The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About98-06225 ~ ,Q.. il/) I I ! . . Jl 17' i i i I~ 13 '-;:t:. ~ ~ 'J ILO ic6 lei I ~ SHOLLENBERGER & JANUZZI, LLP 1820 Linglestown Road P,O, Box 60545 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17106-0545 Telephone Number: (717) 234-3700 Fax Number: (717) 234-8212 AHorne s for Plaintiff, CHERYL T, HARDY CHERYL T, HARDY, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. KEVIN J, SPAAN Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED NOTICE LE HAN DEMANDADO A USTED EN LA CORTE, Si usted quiere defenderse de estas demand as expuestas en las paginas siguientes, usted liene veinte (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de la demanda y la notificacion, Usted debe presentar una apariencia escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en la corte en forma escrita sus defensas 0 sus objeciones alas demandas en contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, la corte tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previa aviso 0 notoficacaion y por cualquier queja 0 alivio que es pedido en la peticion do demanda, usted puede perder dinera 0 sus propiededas 0 otras derechos importantes para usted. ~ I I !,i ,', " LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO IMMEDIATAMENTE. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO 0 SI NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL, " I ii CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION 2 LIBERTY AVENUE CARLISLE, PA. 17013 (717) 249-3166 \: " SHOLLENBERGER & JANUZZI, LLP 1820 Linglestown Road P,O, Box 60545 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17106-0545 Telephone Number: (717) 234-3700 Fax Number: (717) 234-8212 Attorne s for Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY CHERYL T, HARDY, Plaintiff , \ , " IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA l J f. KEVIN J, SPAAN Defendant NO, (h ('.) :', CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COMPLAINT v, AND NOW comes the Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, by and through her attorney, SHOLLENBERGER & JANUZZI, LLP, and does respectfully represent the following: 1. The Plaintiff, CHERYL T, HARDY, is an adult individual who currently resides at 20 Bertha Drive, Steelton, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania 17113, 2, The Defendant, KEVIN JAMES SPAAN, is an adult individual whose last known address is 651 West Lisburg Road, Apartment C, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17055, 3, The facts and circumstances hereinafter set forth took place on the Carlisle Pike, Hampden Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania at or about 1 :45 p,m, '\ I', I; , , I I, I, I 4. At the aforesaid time and place, the Defendant, KEVIN JAMES SPAAN, was the operator of a 1990 Nissan Sentra XE which he co-owned with his wife Christi:1e Spaan, 5, At the aforesaid time and place, the Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, was travelling east in the eastbound lane of the Carlisle Pike, Hampden Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 6, At the aforesaid time and place, the Defendant, KEVIN JAMES SPAAN, was travelling west in the left turn lane of the Carlisle Pike, Hampden Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, when he drove his vehicle into Plaintiff's ,l rr I ! ' I 1 '..''\, lane of travel and struck her vehicle head on, 7. As a result of the aforesaid collision, Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, has suffered serious and permanent injuries, including but not limited to the following: Acute sprain and strain of the muscles, tendons, ligaments and other soft tissues at or about the cervical spine; , , Acute sprain and strain of the muscles, tendons, ligaments and other soft tissues at or about the thoracic spine; Acute sprain and strain of the muscles, tendons, ligaments and other soft tissues at or about the lumbosacral region; Aggravation of left carpal tunnel syndrome; Aggravation of right carpal tunnel syndrome: Contusions of both knees: Contusion of the forehead; Severe headaches; Severe shock to the nerves and nervOUS system; and, Mental and physical anguish. COUNT I CHERYL T. HARDY v, KEVIN JAMES SPAAN 8, Paragraphs 1 through 7 of Plaintiff's Complaint are incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof as if set forth in full. 9, The aforesaid collision was a direct and proximate result of the negligence of Defendant, KEVIN JAMES SPAAN, in operating his vehicle in a careless, reckless and negligent manner as follows: (a) In operating his vehicle at an excessive rate of speed under the circumstances; (b) In failing to have his vehicle under proper and adequate control; (c) In failing to apply his brakes in time to avoid a collision; (d) In failing to observe Plaintiffs vehicle lawfully traveling east in the eastbound lane on the Carlisle Pike; 2 (e) In turning in such a manner as to endanger Plaintifrs vehicle traveling on the Carlisle Pike; (f) In failing to observe oncoming traffic; (g) In failing to have yielded half of the highway to Plaintiffs vehicle; (h) In failing to keep his vehicle within the proper lane; (i) In operating his vehicle in a careless manner in violation of 75 Pa. C.S.A. Section 3714; and, Ul In otherwise operating said vehicle in a careless, reckless, and negligent manner and in a manner violating the Motor Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. 10. As a direct and proximate result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, has undergone and in the future will undergo great pain and suffering for which damages are claimed. 11. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, has suffered and may continue to suffer a loss of earnings for which damages are claimed. 12. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, had and/or may in the future incur expenses for medical treatment and rehabilitation for which damages are claimed. 13. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, has and/or may in the future incur a loss of earning capacity for which damages are claimed. 14. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, has sustained a permanent diminution in her ability to enjoy life and life's pleasures for which damages are claimed. 15. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, has incurred or may hereinafter incur financial expenses and loss which exceed sums recoverable under the limitations and exclusions of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law for which damages are claimed. 16. As a further result of this collision, Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, has and may in the future incur reasonable and necessary medical and rehabilitative costs and expenses in excess in the amounts paid or payable pursuant to 3 Subchapter B of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehiclc Financial Rcsponsibility Law, Workers' Compcnsation or any program. group contract, or othcr <Jrrangcment for payment of bencfits as defined in 75 Pa, C,S,A. Section 1719. 17. Plaintiff is covcred by the full tort option undcr her motor vehicle inSllmnce policy with State Farm Firc & CasuLllty Company, A copy of the declaration page is attached hereto as Exhibit "A." WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, CHERYL T. HARDY, demands judgment against the Defendant, KEVIN JAMES SPAAN, for compensatory damages in an amount in excess of the amount requiring compulsory arbitration. Respectfully submitted, SHOLLENBERGER & JANUZZ/, LLP Dated: November 2, 1998 4 Y 1 Z 1 1 1991 ACURA S523.58 LIABILITY: BODILY INJURY 50.000/100.000 PROPERTY DAMAGE 50.000 125.97 FUNERAL BENEFITS 2.500 .85 MEDICAL PAYMENT 10.000 22.95 COMPREHENSIVE 113.90', 250 DEDUCT COLLISION 202.13 ' EMERGENCY ROAD SERVICE 3.60 CAR RENTAL/THAVfL EXP 21.60 UNINSURED M010Rl~T BODILY INJURY 25.000/50.UOU UNDER INSURED MOTORIST BODILY INJURY 25.000/50.000 DEATH INDEMNITY LOSS OF INCOME 1.000/5.000 \,AJ ~ I '" I t: I''''HIYII'IHt: "'I~U l;A::.UAL I Y l;UliIt'AIH 1":-;~IlU"'"(" CON~ORD.Y..!.ILLl: ,~,.;'?