HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-06413
, ~""-'.~
,I,J "'.__ ,,~~< -'-",_-_" :" ,",,'>-.[ ."'." '-viA' ,.-'. ~,-",.,~
11/13/2001 12:53 FAX 717 730 7366
REAGER & ADLER
1aI002
WALSH TRUCKING SERVICES, LiC,
Plaintiff
v.
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: NO. 01- t...LfIJ, C~oJ.-, '7-~
NINA LOUISE OBERLIN aIkIa
NINA OBERLIN HACH,
Defendant
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NOTICE
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the
following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are
served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the
court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you
fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the
court without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or fOT any other claim or
relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to
you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO
NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-3166
4
,,,.~,,~"'-- ,,"~~ ~..~
-.~
'~
"
~'~".~~)!i
.
.
WALSH TRUCKING SERVICES, LLC,
Plaintiff
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 61 - (.,.CfJ.:3 Q 1C,)~l 't-~
NINA LOUISE OBERLIN a/kJa
NINA OBERLIN HACH,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
COMPI,AINT
1. The Plaintiff is Walsh Trucking Services, LLC (hereinafter "Walsh"), a
corporation incorporated and doing business under the laws of the State of New York, with its
principal place of business located at 50 Burney Avenue, Massena, New York 13662.
2. The Defendant is Nina Louise Oberlin a/kJa Nina Oberlin Hach (hereinafter
"Hach"), an adult individual currently residing at HCR 33, Box 122, Harrison, Arizona 72601.
3. On August 18,2000, the tractor and trailer owned by Plaintiff Walsh was lawfully
and carefully operated in a northerly direction by the driver of the tractor and trailer on Interstate
81 North located in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
4. At that time, date and place, Defendant Hach negligently, recklessly and
carelessly operated her Nissan 2000 X-Terra and attached UHAUL trailer by negligently,
recklessly and carelessly swerving her vehicle and attached UHAUL trailer into the lane
occupied by Walsh's tractor and trailer so as to cause the UHAUL trailer to collide with Walsh's
tractor and trailer causing serious property damage as is more fully described herein.
5. At the time of the accident, Defendant Hach was negligent, reckless and careless
under the circumstances by:
a. Failing to have her motor vehicle under proper and reasonable control;
b. Operating her motor vehicle in such a mauner as to cause it to collide into and
against Plaintiff Walsh's tractor and trailer;
'"
lii.
......
"
. I
~"'.... "
~~<i!l1.'I~;f;
c. Failing to give prompt, proper and adequate warning of her movement into the
lane occupied by Walsh's tractor and trailer;
d. Operating her motor vehicle without due regard to the presence and safety of
Plaintiff Walsh;
e. Failing to operate her motor vehicle so as to avoid the collision;
f. Failing to operate her motor vehicle in a safe and proper manner;
g. Operating her motor vehicle at a high and excessive rate of speed under the
circumstances;
h. Failing to comply with the laws, rules and regulations of the Pennsylvania Motor
Vehicle Code 75 Pa.C.S. ~3301, et. seq. pertaining to the operation of motor
vehicles in or about the public highways in a safe manner. In particular the
Defendant operated her vehicle and trailer in violation of the following Vehicle
Code Section:
(a) ~3303 Overtaking vehicle on the left
(b) ~3309 Driving on roadways laned for traffic
(c) ~3310 Following too closely;
1. Failing to operate her motor vehicle with due regard to the position of other
vehicles on the road including the Plaintiff s tractor and trailer; and
J. Failing to operate her motor vehicle with attached trailer in accordance with the
requirements and guidelines of the owner of the trailer.
6. As a result of the negligence, recklessness and carelessness of Defendant Hach
which caused the aforesaid collision, Plaintiff Walsh suffered substantial damage to its tractor
and trailer. The invoices evidencing the damage caused by Defendant Hach to Plaintiff Walsh's
2
~,J~
,1 _"
'" <,
.I _ ~-~~ ~ "
;-,<,'~.",,^ ;&hill::VlIl-li:~\>
.
tractor and trailer and the costs to repair the damages are attached hereto and incorporated herein
by reference as Exhibit "A".
7. As a result of the Defendant's negligence, recklessness and carelessness, the
Plaintiff has suffered personal property damages and other related damages in the principal
amount of $23,900.43.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Walsh Trucking Services, LLC respectfully requests this
Honorable Court to enter judgment in its favor and against Defendant, Nina Louise Oberlin a/k/a
Nina Oberlin Hach in the amount of $23,900.43, plus interest and costs.
Date: November 13, 2001
Respectfully submitted,
RE~
Thomas O. Williams, Esquire
Attorney J.D. No. 67987
2331 Market Street
Camp Hill, PA 17011-464
Telephone: (717) 763-1383
Attorneys for Plaintiff
3
.C,!
1~.4,' ~
-,
"
PLEASE RETURN I
THIS PORTION
OF THE INVOICE
WITH YOUR
PAYMENT
,"""
r
I
WAlSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena, NY 13662
1315) 769-3574
PAfE
s
o
L
D
OifilSHT
WilLSH T'llJf.K1NG SERlIlCE, IN(
5& aURIlf.'i AVE.
S
H
I
P
SHIIE
T
o
\lIASstNA, ~, 12<;&2
T
o
"
. .. . ....
.. .
.
00/10/00 J
Ei!3 08/30/80
0HlAl.E
R'~35M~1
WHIiD DEl r1; ~ 7"
UM Eil
S~li!1P~d
o \1000
R23~~05
TlI.BO nmmT
1.0000 E~
5hipp(?d
531.2111
531.21
t~~l3.;,13~
t.{~ EH
s~., 1 Dp~:j
:~~~. y't 44- 2"J, :;;
1 ,t 6000 14.&
16.2222 3f'02-
4. me 1.;:
TUBE
i~V..t,)J,~r;..,~
~RJ1;;I'H
EhlPpe1j
i.'WOO tl1
ZFAll31'30133
Q I1l.Illi'lilP B1lHCK8 SfT
Sti ipped
1.0000 Ell
2,+n\l MF
2'X30 ElAfJi iIL'lln FLAP
5I\lpped
1. ilOO0 Ell
:rrM! J'j0402
STAINLESS STEEL Ilt't:PTtP rnffiERS
t. 0000 :3ET
lQ4.43.J3
Sl1ipoeo
,Jf'."<:---------------------.-
."""---"
:;~'( ,
'''n,'~~.,
Please Remit To:
WAJIi'filtIPME'm CO.
50 Burney Ave.
t.fiI3l"m!l!lUWll6!\E
llAI..SHT
,-
,
WAlSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena,NY 13662
(315) 769-3574
5
o
L
D
~iAtS!J("
WflSH TmjC~ING SER~lCE, :~~
50 hlll*EY A'iE.
5
H
,
P
T
o
S~'4f:
T
o
AASSt:NH, Ui 1 ~
,.
.". . . '"' I'
.. .
0S/3\l/00
203 0Bl30!OO
]
01-SllLE
t1:m~1-'S31G-i3-t
JURi\! sr&\fAt,
Shipp.d l.@000 H\
Ship?ed c\ 0000 EA
Shipp8l lr.~ EA
?J":iCpt1j 4. ~~~)~ f~
Stnpp~d 12.\~ IN
Shipped 10ll0OO Ell
ShlDt1-2.j 24~. EA
06-t;d79-~~~1
eATltRY BOLT LONE
! .?:- ~~~4~Hlt~2
::'U:;,~; ~rSS~
:.1:3..'/,"
:'i(fSE [.t.PM-r
::4'l4~
~ 1/211 HOE{
1133-1OC
l;GSf TO I1AI.E Plpf H. 51B' P 318'
?i~ -:::~;)llb..;(j02
nr~t
f:J1ll!E - -.-------------------------..-
'-,
'"
~,,~;
Please Remit To:
;'Hi:'[ 2 wALiiA!ifu'PMEk CO
50 Burney Ave.
;M.~!\!,e'1'\iI~:\llr.w"f
\~HLSH\
. OOI~~OO ~:~;~
B. Gt-oo ,~. ~> , I
f
1
;.455& ~2.5 \
4!~.I;&t7 :~:0.6 I
I
.
