Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01149 '. " ;\' " , " . "" '1 Ii, " " it " " I, " 1'" I I; " !, " ;j' i, " i' ,; I. " .' , " .I' .' " , , " ," ,\, I' " " " , " " .' I'. , ;!, " " ~), 1,1 " ,',I ''j. 1"1' '\0, " "" " " it I ' I,. ".' " " " 'i I' , ' , '11 H " I' " ;; , " I'" "I , 'I" 'I " H '!! II,.. f' " " "',, , , ", , , J: " , ' Irl " i , q ;" " It " , , ' fl. " " "01 " " I. , ' "I I' " ,,' " I, " ,I, q; " HOOP, ~IGHT /lc G~IS~, INo, ", , PI~lntlff v MIORot:NT~RPRI:'lj:!I3, INO, Pefelld~nt ' IINl'H~ OOURT OF oOMMoN P~j:AS of ' :OWMf.lt:f~~ANPOOUNTY, P~NNsY~VANIA , , :pp, 114a olVI~ T~RM , , :OIVI~' AOTloN . ~AW I " TO: Sllml.llll ~, Amflla, ~aql.llre fig/i N, 19lh ~treet . ~emoyne, PA 17o~;3 Allorney for PllllnUff l3anjlll11ln T, W~rnel', ~~q~llre 'ren j:!, Hlgl1 fltrellt O/:!rl/ale, PA 1701:3 AIlQrneyfor D13feml/:!nt ' ,! .. NOTloe OF A~al'rRATIONHeARINIi you AR~ HI:Rj:!I3Y NOTIFI~P fhllllllll ~H1derlllgnlld /:!r/Jltratorll, Io1ppolnted /Jy the QOUrt III the ~boVe p/:!p,Uoned In/:!, tier, will me,et for the pUrposes of the,lr,IlPPolntmellt on Tl.lesd~y,,, PeOlllnpel' 14, 1999, beginning /;111100 p.m, In tllsFlfth Floor lielo1rlng Room of tllll Oumb\lrh:md Oounty Oourthouse, Ollrllale, PennsylVenlfl, fit whloh time end plaoe you mflY appeflr to bs 'he~rd, together Will, your,wltnesses ancf oOlmsel, If you dsslre, ""------1 " ' 'Jc "..' ~" / "el ") " ..... (",/., , . -, IWI,.'( til, '( '~)4 (. c ' ,-(--".n. ' LlndB~flrs atl;d'; Eaqtllre, Oflalrm~n P~t~r 1. Rusao, ~Bq(lfre . . - Debra Denison Otmtor, ~sqlllre Datel NOVember 16, 1999 co; Oourt Admlnlalrator Arbltrlo1t1on Panel " " ;' ' " 'i II }, , HI .. (: ~t'~ I , --II I:' .. I';, 'rLI \::/. , I '. . I" j. '~ 'ii : !~ bi.;:!, II. I : I ',"'1 1,,1 I , . :1,. (,"i '11;1/ ".' I,,, . .' .1/1" I. ;1:: ., t':i (11 .J .,-, r.,) ) " j I., +- . (.f'J /,1 I (<~J'~) ~ G -1 , , ") ~ .~.,. ~, h--;:. ,'- -j, !Q',' "J (2~ \ /() Lq . ~/) ;:c ~ , "'~ 0) (~ ~I '-~ cJ ,. , , .f~~" , ' ,'~ ,.:!;, ('.. :::11 0L '. t I; ,., " ,. " " g ~'j ~ .~ ~ : III ~,~ ~ ~ ~ "~ ~ ~ ~ a 11, ~ ,. "j, ." ....., ' t " " " ,,' /. " , , "j " OlllUllil.CtiTI1Q1LSllR Vlcr! " '." '. , I, ,IIIPllllplhwl\, PPlJkUl'llIlllllllh\lrl~~IIIIIJ(J1l1 nl'Milrl"nll ppnl'llllrfl' WII II IIIlW {IG Olin, hpruhy lJllrll '~Ihll\ II popy nl' IIw 'i1rPllnln~ PrnulJlplJ WII" "prvPII Ihl" Ih\\lJ hYllpPQ"11I1l1l "nn1O In IIw "11M omuu ill cmllHluiilA, OrHI UhIHH'nHIIl, pnHlnllP prlJpnhl, ndlh'IlH"plIlIH 1i)1,lmwl " " , ~lIll1\IPII" AmlPH, nHlllllrlJ 1..1\ W OFFICnS OF SAMWll, I." ANI)ll/), ~2~ Norlh TWlJIlIh StrOll! 