The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About98-06810 i C! ot V); '~: -g ::r. ~ r u:: ,.,~ i. c- f J R. F. FAGER CO. :IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff, v. : No, fJ - 0 '41 D , "rl {l(tI-tL JAMES IIUTCIIISON tJdlb/a IIUTCII CONSTRUCfION. Defendant. :CIVIL ACTION - LAW NOTICE TO DEFEND YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you, You are warned that if you fail to do so, the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice or any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff, You may lose money or property or other rights important to you, YOU SHOULD TAKE TillS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Cumberland County Bar Association 2 Liberty Avenue Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 (717) 249-3166 :r ~, 7, Between April I, 1998 and October 31,1998, various producu,lloods, supplies and materials (hereinafter collectively referred to as "products") were ordered by Defendanl from i j .' Plaintiff. Plaintiff sold and provided Ihe products ordered by Defendant. The invoices arc 100 numerous to be attached hereto, however, invoices, shall, upon request, be supplied 10 Defendant, 8, The prices charged for the products sold to Defendant as set forth in the invoices 1. '.,' ,. l.l n r I," ,I Il I were fair, reasonable market prices of the products and the prices that Defendant agreed to pay, 9. Plaintiff has maintained a statement of account keepinll an accurate and running account of debits and credits for the produdcts sold to Defendant by Plainliff. 10. Plaintilfhas submitted to Defendant statements of account accurately setting forth all debits and credits for transactions with Defendant, said statements of account showing an amount owing to Plaintilfof$ 9,582,99 and reOecting no payments, A statement dated October 3 I, 1998, is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked as Exhibit "n", I I, Despite demand, Defendant has refused to pay the past due balance on the open ) 1,1 I I' d I , i r "l "'; . ",r," ;..:i i,U ;'~' ;: " l: ,';? '~ 1\ account of all sums due and owing to Plaintiff. 12. Plaintilfhas retained the services of the law linn of KUNDRAT & ASSOCIATES at the rate of$135,OO per hour in the colleclion of the amount due from Defendant 13. Plaintilfhas incurred reasonable attorney's fees from the law linn of KUNDRAT & ASSOCIATES in the collection of the amounts due from Defendant in commencing this action, and shall continue to incur such attorney's fees through the conclusion of the proceedings, 14, Any and all conditions precedent to the bringing of this action has been perfonned by Plaintiff. 15, The amount in controversy is within the jurisdictional amount requiring 2 compulsory arbitration, WIIEREFORE,l'laintill: R, F, FAGER CO, respectfully requests that judgment be entered in its behalf and against Defendant, JAMES HUTCHISON tldlb/a IIUTCII CONSTRUCTION, in the amount of$9,582,99, interest at the rate of I 1/2 % per month from Oc10ber 31,1998, allomeys fees, plus the costs of this action and such other relief as the court deems just and proper. Respectfully submilled, S, Kundrat 1I0mey for Plaintiff PA ID 24958 107 Boas Street Harrisburg, P A 17102 (717) 232-3755 3 ~ /S(){). CD . . ' ~. .. . ,..--' ('.....:' ',. ....."." ,n':'t-r ./'1"':-;' . ~..." ,// ~~""""?,,,,~~ .. ._-~ .--- ;>lH.Il(' ~(, !.ttr,(.o' .. r. rl'/"'.r" (" / ,,' ., i l.. 10. " /"" \0,' ';',:,t, ~. k i:fI; ,t Ct:l:j' lli!l.I"'lllI:O.. 17011 , InJu\lrulll"" .nJ J'''lII'f.' . Jtil.tl:l'II';~. U:;tinr.. nu, ~j::r! .