HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-07005
"'
.\1
~
....
\0
~
~
~
{
'..::
()
l.')
I~
~
J I "
l i ~
, I \.
j I~
I
I
I
i
!
t
\..
~
-
.
.5
..
'~
'"
~
~
'"
.
c..
~
~
7, Denied,
Paragraph 7 contains a conclusion 01: law to
which no responsive pleading is required,
8, Denied, Defendant's representative advised Plaintiff
that Defendant would attempt to locate another tenant and that
Defendant would contact Plaintiff if and when a new tenant was
located,
9, Denied as stated, Before Defendant had the opportunity
to contact plaintiff, Plaintiff had already filed a civil
complaint with the District Justice,
10. Denied, Paragraph 10 contains impertinent and
irrelevant allegations; an Appeal from a District Justice
Judgment is de novo review,
11, Admitted,
12, Admitted,
13, Denied as stated, Commission is paid for the referral
of tenants who are approved by Del:endant, By way uf further
response, paragraph 13 contains a conclusion of law to which no
responsive pleadiJ1g is reqllired.
11, Denied, Defendant incurred advertising costs for the
property i3ubject of thiG litigation, By way of further response,
paragraph 1.i contain~; a conclusion of law to which 110 responsive
pleadin(1 is required,
J5. Denied. Paragraph 15 contiiill:-~ ;-1 conclu:;:ion of 1a.\.J to
.....'hi ell no r(:'~~pon~,:i \u:-:- p] .>;H):i nq i ~~ l-Cqll i 3'"c.d.
WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully requests your Honorable
Court to dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint and enter judgment against
Plaintiff and in favor of Defendant, plus costs of suit and
attorneys fees,
NEW MATTER
16, Defendant's responses to paragraphs 1 through 15 of
Plaintiff's Complaint are incorporated herein by reference as if
set forth at length,
17, Plaintiff executed a rental application, A true and
correct copy of the rental application is attached hereto and
made a part hereof as "Exhibit A,"
18, The rental application contains terms and requirements
which provide, inter alia, that the deposit submitted with the
application is nonrefundable unless the application is rejected
by Defendant,
19, Plaintiff's application was approved by Defendant,
20, Based upon the terms of the rental application,
Plaintiff is not entitled to a return of the deposit,
21, Defendant incurred costs to locate a new tenant for the
Premises subject of this litigation,
WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully requests your Honorable
Court to dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint and enter judgment against
Plaintiff and in favor of Defendant, plus costs of suit and
at t ornc:>)'s f c:.-es .
,...----
(;' 'i
",
, ) I I,' II f/!.."
PENTAl APPLICATION
~======c===~==~==~~============~====;==~==~===~======~===
Consolidated Properties
400 North Fron! Street
Wormlaysburg, PA 17043
(717) 761 - 3558 FAX (717) 731 - 0075
(j/U/T.)l 1(1 S~.
PERSONAL HISTORY
, .'
//
Name: /' 111'/:"
I
/
f1
It-, .'
. ) I It: 1\(,:7;
Birth Date /1,))' j')' Marital Status
...J'
'I( i'
5 5 # " ,I(
. .
'; '( t, )___
Drivers License # /.s' / (, 'i J t' :>..
Name:
Birth Date
Marital Status
S.5,#
Drivers License #
Number of Children
I.
, .
Name: /"/:t: ~ ','
,
',: I~k" \1' Age '(I..( Name: k1htl)/,I'f f;'''.k~'(\ Age I ~
~l ..J " ',' ,)
,', .'. .'.' r'r I')J...,- Model,(!/II1' ,lrt'I.1""Year I <;.r- y
I
'III f ,.'; I Registratlon# 42 ~ r.iY. J{3J{o ;;<.
":')/11'.11'- -1. l~? I J.(~ h\"'i.t-
I .\.-
Vehicle #1: Make,
License Plate #
Vehicle #2: Make
Model
Year
License Plate #
Registration#
=~===~==~~======~===~C==~c=====~~==~a=====;===~========z=
RENTAL HISTORY
Current Address ~; ll./ ,v ,1.':7"'" ,:
Street City State
Current Tel~hone Number
Landlord Telephone #
length of Time .'1eason for Moving
Monthly Rent__ Your Portion Utilities
---
Previous Address
Street ----city State
landlord iGIGphone #
Longth of Timo Reason for Mcving ~
Zip Code
~
Zip Coda
l-
Ii)
I
x
\lJ
c======~=-~=-~==~==~==~~==~========~===~==c====~===~==~=;
FOR OFFICE USE OJ\il Y
... CI-. j:1 1')'--
CaSl1 IleCK!\ i I ,~
- ~
Deposit Receivod by ___
Amount of Deposit[, ,', / 1 l_ Applying For \ I "~ ' ,.\,.
