Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-05417PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL (Must be typewritten and sulxnitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUN'T'Y Please list the following case: (Check one) (XX) for JURY trial at the next teen of civil court. ( ) for trial without a jury. ----------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) (check one) Dale Wintermeyer (XX) Civil Action - I,aw ( ) Appeal from Arbitration ( ) (other) (Plaintiff) vs. Josue Salinas-Valdez The trial list will be called on 5/16/06 and Trials commence on 6/12/06 vs. (I~fendant ) Pretrials will beheld on 5/24/06 (Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials.) (The party listing this case for trial shall provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to all counsel, pursuant to local Rule 214.1.) No. 5417 Civil X69[.2001 Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe: Randy C. Greene, Esquire, Dugan, Brinkmann, Maginnis and Pace Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: Dale Wintermeyer, Pro Se This case is ready for trial. Ikzte: March 13, 2006 Print C. Greene, Esquire ~~ ~ Attorney for: Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez f9r ll5s ,:.~%anrxz'4i i" A`s"M3~~Ntikvcn!.. n:~;anri4u,.~aml~~a'.. to C~ fv a c r. `EL'F ~ !~~}f': ~°,r Sua ~ ~ ~~ v3• ~ ~~ ~~i-° .~ ~ y ~~ ~~ C. T ~~ ~ { .. O -C ~~~ ~r DALE WINTERMEYER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. JOSEU SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant N0. 01-5417 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 4th day of January, 2006, we have explained to the Plaintiff that the issue with regard to representation of him by the Angino law firm has previously been settled by order of Judge Hoffer. We will not readdress that issue in this case. We have further advised the Plaintiff that he has three options facing him at the current time: 1. Obtain new counsel to represent him. 2. Represent himself. 3. Accept the policy limits that have been tendered by the Defendant to settle this case. We advise Plaintiff to seek other counsel immediately to at least review this matter on his behalf. We have further advised Plaintiff that this matter is to be relisted by the Prothonotary for the next civil term which occurs during the week of March 13, 2006. The Prothonotary is directed to relist this matte that term of Court. e ~~ t~ 0~ ~~~0 the Court, Edward E. Guido, J. ~, : _ .. 1.-vnmaukdPeaNzan,~a~ue,'~i'>,.~:ia[=e;4ii:.a~iwa+s;hna~t~.gamktaaa;ak,->~rr :±+xaasx~d I`11. .~i8' ,-~. -_•,`-""•=wartNfl { iv 11~ ~ , r•LJ '~ ~~~ R~~ (~~~Y ~` i~U~~G Y Dale Wintermeyer Pro Se Randy C. Green, Esquire For the Defendant Court Administrator :lfh r Mr• LLi -~~'rnrurr- Pl~pt~c _Jnsv ~ ~a I~na~ I~ez-Dom,-rrnd,~.nt~~ C~am herin~, r~ Cou nt 'mart S o . C , 1, -- N~~n Pa-0 Tunc din cu~e~- I.is~in9 Case For ~rqqumenty Pursuant To For lack Of P~o~`ecut~on 1. em~i~ this_ To Praeci~e Fob flo~ian To I~ismiss° have revious)yy res on~ec~ ~o this issue o att- to c~r~umven't ©r quash ~n~/ 1Pga! Ri h ~~ ~~-ti ate -_a~-~~l_u.~r~.~a.~auit l Or coml~en~`ator ~ama es~ ppur~~uant ~~ P! ~inti~fs ~nsu~e~' An ea ores Fo~l,~ Co Taint Should Not Be 1~ismiSSe~ul~ich l su~m~tte'~; to this )-lonorable Cou~'t e~.rona) on Fed, a3 ~OOW ar~d I alsp maile~ a coP a the a or~mentione~ 1~ainti`~ A su, r to ~h~ ~~ ~~nts aorne ~ Rand c, G-re~~~ an t~~t ~at~, Y Y a, z am - n~okin and avai I in n1 ~~I a a ~ °f le al Ri hts ~rs-uant to t~e I~/~` ~on~t`tutior~ c~nd scan to -~he I'aa Con.~titution ~hrou out an~ Burin e . ~n 1n ~is osition and 1 ~~taifl9the le al Ri to i~e a 9MotioY~ Fob' Re~res.r 0 G~'ieWances ~~ a~ t-m~, ~ y 3a la~~ie~~ tat it is the le a~ Bat~f d cz rosecutin Wt~Orn~ to fipSeCute C~'II~T'il1d~ aCtlD~f a~d Uiolation~ and >;hi~ Coml~p) aint is a Civil Hctiol1. ~ y, Sann a ter ~ ankh legg~~r~n~ m mptotc cle, ulei'e ~am- a,gec~ b ~os~u~ ~alinas U~"dez~_i ~eaL9 un ~~ ~n the. !one- ook of le al ~'epre.rentation by ~h~ lava.~ irnl Angino`~Rovne~ i hat a~vi~'ti~eme~rlt state..s~ ~an~ r~ re~nt~ ~~ No Recov~~ ~Na Fee, ~I.~ince I`~~as in` used ~nd T coulrk not work due to m~ inJu~ies~and ~ di~ not have. am incomes dece~~ec~ ~ e d~s~asit° Cl frbm the )au~ ~-`m o~ An ino~Ro~'neV~ i _ a cco~ an e'e. an , com p l i en ~e ~ - th th~i ~ ~e resente~ a~_Vi.rti,re.ment w~ich wQS re resent. d to a~e as _rtn~e~ ~o cudnente~~an~ as Q~~irtise~ as~~~No Recover f r ..o._-Fee, 5~b___Z ~~en cQntacte~ tJ~e haw i~'m of Anpino°~RoV~e, ara.~,_ l_4-t~lke~--to ~tt~rn~., ~a~i 1.utz~~}~oJi~'' a r,-~~- ~-e_,~~nt~tiUe~ o t e___~d~_ . irm o_ A~~19mop R®v ere I in- o~'rne~ ~a~ic~~i,w~z_thA_ I _uJ_t~lltedN~ticn an~-the ° , L~~ ~_rm o 1~~ i_nC4 ~a.u~l_er_to o~~ain ul) _reco_m~- ensa iDn aI ;o ~ ---loSS~~s i nc'u~i ~I~~%o a^~ e ce.sts orf~~ paid n m~ rice ~otorcyyc~~ ~~ck too e _u~e ~nr~`ti~bn t~a i ~,~as in- -~e 'af e Josue Salinas ~~m e~ i~aL also tol D vad >1~t~~ that z wanted ha_m ~~ ee~r~.~ent m e ~s~ i tere,rts in court ir1 a Jurt~ rial. A .ter r~ ~n__orm.e~ Da~,d ~.utZ o m ex- e~te repre~entati on ~e~_ul~~ments o f ~~ r~sen~in r~ie ran this )iti anon to anon in a Jrfr ~6'iai Davin Lutz. a ~e~~ ~o ho.r~._ t~rm~-_ _ a~~-.whin h~ o~~ere~ a m-~at)ly bindi_nq cont~-~~t ~7~~~-~-~e~nent ~o me u~hirh is~_cA Lle~ d QQuasi ~Contrgct __ p_u.~s-uant to the Fie ~A9r~ement contract or 1e al re resen~a'tioC1 b the lain ~~'m o 1~-a__~_i_tno4>~ouner~ ~~ic~i is s~i_qq~~ae~ _b ~ ~a~id l~u~Z. Therf.~ore~ Dae~c~ Lutz an~ or_aa_othc~__a~torne_ who is an attorn~ ,, ° `~ ,y ~ep_resentitive_ of the i_aw arm ~_ An _tno~Ro~ner and( ° ° the._ lay ,cm_ o- ~A_n ,no-~_Ra~ner a e d~ty bound ~o re~- 6'e.,se_rtt y b~st~ int~re,rts~_an~ in a Jur~_ Td~a_I as was ~i~l n~ c~ n~ ~'e~re~en~e~ b c(n.c~ ire e ~Qm- ~A~~ UJ~i ~ pcxv_I~_ ~utz Si_ o~~ anr~ ~u~m-tte~ to {I S ~-IonOra~Ie CootACt}on ~1llllzve'~ as the f eco~d shou~sa 6. I hauc nOt ~irpa ~aviL~ ~,a$z~n0r have I ~ire~ to it A `~ v ~p0.v;r~ -~ut and he I u~ irm thu I Qve c-ontrac~ w~~h or r~ppresen~in ~ clairrm _or just dui com- ~e~lsa~ion br ~yy da~maqq~s and infuries are I~qall 1iAbl~e anal ~re d~(~_y_ ~oun'd to upho`~ the i~ucir~r d_u~_ __ Q malntalll_t~lq~ ~ea~au,r re resentate®i1 o m J'e~~ an.d_ro the Cotp~~a~i~E't~_+~n_ _~Il a ~yccessful re~ou r~y _hQ~s- _~~en o~~ainer~ b e-_t~e~ ~av«l_~.utZfor b_ ~oti~er lawyer of the _An~inY~ ~~Uner_ Ian!? irnl ~ur~an~ to o_~rlst;ll b;n~in _ c_ont~-~ct__a~q.r~_e~m_en~ __or re.~.res'entatio~ ~,nr~_ ,urs~tant te~ the Com_plai~t_ that ~as repare~ b _ -~ a ~n~f o thc. _I~~ _~rm Q_ l~n_qq no~~oU~er,Accor~i~ t~ _~he A~A~ ~rcuches~o t~te~_I_eg. a~_~ I;c~~; I;t ,r o .a pe ~i-~ pert ce, b reach o'~ ar~tr~ct and r~ircach o_ ~du_~i a ~~t a c su_~~n)~~~ _ ~Q _ }~A _d rsc ~I i ~g~~ r~d L h_av beeh~.~u~° e tee ~o in _ ective coynse~~u-e to n~ li- ence o _ but s t~ -I_~~'~-II re~re.reptgtiun )ia~i~i~ys nd ~u~ sJbr/each p ~co'rltrGct~alld breach o re~fe- se n.~at io , f `]~ ~a~;.d Butz-- ~e~ __me _t_o ~hre~e_ tat he u,oua__ ~,,e re _.reserlti me and t~eCo__ ai~~_ that he ~i _~_p an~ 5up~1~1i tte~^~~in c~ ~ur~ T~ia~_Ig ~~hi_ch h re pre~,cepted b _ ~1is sLatenlent o_ /Jur I ~i ._~ Dem_ane~. l ince 1~avitt F ~ i~_, ~ has not note -q ~ccor~ance to ~ re_p_res'ent- e eman~° a~ a ~~?r~ _1"r~a_~ _/l~A .T9o_deI Ruh-e rlal C3) a~_p_ r wh ~ ~~ s~~t~~°`~ ~ ~s~epresentat.i o~,r ~a. occur ~/_ a~Ure ~o_ Qct ~s a~~I~cable and ~elaUant~ $d T_ el~e_for~ I abso~ue t?r self from qq.n_~ I__ ~~reb . d `avow my elf o_ gn_ a~r~_a1I cu Iab~e .n_e _li e~ce..r~ e rise/~ ~Io ~ CC 0 s0__~.SS~+DII _I _.~ mi~~'-~ n_a n br~ h ~ f g a d ~.~ ~r~eeehrs o ASR Rubes o__ ~on~ue~ an~ af_an__ breaches o Canon Cou~es wh;~h are the I~e~~( lia i Iltys o f f 4 all o the dutyys a'ctionsJne li ences~un~~ro ersiana) con~u~ts~ i nactdn~.~ t e a l pro~e~ure~ and le ~I i I i n qs which are con~ucte~ and undertaken by t~e la~y~er-!r an~_ sta..... ~~at ~o_rk _as a eats o that law i~m~ q 9~AIItho_ am_ ~~e is°_~-rah erso~ I J~ave nett ye~t a + b~e.ri___~r~Wi_ e~-va~th an~_ cu_~-- u_l ~ene iciccl eeppr~esen~ a~ioYl which ha,s~ contlnue~~~®~ Ject ,e to un_~lue- ~~ e~Ar.yy_ _}~ardshi,,pp,r r~n~ -ncessan~ ema iona~ d~stre.rs ~t_r_~C },eve ~C -°~re~ a _~ass a ir~cOmean _ I ha~ 6 ((??-g_!j- -p~ he_ ah1~~e repai[rs~0 ~'I mo Qre`y.~~e~_. l~ I't _ls ~~ate~ urn -tr ~'a g~ate~+e~t 0 ~1'he~~as~ Prdced- u_r_a( Hl.rtor in the ~1otion Ta Disonisf for Failuie ~o P_rosecu~e~ ~y~l 1t~~i~ .Dale W1-nter~aeye ilcdq eam~laint a ai_nst De fen~ant ~osue Sx)inu.r-V51~e~~~n the Court 0 ~C®rnnlon' Ple s 0~ ~umb~r~an~ Count o~ .septa 1-- a®oi'' ~- _-ch ~s an un~ruc m isre re,rentat-on . ~ believe tha`~ `~ - rain I in 4misre resen~ation are all e ~~II i llegal~At~A od l ~le~'~~ D6 s~ate.r }hat~cG~t is prA~es~ianal ~ni,~- can~uc ~ ~9 To violate the Rul s o Nro ~essiona~ conduct. 3~ En a in in dishonest ~ ra _~~~e~eit 0~ tnis4'e_presenta- tiorl~~ ~~ nd Green ~Ya~d ~(~ ve c~e~ e~• t6c ~rothonit- a yys d~Ckeat ecord a z didl he ~euld have ucri ~ie t dt Dau id l.u z s i ~~ and subm i tt ~ the Cor~ I~in~ ich u~a.r pre. ~c by either _Davi~ l,~tZ~anal~or b ~.~he~ o ice s~a '_. a ehts o_- An +n~~ R_au_ner,_There fa~e' I entrued all I a~ ~I~ab,~~t s anal actaons or and o~ phis Conl~~ain~ to .avid I> tZ _nd to_ -thee Id~~ irm o f An Ino`~>Zo~neY' ~~rsaan~ ~o -the stall bind+n fcon~ra~t aeement fo~ representation ghat I uses o_ tree 1l~ .I~I_Itho~ .~ Rangy Cyr- e was ~n ©rm. ~ o_ t :.: ' E~-,' . ~~~~a_c~ed~_ ~is re r~esen~ati~t1. ~a act that ~ ~ n~~ ~r~.eYE {, a e 1 t a ~ ' ~ u_?_z- - ~ -pracras~~na~~on o~ ~tnreas4n~~le R~ ~~-teen u~a ~ aw-area ~}r~ Complain rr! iq. ~ 1Si nce a~ lc-] St~i~es ~.~-n_ ~ o~rn ~ fog ~r~ ~~ae coo: ,pe-1~~~I,iDCi ~a~,a~ ~ceeq__,s~~~~ nod _h~-~~--- ~~I_e~_-~o_ ser~r~ A 5~~~men Pro c~s~(_-tp me~ q~A M _o$e) Rule 1,3_ Dili once e-e~uirn~ m ~_~ there ~s to ~e~_1.-Z_ea~OUS- ~e~r~~enl-e!/~- o _ _-h_e -~-ea_t,~an~ ~. No rocr~.r-~i_ ~`on_ or _ur~r_~~~~ '~ d~la , ~~ ~+ _ ~~-~,rS_ ~~'y_ _`~o_u~' 1~ G~_t~e~ ~t~~u. ~f'~'_~~~_ ~. Q _y sc ~ ~P,_I]~I/~ ~_j}~r n(~6~/~ the ess_-_a_na~ ~at~- ct e r~ek~_-_h ~s_ ~ti1l _rt~ -~o~al~ ~aa_~. ` Qlrec ma~__n_o~-_a~t _i_t~_ a I___wi11._cit_~__A~A _. 1~ G S~ T 6 I D~c_x_~3~~aoy _at~ $~~~g ~ ~_ . ~.I~hn.~9n u~l be_-._g.~v_i~e~_ ~4cat I-._.0.m_ ~o~ rs~ Al ~ ~r~ ~ cr_es~ .~_h~~l~ ~-~ ~r cte~ ~o -, c r 6 i Or~ t0___r~-I IAte _~1~G _j _ i_-_ia~~_ ~__Se_t~~eme-fl~~ti 6 - ~n~ .~_n_~nt -ash w e N(_as -. . ~~ - a ~a -icy ~__ e~_'~ ~e _ ~j0- r 4 __t~ - _ . -_tf t~ ~t. _Q l _~~-.r~~--m~_~ s~t~~~r_reo-nt~ Pra' ~-10_x-~~_,S~~te.~j-~!1 -GaLl~9.d'I~ey_ ra_t _m~~~r,~- -- e~~ ~_~ti~i_,ec~~1_e,tte~', tp_ -1~atlay_-_ n_d~~~ _e.6'~~1~~ ~n~ ~~-~'~ . _~l r~ip- e~-_y ~ c °s~' Le r_e A~~~ e r~~ I ~ s~ I~ b mho ve~_. o~_ I -~t~~ ~om__Russ_e I_I-- - ,,nn b t e_s_o~~w~e~htis~ ~~~ D~_c_~ ~ - De~r.__ __-, 0. _~_i_lat~r .e _er =Tease _ r~~w ~ Est r h~ -_ es a~t~ntirr~t_, ~ne~. a pia -n an >n- - y~ ~~ !a _c~n a.~~~ Pt t® a!~~ ~__re~Z~ _~o_ 1~r9__s.lohns~oll i~ ._ s~ i~~`~e~'a ~q~ of ray- ~l~tte~- %~to_ ~~e Qa~c~et t~c~arc~ i I_ew_Kll~ho~ h ~ r~~i led a Subpaer~a Ta Pr~~u~~ ~oc~m~n~s~ or Thin .r ~a ~1ro I~us~s'e.l I_ Jo}~n.ran uih-ch _b~en ~-~ne~ an~~~,scte~_~~~~c~rt-~ryR'.e~ton ~onchl S~I~s y o _t~ C __r~ 0~ er~-S .~~denc~ we.~~ ~ot{~ ~~ Qin met ~ W_it ~e,i~E~'ra e -n~i _ of ence~~ na P~e~ ~d~m_ _ ~~-~ell _Johnsa.nE __ _ff Y 1~.~__T_~~__~.~urt _p cue _ ~cc_ae~ doe~__s1t~a~ ~ha~_-t-here ---h.as -~_~e_rt con~in_~~ ~` s-an~__4c~iu_it p__ the Int.-~-_ 1S ._~,(, .$. _CO-tS ~ i~~L10_l~q~ ~~_enrA.me~1t _Z. S 0.t eS ~-j9q_L dG~ 11 _ ~u=~~ a~ ~amrnon I w ~?_he~~ ~-he uQ Ise i_~ c~_a oven's ~_ _ ~~ta~-~ _e~c. ~e~_~~ ~.q r~.al~Q~'s tie _~i9h~_o f _~~~ c~ l b _ _ _~~'~ shy 1 ~ - ~ _ -~ r ~r.v ~~ o _ DALE' WINTERMEYER IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. JOSUE S. VALDEZ NO. 200 - 5417 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 23RD day of FEBRUARY, 2006, Plaintiff's request to tape record proceedings is DENIED. the Court, Edwazd E. Guido, J. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Cazlisle Road Camp Hill, Pa. 17011 Randy Greene, Esquire 1880 JFK Blvd. 14~' Floor Phila., Pa. 19103 :sld ~ z3 ~ ~, ~ e+' "~i;~ru6rcrsks~srrsa i:,w~uao ..,. st.... ~. ,csr~-uplt~kBW ' ~d935 , ,ate . vy k '!~ Itj r ., . } ~, h~ ~~~~ ~~, i,- u~ ~.,, ~:-.1 ~C .;] ~ i jai ~:i.~~ In T c Court 0~ Coffin Pleas n~ T~ fiil~ n. 01-'~y~7f Qs S t/ald ~-Dp~en nt Civil A Sinn - r ~ . ,.: . ~3 ~.~~ R u i ~. _ - - -- _ _ An_~ __~t~~aJ ~____ ~~ h i_S --d~- - -F ~-b_-_ ~ 0 0 6 - ~~~_~~~ _,s__~~~~~o~t. _To--~ca~~-C~~~--P_t~~cee~i_n_ S _-h_~_, ~~ _- ~~_r_~~ - ~- ---~ba.s--~~I-~~ ~h_~ ch _~h~l ~ a _-_-elm-i_ _~~e _ . L_ `nti _ e ~q ~~~~~ _fie.c~r~ u~ute 1ai- _ ~~i_on--~rocee~t~_ s~f f_q ~h,s _~ouct, - _ -- - ~_v - ~h e Co uC~ ~+Yr;~. iii.-~~"~a',~',~`°° dam:. ...x.r ,~,.::s[~? ___ ~„~ - ~~y . ~ - ~.~~ . ~ ~_ _ - . . P`{ oCAf_ s. Valdez- 1~P.~Pn~, ~n Thy Court ©-~ ~'ommnn Pleas l-i I~ Noo 01-5417 c;ujl. Action Pe`t;tion _T_o Re_cor~ _Court Procee~in9s _1a ~n -_s1c~1~ ~~a0o6~ I-.~~~mi~te~,__a document ~~tle _-Re~~es`~_ _For C-o.~rt Tf~an .-c_r~ ~~_Qns. an that document, ___I ~q~,es~e~ ~ _~~cam_e_n`~e~__~o ~yy o ---the entire trans:- ---_cr--~e~ _c_om.muni_cations ghat-- eihs~e~ duri_n -my Court -_ _q __ egi~~.n-~e-_ _0_~}2__J}~r~,_'~L'pa0~6 which I am err~erir~9 _as ~, On_ fan, a~aoa6~I _tec~`t~te~ m Rp uest Eor Co rt Transc_ri~~%Ons -i-n ~~he_ >'1-a.-1~,-A~t yth~, ~~ottom_ o f -i~it - is stated ~: _P_r--~~r_i~I__cQ~_ ~Ce_nces are. no`s taken _ don -Q_n-_~~e:__ r__~cor_~"a~n~ i_~ is si_ n~~~ l,au_r~ ----N_an~1_e_ ~_o-~r~ _ ~e~ur~er~______ 9 _-3, ~.~t _~~ie__past ~__ h.av~_~ttend.e~ a__Jud~cial pro- . _ cee~_i ~ _~~i___b_~~a~ _ _o- _m.____b_rother which wqs held - . n_ the ~9Cu-mberlan~ Cofunt____~nurt ~?_ Judge .Thomas _P-1_ace_-aa~ --hi_s.__Co_~trt----I _ ~ion__on _of_ irfq Fii_II ~Rd~ M_echa~ics_b_u~ ..Tkir__n~ ho_u_~__tha~ _ roc-ee~-~-n' wit- P ~~,sse~_the 9 act__ ~a~'___ __u_d e _P lace._ all~~e _ m broth-e~ to_t~ e rec_o'r~__t~e- _nt-ir~ raceed~n , ~~~ N I-so i n -th_~ _-_~-~s __ _L _ottt~n e ~- a J udipci a l roc d° ~n_ ~-hat w_~s__h-e~_~o-_t.h~-~o_c_k_~~unt ~o~irt Q J~_ ~-_ S~ott_ ~rro r ~~~-~s_Co~ct-_1oc t~~~j_ Q _ G~6 Yor_ town__R~ 1.~w__i~~r__r__~_~. _q-~_ eo<te~ in ~~at Court _ _~_~ __ t _e~t_~ _ _ ___a s _o~_c~_aS~e~l-Q--f___ w ~ __n_ess__ o r m r 1 en --~ _ s__~~q% __Qi_a ~, Lhr__a~ _h_o-u_tthatf le_ al Y _rf ce~ ho ~ l~ qq ~ w ---t_~ tho~t_ - ~~te_~e~ _~Jud __Sc~tt-_~x-o_s~^__al_1Q--ed , m ---- -~_«n -l raiq--D~ller - o take. -record the e~ti~e~udi_cia-).l ~rOcee~inga J __ ~e __ _ _ __ ~ ~ - ~~ i e c 4e - ~P.nt ~or~rin~ o~ -th a ~'on Ctitu ian your P h am ~,n~.ment,_S~c, -~.~which--stat-~s cc No _st~te .shall _r~~~~,__pr ~n Qrce~_ any law_~hic~ Stall abri~_ t~~ rivi~e~_q~s_ or `rn_munit_ies of Citizens o _ t}te I~n1t-~s~__,~ta~eS _~0_'r--~en- _ to --an- _ _p!~_CSQ-11 ul i t h ~ _ its '~-ra_s~ic~ti~~i~--- ~~l___~_rot~.~'t~Drt___o _ Ethe aws~' - ~~1_~ac_~-ar'th _b~.ce~~-on- -the - ore-m~,~~~on_e~_ acts,. --_a~c~_ wh~_re~.s~--Qtl~er _Ju~ _~s~ __h4~~_ r~ll.ou~P~ th_~ P~o- - o C_ ed_~4. 5_ ~o be__ a_pe _C ,_ 2r e~ to their. Courts ~~ ~~-h-_~Z--hAu~. a.__ en~e~_ ~a w tnr.sse~j z am __t~~r_e. o r-~- r__ u_e~~~a tb~_, -~h,_~ro ~o_urt o f_ the __N~po_r__ Jb e._~lu_~_ _~iua~~ Gu-~~_w ~ 11 _a ~.~o_ A_llow _m~. -_~_a __~ ~ rec~ t~t~__~_~tu_r~_C~~rt _lit~ ation of - -- ~ ~ tl ~ i I 6 _t_h~_s__ _~S~1Q_s_~~~_Q-n_ ~urin~_~h~_Cp_ntlers~'~io__S ~n Coutta Su6mitfer~ on fie6.8."~tn06 ----- __ _ -~-yy-- Thc._ _~Lai~-ti__~ - ~y Thp Court 1"1 fi. Dale_ 4,~1J, _ _ __ - _ - - _ _ -- _ 1 ~ p a _. __.. l ... . .. ._ ... i _ I_. _. _ __ i I. I I i i _. _ i. .... .. _.. . .._. _... .... _ .... ... ... _.___. ...~'. ... _ N ~.__ _. _. .._._ _..... .._ .__... .... __.. ~...___ ___ __.._.. -f k . ._ _C}1 _.. -___.____.____ fi7~ ] ' .._ _._....... .. ... _. .._.. _. d . L _c~ _. ..___,_. _.._ q r ~l ~- .L^ ~ 7 ~j ~i - ~~ j _ f^,a _ .. __ _ _ _ _. _.. _ _ _ ~. ~::. _ _ _.._ _ . ~s arm not 'kit-K~'1 ~ra,_._1~ ~ Cou r~' _ V~ ~l__~a_~V~ _QI~ C.~tl~ \/ _ r,~.. '.Sit .sd,d.~eaisrx~. RoM ,.°-_. _~ .~.. -,.,kF'=rb'-Pi7~N~.~ -. -,.,'a ~,a.~.zabe~ :v.~kdei„""~•~': .~ r ~~ f~J c_ _ ~ ' 4~ TI ~ ' ~ rit _~ ' _____ G :7 +7 ~~ =l{~ _ _ (~ _ ' Y F ~ • S H '1 " '° -i ~) /'_. f' y`~ ~_ 1. DALE WINTERMEYER IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. JOSEU SALINAS-VALDEZ NO.01-5417 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, February 14, 2006, the above-captioned case having not been called for trial at the call of the trial list on today's date, the case is stricken from the list of cases to be tried during the trial term beginning March 13, 2006. Counsel are requested to relist the case for trial at such time as they deem appropriate. By the Court, Dale Wintermeyer, Pro Se Plaintiff ~- ~ 3 ~~ Randy C. Green, Esquire For the Defendant Court Administrator :ssg 1 . lfaf J, ~.. n'",1 iL =,. t I _n~i '~`j ~~ z DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE MAY ~. Q 2006 BY: RANDY C. GREENS, ESQUIRE 13y;__ ATTORNEY LD. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14~' Floor Attorney for Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintenneyer Plaintiff(s), COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY v. Josue Salinas-Valdez NO.: 01-5417 Defendant(s) DEFENDANT JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ'S PRE-TRIAL MEMORANDUM Defendant, Josue Salinas-Valdez, by and through his attorneys, Dugan, Brinlanann, Maginnis and Pace hereby submits the within Pre-Trial Memorandum. A. FACTS AS TO LIABILITY Admitted. B. FACTS AS TO DAMAGES Mr. Wintermeyer appeared at Holy Spirit Hospital later in the evening after the incident. He complained of lower left leg pain. He claims his left leg got caught between the exhaust of the car and his motorcycle. He denied any injury to the head and he was wearing a helmet. He denied injury to his neck, chest, abdomen, upper extremities or right leg. At that time he was able to bear weight on his left leg but with pain. The pain was located in his knee and his ankle. An x-ray of the left tibia and fibula revealed an old fracture of the mid-shaft of the fibula and a new oblique fracture of the proximal fibula and non-deforming fracture of the distal fibula. He was placed on crutches and discharged to home. He was urged to seek out orthopedic treatment from the Orthopedic Institute of Pennsylvania. He came under the care of Dr. Thomas J. Yucha and William W. Demuth of the above identified practice. They provided treatment for the next six weeks, immobilizing his leg and then prescribing physical therapy. Mr. Wmtermeyer rs making a claim for the repair of his bike, a 1983 Honda Shadow. C. STATEMENT OF PRINCIPAL ISSUES OF LIABILITY AND DAMAGES Plaintiff s previous counsel advised in a letter dated February 25, 2002, that if Hartford Insurance tendered its bodily injury limits of $25,000.00, Mr. Wintermeyer would agree to accept 976.50 in property damage to his motorcycle to resolve this claim. Hartford tendered its policy limits on March 26, 2002 and offered $976.50 for property damage on October 3, 2001. D. SUMMARY OF LEGAL ISSUES Whether a settlement has been reached for $25,000.00 plus $976.50? E. WITNESSES Mr. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Josue Salinas-Valdez 7004 Peters Creek Road, No. 21 Roanoke, VA 24019 Tonna Hoot 243 South Third Street Lemoyne, PA 17043 David Lutz, Esquire Angino & Rovner 4503 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 F. EXIIIBITS Statement of Tonna Hoot Plaintiff s Responses to Defendant's Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents Defendant's Responses to Plaintiff s Interrogatories, Request for Production of Documents and Requests for Admissions Any and all medical records supplied by plaintiff Letter dated October 3, 2001 from Brian Yount of Omni Insurance Company to David Lutz, Esquire Letter dated February 25, 2005 from David Lutz, Esquire to Randy C. Greene, Esquire Letter dated March 27, 2002 from Randy C. Greene, Esquire to David Lutz, Esquire confirming voicemail message of March 26, 2002. G. SETTLEMENT NEGOTIATIONS In response to a demand for $25,000.00 policy limits, on March 27, 2002, counsel for defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez extended an offer of the policy limits of $25,000.00 as well as a payment of $976.50 for the property damage to Mr. Wintermeyer's motorcycle. DUGAN, BRINKMANN, ~AGINNIS nND PACE DATE U ~y ~ ovC<--`~ RANDY C. G ENE, SQil1RE ATTORNEY FOR THE DEFENDANT, JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ PYS510D Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Case Entries 2001-05417 WINTERMEYRR DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Filed Date: 9/17/2001 Time: 3;27 Case Type: COMPLAINT Search Date: page ~ of 9 - - - - - - - - - - - - - FIRST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 9/17/01 COMPLAINT - CIVIL ACTION 11/O5/O1 DEFENDANT JOSUE SALINAS VALDEZ'S ANSWER TO PLFF'S COMPLAINT WITH ~i NEW MATTER - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT 11/06/01 PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER - BY DAVID L LUTZ ESQ ~'; FOR PLFF 11/14/01 ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE OF THE COMPLAINT BY RANDY C GREEN ATTY FOR !' DEFTS 11/14/01 ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFTS 5/14/02 PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE COURT SHOULD NOT ORDER THAT PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL BE PERMITTED TO FILE A PRAECIPE TO + F2=Done F10=Print F12=Cancel F17=Top F18=Bot F .~ 1 PYS510D Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office '' Case Entries 2'001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Filed Date: 9/17/2001 Time: 3;27 Case Type: COMPLAINT Search Date: Pa3e ~ of 9 WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE BY DAVID L LUTZ ATTY FOR PLFF 5/16/02 RULE - RATED 5/16/02 - IN RE PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE COURT SHOULD NOT ORDER THAT PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL BE PERMITTED TO FILE A PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE - RULE IS ENTERED UPON DALE WINTERMEYER TO SHOW CAUSE - RULE RETURNABLE WITHIN 15 DAYS OF SERVICE - BY GEORGE E HOFFPER PJ - COPIES MAILED 5/16/02 6/17/02 PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL'S PETITION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE - BY DAVID L LUTZ ESQ FOR PLFF 6/25/02 PETITION TO APPEAL AND SUSPEND JUDGMENT ORDER OF RULE - BY DALE WINTERMEYER PLFF 7/08/02 ORDER - DATED 7/8/02 - IN RE PLFFS COUNSEL'S PETITION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE - IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT PLFFS COUNEL DAVID L LUTZ + F2=Done F10=Print F12=Cancel F17=Top F18=Bot PYS510D Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office `!. Case Entries 2001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Filed Date: 9/17/2001 Time: 3;27 Case Type: COMPLAINT Search Date: Page ~. of 9 ESQ IS PERMITTED TO WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE ON BEHALF OF PLFF DALE WINTERMEYER AND THAT ANY SETTLEMENT DRAFT AND OR DRAFT TO PAY A '.' JUDGMENT IN THE ABOVE CAPTIONED CASE MUST INCLUDE ANGINO & ROVNER P`'' ii PC AS A PAYEE - BY THE COURT GEORGE E HOFFER PJ COPIES MAILED 7/9/02 !', 9/04/02 PRAECIPE FOR WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE OF PLFF PURSUANT TO COURT'S ORDER FOR DAVID L LUTZ ESQ di. 2f02/04 DEFENDANT'S JOSEU SALINAS-VALEZS' MOTION TO AISMISS FOR FAILURE TO "' PROSECUTE - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT 2/03/04 PROOF OF SERVICE FOR PETITION FOR RULE TO APPEAR '' 2/03/04 PETITION FOR RULE TO APPEAR IN PERSON IN THIS COURT IN ORDER TO `' SHOW JUST CAUSE TO QUASH DISMISSAL OF COMPLAINT PENTENTE LITE - B + F2=Done F10=Print F12=Cancel F17=Top F18=Bot PYS510D Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Case Entries 2001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Filed Date: g/17/2001 Time: 3:27 Case Type: COMPLAINT Search Date: Page _g of 9 DALE WINTERMEYER PLFF ------------------------------------------------------------------- 2/09/04 RULE UPON PLFF TO SHOW CAUSE WHY HIS COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE DISMISSED FOR LACE OF PROSECUTION - A RULE US ISSUED UPON PLFF TO SHOW CAUSE IF ANY THERE BY WHY PLFF'S COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE DISMISSED FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION WITHIN 20 DAYS OF THE DATE OF THE ORDER ENTERED BY THIS COURT OR SUFFER APPROPRIATE SANCTIONS TO BE OMPOSED UPON APPLICATION TO THE COURT - RULE RETURNABLE 20 DAYS AFTER SERVICE - BY THE COURT GEORGE E HOFFER PJ COPIES MAILED ------------------------------------------------------------------- 2/23/04 PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER AND REASONS FOR WHY COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE DISMISSED - DALE WINTERMEYER ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3/08/04 RULE - DATED 3/6/04 - UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE PETITION DEFENDANT'S PETITION TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS IS REFUSED - BY GEORGE E HOFFER PJ - COPIES MAILED 3/8/04 + F2=Done F10=Print F12=Cancel F17=Top F18=Bot PYS510D Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Case Entries 2b01-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Filed Date: 9/17/2001 Time: 3;27 Case Type: COMPLAINT Search Date: PaSe _~ of 9 3/26/04 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT ------------------------------------------------------------------- is 2/08/05 PROOF OF SERVICE - TO MR RUSSELL JOHNSON --------------------------- 2/08/O5 PROOF OF SERVICE TO MR. DAVID LUTZ 9/22/05 PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT 12/01/05 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 11/29/05 - IN RE DEFT'S MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROCECUTE - AFTER REVIEW OF THE FILE THE DEFT'S MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROCECUTE IS DENIED THE PROTHONOTARY IS DIRECTED TO LIST MATTER FOR TRIAL - BY THE COURT EDWARD E GUIDO J COPIES MAILED 12/01/05 F2=Done F10=Print F12=Cancel F17=Top F18=Bot PYSSlOD Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Case Entries 2001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Filed Date: 9/17/2001 Time: 3;27 Case Type: COMPLAINT Search Date: Pa3e ~ of 9 12/27/05 MOTION FOR ORDER TO REPRESENT PLFF AND COMPLAINT PURSUANT TO QUASI CONTRACT AGREEMENT FOR TRIAL REPRESENTATION - BY DALE WINTERMEYER ------------------------------------------------------------------- 12/27/05 NUNC PRO TUNC ANSWER TO PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT PURSUANT TO MOTION TO DISMISS FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION - BY DALE WINTERMEYER PLFF ------------------------------------------------------------------- 12/30/OS PROOF OF SERVICE FOR SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OF THINGS - TO MR RANDY GREEN ------------------------------------------------------------------- 12/30/OS PROOF OF SERVICE FOR SUBPOENA TO ATTEND AND REPRESENT COMPLAINT - TO DAVID LUTZ ESQ ------------------------------------------------------------------- 12/30/O5 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 12/27/05 - IN RE CASE STRICKEN FROM TRIAL LIST - THE CASE WILL NOT BE STRICKEN FROM THE TRIAL LIST AND FURTHER ACTION IF ANY BY THE COURT IS DEFERRED TO PRETRAIL + F2=Done F10=Print F12=Cancel F17=Top F18=Bot PYSSlOD Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Case Entries 2001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Filed Date: g/17/2001 Time: 3;27 Case Type: COMPLAINT Search Date: Pa3e -2 of 9 CONFERENCE - BY THE COURT J WESLEY OLER JR J COPIES MAILED ------------------------------------------------------------------- 1/06/06 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 1/4/06 - THE PROTHONOTARY IS DIRECTED TO RELIST THIS MATTER FOR NEXT CIVIL TERM DURING THE WEEK OF 3/13/06 - BY THE COURT EDWARD E GUIDO J COPIES MAILED ------------------------------------------------------------------- 1/09/06 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 1/3/06 - IT APPEARING TO THE COURT THAT PLFF'S FORMER COUNSEL DAVID LUTZ ESQ WAS GRANTED PERMISSION TO WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE BY GEORGE E HOFFER AFTER ADEQUATE NOTICE TO PLFF CURRENT MOTION FOR ORDER TO REPRESENT PLFF AND COMPLAINT PURSUANT TO QUASI CONTRACT AGREEMENT FOR TRIAL REPRESENTATION IS DENIED - BY THE COURT EDWARD E GUIDO J COPIES MAILED ------------------------------------------------------------------- 1/09/06 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 1/4/06 - AFTER REVIEW OF THE PLFF'S NUNC PRO TUNC ANSWER TO PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT PURSUANT TO MOTION FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION WE NOTE THAT THE MATTE + F2=Done F10=Print F12=Cancel F17=Top F18=Bot PYSSIOD Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Case Entries '2001.05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Filed Date: g/17/2001 Time: 3:2~ Case Type: COMPLAINT Search Date: page _~ of 9 WAS PREVIOUSLY RESOLVED BY OUR ORDER OF 11/29/05 - BY THE COURT EDWARD E GUIDO J COPIES MAILED 2/08/06 PETITION TO RECORD COURT PROCEEDINGS BY PLAINTIFF 2/10/06 PROOF OF SERVICE OF THE PETITION TO RECORD COURT PROCEEDINGS ------------------------------------------------------------------- 2/22/06 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 2/14/06 - CASE HAVING NOT BEEN CALLED FOR TRIAL AT THE CALLOF THE TRIAL LIST ON TODAY'S DATE THE CASE IS STRICKEN FROM THE LSIT OF CASES TO BE TRIED DURING THE TRIAL TERM BEINNING 3/13/06 COUNSEL ARE REQUESTED TO RELIST THE CASE FOR TRIAL AT SUCH TIME AS THEY DEEM APPROPRIATE - BY THE COURT J WESLEY OLER JR J COPIES MAILED 2/23/06 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 2/23/06 - PLFF'S REQUEST TO TAPE RECORD PROCEEDINGS IS DENIED - BY THE COURT EDWARD E GUIDO J COPIES + F2=Done F10=Print F12=Cancel F17=Top F18=Bot c _ ~ ~~ - : _ PYS510D Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Case Entries 2001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Filed Date: g/17/2001 Time: 3:27 Case Type: COMPLAINT Search Date: Page ~ bf 9 MAILED 3/21/06 PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL - DATED 03-13-06 - BY RANDY C GREENE ATTY 5/25/06 PRETRIAL CONFERENCE - DATED 05-24-06 - BY KEVIN A HESS J '~'. 6/14/06 ORDER OF COURT - 06-12-06 - IN RE: DEFT'S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT OF NON PROS IS GRANTED AND THE PLFF'S COMPLAINT IS DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE - BY J WESLEY OLER JR J - COPIES MAILED 06-14-06 6/26/06 AFFIDAVIT AND NUNC PRO TUNC RESPONSE TO LETTER - BY PLFF PRO SE 7/10/06 NUNC PRO TUNC AVERMENT AND MOTION FOR ORDER BY PLFF - - - - - - - - - - - - - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - F2=Done F10=Print F12=Cancel F17=Top Fl8=Bot ~~t w~ 1 J cJOCUP_ .`lhlih(1` ~a~ a'7<no f oY1~nn~ Y N ~~ 1~`~'f@ e 0 4~ 4 0 r_ .j Q ~ 0 ~/p~I '.~-SA ~J ~ __I m rro e a 1_-- ~ _ n~o6~~ ~ wr rw I6 ~~~ -I-~ ,~~a (` ~ _ _ ~ GYP P_ iZ~~_ ~~ ~ .. „~: DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff vs. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO. 01-5417 CIVIL IN RE: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE Present at a pretrial conference held May 24, 2006, was Jackie Cassidy, Esquire, attorney for the defendant. The pro se plaintiff did not appear. This case arises out of anautomobile/motorcycle accident which occurred on July 14, 2001. The defendant is ready, willing and able to either try or settle the case. The intentions of the plaintiff are currently unlrnown. He is warned, however, that if he fails to appear for trial or is unprepared to proceed, the court may issue a non pros. May 24, 2006 Dale Wintermeyer, Pro Se 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Plaintiff Jackie Cassidy, Esquire For the Defendant Court Administrator Kevin ~. Hess, J. :rlm 1' ~ ~.~ i ~ - ",'j,~ ,i -+~i ~+~,'~'~:~LIi7 DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED NOTICE TO DEFEND You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice aze served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. COURT ADMINISTRATOR 4th Fl., Cumberland County Courthouse Cazlisle, Pennsylvania 17101 (717)240-6200 NOTICIA Le han demandado a usted en la cone. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en las paginas sugnuientes, usted tiene viente (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de la demands y la notification. Usted debe presentar una apariencia escrita o en persona o por abogado y azchivaz en la torte en forma escrita sus defensas o sus objeciones a las demandas en contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, la torte tomara medidas y puede entrar una Orden contra usted sin previo aviso o notification y por cualquier queja o alivio que es pedido en la petition de demands. Usted puede perder dinero o sus propiedades o otros derechos importantes pars usted. LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO IMMEDIATEMENTE. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO O SI NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIQ VAYA EN PERSONA O LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARR AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. COURT ADMINISTRATOR 4th Fl., Cumberland County Courthouse Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17101 (717)240-6200 ORIGINAL 235144.1~MTG~I.C3 ,. ,-. DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW No. d ~- $'~/l7 ~~~~~-~ JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COMPLAINT 1, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer is an adult individual and a citizen of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania who resides in Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Fennsylvania. 2. Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez is an adult individual who resides at 7004 Peters Creek Road, No. 21, Roanoke, Virginia. 3. The facts and occurrences hereinafter related took place on or about July 14, 2001, at approximately 11:18 p.m. at the intersection of South Third Street (SR 2035) and Herman Avenue, Lemoyne, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 4. At that time and place, Mr. Wintermeyer was operating his 1983 Honda Shadow 750 motorcycle in a northbound direction on South Third Street approaching Herman Avenue. 5. At the same time, Defendant Salinas-Valdez was operating a 1984 Oldsmobile Cutlass in a northbound direction on South Third Street. 6. The Defendant turned on his left turn signal and stopped in the intersection to turn left onto Herman Avenue. 7. After seeing the Defendant's left turn signal, Mr. Wintermeyer slowed his motorcycle and attempted to pass the Defendant's vehicle on the right in accordance with 75 Pa.C.S.A. §3304. 