HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-06530
..., '
.'
.'.
.~~-
,~ l'
~-' ~-'''''~*-,.--~'
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JACOB R. SHANK aIkIa PETE
SHANK, an individual,
Plaintiff,
vs.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. tJ(- &S-3t)
~
NOTICE TO DEFEND
NOTICJJ;
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish
to defeud against the claims set forth in the
following pages, you must take action within twenty
(20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served,
by entering a written appearance personally or by
attorney and filing in writing with the Court your
defenses and objections to the claims set forth
against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so
the case may proceed without you and a judgment
may be entered against you by the Court without
further notice for any money claimed in the
Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested
by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or
other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR
LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A
LAWYER OR CANNOT AFfORD ONE, GO TO
OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH
BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET
LEGAL HELP.
CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
(71 7) 249-3166
AVISO
USTED HA SIDO DEMANDADO/A EN CORTE.
Si usted desea defenderse de las demandas que se
presentan mas adelante en las siguientes paginas,
debe tomar accion dentro de los proximos veinte (20)
dias despues de la notifcacion de esta Demanda y
A viso radicando persona1mente 0 por medio de un
abogado una comparecencia escrita y radicando eu 1a
Corte par escrito sus defensas de, y objeccion'es a, las
demandas presentada aqui en contra suya. Se Ie
advierte de que si usted falla de tomar accion como
se describe anterionnente, el caso puede proceder sin
usted y un fallo por cualquier suma de dinero
reclamada en la demanda 0 cualquier otra
reclamacion 0 remedio solicitado por el demandante
puede ser dictado en contra suya por la Corte sin mas
aviso adicional. Usted puede parder dinero 0
propiedad u otros derechos importantes para usted.
USTED DEBE LLEV AR ESTE DOCUMENTO A
SU ABOGADO INMEDIATAMENTE. SI USTED
NO TIENE UN ABOGADO 0 NO PUEDE
PAGARLE A UNO, LLAME 0 V AY A A LA
SIGUIENTE OFICINA PARA A VERIGUAR
CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, P A 17013
(71 7) 249-3166
~i'
~""-
. ,
I..... '"""'"
> "~,
~-.,(li\{~~;;;
.., .
~.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JACOB R. SHANK aJk/a PETE
SHANK, an individual,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiff,
NO. OI-C9530
vs.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant.
COMPLAINT
AND NOW, comes the Plaintiff, Jacob R. Shank, by and through his counsel, Gates &
Associates, P.C., and makes the following complaint:
1. Jacob R. Shank a/k/a Pete Shank is an adult individual maintaining a residence at
RC. 63 Box 7, McAlisterville, Pennsylvania 17049 (hereinafter referred to as "Plaintiff' or
"Shank").
2. Patricia J. Sterling is an adult individual currently residing at 504 Walton Court,
Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043 (hereinafter referred to as "Defendant" or "Sterling").
3. Beginning in November, 1999 and continuing through July, 2001, Shank provided
numerous services to Defendant, including, but not limited to, the provision of certain labor and
materials, regarding the upkeep, maintenance and improvements to, inter alia, Defendant's
personal residence.
4. Shank paid $49.00 for a garage door repair item for Defendant's personal
residence.
5. Shank paid $1,328.00 for a new garage door for Defendant's personal residence.
..
~ ,,,,~-,
w,,:,,';:,~ ~~, 'ih.!l.~~!]:~_,
"'. .
....
,
6. Shank paid $470.64 for a certain range stove affixed in Defendant's personal
residence.
7. Shank paid for certain window blinds and related materials and expended labor and
provided services installing said window blinds in Defendant's personal residence in the amount of
$110.71.
8. Shank paid $1,472.16 for the service and maintenance of Defendant's 1992
Cadillac automobile.
9. Shank paid for certain painting materials and expended labor and provided services
painting a certain room or rooms within Defendant's personal residence in the amount of$143.09.
10. Shank paid for certain stone materials and expended labor and provided services
installing said stones upon the exterior of Defendant's personal residence in the amount of
$318.08.
11. Shank paid for the materials and installation of a certain fence on the property of
Defendant's personal residence in the amount of$3,839.97.
12. Shank paid certain concrete materials and expended labor and provided services
pouring a concrete foundation on the property of Defendant's personal residence for a utility shed
in the amount of$253.60.
13. Shank expended labor and provided services for the erection of a utility shed upon
the property of Defendant's personal residence in the amount of$240.00.
14. Shank paid for certain landscaping materials for the borders and edging of the
property of Defendant's personal residence in the amount of$94.60.
15. Shank paid $400.00 for certain maintenance materials utilized for the maintenance
2
'-'~
-~
".;.
'J~~;'_,
'. .
11(.
of Defendant's personal residence.
16. Shank paid for certain decorative stone materials and expended labor and provided
services for the installation of said decorative stone in the amount of$484.86.
17. Shank paid $150.00 for certain blacktop materials applied to the driveway of
Defendant's personal residence.
18. Shank paid for a garbage disposal and expended labor and provided services for
the installation of said garbage disposal in Defendant's personal residence in the amount of
$120.00.
19. Shank paid for a certain water system and expended labor and provided services
for the installation of said water system in certain investment real property of the Defendant in the
amount of$I,230.00.
20. Shank paid for certain insulation materials and expended labor and provided
services for the installation of said insulation in Defendant's personal residence in the amount of
$315.00.
21. On multiple occasions, Defendant orally acknowledged to Shank the obligation to
repay Shank for the labor and materials provided to Defendant by Shank.
22. In April, 2001, Shank agreed to purchase a 1992 Cadillac automobile in the
amount of $6,000.00 for Defendant and, in return, Defendant agreed to repay Shank at such time
as Defendant was able.
23. To date, Shank has not received payment for any of the services, including labor
and/or materials provided to Defendant.
24. To date, Shank has not received payment on the above referenced 1992 Cadillac
3
.'"'
-~
~ _I"
--.-~, '^-'-' -"\1.' ~_~.~?1!1il;
J ~ .
..,.' .
automobile.
25. Shank made demand upon Defendant to repay the monies loaned to Defendant for
the purchase of the 1992 Cadillac and to repay of the cost of materials and associated labor
incurred on the aforementioned items on September 25,2001.
COUNT L BREACH OF EXPRESS ORAL AGREEMENT
26. Paragraphs 1 - 25 of this Complaint are herein incorporated by reference as though
set forth in full.
27. Defendant entered into an express oral agreement as set forth above.
28. Defendant was in breach of said Agreement in or about September, 2001.
29. Plaintiff is entitled to interest at the judgment rate of six (6%) percent per annum
from the date ofthe loan.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendant, Patricia 1. Sterling for
principal and judgment interest in the amount of Six Thousand Three Hundred Sixty and 00/1 00
($6,360.00) Dollars, plus costs, attorney fees and additional interest accruing during the pendency
of this action.
COUNT IT. UNJUST ENRICHMENT
30. Paragraphs 1 - 29 of this Complaint are herein incorporated by reference as though
set forth in full.
31. Shank conferred a benefit upon Defendant by purchasing Defendant a 1992
Cadillac automobile for Defendant on the condition that Defendant would repay Shank in full.
32. Shank conferred additional benefits upon Defendant by providing significant
services, including labor and materials to Defendant as set forth above.
4
"'
"- ,
'"_.'"
" ,
~.
-";'tJ:~!:'",-~i$!!i'k';
#. .
",,' .
33. Defendant appreciated the benefits provided by Shank.
34. Defendant accepted and retained the benefits provided by Shank.
3 5. It would be inequitable for Defendant to retain the benefit of the services provided
by Shank without the payment of value for the herein referenced services.
36. Shank is entitled to interest at the judgment rate of six (6%) percent per annum
from the date of the loan.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendant, Patricia 1. Sterling for
principal and judgment interest in the amount of Eighteen Thousand Forty and 89/100
($18,040.89) Dollars, plus costs, attorney fees and additional interest accruing during the
pendency of this action.
Respectfully submitted
GATES & ASSOCIATES, P.c.
Albert N.' eterlin, squire
Attorney I.D. No. 84180
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100
Lemoyne, PA 17043
(717) 731-9600
(Attorneys for PlaintiO)
DATED: VokrYYbf'1' /6) LGJOI
5
~
--
-.
~~
<,"'J 'Iitli.. '-~-,
-,,;.,;"~_,,---, ""''''i~--. "-il:.1iifi
''1
VERIFICATION
I, Jacob R. Shank a1k/a Pete Shank, state that I have reviewed the foregoing Complaint
and verifY that it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief
I further verifY that these statements made by me are subject to the penalties of 18
Pa.C.S.A. ~ 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Jacob R. Shank aIkIa Pete Shank
DATED:
~/~/
'"
jil~iii!.~?~ttili!;i[,~mjl~l;i'llcl'!'-;~~'!"~1!"';;A'jll",,-",~J;;';-:"'",t; ,". }"'-""'-~"':!,".if'''''':":;:\-$,,;::i,-,,",,,~j;':-;''",,,,~.$'ff''$i1';!*~dIllI\f:d,I:>1i!ll<!it:t~~~~I.fI!I~~~~;,:m,;~<'i!,~~I*!!iIII;l;!liil"iI!llli
.-
~l'
~
~ ~ ~ ~~ 0 D C)
,~ C '"
~~ s: % :~J
~ -0-" r-.::>
~" ___, >"1
SPS~; <
~. ,
Zc.- ."..,;-Tj
\\ ~i,;: \..0 '~~;~ ~~
" ~ \ r.;:C;
-'I> ,-.... -.0 ~~
'" Ze
~ ~ 50 N
, C
~ ~ ~
~ .:.AJ :OJ
'i' -<
~
JC~.-".,~,_~"
,_.u ~
~~ ~~
._0-
i~ '"" illb::IiI('~"'~"'~""" t <"~N,.",,"'
.... --.,. ,~
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JACOB R. SHANK aIkIa PETE
SHANK, an individual,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
Plaintiff,
vs.
PATRICIAJ, STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant.
ANSWER TO DEFENDANT'S
ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER
Plaintiff, Jacob R. Shank, by and through his counsel, Gates & Associates, P.C., respond to Defendant's
Answer with New Matter, and aver as follows:
37. Denied. The averments contained in this paragraph constitute conclusions oflaw
to which no response is required.
38. Denied. At all times heretofore, Plaintiff maintained a residence at certain real
property owned by Plaintiff and commonly identified as H.C. 63 Box 7, McAlisterville, Peunsylvania 17049. By
way of further response, although Plaintiff maintained the above-referenced residence at all times heretofore,
Plaintiff paid Defendant approximately Four Hundred and 00/100 ($400.00) Dollars per month to cover certain
living expenses of Defendant from Jannary, 2000 through July, 2001.
Respectfully submitted
GATES & ASSOCIATES, P.e.
o1~~
Attorney LD. No. 84180
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100
Lemoyne, PA 17043
(717) 731-9600
(Attorneys for Plaintiff)
DATED:
J?/;~ /r!lJ
II
.
"
, ",-", ~, Ll''l&~'';t'"'''~''~f'''
..."'" .",.0..
CERTnnCATEOFSER~CE
I, Albert R Peterlin, Esquire, hereby certifY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing
Answer to Defendant's Answer with New Matter, has been served upon the following counsel of
record by first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
James G. Morgan, Jr.
TUCKER ARENSBERG & SWARTZ
III North Front Street
P.O. Box 889
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0889
GATES & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
af&fJ(~
Attorney for the PlaintitT
DATED: Ie, (\4 Jt1)
,
.~.J;"';'~1!i.~\%'"'t:\1'~'"~l.oiliti~;g,&li1\ll:;a;IW,f,]:dtL-;;''''}0.,",", _""".","2!'hjl:!k';,'l'":"'!$:"~.1;,;;gi!i'",li>E,,iJj~~,,tJ.'l$g.~ifi~iltil!~~'-"~.::ID1~jW&IH!1Ililli~
0,0_' ;,-<Y,",'""""'-1'~,,",O<~'''''''''"''''',~~
"'M'_~"M.~,.'"__"".",~'"'n"'1 -~'" "'e_" A -",W,~,"" _.,
~ ,~_ ~ ,~~..""""',, "C.,~~
. ,,-'.~ --
~-~
,.' "-"="' .><~ ,= a" ._<< ~^
o
c
s:
~if.(
Z:L'
6j~
20
~O
>~
~
-
E5
f<S
,.... ~....
C',
"""
~'l
.~j
;<'~F1
'-,.-,!1"1
:60
("')T,!..
-.',,1"'.)
::c'T,
0"
-".0
Om
35
'<
1:::1
r'l
c,
N
Cl
-u
::ii:
r::::
;:-
-.I
.
4.
, "~ 'e . 'I~.~ '
"' .'.',.,' ~,. "~.,I,,-,,"~,u';'>;;Yo.;, "";"'.,,,;~'~,-",~,,,,,10-.d,L':;A""'~'~~'''~'';,,-e.;,' '-":---'':'';:J~;
JACOB R. SHANK a/l<la PETE
SHANK, an Individual,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
PATRICIA J. STERLING, an
Individual,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
vs.
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NOTICE TO PLEAD
TO: JACOB R. SHANK a/k/a PETE SHANK
C/o Albert N. Peterlin, Esquire
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100
Lemoyne, PA 17043
YOU ARE HEREBY notified to file a written response to the enclosed Answer With
New Matter of Defendant Patricia J. Sterling within twenty (20) days from service hereof or
a judgment may be entered against you.
1'\
By:
NSBE~G & SWARTZ
Dated: ;:<-{ /.z.{ 0 (
Attorney for Defendant
. ="""""",,~ ,~ .ll:t""" ~
.
. ~~....." '. ..' liiiJl:~ltilt'i I . "-, ~~jR~,if>Yf
JACOB R. SHANK a/kJa PETE
SHANK, an Individual,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
PATRICIA J. STERLING, an
Individual,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
vs.
DEFENDANT'S ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER
AND NOW COMES the Defendant by her attorney, James G. Morgan, Jr., of the
law firm of TUCKER ARENS BERG & SWARTZ and avers as follows:
1. Admitted.
2. Admitted.
3. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff performed
various services for Defendant and at Defendant's personal residence. By way of
further answer, it is specifically denied that Defendant entered into any oral and/or
written agreement with Plaintiff stating that Defendant would compensate Plaintiff for
these services.
4. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
_ ..J.
1-".'
~' .
,-,~""",,tS'__.
.~., ~'";_.,,,r;-.-.'--' .' '.. '~l>i\l:~--_
5. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
6. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
7. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
8. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
9. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
10. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
11. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
12. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
13. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
14. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
2
. -, - ~'- 4h'^"-" ,'c-,'-, ;0' ~,.:;'~_<;<,-{" i ;:.I;i'::S.,,~ ",~",-;";,~:,;_:, ' ,',-';,-",',_' ii'-,,~~:~;:-'~:,;;,.i:,i{,'
"';-'00'
c-'-~-"'~'eJ
15. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
16. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
17. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
18. Neither admitted nor denied, Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
19. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
20. Neither admitted nor denied. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to
answer the same and demands strict proof at trial.
21. Denied. It is specifically denied that Defendant orally acknowledged to
Plaintiff any obligations to repay him for any alleged labor and materials provided to
Defendant by Plaintiff.
22. Denied. It is specifically denied that Plaintiff purchased a 1992 Cadillac
automobile in April of 2001. By way of further answer, it is specifically denied that
Defendant agreed to repay Plaintiff for the purchase of a 1992 Cadillac automobile in
the amount of $6,000.00 and/or any other monetary amount.
3
""
'.
I, --,.," " ,','i..,; '. ,- -;";",;, _;..i/';'.,~;"'-'J;'" ",'-IMB!!"',-' ",-.,):"'-',,,,-,,~';~:",Wc.:,>-';.-,-;,.:;,-",~,,, "...-'":-; ~~.-. ", i~_~,;
23. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that Defendant has not
paid Plaintiff for any alleged services, labor and materials provided to Defendant. By
way of further answer, it is specifically denied that Defendant orally acknowledged to
Plaintiff any obligations to repay him for any alleged services, labor and materials
provided to Defendant by Plaintiff.
24. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that Defendant has not
paid Plaintiff for the purchase of a 1992 Cadillac automobile. By way of further answer,
it is specifically denied that Defendant orally acknowledged to Plaintiff any obligations to
repay him for a 1992 Cadillac automobile provided to Defendant by Plaintiff.
25. Denied. It is specifically denied that Plaintiff made a demand upon
Defendant to repay the alleged monies loaned to Defendant for the purchase of a 1992
Cadillac automobile and to repay of the cost of materials and associated labor incurred
on the aforementioned items on September 25, 2001.
WHEREFORE, Defendant demands judgment in her favor against Plaintiff as
well as an award for attorneys' fees and costs of suit.
COUNT I
BREACH OF EXPRESS ORAL AGREEMENT
26. No answer is necessary.
27. Denied. It is specifically denied that Defendant entered into an express
oral agreement with Plaintiff,
4
J.
" ,
. ",;I",-,':"'_.h_,,,",,,^~~;,--' "C '~--;,~J' t~"" -'--"0< -"i~ :, .,Ii ,,~,;, ""~' '~,'_,~. ";;;;;ii;(i;",,;;ik'-W,~,iJ;. -, ",,-,-~c,_. .,~ o~llJifjjl
28. Denied. It is specifically denied that Defendant entered into an express
oral agreement with Plaintiff. Thus, Defendant is not in breach of said Agreement in or
about September, 2001.
29. Denied. It is specifically denied that Plaintiff is entitled to interest at the
judgment rate of six (6%) percent per annum from the date of the loan because. in fact,
there never was an express oral agreement between Plaintiff and Defendant at any
time.
WHEREFORE, Defendant demands judgment in her favor against Plaintiff as
well as an award for attorneys' fees and costs of suit.
COUNT II
UNJUST ENRICHMENT
30. No answer is necessary.
31. Denied. It is specifically denied that Plaintiff conferred a benefit upon
Defendant by purchasing Defendant a 1992 Cadillac automobile for Defendant on the
condition that Defendant would repay Plaintiff in full.
32, Admitted.
33, Admitted.
34, Admitted.
35. Denied. It is specifically denied that it would be inequitable for Defendant
to retain the benefit of the services provided by Plaintiff without the payment of value for
5
I",'.
.' ~,_,c
~""~", ";;,"-1;-."";.,.-:',,., >'--',:,f ~"",; c'i\,",o{jlj~-i,~~"';;.;.._',,;" ;,,- "":;':>-"-rr:J
the referenced services enumerated within Plaintiffs Complaint. By way of further
answer, Defendant advised Plaintiff prior to the purchase of the 1992 Cadillac
automobile and prior to the services provided by Plaintiff, that she could not afford to
compensate Plaintiff due to the fact that she was on a fixed monthly income.
36. Denied. It is specifically denied that Plaintiff is entitled to interest at the
judgment rate of six (6%) percent per annum from the date of the loan,
WHEREFORE, Defendant demands judgment in her favor against Plaintiff as
well as an award for attorneys' fees and costs of suit.
NEW MATTER
37, Plaintiff has failed to state a cause of action against Defendant upon which
relief can be granted.
38. Plaintiff was a full time resident at Defendant's residence from approximately
January, 2000 through July, 2001. During this entire time period, Defendant did not
charge Plaintiff any rent.
6
~\
" .
I ' ,~ ,,- '. - _ '. . "" -,. '.
," ,'.
. "", .' :'.",o'i'.';;- :-;,;>\'1. ;~""'''' ,,;.~, ;O:1',>\:~,j
WHEREFORE, the Defendant respectfully requests that the Plaintiffs
Complaint be dismissed in its entirety and attorneys' fees and costs be assessed against
the Plaintiff, as well as any other relief this Court deems appropriate.
111 N rt Front Street
Harris ur ,PA 17101-0889
(717) -4121
Dated: December \ \ , 2001
45705.1
7
~.
~--~
,"-
.,
......,
~ 1.......,""""',.,
'-~_~,..... .'~_. W&liiiiJi.~;~i
VERIFICATION
I, JAMES G. MORGAN, JR., attorney for the Defendant, Patricia J. Sterling, in the
within action, makes this verification on behalf of the Defendant, as a verification from the
Defendant can not be obtained within the time allowed for filing the pleading, and I affirm that
the facts set forth in the foregoing document are true and correct to the best of my information
and belief. The information has been provided to the undersigned by the Defendant.
