Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01058 ,II ,', ""I , . I , .. a, At 1111 tll11!'!~ 111 lit!'! 1'111 I tp till!! flatlPI1, P!'!f!'!n~lInt\ H!'!fltlwr 1=, Mflr!'ltpn, WI\Il pp!'!rllllno fI"IPao Hon~1I Apppr~ pwne~ py Pef!'!MlIl1ti lie!:!tl1!'!r 1=, Mflrston, IIn~ p!'!!:!rlno ' ' , , , Pl3nn!!ylvllnll'! r\30latrlltlpn nump13r AXqq~gg, 7, . Alllllllmea I11l1lerllll tp lhlsllptlqn, Pefen~lInt, li!'!flther 1=, Mllr!ltpn, Wlla . Pflemtlno sAid 1980 l-jond!:! Aoppr~ while In th!'! PP~lr!la fll1~ \lPPP13 pf her flmpli:lYI1113nt, a, At !:!lIlImea I11l1lerlfllh!'!retp, there werflnQ lI~v!'!rse wellth!'!r ppnellllon\1 fit , ' ., , the IIm13 of the IIPol~\3nt, 0, On Nqvemp€lr 1~, 10081\t flpproxllnfltflly 2:36 p,!n" P!'!f!'!nelflnt, H€lllther 1:. Mflraton, wfla trflvellng SO~llhln the, left I~ne of Nqrth HllnoVel' Street In Oflrllsle, ' PenmwlVfll11fl, 10, on Nov€ll11ller 13, 1098 fit flpprpxllnfltely 2:35 p,m... PI~ll1t1ff, ROP€lrt R, Hostett13r, wlla orosl:\lno the I!'!ft sOLlthpoUl1el IlIne qf North/ifll1ov!'!r' street In Oflrllsle, ' , 'Pennaylvflnll'l, , 11, on Nqvel,~per 13, 1 p9/.l~t ClPproxlml'ltely 2:36 p.m" Plfllntlffl RoPert R." Hostett\3r, WflS oro!lsln!:l In fin eflsterly ellreollpn when he WflS str\.lok Py the vehlole driven py P13fenelllnt, HSfltl)er'I:, Mflraton, , I ,,' 12. . On Npvemper 13,1998, fit IIpproxllnlltely 2:35 p,m" .as a reault,pfpelng struok Py thl;! vehlole elrlven by Pef~nelflnt, Heflther.g, Mflraton, PI~ll1tlff, RoP!'!rt R, I, HoatEltter, Was thrpwn onto the hood qf the Pefenelflnt's v!'!hlale l'!nd tl1en'rolled qff onto, the street Iflnellno fllon~ side the pflsseng~r slele cif the vehlole, 13, After Pelng atruok by the vehl91e driven Py Pefenelant, Hea.ther g, ' Ml'lraton, Plaintiff, Robert~. Hostetter's, boely OElIne,to rest on the road~flY In the the I'" , " I ' aouthPound lane of HIII1DVer street, 14, As a ellreot Md proximate reaUltof th~ negllgenoe of Pefendant, H~~ther I:, Maraton, .Plalnllff, Robert I" Hostetter, hflasuffered serious bodily Injury as set forth In fullhereln~fter, I' i .QQillfi..1 ~~ 15, PIII1I111ff, Robert R." Hoatetter, 1I100rporatea Ell1el makes a part of Ul1s0ount parElorapha 1 through 14 oftl;ls complE1lnt aa Is fully set forth, i' " ,I' 16, The oPo~lrranpe of 11113 flforaSfllq I:\oolqpnl fll1q 11113 InJurleG 10 Plfllnllff, RopeI'I R, HOlltetlElr, r\3IlQlllno IIwrefrom ware Pfl~ISe(1 dlreolly f1nq Pfoxlmfllaly IlY 11113 neolloenQa of 11113 Pefanqflnl,l-laf1tllf!r ~, MflrlllQn, oenarfllly flnq more !\peulflofllly flS sat forll1 pelow; fl) In ffllllno \0 apply \1113 Im~kelllnllme 10 flVolq a 9011l1l10n wlll1 11113 Plalnllff: p) In ff\llIng 10 Ilf\ve 11131' vehlola ~lIlqer proper f\nq f:\dequflla oonlroll 0) Oper/;1llnO ')Ell' Illolor' vehlola fllan!?xo~slllva 1'/;1113 qf spaed; , q) In f/;1ll1ng 10 slop, Illow or swerve hi3r motor vt:1hlolewllen. she Imew or 1l110~lld 111Wa Imown 111/;11 I:lY ffllllnolo dp so sl1awoqlq slrllle Il1e PI/;1ldllffi e) Oper~llno /;1~eI1IQla Inlo /;1nq <1gEllnlll Il1e parson of 11113 PI/;1lnllffl " . f) P/;1iilng 10 W/;1rn of 1I1e/;1pprOflOIl of her velllole; ~) P/;1ll1ng 10 opar/;1le l1er vel1lole F11 /;1 speed 111/;11 woqld pannlt 11131' I'" 10 sloP wlll1ln 1I1e flssUl'ad cleflrcllE\lflnOElfll1a/;1d; 11) P/;1ll1nglo opssrve/;1 l11E1rlled orosswl:1lkl , ' ..1) In f/;1ll1ng Iq opserVfil Ihe pl/;1lnllff on Il1e I1lgl1w/;1y; " )).In f/;1ll1no 10 Ileep fl proper. flnq/or re/;1sonaple 100ko~11 for , pedeslrlflns IElwfully on Il1e roaq, and: II) In failing Iqyleld 11113 rlgl1l;of-W/;1Y.lo a pedeslrlM already L1pc;lI1 "." 11113 hlgl1WflY, 17, As Ilie reaLlII of Il1e negllgenoe of pefenqanl, Heflll1er 1=, Marslon,. Plalnllff, I ' ' " ' Rohert R, Hoslel\er, hflS sLlstalned severe InjLlrleG, Inoludlng, bul not.lllnlled la, 10sIlof oonsolollsness, laoer/;1llol' 10 Il1e l1e/;1di InJLII'Y 10 Il1e left shoulder, fraolLlre of 11113 lefll1lp, oonlLlslon of Il1e pl/;1dder, spending IllLlol1l11ne to reouperale and Is In neeq of . ,. ' lmdergqlngex\ellslve rel1apllltflllon 10 le<1l'11hoW 10 walk again wltl1 proslh~\Io le.(:Is and properlY d<1mag.1;l 10 Ills eyegl<1ssEls and Wl1eelohalr, . 18, As a reSlll1 of Ihe negllgenoe of Defendanl, 1-leatl1er E, Marstol1l Plalnllff, RoPeI'I R, Hosle\\er, l1aspeeli and propaply Will In Il1e fLllure pe I1lndered fro!n,al\elldln9 10 Ills usual oooupallon and dally dulles, E\S.l'! bl.lateralal11pulee (haVlngpoll1legs .I: " " , 'I, I1mp~III1Il3~ I1I)PV13 11113 IlIll3a) 11113 lOBs ~f ciiJllI\y 10 WI1I1\ onlll11 prpBtl1l3QeB, 10 Ills oml1l, ~l3lrll11enl,lpBll, 11~ll11l1ll1llpn 1111~ l3mljl1rrl111Bm~nl, 1 p, As 11 mt:1~111 of 11113 negllfJen\le of pefeqql1nt, Hel1lher g, Ml1rslonl Pll1lntlff, I' " " ROP13rl,R. HOBlell13r,.Ilf'Ii> s~lff13re~ I110BB of IIf~'s pl13I1Bllrea 1111~ will oonlln\18 to B~lffer Ihl3 Sl1me IIi 11113 f~ilm13 10 ilia grel11 ~13lrln18nl I1n~ loaa, ' gQ, Aa 11 res~III of tile negllfjen\le ofPl3fl'll1clti1,nt, Hel1lher g, Ml1rslon, Pll1lnllff, "RQparl R, Hosll3Uar, 1111!:\ ~ln~erfjon13 91'1311\ physlol1l pl1ln, ~IBPomforll1n~ m13nll1l . I1nQlllah, I1n~he will oon11l11113 to l3ncillre lIie sl1me fpr I1n Incleflnl\e perlocl of lime In Ihe f\.llLlre, o<lualng him f,lrel1t physlol1l. l3lnollcn<lI, <lllcl fln<lnol<ll clE1lrllllenl<lnQ losa, PI<llntlff, Ropert R,jioateller , palleveB, I1ncl Illerefore I1Verll, 111<11 Ills InjmleB'l1re .. peflll<lnentlnnl1lure, g1, As 11 reslllt of the negllgenoe ofPefancll1nt, HeAlher!:, MmBlon, Plalntlffl I' ' , ,', , Rol)ert R, HOBtell,or, hl1s beenoomnellecll In orcier 10 effecl l1\lllre far IIWl1foreBalcl Injuries, 10 explOlncl Il1rge BLlI11B pf 1110ney for Ihe repair of 11111 wh8eloh<llr <ln~ the , II!' , ' replaoement of ilia gll1ases, he oontll1lles 10 require tret:ltmenl an~ woulci neeci t<;l InOllr 1'1B~19E11 expellses for Ills Injuries, InoiLlclert bul Iwl Ihlll\eci to the <lbll,11Y 10 walk on th~, , ' alumps of his legBI Elnc1 worl\ tllrougll the cl<ll11t:lge 10 ilia allouleler whlQh reqlllreB I, ' " " . flcic1l1lon'l1l rehl1bllllEltlon. " L , ,WH13RI3POREl, Plalnllff, I'~bber\ R, HOBt,eUer, Beeks c1Ell11l1ges frol11 pefenclant, Heather g, Ml1ralon, In t:ln amollllt In exoess of Ihe jurlsc1lotlonEli ElInOllllt, togelher Wllh . IElwfllllntorestthereQn, plus c1elay c1fll11ages anci OOBIs of suit ancl c1el11ancls fl trial Py jllry, " Q.Q.Yill s '22, 1~ll1lntlff, r~obert R, HosteUer, Inoorporates ancll11a\leBa part of thlB Gount paragraphs 1 throllgl, 22 of this GomplEllllt as If (LIlly Bet forth, 2tt AI all times material herelo, Defendalit, Het:lther g, Marston, was f.1n' agent, servant, anelloI' el11plbyee of DefellclElnt, MaBter Manufaoturel's,lno" and was' II " Iwllno Inl'ln~ ltpOn the,llllslneas pI sfllel p13fanelflnt flml willie In Il1e oOHl'ae fI.n~1,!loPp13 pf , " ", Ill'll' el11ployn1l3nt wllll11fllcl Pefencll'lnt, ~4, P13113nelflnt,Ml'later Mflmlfflo\llrerB,lno,! \luollflhlll\ flflt:!nt, at:!rYflnt!fln~ , ell1plpyet:!WflB neollot:!no\3 flncl/m oflr\3laBlllnllPme OH111 pfthe follpwlno pflrtlolllf.