Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01120 \~~~':'!~V~;-' 10 fjr!f~~:~,' t.--.I!-' ~i~;-i /;,,' 'Ii!\', ;H~r[j_l;'~;-\L!f ,,~;J;(i-'iP/j~:, 'rl'!~ '" "II,. .I~;;r:k;;: ;~:~\fL, '.lit\'I!-,.".,.,.I" II' .11111(.','11' ft~~t, , " 111"""'-"" ~ Ce", _ -' - , ' ~- !Ii"-:-- ,'j".'" J.l " , I ':,1 ~; .'" (, .);,';,:./,!,'~,t:, _,. .__ 1:';; ~;I;i;:: : ::::rr,"I! h,.'_n'___! ,;,';':';:\:;'" l " "~I ~}i:I':\I\';~"/--1 i. Ifl__-. ,--, ,-, -k_{;,:-~-~:i':;(-' 1 -, Il __ -i~', ' '1\ :l;~ld: ":~-~' j,~ I_~;J/f;:- I' ilt"', 'j. ',.",' :i-,;-,r.1}i },i- I,';', ',.~-" , , , , ~ ~ \ ~" ~' " '-l' '4).. '(:',.~," ~ " ' " I' ',j 7 " " ,~ J '_I '" ~. r .~ J '01 ,n - -- ,.j" " :,::;:\}:I,;.~:,;I\~!f{Nf!~1 ; _ ""1"'" 1,'" 1'._ ,~;-_ I! _~_,f,I~-;I.- -'I ,I )1'..'.-.' _"'___'__;:'cr"'lFT':--yl-: :.1 - I-\'h--(th~-\'-,il'},\ti:\tl\\-" "" ,,' '('~:::::;;:;::~~I " "'1,<;~1\,,, ;;<_'\"~~! i ,'- ,J~'/1/1r ", I:: ,,' " ';, I' ,,1,'1 " , " , " ".:1' '" " " , . ;, ii ,", " 'i'l, " ',' ~ I " I /(" " " q,'!- ,J-_ " ., " "1\ "-'1,";.'/:_' \; J' \, ,. ," , ~ I' , . " '", 1,1', 'j-, ,. I" " II :\ " 'I, " " ., :' , I' .",' .1' " ." ',.. " ,I' 1-1, I' H' . , ., " I' ,,' 'I' ,,_ I ~r;L ,; :'. " , :;" I ~ , " " ,. .,' , ., , I'" ,'; " , " ,I, I ;;; I' "I' !I " , ;, ," ,. ".'<J d ",' [, q. " " "': '''.. ., " ". \'1 " , , JI'. I' " I~,: "'\ ,- _1" ' " ,. '1 'I' ,I ',I" .' " ,!' " " " " .." .r,-,' " ,,' " ,II,'! 'Ii " " q' "f 'i' ", "I, " II " " J' !' " "/' 1\ p',' '1 I' -! " Ii .. 1-', "1" " 'II' II .1/ " '1; " . ,1' " , " j("-'(' i, ij'I' ',I ,,;. " , " ,t ')' H , .. "', I' " " " ,. " 'Ii ',,' " " ", ,,', I!' I,' I'," " ,.' ". "1,,' ,'I, ,. " " I, " " " . " " 'i. " i ~, " " " , ,. " ". " " . ,. if i: " 'I\,!I 'I, ,I " , ,,' .," HI.. " I. ,~ i ,I (: " " '" i.,' I " " ,. " " " " " ;.11}l: ';;-')(9 J/_o I' -;;lgi:~' i'jJ/:'/!1~ _, .~-jJAt ;.ml Hi {;,.ltU, '!ll'j~ ~; .'; fii ~ , !'~Lt;'\}f~ , ;'__h.,--1}7tti : ':::;}1f~ ',. 'l~l'ln~ -; f':;i~l~j ," ;, " " ,,' "~I ." <1,1 I'"~ In' ll, I, II' ',r, ,. " "" ,_I' " ;,1; 'h (4) M", RobllPOll I., lllpklu~ <lllll'lll 1111 f\1l1' 1'0flll'I'011 \11 ns, Ms, HlokIIlY")1 . , . . , J)ol\:lmhm\ Hlpklo~ \VII", nl nil \ln1\)" 1'011lVlIn\ \\1 \hlll Plll1wlIl1n\, \lw Ph'Il\l\llI' , , " Qf \lw, U\II'OI\\I Ill' PI'IVOI' Llpllnslnj!, II 1l\II'Ollll \11' \Iw