The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About00-07396 ~ilM~ ........ ~ ,j~~--I -<"~~,\'" ..Ai ~ COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COURT OF COMMON PLEAS NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM JUDICIAL DISTRICT DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT COMMON PLEAS No. 00-7396 CIVIL TERM NOTICE OF APPEAL Notice is given that the appellan' has filed in the above Court af Comman Pleas an appeal from the judgment rende1ed by the District Justice on the date and in the case men~oned bel"", :1;ar;~ s I MAG C)-iO ~R >>Ai: nJo <-f srA" Z1PCOOE s:. ('\(' \ \ ,'" (!.V12 ..2..39 -00 lTI9 This black will be signed ONLY when this nota~on is required unci.... Po. R.cP J.P. NO. 1008B. This Notice of Appeal, when received by the District Justice, will operole asa SUPERSEDEAS to the judgment for possession in this case. Signature of Prothonotafy or Deputy If appellant was CLAIMANT (see Pa. . .J.P. No. 1001 (6) In action before Dis(rictJustice, he MUST FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after filing his NOTICE of APPEAL. PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE (This section of form to be used ONLY when appellant was DEFENDANT (see Pa. R.C.P.J.P. No. IF NOT USED, detach from copy of notice of appeal to be served upon appellee). PRAECIPE: To Prothonotary 100 117) in action before District Justice. Enle1 rule upon F I J-c b ~ IV "- -k.1."e..- . t/ame of appel/eels) CIVIL TERM , appellee(s), to file a complaint in this appeal ., (Comman Pleas No. 00- 7396 Signature of appellant or his attorney or agent RULE: To Fur/' ~ Ah../o. /, 'p Nbre'of appeJ~S) , appollee(s). (I) You are no~fied that a rule is h...by entered upon you to file a complaint in this appeal within twenty (20) days afler the dale of """ice of this rule upon you by personal s"",ice or by certified or regislet'ed mail. (2) If you do not file a complaint within this time, a JUDGMENT OF NON ,PROS WIll BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. (3) The date of service of this rule if service was ~mail is the dale of maili Date: Oct. 20 ,:WOO . NJPC~12-84 COURT FILE TO BE FILED WITH PROTHOMOTARY '~""''llii''i'''hilJ'''''"'''''%,*wB___'"""'""""",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,'"'~ " , i '1~_ri!I1-I!i0:1 ~rl!i!i'lIiIM~il!WiIj~ IBf'''''''''M1UIMl'';''.J 1'"biJ '&J11IU j ~ilml~"'" r----~. .H\' ~ ., PROOf OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAl. AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT (This proof of service MUST BE FILED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS AFTER filing the notice of appeal. Check applicable boxes) COMNlONWEALTH OF PENNSYlVANIA COUNTY OF ; $3 AFFIDAVIT: I hereby swear or eilirm that I served o a copy of the Notice of I\ppeal, Common Pleas No, , upon the District Justice designated therein on (date of service) 0 by personal service by (certified) (registered) mail, sender's receipt attached hereto, and upon the appellee, (name) , on , 19._ 0 by personal service 0 by (certified) (registered) mail, sender's receipt attached hereto. o and turthe, that I served t:16 Rule to File a Complaint accompanying the above Notioe of Appeal upon the appel/ee(sJto whom the Rule was addressed on , 19~ 0 by personal service 0 by (certified) (registered) mall, senders feceipt attached hereto. SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS DAY OF .19_ Signature of affiam - ._-~--- Signature of officiaf before wrlom affidavit was mada Tille of official My Commission expires on _ ,19_ ~r c ~ ....J ~ ~ fD ~ i ~\ ~ t:\ -f:' ~~ \-- \ c:' (') 0 c <:: ""Q'(rj m0~ z:. :1:.: r-.' ~~ 0 ~C) ~~ 2:(; -~~ ~:c..C,' t?' YC - "7 ._ :2 ~ n :-\ '~Q 'C', 1\-< . ~~\S) .~'?~ ;S .<: (...) ""'- "I. - ~ ~ ......-. - COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND 09-3-04 NOTICE OF JUDGMENTITRANSCRIPT CIVIL CASE PLAINTIFF: NAME and ADDRESS 'FuCUS. NATALIE I 40 FOXCROFT DRIVE CAMP HILL. PA 17011 L -.J Mag. Disl. No.: OJ Name; Hon. THOMAS A. PLACEY Add'"'' 104 S. SPORTING HILL RD. MECHANICSBURG. PA VS. T,leph,"" (717) 761- 8230 17050 DEFENDANT: NAME and ADDRESS !ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONST. 30 UMBERTO ST. REAR ~ CUMBERLAND. PA 17070 Docket No.: CV - 0000239 - 00 Date Filed: 7/13/00 I ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONST. 30 UMBERTO ST. REAR NEW CUMBERLAND. PA 17070 -.J THI$IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT: Judgment: FOR PI.ATN'I'TFF [iJ Judgment was entered for: (Name) 17rI(,,'1HI. NIITIIT.TR [iJ Judgment was entered against: (Name) ANDRRW !'INRI.I. (".DNCRR'!'R (".DN!'I'!' in the amount of $ 4 1>11; 00 on: (Date of Judgment) Qj?1/00 o Defendants are jointly and severally liable. o Damages will be assessed on: (Date & Time) Amount of Judgment Subject to AttachmenV Act 5 of 1996 $ Amount of Judgment $ 4.500.00 Judgment Costs $ 116.00 Interest on Judgment $ .00 Attorney Fees $ .00 Total $ 4.616.00 Post Judgment Credits $ Post Judgment Coots $ ------------ ------------ Certified Judgment Total $ o This case dismissed without prejudice. o o Levy is stayed for . days or 0 generally stayed. o Objection to levy has been filed and hearing will be held: Date: Place: Time: ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY OF JUQGMENTBY FILING A NOTICE ,... - I , OF APPEAL WITH THE PROTHONOTARY/CLERK OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, CIVIL DIY!S!ON. YOU MUST INCLUDE A COPY OF T OF UDG CRIPT FORMWlTH YOUR NOTICE OF:~PPEAL. . . I certify that this is a true and correct , '. 9-:;11-00 Date , District JUStice f the proceedln ontaining the judgment. , District Justice -3 -,~ H) C) Date My commission expires first Monday of January, AOPC 315.99 SEAL . , ~~i\li'il>M!j2fl"MI'~~;(",'-;:~f5;-'-YA:;'''~.Jk:''tt~~F;.''d''''::bd'''N'_, .~"",di-'r':,""",-'Ui.d",~"-~,A:,';'-'k~,.$W~j(J:Pl!lfI'i;j'I~l.i,@i" ~ ~,' '~!~~"'f,i"_.j!;d'wbr[i0~_;1!1J!llm9:~ ::AJil 'ii1lll Q~ ~c <i--' --...J ~ 'I ,-., ,. "~"', ~'m~~~~ -,^ ~~'_'~""~ , ."~_'"'~,~'~~_ .,,"',__, -,"<."C,"'''"'_'.~.. "_' ;:u ~\,,~ "- --., c ~;: 92Ei. :;":::::,- en ....' ,,' r:= (";' ~-" ~~ -. "<: ~ ."..,.;.;I"""'.....~,.....I ,. (:.~ C':i o 2-' H",,", !C~. ., t-=" '-',"" C) _Ji ~- ~, ~ -.....j Uv ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ I "''"j~J",; PENNeY SUPPLYNC. 1001 PAXTON ST - P.O. BOX 3331 HARRISBURG, PA 17105 (717) 236-7005 FAX: (717) 238-7312 EMAIL: psisales@redrose.net September 14, 2000 Andrew E. Snell 30 Umberto St. Rear New Cumberland, PA 17070 Dear Andy, Re: Concrete Cracking Having work with concrete I'm sure.you realize how hard it is to guarantee a crack free job. Proper joint placement and cutting of the joint is the most acceptable way to control the characteristics of the chemical reactions that fake place in the hardening of the matrix of the concrete. The joint will form a weaken plan and allow the built up stress to produce a crack in the joint. I have seen jobs that the best laid joint plans have failed in producing this result. That's one of the reasons that proper curing, fiber reinforcing and admixtures to control slump have been developed. They deal with stress and water amounts in concrete. Most of these add to the cost ofthe finished project and are eliminated by the project owner to save money. I'm not aware of to many contractors that guarantee there concrete jobs will not crack. Those that do have a action plan that they will come back to seal the crack or if possible repair the crack with patching materials available. Respectfully, PENNSY SUPPLY, INC. Q~--A \). ~~Q~ RICHARD D. HUGHE'W Director of Material Sales SERVING YOUR CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL NEEDS SINCE 1921 http://www.pennsysupply.com ~l - lll~ ,ju<-u.."""~W~1 ,. I',lJflHII .. ''.\'','. ." ,'::/ ,/ / ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTIOiN 30 Umberlo Street (Rear) NEW CUMBEALND, PA 17070 (717)774-7579 ~ IPROJP>OSAIL .- 37 ,.~,.,e: ...., fro ( Natalie Fuch.. i40 Foxcr"!