Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-00835 '" " n , " IIICI,I',IHilCl!I, IHcM, IC~"'i\'I',~ I'HUII'CRRIUN~IiRI 1'111 hll I 1'1' I IN.'I'IIIC COllin nil COMMON l'I,leAR ' I fJ\J~IIIIClH,~NI) cmJN'I'Y, I'ICNNRYI,VIINft\ " I I, I I NO, !J!J,"~~ ' I , I CIYII, IIG'I'ION - II'I'I,!\.W' I I I I ,I, ,.,' .. \'Ht HOmCH'I' 1111 VNW~ 111111 I~i\'I'''',ICICN 1111 VNICR, hllHhlllllllllHlwll'l'l " IMIJIllllllltH" ';, , " " ,1'1,!\.lN'I'WII'R HlWr.V '1'0 IlIWICNJ>AN'I's' NIC\YMA'I"I'ICIt illill l'IUg,IMINAltY Oll.llCC'l'lONS '1'0 mWlcNllAN'I'S' COtJN'I'I~ltcLAIM ,ANIl NOW, ~PIllIlS PIIIlllllff, 1llllp,U,Solll\lllllllallllll Jll'nfuaalol1l1la, hy 1I1\111111'U1lllh lIa IIl1ornoys, l\yu!!Or !Ii Adlol', P,C" 1111\1 ~\lhl11l1a lIa I'oply In l)ul'ol1dllllls' I\OIV 111111101' IIlld 11l'1J1I1I111111ry ol11uolluI1a I~l, tho , PQliJI1Ih1l11s' 1lll\lIllcl'olllhn IIml hi suppnrllhoronf IIvors IhoJoll11WlIllll " .' ,. " ;.1' " Ii i " , NliJW "IA'I"I'lCI! 3!J, No 1'0Sp~11lsll rOlllllrlld" " <In,.. f)lllllotl, Tho llVOtlllollls nl'plll'lI!!l'lIpll <In CUllsllllllo onllchlslulls of hlW'IU whluh'llo' " ' 1'0spOl\slvo plolllllllg Is I'oqllll'od, To Iho oXIOllllhlillll\lIl1SIVOI' Is dOlJlllul/'i'oqull'od, Ills spcolflolllly dOllloll Illlil tho PIli hll 1 1'1' did unl IIclll1gpod I'Ill1h IIl1d wllh CIUIIII hllllds, Ills Illrlllol' dOl1llld 1IIIIIIIio Pllllllllff tilllQd " In dlsclllSIJ 10 tho llllyol' IIl1d Iho DOfoIJdlllllH Ihollllllll'O nflls IIg0110Y l'lllllllollShlps, /; , , ' "I, f)ol1lud, Tho "Y~l'llloIJIH of pllrllgl'lIpll <I I cOIISlhlllo uOllchislulIS of IIIIV Iu whloh 110 l'OSlliillSlvo plolldhl!!ls 1'0llllltc<1. <12. I)Olllod, Tho IIvotlllollls uf PIlI'II!!I'lIpll <12 o\lIlSlllulO cllllOluslollS of IIIW 10 whloh 110 IOHPOIISlvo plondh!!! 1III'oqull'od, " ,'.., " -" " " " " (!l i! ,\. '\ " " " ~~~l'~~~ (~'~I ~f1lt, H9~ I V~!l'lll ~rlVP" " " m~~ll ~q~Wrl 1m 'I' " MVHV ~"~N~P4V 'P'~ '~U'QV , ~UflV~U , " " ',1)\ .. " .. ;, " .. I; " " .. " .. n.; " !; 'h, " !, ',. .. ,I: " ,... Ifl '," I,' " rl~\ {",~ , " I.', Ii') . " " "If -.11.:1 II ., -- I_I,.;'; " ,'I",' . " P'" " ~F'.: " .. ,1 " " 1'\1; " (.\-, 'Fl I'; " ,1'1\\"\ :'L'(I .. ..... hl i (1'.., <i:,l,I ,', if if', " I' 't ,'" (" , f"\"\ , !\ 1,IJ;1' t.~ IOl\.. "" '-' -', 'j !i~ I.' !' -'J.' " .. " oJ' \1- I.',!, d" " ,) (,n " " " !Iii ,'I ,,', " " ..' " " (, "i, .. " " " " , " ,I- .. , .. " " " " "ii' " " , .. " ., " '1\ ",' " ','i !; \'1'1 ;,; "' " .. " .. " " d ,. .. .. " " .., " ,< " I' " Ii /-1, ,I' " P " :., .. ,', .. " i' , "" II! , " .. " I' " " " " " 'I ,; . 'I, " .. !' I:' ',i l. , h\WH pl'\ll\l tJlllI~\1 fl\l\\\lH (~P\lIiIIlD,lIll\\llr\lll\lll\ld IIw \lnnlrll~\ wllh P~I\ll1llllIlIH (Pm1l1l .' I V), ^ hplIl'Il PI' 1II'\11lrnlnl'H l'iil~\1 ~,I 11\ liwnl' PI' PlnllllllT nn ,11\11111\1')' 17, 7,000, \11111 Pol\lIHlnnlH Ilpp\llll\llh l'i'I'i\.'1'1CMICN'I' nt,' nA,HI(J IIi\(J'I'H t\1'i '1'0 l,lt\nll,I'l'Y " , ~, In Mnl'oh, II)QU, Plnh1\IIT l~pll\lrll', IlnYIl\lHII\l\l\lpl\ll\ n 11'lRlllnllllH I I \l1l1'1ng , .. 11xlImhwl' ''',I\li Ilw Pllbll\l R\ll'vl\l\l (:)n\l1I11IRRlnn PI' Ilw Htnl\l nl' Polnwnl'u, AH IIl'uHnll, 1?\lfbllllnIlIH, bugnlltoloolltp 1\ l'unlPHlnl\l ng\l1\1 In Roll tlw Proppl'l)', Ppl\llllhmlR WIII'P e!1nc\ll'lwlllhllllho lI'IIIlHIIPllol\c;lHIR 11\ Ihe Rllle,pnl'lI\lllllll'ly the hl'ok\lI"HcnmmIHRlnn, " , .. wuullll\ullllluw Ih\l P\llbl\dnnIRloli\1lnll\ II 1'0lU\'l1ofllwll' II\VlJHI1ll0n\ In Iho pl'opm)', .' " I ' 'whloh IIw)' hl1\loll'n\ll\ 1'01' 10HR limn Ilvq )'\lnrR, ,4, . " j)~lbmh,lIltR ~onlll\lI\l,1 Pllllnlll'l' llY 101\lphn1W bl\R~d upnn Plnlnllfl'R 'I"., .' ndvorllHunwnlR nl' luwol' iinlua u\lnll11lRRlon limn Illhoi' I'ollloatlll\l ngplwl\lR, In 11110 Mnroh ,. , I'. . " 199U, PlnlnltfrR nlionl Edwhl Owon 1Il01 with !'Jol"iidllntHnl Iho PI'OP~I'IY nnil \lIaoUHHod ,; 'I", " Phllnllfl'R pl'llpoaod Italtng aOl'vloo; MI', Owon \lJl1phIlHlzo\1 PllllntlrrR I\!WPI' \loat, whloh ,. ho oll\lI\\od WIIA nlll'lb\lll1blo to Iho olh11hlllllon of Pllylllg lIo11nilnlRAlolllbr 1\ buyor'RI. oIl1ll1llIRalon,"Tho bU)'UI"H ngont COll1ll1,IHHIIlI\CllUld ho lIvllldu\I, Mr, owun oxplnlllo\I, ' " I. , bool\ll~p \)ol'omlnnIH WOllld hll ahowlng llio Propert)', Inoludh11! hOHlhll! Iln)' UpOI1 hllllaoa, , , < .' " .,1 Unllko olhol' 1'~111 oatnlll ngonuloa, Plnlntlrfoxl1lnlnod, Dulbllt1nl1la nnd liot PlnlnlirfWlllll,1 ot' " \10 nl Iho Pl'oporty wl10n It WII~ ahlllVn III proapootlvo bu)'tlra, Plnlntlfl'wqnld IIllvol'lIao tho 1'l'U)lol'I>,"nd Hohcd\llYlho n)lplllmll1ontH, Tho 0\11)' 01\00pllo11 10 I'lnllillffl,A ~Inndllrd PI'llOO'hi,'o Wlla Wholl tho )ll'OR)lOOtlVO \1\l)'01' rotnlnod n'hu)'ol"a IIg011t, ol\hol' nnotllur , IIgOlio)'ol' I'lnlnllrr.Undol' II hn)'OI"H ngono)' acnlilll'lo, Plnlntll'l' Htnlod, tho bll)'or'a IIgOl1t would ahow tho propol't)' without tho,oWIlOI'H' )lnrllol)llltloll, Tho IllWOI' coat IIlallwlIs 2 " j.;' , , '-" IIl1rl\1\1\II\111l 1\l1""ItHlrl'll\l1 hnvlllB \lw Prnpurly 1I~\UIIII1 \lw M\lIII+IHI, whl\lh IN II ,prnprl\lllll'r p\lhll\lnllpllllxllhlNlwlr IIvnllnl11\lIP pnr\llllplltll111 rlllllulilllllllllllllllH, Tlw ,. I' .- , MIIIIH IIHI, PllllmllT lI11lJnl OIV\ln \lxplnltwll, 1111111\lnlll(1 Ihnl nny pr\lIWr\r 11811l(lln tIIll Mlllt, ' " ., I,IHI pnr II 9\l1111l\\HHlp\llhl' Ilw h\lrlll"H nll\lnlllH wullnH Ih\l H\lIlIlI'~H n~~nl, MI', OWlJ\I .. ,." , HllOwed Polilll\llIntH Plnlntlfl'~ Inlilrnlllllpn pnlhll ill'llilnH nl'h\lIIHlJ HnlllH, whl\lh " Inl'nl'll1nlh)11 p\lrpnrlll\llo ~hnw 1I1lIImnHI hnmo Hnle~ Iwrll1111\\1!lwlthplllII hllr\lI"H 1I11\lnt, j. ,_. ., 5, In n wrllllln nlllWllwnl (IwrlJlnllnlll' "AIM'lJo\1wnl") \lnlll\1 MI11'lJh ~~, 10.9>>, Plnlntlff nnd PlJl'unllnnl~ Hll.llhrlh IIw lormH nmlcondltlnlls wlwl'lll>r PIl\lnlllT wnH to nlllll~ \lw oXlllllSIYllIlIlII,lnl! nllllnl fhl' Ihlll'rl1lwl'ty, Tlw I'rl1pol'ttWnH 1,IHIll\1 I'I1I'snlll n\.$ I 94,900. q, " I' III thll Allrllonwnt, which nlHo pl'ovldlld thnl Plllilti(lnlll~,Wn\lld pll)' Pllllnlll'f'4% of'\llll ,.' ,. aolllllll prloo na'n llnmll1lH~lon If'th~ Plnln\l/'I'HhllWcd Ilw Prl1l)IlI'I)', If!lw Hnlll pcollrrllll '/JnRollnpon J]llf'\lndnnta'~howln!l the PI'OI;Cl't)', Iholl1ho AllrculllOnl pl'ovl\lod Ihllt Pllf'umhmta wO\IIdplI)' Plnlnlll'1'3% ofthu allllhlll Pl'\~ll, Tho AIlI'O~nlllnl WIIH\lPllaIHIllnl ", wllh'Plnlntll'f"H llxplllnll~lolI ~1'1',I,nl;;t\fT 'Iollllllila II 1>1I)'(Jl"H 1I1101!1 II'h~1l Pllllnllffwollld II ,_ " " , ,RhoII' Iho 111'0pOI'I)', At tl10 tl1l10 1\10 AIlI'OOnlllnt\vIlH 1101111thltoll, Dofomhl11lR IlIfol'l1\Od " , ,., " Pllllnlll'r'thnl lilll)' ,lI'ollld nlllr ~oll nl II prluo thllt Jll'ovlclod thom nt 101191 $\80,OOo.nOol'nil " " IrnnHllotloll9uoHIH,whlch 1I'1I91holr InVORll1\cllt III Iho Pl'Opol'ly,DolbndlllltH Illfurl1\oll , ' , , ,', .. I'..' , Plllh\lll'f'thlll Ih,~r,(lllrchIl90d Iho 111'0(l01'1)' In.l995 fhl'$16S;OOO,IUld111l1do l\(lpl'oxhnlllcly, ; j,.;; ,,' $15,000 In hl1\l'I'OV0I\111I;IR Rlhuo Iholl, Tho IIHIlull prlllO 1I110\Vcd Ibl' II (l1'olillllnll1bovlllho " " J)ptblldlll1lH' oOHl thnl, ns \)ofon1hlnloxpliillllld, lI'ilH 11I'udollt III ul'dor 10 111I0\v IIccll(llllnuo' ufolflll'S 11l9R thlllllho IIHklng pl'loo, Tho Agl'ool1\olll II'lIllfol' II t01'11\ of ill x 11101llhH, 0'1,'\11\111 SOplllll\bcr 30.,1998, Tho,Alll'Onll\OlIt nlHn IlIcl\\\lOII n pl'ovlHlon IHllnlld "ngonl'H 1'00 Pl'o(oollllll purllld," whluh nbllgntoll DofillldnlltH In pny Plnlnll!'!' n olll\1ll\IHHlon fhl' IIn)' ,Hnlo " J 1/ ,oF; " ",., ,', In Il h\WIl~' within HllIly IIIIYH IIn~i'lI)\lI\~l'u\lnWnl PIII;lrp(IIt'\Iw h\lY1l1' Wlla Hhllwn\lw I'I'\1pPI'I;.' Ihll'll1~ Ihu IUl'll1 nl'llw ^UI'\l\lI11PIlI, PIlI~I1\llll1\H IIIHllllllln ph\Plll'llIh1l11'l'R YIII'II I, , slUIl IlIllw I'rnpul'lr'R 1\'\1111 YIII'II, Q\ Thl,l Pr\1p\lrIY WlIs nl1llw ll11ll'k\\1 lilr IIppl'\1xll11l\luly lwn \wllks whol1 I'hllnlll'r prORlll1lPllll11 !1n~I' Ihl'llw 1\ll1l1skhl!l prluo. Tho nl'lill'WlIs li'nl11 II Ilnllplllll1lhQ " I1PlIll1ul!!hh\1l'hnnll, whn hml,Hll!l11 tho Yllnlsl!l1l1111l1 hml HIllppullhy Ilw Prnport)', , PPflllHhHllH OI'HI HhnWlllllho I'rnporlY In Ow onllplll wlthnll\ llI1l1uulll,' Tlw 119111 (lilY with 111111!lul1ll1ml tlw \lll~lpl\l t\1\11'uIlllwl'rnpurl)' ImHUII ~lp\1l1l'llIll1lltrH Hohullllhid , "" IIppn11111110111: Tho PI'lPI' r\llll1h'uI\ Pojilll\llInlH \n pll)' tho II!!Ol1llbl' Ih\l p\,opo~o!1 bll)'011 II , , ." J% Onl11mIHHIIlI1I111III\1 PII)' tho IlroHpoOllvu bll)'OI~ $10,000 In \llnHIII~ ooals, P\llilmllll1lH IIIH\lIIH~\ld tlw nlTo(wlth Pllllllllff, \vhn r9oomn1OIlllod ItH IIUOOpII11100,.tv!1',0\Vuil Illlpllljnod lhlll lhu"llral nfful' WIIH g\llw1'll1l)' Ihu bOH\ offol'," Tho 01'1'01' WOllld \,uHI\II 111 Pulilndlll1lH Hollhlg thu Pro pori)' 1'01' IIpprollhnllloly"$17I,OOO, PI' II $9,000 I\1HHIIOOI' ' ".. - ,.. . " PII)'nwnlpflho H~llIng 00818, hwllldlng II ~%, or $~,R50, oOl11l11lsHlon 10 1'llll1111l'flll1d II 3% oOmmlHSll1n l~ll' tho bll)'~I"H Ilgont, DofondlllllH rupolllod 101'1IIh1l11'1' Ihlll Ihu)' wOlIlII , " not HolI for 10HH Ii1\' II prioo Ihllt 1'081111ullln l)ofl111dllnlH ruoolvlilg 108s thlln $\ RO,OOO 111\01' " 1111 OllPUI1HOH, I, 7, [)et'ondllnts IIl1lhol'l~od I'h;lnllt'l'lo I11l1ko II cO\lnlol'oftul' 11\ $\ R4,900 wllh ' - -, - ,. , no PII)'1110111 of'lhe u\1I11I11IHslon fUI:\ho bllYOl"H ngon\, PlulntlfT Hlon!lly oppoHoII IhlH , " , " ~ " COlll1tOI'-oflb,', IIlld ullpl'oHHoII hlH cOlluut:n 10 Dcfcnd;UllH Ihnl 811uh II cO\ll1loroffbr wllh no plI)'ll1olll ul'thubu)'or'H IIgl'n\ \llll11l11lsHlon WIIH "nol npllI'oprh\lo In tho InduHh'y,"11nd Ihllt \1;0 bU)'UI"S lI!lont \Vould Inko his bu)'u,: ohlOwhcro, Moroovor, Mr,Owon ollplulnud 111lI1 , , ' , II ' "ho hud 10 work Itfthu h\IHlnUHH," Thul'o,wuH n dlilq\lBsloll 01' Mr. Owon'H rupl'oHuntnllull " .1 '.. " " " ,', I' Ihlll 11111HI HlllpH IWl'p nimlllwllh I1I1Y\lr'H 1I1l\lI1IH, whlllh WIIH 11\\1 \iIlHIH 1\11' Ilpl~nllll!1IH'" IlppIHII1111n IIHIl 'Pll1h1\IIT IIH II IIHIIl1ll lIlllllll, PIlI\!llIlllnlH 111'111lr\l11 11111111111'1' III IVI'It~ 111\1 I' ' , " 1l\l\ll1lllr-I)fI\!I', 1IIIIInll 1'1' 1J1'II111Jlnllly Ill1l1lplIPIllIllII PI'IlHIII11l1h!r PI'IlHUIlIIlIIII, Tlwrll WI\IIIlII, , , , WI'II\lln I'IlHpnnHp 10 IIw uOII1lIUI'IlITul'; hIli Plnllllll'r Inlhl'llwll Pill\!llIlnnlH Ihlll Ihll hll)'llr'H ' UllllllllH\lllllklln hlH 111I)'\lI' IlIHllwlwru, ' ", Thu I1lIl11hlll' of HhnwlllllH HhllWlllhuruul1lll', 1111111111111' twn 1l1\1l1lhH Mr, OW\l1l1l \l(IIlIUul\lIIPIlI\!Il\lnllla nil" I'IlUIII1lI11UIHllld n $~,OOO 1'\l\1I11l1l11l1lnllw )11'1\l1lIn ol'llur " ,. , 11I\1l1lnln 11l111l110nnllntlll'\lHt, ' Pulhl1dnnlH II\lUllpIUII111IH 1'\l\lOll1nWndllll\lll, whloh atlll " ' nllllw\lll Dol\!l1IhllllH 10 l'\lpulw P':\I\l\l\lIIH \II' $1 "O,UOO, IIH \1I1l\l\laHuII wllhllllllllll'i'l~, '9, ", PUl'hllJ tlw Allr\l\lnWIlI, IIlllllllln'~'IO'Y\ld Ih\l PruP\lI'I)' In P~IlI~l1llnl hUYPl'1l " on a\lvurnl oO\lIIRlona, In PU\l1l of t1WHIl olJUualnllR, fllulllllrr Illdllllll\lllln 1)\ltullllnllta Ihut IJwy W\ll'\lIl\lt10 pnhlulpllto Illlhu ailowhuihuul\\lHU Plnllltll'l'wna wol'klllg wltllll\\l ".- '-, -- ,- ,- ", PI'\lHpoollvo h\I)'Ul'R nli n b\I)'UI"H IIguni,' All \lthul' Iln1\lH,lho Potulll,,"IR ahowolllho 1ll'IIpUI'Iy,hwludlng dU1'11l1l OpUnhl1llR\lR, wlthnut Plnlnlll'fholnll PI'OROIlI Qr hW\llwlli ,- -", . , " (i, ,. 01;0\lpl fOI;ROlwdulIlllllhI)RllPwln~ VIII Iuluphollu, AgollIR J1'om olhul'l'onl oRlnlo,nlll)lloloR " nlRll,Rhowod tho PI'Opol'ty vlnlho Plnlnllfra ROhodullng, ullIl oll,lhuRU oOOnSlollH Plnlnltrl' Illfol'l1wd thu Doful1lhllllH ,Ihlll thoy W~'I'OI\(I1 10 plIl'lIolpllto Inlho ah\l}vhlll HhlOI) lhu hll)'~'I' WIIH I'upl'oaontodhy'n bUyor'a ngon!I, PlnhitllrH oonduolllnd tho ^groOl11\lnt hl(llontod.lhnt whon Plnlnlll'!' ahowod 111\l PI:OpOl't)' without tho ()ulundllllta' )Il1l'lIolplItloll, tho,l1 PllIll1l1rl' WIIH wOl'khlllnR il bllyOI"R l:opl'oaol1t1\tlvo, " , ,\1 , , 10, Durll1g Ihla podod ol'lho Alll'O\ll11\lnt ()olul1\lnl1larooolvod lolophollu onlla , fl'ollllwonllcl\tH Irolll olhol' ngul1oloa, Thu ngollla Inquh'od Il'Iho lJofondnnla would pll)'lI , " f' ,. tluyol"a 1101l11ll1aalon, mid Indtolllod Ihlll PIl\h\tlffhlld h\fbl'lllod Ihom Ihllt Dofulldllnta 5 " ,,' " '.I " , Wl1l1hll1PI, In \1nlh IlIlS\lS IIw P\lliJl\lllInls Inlilhll~(IIIWPIlII\ll's 11111111 \llll11'111lsslun wpnlllll\l " , Pl\lllln n \1nY\lI"H nU\ll1lll'lIwl\\lI11\1prHWl1I'k\l(I.ll1nIIHt Il'lIw pl'nV\l\llls ti'Plll 111\1 ~'III\lllll~1' .1\ \ll1als WPI'\l HlIlIslilVlnl'Y, TI1\ls\l olllls I'IIIHuII n s\ll'lnilS \l(l\W01'l1 n\111111 Whllll',lnll1llffwlIs Ivlllnu nlhul' IIU\llils. lI\1Il P\lliJmhllHs I'IIIHPllllw 1111\1\111' w\lh Mr, OW~l1t wlwlll'Hll'ul1l1\ll1 I, 1I1lIUhlll1\h\lI' IIUllnls shn\lllll1l1l hllVP pnnlll\ll\lllllw l)ufillUhmla. lillll 111M Ih\ll1llwl'nU\l111H wur\ll1pl PUIT\l\lI, ';; ", I; 11, Illln\\I ,lIlly. PIIIII1II11'col1ln\ltuII P\lliJmlll111R !llld Iwol11l11pl1dpII Ihol Ihu " Prnp\1l'lr bu IIsl\1llln 11113 MIII,IH"IHI, U\1llul'lhlH I11111'kulll1U Iluvlo\1, lhu j)pfiJllIll\IltH wnlllll IlIIY\! (\1 OU1'\l\1 to pllr n 3% u~lI11I11IHSI(ll1lil\'lhu \1I1Yol"S IIUplIt, omln 3% o0l11ll1laalol1l11 , , PIIIll1llrr, l)plul1dlll1tahll\llllllull to PlllhltlrCthuh' 110110111'11 11\111 Ihls rooom1lwllllllllb1l wPl1111 I1WlIl11hp IrlIl1~ooll01l oosl Wl1l1ld BllI\rnl1l\lo Pulul1\IIII1.1s wOlIlIll'ooulvo IP9HII1I1I1$1 60.000 ' , " I, ' , /I IInol' 011 \loIs, PllIll1l1ff alluuusl\ld thnt Iho Pl'opol'lY \1ollst\l11 ol.\hp hlul1\1I' pl'loo of , , .. .'" "i' $194.900 III 01'1101' 10. pOVOI' tlw hlulWI' Hlllps OOI1\l11lssloIlS, ,Dofol1lh\llts qllosllul1od,lho " ' , 11101'\lH oropl'loo 11I01'01la\l1l1l(I"lhl1 mlltltl<llllll opal, b\ll PllIll1llfC nss\ll'~~1 thol11 tlml II Wlla " h\lSl1110lhOlI,lu obwln IIl1l1oooplnblo 01'1'01', \!Inhitll'ra 1'000ml1l,Ol1dllllun oCtho MllltI-I'Ilsl Wlla oonlmry to Ilwl'oprosonlllllolls 1'llIlntll'Cl1illtlo whon Mr, Owon l\dVoolltod Plnlnllffns !, tho listing Iluonoy for Iho Proporly, Tho rcooll1ll1ontlllt!ol1oCthdlllCl'lts 01'1110 M\IItI,(,I~t onco Iho l\gonoy rolntlonahlp lwl huol\ oatllbllshcd wns II olllsalc blilt I1l1d swltoh ploy I1s\ld by I'lnll1llrf 10 obmln bllSll1uss ns 0 "dlfluounl brok\ll,lI ul1ly 10 111Il<nllloly swltoh Iho , " uus(ol\lOI' Into Iho hlghol' cost of \I Mnltl-Llsl, ' 12, The lIatlllU In tho Mnlll.Llst did not )l1'o(luco nlly OnOI'M. lIIid lIllho cOlioluslonlll'thc Aureomonl MI', Owon'ool1tnoted J:)efun~llInts nbollllhcl" plnns'; D\1l'olld!lllta Inl'ormod l'hilnlln'thnt 0 uno I\lonlh oxlllllslun wOllld bo lI\llhol'lzod Irlho ,. 6 , , "1" .d " n~llnl pnMPI!lll\ l'ullll~r,\l1l111~11I WnH rOIIIlPo\llnlhlrly IlllYR, whlph wn\lllln\lllllllh'\1 II wnlllll PllIIWlll\l willi IIlll HlIlllll \11I1\lnH I1l'nvl\lpIIIIl tlw nrlulnnl ^urpOl1l1llll, Thp nlllllllliJll ,prOlppl\l1l1ll1'llVIHII1I1 prolppilllll'liill1llfl' lill' IIIlY pnlpl1tlnl I1l1yor wl10 IR Hhl1Wl1l1w I'rllpllrly ,. I', , \lIlrhl!!)lllllol:m ofllw ^urp\lnllll1l, hnt \!lIh11lillll~hnYH IIwl'rl1PllIW nl\llrWnnlH, Thp' , " ^~rll\lI1111I,\1 hl\lllllO 1\l1l pl'lltoPllollpol'll1I1 ol'RlxlY Ih11\1lhollllll nl'tlw ^llr\loI1101\1, Tho , , ;.' ! " " n1\1\Hl1llnllnn Pol\JmhllllH tii1llllhl wnll 10 rlltlllOo 1I111lwrllltl In thlrlY \lIIYH, PlnlllHfT nurllllll lolhlH Oh1lnU1l111 wrlthl!l' TI1\1H, 1I111 Aurll0l1llll11 Willi flXI\ll1llpd tnpplll\lOI' ~ I, 100<<,11\)11 , , , Ihp nuonll'ull pi olQlltlnl1 plll~lnll oxplrlllllln NOVllmblll' 30; 100A Ihl' III1Y hnrol' HhmVI1 thll " ' l'roplll'l)' Ilnl'll1u IIIP tOl'm'nl' 1111' ^!!rlllll111111I, , '" 13, '. Nn n(l'urH,\VOI'Il,l'IlOolwIIIIIl1'IIl!! thO\lxt\lI1Hlnllllfthll^lll'lllllllll11I, At Ihl,l "'; ,," I' 111llloflho ^!!I'OIlIlWllI; Pol'undnlltH Inlhnnolll'lnll1tllT.\hllt ,hor wnllll! lln IOllgol' 111I1l , " , I'lnll1tlfj'H HorvlooH, Qn NllVlll11l1ol' I, 190A,J)IlI'uml\mlll I'OIlH1VOd PllIll1tlfl'H rlll'd Hllm , 11l1t\rllplllooll II \Vilh,poromhllllll'\Ij1nl' Snlo\l)' OWllol"', )'111'11 IIIUI1, f)ofbmlnnllll )'Ill'll IIlgn .. , 1I0t forth J)01Ulld1l111111 lolllphollOlllll11hol'IIllIlIVUl'llllJ lIol'vlco, Tho 1l101l1lllUO olllho , " , II11HWOrlll!! 1I0rvlo'll pl'\lvldoll.lI dotllllod,dollorlptllll1 nl'lho 11011110, IInd IIlIo\vo\1 0111101'11 In " IllllVO'U 1110111111!!0, ,. 14, .Iullklo ^"ulltllllolollhllorY,lld f)llfolldl111IH' )'lIrd Hl~llo 1I11ll'lIttolll)1tod 10 001111101 Dol'undunlH \lHllod IIpon tho 1010)1holl0 llumhol' ol)Dofondllllllll )'nrd allllll ho\Vovol'!' , f'l Hhol'Ooolvod II I'oool'llhlll tlllIl Iho IiUn~lltll' Willi 110t 111 1I01'vloQ, Mil, ^IlHIIIl\olo \Villi 1011ltlllll d I' ,. .. ,. for n propol'ly lollvo h\ wllh hOI' lillnll)' Hlld .Joffi'o)' lIubhllrll. MIII.^lllIlItnolo Hlld MI" , I' " HllbbHl'l1 WOI'O noluHlllg l\ bll)'OI"H l\1l0111 10 101l1l10 pro)10I'tlllllllllllq11'0fol'l'Il\llillt to'\!1I0 UIl 'l\glllil, " 7 ; c ( ~, ' " " I, ,;' III h " ,I " " " " " 15" WlwnMlI, Alll1l1\II~ln WII~ lI11l1hlu In I'ulloh IMomhllllll nll1ho 10101lhl1lio I , , ,lilllilIWI'\l1l Plll'omhmlH' )'111'\1 IIluli, IIho 1l\l11111\l1\1\1 1'11111\111'1' 1I1l111'1l\1\1~1I1011 P\lI~'1\h\IlIIl' " " 1010phnlW lIIlIllhul', 1'11llll11lhlllhl'1111'1\ Mil, AllIIIIllIlllullml 11111111111'1: 0111l11111PIUlw\lll\ lh\! ' POI\llllhmlll' \plllphl111o 11\111\1101', Thill Willi II 'hlllo 111111 11\1 II 11ll\\1I llU IIII1IPI111'111, 1'111111111'1' , , ' " 1111\11'1111'\1 Mil, ^llIllIllIulnlhm 11,1I~ PIIlIl1\ln'~nlllll 1I1\1llV IWI' Ihu Pl'l1p\Jl'lr, ^ulIll1, Ihlll WlIII , 'n n,11I1l 11111111111110111111111 1I11I11l1111lnl, Mil, Alll11111111011l \11\1 01111111111l1' Ihlll 1I11'IInuO 110lmllllu IIlw WII,II nll11l1l111' wllh l-!ulp,\.J.I'loll'lI 1I11111dlll'll pl'\lOO~hll'1l 'Ihill hml tlw\lwIWI' hh\1\v Ih\lIlIlIUI\ pl'opudy, hilI IIhc 1'1l1l1l11 111\ I'llIhlllfl'iJ,l\lllIu lIlll\I11II1I\1I1II11111 1'0prUllullllllllln 11I1I11IUl'IlClllu hllvu MI" OWUI1 IIll1lWllw I'I'llP\lI'I~, 16, 1'11111)111'1' lIuul1l OlVlllllojllphol1otl MrH, IIIlYII\lH IIml 1111111 hll"hllll1111 ' Intlll'UHlotlhllrol''' 1\11'lh\ll'l'llpol'ty IIml wuUI\llIklllU lihmv Ihu I'rnpul'ir wllhlllll " , . , , ,\)ol'9ndlll1ll1' pllrtl\llplltlon, M,:, OWOI1I1 11111 nut IIsk 1\1 ho PuI'Ul\lllIntH' IIlIul1l," Unsoll 011 tlw 111'111" ~xpol'lonuo,'\hlll IIlI1Iulltul\ to IJu!\lIldllnlH thllll'llIl111lrl'wlI8 ruprusunllnu Ihu plllunlllll hll~ul't Ml't OIVUlIlIlso rUllllulllotl Ihnt lJo/\ll1dllI1IH rlll1l\lVO Ihulr Yllrtl sluII so 1111 10 "nol UOI1I\IIIU"lhu pllSlllhllll1llYUI' llmlllg Ihu IIhllWllIg, Ml's, I1IIYIIUS IIgl'Cllllto thu showlnll sllluu on SIlVUI'III 00U1I81111111 lJofolldlllllll hl\\I lI\1owoll burur'lI III1UI\llIlIhow Ihol'l'Oporly , ,. ,I' ',I . " OVUII thO\lgh II wnH "11t1l' Snlu Ily OWllor," Mrll, HII~lluH dlllll\lllHUll wllh MI', HnYl1uII tho ',l'Ol11llVnl 01' tho slglllbl'lhu Hhll\vltlg. whluh Ihuy Ihought wnH \II1UIIUIlI, Dllt\l1ldnl1tll " 1'0l11ovo\llho ynl'd III~n bUOIlUIIU' Ihuydlll not wlIllIln,llllurl'lll'U with Mr, OWOIIIIIS l'ulntll1llllhlp wllh (hu prollpuutlvo buyol', who Dul\mdlllllH I'unsolll\bl~ hu\lovu hlld I'ulllhl'ud Plnlllllfl'nH \\,huyur'H ngol1l, 17, Ml', OW\1I1 did I1qt 1'0q\lllHt (lilY 0011111118HI011 fl'lll1l Dofblldlll1tHlllor did ho" Hlntu v~r\ln\l~ 01' III wrllIl1!! Ihnt ho wnH IJofclldlll1lH' lI!!cn\. lJlllblllllll\lH did not glVu " R 'I. , .. " I, " , 'I " I".. " ,I I' I, "I'II1h1l1lT IIn)' p~I'l\1lstilP1h~llh~r wl'\1nll)',' 111 wl'lllnu, UI' II)' Ilwll' ~hll!hlll\, In 1I1llllS Ihllll' i, ,IlU~111 Ill' lIur~~ 10 Pl\)' Plnlnllffllll)' 11\1l11l11lssl011, IIml P~liJl1\llIll\s knpwn Ihll\ Pllllnllfl'wlIH j. ., , "Illlslll)' rllpl'\lS\llllhW 10 MH' I\nllsll\\llolhlll PllIll1llfl'wnR I\1P P\lIOlHllll1ls' nU\lIlI, Ilwl1 .. P\lliJI1!lnl1ls wnnlll hllV\l r\lI\Isll!IIWl'lnlsHll1Ii ,Ihl' llllllnllfl' I!I shnw Ihll Prop\ll'l)' IIn(~ \vo\1111 , , '"I," 1 hnY\' Cnnlll\lI\l!llhc H!llIIIJsllll!l Cnl11l11lsslon tn \lnl\!hl!lt nl\ In~\lll'r Inln I'lnh)!\lrll!lllllVlnl', P\llol\!lnnts 1'\lllsonn\1l)' b\lll\lw!lllllIl Ilw'PlnlnlllTwns nllllnu ns \llll \1\l>'llr'SIlU!l111 wlwn , , , , ' Ihwnul'o\l!lIn nllnw Ilw PIllh1llfl'In show tlw Pl'Qll,ol'lr, pr\lH\lI1111bl>, tu Plnh\\If/'H !lllllnt, " Pof!lI1(lnnls WOr!l n\lllnlol'\lsIO('lnllli~ HllllllI"S llUQllI, nnd I'lnlnlllfwns nul nnthorlit!llllu 1101 liS l)ol\lmlnllls'l1uont'wlwn MI', ()w(m \olophnno nnll llllslll>, rllpr!lsol1lod thnl'ho hll!l n hll>,ol'lnlol'ostod In lho Pl'nplll'l)' , , , " .. 1", On Nuvol11hcl' 22, 199", MI', Ow,\l11 showoll tho Pnlporl>' to Ms, Al1nslllolu " , " wllholll DO,/omlnnls' pnrllolpntlol1, This wn~ OU11818\0111 with Iho 1'IIIInllff8 pl'lul' prno!\Il\l 'I" .. whon Plnln!