HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-07209
I ~
, ~
i ~
i~
ill)
i
i
i ~
l~
'~
r
I
I j
I
I
\ I
I
II
I
I
,
,
i
j
j
1
, t"
I~
i
::-
.
.~
...
~
~
(;:)
c--J
t'
0.:.
~
.
~
25 Hoffer
SHIBECCA HILL,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
. . ~ ",'" l~.-. "'.r _":-.,..-;:-..'. ~ _' 'w,__ "~,_n'.-." ~ ':.. '," ',:.. ~" vJ~ j.," 'j , ',~, ""-, ,
V.
NO. 98-1209 CIVIL TERM
PATRICE SULLIVAN,
Defendant
IN TRESPASS (M.V.)
IN RE: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE
A pretrial conference was held before the Honorable
George E. Hoffer, P.J., on Wednesday, August 25, 1999.
In this motor vehicle case, David L. Ashworth, Esquire,
represents the plaintiff, and Donald R. Dorer, Esquire, represents
the defendant.
The defendant is a resident of Cumberland County. The
accident happened on Walnut Street in Harrisburg, when the
plaintiff was a pedestrian crossing Walnut Street in the middle of
a block at approximately 11:30 in the evening of February 18,
1998.
Plaintiff claims she used all due care in crossing the
street and was within several steps of completing the cross when
she was struck by a vehicle driven by defendant. Defendant claims
that the driving conditions were rainy and foggy and that. the
plaintiff was wearing dark clothes, which caused defendant not to
see the plaintiff.
Plaint.iff sustained various fractures over her body and
her jury claim is for pain and suffering for the incurring of
these fractures and their contlnuing healing process. Plaintiff
- - -
,- ----,
was unemployed at the time of the accident so the claim is totally
for pain and suffering.
Plaintiff's doctor's deposit,ion is scheduled for
September 2, 1999, and that is the only matter to be prepared
before the trial is ready to go.
Trial is estimated to take a day to a day and a half,
and neither party raises objections to witnesses contained in the
other party's brief nor to any exhibits offered; defense has the
testimony of the police officer who investigated the accident, and
the Court directs defense counsel to limit the police officer's
testimony to his direct observations at the scene and specifically
caution him not to discuss his report.
By the Court,
.J.
. ' . . _, . _ . . :, . .' '. I :' ,...,," ~ : .:. '., . . . " '. ',C :,: . " J '. ", " . ," " ,',' .
David L. Ashworth, Esquire
222 East Orange Street
P.O. Box 1522
Lancaster,Pa. J.7608-1522
For the Plaintiff
Donald R. Dorer, Esquire
214 Senate Avenue, Suite
Camp Hill, lOa. 17011
For the Defendant
503
..,C.\
I ' "\1. c" ' : .' . '.~ ;,\ ',':)
Prothonotary's Office
\"
. (.,)
. ,'\ .~') '..,.
\ \..- .....
Court Administrator
~~ ,~ ,'.:
....
:mti
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION -- LAW
SHIBECCA HILL
Plaintiff
NO. : 98-7209
'. . , . ., '., : ' ~ :. '. . - . . .' '.'. " . ~. " . ~ '. ' .' .' '. '.
v.
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PATRICE SULLIVAN
Defendant
:
:
PRE-TRIAL MEMORANDUM OF PLAINTIFF SHIBECCA HILL
(I) STATEMENT OF THE BASIC FACTS AS TO LIABILITY
On February 18, 1998 at approximately 11:20 p.m., plaintiff
Shibecca Hill was walking across the 2200 block of Walnut Street
in Harrisburg. Ms. Hill had looked both ways before entering the
roadway and no traffic had been visible. As Plaintiff had
crossed nearly all four lanes of traffic and as she approached
the far curb of the westbound lane she was suddenly struck by the
vehicle operated by Defendant which approached from Plaintiff's
right traveling westbound. It was raining that evening and a
light fog had developed; however, the roadway was illuminated by
the lights from the parking lot of an adjacent day care center.
Defendant admits in her deposition that she never saw
Plaintiff prior to the impact despite the fact that Plaintiff had
nearly crossed all four traveled portions of the roadway. The
right front passenger corner of Defendant's vehicle struck
Plaintiff's right leg knocking her to the ground within several
feet of the curb. Plaintiff contends that Defendant violated 75
Pa.C.S.A. S 3361 which notes, in pertinent part as follows:
S 3361. Driving vehicle at safe speed. No
person shall drive a vehicle at a speed
greater than is reasonable and prudent under
the conditions and having regard to the
actual and potential hazards then existing,
nor at a speed greater than will permit the
driver to bring his vehicle to a stop within
the assured clear distance ahead. Consistent
with the foregoing, every person shall drive
at a safe and appropriate speed . . . with
respect to pedestrians or other traffic or by
reason ot weather or highway conditions.
(Emphasis added).
(II) STATEMENT OF BASIC FACTS AS TO DAl{AGES
As a result of being struck by Defendant's vehicle,
Plaintiff sustained displaced, closed comminuted spiral fractures
of both bones in her right leg which required the surgical
placement of an intermedullary rod and screw for fixation. Ms.
Hill also suffered a broken left wrist which required the use of
two metallic orthopedic traction pins. A four centimeter
laceration on her forehead has left a permanent scar.
Nineteen months after the accident, Ms. Hill continues to
experience ongoing orthopedic problems. Although the wrist
fracture seems to have healed, she has a constant, dull pain in
her left arm. Further surgery to remove the 1M rods is
anticipated and she experiences daily pain in the right leg. She
has developed a noticeable limp. Although her anxiety attacks
have become less frequent and are, for the most part, being
controlled through medication, she remains very apprehensive when
she must venture outside her apartment and becomes extremely
anxious when crossing streets. Medical bills presently exceed
$38,000.00, all of which have been paid by first party benefits.
IIII) PRINCIPAL ISSUES OF LIABILITY AND DAMAGES
1. Defendant's negligence.
2
. .". :...' ,." ,..:'" '.'. ,'.' ',J .'. . _ , ..' , ". . . .-.
2. Whether Plaintiff was comparatively negligent under the
circumstances.