~ Drive. Camp Hill PA 17011 . U20/99 Drive JOe NUMUIlt . .... ...... W:l hurtlQy .submir ,pecil:~al;ons .t\d C3limales lor; consider this propos..l for concrete "ork. Includes labor, equipment ~ m..tubls a':cordin" to .local spec.. and as noted below, Radius walk from front porch to drive"ay. Orivew"y from stre.~ to garage. All ...alk frOlll drive.....y along side of gara"a to end of: aid concrete at rear of gar"ge. ~1l t.hese a.re.." t.o b4 """"e dimension" as existina concrete. Include$ ($_ame as first quotu., 4" thi~k 28 stone b..:re, 4" thick concrete ~'th f;~.~!~W;-::M,El~ ,. -.- , contraction joints u per trade specs ias per c~4~'of clear Xure.' Seal compound. l reperly pl,aced exp",:sien joints ~~H , sealed (Sib Flexl, sa\oll1 contractie>n joints as ~ ,:1:Fade prac1:.ice. . . I Relllove debris And leave work area cban. I Permit by owner, ~f nec."sary. .~ - 3~00 psi. strengt. our di,cu#~ioni. '.. . Or1'11n,,1 contract . add fer entire racti"", add for small walk to walk rear of g4uge. . $4994~00 $200.00 $150.00 NEW TOm .$5344.00 . M~Ul-l ~-~.- dP'N:t$">;'G<l~~d4b.r~3'o~~'~f..- :$, . . '. . '".. ..... .... ....' ) '''3...qQ ----,. , . ,,~ . .,. ~ - -; ,'- -'. ',-, _ .. -- --- ," ".-.- 7 ~ . 1/ .:...-1 , ,..,."t .; , . " --oj ,. , , \M: Propose h'teby la ,,-rniari "'...tiar ~ labor';;;;:' 'c~it1;;I.h;'in '..~~ ~idl ih~"3bo~~tsDeCii'c:l..;';e rQ,"I;;~;I~~~~;':; - . , . .. .! . ..r~v. 'l'hou..nd 'l'hr.. HW\dr~ty rour lOJ1d 00/100 Dollars~~.. ...,'r..... .t......:,.,,!':'~.If,........_...~..;1. ...,...."."....m.dH....'..." .. .....O~l'... ..... A" .tU?7\.. ..... .. ''''.' '.. 'lIU-'\ .. "'/"f.vf/!1 '"7 v,'.',,. . b.J:-~SU,"o 1/3 down the d...y work staru ...!pa~O --- 1~3 dAY c.ondr"'te.p1...c....ent:"t..rts''i!'''''l~:^'.~.... .. Balance upon ccmpletiF.J. .. S~.I..fOO~ . . .. ._ . . J:; "--. tf.j1..!). /r/~ \. 'X'. :1,# .7"<; ." . ":"-':::'..__. ., ~".".., ;. ,..,....- .. .. .. ......... ... ..'" " .. ~.. ....- . ':'. /1.~' _0- ,-, ~,'. -"-~-",,,"'. "-,._~.,., , '"....H.' .'Mfc.rd...." 10 """"'0' Pl'KM..., IWr( -"""110". 01 _..."",.. ~-..,.,. 1OtClRG'" A~''''OIlUC: ' ,-,,"-" ,.. ~':'" . 'tt",'l .........."'" "'.". CO.'" ..... .... ........ .....,'~ .........~ _ ""'" ~,1" .so.p":uue-a .. , . ....." ':00"'1111I ,"...t ;0'" .._ .... _......,. at,.-,,,,",,",,, ~ _ *ft..... HiCIOtII" .... .1"1.,,1: "''I'.''. 0.... ~. o-.r ,. &an}' lb.. 'O''''UO .... ..... "........,., III""..... :J\... ...."'Illff. P". f\oIly _.'_ 0, ....01"..... ~.".Ol... 1n,,"IoftC' :"'i ,. 't ....;J' ! , , '-'j :'. "~''', , f -,..4- ,_~,.J. NQf.'"'''''~__''' ....,""taw'" oy". lI'Ao:II ~-_ ;. 30 --dl\Y.. A.r:.c:epraoce of Proposal _ The aOov. "ric... .p.cilicacions Hnrf '=Ol"dillO"S ale Hli.faclcary &net at. heteov accepl.o. You ve ,,,,I"'OIf:ltG 10 do 1"_ ",",0(1( ., ,pecil~. P:a:rm.enl ....in b. made II Ollllined .bO,:-~. .......-:H -r-- /_ '_ SMJn.lu'e /~ ~.::J3 ~ S>9".tu'. ~ "'~t< S. t>, - .f'~fa~ ~/G <. F'I. 1.1. A ~'\ .PJI ~~~ ~ I ~~ ,~. ~iWH.rt:" NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA VB. : NO. 2000 - 7396 CIVIL TERM ANDREW SNELL, tfd/b/a ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - Law (Appeal from DJ Action) : Jury Trial Demanded NOTICE TO: Andrew Snell, Vd/b/a Andrew Snell Concrete Construction YOU BA VE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Notice is served, by entering a written appearance personally or by an attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Defendant. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE TIllS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE TIIE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Cumberland County Lawyer Referral Cumberland County Bar Association 2 Liberty Avenue Carlisle, P A 17013 1-800-990-9108 i' , , " -; NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA VS. : NO. 2000 - 7396 Civil Term ANDREW SNELL, t/dlb/a, ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW : Jnry Trial Demanded COMPLAINT TO THE HONORABLE, JUDGES OF SAID COURT: AND NOW COMES, the Plaintiff, Natalie Fuchs, by and through her legal counsel, Henry F. Coyne, and files the within Complaint and avers the following in support thereof: 1. Plaintiff is Natalie Fuchs, an adult individual who resides at 40 Foxcroft Drive, Hampden Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 2. Defendant, is Andrew Snell, an adult individual who trades and does business under the name of Andrew Snell Concrete Construction with its principal place of business at 30 Umberto (rear), I New Cumberland, York County, Pennsylvania. 3. On or about April 23, 1999, Plaintiff entered into a contract for Defendant to remove a driveway and walk at Plaintiffs residence and to replace same with concrete. A true copy of the complaint is attached as Exhibit "A". 4. On or about August 19, 1999, Defendant removed the concrete walk and driveway and replaced them with concrete and concluded work on the contract on or about September 22, 1999 and was paid for said work. 5. On or about February 13, 2000, Plaintiff noticed numerous cracks in the replaced driveway and sidewalk. . L;~',~; 6. Plaintiff alleges that Defendant's work and services was defective and unworkmanlike and resulted in a breach of warranty, breach of contract and is in violation of the Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law which is incorporated herein by reference. 7. Plaintiff will have to incur at $7,500.00 to remove the defective driveway and sidewalk poured and installed by Defendant and to have the concrete work replaced and installed correctly. A true copy of estimate of corrective work is attached hereto as Exhibit "Boo. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays this Honorable Court to find in favor of Plaintiff and against Defendant and to award Plaintiff damages in the amount of $7,100.00, plus counsel fees, court costs, and interest and all other such damages which this Court deems appropriate pursuant to 73 P .S. 201-8 et se. the Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practice and Consumer Protection Law. Respectfully submitted: Dated: ~ t) Mf91J-'f!nJ- COYNE & COYNE, P.C. BY~ 3901 Market Street Camp Hill, PA 17011-4227 (717) 737-0464 Pa. Supreme Ct. No. 06250 Attorneys for Plaintiff ~~ :. VERlFICATION The facts set forth in the foregoing are true and correct to the best of the UDd.....igJU'fi.s knowledge. information and beIief and are verified subject to the penalties for unsworn falsification to authorities under 18 Pa. C.S.A. ~4904. Dated: 7- (j TV eM- t7e) _..~__J. _'",,~.~.'~- ::LJHa~:,.liltJJ~;f-~ ., "'''C<'''''''~,'r ";;;~".:,,~:':'~,r:. ~. ~ "",, '"'" l~-~' / ,~i~~.~.;;,j~"IJ~~}Y .,..;. .:,> . .. . ANDREW SNEll ,_ 'C'";~ CONCRETE CONSTRUCTfOIN '.~ 30 Umberto Street (Rear) / NEW CUMBERLND, PA 17070 ~" L ill .. ] J1\;,jl.: ' '" 1Si':-' .~ ~1" P_O" No /fJ~ !PROPOSAl .;! 37 (717) 774-7579 ~Io4ONI! "." TO Natalie Fuchs #40 Foxcraft. Drive Camp Hill PA 17011 / 737-7886 Joe HAM!! J LOCATION <;20/99 uch: lO fOKcraft. Drive lllIlp Hill Joe NUMB!" .>Of"""'" WI: hllmQy $Ubmj( 5pecif:c,UOons and eslimale5 10f: Co~sider this proposal for eoncrete work. Includes labor, equipment , mat~ria1. a~cording to .loaa.~ specs and. "" noted. !:lelew, Ra.dius walle frOlll front poreh to driveway. fl Driveway from :street ~o garage. // All walk from driveway along side of garage t.o end o! oia eoncrete 'at rear of g",age. All t.hese areas t.o be same dimensions as existing eonerete_ Indudes (s_ame aoS fir",t quote]., 4" thi~k 28 stone baoSe, 4" thick concrete - 3'p00 psi. strengt w' '. .. " contraction joints aoS per trade specs iu per our eli.cu.sio,,;. cb'..:t' ' of" cl..ar lCuu.' Seal compound, roperly p,lAced el<pension joint.s ~A,,*"a & seded (Sika Flexl, sawn contraction joint.s as per " ~ - :t:rade pract.iee. - - Rell\ove debri" and leave work, area clean. Perlllit by owner, if nece",sary. Oriqinal contract . add for entire rad.ius wdlc ~ld for ",mall wal~ to rear of garage $49~4 ~ 00 $2~0.00 $150.00 NEW TOTAL S5344.00 M...i..yu A'J - \ d / -' _) ) ,.'..L,qS ---I V"-'<.-pc.- ..,.w"" .s)~ G~~~s{4hF~ 3 o....c-ev;[---PI-- ' - '-. - .-. 