235144.1\MTG\LC3 w -~,- 8. Without wanting, the Defendant suddenly accelerated and turned right, which caused the right side of his vehicle to impact Mr. Wintermeyer and his motorcycle, causing an accident. 9. The foregoing accident and all of the injuries and damages set forth hereinafter sustained by Mr. Wintermeyer are the direct and proximate results of the negligent, cazeless, wanton, and reckless manner in which Mr. Salinas-Valdez operated his motor vehicle as follows: a) failure to keep alert and maintain a proper watch for the presence of other motor vehicles on the highway; b) failure to properly use turn signals; c) failure to yield the right-of--way to Mr. Wintermeyer's vehicle; and d) driving his vehicle upon the highway in a manner endangering persons and property and in a reckless manner with careless disregard to the rights and safety of others and in violation of the Motor Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. CLAIM I Dale Wintermever v. Josue Salinas-Valdez 10. Pazagraphs 1 through 9 aze incorporated herein by reference. 11. Mr. Wintenneyer sustained painful and severe injuries that include but are not limited to a proximal left fibular fracture, a distal left fibular fracture, burns, and multiple contusions and abrasions. 12. By reason of his aforesaid injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer was forced to incur liability for medical treatment, medications, physical therapy, and similar miscellaneous expenses in an effort to restore himself to health, and a claim is made therefor. 13. Because of the nature of his injuries, Mr. Wintenneyer has been advised, and therefore avers, that he may be forced to incur similar medical expenses in the future, and a claim is made therefor. ~.: 235144.1~ITGV.C3 2 .._. ~,,, . _,,r , 14. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has undergone and in the future may undergo physical and mental suffering, inconvenience in carrying out his daily activities, and loss of life's pleasures and enjoyment, and a claim is made therefor. 15. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has been and in the future may be subject to embarrassment and humiliation, and a claim is made therefor. 16. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has suffered work loss, loss of opportunity, loss of frequent overtime pay, loss of daily piece rate bonus pay, and a permanent diminution of his earning power and capacity, and a claim is made therefor. 17. Mr. Wintenneyer continues to be plagued by persistent pain and limitation and therefore avers that his injuries may be of a permanent nature, causing residual problems and permanent scarring for the remainder of his lifetime, and a claim is made therefor. COUNT I Dale Wintermeyer v. Josue Salinas-Valdez 18. Paragraphs 1 through 17 are incorporated herein by reference. 19. As a result the subject collision, Mr. Wintermeyer's motorcycle sustained property damage, and a claim is made therefor in the amount of $1,993.18. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer demands judgment against Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez in an amount in excess of Twenty-Five Thousand ($25,000.00) Dollars, 235144.1N4TG~I,C3 3 II ' .. _ .. ,., ~..: . . .F t. .. ". .. , , ._ ... ..n k aYllA•,. '~ exclusive of interest and costs and in excess of any jurisdictional amount requiring compulsory arbitration. ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. D .Lutz LD. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717)238-6791 Attorney for Plaintiff Date: 235144.1~MTG~LC3 ~' VERIFICATION I, Dale Wintermeyer, Plaintiff, have read the foregoing COMPLAINT and do hereby swear or affirm that the facts set forth in the foregoing are true and correct to the best of my lrnowledge, information and belief. I understand that this Verification is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. WITNESS: b ~1r.~~-erm~~r Dale Wintenneyer Dated: ~(1~141 235144.1\MTG\LC3 R ~:, .;s~`Y2~4~.~tisa~Iiv3~i»!c':ga~rr,e~x.n~+v. max, .4 '+~,~~.aisx13i0YSa,4~?"<. ;~..-..:,... ...:,.w„~.. N(~. ,r ~' ~~ ~' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c ~J ~.. 'ry '^~ f'tl ~ i "J i i j/~ ! r J .- ` O « '. ..al ~ ~ ~~r4 ; .~. -=-= r~ ~, , `~ =~ ~.~<< ro r YOU ARE HEREBY N TO THE ENCLOSED IAIIT~~~.. -. DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE STY U MAY BE ENrE Epi BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY LD. # 62692 A 1880 John E Kennedy Boulevard Y 14"' Floor Attorney for D endant Josue Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY v. Josue Salinas-Valdez NO.: 01-5417 Defendant(s). DEFENDANT JOSUE SAUNAS-VALDEZ'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 1 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 2. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 2 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 3. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 3 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 4. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 4 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 5. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 5 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 6. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 6 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 7. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 7 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 8 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 9. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 9 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. By way of further answer, it is specifically denied that answering defendant was negligent, careless, wanton and/or reckless in the operation or control of any motor vehicle. By way of further answer, the specific averments of paragraph 9 are denied as follows: a. It is specifically denied that answering defendant failed to keep alert and maintain a proper watch for the presence of other motor vehicles on the highway; b. It is specifically denied that answering defendant failed to properly use tum signals; c. It is specifically denied that answering defendant failed to yield the right of way to plaintiffs vehicle; and d. It is specifically denied that answering defendant drove his vehicle upon the highway in a matter endangering persons and property and in a reckless manner with careless disregard to the rights and safety of others and in violation of the Motor Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in his favor and against all parties. 10. Answering defendant incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 9 of this Answer to Plaintiff s Complaint as though set forth at length herein. 11. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 11 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 12. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 12 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 13. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 13 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 14. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 14 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 15. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 15 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 16. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 16 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. 17. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 17 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in his favor and against all parties. 18. Answering defendant incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 17 of this Answer to Plaintiff's Complaint as though set forth at length herein. 19. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of paragraph 19 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial. WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in his favor and against all parties. NEW MATTER 20. Answering defendant incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 19 of this Answer to Plaintiff s Complaint as though set forth at length herein. 21. Plaintiffs Complaint fails to set forth a cause of action on which relief may be granted. 22. Plaintiff s cause of action may be barred by the applicable statute of limitations. 23. Answering defendant asserts all of the defenses available under the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law (75 Pa. C.S.A. § 1701). 24. The alleged injuries and damages complained of by plaintiff, if they are proven at trial, may have been caused in whole or in part by the conduct of plaintiff in encountering the risk which was or should have been obvious to them and therefore, recovery by the plaintiff is barred by the doctrine of the assumption of the risk. 25. The alleged injuries and damages complained of by plaintiff, if they are proven at trial, may have been caused in whole or in part by the negligence of others over whom answering defendant had no control or for whom answering defendant is not responsible and, therefore, any recovery on the part of plaintiff against answering defendant is barred. 26. Answering defendant exercised reasonable and prudent care with respect to the operation of his vehicle and was at no time negligent, careless and/or reckless. 27. Plaintiff has failed to mitigate his damages. 28. Plaintiffs injuries and/or damages were not proximately caused by any act or failure to act of answering defendants. 29. Plaintiff did not suffer any injuries as a result of the incident occurring on or about the date alleged in plaintiff s Complaint. 30. Plaintiff has selected the limited tort threshold. WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in his favor and against all parties. MAGINNIS AND PACE R~U'~IyYREENE, ESQUIRE Attorney r Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez VERIFICATION Josue Salinas-Valdez, avers that the allegations contained in the foregoing Answer to Plaintiffs' Complaint With New Matter are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information and belief; and that the statements in said pleading are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. pa R osue Salinas-Valdez Verified this Day day of , 2001 ~,`~~ ~, ~,~~ ~:~~ ~~ ~~ C- _ _ _ ~; :, ~~. C: - ~. i_ _. , !, .. `.i 1SJ l ~_ ~~ DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO.Ol-5417 Civil Term JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER 21. through 30. All of the allegations contained in the Defendant's New Matter are conclusions of law to which no response is necessary. By way of further response, the factual allegations contained in the Plaintiff's Complaint are incorporated herein by reference. By way of further response, the Plaintiff was operating a motorcycle at the time of the subject motor vehicle accident. Therefore, the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law is inapplicable. WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff respectfully requests that the Defendant's New Matter be dismissed. ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. Date: ~~,~ ~'~ David L. Lutz I.D. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717)238-6791 Attorney for Plaintiff 238315.1~DLUMrG CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed as follows: Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendant M T. raets Dated: ~~,L ~~ 238315.1~DLLWITG ~, , ,~ (7 c~ ~_ _._ is r ~.iF:. _- __c ..i.~ ~~~: - e~, t: r~' - °~ ~., t ..,_ "C 1 `_- _f" -q ~ ~ _ _ ~~ ,~:~ 154658~1032006 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Page 1 PYS510 Civil Case Print r 2001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SAUNAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Reference No..: Filed........: 9/17/2001 Cade Type.....: COMPLAINT Time.........: 3:27 Judgment...... 00 Execution Date 0/00/0000 Judge Assigned: HOFFER GEORGE E PJ Jury Trial.... Disposed Desc.: Disposed Date. 0/00/0000 ------------ Case Comments ------------- Higher Crt 1.: Higher Cr't 2.: ********************,t**********************************************yr************ General Index Attorney Info WINTERMEYER DALE CAMP HILL PA SAUNAS-VALDEZ JOSUE 7004 PETERS CREEK ROAD NO 21 ROANOKE VA PLAINTIFF DEFENDANT ******************************************************************************** * Date Entries ******************************************************************************** 9/17/2001 COMPLAINT - CIVIL ACTION FIRST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ----------------------- ------------ ------------------- 11/05/2001 DEFENDANT JOSUE SAUNAS VALDEZ'S ANSWER TO PLFFS COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT ------------------------------------------------------------------- 11/06/2001 PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER - BY DAVID L LUTZ ESQ FOR PLFF ------------------------------------------------------------- 11/14/2001 ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE OF THE COMPLAINT BY RANDY C GREEN ATTY FOR DEFTS - ----------------------------------------------------------- 11/14/2001 ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFTS ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5/14/2002 PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE COURT SHOULD NOT ORDER THAT PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL BE PERMITTED TO FILE A PRAECIPE.TO WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE BY DAVID L LUTZ ATTY FOR PLFF ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5/16/2002 RULE - DATED 5/16/02 - IN RE PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE COURT SHOULD NOT ORDER THAT PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL BE PERMITTED TO FILE A PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE - RULE IS ENTERED UPON DALE WINTERMEYER TO SHOW CAUSE - RULE RETURNABLE WITHIN 15 DAYS OF SERVICE - BY GEORGE E HOFFPER PJ - COPIES MAILED 5/16/02 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6/17/2002 PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL'S PETITION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE - BY DAVID L LUTZ ESQ FOR PLFF ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6/25/2002 PETITION TO APPEAL AND SUSPEND JUDGMENT ORDER OF RULE - BY DALE WINTERMEYER PLFF ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7/08/2002 ORDER - DATED 7/8/02 - IN RE PLFFS COUNSEL'S PETITION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE - IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT PLFFS COUNEL DAVID L LUTZ ESQ IS PERMITTED TO WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE ON BEHALF OF PLFF DALE WINTERMEYER AND THAT ANY SETTLEMENT DRAFT AND OR DRAFT TO PAY A JUDGMENT IN THE ABOVE CAPTIONED CASE MUST INCLUDE ANGINO & ROVNER PC AS A PAYEE - BY THE COURT GEORGE E HOFFER PJ COPIES MAILED 7/9/02 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/04/2002 PRAECIPE FOR WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE OF PLFF PURSUANT TO COURT'S ORDER FOR DAVID L LUTZ ESQ ------------------------------------------------------------------- 2/02/2004 DEFENDANT'S JOSEU SAUNAS-VALEZS' MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROSECUTE - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT ------------------------------------------------------------------- 2/03/2004 PROOF OF SERVICE FOR PETITION FOR RULE TO APPEAR ------------------------------------------------------------------- 2/03/2004 PETITION FOR RULE TO APPEAR IN PERSON IN THIS COURT IN ORDER TO SHOW JUST CAUSE TO QUASH DISMISSAL OF COMPLAINT PENTENTE LITE - BY DALE WINTERMEYER PLFF ------------------------------------------------------------------- _ _ - _ -- .~ru<- 15~658ti1032006 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Page PYS510 Civil Case Print r ~ 2001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE Re~rence No..: Filed........: 9/17/2001 Case Type.....: COMPLAINT Time.........: 3:27 Judgment...... 00 Execution Date 0/00/0000 Judge Assigned: HOFFER GEORGE E PJ Jury Trial.... Disposed Desc.: Disposed Date. 0/00/0000 ------------ Case Comments ------------- Higher Crt 1.: Higher Crt 2.: 2/09/2004 RULE UPON PLFF TO SHOW CAUSE WHY HIS COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE DISMISSED FOR LACE OF PROSECUTION - A RULE US ISSUED UPON PLFF TO SHOW CAUSE IF ANY THERE BY WHY PLFF'S COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE DISMISSED FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION WITHIN 20 DAYS OF THE DATE OF THE ORDER ENTERED BY THIS COURT OR SUFFER APPROPRIATE SANCTIONS TO BE OMPOSED UPON APPLICATION TO THE COURT - RULE RETURNABLE 20 DAYS AFTER SERVICE - BY THE COURT GEORGE E HOFFER PJ COPIES MAILED 2/23/2004 PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER AND REASONS FOR WHY COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE DISMISSED - DALE WINTERMEYER 3/08/2004 RULE - DATED 3/.6/04 - UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE PETITION DEFENDANT'S PETITION TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS IS REFUSED - BY GEORGE E HOFFER PJ - COPIES MAILED 3/8/04 3/26/2004 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT ----------------------------------------------------------- 2/08/2005 PROOF OF SERVICE - TO MR RUSSELL JOHNSON --------------------- ----------------------------- 2/08/2005 PROOF OF SERVICE TO MR. DAVID LUTZ --- ---------------------------------------------------------- 9/22/2005 PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT --------------------- ---------- 12/01/2005 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 11/29/05 - IN RE DEFT'S MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROCECUTE;- AFTER REVIEW OF THE FILE THE DEFT'S MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROCECUTE IS DENIED THE PROTHONOTARY IS DIRECTED TO LIST MATTER FOR TRIAL - BY THE COURT EDWARD E GUIDO J COPIES MAILED 12/01/05 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 12/27/2005 MOTION FOR ORDER TO REPRESENT PLFF AND COMPLAINT PURSUANT TO QUASI CONTRACT AGREEMENT FOR TRIAL REPRESENTATION - BY DALE WINTERMEYER -------------------------------- ----------- 12/27/2005 NUNC PRO TUNC ANSWER TO PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT PURSUANT TO MOTION TO DISMISS FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION - BY DALE WINTERMEYER PLFF --------------------------------------------------- --------- 12/30/2005 PROOF OF SERVICE FOR SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OF THINGS - TO MR RANDY GREEN ---------- ------------- ------------ ------------ 12/30/2005 PROOF OF SERVICE FOR SUBPOENA TO ATTEND AND REPRESENT COMPLAINT - TO DAVID LUTZ ESQ ------------------------------------------------------------------- 12/30/2005 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 12/27/05 - IN RE CASE STRICKEN FROM TRIAL LIST - THE CASE WILL NOT BE STRICKEN FROM THE TRIAL LIST AND FURTHER ACTION IF ANY BY THE COURT IS DEFERRED TO PRETRAIL CONFERENCE - BY THE COURT J WESLEY OLER JR J COPIES MAILED - - - - - - - - - - - - - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ******************************************************************************** * Escrow Information * Fees & Debits Be~ Bal Py*mts/Ad~ End Bal ******************************** ******** ****** ******************************* COMPLAINT 35.00 35.00 .00 TAX ON CMPLT .50 .50 .00 SETTLEMENT 5.00 5.00 .00 JCP FEE 5.00 5.00 .00 ------------------------ ------------ 45.50 45.50 .00 ******************************************************************************** * End of Case Information * ******************************************************************************** DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v JOSEU SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW 01-5417 CIVIL TERM IN RE: CASE STRICKEN FROM TRIAL LIST ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 27th day of December, 2005, upon consideration of the call of the civil trial list in the above-captioned matter, and neither party nor counsel having appeared at the call of the civil list, but it appearing that this matter was listed by direction of the Court on December 1, 2005, the case will not be stricken from the trial list, and further action, if any, by the Court is deferred to the pretrial conference. ~le Wintermeyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 ndy C. Greene, Esquire 880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14th Floor Philadelphia, PA 19103 For Defendant Court Administrator o~ 3~ \`~ mae By the Court, M~ ~~ . __ _. m~uw&ti~t~Et Cwr ~ra.~'e u~~s.ax.~uay,atwsxxh~x.,~~~,s, ~; ,s ~.~susa~4s~ ~"' a.w~~aamuru~e~~m;~~3s~eau~wm~e+~ava~l~L. y. ~, Q ~~ ~G CV 7;.~ ' C T. ' ~1.. l~ f , i [ ~ . t- 4 '.-:i:7.. iL ~ ca-~ N U i a~i ~;n #2 DALE WINTERMEYER V. JOSEU SALINAS-VALDEZ IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA N0.2001- 5417 CIVIL TERM IN RE: DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROSECUTE BEFORE BAYLEY. GUIDO, JJ. ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 29TH day of NOVEMBER, 2005, after review of the file, the Defendant's Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute is DENIED. The Prothonotazy is directed to list this matter for trial. the Court, E. Guido, J. Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 140 Phila., Pa. 19103 Dale Wintermeyer ~ ~ ~~ ©~ 1406 Cazlisle Road Camp Ilill, Pa. 17011 Court Administrator :sld ', +_~~.F r;J` Jf ~i' ~Fii 'G -- ~~.L..,- ; Ti~;~ ~p ~ l ~C~~v~~ NOV 1 5 2005 DUGAN, BRINICMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE FsY: ATTORNEY LD. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14s' Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), v. Joseu Salinas-Valdez Defendant(s). COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY NO.: 01-5417 DEFENDANT JOSEU SALINAS-VALDEZS' BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF HIS MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROSECUTE Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez, by and through his counsel, Dugan, Brinkmann, Maginnis and Pace, files this Brief in Support of his Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute and states as follaws: I. STATEMENT OF THE QUESTION INVOLVED A. SHOULD PLAINTIFF'S CAUSE OF ACTION BE DISMISSED FOR PLAINTIFF'S FAILURE TO PROSECUTE ITS ACTION IN A TIMELY MANNER? Suggested Answer: Yes II. STATEMENT OF THE CASE PROCEDURAL HISTORY Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer (hereinafter referred to as "Plaintiff'), filed a complaint against Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Defendant"), in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County on September 17, 2001. The Plaintiff's Complaint alleged physical injuries and property damage stemming from a collision between Plaintiff's motorcycle and Defendant's automobile On September 3, 2002 ,according to the docket in this matter, Plaintiff s Counsel filed a Praecipe to Withdraw Appeazance. From September 2002 until Februazy 2004 when this motion to dismiss for failure to prosecute was filed, there was absolutely no docket activity. On February 2, 2004, this motion to dismiss currently before the Court was filed, and on February 23, 2004, Plaintiff filed his answer and reasons why his complaint should not be dismissed. On March 8, 2004, a rule was issued denying Plaintiffs petition to proceed in forma pauperis. Since March 8, 2004 Plaintiff has not filed any motion, petition or praecipe concerning this matter. III. SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT Plaintiff has shown a want of due diligence in his failure to proceed with reasonable promptness. Plaintiff has not offered a compelling reason for their delay. It is the plaintiff, not the defendant, who beazs the burden of moving his case along within a reasonable time. A lengthy period of delay can be one reason for dismissal for inactivity. If Plaintiff truly believed that this matter was proceeding accordingly during the past eighteen (18) months, there would be some indication on the record. The passage of time has certainly affected the ability of witnesses to recall the facts and details of the subject matter of the claim thereby resulting in prejudice to Defendant. Joseu Salinas-Valdez. IV. ARGUMENT A. PLAINTIFFS" CAUSE OF ACTION SHOULD BE DISMISSED FOR PLAINTIFF'S FAILURE TO PROSECUTE ITS ACTION IN A TIMELY MANNER. When a civil action has been commenced and the Plaintiff fails to diligently prosecute his case, the Defendant may move to have the action dismissed for lack of prosecution. To dismiss a case for inactivity pursuant to a defendant's motion for non pros three requirements must be met: There must be a lack of due diligence on the part the plaintiff in failing to proceed with reasonable promptitude. Second, the plaintiff must have no compelling reason for the delay. Finally the delay must cause actual prejudice to the Defendant. Jacobs v. Halloran, 551 Pa. 906, 710 A.2d 1098 (1998). Prejudice maybe established by the death or absence of a material witness, as well as any substantial diminution of a party's ability to properly present its case. Neer v. Niedermever, 1998 WL 1068975, 39 Pa. D. & C.4th 158 (1998) (citing James Brothers v. Union Bankine and Trust Co., 432 Pa. 129, 247 A.2d 587 (1968); Metz Contacting Inc. v. Riverwood Builders Inc , 360 Pa.Super. 445, 520 A.2d 891 (1987). Furthermore, determination of a motion for judgment of non pros will not be overturned absent an abuse of discretion. Halloran, 551 Pa. at 359, 710 A.2d at 1103. In the case at bar, the three requirements necessary for a judgment of non pros are met. Plaintiff has failed to move this case since November of 2003. For over two years there has been no activity of record. This amount of time displays a lack of reasonable promptitude and due diligence on the part of the Plaintiff in prosecuting this case. Furthermore, there is no compelling reason for the delay in prosecuting this case. If there were a compelling reason for such a great delay, Plaintiff has not offered it. Finally, this unreasonable delay has caused actual prejudice to the Defendant. The passage of time has certainly affected the ability of witnesses to recall the facts and details of the subject matter of this claim, and information related to the accident has been lost. Plaintiff bears the burderi of moving her case along within a reasonable time and did not do so; Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez should not now be prejudiced further by Plaintiffs' failure to proceed in this matter. Because Plaintiff has failed to diligently prosecute his case, Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez now avails himself of a motion for judgment of non pros so that he may seek a "reasonably prompt conclusion to {this} case." Shope v. Eaele, 710 A.2d 1106. V.CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, given the Plaintiffs complete lack of due diligence in meeting his burden of moving his case, the lack of any compelling reason for such a delay offered by Plaintiff, and the prejudice that such delay has caused Defendant, the Plaintiffs cause of action should be dismissed with prejudice. DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS, AND PACE DATE: JACQUELINE Y. CASSIDY, ESQUIRE RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT ,~ ~- ~s. Josue. S. VaI~PZ-De.~endant _Ig.~Th~ Court o.c Common Pler.~l' ~1~ nn, OI-SLI1~ ~,v, I Arunn PROOF OF SERVICE I, 17~r~._~O~nl~, u1in1 I have this ~_ dayD~o.~f. the foregoing document(s), rCL1 pursuant to I hereby certify that _,.~_, served 0 1 + 1 a Service by First-Class Mail to: RoN eVAr 3 - r, `` _ na o ~ = rTi ~~;' ~., "T4 -i - _ f~; CTJ R ~Gi: __ C+ _'~.`~r .. -~-_ ` ~~CJ _ ~" J ~'' ~! L~ ^-~' --G i~ J~~{ To the }Ipnora_~le. Jul ~__kt~~uar~ Gui~p 6 Th_~n~ _y_ou_ very _m~eh__~or rul ~n'~ an m~ ~jellQ) J on_ Nau° ~9 _~005~_u~he_n. opt ~eni'ed the f ~ ° ° d ~e enfants 1~p~-on to_~~sr~_~s~ _ or Failure ~o ~ Prose.cutee I___be_l~fv~--.that ~_nu rea Iized ~ha~_Ci _~e~' ~ u~_as __C4~lti._n~a~l ysu~ ° ectec( to ° ~ ° ~ ~ ~el~~_~e a~~ ,-nd_~__ _er~rtce_~ ~tto_urn s and b - re -'es~e.ntat_~~ -_a_ __~~_~--y~~- endan~s i~lsur- p a~ ce co m _a~_ t_1, c~~----~---~leserv'e ~o b ~- com- ~ ° e_nsc~tec~_ _o~ m_.._. losses- _wh_~~h are- stated ~n the__~o_~ _I a_i_rt~_th_~t _at~~.ur_n ___~av i d Lutz has ('e arer~_ si.11e~ an~ _ha.s~~'u~m;tted t~ °~~ ~~ this. Nonorab~_ __QU~'~~~s_an a .ant anr~ as a °° le9a) c~°e~r~,~.er-~~_~~_u~_o_.~ _~h~` A_.~_1n0~ Roune~ a~V _ i ~h'1k_ 1_ _GL.e t~_ _~acec~_a~e__ ' _pur_ concern an_c~ _ ~u'r _____airnJ_~ss ~ _ ~e__c~ndr_ o~` m~e, ~ f ~ 1'1C Dalw I,t)intel'mr ~Pr-Plai ~~_ v rs ~lo~~alinas Valdez-J~e,~ n nt - - r~ - Nen ~~ p_rth an this ~la~~e o ____~~ _1_a_~!J ~_rm- ._o_ A n ; n_o a n df Ro v.n er ~ s }, ~re`~ ` p~_ ~r~~vi~eF _i e, Plain_ti_ pale ],Jinte~m er 'I - ~ ~ °~ y a t o_urn~~ o~ n ~~~~,_ a_ ~re.m a~ one. A l w berm ~hr-ou h- '! ---~~t __~he~en i_u'~e._du__~t'oY1-~t1d li_ti_ _~t ~ o~_ ~his-~ _C~ ~ a~in~- quit -a~ -~am~ ~s~ an_d~_un~~i' 'his Com- !, u, y _La~_ -~'u~_~_-1~a~~ ~e~_ -~u~~~s~--_-L~ ___ i nal i_ze~ --u'rsuant__~a__th-e..-~_.__~~--cx_ _C_~em--q`c_k~n~ Con~rac~ or 1~ .al _!'~ r__~s~ent~~~~~n_~hc~~__ha_s been- _o _ erect ~Df ', - th~ -P1~~ ~~__-_ -_b y_ ~h - -1-a~+_-~ crrr~ _oTT..~~ ~1n o a n Qa v er ` ~ ' y '~- K r ~ c [~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ III _--~-h_~__~-v___-~~~i~rr!w~:~.av~_d, lfu~z,,~_I1i_ch-~s Stsll va]i~ I, fY.¢eEtirv]!L CQfdIMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF CUMB~Rf.AND TO: 1. 2. .~#'~~ i n~er e.~F~sai ~~ ~ ~.ma. ° ~i ~'~ ' ~- ~- - No. t .. - El©sur S r~lin nS" Vnlrz~ z ,F re ant m il A ~fiian You are ordered by the court to come to (Specify courtroffp,m or other place) . C u m b e r I An dl County, Pennsylvania, on J u n'~, ~~ 01~ at' ~}t~ sche~ulw~ ~:itn~ ,to U h~_ s> i~l ~rLr _rwDrn Oo ,ti n d ~u}iv_c If you fail to attend or to produce the documents or things re4uired by this sub(~oena, you may be subject to the sanctions authorized~by Rule 234.5 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, including but not limited to costs, attorney fees and imprisonment: RE4UESTED BY: C 1 i plt'~ ~,,, ` = Name: 1 19'. Address: 'J ~(a~ Cali i.ffa~ NGIa I~L~.., C.~1~~i ~~u.i 1lOf l Telephone: ~QU~, 1~1Q1'e~ lhiS ~D 1J0.Vi~ l.u~t2, BYTHEC URT: dale. ~;nterm~~er Protho erk Date: ~' 0,,. ---~- ~ r o200~ Seal of the Court beputy Official Note: This form of subpoena shall be used whenever a subpoena i5 issuable, including hearings in connection with depositions and before arbitrators, masters, commissioners, etc. in compliance with Pa. R. C. P. No: 234.1. If a subpoena for a production of documents, records or things is desired, complete paragraph 2. (Eff. 7/97) 1, Cum~ 7P.~ `0on Co ~~ nt Cour ~ ~ ommo tl 1'1 raa~' .1ZQ~~~_~Ia __.~~-.sti I~ n PROOF OF SERVICE c_ ",,__: ,-:::. - hereby certify that?=, ~.~QQ~_., served"' ~; ~, r~ W O w r.,a Service by First-Glass Mail to: ° S 0 m ~~ m -~ rn ^a j _-'ri c~ ;~, m ...t I have this ~ U i T_ h day of ~ 't-0171 ~' , POWER OF ATTORNEY AND FEE AGREEMENT BY SIGNINGTHIS AGREEMENT, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I (WE) HAVE ENGAGED THE LAW FIRM OF ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. (HEREINAFTER A & R), TO REPRESENT ME (US) UNDER THE FOLLOWING TERMS AND CONDITIONS: A & R may on my (our) behalf secure medical, work and other similar records, conduct an investigation, negotiate, and if necessary start suit against anyone responsible for my (our) injuries and .losses with respect to dAO~D~G Gr2 etCCtL(Q~~ "1- I4-O~, with full power and authority fo:;appear on behalf of the undersrgned in any Court of record or in any administrative or other proceeding, to d'o and perform all and every act and thing whatsoever that may be requisite and necessary to be done in connection with the above claim as fully as the undersigned might or could do if personally present; hereby ratifying and confirming all that said attorneys shall lawfully do or cause to be done therein by virtue of this power of attorney. 2. I (we) understand that so long as the case is handled by an A & R attomey, I (we) will not be responsible for any fees and/or expenses unless a recovery or benefit is Obtained. 3. If my (our) case is handled to a successful completion by an A & R attomey, I (we) agree to pay A & R ail reasonable out-of-pocket expenses without the payment of interest, plus a fee for time expended as follows: ' A & R ME (US) a. SETTLEMENT PRIOR TO STARTING SUIT 3O% 'JO% b. SETTLEMENT FOLLOWING SUIT BUT PRIOR TO TRIAL OR ARBITRATION 35% 65% c. SETTLEMENT OR VERDICT AT TRIAL OR ARBITRATION, AFTER TRIAL, ARBITRATION, OR APPEALS OR SHORTLY BEFORE TRIAL AND AFTER CASE HAS BEEN TOTALLY PREPARED 4O% 6O% d, IF NO-FAULT RECOVERY OR NON-MONETARY BENEFIT: RICHARD C. ANGINO ($500); NEIL J. ROVNER ($450); ASSOCIATES ($400) PER HOUR BUT NOT TO EXCEED 4O% OF TOTAL RECOVERY OF VALUE OF BENEFIT e, OTHER CASES 4, If for any reason I (we) take my (our) case to another attorney or taw firm including a former A & R attomey or handle it myself (ourselves), I (we) recognize that A & R has, in good faith, expended money and time for my (our) benefit and I (we) therefore agree to pay, or have my (our) new attomey pay, immediately, upon severing the A & R attomey/client relationship, all the out-of-pocket expenses incurred on my (our) case plus interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of each expenditure. In addition, when the case is successfully concluded, I(we) agree to pay or to direct my (our) new aiiorney iv pay as a ~ 20°.'0 of the gross recever~ to P. & R. 5. In the event that any settlement is made on a structured or deferred payment basis, A & R shall be entitled to receive their percentage based on the present value of the structured settlement, if paid as a lump sum at the time of settlement. I (we) agree not to settle or discuss settlement of my (o(u~~r;)~•c~ras~'e without the written consent of A & R. $Y SIGNING THIS AGREEMENT, THIS ~_ DAY OF 20~, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I (WE) HAVE READ, UNDERSTOOD, AND RECEIVED A COPY OF SAME AND AGREE TH ITS TERMS AND CONDITIONS. wITNES s S"i n utur~ o A~~aurn DaVit~ I,l~t~ CLIENT(S): X ~.1) ` ~j ~-(SEAL) (SEAL) (OVER) revised 2/00 ®ffice of the Prothonotary Cumberland County Curtis R Long Prothonotary ' DAVID L. LUTZ, ESQ 4503 N. FRONT' STREET HARRISBURG PA 17110 DATE: NOVEMBER 3, 2005 TO: DAVID L. LUTZ, ESQ.: THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT CASE NUMBER O1-5417 CIVIL , DALE WINTERMEYER- Q~41nt~i~f~C~;el1~ of David I,utz`~~he film o~ An9;.no~Rounei- vs. JOSUE SAUNAS-VALDEZ HAS BEEN LISTED FOR ARGUMENT ON NOVEMBER 23, 2005. Cumberland County Argument Court Rules 1028(c), 1034(a) and 1035.2(a) shall be strictly enforced. If the issue was listed for prior argument you must re-file year brief as per Local Rule 1028(c)10. ~ m ~ + _ o Curtis R. Long. cc ;~ed~~n D~~.30.10f~s ; t ~ "~- e e ' x~ r -- „ ~ ~> Rresented by Rich . ~ ~ ~ngtsa ~~;o-,. . Ae:attt'am .:_~~'': a defendant was ne Nv>nt For --~--=~® t - Q~uJ North Front Street. For a list of our services visit www.angino- ms ance, a consumer may:suffer an injury while using a product ~ ~ . rovnercom. HINT: Strict liaMlity on the pan of :' according to its du'ecdonsr Under the doctrine of strict liability he or everyone w11q pro5ts-firm a c d , she can receive compensation for onsumer pro uct increases consumer safety. - damages without showing anything - more than tha manufactarer marketed a product that was unreas bl d t/isIt orir web site.' rwww.artgln0-fOVflBP COt17 ona y angerous. Strict . .C 3 c q"". Y q r.