-33-Y~~.Q'~'~'7_";...,..,, I S94 6736-A24-38B _.._T"II S ,I S ,NOT A III LL. THIS NOTICE IS PROVIDED FOR INfORMATION ONLY. CONTINUED PAYMENT OF YOUR MONTHLY BILL KEEPS THIS POLICY IN FORCE UNTIL JUL 24 97. .... . , ------.--[iJVII\^I.; \It,~II''' VEH A .. ID CARD(S) ENCLOSED .. 5 IJ -3596 F C2 I~ IRS \U W HARDY, CHERYL T 20 BERTHA DR STEELTON PA 17113-1201 1",111,,,1,,,11,,,11,,11,,,,11,,1,111,,,,,,11,,1,111,,,,,,III rOtJf pll'/IlIIIIIII:; l"'.~lld {!II /III' (tlJ/d~~JlllJ If Ill'l I ,"II', ' <"'11.1,/\1'11' .lllt'trl ,,,,.,, ",,,,,,,,,,,,. ,. ,,", ""',, , TOTAL PREMIUM THERE ARE NO DRIVERS UNDER AGE 25. .~, (.1,1',' 1 180011 U...,lu""y".,,,,,r'I'I"l.il' 1 PLEASURE OR UNDER 30 MILES WEEKLY TO AND FROM WORK OR SCHOOL. DRIVEN OVER 7,500 MILES ANNUALLY. (NATIONAL AVERAGE IS 10,000 MILES ANNUALLY.) DISCOUNTS--THE PREMIUM AMOUNT HAS ALREADY BEEN REDUCED BY THE FOLLOWING: (1) AIR BAGS $13.25 (1) STANDARD RISK $138.70 --------------------------------------------- , ADDITIONAL INFORMATION i STATE FARM PAYMENT PLAN NUMBER IS 0330263613. I I THE LAWS OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, AS ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY, ! ONLY REQUIRE THAT YOU PURCHASE LIABILITY AND FIRST-PARTY MEDICAL BENEFIT COVERAGES. I ANY ADDITIONAL COVERAGES OR COVERAGES IN EXCESS OF THE LIMITS REQUIRED BY LAW ARE i PROVIDED ONLY AT YOUR REQUEST AS ENHANCEMENTS TO BASIC COVERAGE. THE PREMIUM FOR I BASIC LIABILITY COVERAGE OF $ 15,000/30,000/5.000 AND MEDICAL PAYMENTS COVERAGE OF $ 5,000 IS $ 114.92. i THIS POLICY PROVIDES FULL TORT OPTION. I I I I I , i 7l~ It fett-,;,! '" 'iJt>iJ /"'". , , i~genl J 1M WAS H I NGTON, J R ,re/ephone 717-240-0775 IF YOU HAVE A NEW OR OIFFERENT CAR, HAVE ADDED ANY DRIVERS, OR HAVE MOVED PLEASE CONTACT YOUR AGENT,. 'a;]'IlSURED HARD y, CHERYL T on"," POLICY NUMBER 594 6736-A24-38B WARNING. . . AllY persoll WilD 1~lln\Nillqly ;11111 willi IJlll~ll! It) illjtlll! ur (h~llllud illlY irl~;Utel 111(>:; iJll npplicatiull ur claim containing any false, incomplete or lIli~;I(,,,t1I1Hlllill,>III1<lIH)1I "llIlll. LlpUII cUllviclioll, IJD suiJjoclllJ illlprisolllllGnl for up lu seven years and paYll1enl of a fino olup I" :,; I !,.IH HI See reverse side tor important information. Please keep t"is part for your record. .. '., lJA1F DlII i'lr^';r: PAY TillS AI;10u~rr THIS IS NOT A BILL. I EXHIBIT>;;:: "fr:,::()};' ,::~:~.:';(i~./':.:f1.;,i::i.~~4~~!~i; II'GION^LOFFlCEUSEONLY APP DATE 0305 1-1B0011 5E005 5 B 001022000 WASHINGTON JR.J 3596-382 0330263613 209702400000000 638502994673612113> II ,I " " , I II " I " I " , I I' Ii " I! I II Ii I I I I I 1f fr ).> s- AYY r n.a. v ('(' C011110lfWEALTlI OF PEIItlSYLVANIA COUNTY OF DAUPlIIIl ~s I, OIERYL flo\RDY ________~,' being duly sworn accorclng law deposes and says that ~i\\~;.w,: the Plaintiff the foregoing action; that the facts and allegations contained herein are based upon facts given by the Pia i nt iff to lITV counsel and are true and correct to the best of r~ knowledge, information and belief; that the languc.ge of said OJrplaint, Interrogatories & to in Request for Prod. of Docurcnts is that of ffil counsel and that Plaintiff has relied upon counsel in making this Carplaint, Interrogatories & Request for Prod. of Docunents based upon Plaintiff's information. Sworn to and subscribed (}(j/5/' l,iff- before me, a Notary Public, tl:overrber this 2nd day of , 19~. 1...\\'(/ OfFlCES Of TIMOnlY ^. SI{OLLENnEllGER ISW L1NGI.ESTO\Y.'N ROAD . PO nox t!OS~5 . H..\RRISBURG, r..\ 17IC(J05~S (717) ZJ4.37iXl . FAX (717) 2J~..'H12 - ....,~::~,'..::~:s~; '\,'..:: ,'i<;<\' ",".' '''''', ',,' ;:;/,:;:':-, ,~ "l r".:;.';' ",:.... '-:'::;:::"-'~', .. , - --"'-0;;-.--,-; ,.. \ '.'-' .-: ;:~t,::,:.;\" ":~~:~". ,'.:i SHOLLENBERGER & JANUZZI, LLP 1820 Lingleslown Road P,O. Box 60545 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17106-0545 Telephone Number: (717) 234-3700 Fax Number: (717) 234-tl212 Altorne s for Plaintiff, CHERYL T, HARDY CHERYL T. HARDY, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v, NO. 98.6225 KEVIN J, SPAAN, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRJAL DEMANDED PRAECIPE TO REINSTATE COMPLAINT Please reinstate the Complaint with reference to the above-captioned acticn. Defendant Kevin J. Spaan can be found al340 North 19" Street, Camp Hill, Pennsylvania, Respectfully submitted, SHOLLENBERGER & JANUZZI, LLP IJ 11 / A/I,d! I,' t'(1,1;/1 JA1/1J-1/ By: LJ.,Ifi//J{j/,? (:iv',,"''"'''- 'L. ", Timothy A, Shollenberger, Esq, Attorney I.D. #34343 Dated: December 28, 1998 ":i. ,,::.:<,~,{: ~/j"/~ '~. .:'~:.' ,~-, , 'de <....-..,-. ..:~\.~~ :;;::J;:~!:::.:z:;~l.=:"~:-':~ . l":! ':""'\;~'f"~~ ,~,:. "", ~~~;,~;!,' : . !, ~~'.?~'[~;'~.,: r~;{L',:i, . --.-~-,-~....-._._- .,- ~. --,- ,~,:(;,;;:~,~,~~~,,'~,'r:; ,'.,:\:::,~:,:" ,l ,', :',~:. , T.P;'''~'' I-l....~'."., .,.,.". :..,-' .;" ( :,:" ~;6.~,;.i"t'):~,'t:;",;:"",~:,, .',: J:..,.f. ",.--.,JL.f ' . """, , . > . riiSi.;,fl.,:;1~,i l:~:'>f-, ,'; ...,1> :',J '. ,~, .' -' <"; ~..' ," '. . t~:"'.,f;~,"p'. .,',,'/:,'....,.' ~f'<"""' '/~~",. ~_ . " 0> "~i~j,ts " """i'!&'l,\;.,. -~ , ., 'j, "t,1 t ,\ ,.~,., 'j, "'J' '-'.:,.t . j , ' ~ , ',:, ~;i~::{; '..~; " I~;,\i ':~\~ ',f. .~:,:..~"~...:'~~: .,~, ' u.. _,____, ~_..".. ;, ;'.J'0;~J~~,f/{~?j " ..-':'I."'I,,,'7/~i!~A.'';7~'.l'~~\ ..-'~ .-""" 1(" ,)1''''/,'11"..",,,, :'~" ,.J"--! "..\,:,p\- "f"t".~~j)' '. ". ~ ::,.~:,:'~';:~~~~~\t2~f~tf:~Ur:~ '," .~;, '(V.v"", j"''Klt>L,.tt:r(i#,: '. ,,' ::' :;~,::~~t' ':;,':,-;,:~'~i.(\;;~:0i~~~%1 ".. ,.. '" 0"".., ~f$:; , . ' ,,' , ". ,;')1,:. ~~ I' ,.,::. b.:.'iC\,l'ii.;'-./i , , ,,,,";,< I "~f'i.~I.",. .,j ; ">,'/;; V..~(I~~:J " .~:;r:.et~ . ~,-,'t'''.~>. ,J'(fj ~)ji;;i i-JftdiJ " _,','J "'+~}~~~~~Ii.~f~~~~~l9:\';' ,'.' ;;,',. .." '-,' '.. ''- ,; . "," '~", ; .' ,:' > . , .. :;.: .i;::,:,~ .... ",{ ",::(\/:'1,", , "";J, " '\:- ," ':',":.:.,\:-':' 'I I ,~'" /:!: ~, ,~, . ~ 'i t ..'.. , .\. ::'"::,:.',':..',,,:,,' ::\:::".:,:;: ",' ':',;< ,.:' '0:':'.-. t";"'" ',~ ' r~,~,(<"~7.,:";/';~\~{, '>r,' 'U"'~'>:~."f'(";'''i. '" '. .:, "Ii, tid~\. /,; <.J'''ll"..~,;r~,~'i!r~" ' :,1;l?rJ.J.i;i~A)r.~<i:;:t,,'i ',\ ~<: :'(.,'~.::!: :;0/;;'~':::~fjS 0f{!~I,::'~~:'.1 '.~I't: ~;::}\ ~; '~:.',":l~;;'~' ..\',\ ,'\:' i , j~~~~~~ ~t!""""'r" h ", .',,,,,,.. i-. < :~k~!iiW1;~~:H;i~;H;~i ~~";V .~..~.,\~",.^:'" :',~ :"'--,'.' ~ "'.: d -' ' , '. . , '... - - " .. .,' .. . .. , . " 11\ 1111, ('OI:I{I III ('0\1\10:'00: I'll ,v, 01 (1 \1/11 HI \:'oo:Il('llI',I)',I'I'!\NSYI \',\~I" ('IIFRYI. (.IIARIlY, I'lalnlll'l ( '1\ Ii .\(llnll ~ 1,.1\\ \~. ~\ll. (}H.Sll-(,2~~ KFYIN 1. SI'AAN, Iklendant .II:R Y \RIAl. IlFMANI>FI> I'RAI'CII'I' FOR I':N'I'R Y OF o\1'1'.li.\R,'\;"( 'U'( :J{SI :ANT J'() l'a,IU ',I' 1 01 ~ TO Till' I'ROTIIONOTAR Y Kindly enler the appearance of Rohert A Lerman and Ann Margaret (;rah. Fsqll1re. of GrilTtth. S(riekler. Lerman. Solymos & Calkins. as attorneys lilf the Delendant. Kevin 1. Spaan, in the ahove-captioned matter and mark the docket accordingly. ) GRIFFITII, STRICKI.ER, LERMAN, SOLYMO;<; & CALKINl " J i 'J)I , , r BY / I~ A, Lerman Supreme Court ID No, 07490 j / ' /, 'r I!I ". Ann Margarct Grab Suprcmc Court ID No. 55986 Attorneys for the Defendant. Kevin J. Spaan 110 South Northern Way York, PA 17402 Telephone: (717) 757-7602 Date: February II. 1999 ... - - ~--- ~_. --.