\I'BI fI) Inffllllno to I'IpplY 1I1a Ilr~llas h~ IIl11a 10 flvolcl I'Icollll\lon wllh Ihe PIf1lnllff; p) ,In fl'llllno to hflve 11er vehlC)la lindaI' propar I'Incl flclaq~If1le opntrpll " a) Oparl'ltin9 her 1110tor vehicle fit r:mexcel\l\lve rflt13 pf I\pe13c1: ,el) ,In ff1ll1notp Blop, lllcw or BWl3rve 11er motor yahlcl13 when Bhe , ", .-, 'I ", knew PI' I\IWlllclhf1ve Ilnpwn Ull~t PY ffllll110 10 cia BO BI1a WOllld Btrllle 1I1\3IJlfllntlff; e) Op13rfltlno fI vehicle Inlo find f1of1lnBllhe p~rBOn of the PlulnUff: f) Fl'llIlng 10 Wf1rnof the UPPI'PUOll of her vehlcla: g) Ffllllng to pperflte her vehicle fll fI Bpeadlhfll woqld pennltl18r . to stop wllhln Ihe a~Bllred clear dIBIE1nce.aheud; h) Ffllllng 10 aPBel've a l11f1rllecl crc~BwE1lk: I) In fE1ll1ng 10 oPBerve the plaintiff on the hIOI1WaYI' J) In fE1.lUno 10 keap a proper and/or reE1BonE1pl.a lookout for pedeBtrlanB lawfLIIly on U1el'aad, unci; " II) In fE1I1,lng to ylelcl Ihe rlOhFof-way ,10 a pedestrlE1n E1lreacly llpon the 1110hwt:lY, ' "I' 26, AB the direct t:lncl proximate teBlllt of the neollgenoe of Defendant, MaBter , . , ' j, " Manuff.1atllrers, Ino., Plaintiff Ropert R, Hosteller hAS sustained severe InJuries, IIi ': , " Inolucllno, but notlll11lted 10, 10SB of oonBclollEll1ess, lacerallonlo Ihe heE1c1, Injury 10 Ihe left shoulder, fraotllre of the left hip, oonluslon of the pladder, sPendlno mllcl111me 10 . . ' reouperE1ta and Is In need of undergoing extensive rehupllltE1Uol1to leE1rn hoW to walk E\galn with prosthetlo legs, , 26, "As a resull of Ihe neollgence of l1efendal1t, Masters Manufaoturers, Ino" Plaintiff, ~()bert R, Hosteller has peen f'll1d ptobf'lply will In 1I1e future be hindered from" ',I ' 'I " , f1l\lIncllno tlll11!l ~I!l\.ml poo~IPl'lllpnl'lnq cllllly ctUII\'l!l, tp'l1ls grel\l ctl3lrlmenl, IOl>s, 11\Imllll\\lol1 ~lIlcl IIm~l\mI8Sm\'lnl, , " ~7, A!lll r!ils~'11 pf Il1e nllollgel1ol1 pf Peflll1ctllnl, MI\8tera.Ml'Imlfl\ot~lrllra, 1110" Pll\ln\lff, RpP\'lrl R,11psllIl\er, I1I1!lS~lfferecl II Ipss of IIfe'8 pl\3l\a\lre!l, IIncl proPlIlJly will oOl1llmle IQ auffar Il1e sl\l11l'lln \1111 MWfl to ilia grelll ctfltrlmenll1mJ loaa, ;21l, Aa 1\ r\'l!lult of Il1enl3glloenoe of pefal1cll'lnl, MII!llers Ml\mlfl\ot~lre~r!l, 1110" Plllll1llff, Roperl R, liosllll\er,l1as unclergol1eorel\t pl1yalpal pllln, qlsopmforlllncl menllll IIno~llsl1, ~nQ he will OPl111mle 10enclWe Ihe Slime for IInlncleflnlt~ pl'lrlpct of,llme in Il1e fi-11\lre, 01\~lsli1g 111m or~1I1 Pl1yslol\l,emo\lol~III, I\nQ flnl\llOll\l clelrimenll\ncllpaA, ' g~, Pll\ln\lff, Ropert R, 110slel\er, pelleyell, I\nd therefore I\yers, 111111 Ills lnjurle!lllre p~nmll1ent In nl\lme, " g9, As 1\ I'IISLIIt of Ihe negllgenoe of Pefendflnl, Maslerll Ml\nufl\olurers, Inp" Pllllnllff, RQ~ert ~,!10sletteri has ~een oompellecl.ln Ordflr 10 effeol a oure for Il1e IIforesald Injmlea, 10 F.lxpend large llW11,S of I1lPn(')y for niedlolne I\nd meglQl'I1 flllantlon, . ,PIEllntlff oon\lllLlel,1 to reoelve treatm?nt elnd Ino~lr meqloal expenllea.fpr Aald Il1jLlrlell, Elnd will oontlnue to do so In the Mme, 10 hlA greal detriment and 10AA, WHI:RI;FORl3t Plaintiff, Ropert R, Hotltetter, seel~A qElmagsA from PefendElntA, lielltl1er 1:, Marston, and MaAters ManufaolLlrers, 1no" In I'In amount In exoeAS of,\l1e jurlacllotlonQI amoLll1tl together With lawfLlllnterest \l1,ereon, pillS delay damages and OOlltA of ALlIt and demands a trl~1 \:ly )Llry, RespeotfLllIY sLlbmltted, j', (d~~~, Peter J, 1~L1sso 61 West LOLlther Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717);249.2721 pl:'lte: -Llu.~6 b '; " " " " " I' I' " EllhlbltA " I' , " ;' ..I, I, " " ", it H "" " " 'I, "I". If, " !! 'I " " " " j. " " " ,," r','" Iii " ,."" I' " l'" " I, I: " " " " " I' ,. !, " I; "H ';, ii' " '" ", " I' ,',', ~. \~~ . , " ;--'. t. " ,. I'. ('J . ,I " , I'" , , \;:.1 , , I ~ ,\ I I , ( , , " ( \ , ) " " "I ,. " J,,, ,,, ~ ' ~ ~ .k 8 11 '4 '~'I!! Ii 'Cl ~,Iii~,' i: ~ " t'") , '\, ..' I' " , I " TII(IMI\H, TIH)~1AS ~~ HAI'lll\\ r.I~J1 ATI'OIlNIJYS AT lAW JIlSH!'III',II,II'I!!I, J,IS\lis ~,'IIIIIM'IS, II 1\il1\lilllSllN II, 1,\\,11111 II<I'Fllli" 1.1, 111'lllll ': , 'lill!11 J.l'IIIIIY , II, 1\\l1I~1! M\'I.I!MIlIII,.JII. Id>W,"IIlI\,IIIIIIl'IN,JiI, 1', ~IiNll'lll!'l! IWW'III,ct,IJ'\I,11 P,WIIl (..SI'I\W,II,sl' !'UTlUI j, SI'I '\~III Ilpll(lI"IS II, M'lill'lil,I,1l !'AIII,J,Illil,I,MI!(J'1 IlI'C'IlIINSI't., I,I~H:S ~,lIIIlSI,IS .111~ NIlIITII FI\()NT NTI\I!llT NIXTlI nOOK 1',lJ, IlOX '1'1'1 1I,\IIHINIHIII(j, I'" I1II1H pill ),17.111"1" '\, F,\X (717) J,H.71U~ WIIITt:Il'S IllItH'T 1>1,11, NU~II"'!I , IlslIlll\Y, I, M'II\~ lI'INWI.j,ct,II,(,'IIIII1I.11 111111\'111 ^, \,\\' ,1111 S,\lI,11I IV, .llIpSlll, t:(llll'Nr N, M<'II\IIIII S l'Iii'IWN I;, 11"11(1(.11111 ~,lliI'N S,I'Il'IITs (1,111\' l, 1,,\111\1111' 111111111, N'I\\I'IlI' IoIs\lisJ,1I11 >IHI ~1:NNlilll ,I, 11,\1'1' ~n'IN (', MI'N'IM,III,I 1I\IIIll~SII. rlll..INII JlJIIN 1'\,IWNI..I\'I;lill IIlI\N SI, l'IlI'I!.il(:~ ' "MIl'III!I,I!J,IIlIlIIl' " . (7'17) ;2~6'7~~;2 ,.QKP@ttlllaw,oofTI . .. Peoamller ;2;2, 1999 Protl1onotl"lry of Oumllarl!:\n~ Oounty OUl)lperl!:\n~ Gllunly Oounl1oU!l6 1 Oounhou!le Squl"lre Of,lrll!llfil, PA 17013.~~B7 R~.I HOQtetter v, MAf'Qton No, 99.1068 Pel"lr Sir or Ma~f1m: ,. I' " " . . Il1ave enolose~ for filing an AnsWar of Pafendan\ to Plaintiff's Mlltlon to Oompel . An!lwers to Interrogatories In the allove maller, Qpntempllraneously l1erewltl1l am serving a ooPY of this document upon Plalnllff's counsel of r~cor~; . Slnoerely yours, ",,, THOMASyH. QMAs &. HAFSR, LLP CL~-q~ '. 0, Kent Price " OI<Plve!l:a!l273.4 .. Snclosure po: . Tile Hotlorable f(evln A. Hess . Plilter J, Russo, l:squlre " " 1// l ,) . ,'I.j 1'\ (, . .' I.I!II1011 V,\1,.HY OFFICI!: 12 I:' ~'I^ltKIIT STI\I'IiT. I'.(), !lIIX 1 m. IIl;'lIll.1illllM, 1',\ IHIIII' ((0111) H(,II<1I,7~ F/\Xy"III HI,S, 17l1l ' . Hi , ' " " " I" " Ii " " " ,I' 11 ' " , ":;, 'j" '" "I" I" , ,I, I ,I' \ ' ,>lil "II l,jY If' "',',;i~I",l)" [1 ;t"t>'lt' 1/,'/,'/,"" II '/,,1,',> ~"'\ ,1,1" Y'",,' d.'" ,,, l' '(il,nll,}',",., "(' .,rl.l",'\'TfI,'t..I~'/,,-I.fi,i' ,,!;:IJ~f~,,"1 , 1'". ,'" , ' ' ,,' " " n < ' \ ,i ' , ..I, I ,~ ';f~":'\!\ \"',1 ;,i~},l"l ,i,I',II:' ;:(,)~ ''\ n'...' /,1 f)) <\"'I'~:~" ,I, ",; ,l ::", ;i'I~: f '.ll)ll.hti,IJ'1,II\ ; ,'"l/jlj',j;rf\"'';j'i' 1:1Jl\l~r .1.,. \ '{~f~~~ ~ t, ,r, \1' jll\"", "'j" 'Ij' n' 'J" '<!I1I,~/i' '''; ,II', ," u /'\'1/"'] t I ,;'1,' "'.' 'iI'1' ";,1'!lr} : ( 1/' .i\1'j :"1'1~~"1 "';"":,,:,' ,Y1(1,':i:: rritn'M'n{;!1l"':';~' "j,a',&;iiuj,lIl'Ilu,{y,'It'D" "";',,;\1.