HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-2888 FX
-
, ~
-,
," .,' ,.,. -"'- "
"j ~Ci.;;'~~., >';;-_I-'~'" :'"'"".~-"-"-" ~, ".-;,,,, ' .<., :'~"';",";;:i~;'-.l.;"',',; ;,'"w'" ."
:1::
. Johnson, Duffie, Stewart & Weidner
By: Mark C. Duffie
LD. No. 75906
301 Market Street
P. O. Box 109
Lernoyne, Pennsylvania 17043-0 I 09
(717) 761-4540
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S., and
MINIUM & KEARNS ORTHODONTISTS, a
General Partnership,
Plaintiff(s)
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO.t\/-.:J.PPj> Dt<.)~tr~
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
ANTHONY C. MUSCARELLI, t/d/b/a
MUKIE'S SEAL COATING,
Defendant(s)
NOTICE TO DEFEND
TO THE DEFENDANT:
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following
pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a
written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defense or objections to
the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you
and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the
complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other
rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A
LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO
FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-3166
:145733
'.
, ,
-
;", ,,[-I -'..' ,"-,,_ I,' k; l'";''' ' ,-+ ,.,-" '. -~'-'~--'. 'I', -i,' I
,'-;-'->.; '~':"'V\",c, '''''''''-,:-~2~->'' ..::: - ~~\.'
,JohnsolIl, Duffie, Stewart & Weidner
By: Mark C. Duffie
J.D. No. 75906
301 Market Street
P. O. Box 109
Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043-0109
(717) 761-4540
Attorneys for Plaintiff
MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S., and
MINIUM & KEARNS ORTHODONTISTS, a
General Partnership
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO.O/-,z'j)li'8""
Plaintiffs
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
ANTHONY C. MUSCARELLI, Vd/b/a
MUKIE'S SEAL COATING,
Defendant(s)
COMPLAINT
AND NOW COMES the Plaintiffs, MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S., and MINIUM & KEARNS
ORTHODONTISTS, by and through their attorneys, Johnson, Duffie, Stewart & Weidner, and files this
Complaint and in support thereof avers as follows:
1. Plaintiff, Mark M. Minium, D.D.S., is an adult individual residing at 1141 Dry Powder Cire/e,
Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
2. Plaintiff, Minium & Kearns Orthodontists, is a domestic general partnership with a principal
place of business located at 1412 Bridge Street, New Cumberland, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
17070. Plaintiff, Minium & Kearns Orthodontists, also has an office located at 4509 Union Deposit Road,
Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania 17111.
3. Plaintiff, Mark M. Minium, D.D.S. and Mark J. Kearns, D.D.S., M.S., formed the domestic
general partnership, Minium & Kearns Orthodontists on~, 19!}%.. At all times relevant hereto, the
principal place of business remained at 1412 BridgeV Str~et, New Cumberland, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania 17070.
._~.._ , .J;
4. Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli is an adult individual residing at 720A Colony Drive, York,
York County, Pennsylvania 17404. At all times relevant hereto, Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli, was
trading and doing business as Mukie's Seal Coating. The address for Mukie's Seal Coating at all times
relevant hereto was 720A Colony Drive, York, York County, Pennsylvania 17404.
5. On or about October 4, 1995, Plaintiffs, Mark M. Minium, D.D.S. and Minium & Kearns
Orthodontists, entered into an agreement with Anthony C. Muscarelli, tld/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating, wherein
Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli agreed to perform services upon Plaintiff's parking lot which included seal
coating over existing blacktop as well as grading and installing new blacktop as well as curbing and lights.
6. Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli, tld/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating, failed to perform the services
set forth in the agreement in a workman-like fashion and Plaintiff hired another contractor to repair and
complete the project. A true and correct copy of said sales agreement is attached hereto and incorporated
herein as Exhibit "A".
7. As a result of the Defendant's negligence, the parties entered into a settlement agreement
dated August 5, 1997, to resolve a Fifteen Thousand Eight Hundred and Seventy-Six and 48/100
($15,876.48) Dollar claim to reimburse Plaintiff for payments rendered for services that were either
performed negligently or not performed whatsoever. A true and correct copy of said letter agreement is
attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit "B".
8. Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli made payment according to the agreement periodically
after executing the settlement agreement in the amount of Five Thousand Five Hundred ($5,500.00) Dollars.
9. Defendant has failed to make any payments under the settlement agreement since June
1998.
10. There remains a balance of Ten Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-Six Dollars and Forty-
Eight Cents ($10,376.48) due and owing from Defendant Anthony C. Muscarelli, tld/b/a Mukie's Seal
Coating, to Plaintiffs, Minium, & Kearns Orthodontists, and Mark M. Minium D.D.S.
11. Despite repeated attempts to seek payment in this matter by telephone and correspondence,
Plaintiffs have not received any payment pursuant to the agreement since June, 1998.
. "-. --
-
. ,'~ ",-,' .,-" ,,--, - - ,,,"
'- ,'"',
_' ,,,,-,.I ' ,'~
~-- -'. -,~'-
~-~"'''',j,,~,~
COUNT I
BREACH OF CONTRACT
Mark M. Minium. D.D.S. and Minium & Kearns Orthodontists
.:t..
Anthony C. Muscarelli. tld/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating.
12. Paragraphs 1 through 11 are incorporated as if set forth fully herein.
13. On August 5, 1997, the parties hereto entered into an agreement whereby the Defendant,
Anthony C. Muscarelli agreed to settle a claim with Plaintiff for Fifteen Thousand Eight Hundred and
Seventy-Six and 48/100 ($15,876.48) Dollars.
14. The terms of the settlement agreement attached hereto as Exhibit "8" includes One
Thousand ($1,000.00) Dollars upon acceptance of the agreement and Five Hundred ($500.00) Dollars a
month commencing on September 1, 1997 with a balloon payment on August 1, 1998.
15. Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli, t1d/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating, has failed to make payment
as required under the agreement and therefore is in breach of the settlement agreement for which Plaintiff
seeks the balance due and owing, Ten Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-Six Dollars and Forty-Eight Cents
($10,376.48) plus interest and costs.
.....
~
,-
~_ k1" - J'-,J_.,", _,-.
, --- .-~o. ""_',;..1 ;.,
',"_,",-.--. -1i-,,'':'":,~ '-0---' - '=""_~':,
COUNT II
BREACH OF CONTRACT
Mark M. Minium. D.D.S. and Minium & Kearns Orthodontists
.JL.