:" ,.\ nOfo :::........ ,;.._...:
i'~~""""'''' tIU";UIIt:'-..
//,cr,ey Order,
t I I r......
11- \ -~_~
HARRY J, BURKETT,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
NO, 7005 CIVIL 1998
v,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CONSOLIDATED PROPERTIES,
Defendant
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing has been duly
served upon the following, by depositing a copy of the same in the
United States Mail, first-class, postage prepaid, at Harrisburg,
pennsylvania, as follows:
Date: I ~ )~.(y}
Mr, Harry J, Burkett
45 Longview Drive
Mechanicsburg, p) 17055 II}
~JffifJ{ljlf(0UJJ/Jiff~
Tracy L, McNamara, Esquire
219 pine Street
Harrisburg, PA. 17101
(717)236-5000
Attorney IDft 72669
Attorney for Defendant
"
,
Harry J, Burkett
Plaintiff
vs,
Consolidated Properties
III TIll! COlllt nl COl1ll1HlIl PIl~as
CIIII1I1I'II.1I111 Cllllllty Pl!lll1sylval1iil
No. ~JB /OOb Civil 1 (J9B
ANSWER TO NEW MATTER
(1) Plaintiff was not verbally il1folllll!d 01 PllIVI<!(id l!Xplillliltiul1 of rCllIal
application of no-refundable deposit,
(2) Plaintiff was 110t provid(id with copy III Il!cnipt,
(3) Plaintiff me(~tinn with Detnl1dill1t Willi II~ss thill1 (lIwhalf 11Our.
Defendant was aware of 12:00 1111Hllinu With "~Illilll~ i1pplicill11. Dnfcndant
mentioned name and time of appointnllil1t With Plail1tiff a IllJIllI.WI of limes during
meeting, Also, indicated on soveral occasiol1s IlOW quickly 01 a tlJrnover in rcntal
units occurs,
(4) Plaintiff was not il1fornwd 01 illlY cOl1llactual aoreemel1t, only a credit
process that would be reviewod l1ext day.
(5)
No residency was establislwd,
(6)
could do"
Defendanf employee, Bert, did indicaw that she would "see wl1at sl1e
and mentioned tl1at Plaillliff Illay IHi i1blo to oet l1alf of deposit back,
(7)
Defendant never attlilllptod to con1ilct Plaintiff,
(8) Plaintiff was aWilld('d $448.17 of OIioinal $700 investment by District
Justice Tom Placey on 11 13 98, otlwfwis(~ w(~ WOllldl1't Iw l\ere
(9) Cost Detendilnt c1ailllS as Clllllllllssion paid to employee, Jol1n, was
paid twice for same r(!l1wIIHIII.
(10) Defendant i1dVI~l1is(~d two I(!ntill Plopl.'lti(~s i1nd clliHges Plaintiff,
Plainti1f would hilVli only llr:Uljlll~d Olll! Insldt'incy.
(11) DI!fl'ndilllt ^dnlll1l~,tl iltllll' CO,,:S illl' illl OVl'rCI1iHUli,
"-
fr:;
.,.:.
.-.~
C.
I.IJ.-';
(,J ;;;...
!.:.::{
(-.II;
6i~~
u.:l.~
:-:-'",
Ll_ .~
i
u.
C
,
"I
('-.
>.
r~-
.'
~~;~
'.::>::(.
~
. r.')
.1:0:
\::: ;;-:
"'IJ.)
d)l~
....,;
:r::
..:L...
'"
CD
'-'-,
L...
(J'\
0'\
:5
o
-:;---
i ~-
};j Q
,- I"" ;-- V) -J
[: 1,-,
j 0 \ ~
" N '\
LIt;
(,'~ ( )-' ~ v I",
II "1 tt. '\
" '-!
(' ~ I I ~O
'j( 1\
1..1;, ~ V)) ~
I;".
