HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-06873
,J. ";
DEG 11 2001 vo
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
jas h J.., .4 f' fl"<;7 rt
APPELLANT
V
: NO. 0 }~0 913
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF
TRANSPORTATION BUREAU OF
DRIVER LICENSING
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 1J!!.dayof ~f1~ ,2W/, based upon Appellant's Appeal, a hearing
shall be held on t)~ day of !1!) Lu/.,/ /11!1 ,20D;l, in Courtroom ~ at 9: 3(/0' clock~.m.
at the Cumberland County Courthouse.
-/<;~ ,4 J
/
1.
. cljJ
Cr.;;~
,:"'J>;jii!\l>~.;l1{~~ _
~ .,
c.
. -
" '''''___,0 ""~-"~,~"'l'''''''~~
"j;;,tj,iI1!J.';c,l'J",,~~,:,,!jl-i~b,.;,,:,,'" -';';,"'f';h\~:; "i!i{')-c"',dW,,',;E';;,;1:; <;,1),:;l"',)-'i .....;",l<,f",'~" ,."!",~"",,\,.,,,"'j,o<_,,""'j'!'~l.;'~!i!4lI'Wjl~ii~,lliI~~,4jjlill!W~l!l#.Mi14'~lIllL.~~ ""'ilId..........<
~
~~
Ui [H I,~
)>,t,l
/,ll"!
II: I,';'
. .-
',j ::~cuj\JrY'
1'),C'I\JI\"'Vj \ '1,1, 'I'
i- ",.I I _'/r\I\II'\
"
.
"
:"
,
.
,
vs.
:IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
:CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
o 0 C'i }
. -)'1
. ~ 0 .J
-oC?' r"1 ."--1'1
rnd:': C'J lr=:
-~7 ~L 1 " 1 ':Tl
ZC ..--
':Q'!):
r.:; C.:: ~-o
?;() -=-
$C) _
C
Z ,-,"'l
=< \0
FileNo.
J iY ~S h.J';
4 /fY\ "" ?f Appellant
Commonwealth of Pennsyl'./ania
Department of Transportation
Appellee
~~I_:~
, )"O=::
:~,t~ ~A
")
~~~
jj
'<
PETITION FOR APPEAL FROM A SUSPENSION OF OPERATING PRIVILEGE J
DENIAL OF DRIVER'S LICENSE J SUSPENSION OF MOTOR VEHICLE REGISTRATION
1. Appellant herein is J", S k~ ~ A r"" _ 1 t
residing at and having a me,i1ing address of: 14'l C h.<:.-S' ../--""r <;-1:-
c.., r 1,'.5 \ a. P A ] ( n r ~
2. Appellee herein is the Department of Transportation of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania, having a mailing address of:
~ Department of Transportation, Bureau of Driver Licensing, Harrisburg,
Pennsylvania 17123.
Department of Transportation, Bureau of Motor Vehicles, Harrisburg,
Pennsylvania 17123.
3. By letter or notice dated 17 / Lj /0> I
, a copy of which is attached
hereto as Exhibit A, the De!)artment of Transportation
X ordered Appellant to surrender his / her operating license / motor vehicle
registration for a period of _ ( ye q r ,
denied the issuance / renewal of a driver's license.
','ri"~~~~,~ "~'~,"
- ," " 'r,~
~,
_ 0'_
~ <4ll'!1 e, ~ f_~.._",
,
.
4. Supersedeas:
-L Pursuant to 75 Pa.C.S.A. ~ 1550(b)(1 IIi), Appellant is retaining driver's
licenbe until final determination of the suspension of operating privilege.
). Pursuant to 75 Pa.C.S.A. 9 1550(b)(1 )(ii}, a hearing attended by the
Appellant must be held before the Court of Common Pleas before an order of
supe:sedeas can be issued.
:i..- Pursuant to 75 Pa.C.S.A. ~ 1377(a}, Appellant is retaining motor vehicle
regisration until final determination of the suspension of registration.
