The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About98-06814 I I , , i ~: C! -- \ ,+-! C' o .. cf I~ !~ : -+ 18" , i . 17 j I i t.. !1 IE I ~ :1i i C i\t I ! i i , i ~ ip F J ~ (fl' 3! 1 I i 001 0-1 , i ~I JOHN R FENSTERMACHER, and BLUE & GRAY ACQUISITIONS, INC., : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiffs NO. 98-6814 Civil Term v. INTEGRA PAINTING, INC., Defendants : CIVIL ACTION - LAW NOTICE YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION 2 LIBERTY AVENUE CARLISLE, PA 17013 T).)Off;v/n. 1_ L1 .. ~D (717) 249-3166 r-.;\., I\. I I ~ .\\ Lt E:x:.h' \ J ; - 17 yel . ., n OV\ 2.\1.0'2- -fyDI('{'\ -\y1 L\...^. tl. Jv\.;"G~ f L~~~ .L-- ~~ ~ 9\-2Co~ LT Y-V2('}77 5. Integra Painting. Inc. ("Integra") is a Pennsylvania corporation with an address for conducting business at 281 Hoy Road, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17013. 6. In or about 1997 through 1998, Integra performed painting services in the office complex owned by Blue & Gray at 5115 East Trindle Road, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17055. Count I Negligence 7. Paragraphs 1 through 6 are incorporated fully herein by reference. 8. During the course of time in which Integra provided painting services to the Plaintiffs, Integra damaged brand new windows which were only recently installed at the office complex. 9. Integra owed a duty to Plaintiffs to perform its services in a safe, professional and workmanlike manner. 10. Integra breached such duty by damaging windows at the office complex. 11. Due to such breach, Plaintiffs have suffered damages. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs respectfully request this Honorable Court enter jUdgment for them and against Integra Painting, Inc. plus award all costs and interest in an amount requiring compulsory arbitration. 2 Count II Broach of Contract 12. Paragraphs 1 through 11 are incorporated fully herein by reference. 13. Plaintiffs paid Integra all sums invoiced, which Integra billed as allegedly for work performed at the office complex. 14. Integra performed substandard work and billed excessive hours and costs for such work. 15. Plaintiffs terminated the services of Integra in or about September, 1998. 16. SUbsequent to Integra's termination, Plaintiffs were required to pay bills for work which Integra had previously billed but did not perform. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs respectfully request this Honorable Court enter judgment for them and against Integra Painting, Inc. plus award all costs and interest in an amount requiring compulsory arbitration. Count 11/ Breach of Covenant In Good Faith and Fair Dealing 17. Paragraphs 1 through 16 are incorporated fully herein by reference. 18. The contract entered into between Plaintiffs and Integra contained an implied warranty of good faith and fair dealing. 19. By the instances of overbilling set forth herein, Integra breached such duty. 3 .... t: [' ~. r i:" WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs respectfully request this Honorable Court enter judgment for them and against Integra Painting, Inc. plus award all costs and interest in Respectfully submitted, , i i I,. " an amount requiring compulsory arbitration. FENSTERMACHER AND ASSOCIATES, P.C. By: ,./ , John R. Fenstermacher Supreme Court I.D. #29940 Mark K. Emery Supreme Court I.D. #72787 5115 East Trindle Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 (717) 691-5400 Attorney for Plaintiffs ) I' DATED: July 15,1999 . ~f ,I .,>:.; J,} . ,~;, I; '1 .'~ ~, 4 ('()( ':'liT III ImEM'1I 0... ('()\' ,,::\1 ,\:'IIT 1:'11 (;0011 "'''1'1'11 ,\:\111 ....\11( 111-:,\1.1:'11(; 17. Thc alcrlllcnls ..I' paraf!raphs I Ihl'..u~h III ar~ incorporalcd hcrdn hy rcli:rcnc~ as iftcxtually s~llilrlh allcnglh. Ill. Dcnicd as 'Iating a k'gal conclusion. rC'luiriug uo r~spomc. 1'). Dcni~d. Int~gra did Jlllt cngagc in any lIIcrhilling. Th~ rcmaindcr of lh~ a\'~rmcnt is d~ni~d as a legal conclusion. rC'luiring n\O rcspons~. II. NEW i\IATTER WIIEREFORI;. Iklcndal1l rC'lu~sts your lIonorahl~ Cour! 10 dismiss I'laintills' Complaint. 20. I'laintifl's claims ar~ harr~d by thc statut~ of/imitations. 