-~~,,--~-...' ,.j{~f;{.::1~~;!" .. ~~!:+\"':'.:" . bi..).~::;;x:.~.;::<,~~h-~i' ". I . . e. ~i;'~1\'-,~S;:.',:;,..",,',:;:,,~~,," '-,';',:J"'i":~":-""""~:':'~-'- + . . ':~_h:;-: --::~~~ - , '..o~'.~:;II -' '.'. ,,~. ' . .,' ;'::,~ -.',;".,~.~;,.-.~~~~.:~ ,,','~,'."/:.~~ A".-;.ooj 'li-.,-.i;',t,..-""" I "." :. " . _ ..... ,_ ~/ . :l:.!.:;~::~"I~~ "~'f:;,~-'! ""'y.l '"f\'.e,,~f.Sq1\".~ ~?it+,1,\l.~''t'h'''''~ ,...;', ,;~. '~-}lt:._}rt~~,~,~,~t,:-'i', . ",'i;A,-/.~');:;;t<:",'~e,;...-.,,', , ., .,.... '(i' .~ ."-.~",,...;.r.!f .~.. r~" -!i "~;"I' "':~'::;ll>..'~'''';.1t~f1t..'''~ ~{tJ;>,t '-01 ~.: ',I'jh~ > /" <". -" ,J v ~~ '~', , r~'l;. ......;\ ~:d.......,::!i ~.'4~}: ..,'f>,'.#~' '~,;(); I . ~,c;r ,. " ...;,. ';<"" r,,:m. 'jl~,tl.i J ~"...~.#t.', ( .' ", ".~:, "~~ "\"i"~~I:".\5i.~,1L{'~ ,.!i.~'~~1"~/!;':"::"'""V" ."~;> , ',,!, ~),:> ",,'l:#:\l:.:'!,l 1 ,"'" .. ',,' .~ ' ,,':~~:"'>,~':T:';/!i~'2~"~~;: ,~ t:::~: :,',i,:.~.{.~r,'t,?~,.'/:',:,';,.;,~,',:,:','" . ':, ;'\'::/;:~'}j?'~~~~i~1fj~ ,.,.. _:...:' -.,'lo!-;;:' - ' "..;'.:':',<:~:;._~ .i..~1 ,','~j~~;~,~!~'i.,u)~~).~~ "0,'fPf!, :-;T,.,]J ~".:~.,. 4 ,...t , ;J;.r\ >r:~'r ~.:: ~ -< z,' " ~,. , 'fJ~-:f1::~'7Jl-"',:--~~,;,,~,-,,~ "'. -' -'-', ,I; :tJ~.'f:)r,~:~~~,'~?714'~{:. . ""ft:~d"'lql:',:"'~~.'tt~~'r"r'" ~ :'~ ~ " ~ ,t:;"~):~",.j\:~~";~.:"''' fl., ~ .!'.t",~\,;o,", I";,.,;, '.\-~"'"' ....J"I.>~,c'r.... ~ .." .'j'l',I~ ", ..' ~ , ~~,:;';r,~~1~' "':"~~l '_' :'.r.tx"...... , \ S;~~" .<t1[J7ii~~~~,,"~:', :~" ': l' -';~, ,,-' ,'1> ~..~,.\t ;"'",...~ .., t . , ~:f~\f;J;i~li~)~~:'::;> "C; ','" '1:I~.,,> ..Xlt, "f.::'.,' '. {:&~~~~~{f.~:1t1}~~{:~k: .- "~~~';-" . ." ~rJ;:f~:;(:~j;':I'J(,' .'.,.c \.' .~. :,~i'j";'~'~ ':t -:0'.;,' ,,' '. '>l"';I.:L;.....""w~,.Jo-l!.,'4..,' , " ," '_';':";:', .':,; \.-;.-":;~~~,'(::,,';:~t'-.--""';.l,~'1'.., " .__ , ':.~~iX:. ,..;.;' ,-" :_ .;, ,~, ,;, ~ ,) . _, j -:". " " ,H~I;:lcr:~~'f'" ,.,;-:,... f".'.. > .....' ~ . .," , ,".'. ) - . i ." '.< <'f -,)1 ~. 'f '" :'.' '. I' " / .,,-,: :J ~','~/\'l' .,;,;1,.J' , \ ~':c::t::~,-::rr::.:..L.:.....:.-::.::~r.::';:2':':'-__:-:~", ;P '(" ';:,: , '. ..... '.J';i;';:'/::>'?' ,':'i,. ., .;.:;',J:',\' ,j'" '. f'."':~' '. '.." ~>" I '. .: : ":';" ,-,', '.~';'.':;" ':,'1;',' ";.. r:;' " ~. . : ;', ':;- ~', -\<-,,- :":.'.' " """,,:;-. ~.'" ; :\~:(;::--' "";,'. ".\ C," :~. I':/i" , ."-, i/ ,,".; ',',' :~~"i';.~:.~ (:)i '. . .\,'~'r::.:. "';:'-' - ' . ',~' . -. ~ (. ."." '.~ '~r\"'i~~""~';4~!ls.:4~ .':;;~::;'~i?;~;~*~~~ -~ ~.:_~~.~>~~:~,~:~:.j : ,':',-::":'::~::,;;:;:"''':"-;-~::;-~ ~,-; ;I.';;t~ 'J, ;\~':/::~:!~,i0'::~ ,.-". "1':[,1 . ., :".; :::;:~;~fit!ti '"., , '. '!;-tH,i'f1 ,1 . . - '1';, 1 ,-~^' 1:'\;1-~' . ' ' ~~<~::.f('(;;i? '" "I ..: :'_~i;I,~. :'/i;jIi~ .' I. ' '. ' _ .' .' . ~ . ". .', ' . '.' . I: , , ',."'. ',.,'",' , '", .' . 1/ ~~:TC- "fli" ',' ,..." rllo::;....,J,,'.. ';"',"~ , ,~"-(l~' ""'j' ~ry~1;: . .."_..:.-.,J;.'~i..J.',} "~.:~.~ '~";'"::'" c..'" ,;'. .~.' ,"" , :~~I';::~~,:~~::;~~~~j~ ;,',. ,,%'f,t,.;,c""\'''' '.'" "};I~i'""~'1\o"-': ''", . ,""" \'" l'1!;. , ~Ii( ; .'41 t' ~,.".~ ",' '.t' n., ,'," )', 'ii' !/~,'11flJ't\'.",,"'" ',,' " ,I fJ; ~,i;"~':J'l'::1.':I"" ,.,' ,,',', ,;,', ' ".,,' "d,,'..'A' " /'It''' ",,'''. : ,,',,-:.' " ,", ",,,,, ;J. , , ;~,j~~}'.?;:~({~:,~~'"i~:\"'; ',." ' ~l:l'~q'~''''I~'' ',".' '. '"' >', ,,,/,,:'::,~;,.~,,,:;",~,,t,'-"J;'.",,~:,,:..,~,I:,:'"":'~.:'::,;.'!",,,'i/'{:;"~~' wji:h;(?'~'.': ,r.:~:,' : ' "~=: t ,,',," .." ' " .,,~ ''Ii! "I' ~"~';V.' /.. , ' .Or,\I,~~,' ~;:t.;.-..'~\:.'~,,"'~"'~ d j,,' .,:," . .'.:c'~'l'f.'t ~",(';:t!/~;,-!'\ ,,',{, i ," ; " ' '" ' 7,':', ',i"",!,'';iI'j ,\'1,';'" ':i<l,:Jl,,-,,~\-",I""1 ' ';,~:," " -,.' _j,~Y/:":i.I'~' ~,'" "oN,' ",' . ". " " , ",,,,,..,,; ~m't2:""""I"" .:'''::'''''' ",'" '\'; " cr",..t":Jt:I'l~".(f..r;~ {li'\:""";;" d"', , -", ;;1"'" , ", ' . '-- ,. ''"'':I,ft;;: , ",::i:~.,..,.'h""~'~'(' ("..:.,;._ \ '",''' .,.".,:""".,"';t~"""~,,, -- '.'.,' :';'::'l/~~:;i'~'~:,"'::" , , ,,;';<~/{:~:;:r'~~''''' <l.J\."~ht,-j.~ . ,'r" ....,.,.\~:t~ \ ,',>" 1',,",,--: ' I ',' '-',' , ,;.-:",iI,' . """i./,' (:, ,_,' I . ,\ ,,,,,,~~t . ~),."v:o ',' . "... i' ,.. " I, .' .. ,.. 'c' " , ".,l.'~; ',' ".,' ,:" :'. "', " ' ,', '...". , '!f'~~IJ;,"; ,','" '" i' . --, /,:,''';' " """t, {",,' " ,J.,.- '" , ' "<,,,' "" 'I,' '"'~:"" "",,'__' ' "",' r~ , tl''J~I~'i/'':;'''':';''':'' .' ' . i",' .":,',r;:;"fi,I",,,.tll-'l.'i: t.....'l,...n" ."" ' >',' '.,' ,f';,,'.1."~"i1\;]: ,i."''''' .... ,,".' ..... .' , I~ >,'\-'l,:'''-'. I:-:,t ~i ",,,,,,,"", ..... ".t'. -" '" '," "," ,,, ..,C/o: ' .1 ~""f"")-':'~l!<:;'" ", .,' ';',': ;:' '.' ,'; ;;;r,r'}~t,~~~ . ",,:.\',:,:t,";<~ '.r" ,"". , :: '-' ,,' ..",,,'''';:',\~liv:r!;!1Ih~ '1>"'.",,",,'. :"': I. __ , " ,'...,"" ' " r , "'I.\,W"...~,('i1j ~",,;:,t'f"""I' .\",' ", ,.' ',.' ' " ,'I.' './1,.' ",:'.':};~ ,,'r:it' ,,",' . ~W,j-1~t):?!;:;::},;;:\:':[' .:' ." '~: '/:':, ::..,~,~:i{fi)~,~.f.f' ,,"",." /.''";("., '.<' ",' C' . , " ,:" ' ,,;',',"" ".~.,'",'" r~')'h'-'''''''- ',"" '" .'. ,'" ' \':" :, ",,",~,'i.,"" '. .'..,,",;qi,";' :'" ,','1 ' ' ...' " I,' ,. "'!Cr",,,' :}~::~;J:~~:j7:'/ ::',:,' .:. ';'~:,:<; <):':;: .;;>"~';!L ," " <,,,\:-;,,,;;:",:.,,1, :"{,:. ."'._ ,",' ,', ,,,,~,:"" y:':-f~:!,.J~Z!1J~ ;':"''''''''$[,';'::'''': ,',', ','" ' " ., ',;' ,. ."',, :';':'''''l",,;,~"J,:i 'r~" ,\;ei.~',"':il",\\,,'1'" ":" ,," ,,',',',..';,: ,v~:~",,""'.:f,:l. '" 'f\ ,;~I'l""';""":'"'' ',J,"''- ,',' , ',," ',,)W,:, ". ...,',\'i",';,'...., ;"I,f)!i,-l'l\ _,' ,,'::;:I~r,," " :" ..,t.' "', ' . ',if'"'' ,;;;(,",.,,;;.:~ "ill! ,,(...v,e.....'. I'"',,, ,',"',,,"','" ~"""':" ?;,\<j..~~: ";,:;' ,....;: ,:'i.,'. ,'\' ,"", ,. ':, ' ,.-""< ;";:;;'\'; ;"fl:s: i'!l .' "'r.';i~~);:::~',:~:>; ,':,"),',:: .:::<: L:\:h::V;;)?~i;';~,;~;' . _..... e~'&:.<'f'f/.\f!t:; ,,' ".\:,1....'. ;,:,.,~,'/;': I;'ll,~>,pyr...(.~;..t'))~.!' ~.' _. ,w.f,' , ,,' ,'.. ." " ,'" ",,,M",,,,,,,,.,,- ""!JJ."" J~""'" ,',,,---" d, ,}'" ,,""" ",',,'1''' '...; ,,,'\'",f''' .",,<alol" ;?f;;':[~'N"'(;i~(;:r; ~,~::.!-'::;;'.; ,".' ;': ' ;'''. " '.,~ ',' <.:::;~~:.,;:i'::t~i ,\,' ':l~MI\};$:;:\::~.'h'~'';'': ,~~ ~,:,,' f;,\':; ,:",),~';t,:;g~?:~;\'r'il;'~t1J1ill;'..- ":q:r,+J::<;??,i':\;"':";; :,', '-0:' >i ,:";;,.':"~'f..~,;,.!,,,,,,;;;3~.~~ " 'tiJ.,~:1t,;,.\~/~~, r':\",; "i~ ,;.~:;',,~J'~'J'...:~~!1':'f' :1!"2"i';~::i;' !::{~:'~;.-;.',,~" "~co' '", ,,; ,,)~,,;~;,>:Ii"~.i-'i ::1:,~;:'!X;>,:, .'c :H.~;.;~ ': ," ;;,\,:/-/,f::,,/,;',i>"",: '\~::~;",jt':~'::\,F ',;,;'!;;""-: ~ ','.:; ""."', :';;"':;"';;~I~;I'ii;~,Q\lf;i';' 0"'" ~. :."- ".'.':; '" ::-;~ ' , , '. ~d \"" .,,',:\,<,-" -.;',,' ':,!.: it'" I':" ,.,,- ;;..-. -\;:.:.' " ", ,:;'~'/" " . , .' .' . . ,..' . . " ..... ,I ' ',' ",' ',t. ';.,' ,'" ,',r~;. i:';) -.:,' ,::,I&\';i,~<^,t,,~',;.,;,",;,,:,{,,-,~ \ \. , ., - ~ ':' ,:',:~:;:'" "J'\" IN '1'111: ('OURT OF ('OMMON I'I.I':AS OF (,lIMJlI'RIt\:".:/) ('( 1I::-; I Y. I'LSSSYI VANIA CIIERYLT,IIARDY, I'laintill Civill\clllll) - I a\\ \'S. No I)X.Sl j.(1~2:, KEVIN J, SI'AAN. Defendalll JURY TRIAL DEMANDI,.J} ANSWER ANI> NEW MATTER OF I>EFENI>ANT TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT AND NOW. cOllie the Defcndant. Kcvin J. Spaan, by his counscl. Robcrt A, Lcrman. Esquire I, AdmiHed upon infomlation and belie!: and Griflith. S(rickler. Lerman. Solymos & Calkins and files the f(lllowing Answer and New MaHer to Plaintilrs Complaint: 2, AdmiHed in part and denied in part. It is admitted that the Defendant is an adult individual. but denied that the Defendant resides at the address se( forth in Plaintilrs Complaint. On the contrary, it is averred that 340 N. 19th Street. Camp Hill. P A 170 II. 3. Denied, It is denied that the facts and circumstances as set forth in Plaintiffs Complaint occurred as Plaintiff alleges and strict proof thereof is hereby demanded, 4. AdmiHed. 