1
. ~.~.:+.." , ",
..1 .
;i
,;
ii
1,15'13 ') ~ I . I'
...~. . 11
I
..sm 4.
31,055~ 52.1 I
Ii
I'
PLEASE RETURN "
THIS PORTION Ii
OF THE INVOICE
WITH YOUR .,
PAYMENT I
,
I
1
I
I
i
..
--.u~_ _ .
, ~ ,JlL '. : ~ -. _.'" ":'_'~,
-, J _I '_~
' . .,'" -,,:-~~ :~ . ;,~, .' ,;,l._.]-1 -
~-'--~_~"- :r~, ":-': c ~_f"<
r
I
WALSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena, NY 13662
(315) 769-3574
WALSHT
IlALSH TW INll SERVICE, IOC
50 BURlEY A\lEo
SllI1E
Please Remit To:
Pf6E 3 W~IPMJrrCO.
50 Burney Ave.
~~INB65E
l/IllSHT
s
o
L
D
T
o
S
H
I
P
i'lA!JSENil, m 13662
T
o
1lll/30/e0 . J
. . . . ...
283 Illlj30Je0
.. ,
.
"
.
"
01-!llt.E
'ea/311/llf 808i8813
~_r>e!-_
.':
- ~, -~ .' --'
, '~ ,'~'.-'~_,'~_(.i:' ':".:t:(~_h'
r
I
WALSH EQUIPMENTCO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena, NY 13662
(315) 769-3574
\IAl.SHT
WALSH TRUCKll'IG SERVICE, [Nt:
50 BlIRIEY AYE.
SAME
Please Remit To:
PAGf' a_'
· WALSHEllOIPMEfu CO-
50 Burney AVe.
Wllf!\W"t\IOO\ lilr'oE
lJIllSHT
s
o
L
D
T
o
S
H
I
p
MI1BSENA, /lY 13662
T
o
..
I"'
I 1-...
.. .
I
I
I
0ll/3lI/11ll J
'203 08/30/'"
BHillJ.E
1
0001881~ 08J38/eIl 00018813
11-n0 Shi pptd 1.0111!0 Ell 7.4222
ELECTRICAl OOX
E-107t\f, Sh ipped 10. EA 43.mB 43~2
LINES
035\\38 Sh ip~,ed ?.0Ilt'll EH 3,05% ;.1
lftHVER3'\!.. GU1& HlUIO
2003-6-b Shipp<d 1.0000 EA 1.25$ L~.
an
4401-65 Shipped 2.00Il0 EA 3.72bl 7.4
SUI~
22-38930-~ Shipped _ I.. EA 10.8889 lU
MI:<l1DR
11021 Shipped I.WOO fA 49.3&'l9 4903
S' III.HLER f
PLEASE RETURN
THIS PORTION
OF THE INVOICE
WITH YOUR I
PAYMENT
NAME--------------- -------
~' "-
,~- --~ '..'1 '-
~_: ,~~ ---~:u.~,~;-~ .,,"_,4,,:~:::t"-jt":"~(~::~'_'1
~i'Jj:c_
r
I
WALSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena. NY 13662
1315) 769-3574
PAGE
.
-
Please Remit To:
W,JlffifuIPM~ co.
50 Burney Ave.
oIt.~~~ir1ll6SE
WI1I..511T
S
o
L
D
iiIlLSHT
Wi1LSH TRllCKING SERUICE, me
50 IlUfIllE'IWlE.
SAiIf.
S
H
I
P
T
o
11ilSSEIlA, N'I 13662
T
D
J
.. .
.
,.
.
2Il3 0lli:J81.
0HlII.E
.... 138"'011819813
1&-1237H00 SIlipptd 2.. Ell 18.7222 :fl. 4
filRIiIIl HAllSER PIli
2901-S 5l1ipped 2._ Ell 801m 16.2
5" STA!liESS FLEX PIPE
150.3-6 Sh ipped 5.1II0llll FT 3. 1649 15.
flllSE
2l7-017g Shipped LoMlOO Ell 36. Wl4
i:LOOW
217-099'2 Shi pped I.. Ell 3801lll0l1 38.
EL9f1l
Dli-P5E'.l151 SIlipptd I.. Ell 44.9222
PLASTIC
HtlN-I3-"GHL5 Shipped 1.00IlIl Ell 13.9222
ELlllJIl
PLEASE RETURN
THIS PORTION
OF THE INVOICE
WITH YOUR
PAYMENT
N"l'!E----------. ------
-~ ,
""
~r
" -~,
'-"" ~ ^'
'<~'[ '"f:'~~,'
r
I
WALSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena. NY 13662
(315) 769-3574
WAlSHT
WW_SH rRllOi,{,~ SERIfICE. {\'-Ie
50 BUR!~Y AVE.
SAtE
Please Remit To:
PI16f. 6 oa;:;~...
WALSHrotJlPMEI<rT co_
so Burney Ave.
~~'\"ilJe'd~~
IoIALSHT
s
o
L
D
T
'0
S
H
I
P
MAS"..ENA, NY 13662
T
o
"
,.,
. .....
.. ,
.
.
,
.
081311i9t J
~ e8/~i0l1
111-SIl.E
1
1lll130/11 *18813
~-----_._----_._---
,",~.",,-
~."_k
1-(
J_.-J
,-'L' .~ -~
,~" "''''-''M-oiIi
r
I
WALSH EaUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena, NY 13662
(315) 769-3574
s
0-
L
D
loiALSHT
wALSH iRlJCI,ING _~'fRI}l(,E, iNC
50 BUFM::i AVC
SAME
Please Remit To:
PAGE 7 p.'1I'l"
. wALSH I'OOIPM~NT C0-
SO Burney Ave.
~~'ffil.lI':)(1006~
iliILSlH
S
H
I
P
T
o
MIlSSENIi, N'i 13E,&l
T
o
'0
. .. ~
... ..
00/30/lI8 J .
00/30liltl
.. .
01..sft.E
.
lB-2!!6<'1-@I!(! Sh i pped I. 0il00 EA 31.3776
BIlACE
Ifl-29tl61-003 Shipped 1.1l0lllI EA 3009556
llAIa
2h~lIH03 Sh i pped 1.0000 EA 269. 1333 269.1"
AiR OOM
21-20128-014 Sll i pped 1. 0e0ll EA 34.1222 lJito!
END CilP
?1-i?0ti:8-015 Shipped 1 ~ 0000 EA 8~.1222 8401
END CAP
21-OCMlt-f11!0 Shipped 2.1l0lllI EA 28.6111 57.
SlJIlPORT TROO< 281
?1-~000 Shipp~d 2.110\10 EA 802111 160
SlmnlT
PLEASE RETURN
THIS PORTION
OF THE INVOICE
WITH YOUR
PAYMENT
P&'i'IE--------------J----
~,
,-.:I~, ~".
, ,',;, :', ,C-,' _ ~ _, "-~_- ~ '''''(--1.' tl-'~
r
I
WALSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena, NY 13662
(315) 769-3574
\Il1LSm
WAlSH TRUCKING seRVICE, INC
50 BU!lIIEY AVE.
SAllE
Please Remit To:
PAGE a W~IPM&CO-
50 Burney Ave.
ik1l!;lf'T",(lfJt'f\ IMfsE
WilLS/iT
5
o
L
D
T
o
S
H
I
P
MA'3SENIl, NY 13662
T
o
"
I-I. I I I It
.. ,
.
.
MIJ9I01) J
203 M/38f0fl
01-!lf1lE
21-25134-000 Shipped l.ll0Il0 Ell 11.38Il9
SUPPORT
A2N~1 Shipped l.l!IlI0IlI Ell 114. i222 11401
CrnnetlEllR NEW S1Yl.E
H22- 323'JtH00 Sl1ipJlj!d 2.l!IlI0IlI EA 40.2222 00.
FIlRING ~
2'2-c>239IHl00 Shlpp~d 2.0000 Ell 17.06b7 34.1
B..,CIlET
22-321f23-11OO Shipped 2.0000 EA 5.781l9 110
PlAIE
22:-33012-000 Shipped 1.'- Ell 51.8UI 51.8
3m> END PlATE
22-3J.i}12-i101 Shipped l.M0 Eli 510. 51.