0/- ~'3'"95' \\e Propose heteby to l\:,ni:s11 J'l'lau,rial Md labot _ CO"innlet. in ac;::orcsancR wilh fh(!- 3bo"<<) Sge.:d'<'1l.iIn:c. tor I"" ~1II1'ltl. ._i'iv. Thou.and 'rh.r~e Hundr!,d Po:t.V iour _snd 00/100 Dollars . "c1'"h,,:o I' ~~:~.. J _.."",....,..."'...m..,....,."_" ~A..A . C~t.v"iJ; 1i{70 -- ~:>>SH,eo 1/3 down the day work starts ..1US~O --- 1'l3 day conc.et:e placement staru ~""P, Balance upon ccmpleti1'!'j Sl..:/.8.4~~ --'-. t1J1.D/tt"7,;). ,-<X'~d .f.II "':"1"'41 1.1 ;UotI~MCJ 10 be- .. ~ .All ...otll 10 Dt . ut .. I"Of...lo.... ....,<111"1 .-.co.dl"~ fO M~ pt.a'cn. ~ .n.,.-tlO" 0' d.....l.... frolft au.,.... so,clf'.c... li\,"~ '''_'''9- ".". eo.,~ -..011 tI.- ..~ nN'f \I!X'ft ....III....~..., ""'lIltllcornc.lt\ ..~.." .:"...gc. 001..., 10'" ..~ I,.. _........ All ~'''.'''''''l. CII,",~ IICICM lIlh..... 'efO'l('I'"'' 'i' ,I"I;,,!O' 1.I0\l'ano OUl C'O"tfot. 0- 10 Catfy flf.. to'''UlO ,..~...low "~~ L"I'\l'AtI'1\'. :'1'( ......~uu .... t\llll' _..0 0)1' .....01_.'.. ~1I."''';on 1"""""(' . 9'''1 ~_. ..-.. AV.IlOIlUG' ~"DW~ . , NOlI.' Till. ~.,.a _..._ """"'n'~'" Iit'f II.... ~ K=~-- 30 lb,.,~. At;.c-ept3nce of Proposal _ The aoov. prilOU. sp.CiIic-.,ion, Hnt1 c:ondiUo", ate S-.1:tisfactory a..nC ate heteoy 3ccepted. You .are J\I(horl:eO to do the wcri(, ,n 51'ecille<1. PaYlNfnt .....ill be mlJ,de as outlined abov~. S~n"ll,I'. ~ '7. .;p / , Siqnl&tu'. ~ '1'~r'- Y/G ~-- S",', p.,.. 6 L I .f'~ a~ - '~'-).~ E"'J. 1/'/1 ~~ - , ~ r.~ 'wit!"""' ~J _ i_ ~~:-, 'NCRETE 43 Cumberland Drive · Mechanicsburg, J:'ennsylvania 17055 T [ " ." Phone: (717) 697-3878 ..I...3VELING OF CENTRAL PA, INC. (800) 822-8880 ."'";~~f#- "- . . , . ""~:~ ~}it9 .,~ .":~~{, .-, .;i';4i!,: WEPtfMPITUPI I DRIVEWAYS · SIDEWALKS · STEPS · PATIOS · APRONS. GARAGES · ANY CONCRETE SLAB I .... Phone: (H) 7:?7 - 7 <f{~ Co . 0N) .Dare" 7 -/:2. -~OOO Work Location:". "'5"-/11e "..;- ''''''''.- .," .",," Salesperson: Water Available: Invoice No.: -')i.l.' Date Accepted: . Signature: X " Electricity. Available: Truck Access: P.O. No.: "* ~ _ ...^" d!> -.:7J.,I. " ". - FI e)/ J Drain Location? Crew: Buried Electric? Date: Truck No.: Start: Finish: JOB SKETCH # Hours: On Sepeta.Je. s}..eef. Paid: Subtotal , . \ Safes Tax ...e-- TOTAL '60 ,IX) 2 'i.. /) fJ)' PA.YMENT CUE UPON COMPlETJON. NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR SiRESS CRACKS. t;,.,.............. "-T':"u . "k' f"-1:,."1 g..o':"KtW PRli''t:IR'E:RGtmm.- ONE YEAR GUARANTEE ON LEVEUNG WORK FROM DATE OF COMPLETION. WE APPRECIATE YOUR BUSINESS. THANK YOU.! . m ti .-. ,.~^': :',-;~" . Go..rwp SAW c.u.j. Join./- 1-/t:re. . 0"1 :J ~;/ ~~ . .. V-l A~;k1.J. /f fi'pW"lf1iofl WE PUMP IT UP! . #~ Porr.h . . -~RepJCALe.,.c,,~. DrI:V~" .o....J J sedJev, .J:...s;J..k.XI.lk . - Rerno-,;e exis.J.i'j G.nc~k. ~ ~ev- J.k,.J C<iU~. . ~Provik6'lo.fCornpa.ck.d. 2. b ..sJone "__'" - P......J.dowl-.Wire. mesh .Reintorcemenl.. ... . ..._.. · PJa.c.e.. Yi A5fbJ./. ExfJan5ion Jo/rrl:s UM. Fi J.er) .Q.s .6hown . on ,sJ:ekk. · Pou.r (!JJld finish S"J /.faoo fJ6i ConCl'ej.~ · Ap/y, Cure -n-.sea.J Ccm~ OI'Ian~l:eu.._... -TJ..e_Con.JrcLJ,,;n ..J..5-bJiJLhe.-1l~ D~f/ cJJe~.Jk~~.. __Co r>crek.~(.,4.,:de":L~he._..loinl.sj.)iJL.ke....sALI..J_j.4f . . . ..c..r. cd ji .f.1t;n:J 4 '.11 l.z,jo .'l.-1',ae5_Je4/ur:, ..__ -The. .gjr:d:-bf g,,-~ 0.+ .i-Ae._skeL..,.dI k..J:O-v.~~'--- . r ~rmwo.rk._o..oLRe;kd_af.kr:llC1~_4.~.k.-,-- .. '~/. JOh..+~e.~ ~ ~r- .He..._.,. _:fur.l"1,s c..r:e .Re./I'J(;ved.,wlJI C<.k,C>~~G:l"c..~ s;;). if Do no+ fl'l""b=, _ hew D6 ve""'j .J.o 5I'1=+h./' H.e. e )/15~"" j . is +c, S-V'loo+L E\(\\{Y' . - --- . , . ~ ~I ~'- I',. h <till; - ~":<l ' . . .' CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Henry F. Coyne, Esquire, of Coyne & Coyne, P.C., hereby certify that true copy of the Complaint was served this date upon the below-referenced individuals at the below listed address by way of Certified Mail (return Receipt Requested) First class mail, postage prepaid: Mr. Andrew Snell Andrew Snell Concrete Construction 30 Umberto Street (rear) New Cumberland, P A 17070 Dated: '2- () 11/ &. r- t"J4) COYNE & COYNE, P.C. M~~<p~ Henry F. Coyne, E uire / 3901 Market Street Camp Hill, PA 17011-4227 (717) 737-0464 ~ - "0 _=...., ~~:li.Ulli.l~i1<0.iil-~iWJli[~,k:;w~.;<<.<.);lt'''''n!i''~in"~h''.i!~.gm!.',;,,lcj''m"-;'"&":ki~j;'ii:'?Z"'<liJ,1$Mlg-"jjjj,~&M"""-"-wr.""":IDliiii!li[I!~Jll.__~~>>i "'~'~-~1il't]jjl , . "., ~ =- , ~~"' I. ", .,~_ ' "' ,J. ,-~~~~ -~ C) ~ -0i:l~ rnj ~"'. tT:i -< c:: c- ~2 z :< "Lllillll6l'il-n -Y-' C) c:) -" ("') :-",-) CC) _.----:;' ."-, -'" "" '.:l :2:~,~~ > :D -< - II f.,i 'I t:1 ~I ~I ! ,! ii ii I! I I i I I ~ " j.-, --l'.j "., - , ~ ...... ,-, ~ "_' '-_'~", 'i- ,'_","~', ~'I;;; .' .c,; ,.." ~,:.-;;-~~>,.',,;' _',_,__,_" "'.-- 'i'.".-,,"' ':'-"', ,,-;;.,'.., "-,,' ;;;;-. NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff vs. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : NO. 200-7396 CIVIL Term ANDREW SNELL, T.D.B.A ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION, Defendant. : CIVIL ACTION - LAW : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 29th day of October, 2001, inconsideration ofa conflict which exists for arbitrator James D. Hughes, Esquire, and in further consideration of Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire, agreeing to serve as an arbitrator in the above-captioned matter, it is hereby ordered that James D. Hughes, Esquire, is removed and Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire, is appointed as arbitrator in the above-captioned matter. The arbitrators for the above-captioned matter will meet for the purpose of their appointment on Monday, October 29,2001 at 1:00 p.m. in the Law Offices of Costopoulos, Foster & Fields, 831 Market Street, Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043. By the Court, 11>>7"2 4/f~ Date: (Ja.:29 ,2001 co: Leslie M. Fields, Esquire Board of Arbitrators TRUe'COPY FROM RECORD In T estimollY wller60i, I here Illlto set my llallO alld t~said Court at Carlisle. Pa. This aY~f~ r;;.~~~ ~' . - .. '/)/lA: 7' "'-J thollotary "--- -f ,., or' J;,~ 1-4<!l \~ PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS AND EXPERIENCE STEPHEN M. YINGST. P.E. Areas of Expertise Mr. Y'mgst is a graduate engineer and Registered Professional Engineer in the State of Pennsylvania. He has also completed all of the course requirements far a Master in Engineering degree from Pennsylvania State University, needing only the completion of his thesis for graduation. As President of Criteriznn-Yingst Engineers, he is responsible for the development and management of the firm. He is also actively involved in serving client needs for building and property evaluations, investigative engineering, builder quality audits, environmental assessments and design assistance. Steve has completed over 3000 residential and commercial property evaluations, a building quality audit for a residential contractor of more than 100 homes per year, numerous structural damage insurance investigations, and various Phase I brviromnental Assessments for Mellon Bank, Pennsylvania National Bank, Dauphin Deposit, the Resolution Trust Corporation and others. In addition, Steve has testified as an expert witness in numerous litigation matters in Allegheny, Cumberland, Dauphin, Lebanon and Jtmiata counties. Qualifications Steve has attended initial and yearly continuing education programs with Criterium Engineers, a national firm which franchises building evaluation services. Steve currently operates two franchises in central and western Pennsylvania Before establishing his ownfinn in 1990, Steve held several design and management positions with AMP, Incorporated, the world's largest electrical interconnection device . manufacturer. His last position there was as Project Manager aver the development of various electro-mechanical devices. In this position, he directed and reviewed both mechanical and electrical engineering disciplines and peiformed general project management responsibilities. Steve has also been involved with various phases if residential and light commercial construction over the past fifieen years. This experience has included residential home construction, major remodeling projects and electrical contract work with area building firms. f,-4 11if~~!