HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-06170
1;
-g
,g;
r)
-)
Il
//
I
g
~
d
3
f
l-
~
J
I
0:
,.
---
...9
MI'.I.ANII: WAI.I.A(,I:.
IN IIIL CO{ 'IU 01 (O\l\ION 1'1 I,\S
('\1\llll.IlI.ANI)('OI'NI \ 1'1 NN"I \'\NIA
1'1.11111111
\'
NO 'IX 101711 ('1\/1 III~"
CIVIL AC liON
A\\
ElIGI:NI' WINGEIlT. II. alld \IAIlClA
SIIAlIllER, CII.bel'utll" of Ille
ESTATE OF 1l0lWTIIY WINGEIlT,
,
i!
Ilefelldalll
lllll), TRIAL 1lI'\lANIJI:1l
CElrnFlc,\TE PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE
OF ,\ SUIlPOE:-i,\ PURSlJA:-iT TO RULE 4009,22
As a prerequisite to scrvil:c of a subpoena for uocuments and thing'> pur~uant 10 Rule 4()()(),22.
Plaillliff eenilles Ihal:
(I) a notice of il1tcm 10 serve tlw suhpoena with a copy of Ihe suhpot.'lIa altadwd thereto was
mailed or delivered to c:l(;h party al Icas! [wellty days prior (0 the date 011 whid1 tlB: suhpol:na is sought
to be served;
(2)
certificate;
a copy of the notice of intcm. including the proposl.:d suhpoena, IS altadlcu 10 this
(3)
no objection to the suhpoena hus heen fl'ccivcd; ami
(4) the subpoella which will he se,ved is idelllicalto the subpoella which is allached 10 Ihe
notice of intent to serve tile suhpoena.
~ J
I
I
I
I
I
Respeclfully SUblllilled.
Dated: 430114
ANGINa & ROVNER, P.c.
/
^
/ "~
elJ' D C' . I' .
ames C Ill!!. :squln:
LD.I/77421
4503 North Frolll Street
Harrisburg. PA 17110
Allorney for Plaimiff
~-----
,
I
,
, I
i
14647J/SC
~"',
COW.\ONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
MEI.ANIE WM.I.AC!':, Plaint if I
v .
EUGENE wuua.:H'I', II, AND ~l^,W I A
SII^UDEH, Co-Executor!; of t tip
ESTNn: 01' I>()I~OTHY WIN(;EI<T
File No. 'JB - (>1 70
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22
TO: The Sentinel
(N.Jmc of Person or EntltYJ
Within twenty (20) days afte( service of tillS subpoena, you are ordered by the cour! to produce the following
documents or things:
Any and all photographs in your possession concerning an automobile
accident on July 23. 1997. on Route 944 (Wertzville Road), Hampden
Township, Cumberland County, involving Dorothy C. Wingert and
Melanie S. Wallace
at4503 North Front St'rp-p.:t, Hr'rr;~hl1rg Ph 17110
(Address)
You may deliver or mail legible copies of the documents 0' produce things requested by this subpoena. together
with the certificate of compliance, to the party making this request at the address listed above. You have the right
to seek in advance the reasonable cost of prepa,ing the copies or producing the things sought.
If you fail to produce the documents or things required by this subpoena within twenty (20) days after its service,
the party serving this subpoena may seek a court order compelling you to comply with it.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOLLOWING PERSON:
Name Jame~ DeCinti. Esquire
Addrnss: 4503 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
Telephone: 717 -23 8- 6 791
Supreme Court ID #
77421
Attorney For:
Plaintiff
BY THE COURT:
Date:
-1n<uuJv 'I /999
.
Seal of the Court
Prothonotar CI rk, Civil Division
C)....'''. C. I1.Ldl~~
I
Deputy
(Eff. 7/97)
...' - .....
I:: C'_ t -
:_1' c'.~ !.:-
,.
"-
~:, ,-.I... 1<1
, (i:
, ('J ;
r'-: u ":1
L -. .I(L
, '.:" -'
C' ....' U
the wlllrary. :\1-.. Wallace herehy incorporales her answer to para~raph ~:\ 'IS Ihon~h the "'l11e
were fully scl forth herein at Icn~lh.
27. Iknied. :\1-.. Wallace b advisl'd hy wunscl and Ihcrclore avers Ihal Ihe
allegalions ,olllaillL'd in p;II'a['raph 27 state wnclusions of law to which uo reply is required.
To Ihe extent a runher reply is required. Ihe aVCrll1euls wnlained in paragraph 27 are denied
pursuant 10 I'a. R.CI'. 1029(e).
2X. Denied. Ms. Wallace IS advised hy wunscl and therefore avers Ihat Ihe
allegalions wutained in paragraph 2X stale conclusions of law to which no reply is required.
To Ihe extent a runher reply is required, Ihe averments wntained in paragraph 2X are denied
pursuant to l'a.R.C.P. 1029(e).
29. Denied. Ms. Wallace IS advised hy counscl and Iherel()re avers thai the
allegations eonlained in paragraph 29 state conclusions of law to which no reply is required.
To Ihe extent a rurther reply is required, Ihe averments contained in paragraph 29 are denied
pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(e). By way of funher answer, after reasonahle invesligalion, Ms,
Wallace is wilhout knowledge or information suflicient to form a belief as 10 Ihe truth of the
avermenls contained in paragraph 29, and the same is Ihererore denied.
30. Denied. Ms. Wallace is advised by counsel and therel(lre avers Ihat the
allegations contained in paragraph 30 state conclusions of law to which no reply is required.
To the extent a further reply is required, the avermenlS contained in paragraph 30 arc denied
pursuanlto Pa.R.C.P. 1029(e). By way of further answer, after reasonable investigation, Ms.
Wallace is without knowledge or information suft1cicnt to form a belief as to the truth of the
averments contained in paragraph 30, and the same is Iherefore denied.
31. l)cni~d. Ms. Wa";l~~ is advi"d hy ~'lllllsel and Iher~li)r~ a\'~I'S Ihat Ih~
all~~alioJ1S conlain~d in parawaph .1 1 .slal~ conclusions or law 10 which no r~ply is r~quir~d.
To tlw e.\l~nl a runhn reply is r~quirl'd. Ih~ awrlll~nts wlllain~d in para~raph .1 1 ar~ d~ni~d
pursualll 10 !'a.R.C.!'. 102lJ(c). fly way or runh~r answer, alkr r~a"")ahJ~ inv~sli~ation, Ms.
Walla~e is wilhout knowlcd~e or inli1rlllation suftici~nl 10 lill'll1 a helief as to Ih~ Inuh or Ih~
avenll~nls cOlllain~d in paragraph .11. and Ih~ salll~ is th~r~lilr~ d~llI~d.
.12. Deni~d. Ms. Walla~e is advis~d hy wunsel and th~relilre avers Ihat Ih~
allegalions wntain~d in paragraph 32 stale wnclusions or law to whj~h llO reply is requjr~d.
To the extelll a runher reply is r~quir~d, the averm~I1IS ~olllained in paragraph 32 are d~ni~d
pursualll to Pa.R.C.P. I029(~). By way or runher answer, arler reasonable investigation, Ms.
Wallac~ is wilhout knowl~dge or inllll'll1ation sufticielll 10 rorm a helieI' as 10 the trulh or the
averm~nts ~ol1lained in paragraph 32, and Ihe sam~ is Ihererore d~ni~d.
WHEREFORE, Melanie Walla~e demands judgment in her ravor and against
Derendanls, without costs.
COUNT" - SURVIVAL ACTION
33. Denied. Ms. Walla~e hereby incorporales her responses 10 paragraphs 19
through 32 as though Ihe same were fully sel fonh herein at lenglh.
34. Denied. Ms. Wallace is advised by counsel and therefore avers that Ihe
allegations contained in paragraph 34 state conclusions or law to which no reply is required.
To the eXlent a further reply is required, the averments ~onlained in paragraph 34 are denied
pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(e). By way of runher answer, after reasonable investigation, Ms,
n:IUFI(''\TJO:-i
I hcrchy afrirmthalthc followin~ racls arc corrccl:
Mclanic Wallacc. is a Plaintiff inthc forc~oin~ acti"n. Thc allachcd Rcply ofPlaintirf.
Melanic Wallacc to Dcfcnd,nm' Answcr with Ncw Mallcr to Plaintilrs Complaint and
Crossclaim is hascd upon information which I havc furnishcd to my counscl and inrormation
which has hccn galhcrcd hy my counscl in p'cparation IiJr Ihis lawsuit. Thc languagc of thc
Rcply or Plaintiff. Melanic Wallacc to Dcfcndants' Answer wilh New Maller to Plaintiff's
Complaint and Crossclaim is that or counsel and not of me. I have read the Reply of Plaintiff.
Melanic Wallace to Defendants' Answer with New Maller to Plaintiff's Complaint and
Crossclaim and to the exlenl that Ihe Reply or Plaintifr. Melanic Wallace to Defendants'
Answer wilh New Maller to Plaintirf's Complaint and Crossclaim is bascd upon inrormation
which I have given to my counsel, it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge.
information and bclief. To the extenl Ihat the contcnt of the Reply of Plaintiff, Melanie
Wallace to Defendants' Answer with New Maller to Plaintiff's Complainl and Crossclaim is
that of counsel, I have relied upon counsel in making this verification. I hereby acknowledge
thai the facts set forth in thc aforesaid Rcply of Plaintiff. Melanic Wallace to Defendants'
Answer with New Maller to Plaintiff's Complaint and Crossclaim is made subjcct to the
penaltics of 18 Pa.C.S. 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Dated: 01/1 /I',.i leS 'V(}rj
.
i/)1.1 . ) II'
" ,J/'!I;" v I II Ii ,,,I',
Melanic Wallace
t'I,;g]IE.!l:"\TIU1I,::'}:ifltV IJ.:.t~
IIIEREBY CERTIFY Ihal a true alld wneet wpy of the rore!!oill!! Plaintiff's Rcply to
1Ilcw i\lallcl' of Ilcfcndants and Plaintiff's Anslll'l' to Countcl'dailll of Dcfcndants has
heen duly served upon all wllnsel or rewru ami parties or inleresl hy deposiling Ihe same ill
the United SlaWS mail. firsl class. poslage prepaid. in lIarrishurg, Pennsylvania. on Ihis
~." iI/: I; ;
L~ 'L 11 uayor I,'I.! /, 'I'
, 1999, auuressed as rollo\Vs:
James DeCinti, Esquire
Angino & Rovner
4503 Nonh Front Street
Harrishurg. P A 17110-1708
(Co-Counsel for Plainlifl)
George B. Faller. Jr.. Esquire
Manson Dearuorff Williams & 0110
Ten East High Slreet
Carlisle. PA 17013
(Counsel for Defenuants)
PETERS & W ASILEFSKI
,/~ ;. /J;
/('<c'//;'f". A, ;-Ic~,.:t(.l'>C
Evonne K. Hoover
r'.ELAN I E WALLACE,
jj; Till': r'()\Ii(j" \Jl: I" :'~>~'):: I':J!':^~;
('i:;:':Hi';i~ I.J\Ni) ('; )\;::':"{ i '1':::::;;YI,Vl\N I ^
Pl"illtiff
NC>, 'IH "')1'/0 ('J'/;:' Tj';I~~'1
v.
crVI I, ACTION ' [,Avl
EUGENE WINGERT, II, dnd MARCIA:
SIIAUDER, CO-EXN:uton; of th"
ESTATE OF DoROTIIY viTW:EWI'
Defendant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE PREREOUISITE TO SERVICE OF A SUBPOENA
PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22
As a prerequisite to service of d subpoena for documents and
things pursuant to Rule 4009.22, Plaintiff certifies that:
1. a notice of intent to serve the subpoena with a copy of
the subpoena attacJled thereto was mailed or delivered to each party
at least twenty (20) days prior to the date of which the subpoena
is sought to be served;
2. a copy of the not ice of intent, including the proposed
subpoena, is attached to this certificate;
3. no objection to the subpoena has been received; and
4. the subpoena which will be served is identical to the
subpoena which is attached to the notice of intent to serve the
subpoena.