~d f!:~cz M:r:d S'.lIl!ln ('1 L:rl'" _:.:1.....:.. H~~ J.J( .',':'1(1~: Dnt~: L/ J&f / F yji' J r~ nt: . . ," -r' ' , .....'.-'-...ol.~L W. 4-~;~ J/\ .' ~ J::I :..: ;;1,:.::; . . ~_.." :; 7~~ ~/ ~A. A'I:~~..,,:..d5' h 1- __-:.. , ZIP CODE /7".r.r : c~._i':(' - -?d.:.f2(f_. .,,:.;!: ). .1 "~r-: A-,,,,/; 7c:./-/7?CJ ?,-L,,-t:~LIa:~ Ct'q'. ;?~~k/ 7 '. "-.--. - 1!. 2 J . c.:.: ,.:] ~ .:: c'c""'r" / II J-/~ '" .._.u.... ~..16..,L~::?~ .. ._' . " . "~:\ ',' .. if; u____--' r-' .._._._..-.,-~ --_._--_._-_._~- z,' l'n .' < ...----.-.-- .' ,I ~,Io " d , ,.f" .. .- .~I , ., , ., ,:' L" '- ! " '. < ~ J I ~ ,,' . i L I -' . I~W u '",' I I , ; ",: Ii -: l "'!.' a: , I' i ~ "'~ ~ ~- -< UI i" ~ , ~~ " ~ I ~ : ; I . J .. <: , i .. o~ u. , i I~ f! C :;'0. < u: , I L "'II: w g I ii '. ", . .., w::> : . Ii ~ ., Ii "'0 L I 'i <> . " ;'~-~- w ~'. II i I .... , ! c' 0- ,< " "' C' < Q --',- -, J -,-- ..--..- I I " : .. , . .. . l" ~- .. , , .. (' .- . , , , , , , , 1 0 0 . 0 . . '" C' w .. " : , " . . , 5 ,- ~ . , I .. : - .' , .- . .. - , 0 . ! , i , . J - . , , - - c L < .. .. . J 0 I .. s, c' .-.----- ~ ~' Ul >- C . 0 z 5 g . a: . . w z > , 0 > < . -1' Ul ! >- .. .. Q , g . ~ ;0 --- , " , , .. .. , , ~ , '! , t, C' I . .. , Ul - ~ l.' ,. ,. , >- . ,- .. - ,. , ! , - < . , -- - , ,- , Q : 0 '" 0 - M -- -- , . . "' , " VI ;1 , I I 5 - - _.. '" , >- L, " i.: , -, ,- , ,- .. < .. - [, , - :-' - .. .. C " -'- 6t Q - L' .. : l , .. , .. u - L' - !-I 0 .. I .. L_ - t , " .. I - t- o' .- L I- - .. . n , , - - - - - I : - d .. - , ii .. .. .. .. " 0, - , , , , - h- i , - .. i: .. . , - : , : , : - ((. <: , . " - " ,- , :.. " r , I - ~'. , - I , .. I ! - C r:; t I .. .. .. ~ ~ , w . " a: . , '. . a: c , .. .. .. .. ::> ,. -- - , , .. U ! "- . " . . .' r., , , ,- ,. , " , : , - .. , , - - - I '- , " , ;. !:- " . "' L - "' .' " , 0 < " 0 "' " () ...; 0 =' " , " cr- ~ " U,I 0 .. ~ " ; ", ;: " c- " , , , " , c ~ " w c . < z u w U Z < , " < ". It] :~ -.' ':', .~;:r/'/J':{-r;{' III i\~~:~~~" ..;....;.:~..'~J oj " ..', "', """- - .. ':" ,,;,~ ~ . ~... ~. -- .-.....' ",. . ''-"I ~~ ,,(",_ , ! ~j .....-..- ~ .. lt~ :>", "0 cr.. It>< IH o:li ZW ",II , &/1 C' 1M, =" Lf, CJ ," > 15 .. I~... ..; \ I", ; , .. I .' ' ~' I'. l::i. , , o~ u'. ,. a: I I wi Cl' C( u. ~' ;- .' u. ~ ' ci~ I,.' :: I ,~ , ,. ,. I I , i , 1(, . '. '. , if ~. t , '\ i ',' . . , ,/ ~ " < L . ," " I ~ . 1;: .. ~ .. ~ .. .. " i, '. ,. " III . > c c 5: ;~ II: " W > a "'-.------ " III > C .. a " 5: ,. ;0 '. l~ I: .; , III > < , , C i C :il .. - 1 .. . ~ .., f. < ,. --~-- . 0 < , - Cl . ,.- --'-_. <.> ..; 0 c " III ~ . , > . CI: :; . " t c .. " L C .., . c .., " .., ~, ., . L' ;: , ~ , " , ~' - ,; ~ ! , ~: , , , , w it c . . w " x , It u . w . II: u L :> z ,; c' u . , , z ! '. "'. . .. . -- ~ '" c e r' __J w Zl '" c .. f! i <' i.. lt~ 0 :>", 0, :nYcrl'~ It'< W~. I :q: Cl~' ..- c:f < z W LL f, ; Wa: . ~ , III C' U. t ! UI::a ~ V," ex: ~ ! ~> 0- I...) , .. I .. l' < L !.= ... :' ... ~ "' .. " ~ i. , , . 0< Ull. 0: l',1 ~ \ -i 0 ~ " i ~ E- ;: <:: I. L' r~ , , , < . . ; , " , - < , . c " .' t 1-.. f.' " . , i f 0 ~ % , ~ .- .. i ~ , .. , ! , , w 0 c . % . U ~ . . U L % ,. . % ! ' , . " < , , "I - C !;: w a: a: :> u YERII.lCAIlmi t:~'fF.ar .1 : I, ~".