1,llllloYIlO, "A 1704~ .' , ' It; !' ,. MARTSON I)UARPOIWF WII,I.,IAMS &. OTTO , . . -. ,; Ii: lly_(J A<<!.l.Jb.JaQ~ IM~IIlO A, l)puko\' . I(IlI1 flnHt H l!lh Slrout , "CnrIlHlu, PA 170 1 ~ (717) ~4~'~~41 . Ii I'" IJlllodlAprll 28, IO!)9 ",' " 0, " .\1 " " ",. II " " I'" " I,.. ", I, I' " " ", ,,". , j, " t?, ,,\",.\.. ',- \... .~ ,,, {t.. t:i' -, ~!.i' ('~Il~l ,~Q /'. r."('I ~r:~ CI(l.:, Il;'L p~ (';)~'J It"' rO ':"1;\ . r "'""' \~\J' t'-l . ~. I'- J ~\\! pO: \\\\h p , v'; ,,1. !.}_~ 'J,. " " lIt' \." :1.-) U (l'\ \'..1 " .1 " jI ! J' i' ,;\' ,J' " " " H .. ;,' " " Ii " If: " L " i' " " , " ;,'1 , " " " ,." " ,. ;) '" " " q " ' I'. .. " ,"',! ',. \, d' " 'I. " "I, ,(' ',I' " " .. ., " " ,. Ii " Ii ,," ,; " It"~ " " " Ii " ;j 'I' ,:- ..> " \I!; " " " ';), ;l' ,. " " 'I " ,," " ,. '" Il " " ,. " " ,. .. ,( I,'; i,:i' " .. I. " , ., ,'1< " NICW 1\1(\.'I"I'lul\ 0, Tlw 1I1l11!llltlpIl8In PIII'llI.l\'\lphH\ thl'PIIl.lh a,lI':p Inoorpol'lMl1 huruln \lY rol'llr\1IlCll\lH If Hu\l'llrlh In \lilliI' \l\1l1rlJ\)', . 10," IIl'vplou II~OHfi, 11\11\111 A\II.IIIHI 27, 1098, 11111\11111'11 III Pllllnlll'rs Compllll\1\ 1111111'1' Tlxhlhll "A," Ilnp8lltl\ \1lJIlP\I11\ 1'01' Illlnllhl\1! 1111111ily (1l'wnr~ 1I1lt! llovlnllla 1)'0111 oHthl1I1IOSII\1\llJllotu~ prnvltlllll.tP J:MIl\lll\1\1\I' , . .. II) PIIIIIl\ll'l'prllvlllull PoI'PIHIII\1! wllh 1111 oalhl1ntu 111111 qll0!U pf$~fiO,OO, for tho goal llfprm\llolnl.\ volpxP8 111111 II 1/4-p1I1.\0 \\111 PllIlIIIIl'f lJhnrl.\Pl1 Dpful1l1111lt $~74,Oli h) \1ll1lnlll'l' provltlotl Dol'ontlllnl wlm 1111 oHllnwlp IIml ljl\otu pI' P4~,7~, (01' ;- " .. , ," -, aorvlooal\1 orolllhl!lll 13I1Hlnp8H ,1n\l1'llnlnrllplllll'lnhlllffohnrllull pol'llllllll\11 $S(i~,721 u) Tho IIrlwpr~ pprfnl'l1wII nntl prnyldlJtl fIll' 11\0 Trodu Show I\ollth WIIH hwol11plo!o, (joI10101l1;\111Hlltlal'nO!or)' n\1llno\1Inwly, \18 II wn8sIIppllotlnOor II llulIdllno, II) Defo\1lhmt WIla nlJVOr IIIlvlaullll wllnld bel'IlHpOIlHlblll for fillJHI111l1oH, pPHIII!lU , - , . , , . IIml olhol' 11118lJellllnOOl\H oxpolla08, whloh PlnlnllffH ilol11lzo lit $3B;56, ' II, Tho tollll HII111 owlnl.