3. Whether the investigating police officer should be
permitted to testify beyond his observations at the scene of the
accident.
3
(IV) SUMMARY OF LEGAL ISSUES
1. Exclusion of here say testimony. The investigating
police officer's report contains heresay testimony of an
individual who was purportedly a witness to the accident but who
cannot be located and is believed to be unavailable for trial.
Furthermore, the police officer has never spoken to Plaintiff.
Accordingly, the officer's testimony must be limited to his
observations at the scene of the accident and his direct
conversati.on with the Defendant only. Lesher v. Henning, 302 Pa.
Super. 508, 449 A.2d 32 (1982).
(V) IDENTITY OF WITNESSES
Plaintiff may call some or all of the following witnesses
during the trial of this action:
1. Plaintiff Shibecca Hill.
2. Jane Turner (Plaintiff's mother).
3. Defendant Patrice Sullivan, as on cross examination.
4. Thomas H. Malin, M.D.
5. Any witnesses identified in Defendant's Pre-Trial
Memorandum.
. ..,-. .- _ _ . -, . -, c'. _ . . ':. _ ". 'I' ',. ~', '" . '.. ., .."
Date:
,f- JF Jj Cj
BY:
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I have this day served a true and
correct copy of the Pre-Trial Memorandum of Shibecca Hill upon
the person set forth below and in the manner indicated:
Service by first class mail, postage prepaid:
Donald R. Dorer, Esquire
Law Offices of Jacobs & Saba
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
1. L. A
aintiff
222 E. Orange Street, P.O. Box 1522
Lancaster, PA 17608-1522
(717) 397-7000
S.ct. ID. No.: 32118
"','
"
,
":~,
,
,
',',1,
.: ~
'.1,,:,
"1'
, ':t: .~, ,
:.1
..:.J
;,,:;-:,
/.:':
.'
<
"
,
",'
':".'
,,;'"
. .....
) "..' < " '. ., '.< ". I
,., . , ,.,' . ., . , ,I,
"
"
TO___~
. YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED TO FILE
'A WRITTEN RESPONSE TO THE
ENCLOSED
WITHIN TWENTY (20) D,\YS FROM
SERVICE HEREOF OR A JUOGEMENT
MAY BE ENTEREO AGAINST YOU
BY
AlTORNEY
LA\\' On'lns
JAC08S & SA8A
214 SENATI: AnNUt:
SlJIn: 503
CHIP UII.I., PA 17011
(717) 731-0988
FAx: (717)731-0987
lruG 1 91999
AUG 2 0 +\\lhQP HEREBY CERTIFY THAr THE
tlI~ IS A TRUE AND CORRECT COPY
J:S OF THE ORIGINAL FILED IN THIS
ACTION,
BY
AlTORNEY
I'~, I
".
"
\
..
,
"
....... I
\
\ "
',' ;
,:' \',
, .. i r
"'-', (
, " "
,". ,
f ,-'-~ ,~
'. , "., ,.i, \
~
'. ,
.,., ,,-,''';
,
" f': .\
~""
'.
''"
,"'" .'." .:.,.. :'.. ';' .' / >..:,::....; '....:..:,.,.. ':'. ':.' '.'
"._-~~.^~.~ >".,~_.>~
;,,'1~~
99HB-OOO 13
LAW OFFICES OF JACOBS & SABA
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Telephone Number: (717) 731-0988
Attorne 5 for Defendant, Patrice Sullivan
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
'.
.-
, , ::, : : " ' ' " , "',: " --:" ,,"': " ".: .'" '. ' ."" -, :'~. , :" ,', ... ,
SHIBECCA HILL,
}'LAINTIFF
VS.
No. 98-7209 CIVIL TERM
PATRICE SULLIVAN,
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE MEMORANDUM OF DEFENDANT, PATRICE SULLIVAN
1 STATEMENT OF BASIC FACTS AS TO LIABILITY
Please see Pre-Trial Memorandum ofPlaintift~ Shibecca Hill, By way of further factual
statement, the Defendant anticipates the evidence at trial will demonstrate that the Plaintiffwas
wearing black or rather dark attire. Additionally, the Defendant asserts that the Plaintiff will
testifY at trial that she did not see the Defendant's vehicle coming towards her from her right until
she saw headlights a few feet away from her before impact.
Additionally, the Defendant will contend at trial that the Plaintiff was comparatively
negligent as she was in violation of75 Pa.C,S.A. s3542(b) which provides as follows:
(b) Exercise of care by pedestrian,-No pedestrian shall suddenly
leave a curb or other place of safety and walk or run into the path
of a vehicle which is so close as to constitute a hazard,
Additionally, the Defendant will contend that the Plaintiff was in violation of75 Pa,C.S,A,
93 543(a) which provides as follows:
(a) General rule,-Every pedestrian crossing a roadway at any point
other than within a crosswalk at an intersection or any marked
crosswalk shall yield the right-of-way to all vehicles upon the
roadway,
II. STATEMENT OF BASIC FACTS OF DAMAGES
=
Please see pre-Trial Memorandum of Plaintiff, Shibecca Hill,
m~ PRINCIPAL ISSUES OF LIABILITY AND DAMAGES
'-
Please see Pre-Trial Memorandum of Plaintiff, Shibecca Hill, By way of further
statement, the Defendant concurs that "...the investigating police officer should [not] be permitted
to testify beyond his observations at the scene of the accident."
lV. PRE-TRIAL EVIDENTIARY ISSUES
Please see Pre-Trial Memorandum of Plaintiff, Shibecca Hill, By way offurther
statement, the Defendant concurs with the Plaintiff s proposed limitations on the testimony of the
;nu,-:.etiNaf:.nn ..."....1;...~ ill
...~_......o........O t''U''''''- 0 leer.
Y. WITNESSES
1. Plaintiff, Shibecca Hill (as on cross-examination)
2, Defendant, J>auicc Sullivan
3.
Patrolman Brian Kauffman
.~,
I, i"'~
,. . ~
." '. . -' "'.,',..j. ,,' : , " . ":.'.".,', ~' , ' ..' " , " , ",' , " ,
.