Anthony C. Muscarelli. tld/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating.
16. Paragraphs 1 through 15 are incorporated as if set forth fully herein.
17. On or about October 1, 1995, the parties entered into a Sales Agreement whereby the
Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli, Vd/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating, agreed to provide certain improvements as
set forth herein to Plaintiff's property located at 1412 Bridge Street, New Cumberland, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania 17070.
18. Defendant failed to perform these services in a workmanlike fashion and therefore, is in
breach of the Sales Agreement and the contract between Plaintiffs and Defendant.
19. Plaintiffs, due to Defendant's negligence, suffered damages in the amount of Fifteen
Thousand Eight Hundred Seventy-Six 48/100 ($15,876.48) Dollars.
20. Plaintiffs have received Five Thousand Five Hundred ($5,500.00) Dollars representing
reimbursement of those damages from Defendant. Plaintiffs seek the balance due and owing of Ten
Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-Six and 48/100 ($10,376.48) Dollars plus interest and costs.
.
~'"'~. ".
.." " '.-L' -;-0.1.,""'- -t.;I'-'_ ,,'''1 .'k_;_:__,,_'_,_i__~_~_-_--.'_.,-__. "~I '-':'[.'0 ,>--~-;-, ",",",;,;..-".-,'o'r;-".,_,,_ "'- ,-~--: "r'<~f
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs request this Honorable Court to award to Plaintiffs Ten Thousand Three
Hundred Seventy-Six Dollars and Forty-Eight Cents ($10,376.48) plus interest, costs and attorney's fees as
well as other damages as this Honorable Court deems fair and equitable.
Respectfully submitted,
JOHNSON, DUFFIE, STEWART & NER
M kC. Duffie
A omey I.D. NO.7
301 Market Street
P. O. Box 109
Lemoyne, PA 17043-01 9
(717) 761-4540
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
DATED:
5/;
.
,2001
:143492
-"
,- -~, .-- -
_.-, ; 0,
'" ~'- -~
- ____1-.1', ,. ' I.:, 0'_;1, -_ \ ,--,~'-, ,_, ,---
;: - "",I ,~-- ~, ,'-L ,- - -.0, '. -,j_~ c"
-'-'all;ldf!lfu;"
VERIFICA TION
I, MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S. and MINIUM & KEARNS ORTHODONTISTS, do verify that the
statements made in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and
belief. I understand that false statements made herein are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. ~904
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S.
~4 /JZ. ~~ /)tJS
MINIUM & KEARNS ORTHODONTISTS
~ ta4. ~ ~.";~.. :..... OJ.?-f
MA M. MINIUIM, D.D.S.
Dated:
'i/~" / cp/
/
:143492
- - ~~
.".~"",ilol<4:<
.1
,III
I. I'
~ Ll~~~~"
...........,'...jj~;.<fu'l'
~""'.~'
',.. ,'"
--
, .KUKlE'S SEAL COADNG .'
CONTRA,CT NUMBER
'" .
',' .
720 A Colony DrIve
York. PA 17404
854-1870
~: I"~ '
SALES AGREEMENT
'''" ,"',:,'" ,'., '\.'
~~,,-~~~.:JnA{~ M. M';dl~M 0.0 oS
ADDRESS '" IJ' Ar I~ TI.
CITY n~ ~~;,Itl>J'> STAll: p", ZIP \ ""In
8lLUNG ADDFIell8 'I' Dl"1'ERl!NT:
TEI.E,,"ONE ,)""'-/~ ~
(JIi1.//1'V
Deacrlptlon 01' work agreed upon:
Equipment
l..ocallon Quantity To Be Ueed
Comments
- II
G9r~"R'it-'*
(u, Pro.. r
v~f!'" ~rc.ot ~;II Ch<I!or d....~ ~-<
, 1'r'r#1t(J 11>'" 6l.1~ ~,-
,
10 Nr~l~ u.o - >T'Ao\I CUl"bwr (C..",.ott) AS
C~~" ,~..J.::r,v bLu<-~~ ~"\ 1'114C."'.:;A,JL 4 'ltd
,,.1..'" 1111" '1"",,,,'I'Ill;(.\ J. ''It.1l.-r,$ ~"T'cC"C:T ')
~,.ct;lIto... :JOf'~<< (~!.. Oe~"Ic.J ~.. ,"""Ic:r ')
~"'e.ot" it) ~<c:..<"""I.I" h,f" AI' Lp.u{)~~
FltlmBr1rlI:
c
~~ q::>d - IO.-l.{.qs CMlI PrlOe,(Ino1udlllll..... Ta) . -1-~t80D.
TIIl'lMS . PAYMBNT Q 600 . ..
1.1,1100 .00 0 ""CO....elt:',' o~
....nee on COmplellon
s \iO, ~OO'
o(~1"1.1 ~iT oc:T IY")\.,
..,_ To Be l'lnanoed .
EXHIBIT "A"
e.d W~e.:.. 000e S0 '+~O
9Le8 8SS L.L : 'ON 3NOHd +S!+uopo~+~O su~e~~ pue wnjulW : WOdj
~,_ ._.~L
_~ - .L............
I, " j.~.....
,_I
~~.L_
jril~oo.+-
. .
-
"
.-,:~: 0-0; 'Countess.Gilbert.Andrews
~\ x5~-" I
~v'f-. r(" " ,jJA em IUlIG'of1Xir~ti<m
'\ \ ' \:Y:, ". 2' Nonh Duke So- 't. York, l'en~lvania 401-1282' Telep~on"; 717.:&l~-4900 . FAX: 717-843.9039 -
.'^'- J"burg Sueer, P,O, !lox 606 . F.>,", Berlin, l'enn.yJlluni. 17Jl6 . Telephone: 717-259-9592 . fAX. 717.2>9:9148
/; : Q\31C1) ---- 9-10-Cl" . L,~,~__.._.
"- CCl\IeS- ~"y~ ~ o.f{..'l:Q
~ Co.l\ed At\1')f~ 'I- 4{J1u.~ m<J~ -\0\0.- .~~~' .