21. I'lail1lifls' claims ar~ harr~d hy doctrinc of~ollat~ral ~stoppcl. WIIEREFORE. Dclcndanl r~qucsls your lIonorabl~ Courl 10 dismiss Plaintiffs' Complaint. BUZGON DAVIS LA W OFFICES BY: '\'~ ~. Timothy J. Huber. Esquire Attorney J.D. #47231 525 South Eighth Street Post Otliee Box 49 Lebanon. P A 17042-0049 (717) 274-1421 Attorneys tor Defcndant I I f -3- ..... JOliN It II:-';S II, R\IM 'IILI( ,lIld Il/.l 'L ,';; (il(,\ Y A( '()l :ISII/l )~S. I~( '.. I'lainlifls I~ 1111. ('olIU oJ ('tI.\l\lO~ 1'L1'.AS of ('( 1\I/II'RI:\~/) ('01 !~ IY. I'I,:-';NSYI. VANIA \~. CIVil A(,1I0~ 1.:\ \\' INIHil(A I'AINIINli. I~('.. Dclcndant i'/O, 'iN.(,l( 14 AFFIDA VIT OF SEHVICF: /lY MAIL cm...1MONWEAI.Tf I OF PE:-JNSYI.V ANIA) ) ss: COllNTY OF LEBANON ) I. KAREN A. NEE. an cmployec of Ihe la\\' firm of Buzgon Dal'is. 525 South Eighth SII'~el. I.chanon. Lebanon County. Pennsyll'ania. Allorneys lilr Deicndant. being duly s\\'nm according to la\\'. dcpos~ and say that I filed on August 13. 1999. in the Oftiee of the I'rolhonolary of Cumherland County. Pennsylvania. Ihe original ANSWER AND NEW MATTER TO COMPLAINT and that Imailcd a copy by Iirst class. regular mail to Mark K. Emery. Esquire. 5115 East Trindl~ Road. Mcehaniesburg. PA 17055. Attorney lor Plaintiffs. '-~ Ii ~ . I........! __t/I..',7l . , /lc-,-- (KAREN A, NEE) Sworn to and subseribed bclol'e me this 13th day gOf AUg~ISI.^-~~.. ~999." I (', -_I. I l_- ~' NOlary Pllblie ~ ---.- SU NOfilrial S;.I----~ sanM W If Jackson Tw 0 B, Notary PUblic My Comm/ss/O~'E;pee:noJn County M S uno 6, 2002 ember Pf'r n I . I sy vaniIJ AS'3tJCmlion 0' No'. . , flfJS .... () '0 "oJ r~ "., -:""1 ~ I "'Uti ,'n Oli.' ,,-, , Z:'_, ,:'n 6,5 c' o~, :"'? ~(} '.::1.':) f__ ~ ~'~ :~i -..f. . .:CJ "'-":;CJ ~jin :'>c --, ~ c- ~~ .,.J =< , , II :1 ~ : " u JOliN It I'TNSll;R~IA(,III'R and BI.\JE &. ORA Y At'l)l JISITIONS. 1:\( '.. Plaintiffs : IN 1111 ('III :IU lll. ('11\l'lll~ PI.Fi\S 01, : ('l :\1I1I',RI.ANI> ('( II iNT'\'. PENNSYI.V ANIA vs. CIVIl. ACTlO:'>J ... LA W INTEORA I'AINTING. INt'.. D~fcmlant NO 'IK.ilK 1-1 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE IlY MAIL COMMONWEAI.TII OF PENNSYl.VANIA) ) ss: COUNTY 01' LEBANON ) 1. KAREN A. NEE. an cmployee of the law firm of Buzgon Davis. 525 South Eighth Street. Lebanon. Lebanon County. I'ennsyll'ania. Attorneys for Dcfendant. being duly sworn aeeording to law. depose and SlIY that Imlliled on August 13. 1999. by regular mail. in a postpaid enl'elope. INTERROGATORIES lInd REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS OF DEFENDANT DIRECTED TO PLAINTIFFS to Mark K. Emcry. Esquire. I'ensterrnaeher and Associates. P,C.. 5115 East Trindlc Road. Mechaniesburg. Pennsylvania 17055, l ~ i: r r f Attorney for PlaintirtS. '';:"~'li' Il (I , )lC( ~AREN A, NEE) - ~ , Sworn to and subseribed before me this 13th day of August, A.D., 1999. --..-..--.- Nolanal Seal '.- Susan M. Wolfe, Notary Public Jackson Twp., Lebanon County My Commission Expires June 6, 2002 Member. Penr.svlvar,J;:l. t.~Soclljljon 01 Notaries (") \D q C U) :". :Po , "UG.' -- , ~"} 1 nlr:~ G> " . %~',' ;;r:.q Zt;. 0' i:;~S UJ..; -<.'- ~L., --I.. "'. :,~} ~;) -> ::i: Zc..~~ .=1., ;:j.-;'I ;>>C ,-, - CO 5J ~ ..... -< If you fail 10 attend or 10 produc~ the documents or lhings r~quircd by lhis Notice To Attend. you may be subject to Ihe sanctions aUlhori/cd hy Rul~ 2J~.5 of the Pcnnsylvania Rules of Civil Proeedure. BlJZGON Date: /0 - /q- 0 0 By: Timo y J. ber, Esquire Attorney LD, #47231 525 South Eighth Street Post Offiee Box 49 Lebanon.PA 17042-0049 (717) 274-1421 Attorneys lor Plaintiffs INTEGRA PAINTING.ISc.. PLAIl"TIFF : IN n II: COURT OF CO:-.t:-'ION I'I.I:AS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA : 1'0,1)1).268 CIVIL vs. JOHN R. FENSTERMACHER and MARGARET A. FENSTER.\tACIIER. DEFENDANTS : CIVIL ACTION - LA W .................................... ................ -- --................ JOHN R. FENSTER.\IACHER and BLUE & GRAY ACQUISITIONS. lNC.. PLAINTIFFS : IN THE COURT OF CO\I~lON PLEAS : Cl;MBERLAND COUNTY. PEI'o.'NSYL VANJA : NO. 98-681-1 CIVIL vs. INTEGRA PAINTlNG.INC.. DEFENDANT : CIVIL ACTION - LA \V AFFIDA VIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COMMONWEAL HI OF PENNSYLVANIA) ) ss: COUNTY OF LEBANON ) I. KAREN A. NEE. a paralegal in the law firm of Buzgon Davis. 