5. AdmiHed. 6, AdmiHed in part and denied in part. It is admiHed that at the aforesaid time and place. the Defendant, Kevin James Spaan, was traveling west in the left turn lane of the Carlisle Pike, Hampton Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, The remaining allegations of paragraph II of Plainliffs ('olllpl<lint <Ill' dClllcd pursuant 10 POl, R,( ',1', Ihlic I 02'1(e) and stricl proofthereof!s herehy dem<lnded, 7, Ilcnicd, Af!crreasonahlc investigation, Answcring Ilefclldalll is wilhllut knowledge or inllJrlnation suflicienl to form a helief as to the truth of the <llIeg<ltions scllllrth in paragr<lph no, 7 of Plaintiffs Complainl and same arc dellled and strict proof thereof is hereh} demanded, COUNT I ('IIERY!. T, HARDY V, KEVIN JAMES SPAAN 8. Paragraphs I through 7, IIlclusive. of Defendant's Answer and New Matter 10 Plaintiffs Complain( arc incorporated herein by reference as if fully sel forth at length 9, Denied. It is denied (hat the aforesaid collision was a direel and proximate result of the negligence ofDefendan(, Kevin James Spaan, in operating his vehicle in a careless. (eekless and negligent manner as follows: (al In operating his vehicle a( an excessive rate of speed under the circumstances; (b) In failing to have his vehicle under proper and adequate control; (e) In failing to apply his brakes in time to avoid a eollision; (d) In failing to observe Plaintiffs vehicle lawfully (raveling east III the eastbound lane on the Carlisle Pike; (e) In turning in such a manner as (0 endanger Plaintiffs vehicle traveling on the Carlisle Pike; (I) In failing to observe oncoming traffic: (g) In failing to have yielded half of the highway to Plaintiffs vehicle; (h) In failing to keep his vehicle within the proper lane: 2 VFRIFlCATlON I. Kevin James Spaan, hereny veri f): thaI the slatemenls made in the lilrcgoing Answer and New Matter to Plaintifrs Complaint arc true and corrccl to the ncsl of my personal knowledge or inflJrmalion and belief: as well as reports. rccords. conli:rellces and other investigatory material made availanlc 10 me To the extcnt that the lilrcgoing contallls averments which arc inconsistent in lilet, I veri!)' that my knowledge or infllflnation is sufficient to form a neliefthat one or more of them is (rue. although I am currently unanle, after reasonable investigation. to ascertain which of the inconsistent avermcnts arc true. To the extent lhat the foregoing contains legal conelusions or opinions, I herehy state that my Verification is made upon (he advice of' counsel. upon whom I have relied in the filing this document. This Verification is made subject co the penalties of' 18 I'a, C.S. * 4904 rela(ed to unsworn falsifications to authorities. Dated: ),/;/ //~yy ,/'" I ii' 'K:?~-Ja~;;'spaaj ',,~ CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND NOW, this .lS~~y of ,_1:1_f':".C: ~ 1_______, 1999. I, Roh~rl A, l.~rJllan. a Jll~Jllh~r of th~ linn of<iRIFFITII. STRICKI.FR, IH{MAN, SOI.YMOS & CAI.KINS. h~r~hy ~~rtify lhall hav~ this dat~ s~r\'Cd a copy ofth~ Answ~r and N~w Matt~r oflklcndanl to Plaintitrs COJllplaint by lJnit~d Stat~s Mail. addr~ss~d to th~ party or altorn~y of r~~ord as I(lllows: Timothy A Sholl~nh~rg~r. Esquir~ Sholl~nh~rg~r & Januzzi, LI.P 1820 Lingl~stown Road P.O. Box 60545 IIarrishurg. P A 1710(,.0545 GRlfFITII STRIe)!'Ll't LERMAN. S L YMOS & ^LKIN~ I J1-(ct --. ~ Robert A. L~rman Supreme Court ID No, 07490 110 Souch North~rn Way York, Pennsylvania 17402 (717) 757.7602 klrlspaan,anm,z . . I.'.' . '. ' . '.. ': '. " .' , . ",,'. . IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PI.EAS m CUMBERI.AND COUNTY. PENNSYI.V ANI A CHERYL T. HARDY. Plaintiff Civil Action - La\\ V5. No, 98.~,6225 KEVIN J, SP^AN, Defendant JURY TRIAL DEMANDED CERTlFICATF. OF SERVICF. AND NOW. this 18" day of March, 1999,1. Rohert A, Lerman, a memheroflhe linn of GRIFF IT I I. STRICKLER. LERMAN, SOL YMOS & CALKINS, hereby certify that I have this date served a copyofthe ,~ Interrogatories and Request for Production orDoeumenls of Defend anI 10 Plainliff,Sel No, I by United States Mail, addressed to the party or attorney of record as follows: Timothy A, Shollenberger. Esquire Shollenberger & Januzzi, LLP 1820 Lingles!own Road 1',0, Box 60545 Harrisburg. I' A 17106.0545 GRIFFITH. STRICKLER. LERMAN, SOL YMOS & GALKINS drj'r :, J ,~~"..I I F"','l{'/~ BY Roben A. Lerman I Supreme Court ID No, 07490 Attorney for the Defendant, Kevin J, Spaan 110 South Northern Way York, PA 17402 Telephone: (717) 757-7602 mlc/spaan.anm.z t r-. .;( ('. ,... t"; IJ,() ~.}( \1.-' L' 2)~ ,1' C'. l!11 _I, U. '. i: . - " C' (.., " SHOLLENBERGER & JANUZZI, LLP 1820 Linglestown Road P.O. Box 60545 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17106-0545 Telephone Number: (717) 234-3700 Fax Number: (717) 234.8212 Attorneys for Plaintiff CHERYL T. HARDY, : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : NO, 98-SU.6225 Plaintiff v. KEVIN J, SPAAN, : CIVIL ACTION. LAW Defendant : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER AND NOW comes Plaintiff, CHERYL T, HARDY, by her attorneys, SHOLLENBERGER & JANUZZI, LLP, and does respectfully respond to the Defendant's New Matter as follows: 18. Paragraphs 1 through 17, inclusive, of Plaintiff's Cornplaint are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in full. 19. Paragraph 19 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa. R.C,P, 1029(e), 20. Paragraph 20 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa, R.C.P. 1029(e). 21, Paragraph 21 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa, R.C,P. 1029(e), 22. Denied, It is denied that the aforesaid collision was caused solely and directly as a result of the negligence, carelessness and recklessness of the Plaintiff, which negligence, carelessness and recklessness consisted of the following: (a) Operating her motor vehicle at an excessive rate of speed; (b) Operating her motor vehicle at a speed in excess of the posted speed limit; (c) Operating her motor vehicle at an unsafe speed for the roadway conditions existing and the geography of the roadway; (d) Operating her motor vehicle at an unsafe speed in violation of 75 Pa. C.SA 93361; (e) Failing to observe Defendant's vehicle already committed to making a left hand turn in sufficient time to avoid a collision; (f) Failing to properly and adequately control her motor vehicle; (g) Failing to keep a proper lookout for other vehicles lawfully on the highway; (h) Failing to take evasive action in order to avoid impacting the Defendant's vehicle; (i) Operating her vehicle at a speed grater than that which would have permitted her to stop within the assured clear distance ahead; and U) Failing to operate her vehicle with due regard for highway and traffic conditions existing of which she should have been aware. 23, Paragraph 23 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa, R,C,P, 1029(e), 24. Pamgraph 24 is in the nLlturc of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa, R.C,P, 1029(e). 25. Paragraph 25 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa. R.C,P, 1029(e), 26. Paragraph 26 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 1029(e). 27. Paragraph 27 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa, R.C,P. 1029(e). 28. Paragraph 28 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa, R.C,P, 1029(e). 