The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About99-00513 , ' " I' m~11I'1I ~1,~1I11,1I.1," '1111\1\"~,lInl~N il~VIIlI" "1111- ",' MIrIl~I!I, II. KU~IK I'~~\I',I.~ (I, ~lIilM~N '\lrll~\m~, ~~UI,n(~K tt" ." ' nglno ,. .. Rovner IMVIII~, WI~Nll.jKI NII!II.\I(!,l/iojnN ' MIl'II~I'I,I, N~VIT~KV , Imll"IIM,ilIlRI~ , P\l~NI\~, II~RR1(lK 'IMHI.j 1I"\lINTI ' I,IN'1111IlN " T111l11l!ST I4\WYI!lIS "---IN-- . MlllRIr.A . Ill'II~'"H~, ~NC!lN() . NII!i<I,lInVNIII! NllVllI11\!PI' ~I 100.9 ,., J\lIl~u qpllnllll/llfr~1' , CIlI11Il\lI'IIIlII\ Cllllllly Clllll'lhllllHU On\! c;Ollrlh\1I1Hu Sqlllll'll CllI'lIHlu,l'A \7()1~'33"7 g~1 ,. llrown v, Kpll!;jlllllh f)PIII' ,Jm\llll.llol'tbl'l I' " " , , , IJnulnHol\lIl'll,ihu Jlllllntlf'l~' Ilnll1tH fhl' Chl1l'~Ullnd II prnpllHlll1 VOl'llIo\ HlIp, YOI'Y truly ynlli'H, ~" J)lIvld ,I" I.lIt~ I' "" i' ", [)/A,nllt~ " EhulnH\II'U I' , ',I "ou I1dWIIl'd KllIlllHH, I1Hqull'o (W/OI\P,) "if , .1; " I' I' " ,; " " H " " . "" ln2.117,1\111.1,\~n'() ,~80n N'OIlTII FIIONT ST'lInnT, HAnnISIIUiHl, '.'^ 17110'17on (717) enn,n7ol , I MK (717) e3n'~OI0 ' " , I' '1, " " "" ,. " .' I' WANrM m~QWN IIIHI KIWIN 1lI~{)WN, " "ll\lnlln~ W, IN TIW rOIJln OF ~~OMM(}N 1'1,lli\/) ~JIJMJlIlH',i\NP (JOIJNTY, PA r1YII, ^(J'1'I0N, I,^ W NO, 09,m ~Ivll JIJIW THI^I, Il!lMANllIlP " . mVlw IT Kl11mAIJQl I l\IIll " CI,olJ~H TIHJrKINO,INc" . P!ll~llllillllN ',; ymmlCT " QllllNllnnl1 W,,~ P!lf!lllllnlll PIVIglll Kqqhmluh nqgllgqnl? " Yq~-- Nn' .-- II' your' nn~wqr I" YO", p.rooqqd In Ql1o~lIol1 2" If ru\ll' nllaIVor IH 1\1l,'pl~nN!ll\u\ll~ tllQ , OO\ll'lrnlll11 !loplll)' Ihnl Yllll hnw ronohod n vorl!lql, ' " " " ,.' QUPRllnn 21 'i , Slnlo Ihp Illl,.1l1l1l1 ul' dl1ll1l1g\IHH1INlnhlol\ by Mra; 13rowlll 'I $ I,., " QlloHllon 31 Slnlo Iho 1Il1l01l1ll6l'111111111goH HUNlnluo!l by MI', Brown: ,. " , // $.' I, i '.1._ , " \ ~ .' '-" ,,/f ,\lloI1S0 I110rllho onlU11'l1011l dqp\1IY Ihllt YO\1 hnvo rCllohod II vonlllJl, f' ", I Pl1lo: 'r, , 'I ForoporNOU " I' ,:i; " 2PI 1"R, 111lJ.I.\M1U " WANDA Ill\OWN IIml KIWIN m~OWN I I I" I I I, I I I I I PIIIllIlll'fa, v, DWIGHT KUl11lt\110H lImt .. .. CWUIlU 'mUCKINO, INC" \)lIfIl11411I1la, , , IN 'l'IIn COURT Oil COMMON J1l,IW~' . l;IJMOI1RP\NP COl1NTY, .. PI1NNIlYIN ANIA CIVII< ACTION I<AW NO, 99... !>~/~ ~~v~'14~y , ,. , JURY TRIAL 1)I1MANDnI) '1, " ~swlm 011 UEFENDAN'!'S 'fO Tim CO~ I '1 91l1111ld, 'MIllr rllnaunnlllc, Il1vllallpnllon DIll'Ilndn11la nrll wUholl1 kllPwllldll1l or . Intbrmllllun s\jfflcIIlI1lIU' 1'01'l11,n\lollllf 11810 tho Irllth of Iho IIVOl'lllllIllS, Imd rruufls dOll1nl1ded I nllrlnl.' 2,.. ' Admtllod, ~, Admhlod. 4, Admlllod, ,~, Admllled, ,6. ,I Adll1l11od, II 7, Admitted, 8, Admllled, 9, Donled, Ii ;" 10, Donled, ";i /, ': ,I ,\1 , ,I' "j I. I' . "WnI3RJlrO~Jl, Pllfl.m~lInlfi 1llll11l1na, Ihllllllll Compllllnl hlllllfiml~~llll nmllhnlJm1nl11\lnl 11\lllnlllf~llln thllh' ti\Vm: willi \lOfit~ i ',' " /, '1; RIl~r\l\llf\lll~~lIh'l1lllpd, I' MJll'ZQHI~1 W'G~m~~IIAM, KN^l1~1l {/(, 131\11', ~,O, ", ,',' " '; 'J ~~~~,"~iL , l,P, tI toDDI!) , 3211 N, rrom ~1I'\lQt Hnfrl~hllr!ll PA I7IlO:03oo (717) 23&-6.1 &7 .j', ;, .' " ,," it " , (I" " I , ",'.' \' , " Ii, 'II " I' ,I " " " 1" " , " " "<1 I' ,I I, " II It .-" , ;,,1 " " 't., " ", " " I' I' "I it ' " , 4 .. " ]",,11 " " " " " I' CER'I'IFICt\'JlU}E SIiJIlVICIU I' _ '", ,'- ,,__ " , !" J hDrllhtPPI'II~lhM Oil 'hlsl~ <<or of Mnrilh, t~!9Q J ~PI'VP\I thl' fPrll~ol"1J A;;swprR' , I pf PpfPIl~AntQ III Omnplolm nil lh\! fpnpwhI8111'1;~IlIlQI " ',I I , , , " .,' , " I " '-to " Pnvlll J.., "'\lI~"EQqnII'P Anslllo (k. ROVllllr 4~Q3 N i Prolll ~lrPIlI UAl'flRhnrs, M 17ttCl COllmpl fol' l~h\hlllt'fsl , ,,' , " ;/;'/' , C::z:' , 4;:. , "". , -.., " .,c:.. ':"\", .f/ . (<1-."'.,__-....___ Edwnrd Un(Ill\\I;S, I " "; " " '''" " J; I' II, ",. "i " " '! ,I " " i' t'" ~ 'i " " t' " 6 " , " <\ 'I I," ,: :,'-' I' i" '-", '.'1": I' I'l-JI,'.) c), , /1::\' 1')1.' "I' li')I' ("" L I' l,l, , I " " 'I I< '. " ('f,t >1 (, "; I' " " I I , " :1, ;;j: I' , .Ii' "i'l '!,', n I ' ;i''-I{I} ,(.I}:L :~ i ,t,J 0', , { . ~ ' I. ,I" II"' O'j " " " (I' " " " I' 'I " " I' I' I' " " ii" 'i. " "; ,'I 1'; H " " I ::':"::-'~:,,-:_;',~.<,:~',;.t!,::~~ <w "_._.-;:.~=,,;' =.-"'::7:':~,',~',.='._.~ ~~::.'::~'::::,~.::::::~.-.~ , " " " i ~: , I' , ~~ t~ I" .I~ ..1 "J ro r. .. Ht 7 ~' ., I ~l ., If " ,,~ . R ,j ;j:; 8 " I' '" I' ". " .",'." I' I' " " ,. I' $~ 8~ ~_ .~b~ ~1: pi c''''' /' ; s: ' I " " 'I, " i' .. ' ';' ,,' ':, I.,,' "" " Ii " ,,II ---. :,~:::-;.~:~:::::;:::;:~ ~::::;:===:_.-.::::==::~-::::::::.::::::=.:_=-~- j, " , , " " 'i ,I " 'l> "" !I , " " ,I I' " " i' , I' , ' ~cltl\l, .' HOHriollll\Iuy 911\11111110\1, Mn'l'Zqm~, WICI\HHSHAM,I\NAP'SS ~ IlIlll, P,C", " " '(/~~';<;::'-d ,',. '" ;;(C~~ " " I.W I. 7 '''''" ,- ;.;?\""-,~~'"'-""-~,:,..: UIIWllrd U, 1<1111\199, IV' 1,1),#109919 " ~211 N, From Slrool HIII'l'19hm'lll flA '17110-0300 (717) 238'81B7 ), ' " " , ;, i\'" I' ;\. II' " " il " ,I' " I t' I' " '" ; t ~ ",' " "~I' " ,', " " " " ;-Ii " I, ", " , ,,I' ','- 'Ii i' II I /I " .' '" " " " 'I, 'I ." " I ' " I' ;: 'I< " II " I' " '" Ii " I' !' " " .,. I; I " ,I.'. 'I , ' " I" " l< it I( " If ,. I; ," , .IJ, I' " " I, " ,', ", I'" " I( " t:;!J I '. " "I' "I ~\) " " 001 :11 ;1' ",; " " ;,' II I , d' " " I' " , , " " , " " , " I' I, " .,' I' , " " , " I, , , " " " , " WlINPI\ l-lRoWN mlq 1<I1lV~N n!l.OWN ,I ' " PlRintiee~ I I Vi'lL I :1 PWlGH'~ I<PlIill3l1UGII fll'ir.l I C!'-1011~!J1, 'l'RUOI<ING, tNc I , I , Peeem:'tflnt~l I :,' " ~t-l '~'IIIU COtJl~'l\ O\" OOMMoN PLIUMI i PtJM\3!W.lINP COl1N~'Y, PI1lNNI3YJ..yIlNU\. o.tv+r. !Ir-~'ION " LAW NO, 99-513 o,j.vH JUIW 7'IUI\!'-1, PIUMflNPJilO I' ;\ ; ~ ", :i , , PLAINtl'.tI~FS !....lill.QUIilS'I' POR ADM I SS raNI;! PfWPOUrDlflO tJPON...nmNDlIN'I' l(nJIilBAUGII.' 