+ R," e°r~n eqi :; ~ou y u aF „° d .. aw°~' tnD q ~.L~ o~ M '~ h G A to '~v cur ~,°q N 6 a .r7AV t-O .b ~" G .~ m O s« q o>Na6 :. .q v arx' _'aa o r tOi N O QI ~ Q: V ~" ~ W A N 7 N v amx~,~ ~ b~~~v~.o w N tri q v u ~~" v ;o Aua•~_N ~a b~Y~oLL~Oavuai uaa`'`u~u' «uyyUb O-uU ~'+'S ~v~~ g °i o a .a v 'u;a.I ~ N U `° c" a ',~,~y]/~ o y a V '.y ~ ~ V ld •U d en ~ ~ O ~ QJ .'.~ ~ ~ y .q :R O m ..OJ'a~ trt q U rn~ '/+ q'v'r ~ N 3 v v w~ N:~ a~. " o.s "' Tt Na"~ ° m~~~~° a fi"iaua° t°~v m°um rn vi ~ x~~ou m >.o,, ~y t.~ a u ea.9 .~ '~ " u a.~ , q 2: m> ~ K rd ~vA ~"/.C~ q 7 ivy toy tOi .+~Tl F7m O a•~"~~~y N 'M a.,7 m A ~~^C w'y ~;? Or:-~ via o N. O m.. a a+ • w q 30-~ ~ow~m.~~>~"m~b v en a w a, ,, v v .b m ~" O ~ O V vi'~r~' w.q m y ar N.N - ~jp' ~+ tg~ y+ 5 A O ~'ar v u v i m .~~~.~ v *:'-^A v n„`°n ~ "ri"'w`-Pttgi s`ri .~ ~ 3 w w v ~ o ~ ~ g q +,+ v b .q y'~+, y tlY ~+,. U m ..'y +' W ~~~«Eaa`va~~~ovv~v Have you ever wondered what RO we strive fo make a legal recourse passengershave - - _pp91[ive' ' nce in ihe~`Ytve9 of ' when they aseipjured in crashes ~ our cllnnts by assiathts t em3n a that are the t'auit of the drivers of enamel concerned efficient sad the vehicles in which they ride? prbfeasianal manner. hen you Passengers hove the snipe nre involved in•a personal injury recourse as anyone else injuieii by matter, Ball {717) 238=¢791,.1Zur the negligence of another As in office is lbcated at 45U3 North ' ' other negligence suits, the injuries Front Street: For a list of ouc suffered must be directly related services visit www.angino- Co the negligent operation o`f the - r . ravner.comi ~ ' - vehicle.' 'HIIVT:(tiossnegligencecanbe eing injured through another"s ~ -definerl as ilia reckless disregard ligence and managing dle ' - for [hr,, ptateptial consequencegof re [ing incotrvenience and one's conduct. unc ainty, can be extremely diffic t, even under fhe best of rl/ts/tour web site: ° *I~ a ' F Presented by Richard ~ Angino Attorney at Law DA GE ASSESSMENT In a civil suit, them.are categories of If you have been injured in ao accident damages upou~ which a recovery may for which you think another'person is be based. Compensatory damages are at fault, a call m your attorney fi in intended to make the person "whole '. order for Instructions abort how to again," meaning that the person is put document your-losses incase you tlo back in the position that.extsted before eventually need to seek compensation. the loss or hamr. One s~ubeate off' of Remember, not all iujudes ate always comnensatot~danraees to uenetal immediately apparent. For additional uamaRes, wmca ra iue~amouni u -ceded information about recouping yom Front Street. par ~- b ? p i DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant MAYK 5 Z0~'I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO.O1-5417 Civil Term JURY TRIAL DEMANDED rA,~ ULE AND NOW, this ~-•da\y of , 2002, a Rule is hereby entered upon Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Co ould not permit Plaintiffls counsel to withdraw his appearance and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment not include Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a payee. Rule returnable within ~ days of service. BY THE COURT: ~~~ ~6' p~Ff a ~, G ~ ~ ~.,u~ ~n911~o ~ Rov~er~ ~ ~_ 245515.1~DLLN~ITG _. -~~ -.: ' -, t p r'i4. r - _~df'i~ P\_L1 "H~~~ ~ .~ -~. ~~ a'~ ~ i ;~1 ~ ~ ~ ~~a ~C' 14.11 f'~+ •_ ~ ~ J`J Il.l. -'li1 ~1 i ~UY_v:'i ~.' _ ~,~ } DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO. 01-5417 Civil Term JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE COURT SHOULD NOT ORDER THAT PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL BE PERMITTED TO FILE A PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE AND NOW COMES Angino &Rovner, P.C., and respectfully requests that Your Honorable Court enter a Rule upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Court should not Order that Plaintiff's counsel be permitted to file a Praecipe to Withdraw His Appearance. In support thereof, Angino &Rovner avers the following: 1. On July 14, 2001, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer was injured in a motorcycle/motor vehicle accident caused by Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez. See, Plaintiff's Complaint filed on September 17, 2001, attached as Exhibit A. 2. Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer retained Angino &Rovner and entered into a Power of Attorney and Fee Agreement with regard to the July 14, 2001, motor vehicle accident. 3. The insurer for the Defendant retained the services of Attorney Randy C. Greene and counsel for the Defendant filed an Answer to the Complaint with New Matter. 4. Counsel for the Plaintiff and Defendant entered into discovery and the depositions of the respective parties were scheduled for February 21, 2002. 5. However, during discovery, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer corresponded directly with Attorney Randy Greene. Mr. Wintenneyer's letter dated December 3, 2001, is attached as Exhibit B. 245515.I~DLUMTG 6. Thereafter, Plaintiffs counsel advised Mr. Wintermeyer to not correspond with defense counsel. 7. On February 20, 2002, two days before the aforementioned depositions of the parties, Attorney Greene called Plaintiffs counsel. At that time, Attorney Greene indicated that he would recommend to the Defendant's insurer that it should tender its policy limits of $25,000.00. Therefore, in order to save both parties the cost of depositions, counsel agreed to cancel the depositions. 8. On February 21, 2002, Mr. Wintermeyer met with Plaintiff's counsel and he provided counsel with authority to accept a tender of policy limits of $25,000 with regard to the bodily injury claim and to accept a property damage settlement offer of $976.50 for damage to his motorcycle. 9. In a letter dated February 22, 2002, attached as Exhibit C, Attorney Greene corresponded with Plaintiff s counsel and confirmed that the depositions were canceled in order to provide additional time for the Defendant's insurer to evaluate the demand for policy limits. 10. In a letter dated February 25, 2002, attached as Exhibit D, Plaintiff's counsel advised defense counsel that Mr. Wintermeyer and counsel met on February 21, 2002, and that Mr. Wintermeyer provided counsel "with authority to accept a tender of policy limits of $25,000 with regard to his bodily injury claim. Secondly, pursuant to Brian Yount's October 3, 2001, letter, enclosed for your convenience, Mr. Wintermeyer has also provided me with authority to accept a property damage [settlement] of $976.50." 11. Thereafter, in a letter dated March 27, 2002, attached as Exhibit E, Attorney Greene corresponded with Plaintiffs counsel and advised that he had obtained authority to tender the policy limits of $25,000 and to pay $976.50 for Mr. Wintermeyer's property damage claim. 245515.1~DLLVVITG 2 II iii I> ~ 12. In a letter dated March 15, 2002, attached as Exhibit F, Mr. Wintermeyer again corresponded directly with Attorney Greene. 13. Plaintiffls counsel has recommended that Mr. Wintermeyer accept the tender of limits of $25,000 and the $976.50 property damage settlement, because to proceed further with the litigation would not be economically feasible. 14. Plaintiffs counsel has also determined that Mr. Wintermeyer had rejected UIM coverage covering his motorcycle. 75 Pa.C.S.A. §1731(c.l). 15. Notwithstanding the tender of limits and property damage settlement offer, Mr. Wintermeyer refuses to consummate the settlement. 16. Given Mr. Wintermeyer's refusal to cease corresponding directly with defense counsel and refusal to settle his claims even though he had provided counsel with authority to do so, Plaintiff's counsel has requested that Mr. Wintermeyer retain new counsel. 17. In fact, Plaintiffls counsel had provided Mr. Wintermeyer with a draft of the aforesaid Petition and requested that Mr. Wintermeyer retain counsel so that the Petition could be served upon Mr. Wintermeyer's new counsel. 18. To date, Plaintiffs counsel has not been contacted by Mr. Wintermeyer's replacement counsel. WHEREFORE, Angino & Rovner respectfully requests that Your Honorable Court enter a Rule upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Court should not Order that 245515.1\DLL\MTG 3 l Plaintiff s counsel be permitted to file a Praecipe to Withdraw His Appearance and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment include as a payee, Angino & Rovner, P.C. ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C Date: ~~~~ "~ 245515.1~DLLUITG David L. Liltz ' I.D. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717)238-6791 Attorney for Plaintiff 4 J~ 11l1~1!!!I~lll~ ~ ' DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED NOTICE TO DEFEND You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personaily or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims se[ forth against you. You aze warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other. claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. COURT ADMINISTRATOR 4th FL, Cumberland County Courthouse Cazlisle, Pennsylvania 17101 (717)240-6200 NOTICIA Le han demandado a usted en la torte. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en las paginas sugnuientes, usted time viente (20) dial de plazo at partir de la fecha de la demanda y la notification, iJsted debe presentaz una apariencia escrita o en persona o por abogado y azchivaz en la cone en forma escrita sus defensas o sus objeciones a Las demandas en contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, la torte tomara medidas y puede entraz una Orden contra usted sin previo aviso o notification y por cualquier queja o alivio que es pedido en la petition de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero o sus propiedades o otros derechos importantes para usted. LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO IMMEDIATEMENTE. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO O SI NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA O LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARR AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGULR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. COURT ADMINISTRATOR 4th Fl., Cumberland County Courthouse Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17101 (717)240-6200 235144.1N~ITC~iLC3 ~ r (~~(~~ ,. DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COMPLAINT ~' =_ 1. Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer is an adult individual and a "~r't%aen '~f the=_. .% ... i e' Commonwealth of Pennsylvania who resides in Camp Hill, Cumberland County, P~i2iisylvania; `.`, =i ~, _ . 2. Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez is an adult individual who Creek Road, No. 21, Roanoke, Virginia. 3. The facts and occurrences hereinafter related took place on or about July 14, 2001, at approximately 11:18 p.m. at the intersection of South Third Street (SR 2035) and Herman Avenue, Lemoyne, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 4. At that time and place, Mr. Wintermeyer was operating his 1983 Honda Shadow 750 motorcycle in a northbound direction on South Third Street approaching Herman Avenue. 5. At the same time, Defendant Salinas-Valdez was operating a 1984 Oldsmobile Cutlass in a northbound direction on South Third Street. 6. The Defendant turned on his left turn signal and stopped in the intersection to turn left onto Herman Avenue. 7. After seeing the Defendant's left turn signal, Mr. Wintermeyer slowed his motorcycle and attempted to pass the Defendant's vehicle on the right in accordance with 75 Pa.C.S.A. §3304. 235144.1\N(TG\LC3 r 8. Without warning, the Defendant suddenly accelerated and turned right, which caused the right side of his vehicle to impact Mr. Wintermeyer and his motorcycle, causing an accident. 9. The foregoing accident and all of the injuries and damages set forth hereinafter sustained by Mr. Wintermeyer are the direct and proximate results of the negligent, careless, wanton, and reckless manner in which Mr. Salinas-Valdez operated his motor vehicle as follows: a) failure to keep alert and maintain a proper watch for the presence of other motor vehicles on the highway; b) failure to properly use turn signals; c) failure to yield the right-of--way to Mr. Wintermeyer's vehicle; and d) driving his vehicle upon the highway in a manner endangering persons and property and in a reckless manner with careless disregard to the rights and safety of others and in violation of the Motor Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. CLAIM I Dale Wintermever v. Josue Salinas-Valdez 10. Paragraphs 1 through 9 are incorporated herein by reference. 11. Mr. Wintermeyer sustained painful and severe injuries that include but are not limited to a proximal left fibular fracture, a distal left fibular fracture, burns, and multiple contusions and abrasions. 12. By reason of his aforesaid injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer was forced to incur liability for medical treatment, medications, physical therapy, and similar miscellaneous expenses in an effort to restore himself to health, and a claim is made therefor. 13. Because of the nature of his injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has been advised, and therefore avers, that he may be forced to incur similar medical expenses in the future, and a claim is made therefor. 2351d4.1VvITG~L.C3 2 t 14. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has undergone and in the future may undergo physical and mental suffering, inconvenience in carrying out his daily activities, and loss of life's pleasures and enjoyment, and a claim is made therefor. 15. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has been and in the fixture may be subject to embarrassment and humiliation, and a claim is made therefor. 16. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has suffered work loss, loss of opportunity, loss of frequent overtime pay, loss of daily piece rate bonus pay, and a permanent diminution of his earning power and capacity, and a claim is made therefor. 17. Mr. Wintermeyer continues to be plagued by persistent pain and limitation and therefore avers that his injuries may be of a permanent nature, causing residual problems and permanent scarring for the remainder of his lifetime, and a claim is made therefor. COUNTI Dale Wintermever v. Josue Salinas-Valdez 18. Paragraphs 1 through 17 aze incorporated herein by reference. 19• As a result the subject collision, Mr. Wintermeyer's motorcycle sustained property damage, and a claim is made therefor in the amount of $1,993.18. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer demands judgment against Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez in an amount in excess of Twenty-Five Thousand ($25,000.00) Dollars, 235144.1NdTGV-C3 3 i exclusive of interest and costs and in excess of any jurisdictional amount requiring compulsory arbitration. ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. D .Lutz I.D. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717)238-6791 Attorney for Plaintiff Date: 235144.1\MTCi\LC3 4 VERIFICATION I, Dale Wintermeyer, Plaintiff, have read the foregoing COMPLAINT and do hereby swear or affirm that the facts set forth in the foregoing are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that this Verification is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. WITNESS: ~~~. uJ,n~~rsnruer Dale Wintermeyer Dated: ~ l «~ ~ 1 235144.1\MTG\LC3 :~~ -ea'f Mr. ; Gene ~ 1~.~3~D f ~ e_.Ln erto a- oty_answet's_ r-~ .hi h,lyy.__v~lv~_thti .im ortance a __-R~ ht~s o confiden~iality f _ .i_Sc .s_kre o,~:_m- Sec.l41_s~_ec~ur~ty (y I_h.a wr,_ttt-~_ c~__le al _comm-e.~t. ~~___m:y __or~~'.gqi.n~-I_I.rlt~e~~'o_ga~o_r_y _~St~temrnt_~t_#SS~ _ _l~l-i-3c. Il ne_ous ~Id)Soc1aQ.1__~ecur~_~_ _~umb#r w.hic}t ..war not _ _inclu~e.~.-o--~---~-- ed-1~o - -t~a~._ ~u~S-_'r_e~urnecl-t0-_me. f~n.re ucntly-T-_hay~-_o.n~e Ai_n yu.~cle~ --ra- --comment-: ~nc~er.__this _~.f_ore_meatione.~~-s~ct~t~..Dc__not-_u,r~ yc_b~ain~_c(isc_Io~`earetain .~ile _p~int~a_r computerize m~ _Con i~e-~tlal._5ocial Jecur7~ _n_um~Er ~-h~ch-~S---~CO~-ecte_~-by_-F_ee~e~ai_.f_ocia~_S~ec~lrit Admi'h, I. 'li s I S t N t 5 t as ( (a.) k) (v.,y) o_ -_tn _.c~rr_ec_ .iollS__ o an ,- w i-~11 _ ws~s e _i n c.c rr--e ct, I-- 9~___retainjn~ m~--.1=e~eral t, -r~-gqc~~rs~~.r_--~t-.o h~~ts_e---an 8ene~~~ _numb-er. Cans-egwei _ _ e - _. I am wiitin _in r_e Girds .tp _m Ir al dis~os,t-on aqain.rt_._Jo.ruc S~linus-Va ~cz~~-h~ is the-~~rsp-~ that rcu _ut~e..r_epr_es_e~l~inqq,Lht_.Civil__Act.ioJ1_caf.e_num~er_if. c~-5y-~, D~t~e._to__q__mer.e__cq~e_._week time_~equi~'cmentjl_Su~mitted tht Interro_ at9r_ies_ to___m_y I_e al--re~reJ'ent_i_ti u~ w~ thout_.makin s_o~i e~r_o~ _i __h_e or_c_1s~mitted_i-t_ and-us---,I--h d_.stibmitt~d i~,_T~_cn---r~_~er_~_ha~_s~bmitted-a~ ta__Duvid _6_u~z i wQ.s ~ent_a--- r_c~a_a~'ei~_co _-~-f _~t_u-hs_h__Was t-y Ped.~an~ u-hich u-_a,s__.~r_o~A_~ ~yy-s_e.nt_ ~~_ y_ _du u~,~O, Thy-cc~ __~I{at,_.~_ wa.r _.se nt ,b_a~k_cont_aikt.r__Q_ ew .$hin s_ ~h.~t ~r_e _nyot_ c~r_r__e-ct c~n~_or__ ,, :-c~r_e__not_~s_I_Jiad_~r~ ,~gN'~~swbrr~,~t~d.s--have_~_n aosed_~~o~rs tl ~~ ~ ti t t __uul._T- e _ oua. ec~1[i _y c~_ ec i~i1_~ c i+ re_ wiLef _t~at Sa-ci_al _S_ecl_ ctmliers__and_~elate _tecor~S that qq _c~re` ~~tai_nei~,o~'_mai.Yltginec _b_ quthcri_ze_~-~crson.r ppNrsNant to un pravis~on e_ .law erlact~~ en or a der Cct, + )qa0~ shall be_ccyn. ~ent~~l a~d_no_uut~hor_ize~_-p~r~son shall _~isclase an su~h ss~~or relate r-ecordf.I hlivt _also f~rwarc~e~ ~o~yys_c~ this in crmat,en to Mr, David ~.utz,I hereby c(eny ycu autAoriaation tc ufre m~ sSN .n any wq , / Mr. D. tVintermeyer liQB Carlisle Ad. ' Camp Hill, PA 17011 ~h~~~~ ~ ~~ A , Media Office 12 S. Monroe Street Media, PA 19063 Attorneys at Law 1880 John f. Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 1400 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103 (215)563-3500 Facsimile: (215)663-5610 www.dbmplaw.com February 22, 2002 David L. Lutz, Esquire 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 RE: Claimant: Dale Wintermeyer Our Insured: Joseu Salinas-Valdez D/L: 7/14/01 Claim #: 01-245468 MBS DBMP File No. 2500 Dear Mr. Lutz: New Jersey Office 16 Aberdeen Place Woodbury, NJ 08096 (856) 251-9600 Facsimile: (856) 251-9602 This will confirm that we have canceled the depositions of the plaintiff and my client scheduled for February 21, 2002 in order to provide additional time for my client to evaluate your demand of the policy limits in this case. I have advised you that we will have a response to your policy limits demand within thirty days. ,r ~ ThaI°uC yC14 1Or y '3r C:;Li:*veu5 . Very truly yours, DUG BY: RCG/ks ~G]NNIS AND PACE (~ VI~~~~ l./ DUGAN BRINKMANN MAGINNIS AND PACE E~GINO & RC JNER, P. C. 4503 NORTH FkoHr SiREEr HARRISBURG, PA 17110.1708 717/2386791 FAx 717/2345610 RICHARD C. ANGINO MICHAEL E. KOSIX NED.]. ROVNER RICHARD A. SADLOCK JOSEPH M. MELILLO JOSEPH M. DORIA TERRY S. HYMAN JAb1ES DECWTI DAVIDL LUTL JOANL SDIIULAK W WN.ANGIN6ROVNP.R.COM EMAIL: DLUTZ@ANGiN6AOVNER.COM February 25, 2002 Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Re: Wintermeyer v. Salinas-Valdez Deaz Randy: This letter will serve to confirm our telephone conversation of February 20, 2002, wherein we agreed to suspend the depositions of our respective clients. You indicated that you made a recommendation that there be a tender of limits of the $25,000, but that there was no guarantee that the insurer would follow through with your recommendation. You also indicated that you wanted to wait 30 days until a claims committee reviewed the file. If you require further information and/or documentation, please advise. I met with Mr. Wintermeyer on February 21, 2002, and he has provided me with authority to accept a tender of policy limits of $25,000 with regard to his bodily injury claim. Secondly, pursuant to Brian Yount's October 3, 2001, letter, enclosed for your convenience, Mr. Winterrneyer has also provided me with authority to accept a property damage of $976.50. However, the property damage settlement is contingent upon a tender of the bodily injury policy limits. Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Very truly yours, t 4 David L. Lutz DLL:mtg Enclosure 237508.I~DLLVv1TG ,~-~~ r DUGAN BRINKMANN MAGINNIS AND PACE Media Office 12 5. Monroe Street Attorneys at Law Media, PA 19063 (610) 891-8400 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 1400 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103 (215) 563-3500 Facsimile: (215) 563-5610 www.dbmplaw.com March 27, 2002 Via Telecony and Regular Mail David L. Lutz, Esquire 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 RE: Claimant: Dale Wintermeyer Our Insured: Joseu Salinas-Valdez D/L:7/14/01 Claim #: 01-245468 MBS DBMP File No. 2500 Dear Mr. Lutz: New Jersey Office 16 Aberdeen Place Woodbury, NJ 08096 (856) 251-9600 Facsimile: (856) 251-9602 This will follow-up my voice mail message to you on March 26, 2002 in which I advised that I have authority to tender the policy limits of $25,000.00 and to pay $976.50 for Mr. Wintermeyer's property damage. I will forward a release for your client's signature in the near future. Ve:~~ tn11y yours, DUGAN, $RINK,A~ANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE C. RCG/ks ~ti;a~+ - e 2002 16:10 ~FR DUGRN-BRINK MRG PRCE15 563 5610 TO 7386#02500#17172 P.O2iO2 ~ ,~ To .I~r. Randy C, Green. March 151dOoz I am wri~in~ in t'r~ardS to our mutuv~ I~tigqa,tio~l dis~toSitiol~.I hav re~ai e~ Mr; Pavia 1,utx~ o Angqino4~touner~to represent m hest intcre.rts~wh;~h 1 hue e~tpresse~ to ?1r, 1,uta.I havf rccently received a letter~from Mr, !, tz wh-~h ~s._dated.Mgfch ~~ aooa,Mr, l,ut~..nas._it1 Or~me~ me..in..t.h4t_. Ic'~te~' tha~ I .have.provide~ .him wi~h-..thr~authori~y.to_acce pt_~1 our'. pr_Qperty_dama e >::;. settlement o fey o-~ ~4~t6,5© and_:t!11~t he-c.ommu'nlca~e~gthu~ :...:Settlemtn~ a er~..to- ou,T.ha~._o_f~ er_is.~tn~_-acce ta.~l_e.~o me. " i hau not ~ned ~n a .e.r..s. u~.hich state thatpl wilt Accep~ thatmount,, .pan ..checl;s..are ser~t to~ne for that amount I will not s~ ~ it~4 ~-~ will be, rc~turneck.That amoun~wil.1 onl cov~ the ~'ieplacemrntglabor. or my rare otorc clc. Qllt~ou h_-there werE othcr_..parts.t~at weh~e ~~ma,q e~ a~ i ~ -_>~r~, Salinas,I have afro in ormed Mr. i ~ f , .David' Lutz tat Z.woul ~ ~e ±ur,t~n .to ou to in orm `J~u that ~ am not nccep~~n your' o er',~ have u~r~tten in th m e y ust r cent letter to Dau~d -.utz = am d~r~ct~n ~ uu td act i n accordance to m+~~ b est i n~errsts and, as m Y representitiue o m~ best ~ntcres~s~b in~orm~n M , ,; . Green thyt I ~i l i not accept his mos~ I'rcent ~~ er, o . .- Q?6. S0, .I then a1,~O wrote to pr'. ~.u~Cz ~`s am al5"O~dl~ec~ -~~ YGU 'to r'e~use to accept Mr, Gr'eerl~o fer."~ would I, e to know ~.~ you have had cop~e,r e~ m medical rrcordr e the p~rtho~pe is Institute o~ Pa, ~urnish c@ to cu }_y that I~ter'+pr~se~or' by An,y One ~rom he la firs 0-~ hn ino K'aUner, if that has occutrred(~please inform +ne o the id ntity of the individuals who have, prou~~c~ec~ yyou ~~th my me~-c~ i hecords qnc~ o the name e the arm d~ businer~ enter~risC which that oe~son~cr person wor~.r ~ofi, Thank yea, Sincerer Mr. A Wmtc»neyer ia~ Cutlets Ad Gmp Hll. PA 19011 p ~,:: X~ ~0~ ~P.O2 ** ~l Vii : . CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Mary T. Geraets; an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE upon defense counsel and Mr. Dale Wintermeyer via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed as follows: Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendant Mr. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Cazlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dated: ~' 245515.1~DLL~NITG ~. . A ~ ~~ 1',.I IGf ~ ~'fil m ... 1 ~__ _ ---. __; t-7 i _'e ~ 4;7 ~y `7 S~ _"" N i i ~. ^~ U --1 K N ,: I->~ ~;: DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE BY: RANDY C. GREENS, ESQUIItE ATTORNEY LD. # 62692 f' 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14`" Floor Attorney for Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY v. Josue Salinas-Valdez NO.: 01-5417 Defendant(s) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE I, Randy C. Greene, Esquire, attorney for defendant, Josue Salinas-Valdez, served upon the plaintiff, Dale Wintermeyer, the following: 1. A letter dated February 13, 2004 enclosing a copy of the Court's February 9, 2004 Rule with regard to Defendant, Josue Salinas-Valdez's Motion to Dismiss for failure to prosecute, via regular and certified mail, in the above-referenced matter; 2. The certified copy of the letter was refused; and the regular mail was not returned and 3. The certified return receipt was received back on March 8, 2004. MAGINNIS ANn PACE Dated: March 16, 2004 ~~ C. GREENS o e for Defendant, Josue alinas-Valdez Media Office 12 5. Monroe Stree[ Media, PA 19063 (215) 563-3500 DUGAN BRINKMANN MAGINNIS AND PACE Attorneys at Law 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 1400 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103 (215) 563-3500 Facsimile: (215) 563-5610 www.dbmplaw.com February 13, 2004 Via Regular and Certified Mail Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 RE: Dale Wintermeyer v. Josue Salinas-Valdez, Docket No. 01-5417 DBMP File No. 2500 Dear Mr. Wintermeyer: New Jersey Office Enclosed please find a copy of the Court's February 9, 2004 Rule with regard to Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez's Motion to Dismiss For Failure to Prosecute in the above- referenced matter. Please note that you must show cause as to why your action should not be dismissed within twenty days of service of this Rule. Very truly yours, DUGAN, BRINICMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE ,~ ~r BY: Y C RBENE RCG/ks Enclosure 16 Aberdeen Place Woodbury, NJ 08096 (856) 251-9600 - Facsimile: (856) 251-9602 . _ I. ~" FEB ~ 3 z0a DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE BY: RANDY C. GREENS, ESQUIItE ATTORNEY LD. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14'h Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY v. Joseu Salinas-Valdez NO.: 01-5417 Defendant(s). RULE UPON PLAINTIFF TO' SHOW CAU5E WHY HIS COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE DISMISSED FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION AND NOW, this 4 ~ day of ~~, 2004, a RULE is hereby issued upon Plaintiff', to show cause, if any thereby, why Plaintiffs Complaint should not be dismissed for lack of prosecution within twenty (20) days of the date of the Order to be entered by this Court, or suffer appropriate sanctions to be imposed upon application to the Court. RULE RETURNABLE: Ono--da'„y~--e=` , X904 at ' - -° °' ~- -~- 20 ~, . ,a~..~x-u- . BY THE COURT; is ( ,(/ n /d~a-~ .~i.~J p J. ~'RtJ~ CQiaY FRGAA F~LCi?~0- ~n Teebma~ly whereof, f flare uttfe set my hand end the stet of saki ~ofC~a~rl~bb. Na. Thl y d!~ ~ F4nthoneEyny . .., ii ,..; ~ ~Y„ C --- _.... a _..._.... _ -.--_. _ o~ z _ ° tai . ~ _. T ~ T o. ~ .. z _;, her 8 ~~ d ~ .... r ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~_ ~ ; s, --- o y - S a "+' ~,,.;~~;...... ~ l ~ ~ ~.::~.. ~ o ~,, ~ W ~ j'~ ~ ro m X^ O i~, y C'1 D I ^~0^ ~zaa- coo.yz ~1 a~ly~mc \ I~I~Sy~ `~ . N ~~ , ~ ` v ~ DICIICCm ~~ as s N i' ~ti ~ sum°o ~u ~ t, ~~ i `~1 ~ ~ ~+ti ~ yN fa '~° Cm o ~~r ryp f'. y ~ eGm % n~ ~ ~~ i. Y N ~ ~ T~ ~ + ~~ R me W ~~~ o -a m ~' _ S W U7 + ~ i ~ }.. i ' . _ Ate.. 1 u ' S i t ! a ..~ .tm N ~ Z ,N n, _, M1 .~ _ .. 4~s ~" 1 '.. ,- v r's, I ~OSUP .~a~lnnt' a~~ - ~rn IN..FORMA.PAUPERIS AFFIDAVIT/PETiT1ON MAR U 1 2004 Com6erla ~ t _Co,r , . -.~Ic°s~ ~- not~r # 0 I-Sy, I`l STATEMENT OF THE PET1T1ONER I hereby request that this Court permit me to proceed in forma pauperis (without payment of the filing tee), In support of this t state'the following: I am the Petitioner in the above matter aad because of my financial condition am unab a to pay the fee for filing SubppCnas and Or Othfr f l ilhc~ .fees that are tl`elittec~ to t~is case and litiga~ion. ® I represent that the infonnatio below relating to my ability to pay the fees and costs is true and correct: e~~W~~~~~,,: None ~~PnaN~ ~lnn~ ~,~: Wnne aEU.eMViovMa+r J1vnr umaenw• ~.s.ic_ LA'OIDE'! EMP{AYER 6h4NY OR WA43E9 PEA MOHM: nxn now, this ~ day of1'1" _h ~ 0 0 y , upon consideration of the above . petition, defendant's petition to proceed In Forma Pauperis is (~~,~~~ . bi~bi~e~t- r .. ~~~~ , J. MgROAOE: NAME: Abe: NM1E M3E .. ~. .~.R~a a,xdasu as„~. .. -.,,.. _.~ru_ .ex .sz~+ea~mx~."~" &~.~.~.wa ss.z,:.-~,Ma~aw„~sav.,msrs '~"u°.2YP' "~ ftln C d ~~ .C' ~ ~ 4~ c ~' 3~ f~ r,_, m O b ~ ~ i.3 D Z O ~ cs~ `'~ t;~t -a _ _ may. IN .FOFIMA.PAUPERIS ',~~ AFFIDAVIT/PETITION MAR U 1 ~U04 ~. ~+l I n T e ~ Art co , s• vrs. Dt)t~T # ~ - STATEMENT OF THE PETITIONER I hereby request that this Courc permit me to proceed in forma pauperis (without payment of the filing fee). In support of this I state the following: I am the Patitioneh in the above matter and because of my financial condition am unab a to pay the fee for filing Subppena.r and Of Ot~1er f l ~ IhCt -~ees that are ~'elctte~; to t~is case and litigation. J ® I represent that the irtformatio below relating to my ability to pay the fees and costs is true and correct: saLaavoa wacES PEi MoNrN: ~ ~ ~ P PAGc Y OP 2 OTNE9 SELF•EMPIAYMENT' p V I I C OMOENGS: 1'I u I I T. WOPKMANS CCMP~NSATICN' N 11 / 1 l `' 1'~ ,p PUELIC AS4ISTANCE: IV \I I I P _ UNEMPLOYMENT CCMP~NSATION ANO SUPPLEMENTAL EENEPrtS' N O11( - . 1 T ~+ ._L 1._ n_._ V - f l.U 1 ~ Q C ~ C ~ e i ~A ._ ~~ t 11 ~.._ AND now, this ~~day o ;~Q Q y , ~~ petition, defendant's petition to proceed I upon consideration of the above Forma pauperis is 9Po16E4 EMROVEiL• SALANY OP WAGE Phi MGNiN: NAME: AGE: NAME AGE: ~.. ;.~, ~ -~~54i~~x~+n~dsv,n ...~_ex .cn-.~siw mNi..a. z~i-.+,__ .:_ i..~~W_US;.ldtlliSH' ..-&~9yY~i A~~i?sx ~.au+.abnW~ux ~ P91~ ~ Ytltl ~TV '~ ft ~~ ~w~V~J ~~~!'f'~i 111 ~ 7~~~' '{ ~ ~~i Idlinterme„r r-p~rnin ti~ vr s ~nc~ae..Ca~j a.~ Il olr~ -De rcn~~n-F _. _ - --- - _And -now on this da~q o_-~ Fe~6r.uar_ aooy i'lainti _.~ale. Wintermeyyer__malU _al~,pear__in this Court ursua tm his Petitidn _For_!Rule Ta Appear 1n 1'ersorl _In Th ~s Court- In _~r~er~o Shoup _Jast ,-Cause To _ uash Dismissa~_o Com~Olaint _Pendent~_l.itL~un~ t~er~ ore pin~nti ~S Petition. is herb rante~. J fJ- f r~ ,~-, ~r~IP_ l,~/~nterrnev~,r Submitted on Feb.3~004_ To the CAU~'`~ .1~.~p uli ni'rrm vre. r-P~in t , .~ Jo cur Co linas Valdez-p r n dan --- - -- __ . _And~~~ on~his ~Q`y_o.~_~~br~.ar_y~_~oow~_- -~'1ain~i_¢ f__D_a)e ~~_nterme_ er_~aS_beei~_gran~e er- -mi~sior~ ~o,__li_~i_qa~~e__thi~~i.s~a~-ataon_J_in_this__~our~ . ;. __'Pen~ente_l.~te__N-!unc_~?ro_Tunc and _De_ endantrriat_ioh _t0 D,sm isS_ For._F.a~l ure_ ~o _PrOSec~te_ts__~ ere fore _den i_ed. _Rv 'the Pe~itin~ter _ _-- -. __ ~ _ __ 1~1,~infi,~'mryr~ __ _._. __Su6mitted Oh Fe~a00'1 _____ _ - .. M, .. m ~. x~; ,. _, e i - Su_bmi~te~_to~~c__Cumbe~lan~S~unt _Lour_t___on_Fzba3_~o-0~_ L-Cop- _Pf the-Compl_altlt~f'i_ nerd by_Oa_id--l~utZ=Fxhibit~_/ _----.__~ -~~ Da~a les~stll'11atc f_pm '~tondq ~ppl=~lhi~it-~/ ~, ~,~~~ _dgted._~1~01_o_~~r~m~r~an 4o_unt~p_~~u~~utztat a __-__~ ~u-~li~~n_esr ~~__pay i~~°i~_~am~9~.r_o-.~_mr_mo~orc_ r~e,_Exhit 3 -~~~~p ; ~; -letter -1J'av~d-I.utz_-~_ent to _6ri_~n~'~unt_dated__~IasLo~_ _ -- - - -- - S,CQ~~_o fJttteh'~~0mI._utz_to~ne ~ate~~loU,_6 2,001_in fo~rmin~ me.- to_b~e at__h,,r_o_ i e o~F~b, a^1~~o_o~_~ta Luc my_c~e~as~tion ~x,_s/ , - e ~ ~~~ t to ~ to J ~ ~ ~ _6_~ I, -tier_that),utz_~'en_-Ku~y~rreen~ _da r~ JaYI, ~~ooz__ ~X,_6 / ~ ~` ~,1.ttt~.r that _I.utz_sent~o__me_date~(_Feb, as~zoa2 ab_outmy~neetiny-_ . wit{, him_on_Feb,zl _D~_th~~_Rand -Greene d~dnt_.r{~ow up__for,_Ex,~j b~Cop o~ my-letter that I__mail~~l_to__Rand,y ._Green-on.~~is~b~_Ex,B~ ,y 9~ Co_p ~ _, ~ I ctter_ ~h~tl _del iu_er_e~ to_I~u~Cz on _Na _~~ oz Cxo ~ / , , I.O, ~1~~ t~~o_r~~or_R~I_e---T~_-Appe~r__~n__~~,~c~~tt_zn__0_;cder--__; To Shp~__J u.st_Cause T_o_ Q~a~h _D_ismissal__0f Co~~p_lai_nt_ p 1 I, ®_ri ~ nuls o-~-my-~_Rule_s_ ------ - -- - - 1;1..i;x b,~___1-O~amage-a.r~e.s.~men~t_ad-b-y Ric~ar~--c,_Anr~mo~ .,. f1r._Ds.~~crme~~' ~ ti ~-~ L Court u rs, C ~Ofl r saii ~,r U I e~ D .rPnr~nnt ~ Ciui ~ HCtion. Noe O I-SNi~ PROOF OF SERVICE I, ~ ~~ .~ _~~. ~.1~ I Yl I. f~' h1 P 1! e r ,hereby certify that I have this a3 rd dayD~,of ~C~ ~ ~ served) the foregoing document(s). ~Q.Lf1~I~~S Ansl eGs~.C 1-0~ W manner the _ listed below, service satisfies the requirements of Service by First-Class Mail to: ~ C gg J ~.- r . COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CHESTER COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. CRIMINAL ACTION v .~ d D. WINTERMYER No. 689 M o3 ORDER AND NOW, this i4th day of May, 2003, upon consideration of the testimony of the Defendant with regard to his financial situation, the Petition to proceed with a summary appeal in forma pauperis is granted, and costs and fees associated with this matter are hereby waived. ~eri':fierl From The ~tscord This__~Day of 20.~ ,~. ~.~ Deputy Cl>~~~ of CQ1's2721Un Pleas C~urt:,~ OA1Nt ,4LTp110P,tLE December 8, 2004 Mr. D. Wintermeyer 1406 Carisle Road Camp Hill, PA. 17011 RE: Oiar Insured: - Our Claim.#: Loss Date: Dear Mr. D. Wintermeyer: pocket N0. O1-5~fll Joseu Salinas Valdez 01-245468 07/14/01 Please be advised that I am the new adjuster handling-this loss. All future correspondence regarding this claim should be directed to my attention. At this time I am requesting that you call me in reference to the above caption loss, so that we might resolve this matter. I can be reached at 800-727-6664, extension 29316, anytime between the hours of 10:00 AM thru 6:30 PM Eastern Standard Time. Your attention to this matter would be most appreciated. Si cerely, Russell Johns Litigation Rep entative Claims P.O. Box 105019 Atlanta, Ga. 30348 800-727-6664 Ext.29316 Fax: 800-680-1904 1 Docket No, 01-5~1~ Maned ~o C9aimS ~ep~ I o f= Hart ford Omni tns, Co, yPer i r~s~re~(~Jos~.u S~I~nc~.s~ Vale ez, All ha~t~h o ~ havti ire. ~1,'e_ ~e~ in Our )ette~ th ~ Z Ic~ h ~ !