CIl111111l1nwIllllth or POl1nsylvlInl1l nllpnl'lnWnl of TI'II\1IlPIlI'II\\II1I1, , (~) " " Mil, Rlok\lly'll hushwlls ndlh'ollll Ill, COl11l1llln\Vllnlth Ill' Pllnllllylvllnlll POplll'ln1\ll1\ of TI'I\1WIWI'\lltl\1n 1l\l1'Ill\\I or 1)l'lvlll' Lloonslng, Hllrl'lsP\IrB, " 'PIl11l11lylvllnln 17104-45 I 6, (6) Mil, Hlokloy Is poh1l!,~\lod 111 hol' indlvl,tunl onpllolt~, I' STATNMICNT <W CLAIM " (7)" On ol'.nbo\ll 80p\ombol', 199R Ml< l~ooso wonl \0 Iho C'lml11onwollllh of Pllnnsylvnnln POplll'II110111 of Tl'I1nspol'llIllol1' BUl'onu of Pl'lvol' IAoonalnB (hol'olnlll\ol' 1'0fol'I'od 10 liS Iho Illhll'Oll\l") building In HIII'I'IsbmB, pennsylvnnlll, fOl' Iho pUl'pOSO of obllllnlng his dl'lvol"H lIoonsoo,.. '. ',. " (R) In lho dl'lvQI"1l 1l00l1so 1'11ll0Wllllol'l11 Ihlll Plnlnllff Pllul M, Rooso WIIA I'o~llll'od 10 nil OUI, Ihol'o \VIIS II blllnk 1'0'luosllnB Ihlll II Soollll' Seoul'lly 1100011111 numbol' bo Onllll'od, .. , I' (9) In lhlllnfol'Cmol11lonod blllnk, MI', Rooso, ol1.lol'od"l\ono", (10) Ml', ROOIlIl ol1lol'od lillOno" 11110 tho nfOI'01\101111l1110d box, boonllso ho did nol hllvo n vlllld Soolnl Sooul'lly nccnunl 111llllhol', " I I I" i. i i.' II 1\1 \ ,\ " '-!' II , I:" "f 2 (II) 'Wh~ll Pin/nil/'/' PIIIII M, RIlQIlQ 1'!lI\ll'fW{lllipllfol'!llHllnllonp~lnppliQl\lIon vl\1 molll nn In~livl~lllnl nfllw ~1\lpnrlnWIH rpllll'nPllllnl~1 npplhmthm viII I11nll to MI', 1~0{l1lt,l1 with nlPIIPI'llol11l1ndlnB Ihnlll Soplnl SOPIII'lty npPollnt mllll~ol' Iwg/vonl nl' {lIIlPlho lippI/Pillion Ihl' lillOllsO I'onpwn/ Would ~P ~Ipnleq, (I~)' Itllho ntpl'pl11\lIlllonud 101l0li, Iho \VI'ilOI'lllnlolllhnl n sllllolllwpl'uvOnl{ld thu "" UIlI'UIllI ll'nIH I'Pll~wlnB n ch'lvOI"1l lioonsou wilhoutf1I'M bolllB l'uglllt~l'Qd "t' I' ~lUi t1lP Soollll SUPUI'ily Adll'lllllsll'nllllll, Cthol'obY'obtnlnlna IInllOOollnt " '. ' , nUI11~PI' n~slgllud by Ow SO,~IIlISoPIII'ily Adl11ltilllll'lItloll, snld nlllllbpt',~\lln/;! th(l ono Ihllt thoy (dplbndnllO clol11nn,lod), (I~) PI'ICll' 10 tho lnoldollpoa d~aol'lbud III tfw prpvlous Pl1l'ngl'lIphs, till> Plnllltlfr " , WI'olp 'II 101101' to tho 13\11'Ollll In 01"101' HUll anitl Ill/lllol' QI' thii (jonlnl 01' ' renown I 01' snld dl'/VOI"/llloOIlSo, 1111g/;t bo ronlQdlod oonslston(wilh tho lnw, , short of' 'lIt/gritlon, SOO Plnltlllt'l~'a I~xhlblt II MI" Rooso,ls 101l01' tO,Ms, Blokloy, " '" (14) .' Tho Dlt'ootol' of' tho BllI:onll,' Ma, I~oboocn L, Blokloy, I;ospondod by snld lottoI' 0'; thoPlnlntlfr dntod Ootobol' 9, 1998, Soo Phllntln~s Exhibit 21 , " Lollol' 11'0111 Ms, Robooen ,." Bleklo)', (15) . 