'rO, Deeenr.lfll1l: P\,/iaht I<eebf\\\gh ala lUr.lwfll.'q m I 1<11<1 U 1'1 8 I IV/ lill3Cjuil:e i, 'Pl8f1l'/e ~ilk:e not~,ae ti)f\t yO\! fire hereby " 4014 oC the Pel1peylVf\nifl RUleI'! tJ, ,," the unde1.'e.i.gn13r.lwithil1 th.i.1.,ty " " reCJUired, PurSUflnt to Rule ,of.CivU proaeqlPie" t:o'l'levve ", , (30 )q<1Y~ ,ham l'lel;Vio\", yqlW upon I' r H l.'esponse to the,admilmion(l'!) , reCjIl13f,lteq'hel.'e,i.nl 1, Do you fldm.i.t:tihAt yqu were .i.nvolVedil1 "A motol: vehiol~ flooic\rmt thAt oacJ\u'~'ed on ,July 2:1/ 199'7 f.\t f1Ppro/CimEltely 12140 1'.111, "" " " 'I " fit \:he intel.'seqt: ion oe the CC11:Hale Pil~e find Hempt RoO\c\? " '''lIDMIrl' OiUNY, ~~ihi t " , ';I, 00 YOll thElt at the time of the subjeot' mo \: 01.' I :vehiole, flee.i.dent / you Wet'e .i.n the 1'1001'13 of employment with ,CloUse 'I'l:'ueldng / Ine ,,?, , ' l\OMI'l' DIDNY ANGINO I< IWVNlUR, P, 0 I " ~".["'" .",1" I,O,,,.35956 " " ,AB03 N, Front Street Ilurdeburg, P)\ l'7HO ('11'7),230-6'791 lIttornoya for Plqintitf.: '), ;," ,I ", , " 1.46036/1>11>11>1 ':t ,i'" "II " " " I' .... <:>1 '''or! ~\; '''I (:p "S \'d' " h ~~ .,~~ -;:'(1 " j"\_V (r)'~;;. '"., i :'1r.1 ., ~r. \:'1, p., ':'1':-:1 "j ~". n\", \(1 ':i' 'I) " , (I,i' " TI" ,"I \\\r& I' 1".\11 \~I ,l,":l,; i" .... 0'1, 1.1" \] D I' U 11 " ", III, ,J '" ", " :1 ;1' ,t.,) " Ii , I' " , " I, {, " " Ij !i .' "\1" ,,' " 1;(/\ j'; " h " " ,," ,df " I<i; "jl i' " ,', I' " !;I,' " "d " "" 'i I' " t-' ;,' " , " " I' I,i " " " 'I ", ,!'I " I; " ',,, /, "l' II, " I' " .' " ,JI ", " t'} " " P i' " " I, it I' 'I" I, " ",,; , WANO/\ 13RPWN An~ll<Inv:fN 131~OWN I ~)+flJntHfl'! I I I I I I I I +N 'l'IIID 00\/1<'1' pp ~oMMPN pr~Jil/\13 f' C '\1 M13, El'IH ~I\NP OPtl,N'!'\' I' PPlNNI3Y,W l\N~,fI!' , ) CXVll, /\C'l'~oN - l-'fIN '.' / NO t qYf ,,' (r./ ~ aU.Leu. .:lplW ~'ln^Lt OIi1Mi\N!lElD , Vf.I, " , PW:rGI'I~1 1< mJil13!\\lOl I Ijnq m,OP,9ln ~'RPCl<lNC1, ~NC t I pefendlHltf.l NO'I'I'ClD 'I'D DElIi'lDl'ill -,," " 'YoU' hl'\Ve peen I>ueq in oo~W\: t H ,Yo~\ w,j.I'!h \:0 rlaffl!1d Ml'\.i.rHl\: t:he oll'\.i.lI\f.I f3el: fo~'t:h in \:hefol.lowing PAgeI'!, YO\1 I11\Hlt l:l'\I~e 110t:iQ!1 within twenty (;:10) ql'\Y!3 l'\ftel; t:h~.!3 COlilplAint l'\nq Notice 1'\1;[;) !3e~'VI'l(:j1 pr ent:13dng OIwdtt:enOlPpeAr<\l1oe per!3onnl.ly or by 'I1t;to~'ney flnc\ f, :ting in wdting w,il:h t:he cO\Wl: YoU1' def;(-)npe!3 01; objoati9,n13 tot:he Oll'\imf3 !3f,1t forth AOl'\in!3t yo~, You Are WArned thAt if; you fAil to qo 130' the 01'11313 mOlY proceed wi!:lwut yoU <\nq' ~ jUc\gment l11<\y pe ,ent:ereq, <\g<1in!3\: yoU, Py the,' ,court Witho~t furthe,l' notioe for f1ny 1110!lIilY o~,<limec1 in the COl11p:t<1,i.n\: 0;1.' f01' "Any other clnim 0,1; rf;lHef l-'eqUe!3ted by t:h!l Pll'\in\::l.ff I YOll IT\<\Y 101313 money or PI;opel't:y or othe1' rightl3 .j.ITlPOl-'tpnt to yoU," , ypu 131-l0Ul,p '1'I\Im 'l'IIII3 Pl\PElR '1'0 YOUR LI\NYIilR 1\'1' ONC;:lilt Hi' yOU DO !'lOT H1WIi1 1\ LI\WYlDR OR CANNO'l' M'POHP PNIil I GO '1'0 olr' '!'J!JUlilpl'IONIi1 ~tHIi1 " OIi'Ii'IOIil SElT ,PORTH I3lDt"OW, TO Ii'INP 'OU~, WlllilRIn YOU "CAN em:!' Itli1GlILJ HlilLP, ClIMBJilIUjANP 'COlIN'1'\' BI\R ASI30CH\~'ION , ,,2 Ltiberty' AVe I Carlil3r~, Pennl3ylVllniOl 17013 ('717) 21\9-3116 1-000-990-9100 , " Ill, t " " ,I fit " " ,I; ORIGINAL IJ9G71/t,C3, " !' ".( '( 'J , ' " , ~ : , .' .\'IANP!\ I3ROWltI <\l1q l~liln N I~HoWN I f.J1f1.1,n~Hf./3 " HI THlil QOUR'~' O\~ cOMMON \'l-llilM3 CUM1WII~!.II\f'./P CO\1N'l')' I, P!ilNNI'lYWMH1\ CIvrr" !\CTION -wAW 1'10, I I I , I , , I , No'rICI1'\ '. '113., P\,/IGII'~ l~!ilmBl\UGII AmI Cl,OUI'lEl 'l'RUC1~INQ, me 1./ ,paf.~ncjAn~/3 !)'U1W 'I'RI!\l.J PlilMI\NPElP ,- ., " j,,, , I.,a hAn" qall1f1nqOlqp 01 lu1\:aq an 101 OOl."\:e t' 13:l, \.\/3~13q Q\.\iar13 qaCenqar/3a 413 a/3~fI/3 qall1Anqf\/3 aKPue/3~fI/3,an 101/3 Pflgina/3 /3UgnUianb13l3/ \.\l3baq ~iane vi13n~a (aO)'~if\/3 qa p1a~0 a1 pflrtir da 1f1 CaohA d13 1f1 ,qamflnqA 'I 1f1 no~if. ip<\pion I ' Upt13d daba pra/3entflr I.1nfl f\pfldano:l,<I al30ri~fI 0 an peraonf\opOr Mbogf\qo '1f1rohiV/3r an 101 COrte an f.ormf\ a/3ori\;fI /3U/3 defanl3f\/3 0/3U/30bj~oiona/3 01 1.13 dem~nda/3 an aon~rf\ da /3\.\ parl3onf\ I l3aa <lVi~f\do qlle /3i Ul'ltaq no, /38 deCj.ende 1 1f1 aorta ~om, f\rOlmediqf.\/3 ''I pl1ecja antrf\r HnA ordan oont,rOl \.\atad,/3:\.n' prElyio avi/3o 0 no~ifioC\oion 'I pOl." ol1f\lquial." ql\ajC\ 0 al.i.vio Cj\.\eea pa#clo an la' patioion qa dall1/3ndf.\ t Uated );ll\13de pal."dar clineroQ /3\.\/3 propiedf\qaao otro/3 ~eraohO/3 ill1port/3ntaa pf\rf\ "/3tad, " J~I.,ElVUl lil13TJ\ PlilM1\NP1\ J\ UN 1\I30G1\Po IMMlilDIl\'l'EiMlilN'rDl .l3l t-lo TIElN~ l\I30C:lfll)0 0 131. NO"I'IIilNlil Jill, PINEiRO flU1!'ICIlilN'I'lil Pjil Pl\C:li\R,.~Il\I., '13!illlVICI01' VJ\'1!1 lilN P1DRSOf'./A 0 I.,I.,1\MlD rOft ~'mI.,Ell~Of'./O 1\ I.,/\ OFICXNA CUYJ\ PIRDlCQION I3ID lDltICUIDf'./Tli1\ IDSCRI'r'A ABMO P1\RA AVDlRIC:IUl\R' POf'./Plil SliJ Pl1li)PlD CONl3li1C:1U)'R i, lIS113~'IDNOIl\I.,IDGl\l,. ." , . " 'OUMB~ftLI\NP COUNTY BAR lISI300I^~ION , ,,;a i1ibert'l Ave I COIr1i/31a\ Pann/3'11vf\ni/3 17013' (7l.1) 249.3116 1- 000 - 990- 9100 , " ,I' Ii (' , " ,I " I, " ' , ", ',' H .. 1', " I' 'i l. . \'/ANP". aRo\,/l'! flnq I~mvm 'BRO\'/N, .. ',!?~Ain\:j.Eff! v~', n~ 'l'Hm pOVI~'V or. COMMoN ~'l-iITI^1'l CUMBEllWAND COUNTY, rmNN'I3\'fNl\!'ffA CIVH, i\C'l'IoN -, Lf\\'L ' NO, 99,/i'/.,' L1,1.'x,'"(.f""- D\'/IClWl' l~mElBl\uClH .'Anq 1" - , qLOUI'lEl ,,'l'RUCIq:NQ, !NC I , DeEenqAnt:l'i 1 1 I I 1 I I I ,~OMPLAIN1' ~UHY 'I'HIl\L PITIM1\NDElP " " , +, 'PICjj.nt:HE~ WAnqCjBrown Anq j(evin Bl'Own fll"e I\qUlt 'I " inqi ViqUf\:):a re~iqilig in HCjrdabl.