I understand that any false statements herein are made subject to penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.
~4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
27065.1
""
, ~
~ '
I, ,___,-,_ '''-'',",-.-.,~..-~'-<~- l~i.'':'''-:, ~"~""" ,"'~"I'. ".C, '~."'c-"j;;~::;i".-'--':;'c :~:o'_;,-~ '". ,. ,c:S'-'illiit;i
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
AND NOW, this I ~ day of December, 2001, I, Cathleen A. Kohr, for the firm
of Tucker Arensberg & Swartz, attorneys for Defendant, hereby certify that I have this day
served Defendant's Answer with New Matter by causing a copy of the same to be placed
in the United States Mail, First Class, postage prepaid, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania,
addressed as follows:
Albert N, Peterlin, Esquire
GATES & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100
Lemoyne, PA 17043
{1~A, I{L
Cathleen A. Kohr
. ~:
~~~:~< >""""'~~'\ii,,-.i,.0;iid'!I~"-''il'';' .,1---- b~~~,~Mt\ID~~~~:~'-rj""",,>.=~ii.iJ.Mi"1.:'~;id''''''
~", ,,-",..n". =_;0'. "~ ... ..=" _,~ 0 ~ ,,"_ _>~~_"'_"""_~:>,,L~-,".~ '"",1_ ;,_ ..~,,~ _ ~ ___c~_,~,= ,-, ."'~"',~, ,,"~, ::"'"
',' "'. ~i",' '~"'-"'-L"--.i1di-l-";~'-" . .~--Ii1."'
0
C~, C)
VJ 0 ~ ",'I
-r, ~
~ ITl D':: I 1 m
C) :-=tJ
('\ ~r'; ;
!----r-j
C,..:' ,
....,
(" VJ ~ ~ ,'.
~;.: \.,,:; T
'0 );~ ,--",
----o-C' -_.~
,"--,-.
\) ~ ...1-,,:-, l~ N ,--',
3 ~-- :::':..
:::''::i ~, II
~- ~<
~ ~ .-J -<
':2
"'; _~ '>t }
,;.
"'. >
, .',
,',"
-
.~
.. ._~..___.~.. ~._ ,_u .., "~'_'_'__'."~_~"_,~,
.~..- -~..- _..,._---~...- ._--_._----_...~,_._._.. ,
. ... '..m,~
........~~~~~1~~~:!J)r~:f~2~B,~,
b~b~~ ~;'J::' /~~ I $ ;K.o",.~ .1
J;t;- .' ~ ~ ;:4:- m--
cii~-~;~{~;i~-t~S~~~w~-o:~~.~o~~r~r.i;~~~~~~2:.;:F~: : .
M~~o.::~~~~~~~.,-=~:-o.:--L:~~~~-I'~.d~W .
1:0 :I ~ b 27 U: .' 0 ~O 70 7 'm~~ ~ 1,8"'-;"00000 1,0000." F.
. -...,--.--.- ~ ,-.- ',~ ---.--.-----________.,_ ."-' -7_.._'~---..':".
,,-~--.....'.-._._,.
. . .
t
EXHIBIT
r___.2-
I
,k.,
,..'
-.
,:",
'0 '
. ,
t'\f~ ,.> "'~,,~_'\, l:",-,-~
",.'
,'.,.
'..
. .
"
.,
1
\
I
;
, ;
II ~~I n
,O'J', ..,'
. .
, ',...~,.., ".'.
";v;,."
:..-
,......
04 104 03 01~
011025250 01t:a-:i23
--+
'.
T>o
I
.
.. I'
.,.,',
-"',
.,.,: " \
"---"".
.',.'j:
"',"
-<-
....
'.0
lilT BttNf?t~1 .
H~mil\.O!l'(
800-523-8:498
,
31 ~){}~~J~})bt)
/
,.
" ;.1'-'.
'.' '
'I . ". '>"~'
,,'.;..
"
:-'"..
...,',
-'_:~",~l~:: ";~~~~
~t
~l
11
.
,
i
t
, "~I
. .
----'.=
"-
"_.~
~ 1 . "
~.
.....~"',_..
Ii" 'c.' :'<='''"';;---''-"~o~~l
, "'..'
JACOB R. SHANK alk/a
PETE SHANK, an Individual,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
vs.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PATRICIA 1. STERLING, an
Individual,
Defendant
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
DEFENDANT'S LIST OF ARBITRATION EXHmITS
1. Motor vehicle pink slip (date of purchase 11/20/99, purchased price - $6,000.00)
transferring title from Charles Pilbey to Jacob Shank
(purchase of 1992 Cadillac)
2. Motor vehicle pink slip (date acquired 12/5/00, purchase price - $0.00)
transferring title from Jacob Shank to Patricia Sterling
(transfer title of 1992 Cadillac)
56559.1
, ,
"Q"""""""'","~",I,"''''~"_--,,",
~,/
/
~
~
.
"
~
~
~
'r~'~ ,.~L
I.
~ ,
-'WI""" 0''''<
No.2228239
I ; I . -
!A.'
, 0
~w
Qi
ffig
>~
.
PORe E
PAleE
(Seeoote on reverse)
1/ ,....
, ;//() )-/<;;../,
.
LESS
TRAoE~IN
/";'/'7
.
.
B.
MIDDLE INfTlAL
lJ\XABLE
AMOUNT
~
~
w
.0
.
c:
. E',' '. MIDDlE-INITIAL
"'-J
<,
~
.W
o
~
u
~ smEET
.
~
;;~
7
./'-"1.
ZIP CODE
.-,-'", '---j"'''''''
F'7o''7,.~'
t!-/-; I 'J
Il.! J {P.~
-,._~}
J\f}
~ ,.,,,"",
--7
/
7
ST.<IE
.>?
.
.., f,
/.f ~>
....k~i.
le.,..4'd
.
.
" D.: ~NAME{OR.fUU:_IiIU$IN~~E) .'
"F1f!Sl:.NAM~
"MIDDLEINIllAL DA1E':ACQU,REDf
. " " . 'PURCHASED
~
w
~
, z
. .
"
.~
o
j'Z
. W
CD-PURCHASER
~
w
~STREEr
~
~
.
o
~
1
. .
~J ""
ilf) .
. .
. .
CITY
STATE
ZIP CODE
REFER TO COUNTY CODES 6. Transfer Fee
. USl1NG otJ'REVERSE'SIIE.
. . OF PIN){ copy'
E,
o POOR'
a,_Repl~nt .
Foe
MAKE OF VEHICtE
VEHICLE IDENTIFICATION NUMBER
7. Increase Fee
~Iil'
gg
....re . MOna YEAR
~"
CONDmON
o GOOD
o FAIR
IF.
ORlGl
o
.
.
PLATE Check One
P'l..JUE,TO'BE ISSUED BY
BUREAU {PROOF OF IN-
SURANCE MUST BE AT-
lACHEOJ
EXCHANGE PlATE lO-SE
ISSUED BY BUREAU
TEMp()f{ARV PLATE
ISSUED_BY FULL AGENT
~NSFER. OF'PREVI. OUSLY ISSUED PLATE
o TRANSFER & RENEWAl OF PLATE '_,
o TRANSFER & REPLACEMENT OF PLATE~
o TRANSFER OF. PLATE & REPLACEMENT OF STIGKER
9.
.10.
TOTAL PAID
(Add 1 thru8)
Send One
Check in
,- ,ThisAmQunt
....
~cs:-- .C?t
"lC ,.,.;v.
11:GRAND TCJ11.L
(Add,S:& 10)
REASON FOR REPLACEMENT
DLOST 0 DEFACED
DNEVEF!-RECElVED_lLOST-INMAlL} _'.
NOTE: If ''NEVER RECEIVED~ block is checked a
IIlN
~
~~
~ii
~!l
~a
~w
.~
.
o
o
D STOLEN
'icant must c
'te form MV-44.
:G~ 'I
SlG)"i"l'lE;" .
l ,/--'/";?,- 4"~,1'!,;;"_,;-?
REQ REG. GROSS WT, /,'
INCLUDING LOAD 1-
INSUI'lA/l<;ECOMI'ANYN!\MEO '. .... .... '.' POUCYNO.loR. .
~~~ .-- ~ -'I- - I"""J-" -~V >, f i ~OQR) /"'J::t'~ ,i ~c,.'rl'" -">'
.' .,' ,~~ _r.r: - '/~i' j,T:tf :,;;;, " ,;",', ". . -,..,.:.;;,. If '~.~")f :'J'
ISSUiNG' ..:icemu=YTI-tATONMotiJ;r..,:,:.,:"d:' ,,',Ofl({ ':'::~l~'I. ':"YEAR~::,,:' rSsUl~~AG.ENTJPflINT.,~E) < .
~ENT . . I HAVE l:;HECKED TQ DFTERMlNE-TRAT THE VEHICtE,IS lNSUBED.~ --rt-~- ~'.,r) " ,-'i;., "t".... iff,
ISSUED TEMPORARY REGlSTRA110N TO THe ABOVE IliPPlICANl;lN ' ' . - . -,< ,
INFOR- Co'MPlJANCE WiTH ALL APPLICABLE PROVISIONS OF THE VEHICLE CODe 1 E IG RE, ". .
MAllON ANO' DEPARrMENT REGULA110NS, '.
: I/WE carn=v mAT I!WE HAVE EXAMIN~D AND SIGNED ,TH]S FORM AFTER rIB l1:0MPLETlON AND THAT THE INFORMAllON-G
IS CLAIMED, THE PURCHASER FURTHER- CERTIFIES THAT HE/SHE IS AUTHORIZED'TO CLAIM THIS EXEMPTION. I/WE AGKNOWL:E:bG ' 1/WE MAY LOSE MY lOUR OPERATING'
PRMLEGE(S) OR VEHICLE REGISTRATION(S} FOR FAIWRE 10 MAI~N ANANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ON THE CURRENTLY RE ISTERED VEHICLE ,FOR THE PERIOD. OF." .
REGJSTRmON. IIWE ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I/WE MAY BE SUBJECT 10 A ANE NOT EXCEEDING $5,000 AND IMPRISONMENT OF' NOT MORE THAN TWO--, YEARS FOR ANY
FALSE SDlJEMENT THAT I/WE MAKE ON THIS FORM, .... ~
1ST Sig7t/~~~~~c~~~~_~~~;~~~~~ner ~~,/ _~LE;HONENUMBI;R ~;g~:;,e~:,:,~. ','~_~ ,~y;/., ~..~/-r/J
~- l~ffiOfCo-Purchaser/TitleofAUthorizedSignef ' :~.~'(rr~:~d~~~ ,'.;_"(,:.. :-d~j~(:~,~
Signaluffi of Second ~rchaser or Authorized Signer TEtEPHONE NUMBER SIgnature Of Seller
)
z
o
~
.
~
~
,
I
2ND
ASSIGN~
MENT
Signatuffi of Co-Purchaser /Trtle of ~lJ!horized Signer
$ig~ure of CO-Seller'
H. -' z
. 0
~~i
~t=:5
o ~
<- iij;
NOTE: If a co-purchaser other than your spouse is lis'ted an'd -you 'wartf'fhe t.itle to"be.listed as nJo-hit T'enants "With
Right of Sur-vivorshipft (On death of one owner, title goes to surviving owner.) CHECK HERE D. Otherwise, the title
will be issued as "Tenants in Commonll (On death of one owner, intf;;'lrest of dec.eased owner goes-to his/her heirs or
estate). .
NQTE: IF 'THE VEHICLE IS BEING LEASED, CHECK THIS BLOCK 0 . IF BLOCK IS CHECKED, COMPLETE AND ATTACH FORM MV-IL
If ~ur registration documents are not received MESSENGER NUMBER:
within 60 days, please contact PennDOT
3. APPLICANTS COPY/TEMPORARY REGISTRATION (VALID FOR 60 DAYS)
*-
'.-,'~~'~ - ,w!ll"""~",<""jj!~il:>ll"--!:___'",, ",="
-""",....,.
"" --
.,"
'.'.0 ".
-~, i Hf/ilIIi""" ,
~" ......
"'~~w..-":;'"f,
~Nb. 5269421
. c,
z
- ~
.
z
" ,
w '".'
.~ <
-
~ ~
z.
'0
, <.
~.
.
~
,
A.
Ml%E 'OF ~HICLE ,-
~~d /114f!..
.CONDITION
MODEL YEAR
r~1'
7
PuRcHAsE
PRICE
(See note onrever:se) 0 0
LESS
TRADE~IN 0
0
TAXABLE
AMOUNT 0
0
0 .
e
~-
o~
.z
g!,al
i1
/
FAIR
o POOR
MIDDLE INITIAL
~ :"~::t~::::,:.,
LA~ NAM~ (OR Fl!~]..: ~U~I~E~~NAME)
Y'.1.- .n I.... '.~...,>.
~.7ff2;.;/t}~" } ~"~L~.;~
~CO::p:URCHASER,~':' _'
A:;. F.IBST NAME
"'Aiil-~,1; ,
,/:1. <'" / a/.ff
'MIDDLE INmAL
--
J,'
PATE_ACQUIREDI
PUR9.!JfS H EJ.-: 1
:.;; '? -()O
F
:-~':'~~~~; ,::;'
'g-ac; t~u:;';;fh
C~T-Y ;
[Pi;?!;1 '
.,'
1::
5;f-
.
1
.-2;;<157'\
~
J~'!J;~~:~'):'2~(- ;
~AfE~:..;
.t;4.~T
ZIP CODE
/[1V3
~~~"e rgNC~E~~~~~S 3. lien
OF PtNK coPY Fee
'.'
o
.
0;: ~Lf5! NAME ( A" f.!JLL BUSINESS NAME)
'tl!1j1"
CQ-PURCl"JASER
_ _FlRST'NAME' 'MIDDLE INITIAL DATE ACQUIREDI
PURCHASED
4. RegistrarlO~ or
.. Processing Fee
.
...<t'
z
-
. <
z W
'C) 'UJ
. .
~ '~
e ,
~ ~
z
"
STREET,
COUNTY CODE
1
. 0
/ i(t~
U "'''-..... .
7, Increase Fee
. o.
8. Replacement
F"
. .
9. 10.
TOTAL PAID
(Add 1 thru,8) 0 0
11.GRAND TOTAL SendQne
_CheckiJ;l
(Ad(f,9&'1'Q) . This >{l,.maunt ~
CITY
STATE
ZIP .CODE
REFER TO COUNTY CODES-
WSTlNG ON REVERSE SIDE
OF,PlNK COPY
E.
MAKE OF VEHICLE
VEHICLE IDENTIFICATION NUMBER
We
"-
~~ MODEL YEAR
~~
F.
._):;:~-/ "",.-,.."" )~~'j
CONDITION
o G~OO
o FAIR
o POOR
o IGlNAL PLATE
o PLATE TO BE ISSUED ElY.
BUREAU (PROOF OF IN.
SURANCE MUST BE At-
TACHED.)
EXCHANGE PLATE TO I3E
ISSUED BY BUREAU
TEMPORARY PLATE
ISSUED BY FULL AGeNT
REASON FOR REPLAOE ENT
QLQ9T;' _' , ' , 0 DEFACED
i "QNEVe:RRECEIVED (LOST IN MAIL)
(f , NOTE: If "NEVE:R RECEIVED" block is ,checked a Iicanl ust co ',form MV-44.
VIN - /' -.' '"
lo:-bFL/3B.7}/ti;{.//!:r i77
RELATIONSHIP TO APPLICANT
.-::~~ ",j' '<."-',;.: "--,,.
REO: REG: GROSS COMB.
WT. (IF ARPUCABLE)
o sroLEN
.
oz
.0
~!:i
~~
,.
.-
.<
.
~':~'" ,':;~~>-'?>_'J't'~(/'",~~.
RE- . REG. GROSS WT.
I LUPING LOAD
G.
WEIG 0.
(Iff APPLICABLE)
l~j~~9MPhZ5 ~ b~N:CY EFFECTIVE b~-MCY EXPIRATION
ISSUING I CERTIFY mAT ON MONTH /',"/ - DAY YEAR / AG~NT ~o:,., _ ,-7y //_ Y
A(jENT I HAVE CHECKED TO DETERMINE'TH/l:l THE VEHICLE IS INSURED AND ';if # 7 V V a
ItilFOR- ISSUED TEMPORARY REGISTRATION TO THE ABOVE APPLICANT, IN
MAllON . COMPLIANCE WITH All APPLICABLE PROVISIONS OF THE VEHICLE CODe .. , 1 TELEPHONE NO.
AND DEPARTMENT REGULATIONS. /\ --/ *':\- ( )
I~WE CERTIFY ,THAT l/WE HA: EXAMINED AND SIGNED THIS FORM AFTER ITS COMPLETION AND rHAT THE'INFORMATION'GIV IS',TRUE AND-CORREct:'IF!!IN EXEMPTION
IS' CLAIMED, THE PURCHASER fURTHER CERTIFIES THAT HE/SHE IS AUTHORIZED TO CLAIM THIS EXEMPTION. I/WE ACKNOWLED THAT I/WE MAY LOSE MY lOUR OPERATING
PF;lMLEGE(S) OR VEHICLE Re:GISTRATION(S) FOR FAILURE TO MAINTAIN FINANCIAL RESPONSIBilITY ON THE CURRENTlY R iSTERED VEHICLE FOR TFiE PERIOD OF
R'EG1STRATION. I/WE ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I/WE MAY BE SUBJECT TO A FINE NOT EXCEEDING $5,000 AND IMPRISONMENT OF NOT MORE THAN TWO YEARS FOR ANY
FALSE STATEMENT THAT IIWE' E ON THIS FORM.
Signature~o~ F,i~ PtJrphaser ~r 'uthorif?d!S~gner('
I '/~r.';_'.-r-' _,,",' ",,,YU',,tJ, ,~' J
Signature of CO.Pu_rchaserttifle of Authorized Signerj
z
e
~
"
"
-
o
TELEPHONE NUMBER
)
Signa~re 3f ~~~~, ".,,--;
'---.,'-!_,--.^''''~,.
:?!gnalure of Co-Seller
~-~ .
it'-- f '
,1ST
AsSIGN.
MENT
Signature of Second Purchaser or Authorized Signer
TELEPHONE NUMBER
Signature of Seller
2ND
ASSIGN~
MENT
Signature of Co~Purchaser /Title of Authorized Signer
Signature of Co..seller
H. ;;! ~
~~~
~i=l!i
c .
. .
NOTE: If a cOMpurchaser other than your spouse is listed and you want the title to be listed as "Joi'nt Tenants Wit'h
Right of Survivorship" (On death of one owner, titie goes to surviving owner.) CHECK HERE O. Otherwise, the title
will be issued as "Tenants in Common" (On death of one owner, interest of deceased owner goes to his/her heirs or'
estate).
NOTE: IF THE VEHlCLE IS BEING lEASED, CHECK THIS BLOCK 0 . IF BLOCK IS CHECKED, COMPLETE AND ATTACH FORM MV.IL.
It y'ourregistration documents are not received ,MESSENGER NuMBER:
Within 60 days, please contact PennOOT
3. APPLICANTS COPY/TEMpORARY REGISlllA1lO1II {VAlID FOR 60 DAYS}
,D~i4~~~iAAiflilbmHil~~f;\;'f<$.j""'~il~~IfJI$M,"i&."'~,' ':,,1i::<',-,,",~,:~ .-' '''~4-B~~,>::{,;iA-.!i,I~~iIiIti'~.alIiljJIl!l'i~ill_
~r{,,-:~,-t,q,~ ~K:<f,'=~,,,, 11'~~ .-" ,J][[], ,: ,y>:,.- "3.--..-','ct,.,_ e-;!)>!~'-jj,n:!""'_':'_~"'H,..' "'.j'-'-. '\N"" ^~--' ~,' .~r,' ~ . ~.,' ',_
<>--~ ...
-<,,-
~, .,-, ,,",'-',
",'......."
