Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01003 " " U I' -I' ''0 " " I' :), " " ',,, I' 1; " " ,. " " " " ,'"~, " " " " ,. Ii ,f' ,I " " l! Ii .. " "~i' iI " Hi (1: r r""'-)i'I;' II: , ,;;' J1i\llY (J\J nrp t1 () i\IIIOI II ' O\ihmUlu"/'jIJ GOI.INI Y , PflNN8) L\'A~W\ ' ," ,," " " \\ I\. H I, " !" " ii' '" " II ..,-" " " !I" " " " ", " " I: " , " Ii " j'\ "j/ ,,' II ;'. I' " ".j " ," PP'19P~ OIVI~ T~RM T~ylpr p, An~rt3Wa,gllql-1lre Fpr Plplnllff Ppnlel M, MYllhln, f,aql-1lm For P!lf!lnd~nl qourl Acjmlnllllr~lor :a~~ "j. 'I, ,,' " " " ,I " ..." ,. 'if " I',,' ,. ,!' " ,'I ,/ ;0 ";',, " I, \. " " " " ')\ I, " " '11 ..I' ,. " ,," 'i I, ,,' I' " I" " " " ,', , ,>" " '1' " " " " ~9.10P~ OlVl~ T~RM AIlrll4, ~(Hll), wllhPUI ~ o.ualoQY or~ar In pl~Qa,ll1afplhar wanllp MI!'Iao~irl /.Incj!'lal~acj Ronllicl, HI3 W~!\ IIpprl3l1anclacj Py 11113 pollQa f.la ha wf.lll'f.lllampllng 10 II3~va Mlllao\.lrl, , ' ' Ron~lcj Wt=!el reMn!3cl 10 hla molhar, Afti'll' a!3rvlng lima In prlaon In Mlaao\.lrl, tlla 1/.Ilhar, rell1rnaq 10 P!3nnaylvl'lnl~, On April Il, 1 QQQ,lha molhar fll!3q 1'1 pallllon for apaQIt=!I rallaf a1313klng' prlmmy " , , , phyalo/.ll oualocly of Ronf.llcj I'Ihcj aaaklno,lopraVanllha,fl'llhal' from h<wlnQ f.lny oonlf.lola In p!3raOn, Py 111f.1 II , , or Py lelephona wlll1 hla aon unllll'l furll1er orqar of oourt. A " .. lampqrary orclf;lr Wl\a I3nlf:lrecf on April II, 1I1QQ, grilnllno Iha motileI' prlml\ry pl1Y!llo~1 oUl'llocfy of.Ron~lcf I'Incf a\llUnpa oualocfy h13l'1rlng for Jun~ 10, 1999, Her reque!'lllo " , '" re!llrflln tl1efl'llhar from hflvlng !'Iny Qonlaol, In pl'lraon, py 111 a II , or py lelepl1cma W.llh ' , . f~on<1lcf pefore Ihe hal'lrlng Wtla clanled, On Juno 10, 101111, 1'1 ouslocfy hef.lrlng WI'lS ' QOndlloted, Althl'll time Ihe fl'lltier WI'IB In theOlllllperlf.lnd Dounly Prlaon on orlmlnal, , , oharges nol relalacj 10 Ihe oustody cflsput~l The mother waa l:Iranlacf permission, nuno pl'o luno, 10 move Ronf.llcf to the elale of Missouri, The orQer further provlcfedl 2, The mother Is awarcled legal oustodY of Il1e ohlld, 3, Tile mother Is awardecf primary physloal oustody of the ohlld, , . 4, Fl:\ll1er.etil:lll have periods of lemporary physloal ouslody of the ohllq 16, pe aUPsequanlly delermlnecf, ' ' . . " ," " The falher was relElliIsecf from Ihe Dumperlancf Oounty Prison In April, 2000, On Juno 20, 2000, hefllecf 1:1 oomplalnt aeeklng periods of lamporaryphyeloal ouetocfy Wllh '. ,. . " .2- , PO.1PO~ OIVl~ T~RM Rgnfll~, \, Thl3 mpthl3r flll3q 1'1 prl3l1mlmllY opjeotlon to Ilwie;pmpll'llnt rl'll~ln9 '" Il'Ipk' pf j4rladlptlpn. l=lh~ mf'llnlfllnl1 Ihf'lUI1l3 fl'lUll3r'l1 reC\ul311111 for perloqll of lemporl'lry phYl1lpl'I1 " t1\.latody IIllo\.lld ,pe (:\l3oldl3(:\ In Mlal1o\.lrl, On J\.lly111, ~aIlP, Ull3 mOlher.flll3q ~ P\.ll1tOqy , I'IQllonln the Qlroult Opurl of I3pone Op~lI1ly, In Whlphl111e re[jlatl3req Ih!l Pennllylvl'lnll'l , O\.llltpqy or(:\~r ql3te(:\ Junl3 10,1PPO, whloh I1hl3 apU[jhl to mo(:\lfy, Thl3 moUll3r'a " prellmlnl'lry opJl3otlon In Ihe prel1enl Ol'lpe Il"'ll peen hrlefed Elnq ",rgl.lecl ",nclll1 rl3f'lqy for ,.' , ", ' df;3ol11lon. " " In Knllum v, KnlllOn, 3g P 81 0,4"\ 66(3 (1Q96), thlapo~lrt, Oler, J" anlerecl ~n orql3r on Aprll10,10P6, Ihl'\II'\IlClWeq ~molher \0 mOVf3 her ohllJloFI'\[[jo, North Pl'lkol'", The father wl'\!lml'lnled perlocla pf temporalY plwalol'\l o\.latocly. On April 10, ,.. '. , " 1096, Ihe fl'\lher fllecl a Qompll'\lnl 111 Ihlll oourt 10 mClcllfY Ihe orcll3r. The molher fllecll'\. pr!3l1mlnary oPjeo\lon mall111'\Inln9 Ihal North PakCltl'\ Wall Ihen Ihe home alate of Ihe child, IhElt Ihe falher'a petition for modlflo",llol1 of the yel'\r old pel1naylvElnla order ahould " " . ." 'be heard In thalall'\le, and thl'\t ahe was InlhEl prooel1a of filing a pe\l\lol1ln North pakola 10 modifY Ihe PennsYlvania order, Judge Oler reviewed Ihe I'\pplloElble law: In fJl'lmdl v. l3amdl, 397 PI'\, Super, (321, 680 A,2d 320(1990), an Il1tarslaleoualody oaae Involvln[j,oolnoldenlallY, Ihe atateofNorth OakolEl and Pennaylvanla, Ihe Pennaylvanla Sllpetlor Oourt held Ihal 111 oertl'\ln olrqumatanoes, by virtue of the federElI Parenlall<ldnapplng Prevention Aol, jurlsdlotlonlo modifY an exlsllng ouatody order 111311 exOIUlllvely wllh Ihe oourt of the slate Whloh Inltlallyls6ued the order, In f3amdt, Judge Kelly, aupportedln aoonoqrrlt:tg opinion by Jlldge Ceroone, dlsOUBsed one '.. . \ Hla ooUl16el represel1ts Ihat he aeeks periods of temporary physloal dustody during ef'lohaummer"al ohrlstmas, and 011 oooaslol1s whel1 he would be able to vlalt Ronald for ahtJrta periods 111 Missouri, ,.'" .3. PP,10013 OIVI~ TI:RM " " Ilml3"of opmmenQeml3nl of Ihe proPf3a~lnal or , , , . '(~) II III In Ihe ~l3l1llnl\3rl3l1l of Ihl3 ol1l1cl Ih~1 ~ oo~,rt pf Ihlll . opmmPnWf3,~llh,f'lIH\wne,Mlscllollon ~fdO~Ulll3 , , , Ihe ohllcl f'lncl hill pf'lrfdnlll, or 11113 ohllcl f'lncl I'Illfdf'lll pnl'l OOnlelll, f'l,nl, 11fWl'l ~ !\Ianlflo~nl Opnnl'lQ\lgn wllh Ihls Oommonwfdf'lllh , , , f:lI1cl Ihfdre Is f1VI1I1~~le In Ihla Oommonw\9~lIh !\u~slsnll~1 evlclemol'l oonpl'lrnlna Iha p,rallenl PI' Mur13 o~re, prolap\lon, Ir~lnlna ~ncl personf',1 rElIf1\lonshlpa of Ihe ohllcl , , , " , ., .. 'Home sl~I\3;' uncl\3r Ih13 Aol, III cl\3flneq f'l!l'UII113 1I11'11flln whloh Ihe ohllcllmml3cllst\3ly pr130ecllng Ihe lima hWolv\3q IIveq with hill Pl'lrenlll, II p~rl3nl or 1'1 pl3rflOn f;1ollna f'fl pf;1renl, or In ~nlnllllMlon, for ~II\3f;1al fllx . oonll\3oullvl3 monlha, !'lnq, In Ihe of\lI\3 of 1'1 ohl"j lesllIhf'ln6 mQnlhs olq, 11113 st~le In Whloh th13 ohllclllv\3clfrom ~Irt~ wllh ~nyof Ihe perSOnll ' ml3nlloner.l, PElrloqs of lemporf;1ry I1Ps\3nOI3 of I1ny of the nl1mar.lpfll'1I0nS I1re oO~lI1leq f;1S p~rl of Ihe slx,monlh or olh\3r p\3rlocj, . Inl1qqlllon, lll1cler Ihe Aol, B P\3nnsylvf;1nl~ oourt whloh hf;1a, " jurlacHollon 10 Isslle f;1n Inlllf;11 qeoreaOrl'l fTlocllflol1110n claoree ml1Y clepllne 10 exerOllll'l ,lluoh hlrlacllo\lon If It flncla Ihl1lII la ~n Inoonvenlant forUm ancl Ihl'll f;1 oourt of f;1nother !lll1le III f;1 morl'! oonVf.lnlenl forum, Ff;1otors 10 pe oonalclerecl Inf;1 clet13rmlnl1t1on f'\llloforum non oonvenlans InolUcle:, ' '(1) If f;1nother stale la OW1Qently ""fill the home slf;1te of th\3 ohll.;!. '(I!) If f;1nQlher st~la 11!.'\s f;1 oloser,oonnaotlon Wllh tha ohll~ find hla fflmlly or wllh th~ ohlld find one or more of the oontestf1l1ts; '(3)' If supstl;\nlll1l evlqenoe oonoernlna the present or future afire,' proleotlon,lrf;1lnlng f;1l1d personal relfltlonslllpa of Ihe ohlld Is more rafldlly f;1Vf;1I1f;1ple In f;1llOlher stflte, .". '(4) If the pf;1rtles hflve aareed on f;1nother forum whloh Is no lells app~oprll1te, '. " " . .. '(6) If the exerolse of jurlsdlotlon Py a oourt of thlsOommonwef;1lth would oontravene f;1ny of the purposes stilted In (the Aot),' , In llUmmflry, 11'111 oourt'lljurlsdlotlon under the Uniform ohlld .. Oustocjy ~urlsQlotlon Aot may ~flln the form of '(1) 'home s,tflte' jurlsdlotlon (or) (2) JurlDdlotlon founded upon 'slgnl(lol1nt opntl1ots' flmong the pl1rtles .. to the oustody flotlon and the looale Inwhloh the aotlon has been brought,' Inter alll1, ,In addition, the oourt may, If II ohooses,deollne to exerolse jurlsdlotlon on arounds of forum nOn.Donvenlens, (Footnotes omlltad,) In Kru80nt Judge Oler oonolqdecj:' " [w)e pelleve thl1t sUfflolentalgnlflol1nt oontrl1otsl1mong Ihe parties I1nd this , looale exist to warrant the oonllnued exerolse of jurlsdlotlon by this oourt under the Uniform Ohlld Oustody Jurltldlotlon Aot, ancl We are not ". ,6, PfHPP3 PIVI\, Tt::r~M 'per~UR~t:l~ tlll1lthl~ fprum III liP Inp.llnvl'lnlt:lnt fpr 1111'1 p~rtll'lll thl1llhl'l mllll13r IIhpl-ll~ PI'I tmnllferrl'l~ III Nllrtll PlIklllll, Fpr Ihl!! rellSpn, pll1lnllff Pl1nript ' pravlIllln her plllllllpn Ihl11 ~l'Ifl3mll1nl'lI pellllpn fill' mpqlflplIllpn \'l1\hl'l(m~'1I1 PI' IIhIlUI~ Pt:ll1~ju~lllllle~ In Nprth PIIIIPIIl, " (Oltllllon Qml\le~,)l, , ,. . ,. H ' Applying tht:llll'l prlriQlpll'ls 10 1111'1 01;\1113 !HIIl Jl-ldIQ~, IIlnpe Ronl1l~ hllllnplllvl3clln PennaylvlInlll alnpl'l JlInl-lllry, 1PPfl, Pl'lnnllylvlInll1 Is no longt:lr hili hplllt:llllllll'l f:lll Ihlll '. ,., j, term la definec! In the Uniform Ohll~ PUllto~y Jurlll~lotllln Aot, . !:I/I'ln If we oonlll~E)r JI-lne i ,.. ' .. , 10, 1 9QQ, 11113 clllt,e thllt the pUlItody orqer Wf\1I entl'lred with permllllllon, nl-lno pro luno, for tile mother to move Ronf:lltl to MIIIIIIlUJI, ElIl the trl~gl3r clllte for p.llloullltlng alkmonth home Iltllle jurh'ldlpllon ~lI1der i!13 Pll,P,S, Seotl~n 6344(1)(11), there la atlll n~ hom~ at lite " jurla~lotlon IIlnoa 11)1'1 fllther'lI ourrent po.mpllllnl lIel;lkln~ tempo.mry phyalo.lll oUlltoclY Willi,. . " not flied until June 110, 2oQ9,l NotwllhatllncHtlg, )urlsc1l0.tlon o."n IlII11 pe eatllPllahed purauElntto 23 PII,O,S, Septlo.n 6344(i!), Ihat pro.videal ' 1 The PlIrentlll Klqnllpplng Prevention Apt la lit 2B U,S,O, ~'113BA, The Uniform Ohlld PUIl\o.