HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-00435
6. Dcnicd. At no limc did thc scopc ofthc work which thc PlaintilTwus to pcrform
changc and strict proof thcrcof is dcmandcd at trial.
7. Admittcd in part. It is admittcd that tlml which is attachcd thc Plaintiff's
Complaint as Exhibit "B" was scntto thc PlaintifT on or about Novcmbcr 23.
/998. To thc cxtcnt that thc documcnts spcaks for itsclf, any attcmptto intcrrupt
or chaructcrizc same is spccifically denicd and strict proof thcrcof is demunded at
trial.
COUNT I
BREACH OF CONTRACT
8. No responsive plcading is required,
9, Denicd. It is specifically denied that the Plaintiff renovated the Defendant's home.
The Defendant agreed to pay thc Plaintiff for time and materials required to dry
wall two rooms in her home at a cost 01'$3,000.00.
10. Denied. It is specifically dcnied that that set forth in Exhibit "B" was a final bill in
that the Plaintiff accepted final payment on or about November 4, I 998 in the
amount 01'$569,04,
II, Denied, The averments contained in paragraph eleven (II) are conclusions of
law to which no rcsponsive plcading is requircd.
12. Admitted.
WHEREFORE, thc Dcfcndant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court entcr
judgment in her favor and againslthe Plaintiff.
NEW MATTER
13. In or about July 1998, the Plaintiff submitted a bid to dry wall two rooms of the
Defendant's home at a cost of$3,000.00.
14. At the Defendant's request, the Plaintiff reduced his bid to writing so that it could
be submitted to the Defendant's lender.
15. When the Plaintiff submitted that which is attached to Plaintift"s Complaint as
Exhibit "A" to the Defendant, the Defendant questioned the discrepancy between
the $3,000.00 oral estimate she had received and the $5,000.00 quote set forth in
said document.
16, The Plaintiff replied to the Defendant's inquiry as set forth in paragraph fifteen
above by stating this was a "high number" quoted for the purpose of submitting
the proposal to Defendant's lender.
17. Upon receiving the Plaintiffs second billing bringing his total charge to
$5,317.72, the Defendant complained about the billings had now exceeded the
Plaintiffs original estimate,
18, The Plaintiff responded to the Defendant's inquiry as set forth above by stating
that the remaining charge to be complete the project would be approximately
$500.00,
19. The Defendant authorized the completion of the project provided that would not
exceed $500.00 in additional costs bringing the total project cost to $5,817.72.
defendant had cxpandcd thc scopc of thc work to include finishing a bay window and installing
duct work for air conditioning as well as framing for a ncw front door.
16.
Thc avcnnents of fact contained in paragraph sixteen (16) are specifically denied. The
defendant kncw that the work she requested would be on a time and material basis. The estimate
was preparcd in order for hcr to be able to borrow the estimated cost of the work she wanted
perfonned at that time.
17.
The avennents offact contained in paragraph seventeen (17) of the New Matter are
admitted.
18.
The avennents of fact contained in paragraph eighteen (18) of the New Matter are
admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that the plaintiff did give her an estimate of
approximately Five Hundred and no/I 00 ($500.00) Dollars. It is denied that the estimate of Five
Hundred and no/IOO ($500.00) Dollars was from the last billing. In fact, there were materials
and timc for which the defendant had not yct been billed when the additional Five Hundred and
no/I 00 ($500,00) Dollar estimate was givcn,
19,
The avcnnents of fact contained in paragraph nineteen (19) of the New Matter are denied.
On the contrary, the plaintiff did submit a final bill consisting of his actual Five Hundred and
no/lOO ($500.00) Dollars which he had estimated would be required to complete the project.
2
>- f
~ ...::1' i'::
>-" lr;
UJQ (.;.) ~f
PC': --d ~
grE ct 9
f? ,:i:!0! r..:::. ~
we..:. <x, --.j
-' .~1~;: B I:'
CC~U 0:: --......
f~f;' (',.._.-
..,~. ,.iJr5 ~
rs :c" ~.9(.L
m ~ ~J
en :i ~ ~
u ~
VI'l\:'/!'\1r:J;"'~~ r.:.:d
) \', 1"'"r' r'\ (" ,r" I...~~' \"-,,......
.J...\\~\ \U. I ,-~"/',' ':.::;:'~:t';i \..J
('>(' 'II' (' -, '.I'" \ cr
OV:S ,\d l..G (l~~:-1 bO
i\rN1!O,'("'I' ,"'I '0
'I 'J~.l \ ,..", ~...i I ...
" I ,.,_'-'.~..,J ~.l u.. ...
