HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-06255
'...s: ~
;. .Q
,- i=
I
I .. of
! ~
I 3 ~
0
I ~ ~
I : '"
~
Ij If
~
&of <=to
~ e
.
, .....
i~ "i-
t)
I ;)0- A
0
ICJ
I
I
,
i (
I .....
! \~
I
I=-:
I .~
i ..
!,-,
,
i
~
Ii
~
\
c...
I;)-
.
~
..
\\' I I"~" NOli"
MARTSON DEAI(tl(lRH ~':"tO-'~-
MDW~
INf"UI.~Il'>N'."I'\'l<I''''IM~_'''T
'r, EAn Hit,.! STRHT 1\
t:N . , I""NNHL""NL" 170 "
C^Rll~U" ."
'-#PI /-5 --<7:;-'
"
1"-- .
"j",
':,1
.'.
"
.;8;,'./:
i
~ ,':!'~' ~,I
',.Jo.
<,
,'.
I 'Ilt,II~I~IHI "I',I~~ ..' "I'
1,'....1,1 '. " ',1".1
h"..l i ". '. .., ,"
111:1.1;:\ ('OYlT,
PI:1I11tllll'l
1:\ IIIH'OI'RI 01. ('O\I\IO\; 1'1. 1::\ SOF
(.t '\1111;1<1 ,\\;1) ('01 ':\ Ir, 1'1:\;l\:S\'I.\'A:\IA
v,
\;0 91' /
(,..) S~:.$
C~" ( ka. 1'1
CO\lMO:\\\'I't\I.TII 01.
I'ENNSYI. \' ANIA, Ill;. I' ARl\II'SI
OF TRANSI'ORTATIOl\:,
Rcspondcllt.
1'LI11lO:--; l'URRLVlLW
AND l"O\\', comcs l'c1ilioncr II.:Icn ('oyle, hy and through hcr allomcys, ivlARTSON
DEARDORFF WII.I.IA\IS & OTTO, and rcspcctlillly petitions thc Court pursuanl to 75 I'a. Cons.
Slat. ~ 1550 for rcvicw of an ordcr of thc Dcpartmcnt of Transportation rccalling Pctitioncr's
opcrating privilegc, ,.nd in sUPPlll'llhcrcof avcrs as li,lIolls:
I, Petilioncr Ildcn Coyle is all adult individual rcsiding al 101 Ladnor Lanc, Carlislc,
Cumbcrland Counly, Pcnnsylvania.
2, Pctitioncr currcntly posscsscs a valid drivcr's liecnsc, which has not hcrctoforc bccn
suspendcd, cancclcd or rcvokcd.
3. By Icllcr datcd Octobcr Cl, 19')8, Pctilioncr was nolificd in writing by thc Departmcnt
of Transportation of thc pcnding rceall of hcr driving privilege. Such rceall is based on mcdical
infomlation rcccivcd by thc Dcpartmcnt of Transportation that Pctitioncr suffcrs from a
Ncuropsychiatric conditionlhat allcgcdly prcvcnts Pctitioncr from safely opcrating a motor vchiclc.
A copy ofthc Icttcr is allachcd hcrclo as Exhibit "'A"',
4, Thc suspcnsion is impropcr in that thc rcfcrcnccd Ncuropsychiatric condition is not
a mcdical condilion cnumcratcd in (,7 Pa, Codc. ~ 83.5 as a condition which is likcly to intcrfcrc
with thc ability to safcly opcratc a motor vchiclc lhcrcby warranting a rccall of driving privilcgcs,
5. Thc suspcnsion is also impropcr in thaI, to lhc cxtcnt thc rcfcrcnccd
Ncuropsychiatric condition may bc a mcdical condition which warrants a rccall of Pctitioncr's
driving privilcgcs, any mcdical informal ion supporting lhc cxistcncc of such a condition is incorrcct
and contradictcd, Pctitioncr rcqucst strict proofofthc cxistcncc of such a condition and its cffcct
on hcr ability to safcly opcratc a motor vchidc.