5. The said suspension of Appellant's operating privileges / registration is
improper or unlawful for the following reasons:
Ne:. .; e r '6+__
T""s-r-. :+ -f-~~K
+Ac..
h ,rc~ rh
Appellant respectfully requests that this matter be set down for a hearing and that
the crder of suspension / order of denial be set aside.
Respectfully submitted by,
~~
/
~
Appellant
-2-
2p.!i'~~'~,L" :;'fAA:"" '
"-
,~ ' ~ 1-
.
, ,-"" ,
~"l .--.._
:~
,{I ,# '",-
.
I verify that the statements made in this Petition are true and correct. I
unde'stand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18
Pa.C, S.A. ~ 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Date 1'"2 / ~ /0 r
rMv//
I'
/hZ~
Appellant
-3-
'"-&t~,~,~. "" _ .:1 ,':'T""""
, 11
l~'
, ,.'"
-~ ~..~"
_~i"'''''''""",'~
:e
'~,
_"e, .
,~, ,<
~-
,-
" ,~", '-"-""'""
~
~)
~
...c
-<:::.
~
"'~, ,~,~~==~
, , ~"'" "" '<u.'","," "'" ...
~
~ 0
~ Gj
Sl....:t:>\)
.t::. ---1 ~
-'''~ ~
~,I
~
~
'"
-C::
U'ia
, .
'6
".JiIW
'~~;;l'!T,~~r'\?o'n;",.)f~--' ~";:p""";",,..
'iiIO:lI~,,~
@'ffij~l~~~~MJW,~""I~'" _
~,Jl?if1:'~_"_"",.
..
,P,":''''
i'''i'~:,')<"v-,,'"~~'%'
o
lJ~~
IT! rT!
L-- _~-'
:?:c
en ,,~,2
-< ~'
r:.:::C:'
"-
,~ "
Z>-~
Sec ',,-
Ys;~
L_
:~
b
")
~
~
"-
'''\--
_" "__,.."w,,
,
~" ";',,;'
C)
CJ
-,1
::::J
r-;'l
C)
I
, I :,~1j
. ~ I
, -'i~~}
, ,
-'-.....,--,
,
-",~ t_ ..'
~=.~r0
""
~
'<
-C)
-,
'J!
-.-J
"~~~;,~~"!":'Hf",'&,, ":""')r?;-';"i"'",,!;:i';,iHi~~~J,~~~~ff~'
FEB-26-2002 TUE 09: 19 PM CARLISLE POLICE DEPT
FAX NO, 2495587
os: 113 PM
; 11~;
"';~~~1pf.J ,,"~"1'-=
.c:t
....... ., .. . "
".~.. . ... .,'~.,
r---~
, ',:: '; Cl'lIl~\;"
'. HnO~lLVZER
: PA MODEL 5000
10/19/81
ALCOHOL A~ALYZ~R
SH 04-01307\;2
TEST ~BAC
pr9;~;,:;r,~~~TlC OK ::'''1'' _,:,;)'" 'JI'
. Villi'!';' i:.HlAHK "'llil'1!l... L',
SUBJECT TEST ,1)1
A lRBUlHK .13l1pa
",SUBJECT TEST !.kP
~,' -- AIR, B\..,AHK .000 l"j'
CAL. CHECK .100
AIR BLANK .0130
,. \0' "~! I'
i,,:hhL 1 SL':
i""'.
I'
I
f-
.
i
i
i
,
,
r~.
, ,'~
:t
.t
.,
! \.
! ;l:
, ~'
!.,~."
.1 ~_'_'h -NQ"R!i'oI,; ,DElE'CTE [I.,.
., . .~, l j.. .' . '..< ,-
r :. ',I, ',,"t T Q:-: 1:' L. \' ';: ::',' '~",.: ..~" c1 ;,. ",. . ,I,',' ) I.,.
,.~, ' 1
-;" ~ ;:'. ~"\ ~: ,::', ~3 (; ~ ...'
f
TIME
01!1lS';l
, 131: 00
1:11:03
131:03
01:06
01~0G
01 :06
01 :'07,
* DEFICIEHT SAMPLE - VALUE
PRINTED ~AS HIGHEST'08T~lHED.
l V ,/ i ',~(
) ,~ ',~.