Sl Ell ElOD PlATE
PLEASE RETURN
THIS PORTION
OF THE INVOICE
WITH YOUR
PAYMENT
NfIIIE
:. 'J
T'
I
WALSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena, NY 13662
(315)769-3574
s
o
L
D
WAlSHT
WALSH TRUCK-IN6 SERIJICE, we
50 JlURNEY RVE.
S
H
I
P
T
o
Sil/l!E
T
o
mssENIl, NY 13662
..
.". " . ......
.. ,
iIlI/3Ml. J
283 08/311/i!
I
0HlIU
L.
::' "~_ ' C~_t~~~~~, ;~.- '}st~~'~ - 't -~,' ( "
Please Remit To:
PAGE S WJ~'PM&-CO.
50 Burney Ave.
~":SH''m\lt\IIfl86Sf
WALSflT
.
, I
"
.
"1
-
" "_~
'...' '~_ J
~' ---'
',..
'; .
o,,,,,__;-"~" .,;." (,;;;C_ _0"" 11'1:::.::
.,--
r
I
WALSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena, NY 13662
(315)769-3574
S
o
L
D
WAl~,IT
WALSH Bur!\lN6 SERVICe, INC
50 BURNEY AVE.
SANE
Please Remit To:
PAGE:@ W~IpJ,fuCO.
50 Burney Ave.
Wtle~"t'P./lff< lil;t6'SE
WAlSHl
T
o
MIl5SEN1l, NY 13662
S
H
I
P
T
o
.'
.. I . . II" t ..
.. .
.
.
.'
.
~~/3!lfllil . J
283 08/3t/ll0
01-Sll.E
08/3M18 i'l0018813
1i€I6-17H3~1 Shipppd 20000ll ER &3.5-;44
RlJAJJl.I!3IiT
IB-2!l&'I-ooil Shipped 1.0Ii00 Ell 3103716
BRACE
2Hl347-~ Sh:pp~rl 2.0000 EA 87,91lil'3 l7'5,~
BRCC;Jtl
0.1-213'k).~, Snppad 20000\1 &1 5.32?2
S'~AP
2iH2:J94-000 Shipppd 2.i'1000 Elf 702178 14.
STEP BRIlL'I<ET
22-~H80 S'llipped 20. EA 3.35Sb 6, 7
S:EP
:103~'2';'5S4-00e ShlP\)~lj 2,_ EA 115.3556 230.7
FUEL TAtll( STRI,PS
PLEASE RETURN
THIS PORTION
OF THE INVOICE
WITH YOUR
PAYMENT
~-------
. ,:'
-
I ^ _ ~
, -""":-~ ,";~'
'Hl;t't')~~
r
I
WALSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney AVe.
Massena, NY 13662
(3151769-3574
irR..SHT
WALSH TW.lfifl Sf.RV1Cf, IN!:
50 lllIRNEY AVEo
SiN
Please Remit To:
PI!6[ I i DtIr... f ,
WAlSH EOlJIPMEM CO-
50 Burney Ave.
~'1'llJtl'.lN663E
~SHT
s
o
L
D
T
o
S
H
I
P
MHSSENA, NY 13tli2
T
o
..
I.. .
I.. .'
.. .
.
.
"
.
1181311i. J
l!83 il813tlillll
81-5AI.E
2H311l'H'i111l Sh ip;nd u. fA 5103778
DUCT
H0l!-I0339-002 Shlppl!D 1.- EA 31.06&7 31.0
BRilOiET
A21-Z54~3-I!0\1 Shipped 1.0llil0 Ell &0.0222 &eo
STt"P BRALF3
;1.22-3%,,,\.0;,5 Shi~ped IoMlil EA \31.4_ i31.~
CAB EXlEf510N
.21-25182-0tIil Shipped 1,_ EA tis. 3444 115.
BIJI""R nTEtt
A!8-2e&\~__ Shi!lPed 1._ EA 144.0778 1'\4.
LATCH
~j'&-13412-OOt S'hipped 10\111I10 f.G 19'UT/8
SPRms
PLEASE RETURN
THIS PORTION
OFTHE INVOICE
WITH YOUR
PAYMENT
tlM-----------------------
"
.
IIIl ~-'~ ~
1.'"
.[,J._..
""~','
d
'_.-i:>' ':'::"_";-"'-"'- ,,"v"';-"";j~1Cik
r
I
WALSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena, NY 13662
(3151769-3574
PAGE 12
Please Remit To:
="
WAlSliEOtlIP~ co.
50 Burney Ave.
WM.1M~I~';E
WAlSHT
i,Ht.,m
WeLSH Ti\1Jr..KiN6 SoH'! Tef, IN/:
50 BllRllEY AVE,
S
H
I
P
SilPIE
s
o
L
o
T
o
MASSENA, NY 13&62
T
o
,.
.. ,
. ...
.. .
.
.
.
08/31108 J
283 08/38
01-s1lE
_111813 08/38/. Ml8813
Ifdm3--000 Shipped 2.~ Ell 18.7<22 370~
SPRING HilNGER PIN
\ I-il%-'Hge Shipped U8Ilil Ell 1407111 58.
U-BfU
~'HJ'111i1-005 Sh ipp.,i 8.0i1JIil0 EA .65Sf, 5.2
7lBIl Wtr1Sl-lER
23-0lYf61-0ti'f1 ::J11pp:~d ... EA 1, T!78 7.9
HIS'H Ntrf
I l'}--I2I.'132-oMl2 Sliipperi 1.0000 Ell 3905444 3905
SHllli HBSORBER
HR5-60593-000 Shipped 8.ilII0ll EA o 5lI89 ~07
EliOCl\ BUSHING
JlfE -~ 1393F S.'1ipp.d 4.11ilil9 fA 4.0556 tf,.2
TAW STi1AP RUBllEl1S PLEASE RETURN
THIS PORTION
OF THE INVOICE
WITH YOUR
PAYMENT
r<<I4E------.---------
,.....
"'!'I''' ,; ; I
,_ ,"" _~ ' ____ , ,..,_ 1 _ '"
T
I
WAlSH EQUIPMENT CO.
50 Burney Ave.
Massena, NY 13662
(315) 769-3574
~Ji;L SliT
s
o
L
D
T
o
~.SH 1P'L:ec~-i6 SERi)1u, Wf.
~J0 BURtoH q~E.
S
H
I
P
T
o
;:;~f
i'IASSEllll, NY 13662
"
. . ~. ..
.. ,
0H1AlE
,.,
iMl/:!0/il8
J
203 88J::lil1
,,~, -, ~-,~~~",";' ",
~~ .
,,' I~'~""';'
Please Remit To:
"AbE t3 wJ.ffifuIJJrrm
50 Burney Ave.
~'1'l!ilt)11;W;5E
WlJlSHT
,
10-lC032-@02 ShiP\led 1._ Ell $3. '5oWt
8100\ ABSORBER
AI6-13412-llll1 Shipped 10. EA m00n8
SJ:'QING
Ii}- 2;:-'048-003 Shipp.d 1.00ll0 EA 347.3111 347.3
SUSP I<SSIl
13-28BI!,HlOO '31"0 i pped 1.\!1100 EA 7f.,.68 76.
BR,LL
UUlO. WTS Sh i pped 79.. H!lJR 13.7754
REP Al1:1DOO
NAME,--------..----
CHAR€f 69"..."9.68
0.
0.
f,929.611
" ,
. '011/3llrii00alll813
PLEASE RETURN
THIS PORTION
OF THE INVOICE
WITH YOUR
PAYMENT
.~ .