-,\-', "],,",:','," ,. ,:,'lv,l, ::A,;.I',"i;"," I,',', ,'1!l'r,!<'I' l\~!;:,~".l1' f1l\",,~,"l!l!,t''!'''''1l,'t~:,\\/'h~'':> j',;,:':\\":" !,;;\U'I', 1:}\~:;'I'U\l,) '\:~ .11,' 1,\',','. "" ,;!I,\~,:I'" '!ll 1\11\1 ""hT1iI1W( t ',1 \1 1"I"I1:U1 ~:( :'1 -,' f 11!1'(~, ~,;f /;~1,1\ j', '1,/,( ", , "0 '" " ",' "~ .Im;.rt;_....' d 'J'" " ", . .oJ, , . ;Jl:ili~;Hlll1di:j! , \. ,1\',',',/, ' " ;~I~ t\TIl rnOU.li!, f*',-",flflf '.' '!, ' 1,1',.'1 1" Ii'" ,!ft ,'i') 1I;!'"'I" j , t' t~l'l I)',ll,U/t':I;"i1,ll}; ,:,,~i(I.\ L'\I ," . ~ .,f 1,1P.,,"II"'1 t:tr\v 4iM ,:\. "1"'1', ;:,: 'I. I," ';'\,1,' 1".,'/1(/,'.1']',':1 ;{l "U~\W~":li'I\'i'l ~,~, I ,..L't 'U?'f,I~\ "\~,,, ,,''IJ '" ";f,~"',r!!l_1" "I'" ,II' I, ,! .'1, ""fllli fl"'" ' 'l'I'lf ~,,'i!f'\~:!~u}\'\i\,LII:'\I; 1,.11;)\ ,lJ,l:,!,",f, I ~"'~:,"^lU\t$'tm~tlr(t\l~~ I"~' ',/\~ ';~~1: n;, "",' ii";"" 1:\llf,,:I,~' :',Ji,~',',Il~;:"tJ~t~'>I';';'; ;{~I"\~ \, 1'\"11,' "t"J ' If'!." r"'" ,-',ii. r,," r "'1/ " '" " l\i~) 'V',i'lr 'l~l)('JII"l. I.), ,,'f 41[.\"\: 1'/ ,;1 '!I' ',I :,: '1:. ,,''l.', : 'fl ,;' .~' I)lt , ' ~ " l', ,," , / 'I , ,~:. ';'< ,',' ~'r'J/ "I 1" I:,': ;',',; " '\ ' ,j",h,:"", '~"" j ,1, ~ ' 'h ' , . ,r ".. ".,' 'I ," ~t.__"L ,1\'1 'I' ;" ': ~ I ,1' \\~,," , '.' I", "f \.1 'I]J \.11:.,,1' ,\.1" ,t , ' , ,\ ' " , ' I "I, ,11 " ,I, ," ~ , ,,- t.. ' " , I 1 < -- ,,' ','1 --. . , "" .,,,,,,.; ,,' ,d "\f~i)'~\r.;l' ;L:/j::.-'_I.i;\;'\liiiJ\l~'jJ'I" '....j _"",~" --"i'i- ,II'," H " " , " " ili I Ii '~ " I' I' Ii " i' " " ",;, " " " "Ii " 1\ H ;{j j1 , , IilCplblt A I' Ii' 1'. ,. " ,:1' ". ii ,/' " " "I' ,.I' " f!\,l"\), (\'i;:(:~: ,,' '~')rMW ')\In;'!; It', Iii ;i1 :q , " -'l '" t, }j,',\ "I' 'i I ,~ I; ,[ 1'( llV', " l'!l'l 1\'( Ii, ", " .' ,. " 'I :','. " I' , I" " " " '1 I' , Ii " , , , I , , I, d'.., , " " :' " J' " " q " " I' " , " " " "1' "I' ,I' i" f' I' 'i j, ",. .. " " , , J, ~ i) " t, ,,' " " " 'I, , '. " , '" '11' ,,' 'I " "" ," d' " " " " '" " , . .' " t'.. ~ \. If q~lina lJIIl lhr~~ mlml\~ r~Ii\1111lI1m~qIAl~ly h~f\1ro Imr~ot ynwworo lln~~l!~q In \lny \lollvlly whloh r~~\llroH \llIl u~~ IIf IInll or \lPlh hl\nrl~,~\loh WI smnkhlBt nrlJ\I~tinll o~\lll]mllnl qr lpuohlnll ~pm\l rer~nn or lllljeol, rloWie lloaolill~,~\loh opmhllll nr iI~\lvily In 11011111, ~~lllnu (brlhl , '\ . < ., (Ill lI11ompllll1l1losllnpllnn PI' ol\eh IIllllvlly, I'., (G) the II~mtl\1n of oll~h lIellvhy, " , " " " I' (0) " " ",. I. ' hQwl~n!!ln sooonda boloro tho ooourronOQ such IIlltlvily ondlld, ' , " " ./ ~2, PIOl\So~tl\lo whoro YOIl woro oomlng lTom IInd whero yO\! \Voro gain!! IIt'the limo of thQ nlto!!oduQourronoo,,, ' . , ' Ii" Ii , " .' ., " ,; r I~I , .-," 01" " .~ (I', I " \:'~ :'! " ,.. , ,'.i' I'C, " ,. (,.1'- ;!"Il, 'I" '1\ <' ' , I , r' I" f:1 I .'1'\(' t') " fi' \,! ,. , , I" 1" ,. r" 1',.1 " t'... ~' ("', i ~:I III l,) " " " " !. Pi b ~' ~"~ ~ ~ J J~ II i J l'i ~ ,i '" !. " ,. " " ,I" (. I; ,. .1,1- I~ C() , ~'. '- 'I:;; P'I;] ,,' :':~5 .,. .u ( 1.;/1 .e wc" tt~ (:>:i: ~'.l'. Il. ,'-:') ~;:! (1'!:':' If) ':.i' (~, 'fr)ll.' (". iL~:.; /J~lJ' H" Id{'O "f.I::, "~ HI!:,. , I- L'(': ~ g.1 (',\ .1 II " I, ., " .;.,. ,. Ii' !j ,. " " , '\. " '-j- , I " ;1' " ,.1' " ,. 'I .' .,. !; I 'I " ',. ., " ;: P~T~R ~, RIJSSP, ~aQUIRt; PA !:ll.lpremp Qouli IP: 7g1397 \31 We!!1 ~pl.llher l3trpel.. . Ollrlll:lle..l fA 1701 \3 717 .24\;1.27~1 . -, -. .. - . fiTj:;PH.ANIJ;.... j:;, CH~RT. OK.!! t;SqUIRt;. PA l3upreme OP\.lrt IPI ii~ftp1 .. 61 Weal I.pl.ltlw l3lreel . .. Ollrlll:lle,l p.^ 1701~ 717-g4"'.27~1 . AllprnaYI:l for Pll'1lnllff " ROI3f:lRT R, HPaTgTT~R, .. ' Plplnllff" . . I I .1 I I I I I 1 ,. v, IN TH~ OOURT OF COMMON P~MB CUMI:I~R~ANP COUNTY, Pj:;NNsYI-VANIA .. OIVII.. AOTION,I..AW No, 00, I 0 SC( OIVII- <1 ., JURY TRIAl- pgMANPISP Hj:;ATH~R!:I, MARSTON, .. . P!lf!lndpnt . ,,' 1iQIIQ.g ,. " To Oell\.llllrOnel '.. Yo~ are req\,llreQ to oom~lete Il1e following Oertlflotlteof Oompllllnoe when' . proQuolng ctooumenta or thlnga purBl.lant to'the Suppoena, ..: '1, ~ ~., an authorl:2:eQ aganl for Oallular One oertlfy to Ihe b':l13t of my ,;nowleQge, InformEltlon Elnd ballef that E!II QooUmentB or,lhlnga raqulreq . I to'peproQuoed pursuant to the BuppoanElIBSUed on ~ have been " priiQuoed, DEltei Signature - ,. " Printed Nama ., " " .. ,. ~,l, l11t;~ t~,( ) [.L. ~I'. IA'I "[&";'!<, ; jr', I-I. ll~ (, I I'" .. II,' '0' '<'I ~I ,. ~~l .,-. i:~: (-,? l'l f:"' d.~ en u,' .",- I,' >.' ~; , ~:) ,:; 1;,'.1,,;.', I, I .'~ i~'J ::;~ ;/' '..1.1 ': :r :fl~ (1'-.;'" 1';1([1 'l.l( . ;'.1; (.) I. \' " /; " 'j, , .. , . .' " " 0", ., , , " , " " ,. j"\i ,. 'I " ,\< " " it I,. li '. !l ;i , " , '.. .. 'I, " " " " ,:1 '. , , , " . It, , , " " "'I ", " '.i, " i. i," ,. "; " IIi' " .. " ',; P~1'!;R ~, R\.Il:jflO, J:flQUIR~ PA :=luprama Court IP; nm97 61 WOIlII.Qulll11r :=llrlllll Ollrllala, PA 1701~ 717.249.2721 " , fl1'~PHAN, I~ J:, OI1J;R1'OK,J J;SqUIR~ IWSuprllme CP\.Jrt IPI 526p1 . 61 Weat I.outher Slreet Cllrllllle, PA 1701~ '. 717.249.2721 A\torneYll for PIEllntlff RO~~R1' R, HOSTJ:1'TI:lR, " Pl~jntlff I I I ' I , , I I I I IN THt; COURT OF COMMON Pf..13:Ml . QUMI3~RI.ANP OOUNTY, PI;NNSYI.VANIA .. OIVII.; ACTI.oN.I.AW " No, a9, IC)$ ll' OIVlI.. ,JURY TRIAl.. PJ;MANOS:P V, 11I:ATH13:R J:, MARSTON, . . Pafanchmt . t:!Q.II.Qg " .. To pas One; VOL) are requlro\i to oomplele 1l1e following Certificate of CompllE1noe wIlen . proqUolng ctopumen\ll'or UllnQs pumuanl to .the Sul;lpoen<l, I, , an authorized "lgent for pes One'oertlfy 10,. , . the besl of my '\nowledge, Information anct .pellrMthOI qll doouments or .Ihln[ls reqlmect i.. , ." to be produoed pursuant 10 Ihe subpoena Issl~eq on _ Ilave been produoed, Pale: Signature , Prulleq 'Name ,. 1"\ t' ,,'I . I I I I I I i 1, ,I, , I I ! , I v, (~>NWIl'1\lil'l OI"'llltllN1J'(INIINITI (:alijl"! ()I~ (:tIM~rnr/lNl) l 1 , , 1 1 I . ~ohart R, Hoatatber Pll\!nl:i ~~ F f I ~ No, _I) \) ~ I 0 ~ &' Hel\thar E, MArab6n. Df;l~f;lncli\nb S,lIQP9ENA TO. flllOOlx:l: ~~,tf ~ ~ FOO DISCOVEIW"lA1SUA l' 0 t: 0 1'9' Pf"'R nn\i - (N/m3 of flerllon 0" t:nt;H;r)" , within llWUl1ty (~O) qllYll IIft:of" llllf"viQIl of t;hil1 O\lp(1Oonl\, YOll lI/'ll Of'qllf"llq Ill' th~ llOtIf"t'tQ pf"rJQqpll llhe fl~I'pwin9'doC4nenllq,()r thin9s1 Cop!aa ot; l\ny .1ncl i111 ufllsp,hona ....aoo...qa .__wi.t:h l\ j)il.U.J.1.u.1~:..allQ oC 444 f,,!3bl'aaU, C'Il.'l!ala, PI\ \70\3 'for cAU!! ", ~ ..,.,....Illil.9~.!Ll.\1\3/1)fl, '.. ,,--_ III; l,tL.Nfl"t !,ollt;har St;~, 01l1't l!!te, ,~~ \70\ 3 " (Aqch'HI ) .~ VI14 IMY c.jllliver or !Mil 111011)113 oopiel! of llt111 QOOLlmnta O!'proQl.Ioo I:hings rt.'lqUol!l:ucjhy UllIlj llllhpoenll, ,,1:091l\:hor w;ll/1 b/1a oortifiol\ta of.. CCffPlil1l1po, 1:0 U/1e part;y IMking Ilhlll' r~q\1eal: lit t/1e qddrl1fl!l listoq nbove, You /1l\Va \:/113 righll t;o Qoull in IlqVllnOll th\l rfll\GOnllblll Gost of proparing tIle qopias 'Ot' proqUO;ngt~/1a I;l1in911 llou9/1t, '" I f,. you flli I to p~odlloa t/1a doC\.l'mnlll! 