.'-r-
"'. \
VI. EXHIBITS
= --
I. Diagram of accident scene,
The Defendant reserves the right to list and/or produce such other and further exhibits as
may be listed by Plaintiff, as well as further or additional exhibits upon reasonable notice to
Plaintiffs counsel.
VII. SETTLEMENT NEGOTIATION STATUS
.
Please see Pre.Trial Memorandum of Plaintiff, Shibecca Hill,
'-
Respectfully submitted,
LAW 9F: lCES OF JACObCABA
1/, )1'
I , I
, /,
By:'v1; , Y'
Donald R. Dorer, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
Identification No, 39126
Date: August 20. 1999
,t
-'
-"~~'"
"j" _:':,,~,:' '~"'~,,,;;;;l':.,, ,--.;-~~,~,., .-~. ~.~-:l.~:'. .,:~"~_:,.-,""~~:h~____<1;;,."~+,:>;-.___~_,:_~"",,,,_,_,, .- ,':~: " ',~,',' ,-lo;,Oi, ,",
99HB-OOO 13
LAW OFFICES OF JACOBS & SABA
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Telephone Number: (717) 731-0988
Attorneys for Defendant, Patrice Sullivan
SHlBECCA HILL,
PLAINTIFF
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VS.
No. 98-7209 CIVIL TERM
PATRICE SULLIVAN,
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Donald R. Dorer, Esquire, hereby certifies that he is the attorney for the Defendant herein,
and that he caused a true and correct copy of the attached Pre-Trial Conference Memorandum
of Defendant. Patrice Sullivan to be served by regular first class mail upon:
David L. Ashworth, Esquire
Wagman, Ashworth, Kreider & Wright
222 East Orange Street, P,O. Box 1522
Lancaster, PA 17608-1522
Date: August 20. 1999
I
onald R. Dorer, EsqUire
Attorney for Defendant
:4
. .
. :"1 ~ ..,~ "",.:l,~,,'ol"l:'.""'~' ~,.,.,:.7.:' "~~,!"t...--~~~:.",~".";....";;,':e'~"'~;;"'("'~",":.c4.;::~~';:"'".:m:, , ~;.~~ ~..~".' .~', . :' '.. Y,'''' .
. -'~ '. ," ""~ id :,,::1;;:'
.,_~M..:! "a'~' _...~'i!'
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLV ANIA
CIVIL ACTION -- LAW
SHIBECCA HILL
Plaintiff
['!.t' 7)( c ('I . f}
NO,: -f.JL----.-'-.:-f--- "LLI-C/L_,
.
_ ,'" " ~ n"," '" . ' '-:~".": 10;*"';..-; .--~:' ~_-;--,-.-~"g~.~rt';,) -: I--;~- "-,' '--, '.. ','," '." I'".. .:' . '~ ~.
v,
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PATRICE SULLIVAN
Defendant
To: Patrice Sullivan. 110 I Yverdon Drive. Apt, C8, Camp Hill, P A 1701\
Date of Notice:
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. IF YOU WISH TO DEFEND AGAINST THE
CLAIMS SET FORTH IN THE FOLLOWING PAGES, YOU MUST TAKE ACTiON WITHIN
TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER THIS COMPLAINT AND NOTICE ARE SERVED. BY
ENTERING A WRITTEN APPEARANCE PERSONALLY OR BY ATTORNEY AND FILING IN
WRITING WITH THE COURT YOUR DEFENSES OR OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAIMS SET
FORTH AGAINST YOU, YOU ARE W ARNED THAT IF YOU I' AIL TO DO SO THE CASE
MAY PROCEED WITHOUT YOU AND A JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU
BY THE COURT WrrnOUT FURTHER NOTICE FOR ANY MONEY CLAIMED IN THE
COMPLAINT OR FOR ANY OTHER CLAIM OR RELIEF REQUESTED BY THE PLAINTIFF,
YOU MAY LOSE MONEY OR PROPERTY OR OTHER RIGHTS IMPORTANT TO YOU.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IFYOUDONOT
HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET
FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
~_('L ~Hbt II ICl '" A_. C\I PO,dI3j!,1I!.ia Bar Association - A
La'.\)'tr R~fwlll SSR1GlI ), "'-. (1--1> I'l.( ,(JVC
1GB 8vdd, :Jlml, P,O, Bel{ \S' tj, P (/ ,)
Il~.;o:'~'b' l'A j~lA!l l . ..>flll I, -.( e- 7U1::>
Telephone No,: I nLn v,1.. :~ I~ \1'\ 9~ll Y) /- ~ 00 Cf'1U 1/ cJf
or (-4!-11~Jb b,' I ~ ("_"_1 i ~I,,'r ."'A)
WAGMAN. ASHWORTH, KREIDER & WRIGlIT
/" r~~
By:
-~: L. Ashwo 1. A meys for Plaintiff
222 E, Orange Street, 1',0, Box J 52~
Lancaster, P A J 7608-\ 522
(717) 397.7000
S.Ct,ID. No,: 32118
.- -~. , .~
" '--fl~ ~
SHIBECCA HILL
PlaintitT
NO,:
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION -- LAW
v,
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PATRICE SULLIVAN
Defendant
To: Patrice Sullivan, 1101 Yverdon Drive, Apt. C8, Camp Hill, PA 17011
Date of Notice:
AVISO
USTED HA SIDO DEMANDADO/A E EN CORTE. Si usted desea defenderse de las
demandas que se presentan mas adelante en las sih'Uientes paginas, debc tomar accion dentro de
los proximos veinte (20) dias despues de la notificacion de esta Demanda y Aviso radicando
personal mente 0 por medio de un abogado una comparecencia escrita y radicando en la Corte pOl'
escrito sus defensas de, y objecciones a, las demandas presentadas aqui en contra suya, Se Ie
advierte de que si usted falla de to mar accion como se describe anteriormente, el caso puede
proceder sin usted y un fallo pOl' cualquier sum a de dincro reclamada en la demand a 0 cualquier
otra reclamacion 0 remedio solicitado pOl' eI demand ante puede ser dictado en contra suya poria
Corte sin mas aviso adicional. Usted puede perder dinero 0 propiedad u otros derechos
import antes para usted,
USTED DEBE LLEVAR ESTE DOCUMENTO A SU ABOGADO