""-j~'it"""'~ ~iIl.lJjL i"
ltCFIVt,
FEB 07 2003
i1j......1ifli'it,
,.. - " , ~
-", .,"=",'
..J "..-" < _'__""" "<-,,,~,;., . I<;'~. "jl,,~, ",' .-""_,'C";<':F' !:;', '~i,;,"'<c,,--;.i;.h,~;i,.,,;,,,,,,,,;.,~.'c;i_"'':;''>';''1vj~;
TUCKER ARENSBERC & SWARTZ
.~
CELEBRA TINe A CENTURY OF SERVICE
E-MAIL: CKOHR@TuCKERLAW.COM
February 6, 2003
Edward 1. Schorpp, Esquire
MARTSON, DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS & OTTO
10 East High Street
Carlisle, P A 17013
RE: Jacob R. Shank aIkIa Pete Shank v. Patricia J. Sterling
Cumberland C.C.P. No: 01-6530 Civil
Dear Mr. Schorpp:
Enclosed please fmd Defendant's List of Exhibits intended for use at Arbitration scheduled for
Thursday, March 6, 2003 at 9:00 a.m. in the above referenced matter. Thank you for your attention
to this matter.
Very truly yours,
TUCKER ARENSBERG & SWARTZ
flft&vl A, ffL
Cathleen A. Kohr,
Paralegal to James G. Morgan, Jr.
/cak
Enclosures
Cc: Albert Peterlin, Esquire (w/encls.)
Patricia Sterling (w/o encls.)
56582.1
111 NORTH FRONT STREET PO BOX 889 HARRISBURG, PA 17108-0889 717-234-4121 800-257-4121 FAX 717-232~6802
Pittsburgh . Pittsburgh Airport Area . Lewistown
E-mail: tapc@tuckerlaw.com
www.tuckerlaw.com
~
-,.
.", ~
._--~' .,..- '~', . ^. ,.. , 0 ~I~~,'
'-""'->4 "-''''''~",...,&;';'",;jf,'''',..;l~'~,', "{itJIDiMir'y;
LAW OFFICES OF
GATES, HALBRUNER & - HATCH, P.C.
LOWELL Fl. GATES
Also Admitted to Massachusell$ Bar
MARK E. HALBRUNER
Also Admitted 10 New Jersey Bar
CRAIG A. HATCH
CORY J. SNOOK
ALBERT N. PETERLlN
Also Admitted to Maryland Bar
1013 MUMMA ROAD' SUITE 100' LEMOYNE, PENNSYLVANIA 17043
(717) 731-9600' FAX: (717) 731-9627
BRANCH OFFICE:
3 WEST MONUMENT SQUARE, SUITE 304
LEWISTQWN, PA 17044
(717)248-6909
February 12,2003
WEB SITE:
www.GatesLawFirm.com
STACEY L NACE
Paralegal/Office Manager
TRACI L SEPKOVIC
Paralegal
VALERIE lONG
Paralegal
CORRESPONDENCE ADDRESS:
Lemoyne Office
VIA U.S. FIRST CLASS MAll.
Edward L. Schorpp, Esquire
MARTSON, DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS & OTTO
10 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
RE: Jacob R. Shank v. Patricia J. Sterling
No.: 01-06530
Dear Mr. Schorpp:
Please find enclosed herewith Plaintiff's List of Exhibits regarding the arbitration of the
above-referenced matter scheduled for March 6,2003 at 9:00 a.m.
~M~
Albert N. Peterlin
ANP
Enclosures
cc; James G. Morgan, Jr., Esquire (w/enclosures)
Jacob R. Shank (w/o enclosures)
.~~- ......
, ~."'~
.
"
.H
'-:. ... nl.-~~Ri-';>}';i~""
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JACOB R. SHANK aIkIa PETE
SHANK, an individual,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
Plaintiff,
vs.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant
PLAINTIFF'S LIST OF EXHIBITS
Plaintiff, Jacob R Shank alk/a Pete Shank, by and through his attorneys, Gates,
Halbruner & Hatch, P.c., presents the following list of exhibits:
I. Sears receipt regaring garage door repair items dated May 11, 200 I.
2. Check, number 148, from Jacob R. Shank to Patricia 1. Sterling, dated July 20,
2001.
3. Receipt, Home Depot dated May 20,2001 in the amount of$58.l6.
4. Receipt - Home Depot dated May 6, 2001 in the amount of $36.44.
5. Receipt - Pennsy Supply dated June 3,2000.
6. Receipt - Pennsy Supply dated June 30,2000 in the amount of$143.63.
7. Check, number 7947, from JacOT R Shank Concrete Contractor to Handwerk
Materials, dated June 13,2001 and a Receipt - Handwerk Materials dated June 13,
2001 in the amount of$148.08.
8. Sears Card transaction receipt regarding transaction dated June 28 in the amount
1
liiIlI!lIoI1 .~
" ~
~
, "
~ :.- 10.;...",
, , ,,",~
,;,'';'. "l~-,~..."';i<;.
of $73,09 and Check, number 7758, from Jacob R. Shank Concrete Contractor to
Sears in the amount of$73.09.
9. Invoice from Brenner Cadillac Oldsmobile, Inc. dated August 21, 2000 in the
amount of $880.87 and a Check, number 7769, from Plaintiff to Breoner Cadillac
in the amount of$880.87.
10. Invoice, dated October 18,2000 from Overhead Door Company of Harrisburg in
the amount of$I,328.00 and two Checks, numbers 7789 and 7813, each one in
the amount of $664.00.
GATES, HALBRUNER & HATCH, P.c.
qi~uf~
Attorney ID: 84180
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100
Lemoyne, PA 17043
(717)731-9600
(Attorneys for Plaintiff)
DATE: February 12, 2003
2
~.
"..~~J~I.:-i. 1f"':'~ ....:--'...........,.
f.'-~~), ...,.~ 'f1!-':l-~_....."4~'" v .'~;o~
.~. '" -ia.""..r -"":.c-~A-;' ~....:+'~: ,..:~.;;~~~::-:--~---~'~
_:t, ~~~~ys,,~'t.~~~I'_~'" -~...--;:-"'.;
~ .' ~ .~.%f, ~~,;::,~'_CC-.:".~"",~:-~ "." ...:7""........-~
,,~ ~"""'''''-~.f...._.,,,,,,,~..,...,-..,.-,,-,,,=.,...,-. .-",.~,".. --. .- .
. ..' ,. """".e>tf;#}iW"''''''i!'''''~'< .""~".,, -';'.~
"if ~'''fi': "~,,,",Cff''''''''''-''''' "'"'.4':""-,,,,''''' ,/"~-
I", . ..",,-,r ""_ ,-,~" "'~,-~''''' "w=.v", ..~".
. , "~''''- . ,,~,,---,~,-,~"'<'^--" <-- ,--,----~.~.~='
, . '"' ,. ,~~.~ ' -"",---",~,,,,,,,,,~,,,,,,.,.,#,,,~ #,",,'-''''
$~:"1 ,~":!;::";4",,:, '''''~ ~_",-.:!;g<.-",,",_,:f",,:!!!f<i':";.-$'?S:=-~~f0-~~
.--' . .' . """"'-,~"" ""~,,. "~,,P ^ ,,"'~' ~,,-"'"
. ~j~J;;!?:.;~~l~jr!~f,f;'I' 'I', '1' . ~~~4'o1"'~~~~~~'(i!~
..,/Iy<'-- ,,' , ~___r' =_ ,," """ ';< ..~^,~,.- ,. ,--]b:-
miii;~"'':;' ~~i"'\'f!'! :~~~%,~~};;\~~~~~~~~
.._ '" " ." :~~ ,,';fttx~,,;;g_-;J'~'%"':""'''''f''~:''''''''lidfi'f>'$''~~-'
, ... .fI. . t'''I'''' ~ .""",'Cf' t!r;;;'i~~~iJ~;$Pii:Jt.'
m-,. _., .,~ ,,,,,.,~""~ .....' .~. -"'" ,..",..."..,"
.,~"" "., ,-,,~. ,-'"'=-~'''''~-~.>..,^'''''
'<""'" . . -~-"'- .= .."- --[ ,~' ""..~,~'---""
~ibp~' 'J~~)' ~ . 'Y'"i;;:;.~~-:' ' ~~~~u.:,- -_~&..f;.;;..:~/?':'::..U;.~~:?.~"g.;.::;$.~",::
, " ,'~ .,..- -~..,,, - --- ,-' ~.,,-
~ '" ,.~~'%i ""-~~*'-~'''''''~''
~". _~ . "",_,,~,_y~~' ,""""" ',A""W'-
'. .' 'I t=*' . ><"<O._'ff"i;O",-",,,~~<t"'" ,,,", ""...~'
1" ,'" '_~'~~';'$~~_..~"':.;;;t.~;~':fJit!i~''''~~':;'_!:'''''''''":":...~~''''''t.-~._>"...,._.~,"" .#""" ~,,=.~.
. . . . nt~ .~""",, ,>"",,,.._..,,~.,,,,. . >.=-<"- ~,~"" "-,,,4''''-'
, . ' .' . ----.".[--~--- .,." ", --" ..'" """.<^'
;.;._~~~~ ~_~<~ ":~~="<_";:;J:.";J.~,,,",..,,..:.->;:;tP.'ft';'~-;:;'''ti''''-Pi.. _'q_I'df'!!.":::}'>"i.';:':o','!.i].~~ '
. ,,"~!ii''''-~ ,p,,,,,,-""^" --~"'. "."= ~ ,..,--" ~,_."~ ,',
. . _~_i,_~"'iSai-""~'?"=--,p;...,","""4F*"
, . ' .,,__,,"'if"",.~",-;"'" ^,~,,~,"'f" "'~= __.....c"-~ ,"".
<. _..,,1,. d ~"""","" %:!t%~""i$,#"'ii---~~"-ti!'
... ... . .. .=~ ..,.. , ".".. - ,,,'" ...-'--" "",;;,"". ' -~"".,..... ~.
_,' ~.;~;;,., _,,'" ""..;;--~O?""""".,?",,,,~~.'i'>l' .,if"'''''-- .::
i' Met " ~'f,.--n>"' ~_ ..~.""""...",-""~",,, fif"'"CK: -;;;,"," .v'.
_ .". ' . ..' U'" ",_____' ~p",--r~"""~' ""-""""""" A"-
__~~' ~lo; $" ' ;;~. .' c'G'~:.'f:';~"*..-,,,,-,<^~.,.-;'~-' ,,,,=.~~.:;:,~':O..~~.~4:L;-"":1"'::""'~"~~:=~-':-~;;'
_ ~. :I _ v.'''-< .t_49.M ~...~ ....~~-.r;:.:..",.;:- ;;,.~~,;........,.;...~....,y.r:'?= ~::;""..;. ."':2".1". """ .s." ~!,~",.,,-
(ltll .' i~l-.'''. .,~<~. ,-,.,' .-'- ...,.,,-,..,.~...-
',,> -,.., ' ,,~' '.."'~' y." ~_'ii",~~i- ;;.!f!'P.1;g,~""e,""'" ,.
~i .f~' ." ',," __ ""'--~.,..-,.,,_._-' -w' .,....,....-_..""'.--
.,,,",,;", '" .,\,,~~ "':fF~~'fj~:'J;i;$-iiiii&"'~~;'l:,.~'
__.. '" ... ." ",,1- ......= -~-- .-~.._~"<" --,' -.-",.. .....'_.. .,."...,,"
~fi ,_~TTaX!~." \;;"';I,.~;,r1~ ,,;:: ~~;&;;~~~~~;'~*"~.t;"":...'i;:7j$
"';.-, - ~.'" .", '" . .,,-" . ,. , '" ",' " ..." " -, ',"" .,.",,~' _.~. "
f'$,"'" ,,, j- , ","","" ," ,""" ",,,,,,~,,,,,,,,,,,,,~,,,,,"f-'~""~~""'~' ':~~'''~O' ,,,,.*,,,,,,,,",",.,..;;z~r
~~;-. ",~.l . tr ' . ,,'" ,,' , .. "".,~~ ~ ~",', "<,,,.,,'" --,z, .,~..>? -- -,' ."~" .
.-;,,~~"l ~.,_1l1ld b"l ,,:-;;._~'~"''':r,'' "" . ;." '!J"'tZ'j"15':~:d~~,;".:;.,::-:.",~"";;~;y.J<::,-,,;.:-...x,,.-:.-;~"ii""":' .:c.,,;' '~,:,,":;.f1:!':-"S::;,ti':.,--:, ~:fi!,i,;:i';
-,.,,,,,~ '.' .' . .~ ,,.--"~ ,,' .'"" ,.. ~ - -"" --,"- -- .. "" . ""
","'" M' ""d ..", "", ". ~ w""'"",.",,"',"....,,: ~",= ,'" ",-c "...."""r"..';' i'''',.''' <,: ;:;;::::.;.:, 'f"$ol'} -;~
~ ..._" ~Tal"l"" .. . " . .",,-7' ,,,~ ..-, " .'.~ "" ,," ' ,-'." ,.,.", . " --'"
_,,,~ .' .' .~, "."""".", ,oo' ~,.",,,,,, ",,~,-.'''' ",,,,~,,,,,,. ",:' ",-", """'" ",,,,,,,,,,,""ZC,,,.,,,'j;'
~.,;i" j"" "/",,<; .' .",.,"" t 4" .~ ",,,,,,'~-"" " .~.""', ,,, . ", .~.,," ,,,'> " "'-''"'" "'~ "
,,"'0, .,j:,.,"";'" ~ >r"'''' , ". . ~"0<,,,f,,,,,,,,,,,"':'C,'"A<iY;''''' """".;.,' .'f,' Y,"i-""-,,.<;;C;;,,'''''''C
~;'1V''' ,,; :~..,~;;- .~. ,:".,o;;:;"";,.,,,,;,,,!.,,,,':!i,~,,,;;';;j,' ~",,,,;;;;i .;:-",,;;fA$;;;' ",,'ii'-';;'
~"'i.'f!;t~'<!.M$re:; t,~,,)~:"11~~-'i!Jt j .j~,.oo.l' . m",~NJ'-,~:?,'''':iiM'3; ,,,,;,,,;,-;;--r-,,,'f1.,c ;,tPf$)'fi'" ',''Jf."".
."""".~ ',,' ""'" ...,. , ' . "^""~.. "...r",~"'''..,.--'' /" . C',.' --"..~,.' <r ., d' ,- "
,.,..,~, ,.. ",,'" _ ,." , . 'J... ,,;o-C....-,p,""-~'"~'"''' ",. &,,"", '" .",,"'-d'''' ",; "<fit,,
,._ 'Y'-""""'':': '~ "'~ ." . " 4~%'"""'~,.,"~,."""'<" ,.,,,CC>" -,c'", ",,,,,~;,,,,,.:, "",,,,,,
~ ~"'--"'1. .... ~~~,,'s&'ii\'M no . ":1-.:;.J'J1""" ,-.,=-."."..,,~,-- ,-.<,_.,,'".' "..----.^"..~.".
z?::,~~ _~'<~I01"1~.~te.j t.,\,-11~~";";~&i'''-'''' ,,2> """","", _,,,i!1,~.$.,,,,--,:~","":"'; .,";"".."~--,,,:- ,,"".'
~ """".: ~__ ~ 1'" ,''','' __ ,,'" ".' ,.". ,. ",..,~ '^,- " ,.--' , ,,<., .. ",.., .,. -=. .-,"- W.'
.;;;~.~~ . _. 8' ,0;.-,..,.,.-;""" ," _ ,___ ,_.~,_,~"..,..,~",~.-.,..,. .,..,~" .. ,-- ..V~I':"''';'-'''':'~~ ,~'- ,~:::"'.f'-"~..':...
~.. .'"" ..,,~, .' . .. ". .. ...' "n ,,' , . - "..,,,.. ' ". ".," - -",' ,,',,~
~ ...~~~"";... -,"-l.l!:::\..KS" se,.,v1 ~". ,j. ~...~l.te't,;"'1.tt.~ ~; ,-,,,,,,,.,,,,"'''f<_.,r.'''''''' ."" ,.~"",.,. . ,,' ,,, .' .."~,,,...,,,.~ .
",,,... -!'~'""; i,',)'''''' "" .",~ ," "",,,,",,,,,, ~".,>tO' '.". ~"". , ,;.c c..' .,i '>-' "'.' , ,,-,""',,""<' ",.",,'{lOr .
~$.ii >it,. '. , """,.,,,,,.,,,.1 ,. , ?,:,""""" ",,,,,;;::,,,,,~.:, <, 'i''''' -'~' -:-.-i ':,;.~,,~"" ;;C",,,.,,,,,,
~ t~~ ~,;,"";":1:'1!;)::i':11)~.$'",~~~;l:~~,,;;;'ii:{')"--;;'): ""~~-:,~,,~:,gC,,t>&
___ , '.-" ., . " " ",' :' ,. """""",,,..' ",,", "''''''.,.' ~ ~ ~ " ~ ""." ", ~_,.u""C" B~'
m:<:~" '~1",!:" ,_~ '.' " .' . ~' . ~'~w".,." ~"~,,,' ,""" ~"". ,,_..., -- .. ~' ,'" < y""" ,.-. '.
,..c. <<" ,.,r, " '''; ,;," :~~; . 'i,,,",,"",.,"'5<,,,"!;c,~,,,~iW'" ~:, ,~.$' ,',y-,', ,.~~.",,'~, ',,%-?''''
:"'~~:;J!t $i ~\ f\~ JOOrl;. 'it'll for ,,"_MY!" ',' ","''''0''''''''''' ,,' .""""'c",,'''''.'' ..' -p.,,,,,' <~.-",~!il'
'0 ..' .... IE'" C, _ ~ . ,'.,,' , "",,' ",-..,' ,~,.r".r'-.jd'.' c> .'" ,.""", --...,,'.' ,..'~' "".,
'.;;;;" "" .',' .~... _ ". ," '.,....,,_,.p~' ","" "...~._ ' ".,' _", ",~..",.., ~.".""",'Yk
~1:~?I;;,,~~,~,~' 'C:' '.&.~flf/i9f*;j;".i~:f;J;j,+'j;:/JiU;t.'!jgi",;i;']l$-,~
.~.~:1f ~ 1 ,~~qp:AS IB!12IT~ ail"'" ;;.' ,',,' ""....,, ,,,/~.,,.., ,'0' ,",C' ";.-..,, -;-.,,,,..,.. ,.,.-y",.....'.,,",. ,,,,,
'^',,,' .,," '" .... " ..n. ' ~~,"~ '." _ ., .. "",,~.. '." ,',' , " ,,".',' A" · '''''''' ",.. ,'~
__~ ,."",,,,,",,,...,,- ,"='" ,,,', ,'';' "if"" ,,,-" ,'."'" ".,~.. ",',." '.-- .;.."'-C"'" ",.. ,', '~ "W
.:G<>:fr' '", .... . ..' " .~,. C~'\"'" ;:-"" ~ :,.,,,..,,@. ",' ",;:. /I,L ,~",,"'''' ","F'"~""
~:.g;,~''''~~ t '_~p " "",':" ....._ .'" ' f..' .",-",,/,,'4 ",,'. .,Y<' ,0'" " ,.- ' '," ...,' '" >*'" '''" ",' ,~.
",--..0"" ., .. ,., ,,"~' __' ' ..;'~'" "'--"<T.',';;i".....~:c...<:" ",''-'' " """ '" '" .,.,4", ,," · ",/ ,,"
;"C:.::"~~ }~1..00r..~rl!}'L~~?11~t.lnl TI. ?MIl ,~c.o.,x,.. _-"",'C--'"","" ">..,.,,....> ' . c' , ...~",,' H'" .'. ".w"
...,.....~ :1.....a~.QlJV""~~.1 "(<1-' ." ." _'"x' ,."..,,~.'. _' ....,,,. ,,,.y ,.,.. .,,,~.-',,,,, 'r'<'
"_",, .___ """,.~ ' . It ,'''" ..,,,....~,,'. ,," -' ".". F. -- . e__.... "<.. · -.",.
.c_"".
~
,'.: _ ,,~t $
:.: <E4'T~~d~~~~it ~
!9.((j
,..-,
...' -;;T--->'-
"_~".'
-
-~...,
~',~~
.:'':'
,~;
.'"J :.t:I
~!=-l..V
-,:'-
--~----'---'-""---"" ~~.
... .
,~ '
. ,
. I
k
~,~: ~_~: ,."-:'J"':'-' '".:;A~~."S\;-,
,..'..,,;<,,,-. ,-
.,:,'-=:..