\l'l'l'opl'osontod Iho p(1lol1l1nl \)nyor whon tlw AUl'oonwnt wns sllllln \If'foot. , Th\l dlftiJl'onoo wns thnl tho^!ll'oomonl Wns npl 01'1'001 nndPlnll1lllThnd I1U I\llthorll)' 10 nlll " II < ,. , ns Pllf\lmlllnls' "!lllnl, ,," , 19, " Wh!iq Ihll Pl'oporlY wns Ihl' snlo b>, Ownol', ()of\lI1dnn,tH hn(ll1lllhorlitod " pnYl110nl of'90111mlssluns 10 ulhol' nuonls hllsodllPUI\ sl!ll\ln!l n wl'ItlQI\ nurool1lolJ1 ' . . ,- , .I.' ,,, ,. 1Il1thol'lzhll~ II iip(\olf1o 001111\\19sluI\ 1'01' 1I bll)'OI"S lIgol\l, I'lnh1\IITdld nol pl'osol1lnl1~ wrlUol1n!lrool1lol11 fhl' Dolbndlll\ts 10 sl!lnnlllllOl'lzh1!lllny 001\1l11ls91011 pl'loI' Iu showll1!l Iho I'ropol'fr t;1 Ms, Al1l1stllolo, lInd Dofbl\lIl1l\tH 1'01l9111\1Ihl)' oOIJollldod Ihot PllIll1tl~rhl\d lItl lI!lr001110111 wlll~ Ms, ^1111911l01u Ibr pnY11\ol1t of' I\ny oOllln\.lsslol1, Dolol\dl\ntsdonr I\lIthol'lzll1g 1\1\)' 001111111HsI01\ 1011lnll1tlfT I\S n condltlol\ tu shuwll1ll tho I'l'Op011>, \0 Ms, .. ^il{lSIl\OIO,Nnl' did Dolondl\l\tH' 1\0tlollH!1l'Ovldo l\I1Y I\lIlh(lI'lzl\tllll\ lo)lhl111111'1'\0 nol ns I 9 I:. IIwlr nlwnl, MI', Iln~I1U" hnill\llllnmm\lnlcnllon wllh l'hilnmf, Ilmll'lnll\lIff <<Illl~hl <<lleh, , , '11\ll1nrl~lIlllln, II WIlIII,1 I1nv\l'bc\ln Ilcnlcll, If'PIlI\lmhil\l<< hllll wnlllUll1I s~lIllr's, nuu!illll II" , nllt I1n tlwlr 1l\ll1nll; Ilwl\ \I\\l>' wI11I1I1 hnvll Ilnhll'\lIl n IIsllnu nurpUI\Wl\1 wllh 1II1nu~np)' nlhcr IIl11n Plnll\lll'l', 70, Plnlllllffclllllnclllll Mr~, Iln)'ncs nnll I'Cllllualud In slww (1)0 pj'I1PIlr\)' Illi , , NI1V\ll11hcI' ~!J, 1900111 Ms, ^\lIlli1noln, wl1lpl1 O\llllll'l'\lll wllhnlll pufumlnnls' pnrlllllpnllllll, , I almllnl'lll IIw ill'S! sl1nwlnu, Plnlnllff wii~, 11111 nl\lhnrl~ulllnncl lis Pllful\dllllls' ngenl slmlhH'W IIw Ilral shnwlnu, 7 \, 01' f)ouPl11bu\; I, 1 !JOB nt 71110 p,IH" Mr, OWCI\ mpl wlll1 ,I)ofl' nnd Jneklu lhlb\1nl'll" (hol'olnoOcr I'ul'urrclllnns "UII>,UI''') nl Phlh\llff"a nfl1cu In Gnmp 1'11111, ".. " ",; l'onna)'lvllnlo, Thc HII)'UI' I'Cljllusllllllhu nlOcllnu oml wnntull I'lnlnll 1'1' 10 1\'1'110 n cimll'llot ofT~1' 1'01' tll\l prop,~I'I)',' Alnollmc IlId Plnlnlll'l' dIH~loH~ tollll)'OI' Ihnl ho'wns 1101 .. II\llIlOl'lzclllo nolnH Dul'undnllls' IIgunl, III 1'1101, whcn PllllnlllTpl'6pnl'od thu 13l\)'cr'<< , " wI'hlpn offul', Plillnllff IIIIHol)' Idontlliod Pllllnllff liS Pb'fcnlhll,IlH' lII\1horli\ollllllonlIn tho off'uI'I f)ofolldllnlsgllVo nil sHoh l\\llhllrl~ntlon, \llllllfl'oq\\osICIII'IWOllld hllvc bCell , " , rof\lslld, PlnlnlllT fIlIHUI~ 1'01]1I11'0d 1311)'01' tll 01\00\\10 n dl~ulllH\I1'O Il1nl Pllllllllffwns , ,I' 1'0pl'osolllln/J 1110, Dol'ondllnls,nlllllhlll this dlsuloHllI'o ollnwuIlP\!lllllln'lo IIIHo ropl'080nl tho.." " I' bll)'OI', "I'hls WlIs IIlhlHO IInd I\\lslulIdlllg slolol\\onllnlondln/J 10 dooolvo tho l3U)'llr, d_ ,. ,22, )lolloWhl!llhullluutln/J, Plolnlll'f ogolil Owonlolol\hollotl DofondnntH 10' 1111'01'1\\ Ihom IhollHs Bu)'ol' hod 11111do on onul' In Ihullll10unt ol'$lllO,OOO,lInd 1I1l1l,ho " , " wllnloll 10 dullvor II pOI'sonlllly, Ml" Owon roqlloslct! 0 moolln>>, 1\1111 DO!\llIdonls OBI'opt! 10 , . . t muul withMt', O\Vun ulllJooulllbor 4, IlJl)lllll thu Proporl)' Il1l11'dol' 10 proHoll1 tho oll'or on boholfoflho BIl)'or, At thu muollng Mr. 011'01\ pl:OSOIIl.udlhu UnOI', \Vhl,uh soltbl'll\ Ihllt 10 , , " , , " "-I " 1'1\\111111'I'wnH Ilw n~~I1\ !ill' Ilw P~I\JI1\'hllllH;n\1lllhn\ I'lnhllllTwnH ~111Il'I~11 \(l$~,(jIO \lIlIllIllIHSlpll Plln p\ll'~lms\l pl'l~~ Ill' $\ <<0,000, Nil p\lIWnlnll~ wnH sl\ll~lllllllw 1ll'f\JI', hilI " Ilw ~lllllll1ltlSlpll \l11\1Il11i~, IlK, Ill'lIw pl'l~\l, " " , Z~, ThlH wnH 1119 1ll'Hlllnw lhnl P~,liln(lnn\ft I'\lnsllnnhly l'\lnll~\l1l1l1\ll,jllnlntlIT ' " ,. hnd nllsvly I'~Pl'lls\llll\l(IItH\lll'l\lllw IlII)'\l1' ns Plnll1llrt"tlnll\ln\, \ll' lhnl Plnlll\lffpm'pOI'\\l11 " " Ii lu n\lIIlH P\lfilmhmlH' nll\llll, MI', Hnyn~H Hihl\lll, Illwhn\ bO\lnn19 II IWI\,\,oll ,IIHQ\1ssloIlWlth MI', OW011t lhn\Plnln\lffwnH \1111 P\llbmhlllls'nll\lnl'shwllllw ^1l1'~On1\lnl hm! oxplr~,\ 00\Ob91' ~ 1, 199Il,Tll\l,\1rtill"s pnlVlHlonllinl PlnlntllTwns Plllbndnllls' IIlllln\, IIn,llhnl Pl1lilnllnn\H WOI'\llo puy I'lnlnllfl' $$,(j IOns II llol1\1liIHslon WIlI'O Imnoc\lplnblo 10 ro. ," _ , , DlllbmlnlllH, nll\ll'llsnl,lolllnlho oflbdwhlllllpprnxll11nloly $7,000 Ilolow Iho P\lfillldnl1liil $IHO,OOO \1ollomllno, In I'oapunfi\l, Plnln\IfTnll\ln\ OWOIl sllll\ld IIm\ ho"wns nolso HIII'1l Ihnl thq ^gl'll\lnlOnl hll(1 Ilxph'\l(I," nnd Ihnlllbs9nl his pn)'IllOllllw wonld \nko "his hll)'ol' , ,... , 'I, l' j, , ' , olaowhol'o," This mll11lHSlonlndlcnlos Ihnl PlnlnllfT bollllvlld \hn\ Iw, hlld IlpI'Oprloln\')' . 'I hllQI'CHlln \119 Illlycr, whlllhcllmclo Plnhlllffonl)' \1oon\1SO Plnlntlfflll\(lmndll fnlsonl1d , ',.' " " I mlslon(llnll stntomonls 1(1 1311)'01' nboll\ not boln!! nhlo 10 Illvo 0111 tho PolilndEmlq tolophono " 11\\lllhol' nnd Ihnt onl)' Plnlnllf:f~ollld show Iho'Pt'OPlll't)' 10 Ih\l \3(1)'01'. Hud nol Plnh\lIff ' "II; II ,- '" nlndo s\lch lillso nnd mlslondhlll 'slntol11o,;ts, th~11 ll\1yor WOIIIII hnvo oOI\tnotod Dotill1dnll!s " 1111'Q\lllh oth~I' 1l10nna, nlld I11ndo nl1 oflbl' to b\1)' tho \I\'Oporl~ with no j\nYI11\ll1t of olll11l11lsHlon, II 1\' '24,' Tho Plnll1llff"a pl'fol' 1\'01\1 tho (311)'ol'l1lso 1l1011ldod n WtIlT1II1\)' sorvloc, to bo", ", plll'ohnspd by Dolbl1dnntrif\'oI111'lnllltlff lbl' tho bol\oOt oflho B\1)'OI', Dorolldlll1tsuakod ,) , ' , \ f, Phl\nlll'fwh(lhnd pl'Oposodlhntboh11llti tho oflbt', nnd Mr, Owon lndlolltodtlln\ ho lind, I, 'i This nctloli WI\S~OI\trlll')' 10 ()crondl\nts' hltOI'OatH nnd Is oonHIHt'i.J1iI Plllhlllffrolil'Osol1lhig " II lI1\lIlII~~I' nl1lllwlllw pOlill1lhl\1lH, I1I'\.IvlmIHI~ Ilw 11111111111'1'hll(III'I\.Illlo H\.III ))pl'pl1l11111Ift , Ihp HIII1W IVlIITlI111y H\.II'Vloo 1111 plln nl'lhu 111i1lnlllHlIl1u ^ur\lol1wl1l, hill Pol\lmllll1lH hllll , . ' . ~" . I ; , . , \llmPII IlpWI1I'IIIII1I1I'1'1I nl'lill', 'Tho Il1oh!~I\lI\ nl' Iho wIIlTnl11~ Hol'vloo In IIw 111'1\11' 111111\1111011 ' " 1111pI'OpOI' 1I\.I11~11\.IlIlIl1u Il~ 11ll1ll1llfl'lII\I)o OXPOl1l1p Mllw polill1l111111H IImllllo 1311~01" ~~, ,Tho IUHPIl\o IIIHolIHftlnll \111\.10 1I1!II1111ho 1J\.Ilill1lll1l1lH U\llllnfohllllllll1U" $1 HO,ooo III pl'lWooll1I 111\01' tho 111110, IIml MI', OW\ln 1I1111\.1111hlll n oP~II1I\.1I"nl'lill' III $1 II 7 ,(l(lo " WOIlIIIII\lhl\.lW111ll1 gOlll, ))olbmllll1ll1l11mlp II 010111' In MI', OWol1l1mlllw nil I)' WII)' Iw ' , ,- - I, "'. I. WOIllIIl'oo\.llw Iho $4,~~1l onmmIIlHlnll,lI11 Ilognthlloll, wna Il'ho gnllho HllYol' 10 Il1prOI\Ho , , 'II ,. " \lw p\l1'ohnHo prloo In $1 H7,ooo, whlph wnlllll rOIl\lllll1lJolbmhmlH rcoclvl.llg Pl'llooOll1l nf , " nPlifOlIhlll1l\.1l)' $\Hll,llOll,IIH rcp1'01l0111\l11 hy Mr,o\vcl1, Tho IIcllOlllllolI OU111111II1HlulI 01\11\1111 nPP1'QXhlll1l\.1ly 2,11%, ThlH onllnlcN11'1'oI' (1111 ml\hnl'ii'.o I1lnllllll'l'lb 1I01llH , , , ))ofblHhll1ll1'ngl,lnl, hilI UUo I'ul' IIl1pooll1o nl1o.III11O ul1l)' ngrocnlOI11 tu pny PIIlIIlIII1'$4,SOO . . , . " J'" t,,,, nH 1100111111111111011 ollly 11'1'1nllllll1; throllgh,Hkll1 h! 110gotlntloll, uhll1hlOII\\ plll'ohllHC prloo of $1 H7,000 1'01' Iho 111110 01'11\0 Prupol'l)'IU tho 1311yol" 1'IIIIIIIIrl'noooPloII tho tor111S 111111 III ' ' qOl1dhhlllH uf thlH 0lJllIl'1I0l, whl,oh 111111101 hllVo nllY ton11 ilH 110 IIHlIllg ngroolllOlIl \VIIS " Hlgl1l,1l1, ,If Phllnllff 1\111011111 tho 1I0gollnllollH, Iholllhoro WII:! liD IIgoll0Y oOlllrllol, Of .. nolo, 110 pOI'OOnlllllll WIIH IIHod, bill Dcfbl1dlll1tll IIBl'ood to I'ny 1'IIIII1tllT$4tSSO IIH n f1Xo~1 , ' , ., pll~tllOl1t Ilod dll'coll~ 10 Ihcllhlll\y'ofl'llIllltln;lhI'Ollllh 1l0rHIIIIHI,l)1l nlldllll11ulltltlotl, to " , .. ohllllllll p"l'ohnso,prlco of$IH7,O[)O Ihlllltho 13l1ycI"l'lnllltlffdld llot pl'Ovldo nlly oORt, " " Hhocl 10 l)ot'ol1dlllltR, Thc Dctolldlll1tli Ihrollgh tholl' OOllntol'-ofl'ol' 111111101111101111 to , .. ,I. pl'ovldQ Plnlnliff 1I11~ llcllol'lIll1l1lhol'lty to nollm bohlllf ofJ)ol'olldllllIH boyond tho Ih11l1od .. ;, ,. ,. HOOpO to oblllll1l1 Hpcolflo prlco, Pllllntln) fhlllll'clo IIchlcvo tlllIlrcRlIl1 olldod nil)' .' 1II'1'\lllgCI1lIl111 with 1'llIll1tlll; IIbHc/\l1\ IlltUwl' ngl'ocll1ll11t: 12 " " " " .. " .,J' ",. " .. " " ii' ';, " ~f1, ',011 P~~~Il1\l\l1' 7, 100R, (1111111111'1'>> 1I11\llltPW~l1ll1lill'l11~\1 MI', HIIYIWS viII , , . " j' 1~lol1h~~IW Ihlll IlIIY\l1' hmlll1l1llp III1UI'III 1'1l1"1I~l'lln\lI' Il1lho IIlHnllI1t uf $1 <<1\,000, \1\lIlhllt IlllY\l,'W\111111Ilul ll\lllll~ hlllh\ll', MI', HIIYIWH IlSkplllflh~ IWI wIlIII'II;i'\1\hl~~ $180,000, IIml(1ll1h1l11'l'slllI\,\1II wo\!I\ll1ul, Plllh1\11'1' IIll\lnt OW~l1lmll~III\l\I.thllllw WIIS Wlllll111 lu Mhlll\lllw slIll'>> PlllHll1lsahl\1lllllllnw P~l\'\1l111111sl(~"'\lP\llw$1 80,000 ""~I' 1I111\'\1I1s\\01l1l1l " ".- , pONls, whl~h MI', Ow~n allllo\\ WIlIII\1 \1PP\II'II' P\l!\mdm\ls, [\\IYPI'III1\,1 PIIIII1,\lfl'lIlI I\I\hlSIO(1 ' tlwll' l1u61\11lll by $I,OOOII,~" llllYIlI' hWl'l'l1alnl! tholl1l1l'clHIHP ul'l\ll' to $18',000 IIml ' , , , j' , Pllfbmlll111fllllworll111 Iholl' 11r11'0 lu $ i 8~,OOO,11l1111l' $I,OOOl'l'lhlo\lonln tho $4,~~O " II " " , , l'ol11l11laslol1l\l'ovlii~IHltlllllhol'll!olllnllw Polbmhli1\>>' IJlll'oll1bol'll, 199R Ollll11IPNlffm', , , , tl:jl" HllYI1\ls IIlll'olld 11111 1'0lhlcll0l1, bl1HOcl IlllUn (1ll1lnlll'l'H I'Ppl'PH0l1t1lllonlhllt POfbmllll1lH , 'j, , W\1\lld 11\1\11111 $1 KO,OOO\lpol1 II $1,000 1'0lhlll\lol1,Inlhll $!I,S~o 001111n1HHlp1110,lwl1"lllto " , Pllllnlll'l', I' , 27," On ()OOOl\1blll' K, 199H, Plnll1l1rt' I\lxoll to Ml', llllynos Iho oosl shllol fhl' thl' " j, /I ,J , $1 KS,OOO slllo prlO\l, whl\lh showod f)\lfonlllll1lsl'ooolvlnll only $178, 249 In pl'ocoods, 01' , , "bo,low $180,000, IIlHI PllIlntlfl's ro~01111Ilf$4,SSO I1s n brokol"s Q0l1111116slon, In olToot, j ,. ,," Phlll1llffll1ndo II 1\llso roprosol1tnllonlhnt PIIIII111I'fwo\lld rodllpo by $1,000 Iho $4,SSO , , oOl11l11lsBlol\ Il!,ovlollsly llollollnlol\ Il1lthorlzclll11 tho Doooll1bol"4, 1998 QO~lIltor-offor:' , MI', HnYl10s hnll)odlntoly I\lXoll tho oOHt shoot hnok to Plllll1tlffwlth Iho l1otniton,of,lIL\d.\ Ihought I wns olollr nhClll\ nul l!olnl! bolow $1 HOI" Mr, HnYllOH nlHo\elophonod Mr, ' f,', . " .. I' . j. " Dwon, who Indlento'l,thnllho UUYOl'WriH not willing to hwrollselhclmrohnBo )11'100 nhow $1 8S,000, nnd thlll Pllllntlff I'cl\lsod to IO\VOI' his coillll1lBSllln holoW$4,SSO, PlnlntllT bronohod Iho ngrooll1ol1t to roduce tho cOll1mlssloll IQ,$~,SSo If DolbmlllntHroduoodtho " Boiling pl'loo 10 $18S,000, I' '" 13 " '" {Ii !, ,2H, In r\l>>pol1s\l, MI'~ PWPl1a 011 P\l\l~I11\1~\' 0, 100H 1\\/(0(1 Mr,lln~'wH n PPH\ shp\lll\lI' n Hlllp II $1117,OOP, whlph provl\lpd 11111111\11'1'11 snlos onl11l11laslul1 01'$5,ClIO, 01' 3% "P('II1O P\ll'\lhIlHO 11\'lpp, This PnHI slwoI WlIs 11OWI' prnvl'lp\1 wlwl1 tlw $IH7,OOOPPIII1\P\', ; " " - I, " nCl'p\, wli~ I11m19, TIll! $\ noon oOlllllp\"llflu\, ,WIIs \lIIHPll nil II IWIMhlll'l1 1'01l11111SHl011 01' M.f\40 III P1'\\PI' \n sllllsl)' tho $\ HO,OOOI'P\l"l\'oI1WI1I, !lml WIIH 11\11 \ll\sPll PlIlIli~ llQrpPI1\!I~P , pnl11111IHslpl1, , , , 20, 011 I)P\lI'I11\1PI' H; \9'911,MI'. l'hi~I1Ps IYroll' MI',OW\l11 IIW\\~I' '1I1l!lPII\hlB 1111\\ ,-." IIIl wnull\ wl'il\lllw UII~OI' 11l\'0\l11~ Il\\loss Plnll1l1fl'rolllloo\\ Iho p0l111l11sHlnl11o lI!loW ,.!, ()ol'ollll!ll1\sln INt ~,\ HO,OOO 111\01' IrnnHnoliol1 cns\s, Polill1llnl1ls WOI'P wllIll1g Inpn~ " Plnll1lll'l'n \lnml11lsHlol1 01'$2,799, whlph WOlIIII hllvo SI,lllsllol\tho 1)019mlll1118' bn\\om 11110 ' , , hllSP11 IIpnl1ll111 DooPlI1ho\, Il, I ?911cll~\ shp\ll, ,MI', OW\l1l8 klww thn\ M\', l-IlI)'l1\ls hlllllo ' ; ,I<" , l<mvoIDI'1I s\lvol'n\ dn)' b\lshl\l'~S II'iP nl1 Dpooll1bpl' 10, '99H, nl1d Mr, Iln)'l1<m I1POl\l'l\n .. ~\lll'k ro~plll1HP f)'1l11l Plnl\llll'l', l" , 30, Plnlnlll'l' I'\lSPOl1dOI\\ly n 10\\01' I1lxod 1)1'001111101' 10, IOOIl, Whloh Indlollloll " \111\\ Plnlnllffh!ld II 4% pOI'OOl1tllBO oOlllmlsslon, whloh hnd bool1l'od\locd ,to 3%, nndlholl rod\loo(1 \I)' $1,000 nl1d 1111\1 Plnll1liffwollld II1nkc l1~f\Il'lhol' 1'0dllollol1, Tho loltol' ,. " Indlcnlo\1 th(11 Plnll1tlffwo\lld Hook n 3% oommlslllol1 on till' slllo If'Dol'ullltnl1ts aollllo 1\ , .. , " U\lYOI', MOI'oOVOI',MI', Owon Hlntod Ihnt ho Ifho did I\ot 110(,\1' 1\'0111 Dololldlll1tS, h~ wOllllt'" ' ." r oOllllldcl' "oUl' 1'0\\ltlollshlploHnllllltod,~' Ml', Olvcns hnd oont!lotod his nttornll~ nlld " 'iii' Pclul1dnntsl'ocolvol\ 110 1\ll'thol' oOl11lllllnlollthll1l1ntll Plnlntlfl' cOIIU11~nool\ this I\\ltltl\i" MI't oW~n dldoontnol tho 1311)'1l1' on sovuml ooonslol1H Ihol'Olll\ol' nlld IIttolllijlod to Holl him olhol'pl'Opol'tlos, Mr, Hllhbnnllndlolltod to MI', Owon thnt ,fnoklo hnd ronlly wlIIltC\t tho fll'opol'lY IIlld lhllt ho hnd' fult hnd nbulIt hUWlho thlnBH hllJlponod, " ". " " 1,\ I' ., I' " ":, " Tlw k~y In IhlH ~n~4IH Ihllllllllll111rl'k4PI IIw !lprPIlIllll\\ llmll\I~ 1\lIr~1' lI'nl11 ,. " l'ulI\lr.hlU 110 hml nOll\llhnl'lty In I'VPI'~H4111I11O III1YPI' 01' Ihu f)~I~IHI1l111H wlwnl10 HhIllW\1 IIw Pl'llpPI'l~ Inlhu IlIl~ul" 1l1l)'UI'H r~IIHnnl\"I~ 11UIlUw\1 Pllllnll.rfrupI'UHPnl\lllllw Pul\JmlllnIH, IIml P\lf~nlhll1\H r\lIlH\1IH\\lly h\llluV\l11 dill I Illllln\ifl' 1'~'pl'l)H4n\411111\l nll~PI', In I\\~I, Ilw n\IY~1' IWV\lI' 'VIlI1I~\llIw Pllllnllfl' \11 l'upl'UHunl Ilw,lln)w 111l11Ihvl)\ll'llmllll1\H " nllV91' WlIl1tllllllw PllIll1l 1 1'1' In r\lpl'~HOn\ 1I11lmln Hlwwlnu \ho PI'OllOI'!y In Ih1l1\1IY41', 1\ WIIH Ph,lnlll'l' I\llHu 11111/ 111 IHI\l1ll1l I1Il H\!llpl1lllnlH IIml 00nlh141, 1\11\11110 tOllll I\IlI\I1'u In IIIH\lI\1HU IIny .' ., lI11lln\l)' IIPI\'\1I1\ 1\11\1 In wl'ltlnlli Ihilt 1I1'1l\lOnll'lIl tolhlH PIIHU, PIIIII1\lfl'I'IlIIIlH Iln 1I11 hnp\lu\I uonll'llol fhl' thu l)ufi,Jl1IllInlH' ilhl,lullllon tll PIlY , '" " Pll1lnlln'II.3%Ool11mIH~llln, ^ PIII'I)' \llll1llUl prnOI 1\'lll11l1 dllntn\ot whlln Ihlll plll'lr IUI,H " ,., " '11111110 lillHIl 1\1lIll11lHllllldlnll Htlltllnlvnt Ihllt WIlI'O I'IlIlHllnllhl)' ruHllllllp\1n hy Ihl! PllrtluH 10 thu 1l0nll'lIul,' Tho hrnklll' I11I1Hl hu thu pl'llO\ll'lnllllllllHu ol'thll Hlllu, Stullt V" HIlVUI'Htpllk, " " 3H~ PII, S\IPO'" 3110, 5~5 A, 211210 (l9H9), In thlH ullHIl"IlUyul' fOllmlth\l PrOP41'lY wllhuul ' . .. , , , 'Plnlntlft'H IIHSIHll\1i1lo wllOn Iho f)ufundnnIH' IWI'U Hulling thu P\'OPOI'l)' Wllhollt Iho " nHHIHt!ll1\l1! of n s41101"H 1I1l0nt, Hlld DolutHlllnts HO\lllht II HQllol"H II1l0nllt WUllld nol hllvQ " " hoon pllllt11lfl'bllHud UPIlIl Ihu pOI'fon\1l1nOQ ohsol'vud diith1!! Ihu ^lll'ounlOnl, .. .. Thu Buyul' WIIH unllblu to C\1nlllut l)of\lI1dnntil Iluo 10 HUlI1~ loohnlullllllluphono , pl'oh!\l1l1, At,(hlR pohU UIl)'OI' oOlltnolud Plnll1tlrr fOl' nHHIRII111\lulll obtnlnlng n wn)' to , cOlllllot \lWlJululldllll(H dli:ootly, llu)'ul' wnH Inlhl'll1ud tlllll Plnlntl 1'1' olluldnotglvo Illlt th\l ! "~I, l'uq\losltld Infhl'll1ntlon nlld ,tlllll Ilnly PIIIII1III'I' oOllld Hhow tho lij'OpQI'lY to B\lYOI'i Thlil \VIIH , , , ' , j' , .. n fhlRO IInd I1lIHlondlnl!sllllul11UIlI (hnt 13\1)'01' I'ulliionnhly \'ullud IlPlll1ln nlll'uoll1ll tll nllow Plnlnllfftu Hhllw lho J1l'llpotl)', hI offuol, Plnlntlrrpnttlolpnlod In pl'l\o\Il'lnll thu Illlyel' i thl'()l1~h fhlRO nlld do~optlvo pl'llotl\luH, nlll11oly, plll'II'II~II111to BIlYul' Ihllt Plnlntlfl'wlIH I~ ,., .' " I' " ~'. P~lilI1II11111~1Ilu~nl, Il1sl~IH'; Plnhnlrl'wlIs llIl IlIHlIlthllrl~~II,I'I1!!\IP II11PI\1I!Hul\1,1I1 SIIIVIIl!hiU 'H' .. ,~nl1\P ~mlll1\lnsl\lIlllllhll1lllw uxplr~lllIsllnu ^I!IWIIWIII, Thl) Illls~~ 1111"~rnIlIUl1t I'n101II'Ill1! oI\\IS~" \yorp l'UI'I~W~11111 !dllUmlllJ1uuw ';, , llills lillhln Runl,Hstntu ~, Rl1lllllUU. 424JIII,~IIPUI', ~ I 0, (i 19 ^, 211 :\711 (191):\), JnllllH' , " ' , "" ~1I~011l I>rnk\lr WIIS II\II.Plltlllolll\1 n 0l1l1l111ls~ll1n \lWII wllh nil OXOIIlslI'o IIslh11! 1I1!l'\lllhlllnl WIW11111\ll'\l WIIHU rll!hllll' Ilr~1 rol\IslIl, 'Il1lhlll OIlS~ Iho burol' IlId Illlnlll\lllho I>mk\lr tn " IIfsIlOY\l1' Iho IIsklnl! pi'lco, IInlllllll I>l'llk\l1' 111\1 ~\loooHHl\llIy n\lllolh\\\lll IllI!!\l hlOl'ollsuln Ihu 'nrl'ul' 1\'0111 thu 1'lI1'Iy wl\Illl1mllllhu Ill'sl onill', Pllllnlln's IIwl1lYunlllllll11 IhlH Illlso WlIs In , , "hCllnll1\l1l hlll'l'lur 10 Ilwslllll 1>001ll1S\l nl'llw \lOHI ol'lho 1'llIlllllft's Ol1l11l11lsslol1, Tho 'I 11IlYlll"S Inilllll$l ao.ooo nl'l'ol' WIlS Ilnly slll!hlly holliw tho Pof\lmllll1ls prloull'nn , \llll1\l\iIHHlnn WIIS Inynlwd, InslolIll, J1lnlllt1ff'~ plll'llolpllllon 01111S011 tho I1ftOI' 10 ho' npPl'oxhlll1lolr $7.0{)O Illw\l1' thnll PuConllnnls' sollhl!! pl'loo, Wlwnl)ol'\ll1dnllls OXllI'\lHHlplllnlno;1 PllIlnllfTto IIWI:OIIS\l tho I1l'1\J1' hy$7,000, .. " ,;" " , , .. Plnllll1l'C Hlllolllo pOl'fol'111 \lI1d\lI'lho oonll'l\ol, Wh\ll'o Iho brokol"s 0011l1111Halon Is " ill \1\ Olllldltloll\ld IIpon tho OOO~II'l'Onoll ol'n \l\ll'lllln ovont, IInd th\l,oondltlon lanoI11l\lt. Oil lloll1l11laalonla olll'lwd, fiill:k..v, Rurul. 4221'n, 512, 222A2d 1190 (l9(6), " Tho \n\hlal onrlohl11onlthool'r nlHo flll1a hOllmlao Iho nlola do lIot, allppOl't nllY ol)lIltllblol'OlilOdy 10 Whlllls OIOl\I'lr II OIlSO of' Plnllllll'l'a \lIlol~nt' hl\l1llR, Tho q1llllltllll1 11l01'ltWollld OOI11P\lIlRllto PllIIlIlIff lhr tho nppl'oxlll1l1toly lil\II' hOlll's (If' work ho pOl'lbl'fllOd , ;, I',; \Ir~howllIg tho Proporty twloo, moollfll! wlth,tho HllYOI' IIl\d tho DOlbl1dlll,lta,IInd ,II , . .' . COl'l'ORPOlldollCO (lIllll Ml', OwolI "olll\l)d tho l'ohlllollRhh1,\1 MllI'oOVol'. Ml:, OWOII dldlWt, , , ,I'. .' lilllow tho tl'nllsllotlollthl'ollgh oloalll!!. nll\IIlIlY01'l\l\d Dolbl1llnflts did nil of'tho w(\rk thl\l , " " '1'lnhlllfl'WOllld hllvo <101\0 hotwcol\ tho n!!I'OOlllllllt IIlId oloalll!!, Tho nbROI1CO of' . H \9 , I' " !' , " iJ' I., " , ,(IOIII\\III'ol'f\lI'H on hplloH' nl' 1:lw /"ln~'noH, nil 11'11,11 l,lw 111l~lll'oH' 1\l1I1WIIllI\Iu nl1ll IIIWIllII'n\I\llllunl" lJuHpllo \,IWIIPOuplllllPO ul'llulp,P-Spll'H Hlll'\'lpUH Iln~'I;IIH HIl\\pl~' ulolll,olllo 1\0nlllh'llPI,I~: 1I'\I,h 1'lllhhlll'III,hllH II'I'OI1III'III1Y U\II,l,ln\I"Hplp,P,Soll ollt: 01' IIH , Olil'IWllllll\1\mIHHlon, 'l'lw HnYllOH III1\'P IlIlmll,lollllolllll\I I,hu PI'opol'\'~' rlll'pul,ly t:1l .. Hllhhnnllln U\lllllmhol' Ul, 11l1)lll\n'*llili,nOn, t:lIOHnmu HPIHnf!' Il1'h111null'ot,lntll(lllll ,l-hu,\I' Hohnll'h~1 l1ulp,U,floll, '.I'h(llln~'1lllH hn\'o I\n'I,hol' l1\\mlHIlI11'uf\IHlnll' tll PII~' Holp' I' I' lJ.;f:luHII uummlHHlpn, lJuHplllll,hu fllu(. (,hili, Hulp,\],SpllIl'IIH 1,110 offilllllnl, PI'IlIIIII'hW Ollllou pI' (:110 h\l~'Ul" 'l,ho HIl~'nuH I'nllllllll\111 l'I;I'\\HUI\ III PII~' (u 1l0Ip,U,Soll II 1l1lll\llllHHlon, '1'1111lnHt:llnl, 1I01:lon "'IIH IIOIIlIllO\lIJUI\ hy {,Iw fillngnl'lI oUlllplllllltjh~1 Hulp,U!Sllll , , r . UII,OI' IIhout l~ohl'I\III'~' 12, WIlIl, '1'1w lloll\JIllllnl, llllnt:1I1nH (,hl'OU OUlmt.HI hl'ol\llh of I; , oonh'lwh hl'ul\Oh of Impllod OO\lt,\'1I0t:, 11m! 11ll,hIHI: Pll1'luhmu\lL '1'110 1I0Illpll\III{: II'IIH II1t.UI' " IIlllullc!udon 0\' "!Wllt: lVlIIl'uh a, llllJlli 011 01' I1hout: MI\I'oh ll2, woo, HIIY\1UH mUll pl'olhl\lnlll'Y ohjllllt:lonHln 1,lwlllIl'UI'\1 of 1I011\\\I'\'UI'H o\ll111 t,hl'UOOO\lilt,U'ol' 1,110 II1\10nclocl ' II" ,. -I' 0011\p1n1nt" OUlI!' I1hol1,l: ,1\1l\o 1()1 IIlIlU, Ihllowln!l OI'1I11ll'!lUl1lUnl" t.hu COlIl't, 11\'U1'lillloc\ 1\11 p\iulhnhllll'Y oh,loot,llI\ill In 1'11\'01' of' (.lulp-U,Soll, On 01' I\hout: Alllnlftt; 12, wiln, , ".- -" "., "." U/\Y\10H mud 11l\;;nIlWul' wlt,h noli' 1\1 II t.tUl' Ilncl oOllnt,l1l'olllhn t.o whloh Holp,U.SolI , , l'OHIIll\1clud Cll\ lI!' IIh(I\\I, All !lll II I, aD, Jll(lIl, thol'uh:.' oloHln!lllll pIOllclln!lH, " 'l'hluOI1Hq 11'1111 llOlI\'d IW 1I1'hll,I'lIt,ol'H Oil ,Jnnllnl'~' 1 H, 1l00D P\Il'Hl\l1llt, t.o Lho 1'\\loH " , , ofl,htfl Com'I" .'1'ho nl'hll,I'nt.II\'H I'lllotllll I'llI'm' of' Holp.U,Sollnnl! nWIIl'do(IHolp,U.SolI $tiiH27,IlD, 'I'ho J.111~'noH 'hn\'oIlPllllnlolll,h~I'!\I'hi(,I'lIt,O\'lIj AII'III'(1, !1 -2- "j .' j,' ,I" " tll(,UIWIOIIH, 1I1HI\ll\l\ llnwlnll UIIIIl'/liiHp!1 III \VOI'I\H, IH h1lhl'IilJlI hy (,Iwh' 1111.1,>> IlIllllht, of'l,lw HIII'I'OIIlHlhill ph'll\llllHIIII1PllH, iI1ur1l11J!J1Wl1L1JI'III(l1I 1\\.OuUl1il1J.~, :ln~l JIll, HIIIHlI', ,UN, itli(l 1\,~r1nM'1 (/lll, SIIIHlI', 111M I), HIIIII II110t,I\III' wn~', ll'n hllP\lulI (ll!l1t,I'II11I: I>> !1I1 . ,,' I " IIIH'uul1wl1l, whiph l(lll\t.hlll\\lll~' (1IIIIIwll1(iII'I'mll'l'lll11 1,110 111\,\1111,11111 ol"t,hu PIll'I:!UH n>> uvldul1Plll1 hy \,Iw llh'II~IIIIHI'III1IJllH In nw 111'IHIIIII'~' POIII'Hll 111' 1lllllllllU 1.1H(I,pl1ml1ll1l1 , .. " , \lndlll'H(,lInrlII1U Ill' mllll' IJ1" nL I\,~ll nR'!. "\III\lI.\l1nn\l~', 1\ )lI'OI11IHll In pny (:Iw l'ullH\lnnhhll'n\lIu nl'01O HUl'l'ltlulH hllpllull "Whlll'(IIlIlP plll'I\lI'I11H lhl' IIno(;1101', wlt;hlhu ',u(;llOl">> 1Il1\1\I'lurluu, II \I>>Il(\1I HOI'l'lllll \.1\1\(; IH \lH\lIIII~' uhlll'l!