! ~ .
~, . ...
,,"I') i;'","';;"
, , r i ~
'I"~
p, 02
I
i
J
i,
i
!
"1
!
....,1
'.'1
'.... ,
......,
i
i
i
1- .
I
I
I
!
,
'~ ".ti
j",.,'"
",/,""
';'-'
'--'--T,"~:': .
',,\,
~ .";; j \, "
\ ~ '
,
/~' :': tl':":" 'Ii', '
CUM~ERIlANO COUNTY CENTRAL PROCESSING
,,~','. "";:.~:-77':;;f'rt~;,t"~---<--">":~'
":'/
j
.._-,
, '
, ,-.,
Commonwealth's
EXHIBIT
~~ _; ;;::;'::;'~'",'c.,;
*.{
r,'~: ::':-.
"._ Li
,:c'"
/).,
;'~ .
. "
, ~ :':': '~>''1.
,;,.-:"'r"
':--,.,'. .!', 'if;'
r
I' .. ,~
r ~ ~"",~,,~~
"""Ir..r.
1,/,
,~ -
~ ~ ,=.~""f ",'"U~,~~ _~""
Ot,...26 ('l'-Ml
'@
CHEMICAL TESTING WARNINGS AND REPORT OF
REFUSAL TO SUBMIT TO CHEMICAL TESTING AS ..
AUTHORIZED BY OF THE VEHICLE CODE
1....
SECTION 1547
flAME
FI~ \
_:'Os. Y1UA
ADDl'IESS
<Ai\. M.;;, H-
ZIP CODE
~ <6
c.y,e s.--h:.'<t
'S\
DRIVER NUMBER.,
STATE
,JS
19<E; ~~"t
LJ
l._ ,rl,
,~...' );,
~.
SEX
DATE OF ~IRTH
"al s; ry~
M
CITY
STATE
~\l~\~
A \1~I::J.
SOCIAL SECURITY HUMSER
l>t
t~
I SECTION 1547 ~ CHEMICAL TESTING WARNINGS
,. _ Please be advj~ that you al'l now under arrest for drivin ,under. the influence of alcohol or a controlled sUbstance pursuant to ,section 3731 of
<z.~;:::;;:~at ~u !"'b;n!~toa <:i1emicall9,.tol __, _' ','..',,' .' , ,.\~. ,.,' ,', (~~~a~h.blood or urina. Offlc.a.~~h~~.a.thachamical ta.1.)
3. Ii ill ';;'I'~';;'\Y. as a poIic~ officer. to inio';;;'yliulhat if yoU ",jii.'lo'submiflii th.ch..,,;i.... lesl yout operatinll privilegewi/(t;.., SUspended, fo~ ,a
period of Dna yor.
4. a) The constitutional rights you have as acriminal defendant commonly known as .the Miranda Rights, includi~,th8 right to, speak, with a lawyer and
the right to remain silent. apply only to crimillat prose,~lions and do not apply to ,the chemical testing procedure' undftr Peonsytvpl)ia's Implied
Coosent Law, which is a civil, not a criminal proceediiig. '
b) You hava no righlto Speak to a lawyer. or,anyone else.b8~ore la!<ing the chemicalle>l requesled by, I!>e,poijce, of~cerllor do ,Y9uhav. a righlto
remain silent when ask8d,by the police officer to submit ,to the chemical test. Unle,$$ YO,,! ~g,ee' t9 subll'utto~. test requested'by the, police, officer
, your conduct will be deemed to b. refusal and'your operating ,privijege 'will be suspended' for one'year." "
c) Your',.'usal to subrnU to chemical testing under the Implied, Consent Law may be introduced into evidence, in a criminal prosecution for driving
while under the influence 0' alcohol Of a controlled substancs;
-
1. Tho above motorist was placed under arrest for driving under the influence of alcohol or a controlled su~stance in violation of Section 3731 of the
Vehicle Code, and there were reasonable grounds to believe that the ,above motorist had been driving, operating or in actual physical control of
the movement of a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or a controlled substance or both.
or
That the above named motorist was involved in an accident in which the operator or passenger of any vehicle involved or a pedestrian required
treatment at a medical facility or was killed.