,
" ~', ;
"'. '
" :."
"-'
.u.'~~t'e~!~t,,),!'J~;;~
PAYTOTHE - Ll ..,L..' - /~ & $ ...v~ 'o~
ORDER OF ~-~./~- -. - . t:7' I ~"'-'i'j)O
~~~_~~_::~d______~tJDO=~RS[l].::.-::l
@ OMEGA -==..:::==="c-=:-c-,--';'....c_---:c:m--.:---c-cc--c..-.-:~:c. .:cc . ~
i:~~~ig~.~~~ig~; :
. ._~
_uu ,_________.___
"'-1.oG;....
'-'--'-. -_ ~ '--,_ .._.______~~.~______.___._. -c-_,__.___.._"
. . .
...__.-.---~-------
....-n
-
"
. ;(...- "<
. ,
: ~
1
i
j
!
I
.,
i
!
....:....
,.",
04 104 03
011025250
, .,.;~:
-.
,.
J.I
., ~~', "".
. .~ \<I
,c:
01~
01~";i23
~
I
6
~ .
.I''';
'._:'J'
,~., ., " ., >:~r,'..,'
, ~ ,~,~,) ,- ",..
,.,.,;/
~l",
.~~ <:'~ -,J.
,',: \'
-..'-,'.
~
....
..co
II&T BflNR120aMl
M~mI;lO\l'C
s00-5&3-,i498 .
,
31 (~~j ~2~)~jb;:}
/
.",;:':_~':~""L<-,' '~~~ffij;;~~
" 1 '
, '.,
',-!
;~ ~; ot
,"
~ I
-<. .
~I
;
-,2;! -~
~~ - .
'0" .)'
,
. -
, ~,;
.,
+:-:.
-,1'
. ,. ,',. \
,. \.
.~:.
,-.,
.u,""
': -.. ...,' ~;A
..;,.
~.~~,c """-.='":',---' '~':'_'~i~
...' 1.
"',.
;;.
~! .'
. "
THE HOME OEPOT 4~20
'~CARLJSLE PIKE, MECH. PA 17055
'. JERR'I ANOERSON MANAGER (717)795-9602
?.I:~:: -
4120 00025 69267 OS/20/01
41 b91 03:21 PM
. ~,~- '~""-'I
;:':'c.~i~_
'~_,o. .', \! ,', :];~'~-N '0'
',... \.;"'." ll..~~~"_,,, ,
~"':,jI;'f'~1I'" 1 ~ .' ~
~, ~dt...-,*: ,
'", ,'"ll?240JQUZiJ.7 "~GING,..., '
..:o:.0224::rrOO1t 17 ~DGllJ.G"'"
"':"::'aS3EJ::l~1"~ PL~'lu.:;~Ak
. ."O~%l0l1d6~"'STAK .
. ,,' .... . . SlIBTOrAL
54.86 TAX p^ 6.000
TOTAL
XXXXX~XXXXXX3513 DISCOVER
AuTH C~DE 020358/7251311
,., . .--'
. ~'~~,.. ~')1.9~,
::"._ .'.!---:24-"-99
,......' 2' 47
.' 2~47
54.86
3.30
$5a.16
58.16
TA .
III/ I11I11 IIIIIIIIIIIIIII'III'/"IIIIII/:/,IIIill;;II'''/,I/III
4120 25 69267 OS/20/01 4654
GREAT CAREERS BUILT HEREr
APPLY IN PERSON OR CALL 1-877-WORK-4HD
SHOP ONLINE! AT WWW.HOMEDEPOT.COM
.' 1i~.\1i~._
,'(
',.".
. ': ~: -;
,
[
i
J
I
f
!
,
,
1
'i
.~
f
f
f
I.
. f~..
1':,
$
;.!'
Ii
~
!
~44g--;7~- .///
. ' .' ~ ' . ~
, I..
j
L----...-. "
. ,
'.',
. . .
'-", '
-',
,.-, '
...."
) , ~~L
,~, .' ,,'-. .,1, '"
."" .,.,: " ,'."
" , ,;.. "". , . ~Y>
. ~ . - ' ,
f '" ~~.
',;'
:.. -',,';,..
THE HOME DEPOT 4~20
6000 CARLISLE PIKE, MECH. PA 17055
JERRV ANDERSON [,tANAGER (717)795-9602
4120 00u08 38094 05/06fOl
SALE 11 300 12:02 PM
r::::--:-- -.-
I:'~'~)
I~~~
~i'"
, ~ @
734565953449 BORDER
734565953449 BORDER
734565953449 BORDER
075381047357 16IN6fTSHE
SUBTOTAL
34.37 TAX PA 6.000
TOTAL
XXXXXXXXXXXX3513 DISCOVER
AUTH CODE 006784/1082481
8.96
8,96
8.96
7.49
34.37
2.07
$36. 44
36.44
TA
1IIIIIIIIIIIUIIJlllIJflfIIIIIIIlJ'lllill!lill,lllfl'III./11I
4120 OB 38094 05/06/01 8251
GREAT CAREERS BUILT HERE!
APPLV IN PERSON OR CALL 1-877-WORK-4HO
VISIT OUR WEBSITE AT WWW.HOMEOEPOT.COM
.~~~
", ..- .',
',:," ,
, ',,"
(,1',
.';,' :':,' :'.;'
."",'
i
~-
--
'. ,.
"," .
;. ~," "
.......-
7-i~r-~".....~~I~'~"-.""':,.',':-':'" ':~:~:-~<~~i",f~id~~.:j;~:~1;.2:'E~!~~~7~''':'''~;:~~~:'h...
,,,I "c ""~""-"""""-""-'''''''' --..... .CONCRETEPLANTSi
'~;J""'I."'N" 'N'S' 'V.';>:~ . :~~~;'::~f~It;~;('~r~;~;i:i4(i:.HARRISBU~~. . . i ,
'''''''' ~, ' . ,.... IIAUIIOFFICE:."........,..;.....,.......,...,i.,,"'."'.41,..CARLlSLE ........, .,'
'..'k ..... " "". ...".... "...,.~, '~"A'.PRESCOTT. .' ',,'i "1
Q 'lIl ....~~;t;~~~;7::.1~1~;\~ : SILVER SPRi~~;<:;~';ll
CI' "..,cii:a~a..:Y~~ ~,-,-, ..m'"'", " HUMMaSTOWN .,
1;}~;1 ,,' . .' '<i~ )t:;i":..';;;,~;sj,f-'~;;~?':.;;;:rF"i~.); }~i}i~' . ,IE~~~0'~;!!f5f'1~;~:l~,;ffi~:r,~t;:Cj;;\;!.:t~:::z""Ji:'!"~:11. '
,~::{i PRICES BASED ON DELIVERY PC>>NT BEING AC~E~i~j~;!}~r~~" .. . ,;c t!':~~tt~)~~~~~i'!;"~:~;;;:9':' .'3 ,;iT {
(lOUR TRUCKS ARE NOT PERMrrrED TO GO BEYOND cURB '~N~. &~~T~':O~N~~S'~.~.::!r(..~:AlL.OWABLE TIME ;,.'.<1"
,!:>r . . ~M~0~~~~'~A~~~~~~I~~TE'W~DbE~E~8~l~~E~1 ~."J16~~~~'fXT~~ ,~h;~i.' 'if;,\~.'i;".{",,;.,;;.. .:....."'11,..
,,<II ;,PURC:A:ER'.S OWNRISK'Si~~5~~;;tX ~~IGNS~;~,~i~;~~~~~fi~~~~~.~iJ~,~{l.!~5:,~~fl5l~rri~~;j Il
....,..' i.'j WARNING: IRRITATING TO THE SKiN AND EYES.Contilins'!<'l' . .. .... . '.' ." ....; ;::',;;;':,;":"';,,,,:,,,'! '
POrllandCeme~I.AVoid contact wiIIl'eYes and prolonged j QU~n!'s:nNG ."\'~'!"':r~~~,:t",,>.:;.~...e
r: l contact with skIn. Wear rubber boots and gloves. In.case. .SLUMP ~."'.''''''.''''''A'R ,"....1>...'..,">..".'.'."CYL..'.ND. E.RSTA~EN
:',; of .contact WlIh skin or eyes,nush Ihoroughly wllh water.. ., '.",.h."",', .... . .
.:' ,./ If ",itallon pItS, get ",ed, I aIlenlion. Keep .children SlU~P <'tff~;;;';/,.; , "AIR ;,'c,";f.i:''''CYLlNDERS TAKEN
I; I away. . . . ..'
'~(.I X By):?7~~+~:~~~gi~:?;n€~t~~~';1:ii,i'i~;'}i ,.'
ft,~C.~U"'.'1/,.. '..' I. i',. ". _.,.....,......~.,...l';.....m',,~...,;,.,...,....,..........,'.~.. ..,.el'....0.,'..,;~'.'...~...,M.".......~..,..:::._.,,........;". '. .<;' >C """Ai' "
Will . ~.... . . ".,:;'t'J",:Jt"'~.'~:;";'::~::]S~::~.':;..
,;; ..~-{~:" ':.:-- -, ...... "",,~-.:~~; '. ,.:t., t,:;:-i!-_;~:,'I'!';~"f"!- -~-'!'_'~-;:~"~;;*~~~~W.-..-i<i:+;'r:~"i'"_"'. ;;.t:....,-4--~ ',;
.Eli .
J51
I
. :';;, I DeliVERY ADDRESS
(1504 WALTON CIR
".;1
:(
i
,.' ......i .
'~. ';:'~',:'~~'" " 1.
'.,
I .'
tIt
,.
i~- '~":"':"~~~f~',ll$"~~
C352 (
e
MIX
R. SHAN,K
,. ,~'''' '
"\..EMOYNE .
'. "
ZONE
;DT
i
C
'-" ,]
;:)
TIME DUE
09100
!
WAL TONST T /R \TO WALTON CI R
2.00
2.0
2.00
2.00
2.00 C3521
0.00 SAT/FREE
~... .'> ' ,-' ,'"
3500 AIR ENT.' CON
SATURDAY/FREE NO
RYARD
YARD
!c
RV,
.'
:0
,
I
.'
,
(
","'1
nfi.
('
!:J '.!
~~I::~Ll'~~ ,nIWl!JjI'L-*,,,'l"'<'~'::'J;(~I~T::io::rtn.:n..~ ';r.,".'-, ;r",~<p -- ~ ~ >', (j ~'~J -", "';;<tJJ"'" -!2-~[~;r:,'!i_.;1 < - -;,W:I!!tg-:" ~~-:.: -;W..";;r'i~1!<;"~ :~l:,
IDa!l~4ilk~TIr.!li~~-<!~,_~&,"1,\ik ,_~t~ "t'hll'" ' '-'., ;: ""~-<-~ ,~ -.l 1~.'.1',_!~o" . ^irroJ.::tt''i=-",~,h;'';'-\'I\'<.~~''''''''"--''
.,
j- i
-,~~'i;.
!C
,'It
",..
NO SATURDAY/FREE N
SUB TOTAL
TAX
. .' SUB TOTAL
i
,
:c
I
,&;.[
I
,
~
,
. .lOB TOTAL
CUSTOMER'S COpy
(~'
1',-
;.w
_........---~ - ---- --------,-.-.-
.-----
; C'
.--L-.
C IN GOOD COND N
(EFT} INCWDJNG A ~ FEE: FOR EACH CHECK RETURNED ~A MN REASON,
\
"
ENNSV
SUPPL"..,~c
I,.'
'i~~" '
QUALITY BUILDING MATERIALS
MONTHLY STATEMENTS WilL NOT BE ITE.','
ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS M'~ 5-
ACCOMPANIED BY THIS INVOICE.
ALL GOODS RETURNED WILL BE SUBJEC- _
10% HANDLING CHARGE.
1001 Paxton Street ' p,O, 80x 33.~
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17105
Phone (71712334511
SOLD
TO
JACOB R. SHANK PAGE
BOX 7, WEST MAIN ST.
MCALI:'Hf~RVILLE, PA 17049
1
~ED. 10 # 23-2729496
JOB : 504
P.O.: 504
FOR
06/03/00
C3521
T/FHEE
WAIT
2.00CY
2.00EA
1.00EA
3500 ~u7 AlE CONCRETE
SA TURDJ\Y
WAITING TIME CHARGE
~ ,.-;, - "
.c;;
>~::;''':';:;'
,~'.~,
46053369
c! 46053369;
46053369;
61.25
0.00
13.00
122..5-:
O.oe
13.0C
NO FINANCE CHARGES MADE. DEUNQUENT CHARGE OF
IF PAll> I-,V
18 % PER ANNUM ON PAST DUE ACCOUNTS.
07/10100
$2.00 DISCOUNT.
135.50
VOU MAY DEDUCT
8.1:.::
143.6:::::
~ENNSY SUPP' 'f INC.
E HARRlSBLRG, PA
t
DISCOUNT
$2.00
TO INSURE
PROPER CREDIT
TO YOUR
ACCOUNT
PLEASE RETURN
THIS PORTION
WITH YOUR
REMITTANCE
135.50
8.13
143.63
I
,.
I
I
I
I
I
I
f
!
,
"!.....'.,...-
, ,~.
,)
'",let
. :. :,,\,.";"';:; \ .:_~,
'"
'.,> '.);'
"
,:.,..
.. ,'t,:".''-,';(.<){,
.,,;
.-n
'~,':I L
~ --:-:r . ,-"
. n'
'. ~:' ~ ~ ~
~,
.~ .L
,.j I
.".;;,),\,.;
.. i :', ',:)
. :,)i; fl.:,!:)
"',\ ):'.
~ :,~
""\
.....
';:l,
" i;.: :. ' t~ ~ . .:~ ',:f ,:; ,", '..
r;,. :/1', '\:"1 ~';
/\ I 1 .~ -!. !. J "
:. 1 ~ ' :
"
"
./:'!--! l.:~ ,,1......,'1
,
~~\..~ ',.'
',~ ~:'" {: ~;~or: , ::
-:'
Yh~~ji! ,....,: i\ ;, '.'
.~j/i (;' i :;.1'). ~'I .!;:; /1 ~;, d.l,
.;
.1:i,:
"'.
',',
_I'llh'
~~ ~.
"~
...
'-,I _.' ':, .~....-.tIii~..",,:~. "...lI~_Iil~~. ~~~,.;~l!bi!$&-:tb~""-
: ~~ ~~' ~. ,J.~.~': ~:/~~~~2i ~~_~i~:~: ~i:~,!~: ~~ ~~.:.,:~::\~:~,~, L~'~.:;~::~:<;:\: E~~l.~ ;:~Sj~:~~j:L.:L~'
.-.- . ---.-- -. .....'~ ,
,
o
.
'9-:- :...,~ ,,,<,,::-:::.=:~,:,::-,:::,::,:: .-'.. ",,-.. .:" '_:>,,=.7'947
JA(;OB R. SHANK ..: ,::-";: :-:.::::~.:.~;:: .. ",,<': :.-":'" ,_~ -:,:.," _: >'>,. " "
CONCRETE CONTRACTOR:-":~~':'-v:>'::<.<>:> >--......::.-..:-<<,
--- ~ ---... --- -~ --- - ~"',-- ...--- .,.~-...~-
H.C. 63, BOX 7 PH. 717-463-2155 -~-:::-.....~:....~.:~~-"-.,....:~ "'~":-.~""~::'~---:":~~_:::~:~."-"_
MCALISTERVILLE, PA 17049.. ::..:;..<>.;::..<-=---...::"<>.:.: ,.::. ": ;' ,...... :::..,'60-15271313
. .... ' -'-' -." '. .., ""'.:1-.::> .,.,,,.,,
" . '., " 03 ,053.011QLl.t.g~E . . .' "". "
~~fHE' ':~.:: "'1/- , ~"/. - --"' ,.'-~-~- -_:'~ -- --~'-~'- ~- ~-~::-""':;.::-""-::-""-.- ....;:--.,,:-... , -....-::~~~~-~~';-'~"':;:;;:c.....::.>;;:,L~;: '. =-.
, ORDEROF~(' . .t-;/ ~"b,~ ~~~>:"-::"~~::::,,"'~~:::'-</I$/i'~:!o;
, .", ~ "'.,' '. _~. n ..-_ _ _ ~ _-' ." .. _" '''g ..."
~, ~~:h~/, ...... .' ". ~~~:~.,~..,.:'Q~~~~~S:~::::::-
:....",,:,@OMEGA... ~-4l~~.SlJj;l!3l 55"~3..,,,,,..... ....
_ ,"'::':-:'-~'.'~'-~~';;"::",~~~;i:-~::'~-,:;.:'::;::~_-..."':~-j',,,,,,,,-'" _:-: <~,,:-,;.,.;--~- " .
BANK' .. .".. ~':;-"'~_.........---.;;'---:---.....'--", ..',..---",~
!"-''=-~--: -.. ''''~'~:~1;~''~~=~~-'' .-..- ,..
FOR, .'_.' : __' ,.n_:'....'" __.:' ,. ..'_~_~:--'::"::' '_.;.~~~__:..'-":''''''''''-~.__~-''''':'" _ ,~",_ _, _" '_':....,. M"
11"001'''1. 1'11" ~'I:O ~. ~.b 21'.1: ";::-00 ~.r;'1,1.'j!1I1'>::---:-/:'<>,II'OOOOO .1.808,"
.-- . -~--_. -_-'__:-""'_--"-.:""'-'~..r-~-~'''~'' --,-"-
L
.'
.-, ..
"'-' ,",--
- ,_.
. , '... :',. , :",~ . ~~~:<;~~;""'"7'.,..__.-:.., ~~,7''':-:''",-,,:--:,,-,,-,-,,--- " ,--.. - - ~
,- ~.,. "--;c-''7' ~~ ::';~(;i~~"::':~'~-~~':,,;,: "i' . '
OPEN: M-F 7: 00-4, 30Pt.1/SAT -CALL
YOU CALL - WE HAUL
HANDWERK MATERIALS
P.O. BOX B
FIDDLERS ELBOW & N. UNION STREET
HUMIV!ELSTOWN, PA 17036
PHONE (717) 5.66'3002 FAX (!17) 566-2304
566-3IZiiZl2.
CRUSHED STONE
,ASPHALT
No.0170 4 7
STEIRING
1711-;';-:-'
PURCHASE
ORDER NO,
CUSTOMER
000iZ1i,H TAXABLE
"""
-
RB RED lB'S
-,
':>
,;.'-r't''':A$~ '''\i c.
..;rRUCKOO; ','
~ ~- _~'",&"..k~~,N
;'~~.~~~G,~i;
':'~
71
. TIME
'-".'';>:'" '"
GROSS
.. UNITSfTONS
~
, .QUANTITY
RDERED
QUANTITY
ELIVERED
QUANTITY
CEIVEn
. QUANTITY .
. REMAINING
The signature below certifies that this materiaJ meets the
applicable contract, specifications and requirements.
1.='-'
TARE
NET
. DEWRECV.
'TODAY
.. 'LOAD NO,
A ..
148,
,-,
SIGNATURE
MIKE 18326
WEIGHMASTER
NOTteE: SEE REVERSE SIDe FOR
x
DRIVER
OFPUR HASEAGREEMENT.
~"~~~
- "-~~ ~~~~.:~:~~~~:",,~;;-1:-~~~~, ..-'~{:~~~;;~;~::~"~!~J.I.;:~:;:~~"":'''',,:,~_~~,,,:''::~;~~:~~s":~~:;;~::~~"C":""
1'11#-;;- - - -"'>---.-.-':""-":-;::':'>--"~.~>--~."'-'~"""-.-c:--;...--"'-"-. - ;
a' .~-JACC '" 'S"H:'A"'N- K-.....~.-.~ '~::::.:::::.s:-------....,.;::;.::-:,~:~.:.:-=::-2:.;J 9~9 ~:: \.
_ ". '.. _ _---.. _........ __ .__ ~ -...._ _~ -""''''T~ _.....-.""_ _.....: _ _"'_", ..