, J ~
,-'
~'-' ~
, "
......, ...., - - -- -
~. ~
-
bd"-!i"'p/YUPdHQ'''''//hh'K''''414
ATTN'
,J~lal!i--
;, -, -,.;,;,;, -',-",'" '" r' :ff'-'ji
. 7314 Schuyler Road, East Syracuse, New York 13057
(315) 458.3808 0 FAX (315) 458-1554
. 264 Clark Slreet, Auburn, New York 13021
(315) 253-8885 . FAX (315) 253.8899
NAM~)~J~U
y(jt; M/G d I~JLj'~ i
/~l$A6El:,2XX56~Z~zl~DEI.NUMBER 53 I
PARTS NECESSARY AND ESTIMATE OF LABOR REQUIRED
AODRESS
I SPEEDOMETER
I PHONE
PAINT COST
ESTIMATE
I.ICENSE NUMBER
&:.: ~~~
,9'
tIE, /.. ~
v
z:.. ~~ ~o--.
If
d<::;
.0./
f/. /.
cs;
z..
~. L
t?
If:. ~ /. .a.....
(/
R".~f__. -'
,
a:; _ /...
v
-' d.c,
/.
"v tff':,u/
es
A7
/1
.ff
./.....,,>JAI -'
,5'
/17';:; j/ /~r A ~
v
/J. .h'L. . A"" I.)'
I /
k!;.,uh pL.h-) ~ .".~J i. A../..-,
I I / (/
.-e of I~...~___ 6Jl.U ?_ /i/ )
A~ /
LU ~ ...t-'..:>
tf?:, .II, '0
fi./o~ /~-'.
/fA
//r;; l'
...,
~
aLP' L/..&.
TOTALS
INSURED PAYS $
INS. CHECK PAYABLE TO
INS. CO. PAYS $
R.O.NO.
The above is an esUmale basad on Our il'JspeoliorJ, and does not cover additional pari$. Of labor which may be re.quired
after the work has been opened up, Occasionally. after wQrk; has starlQd, Worn, broken or damaqed parts are dlscov.
ered whIch are l'lOt r,wldent on firsl inspaolion. QI,Jotallons on parts an d labor are cl,lrrel"t~ and subject to. chang~.
ESTIMATE MADE BY
AUlhorizallon for R9pairs: Yoo arc' hereby QrJthorized to MtlKe the (lbQ~ ~pc(~ed repdirs fQ the cor ducribcd herein.
SIGNED
DATE
'-
./f\
<'\ V
\ \
~
SHEET No._ OF SHEETS
PHONE' --I ~~ z/~
UNIT NUMBER 0 '.--
'3 c:> 6 3.z..:...
CAR LOCATED AT
PAR,S cosr
ESTIMATE,
I.ABOR COST
ESTIMATE
\ \ " \A.
~l'/
" ~
/./
.3,9d/ I I? i/i5!:. .0-0
GRANDTOT~L /,;z,3~/.1'
WRECKER SERVICE I
TAX
TOTAL OF ESTIMATE 11.2-;35 j , J
rL
="~~--~~ - "
~.'. <~-;;
~'t;I
.:",l
~~
~~,f,
.-
,~~j ~~J
~
-. Fi;!--:'
':-~
:/..r:
.".
Ik,
"t;"
,;;,,::.r,
~, -,.-<
:"'iJf? 0
9~i
,:~~
.' ,,;,.Z
, 'zO
_ . m
~;~.,~~
lt~ C{~~ >-
~'::-,~"U :J:J
'\'.:" ';",~: m G)
q;,~" ~~, ::XJ m
t,. i,'i' 0 Cij'
~~;" ~ g
rr.:: ~.g
;;:_' ,~S
~ --, ~II ('0
:ifI! '- '- 0.
" .J ~ ;U cr
""! ' '<
I: Q)
~:~,j ~ (II
, 3'
tt i!
I Sir ~,
......,..' 0..
1;-
iil
iP
9-
'"
#
-0
(l>
~
"'-
1..,
,
,:""
3
o
:J
9'
~l5i'~ ~ ~;:
n..-ifj"
i)"a:::Jmiii QI
5-f"g~o !i
, - .
~ 2: 1! ~ ~
~6<a ~,~ i~'
~iiil!!;tlllllllD
ii 0'~1ffi'1Il ~9-
. "_::12...:11I
~oila'lir21l1
;;r.:~Pi~'IU~
..~. 9.5 a,1II
~ g~~i~'~~
o ~ lUll 'i::;'
i'g~~ .~~
~o30~~;'
Ul<ig.:JQ~S
1Ii[!!g.2":ll[
f*&15~~8'
g Q 9-lii.;!'< if:
c.1lI1l1:l.1lI 0 III
gffifi3ig'
;;*<:(i~~~
g ~H .-f"
<: -.a~; 9-
:J_lD:J III
gJ ~ @~::! )>0 0
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0
m 0 ~ ~ ~ 0
r ~ HI F
m ~
00
i5
z
~
c'
."
m
11llIIiiiIliIIiI~'....
I
",if..
~
~
~
~
~
~
~ ~
....~~I-
:
" ,
I t:F ..,..
I I
: 'f' (b
.'~
~ 0 "
.
7
~ tl> ~
c- ~ ~
~ .. .
rY ,
J
(;)
I
1
n'
,
-~
.
'b
-
.
,
r
r___
t::>
r
~-,-,-~~ j~_",~:"",w.;,;'"",,~,'-r-.--'
"",",,",,;l,.lj~,' ....'.....: li~l~ld,JllI!! ::~j~9.-,
T
b
F-
(:;J Il
~ l:l t.l
y. ~ t
- 1
"
..I ~
<:) <
'1b
'i' "I)
~
~
~ J
,..
--
--
0
(\
rt
'v
I........~~~ .b,~9->9-> 0
~'-!!8~ I
~~[..~ ~
~~~~ ~
f ~ ~ ~" ;::\ ~ 1.-Q1
~~~~~~2 ~
C~\:~ 'r-....k $:- ~ 11
~ tlt=~ ~ ~ ~
~~I~ I ~W ~
""::r
~ ~ ~~ . :f= ~
~ ~~::-t:.Ci\ ~ ~ ~
~~I~~
~!:: ~ ,":~~
mOm- 1i....3
i
4::.
;
I'
~
- ~
V ~;~
nil~. _....'
,g;~ 111
:~t~..,
~~!I'11
u~~
~~ ~
~
,.
o
."
~
o
m
00
o
;e
~
-<
<5
z
"'~ ~~i:I(\'C"""";
~ ~I~~ ~1l>U<;~ ~
1J ~8 ~ ""mo~'-lnj
~_",~""-''t' 0'
S! ....~~,,, ..). .......
m .....c::~ Vl V' ~
--I;J \
___ 0
<1
'"
Sb~
C>~
--.2
lJ\t\
..-C)
'.::l
~(:)6-~ ~
~ ~ }fi - ~ t"'\)g
~ (9 r- ~ rnlC,.0g
~ -.J.J l' ,>,~
- ."
~ (1 ~,Iz
~ ~ ~ P) 9
P
tQ
.'lJ
-~ - ~~= , . ~ . - ........... , , .1.___ III "-'-,,,,- '~:f1i@lj-
A ALLIED SPRING & SERVICES, INC. '~~P;p{} f,AT.,.' 'j ()
.. 031 ~_1\H
PRING REPAIR COMPLETE AUTO AND TRUCK PHONE '~~PI:f.~:l"9J PAGE
=LPER SPRINGS -'-
10CKS ~~IL~~ ~~IRlW~~~ ~ ~1NI~'if ~ILIL~ 'if~((J)1NI 315-437-9967
-'lUCK WALKING BEAMS b CU/jlH~R NO BRANCH
':BUSHEO P.OiBOX 117 . E. SYRACUSE, NY 13057 '.;JJ- ...1
ROUTE #290 & DROTT DR. . EAST MANPUS CENTER RD. . EAST SYRACUSE. NY 13057
Repair Shop Registration Number R434-0QLID# 16-0966308
!-If,LfiH 'PI/IT"W '\ tln"l "'''I Tfl"
J. "" ,.';'!'n:, ; '~ .h" J. ,\,1. !. .~ .. ;,;h
~) \) l::Ul,NEY (\t),h ~o) J ..:~ ~) J':{'IJ.Sn n/;) r:vr:
SOLD ()}.':i.'N: II H;IHii.l,fi nliIHI SHIP "
TO i~,)nG};~N,~\ NY .1 ;.. C~ I',~ ~...; TO H~):::'),'"1.l.ItJr,H NY l~l~~J..".