Respectfully submitted,
A}IGINO & ROVNER, P.C.
,~"q"i<'
I .D. # 77421
4503 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
Attorney for Plaintiff
if( UJfct<1
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
i, rll'~qdll ^. H,.iIldl'd, III "n:p!!)/"" (l: l\l1(lill' 'I HUVllt'l, jl,C'.,
hf.!I',~by cl~rtify Ch.ll ,I IlU" ,lfld ('(lft'.,(,! copy c,f th'_' 101'!.'quillq
CERTIFICATE PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE OF A SUBPOENA PURSUANT TO RULE
4009.22 wan nl't'vf~d, by llnit"rJ ~:tclt,,!: tir~,L.('ld:::; I!ldil, pO~Jtdql'
pn'pdid, upon tlv~ tolluwif\(I:
(;I.!orqe B. Fdl L,!t., ,Jr. I ;';;;'1111 t'(~
MdrtuoIl De(lniorff vii 11 i,H:l:, ,I( C)lLO
10 East High Street
Carliule, PA 17013
! ,
. ,
, ,
'l'l\l C\()(\ ((-t.li 1(1<1.1 r-/
Megan) A. Re ina rei
1/:; 1(1
Dennis Bonetti, E~;qll i r,.!
Peters & WasileEski
2931 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
. ,
, ,
I'
1
!
I
,
'.
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVA"',A
T COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
MELANIE WALLACE,Plaintiff
v.
EUGENE WINGERT, II, and MARCIA
SHAUDER, Co-Executors of the
ESTATE OF DOROTHY ~lINGERT
Frle No. 98-6170
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANTTO RULE 4009.22
TO: -Uamp4Gn-'J!Gwn~~~nt
(Name of Person or Enllly)
Within twenty (20) days after service of this subpoena, you are ordered by the court to produce the following
documents or things:
Any and all photographs in your possession concerning an automobile
accident on July 23, 1997, on Ruute 944 (Wertzville Road), Hampden
Township, Cumberland County, involving Dorothy C. Wingert and
Melan~e S. Wallace.
at 4503 North Front Street, Harrisburg, PA 17110
(Address)
You may deliver or mail legible copies of the documents or produce things requested by this subpoena, together
with the certificate of compliance, to the party making this request at the address listed above. You have the right
to seek in advance the reasonable cost of preparing the copies or producing the things sought.
If you fail to produce the documents or things required by this subpoena within twenty (20) days after its service,
the party serving this subpoena may seek a court order compelling you to comply with it.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OFTHE FOllOWING PERSON:
Name
,1.=tmp.~ npCinti F,!=iql1ire
Address: ..&501 North Front Street
H..rri!';hllrQ'. PA 17110
Telephone: 717-238-6791
Supreme Court 10 # 77 4 21
Attorney For: Plaintiff
Date:
BYTHE COURT:
(0aacJ" ;) fr" 19'!1.
Seal of the Court
Prothonotary/Clerk ivil Division
"- kJ Q.-y, (J , p, '1'f &7.'7-<'-r. r-
Deputy
(EfI.7/97)
...... _' _;'J.,.:
" -'~-'--""-"
:wjL;:f;-:U:,~S_'2':::::-':-.: ...____. ...... '-".-:-:./:::::=::.--:~:.c::::F::7,Sr[!;~.t~_ "'"<'~~~$~
::; ,,' :;~~~,;~}r::i~l!:;;~~i&~~~~
'\> ,.'i-c' 'r":'-\'''''.(~'~i~'''''ll-~~I\~'
, ''',' ,,..! :>-<':;:j, !.~~~,):t{'Vtr17~,,-f.~i~ '
1...., 7~ I~_ ""'1'?"~{I,.,~,.:.",:ti5/!Jt~t"''ii/'
. '.1 ", - ,- " :' ,.' . I ' ~ '''I "I" t y!"~l" ~ '{'ii'} ,
, ' ,'~ :"!'-1"{i;::tt~,tJ~ "~'
;!"'..,:;"H,.-!~'~",_'l1 "
'I.. '1' '."'.'..''';;',;' '~r':..j...J~l'.t'.fl'.~
",' :. ,". '-.;' :_.".A~". .':;....~.I',~.~
~N'''... .."n.:.... .. ." .. ':>:,:1t:~1.
IT~~:~'1'!~:~1}~~~;;~~~H:~~':, ~.. j' ~. ., i ':, ' '.'. ,-:' . ~ ", :~~~.~'~~,~.:(D:},:i~,~~t~i1~~~~'0~~
I.<.'."::(l"~,,,..,,!. '\,J \ " i' . J ,,"",' "1".'- .,...'t" r'r""",...~~,_.,.,,,r{rfJ!:tt,
.. .,,~g~~~~';];'~?",,:,.:"~; ':l:'~:~/!;:'!}<'}.N?,~1J~t~:~~i , ,
""!J'~'I:.~'~...;" .'.,", ," "', '11'"V f:.';";'..~;.'f-....,.,.i',tC'!tl;:~t
,,':)-':".. '(/>~ ,/,~. -p ,.I, ' ,',,:", :~ ~"~~!;'J~{..?[,l,IIJ~:r't:~fi~
'''''l~''c''!'''' ~ ,. ..'" 'I', ," ,,' " - -,,' .,.'...~ 'd. 'k'~~~~';S
\1[" />:. /;/;:1 ";. 1 ", '. , f"" q r ."; ....:>, '....,~:t~i:i/{-:'!!.,. :f';~
,:1.... "1',',". '~:~,,;.;'1~. ' ~,. ;', .},: ~ .l,,~:.,~....;/t ~ ......-:.--~~i1,
"!ll' ,,,,l, "" ~ - , , " , I~ ,\ ,~ " ,. .:" l .... ::) '"' 'i \
r;~:~'r iJ.....~-"J"".1-"'" ," 'i ' /("~"~~/" ~\.\ ,!,{, ',..:/,~t<,-.." ,
pt::"'~~:,")" ";'-;.,r;.,,'\, <,", \ ,<,{,lil,:\' "., ~,~ ,:;,' ,-!",';;:IJ,:rl'lr~~'
'l~;l~:'tt",u~;; '>1 /: .:J:;~, \ ,jrj.:j ~ - ( 1./,' , .:~ t.,:). ~'.; : . :c)"~i../.{ ;~,,:;!~{".-; Y.',/i.ktr.~t~:
~EJrI'lFJCATE OF SERVICE
IIIEREBY CERTIFY that a true am! eorrecl copy or Ihe lilregoing J'raccipc for En!Q'
of Appcllr:mcc has heen duly served upon all counselor record and parties or interest hy
deposiling the same in tile United SlaWs mail, first class, poslage prepaid. in lIarrishurg,
Pennsylvania, on Ihis '11/
day of )1((; u., /.~
, 1999, addressed as follows:
James DeCinti. Esquire
Angino & Rovner
4503 North Front Street
Harrisburg. P A 17110-1708
(Co-Counsel for Plainlift)
George B. Faller, Jr., Esquire
Martson Deardorff Williams & OllO
Ten East High Streel
Carlisle. PA 17013
(Counsel for Detendants)
PETERS & W ASILEFSKI
;:/.~" '.'
(./"'"::/,/1',..........--
Evonne K. Hoover
)'. /4"""
_' /7<-',_v-e--<-
11111\1'\1\111111'\\1"" ".,.
1,,,,,.1 III ,.; ;';'\\1
~" ",..1 I: ' " 1'\1
, "';1
MELANIE \\'AII..'\( '1'.
Plailllllf
1'1111- ('01 '!U O! ('0\1\10' Pllol\S OF
('('\lIlIRI ..\ '\Il ('()(':\ I Y. PI':\:\SYI.\',\"A
\'.
('1\11 A( '110' . I .\ \\.
:\1) 'JS,t>l711 ('I\'IIIII~\1
H)(iENI: W!!':(iER I, II, ,111<1 \L\I{( '1..\
SIIAl!DER, Co.h~~ulors lIflh~
!OS rATE OF DOIWlIlY WI,\( il'ln.
Ikli:lldallls
.II'RY IRI.-\1 OI'l \HIVE D!:\lANDED
VEFI::;:'IiVA:\TS' A;:'IiSWER WITIl :\1:: W :'IATTER
TOl'LAl:\T1F1".s,CO~ll'L\1:\T ,\l'iV COl1l'iTEHCL,\1M
TO: MELANIE WALLACE. I'lailllilT, alld her allonwy, JAMES IkCINTI. ESQUIRE
YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED TO FILE A WIUTTEN RESPONSE TO TilE
ENCLOSED NEW i\IATTER WITIIIN TWENTY (20) IlA YS FRO;'.I SERVICE HEREOF
OR A JUDGMENT i\IA Y BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU.
I. Admill~d has~d 011 inllJrlllatioll r~~~il'~d.
2-3. Admill~d.
4. An~r r~asollabl~ illl'cstigalion. Ihc D~rclldant is without knowledgc or inlunnatioll
suflicicntto form a bclicfas to thc truth or "llsity ofth~ al'~rm~nts conlain~d in this paragraph. Thc
avcrmcnts arc thcrcrorc dc~med denied and praor is d~mand~d.
5. Admillcd.
6-18. Dcnicd pursuant to Pa. R.C.p. 1029(c).
WHEREfORE, Dcfendants demand judgmcnt in their Illl'or and dismissal of PlaintiWs
Complainl with prejudice.
NEW MATTER
19. Thc avemlcnts contained in paragraphs 1 Ihrough 18 of this Answer arc incorporatcd
hcrcin by rcfercncc.
20, Thc Plaintilrs rccovcry is barrcd or reduecd by thc Pcnnsylvania Motor Vchiclc
Financial Responsibilily La\\' as amcndcd.
21 Plaintiff or her rcprcsentalivcs chosc lhc limited tori option by signing a valid
selcction larm.
")") Plailllll'!'s' 1I1111fll.::-. do Illlt 11I\'ohL' ~h:;\th, s~'n{lIlS I 1111);11 I'll H.'111 of htldll~' l"uII:..'IIOI1 or
pCl'lnancnt disligurcmcnl.
\\'III:RI'FOI{I', IkJl:ndanh dcmand ludgnlc'nl nllhc'll' 1"""1' ,nl(1 dismi,,,d "I' I'laintil'!'"
Complainl \\ilh pl'cjudicc.
l'OUXIlRl'LAl:\l
l'OUXr 1- WRONul-L'L Db\111
23. Thc al'cl'lncnls conlaincd in paragraphs I through 22 orlhis Answcr wilh Ncw Mallcr
arc ineorporatcd hcrcin by refercncc.
24. On July 23. 1997. al approximately 12:4(, p.m., I'laintirr Melanic Wallacc was
opcrating hcr vehiclc in thc Eastbound lanc orS.R.lJ44 ("Wcrtzl'illc Road").
25. At that samc timc, Dorothy Wingcr! ("Dcccdcnt"), was allcmpting to Illakc a Icli turn
from thc Wcstbound lanc or Wcrtzvillc Road into a privatc drivcway whcn shc was suddcnly and
without warning simek by Plaintiff's vehiclc, which caused a violcnt collision and Dcccdent's
untimely death.
26. At that timc and placc, Plainlifrwas opcrating hcr vchiclc in a ncgligcnt, carclcss and
recklcss manner, in that shc:
a. failcd to operatc and/or maintain hcr vchiclc at a sarc speed;
b. Failcd to opcrate and/or maintain her vchicl'~ in a safe manner;
c. Failcd to opcratc and/or maintain hcr vchicle under such control so as to be
able to SlOP within the assured clcar distancc ahcad;
d. Failed to yicld to a vehicle Ihat already occupied hcr lane or travel.
e. Failcd to opcratc hcr vehicle at a speed which was safe and reasonable givcn
Icss than optimal weathcr conditions.
r. Failed to operalc and/or maintain her vehicle with rcgard to Ihe highway/road
conditions thcn and there cxisting and of which she was or should have been aware;
and
g. LlIh.:d 10 l;lhl-"IHllp""! ....kp.... of" I.'\;I~I\l.' ;ll'tioll hi OI\~lld \ll'IhIl11'. Ihl.' \\'illg....rt
Idlll'k.