I. V oil ~ I -~
[~' [I \>0-
::!-
I L ')(j
" .'''~ ..
l.....1 t.'., , .. )
J/W/Uf')(1.-J'IJII'l/f"S
\P;IIoJj~;liJ;!i) (fJ~;IjIl,J.l:l) J'II, ;,,),t,I.1', p'lll ",il /'.'1 l;l
(Il 1',),l:1l1.;ddl' ,I\jl IltH111 !i',l!ljV i" ,':I':('l'J ,I^."'p' ,'Ii: I,',' f.!" d,'
njdj,ILI I)"q:)!,)ll' ld!.i:)dl <,.I,'pll.l: '" iOl \i"
lll'
s ';'/'11<1" '/:1'111 \P:)I;I)'; Ii,lll 11"'11" ", " .~, 1
Ilil ".' 1,1 II; 1';111'111" ''''1' ,',11 , III' I " '" I,J
(:-,HOq ,iIO/', '!/O,il ~- ';i: ,"
H,IIVld::JOJ Tll3 01 "-Inti
-~ (~\..-,
..JJ
'" ~~
") ~
f'- t:'-
i ~
~
'0 I-i!.
(o\ "
"lhJ "dil(h.lIj()I~~1l111110:l ^l.^J
fI",i'lIl) I () :~/ll.1
'{Will ',1".1 )1,1/'/"11"111("1'1, ,III "'j fl'1!l1I1! to "jnJI'llli,s
(il ':J(J AVU P
'.ll',1 -~l]n.I'lH (]:JH(H~}SUn~; CJNV (CJlll~HI:J:iVI
'SIIH
~WOMS
l:!.'li'l! p,ilr)l'll!~ Idi;OclJ 5,1;lplJ;,S '1I1'1l1
ill'ii, '11'111' 'I''', "IIQj <Ill 11.''11',1
" i ',; o.:n)1 ':11 P;.'!ILI', ) ;:'ljll,l\ll Ilij IHJI'
( I
'111, filii' : I; 1I"q (",'II" 111'1(1',1:1
I.i
,';, I' ;)'-I~' ,'0 "1/'/,')
! ':\' '(l
: (' i\ . 'i: :,' /,11(7,1 I'
'j; :.,'1';' "I ,;',
',1i';;':;/
LIAVOI:l:l'\1
HJ AJNflO::)
VIN\f (\ 1/, ~~NN"ld :10 IU -1":lr-.\f\.'Ol'\il'\lQ::)
if''''lV,H,,;\' JU J:.J1101'1 :H.J J:JIAH3S :10 :I(JOHd
"'-',1 { ;' .';','i ( ,J' ",J .-i.'1' l.',~'(lr\' ,<.l!I',),;:,;' ,'( ;,,:C'.:'-: ::d~'J)
'COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND
NOTICE OF JUDGMENTITRANSCRIPT
"" CIVIL CASE
PtAINTlrl"': "l.l.""'t lnGACCRE3!i
rs11R.K3TT. liARRY J
45 LONGVIRW DR.
MB~~ICSBURG. PA 17055
L
MlQ. CI't.,~O.;
09-3-04
OJNlme: Her\,
THOMAS A. PLACEY
,,"".., 104 S. SPORTIlm HILL RD.
MECRANICSBURG, FA
VS,
DEF:.NDANi: ~AME If.dAOOA!S5
rcONSOL:DATED PROPERTIES
400 N. l'RONT ST_
WORMLEY9BURG, FA 17043
L
DockeINc.: CV-0000556-98 ~"
Date Filec: 10/20/98 ~
101'''''0:(717) 761-8:130 17055
CONSOLIDATBD PROPERTIES
400 N. FRONT Srr.
WORMLEYSBURG, PA 17043
I~
THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT:
Judgment: POll. PT,,", TN'I'Il'''
[!] Judgment was entered for: (Name) l'lTTR1rRT'('. IU I1I1V T
[i] Judcment was entered against: (Name) 0.()N'R()T.TT'l,",T'lT'l P110P~R"'TF.R
In the amount of $
(Date cf "~dgment)
11/1,</qR
,
44R 17 on:
o Defendents are Jointly and severally liable.
o Damages will be assessed on:
(Cale & Time)
o Thls,case dismissed without preJudice.,
Amount of Judgment
Judgment Costs
Interest on ,Iudgmenl
Attorney Fees
Tolal
$
$
$
$
$
397.67/
50. 5.Q
.00.
.00
448.:17
O Amount of Judcment SUbject to
AttachmenlJAct 5 of 1996 $
I p", Mem.rn C,ool" ,
Fest Judcment Costs $
Cerllfled Judgment Total ;=="""'cc==== I
o Levy is stayed for
days or 0 generally stayed.
o Objection 10 levy has been filed and hearing will be held:
I D."