-~ r_ 1~t,9A ~ phis ?e .a is~Q.ci~ian thin ~nr~ or ~throu }t t e vequ~ _o_ t~t~ ~um~-erl~nr~ fount ~urt , F~zl, r~~ to ask me ~~_ ~ue.rtiQns~ that ou _~ta have too an~~ 2 v q ~ J ~ - II o~nsultr t eth as ~rD~1C,ent y as am ably to,. Corn er!_ n~ Coon? c~urt_ o_~.c,e in cad-I_ sly P , u,hi~h ° ~` ~ ~ ~ , _ts s~ rJl _-F en_ t1~,r ~AV_e. yo-u-_h~e-1 raui.~ed wi~ any o n,_ ca~t_- ient~al med c~1 o ~ rec_o~c( ,n orma~,on t~ciur~~n_ ~~h~ x ~a .~ a_~__ .-m-~/__broken )e in'uri~s Which w~r~ c~~as_e-dy~~ ~'o~S~~/ ~a_~ingS' ~~a dez`~ Are ~o~ _c~ -h-ona __ i~_e. i ~tu~ir?_~f ~o-~-ar_e__a ~onA _ i~e 1~w er Qre ~~..-r~-,~~~~r'i-~e~.Aa 1 a~1 ermit~eo( to r wAl Q~ wr,~~en cammuni catians4 Sind. coinputerr ~r,e a lain. t m ethnic y-~li aus b~li_~_ ,r~ I do n~~ ro-mm- 6 ~ ca~e. _b~ ~ m~~l~no~' com ute~s b.ecau,re com- u~e~~ may h~ ro~~ram ~ ~o ~li~- tt~.~ thr ~o.There,- ore~ ~ !~~y ~on~'inu~ to ~ommt~rticate Ywith m~e in '~ -gro~s ~o t1~i,~ m~t~>?r in ~h~ same manner ~S our re~en~ I~tte~ to m~~ s`ne~ ou are now the mos~ ~tcent claims : ad .user ctnol 1 ita ation re~pr~sentit- a.r for thrs I~_ ~I r~;.rpos-~,on~1~ urould rk~ to k how A . ~tv ~ues~PO_ns. ~o yogic have. a co. m tom 1 i~~ Sup t whi c ha~°' ~~en i lei i ~i~th y ~ wou c~ u ,n re ar ~ ~o tbi~ ma~tcr have et~.rmine hay in p _e~ ~o ~pratect m_ i~e ai R~ h~s so t~-at I m-a ~etatn ~.oc~tn~,ente , _ _roa_-_ a com unica~ions/~Q. ail Barties inc~~~i ~ ~C~m~,~erlan Cou nt~ Courts _ .,_II can`~-nu~e ~-o ~scu~s th_~s .den in Su ,t b 0 _ ~,-. ....~. pti . ~s.~rav,. ..__--' stiw~., s',ncerc-Iy, __ - -, Me. D. MMtermeyer f 1406 Carllsle Rd Camp HN, PA 17011 .~ _ _ ~~. ~w~~ 'Dun . ~ a.~ C,,tmbrrlr~nra . M8 k i1~ I,~in~~.R1e_t~~'~ 9rti-n._,_,iT~-~ Cat, ~$ D-(= Corny ~ ~o ~l~a~` J~~e SaVi~era:~~ V~.hlez-Ll~.~ ndan~'. ~t~se IVo~ ®I-~~RB~ ~i~il l.~ >;I Action . PROOF OF SERVICE I, 111'n tJ 1A! t n ~~ I have this a$ day of the foregoing document(s), o Un' (~, f- hereby certify that _,~~, served pursuant to _, upon the Person(s). Service by First-Class Mail to: T11't RirSSe~ ( ~Dh11,f 1~)~ . ar-Erorr~ 0 n~ r.lni~r,s 0, ~ Q~~~ C7 cn "'1"! ~_r~ r- P -y7fryi CYY ~ T T ~ ~J~' _~ !=a T57 ~ l ~~i' _ ...~.. [u('t ~ ~. ' /~r-~; . ~ ~, ~.,,.. row. CniAn,1:~~p~r~Pua~ar,~ M~~ b.~rntermev~r-Picaint~.~-~= ~s. sLSU~ sali~a~' Vnlr~~z-lie-~en~i~~st c~~~ N~~ QF-~~f~ ClUI! I.POGI~ /~C'~iOYI PROOF OF SERVICE Service by First-Class Mail to: Mr„ ~calsi :~ l.u z H ~ ~ , ,~ . 1~ci,Pa,11110 1, ,hereby certify that I have this ~~,~ day of Ja.n~{aru ,,inns served the foregoing document(s), .SJ TU Produc~umenf s Ur .~ , . is~.r6sbt3"$'.5its~irt?i{w„tl~sSk r <~~"ama.#iv.~x+biob9._4s ... , ,r. , N , '~ 6 WA"~A°y,~^-~~ .•,`.~Bh2~eaa .~ - '"°V:A~~AUaf"~ ._ r•.s ;-~ c7 ~ _ _ .;a ~ CFt 1 ~ i '. S~ ;C -r.F . -a rn cis : ~ "l rJ ,~_, -r: `~- "r ..°'~... ~ 4`i' Yi ,:~ .. i " ~ .y7 ~t N 7 /P ~~ ~ / ~` Fig 0 3 2tt~4 DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE BY: RANDY C. GREENS, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY LD. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14"' Floor Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215)563-3500 Dale Wintenneyer Plaintiff(s), v. Joseu Salinas-Valdez Defendant(s). Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY NO.: 01-5417 RULE UPON PLAINTIFF TO SHOW CAUSE WHY HIS COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE DISI~SSED FO L C OF PROSECUTION AND NOW, this ~ day of , 2004, a RULE is hereby issued upon Plaintiff, to show cause, if any there by, why Plaintiffs Complaint should not be dismissed for lack of prosecution within twenty (20) days of the date of the Order to be entered by this Court, or suffer appropriate sanctions to be imposed upon application to the Court. RULE RETURNABLE: Z~ o ~r ?tr' ~'P~W~G..e. r c~ ~-~: ~~ c~ (~ v. ~, j o 0 ~S ~~. ,! r ~~ ;, ~ i(y_r! 'tZ :'t fed 6- 83.E haQZ ~.~J~`~rJtJ~F;105cf 3i~.I ;0 ~~I~~~O-t7~ ~!~ DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE BY: RANDY C. GREENS, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY LD. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14s' Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY v. Joseu Salinas-Valdez Defendant(s). NO.: 01-5417 ORDER AND NOW, this day of 2004, upon consideration of the Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdezs' Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute, and any and all response thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that said Motion is GRANTED and Plaintiff s Complaint is hereby DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE. BY THE COURT: J. DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY I.D. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevazd 14`" Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY v. Joseu Salinas-Valdez Defendant(s). NO.: 01-5417 DEFENDANT JOSEU SALINAS-VALDEZS' MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROSECUTE Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez, by and through his counsel, Dugan, Brinkmann, Maginnis and Pace, files this Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute and avers as follows: Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer (hereinafter referred to as "Plaintiff'), filed a complaint against Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Defendant"), in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County on September 17, 2001. (See Exhibit "A" attached hereto and incorporated herein). 2. The Plaintiff s Complaint alleged physical injuries and property damage stemming from a collision between Plaintiff's motorcycle and Defendant's automobile. 3. On September 3, 2002 ,according to the docket in this matter, Plaintiff's Counsel filed a Praecipe to Withdraw Appearance. (See Exhibit B) 4. Since Plaintiff s Counsels' Praecipe to Withdraw Appearance on September 3, 2002, Plaintiff has not filed any motion, petition or praecipe concerning this matter. When a civil action has been commenced and the plaintiff fails to diligently prosecute his or her case, a defendant may avail him or herself of a motion for judgment of non pros in seeking a "reasonably prompt conclusion to a case." Shope v. Eagle, 710 A.2d 1104, 1106 (Pa. 1998) 6. The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has established a three part test to examine the circumstances under which a dismissal for failure to prosecute is appropriate: 1) A lack of due diligence on the part of the plaintiff in failing to proceed with "reasonable promptitude"; 2) Lack of a compelling reason for the delay; and , 3) Actual prejudice to the defendant. Shone v. Eagle, 710 A.2d 1107-1108 7. It is the plaintiff, not the defendant, who bears the burden of moving his case along within a reasonable time. Id. citing to Pennridge Elec. v. Souderton School, 615 A.2d 95,99 (Pa. Super. 1992) 8. A lengthy period of delay can be one reason for dismissal for inactivity. See. Metz Contracting v. Riverwood Builders. Inc. 520 A.2d 891 (Pa. Super. 1987) appeal denied 531 A.2d 431 (Pa. 1987) (no activity taken for nearly three and one-half years); Cathcart v. Keene Industrial Insulation, 471 A.2d 493 (Pa.Super 1984)(no activity taken for over four years). 9. The record reflects that Plaintiffs' cause of action was filed in September 2001 and the last action taken by plaintiff was in September of 2002. 10. From September of 2002 to the present, there has been no activity of record. 11. Plaintiff ceased discovery and did not initiate settlement negotiations and Plaintiff, from all indications, abandoned this matter as to Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez. 12. If Plaintiff truly believed that this matter was proceeding accordingly during the past eighteen months, there would be some indication on the record. 13. IF Plaintiff were awaiting discovery that was not being provided to them, there would be some evidence of motions to compel or other indications that they were attempting to move this matter forward. 14. Plaintiff has not proceeded with due diligence and reasonable promptitude in proceeding with this action. 15. Plaintiff has not offered any reason, compelling or not, for his delay. 16. The passage of time has certainly affected the ability of witnesses to recall the facts and details of the subject matter of the claim thereby resulting in prejudice to Joseu Salinas- Valdez 17. Given the Plaintiff s complete lack of diligence, the burden for which lies with him and him alone, and the prejudice to Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez, which resulted therefrom, this matter should be dismissed with prejudice for Plaintiff's failure to prosecute. WHEREFORE, Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez respectfully request this Honorable Court to Dismiss this Plaintiff's Complaint with Prejudice. Respectfully submitted, DUGAN,,$RINI~4IANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE Defendant s-Valdez DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE BY: RANDY C. GREENS, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY LD. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14`s Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY v. Joseu Salinas-Valdez Defendant(s). NO.: 01-5417 DEFENDANT JOSEU 5ALINAS-VALDEZS' BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF HIS MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROSECUTE Defendants Joseu Salinas-Valdez, by and through his counsel, Dugan, Brinkmann, Maginnis and Pace, files this Brief in Support of his Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute and states as follows: I. STATEMENT OF THE QUESTION INVOLVED A. SHOULD PLAINTIFF'S CAUSE OF ACTION BE DISMISSED FOR PLAINTIFF'S FAILURE TO PROSECUTE ITS ACTION IN A TIMELY MANNER? Suggested Answer: Yes II. STATEMENT OF THE CASE PROCEDURAL HISTORY Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer (hereinafter referred to as "Plaintiff'), filed a complaint against Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Defendant"), in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County on September 17, 2001. (See Exhibit "A" attached hereto and incorporated herein). The Plaintiff's Complaint alleged physical injuries and property damage stemming from a collision between Plaintiff's motorcycle and Defendant's automobile On September 3, 2002 ,according to the docket in this matter, Plaintiff's Counsel filed a Praecipe to Withdraw Appearance. (See Exhibit B) Since Plaintiff's Counsels' Praecipe to Withdraw Appearance on September 3, 2002, Plaintiff has not filed any motion, petition or praecipe concerning this matter. III. SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT Plaintiffs have shown a want of due diligence in their failure to proceed with reasonable promptness. Plaintiffs have not offered a compelling reason for their delay. It is the plaintiff, not the defendant, who bears the burden of moving his case along within a reasonable time. A lengthy period of delay can be one reason for dismissal for inactivity. If Plaintiff truly believed that this matter was proceeding accordingly during the past eighteen (18) months, there would be some indication on the record. The passage of time has certainly affected the ability of witnesses to recall the facts and details of the subject matter of the claim thereby resulting in prejudice to Defendant. Joseu Salinas-Valdez IV. ARGUMENT A. PLAINTIFFS" CAUSE OF ACTION SHOULD BE DISMISSED FOR PLAINTIFF'S FAILURE TO PROSECUTE ITS ACTION IN A TIMELY MANNER. When a civil action has been commenced and the plaintiff fails to diligently prosecute his or her case, a defendant may avail him or herself of a motion for judgment of non pros in seeking a "reasonably prompt conclusion to a case." Shope v. Eagle, 710 A.2d 1104, 1106 (Pa. 1998). In examining under what circumstances a court may dismiss an action for inactivity, the Supreme Court, in Shope v. Eagle, 710 A.2d 1107-1108, has established a three part test: 1) A lack of due diligence on the part of the plaintiff in failing to proceed with "reasonable promptitude" 2) Lack of a compelling reason for the delay 3) Actual prejudice to the defendant It is the plaintiff, not the defendant, who bears the risk to move his case along within a reasonable time. Id. citing to Pennridge Elec. v. Souderton School, 615 A.2d 95, 99 (Pa.Super. 1992). A lengthy period of delay can be one reason for dismissal for inactivity. See. Metz Contracting v. Riverwood Builders. Inc., 520 A.2d 891 (Pa.Super. 1987) appeal denied 531 A.2d 431 (Pa. 1987) (no activity taken for nearly three and one-half yeazs); Cathcart v. Keene Industrial Insulation,471 A.2d 493 (Pa.Super. 1984) (no activity taken for over four yeazs). If Plaintiff s truly believed that this matter was proceeding accordingly during the past eighteen (18) months, there would be some indication on the record. If Plaintiff is awaiting discovery that was not being provided to them, there would be some evidence of motions to compel or other indication that they were attempting to move this matter forward. Plaintiff has not proceeded with due diligence and reasonable promptitude in proceeding with this action. Plaintiff has not offered any reason for her delay. The passage of time has certainly affected the ability of witnesses to recall the facts and details of the subject matter of this claim. Plaintiff beazs the burden of moving her case along within a reasonable time and did not do so; Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez should not now be prejudiced further by Plaintiffs' failure to proceed in this matter. Because Plaintiff has failed to diligently prosecute his case, Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez now avails himself of a motion for judgment of non pros so that he may seek a "reasonably prompt conclusion to {this} case." Shope v. Eaele, 710 A.2d 1106. V. CONCLUSION Given the Plaintiffs' complete lack of diligence, the burden for which lies with him and him alone, and the prejudice for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez which resulted therefrom, the Plaintiffs' cause of action should be dismissed with prejudice for his failure to prosecute. Respectfully submitted, MAGINNIS AND PACE By Defendant ~s-Valdez VERIFICATION Randy C. Greene, Esquire, hereby states that he is counsel for the within and based on other verified pleadings that the statements made in the foregoing Defendant's Motion to Dismiss For Failure to Prosecute are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information and belief. The undersigned understands that the statements therein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. DUGAN, BY: ACE RANDY C~. GREE~ESQUIRE Attorney f Def d t Joseu Salinas-Valdez Dated: January 20, 2004 DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE BY: RANDY C. GREENS, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY LD. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14"' Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), v. Joseu Salinas-Valdez Defendant(s). COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY NO.: 01-5417 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Randy C. Greene, Esquire, hereby certifies thgt a true and correct copy of Defendant's Motion to Dismiss was transmitted on January ~, 2004 by first class mail to the following parties or their counsel: Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 GREENS, ESQUIRE OCT-09.-0] 09:12 FROM: the Hartford-Omni ID: 7709521115 ~ ~ PAGE 2/7 ~~LL ~OCT e6-Ox 62025 an 1 ~ ~~ i~ DALE WINTERMEYEIt, Plaiatiff v. iosuE sAL~AS-VALDEZ, Deftamdant n 1N THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA QVII. ACTION -LAW .TORY TRIAL J~BMANDEB Xau have peen anod itt court ifyou wish m dead the claiau secforde is the iollowiag F~.Yw tneLSi take eistiti-\iiflrin twc9ay (2A) drys afha this Complaint and Notim ere sorved, by entahag a wriltta appeataoce peesomlty ar by ~eY and Lung fn writing with tb¢ Coaat your defenses or objeesiws m Ste cimims set Enttlt against yaa. Yw ara warned that if you faS m do so the colce may peaceod aithoru Yw. and a jtadgtoean maybe entered agaiose You by the Cautt wahont tl]tthee notice iM' arty monty damied ie tha ComPlaiae or foe aoy Mho claim arrclief mquasaod by the Plaintiff. Yoa raay ]arc money a property orothar rSghL4 impMteat rayon. YOU SHOULD TAICE'tH1S PAPER TO YOUR LANYP.R AT OfiCE ff Yt7U 170 PIOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CA73NOT AFFORC3 ONE, GO TO OR TELS3PFT0t~ TbDf's OFFICE SEC PORRFI EA.'.OV/ TO F1ND OUT VJI~RE YOU CAIZ GET LEGAL IlELP. COLIItT~TOS ear FL, Curn6elt~ad (3oamty CSOtasfiwse Culisln; iVlaasyl 17101 (7i7) l Le laan~ndedo a vsreden h carte. S'ivaped~qufnte dlr(badaso da eEms~tleaaandas expoestas mi fat pog+nas wl~ientes, testod time vieatc (2o1'daas de. piw aI pertir do la fxba de ]ademaaday fa noC®¢aaan. Usred r-tmeimeeataa o 9mpeswoRa o ~agado yarrl~e~en-is:eottnedzf~neselnses de8~mr o sntobjetioeaa Isvd'nes.~-a contracdcau.petmta- 9a.~avissdoyrac si nm:d nose-de9~c. la.aortc moms med2fas y pttade. tvtsar nos only oontraa~cd sia, ptovio sWao oagp Y lmr cas4p+kr gaga o alinio gnc as podidn ea 1~pecoion de deaiartde. Usted pweda perch diaero o sus peapicdarfec o Mros'daroa9ros iropoetenres pare arced. LLEVE ssTa Df:MMANDA A UN atIOGADO Ii.Sa~DIAT£l~M$. S[ NO T{ENE ABOGADO O SS TIO TlENE 17.OTNERO SUFTCTEN7E DE PAGAR Trti. SF.RaIJIC70, VAYA EN PE~tSONA O LLANSE PO3C TELEFONO A f.A OFICFNA Ct7YA ffiRt?CCIOtc SE i?NCUENTRA ESCRITA ABASO PAtZJt AVLe6`lG[fAR ))Oll!}E SL PUL'D$ CONSEG1.37R ASISTEBICIA L$GAi.. COURT ADMINi5TRA701L 4th Fl., CalnbtYiaad Crnmty [otatlAm~ae Carlisle, Pew%S1r.rria 1^: l0i (71?)24Q-6200 1:1'6~..':Ii'~~>'•] }ie5~i l fl:'~?iSiKa"'f. ~ ~:Si l~~=r1 X139 itl5 ~1 SY? -~IF3 ~:' ` IlI `'~ is;0. >u~. 23516e.IVN7ti2C3 S~d9 ~~ ~~• ~ ~7~.. ,~ ! ~' O,CT-03-01 09:13 FROM: TMe HarLFord-Omni • OCT-06-01 02:25 aH p DALE WIN'!'h'RMEYER, Plaintiff v. 705U1; SAI.INAS-VALT]EZ, Defendant ID=7709521115 Z IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEA5 CU!I~ERLAN7D COUKCY, FA CIVIL ACTlOIa -LAW NO. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COMSLAIhl'T PAG$ 1. Piaiutiff Dak Witrcetmeyer is as adult individual and a citi2en of the Commom~vealth of Petvtsylvania who resides in Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Petulsyhania. 2_ Defendant Iosue Salinas ~'s[dcz is an asluFt individual w)ao resides at 7004 Peters Crest Road, No. 21, Roanoke, Virginia. 3. The facts and occurrences haeinafter related tnok place ao ar about July 14, 2001, at appro7timstety 11:18 p_II1. at the irrfcrseclion of South TNird Street (Sit 2035} and Harlan Avenue, Lemoyne, C~ltabectand Comity, pcnnsylvania. 4. At Ylmrtime and plmcc, Mz. Wirttermcyer aas opelating his 1963 I3a Shadow ?SOmotorcycle in a notd~boimd•diroction on South Third Suoet approaching Hetn'mn Avemle. 5. At the same tiatc, Deter Salinas-Valdrr. xas operating a I96~4 Oldsmobite Cutlass is s noithbolmd•dittlction on South Third Street. 6. The Defendant tamed on his Itft tam signal and stopped in the intaseetion to turn left onto Herman Avenue. 7. A@er srzing the 7Jefendant's left ttun siglmzl, 2vlr. Witliermcycr slowed Ells motorcycle and attetnptcd to pass the DePerdarrt's vehicle on the tight in accordance with 75 Pa.GS.A. §3304. 3/7 2351ad,llS.tCQS.CS tee. _ ....... ~ v - ~ OCi-08-01 09:13 FROM: The Hartford-Omni ID: 7709921319 PAGE 4/7 OCT-BE -01 02:26 p.M ., rt E 8. Without warning, flue Defendart suddenly acxletat,ed and turned right which caused the right side of his vehicle to imp-act Mr. Witttermeyer and his motorcycle, causing an euideat 9. The foregnizag arcident.and al! of the injuries and dazaeges ast faNr hexcinafrGr sustained by Mr, Riiateameyer ~c the direct end ptirximate zesvlts of the negligerlt, careless, wanton, and reckless manner is which Mr. Salinas-Vaidez opaatrd his motor vehicle as foElows a) failure w keep alert anJ maintain a proper vrdtcb far the presence of other motor vehicles on the highway; b) failure to properly use turn signals c) failure W yield the right-of-way to Mr. Wintermeyer'a vehicle; a-td d) driving his vehicle upon the highway in a rllattncr endangering person and property and in a reckless manner with careless disregard to the tiplzffi and safety of others and is violation of the Motor Ychitle Codc of the Cbmnroavrcalth ofPeansylYenia Gb9~I +j;~Je ~¢v Jeeuc~Sati~-YaMez . I A. Paragraphs I thmn~t 4•are ineocporaoed hete'ra by refecenee. t t. AHr. WinLeggeyer susmirmd pain6ul and severe injut3es that include tart am not limited to a prmtitaat !eft fibular flal~ue, a diaeet 1cft 56stlar fzacture, bums, std tltaEgple eontusaons arrd abrasions. I2. 13y reason of his aforesaid injllties, Mr. Wituemteyer was forced to itlgr )iatritity for medical treatment, medications, physrcal tlletapy, sad vnlilar miscellaneous expenses is an effort to restore himself to hcaltB, ad a claim is 11mde theseE'or. 13. Because of the nat>a+c of his injuries, Alr. 'N'imecmcycr has been advised, and therefore avers, that he may be forced to incur sixoilaz mediuli expenses in the future, std a claim is made therefor. a~ss4n.lmrrtat,ea 2 OCS-09-01 09:13 FROM:She Hartford-Omni ID:770552111b rn~.c oii •OCT-0G -01 02:2f Hn { I4. AS s tesnlt of the afotrJnectioned injuries, Asir. Wurte2'Gteyer has uodergoaC and in the future maY ~~ pLYsioal az-d mental suffezing. meonvenience in carrying aut his daily ac4,ici6es, and loss oflife's plcastu~ea eod enjoyment, and a claim is made therefor. 15. As a result of the afotlmcntioned iajurira, AQr. 'Wintetmeyer has been and in the filture may be subject to ~ and humiEiation, and a elairn is made tbcrefnr. 16. As a result of the aforem~tioned injuries, Mr. Winicnneyer has suffered work loss, loss of opporitmity, io.4s of frequcni avertimc pay, loss of daily piece ratc bonus pay, and a pet2itatle-3t diminution ofhis earrdrlg power and Y, and a claim is made therefor. 17. Mr: Wusietrneyer cont~ w be pLlgoed by Persistent pain and limita$on and thcrcfore avers than Liz injuries may 6e of a pemlaaent mac. catlsin~ residual problemz and perataaenY srmring for tLe rrsmaiadet of his Lifetime, and a claim is made therefor. cr~al I,~te v.Jo-uaidrz 18. Papa 1 tbswigh 11 ate inooxporeted~hacioa by reCe. 19. As a zesuit the subject collision, Aiir: titFlrrtcfrssteyer's motorcycic sustained peoprxty darmgo, and a.chum is mado thexeforin the amountof S1;993.i$. f~9RF., P4anaefl'Dnle Winhermey~'.demaesk.jud~tent:4tlt Josuc Salinas-Vaide7: in an amaunr in tacoess of 'LEventy-Five Tho»sand (525,000_Ul1) Dollazs, 233144.11MTC+`.1.C3 3 OCi-09-01 09:14 FROM: the HartFord-Omni ID:7709521115 rv.ut iii 'O CT-06-61 0211: iy Nlv L z • exclusive of interest and oosta and in excess of any jivisdictional amount requiring compulsory acbitratioa. AIdGINt? & 1tOVl~2, P.C. .Lwz LD. No. 35956 4563 AT. Fmnt Stsrxt liaaisburg, PA 17110 (71'n 238-6791 Attorney for Plaintiff 1)afc; 23SWd.iW?rCNC3 . 13 OCi-09-01 09=13 FROM:ihe Hartford-Omni 1 ~ _. io :-ireaeeii~ie r.,un o.. '..J VF~Ri7FIC I, Dale wnternteyer, Plsiatiff, have read the 6acGgang COMPLAIIJI' and do hereby a`t'e' ~ agirm tltai the facts set forth is the foregoing Ste true and correct to the best of my Iosowledge, information and belief. I uedesstand that ffiis Verification is made subject to fire penalties of 13 paC.S_A. § 4904, relatit:o to unawom falsificetlon to authorities. Wl'iNESS: c ~fP_ ~.lxlln .efR4PtrCi' bale Wiatermeyer T Dated: ~1 f3(~ l 235! aa.»y7citt,C3 1 DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant S Q 2500 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW N0.01-5417 Civil Term JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW APPEARANCE To the Prothonotary of Cumberland County: Pursuant to Judge Hoffer's Order dated July 8, 2002, attached hereto, David L. Lutz, Esquire, hereby withdraws his appearance on behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer. ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. Davi .Lutz I.D. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 238-6791 Attorney for Plaintiff Date: ~,~ ~^`~ 236329.1~DLUMTG I ~6t1f~ :t. £~ Eiflf DALE WINTERMEYER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA v. CIVIL ACTION -LAW JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, NO. 01-5417 Civil Term Defendant JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ORDER AND NOW, this $~day of _ , 2002, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Plaintiffs counsel, David L. Lutz, Esquire, is permitted to withdraw his appeazance on behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintenneyer and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment in the above-captioned case must include Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a Payee. BY THE COURT: 247041.1\DLL\MTG CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW APPEARANCE upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed as follows: Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendant Mr. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Cazlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 ~, Dated: Q~~Jo~ 236329.1~DLLN~ITG s...rnia~.h~:da's~.(~1~~1LLT~PIn!~i{*sai~~+tiskSV;i~~zvA. .._ .sim..3~i:&~A~..ui~~w'~""" ~.atib+wliuaiuw~wx4[.. gq _ .... _. ~,. i . t..<.... _. ..1„~~ 4 :y '_?'~ s.. -t~ ~-~ ro~ (~ 1„,. ja •-• ~M~n ~j}T TI -~~ V _ T° ~-- _ff . Ci.~ --t ~~ \ ,. \\ ` r ~iP UJ~nt~r mpu P i Jnin ~ . ~ - - I ~ A C ~ z ~ ~ ( M ~p.i 1 .Hirt ~ _ ~r`r ,~~ ~nmmon Pleas ;- ~n~rdP .Ca ` - ~ CjL~ii Af~joll~hlr - ~ I A I ~ FE8 4 2DD4 Anat now on thjs day o FebruQr ~ooy~ Pigintj dale l~lintermeyyeY~ mad a~~erxr in ~~~~ Caurt ppursnrA to his P~titidn For Rule To A ear 1n Wersort In This Cou~'t In Or~e~ To Show Jpa~.rt Cause To ~t,~as~ ~dsmissal 0 > Complaint i en~ent>`_ l.ite~an~ ~ ere~o~'e~ piain'oi~.~s Pe itiorl i~ hereb ~'ante~o r~ _~ P PP~ ;if ` nPr e e ~ ___L)a1e-_r4'1linter ver-P1R' i r^r ~ rlanr~ Cnupt r C_,____n~~r~t _ _ y i 5'; ~ s Jo~~nlinr~S Ua~,ez D ~ nr~unt (,iy' ~~tiOn=No.01-.S~IL~ I Mra Dale ~Jinterme er do here.b contend and aver ~hat~~he.~ ollowin acs .are true ywhich ~ am submit-~- in ~o this Co~nr~ or_ Judicial Notice. 9 I~ A fter De enfant Josue- Salinas Ualdez rrckle.r~'1 ran into ~ --estnre~ mo~orc cle and my left le which vas broken in ~ ~l~cef oyn Jul 1y aool I su - ~aine~ a totol loss a m ~ncoe~e oryseverul manth~, ab Since I could. no~ ay orc~ to ~u a lay er~~~nd z no Ion e~ had an inca~., dui to ym 1e yin wr z laoked9 t~rou h t~~ hone book an~ Iy ca~e a~cr~ys~s an a~virti~ement b the lau.- arm o An ono and Rovner which statey and re ~~esents~~~9~~~ ~,Gw- ers r~ America"and."Free ~onsultations~Na Recover I ~-~ ~~~. y :3. About ~ w~eKs a ter my le ~~as broken b tie negqli enc~ o Josf~e Sali~has~Ual~ez I calle~,y Mra Dadi ~~ l~utz ~t the 1 aw irnn wh'~c~ h re^pre,rer~t~ ~h~ch ~~ Angono and Rovn~r, ex laine~ ~~is acc- i dent to Dav~'cl l,u Z ~ve~' t~e ,pane and I told him that ~ wante~ him to re r~cse~~ me. in Court. I also tats h6 im ghat I w nte~ him ~o collect )oo%~ 0 the uSt dU~e can ~nSatl~n D the dG~IacCS ofr mc- ghat we~'e cu~s~~ b J osufe Sal inas~ an~o~ hat this com~ensat~on or ymy motor~c ale dame es vur~s m ~ rimer concer~ p i~i~artance~to settl~ i rr~ Abe orb m~/yI odi i i n"~ry claim is s~.ttled. Rn ice ci , o~ntm'e~it ~ua~ then made or me to talk to hi~ in ~~r~-o~ on Auc~ 3~2ooi~ f P _ __. _ ._ ..~..~~a~:~.~..a ~ ~i,~i J.e~_~~ou~ ~~~.~baaw~~ .x. ~~~~r~- ,. ...ti.. :.,:, Rou~ers`'o~~fice~~o~ meet.with David Lutz for the first tim ~ Dunnq that ~eetin Which my T`lother ~t`~tin~ec~~~ a ain~ in or e~ Da~ic~ Katz 'that m ~r-maryy conc~r-~ uta~ that I wanted h• to coylect ull ca~n~Oensa~ion or m ~, o~orc cle lama es irs~~ ~~.~orc, coll~.ctinG o~ my Nodil i n ~r claim~so hat T fcoui~ et my ~motord cf e. iyXe~ `~s ~oon as ~oss~ble, pav+cl c~u-t~ .then tolo~ me ~`~'aufsh uldrit have an trouble collectin ~^or ~yoa~r motorcyycle ~arna ~s,'My Mother then ask~.d David l.utZ a~ou't his ~~~' and he ~cld her that i }~~ ~~ '~_ cG II ~~ ~ co~e ~ doespt et ai - ~ttorne David Lutz then a r e.d ore re p d y ~ p nt ~n de-s~ro- or him ~o collect ~h~ ~nlf ~u men or m~ ~or m ~otorc c ~ d~ar"na es b fp rovidi~ me ~ith a doh a~th coilt~'~c~ a'q'r~e~r~ ~nty ~br hj~ ~~ re ent- ati~n which he si nerd w{~ich dctailt hi,l` per ~en~age e~ i h~ woul~ I~a~e ~ s~ccesT ul recover on ~~~al ~hic~ is to ~e in ~Y1 ~~est i~tef-ests,h~~ Mo~~l Rule.1~~. stQtcsJ~~l~n N Lorne Yis rphibite~; porn asserting also or misl~din s~a~em~ntso~ im licati_o~s about the ~ttgrn~1yys seruice~"l~r: l.ut _'then told me to e an es~ima~C or_ m m~to~rc c~c dama''qq~s and t~a~ ate ~ nuld s~a~t ryepari nq t~e Co m~-la~'nt~ S, A ew vee~ iaterJl aic~ Nonda Plato S orts ~zo~3S r a ~stima~~ ~e dpama es tom~y motorcyycle ~,~at_~_cY'e cause~f~~y Jasue.gSalina~:~inCe m ..Motor- c c-~ was not ~o~~lYe~ m ,~rot~ r r~ ~e it ~o the s~o~ or that e~ti-nat~~u-~hich tD~ole~ ~o65og~~and I au~e, a cop y, o tat estimate ~o m ~'egal re re- se~itiu~. pau',dfl.u~z,About a mart Ylate~ thi le al Com ,,faint was sighed by pavi~ ~.utz an it s s ~ 'it to isJ Court/ ro~a~ b `~Davo ~~ u m e~ th ly ~ Lutz but not b m sel .since i't states o~j that ~ Y ~ f COChi~~'Qlh`r,C6t~~i~u IY~in~ ~~mnn o ~T ,.~~.~ 1„.~ ~-.. and to this .Court that he woul re~re,~ent the and my b e..rt i nt~rests ~o a ' ur i n this Court, 1'1 r. ~AU'id Lutz .has ailed to fo~o~-y`~th~ou h with re re.sentlrl m ~e~t -nte~'es't5 tp,a ur in thl.~ co~r~ whlc~ hey~eppresente~ to thls `~mu t and ~o m Ise~~ ~e,mandlnq q ~ur6 trials L ,res. eat ally .~u~p1111~ ~m ~~IJ~ Caur~t that ',t IS U~~9~a~lOn~O I N~~ Model Rule. 8~~1 ~o erg u e i~r1 ~ish~nestyy, an~ ! u(~ and rp-.J'~epre..~enta~i~n~whlCh are. cons'~d~erec~ ~~ ~e ro es.~-Onal m-scon~t~ct,And ABA ~1odel Ru e yo ~ ~ es' ~c re, r e t ~ I tat P1.s es n atlon Ana also occinr b''yy~ fa-lur~., to apct;'~ver sine ,~yy Hal re~res-enl~it-ve male a cap o tut Cor~,pla~nt t~ ~e w Ich he ~ile~ or ay e>~an~ed ur tr-al hau~ ~ een w anti n ~ or ei~her Ravi e~ l.~t or -this ~ouP'rt to Doti ~e o when s u~oul~ ~f. nat- lea o, ;,the stf t o '~i~r select-~n _ cc ~~o . ,~°;~~ `t';,, reJe~~a~lon/ And l~eman or' a fur ~tr~~ 1 br pau~id Ut _~ Canons. Rule. ~-101(~)~1) s~at~s~ An attorney mus~ ~~ u~ dual in ~ul IIIIn a I r~o _~,~s-~onal cdmrn~t~~en~s: R~1~ Mgd~~R~le ~o~ s~u~~.s~6Th~. at~orne kee_ in with ~h~ c ientS b~Tt pter~.st ]Y1u5~ ~XeCU~e ~easonab~e at~em~p is to ~x~e~it liti Mien"There _orer_r~y best in~Cer sts were no act~~ upp~i ~ie.ca~se ~avic~ I,u z di~ nat ~)( ;~ ~ r®u I~ wi'tM ex e~ i ti n th i~° l i~i anon f~ t~-,s uur~ to a ' u~~;~~ he~represente~d t0 me and t~ ~~ls Court, ~ns~ruentl~ ~1r, ,>vut~ ,c~ile~ to ~rovid~ me ~~th+ ~e0.lous ~ePre~`enta~-on 6~y fhise ile - 1- ento ma~lr-;e~; p~ a-Iin ~o, resent m C~am~~laln~9 an~ ~-s osltlon t~, a J~r I>~ this co~rt without pprocrr~s~°-natlon ~-h~ch ar~ v,olatlnns o Canons pR- ~`101(A)C3)~"fin a~to~ne ma nod act in~a ne~li en~t ~ Y yy s.e u.u.~~u aa~au~,.n~w km~wauwee iwtmbn._.~......o- ~..„ ... ........... -101 (Al (11 ~~ /ItP r ~~ Q Y1 nl l Fl l^- re,s'entation o-~ the cli nt."~Iso relavan to these ac a~'e RJR ~o~c~ )Zule ~ 3 ~~i1ir~ence~ 10 "Zealous re rc- sentation o t e c~iey~t anr~ 2~, No Prorrastinat~~ or unreasonable Bela , Conse uentl ~ led es o a Iaw- ers P ~~ e o P~-o ess~ona~-sm y~erc~ al~o su~se uentl t~i0~ate~ b ~1~e l.u z whicti State ~~I ~~II v r maters ~x~ 6~itio~sly an~ ~?ithou~ unnecess r ex- ~ensc:'An _I will (ono the s iY'it and in~~~it as well as the re ~~remen~s o .tea lica~le les R~ a Coc~e~~p Pro essiohal Co~~uc o~r~m ~urts~ -~.f~~ l one G. Allt~ou h the ro~essional Pfepare~, estimate that w.as r~a're~ or the. da~ja ~s tom rpotorc O4le by the. ~on~a shpp thatI b-e Marly de~~ utoith ~showsy c' n estimated amoant o ~Z 06(S~ 8~~ i t is stated in tie ~om~laint ,which aav~ol l.~z has sr ned and sub- itte~ to_thtis Court a~ Co nt 1~ l~~G~As a result t~e u~ _e ~ collislop _~"irP 1.J~n~e ane_ erg motorsycle sus~ai~e~ ro eG't lama ~. an~~yclrnim is ~(ar~t there o~-e P ~hc amount ~ ~1 93,18."I res ect- ul) ~~bm~~ to t~iis Cour I d ve that o ha e Ie al ~- ~+~ ~o r~ u~~'~. and to seek a recoveryy a menu o )00/0 0 ~ the.. drama e esti mats. ~ n 6r~ei~ to re- p lace the_fda ur~e~ ~rts ~ m motors cle o~' and as Est ,~p c o ~ensatio~n ,d~e. an~ ~a a~l~fan~ rC c_over ~ Ie ~ n u I compensa~-on~ u~hlch ~sti~ wish to co Iles ex~lusi e o any pth~ ~a~~ents or costs, that sa~~ para rapp 1~~ under. Count 1 urthe~ '_ ~x lams t e a ~rehnentione~ intent o mi e to collect th~t ~mou~lt _o~ ~he_ `ust rdUe nom ~ilsQtio~ o ~ m motors cle c~~~aqq,,e~r ~Xeludin , costs~~as it is st~ e~~ ~~ ~h~rey ore Play r~ti Dal ~~nt~rmo,~ e~ de mans dud ~m~nt ~ ainst ~e ~en~Unt ~osu~ Syalinas Ualdez 9 9 t ~ .,, -~ U. _ A- v ~ -1- _ 1 CeSs 0 an `~tri,s~di~tional amount rer~uirir~q com- ~IsOrf ar~i`~ration' 9 ~t~0;~ a~~6~o~~1 receiu~~ a~ letter ~rom pavi~ Lutz u-h~c ha~ beeYl sent to him romf8~ian Yount dated al~o~ ti +uhich states ~`Lt wou{~d a erxr that our in- sUS~e~~appears to ~e lia~Ole -n th~s incider~tr 1 here- .. ore we ~uoul~ be wlli~n tp pA 100/0 0~ the ~an1a ~. ~o t'o'ur clients matore ~Ie i~~ his ~ass,'~uvid l,u~z also sent me a ca y pY his r p y letter that h~ a~~- ressed to rlro Your~~u-hfch ~s ~~~ed .fie tem~ber zs Rool which states~6Degr ~`lrQ ~'ount~i. ewe are una~le to reach an a ica~~e ~~~r solution ~i~h re"q and to tie r~~ert ~a~a e ~c~qim both claims ~i~ll be lita- ate~d; sine >3ripr~ 1~~ur~t a~le~ t~ ~a m seI or l~r U tz 10Q/a o e~ ama es t'hot ~er~ cau~e~dto rye motors ~le~tht r~~lte~ iii mi~'re re- sen ,ut,iorl, r1r~ I,atZ !il~ to ollow throe h ~vithphi~- c iar ut t tl ~~'~c~ a u~ccess v I e~ove~- ©r aGII ~ o c l~~ S ~ ~~~~ ~h~ ~,am Y es tY m mot~~pV~c cIe i n ac~a~'~ ice toYthfs Co lain~~ that ahe~ ~le~ a tee' he a, ree~ to ro re- ', sen~C my Wiest ~nt~re,r~~;s ~ col(ect~y~cq or iDOl~o the dur~ayyes to ~ mo~or~ycle, J f g, Sometiv~e betw~en O,ct, a~o I ccnc~ Jan, zoo~~ Rend '~ Greene became the atto~r-~e for Josue Sa 1 i nos Va~~ez, ~~ David l.atz sent a lett~r to m~. date~~ November ~ goo I which stater1s ~G Deer Mr((,,i~i nterme~/Ver~ pe ease '~, C Uu11Se l has sC~e ~~A led the tarvI C) 0 Ouf ~e~C~SI~IOn 0-1 Februar R~zoOz~at 1z~30 at i~ 'o ice,l,li,l) yyou lease. the~e ore make arras emeynt ~o ~e in any ice at 11~~0 A.MQ nn Feb~-uar ~,Ig zoos' io~~n Jan, ~ z0o~ ~ r '~e'u~ le°~ter from Ravi d l,~atz ~vhic~i I,e ad re.rsed to Rand ~ teen as dated JanuA~ry 1~z00~ which ~tateJ66Ocar ~an~U~UJe wouldl relaxant ~o his bod~l i~' ar claims ~rankl~ when m t, with >~ro ~int~rm~ e~ on Decem ~r ~8' X001 ~e vi5e~ hne that he wayuld ,~e rovi~in'q ~ie wr'th an~~ er recei t o a roximatel ~lo,o~w~icll would ~r~n the to~al ro~pe~r~ ~ama ~ claim,to,aP~~-ox- '~, Imr~~~I ~~~063oI ~~lonq th~s~ li es~we will be pro- s.,, vidin y,~x~ert te.rtirr>9on with rr?ga'r~ to the cost p rep~a~r~'. ~ J Ilf On Ql=~br~nar 2~zp0~~ r went to meet uiith Davec~ >^utz ~n acCO~~ance, to his ~r~or re nest ex~ertin~ to meet ~uitl, the Defendants attorne _~1~ Greens or the purpose of him ~a in mY de osition which ~l~avi~ l,~tz ha~ re resen~e~ to me as sche ulec~, ` e p° w t~ e et- Si nc~ Rangyy, Green ai lei to sho ~q a th m in that 11a'd b~~h rfe s'chec~ Ie~, mo~~. than 3 months b~ o~~ ~ u~as or~c~ a aid su~ ecte~ to m~sre~re- Se~tati'OYi~ Sine ~1r~ ~~en a-`~e~ to Shaw u attorne Da`Oid ~Ut~ i n ~orm~d me that ra teen ha.