(J{! f\1\', nnll (,ho'III(;I,IlI' Il'XPI'USHOH 1101IiHH0I1(; 01' nl'nllH hhnHol1' of' 1;110 HOI'l'lou," IIl" n\; I\,!lll Uli7, H'I"fll hp I j'", , ,t (I slwwl1 nl; tho '/,\'1111 01' I;hla mnl,lul't',hnl, liot; only IIld 1-lnYI1UHI\Illl\\loH(Jo,I\I I,ho 11l'o111l1' HIJl'I'WOH l'OI1I\IlI'otl h~' Hlllp'U-Sllll ",It,h l'OHPlll'\" Ill' (,hoHnlo 01' ~hull' 11l'Ilpul'(;Y 1:0, 1-~lIhhl\l'd, h\ll, I.hnl, (;\1U~'ol1lm\\l'nllodH(Jlp-U-SulI'tonol, 01' (;\1Oh' hohnlf, 'l'huuvldulIPu wiUolulIl'ly IlIlllonl,(J thnl)-Illlp.U.Sull pUI'I\wl11llllauvl1I'nl vnl\ll1hlo hl'oIHlI'l1l!u HUI'vloos ,un huhl1ll' of HI1~lllUH, I,hnt. HI1YI111H h,,1\ Imowlul\l!o Ill' thuHU ~ol'l'loUH' (;hl1t HnynoB, unllll\n'ngud Bulp-U.Sull ~o pu\'fbl'l11 thUHU Hlll'l'luu'H, IIHII (;lllit, Hulp-U.Soll hlld'lI , " " I, I, \'IlIlHOlHlhlo o1(puut.nt,luH ol'pn~'l11oHI; fl'um HIIYlloa na t,hu hOllufit,t:od \lIll'(;y,' ", 0, ill!il.U8'1' IDNRlOl-IMIDN'e ;f, " .. 'l'ilO UO\lI't.H of P~lIl1kylv!\llln hlli'o H(;lIt;OI\.t.llI\t; III ol'dul' t,o'imH(;lIll1 n ulllhn ,fill' \1l1jUHliUllt'lohIllUlI(" n pll1liit.ll'f' mUHt, ahow: "(1) hUlwl'lt,s ullnlbl'l'OII hy (;ho phdntll'f to tho dof'ulld/lllt" (!l) IIppl'oulntloll 01' a\loll hUlloflt,H 11~ thu t1olhIHllIlI(:, nll(1 ~~) llIIUU!l(;1I11011 ' .7. " I, " lV, WITt-lJQSli\YB " " 1\, H, " 0, p, ml\,OWl1lll llplp,U,Bpll HIlIII N~II\(p PI'III\l~HlllnllIH Rlllwl'l; HII~'nll~1 {\~ PII OI'PHH l(nOllpolI H/I~'no~, !\H PH ()1'llH~ . {llnln(,!!,!, l'I)~O\'I'OH.I,llIll'IHhl, (.lloIl1l /lny /111\11111 wlI;no~H(l~ illpnl:lfioll.hY PIl(hHlI/lnl.~, " 'Y" mXH,TIlI'I'S T~tH\,lng AIl"I'Olll1lpn(, bbtwllPn Hlllp,U.Soll /lnd I'I/I~'nll~, ,. IAlil;hllI 1Q1i10nHlnnhllt;wolln Uolp. U,Spll /II\(I H/lyno~, S/l111plo Hphh U.Solh\lll'ol't,l~hlll" of H/I~'no~1 I1I'opol'ty, PIIIlO~ fl'om 011 hJl1e1 II I' of l\ppolnl;l1lonta of IDeI owon 01' !-Ioln.V.Soll 1'01 HI1~'llOB! Pl'PP(ll'l;y,.. .' . . \)\BoloHln'o Vm'lI1 ImHlll1thlll Holp,U.Soll Allon\, fOIl Hl1ynb~,. . .. Alll'oonionl, of Sl1l%ffol' 111111 COllnt:PI'offpl'H!glwll hy Ul1ynoB' I :;l/tllllA Indhillt\nll Hlllp.l).So11 lIB So110I'H' ^Il"onl' IInel COIl11111aalon, AIII'OOl11onl, 01' Sl1l0/0ffol' HOl'lalon. 1:1l AlIl'Uli\1lonl: l11110l112/Wfl8, DOO\II110nl, ontltllllt "Not: PI'pooull~ '1'0 Sollul'" elnt:ocl12//J/fl8, 'I 1,0tl:OI' fl'omlDll Owon of Bohl.U.SOlJ t:o UII~'noa llnt:oel 12/IJ/lJ8, I"ol,t:lll' fl'clm Hohol't; UII~'lwa to lQcI oWon of Bolp, U,Sollll/lt:ocl12101O8, . l"otl,OI' fl'om mIl owun 1.1) HpllUl't Hn~'no~ ltlltod 12/lO/lJIlIIIHt fnoalml1il 00\'01' Bhoot" . " l"oltol' lhnh Rphol't, Bnl'llo~ 10 .Jof/hw llllhhnl'lt I!mlntoc\' Alll'ooI\lOIlI; of Snlo hot,ivool1 Hl1ynoH nncllhlhblll'eI dllt.oel lW13/Ofl, Dofllllllnllt.H' Allal\'ol'H I,ll 11l1;Ol'I'OIlIlI.OI'lclH, 1\, H, 0, D, IQ, I~, Q, " H, 1, .1, 1\.1. I~, M, N,' 'VI,',." I' tlli'I"l'blDMlUN'l' NEClO'l'INI'IONEl' "~,; . " " 'I'ho Dolbndlll1t:n ofTol'od$l,liOO,O() In 11101.(01' dllt.utl A"""Ht 2n, tlJllll, '('hla of/hI'! II'I\H l;uJootllll hy I,ho 1'11\1nl,II'I', 'I'ho . I'lnlntiff UOI11I\lllnlOllt.ud n ooun\.ol'1l(1b\' In (.1w IImount, of $o,()[)o.()() In n lof,l.ol' dl\l.od Slip tom hUl' 7, 'lIlllll, Ii 'j. , , '"" .<< " ,'" .1). " i . " .. , /1" (," ' 'I..i ",' I I (I ""~II' ('rill'; I;' ',iff/.-v,il J I ,_._ Il_., ..,. ,. ., .. ,....~) ('(;, <1i, ((,; ) l ) ) ) 1':"'-.) ~.",,-,,-,,~",!.~..--,....o.;~l\""','l~'''' .':'-..,'................ ........".. " \'111//: In 1'\)11 (li)~\~t, of C;;,>I"ml';n i;'l'llI:j 01" CHm~'\l:V ~(ln(\ CPIll\~)" f'i,!,!lil ~ 1.'/:\\\:(," 'I (/0 P' ~:,> ;.'. '. .. _, !~. \ Pt_!"_.....l......_.~..~_....".,_..,.......".....' .._.......,... 'I, ."111 ;/, .',/ II- i (,Ill \ T I I ....1 k "~I i "It I ' .,.' , "Ilill., '.,,' ,,' 0.",'1'1\ I~" 41) ~plB!ll!\.\.Y ijwellV (Ol;' lIeUvm) ~hllt \'/'~ \i~U ~I!?pql:'\:, ot"l~' ':,1',11 J'Ii' Hid "th\i'QPI\"":~U\lt~on Q~ thl\ ~1\;!,tl1q ~batijl1 1I\1c1,,'I:hta (:ol1~tilll,lI:iQI\ qi 11,~,,"'C':'Ulll\i"I'" 'ill!lI.\.th""n4 thAt \~l! ,..g,~ q;!'l1ohll1;'gathe ,ji\tillQ Ilrl <lql:' \)rlHCl!! "Iilll\ fl,IWli:",. ,,'1 ;' ..' .,1., ...-)", .(,,1 .-0"'1 (' ,I; , I".'" .. I """""'J' I "",' " -~--r-rit....._..-"1tfr'_~:1..' -11.~ ...........~... ....-...""..........,.... ,. -'1 - ',", . _....:I-<,~",'..ld1,'~'jll,h(1. .- , , .1, ,-, " ,:;;'_. ,'"Y " ' :' " .'~! ~ ',' 1;J.'rl (,," )' ,,- " /1,1..,/ " -~.""'!t--,.-......_,1..-.,tr(l'....'-~"t"'t'-.,'i"..,~.~ .........t,...~...;L..,t".. ',~....:;'\' ", ,~, '...",:' f, ' .\)... ',- \h.\~~'" \'<\,\,. \,;\\'().;lr" I, ' .-\ -, '. ~,I,~~~~~")'~';~I'i-'I.:., "i:"',,"")',';"", "'"'''''''',''''''''''' \ / ' :. " I' ,"'\~^.RD '. (Q~ " Will th. \\,,\iG1;'l1i~naq, ~r\liU"l\l!orQ, hllVil'\l! QUEln ~hlLy L'\pp,~1.!1'lldl'lld a1f:f,..-a\IlQ) 1 ,ml\kll Ilh'ti ~0U'Ow:f,t18 l\\iArc\ I , (Hou, U 411nuiBGIl ~Or \:Iday l1re aWI1!'q'!cl, ~hE\Y lha:L I bu sepllretA.\.Y sl!l\uec\.) , , ('l,;:..Jr((\ <' I,:: ~( I' gll,"l)~n " l)..., lvl..f , ' J:.L' /, 'f" , Ii, " " ./ \, , (.1,.-,1' "I'. -it/1(:... I t j' ",.,,1, ,'" '_, \ l4O_~.... ~t-'!' ,.J_....._,t......,_...".."'.':'"I..,.....,..~'~.,.'.,..I,..,,...... I ,lvI-.I"f :-,(,,""'ft':"/-;';~'I',';1 " '! ',. 1),(:,;.,:'/_ ,.~ ) ,. ~-"'-""'-~~;~-"';"..-..4""'1'; ~~..,."..," .~~.!li '. '.. ,. ._""~';'~'I";: :fi ;:., , I ' t..:. f,_.A...---........___.._..""........:."" t........t".....1 ........... -."...IIt,.;~~",."...., ) (~ (u",,; , ... \. I) ". - I -'\. ~ ,.j ~ ' - ." ,.J, I',t (~~) (n, C /,', "Ii '( (" ';'1 (.(1, "/ [, :;1/ " ("I'"'''' ,)/" a\lPUClAbh., ,,' Daile ~f H~arin81_J(~:')cl,' Oatil '\It AWe.Vtll , IIIi f (.11,1 --~------_....._.....4''1'''1''~..., .....'t..."...'..........-.!;.I\+t...1'f_...."'j!,., I. ,. ,.,,_.( ,.."Ii f! " ,I ", I I, Arbitratot', QJ,lISEI\1ns,' (T.nIlElCl \lilllli. ,,;~ "; " - : ; /('i I ' I ' I " I"~ .. r.. I I' ': l' _,/ j,..,\ r')'\-;//''t''':'''I..-t...I.{,,(,. I,: .' "_ ,. '141\1j1. --~...-..,-t'-'4-_.'~~f"-'1"-.~ - ""'1":.' ........_4 ...'!''1\'...,........,H.~. . /I!~"-::<' ,,..,'.::;\1\. .,~!utn . ,- '-;'" ;,-~ ..1; , _.J e,. ,.". _ 1 ,;: ~. I .,., ' ' --~-r:""'~';;', ..-';;~:...{ ~".4:,:,;'~;.,:I' ;:,'" ...... ....".,.""...: .."" .,., ,,';JI~,~,\i\\ '\N~\ ~~\.l(\'/'::<, .. ' ,'I ," ; ", -... ...~~lt-o'4)~.....,~..,.t,' .l4.,.....\-'t.~f.....................I.._.'..H'--.. /, I) I' NOTICE Olr EN'1'1l~~OF'\H/l.llD ~ow; the ,!ay oIl aw.rc\ W~B anUered upon the Hooket partiall 0 r llhdl;' aU toma:,s t Arbil!rAtors' Qo~pe"Bntio" to be paitl upon'eppeA.\.1 $ . 1~ "::,/::_1 III! ,".-'".' '....,,:L 1 tlnq I1CIC:~,qe llnllrlll)f! W,J.'flilll b\'I>.I;,1 Ihl~ ,11;.'1,1"11 Lli.':hli! , , ....-----.......--.."!"-..................._........ ".. ..... tt' .,.... ...... ......."......._..,~..... i' ,~o : ht:, 11 (;I 1:.1 I"'l E'Y1 .......~.-..........._,...,,-,.';,.. ........j;, ...;0"...... ~...*.'...'l..........,oo-t .:,I~pi.\ :;-:' " , " " , ,I' " I" .. Ilm.I',\J,fiHlil,IWAI, Hfl'I'ATIl 1"~OFIl~~IPN^"H, , 1'111111111'1' , IIN Tim COPH'I' PI" OOMMoN PI,llAR I OF C\JM\l111~I,ANPCO\JNTY, i 1'1lNNIiYI,vANIA 1 "I CIVil, ACTION, I,A W I . I 'e/ll' \'."'~ 1 9","'~ CIVil, VII, l~ollnHT 'IA YNHfl nml KATII!,UIlN II!\'YNllfl, " J)pl\lmh111(k , " lli.W1LIlliFIINDANTR' PR(1L1M1M(\RY onmO";IONfl. '1'0 PLAINTIFF'R COMPLAINT' " - _I" .. .. d' 'II -." "" BEFORE BAYLEY AND HIISS. .1.1, 'oPINION AND OIm\ill, . )." Thl~ 11111I\PI' III bofh~'o IIIP pmii,t 0\1 tho prplll11lnnry ob.loPtlill1Hl1fthp IIp(bmlnl1ls III Iho pll1lnl\frll 001111'1111111, TIl\llilolllllllllgollll1,lho \lql11plnll1ll\l'on~ folloWlI1 Th~ Ih)lbmh1l1lH Il1lhlll 011110, Roborl 111111 1{lIlhlool1 UnYl1oll, ol1lol'.ocllnlo II OOl1h'nlllllnl , , 'I .. roll1llo'lll1hlp with tho \lll1ll1tlff, Uolp.U.RoIHton' BIIIlIlllPl'I1lballlol1nl1l 011 ornbolll MI1roh ~"l , , , . 1998, This nlirool11ol1l onllol\ for thu dlll\ll1l1nnlll (0 \lny Iho plnll1llff~ II Ilool1l1od 1'0111 olllnlo brokQr, 11 rlllll'"porpOI1I,Qo'l1l11ll1slol1 (lnlol' rodullolllolhroo'\lprool1t) fol' prOViding 11 bll)'OI' rOlllly, WlIIhl!!, ,. , ;.. . , ",. .. ,. nnel IIblo III buy Iho 1I010111hll119' hmilp" Thllllllllll1g ngrOOll1ol1( oxplroll on SopIOll1hoOO, 1998, 111111, 00111nh10d n Rlxt)',dl1Y IIgonl'lI 1'00 pl'Otoolllin porlud, Tho pllrtloa ngrcolllo OXI,lll1l1lh~ oXp11'n1111111fl110 of tho IIl1l1ng ngrOCI110111 \111111 Ootl1hOI' ~o, 199R, nnd 1I11111l1grlllld III rocll1oo Iho " I1gol\I'~ (00 proloollol1 pOI'IOlllo Ihll'l)' dll)'lI, 011 NOl'oll1bol' 22, 199R,IIf\01':tho oxph:nlll1l1oflho . . t'" .. .. , ., __ l '" 1_,." " oXloI11Ipl\,IIi!I'00111OI1t,lho plllll1l1ffhlll'olluooll,loff)'oy Ihlhhlli'lljo Iho dolbl1lhmlH, 111 \)oooll1hol' ,. i' , " 19911, 11IIhhllrd htJughllho tlofollllllnlK J1I'I~pOl'lr, ^Cool'IUng 10 tho oOll1lllllhlt, MI', lluhhnl'll IlOl1tnolod tho 111111nllffnK II 1'\1allll ot'lillvol'lllIllIl:\ ell1l1o hy Iho lilllllltll'l', Tho I1lnlntlf'f IIhl1woll MI', '1IuhhlU'eI Iho dOfb,ndIIllIH' homo on NI11'0111hol' 24, . 199H,nllllwol'od lluhhlll'lI'lI qUl,llltlol1l1, IInd lIl'l'hngod Ibl'lI lIullollel Rho\l'l\1I!, On Dooomhor' 2, , " " " " !, "I " 9H,Ofl3S PIYII, '; I .' ",. 199fl,lIw plnhlllff PI'P.I'IH'PIIMi'1 IhI11Ill\nl'~ plIl'phllH~ Ilfl\li' Ill' $\ flO,OOO IIIlII PllnVP)'mlll Il1l1w ' . I; , , , I' Ilpl\ll1lli\1l1H, A ~PI'IPH \1fPll11ll1~rnfi~I'H\ln8\IPII'l\IlIII1PP\11llhlllllllh~ PI1111pllllll11 Jlllhhnl'llnl1llllw' " IIpfpI1IIIInl8 I'Pl\Ph~IIII!!l'oPI1WIII nn n Onnl pllI'plHlHl! Pl'lp~ Il'r $\ fl5,OOO, 1<< , ", 'i'lw Plllln\I\'l'lIllw plnll11H 11111111 IH PI1II1IPIII\1 n ,'pnl OHllllp hl'l1Kol' plllllmlsHlpl1 nl'$~,?lin, Ill' P', i';-.. _j" IIH'PP.'pPI'Il~nl' Ill' $1 "lilnOn, 't'lw pllIll1llfl'H nllWIHlpl! pompllllll1 Ilnl1lnhwllllH'\lIl ~llp01;illll PPllIlls,", " i' ."" " hl'lllWh of on nIl' no 1 (Cmlllll), \11'0iWhPl'lI1111IlPllpllnll'np( (Cn\llIlIlIl,I~1' In Iho IIl1p1'I1nllvllll1\hlHI ,,' " ol1l'lphnwl1l (CnmlllD, Tlw dpfpl1dlll1ls' pl'~llmll1m~ nl\jpptlonH nl'O In lIill 1111\\11'0 Ofll~I11II1TPI',S III 1111 Ihrll\! ~1Il11l11H nfllw ,;llllnllff'H \1nl11plllllll, Fllll\holhlh1whl!! I'OnH111\8 WP llon~ Ilw Ilpf\ll1lhmI8" pl'olhnlnnl'Y I1hipollnl1~, ,. l. j, , ;, "" ! ThllloHt HW)ll'olhnlnnl'Y nhJootlpnH IH wlwlllol' !II~ 1l111l1l' OIHI 1\'00 1\'l1m !lo\lhl 1\'11111 ,,1101',. '" " . Ihpl\wtH p!Plldlld tlH!t 111\1 plPlIIlol' wlII 1'0 1111I1blo 10 pml'P .f\IIlIH l~fJnl(y Hllff1ololl(11l oHlnhllHh hlH " ." " I' ,I' I'I!!hllo 1'llllof,Fll'inu \',!Kp)1lmri,466 (In, 560, 563. 31i31\,21\ "33, "35 (1976), .lnllolol'mlnln!! " Ii . -. , ' Whilll\Ql: (11 Rllatn,ln pro!hnlnnry ol\jootloI1H. thlH oomt I11I1HI npoopt IIH 11'110 nil wol\J1londod mnlol'lnl fnpls nH wollns nny 1'01lHIll1nhlo Inforlll1ooH Ihnt I11ny 1>0 dl'l\\~nlfol11lho'Ro fnotH, 'Bowor v, BOWOI', I ; ,_ II ,_ ';,," " "., 531 PII, 5~,57 ;'6 II ^,~d 'I" I, \"2 (fin, 1992), FII'HI, wo 11I'0 ~!lIIHllcd Ihllt Iho plnh\l\f'fhIlR Iltlllod n OI\\IHO of'1I0t\ol1 with I'ollllrd 10 Iho Ill'st . oOlll1lof tho COl11pllllnt; bronoh llfOllnll'lllll, 'rho POIlIl~~ll'nl1lnS\ipl'ol11o Cnlll'l hnH ~IO(C~lhllln " " " , 'I, hrokol'.IlL1l1l111II'CCllVOI' II oOl1l1n\HHlol1 IlI1IPHH tho hl'l1kol' clll1Hhnwthnt I\Clll1lrnot, olthoroxproHs or , 1l11pllod.oxlHtod bolll'ool1lho 11I'llkOl' IIllel Iho Hollol', 01' thnt tho Hllilol' nocoptod or I'ntlllod Iho 1I0lH " llflho tlmKol\, .ig,llhlUH(\" MllAIlIHtOl',Ao7 I'll, 46, 54, IHO A,2d 244, 249 (I'n, 1962); Aeldllllll1l\lIy, Iho clllu:1 Htlltod Ihllllf'tho bl'nKor "OtllIHtItUtoH Ih!) ;'~llolol1tollllRO of tho pr~\hlot\QIl " .. of'n aollol,> 110 Iii !!0I101'1\lly cllllllcd tn hlH IllllllllllsHlol1 ovol1lholl!!h Iho ~l\lo wnH oOI11)1lotod hy,tho l' I' Hollo!' hltll~cll~ nl' IIll0thol' hl'okol'." Axllblll1d, 407 I'll, III 54. 1 HO 1\,2d nt 249, , " " " 2 "" , , " Ufl,nmPIVII, I' ' ", Tlwllvllllll ftlll!ll1flh!ll'lllll ~ft\l\lll \lll1k plllllP 111\01' \llll \ll!plrnllnn qrlllllll"t(I1I.lIlI.lI'~PI1WIII 11llIWP\ll1lh\lplllllll1ffl\l1\llh~ Ilpl~l1\h\l1lil, "" \wllll" plI"IIIWlhll'l~.IIII~ 1I1.!~1'\ pl'l1lllP\11111 pUI'I\1II. HOWPYlll" \I\Pllol11\1II1I111 111;p" 1I1l11l.!ll Iiwlft HllrtlpIll111 10 "IIPpl11'\ II pllIlI11lhll\ Ilw Illl'~ml:ml" 1'1I'1111l11 " " \lHl IIIH\\Ilh\ll'I~OIII,WIH ol'Jlw plllll1lll'1' 111 PI'I1PIll'llIl.llllI\1\1l1n.\11l h\l~lll' I'PIIII~, Wlllllll.!, 1I\1\llIhlp In plll'\lIHlftP Ilw Ilplbmlnlllft' prnpol'\~, " . " I', , ' Hntll1\lnllQn 1ft \1~I1I1P\IIlH "\1wllfl1rl11nl1\lo hr n plll'ftnn of II pl'lul' \lpl Whll,lh ,1111111\11 ,hll\11 hli]1 hilI \yhlllh wi'ft dOlWl11' PI'(1I'ps"PIII~ 1I011P 011 hill lll1lll1l, wlllll'llhr Ilw IIlll,nH 101l0I11\l PI' nil plll'ftl1iift,lftUlwl1llffupl 11ft Ifol'ltllnnllr 1llllhol'l;r.Oll h~ hlll;~1I l'llplo y, Rohhhls, Nu, 1J7;()V447, 1999 WI, ~70()70, III + ~ (1111: SllrO''') (I'ltlllg tlwIMlnlollwnl(Sooolld) of ^1.!\lI1\lY~ 94), 'I'hll: I, ,', ' .' " ' i! , " \l01l1'1 WOlll\lli to llllo Ilwl{~alllllll11\l1l1 III 1lll\ll111.!Ihnl nil 1I00pptn11011 ,~nhlllllln\lih\)\'I;r.\ld IIIlI pnll hp , t,.. ,." llVlllllllooll b~ II fillllll'o 10 1'0Pllllllll0 It, llli ' ,;" "iL, hllh\l oOI\1\1lnll1l, IhopllllllllffnllolW~ fllOlft, whlllh allow Ihllt tho plnll11lffwll8 IIPUIII.! fl1l' ., ......",.. , IhllllOl1OI1t Mtho Ilo(\Jmh1l1Ia, Tlwso 1I11ll\1dll ,t.llnllllll plllll1\1!'flll\l'oll\IPlld Hllhhllrd lolho dllflllldllllts, \I;lIlllw' pllllllllffnl'rlllll.!Olllbl' I\VO ~howllll.!H c{fthu dllfllllllll\118111llliill,liw Hubbm\I, IInIUh,II'i tho plllll1tl!'f'lrnl1s1l1Itlol\ tho Il1ltlnl of'tUI' h~ Ihlhhnl'd,llH \VolI ns oll\1I110nlffol's 1;~lwo0I1 . . .. , HIlllbnnlllndUIll dlllbmlllnts, Thllsll III0I\1nl nllllgiitlol1Hillso S\\p)lOI:\ nolnll1\ lhn1Ihllltol'onl\nntH ' fnllol\to rOpullllilllllw notions Ofthll plnll1ilff,lhlll Wlll'O 111!ldll onlho dlllolle1li\\IH' IllJhnlfnl\ol' Ihll " llxplmlllln Ill' thllllsUng nl.!l'Olll1lOnl, lImllhnltho (loIUndlln!s' thlls mUl1lld 1\\0 plnlnlll'l'8 nots, Aa In Iho d1l1l111lTlll' 10 Uw hnpllol\ OI;illl'lIllt llllUl1lof'tho c;;mplnI111 (Cllllnllll), Iho "plnlntlfrshrlof'slnlos Ihnt p\ll'sllllnllll CIlI;,bol'lnnd County COIlI'I of'Coll1\1111n Pions L(iOlllltulll F' " 21 0-7,(hnt Ihll dofol1l\lInts' !\llll1l1tTlll' ns tll COllnlHlllf' tho Amondod COll1pllllnt ahnllld ho 'I, dlHliilsaod hoonllso,lho !\olbndlllllH f)lllolllo hrloflhoh' dOI\l\nToj, 10 Cll\llIllI\. WllIIOlo, hll\\'llVOI'. '1 ,. " Ihnllhll dolundllll(ii I'llfulTlld 111 his brill" to COUIII till nll\IlH 11011IHlgly, Nlll\ClIlllloHS, tho dOI11\U'I'OI' 'llhnll ho lloiilod ';ollnuslllho )lllllnll!'f'hns nllo~od sllf'flolllllllilll,ls 10 Hllpplll'l his oll\lml11\(llll' Coulll '" J .' Ii I, " , ,. J\ " 9",P~~~ \J1VI1, " 'Ii HI. TIlu \l\1111plllll1lllllu~\l~ nIP\~ Ihlll,In Ihu n\l~\ln\l\l rd'rnllf1\lnllnllhy 111\1 \lul~llllllllla nflh\l 'lllllllllirH ,l\\lI~llhnl IIWI'Il ,vna II U\1nI1'l\\llhnpll\l11 hl nl\ll \WIW\lunlhu plnlnllff IIIl1I Ihu 111l!'1l11l1nnl~, " ru/;llll'lllh/;llhupllllnlll'l'~ IIPI~ nnlll' IIw Ilxpl1'l\1I011 nl'lIwllHlll1/;ln/;ll'llllllWnl, , , , , l\ \lnI111'1\utll11pll\lII'llIli\ull~ "i1l11l1l1\ln! \l\111lrnol whl\lh nrl~\l~ wlwrll,lIw pnrll\l~ Illll'\l\l IIp\ln ;-.' , " .' '. " j. Ihll \lhllll\I.Ilol1~ 10 \l\lII1\lII1WII, hllllhulr 111I\lnllon, hwt\lnlllif 11\llnll \lxpr\l~a\lllln wnl'll~,l~ Inf\llwll , , , f)'ol11lhuh' Il\ll~ IIll1wllllht lll'lhu ~11I'l'llllndll1ll Ch'\lIlIl1~I!\I1\llla !llId 'tllll orlllnnry CoIII'~u nt'llunlh\1l nl1lllh\l \l0111n1\ln \11\dul'~tllndhlll ot'nWI1,'" MI~I'II\I,\','L1l1lo.I}l'llIyn IUld Co" 30f! Pili RIlP\ll"4~4, 4~l). 4~O A,~lll)H4, PH7 (I1I1, flIlPUI', 10H I), MllItl\llllllly, II pro1111~u III pny thu I'CIIHonllhlu YllhlU 01' Ih.u ~urYIC\lI~ hl1PllulllI,vhul'o' Pl1u purlhl'l11H for IIl10thol', wllh 1IW'1l1l1UI'H klll1\vlUllllu, II IIHQt'l11 , " , I, ' " , , H\ll'vlou Ihlll 1~\I~\lIll1y uhllrllull lill',1I1l11 thu Intlul' UXPI'UHHUH n1111l~~UI1I01' nvnllH hll11~ult'Ql'thu " ,-, HOI'vlull," Mur1lJ.l, 304 l;n, '114'30, 4~o A,',2d nlOH7, Flnnllr, 111\1 P"I'(Y PUI't'\ll'll1lnlllho ~\ll'l'luo " , . , , 'lIl1~lhnvu n I'clI~ol1nhl~ cxpuulhllol1 of' pnYl1ll1111 hy tho pl,ll'lr hununlud, M. I,' , In thu cOl11plnhl\, thc PlnlnllffnllcllUH Ihl1t nnorlho oxplrnlhlli'of'lhu IIHlhlgn~ruun\lJl1lln I, ,011\l1huI'190H, thnl,lhu pllllntlffprnYldul1 hl'l1kol'n/;lc ~orl'leuH Ihni'nru 1l~lll\lIy uhnrllcI\ rOI'! nnd tile il , ,., dufullllmllH oxprCHHU\\ no dl~Hulit 10 thcHIl HurvlouH, Thll ooil1plnhl\nl~o nllogoH Illuta Ihnl thu " , ,'-" dulilll(tm;IH nvnllcd \lwI11Hllll'u~ ul'lhu plnll1lll'l'H HOI'l'lcOH, H~luhnH nl!uwlng Ihu plnhllll'flo CUnYllY ., " . . . , ' . . . . . ,Hill dcl'cl1dnlll~' ,c(l\u1\uruf(~I' 10 Huhbnl'd,' Thul'~fbrll, n~ of/or nud 1I0uUp11ll1\lU l\uc\lnut bo Ilccd " n~1 hull\onlllll\blu fbl'l\ CUI\II'l\olll11plluel 11\ Ihut,lulllilllHllI ConHtl'lIotlon C~,.II\Oi' y, WuIIih, 337 , 1'1\, Supol',~H; 66, 4H6 A,2d 47H,4H~ (PI\, SUPUI', 19H4), ihu \1'101' uf f\\~1 could cllltol'll1lt\u t1iilllhu .'" plnll\llff'hnllII 1'0l\Hul11\hlllOXpolltiitllll\ ol'oulI1ponHl\llol\i\l1lllhnl thul'u \VIIH 1111 hnp\luel cOl1trl\ol "bct\V~ol1lhllllll1lnHff'nnd Iho dolbl1dllnl~bllHud 01\ thu fhelH nllollcd Il1lhuo(ll11plnh1\, 'I." \, Adllltlullnlly. In Ul'dol' fhi' Iho plnlnlll'f to oollclll hlH c0l111111HHluII hc I11UH,\ nulol1l~ Hhow 'I' ' " ;, ' " 11\1\1 "hul'u \VnH 1\11 n~tllnl.ul' hl1plllld ounll'llol, hut 111111 thu pll\\ntif'f \VI\H I\IHulho "cf'llclon! onURO of' "If . " Iho pl'llduutlul1ol'1I huycl',"lhnllllthn/llolYlll1l'llhllHCd tho dofbndlllllH' ptl1l1utly; 6.Jillh.uni11407 , ,.Ii " 01' ,. " , Qfl,UQ3S qVII, . " I'll, III '5(1,,1"0 ^,211 III ~4l), 'I'hll \lPlllplllhll III1IlIlIlH Ihlllllll\1hlll'll, 'hp\I1\hllll'llliill'\lhll~\l1' p';lhll ' IllllbmllllllH' pl'nplll'lY, 1l\1I\H\ollllw HIlI'VIIlIlH pfllw phlhllllTII" II 1'1l""1l nl'lhp \1111111111'1'H 1111WI'II"1111l' ,,' < ,- , , Tlw Ilnmp11l1l1l1l1l01l0" Ihlll IIw plllh1\lff' IIITI\lIIWIIIiH' 1111\1\111I:\1 III vlllIY l\w pl'npllrly, 111111 111111 Ilw plllllllll'l'lIPIllll "".1111 hll~rll1lllllllry iiII' III1l plll'lIll" 111II'11I1I'lho IlP\;l'nllnl'l\w IWlIllllllllnllH, 'I'I\\lrllllll'll" , I." Ilw plllh1l11'f'l1I1" 1I1I\l1l1l1'"\lfflIlIVI1I 1'1I\l1" In ~\Ippllrl 11 Illllhl1 1l1l11llw pllllnlln'!l nlll" Wlll'lllho MOllt\lnl \lII1IHo Ilfpl'mlll\l1111l Ihp \1I1YIlI' PI'l\w 11\llbl1dunlH' pl'llpul'ly, Tho IIolbl1lhmlH' Ilo11111lT\l1' IIH lo'thli III\hIHI olll'lllhllWnl \l0\1I11 Ill'lh\l un1111111l1nl(CIlI\lllm I,H IIIHO'llolIlllll, 'I'h\l H\lllllllll. \l!llll1lol'lho ol1l11plllllll ;11I1\lH 111111 In Iho nhHOII\lobl' nil 1111111111 111' hl1pl\011 , , 001111'1101, Ilm\ Iho )llllll1lll'f IH \)111111011 In Ih\! rOllHlllHlhlo I'lIhlo of IlH broklll'l11l0 HOl'l'loo" 1\lI111'\' Iho , ' , . , . , ' .' dplllrllw nf IjIIl1HI,onnll'llol/lli1.lIlHt onrlo\1nwl1l, IIU111lko,ll'Il\l \.lontl'll\lIH, 11\1l1~I,oonlrn\l\H IIr\l I\IlI bll~1l11 nn Iho IIPPllrol1\ Inlol1l1onwpfllw pnrll\lH 1lllllllllll'IIIko IIw pUl'lhl'lnnnoo hi II\)OHllol1,"lhllY Ii' ,,' " "" . " _0, . . ',-, '-', 111'0 olllllllllllll1H lll'\lnllld \1y lowllll' r\lIlHIlI1H ol'hlHII\lo," MIII't1l1, 304 Pn, SIIPOI"111432, 4~o (\,21111'" 9R", ,_, i ._'." To ~11HIIIII1 II olnhl1 fbI' III,I\IHI 01ll'1c\1nw111 1\ plnlnllff lmlHt HhoWI"(\) blll1~f1IH cOl1f\l\'rl1d by Hi ;/ " .' ., Iho plllll1t1rt'tl1lho d\llbl1dlll1l,,(2) nppl'ocllllllll1l1fsuoh hll110nlH b)'lhullofondlll1l, !\l\d (3) , ' , " ,-., , " j, 1I000r\ll110C Ilhd rotol1tlol1 01' HIloh bCl10nlH ul1do\, ~\Illh Clro\lI11HIII1100H Ihlll II WOllld .h~ Il10qllltnhlo , .' ; 101'11\0 dol'omlnl1llll \'\ltnhllh\l bOl1ol1\ without pnYll10l1tof 1'0IlH0I1I1\1101'1IIuo," fluhollillLY...K.J1 Dllvld.LTD" 446 I'll, SUJlor, 94,97, 666 A,2cl 327, 378 (Pn, SUJlo\" 1995,) Fl'oln tho nlol~ " 1I1101!011, tho \lol'ol.\c1l1l1tH W\lllhl hlll'o "pPI'OOllltod tho HO\'l'looH pl'lll'ldod by Iho plllll1tlffthnllod lip 10 tho IllIh11I1(O Hille lolhlbbli\'d, Al1d 1I11110t' Iho IMt~ 1I1101l0d, Ihl\ dolol1c1I1I1IR nqcoptod I1nd ,)r l'\lt\\llIod (hoHe bOllol1\H by Cl1l1t111111111l10 lI110w Iho plnll1lll'l'lollot ol1lhol1' holullf IIllot' Iho OXJlll'lllll1l1oftl1\lll~th\1! 1I1!\'llol11lmt. '1'11011'101' 01' nlot 111l11111Ihol'olbI'0 d~I01'1111110 thlll Hnld , , . 1I0coptllliOlllll1d l'otOl1tl\ll1l1l1 tho pllrlol' Iho dofol1dlllllH WOllld bo Ul1ulJllllllblo \ll1lo~R Iho dofol\dlll1lH cOlllpOliHlltlld tho plnll1lll'f'. ~ .., : 1'-' " , " .',1, , , '10 Ii. ' :n Tl1I11'lilll111ff \VilN 111\1 offl,Wlll'o, offl(:lpnl PI'OI!lll'lnll ril\ISo of 11\11 Sill'p pf 111II1?qf(,lIldnl1ls' In\llpIPPIII\Y, " " :14, Tllll ilrllol16 ilncl HPIVlrll6 oflho I'I;\ll1llff 011 I1nl1l111' of 111\1 l)nfQnclunI6i111c1 Ihn Pnfnl1(lIml6' " m:rllplunl:o unci I'illlflcillllln of 11,1060 urllons PlI16111l1\0 im Impllncl l!onll'ilcl,whnruI1Y' IMllnllUI116 ., " Il11pllllcll\' ullruilcl 10 PilY I'lillnllff iI conll11IHslon In 111\1 nVOl1t il snln WIIS 1!0IlS\1I11Inillmlllncl IIwI'lillnilff ."