\l:\:I, D<luphj,n ppl.lnt:y I L'enlll3ylvAlliA, ., 2.1 peEal1d<ln~ Dwight: l(eebf\ugh fa 1\11 Achi~t: illqiV~duA~ !'Inti oitil'lel1 of the Commol1WeE\lth oE Pemll3ylVClni<l who .feaiqe's <It 9:l.. I3hipp'enablu:g,Mopile l~atE\tes,l3hipPfilIll3Purg" F'r<lnJ<;lin Count:y, l?13 nn ,wlv.m ,1 <I , " 3, DsEend<lllt Ci0413e TruoJ<;ihg, Ino, 113 f\ oorporAt:ion .' , Wi th <I pdno.lple piEloe"oE p.l\aineal3 loo<lteq Elt '207,9 Hi tner i!ighwClY, OElflil'ile, Cumberlf\nd County, pennaylvaniEl, , " 4 I ll'he faata fInd ooollrrenoeahereinElEtel: l"el<lt:eq t:oolt . pIC\o,e on or ,Clbout JUly 21, ,19117 C\t. Clppro~imClt:ely 12140. p,m, on '. CC\rlisle Pilte at the interaedtilon of; the CE\rlil3le, Pilte' find Hsmp\; ROClq, C~mberlClnq County, Penn~YlvE\niCl, 5,'.' l\t:that time and plflOS, Mra... Brown lV.fla fI Eront asat pElsllenger in CI PontiClo Clrand' 1\m drlven by SheliCl Prunty I ,Ma, Prunty WCl13 trflveling in an eClaterhdi~eotion in the leEt ~flne on the CArliale Pi 1<;13 I t ,;' j! I ,6, 1\t: the same ti.me, Defsnc1.\l1t Dw.ight l(eebElugh, while , in the soope of his employmellt wi th Clolllla 'l'rlloking, Ino., W<lS operClting <I Ford l1'-11;0 tt'Ucilt, owned by h.ls employer, 1 I' " I' I, " " '7 I ' "f\t I\H t i\11E1 l'elaYl\nt hl:Jl"I3~n" Dal!enql\n\: Pwiah\: l(aepl\uah W<lI3 I\o\:ina w.tl:hin I:ha acope of hifJ empl~Yl~an\: With pef.a'nql\nl: Olol\a8 '~'r\lCking lnc, " 1\ 0, Defenq<\n\: Pwig\)t I<ea~)i.\\lgh, ,while ope~'I\\:ing \:\1a f\fOI~el3aiq Forq l!'~tliO \:r\wk, hf\q been \:,v<lvaHng in 0\110r\:he1'n , " qirection on Hal\1tit HOf\tl al1q ,Wal3 pl<1nn~ng \:0 t\.\rl1 leCt El'om Hemp\: 'HoO\q onto t:he CI\I,UI31e Pil~e t " 9 t Mt:er Dafenq<ln\: l(aabO\ugh f.!\:oppecl <I\: the I3top l3i~n on Hempt HO<lq, he PUlleq hil3 vehicle clirectly into the PO\th of Mo, " Prunl~Y'13 vehicle I of\\\l3ing E1 motOl' vehiole /.\cciqen\:, 10, 'l'he foregoing /\coiqen\: anq /.\11 of t:he inj\l#el3 O\nq, , " " qal\1/.\gel3 l3et l!prth hereinaJter 13\\8taineg by M~'ElI 131'pwn <ll'e 'the qil'ect <lnd proxim<l tel l'es\ll I: of t:he negligent: I c<lrelel3,I3, Wf\l'\~qn ftnq reckless m/.\nner in which Dafenqcwt Dwight I(aep&ugh OPflrEl\;eq hi8 motDr vflhiols <lsfollow81 <I, fdlure to yield the dght:'-of-waYI P, failurato l~eap <llel'\! and 'naintahi <I proper w<ltoh for the pl'aElenCe of other motor vehicle,s on the highway I 'I, " I' , c, the highWcW I failura to ~eep a proper watch for br~ffip on I, , " " cI, fa.i.1ure ,to keep proper ancl aclequate control oval'. hil3 vehiclel and, e I ddving hiEl vehicle upon the highway in <I mannel' encl<\ngering' per80na ancl pl'oparty find in <I 'l."eClt~!'1"'13 , m<lnnel' with Clc\l~elaS8 cli8rogal~d to the 1'1ghtl3 flncl l3f1fety of" otherl3 and i.n violat1on" of the Motol: ,Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth of "Pennsylvania I " I' 2 '" (' " "", II '" " I< " CIJArOO'J I,' , W~11da 13l:o\,/n y, Dwi l"Jht !<eebaugl1"and Clo\lse '1'l:l\ 9 kiPI'! ,Ino , 11, PAr~grAPh~ 1 through lO of' the ~Omp~A~nt Ar~ il1ao~'por~t:eq herein Py re1;erenoe a~ if l3et, fqrt:h At +endt:h I 1;1, NI1~.nt:Hf WAnq~ 131'own l3Hpt:aineq Painf\-\+ '~nq l3eyere " injlu'iel3 whioh .lnohlqe put: Are not; Hl11it:eq to'I11II:\.\!iple Am!.., rlflep +A(J~r.At.tonl31 ~o ,~le1" dght 'Artll Anq 1;OreA1'I11, Anq <(' ~1'I:\.oiq , hypert:rophied ~9ArfOrI11At:ion, ,,' ;'. " 1'3,' 13y ~"E!AI'IQn' of theaforel'lai,q in~\-lriel3 1'l\-\l3t:Aineq py " M~'1'l t 13rown, I'lh~' w~~ foroeq, 'to inoqr li<lb.i.J,ity for medioAl, t:ieAt:l11ent'" nied~oAt:iQnl3, hOI'lPi\:!\l.t~~i;,tonl'l <lncl 13imili\r misoeH~neo\-\~ e~p'enl3es 'in All effort to re/ilt:ore herself;. to heAlth, <lncl olaim,ll3 I "l11Aqe t:herefor, 111 t 1313 OA\-\'/iI 13 , of t:he nAt\-\re of he~' ind.\-ldef,l, Mrl3, 13rown hql'l been <lqv.i,l3s21 ~nq, t:herefol:e I <lyerf,l thAt she may pe foroecj t:o ;, " " ino\-lr l3:lmilqr e:X:J.,lenl3el'l ih the futqre, <lnd olaim il3 'l11qqe t:herefo~, " "" I! . r",:, 11j I AI'I ,A l"el!Jult 0.,( the Elfb1"elilentionecl inj Udel'l, Ml;'I'I, " 13roWI1 h~~ 'i.\nc1e1"gOne <lncl" in the fq!;qre will \-\\1del'go physioEll ancl ,,111~nt.1;'l, sUfeel'ing, inClol1veniel1oe" in Oq1;l'ying Ollt her "claily EIOt;ivil:ies, loss of Hfe'I3,pleflsUl:es F.md enjoYl11ent, Elnq olF.d,111 il'l mAcle thel:efol'. i , 1~, As a result of the aforesaid-injuries, Mrs! 13rown , , " hM 'been Mq in the f\-\ture ,will be subjeot t:o gl~eEl!; humiHat!on Elliq em6ArrflBBment, 'and claim is made therefor', 17" Af3 EI reSUlt: of thfJ l1fOl"ement:'ioned inj udes,. Ml'B I 13roYln has BUf,ltait1ed work 10ss,los13 o~ opportllnHy fll1d,EI permal1eht I .. I' I, 3 " " c:lim:\.mw:\,on of. he);' efll'n:\.ng power <InrI oC\PC\o:\.~y I ",nil o+f\:\.mh mf\\:\e ~ha;rl3f.p~' , 10, :Mrf'l, I3rown pqn~il1\-lef'l 1:0 pe P+<\9\-lf.lq ~y perllif'l~en~ " , "" p~~n flnq limHC\t:ion C\nel, ~heref.ore, <lverf'l ~h<lt: hel' Jnj\-lr~e13 n1f\Y pe' I of f\ P\3rI11O\nentnf\~ure, Qf\u/3ing l,"e/3icl\l<\+ prob+enw for ~ha ~'al11ll:\.nqer of her +ife~ime, f\ncl clAim i/3 mAcle ~herefor, lP, 1\!'! 1\ ref'lq+~ of t:he afol:ef'laic\ O\oqiqen~ I ,Mrf.l, 13ro\\'n h<\!'! I'lW-l1:C\,ineq /30<lr!,! whlch win ~'e/3\.\n i\l <\ ~)ermanan~ q:\.f'lfig\-lr~men1:, " " <\hc\a+ai~ il3 m<\qe ~herefor; I " I, m';A1M II I' I' , )(eyin BrowI') ,'il ,Dwiqht-Klillbaugh and Clouse 'l'ruokinq I 1no. " , "I' 20, l'f\rf\gr<\plw 1 ~hro\.\gh' 19 of, the Compla~,nt 'Ire " inoorporf\tecl here~n by refel"l'll1oe as' if /3ett:ol't;h <It +eng~h I 2lill;s a I;El $1.\ 1 I: of! the C\forament ioni!JQ inj urie!'!SUl3t<\:\.ned ,,' , " " '- ! "py h:\.13 wife, l'ldntiff Warda Bl'OWI1, l'ldnt:iff. l<evin Bl."owh hEl!'! Peen ancl may in the f.utUl'e be depriVl1cl of" the oare, oomp!1nionahip, oOIWortium, !1nd ~ooiety of: !lh wif:e, all df: whioh will' be to hi!'! " great cle~rimen1: ,and olaim i!'! made, thel'ef:or, WlIIilRIil!"oRlil, Plciinti f:f:s Wflnr.lfl Urawn find Kevin B~'own clem!1rid j~dgment against P~eBndants Ino, in,an amo~ht in exoe!,!s Dwight: l<aeb<l\.\gh anq ClotH3fl 'rl;t\cl~ing ," " '- 1\ of: 'rwentY-Pive Thou!'!<lnd t$25,00'OIOQ) " , 4 I, !' , '\" , , 'I ,,, )illIUl:'J en 'I' r QN We, WlIl1r.1f\ IInr.l l<ev1.n lWown ,1':~A1.nqff~ I hElve l~13~r.I t:lle rore~o~ng gOOl-l1l1ent: I'Ulq do herel)y PWeElr or, Elf~.h'Il1 l!.h41; \th13, fllo\:/3 /3el; fo~'l;ll' ~n " , I 1;1113 ~ol."egQ1.ng lite la"l.