KJlIIPO/fff'1f/.U\D1t JMLIL /P..."". ....w'fifPJS MQJSr BE rHGlHlrlENEftJ WD"fHHN 300 MILES
CUSTOMER f>,Q. RIS ORDER NO. I
',.-3./\:;: () .Ull ~U (;-lJ :~O ..~ :-~ I~. ''J~3? J k.1N V~~()/()O~;
, I PRICE/PER I EXTENSION
1,._: Ui1;,i-' L,~,~ ,d.ll"i ,...' "', - I L /():~:'J ,:"U00
,,"'--.:.-
iUi ~ :" .,,;'J~i i E{\,~ ;. I: tJ ':)4 ii"f(i,;NU,VJ:.L: t: .\~ E Ifi-ffTL I j\qi f( ,
J," ,
~;J,--;i~li";~,~: J. }.:J i ,: r~L..(Xt()hL/~t;'10 11 N :n.tl.)iH\: '1~:'()f.ji!,.r4 261/ " L(3 Ifu. ~
~n;:,!!:~1 j (: ..~ J ; ':1 (;2 ;H, fHi\!N.._;N~(' L_r);:=o~t ,
H,HiN ,'hllNJ . .b-N,ll ,
i....t.:f ';.' +10 MlN 1<:! LIEU , ,
~.. J ':;i':!. " 'r"-:- ~,!hl:c ;...; ~) n J.i~
J f~j,'; , :'''t.iN "
.IN
,h,Wrhi :jU.B.n'j"T,c-;L ,;'\ .;.{}
~
,.
1.(,)$(I1/. SUfi'fO""I/'
SIHH' (>lll-'X". J.h:.
1;), JOtl bUH:'.IJT(I!"
)6..-2<.;
<i.AI::
')b" 7~:f
,.'l:~:U-:),,~ t,;:~ t;':,Q \,IV- t l'lVI\l.l'
<_..~-.I,'t;L:. j:.'"}.fif.: At IG,Ni'viLN,}
;:,ruf. .;LH;:ifJH
""",1'<; \",'1"
~,~ l"! i, ,,"
kJf-).t~'lt:t tiU!i.l tt.t;jl,
1.,1\1:(1)'1 SlH:'l'P';:?iL
biiUtl" Qj~J...!.'t' ,1,".r. {,~,,~J
,~"'\' ,JOR S;JH-J'I}TltI
()" (H,
~~ '1 ,. ~':i\;
:) ~ I. JI
~]:.-' 'l (~ 'i
~;:f[J:i:I\L I'M~\:i ::
'r;,.! ltl "'.' t;,}'jtlUl';::
*rOj~L SHaF SUPPI,IBS~
(I" o.()
.l ;';;;:3 ~ '/;)
i) '" (~~"
'1
,
.,.'. FREIGHT
('- .j;:!). II .
. '" j,,,,-..,. IL:l .'" .~.")
'ETURN OF"MfRCHANDISE MU~i',llE FREIGHT -PREPAID, ACCOM-
.)ANIED BY APPLICABLE INVOICE OR ITS NUMBER, WITHIN 30 DAYS.
mN-STOCK OR SPECIAL-ORDER PARTS ARE NOT RETURNABLE. A
5% MINIMUM SERVICE CHARGE IS APPLICABLE ON RETURNS AFTER
5 DAYS. T~RMS: NET 30 DAYS.
TAXABLE U TOTAL
TAX STATUSlSTAT
SALES TAX
J, :~4" .J?
"
~.~
NY'
I
\)"O()
CUSTOMEI'l COPY
Not Responsible for Damages Or
LOBS to Vehicle While On Our
Premises
l :'~4.. ::',>
, PLEASE PAY..
ed~J1
.,~ J~
11/08/2020 23:12
/"
'.
"' -,
-,
RUSTVS & PADDOCKS
PAGE 01
3154548419
PADDOCK'S
Heavy Duty Trucks And Truc~: -,lrtl
(315) 45$-9999
15 Dippold Ave,
SYRACUSE, N.Y. 13208
CUSTOMER'S ORI3E;:R NO.
::EP~-..
.~
SOlO.~::~._ _
, '- " . - ~
QrY.
~.' i
"i_,
~__'L ~ ..:::.--.;'~"jlli':
,-
HoYoS, Dllmantle, *7003261
(,~--
X.._m_..
;~'? ..r:
DES( - TION
AMOUNT
-- --1-~---~-'~
-7'.....j-.~ 1..<<
-,.-....-'-. -'--.-........,---..-----
'" --- _.~~.,-" -----,-- ~~,.--"
_'0 __,"_ __'----_.____.~,__.'.
-. - "",,_'''"_, '.,,_,,_,___,n _"__'~~~.__._.,
...
Rf.C~MO BV
All claIms and retu'
8734
PRICE
l:::~:~="~-~_
,
,
-'--"-'"-- '..J..., ,.,....1.
9Sf ~C)
_._.,",",._.,u,"_",,, '------1-.'.--"
,
,
-_-.-~ _,__~~,1____".___.
I
,
,
-----'_.'_._-.-.~-- ,-_.... ---.,.....-- --.-_~"~., '~I"'--"'" --+
.
,
-.,.----__".,,1____,_0.-.
,
,
,
'.------~-"-~, ,---- --.'t~__
,
,
,
""1"---
,
,
- .-,.,--................. .'....,'._ ,_> _,... ,.,._,.,._u____., ___.,__._<_".1-__._
,
,
,
--l.~---'-'-
,
,
________,~, ____,._...,_,,j,,..__ __.,_'u
,
,
,
^----":...~--,~~_.--------- '---. .-----'-1-~----'.., -
,
,
"
,
,
,
,
,
,
I
. .-.-.-------. ......-...--, _.~~^~-,_..- ..~-.--l--.-_U_"..
,
,
.1..
,
,
.md,_
TAX ~:
TOTAL
,
':.JiCJ(J:J
[ioods MUST be accompanied by this bill.
CZ1umk%u
r.~'-7 T._Cd
= ,'1.800-225-&110
11/09/2000 THU 12:14
[TX/RX NO 9539 J I4i 001
--
~.............
~'--1
STATE INSPECTlON'24 HOUR TOWING'MECHANICAL WORK'NATIONAL LEASE VENDOR
..
Htnry'SfOWing Inc.
2390 Wertz Lane
Enola. PA 17025
N2
46974
Dale HenlY. Pres_
Shop Phone: 717-732-0934
Nights & Holidays: 717-732-0908
Dale '6'- /[i'-C?<':?_
TO
LU.4/....'5I-1-
-- 1-
./ ru. C (<I'd
P.O. NUMBER
TRUCK NO.
'.
TRAILER NO. ''i>..
ko.
A SERVICE CHARGE OF 1 112 % PEA
MONTH WIll BE ADDEO TO All AC-
COUNTS OVER 30 DAYS. $1.00 MINIMUM
MONTHLY CHARGE.
CUSTOMER COpy (WHITE)
OFFICE COpy (YELLOW)
GRAND TOTAL i s-: "~
'-
ell
,")
.'.., ----------- -'" BY
CJ ~_
....
...,
.0
....
.".:J> \- !J ~;;::C-'Z~J~
g. ~ j Q
_~~ 'J._,
----- ,
- -------,-,------~--
t...
\-
1,
~
,
, ;I.
'1'"
~rM,I<;:""- "
----
-~'~-~><".=-"'" - ~ - ~~~---~I"'" , 'iiUi_~-
'ilE~ _1.>J..,l'i
10130/2020 21:14 3154548419 RUSTY~ & C'AV1Jl-'LK::> r H"-l\-.. u.
.. 0 - .....
.
~ gg.93~ %lI,/'~3l1'-> ~
~o,f ~:r~ ::r~=
~ ~~~%" '.. .&*.
s:-:::r (0 " n ' .
gllilS{ ~'<..,ii' A.l~
. - V
~~f,l- 5- 'C -...i-... ~
a;'!€' 3 ?' ~.~; ~t~ .
~Q;)~8 -, .