Time:
ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE EN~~~J~~BY FILING A NOTICE
OF APPEAL WITH THE PROTHONOT flYJGlER~I'1'H~T OF CQM~t[jJ.:e'As;'oi~I~~yjStON. YOU
MUST INCLUDE A COP~cPTIiiS-N TilE OF JUDGMEt,TrDlA};SCRIPT FerR'l:WI'Tlj .YOUR'lIOTICE OF APPEAL.
. f -~ '1 'j;c'
".'-- ~ :;:.. .
r c _.....- , ' . . r
J \ - P1' f IS Dr:~o, ,. . ' -. District Justice
i
I certily 1'1e\ n"E ,~, a true and eel i:t OPl'.:i.H'"'
I( 1':\ r;Q I r'/ ,
\ - 1 J- I () 0:::0 I
,. u_ ..' 1 J
J P1.~,
cc:-d\;hr.e~fvCF.;I?:::i:;5':;C;l.!6lr;ing t~e judcmGnt.
../ ,'" " '0 DIWlct Justico
,,7 .--
..-'
'-
,." I
....,..... .-.,..._-_.~---
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE or APPEAl. AND RULE TO FILE ,COMPLAINT
(ThiS proof of $o;viCo .'I'lUgr DE FlU:D WIT/-lIN Tf:N (lO) n~\ )'S Atl!:f-? fililJr; tho no/ice of appeal. Cfleek applicable boxes)
COMMONWEALTH Of PENNSYLVANIA
COUNT' O'.~_~v.:J.__.~__,..,_
Af'~IDAVIT:
111l'1t~t1Y ~,\.\'(,'dl 1,1' nl1l1:11 tll;,! j :;/,'1 I.vd
.~ ;'I.C(~J1\1 Of_t;;/; N()tIC,~ (~j\/l"l)p"'al. C~}!tl:11(~lc?l(':';'; rJl)q~,,:7CiJ_2~". Il)'ll:ll, Itl!. L:I;:.;,i1ic,t Jl'~;1i(,l; dt:=.i9nilll~0 l~Olt'reirl,OI1:
(rlar,} of Eo't'n i(,'j).".l.~__ 1'1. _, Fl,'1 Q__, L: "1 i,y J,(CI :.UI,jl;': ~.I~! :.!';I: iyj. /~y IU-I {, 11i.'d I I .,,,.,[,.,,j) mi1i1,~cnctcr't
',.f.c',I,','.r....'..,",,'\',...I_.,',l.! 1\,,;", 11.1'." ,,'.'.'.'.!(,.i.',',J,'il.O.! I)'P.,'_lI':" ;1,.1'; '1',1,,',';,',',:_1,"1,,' ,'"",',',',,','1,',1,.(,, ~Q, t1 . -~u..fJ(...( 1T ._____, on
--- -.--..:? .':':1. _ ___115: - ", - ,iK. llY Ir:i'lt,j.(.'dl ("__ :,nl,JlI,':-~~l1dcr'~!:('c(.'i'PtJll<lche'li'hC"I"'O,
?4
and furt'ht~r ,1h.11 I ';eIVt'cj Ill!' .nul'" to t:li\' ;j ~',rcr'lil,!t!'\l
\!\.'homllw Hull' Wll~; ,;ddl('~";cd nrL..______. \d_ \1-"1 _
mail,s.Hl1df"S rereipt ',Htm:11NJ 1 iNi'h) ,
,~f (' 'P'lldllYIP'1 Ihl" ,1I.H)'.'e hltHiet' 01 '^_I'Pi.':~1 l1p(Jh'tht: :lpbel!~e1'~) to
11 98'. l...l bV lIV'! '-ullal ~,t'lvicc_ iXi by (~eJlified) (_ ',J' l!. _ I)
_!nqg/:KLUutoitliO _
, -'. S'9n'lf~j<lrJt;
SWOBN (i\FFIRMEDI AN~ S.UBSCln~W IlClOiHd'tl.:...
THiS~&\~_l)AY u~__J~{CLvl1~{-=_, 1'1. ,,-,_if,
// 'L d () /?
,;U~--'t .!.':!_~~~:._._ ,
$il;o<1:l(u'(' of ofl/ -,If bt:fo/t,' 1\-110(1/ ,11!1:1,H'f Ihl~. r/J..1.f,'
My rommis~i{)n f'XIIIII'!- Ull_____..,._
1 q~.
Cl "" ~:)
c CO , 1
;~.- c;J ~ :.!
rr);.; ,'" .. ~ ."