\f:l ~11d aOl::r.eo\: 1;0 " :I,nformAl;:I,on 'Anr.l pelter, \:he Pl'J13t: of om: Imow~,ar.lge I ' ' , , , We ~mc\l'Jrf3\:fw:j t:l\f\1; \:h!l3 Vedf,~oE\\:1.qn ~13 " ,'j '\1Hlde 13\.1pjeol!.t:o I;hepl'lnE\l.t:ie13' 01! :\.0, 1'f\,OI,9,I\, :r.e!f\\;!ng \;0 I-Inf3wa:r.n ff\~eifiioAt::I,ont:o III-It:ho:r.it:~ef31 ,geot:1.on 4 901, , , " ,WrII'N~ .-1-' 1..2, '9'9 , /) IA. J 1J.trv\j/; VnK,>G~f1u4~' (f~cttl Bro ." . " , /-/:2,- 71 , , ~. ' ~7 ~II .j' , ' , -" ' "', '" ...--.., . ,~~, &1 Bt"o n" " , . , , . 'j, Ptlt:edi .' ,/ " ,I' """ " " , 1,\ " I' ,.[ 'I 2"22/Mt,s " I, <II' j, :i " 'i ""',' " .. 1\ , I WANDf\ ~ROWN Abq l{lilVn/ l3HPWN / , NA~,nl:H~p , " IN '1'lIm COUWl" of cOMMPN ~JLJIDMI ' PPMnlflHl.I/\NP COVN~lY / J.llilNN,9\'lWl\i'lH\ OIVH, 1\qll1,JOi'l ", IJ1\W ,'j) NO I 1f .~:.- 6-/3, a.L().l~"" JUR\"~RIi\y P~MI\NP~P ;1, Vi'll DWIGHT ImlilJ3i\\.IGII !:Iml cr.,QlJ,91il TRUCKING, INo'1 P13fl3nclAn\:p I' " NOTIOIn 'PO DIil\i'IilNp 'I' \ .. ,YO\\ h<\Va peen f3\-leq in, ~011l."l: I I f yo\-! Wiph l:o qefenq <\m\inlll: the ol<\iml3 l3el: forl:h'in l:he fallOWing PAgl3l'l~ YO\-lm\-lf3l: l:Ake !:Iol:iori w:l.l:h:l,n l:wenl:Y, (~O) ql\Yf3 <\fl:ei' l:hi~, C0I11P1I\inl: Ancl NOl;ioe <\l."e l'l13rve~\, \Jr" enl:el:'ing <\ '\vril:l;en <\ppa<\:r.Anoe pel."l'lon!\1ly qr l)y <\l:l:ornl:lY I\l1q f, Jing in wril:ing wil:h l:he qourl: YO\-ll.' qef,en"'al'l or opjaol:ionl'l l:.C? I:he 01<\il11f3 "'el: fOPl:h <\gl\:l.nElI: yp\.\; Yo\.\ Are wA~'nacl l:h<\1: ;(;f YO\-\ f<\ll I:p clp Sb, the 'dl\lle l11<\y prooeecl wi Ii ho\.\ I: you <mcl A j \.\clgl11enl: m<\ype enl:e!:,eq <\gAinsl: YO\.\ PY l:he CO\.1rl: Wil:ho\.1l: furchEll.' nol:ioe for. [.Iny money oldmecl in l:he ,col1lpll\inl: Ol." fol." Any Ol:hflrclA:l.m Pl." l."alief rel;jUel3l:eq 'Py the Pldnt;:l.ff 1 ,YoU I11<\Y lo/ila money Ol:''' /?ropel;'I:~, a!:' achel." dghl:1'l impo:t;',l:i\nl: 1:0 you, ' , YOu 131'IOULJO TAKIil 'l'IUI3 J?APIilR TO YOUR, L1\WYIilR AT ONQIi) , Il1' YOP po NOT,I-I1\VIiI 1\ Ll\WYIilR OR OANNOT AIi'FORD 9NIiI/ GO \\,0 ORT!llLJIilPHONIil THIil Oli'fo'Iclil alilT FORTI'I l3mr.,ow TO Ii',IND OUT, WI-lIilRIil '(OueAN GD1'r r..IilG1\LJ I-IIilIIJ? 1 CUMBlilRI,AND COUNTY BAR l\I3I30CIJ\'1!I01'l , ;l LJ:l./:le!:'l:y Ave I cqr1:l./ills, Pennllylv<\niA 17013 (717)249-3116 1"QOO~990.910a i' ' dl I " 'I :1' I, " 13P,~71/"a3 " I' " .I: " " ", " WM1P/\ URPWN Af\c'\ 1~P1V~N I3IWWN f I P11\~nt:~fffol' " , I y~, I , pwmmr 1<1il1ilf:lf\UQlIMc:'\ ! . PJ,.ou,9!Jl 'rIWPlqNC:l, lNG, f I Refen~Anbe , \, ,i IN 'm!Jl CPuRT,OP POMMPN Pt'IDM '. ,PUMI3PlRI;f\NP GOuN'~'~ f' P/i1NN,9YHVl:\N1:f\ PJ:VII. f\O'~iION - fJf\W 1'10, , ITURY 'l'IUf\T.IP/llMf\NDIiIP " COMPI,AINT t", " ;L, p+Aint:~fj:e WAnclOl Brown E\nc'\ ,.I<evin I3rbwn /\1;'13, /\c:'\\-\lt: ;lnc'\~viql-l/\l/il l:'el'lij:\ina in H/\+,riI'lPI-I+'fJl ,P/\I-Iph~n Gounty, Pl3nn~y;lvAniA\ " , " /1, Pej:eOPAnt: Pwight; I<E!epAI-Igh ~I'l /\n /\c'\ul\: iOc'\iv;lC\uE\l /\m~' (.1;l,t;i~i:m oj: .t:he PommonweC\lt:h" of " Sh~ppenI'lPl-lrg, Mobile 'ml'lb/\t:~~; Pemnayl v/'\niA I " 3" I' :Pennl'ly1y/\nif;\ Shippenl'lbU~fJ' who :rel'l;lcl!31'l /'\t: ~:L' Prf;\nkl~n cOl-lnt:y, ",;' ,," l)efenc'\/;\nt::, 0'101-11'113 ' 'l'rl-loldnfJ, Ino, ,tl'l ,f;\" oOl;'porA\:.;lon , " , w~bh f;\ pl;'inq;lple,plf;\Oe of bl.\fol;lne/31'1 +ootlt:E!cl,tlt:;;lO?13 Ribner !-lighwOlY, I " . , ' ., I Ctlrlil'lle, cumbel;'bocl cOllnt:y, Pel1l1l'lylvOlni~, 4, The fl\ot:/3 Ancl ooql-lrrenoes hereinaft:er relAt:ecl book ,p+OIoe ~~ or !lbbl-lt:,JlIl~ :al, 1~~7 C\tE\Ppro#mAt:ely ;L2 ;40 p,m,,, on. CArlil3le' Pi)l:e' f;\t: the intel;'l'leot:ion of t:he Oal"Ulille Pike And !-lempt: ROAd, CumberlAnd C6ul1t:y,Penn~YlVAnia, , I Ii I ,f\t: t:h.;!,t: time Mc'I, place, Mr~ I 13rown WI\I3 01 frbnusllll\tl PAssenger in '1\ PontiOlo, C:l).'omcl Am clrivBn by Shelb Prl.lnt:y, Me I "I, , " P:rUnlly WtlS troweling in" /'\11 etlet:erl'1 clir,eot:ion ~n, t:he left bne on tl1ec/'\rliele Pike" 6 I, At the ~/'\me t:~lne, Defendant: DWight: I<eebaut1,h, While in the /3aClpe of his employment: with Clol-lse Truoldl1(;t, Ilia" WM operating"a F'ord P-ll30 truok, ownecl by,hia employer, , ' " I;" , " " 1"li 1 " !!., CIIAlt.1 ;{ ", " \, }iunda Bro\~n v. r)illigh\; l~aQb\luglt al1d q101llla 'rruckilll)' I, lno I 1:1., PAPA~r~ph!'l 1 ~ht'o\,\gh 10 o~ the aOlnrlAj,n~ "al'l'l ,i,noo/,'flollMI'lc1 herej,n /:Jyratl'lrenoe AI'! :l.J 13e~ f.Clr~h ~~ 1l'lnl1~h, ' , , , , , 'l~, f~Ain\;itt WRnc1a BPoWn !'lU13~ainl'lc1,PAintul anc1 !'leVepe .. .i,n~\\~'.i,e!'l WM9n inol\-lc1e P\-II: are ri6~ limit:ec1 ~O mI-lHj,Plf:lanc1 c1~13P , , " lAoerfl~icmfl ,\::0" hap ril1h~ a rill anc1 f,ot'aarm/ omc1 a k:aloic1 .. hYP(:lp\!rophiec1 !'lOar f,orma dOll" pI' 13 I fly r(:lafilon of t:he af.orel3dc1 :lnj\n::le13 !'l\.\13\!aina~ by Mr.!'l, Brown, !'lhe was fOl'oec1~o inour liabiUt:y 1;or ml3c1igal ~l'a~~ment:, mac1:lOAt:.i,OIl!3, hO!3pit:aJ,illl1t:,i.ol1!3 Rnq'!'l:lmilal;' mi~Hlellal1ao\-l13 ".. aXPQn(3el'l :lncm effort: to l'e!'l~ol'eher.llelf t9 hf.lalt:h, al1c1 olailJ1 :l13 'I , I ," II .. ,mac1e t:hapef91', ' 1;; Ii I' /IU, fleoal.ll'll'l of. ~he nat:ure of ,her inj,l,Ide!'l, Mrl'l'. Bpown ~f\l'! peen flc1V:lllac1 all!:l, therefore,' aV8rllt:hat, Ilhe may PEl fO/,'oec1 t:o ,tnO\\f,', l3imilar aXpenllall in ~he fi,ut:llre/ ancl olaim i,. made therefor, 1!i, A~ a rellul1; of t:he aforament:ionec1' inj udell, Ml:'13 ,,," BrOWn hM'unc1ergone anc1in t:\ie fut:ure wHl \-Il1dergo PhYI3:lcl'Il anc\ mental", suf.fering / inoonvenienoe in oarrying out her daily, ao~ivHiall, 101'11l of life'll pleall\\rell and enjoyment, and oldm ;l:1l , ,mI'lClf:l therefor, " j' I, , " ,. ,I' hall been <\nel int:h!! fut:Ul'e ,will pe subj eot: t:o great: humilia,tion anc1 emba~ra$sment:/, anc1 claim is made t:herefor,' 17. As a result: of the aforementioned injurie,., 'Mrll, I' " 16, A,. a ra,.ult of the afore~aic1 injuriea, Mr!3, Brown I3roWnhall SU!3tdMc1 Worle loss/ loss of oPPol't:unit:y and a permallent: " " 3 , " , " ,," " I' PpH!H'~ e~p+II~iVfl oe :J\.Ir.