." " WilS Ihu O(f1d\lnl pl'ol:1II'11111 Ci1\l6U:/Jf Iho 6i1hl, " :15, P06pllo tho n~pll'illloniJ( tliil IIslInll i1111'00111pnl, PnfnlHlill1ls ~l1nW o( ilml rnllflllcl ,I '1'lillnllf('6 (:(lI1tillllll1!luf(oI'16 'IO:MlCllrn iI rlll\dHI6UI (or IIwll' pl'lllinlty unci kl1nw (If unci rnllflolllho "F 11\Illollutlpn6 pnclul' wny \Vllh Ihu !!IIII11UI(~b(lYlll'on Ihull' l)(lhul(. 1'" ,,36, "Thll Pu(onllill116' condllctlllclllcml ilncl ol1cn\II'nllncl thol'lillt\llff 10 (:lll1l1n!!ults offolt6 " III ';PCIII'O ill'oncly, Wlllll1B nlld ilbhl PWclHINUI' (or I)nfonclllnls' !JI'Opnlty ullcl sp;wlfh:ill1y tp contllHlu " I' , . , . " I)oijo(lnlloI]6 wllh Ihu \11t.111111(0 IJllYol'.,PofonclllntN' "ru thl~rufornl!sloppncl (rom c1nltllll111lhlll 11111 llllnmnlllnt l1olwoon Ihill'lnll111(fllnd tho!Joful1c1nnlstnrl11lnntucl, 3 '1, l'lnlnll(f Is ul1lllhicllo it cOl11mlsslol1 of Ihroo PUI'ClII1(' (.10/.1) of Ihn plll'chll60 prlco, 30, l)ofen(1I111Is' fnlllllll nncl rufllsill to PilY Plillntlff n cl1l11mls6lonconslltlltos 11 bronch of ii, ., ,. F ,. " COl1lrill:1 or In thu illtol'l1ntlvu n brunch of 1i\1pllocl Clllltl'llCI:, , . I' , , vYl'I/:I~I:i:ORH, I'hilntlff, I-!nlp-U.Snll Rnnl I:slillo Pro(nsslCllwls, I'ospoclflllly I'nqllosls this "," ii' l-!ol1ol'ilblo COlll1l~) 011101' 11 jll(l!lI1lllnt'llllts (nvol' ill1d illlillnsll)llfllnd"nls, l~oblll1lll1d l<llthlmJilI'luynns, " , " "" I" II1,lho 11111011111 of $!I,!I50, pillS Inlol'osllllld costs, which iU1HllII11 Is wlthllj'\hll illllOllllt tllqlllrlllll I, complllfiory ill'bllmtloll, ;)' 'i, .' " " .(i. " " ". " " " " ;I', .gll~P(I(:I(~llly Hllblllll1(I(!. 1~(:Atm~ & ."PI.I'Il, p,c, '(j w . '~/l'" I I ' ,,/ -' /~, -L ,/ , !.iN\JSI:,I'I;NIC :, l:sQUII~I:, A1\1I11111Y I,P, No, 600,1'1 ' TI-IOMAS 0, WII.I.IA/vIS, P;QUlIlli . 1\110111111' I,P, No, 670/17 . '233.1 Mmkol iillool p Ci1Illp HIli, I'A17011 (717) 7(,:!.131l3 Alloll111YH fOll'lillnllff Pnllll Mnrph 3, l\lOO " " ,', '" " ":'j ';;1' f' ,. " I'.. " ,. " " " I' ,. I ii, " I' " " " " L II " I' , '" .7. I,; 1;; ,; / " I" ., " \I (;', " , " it , ., ':~~,- I: , " r " ", S '\ ~ ~ \ l;'~ ' ~111 ~~ ~~ '<. ,~ ,~~ ~ \ l!,\ ~~ ,I p~g'p~,~~ P~I~~~ H~lp.~.ij~11 ~~~1 U~'~'M ~ 7~P A\'~ I~ 0\11 I, , , J;"PJ..PSI" ,mll1T TQ~',I,I, MllUiliM~:t\'~'..flllljAI,l' III 1I1!.Q, ,;nA'1'I'; nil (MN 111~"1~I'M 1,4 ml,r\!.(,",i~lll, VII by "'1"1\111 vllh""OIl!lii I 1,11'1 ^""ltlll' ~(K~^LTmh" , ' AP \tiT! . t~l,4ri1,\\f1-# &w. pr>m,w K3JV;R9f, r~*~ . "II, ~I!:]NHIU>-UR~ " I ''''''\I'I~I\' IIlhHltll\' , ,""'- ' f ~\1I1~11 tllf! l/q1r /1010 "f~I~'lm ~'II'''~1 ifj/~. .tG0?a ffn""","ai12~_/. ,"""" .' , . \'\h'WHIO i----4~..R.E.'~ '7?. ,:r~,\ .__., " _,..",,,, ',Qw"'JA~~r ANII 11lpf ~111~;P,"'111 'I~'l'''' h'\lttll'l tW"l 'H '~I I~~l.'ill~tlllll It'/l./l!' !'ll~ ',Ij 1'1 "~ 'll Itllf\l!'.ll ''''Wl~ 'I \'WjJII., "I'~ l:?,;e\i~:.. J~.IJ'~~_ ' .,,,, IrI6.,~..I?J!:!.2._ H' III' k_~..Ifi:!'a~::>_"H.l lII'" A'll~~~.L-1~tilr,~g~ ,\I 1~~J:/JL.@Iw...-;"'I'I,! ,11"".fT,IilI\qrtl'~:;-, ''''I "",,,_ ---,_., , "HI ". ,.".~~tl,' III . "....:;I.~er..I,"I3~, ~ '~HU ~'~llltll.,\t1II'I'~_, .., "~-'--.'....'!t. I, H \1111':1./"1 III. \lill1'.III,tll,' '\PIN, \,t"tt,(J"I":'l ~".! ,', "I r'II~I,\ I"h'~:"~., It.I;,IIIII f 111,'1.1 11~U Ilf 1,Il,u\\ \,.",.li",I,~j '0'<1'" f"~ I'~''''''I'' 111l1~IIU ./", 1111.'/"1' ,'tilt, 11,1. '" ~IIH In !thlll, 1,./01'. 'I'll! I.\' 11'1."" I'. .""ll 'f": '.,"q!.'f""t., "',Pll .j,\, 1111 .l( 11'.'U"'I, Illllr,I. Ill" "111l~ltI \'nrl. III ft. '."'1" ',I"""!! h"'"", PI'tl:", Ir' n 11 -w IH~lt\ ',Hj'\jtl' flll'lh,. il'!f\', ," II II, pill "1'1'1",' "I" ,,1"11". lh"lttl '~,j~l.t'l'll 1,,1 I.t" 11/1. 'Itll t,tl-l'''I'utlll I'\~ Il"'~", .,11 '!", ,\.., III! (HIlI. ,'.n 11.1' II r 'i~ll1, llill' \'l~ "11"t'\ ""'" II "I. ." II' \/!llr"~'1 \hl,"I~ 1\''''''[11 '''' V"lll' ,HI'''. 'I hIll.", rlol\' 1"1",,,. "~-"lll,1 '\'~I,I"I"" II, /i \lll~t'I'_I' lH II' I'll' ,l.;~,!.., I, '" 1'1""11 i"l' ~'''''' '!,,/ fllf!'I.I':I. "1 '1I"ll""j "1''1, ,11111111'1\"1' l'h.lt. . 1"""""" 1\ 11"'1 lOt II' 1"'1111'1 '"1"1", ~,'ll ,I.W 'q fll\tl>l" IUI' 1./.(,-, 't"I ,I' ,', 'f'I,I\ 'l~mHlIHII..'. '." I ., .:~ I'l!l'l "1\0""',.4 11il.et1'lIt "J r'/'llJ.ti.'I~tl'~'~ ';,1" .'."1 ~:':" "'~,' ,.ltl,,!11 -'II '~I III ,',I ~lIf' I ,", 'PI '~W"I""I' "~I "'1\"" ~I\i:l /I)11J:r.J::Jl,'-I:;f.J?.,..J:....14.P./.;.\lll, l'(r~ \.r:ofl, '.._____".,.~ --p."", I ... l t1 "I'" >III ''''11,11 'I ..2E:6f!?.!iL1Jt.. ,'l' ~,ult.~'\II,;l6 .. ,-,."........'" iT If 1 ,,, '" ~ ......., ,. .., I..j 'j. " ' . -,-----:~'.~'_n'"-.....".' '.\'01 tt' 11 11M i,. u." ,~\, I 'tlll\'" '11 'Illl~ YlI", 41''1, 1/,II'I,ll ~III., \,.t-'I t' 'I .11'1'+ .,. f.1.!'1 '1\1'11'/11 I '1"111".11 II 1~"1 I' !I,,"I'. "I' . ".'If till. c,>lf. 'I dl, III II~tI'l ',"'" "l""" I,~hl ..', t'~'I""llll'I, 'l"\ ,',11 ,'1'1'1 I'd .,. ',',II!'" , h"!ll ~.AI ,I Ih',', ',' 'I' '1': .', It'llll'l '1'1'1, " ,. '01' .,-, ,\,In'!~1 :11411"11111 'f 1'lIliJltlll1lltPI1\ . ,.... ____.~,..._..________.. " I '\'!""t-i~~--:-- ~-"";":-..t ""-1' , ,.._____._---;0-__. " 1M"IH" 1""1" lIUM.\lI,,,"VI,!"11 ~-I Illll! 1'~I,I"~"I','~. HI'I' I~;tl l'o') jl.I\1 II ''!pjlll\ " fiN l\ql"lllltt.',I'\'\I~j1q.. 1111. 'I,ll. II' .!ol,1111 \" rI III ~lllll 11~IIU ~'11l i .111 '''hl~I'1 tli'I'f'lJ,.-- . ,_ ..,. , t.11\'rlll~'llfll'" hi 'I 1/11.1'1 I. p",!\t r"!I ,"'\I~il~ll /Io\!IlV,I' \,il"'~1 tll','1 H" III illt. ft,II'lq" 'H". 11'1 ", t I'Ylll 11'11<1",1 I ,Of I ( , M 11.1 ~'''r j'-'!,I~ lltl, lIHIlI~, lIlt M., '.1111 It' ""1"'-.1 rill. r'''HI''f 1111('111 ,Ilo, ,i 'III r~1 ~" !Il'" I~ H j\1 IAl"\^!" II., l;i"II,~ . ! \, \1,1"1' "'"IV'lII'" ' , ' ~,II'I"4 ~"IJ ,11~11 t(~ti 1 ....,1 ~.! Iqlhll Il-\n.. lit ,; I, 11,I.hl....j.'..'I' ',IU ~"I'I . ),'II'~ HI'H. r '11 ~~' II "'r,,"1fl ,,',. ~1'''I/'I1 ~11'1'-t "nil', l. "\' ~'/t I, !""'l"j""'" ',\1''''''''' ,,,". "'n <I'\'IHII"q"'j"H("'tIN"il(''''ljlll'l '1"'1"\''''1'''''''''''' ,,,',' ..,.' '\"1"'1'"'' I,UH' "l~t 1'''','11'''/111\1'''',11'11''''1 \ 1111 ~ ;I"llll \'I,I\1l.ll"" Itflt,' #....,' I~~l 1h'H':' ,.t", ~I." !"Il\'j.~' t'/ttlH,_,,,,~,":'''hll,I., 'I~r-j~ttk, ~~m/JI~'~,\ 1'("I'l"t~nH' UII" 'I- ,,' l"ttJ"""'IIlH 11\11 "!<It! I'" II' l"I."I! I ""ll "nn~ 1\\;1 'II 'wv \j.t"l 1 \\1"" 11,,\1 " "'1\ ""~,' I '\' I "'I' '\f "'f"""I"" "~'1I1' :HI '"IN' ''"1''\ '!"" ' !H, tIll "'I H 1""1\ !Ill ,II' l11I1L1L ..11I ~ lIt f,lUI,'d ,.1 ('~ ~"lljI411(1'-I'ln \ :'1,' 'I I. II ,1""'" ",l'.I!\ III" 1'.1\,," 'i\, ',\ IHI Ii itt' t' llh . ~',II I', 1/'111 Hl, II I'~'.\ 11111 I '-'" III! l' 1,IIL',', loW .. 1"'/1 Ii I n.t If; \'/1 \\'111, It \ ':"11 \11':\ t .'Il' 11 l ~1\)\ hqlJlif-H \' ~ ~\\1,\ 11'1/111 ''''111.:.1. ~It' 'I.ll \11' II" ~ ".H,. III II ..'~ ~ It 'I t t"lllll tl! "t~ Jlft1l1 hUt lq ,; ~'lr,iJrall '1' ~ ~!"'~I1III'''''!1.~lYJI /'I~"n,.--1.YJJ~~" "D/ /} 18, lll;Illllf', flU 1I1fl11,' .~<?1,:n:,~", ~ II t,.t; "tll"'l "I r~ ~ 11 ,if(-~,.'~~ll"\ "I IIIHf WI '~"" '111~1" r.'1 "t1~IlI""ll~I'" I ',\I'f-Ifl' ,! ", 1111 ,l"'"f '"'~",,~ III , I.J. ", ".\ iJ~ " '!J,.H"'~llH~1 ''''I\IIH It \l f!Il'II' II "lllf"~H \""1\ 1'"1',1,,,,' <I'll''' ,.. \""11 ~l~ .,f Itu' j"1\'~ 'lfl. '~I '111\ t,~ t"1 ill'" ,.If''''Itt' ~.~h;.1\1 'I,n t I~I "'MI "Hrl ~l',n 'nllll "". f 1'\ A'fl~' 1 J It, HI!.'II" ," lI;I\I\1I'h '.'I'fllll1,. ,., "'ff~I'lllhtt."M '" Itlith! ....II"~'I' t 1"'/11, <4'1111 '1"1., ""I" "IIwl", 'I,' "tot ~"I'I.I" H ""'11'1' ,~, u1l 'Il,~ tln""'U'It1!'rl t'I'Wlt Ht fll ','ltJUl l':Jf ,I'" I'" ("IV'111 "I 'I ,t "'111''1' "If "'l~"ll', ,I"I.~ "1, ", .'. "I ,~" '!I""I'I,.,I/,_II, II'" 'II', hI. 'III' t"" ,,'~'I 11'~1 "N"I14'flo(~n',~, l~ I" '''I '1'-1 ,.Ilil ~ \ 1".1 Iv '....11~1I "II 11'11\ TIJII'II'IlIII".l~lI11~fll'(l'I" t""IIl-tI1nll ~flfllltt' '1'111 A.I ~ '., 'I'IUllII4\11\ iiJUI ntl~411"' '11""ltlll"I'I,,~j ""1,,1 ~-/lllII" . \ \1'110\ tll)"I 1"11 or #.Calli r" "'1" '~' '''' Illj'lnl. J" tor'I"1 _'I 1,,,,'Ph ,,""1'1'" 11 \,11/ ""1'1"\ N'~'.t, oil llr.'ll r't~I' ""'II'ijol. 'W1Itj ~,lltll~1 Ir~ ""11M h ", ~ nlHl'1f4 hilI', Ihl 'II" IIII.~ 'l"~t. """I I ~ 1111,:111'1' Y>1ll.1\i'IJ \' 'II 1"1.1,~'r.1f!';itit t'~~t~1 ~I.h' .', r:'t Atl"'l'" ""'.1 h'l 'W' ,,~I HI \)1 11~I'tIJ . '" I ^II'" ."I"'l I~ It j"l"I'IH. "11' l~tl)' "f"I'tMti I h"l 'Uhf lln,~\ ..11 t"'I"" \ \1 ,... ,1\ 1""11 "t. 1"1 '111111#!~ "\11"''(1'' 1 U'JT1'l.'T,I'I',tH',_ W 1"1)1\111 ,'ft-MIII II 4" '/1.11'11 It. n'l 'f "1'.,1 hi t"II"II.. .,,"'. ~II"""' 'f'," ~,I"I,." 'I<"it "\ 'lIlt"'I'1I" I"t'111~"I"". tI '"'''' 'oft ~II ",,"1111.,,1, 1!11I'~lUtt ., 1M 1fI1f,\...llfjh 'tll "'~"'"'I II, 1,1'11,'111 It t'I~ I"", 1111'11111,,'1, .'Iot"11 ""'I' " III~lIt . . IfllM ItIM rl~IM'Il',.q"'\If\.'1I""I' .'\ "M./t\t'llt '1'''''' ~n,~ ,..'. \II nl ';'''1''1 t~I"I"1 ~'l"h 1',11111:1 \,llh,\ lilllll tI "'11:1\ I't II'.~I tl I~l 'tllf~IIM tl wit 'ItW'lll~'t...,.. U'lH.'1t ,1.1t .N ~ ""./11'" 'Hll"I' tll>I<'lI"I'1f to< "I ",.It ""Itl "'II"'. "1',1 ~~''''\ I" hi. 111.11"1 ,'It I , ,1'~'.1 III ',11'11 ""'IN','I'l'" I 'l\tll,~'I.hh'I" ',A _\Ir''''tt'lh,~ 141'1' II"" \ltl' I IIN' ......ur..u,u HII"HII"l,u41'I Ih 'l~l" "'1,1"'''1,1 ,I ,~"I~"'hl'I""'-I' 'I "'I tI'"" "lIU, 1,,, "11".11<' II" 1/1"""1'" .lt~ 'i'lf' f,'U.'I" I fit 'lilt!, ,," ., 1'111 \HI.H\l ".'1 ,11."111.. "It 1M "'1'1'1\1 f;:ltlfll_ It ."li""I"".tt 111'11'" 1l.,1~4''', "'" ,I, ';Hd..\, ;,h 11.1,1 'Ilu~'I\I'1 '10' "I ,.,,,,, '1j',lt'!'" 1 -'. , " I I "I'", -'I'~I'~I" l! WI'I,I. ...It" ,tiN 11"'\'n'I.~ ",...;1111'11.11104 11'11 HI ,,' '11\1110111.." 'I, 1~11,,.,....,.".tf,, ,U,III ,!-I,,,",,I', t'l t ""1''''''''1 h'I'l 11,/, .'1 \I'\;..,~ "", I ~ '1/" .,,,..\ .,I,,,,.,tl ." -IH \tr.1 hili II., "I.U':jJlh ll.w ",Ii rt'\!1\.I,ll11fllHI" "'1111 ,It '''''-',111' ""'1"" 'I"," !"""l"'1 ""I,.rl'>tll,ulIH'l1. . oil "\ I .,1 IIt.I;'I'l '1IIIIIIfll," III t'/'1I"flill 1t11'1 "t., ",1'1''''1'1'''' .'1 ~""It<I") ""'1' h'l \ll~ ":"I.'HI1 u_ ";"flwlJ" h~II"II~. hIlt, '"\" ~ ~""".'l ,~ I .,1 "ll~lll" .",UII. hllhll~tll.IIII"'''' kl t\Ii II.",', l'Ilf;II" lit /1"11111'.-,,11(1'11".11 "'111" hl".hl'l'~ tlll.j '"M/"" WI\I II II~'I'IIII_~ .', ~4'H"'''' .,111" h t~'r'" liltfl111t.1 1"11111. I . 11,,1 "11I~1 "''111I01 ,',t.....I"',1" \1.," ~ "'" tI~,\t"!I~r l\.t,II tl~\tn' ",,\ ,..trll.flI~II~I,1 1'111" IjlU .'.'t<~"\1 Itl \1.11 r'l,! . . .. . .. 14/ "1'tll'II'lIhll'lt II"U~,I ~ll'" ~.,.hhr ",,,,,,,,M, "1l1ll" Ill', HHill td 1.\114 ";Ilfl('.,~ II . "','HI~ twl~';"'l 1'1'1.111 """", 10' I'~ "I\.i.1 "."~'I 11 ~llll A",~f",.,,1 .' < , \lthl' t,ul'll'I"I." "" "i~..,~' '-.'.1 HI"'_; , h"lh ~.M '.". hl"II, " It, l\\ln.~ Ill' Attltl '1It1'1 1iI,~ It.ltHtll il ~~.ti tltl\l~ ,',11' I,. l...r r ",111,.. ,1,,,.,,", ,,~I" \"'j't'h.,t,!i "~llIj ".fl~ If' ,..t~j"\"IHI 11'1"\f'\I'llll'tt"~I'III. "".fl'" _.....'M ,11114 I~r,",hH", \.I, \ntt11Il1"'~11 'tU'" ._ 1i,1 th,tH II" .1"11 IPllUltl1111 , nil I.Itl,'1 ' " " " ,-., ..,-.- ....':'..,. If\\t.,hll'''1~k\' Uttl., 1'1. lilt.t II' lltll1l~t~l\ltt fll\-lIel", ,,,,,I ~II" 11.'''1'' Iltl'llq~I_I., , 1lh h II\1tll. "111111-& \\1-'/1111 ,I II!'I \I".'lllm"jtlt'l\ II )t.I/1 tllMllt, ,. " I'H"tlltllt"ll 1'h!l OI'II!n),;ul ~llll't H"'u"J \'.1/11 '1'1'1 W ~-lUII t!.IIIUMil\lu,. 1ft III (.'MI ft.1 fI';,I""tl '" 11'1"." '''-'Iln'\IM,.1 ",I>' 4111",,,1 ill IHIt IlIHr.lI, it.,\ tllownlM "'I) tot ''It\~lnt.. 11i~", I IH\'IU h Ihl ,.~nl" UIII~II'tl' "'141"'\111\11.1, . hl'l! "llittllhrJm tHIt..III' 11,\1 ".tI1Ut11hlllli!rtl~ 1'" dIIllNI'lll.n"tl">> (>111t.t It'UIlII~,I.tllvl "r,1I '1"lh If.~IIIII huJlnr ,III 111111 1I11111111lt ~::';~;~~~," lllLH MII.t,o/c.)l " ",.. , ~y -r "'~, .~lL1'w_. .' lHLlk ~~ II,,~ _12Il:i/.ri1f..-_- 11_ hH,II,'__ "...-0,...... 1I1,'ilil III" 'i, , " . I' " 'r, :[I!IIJIU~;t\ lr,m.HmWICli " I "Nil NOW, ll1iti :1,,1 dil\'II( ~"IIIII, I OUIl, I 111111111\' 1'1111(\'111111' I 11111'11 rnlltilJd 1111110 11l1d rpl'I'ort' , rOPlio( 11111 (1111111011111 dill 1111111111 ill 11" pllwIld III Iho I J,S, Illi1l1, (1151 dllSti, pon(ilHCl plopnld illlll " " ; , , ,lIJldil,tiHod llli (\lIIIIII'IiI' \, . i! 1~\lhl'lli 111I\'IIIIIi, I:HIIIIIIIl II,l J, 1111\ rllll I' \,'illlll' lilli, 1'/\ I?ll II I' /:zg~(l I H(fIVIAS 0, WI .I.IAMS, I:SQUil~': " .,1' .' i! '!L , " " I, " 'II ;, j\;- i! " I' 'I" " ;.,J, " I' I, " " " 1,1, II ., " , .. , I!', " .,; ,I. " I, " lIIq,I'.\J,Sl\I,l, IIMI, 1':s'IWn: l'I\lll1l~SS'UN^,.S, ' l'lnhlllff " I' , I I ,I I ,I I I I I I /-. '. v, IN TlII\ r.Il\Jln' Ufo' r.UMMIlN I'I.MIl ' , C\JMm\llI,i\NIl (CUUNTY, "";NNHYINi\Nli\' " II()III~I\'I' IIi\YNliS nllll 1\1I"'lII,l\I~N "i\ YNI\S, ll~f~l\lhlnIH Nil, u~.~J~ CIVil, IIr.TIUN,',I,i\ W ..'I I' t\Nsw~n WITH NICW Mt\'I"I'lm ANI> CO~N'I'ICI~CI"AIM , I, Nol\llOl' nlhnltto\1 nor d~l1locl shwo Pol\ll1dnl1t~ IHlVO no porsonnl " ,1 j Inf\lfI11ntll1Jl OI'Kllowlodgo oonool'l1lllll thololl'nl SllI\ns orlho I'lnlntlffo(hol' tl1l1n Pltllnllffs ,- ,. ; -" ,,1'9prosontntlons, I, .' H, 2, Ponlod nS sllItod, Dorondllnta OUlTontl)' rosldo nt.12\ S, F.llll'l1old I, PrlVll, POllOI', Dolllwnro IlJ90 I" 30' Ponlod liS stUto\l, B)' II wrlttOllllllroonWnl ellItod Mnroh 28,1998 t. ',' ", ("AllrQol11ont"), PlnlnllfT IIlld DI)fondnllls sot Ihrlh tho torllls nl111 oOl1dltlollH whorob)' P1l1lntlft'\\/nH to not n~tho oXllllISlvu Hollll1g IIgolll fbi' tho D01'l1l1dunts' thou rosldolloo lpontod lit 518 GlIlo ROllel, CIlIllP HIli, POl1nsyll'llnln ("PI'OpOl'ly"), Ono tol'lIl of tho 1I1l1'0911l01ltwns tho I)olondllnts' PU)'lIlot\1 pI' II 40/., ~;Jll1ll1lsslpii to tho Plnlntlt't' lit oloslng II' , th,o PllIllltlt't' pl'llolll'clll.l hUrCl' of'tho !'I'operl)' without tito IlSSIHtlllloO ot' nnothol' 1'0111 osllllo '" I. ' " . .' _." bl'llkor, Tho ^1l1'oonlOnt WIIS IInWlllled In IlIto ,hmo to l'oduco Iho 0011111\1ssl\11\ to ~% IInd 10 .' ,. >I., \1 I,; 'I' " ".. hWl'pnsp tl\\l pl'l~p 111 $\ Ol!,ooq wlwn Ihu j)~'~nlhH1IH nlJl'u~11 III IIHt tl;~ 1'l'IlI1PI'IY Ihl'l1l1llh Ilwll1l1lllrllst innl'kllllll!! 1101'1pll, liS mlvlipnl~d hy 1'lnll1lll'f, /, 4, j)~I1I~11 ns ,slntPlli IlIH mhnll\u(llhnl,.lho ^gl'~~1l10111 II'\lH !ill' Hlx l1H1I1Il\lll1l'1l11t11 R~PIPll1hIl1'3(), I OOR,IIIII R~II\I1U PI'I~p Ill' $1 RO,O()O,Hy II'ny Ill' l\ll'IhllI' . "" \( ,I' " nI1RII'Il!', 111\1 ^llr~~111U111 WnH 1111\011lIullll1lnt~H~plllll1h~I' III provlllo,lol' 1111 IlI\IUl1sll1l1'i1flhll IIS11I1ll plll'lmllln(1I Oulohol' 31, 1')09,nlllllll !'lldllllllll\olllllll1l's leu prllluullnl1 purlml nnol' ..Ihp AllrUIlI1\IlI1IIi'1l111 slillY dnys III thlr\tllll)'s,. I' ~, 1)unloll nRRtlltud.\ 1\ Is mhl1lHucl (hlll,Plnll1ll1THhl1wllll ,Jurn'u)' '.1- I'"hhlll'll (u\1\I)'\lI'") ,Ihu I'rl1pllrl)' ~11 NI1V\ll11hOI' :12, I 09R, 1\ Is Ilolllull,lhnll'hlll1tlff " Il1tl'l1lhloUlllhu Ullyor III tllIll'I'l1pOI'W PI' thllDIlful11luI11s, 1\ ,l,~ mlll1lll\llllhol Ull)'1l1' " I ,',pln'\lhoSlllllhl,l Prl1pol'l)'fi'PIl1 Dof\JI\(I~H\ts 011 Mnrohl, 1099, ". j . 6, DOl1lullos,slnlul\' Plnll1llrfllunHucl nil n1l\l'klltll1linotlvlllu~ 011' " b\lll1b~I'3l.199R,'nt Iho Ill1d 11f'lho IIgl'Olll1lOl1t, Dul\JI1(llIl1tH, \lpl1l1lnl'o1'l110110n 1111<1 hollof~" . "j;. " , " nl'u 1111'111'0 tI\J\\ Ihulhl)'\ll' II'lls 11110I'u~(u(lln Iho Pl'I1pol'l)' IlnOI' Obslll'vlnii tl1IllJol\Jlllllll1ts,' , , , . j' ,> 11\l'l1ll1l1l'kotl1W nl1d ndvortlsOl1l1H1ts mid l10t thoso of'tho,plnlntlff', . " 7, Alll11ltlod, It.,. " 8, Donlcd ns stn(ucl, Dol\Jndnnl~ IUd notl1\lthol'lj(c Plnlntl ('I' 10 not on tlluh' bohnlf fl1l1owln!! tho uxplrnllon ol'tllo nlll'ool1l1llH \111 Octohol' ~ t, 199R, f)ofol1dnnts " bolll,lvod tlllll Plnll1t1f'f's ngolH, Edwll1 0\\'011, \Vns noting Oil hohnlfl1f'tho 1311)'01': 9, Dof'ol1c1nnls hnl'o no pOl'sol1l11 kl1owlo\lgool' 111('01'1111111011 111111~91'l1lng ,II I , Plnll1t1f'f's llontnol with Il\lVOI', It Is IIlhl1lttod thllt Pllllntlfl'H ngont Qwon showod tho , 'I, " PI'OPOI'()' to tho B\lyql' on NO\'OI\1!101' 29, 1998', 10, !Jol1lod liS stlltod. Pllllnllf'l'H IIgcnt O\\'on contlllllodMI's,ltn),lios, 2 " I ~ .,J " " " II, I\llmlllv\l, I~" l)vl1lvlll1~ Hllllvll, 1\ 1~,lI\hlllllVII Ihlll 111llhHII'I'H lII~vl11 OWVI1I1WI ,,<; 'Ii " . wllh pul~Il\IIIIIIH \111 \11' 1111\1111 Pvvvnilwl' II, IOOH In pl'vHvnlllw wl'\llVI1 \11'1~1' 11'11111 thv nll~VI', lIwhl,llull111 Ihv 111'1~1' IVIIHtlw IMvmhll\lH1 1I!il'uVI1Wnl In PIlY II vnllil11lHHlnl1 \\1llw PllIll1\1l'r, Thv \11'1~1' WIIH l'u.lu~tOI\ hy Ihl' 1)ul~ll\hlll\H 111111 Pul~mll\11IH hllllvIIIU,(11\1 thv , Pllllmll'l'H lI~vl11 Ihlll Ilw Alllwnwnl hll\l uxpll'u\llIl1\llhlll \)ufvmllll1lH IH"lnn I1hlliilllll1nlb ,. PII~ Iho Alllwnwlll'H UPI11111IHHII1I1, Ily WilY llf l\lI'lhul' I\11H\WI', Pul~mllllll~ IlIfol'l1wcI I' " t." ,,. PIIIIIIIII'I" IIllull( ()\vvl1l1H11 Irhu WI1I1(v\11I 0l11111111HHlnn Ihlll,lh(.l HI\I\llnll~lllu III il pl'loo .' I I, \Vlwl'\lh~ Dol~l1\ll\nl~ wnHlclI'U\l\llw $1 HO, 000 I\I\Ul' 1111 HIII\l \1'11l1Hnutlol1 oxpUnaUH Wol'o "" " J. , plIlll, purol1e1l1nlH IInll Plllllltllr uxuol1\ulI nil IIlll'oOI11\lI1\ \111 1)~COI11IWI' 4,19911wh\ll'\lh~ l)olonllmllH 1Il!l'cullto PRY 1%,111111'1' II uOI11I11I.H~h1l1If Ih~ \'nlpol'\~ WII~ ~plcllo Iho Il\1Yol' fn!', II pl'loo or $,lll7,OOO, Plnll1l.In'~ nllol,~1 I\lall dl~ploaoll lolho D~lbI11Inl1l~ tllill ho hllll 011101'011111111 n OPI111'l1cl Ivhol'\lb~ ho WOllld 1'00011'0 Oll1l1POI1~I\llol1 lI'Ol11lhobllyol', 13, DunlulIlIH ~llIlo\l, I'llIh\lln'H lI110nt Cl\vonlnfnnnocl Dcfondlll1la thlll " "ili . .. ''" I;, " , 1311)'01' 1ll1l1l1Wlo 1I1l01'll1 0\l\111Iol'Of'lol' In)l\o nll1111llllol' $lll~I,ODO, whlol1'lJol'ol1llnl1la , , '" 1'0100to1l hllUlIlla\l PllIll1llfl'wlla I\11Wllllllll III 1'01h100 tho HlIloH oOl11l11la~lpntp IIl\ow " '. . ... ,. , " . Dolol1dlllll~ 10 l'ullolY\l $1 HO, DOO n"ol' 11\1 tl'nl1~lIollol1 ooala, 14, DOl1lollllH Htlltud, \lol\owhmtho oliPlrntlllll oCtho Alll'\l0111011\ Iho ,- H i " \l ". " Dof\lndnn(fj hnd Il1ndo HpoolfIunlll'oOI1WntR with 1'1I1'IOIIH 1'0111 oalnto nllOl1la Ihl' tho PIIYIl1~nt Ofll0Il1111lsslon I('thu IIgonts PI'OOlll'od n huyol', 1J01i)!1dllllt~llld nolllutllorlzo PlnhUIlT(o " " ,.. . ,11 ". I- " ' I' nOI,l'1l buhnlfol'DololllhllllH nllol' tho UXpll'lIllo11 o('tho Alll'oomont, oliool11 h~ tho apoolqu 01111h'1I01 oOlldltlollod upon Il llYo I' 'l1l\yll1lllJoli)n(hlllt~ $11l7,DDO fiji, Iho I'I'(1pOI't~, . .' " I, , 3 ," '" " " '" m:t.I',!l,~lq.l. 1\I~lIlf i;:~'I'!\'n: 1'llllJ1I':HHIPNIIl,li, ' ' 1'111 III lIff " " I I I I I .' I I , . I , .' IN '1'1\1': (~(ljJI\'l' IW f:IIMMIlN "'!I':I\~, rJ!l 11'1111':1\1.1\ Nn qIllN'l'Y,I't:NNliYINI\NII\ y, Nil, UU.HJft' 'i ,. Hnlll~HT 111\ YNI~!i 111111 1~I\'l'''',lq':N 111\ YNI':!i, ll~fpllllllntH f.IVII, /W'I'IIlN,..I.",V VIClUlIIC!\TION .. ,I, Rullor! j1, 111l>'IWn,PoloI11lilll\ 111 'tho nhuw'roforono~ll proooo,lhl~1 nlil\O 1111\11110 ''', IIWI'I1Wllln III tho 11.1l'01Whlg lluo\ll11ollllll'O tl'\lO nlld oUI'I'OOllutI1O,hoHtuI' 1l1~ 1111'\lrl11nlh111t . bol\ol' 1Il1\1 kl1uwl~dgo, '\ll1l1ornllll1ll thnt ,n\IIIO~lnlol1lOnIH 11Oroll11l1'0 11111I10 ullb.looltu Iho pOllllllloH ul' I H Pn, c,s, * 4904, rolntlng l~ IInHWUl'I1lilIHll1ol\llul1 \l1l11l1hurlll,1H. ~r/ ,/~~I. C" , VR()~(.rf r/ / 10\(';,.....::> , ~(lbol'\ p, h~ . Dllloll: J\I\1o 29, 1999 / .," " 'I' " " " " " " II" ",i , "" " " I' , I 'i, I, " 13 ," I, " 1< II I' ">- \1", j"c, \ll(', l_~ i'" I', ,I, ,"1 . (ji( .1'1 \',., 1,'1'.. 'l',i',:!, .\..'1 I' 1\. tJ 'i ;j. I' (0' ~,j,l J.~.. ,., "-I '>" " , , Ii " " 'I. II, d I " J.-; (1' pi " I.'l \'1 ,< 1\' " " " ," " I" " I' " " " ',.. ,', h'; r ,). r: /'t', ( :: ~.' ~'l ,l"{ ,1/. rr ,.- i}I(!\ ',,!I." I ~ U I,; I; " " lit' " "ii' ,do! Ii " "Ii " I,'; j," 'I", " " H. " 'j I', ,I' d " ,,-, , 'I" " " " 'i'. I," ii' " ,,"" "t, " " " " ,." '.; j, "'1' Ii, " Iii " " "I, " ,i, Il !' I' " " " .I,: , \i I' " " " " " " " d, ;11 ,I,; " " ,I' " !if :\' " ," " iI' '" I' " hwr~lIa~ tlw pl'l~~ In $194,9()() wlwn Ow p~r\l'l\lnnla nlllWlllp IIftl thu Prnpprly Ihr\lll~h tllIlIl1I1IlHlall11nrkplln~.119VI\l9, ns ll\\vl1pnlp~1 hy I'lnlll\ln~ . ii, (j~nlpll na aln1911, 'It 1ft nQIllIt\U11 IhUI Iho AllI'~\lIllUnlwlla lhr alII 1110nlha 111' \111111 Sopt9111bur 30,:\998, 11y \V\\Y of l\lrtlwr IIl1ij\Vor,lhu ^Wo911\0"II1~nln \vna nnwnllp,llln Inl9 S9pl~l11bpr 10 Pl'ovl\l~ for nn ~xlonsl\l11 pfOlllllatll111 p~l'lolI\ll1111 I;, ,. .. . . , . ,; ", i", Optohor 31,,1999, nml to I'PIIIIPu Ih\lIlIlPIl\'ftrO~pI'PIPolil1n porloll nl\l/l' 1119 ^IlI'P9I11Qnl ' /fpm alXIY dllYft 10 Ihlt'\)' llliya, " I $,' 013n1911 na allllod, 1\ Is nlhnltlulllhnl I'lnlntlffal.