'l'hol'o oxlatano stnto Imv thiil11111l1dntoa thlll n cltl~on I11l1st hnvo IIllduso n' Soolnl . Sooll/'Ity nlJcollllt Illllll'bol;, olhol' thnll wholl tho)' nl'o ni)j)I~htg fbi' olltltlOl11onts 01' bOllonls li'ol11 (lIP atnlo, .. I;" I ";., 1< 3 "'.. " ..' '\' HI! Ii " '1. .,,' " I; (16.) , . . '. I Thlll'll oxl~l!i nil fodllrnllrlw Ihlll 1'\l~1\,11'1l!i II CIII?~n III hovo nmluap !\ ~\loll\l .. ~.PIl\II'II~ IIIlPIl\lI1t \l\lI11IWI', lllhlll' Ihlln wlwn Ilw~ nl'P' IIpplyln/! l'pl'. pnllllonwnlll Ill' bIJlwOla O'om 111\.1 ~IlVOl'l1n1\.lnl, ( 17) 1I111lllogllllp lill'oP II pOl'aon In gpln ~~'lOhll ~poul'lly nooll\lIll I1Ill11bPI', (Ill) Wlwn Ilia IlIognllnfol'llo n pOl'aon In (111 sonlPlhlng .dll'oolly, Ilia oqlllllly . 1I1pgllllQ fol'llo Ihom 10 do anld sonwlhlng ItHlh'polly, (19) In Ma, 1~loklor'!i nfol'OnlOnllono(llollOI' (Exhibit ~), Rho !illllod, Hln 11011 of II 11001111 Roomlty mimbol', PonnRylvnnl1l IIIW IIl10wa IIppllollnlato slIbmll n gonol'llllllx IdonllOollllon I1l1l11bol', First, Iho IIppllollnl mil III obloln, 0:0111 Iho Fl'dol'lll OOVOl'l1l11ont, II wnlvPI; permitting Ihol11 10 nol hnvo)\ s~olnl ROOIII'II)' numbol', The nppllonnl 1l111Y Ihon 1100\11'0, Ii'om Iho Fodoml 00V01'l1nlont, II IIIX .,' Idontlflollllon Illllnbpl' Ihnt mllY bouRod fbi' lIoonslng PUl'posos.'\ (20) BoonuRo Ihol'o nl'O no lllws Whlllovol" ~vhloh I'o'luil'o Cltlzolls of tho StllloslQ . oblllln II Soolnl Seolu'lly lIooollnl 1111 III bo 1', II wnlvol' IR nol nooeS/llll'y to bll '. " oxompt l)'OIll II IIIW whlch'cloes not oxlst, ,. "" (21) Beollllllo thoro do nol oxlsl, "willvol'sll In n Conslltuitonlll Ropubllo oxempllng Incllvlclunls "'om lllws whloh clo not oxlst, Iho, Soolnl Sooul'lt)' AdmlnlRtt'llllon's Rules, Roglllntlona IInd Stntlltoa, hllve no provisions 1'01' Iho laslInnco ofsnld "wl\lvol's," ns Ms; Blokloy clomnndod In ho\, leltol'l (22) Il'la Ihol'olbl'O Imp~aRlblo Ibl' MI', ROORO looblnln nny RlIoh "wnlyal"" " . 