~.,. J'r'<l?" d,! !jmby~tha1 the &cu lei forth inlhe furcgolna Complaint Ire lru' , end correct to the brsl of my Mowlcdae,lnfonnlllon and belicf 1 UnderlllaM th.t fain ttaternmls herein Ite made tubject lei Ihe penaltie. or 18 PaC,S. ~904 relaling to uhswom rabificltion to IUthorities. E!#- ~~' ~ (0J . w - (>-..u '-" -J ~ c;r ~ - -, ~ - c) VJ v.., ~ ~ ^ \ ~j ~ '-" . \ C>~ "" . J\" ,.\ c:; \" .0, i? \0 ?-: is (\J ;.0: .. :-)..'- l':l CO': ( ) ~ ;; ~;,. :t:: ;):> ~ <;, "- ~ ::J '~, ...., -;.:r;; r" N ' :"." ... f't1 :~. L" t...' ".10) if u.J ~1u.. Q a ~ co en , '" c. o u t) " ~ ~ o u '0 :;; " :l ~ ;'E " 0 .c II o ~ ~~ '" 0 ,- '0 oS " ~e ~ - ~ " " '" u ,_ >..~ ~ l5 ~,g -= ~ -~ o o . .. Q ;:: Q; .. If\jjS OwZ !:!e:~ 01 ZlIl> II:ccn WZZ1 GOlli C'<I "~ll. !:' ~ lIl' .. ~'S! t:. :z:z::l Cl~lD Z"'UI ZC'<Iii: Z II: ::l ~ U :z: ~ oS ~ ~ ;;: . ,\ , " I! Ii !I II I! II il II II ii [I I ! R.I". fAGER CO" Plaintiff IN TilE COUIl1' Of COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. 1998-6810 JAMES HUTCHISON t/d/b/a HUTCH CONSTRUCTION, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW TO: R.F. Faqer Comoanv. Plaintiff and John S. Kundrat, Esquire KUNDRAT & ASSOCIATES 107 Boas Street Harrisburg, PA 17102 (Attorneys for Plaintiff) YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED TO PLEAD TO THE ENCLOSED NEW MATTER WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF SERVICE HEREOF OR A DEFAULT JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. ;ai~~ ;!~d~~~{;~~~~;e~~~~~~e 1. D. #66266 2320 North Second Street P.O. Box 60457 Harrisburg, PA 17106-0457 (717) 238-6570 (Attorneys for Defendants) !; R,F, ~'AGF.R CO., Plaintiff I N 'I'm; COUR1' O~' COMMON PLP.AS CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA . . . . . . NO. 1998-6810 , ii !i 'I I, I' II 'I I, il II II II ii II I, v. JAMES HUTCHISON t/d/b/a HUTCH CONSTRUCTION, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW ANSWER TO COMPLAIN-I' AND NEW MATTER AND NOW, comes the Defendant, James Hutchison t/d/b/a Hutch Construction, by and through his counsel, Cunningham & Chernicoff, P.c., and files his Answer to the Complaint filed by R. F. Fager Company, and in support thereof avers as follows: " ji I' ,I I 1. Admi tted. 2. Admi tted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that James Hutchison is an adult individual. It is denied that James Hutchison trades and does business as HutCh Construction. By way of further reply, HutCh Construction ceased business operations on December 31, 1997. 3. Denied. It is denied that at all times relevant Defendant conducted business under the name Hutch Construction. By way of further reply, on December 31, 1997, !: I: ji i: , Jamos Hutchison ceased doing businoss as Hutch Construction, By way of further reply, on or about January 2, 1998, Articles of Corporation were filed on behalf of Hutch Construction, Inc. I I I II I I I 4. Admitted. 5. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that James Hutchison is a contractor. It is denied that James Hutchison t/d/b/a Hutch Construction, at all times relevant, was a contractor. 6. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that James Hutchison t/d/b/a Hutch Construction executed a credit application with Plaintiff on or about April 30, 1974. It is denied that Hutch Construction is still in business. 