\OW911 Mtr9Y' il' I. Hllbhllrll ("8I1yor") Ih\l Pr\lp91'\)' pn Novumb9r;!2, 199R, Ills Ilul1lolllhlll Plnll1l1ff InlroQ\1901111i1l U\l)'orll1lhu Pl'oporlY or tho D~f\ln\lntlls" It la Illhnlu\lillhlllllllYor I, ' , " pllr~hllsolllhll PI'O~dl'IY 1'1'0111 Dofcnll11l11s on MlIl'ch I, 1999, 6, OunloQ (Isslnlol\, PllIll1llff eenaoel 1111 I1lllrkolln!! (\~tlvIt.19s 011 OeloPol' 31, 1998, lit Iho ond of Ihu mJro0l110111, OOfundllllls, \IPOl1ll1fornwtlOl1l1l1dbollof, If I, " 1I1'0llWIII'0 111l111ho 13\1)'01' WIIS 1I110rostod II11h9 PI'opOI'I>' 111\01' pbaurl'll1!! Iho Dofol1Ql\l1ls' " ,. " OWI1I11I11'kotln!! 1111111lQVOl'tlsoll1onla nl1d liol Ihoao of tho Plllll1l1ff, " 7, Adl11ltlod, 8, 1)0111\1d PS slnloll, Dof'ol1dlll1ls did not nlllhorlzo I'lnll1llfflOllol all ;, " , " Iholr bohnlf f'ollowhl11lhu oxplmllol1 of' Iho lI11rOo1110111 Oil OUlubol' 31, 1998, j)Ofol1Qllllls , bolll/yoel Ihnl PllllnllfPs ngolii, Bdwln 011'011, WnH nulln!! 011 behnlfoftho Bllyor, ' \1'" 9, " Dofondnl1ta hnl'o no pOl'sonll1 knoWledge 01' Inf'ol'nll1tlonoonoornln!! " 'I. ' ',t , Plnlnllfracolllnot wlth"Buyol', It Is ndl11l11od t1H1ll'lnlnllfl's ngonl Owon showodtho PI'Opol'!y to tho I3uyol' on Novol11bul' 29;1998, , 10, Dunlod nH atntod, I'lnlnllfl's ligon! Owoli'oon!no!ud MI'R, llnynoB, i/ 2 " t, ,. " " II, MmIH\l\I, I~! D\lnl\l\1 1\& stlll\lll, 1\ Is mhnl\l\l\llhlll Pllllnllfl'~ 1I~\l11l OIV\lI1I1;~t with P\ltiJl1llnl1la Iln 01' 11110\11 P\l\l\l111h\l1' 4, 199" tll PI'\lN~'1I Iho wrltl\!11 nftiJr trnl11l1w Pn~'OI',. hwhlll\l\lln tho nftiJl' WlIs tho D~tiJmhl\lla 'lI~r\lOl1lOIH III pnr lJ \llll11mlaslnn,11l th\! ,Plnlntlff, Tho \lnbl' wn& 1'0J\l01011 hr llw Pofomlnl1la IIml Pof\lnd(1nls Im\l\lIlI\l\1 tll Ihll .. .' 1.' Jllnhlllfra n~1I111 Ihnl,lI\\l AHI'\l\lI11\l111 h!ld \lxph'\lll mill 1111I\ P\lt~mlllnla hnll nO oiJIIUllllll11 tll pnr IIIIl AurOlll11lll1t'a \lOI1\1nlasllll1, 13r WII~ Ill' I\Il'thol' III1RwOr~ Pofllmlnnta Il1thrnwd .. J1ll1hlllf\"nBlln't OW\l11 thllt It' IIIl mmtollll O\lmmlaslon thnl tho slllll mu&\ \III nfll prl\lo " , ~ ' I' ,", ,- , " wlwr\lIJr pof\lllll(1nta woulll I'ollolvo $180, 000 oflllr nil solo lrol1&IWtlol1\ll(p\lnsOs were polll, Dlllbndlll,lla oml Phllntlff OXO\l\IIOd on II1lrool110l1t on Deo\lmbor 4, 1998 whol'lIbr , Deful1dll\1ls nUNml to por Plohlllfl'n \lol1)inlsslo,n Il'thul,~I'IJpOrl)' woa'sn'~ to tho U\l~or for I. ;, n prloo Ill' $187,000, . Jlloll1lltrs IIgonl olso \lIsoloaoll to tho Dofol1\llIl1tslhntihll'hml ,- - . -.\ enlOrlllllnto 0 oOl1lrool wlwrebr hu WO\lld 1'00011'0 OOl1lpol1Hotlon frciin the l3uyor, I~, /)01116d ns Btntod, Plnll1llff'~'l\IlOl1l Owonll1lbl'l11oel Dofondnnl$ll1i1t ' III I3l1rol' hncll1il\ele IIn oml 001111tO\'(~ffor Inlhll nl,1101ll1t of $184,000, whluh l)otbndlllHs ,. II 1'0J\lotud bOOl\llSO rlnli1tlfl'wns unwlllhlll to I'odu\lo thq snlus commlssloll to nllo\l' Pol'ondonta 10 I'oo\llvo $ t 80, 000 nOor nil trnnsootlol1oosts, . ' 14, Ponlod ns stntod. \1ollowlng tho ~l(pll'nllon oflho Alll'00l11ol11 tho II ,. .. Dofendnl1ts hnd l11ndo spool flo ngrool110111S wlthvnl'lollS 1'0111 osllllo 1I1l0l1ts 1'01' tho pnytnont ,- 1'" ~ ,. ol'oon\lnlsslol1lftho n~oIHsprooln'od II bU)'OI', Dufonelllnts dld,l1olllllthorlzo Plnlntln'lo ". ,,' . not 011 bohnlf of' Do(ol1dlll1ts nt\ol'lhooxplrlltlol1of tho Alll'OOnwllt, oxoopl by lho spo\lltlo, oonlrllc;t oOl1dltlonod Upol1 13I1YOI' pll)'ln!! Dofol1dllllls $1.87,000 (hI' tho Proport)'. ,I" J '. f' ,.1' IIPpupl II IpIV\lI' UIlI11I11laal\lnln onlpl' 10 Pllllalll1l1lllll\l Uw anlplp UIIYul' nl 1\11 111110\1111 ~lIllanWlol'Y In IhuPplilnllmlls, " " 22 " " Pun lUll ns allllull, Thu 11\IYI'I' WIla 1101 Inll'ollllUPllln Ihp Prppul'ly ,. " ,. I' IIl1rhllJ Ihp.lul'm oflhu ABI'PulllOnl oml Plnlntlft'ls 1101 pnll\lu(llo ony I,pu prolPollon few ony optlvlly fullPlvll1B \lw oxplnlllon of Ihp ^lJrpPl1wlll uxoupllor pmapoollvll!>IIYors i ' , , " " Il1lrodlloflll toilwProporlY 11Y Ihol'lolntlfl\lmll1g IIIIl AgroPI1Wnl, N~BPIlIiIl\lns IJUIWllul1 ' lJllyor mnl Pllfomhl\llaol1l11nWIWIlII Pooonlbul' 4, 19?R Ivhul1 Phllmlffs nB~nl OWoI' ' ." '. , " pl'1l8Unlplllln offill' llI1l)ohlllf of Ilw ))IIYol', , " " " 23, Ponlllll, 1)ofullllol1tH'UIIII1OI Illlllao Pllllnllff Ip rilly ol1lhO,l1' o\1nd\\ol \lmlol' Ihu ctoolrhw ofoq\llln!>h: 08101'pol, l'lnhillrfwlI8 nWllrlllhRllhll AurllPnwnl " '" . . ,. " . ; Imd oxplrlllll1nc.lllmll1l1Y pri1HpllollvIl PII)'or wOIIll1 hIlYlllo,pn)' II prloll tll ~oIIHt}' , Pofllndol1l~' pl'loo, whloh WI1S bnsud on Ihll 11I11011111 10 bll rlloolvuclnrtor 111\ trnnHl1ollon ' ,,' . ,,"' " oosls, Plnlullrfkull\V 1,11111 tho 9111(,1s oOl11l11lssl0l\wOS nn hnporlllul porI oflho uOBollnllol\s '" ",' ~O\ween the Plnlullffnllll (he Pefllndnnts d\\rlng tho Agrool\lun(, Pol'9ullnnlshll1mnQd " Pllllullff III Iholr I11llulhl11 ou DO(lel11bur 4, 1998 thnt nool111111881011 \Volll,Q bo pnld liS 0" . e~\ldltl.onibr tho oontrnol \vllh BII)'el' In the l\I,110\1I11 of$187,OOO, 'Plnhlllfffollpc.llo ... ' .' slItlsty this oondltlon, 111111nllfr Iherc~nel'ottol11Pted todlrool Buyor to dlfforont hOl1S09, '24, e'enlcd lIS ~llllodi It Is neltnltted (hilt the ProPerty WlI9 90\1\10 the II I"' "., " I' 'I B\lyel' whhout Oefel\dnllts nUlhorlzll11l Ilny IlSS19tnnCQ li'ol11lho Plnlntlff, I' , " 11 COUNT ((.IN TIm ^LTERNATIVE.lINJU~T ENR(CI.1MENT I' 2$, Defcllllnllls lncorpol'llto hQrlll11 bYJolbrul1oe pllI'ngrllpl)s olle , throUllh Iwollly-foul'ribove liS If aot 101'Ih 1\111)', ... ,'" .C' H, , " f 'I' s .'1/' , " " /'1 2(1, 'P~I1I~fllla&IIM\I, JM~I1flnI1IH 1IIIII1olll\lll1Prl~~ Plnll1l1ff\11 npUolh1l\l Pl1l1wll' \1~hlllf 1I1'pl' Ihp '^~r~pnwl1l ~xpll'oll. P\ll~l1lll1I1IH hllv\I no ppl'~PI1I1I . knpwl~II~~'\lI' 1111(1/'I\ll1\1110 on IIw Pllllntlft'H lI!;lro\lI1\Pl1If~1' ~~I11PPI1Sllllon wllh Ihp U\lyprl'" pofPIlIl1111I& WOI'P wltlll1~ Ip WI{ Plllll1l1ff Ipl' lho snip 10 Ilw J1I1YP1' nlll pnrghnSIl prlpllln tlllll1l11pnlllof $187,000, IIRl\\lIhorlzPIIIIY pxprcS& wrhlol1l111I'\I\lI11PllIlllIl~\\ PpPPI)1hol' 4; 1998, 1111111111ff fllll~lllo pllrs\lllllullnyor IllplIy$187,OOO, Pllfumlnl1ls 'Wi'u willing to , ' pll)' J1ll1ll1llff fill' II\\' snip PI' Ihll J1ropol'\Y Ip U\I)'llr; hOWllvPI', Ihp pll)'I1Wnl WOIIIII \11l1111s1l4 PI1I1I1I1I11P\1I11 Ihm would r~allllll1 Pllfpl1dnl1lH I'ooolvlnll $180,000 nf\llr 1I111rnnslIotlon " " ll11sls, PllIlmlff fP.lolllOcl IlIla llol11pol1slIl111I1, 'n D0l111lllns alel\Oll,' lJIlI\lndllnla pl1torlllll"IO 1I11 ~~pross AllrOo11111l11 , ,- " , ;-', ", i . \ Ihlll ol1e1od 0010 bPI' 31, I ?9S, Thllrollf\ol' Pol'ondllnls did 1101 1I111horlzo Plnllll\lT to np\lIs ,,' " ;, ,- 'L , 'f' Iholr 1I110n!, Dpfondllnts bullpvod 111111 PllIll\llffwlIs roprosonllng Ih\l anyor \111111 1\0gollnllpIIs OOl11l11onood OVOI' pofondnnls' pn)'lI1onl ofn 00I1I111lsslon 10 Iho Plnlnllff, 28, D0l1lo11 ns stlllod, I\a 1\101'01\111)' sol fbhh bclow.Plnhlllffwns Ihe ", . '" ,PlIllso fbr dolny IInd Plnln\.lfrs Involvcmcnl III tho 11Illlotllltlons bctwcon Plnll111ffnl1l1 Pcfbndnnts wns bnsl1d 01\ fmnd omll11lsreproNcl1ll\tI.on, , 'n .. 29, DOlllcd liS stnllld, Plnll1t!frs IlIvoll'ol11onl ot\uNcd doloy OS,II 1'081111 . of fl'll\ld olld I11lsrcpl'csll'ntnllol1 by Ihc Ploll1(lff, PlllllltltnOlll\ll1o, tho problcl11ll1.tho , I' , lIellotlotlons botwoon 11 1111)'01' who did 1\01 ,wolIl,lo IISU tho Plnlllllff IIS,IIIIl\!!CI1I nil\! Iho Dlll'onelollts who olso did nol WIIIII to \lSO Iho Plnll1llff'nsoll Ollont, ~' , . .j1 " COUNT III.IN Till! A',T'II{N^TIVIH~IWAC\1 OF IMPl,1I3P CPNTIWJT " , ,30, I)ulim~lnlll~ In9PI'Pprlllo hy roforpiwo h9rolll pnriilll'nphu 01\0 . , Ihl'PIIBh IWllllly,n,hw nbovp na !I'upl' 1I1rlh I\llly, 31, Ponlp~llIa alntp~I,'Afllll' ()plpl1ur 31, I !JOR nnll tlw tOI'l11lnn\loll Uf lIip ABrIlIlI11Pllt. Pofpl1Ilnl1ls lllclnol hnvll IIny kn~lwlpllllol1f IIny nllllplIK lnkl,ln on Pohlllf pI' ' Ihlll11 Py \llnln\lff, Plltbmlnnla did 1I011llloopl or rol\(}' Pllllntlfrs IIll\lolls, Plnlllllfrs i" , lIollpns lilloI' Ootobllr 31, 199R \VllrO uPllslstpnl wllh \llnlnllff I'pprosontlnB lho llllyor, . AI no Ihl11' did Jltlllntlff sook 10 Plllpr Inlo II now nl!rponlOnl, oX90pl fill' Ihooolldlllollnl l1!!rllol1111nt thlll Wlla bnaolt on lhllIlllyor p\1l'chllslnB Iho Propprly for$IH7,OOO nncl Iho " , I'.. "" o~ndlllpn prQoo~lonll\ld npl 01'0111',' " " . , , 32, Dllnlol\ liS Slnlod, I)ofomlnnls nlhlill thnl Pllllnt'ifrs lIollol1s wuro '" " . 11101l\'lItod for soll1sInOll80118 1111l\ by Brollll, Uppn hlforlnntlonlll1l\ bolioI', Plllonl\nnls IIVO\, 111111 PIIIII1I\(Trllllcll ~n fmlld IIndnilsrcpr080nlnllonln tho l\clllhiIlS)vllh Buyer nllll Potbnl\nnl8 by 1101~II~elosln!! 10 Bllyor Ihnl Phllnllffwns not Iho 11\Hhorl7.cl\ IIBont to soli Iho Proporly nnd I\y 1I011\lsoloslnB 10 Pefcndllnt~ 1111\1 ho WIIS 110111\0 UIIYOI"S IIllcnl, . . ""f , , ,,33, Denlod ns stllteel, PllIlnl\('fWllsl!io Ollllso ol'dolny In tho slIlo of " , " Iho Propor\Y liS II I'osllll of tho Pllllnllfrs frnlldlllonl nnd dooopllvo OOndllollndlllllhlll wllh lho Olwol' nncl bol'onlhll1ls, . 34, Donlod ns slCllod, Tho dxpll'llllon of Ihll ^Ilroonlonl cndoel , , ' " DefllndClllls oOl1ll'nolllnl rolnllonshlp with 1'llill1tlrr, Tho O'\lyor WClS not II prospoot\vo ,. d !" " hllyor lIurlllB IhoAlll'oomonllll1d Plnlntlffs 1I0\l011S lIud'Rorvloos woro not disoloscd to Dofendnl1ls, ()olblldnnls hill! no kl1owlodllo lit tho limo thnll'lnll1lll't'wns mlsl'opl'osonlhl!! ,I; 'I. 7 'I' ,,!I " " , " \\1lh~ llnr\lf tlmllllllll1llrr wna Ih~ 1\\Ilhurl?~'IIlIl~nl 10 a~1I \lwllr\1purw, IMumlnnlN \1111 nl11 nQ~\lpl PI' rmlly nnr or llllllnllt'l'N uomh\QI, The pnYllwl11 01' II ulJnlll1lslllpl1 wnN uul1lrnl , , . 10 IIW"QullPtlnllona \lPlwupn Ihu Plnlnlll'fnllll purUndlllllal hili PllIlnllrrrul\laol\ 1111\PPupl Pul\ln~llInls' poal\lpn, ph,hHlrf, ,liNn ruallllPI' frnml nml,!l1larupruaQnlnllpn, wns IIW pI'I111lpIn In Ihu anlp.of Ihp Propurlr, 3~, . POnlPIllIa allli~llln pnl'l\BflIPh~4 nboY\!, 36, I ' , ponlpl\ na alntud, Puf\lnd(lnla 111,1 nPI IndlluP or pnOOllrnBP l'lnlnllff 10 ponlhlllo Ita prforta 10 aplllho PrppurW lIf1pr Iho ABrpompnllPrn\.lnnlllll, 'Plnh11lffknuw IlsofO\llolJ(li' 3l,1998lhnif)pfllndnnls hn,lrOIllOV\lI\ fllnlnllfra rllrd slBn nnd I'Qph\ll~d 1\ with II "1101' SlIloHy OWnlll''' rnl'cl alBll, Plnll1llfr know Ihlll Ppfondnl1\a wol'unOI anllallod wllh PllllnllrfNnpllpna ullrhlBlhu \pOll ofthpABrucmonl "nd Il\ll ," Plnhll1ffsllllsroptoaontnllon of pufondnnW position In proapootlvu bllyoI's, Plnlntlfr , " " , ' !, I'llqlloN,t,pd Pofol1llni\la to ahow tho Proporty 10 11llrol', pm fnlled,lodlaploau 1~IDofpndnnla 'j " Ihnlllllyof hlid sollsht to oonlllot tho,Pofonllnnls dlroolly, 37. Pooled, The PIlYI11P1l1 of Illlolllllllaalon WIIS Iho 8\1\lJoel of 11QB\1tlllllons blltWQen Pllllnl!tT IInd Po!ondnnls Ihnl IIhlnot result InnllY QBfPelllel1tnftlll' Oelobel' 31, 1998, 38, " After Qolober 31, 1998, f)o!onclnnta did 1101 hll\'C III1Y ~Brep1\1ol1l, eltlw oxprosa or Implied 111 fuet, with Pllllntlffto PIlY II c01\1mlsslon !l1l' Uuyef'a pnrohllao . oftllo Property, except t)'lflho Buyor hndncoepteel tho I)elolldllllla' ePlll\le\'offbr nt: " $187,000, or 2) PIII/lltlff hlld IIcoepled t)ololldllllls' oflor ofll I'edllced OCil1l111laslon ~lIn sllle III $185,000 hI Of del' tll provide Dofondllllls SlllO,OOOIIl proeoeds 1I0el' Iha slllo's trnl1Snctloll costs, I' I. H " " " ., " " ,/Ii" " " !\Ii, Upon Int\mnllllnll !\I'll h~lIpl', Ppl'yIHIl\nl~ l\WI' 111111' IlnYllr " 1I\\\1l11pIPII In Illlo~hlln(J pplpmllln\~ by olllllng 1I11llulpphPlw fl\11l111pl' onlhu ppt\Jmlllnla' Yllnl ~hll1, I, I, ' 47, lJpnll''hlt\lI'lllOlllIil lwl bullllf, 1)6t\Jmlllnta, IIWI' Ihill UllyPI" PI' . I3nyor'a ll!lonl Wlla IInl\\111l tn oPl1lllllt tlw:pot\Jl1\hll1t~\b\\1 hlijlol\cl \Iw ,nllYllr I'HIlIlI VIl\111 . 1IllllphpIW 1'01l0l'lHn!l Ihot IIWI1\II11\lul' wnaolll Ill' ~Il.rvloll, ' , '.. 4", Upon Infonl1l1t1onl1llll bollllf, DIlI\ln11l1l1ta l1wr thllll3l1Yor' pl'Ilvlo\l91y hlll\ oballl'voll Pl111nllft'a YlIl'cl al!ln whlin Pllllntlfl' hmll1l1atll1!l 1I!ll'o01110111 with " I , Dol'llnllllnla, !lllyer elll1ll11111l1\ J1ll1lntlff IInl\ r"'111u9101\ III1l pefel1l\lll1ts\ Illlophlll1ll 11l1l11b\lI' , H ., 111 PI'I\QI' to 001111101 \)QI0I11h1l1Ia, " 4", Upol1lnforl11l1t1oh l1nl\ bellQI;PQlol1dllnla llvur 01111 Pl11111llff l!\laoly rllpr09ol111llllo !lllyor lhlll only J111l1nllffoollll\ show Iho \ll'oporlY 10 thQ !lllror 11111\ 1'01\19011 10 provide Bllyor with thll 00ful1ll\ll1t9' telophol1ll I1l1mbor tis rUl\nostod, 4,9, Uponlnlbrf11l1l1pl1\1l1d bl.lllol; l)otondlll1ls IIvor Ihllt Plnlnl1fra f\llal.l " I' ., l'oprllsel1\l1l10119 WI.II'Q Il1lbndlld to 1\0oolvQ.BllYOI' \ll1d UIIYIlI' w\l9J1I911110d 111 hlarcl1l111111l IhQI'I.I11pOn to bolleve 1I100rrl.lolly Ihilt Plnlnll"/, atlll wnstho 119Ih\!l n!lollt /'01' De/'elldllnI9, , , SO, Uponl111bnnntlol1l11111 boll\lf,Dofol1lll1l1tsllver thllt rl\lll1t1frs /'\llso " ' " , repl'osl.lntlltlol1l1lHO Wll9 11 fl11so'ropru9ollllll10nllmt hn!'ll1ol\ tho Defondlll1ts, Whol1 11 , , . Pllllntlff olllll.llt f)lllol1dllnts 10 Hohodnll.lll 911l~,vll1g oftho Proporty 10 Bnyo'r, Plnll111ff "flllseIY roprosolltod Ihlll tho Buy,ol' \V1I9 hla ollont, Dulolldl1llts rOllsl.)l)lIbly I'ollod Oil tho " I'llIlllllfrs IillsOl:oprOsolltl1tlonl\tiel this rolllllloo Ol1usod Dotollclllllts to Illour nddltlolllll ,00S19 thllt \Voull\not hllVo boon Inolltrod \vlthml\ Iho I'h,lntlft'9 Ihlso,roprosontllllol1, 10 , I, " 5\, I'lnilitlrf~I\II~\1 ~11'~, II\IYlWS In l'uq\I~S' II shn\vlnlllbl' n ullul\l,l\I\\1 ", ' ' rnlHul~ rUpl'~Hulllull In Iwl' 111111 pur~I1\IIIIllH' liFoI' ~lIlu n~ OWIWI'" ~nnl Slllllll\l \,ulllnVllll . , , I' rlnrlllll Ih\l shnwllIll ao IIH In I1PI'po!1liISl,lllw nn~\ll" ..l'lnlllllrr IlIlul1\lllllll\O D\lfp11111l1l1 In 1'I1I11OYIlIIlll ~.nl'\Ishm 1\11\1 PIlI~l1\ll\nla r\lmOw\\ \1111 ~nn\ slulIllI \,UIlHPllnhl\l rolhIl1P\ll1l1lh(l ,l'll1lnllffs rnlsu rllprpsOlllnlloll, I'lnillllft's 1l\1"\ll11laI'PprosiJl1lnllol1 hlli'illPII Pllfpl1llnl1lslls sll1l\l\1111 pnrn""l1ph 50 I1bow, '5~, Upol1 Inthrl11nllol1 I1ml bollpf, QUf0l11ln11ls l\Ylll' lhnl 1'1l\lllllrfhll~11\ dll\~ In dlapl\ls\l In nn~ol' I1l1d 001'01111111119 tlWllntlll'o Qf IIn~ Plll'pOfloll lll!\lllll~ rcll1\lpnshlp , . ,. I , . PI' hlPK Ihor\lQf with Iho 13 IIYO I' 'nr Ih\ll:)ofonllnIll9, Plnlllllft'lllll npI IIls\llosp 10 Illlyllr or Opfonllnl1ls IIW nlllnrq of IIny IIIlPI1Py r\lll1llol1shlp, bll\ IhrnlllJh pOl1\llIol ~l\\,soll Ih\l13\W\lr ' IInll Iho 00fol11111111s 10 \J(l IIPPolvod 11110 b\lllovilllJ lhlll tlw Phlhl\lrr wns roprpsonlhlB Ihp olhllr pllrly, 13\l~pr 111111 OPfpl1\\lIl1ls rllnsonl1\Jly I'ollod IIpon tho PllIlnllff's ~ondllPI IIml Ih\l 11 ". d' , t"lllll'll 10 dlsplpsolll1l1llpnpy rplllllollshllJ by \lslnlJ thp I'lnll1lifflo POIIII\lOI prpllmlllllry IIPIJQlIlIllol1s on IIIP slllp of tho I'rOPOI'l>', ()olbl1dlll1ts \'of\SOI1l1bly rollpd'ol1 Plnlnlll'fs " I' onnd\lcl Illlsod ol1lhq IISSIII1\ptllll1thlll Pll1lnllfl' \'PprOs\lnlo\1 IhuI3I1YOI', Upol1ll1fonnntloll , , (me! bplIllt~ Dofol1llnnls nw\' Ihlll B\lYo\' \,pnsol1nbly I'pllcd 011 Plnll1l1ffbnsod IIpOI1 thp IISS\lll1ptlolllhlll 1>111111111'1' \,oprPSPl\lod Ihp ()pfol1dlll1ls, 53. pfi\ll1tll'l's oPl11hlPI in thosh(,1,wlnlJs oflhll P\'opol'ty \o'thllQu~or olso support (hp,thlso rOllrosontntlol1, Tho showlnlJs 11'01'0 pnl1trnry tll Iho pl'ooodlll'o Ihnl:. Plolnlll'l'sho\Vpc! lho Propor(y du\'lng Iho AgroPI1\Pul, o>{uopt whon Plnlutlf'l' \,pprpspnlod lhl) proapoolll'P bu~o\', Pllllntln's oonduol ponslltulos wllll\1111llsrpprosonlntllln of I1\nlorllll fnp\s lhnl cnusPd thu Oolbndnnts 10 IilcllI'IlI!illl1ngos Ii\ on ntllllUnl of ,. . . . ,. <> nppl'OXlil1ntpl~ $10,000, . II " I" " " 'I " 'I I , I' !, 57, Upon Infhfmlllll1n nnll lwllpl; j)of~l1Ih1111& IIVPI' Ihnl \llllh1\Ift'~, , , ' p'll1\hlOI Wll~ wllll\II, Inlllnllonlll IIIl11 1ll1l1l\llpII&, IInd Ihnl II PI1I1&lIt\1\o~1 1\ Ill'onoll'of PlnlnllfP& fhllllllnl'Y IhllY, n& n I'onl p&lnll! nBllnl, IPIl'\llhl\llIr 111&0111&0 111 Ihll J)pf~n~lInla 1111\1 Ilw Ilurof 'lIl\l nnlIH'o nl' nl1Y nBolWY I'Qlnlllii1shili, 111' Iho InllK of ony lIa\lIWr '-. '. " r\llnllonsl1lpl 1I11111fJ nollri\~rf'pI'Q wUhlho nlllllty of H10 f:lllY\lr 01111 Hill DQI~n~lIl11s'lo nlll ,,' wl,lholll1\11Yl\Bonl, " I' _I, ',. " 'v\'1.mRIWORH, Dol~I1~lnnl& SOoKoOIllPQl1snlory nl1~ pUl1l1tlv\l IInl1lllaos In Ihl! nmp\\nlof $ t 0,000, !lOll OP&ls 011\1 ol\orn\lYs fooa nnll suoh olhor rollof ns Iho Court mllY I1I'1{OI', ., COUNTERC!-.AIM COllN1'IH.VloI~^,1'I0N OF 'I'1'IIJ'fll:IHRMAN AND Cj,I\ YTON ACTS 'I 58," Doflll\dnnlH hl00l'Pl11'II10 by roforllnoll pnrngrnpha 0110 Ihrollllh lll\r. ~ovonllbovo lIa Ifaol fprlh t\llly, , ' , " 59, Plnlnllrfa oonllnol onnalll\llos IIn 11l1lnwt\11 nnd,unrollsol1l1bl\l l'oHlrnlnlonlrndo In Vllllllllon oflho tbllornl nl1tllruslnola, liS oOlllllod nil 5 U,S,C, m 01 ,- I' .", I' " . 'I sqq, Plnlntlrrs oondnol II1\0rforott with Il1torsllllo OOl1\1noroo lIa n 'rosllll of Pllllnllffa rostrlllnl ol'lho Dofondnnta' snlool'th\l Proporly to tho 13uyo,'t 60, Tho Unll1wt\11 oonlll\Ot. ,nsl1l1ugoel nbovll, WIIS Phlh1\lrrs ~plill\l1d , for pnymonl 01' It oommlsslon Ihnl \vns nol/IIlI'Ood In by Dol'onlll1nls I1nd whloh wns oXPl'oaaty roJo~tlld by thom In IIloh'l1ogotltlllol1a wllh Plollltlff, Tho Plnlllttff1a ~ol11l\l\~lbr IlAymonl, nl'st by lottoI' nlld sUb~oqIIOl\lIY through nllnll thlR nollol1, sooks to h111loac II, .. slnl1dl1l'~ PIlYl\1ol11 tOl'lnl1l roall'l1ll1t ol'trndo 111111 bnsod 011 n OOIl\l11lsslol1 dlotAtod 'by tho " ," Illrtrkol pow9r l,lf I'lnlntlff nnd unl1l1111od oo'oo\lsplrntO\'R, Tho pn)'lIlOl1l of ~ oOI\1l11lsslol1 " to Plnll1tlffUl1dol: Iho o\t'OUI11Hlnl\cos cOl\slllllto~,UlIln\VI\11 pdoo nxll1g by n 1I101l0polYI nl\l,l 'I , 13 " " 'I 'L I ,6<1,' Plnillllfl'& ppmhlP\ 111 IIl~ph1H11l1l lill~p '11ll\lrmllllnll dllrlllll Ihll .. Allrp~IlWIlI pon~il\\I\P~ n brunl'h nl' thu !\llUI1l'n ll\\l~ 10, Ilw PPI'Ul1lllll1\~, Plllhlllft'& ell&plll~\ll'P Ilflhp till~p I1l1d ml&lplI\lIllllll1tpl'l11l1lhllllU o\lwr IUlPllla hllrmPll Dplpl1lhml& b)' , .! ' III&POllfl\lllllll pllll'll\11I1 h\l)'urwwhll wuro rl'prU~lll1lpll b)' II!Wl1la, Upolllnl'llrl11l1\llll1l1mt ,.. ,. 'I j, , bll II p 1', DlllplllllIlIl& IIvor 11101 1I\1l 11ll1ln\lt'f& dlaplll&lIrp \,PlhlIlPII lllll 1l1l1l'kll\ Ill' putpl1l1l1l " .. ,.. " I' . 1;1I)'~ra, 1Il11llhllrllb)' hllrl1l1l\-llh~ Ppl\1mlnllla Ihrollllh Il11poHIIIIlIIV\lllh\hluIlPalil 011 Ihom, .. .,. " Wl'lm~I~PORn, Ppl'ul1llnnla' aupk CPl11pPllalllllr)' IIml pllnlltlvp 1111111111l0a 111 tho ., !." 111110\10\ of $1 0,000, lwl cpala l\IlIllIl\orn~)'a tllP& oml allph n\hur rulloI' lIa thll CPllrl mil)' .," 01'1\01', " " , " ' Pllludl AUIl(lat 10, 1999 ,,', .. i, , " , , " ,I; " " " ,," , ",. 'I "J' " I;" 'i. IS " " " . IIfIl,I'.\J'I1Il"I, IIMI, I\!fIWn: I'I\Qn:Il11IPNM.!l1 ' . . "lnlnUff v, I , I I , " I I I I I" " ,. I " IN '1'111\ ~(lI1I1T (>II ~UMMnN J'!..MIl OPMIlI'IIII,ANU CPJJNTV, l'IlNNIlVlN!\NlA " " , IInllllRT 111\ VNf:R '"llt KATIII,f,IlN lMYNIlS, . l1~fplH'"nt~ NO, oo.u~~ OIYIJ. AcnPN...f.,AW ,Il I." Lhula H, Epl1lolo, Eaq\lll'o Tholl1na 0, Wllllml1a,Haqllll'P RI.ll\SQI' &: (\11101', p,C, " :m I Mnrkol Slrolll Cm,11pHIIl,PA 17011 ,', . Pn\OIlIAIIBllat 10, 1999 " I' " "j'l '" IIr " " ' ,,-' " , " II " " 1\ i' ,. I' ,II " I, " , " " I', 16 'I \'" , U1H!I"~'l1fCl!I., IUMI! I~R(I'i\'I'K I'H()FI~I1RIONi\I;111 . I'Il/hllll'l' 'j'" , ,," 'IN 'I'Im CQ~H'I' DI~ CX>MMoN I'I,r~MI , CfJMIIlCln,i\NH CO~N'I'V, I'ICl'INI1Y1!V i\NI~ , ' , , , NO, ~V.H;l$ " , , , CIVil! I\C'I'ION .... 1\'1' I!i\ W , I I , )'~r' HQlmWI' 111\ "NICS 111111. 