~,fil~~p\:~,On!\;t IiImol\n\:. !n\:el.'~fil\: AmI OPIl\:'" Aml.:t.n fl~OI'1Ii'" 'pf '" " :~~tl'1i\-<,r'S"~ I:'fl'.1\l!/;'il)g ClPI11I)\llpol.'Y !\t'p,i1;~l'\\"tpn ," llNQ+NO ~ ROVN~R, p,o, ~ '.", '".,<0 I ,p, II3!i9!i6 " .!iO~ ", 'ron\:~\:rl'1e~ H/I:rri ",P\.l:rll, Pll, :t.?;1.:t. (l 17~7~ 23P-6791 , aO\.lnfilel fo:r P;t/lintiff", I' /IllY , , " I' " I"~ 'I; " j " '. " If, "," I' I' " /, \'. I' :' , ',:J, " " " .1' II I' , , ',; "" I " Ii " " /r" I' " " " " !' ~ I ,,' " " " I " ,," ,; " " ,\1' i/ a .. " " I' I' .. " .,Iid' ., I, " " ",Ii ;. " ,,' " " I' 1\1'" 'I I' oj Jr" 'J I , ld (,i Ii ,,',. " F'! , j'i " " 1/ " , ii' ", , I " " , , " , , "I') I' .. " " in I, ,. , I , .' " " I, " , 'I ;I' " " ." " i< 'I I , ,'; I' '1' " ;, Ii 01' I' _iI I " , " .' .. i! t! " " 1,1 " " I' 'i, , , j,' .' ,I !j i' .' t' .,',1 I ,I; " 'I, I, .,if' I'" 'I, "I< Ii i ~ " d !' :"J ;13 lili I' I' ,!'I " " f ':j ,!, , " Iii " i: 'I I,. 0\ " ';, I' , iH:' " ,I' " " ;1 , " 'i iJ iH';' .' ti /,' ,d' H " ~; ,~ Vi~ " " (( " 'I", I' , " -' ~ .. , ",' lh !' " " I, " ,I JlL~IN'I'II1FW PWNT FOrt ql~'WE N,o, ~ Onllnnl')' pm'" la thl' PlIr\l n I'pnaol1nl11)' PlII'l'lI!1 p\ll'aOI1 wOlllII \!s\llll1dl'l' IIIIl pll'Plll1lahll1pl'a pl'papl1\pllln (hla p'ilal', Ills Ihl'lI\ll)' pf PWI'Y PPl'sPI1 III Ilsl' pnlll101')' PIII'Pl1nl PI1I)' IPI' ilia PWI\ aUfpl)' , " , I., d ' , I1ml. ,llj!J Pl'olpPllpl\ nf hla PI'PjlPI'I)', hilt nlsp 10 nVPll1 111'"1')' (0 Plhpl's, Whlll \lpnslllll(PH mdll101')' PlIl'P J. " vlIl'lp~ lIPPol'!lIn~ tn Ihp plIl'Il\lnll1l' pII'P\II11slnn~pa nml P!lI1dHI\lna pxlslll\ll 111111\ nmllhpl''', ,Thp nlllP\lI1l" \If Pf1l'P I'pqllh'PII by '1111' lnwl11\IBII1P In k\lPpll\ll with Ihl' IIPIlI'PP pflhll1llpl'll\vplvPd, ,,' I' Pn, SSJI (Clv,) 3,021 Mlltomlll v;11ol1l1HvlvlwlnlUt Cn,. 3SR PilI 149, $61\,211 m (194'R)111010l'o v, J1hllndolphlu,3RO 1'11, 5RI, 112 1\,2!lloO (lOSS), .' . .,. ., ' , " , ' ,. " " I. ".' '! ;j' i ~ t "'<' I I ,I,' " " ,) , ;, , 211Il'12.II1lt.l.\MIO " " II .. " I' " /, " " '" IlLAINTIFFS' POINT F()f~ QUAjW,E NO: ~I ", .-,' '''': " , ''- "', j, I' In nl~l, I\il",,'p In >,I~l\l IIw rlllhHlf~Wf\>' PllI1HIIIII\IlH 11~~II11\ln~~, " Cn'llllllll1 v, Ol1l1kpl' Rtlll" CI1011'(;11111 Bnlllll111 ell., ~2H II, 11\IPI1, ~14, (1971)1 HUll IIIH!], Mr\lrH, Plllll1HylvlltilnVQhW~l!llllllllt ~~,2I, " 'I 201 ~42, 1\1I1:1.\~lT(J " I' " " ' I' I' "" iI, I' n J: " " " I' j ~ 1 ' I" " " " Ii I' " ,I " " jf-',i I'",', I' ,,! , " " I' " I', ", II; " " Ii ii' " " .. J.l.LAlNTIFFH~ Il00NT FOR CIIt\IWH NO: ~ Tlwr\lltl nil ~lIal1\l\\l Ihlll Mrs.llrn\Vn \VIIs II pIlHSPI1Il\lI',lnl1 whl\lll,1 IIllhp Ihl1ol1fllw IIP\lhl\ll1l, Th~rl!fllr\l, IIml o\).v\rl\Isl)', Mrs. Urll\YI1 \lllnl1\lllw 11\l1l1l1l\l111, Lh)d v; ThnriillQ, ~6~ 1'11, allPQr, 121, 40 I t\,~\llI~O (I 979)llinMn v. MIIHlIrnvq, 419 I'll. ~46,~ 14 '1\,711276 (l9(i5)1 mll~ y,GI'IIVOij, _ Pili R\lp\lr, ~, 5.60 1\,2\1720 (\ 9R!)), ' .! 'I " " I, " .' I' '"" 'I' ,,' I' "'t " 'I " I' ,I' .' " ' ;'" " " ., " jI' "1, ., I' " "II " II ,i' " I' " I' I' " (I " , ;' " ",. ,I ;, " " "" lOIH),IIIlI.I,IMllJ jl" I, I, " .' , ' I "1,AI~:rIFFRrpoINT 1~"AROIl NP,? , , 'I.. .. lnlhlij ~lIijO 1\ lij IIIhnlll\l\llIlIIl MI', K.\lOhllll~ll ,vila III ,11w111IW Ill' Iho lI~oi\loIllIIQlin~ lIij Iho' ,. \lll1plnYO\l ,1?1'(.;lmIHoTnwklnll, h19" '1111\1 Wllij 01l1l1l1l\l\111I nl1'lhol;ln~ Ilw InlorPll\H,lIoliVllloa,lIflllll'Hor , ""It , 111lHhWijij PI' hlH \ll11pIIlYOI', An \lll1plllYOI' lij 11111110 lhl' IIw nOIlIlIl\lIW\l1l1' lIij \lll1plnYP\l o\lPllitln!l whll\l IIw 1~1l\l1' 'YIIH IIclhm lnllw \l1l1ll'lIP IImlwllhln Iho ~\lnp\ll\l'hlij pmnlllYl1wl1l, " 'l'horol\lro,II'YPII I1ml MI', Koohmluh loho IIl1hlo,lhol1 YIlIlI11\1HI nml C1PIIH\l 'I'1'IIOkll1li, IIw" .. "" IIIHllllllhlo, If, hlllVpvor;YIlII,nn\11I1I\1 Mr, K~obll\1!lh WIIH 1111lllllhlo, Ihol1 YOllll1l1HI 1111111111\1 ClolIHo Trnokll1ll, hlP" WIIH 111111l1l\l1\J, " , "; . I'i" Sfl.ll (Clv,l 4,ll~1 f:l.wLnlIlll, Mnllillvloh v, RnhorlH0I1, 4113 I'll, ~llll, 169 A,2119\ (196\)1 Chuv v, " l!4l1illlll.ljJhln IJn~lluLl!llu1I!1111 CluJl, ?9? F,2d 1265 (3" ell.. 1979), . . " d' I' " ' "I' " i I' .. " lfJIJ"2,1\11I,1,\~n:'1 " I, " " ",' ;I' .I!1LilllTlFFS' IillINT J101~ CllAlwE NO, I~ " ".. '.', , , "'" , " . __, ,1 I' " tvll'a, UmWll I~ Pl1IllIpllll1 I1P' fnll'lrnl1ll mlpl\lllIlQlr \111mll\lI\~lIlpll flll'fiilph phrfilPlIl pili 11. , If'," , " I1wnlnllll1~\llfil1t IlIfiPl1mll11'1. hlPllllVP.lllpll\1o 1IIl\IIlIHtl'PSH IIH rPllll.\1I1\lY\l fihp Will "IlIl\I1'1lIn lhp I\HIll'll, nH n I'Pfilll1 pfhlll' hdlll'lllfil I' I' {' Pn, I'l:'lJI (~Iv) (i,0 I J11 Mlli'l1hv v. TIIYlol'. 44U Pn, I H6, ~(i9 ^,~114H(i (1970)1 QUlUlliiul1nm v, Dllvlq,. I' (iH,H J1./3I1PP, 1030 OJ,P; Pi" 19H"),' , , . " :: '.. 'I Ii i ,i' ," I' " , t',-", oj' ,i ,t F " , , "'i i, .' " " " " ,I' 1',. " " I ~ ," .' Ii " " " " ' IOI'42.1\1l1.1,\~fI'<1 .' I' ;,i' , ,! I' " II '\' " " I' " I JlLAIN'I'illEB' pqlN'I' FO!{ OIIMClE NO, 17. A>> nW>>\l11 nl' Mr>>,llrnwlI'>> It,h'rl~>>, Iwl' 11I1>>\1l1ml, I<\lVIIlUrpwlI, 1l111)' III>>nll\l \lllllll\lllln ~'111l111!J~>> hll~~lt nil III>>>> PI' \lnIlHPrllllll1, Ynllll1l1r l1\lhll'll1h1\l IIn'IIWIII'II pl'lI1\llluillrylhlmll!J\lWln " " MllllllJll' v, Bml\~lnllt ~"~ PilI Sltpur 37,422 ^,~II 664 (lORU), ' ".. -- '''" H !! l. 'I " I, " II' II' ,,;' " " I.' , , Ii,,; " " I' " .' d" p I' " " " " 20IW,11I11.1.\MT<1 " , , ~ " 'I' " " "t , " I< t, I, 1<' " pC\v~q HI 11q;t' the 1,\1\:\10," IU"''1\1:l1~C1 V\'f\in\: H I: ' " " l!lQWf\:l7Q l~ I Knfl\HHl, TV ,1~I.1qll;\;1'O ~Qt' the Pl'lf.enc\tl,lll: I' CP\1vl: ^clm:l~:l~\:rat~r " I]]fle , .' iI " " '\! ,i " 1,\ '\r " I, " .. " I' li " If ;! q " , " ,,' '1' "I' ".' " I' " I' " '[I I' ", 'I, I' '1. " 'I " , " " , ~ t " " " " , I' I, , " " , " " , " " "I' " " "II ," I,', " t'll " " H /i " "', I' 'i. " " " H " I;! ,-; ~ y ':\ j-, <', " 'I , " " j. " " I:, \ ,. ,I ", ,it " ii' ,j; II' " " " "p I',. " " " 'i I, ,,' " ') I' '1" '1. " iI. I' I " " " " " I' ," " " , " I' '. " " " " f! I' ,- ii,' " : ,~' ('II ~, "j' M " (01 .,2 .