~ o y~rer~ ~o sett{e~m rn~otorc cle ama es claimffor ~~~~e50 and t~Yat i I,~~nul ctcc~~~ that 0 e~- I ~uou~ then ~e ~e uire~, to a }aim ~DaUi~ Linz) °300 out o that or his ~~ ~cP11CeSf- ian i ~ c~ortt~d,adict~i ors to Count -~~ , ~aragA~aph 19, o thi~ ,com la- ~ u~h~ch l)au+~ Lutz ~i ne~ an~ tlefc~ tp this Cpur~, Consequentl y~I ~~.~ orme~ Dave I.u~tZ that X would n;~t a~cept for settfle or ~9'~~,50 or the ~a QQ"~Q"~cs o a ~ro~i a~el ~~~oo~that werefin~ ~icte~~o {n,f mo~torc cfe ar~y~ I also in orme~ him t~hut, i t iS h iys ~a i ci ~r ~`~u~C to ca 1I ec~ t e, u Inl ~stimatec~ c~mo~n o ~ ust~due. com en~a~ioff1 ~n~ m ~ est i I1`Gera~" s.Pln attorne is re ~uire~ to c~ct in ac~or~ance to the c-l~ents be.~~ ~ nteC~sts ~Qr the rc~reSentatlo~n and lit~~atlo~n ulhiCll has been ~on- .. ~.~WdsWNtCrn'elsr.t.9aav:-.t~liauumt'kYUV'vs,:ePauVLL~ to Y' siiY.'~b1W~aNS~A4luiaycutYtua:ai E vision once~'nin il,Representation ands e,~eQthe~- to a cce p~ a settlement o oer, At tllt ,end o that mfet- in `~titll David i.ut? If f n ormed h, n, that still no~h-n as been e~i`~Ie~ ~om pmerel talkie about ~hi.~ ~ ~te~ and hat z ~antect hirn Yto ou~ his dis~osi~'on`~~n~o the Lour ov~ a 'ur tri l as he de~man~e~ n~ re~resente , ~o m s;~l Yard ~P th;s Cou~'t ~n tl~e Complaint u1 ich heysiqq''~ec~,ABN Model 1Zule ~o.z ~xpe~;en~e sa states c~Tlte a~ttorne~Keepino~ u'tth the clients best int `~est~,mu ~t execut~ rea ~onakle a~ em t ~o ex~ ~ to I i ~ i anon. And ~~ ~tatef The attor~e is ro~i i~ec( o~or~ "~`unn- u the .~~e .'' 4Canons ypR~~plD~(~)((1)stJates"}fin at~Jorp muff ~e. punctual yn u1 illiq all ra e.~.rional ~ommitr~ents." R Ilth,ou h Davifc~ 1-~u~z 9ma e~a ro essional co it° went t~ m sei and. to t~is C urt~b h;.S' demand or_a 'u~r'1 tr~ul he u~as not punctua~ in ulfillin that c~nmi'tmen~in c,'/ sort o manner a~he re r~- seYlteOi, ~ m''yy~el an~! to thi~Court relative t~ he Com_plQin~OA~/ na ~ilnc ~ur;n m meetin w,th Dav+~ ~~1tz dirk I iuc him m ~ ~ mifsion~to accept or settle or ~~~~.so or t~h~', ama es that were cau~se~fto y moto~r~ cI_e ~ n an wa ver ally or b m s~-qna~c~re on aSettlement a r~~ment ndr ~,~ ~y~raynt l~aUi~, l.~-~Z r~~ e~miss'~~ au~thar~Z~t;on to coI ect ghat ~rnoun~~a~ an4 Qt~e~ time Which you) ~ ~au e. b~ n i n co ntr dilction to co~ .~ ara- ra h 1~ o `~~iS am lain which he ile~e `~~ I~~ Ap tee I ~et wit Dapui~ Lutz on ~eb~~ ~ ooh I rec~i~e~ a 1e-tte~ _ rom him Which is ~~er~~~=eb- ru ary ~S an0~, That letter re .erred to my meetin w; lDaui~, 1.u.`bz on Feb` ~I ~~o~. Which Rand Crr~e~h~. ai lec~ to a eak- ~ r ~n ~iat le,~te-~ to mey~late~ -f- p p t-o ._ - _- -- .,_~.eg,-...ice ,.-.~~~ e.~~rs ,_u ,. "-~~k+: xr ~ __ >... c._ GV municate ~ T1r~ Gr~eY1e that i there is a tender ~ the ~25~000 od~e. olie )imitsf ou hove rovic~er~ m~e, ith authat~~~ to~acce `~ ~x roPer~yy c~Ama e se~t~ement o ~~~t~,so~ z al~o a~~ised du in th~~r reqarch"`~ th er~.~~ oul~ b e a attor ey ee ~concesssi on g ~1~3~0,00;' That untrue s~atemen~ ~'b Dav-d~ Lutz i~ a~o~ uvQS an o;ct o un)aw ~ul mi ~e.presen~ation ~iecau.se- I did not ve_ ~avf~ ~.utZ an verbal er- m 1sSpn to acce,~t ~` ~ ' ,sqQ or m~ moto~C c~e ~q a'qc j t~or ~`~~ r si n an^y settfe~ient a r~ement~ or a~ am aunts C on.~~ uent!~ ~ b ~ l i evec~ ~h~t the a~~orernen~~ ione~ in orma~i~n a~~ m~,~re re.rentation u~hihln David Rutz in rme~ me o re~t~ $eo arc~iZe~ m ability to ca lle t or loo°lo ~ ~~e ° ~s`~ 4d~e, com ens~tion br t~~ lama e~ tomy ~a~torc el~ rn accor~an~e to best iVlt~c.sts9 Luhic~ r tai~tec~ DaVi,d Rutz to f,erve and to rip re.re~t ~ ursuan~ ~o the ~ompla~-nt uJhich h~ si~n~~,~~nce th~~ add~t~onal set o ~ misrep. re5eiltati0-1 c~us~~ me to sustai~t more e~ot~onal ~istress~ un~ ince Daum Lutz has never shou~n me any docv~mrn~e~ settlemen pro pporal ram Rand^yy ~< Green and since ~av~~ ~.utz cbnt~nue~ to ail tea Zealous'I ° t rests ~ ~unctualL ~ ~~ ex~ c~i~ina~ the ` urY trim -n accorr~ n e to my ~i- rec~iu~s~l elie~ier~ that .I ha~ na ot~er afternE~tiue bud to sen~ a letter ~o Rand ,C. Crreene when I had been continually ~x per~encin y ~ ~y f cct~u~ counsel J i n c the ~,~ Uonsti~utibn iJ'~he ~~{ reme )a~u 6~ the Ian"~ helieuecl, that r had a Con.rti~utiona) Ri ht to com`~unica~e pith, Rangyy Green~ulhic)~ ~uQf in A~or~~- ar~cc to n1 hest ~,nter'~sts ~s~eciall since. noth~n~ at all u-as ~ver achieuec~ b ~au~~ l.ut~ t w~r~ rec overi n~ an amount that ~a~alr~ b~ acc~ptab~e to m~ _~ or J ~,,~ ~ _ a ~~ . ~ ~ . ... ~~ , 13o Co~rtsequentl I ~nai7el~ a fetter to i~Ir. Rand C, Green~a oY~ ~1ar~'~ 15~200~ ~Ihich states"l~ hau~ r~Ce~t- 1 received a fetter rom Mr, l.ut~~~uh-~ch is date: ~yarch ll ~oQ~a Mr,~ i~~ ha.r in.~oronec~ m~ in that letter that Z~ave_ r~vide~ im u~-th the uthori to aCCe t ou~ ro erty dama ~e, S t~~ement~o er d ~ ~~1~,~o Qyn~ that ~h~ cbmmuniTte~ that o~(T' editQ ~u, I~Qt U el ~s ,n. ~ acceptQ~~e to mee 1 hQV~~ nat ~ s e~~ n a Q~s wh,c stag that Twill aces t yy ti ~ p P th~ amour~t~I have written %n m ~ most r~.cent letter to Daued I.ut~.j z am d-rectr~n~^ ~ou to act ~n accordance tom best interests anal cis m re resentitiue o m~ best ~nterest~b in orrn~n P~ra Greene that .~~ ~,~yl not accept ~symo~t ~-ec~nt o er o_ ~ Q~~.~O~'I then also wrote to P1r, Lutz `~~ a~f als~ ~irectin yyou to r~e ruse ~o aces t ~r, G~~eenes ® e~~' ~ a4so state; fn m letter ~o hlrp Greene G~I~~oul~like to ICngqw i you have hid copies ~ m me~,~ca records o th O~~ope~ic,Tnst~tute o {'`~o urn, ~ed to ou f tat enter rise or b an one rom the lain ~irm b Angqino~Rovner~~ .ghat hays oc aurre~ Lase ih orfm m~~ n the ~~cn qty o .the inc~iv~~~als u~ho h~v~ ~rovide~~ yyou wit r~ mfe~~~cal rec r~s~~nd o , he n me o the arm o~ , busy Ness en~er rise w~ic~ that ers'on orf ersons '~~ word ora" T1re ~ree~ ha ~.ai le pto reply~tp m lette~r~to him UJhich ertallnf ~o this i~it ev~n '' a ter he r~lus made aware of the ac~th~t ~av`~d >,~ftz is no lonqq,,er m~y attarne' ,L c~n end that Mr. Green has an ~thicaY duty toYr~es an~ to myy le al 1~tters anr~ ~ha ,it is his'yle a du~y to resp~Ond ~o m eo~mu,n~ca~ipnS also wh~c~ he has a~lec~ to ~ yhvld ursuent t~ this ~is~osition, ~ P '' which he represents ich is the I m n An i a and Rouner. On a e 2 o that letter ~~at I ~acldr9essed to David l,~t~ .~ st `fed to ~ira1 c`.~ince mime re- s nta;tl~n If un la~v fu ~ .L am he t~ebY i n ormi ,~ Vou t~~t i yyQU r'eCl~Se, ~urSel '~Qt`Y1 re ~~Sen~~Iril ~1e as~ bu a qreed toy do w~en~you si ~ed our a reem~nt tat represent m_~ to/the c~m Ietion o a S~ccess~ u,l i-ecover on Au , 3~ ~oo~~ ther~i I ~ema~d to ~~ rloulded wlthranothe~ An Ino~Rounfr ~t~tornc t~ rep~~sent rn~ in Courts ndg~ntll a success my ~~caVer hay been obtai ne~ and completed wh~ch iS acceytable to me off- m^y motorcyycle dQmage.r~ Two w~e~k~' a ,ter .I ttaine~ thou I ~nQilcd a ~N~ttcr o nu ~Jh Ich fs date Frl~ pu ! 1"~~Ol, I .stake ~ i n that letter to ou `~l meant t~ ~e aid or the re p lacem r+t co~~tf o eu er , ~ ark ~$ha~ ~as lama ed o_n my mo~orc cle Inc~udin Ytho c, arts that t~~ e.stirhators dl~ n~ lnelu~e~ on t~el~es~lmate~r be- caus~ ~t saves hem tim~e~-monGc~ by not doln a com- ~ 1~~~ e.s~imc~te' r also_ wrote Please reel ~o this letter Immediately and In o~'m me o wea~he~' au u-ill s_e k an ee~ or a 4~-ents ro~ me- a te~ ou u1i II no~ rep~e~ent m~ i~1 ~`ourt anf~ a tee' o~u havy~ nod m de a succes.~ ul, reco~r tofcom~Ietionn,, in actor arlcc to tl,a (which is r~presentrd anon State on the coYl~raCt a f eel~1et1t ~Uhic eu si ne u~_hile ou con~i~u to disre ar~ direct- IU@.5" l0 Ou 0~ m bps 1-~tCrf.J'~.J~~QnGt,I.O IIe UOU gill not ~~s r my wrI_ ten le al ue.rtlons to ou, z _trust t~a , yu Ill not ~o ~ I,beratey I~n ~- erel~t ~o t~l~ leer ~s Pu }lque ~eer1 ~b m o~~~r letter-.r ~i~ec~iv~s any ~o my d~ocumente~ uye.stion.T,"A~ u,s~al~ David- ~utz ~`aile~l to reply to ~ ~ his legal dut~ to ~'e,~pon~ to ~~ m aL~OeASA Model >~Ule 1~ZG ~ tate.rG`1=ven upon termination a the rep- resentatian .the gtta~-ney must take. all reaso~rable and nece.s.rar~ ~te~,r to ~rotec t the c I' eats interest such as,~ ~iut no )~miter~ t~ b3 ~c as at~orney until the cent can roc~nr~ ano~th~~- a~~orne Qn~ c~Surrender all l~ AI ~G~ers and ~rapert relati~`qq~to the repre- ser~ta~~o~l~ Y J I~, ~vefltt~ou9h them area about Io luu~y4 r.r that also , o k a h same law.. arm o~ l~n .no ~iavner as David >,r~~Z~ anr~ t~e ~ also sp e ~ig I izc i n ~ccir~ent i ~'~ ur , 1 iti cation ~a~i~ Lutz has u io later th_e a orer9len~ioned A~ 1/l0~ Rule 1x16 becau.rc he has notf~roUjde~ me y u~~t~ anot er lay e~ to ul -1l .his l~ a1 duties to. ~h~ ABA__-,to I m S~eI_ _ ~ ~ yC Them o~~~T am n~w s e~ci isa van a e b n0 )o~ ~r uvin , an-~.~tarne o ollow thrgouGh y u~~th t~is ~is os~~tion tq ac~c r~a ~e tp what ~uas ~epr~s~nte~ ~to myysel un~,to t is ~our~t^p arsuant ~o this Com vnt u~hic~ ~Dr~vi~ I,o~ z ~le~ to phis Court a ain~~ Josue Salinas Valdez ~inc~ I have not ha~ga 'ob nor an income sincc~A ril ~o02a.~ hau~- -~~cut1~ ' iucn Dau~i ol, ~-utz_~m ~ermi~,~ion, nor m ~ansent o him toy discont~n~y~e represe-lt~n~ m~e. r ~ )1e~'e or~ l,u~-II c~t~ Pay Su C~ G18 A, a d w~l~ Ig9~~~as~as~a ` vcs, Scoville ~nt~err~an~ that iiulin was G`A ~ iscon ~nuenre entered b -~a~'mer',coun 75 ~~tpiout conscn ~~~~1 ~ mint be stt~icken, ~t Pn June. ~5 aoo z sub-matte l eqa l i n orrnation to this Court u~hic~ was and is di~rec I_fu related to tile. 1 iti atioVl ~c this le al dis asi~i(011 which u1a~' a 1e ~l9actiort,~There or~ ~ au~r to t~is Court that ~thc statute. o ~ l,i'mitatioro,r ~ or this ~is~osition ~ t David ),atZ~shoul~ be help( le all accounta~l~. and le all r~s~p onsi~l~ al~ ol(o~in thou h u~ith ~ep- r~se~l~tin , this Com~lain~ whic he s n~e~ and ~ ~e~ a~ -nst Josue Salinas VaI es as e ~~eprc- ~ente~ i to this Court in accordance to his ~ro- ~ess-onal ~ ti~~' uu~ich ~ie. has su-orn to upheld, L also con~e.n~ thu th harden o r~ili ence. ~o %tiqate this,o~atter ~e.s~s Upon D~uid l~~tz and h-S~`epresent-t-ve law f-I'm o Anq~no~-IioUner be- cau e 1)au~~ 1-ut~-, unde~rtoo~. ~he `1e al r,espons~; ~~li~ ~, o this r~,sposit- n when ~ -,le~ th,~s Compy)r~ in~ ~hrch he si ne.rnan~in of ur trial and, vuher~ ~e s~ hey t~e contract a ree`~en~ o An ino~-Roune~~ a eeein to represent e„ the d ty o ~~il i ence ~e.r S sale~l upon the lau-yyers who due s~u~ of that ~~tyy to the ~HPf~and~ to their c~ ~ ants which t~e o-e re.re/nt, 18'~ At l~l und~e~ D~~e n~~ant Jose Salinas' Uald~~s Mot'or1 ~o ,DismiS.Sr For 1=ailt~r~ Ta P~asec t~ which has ~i~en s~ net ~ Ran G ~eene -t is sta~~~`7 aGGiven tlti~ 9Plaintir s CA~mp~ete I~,ck o dll~ ~1ce the ~,ur~~n or wh~c~h lies w-th him a~~ h~m~a,l~n~ and t~~ ~r~~, u~-co. ~o ~e enrl<a ;~ Josuu ~~rlina Val ez~which ~esulte~ them from t~~s mat e~- soul b~ ~~smis~ed ~~th re ud~ce ors i'lain~i.~ .~ ' os' ~ 1~.!' ~ n t~~se~t a-lu~-e. to r ec~ e, ere o'r~e Deed n ~alinas Val~~e~. r~.sp,cct~~-ull ,r~ ue~t ~~is Nonora~le Court to, p'y~m-~~ th,s Isla n ~ ~ Co-r, lai~t w-th P~~~' u~ic~, I,sub~nit t~ t~~s ~onorabl~ Court that ~h~ ~ fo~cment~ ones, ~ tat~.ment b y attorne~yy Green 1S 1_~~elous ,Pr,6 Se~beCau~e hUU`e blQ~`COlrln'11tteU~ an re~ ud-cial acts a a~ s~ Josue Sal-nas val~e~ I~o~ h~ave.`~ committed an~ot~~r unla~ ful acts aeain~ Q~ malice and intimidation a~-e alf violation 10.uf`~T coeT-c~er ~1r, G-rcencrstatement and ,defire+ or th S matt ~ t0 be. d-senisse~ u~~th ~~ppre~ ud-ce a a-~.s-E n1~ t~ b,e unconscionable. bia~marici~~s in~~mic~= at~on,w,h-cl~ ,have caused me to sustain a ditiooal ~rnot'-o~al -~tress~, .hick has ~~e~en determined by ~h~e courts to ~e, a unls~men`~, I 19. All~hou h i~ i~ an attornc s rofessional I~qal dut to e~C~e~lit~ a s~ttlemeynt paqBement ano'NS d~~ c©n~act, Rangy Greene by m I~tte~ nn i~ac~ch rs~~ooz his dell~e~a~e ,-no~- ~ et~cnc~ tomy I~tter, has- in act resul~er~ - n ~h~s des os-t-on/ ~e-n -m e.de~ b 1~and ~ !r~ene ~~ncc he ne~er d-~ rep19 to ~ lette~ nor y~-~ he ev'e~ s n~ a settlcr~ent o yep to >~e eve a ter he was ma~e aware o the an~unts that rare s-~ate~ or compensatoryy da~a es on the eom la-nt a ~ - n f :ht o1~ tic ac~C that ghe was in orm~e~ o ~ t~e ac~9 than Davidf Lutz was no Ion er~my a~torn~ o ~p~ ~fres ect all , s bmit_ ~~ this C~~rt that ~, Y houlcl, no~be ~e ~-t~e~ to and that ~ am not i`eqquu,,-re~ ~o -le a Sub oe~a o r a`~,C ourt Order To Res cr~~l~to ~1~'~~Raro Gr~en ~ ~n rder or him ~:o re I t® m I~-t~~w' thc~t T s~en~t to hf~ on rlarch )~ ~a~~ `~I.yAllt~oue~h 1 have made ~ forts. ~o Seale his r~is~~o° s~t-on -n accordance to thc~eom la-nt~the a~tourn~ .r the''~~selues are soli , res- .ons~blp ~~~.or oai l,n to ~ se~t~~, this d-s os-~yon a~d Com la~lnt fn a ex ed~ i ~ ~ ous mannerp as the a e re q~uire~ too o. ~ a2a Tn I - ht o a II o t~e a bre~nento onec~ acts .~ htreb des ~ct allyy,, reqques~ this Nonorable~ourt ~® Dismi s the~De e~dan~s_P1btion To dismiss For Failure P ~ f To rosecu en ~e~ruar~ J~a00'~1 dale lalin~erme~er`Plaintitf c~ ~_ ~~~ f~L7 ~; _,- c. _~ ~. ~' a w ~~ ~. m -~ Da~~ 1.t~inteY')neUe.r-Plai~ ~, j z-lac-rn 1.n~ ~ . ~ 3 c PROOF OF SERVICE I, W ~ ,hereby certify that this 3 day of Fr b ru aru , ~_, served the foregoing document(s), manner listed below. Service by First-Class Mail to: C G e a ' ~ r,~:~.xx~ - 4Yaniu~r~x~xsnv:~:~aauc,F.~c~.rseu6evkiwrtlWtk~S _ . -fslf~kiE~%1~9i~sti~];x,~'"'•"" ~' - e rn „~:,..d ..:. ... . . .:. .:: ~~ O T7 i; 3 '~'4 _ _? W l i„ ^~,p ~C_, ~~~ ~ ~~ i~+e'= ~ ~ C W 'fi L~ -t, tN~3 OCS-09-01 09=13 FROM:I'he Har~Ford-Omni OCY-06•-0l H2:25 aH DALE WINTERIv~YER, Plaintiff v. IOSUE sAT.RVAS-vA1,DEZ, Defendam I D:7709521 t1b ~xh~b~t 1 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, FA CIVII, ACTION -LAW Na.O!-5yl7 .IE1RY TRIAL DII~lANDEII ~ObI~LAirl'i' rron~ .mi~r 1. Plaintiff Dale Witue~eyer is as adult individual and a dti2at of the Col>ucronwealdt of Petettsylvaniawho~esides is Camp Hill. Cumberland County, Petulsylvania. 2. Defendant ]Dane Salinas Vatdcz is an adult individual who testdcs at 7004 Peters Creed itoad, No. 21, Roanoke, Virginia. 3. The facts atld ~ ilcreinafler related ttak place an or about July I4, 2001, at approximwcly 11:18 pm. at the iatclsection of South 'Tbiril Street (Sit 2035) and Haman Avenue, Lemoyne, d Comrty, Pe+insylvania. 4. A[ that time and pima, Mr. VJirlpermcyer was opetaiitrg his 1963 i Shadow 750•mototnyr}e is a natti~otmd•diioction on South Third Street•npproachirls liemisn Avemle. 5. At the same tiltcc, Deft Salinas-Valdri was operating a 1964. 0ldsntabite Cutlass ins ztortthbolmd~diteeticn on Sovth Third Street. 6. The Defendant tamed on his leR turn signal and stopped in the intersection to tam ledt onto Herman Avetwe. ?. Aaer seeing the Defendant's left i»m sigltai, Mr. Wltltermcyer slowed ltis lnotarcyclc and afternptcd to pass the DePerdaat's vehicle on the tigjtt is accot~datlce with 75 Pa.C.S.A. §3304. rsuatutrata OCi-09-01 09:13 FROM: the Hartford-Omni OCT-0E '81 02:26 NH ID:7709521t15 PAGE 4/7 i & W1thO1It VYBIning, the Defeitdart SLLddl4II).y acoclereted teed ttaneil Light, which caused the right side of his vehicle to impact Drir. Wintermeyer and his motorcycle, causing aLL eccideat 9. The foregoing atxident.amd ell of the injuries and damages sat forth herciaaRea sustained by Mr. Wiatetrneyer arc the direct azld pmxiasate zesuIts of the ttcgligetlk, careless, Waaton, and reckless manner in which Ivir. Salinas-Valdez operatod his motor vehicle as foElows: a) failure to keep alert and maintain a proper watch far the presence of other motor vehicles on the highway; b) faillue to properly use tttm signals, c) failure to yield the tight-of-way to Mr. Wintenlleyer's vehicle; and d) driving his vehicle npoa the highway in a rnaltner etadattgeriltg persoffi and property end in a reckless manner wiflt careless disregard to 81c tip and safcry of otlxzs and in violation of the Motor Vahicle Code of flte Cotnm~onweaith of Penntiylvtittis. GlsdiAfd jJg{Je.~teaae~r~.v Jeeae<Salitau-Valdez . tl). P~aragjosphs 1 throt~ 9•are ineocpoeaeed-helein by referericc. t 1. IWIr. Winteanoyer talsteireed p1na+Gtl and severe i1lguEies that inclvu6e but arc not limited to a prmumel left fibular fracxure, a daval left fibutat fiactnre, bums, std tttetf~ple contustons and abrasiorts. 12. By reason of his efara~said injuries, Mr. 'GUwtemteyer was forced to incur liability for medical treaztnent, aledications, physical ihetapy, Saul vmilar misceIfatteovs expca>ses In an effiort to trstore himscIf to health, arLd a claim is tllade iharefor. 13. Because of tllc natta+c of his injuries, rift. Wirltertucycr has been advised, and therefore avers, tE1at he may be forced w itlcut similar medical expenses in the future, and a claim is made therefor. szslae.IUrrGU.cs 2 OCi-09-01 09:13 FROM: the Hartford-Omni tu: ii:o~eztalo rwn ~„ '~ OCT-0G ~B1 02:2( Hn 14. As s result of the aforemeationod injuries, Ails. Wmtetttieyer has tmdeigtwe and in the fawn may ~~ phYsioal and mmmal sufficing. inconvenience in t:atrying out his daily ac4ifities, and toss oflife's ploasttrra and enjoyment, and a claim is raadc therefor. 15. As a tesrlt of the afatemczitiotted itrjtuiea, Mr. Wintermeyer has been and in the future may be subject to ~ and humiliation. and a claim is made thcrefnr. 16. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, A,ls. Winicmieyer bas suffered work loss, loss of opportunity, to.4s of frequent overtime pay, loss of daily piece raft bonus Pay, and s pemlaneat dminrRitart of his earning power and capacity. and a claim is made therefor. 17. Adr: Wintemreyer coutimxs to be plagued lry persistent pain and limitation and tl,erefnre avea that h!s injuries may 6e of a pemsaaeni natntc, cavsin~ residual problems and peratanent scmriag fos the remainder of his liiietime, and a claim is made therefor. C:I Idsle v Js~.-uaidez l&. P~a~c1 through l7 are imooaparabed~hcrcin~by.r. 19. .4s a result the subject eoltision. A;dr. Wintermeyer's motorcyetc sustained propcxty darnagq and a.claim is mado thereforia the amount.ofi~1;493.1$. 1~t9RS, Ylaineff-19ate W demands. jodg~ont-a~.at 11a~dtnn~t 3osnc Salinas-lreIdz~: in an atnowrr'm cxces& of 'LtventS-Five Thon~sand ($25,000A0) Dollars, xssiaa.nAr[cres 3 OCT-09-01 09:14 FROM: The HarlFord-Omni ID: 7709521115 rr.~.c ... ~p1 V ' ~. exclusive of interest end oosb and in execgs of any,ilsrisdicEionel amount requiring comgttLsory arbi[ratioa. Dsrc: ANC1Nt? ~ 1tOVAtER, P.C. ~~~~ LD. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street I~Saaisburg.PA i91I0 (717) 238-6791 Attorney tbz Plaintiff t~slal,nencaua 4 } Y2EPAIR ESTIMATE NAME: . ' . ~i'vefet' 7Yl ~ CUSTOMER CONTACTS: PHONE: (VV) MODEL V`T7Sa ,_ R.O. DATE ~ ~/0/ . Labor escription Hpurs Amount~a~ ~ Q - _ 3~o a 5~no.a Chr~ - --- .~ _ _ ~ _ 1-"~S•6o ~ c~~~ - ~. - moto spores ., ~~53 C4`~lis(~ Pike f~ec}tanics~ur~~Q,1?OSO ;, . ~' . To .a.7O!o .gQ Total Now: Complete Repair: Adjusted Estimate: phone ?I~ 166-aSa3 /l~'7' 9 _ ~ ~._._ quote . . _,_.. ,--.._ Part No. Source Description Price Qty f5500•ME9-673 _ __HO~,__ '45510.M81-406 _ 219.10 1 . 30545300-000 HO WASHER, OIL BOLT 1.88 3 _ _ _ 11100-ME9-000 ~ HO FENDER, FR. ~ 134.03 1 i1~3-305 _ HO SEAL SET, FR. FORK .~ ~ ~ 2018 2 i1A47-463003 HO CIRCLIP (INNER) 2.47 2 Fo Ain L.t i~5 ~ aft ~ Sao -- l ~ ~~ 1 ~I~~ Sub Tota{: 1,098.78 ~' ~ ~~~ r~~ '~~ +~:~~ ~~~~ ~ 3 .,,~~~ ~ ~ P~~S ~, lr _lv ~L/~ ` ~a ~~5/~ 001 Bell & Howell Publishing Services ..25~.a6 cus~a:.~ ~,~„E /:4 ~:: - . w ~ ~ f -~'°~ C~t,rmmz' 8~t -~'~l.-~~„dQr. ~~~. 3a oo~~wd~r ~~i<c~ ~`.. ~' c z: r r_ u ' 1 - ~ 9 x n ' O m s ~ ¢ _ ~. . O ~ o ~^ ^ m Z v v m ~ n O . ~ o x .~ D m m o= va Z ~ r r N O H m D O o D e T . ~ y O ~ ~ N ~ p y ~ 9 x a m y Z = C z ~ m JJ N r 9 f 1 N P ~ ~~~ / _ O ' C/ N ° + o ( !~ O m _ ' V 1 ~ Z m ti 3 w ~ f+ < ~-. ~ N < 9 w a m ~^ n m / f HK V S O ~ O V m A V m ~ cn o 3 - o m a a ~ m y r UI 0 o D ~~; - ., r m ~~~ * .. ~ o 2 C °s ~m °s m ~ o m ~ ~ ~ n v V -P ~F ~ O (/~ N' 3 L•] O 3 r.. r 0 rt- ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 y 0 . i 0 ~ w x 2 9 . n o °s ~ O ~ -~ m .w o m o ~ m v o ~ m y ~ o _ m ~ '~' O 9 v -o - ' - _ m p v O 't' m m - i a -i +i to r -o a aaocaa C7 r O -i m m m as cn ti ~ ~ a o m .. o+ o z .+~ [1f N V ~ ~ y a O -T+ D as O I ~ c ti N 4 1 w ~ ~-, O s y ~ .. m _ ~ 0 Z Z H ~ m D ~ m O y ~ 4 y. m H y, m ~ a m ~ va ~ v Q ~• - m "1 r. ~ o x i. O ~ ~ ~ o--o o.ia o o.-.o onoo - - o u~ o 0 0 o w 3 Tv ~rn N ^ Z = w v,m an y `~ C) r ~ o~ ~ N 3~~ cm A N ~ ~ w ~ fn 0 0 O oc'i~~ O ~ ~ rm^ m' •. C7 .AJ~ ^:.^ C r 'O ~ m Z --1 0o am~c d 0~ O d- d~ C 0 ~~ d~ O d° O N ~ b O O Q 0 9 b ~- d~mm<Fo~~°~ c• bm d-e sm _. ~Qm s~iSooxo .. 3`'Zm 3°-oZ ~w p° Q< w m N m y d A ~~<~ O .O m C J -~ N m~ s muwi ai $uwij m n ~ dio 3~ o m o ~b'm mmtla ~'aod f~w ~e `-rmm3 ^O~O m imf3~°• ~a a~'y o ob 'Z3 '' w=3 ~~~omom ~-~y]]. 1 mdMO'b g~J~2~. ~ _ a° m d °-~ d~ a 3° '. d.~ 9 m d~~ 0~ ~i O `C ° ad°n4 moo o d$ n n m ~ m 9 f.m ~ a 3 6 m m:? m° s o° m o ~a~o~~'3nQf 3 uwi ~ '.~^. < ~ o' 3 c a ~y~o Fd o-'bndG oo°m Dm 4oon~ O=C~9tl~C~fS ~, ~' 6 (D~ O A p N ~'~ N 3mbC~m °^ 'i d~ao35d%Hal *~ a' o S 6. d O_ F 4 ~'Z o an d i n m O O '~. a~ °b 3 'm I ' w d m 9 v~ ~'~~ m'^ H m m z d d ~ ~ N o' m £ g~v n'^$ c° mFO ~=n p1 ma d o < m,'~ ~~~ m°m m' \o o m ~m o-E~i m 09/20/2001 14:14 FA% 770 952 1115 THE HAR'1'k'UHll TNF NARTiSxx'3 arnx, auro vux P.0. 50% 105013 pTIaNTA, 6A 307405019 Re+mn Scrvice Requested DATE: 09/20!01 ANGINO AND ROVNER LAW FIRM ATTN: DAVID LUTZ-ATTORNEY AT LAW 4503 NORTH FRONT STREET HARRISBURG PA 17110 RE: CLAIM />!: 01-245468 F11 INSURED: SAUNAS, CARRIE M DATE OF LOSS: 07/i4/01 YOUR CLIENT:-DALE WINTERMEYER DEAR MR. LUTZ: PLEASE BE ADVISED, I NAVE BEEN ASSIGNED THE HANDLI AFTER FURTHER REVIEW OF THIS LOSS AND LOOKING INTO STATE STATUTES REGARDING_THE RULES OF THE_ROAD, IT CLATA( IF YOU WILL KINDLY PROVIDE ME A DEMAND PACKAGE WITH + SPECIALS FOR REVIEW LOOKING TOWARDS POSSIBLE SETTLEMENT ON AFTER SPEAKING TO YOUR ASSISTANT TODAY, SHE INDICATED THAT SUIT, TO WHICH I REQUESTED YOUR OFFICE FAX ME A COURTESY C SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT. HAS SERVICE BEEN ATTEMPTED ANO/OR! DO WE HAVE TIME TO TAKE ANOTHER LOOK AT YOUR CLIENT'S INJk`f I NEED TO KNOW WHAT TIME CONSTRAINTS WE ARE DEALING WIT,hJ 'WILL NEED TO REFER THIS TO OUR LEGAL DEPARTMENT OR..„~;~1~; .~ FOR REVIEW OF THE SPECIALS AND DISCUSSION OF,,;POSS~E::EsE°'C BRIAN YOUNT OMNI INSURANCE COMPANY/CLAIM DEP tpJ V U l I~xhibit ~ T~ HARTFORD OmN1AUTOMOBILL LOSS. PHONE 1-800-727-6664 EXT 29345 ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. 4503 NORTH FRONT STREET HARRISBURG, PA 171141708 717/2366791 FAX 717/23&5610 W W W.ANGIN6ROVNER.COM EMAIL: DLUTZ@ANGIN4ROVNERCOD4 RICHARD C. ANGINO NenJ. ROVNeR JOSErH M. MELRIO TERRY S. HYMAN DAVID L Lure September 25, 2001 Mr. Brian Yount The Hartford P.O. Box 105019 Re: Insured: Carrie Salinas Driver: Josue Salinas-Valdez Claimant: Dale Wintermeyer Claim No.: 01-245468 A17 Date of Loss: 7-14-01 Deaz Mr. Yount: MICHAEL E. Kosnc RicHARp A. SADLDCx losers M. DORIA JAMES DECRVrt Receipt of your September 20, 2001, correspondence is acknowledged. With regazd to Mr. Wintermeyer's property damage claim, reference is made to the Complaint. If we are able to resolve the property damage claim, we will then move on to the bodily injury claim. If we aze unable to reach an amicable resolution with regazd to the property damage claim, both claims will be litigated. Very truly yours, C~~~ U David L. Lutz DLL:mtg bcc Dale Wintermeyer 234412.I~DLLNQTG ,. ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. 4503 NDRTH FRDNT STREET HARRYSBURO, FA 1711a1708 717/2386791 FAX 717/238,5610 www.ANCINo-xovNER.coM EMAIL: DLUTL@ANGE96ROVNFILCOM RICHARD C. ANGIlVO NE6]. ROVNER JOSEPH M. MECILLO T1:RRx S. HxnuN DAVID L. LtT1z MICHAEL H KOSM RICHARD A. SADLOCK JOSEPH M. DORIA ]Antes DECtNn JOAN L STEHUTAK Exhib+t ~ November 6, 2001 Mr. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Cazlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dear Mr. Wintermeyer: Defense counsel has scheduled the taking of your deposition on February 21, 2002, at 12:30 p.m. at my office. Depositions are oral answers by you, under oath, to questions asked by defense counsel regarding the accident, your injuries, treatment, present condition, etc. Enclosed is a document entitled "Your Deposition" to help you better understand the deposition process. Naturally, I will attend the deposition with you, and I would like to review your entire case with you prior to the deposition. Will you please, therefore, make arrangements to be in my office at 11:00 a.m. on February 21, 2002. Upon receipt of this letter, please call my secretary to confirm your availability for this date. Thank you for your cooperation in this matter. DLL:mtg Enclosure V yours, D L. L tz 234395.I~DLL4MTG ANGINO & ROVNER, P. C. 4503 NGRrH FRONT srREEr RICHARD C. ANGiNO MICHAEL E KGSB( FIARRISBURG~ FA 171161706 NEIL J. RGVNER RICHARD A. 3ApLOCK JOSEPH M. MELBA JOSEPH M. DORIA 717/2386791 TERRr S. FIYMAN JAMES DECBaTI FAx 717/23&5610 DAVro L Lutz JOAN L STEHULAR NM1IM1V.ANGIN6ROVNER.COM EMAIL• DLUTZ@ANGIN6ROVNER.COM January 7, 2002 Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Re: Wintermeyer v. Salinas-Valdez Dear Randy: EXhi~it ~ dlgg3,l$~not carc'ect The Complaint avers that Mr. Wintermeyer's damaged motorcycle repairs cost W:,:"~v, Frankly, met with Mr. Wintermeyer on December 28, 2001, he advised me that he would be providing me with receipt of annroximately $'70.00. which would brine the total Dronertv damage claim to annroximately we to the cost I await your response with regazd to the property damage claim before discussing the bodily iniurv claim. Very truly yours, David L. Lutz DLL:mtg bcc Dale Wintermeyer 237508.1\DLLVvITG ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. 4503 NORTH FRONT STREET HntuHSRUaG, PA 171141708 717/2386791 FAX 717/238-5610 A' W N.ANGINdR OVNER. COM EMAIL: DLU1Z@ANGPI6ROVNER.COM February 25, 2002 Mr. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dear Mr. Wintermeyer: F_Xhob~t ~ During the time that you and I met on February 21, 2002, at 11:00 a.m., Mr. Frank Hopkins called my office and indicated that he could not locate the letter I had sent him so my secretary faxed it to him. Mary, my secretary, assures me that Mr. Hopkins was sincere. Therefore, upon receipt of a response from Mr. Hopkins, I will send it to you immediately. Enclosed is a copy of my secretary's message from Mr. Hopkins. Additionally, as we discussed during our meeting of February 21, 2002, Randy Greene, counsel for the Defendant, advised me that he has recommended that the Defendant's insurer tender policy limits of $25,000. mtisr~presentation Also during our meeting, I secured your authorization to communicate to Mr. Greene that if there is a tender of the $25,000 of policy limits, you have provided me with authority to accept a property damage settlement of $976.50. I also advised you that in this regard, there would be an attorney fee concession of $300.00. You also indicated that you would provide me with a copy of the rejection of underinsured motorist coverage that you executed with your Progressive agent. Lastly, you indicated that you would be discussing Jeff Conforti's outstanding physical therapy bill, and that I was not to contac± Mr. Confort.i with regard to payment of the bill from your settlement proceeds. As soon as I hear from Attorney Greene, I will advise you immediately. Very truly yours, v David L. Lutz DLI,:mtg Enclosure RICHARD C. ANG1N0 MICHAEL & Kosnc NEIL J. ROVNER RICHARD A. SADLOCK ]osErx M. MELRSO JosEPx M. DORIA TERRY S. HYMAN JAMES DECWTI DAVID L. LUTZ JOAN L. SrE11UI.AK 234395.1\DLLVvITG __ f=x~ibit g __To._I~roRan~y C, G~_e~_n~.__-- ---_-_. -_ ---_ __flarch_iSJaooz_ { ~ - _I am u-ritin iti re qarils ~o .our- - mutual liti atioYl dispositioll.I hav~ retai~le~ Mr, David Lutz o -An ino~~ouner~ta represent_m _b~st interests~wh;ch I h~uc_e~ resse~ to__1~r,-I,utz.I h4u~-rrcentl received c~ letter . rom_ Mr,_I, tz~!~h1ch-is---date~_Mq~ch__I~aOoaa 11r. l,u~z__ha.r~.n f a_rme~~cJ~_th~tt_~ctte.~._th0.t_I_ huvr_~cav~~e~ him with__the_a~thor~~~_tm___a~c.~pt_y~oyu~L_pt'o~ert+~..,da~ age Settlement _o fey of 4 _6,~0 andd tl3at-Ife-cOni-nun~ra ec~ that settlement o fe~-_-~o_youu,-T-ha~'_o_ eris_..no~_acc_e_~table to me, .~ have-not igne~ an_ _ a_p_er~ i_ch_st~te that l will accept that ~mountt~ ~an -ch~c~5 _are se t to e _ oar that amount, ~, w;_I~_not_.si_ ~_i~r~-_it_ will-b_~e re~urne~That amcan~~~ll on) cov~ the replacement __lab~r- ar _rn Fare otarc cle. alltl~mu h_ther_~ _weCe__other purts_t~at w_e~e _ damage o~- i -~? ~~t_Salinas,_.L_J~a~e_al~'o-~n.~-orme~-tlr, Dgvid l,utZ t~at_Z-u~ou) __~-e_~v~,-tin to-- cu_to in orm ou that ~ am not__acc_e ~in ~_.v _our_~ er,~ have wr~tte~ in yy P ~ ~c~d anyy most recent letter to _DaWi_~i_l.utz ~ am ai`f ectin ou td act in accordance_to my b_~st_in~~~~sts and~_as m~ y re resent~tiue o m _b_est_ interests b- -~n_ crm~n M :: Cr pee11 that I -~i_LI y ot__accept _ his_mos~__recent, _~ e~ o gq~G.s4~".I then_also_uJrote to__J1r~l,~tz~~~-am alsf~direc - ~~~ you to _refuse to _accept M~', G'reens o f f?r~,~I ~uoulr~ li e to Know i f you have ha~ copief o f m me .ca t-ecords of the. ~rthope~ic ~nstitAte o pq, urnishey~Q to ou by that ehte~-prise~or ~yy an"y one rom-thc la~ irm o f Rn ino}Rattner. ~f thatphas occ~(rre~(~plea~e in~orm me~o tithe id nti,t o the ~nd~vidual.r u~ho have provi~e~ you ~~th_m medicYal f 'records and of the name o the irm dr busine.rsrenterpl'ise ~-hirh t~~~~ Person or person wor~s fore l-hank ycu, ~ Sincerer Mr. D. Wintcr,neyer 1108 Carlisle Rd. Camp Hill, PA 17011 n , .uW~ ~. T~ Tlr._~u~r_ic~ ?.utz_ --- 1Jelivered_on_Tues,_Clay_z$~0~ exhibit q ------_ - -----I qm _ wr~t.~n _an~r~gAr_cl~~o~~ur-- - - commun~_cc~~~oq_~~ ~m_~which__is-~.Q~e~?~q- l~j~o4_~~which r ~r-~e~~~ u~lc~ase~ co _ o ~he~~l_~ wb~ch J e_ _~{,~~!~__~qS S'1_utle_~~Q_29av I~~aO~~, I ulo-l~~ 1 i ke vnu n L _ t~,S-~1~.~5__I__~1~V~_1~-Ot~.i.~c~141' e-~ ~i~u_.me~_n_;m~,~i_~s~i_nterests.I ~~ ghat I_e_-a_~~sa~~es_~o~ne_tha~y~~.~sh~o--- _~~~ ~u ~tQm~se t n _tn~._L~se~~~' ~t~q_ --- --_ - a .. a-m Pn .,a 1~JA-~1~ `~h~~~ '~i7 _„npr J ~ C~K~__n~ ~ _~e. 4 LI 11 U y 1 I U, ~` ~__ }f~ l a, ~ UJ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ i _ ~ _ - - 0 0 - ~ -- - ~,~-~-mie~b ~ ~~s ~an~a,~~h ~~ ~r_d~~~~h~. ~S c _ai_m_i:_~~_ t~Ai1 `_a ~'~_~if_~CYle~1~1~C1P'd_ _ -~loss~ nt~~-s~~.~_r~e~ ~ e _ _m~e ~~_ b~ ~_t u~ Chu _._ o u ~ ~~ ' ` ~ ~ ~ f __~9~ ._~h'~e ~~~ L f~c~ai_Q~ ~ Jl~t__~0 ---~1~J-u~ ._-C-P~1-C-C_S_C~ f ~ ~ ~ i - ~ c _ CC 0 0 ~- e _ L 0 n -. e w T i .e o Y 1 ~O ~ a ~ 0 . e f 0 GG ~o e ~ ~ - r LU ~ 0rC ` r s - ~.- - ` e- ~-s- -emu r _ . eir c~ ima es~becavtSe i .Caves ~ em ime~- J ~u.~rmdww~~.~sl~Aa. ~ ~, 3 °~ e ' ~. ~~ y e~'~ : ' S v~ ~~ r~~ CI-- - that ~_. o t ~ ~, ~a~tQ cs_ -- o ~ ~ ' ~e~ _. 1~~ no_L_ _ my mctor~y~-Le~~illte~_ __ _i ~so_..~~e~ __~~e ~t~.huve~ea~o~Ol~d~b -_m_ ~e _ or~_~u-m -~ _- ~ ro~~~~l~o~las wJ'~~n~ ~_ a i ~_e~.~m u~_e ~S __a~_ -- ~ ~ '' - - ~~e---~0=for-c:-~pp~~-ht__~QS_uL2rkt 0 ~ a = e w' o e r ' ' r --~r_ian _ o-un _ eAn locate--- ' z - r _.~I q ~3_H_o ~~_~dou1__U T~.~_a C that_ ~o_o~s. a nod ~ ' ~ ' C_.accurre~, en ~ ~e. ~~-e__t~s_ -ac~i as__r~i-~a~e_-~ 4S oo 3 ~ t (_~ _anoe~'_ o ~_l the I ~i L_acce~ )-l~n a S_~ha ov~Cu~tom_~s_a_ r e_ o mirle,_- e ~' o t er i F o p w i f e ~~' o~ srnm mP a~~er vnu wil l. nod e ~ r _ _ ~.~Y _ ~; .f ~, ~i t_I U.~ ' _r_ .~r~ cr_s _~noth~r_~R~ i. a. --me_ or,-a_tte - m~ nlif-nr.un r~e_ u~rc~--b_ mire _r_e~s~ ,; ~~hou_ld-~y o_u _~e c_c i d t ~n _ m~- _ ~1 ~ tKo ~tt__p r_o u_~ -ft_~une_r_Attor__ne_ ~ and. -to__co~~ett _arl ~e~s o~ had e~a1~ e_c~_-ty"-e~ ro_~ _to-w_ th_~~aw . in - me with_ a he __wi lI _char c _~ny _k_~nd -~r~ m~_w_i_th CC~°S~'~ul r~~nu- ~-- U4~ _ o _:a s _ ~ _tQ~~e~:o ~ ~-an~~~~r~ttor~~~~_ .. ~ogS~uP1~t ~c_u~` onduct~~nd__ib(`eech ''~ ~1_a-I_i_c~Anc~ w:i~hout_uny_~~ar e.s ee:rJ , -bra-_m~~ etu~ __c l u - ms _fi~_~e r~ o w__ n_r_ - n --the _ -~~u~e __- :, __t~~~1-_i_r~ 1IC~_me_-gcc_o!r_d~~n91 _~Q_,~i~gt I_cu.q_dec_ei~e ', _o n_-vv e.Q~e~ _I ma __ or_ ma -i~t ? ensue this _ i ssue ~~_~-h~. far Assocfiati4-1a ~:rus~~, that. you will not. V Sincerel~/~ Mr. D. Wintermeyer 1406 Caelisle Rd Camp H01, PA 17011 ----. ... :~.u Your Legal ~tii~ Presented by Richard ~ Angino AttorneyaRLaw; DAMAGE ASSESSMENT In a civil suit, there.are categories of If you have been injured inaa accident damages upon which a recovery may for which you think another person is be based. Compensatory damages are at faul4 a call to your attorney is i¢ intended to make the persoa:"whole order for instructions about how to again," meanhtg that Ute person is put document your losses incase you do back in the~position that exvsted before eventually need to seek-compensation. the loss or harm. One subcateeorv of Remeinber; sot all injuries are always - comuensatorvdamaaes is eeneml immediately apparent. Por additional 8awaees, which is the amount needed information about recouping your - to restore fair market value of the losses after a personal injury, call injured uartv's orotrerty. Special ANGINO & ROVNER at (717) 238- damages, another subcategory, do not - 6791. The office is located at 4503 .arise as a result of the wrongful act or North Front Street omission itself, but arise due to the . FIIN'r: Future damages that are certain 'circnmstanceasfter the loss nr harm' ::. to nciimtn tt e.. ihirn~.aa ~xh~bi~ 10 We loss or harm, aze Visit Our web site: '= damages.-,:~;~.- . r1NWW;8nglOC-rovnt ~Ip ul~nl;erme ~ ` ~~ icumberland ('n~ant,~pur~ n~ yrs. Common PIPas ~- ;sue .S'alinns Ilalrlez-~ ~ ndan C ~ ual lion ~In^01-5'il~l F 0 4 2004 ~IA I e And nou- on phis ~Q~y o f Februar~~~oo~l Plainti Dale 1~int~rme er as been ratite pperk miss io~~~o liti cite. thi~ ~iS~o,sition ~in this Court Pen~ent~ l.ite )\~unc Pro T~snc and De endants Mo~ioh to Dismiss For Failure ~o Prosec~t~ i:r ~~ehefore ~enie~, l~al~. 1n1in~;erm~uer ~~,T1A_e`.~.~111g. -D endan~ ~+mbF~lnnd__~o~An ~ (~ni t gas C~u~l Artion~ oQ01-5y1~ la ] P _ FEB 0 4 20(41 And noun on this day o Fe.bruar aooy Plginti-~f dale. l~lintermeyer may a~~ec~r in th~~r Court ursuQ~1~ t~ hid' Peti~idn For Rule. To Ap eAr Zn ~erson Tn This. Court. In_ ore To Show Jupst .Cause To uas~ ~ismi.rsulao Compla-n~ oPen~ent~ l.itc~c~no< ~~er~ ors. plant, Pet~tio~ ~s herb rante~Q. ~ f~ f y~ ~y `~e_ Petjti~l1e.r l,~Jintfrme~ __ _ _ w,~ . _ (la1e uJintermri~rrP~rnint_,T% P ,~ ~~ " S~mk~rl ~r~nfi,~ ['o~art vrr. _ 0~ Cn 1~on plra.r ~n~.