525 South Eighth Street. Lebanon. Lebanon County. Pennsylvania. Attorneys for Integra Painting. Ine.. being duly sworn aceording to law. depose and say that I tiled on October 19. 2000, in the Offiee of the Prothonotary of Cumberland County. Pennsylvania, a eopy of the NOTICE TO ATTEND. the original of whieh was sent by first class. regular mail to Mark Emery, Esquire, 5115 East Trindle Road. Meehaniesburg. PA, 17055. Attorney for John R. Fenstermaeher and Margaret A. Fensterrnaeher and Blue & Gray Aequisitions, Ine. ,;.yLtlfL (I . '1!.t.L/ (KAREN A. NEE) Sworn to and subscribed before me this 19th day of Oelober, A.D., 2000. Notarial Seal Wanda J. Hoke. Notary Public lebanon, Lebanon County My Commission Expires Apr, 19. 2004 _r, PennsylValllaA5SOClllllOllOfNolllI1eO \.~- ,~ is in no way limited in scope to such relevant evidence so as 10 render it overbroad, B, Integra's purported reason for such a broad request is to determine if other subcontractors on the relevant construction project were not paid, That issue has no bearing on Integra's breach of contract claim, Further, there are less intrusive methods to obtain such information, such as obtaining the information directly from the subcontractors. C, Integra's subpoena requests documentation outside the scope of permissible discovery allowed under the Rules of Civil Procedure, II. Subpoenas to Pennsylvania State Bank and Fulton Bank A. Integra's Subpoena requests documents not relevant to the instant litigation or reasonably calculated to lead to relevant or admissible evidence, and is in no way limited in scope to such relevant evidence so as to render it overbroad, B. Integra's request for documentation regarding financing of construction projects, which would include financial statements of John and Margaret Fenstermacher, is meant solely to harass and is propounded in bad faith, C, Integra's purported reason for requiring such information is to determine if the construction project went over budget. (See Exhibit "A") 2 : ' ., Integra's allegation, even if true, has no bearing on Integra's breach of contract claim or defense of counterclaims asserted against it D, Integra's subpoena requests documentation outside the scope of permissible discovery allowed under the Rules of Civil Procedure, Respectfully submitted, FENSTERMACHER AND ASSOCIATES, P,C, By: , Mark K. Emery Supreme Court I.D. #72787 5115 East Trindle Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 (717) 691-5400 Attorney for John R. Fenstermacher, Margaret A. Fenstermacher and Blue & Gray Acquisitions, Inc, //" DATED: I r ) ,,; I EXHIBIT 'A' < " " , 'I rc ; I r ~ ) !), j \ ( r.., 1,1 (;' '.',' BIIZ( iON I>,\\'IS 1\\\ utili I' ,.'....".....,,, ,,,.,,,.,,,,,, Itllt....1 UII \ It! Il,t J'. 11^I~H\ \I. HilI) JI( 11~1' 1111\ J III 11Il( Ill\\,\IHH Ill'" \1,\1(\ II III IU 1m. "40111 (.H'....o'''1 1'11,1\1' \t "\tI'll'~ Jl )il\ \\ 1l1l111 H "'11' 1\ " 1,1111 III 1'111111'... tI\\I' \." 'oj II 11111/,11111 '"111 I 1",,"'111' I jlll\ h lilt ,',ii', "'1 '"nl' .l'II' f",<, Hh 11\101\\ 11\\1' ,I.." 1'1", 1'1/',,,-, 1/'11,:'11 1l~1 1\\ 1"P',.'~~P~1 I \1 \11 hll/,'''II.' kf","~'1 Mur~h 2'), 2001 J{C: Inlcgrlll'llinling \'S, ,lIIhll Fcnslcrmachcr and l\IlIrgllrcl A, FClIslcrnull'hcr ,John R. FCllslcrlllllchcr und IlIl1c & (;rll~' AC11llisiliolls,llIc. \'. 'nlcgfll I'uilllillg, 11ll', Cumhcrllllld Coullly 1\IIS, 1)11-(,111" lllHi 1)9-2hll Murk Emery, Esquire Fens(~rmacher and ^ssocial~s 5115 East Trinule Road Meclmnicshurg. I' ^ I 7055 Dear Mr. Emery: Thunk you lilr your letter of March n. 200 I, I will have Jim conlaC! you direclly in order 10 arrangc a lime 1'(lr taking photographs of the IWO properties, With regard to Mcrit Ilolllcs. il is el'identlhmllhc Icslimony at the arbitmtion hearing that Mr. Kur!z was involl'Cd to some extcnt in coordinaling thc work of Integra. Furthermore, we have reecived informalion indieating that one or more other contraclors at the sile were not paid in full. I believe lhis has relevunce to the ercdibility of u contention that Inlegra was not paid bceause of ils work performanee, In faet, I have subpoenaed the Iinancing liIes as it relates to the Fenstennaeher home in ordcr to determine whether any inl'(,rmation was provided relating 10 the projeeted eosls of the projeet (including estimates for my client's work) and whether or not thc projeet wenl over budget. Once again. th:~ .....ould have a bearing un th~ credibility r,{' a cuntention that my client \vns not paid beeause of eomplaints abolll lhe qualily of th~ work or its total eost. I will bc glad to diseuss these issues furlher with you if you like. Si~eereIY, J~C~'L-- TI O'IlIY J. HUBER TJH/mam ec: Jim Dymski (W/Cllt,) ~ r;J (," , I" HAR :i a 2001 , . , . ~ ".._.