29, Paragraph 29 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied pursuant to Pa, R,C.P. 1029(e), 30. Paragraph 30 is in the nature of a conclusion of law and to that extent requires no answer to the extent that an answer is required and same is denied gJ;BIlflCAIE OU,J:RVJgE: AND NOW, this} 'I day of March, 1999, I, Timothy A, Shollenborger, of Shollonberger & Januzzi, LLP, hereby certify thJt I hLlvo this dLlte served a copy of Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant's NeVI Matter by United States Mail, L1ddrossed as follows: Robert A, Lerman, Esquire Griffith, Strickler, Lerman, Solymos & Calkins 110 South Northern Way York, PA 17402 :~~~:;i~E~LL Ifr;::2:...-;:::_-Z":_.:;':" ' "'d ,t ,~_-;Ll~~r}i_(;~~~ - ",-.. '<"\"":.:~t~}~1 . ~ ',';:,' 1,':,' J:' .;;'. ";-:i~:,t6~~ "i.".~<__p;~' , ;... ~ _.:..,.;..~.__-".__;;:;..:l.:;'~. "u .,'-._..,;.:,..._.:....:.._ ..-(-. '~.." , ,'rs.:;t:"." i" ,,;>~~ ,;.- il'~;'1'.'\~, '" j~ ," , ,~/,~l:'-'>'. ';i t '" ,,-' 1kl {(,'~,~' ,if.'.'''} t' <fi'.:'" '''''''~'~ ;~2;:n~;~~'~-':;~" I .,;', '" ~;t_I>', . i'~1_:J~'/ ~ ;'.-.\ ' ~i~;-::,:: ~:.~_ '. .;', , 5-;':;--~~. -, ';' Ifk"~ ,.,j.:.l ...' ...,," ,a~'!~~:~;;i: ~~~l!t~<,;;;c . ,', - ~., :'.:'f,;{~~ ,.' . ',' ',r;, , ,: I~ ~ '.' V"" .\;:', 1. ._ '.. ':"J..-:!,-~:..~~ ~~'~.'.., 'l ..--...---- .;"':~ ';"-;,'T~'~,-...,~~7i:n!.,:r; . ~ ,.,:'.'~,~"!-'I;;~~f;:.(:;;{ I '\',;~:";t:::1,~.;:~'.t:.ff?l:~; 1 .' :"', /~J:~ ~'( :'i~i.17t~~.: _t . " ~1,:<j..1" ~'~"jf " '<., ; .. ~':;t'f(:,/' w tft,~ " G,~'~t::,~.~r(;.i"~t?~~ . . .'. "I j V.\~~"::< fi\~1 ~ ,l'~ ( 'I~" .<~ ~~' l~~)' .i/{~l~~%.t~ , .~ ' ~1,,'~l,...:..I""l'<.,'"'' :' .jt~~~",,':~ :' ,~. ~~'" ~'~, w" '$.~Ji:,.-\ I1;.."" ,_1 , , /#'hl'. '1'&:"") I.!' I 1,1:" " " ''fA'1fYj; ,,/",)' ~,; '0;:' ~,',(; "' ,', , .1 ....1' '):,~),~r~'}-.; ;1' ~ ',"r>. .- "~t:t;;hl ~t:" I"...;, M, <,'" 4 ", '. ~'~'~."r1\\M)lft"~'.r'~'> '-':',,' ~.rt~'1f"":tl' ~~)/J' ..\ ", V r" '. - ' ~~~l~~:i;;~~A}~:~\~~?:~:~'~:~' ~,' : ,:_: ':, ~\,,;.~;1.Ir-'~i" ~~" .q1 ~,~~;.r~. I"l' "', il~ rl,40:JI \~/"" uJ <0".' }" ( . . 'l'Ji~..i~~l;j.' . ',;'. I. < , ,..':,,~ ,". "!f'lj}j!-"',~(/::.",l~", '<~ ~ ~~~'rlt"~\~+.i)C.:~/'.I~ :,;"/.}, ,~~ ...'f )',.. ~,<~.,~,\',I' T~" I' ,~ :t";;;::''''!Nll:~,.; ':;~;~ ~;.~'):t ,.,,,/~:; ,:'.:'~ ;',' "',f:;,:li"'i' <.,,', "." ~ ' ',- .'::~,', , "~'I .,'," '- ':"~'/:' ,.' / " '\';,:,. .-",' .,,- '! , , :;~:;'.::,~~/~.,:::. , .: t, : ~ \'<:,; ';," ,',''-''''- """.' ,<,' 'Or,',' """, " ,',,'< "-",.: "", ':,~.;" ..: ,) :."' ....... " '.l.,. ",.',,, ':',\':' '''';',;'' >f;,:':~i;,,:~; ':\"2-::.,,/f."-,",: "..~:',""/:;::\; ...,',' '.." :.::>'~-,- ~~'>;.> ,\':',-. , ' ' , . '.\ .;, .,.... ,. \', , " . , ' , '.,--'.';i> ;:':;- '-""',' ,::'.i,' ,.:!, ::.:-~;:-~~-:.":::":?::IIJGJ.;,.;,1~ It.,- .~_~, ...~, r ';j..'!:.:(::~;:F',~\':~J~;j~~~0'!i!~ ..~:\>~r~it^~i~~f ..., . ..,.,',(-., ",,;: '!~,\ > ,lo (...., ,,' , . , . jOI?":l't';::i "', '- .~ J "'c ';t"'Y.~' " By: /~ ) ( ,/ / ,. ) Cvl' (. {" \.., 7 1,,---;"" Ann Margaret Grab'- t' Supreme Court ID No. 55986 AHorney for the Defendant 110 South Northern Way York, PA 17402 Telephone: (717) 757-7602 IN TilE ('(JUIU (JF ('O:\I:\10N I'LEAS OF ('( 1:\II11':IU.,\:'I;1I ('( II INn', PEN :'I;SYI. "":'1;1,\ CHI'HYI I IIAHIlY, I'lainlifl ('1\ II ,\\'Iion - la\\ vs '0 'IK,SI ;,h~~~ KEVIN j, SI'AAN, I>efendam Jl:H Y I HI"!. 1>I':~MNIlFI> CEIHIFICATE OF sElWin: AND NOW. this' ! day of April, !999. I. Ann Margaret Grab, Esquire. a member..f the linn of GRIFFITH, STHICKLER.LERMAN, SOLYMOS & CALKINS. hereby certify that I have this date served a copy of the I>efendant, Ke\'in .J. Spaan's Response to Plaintiffs Request for I'roduelion of Douements by United States Mail. addressed to the party or attorney of record as follows: Timothy A. Shollenberger, Esquire Shollenberger & Januzzi, LLP 1820 Linglestown Road P.O. Box 60545 Harrisburg, PA 17106.0545 GRIFFITH, STRICKLER, LERMAN, SOL YMOS & CALKINS :R,;~lQL::',,:;, .., L&:J '/i; ';J ;;, ;-~ :~{;~fi0.~jJ'~,:::~,~-: ., Z:;~t:k":~";" {~ ,-:' ..,1. ;.'r" /, " . - ~ ~ VEIUFICATlON I verify Ihat the I\'regoing fa~ls arc true ano ~orreet. upon my personal knowledge t>r inllmnalion ano belief. This verilieation is made subjcct to lhc penalties of 18 l'a,C.S, ~ .1'JIJ.\, rclating to unsworn falsifiealion 10 aUlhoriCies, Dalc: '1 /,r!~9 By: --/ /( , . L.. /' (""n '~U'" K,cvfiH Spaan,/ , IN TilE COlJlrJ' OF COMMON PI.EAS OF CIIMIIEIU.ANIl Cot INH',I'ENNSYI.\'ANIA CIIERYL T, IIARDY, Plaintiff (,ivil Action. I.a\\ vs. No, 'IX-St 1-r.22~ KEVIN J. SPAAN, Defcndant JIIRY lRIALDI:MANIl/:1l CERTIFICATE OF SEI{VICE AND NOW, this, J ", day of April. 1999. I. Ann Margaret Grah. hquire. a mcmbcr of thc firm ofGRIFFlTlI, STRICKLER, LERMAN. SOL YMOS & CALKINS, hcrchy certilY that I have (his date served a copy ofthc Defendant, Kevin .J. Spaan's Praecipe to Substitute Verification by United States Mail, addressed to the party or attorney of record as I(lllows: Timothy A. Shollenberger, Esquire Shollenberger & Januzzi, LLP 1820 Linglestown Road P.O. Box 60545 Harrisburg, PA 17106-0545 GRIFFITH, STRICKLER. LERMAN. SOL YMOS & CALKINS By: ()CCtl ,)) J .~ C Ann Margare( Grab Supreme Court ID No. 55986 Attorney for the Defendant 110 South Northern Way York, PA 17402 Telephone: (717) 757-7602 , ' .. ~,~,,':'~~.-:~:,~~.- ~::""'d!;"'J~':J.=--=::::::= ::;,~=~~:' ...~ -~'-' ~l:;~~~H\~'{\;::': ~\ ~". 1-"'\,, I"~. ~tL~~!~;;~;~~:;' t~:,J:l ,. \..4~{, '~,', : I; !,,~' " ~~1:i:;C}?'" "I, " :::'::-~',-::-:;~: ..~". l~ '.:' ';:/J,' : 5, :~[;};~ '.-.,t',)?(td ,?~~ " " /~. ,;. f',':, ii':[,i~',::~~:;,:::,: ~ :-V-~:'-.....,..-_~--'-7' ---;.;-- .. ~"'J(~~~~~L: '"."IC',t,";, .:. '" "::".: -'-,j,{~:;~~~,j.: ~ t ,~..: ...../ .,' ':f;'" . ,( .,),-~-,,~_-."'t~'7.r~+,:'ilr:"rill""';C,'~ ~'tS':1n:;};' .:" ..~;. ':.:,'~;:'\::;' :k:'i1;8';i>.:?~",~~~' . \'" ".~~\......:~.1. _",",,,,..._,_.. .,...;c, ""V,~,,,,,...,,,,...,~,.<:a:J;,'), ~1t1o :-'!'~jClp'~~,~'7,~~I~ ,~"", .'. ;- ~ -..- ,~,r ";l--:';-f:': ,,-'r,-;-:--:-:"'?:.;;;_ I 'l,r. j r~.''''~' e- ~ ." .'. ',.j,".. ,. '" .'r,~'t :~ '~::~~ ,k,' ...~: .':-,~, ":'.'''':;("l;~511..\;>;>.1~~ I ;II ",; (i" ~ -<, . ',I " :..' ...., "l.~" 't\ ./ r" ~ y'.:";:( \p.p;.', '1"~~' .: ) _.~ '1<, "~,'" :.l~.'_i'.. ,.,,;,;,: j titl, ~r~ '1":'~ ',,1, " ,I .'." ,{V', """'"I"J,.'1"'1 ~,'}<pf}" ~i~ 1:\,;~~{:;~,~'.\"f~' " . - !...~"';~"I~~"':r.~ :~~.\~~ ~?t'\~~'1 '1.'~.~~..., -?',4!' ~",,;, . ;'~,r\":' '~'",", ~<:','-,'\''.l;' :o'~'l?:?i>',},{~t."J' "t:I1J!....}~~/, ,,~ t ";' \ _! ,\ l/o- ~ (, \" ,.~~. 'N),~;;-~~.It!r ~~'l"~,,d(.~,.:\., ~ rl \, '. ,/1 ,<'''~f ',.,....,",.,. V, "r\f~-'l rid,;!'; "'......;. '!1:'(-'I.' t' "r 1\, '" ;1, " I I. . " l, ".1 n .. l, . ~ t'lJ~ ; ~;::J1}:l,r'i.t~!"""~ ,M,,:, ~~, ..VI. ~ '!:.)^.,t,';;;"";:):"~'!~"~~,' J\"'" \1.., ',/.",~\ 1~:r;//":FI"'!<f,rJ;'J~ .-'\,"~ ~.J..."~ . .,', "~""" ~"""r.,:,,'."t' ., ", I' ........I-'~.J:.. ~,~J{\:'-:.:.:4:~J!.; "'.,... ~~,' ,t~l~, ,'., \~ : " . . l '\ ~ I,.. ~ :, I., "I,. ,,;, . ",:'~' 11M'f~ii;";~~.._.~,lit".,t'.."n ,,!\'." ,'. '1')\_' ""-..,_"~,,,>,\~" ." "'.r+\~ ,..,,,;,~,i)>:i.',--',;',.'i ',. ',~ . .,. ""_ ~'" . .,,',' i~c ,- :'( ''}:1i;--1.1):.~.\~'~t~'', ':1. ,\ ,<'".; _I:\,~.M' .'\, "rl:"'l.";'~;F ./.::f,1.':.;tr:l,'i/'I:'~;;";", '('~ ').,,;,' \" ;," '.Pc:;~: ~:;";: ~ ';, " ", .~, .., j' ;itt .1!'<......-;...~....;:..4.- ,;"".1',1.,_,,,:,,11,,:, ",-,.:.,' ;.'" ..,l~\'.i~i.\/:J,' ''<.,,14'..', :"'J I, 'l:'.}"'r..;\,"~"''!J ,~, < , """.1'''': "\{"~{'\"1'" J;1!",~"',J,, r"::!,,,.,1,:"" ",(,>' I. ~_ .I.' , .. ....L . " ", " '\;. . .~tt". 3,:' :.'rt/.f\ ""W',.li't""J \'15., ,;~: ....i ) '.. . ! ;:, ~~'~t" t.~, "J '..~ i :. ,'/~ .