~Sglina.r_i~-d -n rendan~' Cj~il A~t,ioY~lod~l-~-~ i _ ___ - -- - -- - _ - - - _ ._ --------- J.l l a i P - -- -- ~ --- -- i -- ~n~ x~ o~ on --this-_ -day -o_~--Fe.b_r. ~~r~--~9o~i~ __ ---PJai-nt~_ _ _~~-nle_~)i~at~r_me _er m_a~y-a~p~r~~~h~~r__Court- --~ ur~r-ua to_. -~~et,t-_ n - i=or__Rule __To_~ ~ur_1n - ; ~erson~n ~~ is Court tn__~r~e~ Io__ Show_J~t~-t_Cau.~e T_o__; '_- trash--D-lsmi.rsAl~ ---Co~-p~ain~--~ende~~~ _l.i~-cc~~no< . _t er_e ore~plaint~ f~s_p~t itiorl--is _her~b- _ r.ante~,. f Y~ gU the Pe~;itinner - - -- - ~~IP l,J~ntermev~r P1r. 1J~2~_L~ ; C~Am~,rrln~C.o~ r- -~l!~~ t~~t.oYl 1_le-r~_. 0 U ` ~~n~dCZ'~~~~Y11aA11~ _ ~Iyll nC i0n•~a ~~'5~~7 ~~,ShOUId NOt BP_ ~1_ mISS'Pr~_ I_~ ~ have the le aI standin .and u s f ici"ent stake ~n h~.s dl9spos~t-on- ~o seek_ an-~ obtain; G non b~ase~ u~ic~al re~oli~~on o this. Com la~nt ~n ~ uit or" tie " ust due co~~e~sation po my losses. T~t S~ e~~t~on ~ Tacks I.uw Dictionary c lead de Ines Standen , asf6cstandin_ oneans _than a" ~a~t" ~as a sU ~c9ien~ stake ~n9 an other~i.ce ust~c~able cont~®ve~sf to obtain_ a "_udicial resolut~iotl o .that ControUer_s Y rhe_ re uir ~en~t_ o _stanc~in is sa~i5- ied i ~ i~ 'can ~~ ~sai~ that ~h~ _~ urt ha~r ~ ~~ l~ea~all f rotectabl~. an- tin ibis. _~-n_~'_ere,s at stake, Jdo ya P act.. Dave 'a_ ~ e_ -a I_- - r-ot ~ta~6le and tqn ibis i n~e~~st at sake _i~ is~~on~6~QUers which have a l~ al r'i ht to ursine.., y ~,_I hwv_e 9~_ust__9cause ~o pursue_myy'' enti_tleme t to recooe~' -in u]I~ a~- a_ll- o m-y_ lo,~t wa q~s an~ o_r loo.../a o tie ~st_ d_u~ fca M e ,fat onJ o all o. e. arts a~d l ~~~~ rc i_mburse_n~~n w_~ i h fccr~ f s~ ~Pn -Qn -m_ _m~~orc c-Ie_ ~e _ou-r est-ma~e i n of~er to__~e.Y~ore it~~ack ~o _t~e same eXeeLlent condition that it was in be~o_re Josue. Bali as Uulde - r_an into it and. my ) e _~ le ~ du-~e to his 3,_zphau__e th~ C~n_stitutional Fight to _present this Complaint___and __)_iti ati_on to a -Uuu~ _e i~h person by du.e -~~ocess and- ~ ~~ual prot~ct~ian~ an~,1 a`~ Y, ~ Y Ala ar~d I am -nuokin~ phis )eo a( ri~ht~ a ~ ~' S~ 1 ~~~sire_ to went t~.s~__ 1e I di>r osltion ~n per- .~on ~n ront o a Jul c Pend~nt~ 1i~e_an_d Nunc r o _t~nn~c~ as .~ _hque t~~ 1_e~ qa f-_ rte- ht to ~o, 6~ I have. not st~~mitted ~--1'9'otion~of_ lll~_ll~ Pros ~o this Caurt~ ~, This Complaint is still. endin anal it is sti II le~all a_ctlonable. pursuan~ to i~ as it ivassu~mitte~ ~0 thi~ Court 6 ~av~c~ 1,utz,_whp .demanded a Cur,y 1 Cial. Sa Thy statute. o~ ~ mi~atloas or urthe~- anc~ ~'e~rent legal act~_o~ on an~ o -phis ~omp~aint aa~ dis~os~t-on has still...not tolle~, ~, Since I have r~o~ rotracte~ this actionable Complain I h~u~e cont-n~ed; ~o believe .that this Hnnor~ble Cour was oio~9 to apt on this le al Complaint b sen~in~q m~ _a. notice o when the9 im ead~n Ju~ sele,ctNo~~~ ~voul~_ start~p~rs-cant. to ~~e d~-man oryr~ Jur __Tr~al which was re resented to ~hi.s. N_onor~~le ~ou~ and to mysel bavid Lutz, ~IO~I else conteh~,_tfhgt~it-wool be__unconsianable to dismiss this _vali~ an~_ act~ona~le. Le _wl Com_ hint in li ~i~t o t~e ,~_ ct t}~at L hav _ b~n su~`~ecte~~ to ~~liberfate. _ir~di_ erence h t~e_a it i_a~er~ Attaurne s who_ hc~~ef_b~en _hir~e~ in_, _~o~ with, ~o a ul ill ayn~ ~_ ~ol_c~__~~`eit` l~e_~t~~uti .r_.re~pons-bil- i~ ~e~S aid rep~esentat-tOt1~ i~ I~_ t o ~~e act a (~ o ~ f~ aVl re a- t~u~`~he -hav_~ i_1e_~ to e I ~t my I ant &le;~er~' an~ ues~'ons_~h~ch pertain~toythis ~i.rp_ositlon~where-as~ ~~li~erate_ ir~di erenc~e ~s ~s~tally aormall rpwne~ upoq b_ __~~ Courts, lc In lil ht o _allro the a o~remen~i~nec~ relavar~t anti ~ f f f __- 6y ~h~ Plaintif ~_ _ @~ ~h~ cQUrt T1_r_,_ D ~_~l n to rm A y e r y ~, ,., ,. ,., r •, ~ ~., ~ r~ _ <'~ l' - _ .~. ~n Fe ~~ _-~: G -~ C~ ] _r~ is _.... ~ ^; ~ .~ `P> ~_~_ _ VU^ ~i C~y pi b'jl lh!'LhhS hy: ~5 11 IG9hb~(.i ..: ~ F'Alat., .. F71/pG YKIJ I NIJNIJ I AKY' U LUh!(a PRAE+ CIPE TOR L1S'~'!NG CASE FOR Al?GUIVIENT (Must be typew'rltten and submitted in dnplicate) TO TAL PROTHONOTARY OF CUM~LRLAND COUNTY: Please list the within matter for the next Argument Court. CAPTION OF C.aSE (eaaire cnptton musC be stated zn full) Dale Wintermeyer (PlaintiPl) vs. Josue Salinas-Valdez (Defendant] No. 01-5417 Civil 7e7ni 1. Stnte matter to be argued (i.e., plaintiffs motion. for new trial, defendant's deraurrcr to complaint, etc.); Motion to Dtsmi_ss for Lack of,~osecntion 2. Identify counsel who will azgue cases: (a) for plaintiff; David L. Lutz, Esquire (Name and Address) 4503 N. front Street, Harrisburg. PA 17110 (b) for defendant: Randy C. Greene Esquire (Name and Address) 1880 John F Kennedy Blvd. Ste. 1400. Phila.. PA_ 19103 3. i will notify all paztics in writing within two days that this case has been listed for argument. (via first class maill _ _ _ - _ __-_ 4. Argument Court Data Josue Salinas-Valdez Dare; 9/20/05 naon,cy£o+Defendant Randy C. Greene. Esquire Print your name ,__ _,__ -.T -- `=":3s~!9eYi~sbs~s~3~'nwl~s ~,P aft~.> d: rev, .. h ~ , .,..~ 3;r.~ a.n, s~mx%YiNm .. C ~ ~ u r.» ~ ~ ~~ ~rA _= v ~~ ~C rJ ;'~ N tV x ~ Wit:-' -~-r; ~ ~~ i 3> ~- ny ~ :n .~ ~ -:. ~~ ~~~ ~ Mr, D 1~lirlt~rmvi - i C ~ u~ _ ~osU CalinnP UrJdPZ-1)P.~endanf _ (°iVi ~ Ac j011~ o, 01- f, ,. ~. „m i -- ---- ---- ~ w ~; ~ ...-...._ __- --_. ____ - ..._- - - ___. - ~ L `~ ~1 l~ - I _ le ~._ have. thy-__1~4ga1._s_tandin,q __and __u s f _ 1r_ient ~" ,. _ _s~o,-ke ~n_ 1~is__d_cs-Position_t'o__seek__and-_o~b~`~in~`r~on blase_d ' u icla]_~-esol_ut_lon o ~--this Com~la_Igt_.-~n - __ ~'q pit-y, or_the ' u~t --due co~pen,ratio~1 _o ~--m losses, Th~c-S_'t~ editlan_~ -Tacks_~.aw Dlct~onar ~learl de inesstan~in _a.s1G_c~_~-andi~n ._means -~tha't__a` par~t~ i~as-a ~U Ic~,en~_stak~ -n~ an- other~i.re _ust drab-le _-con~~o_u_~~sf_to_-ob_tai-n-_u_ °u~i_c_i_a1 ~~e,r_olut~io~--o_--that y ~o t1 trover_s_ Y-Th e_te_ ui r__ r~e_nt__o_ __s~an_c~ i n_ _is__sa~ i s- __ ~.ed--~- -I~ gun -b~ ~sal~ _that __ he '~_pp_art had` -a - -__l~e- all f rotectabl~.-an_ fan idle. _int!ere,r at__stake:"_ ~' 9do yi ~ act.--have a ~ e a 1- __- rot- cta~_le _and_tan - ib_~e__i_r~~er~~~t at stake i~h i.s~_con~~overs_ _whi~h r have-a i~9al right to _ .ursue,- _ _ ~6 Ihau_e _ °us~ cause ~o- PuCSUe_m __e_ntitl_eme ~ - :. -, --~o -recooer~in ul(~ o~- all_-o -myy -los~C- !~a_q ~s an~ - _ o r __ loo to o t~_e. ~st e~ ue fco M pe sat onJ o a l I o ~. _ arts a~d ) ab~n- re, l mb_ursemen~s w~ I -h fare f s~i_owP~- -on_my _m_otor_c cle.._ r~_ _ai_r_ eS~_I_~a~~. _~n -__ or_deY' to ~'e.If~o'T~ itrback ~o_ the same_ Xce-Item - . condition that i t was i n -be~or~ Josue sal ir~as ~alc~e ran into it and m-y_-I_e t_ le , dui -to .his c_u~ c~~~e ne_li encc~ I f 9 - 3, ~~-.have the ~ nstitutjonal rj qq1h1~ _to ..resent phis Comp-taint-cxnc~ Iiti atjo-1 to a ~Ju~ e _if~ per~ror~by _.due ~rocess and- b ~~ual _p_roteCti_nn~ aid I- am - a _ ar~_d---l--am invo-kir~~_~his_ le al--ri~ht~ - '- - ~' , ~ , ---_ _ S,_2__~desi_re -to_-- -e_serlt._-~ s_le L_d~s -o_s~tio~1 in__~_er-_ , _ son_~r~__ r~nt__o _G Jud e~~nd ~~~_1_i~e_ nd_Nun_c___ ~o_~-un~c _as-_.I_ha~e_th~ 1_e-q a_I_r_i_ h~ to~o,_---------- __6~_1_hav-e n_ot_submi-tte_c~_u l~otio_n~o_~_I~o_Ile~__Pr_os~o__E f ~,T_hi.r---Gampl_aint__ is___still__ en~in _an~l__i.~- is_sti ll_ _ '~ 1_e~a I,y __act-.ionable p~rsuan~ to _i~ _as _i-t-was_.ru~m,tte~_ __~p _~is_ Coulrt - 6 __~au-~~_ -,utzwho demanded a-dur ~ _rial. - ~a~he_Sta~~{te o l`mitation.r._ .or__ _urther_anc~- re..cent - legal action on __an o ~thi~ ~om~~aint_ and dis ositio_rl 4 __h~~ _st ~ I I . --not _t~ l l e < - ~ -- -- ___ _ _ _- __- ____-_ _. _ ~,_S-i_t1c_e I-- hrnu_e at r~ rude _ ~hi.r q~tionable -tom ia~n~ I_-_hc~v-e-_conti_nue~ _to---belieue_that t_his__iior-©rc~bl~e sen~n ~me'~r~9not ae~ .~ whh~. hee~aim ~ np~nnt4)_br~- _ -s~~le_cti~o,r~- would starts p~ursuaot to the--d~man~ ~orya Jur_y tri_aI -which_wo,s_re resente~'_ o _~his_-tlono'r~~-Ie - _Co_ur±t _an ~ to mysel b avid Lutz, _ y _10,I_ A_l_so conteh~_ hat~_it_-would be__urlc-onriogab)e _to -: ;- di.rxni_.~~s__~hi.r _voli_d_an~ _acti-o_nabl_e___I-e ai_~omp_I~i_nt3 L, iq --Ii- ~- o _tl7e~-a ct-ghat _Z huv -_b~n sub ected_ -to___de~~iberfate i-n~di _ ~ereYlCe-_b_ - ~~e-a- __ iI i a~e_c~ --___ Attoucne s- __who hu~ef.b~een -hi'~ecQ _i_n_ _ ~o~_ ,ai~h_~o--_: u_I -i-Il ayn~ _u_p_hol-d_-theiC' _-e- al d:u~t_i .r _r_~~~on.~ib_i_l- _ ~ i efs _ao ~ rep P-e.~entati o ns~ i ~ ) i ht o t~e -act___ . _t~at`~he have a~_le--~ to i-e 1 ~o m --le. aUl_ re~c,- e ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -~ ~ ~ y ° ~ ant. bl ~ters an .nest ons hick er .ain o this ~, h ~ ~ I ~ t i.rposit~on w ereas- e , era e ind~ erenc~e ~5 ~s all no-rmall - r wne~ upon b t~~_~ourts, 1J, In lid ht o allYo f the_a orementid~~~~..rel~vant- anc~ 9 f f f NOV.21.2bb5 4~1bh'PI NIVb1nu a rtU ViYCR nav. rn. "`-+,~ ~, ,,~_,,_ ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. 4503 NOaTa FRONT SraaaT YXAaRISSURC, PA 171ia17aa 737/Z386791 FeJe~17(2S&5610 unu~VaNGIN6ROVNa&COM EbSM.. DLUII®ANG¢dbaOVNQLNM Curtis Long, Prothonotary Cumberland County Courthouse One Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 Re: Wintermeyer v. Valdez No. 01-5417-Civil Deaz lvlr. Long: Rlcnptuo C. At~taavo 1V~1.ROVNEtC ]oserHMbatLaLo De~iD L LViZ ~~~o~ RrexnRne. SADIAC[C lowly L SrElil]fA1C LL¢AMB. WOODSURN Dnari E. CHRL4iDPllEtt ~~--- a ~-o - ~ ~~ o ~.eCre~~~ Enclosed is a copy of your notice with regard to Wintermever v. Salinas~V'aldez. For many years I have not represented Mr. Wintermeyex. Pursuant to Judge I~offer's Order dated July 8, 2002, the Court permitted me to withdraw my appearance. I am sending a copy of this letter and your notice to Mr. Wintermeyer's last lmown address, and I am also sending a copy of this letter to defense counsel, Jacqueline Cassidy, Esquire. Very truly yours, David L. Lutz DLL:mtg Enclosure cc Dale Wintermeyer (w/enc.) Jacqueline Cassidy, Esquire (w/ene,) November 8, 2005 l~~~l-O~ ~~ '- mat ~ - Lu'~ ~ ~S ~a v. ~. 319133 r DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant r IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO. 01-5417 Civil Term JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ER AND NOW, this day of 2002, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Plaintiff's counsel, David L. Lutz, Esquire, ' permitted to withdraw his appearance on behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment in the above-captioned case must include Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a Payee. BY THE COURT: c~, ~., -~, P. ~ . --~ 247041.1~DLL~MTG y$,'ts~~ i ~ V C, X111 i~ r (n~ ~/ . ~- -'~`~ `Y .,'ill IJ i ~ I II 1,_ . ~[} ~~-- ,i , ., .. ;n ~_,~ - - DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO.OI-5417 Civil Term JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PLAINTIFF'5 COUNSEL'S PETITION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE 1. On May 16, 2002, a Rule was entered upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Court should not permit Plaintiffls counsel to withdraw his appeazance and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment not include Angino & Rovner, as a payee. The Rule was returnable within 15 days of service and was executed by the Honorable George E. Hoffer. Attached as Exhibit A is Judge Holler's Rule. Attached as Exhibit B is the referenced Petition (without exhibits). 2. In a letter dated May 17, 2002, attached as Exhibit C, Plaintiff's counsel sent to Mr. Wintermeyer Judge Hoffer's May 16, 2002, executed Rule. 3. Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer has not filed a response to the Petition. Therefore, Plainriff s counsel respectfully requests that Your Honorable Court issue a Rule Absolute and 24704I.1~DLL4~ITG Order that Plaintiffs counsel be permitted to withdraw his appearance and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment in the above-captioned action include Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a Payee. Date: ~ ,,t 1 y ~V ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. David L. Lutz LD. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717)238-6791 Attorney for Plaintiff 247041.1~DLLIMTG ~~#~ .6! ~~ 2El~r DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO. 01-5417 Civil Tenn JURY TRIAL DEMANDED RULE AND NOW, this ~ ?I!'J day of °" , rr ? . f , 2002, a Rule is hereby entered upon Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the C should not permit Plaintiff's counsel to withdraw his appearance and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment not include Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a payee. Rule returnable within / ~ days of service. BY THE COURT: ~, ~. '~ ~ =>/ ~z : J. 4 {n Tesrimony whersc`, i la:;re unta sc-t my hand anda a seal or' said Caur~ at CariisEe, Pa. Th1 ......~.~G.'.... d o~..d..i..'•:1.t.~.., ...irk 245515.1~DLL~ITG I~ DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO. 01-5417 Civil Term r. r ~:. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED HIS APPEARANCE AND NOW COMES Angino &Rovner, P.C., and respectfully requests that Your Honorable Court enter a Rule upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Court should not Order that Plaintiff's counsel be permitted to file a Praecipe to Withdraw His Appeazance. In support thereof, Angino &Rovner avers the following: 1. On July 14, 2001, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer was injured in a motorcycle/motor vehicle accident caused by Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez. See, Plaintiff's Complaint filed on September 17, 2001, attached as Exhibit A. 2. Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer retained Angino &Rovner and entered into a Power of Attorney and Fee Agreement with regard to the July 14, 2001, motor vehicle accident. 3. The insurer for the Defendant retained the services of Attorney Randy C. Greene and counsel for the Defendant filed an Answer to the Complaint with New Matter. 4. Counsel for the Plaintiff and Defendant entered into discovery and the depositions of the respective parties were scheduled for February 21, 2002. 5. However, during discovery, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer corresponded directly with Attorney Randy Greene. Mr. Wintermeyer's letter dated December 3, 2001, is attached as Exhibit B. 245515.1\DLL\MTG ii 6. Thereafter, Plaintiff's counsel advised Mr. Wintermeyer to not correspond with defense counsel, 7. On February 20, 2002, two days before the aforementioned depositions of the parties, Attorney Greene called Plaintiff's counsel. At that time, Attorney Greene indicated that he would recommend to the Defendant's insurer that it should tender its policy limits of $25,000.00. Therefore, in order to save both parties the cost of depositions, counsel agreed to cancel the depositions. 8. On February 21, 2002, Mr. Wintermeyer met with Plaintiffs counsel and he provided counsel with authority to accept a tender of policy limits of $25,000 with regard to the bodily injury claim and to accept a property damage settlement offer of $976.50 for damage to his motorcycle. 9. In a letter dated February 22, 2002, attached as Exhibit C, Attorney Greene corresponded with Plaintiff's counsel and confirmed that the depositions were canceled in order to provide additional time for the Defendant's insurer to evaluate the demand for policy limits. 10. In a letter dated February 25, 2002, attached as Exhibit D, Plaintiff's counsel advised defense counsel that Mr. Wintermeyer and counsel met on February 21, 2002, and that Mr. Wintermeyer provided counsel "with authority to accept a tender of policy limits of $25,000 with regazd to his bodily injury claim. Secondly, pursuant to Brian Yount's October 3, 2001, letter, enclosed for your convenience, Mr. Wintermeyer has also provided me with authority to accept a properly damage [settlement] of $976.50." 1 L Thereafter, in a letter dated March 27, 2002, attached as Exhibit E, Attorney Greene corresponded with Plaintiff's counsel and advised that he had obtained authority to tender the policy limits of $25,000 and to pay $976.50 for Mr. Wintermeyer's property damage claim. 245515.I~DLL~NITG 2 12. In a letter dated Mazch 15, 2002, attached as Exbibit F, Mr. Wintermeyer again corresponded dir' ectly with Attorney Greene. 13. Plaintiff s counsel has recommended that Mr. Wintermeyer accept the tender of limits of $25,000 and the $976.50 property damage settlement, because to proceed further with the litigation would not be economically feasible. 14. Plaintiff's counsel has also determined that Mr. Wintermeyer had rejected UIM coverage covering his motorcycle. 75 Pa.C.S.A. §1731(c.l). 15. Notwithstanding the tender of limits and property damage settlement offer, Mr. Wintenneyer refuses to consummate the settlement. 16. Given Mr. Wintermeyer's refusal to cease corresponding directly with defense counsel and refusal to settle his claims even though he had provided counsel with authority to do so, Plaintiff s counsel has requested that Mr. Wintermeyer retain new counsel. 17. In fact, Plaintiff s counsel had provided Mr. Wintermeyer with a draft of the aforesaid Petition and requested that Mr. Wintermeyer retain counsel so that the Petition could be served upon Mr. Wintermeyer's new counsel. 18. To date, Plaintiffs counsel has not been contacted by Mr. Wintermeyer's replacement counsel. WHEREFORE, Angino & Rovner respectfully requests that Your Honorable Court enter a Rule upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Court should not Order that 245515.1 \DLL\MTG 3 Plaintiffs counsel be permitted to file a Praecipe to Withdraw His Appearance and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment include as a payee, Angino & Rovner, P.C. l / , Date: ~ \ ~'~ 245515.1~DLLN9TG 4 ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. .. ~. ,~ ~ - Davic~ L. Lutz LD. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717)238-6791 Attorney for Plaintiff CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE upon defense counsel and Mr. Dale Wintermeyer via postage prepaid first class United Sues mail addressed as follows: Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendant Mr. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dated: ~ ' I _ ~' 245515.1~DLLVviTG ANGIN®& Rf VNER, P. C. 4503 NORTH FRONT STREET RICHARD C. ANGINO FiARRI56LiRG, PA 171141708 NEll. J. ROVNER )osEea M. MELH10 717/238b791 ~y g, xy~N FAX 717/236.5610 DAVm L L171z W W W.ANGIN6ROVNEIt.COM EMAIL• DLUTL@ANGIN6ROVNER.COM May 17, 2002 Mr. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Cazlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dear Mr. Wintermeyer: Enclosed please find Judge Hoffer's May 16, 2002, executed Rule. Very truly yours, ~r Davld L. Lutz /mtg Enclosure MICHAELE KOSIX RICHARD A. SADLQCK JOSEPH M. DDRIA JAMES DECRVtI JOAN L SIEE[UI.AK 234395.1~DLLVvITG '~ 1 ~ 1 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL'S PETITION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed as follows: Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendant Mr. Dale Wintenneyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dated: ~~~~~~~ 247041.1\DLL\MTG c'-. O .1 -n `f= -p . . , . _ , ~ (_ ~ G _ - i7 .. .L i n_n _ >:7 (A - - „-~ Ll ' _ ~ . ~ ~ `i V Y ., r,~ a ~ ~5 AIL L DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY I.D. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14"' Floor Attorney for Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY v. Josue Salinas-Valdez NO.: 01-5417 Defendant(s). ENTRY OF APPEARANCE TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Kindly enter my appearance on behalf of Defendant, Josue Salinas-Valdez in the above- captioned matter. MAGINNIS AND PACE .iREENE, ESQUIRE Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez ~ ~ Ca ~. %:> ., m -e i7i ra - - ''r'= ~ -h _ .n~ ~~ - G^; ti~: - r y~~C" ~.~ ~ ~I.-=j ' ~ Z~ n ~{ :~~ ~ i •~ m ~J ~M DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO.OI-5417 Civil Term JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PLAINTIFF'S REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS TO DEFENDANT To: Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez, by and through his attorney Randy C. Greene, Esquire Please take notice that you are hereby required, pursuant to Rule 4014 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure (Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 36), to serve upon the undersigned within thirty (30) days from service, your response to the admission(s) requested herein: 1. Do you admit that on July 14, 2001, you were operating a 1984 Oldsmobile in Lemoyne, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania? Admit Deny 2. Do you admit that on July 14, 2001, at approximately 11:18 p.m., you were involved in a motor vehicle accident while operating your 1984 Oldsmobile Cutlass in a northbound direction on South Third Street in Lemoyne, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania? Admit Deny 3. Do you admit that before a motor vehicle/motorcycle accident on July 14, 2001, you stopped your vehicle at the intersection of South Third Street and Herman Avenue, Lemoyne, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania? Admit _ Deny 4. Do you admit that you stopped at the subject intersection, intending to turn left onto Herman Avenue? Admit _ Deny 237520.1\DLL\MTG 5. Do you admit that even though you intended to tum left onto Herman Avenue and had activated your left turn signal, you turned your vehicle to the right? Admit Deny 6. Do you admit that when you turned your vehicle to the right, the right side of your vehicle impacted Mr. Wintermeyer and his motorcycle? Admit Deny ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. David L. u z LD. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717)238-6791 (.~ Attorney for Plaintiff Date: ~~~ -~~ ~~ 237520.1~DLL~MTG ~ ~ ` . i CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the COMPLAINT upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed as follows: Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendant Dated: ~~-'~~~~ 237520.1~DLLN9TG ~ r,.: DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO.OI-5417 Civil Term JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE I, Randy C. Greene, Esquire, counsel for Josue Salinas-Valdez, hereby accept service of the Complaint filed in this action on behalf of the Defendant, and hereby verify that I am authorized by my client to accept service of the Complaint} /1 eene, Esquire 1 JF Blvd., Suite 1400 Phila elphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendants Date: ~~- ~7J-~~ 237530.I~DLUMTG a CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed as follows: Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendant Dated: ~' ~'~ 236329.1~DLLUNTG e~ ,;~ __ ~Q; ~ Wiz, ._ V `art' •~ ~C ~ ~~ C.J ~~~ .,, {__ `:_T `_ e`r5 '` ~~ .ir~~- -DALE WINTERMEYER, Plaintiff v. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA CNIL ACTION -LAW NO. 01-5417 Civil Term JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW APPEARANCE To the Prothonotary of Cumberland County: Pursuant to Judge Hoffer's Order dated July 8, 2002, attached hereto, David L. Lutz, Esquire, hereby withdraws his appearance on behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer. ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. Davtz LD. No. 35956 4503 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 238-6791 Attorney for Plaintiff Date: ~,~ ~ O~ 236329.I~DLL~M7'G III } ~~ JU~i 7. $ 2Q02~ DALE WINTERMEYER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA v. CIVIL ACTION -LAW JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, NO. 01-5417 Civil Term Defendant JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ORDER AND NOW, this $~day of ; 2002, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Plaintiff's counsel, David L. Lutz, Esquire, is permitted to withdraw his appeazance on behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment in the above-captioned case must include Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a Payee. BY THE COURT: /S~~~P. J. 247041.1\DLL\MTG .iz .. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C, do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW APPEARANCE upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed as follows: Randy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendant Mr. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dated: ~~ ~,l ~~ 236329.11DLLU4TG .... s„ _~ z ~~ -~ ~ ;, .,_ z. _: _ _ U ~ r ~ .~ J 'C% -~ ~'=C7 '(' .. ' ~ ' j~ry~(I[y 't ~. ~1~Da ul_in~er~mruPr- Plain ,i.~c Cu her~nn, ~ r vs. JnSU>r .Ca~inn U Ir~~Z-De~~an~ t PROOF OF SERVICE I, 1'((' I I have this day hereby certify that _. ~Q~.. served upon the Person(s) Service by First-Class Mail t Q QM ~• 1` - S ~ 3 the foregoing document(s), IA.~63i~`:m'4~&M~x£sdcYC~~M~aa nu.,a~.a Xsm-~'~sxse,u, ...-_, _ ~_..~ .v _ss-~'3.~-' ~'~dsk€vValm ~s~..~sdn~r~lya~ ,ar uisc^°~, ~ ~ C N o Q -~.~ i~rTi ~ ~ `~ '' ~ __ ' C~'1 C"J 'S7 n71= ~., y7 ~~, O ~ ~ a - t-_ _..,.. ,: -O ~ ~ = `~3 ~ G? •• ~ ...~ Cil ~ G1 'G ~~ CQINMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA CotlNryoF CunRER~AN~ l.ts. ~! ~dt i 11~ e r.1p eV,~ -~ i G i ~ ~ i._~T__ , (11tra(!C) P I ~a S UI';S, No. r1 clnsta,~ S'r~linnS Vnlr~ z- fl are ~ n~' • .~t1Ll I A c~t i n n TO: You are ordered by the court to come to (Specify c1ourt~ro~° m or other place) (~L County, Pennsylvania, on at "tier scherfulpd fiim~ ,to ~,~~,n,~~ ~~ur _c'ulorl 2. If you fail to attend or to produce the documents or things reEluired by this subjoena, you may be subject to the sanctions authorized by Rule 234.5 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, including but not limited to costs, attorney fees and imprisonment. REQUESTED BY: Cligt!$ q Name: r~~, ~~ ~ I ~jte, rJ~ev>?r- Address: 1 yeti i.z'i (~~~~ i ~ C ~ca., 110 i I Telephone: Date: AQ..~,. 0 ~ ~'7 ~d~ Seal of the Court BY THE CO RT: Prothopoiary/C rk Deputy Official Note: This-form of subpoena sha(I 6e used whenever a subpoena is issuable, including hearings in connection with depositiohs and before arbitrators, masters, commissioners, etc. in compliance with Pa. R. C. P. No: 234.1. If a subpoena for a production of documents, records or things is desired, complete paragraph 2. (Eff. 7/97) fi~d_..=4., ., ~~a .M mr.m:,... .--ts- .=r-a. .:_J'2%~4P'~'1 - R+a atW~seuw&..;L &A~J¢IG's*reax-aua5';meYv~}!6- _ ~ N ~ Q C_ CJ~ --1 ;-< ® r4~ lJ t =r t, "b 7~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~={,; C+a ~ b 't=t C..~ .,/. 1`+3 ~~ rJ~~~ ~tlintermr° oPr- Plain~";.~~ "~-- ~S. Joss"e .sa~ina tln)_~pe,~n nn Cum~JP~~an Count ~ CoJr ~ommot1 P1~as 1ZQCkrt Na. -S~II~] PROOF OF SERVICE I, I'J I : J l~ ~ I have this day,^~ ..ottf the foregoing document(s), ,21dd1_ a pursuant to _, upon the Service by First-Class Mail to: ~ ~ S hereby certify that _,.~,~~., served ~tNx M~^'~.w+x> by ~e dw~~x}iyl ~~:4~z°.l. y~s7~x ~m> ~, v.. -~.~&4 am42frs'to9'~ '~°M"web %'~WLRxr~+lfe.4cs ruslx--.c ---""ill - . C n) O Q .-`.-. ~_ J ~ `~~. ~ ~r .. ~ ~0 ice -` ~ n . _ ~~ ~-~' ~ :~ ~v ` T j DALE WINTERMEYER IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ N0.2001 - 5417 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 3RD day of JANUARY, 2006, it appearing to the court that Plaintiff s former counsel David Lutz, Esquire, was granted permission to withdraw his appearance by the Honorable George E. Hoffer after adequate notice to Plaintiff, Plaintiff s current "Motion for Order to Represent Plaintiff and Complaint Pursuant to Quasi Contract Agreement for Trial Representation" is DENIED. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, Pa. 17011 Edward E. Guido, J. ~, ~rn.~u~ ~_/o.oG .~ ,..'d L~.f2~ ~sou,'aE ~' xc~"if4~ixdtf~'aEs'CNVS:'~~'S~ ~Y#~ra . zr~..~i~'as ~ ia~ ,. ..... _.. ~ ._ d~aa~~' F i~„~r`~- - !} :~ _}~~ h- t~~r 9oaz -,y_~ , . ~ ~~~I~ ~` _:_ ..... , _ .......,.._ ...u.;..:.•.raw:.a ussaa~4ez~mWAxs Lm :ycwuv kk._ts> vlev:._ ly-LUn,..u ~., J _..z_ ,:.r. u.. .~-.,,.. '~_ C r C lea f • ~ z ~ ~ fumh~e.r1 urs. 0 ` ~ ~. _. -,. DEC 2 9 2005 I r r'Ifl sin For__~?r~er ~ Ta _Re~re~en-~_ Plainta ~ ~~-~ Pur uant_ _To_ ~uasi- _Cnnt~ct- A~rtemen°~ -o Triul ftepCe.~e~ _ __ _ __ __ _ _ R,r l a van t F a c ~_r __ _ _ _ _ _I-~ SQO_n ~~~~rr ~_o_s~~e Sal i nas_ dc~ue. i ntQ , m~_ ]~e~t lei and my _ .otorC~cl~~_I ~ound an a~~u~r_t~sem_en o~ t6~l~__ irm ~ An~~no I~_4~ner rey~r~,~n a_u~oma ~Ie ce,_lat~.~ ~~c~~n~f_in'. _ries_whi~h -~t-~~es`!~o reco~~ty~_ _N_o Fees'' That___a~u)ctisement__ _or__le~~l__~epr_e..senta~ibn ~~' ~n~tre-~_~~_~xh~b,t s ut~-~h-~h~t~° _Mut~on Fnr O~deC To i~e~resent P__I_ainti. aA s then_ e9ntacte~_~. l.uva._-.rm._o . Angqirlo~ Rovner and I ._ ~onse _u~entl- -then-- tal~fe~- to_fatto~rn_ pau i.~-t~~ ~1~0 ~,s~-'usty-Qne o_. -mun_y attaurn~s-hat han~lt ~ecsonal .in'_ur~-_cas~s__o -_repr~esentatio~! _u,s a ~.~I~ate~ with ~~a~ _I_~w__._~_ irm_F- __ 3t A_ ter 1 _ ex~l-~Ji n e ~ th.i5 - s%t.uatio q _o_ _ m_ _ _I osse.~ anot _n~~~i~cs ~p--~_~i_~__l~~n~~~~n~.I tol~__hi_~ t~~a~_.I waht~d to be_t-e~re~~en~_~ ~~ url __attQurny in _C~~rt__und in a Tr9a~_ who w ul__su pOr an_d o taitl ~ s~~t~~._m.ent ~ay- na~.nt _ or _m~ - -or LOt~~o o ' _t~e_ c9s`~s Q. J'~s~ c~u ~! co m_ ~~satiQ~1__ oc__th_e__~a~a ~__tk,at ut~eJre ca+~sec~ to ~', _m~_p~_c~r_v _Kcal'e___~otQ_c~_,~1e~in__~~c(_i~i~-t1 _~o_co_Il~ctin . Y all_ . , ~ rya q~s ~ n-c _ ~_- -1 ~ t ~~ -qu t ~ on costs. _iq' _armec~_me1~a~ _Me h~S__QV~i' d0 ~.nc~.~ s_all_e~ti_-t_ __cam~en_sa~ion_ano~ s _~~p el _ _ .-__c_l ~-` rri~~n~ ~hat__~ a- I~ect_~n _. ~a~a'a_ ~~ _ _0_~---In- ----m~torcYc~ -show _ .9 f Y - ~- .~+.~+ ..~.e ~~ vc.cd~ .war.w.~YUe.(meuLSn_ Ir P,u,nituv ~._Yld--[ ~ ~u6iea-i -L-eLIJ'~ uJ .ha Li ~_io i II .. ,.- - _x-~.. ' n_ _ . n ° wuWL . woal _ ~olle~~in and _o n re se~_ _r Quazi_ Co _ ,~ Uv~i~e me with.. ° JUL(,~e.-- -be~1~ _GC11,f~~. a s his Ctory y be ~_al or_ _ss_~- _ ~ --aa~- _~-o r- ~ an_ _ t i i m~/--~ ~:ra c t _-a-b~r-e_e_m en t 0 r -- __. _ .. -- ~ ---- a i-~e_ en_ .~o~'____~e_ ~I-_ rep r se, Dad i d l,uti~ -~{~ e I au- _ _i_ _I _ ~ier~eb ._eAtc[~_ a ~ ~ ~ ` .order-To~Re~re~en~ Pi0.in V , :o believe that ~ presentation tat ~I r~,sults to m~e o f m~n~t amo un~ ~or me ~m -ensatioh ~ ~ all. :es' _he- a .rte _to _re-p- - -ec~n a yy c~ ares~en~ ~ i on_ t_d me ~f_rm of An ino and its ~ua~ i Ctrhfrat-t Qua~I GOnt~a~t ion _~o b~_ ro~1i_t~ed o Anc}ioa~Rou~ee -~~_thi~'- >`lation For -- _ _ 1, _T a C r c __ ~ oL-~L - -es~n _ _ _'on ro - e - __ ~ p 0 oU e i ` ~- __ e - e - -r . ___ ~ ~ r p _ `_ _.-QC__ _ _L__ _ U1L~ C `0 _ ---~ ---~~'-C~. _e ~~-- -~- ---QUO' ~.a C `0 I CO. _ ' U ' S G6 C 0 W w~ `+r` ~ i- ~u _Q ---~Qn- c ~~ - - - - ~-- s9 q~ Th~~or_~i~t a Se ~~tion- ut_ ~i~~s he__cantr ~t__a _r~e~rn-en~_ or ce re- ~~~~ ccS_e~tlem-e~ ~~ cc ` >> an ~~__ ~_n.__ oo- ~ ~~t_~h~ _1rd -m e ~a _~rm o _~An ~n~_~ RoUn~~ an~_ Dadi f f 9 t er_vert~l_ ~~ ria~~~ b_~~e_u_-~ that_ the law. d Lutz would b~ .. ~. ~-~ ~~~o:-~....,~,..r~,wauze~-.~ ,~.,~wi:,.. ~o.+ac.ulrxa~mw~ ~..,l uu~.~,.xr, ,i.~u..~..u~u<c.~~, i i.a .,., _... .E~... _ ___ _ _ Pa~~ 3 flro u i~ i r~ o n e 1; t h 1 iA ~-~°-~n~ p i a i n Court ; n n T_W..~ _fl 1~1 111 ~~ S~cce.~"SS~u_I lrecou~ amoun_s .~th~t ar~_ I~ut~ ha,~ ormu_I_r~ to ~h.~s N o _ :®ra~J_e__ 1e,t~er- fi.o ~aUid 1, ~..Co~r o 1V~nu~~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ian~' un S u 'm i e - ''~dl I s s ~_ Q - _ PL. 9_ ' misren r e er g _ _tin _ . hr~rc -- ~~11_...~_r~e e~ - _o-F._ le,~n g,~. tine Ie.~l~e~'._Lha~_L _haU_e_serl_~ 0n l~ou~ ~J~os sus---~l~~i~' -h_e T1o~i_Qn For__~sc~e.~ TQ__ e~ce.s~ s ect. uI( .-ask_the _N_onora~l~. ~~eas~ re.~.~ t~_o~i_ uery__im~o_c~ ~h~~l, t}~er_ein -I- -}~_o.v_~ ~toL~e~ 1'10dej-_R~~eya ~3a~t tee ~ha h5 p`cc~1- ~ I -_~ ~c~._~,~~ct~.--~ _~o~~r_c~c~e~_~ot wig `~~r_om- ---~Lm-~ _An~us~~o--~~--~~ -~r~--9-_ ~m.~s_~~r~s~a~a~i~n_ ~i h~t_is in_4ccot~danc~ to the ~__i-~- ~~~__Com_~laint that Qavl~ i f~q_~e~~ l'e-~resente~ an~ submitted i ice_c__ ~ ,d ~. o` f O `oI+ n ~.. ~ r` .n v~ n J1 T.. b_ree'ch o~~'strict liu- u ` A copyy o~ ~~- -ent~Ced with this ~:.o ~r.~ __a_u_ e Quid p to at_ lette ~o pavid I.u~z ~.-Da~li ~,utz AB_A cc r1i.sce~rc~rc_n~tions may e~~._~c~~a. ~c~-~.~re to ~co sent_Q~~on hat .I haue layi_~ _Lutz ~ _th~ law -~e~am~' _ ~ n -u-n,lqu~~u-I ice, fi~~_ law_ farm Q~ ~n i_a_o_ ~v~~r ailed `~o_- -r_o_ui~e me__with_ 1~~~I r_~- re~entgtiol1 in_oUrt~on _ oVo ~3~~ogs, .~-. -~-._ .. ~ -f. u.. LLdi.c.lv.i .LiYli@~Y~ ~. ~ II. AM1¢z e C - - ...... strip lia slit s' o all o~ e_attoucrl at are _ un~er the .~ir~cti_ a t e ro_~rietor y~uties~re- spp.nsib_Ie I~abil_-tys ~._ fthe. law _ i_rtp y ro rieto-~s, .There-~~~~ _the -st/ric~~ lia:,b_Ilty ~_r,_~_roupio~~n me with ru ~t~l ~ r_Q . e_ss_L~ na--re~_res¢ n~cat_i_~-n o - this _C~o_m- _ _lai.n-t- .s_~i-___tfh~t_Q_~u_i.~----l.ut~__ha_~__re _refsen~e~k -'uu~.ned - n~__s+~m_it~~~ _ta this _Na~t.Qr_a~l_~. _c~~urt was.acsc~pte~ ~ ~waS n_~ertaken .b the. 1aW ~irm o An ino~' ---R~ne~'.--~ ---~_a~tid--_~~t~ ~ursua t to ~hc s~i II le_ _c~ll_y__~,_in_~in~q_Q..-s°_-.Co_nt~ac~__.__or 1egal_ re,p_resPnt- ~t~o.n_!tha~ -_~a~?~r~ _l_.~t~Z __hi_as .s-i_q~~.-~~-_o~_ ercd~ to me as an a~tin_ __a .e~t_an-~ re re~,rer~titive o~ the lain irm_o __Rn ~-n~4Rovn_er~_~h_p ~'econ~,e~i__i~n c Ballcat_ .f ~ i`nes .l,a __R_~~ __iongc_ _~~.__~r~sc~ .breach o_ - _contr~et to 6e G _ Th.~ . _~i_.~ ur_e~--q ~'___ ~.__~_~ __to- . a__c~Qq bra c~ _ to co m I_y u~ i t~i -th~ _~~ _which!_ huh _r~ssume~- h -- -e-abli a~idn o ~. o the. corr~rac~~..o-r___the _doi~q-Q- -_SOm.e~Ch~n_ ~nc~bns~st~ t with its_exa_ste~ce. _may b~~-_~re_ate_~- us_~ breach __th_er-eo_ '~_T_h~r_,e.._or_~~a-~lrec~h---~ _-~u-~ to _re~resent me _ _~n ~=our-_-ia__ r~ ~ _a r~_ -J_~ ~e_---1~as__b~r.r~- comm~tttcQ a_ ~i~1st me~¢I,_ __ _a~~Iin_ t.o_~!ct resent _m_ ~,est interests Court to_ya__~ucc~ss -u-I_co_n_c~usiorY,~until an qcc- epta~)-e_ 0.m_o~t_ _ -r- -,~s_~_ _c~~ e_ _c_o m-,p--c_~a sat i o rl t~ m ~. has -he~en_ob-~~ined~r~e-~o~~r~d~ c~nse_ue'~tl I have. been su~- d ~ ~ ~ ~~ e~ssepnuL_co~a~~~ g~~~su1 ~b1e~r~ ~conc~~n.ce~un~ro- _I.I~ Si_~_c-e. L_ _h~ue-_not ----a[ec~ _.D-U~r_~ .~,u_t-~ from ~epre~-ent- ~_n _m~nor__ ham _Dat~~j ~ _I~~tZ__~~~La~'~c~ _~hi.~ Co_r~ fai nt~.~ait -- -Q~L~a_mA :f~,S__~}lt~~--_1~=~_ -~4S_-_pr~.S_eC~~e~--~0-_thi.~_ CoUit to be _I~u ll_-~ U_o_i~~_an~ si-nc~il~i~hrr'_ y_seJ~_-noc_tl~~ _1_a~ _ i r m _o_ _An ~n~- I~o~?ge~' have __decl-ar!ed __our__Q_ua,ci Con~ra~t .-,~...~ _. ~..-..: ~ .~aaeL~.. .t.uev~~s-. lei ~:~t.,-iu su.l r._uYl ....e:. ,~LU.:.d a......~ma.iu".-~. .FLL ~ ..: _. iu.....-' -~.__... a e S r`~ i ~ Vo' u ~ ~ ..e ° e ,. .r ~t a ° e C f _tion ghat I have. b~_en sU~Ject _ to b ~a.Wic( ~.atz Uav~er~ _l.~ z ~ ~a ~ w thd~aw nqq-~`°~-Rovn r ater ° y ~ r1J his o-eprese atio~ o m ~'~ ~ ~ l_a_i_q~ _~~cause. _ the law irm f -~_..~_.