~- r l: ~: I' I , ~, ~~ i , " , I. ::.. '_1 "r 1 I \ , . ,r/ ,( , 'I. "..' , . '.'.~:. I:,: : ~<~~:. i.' I)'!': i "t.., "I i I , I 1 ' ; ! i ,) .' \ !' INTEGRA PAINTr.-;G,I:-:C., PLAINTIFF vs JOHN R. FENSTER.'vIACHER and MARGARET A. FENSTERMACHER, DEFENDANTS p,o.j TIlE COURT OF COM~ION PLEAS CUMBERI.AND COUNTY, PENNSYL V :\."IIA NO, 99-26& CIVIL : CIVIL ACTION - LAW ... ..-..... -- ---................ ........................................ JOHN R. FENSTER.'vIACHER and BLUE & GRAY ACQUISITIONS, INC., : r.-; THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PLAINTIFFS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : NO. 98-681~ CIVIL vs. INTEGRA PAINTING.INC.. DEFENDANT CIVIL ACTION - LAW NOTICE OF INTENT TO SERVE A SUBPOENA TO PRODI'CE DOCUMENTS AND THINGS FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO PA.R.C.P. RULE ;'\10. ~009.21 TO: ALL COUNSEL OF RECORD/P.-\RTlES IN INTEREST: Defendant intends to serve Subpoenas identieal to the eopies that are attaehed to this Noliee. YOU have Twenty (20) Days from the date you reeeive this Notiee in whieh to file of reeord and serve upon the undersigned an objeetion to the Subpoena. If no objeetion is made, the Subpoena may be served. You mav waive the 20.dav period: ifvou will do so. please advise me tbereofin writinl! and said Subpoenas will be processed at an earlier date. BUZGr DAVIS LAW OFFICES BY: 'If\', mvlOTHiY JJHUtll:.K. ESQUIRE ATTORNEY lD NO. 47231 525 S. 8TH ST - PO BOX 49 LEB:\.'lON P A 17042-0049 717-274- 1421 ATTORt'lEYS FOR lNTEGRA PAINTING DATED: ?} :J-l) 0 I INTEGRA PAr.-.:Tr.-iG, r.-iC.. PLAfNTIFF IN THE COURT OF Cmvl~ION PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PE:-''NSYL V ANlA NO, 99-268 CIVIL vs JOHN R. FENSTER.'vlACHER and MARGARET A. FENSTER.'vlACHER, DEFENDA.'1TS CIVIL ACTION - LAW ....... -............... -... -...... ............ ....... ...................... JOHN R. FENSTER.\lACHER and BLUE & GR.-\ Y ACQUISITIONS, INC., r.-i THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, Pe.'NSYL V A.'11:\ PLAINTIFFS vs. INTEGR.-\ PATI\iTING, INe., DEFDiDA.'iT ; NO. 98-6814 CIVIL CIVIL ACTION - LA \V SCBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCuyIENTS OR TID:"iGS FOR DISCOVERY Pl:RSU.-\.'iT TO RULE 4009.22 To Eb~rlv Lumber t)SiUTlC: :Jf?erson or entity, 135 W~st Allen Street Mechaniesbur2. PA 17055 Within twenty (:0) days after service of this subpoena. you are ordered by the court to produce the following documents or things: C!eJr Jnd !e!!ible eDDies of any invoices. Durchase orders or other documents re"llTdino shutters delivered to rhe Grevsrone ~rooer.v rocated J[ 5115 East Trindle Road. \tlech:micsburt'J'. PA. at;2 urh gill "creer L~banon Pennsvlvania 17042 Ann: Karen A. Nee. Parale17al You may deliver or maillegibJe copies of the documents or produce things requested by this subpoena together with the certificate of compliance to the parry making this request at the address listed above. You have the right to seek in advance the reasonable cost of preparing the copies or producing the rhing sought. ffyou rail to produco the documents or things required by this subpoena within twenty (ZO) days after its service. me party servicing this subpoena may sc=ek a court IJrder compelling you to comply with it. This 3ubpo~nil was issued Jt the request of the following person: Date: fYZ.';::{" r'" 1. ...2 O. ::J f'"jQ!1 . Timothv J. Huber. ESQ. Attorney's Name 47231 ldc:ntuic:won Numbc:r 525 S. 8"' St AiJdress [..ebanon. PA 17042 717-274-1421 Telephone :-.lumber Se:ll of the COUrt BY THE COIJRT: By:(J,~~,~.~ (Prothonotary) " ~ (, " [ INTEGRA PAINTING,INC.. PLAI};TIFF vs JOHN R. FENSTER.