~' ;; It.)~1 i, ,I 11 :c: I..)r~ ,i' , ~ " " .," n... (;)~ 'T .,...i' 'I, ," '~ . it I ", ~. ~ ':\j,(l I, " " G h', 110 t;~., " " " , ' t-' HfB !I ," " :,~J~ ,l5, .~. "I,' I' ?b r>~ I' m ,," t::r 1;' Ii" ,II , , " " "Ii " '" ! " " , ," " " ':' " , , 'I; " " 11, " lj I' " ";H' " I' :,.-' It I' ':, 01' " " , " " " " I' " ,;,1 " I' " " I, If " " I' I,'" ti, " " " I , I' ''" , , '1'1' ,I' II " , , WANPA m~PWN 111111 KnVIN m~()WN, 'I " " J!lnlnllm " IN 'Illll PDPIrI' OF mMMON J!WAfl ,CWMmlHIANI) COUNTY, fll\ ' , .. VH, 1 I CIVlf,MTIPN, lAW' NP,9!l,?'p GlvlI ' ,JURY TIMl, !)f~M^NPmV PW.(CIUT KIlI\!lI\\KlH 111111 , Pl10\1HIJ TRlJCKINC1,/N(!" , P\lf\llllhllllQ ,r'" PLAINTIFFS' J1RlJ.'mIAL MEMORANIlliM .. , I. {\ Slnlolllonl of'th~ (lnslo Fnols ns 10 L111\1!11t~ 'I'hls \l~SO Involvos II l11olpl', vphlplo lIopl\lolll Ihlll' oooll1T\l11 1111 ,J\lI)' 41.199.7, III 1119 , , , ;"',-", , IllIorQo~tloll ofllw Cnrllslo Plko n\llIH\lnlPt ROlld, At tho 111110, tl1\l flliilnlln;WlImlll Ur\\WII,'WIIS II ," 'O'ol1.t,sOIlI p1lSS0111l01' lllll vohlol\l d\'lwll b)'Hhplln Pnl11l)'1 Ms, flnml)"H,whlplo WllHlrllwllnll ollsl ' ' ", " ....',,, , 011 thp ClIl'llQl1l J1lkp,l)of'ol1dnnll<oobll\lllh, whllp IlIp SOU/IO uf his omplu)'lllOllt wlth,Pofllndllnt .. , , I CIU\ISIl Tnloklllll, 111OI,p\llloll fi'ull1 tho stup shll1l'llllompt' 1~l1nll, dlrooll)' Illto tho p1lSS0111l01' sldp. PI' ',' " - ,; , Ms, Prnlll)"Q v~h1910, 1,<0 II, A S!nlolllonl of'tho Bnslo Fllots liS 10 PmnngOij '11, , " J Iy/rs, Bl'Own sllstnluod sowro,d~op,llIeorntlulls OV~I' h\lI:r1llht plbow !Iud rlllht bleop lI\'on, All , ,,' " ' I1mbuhlllo\l tl'llllsportod her to tho HlIrrlsbul'll IhlspltuI111';' sho IlIIdorwollt nil opol'lltlnl1 IIIVolvlull, ' ',; ,\ ,\ , ,'" , lrrllll',llnll, II~hrldolllont, uud W\l\!ud OluslIl'o, PI', Wllllnlll DoM\lth, nu orthupolllo S\1I'1l0UI1, I' porfol'llled tho Surllor)' I !' ",j' ' Thorounor, Mi's, llmwlI dldwoll fl'om11l1 orthopedic stuudpullll, au MUl'ch"l!. 199H,j!lwl,l, " Ms, UI'/lIVn'S kclold S'1111'8, Dr, DeMUlh I'cruned Mr~, Ilrn\\'ii In Dr, Robol't Wlllf~ n plnsIl1.l811l'l!cnll, " , .1 " ., AUlIched liS Exhlhlt A Is n p1wtoeop)' urn phnlnlll'nph tnkun of'MI'H, B1'llwn's rll!ht olhq\\', I,' I' 2IH~127, 11I11.l.lMHI, " \, " '-i" '" ~ ;{,-:(t,-},;:f\,f},,~~::; j , I " " - . - 0'_ ,1',:-,-,;;, ,- __ ': -"c' JI\t.',~ ~ "--_ ~ - .; i. }l, ~l;~~::::\"!~,~,:':':"" ,,:' , " M~~~AtM""Mf,',;.,i1__d...,\o!;i"I""~~<""''''_'~~J\.~',~,";~~ I' '1:\." ,. i 'P'Ii' ':\-" "';1 q !" ", , ",,' , _' i':,r., ,\;;' :;.1, ."Jd--'- ',I, _ ...,-',t i,"('_", ':!'l,/ ',l..",.,"~+" .-+"'.....\;........~.I\....'I"~"".'l'W...U....."*',~I.1f~~I~ H.;l ,,~I._~..:f'" '" \J " /If" I' ,I} /; " 'I' ;, 'I " I' " :1_'lJf 'I " " " " ," ", " " " " ,II It " " , ,II ii',' " , I' " " "-" , " ,\ ",,, ,,' ", I' '" 'I' It " " " ''I' '.1. ;'-:.,; , ' "I .. , " ," ... ii":", 'I '" " " 1/, " ,I' .',1 I' " "',' I 'f! I' " " " {I '" ',:/';" '" ,1" "Ie, ;, " ," " " " ii' " ", " " ,I " " " 'I' 'I, 'I" " ;/:'11 ,\ " I' ,J: ~: I ~"" '.7~:,;"I," '~~_'iI f';,\__"'-ii' '-"'\, I: ',', " .'1;' " ." " I i;r " II " 11;"';;'" Ii" -',r' " ".','!I' ;.:i 'if :', " "-, :1 /I ,>I ",' [;n~~?7?~iltk" 'rnr 'I___r-_:",,< :1\ ',-'~';'M;Y": ", ,,;'; I/i~'//t " ,;\,' ~;;' ,~i,;'?\\,,\'l;:: ',j> 'lcn-'.: i'! i~'. tll ~!_ , _, _l~, ' ';-;-,-!'il' ;;j '-, " .,.1( '-,'" ~,.d 'J' " - . ~ "I"""" I /I " ,1"" " " ~ '; '.II ' 'I;,"~ ," " ' " " '!, I' . ~' ,j, I' 'j , I' " " " , ,,' " l' , ~', ,:/, \ \ \ I " I, " ;1' l' " 'I'; f' " I' " !'t, I' " "" i' " " " " ,I' t:'I-h i/J ~,"I-/~' I"~ Ii IX""IT :It " ',1,-" / " i-' " 'I '.. I' '1(' " il' ,,' I ;t " " " 1\ If' " " ;, " ;1, Ii 'I' I' ,,'j! " " " " ", J, " " ,'] " ;{ ~H . H' ,i, " , ' " ",1 I' " " " " I' I' , ' ~ I I' J',' " I' I' r' .' " " 1 " 'I' " " ,,, " " 1 I' I', " " "l< "/I Ii " ''.'1 I' ., , , !t-' " i " I' " I', 'I '" ;, " "0 ",' " , ,I , ,';(,//.1::; '\~J'~l ': " I , ,t _:1 \:1/. II I' ,J 1\ " '" " " Ii J ~ ' , ,; " f\ ',i', I.':", " , " , " " " " .' " 1/ ,'," ';1 I!,' '" ," fI '"' " " ,I " " " " ,., :J' " , , " I' "I' i, ,I' 'I " -, "h --II' it; I' "", ," " " ';j!! " " , 'I, "" I I. ' .' " ".."" '.I"\~ ~~,,~~~ , ,JQ.,'ITJ<., ""'lilt Jllllm'no, OOW ~rvl9Ot) .,..." , ' UllkM\OO~~l<fiMfll O'.,I~ ol'lm, 1'!\lCI" na \'hIIJdtlphl. p .~ fnlcOfl na. ro~ III\~atfll ~Vllt. ~l"~!\l-lV ~~ T,ll. rIll'll , ' lIl(I\~'JQN ~T~TPIl I' ~()" ~gJl~ " ."T J.llVJt. !\l"J'RQVAl< V,I\,'fl\1eI1 ' 1",^,~-)'I1 t.f. ^' Pfmko ' " "01 mQIll'nml\(W) ,I'll" ml'MlT ,. IM.UlIlR Oll P~CT mtl'QRll '1'tnn,~~pll ,. ' lI~ompll . 'fn\Al1 ' IMflllR all lNlllJMl111tml " ' ,,' " NATUI\'Il ANP 'liOOPll OF JlO~l1'.qN , unctlll'llIlI. ctlf4ll\lllon of,ll\e Chllma 'fllllm Lead\lf1lhl8 poslllon 18 'fe8ponslblll fur Ide, .111ltYlos "od' fellPllOdlollll'i " >>MO, mom\J!ilflUld pnwlder I1nllQernS al1\\ Intlll rills relalod 10 liMO hsl\08 IIl\d I\ssl.lIl1/:1 In Ih\llr fllsollllhm. In addltlClll III pfoClluloa all pOBI-paYI1I01l1 al\l\Islm\lnls IInd ftnaoOIIlII\~1I8lmol1181 ,', " . , To 1l~l1llvely MOil thele I\Q(l(lllnlllbl\\ll\ls, tho 'nollmbonl mllll bo lhorollllhly kl1owllldsel\blo wllh pllll1 \Jenoftll, " pf(lcOIsloS I\lld pllyn\\lllt pl1l\\lI\l8 IIl1d pll.81l.. /:Illod Inlolflcrsfln81 an\\ 110mmlil\loftllon 81<<11" OliO 10 tho short ..... limo A'""e ~Illrl\\llulllly !l\1I,ndllled fur 1111 almomer Inquiries lIod al\llllll11eOls, Ih\lln\lllmh\lnl mUll hllve el!:QeIlClnlllme mllolsllmelll.kllls,lInd bClllblCllo work Independ\lnlly,'l'he In\lum\Jonl provide" (l(l1lf\eOIlI IU\d IIaO"fllle repll\ll to 1\llepl\ol\o IlIId wrl\l\ll\ Intllllrllls. Addlllol\l\l\y, the 'nollmbenl IIlllll hllVll"thOf(lIlSh 1cn0wledllCl ofth\l all\hr" ayslom, " " . a. p b, a, a~noUilC ACCOUNT AntLITmS '1. l'rllmoto memhef 9!1tl.liIotlon of tho heatlh oaro daUvll1")' ~ysI\lm by provldlnlllnfbrmRllonupollreq"Ost. 