}~-p_ ill~`~ 1~.6~_U11f'.r phAf1~__11~ _~ p_CQyi_G~eDI_ _ ~, wtt~ ~~Qt~e~r__A~t_a_u _ __~o_-. u_l_ _~J_I_ ~h_e___I_e aI_ ~~lti-es' any( thc. _I_~ a.~__.__.I_G~~_i_I_i.~ie. _--o- -_-~ar_~_co_r~tra~t__~ _cecment or -aria( r_~~re_5~.nt~~~~n. `t_u~t~_] _a- ~UccesS _~ _recove.r has __~~en_-- m~-~~Qr`~~~i_n_e~__Qn--rrm_ ..b~e~~~ _ ___6_ the law ~~._irm o_ _l~n_ ' ®`~~ovnpr,-. ule~ st t '° I n_~w a~?e. ~ .c~tt ~rn~s that rare ~_ ai11~~_m__~_g ~qn _y Green n~ Jae_~e ine C~ssi~~c~ll- tu h-^-----A.~r1 _~1Qw---v~1_t~~u~-yAr1 l~. ~~ 3'e~reS_C-1~utiDYly --~~c~u~ e I _~c~u~_ ~esQ_me._ ~~sc~~~ua.~_ta_ er~_due t~, the- -~_reec__ Q___can.t~ ~-~ ~-~a~_t~ thz_ ~r_e~~h c ~~~ to r3vi~~ _~~. +s~_i-t~__~~ _r~~_K'e, res~.Cita'~io_r1+ I~., ABA Rule. ids Dilia~ne~ ()states that the renresent- rT.,~P~ GG 1"\IPhI IA}1fln Tortlninn~.iAV1' (1 f ~hr rpnrP.C'cil~n~illll _ _ -~_ of _ _i' _i~~~_~__. ~t___ ` i e e Qc ur~e era '~Si_4ce Duv i '' - ~ -~t __-h-as gi_ - - --~o-_ cQ_n t_i_n_u e to__a~t a s m- _a tto urn o~- As._.h ~_ o_r th_c,_ _ 1-.aw_-- iron-_o A_n. _%n o ~- R ~ u n er ~ c o - vi~e~-me _~?i_tI~_a ~~ _I~~em~ntf-atts~urn _ ~sin~e Da~ial p l_~nt~.-_- ~i_Ied_~o_ ~c~_-a _~er Y _-d i_r_ecte~. ~~i m ~~ o I(ow a \ \ ~ ° ° throe ~ w ~th_-_h~s re~r~s_entotion o~ this com~la~n ~n 9 MW Irh ~`tnf'v c~ G4 ~ Qn~ a l C ~!h_~-a'_~Ore- en~ioned C_o~QS4 ~Ules o Pro ess- I~~~~_I~~e ~_e ~n m_i,s're~l-r_e.se nte~ ~~r ~ r~eche~ al~_~_ ou ~_~,~~,-ut? has -under~_akcn _~1~e sworn oath A_ ~-Pled __o=_ o ess~onali.rm w{~ic}~ is ~~I wrll honor ~r f ~ ~~~ rtdt ,n er~~ as-_we_IL_as ~h~_ r_~juiremen~s o - ___~h_ a ' c~ ~ _ o_ C~ ~_e o ~ ro _ _e'~ ' . Co ct~~ zonal n~~, --~.n.dw~lC__ ve_-mF~tters~ e~-~d~~~ous'I and -~u_~th_o~~_-unn_e_e~,~-o,~yy .~.~- .e_''rr~~se~~},~wever~ hose ~. --~le __~ _~u~0rn__~a~h al_ere n_ot _com_~ l i ed __uu%~~i~' __Z_r~t~~_q_e~.___p_q_vad_ l,u~z _an~ the lay _ f ir~_o _1~n '~o_~ ~QVn~e~ ~o represent my best j__nt~e~~ _-- -~ ~~~ _ ~ i rec~iu_e.so '' ~~I,__A_I~in__c~e~_r~r~~s' to _the _m i~`re~resentation and breech n_.~ d~- _th~~_~~~~ _~~~~- su~Je~te~ ~o ~y ~h dis- -~ _n_~i~e~~.._ _~.~ar_esent-anon d~Q to the wit~~- dr~wip4-~--~=r~e_r~~in4----m_e_1s ~}~e ~~ct _t hat ~ -- - )S, T~iere~ar~ _in_1_' ht of all o the a oremen~ione~ act, 111er~eb :_~~~ ~]l _Q~k ~~s _Non~rable Court ~~ ~, _~ith_er_o ___~ ~_1-~? ~_rm o _ Anqq~no~ Rouser to ~rov~de me_ws~ ___c~a_o ~tt~_ucn --__rom~_-~hqt _1uw_ _ i_rm ~o c-o-~a~-in~_t1-~_caa_tr~~t~~ ~ ~s~n~ati~n5 whi~h -z ~nns~ r_e_ _~g~_Qt_L_~aS~_ Af _an _Q_r~eG'__To Co~inu,e~Resume ~~_es~n~~i~l.~__~~e _.s~n ~ _b.~_ this. _ ]~ o n u ra b 1 ~ -Court t o __1~a~i~u~w o~e_t~_~lo_~~on_~Ar ~ha~ getion is hereby -.. -~6~ oCo - -inai~e.~ _a- )otter- tQ_ _p_qui~ i,utz a0 ~ ,l C0U-~/_ -0~ MV- ~-et~Cr ~0 MG I.U~2. 0.-~ 0 Ott- _h unethic in__orme 1? al_I ~~ t~ -_rea ~t ~_m. a_n~ w _l_ut~ hired. see n~t ~ c ar n~ ' __been_ u~ordi -~ h~__c 6~-~ ~~ _S L a L e_~ _ I U_p- -_.LJl ~ _- _L _~.~ r_e u ~ r-e~ t_~_ bili~_.~~_as _~h~_1e 11~_.~C _a1_sQ__s_~a~e~.- mai_I_e_~_~~_.ha m can ,mss Tonal ~on~-u_ct¢~i_n re Reds ~o his u ~ __('epr~.sentat ions._Z a~so pace a ain h~1is_~rofessiona~ IiQ~i~itie.r anuN ~h_ich h~_-hc~s ailed to u_ hold and r~_~sk~___~~v.d_~l,_~t~z _c~ .ues~ionr i_n my __a__an__~__~rmed__h_%m_ `~h_at z u~ante~l in.a'~__I_nt~e~_ro__atari~S~7 and. once aqain -t'e9.u~sts ~r in~oringtifln ~er~ a~~_ _~n.~_i_~ -_e_~en~e~ by no_ r~rponse, or ~_as__.._th_~a~n~_ ~n_d-~ f fecenc~ thAt rlra ~~ to_ thr hoot. the t`-me. a ter .L hid 1a~_ firm Nn ino~Rovner ~o re~re- er.ests_-b_ __ac~;_n uPor- my direc~iUes .~q-.__~hi~_-_~Qm~I_a_ _uati_Il b _success ul o~er__ _-. f-Qr_ ~ uSt__du~. c_o~~er~satiQfl 11as ____~at.~.r__act,Qn~ ~rsu~nt_to thy, ~~ual ___(~~asi ~on~ract~ and_ pursuant tp yy _am~~nts_that ~avi~ Lutz has bm~1 `_n~._~hat h~_ ha~s_--si qec~ w11i~h h~ q-a~~ut __to_ Cepreseot,_ `'t_p _~.au~__l_.u~z _in_ ghat letter ghat I. _r'om _~e_ _re~~nzin _.me b~ ore- __QU IYa~~ re r h entec~ ~-e ~_~ou-r_~`~e_ ors ~~_~~_rea~he~_ a~set~l~ment _ c~_ r~~ment_wh_~h__e_s_f~~c~ ~1~1~__ta__m_~~the.n I ~nnt to _ h~-u~ _c~r~~t~~r _&~-R_ _C.An ir~_R_oun~r~~ttorn~_yy_ represent m~.'S _.D_h_c~,__a_ _ain__ ~r__I-__~~t-~___that~_r__wc~~___subjected to de- 1_i~t_err~~_i_.n_~f_ec~nc~.L - __ __ _ _ ~_~,_I._a~~i ~~ ova lty _ w cote__i t_ ~h_~t _ l~.tter t ~1e~~ Lut~z~ c6I n my_ 1`~arch__iS~~o2 _i~e~t_e_r to_ you S wr_ote~c~I~ firs Greeyt _ueic,c a ur -l iti q~' ~' -h e ~r~e~~e~% - h_i-m i ,~ to 'the w.o~ t}~e i_a~ - o~ m~~ ~i r~_c~ --~ ~est__~~teres~ eSS"i-o, a1 CQ escnt~t~or1 $r _ Co n~ractk_ - ___ _- -_~Oo Re.ferrin- _-- -o-eA.ues~ o~_ ~iYI_ b_e_ ~~n_~i - _Co~n~ai~ ~~- _ ~o a~~ear __-_n_- -o n--~J-un~-_w~,_o~ ~~~_res~rl.~- ~~s~ A-~ A ~-ied io ir~L~_a~iaLe_ any in Court h- ce~ul~ed i-n cogtinued mis- 1/Io~el ~iul~ w, 1- }3J`-` ~i.rrepre- -__ a~lur_~. to ~ct,_ w~«h .was _~i~~ ___cdn~-a _~r_eech- o~' pro- 'y _ --_ - i n~~-rmer~ _-Dauid__l~ut_z- ghat 1 w~nte~ m best int~rrs~~y,Lr Cour~°~durin a~~~,f' _}1~G__~'l n_eo~ the C'~uazi Contruc~ I_e.~__m~~~._.~1'1~~~--_~ha~- h,c would _truly ~_._i_nter~s~s ~.r1,-_~our~°~a~ Tria( dine ~~_e.._-~~ntrae~ Or r_el~rese,Ylta~ion from Anyino~j~oUne~he.-continued ~o f;~ail to ar` s or Trim r~prese_nta~lon ia__r__ a~c~_ ~o _~-~pr_~..rentation o. mY h i_c b ~U1t ~ ~~ u n.~~t~ i ca_I ~-un r_ o is _misr~~rsentati_Qn,r~Br~eech m gyp- ~~_ _~-d~ciary -d~ty~and Hr~ec~j o ' --- __ - - 1~ 1~~~~rsu~nt to m ~~oC1 b_ ~-court- Ord ~~ To I~~eCld_ 1+ndRepreseat ~hi~h_ w1_IL re~uir~ him ~ l~o_nargbl_~ Ju~_ge ~r_uido ~his__~lotion_ For _~J_r_der T,o _ _ __ - - - - -- s~.~m~tt~ .~`~/' t~~_Pl~inti~ __- ___I'1r,-_ DPI-~_ W i n`~e~ m'e~l~' - __-..-...-._.....~..~.~ +LOO, a ~,;,ww ..cnaWn -„sv,vm uzllL.lo+~~.~s.~.ewv... ~~n:.~-~a ,+ ~_..:.:a ...~t ~i _...~-. - ,. __ I _- _ . _ _. _ _ _ __. -- :~ ~_ er - ., . ,, ~, i - ~ n ~~~, _.. _ _ «,_ r 'v _`77 I ~_ ~~ , . - - ra =i7 i _ _ . __ _,_ - _ I _ .,.,~.___ ___ _. .. __ ' ~ i it _ .. ... _ .. _.... ...._ __ _ _. _ _ _.~_ ert ~xh~b~t ~ •rn, r"vice For h$' Ryobi ~'--761.1677 RACTORS- 419CE W' Lebanon -600363-2767 ~r LLP 445.4541 921-2319 Imt 249.5338 "^ " 243-2686 Irvlce 432.5506 'tl Cadlsle-249-7633 896.3414 1fQ--545.2051 Sttarllsle-249-2505 362-6501 NC. 4KOwn-867.5761 +ecsdDr9 Page Ilne Repair lRtl Etters -938.64fi3 N SERVICE INC VER ~~o~' R~r~ IP uwsslmwn,rsc. & Models • Blade Sharpening Trimmers-Snowblowers-Chainsaw Delivery Available Jscepe Maintenance Tanbark rnla C41zen Discounts 4!g Rtl Mechanlaburg -.761.7975 MowerServlce 'av DI95b W 9------ 432-0932 14 Rd HaniSbUrg " --800 469-4663 f SYc dmrg Mltltlletown----•944-9639 pment Maintenance Rtl Dlllsburg-----------432-4374 IOP THE YFJlOW BOOK WAY. LAWN-LAWYERS 407 1 C Cobb Small Engine Repair 500 stoner or Mlddlerown--• 944-1197 Lawn Ornaments SEE Garden Centers Lawn & Garden Equip & Supplies " Statuary Lawn Spraying SEE Lawn Maintenance Weed Control Service Lawn Sprinklers a& Sprinkling Systems SEE Irrigation 9yatema & Equip Sprinklers-Gazden & Lawn Lawyer-Bar Associations 5EE Lawyers' Referral & Infarmaton Service Lawyer Referral Service SEE Lawyers' Referral & Information Service A MarkWlnter 310 W Chocolate Ave Hershey------ 533-4Hfi6, Abom John A B SOUth Hanover St Canisle --249.0900 10fi Walnut 5t Harnsburg-•-----232-9511 ABOM & KUTULRKIS---I JOHN A. ABOM (FORMER CUMBERLAND COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEI~ JASON P. KUTULAKIS (SOLICITOR DAUPHIN COUNTY CHILDREN & YOUTH SERVICES) • CRIMINAL DEFENSE • FAMILY LAW 106 Walnut st Harrisburg--•-----232.95 106 Walnut St Harrisburg-------232-9511 Abom & KutUlaklS Carlisle----------232.9511 Abraham Law Offices 513 N 2 St Harrisburg---------232-1825 AdIBt & Atller 125 Locust St Harrisbum---234-3289 Ahmatl Anser Serving Harrisburg Area---------- 909.4343 AHMAD & MIRIN Serving Harrisburg Area-----------909.4343 gee aw grgPrgyaaagge ug Ahrens Thomas 1 5521 Carlisle Pke M¢Chanlc5bfg-----697.1800 Alexantler Jane M 148SBaltimore Dlllsburg --•-432-4514 Allen Heath L 210 Walnut St Harrisburg•-- 255.6011 Allen PBUI 4700 Union Deposit Rtl suite 2fi0 HarrlSbufg-----------------•651.0771 Alzamora John A 212 LOCUST ST Harrisburg------- 255•M33 Anderson"Davitl C 3940 Locust Ln Narcisburg---•---541-1194 Anderson Janice L 7105 Silver Pox Ct Hummel5town------566-0100 Andes SamU61 L 525 N 12 St Lemoyne----761-5361 Andrew W Barbfn PC 123 State st Harrisburg--------•--------232-9200 Andrew's & Johnson 78 W Pomfret St Carlisle-----••-----243.0123 Andring Wllllam H 234 North North St Harrisburg------234.4728 CONTINUED NEXT COLUMN LAWYERS continuetl ANCINO & ROVNER SERVING CENTRAIi`1~A , FOR OVER 70 YEARS Recognized Best Lawyers In America 3ar Register Of Preemineed Lawyers Million Dollar Advocates Forum AUTOMOBILE ACCIDENTS MEDICAL MALPRACTICE WORKPLACE INJURIES PERSONAL INJURIES FREE CONSULTATIONS No RecovervMo Fee 238-6791 (800) 648-2070 www.angi no-rovneccom 4503 NORTH FRONT ST. HARRISBURG, PA 17110 Annex Carolyn M 1300 Linglestown Rd Harrisburg----238.2000 Anstine Timothy M 100 Pine St. Harrisburg---------- 221.1111 AplceNl Samuel W 305 Front St N Harrisburg-----•-------- 237-5516 Archer Thomas A Harrisburg-----•- 233-6676 Armstrong Patrltla Z12 Locust St Harcisburg------255-7627 ArOSell Sarah W 305 N Front St Harrisburg-255.7231 ArtZ Charles I & Associates 207 State St Harnsburg---------------238.9905 ASChinger JHCk F 212 Locust Bt Harclsburg- 255-7609 ASmUS Daniel G 212 Locust St Harclsbur9- 255.7624 CONTINUED NEXT PAGE FIND IT HERE FIRST --FAST. 2001 N North FfOnt St HarclSburg-232.1886 Angelos Peter C 2001 N Front St Harrisbum----232.1866 x ,~ i U I ~ ~ POWER OF ATTORNEY AND FEE AGREEMENT BY SIGNING THIS AGREEMENT, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I (WE) HAVE ENGAGED THE LAW FIRM OF ANGINO & ROVNER P.C. (HEREINAFTER A & R), TO REPRESENT ME (US) UNDER THE FOLLOW ING TERMS AND CONDITIONS: A & R may on my (our) behalf secure medical, work and other similar records, conduct an investigation, negotiate, and if necessary start suit against anyone responsible for my (our) injuries and .losses with respect to rl/IG~(GyGle ~CC~Q~I~- '1- IN-nL, with full power and authority to ::appear on behalf of the undersigned in any Court of record or in any administrative or other proceeding, to do and perform all and every act and thing whatsoever that may be requisite and necessary to be done in connection with the above claim as fully as the undersigned might or could do if personally present; hereby ratifying and confirming all that said attorneys shall lawfully do or cause to be done therein by virtue of this power of attorney. D ~~ ~D~ 2. I (we) understand that so long as the case is handled by an A & R attorney, I (we) will not be responsible for any fees andlor expenses unless a recovery or benefit is obtained. 3. If my (our) case is handled to a successful completion by an A & R attorney, I (we) agree to pay A & R all reasonable out-of-pocket expenses without the payment of interest, plus a fee for time expended as follows: ' A & R ME (US) a. SETTLEMENT PRIOR TO STARTING SUIT 30% 7O% b. SETTLEMENT FOLLOWING SUIT BUT PRIOR TO TRIAL OR ARBITRATION 35% 65% C. SETTLEMENT OR VERDICT AT TRIAL OR ARBITRATION, AFTER TRIAL, ARBITRATION, OR APPEALS OR SHORTLY BEFORE TRIAL AND AFTER CASE HAS BEEN TOTALLY PREPARED 40/0 60% 9 d. IF NO-FAULT RECOVERY OR NON-MONETARY BENEFIT: RICHARD C. ANGINO ($500); NEIL J. ROVNER ($450); ASSOCIATES ($400) PER HOUR BUT NOT TO EXCEED 4O% OF TOTAL RECOVERY OF VALUE OF BENEFIT e. OTHER CASES 4. If for any reason I (we) take my (our) case to another attorney or law firm including a former A & R attorney or handle-it myself (ourselves), I (we) recognize that A & R has, imgood faith, expended money and time for my (our) benefit and I (we) therefore agree to pay, or have my (our) new attorney pay, immediately, upon severing the A & R attorney/client relationship, all the out-of-pocket expenses incurred on my (our) case plus interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of each expenditure. In addition, when the case is successfully concluded, I(we) agree to pay or to direct my (our) new aiiorney io pay as a ~c 20°'0 ofthc gross recover; to P. & R. 5. In the event that any settlement is made on a structured or deferred payment basis, A & R shall be entitled to receive their percentage based on the present value of the structured settlement, if paid as a lump sum at the time o1 settlement. ,I (we) agree not to settle or discuss settlement of my (our) case without the written consent of A & R. BY SIGNING THIS AGREEMENT, THIS _ °~ DAY OF 20_, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I (WE) HAVE READ, UNDERSTOOD, AND RECEIVED A COPY OF SAME AND?:GREE TH ITS TERMS AND CONDITIONS. WITNES ES CLIENT(S): ~ Mfi~ ~r ~I11~f(~m~I/C'r (SEAL) (S~) (OVER) svlua voo Y ~X I~iit ~~ ,. t .r €~~~ __`~~ut _.~J ~, rya ch o-~ c S I d _.- - _ - - _ I_e ~ 1I _ -~_i~b1~, - ~o _ ~~~h~1~ _ r_e~r~. ~n~ ~h~ c_om~ ~i-~t _~n G _Ju_r' ~ ~~e Gaur`~ _.~. /yau~. s_i_ .h_a~~r. SUE .. I.e. r ~C~~. .~. .~ o.. c pro-~es~'~©nal -mi,~c_~n~u ~, ~r~ . nrnr`~.irP .C~ai~.r i~-{~~r~, wa6'ran'~ id-~r_~s even i`a~''~'~inc~ _I'_v. l10n 0~1'.~o~rn- _ d t~~ion _o_~_the ion i~_lh__c~ .you Sub-mi~te~ ', d a u--- L'_ _ ..~_-_---.___.._...----- FU. D. VPmterone_ e~- Fxh~b~t '~ dear ~'[r~ ~,utz A prP ~ ~~g~Do ,~ ~~arted __y Qct., _L~ Rl _l~ttcr to _ o~ __ U 4 ~cc a n00f1~A ~ b_ _ ~vs~i~_~i~ _ ~~~'t~rd~- - ~t ~ ~a~~ ~ _a~~~~~~d .~~ r~_~.la a.~ . o r _ y a±~r ` ~ c_~r ~-~rt~ _tb_ _ _~-~.D,~e ~~~`~ T ~ua~r not ~~le. to__c~o. _5'~~c.e__r~,~th~r o ' _yra:~e ~v~rc~_a~re~Ia~l;~&_Nllthpu I~ S. u~c~s~_~ol t}~at: I caul:d -~~av!e__a_m~,rsa ~. on_ . _aur voi ~~_ ~_a1 _~~' _ch_u.~~ ~t~t ta__ d~ -~~o b_e._caus~ ~~ br.l~~u~ ~h~t it_ rs ~.~s~ `~o_ balk"~v__a__~~er~so~cr~'~nal~~ _una_th~t_w°~~tten carr~s~Qn~ance_~s -~h~_ht~_~__~a to S~S~ants~~a~e _my o i~t_ionS.,~L al_s.o _~-rote~ccYau-- m~ _ _a~v%c.e ~r~c~rt Youn~_ ~~ha`t ~_i l~ ~cc~pt._a__~a~~nent of_ ~-I ~~5 .~~r -th~.~am~gqr~.r. ~o m~ mo~o~cyycl~e~ and_ that _I_~i+l~ _a~s~ k~e~ _rn~. rrAp~tar- c y_.cle~ I_dl~~_v~ro`~_~~ .I~ ~rwo~~_~ount_u~~ll_r~o~ concede, ~~b -m __ e.~~eror~~, o ~-_~rr ~- ~.~'e~~~IIl~_s_ ~am~a_ ~e~r _cl~im... ~t::..~. ~~ upl I~In , ~0 (_A_CCCp~~:~n~n _i_ ~t_~~_ ~ .. d o~ ~C altern~t~~~`~ri~'r_ ~Q _a_. .Dort A~ ~on,I~~ o~nt caC]_ lo_c~t~. ~~nQt ~c~__1_a ~3_ an~a ~ha~ a , ha°t_ ~oo~s ~s_...oo_ _ _as _n~ ~n~___~d ~_ b ~ are t h ~ ~,ent_ _o ~.c_u-'r~ tern ._T _u~~ ~I r~.cc~ ~~Qnothet ~o ~ q ~3 N_®_~ S~:ac~o~_-~us~a_~tt -~5_~c~_ tb~-a~ ~~t~._ r_hay~_i~nc_Iase~ ~_coa~_o-~_th~ seat ~~ cc ~er_onc. ~r~an . ~ ur7sac ~' ~S. acc- ~. ,6 _. ._..._.. _ i ~ ~ _t ~ ~. `~ _io~ ~~ .c ~~.unc~.-b --your ~`t~-w ~al_ ~ d 6 3_ ~ ~ ~_t,G_ ~ ~_~Pi e :t~11e ~t~t~1 ~. ~~~t~ ~ represe~~a~~an 1u~ic .i_S_~,~ _~.._ 0.~~4~,~d ~~Cou ~~ aft%_~ a_J~gcce~',~~ ul C_~_co~_~r . ~S i~a~~~_u~_>i_cl~ i~'_-~cC~~tei-b_~~ '~o ~~anc~_ U9~1 c~ .~ havt_uq.['.'~~~_'~4 .~U ,__'_0_td_~ "(1'f ~C71-1_ e_~q~f'_r~_Q.Yi ou~_ ~vr_i.~cn_.r~n~k_r~~.r~?a~..r~~~~en~aotls ~_d ~or~fi- c~~_n.c_e in s Q~. that_ you _ ~auld _b ~ _~'~pre~,ent.i.n m,~. -.n m ~~s~.r~n~~er~ ~s._~ - li~`ti, akin .~m~ mo$o~~c~~e dam- y Y 9 ~ ,. s ~q~~ Clc~~~t -n .Court~as au r~pr~:rente~ tp m~ on up t I ~ ~ a~ur_m~e - t.-~ rn ~~, ~~~~h-c11 ~~tf r~pr esea~e~ to ~~i ~ ~~c as a ar-~h~ r~p~r~ti~-,_ Ar Court ~-th ~r< Gr~c~nc ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ s_ ou_ a~i .. -S ~. res~n s .S r~ c s o n;e -c ~ ° ' C ~__ C~ ~: _d'0~- S` r ec ~ Dn ra t ~ an .a~torne __ o S u ~t c ei ocs' 'v~ r_~~i e_ _is e ` i ra -` °.e co c _ _ r . s,e a °~ h s '' ~c ~r n_ ..i ~i c o Q. _ °J' c U2 a~_i c ~ ~ -nun a _ i 6` 0 r. I c ° C'0 ° C _Z have ~o~ ~i$.~ ' `~s ~ . yob qn uv_ h~u~ a qoa ai th a r~e~- ~.~~~ ~ i c1~4 ~ ~x~ ~cte~ _o~ tau ° of ~ i th ec `u r '~ ~~_~~_~ _~.~d~r~ ~_a lia,n _t~r_au h i t ~ ° ~ya r v~~: a~ an ~r~tt~~ re~r o•~en~at~on,s~ u 'dui: Uu _ ro re. r~ n b~. ~ a v~ a 1 As yyob kno~~~hen an .attorney .~in~~ nit' aba~t another ~t~brn;,e s r~~,s~e.pres~ntu~i~~lor ~anethi~al con~uctth~. attorn~ is r~eq airr~ tp r~~ort the at~orne to t~e far +~+ h' s comr~itte~ acts o _ unethi ca[ con~ucta Tie. Sams ~epoctab4i Iit r~spons~b;-l'i~ ._a~ples to the ot~er_I~o~a1 .~~~s ~a~ ~~ I~r~? ~i~~~Con~se ~~ntl ~i.f ~ ~m._~~sa~vanta c~ byy an .ine ,ectiu~ ~co~n~el and ~. haaft. ~b o~t~~ anbt~ter_ I_a~ ~r due to a u-ran fu[ reta l-{at,or w - th~rau~ th_~ n~~u la!~ er would b e.9 r~ t~ihe~:t~P report the acts and m~ L~oc~m~entec~ ..acts to ~tlte. far ssa° N_a d s a qreed to accept thy. o ~r that au ha~_ rc:rentc~ me' ~i`~h dur~n our las~ ~ ~ ~ ~°~) _ _ Fc.b~ m..~~tn ~L.~Q~I~. have S°i n_e~ a ,Settl~.me~~ ~ _r_~eem~-n_~ nu~_L _~_~~ rtot ~~~~__Qn~a_~ haue ~ntl~se~;--~. c_o~_ .~_ an :-a"~-tprr~e~S-r~uti_es ~~~_I-i.~~~Ii~__,c which shay th- --m -s-u_~_ ar- co-nee---~_~~_q.l ~o~c~:~a _e_J,~' unr~_cQ_ver~c~ _ dr~o:n_e~~t~i~epre:s_~tatoll B_r__~ecl~__o~ _Cant~~ct~_~tee~h_ o __ _ _Dut_y~/,~-~r~~-=t~~e--~_~~qq~L~.-~~~ ~at_L_ma __hdUe, to_un_~e~'ta~e_ ill _g~`:~~~'_ t®_ .s~~_a`h ri_tf±e_ . rc~ti_U~_gtta~n_e f°_L have m. _ ~~i ,`r~a_I_ ° ''~~a lette~'~_an~ m~- ro`ro_~~__a ,~n__.docur~_~i~~at~lunt 0n ~~~°° a f~e~-_. n~oh >{p~~I-_the _l0t ~__~~~~~.Cle_~_.~~ur- ~h~ne_ca1_la_Dnce _. ;a .a~~I ~u_a~s to.l~ ut Qu:~~re nat t_n~anr~.th~t yna u~ould _, , ~:n t ~~ ~~ o~ ~hur.r{ a.r_.~r_~~~t erR_~Ihen ~ +XS`~C~ec~_Voulr hone ~'e~e. ~ioilis~ i_ _ she _uia~al~..take--c~ -~~essQ e1 ~_or ;~-o~_ she _~ick_I hi_t~the voic_e_rrrail r~cordin _ a~ai~ ~a _ask~ tc~e~6~~eco.rc~t6~~'_]~ al _i~~ f~r~u~iu~ Ana .~ ~, - ant C-c~_u~_t1 ~n~ ansu~ ~,~ap1~ _ Mach~_nc to '~~~~ ~se~t ~e. ~brcc~u,~~_tht ~c_~ i n~ f ~CNiU~ _anc~ the ~uil_ to ~ra~id~e. h1~.._uu~.~_~_~}~_~ ~_n__~_~'tC~a~iDn__.tha~ ~.__warfi~ ~o;ob~ain° Since, t~er~ ar_e__I_~l att~rn~ _s at__A~~_ _m_ ca_Il_shou.l~ b~ imm- _~~~atl ._t~ans-~-~r~ed ~ta c~n~th~e~ a. t~rn~y and....a _~'~a e ~ Q+~ -Dct° _,ifl~~_out~.r~n~. o~~~n~~,~u~ se~~~-=td~~. In~~~'ro~ator_i~s ~~z_be ~ ctcd me to ~'eturrl them to ~~u w ~th~_t~ _one ~~eck_ ~vhich._z___c~m -l`,~~_ ~u~ th.A-ter Mary Garae`~~r __~~/_~e_d ~h:emm~sh.e_...S~n~__rn.c a co~_ n her_`k'f _~ed vcrsioYl_ aer~ a_..co~y..ul_~S sent ~0 _~an~yy~r ena thC~e ~IeC'e 5~_~a9es_o _ ~ar~s t~yfed version that u~e~e_..not _. c0~'r~ct. as I_~a~ .submi_~tE~_.~h~mKQ-~ prim.ar i.mport- o ° a ~ ° an.ce wqs ~ tcm SS -~, Sac_~al SecurA~y num~~er,Sin_ce _hav~ i~1 orme~ a~i_i_~ v~ri_tin ~n~ v~rbal~ about- m i hOt ~a?1t.~n to ~au~,-_.my_ _Con._._i_~entiAl_Soc~~~ Securi~~_ i3_ene-f its_ ~urn~~.r-~isclb~~~ o anyyone~I had wri~ten_ _. A ~i~c~a.imt~`_ on .m on ina~ .~nt¢rrogatori~ as I _ ~'~call~~h~ch did r(~t_aea~ ~+~. the. co~~ thdt 1~lar+~ ~~'er~t tP _-n~ a_n_~ t~ -.Nlr G-r~e~1,Sa since.I retain the... r~ _l~t o _ cli~en~ con_ i once c-l ~'~-ave. t~h_e_r.i l '~c c ien`~ con.fir~entaali`Ey~and ~t tG _~a m omrnun i cad ~ ans. can_ve e~ V ~ f an __a cpr~'~c~_._.an_d__~r_o _essi_ n~l__:magn~tj I cor~'~c~c~ G 6 ~ 1`1_ar1~s~ _~r_ror~_~~_rn-c rr~~tl~~~~r~e~xr~te~_informattun. ~_~_~('t_I_I1~Q~~~ m~_le ~~_-r~ ~.~~ k~~ send~D CP~I.?LS__ Q.~_ ~corr~~~ed __~~ `~ ~p l~l~.. ~-r en~all~hd~ h ~ _ _~a ~ ~4t ha~~_had_.~~__~~__~h~t ~_ ~m_ ~o_ri__!r~~~~Znt~rr- o-. a~~ri~_S_~1a~,__b~e~n_t_ peg c~9~r~ct I __r~~r~ hid ~~_ - -_~i_tte.~--them~_5~~ _~~cl~__q__ _~.r_t~. cs~:_°i_o_~lism r~ ui~e m~ ~o' _~ct ~~i c_k_I_ Viand ~n ~lo Est- ~.nter~st~~E ~_ want, _-~o_'-~~clc_~~_-r~ r._ori__~na-I--~_a~o_w _th~e.Int.ert~oua~of~~ ~-h~ ch__$.~s~ab~o ttc_ _t-Q__ __o._u ~hi~cl1 _h~s_ ~ t~mJ~S on,_rt. e , -~_th~r-.~~1__st_ to__rn~ o_.-.._call--~nd__leau~_u.. m~ssa.~~._ 6 ~ 6...._. _~ i l ~n`_ - ~ . ~.SA[I ~_I. L ~. 1-~-...- ~~ .L V; ~C, ~ J ~ ~ 1. U ~l _.. a, ~ w I ~~'_: e,_ro _pri~es are. e 1 .A ~e~'_ 0 _~_ ~~ _s~er~_ m ~vvr .I~t e~_u~hich__S__da. e ~Eea. ~.5,.. ~Q~~ ~-h_rh s'~~l;es ghat.--o~ S~_c~Ce~ my_a~thor«~t~an ` h ` ` ° t.. _ - provided __ ~Q~_ ~ th~ ~~: th~r~~~ ~ ~Qa ~ac~ce~~. _~hat~o er~c .dump ~ _ ~et~l~.~~nt ~~,_~r9~~~~_so _~___~~nt-_y u._a~ I:et~Y.r. on 3rglsloa _~l~~c~!_~i_r~.c~_~e~ ~tou_~o~._~';~-~~~e_._itha~ o~fe_~.,Sinc ,~ , a ~ z_~_~?~~~d__.hav~- aqr~~_ to....accept t_ at _. ~~m~u~1t at our m~e~tin it~_E~eb~ I gm s~ur~_t - ~a~ y-ou _ u~~.uld_h~ve, s_r.c~re~-_~ .~a~lao~ize~_acceptaric,e ~~th_. and ~y_m_Y__~-i~na~~.r~. _on__a :~Sztl:lem~ent A~r~cement.e _ _ ~; ~~ Qua ~n~~rstan~in u~~ our_ i s .~~s ~~'~~ ~x~c~e~ e. ~ ~ _ ~t ~o_ hove r~ept'~,s~rl~ec~_t~. i~~~~~i ~u~a~.~ _cl_a-~r,._ .~ y _ ~ ._ ~~a~ in~~en~sun-_-uo_~__ e~~ire__.__. Sep_t~ _~.5 fool 1e~~er~_~o ~_r%~a Are~un~l~~e tp reac~__~n ami+ :to _th~. ~co~~V'~.Y ~r~mAge c_:~al rx..~ment was _an~ S:til_) _ _ u-ini ~i~zll ~ ctn.cl,_as~ ~/ot~ _ ~a Settl~ my_ m~~~a c_~c(~. Curt `(ou _re~Y'.eSen:~e~ -n_y ~~.~ ..in~~,r.~e~°~s _n leour o~ t _~hicb .~tgtes 6~If ~:e ~.I~ r ~eS-o I Ott i o.rl_ ~u i ~~ _r~~w~ i ~L 9_'_ ,. ._tu f d In~~rVte~ ~_oQl.~~ ~n~ c~~_r~y ~_ou~~ti~L ~.Za~en~~n~ ma~ m~srep_resenta~~ or~~ I ~x_~.e_ct youu to~anc~ I__wa~rlt ~ov~l;Q ~allou~ th.~ough with. ~h~t y~~ have_~~~r~s~~~~e_~ _to rye., L _dorit~ 'rhi~ik that; L _~,m eXp_ect~n .an ~hin~ _uns'easana~le _ ram _ ou _~ ex~~c~in __~p_u__~o _+~~h~1~ ya. i n ~n~ _b~s~,. i_~~et'e~s~~~AS _~ h e _ _ ctiv~l . tare _ 1~ cc~~~, P1t'd_G~e.~rt__wi~l_no- aA~' ur r~._~eSSia~a( d~ti ~S ~anc~ cce~.~_ull``.//_com_pl~te~ recovery aur~._~tt~ti_~e_d you to _do 4 ,~-6 a.J onJ._7hur~'t Nku{. ~' Q I Z ad~r e~se~ _a . letter' t~ yau~,0nce._ o, air ~. ex~luii~~r~ ~-e:~tr~~zl_em c-~__~ot ~e»-`qJ atilt ~o_comm- ~t~_I c~~.e._!~. i ~~t: G. e_~~0_C1..~ o ~`~c~i~__~.n_~9~'~T~ilOq,.~_ Wrote _ ir1__~h~~__.I.~~~e~~~.~ ha.~___c~u11~~ ~o_,t~l~_~o P_~t~ _.on_T~es, c~~°I~. ~u~ ~~e wAS. ~o_ _ ~s k ;her ~o.m.rr .. i no_or1 ~~ ~.~L~va~s__~_e ~~n ~~.~~~__~~ .__ ~(+-yam f~ ry~ et y ~.AI~~_e_~ 1 _ q ~ ~.iQ _~c a_ll~~ ~ Act ~~ ~t_ ~~L~~3~30_ ~9e~a ~a~~e~- ~~i~~~eu~n_. c~,~ ~r~nt desk e ~.__cant__ ~e rtJ'w~rs_ . .~ t .. _ 1 ) ._JS he c'. e s do ! c a s h uii~i ~~tai ~aur re~1.~0 _~n m ut er 1 n letter that I wrote to - out ors A~r~l $_I r~. ~rre~ huc~ t~o my Ma~'~rh ~5 ~OO~~t _Ij~.t_t~~' a.nc~__,L ulrat~ cc~ am also diC~ettin o ~5 ~ ~ ~ y p _r'2.. use ~?_ fACC~ t ~~ Crr,t, ~ G4F~ ve__ u ~ cu _F en~r~_ _~eCr__~hen ~,~ __ ._ asked ~~ a ~.~S~ex~ ted rn ~ e~til6e_to NIr,Green ~ a the _...mann~r. z would~_ I ~ ~~ an answer tomy uest- lon withaat .~c_p~ri~nco_n. the ..went leek u¢ corolm~ni- cation.thc~t .L ~eXp~eC~ertce ~htn__Z_ call. our~~fl ceP I ~}so ~rate,~c~s gri.un__Yoant_ th~.n dtc_ei~ed to snot _ honor,~~s_re.~~tsente~ statement of bean willingq to a~~ __ ~c._ o _m moto~re _cle damn ~s~then e. ~e ~1 ~e ~n~t~~n ~ ~e~~.~repr~sentati~~ fs ca pl~c.ab1~ and p that s~ ~I e a . ~~ narc ~aw~ure,~~ ~r~t.~'_~'ons~e aentl~~ Z belieue ` Arian ~D~~ts h~iSfi'e~lreJ°e~t- ~t~Y1 ~-hich~ Z have inclose a eop~ o~G s am request-. ~n and r.ecommendtn~ that au re art lh~~,s unethical eo~d~trt to th~..~ar~ i n 1 i ~t o he act that Z am only stekin gl~~zs or th~ darn .~ ~~rny nlotoC'c city ~.tt! tJ~~._ oc~ book _vq_~~e~ a_ _ i t an~ not as rhuch as.~the I$ondash~p ~stim~tec~ th~ da ~es to 6ca ~ am veryy wel( aiwt~re a ~ the fact that i~i~ tho. clients de.ci~'ibn o __wl~e~- to settle _ or _~ reasonable. acceptable r~cov~~r amount4,~.fth._ wa din addition 6to s'~udyin ~~~~~~ ~{ ~~~ a:LrQ styudie~ ~~~ _chola w h, ch is a 9 vtr. oo~ asset to have ~ ny m ~i`o~ when others wrd-~'i _think that z am a ~r, ors that they ern take ;aU~~ita e o , Ln rcaArs to what I wrote 9 ~ ' un ~,c~.s,~AY' ~e~ __ _ r0__wCC -1D. __ . ~r 6 .n: /,a ~. ~y~ ~er 0~ F~gf1~ ~_ a~o~it _'~~ m ~si n t~_~ ~~ b o i ,r r urn _.~._~e~ SuI~,S~to me.~T hn~rt. ert~in -- c _`~en~~~~' a ~ lle - ~0~_~ _~ _ co ~~ ~ `. t o m l Q C m _ A [ E a~ h_~c.bpen in~~~e ~,ve in _ m 11 m _ t _ - u. _ a_La _ ~ : u 1_ ~ ._ _~_ 41 a....u. ~, U....__ ~_~ l J d J : a ~.._~e, o~hin _ha~' bye e ._~c `v a e .a_. a~'~'._ac or s t ;_emen ~ ~~li~eve hat the 6AR and ~_ u , _ . ~u ow u_~ ~~ ~ a~ as ~n ro ~ssiona~ G~n~w c~~ e ~ ° m . tine ~ica~ eon-__wc~~_anr~ or u~ ate' b~ _in~ss rac~~ces, e 'y_ a~so b_~el_i~eu th~~t tie a ~r_em~ntiorte~ hin s.u~owl a~ p l tb an _n~orn~. y_ uncQ_o~ a lay _ arm t~u~~~uwl~ -~~ ~~.o_ .c.olltet end °w~ eme_n~ ~+ua~~_~h~`~ ano~Ia~r _ w ec i ~t~ourneyJrria~ o~~ain~a-~~e~ ~l~e ini~~a~ att~_ur~~~_u!~~I~' no~~oll~~+_ throu~~_~ith :thy Coart ~i~- ~t~n..-_ whic~t hLS _ ~~~r~~- ~~,rr~ th~~ attor`n~~ ~o e~~i~~4 o t 0 U ~~, i ~ Q d:~ _ ~e~ _..._tr ~n _ . _r_e~ch co r`rAct r Jul c ~ oc` i maul 1 3 1 b _~.C~J_ L __ L. --- _ Q~ ~`~ S - _~~~m ~~~ scone, s o~tl. ~_~_~r~a~ en~u,q th~roa~ ~o__c~l~em_i~--- _~~t~v~~. _ourtse~ duc. to ~h~ a _w°~ ~ ai rLee i n- )~ ~~~ ~~aS ~l~~ y ~.'~_ ..~.~e..r~_ob~ ~ r1'1 _ ~S~ 111~~~'~s~s :- `~ mo~orc I~ ~~~aa~ ~s.c_Ia_ir~_ ~hi~h :as.~o ~b~_ _ ___ 6 - a_~'S~~~..u-q~__C~~t~,TerLt.~c~alt) e ~otL e ~~~~ - -~-, ~ , b ` s . s" _. C_Q ~ ` ~ o 0 _. iY1. __ S_ .. _ a _ -a- erg, o __C es o_ ~t i ~~ You _arr? wc~i_ in or .Q r~p_l _ ~o ~ our _I~.tters ~_~_-.m~;which_dc~r~ t~atc~~~~~il 4~_and~~~r'iyl_ ~Y~aoo~. A 1 1 f ' ` ~ , _ _ ' . _LY< S ..: A_S _D. L _ ... _L o r_ _ n A U ~ ~ Q~ `s ` QS i ~ 1 ~m a _ ~ _ a ret ~` i cs~ ~e ~ Caur~ I wi ecover w 0 a 0~~ - - -OC ~ _ ~ 3~es ~ r c~~_ G ~een ~~ul ,_~e ~~r.b~~_c~_ o~~_t~a u ~ 1~~2~5_or m. ~oto~:~ ~ ~- c~trda ~e~ ins a~_~-~_h~i~inq_~© trQV 1 u he.l~~_ f o~.__C ~u'r~_a _ _~~rances ~rom Phi_1'~t~ ~3ut _ . he w~~l~__so~ne_r_. s~~.n _m~.r_.e time _~n~ m,ane in C.aur~ than. Pay ,~t1 m;~. c~ _ ~uJ h~n;~re~ _o~o)lw~s m~o~~e ~h~n h~ has.o r~ `', -~~ ~o ~c~ _,~ a~_~he___'_~.st ~~e._com~.~.nsa~~ort o to .~o~orcy~Ie_.~~a__,es_`~~Ien i`d's time ~o__mque this. 0 6 9 L s _ __ta o _rt_ as_ s ~ ' ~ ~` r, g l _Ie~__er e_gs~_~_n ar ~ ~m ~ rren tha ~~ ~o_~ -_~i° _ _ n ~1 S or a ore i~. es i_ __ ` '_Q __ _a_ I o IC t S. .~q~ e u_ Codnm~~ti:ct~~Q_ that ~eS iLa-~ to r'I , Gr_~e~ ,in__un~~__~ec~eve m~rtne~'~ I._r~~so___ra~~~_Srnce t3r~aYt LL _ '(au.nt~ s~~~e~__~ ~i~s___lr,tte~_~r~ y~~~_ .~her~ ire ~~ wu~l_~ be u?ill.in .doe p_~. ; GQ°/u o ~ e, to ~a~r cli_e.t~~s_ m~~orc~.le _t~_t~aas._}~SSg_-an~__~__s._ _ red ~ha~t I _u~o~~c~ gcc~e ~ _~.~~ ~.~5w_t.o_s~~tt:l.~. __ar th_~:,~am~u es_ Which ta±er~. es~i_~rn~~~.a~-a._h.icfh~~_.~o_~r~~ than thQ~JI vuoul~ I~K~c ~o Yn_ow uu~__~~iu~.;..~r~p_osa~l_~a~s .na~.hoY~Qr~~ e e~ b,~._~r,.`~on~a_~_1~utt_e,.__ncl~se~ a_co_ .o hiS_I~tt~er tayou_u o ._t~~_ a~_OY'e_~eV1:~.i~n~.~~~vh_.ch __i,C _~d~e ~ ~~o~_~I~ I f . T`lr'~_ `~~~~~ +~?~~__n~~__~_o.r~o~~th~tt__st~t~merr~_b. ~ayy_~~~ m~J1~Sa ~h.en ~ .~oul~..l_aka__ _ou -I;~ ;r~~~r_t_ ~r®,au-~'ts t~asr~;pr~- „sentat%o_n_to-~he_,Ba _as_s. Y~e~:-u~re~_b __~~c ~~n~°_ DR°~.-)Q~ f~)~ ~~r~ Crtuc~e on 3 1~ o~ at a cd5~ o ~ _~I~_ ,S `: ~ ~~ ~sOna , I _ e . ~?~re jai e a he es~~~ ~ nn.c ~ ~~ c_ ra~'r~w m $~W.~~.whn vi~erp ~}~eu mane a and mailed ~o?Since they u~erea~; made -~or_me _or send. to ~~, :~'~ Iike. ~o Knvu~ uuho wan~e~..nn~ r.~ceiucd that in or-~ r~ati~n~so ~~_hat .I _can send they a bi11 and a co~1~ ~~ thy. eK tn.~er )IS~.~ l'ieas'e cc s~~~ ~ ~~ °o Tien ~ u~rate G~ nce;.i~ has _~nI ~~en ..air) _ecen~y ~ha~ du hau~~' b~ ca~~, i_nter~s~~~ in m o1~ic ih~or~nAtion y hick $ook m~. tlm~ to _abt~lq a1lhau ~h I ~avcn't ch.arye~ ~n40n~.--F_D.C.:~~a`~ .~im~.~~ you) liiC~'~~ Know `--~'i'1re ~- ~ r ~_ haue` ~cpli~:d to our_1ct~et~.r ~ta me Huh°r~h, are. ~ate~ Aoki I ~ and .A~ri I ~!~~aooa. q~ th.~ en.d o- F o~ Aari_6 ~^oa. Nn 6 l~~t~~ter ;to o~z.:u~hcn ~ uar~~e c`s hauc~no'mn~)ice ~u a~~`~hi~ tim~~no~ ~o I ~esif~e to disc:ha~ e ~)1es ~) m.e. alp . no esi e `'~o co "t B e tr. '_~ b_ .o ai _i_n r~not ~~' no ~-. at orn t~~ard~ i~o~ 0.t w e an L ~~ ;~ , 'C . . VxC uJf1IC r s ' c ~ _ ` v_ S~~e u. era he ~abilit ~nc ~ le. ~;1.. _ ~. i~ .a ...re . se ~ in e~'L'S S un i) 4 cC s u G.n a cce: ~i) ~~_ Qu ' sc e yen a °e~em nt s l,~~n ale i arc- or n.c'e__~.Q m bes -` t ere~ u-hic ~ uc ~x r~csse 0.n 'r~el r~esen e ~~ ou C ur' m isa~uan~a~ e wi a~_and_Br.~ac _a :_Con`~ract ans tea o hanorin o ~ on t'~uc b e:it er con~ln~in to re. r~s n me o , bu aroui inu m wit Qna er A~ a`~ a~ne~I w ill en ciise rr.e~c.l~i o it ,a recourses ~u e .a as ' o M bract Ies,.~ncl c ,c~ Z ui ons. rich S haue ~eviorz c ~~ ~ n~.~~tctlu ~ C0~ S incere)y~ ~FVVI DALE WINTERMEYER IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA VI. JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ N0.2001 - 5417 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 4TH day of JANUARY, 2006, after review of the Plaintiffls "Nunc Pro Tunc Answer to Praecipe for Listing the case for Argument, Pursuant to Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Prosecution", we note that the matter was previously resolved by our order of November 29, 2005. B~ D~ r; d L u,7`z JAS 61 u: RE. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Cazlisle Road Camp Hill, Pa. 17011 :sld Edward E. Guido, J. ,~cp~ /1,,,~,,,_P<,d /- I D - b 4 9 t 4-~ 1 ,11 i ~' 1\1 \I I. ~.. r~. `. fV I ,,. ~. _, , .-... _,~ C ~0 i~i1:P.~.~JVFI.II".AIJW L: _.a ~. ~'~1~ I ~ '~ ' 1! t".C a J~SU~ S'nlinas Ual ez-D ~ n not _ _ _ _- - Ntanc Pa°c Tt~nc® ~1nsu-er__ I~is~ill~ Case Far. ~rq_um~nt~ P_ursu-ant- To _f For Lack Q~ P~QS'_~,cu~lon - - 1a I_ haue___~levio~i_s em~in~ ~o C~rcum~.e - ~hi.~ co 'r~..~ ~_~D __L9[rl1-~IaI1Cl''L ~.h~fUl~__IY.. ~0 ~Il_IS n-Q~.p-ra~l~ .CI I -also maile_~ a coP~ Asw-r~CQ_thQ~~~ fat ~at~, _- ~e I ate i-n~lo~in 1~ a l R i }qtr _,,pp~rsrA~.n scan. ~ ~_o._ th ~-_ 1' _ ~o . , _ __I ~e__Q.__l~o~~ o_ _ _. _~im_e, _ agorae too ~os~ aid ~~ti~ C_o__ ~_~a%a~ "~. Soo_n a os_ut~--Bali ~e~~ ~. ~on~__~oalC- -ar__ 1_~ _~ - An_ _n_o`~RQ~!-n~ ~ince. ~_'7w_a_s_i_n i my ~nJ~~Ies~_unr~ J Cu i7efinnr~ Cn un f' f~ni ~~ ~ DEG 2 8 2005 /d''~ r Praeci~~. F t~ ;ion To ~isrniSs _..- ~ __._ ~ D c c _~ , ar ua ~h m~y )e qhu' Rs hue Hof 1.,_t fl ®_a_u_~t~_or_e_omlpen~`~tor _ ~ama.qe. `~ _~ f~s_~n~_~-e~' 1~ n ea _ on>r For' . ~_~~__~5rni_S's_~'L~uJ~ic~1_.T SU~In~~~~ u~r~ ~ei'.~onal~_o.n Fed, a3 ~QO~~nd o,. ~_ ~he ~_ or mentioned ~alntl_ __. n~nts__a_ar_ne ~_~and ~. Gr~e~~!e -oq __ _ -_--- - Y Y ~_ avail inri_m~v~~l.~-_o_~ _u_I1 _o-~ m~ _ ,,. L S~ ,__ t S~ __4~_ G~'ieUances ~i~ ar~'y l~y~a--_dut o a_ rose,c~~/ ire m',_na~lac'tl~~s a~d viol~t~_o~~; s .___._... _ - a Q- ~ z ~.~ad~gq ad zr1 th~_ _e~t~~n -byy ~~~ ?aw -~~m V irk i.S~ ro.e!f1_~__ S-~ a~ e..r._~~-n ~ caald n-at wank du_e to }gave. an-~ ;ncom~~.I dec~i~e~ - ~ .. _~.~ Pane. 2 ` I~ e fee '0 0 -_.~~os°i _ ' r_1___~-_~_~_ ~__1~ - irm-~ -_An,~i_n_o~_~a_.ne _ ~_ a cc~~ aq_~anc~--, ~ _rn ~_l~e~ ~e---uw_i~h__ ~h,~e-~'_re preSet1~ec~ a~vi r~l_~e.i7legt---~h ~c~~__~,U_~S_ r_e_ re.r_ent d ~a ~fe _a,s ~in~e~ o_c-u-m-e~te~~an_o~-as-c~~i~i~~i~'e_~ as~~No Re_covery~ -I~.o--~ee,'~T _ ~i tize,m -._is_i11c `~S ~_ ` e _ s ~ ~ °~ / ;_S. T _~~en~o~_ ac- e ,-- - -aw_-__- a~~n~)- A_t~ggQ~RdV_~e~ - ~~-I~ ~-~~l~e~~Q_c~~oo~n~_-~ D~'~u~,~ W~o_J_ is _~ ~~- ~es~n~-,-~iue._Q--_t ~--_~_a-~u__.~rm-o-- /~ in_a`~_Rou.-er~T ~n_ auJ r-__Q_ ~ 4 u o_ - ~--_.._.._ _. -- - ~_l: s~ '-- - ~- -_ OQLo~ __ e _ s_ -s___ _ or_ _r ~r -- --r_~c~--- 9rc ___ ._ c -- -- e ~ ~ e ~ -- - -- - -- - ~-4s -- J s s- ' .s ~ o t _ Jur -- ~- ~- e~ r _-rL-~-~n1 _Qa~i -- I`utz Q -~,_ eX- p~e e re- ~e~e~l~atiOQ__Ce_~.u_r~me~l~c o-__ ~'e re~SenL-n one and t~p~r_l~~i_q~ti_oq_--~Q __an-~__in_ ~- J~r r-ial DAui~ l>utz -a ~~.e~-fia -~hQ~~-__~~r_ms --gin-~ _w h~~1 h e o ~_f_ere~ --a- ma~~Il_ _binc~r r~~ ~t~~- -f~~~n~n~_~o -me h_~~h is" _ca_Lle~ _~_qq__u_~~-i_~nt~'q~~___.ur~'tu_an~__:~o the Fe[ ~-C~emet~t' ~orlt~'ac~___or___f,e I _r~ res~n'~a~~_o _~b ___the _l~w _ i~'m o.~ , Nn_ iY~p~~QUUne~w_~ic~-i~-s'%_n~~b y-pa~i~ _l.u~z.T ~ re ' __ t or_~no~h~ orn _~.~_san-mot e es~ `' w _A ~~uer ~ o ~~~- .c~Cm of Anninn`~ ~ InPh n n ~ ,v 1701anrl .0 f P.D- - - ~ _. ~~ ~ ~~ a ~_ _ - ~_ ~ - o- r _ - __1L7 ~a h n w '' 6. I _hau~ n~ -_~-ire Davi_ ~u Z~no~' ave l ~iCe .,~ ~ ~~,~~ ~,~.~ ~~,..~.~ ,.~~ ._ ,~ m. pQUici, -~,u~ - and- ~e._ 1-u~ irm ~hA._ I ave con~rac~- wt~~ _~or _r~ep_re.~en~~x~ _ clam foc gust dui c~m- e~lsa ion.. r y _aaq aad in' arias are I_~q~ LLy. l~_a~_I_~_and ~re.__i~~_y__.~~un9 ._~o___u_~_ho`I~ the? iduci_~r /. -_dut- ___D_ -,m_a~n~-al~l_~~i.qq.'~---~eaC_o_l~s~_re_ _r~fentatt~h o m. ~'el f ,__and~o__. the, .C._o:t~~ai_~t~_un. iJa--a----~ cc~esr ul__c~~o_u__ r`,_yy. -}~a~s--~?~en _ o~tai~_e~_b ei_~~~r _._~.a_~~~ 1,u~Z~or b _ nn~tt~er r Ia_w er of ~h~.__~n9_",_n~9- RoVr~er__.~a_~u i~'n1 ~ur~uan~ to o~~'ys~i-la___bi.ndin -~an~~act__~~_qq_r'cemen~_-_or_`e,_~re~~ t~~ion~ -anr~-_ ~trs~n~__-~~t~~~om-~I~~__that_u~a~ repar~~_6 a _en~,~ o_ - _th~.__L~~_____~_rm _o _-~Intl1n_o~_~ov~eC,_ ccor ,_ _ iq 11 .~n ~ t ~ _ ~I ~t 11- ~a i ~~.i 7. DAVi i,t~~z-- _ i'e~Irese~ltin __m Su~Om~-tte ~in_. 0 b_ h -,r s _atem~ _ ~ ~ has -rtat__ e ~emanr~__-~.o~' ~a~) u_r e t o -~]-i- ~1e c Cpl Taal _ ~ur __Trl__ _~` Taal ~ r _r'I_~sr~~ •_ ~o - - - - . - -- _d<isa~ow m~ ~~ f- Q ~ a -~-l-I _-m i.~~e -res_e n at ~ br_ soh _.v ~ p ~irteef-rs of A_~!~__Ru~es o _C'oll~U_ o C_anonS ~o_~le.r wh i _h_ are --t f ~~_~ ~~ he-LUO- bye ', in~__ tat h e_ ,ri q~ p_ and ~~ hi_c_h h. rc_ rerse~ e~. __Deman~e~.~ince -Qavi_d i ~11ce _tv ~ re~C.eseat ~H ire f Ru I~_ ~~~. c~~ !~ %s~en~a~i ors .may--_a_ecur ~e Qrl~_ re~aVarlt~ anal z h ~r~-b~ c~ ~an~.. o f ,art ~~ ac~-es h' Iry~( lia ilia _.r of r ~~ ~ ~ ~'a a y ~~ ~~_._anr~ ~I~ la ~i~m n.~ Anpinn`~ R~Pr Tl,e o~ rs o ,~ nn v is n !_ all o_f_ the ~u~ ac_tionr~a_e li _ences~_ua~ro -e.r~si~al_ _con_du~ts ua_a~-~~~ _a_~__ co -re~r _and _I~ ~I _i-I-i_a..r I' u,_h_ich_-ire._c_o~~uc~~~_an~_ua'"Q+r_t~1~en_ b _.~1~~ la~ ~r ~ Glh_ ~-- Std _ . _ _A,C_~ _e~u~-0---- _~ _~a_ul _ 1~_~1,-__ '--b.~~q___ ~ vide~i _u ~L_ ~~__i_ci_al_.c esen~- c~~io- - ~w i~~ s con i _ ~~ o ~ ~ l0~ .L`t__7s ~~aate~ugc~r_~'~s~ t~.m~tlt o~! ~'h~e~ Cas~ rpc.~c~d' j u t'a I _H._~.rto~'. i~h~--I~at~._I~__~D ~~russ _~Q~' _ ~a ~ lu~e___To ProSeca~~--~~a`~~ 1~~i~ ~al~d - cor~a.int ~_ ai11s~ __Qe_~eq_ ~u_e~~ in~.r_ V _ e ~ ~n ~~_~. C~~ I 0_ C®-1pl~~i~ P__I.e s' fi~ Cu_lq-~ ~e(~~411~._Cou[i~y-- oq---,SQ~t~__IZ Q01'~I fo ~ ±~ i ch_ _ ~s__a~ __~ri~~u~~n~~ recen~~ -o_n_._I ~ e l eu e ~h~ - rain _I_ _i.p . 4_r_ra_is1'e re.~:~i4_n~rea_1~_e u~ll - i I-le ~1~~~A q ~ p cG od l_ .-~~_e._-!~~K __~,-s~~tis_~~~t~__,~t ~_s prA~~es~~n~lal_~_i.~ e , ,can ~c ~ . _To_~_D_~.at~_~h~_~~~ __~ J __Pco . ess-mna _can~uct. 3., En ~ iq --1q---r~i~~~e.~~ Q ~~~ e~ i~ Q~ I~i,1'o'e_~!'~_ea~~ tion~ -~Rn ---Gr~.Qa--~__ Q-_chec-e~__~h~ P~~t~o~t-~t-' ~r-- s d sk~~ _~cor~ ~ ---I---d-i_ _he wo~l~:_hA~~ v~e~i- -1-e _~t_ ~'d c ' r ~ ', ~ e ~~ _ - T_~e.~~-~ ~, b ., Zen -ca__~ ,~.L~ a i _it _s__ . a~ _ions fog anr~ o f ~hi,r_ C~-~ lain~__~u__ _a~cid--1, ~z__ n~_tQ -fie-_ ~~w _ irm__o_ _ A~1 1.411~~-~~r- ~~~S _~0__._°~e_Stl.~~_ _b-i_4~1n ~cD11 _.g~t a ~e_m~gt __~T` ' ref~1_a~_D__n_ ~1~~_,L_ wA~_f~ ~e~'e~~- _ fp~~~- . I ~~ - ~~~~ ~~Q~.lqq~--'utl3~-~/- G~~~ °~AJ` I_~~4~~~1~~~ ~ ~ _1~C~ ~~A~ Oavt~ l.u~z__ret~*~te~e-- - -is _tl'e~ e~'e_nt_a .i. Ilj~an~~ _~c~c~l1 .:~.:...-,. ,_ ::eewiw~-~,m,.~,w.,.n:,,e.wr~.--,. 14lakie "~...=._. .-.oWt~swrw~cx..._ .n ~.~ ..:,:. ~v:::.:4«;~11m.,i;.,.,,..~...: - ~ ~~AP a 0 0 Y~ y Y y Y Q -~_u_i-- ~.__~ra cr~.c~i_pa~iaq_~r~.n re .ra ona ~1e__ ~ ' _~ti _ ~ ~eq- _AW ~~~ _ Co ~~c~~~S_ _ ~ i .