2. The above motorist was l'Iquested to submit to chemical testing as authorized by Section 1.547 of the V8:~icle Code.
3. The above motorist was informed by a police officer of the chemical test warnings contained in paragraph 3 and 4 above,
4~ 1'he above named motorist refused to submit lo chemical tesling.
Om~R NOTE: ne refusal to sign this form is not a refusal to submit to the chemical test. You mlUi,t, stitt give the motorist an opportu-
nity to, 'tako1be ch~ical te$t after reviewing thhJ form. If the indi,vidual was operaUng a comrn",cial :"',Q , ehicle while having any
alcohol or a controlled substance in their system. you must also complete the rever$e side 'is for ~. I
\ 1*.;n~d)
f\<C>HI2-~
. certify that I have read the BhQ,ve waming to ,the mota'
nity tel submit to chemical testing.
Signature of 0 teer.
I havu been advised of the above.
Signature of Motorist
Motolist'refused to sign, after being advised.
Signature of Officer:
SUBSCRIBED AND SWOf\N
. TO BEFORE ME:
I=orward 10: Member.pennsyIYaniaAssoclationotN01arle8
Departmenl of Transportation
Bureau of Driver licensing
P.O. Box 60037
Harrisburg. P A 17106.0037
THIS FORM MAY BE DUPLICATED
e suspension oOheir operating privilege .nd gave the rnotorist an opport-u-
";11 7'-;;'<; Dale' t'\::)"'\'l'~b\
/0'1/1 /0 /
Date:
Date:
AFADAVIT
Officer Signature:
Officer Name:
\\A\I\ J ~
ITypo Of Print)
Badge Number:
Phone: /711 )
JUrisdiC"On:C p.( \,~ \c.. ~.lJ.
,;n ~,;l S-
..) tt'O r S-~S do,
Mailing Addreos $':::' ~' ~'-'.fD1,
CA.r\l~~(.. ,.., \l013
-::.7
".,
Commonwealth's'
EXHIBIT
Note: Any pertinent facts not covered by the affidavit should be submitted on a
ate sheet and aUached hereto. That sheet should include the names of
nal witnesses necessary to prove the elerriemts to which you have attested.
SUPPLIES Of THIS fORM MAY BE SECURED BY COMPLETING FORM OS-511A
I
""~~~~", ~ ,~,~-",,,,",,,,,'-"'~, ' ,pn
I _:c
m ~~~~~!'!'~'"!'!l1~~'m~11 i1I!!111!'111i1F!1rm;111 ,
--~"
~,
-
~.~
,~- ~~~
, ~,
'-
~~~,",," ,~>"" "~"",~",,,,'~~">-,"-"'~"" '.;;""~,'c",,~'''''~'''''N''_.''~" '_
, '~""~";;'>, .<,';;',",,,"<,
AUG-19-2001 SUN 02: 50 AM CUMB CTY CENTRAL PROC,
FAX NO, 7172405331
p, 01/01
Ct..zaP''';
G)
CHEMICAL TESTlN.G WARNINGS AND REPORT OF
REFUSAL TO CHEMICAL U:STlNG AS
AUTliORIZED BY OF THE VEHICLE CODE
(CaMMERCiAL MOl1oRVSHICL~)
/lAIIE
FlIlsf
MIDDlE
LAST
$Ill IlA1~:,0l'1I1I1TH
IlCII y 15M
ADDRESS
CITY
STATE ZlPCOOI!
OfllV~R'NU"BER
SlATE
,~~0A1.