IMMEDlATAMENTE, SI USTED NO T1ENE UN ABOGADO 0 NO PUEDE PAGARLE A
UNO, LLAME 0 VAYA A LA SIGUIENTE OFICINA PARA AVERIGUAR DON DE PUEDE
ENCONTRAR ASISTENCIA LEGAL
Pennsylvania Bar Association --
La....yer Referral Service
100 South Street, P,O Box 186
Harrisburg,PA 17108
Telephone No 1-800.692-7375 (PA ONLY)
or (7] 7) 238-6715 (OUTSIDE PAl
W 'GI\1^N. ~~,II "'~\R 17REIDER & WRIGHT
l b"J.(~1 "
,D \'la'1. Ashwon ;, Attorneys for Plaintiff
222 E Orange Street. PO. Box 1522
1,;Ulcaster. P ^ 17608-1522
(717) 3<)7-7000
SCtID:-':o 32118
By:
, ',"." ...: . ~ " ,. . . . " ". . , . . : "~'} ., :. ~. " " '. . - . ", ' "
6, Solely and dircctly as a conscqucnce of the aforcmentioned accident, PlaintilThas
suffercd, and continues to sutTer, serious and/or permanent injlllies including, but not limited to,
the followiog:
(a) moderate displaced, closed comminuted spiral fractures of the proximal
shans of the right tibia and fibula;
(b) closed, impacted comminuted tracture of the left distal radius with
posterior angulation at the fracture site;
( e) a four centimeter laceration to her forehead;
(d) psychological trauma and anxiety attacks;
(e) constant pain in her right leg and left arm;
(I) other injuries inadvertently excluded herefrom or latent in nature,
7. Solely and directly as a result of the aforementioned accident and the injuries set
forth in paragraph 6 above, Plaintiff has suffered the following damages:
(a) past, present and future pain, suffering and inconvenience;
(b) past, present and future emotional and mental anguish, humiliation and
anxiety;
(c) pust, present and future loss oflife's pleasures;
(d) past, present and future medical expenses; and,
(e) past, present and filture disability,
8, The injuries and damages sustained by PJaintiffwere caused solely by the
carelessness, recklessness and negligence of Defendant Sullivan and were in no manner
whatsoever caused by any act or failure to act on the pan of Plaintiff,
CJ. The carelessness, recklessness and negligence of Defendant Sullivan consisted of
the following-
, .. ~ .. ~, "",' :-,. ,.: -.' - ", I '. ~ ' . ) I" " . '-'" . ' ",.'
,.."""n-- lJ U
;.r-,~ '
.. ~;...-".
(a) failing properly and adequately to operate and eontrolthe motor vehicle
she was driving;
(b) operating a vehicle in careless disregard for the safety of others in violation
of75 !)a,C,SA *3714;
(c) failing to keep a proper lookout in violalion 01'75 Pa.C.SA. ~3361;
(d) tailing to drive her vehicle at a safe speed in violation of75 Pa, C.SA
S3361;
(e)
failing to observe with reasonable care the road conditions, including the
location of Plain tilT in the roadway and to adjust her speed accordingly;
and,
,
,.
(I) failing to employ her brakes in time to avoid colliding with Plaint if I
10. Defendant Sullivan's carelessness, recklessness and negligence were substantial
factors in causing the accident, injuries and danlages set forth in paragraphs 6 and 7 above,
II, PlaintilT did not own a motor vehicle nor did she reside with any relative who
b
r-
: OJ
, ,
! I
I
I
I,
I'
I
owned a motor vehicle at the time of the accident and was not otherwise covered by the Limited
Tort Option of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Act.
WHEREFORE, Plaintitf demands that judgment be entered in her favor and against
Defendant Sullivan in a sum in excess of Twenty Thousand Dollars ($20,000.00), plus costs,
interest and fees as allowed by law, said amount being in excess of the amount requiting referrnl
of the case to arbitration under the Dauphin County Local Rules of Civil Procedure.
Date:-p!..?/ICJs
BY:
WAGMAN, ASHWORTH, KREIDER & WRIGHT
J..f~2
LO ,'idj. Ashworth, Attorneys for Plaintiff
22_ E Orange Street, 1'.0, Box 1522
Lancaster, PA 17608-1522
(717) 397.7000
SCtlD,No 32118
.' '. '. ,I " ", '. . , .' "",.'. '.., . ", :",,:1., ,. :. '..", "'" .
~~ ,-
_."--~
~,...r~~:2I~",,:
'I'
',i.
'::\1'
.:'
-:...:,',"
\
"'"
:::-', -':'.,:-
I' . I .~~ :-- ..' , . , . . . . ". ~, ,\
"" . F . . '-, :' .' -.: ;".' . . '; ~. ' ' '. '. ' - .'. ' "'.' " ,'" .
SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR
CASE NO: 1998-07209 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
HILL SHIBECCA
VS.
SULLIVAN PATRICE
DAWN KELL ' Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according
to law, eays, the wi thin NOTICE AND
upon SULLIVAN PATRICE
d\?fendant, at 15: 13
1999 at 1101 YVERDON
CAMP HILL. PA 17011
COMPLAINT. PLTFF'S
was served
the
HDURS,
DRIVE
on the 11th day of January
APARTMENT C-4
,CUMBERLAND
County, Pennsylvania, by handing to PATRICE SULLIVAN
a true and attested copy of the NOTICE AND COMPLAINT. PLTFF'S
together with REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENT'S.
1 NTERROGA TOR I ES
and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Service
Affidavi t
Surcharge
So ansvers:
'/P
C' ...-:,01 /,/... .
"",'" / ... ~ ,--":~::,_t?
--;:r~ .... I............ - " .