~~ o~ '~~ ens ' ~~~rC,,~~,_ -- __~ -~on~ --_G_r__een_~I_~_q_o~ ~ o ~~~~t~~~~ __ _Pro s~l~_.~_q~~M ~.~R~L~__t~~_I' _e~n_eer_~e~uire,.f' - ~~J~r~_~ _ari~ _ ~.~lc~- c -- a n_r~~~x~ , t ~ ___Xt__i_,r o u ~u e _Ple ~ _ _ _ _-~.au~ e.r~ u _~~ _ ~ ~~ ~ CG i ~~ - ~.~.. _ _-W_ ~..1~--~.Q.~ e ~LRJ I r ,_Y ' cS`I.1 V _ . w S._ ~._.ii..l_. ~ -- --_ . -re_q_LIJ ~~in.~f a_LS s~ Y ~ ' _1Q~~~~ e _ D CQ- _ ~ f ~e~]-_h~s~~_IJ__n-e_a_IPCter~ ~o r ~ m o~_~~~L=_: ~~ - ~ ~~, -- _~rr_een ~n re .r ~ ~ r.scover , -t~p- - ~ W~11.0 J_S Ul- c ` t' o e J' _ ~'~' V ~ _10 ~LP- u nlrth mm~i in Pll Yl/ P !'(1_ 1i1 i!` I.S nt~~nPr. ~1~ _ 0 --, , ' _~~~~mea~L ~~1~_~Q_br~J_ol~n,rea_-~-n_ ~..: rre _-,. .. .. ~.,, w~.~.,~~~eaV '•w .•.. ,uu m~~ull,rmsitw~umu.~d~wma.~.r~~.ee~~.:,,~ww~... .~s,.r~, ~.,,~.~,_.,. ~~n,,.~~~tri~iuwaa iiui-JI i_ _ L , ~ u .. .._A~m .,. _,.~ _ .~ __. if ~I __ _ ~ .. . ._ ___ __... __ _ ~ ____ ~ . __ _.__. ,__ d ~C.= ~'r2= ~ ~ _.. ._ r-t-' TT7 C~ _ ~~ __ -_ __.._ t -, ~.1 __C~3 ~C -C1 _L Ti '. -. P. :~ >+~ .. ~ LA3 "`w _ i t J ~ _ -- ~ ' ~xh~b~t A LAWN-LAWYERS 407 Ryobi LLP Run RdCadisle-2494833 362.9501 JOHN A. ABOM (FORMER CUMBERLAND COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY) JASON P. KUTULAKIS (SOLICITOR DAUPHIN COUNTY CHILDREN & YOUTH SERVICES) • CRIMINAL DEFENSE • FAMILY LAW lNN SERVICE INC iWER ~ PAIR OP uwa sa'"~`vra, rNc IB & Models • Blade Sharpening ke Trimmers-Snov4Nowers-Chainsaw at Delivery Available mdaeePe Maintenance-Tanbark Senor Citizen Discounts Iburg Rtl Mechanicsburg -- 761.7975 le Mower Service Way Dlllsburg-------- 432-0932 UCK AND CO r Rd Hansburg 106 walnut st Harrlsburg------ 232-9511 Abom & KutUlakis Carlisle---------------232.9511 Abraham Law Offices 513 N 2 St Harrisburg----------------232-7625 Adler & Adler 125~ocust St Hamsburg-•-- 2343289 Ahmatl AnSer Serving Harnsburg Area---------- 909.4343 AHMAD & MIRIN Serving Harrlsburg Area -----909.4343 5N OW glsplay Atl Page 930 Ahrens Thomas J 5521 Carlisle Pke Mecha01c5brg----697-1800 AleXander Jane M 148 S Baltimore Dlllsburg---------432.4514 Allen Heath L 210 Walnut St Harrisburg-- 255-8011 Allen Paul 4700 Union Deposit Rd SUlte 260 Harrisburg--•------------------651-0771 Alzamora John A 212 LOCUST ST Harrisburg--------- 255.7233 Anderson David C 3940 Locust Ln Harrlsburg---------541-1194 Antlenon Janice L 7105 511ver Fox Ct Hummelstown-----566-0100 Andes Samuel L 525 N 12 St Lemoyne-----761-5361 Andrew W Barbin PC 123 State St Harnsburg-------------232-9200 Andrew's & Johnson 7a W Pomfret St Carlisle-------------243.0123 Antlring Wllllam H 234 North North st Harrlsburg------- 234-4726 CONTINUED NE7(T COLUMN LAWYERS contlnuetl Ab CINO& ROVNER ,~~ t ~ • SERVING CENTRA4`PA' ;, 'I FOR OVER 70YEAR5'. ' Recognized Best Lawyers In America Bar Register Of Preeminent Lawyers Million Dollar Advocates Forum AUTOMOBILE ACCIDENTS MEDICAL MALPRACTICE WORKPLACE INJURIES PERSONAL INJURIES FREE CONSULTATIONS No RecoveryMo Fee 238-6791 (800) 648.2070 wnvw.angino-rovneccom 4503 NORTH FRONT ST. HARRISBURG, PA 17110 Anner Carolyn M 1300 Linglestown Rtl Harrlsburg--238-2000 Anstine Timothy M 100 Plne St. Harrlsburg--------- 221-1111 Apicelli Samuel W 305 Front St N Harnsburg----------- 237.5516 Afther ThOmaS A Harrlsburg------ 233-8676 Armstrong PatrlcYa 212 Locust St Harclsburg--------255-7627 Ar05011 Sarah W 305 N Front St Harrlsburg-255-7231 Artz Charles I & Associates 207 State StHarrisburg--------236-9905 ASChinger Jack F 212 Locust StHarrisburg-255x609 ASnIUS Daniel C 212 Locust St Harrlsburg-- 255-7624 CCNTINUED NEXT PAGE FIND ITHERE FIRS7 -FAST, AngeloS Peter 0 2001 N Front St Harrisburg 232.1996 EXh~b~~ To T1~'~ Randy Ca C~fren~. March wsl~oo~ I am u~ri~in in rr arils ~o our mvitua~ litiqq,utiorl dis~osition.i hav~ retai~r~ f1r, pav~~ l,uta o ~ Angqino~~(ouner~~o represent m h~s~ interests~~uh;~h I h~uc end reSSr~ to ~1r1 ~utZa1 hvv~ recen~~y received a letter ~rom T1r` I,utz~ uJhich iS t~atrc~ 1~gf c6~ 9I ~oo~a Mre ~•~tz has i n.~ arm e~ me i n that I etter~ that I gave ~ravi ~e~ ham with the t~uthari~y tm acce~t `your proper~~ c~ ~ age se~~le~lent o f e~ a~ ~ 4~i 6., ~C an that !te comm~nica ed that Settlement o ~e~' t0 GU, Tha`~ 0 er is gCCepta~le to me~ .I have no~ i he~ an~~ ~?ape~~'~ u~`~ch sate. that ~ ~i-I accept thin ~mount,~ an Ch~ec~s are- se t ~o ~~++e ar than amaun~, I w~ ll not si ~ it~y~ of will ~~ re~urne~+T~at amoun~w~ll onl ~ cov~ the ~'cpl~tcemtn`~ labor or m Fare otorc cl~. allt~'ou h there were other arty tat ~ue~e ~gma9e~ o~ i ~ T'Ir~ Sa~it~a,s6l ~~ve a~so in grme~ Mr, ~qva~ Lutz tat 1 u~oul ~e ~r,t,n to nu~to in orm ou °~hat ~ a~ not aCCe ~in our 0 e~'e~ have wr~tteyl ;n p ~~~ ~y mos~} ~'ecen~ letter to DaU~~~hutz ~ qm c~i`f~ctin ou 'td nc~ in accor~;~ar~ce to m~ b ~s~ i n~erests and a~~~ m~ Y re~r~esentitiUe o mr best ~nterests~b ~n~~Ormtn I~ 4 -green that I ~i I I not accept .his mos~ rrcen$, ~~ ~~ o q~c.so~'.z then also +urote to 1'Ir~~u~Z~d~ am als'c~~~,rec~ In~ you `~o fe~uS'e to acce~t l~lr~ Greed" o~f er.~~ woulr~ I~ e to know ,f you have ha~ copie,l' of m nlrc~ical rrcords o the 06rtho~e~ic institute a 'Pa, urnish~~ to ou by that e~j~erpr,se~or ~ An Pnt rom ~he. Ia~ ,rrrp of ~n ,no~-Rouner. Lf that has occ~h~re~ plea~c inform me~o the i~' ntityy o tltt ,nd9vic~uals vuho have provar~e~ yyou ~,th m medical ,'records and o-~ the Home o the irrn dr businessrenter~rise u~hic~ ~,~sat, ~erson~ar person wars fora 1"hQn~ ~ou` Sin~~rel~ Mr. D. Wintermeyer - 1408 Carlisle Rd. . Camp Hill, PA 19011 1 L `. ~~` ~-ether to Rnn~ C~reerl~e . `Relnailed cif Toes, Aril a 0~ j •. CAMP HILL POST OFFICE '~ CAMP HI ylvania 0 I ~ NIRBOEIA ~PA t0 17 113717 04/02/2002 (7171737-1461 03:04:06 PM i 40 3 ~ Roeeeae $ . Sales Receipt Product Sale Unit Final ~ ° I m cemneaFee Description 0#y Price Price Return Receipt Fee • r PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 ~ $0 34 '`' ° o (Enaweemeot RegWrea) R~tdct doeln . First-Class '~: p e reryFee (EndmaemencReQWmdj. Return Receipt $1 50 - Certified '''o ~,mtReereaea.tbe. $ ' Label Serial #; 7001194000058708917 Customer Postage . _$0 34 ~ ~ ,-a sent To ~r- (j Subtotal:. $3 60 am k-+i -+--• sireet apt Ro.; . ' _ Issue PVI: -$3.60 O i.~, oM1 o FV w Po Bor Na ~A~ ~ ' 1-_ty-L aigsrea`zPd+a t tt t Total: $3.60 Paid by: Cash $4.00 Change Due: -$0,40 Bill#: 1000400650304 Clerk: O6 Refunds only per DMM P014 - Thank you for your business - Customer Copy P ~rn<<,o k~~PnnR~~ 9. O~Y84/ 2 J LISPS ` ..~ } - it 1 n (~ Czh~b~t~ z k~~~ ~ 73•J ~~A. ~~~~J L~J1 ~~II ~I~N~.1 ~QIdL~v ~~~I VJ)~~14~ ~N~ ~ii~d~ e ~V~.r$ec~ in our let~e~° ~~~~ ~ ~oi~l~ ca~ ~~~,u in ~-e ard.~ to thi,~ mcitter i have determined h~~ iY3 ect m_ ~e _a~ 12r ~~~ ro ~~~t I ma ~etca q ~o~pra me roo _ o_ ~y _com unicuti~ns/~n_ all arti~snin~la~i ~ ~ fCum!~~rlan. Caun$y Court ~- uf~I1 c~url~ir-u~e _~Q -,scuss~~hts.~~en _~nq Surd b `~ w~ ~ ~ur-t~e~ ~~a.tp~un-c~~-ans~ S~~~e eo~~~ters ~re ~Yain~~ m ~~hnic reli ions b.~lie s~ I da not ~omm- ll u~ cane b ~ mail'nor cam~ute~s becau~°e com- ute~s may ~~. ra rain .d to I-~- ~s .they ~D.Th~re- Q~`~~ 0_ - ! nl~n~~yy, O.n~Li1~4L ~0 COIf1n1~~11CG1~~ UJith ~~, in eqar~s ~o t~'~ matter in t~>° same manner rxs our r~c~ent Fetter ~o m~z ~'`nce you are now ~)le mos~ recent claims. a~_ user anol 1-t~. at-on re resent-~- i u~ far this I t; ~I cLisposi tion~~ .Would I~Iki' to a.r~ y_aU al_ ew ~ es~ia_ns. DD au ~av~, a co my cam I -_r~t s~-~ wlaic has been _ -Ied -~~t~~ Curet _erl~n~ Count. eour~~QUS~e in ca~lt`sl~. pq. i.~h-ch i s S~~ i l l -pen_ i r1 ?y}l av_c o ~t ~ e en _ roe i dle d Jw i tJ~.tan.. o m ca-1_,a~ent~ial medyical rec~rds in ormat`-o~1~ tclu~r~~n_ f$h~ ~( ~a_ s o..~~__m __bc.oken le in'uries° ~h-~h w_~re cause~y~y J~Oseu~_Sal-na,~ va de.~~?p Are yoi~ a ~_ona ids 1~u_ ~~er_?_Lf youu are a bona1 ~_~Ae 1a~- _er .art' _.o-n aut~ac'-~ed _ana~ le, ~I.I_. permit~ed to 1 ° ~.i y a~e -~hi.r 1~ a_I__ _dis~Q.rit _on _ur~i ~hiyn a~~ or throe h t~e ~ven_u~. o__. ~~ C.u,m~e-rlaar~ count ~ur~,F~t.l .~rr to ask me ix~,.y _~ue.rt%®ps_that y,you ma J~av,e ~oo~ qnd I w_- P1 .unsuoer ~p_~tYl us fro f-eien~Cy as ~m able to, .S'inc_erel_~ y - ... - . - ~- - . " Mr. D. Wintermeger _ f 1406 Cacllsk Rd, Camp Hill, PA 17011 DALE WINTERMEYER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. CIVIL ACTION -LAW JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ, Defendant NO.O1-5417 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 19`t' day of July, 2006, upon consideration of Plaintiff's "Affidavit and Nunc pro Tunc Response to Letter Titled `IN RE: Pretrial Conference,"' filed June 26 2006, and of Plaintiff's "Nunc pro Tunc Averment and Motion for Order," filed July 10, 2006, which appear to be an attempt to assert a claim against Defendant following the entry of judgment against Plaintiff and in favor of Defendant,l Plaintiff s motions are denied. BY THE COURT, ~Nale Wintermeyer, 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Plaintiff pro Se ~andy C. Greene, Esquire 1800 JFK Blvd. 14~' Floor Philadelphia, PA 19103 Attorney for Defendant V T ~ ((~~\ „ ,V ~A ~~. ~ See Order of Court, June 12, 2006. ,,((O~ ~ ' t ' Q f x I PC Ihf vr c J . n - I~Q ~ ~ e Th ~. Nay .cnY~ ~ Ona p i T c ~~ra ~ e l~n , ~D __-~nr~ nog an hi aU p~ JUI~~,.,, 2r7o~ the _ ____ n^~ e ~ 1~ - ~_~__._. _ J- ~_ ~ 1~ ~ A ~-~--W-U~1-~01~1~~~)l"~C. W~ntrrT r: ~~a~ e Y _-. Nunc Pro T u n c- _ _-_ RV~~'men~ Rnd Mn~:inn Fnt- (7t-r~e>` __ ________ ~1 , i 1 L, „. 1 o t o I _ 1/11J ItUL~'~eQ~_H~ IIDI,IDII .~ ~pJ .\U b=_. _m_i ~~ ~ .~.~ Nunc Pr _ Tub ~--- ~ ~e_~L o e 0~_. T~ ~ ` E1 e ri ~~_en~~~ 1 T ~ e ~_ u o res. J A I~I ~av,e tol~~n~ irect~~ ~ttornr~_D~vi~__~~~z__ 1 1 , , ~--Y -r-~ . , do a O~a_~te- 4q iTs 1 ~ su co ~ T.o_711~ --- - ~ ~ 1 s ~ ~ ~ '---- -- ul i o a c iU~,, A_~1~ ___ . o C ~ c` re i o~~ c~ - -- -- -- - ~ „ Ay1 . 1 ~ e o .1.~__.-____ _...._ ~ T 1 ~ 1 Y t •`• --~ ` c~ e es ` o ~ a U j ~ite ~ W ` ~ 9" U e ]~-~-__ 1 U ~_l~_1 ~ __111...__..._ _ c~01Ar ~ Q11 1 n_ _ -~_ ` ---------------_._-_.___ _ ~~_ a , ~~ ,~..,~.~ow~w.~wumaw.aJ ~A ~~a~a~.eu 3iks'w~ua. ._~, . v.; , w ,~ g ~ r ~ ~ e ~ ' ~ u~ as fi t ° , e e v --$-t~ aq-~.~ swat e ~~e ~ ~~ ' ~- --- cc -~~ ~ ~1~_J~e~z~ -- -- b p ('- , O C J UI/___ul. _.__ 1 1 ~ ° ° ~ 1, w ~ ~ ._~1~_ n nI^ 6 ~3L~LQ Q ~ 0 ' YV ~~++.. ••~~ 11LV [-- C t~~ 1 1 ~JJ ~ ° ~_l! -_ ~ 1. J ° ~~ - l ~ 9~ l ~ hir~ an~p~l} _ r~ c~ ~~ W i ,~ a u i ~ _ I, U ~z __ anr~ l~l ' ~ ' ~' e, 1,V I~ UI • 1 1 0 1 ~~~~j -is=~,.-~~....--J=+1!'11-1--- ~ ~ e' ~ ~St.V__,._ __.-__ aos~c r v i W ` C0 ~lAYI-~-~'C~~ ~- ~ ~p ° f 1. j-~ / ~.n ~a ~ t~~t pa~~d _1~ __~~ '~ _.~ which he hn.c ~ e~_-- ' ~ C~~~ ° ' / -_ a' . ion was a ~s~Z_ s~i. ~- 1 , , ' ~ ~ c _ ! e __ ~e ie~~ 5 e of I~ COl - --------- __-~d~.s~~g2 c ~,~.-}~ ~rP_.CPJ1tnI. ~C ec~l--0~` ~~i_e~ _ C ~ -Q ~ 1 L1_ C ~ ~~fX_~._.!~_2. -_ .__.... 1 l 1 ~ I ° a ~ I /-' ~~ phis Au~.rment. Exhibit 2 o a Pa~riO~ N~u~.t nrtic I~_ -- .. -.,,,ea...u. ~c..+..z~.~,~~~.nux.~~rcwv..-e .~ ., „, ., Lr..,,~.~,.ena. gal .~-... .,.~ <.-.. J ~° 1 A L lr ~L e ` y ` GG W C ~ ° ~~~Up'~ L' C '~ p~'~ a 1 '-""'~--~~-- ° - - 1 ~ ' LRl~- d A u ~~ . o~~m end --- / I~ Ravi f uJ 'r Q .`~_8o_~Ine~_,_ u~oul e ~i r Trim t11 ~sV1 T PinYl.o LL ~~,o ~:fesa-~i l~nnihnr~ n~.V-noM ,..T 1 1 ` / - ___ ~r1~~ ~'~_~_r~ ~ u~ ` ° C c w S r v I a- __ eS G ~ ~ y '~ ~-~ ~ ------ y 1 A __ ~~ ~ y ~ A --gip -- ~- ~ '~ ~ -Q- cc ~ ~~ __ ° ° ° _ i.J rea,c T haV~ -U ~~---- ~ -_~_ CL ' r ~ ~~ L II -- -- ° Q I ~ LLB _~__. _ ~ ~ ~ _by _ __._ ° 1 1 1 0 u c ~mP-~-~a-~-- i~ ~ess_ _ _ _-~l~l ~ e Q CLCI~_. __ / ~_~___ ~ ; r ° r ~' ~vi~a~ ° e ~~ Fir" .. .. ~..-~.. i = xwl' ,ed:v Yni 6Y:k38YE '+ll.:N S]'I JLII~t~ui 13 s~1[L1hJ6 IHU 41tlYM .•.W~~i ~~e1d ::'.a., x .. :. ~. .... '__ b-~-l~ dur~C~eS_u Imo _s1 ~ ~ ~ ~lJ~~ V " _~1_h ~ch- c c , I,_ cer a ~ i _- ~ _ ~~_ t ` o~L~_ Y r .~ cu ~_ ~~h~t _~ _Qa~ly-_e_~~'_ _ eU ~~I-~L2 1 ~ _L~~ _Ci t4-- ° (~n~,S_.u,~c~_ ~ c ~ ~~- _ ~ ~ ° ° ° e T _~ - b o ~ ._. ° ~ ~~~ a C ~ a o ~'~ ~~ ~' - . err = .L ~ie~ipU2 ~ha~ ~ e e.~c,n a.n, r;~ id in Lacf ' ° C ~ .~ r ~ f'e _ ° Co U ~ee _ r _ ° _~O p u L _iQ~1 ' use - ~ -- ' ~ s c ' ~-~-~-------- .~ar an 0r eG' w 'c ec ~c~_~h~-- a. _..~. ...~~~. 1 .:~.L_.s ...iE_ -„~~.v...t ma11.lW 3dh nL. utlJJlzw' 4 .....If_ >~..J , i ........ . .. . ... ~ i ~ S , ~ e o W O a a B o R n _ ~ -I/T --L~-~L- -U.~.1~.- ~ uJ e a a l w ` i 10 . q_ _ __ e _ o a- - -- ------------ _ -- - ~~ ~ -ham -~-~ --~~ _- ~ ~d ~~ - ~, o s ~ a~~~s~l o o~~ i~--- - t ~ , , , -° ~ o , ~- ~--_CS - - ------ a ~ I mv~ r '~o - ~ w 1 ~~~ --~- ---- - ~-r~~, ~~~ii C "~ ~ ea-l-_ ~i~~ ' w ~_.I ~~~.-- /f~~ S~aS'nn v ` ~ ~ e .y~~h~1L~~ Y ~ ~ hours_~ ~ W _ s ~ (' r ~~~ tD_ v U ~ e w't~L_~h.~_i~~-- _ ~Aq i ~,~'~ q a -- U__~-_CQ k1~Ca' W ' ~~ . eS ~o ~__~.or1lP~ e e v ~ e ~ e .~ S ' w ~ ~ 4 C ~ ~,.- ----- ' ~ 2 ~ ~~ .} a. ~ ' CG ~ ~~`iQS p o LCL--- e t Ue e '~ e G 1 ~ Y ~~ -~ o, c ----1•- ~ - ---- a I ~ W I C a s 2. C 0 H r__i_u.p._~ I 6 1 c W 'e r• e v' ~ ~ G6 ~ Cwt -- ~ t1~ 1 6 ~ ~Q V I 0 ~ ~0 ----- our c ~ i,e n~~ r to~ 1 i r ~ ~~ . no _ - - c~ ~~A~ ~~~1~~~ ~ ~l o~~.c~~-u ~ b s- ~ ~ C ~'. (I ( v - ~ t ~ + r p h YY X11 -Lil-I~J1L--S~-V-Jl..l-_ ~ ' l l ~ n 0 i n ~~ a C ~ ~ -~- -~~I__~'r-S__..___. 1 P .S~ ~ ~ _~o~~~- - _~ ~~Qt' ~~~wn Ce'~ ~ i Q ulc~ ~ ~ -~-~J 1, ~ ~ ~~ Ccs - ~ L~~ _ n , ~ ,~ ^ - ~.-><f.~ ~ -~-- ._I .._ll~_ _1_ ~n 1 .. ~1 I 1 1 _~ 1 JI/1C`P_ ~IUUIp~ ' ' e e- -- ~w s~ ° e ` i _~__w ~ n e __1~~_m ~ ~ Y ~ - --~ -~--J~u~~~- _ ~ s _~_~i~_1 ~~v_ - n o ro e ~ _~ ~_~'~.n r~~se n o e~ ~ Y o C ' - ~ ~ _ - e x;51. ~~--- ~ a e \ ~__ ~ I r ~ , ~ ~ ~ _ C' ~ ~. .~(° _ ~. ~.~_ W ]~._ ~ I f~LS_. J° ~ i...te .t..ir6ffi ~ ' ~ ' ~1 I~u-~11A m~sFe~~eS~en~.~ ~a~i ~ ~ _~..~ . . e ~dn0~0-~1 p fTeA~a~ u~h ~r-~1 ~LQtI~~ n p ~11;7~1r 6 ~o f'"n~ P'40 ~ 0 r NOII~ ~V'.D~- 1 e rA n fYs e ~ - 1 1 , ~ /~ S 1 ~ 1-s` ~ -- J __b~_ ~ R3. I.C-~ ~~i ~.`~_~ _ w l-~I_ _ - - u e ' h a C ~'`1 J ~~i_o-Cl-- ~ _ 1 1 t w ~~~ h~ u ~~- 0 1 1 ~ ~ {y~.91{~ 1' e Q~__. -~-~ e~ ' U C - ~1 _ ~ V S~-, ~ ~ ~ y0 ~ /~ ~ 1 / _il~l.-- ~~-- a Y 1 Q. G / / 9 _- 1 1 ( e C _~ 1 --~ ~__Y-J --14.v4~+_.-4__ U~ _ ~..~,.w_._,. ~~- ~ "- ~ww..~,~em ,.um gym., es. raxw.v~va~~..uc ~. _~ ~~e o au -_ ___ F4.q [`.'r.~~ Y'~.iA _.._ ice[. t -w .. :: _. wa...~:~n~.. i...x w.v._w. xi.,~si:.:na'1~:_la>a ._y14.~ e1~4~LLt. i.:+:oaL~ i.._:~J..:. ...::. ,: ~.. v ar~.._:..._ I ~' j _ _. ~. h '08!20/?001 19:14 Fd% 770 952 1115 THE HiiFi'1'b'UHll w~uoi THE HAATrOAU'S 0Mx1 ABTO PIdN P.O. A0X 105019 ~ ~ I- ~ I ' } ATId NTA, 0A 30348-5019 ,Y11 `M, IV ' Re+um Service Hequesh:d ~~~ A~T~'O~ ^ATE; 09/20/01 Obib7i AU3'OMOB~LL ANGINO AND ROVNER LAW FIRM ATTN: DAVID LUTZ-ATTORNEY AT LAW 4503 NdRTH FRONT STREET HARRISBURG PA, 17110 RE: CLAIM #: D1-245468 F11 INSURED: SALINAS, CARRIE M DATE OF LOSS: 07/i4101 ,x YOUR CLIENT: DALE WINTERMEYER `"""~~~~m~ "~"~' BEAR MR. LUTZ: '^^. '' PLEASE BE ADVISED, I HAVE BEEN ASSIGNED THE HANDLII~F<IiEs,. LOSS AFTER FURTHER REVIEW OF i'HIS LOSS AND 100KING INTO T --~A~„LVAN STATE, STA7UTE$ REGARDING THE RULES DF THE ROAD, IT UJOUL`<,D "ifi `: ' I]UR INSURED APPEARS TO BE LIABLE IN THIS INCIDEN _. CLAIM IF YOU WILL KINDLY PROVIDE ME A DEMAND PACKAGE WITH SPECIALS FOR REVIEW LOOKING TOWARDS POSSIBLE SETTLEMENT ON SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT. HAS SERVICE BEEN ATTEMPTED AND DO UtE HAVE TIME TQ TAKE ANOTHER LQOK AT YOUR CLIENT'S I NEED TO KNOUT WHAT TIME CONSTRAINTS 4JE ARE DEALING WI UlILL NEED TO REFER THIS- TO OUR LEGAL DEPARTMENT OR....I;,E;;% FOR REVIEW OF THE SPECIALS AND DISCUSSION OF,,ROSS~~LE;' BRIAN YpUNT OMNI INSURANCE COMPANY/CLAIM DEPA ,; `, PHONE 1-800-727-6664 EX7 29345 ~xhi~~~ ~. k t~ ;( ~ a. ~ I ~~sea~re~ ~,y ~~~~~r~ ~ A~~~~® r-;: A88®TEgey qYY Zuw _ ~~ ~~ Attorneys usually take on personal providing individualized service and injury cases on'a contingent fee meeting the personal and professional basis. The lawyer's fee is a legal needs of our clients is ow ggal ~, pexcentage of anymonay recovered atANGINO & ROVNi3R When you on the cliemt'a behalf, d'ienerally. if have a pressing legal matter at hand, ' no mone4 is recovered. the client is let ow exper[ence go to work fw ypu. ' not resnonaible for any attorney ~ Call our office at (717)238.6791 to fees. Contlngen4 fen anangemetits schedule a consultation. We are ace molt beneficial to those injured conveniently located at4503 Nvrth parties g+ho could not otherwise Front street. Foi a list of ow serviceg, afford au attoney to protect their vial[ vww.angino-rovnazcom legal ihterests. No one who is . injured as a result of another person's negligence need feel that ' he or she is not able to &le a suit in civil cottR tarecover damages foi the injuries suffered. trait our web site: `aiww.angln®-rovnercom a 's s" OFFICE OF PROTHONOTARY Cmmberland Coum7 - CARLISLE, PA. 17013 Exh~~-t ~ DATE si`~lOs ,~ a~~ This is to notify you that No. O~-.S~f/7 (~C(~ 19 has been Relisted for Trial at the Q2w ~~ dC~~ Term 19 of Court. Pre-Trial date ~ ~ ~ I PROTHONOTARY OFFICE OF PROTHONOTARY Cumberland Cuunty CARLISLE, PA. 17013 z rPl~,( this ~n ~1-~It~. DnrE ~ _ /~oz~ ___ This is to notify you That vs. No. L~/- S4%%7 ~~l~irir~„(~~ Iq has been Relisted for Trial et the _L.~/~~~ /,3 ~C~~ Term 19 of Court. Pre-Trial date `~ ~~ I q ^~.~% -_ `z ~.. ?'ROb HONOT RY 0 /~~ ., ,'~ a ~].~..1Jj to e~-pevel'° ~lainti-~.L Cuml~er~an ~ , .. , C :. . _vr~-~TT~ ,. ~ ~_, ° s e e St_~ ° L ° rescn ~.,~il .S~ ~o~e Ti~,~,e l$ S~eC6 L s ~_~~_~i~~_ e o t t c e ~e tiQq ~. e ~ ° " ' u ' o a '~-~ -`- ~-- ---- _a_ ° e e r _ ~ o st' - ' ,~- ~~ __ ~ A oo ~ e D ~ Salir-as_U~I~e~_J__ _ ' ° ° ~ ~ 'C W B ~ ~ V-4- ~-- W ` e c e L.~„~~~~---- ' w . vu e Py-~__ -- ° ' ~ l ~ irm_E ---- ~ ~ ~ a e ~- h~.. -h~._ .,_d .: ,..,, ,.~ ... ~,:.. _~~:.~,.,~..:., .w~~~,w~w ,i.u.w:~uw~aaeeixaw.;as~..a~mwn,~.n:..rs.~a.a.~. ..,i. .. ..,:.... ~.. ._... . 1 0 ~ C 1 / Y Y 1 1 u 0 ~ w a u ~- ---~ `- ~1_-~ _~ ~t- ~ _~ er ~cuu ~~~ _1e / __ e ~-~ _~._e w ~u~ ~~~re css~A 11~~~ ~_ ___ --mod, I eet ~~~n e cut G m Q~tnt ~ ~ u,~ I~u I~ 1 b ~ita~-- - -~ e Qay i ~~ t~ ~ ~~ --~ ~ ~~ u ° ~ i __ W Q`~`~,~ a u ra e r~ _.~ Y ~ O -K - ~_ A l^ V L-1~ ~-LlY _L ~_~ u i I ' 0 ~~4-41-1.1.j~- l.. ~- ~ I ~ ® ~ oU --~n1 ~ e 00 ~_ J~_Q_~,~ L~ ~ z2- -- Ir eemen~ lob' i Cow n , T ' 11c ~n~_ ~ ~ ~ _ c o u _ . ~a,r ~ / ~ - ~ e oq~o __b rye _ ~ ° Y / i a S c ~n~,i c ~p -__-- y ~~ 1 „ ^ I ~ W Y 0 e~-aV_L~_~11A_l~Z~ GG _~1 I C1 - -- C W C W ~ _~_E~_ . ~ ~ av ~. ~ o_v_n~_r ~~_ y ~ c rtrd~ec~ ~- Tn ; . ~ -~ -- (,~ L -~. nn fi.~I~~ QUD`~ i ['0n L , 4~ f e-.-m~ n'~ / 66 C u- c ~J ' _ w ° pp e into u ~ ~n~ c ~ ~. , ~11_ec~_. ~.r .. .__ - t - -- >,~~ ~~.~~ .. ..u.:. ..:a.i.a.~_ ~..:..1'..~ ..aevJ's.~.m~~:w~.~w~ua:ciF:.:-.a.tdLU.titw@atiJ4±LCD.'.~am:uu¢RWLYIie.'~fitm'/A%+,. •~.• :.... ah eu::.::. r. '. J .. • Y 0 4 1 e • 4 I 1 y. --F-lll- ` ~ ~ -- ~-~ --- _. ,/ y~ ~p ~ ~~ ~ ~-~i-'~-~,sr-ELF- S ~~^-6-4`4+ i 1 / c~ 0 1 1 1 I-~ I ~ ' - q~ ~ g ~1 p~ ,~, 0 . 0 1 1 • 1 I C 6 '.9 ' W ,~ 4 1 e - --~~------ / 1 i aka- -h-i:~l-_~ao~_~~_. `~ - aw---- j~-ph ~'`~ ( p -- f ~ -~Nua~'„'-~ I C 4 IcQ17 tin rt _~ e-_ Y 1 4 l a ~ I I 1 ~ Y _s~-J~7 {.~~T-______ ' ~-{ ~-~ ' I ' ~ I W ~- -- p ~'~' ~ 6 0 / /~. l.. 1 ~ ~c ~ ~5 CG~~~-- • l ~~ GG ~ W Ic 1 ~-- y~ Iy~ 1 1 ~ I { • ~ , -^"11-1---- t t I 4 a 4 ~ bQo~.,~~ _~~~_ - -~ -- -_ __ ~,.. ._ ,. ,u,._ . nn ....a....~w,~awa. i..:r~-tica.kmvueaWe..d+vVn§VI&~vklLtiMw~IwaGS~ ~.Lw:•ua[e_ ..1a~u..ra.bl I, i .iz._.~~~: _._ _. ~/~L ~~.,,~_-~I ~~ ~s~Cl-~`~-W-~1-W14--~,-I.~-. ~~ Y-L~V _~. _._ ~ ~ '__- 1 i 1 --1-C1C~°---rLJw ----~~----~1i-~--~-~1.~.^- -Q --- ~~-ne=e -- e ~ `F e ~_ • ~ c~. a ~ 1 ~~_.~~. ~t -- ~~ yy~~ ~ e e ~~__ ~~-~~ ~ e e ~~-~_,se~~~_-- ~ ~c I ~ mne -r~1~. 0 / ~ ~ ~ s ~- ~ 1 i ned .- ' s _ ~h~ _ . ' ee-npnt ~~~__~_eic~ 1 w c e es ~ _(' . S lea °r 1 ~ ° ~- c c e~.~i-~C~-•- - ~ ~~ ' ~ -S~c - - 11 ~p~ p/~ ~~ 1. (. a ,c ~- C ~ ~~ ~~e~LIL~ ~ ' 1"~ J b ~ ~C 1 ~ t / ~~ / ~'--- / W -~S~S' ~- 'u ~G -Z -- --- ~ -~ a G ~ 11 I y ~ ~ ~L.~-- ~ (~ b-L-4f[~ _ ~ y _._ N~_.._-__ ~1nce " ~ „1, cc~-w_r~~__-- - 1 - ~--- - C e ~~ L GL / e ~~ b e _~~___ t YI-- a A 1. ----- t GG G e e ' p ~- c ern-~-- 1 "~' w 1 l o o G °~ ~S-,~~~ e~_ _~.- 1 b r o e S u' t~e.- ° ~ ° 6G ~~ I_!5~45-- t a C - C ~ / ~ r 1 0 1 .S'P YI ~, I ~ S ~ IL~_ ~~ , ,__- ~ w s ~ I ° C ~ } I/ a i ~ e- ` C --~~' ~~ eC ~ ~ ~~ eX ~ ~ ~ hi~ Nono~-~~I ~ cour t o-~ ~ommo~ P lus -,~ i~h_~~ t~t~~~ gyn. 1 1 1 ,. i 1 1 1 dY n d~~J oS? ~I~.al_i-n.~,~- v~l_~1~7 s ~D" t e ~ l-~-~~~1~1L~ __ _ cc ~ ~ ° . ~ ~otn~la.i q~- ° Va ~ac~~ct_ C b~ttun~-~ -~p~emJ~e~-- 1 1 1 1 / 1. ~ I _6 6~ i i and Zh W _!~-~4-- -N~1a-q-I-h~ ~-~\psl_q_Ct'-Z-R-r-e~l.C~S~.11_L-~'~---- ° J n o C v' tr ~ d __ o -Qn~ ° Co o e ~__ o ~c '-- 1 . 1 5~ c c 1 ~ c ~ r ~~--- o S~ ---- - e r ~~~ / 1 C -~L -~~~~Q~a-- Q y~ r 11 ~'n e. ~ Tl,~ .r~atemPnt sn__ s _... _. ...,.~ ~. w.;. '.u ._a.a .~S.L.<e:~iiska _~.w;:..i: ~Il w.5.:~~i e..if:._~ d.~J.'s~+x::._i.. :: _:_ ':.i zir.... ~.~.a. : ... ~. 0 ' e 1 ~ 1 0 e u ~~ -1~A~2 ~(~s e-~~n_~~b __~~ ~'~ '/ Y ~ ~ ~ 1 J/ .~ ~_LN III ' 4 i 6 e / J-~4~L+-6--~~t-14~-t~-J~ - 7~~ ~ Y 0 /` e _~~~_~~- / l b J- ~1 ~1~~~~ e SAO ~ ~~1 __ . ~ ~ U 6 , ~I 6 0 f ~L ,~.. _~ - S 1 4 GN !~ ~~~~~p 0 ~ y~ V l _r haute ~ ' ` ~r__- S e ~~L~~1~~ _-. _ q~~~~c~--- ~ r u11 ` _._ ~l e~l~- ~- ^ ~1--~ ~ tie ~ ~ -. ~ C ~11~e ~ }1olUe ~r~~°~~ ~ es _iq~- e .~_D~ c~_~ri ~._ _a___~t'e e~ e ) -- ~ - e A - ~ 7~---___._ 0 / ` ~ - 1 a ~~~-y~_~_fl1J-Il~!__ ~ °l._~~- G , 1 1 a ~ a a . ~ - s~ ---- ~ (`~. (y r ~D-S-i-~~~_ ~aa~_c~~n..r~~_-~..~~~-m~ 1~ __ n~ to my mo ~~I ~~ 6~~n nun~~e~_~~_~~e _ J t o ' t c ec ~ w --~~-ate o~~° ~t~ 11~ ic+-~-l,~t~---nQ.C 'r ~" -e~-}ate-_ e ~ ---- a ~ 1. om b r a i_a~ "~ia f b e hQ c __ ~ ~- ~ter ~ .rincP ~h ~~asP d m e - ` -~-~~ - --l~~i~_ ~ . ~e e Tha~a~o _- n C ~~ ~' ~ C eon me_ ` -- ~~_Y~ ~. a ' e.n c ~r -la~All~ho la-_q . a~_~~ _~n ----------- -- - .. _ _..- -- _ _ _u. i~~~_ moor u .~-~I ~. is e I 6~F4F__. ~ ._._ ~ o _ assau c ~ C ~ ' ° o u e ' ~e , n mb ~ r~ i-~-ul~ -- e e ~ has a ~ ~-- 0 ° c _ W ~ S ~ ~ e S~ "~' _0 ~~'C ~ _ 11''++ ~~' ~ti- u ~, ,~~~ , , ,~ ~ ~_ _. q e ° I /+. 1. ° ° C `Vf ~ ° 5 ° ° ~ S - --J Qja ce. ------ ~~ 1~ __ p--,s _ ° ~esu ~~ __e~ o ------- - ---- - s ~r~ ` --w-~-~cb-- ~ _ 0 c _ uJ e -~-_QV~ _a~ e ~- ------- ~._ .-- -~.-L ° J 1, U eta ~ m n t ~ ° i~~- ~U1e ~` , On -~1~P_ kern i~ t h ~ _ ~1~atin~ ~-b;ch a~icer Ro~er ~s _~ ~_ -.ss~. U e ~ ' ~Il~ Q~..~-lD. den ~~~1~ C" u° '~o e ~--C_os. --- ~ ~ ~ th ~~o ~ ~ e ~re ~__~ - - - - ° _~~~_ y c 1~ aJ~L[~_QJ1L -~ _ I,Io.S, ConS~i~SeC,~ o~~Le l~I `~~ Amen e t ~__ ~u~ ~ ~ .~ _. m ~ am _ W ~~ , ~ ale J~ c ~ ~~ an -_._---._ _--_ _-- t~..~'pue,r~I vear.e and Z wQ~ __~ni~ol~ Pr ~ in ~ _CJ°~t~1------ e -_~~ ~ "~~~_~nrA a o~rt a ~egrance _wa~____ e ~, i n n~~1~- 4 ,~_%S~[-~~ T ____ ° ° 1 1 ~ C ~ ~ ~5~1-i.-.- ° ~ ' l J J , ~~~„ ~, e ~. c ~~_QE _~~Q--____. W ~ `S 1 ~ _._~e- ~ r~~qqL- - ` ?~a~ gos~c~~ has i.eie~e ~`~ e ~ ~ u - C ~ C ~ L~o U1~f -~ ~ _ -_ P~ ~ i~p S~SJ 1~ L! t D ~1 . . . --- ~~ ' 1 ' ~ ~ ~ ~ rn~rn ~ Q__S~l_ ~ -- a ° ~- ' u c _~ w ` ~s.c. ° ~ C ' t ~~° - °~. ,, e.- °.~ .. G~ .~~~~. n{. .Inn n ~ 1~n1i 1+ nr x-aNf~~v_ I-yr~~ tnp,ip~TUa C,r~oiC,y wig ~r~i~ w-~~ u ~~G-~~v.i~ ~.~ ~~~,~~~- cy u ~ c o uJ1At ° E o u S C s ` o P ~ _ ___ _ aw ° e . T9ranLoue ~~ _ o e _~~ _a r~ ___ g_i1~c~. a ~-a-~ - .0 n_~ _ ~ _~ °• 0 Y~ ~JP_ C o u o' e 0 ~1 l~ I~q_ _ ~J_~_ I ---- g rll I~ C e ~ t ~ Q--~~4- - i n ~. ~ . j ~,.,~ ~ ~x~~~~~..~°'° -~ - -. _ _ ~~, r._~, mmo i it - ~~~~i,.w .~... ,~ ~ etl' , Lewivmow~ns' LAWN-I,i1Wi'ERS' g ,.7 NFTREPLACECENTRE ~ E ~ rv-w~xs i#~yHN {~ }X ~~~~^^ F m, pd+Nm k ~C071t1hllerr ~ - , 85 ARnr ~tl~'~~~ ":~ J C Cobb SmaN Erigtne HePalr is , n ,~ `~"J' a ~ , x,300StOnerDrMltltlletoWn '! r ^~- ^~~' .. ""~r ~~~ RyDbl , s -6441197 wl~.,, ~ ' s, ,~t„s'~` 7,4303CZr8slePlkeCa`'' ~3;n~,< ~~rLawnOrnamtenta ;... m6~lUl 7671617 ,SEE Garden Centers BOTA LAWN & GARDEN TRACTORS t ,:Lawn & Garden E iu"' & Su , "`' ,~ ~. ~sn~ ,x Statuary 4 P PPBea ~~ 'y"K y~~. '~ ~x 9Ali,",4&8ER1'{CE (, e , e _. ' f : ,%` ~~ *,m , ,~ ~. LEerttvoN^r ~ ~~r , Laver[ Splaying KBIERBRtlS~(UBO7ARd Lebanon', SEE'LawuRigmtensnoe,:; £ ~"70N Poaa-- ~ ~ Weed Control Service ^'' ~'^""*•--~--800363 2767 fr w(iCareEqulpii7entCenterLLP .w ~Lawn$i5nnklere`8c3prin>tiiiy ~` „OrlsbnOl Rd Martlntlal ~• g ~. . e~..~.ri .Y„~r 4541 : "BEE Irri` sYiatezns MamtepanC@~ ~~-4 kt" ,r t : gatidnSyetAms'~73 n+` t ` i - ~ RN4rJ;tl Mrddle Paxton . SPrinlclers-Garden;& LewnP `^ i ~ ~ ~fl''POwer EgUlpRlerlt lfiC ., 927 2319 ~ , .: OrkRtlCadhle -" `~ + ~^ ". R'S'er-BarLAeBOOiations ""~''''^u.T"<. 4~raa„*a:lr>~D 1e s ;;;, '-""-"~"-'--='249.5338 "SEE Lawyers' Referral & Informalaan S€mce " r^ `E~hiM1911tCompan"`°`~ :;, ~ ~~ ~'~~,";~I.OW StCartlsi°%~~,'~~~" "`~24~-2686 p~~ SEA ~a~or Bei'err~l $e e . An4ek Peter G WW DfflC a a ~rr)r MOWer Sales`$JOrilr.,e , -a wyere'Referrel.Bi Info~a11on 9e ~ OhtltDWn Rd OIItSbbrgu ~xi j r.- ti rMoe 2001 N North FrpnTSt Marrlaa 4 ,Bf SeNlce E21 Run ktl`darttste-_~2 550fi ~ ~ ~ 5, "' - ' An9e109 P@ter~C 232189G. " toS Ub ~"; ~'1¢ , ~~ ?4$7833 -; ~ -2001 MFfOM 8t H3715burg ~~S~J~~~ '~ '~ ,e ~ <~,-i peters Nlfi Rtl HaB~a ~ `~r 2321886k ~gGlpl»entCO =~r~~° "+ - e9s3414 A'MarkWtrtter ~. _ , ANGINDr&R05gVER " FntcheyStreet ~"'i , -' ~ - 310WChocolatdAVeNersh ~ " r ~nh-----.:545 2051 ABOm Johfl A :. ~ ~ ~`~ ~ .. ~ ~rL8WnC8r@d4Falrfie(d52Car1LS1e 2492505 ';86oUtNHanbverSOCartlshf " ~ ,~ e rr 105&S@NIC@r~ ~ , , -=106 Wamut~t liamsbUrg--_.__.,~~2;~ e ~ _, 2~'MlBersbu ' I' rh ~ 8501 ABOM & KUTUTAKIS • ~ , i BFRGER'S OF FOMTANA ~v ~. ~ JOHN A: ABOM ~,~* ~~ ay.,, 1.~,a~~r , + ' ' Y4~MIIes E OF iranjppa'Aigwn :i`~7 5y61 ` (FORMER CUMBERIAWO000NTya SPP~~' ~ see'oarmprtaypb ~f1-TF7gLPA 1 ~. DIS7RICTATTOAN~ „ ~~Ea1O1'EAHSr , v ~' &TUrf LLC ,± v'rktr „„y.~s ,±~s ~ ~: !~ 7 B:ROatlRt225Hal6aitry,!" :~s:, ~~'JASO~NP.~KUTULAIUS -_- ~'',liecogh(zetl'~'~` ` II° 3823132 tSOLICITORbAUPNMCOUNTY ':' BestL,e AMe1rtoa,4 ,, ~fI Wq 8: Gardet7 rtr~r~ z yl ~ CHO.DAEN &' YOUTH:SERVIC6S} '', Bar.RegfaEet~p'~~ f ` WMatn St Palmyra "~ ,~N,Ir®~.: ~ „;~.-r, 5337900 -, ~. CFIIMINAG'bEFENSE :.".-r ~MIRb/f'~a~°'A'~Forurq, ., ., . ":..FAMILY LAW ~ :: ...... ~ ";..,, t .... ~' '105 walnutstHamsbur^- ~ ~ 23z•§sr1 AUTOMt7BILEACCIDHNTS" - 8 s Hanbverstcarnsle--_.:___~~ygg.~p e 1 Atom & KDtmakis "A4EDICAC MALPRACTICE, ~h'MbWeiRepati'Senilc@„ loswamutseHamsburg-~~232.9511 WORKPkACEINJURIES" , ' 993AIieMbwngrydHarclsburg-.._540.g~ Abom&Kutulaklscanist°- Q' 06ui71s Small Engine SeNice Abraham taw offices _. 232.6511 ~ ' PER50NAI, INJURIES ,8208 Gettysburg Rd (LOWerAOen Shopplri0~ . , . 513 N 2 Sr Harrsburg--~_~ 8nten~CamP HM~.__:_^-_,__-737 8648 232-7825 _ : ~ :;. ~.~ ERTlIne "~' Adler & Atller 125 Locust St Han'Isburg 234-3289 - FR o Repair .~,'~.f ~~ - Ahmatl Anser ~ Recove NS 107MS5lake Rtl Etkers--=-._____~93B-~3 Serving Harrisburg qm. -' ry/No Fee N'Aa1AN/N SERVICE INC ANMAD & MIRIN ,-, ~- '~ ~iV10WBR' ~.. servmgHarnsburgaFea---.-_= 909-x343 238-6791 ;" ~ r 'REPAIR Anrensihsoma~b~'d°~AtlAA~B4~O (800)`_648-2070'' "SHOP ~ ' 5521 CaNtsie Pkd Mechanlcsbrg ~-~.~, 697.1800 - ~.engMo-rovnefcom , r ~ uwM ~,~, ,- Alexander lane M ° ' ~ 4503 NORTN FRONT ST. ~ " 1 ~, MakA9 & Modeta • Blade~SharpeNn - ' 148 S xatdmore DIIhWUrg ~"- • • " ~ 43'1.4514 ` ' tsa1@towgrs•111mrbera-Sn' " 9 Allen Heath L210 WalnutBtHaM '" HARRISBURG, Pq 17110 `OhkkiUP And bexvery Ava6etiloWe ~WSa ~alnsa'a All@n PBUI '-- ~r5'8011. , 4700 UntOn DepOSR Rtl SUtte 260 .. '" ~ -Anner Car0lynM ~ ~,; . rag-Lendscepe'Mainrenersce-Tanbark" Harclsbur9 , 1300 Ungfestown Rtl HarrlsbnM - - 238.2000 i "Ril"inal a Senror G78zen Diacourns Alzamora John~"651-Oi71 Anst(ne Timothy M , „. ~~ ~x,. -. 212 LOCUSTST Harrisburg -~~IWPine St Harisburg--_....-_~ ~ Cettysbiirg'Rd Mechanic'stiurg..T67:7075 gnderson DavlD C 2S5•M33. 'Apitelli Samuel W -. . 221'1111! MoblleMOWerS@NIC@ +:- 3940L000StLnHarrlsburg- ~'.:305FrpntStNNarnSburg ~23R5516i toCUSt WaY Ol1L5buM 432.0932 /intlelSOn JanICB L :.: 541 1194. , . Archer ihOmaS A Harrisburg RSROEBUCKANDCO" 71arS1NerFOxCfHUmmeNtO `° Armstrob9Patrkla 233.x676- fowls Rtl Harrisburg And@5 SamUei 1525 N 12 StLemoyne--._761 536' ~ Ar05@ I Safah W 305 N Frdnt St HaMaburg-255.7231 ' ~•.n-""~ '-'------°6D469-0663 " AnUreW W Barhln PC, ._ ~""'---256 7621 - OWBC'$YL' ~ ~- 123 State SC HaMSbUrg----_._~--2~-g~:,`,;;.ArtZ Charl@Si&RS60CIatCS SCausburg Midtlletown"" `044,9830 •Mdrew's &JOhn50n Z075rate St HatrlsbWg-_-__2389905; blpment'MAIM@nanCe~WPtSTCartlste--.~:_,_-243.0.123.° ~hingerJaCk F212 Locust St Harnsbuig.255.760g Ritlge Rtl D1111burg.-_-_"i~2,~74 "A~InASmUS Dartl@IC212 Locust St Harn;bu 9 WNllam H " , ,.., rg=255.782AI , - ,.~ 234 NOrtFI NOrtn~St HarAst>7~ '=' a ~.. E-YE40W BOOK WAY. ~ ~ 2344728-,~ l'•+. CONTINUED NEXT PA@E ~ ,,::.. i ~"', ~~i ...~~~ ":" COMINUED NEXTCOLUMN. ~. .,4NDIT HERE flRST-FAST, ; v~~ ~, _ . .___ ~~~ POWER OF ATTORNEY AND FEE AGREEMENT ~ X~ 1 p I BY SIGNING THIS AGREEMENT, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I (WE) HAVE ENGAGED THE LAW FIRM OF ANGINO & ROYNEi~, P.C. (HEREINAFTER A & R), TO REPRESENT ME (US) UNDER THE FOLLOWING TERMS AND CONDITIONS: A & R may on my (out) behalf secure medical, work and other similar records, conduct an investigation, negotiate, and if necessary start suit against anyone responsible for my (our) injuries and .losses with respect to Mb~LGy G~P etCLtG2 4~ ~' '1- 14 - O ~, with full power and authority .to ._ appear on behalf of the undersigned in any Court of record or in any administrative or other proceeding, to do and perform all and every act and thing whatsoever that may be requisite and necessary to be done in connection with the above claim as fully as the undersigned might or could do if personally present; hereby ratifying and confirming all that said attorneys shall lawfully do or cause to be done therein by virtue of this power of attomey. 2. I (we) understand that so long as the case is handled by an A & R attorney, I (we) will not be responsible for any fees and/or expenses unless a recovery or benefit is obtained. If my (our) case is handled to a successful completion by an A & R attorney, I (we) agree to pay A & R all reasonable out-of-pocket expenses without the payment of interest, plus a fee for time expended as follows: ' ~~ i~ A & R ME (US) a. SETTLEMENT PRIOR TO STARTING SU[T 30% 70% b. SETTLEMENT FOLLOWING SUIT BUT PR[OR TO TRIAL OR ARBITRATION 35% 65% C. SETTLEMENT OR VERDICT AT TRIAL OR ARBITRATION, AFTER TRIAL, ARBITRATION, OR APPEALS OR SHORTLY BEFORE TRIAL AND AfiIER CASE HA~"BEEN TOTALLY PREPARED 4O% 60% d. IF NO-FAULT RECOVERY OR NON-MONETARY BENEFIT: RICHARD C. ANGINO ($500); NEIL J. ROVNER ($450); ASSOCIATES ($400) PER HOUR BUT NOT TO EXCEED 40% OF TOTAL RECOVERY OF VALUE OF BENEFIT e. OTHER CASES 4. If for any reason I (we) take my (our) case to another attorney or law firm including a former A & R attorney or handle it myself (ourselves),1(we) recognize that A & R has, in good faith, expended money and time for my (our) benefit and I (we) therefore agree to pay, or have my (our) new attorney pay, immediately, upon severing the A & R attomey/client relationship, all the out-of-pocket expenses incurred on my (our) case plus interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of each expenditure. In addition, when the case is successfully concluded, I(we) agree to pay or to direct my (our) new aiiorney io pay as a ~ 20% of the gross receve.; to A. & R. 5. In the event that any settlement is made on a structured or deferred payment basis, A & R shall be entitled to receive their percentage based on the present value of the' structured settlement, if paid as a lump sum at the time o1 settlement. ,I (we) agree not to settle or discuss settlement of my (o(u~~r)~.c~ras~/e without the written consent of A & R. BY SIGNING THIS AGREEMENT, THIS ~_ DAY OF 20_, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I (WE) HAVE READ, UNDERSTOOD, AND RECEIVED A COPY OF SAME AND AGREE TH ITS TERMS AND CONDITIONS. WITNES ..S CLIENT(S): X M 1" ~l~ 111t ~ r lh1 P II~(SEAL) (SEAL) ~O~R~ - revised 2100 ~~~~~~ NOV 1 5 2005 DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINiNI[~.AND PACE BY: RANDY C. 6REENE, ESQ!U31R.E FsY: ATTORNEY I.D. # 62692 1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard 14e' Floor c?4Ltamey for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215)563-3500 Dale Wintermeyer Plaintiff(s), v, Joseu Salinas-Valdez Defendant(s). COURT OF COMMON PLEAS .. OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY .. NO.: 01-5417 r J ~I DEFENDANT JOSEU SALINrye!S='WALDEZS' BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF HIS MOTION TO DISMIS;5IEQ)R FAILURE TO PROSECUTE Defendant Joseu Salinas-Va7ode:z, by and through his counsel, Dugan, Brinlanann, Maginnis and Pace, files this Brief i m support of his Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute and states as follows: I. STATEMEL'~'T' Il]F THE QUESTION INVOLVED A. SHOULD PLAINTIFF'S ~C:e4_USE OF ACTION BE DISMISSED FOR PLAINTIFF'S FAILURE TO PROSECUT)~-'I5 ACTION IN A TIMELY MANNER? Suggested Answer: Yes: II. S7'et4.T'EMENT OF THE CASE P'~~O~CEDURAL HISTORY Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer q1~e-reanafter referred to as "Plaintiff'), filed a complaint against Defendant Joseu Salinas-Va.l~d~ez (hereinafter collectively refereed to as "Defendant"), in the Court of Common Pleas of Currnibedtand County on September 17, 2001. The Plaintiff s Complaint alleged physical injuries and property damage stemming from a collision between Plaintiffs motorcycle and Defendantt's automobile ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C. 4503 NORTH FRONT STREET RICHARD C. ANGINO MICHAEL E KOSIK 11ARI115EURG, PA 171104706 NEa J. RovNeR RICHARD A. SADLOCK JOSEPH M. MELILLO JOSEPH M. DOAIA 717/238ti791 TERRY S. HYhiAN JAMES DECINTI FAx 717/23&5610 DAVID L. Lutz WWW.ANGW6AOVNER.COM t f Eh1AILe DLUTZ@ANGR~76ROVNER.COM ~~ ~ I I ~~ JJ,/, tV August 30, 2001 Mr. Dale Wintermeyer 1406 Carlisle Road Camp Hill, PA ] 7011 iJi:aL 1V11. Y1111iC1i1iCy l:1. Enclosed is a second drafr of the Complaint. Please note tha± we have made changes to paragraph 8, 12, 13, and 16. Based ou our meeting of August 28, 2001, I understand that you will complete paragraph 9, listing, in detail, the parts that were damaged and the cost of labor. Once you obtain the information to complete paragraph 9, send the Complaint and executed Verification back to my office, and I will initiate the litigation. Secondly, enclosed are the records we recently received from the Holy Spirit Hospital. Very truly yours, David L. Lu DLL.:mtg Enclosure 234395.1\DLLIMTG OFFICE OF PROTHONOTARY Cumberland County (4 i CARLISLE, PA. 17013 ~ i•2C`~A tP1iB' ~h u?rl1 Q~ DATE Qibi~. /7o7CD(o This is to notify you that No. ~~ _ -~ tf/ 7 yL~'s~itc.Y~~ 19 has been Relisted for Trial at the _LV~~~-"~ /~ ~~~ Term 19 of Court. Pre-Trial date ~~~ ~a,~ 7~~~ 19 ~_ P HOHOT RY 3' ~. '~: ~1 ~ ~ ~ d q t~ ~ q) T- O G,S ~--. ~ c~ r- ~ ~ 9 ,~X _ G ~ ~ a v ~° L ~ ~ O ~.F..~ G~-. °'~--' ~ Q O~ ~~ ~, E s caa 44 ua 5~= qua ~E u