SOCIA~llE~"I~;J!lII".~'
Cil'; ~$ri'll!fOIlU 'jo'.tiliiiiii !'lIis'ol "'I"~6i(lltl"..; , '" " , "
2. It,l., my, duty. .. a poIIeo olfleor, III Inform l....,I~alslno. you...... oporatinv I CMV, Kyou f1l/!Il;. 10 .ubmilllllile~omlcallas~)'our ICClIIllll8Rlal
dtIll1ngprilillege will be dtaqualiOod fO;1 mInImum j>t!riodofone r.at. '~'" ." ',' ";",,':,' '" '
3. 01 ThO CII1.dlulionol n;h18)'ou h.,.... 1.1 ~lmlnil dafan~I. _nionirlulown a.Ih.~~RIQhIl. induh\he rigbl 10 .poak willi ~ I,'li)'er and
1hIi, rl9hllO re",aln .lhlntlpfil1lirilricl'OItmflli!lproSB.udoris ..d~ lliI,IIJ1P1YIll",* c,~llIlcalo\O'I!nJl'~~!J!!~erPoM.~Il."lmp'od
Coii..1l1 \.aIW, Whlch,l.acivU,~Ola1lrlmill.t/lllMl8l1Clillg. ,.:,',. . .' ,.,' , ".:., ".,' " " ,', ',.", ','
bl You haWl no rig"I 1O.p.a~ III a ,Iayw~qia~ione,.~. "'Iora l8Idnalli'e ~iOal'~.f~~.,ioyll"j~ otfoCllr nOt do you blilulfv/1l 10
rom.ln.ll.nl wtlan a.1ced bylht pol~ol1f""rlo Iubm~iv 1M chemloalii.L iIJjrlf""pU.\(I\lU!ImtllOiIMi'lIJlreqUlltodbylhe poUoe,011tcer
yourCOllducl,wlIIbe deerilod Iob.rorUl"'IId)'Our_merdaldriyfnOPd.go."ilISqilI.~filtOllllr-. , , . "
e) Your raluil' ,10 fUbmll lodlomlo..l ....di\9'.ildel'\". ImpR,d co...nt laWm.; b.,1ri!tti.......lil.... evtde/leoln . criminal prae_on lor ,dr;Mn;
whiJo undor 1I\01n".0...01 aJ<:o"ol oracol\llllllod i.,"'lanOl. "
I oorlily "'all haw ....d i/1O abow walnlnv 10 lheinoloii.llIgllldlnll'~ ilii~nGalfOn 01111"" comrile,doldriWog prM!eOO....gayo Ibe motorisl
an opportunity \0 oublllll 10 ohemleal le_Ung.
Slgnalu,o 01 Officer: Dalo:
I h.ve baan ad>isod oIlho above.
Signature of MalOn.': DalO:
Molori.I rel...d'lo .Ign, .'i" boln; IdvllOd.
SlgnllulD olOllleor: Dolo:
AFFIDf<V1T
I. The aboYl'molori.1 ""'. slOppod by a poKea offtcer who, illor slOpplng Ih. mol.rioL had 1I..0nable ground. III bofi.Yllhe molorl.' had boon
dtIvln; . CC>1ll",orcia' mol<>r vehlclo whBe haYIng anr "coholln hll Il'.,e",.
2. The oboyo' molori.. w., noque.led 10 .ubmlllo chomi.., toiling as authorized b)' Seelion 16 t 3 01 tho V'hlcle Cocll.
3. The .boye: mOlori,1 WI' Inlormod by I pollc. 'olroeor 0/111. cl\Qmloell..I wamlng. ..nlll..d in paragraph 2 and 3 abovo.
4, The abav. namod molorl$l rolvsed 10 .ubmllla cbemicallo.llng.