1] ., i ,'I fi, '1' Il] J; Ii ~ t:, 'J J 11 IJi, " '! I , (2~) Ilr Inv\3ntln~. Ilnl~l wlllvPl' r\Jgulrol1wlH lhllt III unlnwf\ll IJml , 'JII1Q(1111l1IlllllonlJl, wllhwlllI\II cllsrpmml flw lhp I'lghlll of 1119 PllJlntlff. M~, ;f, " . ; alpkl\3Y hlJs vlollJt\3Q lh\3lmv In hOl'lmllvlcllllJl\.lIJPIJ\.lllr, (24) It III llI\JglJl 11.11' lhp feclpml PI' PpnnllrlvlJnlll goVel'lll11pnta, ot, Illl ft~pntlll to "" (25) (26) . fOl'pe Anipl'lplln Clllzpnll io clp lhp II11POlllllblpl 01'10 ppnlJlil~o lIWI11 fOI' /lor doing lIw hnpollslble,,, " I . ,,' In the Unllod Sllltes, It Is only Citizens who IJI'Q nOll'ognh'e(l br IlJw to hllve ' I., ' 1- I 11 Soplnl SeoUl'llr nopounl munbol' - unll~o IJllenR, WhOIlI'~reqllh'pq to IlllvQ ,lIllslgnecllo.lhom, Soollll Seolll'llr Admlnl/ltl'lIllon numbers, " "("" (27) i'h~ !,01l111l 0"'11\.11 hnvlng n Ponns~lynnln' ch'lvel"s "oonRo Is IhllUh~ MI', . ' . , . , . j. " Roose ahnll.I11co Ilubstnnlllll pcnnlllell which Include tho I'lllk going 10 JIIIl, It' ' " .. ,-' , (28) . /'.lloppodon lhc mnd' whilo 'h'lvhlg, whol'ons IIc~nllod dl'iVol'/l d~,not f!\oQthl$, . I'l/lkl flit'thol'! tho plnlnt/frlll dlmled thoh'l'lghl 01' pl'lvllegp or oblnlnlng positive ., I'"'' ,f" Idontlnantlon Illlltpd 1'01' Identifying thomsolvl,ls, whon ollshhlg ohooks'lInd:' , " ,; ." h I.. " tho IIko, WhOl'OIlIl thoso Clllzons who do posRossllool1sos, 111'0 1101 bUl'Chmed With this p/'Oblom" " I' II (2?) Mony l'lghts lllldpl'lvllogos nl'o donlod to tho I'lnlntltT, whon hollldllnlcd hl~ " .'. >i "i' onfltlolllOlll'of' blJlng IssllQd ddvol"slIoonsosl l; " , '-1': " " (~O) 1\",11l1ll ~olp "Pl\~on thl\tllw plnlntllT lfi!:hml\ld l\ !:h'IV\lI"~ IIppil~P, I~ bpol\\l~p .. lw dop~ not hl\\'o ~olllnl ~llllln'IW nPllo\IIa IHlmppl', " OAURH~OF ACTION: " " .. (~I) fly. !:hmyllll! MI', RIlOHIl flnl!:1 (I"'\'ol"a IIPllnao lIaatnlpd In Pl\l'llgl'nph~ 7 lhl'ollgh ~O, tho (Iotcmlnllts hllvo Ihll1loll MI', Roo~p 1l'l11l\1 protoollon\md~r tho Il\\va of tho Cnll1mlll1lVlllllth Ilf' POllns)'lvn,,'", oonll'nl')' to AI't1ole ~f' tho, Constltutlnn of' POIIIIH)'lvnnlll,lInd tho 141h Am6ndnlpnt 0.1' 11lllUnlto(1. Stntos . , " , Constitution, . (n). B)' elolI)'lIm MI', Ro~so fnll' nnd 011U1II tl'onlil1ont un<lol'lho Inw,' tho. dptilndnnts hllvo l\Plod oonll'lll')' to lho Ponns)'lvllllln Constltutlan, 1\1\<1 lho ,-- " ,- lJ " 14'h Amondmont al'tho,Unltod Stl\tos Canstltutlon, II " (33), 13)' lll'bltl'llI'lI~ ,don)'lng Mr, Rooso snlel.. <lI'IVOI"s 1I00nso ns stntod In , , .. , pnl'ngl'nphs 7 thrnugh 3D, solol)' boonuso MI', Rooso Is of tho oll\ss of I' .' oltlzens who do not hnvo Soolnl Sooul'lty nooaunt numbors, tho dofbndnnts hnvo I\I'blll'nl'll)' dlsol'll1llnnlod IIgnlnst lhls Holnss,'~ - United Stntos Cltlzons - In vlolntlol1 of tho POl\llsylvnnllll'lght to I)'oodam I)'alll dlsol'lmlnntlan 'I, , 'f .. stntlllos,43 P,S, ~ 952 ot so<), - ns woll os tho Unltod Stntos Civil Rights " Aot af' 1964, .,";; " I'. 1} <~ " " '\;; !; I' o """10.. ;'!~ " .' '.";' ,::.~ ~Y1'jif :jl I .. peAr MehAPA Vln~l~Y, In ^non~~ of IUOO,I Aprlio~ ~o renew my PAnn~ylvAnlA , ' Prlvev~l~ ll~oonco, My ArplicA~lon YAP rp~npnod dUo ~p'~ho l\p!lenco or 1I0igll~, oyo 00101", 111Hl ae~,'l'hll ~\H"OAU <ll~Pl'e- Q\lo!ltel1 A Spoill t Soo\ld \;y' N\lmpel". Nh 0 1,1. I ooprep~lld thp ronn I 5\;11\;1311 in tho le~~llr ~hnt I do no~ hAve A SOOiAl seo\lrl,~y n~mper. I hAVo no~ yot rlloeivedmy oAmerQCArd, I Qm'~ri~oing, ~o p~p if yon hAve receivod my oOrreotod form/or if i~ ~AY hAve pOlln los~ ifi \;ho mA(l, Inolosed ia A lo~tor I ~on~ nlong with ~ho cbrootod form thA~ I rot\lrnod, thnnk Ybu for YO\lr A!l!liatQnce, " Sinborely " " fa~rI11. ~/ 'I, < ,. PaUl raepe 411 Oroaaroad Sohool pd. Cnrlisle Ponnpl'lvnnia " 170.13 Phone jf (717) 776-7660 " " ".' , " " I I \1 1\: "-{ \~ fr 'I" . - '.' . " " " , IN '!'UIU CQUR'f PF COMMON Pf,IUMI OF CUMtllUlll,i\NP CPUN'f'V,I'fONNRYf.V Mill\. l'i\UI, M, 1l1U1U11IO, " !; ,. I I I I I' CPMMONWIOI\.I"TU pfr l'IilNNSVIN ANI!\~ nnll Rlilm~ccA I" mCf~LIilV I .. I npfpIH'",II~' I , NO, 9HUll Olvll 'I'prlll " I1hl1nllff v, <,' ' p' ., CERTIJrICA}'El of' I?~I~VI<;)IQ . I; I,MIQHA~i;A, FARNAN, PllplIl>'AUornoy OQl1ornl, hllroh)' oorlif}' IIInt I hnvlllhlp ,hlY ,., I' fllll'Vlll\ thp /llro~olnll WrlUpl1 No(jIlP omolHovnl \0 F<<idllrlll COllrt, h)' dOJlo~llinll II oOJl)' oflt 111 " iho UnltlllllllntllP 1111111, I1rst~lnss, 110SlllllPl1rllpnld In HmTlllhul'll, Ponns)'lvlIl1lll, mldroSSIlI\ to thll . folh1Whllll , , ", Pnlll M, ROOBO 411 ,CrosPI'(lnds Sohoo I ROlIll , Cllrllslo, Plll1nB),IVIlI1II1~17"13u .. . ,. ~IIAEL i~^~1 o lInt)' Attonloy Gllnoml I Lh Ilntlol1 Scotloh . DA'mt Minch 23, 1999 " '" ..-; 'I, "0'" i.i' " I'. " " ,. I' " ", " "