pike
Carlisle, P A 17013
(717) 249-2448
Attorney for Plaintiff
Attorney for Defendant
Datc: March 26. 1999
CEIU'IFlC\TE UF SEH\R'E
I, Dellise I. .\,\ c. 'III '''III'''IIIL'd ",:ellll(lI. \1;" Is II II Dl'oI,dll,11 \\'III""lIs <'< ()llll.I'I'lehy l'l'lli!)'
111'11 a L'llpy or Ihe 1(lIl',:lIill': l',al'l'lJlc' II "S Se, \ l.d Ihis dale hy dqlllsilillg S"lIle ill Ih,' I'lIsl Oml'e 'II
('arlisle, 1'..\, li,sl class lIlail. 1"lSla"e p'epaid, add,essl'll as fi,III1I1S:
Joseph D, Buekley, !'squire
1".17 Ilolly Pike
Carlisle, I'A 1711 13
i'vL\RTSO:s.i DEARDORFF WILLIAMS <'< OTTO
By /'/'.", '. ..! . i!
Deuise L. Nye
Tcn Easl II igl1 Streel
Carlisle, 1';\ 17013
(717) "4.1-.1.141
Datcd: April 12, 1999
"- r::c~c~~lr
c..:
r/l>
uJ>:: J
..J 'n
::J,...~ ;.,..
Z~. ".,.
OZ<
_"'..J
~o.. ,
?>,z I
Cf-C~
~~E
cc-::
E- U..J .',
0::0::-
::>z::::
o..:u
U..J
",0::
:X:'"
f-o:l
7:;;:
"-'::>
u
~~:.o
f;!
,,:~~
-! : '
-j ,
~'Q~
> I
-< .~
~f~'
"
:':;1
:::'
~
Z
:.:J
0::
r/l
-::
u
~
..J
vi
'"
'"',
'"
(J
~
- I
, ,- :J
'"
- ~
/ - "
" J. 0 ('":'
- ;; !....
-% /
-
~ - - 2
- -
, - - -
~ /
c >
.." ~ ~
^
v
UJ
~
-.; ;...
;..
0::
0::
of.
..J
.1
~ C> >-
~':;; c:: ,
I ;
,., -
lJj:-.
, i
" r :'\".: ~ ' ,
~.- I.J._ ,
r ~ , ~ . .1
.'
D 0J i.'J
LL
[j~ ! , c':: ,
'.:..1
r- eo , '"'
-..
u. -"
G m .:~"J
a' U
~ ,