9FFICI!II NotEI The r,'ulIllO .'gn lhl.lormI. ilal," reru..11O lubmll '" 1M choml,oall,.L rou m.ez .1l!1 glYelhe molOlltl.n opp~'unl" 10111I. Ih.
chemical tnl.n.r ro.lilwl'.i &hI, /atm.""'. Ind'vldll.I""tft,'~!I"".'."'.1 totl!~d"lll oo"""..olll molor vehlol.""nounl.."", InnIM_
olllcobol Ir ~ oonlroll.d IUb.lln.. punlilnl108iodon ~73fil11iil"lilIIdt'e"', fOU....illl.nampl.I.'he re..... .!d. 01 \!Il,,~
IIIIS~Ai$ED_ SWORN Ollle... Signalvre:
TO IEFO~E ~E: 110. DAY YEAII
~
~
I
I)
z
OIfJcer Nama:
Sadgo Number.
. .:';' ~: ':',' " ."': . ~-,
""n$<lI"'1<>''''".. '. '
....... ',~ ,.~\'.<~' :-;~.
:(~~-"'~~\
, ~.'
Phon.:L........J
..:;".<<>:"'.'
;} I..., .',
.' -:'
,
Maillot Add....
ADDmOI'lAL INFORMATION IF NOT TNS sAloIE OfFICER WHO WITNESSED TNE!JtE'FlJSAL:
Name or ArresU.g OWee,:
...ddte&& or AIl..Ung C!.ioo,:
P~o.. Numbar 01 Allo$UII9 Officer L-) _
II '1'.., nom, of cU$ladlon
Neme ancl.ddr6S$ orniodlcal faeUntll bloodWI$ ",que_lOd:
- ,-. - " t.__.; i
.~~.::<f'~:{~,;;:;~>~
I. lhere . Video!<lpe? (Ve. or No,
and pkono number ( -,--)
1~1l!!ID!l!!!Ifj~;;;';;;;~"";~1't.-.,m.~"'fj-~'~'1~("'~~':!!!Il"'FrW~~~'I1~"'~~~!/11\ijj\};~,..;"","lrh':,':"j;""<'"
-"-":,""-:'''-:;;'
'~,
"'" r
JOSHUA ARMOL T,
Appellant
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL V ANlA
vs.
01-6873 CIVIL
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
COMMONWEALTH OF PA.,
DEPT. OF TRANSPORTATION,
BUREAU OF DRIVER
LICENSING,
Appellee
LICENSE SUSPENSION APPEAL
IN RE: APPEAL FROM SUSPENSION OF OPERATING PRIVILEGES
ORDER
AND NOW, this
'1- > day of March, 2002, the court fmding that the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Transportation having met its burden of proof
with evidence that, despite reasonable and sufficient opportunity, the licensee failed to supply an
adequate second breath sample, the within appeal from suspension of driver's license is DENIED
and the Department is authorized to reinstate its suspension. See Todd v. Com.. Dent. of
Transn" Bureau of Driver Licensing, 723 A.2d 655 (pa. 1999).
BY THE COURT,
4J
)6shua Annolt, Pro Se
148 Chester Street
Carlisle, P A 17013
~rge Kabusk, Esquire
For PennDOT
) ["Piw JD~
03-07-0; l f\Xs
:rlm
')'i; J,HF:.Dt" , "w', ""'''~;'''','',~~'''"", ' , ,
'<, ", "~".. ,,,, .
<, ~
~ <,
-
'~lA'-i~>>i'fllrl!il1;L\l!!~~..l~M~~.~~j(;~-&410~..J:"',~~"'i~'6.foi~'l..'W~&~~~~lnli(1li.~'~ill' ';";'~~li1;!I{~lli !iJ.
11':;)
[;;:1
i~~:,~JJ,;, _,,'. r ~J[l!!)~,J':Nt~JA~(L 'J;,_,
,~~,o"
.''",;'~'''~
:1"',',__"<""'1._""'.
..I:
n>1JffiGc. ~., '
"i' :-",'-":'TU("I,,:Q If-\Rt
0:=
O"} Mil!:! -1
! L.. \ ir" ~ .
r,,' 2'?'
}- t'l . ~
, I i ~ "
CU' E:,>'r\"",!'u',iqu'-' COUNT{
'N;[)' ;, ~
'PENNSYLVI\NiA
_r.",'.',...""
,,,",
-ill_ -~"'~_.~
""'JliL