1\0 ~"tlf{le..nt ("e,-~\>W- (/do' ~'\ h €... fflc.uL.[)
i M~o I-old H~n toi-oA ~ . uS '^-~ Xr 4ElSoc,=
. c1.uo l~ -4IS,'ii'?ln.l/8 a..st-IR l=-t=-~.clc M"t- &J QSi Q)($""
"fu0- mv~ ,'1'\ 1~H-e.t 0(0. ')/Ii}9~ Qcu.t I\.;~~ ~
.\ 9'Q.97 e.el/lea a.:HoI'/l~ O{ja.l" . IC-'('-q7
.;! ~ lef-f- meS-'!:, fer rMt.(Q
/;;0 Cat I ""t- he ~M~~
Co..\I.&t ~ I A-rw""-:-'1 "'" ~ -Ii
~+t.\.c..h.)S. a.::. 5CcI1' uS
~ Wl..-icJ h.'n, ,
,
,,-
\
\
..
.
.
--",,,","::-,!... -.........~.-
,
'r
AUgust 5, 1997
"
Dr. Mark: Mimium
1411 Bridge Street
New Cumberland, PA 17070
Dear Dr. Mimium:
We represent Mukie's Seal Coating, Inc., and I am writing to you regarding the $15,000 claim
for reimbursement for services rendered.
Regarding the substance of the claim, my client is in the process of suing Cooper Paving,
Marvin Schnapp and Advanced Concrete, the subcontractors who did the actual work on your
job, for the entire balance of your reimbursement claim.
In an effort to satisfy your claim aurlng the-pending litigation aild"to resolve this matter with you'
amicably, my client has proposed the following payment schedule: $1,000 down upon your
acceptance of this proposal, $500 a month commencing on sC12temoer I, 1.297 and on the first
day of every month thereafter, with a balloon payment on August 1, 1998 or upon the receipt
of a damage award in the above-referenced litigation, whichever comes earlier.
Ion c. C(lurltl.:s~j . (~-ary M. Gilbert . Pt>{~r It ArlJWW.'i to IJ1WTl'!ll't' V. Vt)lJJJg! . .\1,khad Bml:-'1~;ld\ . ~har~)f\ E. ,My,'f~. . Ri)\1~\\~ll>'I'ry\
. Th()!llH~ D. <rSlll.:i\ . 101m U. llliilchll;lughi . Fr~Ulk II. COllnll's~. J):-'l'ph P. U'.H'k. III I . :'l.lI~i.fl., .'\l!S\ln . 1\("1\\\ 1\. S,l\k.....IIIi\
" .
1/11.\(1 ,l(/J)I;tJ(.~J lfI nc: nlll'. -',11.\/) adll/I//('tl/fl ~:'\ tho". iIJ..,H. .iilX(lfiIlJl. ':1/::1; !:dmli,!'" 1(1 :1-tI i {Jar" '.'1!.,1! Ildlllilfed /r' l.i!: jlUI
9d W~60:11 OOOG SO '+~O
9LG8 8SS LIL : 'ON 3NOHd +Sl+UOPOY+~O SU~ed~ pue wnlUjW WO~j
EXHIBIT "B"
~
, 1 I' '~I
~~~
i; I
I' ,.- ~ ~ . . ,
/ '\.. -..,.... I. r 'v","' ~ "'/ ...~,..,..' ~ I . ~ .. -
, , ",....... . ... ~ "... 4 ......
,.....t" , J....... . . \.. I I \' '.J .., '..' ...... . \ ' ,V., .... . \ "
L.ettc,.;~ oJ Dr. Mark Mimium
DatGi1 Auguat S; 1997
~4-"i '",
, ~- "
,- ':;'lW-i'!;1i"
. ~.\"'
, N:f4, '\ ,
My client wishes to express his gratitude for your understanding and patience in this lI12tter.
If you are in agreement with the terms of this settlement proposal, please sign below.
,- Sinc:.er~. - ,
Countess.GUbert-Andrews
.--..... ":....., , ~ -.", ...-.-"
'" ,','~
~'_I'
, ' ,
. "', "
Vt..- (11,
, .
By: Joseph l'~ Clark, II.
JPC/mkr
'c.c: Tony MuscareUi
,,' ACCBPTED:
~
,
,j" fJ-J'
Ton~uscarel1i
~"",q -?f tWe';.v
Mark Mimium
.......- .~ . ....--
,
'-.
Ld ~,Cl60: n 0002: 50 'PO
EXHIBIT "B"
9L2:8 8SS LrL 'ON 3NOHd 1-SI+UOpo'l1-..IO SU..IP"'>i p~pwniu'!w': WOd;
~YillJ!1tH'r!l'b~~f'fq,~;!'.MW,';>Xf;fM'"",j"ff',li'fr';;&,~kliffilli,~:\ih'l~'ii!1~..'H,"d",;',"';~ii:,,,-i~_ C-",,~"!~;;;,g,fi,;ilit'~it~~1lil!!li!II~~iiill':lnti"- -
S).
~..e
l! J I
~,_",',~'.'-~',~-- '--'~'~'''' " "-~"" ~-'",,-~ - - ,~""'~"
"iLJ.~"!i.'ililll!dIfll1;j~~Pl-
0 C'} l~_)
t C "'1
~ ~ r s:: :7:-
-r) ;:-;:"~
1'"1"1:-"---
""---,-'
""-----.-.-"
h () ~~-~
8 .
fA.) 2 '1 c;::() --0
......... ~ );:C'" ~,
~l~
"- () ( () p' - :"-)
I l.."._
...... Z
~ '-- ~ t? -I ::..J
-< --J
~ ~
J
Iiliil~imlit.fj~'-
_ 'He
,.,10
~"".h~ .~ ~~~~ h 1..-"" ~ '. ~
I:
1,.
II
." ~' '~
;';l- _:J-
,
SHERIFF'S RETURN
OUT OF COUNTY
CASE NO: 2001-02888 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
MINIUM MARK M DDS ET AL
VS
MUSCARELLI ANTHONY C ET AL
R. Thomas Kline
, Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff who being
duly sworn according to law, says, that he made a diligent search and
and inquiry for the within named DEFENDANT
, to wit:
MUSCARELLI ANTHONY C T/D/B/A
MUKIES SEAL COATING
but was unable to locate Him
in his bailiwick. He therefore
deputized the sheriff of YORK
County, Pennsylvania, to
serve the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE
On June
14th , 2001 , this office was in receipt of the
attached return from YORK
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Out of County
Surcharge
Dep York Co
18.00
9.00
10.00
18.76
.00
55.76
06/14/2001
JOHNSON DUFFIE
s~
R. omas Kline
Sheriff of Cumberland County
STEWART & WElD
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this ::u,~, day of ~
.2Ml1 A.D.