'l'hlslnvolve8l' ',.. . , " Promp'ty aoknowledSln8 Ihe Inquiry. Illlplalnlna bonllfill and payment prooedures,' . ' InvClI,ISlltl08 IInd ro.ellrohl08 the problem In queJtl(\l\ vll\ Iho CR'r pmlllltClrfllolns with Ilthor atalf memberl,". ", , d, RCllolvloB thCl aancorn '0 1\ timely manner. , cl. " ' ,_,I Provldlll8 II Qourteou~ and Inlbrmatlve responle to tho pllrtlo~ Involved Cllther by letter or ,. 'CllepholtellilQllmllo, ' , " ''-' 'I II , a41l8^ <W4 ' " ,,"-I I' ,,_". '9 t;, .' 'cltl!l1f PK~mn~ CK>>P ~rvlll\I') rq.~ ., '., 11IIl~ aQ, m.I , Ma~.M~M ." " "I' !I " R"plln4lnll ~1l1"ql1lrl\l' within \lQnlr~QII1Allr IIllr!l~ I1p\lllllm~ II'Amll', a,^dJl1ll IlllllmHlO PP'I.pllrm~nt h. MI..p IIltllr rlllm~\lmmlln~, Tilt. mllr rllql1lrl,l ppmplIll1l rll.prIlPIlI.lnll \If . . Ihllllllllmlllnp.I."~lnll ll/lp\l\llllllln pfmll4.I~1 ppllpy, prhllnlll \llll, , ' , Pll~rm plllliJk vpl~1 fm~ t1nAnclllllldjluimcnl.11l \lmlll r"ll1mlld pllrmllnl', Rllq\llrll \l,qllll.lv\l cllllm. hl.11l1)' r41.~rllll.pl,"ml 1I!\11l11mllnll' 1I1l~ Illll'" \lllordhlllll\ln wllh f'lnIlIlQ\l IIlId ~h\l ~1l"lqmllr, Mil)' f!lltlllr\! ~Ilv~ppm\ll\1 ~p PQmpl\lll,llhllllollv Ir, " '., ' . ." " " ,,' " " R\lvlllw IIm/rllPQlil pfpn,lvlpl1.1rplll~ QllIlm.,ldllnllfY \IIlllllt\jllllcllllml fll'llllrlllll r\lprp~e8.1118 M .' Idllllllfllld ~)' ~ho \111..IPmllr (1'IlIm.lIllllvo\lonlrlll1l \lhllnll\l'), " ~,. ,MpllItPr, ldllllllty IInd r\lporl HMo Qllllplll\lr QPII\l\lm And ,Inqllll'}' Ir\lllda Ip Ih\lllll\lld\ll\d~r on ~ rllaulftrl)' .ohlllllll\ld ~IIII., , " , , f, ~, " 1.1 ~ ; ~~ Mpn\l\lr, rIlPQr\ llrid p~tllln 1111 QPlltrllQllIlI1 allllldllrdll'lllllllld tp Job IlIlkl, , IdonllfY IIfIll\I pfHMO melllber dlllllUlfI\ollon ~Ild nelldft for addltlonlll.ervlllel or prod\1ot8111l~ repprt .1l11h Informa\loll to mll1l~llllmclll, " , . , ,"-- 1\llylew pAr01lln! odllll.lllIllon RWllek-1Y bllllllp Idtll1llty olll101 paY!11\lnlllITora'lllld Idllnll!yQltllml!o b\'!" 114\l"~\lI\lQllXl" Ifom paymllnl proceal" '. . i. " ' , " .i, d' R\lvl\lW Shlll101\ln! pfRcml1lanco VO"Qhe1'8 IInd EXP1I1nllll~il ofJ3ollol\1sllll11melll. weokly. 10, 'Pcrfb!ll1 qUlIlllyoonlrol revlllWI of A\llhorlullon SPOClllllhllllS l'\lqu"lll,ld, ,.' . I" I' , 11, UpdMe and O1I\II\lIdll,1I1I pettlnenl r\ltilrllllce mlltenal", .' 1~; ~~.l.t Sr,l\evlowe'r/Anlllyslslnthe QIlIIUly Conlrul ofRllvlewer/Analyats In trlllnlnB.aa nlllldlld, , ,1~, Porfbtmolherdutles Imd Ilulsnmentllls dlrecled, , ,I,;' (,t' ' '."" ' '-' " ,;\' I. /I " ,. .' " ;,', , ",'j, RllPP~ IPI flt:fWQ1llr . t:mplpye\l: " !:lpplpl ~IlP NlJm~!lfi j,I I " , , I:mplpypp Prpfll~ Fpr, " Rppprl P~11l1 IUl/17/1 PIlIl Q173f1\1 M.., ~mwn,W!ln~!lh ' ~P~4ft14PP " i=lTlPI ~lpIIJP: Aqtlvlt, .. ,.1' , " '" 1'1l1\~ONI\I, !lI\TI\ " " .,'..", . r.., "II',' ,,' -"""" __, gg~ $11l'h 'fHree' H!lrrl.lJlIrp ~Irth PIIIIII ' P,,"lh pplel HlohllPI 1:<< hllWII: ' :, I " , " Qplln\YlTwnphp PpQl11 . ~~ Ii ~PQ [>,', PA, 111Q4 , "Phpnlll 111/~~~,"ft3ft" :' " flllX: 'fem!!I!!' PII'!lIJIQJl? ,.' ' N I:lhnlpl\y: ' Afrln AmQr ' PI!:*!ltlll/~ Vllt? . N ' Mllrlllll Stl1l\lQI "M!lrrle~ Mil a'!ltlllll NQ Mil ftVQ I l1MPI,OYMI1N'I' !lI\TA ,'. , P3/Q'7/1Ilft7 , ,Ha Qr!lq I"", " .,,, , Qrlolnpl.Hlre: RIIPpnl Hlrlll Rllhlr!l flllll\IPI 11/0'7/111114' Vl1ol\lIpn aerv Pille: ., VrwIIlIpn 1:110 PIIIIII "';' p-- '. /. 11/0'7/1 QIl4 T!!Irmlnlllhm Pete: " Oa/01/191lft hl1p\ PIlY Wprkll<<: " ~xpeP\e<<Rllturnl P/~a/1l1 .' " " "Pl\QI\NIM'I'ION PATA l, , OrOllnl~III1Qnl Qm I:;nlry Petel oo~i Ollnler; "" 01llfta Olalmll ProQIl""lno . Nat'l poa OIl/01l/11l1l1i floslllon Num~er:'" QIltlll1 ta~o OQ31l I Ppsn I=n\ry PlIlel OIl/OP/11l11tl JOII PA:"I\ IT 3oilOOO OllllmliJ I=lx!lmlnor 09/01l/11l1l1i alllllry Prog/Gmqe: I:xollp Hrly Grl1de anlry Pelel R Full/Pllrt TII11I1I S\I1!ldl1rcl Hpural Oompllny: hoolltlonl kHB HBTHI:l "0 '~tl~ Tille: . ~P~ antry QI1II1I amploYlle .Typel ReOrrllmpI . I Oa'7 .. " N06 OIl/OIl/199a' fl 3'7,60 ' aao Jo~ Group: aaoo Jtl~ Ode: Shllll PIIY Gr\lf!p: 62 Olllrlolll' \, 1 I' BW3 I,I\S'" 1\0'1'101'1 PA"'A , ; ~lIst, AiJVRllsn: af'eollve pille: Pllhi'~ntereq: P~",n Chg l..oQ. 01/1P/1998 Merit Rilling: 0,1/14/1998 Next Rllvlew PlltS: 06/0~/1998 " COMI'IlNSI\TION PATA 11 Otlmpensetlon Relel ' $ 10,246,00 A 0,36 ~1l~1 Inor Pele: peferred Oomp Pot: ,00% Hourly Rllte: $ 03/08/11l91 , oomml~sl\ln AdJ: $ ,00 "" M\lnthly Rele: $ 1,6aO,42 Ohllnge Amount: $ ,. 0,00 , AnnuIII !3en IlI111il: $ 10,246,00 '. Anhual Rl1tel " ,. ill 10t~45,OO Ohange pot: $ 0;00 , 1lI1NIlFITS PA'f'A " " Vestino '(Bl1ts: 3,00 Rollremont SSIY Pale: 11/07/1994 lUl\1p auii1 Payout? 'll11neflt Yel1rs; 3,00 Retirement .Pilrl.Pl1te: 12/01/1996 aRISA Houts: ,.631,83 Stllak Yeats: 0,00, VIP allglblllty Pslel 03/01/1996.!I.OA Hoursl 0,00 VIP Vestlhg Yellrs: 3,00 VIP partlo Patol "Tote I I;RIBA Htll: lJ31.B3 VIP Sl1lalY: $ ~,OOO,11l Group NUm~ori 06413602 I. ' i" H'~'~l\CI!:P'J'JON 'l'IMW 'tNq\J~RY < "" COMf'I\NY 1~1If:1 ruMP lP 1'1300 . f3f~oWN I WI\NPlI It , .';, cop\.') l\ I;'MI-/\ ^ NONluXIi:MI)fl' , ' 1;'HoM P/\'l'~l O:IQlP? ' '1'0 PM'liJ 1;J31,p9 COf:1'l'PWN'l'ruR 0039 ~WWK~Y HRf:1 37rop , I' VAOM't9N r~Rf:10NA~ *HRf:1 'l~r~Mt 0,0\1 ,.00, truJ,,~O IJI\'l'Et 01019U 010190 t luTlllNIJJDt 90,00 6;1,00 \-' t PHliJV !3/\I,t ,00 " ,00 tqww J3^~t' ,00 WI' PI\'( PM'liJ com I 1ft 13 IPNI~ IPMIJ1\ COf:1'I'c'l'H f:1'1' D1\Y P1\'J'b1 CnI~ 1mB IPNIJ 1"~ljJ{l. CQf3'l'C7.'R , W\i1 07169'/'0 ,,50 N 0039 MO 00049'/ ',I' " ,/',60 Y 0039 071- (WI 'Y " fH ;1,76 N 0039 MO 09n9'?> 0 1 ;(.0 N 01l3p MP 072197 V 3,76 N 0039 'I'l] 09(.39'7 0 ;1 ,\ll3 N 0039 1'\) 0'7ilfl97 '1' , '7,60 Y Ofl39 wm 09;149'1 0 1, 'I;! N " Olnp " W~I 07;!397 'I' '1,60 Y 0039 , '1'1'1, 09~1i!J7 0 ,53 N 003$ TH ,0'7;11\9'7 'I' 7,1;0 Y 0039 PI!' 09;1fip'l' 0 "1,'11 N 003p li'H.o7;JE97 '1' 7,60 Y 0039 131\ OP2'1~'1 0 "1, ;/8 H Oft31) Me) 07;1097 tr '1,IiO y 0039 WIn 10019'1 V '1,50 N 0039 T\) ''I' 7,50 Y 9030 "1'1'1 1.002P'l 3,40 .. 