7. Denied. It is denied that between April 1, 1998 and October 31, 1998, various products, goods, supplies and materials (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Products") were ordered by Defendant from Plaintiff. It is further denied that Plaintiff sold and provided the products to the named Defendant. As to the balance of the averments set forth 3 in Paragraph 7, Defendant is without knowledge sufficient to form a belief and strict proof of the same, if relevant, is demanded at the time of trial. 8. The Defendant is without knowledge sufficient to form belief as to the truth of the averments set forth in Paragraph 8 of the Plaintiff's Complaint and strict proof of the same, if relevant, is demanded at the time of trial. 9. The Defendant is without knowledge sufficient to form belief as to the truth of the averments set forth in Paragraph 9 of the Plaintiff's complaint and strict proof of the same, if relevant, is demanded at the time of trial. By way of further reply, it is specifically denied that between April 1, 1998 and October 31, 1998, Plaintiff sold any goods to the named Defendant. 10. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff has submitted to the named Defendant statements of account which set forth alleged debts and credits for transactions. It is denied that the statements of accounts submitted by Plaintiff to the named Defendant accurately sets forth all debits and credits for transactions with Defendant. 4 Ii 'I " " , ;1 il 13. Answering Defendant is without knowledge Dufficiont to form a bel iof as to the truth of the averments set forth in paragraph 13 of the Plaintiff's Complaint and strict proof of the same, if relevant, is demanded at the time of trial. I 14. The averments set forth in Paragraph 14 state conclusions of law to which no response is required. In the event that an answer is so required the averments set forth in Paragraph 14 of the Plaintiff's Complaint are denied. 15. Admitted. WHEREFORE, Answering Defendant, James Hutchison t/d/b/a Hutch Construction respectfully requests that this Honorable Court enter judgment in its favor and against the Plaintiff, and dismiss the Plaintiff's Complaint with prejudice, and further award Defendant all such other relief as is proper and I ~ just. NEW MATTER 16. The answers set forth in Paragraphs 1-15 are incorporated herein by reference as if more fully set forth at length. 6 ~ , , I' ~ I 'I I, " ,i , il II Ii 17. On or about January 2, 1998, CO-Defendant, Hutch II ': Construction, Inc., filed Articles of Incorporation with the Pennsylvania Corporation Bureau which caused a corporation to be formed known as "Hutch Construction, Inc." 18. On or about January 2, 1998, Co-D~fendant, James Hutchison, as President and Indivi.dually, contacted the Plaintiff to specifically inform Plaintiff that the sole proprietorship known as "Hutch Construction", was no longer in business and that the corporation known as "Hutch Construction, Inc.", had now been formed. 19. After January 2, 1998 any purchase orders placed with Plaintiff were placed by Hutch Construction, Inc., as evidenced by the purchase orders which are attached hereto and are collectively marked as Exhibit "A". 20. Plaintiff knew or should have known that Hutch Construction, Inc. was a corporation because all written communications from Hutch Construction, Inc. between January 2, 1998 and October 31, 1998 were sent on corporation letterhead. A copy of the corporation letterhead is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "B". 