01' thin9a t'aquiraq by thia sllbpven~ wit/1il1 tW1lnhy (}!q) .ql\Yll ,.nftnf" 'itll aerriQo, "the paf"ty llervin9 this lIwbpooIIIlIl'llYllllel\.1\ COUrtlordl\l' ~al1in9 yeq, to c;qrply wit/1 it, THI S SU\3PCEIIA WASi!lsUeo AT n,e Rg<;tIEST OF lHIi FO\..hCWINQ PliRSONI N~" Petet' ,J. Russo , , ADORl;SS,I_6..l \~est; LoujilleJ;' Street _.9.a.ttia~a..!.~~~~.___ 1'lil..nrl'PNfii'" t 7-~49- t t 77 - ,- , , ' S~RS'f.iCC()n 10 II 72097, I\rrOONIiY rOllI Pla i nil! Uf " flY llilt ~Tl ()A Tli '__.~ Sual of hhll bourt prothonotary/olerkl Clivi I Division -oeplllly (1m. 1197) " 'I' to ~~.. ~ \ l' t.. .' H (\l) , ., , f' I, H', .~;: " . '1 (1.. l'b ,'1' ,.:1.': ~I\. t'" ' . (L >'_ .\U 1" \111,\i (, I' ;.)(\1_ ~: " 15 rn ) C,''-' U ;' " 'I' " " d' " , " " II !I" " " " " " '.'" " '.l' , , " .. " " " I " "I' " :1, ,n '-j. i't ji j; I .. ii' " "jl !' . 'I' !: " " " " ,,/. J " " " II, '" " " " " " ,. '.'to il\ ;, " " ROBERT R, HoSn:Trr:r~, .. PI<1lntlff IN THr: COURT of qOMMoN p~gAa CUMI3r:I~I.ANP OP\JNTY, PA .. NO,OP.106B CIVil. ACTION.., lAW y~, HI~ATI'Il~R E, MARSTON, peff3l1clpnt JUI~Y TRIA~ DEMANDEP NQTICE OF INTr:NT TO SERVE A SUBPOENA TO EEQPUOE DOC\)MENTS AND THINGS FOR DISOOVI;BX P.1lliSlJtlli.l1Q.ll!J11i 1\009,~ 1 . TO:" Oounaf31 pf Reoorel ,. ,. Df3fenclpntlntencla to aerve A Suppoenp IdentlOAI to Ille one AtlAohedto tills , '. " " Notloe, Youlll'1ve twenty (20) dAya from the cli1Ii1l1ated below In wlllollto file of reoorel . . r . and !lerve. upon the undersigned ElI1 opjeotlonto tllI3 Sllbpoenl'1. If no objeotlonls mAde; , /. ,. tile SLIPpOen<1I11f.1Y be serveel, THOMAS, THOMAS & I'IAFER, I.~P "C~~~ C, l<e/1t Price, EsqLllre 305 Nortll Front slreel P,O, Sox 990 ., Harrlsburo, PA 17108 (717) 256-7632 LD, No, 06776 ATrORNI:YS FOR DEFENDANT ,. 'I' " PATr:: April 1 . 1999 , \ ",. 1\ I~OIlNt\'I' 1\, I I Of:1'1'WI"1'ln 1\ , I I'lilll\l:! f:1' I I " V, I I IIWI'I'llInl\ In, MlIl\fJ'I'ON, I Po !:Ond,llll: l IN' 'l'm1 COtlll'l' (li" nnMMON 1'1,lilllfJ Cl!Mlll"III,f\NIl C:OtlN'I'Y, 1'/\ NO, !)n~I()~lI , CIVTl, /\C'l'lON -. I,/\W lllJ\lY '1'111/\1, pmM/\NPI"P " ~ ' " II .. II" ~~RTlrl~i\T~ ' , mRmU'm~'T(l S~KVI~~ OF ~Un"p~NAS' , , rlJ.R~U^NHO'kU~~ ~Pllllt:l:l, " ,~ ;'1: : - r .,., . As it Pl'lllUqlllslIu to slllylcnli( Stlhpnnlllls (or dOclllllnl1ts ill1r1lhlllns plll'SlIilllllo Hlllo '100!l,~~, !In(ol1r1nI11 corllflus Ihilll . '1, A No\lCll of 1111011110 survo SII\!pIIIJIH1S with mplos o( Iho sllbpnul111s illlnr:l1l1r1l1wruln Wns Innllod Ill' rlnllvororllo uilch pmly nlluiiilll.yol1lY dllYs pfior In Ihu rlnY ',m which Iho slll)pnUl1i1S wuru sOllnhllq hn sUlY{1{h .,' " '" . , ;!, A copy of thu No\lcll of 111\0111, 1111;llId";nlhn proposlld SllbpOlll'li1S, Is III1i1chorll'; this. Cnrllflcillo) , " :1, A willvor (If Iho 2DdilY porlod hila buull rncol~p(l; ill1d ,t\, TIHi HllbplllJllilS whh~h will hn snlvnd ill'u'ldnl1l1cnl 10 ,Ihu slIhponl1ilS ,whlclil1l'o illlm:hild 10 Ihil Nollcu of Il1lnllllo SUIVO Sllbpllunns, " THOMAS, THOMAS & HM~fl, UI' ~.~6 (")~~ ~~ c, K~NT l'IIlC:~, ~SQUIIl~ ATTOIIN~Y I.D, 1/1l(,77(, :105 NOflHI fflONT STIlm . liTH l'lOOIl I',O,1I0X!lll!l HAIIIIISIIUIIG, "^ mllll (717) :llln-7ft:!:l " ATTOIIN~Y 1'011 DmNDANTS \Ii Dilt~1 .~L t) o::J.'1:J ,\\ ", " jl: RO~~RT r'j, HOSTliTTliR, Plnlntlff v, IN nw gOURT OF GaMMoN PI.pM Qr CUMnPR~ANP OOUNTY, PA NO, PO.1Q6fl ' CIVI~ ACTION . ~AW JURY TRIAh Pr:MANPr:P 1-Ir:ATHr:R r:, MARSTON, .. Ppfol1chH11 '." - - - - . NPlI~~ Of INTF.NT TO ~~IIV~ ~u"roaNMT~ PllOP\J~~ PQGUM~NTH^NPTf1INq~fOII . PI~GOV~RY I'U/(SIJANT TORUI,~ ~OOP,~l , - " - " " H , ' , . TO, t;:Clllll5ol nnrll'nlllus of f~Clcord ~ f)Clflll1clnl1l, "h1nthor ~, Mnl'stnn, hllol1d ICl Scl/yCl slIhpClCll1ns'ldClnllc:nllo thwonus '(llIi\c,hncl to Ihls notlcu, YOll hilVU IWCll1ly (;lO) clnys (1'(Jl11lhn dillCl IIslorllllllnw 111 which 10 fIICl of IlIcord ~Ild sorvu llpnl1,lhCl \lIldCll'slUl1od i1l1 ohJ!!Clloll.lo tho, IHlhpnllll<lS, If 110 nhlncllollls lIlilr.!Cl, Ihn SqhpClllllilS I11ny /lCl sorvud, Pntol s J 1I19~ TI/OMAS,'1l10MAS & I/Af~II,I.I." / ,.-;t. ~ -Q.~-~-l' C, Konlf'tlco, ~s(full'o Altnl'l1uy I,P, II0677ft 31W Nutlh ftont Stl'oot 1',0, flux 900. ' I/tlttlshul'll, I'A .171 O/l-IlOIlO (7m 255.76:12 AltlltllUYH fill' lJofuIldill11 " . '." " (' i', ;' I' " " " " OOMMONW!:AI.'lll of P!:NNSY~VANIA oOUNTY OF OUM~r:R~ANP " IW'j~lIl'\' H, IIOWi'I'l"""I~lll I IN 'I'm: coug'l' 01" COl1MON Pl,H;Ml 1'II1.1.nl:.I. fl' I I NO, 99~lOli8 v, I I own I\C'l'IqN .. l.r,W II pll\'l' I liD Il H1, .MI\IW'J'ON, I !Jafonc!'JIl\; I ,llJllY 'l'lnl\l. pmMI\NPIGP ~8-TIleR.QQJJQJi~R.II::Illliae EQRJdl~U~~.22 ,. 'c, TOI Dr, 0 ralfuluril~nsen,..Qllli'Q.dill.!LMecllol1l~lllilL..Qar.il!l1@,,_M_J1Qj~ " ,(NIIIlI11 of 1'0180n or f'nllly) .. Wllhi'Il'IWonlY (~O) Iluys nllor 80lvlcn of Ihl~ 8111>pool\n, YOII 010 llfeloloel hylllo 00111110 prodlloo 1110 lollowlno l/oolll11onls or IhlllQ81 . . . .ililJDplete'ooples of alwal1c1 ElII reoolds,JQp'orts Elnd cllannQJlUfLliliIilles remmllno Bqbert I~, Hostetter, 1 West Penn Street, Oarllsle, PA, Date of 13Irt!l.l..Qlli16/3B from November 13, 1000 10 IIlli.p.resent elate, ~t: Thamas, Thomas & Hafer, ~LP, 306 N, FrontSt" P.O. Bo.x..ill1!lJ.:lmrlll.lllim, PA 17100-00911 .' . " ., -- II. (^'Ielre8s) YOlll11oY dollvoror 1ll01l100lblo ooplos of Iho dOOIIlIl&nI8 or prOlllloo thlnos roqllosllld hy Ihhl.sllllpoonll,'looolhor wllh' " Iho 00111001110 of oOI\lpllllnoo, 10 tho POlly ,nuklno Ihls loqll081 ollho oddrossll8101/ ul>ovo. YOI! huvo \llorlohllo sook In udvunoo, Iho rousollnhlq cosl of proporl/lO Iho ooplos or proclllolno tho Ihlnos sOIlIlI\1, "P If YOII 101110 prol/lICo Iho dOClllnonls or Ihlnos roqlllred hy Ihls 81111pool1o, Wllhlnlwonly (~O) duys nfior lis sorvloo, Iho , puny sorvlno Ihls slll'poono 1110y sook 0 oOllrl order oon1polllno YO\llo oOl11ply wllh II, .' " , , " THIS SUBPOI2NA WAS ISSUI2D ATTHI2 r~lmUEST OF THE FOI_LOWING PERSON: NAME: 0, I<enl Prloe, EsqLllte . .. , !ADDRESS: p,O, 130xOOO, HE1rrlsburg, PA 17100-0900 TELI3PHONE: (717) 265.7632 SUPREME,COURT !p1I: 06776 ATTORNEY FOR: DefendElnl I3Y THI2 OOUIU: ' DArI2: Seal of the Court ProthollOlaryiOletll, Civil Division :-;' Deputy ,r I' " hpl~prl flllnoltJhWnonr (!irlll Inn\lt!ll1011 ~/ClIl1nI1UP CIQIIl1 Np, 010 17Q\3>>U:lBGI 11'1'1111 llflillQnl1rcal " Iii' " It j'; " " "", " " . " " .', i" ", " !' "" .. '" .. .' , ' \',,'j 'I' "" 1\ , "{',' " " " " '" '" " P, " \'," " 'I " " ,,. " 'i " ji' ,I, " " 'I\, " 'I! I! ,. 1\ " " I, 'i! ,,', ',; " I' ,. ',\< I; I I ,,' " .if " " ',"" " .I, ,',' ..', ,,' ,i' " I.' , j," .. ",. ,..