\IACHER and MARGARET A. FE:-ISTER.\L-\CHER, DEFENDANTS : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : NO. 99-268 CIVIL : CIVIL ACTION - LA W ......-..........-.. -.-...................................... JOHN R. FENSTERMACHER and BLUE & GRAY ACQUISITIONS, INC., : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PLAINTIFFS : NO. 98-681.t CIVIL vs. INTEGRA PAINTING, INe.. DEFENDANT : CIVIL ACTION - LAW AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COMMONWEALTH OF PE~'NSYL V A.'ITA) ) ss: COu'NTY OF LEBANON ) I, K.AREN A. NEE, a paralegal in the law firm of Buzgon Davis Law Offiees, 525 South Eighth Street, Lebanon, Lebanon County, Pennsylvania. Attorneys for Integra Painting, being duly sworn aeeording to law. depose and say that I mailed on Mareh 21. 2001, a NOTICE OF INTENT TO SERVE SUBPOENAS TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS AND THINGS FOR DISCOVERY by first elass mail to Mark K. Emery, Esquire, 5115 East Trindle Road, Meehaniesburg, P A 17055, Attorney for De~~end IS. . ,." '_ ~...Iuj, I, flu _ (IO\REN A. NEE) Sworn to and subseribed before me this 21 st day ofM h, A.D., 2001. bLJ b ~d. Notary Publie ' Notarial Seal Helen L. G. AngsJo. Notary Public lebanon, Lebanon County My Commission EJ<pires Aug. 5. 2003 Member. PennsylvanlaAssOClaUonol Nolanes , INIHiRA I',\IN 11:"li. I:"t'.. : IN 1111, ('Ill 'I{ I OF ('Il:\1\lIlN I'LI'AS OF I'lainlitT : ('tIMIlI'RI/\:S;1> ('01 :r\TY.PL:-;:-;SYI.VANIA \'S. : ('IVII. A(, IIOr\ LA\\' JOliN I{, r:I:NSlm\lAt'lII:.R and MAIHiARI'T A, FLNSTI'R\lAt'lII:R. NO, '1'1.268 CIVIL IklcmlanlS : JURY lRI,\1. I>DIANDEI> ----------------------- JOliN R. FENSTI'RMAt:lIER. ami BLUE & CiRA Y ACQI IISITIONS. INC.. IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF I'lainlilTs CUMBERLAND CO! INTY. I'ENNSYI.V ANIA NO, 98.6814 Cil'il Tern! ../' 1'5, INTEGRA I'AINTlNCi. INC.. Dclcndant CIVIL ACTION - LA W ORDER AND NOW. this 13;U, day of ["w"..L,tv . 1999. upon eonsideration of the within Stipulation for Consolidation. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the ahoI'C-eaptioned eases shall be eonsolidatcd lor the purposes of trial and discol'ery. BY THE COURT: t., 4 tJ....-c....L c.', ~ J. ". : IN 1111, ('ol'IU 01. ('O\l\lO:s.; 1'l.b\S OF : ('( i~lIIlJU A:s.:I)( 'Ol::s.: I\'. 1'1':s.;~S\'I.V ,\NI,\ ('IVII ,\( 'liON I :\\\ IN I Hil(,\ I'A1N IINli.INC.. l'laintiff JOliN It F1':NS I I OIe\l'\( '111'1( and ~1"I((iAHFI A, I'FNSTI:R:-'lAt'III:R. Delcndants No.'j'j.1hK <lVII. JURY IIU,\l.llI:\L\NDLI) JOliN R. FENSTI'.R~lA(,IIER. and BUll' &. (iRA Y ACl)1IISIT10NS. I Nt'.. IN TIn: ('1 II !IH (IF ('( )\I~\l IN PI.EAS I IF ClIMIlERI.ANIl ('Ol NIT. I'ENNSYI.YANIA I'lainlifls NO, 'IK.6K 1-1 Civil Term " " l , -. , ') I , - , ? ::.) :) " :,'.) l';") \'S. INTHiRA I'AINTING. INC.. Delcndant CIVIL ACTION -- 1.1\ W MOTION TO APPROVE: STIJ>ULATION I'etitioner. Integra I'ainting. Ine.. requests your lIonoraole Court to approve Ihe allaehed Stipulation. This Stipulation has the coneurrencc of all counsel. BlIZGON I~A VIS BY: \ ,~ ----",--'------ - Timolhy J: Huber. Esquire AlIorney I.D, #47231 525 South Eighth Street Post Olliee Box 49 Lebanon.PA 17042.0049 (717) 274.1421 Attorneys lor I'laintiff INIHil(A I'AIN IINl i. IN('.. IN II IH '()( 'I~ I oJ ('O\l\loN I'Lh\S OF I'lailllil'i' I '11~III/J(1 M,.:J} ('( II :NI Y. I'I'NNSYLV,\NI,\ \'S. ('JVII. A('l/oN I.,\\\' JOI IN It Fi'NSTERMA( 'I IER ,lIId MAJWi\RET A. I'ENSTERMi\CI IER. NO. ')l).2(,X ('IVII. D~lcl1dants .II IR Y TRIAL I>I;MANJ>EJ> .JOlIN It FENSTERMACIIER. and IlJ.lJE & (iRA Y AC()UISITlONS. INC.. ----------------------- IN TIJE CO( 'RT OF ('OMl-.l0N PLEAS OF I'laintill:, CUMBERLAND ('01 INTY. I'ENNSYI. VAN/A vs. NO.9X-6XI4 Cil'il Tcrm INTEGRA PAINTIN(j. INC.. Delcndant CIVIl. ACTION-LAW STIPULATION FOR CONSOLIDATION Il~ . AND NOW. Ihis I I.. day of t\l~vi",~12, 1999. Integra Painting, Ine.. by its attorncy. Timothy J. Huber. Esquire. and John R. Fenslcrmilchcr. Margaret A. Fenstermaeher. and Blue & Gray Acquisitions. Ine.. by Ihcir attorney. Mark K. Emery. Esquire. stipulate and agree Ihac lhe abol'e-eaplioned eases shall be eonsolidatcd for the purposes of trial and diseol'ery. BUlGON DAVIS LA W OFFICES , .,~ " ' RY:_~~ -c ____~____ Timothy J.,H:lbcr, l:squire-Attnrney 1.0, #47231 525 South Eighth Strcet-Post Ofliee Box 49 Lebanon, l' A 17042-0049 (717) 274.1421 FENSTERMACHER AND ASSOCIATES, 1'.c., BY: ._, ~_y l;l. __/' ",' ',// . ..../ ,<. . .