381:l~O-o31\~
'-61'
LID SaJ!dxa UO!SSIWWOO ^W
f8,/:J!JJOJO 11/1!./.
i1pnw.fl1M I./;ll'P!/I'! WO/IM tlJOjoq 1l!!:J!IIO }O amll1U6/S
Will/If} JO .1JnJI.'lIlilS
'-61' :10 Alia SIHl
3V\J 3~O~3S 03UIU:Jssns ONII (03V\J~J1~~II) N~OMS
(pOJOI,!nOJ) (f'O!!!I'O') Aq '[) O.!MO' l"uoSJod Aq 0 '--61'
CJI, (s)aalladde aliI uodn ItHJdtlV JO DJPON afloqc nLli fiu!Awl<luJOJJp. lU!CICIUJo:J r.
'01:)104 paq:>r.llp. ld!llJlJJ s,mpuiJs 'I!ew
--UD pnSSiUpPl! SCM iJlnU ;)41 W04M
ol!:J 01 ill"8 iH11 !lllMllS I lClI1 JilljlJnJ pue
o
'OHWHI pall:Jene Jd!iJotlJ 5,Jil(lUas 'I!I!W (p.IJ01S!fiaJ) (pa!J!lItJJ) ^q 0 UJ!^Ji)S II?1IoSJild Aq ll-Gl'
lIO' --.---..---- (,iUlllll) 'iJtl/l,}(llIc ,llll uodfl pue 'OlilJilll pi1ljJCI1t.! ld!iJJtJJ
5,JaputJs '1!I?Ul (paJilIS!f)aJ) Ipa!J!JJilJ) ^Cf 0 ilJ!^JaS I!?UOSJiJCI All 0 '-6 l . (OJ!MiJS}O ;ncpJ.
lIO lqlJ.liH/l piJlellfi!sap OlJ!lsnr 1:J!J1S!O "I/l ufHln '-- 'oN Sl!illd IIOWLUO:J 'lcaddV JO iJJ!ION illjl)O Ado:> e 0
II;>^'O'! '"'II Willi" JO '''"M' AqoJ041 :J.I^,,1al:l:lV
55: ~O^lNn~
VINV^1^SNN3d ~O HJ.1V3MNOWWOO
(saxoq a/qaD!ldda ~Da4:J '/eaddu 10 aDt/ou a41 6u!l!lIB1:JII SA va (01) N31 NIH1/M 037/:1 38 1SnW aD/Mas JO Joo;d 5/41),
J.NIV1dLNO::l 311:1 OJ. 31mJ aNIf W3ddlf :10 3::lIJ.ON :10 3::lIMJ3S :10 :lOOl:ld
>c ~. f;
~
~ C': ~.-:-
'0 0' :~~) .,.~'
uJ~-=:, 0",
(..) :::. ~ .- '-~ ,:...:
0:''-' -'.
" ......;. ..~~
~f: !.n
(~;
u-1L' "" "Z::::::
- Lt. ~,~J 11.J
0:" ..::.;: ,':JU...
F: , ~;';
1,'- C"'> 5
0 c.r> U
~ (' I ~
'\::)~ \ I.r--"
'~ ~
---k>
r"\j
~
-...;
.--~
o
~
<'v
~
f_ \
''--..-I
r-""'"
~
~-
-
t! 4>. j...
j"::, ~<
(", ('-:. , r
\) J
<. ) ,
rl.. , -
, .,i- LC.
t.;' J-. :
C"
C,.~ , "~I ..t';
U
.' i , (;.
L~ , I
J.
..... " ~
I , C" ,)
() C~I (' -'
:J
;.;
;...)
-'
~
z
8
B ~ ~ ~
IE ~ ~
o ~ ~ ~
~ 8 g ~
>'
to
i
~
~
~.
CI)
[fj
~
'.
BRUCE E. MILLER
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
COLLEEN R. ENSINGER
IN RE: APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS
: NO. 99-435 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, March 26, 1999. the appointment of Daniel DeArment, Esquire
to the arbitration panel in the above-captioned case is vacated. and Thomas
Collins, Esquire, is appointed in his stead.
By the Court,
P.J.
Michael Scherer, Esquire
Chairman
- CAf'i-~,(, _3/3D/99'
o .>S. -p,
Court Administrator
.,.
:ssg
(-.~
~:',~
'!J 0
\.() TI
.'. ~ ~~
~.~.. T
;~j 'iiilJ
c.) ,'Im
c::;.. '~6
...,' -'rl~r
;, ::tl
::!-c)
co din
0.) =;;!
~
c..:> -<
r:'~; .
':.'< ..
. ~;~,~
>- 0 ~
IT.
is .. 5~
wQ M
Qt-j ~ U~
.-
u....f- a... O~
'.l.-~-
oci \.0 ~~
6c;:
~(:L.. i:l:if:i
u:tc; (.!) U~
X => rDQ..