\ nll' tho HorvlooHllalod on tho ^"gUH! 27, 1!l!lB IlIvplpo IH $t,1!l\,7~, . " '. 12, l\1voloo II~Olfi,!\I\IOll Soplll111bor24, 1!l!l6In!tllohod 10 I'lnlnllfrH Complllll1tun\lor UxhtbU "At duvhl108 1)'0111 Iho OH!ll11l1tod qllolo of $I,!l26,nl Dol'oll!\nlll wnH Ilot IIdvlsetlll WO\llll bo rOHpollHlhlo for Iho OOHls 01'00101' h\H01' prl\1tHI . 13,,, lnvoloo 11:.'1042, dnted Ootohor 6, 199B,ntlllohpd to PIIIIIlII l'rll COl11plnlnlUlldor lixhlhlt !1 ' ,,, \. ,. "A," dovlntoa (1'0111 tho nO!lInl oOHtH Incurrod of $2, 152,00, whloh IH tho filiI' 1I111lrOlisonnblo nl110lllll duo for thoHo HUI'vloOH, ,,' 14, 11lvoloo 113043, dnted Ootlil;~r 8,1 O!lB,nthlpllPd to Plnlntl fra COl\1plnlnlulIdol' Exhlhlt "A,"IH 1'01' IIIOOl\1plolo, doOolont nl1d UI1HnllHfnetol'y work I Jllnll1tlffprovldodlll'oaol1lntlo\1I'?ldol'iI thnt woru U\1l\ceoplnhlull1 q'unllt)'1 PnYl110nt fur thlH work wils contln!lolll UpOI1 Dol'ol1dnnt'H IIpprovlllnl1d ncooptnneo of tho work, Dofondnntdld nolnpprovll ol'lIocopt thlH work,nnd hllH nol u80d thoWol'k pl'ollllol hll1l1Y 1111\\1nill', Thus, Dof'ondnl1t did 110! rebolvo InlY VnlllO, " " "~,I \. , .. ,. !', .. I I' " I~, Thp IllllIll\11111\l\1t i\Pllllllly (11\\1111111 nwlll!ltn PIIIIIl\lffn~ IIrllHlllt llfWol'k ~n\lqn'P\nrlly , Iwrfpl'l11p\IIH $~,;no,I~, Tho lIutnI11P\\11t QWPII \p PIIIIII\lfl',l,o" $~,270,12 IUHH $u~a,so, 1l1l1l'1l pnl'llPlllnl'ly IIIIHPrlh\l1l11l Ihp Cllll\1lurplnlllllwl'o\p, IQ $4,~ II,Ci2, Pul'olHllln\ tumlol'o(llhlH IlnHl\1II1 tn 111nl1111 ff pn pl',n\lnlll NpvPl11hur 12, I 9ua, whlllll pnYl1wnl WM I'Pf\lH\l\I, " " d' "', ' .Qill}~'I'ICRCLAlM ty1101'\)BIII0I'prlli.\lflt ]I\U, V, 1-]oQd,LIUIIl & Oolso, 1110. Tho IIlIpgnlloils 111 pnrngrnphH ltll1'QIIBh 11\ nl'O hwol'pprnlc\1 h~l'uln ns Il'aptl'n1'lh Ill. " '17, tholl' onlll'\lIYi 18, On or nbpnl 80plol11\1ol' 22,1 99a, DofolHlllnl purl'ornlO\1 cpmpnlol' IluaIBn~ql'VI\lOH nil' th\l bunoOI nllll IInllol' lIw dlrcollpn nfPlnlnqfl'ln lhu 1II11Plml of$212,S0, whlph 10 Iho rOuHllnllhlo nllll ',PllHIQI11I11'~ ohnl'BP for tho w~l'k pUl:fnnnodl.I.11l ol11ployoll Ofr'lIlnllfrH nlllllull "K.oll)''' I'Ptl'lbl'u\1 Iho 'f1n,\Hhod pl'mlllPlll'om pofondunt's pllloo Qfh\1alnPHH, A',uoPY pflnvolop No, 1 ~90Ci, \llIlod Oolohol' '1, 1998, \vhloll WIIH dullvol'\ld 10 rlulntlff, Is u\luohlld hOl'olo liS Bxhlhh "A," , ' 19,9n