.' .CON(,nE:TE CONTRACTOR-<--:--~ .;::<...;::.:<>::.--::-..::<,;'~<>-: r
. ':;" _ :::-.---~_/.---.....----~~~,,;...:._----:.,/--...--.---------..:...----,-:::- - ~
'"" H.C. 63, BOX 7 PH, 717-463.2155 --==---....---- ___-....-- ~~..;.._..:...--....--.........--: ..-.:);-....--::-...--:~""'~:-"":~"""'"_-".....-~'--
" . '!. .:MG.ALlSTERVllLE,_.PA_17049v";"."'~~'-~.- _ - <;...: .:'....::..~.'-':_""60-l!27(!13.::/
'7 ,'...: ......... ..... .... -<,- ":-::-__'~:.63 ~'053::::Ql: J'.6lti'9:~- -.- -. s~' ..::.~~:. i.
~~~HE' ~:::.; / ." ." / '.-':)~-~ -<.-.:~-~'::~~ ~':":;::-?-$C :;;':~-::;:i8:~S ~l
OR~ER_O~?~:r-_/1, ~~~~.,_,_-,_~{__~~,-'~:,,~~,,~~~:;::',~'~:;~-~~.Lzt'~~_1~-, - t
~ ~ ~ . /=.... . .~-' .w<------....... '-"Q%' ::.~~.. -';':"': ;
,__, ' ~ . -- _.,_, _,::-' . -- ~_,;::',.".;. .:_"_~. ~-f'"~O_~~~S~~,",:. - ~.
. '@OMEio:.A.....'-,.... -41iDiP,,,,,,,,,~5{lj;jt~c_=1!.3'~...- .-.-,.. -/-.'
^~-~- ,\.iII"\ -. ..': ',,"::-'::--"';:"-~~'~~~~~;'~'~:;"""::~:::"'-";-<;--"':':"':~~-.:;--:~'~:~..;:..~:::;~<-:>:...
~. BANK ...,....,~"_.,~~~-~..,~_........-..~... J.
FOR ,.~_.:~- ->'~:'~f=~:~3f~~~=~-Z:2:~~_'::~~::-~~-?=:~-:~~ t:
11'00 7"11. ?II'.'I:o~ I.? 1.1; 2tlol: -..rJ~,O_J.!!:.-7;..~~~~::~""()D9oDr~.aoa.,' ." ::
OPEN:M-;=
- - ~ - - . - . - -
" . .,' .' '.. ..c "?:.~;-;:':':~' C;'~'1~j'5:iit;:;~"':?:r'~~~:~:~;~-:~:-':-: "~.>:~,. _-~i":'\:i~"
7: 00-4 ,30PM/SE=1T-CE=1LL YOU CE=1LL - wE: HE=1UL ! 5E,6-31?J02.
HANDWERK MATERIALS
P.O. BOle B
FIDDLERS ELBOW~ ~.UNION STREET ., ,".0
HUMMELSTOw~. PA 17036 . ' 0 17 0 4 7
PHONE (717) 566-3002 . 'FAX (717) 566-2304 . No.
CRUSHED STONE
,ASPHALT
C'
7rJi'
PURCHASE
ORDER NO.
JSTOMER
STEIRING
K8C
12112100131 mXE=1BLE
~ "
~ oooe
"""
RB
RED lB'S
GROSS
~1
TARE
Ner
INIT5noNS
~ '"
(.OEWRECV.
TODAY .
LOAD NO.
,-,
,}ltAE: ;
.='1::' Ii ': ~
QUANTITY
ROERED
OUANTITY
EUVERED
aUANTITY
CEIVED
, 'aUANTITY
. REMAINING
The signature beiow certifies !hatth!s material meetS \he
applicable contract, specfflcations and requirements.
.='7 L7i',
,,,
1'-'
~ ,~
148. iZ'
SIGNATURE
MIKE 1832E,
WEiGHMASTER DRIVER
NOTICE: seE REVERSE SIDE FORTER S OF PURCHASE AGREEMENT.
x
~. ::;- '~'.","~" ""..". ,-"'., ---,".'
._-~
.,'"l'
~.~-_._"
.",
0."_
r
'"
!" ',.". /
<I' = ~
~
F~B:::. EB! k!2 '* ~pc - GRqUP
2~~".:'r.:r:"'':I-'=~ ~.=;.~ "'::\- '2:');t...s4 -.'0
-;~~-:~f::'~t-~f'~' :::c.~-.'r, ~'-::~j::
_.
-?.
04 104 03
~1~94~903
+f ~~:i;,[i ~~,
053
010618'
; "_ 0
"_:0,,,-:"
:--:,.,
;;3 ~
:~' ~
,,', ~
"
.,
". :J
"
<
~
~.
-
~,
,'. : :;:~'"
, '
\,,'."..;
',\
.-: ~ .
~;. .
'-'I
, ;'r"
',',
:::~-, >:/'~i.\'.,
;,:':
,.
.":
"":-:<
.'~: ~ ':'.
'..',..,"
"~-" .
;.;'.....,
~
,
--'
""
"
1. -..".,J',,, -"_" ..
'1>031000011-4
1~~1\\1l~~
109?2f 1:~J!4
,
o
o
o
c-
JJZ
'mO
~? -;
'gj:E
<::>
8::;
m
900
~:-1
....)
o
w,
=
, =s;;
~-if'~
'co
~:JJ
-'"
"'~B
~z'
'!sg;
-,-
,~o
5:
m,;
'*ij)
.!:
,-,
~:';..-\
Co
'0
.~
. "
-',
"
:_,=""" , '~
1'D<W'.t<ig.,,,..,,,.,
'.,
.~, '~..'-;
'.,,'
,,' .,'
,'-\'
,- , .',\~ (",
",,'
'."
" "
;. ~,-
:>' '-,
',:
,~.~
',,-,,'
:;"V'., .'. '."_'
'>/, . "', ,
"
't,
I
I
~
a
o
.. "
N-~"':Z1':
0$;00..:
8 ~ i~ ~
...::tmm
Qlmo"tl
· ::O:rJ 0
I~m(j)
iO=1
iJ~~
~ "Il!(
t
I
I
,
'.,'
!iC
"'llllP'
,.
-(,I
-=
=:
=
=,
iiiiiiiOi;i:
i
~
:
-'
-'
~
~
=
;e;;;
......
=
;e;;;
==
=
-
==
-
"""""
-
......
-
.
-
-
=
-
-
-
-
"""'"
~ ~
......J~l!WOO:ikl
.
t~ ~~>> ,
c_, '~"hJ~i[s!'~'"
"l' , '
"
~ " . ~. ,,-
',.,1;'-'."
~ ~
" '"
)" ':,:,,;:,-, \~'<'~:;.,.,~.~:,'.;,,\ :.:.~ ,,}(!;.,'
\,;-':,'(, :',{ ">': "
"
,',".
,
'-;",;
" f ,
,
1 r
I
.
i
;
"
,
t
~;,
;f,
~
"
',I
"
t
r
~;
(,
f~'
.~
,
/.
.,.
r:;
\.t
~
~
:(
.:~
>
:t
~
f
~-
~.
",
~~
t;
~
"
"."
~
f
j,:
,
",
t
t
t;
~
r
I
,.
r:
I
1._,-
",,'
\ .J' ' .,
",~,'~,~ ~:.,: !~- " <, .~'.,'. ;',j"
SEARS CARD ACCOUNT NUMBER, 54 84104 233979 . . '. 1 OF
);tc VERSATILE FLIGHT TRAVELLER IS A ROLLING CARRY-ON lIT FITS 'EASIly'UNDER AIRLINESEATSJ
,THAT CONVERTS TO A BACKPACK. THE BACK AND StRAPS ARE FULLY PADDED TO IlAl(E IT COItFORTABLE
, TO CARRY. . ,..,,-,
$2,866.91
07104100
Previous
Balance
paymen18
And Credl18
$0.00
PurchaBea
And Debito
, Total Account
, Balance
. other Tol8I FINANCE
Cha eo CHARGES
. $0.00 '" $0.00
ANNUAL Average Dally
Purchase Promo. PEllCENTAGE . Dally Periodlo'
T e Amount End Date RATE Balance Rate
Regular $73.09 NlA 21.00% $0.00 0.0576%
NOTICE: See reverae olde for important information, . .
For cuotomer oervice or to report your card loot or otoJen, call 1-800.917.1700, M,S 9AM.9PM, SUN 10AM.6PM
Moil BiUlng Error Noti....to PO BOX 818017 CLEVELAND OH44181.8017 . ..'
$0.00
, $73,09
" $73.09
FINANCE CHARGE
(MJ Minimum
Periodic
, '$0,00 (P)
v~r
~ JI/
9/
fJ. !~;"fSf
~17.
,~
"
. ", '~"
~'" . . '. ""
"",;"\-'"
.:~I::'.:;;ii.;ri;\:'H;0!:<
-\:l'
'i,(.:'<,
:,,'i..,:,:,'::,;~:,t~;,~~~;~r:~\;..:i;IT,"<"'"
, ,1\ ;"
",",',
'~,l'
'.,..""
"',.,.,
',' ,,~- ~
. """','< \
.', t
:'~: '. ,"-::,~,~:<,' t ,~,,,,,-~;.''';'''':,i,\;~::<',~; f ",- .~ \., . ''-." ,
- '" '::''', ,,~~ :....';';. ,; .',',. '
......:'.,.,.;,,',.',','..'.".:...,.,'...' ":",;",::;,',:"","":,,~,',:"':",",,,"';I'"...".,...,..,., '~ " .-
-:~ ~ _ ';:", ~ c. '....~ '_.".',~.: ,<i.,;,~,~r~.:,'.:,;;..'.E,<..,:.~..,i.~".t,'~.,.;,:'.~,,~:<t:~;~'-\~,:...','.'.,..;i' ::,; :', ", " '.), : .',
~ , :-:; I ,,(." \~'-~<P~.J-:;t.'~~,.': ,;:':.}f".,
'.-"
'".'
\
'.
',.,.
"
,i'
',.'
"
."'''t-,'
,
"i
,~, .\_~..;..;, _.'_~;." ~:....~.~;..,....,,~ ;,..;,....~.\<':. .~,,/...c,...
..-,',...-...
9-::,q,
K' .
,; - ',;
-;-- I" '. ._ . ~;\ .
--~.::-:::;.,.:-~ ~:'
- ... - . - ,
"':-,,,:'~-:-~-,-:'-::---: :<:~~- .:>,
7758
@
...._"'~R<u>daI~
-~
JACOB R. SHANK- ~ ~ ' <->-,-, ~~ -,,' ..., , . '.
CONCRETE CONTRACTOR ~;:q~~:R:9\'::~~~';;?<;; ;:~... ::'..-
H.C. 63, BOX 7 PH. 717-463-2155 ._,,"~'...~,:::-:-......;:::--:.:~-::,-_.;~:><;...---::-~ _...:::-.:"~,<::--:::~- "- <~;::,..::
Me AUSTERVILLE. PA 1.7049::":":_:::".:'~~,~.::;<:_~~':::''''-'':>':h60-1627/313:'-
- -' ....':::.,..::::::.::.:-:::;~':::'<-~1T-''/?~~.~ C.'.,:, ;::."';"
02035. :0.1!-.q,;l::>4g"S,~pr..::;<~:.:-c7<';"<" >.<
, ,. -. '~_?-'::'~~~~-:~:'~'::~~,;'~~:~l~",$~~;3'~ ~~<.~~':-"
-- - -.,,- -"- ~.......... "---- '-------- '--" . ,.... y~,' - ~_....~
. ,~ -~__-.::..-. -, <:...- ~.~-"'~',-;i' :~..",...:::.<:'-: 7.IP ...,:".:---:
': "::;'~;~7i;i;a~~iti~k;iJ;~~~~?':~;:
"~~,{~:(~~~?-' ..;:-S-~">~-~' ';, -f:{\, .~.~~.
'.~ ,".
FOR $.y-f?~ /J> Y J 5 ? ~ 7 ~
11"00 'i' 'i' 5811" ,':01 B U; 2 'i',~I:
-
~..:;loObOOo 'i' ~o '1",
i
(
i
~
,.
"
~:
~
,-;~,~." .~...~.-._.,..- ~.,"-..-: '-;0-
.,-~..,_..~,.,
"
",. ,:t
!'
'1""
,,~
,J -~) :~'
.'.J
,
",
:,;~, ,,'
'j'
','.
,.
",
'.
";
fi
"-<
",
"",
, Y;':'~ ~::~:;Y.~: :',1 c
;.
,','f
"
;,"
., ,,'-'
,t,
"
.'
.".'
',"-"
"
-I:
l..,
~~
w
Z
::;
Ul,
IiJJ:
I-o:t}.
;:"
06,
..J - ~
w~:
cat:i
Z'I--,
..~~;
fJ):3i
0:<'
00:
tl.~l
"z.
<t~
5~' ';r"M,:,nr-h' Jr ,,'
!::8 .#~.....'i.,p ~.!,y"j~
~~' :.~:'::'.Og}-8.Cr.'il::""j
~Jj!imti 1\)N{Ji..lWf\~i>N\t1
o l'" j~ ;:n..'" " !i
o
"'--'='.'-'-'-'-=-~=~-=--=-~'.=,-,.o_.
J
r
.::::;, '- _ L::
1! t ~tn ~~} t.~
.' .~l<~lu.n3Wlllld. ' ,. " ~ < , J 0 l.~ q ..
..,~ YO "'~9ilfl4154657 >218S60t:/()~;; f~
..J1OO00JE0-4 . I OOO.Q00000.(r~
. .' !i in~ljl~H ;
r'11,;~~~o~"'I4.P 17Sfi?l'il'~' ;roo -:) ;
r ,,-,... ""'98€l""'zo.t.:;Q:~ .;::t>'Ol. Om
"i::::~:5~~;"!~ ~:3(:~~'~:,(j ~
L,l..j.~:;:Lj.'1 (',1.;. ')':;. ';;;;;'1~.c~..'h '
"W. .... -. ... _-... ",:".....;l_!: ;.,.-,:; ~J~ .
I: '5~' i:;
o,~ .
(,~1 -
;i~ l
~r_~
6t:;6f~=j8~:jE~
'..,"
W
lr
W
I
W
Ul
a:
o
E
W
~
4
\
"
'"
.
tB
(; ~,
:...!U:
.
--~--_...-
"-~-~
-'-r"::-'--
'-'--:~---'--""---,"-""'-'--
, . .
:"~.. -:Pri''''7"',-'''-~T''-;-'''-'7''''_~
"rr.'
",
....
,,'
~ '
. ~
\ . ;~",~'~,~,"';,.',:.','..;.....;.~?: :'!. "., :
~, '-~:'':'.,:J,:':;,
....-.
"/ " 'r:'
,.:; :::.:: ;t;~;::.;~:\{,~';"~;::<:j};~!!f,;;,t~~::;,Y::.'
i' '\'-":
:(~'- -, . ~ '.' , ". ;~'
::<1~~.;,,>~~' ' ,J'"
.. ,.... ~ ,
:,~' .".
\. '-','
,,~<
,"-.'
"
, .
-"'f'
\.
,
...\i.":' "~,'~'I" ";", ,...;',...,......;', .~~;, \ (',
_ 1'" \ ...,.....',',:.,'.;'.','.~.....,:...,. '.;"',:;.,~_..:..:.:"":~"','",',),',\-,,,,,,,"',",..'",'.','.'.',.'"."..,.
,,_,~;~,!\,)':::i;i~':;,:; ~,,~~}ii.' ~r" ,: I \'1
I~'
,'~-
~..
"-~~~~
",'''''''''~'''-''''-;''o"o;~
~~-"-' -,
,i'lililll ^~
I ~
BREflNER
FAMILY OF DEALERSHIPS
:~ ~ o~. ~
CUSTOMEANO,
20621
JACOB SHANK
HC63BOX7
MCAlISTERVlllE. PA 17043
AESIDENCEPHONE
717-483.2166
BUBlNE9&PHOHE
483.2166
'1~IIlBlllill~ r
BRENNE"ADlLLAC OLDSMOBILE, INC.
2222 Paxlo.. Street P.O. Box 2851
Hanisburg, Pa. 17111
PHONE (717) 238-2552
-
~ 1~';Lll GD
ADVISOA
STEPHE TPRNETTE 273
lI.6OI\AAlE L\CEtl$EkO,
""""".'"
~
......
, 1:.:-' '
0.00
-
J.l!STllHER fOP'( ,.:" ,. : [COHTINUalllN rqr PAGE]
/,uu:.(;. ',~(JU. 7(Je aftlzwei4te &j<J4:,: rKt.!.,',tCJ.J!
OIL & FILTER CHANGE
$23.95 Plu,Tax
Lube chassis. if necessary
Install new oil filter
Check & top off all fluids
Add up to 5 qts. Motor oil
Check & adjust tire pressure
FREE multipoint inspection
Most models, some models additional
YE/lRIMAI<E/MODa
92/CADllLAC/ElIIllfIAOD/CPE 20R
VEtllCLEl.O,NO-
IG8Ell3B1UUB16111
F.T.e.NO.
P. 0, NO.
-~
.- . .' ,
:,' Tire Rotatlon/Balanee/
.' Brake ID.speetioD
$39.95 .."Tn
. Inspect for irregular tire wear.
- Check tire pre,sure, rotate per
. JDIlDufacturer's specification.
- Inspect rims.
- Computer Balan<e 4 wheels.
- Check brake liniDgs, rotors,
drums, hydraulic system &.
master cylinder.
13:20:49
'. Scheduled.
Maintenance'
Receive a 10% Discount
on Parts & Labor for any
scheduled maintenance.
BREr JNER
FAMILY OF DEALEBSHIPS
~ ~p o~. c;~
CVQTOllalt-lO-._
JACOB SHANK
HC 63 BOX 7
~"'tt
AD
Yff/lCl-Erol'lO.
MCALlSTERVILLE, PA 17043
,l.Ltlo.
!l.lOIDCENCEI'
auSl<<ESSPI-IOI:
BRENNF ':ADlLLAC OLDSMOBILE,INC.
2222 Paxt".. Street P.O. Box 2851
Harrisburg. Pa. 17111
PHONE (717) 238-2552
CiD h';l\1 G)
'"
'm<:llCE:l:l1,
lNIIClCl;.WJ
ORA
D
~,
WHITE
,~"
DCS:m6ll
.,""~
DarvERYI.!
SEU-lfl CEALEANO.
I'AOCIOCTlCNo.o.T!:
flQ.DAIf<
:1
IolllVoG1!lli
""""'''''
TOTAlS..~.. .---..- -.. -..' n _. __.... n...... <0_" _." __ u _0_.._... _... _. _. .0.... __".. ~_u ._. 0... _..
Visit us on.11ne at LoMl.BRENNrRCADIllAC.ctX'I for more 1nfol
~~r!~~~r~~~W~~ ~~r!J.~~~~~ J.1rIT1~~t]UIJ. t~ruJ..L
: PllY'il'otnt Kethod Bo-x :
: [ ] CllSJL ] Check No......... [ ) MR :
: ( 1 Visa (] MasterCard [ ] kw( :
*[]DiScoYeJ'[]HAC *
. .
* Pll)TIlent Received By...........Un1tfa15) *
* Date......... .,
AUUUJ.UAUU,UUAU.uUUAJ,UU J,.J.uu u, UJ,UJ..J.L
Vehicle Released To:
.;~., ., -,> .,-.t.::~,r-"';~ _._, '''h:, ~.,., .-.~,u.
;'~:,:< , ,~"-l. ':ii'. .-'.r"
. -.'. "~'" .,F.:.':,:.'_:,j',,~.'~. t.',:-,~:~ :if . . -.. ,;
~~;.~:~: . _....~,' ~ .. .~
_, ~;;:.'~,;~~!" r.~, '-;""~~-'.'. ,.
" y/ \t"i;;;,:"",)~E:~;:;L;::;h~<Ui. ,;
i~; ";~l':'~~~~;,..:>^4~:~;1~:f:~~f~;;~~?':.: :j'.'.
--~'~)~$-::;k""'~~'r"'" END 'OF/O'IHVOICE "]'/ .-
'3(/e ,af:ft~e~iaU r-~ 6<<Jtltc4,,!
CUSTaHm SIGNATURE
U~ U! ~~!~ U! U!~~~U~nU!
DUPLICATE INVOICE
PAGE 2 OF' 2
.Q!SJl>lER 9'''.'( , "
lIu""k "tIJt?
OIL & FILTER CHANGE
$23.95 PIWITax
IL~::::
AL lET...
TAL w.<<.G...,
AL HISC CflG.