Cl Q~
I 'f"'-- pr~thonotaT~
COUNTY OF YORK
OFFICE OF THE SHERIFF
SERVICE CALL
(717) 771-9601
28 EAST MARKET ST,. YORK. PA 17401
SHERIFF SERVICE
PROCESS RECEIPT and AFFIDAVIT OF RETURN
INSTRUCTIONS
PLEASE TYPE ONLY LINE 1 THRU 12
DO NOT DETACH ANY COPIES
1. PLAINTIFF/SI
Mark M. Minium, O.O.S. and Miilium & Kearns Orthodontists
3. DEFENDANT/Sf
2. COURT NUMBER
? . T. 1
-4. TYPE OF WRIT OR COMPLAINT
Noti9~ & Complaint
Anthon C. Muscarelli t d a Muk' at'n
SERVE { 5. NAME OF INDIVIDUAL, COMPANY, CORPORATION,-ETC. TO SERVE OR DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY TO BE LEVIED, ATTACHED, OR SOLD.
........ Anthony C. Muscarelli. t/d/b/a Mukje's Se"l r(wt-ing
...". 6. ADDRESS (STREET OR RFO WITH BOX NUMBER, APT. NO_. CITY, BORD, T\NP., STATE AN ZIP CODE)
AT 720 A Colony Drive. York COllnty. York.P)\ 17LlnLl
7. INDICATE SERVICE: Q PERSONAL 0 PERSOJlfIWCHARGE ~EPUT]ZEC:llTn~-J;~'f.A'1Nfl 0 1ST CLASS MAIL 0 POSTED 0 OTHER-
NOW 5/] 1 /01 .,20_ I, SHERIFF OF ~OUNTY PA. do her~bY tize the sheriff of
York COUNTY to exec ' andm er ere faccording
to law. This deputization being made at the request and risk of the piaintiff.
'. SHERIFF CUNTY
8. SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS OR OTHER INFORMATION THAT WIll ASSIST IN EXPEDITING SERVICE:
~CumberJ.and
OUT OF COUNTY
CUMS ERLAND
ADVAN'CEDFELPAID BY SHERIFF
sheriff levying upon or attaching any property under within writ may leave same
ehment, without liability on the part of such deputy or the sheriff to any plaintiff
NOTE: ONLY APPLICABLE ON WRIT OF EXECUTION: N.B. WAIVER OF WATCHMAN ~ An ep
without a watchman, in custody of whomever is found in possession, after notifying person vy or a
herein for any loss, destruction, or removal of any property before s rifl's sale hereof.
9. TYPE NAME and ADDRESS of ATTORNEY J 0 [NATO
March C. Duffie, Esquire
10. TELEPHONE NUMBER 11. DATE FilED
5-11-01
12. SEND NOTICE OF SERVICE COPY TO NAME AND ADDRESS BELOW: (This ar must be completed if notice is to be mailed).
MarlkU~.EltJ-u~'jBi},OEsS.H,EIYJJfuson, Duffie, Stewart & Weidner, 301 N. Market St" Lernoyne, FA 17043
~'-- __ SpACE BELOW FOR USE OF THE SHERIFF - 00 NOT WRITE BEL.OW TI:lISUNE
13. I acknowledge receipt of the writ 14. DATE RECEIVED 15. Expiratiooll:learing Date
orcompla;ntas;,d;oa'edabove. R. AHRENS 5-15-01 6-10-01
16. HOW SERVED: PERSONAL {
RESIDENCE {
POSTED ( )
POE(')'
SHERIFF'S OFFICE ( )
OTHER (
SEE REMARKS BELOW
17. I hereby certify and return a NOT FOUND because'l am unable to locate the individual, company, etc. named aoove._(See remarks bef!)w.)
18. NAME AND TITLE OF INDIVIDUAL SERVED f LIST ADDRESS HERE IF NOT.SHOIJVJ'{"ABOVE (Refationship hDefendant) 19. Date of SerVice 20. Time otSel\dce
In1.
21.ATTEMPTS Date Time Miles
-3 I 115'. 1?'
22'REMARK~ ~bV~ ~ ~_~~
~~~a y~~\tL~4~
~~.~
~
\1
'~ 23, Advance Costs
~ 100.00 9.00
34. Foreign County Costs
40. Costs Due or Refund
42. day of
44. Signature of
ep.---Sheriff
ignature of York_
County Sheriff
i'lILLP'.i'j M. BOSE
45. DATE
47. DATE
6/11/01
49. DATE
51. DA'TE RECEIVED
1. Vv'I-IlTE - Issuing Authority 2. PINK~Attomey 3. CANARY ~-Sheriffs Office 4. BLUE - Sheriff's Office
"'~l~'ll!tifi',f~~',f",:''-~' ,<~
tt::.
"'-
"'''-. ;
0..1
::r
c.'..::
b!.ct ~
lIJ:..:;I: a.. 0-
:;l><CI) ~
::;'i'''i"~ tn>
~-"^,- ~,-,,^,~~_. ""''1~:~~;--'~ :
~ .
=
E::
.....
o.
.
U-
o
J,.I!ii!I!IJ,~!lIUllrllll ]IJl]LI1 ![~:.... tL ,.... .. ...,~. ..",... ...," ..
w
'.
"-",-.'
)
1h 21 LJd 91 AUlJ 10,
Vd')Il:!OA
:/.:11131-19 .:103tH.:l.:lO
..03^,3031:1.. ....
~~
" ...I
~
.,~,- ~..k.._ .... L.
=
, :
,... >_ ;,--J ,'c
_.._ .,';C-. ~ '. _'. ~ _j~,;
.
Johnson, Duffie~ Stewart & Weidner
By: Mark C. Duffie
LD. No. 75906
301 Market Street
P. O. Box 109
Lemoyne, PelIDsylval1ia 17043-0109
(717) 761-4540
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S., and
MINIUM & KEARNS ORTHODONTISTS, a
General Partnership,
Plaintiff(s)
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. ^,-.>>prC'<..l:l7r:i7.Y'-J
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
ANTHONY C. MUSCARELLI, t/d/b/a
MUKIE'S SEAL COATING,
Defendant(s)
NOTICE TO DEFEND
TO THE DEFENDANT:
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following
pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a
written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defense or objections to
the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you
and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the
compiaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other
rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A
LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO
FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
. (717) 249-3166
: 145733
th 2t lJd 5t ^HlJ to,
I
Vd')IHOA
.:Lll1l3H'S.:lO 301:l.:l0
,,03^1303H ..