-","" <.' l .... "l'!i;/( ._~ r;~r'~ }1';/t;I'''.'':: l"':~ :1:/" t ",,~ l'"'...L/','>""':' <"l"'!1~"-jj~t\ l' ,".k' )'/4,:, \j~" ~~ "'4\: . ..:-:'~...:~' :,./..,'~ : ~ ~1'....:, 'r", <_:;\ . :,'.:~j:J." ,;)0' _.~"'t: l ~ ~ ,I. ...."f;~J.. '.,~\,~~~,~~f";/d, ~-.o;~~'" ..'-:.' '~I"<f.1;,"t"':;;t!H.t,~tJ~ ::'-,r~'+~i'~c:as ',.;~,,:J.;J~.\),. _, .~ ,t _. . ,".._ ,r"~ ,,,..... It..\,\~ :t:~""\t!'" ''- "'~,~~.. 'r .\'.... - "'''''~'.l '" "" ~"... ~ .."'t-,.. "J Ii' '" :} '" . ,ty',?::":"$"\~~~~,'\ ill. :J-.', ',j. ~"t"'~"':::""~'r 'l'.'''-:)~'' ,>;':/ ::~n~':{! 1!;JI"~ ~"'r/d';>"'~1' .' ,;" rit! " ,',I. ',( , ~ < '\'''' ,t: ,~!',,~'.:!;,,~:t:!.'~:". j",'>~q'l:"'''''.,,:',''\'i;":7<;,,~ '?,:1,';'1 {j'~ 'J>', !,;. ~ :: J! . r'~. '/ .r,;, \' ; ,'j'. _.. ," ': -..\t, '-,.:,,1:. \;~"t}':\o~';,~,~',,",~.';, ': >"i'J.",;:"!~'f" ~.,~~I~\\:~..J~ 'lr:-'l.zl"I-'',fY ,:'>~ ,:\ ,'~' "1 -~.~t''' "{ ~.~ - ~ '.~ 'X" .r',; ",?XI'I-.~:,~',,'llX.'" "'"i"n \ d' " ~. ~\. ,,,',,, ':i" ~'Z~ ,'" ({', J':i"/;,J. ~r: ,'J~', ->,' :"rf "',"""" '>"J' ~ ',I =':1:: '"'~,-'~~' . ,j.l"~r:'.!}"~i:"...' ~',~..;' ~f'- ~ J ',,"~- '" \~;)>!'.'':.~. .....';.~:~..-"'\~(.h' "k ~t.'.(r"'.1'1' '~",., '~'" \,.' ~ I,. ';".,.,>',\.. ~~'J."'{'-'. '''I'.. 1l,j\~~":a'"~':I~_""II~-:.,;.~ 'j ~.' 1:< ':I.-;~"11!./"".'",;;~~~;' \\i~, " " , "( ... c" ,-:t.... ':.,(, I'~ ~ ~ I). ,.... J' ";~"':''i~j I,:!r.' ~'I .,:,.,i':l,...~;:..."J(./jl~"l' Ilt"{l~:lJ,'" %}j1:i:"'f'~ rJ'''~~ ~:. -t'j1)~~, ;:~ ,,"j'~ ~',,~1."'1\ ,,,.~ ;."...1..~ {;rl;;!g7'~-'tf ~,.,~'}:' ."~: ~ :::~~y!,<~:':..t;',;!!:~h-:J{t:.l, ';;:.p ~ <r ,; ~ '~:~~~ ;~(: '~,{-~ .:~. . . t; .'::~.";.~;'r;: 1'.. !' ,~, ;~td~ a ',"!,,/';I'J\{'\'j. '1", ;;,\ \ih!..; ,_,;f:;~;i;;.""'j{ ,u. :)1, ..~W..!;?:...;;ti.~ r '"d~{ ': '?i;I-\!r~ff:';'\'!J~i~, II.' "I"\'llJ~'''r,\'ii; \;... 'f~:;;;,,~.,I-;'j;\ .r,,~~\:~li'~l'~~; ... 'l,~ I" ~~'l'/I.Wr;.'>j.-~- ",," ." "'lJI,,I..';,.it!,j"'iJj-1 !'i,~" ~ '//":,,, :;-:;J<I) ,,: (;:.1, '~"" 1" tf''b'':, ii,-:~;:;f",'" : "'~;~:~l ,~...~ '~. ~ ..':~',~, 'r.,}r.;',~ 1':';A~j"1;'~ ~}'}"'I!i;,': \;Q.l'{ ~.,... ~i.~\;.-, "'\ ~ ~-r, ~ \I "'"I'; f~':~s:f.?tJ ~~' ,\ "1*1";' ,I.." .' th' ~ I!~'t..;;- 1t.1 ....,' {l;)'l"~~ ~ 'j'~~'~'~,.J f/;;.'.~>\,~~;:.."'< ~'( s ;..', ' l,~., ~ .f/)\s;ff"r ,,~.'{,f.~~ "<:'!~l\~1,..r \'t':' l~' ."e'.... If.; ~" > -l ~:'. N i-t;- ~ .\~~, . 'Ji~';:~' r'r'" ,rj. <" 1 ....:J ';oJ} 'I,.', "f',,\t~ ,'~' ;~.~;:l:i',t;" ',. .t:t"~}>::11(~~r' ~i "",~~.l!~::I~tt,t~~J,,"r~t::~: '\li~'1 ", , ... ..1...f ., r...,,'>;"'J~,(.'1r\J '1-\1< ""'~I')V"-l '~\ -'"It:.l'lr ,or )"'.,::'/..1.(...., /~.t":;. "',' ,'S,..~~t 'tl\'!~' I~ ~.z.;,,~ . '\'tS',:':.; 1 \';,. ',A' ,'.; \- ~ ,;.' \"~;:~' ,~~\,~,\;:..J..lt;i.. ,~/i!:/'(1\ I I;J\r ,...~'~....;, '""h~. "i, '1' ',;,1..,'1"...'1: y. ":~','~:~l~,'~" ~ ,"'\11 .,,~;>:~\r'. ,.~" 'I' "'.'" 'i, 1) '~l-;'~'" Ji, "'''i~:"i! 'I}: ",~v." ~'l ~ ~ '>y)~r;-'((~'~:'..t!;;Q~. f ~fi .+; ';:~~;}fJ,<;(J.'~; ,4;f ,.t7.1~" ,i:~f'~J{2i'~~ ;f'9: .: ,:r"t .;I.v, fl'>"",' ,i',....;.,.,l'l,~_."r..,r;f~}.l~.:~,..\ lIr.,-t' , ~~~,~ '-~'" " :~~: }'"':':J~~,1\,~.,~t:';)'~~f'l~,.,o:.~~;~~'~'I;' ~\-\\,.~,^."",lJ-'" .1~X'''j..~~ r,-{.b"J--J1, f~ '..j'\";'~""4: ,'~\f';l,~,,,,. ';,"'\:::.- 't:;./llit',:})^..I'i..,\;'l~-,:7:.,l,"" :;,.~ j\'i"~~ ,....1/~, ,~,~) . '~,' ';:- .";;,,~.~ ~,.' l' ',". "'I' ....:...'~-tirl, lii\\t?, 1.1.1:) . ;.:{?:~ ::i;~>; f;j,~.;i~'~1{J~:P'~:~~ r,'~;/? ",:\ ':~:~:r:/, '1:~' li~:tf1~t:r\it'~ ~~ ~":>'f.;\,f-' , . " '". ,': ,~,...J ,'.~." ~ # I- ~ ~,1vt~';.Y:!(,":._Hlt.:.U ~ t\.-:~~.'<t!~ ,11..;,/"...... ,1:' '. ",',,) '. ,;,'\ ~\~'-" .~\ ~;;"l,/,.~.\ 'I.'~,,~~.,'~~:,'tl'i.\,::'\ ~,^'~~ii'..,}l.,,\l 'Y-f~,'!-; ".: U' \.' .,' "J;: ~,-l ,~..-r -1'';. ;~ '~~'rt' ,,;,).'r :~~~'~r ., ,',:~,.{. -' '.. ~, .,'" ~' ,"' .,.'/. ':-~,' .~;:\.~ ~)C"~J" 'f"~ ,~.( \1;:",'''':'''~' v, ,. :',: .',;, "1"';";' 11".rll./~\,./f~\~i~'}~:'~ '",0 ."1. \ .' ,',I , I - -' ... ,:,,:)',.':,1"(,':.' 'J,~I'l~",~jj\;~$tl'" tJ~~i~;,~~;~~~i~~?lil~jl."; :,\Sf~~3;h $' r" 3;~,~:~1t~~:~1:~';l?:.~,.:~~t~{;{:,;}J:~*rM~~'t!i;~~i~~~"-;'';I,I:{};j~\~~f;~~ ;p'~~; .~:.,\ ~.:'tj X'(:~~1}.. ll-I,.:J<J., ~~!.l ~l;i:S'~~~if.'"';';':-;":V!. .c" '.e,'i-1\'1."~~I;L;J.it~);',,-, 'j.,;,/ ",-;;:;,'":':~:.l..~. ';~';"" ". ':.__" r _' '~'-h.'c1' \ >' ",.' . , ^ ..-.. '. , ' , " -- ~ , -~. ~:~: ~.~13:~;,?~~'~z~~r:;;!?~~::::~~f~~;' . - .~ . ", } ',(:','\' l''''lfJ,.\,-:..,~j''';':~ '-'l-,!,'-~>J<" ift'-t:"-i{"t~'i"~!~ . ..... ".""::~':';AJff.~ ".-."- ,',", l.:i~A!);~:~:~.j'" " " :TcJ:'r"':'l'"'.-;:;7CI;~C ~-.::-::=~ f~~ffiA'~(:~~~!~:;,;.T , ~1:7:it~~k~;~;:?3J~~: :If;'''''\'' i" , " ~~,i~ir~;~~~f;~,-':."'; ~ ~,.'':.t:..;,j.~:.r",,''''!;'' " ~~fJ};{X,~, _u' . n:r::;y.rr:':-77:Y:'~:;-~,~"'---:; .;',~,--:: '"?;~;. 't~~, l'ti{,..;}~,"Jt!.Jl\)'; ;;~'.. ',..' ',' ~'I~ ~{ ~:'~:\/1'1.4,:;_L. ~ ~""-;~.;. :,' ~ : ~.? \; " ~" (:-.. ~f.\.( 'j., It ',' . ,f ' I ~ ~l .'.. -.. I' ~ \... ";J~"'" "i~ '" ."'.;' "t '''' '~ , ." , It "l~>'~:l;r,/7'.J}~" '.'r"..t:;- ^~~.' ~(, 'i..'i ~IJI " 'l~ . "i), . r - .. ~~'l!-/~',j.-..~~';~l~J:, ", '~,I , .~ .. &i'j:......~....~o) t:';': /~ _>r~'..:. .:~, ~ l;;; "~. ' ., '~-W-~:(;?l\f,::;:',.; ,;"..;t' .'"'~,,o / '.'. .'~:~ '. _"'.'> ~\.,.f(4~',,;,~;."':c.~'/~~' IL,....;~~... '." ~ .. ~; ~q ii~~ifrL~~iT:~'<>'. ,....,; " ,.:' ',..,;. :"'~" ,......,A'.:;\',::~,:'~~';~~~~~ T.'''''.,.,;;..1,,,.,,...,..........,...,..,.,,,!,,.,.'tJ'.,-''''.J... ....1._.... ,'.. .......,., -, ._~..-,.-.... .,t."....~'l'II." ~1/ .7~~j~?~{~~~;it,:'r;t~t':~H/Y:, :f}'; r;~:,}~;>:X:g~:~~;,~;~~~~~ '., ' ~................li~ .'." .".~.,.,,__..,.,--' ~,"__"5'"w-~...,,J._.,' '.~'.."i' ....._,'.,.,'.. ."""_..,, ..t. .,.l;l...............:....~_"'~ :;iDf~J~~;W';~:~/:;~,;;};\ ~': 2~~~~~~l~/~~~~!Y;, - '''If'l(,;:9.g. )>'~ "~#.' ,):" --,)"," . ~ !.. r...r..""".~ l, -~"tjJ;" .". /Ct''''''''.!'''' , ' ....~ ~ '" .~, "'..' ~:", ~ ,~ ~"',, ,--~ J ' ,'~ {1;t.:V:<._ <.. ;'~' ~i""'\:; 4;e.: t ~" ,~~.,~,7.~: ;<',..;.\"Ji" V. 'l'~' ~r'i'...i. ,/10 , ,,):'\,~ ';t,/~'lr; ~~j~:r4;'.'?..;~~~!..~r~' ;1~'.~' :I..,~ .~ t~"-_'DJ."".,'tj.~..;,.,;".,f;. .,1.,,':.:::\ ,Tl~.',:r,:J.,....~". .\,~.., .3/:;'\', _I ,\.~.~,,~'\'J!... . PL;',:;:~;:'-, .,f" 'C:' '~"'::-:~: ," , i';-'. tJ'.... . ...-;,.~" .;..;~I-ir.:\IJ.:"...~~........ ~"..... '.. ........, i" r ", '~"", "I",.. "i'i'I~ >i"~j-',...".~"\\..~u" II. .,\'~~}.I,':.;:,..~..: .;.:; .:..,:: _'...' .:'~ '.~/ ',.; ;, ;.!}~l."...r~;',,:~t, ':, ~J("t.:~;;1. l't-ttJ-',.'d......,,"~.t :tH"",,', 'i='- .,. - 1"," '-"'''-''t\.,/,J''/'''l.t'''.t; .-t..IJ" ~~',..:lf""~ ~.1",.''i<_ .~j~I' ',.~\.1..~,1 J..::"~'''.'-'''jl'--'''Ioi.,,",ilc~\.:' ,r ~.~~t~j;~~i31~~, ~::~j .~!} ::,:,; ~:~~:::,~~ " ,I' ~;~~~~::~~~~:\/~;'~~;~\~~f1;;~f }.t\ ~'~.V;/", ",~\, w~t_ .,-_1 -~ . "It, J",-,,"!""'j","l:r.:ll''''~'l<' ~'" ;/;"'if. ~)"'~~:;~~--::.!-.::.'!;,t~~~~,::;1.~~ ,\ '-';',--:::-~':' jr,"".~r-.7....~~:'i-l.J'i:,;:.f:,~ ~\"fT..~......:'-;c,;-.r.';'\,'.l/.,., ,,,< }r:r>-' _J";~''i'''1:"tr~~;< $ ".>":~'.~\~">;'1,.' ,"',~~'~"I,:,,'..:'1.~', ',', '. -.",,-~....,r-.'L11 (~".; !'.;-..:'~( '!'-("r'(;;-':~~ ;":'~~, ,,",v"./~~' .'-", _ '.L 't:' S;:l"l,' ,~fj.< '. U--"t;:,.,~.,.....-'lI"'''I~''J ~'"' "'1" r:r l, /, t." ,...."..r \,~' ..10< J"t,/--';',", 'l'n-.", "",~ ,>>-.1 ~,. ".' ~\\)'! ,~'. _ ,r r.~~...~...,... ~ w~\(.~f;'~ :l'~~ of ....1 ',,' , ,.~". .' I '.~ "'-'o'j" ~"l't ,~ ,...'((l:. ~~...:;I"ir"."" ("~""'''" , ,,'-"1 .L'l!......rHQ,'~: ~D,i~~.,::.S:: ,,")i\j/ '.; ,~t :',. ;:' "(, ::; ;' _ ..':', - 1 ',) .' : ,\ , :o::~ ,::' ' ;~ '''~'' ,..... ,~-tt~.::..k.,,:f':'<"; \1' ~, .,~ "'+, ~I"I""\ f n,'?,\, , '-: '0'\ '-V',' ,~,.yf ".;~I" ~'""I~ i~~~:". .""";($'.\;:;<::.",,,,1.f.t) :'..,~', , "...........'..~':l I"'::" '" h,' .':;':!~!,:" .., ~!-r. ~,~.~~" "~"r;~ "'''~ j~"" < ""-" ,,"1:.1,_ "'" N,\\t -(I-l~~','l:"~..