{')/// :~;r-)~;,;,/ .. . '-.', ./". ,;/ ., >,'-' 'u _.,:,,\/ ._~, . . " , , . . He i~ ,,!,me.mber of tm. National Society of p'rofessionaIEngineers, the Pennsylvarzia Society ojProjesSianal Enineers, the ProfeSSional Engineers in Private ~ PTactice; a PeTU/S)'lvania Septage Management Association certified septic inspector, the National Association of Building Inspect/on Engineers, aBuilding Officials and Code Administrators International member, and several local Realtor Boards. Steve has been approved as an instructor for Pennsylvania RealtDr continuing education courses and gives presentations to real estate, home buyer, appraiser, and otmr groups on building technology. Educrdion Steve received his Bachelor of Science degree in Electrical Engineering Technology from Pennsylvania State University in 1978. He received various academic awards in completing his studies with a perfect 4.0 grade point average. He has also completed 33 credits in the school's Moster of Engineering program, maintaining a 3.8 average. ''''_-''''1 :~;' '" ". ...,.--; ., \" ""'. tJ~ " '{',:.'t , >.;-".- . ~,:~...J.~ h , -~~! WE PdMP/TUpJjif1j, . . ".~- ......:. ~:....' -'. ......r~,~r;;.; ",:T~~; ..._~ . ..' '^~.'~ . ;.1RIVEWAYS · SIDEWALKS · STEPS · PATIOS · APRONS. GARAGES · AN.Y CONCRETE SLAB I ..~. .,. / Phone: (H) 7.Q7-7"f(-({t, 'rN'J pafi:' 7-/2.-~0a0' PAYMENT DUI! UPON COMPLETION. - NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR SiRESS CRACKS. Q'''uo -,:..... ".T~u "t'!:, tGtb "ll 'j'"o?XW PRg~Ur&RG'~I\?tJ." . ONE YEAR GUARANTE! ON Lf'IaING WOAKFROM DATE OF COMPLETlON. WE APPRECIATE YOUR BUSINESS. THANK YOU'! '- ,.;c'RETE . 43 Cumberland Drive · Mechanicsburg, ~ennsylvania 17055 T ~. . ." Phone: (717) 697-3878 . .L3VELING OF CENTRAL PA, INC. (800) 822-8880 Sold To: l I I J' r I . I\JCA. ie... It: r UC.h5 l-JD Foxc.rot+ Co. Work Location:" 5Cll11e . .-. .' ." Salesperson: Invoice No.: # Water Available: Date Accepted: . Signaiure: X . Electricity. Available: Truck Access: P.O. No~ Special Instructions: .~ '* wI'II lA~ ,. Truck No.: Drain LccatIon? .~ Date: Crew: Buried 8ectric? . i Finish: Start '<<-'1' JOB SKETCH . # Hours: '''''''_',1: .. . ;5epet'r.l..Je. 61- ee.J. , SublglaJ .. On Paid: Sales 1lIx '. ~/0> TOTAL fr'i. II !S I' .~, _"~~,4> ?:';.:~:":-_,,f/'''', , , i f, ~ . ...;.'"" "-.-,, . :d:._. -~~ {-._t.-.x~;,. '~';~p .....~'\ .., , \ .J, ~~.: ~- .~ '.... .,V' ':.. CO , ,'" ~~!it::~:~~{.:~:tg:j::~L~,_:' '- ~~rf~<?::~~: ~:,)'.-;~ ":-.';:. "-rJ:j"t:!!!!~.':,; WE PUMP IT UP! - - "i-'"''-''~.i~':':''\I'lJ/~'f''''\:-''''' ," ;':;Jr-' i"li',.,.l ;'\:'::,J""'~~;l""'; ,;, " -'~?"'Iti'- - '~~~,~)F::":~'~"f,'~~7-F~;~':"; . ;-~,'~ : ~lt", ~'i'''-- "; 4'",,,,,;:.-;; - '~-(~ ~ ':'. .}.'f~~':.' ,-1,,-" '~~~~f;'." '.- ..... > . ,-,.,~*,~if(..,.:, ~ " 'i~~~;~:::~:~'~~- '~~ -:' ,! .. ..,~~:"h) Go.rwy '. '. . ..~iSAW M Join} ... 1-/t:re.. #~. ~ Po~t. . . --~R1JOil,_Co.xreJe - Dr.iv04J"1. _Q,nt!.J sech~.J_.$';'/<:IcXt.Jk . - · Rerno~ e.xi.5.Ji'j C1ncrr:k. a.rd. ~e..r Ik...; cuu~. _:. '!..Provik G11.o+ .Compa.ck.d 2. b .:s.J.one. ........ .... · P..... -+ .down. wi rt! PJesh ."ReJ'"forcerunl,. ....... _ _ · Plo.ce.. Yi As/loll- ~jJan$iOn .10/1'11-:5 6Iof'FiJ,~) -..~ ...6),ol.Un . on ,sJ:.e-k,i.. . · Pour cmd finjs~ 5'laf' /.faoo p,6i Ccnc'''el<:. · ApI} ~re - n - ~J Col11jbwri onCoI'1~k......: __.:.. '. . .TJ,e~Con.J.roL.Jo"n..J..5-/JJiJLk-1~DlXp;/ <:<tJeJk.-.:... ~ r: I I .J /' - " 1 '11 b " . ....f. ~_....Q n.c.eft:.-b.().r-delld._ .~_.Jo,n ';$JUJJJ_e..-S4tt..J_Ckl. '.' '.- 'el.j' , ~. 1/ Y, i ..,. _, I" '. .---~ (!J.d i loral ~ ... _.l,__TtJ -,l-.J.rr:Jt.e5...J:J.4pt!f':,____ . .7},~AIrd:kf' g/d. a.f.IJ,'-"'skeLu.ilLk~v.r~cL . -L~r1J!tuo.f'"lc_o.nd_Re;;kd-cIkr..lka~-~~.k...... .. .~. lOll .J~ J.~o1J"er- .J.J,,!~'..__,. , .' /' _..:/i;r./I'l~ c:.....e -Re/'1?tJvU,wiJl o..kC)fl'l:'4J.(;~~ .s:i of. Do "0+ m",kc _ hew Dr' ~e-j J.o S1'100fh;- Ht:. e )(IS+,'n j . I:' .).0 Sv><"o.J.}. ..' . . - Yd.' A~pkJ.f./f . EI'pW'ti,'on '. 8(\\BC( .---- -" .---.- - =-~,'-.~<::" .::;.-..'~'~_o: "'-.;;"".~ - .- - ... : ".~.;~}. ;:-~~~:t";~~7->f~ ;~~~ :~"--i:~.-~,~ "', " , "--" " " -... . -.' '. "-." .' , - ., - - "... . . .... k"" . .....~".;~~i~~'J~z'l~~~~!j~?,,~~;~iiJ.~~~]~~~fffi.~;~til. . .."-f;~'! 6O-B:l5321 313 38334968 f q DATE ?3 / f2 r I , 6~~~~~~E a~ ~ 1$3,5'(0,00 1\1- -U A,1 ',tAA? 1---YI1A-l.R ~hftl.)o.(;~~~~j]OllARsm=-= o Dauphin Deposit Bank ~ U and Trust Company ~14 I ~rg,PAt7105-296t ME.ol)rlVel.v~f~MA!''''''''OL ~ _ .. 1:031.:10 831,1: 383:1"'I.'1g,8I1' '1'1 1.1,70...006l0:lSg,000,,' ..... _:-V ~RV.l'''''''' NATALIA FUCHS 4.87 40 FOX. CROFT DR. PH. 717.737-7886' CAMP Hill, PA 17011 1470 .. . . . ;,ti~fl~"ii!rtt~i~f#f~4~~~{~f~~ , ! ':! , < ~'-.;:. .... ~~~,~t\~t~'~:j~~j~~~~uz:r~~f:i 6O-B:lS321 313 38334968 8' ~~ ,<} "7 PAYTOTHE~ ~ 1$/7otjOO , O~'5L ~f" ",,' 0 , l~'l..' 0"'Mk~ ~. 70llARSm=-,:: ! ' '/co 0. Dauphin Deposit Bank U and Trust Company ~ MEMO~"^1"-r'AA~~':17~j eX , ~ 1:031.300831,.1 383:1"'I.'1g,Bu' '1'1 1.1.72...00001.781,00," NATALIA FUCHS 4.87 40 FOX CROFf DR. PH. 717.737.7886 CAMP Hill. PA 17011 1472 DATE '\-~;~~:~:i~' . "....'sro~. .- -_.- -,_. --..,..,. .,- ..... ~_. ,-,.,.., ,._-.......,.-,..,~..,. 7"" -._.--- . .,--..-.... ._,. ',.-,:.."."7..... ~..<"7"<.-:'-"'..,~""'..........-,":'..:..'_.,:::~iZ.':"'f. . - -. . '..- , ~~~~~~~~~,~J~l~~;~~I~~~:~~~~l~~~l~'itf~J~~l%".~~jfut0~Ett~B~i~t~:)?~~~~,~t~!:?~:~~~r~--:{~; .'-' ',:. ;..,.\'-.--,-'., -- 0'.,' -. ~" -;',_", ~- -"< . p,rV """""""'~';;-;;-~"'7~;;;;;;~{",,,;'iit,{,;.; .;;C'd"?':0",'~j"".'I'f.;o"",A.';;i;";;'i,/.M(?~1lliiIiiliI~~~ hlG EERS CENTRAL PA: 421 W. CHOCOLATE AVENUE HERSHEY, PA 17033 TEL 717 533-3346 1800231-3346 (PAl FAX 717533-3376 WESTERN PA: 322 FAWCETT CHURCH ROAD BRIDGEVILLE, PA 15017 TEL 1800231-3346 (PAl FAX 717533-3376 January 5, 2001 D ~@~DW~...u..i ,II Ii. fEB J 2 2001 " ! 10 Natalie Fuchs 40 Foxcroft Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011 RE: Partial Inspection - October 26, 2000 40 Foxcroft Drive Camp Hill, P A Job No. 100-0578 Dear Ms. Fuchs: INTRODUCTION At your request, an inspection of the above property was performed on October 26, 2000. The report that follows has been prepared based on that inspection. The purpose of the inspection and this report' was to evaluate the concrete driveway and walkways at the above residence. This inspection was performed by and report written by Stephen M. Yingst, P .E. As you requested, this evaluation is limited in scope, focusing on the concrete driveway and walkway only. This inspection report is limited to observations made from visuiU evidence. No destructive or invasive testing was performed. For your reference while reading the report that follows, the following definitions may be helpful: Excellent - Component or system is in "as new" condition requiring no rehabilitation and should perform in accordance with expected performance. Good - Component or system is sound and performing its function, although it may show signs of normal wear and tear. Some minor rehabilitation work. may be required. , j BUiLDING DIAGNOSTICS INSPECTIONS ANAL VSIS MAINTENANCE PLANNING DESIGN P-s- // '-..'1 /.l-- @JLJj~:~~~'::~~":tt"-'."" ! Fair - Component or system falls into one or more of the following categories: a) Evidence of previous repairs not in compliance with commonly accepted LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERS o ,~ , "~. ;MtJI:! . ~.,,' practice, b) Workmanship not in compliance with commonly accepted standards, c) Component or system is obsolete, d) Component or system approaching end of expected performance. Repair or replacement is required to prevent further deterioration or to prolong expected life. Poor - Component or system has either failed or cannot be relied upon to continue performing its original function as a result of having exceeded its