Exhibit A
~
-r
Q:
8;',' c> ~r3! ')., IV'
<.
t': I r{ 'li
, ,. g (; ,0 -...I ~
,~,
I, ." , -..!:.
c: oJ V;> t---
C'. . d \. v) '::;l
I '-'1
" ~ . ':j:j
'. ~ .d.
I 'try- t:,.... d c::L
l*" - .}
,
\
I'
I,
~; -~ I
,;
il't.
111
d,
.~
'-. :;"',.
,,: ,~ ,
,
~. ,
'.;
".
MDW&C5
INIl'UlA.T1nN' AI........ ALM ~<I' 1
TEN F......ST Hlt,1I STREH
CARLISLE. {ICNNWLVANIA 170U
", ;",i
.,
,) I.,
:,tIJ
.<,.
~',
"l.,'
"
, ,
"'i:~ .
:'"
"'t-'
','
, r)~.':.:.
\
,
"
,
.,,'
; ",
>J.}
.
IIELE:-; ('OYI.I:,
PClllioll\.'1"
. \:
I
~,
\'
't,~ .
,
'J
I.'" ;
<It!
1'1111; ('OIR I m (,O\l\ION I'I."'\S OF
Cl\IIIII(I\\:II(,OI XIY,I'E"SYI\'A":\
v,
'c I. ')s.r,~55 ('i, i11,'l'Ill
CO\1\10N\\'I::\1.111 OF
PENNSYL VANI:\, DEP:\RT\IENT
OF TRANSPORTATION,
Rcspondcnt.
ORDER
AND NO\\', this..:~~~_.day of . _ '-. .:1~lI..L~I!.)~._ ...._.__._' !l/(Cl, upon cousidcratiou of
Pctitioncr's Joint Motion for Contiuuaucc, it i~ hcrchy ORDERED that thc I Icaring schcduled in thc
abovc captioncd mallcr and sct for January J I. I ')1)1) is continucd J(lr a pcriod of thirty (30) days,
Thc Hcaring is hcrcby rc.schcdulcd lilr thc .J~~day of _:JJI,tVt-<J,-
19.'i't, in Courtroom. ) ofthc Cumbcrland County Courthousc.
.
!'
,.
,~
l:
"I
i
I
I
J,
,
i
"
'1,_
:! r ,A
j,I!}?
1\'
r'
II
II: ~
~"
.~
"
'lilt P\llftIJ',!"'IMIl". "'\1"
\,,",) .1-,' ."".'\1
II".,,! "" <ll_'\"
111'1.1;.~ C'C)YI F,
Pl'titiOlIl.:r
1:\1111: ('()[ 'lfl 01. (,O,\I.\I():-'; I'I.I.AS 0I-
l '(I\IBI:RI.A:\I> I 'OJ !:\TY,I'I;:-';:-';SYI.\'..\:\IA
v.
:\(). 'JS,(,255 ('i, il T~nn
COMMONWEALTIIOF
I'Et\NSYI.\'ANIA, DEI'ART\IU';T
OF TRANSI'ORTATlON,
R~spond~nl.
JOlNLMOTIOXl'OlCCONTlt'i VANCE
AND NOW, com~s I'ctilioncr Ildcn Coylc, hy ami through hcr attorncys, MARTSON
DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO, and rcspcctlillly rClJucsts that thc Court grant a Continuancc
in the above captioncd matter, and in support thcrcof avcrs as follows:
I, A Hcaring has bccn schcdulcd for January II, 1999 hclorc thc Honorahlc Gcorgc E.
Hot"t"~r in this Appcal ofthc rceall ot"l'ctitioncr's driv~r's liccnse.