7 Ii I' I! ,I I 'I I[ I I I 21. By virtue of the incorporation of Co-Defendant, Hutch construction, Inc., Co-Defendant James Hutchison, Jr., was not personally responsible for any obligations incurred by Hutch Construction Company, Inc. 22. Co-Defendant, James Hutchison, Individually, did not execute any credit application or personal guarantees on behalf of Hutch construction, Inc. 23. Notwithstanding the prior notification to Plaintiff concerning the incorporation of Hutch Construction, Inc., Plaintiff continued to erroneously request payment from Co- Defendant James Hutchison and James Hutchison tjdjbja Hutch Construction for alleged obligations incurred by Co-Defendant, Hutch Construction, Inc. 24. As a matter of law, an individual cannot do business as a corporation. " 8 " , ~I~IC.lTTON I, J'u.. IIutehlson, Pre\liden1: of HU1:eh COng1:ructlon, Inc., verify that 1:he s1:Il1:8asnts made in the foregoing Ansver ancS New K4tter are ~rue IIncS oorrllOt 1:0 tl1. h"at of III'/ knov1adq., information and b.lief. I ~~cSer&tand that false st.atements herein are _lSe 8\1.llject to the p<onalti.. of IUl5WOrn falsif1ca~10n to authoriti.., Oate: December 22 1998 . R f FAGER C.m~ ~'ll ? . if r 1 76' 6428 07110/96 ~4:~6:; ,C~/O' \0:~S9 " . To: R,P. PAGBR ~05' STATB ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Purchase ~ Purdl_ Order No, J5J'l." I 0.. ....., ~ , 'RDEReD BY; Hutch Conatruction. Inc. P,O. Box 7 ~echan1clburg, PA 17055 SllIpTo, CONSBVAGB 15.90, i I I I , ! '--' Go~ TnN i SlIIp VIA 7/z2/'J8 j,_" ,11_11.- I lu-' =""YIR I--~;; ! Accounl No. r" -. _~N f; t F , L: ~, t' . , j , I I I -' , '- TOT~__ i1horizec:t Slgnalln ~. J , I , I i. I r~ S .A F >'CiA c.~~ ",ll Pa ",;-... W717 761 "'28 07/10/0& "", J:."'l....".,. ~ 0.1 j'-' "'O:"2X Purchase Or4er I PurdlIN O~No, 355'1S/1 c.tt ';: I I .' \OEIlED BY. lutch CQMttuct1on, Inc. >,0. BOle 7 4e~nic'bur9. PA 17055 To: R.r. l'AGJR ~056 STATe ROAr> CAMP KIL~, PA 17Cll Ship To: PO&TKR. i _ ____--------L-- i-.9aodTh~..:=..-=--8t....!PVill -_-=---=--~~~--~---- TIfTIlI -I--~ L8~s/g.!._1 I _; Net Due ~ 1=-=,...J!Il1l-~ _._L_ o.H1<lIlan -[ QUI~~ ..:. UnltPrict \ \P~UMBl!lG FIXTUllBS ! 1. 00 ~, SS8. gO ~. 58.90 I I I I \ I \ <J \ \ '- j( ax.l., TOTAl. Autloriud SlgnIlIJR .' " ... ':" R. F. FAGER CO. :IN TilE counT OF COMMON I'LEAS :CUMDEnLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PlalntilT, v. : No. 1998-6810 JAMES IIUTCIIISON tJdfb/a IIUTCH CONSTRUCfION, Defendant. :CIVIL ACTION - LAW NOTICE TO PI.EAD To: James Hutchison IId/b/a Hutch Construction AND Paige Macdonald.Mauhes, Esquire 2320 North Second Street P.O. Box 60457 Harrisburg, PA 17106-0457 YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED TO PLEAD TO THE ENCLOSED NEW MATTER WITH TWENTY (20) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF SERVICE HEREOF OR A DEFAULT JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU, KUNDRAT & ASSOCIATES his representatives as had been the course of dealings between the parties since 1984, 20. Denied, It is denied that PlaintilT knew or should have known thatllutch Construction, Inc, was a corporation due to the wrillen communications, To the contrary, no wrillen communications on Hutch Construction, Inc, stationery was received by Plaintiff 21. Paragraph 21 is a conclusion of law to which no response is necessary, Ifa response is necessary the allegation is denied, As a result of the application for credit of James w. Hutchison, Jr, co.defendant herein, on April 30, J 974, credit was established for James W, Hutchison, Jr, in his individual capacity and trading as Hutch Construction, The mere formation of