ROM RECORD
'fRUE COP!}. ~Il.lmo-""-
....l.....fu. <,,,,,,, '. .".'" '."..'.~.. ...~- ..
~~;~;~p
I.
~~lIliWi("~
,-I , ." ,',;'"
.n, --,-,.:"~:'-,; "~., .'lL ~_.~,
~
,Johnson, Duffie, Stewart & Weidner
By: Mark C. Duffie
LD. No. 75906
301 Market Street
P. O. Box 109
Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043-0109
(717) 761-4540
Attorneys for Plaintiff
MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S., and
MINIUM & KEARNS ORTHODONTISTS, a
General Partnership
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO.
Plaintiffs
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
ANTHONY C. MUSCARELLI, t/d/b/a
MUKIE'S SEAL COATING,
Defendant(s)
COMPLAINT
AND NOW COMES the Plaintiffs, MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S., and MINIUM & KEARNS
ORTHODONTISTS, by and through their attorneys, Johnson, Duffie, Stewart & Weidner, and files this
Complaint and in support thereof avers as follows:
1. Plaintiff, Mark M. Minium, D.D.S., is an adult individual residing at 1141 Dry Powder Circle,
Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
2. Plaintiff, Minium & Kearns Orthodontists, is a domestic general partnership with a principal
place of business located at 1412 Bridge Street, New Cumberland, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
17070. Plaintiff, Minium & Kearns Orthodontists, also has an office located at 4509 Union Deposit Road,
Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania 17111.
3. Plaintiff, Mark M. Minium, D.D.S. and Mark J. Kearns, D.D.S., M.S., formed the domestic
general partnership, Minium & Kearns Orthodontists on ~I" I ,19(1:;-<. At all times relevant hereto, the
principal place of business remained at 1412 BridgeJ St:~et, New ~mberland, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania 17070.
~~,
. ,
1-, ,
n-" "
" ~L I.
-'
'C~o.v
.
4. Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli is an adult individual residing at 720A Colony Drive, York,
York County, Pennsylvania 17404. At all times relevant hereto, Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli, was
trading and doing business as Mukie's Seal Coating. The address for Mukie's Seal Coating at all times
relevant hereto was 720A Colony Drive, York, York County, Pennsylvania 17404.
5. On or about October 4, 1995, Plaintiffs, Mark M. Minium, D.D.S. and Minium & Kearns
Orthodontists, entered into an agreement with Anthony C. Muscarelli, t/d/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating, wherein
Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli agreed to perform services upon Plaintiff's parking lot which included seal
coating over existing blacktop as well as grading and installing new blacktop as well as curbing and lights.
6. Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli, t/d/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating, failed to perform the services
set forth in the agreement in a workman-like fashion and Plaintiff hired another contractor to repair and
complete the project. A true and correct copy of said sales agreement is attached hereto and incorporated
herein as Exhibit "A".
7. As a result of the Defendant's negligence, the parties entered into a settlement agreement
dated August 5, 1997, to resolve a Fifteen Thousand Eight Hundred and Seventy-Six and 48/100
($15,876.48) Dollar claim to reimburse Plaintiff for payments rendered for services that were either
performed negligently or not performed whatsoever. A true and correct copy of said letter agreement is
attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit "8".
8. Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli made payment according to the agreement periodically
after executing the settlement agreement in the amount of Five Thousand Five Hundred ($5,500.00) Dollars.
9. Defendant has failed to make any payments under the settlement agreement since June
1998.
10. There remains a balance of Ten Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-Six Dollars and Forty-
Eight Cents ($10,376.48) due and owing from Defendant Anthony C. Muscarelli, t/d/b/a Mukie's Seal
Coating, to Plaintiffs, Minium, & Kearns Orthodontists, and Mark M. Minium D.D.S.
11. Despite repeated attempts to seek payment in this matter by telephone and correspondence,
Plaintiffs have not received any payment pursuant to the agreement since June, 1998.
~-~,~"
;'.- ~ ,".
j, _I . ~"
.i,'
_'-o,.'_,~,,~;}
COUNT I
BREACH OF CONTRACT
Mark M. Minium. D.D.S. and Minium & Kearns Orthodontists
.:!!...
Anthony C. Muscarelli. tld/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating.
12. Paragraphs 1 through 11 are incorporated as if set forth fully herein.
13. On August 5, 1997, the parties hereto entered into an agreement whereby the Defendant.
Anthony C. Muscarelli agreed to settle a claim with Plaintiff for Fifteen Thousand Eight Hundred and
Seventy-Six and 48/100 ($15,876.48) Dollars.
14. The terms of the settlement agreement attached hereto as Exhibit "6" includes One
Thousand ($1,000.00) Dollars upon acceptance of the agreement and Five Hundred ($500.00) Dollars a
month commencing on September 1, 1997 with a balloon payment on August 1, 1998.
15. Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli, t/d/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating, has failed to make payment
as required under the agreement and therefore is in breach of the settlement agreement for which Plaintiff
seeks the balance due and owing, Ten Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-Six Dollars and Forty-Eight Cents
($10,376.48) plus interest and costs.
~--
~:
j ,L I .
.' ~ .' ~_.~ -,
!l!IIclM!ijjf",l
!
COUNT II
BREACH OF CONTRACT
Mark M. Minium. D.D.S. and Minium & Kearns Orthodontists
~
Anthony C. Muscarelli. tld/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating.
16. Paragraphs 1 through 15 are incorporated as if set forth fully herein.
17. On or about October 1, 1995, the parties entered into a Sales Agreement whereby the
Defendant, Anthony C. Muscarelli, lIdlbla Mukie's Seal Coating, agreed to provide certain improvements as
set forth herein to Plaintiff's property located at 1412 Bridge Street, New Cumberland, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania 17070.
18. Defendant failed to perform these services in a workmanlike fashion and therefore, is in
breach of the Sales Agreement and the contract between Plaintiffs and Defendant.
19. Plaintiffs, due to Defendant's negligence, suffered damages in the amount of Fifteen
Thousand Eight Hundred Seventy-Six 48/100 ($15,876.48) Dollars.
20. Plaintiffs have received Five Thousand Five Hundred ($5,500.00) Dollars representing
reimbursement of those damages from Defendant. Plaintiffs seek the balance due and owing of Ten
Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-Six and 48/100 ($10,376.48) Dollars plus interest and costs.
r- - -.lll.;.o",:;- - ~ "~~1
,
L
) I
~"~o. ,-
"'--lil~~~)
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs request this Honorable Court to award to Plaintiffs Ten Thousand Three
Hundred Seventy-Six Dollars and Forty-Eight Cents ($10,376.48) plus interest, costs and attorney's fees as
well as other damages as this Honorable Court deems fair and equitable.