~y JUrlsqlotlonAot Is al 113 Pll,O,S, Seollon 6:341-6366, Mlallourl haa ' ' 'el1l'loted the UnlformOhlld Ouatocly ,Iurladlotlon Aot lit V,A,M,S,,~~ 4611.440 to. 462,660, " l The mother having mo.vAd Ronald to Mlasourlln!JlInuary, 100Q, without optalnlng oourt approvlIl, WlIa a vlollltlon of pennsyIV!'lnlaIIlW, Gruber v, GrUber, 400 Pa,Super, 174(19QO); Whlto v. Whlto, 437 Pa, Super, 446(1994); aoera V. aDora, 710 A,2d 1206 (Pa, Super, 109B), Heroonduot preolpltated the father's mlagllldecl effort I'ltaelf-hellp at a lime when Ihenlother had already aupmllted to the jurlsdlotion of this oourt on the ff'lther'a oUatodY oo.mplalnt that had peen flied on Fl'lpruary19, 1999, In PIOwmll11 v, Plowmlln, 409 Pa, Super, 143 (1991), tile Superior Court of Pennaylvanla atated"[tlhat while the oUstodlal parent ht1d a right to mllke deolslons oonoernltlg his or her welfare and the welfare of the minor ohlldren, that parent ht1s a responsibility towarda the non-oustodlal parent to maintain the relationship belWeen the " minor ohlldron t\I1d the non,oLlstodlal parent,Thls mElY only pe aooompllshed where the . oourt 11'1 permitted to deolde oLlstody pefore the minor ohlld Is moved from the . " Jurladlotlon," ' . -6, " ;. ,i ii' " tj, ", j, " ' " P~),1PP~ OIVlhTFRM (g) 'Ills tl1~ P!'!sllnlfJrl'lBl of Ih!'! ohllcl lhf.\l II po~rl of lhls . Opmmonw!'!1I11hllsll~me Jurlscjlpllon P!'!PIIUIlf31 ' , (I) tha Phll~ IImJ his pllrenlll, orlha phll~ f.\ncl 1I11f3I1Bl "onl3 ponl!'!lltllntl 11IWe II algnlflof.\nt ponnaptlon wlthlhls ' Oommpnwl3f.\llh: IInd (II) lhare III IIVllllflPIf3ln this opmmOnWf3111t11 ' Mt!Jslf.\ntlf.\1 avlcll3nol3 oonpernlng thl3 prllBflnt or fulure of.\re" proteollon, trlllnlnQ"ndperBonlll,rlllf.\t1onahlpa pf \Ila ohlldl In In tho Mattltr of p,t."tl." Itt ftl"g7aPII, Supllr,446 (1 aao), tlw l3uparlpr OO\.lrt " pf Pannllylvl'lnlf.\ notecl Ihllt !llll npt nepesaary thl'lt the orltarla In polh tlla home slf.\lll j , ,. , , , I . , ' " lest (Seotlon 6344(11)(1 )), IInd the strtlngth of oonlllols teBI (Sf3Qtlon 6344(a)(g)) !JaP !, , ,'praaent !Jefore a ooUrt oan properly find jltrllldlollon peolluse e1:l0h test Is IIn.. Indepenclant !JIIBlsof f.\~lhorlty. The Oo~rt stated thllt the strength of oontaots tesl,~'ls emplpyed when the liome stllte test olin not IJe met or liS an altarnlltlve tothl'lt tllsl," lel. " " BoO alllo Wannan v, Warman, 2fJ4 PI'I,S\.Iper, 286 (1aa2), In the preallnt Of.\se, Il1a " ' " " father stlll'llves 1110um!Jerlancl oounty E1nd the motherand Ronl'll~ IIvad I1I:lre\mtll Jl'lnuary, 1999, Thus, Ihare Is a slQnlfiollnt oonneotlon tp Ihls oommonwealth, In " oomlTlonwo~lth ox rol, Zl\ffarano v, Gonaro,600 PilI 266 (1983), the Supreme Oourt " , of Pennsylvf.1nla, stilted 1 , , We have repeatedly held that '[oj\.lr pl'lrllmo\.lnt oonoern In oustody oases Is the !Jent Interaat find permllt1ent welfare of the ohlld,! OOll1l11Ol1weallll C1X rai, Pleroe v. Pleroe, 493 Pil, 292, 295, 426 A,2d 666, 667 (1982), O\lrOonoern Is no leBs In OIlBeB otpartlE\1 oUBtody and VIBltl'ltlon, slnoe the gOlllln eElOhOElBe IB to fOBter those relationships whloh wlIl!Je meaningfUl for the ohlld, while proteotlng tI1e ohlld frolrlsltuatlopB whloh would hl1ve a hl'lrmful effeot, ' '" GenerallY, oontaot of a ptlrent with a ohlld Bhould be IImltedbr dell led only If the -7- 'I' "~I, ;0 ,,, I, ~~"100~OIVI~ T!:RM ./ " ~y 11113 09Urt,'::. " \. \>C~. f;cJlJl'lr ~, f3llyley, ~, I " Tl'lylprP, AnctrewB, !;llq\.tlre Fpr PI~lnllff 01lnlel M, Mysl1ln, !;squlre For Pefenctf.\nl " 'il OQ\.trl Admlnlalmlpr. " " .' "" lSE\E\ " " "" ,I' ,', " I" "" ';' i',. " 'I 1'1 " " ..9.. " ,I ;0 " '" If 'I. , , " I" " ,I' ,.1' I' " 1.1' ".I.; ;.1-. IN Till! COIJllToF cOMMoN I'I,Hi\S OF C\JMIWHI,i\NP COIJN'ry, IlI\NNRYINi\NIA I, .' HONi\I-t:l 1\, IWNNI!H, ' 1'11111\1111' , ) ) ) ) " Nil, <Jod OO~ ) ) ) , CIVil, i\C'I'ION 'CIJI'l'I'OPY '. V,, K'M M, I1.Nm,IRII, Pufulllhll11 IlJC'I'I'1'I0N 1"OIUlJll~CIAI"\I')tIIl~II~ ' " ' i\NI) NOW,coIllPN flollllnllPI'. KIM M, I.iNOI.II'lII, hy 1111\1 thl'll\Illh,hol' lI!\ol'llPY, Plil\lol I' " M, MYN~\II\..rlaq" whl1 f1Iua Ilw nhovP Cllllll\1l1c(\ Il\lTITION 1'011. HI1\lCIAI_ 1~11I,IIW PIII'S\I\\I\I'IO . flnKClv,ll, I Ol~, I~. 111111111 Nllpjl~ll'1 \ho1'901', IIVCl'sliN 1~11l0WN: I. POIIlII1I1~i'IN KIM M, HNQI,ISil, \)pfbmllllll, (hol'ol,l\lIl1ol'. "M~lilw,:;') whp r081\les 11\ 603 ThlnlSll'ool, l~ochOlJPrt. Mlssl1\11'l. Mplhol' IN rcpI'osOl1\rld hy Pmllol M, Myilhll1, Hsq, 2, Il.osjll1llllol1\ Is HON^I~I) It Il11NNEI~, ill.., (hol'oll1l1l'1or., "Fo\hol''') who roaldoN III 206., VlIlloy SlrouI;SlIIil1l10l'dlllo, C\ll11borllll1d Clllll1ty, POIlI\NyIVlIl\h\, Flllho'r iN roproHolllod by CIlRl'I08 1\, 110lrlo,ll8q,. who 1\1.18 hooll pruvl(lod willI II copy ol'thl8 PoUlioll 1111(\ mlvl80d of CP\I\lNol'8,IIIIUIIUOII \0 preNullt tho Nil IllU , , 3. Molhol' nlld Fllther woro ,llUVCI' 111111'1'10(1: They .111'0 the 1.111\11I'11\ pllrollt8 111' tho millOI' ohlld, , , ' , . , ' .1l.ON^Lf) It IlHNNEII.. "" (hor~llIlInor, "Ilonnlo") whoau dllto ofhlrlh 18 .I111\\lIIry 4, 190~ IIlld who roald08 wllh Mothor III 60) Third Slrool. ll.oohoport, MI8sourl. 4, Flllhor previously 1lI0d II COMPL^INT FOR CUSTODY wllhthl8 Coul'l lit Ihe nhovo l1umhor IInd lerl11, , Molhel' provlollsly 11I0d 1111 ^NsWnll. TO COMPLAINT Fall ClJSTOIW. which IH IlIcorjlorntod I\oroh\ hy rofol'(1Ilco, ")' ~, On 'l'hIll'HdllY. i\prll I. I t)t)l) hoth pnrtloH nlld Iholr rospoctlvu COUIlRolnttolldcd II pro- honr!llg oustudy,conforonce hoforo Mlchllol It UI\Il!lil, Bsq, Tho pnlll08 woro \lllllhlo 1~1 "I'lllI<h'I',lIl1oI11111 n,w", SI',cj'IIl,Il,j' I 1II',1I7,IYY<) , 2 " ,,' '" , , . , p\lrlPIls PI' Ill11il sllll'l'l{\ll1nll'~s hirth, I:'ulll\lr hUH l\\lvur 111'1l1l ill'!IWIY InVl\lvl'\lllll\nlllllll~H . 1I1\1111l\1 hllH HPIlII! IIml!1l11111\w wllh l~m\l\il' nnly 1111 II Hpnl'lllllllllllll 11111'1'11\11'11I IlIIHIH: " 10. Wlwl! Mpl.!wr urrlvl'lllll thpllnnlW CnlllllY Hlwrlll'H nn11'1l Plllhl' l'V\lnll1~ nf April 4\h In r\loovpr Iwr SOil. Foll1\1r l'\lPI'II!l'lIlV Ihr\llllllnPII Molhlll' Ihlllllpnn hlH mll'OsP 11'0111 MlaanUl'1 l1111, Iw W\llllllu!llllll rPlmn I() Mnthpr'H hUIl1\l 10k,lclnl\p I\U!lIl1P, Mnlhpl' HH\lHPII\lPlllly repplvpclll 11l11'ph111\\l 01111 0'(111\ FlIlhpr'H 111111l1y IndlQIIIIIl!! Ihpll' aIlPpl;" for umlllHspill tn . ,: ,. Fullw's IlIoglll plun to kllll1l\p'l\olllllp'I1'um III" Mplhlll"H hump" Mother hplll'vPIl IIml Ihprpfl1l'p IIVprH 111111 llpsplle his lllTOSI PI\ purllntul klllilupplu!l ehllrllPs, .FuthpI' IIml hla I1nnlly 1I1I?,11l\ IU khlllllp ROllllle mIll PIl\TllUIlPI\lIy lukp I\PllIllplhlm hpr n1r,llw PllrpOie of llpprlvlng Molhel' uf 1111 00.'11111'1 wllh Runnle, ,. 11. " Flllhpl"~ IlIegl\1 eumlHol wlll'ill1t Hllhslllml,lIl1y hnp1'\1VP Ihll qnullty of IInifbr RUlllllpllnd will '1101 provlllplI slllblp Pllvll'l1nllWllllbr Rnlll\lp's ebmlmled'grOWlh,develonl11l'lll, Ilellhh lI11d \vpll1lrp, Flllhpr'" 11I1'1l1l1 COndHO! wlIl.nutllfforcl Mother II rellllslle, Hubslhlllp plli'1I111 enslml)' 1]1' Vlsltlltloll lI1TlIl\gellwnl whloh WII\lIdeqnlltely" fbsler 111\ oll!lolng relllllunshlp helwpen Mothl'r IIlld l\ol1nle, FlIlhpr'.s IIleglll clwlucl llucs lIut eOl\slder l\olll1ll"s soclnl, olllotlulllllllnd psyehllloglelll hOllllh nlld wolfnro nlld will s~vol'oly nlld hl'opnl'l\bly dl~nlpl J\llllll!I"S dnY-lll-elIlY IIfiJ lInllls Ilot III Rllll\\hi's bost Illterosts, 'I ,; 'I 12, . II' FlIlbl'r Iii perlllhtelllO dlsrllpl Ihl' ,I'll/III.\' 1/110 by kldllllpplllg l\llllllll'lIllel rl'llIovln!l hl,11l O'lll11 Mlllhl'l"s Cllro. Mothel' will Wl'olllll\llIy bo Ill'llll'eI CUSlll!ly nlld ,vlsltllllol1 I'I!lhl~lo " Ih1111lIo'sdplrllllollt.Molhor will I\lrthel' be Wl'lllllil\llIy delliI'd ROllnle's coml'nrl IIlld olll11piinlllllllhlp nlld will bo Inepnl'nbly hnl'lnod, I' " 1':III1I1,hil',t/t/Olllhl Ikl1l10/ SI",IIIIUollcr 11111117,1')"9 ' 4 ,. " RONA~P ~, P~NN~Ri ~'lA!n\: f~ I." .V, I IN '1'11~ cOlllW O~' cOMMON pr,mM! 011' I CllMpmRI,I\NP COUN'J'Y, pI~NNI3\'1Nl\N+1\ , I I I , 99~1003 OIVIL TmRM IHM mNQj.,I~lI, DefenclAnt ORI)IUR 01' OOUI~'l' l\NP NOW, th.j.n 101:11 cloy of J\1ne, 1~99f the pAtemA.l, , "gl:{1ndl1\other IFlving fl.1,ocl 0\ pe\:lt:J.on l3eek1ng pedocla of. , 'I .visitation with herQrAnd~on, ROnAlcl mUQene Penner, " " JAI1\1AI:Y ~ f 1093, thAt pot.1.tJ.bn' 1s \d.thdl:~wn Withollt 13y the III r ',110r.n pr.~j ucl.i.oe,' "t. " ,;' I, Id.SAMA!:ie"Coyne, ITIsql1ire, CO'fNhl & CO'iNliI, I.' ,0, 3901 'Mip:l;et Street OAI1\P Hill, 1'1\ 1701l~~22'7 Oounsel f.or. i?IAJ.ntiff . ", I' c.-trp-: .... """,~~L ~,\\,., '\'.... L\C-T ,. PAnie! M, Myshin, E1~ql1ire '," 4000 Ling.1.esl:own ROAcI, SlIite 305 HArrisburg, 1.'1\1'7112-9507 OOll~sel f.or Dllfend/1nt 11: 1" . I .. " . i"; " . ., " " ., " RONALD JTI,' nmHNmR, .PII1I,n \:.i.f; r: V, ' IHfv1 I~NGl,I!3l1 f ", PO/:encllln \: , :11'1 'l'lIl~ oOlJlW Pli'oPf>1MON PltI~1\13 Oh' 'I allMlllillU,ANP OOlJN'l'Y f J?1~NNI3YI,VI\N:r1\ I I I I , 9P-l003 qIVIL TRRM,' "I OIWER Oh' COUR'!.: " l\NP NOW, th,l.a 10th ClAY of ,JUne, 1999, th.tll 11\1ItteJ; havingbe~n cnliecl'for A heArIng on the petition of mother for I3peioial rellpf /leeking to moVeRoni\lclmugone penner,I!I, born . I, .. JaOl1Aqi 4, 1993, to the Sta\:e of Mhl30llr.l., l'l' IS OIWIilH\QDI 1, The petition of \:I1e mother to 'move the ohild' ~o the State of M.l.l3aouri, .ia "gl:antecl. , 2, '1' 11 e motl1er'.1.I3 aWarclect "II. 3 , 'I'he motl1er ia aWar.clecl le~al ousfo~y 9f the ohilcl, I, primary phyaical ouatoclyof " tl1e"ol1Hd, '4, J.i"~ther. ah/lll hAve per~.ocls 'of t;emporElry pI1yaiof.\.1. '. :c,l1at;oclY of the ,ohild ~.o be al1baeql1ently c1ete~m.1.necl, In gOal.: 13, l3ay ey,J;-~ Lisa Marie CoYne~ IDsql1ire OO'fNliI & COYNffi, PIC, 3901 Markel:St;rtiet Camp lUll, 'PI\ 1'7011-4227 Counael. for P.la.1.nU.ff: ,c..IJ,a;....". "'" "~..,,,Q.:. ~'\\'''lCJ - L\~T 'i' Diln.1.e.l M I Myshln I Inaqllire ' 4000 4inglsatown Roacl,SlIito 305 Ha~riabUrg, PA 17112-9507 Counsel for Defendant It. I ii." ,\' " 'I: ,,' " ,I " " " " r: H " it' ",,; , " d'. ,,.L- ,. " " !