expected performance, excessive deferred maintenance, or state of disrepair. Present condition could contribute to or cause the deterioration of other adjoining elements or systems. Repair or replacement is required. All ratings are determined by comparison to other buildings of similar age and construction type. Further, some details of workmanship and materials will be examined more closely in higher quality homes where such details of workmanship and materials typically become more relevant. This inspection and report have been conducted in compliance with the standards of practice of the National Academy of Building Inspection Engineers. DESCRIPTION This home is a single-family residence with an attached garage at the left side. The focus of the inspection was the concrete driveway measuring approximately 16 feet wide x 48 feet long off the front of the garage, a concrete sidewalk at the left side of the garage and a stamped concrete sidewalk between the driveway and front porch. You reported that a previous concrete driveway was removed and replaced during the summer of 1999 . You further reported that the concrete for the new driveway was poured on August 19, 1999. You provided a copy of the original proposal from Andrew Snell Concrete Construction dated April 20, I 99?, regarding repair work. You indicated that this was the contractor that removed the existing driveway and installed the new driveway. The proposal also indicated that the concrete sidewalk. to the left garage door and continuing to the left rear of the home, would be removed and replaced. The proposal further indicated that a curved walk. from the front porch to the driveway would be installed. You also provided a more recent quote from A-I Concrete Leveling ofCentra1 PA, Inc. dated July 12, 2000. This proposal was to remove the new concrete driveway and replace it. Finally you provided copies of excerpts from The (Harrisburg) Patriot News newspaper from Thursday August 19 to Sunday August 22, 1999 regarding weather conditions during that period. For purposes of this report, all directions (left, right, rear, etc.) are taken from the viewpoint of an observer standing in front of the building and facing it. CRITE.RIUM-YlNGST ENGINEERS 2 INSPEcnON FINDINGS During my site inspection on October 26, 2000, you indicated that you noticed surface hairline cracks in the driveway during the first month after pouring. You also reported that you first ~ ~-~.:j? ,,--;'r ~ noticed larger cracks in two of the slabs in February of 2000. You atso reported that the driveway was not used for vehicular traffic for at least five weeks after pouring as your personal car was stored at the neighbor's home across the street. You reported that the concrete was not covered or otherwise protected the day it was placed. You did recall that an unidentified sealer C'Kure & Seal compound" was specified in the Andrew Snell proposal) was applied to the surface of the driveway approximately 24 hours after the concrete was placed. A review of weather conditions from The Patriot News newspaper articles reveals the following: HIGH LOW DATE TEMP. TEMP. PRECIPITATION 8/19/00 (Th) 850P 650F 0.0" 8/20/00 (Fri) 74 71 trace 8/21/00 (Sat) 71 62 0.65" During my site visit, the concrete surfaces were visually inspected. Six small test pits were also dug along the driveway as shown on the attached sketqh. These pits were dug to the bottom of the stone base below the driveway. The following deficiencies were noted in the concrete finish and with respect to the Andrew Snell Concrete Construction proposal of April 20, 1999 (the proposal): . The thickness of the concrete and stone base observed in the test pit areas was inadequate. The following table summarizes the thickness of the stone and concrete in the six test pit areas. Based on the proposal, the stone thickness should have been at least four inches thick with a minimum of four inches of concrete. Photographs 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 show mea~ements of the slab and stone in test pits 1 through 5 respectively. Test Pit No. .Stone Base Thickness Concrete Slab Thickness 1 2 3 4 5 6 1"- 2" 1" 1-112"- 2" 3" 1" 1".. 2" 4"- $" 5"- 6" 5"- 6" 5"- 6" 3".4" 3"-4" . The stone base was specified to be 2Bstone in the proposal. This size of stone (2B) i~ nonnally used under concrete slabs because it is a fairly clean stone (little dirt or dust/fine stone mixed in) and is nominally 3/4" in size to allow drainage below the slab. Based on samples pulled from under the concrete slab, 2A modified stone was instaIIed by the contractor. The 2A stone varies in size from dust to approximately 1/2" and may have some soil mixed in. The 2A modified stone is normaIly used where compaction of the material is desired and it does not provide good drainage. CRITF.RIUM- YINGST ENGINEERS 3 o @ .--.................0:;-... --.A ..............-...."-C.t" ~." '-J.i"..L..II :'ilfp" "-,'.. "~ "', ' ' t:;>!' ,. "" Improper expansion joint material was used between the concrete slabs. As photograph 6 shows, the expansion material has deteriorated and is falling apart. Following my site visit, I reviewed information from the W. R. Meadows Co., who supplies this type of expansion joint material. The material used on this job is a fiberboard material that is not normally recommended for exterior use unless the expansion joint material is recessed 1/2" below the concrete surface and a joint sealant is installed over the expansion joint to prevent water entry and deterioration. The existing fiberboard joints were not recessed and sealed and has deteriorated badly as a result. . A large crack has appeared in the right side concrete slab adjacent to the front street. This can be seen in photograph 7. The crack is approximately 1/8 inch in width with several areas that have opened up from 1/4 inch to 1/2 inch and where concrete along the crack edge has broken loose. This crack continues into the adjacent sllib to the rear as can be seen in the photograph. . Photograph 8 shows hairline cracks throughout the concrete surface. This photograph was taken in the third slab toward the street from the garage on the right side. These cracks are "plastic shrinkage cracks" which are caused by the rapid loss of water from the surface of the concrete as it dries before the concrete has properly set. . A gray and white striped appearance has occurred primarily on three of the concrete slabs at the right side of the driveway. This can be seen in photograph 9. A close-up of this can be seen in photograph 10. . Photograph 11 shows a random crack through the first and second slab in front of the garage on the left side. This crack is approximately 1/8 inch in width with areas where double cracks have developed, and pieces of concrete up to 3/4 inch wide are ready to break from the surface or have already broken out. The crack extends completely through the slab. The crack almost parallels the main front to rear expansion joint, which was installed in the slab. It is my opinion that this crack is the result of settlement due to inadequate sub-base material. . The curved, stamped, concrete sidewalk from the driveway to the front porch is shown in photograph 12. The close-up of this walkway shows that the saw-cut control joints placed in the stamped concrete were not properly sealed as specified in the proposal. Based on the Snell proposal, the joints should have been sealed with Sika Flex sealant. . At the left front corner of the garage, the sidewalk makes a 900 turn to the rear as shown in photograph 14. The close-up of the inside comer of this sidewalk shows that a crack has developed at the inside comer. In addition, the control joint has cracked through in the remaining portion of the joint. This area should have had an expansion joint to allow the two sidewalk sections to move independently. Without the expansion joint, cracking of the surface at the inside corner has occurred as was to be expected. ., ,. CRITERlUM-YINGST ENGINEERS 4 ~ , Un.IU'.l-.l'UK~l'1~~ ' .~ -........ ..