27. PLlllltllr's lIl'gll~~l'lIl'l'. lilll.."k.,'dll'....'. iIlHII'l.'ddl,.....:-.IIL.:-..... '.\;lS till.' dun'{ .lIltl prO\i111all.'
calise or Ikl'l'dl'lIt's 1I11liml'l)' d,,,,th
2S. ElIgl'nl' Wingert. II. and \Lnl'la Shalldl'r. Cll-L'\l'l'lItors "I' the hi ate or Dorothy
Wingert. are l'ntilkd to bring this al'tll1l1 Ii,,' II rongflll ,kath pursuant to 42 l'a.C.S. ~ S}OI. and
Pa.R.C.P. 2202(a).
29. The Dl'l'l'dl'nl kl\ surviving Ihl' Illllolling persons, hl'rl'inai'tl'r rl'rl'lTl'd 10 as the
"Survivors," l'ntilkd to recover damages illr her death, and on their behalf this aclion is being
brought:
NM1E
ADDRESS
RELATlO~Slill~
Eugene Wingerl. II
501 1'Iorth Enola Drive
East Pl'nnsborn, PAl 7025
Son
Marcia Shaudl'r
Longs Gap Road
Enola. I' A
Daughter
}O. Decedent did not bring an action lor her personal injuries during her Iilctime, and no
other actions 1'01' the death of the Decedent has been commenced against Plaintiffs.
31. Solely as a result oflhe negligence. cardessness and reckless oflhe Plaintifl~ which
caused the death of the Decedent. her SUfl'ivors have sufrered pecuniary losses having incurred
funeral expcnses, eemctcry costs. administrative expenses, ambulance services. and medical
expcnses.
32, Solely as a result of the negligence, carelessncss and rcckless or the Plaintiff, which
caused the dealh or the Decedent, her SUfl'ivors have surrered pecuniary losses due to the loss or
contributions which Decedent would have made to them during her lirelime, including, but not
limited to. the care, training, advice. educalion, companionship, soeiely, aflcetion, aid, and
assistance, along with any and all other services Decedent would have provided,
WHEREfORE, Defendants respeetrully demandjudgmenl against the Plaintirfand in favor
or Defendants in an amount in excess or the mandatory arbitration limits,
"
,
~
COL':'-;l II, SL'R\'l\'AL .\l' 110:'-;
I:
I
I
I.
I:
I
,
~
i
:n. Thc a'WlIle'lIts l'OlIl;lIl1cd IIlpala~~raplls I IllIollf:h ,~ ,iI'lllIs All'" l'I \\ Ith ~C\\ :'slallcl
and COlllltl'rclailll tll"l.' iIH:orporall:d IH.:n",'in hy rl.'lcn.'IH':l'.
34. Eugcllc \\'illg"lt, II, allll :'sfalcia Shalld"I, l'll-C\C"lItOIS or thc Estatc or DOlolhy
Wingcrt. bring this a"tioll 011 b"lIalr or DOlOthy \\'illf:lTt ("Dcccdcnl"), pUlsuant 1042 Pa.C.S. *
8302.
35.
Solely as a Icsull oftllc nCf;ligcncc, C:tlel"ssllcSS and Ic"klessncss orlhc Plainlirr, Ihc
,.
Respeetllilly sublllittcd,
MARTSON DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO
') {/ l//~,
~ ,,! f: ' /
By ,/ ~-, '/., ./1, ,/ I
. .; .1 " 1./~7'"
Gearg6 (3, fallel. '1r.,Esillif,
!.D. No. 4lJ813 / \
Ten East High Stleet
Carlisle, PAl 7013
(717) 243-3341
DeccdcntWtlS caused to und"rgo gr"at p"ill, ,uffcring, ",al ;lIlguisll. from tllc timc of tllc "ccidcnl
until her untimely dcalll.
36. Solely "s" r"sull orth" ncglig"nce, earelcssncss, and rccklessncss ortll" Plainli rc the
Decedent has been depri\'ed orall carning, income and bcnclits shc othl'rwise would ha\'e expected
to enjoy during her liretime.
WHEREFORE, Derel1llanls respectrully demand jllllgment against the Plainlill and in Ill\'or
of Defendants in an alllount in excess of the mandatory arbitration limits.
Attorneys for Defendant
I I r Iq.C)"1
Dated: (;j II (,.I I \) I
.. c.1
i,
\
Ii
, "
i':
,~ '
(\,
\ ; ~
c: (
I
I L
I' ,
C. c' ,
"-z
o .
rfJ~
::;~
-.
,,--
~'ll;. ~
-. '" .- -.
~'.. / ..... ',"
Q~:.1-i~
~ - , .-
~:,:%>
(l'-O-
l.JZi::V
W,,::J'. C
O~Vr--
~<
~U,...J~
"'0-'"
::.J"'" > ~
0'. - .
,< c... 0
:...J' Z
~::::::
-OlJ
-C!l
1--
?i<
<::::i
LJ
~
.'
<
;::
z
<
-
<'.
:'~
.::
v f-
c:::':.J......
..-:::: - ,-
- "'::'.,J
'-
~
~;....
:...- ~/
-r:,~
l~
~~l
o ~
o <
~Q~
~~:.
~ S
~ ~
~ 2
/.
/
::i :::
-= 'J.r
OJ _4
~
." -
""-
~ ,"" ...~
,'.., ....I ,-'
~ ~
:z;,.;~
~
?:c3
:..:J::J ,..
Z<
f"- :,....
S :ii ./i
::J OlJ
'"
-
-;;:
~ -
~ .
~
-,
- 'r;.
:.-
~
'r.
ZZ
< ~
'j., ~-
~o
Ci:-
~
~
"
j
~
Q
o
~
~ !- c:
'" ~ Z
?: "';..:
o ~ a
~ ;-; ~ -
OQ ::! 7. t::.
~ ::r:: ~ ZW.
:.0.1 r: .
z ;l ~ g
~ ~ ~ -
i: z;! 3
-( ~u ~
'"
R ...,.
'"
'"
,;,
'<'
'"
;:::
. ,
~.::: < !~
o~ - ....
"'> U"eG
<...J eG.c~ j
~>- ~ c:r:"::o
0.."';" ~ ~~~ !~! ~ '"
z~< U -o~> -
< CO~ ~ 0 ..,.
O~...J ...J C1~ :; >- L:J 0 " '"
~ 0.. ',S ...J ::::~:::: "- ~ '"
~ ~ < .;.,
~>!~ < ..l":..... G ~ "'-l Z
~ ....~' Z ~ ~ ..,.
0....0 ,: eG'O L:J ~ 6 '"
~ ~ ~
U5- ~ L:JOeG ~ o < 0 Vl ~ R
~ ~1 OUO ~Q~ u .,
- :r: z
~ "0 "- < " u z to>
00<, ~fil~ ~ 6 .;,j :t~
I-U~g ~~i ~ ~
...J ~OO ~ ~ 7.
eGO> L:J ~ 0
5~u~ ~ L:J;:JL:J ~ Z
~ .., w.I ~ "
Z<.... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ 2 z ~ ~
li02 ' L:J:I:< ~U ~
~~ ouo", ~ .:: I-
:I:(ll ;:J L:J
....~ L:J
~;:J I
I U
,
.,
:-J
,"'J
, ,
:1')
'-,
.,
~,.;.
. . .
..
':. "
~.. . I '
.', I '
I',. ;,'
~a~/ ~
'~I ~ .b;f;,-...~f-~. ~
. ",
AV . ,J l'lf t.j/-
va/'J1d {// (lvf/JVY1^r
','..1
ril.:
. tt..
{/ -
. IZv-v., ". ~--
!if
p ~/L<.- C. )h,ft~ . /LY,",'
MUANI[ WALLACE,
IN I HE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA
Plall'llff
v.
NO. (I,l
f, nf'
II( lIt (
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
EUGENE WINGERT, II, and MARCIA
SHAUDER, Co. Executors of the EST A TE
OF DOROTHY WINGERT,
Defendant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NOTICE TO DEFEND
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set fo,th in the
following pages, you must take action within twenty 1201 days afte, this Complaint and Notice are
served, by entering a w,itten appea'ance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the
Cou,t vour defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you
fail to do so the case may proceed without you and judgment may be entered against vou by the
Cou,t without fu,the, notice fa, any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief
,equested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property 0' othe, rights impo,tant to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE
LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW
TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION
2 Libe,ty Avenue
Ca,lisle, PA 17013
(717124g.3166
MELANIE WALLACE.
I
I'
I
f.
l
r
I
I
Plaint I"
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO.
EUGENE WINGERT. II. ond MARCIA
SHAUDER, Co. Executors of the ESTATE
OF DOROTHY WINGERT,
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
,
.
I."'
r
Defendant
r'
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
COMPLAINT
1. Plaintiff Melanie Wallace, a citizen of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, is an
t
f\
i'
! ~
I
1
>
1 J
adult individual who resides at RD 111 Box 936, Landisburg, Perrv Countv, Pennsylvania.
2, Defendants Eugene Winge't, II, and Marcia Shauder a'e the co'executo,s of the
Estate of Do,othy Wingert, deceased, in whose Lette,s Testamentary were duly granted to them
by the Register of Wills of Cumbe,land County, Pennsylvania, and who resided in Enola,
Cumbe,land County, Pennsylvania.
3. The facts and occurrences he,einafte, related took place on 0' about July 23, 1997
at app,oximately 12:46 p.m. on Route 944 East (Wertzville Roadl Hampden Township, Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania.
.~
'I
.~
.,
"
4. At that time and place, Plaintiff Melanie Wallace was operating he, vehicle, a 1995
Pontiac G,and Am. in an easterly di,ection on Wertzville Road and was properly proceeding in her
1:,1i
~ !
lane.
5. At that time and place, Defendants' decedent Dorothy Wingert was operating he,
vehicle, a 1991 Chev,olet Cavalie" traveling West on Wertzville Road.
13961 aiLe 1
:'.-,
6, At thilt tlU\I! .me! plilCB, Dl!fl!fl(lilllt~.' dUCl:dllflt Dorothy \NIIlf)lHt !;lIddllllly ilnd
without warning attcmpted to make a left turn mto II privatI! driveway and did pd~;:, dlrtlt;t1y III flt.Jllt
of PlainLff Melanie Wallace's vehicle.
7, As a result of Defendant decedent's Improper turnlllg maneuver, Plaintiff Melanie
Wallace was unable to stop her vehicle which resulted in a violent collision between horse If and
and Defendants' decedent Dorothy Wingert.
8. The torce of lhocollision between Defendant Dorothy WlIloert's vehicle and Plaintiff
Melanie Wallace's vehicle caused Plaintiff painful and seve,e injuries that required immediate and
extensive emergency medical attention.
9. The foregoing accident and all of the injuries and damages set forth hereinafte,
sustained by Plaintiff Melanie Wallace a,e the direct and p,oximate result of the negligent, careless,
and reckless manner in which Defendants' decedent Dorothy Wingert ope,ated her motor vehicle
as follows:
a. failure to have he, vehicle unde, such control as to be able to stop within
the assu,ed clear distance ahead;
b. executing an improper left turn ac'osS the oncoming lane of traffic;
c. failure to keep alert and maintain a proper watch for the presence of othe,
motor vehicles on the highway;
d. failure to keep a p,ope, watch fo, oncoming t,affic on the highway;
e. failure to keep proper and adequate control over he, vehicle;
f, driving her vehicle upon the highway in a manner endange,ing persons and
property and in a reckless manner with careless disrega,d to the rights and safety of others and
in violation of the Motor Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,
g. failure to drive he, vehicle with due rega,d for the highway and traffic
conditions which were existing and of which she was 0' should have been aware; and
2
h. f,lIluru to YUJld till! flUht of W,IY hl!fow Illilklll!l iI left hand turn across tho
path 01 ()P'}(),illl~J tr,llln: which was so c1o~,,~ lI!i to UJlI~itttllt(J iI hil/iHd.