-' ./ . ,;, ./ .....;;;;.--- Mark K. Emery. Esquire-Attorney 1.0, #72787 51 15 East Trindle Road Meehaniesburg, I' A 17055 (717) 691-5400 INTH iR,\ ":\IN n:>;l i. 1:>;1 '.. "iaintilf : I:>; nil C 'Cll1ln ClI' I 'O\l:\ION 1'1 h\s I II' : C'( :\lIlIRI,\:-';1l (,011:-'; I Y.PI-N:>;SYIV..\:>;f,\ (,1\'II,,\C'IIl):>; I,\\\' \'S. .II IJIN R, "":-';S I I:R\I,\C 'III-R and MARCiAIWI A. I-I:NS' UU(AC'III'R. I)di.'ndant.s :>;0, ')').~M' CIVil .I( iRY TRIAl. DI':\I/\NIlU) JOliN R. FENSTERI\IA(,IIER. ;uld BLlJE & CiRA Y A(,()IIISITlC l:-';S. INC., -.-.------------------- IN TIll' ('C)l Iln lJF ('CJMMCIN I'I,b\S cn Pluilllifls ('IIMBERI.ANJ> COUNTY. PENNSYI. VANIA \'s. INTEGRA PAINTING. INC., D~tcndalll NO.9X.6XI.t Cil'il T~rm CIVIL ACTION - LA W AFFIDA VIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COMMONWEAI.TJI OF PENNSYL VAN/A) ) ss: COUNTY OF LEBANON ) I. KAREN A. NEE. an cmployee of the law tirm of 13uzgon DUl'is. 525 South Eighth Str~et. Lebanon. I.ehanon County. Pennsyll'unia. Attorneys lor PlnintilT. being duly sworn aeeording to In\\'. depose nnd say thnt 1 lilcd on December 3. 1999. in the Omee of thc Prothonotllry of Cumherlnnd Coul1ly. Pennsyll'anin. the originnl and one truc and eorrect eopy of the MOTION TO AI'I'ROVE STIPULATION, lhe STIPULATION FOI~ CONSOLIJ)ATION, nnd proposed ORDER and thnl 1 provided the Prothonotary with a first class envelope addressed to Mark Emery. Esquire. 5115 East Trindle Road, Meehaniesburg, I' A, 17055, Attorney lor Delcndants. Sworn to and stlhseribed before me this 3rd dny ~. Defcmher. I~.D.~" 1999,' .- // "1\iA... ' , ,;IU~,,,, 1_ \'~ ' Notary Pub lie ' ...~~ /~{i l O. ILi?.L... (K!AREN A. NEE) Notarial Seal Holon l. G. Angelo, Notary Public Lebanon, Lebanon County _~'y Commission Expires Aug, 5, 2003 ."t"" r ""'''';vIvanii'] A.<;~OCj"li0no' Normlos , J i L i:.' , C Jl ... 'i , ,I i -' JOHN R. FENSTERMACHER, ilnd BLUE' GRAY ACQUISITIONS, INC. , IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plainti Un NO. 9J'-(.~'11/ (I,'I'(....A~),) Respectfully Submitted, v. INTEGRA P~INTING, INC., ,,-PI I-/e't 14.,;/cL 6,dJ~('i, PH Defendants /fc.'l.!, CIVIL ACTION - LAW TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please issue a Writ of Summons in the above-captioned matter, and provide the Writ of Summons to the undersigned. ---;;?<? -, - ..-' / /~y /-:___" ---:-7 Mark K. Emery - Supreme Court 1.0. No. 72787 John R. Fenstermacher Supreme Court 1.0. No. 29940 5115 East Trindle Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 (717) 691-5400 ~... , ' , I. ~.. I .... "j ()'l! ~l """ ~> CJ '\. (, - '" - r--. I" :z:; *-.' lA ~ ....'\ - , -L- , '1 fJ ~ '0 -< I -cJ J.--; ..... \:, ~ - 'b~ " '. - t r..r ~ , - ~ ~. ('tl ......' {' ;. r (' ( . '< ~ -...i\' c;- V r- t( ;0 ,... .1: " ~ r r-- -p ~ V1 """ '" ~ &to ~ ~ ~ ('\ v, () v ~ 0 C' iI', ::--:;, G .::::::: <6J I 0- )::) VI ' ' ('\ ,,' "- ,...... 'l.I 32 --!- , -....z' '. , .....,~Vlar ,(") (")"'... tIle... ~ , '.... .... ..... ?O~~ ~~ , 0-.1 1-1'1 <: , , , . J,irVl;o;' .... ~::CC) !'" , .... , '''''''i:! t;?X cnO$l "'?" , ..... . ~ f;;>< l'f , ..... I 0 ~ C'l , , NU'lUJ f C/l . :a 'tI $lt:l ,0\ , ........C' .... 0:1' ,00 , alO"':::? 0 ~ 'tiEl'" ><1)i ,.... , ..... OJ! ....:J :J !' ~ .VI :>' fit;] I S! . 5.' I 8 ... ,(") .... tl ;i ~~ '.... 31 'tI....t':l f 0 .., 1< :l'l1>'" 6l 0 ,.... ~I .0 .... ,.... , .... :a ' w ... ~Eii , , ClSl ~, 1'l I~ , 1:1 H:a , VIe. o. i~ , VI pi~ I I , , , - , H l'" , n , I , , , 1:\ 1111 ('OIH 101 ('0\1\10:\ I'II:..\S 01 1'1 '\11111(1..\:\1> ('( 11\ I \'. I'I:\\S\'IV,\:\"\ I'IVII ,\1110\ I ,\ \\ JOII\ R,II\S 1I1(\f.\l'IlIlt and 111,1'1, ,';; I ,({,,\ \' ,\( '()l 'lS11I( >\S. 17\(" I'lail1liffs \, " I H jR:\ 1',\1\ 11\( i. 1\(', ~X I 1111) Rllad Carli,Ie.I'A J 701.1. Delcndanl 7\0, 'IX.hX 1-1 I'/{AECII'E FO'{ IWI.E TO FILE (,O:\II'L\liliT TO Till: I'IWlII07\OT..\RY OF ClJ\lJlI:RI...