.. iVi'~ ~ ~ngllil"Q5w V '- ~
fJ;::rt\; 5- ttOl1i.! 0 1/ 0
C:!!t~ rt m ~~h ~e- " Ie -=
x:'?-~ ~ n 19 3.. '< i/\,/ , ./ Ii
ril_~ a tiS"o;':r'" V '"
m ::r d1
~iff' ~;:~~r~lI~
,. .~ it!>> tT33 ~ I. h
gi'fo if . U1~3QRI~ '-
",:::I -: 0. il -. h
.. ~cu-g~ g~t1 ~':f; L I / j
hUe :r!:'!: o.;~l I i~
-'~...ii ~ i
' Q ~ g -. -
o.li'~D. nlolfl>::ri g- 01 ,
lll(Ilijjg g" . J l~
_o'il !r'
~Ir~. /1:1 &flq \
o. "St -if
\1l ~'P lr it":::J 2:':J
25 5',B "Obi .c:: go;
~~t · · ~ S!: il.-l! If \
:;r.3' 9' ;- 1IQ1--;' ~
~: ~f~ ;:1:\;..:lI""tI ( -- 12/ I
_Y'e!I:L""" :r /
g 8'0 :::J !- 3~a~D1
Ale ....~ . ~ ij'Q.{1 d - \
g.a~J I
[19." it Lr-.. ~
.p 1>: ~;pi.~ " "- \ I
1- '* ~3 ~ ~l ~'~[ " I
-- l! ti--
~ o.~ ,.
~:T i' ~ '" 11 ] - . - -- -- - .. . --- - - , -- - - "" - - -.. . - - - - - . - . - - - .. - - - -
Op [HF ;. r of~
il~ -ll .1"=1'- i'-.
J ~ lPp ~"< . -. ::t'
!)::l";;:d!: ig . I
~~.~[ !
, ~!l.- ~ L
'0 o ~ c'9'~ r;
I~ ;~"~ .. !l. -.. - -- .. .. -- - - - - - - - - -- -- .. - , - - - - -- .. - -- - - - - -- - - ..
I
I . 8- J
.. ~
I ~ i ~ ~ i ~ I . ~,' ~ ~ !
" ? ~ .~ 3
>> ~. ~\ ::f:~ I~ ~
i . m ~.
8
~ ~ "... '.~ ::t
~. ,~ , B 0 ;;;..
(. A , ~ ~,
-- I-- l ~ j :\ ~'" -
~ ~ " ~~~ C> ~ ~
~ ~ .~ VIr"
"'l ~ ~ .CS 'r- ~'"
i'i "'.'0; () w~o~
~ ~ ~ ~ '.- ~I t..J ~ J)
~. /~ ~(')~c
~c
p~ b " m ~ VI ('
;;l ~ ~ :-:. '\'.. ~/TIr-,
1-l1 --" "'- 0
"l ,. r " ;"0 ~ 8 f' 'fz;,. CI
g " ~ ':; ~ (7) "'<<I'
. ;; . ,t , ...... I..... i "'..../TI
~ !i) ~ II ....wz
,. " ". ~ ,) ~ WIVe
r ~fT1r
.. :( G ~ \,\ VI
0 . 0
~ 11 ~ , , ~ !'
,- " r . ~ b
'----:; ~ f--c;; "',<:: ~
',' Iii
~ a ) ;.,
~ 'v
. ~ '1
~ ~ .
0 0 - ~
r i~ J
t?~ -'1 , I
.
-, > r- I g a I~ ~
m -~ oi ~
" .. ~ ".) ~ ~ ~
);> b " - ~i
:a; ~ <) b 0
,. '" ~
If> ~ ... ". ~ ',jJ vJ .,J ~
... !< ~ c;
'" -I ~ 0 ~
d 0 0 ... > > ~ l! ~;
~ r:>r:> III ,.. ,.. '\> 1'\
,,> c " r' ~ I . ~ l\
~ 0 ~!Il .. ~ ;l> 'if
~ III r ., ~
);> "'0 ~ 0 ! ~
r- >< ,.. rnp :D . i
..-.... ...~~ /;
~ ~ ~ --~ , ~
I .
- 4 d. .
- - . -.. - - - .. ;......., ,- -- ~' -- - - - - - .~ ~ -- ~ - -. .- - .. - - -- !i
\ 1 E1" , r
:! ! I . .
,00 .,. ...
..i~l
c:
'"
....;
"
::0
c::
:2
r
w
(..0
lO
00
~
-
~
, ' '! ,,- " "-~,'
1,_ , .' ,; , '," -c , '-, > ~ ~ ,~,-
""i.'0i;
f
VRRTFTCATTON
I, Gerald R. Matteo, hereby verify that I am the Director of Loss Prevention of Walsh
Tmcking Services, LLC and, as such, I am authorized to verify the averments of the foregoing
document are tme and correct to my personal knowledge, information and belief. I understand
that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. g4904, relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities.
Date: /o.,frs 10 /
:Jv.1d r Ii kk re me:.
;~
NO'TJIr/ p.a.1C. $'T1i
S'T.~
~C~J~HJJl
~. -
flf~.J t'l~Nr
ItJ)~1
-
C'":;;
~"J.si,:-,:;,,;,;,.~t!'~._~f':;.(' -'"'~ -";''''',,', ~-",," '-' ' --.'; -, --- -', - ,_:- ,:
I~[!~~jg~!l:l~~M'dW'ii",~"-,"",,,k..'lPi,;i~'K"~ ' ~"
~
~
I.
u ~~_'~N _.
7J
~
......
......
~
~
.-"
"""- ~ ~ -~
(-)
fl,
~ ~
~ ..t
h .~D
~ D "1
OC);
~~
~~
J:
"-
~
~
o
C
"T) ...
c~' -
~. ,
c-'o, -.
.,
~~ :~~-,
#:.~::..~
~~:
:;;!
(ft
C')
'--'-;
:--1
jS
-<
...............-- ~
... .~-
'" ,-
: L
~-y",.~
~'.....," '~:dliar~M~~l!oj
'" ..
WALSH TRUCKING SERVICES, LLC,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
: NO. 01-6413 Civil Term
NINA LOUISE OBERLIN a!k/a
Nll-rA OBERLIN HACH,
Defendant
CNIL ACTION - LAW
AFFTDA VIT OF SRRVICR BY MAIL
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
) SS:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND )
Thomas O. Williams, Esquire, being duly sworn, upon oath, deposes and says as follows:
I. I am the attorney for Walsh Trucking Services, LLC in the above-entitled case.
On December 18,2001, I caused to be transmitted, by a form of mail requiring a signed receipt, a
copy ofthe Complaint filed in this action to the following: Nina Louise Oberlin alk!a Nina
Oberlin Hach. A copy of my transmittal letter is attached hereto as Exhibit "A".
2. I further depose and say that I thereafter received from the Postmaster of Camp
HilI, a return receipt bearing the notation "Date of delivery: 12/21/01." A copy of the official
retum receipt is attached hereto as Exhibit "B".
Respectfully subm'
REAGER E
Th mas O. Williams, Esquire
Attorney J.D. No. 67987
2331 Market Street
CampHill,PA 17011-464
Telephone: (717) 763-1383
Sworn to and subscribed
befiJre me this 28th day of
December, 2001.
/1
.{/ffiJ i,AUAA ~tU~
" Notary Public
NoIariai Seal i
Deborah L. Brenneman, Notary Public 1
Camp Hill Boro, Cumberland County
My Commission Expires June ~~ 2,O?!~_",
f\J,e~b~r:P8I~':rwfiVania A8Soclallon 0; _\o;:,;'es
"-;~i
~. ~
"' -'l
.....~- .
J ~__~,~=, '~..""
_ .:,........ _ __ : ~_ c_"
'-,. .' -' ',-'
-Jft~~"
, ..
...