10, PlilUltllf Melante Wallace ~;lI~;tallwd piltllful and severn HlJlJflCS which I/lclude but are
not lirllltcd to: closed supracondylar ffilcturu of the distal right felllur with an mtra.articular
component, V-shaped In character with comminution,
11. By Wilson of the aforesiJid lIlJlHlCS sllstalrlOd by Plaintiff Melanie Willlilce, she was
forced to incur liability for medical treatment, medications, hospitalizations, physicalthe,apy, and
similar misccltancous expenses in an effort to restore herself to health. and claim is made therefor,
12. Because of the nature of he, injuries, Plaintiff Melanie Wallace has been advised
and, therefore, avers that she may be forced to incLJ' similar expenses in the future. and claim is
made therefor.
13. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Plaintiff Melanie Wallace has undergone
and in the future will undergo g,eat physical and mental suffe,ing. great inconvenience in carrying
out he, daily activities, loss of life's pleasures and enjoyment. and claim is made therefor.
14. As a result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff Melanie Wallace has been and in the
futu,e will be subject to great humiliation and embarrassment, and claim is made therefor.
15. As a ,esult of the aforementioned injuries. Plaintiff Melanie Wallace has sustained
wo,k loss, loss of opportunity and a permanent diminution of he, earning powe, and capacity, and
claim is made therefor.
16. As a ,esult of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff Melanie Wallace has sustained
uncompensated work loss, and claim is made therefor.
3
1r
:1
17, PlilJllllff Mnlill1w WilllaCI! COlltHllW~; 10 Iw pl<l!llll!d hy pl:r~il~;tt:llt pillrl ilnd 11lllttatl0l1
I:
I
I
~, I
k
~'
and, thereforo. avers that her injurieS may be of a permanent nature. CilLJSlIln reslduill problems for
tho remainder of her lifetime, and claim is made therefor.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Melanie Wallace demands Judgment against Defendants
~
Eugene Wingert, II and Marcia A. Shauder, Co' Executors of the Estate of Dorothy Wingert in an
ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C.
amount in excess of Twenty Five Thousand ($25,000.00) Dollars exclusive of interest and costs
and in excess of any jurisdictional amount requiring compulsory arbitration,
DATED:
/' ,
(.,:~ r '
-i---
James DeCinti, Esqui,e
1.0. No. 77421
4503 N. Front St,eet
Harrisburg, PA 17110
(7171 238.679 1
Counsel fa, Plaintiff
,.j
)
'\
i
,
,
''"I'
..
I
i
I
:','
4
(
.\,.
. .'
~j:.BlElGAIIOj\l
I, Melanie Wallace, verify that I have read tho forogolr1g document imu do hereby swear
or affirm that the facts set forth in the foregoing are true and correct to the best of my knowledge.
i!
"
information. and belief. I understand that false statements herein a'e made subject to the penalties
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
'--(}! d Q..,(.l~C ..J. uJ (J (/ rlO a
Melanie Wallace
/
DATED: IO-7S-iS'"
I
i
i
.
i
I
I
I
, .,';'
,~ , ., .
~~~~.~g~~t?~,., __ ~., , ,~.~.
!h~\~:r:":iJrri;..:~- .-,: . -::: ~ .. 'u."'_ d
l'i#;~f:1~'~~'i~:,:':;'~
r4{~!fJli,"T~"jr. I," ~ .1, r:,;,~:' \
, ~t'lr:'~~f~~' 'r ~~I2' ,:'; I
,~"," '" ";.' , "','
> ~:i~'(~ct':(~r::r., '. ;1'< ':'':<':'f>:<''', :
" "~,g(i~(~l.,J,, ,I',"" '~'
'/.'''';;.f'.i~,...'r'.;\'3-,.i'~''1':::.f.0':"" f..:' \
:JiI1\>;"!ij'I,:;, .,I";....!/.,~.f,'()
..l~~f1 /;,':1 '~\:r_'\" ^ rn
!t'j1"!'," , '.
, .,
'..
I I tll " P\ T \1 II t I ~"I ~ ~ ...,.. I'~ \ I ;"
l,n"" II',', ..I. :::'1'\'
"",,,.! '1"'''1'.'''',1'\'
',"'.11
MEI.ANII: WAI.I.M'I:.
I'lainlilT
Ii': 1111: ('(Jl KI OF CO:Yl'vl0N 1'L1:AS OF
('( i~IIlI'RI.A~1l ('OIINTY. I'ENNSYI.\'A~IA
.,
\,
"
v,
CIVIL AClIO~ - LA \\'
;-':O,')X-id71l CIVIL '11:IUvl
I
,
EUGENE WINGERT, II. and MARCIA
SIIAUDER. Co-Executors of the
ESTATE OF DOROTIIY WIN(jERT.
Dcfendants
JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMANDED
l'RAECll'J:;
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY:
Entcr the appcarance of MARTSON DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO on bchalf of
Dcfendants inlhe abovc mattcr. Defendanls hcrcby dcmand a twclvc juror jury trial inlhe abovc
eaptioncd action,
MARTSON DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO
..;/"
By
Ge rgc 13, Fallcr, Jr.
I.D. No, 49813
Tcn East High Strcet
Carlislc, P A 17013
(717) 243-3341
Attorneys for Defcndant
Dated: November 9, 1998
,..
t, (;'",
, ,
!.
,
\,
: 'I
,~
I: C-'
L' \..~, ',J
<: ~o
"'- <:
O~ - I-
"'> UU~
<:..J ~;SLU ~~ "
LU;.. '-0 l~, j
..J", LU ::;Oz ~ '"
o...~> U .."V>_ :;;:
Z :;;: cl5;:: :2 0
<: " '"
OLU...J ..J ~ :i... LU 3 '"
::Eo..., ..J "":r::: 0... ~ ;- < .;.,
~ ~ ~ I.l.l Z
~~Z <: -:J....... 0 Z ...
.. x "- " ~ P N
Q Q ::: I- LU . LU =- ~
;; ~,o o < R
~ ~Q~ 0 Vl ~
U . I- LU LUo~ U ~ Z D
'" U ~ OUo ;5 ~ .ll 13 Z
00< zoio 0... :t~
e.~1 ~ ~
l-u...J -o.:.Ju.. ~ H z
..J :::00 ~ 0
~Cl- LU ~ " 2 "
:i)z::: LU:i)LU "-l ~
;::2 ~ ~ ~ z o! "
O<U z<1- ~ ~ ~
~
u;:2 LU:I:< ::E z <( ~u I-
tI.1tI.1 o "H"
:I:el ::J LU
1-;::2 LU
~::J
U
. .
I 1111 ~ II \ J \llll III.'" 1 ItH '".. II ,...~ l i.I,'
lor.",',J "J"""",.' '"pl'\!
~.."d ' 'Il'"" I' I. \\,
'.'~",1 J
MELANIE WAI.I.M'E.
I'laintiff
1:"1111' COt '1(( OFt 'O~I ~ ION I'I.EAS OF
('\ :~IIlI'RJ...\~1l ('OU~TY. I'I:N~SYI.V ANI:\
v.
CIVil. A( "1(( IN - I ,\ \\.
NO, ')X-id 70 (,IVII.II:R~1
EU(jENE WIN(jERT. II. and MARCIA
SHAUDER. Co-Executors of thc
ESTATE OF DOROTIIY WINGERT.
Defcndants
JURY TRIAL OF TWFI.VE DFMANDED
llEEEl'iDAl'iT~S_llliSl'Ol'iSE..I.O_l'LAli'\TlFF~S MOTl ON TOCOMl'EL
llliQUESTSFOR AD~llSSlOi'\
I. Admitted,
2. Admitted,
3. Admitted.
4, Admittcd.
5. Admittcd.
6, Admitted.
7. Admittcd,
8. Dcnied. To the contrary. Dcfendant's answers were proper and suflieient. By way
of furthcr answcr. Dcfcndant's decedent dicd as a rcsult of thc injurics sustaincd in this accidcnt and
it is the understanding ofthc Dcfcndants and thcir counsel that there wcrc no eyc witncsscs to thc
collision othcr than the Plaintiff. Thcrcforc. the inlonnation sought through thc Rcquest for
Admissions is morc likely, than not, within thc exclusivc provinec of Plaintifrs knowlcdgc or
Plaintifrs control. The local policc departmcnt apparcntly did investigatc thc aeeidcnt and it is
bclicvcd that P1aintifrs counsel is in posscssion ofa copy of the Policc Accidcnt Rcport which is
hcreby attached as Exhibit "A."
9. Denied, To thc contrary, see the avcrments in rcsponsc to Paragraph 8 of this
,\nswcr.
Datc: July 13. 1999
By
George B. Faller. Jr., Es
I.D, Number 49813
Tcn East High Strcet
Carlisle. PA 17013-3093
(717) 243-3341
Attorneys lor Dcfendant
Exhibit A
GX)REFER 1"0 OVERI.AY SHEETS
....~
w
COMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYL VANIA
POLICE ACCIDENT REPORT
REPOATABlE ~ NON, REPORTABLE D
POLICE INFORMATION
rn
w
r 16. HAZAROOUS
MATERIALS
66, CARRIER
AODRESS
69. CITY. STATE
& ZIPCODE
70, USOOT II
ICCII
PUC II
I. INCIDENT ItA (J Q"7
NUMBER 'Tl - I
2~':J:eCY H!/'I1lPi)OJ /All' fbuCG" lJe"t'r
3, STATION! ..;130 ". 5.iJ:/'-rTN(;,.!:!'u.. Kb 4. PATROL " W
PREC"'CT m.:-r,i. PII .,.,c.r ZONE'v
5.,NVESmm. k. $'"HA-Ul;i-lp~.r~~~~iR 17/ (p
6. APPROVED BV BADGE
NUMBER
7'~:T~STIGATlON0l3 ~I..Y 9718~~R~VAL J~S'3
ACCIDENT INFORMATION
..~~~OENTJ3 $II-\" '17 100AVOFWYbE'D.
11. T'ME OF / "'4'. 12, NUMBER .;l
DAY 01.. UJ OF UNITS
13," KILLED I 114. 'INJURED 15. PRIV. PROP. 0 r;n
/ ACCIOENT V N ICj
lB. 010 VEHiCLE HAVE TO Be REMOVED 7. VEHICLE DAMAGE
FROM THE SCENE" 0 . NONE UNIT 1
UNIT 1 UNIT 2 1 . LIGHT
2. MODERATE
V 1&1 NO V Ii9 NO 3. SEVERE UNIT 2
O rv1 9. PENNDOT 0 rvI
v N ~ PROPERTV V N ~
UNIT /11 UNIT /I 2
38. LEGA~L V V !i 137. REG. /),SN 74 3 138, S~AE 38. LEGALL V V N_I37. REG, Y V -r- C) 83
PARKED?O~I PLATE n I rl1 PARKED? 0001 PLATE .J
~t:'~;'~i;~RV'N '*4 308 734 '104- ~.u:'~;'~i;T~RvIN 48 Gll <c /llD;Jo 1
40.0WNE"])Cf?Tl1Y C. 'WINGa<.T '0. OWNER M GU'rNI/Z 5:. WA1.LAC.E'"
41.~;0':.E:SS 7J R W'N~ LltrvG' 41~6'~REERsS _.{""~ 'bOGWOob I-AflC
42'i'~Cs.;~~E ~fJOLA PI+ J'7(J26 42i'~CSci~~E /)/LL.SBuR.G fA 1'70/9
43. VEAR q / 44, MAKE (2HevR-oL6-r '3. VEAR q ~ I'" MAKE Po NT! f\-G
45, MOOEL . (NOT ,.. A.o J A II' ~ 146. INS.... 45. MOOEL . (NOT G" ^. 'D' A 1'6, INS
BOOV TVPE) LT\V rr" c: J"'.,., I v a NO UNK 0 BOOV TVPE) /VTN m 1 v i:8I NO UNK 0
47,) BOOV 01'1 ('8,lSPECIAL 0 \4..jVEHIClE 1 [47.jBOOV 0' A (4B,)SPECIAL 0 4S,jVEHleLE I
"-" TYPE -,- '-' USAGE '-' OWNERSHJP i........ TYPE ' -,. '-' USAGE '-' OWNERSHIP
5O.)lNITIAL IMPACTI \.SI.IVEHICLE 0 (52,)TRAVEl 10 [50.)INITIAL IMPACT/2. [51,)VEHICLE 0 52.)TRAVEl 48
"-" POINT ~ STATUS '-' SPEED "-" POINT -..- STATUS '-' SPEED
:53.)VEHIClE I 1S4,)DRIVER I I I \55.jORIVER <1 153.jVEHICLE 1 (".lOA'VER I I I ~5,)DRIVER 1
-..- GRADIENT 1'-' PRESENCE I '-' CONDITION I........ GRADIENT ~ PRESENCE '-' CONDITION
56. ~~~~~R 64- 4 7lf ~:J 4- 157.s'P11 56, ~~~~~R .93 714- 0 <[ 5' '57.S'f,2)
58.~~~~R Dcl/2-lHi C. WltJt!,iEf<. T 58.~~~~R (Yl6l-Af-J/c 5. lUALt.AC.~
59.~~~~:ss 7:).. R WltJTl::"R LN 59'~~~Re:SS .,0'2. '])OG,WOOD UnJb'
60'i'~csci~~E eNOLA PA /70"25' 6O'i'~Cs.;~~E 1)/1-1-56lA.R..(; PA /701'1
81,SEXF 162 ~;;'~~OF()R_15 _ 13 63'l7'~~-.;2.5"5B 61. SEX F 162. ~;;.rT~OF O,;),-C)O -6,0 163 Pry~9-J4J '1
64. COMM, Y~!f'165, DRIVER ;'\ 166. DRIVER 64. COMM, YE" t 65. DAIVER c.. 166, DRIVER
YO NlIIl CLASS,-,," I S5' yo NlJl I CLASS 1 SS/I
67. CARRIER 67. CARRIER
1{12.\VEH.