AL HISC DISC
AL TAX.....,
lUTAL IHVOICf $
J.J~U JU U
:f~':f1_tl
" ','
--~ .
.'
..
" Tire Rotation/Balancel
Brake Inspection
$39.95 'Iu.Tn
. Inspect for imgclar tire wear,
<< Check tire pressure, rotate per
manufacturc:fa specification..
. Inspect rims.
. Computer Balance 4 wheels.
. Check brake linings, rotors,
drums, hydraulic system &
master cylinder.
Lube chassis, if necessary
InstaU new oil filter
I Check & top off.ll fluids
i Add up to 5 qts. MOIor oil
I Check & .djust tire pressure
FREE multipoint inspection
Most models. some models additional
ffi:~
G.OO
G,GG
0'38
G.
49. 7
saO.S7
U 1111
~ ::~t
.' ". ~
'.'.
,
.\"
-c.
~
,':t;,~;,.
,
13:20:49
.
~
Scheduled.
Maintenance
".
Receive a 10% Discount
on Parts & Labor for any
scheduled maintenance.
..:...,,;,.,~ '<<t
"M.:.
I _~L
~ . .
,~ '. ", ',;' -,
'1<w,.J4-",-'l-~.i
"~, ""- .....'.
:c', ~""
,..
'.~~," ',.. :-:'~:; '~~'::;'<~~i'
~, ' ,.~
p,I '\'
", .~ ,i '
1',".1"
""1' ,.\
",.'n
j"' "".'
',<,",
, ~,~ '\
.',-
:,','
'.,
d
9ti JACOB R. SHANK 7769 II
~ ,; CONCRETE CONTRACTOR II
" H,C, 63. BOX 7 PH. 717-463-2155 " I
-,- ".' "i1~ Me ALlSTERVllLE, PA 17049 . - 60-1627/313 -I'
. ~02 '
~~~HE 02 028 Oii0236~_TE~ -~:, __. ~ . !I
ORDER OF ~----~~ ~.,,<?/~-. " 1$ _ff"Fc,.P.J. III
~A/" :12'0 I
. fiP'~-:::"'..-/ A-"'1/!4- -!Z~DoLLARS liJ=.'::' I'
~ OMEGA ~~5953 ,,~~g ,,14.;;ur:!:!'-l' 1006 !/
,BANK v" -, "
_Ol,,",-_~ .- ~'~.. ~ I
FOR "7/[p"'95 ," " -. ". " ... I
,
IIIQO??!;"lIl" I:OHH~2HI:O ."000008808U:,
'.
,~, -
'i."
"
,
"
'-.' .
,.',
~v, .,
FRB-PHILB.***~**M]XED
020095953 D310~0004-0
020095953 08-24-00
04 104 02 028
011023672 000824
.'
.
"
.....
"
, . ~ J'
','.
,
-'" , -,
. ,"-'
'", .'" ,:
,
-~ ~
'5
"
.J ~..r.J
HHilil MMi ::>
EMT pmRSSt~, 1't;'-'>
i!3lj.~79~r::el~i
?3~J2~J6?~f[~}
,
....,
'. ','';',-,
~I "",,' ,,'
-: .,' ,':'" J'.. -',,' ':~;; "
::.L'l
'-,
--':::t.--I
,~'-j:.;t....J
~
,'. r'...)
,-
<:- C...
'," "N', 6,~JIiK:~,
~""
G)9t
~ g \
~ (l)
!!i""""
- 00
~ro"'"'l
g g. c:l
o ~"tl>
c~"O
;::l <> 0
i-I"O~
~ --
",0-0
0> sg ::l
...'" -
<co<
, Cf' .
--i =:
0:><:>
~=r
c.~
~
'.
INVOICE ~age 1
~ OVERHEj DOOR COMPANY OF HARRISBUn laRK .j)
49582A
"
576 Grandview Drive _ Lewisberry, PA 17339_
Telephone (717) 236-4011 - York (717) 854-5501 _ Hanover Branch (717) 633-5776
INVOICE NO.:
'49582A bATE: Oct 18 00
TYPE: Residential Sales
SOLD MS PATRICIA STERLING
TO: 504 WALTON CT
LEMOYNE PA 17043
SHIPPE,D MS PATRICIA "STERLING
TO: 504 WALTON CT
LEMOYNE PA 17043
.
JOBNU~IBER : AUTHORIZED BY: .. TERMS:
49582 Patricia Sterling NET 10
CUSTOMER PO #: CUST ACCT #:
STE22
REMARKS: Patricia Sterling
77 4-8009
.~~,.
Furnish and Install:
1.000 Sectional, 194 Series 14'0 x 7'0
1.000 Labor to Install 194 Series 14'0 x 7'0
RETAIL TAX (IF APPLICABLE):
INVOICE TOTAL:
LESS CREDITS:
NET TOTAL DUE (Please Pay This Amountt:
~,
0.00
1,328.00
1,328.00
0.00
WHITE-CUSTOMER COPY
YELLOW-FILE COpy
PINK-CONTROL COpy
PLEASE INCLUDE INVOICE NUMBER WHEN MAKING PAYMENT
PLEASE PAY FROM THIS INVOICE - NO STATEMENT WILL BE SENT
'" " ,"
"
" ",. ". ".~-; . ' ~ .
\
'r J"
'..
.. ., ..
""".-~ "-~."'~ ,,:..:,: . ...~ .r:;.~r.)~;,~i.~
. > ~/~ ~ -,'.,
"?::,:,. :.,:~',. :'~:::/':~~~~~~'~"::;.:'/;i;,.~'::>';7: 2t '::' ~:. :',::, .'>.
,'~!' ..
,'. '.. ,.
"" ,-,
~;;": -
_~~:Z~~~CTOR :Jt
p;y 03 003 01103210&)<TFf;;;~ ,('~/.~
TO THE ~~~."
O~:/ ~~_.~~~-'/: . .,~. ~~~:~~ .
J::\ OMEGA . ." .
~ BANK ' -.- ,
.....-oIc:::..~~ '" .
FOR~""'/-:. ~'f uJt>I&d:. ~.
11'00778'111' 1:0:i~:iH,27~1:. 0
7789
60-1627/313
d~
. ~.tG~t{~
. - ..f)a. DOLLARS m=."::"
;7 . . -
>!
lIP
1.1, 71,711'
,"00000 b bloOD",
..':- ~ - -.,
-;.,~ -'
.'. -- .... ,.~ '.
. -:, '... -,~~, ",,.,.' ,..."i:-'. ~. ,"
. ~ n.~,.' ~", "
"
. .
..
" .,'. __,> > '" ~ 'n' _d.. '.'
JACOB R. SHANK
; CONCRETE CONTRACTOR
~~\ H,C. 63, BOX 7 PH. 717-463-2155
". . -', MC AUSTERVILlE, PA 17049 . ,- .. A~.7-.Pp 60-16271313
. 02 040 01102849B~~~
~J~~oF~~h_/ ~AL/ . ..I$?r;;~~
M_____ __ ./ // // ./
FOR4,.t!#:- 9'9i?:z ~ / ~.,/.-r_~~ ..
f.0078j,:iIl' -1:0:iBlrb27lrl: 0 :ilrl,?I.?II' /'OOgOObbI,OO,"
7813
':
.
.
;'
,
.
;::~
-
04 104
011032103
_ _ 07
-:..r.
.~-Ma- --~.~
~_~~;oo
Q:~Tft~~":> '-
,,-,0. 'W:-;S~
. ':.,~-~..1.:
04 104
Cl1102 02
8456
.gj'1Q,
Clli't~P !~i1G $ t4
~? RSr'MK "
~l~i"~
~}4?~:It~f~~
-..
,,',
"','",,'
003
000925
.
040
001103
"
,-,:,'
-;~"
~
'"
N
g
.
.
.
1
i
f _
.."1,'
. ,~
;::0-
_m_
C-Co
tr. :"'f.~, ::0
l"-~,,:~::-::n
c:~ ''I ...~. C .,,--")
~, ".J
C -..;3
:;: ~~~::::
v.z :.' ~ ...- ~....
():'~
""..
~
~-
'"
~-,' J
F "C. 0
t ',,'r:' :".t
'-'"
c
.; -, .j'
:~
"
'""
,-,',
C' . .~
~,fQ
.~".
. }~,'
,:,.\
"','
~.": - ,'..
-<:0
.....
N
.""
~
....
.::.~~
'"
t,;.
..,
......
c:
.t::"
0>
'51
'l..-. "
,~ ' ,
.."
co
',--,..'.
--'C_''('~~'~@!t;'M3'
. .~, '
,l!
.~,'
(
-;
o
<-n
_.:'tk ~ Q
~:r::'-
Cll <ll 0
, '00"", <ll
"_~ -:~;Q) '9 Q. ""0
~;{)C:oiE
::;,,0) -. 0 .::::
-;{~" 0
.- .... 0
O:e.
P'<
(
0"
~ Q
% ~~
~:I::ro
CllC;<llco
oeo OJ 1J
00,0.0
.b. cf C r"l
'\J ..... 0 .~:
Jl:>:-Q ~
-'- _ LI
o~
~-'
~ -
'- '" 'rlii;1!'Lllj-;.:,Yc'
F:IFILESIOAT AFILE\MlSC\els-arb shank/tde
Created: 1/211031:15:51 PM
Revised: 1/2I!031:23:45PM
JACOB R. SHANK a1k/a
PETE SHANK, an individual,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO. 01-6530 - CNIL ACTION - LAW
PATRICIA J, STERLING, an individual,
Defendant
TO: JACOB R. SHANK alk!a PETE SHANK, Plaintiff, and his attorney,
ALBERT N. PETERLIN, ESQUIRE
PATRICIA J. STERLING, Defendant, and her attorney,
JAMES G. MORGAN, JR., ESQUIRE
NOTICE OF HEARING
YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED that the undersigned arbitrators appointed by the Court in
the above captioned matter will meet for the purpose of their appointment on Thursday, March 6,
2003, beginning at 9:00 a.m, in the Old Courtroom of the Old Cumberland County Courthouse,
Carlisle, Pennsylvania, at which time and place you may appear and be heard, together with your
witnesses and counsel, if you so desire.
Dated: January 21, 2003
~Af/-
Edward 1. Schorpp, Esquire, Chairman
Debra Wallet, Esquire, Arbitrator
Galen WaItz, Esquire, Arbitrator
cc: Court Administrator's Office
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, P A 17013
,
""~ ,.
.l.'
,L ~ =~
,'-........',-- "~
~.t:,
>
,.... ..
JACOB R. SHANK a/k/a
PETE SHANK, an
Individual
IN 1HE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO.
CNIL
19
Plaintiff
CN- 4>.5'30 ~~
v.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
An individual
RULE 1312-1.
Defendant
The Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators shall be substantially in the following form:
PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS
TO 1HE HONORABLE, 1HE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
IJ.-f..-/3Yr Ai, Pt:rt:eq It) ts a Il(~~ounsel for the plaintiff/defendant in the above action (or actions),
/
respectfully represents that:
1. The above-captioned action (or actions) is (are) at issue.
2, The claim of the plaintiff in the action is $ /8, 01(0/89
The counterclaim of the defendant in the action is
The following attorneys are interested in the case(s) as counselor are otherwise disqualified to sit as arbitrators:
Jl}mu;. C;. fktJfGI1-,J, 1p-.., (SQu.l,e~
. f
WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be
submitted.
Respectfully submitted,
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, ); /f"U .PAM /h oJ 02 S , tiT.l-N % consideration of the
foregoing petition, /!t-l.Jl.1:nl fkklf./ Esq., ,JthLu.d.J /tJ~
Esq., and Ad.# At) h~ ' Esq., are appointed arbitrators in tbe above captioned action (or
actions) as prayed for.
By~~
PJ.
'. ""
"
,-
, "' ,~ -~..,
"',~ ~
... ~~~.,,-^ '~---
. ."~^ . ""~ ~'" ,-.
-,
F'\LOI..,{YF\('L
I,J,~ .../f v...
OF THL ""'F'TLI(\t"O"hnv
; ,,,,-_ ' , ',,~, i \ "~!'~ Ilt\l'1 i
02 NOnS ~M 11: 24
CUMBERLAHD COUN1Y
PENNS':{LVANlA
l
~
~~Al. 1',~ ~
,.~, ,,=~'~ ~,'n\Wlllli_!iW
,_ ..,,_ ~ "l!--lIifi~~~;W'''1.'\''f.'''O'--'?';"''''''''-'~''
,,>~'_'!i'li~~
,,__, "!WJOOl!~~.-~,~!r;tI~,~,,.,_
.~w
-.-.
. _:" .,-_b'__T
~ -"-w...,...... - -~'" '< ~ -."_
,,~
b~<'u~~
.
. ',. ~ .....
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JACOB R. SHANK Illk/a PETE
SHANK, an individual,
Plaintiff,
CML ACTION - LAW
NO. 01- I.SJO ({'l,)'lL ~~
vs.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant
ORDER
AND NOW, this
day of
. 2002, upon
consideration of Plaintiff s Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators, it is hereby ORDERED and
DECREED that said petition is GRANTED and three arbitrators shall be appointed.
BY THE COURT:
J.
- ~~ ~
.-
. ~. .
.....-"'''''"'
.,,'~
,,~ ',-
-'-----"~"'j;;tYiill".-'~::
"
".
....
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JACOB R. SHANK aIkIa PETE
SHANK, an individual,
Plaintiff,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. CI-I...S'J() e(J~(~~
vs.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant.
PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT
OF ARBITRATORS
Plaintiff, Jacob R. Shank alk/a Pete Shank ("Plaintiff'), by and through his attorneys,
Gates, Halbruner & Hatch, P.C., makes the following Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators:
I. The above-captioned action is at issue.
2. The claim of the Plaintiff in the action is $18,040.89.
3. The following attorneys are interested in the case as counsel or are otherwise
disqualified to sit as arbitrators:
(a) AlbertN. Peterlin, Esquire,
Gates, Halbruner & Hatch, P.c.
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100,
Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043
(717) 731-9600
(Attorneys for Plaintiff)
(b) James G. Morgan, Jr., Esquire
Tucker Arensberg & Swartz
III North Front Street
P,O. Box 889
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0889
(717) 234-4121
(Attorneys for Defendant)
""J
W.'.~~.~ ,
~'~-,
~ "~
.~_,--,~~I_~~.......
"~ ""L.-"'~ub'L ",L:,,~ "'~c,""~~<C
10
"
WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3)
arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted,
Respectfully submitted,
GATES, HALBRUNER & HATCH, P.C.
~}C/liJ ~~
Albert N. Peterlin, squire
Supreme Court Bar No.: 84180
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100
Lemoyne, PA 17043
(717) 731-9600
(Attorneys for PlaintiO)
DATE:
November 6, 2002
- --
I ~
........
.,;;.1
~,~ ,,;~ 'II ;,,~_ii.':
,
~ " ....
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Albert N. Peterlin, Esquire, hereby certifY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing
Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators, has been served, on this day, upon the following counsel
of record by first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
James G. Morgan, Jr.
TUCKERARENSBERG & SWARTZ
111 North Front Street
P.O. Box 889
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0889
GATES, HALBRUNER & HATCH, P.C.
~~~At~
Albert N. Peterlin, Esquire
Attorney for Debtors
DATED: November 6, 2002
~~~W~_'ffi>!ii;>,}.":"'"""'1.;M:1i*,,IWM1~.tili~J>j,>i1,.C!,-f'~"-'
''''"',
;j''1,';~:~~1r,lli,l&~REmm IlBiIlIlb,~iil'IIAAliitt\':~'l{ MaJlilil\!i!!-,<1V'
~.
...="
f
#
~ (.) ~ 0 c::
1l C !'-..'
."l "".:-. ,",-
urT ~
0 Q][T .-,.::
",,--.- -~.
() ;7f.n
- f' ~~~~;. f"--,}
(}J .!::: W ~~ l.~, :;C,\
:;--'~, j~~
....... -.....] ~f=~
~ ,.' ,
:Pc co ('jfTi
...0 -1- -7 :;::;!
~
~ =2 :.n :0
\0 -<
~
-=\~
':,=,_'""~.~_ ,,",""''''~ c~,~,
""",>,,'_'~<i','o';" ',~,."-.,,_""^I,>"'"',~,~,c_r-_,~., "'""" >-' '''''''''_,'' ",_, ~~~" ,_,
-
~' ,=_, ' _" 1<<," ,~, _~ N ~~
,
--
~O"
:'
~1:&Jsl -0- ~ ' _h '~'"
" ~: , '
" ,"flili~:lli"['j'l_l:'"
to
.
1
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
JACOB R. SHANK a1kJa PETE
SHANK, an individual,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
Plaintiff,
vs.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant.
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
AND NOW, comes the Plaintiff, Jacob R. Shank a1k/a Pete Shank (hereinafter referred to as
"Shank"), by and through his counsel, Gates, Halbruner & Hatch, P,C" and makes the following motion
for summary judgment against Defendant, Patricia 1. Sterling:
1. Shank instituted the present action by filing a Complaint with this Court on
November 19, 2001 and alleging, inter alia, that defendant was unjustly enriched,
2, Defendant was served, by hand delivery, with a copy of the Complaint and a
Notice to Defend by the Cumberland County Sheriff's Office on November 20, 2001.
3, On or about December 12, 2001, Defendant filed an Answer with New Matter in
response to Shank's Complaint.
4, Shank filed an Answer to Defendant's Answer with New Matter with this Court
on December 20, 2002,
5, As a result of the foregoing, the relevant pleadings are closed,
6, Shank alleges, inter alia, in his Complaint that Defendant has received significant
labor and materials, at considerable effort and expense to Shank,
7, Shank alleges, inter alia, in his Complaint that Defendant appreciated the
I
"'>1-
",' ,~ ,.b' ", j'",~,._,,~- ",,,,,,-, ,'-0 C ~.-' ,'"<-J~':',,""~" ';;',-'., ','~", "-~. ~ '--" ~:'c
aforementioned services provided by the Plaintiff.
8. Shank alleges, inter alia, in his Complaint that Defendant wrongfully secured or
passively received a benefit under such circumstances that it would be unconscionable to retain it without
payment.
9, Defendant admits that Shank conferred significant benefits upon Defendant. Answer p, I,
~ 3 & Answer p, 5, ~ 32,
10, Defendant admits that Defendant appreciated the benefits conferred upon
Defendant. Answerp. 5, ~ 33,
II, Defendant admits that Defendant accepted and retained the benefits provided by
Shank, Answer p. 5, ~ 34,
12, On December 28,2001, Shank served, inter alia, Requests for Admissions upon
the Defendant. A true and correct copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A."
13, On or about January 22,2002, Shank received the Defendant's Answers to
Plaintiff's Request for Admissions, A true and correct copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "B,"
14, Defendant admitted outright thirty (30) of the forty-three (43) requests for
admissions regarding the fact that Shank conferred numerous and significant benefits upon Defendant and
that Defendant appreciated or realized those benefits. See Exhibit "B."
15, Defendant admitted-in-part an additional three (3) of the forty-three (43) request
for admissions regarding the fact that Shank conferred numerous and significant benefits upon Defendant
and that Defendant appreciated or realized those benefits, See Exhibit "B,"
16, Shank is not related to the Defendant by blood or marriage, See attached Exhibit
"C."
17, As the Defendant has admitted, Shank conferred upon and Defendant appreciated and
accepted significant benefits over the limited period of approximately one and one-half (I Yz) years,
2
~
~--, ".",-,.
,',,- '~l'Tflh:'-- -',-",' ~-'''..h.1.,j'~;L'-.n;,~~';iL'
,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Albert N, Peterlin, Esquire, hereby certifY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing
Motion for Summary Judgment, has been served upon the following counsel of record by first
class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
James G, Morgan, Jr., Esquire
Tucker, Arensberg & Swartz
III North Front Street
P,O, Box 889
Harrisburg, P A 17108-0889
GATES, HALBRUNER & HATCH, P.c.
DATED, 2MI1V
~Ji~-
Albert N. eterlin, Esquire
Attorney for the Plaintiff
l'r
~ "~
.., ..~--_. L,~ 'riA&:.' '-'~[;',,-:;,
EXHIBIT
"A"
---
~' '..,
,I,
, ",' r- " " 0,__<; ',] -, ., ,:"--,,,,")',; '-'~'~ .' 'f'f"'-;i
(
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JACOB R. SHANK alk/a PETE
SHANK, an individual,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
Plaintiff,
vs.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant.