- , 19, Pl'lnll3~ In ~PPQr(.hmpe wllhPfl,R,O,P, 1pga(e), " , ,1~, AQmllle~ In pflrt, gl'lnl~cj In pl1rl, 1\ 1\1 fl~mllll'l~ II1f11 flfll'lr pelng \1lr~lPk by Ihe vehloll3 clrlven hy Pl3fenclf\nl lil'll1lher Mflralon, PIEllnllff RO~\3rl Hoaleller Pflme 10 r\'lElI on Ihl'! rq~clWl1Y pf Nor\I1Hflnovar ~Ire\'lt, l'he rel1lfllnlng 11111'1gfl\lpn I" ~\'lnl\'l~ In flPpprclflnpewllh Pl1,R,C,P, 10ga(e), 14, Penll'lcl, The fllIl'lgfltlpna I1re ponolu!llpl1!l of Il1w ~ncl/pr fl1pllp whlph no I1nawer h~ requlre~, To II1\'leXlenl Ihfll fin I1n\1Wer ml'lY ,be requlre~, II la apeolflpally ~enlecl Ihfll Ihe answering Pefenclflnt oflullecl or QonlrlpUlecl 10 oflualng the InjurleEl l1ncl cll1ml1gea l1l1egl'lcl by l1ny n\'lQllgenl aol or omlElslon, l3y Wf1.y of furlher l1nawer, 1111'1 allegl\lIons I'lre clenl\'lcl In I1ppprdanoe wllh P",;R,c,P, 10g0(e), COUNT I Hostetter v, Marslol1 16, The "'nawers sel forth above ,In 1 Ihrqugh14 ",ra Inoorpor",leQ herein by '.' ' referenoe, I, " 16~ Penlecl, The allegations l1rl'l opnolualons of laW I'lnd/or faol 10 Whloh no l1naWer la required, To Ihe extent Ih",1 ",nf1.nSWer may bE) required, II Is llpeolfloally , denlecl Ihal Ihe f.mawerlng Pefencll1nt Ol'lUBeQ 01' oontrlputed 10 oauslng IhEllnJurles ancl cll1tnl'lges l1l1eged Py l1ny negligent 1301 or omlaalon, ay w"'y of further answer, the ,. " l1l1eg",t1ona are denied In aooordanoe with Pa,R,C,P" 1020(e), 17, Penlecl, The allegations are oonoluslonB of law and/or faot to whloh no anBwer Is requlrecl,To Ihe exlentthat an anBwer may be rf3qulrad, It Is speoifloallY denied that the anBwerlng Pefendemt oauBed or oontrlbuted to ()auslng the InJurlea ancl clamagea alleged ,by any negligent aot or OmlSBlon, ay way of further l1nsWer, the allegations ara denied, In E1oqordanoe with Pa,R,O,P, 1020(e), ,. 113, P\3nl\3~, Thl3 fllI130f.ltlpnaflff3 P\ll1plUlllona of If:\w f.l11~lor ff.lot to whlph np fll1l1Wftr III r13qulrf3Q, To thf3 f'lKtf3l1t thf.lt f.l11 f.lI1I1Wf31' Il1f.1Y,ll13 rf3qulrf3~, ,It III apf3plflp!'IlIy Q13nl13Q 1I1f.1! the f.ln~warlno P13fenQf.ll1t \If.lua\3~ PI' ool1trlputeQ to P!'I~lIlnotl113lnJllrleaf.lml , ' , ~!'Im!'1013a f.l1I13g13~ Py f.lny npollg13nt !'lot or P1nlaalon, 13y limy of further f.lnawar, the !'IlIagf.ltlOi1a !'Ire Qanlacl In f.!oporclf.lnoa with P!'I,R,Q,P, 10I!O(e), 1~, penle~j, The allPOf.ltlona f.lre ponolualona of Il=1w ~n~lor ff.lot to whlbh no f.lnl\wer la requlrecl' To the /:1Ktent 1I1f.1! I=1n I=1nawer Il1f.1Y Pa ra9~llraQ, It la apaolflplillly c1enlecl 1I11=1t the f.lnawflrlno Pefenclant Of.l~laecl or oontrIP~lte~ to of.lwllng tIle InJurl13~ ancl cllilmf.lgea f.llleOacl Py f.lny nagllopnt aot or omlaalon, 13y way of further anaW13r, the , . . - . . . f.lllagf.ltlona f.lre clenlacl In aooorclf.lnoe with Pa,R,Q,P,,1029(e), I!O, penlecl, The alleOatlona are oOl1olualonll of Il:'\W f.lncllorfl:'\ot to whloh no , , ". . i all1lwer la rel.\ulrecl, To the exte.nt that f.ln anawermay pe requlracl, It la apeolfloally . denied that the anBwerlno Dafendant oEluaeQ or oontrlPuted to oElualng the InJurlea Elnd dElmEloeo alleOaQ Py Elny negligent aot or ami Balon, 13y way of fu~ll13r anBwer,the aileOEltlonBElre Qenled In ElooordElnoe with Pa,R.o,P, 10~9(e), 21, penled, 1he allegEltlona EIre oonoluelol1B of IElW Elndlo~ fElot to whloh no f.lnllwer Ie requlrecl, To the extent .that Eln E1newer may be required, It la apaolfloallY denleclthElt the Elnawerlng Defendant oalllled or oontrlbuted to oEluelng the InJurlea and j .., dal1iElgeB allegecl by any neglloent act or om laB lon, 13y way of furtller ElnBwer, .lhe ElllegEltlonB al'e denied In ElooordE1l1oe with PEl,R,Q,P,1029(e), WHEREFORE, Defenclant Heather E, ME1rBton demandB judgment In her favor and agalnat Plaintiff, " , , " ., ' Ii " 0, . lIml~1' fll'lllWrUllllllllplllllllc rOlllrlll. III 1\lI'Ihpl' 1I1l~\WI', Ppt~IHllHll, MIINlol', IlplllPN ~1I1111l1l0~1I1111l1N PIII'~\lIl1lll11 PII, H,c,P, 1029(1l), Plllllllll, 'I'll IlwOllull'lIry, IIflllllllllhl'll1l1ll11llllnll 'WUIlI', llllfplllllIlll, MIII'Htllll, IVIIN llPPI'lIlll1ll hel' vehlpllllIl nil nppl'llpl'JlltulIlll1 Nnl~ Hppoll, 11l1\11'1hPI' IlI1HIVIlI', Pul\llldnnl, " '! i", MIIHlor, "culps HlIlllllllpllnlhlf1H plIrHllIlIIlllll'n, H"c,p,.. , 1(l~!J(lll, -.", " II. bpnlell. Tlllhe 1l0llll'lIrY,lIpolllnlbrllllltllln 1Il1lllwllel', Pel'elldlllll, MIII'NIllll, dlllevol'ythlll~ hI hul' el1llll'llllll IIvlllll PllIlllllf'l' !ll'lvlllll his whoelohnlr hllo her vehlole, In f\11:'hel' IInSIVel', '/)cfendlllll, MIINtlll', llllnlell Hnld IIl1elllltlolls 1\ ;" " " p\ll'Nllllnt 101.'11, R,c,P" ~039(Q), e' /)01111Id, ''1'0 Ihu Cllllll'/II'y, lIpOIl Inrllrllllltlollllnd holloI', II WIIN rllllnllr!' Ihlllllpurllled hlN whoolchllll' directly Jlllo'the vohloleol' Dclolldllllt, Mllr~llll1, IlIl\lI'lhol'lI11NWOI', ,i Dololldllnl, MIINlol', dellleN NIIIllllllelllltlol1s plll'Sllllnt to PII, " R,C,P, I029(el, 1', DUlllolI, Tho vohlolll Of' lJelolldllnliMlIl'stoll, IVIIH III pili III . (j , 'I, III1~WOI' I~ 1'~11\II1'PII, To IIIIl IlXI1l11l11111111~\WI' 1H1I>,'\1oI10UO~~III'>', IMllmllllll,MIINllll', , ~plllllnllllll>, lIolllo~ 111111 Pllrllmhll1l, MIII'~lolI, Wll~ 1I0~lIgolllllmIIl1l1l1l11>' 1101 01' rlllh11'0 10 " ., 11111 ol1lwlllllr of P\lI~IlII1\11I, Mlll'~IIl\1. 01\\1~\l11 or oOllli'lhlllol1 10 Iho 1I11~1l~\II1\lll1'lo~ 1111\1 \11I1111111\l~ ulllllllOll hr PllIllIlIfl'. '1'01110 001111'111'>', \lpol1ll1f01'll1ll1l011111\11 holloI', III~ IIWI'1'Ollllml illlllllll11o~ po 1'0 ml II III , MIII'~lol1, 111'10\111111 011 I'll I'll \ 'IImrpl'\I\lul1\ 11111111101' 111111 , " '1101101 01', l'n 11I1 1'0 101101 011 1101' pllrl ol\\lHo\I'111' oOllll'lhllloll 111'1111>' ol'lllllll1\lfr'~ 1I111'IIIlII , ,,, 111I111l\1I1l~, Wllh 1'1l11llnllo ,tl1\lllllollllllol1~ 1'01l1\1'\1I111l11\11I1'1\l~ 1~1111111111l1l1lIlH, \)ofomllllll, MII~IOI', \lol1lo~ ~lIld,lIllolllltlol1~ 1I11\IIIVIlI'~ Ihlll 1I111l1' 1'\lIl~Pllllhl\llllv\lNlIlllltlOll, Polilil\III1II, " MII~lol', I>> wltholll KI10W\\l\\llo 01' 1111' o 1'111 II II II 11 ~\lt'l'lllluI1I10 1'01'111 II holloI' IIH, 10 tho \null I., " ~)f HIIIIIIIIlOllllllol1~ IIml proM 11101'001' IH 1IIlll1111111ollllt 1I'IIIIi '" 1\11'Ihol' 1I1l1l\Vlll', \)01'011\111111, MII~IIlI', Ilol1lo~ 1l1l1111l1l\lglltl0I1N plll'~lIlInt 10PII, R,C,P, 1()29(0), 71, \)01'01111111\1, MIIHI\lI',IIOl1loH 1110 1I1l1l11l\lInll~ Ollll,llIllIollll1"'llll'lllln\PII 21111' Plllll1tln"~ COlllpllllll\. Dol' 011\111111 , MIIHI\lI', l~ 1I11vl~o\11I1l1I Ihol'ofol' IIVOI'>> thlll ~01ll0 or tho l\lIoglltl<1I1~d(1I1l1l11l011 III ~1I111 )1111'1I11l'lIpll II\'O oOIj(Jhllllol1~ nl'lllW 1I1\t! 110 I\II'thlll' IIIlSWOI' 'Is 1'0q1l11'0<1, Tn 1110 oXI0l111111 IIIlSWOI' 11111>' \10 lIuoossllI'>,. pol' 011<11111\, MlIstCl', s)1oolflollll>, <lol1llls 111111 pol' 011<111111. MlIl'llloll, WIIS 1I0111l110\l1 1Il\\1 111111 1111>' 1I0t 01' fllllul'o 10 1I0t 01\ hol1l1lf nf Dol'oI\llllllt, MlIl'sloll, OIlUsOllnl' oOllll'lhllloll lotho II110go<lIIlJ\II'loH 11\111 <l1I1111\1l0H olllllllOiI br Pllllllll1'1'. Tn tlwoOI\II'lIl'>', upnl\ 1\lI'nl'lllll\lol\ 1I1\t! holloI', II, Is llVOl'ro<l IlIlIt 1I11lH'11I11O~ 1)01'01\<111111; MIIl'slol1, IIUl\ld It\ II cllrol\lllll1d prut!ollt nlll\l\lUl' 111111 , II ", 1\ i ~ ;Po lilmlII 1\l, 'MlIl'slOI1, 1I11111111ll1l~ OP~l'lIlll\1 hilI' yuhlllllllll n slIlilllml pn\\lllnl ~PIlIl\1, 1111\1l'lhol'lInN\VIlI', Plllilnlilllll, MlIsl\lI', donluH slllll nllllllllllll.