a corporation known as Hutch Construction, Jnc, does not eliminate lhe liability of Defendant HU1ehison, individually, 22, Admitted with clarification, It is admitted that James W, Hutchison, Jr, co- defendant did not execute a credit application on behalf of Hutch Construction, Inc, or execute personal guarantees on behalf of Hutch Construction, Inc, However, James W, Hutchison, Jr, did execute a credit application in 1974 on his own behalftldlb/a Hutch Construction, Plaintiff extended credit to James W. Hutchison, Jr, based upon that credit application, In that no credit application was supplied to Plaintiff by Hutch Construction, Inc, no credit was ever extended to that entity by Plain1iff. 23, Denied, It is denied that there was prior notification to Plaintiff that James Hutchison individually would no longer be using his credit line established in his individual capacity and that all purchases and responsibilities for payment of same would be that ofHu1ch Construction, Inc, It is denied that Plaintiff continued to erroneously request payment from co- defendant James Hutchison for alleged obligations of Hutch Construction, Inc, To the contrary, 2 all obligations due and owing and requested under Ihis Complaint are those of James W, Hutchison, Jr, IId/b/a HUlch Construction, 24, Paragraph 24 is a conclusion ofJaw to which no response is necessary, WHEREFORE, PlaintilTrequcsts Ihsllhe Ncw Mallcr bc dismissed, PLAINTIFF'S NEW MAITER 25, In 1974, Jamcs W, Hutchison, Jr. (Hcreinaftcr refcrred 10 as "Hutchison") applied for credit with Plaintiff. 26, PJaintilTinvestigalcd thc crcdit of Hutchison and cxtended a Iinc of credit. Thc partics conducled busincss undcr this Iinc of crcdit throughout thcir busincss rclationship, 27. Hutchison never advised PlaintilTthat he had created a corporation known as Hutch Construction, lnc, 28, Hutch Construction, lnc, never applied for credit with PlaintilT and Plaintiff never extendcd credit to Hutch Construction, lnc, 29. If, in fact, purchase orders for Hutch Construction, lnc, or correspondence between the parties on Hutch Construction, lnc, stationery exists, it is irrelevant to this maller, WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, R. F, FAGER CO, respectfully requests that judgment be entered in its behalf and against Defendant, JAMES HVTCmSON t/dIb/a HUrCH CONSTRUCTION, in the amount of$9,582,99, interest at the rate of I V, % per month from 3 October 31, 1998, allomcys fees, plus Ihe costs oflhis action and such olher reliefas Ihe court Respeclfully submilled, deems just and proper )0 S, undrat / J lomey for Plaintiff i A ID 24958 107 Boas Streel Harrisburg, PAl 71 02 (717) 232-3755 . \ , J 4 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND NOW, this Ilh day of January, 1999, I, John S Kundrat. Esquire, Counsel for Plaintiff, hereby certify that a true and correct copy of tile foregoing Reply to New Matter was selVed via first class mail, postage prepaid addressed to the parties or counsel of record as follows: Paige Macdonald.Matthes, Esquire 2320 North Second Street P,O, Box 60457 Harrisburg, PA J 7106-0457 January II, 1999 Jo S, Kundrat torney for Plaintiff ~ CI C: ~~ -... r (fj ". <~ . .. , c: ,~ . , h' t:t. , r ..;.J) tt c'.a ' 'OJ ~ '~ - r:: ~ ~~ ,'lU1 -, ::~Cl. 15 en ::) en (J cJ 5! a: r:: If .. II! ~ ..8~li ;lll:i S' aza: r::. zgiil zt;l!l! z a: o ~ , '" '" o " <> " ~ ~ o " '0 = .. " 5 "=-E " 0 .c " o ~ -.... .