2. Petitioncr has surrcndcrcd hcr drivcr's liccnsc.
3. Pctitioner is attcmpting to schcdulc an Indcpcndcnt Mcdical Exam to support hcr
contcntionthat hcr mcdical condition docs not warrant a rccall ofhcr driving privilcgcs,
4. It is ncccssary to Pctitioncr's dct"cnsc that an cxam bc conductcd prior to thc Hearing.
5. This mattcr is not prcscntly ripc for Hcaring.
6, PClitioncr has contactcd Gcorgc II. Kahusk, counsel for thc Rcspondcnt, who has
agrccd to a thirty (30) day continuancc ofth~ Hcaring.
WHEREFORE, Pctitioncr and Rcspondcnt rcspcctfully rcqucst that thc Court grant hcr
Motion for Continuancc and rc.schcdulc thc Hcaring inlhis matter to a latcr datc,
\1. Ins.'()1\: EARDOI\. :FF _W Will.. .IAMS & OTTO
/lY:~ .W. __
Thulllas (i. Collins, I'slfuir~
J.D, 1\:u. 75SlJh
T~n Easl II igh Str~d
Carlisk. P A 170 t:1
(717) 243.3341
Dat~: January S, I'I'IS
Attol'l1~Ys Illl' P~lilion~1'
,
\,
r
,
\ '
'r4,
,;'
{,
:tf
,'\ .
., ,~, 'I,
I . .1' ,~
" ...,
;.};I",
'.,
, .
.... \ ~\ I; ~
MDW&O
l~fnllM~ru'to'^I""I"f'^lr.l",,:,o.L'Y
fES
9 1999..~
~-Y
TEN EAST Hllal STREET
CARl.ISlE. PW:-OSYL\'AN1A 17013
.,.1
','
,../;,{ ~ '"
. ;~
,
.'.
,
,y" "{,I
1'. .,,,, f."
. :1,1,
".
"
1
,
/;t;'!f;l
"
.1
, ~7v."l
, !_'~
....
.'
'.).
) ~~"
111I1\11.\l\llll,,''''I"'l'''.I.'':\h'.I,;
(,t..",l d: ;'~'" I. 0', ~ I .\\1
Iln,.r I "." ~ "II I: ': \\1
IIELEN COYLE,
P~titilln~r
,'\ Till; COURT 01: ('0:-'1:-'10'\ PLEAS OF
CII~IIlERLA:'\1l (,OII:'\TY, PI;NNSYLVA1\IA
v.
1\0, 'IS.()255
Ci,.jJ T~rlll
COMMONWEALTII OF
PENNSYLV ANIA, DEPARTMENT
OF TRANSPORTATION,
R~spond~nl.
J.lli!l/I.i\lOTlilllI.O..DLSCONTh"\.U.E..f.URSU..f\J\TlQ1~U.LE.222
I. Th~ abov~.caption~d a~tion was comm~n~~d by P~tition lor R~vi~w on or about
Nov~mb~r 4, 1998.
ry The instant disput~ aris~s out or the suspension or P~tition~r's driv~r's liccnsc by
Rcspondent to bc ~rrecti\'e on or about No\'cmb~r II, 1998.
3, By Ordcr datcd JanualY 8, 1999, upon considcration or Petitioner's Joint Motion ror
Continuance, a hcaring in the abovc captioncd mattcr was schcduled ror March 24, 1999,
4. The parties arc now in agrccmcnt that the matter should propcrly be withdrawn and
discontinued, without prejudicc.
WHEREFORE, it is rcspeclrully rcqucsted that thc above.captioncd action bc withdrawn and
dismissed, without prejudicc.
By,,"-
Thomas G. Co '~squire
!.D. No, 75896
Tcn East High Street
Carlislc, PA 17013
(717) 243.3341
DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO
~
Attorneys lor Plaintirr
Datcd: February 8, 1999
"R
~l ~
Z'1
...:::
'1
':1 r
~
~
r:'.
1.:
, ,
L-: !
I
"
L
,
<.
I
I
II"
( .
i.__
"
(,.j,
I
!
i
~
~
.
l-
n
~