~ rf.i>i7~ "'iW-~ CONCLUSIONS Based on the visible evidence available, it is my opinion that the concrete driveway slab at the front of the home is in poor condition and below normal workmanship standards. This is the result of improper installation. In addition the work does not meet the specifications outlined in the April 20, 1999 proposal from Andrew Snell Concrete Construction. Specific deficiencies include: . · Improper use of expansion joint material which has deteriorated and should be replaced. . Inadequate stone sub-base material (less than four inches thick). . Use of different (improper) stone material for sub-base (2A stone was used in place of 2B stone as specified). · Inadequate concrete thickness in some areas including test pits 5 and 6 (less than four inches). . Unsealed control joints which were cut into the concrete walk. Furthermore, it is my opinion that the plastic shrinkage cracks in the surface of the concrete are the result of improper curing conditions due to the high temperatures at the time of the pour, and the lack of proper protection of the concrete surface. Specifically, the concrete surface cured too quickly without allowing the main portion of the concrete to set and bleed water to escape in a normal curing process. As a result the amount of cracks in the driveway slabs are more than normal and the construction quality is below typical workmanship standards. In addition, it is my opinion that the cracks that penetrate the entire slab thickness are the result of inadequate sub-base material and resulting settlement. Finally, the crack in the sidewalk surface at the left front of the garage is the result of a missing expansion joint in this area. To properly correct these conditions, the entire concrete driveway slab and a portion of the left side sidewalk should be removed, proper stone sub-base installed, and new concrete placed. You also requested that I review the proposal provided by A-I Concrete Leveling of Central PA., Inc. to do the repair work. This proposal is generally in line with the work I would recommend. Key improvements over the Snell contract are: . Six inches of2B stone sub-base. --. The use of wire reinforcing mesh in this concrete. . Asphalt expansion joints instead of fiber joints. . Five inches of concrete. . 4,000 psi concrete versus 3,500 psi in the original proposal. Most of the A-I Concrete Leveling of Central PA., Inc. propOsal indicates that all of the driveway will be replaced. However, there is an.asterisked item on page one which indicates that only five sections of the driveway (the cracked sections only) will be replaced. This should be clarified prior to performing the work. I recommend that all of the driveway be removed so that CRITERIUM-YINGST ENGINF.ERS 5 ~ @ :) . - '- . -">c" '_ _"" .'''' a proper sub-base be installed. As such, all sections; and not just five of the sections, should be " removed and replaced. " " , , -~ ~-~.@;J. . Thank you again for the opportunity to be of service, and please call if you have any questions. Sincerely, Stephen M Yingst, P.E. CRlTERillM_ YINGST ENGINEERS SMY/avf Enclosure CRITERIUM-YINGST ENGINEERS 6 @ ,I,'"' ,~, ~''Illli!IlI~,-h~ .\0, NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 2000.7396 CIVIL TERM vs. ANDREW SNELL, tld/b/a ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION, Defendant CIVIL ACTION. LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ANSWER TO COMPLAINT NOW COMES ANDREW SNELL, Defendant above, and answers the Complaint as follows: 1. Admitted. 2. Admitted. 3. Admitted. 4. Admitted. 5. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of averment in Paragraph 5, and said averment is denied. Strict proof is demanded at trial. 6. Denied. By way of further answer, at all relevant time Defendant performed work in a good and workmanlike manner. By way of still further answer, the balance of the averments in Paragraph 6 are conclusions of law to which no answer is required. 7. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without information sufficient to form a belief as tothe truth of averment in Paragraph 7, and said averment is denied. Strict proof is demanded at trial. .j.iJ L Andrew E. Snell Andrew Snell Concrete Construction 30 Umberto Street New Cumberland, PA 17070 \" II Ii Ii " ;1 I II II " , Ii -'-",." ",- ,-,' l.. ", , VERIFICA TION I, the undersigned, hereby verify that the statements made herein are true and correct. 1 understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. , 4904, "''''09 to ""'W,"O faj'''oatioo to autho;~ /.~ , Date: 1J.//1160 ~. ,-,,'.,d' - 1,,,_--- ,~~'_ _.~_V'" ~~~!~ '" NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 2000 - 7396 CIVIL TERM vs. ANDREW SNELL, t1d/b/a ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION, CIVIL ACTION - LAW Defendant JURY TRIAL DEMANDED CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND now, this if fA day of \) roc em ,b{' 0- ,2000, I,Andrew Snell, hereby certify that I served the within Answer to Complaint this day by depositing same in the United States Mail, First Class, Postage Prepaid, in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, addressed to: Henry F. Coyne. Esquire 3901 Market Street Camp Hill, PA 17011-4227 iLJ'" r ..A~ L--u .-/ Andrew E. Snell Andrew Snell Concrete Construction 30 Umberto Street New Cumberland, PA 17070 )Til~'v^" '" ,"4-P,c ,", ," _ ~__,,~,~~_~_ ~, ''''" ~-",.k& ~ "& ~- ~;;;'~.~lli) C, Y,'_>_ '" ~"-" >~ < ,^'-~' ~-- -" .,- ~ ' W~ .'~"" " ~ ,--~--, --,,- ,>,~ . " ;'"""""""" ~ --'I .; (") (.:~ i";1 c: <::> ?' C:J '"0 tK7 ""' -,- sprr: C"") iP:l ;:r, ZC;:' ~,S'-Z~~:; 05, ~2: ....;:,.:... ~C',) -'0 ::-::i~ ~() "'rr ;:~?I:~; - ~C' r:? (j {:n )>c 2:' ;.n 'j;! :< ::u 0 -< " - '~~~.ij'o- NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA v. No. 200-7396 Civil Term ANDREW SNELL, tJd/b/a ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION, CIVIL ACTION-LAW Defendant JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ORDRR AND NOW, this /7 rtv day of (YCc6 ~ ,2001, Murrel R. Walters, III, Esquire is hereby appointed to replace Mary Kollas-Kennedy, Esquire as an arbitrator in the above matter. BY THE COURT: Distribution: G~ Leslie M. Fields, Esquire Murrel R. Walters, III, Esquire Henry F. Coyne, Esquire Mr. Andrew Snell fRUE COPY FROM RECORD In r est/moilY whereol, ! here 111110 set mlll1,md and the sf.;,;']l of sBj~j Ct'm1 tal Caf~~tr.ii~) P;.t fhis ItS" -'Jay alf!';;!::- ( , -:"M) ( U'A~.r2 I ~~ I . Prothollotarf ~ L__ ..J.." ~~ LRii>,oiMil'tllil!Ob"';}_"_, :.. ~ WILLIAM C. COSTOPOULOS DAVID]. FOSTER LESLIE M. FIELDS GEORGE Ii MATANGOS COSTOPOULOS, FOSTER & FIELDS ATIORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW 831 MARKET STREET P.O. BOX 222 LEMOYNE, PENNSYL VANIA 17043-0222 TELEPHONE 761-2121 AREA CODE 717 FAX 761-4031 October 19, 2001 Henry F. Coyne, Esquire COYNE & COYNE, P.C. 3901 Market Street Camp Hill, PA 17011-4227 Andrew Snell Andrew Snell Concrete Constmction 30 Umberto Street New Cumberland, P A 17070 Re: Fuchs v. Andrew Snell Concrete Construction No.: 2000-7396 Dear Gentlemen: Please be advised that due to a conflict, Mary Kollas-Kennedy, Esquire has been removed as an arbitrator in the above matter. Judge Hoffer has appointed Murrel R. Walters, Esquire to replace her. The arbitration will commence on the same date, time and place as previously scheduled. If you have any questions in reference to the enclosed, please do not hesitate to contact my office. ~"7:~ Leslie M. Fields LMF/jme Enclosure cc: James Hughes, Esquire Murrel R. Walters, Ill, Esquire ..... - r- ,.., C":>> <<= --.:I -C Carlisle Office: 10 East Louther Street. I" Floof" Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-0407 . Fax (717) 243-0950 " ~'",.' '.'