~!"~" ," ~':_;;:":/,I...""~\i. ':. "I' ,r',";~ ",;, t~ "/1't...'s-' ~!'...l'i:;~;-;17~ ''';'~' .~;;(,tt~.l~~J!"'~^" J !:'- ~.:~ ':.;~(S:':jl;:U:r- : >~"J''''~}~'T:'?~~~f.. "i~'J'/''''' ,~".. .' .~ ~ . .'.,1,. ,-,.,\. ''''~~' ':!.llfi":i: 'a-'l';'t"~'i~/" ;{/A~"'~*';f~~' '~:'''~''''~I~ 1;:',.... "; .,,>":\.::J ~',~t~.(':,i~.: ~ ~:,.: :":"J?:-tt J,.::..'''~.~;~ . :~!'htl}',-' ;v':~~!,,":,l.:.."'~',~,;, _ ''';'II ( :: ,.\~'~~' ~.._/l .,/.~_, ..' It,;. '~,:-r-';;""\f;l{''f1 ~:.-- ~\t'-'.1V7f"~'..1.'~~:r .~. {.i>.r~~t' ,t~~T.;'";-',,},,'i<- -1-:," ",,--t,,,,,,'~~0; . ~ ."?f ~~",~~\,r;. <2i~'~ ;;;':\,:1/J,f.~1: .d~'.>, ::rfl :,~'1:(j':.~5: ~":W~:J'>'~":~":-,j;"B}" ';;JY.\'~t'~ tJ.j\~"~,~ '~i)/i~<',~',.;-"'*1 .fJJ;;~L:':t. :~:('0~~'tt?&;~~i):~j:r.. )Z~~z~:;;',!i':~.~ki~~~f@J~Y~r~j;?~f:.~:{f~i.~~~~~~.; '''','. _.~-' ':"._.:__...~..;.'._-~-,:~.~ ~_.~- '. -_.. ----- ..-."- ,,-,-,,,~,-~,~~;:.':,,,:::,., .~-,"'::I~~;. ',., ,:--.'.-:,,') 'll~~~ ) ~".' :~,~.(, 'I ... .~..' ~';,'J-:" .. -. ~ ' .,,', ''''i:" ','v .} -..,." IN TilE ('OIIIH OF ('O:\l1\10N PI.EAS OF ClJMIIEIU.ANJ> COlJNTY.PENNSYLV ANI A ('HI':RYII, HAllin', I'laintill Civil Action. LI\\ \'~. No, lJX-Sll.6~~5 KI:VIN J, SP^AN. Dcfcndant JURY TRIAL DEMANDED CElnlFICATE OF SElWin: / AND NOW, this i)'1 day of May. 1999. I. Ann Margarct Grab, Esquire, a mcmbcr ofthc linn ofGRIFFITll, STRfCKLER. LERMAN, SOL YMOS & CALKINS, hcrchy ecrtily that I have By: !~(Li);]' /(/L Ann Margaret Grab / Supreme Court ID No. 55986 Attorney for the Defendant 110 South Northern Way York, PA 17402 Telephone: (717) 757-7602 chis date served a copy of Defendant, Kevin ,/. Spaan's Supplemental Answers to l'laintifrs Interro~atories by Uniced StaCes Mail, addrcssed to the party or aHorncy of rceord as follows: Timothy A. Shollenberger, Esquire Shollenberger & Januzzi, LLP 1820 Linglestown Road P.O. Box 60545 Harrisburg, PA 17106-0545 GRIFFITH, STRICKLER, LERMAN, SOL YMOS & CALKINS ',~--~-"-'-~:-"-~--- --. ~...:....'-,~".;. ~......,....- ._~ ;F5~Yj:~,~/~e:~ ,j; ~ r2:~'1,:l'"' . '~ ~,:.~~:.:." J " ~:' 'if'" ''''- ,I" .., (~~:lJ~' ",':"l.;- '" '~ : ;iI,' ,,'t""""'f f",-t p ..;,.t,~t~":,' I': ~ .' .~I~'!, III '{ " '" 'J: ' ?ff~\:51~~~': I_~..~'~f. '~"!Ilfjl't~!~ .Jll ';' ., -. 't~'IJ\' "::u,-~!, . ~~,~;~t:'~,:,;'_'-,,~':'>~ . "._, ,_.....~...;!3~<~~ .. ~,- --"---".~----~ <." '. "> .: ---'. ,:,,- .",:. '-.:>.:~: ;)>i;;~~:!(~~~:f~ . '\' ': !~, ,.,.j: -.-.',' "(,r"-tJ..",<,,. ~I\f",~~ ".I::' '; '", ~;<', . '.' ;':~:/-~~~):}~~~(i~'::~'i.::/;~~~;t~~I'~:~ ,- ...-, h".,..t,....... ;,-'~~r."\.-,.j{~:'..i:.- " '-~\; --.\ ~:-, 't~;,~,':i ,;: ;:,~ ~':_.J\':I/.\:':-J~.;~7).~},~.;:.{';t'!~~\!i >.'" ...,.,.,...........- ~>'}.rt'<''f\.' ..lhl't1-'i.J...,.,#"'..~t~ '" ':'.~;t;f(:!F;:~i\?(1IJ;~~1 ";::~.I~,~,. <"':~, ."" . t::~.j(~, ,,<<,,'t'"r,. . A <'~ J" ~',.~"" ,~:.:. ~X:H"j~'~;;;'-1 ~~.:""<:;.': r<';-,::;-.,.;;;.,,,,,;:, ;~~ .:: ., " -:,.; ~- '"':;: ..., :..; \'~:;::t..?~::~." I', .n- ,~"'!'" ,~~t1~..),", ll;j'"~"\'I'''''''.:'- " ".--;' '~'""'-'.\,7'/'.:r"':''''';':~';:{ ~\~'l 1 1,;:""Jl.~l>.,,.,,..,f."(;.'~ll'l ";;'~tl '+..:'1 \ 1.. . '-, "\ '."'i:' , (~./."J ,,~.,,".... ~~1". ':;: 1,+"" ~..,.('f" 1 "'+ ~ _' """"rJ ,,''' f' f" ;.:.,....+!~, ~'f1;'".,C" -.,.".... ^ 0'-' ~I ~.. ',' , ..'" ~"I~:'~' t.. "... <\}~;.J"'~;V"1.,;-.T~"-'1.<"-;':l:~"' tl'",,<,~'~. j.."l. "i.}:",,:'''-'~'_.'' ..'. . '::rj.;.~r:t:;;: ~'{:rt}.';:4.'{"f/:.':''.!~;': ' ~~ ~;"" :'oC:i-I;.":t;:~J ',~r~jiJ\' M.<",:..,;!~ , O),...;r'...\-.''', {,~.., .l"7::" 'I..~"),'. . , J ~.\.,~ ~ ,," \ r '.~~, r t ~"i",l<' ,~ ,~,r?~~~:~}.}~:}f~~i~~~,~!~j~};.~:~\::~ ~ ,:; }:/, ',:~'~:,.(,~.: :-.,\~~~:,~;,?~~~r?~. ~~~j,:lift~~~':;~",,!,l/ 1~':~::0 ' ,."",,:.'~ _ <' , ,)':~..:-." J .,1,"." ',i;1"-';;~J ~"~''-':.~?-[ti~i~~~f.:,:t:,2;~,\~:?;',~::, .. .' ,/ ';: ;t,' /:,?j}~:;:5::,:~:~~:~:~ "'r,,,~,~,'..,~...,.;\,.,1~'~t-'~O, .'_ .~ "~'(:.r_"'1.:t>~, O.""-,\,,,{,}~-,.~'t:'i"p . :rr f~~,,;;"-;'1~:::t;;J*5~":;;::~' ~ ~t.:t.\',"! . ( ;:~";r; - ';'-" ',\~':""'f:t" >'l:{lN,,~.:~~,~;, ...:_:~=...}'t-.;;;'f<~~..)""~~'I-',Z:' "'~/"r; 0 '~.",i , ~ .. {t :'i" ::':.:~,!., f'/" ~~ '-/....V'i-.('( :lt~'. ~ ,~,,,,\Y~,:r""",I'i'~~.t;Iif:t',;-"':f" .~..,~.,.. '."111"-"'",%, ....-,) 1 'h!(i."",j;~ ;~?,lj~i~:i\~~~~~~::€?Kt;~;~:~r~o; ;~~;~.>~; ~~ ~'~\j~: I{~ ~~:,:~ :'~:~~~~:\:~ ~,*~f~~:~ . :!t "~'\ ;,~~ :t,;,tPi; '~'. :. ,.l'h~,../,t.i ':..,,' ,i, I"" - ~, " ,!< \ >' ~ , i~ ;'1' './;;,i-:t":':'rfl> ~_ jJ""'Cf ,-<" o:iI~l- .~, OJ' , I .....(' 1,{' ~., - ", 0 ~~"" ",~ \t ""'1\ ",...' '~j/;(~~j:'i~~ 'i:/:~, ~1,:'7.:,~' ' :' :' '~\'o ';;.'; ;,~~a~~. ':: :,';:{:~:~ ;~;~~~' ':~ ;f.j:~~o~J;~\~~~! o,-",.J..I{.,1' ~>:-",",,",,'.: C~ "I' "'.~ '.__ ... '}' ')'\00,1_"',,'.).1,1,'5' i>l . ~~?;j),';;:;, ;:;i;,~ii~;;~." ~';"~ ~;",'i.;'.~,<~~_~, fI'7:' :t~ 'rt~');;'I~X }'<' , :\",;.".-;-", ".,~' ~'h~,\f';_ ~<,", ,\:'~ ;',' *_~~1\.'!;( -;,~:;~~:x,tl:~.~";: , ;g~f1j~WI~~;t~~~~f~~~~ t~~;~{~ ,:r;~:~-\,,;r.~1,"'''~',.,- ~l" >:<',:t-L " ':t, '1,r '~'''~!>'''''',r , -',"', \"t."\"""'''\~1'''',\'i,,~~~,,\t~'1F\~t'/Il~;& " \~,~",'r{',~':","{(:..J,'" I, . \ "~~' A~,,,;.,J..'\'IJ."'t::'n'!~,U~\ ~:;~C~;:":::;f;f:;;;;~ ;;,(,: :::;/. :~~:i;,\"\,,;~;:hi;:~~~),;;}~l:~::;~:"';' ,'hj"Q) t -:', ~'(".'~ "1-.'4l-'~f~':>~'V(\",("~'~,~, ~ :'~'\ :>1. ,!.;~iv~~~+'~/ lIt,;.!;;, j';:""'1't"I~Nf' " 'i~.,...,.,"'''y'~:''''''''''V'v.''''';'' ,.<:'", l'~ ~i!;IW .,}"\;".~[~.. \',' ';\,~ v-(~)fe~~~";;:::r\I:s..t:}J~ 'itJi;;;1."iIJ~.7~1t~~1b ~;~ -.-,- .". , , " .. " "1 \-,' <;-:': " ~.: iX". 'r. ..:!;<-", SHOLLENBERGEH & JANUZlI, LLP 1820 Linglestown Road P,O, Box 60545 Harrisburg, Pennsylvanlil 171OG.()S,1~j Telephone Numl)()r, (717) 234.37lJlJ Fax Number: (l1l) 234.e212 Attorneys for Plaintiff CHERYL HARDY, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 98-SU.6225 , r I , v, KEVIN J, SPAAN, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Certificate of Service I, Timothy A, Shollenberger, Esq" do hereby certify that I have served a copy of the within Answers to Interrogatories/Response to Request for Production of Documents by depositing a true and correct copy of same in the United States mail, postage prepaid, addressed to: Ann Margaret Grab, Esq, Griffith, Strickler, Lerman Solymos & Calkins 110 South Northern Way York, PA 17402 II I~ I f' Respectfully submitted, Date: July 15, 1999 I. I I , ; ; " ~i'",~~m~~;:" At,,; iTl":'T. ;<., 1'(~('1.:"I'" 1", "'~ ~ l \.14,.t;,'HYl" ~~~:.-',:<"'i' 1.( " h1(t.i~:>; J.'",;.,I _' /r,f,l',,-, ." .4" :~r~:"':: :": -: ~,: ,'"", <'I, C",' "', ~:':"",-~~:::i; ":\:~: .~<,,:;. j~;,;~~1}!fi; ,-; ,',' :'". \""""~""~"IrJ:-'\~~~'~ };;~t'3:~\lt~~ .,~J/.~d.~. ..,....,l." ",,,'(,,{;-~'l.~;t , :.~ ;?~i.~"; ~}:..:i:~' t:i::,~:~;t ~:;;:;\~tj~'8%ti~:' .,-;:,.,:;, .~:;;. :~,'~~i't'~'J;;(l:f';'Jcii%;~ki'tib~J~~ ""..',.,l,~,~,:~<\I'_~.::r(:;.;~Ei::.~.~o.r;::;$:''l';:':'~ror,e .. '( ," '.1; '.." ," :; '/,;':: .~ ::'~ " ....._':<'( ,,;...' 'F" ;,.-. '<."- .;.,:, '.'~' :; "j :,'; '-,,' " ~-. ',' ,', .;' <;",".;: ,,,.:,.'I"""~':;' '1"_ I'~",' , .,' "''''';'!'~'~'''{~&l;:'':l:::'~': ~f.'~!V\L"': .~1:W~~^,1'l~1..rtp"I:1 " , --,.,\,.. :;~;~;~,~~)-~'""",,; r~'lo'rJtiti';i'~'~~r~~r\"- .f.\ .,-1 t .';-"- 0'" ""'.<""{'\':l,:t+\;~ ~."MI"1lIY~'t,~ '~~;:,~!j;;~~t~:~~_-'}:::;:'-i.'/.'< ,J'" .