\Ii ,,0' , I ~ " " " PH , ili " " " jf- "I '1:'1 :1')' '11:" IJ. i I ,L_ OJ '011' ! i"i ":,o,:.IT/uIY' 1l~I.lllllllll\ii Iii II V " CUll'liji.lilA'I,) I.OlJl~r'(. rJHi~I:JY~YNN\. . " " ,\ " , '1 '\, " '1 'I " ," H " " I' " ii,' ,,' I' " ,,;' ;; H "j; " " " " 01, ;' " " " ,i, " " ,. I' " .. " .' .. "" IiII.W'()FF/('F" . . OF '[I If' f"f'lll'lhTNlY c,I"IIF..Il,f),lt" ;J f'll :il?2 ,(;(JLII;i.i\i ;i"1 J Cd), III' , FI':i-I:'I:,;"d\"II'I'\ I' ..' Ii 'I ,I " .,;;:h1f/,11v' I' r . 1.~ .~ . ')// ",~, (.X: ,..,., r 'r/p " . ,::.1)'0') (/, fY d? (. (iJfY 11.1/;:1. a:r'l? (l!.?j', .' / ~ );I!..it.... //uiiV .?!o~ ((t.-Ir< /.1" ~ . ( (. " "'!1')' ,P(-<1H?( H'fl /.~. ?:~i'7'~ ;li-& ~. .,1'.,.,(.... , ...,."lfte,c' I;, ,.". ,.. " I' " " '.".; ". 'i, 'I! ." " I, I' ." ,. " .. " .: " ji, ,/' 'ii ,.1' I. .',; " " .. !" .' t". .. " . i, .KIM M, t;NClI-ISH, Pl3fl3ndrlnt I IN TI-n: POURT OF OOMMON Ph!:A13 01= . I . GUM~~RhANP OO\JNTY, pgNNSYl..YANIA I I NO, 1QPll~1QO~ ' I I OIVlh AOTION .\..AW I OUI=lToPY RONAl.;P !;, ~t:lNN~R, pll'llntlff VII, O\J8T09;tJlQmm.ll\TlO.tt.aiJ.MtIlABY-aaeoB1: , IN AOOORPANO/il WITH OUMI3t:lRI-ANP OOUNTY RUI-J:! OFOIVI\., PRoO~PUR~ '1P16,3.(I, tl113 UndElr~lonl3q O~llItodyOonolllt:ltor llupmlla the followlno report:' .,. .1, The pl3rtlnent Informt:ltlon oonoenllnlJ the ohlld wl10 Is the~\j~jeot of Ihla li!iOflllon ' Iplla followa; . . " "NAMa "DATE OlUlllill:l tllJ~R8NTLY lNJJUSTOQ.'(Q.E I. , Ront:llq 1:, !.'Ianner, III J~mlt:lry 4, 19P3 Mother . . 2, A Ouatoqy Oonolllt:ltlon Conferenoe Wllahelq on July 20, 2000, wllh th(3 following Inqlvldut:lla In t:lttenql'll1oe:tllf1 Ft:lthElr, Ront:llq 1:, 13ennerl' t:lnd his oOllnael, TaYlor p, Andrawa, l:aqulre:Mother's.loP!l1 oounael, pt:lnlel M, Mvahln,Eaqulre, Mather,l<lm M, Flahar, f:lnq hi'll' pQunsel,ln Mlasourl,lJllnlalSlmon, gsqulre,'pt:lrtlolpt:ltaq In tha Oonfer~noe Py talephona. :" '. , I' i. 3, ' The pE1rtles Ware not apli;l to re~oh an t:lgreemenl. CO\lIlael for Mother verpE1llv rt:llaeq Preliminary ObJeotlona to Jurlsdlotlon oltlng the langth of time the ohlld h<1a resided In Mlasourl, Mother'a loot:ll oounael, Mr, Myshln, Inqlot:ltad at the Oonferenoe that he may file , prellrnlnt:lry objeotlona on the mt:lller of Jurlsdlotlon baoausethe ohltq ht:la been realqlng In . ., Mlasourl for In exoeaa of eighteen monthE), . Mother'a loot:ll oounael alao (eporta tha.t thera la t:lnother Aotlon pending In tl1la matter In Missouri whloh mothi'll' flied throuflh tha offloe of Pall Shmlfl, gaqul,~e, In the event that the Jurlsdlotlonallaalle Is maolveq In Fl:1ther'o !tWoI', thE1t Aotlon Will Pl! withdrawn, ,I',.. 'II, 4,. Mother left Cf1ntral Pennsylvania with the ohlld In ,IElllU<1ry of 1999 <1nd move~l. to Missouri, In April 1999, F<1thar V\'sltaq with tills ohlld In Missouri anrlreportedly kldnappad the ohlld E1nd droye.some 90 miles prior to pelng apprehended In Mlsaourl, ApparentlY,I1ewao . proseouted and 1I10a(oerated aB t:I result of theseaotlons, He, therefore, was Ino<1roerated'at , the time of tl1e June .10, 19119, heating for Speolal Relief whloh resulted In 91'antlng mother'a ,. , pennlsBlonto move to the atE1te of Missouri wltl1the mlhor ohlld, PursU<1ntto the present Order Mother has legal oustody and prlmE1rypl1ysloal oustody of tile ohlld, The FaUl\'!r waa to be allowed period a of temporary plwsloal oustody of the ohlld to be aubaequently determined, However, the parties have never.been able to reaoh t1I1 agreement 011 that point ,I. ,. :;, .. , ~, " (i, M IHHP\II'I IH 1110 HIIIIIl wlM\l' Mpll1Ol' 1111\\ \lhllll hn\'\l ,lIw \lhlH\lHI,\lPI1I1Ullllpl1H 1\1111 wh\ll'\l filunll1vll111 \lylll\lIW\lIl\1I1IlIlI'I1II1U Ihoohllll'H UIII'\l, pI'PI\l\liII1111 Imlnll1l! lIIlIl P\3I'H\1I111I" l'\lhlilllllHhlpH III'\lI11\1HI I'cl1llll~' I"'III111hl\l' ~~ PII,C,H,A, m4~, 7,MIHHIlIII'IIHIl1O IWl1w Hlllic Ill' 1110 ohlillnl Iho limo of OOl11l11ol)OOI1WII\ Ill' IhlH p1'llUoo<III1U , H, . , I lIIlIl'hllH IWI1 IIw IWl1w ~I1II,11 PI' IIw, 11hllll with 111 IhoHlx (0) nWI11hH IIl1111Uilllll\lly bothl'o 0\111111l\l11~\lllWnl pflhlH pl'o\luulIll1g, ,~:l Pn,C,H,A, ~~M"(n)(I), It IH 111 'tho 11~H\ Il1tol'oHI Ill' Iho \ll1II<1 Ihlll MIHHllHI'I'II1111 1101' P\lI1I1HylvIII1I11 I1HH\II11\1, .I\11'IHdl\lllol1 11/'lh1H chll<II1H IIw chlllllH 1\01 110w, nIlI' tHlH Iw bClln ph~'HlcIIII)' pl'cHUI1\ wlthll1 II, ,. ., " I, -'., ,. h ' tho HIII\1l of Ponl1Hylvllnln within Iho hlH\ oluhloOI1 (I H) 111\1I1(hwlll1<ll1o HllbHIIII1II111, u\'I\lol1o\1 conoul'IIll1g Ihu PI'OHol11 01' l\li\ll'J 0111'0. Pl'oluOllol1. Imll1ll1!! 01' POI'Ro,lHlll'olnllpl1HhlpH \Ifthll ohlllllH I1vnllnblo wlthll1lhu,H\lIlU ofl'OI1I1H)'lvllllhl, 2l PI1,C;H,A, *5344(I1)(~), , " 9, Tho uIlII\IIH'I1IJIPI'OHUI1\ wllhln \ho Hlnto 01' POl1nH)'I\,I1I1II1. 1101' hl1H Iho chlllltlOol1 IIhlll1\lolWIl, 11l11' IH II nOOUHH\II'Y 111,1111 Oll1UI'!!Ol1uy 10 Pl'olout Ilio ohlld, Tho ohll<l hl1H not hool1 HllbJuollO 01' Ihl'ulltol1\l<l with 1l1lHU'ulltll1ll11lol' I1b\1R91111<1IH 1101 olhul'wlso l1ugil,clod 01' " dopo11l10111, 23 PI1,C,S,A, *~3""(11)(3), ,.''.' , " 10, MIRHolll'1 IH1H Jl1I'lHlllotloll llIlllol' pl'Ul'ul]\1IHlluH H\1hHII1I1UI1'!Y, 111' I1ceOl'lII1l1cu with IJonI1H~'lvlll1ll1'H chilli UllHtO<ly H(IIIHlu IInd IH the 1l11ll'O IIPPI'IlJ1I'llIlu Ihl'lIll1 10 dclul'lnlno Ullslody Ill' tho child, (\I1dll Is not In 1110 husl Intol'ust Ill' Iho child thnllhlH OIlIIl'Il\HHlII1.1U ,111l'lsdlulloll" 23 PII,C,S,A, *5~4"(1I)(4), ""1111."/1'101""1"",), OIU~~III111' .1111)'211,2111111 :1 " .' " ".' " ":I~;' ,!~" ,~P'I~'PI, :'*,,1. ",'J:~nJI,~"'H~Hml\ ~ If,\~'m " . " ,. \ \ t, . mmm? NIP'- III ~ " ", " .~@~ ' IN TtiJ (l1~CVIT ~\.lfllT Q~ PQQN.~ QOVNlY, MltaQVRI "" . ' , 'if, """"~ ~t "'I\",r, II, I, P.ut!Q,,,r, '. v, . ell" N(l, Kim M,tr* J:lnp",h, R"~'n', ~j.ifMkm ctf Fllt'lllllnalMt~ ~'" 'n (lllllr"'. A,,,,,"V . Il'u.... "~nl ,Ii A.MQ, . '". 11./l.1P), '"" . ' R-..n.""1I Mllt'IfflICl.~1f)' OU'J,",~ Oflltr :~~IlMCf~r~"~.\fV' , . , ' '. ~ Now R!'flC1IlCIflnl K~n Marllll SflQHlh, WlhtlllW flrm,ClI TQ~, OKllnhlndl.r .. , HltJkIIIk, Altam.Yil p,C" 1Ilfo1l8h p~ Sf Simon, llId .ltIMq t\I,,1O . CJf1m.d 'omer PI ' '~,' fCll"l'felelrllllkWl,/fI tilt 0Wr1'. ~"Irv /Mln.'"" In IIOOHCtllnct Wi'" RaMII, . 4fla'~'"1 ' ,~ llIM~ ordtrlI'~,.. .nle," In !;4I1lt numbtr ",,1003 Olvll/n lilt CclYrt ,C)f common P~. 'C)f CJml~ ~IV. "'/lIMY!van., " , ,,' ." . ....~')l'. Mo~ kl WIv OUltoqvO..t " , , Com-. Now "NCIClI'ldtnf./(lm M<<r/e 1tllQI11h, b~.!1d IhM\.lDh (;o\ln"I,01 R,oord, .net Iqr htr MQIIon to Modify OIlItody Orcf41r .111.. .1 rolloWlil , " " , 1) I<lm MIl,.,_ ~IlQN'h:: hertfnlfler 1'Ifen1d'lo .. RlItpondlnt, III a _nlll Roohtport, ~ a) ~=I :~, hIIt/""lter ,..r.nwd to .. PIII\kInfirHJ..rtllantC)fPlnn8~vanll, ':t) ~:'=I"~ 'f~..t ~f\~~::n.'~~ ':1\~Rltv~n1~r, '~UMble, Mlhoorfl htr IlJOlaI Hcurtev number' 1 -",2. '..' '" P,lnforWt =' UnlInClWnI IIIUooCal ~ I1\lmbltr" 1111>64-4<481. IS ,'fNI ColIn 11II1 lllloo alle' "" ,u~MII"" .net Partin h.""II, ' CI RIl'fIOI'!dtnl '"" tIiiantr havt MVlr bMn MlITlId to ..ell olhclr. ., The minor llI1Ud, ~ E. RIm"'f III Wit \lOt" Ja"uarv oi, 1093 end hll. "'"fdld conllnuoully'ln Qoon. Oounw Inlhl sll'l 01 M'''ourf .Inet on Clr aboul Janu.ry, 1999 Wlth hit m~\ ""pG\'\den'l ""'1'\111, Melinda llllticll\ and hili mother:" fIlIna(!, Glorg. 8Itntlll'lll..-r. , I 8) Tllel Cll'I Of IbcM J\Int 10w:r' IhI OouI111f Oomrnon Pilla of Oumberland CClUncv. ' ""'lil~MInlI tntlmMt lis 11\ III Ot'dtr of ~ (hI,..',..I'I., lClII .Orde,., onltNfna, tnt.r ...~ tIl.... ""llIl11\d P~l M\OClV of Cht PlIrtlll' mll'lOf cI1lldl f'onald I!:. , '.1Ubfect to u. ~~ P~IClIllllllIOdy of.1Hltt mlntIr oIlHd,~ Pttlllolltf to .,. "''''''''daIe. ' ~) ~ lInd ~~ ~ Illttumatanc.. 'Idillll,. lhe enttY of 1t1iI, Ordef ' " r=- Met "*'- Itltt mliiot child Ml bt bill ~ IW.. modlf1aa,= CUlnInt .. t ,~I Q . ~UIt In ICClCltdancI WIth "etpOndllnfl ,"", . , . , ,. it t. I, , , I Ii,;., i +j,i"!':;"j:"; ij ;: i.i . .)11' I' '" I,' ,,: i """.I'Wln .' , .J '>:-tio"fl'\ Ih..'l.......__~~.;..t!..... ,... ,. j _I ! ' i d 1<1" ;" I ',j:.\ ~::',!, ." " " "'11 .. '.QQ 'ifni U'.'~i,...."n/!~.UnH'\.\HmB ",!,IUIl/n, I .., I', , m m 91'7' ~~Q~. ,'I \' ' , I " , " ,"'fflJl g",~utT CPUm' Of, '"" 0f)UHl'Y M lIOQ,.. '. JT^,", ~ MIllO"'" ..' .'" ." ,RIm"" ta,al"""" II, , t'i '" ! 'P~lUoMr, VII, 0... NQ, Kim ~'rl..~, , ~,. " \ .. r I, , ,. ',~J! ~Hd ~~,~M~ntfl dloIb 1W1lH)31 fJ8N17M+a13:S' , I.' ~OUIYOPV^"~IfW'tHGOf'''MI""N'',TMI ' ., A,' R1!IP!II"lIInt (1<IM~).~1 tilt. I'" n.;'~~ aulladV ofL\M , IctllIIt Ind tMl -t<"".. re.'.... ..,,... ,"MIMo\.l~ " c1tl1lQ~ ~ C.' hlld'l mtIllno, ~. fat' pumc...'QC mtlIII'lO .nd,tdu~, t<lm furitw ~I tIl., till cnIICi /tIld. wIItl,~'aul .to Aon.!d".ANlIO"",1e rill. hit of .u........tet YlIh.! lion. ..1Qrttd .. .. bv....:.~ ' ~tlmI ,'""'.~' ,. , "" , , . 1. ~0CleQ1 Thf chlkl '11cw1d have ttleptloot tcetM With ' , both Plrtfllu, 1ImtI..' ...' .' , a,' I 'n1tt PIIrtlM' lOIledulH .nd OQlYlmltmenlt ITIIlV .! requlJe CMXl*1lonIl .. Ultd Ume,' The ~ II\OUId cooper.teln trvIng .. ,., to !'M<<1~ltthe time tn. Clt11ld 10 ...ure IPPfOPri.t.oont.u wtth boUl pIIrtmt, A PII'fnt r~ van.nclt fl9m . 'oMdll\lC$ .1t_1d _ \hi other Pflrent "llOOfl , .. pbfIlble,but no 11fti' thin oneWMk prior to 1111 dill otto. !:htng" . . ,,' 3" " ~Il Ronlld ,hQ\A1d noIl'llnOve 'he child from MI..ourl or 'Upt"'I'ICln~. I"'. pt rm. "'Ion of KIm, . " 4.H .,T~l R~ .hoUld be I'e'f)OnIlble for tftnlfHl'lltlofl \0 M~=~' ",..., ,..,.. , A. I<'"n'toommtndt Ihtt "".. MIlMIln _ 191 C1Um<lY Qf tht child iOOOI'dfno to ...'~ Itgll. ~.=r. pi,", Klm.WIIl malie 1M IIgnIf\Qent "Ion' I1CIIitdlflo lit h~.Ilhl..~ and -of lhtt ohlld, ,. .. ' .. 