Orllllll\11 Oo\pbol' 19, 199a, l)ofondll111 rCBIHloroll lho dOl11l1ln Imino "HorHlwyloooroIl11l,Ollm" IIpon tlw roq\10Ht of Suoll I3rlokol, n'Vloo IIr\1Hlllolll of Plllllll1fl', '1'111,1 rOIlHotlllblo ulld Pllstpmm')' ohul'go for IIIUI sorvloo WIIH $149,00, 1\ oop)' of lnvoloo No, I ~!lCio, dlltOll <" ". "" '.', ., 0010\101' 19, 1998, whloh WIIH dolll'orod to PIIIlllUffdH IIl1u~lIo!\ hOl'oto UB Uxhl\lh IIi)," 20, In AII!lll,HI, 80plombol' lmd 00tohor,pol'onllllll1 hostod 1110110111.11111 "l'o~)'olon\1x,oOI\1" IIpon Iho 1'01l\loHlund 101' tho honollt of 1'llIllltlff, Tho 1'0llH\1nuhlo mId ollatoll1l1ry ohm'lloH flw.Huoh sorl'loOH IH $H7,OO; A copy oflnvolcq No, I 3990.A, dlllod Novcmhor 3, ,I 998, whloh WIIH dolll'ul'Oll 10 I'llllnllff, I~ Iltlllohod hOl'oto IIH Bxhlhit "e," 21, 011 OOloblll' 8, 1998; Dofondulll 1'0l1dol'o.ll oomplllol' dOHlll1l HUl'vloo" I'll!' tho "1,0(11) , Wlntol'myor Hllo," llpontho 1'0ll\\IlHt find 1'01' Iho. bOllof1t ofPlnln\ICn LoolI Wlnlol'lI1yol' lA, 01' WnA,1\ o\lont of Pin Inti IT, Thorollsol1nhto nnd cllstoll1nl')' olllll'gOH I'M thoHO HOI'vloOH IH $51 (J,()(J, t\ copy ~ll' .. InvolooNo, 13916, dlltod OOlohol'H, 1998, whloh wlIH 1I01l1'0rcd.tn Plnln\ln; IH lIUnohu!1 htll'otn nH " ' Exhlbll"D," f\ -.. ,. " " ,. " ., " " 1\ " " " " , " , " Ii d " 'I; " ., , 'i! ,j' ., " '", " " j exhibit A 1!lI~~1I111 1"111 U~laa ,,'~,\m TaT m~ .1I1(!"(Ili~'I'lllll'lIl~1:16 r'I' MIC www.ml~l.o~.cQm 1004 Rc:mCl VlIlq AV\'ll1\J1l ' Cl1mp Hili, rA 170\ 1 P\1Cl11111 7'1 r,7a7,5~1l~ F~I\I 717.7a~A(1 ~ lImqllllnIQ@ml!;\'Pf!,cpm Il~UIJlf~~1i'mmw~ 'ffipMllllll ~q~lq~, 1M, . .. ,,'.. . 'O~ l'!PIU, a~~\ll1\\ fill~\ ,,' , lilllT1a\l~r~ r... \7IQ\ . I,lSI\. " INVOICE . I I,. i, .,,",,,""'" ; \ap\ll> \lQQP -::-.~ , '"' "I!R~tii1tru~Wl~~I'\l~Ti1'_~ N\lQ\~ ).,16\\\ ,Ie. O~I~Q,l"P, . ... ' . sliP \'IQl1h aa~Ql1\\ Slr~~\ . \'lnlTli\l\\r~; 1'1\ 171 II' VIlA " I \ \ I \ 1'9\llpllllll" H 70234.0\\9 \ cQ""~n 'rmi' !luBII I I; ';1)'. " p I' " '" " ..I' ,1\ ,I , ~, " ~~h il-" p,. " 'I", '. " '", II " " ,. .. " , ji " f-'!, . " .j' ,,' " 'i, H " , ' ,,/ II' " 'i< ii, ".,,' ,,';' ";. " Ill' " , ", " " ,:" " " . " " ' "~I' . ' ,q, ,. " . , ~ ,"\ I, " ," 'I., " " , \ ~' " " , " 111: 'Ii ,. ;,. ,." Ii ,. I, .. aKhlbllO "r ,.' n " , ", \11 " 1 ",. ;'1, , '1,1' I' I' '; ,. " 1'.., " ;1' "~'-I. " ," " ii, " " " " ". ;/, .," " ,. , , " " H ".'" " ,', " ",' " ,. " ,Ii " " I. " ,. i' , 1'\ 1'1' ,. " " " /," ", " 'I, " " "" " i ;', Ii' II, ,; d ";' " Ii "" I, p ,. p " /I " " " Ii ,( ,. " " " " " .,;j " ,," It "Ii ,. ,,! " H ii' " \'1 If, " " ;; " " I' If., " " " 'j , ., , " " Exhibit 0 " i'q ,i_ , \", , d' Ii ;1' ,. ,. " ., .,. ,. " 'il \. ;1' " ,. ,. Ii " W: .., ~' w, jr. . ,. j' 1-." ~ .-'j..,. rJt:/ tl') {\ .f'.f.;' o!fll) 1";1 -. "'.. 1.)1' ~.. " nl~1 Ilib 'c. .', ('"l .';7?:.i r'l\;' I ..1.,,, I I.'.; ,hn:i " C,oj >-. i"'j ""~ '.!~. . F ~- p: (.n rj ,) p~ " I' " ..I' " "" h " " " " .' ".1 ,.,. if! ,I, ;' " ,. t.', " L " ... " (.j' " ,. " II, " " ,. " ii' <I , Ii I' \d' j; " " I, " " " rl . . 'Ii h 11, Panleq, Tlw Palanca owaq for tha~allamsl~ as sat forth In Rlalntlff:~ Complaint, 1~, P13nleCf, Tllere Was no i1astlmotec;l quoteil onq no agreement petween IIle parties to qp the work for 0 pre'~et price, Any allega~ Iiquots" Wa~ npt 0 blncllng , - j., ' gemtragt petween the pqrtles, pefenclantwas aclvlsed and WaS aware that It waS 'responsible for Plqlntlff's out of pocket f.txpemes, Inqludlngthe cost of color las\3r prints, , ' 1;3, Denleq, Plaintiff's charges for these'SElTY!CElS ore the fair and reaso'nabla amount. que and are os set out In Plaintiff's Complaint. .. 14, pen led as stated, The final work Py Plqlntlff 6n IIleSe Items llaq not peen aompletecl peaause the work WaS stili In process, The work clone I:lY PI61ntlff WqS noj " <;leflalent or unsatisfactory and all of Itwasacceptqble InqualltYI 1~laintlff's stafiwa's In . tile process of meeting with Pefendant's representatives to eHsauss ahanges In the work I' - , I to complete It, when pefenclant prol(e off all further communlcallons with plaintiff. Defendant qcc!3pte'd t1~e work WIllchhadpeendone by P(alntlffup to that time and' , hanetalned the peneflt of that work and retains that benefit to this day, ,15, Penled, The propsI' bola nee owed Plaintiff Is that set out In Its Complalnt, , d "i Induding Interest. , o u , 17, I~o answer required, To the extent an answerls ,requlred, Plaintiff Incorporates herein the aYElrt't1ehts setout In Its Complaint and Its Replv to New Matter, 18, Admlttedlh part an~ denied In port, q Is admltte,d tllat Defendqnt performed certaln'Work for Plalnllff,lt Is denled, ho'wever, that Defendant ever submitted