~'<- "~"_."""""". ~iii><i';! ~ l. NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA v. No. 200-7396 Civil Term ANDREW SNELL, t/d/b/a ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION, CIVIL ACTION-LAW Defendant JURY lRIAL DEMANDED ORDRR AND NOW, this 17-rw day of (JbU5~ ,2001, Murrel R. Walters, III, Esquire is hereby appointed to replace Mary Kollas-Kennedy, Esquire as an arbitrator in the above matter. BY THE COURT: Distribution: Leslie M. Fields, Esquire Murrel R. Waiters, III, Esquire Henry F. Coyne, Esquire Mr. Andrew Snell rRUE COpy FBOM RECORD 111 r estlmO\ljl WilfJr\1fJI, I tlllre unlo Sill my hand and the s,e.;;),1 of sa.~d GGwi: id CarUsie ~ Pa~ fhls 14 day {;!(PtJ:J.,:; , -:MJ ( "r~ . () ~ t'~ ProtlloofJtarf . l,.. NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff v. ANDREW SNELL, t/d/b/a ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONlRUCTION, Defendant . ..-....0.. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYL VANIA No. 200-7396 CiviITerm CIVIL ACTION-LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED NOTICE OF ARBITRATION HEARING To; Natalie Fuchs c/o Henry F. Coyne, Esquire COYNE & COYNE, P.C. 390 I Market Street Camp Hill, PA 17011-4227 Andrew Snell Andrew Snell Concrete Construction 30 Umberto Street New Cumberland, P A 17070 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Arbitration Hearing in the above-captioned matter has been scheduled for Monday, October 29, 200 I, commencing at 1 :00 p.m., in the Law Offices of Costopoulos, Foster & Fields, located at 831 Market Street, Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043. Dated: October 15,2001 Leslie M. Fields, Esquire Board of Arbitrators James D. Hughes, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, PA 17013 Murrel R. Walters, III, Esquire 54 East Main Street Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 ,. ~ ~",,*,,{, . - ...~~" ,. i'_'!ci"''ii><~"gj;::. WILLIAM C. COSTOPOULOS DAVID j, FOSTER LESLIE M, FIELDS GEORGE H. MATANGOS COSTOPOULOS, FOSTER & FIELDS ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW 831 MARKET STREET P.O. BOX 222 LEMOYNE, PENNSYL VANIA 17043-0222 TELEPHONE 761-2121 AREA CODE 717 FAX 761- 4031 October 16, 2001 Hon. George E. Hoffer, P.J. c/o Sandy Cumberland County Courthouse One Courthouse Square Carlisle, PAl 7013-3387 Re: Fuchs v. Andrew Snell Concrete Construction No.: 2000-7396 Dear Sandy: Pursuant to our conversation today, enclosed please find the Order appointing Murrel R. Walters, Ill, Esquire to replace Mary Kollas-Kennedy, Esquire as an arbitrator in the above matter. In the meantime, if you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact our office. Very truly yours, COpy Jayme M. Emig Secretary to Leslie M. Fields Enclosures Carlisle Office: 10 East Louther Street. 1st Floor. Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-0407 . Fax (717) 243-0950 l ........,,~,.,.""*'!i:,;;,;,:;-.;., WILLIAM C. COSTOPOULOS DAVID}. FOSTER LESLIE M. FIELDS GEORGE H. MATANGOS COSTOPOULOS, FOSTER & FIELDS ATfORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW 831 MARKET STREET P.O. BOX 222 LEMOYNE, PENNSYLVANIA 17043-0222 TELEPHONE 761-2121 AREA CODE 717 FAX 161. 4()31 . ... October 10, 2001 Henry F. Coyne, Esquire COYNE & COYNY, P.C. 3901 Market Street Camp Hill, PA 17011-4227 Andrew Snell Andrew Snell Concrete Construction 30 Umberto Street New Cumberland, P A 17070 Re: Fuchs v. Andrew Snell Concrete Construction No.: 2000-7396 'Dear Gentlemen: Enclosed please find the Notice of Arbitration Hearing in the abo~-captioned matter which has been scheduled for Monday, October 29, 2001 at 1:00 p.m., in the offices-ofCostopoulos, Foster & Fields, locate~ at 831 Market Street, Lemoyne, P A. If you have any questions in reference to the enclosed, please do not hesitate to contact my office. LMF/jme Enclosure cc: James Hughes, Esquire (w/enc.) Mary KoIlas-Kennedy, Esquire (w/enc.) Very truly yours, ~VJ~ esli M. Fields CaTI;sle Office: 10 East LoutheT Street. I" FI<>OT' CaTlisle, P A \1013 (111) 243-0407' Fax (711) 243-0950 ' ...., - r- 1"""1 C"':) c:::. -a -C . ... - NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff v. ANDREW SNELL, t/dlb/a ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONTRUCTION, Defendant " -. . - ,,'-'~'-~ --~ ~-"",,,~~.:>::, IN TIIE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA No. 200-7396 CiviITenn CIVIL ACTION-LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED NOTICE OF ARBITRATION HEARING To: Natalie Fuchs c/o Henry F. Coyne, Esquire COYNE & COYNY, P.C. 390 I Market Street Camp Hill, PA 17011-4227 Andrew Snell Andrew Snell Concrete Construction 30 Umberto Street New Cumberland, P A 17070 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Arbitration Hearing in the above-captioned matter has been scheduled for Monday, October 29,2001, commencing at 1:00 p.m., in the Law Offices ofCostopouIos, Foster & Fields, located at 831 Market Street, Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043. Dated: October 10, 2001 James D. Hughes, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, P A 17013 Mary Kollas-Kennedy, Esquire 1104 Fernwood Avenue Camp Hill, PA 17011 .-"" "'-.- .~ ", ~ , if.:.", ~ .- NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, : PENNSYL VANIA vs. : NO. 2000 - 7396 ANDREW SNELL, t1d!b/a ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION, Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS TO lHE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT: Henry F. Coyne, counsel for the plaintiff in the above action respectfully represents that: I. The above-captioned action is at issue. 2. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is $7,500.00 The following attorneys are interested.in the case as counsel or are otherwise disqualified to sit as arbitrators: Richard Snelbaker and Lowell Gates. WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted. Respectfully submitted, Dated: .~ /'? ~ COYNE & COYNE, P.c. f 2: ~-~ ~enry F. Coyne, quire 3901 Market Street CampHiII,PA 17011-4227 (717) 737-0464 Pa. Supreme Ct. No. 06250 Attorneys for Plaintiff AND NOW, the , foregOm:~n, ~", for. ORDER OF COURT J.7 ~ of - , 00 in consideration of the .,and . oned action as prayed /2 /0/:;'/0/ - rnurr<z-/ WaJW.s) 177 \.S-v L. mAIN U'rR.EET lnecnanlC'..s;,bt.L'3.J m /'JDOJ C7n) 697- .<j65V L/.'OO j J. J:~ , ~~~...~__~ 0' <-'~-b~iW8f'ir; -- y,,- ", ," >- ~ 'f '-~O;,\"b.f:,0~ililtm "' "~<~.,~" V\N\I~i\1^S)'~N3d -'-'1"ln:] I I' .nr.r...'.'...,.,,\, f\..!J\i 1\)'-,' "_' .."._,. 'I ", ,~'t~ .nl ~-1~! L Z iJll~ 10 I v':."' .., \".\; ,~,J" =, '-':" . .~,,,,. "" ,_..~ L -~-":...- "'llil!l1iiIiIl:Il!IiII.... ?=J ~ , .~ g - ~jt! 1 o 1- rlllllllkii' ",,,,-".,,.- _0 ., , 0 C) 0 c:: -- -1-1 u~. lo> rnFP c ~~f L::1) 1',) G.> > ~8 ~. CO L. :J1 -, -< r",) iII1mimil\,i ~~, ;b}J:.6~ ,;w,ll'~~~iU~ll,I"~',~l:~:,~,\!,~~I!~I."I!$I~", , ,_ . _ . ,- ,,-' -," ,'.'! ','_<<,;i::' '" '-;"" -; , -',' I!,"'; :" -' - " ,COMMONWEALTH OF P~NNSY~V"_~IA,i ; COURT OF CC1N!I\\O~~LE~S , I .~!~,~,J.II).IJ~I.,~II" In)~~'J~l\}l.~[)!~~Ul'\I.11\l !'l!t.I.~ NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM JU,DICIAL DISTRICT DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT COM_NPLEASNo. OO~7396 CIVIL TERM NOTICE OF APPEAL Notice is given that the appelk.nt has liled in the above Court ,of Common Pleas an appeal fram the judgment rendered by the District Justice on the date and in the case mention!>,! below. ' NAME OF APPEUANT Af1rl r< ItJ ADDRESS OF APPELLANT aTY ~VJ L<.J/v\ ber ( I MAG ~ST~Q.:' NAi OF:!O "i STAre ZPCOOE CVII' ~39 -00 LT 19 This block will be signed ONW When this. nOtation is required under ,Pc. R.cP J.P. NO. 10088.' '.. .', This Notice of Appeal. when received by the District Justice. will.oPerate as 0 SUPERSEDEAS Ie:> the judgment lot- possession in this cose, .:'i:', Signature ,pi Pmthonotafy, Of Deputy '.../ If appellant Was CLAIMANT (see Pa. .J.P. No. 1001 (6) in action beforeDistrictJustice, he MUST FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after filing his NOTICE of APPEAL. " . I'RAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILECOMPl:AINT AND RULE TO IFILE ' ;', ',' "" -"",' ',\', , ", .\"1 '-, . - , {Thissettion of form to be used ONLY when appellant was DEFENDANT (see Pa. R.C.p.J.P. No. 1001 (7 )J,,!,ac'tiq;,:bef6re Di{3trict Justice, IF NOT USED, detach frotn copy of notice of appeal to be 'served' upon appellee). ' \ PRAECIPE: To Prathonotary I, RULE: To Fvc/''s ',' N#.