R1: Thomas K11ne,' i:;her1tt
I
~-
f
f
I
18.00
9.30
.00
6.00
G3~.~~ WAGMAN. ASHWDRTH, KRIEDERI
01/12/1999
by
('-\-~
'\~_).ll .. ", y\ ':
Ueputy
VttL
Sher1ff
Sworn and subscribed to before me
IJI! /1
this day of.._/" "j_
19 11'1 A. D.
c J' "
./ I
(" 'J" ,.',
, 1\. l \ ~-~'f-,~---
Prothonotary
~." .' .. : ,",'.... . ", . ;;--,~ ~ !~r .~"""'f-.~ :,/,"...;-.-:'~;''''':-::-;'~ .'::""0( t~""'-..-n-:::~"7. "l-~ ",,", '...:....., .'...., ,."..' .
'-"~ _ ~'J
IN TilE COUPT OF COMMON PLE/\S OF' CUMBE:HLAND COUNTY / PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL l\CTlON -- LAW
SIIIBECC1\ III LL
plilinl: iff
NO.: 98-7209
v.
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PATRICE SULLIVAN
Defendant
To: Patrice Sullivan, 1101 Yverdon Drive, Apt. C4, Camp
Hill, PA 17011
Date of Notice: February 4, 1999
IMPORTANT NOTICE
YOU ARE IN DEFAULT BECAUSE HAVE FAILED TO 8NTER A WRITTEN
APPEARANCE PERSONALLY OR BY ATTORNEY AND FILE IN WRITING WITH THE
COURT YOUR DEFENSES OR OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAIMS SET FORTH AGAINST
YOU. UNLESS YOU ACT WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS
NOTICE, A JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU WITHOUT A HEARING
AND YOU MAY LOSE YOUR PROPERTY OR OTHER IMPORTANT RIGHTS. YOU
SHOULD TAKE THIS NOTICE TO A LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE
A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE FOLLOWING
OFFICE TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Court Administrator's Office
Fourth Floor
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, Pennsylvania
(717) 240-6200
Date: J- '-/- 99
KREIDER & WRIGHT
L. As'lw
aint,iff
222 E. Orange
Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-7000
S.Ct.ID. No.:
rth, Attorneys for
Street, P.O. Box 1522
17608-1522
32118
" ',..,' ,', ,';'" ,"'-'" ';"7 ,...n~.,~:~::'.'"" r:':--::""":"'~',,-?"':"""":~':"'~""'~":-'.~O-':"~~:", ..:'~:. ,,'. ....." '.. ,
;~~.>.
.'
~..
. '
. .
.
q~FTI F] CAn: OF SEFVICE
I hereby certify that 1. have this day served a true and
correct copy of the foregoing Important Notice upon the persons
set forth below and in the manner indicated:
Service by first class mail:
Patrice Sullivan
110] Yverdon Drive, Apt. C4
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Date
c2-L{-~9
By:
& WRIGHT
i L. A
P intiff
222 E. Orange
Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-7000
S.ct.ID. No.:
Attorneys for
St., P.O. Box 1522
17602
32118
" ',J: :.;,......"iM:,1 ""'-_',,",1' '(',':r'~'~'~-.~,':7\-:---'-;"""-~:-;'-'~';;--',"::-:',-~;~~:"'"-,--",;-,~,_, ..,'. ',' . -~. ~."'" ,~:_.'
I....
~.__.__ ____ _~__:~_~_:""''''':~'~--:~.~:;~L...2''-~
'..
" .'.
,,'
~ ; ':,
',"."
':,
",
..
. "~ 1'; -!,
-'t'
, .
, .
\ I,'" " -:. -, .
. . . '
, '
" .
:,~,~:"~;;;':'..":" ;,-~':
.__0':"':..'
, 99H13-00013
LAW OFFICES OF JACOBS & SABA
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Telephone Number: (717) 731-0988
Attorneys for Defendant, Patrice Sullivan
5mBECCA HILL,
PLAINTIFF
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VS.
No. 98-7209 CIVIL TERM
PATRICE SULLIVAN,
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ENTRY OF ApPEARANCE
TO TIlE PROTIlONOTARY:
Kindly enter my appearance in the above-captioned matter on behalf of the Defendant,
Patrice Sullivan. The Defendant reserves the right to otherwise plead in this matter.
Respectfully submitted,
LAW OFFICES OF JACOBS & SABA
It
By: fL.
, Donald R. Dorer, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
Identification No. 39126
.
/ /
i!//-~
Date: Febmary 22. 1999
. ~,'.~:"'_M"' ~~_;.'~".' .'" 'l~":" ':'.';~ " j ~'~:' "~~., ,t,:- :$\", " '''.' ., ... " .~,. ____, ,,"
.'-...7_'A~"~).~-~~L..._~
,
99HB.oOO 13
LAW OFFICES OF JACOBS & SABA
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Telephone Number: (717) 731-0988
Attorne '5 for Defendant. Patrice Sullivan
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY . PENNSYLVANIA
SIllBECCA HILL,
PLAINTIFF
VS.
No. 98-7209 CIVIL TERM
PATRICE SULLIVAN,
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Donald R, Dorer, Esquire, hereby certifies that he is the attorney for the Defendant herein,
and that he caused a true and correct copy of the attached Entrv of Aopearance to be served
by regular first class mail upon:
David L. Ashworth, Esquire
Wagman, Ashworth, Kreider & Wright
222 East Orange Street, P.O, Box 1522
Lancaster, P A 17608-1522
Date: February 22. 1999
),.
;\i
if /
//~L
(jl~
'Donald R. Dorer, Esquire'
Attorney for Defendant
: - ;.""'-.....~... ...~..
" , ,.." .: ,;* ".j{j"~ .~:.: ,;:-,'" , ~. '.~'''-'''~'''''"':~1-\~': ;'M\'/~'\"~~~~~;"~"~'\'Il, '~::"<' "/:,..''''',',. "~'."""'":~:,~,,:,,.,,~ '.:" '. 4 '~:' \~', . \ ~''. ',' .~- .
>-
IT:
."
...~
lUt;;:
0':
rt~j
,;','r',"
()
Xc..
L~.",..
...1.,
L:!j"
r.:
1I..
o
...::r
.;:)
M
t:
'"
:" 5~:!"
( ) ,:~
')-',
~~g~
"?"