1," " DIiIPIII. ~~ ~t SlOtlparent .nould ~e '" routInI .nd ""'* InIltIfI ClOI1OIfflIfllJ lht ch*t', Wflfere OOOUrrlng wnllt In tI1llt f*lWnt'. lllllItIptlVlfld oontnlI, '. ' ' ., " ,I , " " I ,'.1. I 'I" )"1 :...1 ': ; "11 i, ~ ' I; ;1' ,',, II I,i I I;' ",'. ' ", "t.""~J , ~~" II"" '1 01 .......,.,'; "'-_"'~I" "'" ...., "" ., , I' I''"'" " I ,,/I~, "," I j ',l! . ,t1,\.' " I, 1\ .m,19,!M"Il'/Hl If.,~,.""TOm,..~mllm~~fl.IM~lm. . S?,J m ~?S7 ,. f^Q~. .119 , , '. .. I t,. l . "~'" ~I Th. plllt"" .~Id (lQmmlln~I'dl~y wllh "Ph lllflllf 11I00, rmt JI" ~ P.hlkl'lI III "1tlII'nptt, Thll ".r,nt. IIInd th. c:f1lkt .hcwkt hlllv" lllftlpoo". ~'" wllI1 '."h Illhll' t IPlIlml!~llt "mtll '00 Wllh llppmprllll. ',.,qllllnIlV, Thll PMV InKIIIl11Q Ih4lCl9mmwniofl ./lQllkl /.le,,, Ih" !lOll of Ih. IQ" MlIIV*', If .ny, .. ~,' , .' ~'Ph p.l'8nl IIhll\.ll<< InfQrm thl! 1I1h'f' Q . h" Of hit' r\lll aenlif AOO .mplQYm'nl~MII' III"~ 1"'PlIon. nlllOOt. r. 1alKlt1. PlllffJO' IIhmlld W, n pQ..lbl., III ~dvl.. t.h .. Ill"" Qf Ih. dtallnallon '11<<"'''' 1In<l It"Pho~:ro~~tQNlIwn,' . '. ," ': 4. . I If Kim nltll Qf ~lIllQm'8 In~mPtI'nt, ,I. d'l.rmlnld ~y,,, ~rt. of '.w, It ool.lrt llf' oomp.l.nl Jllr',llllltllln 1Ih(ll.lld lIppmnt IIn " IIIPPmpr/alll lJulllm~n 11M Cl4l"lldkln fpr Ih. c:I1lld, Rlmald 'hollld I1<lHIIOf.Im' Ihe ' Qijl!wl/.lnQfIl(,'lIlod"n Wllhoul JIlclIIlI/ilIIlPPTQVA' P' "'''lime, .. .. . . \. . el, ' I Ronlil'lf IIMI.4l<f bo !\OlIfltllf .nd "Ilow 10 l".nd Iholll 1I~1 .v.",. wI1 h Kim qllemll IIPPfQprtlllll 10 . ~vllle 'him "' And Invll. hIm tQ, . . 'Q, . .' . \ RQn.kl'h~"1d 1\0\ ~.V8I1CIlIl"lIlo Ihlt ohlld', m8<l1oll1 .. It tKOfIpt "'lI{Irl. /ly Klmln _ WT1llnQ .Ion.d by hllr, Kllflllhpuld. hIlWUlQmp",. .ooe.. 10\t1UlImll,. ,. ", .. '.. ,7, ~oulln81 glllllh parllntllllQuld provlr,f8proPfjr MuUne .htll/ttl. and dllnt./ CI4!"to lfle ~eidCld WhNa under lhe un.upervlQd IlOnt~ pf Illal parenl, " ... '. .' . 8,. : I<lm 'I1QU~ nlllllY Ronald of ,11\0" Uln..se. IoU hwr'-lIu.t.IMd b I,", ct11 81'M! d~8 "PPl'OIlrla!.Q, Ronald IIhllUl<f :' , nQllfV KIm ',of III" ,Hln..... ,1M fnJUlWt. ,u.,.llItll by ,the child while, In hili unllUp.rvl.~ ' contrPI, '/. , , " ' . 0, , MldiPlll QOI,lI,lQllIll Kim .hould noll'y ,Ronald 01 Ilny Plllptllllcl mldklail Ilotlll for Ihl ohlllf 'I' -he d.-mil, approPriate, ' However, 'mlrpnoy.ClIf.'I ~y /It IUlloorlzCld Wffhoul the olhtr p.,.nl'. prior oon"'nl, 1Q, ..~I Kim 1/IQu/q ohPQ.. thl .pproprlale madl(1llf pf1)vldlfll fpr If1Q Qhlfd, ' " .11, . aG/1OOI R~II Kim 'hou!d hllV8 full ~1I"o the Mild'. lohool recordll, Ronallf IholJl<f ~ PfOI(ldlld too.. \llOOrd. tll". KIm deem. approprlllto, ' .. 12,. &ttnd'~,1I SCltIOllI, ThlChHd currently at\erdl publlo l(lnOO'I Fulure d"thlllln~ ~II\\J the tol\OOl, .Uernlld b the ohlld .Ihoukl be maqll by Kim, 13, I KIm IIh<>uld ,.'lICI .nd IInrQII Ihe chNd In IlOhool and ol'Olnllld . el .hll dleml appropriate, . III. OHII.P 8UPPORT OhUdSupport 'h.. been ord'red In penn8YIv8nl~\ and, II 8hould rllm_ln .. ... ord.~ theMIn, , . ,., e Of thle propoeedpl.n, 'I I' " " " ~~ Oat_ ~, I 'i.< " , 2 " , " ", ", I: :'" "', , \I'oI"IoIl;il'''j.iiltl'(,'.''lll:..t..",., . ' ej, If-' /,1............., ..~."" " , 1,'1111 ' I q,!, I.!. . " '.,. i'. I' " \",1 .1", , " 1 i. r /I i , ,. .I") I' , ) ri: (.l)i I',: )"i i.l" .I' l':1 "., I' I; \~J I .,',.. c.n" 'I"' '11'f'j , : ~ ,J \1,10-. ,':4' '.. I,F' I" 1-" ':J , , ,'::i 0 "F ~ Q g N ~l ~ GJ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~'~ ~ ~ ~.~ ~ m ~ (~ ~' ~ ~ ~ : I' (:1 ~ l!I F, " n: 0: <( :v Iii " " j" Ii ,: ",. " " " ,I' , -..----- " , ., JIIl{; .I IUIH\, ) , I "I ,f' " I . 1I1'~1I, W\wn 1\111 111'11~UI' Ill' JlIIIIIllI.ri"~ pUlllllln IH unnHlll\ll'oll, IIIH ol~III'lhll\ mnH\ HIIIIIII'\~1I11\ \Ivl~lon~lI with 1'011111'11111 Fllllwl"H cllllm fill' plll'llul C\'H'IlII~ 11\ Ihu HIIIl1IlWI' 111111 nWI' Chl'lHlmllH cl;IHIH In IIw CIIl1\\wl'llIl1\l COIIIll~ III'CII,' 7, \lUI1I1H~'IVII1\11I IVIIH \Iw hnmc HIIIIC (;i' \1111 uhllllll' 11111 IInw \hlll \hlH UI1H\(III~ pl'oucullllll1 IVIIHIlIlmI1WIlIlUIIII1I!l!l9, , ' ~, ..IIIH 1I1111\IIICII 111111 Ihc uhllll hllH 110\ I'u'iil\\ud 111 PunnH~11'1I1l111 HI1\1l1l ,'lImllll'~ 1999, 11 . , " 'I~ Ihl11lOlllhllt 1\10 \1uHt 111\IlI'UH\ Ill' \IwulIlIl\ wllllw HUI'I'lI\llf MIHHnlll'llIHHIIIllUH .II11'IHlllullll1\ nl' thlH uhlld ull,H\lul~ Ilutul'll1l1mllol), .'\'lwl'o IH HII\IHIIII1I1I1I evlllunou cnl1cul'1\II1I1I11O 1'1I1111'1l CIII'U, pl'n\\lc\lon, \1'1I11111111111\\11101'HOIlII'\ I'clllllllllHhlpH nl' tho cl1l\lll1\ CIII1\\1UI'IIII\\1 CO\1l1\~, PUIlIlH~lvllnlll:; . I'. .' 9, AIIil11l\clL , 10, 'J'IIIHIH II cnnclnHlon of IIIIV I'CIIIIll'lIlIIllollnH\I'lII', n~ IVllyof 1\1I'\lIul' III1H\WI', MIHHolll'lmllHIIIII'lI PullnH~lvlIl\llI'H ulIHlml~ du\ul'mll1l\llonl\11I I'lIhh 1111\1 cl'udH IIml MIHHO\II'I11IIR110 " . ,. 'H' /. ., ,. )lIrlHdlcllllll II~ 11111d1lY PcnnH~lvlll1ll1'H clIslmly Ol'dUl'slllollllllS \huulllld IH II\lHCI1' from POl1l1H~\VIIIlIII \1uUII\lHO lll' I1IH l'ul1\nvlll \l~ his Mllthul' IIml Hn Inll!!IIH 111111\01' cnl1\hlllUH In'lIvo \n , ,. " PenllHylvllllllI, 21:1 \.I,S,C,^, ,Soctlnll173K ^ (PIII'CIlIIIIKldllllplll!! pl'uvul1tlnn ^ct), PCllllHylvlIlll1I , ' Is illHn Ih\l 1l1OHt IIPl1l'0(ll'IIIIU 1'1lI'ml1't!) dUlo;:l1\lllu \111\11III"s CllIlIl1 I'nl' PIII'11i11 CIIHI;ul~ dlll'lll!! Huhm;1 ., ' ,I )'j: VIICllllollS, I 1 ~ It IH IIdmlltud 111111 PUllnHylvlIllhl IR IlI~W 1111 \IlUOllvol1lulll f01'l11l1 l'ul' Mnlhul', This Is. " 'dllC 10 Mo\l1ll1"s OIVlllICllol1H 111\11UVhl!! cI1l1d I'l'nm thuuhlld's hlllllU swtu, MlsHllur\ Is JUHI liS ,- ' ",,, , ' .... 'lllCO\1vulllullt II 1'01'11111 1'01' J1l1tl1lll' to Ihl!!lItu hlH Clllllll 1'01' )1111'11111 cllslmly, . " 12, NllllllHlVor I'Ullllll'ud, Pllthol' ruslslH IhlH SU!!!!uS.tloll, '13, It Isdu\1lod Ihllt 1IIIIIIuI"s CIIIIIll I'll\' 11111'\1111 oUHt(l(l~ IH IllllllYWllY hUllul'ltud '\I~ , ' , . Jlllthul"s lIuthHIH III MlssnUI'111l April I 999, , ;" I \'Vrlf~ (hilI lIw sllIl\lIlWl1ls 11111'10 In llw l\lrogoll1g ~'1l0\II1Wl1lnrllll'llllllllllc\lI'l'QPI, I 1IIlIIIlI'HlIlI1li lhlll flllso sllllllllWIlIshol'lllllnro 1111\\10 sllh.loo\ Illllw pOl1llllllls\ltlH Pn,C,H, ij 4904, rolinlll!! 1<1 IIIlSworn I\llslrtllnlhll1l<1 1\\llhol'lliIlH, PATH: '75....c;2.... 0'0 '-f?~.,t:,~ f,. ~;,'1",01~ HOllnld r\, 110111101' , " 'j_ 'I " d,", (I ,', \,', ;;' d' .', " .. " ," (' .. " d'" ,Ii " i' ! ":1 " " ' , II " \' ,t:' 'i, .. ';, , , " , '" " PI, ,I ,,' ,. 'I I; 1', , I' " " /'1. I ,i ";"'.\",: "",: .,',' ,','. ' ,,' , ,,' ,'. ;'"" " " ' '~tJI\'~:I~~~~;ijt~Wl~J~\'!h~l~ljll'h'f 11:~';;~:t ~t?YnlQUlN~'~~~'IIf.4'r'nlr{jf,t!I~~~l\I;'\'H I.. lil"J:!~;'i~ Mt\ '(I,: \JOn li'\ ;l!I',!ii'f..1 "'~":\'tiKf'('" . ...~ (t'tf ' ." )1'>I;"':11',,:\. ~W{~;~~jl,\~~f~~'~li",~~Y~/~J'::.J:l~W\[;~lf;\! . "l,"'\1:"'(:1rtl'";,,/lf!"~"I" 'ttA:a. IAft" llld,fl\:\\l~lt;,;, ',' '"., " "'" ('!II"" ~, ""'. ,,', "'><,th '1." C',1," :L'~!.?:.I"\"I"\'\""^""':"',,,,, U":,';" "It fI,~:_'r IO;~,' ;,1l:~,,;jf,f,\~, jilt" ,(: ", ,I fir:-:, ".. " .' j , . '." " ',. "j, " " il 11: " " , III I' {\; !i " " (I' I, oj; ;, I, I' , "p'. " p " it .' i" "'" '" ," " "" " ," ! , , \ (I t\ " RONftLP R, PITINNRR. ' L'lAJ.n\:iff; v, I~IM ~,NGI!HlIl, ., , Pet:entjfln\: , IN, '\'IIUl COUI~'\' OU' cOMMoN PI,I!1Ml OW I CUM13lilRI,I\NP COUN'\'Y, PIi1NNaYWl\NIf\ I I , I , 90-1003 CIVIL ~~RM ! " ,J 'QBDER' Oli' OOlJH'l' " I\NP 'NoW, t:hi.s 101:11 dAY of ,)\me, 1999'; t:h~ pat\'1rnAI " gr/.jndmothep haV1,l1g filed a patl.l:i.on sel'!ki.ngperiocl!3, of , ' visit~t!on, wil:h her. Qrancl!3on, Ronalcl mugene Penner, III, born J<1nullry 4, 1993, tha t pet.t Uon is w.l\:hc\rAwn without pl:e'j uc\i.oe, i' ~ '\,." ,. ., ", ;j ;' '.1 LiS/1 Marie ooyne, ml3quire, COYNITI & CO'fNliI, P,C, " 3901 Market ~treet Camp lUll, 1.'1\ 1'7011-4227 "Counsel for I?laintHf ,,'" c..rrp-.......:.- ~,\ \,,:,\ , "fV'. a-' Q . L~'I ..L ',!'" D<1rilel M, Mysl1in, illsquire ~OOO,L.tnglestown Roact, Slli~e 305 IIArdl3burg, PI\,. 17112-9507 ao"nsel for Pefendant 1', It! ':j " .. ,,' 'I, " " " n\rn()lliCli 0;: "l" 1"'(' 1("")'!'N1'I 1'- ..".II!', ';"" F,IIY I 0 , (,II \\1 H \ I,ll) q, C\Jli,l.',j,q\.:'l'i,) cOlli'wl " . I'l:~IH:;Y1 YN IV\ . " :i " ')1 "I' " " " Ii " .. ill " " " , " 'i, I; " '," " " " r,. '" " "1' ..,- " " .. " " .. q " :i " .. " ,.J' " q " " " " .. ,j' .. ,I' , " I; " !! I' .. 1\ .. II "i" 'f " , " " " " " " .. " ii' " H,. " " I ~ Jj H'_ " " ill if " " ,." " !i " '.' Ji " ,', Ii " " " " .~ ' " I, ~: On April \, I 000 Ih~ pllnl~H 1111\\ lh~lr 1'~HI1PpIlY\l \lolllli1\11 11I\~11I1~\\ \lIIHIPlly \lI1I1PI\lIlII~lll ". , . " ,_ ,,'I \I\llllilrOllo~ \1PrOrO Mloh\l~1 n,nl\l1llH, !iHq,Allho oOIlI\Jr\ln'~\lI Ihl' pllllloH wor~ IIIlIl\lI\l 1\1 ' , , r\lH\;IY\lIlIlY IHH\lPH r~l:IlIr\\Illll Iplllllor pllYlllclIl C\IHII1\IY," (I, 011 April 1\, 1!l00 Flllhc1' WIIH lII'ro>>\ollll1 Ih~ SIII\1l \1l'MIHHI1\1\1 Oil Iho ~lllInJP ofpll1'\lI1\1I1 " .. kl\lllllpplllj! IIH II 1'oH\l1I or FII\lW1"H 1111 11111 pi 1\1 1\lrclbly IlIkll YPIIIlI:I I~Pllnlp Ihllll'M\llhlli"1I " CIIH\n,ly wllhnHllwr cnllHIlI1l. 7, 011 April ~I\, 11)1)1) FlIlhor WIIRIIITIlHlm\ by PII, ,)omllY O'f)nlllloll nflho Wo"1 Shnro 1~01:l1n11111 ,- ' .. " ,. , Pnll\l~ I)~pllnl11~1l1 \111 ()UI ~hllrllcs, PlII'hlB Iho Olllll'lIll of his lIITOSI, Fllllwr 1It1l1pko,1 Iho: " . , , ,: poll\10 ,9mOOI"lIl1\1 OHCIIPO\I. Flllhor III OllrrOl1lly Inollro~rllled 111 Ih\lClllllbcrllll1ll Cn\III1Y'prisol1' onOhlll'!l~1I or 1I1:11:11'l1Vlllocl IIHsl\\11I on n p\1l1oo llmOCI', rOHIHlll1ll, lIITOHI, PSOIlPO, PUI, 11111\ PI1HlloHslnn of n HI111111111110llnl 01' 111nriJlinnll. jI 8, A OIlHlody hOllrlnl:llH Hohocllllp\\ b\llllr~ Ihlll Courll1l1 ,111110 10, 11)01), , ' 0, Flllhor, Molhorlllld yOlll1g l~nnlllo hllve nol b~on ovnlHlllod, 10, Molhor bollovos IIl1d lhorofnl'o IIY\lI'S',lhlll uno lll'lhp Hor\nlls ISHlIOS 10 bo o0l1sldol'Ql1 by tho COllrt Is Flllhor'H propol1l1ity Ihr Irrnllol1nlbohrtvlllr,nl1d physlonl v\nlono,o liS clomol1slrlllod by Fl\thor's April 4, 11)1)1) IIltollllll to kldl1np YOUllg \tnlll1\o 1)'0111 Iho Stnto 111' Missouri, liS \\,OIlIlH Fnlhor'H April 24, 11)1)9 IIggrllvnlpd nSlIlllllt of IInd oscnp~ 11'11111 n polloo ,;01001' dllrlng Ihp , 00111'110 ol'n Cllmborlnnd COllnly, ponnsylvnl1ln DUll\lHlsl, II. 