\ls PIl I'sll II 111 In PII, ,~,C, p, 11120(1l), " .' " h, ,Pllnllld, '\'ollw Uonll'lll'r, Ilpon Inthl'll.1llllonnml holllll\ lJolilndllllt, MIII'~tnn, nbHUI'Wd II 1ll11l'KUII,uI'OHHWnlk, In 111l'lhlll' IInHWOI', Poton<hllll, Mn~t\ll', <Iunll's ~lIhllllllllllltlons ,:1 ' Pll1's\l1l1111oPII, H,C,P, I070(1l),' I. pOlllod, To tho 0\11111'1I1'>', Ilpt1n Inl'onllntlol1 nml'hlllllll', .. ,) IJot'omlll1\l, MlIl'slOll,dl1l oh~ul'Vo Plnlllllft'llP<11\ tl1ll hlllhwllr IIN Plnlnlll'l' drllvo hlH whlllll~hnll' (111'0011>,' 11110 hol' .. " vohlolo, '"l\ll'lhol' nl1~\V01', /Jol'omlllnl, MnHtul', dOilies " " snhl nllollnllol1s plll'~(llInllo Pn, H,C,p, 1029(0), .I, !Jonlc\I, '\'0 tho oonII'lH'>"llponhlfbl'll1nllollllll<1bollol',' ',I' !Jol'ol1l1l1nl, Mnl'~lon, dl<1 kcop n pl'opOI' 1\11<1 n<luljunlo " " ',lookoul Ihl' pll<losli'lnl1s, 1I\'l\ll'lhol' n\lSWUI', IJol'omlnlll, , ' MustoI', d01\IOH >>nld II110gllllonH plll'Sllnl1llol'll, R,C,p, 1029(0), , ,,' k, !Jol1lod, To Iho oonll'nl'>', npol1 II1I\1I'l11nlloll nml \1cllol'. It I.~ q. " MII~IIlI'I 11~1I111H HIIIIIIIII\lI\III1I111~ 111111 IIVOI'H dHllllftVI \'IlIlHllllllhlv I11VIlSII~\"IIlIl, 'MIlI1\IIlIll, ..'- " " MII~IIlI', IH 11'111111111 kllll\l'hlllll~ Ill' 1111111'1\\11111111 HnlTllllvl\1 III l'Il\'lll11 111l1I1ll'nH III OW 1\'\lIh Ill' HllhlllllllUlIlllIlIH II III 1 Pl'IllIl' IIW\,vIII: I~ 111l11\1IIl1IVIIIIIII'11I1, 1111\1\'IIIIlI'II11sWIl\', I 1ll1'1lH\11I1l1 , MIIHIIl\',lIolllvH slilll IIllv~lIlll111s pl1l'Hlll1l1ll11 PII, H,C,Jl, lOZO(v), 7u, IMvllllll1l\, MII,~IOI',\lvl1lvH Ow IIl1vllllllo11H OI1I1II1I1WIlIIl PlI1'IIl!.l'lIph 21) 111'\lIIlIlIlIl'fl~ Clll\1plllllll, lllllillllllll1l, MIIHill\', IH mlvlsollllmllhol'vl'oI' IIVlll'Hlhlll sUI1W " . ' " 111'II,11l IIl1vlllIlIIlllH CIlIlIIIIIlVIIII1 slllll PII1'lIl1l'lIph III'U 0111\CI\IIlIIIIlH <il' Inw 1I1ll11111 1\11'11101' , IIllH\V\l1' Is I'VIIIII\'oll, 'I'll Ow 01l101l1111l1111SWOI' 1I111Y IW.l1llvOHSIII'>"llotilnlllllll. MlIsIVI'. Hl'vcll'lclIlIY 1I0111vH IhllIIMvll<lIl1l\, Mill'sllli\, \VIIH 110~1I1l011l11ll11 Ihlll IIIlY 1I\l1 n,' 1'1111\11'0 10 " ,; , IIvl nil hohllll' Ill' INI\Jmllllll, Mn)'sloll, IlI111HC<l nl' oOI1II'lh\IIOlllll lho 1IIIIlll0lllnl\l1'Ios 1111<1 , ' " 111I11111110H 1l11l11110<1 h>, PIIIIIII\lT, To Ihu Onl1ll'1l1')', IIpOI1 1I11'01'1111111nll IHI<I holloI'. II IH '1\'01'1'011 Ihlll III 1111 1I11l0H \)01'0111111111, MIII'HIoI1. IIUlo<II'1111 011 ro l'll I 1111\1 I'l'mlOll1 111111\1101' 111111 ,;' " , ., ' " Iln 1101111' 1\111111'0 In IIcl ollhol' PIII't CIlIIHOII Ill' cOIlI1'1I1\1l0d 101111>' nl' PIIIIIlIIt'f'~ 1I11~~Il11 " , <IIII\\III!OH, Willi willii'll IlIlho 1I1l~'l1l1llnll~rOIlIlI'<lII\l1 1I\1\11'IvH 111111 <lIIHIllgUH, Dof'ol1l1l1l1l, ,.' .,..,' ,.' MII~IOI> 1101\lu~ slll<llIlIol!II0nl1~ 1I11l11lVOI'~ 111111 i\t'tol' \,0IlH<1I1I1hI0 IlIvoHlIlllltln1\. ,\)01'lll1<1111111 MIIHI~I" IH \Vllhnlll kl1owlellgo 01' hll'ol'llllllloll ~lIlTlul,olll 10 1'01'111 II \101101' II~ Inlhv trllth Ill' klllllllilol\lllhl1"~ 1111<1 p\'ool' 111111'001' IH<lol1\lIl1<1e<l1l1 11'1111. tlll\Il'lhol'III1S\VCI', 1J01'oIl<lIlI1I, MIIHIOI'. <lolllotl ~1I1<llIllolllltloIIS 1'1I1'HIlIIIlI to I'll, R,C,P, 1020(0), WlmlUWOIm, 1J0 lil 1111 II 111 , MIIslol'; dOI11I\II<ls Ihlll PIIIllltllT's Ci1111plllhll tU "i' , " " .. Il\l \1l~1l1IsH~II, 'I" .N~ , ,~o, Allnt' PIIII11\ltT'ij 1I111l~1l\1 011l11l1~ t'lll' 11I1\ll'll'sWlll'o \111'llllllr 111\\1 )11'\l1\hnntolr CII\l~0\\11YJlIIII\llltT'~ \lWI1 flll1l1l1\\ll1oulnll1nl 110 110l\1I1l1lI1\1~, 1'1I1'\l\~~slr IIml 1'00~lossl>, n)1IlI'n\Il\\11\H wlwol\1ll1lll' 011101110,HII'I'01 <Ill'llo\l~ IllIll \1'1It'lWwlll1l1\\IIVIIJ'lill111 , , ' _ _ . 1 \\11\\ wllllo\ll kQophl1111 Pl'llp\ll'l\1o~Il\1\.rnl' 1110 Pl'u~\l'l\lont' 1\1litlll' vohl910H llll \119 , " hllll1wlI>,III1\\l/lll' 111 1l111Vlng Ills wll\lulohnll' 011\011 \hoI'O\lllhfIlI'IlWhol1 hu ~110W or Hho\1111 ,III1VO ~\lllWI1II1I1II1)llllll' vphloluH W01'\l)1I'IIHOI1I, ~ \. AIl'lIf Pll\ll1tltr~ IIIl0glld InJlIl'luH 1111<1 <l1I1l1111l1ls 111'0 h'llI'l'o<l111 wholll PI' 111 pi\l'Il1s II I'os\lll ot' tho 1I)101'1I1I0I111t' P<ml1s>,IVIHlllI C1I1l1PIIl'llllvo N9111l1l01l0P AIl\, ~2,A1l1l1' plll'\ lit' Plnll1l1lT's ,1I\ogoddll1\1I1110S hUho t'ol'm 11\, I1W\IlI'II\. " " oxpoliSOSIII1<1 WlIllo loss 111'0 hll1'l'o\\ h>"lIpOl'lIllol1l1t' pOl1l1srlvllnl1l 11111111\01111 " ',I HIlSplII1HIl111l\>, Aot, ,Ii' :\3, PllIllIllt'l' IIllollo<lln.llll'los IIn<l 11lIlIlIIllOs 111'0 hll\'l'Olllj~ Iho 1011111 II) I1l'liiolplIl ofIlSS\l\11p\llIll or I'IHk, ' WllmtlwOIUC, \)01'011<11111\, MIIN\OI', \I01\1l1l1cls Ihlll PllIll1ll1'1"s qlllllllll1l111 I'i 'ho IIls\11lsso<l, " \.; " '.'1 20 I' 'I; " ," " I' FI) i' " " " '" :1' Ii, ,I- 'j, .. " " 'I, .. ", I' I' 'I " .. ill 'I, I, i'; (fI :>- " '" \" '" II,. " t~;i . Or. ..I .., " IJ,I,.\ ,~ T ~ (~ ~ " , <. ~l i" , 'r.; ( . ~.lr., I'" ..Ii':" h'.I. ,(':) r:.~i I' I ~, ' I., \", . ,. I"" ..'j'f!} iVI'; I i'1'l(,; ,I :J /1:1[' (V' 11JW till' l,'.t:I.. " r..: '1'\ I, .... "'i.. l::i fP tot (J I' I' I' " I' " I' .' I' .. " , H " " /1 " " " "H 'I, II; I' ii " .' I' .' \il' ;I' " " II , Ii" " " Ii " I' " d " " " .. 'I , .', ", j; i' " I' " n, ;, .' " " I' ~J ~ \'() ::'" l,,' .,(',\' " ,,\' I:: ., 'I I u~ '? r>! (,:-; ~ :' i "" C,) ;!.;, /'''' 1.1.. I') :1 ,( .~ I "(Ii_. '.' I'll ,:1' ;-"VJ /,j. ...... I;!,:' 1,:J/1 t C::: I"l",/,I 1,-;. '-'. I.: ;""" :'IL", .'.-. " II. CO" ) l;) L:I (J " " " " -'i' "" " 1\' ;, !I ,/ 'I, " " ,! " " , I' , " ,I' " 'I; " " 'I " I' , !' I' " " ", 'I " " Ii ",. "j' " j; I, I '" 'if " " ~ d 'I:' " H " 'I " " I' '-, Ii ,;' H ,! .' '1,'; .I:, !.- ,I I' " ';" !! i,! ,." " " q, ., .. gfillIIFIOA'fF. OF SERVlog ,AND NOW,' IhlEl ~Otll day pf A\.1p~IElI, gOOO,I, 0, I~RNT PRIOR, RSQ\JIR~, fpr Ihll ., firm pf THOMA{:l, THoMAS ~ HAFI=R, ~~P, flllorn13Ys for P"lfllndflnl, herepy ,c"lrtlfy Ih~II" . ,_' _ . _ ii. hElVe Ihlfl dflY ElllrvEldlhe, wlthln,Nqtl~E1 of Intent 10 ServfJ fl suppoenfl 10' Pro.duoe , PocUmen\1l f1nd Thln9El for Plflcovary Pur!l\.1flnl 10 RulfJ 4009,,21 Py dl'lpoflltlnQ f1 qopy of ' Iha same In Illa United ~lalEls Mall, posle91'!" prepaid, al Harrisburg, PannElylvanlE1, addreflflBd IpI " Paler J, Ruaso, 1=1l(1\.1lrfJ ~1 Wesl ~pulher SIreel OElrll!lle, PA 17013 arlan 0, Oaffmy, Rllqulre .. Oharlell a, WallllfJfakl, I:llqulre, PalerEl ~ WaElllefElkl ' 2931 North Fronl strefJt Harrlspurp, PA 17110.1280 THOMAS, THOMA8~ HAFEm, l.,\.lP" "r.!