:,j~~
nJ(1..
"~
<'i
6
.-
"-
l.l..
I"")
N
C'-:'l
u.J
u_
C'o
0"\
.. ....
'" .. '"
<:J =000\"
=;.0: r-ooo
:Il<;,,; ......COII
\.I.ltr..l ~ l'I") -< =.-l
~.."JI<~~..l~
"''''''WI ~ O&J J'M'_
OtIJ<.......lI',t--
~=~S,;:-r:
'ot..:l:I'J.....l""oo_
j U ,m :: r:: ~.
<~ ~-~
~... U ~
..
, '.
"
99BB-OOO 13
LA W OFFICES OF JACOBS & SABA
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Telephone Number: (717) 731-0988
Attorne 5 for Defendant, Patrice Sullivan
5mBECCA HILL,
PLAINTIFF
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, I'ENNSYLV ANIA
VS.
No. 98-7209 CIVIL TERM
PATRICE SULLIVAN,
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT, PATRICE SULLIVAN,
TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT
I, Admitted,
2, Admitted.
3. Admitted,
4.-11. Denied. These paragraphs are generally denied pursuant to Pa.R.C.P.
gI029(e).
WHEREFORE, the Defendant respectfully prays this Honorable Court to dismiss
Plaintiff's Complaint, and to enter judgment against the Plaintiff and in favor of the
Defendant.
"/.' : ,.,:,:.' '::' >",.-' ".I!::'~',;"''''.''':,'' ~ ". . .... -'..'."':', ....1' ,.,":~ ,'" :'.' I:' "'.'
99HB.o0013
LAW OFFICES OF JACOBS & SABA
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA non
Telephoue Number: (717) 731-0988
Attorne s for Defendant. Patrice Snllivan
SIllBECCA HILL,
PLAINTIFF
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON I'LEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VS.
No. 98-7209 CiVIL TER~t
PATRICE SULLIVAN,
DEFENDANf
CiVIL ACTION - LA W
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
VERIFICATION
I, Patrice Sullivan , verify that the statements made in the
foregoing Answer of Defendant. Patrice Sullivan. to Plaintiffs Complaint
_. which are within the personal knowledge of the undersigned, are true and correct, and as to
the facts based on the information of olhers, the undersigned, after diligent inquiry, believe
them to be true. And funher, this Verification is signed on the recommendation of my
attorneys. who advise me that the allegations and language in this document are required
legally to raise issues for resolution at trial, by the Court, or by continuing investigation and
preparation for trial. I understand that some of these allegations may prove inappropriate after
investigation and trial preparation are complete and I leave the determination of these matters
to my attorneys on their advice.
I understand that all statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18
Pa.C.S.A. g4904, relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities.
Dated:
~.; I u I
,
I',l, '
I I
, I
(,
. (i),-- , .... tA /, t
u~-,,-- \,t llL
Patnce Sullivan
,,,,,,.
;....r.-. .
.:.-
, , '., .' '. , . ' ' '. . . . . ,." . ~ '..: "~, . I.' . '. I >. .'
"
......'....,\.<,
.~.
99HB-OOO 13
LAW OFFICES OF JACOBS & SABA
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Telephone Number: (717) 731-0988
Attorneys for Defendant, Patrice Sullivan
5mBECCA HILL,
PLAINTIFF
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
, .' ,",' ~/ ~ '> '~: )'..' "."I""~':'- '.' ::'. .',;' ':; '~, '.",1,': ,,'.',.,'. ",' '...~_ .'. ," "
VS.
No. 98-7209 CIVIL TERM
PATRICE SULLIVAN,
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Donald R, Dorer, Esquire, hereby certifies that he is the attorney for the Defendant herein,
and that he caused a true and correct copy of the attached Answer of Defend anI. Patrice
Sullivan. to Plaintiff's Comolaint to be served by regular first class mail upon:
David L. Ashworth, Esquire
Wagman, Ashworth, Kreider & Wright
222 East Orange Street, P,O, Box 1522
Lancaster, PA 17608-1522
Date: March 4. 1999
1/'
/7ff /
hl---
t.'
')
/~
Donald R, Dorer, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF DAUPHIN COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION -- LAW
SHIBECCA HILL
Plaintiff
v.
PATRICE SULLIVAN
Defendant
NO,: 98-7209-Ci\~1 Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
GERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I have this day served a true and correct ccpy of Plaintiffs
Response to Request for Production of Documents upon the persons listed below and
in the manner indicated:
Service by first class mail:
Donald R. Dorer, Esquire
Law Offices of Jacobs & Saba
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Date: if! u/9 ~
BY:
WAGMAN, ASHWORTH, KREIDER &
WRI
, Ashworth, Attorneys for Plaintiff
222 ,Orange Street, P.O. Box 1522
Lancaster, PA 17608-1522
(717) 397-7000
S,Ct.lD, NQ,: 32118
. " .
. ' ..' . " .' : . ~, " " .' . ,,": ". ~- . , . .,. '. ,', '~ . ' ' . , ,'. . .,:' ", . J' .
",
,,>..'
<"'i'"
':~:::':::~i,,:-,.i''''
, ~\"
'.,'
.'
: ':".'~
',~ ,
,',
..-,.
,.,:
;""',:,
''',/
"i',',
I.);...
,'0,'
",,'
".:"
'::,' ',.
'"..
'"".",,
r''-'
1 \tr\~<::;:'?':':
i ~~f8~ '. '".'" , ,",
, ~~~I~ :(;. :',
~'~ \h,'
~il ~:\:"
I; ~i I-!' ~>./'
I t:1~ ,~:.-,
':;:'8 i'"
i~'II~~:';(~
; '~I ~:i:'::':'::'"
~ ~~i:' ~~;~?:):~i ::->~,:
I, '~i1i~:;~tt/~; ,~.:,/..,- .
'\',
'. .,
-.:'
.' '\)~~'
I'
i
,""
.,.'1
""'if .~,~ .'
" ;1';'
,'.
,.;"
:~.
.,'.
'.,' ';
,.",'
..,\
'~'~".," ~.,~._~:,,:'
':~-F~;,),~~~:~U":'L~~
'. ,
;,\ :~~ ... .