\' "):!,<,:', ',- ..:'~~~~~~~j}\~i~~;::~~\~& 'r,', . .'" " '",', '.' " . ',.,' , ," " .,_. _,'. ^' _ ~ . ~, L. h " _ '_~ .. '^ . , . \' '. IN THE COllRT OF CO:\J:\IO~ PLEAS OF ClIMBERLAND COllNTY HARDY Va. NO, 98SU6225 SPAAN CERTIFICATE PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE OF A SUBPOENA PURSUAr>.T TO RULE 4009.22 As a prerequisite to service of a subpoena(s) for documents and things pursuant to Rule 4009,22 ANN MARGARET GRAB, ESQUIRE certifies that: 1. A Notice of Intent to Serve the Subpoena(s) with a copy of the subpoena(s) attached thereto was mailed or delivered to each party at least twenty days prior to the date on which the subpoena(s) is sought to be served, 2. A copy of the Notice of Intent, including the proposed subpoena(s) is attached to this certificate, 3, No objection to the subpoena(s) has been received, and 4. The subpoena(s) which will be served is identical to the subpoena(s) which is attached to the Notice of Intent to Serve the Subpoena(s), Date: 9/1/99 ANN MARGARET GRAB, ESQUIRE 110 S NORTHERN WAY ~-;;/ ~J/'7---{:-~ -, c:/-./.' ~-,~ YORK, PA 17402 717-757-7602 ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT INQUIRIES SHOULD BE ADDRESSED TO: MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODUCTIONS, INC. 4940 DISSTON STREET PHILADELPHIA PA 19135 (215) 335-3590 File #: M255011 By: Margaret Bas iura ,0 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CU:\t8ERLAND COUNTY HARDY Vs. SPAAN No. 98SU6225 TO: TIM SHOLLENBERGER, ESQ NOTICE OF INTENT TO SERVE A SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS AND THINGS FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.21 DEFENDANT intends to serve a subpoena(s) identical to the one(s) attached to this notice, You have twenty (20) days from the date listed below in which to file of record and serve upon the undersigned an objection to the subpoena, If no objection is made the subpoena may be served. Date: 8/11/99 ANN MARGARET GRAB, ESQUIRE 110 S NORTHERN WAY YORK, PA 17402 ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT INQUIRIES SHOULD BB ADDRESSED TOI MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODUCTIONS, INC. 4940 DISSTON STREET PHILADELPHIA, PA 19135 (215) 335-3590 By: Margaret Basiura Enc(s) : Copy of subpoena(s) Counsel return card File #: M255011 ca-M)NWE7\LTlI OF PENlSYLVANIA CllJNI"l OF a.JMBE1UJ\Nll HARDY Vs, ~laSUG225 File No. SPAAN SUBPOENA TO PR<X:U;E DCCl.tENTS OR TIi I NGS FOR 0 I SCOVERY PURSUANT TO RLt.E 4009.22 PA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIV" RM 210 SOUTH OFFICE, BLDG, HARRISBURG PA 1712 TO: n~~N. P~RSONNEL DEPT (N!ITle of Person or Entity) Within twenty (20) days after service of this subpoena, you are ordered by the court tc produce the following docunent'l or thin~: SEE A TTACHl';U AuDENDUM at IM~JJ~Q40 DISSTON ST., PHILA., PA MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODUCTIONS, ~~esSl You may deliver or mai I legible "copies of the docUnents'."",-~produce things reQUested ". this subpoena, together with the certificate of carpliance, to the party making thl: rllqUest at the address listed above. You have therisht to seek in advance tha rea-.onabil cost of. preparing the copies or producing the things ~~9ht. . . ~, '.. If you fail to. Produce the docunents or things reQUired by this subpoena within twent, (20)"oays", aft'll!" it's serv~i::e','''tne' party serving,-:tll-":\, sul:\pOehamay seek' a COI.rt'orde- c:arpel'ling youto:,CQTply:with it. .,' .' " THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT TI-E REOLeST OF THE, FOLLO\I/ING PERSON: NA/'E : ADDRESS: . ANN MARGARET GKAH, ESQ 110 S NORTHEP~ WA~, . ,~~ TELEPHEltJE~-,.,. ,,,. "_YQ~PI\' 17402., ",' '," slJ>REJ.E:cd.m" io If':;~'''-' ,': -" ",". ';~:";7 V':~ 2.~l_GJ:~T.j,..,j::J-02.1J'. ATTORNEY FOR;. . ''',. ,r",,_ ,,'.' ..- ~>' I , ,.J.~,:'~:". ..,~~ ,.". ~1~.<\J~'.~ -f" '"r " l~' . . _~ . .,1) ~.I;.~ , . ',:-. r~-:'.:-,'t:.. t.:.. . .... .r\~<. , r'" ,.: -<il -,"',1 55986 :. ; I.... . ", ,c QEFENJ;lANT ,", .. . ~~.. ' " .!.,...~ '. .. \.t..:/ J/ '~>~: ' . ,: "& ! '.: . "~,, i. ':.: -:, '~ M255011-01 ~A~: · ~~~e9~~~99 :".i" . p!"othonotary/O erk, Oi Division . ~;;"'r,P~'!-7?;(Y?~~~Cy '-- , ;:...":. .':, '~ './ ' .' . " ..~ (Eff. 7/97) "':':',::1,,' -...... . -~, " .".~t.:'l :/~., .--" I....,., .~ ADDENDUM TO SUBPOENA HARDY Vs. No. 98SU6225 SPAAN CUSTODIAN O~' RECORDS FOR: I'A 1I0VSE OF REI'RESENTATIV ANY EMPLOYMENT APPLICATIONS, EARNINGS, LEDGER SHEETS, TIME CARDS REVIEWS, ATTENDANCE SHEETS, ANY AND ALL MEDICAL RECORDS AND REPORTS AND PRE-EMPLOYMENT PHYSICALS, WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION CLAIMS MADE, ANY W-2 WITHHOLDING TAX FORMS, AND ANY OTHER INFORMATION PERTAINING TO: NAME: CHERYL T HARDY ADDRESS: 20 BERTHA DR OBERLIN PA DATE OF BIRTH: 09/05/98 SSAN: 170520301 CERTIFIED PHOTOCOPIES OF THE RECORDS WILL BE ACCEPTED IN LIEU OF YOUR PERSONAL APPEARANCE. County of: CUMBERLAND MLR File #: M255011-01 lU+llNWFlIl:111 (J/o' P~:NNSYI.v1lN1J\ . . axMl"i O_~WMUl-lUlIND I !td~_:; '( . " ') dSIJ{;;;;~ {.J File No. " . ~ .. ',t'(\I\.. SUBPC€NA TO PROCIC..aO DOCl..tE~S OR TH I NClS FOR 0 I SCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009. 22 DR FRANK GALLA. 4930 RITTER RD, MECHANICSBURG PA 17055 TO: (NlIlle of Person 0<" Entity) within twenty (20) days after uervice of this subpoena, you are ordered by the court t procllce the following doa.rnent.'l or thing:s: DDE"'DIT"I SEE AT'I'ACH~U A l~ u~. at - MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODUCTIONS, I~~~ DISSTON ST., PHILA., PA You may deliver 0<" mail legible copies of the doctment'sOr produce things requested' this subpoena, together with the certificate of COTllliance, to the party making th r.equest at the address 1 isted above. You have the right to seek in advance the rea'onab cost of preoaring the copies 0<" producing the things sought. I f you fai I to produce the docunents 0<" things required by this subpoena within twent (201 days after its serv~ce, the party serving thi:; siJbpoena'm;iy seek a court ord, cprpel 1 ing you tocarp1y wit.h it... THIS SUBPOENA WAS NA/'E : AOlJAESS: ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF TI-E FOLLONING PERSON:, ANN MARGAReT Gl-Ulli, ESQ 110 S NORTHERN WAY TELEPHONE: sU>REI'E exulT ATTORNEY FOR:. YORK. Oil 17402 10 If'.o.. "" ,~-.j.j5-3~12-- 55986 '. ,.: DEFENDANT . " . Y. M255011-03 OATE:'- , [),. ~-; 9 /999. ,'..~~rt. " (Eff. 1/97) ,..pi-: aM-{)t~'EI\I.TI! OP PtMlSYINANIA ~-()~~~ iUd~j:,'{ ,. 1.~:~;;jJ 2 2 ') Fi Ie No. S Pt\A~; SUBPOENA TO PI!OOU::E OOCl.t1:NTS 00 TH I NQS FOR 0 I SCOVERY PUlSUANT TO RLtE 4~.....lZ. HEALTHSOUTH, -150 pmiERS AVE, HARRISBURG PA 17109 TO: I\TTN. ~F'D I C,,,. RECORDS DEPT (Nerne of Person or Entity) Within twenty (20) days after :>crvice vf this subpoena, you lire ordered by the court tc produce the follOWing doct.ment!l or thin,as: .........,r IRJ..1" f SEE ATIAL'Hl!,U AU1.m 'UU1V at CTIONS I~.JJdQdn DISSTON ST., PHILA., PA MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODU '-\~~sJ You may deliver or mail legible copies of the cloCunents or produce things requested h this subpoena, together with the certificate of ccrrpliance. to the party making thi request at the address listed above. You have the right to seek in advance the rea-,onabl, cost of prll9aring the copies or produdng the things ,sought. I f you fai I to produce the docunents or things required by this subpoena within t"'ent' (20) 'days' after its serv~ce. the party serving' thb subpoena illayseek.'a cOurt.ofde' c:arpe 11.;ng you to carp ly with ,.it. THIS SUBPOENA WAS NAI'E :' ADDRESS: I SSUED AT 1l-E REau::ST OF 1l-E Fa,LCNlI NG PERSON} ANN MAKGAK~l GRAB, ESQ 110 S NORTHERN WAY TELEPI-(lNE:,- V('\RI( P/\ 17402 stFREI-E CXlUrr 10 If':" ':5 :'_. ~' __. _.~ .' . - . ': . "; ~ .t:.l.. -.J.J J-.)L.:I:Z ATTORNEY f'OR: " , 55986 DEFENQANT' . : " . M255011-06., ~ 9. /999 DATE'e9' Q f ' Sea of the Court "-.... ", .. (Eff. 7/97) ~. .' " --'!i. l'h";f,' . . . ,:, :~:,AKl1t'i~ )\")'-.I-',~:"i'::"_'''''~ " i ~J,r,~tJ~r -:=-~5t~ "L'f.;W ;~~