~~' 0, KfJnt Price, I:squlre ,. f ;i " ,. .. ,~"'ICI'n^Nm IC, CmCWI'UI}, ICfiQllllUtI S\1rr~1110 Cllllrl \,P, . 5=\05\ 01 Wllall<iIIllIlIlI' ~\\'Il~1 Onl'lIalll, I~A 17013 ' '(717)240-1.177 'ROlllCR'l' R, HUS1'lC1'1"CH' I "'ninllff I I V, I I,' 1 1 mC/\.'l'mm 'C, M/\.RS'rON ,I, llpfpnllnlll' 1 1 A\\l1l'1w>, lb\' 11lnl\1l1ff l~pll~\,\ I~, HPa\p\\Or lNnnc COURT OF COMMON 1'~.'Ci\S of ' CUMnlCln~l\l'm GOIJN'l'V ,11'CNl'ISYLY ANI/\. I' " No, !l!l~ 1Il~" Clvn~ ACTION . "I\W I' ,l\JlW 'l'R'AL 'lJi)MANU!CP 'WI1'IIIl1~A W AI. OF Al1111CARANCE TO '\lIE PIW'llloNOTAl{ Yi " K-ill<1l>, wllh<lmw Ilw npponl'lmO~ of polol' j, R\laSO, 1\6\1\111'0 Ila 00\111sollor Pln.lllllft'Robol'l, ' .". R, Hoalol\o\, In Ih~ nhllvo-OIlPlloflO\\ mn\l~I', ,- .. 1lY1G:&~~ PIWUR .1, ,WRSO, nSQUIRE ,. p ENTRV 011 AIIPEARANCIC TO THE PROTHONOTARY, Kindly on\ol' tho IIPI'OIl\'III\OO of S\ophllnlo 11; Chorlok, BHq\1lro Oil bohnlf of I'lnlntln' Robott R, HOHtoltol' In tho lIhOVO-CIlPlloIl011111l1tlOl', , I llY, ) -' , ,I , "a/l/ICNIC H, 1l0H"'lC'I"I'I':B, INUlVllU'(\l".v , !\Nn Mi I\UI\1IN, m' Tim ICH"'I\'I'1'1 UF I ' HllIINH'I' H,llnHTI'1""ml~, mcc'Ci\/ilml I I'lnhllll'f ' , I , I I , I V, IIIW"IIICHIC, Mi\H(!l"'ONJII"l 1\1!\R'I'IClt MI\NIlFl\C"'I',mH/i 'Nf'" 'MpIIIIlInIH ' IN "',m {;OI'H'" (W (JUMMnN "',ICI\Ii <U<' CIJMIIIO'U,ANIl {~mJN'I'y,"'CNNHYIN (\N'I\ NU, UI),ln~" (c'VII, AC'I'ION.',!\ W ,IPltY 'I'HIAI, !H'1M!\NlUCU. CIO't'IWICA'I'IC (HI SICI\YICIC " " I, Rtllphl1l1lll E, CIWI'I\1k, nt\Ol'l1or fill' nll~PI)o H, IlllSIPt\OI', II00s IWl'llh>, Plll'lIf)'ll1nlll Ill\pr 111'1110 f'IIIII1III'I'H Hl1hs\ltllth1l1 lll' RIIIlIlOHS\11' 1111<101' M H,c,P, 23~2, WIIH I1lnllolllhlH .i?:o~ 1111>' 01'. (Jv~~. ! 200 I, hr I1I'Ht'\lIIl~,~ 11;8, Mnll, pllH\l1~o )1l'oplllll, IIpOI1 tl10HIl IIHIPII holPWI , , " Chll1'loH Wn~lIpf'skl, Ils11" nl1d Urlnl1 CllfIl'or, IJHll', Attol'lw>,wfol' PQlill1lhll\t, MIIHlol' MllI\lllholmol'H 29:lIN, FI'OI1I HI, llnl'r1Hhlll'll, M 171 10 " C, KOI1I PI'loo, IlHll, At\llI'l1o)' Ihl' Polol1dnl1l, "OlllhPI' MIII'HI\111 30S N, F!,lll1l I'll,; 6'10 Fhllll'. 11111'1'1~hlll'll, M 17 I OR ,J' " .' j~:.. ~~JrO~E' CllOj'lok, ESI" . . " "'f' " I' H " 'I " , , j;~'i ' f,': ,.'.' ,-,' ~'..1 .. , "\.. ~ " , 5 ~,r 11,1 ~.] I }1.1 , , , :.Ii" :' ;:i.: \.: \".r. ,:-, ::.'.i ("I :J_," \ ~ ~ l ',;" ;~" ',:(/l lil[. l'J ..!!';; ,'.'11, .-,-. 1\.". [I, l\lltl \''-; !IJD.. " " I" , II. .~... .,:1 ,1_) , I~:" 0 f' 11, ,'" \1' I' " . ..' 'j,; " [ ",. " ,,, .' .. " 'I' " " [, I .ii' , I ','I' .. " .' ;, .' " 'j .." .. " , " " ..I " , , Hf\vlno rapalvf.l~ no ra13pOn~13 to 11113 !1forallf\l(:I Intl3rrOOlltorll313, 11113 " .," un~ar13lonl3~ clll'aotf.lclll.ll3tt~r tg Pllllntlfrll IIttornay qlltacl Mou!lt ;24, goPO Ingull'lng 1111 to the 13t~'tUli of tha cll13Qovary ra13ppn!la!l, A tr~la ancl porraot oapyof 13111(:1 lattar 113 IIttllohecl .' " I har~to 1113 Exhibit W', 6, !j, , '7, On or apo~lt Novampel' 0, ;!OO() , Pllllntlff Sl3rvecl pllrtllllllnllwar!l totha .' IIfOl'allalcl InterrOOl'ltol'laa, p~ltfallad to provlcle any Infol'hlllt!t:m ragal'Qlng axpart.. wltna!lllell Elncl fllllact to pl'ocl\Joa IIny expart raport13 ~13, rag~la13ted In InlerroglltOl'le13 13 . ,16, Atnla fllld oorl'aot oopy of Ilalcl anawel'll IfllltllIPhecl haratoaa ~, 0, " H!lvlno reoalvecl no, Information I'eg~rdlng axpert wllna1313e13 or any ElXparl l'eport13, the underalgnerl dll'eoled two follow.up letl~ra toPlalntlff'13 1Il16rney cllltecl " , ' peoemper 19, 2000 an~ Janullry 20, 2001Inq~,ll'lnQ liS to tl1a atat~I!l. of any expel't.. repOl't131 A true lind, QOrreotoopl(:Jll of Blllcl letlersllre atlaol1e(:l h~reto all~, '0, No axpart I'epol'ts 9n elthal', IIl1plllty or damagaa hl:lva peen pl'oduoed PY the Plaintiff Elsof the data of the filing of this motion, " , . 10, Pllllntlff hila a subatElntlll1 medloal history whloh neoeasltEltes expert ,,' I. . reports from mecllol'l.1 speolElllsts Inorder to ElllooElte or IIttrlbllte the PIEllntlff's multiple medloElI pl'oblemsamong VEl,~lous Inoldents Elnd/or OEluses, In~ludlng: " fl,) On or about O%ber.NoVember1996 the PIEllntlff underwent ", oorol1Ell'Y IIrtary bypass grafting whloh resulted In II variety of lIerlous oomplloEltlons, one, or mClrl'lof Whl~h required bllEltel'ElI below.lmee Elmplltatlol1s, Elnd for whloh Pl,alntlff ,has brought suit thElt Is presently pending dlsposltloni' I'" " .' I' 'I 1" " P,) On or f:1Pp\.lI,N()VBm~lfl/' 1~,'199/3ll1e fllfllnllff wfll1lnvolY~!:Un thl') flpplclenl whlpt11111he l1uiljeol of II113prel113nl13~lt flllcl Inwl1loh he l1ustlllnecl Il frflPlurl3ct hip, f111 well~!l 0111131' flllpg!'lq Injurl13ei p,) On o~ IiIPoul AlIall~I~, I?OOOlhe Plfllnllff WI'\!l~flflln Illruok PV f! mglor y",hiple fllll1l'l wae atlempllnp to pl'Pell NQrth HflnoVel' Slr13elln Ihfll':lprpUllh pf , Oarlllll~ In hie molorlii:ecl whfl~lphfllr, an,cl for whloh Plfllnllff h~s pl'oughl sull Ihalls preef.lnt,ly penellng: cl,)" On or ElPoul AtlrJust 14, gooo 1I1e PI~lnllff euffel'ecl fl alrokfl, " I' ,11; TI1(3 PIEllnllff cllecl on or ElPoul April ,21, gpo1 pf OEUleBS unrelflll'ldto the' aoolcfenl whloh la Ihe sUilJeol mfl\ter of Il1le OBlla, ,12, WllhoUI Ihe penefil of eXPQrl report,s, Oefen,clBnlMflrslon hflll no i' , , Informfl\lon a a 10 whl'll InJurlas, Wllh Ihlil13xoepllon 001113 frl'lotureclhlp, Ih13 ~ll'llntlff " ' oonlencls were the I'eeult of the l'loolcfentll1volved In Ihls ol'lse I'l'lther than 11113 result of' solne unrell'ltecl OflUse or evenl, 13, 'Without suoh expert repol'la, Oefanclflnl Ml'll'slonlB unBille to clelermlne whl'll expert or experts neecl 10 be I'ell'llnecl In orcler 10 prepare I'l cfefenae, 14, PElfendl'ltil MEuaionlB preJUcfloecl InherBPlllty tQ pl'epare a dl'lfenBe to this oase, 10 eVl:'1lUl'lte the merlin of the ODmplalnl 01' to otl1erwlae dlBpoBe of. thlll oase, 'Without knowing the Iclenllty, quallfloatlons and oplnlonB of Plalnllffs expert wltneBBes, ' , . .', , 16,' PlalntlffB attorney haB hacf ample lime to reopond to Pefencfant Marston'a 'j, , reqUeBt for expert reportB, " 16, befendl'lnt MarBton IB furthBI' preJudloed In that ctelay damages are ,., ' aooruh1g during the period that Plalnllff fallB or refuses to prOVide expert reports, ',i' " ;" ('j II I!lIlhl'blt A " ,ii', I' " , q ", " " .. '"11 " " <;' I. d " " ," I'" o!" >, " " " ,'., n rl' " I', " " '.Ii " " " >, " /, .. "; .[1 " " " " ,I' h;;; " ;, it /, Ii' " ,I, " I, " " d' ;-,.' " " "-f, I' 'I, Ellhlbll B " " " , , I' i, " " " q' " '\ " " " ",. ii Ii " " 'I' h , ;'-" " ", " " " II j' " I" ,.!