a statement or Invoice for the work or even demallded or requested paYl)lent prior to this plE;ladlng, DefehdCint Is not able to determine whether the charge for th~ work done Is' ., pf()per or due because the Infol'l'natlon necessalY to l1lake that deten'lllnollon Is Within the control of the Defendant and so Plalntllf denies these averments and demands, prqof thE;lreof at trial., ,. II .t, " 1 I' 1?, penledfor the reqsons set O\Jt In tI~e qnswer to pqrqgrqplJ 18 qpoye, ~O. penleq for the req~onsset out In the answer to I)qrqgraph 18 aPOYe,' ~.\, Penleq, Plqlntlff neyer requested PefElnclant to do ony work for Wlntermyer, , Wlntermyer contaoted pefElIldant directly te> do wPrk a~<;j pefendant's work for Wlntermyer WaS not satlsfaotory and was relected'py Wlntermyer, As a result of this proplem, Plalnllff had to do additional work f~rWlntermyer to"oorreot 1118 d~f1olenoles In Defendant's work, Plaintiff neyer requesteq Pefendant do any work f~r Wlntermyer qnd neY~r qgreed to pay pefemqant forwork done for Wlntermyer, 2~" Denied., Pefendant neyer su~xnltteq IIwoloes or bills f.orthe wbrk It olqlli1~ to , ' haYEl done and so PI(~lntlff was neyer aWare of pefendant's olah:n for these services until this. action was cornmenced, " 23, Denied, Plcllntlff,lsnot aple tocletermlne whether pefendant'scharges are for' work aotuallY d0l;16 and If the. charldes are fair and reasonaoll;l peoause all of the , I' ' , Informatll;m neoessary ton~qke that determination Is within the oontrol of Pefendanj.and I, so Plalnliff denies those oyerments and det1iands propf 1I1e(f.lof at trial, WHEREfORE, PI(~lntlff demanqs Ihat Defendant's Counterclaim o!;j dismissed and thai judgment oe entered In fayor of Plaintiff III qocordanoe with Its complaint. , " , ~ \ '--- J ~~\~. ,j1 Samuel I" Andes ' Attorney for Pltlln'tlff SuprElIne court ID 17225 525 Horth 12'h Slreet Lemoyne, rA 17043 '(717)761-5361 " " ,j/V\.~,,11/11 a06~ \) I ~.l3 q (OJ ,,:,;,,\ l,:.j ') ~':II',J ;,""" , ,I~:". ....~ ( ,. " " >, W ',. Iy: r" b r~I'1 , 'J 1'" 1. \ I ';' ~) .../ J-~~ ~V: " , ~ , ; :f!:: ~'-) .~;, '.' Ii:'.. C\. ".1 1":.1 '( 71 :~;I ",,-f .. ..~ "- ,'- 'f/) ,/ I', " I "'/ ;,i..i; If" I,i' " .,.1'1 [, illi't1 ',;,,',1 .J..'! ;,10... , .t.. " '.1 " c')" ~;) (:1 ,:;5 C) ",' "I, ", II' 'f' I, " " " I' I' " " " ,.;1 :; '. ., .' ",J " 'I ;'f'