0830 onpp'/ 0 N wm 073\1P7 T 7,50 Y 0039 PH 1003P7 0 3.00 ,1'1 ,0039, J'li 07319,/ 'I' 7.1i0 Y 003p B/\ 100497 0 5,08 N 01l3p' Ji'R 0001!)7 '1' '/" 60 Y 0039 MO 100697 0 ,Ii? N " 0039 PJi'~c:IJmllr;> pf'3 c: lUX I Il' ~ PIP,/c:PRIW> I'Ji'Oc:N!iJX'l> " I' , I' " " h P" ", "I! ", " ;! ' I' ';; I, i' ,I', " ,: ,j /' " 'I'" " ,,- "~I iJ, . . ;\ I. "1\ I'"'' ilh""li},YJjfAtlI!t}~t.il/;r '" " ~l;fl''iM.''",\-, ,tl~fl'lrli'it 'j' ; ,'/r ";1' IT''''o,, .', "", " I:' I' }1:r{.,.11\I':,i"'"""""" ',', ,'" 'I "j MKt1'IIIITQ \. ",:,,",,:, "," h' _1~~ftt~~~W"'M~I!.lM'1M;\\I"~~""':';~;M',"",m~;i'''''~'"'~,~,\(l\,,,""~~~,4~",;./ ", ", ~'\\~!l'lr_~ 1,( ',1' " " ,I ,.' " ",' " 'I" " " "" 'I ".. "j, " " 'I " " " " 'I ,I, " ,,-j 'J: " I'" ,I' " "I" " " " " " " '>I' " t, I' ,,' "t ,/ '" I' ';j, " I(",t:',. " ;',','1," " " 'Ik j " " ,:f " " , " "'j I h 11,\' f'" " " " I " " I' " " I', ',I, j:':;", , , " '" ", ";' I, " 'I"~ " ,'I) I' " " " "n,,';),I) ,i',i; 'I,,: ", " " 'It, "I,' it'.' ",J' , " ,: " I' " " ,I,' I' :1 q" , !,i J ,I I' '" " "~I, :1,:1' " " "" ,:~)\' ,,' ,-'l ~ "" " , " ,p " " I' " " .. " I' ", " ,,' '''''11 " ;" " ,Ii, " " " , ", ';1' I " i, " I, ;1 , 'II " !, ". ~;-IT"f~'l-..,.~,,,",..,.,r',T' ":''''\'I/~il.'~,/I:; ,-':;, ' " " Ii . "'~:' . i /1' 'I Ii U;I '," I' " ", " " ,,' , ,; ", " " ;i: '," . u" " ':. ;', , I " '" " ,,' i; " " " "" ,," ~ '"":' '" "" '\ "'I,. " ~~n'!l\'i-l;1~rl"'i '-'\.l!~;;~lj~,~,; ;'(,',j,;n')\!,:, ,'; r}'!~", '/.,;,-';',','/".-;"", I, "'''-''' I, II ;'\'" "!I " I' I; vJ~ () f+ "JevlN I' V~t ,. , J \^/~c.lV\4- ~e..RbtU\6~_ , . C4~ VI U6JM}-Ildit.. B{'\~~ IOro\.-\lN .., Il1ll1u (:lll1l'lnr Cllll1 III nil I'I~II~ nf Cllll1l1vl'lnllll ()nlllltrl."~III1~rlvlIlIllI Nil, _iq - 5J3> ---, Clvll,lQ ':ill (.t-iLt1vi~:rq1!:Y- -----'-:-:-----0_ I' (lJe CL~~ ,,~.I..L(~ 1'ir\-ldJ,LZikt~ ,o),xiw: C?o(2:\1(JV11) cA~{d.Qh~ ." -~---~DAvl t2. Wt-? . " ". ' . -,--QQJJ.,.&(~(--r-a <2-~ Il\If{:~' Ii. " '1'0 ~o \/, S> I q '!.1-rq-.:.. Prulhlllllllllry' I ~ 1 _,,1~9"': " . -._- --- '", .., AlIllfl\OY I\lr Pllllnllrr ",;. Ii' i",> " I'l' '1" li;"\' 'L, "i;' 1 ',\ I r },j 'I' , 'I 1''- " I' ,! ,. " , " " 'I r Ul i~:. - " \,~tJ \1.:.1 ~: i ~~. "'1"; I", ....'. ;1: l )"1 .' !,I. f;'ll q. t'".:, ';~ ',.. " ('1''\'' In ' "Ii'" ( (.r) : I : j'},.r.; 1'(' ~\I! r 1,1,\1 ". I;: ~,tJ \ . ii" "I!: ,,, " U~ ", .. l~i () " I, " " Ii I' 'I " ,! " ,-: ,. I, " , ,; " '\,1' ij' " I' " " " I' i' ,I' " ,I. I' ',i " " ;j' 1', .t " " ';"';=-'::C:'=O'::;:",~:,;,;::=:;,;.~=::"=:::".~::",;:;~;,:::':::::: I,;;o,:,;,.,;'::r;-,:,~=:;;::;::..-:::::::"r.:':~~,_,:,;;,,~"~-::::~:c:';':.::::,::,::::,'o::::c:::",," i' II 'n:::'~. "::-.-;: -.-;::=-:F~ ::-;;:-:;::;-,''':::;;;;:;:--.=.::;;~ ~::: 'C.:::.:-.:. __ .,_ .. ,_ I' ;'i jI " " j'rl J., ~ ., '" ,.~' "'"i {"O .,,~, J~,' ,~,~' ~ iii i '" l!' ~'8", ~ ~ ~I ~ ~1 8 " ,I; ;t" " ~ j ;, " Ii q, 'I 't' ", --.--=--=.'=,.--- " -'-::'::'~:':::;:-;:--j~".,-:::.--~r=:=-::==:.._._..~~~.._~ '-::..-:===---.:::=.-:.. nit ", 'I 'I 'i! ,I J; " Jr I' I' I' d !' , " .. i\ ~ '., j," 'I,,, WANPA m~OWN nml K1WIN m~OWN, \lllllnllffH, '1' V. IN '1'1111 COUH'I' OF aOMMoN PLEA~ CtJMllnj~I~ANP COUNTY, " JlllNN~YI~ VANIA CIVil-, MJTION I-AW NO, p~.~13 PWIOUT KnnMtJOllnml cwu~m 'I'HUOKINO, INc" " lU1W TRIAL PUMANPEO , PUfbndnl1lH, " J.RAECII'JC II00l SUIIS'lil'I'U','ION OIl VICIUlIICA'I'ION '1'01 'ThpYrnth\l11l11I1r)' , I PlolIHoHnhHIIlIl\O lhu I1l1l1uhu" Vol'iflolltlnnlhr, tho VOI'II1~nllolllll' C()nn~ol hi tho AI1HWUr to tho C\ll11plllhlt flIull by 1)01'1l11dl\ll1H. " HOHpou1l\llly s\lhmlllc\I, , Mlnzqn,l~, WICKl1HRIINv1, KN^USS& \i,Rll. P,C" B)'l , '~--? /'~.:--. '" ..... r', ~~ ,,~ bc-_//:?-,~",............A-o-1~.~, 11\lwllrd Il, KnA\lss, IV, Esqnlre, ^1t(lI'I1UY W, 1'10,109919' ., 32tl 1'1, Fl'ollt Slreot l-llll'rIHhnrll. I' ^ 17\10-0300 (717)238-8187 ", ' " 1)1\(01' 7';i/f? ,j'" /J,It'I""'''' H: !4P,YN.1 Ii, I', r'" 1, 'i' ~ ':, "" ~ 'I ,,' c:~(,~-<"rtvvl ~..-&.(~ ~,dQ h~r\lh>, v\lrll~ Hmllh!l fMI~ ~\llfl1,~hln Ihll f!lr\llJnlna'^n~WIlI' !lrll 11'\I1I1I11(1\11l1'l'II\1llplhll tJII~1 PI' Ill>' p~r~pn!ll kl1Pwlll(llllIlll' Infnrmnllllll 1111~ " '\I\lllllf, 11I11\1\lr~llIlI~ 111111 Oll~\l ~tnlllIlWII\& hlll'Plnlll'lIl11l1(11I Rllt,llllllln Hill p\lnlllll!l8 of I R PII,c,a, I "" , , , ~4!l(J4, rlllllllnl\ Ip \l11~Wprn Ihlpllllllllh.m In 1II11hmlll\ls, , i" 1\ I', I " " ';'" , Ol\teIL1~:<'J .rrr._ ,I, ; ,. ,; " ,'I 'f " " , , 'L ;1 ',1 ,;, " I', I, !! I. ",' H", I, ,," " " " , " ,p' " , i, " " " " i'i f " " " "I, CICll'I'WICI\'I'IC 011 SICltVIOO I, I\IIWII\'\I H,~I\I\lISS, IV, nSII\I\I'U, Ut' M~IZIl\l\'" WI~k\lI'Hhll\n, ~1111\'sS ~1l1'\1, I',p" '" 1I\1\l\'ll\l~H till' P~f~l1\hll\ls l)wlllhl Kuuhll\lllh 1111\1 C\\l\IS~ 'I'nwklnll, 111~" hUI'\lh~ ~~1'1If'>' Ihllll ' SIJI'V\llllhIJ lill'IJIlUlnll, PfII~\llru till' Rllhslllllllun uf Wl'ltl~lIllnn Ihls '12- IIII~ ut' Apl'lI, lllllll, \I~ , dUpOHh1111! s,'nw In lh~ \.lnllell SllIlus 1111111, pustllllu pl'uplIl~l, 1\11 ,<, , , Dllvld 1.,'1.\117., Ilsqllll'IJ Anlllnil &. HlwnUl' 4503 N i FI'\1nt Sll'cul 111\\'1'181111I'11, PA 17110 CO\l\lsc\ for Pllllntlffs I' " ';? d: ".. ~~/~. ",', /'" .~.i (HdwIIl'dH, ~nllllss,.IV " " " 'I " !' \ " " 'I .,,11 I' \ I' , " " I' ,', tl " " I' < '" " I I " " "., '" I' i' " , ,..\1 "ltl, " " '''f ,'i I, I " " I, " "" 111'11 " " \' " , " , " ,\ it;:: ,,"' r: -, '':':1 (... I,' 1.1~ ?(.l; 1l1I,,! "11) ," II'. ~;I,/. I ~.'<: ,,) :~,t' , I,,' II.. ',1 ~'j ,f!/)l' \... ", i III ,;\' 1~(1 til' (,,) .J .{'!' 'I " r"li' ,,,j I Fi~ ,(11,\.. I t:)" ~'J 1\, (:1'\ ," d (,"1 (.1'1 " I' ,I" i , " '". " " " " " I ',f' I. ",1 "" '" ,I' ,-t',' ", "f/; ", " " " " " I, " I, ", ,!' ,,' d " " " " " " ,~\ t I, .\1 ti I,. 'I'