\ , .' .. . . ... '.' '. ' ' . . ':..., , . f' ." . ,: ~ ': : '.' '.'._ ': ~ , "~. '."~. '_ ' _",' .":'" .' --, 'I," ' '. . :
~ ~
i ...... ~..-=:
~""
1
...'
o
',;
e
, '
..c:: ',~'
,"t:: ' ,'~, ,~ ','
Ote
.~~,
...~.
t!
. ,
'i::
~ J'",
, ;i ",~::"~,', ",
:::':s' f/ j ~ ;("
. ,,;.; liU'l '
,"0>< 15;j.'.'
0,,....., ~ "':,"~
,x [&I:,>', :':;;':';',,1
! ,V,VI: ..... ...;,\, ?
t;~ I ESi'::' "i""
,,' :i ln~ ;~;... ;::,,;>:;;:'ti:
. , :',~'::! ,,~:' r: :::.:: :~,__:"~~.:L::'l:..'"::~'!:;';;~'~~~
., ~,' ".l"< ,':iY~.;i:;fl~l.,
/0.
'1 ~ ; J.'
.,
,.',
'~; .
'.""-:',
"
"
,'"
,
",
"\
,,;,',
,',
r ~ ''':
:',"
'I'"
'j',::
, ,
,,',
<,
'\,:'
',,"''; .,.,'-'.
......';.
.";}':,:,:\.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF DAUPHIN COUNTY. PENNSYLV ANIA
CIVIL ACTION -- LAW
SHIBECCA HILL
Plaintiff
v.
PATRICE SULLlV AN
Defendant
NO,: 98-7209-Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I have this day served a true and correct copy of Plaintiffs
Answers to Interrogatories upon the persons listed below and in the manner
indicated:
Service by first class mail:
Donald R. Dorer, Esquire
Law Offices of Jacobs & Saba
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Date: 'If ~J9 ~
WAGMAN, ASHWORTH, KREIDER &
W T
BY:
. L. As , Attorneys for Plaintiff
2 F.. Orange Street, P.O. Box 1522
Lancaster, PA 17608.1522
(717) 397-7000
S.Ct.lD. No.: 32118
. , > ' . , ',' .', ' _, ',' ,'" .:", i'~:- ~ :'~.. " ,',. . > . f '; ,: . - ., ':.', .'. ' I ." .'.
. . . '
\ ~,i!';\;;;):
,
~'~;.~ .:'
~j1 ill
:' 1'~.1lt ~,
~ ~rQ d:,i'
"}~'II~'~i ,,'
".1"', O'c.'.'.'
~':.$1:' ",- :".,.<;',;:t"':',,.:..
" 1,'01.' '}",.. "'"..-'
.. ,:#.; II ~,:;,'i,.:;;,;
) ~!~:i(\'~\:-)':
:!<,::-'- ;,.:,
"':'.'. '" .:,"
:i
'I'
.': ~
,',. ',~:
;..,."''''''
'{'.
,,>:'
',,'
,-€"~,'
'k'i, ,','
''"0..0,
"~"""'"''
< ,-~. ,\,~.
: .>.-r-~_:-'
;"".'
..
..
.,\,'
..
"
:'1':':'
, ",'
".-"',.
'.0'.:-
','.
i',
'.'-
"
"',:"".
',I:,'
'.;,.
,',<;.
",.'."
;,.
,
",','.
...."
0",1,
.',"
"",;.,.,.,
"
" \~. "
";.
';,;>",i
"(.'
'o';
'".:,.
,"
1:.
',;
'~
;
'...
0,
r:J'
~,
r
.,f' II","""",'".:.,".,':,".."",':' .....",,1'
.~.
~~\.
,I:"
,,;'
,,-.,--'
1,:",'.-,-::;
''''~'','
..
"
1
I
~
.:,'
,'<<'r
"
, -,'~~
i,'
..
";:i,"
.'".'
',,'
"i"
:';:-,'
".:
',,'
" ,,'~ ;'; .
""1'
"'-' ;
.....J,..,.
'.;'.
..
"
,-.
','P
.~
\t
. "
. ~.. . , . .-
" .',
'Ii,,'
, (f ~ :
.>g
'.'.,.m, ,'."."", ,
. "
:, '!' -:
.- ',:: '
" ,
, " ,
,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLV ANIA
CIVIL ACTION -- LAW
SHlBECCA HILL
PlaintilT
NO.: 98-7209
v,
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PATRICE SULLIVAN
Defendant
CERTIFICA TE OF SERVICE
I hereby certifY that I have this day served a tme and correct copy of the Notice of
Deposition of Patrice Sullivan upon the persons set forth below and in the manner indicated:
Service by first class mail, postage prepaid:
Donald R, Dorer, Esquire
Law Offices of Jacobs & Saba
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
DateJdili 1
WAGMAN, ASHWORTH, KREIDER & WRIGHT
, ~ "
) j (, :/<---
/~/ (\ >;/
[) \1\ ' Ashworth, Attomeys for Plaintiffs
222 E. Orange SI., P,O, Box 1522
Lancaster, PA 17602
(717) 397-7000
S,Ct.IO, No: 32118
By:
'"'
.,',.,',' ''.,'.... t" ,;~..">. ";_-"~":':".':, ,',', ',""', ,...,~I..:,~'.~.. "",' .',: '
,-,J,WI,\
File No.: 99H~-OOO13
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL
(Must be typewritten and submitted in duplicate.)
Patrice Sullivan,
(The party listing this cue for triallh.U provide forthwith. copy of the
praecipe to aU eounae1. purau.nt to local Rule 214-1.)
No. 98-7209
Civil_ 19 98
Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe: Donald R. Dorer. Esquire. Attorney
for Defendant. Jacobs & Saba. 214 Senate Avenue. Suite 503. Camp Hill. Pennsylvania. 17011: (717\ 731-0988.
Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: David 1.. A~hworth. Esquire. Attornev for Plaintiff. Walmlan.