REOUEST FOR ADMISSIONS OF THE PLAINTIFF
ADDRESSED TO THE DEFENDANT
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Defendant, Patricia 1. Sterling is required, pursuant
to Pa. R. Civ. p, 4014, to serve upon the undersigned an original of Defendant's answers in
writing and under oath, to the following requests for admissions within thirty (30) days after the
service of this document.
A. GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS
1, The General Instructions set forth in Plaintiff, Jacob R. Shank's Interrogatories of
the Plaintiff Addressed to the Defendant are incorporated by reference as though set forth fully at
length herein.
B. DEFINffiONS
1. The Definitions set forth in Plaintiff, Jacob R. Shank's Interrogatories of the
Plaintiff Addressed to the Defendant are incorporated by reference as though set forth fully at
length herein.
..' ~
~ ~ ~ .~ -,
~~'.iMr ,~"
~' ',~. - .
~"i1rl~...+~;!;'i"","
REOUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS
1. Plaintiff paid the purchase price of the 1992 Cadillac automobile for the Defendant.
2, Defendant agreed to repay Plaintiff the amount of the purchase price of the 1992
Cadillac automobile.
3, Defendant obtained possession of a certain garage door part necessary to repair
said garage door,
4, Plaintiff paid for the item( s) referenced in the previous paragraph,
5. Defendant obtained possession of a certain new garage door or garage door
opener for Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years,
6, Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph,
7, Defendant obtained possession of a certain range stove affixed in Defendant's
personal residence within the past two (2) years.
8. Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph,
9, Defendant obtained possession of certain window blinds and related materials
affi){ed in Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years.
10, Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph.
11. Plaintiff installed the item referenced in Paragraph 8 in Defendant's personal
residence.
12. Defendant obtained certain maintenance and repairs of Defendant's 1992
Cadillac automobile.
13, Plaintiff paid for the services referenced in the previous paragraph.
14, Defendant obtained possession of certain painting materials within the past two (2)
2
= ~ ~
~ ~ ,
~,~,~
'-"'""" -, ~.
-l,,' ";~'.""'~-~;::::r'"
years.
15. Plaintiff paid for the item( s) referenced in the previous paragraph,
16. Plaintiff painted certain rooms of Defendant's personal residence with the materials
referenced in Paragraph 13.
17. Defendant obtained possession of certain stone materials for the exterior of
Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years.
18. Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph,
19, Plaintiff affixed the item( s) referenced in Paragraph 16 to the exterior premises of
Defendant's personal residence.
20. Defendant obtained possession of a certain fence on the property of
Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years.
21. Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph.
22, Defendant obtained possession of certain concrete materials regarding a concrete
foundation on the property of Defendant's personal residence for a utility shed.
23, Plaintiff paid for the item( s) referenced in the previous paragraph,
24, Plaintiff poured the concrete foundation for the construction ofa certain utility
shed upon Defendant's personal residence.
25, Plaintiff erected a certain utility shed upon the property of Defendant' s personal
residence.
26. Defendant obtained possession of certain landscaping materials for the borders and
edging of the property of Defendant' s personal residence.
27. Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph.
3
l~~ o....~ _~~~, _
-,~
1-
~~
--'" -,~ ,1- - 'Jli - <
-
" ,,- , . ~~~~*"
28, Defendant obtained possession of certain maintenance materials utilized for the
maintenance of Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years.
29. Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph.
30. Defendant obtained possession of certain decorative stone materials within the past
two (2) years.
31.
32,
Plaintiff paid for the item( s) referenced in the previous paragraph.
Plaintiff affixed the item(s) referenced in Paragraph 29 to the premises of
Defendant's personal residence,
33, Defendant obtained possession of certain blacktop materials applied to the
driveway of Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years.
34, Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph.
35, Defendant obtained possession of a certain garbage disposal installed in
Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years,
36. Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph.
37, Plaintiff installed the item(s) referenced in Paragraph 34 in Defendant's personal
residence,
38. Defendant obtained possession ofa certain water system installed in certain
investment real property of the Defendant within the past two (2) years.
39, Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph,
40, Plaintiff installed the item( s) referenced in Paragraph 37 in certain investment real
property of the Defendant.
41. Defendant obtained possession of certain insulation materials installed in
4
'J;!
-,.
""-
iIi~
~--- ....,~-,"'" .~lfM1:li:l~'L",'
/-
Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years,
42, Plaintiff paid for the item(s) referenced in the previous paragraph.
43. Plaintiff installed the item(s) referenced in Paragraph 40 in Defendant's personal
residence.
GATES & ASSOCIATES, P.c.
Date: '0!~h)
By:
~f~~f$~11
Ibert N. eterlin, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff, Jacob R. Shank
5
\C;
~ "
~n=~ "
I, I
'-
<,;;;,,';.~~.;,~< ,,~, "ili.!!i"'" j~~(;
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Albert N. Peterlin, Esquire, hereby certifY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing
Request for Admissions of the Plaintiff Addressed to the Defendant, has been served upon the
foIlowing counsel of record by first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
James G. Morgan, Jr,
TUCKER ARENSBERG & SWARTZ
III North Front Street
P.O. Box 889
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0889
GATES & ASSOCIATES, P.c.
~~A)g-!t/2~~
Albert N. eterlin, Esquire
Attorney for the Plaintiff
DATED: ('2../2S/CJ )
.'-', ," "_."''1,,,,,," '" '-':'''---':'illIL,''--~-'"'- "-~@.h]l,'1
EXHIBIT
"B"
v~
--=
~~, .~
"~ .
'-i~....~"" " :.' 1_" -.~ .-n
0'_',", ','-~.,,"","'-' -'''''"''~1!!awii!:':
JACOB R. SHANK alkfa PETE
SHANK, an Individual,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
PATRICIA J, STERLING, an
Individual,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
vs.
DEFENDANT'S ANSWERS TO PLAINTIFF'S
REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS
1. Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff paid the purchased price of the 1992
Cadillac automobile.
2. Denied. It is specifically denied that Defendant agreed to repay Plaintiff
for the purchase of the1992 Cadillac automobile in the amount of
$6,000.00 and/or any other monetary amount.
3. Denied. It is denied that Defendant obtained possession of a certain new
garage door part necessary to repair said garage door.
4. Admitted, It is admitted that Plaintiff paid for a serviceman to come to the
house in order to determine why the garage door wasn't working. It was
determined that Plaintiff left a broom in front of the electronic garage door
eye which caused the garage door not to open and/or close. Once the
serviceman removed the broom, the garage door began to work.
",
5.
6.
7,
8.
9.
~"~
,.,~I~^", ,J:' '.rlll_If"'."--. L~.--
""'~~",
t'~--
10.
Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained a certain new garage
door or garage door opener for Defendant's personal residence within the
past two (2) years.
Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for the new
garage door or garage door opener.
Admitted in part and Denied in part. It is admitted that Defendant obtained
possession of a certain range stove. However, it is denied that the certain
range stove was affixed in Defendant's personal property within the past
two (2) years. The certain range stove was affixed in Defendant's rental
property.
Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for the new
certain range stove.
Admitted in part and Denied in part. It is admitted that Defendant obtained
possession of certain window blinds affixed in Defendant's personal
residence within the past two (2) years. It is denied that Defendant
obtained possession of related materials affixed in Defendant's personal
residence within the past two (2) years,
Admitted, It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid approximately
$90.00 in the Spring of 2001 for certain window blinds affixed in
Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years.
Defendant can not answer said request as stated.
11.
2
~ -"^'~-
I I
~I.......jjj'" - ' ,.' n~~;'-'-- ',.. "'~"" -,,' ---,,? .~'-""~ltt:1
12. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained certain maintenance and
repairs of Defendant's 1992 Cadillac automobile.
13. Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for certain
maintenance and repairs of Defendant's 1992 Cadillac automobile.
14. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained possession of certain
painting materials within the past two (2) years. However, it is unknown
by Defendant as to the specifics and quantity of those certain painting
materials.
15. Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for certain
painting materials within the past two (2) years,
16. Denied in part and Admitted in part. It is specifically denied that Plaintiff
painted certain rooms of Defendant's personal residence with the
materials referenced in paragraph 14. However, it is admitted that Plaintiff
did paint the kitchen ceiling and only the kitchen ceiling of Defendant's
personal residence.
17. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained possession of certain
stone materials for the exterior of Defendant's personal residence within
the past two (2) years,
18. Admitted, It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for certain
stone materials for exterior of Defendant's personal residence within the
past two (2) years.
19. Defendant can not answer said request as stated,
3
,~- ~~
,.1_
.:,,-,
-, ",'.;.i'"-,,,~__," '~ ,__ !_~.:~(
".
20. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained possession of a certain'
fence on the property of Defendant's personal residence within the past
two (2) years,
21. Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for the certain
fence on the property of Defendant's personal residence within the past
two (2) years.
22. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained possession of certain
concrete materials regarding a concrete foundation on the property of
Defendant's personal residence for a utility shed.
23. Admitted, It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for the certain
concrete materials regarding a concrete foundation on the property of
Defendant's personal residence for a utility shed.
24. Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff poured the concrete foundation for
the construction of a certain utility shed upon Defendant's person
residence. By way of further answer, prior to Plaintiff pouring the concrete
foundation, Defendant previously had a stone foundation area prepared
for the utility shed that Plaintiff did not like and changed it to the concrete
foundation, By way of further answer, Defendant assisted Plaintiff with
pouring the concrete foundation for the utility shed.
25. Admitted, Plaintiff with the assistance of Plaintiff's friend, erected a certain
utility shed upon the property of Defendant's personal residence,
4
, ,
.
. w~-..~ _._,~~... ~'"
-,~"
~ loimoJow;" ,'"
"" &d:il"-~'-' ~.'4!-~-;;,~"''':',
26, Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained possession of certain
landscaping materials for the borders and edging of the property of
Defendant's personal residence,
27. Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for certain
landscaping'materials for the borders and edging of the property of
Defendant's personal residence.
28. Neither Admitted nor Denied. It is neither admitted nor denied that
Defendant obtained possession of certain maintenance materials utilized
for the maintenance of Defendant's personal residence within the past two
(2) years. As such, Defendant can not truthfully admit nor deny the
allegation.
29. Neither Admitted nor Denied, It is neither admitted nor denied that Plaintiff
paid for maintenance materials, As such, Defendant can not truthfully
admit nor deny the allegation,
30. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained possession of certain
decorative stone materials within the past two (2) years.
31, Admitted, It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for certain
decorative stone materials within the past two (2) years,
32. Defendant can not answer said request as stated.
33. Admitted, It is admitted that Defendant obtained possession of certain
blacktop materials applied to the driveway of Defendant's personal
residence within the past two (2) years.
5
--
""""'"~~...' -~~ . " .
=
~"~ _,..,. "- "-----'.J~ ,- ,', ,i' ,- ,-,-,~ ,-" ,',;"<-,,~,, "" - " ::'tit:i
t_ ,
.
34. Denied. It is specifically denied that Plaintiff paid for certain blacktop
materials applied to the driveway of Defendant personal residence within
the past two (2) years. By way of further answer, Plaintiff went down the
street and obtained a free wheel barrel full of blacktop from a business
laying blacktop and brought it back to Defendant's personal residence to
fix a 2 by 4 foot hole in the driveway,
35. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained possession of a certain
garbage disposal installed in Defendant's personal residence within the
past two (2) years.
36. Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for a certain
garbage disposal installed in Defendant's person residence within the past
two (2) years.
37. Defendant can not answer said request as stated.
38. Admitted, It is admitted that Defendant obtained possesion of a certain
water system installed in certain investment real property of the Defendant
within the past two (2) years.
39. Admitted. It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for a certain
water system installed in certain investment real property of the Defendant
within the past two (2) years.
40. Defendant can not answer said request as stated.
6
"
. .
~
.".1..:..-. =,,'
. ~,---<' ,-, . ", .^l-"~>-;:~;
~,_"W" __' .
.
41. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant obtained possession of certain
insulation materials installed in Defendant's personal residence within the
past two (2) years,
42. Admitted, It is admitted that Plaintiff offered to pay and paid for certain
insulation materials installed in Defendant's person residence within the
past two (2) years.
43. Admitted, It is admitted that Plaintiff installed certain insulation materials
in Defendant's personal residence within the past two (2) years.
i
Ja ~./Morgan, rJ, Esquire
Attort,e ltD. NO.1 97
111 rth Front Street
Harri burg, PA 17101-0889
(717) 234-4121
Dated: January ---/=J::. 2002
46274,1
7
,
I*~"
~d;."."" ,,",., j.,;,-. "-".'''~' ^-','",. '''01
1-, ( .
VERIFICATION
I, Patricia J. Sterling, verifY that the facts stated in the foregoing document are true and
correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief.
I understand that any false statements made to this verification are subject to the penalties
of 18 Pa, C.S.A. ~4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
~~>J Y1fid.dy
airicia 1. Sterling;?'
46280,[
~
-
~ ,
, ~ '
J..;;... ~"""-,' ~ ~---."",--' '.-",^ ."> o::.J-,,,,._~ ---, .,' -,-"",~ '1~i~_i,
~ ~.
,a.h
.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
AND NOW, this @lltLdaYOfDecember, 2001, I, Cathleen A. Kohr, for the firm
of Tucker Arensberg & Swartz, attomeys for Defendant, hereby certify that I have this day
served Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs Request for Admissions by causing a copy of
the same to be placed in the United States Mail, First Class, postage prepaid, at
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, addressed as follows:
Albert N. Peterlin, Esquire
GATES & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100
Lemoyne, PA 17043
(lw~ A ;(~
Cathleen A. Kohr
'" II, .
EXHIBIT
"c"
"' I" , -, :,.' ,'-' ""--~,--, 'L" :', - <'-'c--il~.ii~",i
",
-,<~~ ~'"~.
~_..
,--1"","",,,.,
"--""'.......
[' :'1:Hj)jili;,\~\i"'~",l'_"-;,
"'I.~ C
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JACOB R. SHANK i1/k1a PETE
SHANK, an individual,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
Plaintiff,
vs.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant.
AFFIDAVIT OF JACOB R. SHANK
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYL VANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
I, Jacob R. Shank, being duly sworn according to law, hereby depose and say as follows:
1. I am not related to Patricia 1. Sterling by blood or marriage,
a~e ~~L
~acob R. Shank
Sworn to and subscribed before me
this day of
February, 2002
Notary Public
~'-,-.~" W~UlIiiit:11:lRIHhj'~!i~~~m:-l!lli~-f;ii~~.t",,k,h""',"~;~"-'"''''-'--''''' "u",!,;,,,,,-,,,,,,~'Jl!w.t,I~M,t '""',,"-",,, '.illii!fi~iWffl;'iIiib~~~
4;'.:J _""""""",~~~_",o~;;>O;~'P;;',="""",,_",,""~_.^ . ~"',1'",_""" ,"" ','0c",_~ ."_.,,.y~~__~_, "',~~"'.cr_",_~,'"","" ,.,.",,,'~~_ ~~" ~~" '_. '-'. ~, __ "",~,=,_, , "~,' ,.r", ,,~_. ,~,
l!l'!l
"'I .. '...
n C:) (-:-)
~:,,: 1-,.) -n
< -,
T [ ,--.j
[~ " i "'.'1
"Tl '~'j - .,..,
C>) ;'1
0..'1 c:;
r 0
:;--..'; T .,
r) :-~::!
",,,- , C)
~.. " .) .. , :--"
'-'
:;::7 ~
-j :::> :~
:.:J
-, (,,...i -<
f;5
~
~.,
~ ~.. ," ~ I
'~'-" ~'
I "'l:f""
, ~
~~tii-"
,
" .
JACOB R. SHANK aIkIa PETE
SHANK, an Individual,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
vs.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PATRICIAJ. STERLING, an
Individual,
Defendant
NO, 01-6530 CIVIL
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
DEFENDANT'S ANSWER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION
FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
AND NOW, comes the Defendant, Patricia Sterling, by and through her counsel, James G.
Morgan, Jr., Esquire, and TUCKER ARENSBERG & SWARTZ, and hereby aver the following:
1. Admitted.
2. i\dmitted.
3. Denied. Defendant's Answer with New Matter in response to Plaintiff's Complaint
was filed on December 13,2001.
4. Admitted.
5. Admitted. By way of further answer, there is outstanding discovery responses to
Defendant's Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents directed to Plaintiff wherein
additional facts will be produced to support Defendant's Answer in Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion
for Summary Judgment.
6. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant has received labor and materials from
Plaintiff. By way of further answer, Plaintiff insisted on providing certain benefits to Defendant
even though Plaintiff was aware of Defendant's economic situation wherein she wasn't able to
Ii;
"
'~--,' ,~
...;,~" "
lil~dilil'-:'-l~lil!.etl.< ~"""","",,,.;..,. ,'^' jjgin~iiti.t~a?_.f;,
. '
compensate Plaintiff for these services. Further, Plaintiff provided the labor and materials to
Defendll11t as gifts, wherein Plaintiff willingly transferred money and/or property to Defendant
without payment and with no thought of any possible financial benefit to the giver, the Plaintiff.
7. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant has received labor and materials from
Plaintiff. By way of further answer, Plaintiff insisted on providing certain benefits to Defendant
even though Plaintiff was aware of Defendant's economic situation wherein she wasn't able to
compensate Plaintiff for these services. Further, Plaintiff provided the labor and materials to
Defendant as gifts, wherein Plaintiff willingly transferred money and/or property to Defendant
without payment and with no thought of any possible financial benefit to the giver, the Plaintiff.
8. Denied. It is specifically denied that Defendant wrongfully secured or passively
received a benefit under such circumstances that it would be unconscionable to retain it without
payment. By way of further answer, Plaintiff provided the labor and materials to Defendant as gifts,
wherein Plaintiff willingly transferred money and/or property to Defendant without payment and
with no thought of any possible financial benefit to the giver, the Plaintiff. Further, Plaintiff
appreciated the benefit of residing at Defendant's premises for a period of one year, at considerable
effort and expense to Defendant.
9. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff conferred benefits
upon Defendant. It is admitted that Plaintiff conferred benefits upon Defendant as gifts, wherein
Plaintiff willingly transferred labor, money and/or property to Defendant without payment and with
no thought of any possible financial benefit to the giver, the Plaintiff. By way of further answer, it.
is specifically denied that Defendant entered into any oral and/or written agreement with Plaintiff
stating that Defendant would compensate Plaintiff for these services. Further, Plaintiff appreciated
2
"~ ~"___IUo__-'
~-'"
'. ",....! '-..".. "",' '.<, ~.
"^'l>ii~0j;::
the benefit of residing at Defendant's premises for a period of one year, at considerable effort and
expense to Defendant.
10. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant appreciated the benefits conferred upon
Defendant. By way of further answer, there is outstanding discovery responses to Defendant's
Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents directed to Plaintiff wherein additional
facts will be produced to support Defendant's Answer in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for
Summary Judgment.
11. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant accepted and retained the benefits provided
by Plaintiff. By way of further answer, Plaintiff insisted on providing certain benefits to Defendant
even though Plaintiff was aware of Defendant's economic situation wherein she wasn't able to
compensate Plaintiff for these benefits. Further, Plaintiff conferred benefits upon Defendant as
gifts, wherein Plaintiff willingly transferred labor, money and/or property to Defendant without
payment and with no thought of any possible financial benefit to the giver, the Plaintiff.
12. Admitted.
13. Admitted.
14. Admitted in part and denied in part. By way offurther answer, there is outstanding
discovery responses to Defendant's Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents
directed to Plaintiff wherein additional facts will be produced to support Defendant's Answer in
Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment.
15, Admitted in part and denied in part. By way offurther answer, there is outstanding
discovery responses to Defendant's Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents
3
'!
"-'- ~.,
""
" J ,~
'.J_,IIi"-=-~ ., ~'':i_o~ii:!'' IliOii
~""""U4i'W.l":m4~'
, ,
directed to Plaintiff wherein additional facts will be produced to support Defendant's Answer in
Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment.
16. Admitted. It is admitted that Defendant is not related to Plaintiff by blood or
marriage. By way of further answer, Defendant and Plaintiff were residing together as a couple
within Defendant's residence for a significant period of time.