Respectfully submitted,
JOHNSON, DUFFIE, STEWART & NER
M k C. Duffie
A orney I.D. No.7
301 Market Street
P. O. Box 109
Lemoyne, PA 17043-01
(717) 761-4540
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
DATED:
5/1
,
,2001
:143492
.~=".~
- "
l c, ~ L
" L, I '~
,. ,~-~' "-~d
VERIFICA TION
I, MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S. and MINIUM & KEARNS ORTHODONTISTS, do verify that the
statements made in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and
belief. I understand that false statements made herein are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. ~4904
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S.
'~4 /1t ~~ /)?JS
MINIUM & KEARNS ORTHODONTISTS
~ ./JAA --V < ,
~~. P/I~ rrl&e'#ef.-~~
MARK M. MINIUIM. D.D.S.
-' O);;d
Dated:
;/,/1# / (/ I
I
:143492
u-
ilIIll~^ _,""" "I
" -" ""
~O),
.~.
,-I
; i. I
,- -~. -'"'1:
?_'J~_ >
::. .....
'''-.
-.......
,-
. MUKtE"S SEAL COATiNG ".
, CONTRACT NUMSEFl
.1 ~.
"'. I
,"\'.'
\~t,' ;.
;," .
.:.<'
..,
?20 A Colony Dt1ve
York. PA 17404
$54.1870
, SALES AGREEMEtfT
. ," .," '. \: .
~~~-~'~M~i~ ~.M:?"I~M O,O.s
ADDRESS 14 JJ At cD6l. 3'i .
CITY o~ ~!,.,/'I~ STATE p", ZIP \ "'()In
8lLLlNG ADOAESS IF DlPFERENT;
TELEPIiQI\(I! ,)""'-/~ ~
V;1. II PI
/,1>1,."-' MQ 'TA.ls,'Il'I't' J ",~".s (..Si'4"tc.'T ')
A<.vM$/Ilo'" ;)0(.<<' (A!. ae~tlkJ "l,. "",...fc.- ')
Ow JJt.,'C'" -ro ~<c..t.~~A,I.JC. .for- AI \ tAl.)>/) ~f+hJJ
Description of work agreed upon:
.___ Equipment
~th:ln Quantity To Be UHd
-
,
Aem8rfc1:
,. .....
Oomrnenia
() -AI. 'I /1'1' ~ CtS07~
bVC:Y. e,..-d;-1;v(,. t$~P (.; 'C:!H"6$-"If~~
Oil ~6-)
~~ (:r fIJ
10 Mlr"'~ lJD- .>TD<\I Curbwr (C..",.>tt) 1'15
C~~'l'\'x.l:;;v &v...~,,~\ I'/I4cA::r'VL 4 'ltd
TlIlMl . "AYMINT 1:1 600 . o'
"
~~ ~d - IO.-l.{-'t5 Cull "rIce'(Ino1udlnQ"_ To) . -L~igO D:
1.I,l1bO ..,0 o'^'eo....cf~1ro,iJ.
O(~IQ~iT oer 14~
$ \~\ ~OO'
Baa-net on Completion
Balance To Be F1rwnoecl .
EXHIBtT "Au
clq W~cl:ll 000c S0 "lOO
9Lc8 8SS L1L : "ON 3NOHd lSlluoPOYlJO SUJed~ pue wnlu1W WO~~
""",,""~ ~
~ "
L l
i L __
_ _~, , ' _c,.~__""~.
,
'.'
'\.. '
"
,
,
" .
( ~\':
-""-~-~... ._~.~.-
d \ \ f '. .
.jv .?J ',:',' , " (A esy ltaJ'CQrpor~lioll' "
~ ~'" ,i;]'<Otth'Duke Stc ,to York, pen~ania 401-1282' Telephone; 7l7.:&il!-4900 0 FAX, 7JH43.9039' "'-'
.'^' ~burg Street, ~.O.llox 606 ~ ~..t Berlin, l'ennsylvnni. 17316 ; Telephone: 717-259-9592 . FAX: 7I 7.2W:~~~8 :'.
/;' "'_ q\3Iq) ~---_._- 9-10-"1). ~
.. C'D.\l~ ~"t~~ of.{'..'(Q
"-C Cculed f\ttor~ 'I-- 4(J1CI;M.(I mlj~ \010- ~~ -::'1'~ . .
1\0 ~otJfCI%-B. ('e.<:..~uw.ifd" . .~" h~(,f\CuL{)
i (lr\-o,o kll(.l K~Y) tel 'fo.Q. a..rl"CWt . uS <^- ~ .Q:., ~ lSoc, C{>
. cl.vo I ~ -415, '8'?lJJ.l.{8 a6 vR X;{:. ~.clc ru:;)- &oJ b!,l Q)($""
ie0- l\'W\I.U. "1"\ lc~ of. '""JJ/lJ9? 0.c.u.t ~~ ~
.'. ',\ 9'Q.97 tClf/eCl. a.J-iofll~ 0{jC1.1h IO-~-q7
. , :! ~ tet+ mes~, W rvw~
to Cat I i?0'I- he ~ 1\Ci- ~
to,\I.&I... ~ t A-\i:Cf~'1 v..'l VI
~~v.s.. a~ 5Cct1' (),5.
~ WLlo hIm,
",,'
...----.
.
,
,('
A.ugust S, 1997
,<
Dr. Mark Mimium
1411 Bridge Street
New Cumberland, PA 17070
Dear OJ.'. Mimium:
We represent Mukie's Seal Coating, Inc., and I am writing to you regarding the $15,000 claim
for reimbursement for services rendered.
Regarding the substance of the claim, my client is in the process of suing Cooper Paving,
Marvin Schnapp and Advanced Concrete, the sub(.:ontractors who did the actual work on your
job, for the entire balance of your reimbursement claim.
In an effort to sati-sfy your c1airr1'iiurlng the'pendihg litigation ahd"to resolve this matter with you-
amicably, my client has proposed the following payment schedule: $1,000 down upon your
acceptance of this proposal, $500 a month commencing on Sel;'tember] 1997 and on the first
day of every month thereafter, with a balloon payment on August 1, 1998 or upon the receipt
of a damage award in the above-referenced litigation, whichever comes earlier.