< " '1<1' ,,, ,;;' " l' '\; .lj 1"- ,,, I' .. .. " ,II. .:' " " 'I> " " ';, .", j'; .,,-,., " 'I, " , ;' j,P "" " ;," " , pI'IlWnl\l\1 fl'l1m l1f IImlllllj hl'IlI1BI\llhlllll1 YOIII' l1ul'mnl \111~lnoss, sl111I(\I, I'Il11I'Il(\llpl1l\11 " ' f(ll1111r PI' 01111'1' 1I11llvlllllS; Slllllll (1\) hpmlj(\l1l1l1l11 nf 1I1llllPIIVhlos Sll IIfflletcl\1 1111\1 , , (p) Qlls~I'I\l\l Hill mmllllll' 111 whlllh 1I11l hwlQ\l111 nffllPI\lll YO\11' I\\llllly IPlll1ll11Il11lll \lIlPI1 iill111i npllvl\>', i\NSW,m, PIIIlllIlfrs 1l\1\lr11l~ IIl'll OXIOllslvo onp\1llh 10 hllVlll11ndll hlmlllonpl\\1I11l1flllkll1l! Pl\I'O qfl1ls' .. plll'~oilIlI11011d~, IIn<I, liS s\1oh, 1111 now I'lllllllnls 24 hll\II' pOl'sonlll,llll1'Il, 'I'he ~hOllllllll' 11\11111 (torn " " 1'011l10(cl\m Hufflll'llq \1r Ihll PIIIlmlff I'llnlllll'lld hl~ ol1lyl1ellllh)' linn \IseloSH, hl~ Olhlll' lInn hllvlnB bOlln <l1I11111110d lI'ol11n' S\lbSOq\I11111 sll'oKP, !-Ill now hilS 10 BO throlllll1 11Wl'llpr, whlllh hll pOl'forms 'ollhl11lS11lf hp,OllllHlllllqk of 1\l11dH,.I\I Iho hnpll tllll\ hp olin I'llgnll1 SOlll," IISIl Ilftllo IIl'm 11\1\1 WI\S ' Injlll'lld by thll DefllndAnt, Alsn, rllllnllff Is 110111\11010 lISll his proalhallplaBs \1ellllUSo of Ills Il'nOl\\l'od palvlH III1Q , Illjlll'a<lllrm, PllIlntlfflH 11111\\110 10 ,vlllk IIShlll his prosthosoH \1aollnse (Jfll1\) sovoro pllln IIlIdlhe " . -, " " " .. Jl1n\1l11wto 11se Ills l\l'IlW to help him with \1111111100, Balol'o, 1110 IIOQldellt, Ihp PllltnllffwlIs doing vory wall wl\lklng with hi,S pl'oslhoSllS, 1)110 lo,\hallooklllnt, PllIllItlffhlls 10 Illllm IIn oval' IIgnl11 how 10 wlllk UShlll I1ls,prastllotio hlBs, kl1owhl11I\\lly wen Il1l1t ho 11111>' 1101 ba suooassf\II(1I111lo Ihllllooldant, 1-10 Is wlthallt thll I1l1l1nollll rosouroos 10 110 \hl'Ollllh Ihe I'llhllbllltlltltl11 prOlll'lIhl IIll1t .., ! , he would requll'o 10 lIt1elnpt to,wlllk 01111111. Plul1\llfrs bll\Qder h\lury Ihut \VIIS,sustutllad f\'om Ihe IIQoldel1\.ts IIlso 1111 ombllrrnsshlll, bOlhersolllo, I\.lId \I1100111!brtllblo Ilulslllloa, Dllato tlla \1ll1ddel' 001lttlSi011 Plul11ttff must SIllY alosa to the bllthro6l\\ III ol'dar to ta11dto his utlnary problallls, Undarstnndllbly, thts seval'aly limits iha 1I0tlvhlas in which the Plaintiff 01111 tllke I'urt, . .." " P-uph 1111\1 ~V\l!,>, IIPl!vll>, Ilmllhp PlnhHlff Il1k(l~purlln I~ npIV liln<lpr(l~ hy hl~ Illllll>' InJ\lrlpij, lI1\llloll, Ihlll'c I~ n ,Iptlnhlllupk pfl1l1r ~oplulllll\lt'lllll!pl1a pn IIw I'I1Ihlllfra PlIl'l ~hwp Iw lu llIllI\lllllp InkpPIH'1l of hi a ovo!,>,III\>, nIlO~U, Uc('prlllll\lIIOIlI~pnl, Ilw Plulntllfwn~ 6plf,ilIlH\ull1inll 1Il1~ proll~llInpl' lh(lIlIlIlI~Iln1, IIwl'lnlnllff 11111s1 I'pl>, (In pll1\lr~ Ip ~lvP him Hw lIijsl~liIl1PIlIlPO\lP\1 ,- " IPlIlnkq 111111'PIIllh Ihc qllY 111111 Pl'ovl\11l for his mosl bllulo IwrsPlll11 npll!ls, ,- .."., I "" p, pCH\l1'1I1P pnpl1 lnJul'r tl1l\1 rOil opnlol1d >,011 ulIstllhwdnu II 1'091111 llflll\lIIlOI~onl " , I'pfcmd 10 in Ilw Cpmplnhn, ANSWJi)R, '. ,,'i. , 'n 1l\llwml,lnJml\ls 10 Iho ~hOllldQI', nopk, h\lIl\I, 1I1'ld bluddct', I1S wplllls 1l.(h\c\III'QII I1lp, III , , , .. , '1011111, 11 loft pplvlo thwllll'O with hOI11I1\OI11I11I1Ii'IIPllIl'otl1rO\lllh Ilw 10t\,sl<lolIIl01l1I-1bllh1l11l f\'l\\lllll'Pslhl'bllllh 'tI1O ,Ion sllp\ll'llll' IIl1d 1111'01'101' pll\1lo 1'11I1111 11lslonQ\ld IIrlnol'r \1lud<lol'l nnd l:ollllOI' oliff lpnI', " 6, 'If )'01\ nro \llllhlllnllll plIYlllonllllld/ol' 1110nlol IlIsllblllly I\S II oOllsoq\lonpp of Iho .. " hwIIlQl1ll'ofort'\l<1 10 IlIlho C01l1nlul1n, stlllOI (II) tho spooltlOllUllll'C Ulld <IpllrOQ of slloh <Ilsol>lIll>,1 '. (b) whcthol' Ilia tOlnt Or pnl'lllIlI Rnd (Q) wl1othor Ills pcrmllllonl 01' tell1pol'l\l'y, ANSWER, a, Constllnl pain fn tho neok ,shOIlIOol', 1Ir111S, 11l1d '\lp, liS woU liS dlffio\lltloa with thu bladdor, b, Totnl dlaol>lllly 00l1lpllrod 10, p1'0'1I001do111 plws10lll HMo of Plnlllllff, 0, It IH 0111' hopo thM \10110 llf Iho PllIll1l1ff' a h~UrlQH (\1'0 pOrl1lllnCnl, but t'ollllstlonlly, fllOIOl'lll1l ' In Ihol'lnllltlff's allO, thaoXlol1t oftholt~Ur1os, and Ihellkolihood ofl'ooOVo1')' from suoh Injul'los, II fs ll\osl IIkoly thnt thl) 11lnhlllff'a h~utfos nt'o port1\tulotlt, \), hl~n\lf>, \l1\php~r~fll1li'l1111 Whl1111 rill I, ~nlll' 1\l\l1l'11\l~ or IIn~ono\lo\111~ lln rulll' holllllfhl\&l1hllllll\l111l Hllllonwnl O\lnllornlnllll1\~ mlll\or rlllll\lnllln'\hl& 1I0110n 1111\\ provl\lp th~ lIlliI' \lll \Vl1loh \111>' Hlloh HI\llplI1\l1l1 WII~ 0111111no\l, " ,.. i\.l'lliW'ml Tl'I1\1801'1pl~ Wol'o IIIKlln 11111 >>\l11111111I'r hOl1rlllllOIl April 1 5, I \)\)9, III Ibmt oft)) PI\\IIII " Cprl'PlIllIlHI \\\lIn IIPpOll1IWIl.l'I111lIII 11'011\ ~i'JIIIIIlO Ilof'fill' Oil AIIBIIHII 0,.1090, 'AllIU, \lopn~l\l(ln~ /' of 'toll~rl HO"I\l\\ol' IIml 1-10\111101' MIII'810n \VPl'o I\lkon 011 Apl'1I24, 2000,111 Ivhtoh tlmp \l'lIn8ol'lpl" ", " ., , " !' " \Vol'o IlIk~n; , .. " 10, Stlllll 1110 1\ll1n\lmo \111\111181 Knl1WI1I1<1<lross of ol'OI'Y PQr~on l\I1owII 10 >,011, >'\111rl1\I01'll0Y or \In)'ol1lllwIllIll'on >,o\lr hol1lllf \Vho ,\VIIS 1\ wl\l,lOss totl1o'h'~'\lonl 0\' whl) Pll1l111s 10 h\lvP II1W Imowlp<IBO rdllllr<lInll tho Ihots IIn\lolrOIlI1;SIII1100" SllITl1\1ndhlll tho I 11Ioldon\ sot forth In Iho Complnlnt IImt lIs oOOlll'rOnOO, " ANsw,ml ' \1lollSel'ofol' 10 I\n&\Vol' 9, Tho IdontllY llfnn>, Ilnd 1111 wl\l1oSS\ls to Iho l1\lolQonl klll1\V1\ to L , Ihohllllllffllro dl\'\\lllo\l Il1lho Irnnsorlpls roforl'od 10 In Answor 9, Pllllnllffl'os~rvos Iho rllll1t '(0 sUpplOl1lOnll\1ts IIns\Vor If Ilddlllolmllnfol'11'lltlon hpoo11'os known, 11, 8111to Ihe lHllno IItl<lllddross of cnol1 pOl'soll wl1o111 ronhl\Ond (0 01111 us II non.ollpert wi (nOsH II( Ihe l\'lnllll' Ihls OIlSO, ANSWERI Robel't Boslc\tol' I Wos( POlin sill ApI, 202 Cllrllsle.PA 1701~ ' Other IlOIl-ollller( WI(lIesses mny b\l onllo<l ntld Plnll\tlfT resorves (ho rlgh( \0 01l11lhoso . " wltnossea when (holl' ldlll\llI>, beotlmoa known, '\. ... ,," I'" , " Iii " " " , ')'-'L I'.. ,;' , , Sllhlblt 0, ',ll Ii Ii I., " " " " " I' ",; I', ;/,' " i' " " " ';, ;;" 'I; " " !.~ (/) ~l:-" (I" ,.... I~; j'!; ~ll (,) It.. (", ,J.:r I" , " r. I ~. ,', i.;" >.r4 : \ :~r~ ;~;;! '..' , " ~ , !li:-! ' J'i .. .~ I'ii) , (,! I,,:, , , I!l;';.:" t:r ""1';,1 ~'t:. \1'11. , "1 , (,',1 tj " " " .. " " " '.\ ".' ! 'f t.' " " "" 1'... ',,: 'I .. .. ( i,I "." " ";( " I'; " II " " /, " , " "\11 " Ii , .., " ii "" " "" , " 111 q 'I,'. " ,,' " I,' ;,1 " " '11 " " " " " , ..~ i. , I '" I" .' ,~ ~. \ ,I ~i ( '...1.... ::) ;~" '1;'1 ';'1,',) l,. ",r '-'1',", \.1' J.. "to C,) Cl ,J: (II ,of:: /l~") .. , , :1 Ii' .,'j " " '.. {"..1 L.~ '. ,I '"1' " b ' ~' , ~ ~' ~l J ~ ~ ~ Ii m ~ rr ~~ x d ~ ~ " 5 m x " /, I, I;, '1; j, ,.. " ," " " " !' " 'I'''' .' " " ,p ", 'I ?.Otl1 ,,' 'f t 'f " , () (I.; I ,:;" i ~ j ,~ 1:-.: ,,,;' I , " .!.!. :-:1'1' , , ~ '.'!. ;~' r: , I , '" 1:,J , ';;":i. , , ,,:'~t :(i; , , Ii ...... 1 .: , , ",."... " i >l i~ 1 ~'1i ."-J ',!lli. I '. r' ) ''1 L) (;:1 U I'., 'i'/ " " " I' " j, :1 '., ;, ;1'. " I I I. .." '.'.' "