. '" llr~';'
::>i N Tlrn
U? . ;5:'
" .;-j~ rJ
r--
;,.:- ~- 'd:l
( -,.... ;.( )
j:"; ~;~ <::> (.'")1'1'1
, ~
:::.1 ,'\:) :on
-. . 0 "
7111('0' vO,ci,11
Notarial Stal
f<irnfJerly D. Drovm. NOlar)' Public
Harrisburc. O&U~lin Coullty
My Com:nisSlor' r.:t:.pitflS r~b. 1B. 2002
"
/ 1III11 Fllet.Class Moil
UNITED STATES POSTAL SEIlVICE/'" \ PoslLlqe &.Fr.os Pa'id
, ,1\' ~~';'~1 No G.l0
','- ,'0 I "-" , ' . --
. Print your n<l.';1e_a?rdre,S5, and ZIP Code in Ulis,box ..
"--- ...........
c- _ .
I(~qcu/e
-rRoC-lj L /l7cf\J:J.-vno..v(},
..-Z/q P'fH SuccI-
I-.J Of r; s.b Uv( 5 P /l
(OSlG/lflU) ~()G~ I:JdV 'OOSE: 1I110.:l Sd
u
.
oJ
"
'ij
.
u
"
t
~
~'
o
"-
. .
.'
fl: i'
~;!
ii: ;..,
~ ,~
" <
~~ ~
. ,
~ 'f:
. ,
on
... <..
:: :. ~
~ ~
f,",~
\~ ""
(, ~;.
" ;.
.. ,
[;f:
~ ~,
'I' 'J;
; Jl
1: ~~
o. ,r.
" i~
"
~, m
;?m
~~ 5:'
," <.'
" ,.
1,: '"
r- ",
(. ,"
1-- 4;
1\, r ~:.
~' L f':
", ~., ..
~/ ~,. ~,
"
~. ~.
l ;'
:' \
"
~. ~
"
L
~; ~"'-~ -~
~~ ~:; ~
mt"'0
1~ 2 r:
<Ill: f2
(1 j:; ~~
~ C' t;;J
;:\>i"i
, \',' ~.
\2.ml-lJ
,., ~..,' <I'
t. "'_'
<C~. ,',
..I..'t-
.l~: i;.- ~"
I; i:~' ("
.~. ~I' :.; l'
,,,<-.., ..
L f; ,'- ,
{'~ I: ~. ~"
;~~~;~:
.. ~ .:
{~, .s
t. L
" .
r. c'
-.; :~
J~ m
.-~ [
v. ~~
.,'
~. '"
;.1.1
',' G)
;T ~~
'J> ,-,
~'. ...'-,'
of,;'
,. .-
G' n
~, ;"
J ~,
Y::"
~: t oj>
'; [
,
, 0
W
,-
",
"'
:',0
"'~
,.
"
'"
u
,-,
~r
.'
0:
"f'
~- .-
,:.
,:"" ~'l
~; I':
.;;. ~~
L "
i:
,
0'
"
"
~,
;) 'IJ
....."
'.;\c
< "'
" ~.
'c,[
,-
u t
,~ .":
"
, ,
~, .
~; ~:
" ~~ ~~
~. 'l'
~': ~':
\ ~1
'I:'
","
", ,-
"
!, r.
~: >
~, a;
c' ~
;' ~
,--, UJ
'"
n
1~
'-'
Ii
,-
III ".
. "J
U
,,'
;,'~' ['
': 0'
/ 7/0/
(.1SJiMi1t:j) SGGI 'iudV 'oose WJO~ Sd
~ E ~ 0> ~ co ',' L "
. , L i' f,- c. , ,
.*. ~, " "], ~ " 7, ~
.' 1: .' ~, ..
:f. ., '" l:' " < , ~ [
'Ii> l' .: , E ~~,
E 0 " J' ^' "' ? " "
. " ~' "
u L" " , , " r' .,
:!' , .. " .' " ,
" ,
~ 1" Li ',':, " ,', .' I
"' l - " , !; n ~':
" " " " "' ," ~ :::
~ ., "' " "' ~ ! ., ~ "
" " .' , t
, " ."
~,; , ;, I ~ , ;, , ~
0 " " :
" [.' , ':'
" 1 f' ,
~'. , "
" I " . i'
~ .<; " i,
I ,
, " , " .
" , > , ,.
" " . "
. ::; " , ~
;;" '. ;
" , :0
" ~ , ~
" "
, . i 0 ~' !
, ! ~ "
<:> , .. '" ~
- ,-
;,., " I ". " .'
" I "' ~
.. <C' , (, "
.' ,"
i " U "
, ~
"
..
I
I
"
.' "l.q
~",> "
.
. ,"' ~
,
I .'
r ~
l
t
't
;
,
!
I
( i
"