I~ CONFIG,
75, NO, OF
AXLES
AA-45(1I92)
2; CARGO
-, <lDV TVPE
,6; HAZARDOUS
- MATERIALS
74, GVWR
n. REL.5.aSE OF HAl MAT
vU NO UNKO
1968919
_'80//7']0
PENNOOT USE ONL v
ACCIDENT LOCATION
20 COUNTY ~n1I3E:/UA'1fO COOE dll
21 MUNICIPALITV/I~"/)E.v ~p COOE /0.3
PRINCIPAL ROADWA Y INFORMA nON
22 ~?~;:r".?A~: NER'T'z. V/t/.C RoM (~p.. 944)
23 SPEED A r- K2IjiYPE Ao K25.)ACCESS J
LIMIT ...,..~ I.........UOHWAY v I-CONTROL
INTERSECTING ROAD:
26. AOUTE NO. OR
STREET NAME
27. SPEED
LIMIT
K2B)TVPE
1'-' HIGHWAY
K.29)ACCESS
,- CONTROL
IF NOT A T INTERSECTION:
30. CROSS STREET OR 7'100,. u/::,-S TJ~ f~.........
SEGMENT MARKER """ r-~J I - n V
31,0IRECTlON N S E' "'W::\ 132 OISTANCE "!r. .~.;o.
FROM SITE : CW) FROM SITE Q-'t..-",\ FT,
33. DISTANCE WAS r::I1 _.~.I J' If'71
MEASURED IdJ ESTIMATED U
~:l4)CONSTRUCTfON @] ~35)TRAFFIC PRINCIPAL INTERSECTING
~ ZONE 0 I~ CONTROL rnI D
DEVICE LJ:LJ
MI.
138'~Jf
66, CARRIER
ADDRESS
69, CITY. STATE
& !IPCQDE
70. USDaT /I
ICC'
PUC /I
:72,)VEH,
-..- CONFJG,
75. NO. OF
AXLES
1(13, CARGO
, cODY TYPE
1(78.1HAZAROOUS
1'-' MATERIALS
74. GVWR
n, REL.s.ASE Qf HAZ MAT
vU NU UNKD
,
,
PAGE. ~r7 ~ FOR HIGHWAY 0AfETY
EXHIBIT "A"
~~',: ',".'11
7a,RESPONOlNOEMSAGENCY I-I/rIhP'bf/J -rI.iP ;m.,.,. 7'
7'11. MEDICAL FACILITY HOt. '( .,>Plftt f' H,uS(>lffiL.
[1lO.JPEOt'U: INfQhMA liON
1"1(' BCD e F G NAME
/ I FW~ 3 :J. 0 bo(Ulf( e, W"Jf:r~ T
IINCIDENT H /4-9' "'7
IACCIDENT DATE: ,.;J., JUt T' Ci 7
AOQRESS
7~ (( 1J:..!,tJ ~P~~.....-
H I J K l M
I I'~ 'I A 3 8
Z. I F 373 I I (fl1tL/rfJu; 5. W~I\C.C 1'f-9_':.' ~,~:-.. 7~"Z 1;11.40 4-l?h" 8 fa I
VllUMINATlON ~ @WEATHER []]
::;. SURFACE ~
84. PENNSYLVANIA SCHOOL DISTRICT
(IF APPUCABLE)
ae. DIAGRAM
o
86. DESCRIPTlON OF DAMAGED PROPERlY
,.............FDIA&~A(V\... ........,.,...........-............" ......,
. 56QiAaJCE.
. . . .
................l.,.....,......... A7TA"H~P.. ...,..."...,,1....,............,...,. ".....
OWNER
AQORESS
PHONE
,..,..... ,.........,.,.............,",...~....................... ."....
. ,
87. NARRATIVE -IDENTIFY PRECIPITATING EVENTS. CAUSATION FACTORS. SEQUENCES OF EVENTS. WITNESS STATEMENTS. AND PROVIDE AOOfTIONAL
DETAlLS. lIKE INSURANCE INFORMAnON AND lOCATION OF revvED VEHiClES. IF KNOWN,
'1/.tIS Ac.cllJ.c,ur oc:.c-I./.,e..~'i:> IN ff4NI "p .Q/.5- ttlr:,7!-r2..VILLC ;e,-1i>.
-;;::-r NIJ:S Jl2.t:ff1l/"1,v(; r 71tG'" ,I2t7,q-1)tvltY W/"rS NeT. tI#lr #/ W,4-S
- e:U,l./G Wes, .8tJuN'}) OAl 1-f,klfl-r2..l//t.L€";eoffl). UNIT'2 Jln"rS
- r::a.JNt; 8J1sr BtJI!Jt/l> L1f1/lr ~...t ./1'1T'crn,aTl,::1> ,IJ-' 7Z'f~
jfl/7'Z> A- ,.o,R.Jv~ 'b1'..JIle-W/1Y /i-r #S-01/~ j!?ttt,;.u""'/G /A/RJ "7Ht: -:,.
oP UIlII r ~Z . t/fl/lr #2 ',j' P/JSs6'l'c,1;:'7!... s/;-'G- ~/-'T /-Ia:J?} ~p ~7'1
::z;:-m/J/tC-7"b-J) Ml'1a1 tlNI'>>"?'.s ,cAsS~"7JG~'",- 51LJl?: ~Nr /'O.e..N67e.
I./Nlr '#..1 Silt/AI CI/(IIVl'7::)7Z.. Ct..Oc.i::-WISt: ..r- //.;:Fr ?H5"duiTUS'IDC:;-OF
-rH€ H/olfWff'r' -r- 1>ow/IJ A- S/Y1/-IU.. 6:.7n8/1?tFjqY)&;7J/7' /l/1'ft.:;.7JtF /,
F~f'/'CD (J'A!7(:) /T$ /'/J-S'S'RA/S.o? S/l)G'". ::J:-r 7J{i:;--,..J J!!.dt..Ltd)
ONTO IT'S ~oF +- 6<trrJs '-0 Rt:.:sr ON IT'S ])fiJl/&<.'s "//:)G"
R'fC..;;/G /LIo,l'-TH€ITS'7: fJ-Pn:::-~ ;Z:m/1AGT. t/Alir#2 Sl'ttll/ ~ '
INSURANCE CQ!.1~ANY~ r:': 'f":. /" INSURANCE CO~PANY... hi --r'.. A
INFORMAnON 7HIZ sr .. ,ft~ rlRE .J-N~. c.-a, INFORMATION NlrntJ.vWI/)t;; ('/IIn/1IL .HI!; l..<:
U~ ~CY~:33 SY (J()(JS7~7a39 pes U~lT PO~~Y.5"'8 31C 6;7 i 03(;,
NAME ADDRESS PHONE
88.
WITNESSES NAME
ADDRESS
PHONE
. ,:'~\A~: 89. VIOLATIONS INDICATED
..7-;;t;.i'"
UNIT 1 VeHIc'L€ /L.R.l.IiNG LeFT
UNIT 2 "DRilliNG VeHICLe A-r S/l-F€ SPct::D
'/,:.,..~.;". 11.)r'AOBABLE K92.)TYPE J(93,jRESULTS 8JNOTEST .~:~.\.~' (91.)PAOBABlE
. ...... USE I'-'TEST 1'-' ....:'.~.;.. .......,. USE
UNIT 1 () 0 0 'k 0 REFUSE UNIT i ()
'-- 0 UNK
90. SECTION NUMBERS (ONI. Y IF CHARGED)
TC NTC
M-45(1192)
DO
00
~~~~~ ~RESULTS ~ NO TEST 94. INVESTIGATION
O 0 'Ii 0 REFUSE COMPLETE'
'-- '0 UNK YES 0 NO 0
-: c (~ " C,'1 C PAGE, ~F 7 C:ilNTEli ;:0001 hlGilWAY ~"Fl:Tf
..J.. ..~ "-...J {) '.J '.. ,)
. .
@
COMMONWEALTH OF . ~NSYLVANJA
PAR CONTINUA TJON SHEET
(XX) REFER TO OVERLAY SHEn 5 nU'OIl'Allll l&J NON'llf"OR'AalE 0 P(N~l US( ONLY
I~~T /4 '1- '17 IA~;',o.(Nr~-?,:TZtu... 91 f~~~Y .;1./ I MU~~~Al J() :3
RSaN IHFOAM"nON. USE OVERLAY. 2 SHEET FOR CODES
BCDEFDNAME ADoor ss II , J K l t.4
87.ItARRATlVE: ~L.()Ck i'J/s~ /P.f1l>e-~~.5 /1().1??/NG nJ. /<t:ST: QA/:
. . .
. . .
..;., ~:-;-: FI'fsT:- J:?O/../N''n J:?I--,-:e.rn . - "vr::. We-S-- : : :
/. . :
: : /biA/r '<:JF ::;:-/11;O/1C.r tJ/tS J11/J7P-K/-!1} 73V /f (.:;JOf.,o((5L /#:TH~
A:_ h;-{ At 7: h,.J me 6?9-Sr ~;vt) /:? /r/</n . ;).7 j/ll~H.b /N1' IliG"
-NC': WH;~ ~.!:A!.rn L/ .A/l:!"~ fJo/1II'r Or fm;O/1r::.T 7z; : /i..vh )!cir
A(}Si rUIN': r'1p: UAJlr~J.. MfA- S C':? ~ 8/'</CH~-S_: A/;.vr ~r.. -
7z;J: ;=t1:JAt. ~/ -""SIT7(}/J /JF ///lfl,-# 2 flJ/211/et<. sl))(::Riz:t"JT77:ee
i.t/As : is/:. : ~ 1,J'0t,f:;:;.. : : :
. . '(1 A:it2-A:-roR.... #-.:L. N/!--S !Qa/::--j..... /tJ mb. ~cID671:/.. : :Z:r'lvlJ
. . .
. . ,
. . .
.M '~)'- : :.~f(G . ,... )1I'or 11J'C;,~--/N'G A- Sl~8~~7;' : 1M i.ur
~7i:::. :7.'
-' : In.!.. y b~<.,.ncD ml1'7 7Jtrz- I/8HICL6 /r//-(f:::,?) IT" ;:a;t.U-.r]) dllZJ.