'I'hrollgh Iholrl'ospoollvo oOllnsol, Molhol' hns 1'0'llloSIod Fllthor In pnrtlolpnto In nn 'Indopondonl ol1llrl:ol'dprcd psychologlonl oVlllullllolllo bo porlbl'lllcd hy Dr. SllInloy Sohnpldor or Olll,dllllOO Assoclllloll, 412 El'lhrd ROlld, GIIIllP 1-1111, POllnsylvllnlll, Mothor hns IIISIl rO'lllolllodlhnt Fllthol' plIyllls shnro of 1110 oo~l~ of Ihls oVlIlllnllon III lIoconlnnoowlth tho 1'1\1'11011' ;'ospcotlvo net l1H111thly Incomo~,__ " " J1t1nll~h'llcllllcr 111)1111\111 1:IIII'W~I\lllllllh:IIII~"Rlllllllllll Mar-!, I~~'J 3 " , I " I~. Pl'. H~hll~lll~1' IHwpll klll1Wllln IIw COliI'! IIW nil PWol'I nmply 1111111111011111 11Pl'lilflll II ~hlhl " " ~llHll1lly payphl1ln~lol\1 OVII 1\1111 hlll , PI', Rolnwlllol' hila 111111PII1\l11 thllllw \lll.ll \lVIII\lIlI\l thp plll'tl\lH " .. , 1I1l111'\llmnt wlln\latloa 1I111111P tn pl'\lplll'\lll l'\lpnl'! 1l1l1llvlIl1\lo 111' th~ HOhOlllllolllWlIl'll1l:1 '1IIIIp, PI', ~phn\llll\ll' IHlS HOI,IOlhIIPII Mnlh\ll., 1~lll1nl\l lilHllI1omh\lI'H PI' Ilwll'Iml1WIIIII'IO l111nIlY.fbl' oVIII\IIIIII1I1H Ilmll1l! tho wO\lkol1ll Il( MI\Y 15, 1 !Jl)(). , p, Fl\Ihol' In\s Iml'ollslll1l1hly 1'01\1s\l11 III a\lhmll III Iho oVlIlHllllnn hr PI'. Rohl1\llllol', Ylllhol' hllH ' " nl1'ol'oll no l\llllllly s\llllpl\lI1I11I'Il\lIllIH tpl' IIIHCjlllllll1ollll\l1l or PI', Rohno\dol', " , 1'1, Fllthol' hilS pl'\lpoHod nn\lth\ll' pHyphol\lIlIHI wh\lIH llIllIOC\lp\llhlo III M\llhpl' 111 t1w PI'OHOIl1 \lIIHO 101' Hov\ll'lllrOllsoI1H: WFl\lhor'a psYPh1llllglH\ IH \Illlillnllll\l' wllh tho 1'0llllll'01lWIIIH 111'11 Utl/hpl' h\llwlnll; (2) PI', Sohl1oldol' IHn 11101'0, oxporlol1ood Owol't wlll10ss thl\ll I1111hol"H pHyoh\lIClBlst 11\11\ hns 10slll1od hol'olo th\l C\ll11borllll1d CO\lllly oOllns In slllllll1clIl1t1y maI'O oO!l\os\\lII. ~hlld p\ls\mly ovnhll\tllllls 111 lIH1n Fnthol"s psyoholnlllHt, m Pl\thor's I\syohololllsl la\llll\h'll to pl'Oplll'O 1111 ovnl\lntl\l11111 time Ihl' tho scholl\llod hOllrlng (h\lo, Wllllo 1J1'.<Rohnoldol' la IIhlo 10 . '/ ' 1I00011111\\)[llIto tho Com! 'Ii HOI\OII\llo; I\l1d, (4) Fl\thol"a psychnlolllal roq\llros l11\lltlplovlalts with Iho ohlld In tho P\lslody (;1' ol\oh p",'oll\, 1I11111ll\COOplllblo 1'0'1\l11'01110ntlllll11ht or Fl\thor"~. April 41h 1I1\0ll1Ptollporol\iol'kldl\lIppll\!l chl\l'lloa Il\tl1o RIOlo or MISHl1\1rlnllll curl'ol\tll1onrcomtlon, I'" .. for, l\llll!'nvntod I\HHlIllllol1l\l\d oscllpo Ih1ll1 n CUl1lborllll1d COUl1ly pollco ollleol' lbllowhlll FlIIhor'~ April 241h PUIIIIToal. , '15: M;lthor bollovoH nl1d \horofbro nVOl'H Ihnl 11'0 oOl11plOllol1 of II pHycllOlolllcnl ovnl\1l1llol\ I\l1d , subsoqllolH roport 1I1\((roCOllll11ol\dl1tlol1 by Dr, Schnuldor \Voultl HOIVo'lll dl'lllllntlonlly movo , this on so to\Vnrds sclllol11ol\l, or III IOl\slllorro\V Iho.lsHucs for IrllIl. FIII'lhor, Mothor bollovos fhnt n Colll'! ol'dored IlsychololllclIl, ovnluntlol1, by Ill'. Schnoltlol' will IIsslst ")~ COUl't h\ ''''llli.'''I''''.." 1',lIllllIllill 1"l'<h<1'"ltlco' I\1'.I..nll<111 4 MII~"1111)IJlJ ' :1", "- Cll ~: /.." 1t'1; ,,' ....t 1,.,I:i: " ::)"n ..... ..- (,_)1:,1 '".li"-:; :t'~: LJ:.!, rj: :',. ,..:~ '::1;;') f.,)L, ,." ':..'l;:j (1),'1 I . 'i,~; 1;;',', -,. IIi" :t., " (t,j (,: u',) "!}J(.\, 1 "tIS' T \)'\ j fll 0 ,,(II \i " " ';,i< ."" " ,. I' " " "d " " " d' .. " ., p .1. " " !' H " .. !I ",. "t. " 'fi ,. .. '. '."! " , ,I' .. , , .. " -. I' \i " iI, 'j, .. " " " " 'I' "j, , I ",* ~ " ('(f' . II' , " " . ~ . ~~&~ \. ~ ~ ~~. U~ ~ i5 I; Q 5 g ~ );~~~ I 8 ,. 15 L 1/ " ~ If) , ,ti s 'm tIl..~ M]I~ (~ ~, , i ~ l]I~lli, 'El8' r:\~ , "n., '. .~ .,' " " d ,!' ! " ", I ','1' " I 'I " 1 I >I' I \ I; ,. " \ 'I I " I:' I' .' ". , ",'I I " , ! " " " .. " \ ." I I", ! , I I \ " " I, t, \ 'I \ \ I' i,I' I " I ',. ," ill jJ' ,,'" 'Ii ,',' 'I, d I , " \ \' ;/, " A',' ,I' , , ,;i' " " , i " IN TIIII COUI\T OF COMMON I'I.r\t\~ OF C\JMUl.\I\I,ANll CO\JNTY. I'IINNHY1,V ANI^ CiA Yl,n V. ntINNIlI\, I'u\llllllwr ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) CIVil, ACTION. cliil'l'OIlY . v' Nil, 1)1),\003 Civil RONt\I,IlIl. IWNNlllt, Jlt IIIl1I I\IM M. I1NCiI.\Hll, l\uspollllUllls " OIlI)lm ANllNOW, Ihls _____ IIIIY of J\lllu, \999 \IpOI1 uonslclorlltlo\l of MO'nmR's ..^NHWllll TO I'lrrrrlON 1'01\ Cil\ANPMI\IlN'I' VIS1T^TION I\NIl I'IU\I,IMINA\W OIlJllCT10NS. 1"1\lIlollur, GA VW V, IlIlNNHll, IlIuks slll\lllln!l p\ll's\llln\ 1\1 23 I'II.C.S,A, , ' , ~~313 10 Join 111 thu prusu11l1l9llon, or hrlll!! III l)ul' own rl!!I1I. ,IIPullllon li1ronmilpllrul\\ Vlslllltloll, wllh ruspuul \0 lhumlnor uhlld. IlONAI,!) B. IlENNHll, Ill, Thu l'ollllol1 for ,', . Ornndpllrul11 Vlsllllllol1lslhorolhru lllsmlsRUlI wllh proJudluo, llV TIlE COllRT ----------------.--' J.. I, I' I' .. " "01 ,. "" , 'I ')1 ' ~ .\, ' , " " 1':IIl\ll~hl(\"'\\C' III lll\yll) t'1l1ll111l\11l1 JUliO K. 11)1)1) I) ,'(" iI' " , , . , . , ," " ,I' jllll'Ollllllllhllsol lIo~lool, Ilnlg nl' nIO(lhllll\hIlHO Ill' l119nllllllhwsH nH 1'0'11111'011 III glvo Pollllllnol' Hlllmllng P\II'H\IIII\I III 2:1 PII.CJ.SoA. ~~~ 1 ~(h), Whllp Fnlhol' IIvps \Vllh 11011\1(11)01' IIml \'Iltholllll oomplolo PHYohnlo~lonl oVllhlll"lnll qr.. ." . , I . Fl\llwl' wilh I'ol\pool \0 Flllhpi"s Pl'opollslty Illl' Il'l'nllnll!\1 hohllVIIlI', phYHlonl vlnlonpo 1I1l11 1I1011hnlll1111 II\'\IU IIlnlHo, vlftltllllnn with ,Polltlonpl' Is nul. 111 thohos\ III\oI'OHIH or yn\1I1~ I~onnlo i , ' IInll will IIl1Pl'fol'o willi tho plIl'lIIll-ohll\1 I'olllllllnfthlp \lplwoon Mlllhol' nnd ylllll1!! I~(lnnlo i" . ,. " IIp.nylllg Pollllollol' ft\llmllng PllrH\llInl to 2J PlI,c,S,A, ,*~,1IJ(I\), . IIIH I\ll'\hol' IIpooll1olllly PIlNI\lJ) Ihlll 111\11191' hlld Hhlll'od ollfttmly nfyo\ll)g Ronnie, '1'\1 tho opnll'lIl'y,l1nlhol' hllH llQY.Q1: IISH\1I11Od IIny of PIII'Olllllll'oHpllllHlhllltl\lH with I'~HP\lOIIO yoU II!! I~Olllllo, l'l'lpl' 10 I1l1n!!1I Cqll1pllllnl rol' C\IHIl1I1y llllh\l IIhovo I1\lll1hol' 111111101'111, Fllthor hllft " llQY~ tnkoll IIny IIml'lllllllvc Htcp 1\1 cxol'olHcl'lghlH of physlolll UI' Icglll o\ISlody wltll I'OSpcot 10 I Yll\l11g I~PlInlo, Thoro hllVll IUW.QJ: hoon III\Y \IIHO\llllllons, IIgl'cclllonls 01' \lIldOl'stlllldlngs, writ Ion /.' . ,. " 01' llI'lIl, holwoon.FIIIIlIll' IIn\1 Molhol'l'cglll'dlng IIhill'od o\lstody \11' Y\)\Ill!!I~Ol1nlc. Thcl'o hilS I . . . l\!lY.Qt hoon II c\lftlody ol'llcl' gl'lIntlng shl\rod o\lstmly c,f'Y\1\lng Ronnlo ontcl'od 111I1I1Y 00111'\. . 'I, 1 : Ills 1\II'Ihol' IIpooll1ol\lIy mlNIlW thlll Mdthol' lI11d chll\llIbl'\ll1lly dopnl'tc\1 f)'PI11 Ihls , COl11nmnwolllth, To Iho contl'lll'Y, 1111 IllOI'O IIpocll1Olllly Rot forth III Molhcr'lI AlIswol' 10 , " COl11pllllnt lor ClIlllody, IIlId IIll'thor Incorpo\'lIto<! h\ll'oln by rcfo\'oncc, Motho\, ndvlHcd Flllhcl' IInd pctltloncl' Mhor Intolltlonll wollIn IIdvllnoO \If'hol' IllOVO to Mlllllo\ll'1. II 'I' \), DBNIED, It IB 'lIpooll1olllly PBNIHDlhll1 on~)r IIbulll JUIlUury 21,' I \)\)\), without udvllnoc .. 1I0tloo to 1IIIIhol' 01' potltlul1\l\', Muthcr \'ollll1V~d yOUl1g Ronnlon'olll PonnllYlvllnlll, IInd moved' " lIvol'lllght lol~ochcpo1't'; MIIIsuurl with u nU111 tlllIl Bho hnd kn\lwl1lol' \lllly II brloflllllO. '1'0 tho oOlltl'lll'Y, IIR 1lIOl'l1 lI(loclt1cnll~ sot lhrth hI Motho\"s ^nllIVOI' tu C0ll1lllnlll1 for Custmly, lIlId Hnnll~hf"II~W~lln (lllyl" l'1lI111ll/\lnl Jlllluk,IC}I)l) t' ~ I, " , ,l\ll'Ih~r hwnrpnrlll~\llwr~111 \lY r~liJr\lIHJ\l, Mplhor IHlvl~\l11 Fll\h~r 111111 polillonor \If l\Ilr " " hl\lll1llnl1a W\lll111 IHlvl\Iw\l nl'lwr I11IWIlln MlaanHl'I. Funhllr In Ihp 1l11I11rllry, 10 Ihll 1l1I1\lnl r\lIIlVIII1I, Mnlhor rllllllllll1ahhl wl\h QllORQH , .. H'I'I~OIIMnYlm hila hlllln 1111 nl1!!pll1~ rollllll111Hhlp 1l>;I\llHlhm IWIlI' I11I111y I1Hll1lh~, 1 q. ilia 1I111111111l1l111ll1 Fllll\Ol' ~1~111l\11Il\l Yorll1llllll\lI11111 FqhnllllY 12, Il)l)l) IImlllw C\1Inplllll1l wlIa I1lml nn Jlcbl'l1l1ry 24,' \ opo, II. UJ:INllllJ. II IK Kpooll1clllly 1)I1NlflP q1\1\ IIIK 111 11\\l hPHllnlorOKI nr Y\lUI1!! I\olmll' lhlll hll " .. ' 11l\Vo VIKIIIIII\lI1K wllh pollIl\lI\Or, '\'0'11\0 conll'luy, whllp FlIlhor IIvoH wllh 1'~IIII\ln\lr 111111 without II COl11pl(ilo pKychlllo!!lolIl cVllhll\llnll nr F(I\h~r wllh rOal1cllI ,In Fl1lhcr's prnpol1sllY 1111' .. , Irl'llllnnl1l hohllvlpl', phy~lclIl vllllcncc IInlllllcnhollll\lIl1l'11!! IIbua\l, vlslllltllln with P\Jllllul\cl' la ! .. .... .. j. nnl Il1lhc \lCKlll1lo\,\JHIK \lfy,oUI1!! 1\01\1110 111\11 \volllll hllol'lbr~ wllh Iho pl1ronHJhlllll'oll1tlllnshlp bolwool\ M\1lhor'lmll ymllm I\ol\nlo, dOl1yll\!! I'ollllollcr KllIlHtln!! pmslllll\l 10 ~3 I'II,c,S,A, !jS3 \:1(11), p, 12. PIlNlEll II Is Hpoclt1cllllY 1)I?NlI1J) Ihl1111 IK,II\ Iho bOKI 111101'08101' youn!! Ilonnlo Ihlll ho 1111111\Inll\ 1II'011111011Shlp wllh Pol.l1101101', '1'lllho CI1nll'IIIYI whllo Flllhlll'lIvos with pOlltlonor nllll .., .. wlthoullI cOl11plolo"Ps~cholll!!lonl CVlIlUllllol\ or Fnlher wllh rospoc,llo Flllhor's pI'OpOI\,~ltt for , Irl'lIllol\lIllwhnvlol', pl\Y~lclIl vlolol\co I\lIl1nlcnhollll1ll <l1'1I!! IIbusc, vlsllnllol\ with Pollllol1ol' IH , 1101111 Iho bOKI II\t'ol'osla ol'yoUI\!! 