....' "'" ~
l..:_ <:n :::J
0 en u
BRvcl< F. /J11<..L..~r< }
Pit".,,+-, '.(f )
}
v. }
)
(">L L<:: ~-/V E. crV>/NGf:"rl ) U
)
OATH
In The Court of Cornmon Pleas of
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
..J
qq- Jj j'~ C/v,.,
,
!;
~lo .
Civ,' , A<.. /--;~...
G.~ v--'
We do solemnly swear (or affirm) that we will support. obey and defend
the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of this Co~on-
~ . . - 4((;1:~~?G (,'-~
/ /l'1\)wo
AWARD
We, the undersigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn
(or affirmed). make the following award:
(Note: If damages for delay are awar~ed, they shall be
separately stated.)
Irle ~'/lA f,r 1'J,L
1h~
Ac Pef-vd~f /'"
{psfs 0 -F ~oJ 1'1 .
~,,, f,'(,( WId ('-jc, ,....sI
("
({,n:Jv,,1-- of JlI, /53.OS pillS
. Arbitrator. dissents. (Insert name if
applicable. )
Date of Hearing: f/j /.qq
g .//1C; n
Date of Award:
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF AWARD
Now, the If::'-' day of (l~~
award was entered upon the docket and
parties or their attorneys.
. 19.f,L, atY<J/ . &....:1., the above
notice thereof given by mail to the
Arbitrators' compensation to be
paid upon appeal:
$ ;;.qo,L'lJ
f.,~,OC&tA tlr::~ e~ ~.
Q ) P~othonotary
---.2 J..<r" 0 ~/~~
I De?uty
By:
/9?Qr./f).fj
(I)'/i<..b;"', ~. SJ"-'A^-'
L). J~~.
Ih. tUJ. Lv. dO.
I~ e.. 1""-' tiJ-. 8./'1,9')
c:. ~:) ~-)
~'.; \...; ';']
,::'
pc ,
n i '- ., )
-.'
-~ i
(" '.
~~ '~)
r:: L .!
. ..
.' ... ,
. :.,) ~j , ; I
" ~~~ :-i
=> ,>
--j ::.J
", -~
I::
~ ~.t,;CUZ~,
. . ~. C.
(:",::: ~~
1-.:
,-., , .: ) ::-<
') , )
, , ..~-
: "
r." '0 I ;::~l
'-.'
.-~ ,=) ((;
l -.
e_ I.~ r_'.
'" I ".
L~... rf":
U' ~'..-
I'. ",.. :.:)
'--' (I. ':..J
:
.
.' .
BRvcs: C. 4? ,,-..;fl<. AUG~2 1981ln The Court ,
of COCllllon Pleas of
pIt, ,."t. '.ff ). Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
1
v. ) qc; -, 1!5~ Civ,')
) lIo. !lJ
(ot'C:I:-^, :e. ErV~'NGE"(l ) Civ'-' A....).,-"", - U..,...,
)
OATH
We do solemnly swear (or affirm) that we will support, obey and defend
the Constitution of the United States and the Consticutioa of this Common-
wealth and-chat we will discharge the duties
19'?-lfr-l,t)sJ
(
/l1\:)~o
AWARD
We, the undersigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn
(or affirmed), lllake the following award:
(Note: If damages for delay are awar~ed, they shall be
separately stated.)
IN'e [;'tlA (:,t" -/he..
11~
f/A,'<o!->'f.(VvicJ (c,e. I'-sf
/
t{,??:)",,,/- of Jt I, 153. os- pills
~c j)eJ:?d~f I',..,
C9sfs 0 -F so/ (-t .
applicable. )
. Arbitrator, dissents. (Insert name if
Date of Hearing:
i.//-qq
8'/l'jti
n
Date of Award:
'^-'-
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF AWARD
Now, the IJI:5:' day of a~,wl-
award was entered upon the d~~ and
?arties or thei= atto~eys.
, 19.fL, at,J'()1 , e....~1., the above
tlotice ::hereof given by mail to t!1.e
Arbitrators' compensation to be
paid upon appeal:
$ .;J.</o.cll.J
By:
f..u.llX...d d. r.... ~.
Q , '-P;[ocf1otlocary
_,~~, (} ~.p)~,
/ Deputy
~ l(J 0-
S (Y) ill
," -. .... CQ :t
tG ~; ro
i:> LO
~, CO
1..': c.-; ':~) ;.~ 0 00
( ) ~--:-
r!-= ~ _l::-- 0- =+1
".- -- -=Ii
r'<) ',: ~ .;::i ~ j
~ "
("I' '::1 1;tl <X
,. .
." r::_.
I:. " ".'
V: ::"-
..,::
dO'. ~:--)
.J , ()