.
tI#IT:"".1~; H iP9tJ ...... 7111 L. LA'm,/J s N~ ON A-r me /J~~.ij)fi:Wr
. , . , 17/e- : ~/1d.J~G E./c.. SI)l(;- M/J,S Aq(AJe7) /1r 'rite: c~'n.dL
ScerJ~.:
2>ho~ ftoST +- /(/ft> /.!/!.H$S/ /1'1 ui'l lJe-I3R.1'\ WHICH /ni.m:H~: 2'>iVtl 13'
/)J : m':'" tA-z,JAJ WHt::.-"72-G II ?rrND e7) P-,,-/Cltl2., '/'0 ::I24u)N~ iuv
, . ,6 . . .
. . ., . 77t~ ~~e/,f.L(.5 jJ/lJOI<. hi :17-i.6lJltiOTS
Its :7Zi:dF: ,.... d>>7(J S/)j ~
III t;"1<- it rwo: -rIR~ -r.eA<-l<. " otJe !tv /HtS' 6'IV1-SS -ru':P...c.. I- :7HG- d.ni~
/~i.t- !J!ifcH: oP .::fl.<1II/,ccP- SIi~t3S ' L6rr SY ~ '#/' ,&:;e.d,.v T:-
'Nlr ,IS:
jj/f{~~ i1-S /r 7'1Vh/ezdD 7'J()w"J 711 e- S/Y)/ft-t..: b7n ;.!).....:. /k:.'mt:')Ji.
&-~'tv :7il6': 7l.ec- ~<; f- 1He AJI'Nr of ~*-rr:'Of.I'c5EJ
tJl'is /t:5~N)) .<)/I'l,"I'u..c:n '-01./(;[. IN 71fE /!-sPHlh-r,:~ /3Y tI/I;r#;
.45 fr: ;;:r7 ifJ.(e- HI(;(-{.WhY. ' : : : :
: : ;::-titJ,Jr '=r-Jv 7) J)t::,/3,eJS F/4Jm GlNlr#~ tuA:5 LJiFi: /).} A :
: :
"SI4rrGuN'~ . [,f!.J.J F/ltJYI1 7H.~ Pel tV T 0 F .:z:I11f'.A<T~ / i! 7:1111" )jIMJj
, " 1'-'1'</71
:f1:1.1J:r: UNIT ~ "11ZPrt/eu5b /fFn:;7<.. f(YlfY-J-c.7: U IJ IT1t'2. ~s tl6lfTS 7
. 89. DESCRIBE VIOLATIONS 90. SECTION NUMBERS (ONLY IF CHARGED) TC NTC
UNIT I 0 0
UNIT 2 0 0
~ROBABLE ~-:VPE ~ESULTS DNOTEST ~;r.l~~~?;' ~A08A8lE ~;VPE ~ESUL TS D NO TEST 94. INVESTIGATION
" . USE TEST -"""., ~'
D REFUSE ~ USE TEST D REFUSE COMPLETE ?
UNIT 1 0,__0/0 0 UNK UNIT 2 0.__0/0 DUNK YES D NO D
AA~5C (1192) PAGE:~, - 1 CENTER FOR HIGHWAY SAFETY
tJ
<)f
.(iCX) REFER TO OVERlAY SHEETS REPORTAIllE Ii1J NONREf'ORTABlE 0 F'ENIOJl'USEoP<<.Y
~ /49-'17 IA~~~Nr-1_1J(..u..Y971~~Y ;)./ IMU~~Cl:'AL /03
RSOH IHFORMAnOH.. USE OVERlAY '2SI<EEf FOR CODES
9 C 0 E F 0 NAME ADORess I< I J K L M
87.NAAFU.TIVE:tJ.i-'-'"'i2l:- aN t1-'r 7"He ~CI/)eNr S<~NE OP~ ~ : &..it<;
: : : .e, --
!:-rl L..l. j ,'../fli!:7i //t::hICL e. SH€ W/K WI3'l't?-/NC A:StD:ri"$~r r'
/.(eJ)a.: /f:7/<i A~G h"'ttJ 'Z:>c:: I'La Ye'L>. SI-f€'" WitS €X#I"''n..:nro: ..6'Y :
int::.~/i-~ 1~~Cu.&' f'~So/JN~ /JVn./S P.::J/2..17~)) f/iA- : . . ,
..,:- 't.tUfN'~
-m: R(/c,y S'P/,e.tr f0~Prl7't-L 'm /:-"'P....c we1!.G' No f//.s~I3t.E" 's",e:io /J1Mk.~
I:.e-F.,-': EY :UNl'f#2 fJ/ZJdJ2.. "1?J :I/nfJ/tGT :
: - '#.;).. S - S"I-{C tV.4-S ~rA 'buiv)j : o;i/
:
(;J~~/4I~ 'teot7j) r'JAJ i-Ie72- W-1"Y 73 '^-'tI1U::. /Ir EdtE;:e" ~E /-Iwb../
IA) /,,,,, ' , '" 'J.It',-,-~ SHe srn., '"' ""D SItG WI1s '7'if?nVt....'LI AlG &~ 45inf'#
-i.-) : 48da...:49"i,jJH. .1H€ S17Yl2....7:> /H11-r SHe- sAiJ UiJlr~.$..
AI'P/!.(j/fGHf.A/G :LdEsr i?dultlD .."... "bID Aior H/-lv6'" /T7zj~ SI6Nh6 a- Il
.
SHG : :s f h:T'l:f:'7:>: 77-I11-r SI-I e- NIts OIJL r- sev~ :CA:7z :L~(;ml"
~M /.(iY/r.#:2 LuHbrJ Ir Ih /tt) C A- Su i;)1)e;70..i ~AI: I' Ai'
~~,)JT OF I-ie:e.. I/e-HICu.;; . S'i-{~ S.47b t..I/IIlr#j Ale'Ve..-1e.. sm~ I)
J. ~(~ 1U'etVINGo CJ.P~ '*.;2 S'17HZ...,""i:> 7Hr-rr SH~ 2>/M7"
R~ P/'J()!Z.. J:l'htO~7: . , .
" 'jl'rile: 77Me;" 70 111 T 711t::.. 7Zl : :
: : '1JItiRG :WG~ No .IN&7'6rJb€Nt wlnV$.isd:J j;?; : PiG
A:cO lJ8?J7:: 7uIS CJmC6---;L 7)//) SP6'7hE::.. tdlTl-( /r k"7sl/)mr:
Irr. ,Q:/5'" I. r: '>>1 /..LiZ' ~A7'J . #DI'i'11-I YA-M/lsI<.IG'{ ;.'f...L'-IOf.,/)o
I :tl:-! ..; : .h->: 7J..( t:;Y W672t:: 6?Pt::.L77A1{.; A- vi5l'f F/2..dth
-. .'1-'. :
d,o,' . . . '#1. :!?om Vert/CUTS we7<..t::: 7c::iwen :AY
"r ,u1<-. :.
J-/ t.::7.J1<. r-~: 7oWI/l/6 ::Z;-;I./ c. ;;1390 tJeaTZ. Uwc &1041 fif-/?{)2,:,,(m.a?~
5om& PWdrdG'" -",,'5 frS t(j{,..."l.~ /J-s S:;mt:; 1J?ar.sI.tI4....:rnltldvrl i /0.:3-
1!f1::e:JJ' h . rHt : :
" : -: : . IE S'CeN€, :
: : :
:
89. DESCRIBE VIOLATIONS 90. SECTION NUMBERS (ONL V IF CHARGEO) TC mc
UNIT. 0 0
UNIT2 0 0
~ROBABLE ~PE ~ESULTS D NO TEST ~$l<w ~ ROBABLE ~~PE ~ESULTS DNOTEST !l-4.INVESTIGATIOH
' USE TEST USE TEST
UNIT I D REFUSE O. D REFUSE COMPLETE ?
0._._% DUNK UNIT2 _% DUNK YES 0 NO 0
M-4SCt'/92) PAGE' ~F 7 CENTER FOR HIGHWAY SAFETY
@
COMMl NEALTH OF- PENNSYL VANIA
PAR CONTINUA TlON SHEET
,..:i-'.' ,',~. ~..;
@ COMML .INEALTHOFPENNSYLVANlA
PAR CONTINUA TlON SHEET
lxXl RefER TO OVERLAY SHEETS REPORTABlE fi] NON.~PORTAOlE 0
~' IOENT /49 - 9 7 IA~~~tNI.;23 $Il.'7' 9 7 ~~Y ,;) /
RSON INFORMATION. USE OVERLAY. 2SHEET fOR CODES
BCD E F G NAME ADDRESS
PENJ4)O' U'"",{ ON. 'i
I""~~::L / () 3
H I J K l M
B7.~T1VE: : ('l1eJ1rSUft6Mi::-'"NTS
PnjLI'A nF. R.:.~c.6' /)1!1d..'L.I3C)I. Rsr Nr ~5"~IS- : :
: 2.') m.4oN f-laLG CuVeTt. (IN l:::7rSr: 13i;'7aiY>
: :
:
:
I) N\^,~~: ,...: i.cL''fl.< 1"1:) GcuGt."', (p-r. cF L"MPA<:;r) II 'j:.
x: G.ov.r_i,~{ AIOIJH.'~ WHlrc~7Lm LJ;v't;" .;27"
: t ~u6t.:$1 /.bJG1i-I nil)
~r(Y\~H..i?C)o(, Pc...j- :EAs'r '11. !-Jc14rn '7 IS. ;e C-<)uGL 1F;;J.
t.l' r~"j:[, ~2: NC?.fti TZl WMIfE' B~..M LINE' G, 'i'
: (G<t'~Gt.. ;o-:i LetJGm /0")
~1 (,~\ir..,t $/ : I::~T" TO Gcu...t- 1#-2. /0 ~ : : : :
l~i r-_,i"tW:Z.: ~rTn UNI'rIF2 1l1l.1"lP..~rWI{"''1.:.''1..~"'N.tVt:4:t..!o': ,
r-7)L"I1A1t1\ok POf;.;, :....A~r /4-3: t-)c.~Tli ("..5. "0 LllJir1P21:l/ZlJ.zlZ..:~N,:W'l~si..
l<a\ IYiAU:'P.dK PO~T: fJO?..:rH T'1J PtWe;.~ 8'n6~ OF i3c::'l2-.... 4 ~ :
/., M~I#JLJ::7,-,;i;,-sre'bGf.') ~"'3,n: G,U(;E.. tF2.. /S"
<2 ~ MI\'N.H4l~: Sa4iH TO eoC:.~(!J.:<<!b T'>>I~~ ~/JIP<-P.. Bet> c,:z :Wt:";'s; ~ Ca1hl~~_
: : : ~l)GL CF ::::ruN/PM. B~ 4LS
1/: v.,..Jlr ~ / : pASS..5IbG -nl!..e 5(i./ /:) IN Gf-'l-SS 5" /.e1JG17..(
Z U/Jir1#-/: ?)f<JiJu.. S"lbE" i7P-€SIal:> It-) Jli/Jil';)u' f3b'/) 10 I Lt:;NGrrt
fa wnim-! clF: B?~ A1 P<Ji/JioF ;I:ivtP~I(G:JI.IGf..fI'f) 10 ~ ~
71: UtJir ~ r (,it-Ji}-L r<...ss'l tbStl1()N FP..oM PO!N"rcr- =PI-\,oll~r: S':? ~
iJiSi ClNi; (F2: i0/JM ~-sr f(]S'tn.:JN Ff2.t:;m f'6LlJroF ::cMPA~.I: / S-~:
. . . , . , ,
_69. ~ES~RIBE'VIOLATIO~S
UNIT 1
90. SECTION NUMBERS (ONLY IF CHARGED)
TC HIC
UNIT2
"""' .,.,'91. 'PROBABLE
'""Bt>" '-" USE
I UNIT 1
M-4SC (1/92)
: 92. )TYPE
f---/TEST
o 0
o 0
~ESULTS DNOTEST~1. ROBABLE ~';'PE ~ESULTS DNOTEST GO.INVESTlGATlON
o REFUSE USE TEST 0 REFUSE COMPLETE ?