1101111 III 111111 woulll hllol'lol'o wllh Iho Pllrol\l~chlld l'olllilonshlp bel ween Mothor IInd youn!! Ronnlo, dOl\yhl!! PollIl<lnol' HllIndhl!! PUI'Sllllnt ,to 23 I'II,C,SA 'r.] 1]( ')' !j." . II. .. . I:!. DENIUD, II Is ,spooll1clllly DENIHD Ihllt Molhol' IIblUp\ly <loPI\IIod n'Ml .lhlH 'I, I! COllllllonwOllllh, To lho conI rillY, liS IllOI'\) sjlOc\l1Clllly SIlt tbrth' In Molhol"H Allswel' III ,. ." l(jl(\ll,.h'I'n~Wct In {Jl1ylll t'nlllplllhil "'- ,~III1~ HI 191}fJ ''4' 1<' r\ll11pl!lll\I !i1l' C'Iij\mly, 111111 III \'liw \' hWl1l'l1nrll\plllwr~111 hy rpl~r~lI~p, N\nlhp\, mlvlsp!1 Flllhpr' 111111 Pu\lIlnl\pr nl'lwr ill\ul1l1Plls wullll1l\!lVlIlIPp nl'hur l11nvu 1<1 MlsHn\lrI, 14, nnNIHll IIlij spo\Jll1ollllY nllNllif) Ihllll'o\l\lnl1or's 0\1\1I18ul plwlll\lijlylnll1l'I1ioll Mnlhur's! PIl\II1Hlllpl' \hp pu"dhm \191111111\. 1111' llI'lI11\\pllrpl1\ vlsllllllpll, nr Ihlll Mll\hur 11118 rplIIHu!1 . rlinHPl1l1hhi'. rUf\ll!lHlij Ill\, vlHllllllpl1,' Tn Ihu 011l1\l'1I1'Y. liS. Hul !ill'lh 111 111\1 11111\01\01\ onrrullpn11\lol1\l0 119\\vcoll \l11l1l1801 dnl\lll t\prll'f7, 30, IIIl1I MnY'3, I DOc) M!lllw\' hnij nlli1rdnll .' ,. . 1'\lllllpl1or \,0"aI111lIhlp pprll1\IH \11' 11111\1 ,wl\hY\1\11l1l 1\\1nl1lo whl~h hnvu'h~ol1 \lnrollij\lmlhly \'olllspd hy Fnlhp\, I1l1d PoIIII\1I1\lj;. .. WIIHI\I\FOlll!, RIlHI1\1l1dul1l. I\IM M, liNGlASII, rosppolnllly roquoH\S Ihls Court 1\1 1'1110111111 Polhlol1or, aA YI,,11 V" nnNNnl\, IlIoks ,slllmllllll p\l1'sUIIIlI 10 23 I1I1,C.S,A, !iSiI3. III jlllll hI Iho (iI'OSOIlI nolloll Ibr o\Islody, Ill' hrlllg Illh~i: IlWI1 rlllhl, n po\l\ll1n Ibl'Orlllldpllronl . ' " Vlsllnllon ~ll' Iho 1I111l01'0hlld, ItONAI,\) n. nllNNIlI\, 111, lIIHI\\1 dlsllllss Iho Inslnnt polhllln ' . whh prpjuIlloo, " .. '\j .. rJUll.lMI1'W\'y'_OLUUCTlQNS AN\) NOW;' 001110H I\OHP\1Ilc\OIlt. I<-IM M.,BNOI,ISl-I, hy nnd Ihrough hol' 1I1\01'l10YI' , ' " J:>1\1l101 M.Myshln, Bsq., who I110s Iho wllhlnPllHl,IMIN^IW OBJECTIONS 1\1\I1111111iOlho fhllow/,Ill\ nvortnonlH III s(lppl1l'I Ihol'ool': IS. Pnrllgrllphs 1 II1rollllh 14 or .tv1Olhol"H t\NSWElt TO PBTITloN FOR ,Oll^N1JllAllI1NT VISI'I'A'I'ION .l\l1d 1\11 Ill' tho I\yorlllon\s of Mplhpr's ANSWEIl TO COMPL^INT FOil ", CUs~rOf)Y nro IIlCOI'pornled horoll1 hy rororol1oo I\H l,fllloro fillly sot Ibnh IM'oll1, 16, YUlll1llllol1lllo hilS llQY.!.![ llvod wllh \1o,tl1lol1or Ihl' l\ porlml uf\wolvo (12) .Illot1\hs 01' 1ll0l'ol)s I'oqllll'od hy 2~ Pn.C,S.^, !i5313, to Illve Potltlnllol' SII\IHIII1Il 10 11I1Ilg n Polltlol1 1'01' , OI'nndpl\l'ollt VIS\tlllloll,O ; HlllIU~hl,'"~wclln (In'ylu Clll1llllnl", ~.lInu H. IW') . 5 , Wlllil~lwnl~l\, 1~~>>llll1l\l~nl, 1\11'11 1'11', I!NW"I~II, r~>>p\l\lIl\llIy I'oll\i~al>> Ihl>> C~l1\11'1 In 1'\llp " Ihllt.11\l\Ulnl1\lI'I OA Yl-n y, l\I\NNlll~, h\\lk>> Hlllmlhlll P\\I'H\1I111111\2~ Pn.(~.R,A. ~fi~ n In jnln Inllw pl'~H~nl IIcllnl1, 01' \11'1\1l1hlll\lr I1W\1 r1!!h(, II 11\l1\11111\ 1i1rnl'llllllpm;vlII YI"llnllnll, wilh I'\lHp\l\ll 1;1 Ih\l ml\1ol' phllll, l~nN^I~p u. IHiNNI~g, IIl.nmlllnlhur. In \I\HI11I"H lho h)~"\Il\ P\llhlnn l\lI' mlll1llpllr\lnl \'IHI""lol1 wllh Ill'\\hllll\lll. \~\lHpuc\l\,lIy >>\1\1\1\llIu\I, ,. ,; 1().;~J~li~~" ' p~, -~1)i~ili!l; j3Hli~"-":-'-' , ^"n\'l1oy Ihl' '~OHpll\ll\lIll, Kim M, 11l1gllsh PII,R\lpr\lI1W enUrll\) 11'10366 4ROO l"I\1!!loHIOWI1I~OIl(I, Rullo 30$ llllrl'lshul'!!, PA 17112"9$07 71M4H4fil 717.541-54571\\x P. " v~mIllICA'I'ION I yorllY Ihlll Iho HIIII0l11011lH Imido' horoll1 111'0 11'\10 111111 oorrool, I \1I11101'8111nd (IHlI 1\\181l < " . ,- ." 8(IIIUl11onl" '1111\110 heroll1 Ill'll I11l1dll >>'lbjoOI 10 Iho p\lI1I1UI08 of I R PII:C.S,A, ~4904, rolllllll!! (0 11118W01'l1 n\lsltlollllonl!1l\\lIhnrltloH. ., __~11(!l~L_ Dlllo " .. , Kliii"M, 1!11l!1I8h------- " '" " ' I' 1':I'ltll~IIII'Il,\wlltl(llI).I\l CUll1l)lnlnl .IUII\! MllfJI)I) " , 7 " " , ~'."~ll,J""'i"""'~_" . ~"~I'" ~"'Hc. T,. W,,,,,,,,__.,,. ~~,'~ J,t ,\{ 'ji/, J11~t!;' '/;\H1, "~'l' l~~:.ln J '~" I' I"',;,! i{f;f( ;,L l< ",,:Jti'~~~I~~~t%~Y"~~j!,~tl~~~~' :~ ,',' . ..:",.: Ii.:, ';. I':',!' , I.'..'"'. : h~, '~I~.liI~~~o: ~~~N~Y~V"lNI"I17'1 ',M,il~l;1~ :,;, . ' '" "" '.l 'II' ',,',,,,,.', "1Mf., "",:,'1'11 1,1~..4,H(1,~".\'i,. ,',' " , , '" ':" ' " ,,", >;..!..:, , " \~ ;l!i'''~\'':':',(", ;,' oj' ;\'i: '1" "', ",""" , .." ',,', '::'" p 'I}"~"~ " JI41\'1~1\'i '(!-:1~1\11"X,i\\\ ., ~ )1l;i.!;~,j:':~7r;n:;H l' ;"\~ "L;," ~,. ~I';~': ~, :. '!;:U;':!:~iHr1;~:rmi'ri!i!.T'i,'.;i{: \~t,{\ \ .1~U,/1f ~ . , , ! " " 'I ", ',; " " i< I, " -:;'~H", ,.. U.'r Y,'1' .:,",;1;;,-:-, i'I,),';.li:,ii-: ,';;,', -!rtiL~.i ':\ Jli;;>~ J.I " " Ii " ., "I . ,.,v"",, ,,. , ',,,,, .,.., \1 ' ~, "., ,. "'.. "'.1' r~~' 71 ~ ,'II'. Ill," ,'1',11 1,,', '\'H!'A.",(:,:'I 'ij '!' .., I: :.' 1!:"~: :j'~ < '~"i'.'~ ,'.~,jI, ,;':" 'I,' "Ilik~'bvq~"%il Yrl'f~\~'~Tiill. ' ".. ,', '", I' ~ rnl1l! ~ Pi> !l, ll,\! ' 1\1'" /il " <1'11"';" TI ~,11~1~1~^~, !~~~:I }I'U~. ;, ii,,' I.,d',j" I. "VNi;i'lt!'>)'-.'f:;;\,"..~I,I<"i,;/'::'\ri!,'(',/I\';~}'llt~r.1 1') ,,:,' .llk.' .'."l("\i'C'!;: i' "";("/r~;(();'-';;!!.J;;.1Irlf'''_f;\~,-,),\ : it; i ,,':\t!.' :.,i,:) J ~~, ",: .',.~:.' ~,' :.!:,~ :;;" '\',,:; ,; ,.~ '., ~~:; I:":'."~':~; :), ') '.~, ~ ~ ,,'''.\ '.; ,~ '.,td;'~NI;",,\'ji~d"dl .lbu. .','I -f.J~:'I,,:.: '.;,":)' .', H-~~:....; 'X.',.,",,', t,. 'I ,i, "':' '.1'. ".')IYN~W\,!;,l""l";.;,\\h' "1\1o.jo;~H{ii;.,~'ln\';;\\./ij./Wii~f\.;Vf~~~,t" H' \" ,Ii I I " ! i I ! I " " ,,, H ;1' " ",. i'lt .' 1\' I, ." " II ., '\ ' " " ,! y, I'. ,. ,,' " owo~ - 04!\l5 155 111I\l g\11111, M(\I'Y~vlIl\l, I'A P\llilmlllnl, Kim 1\. 11llllllijh M\llhlllllllllrrlck (ijl~I\lI'l . 1~\1b\lrl (l; Il\lv\lrly Nllllwrl . II) OM9~ . oa/05 H4,1\IlYllnoy WllP\lij N\1rth, ClIrllijlll, flA I1lnlnllm I~onllh' I~, "PIHlIlI', Ih', , Pplblllhllll;Khn M, 1~llyll~h " M\lllndllllnrrlck (~I~lpr); ,cl ,,' ., ll) OH/9$ . 00/95 . H4 l\pYllnoy WIlP!ls North, ClIr!lslp, flA Ppfolllllllll, Kim M. Unyllijh Mllllmlllllllrrl\lk (~Iijlpr); f)', 09/95_ 07/1)6 114 I~oypnoy Woollij NOl'lh, ClIrllslc, I'A PIl\lnllfl', nonnhl ~, QOII"lll', ,h', P\lfIlI1\IRlH, I<hn M. nl1l~lhjh Mclhlllnllllrrlllk (ijlijlor)i 1\ 'L ' g) 07/96. \ 1196, H4 goyonoy Woodij North, Cllrllijlo, I'A" POfllndllnt, Kim M, Hllyllsh /, MIlIIIlIIIIIl"ITlok (~Islor); '" ,. j. " h) II/Op . 01/03/98 H4 RogollPY Woods Nprth; clI'rllslo, P ^ PlnlnlllT, nQnnhl Ie, QOIIIIOr, .It', .. PoronllmH. 1<1111 M, 1\lmllsh Mcllflllllllnrrlck (slslor); 'I)' ,. 01/03/911. 10/98 H4 RoyonpyWoods Npl'th, C1I1'1I910. PA . Polbnllllnl, Kim M. Enyllsh " Mollndlllllll'rluk (slslor); J) d I' k) .... , 10/98.01/27/99 Pl7 Snit I~Plld, Hnolll, IIA IJofondllnt. Kim M. Enyllsh Mollndll BlltTlok (sistoI') JosslolI {it. Annol!lI Boyor: IIIld. 01/27/99. pl'oBonl . .... 603 Third SIrool, Roohoporl. MO (JofendOllt, Kim M, Hnyllsh Mellndn 1llll'I'Iek (slslo!'); Georye Strohnleyer. 4, ^dmhtod:' . ',' " .1\1;J1I1~h/l'll~\\'cr In ClllUfll",lnt Ihr t'1I~~I(ltl)' M",h Il, 1999 "" .' 2' I' " " ." 5, t\Ill11lll~\lln \11111111111 PIINllm In \111r1, ilia apopll1rlllly Ilpl1lPlllhll\,PplplI\llIl1lPllrl'Pl1l1y , rpslll~s wllh 1111 Inlllvl\llIlIl nll11wll"l\II!';III", Tn .1119 pOI1\nIl)', pofl.ll\111I111 P\I1'1'91111y 1'9~III~s wllh 1191' I11lnl1l' \lhlllll'911. Mlll.INPA IlA'~I\IC'\, IImll\ON^W IWOliN\:! IlI1NNHI\, III, IIml OnOI\Cl!\ WmOllMIWllIt " Ii, Adl111l1911, , 7, pnNml~, Ills sllPoll1olllly 11~l1lo(llhlllll\\l hOst 111101'0sllll1\1 PPI'Il1l\1lOI11 wollill'911fllw ohll\1 will ho sOl'vllII hy olll1l1nnll1l! I'I!!hls llf pl'lmlll'Y physlonl 9uslollyn11d slHll'olllo!!nl ollslnlly 111 1'1111 m 11\ hllOl\\lSO \11111111111' 01111 hOIl,IlI' \1111'9 lbl' Iho ohllll 1111\11'11111\1111' 101l1ls n I11PI'9 Slllhlo IIf9 , Ihlll1 Plllbl\lllInl 111111 1'llIll1ll1f Is o0l1lllll'ilOll.Ihll1 1110lhol' hilS 1'011l0llloll 10 Ih9 SIlIIp of Mlssnml with II 1111111 whn1l1 sho 11101 only 1'00011lly 1111\lnbo\1I whol11 PIIIII1!1IT knows IWlhh,!! IIbolll, To Ih\1. 01l11lrn1'Y, Dolbndllnl Olin b91101' '0111'9 fpl' Iho Inlnol' ohllllllml\ollds 1\ 111111'9 Sllllllo IIfostylo, ,Furlhol', II Is I)ofomlnn(whll hilS oxohlslvely porfol'lnollnll oflhe 11111101'1111 , '. I " IInd sllhslnmhl\ \1nrenlln!! dulles for Iho 1I11nol' ohlld nnd Iho' minor ohlld hilS, lit nll'lIhloR , "" " S1110~ hll1ll', IIvod wllh pofondllnt, Furlhor, Plllhl\lff hilS (1I11y spol'ucll\llllly IIvod wllh tho , 1I11lic~r ohlld I1l1d hilS novel' tllkon IInnotlvo pllrol11111 1'010 1'1111\ rospool to"lI1o lnlnol' ohllll, FUI:lhor, slnoo I~nvlllll \he. pllrll08' honjo on JlIl1ullry3. 199" PIIIII1t1lf's l,n~1 porl\ld of , oXlel1dod 001111101 wllh Ihe millOI' ohlld W,~S IIn ovornlghl vlslthtll1l1 (III tho "plllornlll , ;\, " , " Grtu1\lmothor's homo) dml!1!! qhrlsll11l1s. 1998, Ful'lhol' to lhe oontl'lIry. Pllllnlllf hna II .., history of unrosolved nloohpl, physlolll nlld vorblll nbuso, ohll;i cllsolpllllellntl Plll'Olllhl!! prpblollls, FUl'lhol' to lho onllt~'lIry, 10 Iho o>(tol1ll1 Is l'olo\.lInt, Plnhlllll'ls (\llly I1WI1I'o thllt MI', Sll'olhnoyol"s rolllllol18hlp wllh f)otblldl1llt I1nd hor ohlldl:on, Inohldlnglho mlllot. ohlld, hilS booll nil ollgolllllrolllllollahlp o><lol1dlllgovcl' IllIlIlY ll1onlhs. Furthol' to tho 0011\1'111)'. j . -. , . . . prlot' to 10nvhlIJ tho COll1Il\OI\wolllth of' Jloll11sylvllllllI, DofilmhUll.lIdvlsoH Plnlnllff of hor " l(l'llU~h',\II~wcr In CUlJll'll1lnllht Vu~~llllly M't,hll,I'II}'1 3 , , , , IN 'nUl CUPI\'!' nn~nMMON 1'1,llAH OF CPMIlIll~I;^NI> (lOIJN'I'Y, '" ,1'HNNSYJ,YANIA ' IWNM,P Ie UllNNlq~, m" l'lnllllln' Ie ) ) ) ) ) ) ) , 99,1003 V. KIM M, IjNOI.ISII, I~pl~nllllnl " OIVII, ACTION. CIJSTPDY OltlllClt OF COIJIt'" ANP NQW,lhls~, IlnY\1rMIIYI 1901J Up\1ll oon>>lllornllon nl' thpforognhlg potltlon !hI', ' COlin OrdorollPHypliilloBlonlllvlllllnllnn, III>> 11Oroby ()1\pm~IlP nnlll)nCl~I~IlP liS fbllnwH: , " I. :I'hnt ,~qNAI.P I~, IlnNNllI~, Jlt, I~IM M, I1NQI.IRH, nlld IWNAI<P [:l,' UnNNm~, lilt f\1n";wllh R\lbl11l1 In II \lhlld~;IRIOIIY psyoholoBlcnl OVIII\lIIliolll~ bo pomluotod by Stllnloy " Sohnoldor, Ph,I)" by cOlllnollng Olllllllncll AaH11011IlllH. 