Jon C. c()untl.:s~; . (~;.Lry M. {;ilhl.'rt ,. P{'{e!' H. AIiJ(~W..; .. 'UI":I'l'lll't. V. Ymlllg! . ~1!~'h~d l\~~)u~t~;lt~\ .. ~h:t.r~).r\ E. ,M)'~'f~, . ..Hill~~\\~ll>'n'Y'
TholllilS D. O'Shl"iI . ]ohn D. l'lin{'hIM~lgh" .. l'r~ll\k II. Clllllllt':b . J'hL'ph V U.lrk. It .. .~.1I"' A. 1\lIs[11I . 1\(-1111 1\. ~,llh",llll'
'..11.\0 c,dJJlill(!d ill DC' HIP". l/ll.~I' adll/l//(ltl/pllll1af. '/./...11 ';iJ,xO[i()}/. ':lh:/i _'IIIIIIJ;;I'd to /1-/1, fillr. ';\:,,'lllJIJ/!"/k(/ 1(' Wi Hill"
9d W~50:11 000Z S0 '+00
9LZB BSS L1L : .ON 3NOHd +Sl+uoPO~+~O su~ea~ pue wnlUlW WO~3
EXHIBIT "E"
~,~"
.
l.;
! ~
i,1
, ~ '"
,', '<',-. '., ~ ~~j
" -::---L':':
.__":.It..~. >~~ ,,'. ~, .
. ..._.~ .. '.. ..!'l .
I .. . ,... ~ . .
, ,- -.......;. r v". """'"'\/'#......~
, . " .......... . ...
. '.01'..1 ...... ... \... '. ~. '...... ,.. .... ...... .
,.'
..... . .....1,:-.-,
\. . ._.. .... . \ "
. ~~\"''1
. NYfbY!.
Lette.~~ 41 Dr. Mark Mimium
DatI4 Aug\l5t 5,' 1997
P~e .w.' '; ." .
.
My client wishes to express his gratitude for your understanding and patience in this 11l2tter.
If you are in agreement with the terms of this settlement proposal, please sign below.
.- Sinc:.erllly. - .
Countess.Gllberte Andrews
~"'-:~'. Vt.- ,1L-
__.............. '~_.. C n' '.._.
..-.......-:
. ,
By: Joseph p, CliU'k, n.
JPCImIa
. cc: Tony Muscarelli
, ACCEPTED.:
,
,~~.
Tony USClU'cUi
~~4-?J(~
Mark Mimium
.-...- ... . ....--
,.~~ .
. ;'~
,
.".
,,~
,.:
.'
. ,
t,
,
~"'-,~
Ld W~60:.. 000c S0 '100
EXHIBIT "B"
9LCB BSS L.L 'ON 3NOHd lS!lUOroYl~O sU~Ea~ r~E'Wn!U!W '; wo~j
"~W..iti"~t!._~~'1Ilii_l:t~~rn~~:tiJ;J!iftil>iiil$1~~~~~i'$.%jiIi1;'i,-j~t"IW"l\'i)_N.lt,w~~~k-!~1,~~tW~nill~.li'-{i.\il-;;ri>Oil~~~W/iIltJ.-""-~"'''''~~j~~~~~M-S'.""-'r."'"
~s
~
"
,
_ \_.-' t-l ~~\ d
,.... i \._., (: \i-
\-; -, \ ".' ,>; (..
\,('\
",\ (;
'.~ I lj
. "\"V>
H'U";\i,~
j~\"."
,,,~-4'Itfr>r n,,~LLJU!] mtllWL ,.~~=_,. ,._. H.U~m.,._",,_,..~p_~ _<~_~r<
~-~
LLd
;}' ,
";.\';' ,"
\ \ k~,~
.,.JJ.
i\H;\1l
~
itE7
~
~
-
,- "
"~~. .--)-~ -,~ ,-'_,'_.' - -"'-"',.',,,,- "'I"_I'."'",~,^ ,~,.. ".__ ,-
;., ,-,,~ ~ ,-_ok
- ......
,
.
FES 1 5 2001 s
Johnson, Duffie, Stewart & Weidner
By: Mark C. Duffie, Esquire
I.D. No. 75906
301 Market Street
P. O. Box 109
Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043-0109
(717) 761-4540
mcd@jdsw.com
Attorneys for Plaintiff
MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S., and
MINIUM & KEARNS
ORTHODONTISTS, a General
Partnership,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON
PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
NO.. Docket # OI~J..FPP eUI'l
I~
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
ANTHONY C. MUSCARELLI, tld/b/a
MUKIE'S SEAL COATING,
Defendant
PROPOSED ORDER
AND NOW, this I ~ ~ay of F~
, 2005, upon consideration of
the attached Petition filed pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 230.2, the above action is reinstated
with direction to Plaintiff to reinstate the Complaint and affect service upon the
Defendant.
J.
:244438
~~o~
~'\
o
.- ,_. . ""'-' ,,- ,.- - C'~",",'-_' -, ,'J c-~",>)k, ',,, - _,'_~. dO' " _ "^.
.~
,
Johnson, Duffie, Stewart & Weidner
By: Mark C. Duffie, Esquire
I.D. No. 75906
301 Market Street
P. O. Box 109
Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043-0109
(717) 761-4540
rncd@jdsw.com
Attorneys for Plaintiff
MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S., and
MINIUM & KEARNS
ORTHODONTISTS, a General
Partnership,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON
PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
NO. Dock.et # b (J' ,['-----E,.
01- ;;2.,pp~ L.l<.>' - 'vL
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
ANTHONY C. MUSCARELLI, tld/b/a
MUKIE'S SEAL COATING,
Defendant
PETITION TO REINSTA TE THE ACTION
PURSUANT TO Pa.R.C.P. 230.2
AND NOW, comes the Petitioner/Plaintiff, Mark M. Minium, D.D.S., and Minium &
Kearns Orthodontists, by and through their counsel, Johnson, Duffie, Stewart &
Weidner, and files this Petition to reinstate the above action and in support thereof
avers as follows.
1 . The undersigned counsel for the Plaintiff have filed a Complaint in the
above-captioned matter on or about May 11, 2001.
- - ,,-- - - ~ -~-'",.., ,,-~- 0 - , _. -'""', '.-t .'," -"_"'" f:<,',':ui.;' if-' J"l",,""..'.;. c~ _;;~.J""
'r
,
2. The Sheriff of Cumberland County deputized the Sheriff of York County to
affect service upon the Defendant. The Sheriff of York County was unable to locate the
Defendant as the Defendant had moved and they foreclosed upon his home.