-k I"e.. Nt#ne '01 awe'foe(s) Fur h~ IV&., -k \."C.- IIune or awelfee(s) CIVIL TERM ) within twenty (20) doys alter service of ,rule 'l".ffenmt"ryof iU"""~t o~: Adu/ C' ~~U Signature of appellant' or his attorney or agent \, , appellee(.), Ie:> file a complaint in this appeal Enter rule upon . (Common Pleas No. 00-7396 , appellee(s). ( 1) You are notified that 0 rule is hereby entered upon you Ie:> file a complaint in this appeal within twenty (20) doys after thedote of _vice of this rule upon you by pers, onal service or by certified or registered moil. ,<.;;..;;"",~.....,...:, " .'~"'.",~ .\h ::" -<.:""~, ,1,,',-,~~\ t"":, 'l,h (2) If you do notlile a complaint within this time. a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED !\~1iij);~~:Yi,....,~~" k:(\ );:~~:~',>,:":""'" '1\21_,' -< 4t'\ (3) The date of service af this rul,eif service was by mail is the date af maili :'$'" "'. !~ ;:i, r '~~ (" ,. , "-,'. ; Oct. 20 .~. , \ , ;\?~:::~.,.;<< ~f, '-:.'''-;, < w'., ~"'k,""; ~v :","-,,-L hk ,'~ '" ". ";~t\y\(,>.-~ " -\ ()<:," Date: , ~ AOPC 312-84 C,OURTF,ILE ", '"~"',,"',..~, ....,\.'_,"''''~,'i-r,.;:....'"''''.....~._'''"-,';',.r'.,,. ,...,- ,"~~',-"t, "^',~.' ".,,, ~~ ;jjy.;,,,.<'..;.. , H.~~'_"~no.. '0' ,~'" , ' <",.'__ I ",,-' ,_" .,,", ,.~", ,''''...._ . " _ " . ~;""-,j'''-o/;'''''k,'':-~!i'';.''!!'_~~'~>$~1:_-<f'If,;~:~,,,.WF*rJ'~~'~i;C, '"' ,,,,,",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,~,,,,,~~,,t .!II!II~. ~~I,~~~I't~~",lII""!!"...""I."', ,i 1:1'" ! ' , , ~ ' ,~. 00.11 r ..-. ::~'IfiIl,,!__,o_',,;, '''-,fj,,~!",~ _.JlIi!l\l\ ~i'l' r i : , "'I I",: ,I I!!i.! ': " PROOF Of SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL.'A~qlli~lILE TO FILE COMPLAINT (This proof of service MUST BE FILED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS AFTE' fiI~ng!,:ri~'notice of appeal, Check applicable boxes) COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA I ,II b \ 1 I ;1:, C ii" COUNTVOF UM e, "'.... :s. i ill 'I i !'!::: AFFIDAVIT: I hereby swear or affirm that I served ~' a copy ot the Notice of Appeal, COl"mor Pleas No, 00 .':"1,, upon the Distrlcf Justice designated therein on (dete of service) ~ ;/")lbUt"?t') ,j(~yj '?'Hervice o ,bY (cerlifled){registered) mail, sender's receipl altaFhed hereto, and upon the appellee, (name)" , '" " 'I:, "s , pn 1(712.-3 too , ttl~D by personal serViCe~bY{citIIIJ'ih~Qistered) mail, sender's receipt attachedh~reio -t5' and further that I served the Rule to File a Complaint accompanYllng;th~ ",: ~~ve Notloe of Appealupon the appellee(s) to Wh<1m the Rule was addressed on 10\ z..~'OO ,1~,llli,pbY personal servioeJl!'bY (certlfie.9) (registerea), -? mall. sender's attached hereto, ! ii' 'I . ,l / (/ ,..<~;>:::" SWORN (~;~AD) AND SUBSG~ED BEFORE ME ' .' ! , ,~'~,~ J// . //.(/ ,,t'1:":" THIS ;;r..j'')1 DAY OF (X'f~~ .1w.tl:12~~/~./ "",,""~"'''.~-''~ .. V ' Signature ofafflam: . 19____ Member, Pennsylv~n:~I'As;}oc,a~!,)n ai Notaries ~ ~~ 1+-- ...L.....L. 9b C-C:C WOn ....J ;-;-t.u -." F=' tL b a. x: "'= Q M I- c.J o o o ;:j" IT' 1, Return Receipt Fee ~' (Endorsement ReqUired) Cl en ~ :::>:g; 8~ 021 365 CC';Z w(fi aJa ~ () IT' l'- .-'l Cl Restricted Delivery Fee (Endorsement Required) $1.2 SO.OO } Total Postage & Fees $ S2.98 10/23/2000 Cl Cl ~ _~~~/l4_~he[I~~~_PflE;;ZAo ~e ~omPleted ~y matler). _ Street Apt [!} or PO BOX' g i.io.",Ia 1,( ro.uij) r !"', ~ ory S"",ZIP04 J4 170 II ""'",',M...u ,"L ,'.""~' 9L ___,_, _, ",_,v,J,,,,,,,,,,,,, ^..' ____ l.._~ ~ " L I l,UIJl!ili .,- , ,-- ~ ~~ ,,~" ,... F_"..~'_~ - n., -t ~~Il , . """ ~ - ~ ~'-"IHlib'-'E;,l \),,: 'i~~l' NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA v. No. 200-7396 Civil Term ANDREW SNELL, t/d/b/a ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION, CIVIL ACTION-LAW Defendant JURY TRIAL DEMANDED AND NOW, this ORDER /7 1'^-" day of {Ye--ti~ ,2001, Murrel R. Walters, III, Esquire is hereby appointed to replace Mary Kollas-Kennedy, Esquire as an arbitrator in the above matter. BY THE COURT: Distribution: Leslie M. Fields, Esquire Murrel R. Walters, III, Esquire (~nJ'~ ~ /0-1 i-of Henry F. Coyne, Esquire -T- Mr. Andrew Snell '-f- -- -. =- ., ,.. ,- <~-,'" ,~- ~~~="""",,,,'=,-' '0', ""~~."~_",, '-"~""_~,,, """'""_""~I"'~, ---',I ',<,_J"",,",.. '"y.j'^';'C,",--"d'~'.:;i.":.",,~),;'ib""C;;'';''''i,,, "";~,' ~ ~J NATALIE FUCHS, Plaintiff VS. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ; NO. 20(..7396 CIVIL Term ANDREW SNELL, T.D.B.A ANDREW SNELL CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION, Defendant. : CIVIL ACTION - LAW : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 29th day of October, 2001, in consideration ofa conflict which exists for arbitrator James D. Hughes, Esquire, and in further consideration of Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire, agreeing to serve as an arbitrator in the above-captioned matter, it is hereby ordered that James D. Hughes, Esquire, is removed and Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire, is appointed as arbitrator in the above-captioned matter. The arbitrators for the above-captioned matter will meet for the purpose of their appointment on Monday, October 29,2001 at 1:00 p.m. in the Law Offices of Costopoulos, Foster & Fields, 83 I Market Street, Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043. By the Court, I'J. Date: /() - t.. 9 ,2001 cc: Leslie M. Fields, Esquire Board of Arbitrators 06 pr'€-S ?~ay G;;'c.)gA;) --b M'r t.LqL..r.s {YLaILL ~cfv0~ voJ~t-clb'( 17J~c:.o..:1L- J.~ om~ lo/~R/O( _ n ~ ~. _. ~_ l)l;ll,;lIl;p Fll~h!=: plaintiff VS. Andrew Snel~, t/d/b/a Andrew Snell Concrete Construction Defendant IJe do soll!lllllly S'loIear (or affirm) the Constitution of the United States ~ealth aud that V" viII discharge the " .J ":~~~~,: .. In The Court of Co~on Pleas of ) C/ ~ Cumberland Couney, Pennsrlvania ) ) ) ) 0' ~Q..'),nf)f),~"71.QF\ r; ,d 1 19 OATH that we will sup~ort, obey and defend and the Consticut1o~ of this Co~on- duties of lity. 10 AWARD We. ehe,undersigned arbitrators. having heen duly appointed and s'loIorn (or affirm.ed), uke the following aVBrd: (Note: If damages for delay are avarqed. they shall be separately stated.) (TWo it.O{.,00~ 1/vr'i"<2- rof<.- "tlfE _H-u/v<:Ue.d -fo rr-'j , I PL!\INrlFF $2..3Lf(.oo I " i)fJf- :st> "OL-LAiLs ') applicable. ) Date of lIearing: OG-'t, 2-1,2-00 \ ocr 2-'1 >~o\ , Da!:a of Avard: NOTICE OF ENTRY OF AWAR!) Nov, !:he,2<JQ<'day oi~ . lIPdtt'1/, at$:S'4. P..:l., the above avard was entared upon the docket and nO!::!.C" thereaf giVen by lIIail to the ~arties or !:heir attorneys. "'Ar!iitraCors ' c:o~ensat"!ol1 to be pa:l.d ullc)l1 al'l'eal.: S ,:).90,oi) , , &u.:r;~ !? ~ J.... r.~1::houotaxy 8y: 0,1'.....-1) /'v,,/h._ Deputy ~HIJ~1lW~"",1i!i;,~,t0:.E:;"'''''''"dll-'''-''l.A-;;,~)~\,,"~''''''i,'''',Wli.oii'kF,,,,,,~;1;"~f''>'':"'''7-""",",~",~L',-,, "__t-~iiif.'mlli~<!Iliilii1ail!iit'if\' >"~"~^'.l'~8\!to&l~~~_I!~ ~~ .&w ;t.e /J1. ~ _/'..,_7.:. frLvJ"-' fl, ~"2J ~ ~ :t ......u..- J 1n'1!" Ii iJ.)~' ff[. , ~ '~'~ 11-,;11-0) J.2/0{,!OI ~(J 1li...AJ o c- ? -0'"' fTl g;; 2""1"' Zr-.l (f) do: -<' ~C~;~ ~C )>0 C z :< Q ,~ .::.r, Z i';7,) .c N Q ',;i 1--; -'c ,.'.- ' 7;~~ 5~~ ~ c. :& S~ :n .r.- ?Ii -< / _J --;'" , I l ~ . ,', . < ~- ~ j)J ntJuJ ~j'j~ In the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania vs. O~A.... s,/IA..tl ~ > -r[A IA~/a C.AA~J.oflp ~1'~ D~,. tJ~~ ~,,~~, ~tll~i(j~~~~~ ~q~~ t: ~;.l:'{ :tl;:4 .j4lAiid !~ No.l- CJ ~ n -1 3Ci6 Civil.19 To 1/vi1f'- ~ AJJ-' 1< ~1- 2.. r;.,D~ Prothonotary I' .1 'cOii~~NliIlli4.~~l'HMO"o,"",,~O!jii\I~.illI"lhi,\JI!;!oWiI"AU.+"~!_"-""~'''\''_1'':''-~clC.L~.;;:,;,.~...LAAli>~~,h,J~lUllJi"~~11""Aii!W""jI;~I!MMt..,,*~i!'[-li .l1.il'-l~[nll . No. Tenn, 19 _ VS. PRAECIPE Filed 19 , Ally. ~(!) ~ ~ () 0 0 c ~ \ . s:: -n 0 '"Urn ,., ~i ~~!_~ k$ mrn n Z:D Z-' N ~~ CI) t... ~:Z 0-. 0 ~ -0 '7'0 ...;;". C~) ;n -0 .-7....:) -:-f\ >c w OrT! ~ ""' ~ w :'0 -< r" -< ,......... ",. i J