\:>.:n COllNTY.I'E:-INSYI.VANIA: ANIl \O\\'. .Il1n~ II. 1'1'1<). issu~ a Rule upon Plailllills 10 file Iheir COlllplainl in the ahole 1ll.Ill~r within t\\Cnly (20) days of ser,icc of said Rulc upon Ihelll or sullcr ajudglllent of nlln pros, 1l1lZCio:>.:(nA VIS Ily:_l_'_\-~ -- _ TI\IOTJ W .I. IIUBER. ESQUIRE /\Horney f.n. #47231 525 South Eighlh Street. P.O. Box 49 f.ehanon. I' A 17042.0049 (717) 274~1421 AHorncy tor Dctcndal1l I{ULF: AND NOW. Ihis /5 day of ~u; issu~d in accordancc \\'ilh the ahol'e Praeeipe. . 1999. a Rule is ~~E~ ',f?~.1? ~",.:tk7l(4" " , Prolhoffotary ,;/ :?~4' '/3,,' 1./ v./ CI 7 IIftll<\. F., ~t't! /J:;ru",,;y '" ',\, . :' , ,,'I ","1 , , ;') ) i ',' ~ ;--. . J 'i 1." ,. ,. 11:' I' ,...... I '. I.'" 1"'; ~ ~',t'. l:~,~) ,. "' ..' ...'" i. l,:/ ':~, fi:.., I:~' '\ WiEGHA PAINTING, INC.. PI,dntiff TN TilE COURT O~. cmlMON I'I.~:M'; OF CUI.lIJEHI.MJD COUNTY, PENNSYINANIA V. JOliN R. FENSTERMACIIER and /1ARG/\RET ^. FENSTERMACHER. Defendlmtn 99-268 CIVn TERN ----------------- JOliN R. l"EIlS'I'ERNACIIEH Ilnd ilLUE [. GRAY ACQUI51'I'lON~, Ille.: Plaintiff IIJ THE COUH'l' 01" COMl10N pr.F-AS O~' CI1:-lBEHL!\l'JD COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. INTEGRA PAINTING, INC.. Defendantn 98-6814 CIVIL TERN QRJ;lER OF COURT N,D NOW, this 11th day of February, 2002, after bench trial at 98-6814 Civil Term, we find in favor of John R. Fenstermacher and Blue & Gray Acquisitions, Inc., Plaintiffs, and against Integra Painting, Inc., Defendant in the amount of $9,087.61, plus costs. At 99-0268 Civil Term, we find in favor of Plaintiff, Integra Painting, Inc., and against John R. Fenstermacher and l1argaret A. Fenstermacher, Defendants, jointly and severally, in the amount of $7,751.67, plus costs. At said term and number we find in favor of the Defendants and against Plaintiff on the counterclaims in ~he amount of $1,000.00. ~thY J. Huber, Esquire For Integra Painting, Inc. ~rk K. Emery, Esquire For John and Margaret Fenstermacher and Blue & Gray Acquisitions. Inc. Edward E. Guido, J. ) f.oples f10:.Jc.J OJ.-Iq-o~ 'R'X..s It JOliN It FEI';STERMM'III'1(, '"HI BLUE & (jl{A Y ACQI lISnIO~S, 11';(', I~ TilE ('oun 01' CO\I~IO~ I'I.EJ\S 0" ('lJ~lIIERI.M';() COI XI Y. 1'I'~~SYI.VJ\~IA v, INTECiRA l'AINTI:-';(j,INt'. NO, 'IS.(,SI-l CIVIL TERM OI{DER OF COURT AND NOW. lhis ~ day of MARCil, 2002, ;1 Rille is isslI,'d IIpon Delcndanls 10 Show Cause why Plainliffs Request for Delay Damages should nol he granted. Rule retumable twenly (20) days after serl'ice. ~othY J. Huher, Esquire Altomey for Inlegra Painting, Inc. ~rk K. Emery. Esquire For Fenstemmeher and Associates, P.c. Edward E. Guido, J. > ~hoJ7ir} Taryn Dixon Courl Administrator '.. i; '\. I ,,' ~.,,:.. i I .;..~ ~- i c1 \ " J";-'l:" " '~';l " ~~t. -l\ 'r'~ '... . ~~:'lZ::~.' . , I, t I I I i \ \ 't v , '~'-' ~ ',',:,., '\- . , ,.. , .~~ ~ ,t ~:;{;. . I.,. , , ......h t~.. 1 I ~ t j .I.I , j~'L il ;j,'. , ,.' ( 1 t- J.~.!~t';-J" .'.'4'I{('.'" ,,;,,. ; ."/7~~"; "'.' '/,,;.- "\\ .". , " " J.-r:'" JOHN R FENSTERMACHER. and BLUE & GRAY ACQUISITIONS, INC" IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiffs : NO, 98.6814 Civil Term v, INTEGRA PAINTING, INC., Defendants : CIVIL ACTION - LAW INTEGRA PAINTING, INC., IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO, 99-268 Civil Term JOHN R. FENSTERMACHER and MARGARET A. FENSTERMACHER, CIVIL ACTION - LAW Defendants : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ORDER AND NOW, this __ day of , 2002, upon consideration of Plaintiffs' Motion for Delay Damage::; under Docl;et No, 98.68111. it is hereb~' ordered that such Motion is GRANTED, and delay damages are assessed in the amount of $1,940.80. BY THE COURT, J, MOTION FOR DELAY DAMAGES PURSUANT TO PA. R.C.P. 238 AND NOW come the Plaintiffs, by and through their attorneys, the Offices of Fenstermacher and Associates, P,C" and files this Motion for Delay Damages Pursuant to Pa, R.C,P. 238, as follows: 1, Plaintiffs, at Docket No 98-6814, instituted suit for the recovery of damages sustained by Plaintiffs' real property as a result of Defendant's conduct. 2. After a bench trial, this Court found in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendant in the amount of $9,087,61 plus costs. 3. This action was filed on December 2,1998, 4. At no time during the pendency of this action did Defendant issue a written offer of settlement. 