3. Counsel for Plaintiff has been attempting to locate Defendant but to date
has been unable to do so. Therefore, there has been no opposition in this matter to
date.
4. To the best of the undersigned's information and knowledge, the
aforementioned matter was purged on December 30, 2004. The undersigned
discovered the same by contacting the Prothonotary by telephone.
5. The undersigned counsel did not receive a copy of the Notice of Proposed
Termination of Court Case and therefore was not afforded the opportunity to remit the
statement of intention to proceed,
6, The undersigned counsel did not receive a copy of the Order terminating
the case and therefore is unable to file this Petition within the thirty day window as
allotted by Pa,R.C,P. 230.2(d)(2).
7. The undersigned counsel filed this Petition immediately upon discovering
that the matter had been terminated without notice.
=
,~ ,~
,-
_.p,--' ,',--
. ".Lo' I ,..",,' ,'- ~'_" ---'''''~"' .C~, -""--'~;;O:,~.~",-~'i,,,- ", ,'.-. "~~'"'i!l1!i
, "'l'~
8, Should the undersigned counsel have received a copy of the Notice of
Proposed Termination of the court case, the undersigned would have promptly filed a
Statement of Intention to Proceed.
9. The undersigned was unable to file said Petition within said thirty days as
the undersigned only discovered that the matter had been terminated on December 30,
2004, by a telephone call to the Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office. Therefore,
said Petition was filed immediately upon said discovery.
WHEREFORE, the Petitioner prays this Honorable Court to reinstate said action,
Respectfully submitted,
Dated:
RI,%S
.
Wi~lml.1Wi;~Ni!l$!ifjIiMW.m!I:~iM""""\"'~i~~jJ;"jl,~,.~&it';""i!l~~!iiI~;~";''' ~~",-, ',~,
)~.-.
~~'
,_~': ,L ~,~JU~o'oL,-" lKn_ . J[[J[L JU,tL~,__~., ,___~,_" _~_ __'"_~<>",,,"'_'~,~~_ e ~. _~. "_' ~ _, ~_
~ ,v_
-.-.'
,""'- 'l!i.iiIlI~
ro_ -.0
"'~
"'1
'.r
,
l"--,' ()
c::,
:;;;~:) ~n
".....-,
1'.1 .." :r
r'1 ;g
CU rn
-1-' rn
.;:.- ~j9
()--)
~",J \Tl
-0 C~?~j
-',,'.
i'5 n'l
w.' -...,
... '1,;.-
----1 ~~J
~( N .<
~
"~ "
< ~
-~ ~ ~~"...~, ",~~u~"'~""""-,,"L'>'," ",""-' <'; _ _~~_. '<".',_ ~ ,~~,_, _'~',..,,"
."0 "i;,:,;
JERRY R. DUFFIE
RICHAIID W STEWART
-C. ROY WEIDNER. JR.
EDMUND G. MYERS
DAVID W. DELuCE
)011" A STATLER
IEFfEI\SON J. SIIIPMAN
RALPII H. WHlGHT, JR.
MAHK C. DUFfIE
JOliN R. NINOSKY
MICHAEL J. CASSIDY
MELISSA PEEL GREEVY
ROBERT M. WALKER
WADE D. MANLEY
LAW OFFICES
JOHNSON
DUFFIE
OF COUNSEL
HORACE A. JOHNSON
F. LEE SHIPMAN
BRUCE J. GROSSMAN"
"admitted in NY only
\-FWTl.:R'S ES.T. NO. 11 '"i
[';-1\..1 /\! 1, .1Vi Cn~r;;,id.s\v.!~Om
February 11, 2005
Curt Long, Prothonotary
Cumberland County Courthouse
One Courthouse Square
Carlisle, PA 17013
Re: Mark M. Minium, D.D.S., and Minium & Kearns Orthodontists v.
Anthony C. Muscarelli, t/d/b/a Mukie's Seal Coating
Dear Mr. Long:
j"
r
r
Enclosed herewith for filing please find an original and five copies of the Petition to Reinstate
the Action Pursuant to Pa,R.C,P. 230,2 in regard to the above-captioned action. Please return the
clocked-in copies to the undersigned in the self-addressed, stamped envelope provided.
~;::
"
i
U
As always, if you have any questions or comments, please do not hesitate to call. If I am
unavailable, please feel free to speak with my legal assistant, Deborah Ziesman. If you call other
than during our normal business hours, which are 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. on weekdays, my Voice
Mail extension is #116 and Deborah's is #126, Please feel free to leave a message with either one
of us, and we will return your call. If you would prefer, you may contact me through my direct e-mail
address, mcd@jdsw.com.
"
Ii
[:i
Very truly yours,
JOHNSON, DUFFIE, STEWART & WEIDNER
dz:244728
4985-1 0
Enclosures
cc: Mark M, Minium, DDS
4t/~Ci)~
Mark rD'Uffle Ij'-
:L/J4 - ~?~L ~ a LA:) 1'1-( f)..I-~ ~
o-P--C; Q:/ ~Ly ~f..)e. ,.u6 dclc~j
-PDfL.. --J-lL.- -nc-PJ. t.. C2v ~af Loc.;d"c)1-I~)
'2uy~<Vl.:L .
301 MARKET STREET P.O. BOX 109 LEMOYNE, PENNSYLVANJA 17043.0109
WWW.jDSWCOM 717,761.4540 FAX: 717.761.3015 MAIL@jDSWCOM
JOHNSON, DUFFIE, STEWART & WEIDNER, P,C.
Johnson, Duffle, Stewart & Weidner
By: Mark C. Duffle
I.D. No. 75906
301 Market Street
P. O. Box 109
Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043-0109
(717) 761-4540
MARK M. MINIUM, D.D.S., and,
MINIUM & KEARNS ORTHODONTISTS, a
General Partnership,
Plaintiff(s)
V.
ANTHONY C. MUSCARELLI, t/d/b/a
MUKIE'S SEAL COATING,
Defendant(s)
THELPROTHQI?OTARY
Attorneys for AAWs 'Z AN 8= 36
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
PENNSYLVANIA
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 01-2888
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
STATEMENT OF INTENTION TO PROCEED
TO THE HONORABLE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
It is the intention of the Plaintiffs in this case to proceed with the above-captioned case.
JOHNSON, DUFFIE, STEWAR7-8j WEIDNER
Dated: 6h( By:
Mark C. Duffie
Attorney I.D. No.
:457681