REAGER &ADLER, PC
ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW
2331 MARKET STREET
CAMP HILL, PENNSYLVANIA 17011-4642
717.763-1383
TELEFAX 717.730-7366
wEBSITE: ReagerAdlerPC.com
THEODORE A. ADLER ~
DAVID W. Ri:.~GER
CHARLES E. ZALESKI
LINUS E. FENICLE
DEBRA DENISON CANTOR
THOMAS O. WILLIAMS
SUSAN H. CONFAIR
JOANNE HARRISON CLOUGH
CHRISTINE.SCHWAMBERGER
Writer's E~Mail Address: tomwi1l@epix.f'let
+ Certified Civil Trial Specialist
December 18,2001
via Certified MaillRetum Receipt Requested
Nina Louise Oberlin
a/k/a Nina Oberlin Hach'
HCR 33, Box 122
Harrison, AZ 72601
Re: Walsh Trucking Services, LLC v. Nina Louise Oberlin a/k/a Nina Oberlin Hach
Docket No.: 01-6413 (Cumberland Co. C.C.P.)
Our File No.: 01-821.000
Dear Ms. Hach:
Enclosed for service upon you please find a Complaint filed in the above captioned
matt~:r. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.
;em 0 W,lli=.
TOW/cmc
Enclosure
EXHIBI.T "A"
.1
J
~~,
I... ~,~
<~
-~
I 'TlA)T'~~;'~~,..:"-:-l,.("~.,;-
I .... ".... .;f1\;..,
.; . ..' ."' ,.;."'-'
1 REAGER!~'A~LEI~ftj> ..( ,.'
1 2331 MARKET STREET ;:'
CAMP HILL, PA 17011~,'
1 -1
1
.'-' ,
"'
" ~
~" ~,-, ~~lt,:;
..
.
4. Restricted Delivery? 3.- Se~i~-TYP~ - - - --T
CERTIFIED I
I
7111 174~ 2100 0000 0955 I
-~')>!."'-'!"'r"-'-""",--, ,
j "s~~o~daii'&~iir8.~ii'~'siirteTAPi:TFioor'(Pi"$~i'PiinrCiBiii{Yj
I ..............,.".......,.........................................................
t Delivery' 'Address
I .cYG..-.....-.....-....-............- .siiie ..........zip.i-Tc04ii
;1
(Extra Fee) 0 Yes
2. Article Number
IIIIIIIIIIII~II-IIIIIIIIIHIIIIIIIIIIII
7111 1746 2100 0000 0955
1. Article Addressed To:
NINA LOUISE OBERLIN
A'AKA:A NINA'O'BERLIN HACH
1'I(;.R'!:33, BOX 122
HARRISON AZ 72601
';"'./)'
'. .::::"
~.,'_.-
IEXHIBIT "B"
lI.uai\1
-,- -, ~~~-~%~,. - =~' 'M'
O'J:':-',*,~W:tJ;.,_;
~ ' , ,
~
WALSH TRUCKING SERVICES, LLC, :IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
: No. 01..6413 Civil Term
NINA LOUISE OBERLIN ajkj a
NINA OBERLIN HACH
Defendant
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
To: Curt Long, Prothonotary
Kindly enter my appearance for defendant, Nina Louise Oberlin ajkj a Nina
Oberlin Hach.
Respectfully submitted,
Lavery, Faherty, Young
DATE: J \ \ D \ ~
Frank J. Lavery, J Esquire
Atty No. 42370
301 Market St., Sui e 800
P.O. Box 1245
Harrisburg, PA 17108..1245
Attys for Defendant
"
<
^I "J,;,. "~- .. . -- ,- , ' ..,--, '-iOjijii'i!ili:;j('~Ii<fi::'
~... \
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Megan 1. Renno, an employee with the law firm of Lavery, Faherty, Young &
Patterson, P.e., do hereby certify that on this I rl day of January, 2002, I served a true
and correct copy of the foregoing Entry of Appearance via U.S. First Class mail,
postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
Thomas O. Williams, Esquire
Reager & Adler, P.e.
2331 Market Street
Camp Hill, PA 17011
bt~~~~~~~~:fit",!/(!~l~>l\i!Gi"lj.M~.~Ib-;;\',,;A"W'-"~','H"~":"'-'" i ,i:'i"";f'~llii!',iI3~.
l
III
~. ~ ,_ ,___.,"'''''''_ ," '"""""_.;,, ,__'"Wf?"'_ - ,,~~
.
<~I~_~-- ~"'~~~Il.Ii!&aWlMl!II;li'!III'C1r,a
~ .
L
1
.
C) p ()
C N -n
~~ '-----
-U u:; .\:~ll -r;
mrr: z r':'::
~~T rn
~,
2.t,_ .;:- J,
~~;
'-'2C; .'0 ---:, ~,d
"" c ..z,.. C)
2~ C) ,"-- en
;p- O,
C -',
"7 W ">
~ :0
.-1 -<
r;s
jj;j
.-" '-~"
WALSH TRUCKING SERVICES, LLC,
Plaintiff
v.
NINA LOUISE OBERLIN a/k/a
NINA OBERLIN HACH
Defendant
,-
,',.,' -
-~~-'~~;7'
:IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
:CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
: No. 01-6413 Civil Term
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
DEFENDANT'S ANSWER TO COMPLAINT
NOTICE TO PLEAD
To: Walsh Trucking Services, LLC,
c/o Thomas O. Williams, Esquire
You are hereby notified to file a written response to the enclosed NEW MATTER within
twenty (20) days from service hereof or a judgment may be entered against you.
ANSWER
1. Admitted in part. Denied in part. It is admitted only that Plaintiff Walsh
Trucking Services, LLC (hereinafter, "Plaintiff') is a corporation. After reasonable investigation,
Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the veracity of
the remaining allegations of paragraph 1, which are therefore denied, with strict proof thereof
demanded, if relevant.
2. Admitted.
2-{
--
"~ ~
"
. ,
"~al_ -,
~l>i!:lI~~,~~S;;.1iiwll;'c(hl,j
3. Admitted in part. Denied in part. It is admitted only that, on August 18, 2000, a
tractor and trailer operated by Harry E. Hinkley and registered to Walsh Trucking Services, LLC,
were traveling in a northerly direction on Interstate 81 in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form
a belief as to the veracity of the remaining allegations of paragraph 2, which are therefore denied,
with strict proof thereof demanded, if relevant.
4. Denied. These averments are denied as they are conclusions of law to which no
response is necessary pursuant to the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure and the same are
therefore deemed to be denied. To the extent that further response is deemed necessary, these
averments are denied pursuant to Rule 1029(e), Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.
5. a.-j. Denied. These averments are denied as they are conclusions oflaw to which
no response is necessary pursuant to the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure and the same are
therefore deemed to be denied. To the extent that further response is deemed necessary, these
averments are denied pursuant to Rule I 029( e), Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.
6. Denied. These averments are denied as they are conclusions of law to which no
response is necessary pursuant to the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure and the same are
therefore deemed to be denied. By way of further answer, after reasonable investigation,
Answering Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of paragraph 6 of Plaintiff's Complaint and the same are therefore denied
with strict proof demanded, if relevant.
7. Denied. These averments are denied as they are conclusions of law to which no
response is necessary pursuant to the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure and the same are
therefore deemed to be denied. By way of further answer, after reasonable investigation,
.~
. ,
~ I ....""
. '<IIJ:lillFi;)~-' a rr"
J:;;~~~'~';.
Answering Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of paragraph 7 of Plaintiff's Complaint and the same are therefore denied
with strict proof demanded, if relevant.
NEW MATTER
8. Plaintiff's Complaint and/or one or more of the Counts of Plain tift's Complaint fails
to state claims or causes of action upon which relief can be granted.
9. Plaintiffs' claims are barred and/or limited by application of the provisions of the
Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law, as amended, of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
10. Plaintiffs' claims are barred and/or limited by application of the provisions of the
Pennsylvania Comparative Negligence Act.
11. Plaintiff's operator/employee may have negligently caused and/or contributed to this
accident in that he may have failed to observe due care in the operation of his vehicle in the
following particulars:
(a) failure to exercise vigilance in operating his vehicle in a manner to
ensure avoidance of motor vehicles in the roadway;
(b) failure to control his vehicle;
( c) failure to drive his vehicle in a safe and non-negligent manner;
(d) failure to mitigate his damages; and
(e) violation of the "last clear chance" doctrine.
12. The accident was solely attributable to the negligent acts and/or omissions of a
person or persons other than Defendant.