1~I\'I'.IH!lCICN"1\ VNICI1, hll~hlllll' 111111 wlf'~, npl'olllh"\I~ I , JlLi\.I~'I'J1rF'R R1CJlLYJ'o NICW MA'I"I'I~1t AND r\NSWICH '1'0 CO~Nrl'ICIWI,AJM Wl'I'1! NICWMA'I"I'I~I! NICW ~ "I'ICI '39, . No I'ONpllnS~ 1'~'1nll'~d, I' '" 'I, " 40, P~nlcd, \( Is spoolllcnlly donlcll thnl tho PlnhllUT Hilled (0 nelln ~pod Ihl1h nndwllh " , elenn hnlllls, By )Vlly ol'.l\ll'lhol' l'espOnNo, Iho' PlnlnlllT I\llIy IlIwloNlld,10 the hny~1' nnd,lllll , , " .' " IJel'cndnl1ls Ihe OXIIlIllI;f' lis IIg0lieYlnllhol'lly, 41" l)onled, Tho n1'01'l1101l1s of.pnrngl'nph 41 conslltuIP eCll1ehlNlolls of' In\\' lo\\'hlch llo , , I'osponslvo plelldlng Is 1'0(1l111'ed, 42,. Ponied. Tho nVol'll1olll~ of pnl'Ugl'nph 42clIl1stiluto llol1chlSlol\H of In\l' 10 Ivhloh 110 . l'espol1sll'o plcn\llng Is I'oqnll'oel, "To tho oxlunt lltill nil n1l8\1'OI' Is deoll1odl'oqnll'ed, ills spcolflonlly , dOlllod Ihn( Iho Plnll111lT lundo nl1Y,ll1lsl'Opl'oslllltnllons 01' hronched nllY dl1ty 10 thd'l)of'ol1dnl1ls. I"~ 'i" ,,,' '1\ ;'1 " , I, (i I, ,Ponlull. Tlw IIIWnWlllR Ill' plll'Hlll'llph (i I ~\lllRlh'lI\l ~\lIlPhIRI\ln~ or IHW III whlph 1lP" " ' ;, " , 1'\l~pllIlHI\'U plplIIllnlllR l'\lqllh'~II, T\lIlW ~~I\lllllhll( Iln IIll~WOI'IH II0PIH\lIII'\lIIIlII'OII, ,ho 11111111111'1' IIUIII\lM \l1l\Jh 1I11111l1'UI'~ I'IIU1\I1Ililwl'I1wn\ cJ\llllllhWIIIIl PIII'IIUI1Ilph0 I, I ' W'IIIlHIlFOHH, \1ll1hll 1 1'1\' 11\llp"1J,~plI HplIlll~(lHu Pl'I1lbHHllllllIlH, 'i'\lHP~PII\III~ 1'\lII;WHIH IIIIN C01JN'I'lV (lh'UIIUh Ill' Cnllh'lIct) " " ,,62, No 1'0Hponko l'U11Ilh'\1", 'I'hu PllllnIlITlIlOOl'p\lI'IIICR IWl'o11l \lyrolbl'oll\10 ItRCqmpllll1ll .lIml AmonllollComplnlllt fIIo\llll '111~ OIlHO liS II' Hol rlll'lh 1\111)', , 6~, J)ollloll. ItlH spoo\nol\lI~ \lpllloll thllllho 111111nlll'l' dlRolmolllo Pl1lol\i1111 hnyul's Ill' " " 'Ihoh' UllOl1lR III nn~ IInw Ihllllho l)ofol1dnnls 1'01\IRUd In pll~ ,1111)' oomlHl~NII;n li1l'1I hU)'QI"H 1I1101l1, HIN I\nllwr "onlod npul1lnfiH'nmllnn nl\ll hullol' 111111 tho J)ol'ondnn(H WOI'00qI11llolu" hy lI11unlR jill' " hn~or~ who Indlolllod ,Ihll( tho .Plnhillfl' hod pl'osontod 111111 Ihu!iol'onUI\nIR 'l'ol\lsodto, pny un)': ,,,' olllnmlslllonln n hnyor'Ii'II11olll; Slrlol pl'Ool', Ihul'olilro, Is 1101111lndcd'n( \l'ln!. ' " " " , 64, !?onlod, It ,IH spolllflollll)' donlod thllt (ho PllllntilT dlRol\)sod nllY I\\lsolnl'ol'lnntipn rOlllll'llll111 Iho l)ofiJI'ld!lnls, 11 IN,I\lrlhor donlod (hllllho PllllnllfT hrllllohod II lhn)' oIVod hy II 10 th~ ' ;" ;, ., t1ol'ondlnltll, Flnllll)'"lIls spoolrlcl'lI)' d~lllcid IhlllulIY 01' Iho Plnhllll'l"N oondnol hni:lIlCll,lho J)ol'olldllnls 1111111)' WII)', d " " .6. " , " " , Ii " 'I " , , .' ' " , WllHHlWOHll, 111nlnlllT, 1I1l111-11-I11l11 Honll1sl'lIlll Pl'lll~~~hmnl~, rpspllllll\lll)' rP1lIlllSlWlhls l' , Ilnni1!'nlllll Cmll'll,o IlIsml~~ IIIIl ,jlll~mlnnls' COlllllorplnhn wllh prll,lmllcll nml cnsl~, NICW..MAj"I',m '1'0 cmii'/'I'lmCLAIM, ,.-." . ,. J " 6~, Tlw PlnllllllT h\Opl'pol'ntll~ 11OI'vln h)' r\Jlilrllnpoills Anwmloll Complnhll, I~oply In Now Mnltol' I1ml Answllr In' Cn\lnlol'plllhn ns II' sol Ihl'lh 1\111)', , , , Tho PIl('omln\lls' \lo\l\llllrolnlms ill'o hnrrod hy pl'n1ll1~sor)' o,~lnppol, Tlw poromhl11ls' oo\lnlOl'olnhl1s nrll hnl'l'oll hy Iho'llno(l'lno nr wnlvol' nllllostnPPll1, Tho Polill1dnnts' olnlms nru hnl'l'od hy Iho \InOlrlno or \n1Clonnllliilll~, porlll1llnnl~\Il(I'ilOt suITor nn)' Ilnl11ngo~, Pofvndnnt I'nllod In IIllllgnlo Iholl'lhunngos, , '\'0 Iho' OX Ion! Ihllt tho Pllfollllllnl~ Slll'l'o\'od nny tln1l1ngos, II'hloh Is ~poolflllnll)' " dCl1lod, suchdnl11nllOll 11'01'0 O'\llsod hy Iho Pofondnl1tH' oWl1l1ollol1~ 01' Inllollol1s, nud I1nl h)' IIw " ,t' )f Plnl"II(T, 72, Dol'o"dllnt~1 onl1111v'i'olllhn~ fnllln ~tllto n olnhl1 lIpO" whloh !'lIlloI' mil)' ho gl'll"lrll. WI1I1IWJ10Hll, Plnl"t1rf, Holp,U-solI HOIII Ils(nlo Pl'nfosslnlllll~, I'ospootl\lll)' \'oquosls this Ilolltll,'nhlo Cn\ll'( to dl~ll1IH~ (ho Dol'olllhiillH' cOu,,(o\'olnll11 wllh Pl'O.lIldlou 1\1111 OO~IH, " .7. ;I, "" ,l, " Ii" " 1\ !; I' I' !i " " " , t'~' l::I.i. p:~\t,l! \j\~ll '\,.'(' (hi 1'11' ,r,\! ' 't'k , Co> " " " " " " )'i I .. -.11 pi ~I~ ,. /, )',. , ~~Mq? (?ftl m~'HP?\ V~ '11111 ~~yp h ~~""~" ~Q~WI'i IH' ,. " MV1 ~V ""aN"p4V 'P'~ 'UQ'lqy OW UQPY~U ,,[ "" II " 1'\, " :i'.~ n.., ~I ~ (,,, , '.' !::\ f ( t:JI,;1 'i()~'i; '''I:'::', '\ ),:, ".1'('1 , I:J (i.~; ':.1.\(1\ ii', p,. ,j~I ty ."f'. ~n (.':'.' :'-:l hJ~ m ()., I, 'I" " , '. I"~ 'j ,I " I' , " " " '" " n,. I; " ',I "" ,:, " , " II .' ',i 'II 'I, " l' I, I' ",' Ii .' " ",j' .' " "" ',Ii ',j '" ;, ',11 " "j. ',(, I, ,i' 't, 'I " " .-, I' "jj'l\" ". Ii "It " '1 I' ", , " II !; ,,' ;1 " I; ", " , i',i' '. 'I' " Ii' {,t. " " ,I;, \1, "i q' "n ., " " " " '0; ., .. I, " " i'" " " Il1pr\lIl~\l Ih\l prl\l\lIC1 $II)!I,I)()O wlwl1l1w IMIlI\lll\lll~ 1I~lwll '11l11~11I1\l I'l'I1lwrlr Ihl'll\li!h ' j.. , 1,Iw mllltl'II~II1H\l'k\llhll! Ilpvloll,n~ mlvlWi\lIlIIIW Plnhlllrl', " 4, Ppl1l\llln~ ftlnl\ld, II 1ft ml1nlttlllllhnl tlw A!lI'PPI1WI1I wnH Ihr ~Ix nll1l1lh8111', \111111 fl\lpl\l11l11PI' 30, 19~R, Ilr wnr PI' l\1I'l119r nI18WOI', Iho ^loll'OPIl1\l111 n"llIln ' , .. 'II, " , wn~ nl11011\lpllln 111111 RopIOIl1\!PI'(ll pl'\lVIII\llhr nn IlXloll81nl1 p'f lIl\lll~tlng IWrlplhl11l11 , , , ,- , ...-" I ' Oplnlwl' 31, 1999, 111111 \OI'Pll\lIlP tlw nlloul '~I'PIl prlli\lllllol1ll\lrlmlul\IlI' Ihp AllrpPl1lpnl O'C11l1 slXlrllnrft I') Ihll'lr Ilnrs, $, \}llnloll118 stulolI, Ills ulll11ll\\lllllllll P\\\ll1llfl'slH1woll ,Io('O'or ' Ihl\ll?l\l'Il (1IIlllrCI,lI) 1\10 Pl'npol'lr 011 Nnvol1llwl' ~~" 191)R, 111<< Ilpl1llllllhnl PI,lIhull'!' 'h1ll'1llhloolllhc 13l1rol' In thQ Pl'opol'lr nr Ihp Dp!'olllhmls, It Is mhnllloll thnl \l\lYIlI' , ,-j PIU'\lhllSQII tlw PI'OllQI'lr I\Wn Dolllllllnl1lsol1 MIIl'oh 1,191)9, . '. - , " , 6, ' I)PlllplIlIs sInloll, Jllnll1l1l'j' onnsol\ nllll1l11'kolll111ll,otlvlliOSI)l1 OPlolwr'3l, 1 f)9!l, nt Ihollnll oflholllll'oomlll1t: 1)lllomlnl1ls, IIpnl1ll1lhl'mllllpu nllll b\ll1pl; , n',:o nwnl'O Ih'nl tlw 13(1)'01' wns Inlol'oHlplllu Ow Pl'llpol'l)' nl\ol' obsPl'vlnll'lho JioI'0111hinl~; " . ,. - ,,,III ' " own nllll'kolhll! I1l1l1nlll'Ol'lIsoll1onlH nnd l1ollhosoot,' tho Jllnlnlll'l', ,. ., 7, Admltloll, II, Donlllll nH HtlllQl\, Pofonlln;llH IIll1no\ nUlhol'lzo I'lnll1tlfflo 1\0\ on thull'bohnlr I'ollowlng Iho oxpl1'ntllll1ol' thQ nlll'OOI11Ollt 011 Oolohol' 31, 19911, Dofol1l1nnls '. -, ' . -I, H " j. \1 . ,. ;. .., bollovod, thnt 1'1"lulln'H nllolll. Edwlll 011'011. wns lIo\lllll Oil hohnll'ol'lho13\1Y~I', , 9, Dofondnl1tH hnvo 110 pOI'SOIlIlI kl1owlodgo 01' Il1lhl'l1lnlloll OOIlOOrlllllll l ,. ,11 fllllll1t1f1's eOl1ll1lll with BU)'OI" It ,IH 1Ic\l1llltoel Ihllll'llIll1\1f'1's IIg0l11 011'011 showed Iho " " ,; 10, DOllloc\ nS,HIII(od, '1111I11I111'I's lI110llt OWOII llolltllotod MI'S, IlnYllos, 2 " " 'I I' I' ,,' " ,. j, ".. II, ,A111,1111l~i" 12, PVIlIVII ita alnlvd, IIlallllmlllv\i tllnll'lnhlllfl'a nllolll PWVIlIlW\ with P~li"Hlnnla ~n II!' nl)n\\\ 1)vov111hvrfl,llJlJH.\nl'r\1aOIlI\lw wrhlvlIllf'lilr lhlln\lw !lllrol'! 11101\1\1\111111 thv llflill' WIlH IlwlMull\lnllls'nlllWIlWI1l In nn)' n vl1ll1llllaalllllllllhp Plnll1llff, 'l'hv llflilr wnH rv.lpvlvd Ily Ih\! PIII~IHIIIIIIHnll\l PolUlHlnnlH 1\1lllpnlpll IiI \lw PlnhHIff'a n!lvl)1 thnl tlw ^llrpol\lolllllllll \lxplrv\llIlIIllhnt Pvt'ollllnllta hn\llIl111hll!lnllnllln pny Ih\1 ^llrpVI11PIlI'a \101l11l1IaHlllll, U)' Wllr Ill' l\nlhvr nllHIV\lr, Pi11\Jl1Ilnlltallllhl'l110d PlnhHlfI" nlwllt O)volllhntll'lw \vnntvd n Vllll1l11lRHhllllhllt \lIP Hulo 1l1\IHI hv nt n prl\lll wllPrvhy PolUllllllnla wllnlll moolvo $1 HO, '000 nnur 1111 Hlllo 11'l\llallo\lnll QXrUIl~oa wor\! pnlll, I)uf'olllhmla n\111 Plnllllirl'oxQon(oll nllll!lrVunwlll on 1)OP0l11hOI'4, IlJ98 whQr\lh)'. . " Pvl'ollllnlli~ lI!lrovcl tn nny I'lnlll\ll'l' n Ollll1llllsallil\ IftlIPPrllportr wna ~old l(lth~ UII)'Qr 1'01' 1\.. 1" , n pI'lpo 01'$1 H7,OOO, I'lnhHlfl'a n!lollllllao dlsolpsul! Inlhp ()olimdllllt~\hnl hv hllll " .' ". " " uIlI\lr\llllllllln oOI,ltl'OoIWhorob)'ho wO\llllrooolyo ulllllpollHnllon O'01111ho Hurol', 13, . j)olll~d na stnloll, Plnlnllfl's lI!lollt Owolllnlorl11Qll Dvl'oll\huHH'ihnl \lU)'OI' hllllll1l1do 1111 ol'lllun(lntornl'f'ol' Illlho lllllllunllll' $1 84,000, whloh Dolulldnllla " roll1010d hOOllllHO 11lnllllll'I'wlIH unwlIlIn!l to rodnco tho sllloR c0ll11111sfllol110 nllolY. \ J'" J)cfl1ndlllllR 10 rccclvo $180, 000 nl\or nllll'llllflllollnn IlOS(S, , , ,," 14, D0l11ud nH Hlnlcd, !101l11WI1l8 tho cxplrlllloll oftho A!lrulll110111lho IJul'ol\dnntR hllll l11illlc spuolllo n!lrOOl11cntH with I'mlous rUIII osllltu IIg0l1ta 101' Iho P\IYl11ol1l , " , OfCOlllllllsslolllt'lho n!lUlltH pl'Oclll'od II hu)'cr, DOrulldllllls did 1)P1 nuthorlzo Plllh1\lffto IIC\ nil hohlllfol' Dulullllnl1lH 111\01' tho oxplrntloll ol'lhu Agroul11olll, cxcopl by thu apoclllc IlOIlIl'lIcl cOlldltlon~d \lpol1lhl)'ol' PII)'h1!l IJulundllllls $1117,000 1\1I'lho I'rop~rl)', J ", i ~ ,10'.1" ';',. 1I~~~pt II lnw~,' ~\1l1l1nIH~llln In 111'11111' In \l11HSllllll1H111l H\~ slllllll1 Ihl~~1' 11\ IIn nni\111ll1 'I ,. ~IIIIHlh\lI\1l'rl\1lhll P~lul\llllnlH, n !lIlIlIIlIIIlH ~lIl1~\I, Tlw llnrql' 11'11<<' nnt hlll'mhl~\lfllll\lw Prl1pprtr I, Ihlrlllllllw 10l'm Ill'1IIP ^B1'll1lI1Wlllllllll ,1'111111111'1' IH nnl ~n.\Illullllllll1r fllll pl'l1l11~lll1l1liil' IIn)' Iwllvllr liillnwlnl! Ih~IlXpl\'l\lhll1l1l' lIIP All''PllIIWI1I11XIl~pl 1\11' Pl'l1Hpllll\lY\l hnr\lI'H . hlll'ocl\llllllllll.lhlll'l'llpJI'l)' hr \Iw I'lnlnllrl'IlllI'1I1l! IIIP AI!l'OpI1Wnl, N~llollIlIlI1I1H 11Plwll~n I. Ilnrlll'lInll Dot~l1\llIl1l~ 1l1l1l111111llclllt PIl\lom!1ul' 4, 199" wholll'llIln\lfl'H nlllllll 011'011 I " PI'\1HI1I1IOlllln \1fflll' Oil \1111111\1' llr\lwll\I~\lI', " , , ,. 2~, "polllcll, \)\1l'lllllll'"IH 11111 nol \l1\\IHO Pllllnllfflol'olr I1l1lhllll' ., , ' ' , " IlOmhl\l1 \111I1\l1' tlw llU\ltrlllll of \lqllllllhl\l \l~topplll".I'IIIII1\1fl'wIIH 1111'111'0 Uillnhll Alll'oQIl1111l1 '" ", hl\\l \lxpll'o\1 1I1111lhlll 1111)' PI'nHPo\ltlvo hllr\ll' 11'011111 hllVo t\1 plly II r1'loo 10 HIIIIHt~, . ','. ' , ".' "- Pllf~I1(llInls' pl'l\lo, whloh wnH \'nS\lel 1111 tlw IImonlltlo hOl'o~olvOlllltlol' nllll'IIn8110111111 costs, Plntnll,rf ~n\lw t1mllho SlIlcs oOnll,nlHHllln WIIs IIn hnpol'llInl pnl'lllf Iho n\lUOlllltlol1s' ,'wt\VoUl1lhojllllll1tlfrllmllho Dplblllllll\l~ dlll'hl!!,lho ^l!1'001l1\l1l1, Plllul1lllllllH 1111'01'111011 Plnlntlff III tholl' 11100thll!on PCOPl11bPI' 4, 199111hlll II 11,l'l11n\lsslon would b~ rllld liS II qpII(lhlol1l~1' Iho oonlrnolwllh Burol' In tho 1I11111UIII 1:1' $1117,000, 1'111111111'1' I'lIl1uII',o "I , " " l' SlIllsl)' Ihls \londltllln, Plllhll!fftheI'UlltlOI'IIt1Ul11plud tOllll'outHII)'UI' 10 lllffcl'cnl hOllsuH,' 24, . I)ol1lod ns stilted, It Is IIdl11lttod tlm! Iho. PI'01101'1)' wn~.,Hl1ld 10 Iho , 11\l~ul' wlthoul Dulblltlnllts nuthol'lzhll! 11I1)' nHHls,\IlllO\ll\.'OII1 thu Plnl1ltlfl', COUN'{lI,IN THE ^r~Ti~RN^TlVE.UN.JUST ENluCllMENT 25, DofolllhmtR '"llol'pol'nlo hUl'ul11 b)' l'ulurul1oe pnl'll!!rnphs ono Ihl'o\lgh I\vonty.fhlll' nhOI'OIlH If HUlltWlh f\lll~, 5 ,/ " " , ", il I' I" "I ", 'I, ,I (JPUN'I' IIHN '1'1 III I\I.THHNI\TIYI::,nli!\I\OII PF IMIlI,llm CllNTMIJ'I' I' ~(), PlllvllIlmllH hWlll'pl1l'nl1l h)' I'lllul'lllWV hUl'lllnplII'nlJl'llphHllllll thl'l1l1uh IWlllllY'lIhw nl,lllW nul r 11111 lilj'lh 1\111)', , 31 ,bulllvlI {llllllnlllll, !\nvl"OotnhOI' ~ I, 1 !)!JHnmlllw Illl'lnlllnll\1I111l' tho 1\1J1'1I1111101I1, Plllvmllllltu \1I1\11111 hnwnl1)' kl1PI1'1iH11J1l prllll)' IIllllpl1H IlIkon PI1 huhllll'pf . Ihllln h)' Plnllllln~ PlIlUl1\,llIl1lH ,1I1lnnt IIfJoop\ nt' 1'11\11)' 1llllll111f1'Hnlllllll11l, Plnllllll'l'H nlllll1l1ll, IIn\lI'Ootllhul' 31, I!lOH WUr\lllnl1Hlullll1t wllh Pllllnllfrl'lll'l'lIlllll1lllllJ Ihci 1l\l)'IlI',l\t '1111 Ilnw 1111\ Pllllnllf'f'ull\lk III UIIIIlI' II1IP II I1UIVIIIJI'1I0nlllnl,llXIl1lI't fbi' Ilw 1I111HlIIlpI1nl I, , _ ,,' ., , " "1JI'lIfJlI1l1l1llh"I, wnllllli~II,1 1111 thll 1111)'111' PIII'fJhll~'lnll Ihll PI'I1PIlI'tylill' $1 H7,000lll1l\ thll, ' " . ',lIp\1dlllol1 proollllllnnllll n1111101l1ll', , ,. 32, PUllllld liH ulillulI, I)lllill1l111nlu ndml\ Ihlll Pllllnllff'll notlpnll IVUI'o, ;, ;', I" ml1llvll!1I11 1'111' Ilolnuh runllllnll illld b)' Ill'oull, Uplln Il1fbl'l11tllll1llllllil bollol; l)uflmeln\111l IIvol' . '., I '.. 'I f, "10 "Ihnl Plnlnllff'rullfJ\1 pn 0'111111 nnil mIHrupl'OIlOI1,lllllpl1ll1thll,\lonlhl!l1l wllhUu)'ol' find .,' P\lfllndllUIIl b)' nol dlllulollhllJ to U'U)'OI' thnt PlnfntllTwnll11l11, thl) lIuthlll'izud nBonl\PllulI ,- ,-" " Ihlll'rl1purl)' nnd b)' not d1lloll1lllnB to l)lIf'ondnl1llllhlll ho wnll not tho BU)'OI,11I nllon\! ",. 33, " , PlInlllll nlllltnlod, Plnlntlf'f'wnll th\l'(lll\luo l1f',dlllll)' hl'tho ~nlo of '-,', ., , Iho Propurt)' nil l1roRullof' tho Pll1lntlfl'H I'rl1udul\l1l1 nnd dcoopllvu comlllot hI elllllllng with tho Hllyor I\Ild J)llf\ll1dnl\ls,' , I. " 34, D0I1I11d 1Ii1lltlllod, '1'1\0 oxplmtllln of thll ^BI'OOI11UIH ol\dod Dofonllnl\tll OOI1I.l'lIotlllll rolntlnnHhlp Ivlth Pllllnlll'l', '1'1\0 13u)'ol' wnll lint II J11'111lJ1ootlvo , 1111)'01' elul'll1g tho Ag.l'ootllol\llIndPh,lntlf'l'H 1I0110nH nud llo1'vlllOH woronnldlllololl~d 10 .l)01011(llIl\t8, .))o'folldnn\1l hlld ,no kl1llwlodgollllhclhno thnl Pll\ll\tlffwnll mlll\'Opl'ORlll\tll\g , " 7 ., I" :...\ " 'I' " .." I, " " I " ,I. '; fit " (j(i, lJPI111 IIl(hnllllll\11\ nllli 11\lIIlII', P\lI~IlIIIlIlIH n\'Ul' 1I1l11 Iln)'\ll' 1I1I\ll\1l1lullll1 t\ll\lph\1ll\l l>\lI~IHIIIIlIH h)' ilnl.llnllllwl~\I\lphI1IW nllllill\ll' 1111lh\l P\lI~l\llnIlIH' ',.' ., ,. " .' ; )'1.'111 HI!!Il, 'j! 117, "UPI111 Illlill'l11l1l1l111 nml hull\ll; Plllbml!mlH IIWI' '11ml H u)'\l I' \11'" nIW\lI"" nUPlll wnH ullnhll, 1I1PI111ln~t IIw 1)ulbllllnllta, IlullllHI\llllllll\l 1l,,)'pl'roq\llwll n ,j 'j , .' I lul\lpl1\1110 I'o\lol'llhm Ihnl IIwlilll11\1\l1' wnR 11\\1111' H\ll'vl\ll', " , 'I", ' Upnllllllbl'l11nlll111111111 \1ulll'l; P\llblllhmlH nWI' Ihnlllll>'\ll' I, , " I, " pl'\lvll1l1Hly hllll OhH\lIVull Plulnllt't"H)'1I1'11 HI!!1l wlwIl11lnllllllThnd n lIalhm n!ll'pollWnl wllh I, .,' _ I .. " ,. , Pulbll~\nnIR, UII)'\l1' oPIlIIIPI\lI\ Plnllll1ffnnd I'PqullRtpd IIw POfOlldnllla' 10lQPhollO 1111l11hol' In orelpl',lu (lOlllllpl Pu('ol1dn11IR, II"i Upllllllllhl'l\1l1l1l1n nn(1 h\lllll(; 1)9lomlnllts,1I1'1l1' Ihnl PlnlllllffllllRPI)' ,. , I'IlPl'llHUlllod 10 13l1yol" \hilI ~nl)' Pln,l,nllffouullI Hhow IIwPl'opol'l)' Inllw UII)'ol'n1111 I'PfllRoel , I, /j , , , 10 pruvldo UU)'QI",illh Ihlll)olondnntH' 10lppho,1\0 I11ll\1hol' lIa 1'1'1)\10Rlod, 49, Up,onllllbl'\':!llllnl1 nm\ hllllol;Dolbl1dnl1ts n\'Ol' Ihnl pl"lllnn'a 1\1lso l'oproHontntlnl1a wOI'~ 1I\I0l1dod tn dO,uol\'O BIIYol' nlld l~uYIH"wl1a ,IUHllI.lodil1!IIH 1'01111111,10 Ihol'OUpol1 to hulll1,\'O Inllol'l'ooll)' thnt Plnlnllff stili wnR tho lIallng nuol1l till' Dol'ondnl1ls," 50, Upn11tlllhl'l11nlloll nnd bollol; ()olbndllntH n\,ol' tlllIl Jlh,ll1tlfl'H \iIIRo , .. '" ;' "I',. j, 'I' 1'0pI'0~ontntl\1I1I1IHO\VIIS n \iIIRo \'OPI'IlHOl1tllllol1 IIIlII hnl'l\\od tho ()Of~11111111Ia. Whlln t- . ., " Plnlllllffonllcd f)olonellll1ts 10 S~I\lldlllo Il showlnu of tho 1'1'01101'1>' (0 UUYlll', I'lnlnllrf fnla~'y rUpl'OHol1tclllhnllho UUYOI' \VIlH hla ullonl. D~I'ondnntR l'~nRonnbly 1'0\l~1I Qn tho j, "" , Plnlnlll'l'a Ihlso l'cmORciltllllonllnd IhlR 1'0llnl1co llnllscd DolblldnntH (olnoul: nddltlol1nl OIlHt~ tlU\1 wuuleI 1\01 hnvo bool\ Inolll'l'llll wltholll tho I'lnllltll'l's fhlao l'OPI'OHOlllnllol1, 10 " I' , " , " il !,; " , ,. ~ I , 1'111111111'1' ~nllo\1 Ml'fl, IIIIYl1'o>> 10 rllllllo>>ln >>howll1u Ihl' II 01\0111, 1111\1. l\IIH\lly r\lpr~>>olllo\ll\i Iwrlhnl P\lfilllllll\1I>>' 1'1"111' Hlllo llr PWl1or" )'111'1\ HIIlll110 r~ll1ov~11 ;_ < ,." 'l. ,.' I " ", II\II'h\lllh~ >>howll1U HO /I>> 101101 '0\1I1IiIH\lllw 1\11)'01", 1'11I11I1I1'I'lnlomlll\llh\l P~lilmlnl1llo" "Ol1lOV\llh\l ynnl >>11l1l1l11\1 n~lilllllllnlH rOll1l1V\l\llIw rllrd ~,!Iln 111 r\lll>>ol1l1\1lo I'ollin\ll~ oil Ih\l Plnlnlltr>> 1111>>\l rllprll>>lllllllllolI, I'lnlllllfl'>> nll>>il Il1I>>rllpl'll>>ollll\\lon hnnnwl Plllilmlnnt>> II>> ~Ullo\lln pnrnlll'llph ~nn\10VIl, ~~, Up\111 111lhrll1nlllll1 nlld hollor; P\lI\lmIIlIlIH nV\lI' Ihlll Pllllnllffhll\11I lhllr .In dl>>ol\1>>o In 1\11)'01' IIlId Pol\111\II\I1I>> Iho 11111\1ro \11' I1l1r pmp\1rlollllll\ll1oy 1'01n111111>>hlp , ;,., '.. \11' lllok Ihorollfwllh iho 1\11)'\11' ofllw 1)\11\1111Inl1l>>, lllnhlllffllldllPlllIH\1loHo jollnY\ll' 91' , 1)\lfOI1\\nlll>> IIw,IH\\\lr~ ufnl1Y 1I!l\lnOr r\llnllon>>hlp, \1\1\ IhrPllllh 1l011lhlOl Oi1\lIlOlllhoHllrol" IIl1d IIw Pof\lmlnl1l,>> 10 bo II\loolv\l\lll1lo hllllovlnll lhnllllll Plnll1tlffwns ropr\1>>onlll1llllw olhOI' pony, 1311)'\11' 1\11\1 Pof\ll1dnl1ts ronHI11Hlblr 1'01\011 IlpOI1 tho Plnll1tlft's oOI1e1nol ol1d Iho I " ,. ,. , 1'011111'010 \1I>>IIIUS\lnil nllonor rolnllol1shlplw 1111111lltho 1'11IInlllTtl1 oonllllojpl'olhnlnnry , " 11\lllollnllol1s ol1lhll snlo of tho l't'oporlr, Pol\ll1clnl1ta 1'0nHol1nbly rollod 011 !Plnll1l1l'1'a 0011(11101 bllsod 011 tho \ls>>llInpt!ol1thnl )1111111111'1' ropl'osol\lod Iho Ilnrol', Up'i1l11nlb1'l1HltI\111 1111d boll\ll; Pof'lmdllllta nl'or IhM 1311)'01' ro\\soIHlbly rollod ol1l'lnlnllff'bllsod IIPOIl Iho " n9allll1pll011 thilt 1'InhlllffropI'oso111011 tho ):)ol'ondnnIH, I' , ~3, Plnlntlft's ol1l1duot Inlho showln!!H 111'Iho Propol'ty 10 tho Bnrol', nlHo aupjlort Ihofnlso ropl'osonlntlon, Tho showln!!>> WQI'O oonll'nry l,n tho prooodllro lhnl", Plnlntll'fahowod tho Pmpol't)' elln'hl!! lho AllrOllll1onl, oxcopt whon PI\llntlff t'opl'oRontod ,. ., ., Iho prospcotlvo bu)'ol', Plnlntll't'H oonl\uct oon>>lltnlcR wllll\lllI1lsropro>>onlnllon of . ninlol'lnl tholH 111111 cnu>>od tho Dolilndonl>> to hW1I1'll tlnll1n!los In nn nl11unnl uf " , IlllPM\hlllltoly $\ n,noo, , I' ", II "I' " '" ".. I" " '" ., " "i' 5'1, P\lI\lIHhlll(S..lIpI11lInl\lI'I11I1IIPIlIll1\1 hllll\ll; I\\:~l' thlll IIw Phlhlllfl's (iIIH\l rllpr\lH\lIlIlIlI,;nH 111\llllll1llllllhllW W\ll'\l h\lull\lIlIlIlIIllHII11I1II\lhHIS nl\ll \V\ll'llllllsl~I\ll,1 III .11111'I11 \lw IIhlllly Ill' P\lthlllh\IlI~IO \llll\ll' Inhllln IIlll'\l\ll11llnl 1\11' IIl1l slllll 01' Ihll f1I'Pplll'lY IP ,1111YIlI'. !' WllliRIW'ORH, PIlI\lllllllnts sllllk 911I11pollslllol')' 111111 PIlllllIlVlldlllll1lUPS In " IIw nl11Pllnl PI' $1 Q,QOQ, 111111 \lIlHIs IIIl1I IItllll'lW)'s t'll\lH IInll sll\lh ill/WI' 1'I.lIIl.lf IIH IIIIl Coml . i . , . 11111)' Ilrdlll', .. < ,. I " COUN'lllRCf,AIM COUNT 'f.'I'ORTrOIJ~ INTlllwmWNCI\ WITH nU~INIJHH IWI,AT10NS 55, P\lfondllnls IlIoprpol'Hlo \1)' rIlIOI'IlIl\lO plII'nl!l'lIphs 011\l thrnlll!h I1l\y. .' ;, 1'0\11' IIllllv\l lIalfsol forlh HIli)', I. "', " 56, Upo" Inlhl'll1l1(lon 1Ill11 bullot; Polomlllllts 1I1'\l1' IlllIl 1'llIllIllft's 01111111101 oPI1Htll\ll\ld II 1111'\lO\lH hllol'loI'011110 hI Ilw h\lslnoss rollllloll, bOlwool1 D\lfomllll1lH j' ';,'" " " IIl1d BII)'ul" PIIIIIlUrf hlld IIl1l1flll'lllll\lvu 11\1\)' 10 Illso/090 10 Dolondlll1ls nl11110 Iho B\I)'ul' ' ' "', , ", Ihn! Plnh!llff hnd I1l1nl!OIW)' cClnll'1I01 Wllh thu B\I)'ol' 01' thu PllIUI1IHl11IS, upon such dIHoloslII'~; 1)01011l11l11ls nnd 11\1)'01' \vOIild hllvu I'ollo,hud nn 1Il!1'OQ11101l1 HOOI1UI' \VlthOIl!' Pllllhtlt'f's lntlll'tul'oncu 111 Iho nOl!otlll\lI1I1S, Jllnlntlffls hllol'IQl'olloo ,III thu l1ulMllltlon, Dolundlll1!s 111'01' \lpOI1 Infol'll1lltllll1 1I11\'lhollol; Oll\lsod dolll)' nllel IIddltlonnl oostH, 1011\13 .' I' DOIUndlll1!S ll1lho Hnlo of tho Jll'opOl't)', Plfjll1llfl's OOlld\lot \VIIS 10 l!1I11111 cOl\1l11lsslol1b)' " .' vlollltll1l! Iho dllt)' \0 dl~olo~o IIndlhl'o\ll!h docoptlol1l' PIIIII1III'I' know, 01' sholllclhllVll kuoIVnlhnl his fhllul'o III dlHcloHO Iho IlIek 01' lIuy lIgollll)' Ul!I'OoI110nl wlluld hnvo l'IlSUltod" Iu .tho Ilu)'ei' HuocosHf\III)' ollntllllllnl! tho Dol\lndllutH IInd ll(lnll'lI11llul! fbl' Iho purohllso df' " " thu III'opoI'I)' wlthll\\l 1111)' IIsslstnllllll f\'lll11 tho Plnlutl n~ 12 !:. I; , 'n PpOIl Illlhl'l1lilllllll Illlil 11\l1l\l1; n\II~I1III1I1IH IIY1lI' Ihlll I'lnllllll'l'H ,\llll1lhl\l1 WIIH wllIl\II, .hll~nlhllllll 1111\1 1\11111\lh\\IH, 1I1l~1 Ihlll II \lllnHIII\I\\l~1 1\ \11'\ln\lh or 1,111lInllft'll 11111101111')' \hll)', IIH n l'\lnl\lHtlll\l IlIwnl, In 1I'\lIhl\lIl)' IIIH\lhlHlIlnllw PIII~llIlnnlH '1 " nllll IIw H\ly\lI'lIw 11111111'11 or nil)' n!WIWy l'\lh\\h1nHhlp, PI' 111\1 hl\lK or nn)' nl!\llw)' , ' ,. . " ; .. I"" 1'0lnllonHhlp, nmll\1l1pllnl\lI'l\w wllh 111\1 n\lllh)' or 1,11\1 UII)'l,l1' nnlllho PO,I\1I1III1I1IH 1\1 nol wllhl1\1l nn)' n!lont, ' II " WIHm.nrOIW, P\llpl1IhllllH Hook OOl11pl,lIlHnllll'r IIl1d pllnllllvu Ihll11111l0H In IIw n1110\1I11 of' $lll,OOO, IInll \ln~IH IIl1d nllnl'l1o)'H tqoH IInll !ll\oh nlh\ll' l'pll\lf' liS Ih\lCOIII'! 'II1n)' nl'dOI'1 " COUNT1JIWI41\IMCOUNT III.VIOI,AT!ONOF TIm SI-JURMAN ANP CLA YTON ACTS , ' . 5a, Pot'onelmlls hwnrpol'l1tll 'hr 1'0lQl'oilOO Pl1l'lIl!l'Ilphs dnoJhl'oliuh OOr" " " 1l\l1'01l IIbovo liS If~ol ftll'th 1\111)', 'I 59, Pllllntlfl) \lol1dliol oOllslI\I\loH 1IIlIlIlh1\vl\11 nI11111l1l'IIIISPlln\1l\l '1'01111'111111 ooll'llllolh vlollltlol1 of' Ihol'odol'l1l' IIlltlh'lIsIIICls, liS oodln\ld III 15 U,S,C', ~~ 101 I; ,. :_ . , ,.' - " " ,- 1 ' , , SOIl, Plnlntlft'a OOlldllollntol'l'oI'OIt'\vlth Illlol'slnto comnlOl'cll '(IS II I'.