412 '~rfnrd l~q~ll" CIlI11P Hili, PPllllRylvnnlll, lit (71 'I) 732-2917, , 2, Dr, SQhnolllor iR lIh'oclod t~~ ;dcllvor. to Iho CO\ll'I I1l1d,lo" tho ntlol'!loy~ of 1'0001'11 ooplo>>of II " dOlnllod roport >>CtlhlB for'thhl>>OndlnBs, rosults 01'1111 tosts, dlllBnoRIR IInd concluslol1s. 3:' ThoonRI oLlho oVlIllIllllbl1, 111111 PI'. Sohl1oldor'R \oRlll11ol\y, If nOooRullry, IIrc to' bo lllvldod i' " " ;",. , botweel1 the pllrllcR In proporllol1 to Iholr'I'o>>pOCllvcl1pt l11ol1thly 111001\10s. I, " 4, Tho pI\l.tloR 111'0 dlrocted to llxchnl1Bo,throllgh cOlllISlll, ooplos of tholr I!tORI rocont PllY RtllbR 1IIIlIIlJlJR 11100'1110 tlPo; 1'011l1'I1R liS OIod, IlY TUE COl/RT: " J. ' ,I' 1!!,"I1'hlllcl1l1"l'cllllllflfilrl''YC'I,!II1I'cn'I!l'oll1oll'''' Moy'I,I')99 ;i " ;. . '., " 5, Oil ^prll I; IlJl.l!J Ihl1 pllrlipH 1\11\1 Ilwlr I'IlHIWPllvp oOIlI\HOIIIIIVIlIl\l11 PI\HIPlly \lol\pllillllfln. pOllfiJrel\c\l hpn1ro Mlphll\ll ll, llllllllH, nSII." 1\1 llw opnliJrlllwc, !hl' pllnleH Wllr\l Il1\lIhle Ip rOHOIVllIHlY IHSIlll~. rOllill'llllllllplll\1 or pllYHlcl\1 IlIlHlolly, (1, . Oil I\prll'll, 10(1) FIIII!\lr wlla HlTllsl\lllln 1,110 ~11\1\l or MIHaoml 011 Ihe chl\ml' or pllr\l1ll1\1 klllllllpplllll .IIH II resllll PI' FIIIII\lr'a 1I\leHlpl 10 l\lrclhly 11I~0 ymlllll j\()lllllll 11'11111 Molhor'H ,; II "IIalolly wllh\1111 her O(1l1aol\l, 7, 011 April 41\,'10(1) FlIlIlll\' WI1S l\IT\la\ed hy PII, ,lo\l1'oy O'1)011l1ll1l()1' Iho W~HI Shl1rO I~elllonlll " ,. . .j \lp\loo f)eplIrll11on\ pn PUI ollll\'lles, Pmhlll Iho Ollll1'SO of hla IIITllal, FlIlIlll\' IIl1nokoll Ihe polloo oOloo\, 11"11 \laollpol!. FlIlllllr la OIl1Telltly IlIonroen\toll,lnlho C\I1nherllllld Cmlllty prlaon PI1 l,lhnl'llOH or 1I1111rIlVllledllaallllll olli\ pollco \1ll1oer, I'IlHlalhlll IIIToal, Oaollpo, Pili, 1111\1 .' " pl1SSllHRlml or II ilHlIlIlIlI11I~ll11lof 111111'IJIJIIIlII, , H, A o\lslo,dyhollrln!:l la schllllllled 11l,JI\11'0 IlIla COllrt Oil JlIne 10, 1999, 9. Flllhol', Molhol' nml yllllnllllol1nlo hllVo not beol1 oVlIllIlllod.' 10: Mothor l~ollovos IIIl1I thorol'oro IIvera tlml ono of Iho sorlOllsisslIos III he oOl1allloredhy Iho' Courlla FIIII1or's 111'0pol1ally l'orllTIIIlnnlllhehllV1nl' I\nd pllyslol\l vlolollo~ns d0l11nnslrlll.9d by Fllthor's Api'll 1\, 1999 1I\lompl to kldnllp ynllng itol1nlo 1)'0111 tho SllIto nl'Mlss\lIIrl, liS wolllls Flllhor's Apl'll 24, 1990Il1111l'llvlltod IISS1I1I11I1I','1\I1d OSOllpO 1)'011\ II polloo omcllr dlll'lnll 1110 COUI'SO 61'11 Cll1uhorllllld COllllly, ]lolll1sylvnill" \)UI ntTos\, II. 'I'hl'l1Il11h Ihoh' IOSlloctlvo counsol, .Mothol' hilS .roquostod Fnlhol' 10 pnrllclpnlo III 1111 II .. , ' IlldllPondoll1 cOllrl"llI'dol'od psychnloglcnl oVlllulltloll 10 ho pOl'fhrmod by 1)1'. SllIllloy Sohllold~1' of'.Ollldnl\co ^ssoclnlo~, 412 I1rlhl'll Mlld, Cump HIli, 1'1111llsylvlIl1ll1. . MOlhol'hns IIlso ., ',' " ,l'oquoSlod \llIIt Flllhor pl1Y his shllro of tho oosts of Ihls ovolllnlloll iiI IIccordllnod 'wl.\h tho " , ,. portlonl I'o~llocllvo nol mOl1thly IIlc0ll10S, liilnll'hlllu""c! I',I/il"" liJll',\'cli"I"n"nll\\'nlllnll"" MiIY'I.ll)l)1) , :1 '12. PI', S~lm~1111l1' la willi kl1\lwl1ln IIIIl CO\ll'I 1I~lIn ll~plll'\ limplY IIUIIIII11111 i\l plll'lhl'l1\ II Ilhllll' cualnlly paycllnln~llllll cVllhlllllpl1. PI'. SlllHWlllcl' hila iI,ll1cllllllllhlllhIlIlIlI1IlYIIIIUI\l) Ihll plllllllH 1I1ll11'1l1~Vlml WItI111HHOH 111 Il,mlllo pl'Cplll'1l II l'~pl1r\ In IIIIYlIIlPO 01' Ilw HlllwllulolllwlIl'll111lhllll, . J' ., PI', Rllhllllllllll' hils Hcho(lnlllll tv1ollwl', Itpl1nlo IIIllI 1111l111110l'H PI' Ilwl!' Imnwllllllo li1mlly 1\11' \lvIIll1l1llol1H 1llll'II1llllm WIlIlKol1f! 01' MllY 15, Il)l)\). \~, FII\lllll' hllH lIl11'ollaOnllllly 1'Ill\Ialllllo submit 10 Ilw oVlIlullllnn W PI'. SllhIWI(I\lI'. oflpl'lld no.llll/.lll1y sullllll\l111 gl'Q\lI1ds fill' IIlH1111lllln\lllllnl1 01' PI'. Slllllllllllol'. FII\ll1l1'11I\s 14. FI1I11\l1' hl1H pro po sod IIl1o\lWI' pHychl110glHI who ,Is UI111000pll1blo In Molhol' 111 Iho pI'OSOI1\ OIlSIl fnl' sOYUI'"II'~lIsnnW (t) FIIIllIl!"s psyohnlolllsl .Is \'11111\11111I111' with Iho 1'0(jull'lllllonls 01' II U/'I/IIq/' h\lIlI'II111; Gn PI'.Sllhllolllol' hi II 1ll01'\l ll~por\oncllllllxpOrl'wltn\lss Ilml1 Flllhol"s psychololllsl , . '1lm\'1wH 1~8\1noll blll'ol'o Iho Cumborlnl1(1 (!OlIl1IY OOl.II'IS In sllll1lnolll1\1~;nol'o oontoslo(1 ohll(\ cUSlody oVlllllllllpl1s In Ihon F",hol"8 pSYllhololllHI; (3) Flllhol"a pSYllhololllsl Is 11110\110 Ip pl'olllll'O 1111 OYllhlllllon In 111110 I'llI' Iho soho(lulo(1 hOlll'lllll 111110, whllo 01', Schnoldol' Is IIblo 10 IIcco\1lll1nllolo Iho COllrl'S Hohodulo; IInd. (4) Flllhol"H psyohololllsl 1'0qllll'llS lmllt1plo vlslla with .. l' Iho cltlld Il1lho \lUSloily of Pilch plIl'onl, IInl111llCCoplllblo 1'0qull'01l10nlllllillhl of Flllhol"s April " ., ,. 41h 1I\10111plo(1 plll'Illll1l1 kldllllPplnll chlll'llOS In Ihc SllIlo of MI8Ho\\l'IlInd cUITcnl hlclIl'col'nllon . fhl' IIlllll'l";IIIOlI IIHSIlUli 'Oil IInd OSCIlPO 11'0111 II CUlI1bcl'llIlll1 CnUllIy pollco olllccl' followln!! Fnlhor'a April 24111 DlJlllrl'cst. ' I~, Mo\hor bollovoa nnd thcl'ollll'o IlVOI'S Ihlll Iho cOl11plotloll of'n psycholnglclll oVlllllnlloll IIlld , - - , I . . . s\1bso(j\10111 1'0pol'I nlld 1'0coll1l110lldlltlpll by Dr, SChnoldol: WOllld sorVQ to dl'lll1l1l11111111y 1110VO , " thla CIlSO 10WIlI'ds Hotlloll)Onl, 01' III IOIlHlllllrl'ow tho IHHlIOS for trill!. FUl'lhol', Mothorbol\ovea Ihllt,,1I COlll't ordol'od 'psychulOgloll1 oVlIllInlloll hy Dr. Schneldor will Ilsslsl'lhc Coml III 1!I1UIl_h1llclll1cll'llU\h1l1 lilt llliy~'h\llnlllcl,l E\'l\lunllllll 4 ~IIIY 'Ii llJlJ9 " " i,' " ,. ,'I' " Ii' d' ." ; " ~ Cl} ~ ~ f.! ~ ,~ t; I', I I. h IJ ~ ~l ~ ~ ~ ~ I' ~h ; ~ ~ (9 .~ o ~ I' () . r:l '1 ill ' . ~ ~ :I: ..... ,"., .. f';. ..:. I" "l. I (y., (--' I'" .,1', ,I' I,'.' .. hi l,l! ."1 " 'l,., I Ul !! ItI, ,; I i I' " f"llJ :. . ; ': I,Ll 1".,1' ..,( !IL I.. ~J.~' " Il~. t; ~ " (,'/\ U " U <1' ,I I' " i,-. ,. ,IWM " Ii '{ 'IH99 .J 'N ll, llUNlriP, 1\ iK Kp~pln~III1Y PHNlllP 111n\ 1l'lIm .lIlIllIl\l'Y 100H 11I1I1\PI'l1'II111I\IPly ,llllllmry 21, 10110, FlIllwl'hllil Khllrp,1 PIIKIIIIly or l~nN^l.P Il, ImNNIlI~, Ill, (\WI'UIIlIIOOI', "YI1\I11Il , ltlllllllp") wllh phil II I'pshlhlll wllh Fllllwl' 1I111\. IlullIl\1Il~1' 1\11' KllllllllclI!1\ pUI'I\1IIK nl' ihl1u III PullllnlWl"K l'uKlllullPIl Ihl: \lw YUill' pl'ep\lllhlll Ilw phl\(\,~ 11111'\1\11 Ilepllr\\lr1l 1l'1l111 IhlK 'Cnllll11\1IlWllllllh, Tn Ihe ,pnl1\l'lIry, ynllllll I~nllllle hllK IIQsm I'I1Kll1u11 willi' PulIlllllllll' or III PUllllnlWI"K . ' h11ll\\l l'ul' IIpurll111 nf 12l1\nlllh~ nl'mnl'llll~ 1'9111111'911 l\llllvc PllllllnllPr KIIIIl\\lllllpIII'S\Il\ll1 In 2~ PII,C,SA ~s~ l~(II), Fmllwl' In Ihu oll1\lrnl'Y, rnlllll! Itulll1lll hllK J\QWI' resltletlllllywhcrll 1\1 . . . , , IIllytll110 wllh Fllllwl' IIhsolll Mnlhol', !l1ly'QI' I'PKlllutl wllh Fntlwl' I\IH! Pllllllntl\lI', 1I1l11 llllW II, p "I''' ' I'osl{\otllll pollllollol"~ hlll11ll. SlllPu Ihe IIIlY uf his hlrlh, YU\lIIll l~ol1lllu hilS SplllII Ullly II very ", ",.JI ,," " I1mllull 111111l wllh linlll\ll' 01' l'ellllplWI' whel1 Mollwl' wlIKliol PI'IlS01l1, 111 pmllclIlIII',' Khwu 100R;. i' Yll\l11ll Itpl1lllo hllK Kplllll ol1ly 2 I1lghlKIII \'.ollllollOl"K IWl\lo:' Ilw I1l's\, Ol1l)ooPl11llol' l~, 199R, .: WhPI1 Mnlhol' tOlll\ Yll\lIlll ltlll1l1lo'K llltlol' Klstol', Mll1dy, 11\ soe Iho 81111\10 llf 1.lbqI'IY; 11111\ tho' soollllll,. ,~hOI1 YOUl1ll ltonl1lo spol11 IIn llvornlghtwllh his MOlhol:l\nd slslel:OI1 ehrl~t1l1l1K nvo 1998, . " " Fmlhpl' III Iho OllnU;\I'Y, 1'01111111101' hils uul (for 12 111\111\hs lll' III1Y olhol' Slll111ncll111 . ' porlOlI of thno 1l1lll'e Ihlll1 II lbw hmll'K) I1KK\11ll0t! Iho I'nllllllld rosplll1slbllllles llf' youn!! ltotll1lo'K "f' , ,.' " plll'Onl' Potltlonol'hllK UQ,V.9J provided thrtho pl'/Klelll, o'mollllnlllllncl KOCIIlI noodK of' YlllllllJ .1 Hllnnlo, 1'~lillllnol' hilS IlQ.YQt IIss\111wd thol'esplll1Klhlllly 1\\1' ~o\1ng Rlll1l1lo, . FlIl't1lOl', ymll1!! Rlll111lo hllK IlQ.V.Il[ hpen doltl!'ll1lnod 10 be II dOp011do111 child plll'slll\1\1 to .. 42 PII.e,s. eh. 6:1. Potltlol1ol' hllK 1l~~Q~ IIIlK\1\llod llt' dOolllod II l1oCOKSllry 10 'IISS\11l10 rosplll1slblllty lhr youl1!!l~onl1lo. And, young ROl1nlo hllllllQ.Y.Qt boon subslllntlllllY III rlKk duo 10 1':l1l111~ljll\l1~wcr 111 (J:J~'lc Cnml1lillll' JUlie H, II)C)f) 2 ", plll'OllllllllhllKll, IIPIlI\lIlI, 1II'IIgnl' IIlpnhplllllllHU \lI' IIwllInlllllwKK ilK I'Pllllh'u\\ln !lIVIl PlllillnlW\, K\I\IltllllllPllfH\ll\Il1 In 2~ PnJl.~,^, ~S~ I ~(i)), Whllll Fl\llw\' llvos wllh Pplillnlle\' Ilm\ wllhPlll1I ppmplPlu psyehph11lluI\I mlllllllpl1 nf i. " 'I F\\II19I' wllh I'cKppcl In Fnllw\"H pl'Ppol1sllY Ihl' 11'1'1\110111\1 hehl\vlpr, physlel\l vlol~II\lP IIm\ nlcnhplllml \lnllll\b\IHIl' vlHlll\llnll wllh 1'0111lplwI' IK nul ,Ill \lw hIlKIIIlIO\'IlKlfi Ill' ymllllll\pl1l1lll .,lIml will IllIorlb\,u wllh Iho plll'9111'llhllll 1'011\1Ipllshlp h\lIWooll MOlhol'nlll1 ymlllll I~olllllo \Iollyllllll'\lllllollllr Sllllldlllll P\II'~III\1I1 Ip 2~ PII.C,~.A. *s~ 13(1\). It Is l\lI'lhol' Hpocll1\lIlIlY PllNIHP 1111\1 FII\ho\':hllll HhllI'Ollo\I&IOlly pl'ynllllll Rnlllllo, Tn Iho Ilnl1lnllY, Fl\lhol' hilS llQ.