':'
~,~ ~ , -~~
-~
;J!i~"JM~'iiiu"
13. The accident was caused by an uuidentified tractor trailer that suddenly and
unlawfully entered into Defendant's lane of travel, forcing Defendant from the center lane into
the right travel lane.
Respectfully submitted,
Lavery, Faherty, Young & Patterso , P.C.
BY:~
DATE:
1 /29} ~
Frank J. La ry, Jr., Esqu e
Atty No.7 693
301 Market St., Suite 80
P.O. Box 1245
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1245
Attys for Defendant
-
-
~< d~ 'J_..."~ ~
~ "
="-'-~~~.. K
""'~i11llO!r...,,,,,,~~~~h,1&'
VERIFICA nON
The undersigned hereby verifies that the facts set forth in the foregoing Answer and New
Matter are based upon information which has been furnished to counsel by me and information
which has been gathered by counsel in the preparation of this lawsuit. The language of the
Answer and New Matter is that of counsel and not my own. I have read the Answer and New
Matter and to the extent that the Answer and New Matter are based upon information which I
have given to counsel, it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief.
To the extent that the content of the Answer and New Matter is that of counsel, I have relied
upon my counsel in making this verification. The undersigned also understands that the
statements therein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. S4904, relating to unsworn
falsification to authorities.
Date:
I / I;;; J/);Z
1(-
~~
Nme Oberlm Hach
Niv1.C'\ O~rii.l\
\
I.
I
\
l
l1f
> '"""'~~ "
~~~W,""l!1lfj'l'-"<;;'~:_:
~ ( . ..
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Megan 1. Renno, an employee with the law fIrm of Lavery, Faherty, Young &
Patterson, P.C., do hereby certify that on this ~ay of January, 2002, I served a true and
correct copy of the foregoing Answer via U.s. First Class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as
follows:
Thomas o. Williams, Esquire
Reager & Adler, P.C.
2331 Market Street
Camp Hill, P A 17011-464
t:~j""';';~{~~~1ffi:i'l.~"'-]ti\'~'_~i~"'-~A1'lf#;'--i:aJl<;ffi'i':'"",_,"~"",,,,,,,;".h""",!c:"."i"'-'A"'~h'ji'o!'lI,'3~WkJJ1'f_~~!l~~~I""';'_li!;l!!i~~~~
. .
0 0 0
C N "T1
<' .....
-OrI.'1 :::-.... "r-
rn fT-, ;;c:: ~'il~
:::: ~r'
~~~ w -68
0 -~s~
c::c:; -0
'Oc ;:0;'::;; --n
~8 ::; "::"C)
N Ol-n
"- :::> s;!
-I ~
-< (;J
_l,~,~, _ "'"
',<"'-'~~
,~, ~t"..r~".,^
,0
~*
, -
,~-
...
--
, .', ",
, ~' ~ , ,
_,_I
"""'..."" -~ ~
JQ,Jj .
~='"'~i ttJ~mi3c'l<jL;
, ~ ,~
A
,.
WALSH TRUCKING SERVICES, LLC,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO. 01-6413 Civil Term
NINA LOUISE OBERLIN a/k/a
NINA OBERLIN HACH,
Defendant
CNIL ACTION - LAW
PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO NEW MATTER
8. Denied. The averments of paragraph 8 constitute conclusions oflaw to which no
responsive pleading is required.
9. Denied. The averments of paragraph 9 constitute conclusions of law to which no
responsive pleading is required.
10. Denied. The averments of paragraph 10 constitute conclusions of law to which no
responsive pleading is required.
II. Denied. The averments of paragraph 11 constitute conclusions of law to which no
responsive pleading is required. To the extent that a reply is judicially deemed required, each
and every factual averment of paragraph 11 are denied.
12, Denied. The averments of paragraph 12 constitute conclusions oflaw to which no
. responsive pleading is required.
13. Denied. By way of further response, the cause of the collision between the
Defendant's vehicle and the Plaintiff s truck was the Defendant's unlawful, negligent and
unjustified entry into the Plaintiff s lane of travel. By way of further response, as between the
Defendant and the Plaintiff, the actions ofthird parties as alleged in paragraph 13 does not affect
the liability of the Defendant to the Plaintiff inasmuch as the Plaintiff was traveling safely and
lawfully within its own lane of travel at the time the Defendant entered into its lane causing the
collision between the Plaintiff and the Defendant.
nrrltt
" " ~
-
i I~.
.....,
'~~'$I~ .
"--""'':'"'~'tl!;_:''
, ~
~
l.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Walsh Trucking Services, LLC, respectfully requests judgment
against the Defendant in keeping with the Plaintiffs Complaint which is incorporated by
reference herein,
Respectfully submitted,
REAGE , P.C.
Date: February 15, 2002
!
Tomas O. Williams, Esquir
Attorney I.D. No. 67987
2331 Market Street
Camp Hill, PA 17011-464
Telephone: (717) 763-1383
Attorneys for Plaintiff
2
~
,"'--
" ~
, \'
~
~~~I:!li""'"
'- -"
'~"~'e"\iim~{
- . ..
'"
VERIFICA TION
I, Gerald R. Matteo, hereby verify that I am the Director of Loss Prevention of Walsh
Trucking Services, LLC and, as such, I am authorized to verifY the averments of the foregoing
document arc true and correct to my personal knowledge, information and belief. I understand
that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. g4904, relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities.
Date:
';h fUel" Y '11 2019:J-..,
I
By: ~
Gerald R. Matteo
""
,
-,<,I'
- -~,'" - ~.._',--, ~ '">18~ ",' -~~
...
.;.
CRRTTFICATR OF SRRVWR
AND NOW, this 15th day of February, 2002, I hereby verify that I have caused a true and
correct copy of the foregoing document to be placed in the U.S. mail, first class, postage prepaid and
addressed as follows:
Frank 1. Lavery, Jr., Esquire
Lavery, Faherty, Young & Patterson, P.C.
The Kunkel Building
30 I Market Street, Suite 800
P,O. Box 1245
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1245
tI!f{1J)}
THOMAS 0, WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE
"
:'if~",:";j~,t;j4t.fi:~~i'tJL'!>\'~~io.i,~,,,i^~j!!,;i~~~M)-j-,":i ''','",~"A~}",:',~''/i:",i\' l&:.di.\,!>;o$,fiA1L'liliJr;djjff_~iIM!!ii!i~~lWhI!Ml:" i--\J
" ...
~,o,'~" ",' ,,,'.'
'-'~, " ,,"- '"~~
,
lfjII:[jr - 'IilInllt:j;1"'ifIiIU.dIIIilIi
...
2;C
S:; ~:2
"7
::;J
-,
--1'"\
"1
- ))
;.,'
,
u-,
;f
~~.,
.--
,-'
)
'~~{"
51
-<
,:.0
.-.1
, ,
~ " I U
, ~ -.'
--"~:"'Ill!~;
,AIO
~
'\
WALSH TRUCKING SERVICES, LLC,
Plaintiff
:IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
:CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
v.
: No. 01-6413 Civil Term
NINA LOUISE OBERLIN alk!a
NINA OBERLIN HACH
Defendant
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE FOR DISCONTINUANCE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
PLEASE mark the above-captioned matter ended, settled and discontinued.
Date: If} - 3/- 0).
Thomas . Williams, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
~~I"""J"it-:i~~" "'-'<-'3"-'" ,~",,,,~ ""'~-^'~~N:I!l>jf<;;~~~~
..
~
)".11.. U !1ll11r
. ,,,c.~, ''-'' ,~~~. \j",s,'_A~""'6'" _,,'" <i~'n'l~l_
,-
IiilliII~~
'-!JIBliIl "~'
<0__
~
~,,-
'II
I
Ii
(') C) 0
C i".)
<" '."r'~
"'nui 0
n1p", r; ,---
~::c; -I .. T
c.o) 1---
(I)S:~' -.. ,
-<"" --~~-' ~-,'
r"C ,~
'!ii' ~ -;" ~
~",C"'-, ::r-:
.$' C) c'
'-- r-n
2.: '.:.0
;::;J
~ (:J
,',,~>,' ,_, c "r~= ,""