\lslllt of' Plnllltlfl's 1'01l1l'lIIIll of tho Dot'omlllnla' HlIlo of' 1')0 PI'opod)' 10 Iho 1311)'01', " I, GO, Tho II 11 I lI\vf\1 I oondlllll, lIH nllol!oel lIhovo, WIIH pllllnllfra dlll1l1l11d (hI' plI)'l11onlllf' II cl1l11\1llaslon Ihlll wna UC;llll!l'ood tob)' ))c('ohdm\lH lIlId whloh Wlla " oxpl'oasl)' I'o,lolllodbr 11101\1 In Iholl' nOl!otllltlollA with Phlllltln~ Tho Pllllntlff'A elol11l1lld f'or , ,- !I u , P"YlllOllt, Ol'at hr 101101' lInd allhaoqllolltlr thl'olll!h flIh,\!! IhlA IIctlon, HookH 10 hl1p~lao II " I; stllndlll'd plI)'l11ol\l tOl'lllln l'oHtmll1t nl'tl'udo lIllll hUHod 01111 onlllml~Alol1dlotlltceI by tho , lllul'kot POWCI' of Plnlnll 1'1' Ilml,\llll1nl1l111Icll'IlOIlHp/l'lIt\1l'H:' Tho pn)'11l0llt or n oOl1ll1\IHHlnu In Plulul!fl'uuelol' IhoclrClIl1lAlnhcllA oOI1AtltutCH ul1ll1\1'l\11 pl'lOIl tlxlug h)' 1\ 11l11I\opoly,'nllt\'" " 13 " " ;'.., " " , I I\~ SllPlh Vl\llllllons 111' IIII' Hlwl'mnn 111111 PlnYllln ^~I~I whl~h nl~IUl\llhdl'l~olho nwnnl (If 1!'I'l1lp Ih'mnlw~ nmln\lol'l\O)'~ l~p~ 1\11' Vlllh\\lon~, , I' , 61, \.1pon.lnf\lnl1l1lhlll 1\Il\IIl~II~I; Ppl~I)(lnl1\s nWI' Ihlll Pllllnlln; n~ 1\ II\lPIWPllyonl P~III\Pl1l'11klll' 1\111111 nwmbpl' (11'11 111\111 1 'I11PII1 1101' l'\Jnl o~llllo nHH\liJllIlIon, !in Ills , ~\lllHlllnlllll mlll'KlllpnWol' Inlho oOlltrnl Ponl\H)'lvnnlll I'onl o~I'lIpI\Hll'kpI thnl hwhldps \1\0 . I. ,. , .' . . ,Ioonllol\ oflhp Pmpol'l)', PIIIII.11Irr~ oll.'lIll1ot III ~o\lkII1U II 4% o\lml1ils~lonli'l1m j)ol~'1\llInlH' Hlllp nflho Jll'npol'ly 10 UI1YOI' OOI1HIIlIIIPH tho I1l1lnwf\,loxol'pIHP lIf'mnrkol , , POWPI' Ihl'llnuh ImpnHlllU pl'loo 101'I11H 111111'1\[10 O(llll!ilololl hy plIl'llo~ IInl nWl11bOl'1I nf thl! IIH~nplnllnn, 'I' , WllUHnl1olm, j)olb"('"n\~ Hook oOI11POIISI\\[lI'Y 1111\'"\11111\11'0 cllIl11l\l!OH 111 . tho 1II11\l1l1ll111' $ I 0,000, IIncl tl'ohlo dnmng~H, nl1d lln~IH 1111\1 n\l\ll'l1o)'H fooa' nl1c1Hllllh nlhlll' " 1'01101' 1111 Iho Cnlll'! I11n)' Ill'clPI', I" COUNTERClAIM COUNT f1HmHACH OF CON'I'R^~T "',; ('I " 62, ))0('0111111l1tH IlIo\ll'pol'nto 11)' 1'Ilflll'01100 Plll'llUl'nphH cilWlhl'ollgh I1l)y" ~oWII nbow 1111 II'Hollbl'th 1\111)', " 63, UpOI1 Il1fol'l11nllol1 1111\\ bolioI', Pllllnllff'H dlsolhHoi.I to flolllll\lnl bU)'ol'H or , " Iholl' ngOlltH dlll'l!lg Iho 101'111 01' Ihu A!lI'00I11C1I1 thlll l)ol'ol1c1l\lIls l'ol\lsccl 10 pn)' ml)':' OOllll11lsslol1 /i1l', nbuypr'H I\uollt, '/)of'olllll1l1ts 11'01'0 oOl1lno\od on SOVOI"" oool\HlolIS h)' lIgOllts fIll' buyol'H IIn\lllIdlol\lod Ihlll Pll\ll1\1ffhlld 1l01l1'o)'od 1I1lhol11 tho 1'0Pl'OH0l111\IIoII \lllll (Jul'ondllllls l'pf\ISlld 10 pny lIl1X,Ool11ll1lHsloll 10 II bl1Yol"s II!lUllt, 'PllIhlllf'f's l'Ofll'OSOllllltlol1 ,. .' , ;1, WlIH HIIRO 1I11d Iho dlscloaul'~ uf H\1oh llllhl'llllltloll WIIS 001111'111')' 10 \llnlntlff's, d\1IY I~ mlll'kot tho \lmporty Oil f)of'ond11l1ls' hoiuM, 1,1 'i. " " 'I " " " f ,", "" , 'IIUI'PPIlWIlI ,(Iwl'Illl1nnPI' 1'~~Pllll'n~I!I) \1\1 MIIWh2<<, 100<< lhl' Ihp >>nlp III' lIw 11n1f!PI'I)',whlph (lXplI'PIlllll SppIPIl1\1pI'3P, 190<<, .. ,. II 3, Tlw wl1lplnllllllll(lUP~ Ihlll \Iw COIlIl'llpI ,\VIIN' pxt\lllllllll \II1II1IMI)\1\lI' :lO, 190<<, lmlllhv IIUPIH'H IUIlPI'l1\PIIIIIIIlI1\lI'IOlllilllnwlnu Ilw PXpll'lllloll 01' Ilw C0l111'l1pl WII~ IlXIIlIlIIIlII 1I1I11I1hll'l)' 111l)'N Ihlll'\lnl\ol', 4, Tho 1l0I11plnII1II1I1QU\lN Ihnl Plnllllll'f1llll'odIlIlOII',hlf'l\'O>, IIII\1\1nnl(HIlII)'1l1,1I) Il1lhll PllliJmlnnlN nOIlI' \Iw Ilxpll'(\llol1 ol'lhu Conll'nlll, " , ." " '1'- " S, 'I'h\l 1l11ll1plnlnl nllpgll>>,thnl Ihu anlll (If \I1\l Prnlwl'l)' 10 Iho 1311)'1l1' QPIl\ll'l'uII " iil\\ll' th\l IlXph'lIllol1 oflh\lCol\lI'llIlI'N ngullt'>> f~\l PI'Ololl\ll)11 purloll, I' ' Tlw o0l11jllnll11 nlll1uo>> tlml PlllhHIf'f'H ropl'p>>unlll\lvo,I\IIOwon,11l'plillrollnn 6, , ',< ,. , 01'1'01' onbphlllf'l1f'lho 1311)'ul' lill' lIw P\'IlIIUn)' Ihllt I1r>>t IVlI>> pruNuntod 10 Iho Plllul1Ilnl1lH 111\01' , . . tho oxplmll\1l1of'thO CI1\ltl'llulllnd tho (lgum'>> luu I1I'oloullnl1 purlllll, 7, Thollol11plnllllllllogoH Ihl;lthu of'furH MI', O\VOIl proRol1toll tothu Pp/ondllnl>> " . 011 hplllIll'oftho 1311>'01' Wul'O 11011l000P\011 \1)' tho ()olundlll1t>>, ,I' ;1". , ,H, "Tho oompllllllll\lIog1,1>> 111II( ()olbl1dnlltN 1I0tlllllll htld nlllh IIl','llIlI'pOHoI\III)' .. , I'" Pl'evolltcllllllil elohlyolllho COI1HIIIl1l11l1l1on ill' II ~lIlp" tPllll)'OI' IIlItllllOOI' \lIP oxpll,jlllon oflhe ' IIgellt'H roo protoollOIl pOI'lod, <}, Tho oQmplllll1t IiIIlH to.>>tllto II ollllNO of' 1I011111l nil' hl'ollollof 001111'001 boolln>>o tho 00111plllllll HIIIH to II110go Ihllt Plllllllln'WIIN IIlldol' 1111)' IIgroulllonl, ollhol' OXPI'O>>H 01' ' , hnpllod, wllh tho ()0f'0I1clnI11H nt the tlmo tho Dulbl1clnl1tH nnd Iho Buyol' ngl'oocl 10 tho anlll of . tl1l,l Pl'oJ1ul't)', j" 10, Tho o01\1plnll1l rnllH 10 Htnlo n llnUHO l;'f' {lotlol1/hl' bl'unoh of' oOl1tl'llol boonl1Hll " " Ii" . It filllH to nllolJo (hnt tho Plnllltlf'f'jlol'lhl'll\u\1 nil)' HOl'I'160 Itl tho 1l1ll'llhllHO 0/' Iho PI'opor(y tll 2 " " I'"~ " ",. " " ',I , , 'i( " Ilwllll)'\l'" 1 " I' I' " II, Th~ \l\ll11plllhlllhll~ 10 Hlli\\lll \lIllIS\l 01' nllll\lll\ll'S\lPPOI'I nil)' \l11l1111 of hllll flllth Oil Ihll PIII'II\f 1)1'1~llIlnll\s Ihl' "l')' 11\1111)' Iwoii\ls~ thl' \ll1mpllIllIllIlI\l~;;s Ihlll Plllhillfl's nll\llll, B~lwlll OWPll, PI'\lS\lIlIPlltho Il\lYPI'I~ I1l's\ offol' nnpl' Ihl' p1\plmllolll1f'lI1\l n!lPIII '& \~p , ! ,. Pl'IlloPllon j19i'10,\1 \~lthn'il nlly IIpth1l1 \l1:QI1Illhll'l on IllI' pnl'l nfllw, P\lliJllllmlls, 12, TIll' pOl11plnlllt 1\111s 111 HIIIll'n \llllIS\lOI' lIothl\1I\1I' 111\hlS\ PIII'I\lhnWIlI IWOIIIIHP It ~Pl'kHlIs It~ l'ollwlI)' 'hiIlHI!l~a 1\11' II hl'\lIlPh 111'\llllllrn\lt \\I1d HIlla t(lI~lolltlf~ IIII' vlIl\l\ll1l'lIW aOI'Vlp\l pl'MI~I\l1l 11)',lIw PllIllIlIl'f, '13, Tlw P0l11p11l11l1 I'nlla 111 ~ill(\l n pn\lS\l of {JOtlon /\11' bl'\ln\lh 111' hnpll\lll ponlrnot " bpOIllISI',ll\lJI'1l wns no ~II!I'I'Pl11onl,hpl\mll tho Plnlllllff'nl111 till' Ppfu,llllnnls Ihl' Plnlnllffs sOI'vlpos on hol1l\Ifl11' ))o\'oI1\lill1l&, ',I 'I',. 1\ I, " \! i " , . 14, " 'l'lw ol1l11plnlllll\\lI& 10 allllp n lln\lSO or {\pllon Ihl' hl'OllPh of 11I1p1l011 oontnwt , , ;. ,I l;cPlI\l~O IIlpll' IYnano n!l1'9\lI11\llit h\ltw\l\lllth\l PlnlnlltTlllld tho lJolbnllnnll\J1' tho plI)'I11\lI\l or, " ",. fJ II 3% 'Pllll1l11l&~lon I'IW Plnlntll'rs S,OI'I'I\lUH Iln hohnll'nf Iho BII)'\lI' nllb\' Ih\l plll'olHIsP of thl' Proporl)' IIltllP prloo of $1 RS,OOO, t S,' Tho oo'mphllnl Allis \0 a,\IIIO n ollllSO Ill' notlonlbl' hl'onoh of oonll'l\ol boollllsl' ,. H '\10001111'1191 oxlstod hol\vcl'n l'ilnlnlllTl\Illlbofonclllnt whol1lho COnll'nol oX'lli'oll 011 Oolobol' " 31, \99R, 16, .Tho oOl11plnlnt flIod b)' Iho Pllllntlfrllllls 10Hlllto n onll80 of nOli on fur bl'ollPh of' oonij'lIot h,OOI\IISO tho nBonl Pl'otootlon purlml fbi' tho ?ontl'not ox)\h'od 011 NOl'ombor 30; .1998, . 17, Thoool11plnlnt fhllH to ~Into n OIIIlSO 01' 110110111'01' lmilloh of 001111'1101 bOOllllSIl It doos 1161 II II 0!l0 nil)' OOI1I'O)'lInOO 01' 101l1l1 tltlo 01' tho PI'Opol't~ 10 HIIJlJlOI'1 tho JlII)'I1Ill11t uf 1\ ' ,. j" ,. "1," J " , " , 'I,' "" " ,'.! ,\.', " ':0 I' " " '\ , " IIICI<II4HlIClrl dHM I, ICS'IWI'IC I'I{(WICIiHIONI\I,St' I'llIhllll'l' " "H, nOlllcirl' 111\ YNICH lll\ll I\A'I'llIAClCN 111\ YNICS, hIlHlllll\lI'lll\l1 \\,11'0, IMvl\lhlllIH , , " IIN '1'lIle ~()\lH'I' (lit' COMMON I'Wi\S . ' I <J\lMIIICIHd\NIl COIJN'I'Y, I1IcNNSYI,Vi\NIi\ I I I I NO. V!l,~H~1i I.. ," I OIVII, I\C'I'ION ,..... 1\'1' ',1\ W I , I I '" " ", " ,i' " It ULlJ: " " ANI> NO~\', 'lhlH _'t.~(IIIY 1l1'._..JI~ _~,1999, 1I1~lIlu Is IHHIIU\IIIPllll polvilUIIIl(H, . '. ,. .. " 1~1)llUl'l HnYlluH IIIUII\lIlliluoIlIlIIYIIUS,'III1IIIIH uPlIllsollo ShllW CIIIIHO wliy thu 'rullur rOll\lllHlo\lln Pllllntlrr's ,J, ." , .,'MI1II1111I11 Compo I SlillUI(IIIOl ho Ill'lllllUd, " ' d, ".d " Hlllo. rollil'iHlhlu wllhln .....P-~ dllYH 11r.~orvlcu 011 l)uful1lhllllH, l~ohcrl IlllynoHnml, Ki\thloUll ., IllIynos, " ' , I' "; ;: ;0 " '-" BY '1'111\ COllll'!': Ii " -' ._-t '/l2~ '~'~P-[l1)) AYLiJuL ,J. . 11-,4..99 , glK ., "1..' :1 i,j' " ", , r' d' , I, IH~I.Jl'I1'Hlq,l, HIMI, ICH'IWI'N ., l'H(WICHHIONI\I,H, I'lnlllll1'1' " I IN Tim IJmJH'1' Ill" COMMUN l'!',ICI\H I qIM/IICHI.I\NIl COIiN'I'Y, l'ICNNHY\,vi\NIi\ " I . I I , INO, lI!I,H~~ I I CIVIl,M~'I'ION..... "'I' I,/\W , It. I I I , " !. "H, ' IWIINH'I' II" YNICH IIIllI I\i\'I'III,lmN 111\ YNICS, hIlHh'I1IHII1IHII\'II'~1 IM~II(lnmH OlWlJlH ANP NOW III Is <IllY 01'....., I 1999!ilpon cplIsl\lol'lllhill 01' 1'11\11\111'1';' lIelp'I,)' ':." SV,II /luIII nstlll~ i'rlllosslollnl's M\JIIIlI1IIl COl11pull\llswurs In "lIe!TIl~lIlllrlus, Ii Is lIeruhy onlpru\111I1I1 I)uj'pndllllls, Hlllwl'! I.IIIYIIOSII,I,III,l\lIIl1luulI IIII~'"USI sllllllservu IIpon 1lllllllsull\Jr IlIp 1'111 Iill liT nl1swul's' 10 ,,'- "!'" I IIIIU!TOlllllllrles wlilliil _~_ (lIiys III' IlIls Onlul', , " Ills 1\lrllwr ol'durcd 111111 ()uIOII\lnnl~, I~llhurl Iln)'l1cs 1I11\II\II1hleen I "'YII~SI sllllll plly (1)'l'lillndir' " " q , " tllu 1111101111101' $ _ 1\11' nllorne)'s' lues 111 prep"l'h1llllld'pr(lSulltlll11 snl\1 MoHon, .' IIY TIlE COUIn'I' ,It ,," ',-, ....~..._..~._~.._-_.._.._._---_..._...-~--.._--._-_..------ ,," J, '1\ " I .j. " ,t.'- " " I " I I TI1III1IV, I1I1I'V~pI1IlHVS hlll'v IwvlI '11l'lll'lllvil l1yl fnYlws lolhv IIlIVri'I1!:\lllIlIi I'VIIIIVHIH " ." , ' " " , ,or Ilvlp-U-Svll. " ~t "I' " ' I' 'I. . '1IIIYlw's I,lIIH'I1\11 ohjvlJlpllll1l1l1r of Ihv 1 III 0 1'1'11>>11I Ill' IV;I, ~, IlnYIIPH '1'1111111'0 10 (11'01'1\111 I1I1HIIWS 11,1 Ow IIIIOI'I'O!lIlIOl'lv~, IH 'II 1'1011111011 11(lhv , I1vllnHyll'lInlnl{lIlvs of CII'II {11:ooqi!mv, I' .;, . ,,'1 , j , WIHiIW/loHI1, Ihp,PhillllllT, 'Iolp.t!.Solll{ollllJsIIIIP PI'I1I\JsslolIlIls, l'oSpVlJlI\III~JI)(IIW~IH ., " 'ihls Ilolllll'lIhl\1 COIII'I W OIlI~'1' 1111 ol'llul' 1J0lllPolllnll POl'ondlllllH, HolwrI' fllll'l1Vs (wi KlIlhlpvn . '.... t ,- j. IIIIYlw<lo pl'lll'ldo IInSIWl's Illll\li 111lolTollllll1l'loH Iwllo 1'\11'11101' IIII'llI'd 010 PlllhnllT Iho O,~lHls of, PI'OpIlI'1I1!llllld'pI'IJSOlllln!:\lhls IIJP,III11110 cOl11pvl. 'I, .'- ; I/: '", l~ospooll'lIl1y SlIbl11ll1cd, " " ., ,I, " ;," ,,' IUii\ClIm \~ ADLBI~, p,C' 'ai') ," , , ' 141~lii~' E1I1j~I'~..-"---'-_."-'---=--- "11, J.D, No, 60944 ThonlllHO, Wllllllll1S PII, l. D, No, 07987 2:1~ I MIII'kot Sll'uVI ,CIIIllP 11111, "A 17011 " ,(7\7) 7(j~'1~8~ Mol'lloys lill' 1,1,111111111'1' I, " f)IIIV: PGIllhul',29, 1999 \1 ,. I .,.;' " 'j- " ,. 0, '1 ..2.. ",I' " .-, " Iii " :, I!l(hlblt A " '..l ,I'" q,,", I"~, '.-,' 1 :,,,,,11' jtJ 1"'\ ,. I, " " " " " ",. " " " ,. i.' 1\" I 't ii' " I'; .' ,; " ,. " " 1:, " d' ',r' .. !; " .I' " " .f " " " " Ii " .J' " "I; ;d, " " , , II' .. " ,. " " " , 'I " ,. " " " " l! " (i .. ;., ';i Ii' !; " j. , " it;; I, ,;1 il i.Ii '" H Ii " " " " " " I" " I, .. " " ,I " ,I' " " , " ,-' I' " II, PI!I'I,NIT,ION:l. "ldpnllf\,~lt wlwn \Ispd In rpspo,-! of 0 p(mon/l11uMS 1~ ~lolu 11101 pClrsnn'~ non% ridd,'uss, < " ' ,. ," I luluphonu 11I111111Ul't)O\1 Ohlsslfh:I\llol1 1"'d"SII~ll 011101' In(orl11o\lol1 os wOllld unllblul'llIln\1ff 1<,1 looo\u\llIl , pllr~ol1, Inl\lfvl!lw 1)ln1. or hqr,.or S\lrVO II sul1poulln \IP911 hll11llr Iwr, Whunwod 111 ruspuol of n ..." " . , ~IOC\I;'1Pnl, Ihudnlu of l\sl11l1llll1l1 or oXI,10\lllol1,' Ihu Idon\l\y of Ihu purson 01' porsol1s who 1110\10 01' . .. " "\lXllC\lloilllt und \1111 purllc:ull1l' pml, purilurnph, or olhur S\lbdlvlslOI1 Ihqru of which Is pnrllcl1lnr!y , , ' l:olllvUnl Hl Iho ,CI\IC1S\1PI1J ulse) sll1lo 111<1 plnr.u wlwrullls \IIlPII\lll\ldullllfy thu pl1l'IiOl1 111 WhClSUCllslody , 'llIl1i,y bo fOllnel, wllh sllC;h ~poclnr.l\y uS wllll)l1l1blu I1luln\1f( 10 oblul111hu doC\1I110111 \hr~.\luh IhullSP " qf II s\lbpopnu, Whul1 \Isud In ruspue! o( u cOl11n1\lnlc:ullol1, ,II In\ll1I1S 10 lclunllfy lho pnrllus \0. tho " ' !I ' " " conll11\lI1lcOllpnlhI!I11101111S u( c0I11111\1I1IcOllpn, IInd Ihu dulo. und 111110 Ihoreof," ',,' " "rcir~pn"lnUI1I1S I1ny'nll\lIrnl or)\Il'ldlcrilllursOn, llrO\Jp Il( parsons, or IIssocl"llol1, "CQlnm\lnlou\lon" muons uny, trl1l1'SI11lsslon or oxchl1nllO of Informl\llon or,"cii1l1Inll bolwpon " " " 'j' \Wo or moru pursons 111 IIny (()rl1l, '''''POC\ll11on!:' monn5 nny wrlllnu, rocordlnu or olho'l mnlorlol 5ul;51l1noo hovlnl\ on 1\ n ' ropr~~onhlliol1 o(lllllllU 1I1lcll'I11l1llol1, whulhur 111 tho (orm of mnUl1ullc Impuhills, pl'lnllnlJ, 0'1' III\yolhur . "". "" ,,":" ,.. " ,> . '; mudl\lIn Ili:whlcl1lnformnllon 1n11ybo prU~\lrvml. I "You" shnll bn dool11od 10 monn IInd rofu!' 10 lho Dofof\tlnnts, I~obort I-\nYl1os nnd/or Knll1loon " .., .. . ." I" " I I-\lIyn~s, il!" .\, " , " ":',2" .... " " " II" :" III, SPI!CIA~.INSTIWCTION1i, 1, 'I( YlllI till I1nl nmwor nil lillllrl'llunlnlY, In wliqlll or Il1pnrl, Illl(lil\I6U or n (:lnll11 (H. prlv\loUll, ~i;1 (qrlh IIHl prlvi1clIlll cllnll11ucI, Iclonllry 111(1(11(;16 \lpOI1 which YOII rlllylCl 6\IPpprl i1w (;1111111 Ii " ' llr prlvllouoIl\l1111dclnllry 1111 dpCl!l11U1116 (or which KIICIl prlviloUl1lli CJlllll11llcl, In pnrllqllnr, Ir YOClro(\ISo .' lp Irlllnl1ry 0 QPlllllHll1lcnl,lnn bocnllao pr 0 ~loll11 o( 1110 ollCHl1uy/r.llonl prlvllllllo, IclonllrYlho apllokor or " ,. " I1\l\hor or llw1IoIl1l1l\lIil\1l1\ICll1lho c:npncl1Y In which Ihll Si)\lnl,or or IHllhor wns nCIIIll\whlll111llllWln i'llill CPI11111lllilcnllpI11 11'1l rnalplonlo( Iho cOI11IlHII1,lclllhJl1,IlIlY.ljOl'liClIlS prllslll1('whonlho (Joll1l11l1nlcn\lon w~s mOllo, ond Iho s((blllet or loplels c116c\lsaod .Inlho cOI11I11\II1Ir.nllon, ~ i UnlosK ollwrwlslIspclc!(Ioli, ollchlnlolTounlllry rOCjlllros n CIJI1tllllllnu nl1SWOr, ~nch . . .. sopnxnlo pnrl or ooch ,IlllulTolllllory shnll bn snplHnlllly nnswcHllcl, 3, .. A'I'onll with Iho nllswor 10 ollch I1CII11borod 111\IHlOllnlory" Iclon\l(y onellPorKon who ,,,J! ,I I pnrllclpnlod lil or sllpplllld hlfotl11n,I,lon wllh roapecl to Iho I,lreporn\lon or Iho rosp0l1S0 to allGh II\lorrol\nlory, sllllclrylll!l wholllClr on.Gh or 6\ldl porsona slIppllod rf!lllV\\nl, InflHl11nllon, pnrllr.lpolod In " ,1119 propnrnllpn of Iho I'ClsponSU, or bolh, I( II~o rq~pqnso 10 nny Inlnrrollil\cjty eonlnlns Inron11nllim , ' ", a\lppllod by I11Clr~ Ihlln 0110 Iloracll1, apocl(Y Ihopmllcllhlrlnrorl11nllol1 s\lppllocl by oneh s\IC,:h 'l?qr~On, .. ,,'S\O\O wholhor 11O/6ho hod f1!'at,l\ol1clln(orl11nllol1 il6 \olho I11I,tlor~ conlnlnoclll1yo\ll'l'nawors, ilnd Ir ~o, Iho 111""\ nil I' 11), which ho, ncqlllrod ~\Idh In(orl11nllol1, or If nClI, \lio,bnsl~ (01' hla pOrllclpn\lol1 or', Involvol11lll1l, I' II, ^~ spll\Jlflod by IIlCll'onn6ylvnnln l~lIlo~ o( Clvlll'rocilclllro, YO\I nl'll' rUqlllro~IKOn6(1)nbly i~ S'ilPIJlmllll1ll ~lI' nl~1ond YOllr ro~p~l1soa 10 thoao.lnlolTollnIClI:ioB Ilusod lIpOI1 nl1Y unci nll.ln(on11o(lol1' 'i, oblnl1\llcluftllr flllnB slIch I'OBIlCll1aoa, :,! " ...3- " ';~ ", \\ i , 'I I I I " I',"' , ' IV,~I!I!CIAI.INSTIWCl'IO"1 AS TO OIW" COMMl}NICATIOI-l!i ANlL..YYI~ITTI:N . COMMUNICATIONH .. 1,.' WII\1 I'ofipuclln m'Y II1\nrrpuoll1fY 111 which rufurol1~o I~ 1110dUIO lhl~ spocll\III1~If\lcll()l1, ,I' ;,;' sill fQr\\1wllh rUl!nrd 10 pnr.h prol O\ll11l11\ll1lcnllol1.\hu foll.owll1111 " A,' Th~ll1nl1lal cnmpol1y lll' 011101' offlllnllol1, IlIlu ol'.p\IHlrlclol1l1fyIl1Il fOlllllru of'lhu I' , ' Il1dlvl~I\1I\1 whn l1\udo Il\11llrnl cOI1lI11\ll1lcllllol1, , i' o. Il, .Rl0lu ,1I1\llHiI1111(~) of \llwh I I1Cllv I IIlIll I In whol11 i'llth.OIiII cnl1111HII11clil1ol1 WilS l11l\dol.ll1cludll1U HICh dl1~crlpllol1 of IhoBo Il1dlvld~mls os In 11l1nblu 1'11111111((\0 Iclol1l1fy Ih~sull1dlvlcllli\l~ . , ' " il~ 1011\\111' offlllllllol1, IlIlu PI' rospnl1slhllllY, c, 51nlpl11O clnlll IIpol1Whlch SIII:\1 ornl COl1\11111111Cilllnl1 wns n111(111! " p, .... 510la 11111 plo~o whom such ornl, COl11l1Hll1lcnllol1 WIlS I11nclu, , ft, 51010 tho I1llma nl1d Iclul1llf1cnllol1 ofonch Il1dlvlCl\lal who hunrd Iho ami C0I11111\ll1lcnllol1lr'dlffl1l'0I1I or 111"n~ld1l1ol1 \0 Iho~u Il1dlvld\1I1ls 10 wl,ol1\ s\ld; ornl r.ol1\l1llll1lcnllol1 WOs ,I l11udo, , H. . Slnll). 11\ dolOIl lhu 1111\\lrU of Iho words COI1\I11\1I1Icu\l1\1 d\lrll111 s'llch ornl " o I - " 0 " " . C0I\1I11,\1I111:l1lh1l\ 1'(11)011111111 IhUiiCII!i\1 Words \Isud 10 lho oXlol1t posslbln I1I1d, whllll 11\11 'possl~llll . pnl'llphrnsll1l1lhosll words.. " 0, Slnlo If I1I1Y IndividUal 10 whol11 sllch otlll COl1\l1\lll1lCllllol1 wns I11l1do, I'nada nl1Y " slniol\1ul1tllll1 ro~pPl1llolo nnltlcOl\1l11l1nlcnllol1, Ilnd If nO, Iclolltlfy nlich ruspol1SUS In slIfflclol1t dull\1I by q\loill1U Iho prl1l:isll words \IRllCl or by olhllrw\~u phrilsll1l1 Ih050 \vllrclR. .. , , . 1-I,Stnlu If Sllld oml COI\11l1\1I\lcn\loI1(s) \Vns/woru nvnr l11uil\orlnll~cd 111 My I . ' dOC\ll1lUl\l 01' IInl forlh n copy of Sl1n\o, , ;"" " ;I" ..~- " '. ' 7, " " " " I, " II, '" .. ./.' ,I ), ...... '1 " AI Pnrnllfnph no l1[Yl1\ir'AI1RW\lr wllh l~nW MlIllbr IIl1dCOlII'\lIl'clllll1"YIl\III\lIllI, 111 PlH\"Wlwl1 :', Plllli111H \111111111 p\1[\1I1\II\I1\1I 10 s\111\111111011 III1Pwlnu p( Iho 111'01lllr\y 10 \JIIYIII.', Plnll111fffnhifJly rOprQlllll1lod lho\ 1111i !lIlYPf wosNs \:111111\," With I'osp\lql \0 1\1II1IIVlIrn\(ll1l, 1\11I\lIlhll foll.\1wll1l1l " " II, wilt' yu\u:1111111 11111\111 11\11 [nl'lIl\n\I\II"\iI\(Jl11111\11, \l, who YIlII oIn I 111 Iho 1111\ III 11'11 11 \ WI\II1\1II'IlI \(Jjlll1c1 0, IIH111pulllflc \11I111I1I1CI1lI1w l'IlII clillll1 Iho 1I\I\\lIll1l1l11 1'1'11111111\\10, ,." " . 6NHWIII~1 " ' ", " " ,.!j ", " ", ,Ii " 'j, , A'III\rIII\I\lph llJ lIfYlnll' Al1l1worwllh NllwMllll11r \11\[1 Cnlllll11i'o\llll11, ynllllll\lo II1pUrlll1\111' pm( " Ih\1I"IIHl Plnlllll!!'1I clll1thld Olllllllllll\llll wlllfllll11ll1rUprllllol1li1l1l1ll of 111i1lorlill fnolll nl1d cmllllld' . tho PUflll1dlll1\1I11l Il10ur c1ll1n'nlloll hI lil1 nl11 Oll 11 \ or IIpproxl11111\(Jly $10,000,11 "Wllluospncl III Ihlll nVOI'1110111, sll\l(l Iho 111l1110(S) of lho Imllvldllollllhnl npprl1XII1111lotl YOllr chil11111l0S III $10,000 ".' nl1c1 provldlllll1l111I11I~l1llol1 of Ihll dnmi\llll11 YOll c1nll11, '.. '.' , " " " 6NHWIiI~1 '.. ,"~ '1 (I! " ,,' .. " " ,. 'i Ii if "':9'" !,;-., " ""'; " .\' "".'" " " " " (', I;, ,,, ;'1 " " " '('I ','" H " " ,r, L ';" I I , !L i. I " d' ii II !I "i'" <;" " 'I ".\l;'!I~.".._, ".'.:,,!',', " ''''''''.,'."' " " t I ~ t II ,iI " II~AQPn ~ API,PII, 'I',CI ATTOnNPV~ AT ~AW ~~~1 MAnK~T ~TI\PPT CAMP III~I" i'A 17011.4Q42 '17171703'13~3 " ii. ':NDV (] al~l~][) (P 'II 1 ,~;'i" ; " ,t ;,i i - ,',. "-'.. I ;.. i ~ .- ~ .-Ii I.~' "., j ! i,'. .'.0' ,,,.-_......!,_ " " " 'I' "" 'I " " I'" b I " I, I ',', " i! " " 'j, ,. ' " I' "). 1> "I' I' " ,,, '" \\,-' " ,I' ;,1 " ';, " 'I .. 'I '! '" " I;' " " Ii ,\; It " '" H " ,_oj, " 'I, 'j, Exhibit a I, I' " " jj, " I\,' " {, /, )i .f; It " " , " .1, .. " 'i H':' "" "... '" " " I,' ,,', ",p ~fi) I. I' " ,,, ", 'q, i' " " " I ~ " H " " " 'i, " " I' 'i' I" 'il" I' " {I, I",' J!, II " ," " '1" Ii, Ii ,,' , ,< ./' ,\) " H " " "I, " ! I, f 1~i:t\q:I~& API.HR, PC 1\'IT(lIl~lliYIl ^NP C:P\JNlliil,OI\S ^T I,^W 1111 M~II~I1' mITT C~~II' 11M, i'l'NNSYiV^"ll~ 111111I~('~1 1II,1Id":III:1 H11rM 1II1I:iII,I:llir, WIIISI1I'I111"III',Allh',I'll,f1l1l1 . !, i ml'OIlPllI! A,AI1I,m', PAVIP W, 1\IAI1II1 I,IN\JS I:, !'''NWI,I:' 1l'IIIIA IlI:NIS'II~ CAN1(l11 'AI'" "1111I1111'1111111,(;, 11,11 "'AlII' """11111'\ ,111 (lhll1l1ll1 OOlllho\, Ill, I PPO , KI'NNi,.'T11 W, \[:1' TIIOMAfp, WMIAMS SIJSAN Ii, ~ONrAlI\ ' MIl' A, McCONAIIY "\'- 1\111101'1 p, l'III)'II\lH, IIsll\\ll'V 1<1111110011 I'IIIYIIOH 171 ,~Il\lill Flllrl1ul\11l1'Ivv '" Plll'~l', Pl\lOOol " Iml Holp.U.Solll~ulll 1\1I1i1l0 ProfoslIllllIlIls v, l'~nYlloll, Pou~o\N(,I, Illlr8~' POIII' Mi', 1111\1 ~II'H,IIII>iIWSI d' , -, ,. -, I AH YO\I ~lIuW, YO!I IWru Mvu,I'Wllh \1ll1lnllff'1l11l10ft(11l1l10rlos Oil or nho\il Suploll1h~r 7,IIlPO, " To \11110, \YU IIl1vvrvuolvoll 1111 II llil\YUI'H' 1\111luRU lIlIUI'I'\ Olllol'los. Ulldor Iho PolIlIllylVlIlll1I 1\\llos (,If civil' 1\1'110011l1l'UIII1HIWI'H III ,lho\llflOllVUI')' 1'0qlloSlil 111',0 (1110 wllllllllhlrlY(~O) (11IYs (If I'o(llllp\pf 1110 1'0q\lost, PIOIIR~ \10 IIdvlilOl1 11111111' IIIIHIWI'H IOlllu llllu\,I'OUlIlorloR lI\'o'lloll'oooIVol\ wllllln Ion (10) dllya of tills 101101', llVlllltllVu no ultolw \lOllo PIII'illlu II IlW\loll 10 oompol. I WO\IIII 1I0po 111111 \vo oOllld IlVollllllo 1I110QSRIIY 01' II 1lllllluIlIII UIlIlllwl, Ii', '11\1\1'0\'01'; 11'0111'0 l'ul'oolllU l1Io,sllul1 II n1olltll1, \\'0' will bO'~09kIIlU rQoovot~ (II' 1I1InI'IIUYX' l'oulIlIlIII UlIslS 1,1,1 1\I'UI\lII'I1I[\ ,lIl1d pruilolllllllllllu 11101101\, ' I' " " 'TOW/IIII' (' OUI !:id OI\'U1\H, Ilulp.IJ'Nulllh'IIII!HIIIIU i'l'nl'oilsluIIIIIR " " " " I' "I; "I' . , , ' , . I- CI"il(II'd ~\-~'~ilViT1ii;rsr;,jT{,;ii,Tlly'ih~' .N1I1I1I!1I" 111111111 IIf 'h!111 ^dv'",m:y, ^ l'iJhli~ylvnlllil Sl'prol1ll1 emlll At<*llllll1ti'^lIuncy" i I .j' i ,I I I I. " .., ~J \1I '.. ' , - 1;,: t:" ("J (11 t') . t:~'" t.,:.l! .li ,._-, ( ", 1..( ;~::!' .'....1,' !'f .' i f,'\", (1" nl i I,'} ,,/;', ('-:.' If 11._' .0" !