0.__0/0 0 UNK UNIT 2 0.__0/0 0 UNK YES 1&1 NO D
PAGE: ~f' 7 CENTER FOR HIGHW.V SAFEIV
ACC.ICL^:T Re=wT it /4'\-'11
c23 JUl_ Y q', 12f(" IH~-"j
TwF fOJ..ICC D~ pr
5".)./5'
I /' SMA~t t:118/lNi'r-li./'l r
,~::: l
'\ Pr 0/--
~MP"G'T
PMt::ll BcR'"
[I]
~
d.."." '._.
ReAD
-.
.----
--
PAvt::ll B::RM
--
---
-.'----........'.-----,..-----
NOT ,0 <;CALE'
N
J
I, 5.di7 ~l l
I l<
i
,
I:
,
\
,
,
0,
)
,.
~
------
/. z.. I
l:>"A.c:.H~~T"A. ~o"b-..
r,
5;}.13
1
f1J
1___~=I5' I
~')" I r------
~ ~ /'~ SM^~L E:1'lE<ANKM(""'"
~ &"~ /. ",.," l
~ , 6~
!.:;~ M
t:::J '\ I...!!
'--
~
-.
-......... ......-
/'l\AN H41.~ 0
(.ovlC" -
PMEb 13.:.~""
-~
-------- --.--.-.-
-..-"..--
't/ERT7-VILL-f: ROAD
5,,- '14-4-
-.....--
PAvt:/> BeR.M
-
-..----------.____0...
N
;.
, \
.
,
I, ~~/7l
: .
o
I
I
I ~'
I .,. i
"-- . '.
---I,
I
-,
,
_______ i
!',
/lap.cHe:: srt:.r.;, R~A])-'"
k
NGT To SCALE
PMC {" .'P 7
\ 5J.13
\
\
rr)
J
.N
j
\ 5J J ;==-1
i
\
i
I
1
Ac..G1D~Ni Rf:'f"hl 'Ii: /4.9--:::7
~3 :fL1LY en 1;l4(P H~S
~~ :l
-------- --
~
~.
'-
------
rn
::-I/JAL RtST
fOSIT'lONS
---.----
NOT 'TO SC.P,I..[
0J
pfiYSI<.ftL
E'i I DE Nt:.€
....-.
-""-
Ne'T TO sc.r;LE
5" d- I 5" ,'_ I
._ __. ., .'" ,I
.- --\....~.
, ~...
t "\, \. ~
,\~.:-. .
~\,';'
~ ~ i .
"'~",., ~ \, ",.
" ' ,\(',)0 , .
~'\lv .....'y
I'~:;;' ~_....~'\O\
[]... ar
.,
'. "- .
!
Dj
\
Jlf\AN".\,.~ -0 r;-;;;:-..z. - "-
(.QVC!;. L.::.:..:J"
~
y./ERT:l.VIL.l-€' p.eAD
SF. H.4-
.-........ .
~.----
-----
" -"-'--"'-~~------' ...--
\ 5J. 13
('4 ~ tt~o,
4{;, ",P
'r, .e "'.
'':
5" d- I 5"l.9.9;>
-
.
--, ---
N
f
\
J
[ 5~1 7
C I V~ is:
i
\
I
\
I
"0
o
1'". I
so> \
GOtAC:,C ~1. 0,_...
,
I
~
\
D
i~
-----=-
------ -.
-~
--
------
""''''''''H4'-!:_0
c.QYC~
'" (,(JuC.l ~ I
.__._._ _a~" ,.a__ __.... .._ . ...
-_"_0'. .,. .'__
y./ERT:l.VIL.l-€' ReAD
5,,, ~ f4-
.-
-\
_....-- .
--.---------------. .
---------
PIIC; '7 cF 7
VElUnl'AnO~
(icllrgc' II I',dkl. .II, hquir." III' Ihe lif'lll of ~1:\RTS01\ IlI'ARIlORI:F
WII.L1t\~IS .\: OTTO. alltllllL'Y' li'r Ikli:ndanl in Ihc wilhin actjlln. ccrtilics that thc stalcmcnts
made in the forcglling Dcfcndant's Rcsponse to I'laintil'i"s :Ylolilln to Compel Rcquests for
Admissions are truc :111" corrccl hI Ihe bcst or his knowledgc. inlof'll1alion and helieI'. Hc
undcrst:mds that falsc statements hcrcin are made subjccttothe penalties of I X Pa, c.s, Section 4'J04
relating to unsworn 1:t1silicalillnto authoritics.
I
~
I
,
MI:I.ANII: \\'AI.I.;\('I:.
I'lainlil r
I:'-JIIII., COI il{ I OF ('O~IMOt\ I'II';\S 01,
('II\IIlI'.I{(.t\t\1> CO( NI Y.I'I':'-Jt\SYIV.\t\I;\
\'s,
'IX-ill 70 CIVIl.
CIVIL ACTION LAW
ElJ(iENE WIN(iIXI.II and
MARCIA SIIAIIIJl-:R.
Co-Executors of the !'STAr!'
OF DOROTIIY WIN(il':RT.
Ilcfcndants
JlJR Y TRIAl. D!'MANDED
j
t
,
IN RE: PI.AINTlFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL
ORDER
AND NOW. this
'r
day of July. 1999, a brief argument on the plaintiffs
motion 10 compel is sct for Thursday, August 5. 1999. at 2:00 p.m. in Courtroom Numbcr 4.
Cumbcrland County Courthousc. Carlisle. P A.
BY TilE COURT.
George 13, Faller. Jr.. Esquirc
For the Defendants
/(.[ All
7"=J
C"'J'lU: -t. ./}..".u,C '1/ 'i{r, (t.
~"" ~'
James DeCinti. Esquire
I' or thc Plainti 1'1'
:rlm
i
I,
'I
'.
L'
I
~
i'
'p ,.~,
.' .l!
",r r II ,I I,; ;:: c; ~
I"
Ii
,\
~
,:-'
~~
,
,
I'
,
..
,
;
i
i
.
\
\\
.~
,
~ )
,
., !
I.
"
t..,.
..'
E1JCI.;rn; ~'JlN(;!':lI'l'. ! I dnl ~':;l1i"J/\
:;IlAUDER, l'u EXt'('ut (Il~; (d Ill"
ES'j'I,TE uF IJ\.J;~\ llii'l' i-/ I lJ' ;U(i
'; ') I;, /\1''1' I( in Li,','J
tJlEt.i\NIE ....ud.r.N'E.
! ii THE ('( ll1i<T OF ('()~-1W}N I'LEr\:;
r ': J;'!\lJ':HI./\tlIJ ('OUtlT'I PENN:;YI,VMJ I ^
l'l,lll1t 111
::) 'jH 1,1"/1) CIVIL TE1~1~
,11))(,' I'J~ltd, 1)I'J-1^~JlJJ.:IJ
PLAINTIFF'S MO'tIQILTO..C0.IolP.ELRE.,---R.EQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS
, I
, ,
Pl<1intiff, by <111<1 thro\lq!1 IiI'I <tl torn!'yr~, 11l}rC'by move thi[i Honol-able
t
I
Court to cornpt!J De(l~tlddIH:;' to /\ll:~'''''t'r Pl.lintit l':j l{f~quer;t tOl- Adrnir.;[;ionG, und
avers as follows:
,
.
1. Plaintiff fi l-.d !1pr- 1")mpldJ:lt i:J thi:-: action on October .29, 1998,
2, This case involv(~n a motor vehicle collision that occurred on
July 23, 1997, on Route 94.1 Ea"t (\'lerL,ville Road). Hampden Township,
Cumberland County,
3. On February 5, 1999, Defendants' decedent filed an Answer with New
Matter to Plaintiff's Complaint along with a counterclaim.
4, On March 26, 1999. Plaintiff served upon Defendants'
decedent
~
iJ
I'
,
Request for Admissions-Set I, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit
A.
.,
".
5 .
On May 3.
1999,
Defendants'
decedent served Answers to
Plaintiff's Request for Admissions, a copy of which is attached hereto as
Exhibit B.
6. Defendants' decedent answered Requests 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 10
with the following statement:
After reasonable inquiry, the answering defendant is
without knowledge or information sufficient to admit
or deny this request.
See, Exhibit B.
.t
. '
,
,
7, Rule 4014(b) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure states,
in relevant part:
1525,13/W\R
'.0(
,
'I'll" ,l!::.'......: ::ll,lll ,Idllllt 01' d','n,' th., ::1.1' ~ /'1 (Jl :;..t
ICill1l III d..t,.il Ill,. !P"~;()!l:; '....il',. tlJ" -Il:::'..../'! In'l p,lllj'
Collll\()1 tl~l!ld11!1'/ eLl ::(). i\ d"1l1dl ::ll,.ll 1,1111i' 1::""1
tlJl' !.llfJ::!,jllt'" cd 11\1' !"fllll'::t/'d dd::11::::1"Il, Ill,1 '....l1.'1l
quod t.J1th :";r1lt..:; Uldt ,\ Pd!tj' qll.d1tj' Ill:: .Ill:;......'l
en df'llj' nllli' !1.lrl cd th.., lTldtt..! of ".,.hleb IU: IIhll:::;JOL
i:: n'qw,:.t,'d. I,l' ~;h,d I :;pl'r:lfi' ,;0 lt1\H'h 0: II d:; 1"
Ii'll!' d!ld qUd 11: '/ (>1 d!~llj' till' 1"1:1'1 lllik'l r~ll_ ,11l:;:~"'I.~I,l'J
11. ,1)J_r_,I!~',I.j'.,) 1~ !,l_':.EY-'- '_. J _c!E_:~~---.SLLU! ~...!n~.:.!,~ u.)! L'<,~ l~_ ~~,1,1 'I~~J.' .'.\ ,I :J,~ .
:..l1.:.-:..Ll~_:~~,~ 'lL__..! ,,! f .11 1 ~ln~ tG .1d:n i I tJl~_'J:~_u.:L._!J.!1Lr.:l~.!_:
nIdI!'.'; t/:,Jt hI' lid.'; mdcle d n'd!;pnlid," in(lllW~Eu.L~!l
l.fu.2_i.!.)fnllr~,-lt lC1ll kllot\'ll 0r readi ]v ()ht<lllldhI~l l)~' !Ji:~~
111!illfficil'llt tCl t'lldhlt> him to admit 01' ~~.
Respectfully submitted,
See, Pa, R,C,P, .101.1, (Empha:;ir; ::upplied.l
8, Under Rule .~Ol.1 (b), De[enddnts' d('cedt.!llt':,: t\n~,~'''''t.'l' to Pldintiff's
Request for Adrnh:sioll!:, number!j 2, 3, '1, S, G, ", and 10 ,]r(! insufficient.
9. Defendants' decedent should be compelled to either admit or den)"
Plaintiff's request numbered 2, 3, '1, 5, G, 7, and 10, and/or otherwise
properly answer same.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that De(endcJ.nts' decedent
be required to properly answer Plaintiff's Request for Admissions, numbers
2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, ilnd 10.
'.
& ROVNER, P.C.
,
,
,
DATED:lj-v/71
I~ames DeCinti, Esquire
Attorney 1.0, No. 77421
4503 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
Attorney for Plaintiff
\
~
i
t
! \
I
I
2
CERT.IUc:ArE. _OJ-:_!l.F:.RVJ;.c:~
I, t/lcgan 1\. Reinard, an (~lnploy(!c of ^n9ino ~( HavIler, P.C.,
hereby cert i fy that. ;] t ru(, illld con'(,cl copy of the foregoing
Requests for Admissions Directed to Defendants - Set I was served.
by United States first-class mail, pos'i::age 'prepaid, upon the
following:
George B. Faller, Jr.. Esquire
Martson, Deardorff, Williams & Otto
10 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Dennis Bonetti, Esquire
Peters & Wasilefski
2931 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
-~OXl Q e-Quf\aAd
Megan A. Re1nard
Dated: ?:> lci-S \ '1 q
lD
t:
lD
:E
~
f '1IlJ.'s'lJ"lAnLl' fIlA\'[){)(" n61t ^~S :'.