17. Admitted. By way of further answer, there is outstanding discovery responses to
Defendant's Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents directed to Plaintiff wherein
additional facts will be produced to support Defendant's Answer in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion
for Summary Judgment.
18. Denied. Although Defendant hasn't provided any monetary compensation to
Plaintiff in return for benefits conferred upon the Defendant by Plaintiff, it is denied that Plaintiff
hasn't received consideration from Defendant in the form of companionship and housing for a
significant period oftime. By way of further answer, Plaintiff conferred benefits upon Defendant as
gifts, wherein Plaintiff willingly transferred labor, money and/or property to Defendant without
payment and with no thought of any possible financial benefit to the giver, the Plaintiff.
19. Denied. By way of further answer, there is outstanding discovery responses to
Defendant's Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents directed to Plaintiffwherein
additional facts will be produced to support Defendant's Answer in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion
for Summary Judgment.
20. Denied. By way of further answer, there is outstanding discovery responses to
Defendant's Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents directed to Plaintiff wherein
4
~ '-" _ .."'~~ ~" rJOii" . ~ ..
1_. = '~', Jli1J
'-"- '~ -"" i''1'~i!l Y:.iIi<-~"4.\Wns't~:
additional facts will be produced to support Defendant's Answer in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion
for Summary Judgment.
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Patricia Sterling, respectfully requests that this Honorable
Court deny Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment.
Respectfully submitted,
TUCKERARE BERG & SWARTZ
1/)J,~
By:
Jam s G. Morgan, .,
A eyI.D.#16897
Dated:
r~_or
orth Front Street
P.O ox 889
Hamsburg,PA 17108-0889
(717) 234-4121
Attorneys for Defendant
47628.1
5
,
-'._._-'.~~'~><~~~
~ ,
~ 1- 11i -I'~"li~ .~.. ~gjj_';"-,- ' 0' -~'c;' . h l'tiUr%:~
VERIFICATION
I, Patricia J. Sterling, verifY that the facts stated in the foregoing document are true and
correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief,
I understand that any false statements made to this verification are subject to the penalties
of 18 Pa. C.S.A. ~4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
~~QA~
atricia J. Sterling{/'
46280.1
'Iii
,--,~ ,,.. ~ ._,.~ "
,.~..J__j~ - ....~,l_]I. ._:.~-,'.;. li;i(j;~titi,JJ!'!it,-
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
AND NOW, this I.tIItJ day of February, 2002, Cathleen A. Kohr, for the firm of
TUCKER ARENSBERG& SWARTZ, attorneys for Defendant, hereby certifY that I have this
day served the within DEFENDANT'S REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
by depositing a copy of the same in the United States Mail, first class, postage prepaid, at
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, addressed as follows:
Albert No Peterlin, Esquire
GATES & ASSOCIATES, PoCo
1013 Mumma Road
Suite 100
Lemoyne, P A 17043
6~ If. /{~
CATHLEEN A. KOHR
6
g
,_~~~,.K '~~'[aIiiM,i,~~l~w~~~-,,:l;~,,-,kJ'frM\"}'h~:;._>n.'.b;"~-'">'.''' ,-,..,'j'~bM~Jm,,-,,--,MiJli.;.1Bj,t' ""-"'~'a.Iii!~ill.lf" ~,~
"'~
,
I
,
i
,
,
i
!
(') C)
C ij"'~)
s: ~
-OQ:J ~ -'
flIP, -~
Z:J:, I
~S __I
-<~.::
CL} -0
~o :x ; .'
M-Ci r:~ ~~;'
)>c
:z: 't>
-oj =:0
-<. '0 .-<
.f:<("
eJ/
~"'--'~, ",'
~~~,
~_~ ~ ,. ___A
,.~
~ -, .....
,^,,,'""',,"," .
~''-'--u:!l~~&<;Ui
'I'
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JACOB R. SHANK a1k1a PETE
SHANK, an individnal,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
Plaintiff,
vs.
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant.
PRAECIPE TO LIST CASE FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
TO TI:IE PROlliONOTARY:
Please list the within matter for the next Argument Court,
1, The matter to be argued is the Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment.
2, Names and addresses of all attorneys who will argue the case:
(a) Plaintiff(s): Albert N, Peterlin, Esquire, Gates, Halbruner & Hatch, p,c., 1013
Mumma Road, Suite 100, Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043,
(b) Defendant(s): James G, Morgan, Jr" Esquire, Tucker Arensburg & Swartz, 111
North Front Street, P,O. Box 889, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17108-0889,
3, Within two (2) days, I will notifY all parties that tins case has been listed for
argument.
4,
Argument Court Date: July 24, 2002
Respectfully submitted,
GATES, HALBRUNER & HATCH, P,C.
f~
Attorney I.D. #84180
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100
Lemoyne, P A 17043
(717) 731-9600
(Attorney for Plaintiff)
Dated: June 28, 2002
~" ~~ ~.
"~I
I..at.
, .L' - ~~~ ~)lik\\i"'~\lr'..'
..." " .~
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Albert N, Peterlin, Esquire, hereby certifY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing
Praecipe to List Case for Oral Argument, has been served upon the following counsel of record
by first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
James G. Morgan, Jr.
TUCKER ARENSBERG & SWARTZ
III North Front Street
P,O, Box 889
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0889
GATES, HALBRUNER & HATCH, P.C.
ct4:~I' ~
Albert . Peter m, squIre
Attorney for the Plaintiff
DATED: June 28, 2002
ok?
~4\~:M:J1~~$~E~j!j.!k~.r~..-.;?1J."......d~....%;U:.....i~i;..i;ioi_@wr.Q...ii~)i.;\~lh>ii~___ilWlii1ll~I~I~.ai
'-'~,,,
," -~,
~
~..
~k _,.,,",,<,>'<,""',,",_. h ..,~r__. ,..
'-, ,~ '-' "-^,,,
-'."~~' ,..,,-- ',~
,
"
~. ,."
".-"",,"-'
o
c:
<
~t~
.-cc
~<
~C;
)I:( ..
~:~~;
:::~
-<
tis
&1/
.'
-..
C)
f'-..)
o
-1'1
-
~
~=
-"
r
-,,,,in
~6
.-~ -r)
'~~~; ,~~
;o~.:in
'.:..--=1
'''c.
::0
-<
\7
.::....;.
;....)
,
, ~' ~
, I
~, ~ -, ," ,,-.;,"';'~,~'"":';: ;",., '-'~>"t:t!i!t'_ i-~~:,\
JACOB R. SHANK aIkIa PETE
SHANK, an individual,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
01-6530 CIVIL
VS,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant
IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
BEFORE HOFFER. PJ.. HESS AND OLER, JJ.
ORDER
AND NOW, this Z)~ day of July, 2002, following argument thereon, the motion
of the plaintiff for summary judgment is DENIED.
BY THE COURT,
/Albert N. Petelin, Esquire
For the Plaintiff
/ L;;:a~
T1J
/James G. Morgan, Jr., Esquire
For the Defendant
:rlm
.0
"~~
...-,--~ , '
~,.- ~
'.'-<':,"0"0
0',= r)-
"i);i\~N
h9
:s3
r~ '1 II'
U;::. ~~ .,L
2E
["rlln~ S3
CUlviBc.t;I",.\. l.'/L)t;NTY
DEI' 'N!,'vL'\f!\ 1\;',,"
I \I. \): .(" ,I
""~ --
, -~.
~'iIM ~,~!~~11 .,.1~M~~~~!';~f.1J'\,;-W'f><!tn~';!f"''iJi?~~r~~:r,~!iw~m;~~
. ~ .~
J~li!t!PliIii~"-'
',,,.-,,,
1~~~Mm&"'"
'., . '/
i)
JUL 0 9 2002 \Y
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
JACOB R. SHANK alkla PETE
SHANK, an individual,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-6530 CIVIL
Plaintiff,
vs,
PATRICIA J. STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant,
ORDER
AND NOW, this
day of
, 2002, upon
consideration of Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment, it is hereby ORDERED and
IDECREED that said motion is GRANTED and that judgment is hereby entered in favor of
I!laintiff and against Defendant in the amount of Eighteen Thousand Forty and 89/1 00
($18,040,89) Dollars. Further, pursuant to C,C,R,P, 206-6 and Pa,R.C,P, 236(a), notice of
judgment shall be made upon Defendant, Patricia J, Sterling and counsel for Defendant, James G,
Morgan, Jr., Esquire,
BY THE COURT:
1.
~:l:",;';:;it:V};:-:i~'f'->.; ~"t;>h
"C',
.
~~
~~
I~~,-,,-~
~~y-'~~'"
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
JACOB R. SHANK a1k1a PETE
SHANK, an individual,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO, 01-6530 CIVIL
Plaintiff,
vs.
PATRICIA J, STERLING,
an individual,
Defendant,
PLAINTIFF'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF HIS
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
AND NOW, comes the Plaintiff, Jacob R. Shank a!k/a Pete Shank (bereinafter referred to as
"Shank"), by and through his counsel, Gates, Halbruner & Hatch, P,C" and respectfully files this Brief in
Opposition to Plaintiff's Third Set of Preliminary Objections:
I. STATEMENT OF FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
Beginning in November, 1999 and continuing through July, 200 I, Shank provided
numerous services to Defendant, including, but not limited to, the provision of certain labor and materials
regarding the upkeep, maintenance and improvements to Defendant's personal residence and Defendant's
rental property, (Complaint p,l) Shank expended seventeen thousand nineteen and 71/100 ($17,019,71)
dollars in materials and labor regarding the provision of certain services to Defendant in the above
referenced period oftitne, (Complaint p,I-3) Defendant admits to the receipt of the services, including all
labor and materials, (Defendant's Answer with New Matter p, 1-3 & 5) In September, 2001, Shank
demanded Defendant repay Shank for the cost of the above-referenced materials and labor incurred,
(Complaint p, 4) To date, Defendant has not repaid or compensated Shank in any way,
Shank instituted the present action by filing a Complaint on November 19, 2001. Defendant filed
an Answer with New Matter on December 13, 2001, Shank filed an Answer to Defendant's Answer with
New Matter on December 20,2001. Thereafter, Plaintiff propounded, inter alia, Interrogatories and
-
~~-. ~-
,
-I..~ '
<.- ,~> '&:,,-~' l'h@'j~l%iR,
Requests for Admissions upon Defendant. Defendant provided timely responses thereto, On February 8,
2002, Plaintiff filed this Motion for Summary Judgment regarding Count II, Unjust Enrichment of the
Complaint.
II. STATEMENT OF OUESTIONS PRESENTED
SHOULD SUMMARY JUDGMENT BE GRANTED REGARDING SHANK'S UNJUST
ENRICHMENT COUNT WHERE DEFENDANT HAS ADMITTED RECEIVING
SIGNIFICANT SERVICES FROM SHANK,
(Suggested Answer: Yes)
III. ARGUMENT
Summary judgment should be entered regarding Shank's Unjust Enrichment Count and against
Defendant as a result of the Defendant's total admission regarding the receipt of significant services from
Shank tlmt include over seventeen thousand and 00/1 00 ($17,000,00) dollars in materials and labor.
It is hornbook law that summary judgment is properly granted where there is no genuine issue of
any material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter oflaw, Barter v, Southmoore
Golf Course Associates, L,P" 48 Pa, D, & C. 4th 206, 210 (1999), See also; Biganskv v, Thomsa
Jefferson Universitv Hospital, 442 Pa. Super. 69, 73, 658 A,2d 423,425 (1995), appeal denied, 542 Pa,
655,668 A.2d 1119 (1995), Summary judgment may be granted only where the right is clear and free
from doubt. Barter, 48 Pa, D, & C, 4th at 210, "The record must be viewed in the light most favorable to
the non-moving party, and all doubt as to the existence of a genuine issue of material fact must be resolved
against the moving party," Id" at 210, fili!lg Ertel v. Patriot-News Co" 544 Pa, 93, 98-99, 674 A.2d
1038, 1041 (1996), The record includes, inter alia, the pleadings, affidavits, answers to interrogatories and
admissions on file, Salvino Steel & Iron Works, Inc, v, Fletcher & Sons, mc" 398 Pa, Super. 86, 90, 580
A.2d 853, 855 (1990),
In order to establish a claim for Unjust Enrichment, the following elements must be shown: (1) that
a benefit was conferred upon the offending party; (2) the offending party appreciated or knew of the
2
MoL;
.01
, ..<.("''''"''t~.l!b..
.a-ttm~.;w;;}:);,'\;",-+-
"
benefits provided; and (3) the acceptance and retention of the benefit by the offending party would be
inequitable without the payment of value to the provider, See, Correll v, Millville Area School District,
662 A.2d 696, 701 (1995); and Stver v, Hugo, 422 Pa,Super. 262, 268, 619 A.2d 347,350 (1993), The
most significant element of the doctrine of unjust enrichment is whether or not the acceptance and retention
of the benefit by the offending party is unjust to the provider, Styer, 422 Pa,Super at 268,619 A.2d at
350, In order to establish that it would be unjust for the offending party to retain the received benefit, it
must be shown that the offending party wrongfully secured or passively received a benefit that it would be
unconscionable for the offending party to retain, Stone & Edwards Insurance kencv, Inc, v, Stumof, 31
Pa, D, & C, 4th 462,473 (1996),
In the instant case, Defendant admits that Shank conferred a benefit upon her (Answer p, 5, , 32)
Defendant further admits that Defendant appreciated the benefits provided by Shank, (Answer p, 5, , 33)
Defendant further admits that Defendant accepted and retained the benefits provided by Shank, (Answer p,
5, , 34), Finally, Defendant admits to the receipt of services, including labor and materials, (Answer pp,
1-3, , 4-20) I Defendant specifically admits to the receipt of services from Shank, (Answer pp. 2-3, , 7,
9, 10, 12, 13, 16, 18 - 20) The term "services" is defined by Blacks Law Dictionary as follows: "Things
purchased by consumers that do not have physical characteristics (e,g, services of doctors, lawyers,
dentists, repair personnel)," Black's Law Dictionary 1369 (6th ed, 1990), (Emphasis added), A "service"
is, by definition, not gratuitous, As a result of Defendant's admission that she received the aforementioned
services, that included significant labor and materials, it is patently inequitable for Defendant to retain over
seventeen thousand and 00/100 ($17,000,00) dollars worth of services provided to her by Shank, As a
IDefendant's statement that she is without knowledge or information has the effect of an admission
pursuant to Pa.R. C,P, 1 029( c) where the means of information are not within the exclusive control of Shank, See;
Cercone v, Cercone, 254 Pa,Super, 381, 386 A.2d 1 (1978); and First Wis. Trust Co, v, Strausser, 439 Pa,Super,
192, 199,653 A.2d 688,692 (1995), Defendant's substantial admissions made pursuant to the Request for
Admissions of the Plaintiff Addressed to the Defendant testify to the fact that the information was not within the
exclusive control of Shank, See Exhibit "A" and "B,"
3
;,
~'~I
--.
~-,' .-.' "t};'-W~'iD~;";,;T~
"
result of the foregoing, Defendant has admitted each and every element of Shank's U~ust Enriclunent
claim,
There is no genuine issue of material fact and Shank is entitled to judgment as a matter of law
where Defendant has admitted each and every element of the U~ust Enriclunent claim brought against her,
IV. CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, the Court should grant Shank's Motion for Summary Judgment and
enter judgment against Defendant, Patricia J, Sterling,
Respectfully submitted
GATES, HALBRUNER & HATCH, p,c.
iflbJ ~~
Albert N. Peterlin, squire
Attorney I,D. No. 84180
1013 Mumma Road, Suite 100
Lemoyne, PA 17043
(717) 731-9600
(Attorneys for Plaintiff)
DATED, 7/i~
4
~,
-- "
.
'" ",.!J~'i''''''''"~".'~"'''.l!Il ----. J--'''''- ~.l- -'i -'".l~%lilu.~~-iW/'
.-' .',
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Albert N. Peterlin, Esquire, hereby certifY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing
Plaintiff's Brief in Support ofRis Motion for Summary Judgment, has been served, on this day,
upon the following counsel of record by first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
James G. Morgan, Jr.
TUCKER ARENSBERG & SWARTZ
III North Front Street
P.O. Box 889
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0889
GATES, HALBRUNER & HATCH, P.C.
~~/lJ/11frv
Attorney for Debtors
DATED: 7/o/rf'v-
.
-"_.=~- ~
~~ ~- .~
,..
.' ,-
J.._... ._..
~ ' ~ '
"~Mif~j>,_"
SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR
CASE NO: 2001-06530 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
SHANK JACOB R A/K/A PETE SHANK
VS
STERLING PATRICIA J
CPL TIMOTHY REITZ
, Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law,
says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE
was served upon
STERLING PATRICIA J
the
DEFENDANT
, at 1920:00 HOURS, on the 20th day of November, 2001
at 504 WALTON CIRCLE
LEMOYNE, PA 17043
by handing to
PATRICIA J STERLING
a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE
together with
and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Service
Affidavit
Surcharge
18.00
11.05
.00
10.00
.00
39.05
So Answers:
r~~~
R. Thomas Kline
11/21/2001
GATES & ASSOC
me this
J. 9 (j.
day of
Sworn and Subscribed to before By:
~ d/ff)! A.D.
~Q~ -
P othonotary . ~
-- ..- .~ .h....~_
}
JACOB R. SHANK alk/a PETE )
SHANK, )
an individual, )
Plaintiff
v. )
PATRICIA J. STERLING, an individual )
Defendant \
OATH
.., "J-C__"_~ &"-.I!QiI~lt-<il~~~~.,l&li'~-
III The Court of COIIIIlOIl ,leu of
CuIIlhedud COUllty. 'ell1laylvallia
No. 01-6~0'
19
We do 801elllllly near (or .ffin) that ve will 8upport. obey alld defelld
the Con8UtuUoll of tbe UDited States aDd tbe Co1l8t1tutloll of th18 ColIIl!IoIl-
vea1tb and that ve vi11 discharge tbe duties of our office vi h fidelity.
AWARD
We. the unde:tsi8lled arbitrators. having been duly appointed aud SIoI'oru
(or :affirmed). _ke the follOWing award:
(Note: If damages for delay are avarded. they aball be
separately stated.)
VUe: /'lA/I::::, hV F""/9/./oA=' c:7...c=" rff€ ~....vO.-09"/......-_
. Arbitrator, dissents. (Insert name if
a\')pl1cable. )
Date of Bearing: 3--<6'-05
Date of Award: 3-6..-03
en Waltz,
NOTICE OF ENTR.Y OF AWARD
Now. the (y~hday of frl()JGA . t.'9~, at 10.1/, fl..M..
lW&rd was entered upon the docket and notice thereof given by mail
parties or their attorneys.
the above
to the
Arbitrators' compensation
paid upon appeal:
$ :J.90~ (X)
to be
JsI(~ i?~
. L ~7J;
By. /fl ' ~
Deputy
J
~~~___~~.(OO'D.~lI.~!!5'I!:i~i\"~~~ti~fiSfJ~''''"B''<!h'1b'l1i'M~'--!'''P"''',.-,:;;i;"J;"",;2,,.-,,:,i,-&>',,r>it,;~~&il!Wt~iia!~if'.!8l~lli\l~iliUi-l-'l~
~ ~
_J._~. "~~~" =,~ .,. ~
~~,~_ -c.-
~-~'~I~"--'-~=~
0'
;:~
~
'"
~
~
:i~ ~
~ +- ~
~:J .-
."<. ('
~ .:!::> ? ?:
~ ~;-r"p
~~ ~ t
7" '\ ~ ;:?
~\
~
~
;: ~~
~~
~ ~_ ,_ "'~, ~^H'
()
~ C) c:::
~ ~ (...) ()
"""""' 11.:':";'- - ._'~
rt& '''''0..
~;:;J?i 'j'
~ ;il]'_; ::0
<of -;',
S (f)~: - -,-,~!
/ -<"- m
~F _;",' ,--~~l
~.. ':'-.7~~)
?..~-. ::;,.
"+-Z'~. ~."'-. :;'}'.-H
<> j;;;C
C S? ~~5~~
~:;.>'
()~ ~...
< -, J.-:>:
..D - :u
~~
(?Q}\