-' 'j;' 1 -, /.', ~.,' 1ft. ,;'; I!i C:1l :.;) t:}l " \.) " "! d' , . " "'I I' Jj. 1,1 I' 1', " '1 , , , " 'I I , " , ,-,. I' " " \I" '/; , ;, " .. " " " " " " " I', " "j I " " " " " ~ i .. " " H I, .. , , " " 'I' \. " ".1 " i> .. il ..'" (, 'I' ii 1\ 1/' " ,,' ',I " " i.'; Ii " " " " H " I;. I' " " " , , ii' " \', " " ,,,5,' I,ll1Ip.IJ.SplIll1lrlldIIQld HilYl105,.lll Jilffl\lYI:lIlbl1illd, il prpspoll\lVli p"rcIHl5l1r, nil or' " nbmll NllVI;I'nl)ilr7~, 10\lIl, In ,1I'11\I1l11h11 I'lilYl1os \Ilthlli1loIY~ohlll\ll prnporlY PI1 or nl1o\1I POFPlllbl,r 10\>1\, "-" '" r1, Mr, l-I\lbl>llI'<I, \11\1 prospllcllvll pUl:dlilHor, COlllill:llld Holp.lJ.SolI il5 iI 1'051111 nf Iho 'n<l,vorlI511IlWIl15 nl1<1l1lilrkll\lllll ofl-llllp.U.solI. " 7," Hlllp.U'SllllsI1\IWll<l Mr, I-IlIbbmd.IIl\ll-lilYl1llS' hOI1).lllll1 NnV\lll1bor 22, 1 \lOll, Il, '1'lolp.U,sllllll1lllnlll<l illl1l01lilllnllN wllh thll 1111hnilllllnWllr 011 hlll1i\lf of dill I'lilYI111a (PI' " Ihll Hnlllllf tho /-InYl1lla' prllporlY, " , O,I'lo,llhlJ.SlllI fllllnwp<lllp wllh Mr, l'l\lbllnr<l ,~1I1 NI1Ylll11bor 24, 1 \l\lO, illld ill1aworod '1l1q~lIol1a iHHI ilrrill1ll\ld II aoconel .1"llvll1l\ of thol-lilYI105' hOl11ool1 Noyoll111llr 2\l, 1 \>\lll, 10, lviI', I:d QWOIl of 1-t'(Jlp.IJ.sollcllllinclmll\lo I:lnyno~ol1 NOVllll1bor30, 1\>0/1, i1l1d , 1i1\lIcnlil(llhil\,ho Wila lloli)!lln'lI'rito il conlrncl for Mr. /-Il1blJnr<llo pllrcliilsollmlr IlPll1o, " _. I, , '" ' , 11," on Docoll1llor 2, 1 DDO, "lolp'U,Sollll111t wllh ,Mr, I-IlIbbnrd nnd p!,opilrll<ll-llIblwd's ,. ... , wrllloll pllrchnso offill' nn<llll11l1l1cllnloly c~nlnclocllho HilYllllS, Thll,wrlllol1 Pllrchnso offor WilS " ,,'... ,. " " $1Il0,OOO, 12, "'rho l-I<lYl1osll1uclo n collilloroffor'ln tho iHll11 II 11 I of $1.07,000, 13, :, l-Iolp.u.solI cOllvoyod Ihol-lnYlllls co\llllorofforn( $1117,00010 Mr. H\lbbllr<lto which Mr, I-Illbbnrdlllilclll i\IlOthor cOlllltlllO(fllr 1Il1l\ll iH1l01lllt of $104,000 14, Dospllo Ihu oxplrnlloll of Iho IIslh'll illlroOll1l11lt, HilYl10s kilOII' o( Holp.u.solI's , ' COllllllllll111 offorlslo SOCllro n pllrchilsClr fill' tlwpropOrly illl,d know thnt Ilullutlilllolls 11'010 1I11c1ol' WilY wllh tho \llllmulo buyul'on bohul( of tho HilY'IlOS, ,15, Holp.U.SolI'~ o(follslln Imhill( o( Hnynos wllro tho o((ucllvo procurlnll CilIIS!! o( tho sillll bO\Wulln HUYllllS <1IHI tho ulllmuto bllYl1I', 16, Ills bullovocl i1l1d, tholl1(oro, nvolTod Ihul tho II II I milto pllrdlil50 pllcl1whlch WilS Mrcmd . . Oil bIJlwo!!lll-lnyno~ ulld tho bUY111 \Vi\S $1 U5,OOO, . " .4~ ..p i, ,: ',. , " l!llhlbltA I,. " "," '1 .'.' 'I"',"" " '1\ II' "~I\"~ ((J " " I" " " I' .,' 'lI " " 01' " "i,., l' 'j Ij, " " I' " " it b " " I" 1/ (j " If \'1; f! H" d IL" " ,/ " " \ ,;' . 1''' ,!' " ,,' II " " ,/ ", .1' " " " " " " 11 " L' , Ii )'1' I' " :1, I' ,. 'j. I' t, II I:" " " p" " " " ',. I, " if " " ", Ii "d '" Ii " , ,I, " I'" jf' PIt\l'PIl.11II l)llt r.~t' 1I~1"'\I-~lll1 Ullft 1 't~tn\,I' \l ?:tll Pl.'.'!! I' .\11 '. 'I ~;1iI1'.l!aIYf, "Imn' TO ~~".mlll!>;~mtnnlll:~^f,l' 1)1' 'm"I,I\~T^TI': .. 1'\'.11 fOl~1 'H.\"o\'~illl '0. '~Yp'!J.'~'U(~",~~~~~~.. ~~Wl!:'I:~!~Yl'hl..~!!~~~~~I' AIIOlllll,,,.r ~~^,.lllhlil ~~_'f~~,~ ~'~i~~m~~~~~~,-~J ' '.\''''I''~'l'IlI'';'I~~, .-.... , I. \1l1~i'1I11' ,IGI/'/ICJP , """H\1 ""'!!" -J}.t'i>, (.iJ,f:1I-!f7fl?o "."...(l.-im/.~.ItI'M::..__"" , , "u~t\'~11I11 -,/l~IV'.1.?.f'~ "(f ,L,_.",_,_,_.__.___..", " , I. tl\\"'~\jl" ANlllllll. \Jl' r ,"10'1\ Ihll'II\'II\'tl~, \1It11! un I~l h~II'ill'ltl'lfll "oJ ,\I"II'lllll~lf 111 III II! lll.J'1I111 f'~tljlt 'II \'UlII,1 ' '"'' \'9P->PI?I:.. l\~~~I'lti.-- 1 II 1"'6..~i.l?.l'l!!L", III "k.!p.lf1..:fr'J)~::i."f.I.l 11I'\1 ~A'11~ ~.Jll~~-d,.Ll:{llf,lNf:!~ I II W.illjll,!J..m.J"_,,, 'II , Il, .i';~I," Q((r,~' '''''1 ,,,,,,,_,_-,,__,_, Ill, __~,..,,'"'' ,::7.lf{~'I'liill{'IH \nH~ ~HH Itll' ~HII~' \,, __,_, ,., ~'______'___,_,~,_", J. I'f.lt~Il'l~1 "~ "If !IIIIlI! 1I"t.'_',n, "Illn',. \'I."~f\~\I"~ljl'l ,uJI ,If( 'I t"I~U\ (",.I(hl,nt 1~1',I'HII A n,II". IInll II:' "11111\\ I"I\~'\\"I.'I ii'I"I>'I':J t"""I"I' nrl '~IHO ,t1l9 'lIt~'fit' ""1" 111''''1'0 U 1I11~1 tll "hili. I\~I, I, 'l~ , l.~ 1"\I""li. ",.,1, ,~>II,,'''' ".".ll"..<" 'II "'.\ "I t f II WIlIII?I: HIIM, Ill. III "II HdlN 11""1'1, It 1 \, I~I''''I'' 111\1'... ""'*1', \'~lrl..\. h' 1\1\/:\1\' ",,\u\ "j ~'lCI\. 11/, ,hilI<" '.-""'" ,"",I-It. ..1'.' """-"1, 1-1'1'1 I tldl'l, llllltrl "~l, V'Hf') 1I,'h"., II, I~UI ., Itfl, 11'111" 11'1.1 ,.rv,~ II.n 'f'\, t~"~N'r, I ,M nil f.~, 1'1' Ill'ljl_lli. "1'1' t..- "I~I.\'\ ,1'llh, II ,'11. hI 't" 'H.II'1 \[1 \hlll'l~ """l'll'~ 1I,\I~,tld 11I1l.IIH I' \Vllh,U I'll", f1'lt~ "I I", ~I",,, If" '\I~Ijl ~l'f)l II,.,! Ii 111'1 'If II 1~\ \'\~Il' I'l j~l' ~,I~llt1'!t I '1",jlll liI\1 <Jilt "I 11111 il.lllt,j""I' ,"1 'l"'l'."'j """11 " I' ''''H\ IYllJ 111''''41\, 1'\ 1"1'1'1111 fill"" "I \1"II't!!! ~'. ,11'lll.. ~"'j ~f411111'\ "11111\1.1\1 ~/lllJ 1,1""'1 P!"l 'I' 11,1' .,1,., .I~ _I~\" f~ 1'1. .n 1"ll~ .!\j~ ,1,"'1""'/1 1~I.ll1.!.:!J"\' 41)11 ~ Y'A ^ tU.~~!~'I'" '~: ;,,,1. \""~I"t 't"", , .'l.\ It "hl~,~\. ~~~ I' o "'IIYHI ':1,"\ jl~ 'PPllII""1 "ii'''''' '\ II'lIfP l~m.';I':'1 ~-W-l~-I-(~lL,,~\~~ll, fi'f \'1"':"/1- ,..::,____..,..,... ~~.;;""I"II.\ _b~a.Il1??I~ COP-fA(""':) I, ~~ ~ t, lMNlrPl TIt"\., 1"\MI~\I~"I,'lllt~llltllll'.,ln~4HO~1 ~tllll I~,II hI I" \ql"'~'1!I /Ill tr 4fN 1"11'11111111, M,VlIl/.lI.lIIUI' " III;, Iff fI,e'I'II.' 1,'1,11 Itl ~'ltlt II'HII HilI. '1'1f\1 /Ij~\"f'1 IU~ \fIl~' -..~-. , i ~' t. DI.,~ql.w, ~flI~ 1~1'\I hI r..llb 'l'I1\IUruf1joJ_h'(lf1 mytl~1l ~1'11"1 HJIIII f~~I.'lttr, .IIIIt,Hor, lu". illl I"~ 'l'Ilh' '. '111""'1 I "I I,b , 1''''1' II.I~'''' i,\<"jY 11." l"yhl~I Ill' I\nl (II tll ,,1""11'1101 IW, r'.'1HII'f 1111"1111'( 1,1' It 1111't1 ~tl f1mf _ \ ~ 1\1 '~>'I~~II,I'I" 1'1\'111'1' , 1,\t,I,II-lllt"IIIU"'WII ,'1,1 " ~ ~,~1".~1~..\,J\11~11 J()" I'N.. l', ~~Il~l'Ii "..\'11 UNo 'I u",lojWj'h'"li II111 ~'j'1 . "'n III oll,u. r .~I ~k,' - n fll_lIlflltl 'Il~ ~1~~lrtt ~IW.t ~"'''_ l. \'II ~!lt I, "Il'~r'llt".t ~"'"' "'" \1"1' "1r.'~llIllrlt,I\'t "1111' ':0"11111''''\11'1\1''1'1 ",ltll 1'0'11'111""'" " ,.., '"" '"'''',,'''' "~ fti'tT~{ U~~:dl :~I"II/"'\1 ~ II n l'l<jr.~' 111111, ll. tlt,.\I,IMt~l'tflM "'NV Ur,~11,11~'l/'.'f H.l,\leU' ,(I~." ~"" rlllll"(Jkv\t11~', U ,.'tVIOllllIO \m...c_n~"lfT'1If UI I U. "'''\lhlII11''1111I1'' ~ 1111 l\I'f 11 1'\ Itl '11111111 I '\1'It"'IHI~ 11\1111I lIuq( ~II ~11 ~/II"\ I II ~ 11'1l \1'111;1'1 '" It 't'\'I' '" 1{l!1(JlIA'lO~~ n""'lw 11lf ...,atil Mtllllfl 'IHH ~ flf.-'ulP1llCllill'1\ltII ~llJl IIHll,l~ HUll \ICAMt,\I'I(ltt'(./'lrlfl'4U(11I"JJ1H ~1l'/~II"'ht~H4"U~IIHk~'lit"d~,1'4M"'\~I(l1 ' "ltt U lItll ~"l\ I'. III1IHI..11I'W Itlll I'" I'll' tmlr~N""ll/1N ntrtHfll tilt 41J11/T Will, U \()~t1tml\'~ !lilt' 41 ~ ~ "(I I "t41\'lIiA~ '( (A ,11I41tll Ill.', 111.1.1\ lit "I IlIj" II' 11"1'iIll{llt 1111 I ~"j r\lltH'~ lfl "1" H' "H hlUU1t{1 'JI(.iW,uI(ltfl.\'\ ~ l;/.~ Inll"tltl'I~~~J)1 ~11'l'fnr.~,~(.Y.lf.\~C.l\,. 1; I) q g 111~lllj~1'l 4111 " 111110\ ~m[n"., ,., :?i;> I~ .. , "',t..... II' ..~41-' ~((~. .t~ltl~" ItllflU~ lt~ I"/Iil "flll\" '1'11111'>11'1''''11'1110.1 f" 1"/1/11"1' 1"llIj .1"/ 't(o...II..., t,1 ,,'f', ~_OJ1J~f? 't.. ~ " Pl)n1Jl~lllt'll rt\Il\I,t_ t. ~11't'.ttI'I IWII~'I~I ""Iell IIII'\l~I"'I"Y"f'\lI, --..~ I, hI '14'1 ~ ~ "111 I~I~ II '1"111 .~l "Ill II" 1.:::. ~ 1'" 111'1\ "h'I"flt' Itl,fl~l, I~I Iltlf,' '~ll Wilt! IUll'1 ~1"1l "'1111(11 '''1~~ Ij\ "'iill, ~\. 1',41/1.''11'"'' Tl:Mtlln\vllldlf'IIU ~ AttAl'I l'h"\~M l'IUfilh. '" I~''''I\'J '''111'' "IIyIII'II'1 ""II' _",'il., iI,' I"".~"'I rId "'" ~t;~l III! I~' III, "I I" ."l~ "II"I"'III~"HI t"I'flllr .1\1 'I. MI .,"1 lilt 1c.4 l~' HII\lIi\IIII'II~ 1,-1 Ihe I" I'h"~lt', ..,\t'"H'III~ 'I.t "I .,.1. "1,,,",,1 ." dl," II"/I"t 'fINr." f,,' Illt"'I ,,'II \ ~ h,Nt ~N"1 '111"1\111'111, tI' III' tI'l 1~~1 tll(t VII 111I1 Iv IN ~ llilllllll' tIIfl, . . ". t 'IT 'IJIIIII'l \I ~ I ,11I1~ll~~'!I' ~I'll' ~,."IIi.1 "Irlll" II It, II I fI "1 I' III '" I Nl t', 'I It'I IlUlI ~11'\ \'AIIII'I1I~fI4 111 '1111"1 t\ 11,1 I'.llIill "11/101 "1111. l'~ ' \ \1'/1\'-' ll/m IAlI or ~C~tilY" OJ .'11 n~nl l~ dltl'IlI'Jh A",.., .'III~ItIII_II',IIII""II~'.. "I '" ~I If','I'I'" rl~N.t. .1 lint 1"I'J,III1~I\IIN', ." ~Ili "'ll' Ib.11I \Ill 01'1111I11101 .1 t\1~II'h4 ~I'~i lllllim ,I' 'f'" "11'1. I. lVIII' I II V 1111 II I 'I' YdlmlWI V ;1\ IHI.l.t.I~W/J TIID ~ttlt~, ~Illc' ' "'11[41 "11M IN "M 1"1 Utili ,~I till.' Unll IN' .." It'l A'lnl "I'jrl 1\l1~ It."""11911 ;1/\ !HI HI" IlffJftl1 h,tl IUfr, 'oolll,n\ ','lll".!II ."'11,,,, '1\'1'1111.'" I'll '1~III'f '/" il\ill'Nllf H'UI.ltH fI/.ll<j fb 10 1'11'1 u f ~11"'lh II to14 91 "1')I'fl..l In "'I,>, ," 'II 1"'II'II"""~ II' _I,."'. ~I"'" ""II~ll' "'It"I." ,,,1'11 'llllllllltJ~\I~ I~I\ 111",,,,111, l'II~_"lhf .,11 \~, ~11\1f1,1I9~1, 1I'111~fU\t M Ihlll/M 'IfIll Illll~'''''''lllll 1'!'1~111 ,,1,..1 ~~I~ \ltlwl\l, ,.'1, .II""~" r,'nll '1111'Iln,\' I. ." .' ' In It.! htt.\ 'l'UII'~141t'\'I'~ I~''''Y'.'I'I~ ,II "','hll",1 if-Mil >11 ". "'1'1 tlI l~i 1""1111 ~1l'~"'II"lJ'h II.t !Ifill \1 a,II,'I"1 OI,t.'IIIII' lI'f III~I .'lnllltll,lljM.' ~t"IIWII' I~lI'<1i~ 1~'1 "I'I~ "~jl_ ."" J 11~"'III>llllfll'llll ~1"I,,'lill"ll It, III U.", ,1.lf" III ,.',1, \IUIl 't''''1 "'I'lt ~""'l ~'lIt'lI II~',I III "1'IIII'~ll'4'I.I",,~ 1\\111\1111"""1"1,..1 j\111"'lli-,,;, HI.llr.I"'~I"\h 1\1' on\tIMII'H~II 'o,'fll Il\I"I~ 1'1 '~I '1Ij",~'o'I., "111,,111' '\f'hl""'I"~""11 If l"I'tllI'" ,'UII '""lu,,'I'1 IU~t 1lI,I,.".'tl .'I~ " '" f.",'tt". I '" t,lhl. II 111'11 \141,1;1\' '1'111 ,1,,1111 III \'illhll'II\lf'n tr.U'tlf416 tnll~II\/\',.IU 11",i,', !_l'Il~~.''', ,,','1. _", .... I,." .",""I"I,ltt""lt.t '111~ 1~I';-!",,'1i'!11l dl~ .' ,,' 1"''''1 AI'I""'I" It ."",.,1 1"",,/ I'I~I \I'~I"l'l j~ "nin1 I~H ....II,II11n HIlI I 'j/HI Alii.'" '" I"t tw"..-',,~, IlIl~f'l" iI'l fll,.,ll/ Ill. (o',I'fI"-ll" .~HI llil"I\ II'I\'I\J lI~r, . I. It('\ .,"11 .,I'W'I~1 "'.,, III 1ft'll ~11 I" 'llit! Hnu,'1I11t I~'u ..,h 1,,,11/1'1\1'1\ 1I1l11l1"Wlll' 'I,. 1'11,+,,11', "1 !If' 1111'.., "-""111" l'I\\I~I(~lllr""I'I'hl:. ".. ' 'llH' "t,M I\f~ l'hllUt n Irt f"1\tl>'Ihlf II~Jll 'I~I, ."I>"'Io/IIII".lI""'I"",' "I ~,I'lf ll'l I'll" Itlll""I~11 It,d "t,lllflll" ''''11 ~llIh. 11\ 1,1, h1~,1 I.,. ~""""~i '" It-III "'''1,1 .fll~"1 ~O_lltlllll.!lltnt 1,\ liI'''.'I /l11Ihlll,.I'II,U I" I" ""/llll" ~lll"lli~llI"'lll'It 1'4II'lI\ll~,.1 Ih11t1f(1II\f 'I'h: h I 1'11'1"/11 ." Atlll~I~I" till It ,,,Itlff \'1tll'I1111hI111Iill, I' l't,1 "'I"" l'I~"I,.1 ."I.lmllo"'" I~,"II" t"llr 11"..'''1 t>r "'1/' .fll 1I'II,~.1 tn.,j ~h '"'Iltt 11111'1. l\hJ ,\,I"I"tIIl 1I1 hili .~oJ . . .". ," AJ'''I'I '\J"\'I\~ " "u~" "f"~' II,II~, M,II.11 'hllflWllt tm Hill" ,n& "W,l whll~rl!lu li, t "'>"'11\11 '.:1.".'11 HI'"IIlilll~lt.~, IIIIU "11'111 Afl"I' I: MIl'll Ad~I."'II'II,I' t' .' ~I~l Ilflih, 11"li~tl fl+, Ili..~,\,. I~!.I '11t.lt' Ilil'lll _~ ,~'.. I",ilh .' II, hIIVl.'I l1I"'IIITI AiIM'111I '''11.111/1110 ~nl. 4Ih~~ \'1111 II; LrfJ.. nlllll" ,I, "I'tll\ ~.H .,1, t'ilt'~M. ~'''flll yl,fH If! .tl:V,IIlllfiU ,hl~,\,,'I', fl,ull'" Il.ltlt '"llf '''I flnl'llAl .r Ihe i,,'ntflilll~ I, ' II, ,\lIIl1Wll(t\I, TMUII '_11.1 U'!ll~ lltl ,'Ith fftmlttillft. NIH'lhlll "'''~''I'!,.~''- It It, ...~._...I" '"'''''' , '. ---"'~"_H_'_. nflll ~ I' IIMIl lit, tI .,.", 1"111'" Tf'''II,ll'flltfiU .'llllth/'I' I~ll Wltl .!,rtl ~f ~l "'llllill 'r,',j,l,t~I"\I'fljllt 11~1'~III~1!'11 ~11~'II'i.r'IflY, " ,. . ~'rllf till' J,lllt,; 11,11I, IIId,oJ 1\011 101/\1'1' I.t~ 'I ~'I Illlll"" "l'II".lfI'411.1i'1"\ II' I~J"/'1 I',' II {III II' ,I I,lllh ,,, )rllill Ital ,( 11,11 HI '1',II,,'j" I" 1\"111"'11"\, '1"11<10'1111' '1-'Itlrlll'I~lol~11I9" II f!HlltllH HIHIIIII '. .... 'r--....u,t-......---..__':"......_~__........_ t. .', ."----' -.-------..--, " ---- "" . ..........~..----..-----_.__._,...._----- " -,'. ...,..,..--- .-..,.,.,. I' " II", '\..~llitlf'hl' l,i,l~i III. ,It'~t f'l11~t 111f(IIJtlllt JlICtI61^t Jlltl I:tltlt "*"HI 1(j1'IiIIMhl~, Hh II . U,.II; ~ln~j". '''AI/HIIII "~llIndfll'''.I.t f!lnwll ~nv' '1t/llllH. " /'U "/,I"~IM. 1'hU t'lNllin.llllil', l'j HMlfJ~. lit, WWI'11I1 ~JlIiI .hll'''fllll'\hIU 11'1 I~,t !'>'hll fM fIH'lml1 H h'ltht, Wblll \'IH\llhl lIu,l,h1hllil\ Ii \W\' l,mihhll, ,~.1, fll\fotlfllM ""II W ~lnlllll~ II III(lII.h ltrwI' h 1I11'1~llhl Ulllhl tIIl,l~lI ~II\V"'tM, . .' , . I'IIU 1iI11111l1l1UJI.J hYI~II"d thll tM\I~lllhlludrhA lilt dlWNIUlI MId 1'"111 (lu Iht It1WlllJt 1'111\11 ~,,~ 'rIm lh~llj 11 bluJul' I'lt Itllll ~IIJ Iflltl I::::'II'~~J~~~~:~;;;\ , mm ~~f0: ..,.. !vo....r;,q~*Ud-_.. SelI.ell ~1..j{~~_,_ \I'TI'-!1l/:U/!:fL. ,,-. 1'11'1,1 hll____._..;.;..,.......,...... 11I},11lI Ili~l" " i' , ' Ii ~ ; I.'" '.)', , " .i' " ,j', " '" " , " 'I " 1 " " I'" I' h " " .' ", SXHIBlf Ii " I' .' I' " 'I' u " ':, '. " " " " ti '. 'I " " ,,' " " .Ii 'Ii " I, "',1 "I' I, ;0, .' ,I' " I' I' H II 'I; " H"" It,', " j,11 " /I " " ,II' I'," " II.. II I' ,: " " Ii '"" HI, ,I,; , ;! 'I, ;';(j ,:i," " ", , " ,.., " I' " .. " ," " II " " , ,,'" " " ", " " "I' d' 'i j ~ !! " " '" ..11 Ii, " " " "" " H 1"1;; " 1< .. I' " " ,," , , , I; " " " '- J::l " ~. .. it f:r:; I, ~~ t.- ''''1 " ~L' ~;) (~\ {I~I: 'Ii " )." :,-. fl' ( ~..J :", " ',::/' '~4;~ , d.-~ " ,10"_' r ):-.'J "( C.:) t(.l I~;J ;'l.! (il/:;' (',/ ~"I" U'l "Jri! I... (I. .,:, (.; h .rl,. J., /I, n'\ "j., ,.J d," ,\3 " , ol' " d"' Ii 1\ ,> ;1' " l' I' . " :1 .., . .. II/ " " " ',,1' , " " " " " " Ii ,11 ,,' ,I' " 'J' 'i, ',T " .. " " 1'1; ,II " " " .. "" " " Ii " " " Ii ,,' " ; ., !i i', " " " I;' ,d' o. 'i , " " " I" , " " "", " ,j " " " " " ", " " " <! , j,',1 ,: " I' " " " " " " fl: t.i.l' ',. ", t"~ ..t,; t I~~\ ",,:r:'1 1',. Ii. 8J .. , I. , 1," ~ I:, ".. (,) lX. ," " ,I: (I" (.'I'~ (;') ;"~"l 1'.. " .. .. l1u o. Ul , \ ~-J " (f "'" " " " " ..,' (....1 i,'j) :' ~l " I, l1:1\! n.~; 1111,;'1 /, ll. t ,~ ~l" I,'; ..J.: t>j , }.;j' .. ~ en " 1 en U " " " " " , " " " Ii ',,' " " " "",I " " " /, " " ", ,,~ I ' , , i! I' I' " tI, .. " " Ii, .I' ";' " II " " " " , " u " " , !i ", " " " I. 1, II .. . " ", " '11~111'.IJ,lilq,I'I\";'\I,I':Ii'lwn: IIIHWI':lililnr'1!\ I,S,. , I'llIlnlllf .. V, I\UllIm'l' """NI':1i 1111I1 1(!\'l'III,IHo:N ,,1\ \'NI~1i1 , IlpfvlllhmlH " I I I 1 I I I , I I, "I Nil, UU""~" C,,% I\P'I'IIlN",I,1\ W II IN '1'11I': (~npl\'I' Ill<' PUMMIlN l'I,MIi rPMlllml,^NIl PIl\JN'I'Y, "":NNI1YINI\NII\ ,. " "I " I ~\!l'lIIY Ihlll Oil\! lhlH \III~ Ihlll IIIl 1l1'11lIIHlI 1111\1 IhI'V~ II'\IV 111111 OIlIWo\ ll\lpl~1I 1lf'lh\l 1\l1'.llgnhlllllll~\IIlWl1t IVV. I'V IIPI'WII11Y. 111'111 pIIIIIH 1111111, 111l1I1II!lll m'1l111lill \lPOI1,oolll1l1pl 1'01' lIw 1'111111111'1' II111wllllnVP'rv'~I'0l1voII proo\lo\lhllll11 tllll 1\1 lowhlll Hill I'VIIHI .. . ,,!illIH H, FVIlI~lv; H~\f\lII'U, ' Tholllllll (), WlllhII11H,Tilll]IIII'O HOII!lOI' 1'It" A\lI~I', \I,C, , 2~~ 1 Ml1I'kllt Hllwt Cllllll1l1ll1, M 1701\ ")lIlodl MIIl'~h 4~, 1999 " " " ii' iI " Ii I ~ "; " '" ;d "j, ,I Ii " . ~<Af1!~~~~p ,,'RIl~I~~Hn>'l1oSI~l\\I11'1l , " ii " , I " " , , Ii , " , " , .. " "I L I' " " " II " '" i' " " " "" I, \," ", " \\ !' " ,-" " I! II " '1 ' I, .. " I. " "".., ." ','" ,. ,1 " " " " ! " II,' I' I' " " I' " " " 'I' " I' " " ,I " 'i. I' d I; )(~,\ ','t,'..,'" .~,., '''''','r'''''''1 " ill/I...'" 'II """'-;;'!''.I,'',';'\'' \i;;;'I,~;: , ,; " '.,:,,, ''''''''''''\11l'1''iW''~ J""I..""{.\t!j;j,,A,'-t,'~,4Hfj"k't,:},-"[ij";;;':'_,fl" 'In. .- .... ",'!!."""'!","'-,..,.. '''-.'' -....." "1,',"',:--.' Le:. I ,; .,',',.L '.. " n '. " i' " " C /.. " ii' " " ", ,i' " IWAllPn III An~pn, 1',0, AlTPnNf.YQ AT ~AW a3~1 MllnKPT PTnPPT, OAMI' H1~I" rA 1701104MJ (717170a.1aQ3. " 'I, I' " 'p " " '" I' ,.,," " " I; " ',I Ii I [\,1 . '''U " " ", J', " " " I' 'i'I" " " H' ,\\ " " " Jj il' I!', ", '.., " I." :.1 I'" /-, ii " ,ii " ", jl " I, , " I' " <.l f. If i. i 1 " 'fl (",) r/,i It; 1.1: ,-":." C,'_I ,. " ..!, " ill " /,") , I,f;'; I,'".l' . 'rl {_~ :,1 .'f'l.! I ' I:;" 1(,) Iii, ".3 U ,. ., ,-I' " " " " " ~' ~ ~ (1_ II' " , - ' ~ ...S'- ~. Q:; ~ .7f '7J:\ . ~ d.p( .() ~, ~ ...,. " ", il" I' " " ;\1 ;;' 'If; !!' " ',j " " " " " " " " " ;,;' " "j' I' ", " " " " " ", " " " " " " ,I< I " " , , " :t .j; I'" I' I.,j p'; '" ,-! , ' '\ ;,'1 " " " Ii 'I " 'I' CI' , , 'l " r:; " Lid I,,'j 'J ;"~ , [,.) I,} ) ~ 1\, , ') ;;'1 ; , ~) i I,I , " <~d II , i 'j--I JI ! I.L~ , , .' ":-~-J ,- '" , d " 1:,( t.~.1 ':.) I: " " " " i'l i' I,d " .. " ": " " " " " .. " !' ";, Ii " 'I I' " " ,j< '" " " Ii H " ;,. "'\- " " " 1." ," " I' . ,I, " " " II " " " " ,); " " " " " I' " " ,'''' ,,' I, I' .1" " " Ii J' j, " "I' "';. ;1 ,f ., '" " " .. ,I'. " "jf !i-j " " 'Ii " I, P..MIill1f.S.rQB...hIJlllNg,,9A~.J;..fQllm,IA,b, '(M\11l1 llll IVPllwr11l1l11 ~IHI'HIIIIl1I"1I11111 IIIIPII\1I)\I1) TO Tli{: PRQT~IPNQTAiw Pf' OUMPlml.ANP OOUNTY J' " ' Plllllnllllll\ \1111 1\lIIPWII1\1 alllllll (01111111\ PI111) ,.) fpr J\JIW Irllll 111 \Ill) I1P,X\\ortl1 ul plvll OPIHI.. . . ',' l XX ) for IrI!\1 w1l11Q\11 1\ lurv, ' , . t . ' " '.',Hnttt~""t""lI"'HH"Hfllh'!t"t IT""'" 'ff"'"""",! .,.." ''', !'H.'" '''' H'" ..."." ,H..t!l' If..;. t, ,.", I" It,...." I"'!' ": "'!"" I'" "'" ,."., ,., PAPTlON of OAf'I{: . . " (anUm p~plIpI1Il1UIl\ hp. OIlIIPIIII1 IIIIH (011001\ (110) , 1II11,I''''NI~I.,1, 1I11^1, 11R'1'A'1'11 1'I\OFI\~flTON^,,~ . ( X) ( ) ( ) ) . AuQ\lInpnl1 T~ollfllloO TronllOll1l (MPlnr Vpl1lola) " " .." ..-.(oiiiiirj....' ,. . (PI!\ll1l1ff) Vo, 1I011ln,I'l' lW~mlflol1l1 KN]'m,IIIIN "^Vfmfl TI10 Irl/.1III~1 will ho Qollotl on".......",......,.,.. . ollll ..,..,'.' .. .., ~ .... c ..,. . .,.... ,,_ _.' p ____ ...~ '.,.",_ ,_. :~. _".... _. . ...01,. I " ), (pefemlonll Trlols OOIllIl\OnOIl on ......_..__..........,_.....,_...,.,..,.......".. Plulrlola willl10 1\0111 011 .., ,._, _.,..,..,_.".......... ,..., (nrlllfs l\rollull I) tll\V~, 1l0,lolllprolrlula,) " , \T110 ponv 118\1no Ihlo Oono for \1101 sh!llllllovltlll or\l1WI.lh 0 oopy 01 1110 prooolpll 10 all QounBElI, purBuonl 10 10llal l1ulB 214,1,) , , ",' ii, VS, .. " , I; " " No, ,,_.I!.~?_,u, ..' CiVil M 1.nw , , 10 9~ " 'Indlo!\la Il1a al\o!l1llV who wllhrv oaae for \lHi.party Wlllllllos thle prnoulpul . " u.:',u,._ _ 'l'holl~!~~:l1~~~!,..~'=-'I~~,:,~~~:~u~~.&_\).~I!!l~ ~ ~~_,.l'. 0., 2331 ~~n rku tSY~'IIU~1 OUIIlP , . I IntlloEllo Ir,laloounoB,llorothllt Ill\rlles Ifllnbwnl .c.',.,-,..". ., on ", ...., Ilohu l' ~ IIII>,nl\l1, 121 Soil ~h 1/n:I.1'f :Lul<l 1l1.1vu, Iluvu \', Ilu 1.1I\~II1'U 1991l I ", i' ,.. ~ -,.- ,,- 'r, , ,- ..c'-. ~l.' - OM' ,.1110 0001l Ie IBOlly lot Hlal. BIUlwlt: ,. 'f2{()' .fl),:" , ..., (1 . - '~_'''L:'L'" .. ----'---..-~--._.-.......-.-...__....... .-. ~.~.~, .-.. -.. ..-, ....- -- ..-- .",.. --.... .. l'Ilnt Nnlnol. ,'I'I,111!!ln,H ,0 \, HtlUIII~~,I, 1\,Hq\..jxU~" ' Da\!l: _.JjJIQ$L,~,_'m"___.. ....,........ ^\totl1OY 10t:J'l~i.n~ff r " .. ...... .,. ...................-j; " " " /, " " " " " "" " " " " ij', ..... ,..., '~ ,.1' " l'i \'Ii E'; 1'" ~.r'l ,1: l'~ ~:j \t~ " (,)";1 Iri,'i m:~ r...., ;~;: . . rl, f:I., 1';.1;.'.:1 ,,, f J.., "',..... '( (, I.t., ",l't/J f1'" I rr' t~~J r /,\ U'I' ~:, I:J\p '[', " ~Ul, -. ~,. C, ~I, I:.:' :;:5 J.' t:;) C,l " " -Ii " if j'j .\, " ,i' " " " 'r! ", " .; " 'j- 'j " !! " " " I, " ~H " .1" " " ,.I " I, I: " II " I' " " l' " " " " '" "I. " !' {'J "", " II, 'I " ,; " " j( i> " oj " ", " I' " , " if, lit I' " " " fl' " " ";' " " " " .. " " ,'11\ q, ,'I ,,' Ii;.' di "I ii' " " !I'i " , " 'i,; " " " ',,', " " '1, " /I )J " ", I'" " ;' I;' /, " H I' " 'I , 'H " " f' i, " q " " " " " I ~ " , I, ,,' " " I> " II " " ii' ," " " " 'I' " , " " " .. " 'I;' " I , " ,I' " " '-j 'I 'r, " " " " , ! i; ~ Ii' " " ;'1 ," Ir' " " ,,' Ie"" , " I'll rJI,(WfI!W: . Olr"!J ::1', i 11"\'if)'lNlY (II] t,W\' I'll !\II 11' 113 (JI Jivli }iJji),j\1 ) (:OUI'!I Y f"}Ij\J:I'lLVi\~il/\ , " " /, ., " 't' " (,'1 Ii , I" " , " " " " "", " " 'I' " Ii .'; ", " " " " "'II " " " H " ", \ Ii II. l; " ,'I I, " ',I I' , " ", " ,~ ' , ,I' ,\ " ,.... In ';,1'1 b", f.... \" llS~~\ .;-:. " '\,.-,' eJ'i ,', ;.);,',! ,C.'.t"i , t \ ~ i: " \:\', '\' '('l,: 'I~ i; " \'1 , , (,1)" , eO \:-1 " ;"in (,II t~J \",' li,li) n\1 I '~; , \ '1\\-' f'{ i,t'li.., j.';: ~I; \,1 ("":\ ) ,.J "r.;> 'L) Ii " " ". " \II ....." ., ",. 'fl, ,I " ," " " " ;! " ,; " " it I' I'" " II ,;' I" " " I, " 'j!; " " ;',1; ,n" " I' 'I' " ," d1t :1 " " '-,' " '" i, " t: ,I .. I'" .,1' ..... I~, [:: rr~ ('; <'-J !;~, 'J;:;! UI,(') '_"I ( '.;, ,( I \.'J;.E ('\1:\ ..... ::);;;',, (I)'L' ,.' I:~ ' . '~1 ;;.'i " '( r " f-'_'-( (1) ,tr~) 1/;". -..... , Jf~ , /"'. I , I lh .;~ , , r-/ ,(1/-,,1 , t:" "I ',; .t, ", C;~I '''i... (,'1 ,,) ('':;1 (.;) " " I; II: " I ,J.: , In '1 ~.. " " " " "I " " 1', " .'! " " "