Ashworth. Kreider & Wright. 222 East Orange Street. PO BOlLI 522. Lancaster. PA 17608.1522: (717) 397-7000
/7
'I ,/
/~---
Signed: [~ '
Prim Namd~/Donald R. rlOrer. Esauire
Attorney for:-Pefendant
. .:~.:!' :'-", .~~--,'-- ~ ,'" ''''~C, ._-~ -,. - .-'. '. ....".,.*-'~~. "~-~-'.~'" .-:: _' ," -, . I" .... . 1 '
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUM:BERLAND COUNTY:
Please list the foIlowing case (check one):
( x) for JURY trial at the next tenn of civil coun.
( ) for trial without a jury.
CAPTION OF CASE:
(Entire Caption Must Be Stated In FuIl)
(Check One)
( ) Assumpsit
Shibecca Hill,
( ) Trespass
(plaintiff)
(x) Trespass (Motor Vehicle)
vs.
( )
(Other)
(Defendant)
The trial list will be called on AUl!llst 17. 1999
Trials commence on September 13. 1999
Pre-trials will be held on AUi!I1st 25. 1999
(Brief. are due S day. before pre-trie-I..)
This case is ready for trial.
Date: July 6. 1999
;""-'~...:z
~ tJ') ~
I- N 5~
' u~Q
~ """ =c ~l
~c. a..
~iE '.....
0 r- o.
.'
'" .,)-
d.": I 0:;-
_JU1 -' IiI,
0:-. :::> tll
~ -, ::;;
~ C\ a
C\
II
n
~~ ~II
~<l-1 ... I
I..I~<:::!'~ ...
Eo.lJl:!Il\A;.!.~
0",7' S ::f~~
$ ~ .~ ~= ~ c...
o-l w wo !l,'"
<" :r. t:. :.!
........ <If: <It.
... t.J I&<
,
,
.....
I'
I
I
I
I
"f,:'
~ ." .
'-
....
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION -- LAW
SHIBECCA HILL
Plaintiff
NO,: 98-7209
v,
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PATRICE SULLIVAN
Defendant
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I have this day served a true and correct copy of the Notice
of Videotape Deposition upon the persons set forth below and in the manner indicated:
Service by first class mail, postage pre-paid:
Donald Dorer, Esquire
Law Office of Jacobs & Saba
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Date 1 ! ~o ) ~ C)
By:
, "':', " ", " ,", '. ...; "'.',".:. _.." _~" .. .:, '~ ',<'., ". " ,,'. ': t" .
'''-~'-''-'~"
-
;""''''~~d;,;
.,.....'
.",
,';"
....~':: ;'
, ~ '
'< "
"',""
'"
',',
'I'
I.'" "
..",
, .'~
',:';
',,'.
";'1
'..\.
"I.
,
..
,
:'.
" '
"
""
"':\
ii"
-
.,
"',
"..
"
. "p<)"
...' tI'J'
"'\:l
, .~
:~.
i'
'~
j:!,
~'
~"",'
I,
"Jj
',:
"!
"
.',.
"
'. ,,~
..r-;,,'
.~ ~ .'
-.
..'
. ~-l
',", ,..'.;J..'.',~
,
"
,...
., . ' "',;" ,_,,;t..",',~_'. "'-'::~I"'_ .,"" '.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION -- LAW
SHIBECCA HILL
Plaintiff
NO,: 98-7209
v,
PATRICE SULLIVAN
Defendant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I have this day served a true and correct copy of the Notice
of Videotape Deposition upon the persons set forth below and in the manner indicated:
Service by first class mail, postage pre-paid:
Donald Dorer, Esquire
Law Office of Jacobs & Saba
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
WAGMAN, ASHWORTH, KREIDER & WRIGHT
Date )/ /10/11
/~ A,'
By: ').-/ /, y~ ,t:?j7t/:
vid L. Ashworth, Attorney~for Plaintiff
/222 E. Orange St., P,O, BGX 1522
(lancaster, PA 17602 /
(717) 397-7000 '
S,Ct,lD, No.: 32118
; ...,I~'
. :. " .. . "'. ,
L ,'. : ,_. . '. I' fI'-. : -. I '. < .. , '
. . ~, ' ,,": ' ~ .'.". \' -, .: . \ . , '-: ,- 't' " "". . j
, '
~
tI.;...'>I~.'
._.....t..~;~.:
\-.
"
9900-00013
LA W OFFICES OF JACOBS & SABA
214 Senate Avenue, Suite 503
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Telephone Number: (717) 731-0988
Attorneys for Defendant, Patrice Sullivan
SHIBECCA HILL,
PLAINTIFF
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
VS.
No. 98-7209 CIVIL TERM
PATRICE SULLIVAN,
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Donald R. Dorer, Esquire, hereby certifies that he is the attorney for the Defendant herein,
and that he caused a true and correct copy of the attached Praecioe to Settle. Discontinue and
End to be selVed by regular first class mail upon:
David L. Ashworth, Esquire
Wagman, Ashworth, Kreider & Wright
222 East Orange Street, P.O, Box 1522
Lancaster, P A 17608-1522
Date: December 1. 1999
?{(J /1~ll
Donald R, Dorer. Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
. ' . . J , ,'.' '. . ' . .' .,. . . ,_ " " ., . I. ~ '
, " , ',,' " '" ',' I, ,...'. .
' , . J, ,,',' , , .' ,;".... ' :" . .' _
~ CO G
I.r,
~ & %
(') ')
I.JJ "'.'~ ;S'~
[;?() -- (J~~
"-
'...l~,: /~ Cl. t)=?:J
't.,
~'i': '" ',if,
C_..,.. j;;::
t.Lit.J_ I
[L!~.</ c.., i,:::~""
Cd !t.lli]
r: c:.::: ~{1 C-
:'1., 0'>
<:) :.:)
0"\ (...l
... ....
~~ ~~~
::l ,-:; ~ '" :: g: ,.!.
u~. -< '" '" I....
e~ 1Wt.n-..-41'
o CIJ ~ ~ :f~, t:'
7.t:__~
~~~~=~C
.:l t,) rn e: I' ..
<~ ~--~
,""", t.l r...
':'':'
;'..
--
;""--''"''
.' ,