5, At no time during the pendency of this action did Plaintiffs cause a delay of the trial. 6. Calculation of the delay damages, commencing as of December 3, 1999, is as follows: Year 1999 (from Dec, 3) @ 8.3/4% $63,17 Year 2000 @ 9-1/2% 863.32 Year 2001 @10-1/2% 954.19 Year 2002 (to Feb, 11) @ 5.3/4% 60.12 Total $1940.80 2 WHEREFORE. Plaintiffs respectfully request this Honorable Court award delay damages in the amount of $1940.80, thereby awarding to Plaintiffs the total amount of $11,028.41, Respectfully submitted, FENSTERMACHER AND ASSOCIATES, P.C. By: , -- .../...--- Mark K. Emery Supreme Court I.D. #72787 5115 East Trindle Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 (717) 691-5400 Attorney for Plaintiffs DATED: J. -J,;".())' 3 <- ^'- , I'..) -c ; ...., '- , ,-" :~.., (I' I'.' -' I, " i- ( .;... ~) , ::? -. '" -~ \D .~I -: BUZGON DA VIS UWolll('" ""If".IU"ufn.I'f'Il".n, APR 2 - 2002.)~ IIERNEKII ^ IIlJ,,~.N ,,^RKY w, Klrn. JR TIMOrtlY J UlIllI,R WW^KDJCOYI,I M^RY IIIIURCIIIK scorr L. GRENOIllI JOliN W. [1111I.l'R MSON J SCllIIIIMHR ~l~ ~otJ Iff Uc,lIrll ~Utll, I 1't)\rC)lIItTIt(),><"'4 IIIIM-';ON,I',\ 17011 1'111111'" I),\VI~ 11~1:. l'l"'~ I IU(lI"fW", IMV" IIW.I 1'1'1", COpy 1'ltO\1 (717.11&.U11 I ^X 1711117~.17~1 hut>cr " hU/,nnJ,,,,, (um April 2, 2002 Re: Integra Painting vs. ,John R. Fenstermacher and l\1argarel a, Fenslermlleher Cumherhmd County No. 99.268 John R. Fenstermllch~r and lJIue & Grny AC1luisitions, Inc. \'. Inlegrll )'lIinting, Inc. Cumberland Coun!)' No. 98.68)-1 The Honorable Edward E. Guido Cumberland County Cour!housc 1 Cour!house Square Carlisle, PA 17013-3387 Dear Judge Guido: This will serve to notify youlhat the parties to the abol'e matter have settled all outstanding claims. 1 expect 10 file a praecipe to mark lhe docket settled and diseontinued in the near future. I do not believe lhat any further proeeedings will be required. Si erely, TIMOTHY J. HUBER TJH/mam ee: Mark Emery, Esq. O~#tu,.C-4r,_._..,_. ~r/ i;/~.',:_~"~' ff-- :Uk /~" (:PJt~~ 7/ ":~:~" ~,' .' .,'~~~,,:'::~ ;'i:;""',':: "tf, , 'I""'>'" , :'-.; '.'"....,~,;,::~..:,'~~ :'<l;~~ .' ., ',',' ,.',',. "~~'r"'iI' ' ;,. , '~""-':'Y;';::~;:~~):'-{~~ - , 'f' 'n.~",,._...,,.....,_.,~,,;....~. ...;.A...., JI: IN'l'r;Gl~I\ I'A I NT 1 Nt;. I NC. . I N 'I'm: COUH'I' (J!-' CO~::':O:I 1'1,1';,;; OF I'lilintil t ('Ul'lllEHLANlJ COUNTY, I'I':NNSYLVANIA V. ,JOllll H. FENSTEHJ.lACIlEH and: r'!AHGMm'l' A. FENSTEHI1ACIlEH: Dcfenclanu: ""';;f,fl CIVIL 'I'EHH ----------------- JOliN H. FENSTEHJ.lACIlER and: BLUE & GMY ACQUISITIONS, : INC. , It, TilE ('OUHT OF COMMOrl PLEAS OF CU/oIBEHLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plainti ifr: v. IN1'EGM PAINTING, INC., Defendant 98-6814 CIVIL TERM /' TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS ! I J. i , ' . 'I I IN RE: REQUESTED TESTIMONY ONLY Proceedings were held before the j , .; HONORABLE EDWARD E. GUIDO, J., Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, Courtroom Number Five, February 11, 2002. APPEARANCES: TIMOTHY J. HUBER, ESQUIRE For - Integra Painting, Inc. HARK K. EMERY, ESQUIRE For - John and Margaret Fenstermacher Blue & Gray Acquisitions, Inc. {l "': I t , I \ . " . :' \ I .. ~ j . r ]' .< .1 I t# CORRECTION ~ ~., ! I }, ,. "{:' , Previous Image . ; J Refilmed to Correct ",I/{ . II':: Possible Error/ii :. ! " :' I h 1'1 ! i I L I ( ':'~ I; l r- , .Ill/IN R. FI:NSTI:/{M.\l '111Jl. and ilL! IE & GRA Y At 'QlllSITIl I;\iS. INC'.. I\: II/I- ('Ill :RI Ill, I( l\l\IO;\i PI.EAS OF , , (., :\IIII:RI.,\NIl COI !NTY. I'ENNSYI.V ANIA Plainlifls \:0, IIX.Ill;).j Cilil Tcrm : ! .. VS. INTEGRA I'AINTlN<i. INC.. Iletcndunt CIVIl. NTluN ~.I.A\\' PRAECIPE TO SATISFY .JlJl)GMENT TO THE I'ROTIIONOTARY OF SAID ('OU~IY: I'leuse satisfy Ih~ juugmem in Ihis euse, IlllZGON DAVIS I.A W OFFICES (.. } fj_~_ 'c ~ By: TIM lHIY J. fIImER. ESQUIRI' Attomey I.D, 1/47231 525 South Xli' Strecl I.cba~[)n. 1',\ 1704~ Attorn~ys lilr Defendant 717/274-1421 BY: ~e+ I Dated: sit/I 2-- MARK K. EMERY. ESQUIRE Attorney I.D, 727X7 '5115 East Trindle Roau Mcehanicsburg. P A 17050 Attorneys for John R, anu Margaret A. Fenstermaeher and Blue & Gray Aequisitions, Ine. 717/691.5400