~ 0 .0'0 - " ~i: - - t ~ u .._ >..~ .c ~ " 0 ~ " .0':; -.... o Ii ii II P d 'I i: II Ii II I II Ii " I II Ii rnc., and <ll:i' i ~L'" :" I, I ~ ' , , ,',; If I' " 1997 OCClJl"!",.d Jlt., .....'.^...ll 11., ::,' ~! I I' ! ! '~ . '1:: I t'l' 1'111, lllC', By way of Ill!!!:.., 1"pJ,', "'I,' ,Il.' ;;" J -/:'" 'r; flt't:" III 14 and 207,1, whir'h w..!., ~':'l I. 1',' II ),.;I,':!l l,y Hut,('h COnstl"Uct 1(;':., '. I,: ',,'. Lt.1) M,.lY j' : 13, 1998, whicll .I!" I' .Ij i d! ~ ,I' I., 1 ::. r." I'ul J,'ctivf21y ,Iii .11" marked as Exh i b i ~ "'II I :'J!fJ."J ':"J'.'., !I' \j":!ll)lultl"dte that Plaintiffs hdd ,H.."t.udl kr;i 'Nl" t",. Hi' !j"r;;i'I\j<.'rj,.Jll, Inc',ls corporate statu~; <HId t h.ll Limes 1;., ,t. " , I ; :, ~ ,,1 j r:I:"W. <it relevant, that it Wd'<; (j".ill L' ....'; I Ii " ,".)q,. i/ dt 'd' (!Z1t i Ly. 28. Adrnitt(lci. in pdl [ H.d j"L;,'d III lidl L It is admitted that Hutch Consu'ueL jon. Ill", Ii"'}," "I'f.,j 1,.d tOt' en,dit with Plaintiff. It is d.,-.ni'-:'ii !ll,i' i j,i:fit ift 1J"V;~I' c:,xtended credit to Hutch COI1SLt"lIctiorl, ! Ih'. I-,y W(-IY of further reply, Plaintiff, havinq kno'h'l,_'rll'l" )1 ! h.. "I;!'f)(JI ,11 ion known as Hutch Construction, Tne. e;~tended el pd I t to HULch Construction, Ine. 29. The averments Det forth in Paragraph 29 state conclusions of law to wh i eh no "esponse is required. In the event that an answer is so rogllired the averments set forth in Paragraph 29 of th,,' 1'1 ,Ii nL I fr' s Nc,w Matter are denied. ~ WHERFFuHE, D.'ti'nd,l!:~, .J,l~!:";~ t-J. HULchi:"'.1l , "d/l:'l/a Hutch construction n,spectfully n:'qu.,,;t,; t.hat thi,; Honorable Court enter judgment in his favor and aqainst Lhe PL.lintiff and dismiss the Plaintiff's Complaint and New Matter with prejudice, and further award Defendant all such other relief as is proper and just. Respectfully submitted, CUNNINGHAM & CHERNICOFF, P.C. Date: January 27, 1999 By: ,--;:7""Y- l-"""".:Jw.J.I~ ~10!/.) Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire 1.0. #66266 2320 North Second Street P.O. Box 60457 Harrisburg, PA 17106-0457 (717) 238-6570 (Attorneys for Defendants) 3 >. $;:..~~'., , . w,'''-J, _ I " i". ':', '.. ,. ., . ,.... ~I' ~ I ',. PAY One Tho1i,sand, Two H~~~ed .; ;...~: ~~.~: . . ,.... ". .,~ .. I R:P.'PoAGBR ',:.'.. 2056 STATE ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17011 . ;!:;t.,,~:~,-,_. ,,..,...~..<:'~. "'.:: . '.",,;",. ~ '.~" .. .'~" ....:...,., Nineteen"arid'S/10ilDollara' '. ".~',,' '.?:,~':': .,;. " '- ' .. . DATE :. .-..,....... .. . I 'Jul 2,:ijg'a'.:' AMOUNT ..........$1,2i9,OS.. TO THE ORoeR OF, ?~ 11'00 ~'1 ~""' .:03 Bo ~a"bl: 5 ~ 002 , !! Ii " II II I 1 I I ('!:YT:. F.l' 'ATJ.;,"I:' ~:L!<Vl.iJ:: I, Pdiq.. :~d('J')n"Jd M.! 1 1:..:;, E:;qlJil.', do h..t../;,. cel'tify that d t nl" ,,,,.j " I , " '. '!:'/ : ", : "::,Lo:: H..p: ,. to Pla int j f [ , ,. N~:'th' r"Lit~. " t" I n thO' li)(.,v.., Cdpt iUllt.:d ITldtter was ., placed in the Unit.cod Sldt0S Mdi l, ri.t'sl class deliver, postage the following: prepaid in Harrisburg, PellllS,.lvania on January 2'1, 199", on John S. Kundrat Kundrat & Associates 107 Boas Street Harrisburg, PA 17102 (Attorney for Plaintiff) Respectfully submitted, CUNNINGHAM & CHERNICOFF, P.C. Date: Januarv 27 .1999 -----. ~ . ",", ') By: ,1, ~~"""~'c.\'\'\n'F'<'t\D/' . Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire I .D. #66266 2320 North Second Street P.O. Box 60457 Harrisburg, pA 17106-0457 (717) 238-6570 (Attorneys for Defendant)