('IUI'" O';II1.""O~ 11'1 t.rM
iltotlN O,,1)~WOl"'lr"
)O'lOtlt
MELANIE WALLACE,
Plaintiff
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 98-6170 CIVIL TERM
EUGENE WINGERT, II, and MARCIA
SHAUDER, Co-Executors ofthc
ESTATE OF DOROTHY WINGERT,
Dcfcndants
JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMANDED
ANSWFRS TO PI.AINTIFF'S REQIJFST FOR ADMISSlQl'iS
1. Admittcd.
2-6. Allcr reasonablc inquiry, thc answering Defcndant is without knowledgc or
information sufficicnt to admit or dcny this requcst. It is admitted, howcvcr, that thc dcccdent,
Dorothy Wingcrt, was thc owncr of thc 1991 Chevrolct Cavalier that was involved in thc aceidcnt
on Wertzville Road at thc stated date and time.
7. After reasonable inquiry, the answering Defendant is without knowlcdgc or
information sufficient to admit or dcny this rcquest. Dcfendants do, however, intcnd to scck copies
of any photographs which are or would bc availablc to detcrmine the extent of thc damage to both
vehiclcs.
8. Admittcd with the qualification thatthc violence ofthc collision was caused at least
in part by the fact that the Plaintiff was traveling in excess of the posted speed limit on a day in
which conditions wcrc less than optimal.
9. Admitted.
10. After reasonable inquiry, the answering Defcndant IS without knowledge or
information sufficient to admit or deny this request.
11. Admitted.
By
George B. Faller, Jr., Esquire
I.D. Number 49813
Ten East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013-3093
(717) 243-3341
aEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO
LN~,
Date: J J 3/ i7
Attorneys for Defendant
CERIJ.flCATE OESERYlCE
I, Nicholc L. Mycrs, an authorizcd agent of Martson Deardorff Williams & Otto, hcreby
ccrtify that a copy ofthc forcgoing Answers to Plaintiffs Request for Admissions was served this
date by dcpositing samc in thc Post Officc at Carlisle, P A, first class mail, postage prepaid,
addressed as follows:
James DeCinti, Esquirc
ANGINO & ROVNER, P.c.
4503 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1708
MARTSON DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO
By nlcJ~f?1? /t(JY
Nlchole L. Mycrs .
Ten East High Street
Carlisle, P A 17013
(717) 243-3341
Dated:)h 11 c:;
,
I'
r
h
'.
i
,
\
.
:~
t '
. i
, '
i
I,
I
1\
k
MELAN IE ;IALLACE,
I N TilE ('OiIHT OF ('Or.1WJN PLE/\S
CU:'1HEf<LANlJ ('()lJN'j'"{ PE~HJ~;'{r:/AN IA
PLlinti![
v.
NO. (JH (,l'!U ell/II. TEP;.'
EUGENE ;11 Nr:ERT, [I cHid [,IAH(' I A
SHAUDER, Co~ExeC:\Itol"s of thl~
ESTATE OF DOHOTHY ;IlNGEHT
('I~JIL i\C'TI~):l I,N,;
JURY Tk Ifd. Ul,;rIJANtJELJ
i
I
I
11
II
II
I
I
PLAINTIrF'S MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF
MOTION TO COMPEL RE: REOUEST FOR ADMISSIONS
This case involves the collision of two motor vehicles on ~Jertzville
Road, Hampden Township, Cumberland County, on July 23, 1997,
A Complaint
in the action was filed on October 29, 1998. An Answer with New Matter and
Counter Claim was filed on February 5, 1999, Plaintiff filed Request for
Admissions upon Defendants' decedent on Narch 26, 1999. Defendant's decedent
filed Answers to Plaintiff's Request for Admissions on May 3, 1999,
Rule 4014 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure sets forth the
requirements for an answer to a Request for Admission.
In relevant part,
Rule 4014 (b) states:
. ,. The answer shall admit or deny the matter or set
forth in detail the reasons why the answering party
cannot truthfully do so. A denial shall fairly meet
the substance of the requested admission, and when
good faith requires that a party qualify his answer
or deny only part of the matter of which an admission
is requested, he shall specify so much of it as is
true and qualify or deny the remainder. An answerinq
oartv may not qive lack of information or knowledqe
as a reason for failure to admit or deny. unless he
states that he has made a reasonable inauirv and that
the information known or readily obtainable bv him is
insufficient to enable him to admit or deny.
Pa. R,C,P. 4014, (Emphasis supplied,)
Defendants' decedent's answers to Plaintiff's Request for Admissions,
numbers 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 10 are insufficient under Rule 4014 in that
Defendants' decedent has indicated that he is without knowledge sufficient
to enable him to admit or deny the request,
However, Defendants' decedent
does not indicated that he has made any inquiry, let alone
a reasonable
152545/MAR
10. ,irp in:aJff ICI"lI!
!),.j":I,JI:,'
" , " , ,. " , I''''', ;..: 'll\,llll " 1\" ""\"1.' "
;, ~ " I"" " , ,; , " I, dll,l
" '.
,I" I, " :11 , ld c(JIll!J"l I,.d t " ,100ml t ot'
tUqllll'/ 111l-,) t !lr' l':::\Il':;, ';'~i;j
1\11::.......I~; t r) PI d Illl I t I '" j;"'jljlo:"
dl'ny Pl d lilt i j f ':: P"q\l'.:~t
!'ll
1\,1::11
"ll:'
: ; , I:' ~
'1::
'.
,1.
'"
(,,"
,Illd 10.
,
"
Ii
"
"
I'
I
I
II
I
1"'::lil' '1 ! Illl 'r' :;\d)!!I1 tt,'d,
!,:H;rt~') t. PO'.JNER, P,C,
I
!
/'0--......-
.Lllt!.':; Dt~CiIlti, E~;quil"e
At! '.~!..Il':'Y I.[). No. 77.121
.j tj03 Nr..lL"th Front Street
Harri:;bll.rq, PA 17110
Attorney for PlaiIltiff
DATED'I/7/('1Cj
2
CERTIFICATE OF DERVICE
I, r"lI'qdIl A. P"lll.lld. ,1:1 "!T\ld"i"'" ,': 1\11'111l' .. I/I":Il"I, I' (' , Ip'llOll/,
eel-tiff llldt d UilI' dlld Clll l'",'t ""1"/ 'd ! ll" t 'l"'! 'Ill'! P.LAINTIFF'S MOTION__T.Q
COMP~~J~I!~Q..t!.E!_~:r."_FOIL^OMIS.sIONS '#L:; ::"I'Jpd, 1,'/ IIlll!"'! ;;1,.,,':; Ill:;! ('ldn:;
m,lil, po~;tdql' PI'!'p.II,I, 1l!)(i1} Ill.' 1rlll"'I'o'lll"
Ct!orqc II, F,.11I'r. .; I ., E;;qu; l"
r.1aL'lson, Dl'llnhll II , ',Ii 11 i,II:I:: i( (ill (J
10 East High Sl n~'I'L
Carlisle, PA l'101J
Denni.s Bonetli, E~:;qtlirf~
Peters & Wasilef[jki
2931 North Front St['CeL
Harrisburg, PA 17110
tn~CLn 0.. '-if2.o. l..Y\lL~
r'tegan ;.... Reinard
Dated: T lex \'1 q
. . ::; ..,('f'::;j::::t;:~~
Jrt!i,1 ;,j:<' ,.:', ~ ,.,,", <.; ,-", t"'.Jf,~_'<. ~."'J'{"t~1 !fi'M~1
/:'" ~ It".'; '-"'~7.;~'ll"'V~J;';~\'I.:i':'-.r. ;t.':::~M~Jf;
.,t:}{~~~:~}f~~E~~~!;;:~'~';:, ;~f5i:1f}it:D;~\[?k~~
;~.}:irfq~_;1rr:;~:W::'~5::W~~f?~~f,~~
:>,~ ~ ,,>"f'" ,[j~.... i-( I; ",,:~"j ~',l,.~
, I v 0" """<-'cl,L:j..
". ",,_', _,I.': '';:J,,':'.' '\'," "/1\ lr ~t
" ".';' ..~;l1t~';"l"t";,.:,{}~:,,~"'~l;t~
. ' , ' , t,., ,"., '" '"'j'" ~ ~ ~f!/{'
MELANIE WAI.I.ACE.
I'laintill
INIIIE COllin or ('O~I~ION I'I.I'AS 01
CI i;..f/lI':I{I.:\NI> COI iNTY. I'I:NNSYIV..\NIA
VS.
')H-I,J 'Ill ('IVII.
CIVIL AC liON - LAW
EUGENE WIN(jFRT. II and
MARCIA SIIAUDER.
Co-Excculors of the ESTATI.:
OF DOROTIIY WIN(jERT.
Dcfcndants
,1UR Y TRIAL DEMANDED
IN RE: I'I.AINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL
ORDER
AND NOW. this
'/ . ' day of August. I I)!)!). the motion of thc plaintiff to compel
answers to the plaintiffs requestli1r admissions is DENIED.
BY TilE COURT.
Georgc B. Faller, Jr.. Esquire
For the Delcndants
/
A 1./
.-.. " I . , ':"1
_ ' ,.t.- /,' 1-
Kevin,A. IIess. J.
/
/
,
,,.:::'d.L ;/9/'1 '1 .
.....5 .1-~
Jamcs DeCinti, Esquire
For the Plaintiff
c "'j'~ ~
:r1m
MELANIE WAU,ACE,
I'laillliff
1:\ TilE COURT OF CO~I~lON PLEAS
CIJ:YIIlERLAND ('OU",TY.
I'ENNSYLV ANIA
v,
EUGENE WINGERT, II, and MARCIA
SHAUDER. Co-Executors of thc
ESTATE OF DOROTHY WINGERT.
Dcfendallls
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
1'0.: 98.6170 CIVIL TERM
()JWER
AND NOW. this ~ day of _ tJ~d"V
, 19 ff , upon consideration of the
Oral Motion to Discontinue the counter. ~aim in the above captioned matter pursuant to 20
P.A.C,S,A. 3323 (b)(l), said Motion is g :tnted. Eugene Wingert. II and Marcia Shauder, co-
executors of the Estare of Dorothy Wing ,rt are hereby authorized to execute an appropriate
Release to conclude this matter. The f~othonotary is hereby directed to mark the above
captioned matter Settled. Discontinued, au] Ended.
By thc Court:
IIi
Judge
i .
-
[,
- 0' --
u. c'"; ~--
~; :.-->:
't~ S' c, ;,~~~
u~~ L. :c ,:-,.;-:
, '.
'()(' .,,:,,~ ~:':J
,...., ..~ ,,:> ,,'1
t.':'l'-" (...;; .. -~
.-,.1, t- ...,-
l~' W ,'J\U
" 0 _:U""_
'6 <J"l _:)
'" <.)
(I HI 111(' \ II, (l/ SII{Vf( 'I
I. \k!!;1ll ,\, Ikill;lfd, anl'lllplo~<'l' ol,\1If'1I1tl.\: HOllier. I' (' . IIl'rl'h~ Il'lll1~ Ihat a Irlle and
l'Om..'l't l..'Opy ofthl..' Ji.1rl'!-':tling \\.1'.. '1.:1'\,:d II: I 'lllh..'d Still'" li,...l-,.:!.I...... IlJ;lil. fln"l.!!'l' prepaid. upon
thl'li'"(\l\ill!!:
(jcorge II, Fallcr. Jr.. I\qllirc
Martson Ilcardorli' Willi;lll1S'\: ()1I0
10 East Iligh Strccl
Carlisle.I'A 170!.1
Denllis lIonclli. I'slluirc
I'eters & Wasilclski
2931 North Front Slrecl
Harrisburg. I' A 17110
{, \ :"11 J
-~__-'-1______
Mcgan A Reinard
I : I . , '.--e!__
Datcd: I I), Inl
rF,",
;'J;:;!_;~: ,-
, ,
" ',,' I, '.', '"
. ,. -, . - '-, .., -~ -. ,~- - .,-, ~ ", -,.- ,- 'o' - ~