\,~11' IIssllInol\ I\lIy Ill' 11"1'0111111 \'ospPl1sllllllllus wllh \,OSIWull\l yOIlI1!l Itlll1l1lo, Pl'lp\, III I11hlllll Cpmpll\lllI 1\l1' CIIHlndy III Iho IIhnvo mimbo\' IIl1d 10l'm, Fl\lhol' hl\K UYxlll' IlIkol1l1l1Y 1I111nl11111vo HIIlP 10 o"lll'lllso I'lghlH PI' phy"lolIlll\' 10111\1 CIlslmly with 1'0Hpool Ip , "Ii yonnll l~ol1l1lo, Tho\,? hllVo n.QYllt bool1l1l1Y IIlHC\lHHlollfi, lI!lro011101l1H 01' UlldoI'611\1l\III1!lH, wrlUolI "o\, 01'1I1, bpIWOOII Flllho\, 11111\ Mpllw\' rO!lllnllllg Hhlll'od clISllllly of YO\lllg Itol1l1lo: Thoro hllH ;I . .' , ' Jl~r hooll II cIlslmtyon\L1\, !ll'lIl1lll1g Khll\'od OllfilodY ofymlllg 1\0111110 01110l'cd 1I11\IIY 0011I'1, It IH 1\ll'\hol' spocll1clllly DENlI.lP 1111\1 MOlhor I\lId ohlld IIbl'lIptly dopl\[\o\1 fl'om Ihls C011111111nwel\lIh, '1'0 tho conll'l\IY. liS 1110ro spocll1cl\lIy Hel flmh 111 Mo\hol"~ AnHWOI' In Complnll1l Ih\' c\lHllllly, IIIl1I t\lrlhor IIIcoqlll1'llled hOl'ol1l hy rolbrollco, Molhol' IIdvlHOtl Fl\lhll\, i I1l1d'pollllolIOI' ofhp\, 1I1101l110l1s wo\l111 I\dVlll1CO ofho\' Illnvo to Mlssll\ul 0, DBNIBD. It 16 spocll1Clllly \)ENIBP lh"lnll or IIbm" JlIlI\lnry 21, IOI)l), wllhll\Il 1I\lv1I111l0 1I01lco 10 Fnlhol' O\, 11olh101l01', MOlhur rOl11ovcd ymlllllltol1l1lo Ihlln,,11olIlIsylvlIlIll\, IIl1d movod oVllI'llI!lhl 10 Rodloporl, MIHHOlll'l with II 1111\I11hl\I sho hili! kllowlI Ihl' ol1ly n hrlof'tllllo.To tho , cOlltrnl'Y, liS 11101'0 fipocll1clI\ly Hol Ihl'lh III Molh?I"H AIIH\VOr:lo Cnllllllllllll 1'01' CIIHtl1dy, 1\11<1 I\Htlll~h'I\II\WCl tn (In)'lll 'Ci11111'1nllll Jllllcf(,IIJI)C) ~ .. h, " 'I\\I'III~I' 111~OI'PPI'l\I\l11 h~l'plll by 1'01\1I'PI1Cll, MlllIlCl' mlvlKPI\ FIIII\p1' 111111 I'Pllllnl1~1' nl' hpl' IlIlpl1l1pl1K ,wIIIII '1I1\'ml~p nl' 11\11' move 10 MIHsoml, , . FllrlJlCl' In \hllOonll'l\ry, 10 Ilw o>;lplII I'lllevnl1\, MPlhpl' IplnllnllHhlp wilh 'Cl\lOI\CHl R'I'I\OllMUYIlI\ hnH 119011 nn PIIIlOIIIIl l'ell\\lonHhlll 0)(lp1\\11I11l nwl' mlllly 11I11111hs, ' 10, 1\ IK nlhnltloli'lhnl Fnll\C1' ~lllllP\! Ihll Ylll'll1pnl!tl11 Oil Fohnll1l)' '12, 11)90 Olllllllll Cnll1l1lnllll \VIIS I1IPII nil Fphnml'Y ?'l, 1009, II.' PI1NIHP,1I IH Hl1ooll1pnllY PI1NlHP 1111\\ IIIH III Ihe I)PHI h1l01'0s\ of ymlllg Itnlll1lo Ihnl lIP IlllVP vl~lInllollK wllh 11ellllnllPI', '1'0 Iho llllllll'nl'y, whllo FII\hol' IIvoK wllh Ilollllnllol' 1\1111 , wltl1P\1\ 0 oOlllplp\o pHyolll1l11lllPIII ovnlllllllllll 01' Fill 1101' wllh 1'0Kpool.\p Fnlhol"H pl'oplllIslly 101' Il'rnllol1l1l bohnvlol', phYHlolI1 vlololloo nil\! 1I10llhol 1\1111 Ilrll!! IIh\IHO, vlHltnllPII wllh POllllonor IK ,. I' . . 1101 IlIlhe l)psl hllol'oals lll'yollll!! ltlllllllo nil\! WO\lIIIIIlIOI'l'ol'o wllh Iho pIII'OI1\,~hllll I'olllllollshlp " "", " blllwool1 Molhol', nl1d yOllllll ]\ollllle, "ol1ylllll I'olltlllllol' HIlIlldhl1l p\l1'HlIIlIlI lo2~ Pn.C.S,A, ~~~ I ~(II). /'i ..' .. 12i 1)\!NIUP, Ills sl1ooll1onlly pnNlllP Ihlll It Is 111 Ih\l bosl1t1l01'0HI nf YOI\II!! lt01l1l11l Ihlll ho 11\II1111nlll n rollltlollshlp wllh pOII\lollOl'. Tolho 001111'1\1)', whllo Flllhol' IIvos wllh PoIIIIOIl\lr IIlld wllhol\l 11 0011\1>1010 payohollllllolll OVlIll\l\llolIlll' Flllhol' with I'osp~ol 10 110lhol"s pl'opollslly 1'01' hTlltlollnl bohllvlol', physl(\1I1 vlolol1co nl1d 1I100hollll1d dl'lIllllbllSO, vlaltllt'lol1 wilh PlltllloIlOI'.ls. , 1101111 Iho hoslllllol'oHls ol'Ylllll\!lltlll1l1le nlld \Vllllltlllllol'fol'O with Iho p1lretll,ohlltl I'olllllonahlp bolWooo Mothol' nl1d YIHlllg 1\0111110, dOllyln!! Pollllollol' Sllllldlll!! 11111'HI\II111 10 23 Po,C.SA Hl1l1l1khll\II~\\'crlll (Inylo('nlllpli\llll .tUlle Hj 11)1)/) " ., , , C\1llwlnin\ 1'01' (~\I"lnIIY, IIml Hinlwl' Il1onl'p\11'1I10II hpl'elllllY 1'~lill'ulloo, M\llhcl' 1\llvlsPI\ IIl\lhol' 111111 PIlIIII\1l1ol' \1rhol' hllPIIIIIlIHl wolllulHlvlIIWo nl'h~1' 1l1\lV\l11l MlsKnlH'l. ., 14, PHNllm. IIIK Hlw~lnPlIl\y I~IJNIHP 111l\IIIPllllnl1~I"K CtlllllHll1 PI'PV!tl\IHIYll1lilr\1WII MIllhol"K 1)ll\II1Sol \II' Ihc ppl1tlll1ll 1101\11011 1(1\, !!rnlltlplI\'l1ni vlKllnlllll1, Ill' Ihnt Ml1lhlll' hll~ rolil80d ., 1'0llSnl1nl1lP 1'0(\III1HIH !i1l' .Vlsl\lIllnl1, ''I'll llw I1tlllll'lIry, nil Kol nlrth III Iho I\lIl1choil , COITIlSpllllllol1cO holwoolI'P\1IIll!;ol 1II\Iotl April ~7, ~o,IIIHI MIIY~, 1001) MOlhpl' hll811ml1'II011 , .. I' 1'0111101101' 1'01l8tlnnhlll pOl'llllls of 111110 wllh ynlll1!! Ittll1l1ll1 whloh hnV\l 1100n lII11'Ul\K0l111111y I'OlilHod \lY 1'1111\01' IIml polllll1lwl', WlllllWFC)I~l\, 1~1l8p\1l1llonl, I\IM M, llNcil~ISII, rllllpuclllllly 1'0il\IP~IS thlH C\1l1l'llp rnlo,thlll 110111111\191', OA YLI~ V,.llIZNNnlt, IIIOKK 1I11\11\lh1l.l P\l1'1I\11I111 10;13 l'o.C,R,A, ~~~ 13, 10 ' Jilin h'; th\lpl'I.lHonlllotllll\ 1\)1' C\IKlotly, Ill' hl'llIllllI hol' llWII I'll.Ihl, II I'Qtllilll1l\1I' O1'll11;lpll1'0111 " ,- " VIHIIII\lllnol' Iho I11lnol' ohlld" ItONAW n, IlHNNlllt, III, 1111(11\1 dismiss tllo 1118111111 pOIIlIOI1' IVltll pl'uJlItlloo, ERBL.IMlli6ltY-OumC'I'IONS ANP NOW, 01l1l1011 I~ospnl1t1ol\l, KIM M, ENOI.,ISH, by 1I11d Ihl'o\lllh hol' 1Il1\11'l1oy, lJllnlol M, Myshl!" Ellq,; Wh\lI1lIlH Ihe within 'p1~lll~IMIN^RY OllmCTIQNS IInlll\111Ko tho , IhllowlllllnVormel1tH hI HlIppol't lheroo\': i; is. PlIl'lIlll'llphsl thl'nUllh 14 ufMnlhol"lI ANSWmt '1'0 PETITION FOR OItANI)PARENT Ii VISITATION IIIllI 1111 01' tho IIVOl'lllOl\tH \11' Molhol"H ANSWIJll TO cOMPLA1N'I' FOR " \\ l' '.' ClJSTOPV 111'0 lilool'porntoc! hOl'o,l1\ hy rofol'onco iilll,l'ml~l'o flllly sol fhl'lh horoln, '" . "Ifl, YOUI1!! Ronn1ul1l\H llQ'lQI' lived Ivlth Potltlol\ol' fnl' II porlod ofllVolvu (12) lllol\lhs or 11101'0 liS I'cqulrcd by 23 I'II,C,S,A, *S~ I~, to glvol'ellllol\ol' IItllntllng to bring II 1'0111101\ rur Ol'lIlIdl'lIl'0l11 VIHIIIIllo\1, l~lInll~hf,\I1I1W~f III (lit~'ltl ('ilI\II'IIII1l1 JUnl.1 HI JlJlJlJ 5 , /.' ,. Ullnl,,1 /H, MYHill", I~HI1' ^ttlll'ncy"t\t~LlIw ~""nl.II1I1,,'i'nWII 14ft"'" H1111~ JII~II'ftl'rl~lil1rH"'^ 17m,U~t11 . .., 717,MI.~~ftl 7IH~"M~7 r"~ ,~~ IIllIh Sll'~~" I\1flll~'l~I" "^ '~lIfi2., , III 12H"H~H I 7~HiIlH~q~ f"\ I"ACSI/HIU~ COVI~I\ sm~ln I', TP FM\ /I' \),\'1'1\ ' gn 1,lslI rv1. ,(:nYIIP, Ilall' 717.m.51(1I April 27, I \J01) 111'/1111'1' ,,: 1'://III1,rlt, I, , , ,. , " 1)011,1,lall: .!lloIISO 1111(IIho Im1UlIlluIIP~lIIll\lIlhr Il1lp\lllllell C\lHlolly "IllllHlpullllell C\lslmly OrdCl'lIa '. dlsOIlIlHPI! Ihlfllll)llrnnnn, I \lmlpl'sllllllllhlll YlllI will hllV\l YIHII' cllpnl OWClIIO,Ihl'pcq) llrll:\innlK' . .lllclI~1I 110 mlvlHud Ih"I Mil nll!lll~h hilS sllIroll Ihlll ahc hllnl1\1 ollJcollnn In IIl1nwhm Ml'a 130111101' sOI11P 111110 wllh Yllllll!ll\r.mlllu whul) she I'cl\lrna In PO!lIlavll'lIl1ll1l11 pluk IIPllIld doh WI' lwr Ihl\lIlhlor, Mlmly Whhnlll spollll1\1l1l1y I'pcllllhlllllw dllll1a, 111111 nWnl'P. Ihnl Ma, l~nl:\lIsh will ho In POl1nsyll'lIl1in for sowl'lIl IlnYH in olll'ly Jllno, Sho IllIlY nlao pll1l1 III rolliI'", III:\IIln I'm KOI'OI'llI dllya, In \lllr1y ~~\ll:\lInl shlll11ny nlsIl hl1l'o pllll1S \11 1'01llm III POllnsylvllnln IIIII'!"!llho Chrlall11na holldnv. . ,..\H 10111\ nil MI', HOl11wl' rCl1l11ll1s IlIcllrcornloll, I SOo 110 rOllanl1 why I11Il\hol' IIml gl'llndl11nlhN Clln'l rPllch IIn 111:\100111011\ Ihlll will 11IlIvillo !ll'l\llIll11nlhol "OOPan whilo prnvldlng l11ulholWllh i' 1'0llHnllllhlo (lcwoo 01' seomhy. Htlll'OWl', YlllI Khllllld kllnw Ihlll 111 Iho ovcnllhlll MI, 1l0l1nar Is rolUllaud, Iw wllLho loqlllrodlucIl1l1ply wllh Ihe Hllpllllllellllrdor prior 11j l\rllntlllllllhol"H I'IHlIlIl\lln: , Itosp~olllllly, .. .1..~;P\S.J~Tf~;~" PllnlolM, MYHill" n , '; ,,' I. " , NlITII:\(,,, ' ", Ihl" lih'lIlll'~ l\lIlt 1/1... 111l~d....c1 Ihlt,III1Wl,II\\'Ull1.l111 ('n,NI"IU~:S'I'I,"., l:\'t'OU~'I\T1n~, \\hkh "I~\l 111<1\ \~~ "~tj,\I.I.\' l1IU\'II.Ha:u ,1M \\hldl h 11l1~'IIII.1tl tllIl\' nlllllllll~lll1llhc Ic~llll~nl(lI) 11;1111\111 ,Illt,,"u II 'YII 'I\.' ,wi 111\l h1h:ndcll rC\'lrkl1lur Ilh11'/lll'hWl!il N .(:\'111 1.l~I"ln'1111~ lill II"'h.\lini1Ihl~ fl\\'\IIUIlt,l11n11 II1\! ~lti,~'h~dllll~m".;ul~ 11Ilh\.' h"t.'lllk'llll/cll'IIII\I(~I,YIl\1 ah,1 hoJrch~' 1It\1II1~'d Ihlllll") 11I"wnllnMtlnn Ill' "llrnln.l1rthl. r~\,.llI\lIt', thr "1IIIth.'I' dlll"lllllrlll~, 111'1111' IlIlun1lnllul! "1111111\1"',1 'h~"'rll1t h Illh'U)' rrul'lbllt~, If \'nll hn,' H'\'lliWllthi\ ItIP.il1li!1I in I'IM. I'k;I~IlI111Il(" the ilhuw ul11\'\l \1\ hll~l'hu/lll h'~1I ~'nll~'\.'I, Illlw~\~al)') lIIld hll\II11lh", 1If1f\llI4 lilnlnuh1 IlIlhlt IIhn\'1l ~lhlll'"~ II)' Inall \\ilhl\itl /l'I;lI1I1III'"U\\'I'lll'k"i '11l.U1~ \'1111, " \) Tllu I1llullilll "nrIMpOlllloll~o will bu 1i1lWllrdod by 11I1111, (S 1 '1'110 I111Uin1l1 001l05111111110llco 11'11111111 ho rll"~lIlllod by 1111111, lillllll~h'lkni1\'1 Slll11II;llc(1 t:I""lkl\' (1'111'1 .\1',021, Pll,l) 5 -....~_.~--..-.__._.._-_._-~.._-~-~.-.-----_.....-'---_._-----....-...-. (,I I'':'' ,': I' :\ I '1/'.1\'( 00 Iln\l ,.9 I'li \I?5 ", C\JtNIU 11./, IU i).JlIHIY , ' P~I'II\lnlWN!il\ ", ", !' " ,1\, I'; ,." " ';. " " " " .I " iJ " I' II 'll " q " " ,,"~ ,., !' Ii I', " " ,.11 " ,I; I'" " 1," " Ii " " H" " " " " " " I' " I \ I \" (, 'I" " \, "" " I' ". '" .... 1"1 ~: r~; .-'I r!i:l lJ~I;~ &!I ..~ ..~r! r. ) "J {IIi ' ::t~~ ()~f 11,.,' l;(Lj ;. L 0"1 Ill'" " r- '~/L III ;i\.(i,) IT (.\, I . .)~. 1''''/1 r_' l'lja~ I., bl II . rl" "., p . "~ Ii' C:J' <: .,1,. C;l ., " j" '\0 " " III " ,. " " " .j .1" " p" .. " I' 'I' " q " " I;" ~ . " " " " , ., 'L ,. " il. " ~ "